LETTER FROM MELBOURNE
LETTER FROM MELBOURNE
LETTER FROM MELBOURNE
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
1 AUGUST TO 4 SEPTEMBER<br />
<strong>LETTER</strong> <strong>FROM</strong> <strong>MELBOURNE</strong><br />
Pipe blow out<br />
The Wimmera-Mallee pipeline is now expected<br />
to cost $688m, over a third more than originally<br />
planned. The blow out was revealed by Grampians<br />
Wimmera Mallee Water in its new five year water<br />
plan, raising questions of who will pay for the<br />
increase. The previous budget ($501m) was to be<br />
shared equally between the water company, State<br />
Government and Federal Government, The Age<br />
said.<br />
Desalination plant<br />
An independent Bass Coast Councillor Gareth<br />
Barlow has gone against his colleagues, criticising<br />
the State Government’s $3.1b desalination plant.<br />
Barlow also criticised his colleagues for their<br />
‘wait and see’ approach, The Age reported. Age<br />
Senior columnist, Kenneth Davidson, who has<br />
consistently opposed the Bracks/Thwaites plans for<br />
a desalination plant and piping water over the great<br />
divide on the grounds that they are economically and<br />
environmentally unsound, urged Premier Brumby<br />
to reconsider other, more sound, water options,<br />
including piping Tasmania’s water surplus (no need<br />
to watch this space) to Melbourne.<br />
Other views (1)<br />
Tony Cutcliffe, director of the Eureka Project, a<br />
strategic consultancy, wrote a fascinating article in<br />
The Age (16 August) explaining how the desalination<br />
plant will be funded, owned and operated, and<br />
suggests that it will probably not be built because<br />
foreign owners would be making a politically<br />
unacceptable number of cents from each litre of<br />
cleaned water.<br />
Other views (2)<br />
Senior departmental water bureaucrat Garry<br />
Seaborne seems to have contradicted government<br />
policy, when he said Victoria’s drinking water should<br />
include 10 per cent recycled water according to the<br />
Leongatha Star. Around the same time former-water<br />
minister John Thwaites revealed Melbourne’s water<br />
authorities were considering recycled water for<br />
drinking last year The Age said.<br />
Murray debate moves along<br />
The Queensland Nationals (especially Barnaby<br />
Joyce) caused fresh problems for the Federal<br />
Government by rejecting the draft legislation for<br />
Prime Minister John Howard’s $10b plan to rescue<br />
the Murray-Darling river system, The Age reported.<br />
Victorian Premier Brumby is maintaining a hard<br />
line on the issue, saying that the Murray-Darling<br />
take-over would not have his government’s support<br />
unless Victoria’s amendments were included.<br />
Brumby’s scepticism comes partly from his<br />
perception of the move as being located within the<br />
context of Howard’s ‘rush of interventions’. State<br />
Labor members of an inquiry into the controversial<br />
water bill have said that the takeover may involve<br />
reductions in water entitlements to farmers. The<br />
government has repeatedly ruled out compulsory<br />
acquisition of water under the plan, The Age said.<br />
The Federal Government made a significant<br />
concession to Victoria this month, formally ruling<br />
out compulsory acquisition of water entitlements.<br />
The Prime Minister had threatened to deny Victoria<br />
its share of the $3.5b budget for irrigation but<br />
subsequently decided to use it as a bargaining chip.<br />
It will be quarantined for use by the state should it<br />
sign up to the deal, according to The Age. Another<br />
bargaining chip is that any State Government which<br />
does not surrender its powers will not have a say<br />
in who sits on a new council set up to determine<br />
sustainable levels of water use, the Financial Review<br />
said.<br />
The Victorian Government says the project would<br />
be bad for Victorian farmers, but the stand has<br />
given Prime Minister John Howard an opportunity<br />
to criticise the states’ obstructionism and promote<br />
his new federalism, the Financial Review said.<br />
Victoria was the first state to introduce large scale<br />
irrigation and this is detailed in an interesting article<br />
in The Age by Edwyna Harris of Monash University’s<br />
economics department.<br />
The Federal Government increased pressure on<br />
Victoria by saying it will not fund water buybacks<br />
unless all four basin states agree to give Canberra<br />
total control, a move that upset NSW Premier Morris<br />
Iemma, the Financial Review said.<br />
Clear view<br />
Graham Kraehe, chairman of BlueScope Steel, a<br />
non-executive director of Brambles, and a member<br />
of the Reserve Bank board, outlined his ideas about<br />
water management, pricing, and efficiency in a<br />
speech to an Australian Industry Group forum at<br />
Zinc, in Melbourne. Kraehe argued that government<br />
must introduce sensible pricing strategies that take<br />
into account how water is being used; that pricing<br />
changes can be used to make water-saving projects<br />
more economical and more attractive to companies;<br />
and finally, that government must encourage<br />
decentralised water solutions (such as rain-water<br />
harvesting).<br />
Bottling up water info<br />
According to The Age, Melbourne Water is<br />
spending thousands of tax-payer dollars in legal<br />
fees to block the release of cabinet briefings on the<br />
states water crisis on the grounds that they may<br />
cause ‘unnecessary debate’ about the drought and<br />
water supplies. The Age requested the documents<br />
under freedom-of-information laws, and the case<br />
will go before the Victorian Civil and Administrative<br />
Tribunal this year.<br />
Fruit tree danger<br />
Although farmers in Victoria’s Goulburn system were<br />
allocated water from 15 August, their counterparts<br />
in the Murray district started the irrigation season<br />
with just five per cent of their allocations, their<br />
least ever and barely enough to keep trees alive,<br />
The Age reported. The effect on fruit crops will<br />
be devastating and many acres will be bulldozed.<br />
Victorian agriculture is more about trees and vines<br />
and longer term commitment crops, whereas NSW<br />
and Queensland have much more rice, and cotton.<br />
Waterfind, a national water broking company says<br />
water prices shot up by 180 per cent last year on the<br />
temporary trading market as irrigators frantically<br />
topped up supplies.<br />
In the pipeline<br />
New Premier Brumby faces his first significant<br />
challenge: pushing through the water infrastructure<br />
bill, which is crucial for the north-south pipeline. The<br />
legislation would allow the government to overrule<br />
local planning laws to speed up major water<br />
projects. Amendments were made to the Bill in the<br />
Legislative Council through the combined efforts of<br />
Liberals, Nationals and Greens, The Age said.<br />
Practical competition flushed<br />
Services Sydney, a private company, is upset that<br />
the NSW government will go ahead with its Kurnell<br />
desalination plant (which is expected to provide<br />
16.5 per cent of Sydney’s daily water supply) saying<br />
it will ‘flood the market’ and that it is uncompetitive<br />
behaviour.<br />
The company, which has been trying for some<br />
time to break Sydney Water’s monopoly on water<br />
and sewerage services, was dealt a double blow:<br />
the same day that the NSW government signed a<br />
contract to begin work on the desalination plant, the<br />
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission<br />
accepted Sydney Water’s proposed terms for<br />
access to its sewerage transportation infrastructure.<br />
Services Sydney has applied to the Australian<br />
Competition Tribunal for a review of the decision,<br />
the Financial Review reported.<br />
Another water conference<br />
The Victorian Water Industry Association is holding its<br />
annual water conference on 13 and 14 September<br />
in the Yarra Valley, www.vicwater.org.au. Standard<br />
good quality speakers. There are so many energy<br />
and water conferences these days.<br />
Gaming<br />
Victoria’s gambling problem<br />
Victorians have lost $27.3b in 15 years of poker<br />
machines, The Herald Sun said, and are now losing<br />
$2.5b per year (about $7m a day).<br />
Former Premier Jeff Kennett expressed regret this<br />
month that regional pokies ‘super clubs’ had never<br />
got off the ground. He rejected critics saying the<br />
vast majority of poker machine players do so within<br />
their financial limits, The Herald Sun reported.<br />
Attempts to cut the number of poker machines from<br />
the current 27,500 in Victoria were defeated by<br />
a voting bloc of the Nationals and Labor, The Age<br />
said.<br />
First it was St Kilda, now …<br />
The Western Bulldogs found themselves (as St<br />
Kilda and its relationship with gaming machines<br />
and councils) up against a formidable opponent this<br />
month in the form of gaming giant Tabcorp. Tabcorp<br />
is believed to be angry (and possibly considering<br />
legal action) over plans to move 48 poker machines<br />
from the club’s headquarters. Maribyrnong Council<br />
is expected to require the Bulldogs to remove the<br />
pokies in line with its $21.5m plan to redevelop<br />
the dilapidated Whitten Oval into a community hub.<br />
Victoria University, which has plans for a sports<br />
science campus on the site, and would contribute<br />
$8m to the project, is unlikely to go ahead with the<br />
pokies in place. There are also many federal dollars<br />
13