Respondent's Motion to Quash
Respondent's Motion to Quash
Respondent's Motion to Quash
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
FL-301<br />
[1eI N RNtt OR PARTY WITHCJT ATTORNEY (Name, t r number, and address):<br />
• --PAROLE D. BALDWIN, CFL,<br />
BALDWIN & BALDWIN<br />
9171 TOWNE CENTRE DRIVE, SUITE 440<br />
SAN DIEGO, CA 92122<br />
213310<br />
0 0 1 5 b<br />
FOR COURT USE ONLY<br />
TELEPHONE NO.: 858.452.2898 FAX NO. (Optional):<br />
E-MAIL ADDRESS (Optional):<br />
ATTORNEY FOR (Name): MICHAEL J. CALDWELL<br />
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO<br />
STREET ADDRESS: 250 EAST MAIN STREET<br />
MAILING ADDRESS: SAME<br />
CITY AND ZIP CODE: EL CAJON, CA 92020<br />
BRANCH NAME: EAST COUNTY DIVISION<br />
GINNY L. CALDWELL<br />
PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF:<br />
RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:<br />
MICHAEL J. CALDWELL<br />
NOTICE OF MOTION<br />
D Child Cus<strong>to</strong>dy<br />
-0-Child-Support -<br />
0 At<strong>to</strong>rney Fees and<br />
D MODIFICATION<br />
Visitation<br />
-0-Spousal-Support<br />
Costs<br />
D Injunctive Order<br />
al- Other (specify-<br />
MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENAS<br />
1. TO (name): GINNY EDMUNDS (FKA CALDWELL)<br />
2. A hearing on this motion for the relief requested in the attached application will be held as follows:<br />
CASE NUMBER:<br />
ED 047912-EPK<br />
a. Date: JAN 1 2 2012 Time: *Oa alals D Dept.: bows,f1 Rm.:<br />
b. Address of court al same as noted above 0 other (specify)<br />
3. Supporting attachments:<br />
a. Completed Application for Order and Supporting Declaration d.<br />
(form FL-310) and a blank Responsive Declaration (form FL-320)<br />
b. D Completed Income and Expense Declaration (form FL-150) e.<br />
and a blank Income and Expense Declaration f.<br />
c. D Completed Financial Statement (Simplified) (form FL-155)<br />
and a blank Financial Statement (Simplified)<br />
Date: 11/14/11<br />
CAROI F D BAI DWIN<br />
(TYPE OR PRINT NAME)<br />
1::1 Completed Property Declaration (form FL-160)<br />
and a blank Property Declaration<br />
11 Points and authorities<br />
Zi Other (specify):<br />
ect7c0112, ealdwz,,<br />
(SIGNATURE)<br />
ORDER<br />
4. D Time for Q service Q hearing is shortened. Service must be on or before (date) :<br />
5. Any responsive declaration must be served on or before(date) :<br />
6. If child cus<strong>to</strong>dy or visitation is an issue in this proceeding, Family Code section 3170 requires mediation before or concurrently<br />
with the hearing listed above. The parties are ordered <strong>to</strong> attend orientation and manda<strong>to</strong>ry cus<strong>to</strong>dy services as follows:<br />
Date:<br />
JUDICIAL OFFICER<br />
NOTICE: If you have children from this relationship, the court is required <strong>to</strong> order payment of child support based on<br />
the incomes of both parents. The amount of child support can be large. It normally continues until the child is 18. You<br />
should supply the court with information about your finances. Otherwise, the child support order will be based on the<br />
information supplied by the other parent.<br />
You do not have <strong>to</strong> pay any fee <strong>to</strong> file declarations in response <strong>to</strong> thisNotice of <strong>Motion</strong> (including a<br />
completed Income and Expense Declaration (form FL-150) or Financial Statement(Simp/ified) (form FL-155) that will<br />
show your finances). In the absence of an order shortening time, the original of the responsive declaration must be filed<br />
with the court and a copy served on the other party at least nine court days before the hearing date. Add five calendar<br />
days if you serve by mail within California. (See Code of Civil Procedure 1005 for other situations.) To determine court<br />
and calendar days, go <strong>to</strong> www.courtinfo.ca.goviselfhelp/councalendarsZ<br />
Form Adopted for Manda<strong>to</strong>ry Use<br />
Judicial Council of California<br />
FL-301 [Rev. January 1, 20071<br />
MartIll Uru Ws<br />
ESSENTIAL FORMS"<br />
NOTICE OF MOTION<br />
CALDWELL<br />
Page 1 of 2<br />
Government Code, § 26826<br />
www.courtinfo.ca.gov
PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF:GINNY L. GALDWELL<br />
RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:MICHAEL J. CALDWELL<br />
CASE NUMBER:<br />
ED 047912-EPK n n -<br />
u<br />
APPLICATION FOR ORDER AND SUPPORTING DECLARATION<br />
- THIS IS NOT AN ORDER -<br />
FL-310<br />
Petitioner El Respondent LI Claimant requests the following orders:<br />
1. D CHILD CUSTODY Q To be ordered pending the hearing<br />
a. Child's name and aqe b. Legal cus<strong>to</strong>dy <strong>to</strong> (name of person who c. Physical cus<strong>to</strong>dy <strong>to</strong> (name of<br />
makes decisions about health, education, etc.) person with whom child will live.)<br />
d. La Modify existing order<br />
(1) filed on (date):<br />
(2) ordering (specify):<br />
requested in form- 1E1 FL 31-1- El FL 312- L]—FL-341(C) D FL-341(D) El FL-341(E)<br />
2. D CHILD VISITATION D To be ordered pending the hearing<br />
a. As requested in: (1) El Attachment 2a (2) D Form FL-311 (3) D Other (specify):<br />
b. D Modify existing order<br />
(1) filed on (date):<br />
(2) ordering (specify):<br />
c. One or more domestic violence restraining/protective orders are now in effect. (Attach a copy of the orders if you<br />
have one.) The orders are from the following court or courts (specify county and state):<br />
(1) D Criminal: County/state: (3) rj.1 Juvenile: County/state.<br />
Case No. (if known):<br />
Case No. (if known):<br />
(2) D Family: County/state: (4) El Other: County/state:<br />
Case No. (if known):<br />
Case No. (if known):<br />
3. D CHILD SUPPORT (An earnings assignment order may be issued.)<br />
a. Child's name and aqe b. Monthly amount requested (if not by guideline)<br />
c. lE1 Modify existing order<br />
(1) filed on (date):<br />
(2) ordering (specify):<br />
4. El SPOUSAL OR PARTNER SUPPORT (An earnings assignment order may be issued.)<br />
a. El Amount requested (monthly): $ c. D Modify existing order<br />
b. D Terminate existing order (1) filed on (date):<br />
(1) filed on (date): (2) ordering (specify):<br />
(2) ordering (specify):<br />
NOTE: To obtain domestic violence restraining orders, you must use the forms Request for Order<br />
(Domestic Violence Prevention) (form DV-100), Temporary Restraining Order (Domestic Violence<br />
Prevention) (form DV-110), and Notice of Court Hearing (Domestic Violence Prevention) (form DV-109).<br />
Form Adopted for Manda<strong>to</strong>ry Use<br />
Judicial Council of California<br />
FL-310 [Rev. July 1, 2011]<br />
101 Martin DeaiA<br />
10'4AJ ESSENTIAL FORMS-<br />
Page 1 of 2<br />
APPLICATION FOR ORDER AND SUPPORTING DECLARATION Family Code, §§ 2045, 2107, 6224,<br />
6226, 6320-6326, 6380-6383<br />
www.courtinfo.ca.gov<br />
CALDWELL
Nov. 14. 2U11 5:441111 No. bilD r.<br />
—<br />
PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF: GINNY L. CALDWELL<br />
RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT: MICHAEL. J. CALDWELL<br />
CASE NUMBER<br />
ED 047912-EPK<br />
001h0<br />
FL-310<br />
5. ❑ ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS a. 0 Fees: $ b. 0 Costs: $<br />
6. 0 PROPERTY RESTRAINT 0 To be ordered pending the hearing<br />
a. The 0 petitioner ❑ respondent ❑ claimant is restrained from transferring, encumbering, hypothecating,<br />
concealing, or in any way disposing of any properly, real or personal, whether community, quasi-community, or<br />
separate, except in the usual course of business or for the necessities of life.<br />
L] The applicant will be nolilied at least live business days before any proposed extraordinary expenditures,<br />
and an accounting of such will be made <strong>to</strong> the court.<br />
b. ❑ Both parties are restrained and enjoined from cashing, borrowing against, canceling, transferring, disposing of, or<br />
changing the beneficiaries of any Insurance or other coverage, including life, health, au<strong>to</strong>mobile, and disability,<br />
held for the benefit of the parties or their minor children.<br />
o. D Neither party may incur any debts or liabililies for which Ihe other may be held responsible, other than in the<br />
ordinary course of business or for the necessities of life.<br />
7. El PROPERTY CONTROL ❑ To be ordered pending the hearing<br />
a. 0 The pelilioner ID respondent is given the exclusive temporary use, possession, and control of the following<br />
properly Thal we own or are buying (specify):<br />
b. D The pelilioner LI respondent is ordered lo make the lollowing payments on liens and encumbrances coming<br />
due while the order is in elfect:<br />
Debt Amount of payment Pay IQ<br />
8. Zi OTHER RELIEF (specify).<br />
AM REQUESTING THAT THE COURT QUASH THE SUBPOENAS SUBMITTED BY PETITIONER TO AMERICAN EXPRESS CENTURION BANK C.T.<br />
CORP., BANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION, C.T. CORP., CAPITAL ONE, DISCOVER BANK - C.T. CORP., AND HSBC BANK USA OR, IN THE<br />
ALTERNATIVE, MODIFY THE SUBPOENAS AND PUT IN PLACE PROTECTIVE ORDERS TO LIMIT THE SCOPE OF THE DOCUMENTATION<br />
REQUESTED.<br />
9. ID I request that lime lor service of Ihe Order <strong>to</strong> Show Cause and accompanying papers be shortened so that these documents<br />
may be served no less than (specify number): days before Ihe lime set for the hearing. I need lo have Ihe order<br />
shortening lime because of [he facts specilied in item 10 or the attached declaration.<br />
10. (Z) FACTS IN SUPPORT of relief requested and change of circumstances for any modification are (specify):<br />
Contained in the attached declaration. (You may use Attached Declaration (form MC.031) for this purpose).<br />
I declare under penally of perjury under ihe laws of the State of California Ihat the foregoing is True and correct.<br />
Date: 11/14/2011<br />
MIC.HAFI CAI DWFLL<br />
FL-310 (Rev. Jtey 1. NI I)<br />
6-1<br />
(TYPE OR PRINT NAME)<br />
it.olAUrent<br />
Esnigt low<br />
(SIGNATURE OF APPLICANT)<br />
APPLICATION FOR ORDER AND SUPPORTING DECLARATION<br />
CALDWELL<br />
Page X el a
0 0 1 1<br />
IN RE MARRIAGE OF CALDWELL — ED 047912<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
13<br />
14<br />
15<br />
16<br />
17<br />
18<br />
19<br />
20<br />
21<br />
22<br />
23<br />
24<br />
25<br />
26<br />
27<br />
28<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER — MOTION TO QUASH/MODIFY<br />
SUBPOENAS OF AMERICAN EXPRESS CENTURION BANK, BANK OF AMERICA,<br />
CAPITAL ONE, DISCOVER BANK, AND HSBC BANK USA<br />
RELIEF REQUESTED<br />
The Respondent requests that the court quash the subpoenas submitted by<br />
Petitioner <strong>to</strong> American Express Centurion Bank, Bank of America, Capital One,<br />
Discover Bank and HSBC Bank USA or, in the alternative, modify the subpoenas and<br />
put in place protective orders <strong>to</strong> limit the scope of the documentation requested by<br />
Petitioner.<br />
BACKGROUND AND BASIS FOR RELIEF REQUESTED<br />
On Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 28, 2011, Respondent was served by and through his at<strong>to</strong>rney of<br />
record with five Notices <strong>to</strong> Consumer and five Deposition Subpoenas for Production of<br />
Business Records for American Express Centurion Bank, Bank of America, Capital<br />
One, Discover Bank and HSBC Bank USA.<br />
On August 25, 2011, this Court ordered that it shall be making child support<br />
orders retroactive <strong>to</strong> December 20, 2010, the date Petitioner filed her motion <strong>to</strong> modify<br />
child support and set a full day hearing on the issue of child support on January 6,<br />
2012. This Court also stated that an earlier date for retroactivity can be argued at the<br />
hearing in January.<br />
On August 30, 2011, at the hearing on <strong>Respondent's</strong> motion <strong>to</strong> quash or modify<br />
subpoenas <strong>to</strong> his current employer, CSldentity, and a third party, Marilyn Weakly, the<br />
court granted <strong>Respondent's</strong> motion <strong>to</strong> modify the time period for his employer <strong>to</strong><br />
provide documents going back <strong>to</strong> 2009 only.<br />
SUBPOENA OF AMERICAN EXPRESS CENTURION BANK<br />
The following are <strong>Respondent's</strong> objections <strong>to</strong> the subpoena served on American<br />
Express Centurion Bank. A copy of "Exhibit 1" attached <strong>to</strong> the subpoena is attached as<br />
Exhibit A <strong>to</strong> this declaration.<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
13<br />
14<br />
15<br />
16<br />
17<br />
18<br />
001b2<br />
1. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> American Express providing loan applications,<br />
but requests that the time period be limited <strong>to</strong> 2009 forward.<br />
2. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 2 but requests that the time period be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 3 but requests that the time period be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
4. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 4 and requests that it be quashed. First, the<br />
request is vague as <strong>to</strong> "relevant attachments or supporting documents." Second, the<br />
Court already ruled on Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 20, 2011 that Petitioner was not entitled <strong>to</strong> receive<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> credit reports, but she is attempting <strong>to</strong> bypass that ruling with this<br />
request. Sales projections and schedules of assets and liabilities are also not relevant<br />
<strong>to</strong> the issue of the modification of child support because such documentation would not<br />
prove or disprove <strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
5. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 5 and asks that it be quashed.<br />
Correspondence between the bank and the Respondent and/or third parties is not<br />
relevant <strong>to</strong> any proceedings currently before the court.<br />
6. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 6 and asks that it be quashed as being overlybroad.<br />
19 SUBPOENA OF BANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION<br />
20 The following are <strong>Respondent's</strong> objections <strong>to</strong> the subpoena served on Bank of<br />
21 America Corporation. A copy of "Exhibit 1" attached <strong>to</strong> the subpoena is attached as<br />
22 Exhibit B <strong>to</strong> this declaration.<br />
23 1. Respondent requests that number 1 be modified <strong>to</strong> eliminate the request for<br />
24 signature cards as they are not relevant <strong>to</strong> the court proceedings. He also requests that<br />
25 number 1 be limited <strong>to</strong> the timeframe of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
26 Otherwise, Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 1.<br />
27 I a. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 1 a except that he requests that the<br />
28 timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
2
001h3<br />
1 b. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number lb except that he requests that the<br />
timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
2. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 2 but he requests that the timeframe<br />
be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 3 and requests that it be quashed.<br />
Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong> other accounts will not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income. Also, "All known transfer recipient information" is very broad and<br />
not likely <strong>to</strong> lead <strong>to</strong> information relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
4. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 4 as overly-broad and requests that it be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> permit the disclosure of loan applications only and for the time period of<br />
January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
5. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 5 as overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue<br />
currently before the court and requests that it be modified <strong>to</strong> permit statements for<br />
savings accounts only and for the time period of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30,<br />
2011.<br />
6. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 6 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
7. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 7 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
8. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 8 and requests that it be quashed. First, the<br />
request is vague as <strong>to</strong> "relevant attachments or supporting documents." Second, the<br />
Court already ruled that Petitioner was not entitled <strong>to</strong> receive <strong>Respondent's</strong> credit<br />
reports, but she is attempting <strong>to</strong> by-pass that ruling with this request. Sales projections<br />
and schedules of assets and liabilities are also not relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue of the<br />
modification of child support because such documentation would not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
9. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 9 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Correspondence between the bank<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
3
001b4<br />
and the Respondent and/or third parties is not relevant <strong>to</strong> any proceedings currently<br />
before the court.<br />
10. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 10 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong><br />
other accounts will not prove or disprove <strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
11. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 11.<br />
12. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 12 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
overly-broad.<br />
SUBPOENA OF CAPITAL ONE<br />
The following are <strong>Respondent's</strong> objections <strong>to</strong> the subpoena served on Capital<br />
One. A copy of "Exhibit 1" attached <strong>to</strong> the subpoena is attached as Exhibit C <strong>to</strong> this<br />
declaration.<br />
1. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> Capital One providing loan applications, but<br />
requests that the time period be limited <strong>to</strong> 2009 forward.<br />
2. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 2 but requests that the time period be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 3 but requests that the time period be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
4. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 4 and requests that it be quashed. First, the<br />
request is vague as <strong>to</strong> "relevant attachments or supporting documents." Second, the<br />
Court already ruled that Petitioner was not entitled <strong>to</strong> receive <strong>Respondent's</strong> credit<br />
reports, but she is attempting <strong>to</strong> by-pass that ruling with this request. Sales projections<br />
and schedules of assets and liabilities are also not relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue of the<br />
modification of child support because such documentation would not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
5. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 5 and asks that it be quashed.<br />
Correspondence between the bank and the Respondent and/or third parties is not<br />
relevant <strong>to</strong> any proceedings currently before the court.<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
4
0016 5<br />
6. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 6 and asks that it be quashed as being overly-<br />
broad.<br />
SUBPOENA OF DISCOVER BANK<br />
The following are <strong>Respondent's</strong> objections <strong>to</strong> the subpoena served on Discover<br />
Bank. A copy of "Exhibit 1" attached <strong>to</strong> the subpoena is attached as Exhibit D <strong>to</strong> this<br />
declaration.<br />
1. Respondent requests that number 1 be modified <strong>to</strong> eliminate the request for<br />
signature cards as they are not relevant <strong>to</strong> the court proceedings. He also requests that<br />
number 1 be limited <strong>to</strong> the timeframe of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
Otherwise, Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 1.<br />
1a. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 1a except that he requests that the<br />
timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1. 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
1 b. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number lb except that he requests that the<br />
timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
2. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 2 but he requests that the timeframe<br />
be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 3 and requests that it be quashed.<br />
Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong> other accounts will not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income. Also, "All known transfer recipient information" is very broad and<br />
not likely <strong>to</strong> lead <strong>to</strong> information relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
4. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 4 as overly-broad and requests that it be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> permit the disclosure of loan applications only and for the time period of<br />
January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
5. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 5 as overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue<br />
currently before the court and requests that it be modified <strong>to</strong> permit statements for<br />
savings accounts only and for the time period of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30,<br />
2011.<br />
6. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 6 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
5
001bb<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
13<br />
14<br />
15<br />
16<br />
17<br />
18<br />
19<br />
20<br />
21<br />
22<br />
23<br />
24<br />
25<br />
26<br />
27<br />
28<br />
overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
7. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 7 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
8. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 8 and requests that it be quashed. First, the<br />
request is vague as <strong>to</strong> "relevant attachments or supporting documents." Second, the<br />
Court already ruled that Petitioner was not entitled <strong>to</strong> receive <strong>Respondent's</strong> credit<br />
reports, but she is attempting <strong>to</strong> by-pass that ruling with this request. Sales projections<br />
and schedules of assets and liabilities are also not relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue of the<br />
modification of child support because such documentation would not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
9. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 9 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Correspondence between the bank<br />
and the Respondent and/or third parties is not relevant <strong>to</strong> any proceedings currently<br />
before the court.<br />
10. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 10 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong><br />
other accounts will not prove or disprove <strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
11. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 11.<br />
12. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 12 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
overly-broad.<br />
SUBPOENA OF HSBC BANK USA<br />
The following are <strong>Respondent's</strong> objections <strong>to</strong> the subpoena served on HSBC<br />
Bank USA. A copy of "Exhibit 1" attached <strong>to</strong> the subpoena is attached as Exhibit E <strong>to</strong><br />
this declaration.<br />
1. Respondent requests that number 1 be modified <strong>to</strong> eliminate the request for<br />
signature cards as they are not relevant <strong>to</strong> the court proceedings. He also requests that<br />
number 1 be limited <strong>to</strong> the timeframe of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
Otherwise, Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 1.<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
6
001bl<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
13<br />
14<br />
15<br />
16<br />
17<br />
18<br />
19<br />
20<br />
21<br />
22<br />
23<br />
24<br />
25<br />
26<br />
27<br />
28<br />
la. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 1 a except that he requests that the<br />
timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
1 b. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number lb except that he requests that the<br />
timeframe be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
2. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> number 2 but he requests that the timeframe<br />
be limited <strong>to</strong> January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 3 and requests that it be quashed.<br />
Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong> other accounts will not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income. Also, "All known transfer recipient information" is very broad and<br />
not likely <strong>to</strong> lead <strong>to</strong> information relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
4. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 4 as overly-broad and requests that it be<br />
modified <strong>to</strong> permit the disclosure of loan applications only and for the time period of<br />
January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
5. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 5 as overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue<br />
currently before the court and requests that it be modified <strong>to</strong> permit statements for<br />
savings accounts only and for the time period of January 1, 2009 <strong>to</strong> September 30,<br />
2011.<br />
6. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 6 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
overly-broad and irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
7. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 7 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court.<br />
8. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 8 and requests that it be quashed. First, the<br />
request is vague as <strong>to</strong> "relevant attachments or supporting documents." Second, the<br />
Court already ruled that Petitioner was not entitled <strong>to</strong> receive <strong>Respondent's</strong> credit<br />
reports, but she is attempting <strong>to</strong> by-pass that ruling with this request. Sales projections<br />
and schedules of assets and liabilities are also not relevant <strong>to</strong> the issue of the<br />
modification of child support because such documentation would not prove or disprove<br />
<strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
7
001b 8<br />
9. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 9 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Correspondence between the bank<br />
and the Respondent and/or third parties is not relevant <strong>to</strong> any proceedings currently<br />
before the court.<br />
10. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 10 and requests that it be quashed as being<br />
irrelevant <strong>to</strong> the issue currently before the court. Information regarding transfers <strong>to</strong><br />
other accounts will not prove or disprove <strong>Respondent's</strong> income.<br />
11. Respondent does not object <strong>to</strong> the items requested in number 11.<br />
12. Respondent objects <strong>to</strong> number 12 and asks that it be quashed as being<br />
overly-broad.<br />
END OF DECLARATION<br />
ATTACHMENT 10 TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER - MOTION TO QUASH<br />
8
Legal Tabs Co. 1-800-322-3022<br />
Recycled 04 S<strong>to</strong>ck # EXA-5-8<br />
EXHIBIT A
0 0 1 1 0<br />
EXHIBIT 1<br />
For Michael Caldwell SS# 547-88-5645 DOB 11/19/1964<br />
Last known address 4181 Tamilyn Ct, San Diego, CA 92122<br />
All records in the name of Michael Caldwell for the period from January 1, 2008 through<br />
September 30, 2011, <strong>to</strong> include, but not limited <strong>to</strong>, the following:<br />
1. Loan applications received by you for Michael Caldwell between January 2008 and September<br />
2011 for the purpose of obtaining credit or credit approval for any reason.<br />
2. Copies of statements of any credit card accounts with your company for the period January 1,<br />
2008 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Copies of any payments made <strong>to</strong> any of Michael Caldwell's accounts, checks, electronic<br />
(including the origination location)-ie bank account number.<br />
4. Any relevant attachments or supporting documents; especially copies of Federal and State tax<br />
returns, financial statements, revenue and exT else summaries, sales projections, credit reports<br />
and ratings, schedules of assets and liabilities along with applicable bank verifications, and<br />
officers notes, etc.<br />
5. All correspondence between the subject, bank and any other third parties.<br />
6. Any and all other information not specifically requested above.
EXHIBIT B<br />
0 0 1 1 1<br />
Legal Tabs Co. 1-800-322-3022<br />
S<strong>to</strong>ck # EXA- 5- B
00112<br />
EXHIBIT I.<br />
re: Michael Caldwell SS# 547-88-5645 DOB 11/19/1964<br />
Last known address 4181 Tamilvn Ct, San Dieiao, CA 92122<br />
All records in the name of Michael Caldwell for the period from January 1, 2008 through<br />
September 30, 2011, <strong>to</strong> include, but not limited <strong>to</strong>, the following:<br />
1. Checking account records, including signature cards, bank statements, canceled checks, debit<br />
and credit memos, deposit tickets and deposited items.<br />
Cepies-of all deposit items-actual depos-i-ted check or item-eepics and the-corresponding<br />
deposit slips<br />
b. Copies of all checks written from all accounts<br />
2. Copies of statements of any credit card accounts<br />
3. Copies of any transfers made from account listing all known transfer recipient information<br />
4. Loans, <strong>to</strong> include applications, notes. morts.tattes. credit cards, or other instruments of<br />
indebtedness, ledgers. records of advancing those loans, that is, checks, deposit tickets, debit<br />
memos, records of loan payments, including, copies of checks and receipts issued there<strong>to</strong>,<br />
statements of interest paid on each loan per calendar year.<br />
5. Records of savings accounts. certificates of deposits, and other savings instruments by<br />
whatever name known, <strong>to</strong> include application, signature cards, periodic statements, deposit<br />
tickets, items deposited, withdrawal slips, checks issued on those withdrawals, debit and credit<br />
memos <strong>to</strong> those accounts, ant !RS Form:: 4789 (CAL -renc:y Transfer Report).<br />
6. Records of security nurchses. <strong>to</strong> include applications and financial statements, records of the<br />
purchase and sale of those securities andlor bonds, records of receipt of moneys for the purchase<br />
of the securities and/or bonds, <strong>to</strong> include checks and receipts, records of the sale of any<br />
securities, including checks or credit memos issued by your firm relative <strong>to</strong> those sales.<br />
7. Application, records ol'oal,nent for, end entry records of all safe deposit boxes.<br />
8. An" relevant attachments orsipportri$z documents; especially copies of Federal and State tax<br />
returns, financial statements, :evenue and expense summaries, sales projections, credit reports<br />
and ratings. schedules of assets and liabilities along with applicable bank verifications, and<br />
officers notes, etc.<br />
9. Corporate Resolution documents. collateral cards or register, hypothecation certificates, and<br />
Bank's Central File regarcing the s ,aoject. Ail correspondence between the subject, bank and any<br />
other third parties.
00113<br />
10. Copies of any transfers made <strong>to</strong> any other account listing all known transfer information11.<br />
Statements of any other type of accounts<br />
11. Copies of all payments received by your bank (via transfer, or by check, or other payment<br />
method) for payment of a credit card or other loan account type<br />
12. Any and all other information not specifically requested above.
Legal Tabs Co. 1-800-322-3022 Recycled *<br />
S<strong>to</strong>ck<br />
# EXA-5-B<br />
EXHIBIT C
EXHIBIT 1<br />
00115<br />
For Michael Caldwell SS# 547-88-5645 DOB 11/19/1964<br />
Last known address 4181 Tamilyn Ct, San Diego, CA 92122<br />
All records in the name of Michael Caldwell for the period from January 1, 2008 through<br />
September 30, 2011, <strong>to</strong> include, but not limited <strong>to</strong>, the following:<br />
1. Loan applications received by you for Michael Caldwell between January 2008 and September<br />
2011 for the purpose of obtaining credit or credit approval for any reason.<br />
2. Copies of statements of any credit card accounts with your company for the period January 1,<br />
2008 <strong>to</strong> September 30, 2011.<br />
3. Copies of any payments made <strong>to</strong> any of Michael Caldwell's accounts, checks, electronic<br />
(including the origination location)-ie bank account number.<br />
4. Any relevant attachments or supporting documents; especially copies of Federal and State tax<br />
returns, financial statements, revenue and excensc summaries, sales projections, credit reports<br />
and ratings, schedules of assets and liabilities along with applicable bank verifications, and<br />
officers notes, etc.<br />
5. All correspondence between the subject, bank and any other third parties.<br />
6. Any and all other information not specifically requested above.
Legal Tabs Co. 1-800-322-3022 Recycled *<br />
S<strong>to</strong>ck<br />
# EXA-5-B<br />
EXHIBIT D
EXHIBIT 1<br />
0 0 1 1 1<br />
re: Michael Caldwell SS# 547-88-5645 DOB 11/19/1964<br />
Last known address 4181 Tamilyn Ct, San Diego, CA 92122<br />
All records in the name of Michael Caldwell for the period from January 1, 2008 through<br />
September 30, 2011, <strong>to</strong> include, but not limited <strong>to</strong>, the following:<br />
1. Checking account records, including signature cards, bank statements, canceled checks, debit<br />
and credit memos, deposit tickets and deposited items.<br />
a. Copies of all deposit items-actual deposited check or item copies and the corresponding<br />
deposit slips<br />
b. Copies of all checks written from all accounts<br />
2. Copies of statements of any credit card accounts<br />
3. Copies of any transfers made from account listing all known transfer recipient information<br />
4. Loans, <strong>to</strong> include applications, notes, mortgages, credit cards, or other instruments of<br />
indebtedness, ledgers, records of advancing those loans, that is, checks, deposit tickets, debit<br />
memos, records of loan payments, including copies of checks and receipts issued there<strong>to</strong>,<br />
statements of interest paid on each loan per calendar year.<br />
5. Records of savings accounts, certificates of deposits, and other savings instruments by<br />
whatever name known, <strong>to</strong> include application, signature cards, periodic statements, deposit<br />
tickets, items deposited, withdrawal slips, checks issued on those withdrawals, debit and credit<br />
memos <strong>to</strong> those accounts, and. IRS Form: , 47n- (C1 ,-rency Transfer Report).<br />
6. Records of security purchases, <strong>to</strong> include applications and financial statements, records of the<br />
purchase and sale of those securities and/or bonds, records of receipt of moneys for the purchase<br />
of the securities and/or bonds, .1:0 include checks and receipts, records of the sale of any<br />
securities, including checks or credit memos issued by your firm relative <strong>to</strong> those sales.<br />
7. Application, records of payment for, and entry records of all safe deposit boxes.<br />
8. Any relevant attachments 0: supporting, docements:, especially copies of Federal and State tax<br />
returns, financial statements, ).-evenue and expense summaries, sales projections, credit reports<br />
and ratings, schedules of assets and liabilities along with applicable bank verifications, and<br />
officers notes, etc.<br />
9. Corporate Resolution documents, collateral cards or register, hypothecation certificates, and<br />
Bank's Central File regarding the subject.. All correspondence between the subject, bank and any<br />
other third parties.
10. Copies of any transfers made <strong>to</strong> any other account listing all known transfer information) 1.<br />
Statements of any other type of accounts<br />
11. Copies of all payments received by your bank (via transfer, or by check, or other payment<br />
method) for payment of a credit card or other loan account type<br />
12. Any and all other information not specifically requested above.
Legal Tabs Co. 1-800.322-3022 Recycled S<strong>to</strong>ck # EXA-5-B<br />
EXHIBIT E
EXHIBIT I<br />
00180<br />
re: Michael Caldwell SS# 547-88-5645 DOB 11/19/1964<br />
Last known address 4181 Tamilyn Ct, San Diego, CA 92122<br />
All records in the name of Michael Caldwell for the period from January 1, 2008 through<br />
September 30, 2011, <strong>to</strong> include, but not limited <strong>to</strong>, the following:<br />
1. Checking account records, including signature cards, bank statements, canceled checks, debit<br />
and credit memos, deposit tickets and deposited hems.<br />
a. Copies of all deposit items-actual deposited check or item copies and the corresponding<br />
deposit slips<br />
b. Copies of all checks written from all accounts<br />
2. Copies of statements of any credit card accounts<br />
3. Copies of any transfers made from account. listing all known transfer recipient information<br />
4. Loans, <strong>to</strong> include applications, notes, mortgages, credit cards, or other instruments of<br />
indebtedness, ledgers, records of advancing those loans, that is, checks, deposit tickets, debit<br />
memos, records of loan payments, including copies of checks and receipts issued there<strong>to</strong>,<br />
statements of interest paid on each loan per calendar year.<br />
5. Records of savings accounts, certificates of deposits, and other savings instruments by<br />
whatever name known, <strong>to</strong> include application, signature cards, periodic statements, deposit<br />
tickets, items deposited, withdraw& slips, checks issued on those withdrawals, debit and credit<br />
memos <strong>to</strong> those accounts, and. IRS Foam 4789 f,Co.3. -rmcy Transfer Report).<br />
6. Records of security purchases. <strong>to</strong> include applications and financial statements, records of the<br />
purchase and sale of those securities and/or bonds, records of receipt of moneys for the purchase<br />
of the securities and/or bonds, <strong>to</strong> include checks and receipts, records of the sale of any<br />
securities, including checks or credit memos issued by your firm relative <strong>to</strong> those sales.<br />
7. Application, records of payment for, and entry records of all safe deposit boxes.<br />
8. Any relevant attachments or Krpportina documents; especially copies of Federal and State tax<br />
returns, financial statements, revenue anei expense summaries, sales projections, credit reports<br />
and ratings, schedules of assets and liabilities along with applicable bank verifications, and<br />
officers notes, etc.<br />
9. Corporate Resolution documents, collateral cards or register, hypothecation certificates, and<br />
Bank's Central File regarding the subject. All correspondence between the subject, bank and any<br />
other third parties.
00181<br />
10. Copies of any transfers made <strong>to</strong> any other account listing all known transfer information] 1.<br />
Statements of any other type of accounts<br />
11. Copies of all payments received by your bank (via transfer, or by check, or other payment<br />
method) for payment of a credit card or ether loan account type<br />
12. Any and all other information not specifically requested above.
SLSC EAST COUNTY EL CAJON<br />
Date 11-15-11 Oper Id CB<br />
Case No. ED47912<br />
Receipt Na. 014136-03562<br />
Trans Type AF<br />
Allocations<br />
Amount<br />
FX 40.00<br />
Total Allocated 40.00<br />
Tender CK Amt 40.00<br />
Tender Amt<br />
--.. Total Amt Paid 40.00<br />
Change 0.00