A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth
A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth
A Tale of Two Millionaires: - Managers of Wealth
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Financial Services Practice<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>:<br />
The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for<br />
Private Banks to Look Beyond<br />
The Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>:<br />
The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for<br />
Private Banks to Look Beyond<br />
The Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
Introduction<br />
1<br />
How Private Banks Are Navigating Choppy Waters<br />
5<br />
Looking Beyond Ultra-High-Net-Worth Clients<br />
9<br />
Crafting a Core Millionaire Offering<br />
15<br />
Issues for Management Teams to Consider<br />
23
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
1<br />
Introduction<br />
Private banking has long been one <strong>of</strong> the most<br />
attractive and rewarding businesses in financial<br />
services – a rarified world where elite bankers serve<br />
as trusted advisors to wealthy clients and their<br />
families, providing them with customized solutions<br />
to a myriad <strong>of</strong> complex financial issues and the<br />
ultimate in personal service. Traditionally, private<br />
banks have focused on high-net-worth individuals<br />
with a minimum <strong>of</strong> $10 million in investable assets<br />
and <strong>of</strong>ten significantly more substantial levels <strong>of</strong><br />
wealth. This focus intensified over the past decade<br />
as private banks invested in an array <strong>of</strong> specialized<br />
capabilities and teams <strong>of</strong> well-compensated<br />
pr<strong>of</strong>essionals from relationship managers to<br />
specialists in customized investment strategies, tax<br />
and estate planning and advisory services in art<br />
and philanthropy.<br />
Having steadily taken their business models up-market, however, private<br />
banks risk neglecting one <strong>of</strong> the largest growth opportunities <strong>of</strong> the next<br />
decade: the “Core Millionaire.” Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, who have between $1<br />
million and $10 million to invest, have <strong>of</strong>ten been served only as an accommodation<br />
or in the hope that their assets will grow. These 4.2 million
2<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
households include doctors, lawyers, engineers, successful small to mid-size<br />
entrepreneurs and frugal savers who have different needs than the ultrahigh-net-worth<br />
(UHNW) segment with $10 million or more in assets. They<br />
are more concerned about wealth preservation and retirement than philanthropy<br />
and legacy issues. In the coming years, they will also be the fastestgrowing,<br />
largest and most pr<strong>of</strong>itable segment <strong>of</strong> the wealth market. The Core<br />
Millionaire segment:<br />
• Accounts for 27 percent <strong>of</strong> the typical private bank’s assets today, but<br />
will generate nearly two-thirds <strong>of</strong> the asset growth in wealth management<br />
by 2015.<br />
• Represents the acquisition “sweet spot” for private banks, as<br />
high-net-worth clients who are considering financial advisors for the<br />
first time.<br />
• Delivers revenue margins two-to-three times the average for the UHNW<br />
segment at a lower cost-to-serve.<br />
• Generates a higher proportion <strong>of</strong> business in pr<strong>of</strong>itable deposit, lending<br />
and discretionary investment products than the UHNW segment.<br />
• Will generate over 80 percent <strong>of</strong> all net new revenue growth in wealth<br />
management by 2015.<br />
For many institutions, focusing on Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> will require a fundamental<br />
shift in how they provide private banking services, because private<br />
bankers <strong>of</strong>ten indulge this segment with the customized personal service<br />
intended for UHNW clients.<br />
In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>,<br />
private banks need to create a multifaceted<br />
product and service line that <strong>of</strong>fers<br />
value, but can be delivered at lower cost.<br />
In particular, banks need to address three<br />
imperatives:<br />
• Develop an integrated investment and banking experience that feels<br />
customized, but <strong>of</strong>fers standardized packages <strong>of</strong> services that meet<br />
the typical needs <strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>.<br />
In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong>, private banks need to<br />
create a multi-faceted product and<br />
service line that <strong>of</strong>fers value, but can<br />
be delivered at lower cost.<br />
• Design solutions for specific segments <strong>of</strong> the Core Millionaire market,<br />
for example, entrepreneurs in selected industries, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or retirees<br />
with wealth preservation and income goals.
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
3<br />
• Implement a disciplined and pr<strong>of</strong>itable service model – providing<br />
services centrally, increasing the coverage and productivity <strong>of</strong><br />
bankers and account managers, <strong>of</strong>fering selective tax and estate<br />
guidance as required, and enforcing pricing discipline.<br />
Despite market uncertainty, the outlook for private banking over the next<br />
decade is strong, but growth will come from new client segments with different<br />
needs. Private banks that are able to adapt their business models to<br />
serve not just the UHNW market, but also Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, will find ample<br />
opportunities for pr<strong>of</strong>itable growth.
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
5<br />
How Private Banks Are<br />
Navigating Choppy Waters<br />
During the pre-crisis bull market, private banks<br />
enjoyed tremendous growth and welcomed clients<br />
below their stated minimums. Although private banks’<br />
business models were geared to serve clients with<br />
assets above $10 million, the high pr<strong>of</strong>its from rapid<br />
market growth obscured structural issues in the<br />
service model for the lower end <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />
In the wake <strong>of</strong> the financial crisis, wealth managers, including U.S. private<br />
banks, experienced a dramatic reversal. Not only did private banking<br />
asset levels fall sharply – 25 percent over the course <strong>of</strong> 2008 – but<br />
average pr<strong>of</strong>it margins contracted from 35 basis points in 2007 to 24<br />
basis points in 2009.<br />
Despite efforts to improve pr<strong>of</strong>itability since 2008, private banking continues<br />
to face challenges. Results from McKinsey’s Global Private Banking<br />
Survey show that asset gains in 2009 and 2010 came entirely from market<br />
appreciation and that net new<br />
asset flows from clients were<br />
negligible (Exhibit 1, page 6).<br />
Asset gains in 2009 and 2010<br />
came entirely from market<br />
appreciation, and net new asset<br />
flows from clients were negligible.<br />
Additionally, many clients have<br />
changed their asset allocation<br />
strategies since the crisis and<br />
shifted toward asset classes with lower fees. McKinsey’s benchmarking<br />
results show that the proportion <strong>of</strong> equities and alternative investments<br />
in private banks’ managed assets, which dropped from 54 percent to 36<br />
percent in 2008, recovered only partially to 45 percent by 2010. More-
6<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
Exhibit 1<br />
Private banking net flows have been flat over past 2 years<br />
Net flows by wealth manager category<br />
Percent change<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
Private banks<br />
0.8<br />
0.4<br />
Wirehouses<br />
-1.6<br />
-0.8<br />
Discount brokerages<br />
8.0<br />
3.5<br />
Independent advisors<br />
6.1<br />
5.8<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />
over, banking and lending revenue – critical to the pr<strong>of</strong>itability <strong>of</strong> most private<br />
banks – has suffered in the recent low-interest rate environment.<br />
Consequently, the industry pr<strong>of</strong>it pool has dropped about 50 percent below<br />
its pre-crisis peak (Exhibit 2).<br />
Not only has the level and growth rate <strong>of</strong> private banks’ pr<strong>of</strong>its declined, the<br />
post-crisis environment has also exposed fundamental weaknesses in the industry’s<br />
business model – in particular, the high cost <strong>of</strong> serving clients at the<br />
lower end <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />
The decrease in managed assets was not entirely involuntary. In reaction to<br />
the financial crisis, some private banks moved to improve their pr<strong>of</strong>itability by<br />
focusing on the UHNW segment, with the goal <strong>of</strong> reducing their average cost<br />
<strong>of</strong> service. Some institutions proactively stopped serving clients at lower<br />
asset levels, so that industry benchmarking for both 2009 and 2010 shows<br />
net outflows among clients with less than $10 million in assets. These were<br />
<strong>of</strong>fset by inflows from clients with over $10 million in assets (Exhibit 3).<br />
Today, private bankers are skeptical about their ability to recapture momentum<br />
in growth. In McKinsey’s 2011 Private Banking Survey, just one in five<br />
banks surveyed believed that acquiring new clients would contribute significantly<br />
to near-term revenue growth. Instead, they expect to rely on market<br />
appreciation and pricing. To some extent, these low expectations reflect the<br />
defensive posture <strong>of</strong> the industry following the crisis, as well as increased
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
7<br />
Exhibit 2<br />
Total private banking pr<strong>of</strong>its are down by over 50% since 2007<br />
Average assets<br />
Indexed at 2007<br />
100<br />
76<br />
67<br />
70<br />
-30%<br />
Revenues<br />
Indexed at 2007<br />
100<br />
73<br />
63<br />
67<br />
-33%<br />
Costs<br />
Indexed at 2007<br />
100<br />
81<br />
76<br />
81<br />
-19%<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>its<br />
Indexed at 2007<br />
100<br />
64<br />
47<br />
49<br />
-51%<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />
Exhibit 3<br />
Private banking client mix has shifted toward UHNW households<br />
over past 2 years<br />
Private banking asset growth by wealth band<br />
Percent change<br />
Assets<br />
2009<br />
2010<br />
$30 million +<br />
10.0<br />
5.1<br />
$10-30 million<br />
11.7<br />
4.0<br />
$1-10 million<br />
-0.4<br />
-2.9<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
9<br />
Looking Beyond<br />
Ultra-High-Net-Worth Clients<br />
Private banks that build a business model that effectively<br />
courts and pr<strong>of</strong>itably serves Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
will be well positioned to generate pr<strong>of</strong>itable growth.<br />
Several factors argue for more strategic attention to<br />
this segment <strong>of</strong> the wealth market.<br />
• The predominant source <strong>of</strong> new wealth. While only 27 percent <strong>of</strong> current<br />
private banking assets come from households with $1 million to<br />
$10 million in investable assets, the Core Millionaire segment already<br />
holds a large slice <strong>of</strong> U.S. household net worth and is expected to account<br />
for 60 percent <strong>of</strong> the asset growth among individuals with over<br />
$1 million in assets through 2015 (Exhibit 4, page 10).<br />
• Acquisition sweet spot. Private banking clients, especially UHNW<br />
clients, tend to skew disproportionately toward an older demographic.<br />
Overall, fewer than 15 percent <strong>of</strong> private banking clients are under 40.<br />
McKinsey’s interviews with clients and bankers suggest that those<br />
who inherit UHNW estates are more likely than ever to seek new financial<br />
advisors, rather than rely on their parents’ bankers. Long-term<br />
success will therefore require building relationships with Gen X and<br />
Millennial clients, who are in the market for wealth management services<br />
for the first time. These clients typically enter the market at the<br />
lower end <strong>of</strong> the $1 million to $10 million in assets range and are<br />
much easier to acquire at the point <strong>of</strong> entry than after they have developed<br />
a relationship elsewhere.<br />
• Higher investment fee income. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, with $1 million to<br />
$10 million in investable assets, are large enough to justify relationship<br />
banking but do not have the pricing leverage <strong>of</strong> the wealthiest
10 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
Exhibit 4<br />
From 2011 to 2015, Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> are projected to create nearly<br />
twice as much net new wealth as UHNW households<br />
U.S. onshore personal financial assets<br />
(PFA) by wealth band<br />
$ trillion<br />
31.1<br />
PFA growth,<br />
2010-2015<br />
$ trillion<br />
PFA growth,<br />
2010-2015<br />
Percent total<br />
26.0<br />
24.7<br />
25.7<br />
23.3<br />
5.3<br />
20.8<br />
4.7<br />
5.0<br />
5.2<br />
4.1<br />
10.3<br />
9.1 9.7<br />
10.1<br />
8.0<br />
26.8<br />
5.5<br />
10.6<br />
6.5<br />
12.5<br />
Ultra-High-<br />
Net-Worth<br />
>$10 million<br />
Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
$1-10 million<br />
10<br />
>30<br />
28<br />
38<br />
10-30<br />
51<br />
Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
1-10<br />
2.5-10<br />
72<br />
85<br />
1-2.5<br />
107<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
11<br />
families. McKinsey’s research shows that the industry average ratio <strong>of</strong><br />
revenue on client assets (ROCA) is 85 basis points for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
versus an average <strong>of</strong> 38 basis points for UHNW clients (Exhibit 5).<br />
Moreover, private banking clients with less than $10 million in assets<br />
usually expect their private banker to directly manage their assets. On<br />
average, less than 5 percent <strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>’ assets are held in<br />
custody, compared to 25 percent to 30 percent <strong>of</strong> UHNW clients’ assets.<br />
Custody assets typically have revenue margins under 10 basis<br />
points and sometimes much lower.<br />
• Greater use <strong>of</strong> lending and deposit products. McKinsey’s 2011<br />
benchmarking reflects the important link between banking product<br />
penetration and overall revenue margins. In top-quartile private<br />
McKinsey’s Global <strong>Wealth</strong> Sizing<br />
McKinsey & Company’s proprietary Global <strong>Wealth</strong> Distribution<br />
database provides current and future projections <strong>of</strong> high-net-worth<br />
assets. The firm’s sizing <strong>of</strong> the global high-net-worth market includes<br />
detailed projections for all regions and over 50 markets (both onshore<br />
and <strong>of</strong>fshore assets). Among the highlights for 2011:<br />
• Total onshore assets <strong>of</strong> U.S. high-net-worth households will<br />
increase by $3.7 trillion over the next four years, with 955,000 net<br />
new households having at least $1 million to invest.<br />
• Financial assets <strong>of</strong> high-net-worth individuals have grown over<br />
24 percent annually since 2008 in Asia (excluding Japan) and are<br />
expected to increase at a rate <strong>of</strong> approximately 19 percent over the<br />
next four years.<br />
• Despite faster economic growth in emerging markets, over 40 percent<br />
<strong>of</strong> the world’s millionaires reside in North America, and a large<br />
majority <strong>of</strong> their assets are onshore.<br />
• Among major regions, Latin America has the highest concentration<br />
<strong>of</strong> wealth in ultra-high-net-worth households with $30 million or<br />
more in assets – representing 32 percent <strong>of</strong> total personal financial<br />
assets compared to a global average <strong>of</strong> 15 percent.
12 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
Exhibit 6<br />
High yields on Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> are driven by attractive product mix<br />
Composition <strong>of</strong> U.S. private banking client assets by wealth band<br />
<strong>Wealth</strong> band<br />
$ million<br />
Share <strong>of</strong> assets<br />
Percent<br />
Managed<br />
assets<br />
Non-managed<br />
assets<br />
Deposits<br />
Loans<br />
Ultra-High-<br />
Net-Worth<br />
>10<br />
>100<br />
47<br />
42<br />
6 5<br />
30-100<br />
59<br />
21<br />
10<br />
10<br />
10-30<br />
67<br />
11<br />
11 11<br />
Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
1-10<br />
2.5-10<br />
67<br />
6<br />
12<br />
14<br />
1-2.5<br />
65<br />
3<br />
15<br />
17<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey<br />
Exhibit 7<br />
Through 2015, new revenue pools created in the Core Millionaire<br />
segment will be quadruple those created in the UHNW segment<br />
<strong>Wealth</strong> band<br />
$ million<br />
Net new revenue pool 2010-2015<br />
(at current private banking revenue margins)<br />
$ billion<br />
Group<br />
total<br />
Ultra-High-<br />
Net-Worth<br />
>10<br />
>30<br />
1.9<br />
5.0<br />
10-30<br />
3.1<br />
Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
1-10<br />
2.5-10<br />
10.6<br />
20.4<br />
1-2.5<br />
9.8<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
13<br />
banks, deposits and lending products accounted for over 55 percent<br />
<strong>of</strong> total revenue, compared to 35 percent for their bottom-quartile<br />
peers. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
can be important to boosting<br />
pr<strong>of</strong>its, since they are<br />
more likely to require<br />
credit and cash management<br />
services. On average,<br />
lending and deposit<br />
products represent 28 percent<br />
<strong>of</strong> total account balances for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, twice the average<br />
for wealthier families (Exhibit 6).<br />
On average, lending and<br />
deposit products represent 30<br />
percent <strong>of</strong> total account balances<br />
for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, twice the<br />
average for wealthier families.<br />
Overall, the incremental revenue opportunity from the Core Millionaire segment<br />
is more than four times larger than from UHNW clients (Exhibit 7).
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
15<br />
Crafting a Core<br />
Millionaire Offering<br />
Private banks should take a page from the luxury retail<br />
playbook and begin to think about their traditional<br />
<strong>of</strong>fering for the UHNW market as a high-end brand –<br />
necessary, but not sufficient, for success. Private banks<br />
could introduce the equivalent <strong>of</strong> complementary<br />
brands to pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>.<br />
Tiffany & Co. serves as an instructive example. At the time <strong>of</strong> its 1987 IPO,<br />
the jewelry chain had eight stores and was almost exclusively focused on<br />
selling high-end jewelry. Starting in the mid-1990s, Tiffany began to develop<br />
sterling silver and gold items priced below $1,000. Today, these<br />
products drive nearly $1 billion in annual sales and represent almost onethird<br />
<strong>of</strong> the company’s overall revenue. Tiffany has bifurcated its sales<br />
model to generate pr<strong>of</strong>its in lower-priced merchandise, while maintaining<br />
an exclusive buying experience for its wealthier clients. Today, a typical<br />
Tiffany store has a dedicated area for high-end jewelry sales that is spacious<br />
and located near the front <strong>of</strong> the store, with numerous salespeople.<br />
Sterling silver products are located in a separate, smaller area with fewer<br />
salespeople and are also increasingly sold online. Tiffany & Co. is not alone<br />
in developing different business models to serve various client segments –<br />
similar examples can be found in apparel (Ralph Lauren), automobiles<br />
(Ferrari) and hospitality (Starwood).<br />
What these consumer brands have in common is that they have expanded<br />
beyond their core operating models in order to pr<strong>of</strong>itably meet the needs <strong>of</strong><br />
new customers. In contrast, private banks <strong>of</strong>ten attempt to serve Core <strong>Millionaires</strong><br />
with the same value proposition and service model designed for<br />
UHNW clients.
16<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
In order to pr<strong>of</strong>itability serve the Core Millionaire segment, many banks will<br />
need to craft new value propositions and service models that meet the needs<br />
<strong>of</strong> these clients and capture their revenue potential. The Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>fer<br />
should include comprehensive investment and banking products, augmented<br />
by a limited but substantive set <strong>of</strong> other specialized services, with controlled<br />
access to a relationship manager.<br />
• An integrated private banking experience that feels privileged, but is costeffective.<br />
Clients have diverse service preferences – ranging from those<br />
who prize the exclusivity and personalized service <strong>of</strong> a private bank to<br />
those who see dedicated bankers and relationship managers as signs <strong>of</strong><br />
excessive fees. Private banks should design their value proposition to<br />
focus on partially self-directed clients who want the advice and products<br />
<strong>of</strong>fered by a private bank and are willing to<br />
pay for an <strong>of</strong>fering that can be pr<strong>of</strong>itably delivered.<br />
These clients would welcome a tailored<br />
<strong>of</strong>fering that emphasizes:<br />
Full-service brokers who serve<br />
high-net-worth clients <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
struggle to broaden their<br />
investment advice beyond<br />
traditional products.<br />
◦ Outcome-oriented, tax-efficient planning<br />
“at your fingertips.” In recent decades,<br />
the emergence <strong>of</strong> sophisticated family <strong>of</strong>fices<br />
that serve the UHNW segment has<br />
driven private bankers to focus more on customized investments and<br />
specialized services. For Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>, private banks should revive<br />
their traditional emphasis on tax-efficient, outcome-oriented financial<br />
planning focused on individual and family goals. Full-service brokers<br />
who serve high-net-worth clients <strong>of</strong>ten struggle to broaden their investment<br />
advice beyond traditional products. Clients frequently complain<br />
that their financial advisor does not even ask about their other assets.<br />
These clients are looking for a pr<strong>of</strong>essional “financial quarterback,” and<br />
private bankers are well-positioned to fill this role.<br />
To enable private bankers to efficiently deliver an integrated planning<br />
experience at scale, private banks should focus on developing userfriendly<br />
online platforms that aggregate assets across multiple institutions<br />
and reflect progress against financial plans. The popularity <strong>of</strong> web<br />
sites such as Mint.com and independent financial planning services<br />
highlights an unmet need for comprehensive financial planning.<br />
Bankers and their teams should be trained to integrate these platforms<br />
into their service models (e.g., incorporating them into client conversa-
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
17<br />
tions, setting alerts that trigger real-time advice) and to layer on valueadded<br />
services (e.g., interfacing with family accountants).<br />
◦ Rewards for consolidating assets. Clients with less than $10 million in<br />
assets tend to concentrate their assets with one provider to ensure<br />
that they qualify as a “premium relationship,” unlike UHNW families,<br />
who <strong>of</strong>ten allocate assets across multiple institutions and receive premium<br />
service everywhere. Banks can capitalize on this tendency via<br />
relationship pricing and by creating benefits, such as greater access<br />
to specialists and additional services, at tiered asset levels (e.g., a<br />
loyalty ladder with incremental benefits for every additional $1 million<br />
<strong>of</strong> assets up to $10 million).<br />
◦ Private bank packaging without customized solutions. The needs <strong>of</strong><br />
the Core Millionaire segment can typically be addressed through a<br />
standard model portfolio that is delivered in a manner that reflects<br />
the cachet <strong>of</strong> the private bank. Too <strong>of</strong>ten, private banks deploy their<br />
full set <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional skills to design customized solutions for<br />
clients who do not require this level <strong>of</strong> advice or service. In the absence<br />
<strong>of</strong> an alternative approach to financial advice, bankers simply<br />
tend to employ the service model that they <strong>of</strong>fer to UHNW clients.<br />
Private banks need to work with their bankers to build five to seven<br />
standard portfolios <strong>of</strong> investments aimed at particular outcomes<br />
(e.g., income in retirement), with a flexible overlay that makes the<br />
plan feel custom-tailored.<br />
◦ Access to exclusive proprietary products. Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> value exclusive<br />
investment opportunities in alternative asset classes and other<br />
non-traditional investments,<br />
but these opportunities do<br />
not necessarily require custom-tailoring.<br />
Private banks<br />
should focus on proprietary<br />
<strong>of</strong>ferings to reinforce privatebanking<br />
exclusivity and<br />
maintain the premium revenue<br />
margins associated<br />
with the Core Millionaire segment.<br />
Creating an attractive portfolio <strong>of</strong> investment products requires<br />
collaboration with capital markets organizations (“white label” partner-<br />
Private banks should focus on<br />
proprietary <strong>of</strong>ferings to reinforce<br />
private-banking exclusivity<br />
and maintain the premium<br />
revenue margins associated with<br />
the Core Millionaire segment.
18<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
ships for smaller regional institutions) and specialist wholesalers who<br />
focus on proprietary solutions.<br />
• Solutions that address the critical needs <strong>of</strong> key market segments. Private<br />
banking clients with $1 million to $10 million in assets can be grouped into<br />
major market segments – e.g., retirees, business owners, pr<strong>of</strong>essionals –<br />
each with a distinctive pr<strong>of</strong>ile. Since banks cannot create a pr<strong>of</strong>itable<br />
model in the $1 million to $10 million space if they try to address all possible<br />
client needs, understanding the common needs <strong>of</strong> these sub-segments<br />
<strong>of</strong> Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is crucial to developing a compelling <strong>of</strong>fering.<br />
◦ Help Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> retire “rich.” Retirees in the Core Millionaire segment<br />
require careful financial planning to comfortably maintain their<br />
lifestyle throughout retirement. Unlike UHNW retirees who will remain<br />
wealthy under almost any circumstances, retirement outcomes for<br />
Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> can vary widely based on the financial decisions they<br />
make today. To support these clients, private banks need to:<br />
u<br />
u<br />
u<br />
Focus their advisory models for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> on wealth preservation<br />
and income generation rather than UHNW concerns about<br />
legacy and philanthropy. In particular, concentrate on trade-<strong>of</strong>fs<br />
between spending versus leaving an inheritance and the issue <strong>of</strong><br />
retirement risk tolerance (e.g., spending more in early retirement<br />
while active versus conserving assets to avoid income reduction in<br />
late retirement).<br />
Recraft <strong>of</strong>fering from wealth accumulation to income generation by<br />
creating target-date and target-interest products and strategies that<br />
allow retirees to comfortably draw<br />
down their savings based on a wellthought-out<br />
plan.<br />
Play a proactive role in cash management,<br />
including guidance on spending<br />
decisions as retirees transition to new<br />
lifestyles, e.g., retirement lifestyle<br />
benchmarks for various locales or<br />
alerts tied to actual spending versus a<br />
planned budget.<br />
According to McKinsey’s Personal<br />
Financial Assets Survey, business<br />
owners are 25-to-30 percent more<br />
likely to require immediate access<br />
to funds and to feel financially<br />
stressed than pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or<br />
retirees at the same level <strong>of</strong> wealth.<br />
◦ Create liquidity and credit solutions for entrepreneurs. Core Millionaire<br />
business owners represent an important source <strong>of</strong> new assets for
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
19<br />
private banks. Lending and liquidity needs loom especially large for<br />
these clients. According to McKinsey’s Personal Financial Assets<br />
Survey, business owners are 25-to-30 percent more likely to require<br />
immediate access to funds and to feel financially stressed<br />
than pr<strong>of</strong>essionals or retirees at the same level <strong>of</strong> wealth. Entrepreneurs’<br />
investment patterns also differ, with many reporting that they<br />
use their businesses to take investment risks. To serve these<br />
clients, banks should focus on making credit decisions based on<br />
an integrated view <strong>of</strong> personal and business assets and on providing<br />
investment strategies that take into consideration the risks<br />
owners face in their businesses.<br />
◦ Provide tailored solutions for corporate executives and pr<strong>of</strong>essionals.<br />
Corporate executives and pr<strong>of</strong>essionals, such as attorneys,<br />
especially tend to<br />
value the investment and<br />
planning expertise provided<br />
by financial advisors. They<br />
are <strong>of</strong>ten realistic about<br />
their own financial management<br />
ability and want to<br />
engage with institutions and individuals that can deliver expert advice.<br />
To serve these clients most effectively, banks should designate<br />
certain bankers to focus on specific pr<strong>of</strong>essions or<br />
companies and develop strategies for diversifying around the<br />
large restricted equity positions that are a central component <strong>of</strong><br />
executive compensation (e.g., stock and options for corporate executives,<br />
partnership shares for attorneys).<br />
Determining the right sales<br />
and service model for<br />
Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is essential to<br />
capitalizing on the opportunity.<br />
• A pr<strong>of</strong>itable operating model. Determining the right sales and service<br />
model for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> is essential to capitalizing on the opportunity.<br />
To serve this segment pr<strong>of</strong>itably, banks should focus on five elements:<br />
◦ Dedicated bankers for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. To pr<strong>of</strong>itably serve this<br />
market, bankers need a different skill set and practice model than<br />
for the UHNW segment. Private banks should concentrate on building<br />
a stable <strong>of</strong> focused bankers who have the client acquisition<br />
skills required to develop a book <strong>of</strong> business and are able to serve<br />
a larger number <strong>of</strong> households by effectively delegating without diminishing<br />
the overall client experience. Creating dedicated pools <strong>of</strong>
20<br />
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
bankers will entail changes to organizational structures, performance<br />
management and compensation in order to develop and encourage<br />
the required behaviors.<br />
◦ Intelligent use <strong>of</strong> specialists. Not all Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> require frequent<br />
access to specialists in estate planning or trusts. Accordingly, private<br />
banks should be prepared to field a full team <strong>of</strong> specialists if necessary,<br />
but in limited numbers and with clearly defined missions and areas <strong>of</strong><br />
practice. Coverage at many private banks ranges from 100 to 250<br />
clients per specialist, while successful regional banks are able to utilize<br />
specialists at a ratio <strong>of</strong> 500 to 600 clients per specialist.<br />
◦ Extensive application <strong>of</strong> technology to client service functions. Private<br />
banks should place a greater premium on back-<strong>of</strong>fice operations,<br />
which enable Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> to provide some <strong>of</strong> their own client service,<br />
freeing up bankers to recruit and serve more clients. Moreover,<br />
surveys and interviews reveal that not all clients want a high-touch experience<br />
and many are willing to use convenient self-service applications<br />
to complete simple tasks. For example, Fidelity and Schwab hold<br />
Exhibit 8<br />
Banks with bottom quartile revenue margins can double<br />
Core Millionaire investment income through pricing discipline<br />
Average revenue on invested assets<br />
Basis points<br />
Average revenue on deposits and loans<br />
Basis points 1<br />
Top quartile<br />
98<br />
Top quartile<br />
381<br />
2nd quartile<br />
82<br />
2nd quartile<br />
333<br />
3rd quartile<br />
76<br />
3rd quartile<br />
286<br />
Bottom quartile<br />
42<br />
Bottom quartile<br />
248<br />
+133% +54%<br />
1<br />
Total yield on deposits and loans to adjust for FTP anomalies<br />
Source: McKinsey 2011 Global Private Banking Survey
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
21<br />
substantial assets from households with more than $5 million in investable<br />
assets and together would rank among the top five private<br />
banks in the U.S.<br />
Banks should provide online capabilities and encourage clients to use<br />
them for transactions whenever feasible. These might include the purchase<br />
or sale <strong>of</strong> securities, cash transfers or other financial housekeeping.<br />
Technology can also be brought to bear on client-facing<br />
activities, such as individual meetings with specialists via videoconference<br />
or the group delivery <strong>of</strong> investment perspectives from firm strategists<br />
through webinars.<br />
◦ Enforcement <strong>of</strong> pricing discipline. As a group, clients with less than<br />
$10 million in assets have substantially less negotiating leverage regarding<br />
fees than wealthier private banking clients. However, individual<br />
private bankers frequently extend standard UHNW discounts and preferred<br />
rates to Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. This lack <strong>of</strong> pricing rigor is evident in<br />
the wide dispersion <strong>of</strong> realized fee rates across institutions, based on<br />
McKinsey’s observations at individual institutions and the 2010 Global<br />
Private Banking Survey (Exhibit 8). The average revenue margin on investments<br />
for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong> ranged from 42 basis points to 98<br />
basis points, and total yields on deposits and loans ranged from 248<br />
basis points to 381 basis points. Banks should put in place rigid pricing<br />
guidelines covering the lower end <strong>of</strong> the market and closely track<br />
and manage exceptions.<br />
These suggestions for creating a service level below traditional private banking<br />
for UHNW clients could be counterproductive, if that initiative has a negative<br />
impact on a bank’s established image and reputation with wealthier<br />
clients. But, as in the Tiffany example, private banks should be able to protect<br />
their traditional franchise and preserve their cachet, while creating a new<br />
<strong>of</strong>fering for Core <strong>Millionaires</strong>. In fact, given the importance <strong>of</strong> the individual<br />
advisor-client relationship in wealth management, private banks that protect<br />
the integrity <strong>of</strong> their traditional business models are unlikely to lose their most<br />
affluent clients.
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
23<br />
Issues for Management<br />
Teams to Consider<br />
Private banks that concentrate primarily on the<br />
UHNW market, as they attempt to revive pr<strong>of</strong>itable<br />
growth, will face stiffer headwinds than in the past.<br />
Banks that broaden their traditional focus on UHNW<br />
clients to build a parallel <strong>of</strong>fering to serve Core<br />
<strong>Millionaires</strong> will gain an important edge. There are<br />
seven major issues that management teams should<br />
consider as they contemplate this move:<br />
• Focus. How well has the bank penetrated the Core Millionaire and<br />
UHNW market segments already How well aligned is its strategic focus<br />
with where growth will be in the future, given its product set, strengths,<br />
brand and service <strong>of</strong>fering<br />
• Business model. What scale (e.g., assets, number <strong>of</strong> bankers, number<br />
<strong>of</strong> specialists) is required to manage two distinct business models How<br />
can a private bank capture synergies between the two models, while<br />
ensuring the pr<strong>of</strong>itability <strong>of</strong> each<br />
• Brand dilution and extension. Will bifurcating the business model dilute<br />
UHNW client relationships How can a private bank retain enough<br />
distinction to preserve the cachet <strong>of</strong> its high-end brand How important<br />
is exclusiveness to UHNW clients versus personal/institutional relationships,<br />
valuable advice and favorable pricing<br />
• Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>fer. What are the appropriate benefits and incentives<br />
to <strong>of</strong>fer clients in the $1 million to $10 million segment to preserve<br />
the image <strong>of</strong> a private bank while maintaining high returns and
24 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
focusing on Core Millionaire issues (wealth preservation, retirement income)<br />
in a customized, yet cost-effective manner<br />
• Micro-market geographic focus. How should the geographic footprint differ<br />
for the UHNW and Core Millionaire <strong>of</strong>ferings How can private banks<br />
take advantage <strong>of</strong> opportunities outside <strong>of</strong> traditional money center locations<br />
in areas where the wealth market is smaller and less competitive<br />
• Banker sales and service model. What changes in structure and service<br />
model are required to enable bankers to cover a larger number <strong>of</strong> less affluent<br />
clients What technology and operations investments are necessary<br />
to give bankers the tools to provide comprehensive service to this<br />
market efficiently<br />
• Compensation. How should bankers and specialists be compensated<br />
when serving the $1 million to $10 million segment Can private banks retain<br />
talent in this segment with a salary plus bonus compensation model<br />
* * *<br />
Ultimately, a Core Millionaire focus may not be right for every bank, and not<br />
every institution will be able to make the transition successfully. However,<br />
those that do will realize a growth multiple relative to their peers and will secure<br />
a lasting advantage in serving this market in the years ahead.<br />
Pooneh Baghai<br />
Daniel Gourvitch<br />
Salim Ramji<br />
Jill Zucker<br />
The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions <strong>of</strong> Jeremy Borot,<br />
Owen Jones and Nakul Kapoor to this report.
A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
25<br />
About McKinsey & Company<br />
McKinsey & Company is a management consulting firm that helps many <strong>of</strong><br />
the world’s leading corporations and organizations address their strategic<br />
challenges, from reorganizing for long-term growth to improving business<br />
performance and maximizing pr<strong>of</strong>itability. For more than 80 years, the firm’s<br />
primary objective has been to serve as an organization’s most trusted external<br />
advisor on critical issues facing senior management. With consultants in<br />
more than 40 countries around the globe, McKinsey advises clients on strategic,<br />
operational, organizational and technological issues.<br />
McKinsey’s <strong>Wealth</strong> Management, Asset Management & Retirement Practice<br />
serves asset managers, wealth management companies and retirement players<br />
globally on issues <strong>of</strong> strategy, organization, operations and business performance.<br />
Our partners and consultants in the Americas have deep expertise<br />
in all facets <strong>of</strong> asset management. Our proprietary research spans all institutional<br />
and retail segments, asset classes (e.g., alternatives) and products<br />
(e.g., ETFs, outcome-oriented funds). Our proprietary tools provide deep insights<br />
into the flows, assets and economics <strong>of</strong> each <strong>of</strong> the sub-segments <strong>of</strong><br />
these markets and into the preferences and behaviors <strong>of</strong> consumers, investors<br />
and intermediaries.<br />
To learn more about McKinsey & Company’s specialized expertise and capabilities<br />
related to the asset management industry, or for additional information<br />
about this report, please contact:<br />
Pooneh Baghai<br />
Director<br />
(416) 313-3939<br />
pooneh_baghai@mckinsey.com<br />
Salim Ramji<br />
Director<br />
(212) 446-7393<br />
salim_ramji@mckinsey.com<br />
Céline Dufétel<br />
Principal<br />
(212) 446-8081<br />
celine_dufetel@mckinsey.com<br />
Kweilin Ellingrud<br />
Principal<br />
(612) 371-3132<br />
kweilin_ellingrud@mckinsey.com<br />
Onur Erzan<br />
Principal<br />
(212) 446-7172<br />
onur_erzan@mckinsey.com<br />
Jill Zucker<br />
Principal<br />
(212) 446-7989<br />
jill_zucker@mckinsey.com
26 A <strong>Tale</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Two</strong> <strong>Millionaires</strong>: The Best <strong>of</strong> Times for Private Banks to Look Beyond the Ultra-High-Net-Worth Market<br />
Further insights<br />
McKinsey’s <strong>Wealth</strong> Management, Asset Management & Retirement Practice<br />
publishes frequently on issues <strong>of</strong> interest to industry executives. Among our<br />
recent reports:<br />
Growth in a Time <strong>of</strong> Uncertainty: The Asset Management Industry in 2015<br />
November 2011<br />
The Second Act Begins for ETFs: A Disruptive Investment Vehicle Vies for Center<br />
Stage in Asset Management<br />
August 2011<br />
Capturing IRA Rollovers: The Net New Money Opportunity for <strong>Wealth</strong> <strong>Managers</strong><br />
July 2011<br />
Winning in the Defined Contribution Market: New Realities Reshape the<br />
Competitive Landscape<br />
September 2010<br />
Restoring Americans’ Retirement Security: A Shared Responsibility<br />
October 2009<br />
Endnote on data sources<br />
This paper incorporates the results <strong>of</strong> McKinsey & Company’s 2011 Global<br />
Private Banking Survey, which provides comprehensive information on the<br />
global private banking industry. The survey covers all relevant markets: North<br />
America, Latin America, Western Europe, Central and Eastern Europe, the<br />
Middle East and Asia. More than 160 banks participated in the survey,<br />
including eight <strong>of</strong> the top 15 private banks in the United States.<br />
Survey participants receive customized benchmarking and feedback sessions<br />
and have access to more detailed information than is presented in this report,<br />
while the confidentiality governing the data supplied by individual participants<br />
is preserved.<br />
In addition, this report draws on McKinsey’s proprietary 2011 Global <strong>Wealth</strong><br />
Sizing, which includes the firm’s projections for high-net-worth financial<br />
assets in all major markets.<br />
McKinsey would like to thank the firms that participated in the 2011 survey<br />
and sizing efforts for their valuable contributions.
Financial Services Practice<br />
March 2012<br />
Designed by Hudspith Design<br />
Copyright © McKinsey & Company<br />
www.mckinsey.com/clientservice/financial_services