25.01.2015 Views

A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth

A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth

A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Financial Services Practice<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>:<br />

The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for<br />

Private Banks to Look Beyond<br />

The Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>:<br />

The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for<br />

Private Banks to Look Beyond<br />

The Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

Introduction<br />

1<br />

How Private Banks Are Navigating Choppy Waters<br />

5<br />

Looking Beyond Ultra-High-Net-Worth Clients<br />

9<br />

Crafting a Core Millionaire Offering<br />

15<br />

Issues for Management Teams to Consider<br />

23


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

1<br />

Introduction<br />

Private banking has long been one <strong>of</strong> the most<br />

attractive and rewarding businesses in financial<br />

services – a rarified world where elite bankers serve<br />

as trusted advisors to wealthy clients and their<br />

families, providing them with customized solutions<br />

to a myriad <strong>of</strong> complex financial issues and the<br />

ultimate in personal service. Traditionally, private<br />

banks have focused on high-net-worth individuals<br />

with a minimum <strong>of</strong> $10 million in investable assets<br />

and <strong>of</strong>ten significantly more substantial levels <strong>of</strong><br />

wealth. This focus intensified over the past decade<br />

as private banks invested in an array <strong>of</strong> specialized<br />

capabilities and teams <strong>of</strong> well-compensated<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essionals from relationship managers to<br />

specialists in customized investment strategies, tax<br />

and estate planning and advisory services in art<br />

and philanthropy.<br />

Having steadily taken their business models up-market, however, private<br />

banks risk neglecting one <strong>of</strong> the largest growth opportunities <strong>of</strong> the next<br />

decade: the “Core Millionaire.” Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, who have between $1<br />

million and $10 million to invest, have <strong>of</strong>ten been served only as an accommodation<br />

or in the hope that their assets will grow. These 4.2 million


2<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

households include doctors, lawyers, engineers, successful small to mid-size<br />

entrepreneurs and frugal savers who have different needs than the ultrahigh-net-worth<br />

(UHNW) segment with $10 million or more in assets. They<br />

are more concerned about wealth preservation and retirement than philanthropy<br />

and legacy issues. In the coming years, they will also be the fastestgrowing,<br />

largest and most pr<strong>of</strong>itable segment <strong>of</strong> the wealth market. The Core<br />

Millionaire segment:<br />

• Accounts for 27 percent <strong>of</strong> the typical private bank’s assets today, but<br />

will generate nearly two-thirds <strong>of</strong> the asset growth in wealth management<br />

by 2015.<br />

• Represents the acquisition “sweet spot” for private banks, as<br />

high-net-worth clients who are considering financial advisors for the<br />

first time.<br />

• Delivers revenue margins two-to-three times the average for the UHNW<br />

segment at a lower cost-to-serve.<br />

• Generates a higher proportion <strong>of</strong> business in pr<strong>of</strong>itable deposit, lending<br />

and discretionary investment products than the UHNW segment.<br />

• Will generate over 80 percent <strong>of</strong> all net new revenue growth in wealth<br />

management by 2015.<br />

For many institutions, focusing on Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> will require a fundamental<br />

shift in how they provide private banking services, because private<br />

bankers <strong>of</strong>ten indulge this segment with the customized personal service<br />

intended for UHNW clients.<br />

In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>,<br />

private banks need to create a multifaceted<br />

product and service line that <strong>of</strong>fers<br />

value, but can be delivered at lower cost.<br />

In particular, banks need to address three<br />

imperatives:<br />

• Develop an integrated investment and banking experience that feels<br />

customized, but <strong>of</strong>fers standardized packages <strong>of</strong> services that meet<br />

the typical needs <strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>.<br />

In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong>, private banks need to<br />

create a multi-faceted product and<br />

service line that <strong>of</strong>fers value, but can<br />

be delivered at lower cost.<br />

• Design solutions for specific segments <strong>of</strong> the Core Millionaire market,<br />

for example, entrepreneurs in selected industries, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or retirees<br />

with wealth preservation and income goals.


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

3<br />

• Implement a disciplined and pr<strong>of</strong>itable service model – providing<br />

services centrally, increasing the coverage and productivity <strong>of</strong><br />

bankers and account managers, <strong>of</strong>fering selective tax and estate<br />

guidance as required, and enforcing pricing discipline.<br />

Despite market uncertainty, the outlook for private banking over the next<br />

decade is strong, but growth will come from new client segments with different<br />

needs. Private banks that are able to adapt their business models to<br />

serve not just the UHNW market, but also Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, will find ample<br />

opportunities for pr<strong>of</strong>itable growth.


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

5<br />

How Private Banks Are<br />

Navigating Choppy Waters<br />

During the pre-crisis bull market, private banks<br />

enjoyed tremendous growth and welcomed clients<br />

below their stated minimums. Although private banks’<br />

business models were geared to serve clients with<br />

assets above $10 million, the high pr<strong>of</strong>its from rapid<br />

market growth obscured structural issues in the<br />

service model for the lower end <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />

In the wake <strong>of</strong> the financial crisis, wealth managers, including U.S. private<br />

banks, experienced a dramatic reversal. Not only did private banking<br />

asset levels fall sharply – 25 percent over the course <strong>of</strong> 2008 – but<br />

average pr<strong>of</strong>it margins contracted from 35 basis points in 2007 to 24<br />

basis points in 2009.<br />

Despite efforts to improve pr<strong>of</strong>itability since 2008, private banking continues<br />

to face challenges. Results from McKinsey’s Global Private Banking<br />

Survey show that asset gains in 2009 and 2010 came entirely from market<br />

appreciation and that net new<br />

asset flows from clients were<br />

negligible (Exhibit 1, page 6).<br />

Asset gains in 2009 and 2010<br />

came entirely from market<br />

appreciation, and net new asset<br />

flows from clients were negligible.<br />

Additionally, many clients have<br />

changed their asset allocation<br />

strategies since the crisis and<br />

shifted toward asset classes with lower fees. McKinsey’s benchmarking<br />

results show that the proportion <strong>of</strong> equities and alternative investments<br />

in private banks’ managed assets, which dropped from 54 percent to 36<br />

percent in 2008, recovered only partially to 45 percent by 2010. More-


6<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

Exhibit 1<br />

Private banking net flows have been flat over past 2 years<br />

Net flows by wealth manager category<br />

Percent change<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

Private banks<br />

0.8<br />

0.4<br />

Wirehouses<br />

-1.6<br />

-0.8<br />

Discount brokerages<br />

8.0<br />

3.5<br />

Independent advisors<br />

6.1<br />

5.8<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />

over, banking and lending revenue – critical to the pr<strong>of</strong>itability <strong>of</strong> most private<br />

banks – has suffered in the recent low-interest rate environment.<br />

Consequently, the industry pr<strong>of</strong>it pool has dropped about 50 percent below<br />

its pre-crisis peak (Exhibit 2).<br />

Not only has the level and growth rate <strong>of</strong> private banks’ pr<strong>of</strong>its declined, the<br />

post-crisis environment has also exposed fundamental weaknesses in the industry’s<br />

business model – in particular, the high cost <strong>of</strong> serving clients at the<br />

lower end <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />

The decrease in managed assets was not entirely involuntary. In reaction to<br />

the financial crisis, some private banks moved to improve their pr<strong>of</strong>itability by<br />

focusing on the UHNW segment, with the goal <strong>of</strong> reducing their average cost<br />

<strong>of</strong> service. Some institutions proactively stopped serving clients at lower<br />

asset levels, so that industry benchmarking for both 2009 and 2010 shows<br />

net outflows among clients with less than $10 million in assets. These were<br />

<strong>of</strong>fset by inflows from clients with over $10 million in assets (Exhibit 3).<br />

Today, private bankers are skeptical about their ability to recapture momentum<br />

in growth. In McKinsey’s 2011 Private Banking Survey, just one in five<br />

banks surveyed believed that acquiring new clients would contribute significantly<br />

to near-term revenue growth. Instead, they expect to rely on market<br />

appreciation and pricing. To some extent, these low expectations reflect the<br />

defensive posture <strong>of</strong> the industry following the crisis, as well as increased


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

7<br />

Exhibit 2<br />

Total private banking pr<strong>of</strong>its are down by over 50% since 2007<br />

Average assets<br />

Indexed at 2007<br />

100<br />

76<br />

67<br />

70<br />

-30%<br />

Revenues<br />

Indexed at 2007<br />

100<br />

73<br />

63<br />

67<br />

-33%<br />

Costs<br />

Indexed at 2007<br />

100<br />

81<br />

76<br />

81<br />

-19%<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>its<br />

Indexed at 2007<br />

100<br />

64<br />

47<br />

49<br />

-51%<br />

2007<br />

2008<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

2007<br />

2008<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

2007<br />

2008<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

2007<br />

2008<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />

Exhibit 3<br />

Private banking client mix has shifted toward UHNW households<br />

over past 2 years<br />

Private banking asset growth by wealth band<br />

Percent change<br />

Assets<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

$30 million +<br />

10.0<br />

5.1<br />

$10-30 million<br />

11.7<br />

4.0<br />

$1-10 million<br />

-0.4<br />

-2.9<br />


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

9<br />

Looking Beyond<br />

Ultra-High-Net-Worth Clients<br />

Private banks that build a business model that effectively<br />

courts and pr<strong>of</strong>itably serves Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

will be well positioned to generate pr<strong>of</strong>itable growth.<br />

Several factors argue for more strategic attention to<br />

this segment <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />

• The predominant source <strong>of</strong> new wealth. While only 27 percent <strong>of</strong> current<br />

private banking assets come from households with $1 million to<br />

$10 million in investable assets, the Core Millionaire segment already<br />

holds a large slice <strong>of</strong> U.S. household net worth and is expected to account<br />

for 60 percent <strong>of</strong> the asset growth among individuals with over<br />

$1 million in assets through 2015 (Exhibit 4, page 10).<br />

• Acquisition sweet spot. Private banking clients, especially UHNW<br />

clients, tend to skew disproportionately toward an older demographic.<br />

Overall, fewer than 15 percent <strong>of</strong> private banking clients are under 40.<br />

McKinsey’s interviews with clients and bankers suggest that those<br />

who inherit UHNW estates are more likely than ever to seek new financial<br />

advisors, rather than rely on their parents’ bankers. Long-term<br />

success will therefore require building relationships with Gen X and<br />

Millennial clients, who are in the market for wealth management services<br />

for the first time. These clients typically enter the market at the<br />

lower end <strong>of</strong> the $1 million to $10 million in assets range and are<br />

much easier to acquire at the point <strong>of</strong> entry than after they have developed<br />

a relationship elsewhere.<br />

• Higher investment fee income. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, with $1 million to<br />

$10 million in investable assets, are large enough to justify relationship<br />

banking but do not have the pricing leverage <strong>of</strong> the wealthiest


10 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

Exhibit 4<br />

From 2011 to 2015, Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> are projected to create nearly<br />

twice as much net new wealth as UHNW households<br />

U.S. onshore personal financial assets<br />

(PFA) by wealth band<br />

$ trillion<br />

31.1<br />

PFA growth,<br />

2010-2015<br />

$ trillion<br />

PFA growth,<br />

2010-2015<br />

Percent total<br />

26.0<br />

24.7<br />

25.7<br />

23.3<br />

5.3<br />

20.8<br />

4.7<br />

5.0<br />

5.2<br />

4.1<br />

10.3<br />

9.1 9.7<br />

10.1<br />

8.0<br />

26.8<br />

5.5<br />

10.6<br />

6.5<br />

12.5<br />

Ultra-High-<br />

Net-Worth<br />

>$10 million<br />

Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

$1-10 million<br />

10<br />

>30<br />

28<br />

38<br />

10-30<br />

51<br />

Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

1-10<br />

2.5-10<br />

72<br />

85<br />

1-2.5<br />

107<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

11<br />

families. McKinsey’s research shows that the industry average ratio <strong>of</strong><br />

revenue on client assets (ROCA) is 85 basis points for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

versus an average <strong>of</strong> 38 basis points for UHNW clients (Exhibit 5).<br />

Moreover, private banking clients with less than $10 million in assets<br />

usually expect their private banker to directly manage their assets. On<br />

average, less than 5 percent <strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>’ assets are held in<br />

custody, compared to 25 percent to 30 percent <strong>of</strong> UHNW clients’ assets.<br />

Custody assets typically have revenue margins under 10 basis<br />

points and sometimes much lower.<br />

• Greater use <strong>of</strong> lending and deposit products. McKinsey’s 2011<br />

benchmarking reflects the important link between banking product<br />

penetration and overall revenue margins. In top-quartile private<br />

McKinsey’s Global <strong>Wealth</strong> Sizing<br />

McKinsey & Company’s proprietary Global <strong>Wealth</strong> Distribution<br />

database provides current and future projections <strong>of</strong> high-net-worth<br />

assets. The firm’s sizing <strong>of</strong> the global high-net-worth market includes<br />

detailed projections for all regions and over 50 markets (both onshore<br />

and <strong>of</strong>fshore assets). Among the highlights for 2011:<br />

• Total onshore assets <strong>of</strong> U.S. high-net-worth households will<br />

increase by $3.7 trillion over the next four years, with 955,000 net<br />

new households having at least $1 million to invest.<br />

• Financial assets <strong>of</strong> high-net-worth individuals have grown over<br />

24 percent annually since 2008 in Asia (excluding Japan) and are<br />

expected to increase at a rate <strong>of</strong> approximately 19 percent over the<br />

next four years.<br />

• Despite faster economic growth in emerging markets, over 40 percent<br />

<strong>of</strong> the world’s millionaires reside in North America, and a large<br />

majority <strong>of</strong> their assets are onshore.<br />

• Among major regions, Latin America has the highest concentration<br />

<strong>of</strong> wealth in ultra-high-net-worth households with $30 million or<br />

more in assets – representing 32 percent <strong>of</strong> total personal financial<br />

assets compared to a global average <strong>of</strong> 15 percent.


12 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

Exhibit 6<br />

High yields on Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> are driven by attractive product mix<br />

Composition <strong>of</strong> U.S. private banking client assets by wealth band<br />

<strong>Wealth</strong> band<br />

$ million<br />

Share <strong>of</strong> assets<br />

Percent<br />

Managed<br />

assets<br />

Non-managed<br />

assets<br />

Deposits<br />

Loans<br />

Ultra-High-<br />

Net-Worth<br />

>10<br />

>100<br />

47<br />

42<br />

6 5<br />

30-100<br />

59<br />

21<br />

10<br />

10<br />

10-30<br />

67<br />

11<br />

11 11<br />

Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

1-10<br />

2.5-10<br />

67<br />

6<br />

12<br />

14<br />

1-2.5<br />

65<br />

3<br />

15<br />

17<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />

Exhibit 7<br />

Through 2015, new revenue pools created in the Core Millionaire<br />

segment will be quadruple those created in the UHNW segment<br />

<strong>Wealth</strong> band<br />

$ million<br />

Net new revenue pool 2010-2015<br />

(at current private banking revenue margins)<br />

$ billion<br />

Group<br />

total<br />

Ultra-High-<br />

Net-Worth<br />

>10<br />

>30<br />

1.9<br />

5.0<br />

10-30<br />

3.1<br />

Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

1-10<br />

2.5-10<br />

10.6<br />

20.4<br />

1-2.5<br />

9.8<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

13<br />

banks, deposits and lending products accounted for over 55 percent<br />

<strong>of</strong> total revenue, compared to 35 percent for their bottom-quartile<br />

peers. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

can be important to boosting<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>its, since they are<br />

more likely to require<br />

credit and cash management<br />

services. On average,<br />

lending and deposit<br />

products represent 28 percent<br />

<strong>of</strong> total account balances for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, twice the average<br />

for wealthier families (Exhibit 6).<br />

On average, lending and<br />

deposit products represent 30<br />

percent <strong>of</strong> total account balances<br />

for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, twice the<br />

average for wealthier families.<br />

Overall, the incremental revenue opportunity from the Core Millionaire segment<br />

is more than four times larger than from UHNW clients (Exhibit 7).


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

15<br />

Crafting a Core<br />

Millionaire Offering<br />

Private banks should take a page from the luxury retail<br />

playbook and begin to think about their traditional<br />

<strong>of</strong>fering for the UHNW market as a high-end brand –<br />

necessary, but not sufficient, for success. Private banks<br />

could introduce the equivalent <strong>of</strong> complementary<br />

brands to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>.<br />

Tiffany & Co. serves as an instructive example. At the time <strong>of</strong> its 1987 IPO,<br />

the jewelry chain had eight stores and was almost exclusively focused on<br />

selling high-end jewelry. Starting in the mid-1990s, Tiffany began to develop<br />

sterling silver and gold items priced below $1,000. Today, these<br />

products drive nearly $1 billion in annual sales and represent almost onethird<br />

<strong>of</strong> the company’s overall revenue. Tiffany has bifurcated its sales<br />

model to generate pr<strong>of</strong>its in lower-priced merchandise, while maintaining<br />

an exclusive buying experience for its wealthier clients. Today, a typical<br />

Tiffany store has a dedicated area for high-end jewelry sales that is spacious<br />

and located near the front <strong>of</strong> the store, with numerous salespeople.<br />

Sterling silver products are located in a separate, smaller area with fewer<br />

salespeople and are also increasingly sold online. Tiffany & Co. is not alone<br />

in developing different business models to serve various client segments –<br />

similar examples can be found in apparel (Ralph Lauren), automobiles<br />

(Ferrari) and hospitality (Starwood).<br />

What these consumer brands have in common is that they have expanded<br />

beyond their core operating models in order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably meet the needs <strong>of</strong><br />

new customers. In contrast, private banks <strong>of</strong>ten attempt to serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />

with the same value proposition and service model designed for<br />

UHNW clients.


16<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itability serve the Core Millionaire segment, many banks will<br />

need to craft new value propositions and service models that meet the needs<br />

<strong>of</strong> these clients and capture their revenue potential. The Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

should include comprehensive investment and banking products, augmented<br />

by a limited but substantive set <strong>of</strong> other specialized services, with controlled<br />

access to a relationship manager.<br />

• An integrated private banking experience that feels privileged, but is costeffective.<br />

Clients have diverse service preferences – ranging from those<br />

who prize the exclusivity and personalized service <strong>of</strong> a private bank to<br />

those who see dedicated bankers and relationship managers as signs <strong>of</strong><br />

excessive fees. Private banks should design their value proposition to<br />

focus on partially self-directed clients who want the advice and products<br />

<strong>of</strong>fered by a private bank and are willing to<br />

pay for an <strong>of</strong>fering that can be pr<strong>of</strong>itably delivered.<br />

These clients would welcome a tailored<br />

<strong>of</strong>fering that emphasizes:<br />

Full-service brokers who serve<br />

high-net-worth clients <strong>of</strong>ten<br />

struggle to broaden their<br />

investment advice beyond<br />

traditional products.<br />

◦ Outcome-oriented, tax-efficient planning<br />

“at your fingertips.” In recent decades,<br />

the emergence <strong>of</strong> sophisticated family <strong>of</strong>fices<br />

that serve the UHNW segment has<br />

driven private bankers to focus more on customized investments and<br />

specialized services. For Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, private banks should revive<br />

their traditional emphasis on tax-efficient, outcome-oriented financial<br />

planning focused on individual and family goals. Full-service brokers<br />

who serve high-net-worth clients <strong>of</strong>ten struggle to broaden their investment<br />

advice beyond traditional products. Clients frequently complain<br />

that their financial advisor does not even ask about their other assets.<br />

These clients are looking for a pr<strong>of</strong>essional “financial quarterback,” and<br />

private bankers are well-positioned to fill this role.<br />

To enable private bankers to efficiently deliver an integrated planning<br />

experience at scale, private banks should focus on developing userfriendly<br />

online platforms that aggregate assets across multiple institutions<br />

and reflect progress against financial plans. The popularity <strong>of</strong> web<br />

sites such as Mint.com and independent financial planning services<br />

highlights an unmet need for comprehensive financial planning.<br />

Bankers and their teams should be trained to integrate these platforms<br />

into their service models (e.g., incorporating them into client conversa-


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

17<br />

tions, setting alerts that trigger real-time advice) and to layer on valueadded<br />

services (e.g., interfacing with family accountants).<br />

◦ Rewards for consolidating assets. Clients with less than $10 million in<br />

assets tend to concentrate their assets with one provider to ensure<br />

that they qualify as a “premium relationship,” unlike UHNW families,<br />

who <strong>of</strong>ten allocate assets across multiple institutions and receive premium<br />

service everywhere. Banks can capitalize on this tendency via<br />

relationship pricing and by creating benefits, such as greater access<br />

to specialists and additional services, at tiered asset levels (e.g., a<br />

loyalty ladder with incremental benefits for every additional $1 million<br />

<strong>of</strong> assets up to $10 million).<br />

◦ Private bank packaging without customized solutions. The needs <strong>of</strong><br />

the Core Millionaire segment can typically be addressed through a<br />

standard model portfolio that is delivered in a manner that reflects<br />

the cachet <strong>of</strong> the private bank. Too <strong>of</strong>ten, private banks deploy their<br />

full set <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional skills to design customized solutions for<br />

clients who do not require this level <strong>of</strong> advice or service. In the absence<br />

<strong>of</strong> an alternative approach to financial advice, bankers simply<br />

tend to employ the service model that they <strong>of</strong>fer to UHNW clients.<br />

Private banks need to work with their bankers to build five to seven<br />

standard portfolios <strong>of</strong> investments aimed at particular outcomes<br />

(e.g., income in retirement), with a flexible overlay that makes the<br />

plan feel custom-tailored.<br />

◦ Access to exclusive proprietary products. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> value exclusive<br />

investment opportunities in alternative asset classes and other<br />

non-traditional investments,<br />

but these opportunities do<br />

not necessarily require custom-tailoring.<br />

Private banks<br />

should focus on proprietary<br />

<strong>of</strong>ferings to reinforce privatebanking<br />

exclusivity and<br />

maintain the premium revenue<br />

margins associated<br />

with the Core Millionaire segment.<br />

Creating an attractive portfolio <strong>of</strong> investment products requires<br />

collaboration with capital markets organizations (“white label” partner-<br />

Private banks should focus on<br />

proprietary <strong>of</strong>ferings to reinforce<br />

private-banking exclusivity<br />

and maintain the premium<br />

revenue margins associated with<br />

the Core Millionaire segment.


18<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

ships for smaller regional institutions) and specialist wholesalers who<br />

focus on proprietary solutions.<br />

• Solutions that address the critical needs <strong>of</strong> key market segments. Private<br />

banking clients with $1 million to $10 million in assets can be grouped into<br />

major market segments – e.g., retirees, business owners, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals –<br />

each with a distinctive pr<strong>of</strong>ile. Since banks cannot create a pr<strong>of</strong>itable<br />

model in the $1 million to $10 million space if they try to address all possible<br />

client needs, understanding the common needs <strong>of</strong> these sub-segments<br />

<strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is crucial to developing a compelling <strong>of</strong>fering.<br />

◦ Help Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> retire “rich.” Retirees in the Core Millionaire segment<br />

require careful financial planning to comfortably maintain their<br />

lifestyle throughout retirement. Unlike UHNW retirees who will remain<br />

wealthy under almost any circumstances, retirement outcomes for<br />

Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> can vary widely based on the financial decisions they<br />

make today. To support these clients, private banks need to:<br />

u<br />

u<br />

u<br />

Focus their advisory models for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> on wealth preservation<br />

and income generation rather than UHNW concerns about<br />

legacy and philanthropy. In particular, concentrate on trade-<strong>of</strong>fs<br />

between spending versus leaving an inheritance and the issue <strong>of</strong><br />

retirement risk tolerance (e.g., spending more in early retirement<br />

while active versus conserving assets to avoid income reduction in<br />

late retirement).<br />

Recraft <strong>of</strong>fering from wealth accumulation to income generation by<br />

creating target-date and target-interest products and strategies that<br />

allow retirees to comfortably draw<br />

down their savings based on a wellthought-out<br />

plan.<br />

Play a proactive role in cash management,<br />

including guidance on spending<br />

decisions as retirees transition to new<br />

lifestyles, e.g., retirement lifestyle<br />

benchmarks for various locales or<br />

alerts tied to actual spending versus a<br />

planned budget.<br />

According to McKinsey’s Personal<br />

Financial Assets Survey, business<br />

owners are 25-to-30 percent more<br />

likely to require immediate access<br />

to funds and to feel financially<br />

stressed than pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or<br />

retirees at the same level <strong>of</strong> wealth.<br />

◦ Create liquidity and credit solutions for entrepreneurs. Core Millionaire<br />

business owners represent an important source <strong>of</strong> new assets for


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

19<br />

private banks. Lending and liquidity needs loom especially large for<br />

these clients. According to McKinsey’s Personal Financial Assets<br />

Survey, business owners are 25-to-30 percent more likely to require<br />

immediate access to funds and to feel financially stressed<br />

than pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or retirees at the same level <strong>of</strong> wealth. Entrepreneurs’<br />

investment patterns also differ, with many reporting that they<br />

use their businesses to take investment risks. To serve these<br />

clients, banks should focus on making credit decisions based on<br />

an integrated view <strong>of</strong> personal and business assets and on providing<br />

investment strategies that take into consideration the risks<br />

owners face in their businesses.<br />

◦ Provide tailored solutions for corporate executives and pr<strong>of</strong>essionals.<br />

Corporate executives and pr<strong>of</strong>essionals, such as attorneys,<br />

especially tend to<br />

value the investment and<br />

planning expertise provided<br />

by financial advisors. They<br />

are <strong>of</strong>ten realistic about<br />

their own financial management<br />

ability and want to<br />

engage with institutions and individuals that can deliver expert advice.<br />

To serve these clients most effectively, banks should designate<br />

certain bankers to focus on specific pr<strong>of</strong>essions or<br />

companies and develop strategies for diversifying around the<br />

large restricted equity positions that are a central component <strong>of</strong><br />

executive compensation (e.g., stock and options for corporate executives,<br />

partnership shares for attorneys).<br />

Determining the right sales<br />

and service model for<br />

Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is essential to<br />

capitalizing on the opportunity.<br />

• A pr<strong>of</strong>itable operating model. Determining the right sales and service<br />

model for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is essential to capitalizing on the opportunity.<br />

To serve this segment pr<strong>of</strong>itably, banks should focus on five elements:<br />

◦ Dedicated bankers for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. To pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve this<br />

market, bankers need a different skill set and practice model than<br />

for the UHNW segment. Private banks should concentrate on building<br />

a stable <strong>of</strong> focused bankers who have the client acquisition<br />

skills required to develop a book <strong>of</strong> business and are able to serve<br />

a larger number <strong>of</strong> households by effectively delegating without diminishing<br />

the overall client experience. Creating dedicated pools <strong>of</strong>


20<br />

A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

bankers will entail changes to organizational structures, performance<br />

management and compensation in order to develop and encourage<br />

the required behaviors.<br />

◦ Intelligent use <strong>of</strong> specialists. Not all Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> require frequent<br />

access to specialists in estate planning or trusts. Accordingly, private<br />

banks should be prepared to field a full team <strong>of</strong> specialists if necessary,<br />

but in limited numbers and with clearly defined missions and areas <strong>of</strong><br />

practice. Coverage at many private banks ranges from 100 to 250<br />

clients per specialist, while successful regional banks are able to utilize<br />

specialists at a ratio <strong>of</strong> 500 to 600 clients per specialist.<br />

◦ Extensive application <strong>of</strong> technology to client service functions. Private<br />

banks should place a greater premium on back-<strong>of</strong>fice operations,<br />

which enable Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> to provide some <strong>of</strong> their own client service,<br />

freeing up bankers to recruit and serve more clients. Moreover,<br />

surveys and interviews reveal that not all clients want a high-touch experience<br />

and many are willing to use convenient self-service applications<br />

to complete simple tasks. For example, Fidelity and Schwab hold<br />

Exhibit 8<br />

Banks with bottom quartile revenue margins can double<br />

Core Millionaire investment income through pricing discipline<br />

Average revenue on invested assets<br />

Basis points<br />

Average revenue on deposits and loans<br />

Basis points 1<br />

Top quartile<br />

98<br />

Top quartile<br />

381<br />

2nd quartile<br />

82<br />

2nd quartile<br />

333<br />

3rd quartile<br />

76<br />

3rd quartile<br />

286<br />

Bottom quartile<br />

42<br />

Bottom quartile<br />

248<br />

+133% +54%<br />

1<br />

Total yield on deposits and loans to adjust for FTP anomalies<br />

Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

21<br />

substantial assets from households with more than $5 million in investable<br />

assets and together would rank among the top five private<br />

banks in the U.S.<br />

Banks should provide online capabilities and encourage clients to use<br />

them for transactions whenever feasible. These might include the purchase<br />

or sale <strong>of</strong> securities, cash transfers or other financial housekeeping.<br />

Technology can also be brought to bear on client-facing<br />

activities, such as individual meetings with specialists via videoconference<br />

or the group delivery <strong>of</strong> investment perspectives from firm strategists<br />

through webinars.<br />

◦ Enforcement <strong>of</strong> pricing discipline. As a group, clients with less than<br />

$10 million in assets have substantially less negotiating leverage regarding<br />

fees than wealthier private banking clients. However, individual<br />

private bankers frequently extend standard UHNW discounts and preferred<br />

rates to Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. This lack <strong>of</strong> pricing rigor is evident in<br />

the wide dispersion <strong>of</strong> realized fee rates across institutions, based on<br />

McKinsey’s observations at individual institutions and the 2010 Global<br />

Private Banking Survey (Exhibit 8). The average revenue margin on investments<br />

for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> ranged from 42 basis points to 98<br />

basis points, and total yields on deposits and loans ranged from 248<br />

basis points to 381 basis points. Banks should put in place rigid pricing<br />

guidelines covering the lower end <strong>of</strong> the market and closely track<br />

and manage exceptions.<br />

These suggestions for creating a service level below traditional private banking<br />

for UHNW clients could be counterproductive, if that initiative has a negative<br />

impact on a bank’s established image and reputation with wealthier<br />

clients. But, as in the Tiffany example, private banks should be able to protect<br />

their traditional franchise and preserve their cachet, while creating a new<br />

<strong>of</strong>fering for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. In fact, given the importance <strong>of</strong> the individual<br />

advisor-client relationship in wealth management, private banks that protect<br />

the integrity <strong>of</strong> their traditional business models are unlikely to lose their most<br />

affluent clients.


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

23<br />

Issues for Management<br />

Teams to Consider<br />

Private banks that concentrate primarily on the<br />

UHNW market, as they attempt to revive pr<strong>of</strong>itable<br />

growth, will face stiffer headwinds than in the past.<br />

Banks that broaden their traditional focus on UHNW<br />

clients to build a parallel <strong>of</strong>fering to serve Core<br />

<strong>Millionaires</strong> will gain an important edge. There are<br />

seven major issues that management teams should<br />

consider as they contemplate this move:<br />

• Focus. How well has the bank penetrated the Core Millionaire and<br />

UHNW market segments already How well aligned is its strategic focus<br />

with where growth will be in the future, given its product set, strengths,<br />

brand and service <strong>of</strong>fering<br />

• Business model. What scale (e.g., assets, number <strong>of</strong> bankers, number<br />

<strong>of</strong> specialists) is required to manage two distinct business models How<br />

can a private bank capture synergies between the two models, while<br />

ensuring the pr<strong>of</strong>itability <strong>of</strong> each<br />

• Brand dilution and extension. Will bifurcating the business model dilute<br />

UHNW client relationships How can a private bank retain enough<br />

distinction to preserve the cachet <strong>of</strong> its high-end brand How important<br />

is exclusiveness to UHNW clients versus personal/institutional relationships,<br />

valuable advice and favorable pricing<br />

• Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>fer. What are the appropriate benefits and incentives<br />

to <strong>of</strong>fer clients in the $1 million to $10 million segment to preserve<br />

the image <strong>of</strong> a private bank while maintaining high returns and


24 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

focusing on Core Millionaire issues (wealth preservation, retirement income)<br />

in a customized, yet cost-effective manner<br />

• Micro-market geographic focus. How should the geographic footprint differ<br />

for the UHNW and Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>ferings How can private banks<br />

take advantage <strong>of</strong> opportunities outside <strong>of</strong> traditional money center locations<br />

in areas where the wealth market is smaller and less competitive<br />

• Banker sales and service model. What changes in structure and service<br />

model are required to enable bankers to cover a larger number <strong>of</strong> less affluent<br />

clients What technology and operations investments are necessary<br />

to give bankers the tools to provide comprehensive service to this<br />

market efficiently<br />

• Compensation. How should bankers and specialists be compensated<br />

when serving the $1 million to $10 million segment Can private banks retain<br />

talent in this segment with a salary plus bonus compensation model<br />

* * *<br />

Ultimately, a Core Millionaire focus may not be right for every bank, and not<br />

every institution will be able to make the transition successfully. However,<br />

those that do will realize a growth multiple relative to their peers and will secure<br />

a lasting advantage in serving this market in the years ahead.<br />

Pooneh Baghai<br />

Daniel Gourvitch<br />

Salim Ramji<br />

Jill Zucker<br />

The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions <strong>of</strong> Jeremy Borot,<br />

Owen Jones and Nakul Kapoor to this report.


A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

25<br />

About McKinsey & Company<br />

McKinsey & Company is a management consulting firm that helps many <strong>of</strong><br />

the world’s leading corporations and organizations address their strategic<br />

challenges, from reorganizing for long-term growth to improving business<br />

performance and maximizing pr<strong>of</strong>itability. For more than 80 years, the firm’s<br />

primary objective has been to serve as an organization’s most trusted external<br />

advisor on critical issues facing senior management. With consultants in<br />

more than 40 countries around the globe, McKinsey advises clients on strategic,<br />

operational, organizational and technological issues.<br />

McKinsey’s <strong>Wealth</strong> Management, Asset Management & Retirement Practice<br />

serves asset managers, wealth management companies and retirement players<br />

globally on issues <strong>of</strong> strategy, organization, operations and business performance.<br />

Our partners and consultants in the Americas have deep expertise<br />

in all facets <strong>of</strong> asset management. Our proprietary research spans all institutional<br />

and retail segments, asset classes (e.g., alternatives) and products<br />

(e.g., ETFs, outcome-oriented funds). Our proprietary tools provide deep insights<br />

into the flows, assets and economics <strong>of</strong> each <strong>of</strong> the sub-segments <strong>of</strong><br />

these markets and into the preferences and behaviors <strong>of</strong> consumers, investors<br />

and intermediaries.<br />

To learn more about McKinsey & Company’s specialized expertise and capabilities<br />

related to the asset management industry, or for additional information<br />

about this report, please contact:<br />

Pooneh Baghai<br />

Director<br />

(416) 313-3939<br />

pooneh_baghai@mckinsey.com<br />

Salim Ramji<br />

Director<br />

(212) 446-7393<br />

salim_ramji@mckinsey.com<br />

Céline Dufétel<br />

Principal<br />

(212) 446-8081<br />

celine_dufetel@mckinsey.com<br />

Kweilin Ellingrud<br />

Principal<br />

(612) 371-3132<br />

kweilin_ellingrud@mckinsey.com<br />

Onur Erzan<br />

Principal<br />

(212) 446-7172<br />

onur_erzan@mckinsey.com<br />

Jill Zucker<br />

Principal<br />

(212) 446-7989<br />

jill_zucker@mckinsey.com


26 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />

Further insights<br />

McKinsey’s <strong>Wealth</strong> Management, Asset Management & Retirement Practice<br />

publishes frequently on issues <strong>of</strong> interest to industry executives. Among our<br />

recent reports:<br />

Growth in a Time <strong>of</strong> Uncertainty: The Asset Management Industry in 2015<br />

November 2011<br />

The Second Act Begins for ETFs: A Disruptive Investment Vehicle Vies for Center<br />

Stage in Asset Management<br />

August 2011<br />

Capturing IRA Rollovers: The Net New Money Opportunity for <strong>Wealth</strong> <strong>Managers</strong><br />

July 2011<br />

Winning in the Defined Contribution Market: New Realities Reshape the<br />

Competitive Landscape<br />

September 2010<br />

Restoring Americans’ Retirement Security: A Shared Responsibility<br />

October 2009<br />

Endnote on data sources<br />

This paper incorporates the results <strong>of</strong> McKinsey & Company’s 2011 Global<br />

Private Banking Survey, which provides comprehensive information on the<br />

global private banking industry. The survey covers all relevant markets: North<br />

America, Latin America, Western Europe, Central and Eastern Europe, the<br />

Middle East and Asia. More than 160 banks participated in the survey,<br />

including eight <strong>of</strong> the top 15 private banks in the United States.<br />

Survey participants receive customized benchmarking and feedback sessions<br />

and have access to more detailed information than is presented in this report,<br />

while the confidentiality governing the data supplied by individual participants<br />

is preserved.<br />

In addition, this report draws on McKinsey’s proprietary 2011 Global <strong>Wealth</strong><br />

Sizing, which includes the firm’s projections for high-net-worth financial<br />

assets in all major markets.<br />

McKinsey would like to thank the firms that participated in the 2011 survey<br />

and sizing efforts for their valuable contributions.


Financial Services Practice<br />

March 2012<br />

Designed by Hudspith Design<br />

Copyright © McKinsey & Company<br />

www.mckinsey.com/clientservice/financial_services

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!