Jury's Report

Jury’s Report
Up to the closing date of the submission,
we have received 87 entries. The adjudication
process took place in Rotterdam,
the Netherlands between 7-13 April 2009.
The following criteria were used:
-how the proposal brings up relevant urban
issues in Jakarta
-how it offers creative, visionary architectural/
urbanistic intervention
-how it corresponds to the theme Reciprocity/
Gotong Royong
-how it situates itself within the context
of Jakarta
-potential for further work to be exhibited
in IABR 2009
-built on sound research
-strong representational skill
Jury:
Stephen Cairns (Edinburgh University, subcurator
IABR 2009)
Kees Christiaanse (KCAP Rotterdam,
curator IABR 2009)
Winy Maas (MVRDV, the why factory)
Vedran Mimica (Berlage Institute Rotterdam)
Andrea Peresthu (TU Delft)
Daliana Suryawinata (SHAU Rotterdam, the why factory,
subcurator IABR 2009)
All decisions by the jury are final and indisputable.

FIRST PRIZE
Jakarta Bersih!
402777
NUNC architecten
Steven Brunsmann
Johan Krol
João Bentes
Floor Moormann
Tanja Van der Laan

SECOND PRIZE
Let’s Catch the Water!
Jakarta Sponge City
135677
mamostudio + UPH University
Adi Purnomo and David Hutama
with Carolina Setiawan, Steven Rendi Willyvans, Irene
Setiawati, Tifani Veronica, Cicilia Angelia, Arsheila Kinan,
Ayudya Paramitha, Kelly, Conny Andriani Yosisca

THIRD PRIZE
Field Estate: A Platform
for Symbiotic Urbanism
777881
GABPA architects
Gesa Buettner and Alejo Paillard
with Alvar Mensana

FIELD_ESTATE: a platform for symbiotic urbanism
Segitiga Emas Area
Co 2
777881
KAMPONG
TODAY
TOMORROW
SITE PLAN: 1:4000
H O 2
HIGH-RISE
PLATFORMS
WATER LILY ORGANISM
Field Estate – a platform for symbiotic urbanism
Field Estate is an urban development game. The
aim is to achieve a city-scape of typological
diversity and cooperative coexistence, combining
segregated urban conditions into strategic
partners: high-rise AND kampong; mall AND
street market. The game is played with two
pieces: towers and platforms. Tower and
platforms move interdependently; their formation
mimics a water lily: every vertical stem of a
tower is surrounded by elevated platforms
floating above the city. The purpose of the
towers is to provide density; their employment
follows the logics of the real estate market. The
purpose of the platforms is adaptation of the
existing; their employment follows the logic of
community and preservation. The bio-textile
semi-transparent roofs absorb and recycle
water, and they dehumidify, cool and clean the
air. By erecting the elevated platforms citizens
across the social, religious and political divide
join in a Gotong-Royong to diminish the danger
of flooding and improving the city’s climate.
1

FIELD_ESTATE: a platform for symbiotic urbanism
Segitiga Emas Area
777881
WATER TANK
Current trends
PLATFORM 1:125
IRRIGATION
CLEAN TRANSPORTATION
RENEWABLE ENERGY
CO2 ABSORBANT
H O 2
SHADE
FARMING
LEISURE
PARK
DEHUMIDIFYING LAYER: BIOTEXTILE
COOLING SPRINKLERS
COMMUNAL WATER SOURCE
H O
2
WATER MANAGEMENT
Jakarta’s development follows the same
scheme as other Asian mega cities where high
land values and weak legal frameworks for
preservation of low-income neighborhoods and
open space facilitated mono-development of
high-rise towers and mega-malls. Whole functioning
neighborhoods are being displaced to
make room for luxury towers, rural migrants
have to squat in informal settlements and green
space has reduced to a meager 9%. The informal
sector of street vendors and urban farmers
today accounts for 70% of the work-force and
20% of the GDP. The unregulated densification
leads to an increase in pollution, waste and
energy-consumption. Indonesia is the 3rd
largest greenhouse gas provider and most
vulnerable to the increase in sea water levels
and climate patterns due to global warming.
Outside air pollution and the hot and humid
tropical climate make walking the streets
unbearable. Well-off citizens flock to the malls,
their poorer counterparts migrants escape
from the climate by setting up camp in areas
with naturally cooler climate: under bridges and
close to the rivers
Field Estates learns from successful strategies.
Instead of furthering the segregation between
tower and low-rise dwellers Field Estates
encourages the coexistence of the two housing
typologies, allowing for different scenarios of
cohabitation. It turns the city itno an indooroutdoor
continuum, enticing all citizens back to
the streets by providing for a semi-conditioned
climate throughout the city.
Rules of the game
FOUR CONDITIONS THAT SEGREGATE JAKARTA
1.DENSIFICATION
HIGH RISE
KAMPONG
2.SHOPPING
PRIVATE MALL
3.FLOODING
4.TROPICAL CLIMATE
STREET MARKET PROTECTED UNPROTECTED CONDITIONED UNCONDITIONED
+ + + +
With every new high-rise a developer has to
provide 20% of the gross floor area as elevated
platforms. The platforms are placed as a
climatic layer above the existing low rise, providing
shade and air-conditioning, a full water cycle
from water collection and absorption to drinking
water and irrigation, and amenities to the neighborhood.
75% of the platforms are for water
collection and renewable energies, their waterabsorbing
semi-transparent roof shading the
houses and streets below. The remaining 25%
range from urban farmland to sport fields.
Platforms can also be installed per community
initiative without entailing towers.
ONE STRATEGY THAT UNITES JAKARTA
$
RULES OF THE GAME
FARMING 15% ACCESS 10% ENERGY 65% ACCESS 10% FARMING 15%
SPORTS 10% WATER 65% PARK 10% PLAYGROUND 10%
SITE SECTION 1:750
2

SPECIAL MENTION
Ojek City: Permeable Mobility
523477
LABO Architecture+Design
Deddy Wahjudi PhD, Nelly L. Daniel PhD,
Hamal O. Pangestu, Mariska Pratimi, Angga Rosiawan

OJEK CITY : permeable mobility
jl.Rasuna Said - jl. Jend Sudirman - jl. Gatot Subroto ( South Jakarta )
Ojek city
523477
interchage transportation mode...
( in traffic jam )
no-car Jakarta
(with a good public transportation)
new transportation in disaster
A place to interaction
a new car lanes
or a new strategy
What have lost in Jakarta a man that lost themself in
the middle of city named Jakarta. City development that
dominated by physical consideration. It has conduced
gap between human and environment and the net of
human social. Design and strategy plays role in
dismissing the humanity.
Ojek city is an issue that focused, represented city face
and city life in Jakarta, at present and the future. Ojek is
a motorcycle taxi part of public transportation which
have efficiency and ability to trough the traffic jam, so
that it can be deliver people faster than other vehicle. It
can be help people to access places which
uncomfortable to walk, and can be maneuver in density
area with its narrow alleys.
Ojek is so humanist, very Jakarta, and very Indonesia.
Ojek’s motor owned by the driver itself, and it's a
unofficial and unlicenced public transportation. Thus,
the transaction in the practice is very informal, there is
no tax standard based distance, but its play with
compromise between driver and passenger. A
bargaining communication. Ojek has its zone or service
area, but in the practice its very permissive and
sometimes very accidental to access places where the
passenger want.
No standart price (bargaining)
In the future, ojek with its network and relationship can
provide range of services like ride children go to the
school,delivery service with gentleman agreement, or a
part of 24 hour shop’s delivery.
an ojek stop...
new cheap transportation for family
a mobile shop
Ojek corner (pangkalan ojek) is a place to park the
motorcycle and a place for socialization its drivers and
colleagues , a part of social space in the city. Its
potential to become an interaction place can be happen
if its near of kiosk or food court. It is a strategic place to
ask an address if we lost, a node or security center of a
dwelling zone.
How we can live as a human in Jakarta Enjoy a
conversation at ojek corner, and make a plan to trough
the traffic jam with ojek.
1
Busway route - artery road
Jl. Jenderal Sudirman
Jl. Rasuna Sa id
J l. Gat o t Subrot
o
There are 2 type of routes in Jakarta : a planned route and unplanned
one, which grows organic and sprawling from the settlement area in
the city. This organic route cannot be mapped and only can be
understanding trough human-scale space experienced by the ojek
driver and the community inside. These kind of routes are
scattered all around jakarta, folded, wrapped, and growth
between settlement area. Furthermore, these roads have a high
permeability, crossing main roads, with unlimited route that can be
provide by any kind of ojek : an unplanned road become an
alterative road with human scale dimension. It can be developed to
free-car road and walkable area, an escape route from the traffic.
If these route traced ,the result is a pattern like fireworks spreading
all around the city. An unlimited end with high permeability, that is
ojek route.
2
Ojek corner points
3
Ojek routes

OJEK CITY : permeable mobility
jl.Rasuna Said - jl. Jend Sudirman - jl. Gatot Subroto ( South Jakarta ) 523477
CONCEPT
a nest , organic shelter that can be build everywhere,a temporary and place for community.
Placements of ojek’s shelter
PLACEMENT
Like a nest, ojek corner can be placed everywhere,
from crossroad side to under highway.
It will fill lost spaces which have potential to become
a social space and easy to
find,naturally,sporadic,organic,and unplanned.
It maintained by community,belong to community,
and a part of community space.
APPLICATION.........

SPECIAL MENTION
Stitching the Strip
513557
Dimitrij Zadorin

513557
STITCHING THE STRIP
GOTONG ROYONG CITY JAKARTA
Jalan Sudirman in Jakarta is a blatant example of a modern corporate strip that expands depthward at the
cost of the existing urban structure. This process is accompanied by rupture and isolation of existing
villages – kampongs (dating from before WWII in this area) as well as visual contamination and physical
fragmentation of the space acquired.
The proposal, representing metaphorically ‘stitching the cut’, is based upon reconnecting kampongs by
series of ‘bridges’ and reorganization of space around the skyscrapers. As form is dominant for these
buildings, they will wallow in their symbolical verticality while all service and parking buildings are
removed to the back. Conversely the everyday life is amorphous and horizontal (what allows to create an
abstract slab of a fixed low height). It uses bridges to reconnect kampongs among the ribbons of public
space for all, which is safeguarded against uncontrolled kampong‘s expansions by physical barriers –
walls.
DKI JAKARTA - SITE
JAKARTA UTARA
JAKARTA BARAT
JAKARTA PUSAT
JAKARTA TIMUR
JAKARTA SELATAN
INTEGRATION FIELD SLAB
REORGANIZATION OF SPACE
BRIDGE LAYOUT
SEPARATING WALLS PREVENT FROM
UNCONTROLLED EXPANSION OF
KAMPONGS INTO PUBLIC SPACE
KAMPONGS
PUBLIC SPACE
KAMPONGS
LOW HEIGHT OF KAMPONG BUILDINGS
ALLOWS FOR CONTAINING THEM IN
A HORIZONTAL SLAB OF A FIXED HEIGHT
FOR PRESERVING THE ABSTRACT
CHARACTER OF CLEANED-UP SPACE
CORPORATE ORATE
SPACE
FREED ED FROM VISUAL
CONTAMINATION NAT
ATI
TION NAN
AND
RECONNECTING
NEC
ECT
CTIN
NG
FRAGMENTED ED
SPACE
EXISTING KAMPONGS
STITCHING BRIDGE
CLEANED-UP ED-
ABSTRACT ACT
SPACE
GREEN BELT
SERVICE ZONE
EXISTING KAMPONGS
KAMPONGS AND THE STRIP
STITCHINGS OF KAMPONGS
CLEAN-UP OF THE STRIP
PROJECT SITE 1:20000
NEW KAMPONGS
CORPORATE
STRIP
CONNECTION
POINTS
575 m
520 m
525 m
445 m
CORPORATE
BUILDINGS
SERVICE ZONE
415 m
GREEN BELT
OLD
KAMPONGS
REQUIRED
CONNECTIONS
/STITCHINGS
580 m
500 m
CLEANED-UP
ABSTRACT
SPACE
JALAN
SUDIRMAN
CITY FABRIC

SITE PLAN 1:2000
513557
existing greenery
Jalan Kh Mas Mansyur
PARKING FACILITIES
WITH BASKET AND TENNIS
COURT ON THE ROOFS
existing
corporate building
existing
kampong building
NEW
PUBLIC BUILDING
Jalan Karet Pasar
Baru Barat VII
STITCHING 5: LIGHT COVERED BAMBOO BRIDGE TO THE NEXT KAMPONG
ESCALATORS
NEW
BUILDING/INFRASTRUCTURE
STITCHING 4: INTEGRATION FIELD SLAB WITH ELABORATED PUBLIC FACILITIES
SPORT CENTRE
ELEVATORS
PARK
NEW
KAMPONG BUILDING
TREE
CULTURAL CENTRE
FOR LOCAL RESIDENTS
NEW KAMPONG
EXTENSION
NEW KAMPONG
EXTENSION
ELEVATORS
FOOD
FACILITIES
NEW KAMPONG
EXTENSION
STAIRCASE SHAFT
NEW KAMPONG
EXTENSION
existing
greenery
CHILDREN PLAYGROUND
kampong
Karetpasarbaroe
CROPS FIELD
CONTINUOUS WALL AS VISUAL MANIFESTATION OF CONNECTIONS
MOSQUE
CENTRAL SQUARE
ELEVATOR
SMALL SHOPS
NEW KAMPONG
EXTENSION
existing
mosque
SQUARE FOR
INFORMAL MEETINGS
Jalan Karet Gusuran III
ESCALATORS
Jalan Jend Sudirman
AIR TUNNELS
COCONUT PARK
AS PART OF THE GREEN BELT
SEPARATING CORPORATE BUILDINGS
FROM PARKING AND SERVICE BUILDINGS
PARKING
FACILITIES
kampong Karetblakang
STITCHING 3: BRIDGE-ALLEY TO THE NEXT KAMPONG
Jalan Komando Raya
SITE VIEWS
CENTRAL SQUARE IN THE INTEGRATION FIELD SLAB
TO THE LEFT: NEW MOSQUE
STITCHING 3: BRIDGE-ALLEY
ENTRANCE TO THE SLAB FROM KAMPONG KARETBLAKANG
IN THE CENTRE: TRANSFORMATION OF THE CONTINUOUS WALL
STITCHING 5: LIGHT BAMBOO BRIDGE
PARK OF LOW-HEIGHT TREES
TO THE LEFT: NEW GARAGE BUILDINGS WITH SPORT COURTS ON TOP
ENTRANCE TO THE SLAB FROM KAMPONG KARETPASARBAROE

SPECIAL MENTION
Eco Gate as Border Device
534558
Budi Pradono Architects
Budi Pradono, Anton Suryono, Yuli Sri Hartanto, Rina Nur
Aisah, Adam Modigliani Prana, Adryan Fernando Hutagaol,
Primaldi Perdana

ECO GATE
BUMI SERPONG DAMAI
AS BORDER DEVICE
534558
POTENTIAL ECO-GATE PROGRAM
BIOETANOL
PRODUCER
ENERGY
DEPOSIT
SUNFLOWER
FOREST
FOOD
COURT
APPLE
FOREST
HANDICRAFT
INDUSTRY
ECO GATE - INDUSTRIAL
HOME
ACESSORIES
ECO GATE - COW FARM
LOW-COST
HOUSING
ECO GATE - AGRICULTURE
Gotong Royong City
Eco gate as border device
The periphery of Jakarta has experienced a drastic
increase in population. The population in the
periphery of Jakarta has tripled from 4.4 million in
1980 to 12.6 million in 2000, while Jakarta's
population increased by only 30 percent.
The growth of Jakarta is the cause of suburbanization
in Jakarta's peripheral areas, and will correspond to
suburbanization in Jakarta's neighboring areas such
as Tangerang area of Bumi Serpong Damai (BSD) city
development.
Gated functional suburban housing estates / gated
communities are the products of the market. The
sprawl of private new towns that have been
developed without regional planning coordination,
and the resultant social and natural segregation,
which we can see from the concrete wall as a rigid
symbol of two areas desa /rural and inside the gate
kota / urban
In our research Tangerang area as one of suburban
area lost its fast frontier forest and agricultural paddy
field, everyday the equivalent of 5 football fields of
agricultural land disappears.
For many years The rural-kampung where traditional
people depend on agricultural sector are neglected.
Can we in the context and based on the uniqueness demographic
circumstances, provide BSD rural area with series of contemporary ecogate
Eco gate is a contemporary gate, which is replaced the conventional
physical concrete fence. It is an open plan structure, which can be mutated
in term of form or programming depend on the specificity of the place.
Eco gate will function as the border to stop the
development of the gated communities at the same
time to provide a new opportunity for both
communities to maximize the cohabitation
relationship by providing several attractive
programming such as energy producer, CO2
producer by re-planting the forest, fish market, fishing
garden, ethanol producer from the cow farm, social
housing, bamboo producer, organic vegetable.
ECO GATE - INDUSTRIAL
Eco gate also act as job provider for several informal
job, such as servant, housekeeper, car washer, baby
sitter, florist, mobile tailor, food stall, café, and
practical business education,
Eco gate is a border device, between gated
communities and rural kampung-settlement.

ECO GATE AS BORDER DEVICE
BUMI SERPONG DAMAI
534558
TANGERANG
CONVENTIONAL
SECURITY GUARD
GAS
STATION
SOCIAL
INTERACTION
WE DO NOT NEED ANYMORE CONVENTIONAL SECURITY GUARD IN THE FUTURE, TO BE REPLACED WITH ECO GATE
INFORMAL
WORKER
DEVELOPMENT OF PRIVATE HOUSING
IN JABOTABEK
DIRECT CONTACT
BETWEEN
CONVENTIONAL
FENCE AND
RURAL-KAMPUNG
HOUSING
SERVICE
AGRICULTURE
CONVENTIONAL
FENCE
GATED COMMUNITY
RURAL-KAMPUNG COMMUNITY
MUTUALISM
RELATIONSHIP
TANGERANG POPULATION GROWTH
HOMOGEN
BASED ON
TRADITION
TANGERANG BUILT-UP GROWTH
GATED COMMUNITY
CLUSTER
SOCIAL
FORMAL WORKER INTERACTION SERVICE SIMILAR STRATA HETEROGEN BASED ON LIFESTYLE
MONOTONE SPACE
LESS NATURE/GREEN
ORDER
ORGANIZED PUBLIC SPACE
RURAL-KAMPUNG COMMUNITY
FRAGMENTED DYNAMIC SPACE MORE NATURE/GREEN UN-ORDER SPREAD PUBLIC SPACE
ECO GATE INDUSTRIAL
ECOGATE PROTOTYPE
ECO GATE CATTLE BREEDING ECO GATE NURSERY ECO GATE FISHMARKET
ECO GATE AGRICULTURE
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
FISH MARKET
SEA FOOD RESTAURANT
MARKET
GARDENER
POOL
CAR WASH/BENGKEL
NURSERY
CAFE+RESTO
ATM CENTER
PARKING CENTER
GREENERY
BOUTIQUE AND TAYLOR
ECO GATE FISHMARKET
ECO GATE FISHMARKET
ECO GATE NURSERY