Chapter A General rules of electrical installation design

2008 

http://theguide.schneider-electric.com 

Technical Series 

Electrical 

installation guide 

According to IEC International Standards

This technical guide is the result of 

a collective effort. 

Technical advisor: 

Serge Volut - Jacques Schonek 

Illustrations and production: 

AXESS - Valence -France 

Printing: 

Les Deux-Ponts - France 

Edition 

March 2008 

Price: 90 � 

ISBN: 978.2.9531643.0.5 

N° dépôt légal: 1er semestre 2008 

© Schneider Electric 

All rights reserved in all countries 

This guide has been written for electrical Engineers who have to 

design, realize, inspect or maintain electrical installations in compliance 

with international Standards of the International Electrotechnical 

Commission (IEC). 

“Which technical solution will guarantee that all relevant safety rules are 

met?” This question has been a permanent guideline for the elaboration of 

this document. 

An international Standard such as the IEC 60364 “Electrical Installation 

in Buldings” specifies extensively the rules to comply with to ensure 

safety and predicted operational characteristics for all types of electrical 

installations. As the Standard must be extensive, and has to be applicable 

to all types of products and the technical solutions in use worldwide, the 

text of the IEC rules is complex, and not presented in a ready-to-use order. 

The Standard cannot therefore be considered as a working handbook, but 

only as a reference document. 

The aim of the present guide is to provide a clear, practical and stepby-step 

explanation for the complete study of an electrical installation, 

according to IEC 60364 and other relevant IEC Standards. Therefore, the 

first chapter (B) presents the methodology to be used, and each chapter 

deals with one out of the eight steps of the study. The two last chapter are 

devoted to particular supply sources, loads and locations, and appendix 

provides additional information. Special attention must be paid to the 

EMC appendix, which is based on the broad and practical experience on 

electromagnetic compatibility problems. 

We all hope that you, the user, will find this handbook genuinely helpful. 

Schneider Electric S.A. 

The Electrical Installation Guide is a single document covering the 

techniques, regulations and standards related to electrical installations. 

It is intended for electrical professionals in companies, design offices, 

inspection organisations, etc. 

This Technical Guide is aimed at professional users and is only intended 

to provide them guidelines for the definition of an industrial, tertiary or 

domestic electrical installation. Information and guidelines contained in this 

Guide are provided AS IS. Schneider Electric makes no warranty of any 

kind, whether express or implied, such as but not limited to the warranties 

of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, nor assumes any 

legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness 

of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed in this Guide, 

nor represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. 

The purpose of this guide is to facilitate the implementation of International 

installation standards for designers & contractors, but in all cases the 

original text of International or local standards in force shall prevail. 

This new edition has been published to take into account changes in 

techniques, standards and regulations, in particular electrical installation 

standard IEC 60364. 

We thank all the readers of the previous edition of this guide for their 

comments that have helped improve the current edition. 

We also thank the many people and organisations, to numerous to name 

here, who have contributed in one way or another to the preparation of this 

guide.

Guiding tools for more efficiency in electrical 

distribution design 

Technical knowledge Pre-design help for budget 

approach 

10-30mn eLearning modules for 

individual training 

Articles giving base skills about 

general subjects: “Cahiers 

Techniques” 

Schneider Electric - Electrical installation guide 2008 

Selection criterias & method 

to follow in order to pre-define 

project specification: 

b Architecture guide 

b ID-Spec software 

Solutions and examples with 

recommended architectures in 

Solution guides: 

b airport 

b automative 

b food 

b retail 

b office 

b industrial buildings 

b healthcare 

b ...

Design support Specification help Help in installation, use & 

maintenance 

Practical data & methods 

through major design guides: 

b Electrical Installation Guide 

b Protection guide 

b Industrial electrical network 

design guide 

b ... 

Product presentation of technical 

characteristics in all Schneider 

Electric product Catalogues 

Design Software: 

b My Ecodial 

Ecodial software provides a 

complete design package for 

LV installations, in accordance 

with IEC standards and 

recommendations. 

Main features: 

v Create diagrams 

v Optimise circuit breakers curves 

v Determine source power 

v Follow step by step calculation 

v Print the project design file 

b SISPRO building 

b ... 

Drawing source files for 

connection, dimension, diagram, 

mounting & safety: CAD library 

Technical specification on 

products & solutions for tender 

request 


Product installation data 

Product how to use data 

Product maintenance data

General rules of electrical 

installation design 

Connection to the MV utility 

distribution network 

Connection to the LV utility 


MV & LV architecture selection 

guide 

LV Distribution 

Protection against electric 

shocks 

Sizing and protection of 

conductors 

LV switchgear: functions & 

selection 

Protection against voltage 

surges in LV 

Energy Efficiency in electrical 

distribution 

Power factor correction and 

harmonic filtering 

Harmonic management 

Characteristics of particular 

sources and loads 

Residential and other special 

locations 

EMC guidelines 

A 

B 

C 

D 

E 

F 

G 

H 

J 

K 

L 

M 

N 

P 

Q

A 

B 

C 

D 

E 

F 

G 

H 

General contents 

General rules of electrical installation design 

1 Methodology A2 

2 Rules and statutory regulations A4 

3 Installed power loads - Characteristics A10 

4 Power loading of an installation A15 

Connection to the MV utility distribution network 

1 Supply of power at medium voltage B2 

2 Procedure for the establishment of a new substation B14 

3 Protection aspect B16 

4 The consumer substation with LV metering B22 

5 The consumer substation with MV metering B30 

6 Constitution of MV/LV distribution substations B35 

Connection to the LV utility distribution network 

1 Low voltage utility distribution networks C2 

2 Tariffs and metering C16 

MV & LV architecture selection guide 

1 Stakes for the user D3 

2 Simplified architecture design process D4 

3 Electrical installation characteristics D7 

4 Technological characteristics D11 

5 Architecture assessment criteria D13 

6 Choice of architecture fundamentals D15 

7 Choice of architecture details D19 

8 Choice of equiment D24 

9 Recommendations for architecture optimization D26 

10 Glossary D29 

11 ID-Spec software D30 

12 Example: electrical installation in a printworks D31 


1 Earthing schemes E2 

2 The installation system E15 

3 External influences (IEC 60364-5-51) E25 

Protection against electric shocks 

1 General F2 

2 Protection against direct contact F4 

3 Protection against indirect contact F6 

4 Protection of goods due to insulation fault F17 

5 Implementation of the TT system F19 

6 Implementation of the TN system F25 

7 Implementation of the IT system F31 

8 Residual current differential devices RCDs F38 

Sizing and protection of conductors 

1 General G2 

2 Practical method for determining the smallest allowable G7 

cross-sectional area of circuit conductors 

3 Determination of voltage drop G20 

4 Short-circuit current G24 

5 Particular cases of short-circuit current G30 

6 Protective earthing conductor G37 

7 The neutral conductor G42 

8 Worked example of cable calculation G46 

LV switchgear: functions & selection 

1 The basic functions of LV switchgear H2 

2 The switchgear H5 

3 Choice of switchgear H10 

4 Circuit breaker H11 

Schneider Electric - Electrical installation guide 2008

J 

K 

L 

M 

N 

P 

Q 

General contents 

Protection against voltage surges in LV 

1 General J2 

2 Overvoltage protection devices J6 

3 Standards J11 

4 Choosing a protection device J14 

Energy Efficiency in electrical distribution 

1 Introduction K2 

2 Energy efficiency and electricity K3 

3 One process, several players K5 

4 From electrical measurement to electrical information K10 

5 Communication and Information System K16 

Power factor correction and harmonic filtering 

1 Reactive energy and power factor L2 

2 Why to improve the power factor? L5 

3 How to improve the power factor? L7 

4 Where to install power correction capacitors? L10 

5 How to decide the optimum level of compensation? L12 

6 Compensation at the terminals of a transformer L15 

7 Power factor correction of induction motors L18 

8 Example of an installation before and after power factor correction L20 

9 The effects of harmonics L21 

10 Implementation of capacitor banks L24 


1 The problem: M2 

Why is it necessary to detect and eliminate harmonics? 

2 Standards M3 

3 General M4 

4 Main effects of harmonics in installations M6 

5 Essential indicators of harmonic distortion and M11 

measurement principles 

6 Measuring the indicators M14 

7 Detection devices M16 

8 Solutions to attenuate harmonics M17 

Characteristics of particular sources and loads 

1 Protection of a LV generator set and the downstream circuits N2 

2 Uninterruptible Power Supply Units (UPS) N11 

3 Protection of LV/LV transformers N24 

4 Lighting circuits N27 

5 Asynchronous motors N42 

Residential and other special locations 

1 Residential and similar premises P2 

2 Bathrooms and showers P8 

3 Recommendations applicable to special installations and locations P12 


1 Electrical distribution Q2 

2 Earthing principles and structures Q3 

3 Implementation Q5 

4 Coupling mechanism and counter-measures Q14 

5 Wiring recommendations Q20 


2 

3 

4 

Chapter A 

General rules of electrical 

installation design 

Contents 

Methodology A2 

Rules and statutory regulations A4 

2.1 Definition of voltage ranges A4 

2.2 Regulations A5 

2.3 Standards A5 

2.4 Quality and safety of an electrical installation A6 

2.5 Initial testing of an installation A6 

2.6 Periodic check-testing of an installation 

2.7 Conformity (with standards and specifications) of equipment 

A7 

used in the installation A7 

2.8 Environment A8 

Installed power loads - Characteristics A 0 

3.1 Induction motors 

3.2 Resistive-type heating appliances and incandescent lamps 

A10 

(conventional or halogen) A12 

Power loading of an installation A 5 

4.1 Installed power (kW) A15 

4.2 Installed apparent power (kVA) A15 

4.3 Estimation of actual maximum kVA demand A16 

4.4 Example of application of factors ku and ks A17 

4.5 Diversity factor A18 

4.6 Choice of transformer rating A19 

4.7 Choice of power-supply sources A20 


A 

© Schneider Electric - all rights reserved

© Schneider Electric - all rights reserved 

A2 

A - General rules of electrical installation design 


B – Connection to the MV utility distribution 

network 

C - Connection to the LV utility distribution 

network 

D - MV & LV architecture selection guide 

E - LV Distribution 

F - Protection against electric shocks 

G - Sizing and protection of conductors 

H - LV switchgear: functions & selection 

Methodology 

For the best results in electrical installation design it is recommended to read all the 

chapters of this guide in the order in which they are presented. 

Listing of power demands 

The study of a proposed electrical installation requires an adequate understanding of 

all governing rules and regulations. 

The total power demand can be calculated from the data relative to the location and 

power of each load, together with the knowledge of the operating modes (steady 

state demand, starting conditions, non simultaneous operation, etc.) 

From these data, the power required from the supply source and (where appropriate) 

the number of sources necessary for an adequate supply to the installation are 

readily obtained. 

Local information regarding tariff structures is also required to allow the best choice 

of connection arrangement to the power-supply network, e.g. at medium voltage or 

low voltage level. 

Service connection 

This connection can be made at: 

b Medium Voltage level 

A consumer-type substation will then have to be studied, built and equipped. This 

substation may be an outdoor or indoor installation conforming to relevant standards 

and regulations (the low-voltage section may be studied separately if necessary). 

Metering at medium-voltage or low-voltage is possible in this case. 

b Low Voltage level 

The installation will be connected to the local power network and will (necessarily) be 

metered according to LV tariffs. 

Electrical Distribution architecture 

The whole installation distribution network is studied as a complete system. 

A selection guide is proposed for determination of the most suitable architecture. 

MV/LV main distribution and LV power distribution levels are covered. 

Neutral earthing arrangements are chosen according to local regulations, constraints 

related to the power-supply, and to the type of loads. 

The distribution equipment (panelboards, switchgears, circuit connections, ...) are 

determined from building plans and from the location and grouping of loads. 

The type of premises and allocation can influence their immunity to external 

disturbances. 


The earthing system (TT, IT or TN) having been previously determined, then the 

appropriate protective devices must be implemented in order to achieve protection 

against hazards of direct or indirect contact. 

Circuits and switchgear 

Each circuit is then studied in detail. From the rated currents of the loads, the level 

of short-circuit current, and the type of protective device, the cross-sectional area 

of circuit conductors can be determined, taking into account the nature of the 

cableways and their influence on the current rating of conductors. 

Before adopting the conductor size indicated above, the following requirements must 

be satisfied: 

b The voltage drop complies with the relevant standard 

b Motor starting is satisfactory 

b Protection against electric shock is assured 

The short-circuit current Isc is then determined, and the thermal and electrodynamic 

withstand capability of the circuit is checked. 

These calculations may indicate that it is necessary to use a conductor size larger 

than the size originally chosen. 

The performance required by the switchgear will determine its type and 

characteristics. 

The use of cascading techniques and the discriminative operation of fuses and 

tripping of circuit breakers are examined. 



J – Protection against voltage surges in LV 

K – Energy efficiency in electrical distribution 

L - Power factor correction and harmonic filtering 

M - Harmonic management 

N - Characteristics of particular sources and 

loads 

P - Residential and other special locations 

Q - EMC guideline 

(1) Ecodial is a Merlin Gerin product and is available in French 

and English versions. 

Methodology 

Protection against overvoltages 

Direct or indirect lightning strokes can damage electrical equipment at a distance 

of several kilometers. Operating voltage surges, transient and industrial frequency 

over-voltage can also produce the same consequences.The effects are examined 

and solutions are proposed. 

Energy efficiency in electrial distribution 

Implementation of measuring devices with an adequate communication system 

within the electrical installation can produce high benefits for the user or owner: 

reduced power consumption, reduced cost of energy, better use of electrical 

equipment. 

Reactive energy 

The power factor correction within electrical installations is carried out locally, 

globally or as a combination of both methods. 

Harmonics 

Harmonics in the network affect the quality of energy and are at the origin of many 

disturbances as overloads, vibrations, ageing of equipment, trouble of sensitive 

equipment, of local area networks, telephone networks. This chapter deals with the 

origins and the effects of harmonics and explain how to measure them and present 

the solutions. 

Particular supply sources and loads 

Particular items or equipment are studied: 

b Specific sources such as alternators or inverters 

b Specific loads with special characteristics, such as induction motors, lighting 

circuits or LV/LV transformers 

b Specific systems, such as direct-current networks 

Generic applications 

Certain premises and locations are subject to particularly strict regulations: the most 

common example being residential dwellings. 

EMC Guidelines 

Some basic rules must be followed in order to ensure Electromagnetic Compatibility. 

Non observance of these rules may have serious consequences in the operation of 

the electrical installation: disturbance of communication systems, nuisance tripping 

of protection devices, and even destruction of sensitive devices. 

Ecodial software 

Ecodial software (1) provides a complete design package for LV installations, in 

accordance with IEC standards and recommendations. 

The following features are included: 

b Construction of one-line diagrams 

b Calculation of short-circuit currents 

b Calculation of voltage drops 

b Optimization of cable sizes 

b Required ratings of switchgear and fusegear 

b Discrimination of protective devices 

b Recommendations for cascading schemes 

b Verification of the protection of people 

b Comprehensive print-out of the foregoing calculated design data 


A3 



A 


2 Rules and statutory regulations 

Low-voltage installations are governed by a number of regulatory and advisory texts, 

which may be classified as follows: 

b Statutory regulations (decrees, factory acts,etc.) 

b Codes of practice, regulations issued by professional institutions, job specifications 

b National and international standards for installations 

b National and international standards for products 

2.1 Definition of voltage ranges 

IEC voltage standards and recommendations 

Three-phase four-wire or three-wire systems Single-phase three-wire systems 

Nominal voltage (V) Nominal voltage (V) 

50 Hz 60 Hz 60 Hz 

– 120/208 120/240 

– 240 – 

230/400 (1) 277/480 – 

400/690 (1) 480 – 

– 347/600 – 

1000 600 – 

(1) The nominal voltage of existing 220/380 V and 240/415 V systems shall evolve 

toward the recommended value of 230/400 V. The transition period should be as short 

as possible and should not exceed the year 2003. During this period, as a first step, the 

electricity supply authorities of countries having 220/380 V systems should bring the 

voltage within the range 230/400 V +6 %, -10 % and those of countries having 

240/415 V systems should bring the voltage within the range 230/400 V +10 %, 

-6 %. At the end of this transition period, the tolerance of 230/400 V ± 10 % should 

have been achieved; after this the reduction of this range will be considered. All the 

above considerations apply also to the present 380/660 V value with respect to the 

recommended value 400/690 V. 

Fig. A1 : Standard voltages between 100 V and 1000 V (IEC 60038 Edition 6.2 2002-07) 

Series I Series II 

Highest voltage Nominal system Highest voltage Nominal system 

for equipment (kV) voltage (kV) for equipment (kV) voltage (kV) 

3.6 (1) 3.3 (1) 3 (1) 4.40 (1) 4.16 (1) 

7.2 (1) 6.6 (1) 6 (1) – – 

12 11 10 – – 

– – – 13.2 (2) 12.47 (2) 

– – – 13.97 (2) 13.2 (2) 

– – – 14.52 (1) 13.8 (1) 

(17.5) – (15) – – 

24 22 20 – – 

– – – 26.4 (2) 24.94 (2) 

36 (3) 33 (3) – – – 

– – – 36.5 34.5 

40.5 (3) – 35 (3) – – 

These systems are generally three-wire systems unless otherwise indicated. 

The values indicated are voltages between phases. 

The values indicated in parentheses should be considered as non-preferred values. It is 

recommended that these values should not be used for new systems to be constructed 

in future. 

Note 1: It is recommended that in any one country the ratio between two adjacent 

nominal voltages should be not less than two. 

Note 2: In a normal system of Series I, the highest voltage and the lowest voltage do 

not differ by more than approximately ±10 % from the nominal voltage of the system. 

In a normal system of Series II, the highest voltage does not differ by more then +5 % 

and the lowest voltage by more than -10 % from the nominal voltage of the system. 

(1) These values should not be used for public distribution systems. 

(2) These systems are generally four-wire systems. 

(3) The unification of these values is under consideration. 

Fig. A2 : Standard voltages above 1 kV and not exceeding 35 kV 

(IEC 60038 Edition 6.2 2002-07) 




2.2 Regulations 

In most countries, electrical installations shall comply with more than one set of 

regulations, issued by National Authorities or by recognized private bodies. It is 

essential to take into account these local constraints before starting the design. 

2.3 Standards 

This Guide is based on relevant IEC standards, in particular IEC 60364. IEC 60364 

has been established by medical and engineering experts of all countries in the 

world comparing their experience at an international level. Currently, the safety 

principles of IEC 60364 and 60479-1 are the fundamentals of most electrical 

standards in the world (see table below and next page). 

IEC 60038 Standard voltages 

IEC 60076-2 Power transformers - Temperature rise 

IEC 60076-3 Power transformers - Insulation levels, dielectric tests and external clearances in air 

IEC 60076- Power transformers - Ability to withstand short-circuit 

IEC 60076-10 Power transformers - Determination of sound levels 

IEC 601 6 Semiconductor convertors - General requirements and line commutated convertors 

IEC 602 Electrical relays 

IEC 6026 -1 High-voltage switches - High-voltage switches for rated voltages above 1 kV and less than 52 kV 

IEC 60269-1 Low-voltage fuses - General requirements 

IEC 60269-2 Low-voltage fuses - Supplementary requirements for fuses for use by unskilled persons (fuses mainly for household and similar applications) 

IEC 60282-1 High-voltage fuses - Current-limiting fuses 

IEC 60287-1-1 Electric cables - Calculation of the current rating - Current rating equations (100% load factor) and calculation of losses - General 

IEC 6036 Electrical installations of buildings 

IEC 6036 -1 Electrical installations of buildings - Fundamental principles 

IEC 6036 - - 1 Electrical installations of buildings - Protection for safety - Protection against electric shock 

IEC 6036 - - 2 Electrical installations of buildings - Protection for safety - Protection against thermal effects 

IEC 6036 - - 3 Electrical installations of buildings - Protection for safety - Protection against overcurrent 

IEC 6036 - - Electrical installations of buildings - Protection for safety - Protection against electromagnetic and voltage disrurbance 

IEC 6036 - - 1 Electrical installations of buildings - Selection and erection of electrical equipment - Common rules 

IEC 6036 - - 2 Electrical installations of buildings - Selection and erection of electrical equipment - Wiring systems 

IEC 6036 - - 3 Electrical installations of buildings - Selection and erection of electrical equipment - Isolation, switching and control 

IEC 6036 - - Electrical installations of buildings - Selection and erection of electrical equipment - Earthing arrangements 

IEC 6036 - - Electrical installations of buildings - Selection and erection of electrical equipment - Other equipments 

IEC 6036 -6-61 Electrical installations of buildings - Verification and testing - Initial verification 

IEC 6036 -7-701 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Locations containing a bath tub or shower basin 

IEC 6036 -7-702 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Swimming pools and other basins 

IEC 6036 -7-703 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Locations containing sauna heaters 

IEC 6036 -7-70 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Construction and demolition site installations 

IEC 6036 -7-70 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Electrical installations of agricultural and horticultural 

premises 

IEC 6036 -7-706 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Restrictive conducting locations 

IEC 6036 -7-707 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Earthing requirements for the installation of data 

processing equipment 

IEC 6036 -7-708 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Electrical installations in caravan parks and caravans 

IEC 6036 -7-709 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Marinas and pleasure craft 

IEC 6036 -7-710 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Medical locations 

IEC 6036 -7-711 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Exhibitions, shows and stands 

IEC 6036 -7-712 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Solar photovoltaic (PV) power supply systems 

IEC 6036 -7-713 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Furniture 

IEC 6036 -7-71 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - External lighting installations 

IEC 6036 -7-71 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Extra-low-voltage lighting installations 

IEC 6036 -7-717 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Mobile or transportable units 

IEC 6036 -7-7 0 Electrical installations of buildings - Requirements for special installations or locations - Temporary electrical installations for structures, 

amusement devices and booths at fairgrounds, amusement parks and circuses 

IEC 60 27 High-voltage alternating current circuit-breakers 

IEC 60 39-1 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Type-tested and partially type-tested assemblies 

IEC 60 39-2 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Particular requirements for busbar trunking systems (busways) 

IEC 60 39-3 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Particular requirements for low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies intended to 

be installed in places where unskilled persons have access for their use - Distribution boards 

IEC 60 39- Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Particular requirements for assemblies for construction sites (ACS) 

IEC 60 6 Basic and safety principles for man-machine interface, marking and identification - Identification of conductors by colours or numerals 

IEC 60 39- Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies - Particular requirements for assemblies intended to be installed outdoors in public places 

- Cable distribution cabinets (CDCs) 

IEC 60 79-1 Effects of current on human beings and livestock - General aspects 

IEC 60 79-2 Effects of current on human beings and livestock - Special aspects 

IEC 60 79-3 Effects of current on human beings and livestock - Effects of currents passing through the body of livestock 


(Continued on next page) 

A 



A6 



IEC 60 29 Degrees of protection provided by enclosures (IP code) 

IEC 606 Spécification for high-voltage fuse-links for motor circuit applications 

IEC 6066 Insulation coordination for equipment within low-voltage systems 

IEC 6071 Dimensions of low-voltage switchgear and controlgear. Standardized mounting on rails for mechanical support of electrical devices in switchgear 

and controlgear installations. 

IEC 6072 Short-circuit temperature limits of electric cables with rated voltages of 1 kV (Um = 1.2 kV) and 3 kV (Um = 3.6 kV) 

IEC 607 General requirements for residual current operated protective devices 

IEC 60787 Application guide for the selection of fuse-links of high-voltage fuses for transformer circuit application 

IEC 60831 Shunt power capacitors of the self-healing type for AC systems having a rated voltage up to and including 1000 V - General - Performance, testing 

and rating - Safety requirements - Guide for installation and operation 

IEC 609 7-1 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - General rules 

IEC 609 7-2 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Circuit-breakers 

IEC 609 7-3 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Switches, disconnectors, switch-disconnectors and fuse-combination units 

IEC 609 7- -1 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Contactors and motor-starters - Electromechanical contactors and motor-starters 

IEC 609 7-6-1 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Multiple function equipment - Automatic transfer switching equipment 

IEC 61000 Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) 

IEC 611 0 Protection against electric shocks - common aspects for installation and equipment 

IEC 61 7-1 Electrical safety in low-voltage distribution systems up to 1000 V AC and 1500 V DC - Equipment for testing, measuring or monitoring of protective 

measures - General requirements 

IEC 61 7-8 Electrical safety in low-voltage distribution systems up to 1000 V AC and 1500 V DC - Equipment for testing, measuring or monitoring of protective 

measures 

IEC 61 7-9 Electrical safety in low-voltage distribution systems up to 1000 V AC and 1500 V DC - Equipment for insulation fault location in IT systems 

IEC 61 8-2-6 Safety of power transformers, power supply units and similar - Particular requirements for safety isolating transformers for general use 

IEC 62271-1 Common specifications for high-voltage switchgear and controlgear standards 

IEC 62271-100 High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - High-voltage alternating-current circuit-breakers 

IEC 62271-102 High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Alternating current disconnectors and earthing switches 

IEC 62271-10 High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Alternating current switch-fuse combinations 

IEC 62271-200 High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Alternating current metal-enclosed switchgear and controlgear for rated voltages above 1 kV and up to 

and including 52 kV 

IEC 62271-202 High-voltage/low voltage prefabricated substations 

2. Quality and safety of an electrical installation 


(Concluded) 

In so far as control procedures are respected, quality and safety will be assured 

only if: 

b The initial checking of conformity of the electrical installation with the standard and 

regulation has been achieved 

b The electrical equipment comply with standards 

b The periodic checking of the installation recommended by the equipment 

manufacturer is respected. 

2. Initial testing of an installation 

Before a utility will connect an installation to its supply network, strict precommissioning 

electrical tests and visual inspections by the authority, or by its 

appointed agent, must be satisfied. 

These tests are made according to local (governmental and/or institutional) 

regulations, which may differ slightly from one country to another. The principles of 

all such regulations however, are common, and are based on the observance of 

rigorous safety rules in the design and realization of the installation. 

IEC 60364-6-61 and related standards included in this guide are based on an 

international consensus for such tests, intended to cover all the safety measures and 

approved installation practices normally required for residential, commercial and (the 

majority of) industrial buildings. Many industries however have additional regulations 

related to a particular product (petroleum, coal, natural gas, etc.). Such additional 

requirements are beyond the scope of this guide. 

The pre-commissioning electrical tests and visual-inspection checks for installations 

in buildings include, typically, all of the following: 

b Insulation tests of all cable and wiring conductors of the fixed installation, between 

phases and between phases and earth 

b Continuity and conductivity tests of protective, equipotential and earth-bonding 

conductors 

b Resistance tests of earthing electrodes with respect to remote earth 

b Verification of the proper operation of the interlocks, if any 

b Check of allowable number of socket-outlets per circuit


Conformity of equipment with the relevant 

standards can be attested in several ways 


b Cross-sectional-area check of all conductors for adequacy at the short-circuit 

levels prevailing, taking account of the associated protective devices, materials and 

installation conditions (in air, conduit, etc.) 

b Verification that all exposed- and extraneous metallic parts are properly earthed 

(where appropriate) 

b Check of clearance distances in bathrooms, etc. 

These tests and checks are basic (but not exhaustive) to the majority of installations, 

while numerous other tests and rules are included in the regulations to cover 

particular cases, for example: TN-, TT- or IT-earthed installations, installations based 

on class 2 insulation, SELV circuits, and special locations, etc. 

The aim of this guide is to draw attention to the particular features of different types 

of installation, and to indicate the essential rules to be observed in order to achieve 

a satisfactory level of quality, which will ensure safe and trouble-free performance. 

The methods recommended in this guide, modified if necessary to comply with any 

possible variation imposed by a utility, are intended to satisfy all precommissioning 

test and inspection requirements. 

2.6 Periodic check-testing of an installation 

In many countries, all industrial and commercial-building installations, together with 

installations in buildings used for public gatherings, must be re-tested periodically by 

authorized agents. 

Figure A3 shows the frequency of testing commonly prescribed according to the 

kind of installation concerned. 

Type of installation Testing 

frequency 

Installations which b Locations at which a risk of degradation, Annually 

require the protection fire or explosion exists 

of employees b Temporary installations at worksites 

b Locations at which MV installations exist 

b Restrictive conducting locations 

where mobile equipment is used 

Other cases Every 3 years 

Installations in buildings According to the type of establishment From one to 

used for public gatherings, and its capacity for receiving the public three years 

where protection against 

the risks of fire and panic 

are required 

Residential According to local regulations 

Fig A3 : Frequency of check-tests commonly recommended for an electrical installation 

2.7 Conformity (with standards and specifications) 

of equipment used in the installation 

Attestation of conformity 

The conformity of equipment with the relevant standards can be attested: 

b By an official mark of conformity granted by the certification body concerned, or 

b By a certificate of conformity issued by a certification body, or 

b By a declaration of conformity from the manufacturer 

The first two solutions are generally not available for high voltage equipment. 

Declaration of conformity 

Where the equipment is to be used by skilled or instructed persons, the 

manufacturer’s declaration of conformity (included in the technical documentation), 

is generally recognized as a valid attestation. Where the competence of the 

manufacturer is in doubt, a certificate of conformity can reinforce the manufacturer’s 

declaration. 


A7 



A8 



Note: CE marking 

In Europe, the European directives require the manufacturer or his authorized 

representative to affix the CE marking on his own responsibility. It means that: 

b The product meets the legal requirements 

b It is presumed to be marketable in Europe 

The CE marking is neither a mark of origin nor a mark of conformity. 

Mark of conformity 

Marks of conformity are affixed on appliances and equipment generally used by 

ordinary non instructed people (e.g in the field of domestic appliances). A mark of 

conformity is delivered by certification body if the equipment meet the requirements 

from an applicable standard and after verification of the manufacturer’s quality 

management system. 

Certification of Quality 

The standards define several methods of quality assurance which correspond to 

different situations rather than to different levels of quality. 

Assurance 

A laboratory for testing samples cannot certify the conformity of an entire production 

run: these tests are called type tests. In some tests for conformity to standards, 

the samples are destroyed (tests on fuses, for example). 

Only the manufacturer can certify that the fabricated products have, in fact, 

the characteristics stated. 

Quality assurance certification is intended to complete the initial declaration or 

certification of conformity. 

As proof that all the necessary measures have been taken for assuring the quality of 

production, the manufacturer obtains certification of the quality control system which 

monitors the fabrication of the product concerned. These certificates are issued 

by organizations specializing in quality control, and are based on the international 

standard ISO 9001: 2000. 

These standards define three model systems of quality assurance control 

corresponding to different situations rather than to different levels of quality: 

b Model 3 defines assurance of quality by inspection and checking of final products. 

b Model 2 includes, in addition to checking of the final product, verification of the 

manufacturing process. For example, this method is applied, to the manufacturer of 

fuses where performance characteristics cannot be checked without destroying the 

fuse. 

b Model 1 corresponds to model 2, but with the additional requirement that the 

quality of the design process must be rigorously scrutinized; for example, where it is 

not intended to fabricate and test a prototype (case of a custom-built product made to 

specification). 

2.8 Environment 

Environmental management systems can be certified by an independent body if they 

meet requirements given in ISO 14001. This type of certification mainly concerns 

industrial settings but can also be granted to places where products are designed. 

A product environmental design sometimes called “eco-design” is an approach of 

sustainable development with the objective of designing products/services best 

meeting the customers’ requirements while reducing their environmental impact 

over their whole life cycle. The methodologies used for this purpose lead to choose 

equipment’s architecture together with components and materials taking into account 

the influence of a product on the environment along its life cycle (from extraction of 

raw materials to scrap) i.e. production, transport, distribution, end of life etc. 

In Europe two Directives have been published, they are called: 

b RoHS Directive (Restriction of Hazardous Substances) coming into force on 

July 2006 (the coming into force was on February 13th , 2003, and the application 

date is July 1st , 2006) aims to eliminate from products six hazardous substances: 

lead, mercury, cadmium, hexavalent chromium, polybrominated biphenyls (PBB) or 

polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDE). 




b WEEE Directive (Waste of Electrical and Electronic Equipment) coming into 

force in August 2005 (the coming into force was on February 13 th , 2003, and 

the application date is August 13 th , 2005) in order to master the end of life and 

treatments for household and non household equipment. 

In other parts of the world some new legislation will follow the same objectives. 

In addition to manufacturers action in favour of products eco-design, the contribution 

of the whole electrical installation to sustainable development can be significantly 

improved through the design of the installation. Actually, it has been shown that an 

optimised design of the installation, taking into account operation conditions, MV/LV 

substations location and distribution structure (switchboards, busways, cables), 

can reduce substantially environmental impacts (raw material depletion, energy 

depletion, end of life) 

See chapter D about location of the substation and the main LV switchboard. 


A9 


A10 



An examination of the actual apparentpower 

demands of different loads: a 

necessary preliminary step in the design of a 

LV installation 

The nominal power in kW (Pn) of a motor 

indicates its rated equivalent mechanical power 

output. 

The apparent power in kVA (Pa) supplied to 

the motor is a function of the output, the motor 

efficiency and the power factor. 

Pa = Pn 

ηcosϕ 3 Installed power loads - 

Characteristics 

The examination of actual values of apparent-power required by each load enables 

the establishment of: 

b A declared power demand which determines the contract for the supply of energy 

b The rating of the MV/LV transformer, where applicable (allowing for expected 

increased load) 

b Levels of load current at each distribution board 

3.1 Induction motors 

Current demand 

The full-load current Ia supplied to the motor is given by the following formulae: 

b 3-phase motor: Ia = Pn x 1,000 / (√3 x U x η x cos ϕ) 

b 1-phase motor: Ia = Pn x 1,000 / (U x η x cos ϕ) 

where 

Ia: current demand (in amps) 

Pn: nominal power (in kW) 

U: voltage between phases for 3-phase motors and voltage between the terminals 

for single-phase motors (in volts). A single-phase motor may be connected phase-toneutral 

or phase-to-phase. 

η: per-unit efficiency, i.e. output kW / input kW 

cos ϕ: power factor, i.e. kW input / kVA input 

Subtransient current and protection setting 

b Subtransient current peak value can be very high ; typical value is about 12 

to 15 times the rms rated value Inm. Sometimes this value can reach 25 times Inm. 

b Merlin Gerin circuit-breakers, Telemecanique contactors and thermal relays are 

designed to withstand motor starts with very high subtransient current (subtransient 

peak value can be up to 19 times the rms rated value Inm). 

b If unexpected tripping of the overcurrent protection occurs during starting, this 

means the starting current exceeds the normal limits. As a result, some maximum 

switchgear withstands can be reached, life time can be reduced and even some 

devices can be destroyed. In order to avoid such a situation, oversizing of the 

switchgear must be considered. 

b Merlin Gerin and Telemecanique switchgears are designed to ensure the 

protection of motor starters against short-circuits. According to the risk, tables show 

the combination of circuit-breaker, contactor and thermal relay to obtain type 1 or 

type 2 coordination (see chapter N). 

Motor starting current 

Although high efficiency motors can be found on the market, in practice their starting 

currents are roughly the same as some of standard motors. 

The use of start-delta starter, static soft start unit or variable speed drive allows to 

reduce the value of the starting current (Example : 4 Ia instead of 7.5 Ia). 

Compensation of reactive-power (kvar) supplied to induction motors 

It is generally advantageous for technical and financial reasons to reduce the current 

supplied to induction motors. This can be achieved by using capacitors without 

affecting the power output of the motors. 

The application of this principle to the operation of induction motors is generally 

referred to as “power-factor improvement” or “power-factor correction”. 

As discussed in chapter L, the apparent power (kVA) supplied to an induction motor 

can be significantly reduced by the use of shunt-connected capacitors. Reduction 

of input kVA means a corresponding reduction of input current (since the voltage 

remains constant). 

Compensation of reactive-power is particularly advised for motors that operate for 

long periods at reduced power. 

kW input 

As noted above cos � = so so that a kVA input reduction in will kVA increase input will 

kVA input 

increase (i.e. improve) (i.e. improve) the value the of cos value ϕ. of cos 



3 Installed power loads - 


The current supplied to the motor, after power-factor correction, is given by: 

cos � 

I= 

Ia 

cos �' 

where cos �ϕ 

is the power factor before compensation and cos ϕ’ is the power factor 

after compensation, Ia being the original current. 

Figure A4 below shows, in function of motor rated power, standard motor current 

values for several voltage supplies. 

kW hp 230 V 380 - 400 V 440 - 500 V 690 V 

415 V 480 V 

A A A A A A 

0.18 - 1.0 - 0.6 - 0.48 0.35 

0.25 - 1.5 - 0.85 - 0.68 0.49 

0.37 - 1.9 - 1.1 - 0.88 0.64 

- 1/2 - 1.3 - 1.1 - - 

0.55 - 2.6 - 1.5 - 1.2 0.87 

- 3/4 - 1.8 - 1.6 - - 

- 1 - 2.3 - 2.1 - - 

0.75 - 3.3 - 1.9 - 1.5 1.1 

1.1 - 4.7 - 2.7 - 2.2 1.6 

- 1-1/2 - 3.3 - 3.0 - - 

- 2 - 4.3 - 3.4 - - 

1.5 - 6.3 - 3.6 - 2.9 2.1 

2.2 - 8.5 - 4.9 - 3.9 2.8 

- 3 - 6.1 - 4.8 - - 

3.0 - 11.3 - 6.5 - 5.2 3.8 

3.7 - - - - - - - 

4 - 15 9.7 8.5 7.6 6.8 4.9 

5.5 - 20 - 11.5 - 9.2 6.7 

- 7-1/2 - 14.0 - 11.0 - - 

- 10 - 18.0 - 14.0 - - 

7.5 - 27 - 15.5 - 12.4 8.9 

11 - 38.0 - 22.0 - 17.6 12.8 

- 15 - 27.0 - 21.0 - - 

- 20 - 34.0 - 27.0 - - 

15 - 51 - 29 - 23 17 

18.5 - 61 - 35 - 28 21 

- 25 - 44 - 34 - 

22 - 72 - 41 - 33 24 

- 30 - 51 - 40 - - 

- 40 - 66 - 52 - - 

30 - 96 - 55 - 44 32 

37 - 115 - 66 - 53 39 

- 50 - 83 - 65 - - 

- 60 - 103 - 77 - - 

45 - 140 - 80 - 64 47 

55 - 169 - 97 - 78 57 

- 75 - 128 - 96 - - 

- 100 - 165 - 124 - - 

75 - 230 - 132 - 106 77 

90 - 278 - 160 - 128 93 

- 125 - 208 - 156 - - 

110 - 340 - 195 156 113 

- 150 - 240 - 180 - - 

132 - 400 - 230 - 184 134 

- 200 - 320 - 240 - - 

150 - - - - - - - 

160 - 487 - 280 - 224 162 

185 - - - - - - - 

- 250 - 403 - 302 - - 

200 - 609 - 350 - 280 203 

220 - - - - - - - 

- 300 - 482 - 361 - - 

250 - 748 - 430 - 344 250 

280 - - - - - - - 

- 350 - 560 - 414 - - 

- 400 - 636 - 474 - - 

300 - - - - - - - 

Fig. A4 : Rated operational power and currents (continued on next page) 


A11 


A12 





kW hp 230 V 380 - 400 V 440 - 500 V 690 V 

415 V 480 V 

A A A A A A 

315 - 940 - 540 - 432 313 

- 540 - - - 515 - - 

335 - - - - - - - 

355 - 1061 - 610 - 488 354 

- 500 - 786 - 590 - - 

375 - - - - - - - 

400 - 1200 - 690 - 552 400 

425 - - - - - - - 

450 - - - - - - - 

475 - - - - - - - 

500 - 1478 - 850 - 680 493 

530 - - - - - - - 

560 - 1652 - 950 - 760 551 

600 - - - - - - - 

630 - 1844 - 1060 - 848 615 

670 - - - - - - - 

710 - 2070 - 1190 - 952 690 

750 - - - - - - - 

800 - 2340 - 1346 - 1076 780 

850 - - - - - - - 

900 - 2640 - 1518 - 1214 880 

950 - - - - - - - 

1000 - 2910 - 1673 - 1339 970 

Fig. A4 : Rated operational power and currents (concluded) 

3.2 Resistive-type heating appliances and 

incandescent lamps (conventional or halogen) 

The current demand of a heating appliance or an incandescent lamp is easily 

obtained from the nominal power Pn quoted by the manufacturer (i.e. cos ϕ = 1) 

(see Fig. A5). 

Fig. A5 : Current demands of resistive heating and incandescent lighting (conventional or 

halogen) appliances 


Nominal Current demand (A) 

power 1-phase 1-phase 3-phase 3-phase 

(kW) 127 V 230 V 230 V 400 V 

0.1 0.79 0.43 0.25 0.14 

0.2 1.58 0.87 0.50 0.29 

0.5 3.94 2.17 1.26 0.72 

1 7.9 4.35 2.51 1.44 

1.5 11.8 6.52 3.77 2.17 

2 15.8 8.70 5.02 2.89 

2.5 19.7 10.9 6.28 3.61 

3 23.6 13 7.53 4.33 

3.5 27.6 15.2 8.72 5.05 

4 31.5 17.4 10 5.77 

4.5 35.4 19.6 11.3 6.5 

5 39.4 21.7 12.6 7.22 

6 47.2 26.1 15.1 8.66 

7 55.1 30.4 17.6 10.1 

8 63 34.8 20.1 11.5 

9 71 39.1 22.6 13 

10 79 43.5 25.1 14.4


(1) Ia in amps; U in volts. Pn is in watts. If Pn is in kW, then 

multiply the equation by 1,000 

(2) “Power-factor correction” is often referred to as 

“compensation” in discharge-lighting-tube terminology. 

Cos ϕ is approximately 0.95 (the zero values of V and I 

are almost in phase) but the power factor is 0.5 due to the 

impulsive form of the current, the peak of which occurs “late” 

in each half cycle 



The currents are given by: 

b 3-phase case: I a = Pn 

3 U 


(1) 

(1) 

b 1-phase case: I a = Pn 

U 

where U is the voltage between the terminals of the equipment. 

where U is the voltage between the terminals of the equipment. 

For an incandescent lamp, the use of halogen gas allows a more concentrated light 

source. The light output is increased and the lifetime of the lamp is doubled. 

Note: At the instant of switching on, the cold filament gives rise to a very brief but 

intense peak of current. 

Fluorescent lamps and related equipment 

The power Pn (watts) indicated on the tube of a fluorescent lamp does not include 

the power dissipated in the ballast. 

The current is is given by: by: 

P + 

I a = ballast Pn 

U cos � 

If no power-loss value is indicated for the ballast, a figure of 25% of Pn may be used. 

Where U = the voltage applied to the lamp, complete with its related equipment. 


Standard tubular fluorescent lamps 

With (unless otherwise indicated): 

b cos ϕ = 0.6 with no power factor (PF) correction (2) capacitor 

b cos ϕ = 0.86 with PF correction (2) (single or twin tubes) 

b cos ϕ = 0.96 for electronic ballast. 


Figure A6 gives these values for different arrangements of ballast. 

Arrangement Tube power Current (A) at 230 V Tube 

of lamps, starters (W) (3) Magnetic ballast Electronic length 

and ballasts ballast (cm) 

Without PF With PF 

correction correction 

capacitor capacitor 

Single tube 18 0.20 0.14 0.10 60 

36 0.33 0.23 0.18 120 

58 0.50 0.36 0.28 150 

Twin tubes 2 x 18 0.28 0.18 60 

2 x 36 0.46 0.35 120 

2 x 58 0.72 0.52 150 

(3) Power in watts marked on tube 

Fig. A6 : Current demands and power consumption of commonly-dimensioned fluorescent 

lighting tubes (at 230 V-50 Hz) 

Compact fluorescent lamps 

Compact fluorescent lamps have the same characteristics of economy and long life 

as classical tubes. They are commonly used in public places which are permanently 

illuminated (for example: corridors, hallways, bars, etc.) and can be mounted in 

situations otherwise illuminated by incandescent lamps (see Fig. A7 next page). 

A13 


A14 



The power in watts indicated on the tube of 

a discharge lamp does not include the power 

dissipated in the ballast. 

Fig. A8 : Current demands of discharge lamps 



Fig. A7 : Current demands and power consumption of compact fluorescent lamps (at 230 V - 50 Hz) 

Discharge lamps 


Type of lamp Lamp power Current at 230 V 

(W) (A) 

Separated 10 0.080 

ballast lamp 18 0.110 

26 0.150 

Integrated 8 0.075 

ballast lamp 11 0.095 

16 0.125 

21 0.170 

Figure A8 gives the current taken by a complete unit, including all associated 

ancillary equipment. 

These lamps depend on the luminous electrical discharge through a gas or vapour 

of a metallic compound, which is contained in a hermetically-sealed transparent 

envelope at a pre-determined pressure. These lamps have a long start-up time, 

during which the current Ia is greater than the nominal current In. Power and current 

demands are given for different types of lamp (typical average values which may 

differ slightly from one manufacturer to another). 

Type of Power Current In(A) Starting Luminous Average Utilization 

lamp (W) demand PF not PF Ia/In Period efficiency timelife of 

(W) at corrected corrected (mins) (lumens lamp (h) 

230 V 400 V 230 V 400 V 230 V 400 V per watt) 

High-pressure sodium vapour lamps 

50 60 0.76 0.3 1.4 to 1.6 4 to 6 80 to 120 9000 b Lighting of 

70 80 1 0.45 large halls 

100 115 1.2 0.65 b Outdoor spaces 

150 168 1.8 0.85 b Public lighting 

250 274 3 1.4 

400 431 4.4 2.2 

1000 1055 10.45 4.9 

Low-pressure sodium vapour lamps 

26 34.5 0.45 0.17 1.1 to 1.3 7 to 15 100 to 200 8000 b Lighting of 

36 46.5 0.22 to 12000 autoroutes 

66 80.5 0.39 b Security lighting, 

91 105.5 0.49 station 

131 154 0.69 b Platform, storage 

areas 

Mercury vapour + metal halide (also called metal-iodide) 

70 80.5 1 0.40 1.7 3 to 5 70 to 90 6000 b Lighting of very 

150 172 1.80 0.88 6000 large areas by 

250 276 2.10 1.35 6000 projectors (for 

400 425 3.40 2.15 6000 example: sports 

1000 1046 8.25 5.30 6000 stadiums, etc.) 

2000 2092 2052 16.50 8.60 10.50 6 2000 

Mercury vapour + fluorescent substance (fluorescent bulb) 

50 57 0.6 0.30 1.7 to 2 3 to 6 40 to 60 8000 b Workshops 

80 90 0.8 0.45 to 12000 with very high 

125 141 1.15 0.70 ceilings (halls, 

250 268 2.15 1.35 hangars) 

400 421 3.25 2.15 b Outdoor lighting 

700 731 5.4 3.85 b Low light output (1) 

1000 1046 8.25 5.30 

2000 2140 2080 15 11 6.1 

(1) Replaced by sodium vapour lamps. 

Note: these lamps are sensitive to voltage dips. They extinguish if the voltage falls to less than 50% of their nominal voltage, and will 

not re-ignite before cooling for approximately 4 minutes. 

Note: Sodium vapour low-pressure lamps have a light-output efficiency which is superior to that of all other sources. However, use of 

these lamps is restricted by the fact that the yellow-orange colour emitted makes colour recognition practically impossible.


The installed power is the sum of the nominal 

powers of all power consuming devices in the 

installation. 

This is not the power to be actually supplied in 

practice. 

The installed apparent power is commonly 

assumed to be the arithmetical sum of the kVA 

of individual loads. The maximum estimated 

kVA to be supplied however is not equal to the 

total installed kVA. 

(1) For greater precision, account must be taken of the factor 

of maximum utilization as explained below in 4.3 

4 Power loading of an installation 

In order to design an installation, the actual maximum load demand likely to be 

imposed on the power-supply system must be assessed. 

To base the design simply on the arithmetic sum of all the loads existing in the 

installation would be extravagantly uneconomical, and bad engineering practice. 

The aim of this chapter is to show how some factors taking into account the diversity 

(non simultaneous operation of all appliances of a given group) and utilization 

(e.g. an electric motor is not generally operated at its full-load capability, etc.) of 

all existing and projected loads can be assessed. The values given are based on 

experience and on records taken from actual installations. In addition to providing 

basic installation-design data on individual circuits, the results will provide a 

global value for the installation, from which the requirements of a supply system 

(distribution network, MV/LV transformer, or generating set) can be specified. 

4.1 Installed power (kW) 

Most electrical appliances and equipments are marked to indicate their nominal 

power rating (Pn). 

The installed power is the sum of the nominal powers of all power-consuming 

devices in the installation. This is not the power to be actually supplied in practice. 

This is the case for electric motors, where the power rating refers to the output power 

at its driving shaft. The input power consumption will evidently be greater 

Fluorescent and discharge lamps associated with stabilizing ballasts, are other 

cases in which the nominal power indicated on the lamp is less than the power 

consumed by the lamp and its ballast. 

Methods of assessing the actual power consumption of motors and lighting 

appliances are given in Section 3 of this Chapter. 

The power demand (kW) is necessary to choose the rated power of a generating set 

or battery, and where the requirements of a prime mover have to be considered. 

For a power supply from a LV public-supply network, or through a MV/LV transformer, 

the significant quantity is the apparent power in kVA. 

4.2 Installed apparent power (kVA) 

The installed apparent power is commonly assumed to be the arithmetical sum of 

the kVA of individual loads. The maximum estimated kVA to be supplied however is 

not equal to the total installed kVA. 

The apparent-power demand of a load (which might be a single appliance) is 

obtained from its nominal power rating (corrected if necessary, as noted above for 

motors, etc.) and the application of the following coefficients: 

η = the per-unit efficiency = output kW / input kW 

cos ϕ = the power factor = kW / kVA 

The apparent-power kVA demand of the load 

Pa = Pn /(η x cos ϕ) 

From this value, the full-load current Ia (A) (1) From this value, the full-load current taken by the load will be: 

3 

Pa x 10 

cb Ia = 

V 

for 

From 

single phase-to-neutral connected load 

for single this phase-to-neutral value, the full-load connected current load 

Pa x 103 

c b Ia = 

3 x U 

for 

for three-phase 

single phase-to-neutral 

balanced load 

connected 

where: 

load 

V = phase-to-neutral voltage (volts) 

U = phase-to-phase voltage (volts) 

It may be noted that, strictly speaking, the total kVA of apparent power is not the 

arithmetical sum of the calculated kVA ratings of individual loads (unless all loads are 

at the same power factor). 

It is common practice however, to make a simple arithmetical summation, the result 

of which will give a kVA value that exceeds the true value by an acceptable “design 

margin”. 

When some or all of the load characteristics are not known, the values shown 

in Figure A9 next page may be used to give a very approximate estimate of VA 

demands (individual loads are generally too small to be expressed in kVA or kW). 

The estimates for lighting loads are based on floor areas of 500 m2 . 


A15 


A16 




Fluorescent lighting (corrected to cos ϕ = 0.86) 

Type of application Estimated (VA/m 2 ) Average lighting 

fluorescent tube level (lux = lm/m 2 ) 

with industrial reflector (1) 

Roads and highways 7 150 

storage areas, intermittent work 

Heavy-duty works: fabrication and 14 300 

assembly of very large work pieces 

Day-to-day work: office work 24 500 

Fine work: drawing offices 41 800 

high-precision assembly workshops 

Power circuits 

Type of application Estimated (VA/m 2 ) 

Pumping station compressed air 3 to 6 

Ventilation of premises 23 

Electrical convection heaters: 

private houses 115 to 146 

flats and apartments 90 

Offices 25 

Dispatching workshop 50 

Assembly workshop 70 

Machine shop 300 

Painting workshop 350 

Heat-treatment plant 700 

(1) example: 65 W tube (ballast not included), flux 5,100 lumens (Im), 

luminous efficiency of the tube = 78.5 Im / W. 

Fig. A9 : Estimation of installed apparent power 

4.3 Estimation of actual maximum kVA demand 

All individual loads are not necessarily operating at full rated nominal power nor 

necessarily at the same time. Factors ku and ks allow the determination of the 

maximum power and apparent-power demands actually required to dimension the 


Factor of maximum utilization (ku) 

In normal operating conditions the power consumption of a load is sometimes less 

than that indicated as its nominal power rating, a fairly common occurrence that 

justifies the application of an utilization factor (ku) in the estimation of realistic values. 

This factor must be applied to each individual load, with particular attention to 

electric motors, which are very rarely operated at full load. 

In an industrial installation this factor may be estimated on an average at 0.75 for 

motors. 

For incandescent-lighting loads, the factor always equals 1. 

For socket-outlet circuits, the factors depend entirely on the type of appliances being 

supplied from the sockets concerned. 

Factor of simultaneity (ks) 

It is a matter of common experience that the simultaneous operation of all installed 

loads of a given installation never occurs in practice, i.e. there is always some degree 

of diversity and this fact is taken into account for estimating purposes by the use of a 

simultaneity factor (ks). 

The factor ks is applied to each group of loads (e.g. being supplied from a distribution 

or sub-distribution board). The determination of these factors is the responsibility 

of the designer, since it requires a detailed knowledge of the installation and the 

conditions in which the individual circuits are to be exploited. For this reason, it is not 

possible to give precise values for general application. 

Factor of simultaneity for an apartment block 

Some typical values for this case are given in Figure A10 opposite page, and are 

applicable to domestic consumers supplied at 230/400 V (3-phase 4-wires). In the 

case of consumers using electrical heat-storage units for space heating, a factor of 

0.8 is recommended, regardless of the number of consumers. 




Example (see Fig. A11): 

5 storeys apartment building with 25 consumers, each having 6 kVA of installed load. 

The total installed load for the building is: 36 + 24 + 30 + 36 + 24 = 150 kVA 

The apparent-power supply required for the building is: 150 x 0.46 = 69 kVA 

From Figure A10, it is possible to determine the magnitude of currents in different 

sections of the common main feeder supplying all floors. For vertical rising mains 

fed at ground level, the cross-sectional area of the conductors can evidently be 

progressively reduced from the lower floors towards the upper floors. 

These changes of conductor size are conventionally spaced by at least 3-floor 

intervals. 

In the example, the current entering the rising main at ground level is: 

3 

150 x 0.46 x 10 

= 100 A 

400 3 

the current entering the third floor is: 

3 

(36 + 24) x 0.63 x 10 

= 55 A 

400 3 

4th 

floor 

3 rd 

floor 

2nd 

floor 

1 st 

floor 

ground 

floor 


Number of downstream Factor of 

consumers simultaneity (ks) 

2 to 4 1 

5 to 9 0.78 

10 to 14 0.63 

15 to 19 0.53 

20 to 24 0.49 

25 to 29 0.46 

30 to 34 0.44 

35 to 39 0.42 

40 to 49 0.41 

50 and more 0.40 

Fig. A10 : Simultaneity factors in an apartment block 

6 consumers 

36 kVA 

4 consumers 

24 kVA 

5 consumers 

30 kVA 

6 consumers 

36 kVA 

4 consumers 

24 kVA 

0.78 

0.63 

0.53 

0.49 

0.46 

Fig. A11 : Application of the factor of simultaneity (ks) to an apartment block of 5 storeys 

A17 


A18 




Factor of simultaneity for distribution boards 

Figure A12 shows hypothetical values of ks for a distribution board supplying a 

number of circuits for which there is no indication of the manner in which the total 

load divides between them. 

If the circuits are mainly for lighting loads, it is prudent to adopt ks values close to 

unity. 

Fig. A12 : Factor of simultaneity for distribution boards (IEC 60439) 

Circuit function Factor of simultaneity (ks) 

Lighting 1 

Heating and air conditioning 1 

Socket-outlets 0.1 to 0.2 (1) 

Lifts and catering hoist (2) b For the most powerful 

motor 1 

b For the second most 

powerful motor 0.75 

b For all motors 0.60 

(1) In certain cases, notably in industrial installations, this factor can be higher. 

(2) The current to take into consideration is equal to the nominal current of the motor, 

increased by a third of its starting current. 

Fig. A13 : Factor of simultaneity according to circuit function 

4.4 Example of application of factors ku and ks 

An example in the estimation of actual maximum kVA demands at all levels of an 

installation, from each load position to the point of supply is given Fig. A14 (opposite 

page). 

In this example, the total installed apparent power is 126.6 kVA, which corresponds 

to an actual (estimated) maximum value at the LV terminals of the MV/LV transformer 

of 65 kVA only. 

Note: in order to select cable sizes for the distribution circuits of an installation, the 

current I (in amps) through a circuit is determined from the equation: 

I = kVA x 10 

U 

3 

3 

where kVA is the actual maximum 3-phase apparent-power value shown on the 

diagram for the circuit concerned, and U is the phase to- phase voltage (in volts). 

4.5 Diversity factor 

The term diversity factor, as defined in IEC standards, is identical to the factor of 

simultaneity (ks) used in this guide, as described in 4.3. In some English-speaking 

countries however (at the time of writing) diversity factor is the inverse of ks i.e. it is 

always u 1. 


Number of Factor of 

circuits simultaneity (ks) 

Assemblies entirely tested 0.9 

2 and 3 

4 and 5 0.8 

6 to 9 0.7 

10 and more 0.6 

Assemblies partially tested 1.0 

in every case choose 

Factor of simultaneity according to circuit function 

ks factors which may be used for circuits supplying commonly-occurring loads, are 

shown in Figure A13.


Workshop A Lathe no. 1 5 0.8 

Pedestaldrill 

30 fluorescent 

lamps 

Workshop B Compressor 

Oven 

no. 2 

no. 3 

no. 4 

no. 1 

no. 2 

5 socketoutlets 

10/16 A 


10/16 A 


lamps 

Workshop C Ventilation no. 1 

no. 2 

no. 1 

no. 2 


10/16 A 


lamps 

5 

5 

5 

2 

2 

18 

0.8 

0.8 

0.8 

0.8 

0.8 

1 


Distribution 

box 

3 1 3 

1 

15 

10.6 

1 

2.5 

2.5 

15 

15 

18 

2 

1 

0.8 

1 

1 

1 

1 

1 

1 

1 

4 

4 

4 

4 

1.6 

1.6 

18 

12 

10.6 

1 

2.5 

2.5 

15 

15 

18 

2 

Fig A14 : An example in estimating the maximum predicted loading of an installation (the factor values used are for demonstration purposes only) 

0.75 

0.2 


1 

0.4 

1 

Distribution 

box 

1 

0.28 

1 

Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 

Utilization Apparent Utilization Apparent Simultaneity Apparent Simultaneity Apparent Simultaneity Apparent 

power factor power factor power factor power factor power 

(Pa) max. demand demand demand demand 

kVA max. kVA kVA kVA kVA 

14.4 

3.6 

3 

Power 

circuit 

Socketoulets 

Lighting 

circuit 

Powver 

circuit 

Workshop A 

distribution 

box 

Power 

circuit 

12 Workshop B 

Socketoulets 

distribution 

4.3 box 

1 

35 

5 

2 

Lighting 

circuit 

Socketoulets 

Lighting 

circuit 

0.9 

0.9 

Workshop C 

distribution 

box 

0.9 

18.9 

15.6 

37.8 

4.6 Choice of transformer rating 

Main 

general 

distribution 

board 

MGDB 

0.9 

65 

LV / MV 

When an installation is to be supplied directly from a MV/LV transformer and 

the maximum apparent-power loading of the installation has been determined, a 

suitable rating for the transformer can be decided, taking into account the following 

considerations (see Fig. A15): 

b The possibility of improving the power factor of the installation (see chapter L) 

b Anticipated extensions to the installation 

b Installation constraints (e.g. temperature) 

b Standard transformer ratings 

Apparent power In (A) 

kVA 237 V 410 V 

100 244 141 

160 390 225 

250 609 352 

315 767 444 

400 974 563 

500 1218 704 

630 1535 887 

800 1949 1127 

1000 2436 1408 

1250 3045 1760 

1600 3898 2253 

2000 4872 2816 

2500 6090 3520 

3150 7673 4436 

Fig. A15 : Standard apparent powers for MV/LV transformers and related nominal output currents 

A19 


A20 




The nominal full-load current In on the LV side of a 3-phase transformer is given by: 

a x 10 

In 

3 

= P 

U 3 

where 

b Pa = kVA rating of the transformer 

b U = phase-to-phase voltage at no-load in volts (237 V or 410 V) 

b In is in amperes. 

For a single-phase transformer: 

a x 10 

In 

3 

= P 

V 

where 

where 

b V = voltage between LV terminals at no-load (in volts) 

Simplified equation for 400 V (3-phase load) 

b In = kVA x 1.4 

The IEC standard for power transformers is IEC 60076. 

4.7 Choice of power-supply sources 

The importance of maintaining a continuous supply raises the question of the use of 

standby-power plant. The choice and characteristics of these alternative sources are 

part of the architecture selection, as described in chapter D. 

For the main source of supply the choice is generally between a connection to the 

MV or the LV network of the power-supply utility. 

In practice, connection to a MV source may be necessary where the load exceeds 

(or is planned eventually to exceed) a certain level - generally of the order of 

250 kVA, or if the quality of service required is greater than that normally available 

from a LV network. 

Moreover, if the installation is likely to cause disturbance to neighbouring consumers, 

when connected to a LV network, the supply authorities may propose a MV service. 

Supplies at MV can have certain advantages: in fact, a MV consumer: 

b Is not disturbed by other consumers, which could be the case at LV 

b Is free to choose any type of LV earthing system 

b Has a wider choice of economic tariffs 

b Can accept very large increases in load 

It should be noted, however, that: 

b The consumer is the owner of the MV/LV substation and, in some countries, 

he must build and equip it at his own expense. The power utility can, in certain 

circumstances, participate in the investment, at the level of the MV line for example 

b A part of the connection costs can, for instance, often be recovered if a second 

consumer is connected to the MV line within a certain time following the original 

consumer’s own connection 

b The consumer has access only to the LV part of the installation, access to the 

MV part being reserved to the utility personnel (meter reading, operations, etc.). 

However, in certain countries, the MV protective circuit-breaker (or fused load-break 

switch) can be operated by the consumer 

b The type and location of the substation are agreed between the consumer and 

the utility 


2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

Chapter B 

Connection to the MV utility 


Contents 

Supply of power at medium voltage B2 

1.1 Power supply characteristics of medium voltage B2 

utility distribution network 

1.2 Different MV service connections B11 

1.3 Some operational aspects of MV distribution networks B12 

Procedure for the establishment of a new substation B 4 

2.1 Preliminary informations B14 

2.2 Project studies B15 

2.3 Implementation B15 

2.4 Commissioning B15 

Protection aspect B 6 

3.1 Protection against electric shocks B16 

3.2 Protection of transformer and circuits B17 

3.3 Interlocks and conditioned operations B19 

The consumer substation with LV metering B22 

4.1 General B22 

4.2 Choice of MV switchgear B22 

4.3 Choice of MV switchgear panel for a transformer circuit B25 

4.4 Choice of MV/LV transformer B25 

4.5 Instructions for use of MV equipment B29 

The consumer substation with MV metering B32 

5.1 General B32 

5.2 Choice of panels B34 

5.3 Parallel operation of transformers B35 

Constitution of MV/LV distribution substations B37 

6.1 Different types of substation B37 

6.2 Indoor substation B37 

6.3 Outdoor substation B39 


B 



B2 

B - Connection to the MV public 


The main features which characterize a powersupply 

system include: 

b The nominal voltage and related insulation 

levels 

b The short-circuit current 

b The rated normal current of items of plant 

and equipment 

b The earthing system 

Supply of power at medium 

voltage 

The term "medium voltage" is commonly used for distribution systems with voltages 

above 1 kV and generally applied up to and including 52 kV (see IEC 601-01-28 

Standard). 

In this chapter, distribution networks which operate at voltages of 1,000 V or less 

are referred to as Low-Voltage systems, while systems of power distribution which 

require one stage of stepdown voltage transformation, in order to feed into low voltage 

networks, will be referred to as Medium- Voltage systems. 

For economic and technical reasons the nominal voltage of medium-voltage 

distribution systems, as defined above, seldom exceeds 35 kV. 

. Power supply characteristics of medium voltage 

utility distribution network 

Nominal voltage and related insulation levels 

The nominal voltage of a system or of an equipment is defined in IEC 60038 Standard 

as “the voltage by which a system or equipment is designated and to which certain 

operating characteristics are referred”. Closely related to the nominal voltage is the 

“highest voltage for equipment” which concerns the level of insulation at normal 

working frequency, and to which other characteristics may be referred in relevant 

equipment recommendations. 

The “highest voltage for equipment” is defined in IEC 60038 Standard as: 

“the maximum value of voltage for which equipment may be used, that occurs under 

normal operating conditions at any time and at any point on the system. It excludes 

voltage transients, such as those due to system switching, and temporary voltage 

variations”. 

Notes: 

- The highest voltage for equipment is indicated for nominal system voltages 

higher than 1,000 V only. It is understood that, particularly for some categories 

of equipment, normal operation cannot be ensured up to this "highest voltage for 

equipment", having regard to voltage sensitive characteristics such as losses of 

capacitors, magnetizing current of transformers, etc. In such cases, IEC standards 

specify the limit to which the normal operation of this equipment can be ensured. 

2- It is understood that the equipment to be used in systems having nominal voltage 

not exceeding 1,000 V should be specified with reference to the nominal system 

voltage only, both for operation and for insulation. 

3- The definition for “highest voltage for equipment” given in IEC 60038 Standard 

is identical to the definition given in IEC 62271-1 Standard for “rated voltage”. 

IEC 62271-1 Standard concerns switchgear for voltages exceeding 1,000 V. 

The following values of Figure B , taken from IEC 60038 Standard, list the 

most-commonly used standard levels of medium-voltage distribution, and relate 

the nominal voltages to corresponding standard values of “Highest Voltage for 

Equipment”. 

These systems are generally three-wire systems unless otherwise indicated. The 

values shown are voltages between phases. 

The values indicated in parentheses should be considered as non-preferred values. 

It is recommended that these values should not be used for new systems to be 

constructed in future. 

It is recommended that in any one country the ratio between two adjacent nominal 

voltages should be not less than two. 

Series I (for 50 Hz and 60 Hz networks) 

Nominal system voltage Highest voltage for equipement 

(kV) (kV) 

3.3 (1) 3 (1) 3.6 (1) 

6.6 (1) 6 (1) 7.2 (1) 

11 10 12 

- 15 17.5 

22 20 24 

33 (2) - 36 (2) 

- 35 (2) 40.5 (2) 

(1) These values should not be used for public distribution systems. 

(2) The unification of these values is under consideration. 

Fig. B1 : Relation between nominal system voltages and highest voltages for the equipment 




(1) This means basically that List 1 generally applies to 

switchgear to be used on underground-cable systems while 

List 2 is chosen for switchgear to be used on overhead-line 

systems. 


voltage 

In order to ensure adequate protection of equipment against abnormally-medium 

short term power-frequency overvoltages, and transient overvoltages caused by 

lightning, switching, and system fault conditions, etc. all MV equipment must be 

specified to have appropriate rated insulation levels. 

A "rated insulation level" is a set of specified dielectric withstand values covering 

various operating conditions. For MV equipment, in addition to the "highest voltage 

for equipment", it includes lightning impulse withstand and short-duration power 

frequency withstand. 

Switchgear 

Figure B2 shown below, lists normal values of “withstand” voltage requirements 

from IEC 62271-1 Standard. The choice between List 1 and List 2 values of table 

B2 depends on the degree of exposure to lightning and switching overvoltages (1) , 

the type of neutral earthing, and the type of overvoltage protection devices, etc. (for 

further guidance reference should be made to IEC 60071). 

Rated Rated lightning impulse withstand voltage Rated short-duration 

voltage (peak value) power-frequency 

U (r.m.s. withstand voltage 

value) List List 2 (r.m.s. value) 

To earth, Across the To earth, Across the To earth, Across the 

between isolating between isolating between isolating 

poles distance poles distance poles distance 

and across and across and across 

open open open 

switching switching switching 

device device device 

(kV) (kV) (kV) (kV) (kV) (kV) (kV) 

3.6 20 23 40 46 10 12 

7.2 40 46 60 70 20 23 

12 60 70 75 85 28 32 

17.5 75 85 95 110 38 45 

24 95 110 125 145 50 60 

36 145 165 170 195 70 80 

52 - - 250 290 95 110 

72.5 - - 325 375 140 160 

Note: The withstand voltage values “across the isolating distance” are valid only for 

the switching devices where the clearance between open contacts is designed to meet 

requirements specified for disconnectors (isolators). 

Fig. B2 : Switchgear rated insulation levels 

It should be noted that, at the voltage levels in question, no switching overvoltage 

ratings are mentioned. This is because overvoltages due to switching transients are 

less severe at these voltage levels than those due to lightning. 

Transformers 

Figure B3 shown below have been extracted from IEC 60076-3. 

The significance of list 1 and list 2 is the same as that for the switchgear table, i.e. 

the choice depends on the degree of exposure to lightning, etc. 

Highest voltage Rated short duration Rated lightning impulse 

for equipment power frequency withstand voltage 

(r.m.s.) withstand voltage (peak) 

(r.m.s.) List List 2 

(kV) (kV) (kV) (kV) 

y 1.1 3 - - 

3.6 10 20 40 

7.2 20 40 60 

12 28 60 75 

17.5 38 75 95 

24 50 95 125 

36 70 145 170 

52 95 250 

72.5 140 325 

Fig. B3 : Transformers rated insulation levels 


B3 



B4 



The national standards of any particular country 

are normally rationalized to include one or two 

levels only of voltage, current, and fault-levels, 

etc. 

A circuit-breaker (or fuse switch, over a limited 

voltage range) is the only form of switchgear 

capable of safely breaking all kinds of fault 

currents occurring on a power system. 

I p 

Current (I) 

22I'' k 

t min 

22I b 

IDC 22Ik Time (t) 

Fig. B5 : Graphic representation of short-circuit quantities as 

per IEC 60909 


voltage 

Other components 

It is evident that the insulation performance of other MV components associated 

with these major items, e.g. porcelain or glass insulators, MV cables, instrument 

transformers, etc. must be compatible with that of the switchgear and 

transformers noted above. Test schedules for these items are given in appropriate 

IEC publications. 

The national standards of any particular country are normally rationalized to include 

one or two levels only of voltage, current, and fault-levels, etc. 

General note: 

The IEC standards are intended for worldwide application and consequently 

embrace an extensive range of voltage and current levels. 

These reflect the diverse practices adopted in countries of different meteorologic, 

geographic and economic constraints. 

Short-circuit current 

Standard values of circuit-breaker short-circuit current-breaking capability are 

normally given in kilo-amps. 

These values refer to a 3-phase short-circuit condition, and are expressed as the 

average of the r.m.s. values of the AC component of current in each of the three 

phases. 

For circuit-breakers in the rated voltage ranges being considered in this chapter, 

Figure B4 gives standard short-circuit current-breaking ratings. 

kV 3.6 7.2 2 7.5 24 36 52 

kA 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 

(rms) 10 12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 

16 16 16 16 16 16 20 

25 25 25 25 25 25 

40 40 40 40 40 40 

50 

Fig. B4 : Standard short-circuit current-breaking ratings 

Short-circuit current calculation 

The rules for calculating short-circuit currents in electrical installations are presented 

in IEC standard 60909. 

The calculation of short-circuit currents at various points in a power system can 

quickly turn into an arduous task when the installation is complicated. 

The use of specialized software accelerates calculations. 

This general standard, applicable for all radial and meshed power systems, 50 or 

60 Hz and up to 550 kV, is extremely accurate and conservative. 

It may be used to handle the different types of solid short-circuit (symmetrical or 

dissymmetrical) that can occur in an electrical installation: 

b Three-phase short-circuit (all three phases), generally the type producing the 

highest currents 

b Two-phase short-circuit (between two phases), currents lower than three-phase faults 

b Two-phase-to-earth short-circuit (between two phases and earth) 

b Phase-to-earth short-circuit (between a phase and earth), the most frequent type 

(80% of all cases). 

When a fault occurs, the transient short-circuit current is a function of time and 

comprises two components (see Fig. B5). 

b An AC component, decreasing to its steady-state value, caused by the various 

rotating machines and a function of the combination of their time constants 

b A DC component, decreasing to zero, caused by the initiation of the current and a 

function of the circuit impedances 

Practically speaking, one must define the short-circuit values that are useful in 

selecting system equipment and the protection system: 

b I’’ k: rms value of the initial symmetrical current 

b Ib: rms value of the symmetrical current interrupted by the switching device when 

the first pole opens at tmin (minimum delay) 

b Ik: rms value of the steady-state symmetrical current 

b Ip: maximum instantaneous value of the current at the first peak 

b IDC: DC value of the current 





voltage 

These currents are identified by subscripts 3, 2, 2E, 1, depending on the type of 

short-circuit, respectively three-phase, two-phase clear of earth, two-phase-to-earth, 

phase-to-earth. 

The method, based on the Thevenin superposition theorem and decomposition into 

symmetrical components, consists in applying to the short-circuit point an equivalent 

source of voltage in view of determining the current. The calculation takes place in 

three steps. 

b Define the equivalent source of voltage applied to the fault point. It represents the 

voltage existing just before the fault and is the rated voltage multiplied by a factor 

taking into account source variations, transformer on-load tap changers and the 

subtransient behavior of the machines. 

b Calculate the impedances, as seen from the fault point, of each branch arriving at 

this point. For positive and negative-sequence systems, the calculation does not take 

into account line capacitances and the admittances of parallel, non-rotating loads. 

b Once the voltage and impedance values are defined, calculate the characteristic 

minimum and maximum values of the short-circuit currents. 

The various current values at the fault point are calculated using: 

b The equations provided 

b A summing law for the currents flowing in the branches connected to the node: 

v I’’ k (see Fig. B6 for I’’ k calculation, where voltage factor c is defined by the 

standard; geometric or algebraic summing) 

v I p = κ x 2 x I’’ k, where κ is less than 2, depending on the R/X ratio of the positive 

sequence impedance for the given branch; peak summing 

v I b = μ x q x I’’ k, where μ and q are less than 1, depending on the generators and 

motors, and the minimum current interruption delay; algebraic summing 

v I k = I’’ k, when the fault is far from the generator 

v I k = λ x I r, for a generator, where Ir is the rated generator current and λ is a factor 

depending on its saturation inductance; algebraic summing. 

Type of short-circuit I’’ k 

General situation Distant faults 

3-phase 

2-phase 

2-phase-to-earth 

Phase-to-earth + 0 + 1 0 

Fig. B6 : Short-circuit currents as per IEC 60909 

Characterization 


c Un 

3 Z1 c Un 

Z1 + Z2 

c Un 3 Z2 

Z1 Z2 + Z2 Z0 + Z1 Z0 

c Un 3 

Z1 

+Z +Z 2 0 

c Un 

3 Z1 c Un 

2Z1 

c Un 3 

1 + Z 2Z0 c Un 3 

2 Z1 + Z0 

There are 2 types of system equipment, based on whether or not they react when a 

fault occurs. 

Passive equipment 

This category comprises all equipment which, due to its function, must have 

the capacity to transport both normal current and short-circuit current. 

This equipment includes cables, lines, busbars, disconnecting switches, switches, 

transformers, series reactances and capacitors, instrument transformers. 

For this equipment, the capacity to withstand a short-circuit without damage 

is defined in terms of: 

b Electrodynamic withstand (“peak withstand current”; value of the peak current 

expressed in kA), characterizing mechanical resistance to electrodynamic stress 

b Thermal withstand (“short time withstand current”; rms value expressed in kA 

for duration between 0,5 and 3 seconds, with a preferred value of 1 second), 

characterizing maximum permissible heat dissipation. 

B5 



B6 



Current (I) 

I AC 

I DC 

I AC : Peak of the periodic component 

I DC : Aperiodic component 

Time (t) 


voltage 

Active equipment 

This category comprises the equipment designed to clear short-circuit currents, i.e. 

circuit-breakers and fuses. This property is expressed by the breaking capacity and, 

if required, the making capacity when a fault occurs. 

b Breaking capacity (see Fig. B7) 

This basic characteristic of a fault interrupting device is the maximum current (rms 

value expressed in kA) it is capable of breaking under the specific conditions defined 

by the standards; in the IEC 62271-100 standard, it refers to the rms value of the 

AC component of the short-circuit current. In some other standards, the rms value 

of the sum of the 2 components (AC and DC) is specified, in which case, it is the 

“asymmetrical current”. 

The breaking capacity depends on other factors such as: 

v Voltage 

v R/X ratio of the interrupted circuit 

v Power system natural frequency 

v Number of breaking operations at maximum current, for example the cycle: 

O - C/O - C/O (O = opening, C = closing) 

The breaking capacity is a relatively complicated characteristic to define and it 

therefore comes as no surprise that the same device can be assigned different 

breaking capacities depending on the standard by which it is defined. 

b Short-circuit making capacity 

In general, this characteristic is implicitly defined by the breaking capacity because a 

device should be able to close for a current that it can break. 

Sometimes, the making capacity needs to be higher, for example for circuit-breakers 

protecting generators. 

The making capacity is defined in terms of peak value (expressed in kA) because the 

first asymmetric peak is the most demanding from an electrodynamic point of view. 

For example, according to standard IEC 62271-100, a circuit-breaker used in a 50 Hz 

power system must be able to handle a peak making current equal to 2.5 times the 

rms breaking current (2.6 times for 60 Hz systems). 

Making capacity is also required for switches, and sometimes for disconnectors, even 

if these devices are not able to clear the fault. 

b Prospective short-circuit breaking current 

Some devices have the capacity to limit the fault current to be interrupted. 

Their breaking capacity is defined as the maximum prospective breaking current that 

would develop during a solid short-circuit across the upstream terminals of the device. 

Specific device characteristics 

The functions provided by various interrupting devices and their main constraints are 

presented in Figure B8. 

Device Isolation of Current switching Main constrains 

two active conditions 

networks Normal Fault 

Disconnector Yes No No Longitudinal input/output isolation 

Switch No Yes No Making and breaking of normal 

load current 

Short-circuit making capacity 

Contactor No Yes No Rated making and breaking 

capacities 

Maximum making and breaking 

capacities 

Duty and endurance 

characteristics 

Circuit-breaker No Yes Yes Short-circuit breaking capacity 

Short-circuit making capacity 

Fuse No No Yes Minimum short-circuit breaking 

capacity 

Maximum short-circuit breaking 

capacity 

Fig. B7 : Rated breaking current of a circuit-breaker subjected 

to a short-circuit as per IEC 60056 Fig. B8 : Functions provided by interrupting devices 




The most common normal current rating for 

general-purpose MV distribution switchgear is 

400 A. 


voltage 

Rated normal current 

The rated normal current is defined as “the r.m.s. value of the current which can be 

carried continuously at rated frequency with a temperature rise not exceeding that 

specified by the relevant product standard”. 

The rated normal current requirements for switchgear are decided at the substation 

design stage. 

The most common normal current rating for general-purpose MV distribution 

switchgear is 400 A. 

In industrial areas and medium-load-density urban districts, circuits rated at 630 A 

are sometimes required, while at bulk-supply substations which feed into MV 

networks, 

800 A; 1,250 A; 1,600 A; 2,500 A and 4,000 A circuit-breakers are listed as standard 

ratings for incoming-transformer circuits, bus-section and bus-coupler CBs, etc. 

For MV/LV transformer with a normal primary current up to roughly 60 A, 

a MV switch-fuse combination can be used . For higher primary currents, 

switch-fuse combination usually does not have the required performances. 

There are no IEC-recommended rated current values for switch-fuse combinations. 

The actual rated current of a given combination, meaning a switchgear base 

and defined fuses, is provided by the manufacturer of the combination as a table 

"fuse reference / rated current". These values of the rated current are defined by 

considering parameters of the combination as: 

b Normal thermal current of the fuses 

b Necessary derating of the fuses, due to their usage within the enclosure. 

When combinations are used for protecting transformers, then further parameters 

are to be considered, as presented in Appendix A of the IEC 62271-105 and in the 

IEC 60787. They are mainly: 

b The normal MV current of the transformer 

b The possible need for overloading the transformer 

b The inrush magnetizing current 

b The MV short-circuit power 

b The tapping switch adjustment range. 

Manufacturers usually provide an application table "service voltage / transformer 

power / fuse reference" based on standard distribution network and transformer 

parameters, and such table should be used with care, if dealing with unusual 

installations. 

In such a scheme, the load-break switch should be suitably fitted with a tripping 

device e.g. with a relay to be able to trip at low fault-current levels which must cover 

(by an appropriate margin) the rated minimum breaking current of the MV fuses. In 

this way, medium values of fault current which are beyond the breaking capability of 

the load-break switch will be cleared by the fuses, while low fault-current values, that 

cannot be correctly cleared by the fuses, will be cleared by the tripped load-break 

switch. 

Influence of the ambient temperature and altitude on the rated current 

Normal-current ratings are assigned to all current-carrying electrical appliances, 

and upper limits are decided by the acceptable temperature rise caused by the 

I 2 R (watts) dissipated in the conductors, (where I = r.m.s. current in amperes and 

R = the resistance of the conductor in ohms), together with the heat produced 

by magnetic-hysteresis and eddy-current losses in motors, transformers, steel 

enclosures, etc. and dielectric losses in cables and capacitors, where appropriate. 

The temperature rise above the ambient temperature will depend mainly on the 

rate at which the heat is removed. For example, large currents can be passed 

through electric motor windings without causing them to overheat, simply because 

a cooling fan fixed to the shaft of the motor removes the heat at the same rate as it 

is produced, and so the temperature reaches a stable value below that which could 

damage the insulation and result in a burnt-out motor. 

The normal-current values recommended by IEC are based on ambientair 

temperatures common to temperate climates at altitudes not exceeding 

1,000 metres, so that items which depend on natural cooling by radiation and 

air-convection will overheat if operated at rated normal current in a tropical climate 

and/ or at altitudes exceeding 1,000 metres. In such cases, the equipment has to be 

derated, i.e. be assigned a lower value of normal current rating. 

The case of transformer is addressed in IEC 60076-2. 


B7 



B8 



Earth faults on medium-voltage systems 

can produce dangerous voltage levels on 

LV installations. LV consumers (and substation 

operating personnel) can be safeguarded 

against this danger by: 

b Restricting the magnitude of MV earth-fault 

currents 

b Reducing the substation earthing resistance 

to the lowest possible value 

b Creating equipotential conditions at the 

substation and at the consumer’s installation 

Fault 

HV LV 

I f 

I f 

R s 

Fig. B9 : Transferred potential 

V= I f R s 

Consumer 

(1) The others being unearthed. A particular case of earth-fault 

current limitation is by means of a Petersen coil. 

1 

2 

3 

N 


voltage 

Earthing systems 

Earthing and equipment-bonding earth connections require careful consideration, 

particularly regarding safety of the LV consumer during the occurrence of a shortcircuit 

to earth on the MV system. 

Earth electrodes 

In general, it is preferable, where physically possible, to separate the electrode 

provided for earthing exposed conductive parts of MV equipment from the electrode 

intended for earthing the LV neutral conductor. This is commonly practised in rural 

systems where the LV neutral-conductor earth electrode is installed at one or two 

spans of LV distribution line away from the substation. 

In most cases, the limited space available in urban substations precludes this 

practice, i.e. there is no possibility of separating a MV electrode sufficiently from 

a LV electrode to avoid the transference of (possibly dangerous) voltages to the 

LV system. 

Earth-fault current 

Earth-fault current levels at medium voltage are generally (unless deliberately 

restricted) comparable to those of a 3-phase short-circuit. 

Such currents passing through an earth electrode will raise its voltage to a medium 

value with respect to “remote earth” (the earth surrounding the electrode will be 

raised to a medium potential; “remote earth” is at zero potential). 

For example, 10,000 A of earth-fault current passing through an electrode with an 

(unusually low) resistance of 0.5 ohms will raise its voltage to 5,000 V. 

Providing that all exposed metal in the substation is “bonded” (connected together) 

and then connected to the earth electrode, and the electrode is in the form of (or is 

connected to) a grid of conductors under the floor of the substation, then there is no 

danger to personnel, since this arrangement forms an equipotential “cage” in which 

all conductive material, including personnel, is raised to the same potential. 

Transferred potential 

A danger exists however from the problem known as Transferred Potential. It will be 

seen in Figure B9 that the neutral point of the LV winding of the MV/LV transformer 

is also connected to the common substation earth electrode, so that the neutral 

conductor, the LV phase windings and all phase conductors are also raised to the 

electrode potential. 

Low-voltage distribution cables leaving the substation will transfer this potential to 

consumers installations. It may be noted that there will be no LV insulation failure 

between phases or from phase to neutral since they are all at the same potential. It is 

probable, however, that the insulation between phase and earth of a cable or some 

part of an installation would fail. 

Solutions 

A first step in minimizing the obvious dangers of transferred potentials is to reduce 

the magnitude of MV earth-fault currents. This is commonly achieved by earthing the 

MV system through resistors or reactors at the star points of selected transformers (1) , 

located at bulk-supply substations. 

A relatively medium transferred potential cannot be entirely avoided by this means, 

however, and so the following strategy has been adopted in some countries. 

The equipotential earthing installation at a consumer’s premises represents a remote 

earth, i.e. at zero potential. However, if this earthing installation were to be connected 

by a low-impedance conductor to the earth electrode at the substation, then the 

equipotential conditions existing in the substation would also exist at the consumer’s 


Low-impedance interconnection 

This low-impedance interconnection is achieved simply by connecting the neutral 

conductor to the consumer’s equipotential installation, and the result is recognized as 

the TN earthing system (IEC 60364) as shown in diagram A of Figure B 0 next page. 

The TN system is generally associated with a Protective Multiple Earthing (PME) 

scheme, in which the neutral conductor is earthed at intervals along its length (every 

3rd or 4th pole on a LV overhead-line distributor) and at each consumer’s service 

position. It can be seen that the network of neutral conductors radiating from a 

substation, each of which is earthed at regular intervals, constitutes, together with 

the substation earthing, a very effective low-resistance earth electrode. 





voltage 

Diagram Rs value 

A - TN-a 

MV LV 

C - TT-a 

MV LV 

E - TT-b 

MV LV 

R S 

R S 

R S 

R N 

1 

2 

3 

N 

1 

2 

3 

N 

1 

2 

3 

N 

B - IT-a 

MV LV 

R S 

D - IT-b 

MV LV 

F - IT-c 

MV LV 

In cases E and F the LV protective conductors (bonding exposed conductive parts) in the substation 

are earthed via the substation earth electrode, and it is therefore the substation LV equipment (only) 

that could be subjected to overvoltage. 

R S 

R S 

R N 

Fig. B10 : Maximum earthing resistance Rs at a MV/LV substation to ensure safety during a short-circuit to earth fault on the medium-voltage equipment for different 

earthing systems 

The combination of restricted earth-fault currents, equipotential installations and 

low resistance substation earthing, results in greatly reduced levels of overvoltage 

and limited stressing of phase-to-earth insulation during the type of MV earth-fault 

situation described above. 

Limitation of the MV earth-fault current and earth resistance of the substation 

Another widely-used earthing system is shown in diagram C of Figure B10. It will be 

seen that in the TT system, the consumer’s earthing installation (being isolated from 

that of the substation) constitutes a remote earth. 

This means that, although the transferred potential will not stress the phase-to-phase 

insulation of the consumer’s equipment, the phase-to-earth insulation of all three 

phases will be subjected to overvoltage. 


1 

2 

3 

N 

1 

2 

3 

N 

1 

2 

3 

N 

Cases A and B 

No particular resistance value for Rs is imposed 

in these cases 

Cases C and D 

Uw - Uo 

Rs y 

Im 

Where 

Uw = the rated normal-frequency withstand 

voltage for low-voltage equipment at 

consumer installations 

Uo = phase to neutral voltage at consumer's 

installations 

Im = maximum value of MV earth-fault current 

Cases E and F 

Uws - U 

Rs y 

Im 

Where 

Uws = the normal-frequency withstand voltage 

for low-voltage equipments in the 

substation (since the exposed conductive 

parts of these equipments are earthed 

via Rs) 

U = phase to neutral voltage at the substation 

for the TT(s) system, but the phase-tophase 

voltage for the IT(s) system 

Im = maximum value of MV earth-fault current 

Notes: 

b For TN-a and IT-a, the MV and LV exposed conductive parts at the substation and those at the consumer’s installations, together with the 

LV neutral point of the transformer, are all earthed via the substation electrode system. 

b For TT-a and IT-b, the MV and LV exposed conductive parts at the substation, together with the LV neutral point of the transformer are earthed via 

the substation electrode system. 

b For TT-b and IT-c, the LV neutral point of the transformer is separately earthed outside of the area of influence of the substation earth electrode. 

Uw and Uws are commonly given the (IEC 60364-4-44) value Uo + 1200 V, where Uo is the nominal phase-to-neutral voltage of the LV system 

concerned. 

B9 


B 0 





voltage 

The strategy in this case, is to reduce the resistance of the substation earth 

electrode, such that the standard value of 5-second withstand-voltage-to-earth for 

LV equipment and appliances will not be exceeded. 

Practical values adopted by one national electrical power-supply authority, on its 

20 kV distribution systems, are as follows: 

b Maximum earth-fault current in the neutral connection on overhead line distribution 

systems, or mixed (O/H line and U/G cable) systems, is 300 A 

b Maximum earth-fault current in the neutral connection on underground systems is 

1,000 A 

The formula required to determine the maximum value of earthing resistance Rs at 

the 

the 

substation, 

substation, 

to 

to 

ensure 

ensure 

that 

that 

the 

the 

LV 

LV 

withstand 

withstand 

voltage 

voltage will 

will 

not 

not 

be 

be 

exceeded, 

exceeded, 

is: 

is: 

Uw �Uo 

Rs = in ohms (see cases C and D in Figure B10). C10). 

Im 

Where 

Where 

Uw = the lowest standard value (in volts) of short-term (5 s) withstand voltage for the 

consumer’s installation and appliances = Uo + 1200 V (IEC 60364-4-44) 

Uo = phase to neutral voltage (in volts) at the consumer’s LV service position 

Im = maximum earth-fault current on the MV system (in amps). This maximum earth 

fault current Im is the vectorial sum of maximum earth-fault current in the neutral 

connection and total unbalanced capacitive current of the network. 

A third form of system earthing referred to as the “IT” system in IEC 60364 is 

commonly used where continuity of supply is essential, e.g. in hospitals, continuousprocess 

manufacturing, etc. The principle depends on taking a supply from an 

unearthed source, usually a transformer, the secondary winding of which is 

unearthed, or earthed through a medium impedance (u1,000 ohms). In these cases, 

an insulation failure to earth in the low-voltage circuits supplied from the secondary 

windings will result in zero or negligible fault-current flow, which can be allowed to 

persist until it is convenient to shut-down the affected circuit to carry out repair work. 

Diagrams B, D and F (Figure B10) 

They show IT systems in which resistors (of approximately 1,000 ohms) are included 

in the neutral earthing lead. 

If however, these resistors were removed, so that the system is unearthed, the 

following notes apply. 

Diagram B (Figure B10) 

All phase wires and the neutral conductor are “floating” with respect to earth, to which 

they are “connected” via the (normally very medium) insulation resistances and (very 

small) capacitances between the live conductors and earthed metal (conduits, etc.). 

Assuming perfect insulation, all LV phase and neutral conductors will be raised by 

electrostatic induction to a potential approaching that of the equipotential conductors. 

In practice, it is more likely, because of the numerous earth-leakage paths of all live 

conductors in a number of installations acting in parallel, that the system will behave 

similarly to the case where a neutral earthing resistor is present, i.e. all conductors 

will be raised to the potential of the substation earth. 

In these cases, the overvoltage stresses on the LV insulation are small or nonexistent. 

Diagrams D and F (Figure B10) 

In these cases, the medium potential of the substation (S/S) earthing system acts on 

the isolated LV phase and neutral conductors: 

b Through the capacitance between the LV windings of the transformer and the 

transformer tank 

b Through capacitance between the equipotential conductors in the S/S and the 

cores of LV distribution cables leaving the S/S 

b Through current leakage paths in the insulation, in each case. 

At positions outside the area of influence of the S/S earthing, system capacitances 

exist between the conductors and earth at zero potential (capacitances between 

cores are irrelevant - all cores being raised to the same potential). 

The result is essentially a capacitive voltage divider, where each “capacitor” is 

shunted by (leakage path) resistances. 

In general, LV cable and installation wiring capacitances to earth are much 

larger, and the insulation resistances to earth are much smaller than those of the 

corresponding parameters at the S/S, so that most of the voltage stresses appear at 

the substation between the transformer tank and the LV winding. 

The rise in potential at consumers’ installations is not likely therefore to be a problem 

where the MV earth-fault current level is restricted as previously mentioned. 




Overhead line 

Fig. B11 : Single-line service 

Underground cable 

ring main 

Fig. B12 : Ring-main service 

(1) Copper is cathodic to most other metals and therefore 

resists corrosion. 

(2) A ring main is a continuous distributor in the form of a 

closed loop, which originates and terminates on one set of 

busbars. Each end of the loop is controlled by its own circuitbreaker. 

In order to improve operational flexibility the busbars 

are often divided into two sections by a normally closed bussection 

circuit-breaker, and each end of the ring is connected 

to a different section. 

An interconnector is a continuous untapped feeder connecting 

the busbars of two substations. Each end of the interconnector 

is usually controlled by a circuit beaker. 

An interconnector-distributor is an interconnector which 

supplies one or more distribution substations along its length. 


voltage 

All IT-earthed transformers, whether the neutral point is isolated or earthed through 

a medium impedance, are routinely provided with an overvoltage limiting device 

which will automatically connect the neutral point directly to earth if an overvoltage 

condition approaches the insulation-withstand level of the LV system. 

In addition to the possibilities mentioned above, several other ways in which these 

overvoltages can occur are described in Clause 3.1. 

This kind of earth-fault is very rare, and when does occur is quickly detected and 

cleared by the automatic tripping of a circuit-breaker in a properly designed and 

constructed installation. 

Safety in situations of elevated potentials depends entirely on the provision of 

properly arranged equipotential areas, the basis of which is generally in the form of a 

widemeshed grid of interconnected bare copper conductors connected to verticallydriven 

copper-clad (1) steel rods. 

The equipotential criterion to be respected is that which is mentioned in Chapter F 

dealing with protection against electric shock by indirect contact, namely: that the 

potential between any two exposed metal parts which can be touched simultaneously 

by any parts the body must never, under any circumstances, exceed 50 V in dry 

conditions, or 25 V in wet conditions. 

Special care should be taken at the boundaries of equipotential areas to avoid steep 

potential gradients on the surface of the ground which give rise to dangerous “step 

potentials”. 

This question is closely related to the safe earthing of boundary fences and is further 

discussed in Sub-clause 3.1. 

.2 Different MV service connections 

According to the type of medium-voltage network, the following supply arrangements 

are commonly adopted. 

Single-line service 

The substation is supplied by a single circuit tee-off from a MV distributor (cable or 

line). 

In general, the MV service is connected into a panel containing a load-break/ 

isolating switch-fuse combination and earthing switches, as shown in Figure B . 

In some countries a pole-mounted transformer with no MV switchgear or fuses 

(at the pole) constitutes the “substation”. This type of MV service is very common in 

rural areas. 

Protection and switching devices are remote from the transformer, and generally 

control a main overhead line, from which a number of these elementary service lines 

are tapped. 

Ring-main service 

Ring-main units (RMU) are normally connected to form a MV ring main (2) or 

interconnector-distributor (2) , such that the RMU busbars carry the full ring-main or 

interconnector current (see Fig. B 2). 

The RMU consists of three units, integrated to form a single assembly, viz: 

b 2 incoming units, each containing a load break/isolating switch and a circuit 

earthing switch 

b 1 outgoing and general protection unit, containing a load-break switch and 

MV fuses, or a combined load-break/fuse switch, or a circuit-breaker and isolating 

switch, together with a circuit-earthing switch in each case. 

All load-break switches and earthing switches are fully rated for short-circuit currentmaking 

duty. 

This arrangement provides the user with a two-source supply, thereby reducing 

considerably any interruption of service due to system faults or operations by the 

supply authority, etc. 

The main application for RMUs is in utility supply MV underground-cable networks in 

urban areas. 


B 


B 2 




Paralleled underground 

cable distributors 

Fig. B13 : Parallel feeders service 


voltage 

Parallel feeders service 

Where a MV supply connection to two lines or cables originating from the same 

busbar of a substation is possible, a similar MV switchboard to that of a RMU is 

commonly used (see Fig. B 3). 

The main operational difference between this arrangement and that of a RMU is that 

the two incoming panels are mutually interlocked, such that one incoming switch only 

can be closed at a time, i.e. its closure prevents the closure of the other. 

On the loss of power supply, the closed incoming switch must be opened and the 

(formerly open) switch can then be closed. 

The sequence may be carried out manually or automatically. 

This type of switchboard is used particularly in networks of medium-load density and 

in rapidly-expanding urban areas supplied by MV underground cable systems. 

.3 Some operational aspects of MV distribution 

networks 

Overhead lines 

Medium winds, ice formation, etc., can cause the conductors of overhead lines to 

touch each other, thereby causing a momentary (i.e. not permanent) short-circuit 

fault. 

Insulation failure due to broken ceramic or glass insulators, caused by air-borne 

debris; careless use of shot-guns, etc., or again, heavily polluted insulator surfaces, 

can result in a short-circuit to earth. 

Many of these faults are self-clearing. For example, in dry conditions, broken 

insulators can very often remain in service undetected, but are likely to flashover to 

earth (e.g. to a metal supporting structure) during a rainstorm. Moreover, polluted 

surfaces generally cause a flashover to earth only in damp conditions. 

The passage of fault current almost invariably takes the form of an electric arc, the 

intense heat of which dries the current path, and to some extent, re-establishes its 

insulating properties. In the meantime, protective devices have usually operated to 

clear the fault, i.e. fuses have blown or a circuit-breaker has tripped. 

Experience has shown that in the large majority of cases, restoration of supply by 

replacing fuses or by re-closing a circuit-breaker will be successful. 

For this reason it has been possible to considerably improve the continuity of service 

on MV overhead-line distribution networks by the application of automatic circuitbreaker 

reclosing schemes at the origin of the circuits concerned. 

These automatic schemes permit a number of reclosing operations if a first attempt 

fails, with adjustable time delays between successive attempts (to allow de-ionization 

of the air at the fault) before a final lock-out of the circuit-breaker occurs, after all 

(generally three) attempts fail. 

Other improvements in service continuity are achieved by the use of remotelycontrolled 

section switches and by automatic isolating switches which operate in 

conjunction with an auto-reclosing circuit-breaker. 

This last scheme is exemplified by the final sequence shown in Figure B 4 next 

page. 

The principle is as follows: if, after two reclosing attempts, the circuit-breaker trips, 

the fault is assumed to be permanent, then there are two possibilities: 

b The fault is on the section downstream the Automatic Line Switch, and while the 

feeder is dead the ALS opens to isolate this section of the network, before the third 

(and final) reclosing takes place, 

b The fault is on the section upstream the ALS and the circuit-breaker will make a 

third reclosing attempt and thus trip and lock out. 

While these measures have greatly improved the reliability of supplies from 

MV overhead line systems, the consumers must, where considered necessary, make 

their own arrangements to counter the effects of momentary interruptions to supply 

(between reclosures), for example: 

b Uninterruptible standby emergency power 

b Lighting that requires no cooling down before re-striking (“hot restrike”). 




Centralized remote control, based on SCADA 

(Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition) 

systems and recent developments in IT 

(Information Technology) techniques, is 

becoming more and more common in countries 

in which the complexity of highly interconnected 

systems justifies the expenditure. 


voltage 

1- Cycle 1SR 

If O1 O2 

In Io 15 to 30 s 

fault 

0.3 s 0.4 s 

2 - Cycle 2SR 

a - Fault on main feeder 

If O1 O2 

In Io 15 to 30s 

fault 

b - Fault on section supplied through Automatic Line Switch 

If O1 O2 

SR1 O3 

In Io 15 to 30 s 

15 to 30 s 

Fault 

0.3 s 0.4 s 

0.3 s 0.4 s 

Fig. B14 : Automatic reclosing cycles of a circuit-breaker controlling a radial MV feeder 

Underground cable networks 

Faults on underground cable networks are sometimes the result of careless 

workmanship by cable jointers or by cable laying contractors, etc., but are more 

commonly due to damage from tools such as pick-axes, pneumatic drills and trench 

excavating machines, and so on, used by other utilities. 

Insulation failures sometimes occur in cable terminating boxes due to overvoltage, 

particularly at points in a MV system where an overhead line is connected to an 

underground cable. The overvoltage in such a case is generally of atmospheric 

origin, and electromagnetic-wave reflection effects at the joint box (where the natural 

impedance of the circuit changes abruptly) can result in overstressing of the cablebox 

insulation to the point of failure. Overvoltage protection devices, such as lightning 

arresters, are frequently installed at these locations. 

Faults occurring in cable networks are less frequent than those on overhead (O/H) 

line systems, but are almost invariably permanent faults, which require more time for 

localization and repair than those on O/H lines. 

Where a cable fault occurs on a ring, supply can be quickly restored to all consumers 

when the faulty section of cable has been determined. 

If, however, the fault occurs on a radial feeder, the delay in locating the fault and 

carrying out repair work can amount to several hours, and will affect all consumers 

downstream of the fault position. In any case, if supply continuity is essential on all, 

or part of, an installation, a standby source must be provided. 

Remote control of MV networks 

Remote control on MV feeders is useful to reduce outage durations in case of cable 

fault by providing an efficient and fast mean for loop configuration. This is achieved 

by motor operated switches implemented in some of the substations along the loop 

associated with relevant remote telecontrol units. Remote controled substation will 

always be reenergized through telecontroled operation when the other ones could 

have to wait for further manual operation. 


SR O3 

Permanent fault 

SR1 O3 

0.4 s 

0.4 s 

15 to 30 s 

SR2 O4 

Permanent fault 

0.45 s 

SR2 

Opening of ALS 

B 3 


B14 




The consumer must provide certain data to the 

utility at the earliest stage of the project. 

2 Procedure for the establishment 

of a new substation 

Large consumers of electricity are invariably supplied at MV. 

On LV systems operating at 120/208 V (3-phase 4-wires), a load of 50 kVA might be 

considered to be “large”, while on a 240/415 V 3-phase system a “large” consumer 

could have a load in excess of 100 kVA. Both systems of LV distribution are common 

in many parts of the world. 

As a matter of interest, the IEC recommends a “world” standard of 230/400 V for 

3-phase 4-wire systems. This is a compromise level and will allow existing systems 

which operate at 220/380 V and at 240/415 V, or close to these values, to comply 

with the proposed standard simply by adjusting the off-circuit tapping switches of 

standard distribution transformers. 

The distance over which the energy has to be transmitted is a further factor in 

considering an MV or LV service. Services to small but isolated rural consumers are 

obvious examples. 

The decision of a MV or LV supply will depend on local circumstances and 

considerations such as those mentioned above, and will generally be imposed by the 

utility for the district concerned. 

When a decision to supply power at MV has been made, there are two widelyfollowed 

methods of proceeding: 

1 - The power-supplier constructs a standard substation close to the consumer’s 

premises, but the MV/LV transformer(s) is (are) located in transformer chamber(s) 

inside the premises, close to the load centre 

2 - The consumer constructs and equips his own substation on his own premises, to 

which the power supplier makes the MV connection 

In method no. 1 the power supplier owns the substation, the cable(s) to the 

transformer(s), the transformer(s) and the transformer chamber(s), to which he has 

unrestricted access. 

The transformer chamber(s) is (are) constructed by the consumer (to plans and 

regulations provided by the supplier) and include plinths, oil drains, fire walls and 

ceilings, ventilation, lighting, and earthing systems, all to be approved by the supply 

authority. 

The tariff structure will cover an agreed part of the expenditure required to provide 

the service. 

Whichever procedure is followed, the same principles apply in the conception and 

realization of the project. The following notes refer to procedure no. 2. 

2.1 Preliminary information 

Before any negotiations or discussions can be initiated with the supply authorities, 

the following basic elements must be established: 

Maximum anticipated power (kVA) demand 

Determination of this parameter is described in Chapter A, and must take into 

account the possibility of future additional load requirements. Factors to evaluate at 

this stage are: 

b The utilization factor (ku) 

b The simultaneity factor (ks) 

Layout plans and elevations showing location of proposed substation 

Plans should indicate clearly the means of access to the proposed substation, with 

dimensions of possible restrictions, e.g. entrances corridors and ceiling height, 

together with possible load (weight) bearing limits, and so on, keeping in mind that: 

b The power-supply personnel must have free and unrestricted access to the 

MV equipment in the substation at all times 

b Only qualified and authorized consumer’s personnel are allowed access to the 

substation 

b Some supply authorities or regulations require that the part of the installation operated 

by the authority is located in a separated room from the part operated by the customer. 

Degree of supply continuity required 

The consumer must estimate the consequences of a supply failure in terms of its 

duration: 

b Loss of production 

b Safety of personnel and equipment 




The utility must give specific information to the 

prospective consumer. 

The utility must give official approval of the 

equipment to be installed in the substation, 

and of proposed methods of installation. 

After testing and checking of the installation by 

an independent test authority, a certificate is 

granted which permits the substation to be put 

into service. 

2 Procedure for the establishment 

of a new substation 

2.2 Project studies 

From the information provided by the consumer, the power-supplier must indicate: 

The type of power supply proposed, and define: 

b The kind of power-supply system: overheadline or underground-cable network 

b Service connection details: single-line service, ring-main installation, or parallel 

feeders, etc. 

b Power (kVA) limit and fault current level 

The nominal voltage and rated voltage (Highest voltage for equipment) 

Existing or future, depending on the development of the system. 

Metering details which define: 

b The cost of connection to the power network 

b Tariff details (consumption and standing charges) 

2.3 Implementation 

Before any installation work is started, the official agreement of the power-supplier 

must be obtained. The request for approval must include the following information, 

largely based on the preliminary exchanges noted above: 

b Location of the proposed substation 

b Single-line diagram of power circuits and connections, together with earthingcircuit 

proposals 

b Full details of electrical equipment to be installed, including performance 


b Layout of equipment and provision for metering components 

b Arrangements for power-factor improvement if required 

b Arrangements provided for emergency standby power plant (MV or LV) if eventually 

required 

2.4 Commissioning 

When required by the authority, commissioning tests must be successfully completed 

before authority is given to energize the installation from the power supply system. 

Even if no test is required by the authority it is better to do the following verification tests: 

b Measurement of earth-electrode resistances 

b Continuity of all equipotential earth-and safety bonding conductors 

b Inspection and functional testing of all MV components 

b Insulation checks of MV equipment 

b Dielectric strength test of transformer oil (and switchgear oil if appropriate), if 

applicable 

b Inspection and testing of the LV installation in the substation 

b Checks on all interlocks (mechanical key and electrical) and on all automatic 

sequences 

b Checks on correct protective-relay operation and settings 

It is also imperative to check that all equipment is provided, such that any properly 

executed operation can be carried out in complete safety. On receipt of the certificate 

of conformity (if required): 

b Personnel of the power-supply authority will energize the MV equipment and check 

for correct operation of the metering 

b The installation contractor is responsible for testing and connection of the 

LV installation 

When finally the substation is operational: 

b The substation and all equipment belongs to the consumer 

b The power-supply authority has operational control over all MV switchgear in the 

substation, e.g. the two incoming load-break switches and the transformer MV switch 

(or CB) in the case of a RingMainUnit, together with all associated MV earthing switches 

b The power-supply personnel has unrestricted access to the MV equipment 

b The consumer has independent control of the MV switch (or CB) of the transformer(s) 

only, the consumer is responsible for the maintenance of all substation equipment, 

and must request the power-supply authority to isolate and earth the switchgear to 

allow maintenance work to proceed. The power supplier must issue a signed permitto-work 

to the consumers maintenance personnel, together with keys of locked-off 

isolators, etc. at which the isolation has been carried out. 


B15 


B16 




Protection against electric shocks and 

overvoltages is closely related to the 

achievement of efficient (low resistance) 

earthing and effective application of the 

principles of equipotential environments. 

3 Protection aspect 

The subject of protection in the electrical power industry is vast: it covers all aspects 

of safety for personnel, and protection against damage or destruction of property, 

plant, and equipment. 

These different aspects of protection can be broadly classified according to the 

following objectives: 

b Protection of personnel and animals against the dangers of overvoltages and 

electric shock, fire, explosions, and toxic gases, etc. 

b Protection of the plant, equipment and components of a power system against 

the stresses of short-circuit faults, atmospheric surges (lightning) and power-system 

instability (loss of synchronism) etc. 

b Protection of personnel and plant from the dangers of incorrect power-system 

operation, by the use of electrical and mechanical interlocking. All classes of 

switchgear (including, for example, tap-position selector switches on transformers, 

and so on...) have well-defined operating limits. This means that the order in which 

the different kinds of switching device can be safely closed or opened is vitally 

important. Interlocking keys and analogous electrical control circuits are frequently 

used to ensure strict compliance with correct operating sequences. 

It is beyond the scope of a guide to describe in full technical detail the numerous 

schemes of protection available to power-systems engineers, but it is hoped that the 

following sections will prove to be useful through a discussion of general principles. 

While some of the protective devices mentioned are of universal application, 

descriptions generally will be confined to those in common use on MV and 

LV systems only, as defined in Sub-clause 1.1 of this Chapter. 

3.1 Protection against electric shocks 

Protective measures against electric shock are based on two common dangers: 

b Contact with an active conductor, i.e. which is live with respect to earth in normal 

circumstances. This is referred to as a “direct contact” hazard. 

b Contact with a conductive part of an apparatus which is normally dead, but which 

has become live due to insulation failure in the apparatus. This is referred to as an 

“indirect contact” hazard. 

It may be noted that a third type of shock hazard can exist in the proximity of MV or 

LV (or mixed) earth electrodes which are passing earth-fault currents. This hazard 

is due to potential gradients on the surface of the ground and is referred to as a 

“step-voltage” hazard; shock current enters one foot and leaves by the other foot, and 

is particular dangerous for four-legged animals. A variation of this danger, known as 

a “touch voltage” hazard can occur, for instance, when an earthed metallic part is 

situated in an area in which potential gradients exist. 

Touching the part would cause current to pass through the hand and both feet. 

Animals with a relatively long front-to-hind legs span are particularly sensitive to 

step-voltage hazards and cattle have been killed by the potential gradients caused by 

a low voltage (230/400 V) neutral earth electrode of insufficiently low resistance. 

Potential-gradient problems of the kind mentioned above are not normally 

encountered in electrical installations of buildings, providing that equipotential 

conductors properly bond all exposed metal parts of equipment and all extraneous 

metal (i.e. not part of an electrical apparatus or the installation - for example 

structural steelwork, etc.) to the protective-earthing conductor. 

Direct-contact protection or basic protection 

The main form of protection against direct contact hazards is to contain all live parts 

in housings of insulating material or in metallic earthed housings, by placing out of 

reach (behind insulated barriers or at the top of poles) or by means of obstacles. 

Where insulated live parts are housed in a metal envelope, for example transformers, 

electric motors and many domestic appliances, the metal envelope is connected to 

the installation protective earthing system. 

For MV switchgear, the IEC standard 62271-200 (Prefabricated Metal Enclosed 

switchgear and controlgear for voltages up to 52 kV) specifies a minimum Protection 

Index (IP coding) of IP2X which ensures the direct-contact protection. Furthermore, 

the metallic enclosure has to demonstrate an electrical continuity, then establishing 

a good segregation between inside and ouside of the enclosure. Proper grounding of 

the enclosure further participates to the electrical protection of the operators under 

normal operating conditions. 

For LV appliances this is achieved through the third pin of a 3-pin plug and socket. 

Total or even partial failure of insulation to the metal, can raise the voltage of the 

envelope to a dangerous level (depending on the ratio of the resistance of the leakage 

path through the insulation, to the resistance from the metal envelope to earth). 





Indirect-contact protection or fault protection 

A person touching the metal envelope of an apparatus with a faulty insulation, as 

described above, is said to be making an indirect contact. 

An indirect contact is characterized by the fact that a current path to earth exists 

(through the protective earthing (PE) conductor) in parallel with the shock current 

through the person concerned. 

Case of fault on L.V. system 

Extensive tests have shown that, providing the potential of the metal envelope is not 

greater than 50 V with respect to earth, or to any conductive material within reaching 

distance, no danger exists. 

Indirect-contact hazard in the case of a MV fault 

If the insulation failure in an apparatus is between a MV conductor and the metal 

envelope, it is not generally possible to limit the rise of voltage of the envelope to 

50 V or less, simply by reducing the earthing resistance to a low value. The solution 

in this case is to create an equipotential situation, as described in Sub-clause 1.1 

“Earthing systems”. 

3.2 Protection of transformer and circuits 

General 

The electrical equipment and circuits in a substation must be protected in order 

to avoid or to control damage due to abnormal currents and/or voltages. All 

equipment normally used in power system installations have standardized short-time 

withstand ratings for overcurrent and overvoltage. The role of protective scheme is 

to ensure that this withstand limits can never be exceeded. In general, this means 

that fault conditions must be cleared as fast as possible without missing to ensure 

coordination between protective devices upstream and downstream the equipement 

to be protected. This means, when there is a fault in a network, generally several 

protective devices see the fault at the same time but only one must act. 

These devices may be: 

b Fuses which clear the faulty circuit directly or together with a mechanical tripping 

attachment, which opens an associated three-phase load-break switch 

b Relays which act indirectly on the circuit-breaker coil 

Transformer protection 

Stresses due to the supply network 

Some voltage surges can occur on the network such as : 

b Atmospheric voltage surges 

Atmospheric voltage surges are caused by a stroke of lightning falling on or near an 

overhead line. 

b Operating voltage surges 

A sudden change in the established operating conditions in an electrical network 

causes transient phenomena to occur. This is generally a high frequency or damped 

oscillation voltage surge wave. 

For both voltage surges, the overvoltage protection device generally used is a 

varistor (Zinc Oxide). 

In most cases, voltage surges protection has no action on switchgear. 

Stresses due to the load 

Overloading is frequently due to the coincidental demand of a number of small 

loads, or to an increase in the apparent power (kVA) demand of the installation, 

due to expansion in a factory, with consequent building extensions, and so on. Load 

increases raise the temperature of the wirings and of the insulation material. As 

a result, temperature increases involve a reduction of the equipment working life. 

Overload protection devices can be located on primary or secondary side of the 

transformer. 

The protection against overloading of a transformer is now provided by a digital relay 

which acts to trip the circuit-breaker on the secondary side of the transformer. Such 

relay, generally called thermal overload relay, artificially simulates the temperature, 

taking into account the time constant of the transformer. Some of them are able to 

take into account the effect of harmonic currents due to non linear loads (rectifiers, 

computer equipment, variable speed drives…).This type of relay is also able to 

predict the time before overload tripping and the waiting time after tripping. So, this 

information is very helpful to control load shedding operation. 


B17 


B18 




Fig. B15 : Transformer with conservator tank 

Fig. B16 : Totally filled transformer 

1 

2 

3 

Overcurrent relay 

E/F relay 

HV LV 

Fig. B17 : Protection against earth fault on the MV winding 

1 

2 

3 

N 


In addition, larger oil-immersed transformers frequently have thermostats with two 

settings, one for alarm purposes and the other for tripping. 

Dry-type transformers use heat sensors embedded in the hottest part of the windings 

insulation for alarm and tripping. 

Internal faults 

The protection of transformers by transformer-mounted devices, against the effects 

of internal faults, is provided on transformers which are fitted with airbreathing 

conservator tanks by the classical Buchholz mechanical relay (see Fig. B15). These 

relays can detect a slow accumulation of gases which results from the arcing of 

incipient faults in the winding insulation or from the ingress of air due to an oil leak. 

This first level of detection generally gives an alarm, but if the condition deteriorates 

further, a second level of detection will trip the upstream circuit-breaker. 

An oil-surge detection feature of the Buchholz relay will trip the upstream circuitbreaker 

“instantaneously” if a surge of oil occurs in the pipe connecting the main tank 

with the conservator tank. 

Such a surge can only occur due to the displacement of oil caused by a rapidly 

formed bubble of gas, generated by an arc of short-circuit current in the oil. 

By specially designing the cooling-oil radiator elements to perform a concerting action, 

“totally filled” types of transformer as large as 10 MVA are now currently available. 

Expansion of the oil is accommodated without an excessive rise in pressure by the 

“bellows” effect of the radiator elements. A full description of these transformers is 

given in Sub-clause 4.4 (see Fig. B16). 

Evidently the Buchholz devices mentioned above cannot be applied to this design; a 

modern counterpart has been developed however, which measures: 

b The accumulation of gas 

b Overpressure 

b Overtemperature 

The first two conditions trip the upstream circuit-breaker, and the third condition trips 

the downstream circuit-breaker of the transformer. 

Internal phase-to-phase short-circuit 

Internal phase-to-phase short-circuit must be detected and cleared by: 

b 3 fuses on the primary side of the tranformer or 

b An overcurrent relay that trips a circuit-breaker upstream of the transformer 

Internal phase-to-earth short-circuit 

This is the most common type of internal fault. It must be detected by an earth fault 

relay. Earth fault current can be calculated with the sum of the 3 primary phase 

currents (if 3 current transformers are used) or by a specific core current transformer. 

If a great sensitivity is needed, specific core current transformer will be prefered. In 

such a case, a two current transformers set is sufficient (see Fig. B17). 

Protection of circuits 

The protection of the circuits downstream of the transformer must comply with the 

IEC 60364 requirements. 

Discrimination between the protective devices upstream and 

downstream of the transformer 

The consumer-type substation with LV metering requires discriminative operation 

between the MV fuses or MV circuit-breaker and the LV circuit-breaker or fuses. 

The rating of the MV fuses will be chosen according to the characteristics of the 

transformer. 

The tripping characteristics of the LV circuit-breaker must be such that, for an 

overload or short-circuit condition downstream of its location, the breaker will trip 

sufficiently quickly to ensure that the MV fuses or the MV circuit-breaker will not be 

adversely affected by the passage of overcurrent through them. 

The tripping performance curves for MV fuses or MV circuit-breaker and LV circuitbreakers 

are given by graphs of time-to-operate against current passing through 

them. Both curves have the general inverse-time/current form (with an abrupt 

discontinuity in the CB curve at the current value above which “instantaneous” 

tripping occurs). 

These curves are shown typically in Figure B18. 




Time 

D 

C 

A 

B 

Minimum pre-arcing 

time of MV fuse 

B/A u 1.35 at any 

moment in time 

D/C u 2 at any 

current value 

Circuit breaker 

tripping 

characteristic 

Current 

Fig. B18 : Discrimination between MV fuse operation and LV 

circuit-breaker tripping, for transformer protection 

U 1 MV LV U 2 

Fig. B19 : MV fuse and LV circuit-breaker configuration 


b In order to achieve discrimination: 

All parts of the fuse or MV circuit-breaker curve must be above and to the right of the 

CB curve. 

b In order to leave the fuses unaffected (i.e. undamaged): 

All parts of the minimum pre-arcing fuse curve must be located to the right of the CB 

curve by a factor of 1.35 or more (e.g. where, at time T, the CB curve passes through 

a point corresponding to 100 A, the fuse curve at the same time T must pass through 

a point corresponding to 135 A, or more, and so on...) and, all parts of the fuse curve 

must be above the CB curve by a factor of 2 or more (e.g. where, at a current level I 

the CB curve passes through a point corresponding to 1.5 seconds, the fuse curve 

at the same current level I must pass through a point corresponding to 3 seconds, or 

more, etc.). 

The factors 1.35 and 2 are based on standard maximum manufacturing tolerances 

for MV fuses and LV circuit-breakers. 

In order to compare the two curves, the MV currents must be converted to the 

equivalent LV currents, or vice-versa. 

Where a LV fuse-switch is used, similar separation of the characteristic curves of the 

MV and LV fuses must be respected. 

b In order to leave the MV circuit-breaker protection untripped: 

All parts of the minimum pre-arcing fuse curve must be located to the right of the 

CB curve by a factor of 1.35 or more (e.g. where, at time T, the LV CB curve passes 

through a point corresponding to 100 A, the MV CB curve at the same time T must 

pass through a point corresponding to 135 A, or more, and so on...) and, all parts of 

the MV CB curve must be above the LV CB curve (time of LV CB curve must be less 

or equal than MV CB curves minus 0.3 s) 

The factors 1.35 and 0.3 s are based on standard maximum manufacturing 

tolerances for MV current transformers, MV protection relay and LV circuit-breakers. 

In order to compare the two curves, the MV currents must be converted to the 

equivalent LV currents, or vice-versa. 

Choice of protective device on the primary side of the 

transformer 

As explained before, for low reference current, the protection may be by fuses or by 

circuit-breaker. 

When the reference current is high, the protection will be achieved by circuit-breaker. 

Protection by circuit-breaker provides a more sensitive transformer protection 

compared with fuses. The implementation of additional protections (earth fault 

protection, thermal overload protection) is easier with circuit-breakers. 

3.3 Interlocks and conditioned operations 

Mechanical and electrical interlocks are included on mechanisms and in the control 

circuits of apparatus installed in substations, as a measure of protection against an 

incorrect sequence of manœuvres by operating personnel. 

Mechanical protection between functions located on separate equipment 

(e.g. switchboard and transformer) is provided by key-transfer interlocking. 

An interlocking scheme is intended to prevent any abnormal operational manœuvre. 

Some of such operations would expose operating personnel to danger, some others 

would only lead to an electrical incident. 

Basic interlocking 

Basic interlocking functions can be introduced in one given functionnal unit; some 

of these functions are made mandatory by the IEC 62271-200, for metal-enclosed 

MV switchgear, but some others are the result of a choice from the user. 

Considering access to a MV panel, it requires a certain number of operations 

which shall be carried out in a pre-determined order. It is necessary to carry out 

operations in the reverse order to restore the system to its former condition. Either 

proper procedures, or dedicated interlocks, can ensure that the required operations 

are performed in the right sequence. Then such accessible compartment will be 

classified as “accessible and interlocked” or “accessible by procedure”. Even for 

users with proper rigorous procedures, use of interlocks can provide a further help 

for safety of the operators. 


B19 


B20 




(1) If the earthing switch is on an incoming circuit, the 

associated isolating switches are those at both ends of the 

circuit, and these should be suitably interlocked. In such 

situation, the interlocking function becomes a multi-units key 

interlock. 


Key interlocking 

Beyond the interlocks available within a given functionnal unit (see also 4.2), the 

most widely-used form of locking/interlocking depends on the principle of key transfer. 

The principle is based on the possibility of freeing or trapping one or several keys, 

according to whether or not the required conditions are satisfied. 

These conditions can be combined in unique and obligatory sequences, thereby 

guaranteeing the safety of personnel and installation by the avoidance of an incorrect 

operational procedure. 

Non-observance of the correct sequence of operations in either case may have 

extremely serious consequences for the operating personnel, as well as for the 

equipment concerned. 

Note: It is important to provide for a scheme of interlocking in the basic design stage 

of planning a MV/LV substation. In this way, the apparatuses concerned will be 

equipped during manufacture in a coherent manner, with assured compatibility of 

keys and locking devices. 

Service continuity 

For a given MV switchboard, the definition of the accessible compartments as well 

as their access conditions provide the basis of the “Loss of Service Continuity” 

classification defined in the standard IEC 62271-200. Use of interlocks or only proper 

procedure does not have any influence on the service continuity. Only the request for 

accessing a given part of the switchboard, under normal operation conditions, results 

in limiting conditions which can be more or less severe regarding the continuity of the 

electrical distribution process. 

Interlocks in substations 

In a MV/LV distribution substation which includes: 

b A single incoming MV panel or two incoming panels (from parallel feeders) or two 

incoming/outgoing ring-main panels 

b A transformer switchgear-and-protection panel, which can include a load-break/ 

disconnecting switch with MV fuses and an earthing switch, or a circuit-breaker and 

line disconnecting switch together with an earthing switch 

b A transformer compartment 

Interlocks allow manœuvres and access to different panels in the following conditions: 

Basic interlocks, embedded in single functionnal units 

b Operation of the load-break/isolating switch 

v If the panel door is closed and the associated earthing switch is open 

b Operation of the line-disconnecting switch of the transformer switchgear - and 

- protection panel 

v If the door of the panel is closed, and 

v If the circuit-breaker is open, and the earthing switch(es) is (are) open 

b Closure of an earthing switch 

v If the associated isolating switch(es) is (are) open (1) 

b Access to an accessible compartment of each panel, if interlocks have been 

specified 

v If the isolating switch for the compartment is open and the earthing switch(es) for 

the compartment is (are) closed 

b Closure of the door of each accessible compartment, if interlocks have been 

specified 

v If the earthing switch(es) for the compartment is (are) closed 

Functional interlocks involving several functional units or separate equipment 

b Access to the terminals of a MV/LV transformer 

v If the tee-off functional unit has its switch open and its earthing switch closed. 

According to the possibility of back-feed from the LV side, a condition on the LV main 

breaker can be necessary. 

Practical example 

In a consumer-type substation with LV metering, the interlocking scheme most 

commonly used is MV/LV/TR (high voltage/ low voltage/transformer). 

The aim of the interlocking is: 

b To prevent access to the transformer compartment if the earthing switch has not 

been previously closed 

b To prevent the closure of the earthing switch in a transformer switchgear-andprotection 

panel, if the LV circuit-breaker of the transformer has not been previously 

locked “open” or “withdrawn” 




S 

MV switch and LV CB closed 

O 

S 

MV fuses accessible 

S 

Fig. B20 : Example of MV/LV/TR interlocking 

O 

O 

Transformer MV terminals accessible 

Legend 

Key absent 

Key free 

Key trapped 

Panel or door 

(1) Or may be provided with a common protective cover over 

the three terminals. 

S 

S 

S 

O 


Access to the MV or LV terminals of a transformer, (protected upstream by a 

MV switchgear-and-protection panel, containing a MV load-break / isolating 

switch, MV fuses, and a MV earthing switch) must comply with the strict procedure 

described below, and is illustrated by the diagrams of Figure B20. 

Note: The transformer in this example is provided with plug-in type MV terminal 

connectors which can only be removed by unlocking a retaining device common to 

all three phase connectors (1) . 

The MV load-break / disconnecting switch is mechanically linked with the 

MV earthing switch such that only one of the switches can be closed, i.e. closure 

of one switch automatically locks the closure of the other. 

Procedure for the isolation and earthing of the power transformer, and removal 

of the MV plug-type shrouded terminal connections (or protective cover) 

Initial conditions 

b MV load-break/disconnection switch and LV circuit-breaker are closed 

b MV earthing switch locked in the open position by key “O” 

b Key “O” is trapped in the LV circuit-breaker as long as that circuit-breaker is closed 

Step 1 

b Open LV CB and lock it open with key “O” 

b Key “O” is then released 

Step 2 

b Open the MV switch 

b Check that the “voltage presence” indicators extinguish when the MV switch is 

opened 

Step 3 

b Unlock the MV earthing switch with key “O” and close the earthing switch 

b Key “O” is now trapped 

Step 4 

The access panel to the MV fuses can now be removed (i.e. is released by closure of 

the MV earthing switch). Key “S” is located in this panel, and is trapped when the MV 

switch is closed 

b Turn key “S” to lock the MV switch in the open position 

b Key “S” is now released 

Step 5 

Key “S” allows removal of the common locking device of the plug-type MV terminal 

connectors on the transformer or of the common protective cover over the terminals, 

as the case may be. 

In either case, exposure of one or more terminals will trap key “S” in the interlock. 

The result of the foregoing procedure is that: 

b The MV switch is locked in the open position by key “S”. 

Key “S” is trapped at the transformer terminals interlock as long as the terminals are 

exposed. 

b The MV earthing switch is in the closed position but not locked, i.e. may be opened 

or closed. When carrying out maintenance work, a padlock is generally used to lock 

the earthing switch in the closed position, the key of the padlock being held by the 

engineer supervizing the work. 

b The LV CB is locked open by key “O”, which is trapped by the closed MV earthing 

switch. The transformer is therefore safely isolated and earthed. 

It may be noted that the upstream terminal of the load-break disconnecting switch 

may remain live in the procedure described as the terminals in question are located 

in a separate non accessible compartment in the particular switchgear under 

discussion. Any other technical solution with exposed terminals in the accessed 

compartment would need further de-energisation and interlocks. 


B21 


B22 




(1) Polychlorinated biphenyl 

4 The consumer substation 

with LV metering 

4.1 General 

A consumer substation with LV metering is an electrical installation connected to a 

utility supply system at a nominal voltage of 1 kV - 35 kV, and includes a single 

MV/LV transformer generally not exceeding 1,250 kVA. 

Functions 

The substation 

All component parts of the substation are located in one room, either in an existing 

building, or in the form of a prefabricated housing exterior to the building. 

Connection to the MV network 

Connection at MV can be: 

b Either by a single service cable or overhead line, or 

b Via two mechanically interlocked load-break switches with two service cables from 

duplicate supply feeders, or 

b Via two load-break switches of a ring-main unit 

The transformer 

Since the use of PCB (1) -filled transformers is prohibited in most countries, 

the preferred available technologies are: 

b Oil-immersed transformers for substations located outside premises 

b Dry-type, vacuum-cast-resin transformers for locations inside premises, e.g. 

multistoreyed buildings, buildings receiving the public, and so on... 

Metering 

Metering at low voltage allows the use of small metering transformers at modest cost. 

Most tariff structures take account of MV/LV transformer losses. 

LV installation circuits 

A low-voltage circuit-breaker, suitable for isolation duty and locking off facilities, to: 

b Supply a distribution board 

b Protect the transformer against overloading and the downstream circuits against 

short-circuit faults. 

One-line diagrams 

The diagrams on the following page (see Fig. B21) represent the different methods 

of MV service connection, which may be one of four types: 

b Single-line service 

b Single-line service (equipped for extension to form a ring main) 

b Duplicate supply service 

b Ring main service 

4.2 Choice of MV switchgear 

Standards and specifications 

The switchgear and equipment described below are rated for 1 kV - 24 kV systems 

and comply with the following international standards: 

IEC 62271-1, 62271-200, 60265-1, 62271-102, 62271-100, 62271-105 

Local regulations can also require compliance with national standards as: 

b France: UTE 

b United Kingdom: BS 

b Germany: VDE 

b United States of America: ANSI 

Type of equipment 

In addition of Ring Main Units discussed in section 1.2, all kinds of switchgear 

arrangements are possible when using modular switchgear, and provisions for later 

extensions are easily realized. 




Power supply 

system 

Service 

connection 

Supplier/consumer 

interface 



(equipped for extension 

to form a ring main) 

Duplicatesupply 

service 

Fig. B21 : Consumer substation with LV metering 



MV protection and 

MV/LV transformation 

Protection 

Permitted if only one 

transformer and rated power 

low enough to accomodate 

the limitations of fuses and 

combinations 

Protection 

Permitted if only one 

transformer and rated power 

low enough to accomodate 

the limitations of fuses and 

combinations 

Transformer 

LV terminals 

LV metering 

and isolation 


LV distribution 

and protection 

Downstream terminals 

of LV isolator 

Protection 

Protection 

+ 

Auto-changeover 

switch 

Ring main 

service 

Protection 

Automatic 

LV standby 

source 

Always permitted 

B23 


B24 




Fig. B22 : Metal enclosed MV load break disconnecting switch 

(1) Where MV fuses are used they are located in this 

compartment. 



Operational safety of metal enclosed switchgear 

Description 

The following notes describe a “state-of-the art” load-break / disconnecting-switch 

panel (see Fig. B22) incorporating the most modern developments for ensuring: 

b Operational safety 

b Minimum space requirements 

b Extendibility and flexibility 

b Minimum maintenance requirements 

Each panel includes 3 compartments: 

b Switchgear: the load-break disconnecting switch is incorporated in an hermetically 

sealed (for life) molded epoxy-resin unit 

b Connections: by cable at terminals located on the molded switch unit 

b Busbars: modular, such that any number of panels may be assembled side-by-side 

to form a continuous switchboard, and for control and indication a low voltage cabinet 

which can accommodate automatic control and relaying equipment. An additional 

cabinet may be mounted above the existing one if further space is required. 

Cable connections are provided inside a cable-terminating compartment at the 

front of the unit, to which access is gained by removal of the front panel of the 

compartment. 

The units are connected electrically by means of prefabricated sections of busbars. 

Site erection is effected by following the assembly instructions. 

Operation of the switchgear is simplified by the grouping of all controls and 

indications on a control panel at the front of each unit. 

The technology of these switchgear units is essentially based on operational safety, 

ease of installation and low maintenance requirements. 

Switchgear internal safety measures 

b The load-break/disconnecting switch fully satisfies the requirement of “reliable 

position indicating device” as defined in IEC 62271-102 (disconnectors and earthing 

switches) 

b The functionnal unit incorporates the basic interlocks specified by the 

IEC 62271-200 (prefabricated metal enclosed switchgear and controlgear): 

v Closure of the switch is not possible unless the earth switch is open 

v Closure of the earthing switch is only possible if the load break/isolating switch is 

open 

b Access to the cable compartment, which is the only user-accessible compartment 

during operation, is secured by further interlocks: 

v Opening of the access panel to the cable terminations compartment (1) is only 

possible if the earthing switch is closed 

v The load-break/disconnecting switch is locked in the open position when the 

above-mentioned access panel is open. Opening of the earthing switch is then 

possible, for instance to allow a dielectric test on the cables. 

With such features, the switchboard can be operated with live busbars and cables, 

except for the unit where the access to cables is made. It complies then with the 

Loss of Service Continuity class LSB2A, as defined in the IEC 62271-200. 

Apart from the interlocks noted above, each switchgear panel includes: 

b Built-in padlocking facilities on the operation levers 

b 5 predrilled sets of fixing holes for possible future interlocking locks 

Operations 

b Operating handles, levers, etc. required for switching operations are grouped 

together on a clearly illustrated panel 

b All closing-operation levers are identical on all units (except those containing a 

circuit-breaker) 

b Operation of a closing lever requires very little effort 

b Opening or closing of a load-break/disconnecting switch can be by lever or by 

push-button for automatic switches 

b Conditions of switches (Open, Closed, Spring-charged), are clearly indicated 






4.3 Choice of MV switchgear panel for a transformer 

circuit 

Three types of MV switchgear panel are generally available: 

b Load-break switch and separate MV fuses in the panel 

b Load-break switch/MV fuses combination 

b Circuit-breaker 

Seven parameters influence the optimum choice: 

b The primary current of the transformer 

b The insulating medium of the transformer 

b The position of the substation with respect to the load centre 

b The kVA rating of the transformer 

b The distance from switchgear to the transformer 

b The use of separate protection relays (as opposed to direct-acting trip coils). 

Note: The fuses used in the load-break/switch fuses combination have striker-pins 

which ensure tripping of the 3-pole switch on the operation of one (or more) fuse(s). 

4.4 Choice of MV/LV transformer 

Characteristic parameters of a transformer 

A transformer is characterized in part by its electrical parameters, but also by its 

technology and its conditions of use. 

Electrical characteristics 

b Rated power (Pn): the conventional apparent-power in kVA on which other designparameter 

values and the construction of the transformer are based. Manufacturing 

tests and guarantees are referred to this rating 

b Frequency: for power distribution systems of the kind discussed in this guide, the 

frequency will be 50 Hz or 60 Hz 

b Rated primary and secondary voltages: For a primary winding capable of operating at 

more than one voltage level, a kVA rating corresponding to each level must be given. 

The secondary rated voltage is its open circuit value 

b Rated insulation levels are given by overvoltage-withstand test values at power 

frequency, and by high voltage impulse tests values which simulate lightning 

discharges. At the voltage levels discussed in this guide, overvoltages caused by 

MV switching operations are generally less severe than those due to lightning, so 

that no separate tests for switching-surge withstand capability are made 

b Off-circuit tap-selector switch generally allows a choice of up to ± 2.5% and ± 5% 

level about the rated voltage of the highest voltage winding. The transformer must be 

de-energized before this switch is operated 

b Winding configurations are indicated in diagrammatic form by standard symbols for 

star, delta and inter-connected-star windings; (and combinations of these for special 

duty, e.g. six-or twelve-phase rectifier transformers, etc.) and in an IEC-recommended 

alphanumeric code. This code is read from left-to-right, the first letter refers to the 

highest voltage winding, the second letter to the next highest, and so on: 

v Capital letters refer to the highest voltage winding 

D = delta 

Y = star 

Z = interconnected-star (or zigzag) 

N = neutral connection brought out to a terminal 

v Lower-case letters are used for tertiary and secondary windings 

d = delta 

y = star 

z = interconnected-star (or zigzag) 

n = neutral connection brought out to a terminal 

v A number from 0 to 11, corresponding to those, on a clock dial (“0” is used instead 

of “12”) follows any pair of letters to indicate the phase change (if any) which occurs 

during the transformation. 

A very common winding configuration used for distribution transformers is that 

of a Dyn 11 transformer, which has a delta MV winding with a star-connected 

secondary winding the neutral point of which is brought out to a terminal. The phase 

change through the transformer is +30 degrees, i.e. phase 1 secondary voltage is 

at “11 o’clock” when phase 1 of the primary voltage is at “12 o’clock”, as shown in 

Figure B31 page B34. All combinations of delta, star and zigzag windings produce a 

phase change which (if not zero) is either 30 degrees or a multiple of 30 degrees. 

IEC 60076-4 describes the “clock code” in detail. 


B25 


B26 




Fig. B23 : Dry-type transformer 



Characteristics related to the technology and utilization of the transformer 

This list is not exhaustive: 

b Choice of technology 

The insulating medium is: 

v Liquid (mineral oil) or 

v Solid (epoxy resin and air) 

b For indoor or outdoor installation 

b Altitude (



Fig. B24 : Hermetically-sealed totally-filled tank 

Fig. B25 : Air-breathing conservator-type tank at atmosphere 

pressure 



There are two ways in which this pressure limitation is commonly achieved: 

b Hermetically-sealed totally-filled tank (up to 10 MVA at the present time) 

Developed by a leading French manufacturer in 1963, this method was adopted by the 

national utility in 1972, and is now in world-wide service (see Fig. B24). 

Expansion of the liquid is compensated by the elastic deformation of the oil-cooling 

passages attached to the tank. 

The “total-fill” technique has many important advantages over other methods: 

v Oxydation of the dielectric liquid (with atmospheric oxygen) is entirely precluded 

v No need for an air-drying device, and so no consequent maintenance (inspection 

and changing of saturated dessicant) 

v No need for dielectric-strength test of the liquid for at least 10 years 

v Simplified protection against internal faults by means of a DGPT device is possible 

v Simplicity of installation: lighter and lower profile (than tanks with a conservator) 

and access to the MV and LV terminals is unobstructed 

v Immediate detection of (even small) oil leaks; water cannot enter the tank 

b Air-breathing conservator-type tank at atmospheric pressure 

Expansion of the insulating liquid is taken up by a change in the level of liquid in 

an expansion (conservator) tank, mounted above the transformer main tank, as 

shown in Figure B25. The space above the liquid in the conservator may be filled 

with air which is drawn in when the level of liquid falls, and is partially expelled 

when the level rises. When the air is drawn in from the surrounding atmosphere it is 

admitted through an oil seal, before passing through a dessicating device (generally 

containing silica-gel crystals) before entering the conservator. In some designs of 

larger transformers the space above the oil is occupied by an impermeable air bag 

so that the insulation liquid is never in contact with the atmosphere. The air enters 

and exits from the deformable bag through an oil seal and dessicator, as previously 

described. A conservator expansion tank is obligatory for transformers rated above 

10 MVA (which is presently the upper limit for “total-fill” type transformers). 

Choice of technology 

As discussed above, the choice of transformer is between liquid-filled or dry type. 

For ratings up to 10 MVA, totally-filled units are available as an alternative to 

conservator-type transformers. 

A choice depends on a number of considerations, including: 

b Safety of persons in proximity to the transformer. Local regulations and official 

recommendations may have to be respected 

b Economic considerations, taking account of the relative advantages of each technique 

The regulations affecting the choice are: 

b Dry-type transformer: 

v In some countries a dry-type transformer is obligatory in high apartment blocks 

v Dry-type transformers impose no constraints in other situations 

b Transformers with liquid insulation: 

v This type of transformer is generally forbidden in high apartment blocks 

v For different kinds of insulation liquids, installation restrictions, or minimum 

protection against fire risk, vary according to the class of insulation used 

v Some countries in which the use of liquid dielectrics is highly developed, classify 

the several categories of liquid according to their fire performance. This latter is 

assessed according to two criteria: the flash-point temperature, and the minimum 

calorific power. The principal categories are shown in Figure B26 in which a 

classification code is used for convenience. 

As an example, French standard defines the conditions for the installation of liquidfilled 

transformers. No equivalent IEC standard has yet been established. 

The French standard is aimed at ensuring the safety of persons and property and 

recommends, notably, the minimum measures to be taken against the risk of fire. 

Code Dielectric fluid Flash-point Minimum calorific power 

(°C) (MJ/kg) 

O1 Mineral oil < 300 - 

K1 High-density hydrocarbons > 300 48 

K2 Esters > 300 34 - 37 

K3 Silicones > 300 27 - 28 

L3 Insulating halogen liquids - 12 

Fig. B26 : Categories of dielectric fluids 


B27 


B28 






The main precautions to observe are indicated in Figure B27. 

b For liquid dielectrics of class L3 there are no special measures to be taken 

b For dielectrics of classes O1 and K1 the measures indicated are applicable only if 

there are more than 25 litres of dielectric liquid in the transformer 

b For dielectrics of classes K2 and K3 the measures indicated are applicable only if 

there are more than 50 litres of dielectric liquid in the transformer. 

Class No. of Locations 

of litres above Chamber or enclosed area reserved to qualified Reserved to trained personnel Other chambers 

dielectric which and authorized personnel, and separated from any and isolated from work areas or locations (2) 

fluid measures other building by a distance D by fire-proof walls (2 hours rating) 

must be D > 8 m 4 m < D < 8 m D < 4 m (1) in the direc- No openings With opening(s) 

taken tion of occupied areas 

O1 25 No special Interposition of Fire-proof wall Measures Measures Measures 

measures a fire-proof (2 hour rating) (1 + 2) (1 + 2 + 5) (1A + 2 + 4) (3) 

K1 screen against adjoining or 3 or 3 or 3 

(1 hour rating) building or 4 or (4 + 5) 

K2 50 No special measures Interposition of a No special Measures 1A Measures 1 

K3 fire-proof screen measures or 3 or 3 

(1 hour rating) or 4 or 4 

L3 No special measures 

Measure 1: Arrangements such that if the dielectric escapes from the transformer, it will be completely contained (in a sump, by sills around the 

transformer, and by blocking of cable trenches, ducts and so on, during construction). 

Measure 1A: In addition to measure 1, arrange that, in the event of liquid ignition there is no possibility of the fire spreading (any combustible 

material must be moved to a distance of at least 4 metres from the transformer, or at least 2 metres from it if a fire-proof screen [of 1 hour rating] is 

interposed). 

Measure 2: Arrange that burning liquid will extinguish rapidly and naturally (by providing a pebble bed in the containment sump). 

Measure 3: An automatic device (gas, pressure & thermal relay, or Buchholz) for cutting off the primary power supply, and giving an alarm, if gas 

appears in the transformer tank. 

Measure 4: Automatic fire-detection devices in close proximity to the transformer, for cutting off primary power supply, and giving an alarm. 

Measure 5: Automatic closure by fire-proof panels (1/2 hour minimum rating) of all openings (ventilation louvres, etc.) in the walls and ceiling of 

the substation chamber. 

Notes: 

(1) A fire-proof door (rated at 2 hours) is not considered to be an opening. 

(2) Transformer chamber adjoining a workshop and separated from it by walls, the fire-proof characteristics of which are not rated for 2 hours. 

Areas situated in the middle of workshops the material being placed (or not) in a protective container. 

(3) It is indispensable that the equipment be enclosed in a chamber, the walls of which are solid, the only orifices being those necessary for 

ventilation purposes. 

Fig. B27 : Safety measures recommended in electrical installations using dielectric liquids of classes 01, K1, K2 or K3 

The determination of optimal power 

Oversizing a transformer 

It results in: 

b Excessive investment and unecessarily high no-load losses, but 

b Lower on-load losses 

Undersizing a transformer 

It causes: 

b A reduced efficiency when fully loaded, (the highest efficiency is attained in the 

range 50% - 70% full load) so that the optimum loading is not achieved 

b On long-term overload, serious consequences for 

v The transformer, owing to the premature ageing of the windings insulation, and in 

extreme cases, resulting in failure of insulation and loss of the transformer 

v The installation, if overheating of the transformer causes protective relays to trip 

the controlling circuit-breaker. 

Definition of optimal power 

In order to select an optimal power (kVA) rating for a transformer, the following 

factors must be taken into account: 

b List the power of installed power-consuming equipment as described in Chapter A 

b Decide the utilization (or demand) factor for each individual item of load 

b Determine the load cycle of the installation, noting the duration of loads and overloads 

b Arrange for power-factor correction, if justified, in order to: 

v Reduce cost penalties in tariffs based, in part, on maximum kVA demand 

v Reduce the value of declared load (P(kVA) = P (kW)/cos ϕ) 

b Select, among the range of standard transformer ratings available, taking into 

account all possible future extensions to the installation. 

It is important to ensure that cooling arrangements for the transformer are adequate. 




Fig. B28 : SM6 metal enclosed indoor MV eqpuipment 



4.5 Instructions for use of MV equipment 

The purpose of this chapter is to provide general guidelines on how to avoid 

or greatly reduce MV equipment degradation on sites exposed to humidity and 

pollution. 

Normal service conditions for indoor MV equipment 

All MV equipments comply with specific standards and with the IEC 62271-1 

standard “Common specifications for high-voltage switchgear and controlgear”, 

which defines the normal conditions for the installation and use of such equipment. 

For instance, regarding humidity, the standard mentions: 

The conditions of humidity are as follows: 

b The average value of the relative humidity, measured over a period of 24 h does 

not exceed 90%; 

b The average value of the water vapour pressure, over a period of 24 h does not 

exceed 2.2 kPa; 

b The average value of the relative humidity, over a period of one month does not 

exceed 90%; 

b The average value of water vapour pressure, over a period of one month does not 

exceed 1.8 kPa; 

Under these conditions, condensation may occasionally occur. 

NOTE 1: Condensation can be expected where sudden temperature changes occur 

in period of high humidity. 

NOTE 2: To withstand the effects of high humidity and condensation, such as a 

breakdown of insulation or corrosion of metallic parts, switchgear designed for such 

conditions and tested accordingly shoul be used. 

NOTE 3: Condensation may be prevented by special design of the building or 

housing, by suitable ventilation and heating of the station or by use of dehumifying 

equipment. 

As indicated in the standard, condensation may occasionally occur even under 

normal conditions. The standard goes on to indicate special measures concerning 

the substation premises that can be implemented to prevent condensation. 

Use under severe conditions 

Under certain severe conditions concerning humidity and pollution, largely beyond 

the normal conditions of use mentioned above, correctly designed electrical 

equipment can be subject to damage by rapid corrosion of metal parts and surface 

degradation of insulating parts. 

Remedial measures for condensation problems 

b Carefully design or adapt substation ventilation. 

b Avoid temperature variations. 

b Eliminate sources of humidity in the substation environment. 

b Install an air conditioning system. 

b Make sure cabling is in accordance with applicable rules. 

Remedial measures for pollution problems 

b Equip substation ventilation openings with chevron-type baffles to reduce entry 

of dust and pollution. 

b Keep substation ventilation to the minimum required for evacuation of transformer 

heat to reduce entry of pollution and dust. 

b Use MV cubicles with a sufficiently high degree of protection (IP). 

b Use air conditioning systems with filters to restrict entry of pollution and dust. 

b Regularly clean all traces of pollution from metal and insulating parts. 

Ventilation 

Substation ventilation is generally required to dissipate the heat produced by 

transformers and to allow drying after particularly wet or humid periods. 

However, a number of studies have shown that excessive ventilation can drastically 

increase condensation. 

Ventilation should therefore be kept to the minimum level required. 

Furthermore, ventilation should never generate sudden temperature variations that 

can cause the dew point to be reached. 

For this reason: 

Natural ventilation should be used whenever possible. If forced ventilation is 

necessary, the fans should operate continuously to avoid temperature fluctuations. 

Guidelines for sizing the air entry and exit openings of substations are presented 

hereafter. 


B29 


B30 




Fig. B29 : Natural ventilation 

200 mm 

mini 

Fig. B30 : Ventilation opening locations 

S 

S' 

H 



Calculation methods 

A number of calculation methods are available to estimate the required size of 

substation ventilation openings, either for the design of new substations or the 

adaptation of existing substations for which condensation problems have occurred. 

The basic method is based on transformer dissipation. 

The required ventilation opening surface areas S and S’ can be estimated using the 

following formulas: 

S � 1.8 x 10-4 P 

H 

and S'� 1.10 x S 

where: 

S = Lower (air entry) ventilation opening area [m²] (grid surface deducted) 

S’= Upper (air exit) ventilation opening area [m²] (grid surface deducted) 

P = Total dissipated power [W] 

P is the sum of the power dissipated by: 

b The transformer (dissipation at no load and due to load) 

b The LV switchgear 

b The MV switchgear 

H = Height between ventilation opening mid-points [m] 

See Fig. B29 

Note: 

This formula is valid for a yearly average temperature of 20 °C and a maximum 

altitude of 1,000 m. 

It must be noted that these formulae are able to determine only one order of 

magnitude of the sections S and S', which are qualified as thermal section, i.e. fully 

open and just necessary to evacuate the thermal energy generated inside the MV/LV 

substation. 

The pratical sections are of course larger according ot the adopted technological 

solution. 

Indeed, the real air flow is strongly dependant: 

b on the openings shape and solutions adopted to ensure the cubicle protection 

index (IP): metal grid, stamped holes, chevron louvers,... 

b on internal components size and their position compared to the openings: 

transformer and/or retention oil box position and dimensions, flow channel between 

the components, ... 

b and on some physical and environmental parameters: outside ambient 

temperature, altitude, magnitude of the resulting temperature rise. 

The understanding and the optimization of the attached physical phenomena are 

subject to precise flow studies, based on the fluid dynamics laws, and realized with 

specific analytic software. 

Example: 

Transformer dissipation = 7,970 W 

LV switchgear dissipation = 750 W 

MV switchgear dissipation = 300 W 

The height between ventilation opening mid-points is 1.5 m. 

Calculation: 

Dissipated Power P = 7,970 + 750 + 300 = 9,020 W 

S � 1.8 x 10-4 P 

1.5 


� 1.32 m 2 and S'� 1.1 x 1.32 � 1.46 m 2 

Ventilation opening locations 

To favour evacuation of the heat produced by the transformer via natural convection, 

ventilation openings should be located at the top and bottom of the wall near the 

transformer. The heat dissipated by the MV switchboard is negligible. 

To avoid condensation problems, the substation ventilation openings should be 

located as far as possible from the switchboard (see Fig. B 30).



Fig. B31 : Chevron-blade baffles 



Type of ventilation openings 

To reduce the entry of dust, pollution, mist, etc., the substation ventilation openings 

should be equipped with chevron-blade baffles. 

Always make sure the baffles are oriented in the right direction (see Fig. B31). 

Temperature variations inside cubicles 

To reduce temperature variations, always install anti-condensation heaters inside 

MV cubicles if the average relative humidity can remain high over a long period of 

time. The heaters must operate continuously, 24 hours a day all year long. 

Never connect them to a temperature control or regulation system as this could lead 

to temperature variations and condensation as well as a shorter service life for the 

heating elements. Make sure the heaters offer an adequate service life (standard 

versions are generally sufficient). 

Temperature variations inside the substation 

The following measures can be taken to reduce temperature variations inside the 

substation: 

b Improve the thermal insulation of the substation to reduce the effects of outdoor 

temperature variations on the temperature inside the substation. 

b Avoid substation heating if possible. If heating is required, make sure the regulation 

system and/or thermostat are sufficiently accurate and designed to avoid excessive 

temperature swings (e.g. no greater than 1 °C). 

If a sufficiently accurate temperature regulation system is not available, leave the 

heating on continuously, 24 hours a day all year long. 

b Eliminate cold air drafts from cable trenches under cubicles or from openings in the 

substation (under doors, roof joints, etc.). 

Substation environment and humidity 

Various factors outside the substation can affect the humidity inside. 

b Plants 

Avoid excessive plant growth around the substation. 

b Substation waterproofing 

The substation roof must not leak. Avoid flat roofs for which 

waterproofing is difficult to implement and maintain. 

b Humidity from cable trenches 

Make sure cable trenches are dry under all conditions. 

A partial solution is to add sand to the bottom of the cable trench. 

Pollution protection and cleaning 

Excessive pollution favours leakage current, tracking and flashover on insulators. 

To prevent MV equipment degradation by pollution, it is possible to either protect the 

equipment against pollution or regularly clean the resulting contamination. 

Protection 

Indoor MV switchgear can be protected by enclosures providing a sufficiently high 

degree of protection (IP). 

Cleaning 

If not fully protected, MV equipment must be cleaned regularly to prevent 

degradation by contamination from pollution. 

Cleaning is a critical process. The use of unsuitable products can irreversibly 

damage the equipment. 

For cleaning procedures, please contact your Schneider Electric correspondent. 


B31 


B32 




A consumer substation with MV metering 

is an electrical installation connected to a 

utility supply system at a nominal voltage of 

1 kV - 35 kV and generally includes a single 

MV/LV transformer which exceeds 1,250 kVA, 

or several smaller transformers. 

The rated current of the MV switchgear does 

not normally exceed 400 A. 


with MV metering 


Functions 

The substation 

According to the complexity of the installation and the manner in which the load is 

divided, the substation: 

b Might include one room containing the MV switchboard and metering panel(s), 

together with the transformer(s) and low-voltage main distribution board(s), 

b Or might supply one or more transformer rooms, which include local LV distribution 

boards, supplied at MV from switchgear in a main substation, similar to that 

described above. 

These substations may be installed, either: 

b Inside a building, or 

b Outdoors in prefabricated housings. 

Connection to the MV network 

Connection at MV can be: 

b Either by a single service cable or overhead line, or 

b Via two mechanically interlocked load-break switches with two service cables from 

duplicate supply feeders, or 

b Via two load-break switches of a ring-main unit. 

Metering 

Before the installation project begins, the agreement of the power-supply utility 

regarding metering arrangements must be obtained. 

A metering panel will be incorporated in the MV switchboard. Voltage transformers 

and current transformers, having the necessary metering accuracy, may be included 

in the main incoming circuit-breaker panel or (in the case of the voltage transformer) 

may be installed separately in the metering panel. 

Transformer rooms 

If the installation includes a number of transformer rooms, MV supplies from the main 

substation may be by simple radial feeders connected directly to the transformers, or 

by duplicate feeders to each room, or again, by a ring-main, according to the degree 

of supply availability desired. 

In the two latter cases, 3-panel ring-main units will be required at each transformer 

room. 

Local emergency generators 

Emergency standby generators are intended to maintain a power supply to essential 

loads, in the event of failure of the power supply system. 

Capacitors 

Capacitors will be installed, according to requirements: 

b In stepped MV banks at the main substation, or 

b At LV in transformer rooms. 

Transformers 

For additional supply-security reasons, transformers may be arranged for automatic 

changeover operation, or for parallel operation. 

One-line diagrams 

The diagrams shown in Figure B32 next page represent: 

b The different methods of MV service connection, which may be one of four types: 

v Single-line service 

v Single-line service (equipped for extension to form a ring main) 

v Duplicate supply service 

v Ring main service 

b General protection at MV, and MV metering functions 

b Protection of outgoing MV circuits 

b Protection of LV distribution circuits 




Power supply 

system 

Service connection MV protection 

and metering 

Supplier/consumer 

interface 



(equipped for 

extension to form 

a ring main) 

Duplicatesupply 

service 

Ring-main 

service 

Fig. B32 : Consumer substation with MV metering 



MV distribution and protection 

of outgoing circuits 

Downstream terminals of 

MV isolator for the installation 

A single transformer 

Protection 


LV distribution 


LV terminals of 

transformer 

Protection 

LV 

Automatic LV/MV 

standby source 

Protection 

+ automatic 

changeover 

feature 

Automatic LV 

standby source 

B33 


B34 




MV distribution 

panels for 

which standby 

supply is 

required 

Automatic 

changeover 

panel 

Busbar 

transition 

panel 

From standby generator 

P y 20,000 kVA 

To remainder 

of the MV 

switchboard 

Fig. B33 : Section of MV switchboard including standby supply 

panel 



5.2 Choice of panels 

A substation with MV metering includes, in addition to the panels described in 4.2, 

panels specifically designed for metering and, if required, for automatic or manual 

changeover from one source to another. 

Metering and general protection 

These two functions are achieved by the association of two panels: 

b One panel containing the VT 

b The main MV circuit-breaker panel containing the CTs for measurement and 

protection 

The general protection is usually against overcurrent (overload and short-circuit) and 

earth faults. Both schemes use protective relays which are sealed by the powersupply 

utility. 

Substation including generators 

Generator in stand alone operation 

If the installation needs great power supply availability, a MV standby generator set 

can be used. In such a case, the installation must include an automatic changeover. 

In order to avoid any posssibility of parallel operation of the generator with the power 

supply network, a specific panel with automatic changeover is needed (see Fig. B33). 

b Protection 

Specific protective devices are intended to protect the generator itself. It must be 

noted that, due to the very low short-circuit power of the generator comparing with 

the power supply network, a great attention must be paid to protection discrimination. 

b Control 

A voltage regulator controlling an alternator is generally arranged to respond to a 

reduction of voltage at its terminals by automatically increasing the excitation current 

of the alternator, until the voltage is restored to normal. When it is intended that 

the alternator should operate in parallel with others, the AVR (Automatic Voltage 

Regulator) is switched to “parallel operation” in which the AVR control circuit is 

slightly modified (compounded) to ensure satisfactory sharing of kvars with the other 

parallel machines. 

When a number of alternators are operating in parallel under AVR control, an 

increase in the excitation current of one of them (for example, carried out manually 

after switching its AVR to Manual control) will have practically no effect on the voltage 

level. In fact, the alternator in question will simply operate at a lower power factor 

(more kVA, and therefore more current) than before. 

The power factor of all the other machines will automatically improve, such that the 

load power factor requirements are satisfied, as before. 

Generator operating in parallel with the utility supply network 

To connect a generator set on the network, the agreement of the power supply utility 

is usually required. Generally the equipement (panels, protection relays) must be 

approved by the utility. 

The following notes indicate some basic consideration to be taken into account for 

protection and control. 

b Protection 

To study the connection of generator set, the power supply utility needs some data 

as follows : 

v Power injected on the network 

v Connection mode 

v Short-circuit current of the generator set 

v Voltage unbalance of the generator 

v etc. 

Depending on the connection mode, dedicated uncoupling protection functions are 

required : 

v Under-voltage and over-voltage protection 

v Under-frequency and over-frequency protection 

v Zero sequence overvoltage protection 

v Maximum time of coupling (for momentary coupling) 

v Reverse real power 

For safety reasons, the switchgear used for uncoupling must also be provided 

with the characteristics of a disconnector (i.e total isolation of all active conductors 

between the generator set and the power supply network). 






b Control 

When generators at a consumer’s substation operate in parallel with all the 

generation of the utility power supply system, supposing the power system voltage is 

reduced for operational reasons (it is common to operate MV systems within a range 

of ± 5% of nominal voltage, or even more, where load-flow patterns require it), an 

AVR set to maintain the voltage within ± 3% (for example) will immediately attempt to 

raise the voltage by increasing the excitation current of the alternator. 

Instead of raising the voltage, the alternator will simply operate at a lower power 

factor than before, thereby increasing its current output, and will continue to do so, 

until it is eventually tripped out by its overcurrent protective relays. This is a wellknown 

problem and is usually overcome by the provision of a “constant power- 

factor” control switch on the AVR unit. 

By making this selection, the AVR will automatically adjust the excitation current 

to match whatever voltage exists on the power system, while at the same time 

maintaining the power factor of the alternator constant at the pre-set value (selected 

on the AVR control unit). 

In the event that the alternator becomes decoupled from the power system, the AVR 

must be automatically (rapidly) switched back to “constant-voltage” control. 

5.3 Parallel operation of transformers 

The need for operation of two or more transformers in parallel often arises due to: 

b Load growth, which exceeds the capactiy of an existing transformer 

b Lack of space (height) for one large transformer 

b A measure of security (the probability of two transformers failing at the same time 

is very small) 

b The adoption of a standard size of transformer throughout an installation 

Total power (kVA) 

The total power (kVA) available when two or more transformers of the same 

kVA rating are connected in parallel, is equal to the sum of the individual ratings, 

providing that the percentage impedances are all equal and the voltage ratios are 

identical. 

Transformers of unequal kVA ratings will share a load practically (but not exactly) 

in proportion to their ratings, providing that the voltage ratios are identical and the 

percentage impedances (at their own kVA rating) are identical, or very nearly so. 

In these cases, a total of more than 90% of the sum of the two ratings is normally 

available. 

It is recommended that transformers, the kVA ratings of which differ by more 

than 2:1, should not be operated permanently in parallel. 

Conditions necessary for parallel operation 

All paralleled units must be supplied from the same network. 

The inevitable circulating currents exchanged between the secondary circuits of 

paralleled transformers will be negligibly small providing that: 

b Secondary cabling from the transformers to the point of paralleling have 

approximately equal lengths and characteristics 

b The transformer manufacturer is fully informed of the duty intended for the 

transformers, so that: 

v The winding configurations (star, delta, zigzag star) of the several transformers 

have the same phase change between primary and secondary voltages 

v The short-circuit impedances are equal, or differ by less than 10% 

v Voltage differences between corresponding phases must not exceed 0.4% 

v All possible information on the conditions of use, expected load cycles, etc. should 

be given to the manufacturer with a view to optimizing load and no-load losses 


B35 


B36 






Common winding arrangements 

As described in 4.4 “Electrical characteristics-winding configurations” the 

relationships between primary, secondary, and tertiary windings depend on: 

b Type of windings (delta, star, zigzag) 

b Connection of the phase windings 

Depending on which ends of the windings form the star point (for example), a 

star winding will produce voltages which are 180° displaced with respect to those 

produced if the opposite ends had been joined to form the star point. Similar 180° 

changes occur in the two possible ways of connecting phase-to-phase coils to form 

delta windings, while four different combinations of zigzag connections are possible. 

b The phase displacement of the secondary phase voltages with respect to the 

corresponding primary phase voltages. 

As previously noted, this displacement (if not zero) will always be a multiple of 

30° and will depend on the two factors mentioned above, viz type of windings and 

connection (i.e. polarity) of the phase windings. 

By far the most common type of distribution transformer winding configuration is the 

Dyn 11 connection (see Fig. B34). 

Voltage vectors 

1 

Fig. B34 : Phase change through a Dyn 11 transformer 


3 

1 

2 

3 

V 12 

Windings 

correspondence 

V 12 on the primary winding produces V 1N in the 

secondary winding and so on ... 

2 

1 

3 

N 

N 

2 

1 

2 

3



6 Constitution of 

MV/LV distribution substations 

MV/LV substations are constructed according to the magnitude of the load and the 

kind of power system in question. 

Substations may be built in public places, such as parks, residential districts, etc. or 

on private premises, in which case the power supply authority must have unrestricted 

access. This is normally assured by locating the substation, such that one of its 

walls, which includes an access door, coincides with the boundary of the consumers 

premises and the public way. 

6.1 Different types of substation 

Substations may be classified according to metering arrangements (MV or LV) and 

type of supply (overhead line or underground cable). 

The substations may be installed: 

b Either indoors in room specially built for the purpose, within a building, or 

b An outdoor installation which could be : 

v Installed in a dedicated enclosure prefabricated or not, with indoor equipment 

(switchgear and transformer) 

v Ground mounted with outdoor equipment (switchgear and transformers) 

v Pole mounted with dedicated outdoor equipment (swithgear and transformers) 

Prefabricated substations provide a particularly simple, rapid and competitive choice. 

6.2 Indoor substation 

Conception 

Figure B35 shows a typical equipment layout recommended for a LV metering 

substation. 

Remark: the use of a cast-resin dry-type transformer does not need a fireprotection 

oil sump. However, periodic cleaning is needed. 

MV connections to transformer 

(included in a panel or free-standing) 

2 incoming 

MV panels 

MV 

switching 

and 

protection 

panel 

Connection to the powersupply 

network by single-core 

or three-core cables, 

with or without a cable trench 

Fig. B35 : Typical arrangment of switchgear panels for LV metering 


LV connections 

from 

transformer 

LV switchgear 

Current 

transformers 

provided by 

power-supply 

authority 

Transformer Oil sump LV cable 

trench 

B37 


B38 






Service connections and equipment interconnections 

At high voltage 

b Connections to the MV system are made by, and are the responsibility of the utility 

b Connections between the MV switchgear and the transformers may be: 

v By short copper bars where the transformer is housed in a panel forming part of 

the MV switchboard 

v By single-core screened cables with synthetic insulation, with possible use of plugin 

type terminals at the transformer 

At low voltage 

b Connections between the LV terminals of the transformer and the LV switchgear 

may be: 

v Single-core cables 

v Solid copper bars (circular or rectangular section) with heat-shrinkable insulation 

Metering (see Fig. B36) 

b Metering current transformers are generally installed in the protective cover of the 

power transformer LV terminals, the cover being sealed by the supply utility 

b Alternatively, the current transformers are installed in a sealed compartment within 

the main LV distribution cabinet 

b The meters are mounted on a panel which is completely free from vibrations 

b Placed as close to the current transformers as possible, and 

b Are accessible only to the utility 

100 

MV supply LV distribution 

Fig. B36 : Plan view of typical substation with LV metering 

Earthing circuits 

Common earth busbar 

for the substation 

The substation must include: 


Safety accessories 

800 mini 

Meters 

b An earth electrode for all exposed conductive parts of electrical equipment in the 

substation and exposed extraneous metal including: 

v Protective metal screens 

v Reinforcing rods in the concrete base of the substation 

Substation lighting 

Supply to the lighting circuits can be taken from a point upstream or downstream 

of the main incoming LV circuit-breaker. In either case, appropriate overcurrent 

protection must be provided. A separate automatic circuit (or circuits) is (are) 

recommended for emergency lighting purposes. 

Operating switches, pushbuttons, etc. are normally located immediately adjacent to 

entrances. 

Lighting fittings are arranged such that: 

b Switchgear operating handles and position indication markings are adequately 

illuminated 

b All metering dials and instruction plaques and so on, can be easily read



Walk-in Non walk-in Half buried 

a - b - 

Underground 

Fig. B38 : The four designs according to IEC 62271-202 

standard and two pictures [a] walk-in type MV/LV substation; 

[b] half buried type MV/LV substation 



Materials for operation and safety 

According to local safety rules, generally, the substation is provided with: 

b Materials for assuring safe exploitation of the equipment including: 

v Insulating stool and/or an insulating mat (rubber or synthetic) 

v A pair of insulated gloves stored in an envelope provided for the purpose 

v A voltage-detecting device for use on the MV equipment 

v Earthing attachments (according to type of switchgear) 

b Fire-extinguishing devices of the powder or CO2 type 

b Warning signs, notices and safety alarms: 

v On the external face of all access doors, a DANGER warning plaque and 

prohibition of entry notice, together with instructions for first-aid care for victims of 

electrical accidents. 

6.3 Outdoor substations 

Outdoor substation with prefabricated enclosures 

A prefabricated MV/LV substation complying with IEC 62271-202 standard includes : 

b equipement in accordance with IEC standards 

b a type tested enclosure, which means during its design, it has undergone a battery 

of tests (see Fig. B37): 

v Degree of protection 

v Functional tests 

v Temperature class 

v Non-flammable materials 

v Mechanical resistance of the enclosure 

v Sound level 

v Insulation level 

v Internal arc withstand 

v Earthing circuit test 

v Oil retention,… 

Use of equipment conform 

to IEC standards: 

b Degree of protection 

b Electromagnetic 

compatibility 

b Functional tests 

b Temperature class 

b Non-flammable 

materials 

Fig. B37 : Type tested substation according to IEC 62271-202 standard 

Main benefits are : 

b Safety: 

v For public and operators thanks to a high reproducible quality level 

b Cost effective: 

v Manufactured, equipped and tested in the factory 

b Delivery time 

v Delivered ready to be connected. 

IEC 62271-202 standard includes four main designs (see Fig. B38) 

b Walk-in type substation : 

v Operation protected from bad weather conditions 

b Non walk-in substation 

v Ground space savings, and outdoors operations 

b Half buried substation 

v Limited visual impact 

b Underground substation 

v Blends completely into the environment. 

LV 


MV 

Earthing circuit test Oil retention 

Mechanical resistance 

of the enclosure: 

b Sound level 

b Insulation level 

b Internal arcing 

withstand 

B39 


B40 




Fig. B39 : Outdoor substations without enclosures 



Outdoor substations without enclosures (see Fig. B39) 

These kinds of outdoor substation are common in some countries, based on 

weatherproof equipment exposed to the elements. 

These substations comprise a fenced area in which three or more concrete plinths 

are installed for: 

b A ring-main unit, or one or more switch-fuse or circuit-breaker unit(s) 

b One or more transformer(s), and 

b One or more LV distribution panel(s). 

Pole mounted substations 

Field of application 

These substations are mainly used to supply isolated rural consumers from MV 

overhead line distribution systems. 

Constitution 

In this type of substation, most often, the MV transformer protection is provided by 

fuses. 

Lightning arresters are provided, however, to protect the transformer and consumers 

as shown in Figure B40. 

General arrangement of equipment 

As previously noted the location of the substation must allow easy access, not only 

for personnel but for equipment handling (raising the transformer, for example) and 

the manœuvring of heavy vehicles. 

LV circuit breaker D1 

Safety earth mat 

Fig. B40 : Pole-mounted transformer substation 


Lightning 

arresters 

Earthing conductor 25 mm 2 copper 

Protective conductor cover

2 

Chapter C 

Connection to the LV utility 


Contents 

Low-voltage utility distribution networks C2 

1.1 Low-voltage consumers C2 

1.2 Low-voltage distribution networks C10 

1.3 The consumer service connection C11 

1.4 Quality of supply voltage C15 

Tariffs and metering C 6 


C 



C2 

C - Connecion to the LV public 


The most-common LV supplies are within the 

range 120 V single phase to 240/415 V 

3-phase 4-wires. 

Loads up to 250 kVA can be supplied at LV, but 

power-supply organizations generally propose 

a MV service at load levels for which their 

LV networks are marginally adequate. 

An international voltage standard for 3-phase 

4-wire LV systems is recommended by the 

IEC 60038 to be 230/400 V 

Low-voltage utility distribution 

networks 

. Low-voltage consumers 

In Europe, the transition period on the voltage tolerance to “230V/400V + 10% / - 10%” 

has been extended for another 5 years up to the year 2008. 

Low-voltage consumers are, by definition, those consumers whose loads can be 

satisfactorily supplied from the low-voltage system in their locality. 

The voltage of the local LV network may be 120/208 V or 240/415 V, i.e. the lower 

or upper extremes of the most common 3-phase levels in general use, or at some 

intermediate level, as shown in Figure C . 

An international voltage standard for 3-phase 4-wire LV systems is recommended 

by the IEC 60038 to be 230/400 V. 

Loads up to 250 kVA can be supplied at LV, but power-supply organizations 

generally propose a MV service at load levels for which their LV networks are 

marginally adequate. 

Country Frequency & tolerance Domestic (V) Commercial (V) Industrial (V) 

(Hz & %) 

Afghanistan 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

Algeria 50 ± 1.5 220/127 (e) 380/220 (a) 10,000 

220 (k) 220/127 (a) 5,500 

6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Angola 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

Antigua and Barbuda 60 240 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

120 (k) 120/208 (a) 120/208 (a) 

Argentina 50 ± 2 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Armenia 50 ± 5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Australia 50 ± 0.1 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 22,000 

240 (k) 440/250 (a) 11,000 

440 (m) 6,600 

415/240 

440/250 

Austria 50 ± 0.1 230 (k) 380/230 (a) (b) 5,000 

230 (k) 380/220 (a) 

Azerbaijan 50 ± 0.1 208/120 (a) 208/120 (a) 

240/120 (k) 240/120 (k) 

Bahrain 50 ± 0.1 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 11,000 

240 (k) 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 

240 (k) 

Bangladesh 50 ± 2 410/220 (a) 410/220 (a) 11,000 

220 (k) 410/220 (a) 

Barbados 50 ± 6 230/115 (j) 230/115 (j) 230/400 (g) 

115 (k) 200/115 (a) 230/155 (j) 

220/115 (a) 

Belarus 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

Belgium 50 ± 5 230 (k) 230 (k) 6,600 

230 (a) 230 (a) 10,000 

3N, 400 3N, 400 11,000 

15,000 

Bolivia 50 ± 0.5 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

230 (k) 

Botswana 50 ± 3 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

Brazil 60 220 (k) 220/380 (a) 13,800 

127 (k) 127/220 (a) 11,200 

220/380 (a) 

127/220 (a) 

Brunei 50 ± 2 230 230 11,000 

68,000 

Bulgaria 50 ± 0.1 220 220/240 1,000 

690 

380 

Fig. C1 : Voltage of local LV network and their associated circuit diagrams (continued on next page) 






networks 

Country Frequency & tolerance 

(Hz & %) 

Domestic (V) Commercial (V) Industrial (V) 

Cambodia 50 ± 1 220 (k) 220/300 220/380 

Cameroon 50 ± 1 220/260 (k) 220/260 (k) 220/380 (a) 

Canada 60 ± 0.02 120/240 (j) 347/600 (a) 7,200/12,500 

480 (f) 347/600 (a) 

240 (f) 120/208 

120/240 (j) 600 (f) 

120/208 (a) 480 (f) 

240 (f) 

Cape Verde 220 220 380/400 

Chad 50 ± 1 220 (k) 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 

Chile 50 ± 1 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

China 50 ± 0.5 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Colombia 60 ± 1 120/240 (g) 120/240 (g) 13,200 

120 (k) 120 (k) 120/240 (g) 

Congo 50 220 (k) 240/120 (j) 

120 (k) 

380/220 (a) 

Croatia 50 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

230 (k) 230 (k) 

Cyprus 50 ± 0.1 240 (k) 415/240 11,000 

415/240 

Czech Republic 50 ± 1 230 500 400,000 

230/400 220,000 

110,000 

35,000 

22,000 

10,000 

6,000 

3,000 

Denmark 50 ± 1 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

Djibouti 50 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

Dominica 50 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

Egypt 50 ± 0.5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 66,000 

220 (k) 220 (k) 33,000 

20,000 

11,000 

6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Estonia 50 ± 1 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Ethiopia 50 ± 2.5 220 (k) 380/231 (a) 15 000 

380/231 (a) 

Falkland Islands 50 ± 3 230 (k) 415/230 (a) 415/230 (a) 

Fidji Islands 50 ± 2 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 11,000 

240 (k) 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 

Finland 50 ± 0.1 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 690/400 (a) 

400/230 (a) 

France 50 ± 1 400/230 (a) 400/230 20,000 

230 (a) 690/400 10,000 

590/100 230/400 

Gambia 50 220 (k) 220/380 380 

Georgia 50 ± 0.5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Germany 50 ± 0.3 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 20,000 

230 (k) 230 (k) 10,000 

6,000 

690/400 

400/230 

Ghana 50 ± 5 220/240 220/240 415/240 (a) 

Gibraltar 50 ± 1 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

Greece 50 220 (k) 6,000 22,000 

230 380/220 (a) 20,000 

15,000 

6,600 

Granada 50 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

Hong Kong 50 ± 2 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 11,000 

220 (k) 386/220 (a) 

Hungary 50 ± 5 220 220 220/380 

Iceland 50 ± 0.1 230 230/400 230/400 


C 



C 





networks 


(Hz & %) 

India 50 ± 1.5 440/250 (a) 440/250 (a) 11,000 

230 (k) 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

440/250 (a) 

Indonesia 50 ± 2 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 150,000 

20,000 

380/220 (a) 

Iran 50 ± 5 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 20,000 

11,000 

400/231 (a) 

380/220 (a) 

Iraq 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 11,000 

6,600 

3,000 

380/220 (a) 

Ireland 50 ± 2 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 20,000 

10,000 

400/230 (a) 

Israel 50 ± 0.2 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 22,000 

230 (k) 230 (k) 12,600 

6,300 

400/230 (a) 

Italy 50 ± 0.4 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 20,000 

230 (k) 15,000 

10,000 

400/230 (a) 

Jamaica 50 ± 1 220/110 (g) (j) 220/110 (g) (j) 4,000 

2,300 

220/110 (g) 

Japan (east) + 0.1 200/100 (h) 200/100 (h) 140,000 

- 0.3 (up to 50 kW) 60,000 

20,000 

6,000 

200/100 (h) 

Jordan 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 400 (a) 

400/230 (k) 

Kazakhstan 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

Kenya 50 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

Kirghizia 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

Korea (North) 60 +0, -5 220 (k) 220/380 (a) 13,600 

6,800 

Korea (South) 60 100 (k) 100/200 (j) 

Kuwait 50 ± 3 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

Laos 50 ± 8 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

Lesotho 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

Latvia 50 ± 0.4 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Lebanon 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

Libya 50 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

127 (k) 220/127 (a) 220/127 (a) 

230 (k) 

127 (k) 

Lithuania 50 ± 0.5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Luxembourg 50 ± 0.5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 20,000 

15,000 

5,000 

Macedonia 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 10,000 

220 (k) 220 (k) 6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Madagascar 50 220/110 (k) 380/220 (a) 35,000 

5,000 

380/220 






networks 


(Hz & %) 


Malaysia 50 ± 1 240 (k) 

415 (a) 

415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

Malawi 50 ± 2.5 230 (k) 400 (a) 

230 (k) 

400 (a) 

Mali 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

127 (k) 220/127 (a) 

220 (k) 

127 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

Malta 50 ± 2 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

Martinique 50 127 (k) 220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

Mauritania 50 ± 1 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

Mexico 60 ± 0.2 127/220 (a) 127/220 (a) 13,800 

220 (k) 220 (k) 13,200 

120 (l) 120 (l) 277/480 (a) 

127/220 (b) 

Moldavia 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

220 (k) 

Morocco 50 ± 5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 225,000 

220/110 (a) 150,000 

60,000 

22,000 

20,000 

Mozambique 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 6,000 

10,000 

Nepal 50 ± 1 220 (k) 440/220 (a) 11,000 

220 (k) 440/220 (a) 

Netherlands 50 ± 0.4 230/400 (a) 230/400 (a) 25,000 

230 (k) 20,000 

12,000 

10,000 

230/400 

New Zealand 50 ± 1.5 400/230 (e) (a) 400/230 (e) (a) 11,000 

230 (k) 

460/230 (e) 

230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

Niger 50 ± 1 230 (k) 380/220 (a) 15,000 

380/220 (a) 

Nigeria 50 ± 1 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 15,000 

220 (k) 380/220 (a) 11,000 

400/230 (a) 

380/220 (a) 

Norway 50 ± 2 230/400 230/400 230/400 

690 

Oman 50 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 

240 (k) 

415/240 (a) 

Pakistan 50 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

230 (k) 

400/230 (a) 

Papua New Guinea 50 ± 2 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 22,000 

240 (k) 11,000 

415/240 (a) 

Paraguay 50 ± 0.5 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 22,000 

220 (k) 380/220 (a) 

Philippines (Rep of the) 60 ± 0.16 110/220 (j) 13,800 13,800 

4,160 4,160 

2,400 2,400 

110/220 (h) 440 (b) 

110/220 (h) 

Poland 50 ± 0.1 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 1,000 

690/400 

400/230 (a) 

Portugal 50 ± 1 380/220 (a) 15,000 15,000 

220 (k) 5,000 5,000 

380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

380/220 (a) 

Qatar 50 ± 0.1 415/240 (k) 415/240 (a) 11,000 

415/240 (a) 


C 



C6 





networks 


(Hz & %) 

Romania 50 ± 0.5 220 (k) 220/380 (a) 20,000 

220/380 (a) 10,000 

6,000 

220/380 (a) 

Russia 50 ± 0.2 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

Rwanda 50 ± 1 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 15,000 

6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Saint Lucia 50 ± 3 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 11,000 

415/240 (a) 

Samoa 400/230 

San Marino 50 ± 1 230/220 380 15,000 

380 

Saudi Arabia 60 220/127 (a) 220/127 (a) 11,000 

380/220 (a) 7,200 

380/220 (a) 

The Solomon Islands 50 ± 2 240 415/240 415/240 

Senegal 50 ± 5 220 (a) 380/220 (a) 90,000 

127 (k) 220/127 (k) 30,000 

6,600 

Serbia and Montenegro 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 10,000 

220 (k) 220 (k) 6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Seychelles 50 ± 1 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 11,000 

400/230 (a) 

Sierra Leone 50 ± 5 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 11,000 

230 (k) 400 

Singapore 50 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 22,000 

230 (k) 6,600 

400/230 (a) 

Slovakia 50 ± 0.5 230 230 230/400 

Slovenia 50 ± 0.1 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 10,000 

6,600 

380/220 (a) 

Somalia 50 230 (k) 440/220 (j) 440/220 (g) 

220 (k) 220/110 (j) 220/110 (g) 

110 (k) 230 (k) 

South Africa 50 ± 2.5 433/250 (a) 11,000 11,000 

400/230 (a) 6,600 6,600 

380/220 (a) 3,300 3,300 

220 (k) 433/250 (a) 500 (b) 

400/230 (a) 380/220 (a) 

380/220 (a) 

Spain 50 ± 3 380/220 (a) (e) 380/220 (a) 15,000 

220 (k) 220/127 (a) (e) 11,000 

220/127 (a) 380/220 (a) 

127 (k) 

Sri Lanka 50 ± 2 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 11,000 

230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

Sudan 50 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 415/240 (a) 

240 (k) 

Swaziland 50 ± 2.5 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 11,000 

230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

Sweden 50 ± 0.5 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 6,000 

230 (k) 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 

Switzerland 50 ± 2 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 20,000 

10,000 

3,000 

1,000 

690/500 

Syria 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

115 (k) 220 (k) 

200/115 (a) 

Tadzhikistan 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 






networks 


(Hz & %) 


Tanzania 50 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 11,000 

400/230 (a) 

Thailand 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

380/220 (a) 

Togo 50 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 20,000 

5,500 

380/220 (a) 

Tunisia 50 ± 2 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 30,000 

220 (k) 220 (k) 15,000 

10,000 

380/220 (a) 

Turkmenistan 50 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 

220/127 (a) 

127 (k) 

220 (k) 

Turkey 50 ± 1 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 15,000 

6,300 

380/220 (a) 

Uganda + 0.1 240 (k) 415/240 (a) 11,000 

415/240 (a) 

Ukraine + 0.2 / - 1.5 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

220 (k) 220 (k) 220 (k) 

United Arab Emirates 50 ± 1 220 (k) 415/240 (a) 6,600 

380/220 (a) 415/210 (a) 

220 (k) 380/220 (a) 

United Kingdom 50 ± 1 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 22,000 

(except Northern 11,000 

Ireland) 6,600 

3,300 

400/230 (a) 

United Kingdom 50 ± 0.4 230 (k) 400/230 (a) 400/230 (a) 

(Including Northern 

Ireland) 

220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380/220 (a) 

United States of 60 ± 0.06 120/240 (j) 265/460 (a) 14,400 

America 120/208 (a) 120/240 (j) 7,200 

Charlotte 120/208 (a) 2,400 

(North Carolina) 575 (f) 

460 (f) 

240 (f) 

265/460 (a) 

120/240 (j) 

120/208 (a) 

United States of 60 ± 0.2 120/240 (j) 480 (f) 13,200 

America 120/208 (a) 120/240 (h) 4,800 

Detroit (Michigan) 120/208 (a) 4,160 

480 (f) 

120/240 (h) 

120/208 (a) 

United States of 60 ± 0.2 120/240 (j) 4,800 4,800 

America 

Los Angeles (California) 

120/240 (g) 120/240 (g) 

United States of 60 ± 0.3 120/240 (j) 120/240 (j) 13,200 

America 120/208 (a) 120/240 (h) 2,400 

Miami (Florida) 120/208 (a) 480/277 (a) 

120/240 (h) 

United States of 60 120/240 (j) 120/240 (j) 12,470 

America New York 120/208 (a) 120/208 (a) 4,160 

(New York) 240 (f) 277/480 (a) 

480 (f) 


America 120/240 (j) 11,500 

Pittsburg 120/208 (a) 2,400 

(Pennsylvania) 460 (f) 265/460 (a) 

230 (f) 120/208 (a) 

460 (f) 

230 (f) 


C 



C 




(Hz & %) 

United States of 60 120/240 (j) 227/480 (a) 19,900 

America 120/240 (j) 12,000 

Portland (Oregon) 120/208 (a) 7,200 

480 (f) 2,400 

240 (f) 277/480 (a) 

120/208 (a) 

480 (f) 

240 (f) 


America 120/240 (j) 12,000 

San Francisco 4,160 

(California) 277/480 (a) 

120/240 (g) 

United States of 60 ± 0.08 120/240 (j) 277/480 (c) 12,470 

America 120/208 (a) 120/240(h) 7,200 

Toledo (Ohio) 120/208 (j) 4,800 

4,160 

480 (f) 

277/480 (a) 

120/208 (a) 

Uruguay 50 ± 1 220 (b) (k) 220 (b) (k) 15,000 

6,000 

220 (b) 

Vietnam 50 ± 0.1 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 35,000 

15,000 

10,000 

6,000 

Yemen 50 250 (k) 440/250 (a) 440/250 (a) 

Zambia 50 ± 2.5 220 (k) 380/220 (a) 380 (a) 

Zimbabwe 50 225 (k) 390/225 (a) 11,000 

390/225 (a) 

Circuit diagrams 

(a) Three-phase star; 

Four-wire: 

Earthed neutral 

(f) Three-phase delta: 

Three-wire 

(j) Single-phase; 

Three-wire: 

Earthed mid point 

(b) Three-phase star: 

Three-wire 

(g) Three-phase delta; 

Four-wire: 

Earthed mid point of 

one phase 

(k) Single-phase; 

Two-wire: 

Earthed end of phase 

(l) Single-phase; 

Two-wire 

Unearthed 

Fig. C1 : Voltage of local LV network and their associated circuit diagrams (concluded) 


networks 

(c) Three-phase star; 

Three-wire: 


(h) Three-phase open delta; 

Four-wire: 

Earthed mid point of one 

phase 

V Vk 

(m) Single-wire: 

Earthed return (swer) 


(d) Three-phase star; 

Four-wire: 

Non-earthed neutral 

(e) Two-phase star; 

Three-wire 


(i) Three-phase 

open delta: 

Earthed junction 

of phases 

(n) DC: 

Three-wire: 

Unearthed



(1) The Figure C2 values shown are indicative only, being 

(arbitrarily) based on 60 A maximum service currents for the 

first three systems, since smaller voltage drops are allowed at 

these lower voltages, for a given percentage statutory limit. 

The second group of systems is (again, arbitrarily) based on a 

maximum permitted service current of 120 A. 


networks 

Residential and commercial consumers 

The function of a LV “mains” distributor is to provide service connections 

(underground cable or overhead line) to a number of consumers along its route. 

The current-rating requirements of distributors are estimated from the number of 

consumers to be connected and an average demand per consumer. 

The two principal limiting parameters of a distributor are: 

b The maximum current which it is capable of carrying indefinitely, and 

b The maximum length of cable which, when carrying its maximum current, will not 

exceed the statutory voltage-drop limit 

These constraints mean that the magnitude of loads which utilities are willing to 

connect to their LV distribution mains, is necessarily restricted. 

For the range of LV systems mentioned in the second paragraph of this sub-clause 

(1.1) viz: 120 V single phase to 240/415 V 3-phase, typical maximum permitted loads 

connected to a LV distributor might (1) be (see Fig. C2): 

System Assumed max. permitted current kVA 

per consumer service 

120 V 1-phase 2-wire 60 A 7.2 

120/240 V 1-phase 3-wire 60 A 14.4 

120/208 V 3-phase 4-wire 60 A 22 

220/380 V 3-phase 4-wire 120 A 80 

230/400 V 3-phase 4-wire 120 A 83 

240/415 V 3-phase 4-wire 120 A 86 

Fig. C2 : Typical maximum permitted loads connected to a LV distributor 

Practices vary considerably from one power supply organization to another, and no 

“standardized” values can be given. 

Factors to be considered include: 

b The size of an existing distribution network to which the new load is to be connected 

b The total load already connected to the distribution network 

b The location along the distribution network of the proposed new load, i.e. close to 

the substation, or near the remote end of the distribution network, etc 

In short, each case must be examined individually. 

The load levels listed above are adequate for all normal residential consumers, and 

will be sufficient for the installations of many administrative, commercial and similar 

buildings. 

Medium-size and small industrial consumers (with dedicated 

LV lines direct from a utility supply MV/LV substation) 

Medium and small industrial consumers can also be satisfactorily supplied at lowvoltage. 

For loads which exceed the maximum permitted limit for a service from a distributor, 

a dedicated cable can usually be provided from the LV distribution fuse- (or switch-) 

board, in the power utility substation. 

Generaly, the upper load limit which can be supplied by this means is restricted only 

by the available spare transformer capacity in the substation. 

In practice, however: 

b Large loads (e.g. > 300 kVA) require correspondingly large cables, so that, 

unless the load centre is close to the substation, this method can be economically 

unfavourable 

b Many utilities prefer to supply loads exceeding 200 kVA (this figure varies with 

different suppliers) at medium voltage 

For these reasons, dedicated supply lines at LV are generally applied (at 220/380 V 

to 240/415 V) to a load range of 80 kVA to 250 kVA. 

Consumers normally supplied at low voltage include: 

b Residential dwellings 

b Shops and commercial buildings 

b Small factories, workshops and filling stations 

b Restaurants 

b Farms, etc 


C 


C 0 




In cities and large towns, standardized 

LV distribution cables form a network through 

link boxes. Some links are removed, so that 

each (fused) distributor leaving a substation 

forms a branched open-ended radial system, 

as shown in Figure C3 


networks 

.2 LV distribution networks 

In European countries the standard 3-phase 4-wire distribution voltage level is 

230/400 V. Many countries are currently converting their LV systems to the latest IEC 

standard of 230/400 V nominal (IEC 60038). Medium 

to large-sized towns and cities have underground cable distribution systems. 

MV/LV distribution substations, mutually spaced at approximately 500-600 metres, 

are typically equipped with: 

b A 3-or 4-way MV switchboard, often made up of incoming and outgoing loadbreak 

switches forming part of a ring main, and one or two MV circuit-breakers or 

combined fuse/ load-break switches for the transformer circuits 

b One or two 1,000 kVA MV/LV transformers 

b One or two (coupled) 6-or 8-way LV 3-phase 4-wire distribution fuse boards, or 

moulded-case circuit-breaker boards, control and protect outgoing 4-core distribution 

cables, generally referred to as “distributors” 

The output from a transformer is connected to the LV busbars via a load-break 

switch, or simply through isolating links. 

In densely-loaded areas, a standard size of distributor is laid to form a network, 

with (generally) one cable along each pavement and 4-way link boxes located in 

manholes at street corners, where two cables cross. 

Recent trends are towards weather-proof cabinets above ground level, either against 

a wall, or where possible, flush-mounted in the wall. 

Links are inserted in such a way that distributors form radial circuits from the 

substation with open-ended branches (see Fig. C3). Where a link box unites a 

distributor from one substation with that from a neighbouring substation, the phase 

links are omitted or replaced by fuses, but the neutral link remains in place. 

Service 

cable 

Fig. C3 : Showing one of several ways in which a LV distribution network may be arranged for 

radial branched-distributor operation, by removing (phase) links 


HV/LV 

substation 

4-way 

link box 

Phase links 

removed



In less-densely loaded urban areas a moreeconomic 

system of tapered radial distribution 

is commonly used, in which conductors of 

reduced size are installed as the distance from 

a substation increases 

Improved methods using insulated twisted 

conductors to form a pole mounted aerial cable 

are now standard practice in many countries 

In Europe, each utility-supply distribution 

substation is able to supply at LV an area 

corresponding to a radius of approximately 

300 metres from the substation. 

North and Central American systems of 

distribution consist of a MV network from which 

numerous (small) MV/LV transformers each 

supply one or several consumers, by direct 

service cable (or line) from the transformer 

location 

Service components and metering equipment 

were formerly installed inside a consumer’s 

building. The modern tendency is to locate 

these items outside in a weatherproof cabinet 


networks 

This arrangement provides a very flexible system in which a complete substation can 

be taken out of service, while the area normally supplied from it is fed from link boxes 

of the surrounding substations. 

Moreover, short lengths of distributor (between two link boxes) can be isolated for 

fault-location and repair. 

Where the load density requires it, the substations are more closely spaced, and 

transformers up to 1,500 kVA are sometimes necessary. 

Other forms of urban LV network, based on free-standing LV distribution pillars, 

placed above ground at strategic points in the network, are widely used in areas of 

lower load density. This scheme exploits the principle of tapered radial distributors in 

which the distribution cable conductor size is reduced as the number of consumers 

downstream diminish with distance from the substation. 

In this scheme a number of large-sectioned LV radial feeders from the distribution 

board in the substation supply the busbars of a distribution pillar, from which smaller 

distributors supply consumers immediately surrounding the pillar. 

Distribution in market towns, villages and rural areas generally has, for many years, 

been based on bare copper conductors supported on wooden, concrete or steel 

poles, and supplied from pole-mounted or ground-mounted transformers. 

In recent years, LV insulated conductors, twisted to form a two-core or 4-core self 

supporting cable for overhead use, have been developed, and are considered to be 

safer and visually more acceptable than bare copper lines. 

This is particularly so when the conductors are fixed to walls (e.g. under-eaves 

wiring) where they are hardly noticeable. 

As a matter of interest, similar principles have been applied at higher voltages, and 

self supporting “bundled” insulated conductors for MV overhead installations are now 

available for operation at 24 kV. 

Where more than one substation supplies a village, arrangements are made at poles 

on which the LV lines from different substations meet, to interconnect corresponding 

phases. 

North and Central American practice differs fundamentally from that in Europe, in 

that LV networks are practically nonexistent, and 3-phase supplies to premises in 

residential areas are rare. 

The distribution is effectively carried out at medium voltage in a way, which again 

differs from standard European practices. The MV system is, in fact, a 3-phase 

4-wire system from which single-phase distribution networks (phase and neutral 

conductors) supply numerous single-phase transformers, the secondary windings 

of which are centre-tapped to produce 120/240 V single-phase 3-wire supplies. 

The central conductors provide the LV neutrals, which, together with the MV neutral 

conductors, are solidly earthed at intervals along their lengths. 

Each MV/LV transformer normally supplies one or several premises directly from the 

transformer position by radial service cable(s) or by overhead line(s). 

Many other systems exist in these countries, but the one described appears to be 

the most common. 

Figure C (next page) shows the main features of the two systems. 

. The consumer-service connection 

In the past, an underground cable service or the wall-mounted insulated conductors 

from an overhead line service, invariably terminated inside the consumer’s premises, 

where the cable-end sealing box, the utility fuses (inaccessible to the consumer) and 

meters were installed. 

A more recent trend is (as far as possible) to locate these service components in a 

weatherproof housing outside the building. 

The utility/consumer interface is often at the outgoing terminals of the meter(s) or, 

in some cases, at the outgoing terminals of the installation main circuit-breaker 

(depending on local practices) to which connection is made by utility staff, following a 

satisfactory test and inspection of the installation. 

A typical arrangement is shown in Figure C (next page). 


C 


C 2 




1 2 3 

1 

2 

13.8 kV / 2.4-4.16 kV 

Fig. C4 : Widely-used American and European-type systems 

N 

Each MV/LV transformer shown 

represents many similar units 

2.4 kV / 120-240 V 

1 ph - 3 wire 

distribution 

transformer 

N 

N 


networks 

2 

3 

N 

1 

N 

2 

N 

HV (1) 

MV (2) 

Fig. C5 : Typical service arrangement for TT-earthed systems 


For primary voltages > 72.5 kV 

(see note) primary 

winding may be: 

- Delta 

- Earthed star 

- Earthed zigzag 

Depending on the country concerned 

Tertiary delta normally 

(not always) used if the 

primary winding is not delta 

1 ph MV / 230 V 

service transformer 

to isolated consumer(s) 

(rural supplies) 

Resistor replaced 

by a Petersen 

coil on O/H line 

systems in some 

countries 

Ph N 

1 2 3 N 

N 

N 1 2 3 

Main 3 ph and neutral 

MV distributor 

LV distribution network 

(1) 132 kV for example 

(2) 11 kV for example 

Note: At primary voltages greater than 72.5 kV in bulk-supply substations, it is common practice in some European countries 

to use an earthed-star primary winding and a delta secondary winding. The neutral point on the secondary side is then 

provided by a zigzag earthing reactor, the star point of which is connected to earth through a resistor. 

Frequently, the earthing reactor has a secondary winding to provide LV 3-phase supplies for the substation. It is then referred 

to as an “earthing transformer”. 

CB 

M 

F 

A 

} 

3 ph 

MV / 230/400 V 

4-wire distribution 

transformer



LV consumers are normally supplied according 

to the TN or TT system, as described in 

chapters F and G. The installation main circuitbreaker 

for a TT supply must include a residual 

current earth-leakage protective device. For a 

TN service, overcurrent protection by circuitbreaker 

or switch-fuse is required 


networks 

A MCCB -moulded case circuit-breaker- which incorporates a sensitive residualcurrent 

earth-fault protective feature is mandatory at the origin of any LV installation 

forming part of a TT earthing system. The reason for this feature and related 

leakage-current tripping levels are discussed in Clause 3 of Chapter G. 

A further reason for this MCCB is that the consumer cannot exceed his (contractual) 

declared maximum load, since the overload trip setting, which is sealed by the 

supply authority, will cut off supply above the declared value. Closing and tripping of 

the MCCB is freely available to the consumer, so that if the MCCB is inadvertently 

tripped on overload, or due to an appliance fault, supplies can be quickly restored 

following correction of the anomaly. 

In view of the inconvenience to both the meter reader and consumer, the location of 

meters is nowadays generally outside the premises, either: 

b In a free-standing pillar-type housing as shown in Figures C6 and C 

b In a space inside a building, but with cable termination and supply authority’s fuses 

located in a flush-mounted weatherproof cabinet accessible from the public way, as 

shown in Figure C next page 

b For private residential consumers, the equipment shown in the cabinet in 

Figure C5 is installed in a weatherproof cabinet mounted vertically on a metal 

frame in the front garden, or flush-mounted in the boundary wall, and accessible to 

authorized personnel from the pavement. Figure C (next page) shows the general 

arrangement, in which removable fuse links provide the means of isolation 

Fig. C6 : Typical rural-type installation 


F 

A 

M 

CB 

In this kind of installation it is often necessary to place the main installation circuitbreaker 

some distance from the point of utilization, e.g. saw-mills, pumping stations, 

etc. 

The main installation CB is located in the consumer’s premises in cases where it is 

set to trip if the declared kVA load demand is exceeded. 

CB 

Fig. C7 : Semi-urban installations (shopping precincts, etc.) 

M 

F 

A 

C 


C 





networks 

The service cable terminates in a flushmounted wall cabinet which contains the 

isolating fuse links, accessible from the public way. This method is preferred for 

esthetic reasons, when the consumer can provide a suitable metering and mainswitch 

location. 

Fig. C8 : Town centre installations 

Service cable 

Isolation by 

fuse links 

Meter cabinet 

Fig. C9 : Typical LV service arrangement for residential consumers 

In the field of electronic metering, techniques have developed which make their 

use attractive by utilities either for electricity metering and for billing purposes, the 

liberalisation of the electricity market having increased the needs for more data 

collection to be returned from the meters. For example electronic metering can also 

help utilities to understand their customers’ consumption profiles. In the same way, 

they will be useful for more and more power line communication and radio-frequency 

applications as well. 

In this area, prepayment systems are also more and more employed when 

economically justified. They are based on the fact that for instance consumers having 

made their payment at vending stations, generate tokens to pass the information 

concerning this payment on to the meters. For these systems the key issues are 

security and inter-operability which seem to have been addressed successfully 

now. The attractiveness of these systems is due to the fact they not only replace the 

meters but also the billing systems, the reading of meters and the administration of 

the revenue collection. 


Meter 

F 

A 

Interface 

Utility 

Main 

circuit 

breaker 

CB 

M 

Consumer 

Installation



An adequate level of voltage at the consumers 

supply-service terminals is essential for 

satisfactory operation of equipment and 

appliances. Practical values of current, and 

resulting voltage drops in a typical LV system, 

show the importance of maintaining a high 

Power Factor as a means of reducing voltage 

drop. 

(1) Transformers designed for the 230/400 V IEC standard 

will have a no-load output of 420 V, i.e. 105% of the nominal 

voltage 


networks 

. Quality of supply voltage 

The quality of the LV network supply voltage in its widest sense implies: 

b Compliance with statutory limits of magnitude and frequency 

b Freedom from continual fluctuation within those limits 

b Uninterrupted power supply, except for scheduled maintenance shutdowns, or as a 

result of system faults or other emergencies 

b Preservation of a near-sinusoidal wave form 

In this Sub-clause the maintenance of voltage magnitude only will be discussed. 

In most countries, power-supply authorities have a statutory obligation to maintain 

the level of voltage at the service position of consumers within the limits of ± 5% (or 

in some cases ± 6% or more-see table C1) of the declared nominal value. 

Again, IEC and most national standards recommend that LV appliances be designed 

and tested to perform satisfactorily within the limits of ± 10% of nominal voltage. This 

leaves a margin, under the worst conditions (of minus 5% at the service position, for 

example) of 5% allowable voltage drop in the installation wiring. 

The voltage drops in a typical distribution system occur as follows: the voltage at 

the MV terminals of a MV/LV transformer is normally maintained within a ± 2% band 

by the action of automatic onload tapchangers of the transformers at bulk-supply 

substations, which feed the MV network from a higher-voltage subtransmission 

system. 

If the MV/LV transformer is in a location close to a bulk-supply substation, the ± 2% 

voltage band may be centered on a voltage level which is higher than the nominal 

MV value. For example, the voltage could be 20.5 kV ± 2% on a 20 kV system. In this 

case, the MV/LV distribution transformer should have its MV off-circuit tapping switch 

selected to the + 2.5% tap position. 

Conversely, at locations remote from bulk supply substations a value of 19.5 kV ± 

2% is possible, in which case the off-circuit tapping switch should be selected to the 

- 5% position. 

The different levels of voltage in a system are normal, and depend on the system 

powerflow pattern. Moreover, these voltage differences are the reason for the term 

“nominal” when referring to the system voltage. 

Practical application 

With the MV/LV transformer correctly selected at its off-circuit tapping switch, an 

unloaded transformer output voltage will be held within a band of ± 2% of its no-load 

voltage output. 

To ensure that the transformer can maintain the necessary voltage level when fully 

loaded, the output voltage at no-load must be as high as possible without exceeding 

the upper + 5% limit (adopted for this example). In present-day practice, the winding 

ratios generally give an output voltage of about 104% at no-load (1) , when nominal 

voltage is applied at MV, or is corrected by the tapping switch, as described above. 

This would result in a voltage band of 102% to 106% in the present case. 

A typical LV distribution transformer has a short-circuit reactance voltage of 5%. If it 

is assumed that its resistance voltage is one tenth of this value, then the voltage drop 

within the transformer when supplying full load at 0.8 power factor lagging, will be: 

V% drop = R% cos ϕ + X% sin ϕ 

= 0.5 x 0.8 + 5 x 0.6 

= 0.4 + 3 = 3.4% 

The voltage band at the output terminals of the fully-loaded transformer will therefore 

be (102 - 3.4) = 98.6% to (106 - 3.4) = 102.6%. 

The maximum allowable voltage drop along a distributor is therefore 98.6 - 95 = 3.6%. 

This means, in practical terms, that a medium-sized 230/400 V 3-phase 4-wire 

distribution cable of 240 mm 2 copper conductors would be able to supply a total load 

of 292 kVA at 0.8 PF lagging, distributed evenly over 306 metres of the distributor. 

Alternatively, the same load at the premises of a single consumer could be supplied 

at a distance of 153 metres from the transformer, for the same volt-drop, and so on... 

As a matter of interest, the maximum rating of the cable, based on calculations 

derived from IEC 60287 (1982) is 290 kVA, and so the 3.6% voltage margin is not 

unduly restrictive, i.e. the cable can be fully loaded for distances normally required in 

LV distribution systems. 

Furthermore, 0.8 PF lagging is appropriate to industrial loads. In mixed semiindustrial 

areas 0.85 is a more common value, while 0.9 is generally used for 

calculations concerning residential areas, so that the volt-drop noted above may be 

considered as a “worst case” example. 


C 


C16 




(1) Ripple control is a system of signalling in which a voice 

frequency current (commonly at 175 Hz) is injected into the 

LV mains at appropriate substations. The signal is injected 

as coded impulses, and relays which are tuned to the signal 

frequency and which recognize the particular code will operate 

to initiate a required function. In this way, up to 960 discrete 

control signals are available. 

2 Tariffs and metering 

No attempt will be made in this guide to discuss particular tariffs, since there appears 

to be as many different tariff structures around the world as there are utilities. 

Some tariffs are very complicated in detail but certain elements are basic to all of 

them and are aimed at encouraging consumers to manage their power consumption 

in a way which reduces the cost of generation, transmission and distribution. 

The two predominant ways in which the cost of supplying power to consumers can 

be reduced, are: 

b Reduction of power losses in the generation, transmission and distribution of 

electrical energy. In principle the lowest losses in a power system are attained when 

all parts of the system operate at unity power factor 

b Reduction of the peak power demand, while increasing the demand at low-load 

periods, thereby exploiting the generating plant more fully, and minimizing plant 

redundancy 

Reduction of losses 

Although the ideal condition noted in the first possibility mentioned above cannot 

be realized in practice, many tariff structures are based partly on kVA demand, as 

well as on kWh consumed. Since, for a given kW loading, the minimum value of kVA 

occurs at unity power factor, the consumer can minimize billing costs by taking steps 

to improve the power factor of the load (as discussed in Chapter L). The kVA demand 

generally used for tariff purposes is the maximum average kVA demand occurring 

during each billing period, and is based on average kVA demands, over fixed periods 

(generally 10, 30 or 60 minute periods) and selecting the highest of these values. 

The principle is described below in “principle of kVA maximum-demand metering”. 

Reduction of peak power demand 

The second aim, i.e. that of reducing peak power demands, while increasing demand 

at low-load periods, has resulted in tariffs which offer substantial reduction in the cost 

of energy at: 

b Certain hours during the 24-hour day 

b Certain periods of the year 

The simplest example is that of a residential consumer with a storage-type water 

heater (or storage-type space heater, etc.). The meter has two digital registers, one 

of which operates during the day and the other (switched over by a timing device) 

operates during the night. A contactor, operated by the same timing device, closes 

the circuit of the water heater, the consumption of which is then indicated on the 

register to which the cheaper rate applies. The heater can be switched on and off at 

any time during the day if required, but will then be metered at the normal rate. Large 

industrial consumers may have 3 or 4 rates which apply at different periods during 

a 24-hour interval, and a similar number for different periods of the year. In such 

schemes the ratio of cost per kWh during a period of peak demand for the year, and 

that for the lowest-load period of the year, may be as much as 10: 1. 

Meters 

It will be appreciated that high-quality instruments and devices are necessary to 

implement this kind of metering, when using classical electro-mechanical equipment. 

Recent developments in electronic metering and micro-processors, together with 

remote ripple-control (1) from an utility control centre (to change peak-period timing 

throughout the year, etc.) are now operational, and facilitate considerably the 

application of the principles discussed. 

In most countries, some tariffs, as noted above, are partly based on kVA demand, 

in addition to the kWh consumption, during the billing periods (often 3-monthly 

intervals). The maximum demand registered by the meter to be described, is, in fact, 

a maximum (i.e. the highest) average kVA demand registered for succeeding periods 

during the billing interval. 




2 Tariffs and metering 

Figure C10 shows a typical kVA demand curve over a period of two hours divided 

into succeeding periods of 10 minutes. The meter measures the average value of 

kVA during each of these 10 minute periods. 

kVA 

Fig. C10 : Maximum average value of kVA over an interval of 2 hours 


Maximum average value 

during the 2 hour interval 

Average values 

for 10 minute 

periods 

0 1 2 hrs 

Principle of kVA maximum demand metering 

A kVAh meter is similar in all essentials to a kWh meter but the current and voltage 

phase relationship has been modified so that it effectively measures kVAh (kilovolt-ampere-hours). 

Furthermore, instead of having a set of decade counter dials, 

as in the case of a conventional kWh meter, this instrument has a rotating pointer. 

When the pointer turns it is measuring kVAh and pushing a red indicator before it. 

At the end of 10 minutes the pointer will have moved part way round the dial (it is 

designed so that it can never complete one revolution in 10 minutes) and is then 

electrically reset to the zero position, to start another 10 minute period. The red 

indicator remains at the position reached by the measuring pointer, and that position, 

corresponds to the number of kVAh (kilo-volt-ampere-hours) taken by the load in 

10 minutes. Instead of the dial being marked in kVAh at that point however it can be 

marked in units of average kVA. The following figures will clarify the matter. 

Supposing the point at which the red indicator reached corresponds to 5 kVAh. 

It is known that a varying amount of kVA of apparent power has been flowing for 

10 minutes, i.e. 1/6 hour. 

If now, the 5 kVAh is divided by the number of hours, then the average kVA for the 

period is obtained. 

In this case the average kVA for the period will be: 

5 x 1 = 5 x 6 = 30 kVA 

1 

6 

Every point around the dial will be similarly marked i.e. the figure for average kVA will 

be 6 times greater than the kVAh value at any given point. Similar reasoning can be 

applied to any other reset-time interval. 

At the end of the billing period, the red indicator will be at the maximum of all the 

average values occurring in the billing period. 

The red indicator will be reset to zero at the beginning of each billing period. Electromechanical 

meters of the kind described are rapidly being replaced by electronic 

instruments. The basic measuring principles on which these electronic meters 

depend however, are the same as those described above. 

t 

C17 


2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

Chapter D 

MV & LV architecture selection 

guide 

Contents 

Stakes for the user D3 

Simplified architecture design process D4 

2.1 The architecture design D4 

2.2 The whole process D5 

Electrical installation characteristics D7 

3.1 Activity D7 

3.2 Site topology D7 

3.3 Layout latitude D7 

3.4 Service reliability D8 

3.5 Maintainability D8 

3.6 Installation flexibility D8 

3.7 Power demand D8 

3.8 Load distribution D9 

3.9 Power interruption sensitivity D9 

3.10 Disturbance sensitivity D9 

3.11 Disturbance capability of circuits D10 

3.12 Other considerations or constraints D10 

Technological characteristics D 

4.1 Environment, atmosphere D11 

4.2 Service Index D11 

4.3 Other considerations D12 

Architecture assessment criteria D 3 

5.1 On-site work time D13 

5.2 Environmental impact D13 

5.3 Preventive maintenance level D13 

5.4 Availability of electrical power supply D14 

Choice of architecture fundamentals D 5 

6.1 Connection to the upstream network D15 

6.2 MV circuit configuration D16 

6.3 Number and distribution of MV/LV transformation substations D17 

6.4 Number of MV/LV transformers D18 

6.5 MV back-up generator D18 

Choice of architecture details D 9 

7.1 Layout D19 

7.2 Centralized or distributed layout D20 

7.3 Presence of an Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) D22 

7.4 Configuration of LV circuits D22 

Choice of equiment D24 


D 



D2 


9 

0 

2 

Recommendations for architecture optimization D26 

9.1 On-site work time D26 

9.2 Environmental impact D26 

9.3 Preventive maintenance volume D28 

9.4 Electrical power availability D28 

Glossary D29 

ID-Spec software D30 

Example: electrical installation in a printworks D3 

12.1 Brief description D31 

12.2 Installation characteristics D31 

12.3 Technological characteristics D31 

12.4 Architecture assessment criteria D32 

12.5 Choice of technogical solutions D34 



Potential for 

optimization 

Fig. D1 : Optimization potential 

ID-Spec 

Preliminary 

design 

Stakes for the user 

Choice of distribution architecture 

The choice of distribution architecture has a decisive impact on installation 

performance throughout its lifecycle: 

b right from the construction phase, choices can greatly influence the installation 

time, possibilities of work rate, required competencies of installation teams, etc. 

b there will also be an impact on performance during the operation phase in terms 

of quality and continuity of power supply to sensitive loads, power losses in power 

supply circuits, 

b and lastly, there will be an impact on the proportion of the installation that can be 

recycled in the end-of-life phase. 

The Electrical Distribution architecture of an installation involves the spatial 

configuration, the choice of power sources, the definition of different distribution 

levels, the single-line diagram and the choice of equipment. 

The choice of the best architecture is often expressed in terms of seeking a 

compromise between the various performance criteria that interest the customer who 

will use the installation at different phases in its lifecycle. The earlier we search for 

solutions, the more optimization possibilities exist (see Fig. D1). 

Ecodial 

Detailled 


Installation 

A successful search for an optimal solution is also strongly linked to the ability for 

exchange between the various players involved in designing the various sections of 

a project: 

b the architect who defines the organization of the building according to user 

requirements, 

b the designers of different technical sections (lighting, heating, air conditioning, 

fluids, etc.), 

b the user’s representatives e.g. defining the process. 

The following paragraphs present the selection criteria as well as the architecture 

design process to meet the project performance criteria in the context of industrial 

and tertiary buildings (excluding large sites). 


Exploitation 

D3 



D 


2 Simplified architecture design 

process 

2.1 The architecture design 

The architecture design considered in this document is positioned at the Draft 

Design stage. It generally covers the levels of MV/LV main distribution, LV power 

distribution, and exceptionally the terminal distribution level. (see Fig. D2). 

MV/LV main 

distribution 

LV power 

distribution 

LV terminal 

distribution 

The design of an electrical distribution architecture can be described by a 3-stage 

process, with iterative possibilities. This process is based on taking account of the 

installation characteristics and criteria to be satisfied. 


M M M M 

Fig. D2 : Example of single-line diagram


Data 

Step 

Deliverable 

See § 4 

Technological 


See § 5 

Assessment 

criteria 

Fig. D3 : Flow diagram for choosing the electrical distribution architecture 


process 

2.2 The whole process 

The whole process is described briefly in the following paragraphs and illustrated on 

Figure D3. 

The process described in this document is not intended as the only solution. This 

document is a guide intended for the use of electrical installation designers. 

See § 3 

Installation 


See § 6 

Step 1 

Choice of 

fundamentals 

Schematic 

diagram 

See § 7 

Step 2 


architecturedetails 

See § 8 

Detailed 

diagram 

Step 3 


equipment 

Techno. 

Solution 

ASSESSMENT 

Definitive 

solution 


See § 9 

Optimisation 

recommendations 

Step 1: Choice of distribution architecture fundamentals 

This involves defining the general features of the electrical installation. It is based 

on taking account of macroscopic characteristics concerning the installation and its 

usage. 

These characteristics have an impact on the connection to the upstream network, 

MV circuits, the number of transformer substations, etc. 

At the end of this step, we have several distribution schematic diagram solutions, 

which are used as a starting point for the single-line diagram. The definitive choice is 

confirmed at the end of the step 2. 

D 



D 



process 

Step 2: choice of architecture details 

This involves defining the electrical installation in more detail. It is based on the 

results of the previous step, as well as on satisfying criteria relative to implementation 

and operation of the installation. 

The process loops back into step1 if the criteria are not satisfied. An iterative process 

allows several assessment criteria combinations to be analyzed. 

At the end of this step, we have a detailed single-line diagram. 

Step 3: choice of equipment 

The choice of equipment to be implemented is carried out in this stage, and results 

from the choice of architecture. The choices are made from the manufacturer 

catalogues, in order to satisfy certain criteria. 

This stage is looped back into step 2 if the characteristics are not satisfied. 

Assessment 

This assessment step allows the Engineering Office to have figures as a basis for 

discussions with the customer and other players. 

According to the result of these discussions, it may be possible to loop back into step 1. 



3 Electrical installation 


These are the main installation characteristics enabling the defining of the 

fundamentals and details of the electrical distribution architecture. For each of these 

characteristics, we supply a definition and the different categories or possible values. 

3.1 Activity 

Definition: 

Main economic activity carried out on the site. 

Indicative list of sectors considered for industrial buildings: 

b Manufacturing 

b Food & Beverage 

b Logistics 

Indicative list of sectors considered for tertiary buildings: 

b Offices buildings 

b Hypermarkets 

b Shopping malls 

3.2 Site topology 

Definition: 

Architectural characteristic of the building(s), taking account of the number of 

buildings, number of floors, and of the surface area of each floor. 

Different categories: 

b Single storey building, 

b Multi-storey building, 

b Multi-building site, 

b High-rise building. 

3.3 Layout latitude 

Definition: 

Characteristic taking account of constraints in terms of the layout of the electrical 

equipment in the building: 

b aesthetics, 

b accessibility, 

b presence of dedicated locations, 

b use of technical corridors (per floor), 

b use of technical ducts (vertical). 


b Low: the position of the electrical equipment is virtually imposed 

b Medium: the position of the electrical equipment is partially imposed, to the 

detriment of the criteria to be satisfied 

b High: no constraints. The position of the electrical equipment can be defined to 

best satisfy the criteria. 


D 



D 




3.4 Service reliability 

Definition: 

The ability of a power system to meet its supply function under stated conditions for 

a specified period of time. 


b Minimum: this level of service reliability implies risk of interruptions related to 

constraints that are geographical (separate network, area distant from power 

production centers), technical (overhead line, poorly meshed system), or economic 

(insufficient maintenance, under-dimensioned generation). 

b Standard 

b Enhanced: this level of service reliability can be obtained by special measures 

taken to reduce the probability of interruption (underground network, strong meshing, 

etc.) 

3.5 Maintainability 

Definition: 

Features input during design to limit the impact of maintenance actions on the 

operation of the whole or part of the installation. 


b Minimum: the installation must be stopped to carry out maintenance operations. 

b Standard: maintenance operations can be carried out during installation 

operations, but with deteriorated performance. These operations must be preferably 

scheduled during periods of low activity. Example: several transformers with partial 

redundancy and load shedding. 

b Enhanced: special measures are taken to allow maintenance operations without 

disturbing the installation operations. Example: double-ended configuration. 

3.6 Installation flexibility 

Definition: 

Possibility of easily moving electricity delivery points within the installation, or to 

easily increase the power supplied at certain points. Flexibility is a criterion which 

also appears due to the uncertainty of the building during the pre-project summary 

stage. 


b No flexibility: the position of loads is fixed throughout the lifecycle, due to the high 

constraints related to the building construction or the high weight of the supplied 

process. E.g.: smelting works. 

b Flexibility of design: the number of delivery points, the power of loads or their 

location are not precisely known. 

b Implementation flexibility: the loads can be installed after the installation is 

commissioned. 

b Operating flexibility: the position of loads will fluctuate, according to process reorganization. 

Examples: 

v industrial building: extension, splitting and changing usage 

v office building: splitting 



* indicative value, supplied by standard EN50160: 

“Characteristics of the voltage supplied by public distribution 

networks”. 



3. Power demand 

Definition: 

The sum of the apparent load power (in kVA), to which is applied a usage coefficient. 

This represents the maximum power which can be consumed at a given time for the 

installation, with the possibility of limited overloads that are of short duration. 

Significant power ranges correspond to the transformer power limits most commonly 

used: 

b < 630kVA 

b from 630 to 1250kVA 

b from 1250 to 2500kVA 

b > 2500kVA 

3. Load distribution 

Definition: 

A characteristic related to the uniformity of load distribution (in kVA / m²) over an area 

or throughout the building. 


b Uniform distribution: the loads are generally of an average or low unit power and 

spread throughout the surface area or over a large area of the building (uniform 

density). 

E.g.: lighting, individual workstations 

b intermediate distribution: the loads are generally of medium power, placed in 

groups over the whole building surface area 

E.g.: machines for assembly, conveying, workstations, modular logistics “sites” 

b localized loads: the loads are generally high power and localized in several areas 

of the building (non-uniform density). 

E.g.: HVAC 

3. Power Interruption Sensitivity 

Definition: 

The aptitude of a circuit to accept a power interruption. 


b “Sheddable” circuit: possible to shut down at any time for an indefinite duration 

b Long interruption acceptable: interruption time > 3 minutes * 

b Short interruption acceptable: interruption time < 3 minutes * 

b No interruption acceptable. 

We can distinguish various levels of severity of an electrical power interruption, 

according to the possible consequences: 

b No notable consequence, 

b Loss of production, 

b Deterioration of the production facilities or loss of sensitive data, 

b Causing mortal danger. 

This is expressed in terms of the criticality of supplying of loads or circuits. 

b Non-critical: 

The load or the circuit can be “shed” at any time. E.g.: sanitary water heating circuit. 

b Low criticality: 

A power interruption causes temporary discomfort for the occupants of a building, 

without any financial consequences. Prolonging of the interruption beyond the critical 

time can cause a loss of production or lower productivity. E.g.: heating, ventilation 

and air conditioning circuits (HVAC). 

b Medium criticality 

A power interruption causes a short break in process or service. Prolonging of 

the interruption beyond a critical time can cause a deterioration of the production 

facilities or a cost of starting for starting back up. 

E.g.: refrigerated units, lifts. 

b High criticality 

Any power interruption causes mortal danger or unacceptable financial losses. 

E.g.: operating theatre, IT department, security department. 


D 


D10 





3.10 Disturbance sensitivity 

Definition 

The ability of a circuit to work correctly in presence of an electrical power 

disturbance. 

A disturbance can lead to varying degrees of malfunctioning. E.g.: stopping working, 

incorrect working, accelerated ageing, increase of losses, etc 

Types of disturbances with an impact on circuit operations: 

b brown-outs, 

b overvoltages 

b voltage distortion, 

b voltage fluctuation, 

b voltage imbalance. 


b low sensitivity: disturbances in supply voltages have very little effect on operations. 

E.g.: heating device. 

b medium sensitivity: voltage disturbances cause a notable deterioration in 

operations. 

E.g.: motors, lighting. 

b high sensitivity: voltage disturbances can cause operation stoppages or even the 

deterioration of the supplied equipment. 

E.g.: IT equipment. 

The sensitivity of circuits to disturbances determines the design of shared or 

dedicated power circuits. Indeed it is better to separate “sensitive” loads from 

“disturbing” loads. E.g.: separating lighting circuits from motor supply circuits. 

This choice also depends on operating features. E.g.: separate power supply of 

lighting circuits to enable measurement of power consumption. 

3.11 Disturbance capability of circuits 

Definition 

The ability of a circuit to disturb the operation of surrounding circuits due to 

phenomena such as: harmonics, in-rush current, imbalance, High Frequency 

currents, electromagnetic radiation, etc. 

Different categories 

b Non disturbing: no specific precaution to take 

b moderate or occasional disturbance: separate power supply may be necessary in 

the presence of medium or high sensitivity circuits. E.g.: lighting circuit generating 

harmonic currents. 

b Very disturbing: a dedicated power circuit or ways of attenuating disturbances are 

essential for the correct functioning of the installation. E.g.: electrical motor with a 

strong start-up current, welding equipment with fluctuating current. 

3.12 Other considerations or constraints 

b Environment 

E.g.: lightning classification, sun exposure 

b Specific rules 

E.g.: hospitals, high rise buildings, etc. 

b Rule of the Energy Distributor 

Example: limits of connection power for LV, access to MV substation, etc 

b Attachment loads 

Loads attached to 2 independent circuits for reasons of redundancy. 

b Designer experience 

Consistency with previous designs or partial usage of previous designs, 

standardization of sub-assemblies, existence of an installed equipment base. 

b Load power supply constraints 

Voltage level (230V, 400V, 690V), voltage system (single-phase, three-phase with or 

without neutral, etc) 



Fig. D4 : Different index values 

4 Technological characteristics 

The technological solutions considered concern the various types of MV and LV 

equipment, as well as Busbar Trunking Systems . 

The choice of technological solutions is made following the choice of single-line 

diagram and according to characteristics given below. 

4.1 Environment, atmosphere 

A notion taking account of all of the environmental constraints (average ambient 

temperature, altitude, humidity, corrosion, dust, impact, etc.) and bringing together 

protection indexes IP and IK. 


b Standard: no particular environmental constraints 

b Enhanced: severe environment, several environmental parameters generate 

important constraints for the installed equipment 

b Specific: atypical environment, requiring special enhancements 

4.2 Service Index 

The service index (IS) is a value that allows us to characterize an LV switchboard 

according to user requirements in terms of operation, maintenance, and scalability. 

The different index values are indicated in the following table (Fig D4): 

Operation Maintenance Upgrade 

Level 1 IS = 1 • • 

Operation may lead to complete 

stoppage of the switchboard 

Level 2 IS = 2 • • 

Operation may lead to stoppage of 

only the functional unit 

Level 3 IS = 3 • • 


the power of the functional unit only 

IS = • 1 • 



IS = • 2 • 


only the functional unit, with work on 

connections 

IS = • 3 • 


only the functional unit, without work 

on connections 


IS = • • 1 



IS = • • 2 

Operation may lead to stoppage 

of only the functional unit, with 

functional units provided for back-up 

IS = • • 3 


only the functional unit, with total 

freedom in terms of upgrade 

b Examples of an operation event: turning off a circuit-breaker, switching operation to 

energize/de-energize a machine 

b Example of a maintenance operation: tightening connections 

b Example of an upgrade operation: connecting an additional feeder 

There are a limited number of relevant service indices (see Fig. D5) 

IS Operation Maintenance Upgrade 

1 1 1 Switching off the whole switchboard Working time > 1h, with total nonavailability 

Extension not planned 

2 1 1 

2 2 3 Working time between 1/4h and 1h, 

with work on connections 

2 3 2 

Individually switching off the functional 

unit and re-commissioning < 1h 

Working time between 1/4h and 1h, 

without work on connections 

Possible adding of functional units 

without stopping the switchboard 

Possible adding of functional units with 

stopping the switchboard 

2 3 3 Possible adding of functional units 


3 3 2 

Possible adding of functional units with 

stopping the switchboard 

3 3 3 

Individually switching off the functional 

unit and re-commissioning < 1/4h 

Possible adding of functional units 


Fig. D5 : Relevant service indices (IS) 

D11 


D12 



Service rating Protection index 

IP 

4 Technological characteristics 

The types of electrical connections of functional units can be denoted by a threeletter 

code: 

b The first letter denotes the type of electrical connection of the main incoming 

circuit, 

b The second letter denotes the type of electrical connection of the main outgoing 

circuit, 

b The third letter denotes the type of electrical connection of the auxiliary circuits. 

The following letters are used: 

b F for fixed connections, 

b D for disconnectable connections, 

b W for withdrawable connections. 

Service ratings are related to other mechanical parameters, such as the Protection 

Index (IP), form of internal separations, the type of connection of functional units or 

switchgear (Fig. D6): 

Form Functional Unit 

Withdrawability 

1 1 1 2 X X 1 F F F 

2 1 1 2 X B 1 F F F 

2 2 3 2 X B 3b W F D 

2 3 2 2 X B 3b W F W 

2 3 3 2 X B 3b W W W 

3 3 2 2 X B 3b W W W 

3 3 3 2 X B 3b W W W 

Fig. D6 : Correspondence between service index and other mechanical parameters 

Technological examples are given in chapter E2. 

b Definition of the protection index: see IEC 60529: “Degree of protection given by 

enclosures (IP code)”, 

b Definitions of the form and withdrawability: see IEC 60439-1: “Low-voltage 

switchgear and controlgear assemblies; part 1: type-tested and partially type-tested 

assemblies”. 

4.3 Other considerations 

Other considerations have an impact on the choice of technological solutions: 

b Designer experience, 

b Consistency with past designs or the partial use of past designs, 

b Standardization of sub-assemblies, 

b The existence of an installed equipment base, 

b Utilities requirements, 

b Technical criteria: target power factor, backed-up load power, presence of harmonic 

generators… 

These considerations should be taken into account during the detailed electrical 

definition phase following the draft design stage. 



5 Architecture assessment criteria 

Certain decisive criteria are assessed at the end of the 3 stages in defining 

architecture, in order to validate the architecture choice. These criteria are listed 

below with the different allocated levels of priority. 

5.1 On-site work time 

Time for implementing the electrical equipment on the site. 

Different levels of priority: 

b Secondary: the on-site work time can be extended, if this gives a reduction in 

overall installation costs, 

b Special: the on-site work time must be minimized, without generating any 

significant excess cost, 

b Critical: the on-site work time must be reduced as far as possible, imperatively, 

even if this generates a higher total installation cost, 

5.2 Environmental impact 

Taking into consideration environmental constraints in the installation design. This 

takes account of: consumption of natural resources, Joule losses (related to CO 2 

emission), “recyclability” potential, throughout the installation’s lifecycle. 

Different levels of priority: 

b Non significant: environmental constraints are not given any special consideration, 

b Minimal: the installation is designed with minimum regulatory requirements, 

b Proactive: the installation is designed with a specific concern for protecting 

the environment. Excess cost is allowed in this situation. E.g.: using low-loss 

transformers. 

The environmental impact of an installation will be determined according to the 

method carrying out an installation lifecycle analysis, in which we distinguish 

between the following 3 phases: 

b manufacture, 

b operation, 

b end of life (dismantling, recycling). 

In terms of environmental impact, 3 indicators (at least) can be taken into account 

and influenced by the design of an electrical installation. Although each lifecycle 

phase contributes to the three indicators, each of these indicators is mainly related to 

one phase in particular: 

b consumption of natural resources mainly has an impact on the manufacturing 

phase, 

b consumption of energy has an impact on the operation phase, 

b “recycleability” potential has an impact on the end of life. 

The following table details the contributing factors to the 3 environmental indicators 

(Fig D7). 

Indicators Contributors 

Natural resources consumption Mass and type of materials used 

Power consumption Joule losses at full load and no load 

«Recyclability» potential Mass and type of material used 

Fig D7 : Contributing factors to the 3 environmental indicators 


D13 


D14 



5 Architecture assessment criteria 

5.3 Preventive maintenance level 

Definition: 

Number of hours and sophistication of maintenance carried out during operations in 

conformity with manufacturer recommendations to ensure dependable operation of 

the installation and the maintaining of performance levels (avoiding failure: tripping, 

down time, etc). 


b Standard: according to manufacturer recommendations. 

b Enhanced: according to manufacturer recommendations, with a severe 

environment, 

b Specific: specific maintenance plan, meeting high requirements for continuity of 

service, and requiring a high level of maintenance staff competency. 

5.4 Availability of electrical power supply 

Definition: 

This is the probability that an electrical installation be capable of supplying quality 

power in conformity with the specifications of the equipment it is supplying. This is 

expressed by an availability level: 

Availability (%) = (1 - MTTR/ MTBF) x 100 

MTTR (Mean Time To Repair): the average time to make the electrical system once 

again operational following a failure (this includes detection of the reason for failure, 

its repair and re-commissioning), 

MTBF (Mean Time Between Failure): measurement of the average time for which 

the electrical system is operational and therefore enables correct operation of the 

application. 

The different availability categories can only be defined for a given type of 

installation. E.g.: hospitals, data centers. 

Example of classification used in data centers: 

Tier 1: the power supply and air conditioning are provided by one single channel, 

without redundancy, which allows availability of 99.671%, 

Tier 2: the power supply and air conditioning are provided by one single channel, 

with redundancy, which allows availability of 99.741%, 

Tier 3: the power supply and air conditioning are provided by several channels, with 

one single redundant channel, which allows availability of 99.982%, 

Tier 4: the power supply and air conditioning are provided by several channels, with 

redundancy, which allows availability of 99.995%. 



6 Choice of architecture 

fundamentals 

The single-line diagram can be broken down into different key parts, which are 

determined throughout a process in 2 successive stages. During the first stage we 

make the following choices: 

b connection to the utilities network, 

b configuration of MV circuits, 

b number of power transformers, 

b number and distribution of transformation substations, 

b MV back-up generator 

6.1 Connection to the upstream network 

The main configurations for possible connection are as follows (see Fig. D8 for MV 

service): 

b LV service, 

b MV single-line service, 

b MV ring-main service, 

b MV duplicate supply service, 

b MV duplicate supply service with double busbar. 

Metering, protection, disconnection devices, located in the delivery substations are 

not represented on the following diagrams. They are often specific to each utilities 

company and do not have an influence on the choice of installation architecture. 

For each connection, one single transformer is shown for simplification purposes, but 

in the practice, several transformers can be connected. 

(MLVS: Main Low Voltage Switchboard) 

a) Single-line: b) Ring-main: 

MV 

LV 

MLVS 


MLVS 

c) Duplicate supply: d) Double busbar with duplicate supply: 

MV 

LV 

MLVS 

Fig. D8 : MV connection to the utilities network 

MV 

LV 

MV 

LV 

MLVS1 

MV 

LV 

MLVS2 

D15 


D16 



Characteristic to 

consider 

Configuration 

LV MV 

For the different possible configurations, the most probable and usual set of 

characteristics is given in the following table: 

Simple-line Ring-main Duplicate supply Duplicate supply 

with double 

busbars 

Activity Any Any Any Hi-tech, sensitive 

office, health-care 

Site topology Single building Single building Single building Single building Several buildings 

Service reliability Minimal Minimal Standard Enhanced Enhanced 

Power demand < 630kVA ≤ 1250kVA ≤ 2500kVA > 2500kVA > 2500kVA 

Other connection 

constraints 

Any Isolated site Low density urban 

area 

a) Single feeder: b) Open ring, 1 MV substation: 

MV MV MV MV MV 

LV 

MLVS 1 

LV 

MLVS n 

Fig. D9 : MV circuit configuration 

LV 

MLVS 1 


fundamentals 


High density 

urban area 

6.2 MV circuit configuration 

Any 

Urban area with 

utility constraint 

The main possible connection configurations are as follows (Fig. D9): 

b single feeder, one or several transformers 

b open ring, one MV incomer 

b open ring, 2 MV incomers 

The basic configuration is a radial single-feeder architecture, with one single 

transformer. 

In the case of using several transformers, no ring is realised unless all of the 

transformers are located in a same substation. 

Closed-ring configuration is not taken into account. 

LV 

MLVS 2 

LV 

MLVS n 

c) Open ring, 2 MV substations: 

MV 

LV 

MLVS 1 

MV 

LV 

MLVS 2 

MV 

LV 

MLVS n



fundamentals 


characteristics is given in the table on Fig D10. 


consider 

Site topology Any 

< 25000m² 


MV circuit configuration 

Single feeder Open ring 

1 MV substation 

Building with one 

level or several 

buildings 

≤ 25000m² 

Open ring 

2 MV substations 

Several buildings 

≥ 25000m² 

Maintainability Minimal or standard Enhanced Enhanced 

Power demand Any > 1250kVA > 2500kVA 

Disturbance sensitivity Long interruption 

acceptable 

Fig. D10 : Typical values of the installation characteristics 

Short interruption 

acceptable 

Short interruption 

acceptable 

Another exceptional configuration: power supply by 2 MV substations and connection 

of the transformers to each of these 2 substations (MV “double ended” connection). 

6.3 Number and distribution of MV/LV 

transformation substations 

Main characteristics to consider to determine the transformation substations: 

b Surface area of building or site 

b Power demand, (to be compared with standardized transformer power), 

b Load distribution 

The preferred basic configuration comprises one single substation. Certain factors 

contribute to increasing the number of substations (> 1): 

b A large surface area (> 25000m²), 

b The site configuration: several buildings, 

b Total power > 2500kVA, 

b Sensitivity to interruption: need for redundancy in the case of a fire. 


consider 

Configuration 

1 substation with 

N transformers 

N substations 

N transformers 

(identical substations) 

Building configuration < 25000m² ≥ 25000m² 

1 building with several 

floors 

N substations 

M transformers 

(different powers) 

≥ 25000m² 

several buildings 

Power demand < 2500kVA ≥ 2500kVA ≥ 2500kVA 

Load distribution Localized loads Uniform distribution Medium density 

Fig. D11 : Typical characteristics of the different configurations 

D17 


D18 




fundamentals 

6.4 Number of MV/LV transformers 

Main characteristics to consider to determine the number of transformers: 

b Surface of building or site 

b Total power of the installed loads 

b Sensitivity of circuits to power interruptions 

b Sensitivity of circuits to disturbances 

b Installation scalability 

The basic preferred configuration comprises a single transformer supplying the total 

power of the installed loads. Certain factors contribute to increasing the number of 

transformers (> 1), preferably of equal power: 

b A high total installed power (> 1250kVA): practical limit of unit power 

(standardization, ease of replacement, space requirement, etc), 

b A large surface area (> 5000m²): the setting up of several transformers as close as 

possible to the distributed loads allows the length of LV trunking to be reduced 

b A need for partial redundancy (down-graded operation possible in the case of a 

transformer failure) or total redundancy (normal operation ensured in the case a 

transformer failure) 

b Separating of sensitive and disturbing loads (e.g.: IT, motors) 

6.5 MV back-up generator 

Main characteristics to consider for the implementation of an MV back-up generator: 

b Site activity 

b Total power of the installed loads 

b Sensitivity of circuits to power interruptions 

b Availability of the public distribution network 

The preferred basic configuration does not include an MV generator. Certain factors 

contribute to installing an MV generator: 

b Site activity: process with co-generation, optimizing the energy bill, 

b Low availability of the public distribution network. 

Installation of a back-up generator can also be carried out at LV level. 



Office 

Finishing 

7 Choice of architecture details 

This is the second stage in designing of the electrical installation. During this stage 

we carry out the following choices are carried out: 

b Layout, 

b Centralized or decentralized distribution, 

b Presence of back-up generators, 

b Presence of uninterruptible power supplies, 

b Configuration of LV circuits, 

b Architecture combinations. 

7.1 Layout 

Position of the main MV and LV equipment on the site or in the building. 

This layout choice is applied to the results of stage 1. 

Selection guide: 

b Place power sources as close as possible to the barycenter of power consumers, 

b Reduce atmospheric constraints: building dedicated premises if the layout in the 

workshop is too restrictive (temperature, vibrations, dust, etc.), 

b Placing heavy equipment (transformers, generators, etc) close to walls or main 

exists for ease of maintenance, 

A layout example is given in the following diagram (Fig. D12): 

Global current 

consumer 

Barycenter 

Painting 

Fig. D12 : The position of the global current consumer barycenter guides the positioning of power sources 


Panel 

shop 

D19 


D20 




7.2 Centralized or distributed layout 

In centralized layout, current consumers are connected to the power sources 

by a star-connection. Cables are suitable for centralized layout, with point to point 

links between the MLVS and current consumers or sub-distribution boards (radial 

distribution, star- distribution) (Fig. D13): 

Fig. D13: Example of centralized layout with point to point links 

In decentralized layout, current consumers are connected to sources via a busway. 

Busbar trunking systems are well suited to decentralized layout, to supply many 

loads that are spread out, making it easy to change, move or add connections 

(Fig D14): 

Fig. D14 : Example of decentralized layout, with busbar trunking links 

Factors in favour of centralized layout (see summary table in Fig. D15): 

b Installation flexibility: no, 

b Load distribution: localized loads (high unit power loads). 

Factors in favor of decentralized layout: 

b Installation flexibility: "Implementation" flexibility (moving of workstations, etc…), 

b Load distribution: uniform distribution of low unit power loads 




Load distribution 

Flexibility Localized loads Intermediate 

distribution 

No flexibility 

Design flexibility 


Uniform distributed 

Centralized Decentralized 

Implementation 

flexibility Centralized Decentralized 

Operation flexibility 

Fig. D15 : Recommendations for centralized or decentralized layout 

Power supply by cables gives greater independence of circuits (lighting, power 

sockets, HVAC, motors, auxiliaries, security, etc), reducing the consequences of a 

fault from the point of view of power availability. 

The use of busbar trunking systems allows load power circuits to be combined and 

saves on conductors by taking advantage of a clustering coefficient. The choice 

between cable and busbar trunking, according to the clustering coefficient, allows us 

to find an economic optimum between investment costs, implementation costs and 

operating costs. 

These two distribution modes are often combined. 

Presence of back-up generators (Fig. D16) 

Here we only consider LV back-up generators. 

The electrical power supply supplied by a back-up generator is produced by an 

alternator, driven by a thermal engine. 

No power can be produced until the generator has reached its rated speed. This type 

of device is therefore not suitable for an uninterrupted power supply. 

According to the generator’s capacity to supply power to all or only part of the 

installation, there is either total or partial redundancy. 

A back-up generator functions generally disconnected from the network. A source 

switching system is therefore necessary. 

The generator can function permanently or intermittently. Its back-up time depends 

on the quantity of available fuel. 

Fig. D16 : Connection of a back-up generator 

LV switchboard 

The main characteristics to consider for implementing LV back-up generator: 

b Sensitivity of loads to power interruption, 

b Availability of the public distribution network, 

b Other constraints (e.g.: generators compulsory in hospitals or high-vise buildings) 

The presence of generators can be decided to reduce the energy bill or due to the 

opportunity for co-generation. These two aspects are not taken into account in this 

guide. 

The presence of a back-up generator is essential if the loads cannot be shed for 

an indefinite duration (long interruption only acceptable) or if the utility network 

availability is low. 

Determining the number of back-up generator units is in line with the same criteria 

as determining the number of transformers, as well as taking account of economic 

and availability considerations (redundancy, start-up reliability, maintenance facility). 

G 

D21 


D22 



MLVS 

Fig. D18 : Radial single feeder configuration 

MLVS 

Fig. D19 : Two-pole configuration 

MLVS 

NO 

Fig. D20 : Two-pole configuration with two ½ MLVS and NO link 


7.3 Presence of an Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) 

The electrical power from a UPS is supplied from a storage unit: batteries or inertia 

wheel. This system allows us to avoid any power failure. The back-up time of the 

system is limited: from several minutes to several hours. 

The simultaneous presence of a back-up generator and a UPS unit is used for 

permanently supply loads for which no failure is acceptable (Fig. D17). The back-up 

time of the battery or the inertia wheel must be compatible with the maximum time 

for the generator to start up and be brought on-line. 

A UPS unit is also used for supply power to loads that are sensitive to disturbances 

(generating a “clean” voltage that is independent of the network). 

Main characteristics to be considered for implementing a UPS: 

b Sensitivity of loads to power interruptions, 

b Sensitivity of loads to disturbances. 

The presence of a UPS unit is essential if and only if no failure is acceptable. 

LV Switchboard 

Non-critical 

circuit 

Fig. D17 : Example of connection for a UPS 


Normal 

ASI 

Critical 

circuit 

7.4 Configuration of LV circuits 

G 

By-pass 

Main possible configurations (see figures D18 to D25): 

b Radial single feeder configuration: This is the reference configuration and 

the most simple. A load is connected to only one single source. This configuration 

provides a minimum level of availability, since there is no redundancy in case of 

power source failure. 

b Two-pole configuration: The power supply is provided by 2 transformers, 

connected to the same MV line. When the transformers are close, they are generally 

connected in parallel to the same MLVS. 

b Variant: two-pole with two ½ MLVS: In order to increase the availability in case 

of failure of the busbars or authorize maintenance on one of the transformers, 

it is possible to split the MLVS into 2 parts, with a normally open link (NO). This 

configuration generally requires an Automatic Transfer Switch, (ATS). 

b Shedable switchboard (simple disconnectable attachment): A series of 

shedable circuits can be connected to a dedicated switchboard. The connection to 

the MLVS is interrupted when needed (overload, generator operation, etc) 

b Interconnected switchboards: If transformers are physically distant from one 

another, they may be connected by a busbar trunking. A critical load can be supplied 

by one or other of the transformers. The availability of power is therefore improved, 

since the load can always be supplied in the case of failure of one of the sources. 

The redundancy can be: 

v Total: each transformer being capable of supplying all of the installation, 

v Partial: each transformer only being able to supply part of the installation. In this 

case, part of the loads must be disconnected (load-shedding) in the case of one of 

the transformers failing.


LV swichboard 

Fig. D21 : Shedable switchboard 

MLVS 

Busbar 

Fig. D22 : Interconnected switchboards 

Busbar 

MLVS 

MLVS 

Fig. D23 : Ring configuration 

Busbar 

Busbar 

MLVS 

MLVS 

MLVS 

MLVS 

Busbar 


b Ring configuration: This configuration can be considered as an extension of the 

configuration with interconnection between switchboards. Typically, 4 transformers 

connected to the same MV line, supply a ring using busbar trunking. A given load 

is then supplied power by several clustered transformers. This configuration is well 

suited to extended installations, with a high load density (in kVA/m²). If all of the loads 

can be supplied by 3 transformers, there is total redundancy in the case of failure 

of one of the transformers. In fact, each busbar can be fed power by one or other 

of its ends. Otherwise, downgraded operation must be considered (with partial load 

shedding). This configuration requires special design of the protection plan in order 

to ensure discrimination in all of the fault circumstances. 

b Double-ended power supply: This configuration is implemented in cases where 

maximum availability is required. The principle involves having 2 independent power 

sources, e.g.: 

v 2 transformers supplied by different MV lines, 

v 1 transformer and 1 generator, 

v 1 transformer and 1 UPS. 

An automatic transfer switch (ATS) is used to avoid the sources being parallel 

connected. This configuration allows preventive and curative maintenance to be 

carried out on all of the electrical distribution system upstream without interrupting 

the power supply. 

b Configuration combinations: An installation can be made up of several subasssemblies 

with different configurations, according to requirements for the 

availability of the different types of load. E.g.: generator unit and UPS, choice by 

sectors (some sectors supplied by cables and others by busbar trunking). 


or G or UPS 

Fig. D24 : Double-ended configuration with automatic transfer switch 

1 

MLVS 

2 3 

Busbar 

MLVS 

Fig. D25 : Example of a configuration combination 

1: Single feeder, 2: Switchboard interconnection, 3: Double-ended 

G 

D23 


D24 



Characteristic to be 

considered 

Configuration 



characteristics is given in the following table: 

Radial Two-pole Sheddable load Interconnected 

switchboards 

Site topology Any Any Any 1 level 

5 to 25000m² 


Ring Double-ended 

1 level 

5 to 25000m² 

Location latitude Any Any Any Medium of high Medium or high Any 

Maintainability Minimal Standard Minimal Standard Standard Enhanced 

Power demand < 2500kVA Any Any ≥ 1250kVA > 2500kVA Any 

Load distribution Localized loads Localized loads Localized load Intermediate or 

uniforme distribution 

Interruptions sensitivity Long 

interruption 

acceptable 

Long 

interruption 

acceptable 

Sheddable Long 

interruption 

acceptable 

Any 

Uniform distribution Localized loads 

Long 

interruption 

acceptable 

Short or no 

interruption 

Disturbances sensitivity Low sensitivity High sensitivity Low sensitivity High sensitivity High sensitivity High sensitivity 

Other constraints / / / / / Double-ended 

loads


8 Choice of equipment 

The choice of equipment is step 3 in the design of an electrical installation. The aim 

of this step is to select equipment from the manufacturers’ catalogues. The choice of 

technological solutions results from the choice of architecture. 

List of equipment to consider: 

b MV/LV substation, 

b MV switchboards, 

b Transformers, 

b LV switchboards, 

b Busbar trunking, 

b UPS units, 

b Power factor correction and filtering equipment. 

Criteria to consider: 

b Atmosphere, environment, 

b Service index, 

b Offer availability per country, 

b Utilities requirements, 

b Previous architecture choices. 

The choice of equipment is basically linked to the offer availability in the country. This 

criterion takes into account the availability of certain ranges of equipment or local 

technical support. 

The detailed selection of equipment is out of the scope of this document. 


D25 


D26 



9 Recommendations for 

architecture optimization 

These recommendations are intended to guide the designer towards architecture 

upgrades which allow him to improve assessment criteria. 

9.1 On-site work 

To be compatible with the “special” or “critical” work-site time, it is recommended to 

limit uncertainties by applying the following recommendations: 

b Use of proven solutions and equipment that has been validated and tested by 

manufacturers (“functional” switchboard or “manufacturer” switchboard according to 

the application criticality), 

b Prefer the implementation of equipment for which there is a reliable distribution 

network and for which it is possible to have local support (supplier well established), 

b Prefer the use of factory-built equipment (MV/LV substation, busbar trunking), 

allowing the volume of operations on site to be limited, 

b Limit the variety of equipment implemented (e.g. the power of transformers), 

b Avoid mixing equipment from different manufacturers. 

9.2 Environmental impact 

The optimization of the environmental assessment of an installation will involve 

reducing: 

b Power losses at full load and no load during installation operation, 

b Overall, the mass of materials used to produce the installation. 

Taken separately and when looking at only one piece of equipment, these 2 

objectives may seem contradictory. However, when applied to whole installation, it 

is possible to design the architecture to contribute to both objectives. The optimal 

installation will therefore not be the sum of the optimal equipment taken separately, 

but the result of an optimization of the overall installation. 

Figure D26 gives an example of the contribution per equipment category to the 

weight and energy dissipation for a 3500 kVA installation spread over 10000m². 


and switchgear 

5 % 

LV cables 

and trunking 

75 % 

Transformers 

20 % 

10 % 

LV cables 

and trunking 

46 % 

Transformers 

44 % 

Total loss for equipment considered: 414 MWh Total mass of equipment considered: 18,900 kg 

Fig. D26 : Example of the spread of losses and the weight of material for each equipment category 


and switchgear 

Generally speaking, LV cables and trunking as well as the MV/LV transformers are 

the main contributors to operating losses and the weight of equipment used. 

Environmental optimization of the installation by the architecture will therefore 

involve: 

b reducing the length of LV circuits in the installation, 

b clustering LV circuits wherever possible to take advantage of the factor of 

simultaneity ks (see chapter A: General rules of electrical installation design, Chapter 

– Power loading of an installation, 4.3 “Estimation of actual maximum kVA demand”) 



Objectives Resources 

Reducing the length of LV 

circuits 

Solution Barycenter position 

N°1 

N°2 

Fig. D28 : Example of barycenter positioning 

MLVS area 

MLVS area 

Workshop 1 

Workshop 1 

Barycenter 

Barycenter 

line 1 

Workshop 1 




Placing MV/LV substations as close as possible to the barycenter 

of all of the LV loads to be supplied 

Clustering LV circuits When the simultaneity factor of a group of loads to be supplied 

is less than 0.7, the clustering of circuits allows us to limit the 

volume of conductors supplying power to these loads. 

In real terms this involves: 

b setting up sub-distribution switchboards as close as possible to 

the barycenter of the groups of loads if they are localized, 

b setting up busbar trunking systems as close as possible to the 

barycenter of the groups of loads if they are distributed. 

The search for an optimal solution may lead to consider several 

clustering scenarios. 

In all cases, reducing the distance between the barycenter of 

a group of loads and the equipment that supplies them power 

allows to reduce environmental impact. 

Fig. D27 : Environmental optimization : Objectives and Ressources. 

As an example figure D28 shows the impact of clustering circuits on reducing 

the distance between the barycenter of the loads of an installation and that of the 

sources considered (MLVS whose position is imposed). This example concerns a 

mineral water bottling plant for which: 

b the position of electrical equipment (MLVS) is imposed in the premises outside of 

the process area for reasons of accessibility and atmosphere constraints, 

b the installed power is around 4 MVA. 

In solution No.1, the circuits are distributed for each workshop. 

In solution No. 2, the circuits are distributed by process functions (production lines). 

Barycenter 

line 2 

Workshop 2 

Workshop 2 

Barycenter 

Workshop 2 

Barycenter 

line 3 

Workshop 3 

Workshop 3 

Barycenter 

Workshop 3 

Barycenter 

line 3 

Storage 

Storage 

D27 


D28 





Without changing the layout of electrical equipment, the second solution allows us 

to achieve gains of around 15% on the weight of LV cables to be installed (gain on 

lengths) and a better uniformity of transformer power. 

To supplement the optimizations carried out in terms of architecture, the following 

points also contribute to the optimization: 

b the setting up of LV power factor correction to limit losses in the transformers and 

LV circuits if this compensation is distributed, 

b the use of low loss transformers, 

b the use of aluminum LV busbar trunking when possible, since natural resources of 

this metal are greater. 

9.3 Preventive maintenance volume 

Recommendations for reducing the volume of preventive maintenance: 

b Use the same recommendations as for reducing the work site time, 

b Focus maintenance work on critical circuits, 

b Standardize the choice of equipment, 

b Use equipment designed for severe atmospheres (requires less maintenance). 

9.4 Electrical power availability 

Recommendations for improving the electrical power availability: 

b Reduce the number of feeders per switchboard, in order to limit the effects of a 

possible failure of a switchboard, 

b Distributing circuits according to availability requirements, 

b Using equipment that is in line with requirements (see Service Index, 4.2), 

b Follow the selection guides proposed for steps 1 & 2 (see Fig. D3 page D5). 

Recommendations to increase the level of availability: 

b Change from a radial single feeder configuration to a two-pole configuration, 

b Change from a two-pole configuration to a double-ended configuration, 

b Change from a double-ended configuration to a uninterruptible configuration with a 

UPS unit and a Static Transfer Switch 

b Increase the level of maintenance (reducing the MTTR, increasing the MTBF) 



10 Glossary 

Architecture: choice of a single-line diagram and technological solutions, from 

connection to the utility network through to load power supply circuits. 

Main MV/LV distribution: Level upstream of the architecture, from connection 

to the network utility through to LV distribution equipment on the site (MLVS – or 

equivalent). 

MLVS – Main Low Voltage Switchboard: Main switchboard downstream of the 

MV/LV transformer, starting point of power distribution circuits in the installation 

LV power distribution: intermediate level in the architecture, downstream of the 

main level through to the sub-distribution switchboards (spatial and functional 

distribution of electrical power in the circuits). 

LV terminal distribution: Downstream level of the architecture, downstream of the 

sub-distribution switchboards through to the loads. This level of distribution is not 

dealt with in this guide. 

Single-line diagram: general electrical schematic diagram to represent the main 

electrical equipment and their interconnection. 

MV substation, transformation substation: Enclosures grouping together MV 

equipment and/or MV/LV transformers. These enclosures can be shared or separate, 

according to the site layout, or the equipment technology. In certain countries, the 

MV substation is assimilated with the delivery substation. 

Technological solution: Resulting from the choice of technology for an installation 

sub-assembly, from among the different products and equipment proposed by the 

manufacturer. 

Characteristics: Technical or environmental data relative to the installation, enabling 

the best-suited architecture to be selected. 

Criteria: Parameters for assessing the installation, enabling selection of the 

architecture that is the best-suited to the needs of the customer. 


D29 


D30 



11 ID-Spec software 

ID-Spec is a new software which aims at helping the designer to be more productive 

in draft design phase and argue easily his design decisions. 

It supports the designer in selecting the relevant single line diagram patterns for main 

distribution and sub distribution and in adapting these patterns to his project. It also 

supports the designer in equipment technology and rating selection. Its generates 

automatically the corresponding design specification documentation including single 

line diagram and its argument, list and specification of the corresponding equipment. 



12 Example: electrical installation 

in a printworks 

12.1 Brief description 

Printing of personalized mailshots intended for mail order sales. 

12.2 Installation characteristics 

Characteristic Category 

Activity Mechanical 

Site topology single storey building, 

10000m² (8000m² dedicated to the process, 2000m² for 

ancillary areas) 

Layout latitude High 

Service reliability Standard 

Maintainability Standard 

Installation flexibility b No flexibility planned: 

v HVAC 

v Process utilities 

v Office power supply 

b Possible flexibility: 

v finishing, putting in envelopes 

v special machines, installed at a later date 

v rotary machines (uncertainty at the draft design stage) 

Power demand 3500kVA 

Load distribution Intermediate distribution 

Power interruptions sensitivity b Sheddable circuits: 

v offices (apart from PC power sockets) 

v air conditioning, office heating 

v social premises 

v maintenance premises 

b long interruptions acceptable: 

v printing machines 

v workshop HVAC (hygrometric control) 

v Finishing, envelope filling 

v Process utilities (compressor, recycling of cooled water) 

b No interruptions acceptable: 

v servers, office PCs 

Disturbance sensitivity b Average sensitivity: 

v motors, lighting 

b High sensitivity: 

v IT 

Disturbance capability Non disturbing 


No special precaution to be taken due to the connection to 

the EdF network (low level of disturbance) 

Other constraints b Building with lightning classification: lightning surge 

arresters installed 

b Power supply by overhead single feeder line 

12.3 Technological characteristics 

Criteria Category 

Atmosphere, environment b IP: standard (no dust, no water protection) 

b IK: standard (use of technical pits, dedicated premises) 

b °C: standard (temperature regulation) 

Service index 211 

Offer availability by country No problem (project carried out in France) 

Other criteria Nothing particular 

D31 


D32 





12.4 Architecture assessment criteria 

Criteria Category 

On-site work time Secondary 

Environmental impact Minimal: compliance with European standard regulations 

Preventive maintenance costs Standard 

Power supply availability Level I 

Step 1: Architecture fundamentals 

Choice Main criteria Solution 

Connection to upstream 

network 


Isolated site single branch circuit 

MV Circuits Layout + criticality single feeder 

Number of transformers Power > 2500kVA 2 x 2000kVA 

Number and distribution of 

substations 

Surface area and power 

distribution 

MV Generator Site activity No 

MV 

LV 

MV 

LV 

2 possible solutions: 1 

substation or 2 substations 

b if 1 substations: NO link 

between MLVS 

b if 2 substations: 

interconnected switchboards 

MLVS 1 MLVS 2 MLVS 1 MLVS 2 

Fig. D29 : Two possible single-line diagrams 

MV 

LV 

Trunking 

MV 

LV




Step 2: Architecture details 

“1 substation” solution 


Layout Atmospheric constraint Dedicated premises 

Centralized or decentralized 

layout 

Presence of back-up 

generator 


Uniform loads, distributed 

power, scalability possibilities 

Non-uniform loads, direct link 

from MLVS 

Criticality ≤ low 

Network availability: standard 

b Decentralized with busbar 

trunking: 

v finishing sector, envelope 

filling 

b Centralized with cables: 

v special machines, 

rotary machines, HVAC, 

process utilities, offices 

(2 switchboards), office air 

conditioning, social premises, 

maintenance 

No back-up generator 

Presence of UPS Criticality UPS unit for servers and office 

PCs 

LV circuit configuration 2 transformers, possible 

partial redundancy 

MV 

MLVS 1 MLVS 2 

ASI 

Sheddable Offices 

Fig. D30 : Detailed single-line diagram (1 substation) 

LV 

HVAC 

MV 

LV 

b Two-pole, variant 2 ½ MLVS 

+ NO link (reduction of the Isc 

by MLVS, no redundancy 

b process (≤ weak) 

b sheddable circuit for noncritical 

loads 

Trunking 

Machines 

D33 


D34 





12.5 Choice of technological solutions: 


MV/LV substation Atmosphere, environment indoor (dedicated premises) 

MV switchboard Offer availability by country SM6 (installation produced in 

France) 

Transformers Atmosphere, environment cast resin transfo (avoids 

constraints related to oil) 

LV switchboard Atmosphere, IS MLVS: Prisma + P 

Sub-distribution: Prisma + 

Busbar trunking Installed power to be 

supplied 

UPS units Installed power to be 

supplied, back-up time 

Power factor correction Installed power, presence of 

harmonics 

“2 substation” solution 

Ditto apart from: 

LV circuit: 2 remote MLVS connected via busbar trunking 

MV 

LV 

Fig. D31 : Detailed single-line diagram (2 substations) 


Canalis KS 

Galaxy PW 

MLVS 1 MLVS 2 

Sheddable 

ASI 

Offices 

LV, standard, automatic 

(Average Q, ease of 

installation) 

Trunking Trunking 

HVAC 

MV 

LV 

Machines

2 

3 

Chapter E 


Contents 

Earthing schemes E2 

1.1 Earthing connections E2 

1.2 Definition of standardised earthing schemes E3 

1.3 Characteristics of TT, TN and IT systems E6 

1.4 Selection criteria for the TT, TN and IT systems E8 

1.5 Choice of earthing method - implementation E10 

1.6 Installation and measurements of earth electrodes E11 

The installation system E 5 

2.1 Distribution boards E15 

2.2 Cables and busways E18 

External influences (IEC 60364-5-5 ) E25 

3.1 Definition and reference standards E25 

3.2 Classification E25 

3.3 List of external influences E25 

3.4 Protection provided for enclosed equipment: codes IP and IK E28 


E 



E2 

E - Distribution in low-voltage installations 

In a building, the connection of all metal parts 

of the building and all exposed conductive parts 

of electrical equipment to an earth electrode 

prevents the appearance of dangerously high 

voltages between any two simultaneously 

accessible metal parts 

4 

Extraneous 

conductive 

parts 

4 

Heating 

Water 

Branched 

protective 

conductors 

to individual 

consumers 

Gas 

5 

1 

5 

5 

Fig. E1 : An example of a block of flats in which the main 

earthing terminal (6) provides the main equipotential connection; 

the removable link (7) allows an earth-electrode-resistance 

check 

2 

7 

3 

3 

3 

6 

Main 

protective 

conductor 

Earthing schemes 

. Earthing connections 

Definitions 

National and international standards (IEC 60364) clearly define the various elements 

of earthing connections. The following terms are commonly used in industry and in 

the literature. Bracketed numbers refer to Figure E : 

b Earth electrode (1): A conductor or group of conductors in intimate contact with, 

and providing an electrical connection with Earth (cf details in section 1.6 of Chapter E.) 

b Earth: The conductive mass of the Earth, whose electric potential at any point is 

conventionally taken as zero 

b Electrically independent earth electrodes: Earth electrodes located at such a 

distance from one another that the maximum current likely to flow through one of 

them does not significantly affect the potential of the other(s) 

b Earth electrode resistance: The contact resistance of an earth electrode with the 

Earth 

b Earthing conductor (2): A protective conductor connecting the main earthing 

terminal (6) of an installation to an earth electrode (1) or to other means of earthing 

(e.g. TN systems); 

b Exposed-conductive-part: A conductive part of equipment which can be touched 

and which is not a live part, but which may become live under fault conditions 

b Protective conductor (3): A conductor used for some measures of protection against 

electric shock and intended for connecting together any of the following parts: 

v Exposed-conductive-parts 

v Extraneous-conductive-parts 

v The main earthing terminal 

v Earth electrode(s) 

v The earthed point of the source or an artificial neutral 

b Extraneous-conductive-part: A conductive part liable to introduce a potential, 

generally earth potential, and not forming part of the electrical installation (4). 

For example: 

v Non-insulated floors or walls, metal framework of buildings 

v Metal conduits and pipework (not part of the electrical installation) for water, gas, 

heating, compressed-air, etc. and metal materials associated with them 

b Bonding conductor (5): A protective conductor providing equipotential bonding 

b Main earthing terminal (6): The terminal or bar provided for the connection of 

protective conductors, including equipotential bonding conductors, and conductors 

for functional earthing, if any, to the means of earthing. 

Connections 

The main equipotential bonding system 

The bonding is carried out by protective conductors and the aim is to ensure that, 

in the event of an incoming extraneous conductor (such as a gas pipe, etc.) being 

raised to some potential due to a fault external to the building, no difference of 

potential can occur between extraneous-conductive-parts within the installation. 

The bonding must be effected as close as possible to the point(s) of entry into the 

building, and be connected to the main earthing terminal (6). 

However, connections to earth of metallic sheaths of communications cables require 

the authorisation of the owners of the cables. 

Supplementary equipotential connections 

These connections are intended to connect all exposed-conductive-parts and all 

extraneous-conductive-parts simultaneously accessible, when correct conditions 

for protection have not been met, i.e. the original bonding conductors present an 

unacceptably high resistance. 

Connection of exposed-conductive-parts to the earth electrode(s) 

The connection is made by protective conductors with the object of providing a lowresistance 

path for fault currents flowing to earth. 



The different earthing schemes (often referred 

to as the type of power system or system 

earthing arrangements) described characterise 

the method of earthing the installation 

downstream of the secondary winding of a 

MV/LV transformer and the means used for 

earthing the exposed conductive-parts of the 

LV installation supplied from it 


Components (see Fig. E2) 

Effective connection of all accessible metal fixtures and all exposed-conductive-parts 

of electrical appliances and equipment, is essential for effective protection against 

electric shocks. 

Component parts to consider: 

as exposed-conductive-parts as extraneous-conductive-parts 

Cableways Elements used in building construction 

b Conduits b Metal or reinforced concrete (RC): 

b Impregnated-paper-insulated lead-covered v Steel-framed structure 

cable, armoured or unarmoured v Reinforcement rods 

b Mineral insulated metal-sheathed cable v Prefabricated RC panels 

(pyrotenax, etc.) b Surface finishes: 

Switchgear 

b cradle of withdrawable switchgear 

Appliances 

b Exposed metal parts of class 1 insulated 

appliances 

v Floors and walls in reinforced concrete 

without further surface treatment 

v 

Tiled surface 

b 

Metallic covering: 

v 

Metallic wall covering 

Non-electrical elements Building services elements other than electrical 

b metallic fittings associated with cableways b Metal pipes, conduits, trunking, etc. for gas, 

(cable trays, cable ladders, etc.) water and heating systems, etc. 

b Metal objects: b Related metal components (furnaces, tanks, 

v Close to aerial conductors or to busbars reservoirs, radiators) 

v In contact with electrical equipment. b Metallic fittings in wash rooms, bathrooms, 

toilets, etc. 

b Metallised papers 

Component parts not to be considered: 

as exposed-conductive-parts as extraneous-conductive-parts 

Diverse service channels, ducts, etc. b Wooden-block floors 

b Conduits made of insulating material b Rubber-covered or linoleum-covered floors 

b Mouldings in wood or other insulating b Dry plaster-block partition 

material b Brick walls 

b Conductors and cables without metallic sheaths b Carpets and wall-to-wall carpeting 

Switchgear 

b Enclosures made of insulating material 

Appliances 

b All appliances having class II insulation 

regardless of the type of exterior envelope 

Fig. E2 : List of exposed-conductive-parts and extraneous-conductive-parts 

.2 Definition of standardised earthing schemes 

The choice of these methods governs the measures necessary for protection against 

indirect-contact hazards. 

The earthing system qualifies three originally independent choices made by the 

designer of an electrical distribution system or installation: 

b The type of connection of the electrical system (that is generally of the neutral 

conductor) and of the exposed parts to earth electrode(s) 

b A separate protective conductor or protective conductor and neutral conductor 

being a single conductor 

b The use of earth fault protection of overcurrent protective switchgear which clear 

only relatively high fault currents or the use of additional relays able to detect and 

clear small insulation fault currents to earth 

In practice, these choices have been grouped and standardised as explained below. 

Each of these choices provides standardised earthing systems with three 

advantages and drawbacks: 

b Connection of the exposed conductive parts of the equipment and of the neutral 

conductor to the PE conductor results in equipotentiality and lower overvoltages but 

increases earth fault currents 

b A separate protective conductor is costly even if it has a small cross-sectional area 

but it is much more unlikely to be polluted by voltage drops and harmonics, etc. than a 

neutral conductor is. Leakage currents are also avoided in extraneous conductive parts 

b Installation of residual current protective relays or insulation monitoring devices are 

much more sensitive and permits in many circumstances to clear faults before heavy 

damage occurs (motors, fires, electrocution). The protection offered is in addition 

independent with respect to changes in an existing installation 


E3 



E4 


Rn 

Neutral 

Earth 

Fig. E3 : TT System 

Rn 

Neutral 

Earth 

Fig. E4 : TN-C system 

Rn 

Fig. E5 : TN-S system 

Fig. E6 : TN-C-S system 

Exposed conductive parts 

Earth 


Neutral 

PEN 

L1 

L2 

L3 

N 

PE 

L1 

L2 

L3 

PEN 

L1 

L2 

L3 

N 

PE 

TT system (earthed neutral) (see Fig. E3) 

One point at the supply source is connected directly to earth. All exposed- and 

extraneous-conductive-parts are connected to a separate earth electrode at the 

installation. This electrode may or may not be electrically independent of the source 

electrode. The two zones of influence may overlap without affecting the operation of 

protective devices. 

TN systems (exposed conductive parts connected to the 

neutral) 

The source is earthed as for the TT system (above). In the installation, all exposed- 

and extraneous-conductive-parts are connected to the neutral conductor. The several 

versions of TN systems are shown below. 

TN-C system (see Fig. E4) 

The neutral conductor is also used as a protective conductor and is referred to as 

a PEN (Protective Earth and Neutral) conductor. This system is not permitted for 

conductors of less than 10 mm 2 or for portable equipment. 

The TN-C system requires an effective equipotential environment within the 

installation with dispersed earth electrodes spaced as regularly as possible since 

the PEN conductor is both the neutral conductor and at the same time carries phase 

unbalance currents as well as 3 rd order harmonic currents (and their multiples). 

The PEN conductor must therefore be connected to a number of earth electrodes in 

the installation. 

Caution: In the TN-C system, the “protective conductor” function has priority over 

the “neutral function”. In particular, a PEN conductor must always be connected to 

the earthing terminal of a load and a jumper is used to connect this terminal to the 

neutral terminal. 

TN-S system (see Fig. E5) 

The TN-S system (5 wires) is obligatory for circuits with cross-sectional areas less 

than 10 mm 2 for portable equipment. 

The protective conductor and the neutral conductor are separate. On underground 

cable systems where lead-sheathed cables exist, the protective conductor is 

generally the lead sheath. The use of separate PE and N conductors (5 wires) 

is obligatory for circuits with cross-sectional areas less than 10 mm 2 for portable 

equipment. 

TN-C-S system (see Fig. E6 below and Fig. E7 next page) 

The TN-C and TN-S systems can be used in the same installation. In the TN-C-S 

system, the TN-C (4 wires) system must never be used downstream of the TN-S 

(5 wires) system, since any accidental interruption in the neutral on the upstream 

part would lead to an interruption in the protective conductor in the downstream part 

and therefore a danger. 

PE 



5 x 50 mm 2 

Bad Bad 

L1 

L2 

L3 

N 

PE 

16 mm2 6 mm2 16 mm2 16 mm2 

PEN 

TN-C scheme not permitted 

downstream of TN-S scheme


Neutral 

Isolated or 

impedance-earthed 

Fig. E8 : IT system (isolated neutral) 

MV/LV 

C1 

Fig. E9 : IT system (isolated neutral) 


Earth 

C2 

MV/LV 

Zct 

C3 

R1 

R2 

L1 

L2 

L3 

N 

PE 

R3 


Fig. E7 : Connection of the PEN conductor in the TN-C system 

IT system (isolated or impedance-earthed neutral) 

IT system (isolated neutral) 

No intentional connection is made between the neutral point of the supply source 

and earth (see Fig. E8). 

Exposed- and extraneous-conductive-parts of the installation are connected to an 

earth electrode. 

In practice all circuits have a leakage impedance to earth, since no insulation 

is perfect. In parallel with this (distributed) resistive leakage path, there is the 

distributed capacitive current path, the two paths together constituting the normal 

leakage impedance to earth (see Fig. E9). 

Example (see Fig. E 0) 

In a LV 3-phase 3-wire system, 1 km of cable will have a leakage impedance due to 

C1, C2, C3 and R1, R2 and R3 equivalent to a neutral earth impedance Zct of 3,000 

to 4,000 Ω, without counting the filtering capacitances of electronic devices. 

IT system (impedance-earthed neutral) 

An impedance Zs (in the order of 1,000 to 2,000 Ω) is connected permanently 

between the neutral point of the transformer LV winding and earth (see Fig. E ). 

All exposed- and extraneous-conductive-parts are connected to an earth electrode. 

The reasons for this form of power-source earthing are to fix the potential of a small 

network with respect to earth (Zs is small compared to the leakage impedance) and to 

reduce the level of overvoltages, such as transmitted surges from the MV windings, 

static charges, etc. with respect to earth. It has, however, the effect of slightly 

increasing the first-fault current level. 


4 x 95 mm 2 

Correct Incorrect Correct Incorrect 

PEN connected to the neutral 

terminal is prohibited 

Fig. E10 : Impedance equivalent to leakage impedances in an 

IT system Fig. E11 : IT system (impedance-earthed neutral) 

L1 

L2 

L3 

PEN 

16 mm2 10 mm2 6 mm2 6 mm2 PEN 

PEN 

N 

MV/LV 

Zs 

S < 10 mm 2 

TNC prohibited 

E5 



E6 


The TT system: 

b Technique for the protection of persons: the 

exposed conductive parts are earthed and 

residual current devices (RCDs) are used 

b Operating technique: interruption for the first 

insulation fault 

The TN system: 

b Technique for the protection of persons: 

v Interconnection and earthing of exposed 

conductive parts and the neutral are mandatory 

v Interruption for the first fault using overcurrent 

protection (circuit-breakers or fuses) 

b Operating technique: interruption for the first 

insulation fault 


.3 Characteristics of TT, TN and IT systems 

TT system (see Fig. E 2) 

Fig. E12 : TT system 

Note: If the exposed conductive parts are earthed at a number of points, an RCD 

must be installed for each set of circuits connected to a given earth electrode. 

Main characteristics 

b Simplest solution to design and install. Used in installations supplied directly by the 

public LV distribution network. 

b Does not require continuous monitoring during operation (a periodic check on the 

RCDs may be necessary). 

b Protection is ensured by special devices, the residual current devices (RCD), which 

also prevent the risk of fire when they are set to y 500 mA. 

b Each insulation fault results in an interruption in the supply of power, however the 

outage is limited to the faulty circuit by installing the RCDs in series (selective RCDs) 

or in parallel (circuit selection). 

b Loads or parts of the installation which, during normal operation, cause high leakage 

currents, require special measures to avoid nuisance tripping, i.e. supply the loads 

with a separation transformer or use specific RCDs (see section 5.1 in chapter F). 

TN system (see Fig. E 3 and Fig. E 4 ) 

Fig. E13 : TN-C system 

Fig. E14 : TN-S system 


PEN 

N 

PE


IT system: 

b Protection technique: 

v Interconnection and earthing of exposed 

conductive parts 

v Indication of the first fault by an insulation 

monitoring device (IMD) 

v Interruption for the second fault using 

overcurrent protection (circuit-breakers or fuses) 

b Operating technique: 

v Monitoring of the first insulation fault 

v Mandatory location and clearing of the fault 

v Interruption for two simultaneous insulation 

faults 



b Generally speaking, the TN system: 

v requires the installation of earth electrodes at regular intervals throughout the 

installation 

v Requires that the initial check on effective tripping for the first insulation fault 

be carried out by calculations during the design stage, followed by mandatory 

measurements to confirm tripping during commissioning 

v Requires that any modification or extension be designed and carried out by a 

qualified electrician 

v May result, in the case of insulation faults, in greater damage to the windings of 

rotating machines 

v May, on premises with a risk of fire, represent a greater danger due to the higher 

fault currents 

b In addition, the TN-C system: 

v At first glance, would appear to be less expensive (elimination of a device pole and 

of a conductor) 

v Requires the use of fixed and rigid conductors 

v Is forbidden in certain cases: 

- Premises with a risk of fire 

- For computer equipment (presence of harmonic currents in the neutral) 

b In addition, the TN-S system: 

v May be used even with flexible conductors and small conduits 

v Due to the separation of the neutral and the protection conductor, provides a clean 

PE (computer systems and premises with special risks) 

IT system (see Fig. E 5) 

Cardew 

Fig. E15 : IT system 

IMD 


b Solution offering the best continuity of service during operation 

b Indication of the first insulation fault, followed by mandatory location and clearing, 

ensures systematic prevention of supply outages 

b Generally used in installations supplied by a private MV/LV or LV/LV transformer 

b Requires maintenance personnel for monitoring and operation 

b Requires a high level of insulation in the network (implies breaking up the network 

if it is very large and the use of circuit-separation transformers to supply loads with 

high leakage currents) 

b The check on effective tripping for two simultaneous faults must be carried out by 

calculations during the design stage, followed by mandatory measurements during 

commissioning on each group of interconnected exposed conductive parts 

b Protection of the neutral conductor must be ensured as indicated in section 7.2 of 

Chapter G 


E7 



E8 


Selection does not depend on safety criteria. 

The three systems are equivalent in terms 

of protection of persons if all installation and 

operating rules are correctly followed. 

The selection criteria for the best system(s) 

depend on the regulatory requirements, 

the required continuity of service, operating 

conditions and the types of network and loads. 

Fig. E16 : Comparison of system earthing arrangements 


.4 Selection criteria for the TT, TN and IT systems 

In terms of the protection of persons, the three system earthing arrangements 

(SEA) are equivalent if all installation and operating rules are correctly followed. 

Consequently, selection does not depend on safety criteria. 

It is by combining all requirements in terms of regulations, continuity of service, 

operating conditions and the types of network and loads that it is possible to 

determine the best system(s) (see Fig. E 6). 

Selection is determined by the following factors: 

b Above all, the applicable regulations which in some cases impose certain types of 

SEA 

b Secondly, the decision of the owner if supply is via a private MV/LV transformer 

(MV subscription) or the owner has a private energy source (or a separate-winding 

transformer) 

If the owner effectively has a choice, the decision on the SEA is taken following 

discussions with the network designer (design office, contractor) 

The discussions must cover: 

b First of all, the operating requirements (the required level of continuity of service) 

and the operating conditions (maintenance ensured by electrical personnel or not, 

in-house personnel or outsourced, etc.) 

b Secondly, the particular characteristics of the network and the loads 

(see Fig. E 7 next page) 

TT TN-S TN-C IT IT2 Comments 


Fault current - - - - - + - - Only the IT system offers virtually negligible first-fault currents 

Fault voltage - - - + - In the IT system, the touch voltage is very low for the first fault, 

but is considerable for the second 

Touch voltage 

Protection 

+/- - - - + - In the TT system, the touch voltage is very low if system is 

equipotential, otherwise it is high 

Protection of persons against indirect contact + + + + + All SEAs (system earthing arrangement) are equivalent, 

if the rules are followed 

Protection of persons with emergency + - - + - Systems where protection is ensured by RCDs are not sensitive 

generating sets to a change in the internal impedance of the source 

Protection against fire (with an RCD) + + Not + + All SEAs in which RCDs can be used are equivalent. 

allowed The TN-C system is forbidden on premises where there is a risk of fire 

Overvoltages 

Continuous overvoltage + + + - + A phase-to-earth overvoltage is continuous in the IT system 

if there is a first insulation fault 

Transient overvoltage + - - + - Systems with high fault currents may cause transient overvoltages 

Overvoltage if transformer breakdown - + + + + In the TT system, there is a voltage imbalance between 

(primary/secondary) 

Electromagnetic compatibility 

the different earth electrodes. The other systems are interconnected 

to a single earth electrode 

Immunity to nearby lightning strikes - + + + + In the TT system, there may be voltage imbalances between 

the earth electrodes. In the TT system, there is a significant current 

loop between the two separate earth electrodes 

Immunity to lightning strikes on MV lines - - - - - All SEAs are equivalent when a MV line takes a direct lightning strike 

Continuous emission of an + + - + + Connection of the PEN to the metal structures of the building is 

electromagnetic field conducive to the continuous generation of electromagnetic fields 

Transient non-equipotentiality of the PE 

Continuity of service 

+ - - + - The PE is no longer equipotential if there is a high fault current 

Interruption for first fault - - - + + Only the IT system avoids tripping for the first insulation fault 

Voltage dip during insulation fault + - - + - The TN-S, TNC and IT (2nd Installation 

fault) systems generate high fault 

currents which may cause phase voltage dips 

Special devices - + + - - The TT system requires the use of RCDs. The IT system requires 

the use of IMDs 

Number of earth electrodes - + + -/+ -/+ The TT system requires two distinct earth electrodes. The IT system 

offers a choice between one or two earth electrodes 

Number of cables 

Maintenance 

- - + - - Only the TN-C system offers, in certain cases, a reduction in 

the number of cables 

Cost of repairs - - - - - - - - The cost of repairs depends on the damage caused by 

the amplitude of the fault currents 

Installation damage + - - ++ - Systems causing high fault currents require a check on 

the installation after clearing the fault 



Type of network Advised Possible Not advised 

Very large network with high-quality earth electrodes TT, TN, IT (1) 

for exposed conductive parts (10 Ω max.) or mixed 

Very large network with low-quality earth electrodes TN TN-S IT (1) 

for exposed conductive parts (> 30 Ω) TN-C 

Disturbed area (storms) TN TT IT (2) 

(e.g. television or radio transmitter) 

Network with high leakage currents (> 500 mA) TN (4) IT (4) 

Network with outdoor overhead lines TT 

TT (3) (4) 

(5) TN (5) (6) IT (6) 

Emergency standby generator set IT TT TN (7) 

Type of loads 

Loads sensitive to high fault currents (motors, etc.) IT TT TN (8) 

Loads with a low insulation level (electric furnaces, TN (9) TT (9) IT 

welding machines, heating elements, immersion heaters, 

equipment in large kitchens) 

Numerous phase-neutral single-phase loads TT (10) IT (10) 

(mobile, semi-fixed, portable) TN-S TN-C (10) 

Loads with sizeable risks (hoists, conveyers, etc.) TN (11) TT (11) IT (11) 

Numerous auxiliaries (machine tools) TN-S TN-C TT (12) 

(1) When the SEA is not imposed by regulations, it is selected according to the level of operating characteristics (continuity of service that is 

mandatory for safety reasons or desired to enhance productivity, etc.) 

Whatever the SEA, the probability of an insulation failure increases with the length of the network. It may be a good idea to break up the 

network, which facilitates fault location and makes it possible to implement the system advised above for each type of application. 

(2) The risk of flashover on the surge limiter turns the isolated neutral into an earthed neutral. These risks are high for regions with frequent 

thunder storms or installations supplied by overhead lines. If the IT system is selected to ensure a higher level of continuity of service, the 

system designer must precisely calculate the tripping conditions for a second fault. 

(3) Risk of RCD nuisance tripping. 

(4) Whatever the SEA, the ideal solution is to isolate the disturbing section if it can be easily identified. 

(5) Risks of phase-to-earth faults affecting equipotentiality. 

(6) Insulation is uncertain due to humidity and conducting dust. 

(7) The TN system is not advised due to the risk of damage to the generator in the case of an internal fault. What is more, when generator sets 

supply safety equipment, the system must not trip for the first fault. 

(8) The phase-to-earth current may be several times higher than In, with the risk of damaging or accelerating the ageing of motor windings, or of 

destroying magnetic circuits. 

(9) To combine continuity of service and safety, it is necessary and highly advised, whatever the SEA, to separate these loads from the rest of 

the installation (transformers with local neutral connection). 

(10) When load equipment quality is not a design priority, there is a risk that the insulation resistance will fall rapidly. The TT system with RCDs 

is the best means to avoid problems. 

(11) The mobility of this type of load causes frequent faults (sliding contact for bonding of exposed conductive parts) that must be countered. 

Whatever the SEA, it is advised to supply these circuits using transformers with a local neutral connection. 

(12) Requires the use of transformers with a local TN system to avoid operating risks and nuisance tripping at the first fault (TT) or a double fault (IT). 

(12 bis) With a double break in the control circuit. 

(13) Excessive limitation of the phase-to-neutral current due to the high value of the zero-phase impedance (at least 4 to 5 times the direct 

impedance). This system must be replaced by a star-delta arrangement. 

(14) The high fault currents make the TN system dangerous. The TN-C system is forbidden. 

(15) Whatever the system, the RCD must be set to Δn y 500 mA. 

(16) An installation supplied with LV energy must use the TT system. Maintaining this SEA means the least amount of modifications on the 

existing network (no cables to be run, no protection devices to be modified). 

(17) Possible without highly competent maintenance personnel. 

(18) This type of installation requires particular attention in maintaining safety. The absence of preventive measures in the TN system means 

highly qualified personnel are required to ensure safety over time. 

(19) The risks of breaks in conductors (supply, protection) may cause the loss of equipotentiality for exposed conductive parts. A TT system or a 

TN-S system with 30 mA RCDs is advised and is often mandatory. The IT system may be used in very specific cases. 

(20) This solution avoids nuisance tripping for unexpected earth leakage. 

Fig. E17 : Influence of networks and loads on the selection of system earthing arrangements 



IT (12 bis) 

Miscellaneous 

Supply via star-star connected power transformer (13) TT IT IT (13) 

without neutral with neutral 

Premises with risk of fire IT (15) TN-S (15) TN-C (14) 

Increase in power level of LV utility subscription, TT (16) 

requiring a private substation 

Installation with frequent modifications TT (17) TN (18) 

IT (18) 

Installation where the continuity of earth circuits is uncertain TT (19) TN-S TN-C 

(work sites, old installations) IT (19) 

Electronic equipment (computers, PLCs) TN-S TT TN-C 

Machine control-monitoring network, PLC sensors and actuators IT (20) LV 

MV/LV 

TN-S, TT 

TT (15) 

E9 


E 0 




.5 Choice of earthing method - implementation 

After consulting applicable regulations, Figures E16 and E17 can be used as an aid 

in deciding on divisions and possible galvanic isolation of appropriate sections of a 

proposed installation. 

Division of source 

This technique concerns the use of several transformers instead of employing one 

high-rated unit. In this way, a load that is a source of network disturbances (large 

motors, furnaces, etc.) can be supplied by its own transformer. 

The quality and continuity of supply to the whole installation are thereby improved. 

The cost of switchgear is reduced (short-circuit current level is lower). 

The cost-effectiveness of separate transformers must be determined on a case by 

case basis. 

Network islands 

The creation of galvanically-separated “islands” by means of LV/LV transformers 

makes it possible to optimise the choice of earthing methods to meet specific 

requirements (see Fig. E 8 and Fig. E 9 ). 

Fig. E18 : TN-S island within an IT system 

TN-S system 

Fig. E19 : IT islands within a TN-S system 

Conclusion 


MV/LV 

IT system 

MV/LV TN-S 

LV/LV 

Hospital 

LV/LV 

IMD 

TN-S system 

LV/LV 

IMD IMD 

IT IT 

Operating room 

The optimisation of the performance of the whole installation governs the choice of 

earthing system. 

Including: 

b Initial investments, and 

b Future operational expenditures, hard to assess, that can arise from insufficient 

reliability, quality of equipment, safety, continuity of service, etc. 

An ideal structure would comprise normal power supply sources, local reserve 

power supply sources (see section 1.4 of Chapter E) and the appropriate earthing 

arrangements.


A very effective method of obtaining a lowresistance 

earth connection is to bury a 

conductor in the form of a closed loop in the 

soil at the bottom of the excavation for building 

foundations. 

The resistance R of such an electrode (in 

homogeneous soil) is given (approximately) in 

ohms by: R = 

L 

2 � where 

L L = = length of the buried conductor in metres in metres 

ρ = soil resistivity in ohm-metres 

For n rods: R = 

n L 

1 � 

where 

Fig. E20 : Conductor buried below the level of the foundations, 

i.e. not in the concrete 


.6 Installation and measurements of earth 

electrodes 

The quality of an earth electrode (resistance as low as possible) depends essentially 

on two factors: 

b Installation method 

b Type of soil 

Installation methods 

Three common types of installation will be discussed: 

Buried ring (see Fig. E20) 

This solution is strongly recommended, particularly in the case of a new building. 

The electrode should be buried around the perimeter of the excavation made for 

the foundations. It is important that the bare conductor be in intimate contact with 

the soil (and not placed in the gravel or aggregate hard-core, often forming a base 

for concrete). At least four (widely-spaced) vertically arranged conductors from the 

electrode should be provided for the installation connections and, where possible, 

any reinforcing rods in concrete work should be connected to the electrode. 

The conductor forming the earth electrode, particularly when it is laid in an 

excavation for foundations, must be in the earth, at least 50 cm below the hard-core 

or aggregate base for the concrete foundation. Neither the electrode nor the vertical 

rising conductors to the ground floor, should ever be in contact with the foundation 

concrete. 

For existing buildings, the electrode conductor should be buried around the outside 

wall of the premises to a depth of at least 1 metre. As a general rule, all vertical 

connections from an electrode to above-ground level should be insulated for the 

nominal LV voltage (600-1,000 V). 

The conductors may be: 

b Copper: Bare cable (u 25 mm 2 ) or multiple-strip (u 25 mm 2 and u 2 mm thick) 

b Aluminium with lead jacket: Cable (u 35 mm 2 ) 

b Galvanised-steel cable: Bare cable (u 95 mm 2 ) or multiple-strip (u 100 mm 2 

and u 3 mm thick) 

The approximate resistance R of the electrode in ohms: 

R = 

L 

2 � where 

L = length where of the buried conductor in metres 

L = length of conductor in metres 

ρ = resistivity of the soil in ohm-metres (see “Influence of the type of soil” next page) 

Earthing rods (see Fig. E2 ) 

Vertically driven earthing rods are often used for existing buildings, and for improving 

(i.e. reducing the resistance of) existing earth electrodes. 

The rods may be: 

b Copper or (more commonly) copper-clad steel. The latter are generally 1 or 

2 metres long and provided with screwed ends and sockets in order to reach 

considerable depths, if necessary (for instance, the water-table level in areas of high 

soil resistivity) 

b Galvanised (see note (1) next page) steel pipe u 25 mm diameter or 

rod u 15 mm diameter, u 2 metres long in each case. 

Fig. E21 : Earthing rods 

L u 3 m 


Rods connected in parallel 

E 


E 2 



For a vertical plate electrode: R = 

L 

0.8 � 

Measurements on earth electrodes in similar 

soils are useful to determine the resistivity 

value to be applied for the design of an earthelectrode 

system 

Fig. E22 : Vertical plate 

2 mm thickness (Cu) 

(1) Where galvanised conducting materials are used for earth 

electrodes, sacrificial cathodic protection anodes may be 

necessary to avoid rapid corrosion of the electrodes where 

the soil is aggressive. Specially prepared magnesium anodes 

(in a porous sack filled with a suitable “soil”) are available for 

direct connection to the electrodes. In such circumstances, a 

specialist should be consulted 

It is often necessary to use more than one rod, in which case the spacing between 

them should exceed the depth to which they are driven, by a factor of 2 to 3. 

The total resistance (in homogeneous soil) is then equal to the resistance of one rod, 

divided by the number of rods in question. The approximate resistance R obtained is: 

R = 

n L 

1 � 

if the distance separating the rods > 4L 

where 


where 

L = the length of the rod in metres 

ρ = resistivity of the soil in ohm-metres (see “Influence of the type of soil” below) 

n = the number of rods 

Vertical plates (see Fig. E22) 

Rectangular plates, each side of which must be u 0.5 metres, are commonly used as 

earth electrodes, being buried in a vertical plane such that the centre of the plate is 

at least 1 metre below the surface of the soil. 

The plates may be: 

b Copper of 2 mm thickness 

b Galvanised (1) steel of 3 mm thickness 

The resistance R in ohms is given (approximately), by: 

R = 

L 

0.8 � 

L = the perimeter of the plate in metres 

ρ = resistivity of the soil in ohm-metres (see “Influence of the type of soil” below) 

Influence of the type of soil 

Type of soil Mean value of resistivity 

in Ωm 

Swampy soil, bogs 1 - 30 

Silt alluvium 20 - 100 

Humus, leaf mould 10 - 150 

Peat, turf 5 - 100 

Soft clay 50 

Marl and compacted clay 100 - 200 

Jurassic marl 30 - 40 

Clayey sand 50 - 500 

Siliceous sand 200 - 300 

Stoney ground 1,500 - 3,000 

Grass-covered-stoney sub-soil 300 - 500 

Chalky soil 100 - 300 

Limestone 1,000 - 5,000 

Fissured limestone 500 - 1,000 

Schist, shale 50 - 300 

Mica schist 800 

Granite and sandstone 1,500 - 10,000 

Modified granite and sandstone 100 - 600 

Fig. E23 : Resistivity (Ωm) for different types of soil 

Type of soil Average value of resistivity 

in Ωm 

Fertile soil, compacted damp fill 50 

Arid soil, gravel, uncompacted non-uniform fill 500 

Stoney soil, bare, dry sand, fissured rocks 3,000 

Fig. E24 : Average resistivity (Ωm) values for approximate earth-elect 




Measurement and constancy of the resistance between an 

earth electrode and the earth 

The resistance of the electrode/earth interface rarely remains constant 

Among the principal factors affecting this resistance are the following: 

b Humidity of the soil 

The seasonal changes in the moisture content of the soil can be significant at depths 

of up to 2 meters. 

At a depth of 1 metre the resistivity and therefore the resistance can vary by a ratio 

of 1 to 3 between a wet winter and a dry summer in temperate regions 

b Frost 

Frozen earth can increase the resistivity of the soil by several orders of magnitude. 

This is one reason for recommending the installation of deep electrodes, in particular 

in cold climates 

b Ageing 

The materials used for electrodes will generally deteriorate to some extent for 

various reasons, for example: 

v Chemical reactions (in acidic or alkaline soils) 

v Galvanic: due to stray DC currents in the earth, for example from electric railways, 

etc. or due to dissimilar metals forming primary cells. Different soils acting on 

sections of the same conductor can also form cathodic and anodic areas with 

consequent loss of surface metal from the latter areas. Unfortunately, the most 

favourable conditions for low earth-electrode resistance (i.e. low soil resistivity) are 

also those in which galvanic currents can most easily flow. 

b Oxidation 

Brazed and welded joints and connections are the points most sensitive to oxidation. 

Thorough cleaning of a newly made joint or connection and wrapping with a suitable 

greased-tape binding is a commonly used preventive measure. 

Measurement of the earth-electrode resistance 

There must always be one or more removable links to isolate an earth electrode so 

that it can be tested. 

There must always be removable links which allow the earth electrode to be isolated 

from the installation, so that periodic tests of the earthing resistance can be carried 

out. To make such tests, two auxiliary electrodes are required, each consisting of a 

vertically driven rod. 

b Ammeter method (see Fig. E25) 

Fig. E25 : Measurement of the resistance to earth of the earth electrode of an installation by 

means of an ammeter 

U 

A = RT + Rt 

= Tt1 

1 

i1 

U 

B = Rt + R t t 

t = 1 2 

1 2 

i2 

U 

C = Rt + R t T 

T = 2 

2 

i3 


T 

A 

t2 

When the source voltage U is constant (adjusted to be the same value for each test) 

then: 

U � 1 1 1� 

RT 

= � + � 

2 � i i i 

� 

1 3 2 � 

U 

t1 

E 3 


E 4 




In order to avoid errors due to stray earth currents (galvanic -DC- or leakage currents 

from power and communication networks and so on) the test current should be 

AC, but at a different frequency to that of the power system or any of its harmonics. 

Instruments using hand-driven generators to make these measurements usually 

produce an AC voltage at a frequency of between 85 Hz and 135 Hz. 

The distances between the electrodes are not critical and may be in different 

directions from the electrode being tested, according to site conditions. A number of 

tests at different spacings and directions are generally made to cross-check the test 

results. 

b Use of a direct-reading earthing-resistance ohmmeter 

These instruments use a hand-driven or electronic-type AC generator, together 

with two auxiliary electrodes, the spacing of which must be such that the zone of 

influence of the electrode being tested should not overlap that of the test electrode (C). 

The test electrode (C) furthest from the electrode (X) under test, passes a current 

through the earth and the electrode under test, while the second test electrode (P) 

picks up a voltage. This voltage, measured between (X) and (P), is due to the test 

current and is a measure of the contact resistance (of the electrode under test) with 

earth. It is clear that the distance (X) to (P) must be carefully chosen to give accurate 

results. If the distance (X) to (C) is increased, however, the zones of resistance of 

electrodes (X) and (C) become more remote, one from the other, and the curve of 

potential (voltage) becomes more nearly horizontal about the point (O). 

In practical tests, therefore, the distance (X) to (C) is increased until readings taken 

with electrode (P) at three different points, i.e. at (P) and at approximately 5 metres 

on either side of (P), give similar values. The distance (X) to (P) is generally about 

0.68 of the distance (X) to (C). 

voltage-drop due 

to the resistance 

of electrode (X) 

voltage-drop due 

to the resistance 

of electrode (C) 

Fig. E26 : Measurement of the resistance to the mass of earth of electrode (X) using an earthelectrode-testing 

ohmmeter. 


G 

V 

I 

X P 

C 

a) the principle of measurement is based on assumed homogeneous soil conditions. Where the 

zones of influence of electrodes C and X overlap, the location of test electrode P is difficult to 

determine for satisfactory results. 

X P 

b) showing the effect on the potential gradient when (X) and (C) are widely spaced. The location 

of test electrode P is not critical and can be easily determined. 

VG 

O 

O 

C 

VG


Distribution switchboards, including the main 

LV switchboard (MLVS), are critical to the 

dependability of an electrical installation. 

They must comply with well-defined standards 

governing the design and construction of 

LV switchgear assemblies 

The load requirements dictate the type of 

distribution switchboard to be installed 

2 The installation system 

2.1 Distribution switchboards 

A distribution switchboard is the point at which an incoming-power supply divides 

into separate circuits, each of which is controlled and protected by the fuses or 

switchgear of the switchboard. A distribution switchboard is divided into a number 

of functional units, each comprising all the electrical and mechanical elements 

that contribute to the fulfilment of a given function. It represents a key link in the 

dependability chain. 

Consequently, the type of distribution switchboard must be perfectly adapted to its 

application. Its design and construction must comply with applicable standards and 

working practises. 

The distribution switchboard enclosure provides dual protection: 

b Protection of switchgear, indicating instruments, relays, fusegear, etc. against 

mechanical impacts, vibrations and other external influences likely to interfere with 

operational integrity (EMI, dust, moisture, vermin, etc.) 

b The protection of human life against the possibility of direct and indirect electric 

shock (see degree of protection IP and the IK index in section 3.3 of Chapter E). 

Types of distribution switchboards 

Distribution switchboards may differ according to the kind of application and the 

design principle adopted (notably in the arrangement of the busbars). 

Distribution switchboards according to specific applications 

The principal types of distribution switchboards are: 

b The main LV switchboard - MLVS - (see Fig. E27a) 

b Motor control centres - MCC - (see Fig. E27b) 

b Sub-distribution switchboards (see Fig. E28) 

b Final distribution switchboards (see Fig. E29) 

Distribution switchboards for specific applications (e.g. heating, lifts, industrial 

processes) can be located: 

b Adjacent to the main LV switchboard, or 

b Near the application concerned 

Sub-distribution and final distribution switchboards are generally distributed 

throughout the site. 

a b 

Fig. E27 : [a] A main LV switchboard - MLVS - (Prisma Plus P) with incoming circuits in the form 

of busways - [b] A LV motor control centre - MCC - (Okken) 

a b c 

Fig. E28 : A sub-distribution switchboard (Prisma Plus G) Fig. E29 : Final distribution switchboards [a] Prisma Plus G Pack; [b] Kaedra; [c] mini-Pragma 


E15 


E16 



A distinction is made between: 

b Traditional distribution switchboards in which 

switchgear and fusegear, etc. are fixed to a 

chassis at the rear of an enclosure 

b Functional distribution switchboards for 

specific applications, based on modular and 

standardised design. 

Fig. E30 : Assembly of a final distribution switchboard with 

fixed functional units (Prisma Plus G) 

Fig. E31 : Distribution switchboard with disconnectable 

functional units 

Fig. E32 : Distribution switchboard with withdrawable functional 

units in drawers 


Two technologies of distribution switchboards 

Traditional distribution switchboards 

Switchgear and fusegear, etc. are normally located on a chassis at the rear of the 

enclosure. Indications and control devices (meters, lamps, pushbuttons, etc.) are 

mounted on the front face of the switchboard. 

The placement of the components within the enclosure requires very careful study, 

taking into account the dimensions of each item, the connections to be made to it, 

and the clearances necessary to ensure safe and trouble-free operation. . 

Functional distribution switchboards 

Generally dedicated to specific applications, these distribution switchboards are 

made up of functional modules that include switchgear devices together with 

standardised accessories for mounting and connections, ensuring a high level of 

reliability and a great capacity for last-minute and future changes. 

b Many advantages 

The use of functional distribution switchboards has spread to all levels of LV 

electrical distribution, from the main LV switchboard (MLVS) to final distribution 

switchboards, due to their many advantages: 

v System modularity that makes it possible to integrate numerous functions in a 

single distribution switchboard, including protection, control, technical management 

and monitoring of electrical installations. Modular design also enhances distribution 

switchboard maintenance, operation and upgrades 

v Distribution switchboard design is fast because it simply involves adding functional 

modules 

v Prefabricated components can be mounted faster 

v Finally, these distribution switchboards are subjected to type tests that ensure a 

high degree of dependability. 

The new Prisma Plus G and P ranges of functional distribution switchboards from 

Schneider Electric cover needs up to 3200 A and offer: 

v Flexibility and ease in building distribution switchboards 

v Certification of a distribution switchboard complying with standard IEC 60439 and 

the assurance of servicing under safe conditions 

v Time savings at all stages, from design to installation, operation and modifications 

or upgrades 

v Easy adaptation, for example to meet the specific work habits and standards in 

different countries 

Figures E27a, E28 and E29 show examples of functional distribution switchboards 

ranging for all power ratings and figure E27b shows a high-power industrial functional 

distribution switchboard. 

b Main types of functional units 

Three basic technologies are used in functional distribution switchboards. 

v Fixed functional units (see Fig. E30) 

These units cannot be isolated from the supply so that any intervention for 

maintenance, modifications and so on, requires the shutdown of the entire 

distribution switchboard. Plug-in or withdrawable devices can however be used to 

minimise shutdown times and improve the availability of the rest of the installation. 

v Disconnectable functional units (see Fig. E31) 

Each functional unit is mounted on a removable mounting plate and provided with a 

means of isolation on the upstream side (busbars) and disconnecting facilities on the 

downstream (outgoing circuit) side. The complete unit can therefore be removed for 

servicing, without requiring a general shutdown. 

v Drawer-type withdrawable functional units (see Fig. E32) 

The switchgear and associated accessories for a complete function are mounted on 

a drawer-type horizontally withdrawable chassis. The function is generally complex 

and often concerns motor control. 

Isolation is possible on both the upstream and downstream sides by the complete 

withdrawal of the drawer, allowing fast replacement of a faulty unit without deenergising 

the rest of the distribution switchboard. 



Compliance with applicable standards is 

essential in order to ensure an adequate 

degree of dependability 

Three elements of standard IEC 60439-1 

contribute significantly to dependability: 

b Clear definition of functional units 

b Forms of separation between adjacent 

functional units in accordance with user 

requirements 

b Clearly defined routine tests and type tests 

Standards 

Different standards 

Certain types of distribution switchboards (in particular, functional distribution 

switchboards) must comply with specific standards according to the application or 

environment involved. 

The reference international standard is IEC 60439-1 type-tested and partially typetested 

assemblies 

Standard IEC 60439-1 

b Categories of assemblies 

Standard IEC 60439-1 distinguishes between two categories of assemblies: 

v Type-tested LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies (TTA), which do not diverge 

significantly from an established type or system for which conformity is ensured by 

the type tests provided in the standard 

v Partially type-tested LV switchgear and controlgear assemblies (PTTA), which may 

contain non-type-tested arrangements provided that the latter are derived from typetested 

arrangements 

When implemented in compliance with professional work standards and 

manufacturer instructions by qualified personnel, they offer the same level of safety 

and quality. 

b Functional units 

The same standard defines functional units: 

v Part of an assembly comprising all the electrical and mechanical elements that 

contribute to the fulfilment of the same function 

v The distribution switchboard includes an incoming functional unit and one or more 

functional units for outgoing circuits, depending on the operating requirements of the 

installation 

What is more, distribution switchboard technologies use functional units that may be 

fixed, disconnectable or withdrawable (see section 3.1 of Chapter E). 

b Forms (see Fig. E33) 

Separation of functional units within the assembly is provided by forms that are 

specified for different types of operation. 

The various forms are numbered from 1 to 4 with variations labelled “a” or “b”. Each 

step up (from 1 to 4) is cumulative, i.e. a form with a higher number includes the 

characteristics of forms with lower numbers. The standard distinguishes: 

v Form 1: No separation 

v Form 2: Separation of busbars from the functional units 

v Form 3: Separation of busbars from the functional units and separation of all 

functional units, one from another, except at their output terminals 

v Form 4: As for Form 3, but including separation of the outgoing terminals of all 

functional units, one from another 

The decision on which form to implement results from an agreement between the 

manufacturer and the user. 

The Prima Plus functional range offers solutions for forms 1, 2b, 3b, 4a, 4b. 

Form 1 Form 2a Form 2b Form 3a 

Form 3b Form 4a Form 4b 

Fig. E33 : Representation of different forms of LV functional distribution switchboards 



Busbar 

Separation 

E17 


E18 



Total accessibility of electrical information and 

intelligent distribution switchboards are now a 

reality 

Two types of distribution are possible: 

b By insulated wires and cables 

b By busbar trunking (busways) 


b Type tests and routine tests 

They ensure compliance of each distribution switchboard with the standard. The 

availability of test documents certified by independent organisations is a guarantee 

for users. 

Remote monitoring and control of the electrical installation 

Remote monitoring and control are no longer limited to large installations. 

These functions are increasingly used and provide considerable cost savings. 

The main potential advantages are: 

b Reductions in energy bills 

b Reductions in structural costs to maintain the installation in running order 

b Better use of the investment, notably concerning optimisation of the installation life 

cycle 

b Greater satisfaction for energy users (in a building or in process industries) due to 

improved power availability and/or quality 

The above possibilities are all the more an option given the current deregulation of 

the electrical-energy sector. 

Modbus is increasingly used as the open standard for communication within the 

distribution switchboard and between the distribution switchboard and customer 

power monitoring and control applications. Modbus exists in two forms, twisted pair 

(RS 485) and Ethernet-TCP/IP (IEEE 802.3). 

The www.modbus.org site presents all bus specifications and constantly updates the 

list of products and companies using the open industrial standard. 

The use of web technologies has largely contributed to wider use by drastically 

reducing the cost of accessing these functions through the use of an interface that is 

now universal (web pages) and a degree of openness and upgradeability that simply 

did not exist just a few years ago. 

2.2 Cables and busway trunking 

Distribution by insulated conductors and cables 

Definitions 

b Conductor 

A conductor comprises a single metallic core with or without an insulating envelope. 

b Cable 

A cable is made up of a number of conductors, electrically separated, but joined 

mechanically, generally enclosed in a protective flexible sheath. 

b Cableway 

The term cableway refers to conductors and/or cables together with the means of 

support and protection, etc. for example : cable trays, ladders, ducts, trenches, and 

so on… are all “cableways”. 

Conductor marking 

Conductor identification must always respect the following three rules: 

b Rule 1 

The double colour green and yellow is strictly reserved for the PE and PEN 

protection conductors. 

b Rule 2 

v When a circuit comprises a neutral conductor, it must be light blue or marked “1” for 

cables with more than five conductors 

v When a circuit does not have a neutral conductor, the light blue conductor may be 

used as a phase conductor if it is part of a cable with more than one conductor 

b Rule 3 

Phase conductors may be any colour except: 

v Green and yellow 

v Green 

v Yellow 

v Light blue (see rule 2) 



Conductors in a cable are identified either by their colour or by numbers (see Fig. E34). 

Number of Circuit Fixed cableways 

conductors Insulated conductors Rigid and flexible multi- 

in circuit conductor cables 

Ph Ph Pn N PE Ph Ph Ph N PE 

1 Protection or earth G/Y 

2 Single-phase between phases b b BL LB 

Single-phase between phase and neutral b LB BL LB 

Single-phase between phase and neutral b G/Y BL G/Y 

+ protection conductor 

3 Three-phase without neutral b b b BL B LB 

2 phases + neutral b b LB BL B LB 

2 phases + protection conductor b b G/Y BL LB G/Y 

Single-phase between phase and neutral b LB G/Y BL LB G/Y 

+ protection conductor 

4 Three-phase with neutral b b b LB BL B BL LB 

Three-phase with neutral + protection conductor b b b G/Y BL B LB G/Y 

2 phases + neutral + protection conductor b b LB G/Y BL B LB G/Y 

Three-phase with PEN conductor b b b G/Y BL B LB G/Y 

5 Three-phase + neutral + protection conductor b b b LB G/Y BL B BL LB G/Y 

> 5 Protection conductor: G/Y - Other conductors: BL: with numbering 

The number “1” is reserved for the neutral conductor if it exists 

G/Y: Green and yellow BL: Black b : As indicated in rule 3 LB: Light blue B: Brown 

Fig. E34 : Conductor identification according to the type of circuit 

N 

Black conductor 

Light blue conductor 

Fig. E35 : Conductor identification on a circuit-breaker with a 

phase and a neutral 


Note: If the circuit includes a protection conductor and if the available cable does not 

have a green and yellow conductor, the protection conductor may be: 

b A separate green and yellow conductor 

b The blue conductor if the circuit does not have a neutral conductor 

b A black conductor if the circuit has a neutral conductor 

In the last two cases, the conductor used must be marked by green and yellow 

bands or markings at the ends and on all visible lengths of the conductor. 

Equipment power cords are marked similar to multi-conductor cables (see Fig. E35). 

Distribution and installation methods (see Fig. E36) 

Distribution takes place via cableways that carry single insulated conductors or 

cables and include a fixing system and mechanical protection. 

Floor subdistribution 

swichboard 


Main LV switchboard 

(MLVS) 

Fig. E36 : Radial distribution using cables in a hotel 

Heating, etc. 

Final 

distribution 

swichboard 

Building utilities sub-distribution swichboard 

E19 


E20 



Busways, also referred to as busbar trunking 

systems, stand out for their ease of installation, 

flexibility and number of possible connection 

points 


Busbar trunking (busways) 

Busbar trunking is intended to distribute power (from 20 A to 5000 A) and lighting 

(in this application, the busbar trunking may play a dual role of supplying electrical 

power and physically holding the lights). 

Busbar trunking system components 

A busbar trunking system comprises a set of conductors protected by an enclosure 

(see Fig. E37). Used for the transmission and distribution of electrical power, busbar 

trunking systems have all the necessary features for fitting: connectors, straights, 

angles, fixings, etc. The tap-off points placed at regular intervals make power 

available at every point in the installation. 

Straight trunking Tap-off points to 

distribute current 

Power Unit Range of clip-on tap-off units to 

connect a load (e.g.: a machine) to 

the busbar trunking 

Fig. E37 : Busbar trunking system design for distribution of currents from 25 to 4000 A. 

The various types of busbar trunking: 

Busbar trunking systems are present at every level in electrical distribution: from 

the link between the transformer and the low voltage switch switchboard (MLVS) 

to the distribution of power sockets and lighting to offices, or power distribution to 

workshops. 

Fig. E38 : Radial distribution using busways 

We talk about a distributed network architecture. 


Fixing system for ceilings, walls or 

raised floor, etc. 

Angle 

End piece



There are essentially three categories of busways. 

b Transformer to MLVS busbar trunking 

Installation of the busway may be considered as permanent and will most likely never 

be modified. There are no tap-off points. 

Frequently used for short runs, it is almost always used for ratings above 1,600 / 

2,000 A, i.e. when the use of parallel cables makes installation impossible. Busways 

are also used between the MLVS and downstream distribution switchboards. 

The characteristics of main-distribution busways authorize operational currents from 

1,000 to 5,000 A and short-circuit withstands up to 150 kA. 

b Sub-distribution busbar trunking with low or high tap-off densities 

Downstream of main-distribution busbar trunking , two types of applications must be 

supplied: 

v Mid-sized premises (industrial workshops with injection presses and metalwork 

machines or large supermarkets with heavy loads). The short-circuit and current 

levels can be fairly high (respectively 20 to 70 kA and 100 to 1,000 A) 

v Small sites (workshops with machine-tools, textile factories with small machines, 

supermarkets with small loads). The short-circuit and current levels are lower 

(respectively 10 to 40 kA and 40 to 400 A) 

Sub-distribution using busbar trunking meets user needs in terms of: 

v Modifications and upgrades given the high number of tap-off points 

v Dependability and continuity of service because tap-off units can be connected 

under energized conditions in complete safety 

The sub-distribution concept is also valid for vertical distribution in the form of 100 to 

5,000 A risers in tall buildings. 

b Lighting distribution busbar trunking 

Lighting circuits can be distributed using two types of busbar trunking according to 

whether the lighting fixtures are suspended from the busbar trunking or not. 

v busbar trunking designed for the suspension of lighting fixtures 

These busways supply and support light fixtures (industrial reflectors, discharge 

lamps, etc.). They are used in industrial buildings, supermarkets, department stores 

and warehouses. The busbar trunkings are very rigid and are designed for one or 

two 25 A or 40 A circuits. They have tap-off outlets every 0.5 to 1 m. 

v busbar trunking not designed for the suspension of lighting fixtures 

Similar to prefabricated cable systems, these busways are used to supply all types 

of lighting fixtures secured to the building structure. They are used in commercial 

buildings (offices, shops, restaurants, hotels, etc.), especially in false ceilings. The 

busbar trunking is flexible and designed for one 20 A circuit. It has tap-off outlets 

every 1.2 m to 3 m. 

Busbar trunking systems are suited to the requirements of a large number of 

buildings. 

b Industrial buildings: garages, workshops, farm buildings, logistic centers, etc. 

b Commercial areas: stores, shopping malls, supermarkets, hotels, etc. 

b Tertiary buildings: offices, schools, hospitals, sports rooms, cruise liners, etc. 

Standards 

Busbar trunking systems must meet all rules stated in IEC 439-2. 

This defines the manufacturing arrangements to be complied with in the design 

of busbar trunking systems (e.g.: temperature rise characteristics, short-circuit 

withstand, mechanical strength, etc.) as well as test methods to check them. 

Standard IEC 439-2 defines 13 compulsory type-tests on configurations or system 

components.. 

By assembling the system components on the site according to the assembly 

instructions, the contractor benefits from conformity with the standard. 

The advantages of busbar trunking systems 

Flexibility 

b Easy to change configuration (on-site modification to change production line 

configuration or extend production areas). 

b Reusing components (components are kept intact): when an installation is subject 

to major modifications, the busbar trunking is easy to dismantle and reuse. 

b Power availability throughout the installation (possibility of having a tap-off point 

every meter). 

b Wide choice of tap-off units. 


E21 


E22 



Simplicity 

b Design can be carried out independently from the distribution and layout of current 

consumers. 

b Performances are independent of implementation: the use of cables requires a lot 

of derating coefficients. 

b Clear distribution layout 

b Reduction of fitting time: the trunking system allows fitting times to be reduced by 

up to 50% compared with a traditional cable installation. 

b Manufacturer’s guarantee. 

b Controlled execution times: the trunking system concept guarantees that there are 

no unexpected surprises when fitting. The fitting time is clearly known in advance 

and a quick solution can be provided to any problems on site with this adaptable and 

scalable equipment. 

b Easy to implement: modular components that are easy to handle, simple and quick 

to connect. 

Dependability 

b Reliability guaranteed by being factory-built 

b Fool-proof units 

b Sequential assembly of straight components and tap-off units making it impossible 

to make any mistakes 

Continuity of service 

b The large number of tap-off points makes it easy to supply power to any new 

current consumer. Connecting and disconnecting is quick and can be carried out in 

complete safety even when energized. These two operations (adding or modifying) 

take place without having to stop operations. 

b Quick and easy fault location since current consumers are near to the line 

b Maintenance is non existent or greatly reduced 

Major contribution to sustainable development 

b Busbar trunking systems allow circuits to be combined. Compared with a 

traditional cable distribution system, consumption of copper raw materials and 

insulators is divided by 3 due to the busbar trunking distributed network concept 

(see Fig. E39). 

Example: 

30 m of Canalis KS 250A equipped with 10 25 A, four-pole feeders 

Distribution type Conductors 

Insulators Consumption 

Branched 

ΣI x k s 

ks: clustering coefficient= 0.6 

Centralized 

ΣI x k s 

ks: clustering coefficient= 0.6 

I 1 I 2 I 3 I 4 I 5 I 6 I 7 

R R R R R R R 

I 1 I 2 I 3 I 4 I 5 I 6 I 7 

R R R R R R R 

Fig. E39 : Example: 30 m of Canalis KS 250A equipped with 10 25 A, four-pole feeders 


Alu: 128 mm² 

Copper equivalent: 86 mm² 

Copper: 250 mm² 

b Reusable device and all of its components are fully recyclable. 

b Does not contain PVC and does not generate toxic gases or waste. 

b Reduction of risks due to exposure to electromagnetic fields. 

New functional features for Canalis 

Busbar trunking systems are getting even better. Among the new features we can 

mention: 

b Increased performance with a IP55 protection index and new ratings of 160 A 

through to 1000 A (Ks). 

b New lighting offers with pre-cabled lights and new light ducts. 

b New fixing accessories. Quick fixing system, cable ducts, shared support with 

“VDI” (voice, data, images) circuits. 


4 kg 

12 kg 

1 000 Joules 

1 600 Joules



Busbar trunking systems are perfectly integrated with the environment: 

b white color to enhance the working environment, naturally integrated in a range of 

electrical distribution products. 

b conformity with European regulations on reducing hazardous materials (RoHS). 

Examples of Canalis busbar trunking systems 

Fig. E40 : Flexible busbar trunking not capable of supporting light fittings : Canalis KDP (20 A) 

Fig. E41 : Rigid busbar trunking able to support light fittings : Canalis KBA or KBB (25 and 40 A) 

Fig. E42 : Lighting duct : Canalis KBX (25 A) 

Fig. E43 : A busway for medium power distribution : Canalis KN (40 up to 160 A) 


E23 


E24 




Fig. E44 : A busway for medium power distribution : Canalis KS (100 up to 1000 A) 

Fig. E45 : A busway for high power distribution : Canalis KT (800 up to 1000 A) 



External influences shall be taken into account 

when choosing: 

b The appropriate measures to ensure the 

safety of persons (in particular in special 

locations or electrical installations) 

b The characteristics of electrical equipment, 

such as degree of protection (IP), mechanical 

withstand (IK), etc. 

If several external influences appear at the 

same time, they can have independent or 

mutual effects and the degree of protection must 

be chosen accordingly 

3 External influences 

(IEC 60364-5-51) 

3.1 Definition and reference standards 

Every electrical installation occupies an environment that presents a variable degree 

of risk: 

b For people 

b For the equipment constituting the installation 

Consequently, environmental conditions influence the definition and choice of 

appropriate installation equipment and the choice of protective measures for the 

safety of persons. 

The environmental conditions are referred to collectively as “external influences”. 

Many national standards concerned with external influences include a classification 

scheme which is based on, or which closely resembles, that of international standard 

IEC 60364-5-51. 

3.2 Classification 

Each condition of external influence is designated by a code comprising a group of 

two capital letters and a number as follows: 

First letter (A, B or C) 

The first letter relates to the general category of external influence : 

b A = environment 

b B = utilisation 

b C = construction of buildings 

Second letter 

The second letter relates to the nature of the external influence. 

Number 

The number relates to the class within each external influence. 

Additional letter (optional) 

Used only if the effective protection of persons is greater than that indicated by the 

first IP digit. 

When only the protection of persons is to be specified, the two digits of the IP code 

are replaced by the X’s. 

Example: IP XXB. 

Example 

For example the code AC2 signifies: 

A = environment 

AC = environment-altitude 

AC2 = environment-altitude > 2,000 m 

3.3 List of external influences 

Figure E46 below is from IEC 60364-5-51, which should be referred to if further 

details are required. 

Code External influences Characteristics required for equipment 

A - Environment 

AA Ambient temperature (°C) 

Low High Specially designed equipment or appropriate arrangements 

AA1 - 60 °C + 5 °C 

AA2 - 40 °C + 5 °C 

AA3 - 25 °C + 5 °C 

AA4 - 5° C + 40 °C Normal (special precautions in certain cases) 

AA5 + 5 °C + 40 °C Normal 

AA6 + 5 °C + 60 °C Specially designed equipment or appropriate arrangements 

AA7 - 25 °C + 55 °C 

AA8 - 50 °C + 40 °C 

Fig. E46 : List of external influences (taken from Appendix A of IEC 60364-5-51) (continued on next page) 


E25 


E26 




(IEC 60364-5-51) 



AB Atmospheric humidity 

Air temperature °C Relative humidity % Absolute humidity g/m 3 

Low High Low High Low High 

AB1 - 60 °C + 5 °C 3 100 0.003 7 Appropriate arrangements shall be made 

AB2 - 40 °C + 5 °C 10 100 0.1 7 

AB3 - 25 °C + 5 °C 10 100 0.5 7 

AB4 - 5° C + 40 °C 5 95 1 29 Normal 

AB5 + 5 °C + 40 °C 5 85 1 25 Normal 

AB6 + 5 °C + 60 °C 10 100 1 35 Appropriate arrangements shall be made 

AB7 - 25 °C + 55 °C 10 100 0.5 29 

AB8 - 50 °C + 40 °C 15 100 0.04 36 

AC Altitude 

AC1 y 2000 m Normal 

AC2 > 2000 m May necessitate precaution (derating factors) 

AD Presence of water 

AD1 Negligible Outdoor or non-weather protected locations IPX0 

AD2 Free-falling drops IPX1 or IPX2 

AD3 Sprays IPX3 

AD4 Splashes IPX4 

AD5 Jets Locations where hose water is used regularly IPX5 

AD6 Waves Seashore locations (piers, beaches, quays…) IPX6 

AD7 Immersion Water 150 mm above the highest point and IPX7 

equipment not more than 1m below the surface 

AD8 Submersion Equipment is permanently and totally covered IPX8 

AE Presence of foreign solid bodies 

Smallest dimension Example 

AE1 Negligible IP0X 

AE2 Small objects 2.5 mm Tools IP3X 

AE3 Very small objects 1 mm Wire IP4X 

AE4 Light dust IP5X if dust penetration is not harmful to functioning 

AE5 Moderate dust IP6X if dust should not penetrate 

AE6 Heavy dust IP6X 

AF Presence of corrosive or polluting substances 

AF1 Negligible Normal 

AF2 Atmospheric According to the nature of the substance 

AF3 Intermittent, accidental Protection against corrosion 

AF4 Continuous Equipment specially designed 

AG Mechanical stress impact 

AG1 Low severity Normal 

AG2 Medium severity Standard where applicable or reinforced material 

AG3 High severity Reinforced protection 

AH Vibrations 

AH1 Low severity Household or similar Normal 

AH2 Medium severity Usual industrial conditions Specially designed equipment or special arrangements 

AH3 High severity Severe industrial conditions 

AJ Other mechanical stresses 

AK Presence of flora and/or mould growth 

AH1 No hazard Normal 

AH2 Hazard 

AL Presence of fauna 

AH1 No hazard Normal 

AH2 Hazard 

AM Electromagnetic, electrostatic or ionising influences / Low frequency electromagnetic phenomena / Harmonics 

AM1 Harmonics, interharmonics Refer to applicable IEC standards 

AM2 Signalling voltage 

AM3 Voltage amplitude variations 

AM4 Voltage unbalance 

AM5 Power frequency variations 

AM6 Induced low-frequency voltages 

AM7 Direct current in a.c. networks 

AM8 Radiated magnetic fields 

AM9 Electric field 

AM21 Induced oscillatory voltages or currents 

Fig. E46 : List of external influences (taken from Appendix A of IEC 60364-5-51) (continued on next page) 



Fig. E46 : List of external influences (taken from Appendix A of IEC 60364-5-51) (concluded) 


(IEC 60364-5-51) 



AM22 Conducted unidirectional transients of the nanosecond time scale Refer to applicable IEC standards 

AM23 Conducted unidirectional transients of the microsecond to the millisecond 

time scale 

AM24 Conducted oscillatory transients 

AM25 Radiated high frequency phenomena 

AM31 Electrostatic discharges 

AM41 Ionisation 

AN Solar radiation 

AN1 Low Normal 

AN2 Medium 

AN3 High 

AP Seismic effect 

AP1 Negligible Normal 

AP2 Low severity 

AP3 Medium severity 

AP4 High severity 

AQ Lightning 

AQ1 Negligible Normal 

AQ2 Indirect exposure 

AQ3 Direct exposure 

AR Movement of air 

AQ1 Low Normal 

AQ2 Medium 

AQ3 High 

AS Wind 

AQ1 Low Normal 

AQ2 Medium 

AQ3 High 

B - Utilization 

BA Capability of persons 

BA1 Ordinary Normal 

BA2 Children 

BA3 Handicapped 

BA4 Instructed 

BA5 Skilled 

BB Electrical resistance of human body 

BC Contact of persons with earth potential 

BC1 None Class of equipment according to IEC61140 

BC2 Low 

BC3 Frequent 

BC4 Continuous 

BD Condition of evacuation in case of emergency 

BD1 Low density / easy exit Normal 

BD2 Low density / difficult exit 

BD3 High density / easy exit 

BD4 High density / difficult exit 

BE Nature of processed or stored materials 

BE1 No significant risks Normal 

BE2 Fire risks 

BE3 Explosion risks 

BE4 Contamination risks 

C - Construction of building 

CA Construction materials 

CA1 Non combustible Normal 

CA2 Combustible 

CB Building design 

CB1 Negligible risks Normal 

CB2 Propagation of fire 

CB3 Movement 

CB4 lexible or unstable 


E27 


E28 



Code letters 

(International Protection) 

First characteristic numeral 

(numerals 0 to 6, or letter X) 

Second characteristic numeral 

(numerals 0 to 6, or letter X) 

Additional letter (optional) 

(letters A, B, C, D) 

Supplementary letter (optional) 

(letters H, M, S, W) 

Fig. E47 : IP Code arrangement 

IP 2 3 C H 

Where a characteristic numeral is not required to be specified, 

it shall be replaced by the letter "X" ("XX" if both numerals 

are omitted). Additional letters and/or supplementary letters 

may be omitted without replacement. 


(IEC 60364-5-51) 

3.4 Protection provided for enclosed equipment: 

codes IP and IK 

IP code definition (see Fig. E47) 

The degree of protection provided by an enclosure is indicated in the IP code, 

recommended in IEC 60529. 

Protection is afforded against the following external influences: 

b Penetration by solid bodies 

b Protection of persons against access to live parts 

b Protection against the ingress of dust 

b Protection against the ingress of liquids 

Note: the IP code applies to electrical equipment for voltages up to and including 

72.5 kV. 

Elements of the IP Code and their meanings 

A brief description of the IP Code elements is given in the following chart 

(see Fig. E48). 

Element Numerals 

or letters 

Code letters 

First 


numeral 

Second 


numeral 

0 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 


IP 

Additional 

letter 

(optional) A 

B 

C 

D 

Supplementary 

letter 

(optional) 

0 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

H 

M 

S 

W 

Fig. E48 : Elements of the IP Code 

Meaning for the protection 

of equipment 

Against ingress of solid foreign 

objects 

(non-protected) 

u 50 mm diameter 

u 12.5 mm diameter 



Dust-protected 

Dust-tight 

Against ingress of water with 

harmful effects 


Vertically dripping 

Dripping (15° tilted) 

Spraying 

Splashing 

Jetting 

Powerful jetting 

Temporary immersion 

Continuous immersion 

Supplementary information specific to: 

High-voltage apparatus 

Motion during water test 

Stationary during water test 

Weather conditions 

Meaning for the 

protection of persons 

Against access to 

hazardous parts with 


Back of hand 

Finger 

Tool 

Wire 

Wire 

Wire 

Against access to 

hazardous parts with 

back of hand 

Finger 

Tool 

Wire



(IEC 60364-5-51) 

IK Code definition 

Standard IEC 62262 defines an IK code that characterises the aptitude of equipment 

to resist mechanical impacts on all sides (see Fig. E49). 


IK code Impact energy AG code 

(in Joules) 

00 0 

01 y 0.14 

02 y 0.20 AG1 

03 y 0.35 

04 y 0.50 

05 y 0.70 

06 y 1 

07 y 2 AG2 

08 y 5 AG3 

09 y 10 

10 y 20 AG4 

Fig. E49 : Elements of the IK Code 

IP and IK code specifications for distribution switchboards 

The degrees of protection IP and IK of an enclosure must be specified as a function 

of the different external influences defined by standard IEC 60364-5-51, in particular: 

b Presence of solid bodies (code AE) 

b Presence of water (code AD) 

b Mechanical stresses (no code) 

b Capability of persons (code BA) 

b … 

Prisma Plus switchboards are designed for indoor installation. 

Unless the rules, standards and regulations of a specific country stipulate otherwise, 

Schneider Electric recommends the following IP and IK values (see Fig. E50 and 

Fig. E51 ) 

IP recommendations 

IP codes according to conditions 

Normal without risk of vertically falling water Technical rooms 30 

Normal with risk of vertically falling water Hallways 31 

Very severe with risk of splashing water Workshops 54/55 

from all directions 

Fig. E50 : IP recommendations 

IK recommendations 

IK codes according to conditions 

No risk of major impact Technical rooms 07 

Significant risk of major impact that could Hallways 08 (enclosure 

damage devices with door) 

Maximum risk of impact that could damage Workshops 10 

the enclosure 

Fig. E51 : IK recommendations 

E29 


2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

Chapter F 


Contents 

General F2 

1.1 Electric shock F2 

1.2 Protection against electric shock F3 

1.3 Direct and indirect contact F3 

Protection against direct contact F4 

2.1 Measures of protection against direct contact F4 

2.2 Additional measure of protection against direct contact F6 

Protection against indirect contact F6 

3.1 Measures of protection: two levels F6 

3.2 Automatic disconnection for TT system F7 

3.3 Automatic disconnection for TN systems F8 

3.4 Automatic disconnection on a second fault in an IT system F10 

3.5 Measures of protection against direct or indirect contact 

without automatic disconnection of supply F13 

Protection of goods in case of insulation fault F 7 

4.1 Measures of protection against fire risk with RCDs F17 

4.2 Ground Fault Protection (GFP) F17 

Implementation of the TT system F 9 

5.1 Protective measures F19 

5.2 Coordination of residual current protective devices F20 

Implementation of the TN system F23 

6.1 Preliminary conditions F23 

6.2 Protection against indirect contact F23 

6.3 High-sensitivity RCDs F27 

6.4 Protection in high fire-risk locations F28 

6.5 When the fault current-loop impedance is particularly high F28 

Implementation of the IT system F29 

7.1 Preliminary conditions F29 

7.2 Protection against indirect contact F30 

7.3 High-sensitivity RCDs F34 

7.4 Protection in high fire-risk locations F35 

7.5 When the fault current-loop impedance is particularly high F35 

Residual current differential devices (RCDs) F36 

8.1 Types of RCDs F36 

8.2 Description F36 

8.3 Sensitivity of RDCs to disturbances F39 


F 



F2 

F - Protection against electric shock 

When a current exceeding 30 mA passes 

through a part of a human body, the person 

concerned is in serious danger if the current is 

not interrupted in a very short time. 

The protection of persons against electric 

shock in LV installations must be provided in 

conformity with appropriate national standards 

statutory regulations, codes of practice, official 

guides and circulars etc. 

Relevant IEC standards include: IEC 60364, 

IEC 60479 series, IEC 61008, IEC 61009 and 

IEC 60947-2. 

10,000 

5,000 

2,000 

1,000 

500 

200 

100 

50 

20 

10 

Duration of current 

flow I (ms) 

AC-1 

A B 


. Electric shock 

Fig. F1 : Zones time/current of effects of AC current on human body when passing from left hand to feet 

An electric shock is the pathophysiological effect of an electric current through the 

human body. 

Its passage affects essentially the muscular, circulatory and respiratory functions and 

sometimes results in serious burns. The degree of danger for the victim is a function 

of the magnitude of the current, the parts of the body through which the current 

passes, and the duration of current flow. 

IEC publication 60479-1 updated in 2005 defines four zones of current-magnitude/ 

time-duration, in each of which the pathophysiological effects are described (see Fig 

F ). Any person coming into contact with live metal risks an electric shock. 

Curve C1 shows that when a current greater than 30 mA passes through a human 

being from one hand to feet, the person concerned is likely to be killed, unless the 

current is interrupted in a relatively short time. 

The point 500 ms/100 mA close to the curve C1 corresponds to a probability of heart 

fibrillation of the order of 0.14%. 

The protection of persons against electric shock in LV installations must be provided 

in conformity with appropriate national standards and statutory regulations, codes of 

practice, official guides and circulars, etc. Relevant IEC standards include: IEC 60364 

series, IEC 60479 series, IEC 60755, IEC 61008 series, IEC 61009 series and IEC 

60947-2. 

C 1 C 2 C 3 

AC-2 AC-3 AC-4 

0.1 0.2 0.5 1 2 5 10 20 50 100 200 500 2,000 10,000 

1,000 5,000 

AC-1 zone: Imperceptible 

AC-2 zone: Perceptible 

AC-3 zone : Reversible effects: muscular contraction 

AC-4 zone: Possibility of irreversible effects 

AC-4-1 zone: Up to 5%probability of heart fibrillation 

AC-4-2 zone: Up to 50% probability of heart fibrillation 

AC-4-3 zone: More than 50% probability of heart fibrillation 

AC-4.1 AC-4.2 

AC-4.3 


A curve: Threshold of perception of current 

B curve: Threshold of muscular reactions 

Body current 

I s (mA) 

C 1 curve: Threshold of 0% probability of ventricular 

fibrillation 


fibrillation 


fibrillation


Two measures of protection against direct 

contact hazards are often required, since, in 

practice, the first measure may not be infallible 

Standards and regulations distinguish two kinds 

of dangerous contact, 

b Direct contact 

b Indirect contact 

and corresponding protective measures 

Is 

Is: Touch current 

1 2 3 N 

Busbars 


.2 Protection against electric shock 

The fundamental rule of protection against electric shock is provided by the 

document IEC 61140 which covers both electrical installations and electrical 

equipment. 

Hazardous-live-parts shall not be accessible and accessible conductive parts shall 

not be hazardous. 

This requirement needs to apply under: 

b Normal conditions, and 

b Under a single fault condition 

Various measures are adopted to protect against this hazard, and include: 

b Automatic disconnection of the power supply to the connected electrical equipment 

b Special arrangements such as: 

v The use of class II insulation materials, or an equivalent level of insulation 

v Non-conducting location, out of arm’s reach or interposition of barriers 

v Equipotential bonding 

v Electrical separation by means of isolating transformers 

.3 Direct and indirect contact 

Direct contact 

A direct contact refers to a person coming into contact with a conductor which is live 

in normal circumstances (see Fig. F2). 

IEC 61140 standard has renamed “protection against direct contact” with the term 

“basic protection”. The former name is at least kept for information. 

Indirect contact 

Fig. F2 : Direct contact Fig F3 : Indirect contact 

An indirect contact refers to a person coming into contact with an exposedconductive-part 

which is not normally alive, but has become alive accidentally (due 

to insulation failure or some other cause). 

The fault current raise the exposed-conductive-part to a voltage liable to be 

hazardous which could be at the origin of a touch current through a person coming 

into contact with this exposed-conductive-part (see Fig. F3). 

IEC 61140 standard has renamed “protection against indirect contact” with the term 

“fault protection”. The former name is at least kept for information. 


Is 

1 2 3 PE 

Id 

Insulation 

failure 

Id: Insulation fault current 

F3 



F 


IEC and national standards frequently 

distinguish two protection: 

b Complete (insulation, enclosures) 

b Partial or particular 

Fig. F5 : Example of isolation by envelope 

2 Protection against direct contact 

Two complementary measures are commonly used as protection against the 

dangers of direct contact: 

b The physical prevention of contact with live parts by barriers, insulation, 

inaccessibility, etc. 

b Additional protection in the event that a direct contact occurs, despite or due to 

failure of the above measures. This protection is based on residual-current operating 

device with a high sensitivity (IΔn y 30 mA) and a low operating time. These devices 

are highly effective in the majority of case of direct contact. 

2.1 Measures of protection against direct contact 

Protection by the insulation of live parts 

This protection consists of an insulation which complies with the relevant standards 

(see Fig. F ). Paints, lacquers and varnishes do not provide an adequate protection. 

Fig. F4 : Inherent protection against direct contact by insulation of a 3-phase cable with outer 

sheath 

Protection by means of barriers or enclosures 

This measure is in widespread use, since many components and materials are 

installed in cabinets, assemblies, control panels and distribution boards (see Fig. F5). 

To be considered as providing effective protection against direct contact hazards, 

these equipment must possess a degree of protection equal to at least IP 2X or 

IP XXB (see chapter E sub-clause 3.4). 

Moreover, an opening in an enclosure (door, front panel, drawer, etc.) must only be 

removable, open or withdrawn: 

b By means of a key or tool provided for this purpose, or 

b After complete isolation of the live parts in the enclosure, or 

b With the automatic interposition of another screen removable only with a key or 

a tool. The metal enclosure and all metal removable screen must be bonded to the 

protective earthing conductor of the installation. 

Partial measures of protection 

b Protection by means of obstacles, or by placing out of arm’s reach 

This protection is reserved only to locations to which skilled or instructed 

persons only have access. The erection of this protective measure is detailed in 

IEC 60364-4-41. 

Particular measures of protection 

b Protection by use of extra-low voltage SELV (Safety Extra-Low Voltage) or by 

limitation of the energy of discharge. 

These measures are used only in low-power circuits, and in particular circumstances, 

as described in section 3.5. 



An additional measure of protection against 

the hazards of direct contact is provided by the 

use of residual current operating device, which 

operate at 30 mA or less, and are referred to as 

RCDs of high sensitivity 

Fig. F6 : High sensitivity RCD 

2 Protection against direct contact 

2.2 Additional measure of protection against direct 

contact 

All the preceding protective measures are preventive, but experience has shown 

that for various reasons they cannot be regarded as being infallible. Among these 

reasons may be cited: 

b Lack of proper maintenance 

b Imprudence, carelessness 

b Normal (or abnormal) wear and tear of insulation; for instance flexure and abrasion 

of connecting leads 

b Accidental contact 

b Immersion in water, etc. A situation in which insulation is no longer effective 

In order to protect users in such circumstances, highly sensitive fast tripping 

devices, based on the detection of residual currents to earth (which may or may 

not be through a human being or animal) are used to disconnect the power 

supply automatically, and with sufficient rapidity to prevent injury to, or death by 

electrocution, of a normally healthy human being (see Fig. F6). 

These devices operate on the principle of differential current measurement, in which 

any difference between the current entering a circuit and that leaving it (on a system 

supplied from an earthed source) be flowing to earth, either through faulty insulation 

or through contact of an earthed part, such as a person, with a live conductor. 

Standardised residual-current devices, referred to as RCDs, sufficiently sensitive for 

protection against direct contact are rated at 30 mA of differential current. 

According to IEC 60364-4-41, additional protection by means of high sensitivity 

RCDs (I∆n y 30 mA) must be provided for circuits supplying socket-outlets with a 

rated current y 20 A in all locations, and for circuits supplying mobile equipment with 

a rated current y 32 A for use outdoors. 

This additional protection is required in certain countries for circuits supplying socketoutlets 

rated up to 32 A, and even higher if the location is wet and/or temporary 

(such as work sites for instance). 

It is also recommended to limit the number of socket-outlets protected by a RCD 

(e.g. 10 socket-outlets for one RCD). 

Chapter P section 3 itemises various common locations in which RCDs of 

high sensitivity are obligatory (in some countries), but in any case, are highly 

recommended as an effective protection against both direct and indirect contact 

hazards. 


F5 



F 


Protection against indirect contact hazards 

can be achieved by automatic disconnection of 

the supply if the exposed-conductive-parts of 

equipment are properly earthed 

(1) Touch voltage Uc is the voltage existing (as the result of 

insulation failure) between an exposed-conductive-part and 

any conductive element within reach which is at a different 

(generally earth) potential. 

3 Protection against indirect 

contact 

Exposed-conductive-parts used in the manufacturing process of an electrical 

equipment is separated from the live parts of the equipment by the “basic insulation”. 

Failure of the basic insulation will result in the exposed-conductive-parts being alive. 

Touching a normally dead part of an electrical equipment which has become live due 

to the failure of its insulation, is referred to as an indirect contact. 

3.1 Measures of protection: two levels 

Two levels of protective measures exist: 

b 1 st level: The earthing of all exposed-conductive-parts of electrical equipment in the 

installation and the constitution of an equipotential bonding network (see chapter G 

section 6). 

b 2 sd level: Automatic disconnection of the supply of the section of the installation 

concerned, in such a way that the touch-voltage/time safety requirements are 

respected for any level of touch voltage Uc (1) (see Fig. F7). 

Earth 

connection 

Fig. F7 : Illustration of the dangerous touch voltage Uc 

The greater the value of Uc, the greater the rapidity of supply disconnection required 

to provide protection (see Fig. F8). The highest value of Uc that can be tolerated 

indefinitely without danger to human beings is 50 V a.c. 

Reminder of the theoretical disconnecting-time limits 

Uo (V) 50 < Uo y 120 120 < Uo y 230 230 < Uo y 400 Uo > 400 

System TN or IT 0.8 0.4 0.2 0.1 

TT 0.3 0.2 0.07 0.04 

Fig. F8 : Maximum safe duration of the assumed values of AC touch voltage (in seconds) 


Uc


Automatic disconnection for TT system is 

achieved by RCD having a sensitivity of 

I�n i 

R 

50 

where R A is the resistance of the 

A 

installation earth electrode 

R n = 10 Ω 

Substation 

earth 

electrode 

R A = 20 Ω 

Installation 

earth 

electrode 

U f 

1 

2 

3 

N 

PE 

Fig. F9 : Automatic disconnection of supply for TT system 


contact 

3.2 Automatic disconnection for TT system 

Principle 

In this system all exposed-conductive-parts and extraneous-conductive-parts of 

the installation must be connected to a common earth electrode. The neutral point 

of the supply system is normally earthed at a pint outside the influence area of the 

installation earth electrode, but need not be so. The impedance of the earth-fault loop 

therefore consists mainly in the two earth electrodes (i.e. the source and installation 

electrodes) in series, so that the magnitude of the earth fault current is generally 

too small to operate overcurrent relay or fuses, and the use of a residual current 

operated device is essential. 

This principle of protection is also valid if one common earth electrode only is used, 

notably in the case of a consumer-type substation within the installation area, where 

space limitation may impose the adoption of a TN system earthing, but where all 

other conditions required by the TN system cannot be fulfilled. 

Protection by automatic disconnection of the supply used in TT system is by RCD of 

sensitivity: I�n i 

R 

50 

where R 

A 

where 

installation earth electrode 

R A is the resistance of the earth electrode for the installation 

I Δn is the rated residual operating current of the RCD 

For temporary supplies (to work sites, …) and agricultural and horticultural premises, 

the value of 50 V is replaced by 25 V. 

Example (see Fig. F9) 

b The resistance of the earth electrode of substation neutral Rn is 10 Ω. 

b The resistance of the earth electrode of the installation RA is 20 Ω. 

b The earth-fault loop current Id = 7.7 A. 

b The fault voltage Uf = Id x RA = 154 V and therefore dangerous, but 

IΔn = 50/20 = 2.5 A so that a standard 300 mA RCD will operate in about 30 ms 

without intentional time delay and will clear the fault where a fault voltage exceeding 

appears on an exposed-conductive-part. 

Fig. F10 : Maximum disconnecting time for AC final circuits not exceeding 32 A 


Uo 

(1) Uo is the nominal phase to earth voltage 

(1) (V) T (s) 

50 < Uo y 120 0.3 

120 < Uo y 230 0.2 

230 < Uo y 400 0.07 

Uo > 400 0.04 

Specified maximum disconnection time 

The tripping times of RCDs are generally lower than those required in the majority 

of national standards; this feature facilitates their use and allows the adoption of an 

effective discriminative protection. 

The IEC 60364-4-41 specifies the maximum operating time of protective devices 

used in TT system for the protection against indirect contact: 

b For all final circuits with a rated current not exceeding 32 A, the maximum 

disconnecting time will not exceed the values indicated in Figure F10 

b For all other circuits, the maximum disconnecting time is fixed to 1s. This limit 

enables discrimination between RCDs when installed on distribution circuits. 

RCD is a general term for all devices operating on the residual-current principle. 

RCCB (Residual Current Circuit-Breaker) as defined in IEC 61008 series is a specific 

class of RCD. 

Type G (general) and type S (Selective) of IEC 61008 have a tripping time/current 

characteristics as shown in Figure F11 next page. These characteristics allow a certain 

degree of selective tripping between the several combination of ratings and types, as 

shown later in sub-clause 4.3. Industrial type RCD according to IEC 60947-2 provide 

more possibilities of discrimination due to their flexibility of time-delaying. 

F7 



F8 


The automatic disconnection for TN system is 

achieved by overcurrent protective devices or 

RCD’s 

N 

A 

F 

35 mm 2 

Fig. F12 : Automatic disconnection in TN system 

E 

B 

D C 

1 

2 

3 

PEN 

NS160 

50 m 

35 mm 2 

U f 


contact 

3.3 Automatic disconnection for TN systems 

Principle 

x I Δn 1 2 5 > 5 

Domestic Instantaneous 0.3 0.15 0.04 0.04 

Fig. F11 : Maximum operating time of RCD’s (in seconds) 

In this system all exposed and extraneous-conductive-parts of the installation are 

connected directly to the earthed point of the power supply by protective conductors. 

As noted in Chapter E Sub-clause 1.2, the way in which this direct connection is 

carried out depends on whether the TN-C, TN-S, or TN-C-S method of implementing 

the TN principle is used. In figure F12 the method TN-C is shown, in which the 

neutral conductor acts as both the Protective-Earth and Neutral (PEN) conductor. In 

all TN systems, any insulation fault to earth results in a phase to neutral short-circuit. 

High fault current levels allow to use overcurrent protection but can give rise to touch 

voltages exceeding 50% of the phase to neutral voltage at the fault position during 

the short disconnection time. 

In practice for utility distribution network, earth electrodes are normally installed at 

regular intervals along the protective conductor (PE or PEN) of the network, while 

the consumer is often required to install an earth electrode at the service entrance. 

On large installations additional earth electrodes dispersed around the premises are 

often provided, in order to reduce the touch voltage as much as possible. In high-rise 

apartment blocks, all extraneous conductive parts are connected to the protective 

conductor at each level. In order to ensure adequate protection, the earth-fault 

current 

Id or 0.8 I 

Uo 

= 

Zc 

Uo 

u must be higher or equal to Ia, where: 

Zs 

b Uo = nominal phase to neutral voltage 

b Id = the fault current 

b Ia = current equal to the value required to operate the protective device in the time 

specified 

b Zs = earth-fault current loop impedance, equal to the sum of the impedances of the 

source, the live phase conductors to the fault position, the protective conductors from 

the fault position back to the source 

b Zc = the faulty-circuit loop impedance (see “conventional method” Sub-clause 6.2) 

Note: The path through earth electrodes back to the source will have (generally) 

much higher impedance values than those listed above, and need not be considered. 

Example (see Fig. F12) 

230 

The fault voltage Uf = = 115 V and and is is hazardous; 

2 

The fault loop impedance Zs=Zab + Zbc + Zde + Zen + Zna. 

If Zbc and Zde are predominant, then: 

L 

“conventional Zs = 2� = 64method” . 3 m� , , so and so that in this example will give an estimated fault current of 

S 

230 

Id= 

= ( 

64.3 x10-3 3,576 A (≈ 22 In based on a NS 160 circuit-breaker). 

The “instantaneous” magnetic trip unit adjustment of the circuit-breaker is many time 

less than this short-circuit value, so that positive operation in the shortest possible 

time is assured. 

Note: Some authorities base such calculations on the assumption that a voltage 

drop of 20% occurs in the part of the impedance loop BANE. 

This method, which is recommended, is explained in chapter F sub-clause 6.2 

“conventional 

“conventional 

method” 

method” 

and 

and 

in 

in 

this 

this 

example 

example 

will 

will 

give 

give 

an 

an 

estimated 

estimated 

fault 

fault 

current 

current 

of 


3 

230 x 0.8 x 10 

= 2,816 A ( (≈ 18 In). 

64.3 


Type S 0.5 0.2 0.15 0.15 

Industrial Instantaneous 0.3 0.15 0.04 0.04 

Time-delay (0.06) 0.5 0.2 0.15 0.15 

Time-delay (other) According to manufacturer


If the protection is to be provided by a circuitbreaker, 

it is sufficient to verify that the fault 

current will always exceed the current-setting 

level of the instantaneous or short-time delay 

tripping unit (Im) 

t 

1: Short-time delayed trip 

2: Instantaneous trip 

Im Uo/Zs 

1 

2 

I 


contact 

Specified maximum disconnection time 

The IEC 60364-4-41 specifies the maximum operating time of protective devices 

used in TN system for the protection against indirect contact: 

b For all final circuits with a rated current not exceeding 32 A, the maximum 

disconnecting time will not exceed the values indicated in Figure F13 

b For all other circuits, the maximum disconnecting time is fixed to 5s. This limit 

enables discrimination between protective devices installed on distribution circuits 

Note: The use of RCDs may be necessary on TN-earthed systems. Use of RCDs on 

TN-C-S systems means that the protective conductor and the neutral conductor must 

(evidently) be separated upstream of the RCD. This separation is commonly made at 

the service entrance. 

Fig. F13 : Maximum disconnecting time for AC final circuits not exceeding 32 A 

tc = 0.4 s 

Fig. F14 : Disconnection by circuit-breaker for a TN system Fig. F15 : Disconnection by fuses for a TN system 


Uo 

(1) Uo is the nominal phase to earth voltage 

(1) (V) T (s) 

50 < Uo y 120 0.8 

120 < Uo y 230 0.4 

230 < Uo y 400 0.2 

Uo > 400 0.1 

Protection by means of circuit-breaker (see Fig. F14) 

The instantaneous trip unit of a circuit-breaker will eliminate a short-circuit to earth in 

less than 0.1 second. 

In consequence, automatic disconnection within the maximum allowable time will 

always be assured, since all types of trip unit, magnetic or electronic, instantaneous 

or slightly retarded, are suitable: Ia = Im. The maximum tolerance authorised 

by the relevant standard, however, must always be taken into consideration. It is 

sufficient therefore that the fault current Uo Uo 

or 0.8 determined by by calculation (or estimated 

Zs Zc 

(or estimated on site) on site) be greater be greater than than the instantaneous the instantaneous trip-setting trip-setting current, current, or than or than the very short- 

the very short-time tripping threshold level, to be sure of tripping within the permitted 

time limit. 

Ia can be determined from the fuse 

Protection by means of fuses (see Fig. F15) 

performance curve. In any case, protection The value of current which assures the correct operation of a fuse can be 

cannot be achieved if the loop impedance Zs ascertained from a current/time performance graph for the fuse concerned. 

or Zc exceeds a certain value 

therefore that The the fault current Uo Uo 

or 0.8 determined as determined by calculation above, must (or largely estimated exceed that 

Zs Zc 

on site) be greater necessary than the to ensure instantaneous positive operation trip-setting operation of current, the fuse. or The than condition the very short- to observe 

therefore is that Ia < Uo Uo 

or 0.8 as as indicated in Figure in Figure F15. F15. 

Zs Zc 

t 

Ia Uo/Zs 

I 

F9 


F10 



In IT system the first fault to earth should not 

cause any disconnection 

Fig. F16 : Phases to earth insulation monitoring device 

obligatory in IT system 

(1) Resistive leakage current to earth through the insulation is 

assumed to be negligibly small in the example. 


contact 

Example: The nominal phase to neutral voltage of the network is 230 V and 

the maximum disconnection time given by the graph in Figure F15 is 0.4 s. 

The corresponding value of Ia can be read from the graph. Using the voltage (230 V) 

and the current Ia, 

Ia, 

the 

the 

complete 

complete 

loop 

loop 

impedance 

impedance 

or 

or 

the 

the 

circuit 

circuit 

loop 

loop 

impedance 

impedance 

can 

can 

230 

be calculated from Zs = or Zc = 0.8 

Ia Ia 

230 . This impedance value must never be 

exceeded and should preferably be substantially less to ensure satisfactory fuse 

operation. 

Protection by means of Residual Current Devices for 

TN-S circuits 

Residual Current Devices must be used where: 

b The loop impedance cannot be determined precisely (lengths difficult to estimate, 

presence of metallic material close to the wiring) 

b The fault current is so low that the disconnecting time cannot be met by using 

overcurrent protective devices 

The rated tripping current of RCDs being in the order of a few amps, it is well below 

the fault current level. RCDs are consequently well adapted to this situation. 

In practice, they are often installed in the LV sub distribution and in many countries, 

the automatic disconnection of final circuits shall be achieved by Residual Current 

Devices. 

3.4 Automatic disconnection on a second fault in an 

IT system 

In this type of system: 

b The installation is isolated from earth, or the neutral point of its power-supply 

source is connected to earth through a high impedance 

b All exposed and extraneous-conductive-parts are earthed via an installation earth 

electrode. 

First fault situation 

On the occurrence of a true fault to earth, referred to as a “first fault”, the fault current 

is very low, such that the rule Id x RA y 50 V (see F3.2) is fulfilled and no dangerous 

fault voltages can occur. 

In practice the current Id is low, a condition that is neither dangerous to personnel, 

nor harmful to the installation. 

However, in this system: 

b A permanent monitoring of the insulation to earth must be provided, coupled with 

an alarm signal (audio and/or flashing lights, etc.) operating in the event of a first 

earth fault (see Fig. F1 ) 

b The rapid location and repair of a first fault is imperative if the full benefits of the 

IT system are to be realised. Continuity of service is the great advantage afforded by 

the system. 

For a network formed from 1 km of new conductors, the leakage (capacitive) 

impedance to earth Zf is of the order of 3,500 Ω per phase. In normal operation, the 

capacitive current (1) to earth is therefore: 

Uo 230 

= = 66 mA per phase. 

Zf 3,500 

During a phase to earth fault, as indicated in Figure F17 opposite page, the current 

passing through the electrode resistance RnA is the vector sum of the capacitive 

currents in the two healthy phases. The voltages of the healthy phases have 

(because of the fault) increased to 3 the normal phase voltage, so that the capacitive 

currents increase by the same amount. These currents are displaced, one from the 

other by 60°, so that when added vectorially, this amounts to 3 x 66 mA = 198 mA, in 

the present example. 

The fault voltage Uf is therefore equal to 198 x 5 x 10-3 = 0.99 V, which is obviously 

harmless. 

The current through the short-circuit to earth is given by the vector sum of the 

neutral-resistor current Id1 (=153 mA) and the capacitive current Id2 (198 mA). 

Since the exposed-conductive-parts of the installation are connected directly to 

earth, the neutral impedance Zct plays practically no part in the production of touch 

voltages to earth. 



The simultaneous existence of two earth faults 

(if not both on the same phase) is dangerous, 

and rapid clearance by fuses or automatic 

circuit-breaker tripping depends on the type of 

earth-bonding scheme, and whether separate 

earthing electrodes are used or not, in the 

installation concerned 

(1) Based on the “conventional method” noted in the first 

example of Sub-clause 3.3. 


contact 

Z ct = 1,500 Ω 

R nA = 5 Ω 

Id1 

Fig. F17 : Fault current path for a first fault in IT system 

Second fault situation 

On the appearance of a second fault, on a different phase, or on a neutral conductor, 

a rapid disconnection becomes imperative. Fault clearance is carried out differently in 

each of the following cases: 

1 st case 

It concerns an installation in which all exposed conductive parts are bonded to a 

common PE conductor, as shown in Figure F18. 

In this case no earth electrodes are included in the fault current path, so that a high 

level of fault current is assured, and conventional overcurrent protective devices are 

used, i.e. circuit-breakers and fuses. 

The first fault could occur at the end of a circuit in a remote part of the installation, 

while the second fault could feasibly be located at the opposite end of the installation. 

For this reason, it is conventional to double the loop impedance of a circuit, when 

calculating the anticipated fault setting level for its overcurrent protective device(s). 

Where the system includes a neutral conductor in addition to the 3 phase 

conductors, the lowest short-circuit fault currents will occur if one of the (two) faults is 

from the neutral conductor to earth (all four conductors are insulated from earth in an 

IT scheme). In four-wire IT installations, therefore, the phase-to-neutral voltage must 

be used to calculate short-circuit protective levels i.e. 0.8 Uo 

u I a (1) where 

2 Zc 

Uo = phase to neutral voltage 

Zc = impedance of the circuit fault-current loop (see F3.3) 

Ia = current level for trip setting 

If no neutral conductor is distributed, then the voltage to use for the fault-current 

calculation is the phase-to-phase value, i.e. 

calculation is the phase-to-phase value, i.e. 0.8 

b Maximum tripping times 


Ω 

Id2 

3 Uo 

2 Zc 

(1) 

(1) u I a 

Id1 + Id2 

Disconnecting times for IT system depends on how the different installation and 

substation earth electrodes are interconnected. 

1 

2 

3 

N 

PE 

For final circuits supplying electrical equipment with a rated current not exceeding 

32 A and having their exposed-conductive-parts bonded with the substation earth 

electrode, the maximum tripping time is given in table F8. For the other circuits 

within the same group of interconnected exposed-conductive-parts, the maximum 

disconnecting time is 5 s. This is due to the fact that any double fault situation within 

this group will result in a short-circuit current as in TN system. 

For final circuits supplying electrical equipment with a rated current not exceeding 

32 A and having their exposed-conductive-parts connected to an independent earth 

electrode electrically separated from the substation earth electrode, the maximum 

tripping time is given in Figure F13. For the other circuits within the same group of 

non interconnected exposed-conductive-parts, the maximum disconnecting time is 

1s. This is due to the fact that any double fault situation resulting from one insulation 

fault within this group and another insulation fault from another group will generate a 

fault current limited by the different earth electrode resistances as in TT system. 

Zf 

B 

U f 

F11 


F12 




contact 

Fig. F18 : Circuit-breaker tripping on double fault situation when exposed-conductive-parts are 

connected to a common protective conductor 

b Protection by circuit-breaker 

In the case shown in Figure F18, the adjustments of instantaneous and short-time 

delay overcurrent trip unit must be decided. The times recommended here above can 

be readily complied with. The short-circuit protection provided by the NS 160 circuitbreaker 

is suitable to clear a phase to phase short-circuit occurring at the load ends 

of the circuits concerned. 

Reminder: In an IT system, the two circuits involved in a phase to phase short-circuit 

are assumed to be of equal length, with the same cross sectional area conductors, 

the PE conductors being the same cross sectional area as the phase conductors. In 

such a case, the impedance of the circuit loop when using the “conventional method” 

(sub clause 6.2) will be twice that calculated for one of the circuits in the TN case, 

shown in Chapter F sub clause 3.3. 

L 

So that The the resistance resistance of of circuit 1 loop FGHJ = 22R RJH JH = 2� 

in m� 

where: where: 

a 

ρ = resistance of copper rod 1 meter long of cross sectional area 1 mm2 , in mΩ 

L = length of the circuit in meters 

a = cross sectional area of the conductor in mm2 FGHJ = 2 x 22.5 x 50/35 = 64.3 mΩ 

and the loop resistance B, C, D, E, F, G, H, J will be 2 x 64.3 = 129 mΩ. 

The fault current will therefore be 0.8 x 3 x 230 x 10 3 /129 = 2,470 A. 

b Protection by fuses 

The current I a for which fuse operation must be assured in a time specified according 

to here above can be found from fuse operating curves, as described in figure F15. 

The current indicated should be significantly lower than the fault currents calculated 

for the circuit concerned. 

b Protection by Residual current circuit-breakers (RCCBs) 

For low values of short-circuit current, RCCBs are necessary. Protection against 

indirect contact hazards can be achieved then by using one RCCB for each circuit. 

2 nd case 

b It concerns exposed conductive parts which are earthed either individually (each part 

having its own earth electrode) or in separate groups (one electrode for each group). 

If all exposed conductive parts are not bonded to a common electrode system, then 

it is possible for the second earth fault to occur in a different group or in a separately 

earthed individual apparatus. Additional protection to that described above for 

case 1, is required, and consists of a RCD placed at the circuit-breaker controlling 

each group and each individually-earthed apparatus. 


K 

A 

Id 

R A 

NS160 

160 A 

50 m 

35 mm2 F 

G 

J 

H 

E 

D 

B 

C 

1 

2 

3 

N 

PE 

50 m 

35 mm 2


Case 1 

Rn 

RCD 

Ω 

N 

PIM 

RA 

Fig. F19 : Correspondence between the earth leakage capacitance and the first fault current 

Group 

earth 

Case 2 

Fig. F20 : Application of RCDs when exposed-conductive-parts are earthed individually or by group on IT system 

Extra-low voltage is used where the risks 

are great: swimming pools, wandering-lead 

hand lamps, and other portable appliances for 

outdoor use, etc. 


contact 

The reason for this requirement is that the separate-group electrodes are “bonded” 

through the earth so that the phase to phase short-circuit current will generally be 

limited when passing through the earth bond by the electrode contact resistances 

with the earth, thereby making protection by overcurrent devices unreliable. The 

more sensitive RCDs are therefore necessary, but the operating current of the RCDs 

must evidently exceed that which occurs for a first fault (see Fig. F19). 


Leakage capacitance First fault current 

(µF) (A) 

1 0.07 

5 0.36 

30 2.17 

Note: 1 µF is the 1 km typical leakage capacitance for 

4-conductor cable. 

For a second fault occurring within a group having a common earth-electrode 

system, the overcurrent protection operates, as described above for case 1. 

Note 1: See also Chapter G Sub-clause 7.2, protection of the neutral conductor. 

Note 2: In 3-phase 4-wire installations, protection against overcurrent in the neutral 

conductor is sometimes more conveniently achieved by using a ring-type current 

transformer over the single-core neutral conductor (see Fig. F20). 

RCD 

Ω 

N 

PIM 

Group 

earth 1 

RCD RCD 

Rn RA1 RA2 

Group 

earth 2 

3.5 Measures of protection against direct or indirect 

contact without automatic disconnection of supply 

The use of SELV (Safety Extra-Low Voltage) 

Safety by extra low voltage SELV is used in situations where the operation of electrical 

equipment presents a serious hazard (swimming pools, amusement parks, etc.). 

This measure depends on supplying power at extra-low voltage from the secondary 

windings of isolating transformers especially designed according to national or to 

international (IEC 60742) standard. The impulse withstand level of insulation between 

the primary and secondary windings is very high, and/or an earthed metal screen 

is sometimes incorporated between the windings. The secondary voltage never 

exceeds 50 V rms. 

Three conditions of exploitation must be respected in order to provide satisfactory 

protection against indirect contact: 

b No live conductor at SELV must be connected to earth 

b Exposed-conductive-parts of SELV supplied equipment must not be connected to 

earth, to other exposed conductive parts, or to extraneous-conductive-parts 

b All live parts of SELV circuits and of other circuits of higher voltage must be 

separated by a distance at least equal to that between the primary and secondary 

windings of a safety isolating transformer. 

F13 


F14 



The electrical separation of circuits is suitable 

for relatively short cable lengths and high levels 

of insulation resistance. It is preferably used for 

an individual appliance 

230 V/230 V 

Fig. F22 : Safety supply from a class II separation transformer 


contact 

These measures require that: 

b SELV circuits must use conduits exclusively provided for them, unless cables which 

are insulated for the highest voltage of the other circuits are used for the SELV circuits 

b Socket outlets for the SELV system must not have an earth-pin contact. The 

SELV circuit plugs and sockets must be special, so that inadvertent connection to a 

different voltage level is not possible. 

Note: In normal conditions, when the SELV voltage is less than 25 V, there is no 

need to provide protection against direct contact hazards. Particular requirements 

are indicated in Chapter P, Clause 3: “special locations”. 

The use of PELV (Protection by Extra Low Voltage) (see Fig. F21) 

This system is for general use where low voltage is required, or preferred for safety 

reasons, other than in the high-risk locations noted above. The conception is similar 

to that of the SELV system, but the secondary circuit is earthed at one point. 

IEC 60364-4-41 defines precisely the significance of the reference PELV. Protection 

against direct contact hazards is generally necessary, except when the equipment 

is in the zone of equipotential bonding, and the nominal voltage does not exceed 

25 V rms, and the equipment is used in normally dry locations only, and large-area 

contact with the human body is not expected. In all other cases, 6 V rms is the 

maximum permitted voltage, where no direct contact protection is provided. 

230 V / 24 V 

Fig. F21 : Low-voltage supplies from a safety isolating transformer 

FELV system (Functional Extra-Low Voltage) 

Where, for functional reasons, a voltage of 50 V or less is used, but not all of the 

requirements relating to SELV or PELV are fulfilled, appropriate measures described 

in IEC 60364-4-41 must be taken to ensure protection against both direct and 

indirect contact hazards, according to the location and use of these circuits. 

Note: Such conditions may, for example, be encountered when the circuit contains 

equipment (such as transformers, relays, remote-control switches, contactors) 

insufficiently insulated with respect to circuits at higher voltages. 

The electrical separation of circuits (see Fig. F22) 

The principle of the electrical separation of circuits (generally single-phase circuits) 

for safety purposes is based on the following rationale. 

The two conductors from the unearthed single-phase secondary winding of a 

separation transformer are insulated from earth. 

If a direct contact is made with one conductor, a very small current only will flow into 

the person making contact, through the earth and back to the other conductor, via 

the inherent capacitance of that conductor with respect to earth. Since the conductor 

capacitance to earth is very small, the current is generally below the level of perception. 

As the length of circuit cable increases, the direct contact current will progressively 

increase to a point where a dangerous electric shock will be experienced. 

Even if a short length of cable precludes any danger from capacitive current, a low 

value of insulation resistance with respect to earth can result in danger, since the 

current path is then via the person making contact, through the earth and back to the 

other conductor through the low conductor-to-earth insulation resistance. 

For these reasons, relatively short lengths of well insulated cables are essential in 

separation systems. 

Transformers are specially designed for this duty, with a high degree of insulation 

between primary and secondary windings, or with equivalent protection, such as an 

earthed metal screen between the windings. Construction of the transformer is to 

class II insulation standards. 



Symbol: 

In principle, safety by placing simultaneouslyaccessible 

conductive parts out-of-reach, or by 

interposing obstacles, requires also a nonconducting 

floor, and so is not an easily applied 

principle 

(1) It is recommended in IEC 364-4-41 that the product of the 

nominal voltage of the circuit in volts and length in metres of 

the wiring system should not exceed 100,000, and that the 

length of the wiring system should not exceed 500 m. 


contact 

As indicated before, successful exploitation of the principle requires that: 

b No conductor or exposed conductive part of the secondary circuit must be 

connected to earth, 

b The length of secondary cabling must be limited to avoid large capacitance values (1) , 

b A high insulation-resistance value must be maintained for the cabling and appliances. 

These conditions generally limit the application of this safety measure to an 

individual appliance. 

In the case where several appliances are supplied from a separation transformer, it is 

necessary to observe the following requirements: 

b The exposed conductive parts of all appliances must be connected together by an 

insulated protective conductor, but not connected to earth, 

b The socket outlets must be provided with an earth-pin connection. The earth-pin 

connection is used in this case only to ensure the interconnection (bonding) of all 

exposed conductive parts. 

In the case of a second fault, overcurrent protection must provide automatic 

disconnection in the same conditions as those required for an IT system of power 

system earthing. 

Class II equipment 

These appliances are also referred to as having “double insulation” since in class 

II appliances a supplementary insulation is added to the basic insulation (see 

Fig. F23). 

No conductive parts of a class II appliance must be connected to a protective conductor: 

b Most portable or semi-fixed equipment, certain lamps, and some types of 

transformer are designed to have double insulation. It is important to take particular 

care in the exploitation of class II equipment and to verify regularly and often that the 

class II standard is maintained (no broken outer envelope, etc.). Electronic devices, 

radio and television sets have safety levels equivalent to class II, but are not formally 

class II appliances 

b Supplementary insulation in an electrical installation: IEC 60364-4-41(Sub-clause 

413-2) and some national standards such as NF C 15-100 (France) describe in 

more detail the necessary measures to achieve the supplementary insulation during 

installation work. 

Fig. F23 : Principle of class II insulation level 


Active part 

Basic insulation 

Supplementary insulation 

A simple example is that of drawing a cable into a PVC conduit. Methods are also 

described for distribution switchboards. 

b For distribution switchboards and similar equipment, IEC 60439-1 describes a set 

of requirements, for what is referred to as “total insulation”, equivalent to class II 

b Some cables are recognised as being equivalent to class II by many national standards 

Out-of-arm’s reach or interposition of obstacles 

By these means, the probability of touching a live exposed-conductive-part, while at 

the same time touching an extraneous-conductive-part at earth potential, is extremely 

low (see Fig. F24 next page). In practice, this measure can only be applied in a dry 

location, and is implemented according to the following conditions: 

b The floor and the wall of the chamber must be non-conducting, i.e. the resistance 

to earth at any point must be: 

v > 50 kΩ (installation voltage y 500 V) 

v > 100 kΩ (500 V < installation voltage y 1000 V) 

Resistance is measured by means of “MEGGER” type instruments (hand-operated 

generator or battery-operated electronic model) between an electrode placed on the 

floor or against the wall, and earth (i.e. the nearest protective earth conductor). The 

electrode contact area pressure must be evidently be the same for all tests. 

Different instruments suppliers provide electrodes specific to their own product, so 

that care should be taken to ensure that the electrodes used are those supplied with 

the instrument. 

F15 


F1 



2.5 m 

Electrical 

apparatus 

Fig. F24 : Protection by out-of arm’s reach arrangements and the interposition of non-conducting obstacles 

Earth-free equipotential chambers are 

associated with particular installations 

(laboratories, etc.) and give rise to a number of 

practical installation difficulties 

> 2 m 

(1) Extraneous conductive parts entering (or leaving) the 

equipotential space (such as water pipes, etc.) must be 

encased in suitable insulating material and excluded from the 

equipotential network, since such parts are likely to be bonded 

to protective (earthed) conductors elsewhere in the installation. 


contact 

b The placing of equipment and obstacles must be such that simultaneous contact 

with two exposed-conductive-parts or with an exposed conductive-part and an 

extraneous-conductive-part by an individual person is not possible. 

b No exposed protective conductor must be introduced into the chamber concerned. 

b Entrances to the chamber must be arranged so that persons entering are not at 

risk, e.g. a person standing on a conducting floor outside the chamber must not be 

able to reach through the doorway to touch an exposed-conductive-part, such as a 

lighting switch mounted in an industrial-type cast-iron conduit box, for example. 

Insulated floor 

Electrical 

apparatus 

Insulated 

obstacles 

Earth-free equipotential chambers 

In this scheme, all exposed-conductive-parts, including the floor (1) are bonded by 

suitably large conductors, such that no significant difference of potential can exist 

between any two points. A failure of insulation between a live conductor and the 

metal envelope of an appliance will result in the whole “cage” being raised to phaseto-earth 

voltage, but no fault current will flow. In such conditions, a person entering 

the chamber would be at risk (since he/she would be stepping on to a live floor). 

Suitable precautions must be taken to protect personnel from this danger (e.g. nonconducting 

floor at entrances, etc.). Special protective devices are also necessary to 

detect insulation failure, in the absence of significant fault current. 

M 


< 2 m 

Insulating material 

Electrical 

apparatus 

Conductive 

floor 

Insulated 

walls 

Fig. F25 : Equipotential bonding of all exposed-conductive-parts simultaneously accessible


RCDs are very effective devices to provide 

protection against fire risk due to insulation 

fault because they can detect leakage current 

(ex : 300 mA) wich are too low for the other 

protections, but sufficient to cause a fire 

Beginning of fire 

Fig. F26 : Origin of fires in buildings 

Id

F18 



4 Protection of goods 

in case of insulation fault 

Positioning GFP devices in the installation 

Type / installation level Main-distribution Sub-distribution Comments 

Source Ground Return 

(SGR) 

v Used 

Residual Sensing (RS) 

(SGR) 

v b Often used 

Zero Sequence 

(SGR) 

v Possible 

v b Rarely used 

b Recommended or required 



A 

RCD 

Fig. F29 : Distribution circuits 

RCD 

B 

RCD 

RA1 RA2 

Distant location 

5 Implementation of the TT system 

5.1 Protective measures 

Protection against indirect contact 

General case 

Protection against indirect contact is assured by RCDs, the sensitivity IΔn of which 

50 V 

complies with the condition I �n i (1) (1) 

RA 

The choice of sensitivity of the residual current device is a function of the resistance 

RA of the earth electrode for the installation, and is given in Figure F28. 


IΔn Maximum resistance of the earth electrode 

(50 V) (25 V) 

3 A 16 Ω 8 Ω 

1 A 50 Ω 25 Ω 

500 mA 100 Ω 50 Ω 

300 mA 166 Ω 83 Ω 

30 mA 1666 Ω 833 Ω 

Fig. F28 : The upper limit of resistance for an installation earthing electrode which must not be 

exceeded, for given sensitivity levels of RCDs at U L voltage limits of 50 V and 25 V 

Case of distribution circuits (see Fig. F29) 

IEC 60364-4-41 and a number of national standards recognize a maximum tripping 

time of 1 second in installation distribution circuits (as opposed to final circuits). This 

allows a degree of selective discrimination to be achieved: 

b At level A: RCD time-delayed, e.g. “S” type 

b At level B: RCD instantaneous 

Case where the exposed conductive parts of an appliance, or group of 

appliances, are connected to a separate earth electrode (see Fig. F30) 

Protection against indirect contact by a RCD at the circuit-breaker level protecting 

each group or separately-earthed individual appliance. 

In each case, the sensitivity must be compatible with the resistance of the earth 

electrode concerned. 

High-sensitivity RCDs (see Fig. F31) 

Fig. F30 : Separate earth electrode Fig. F31 : Circuit supplying socket-outlets 

(1) 25 V for work-site installations, agricultural establishments, etc. 

According to IEC 60364-4-41, high sensitivity RCDs (y 30 mA) must be used for 

protection of socket outlets with rated current y 20 A in all locations. The use of such 

RCDs is also recommended in the following cases: 

b Socket-outlet circuits in wet locations at all current ratings 

b Socket-outlet circuits in temporary installations 

b Circuits supplying laundry rooms and swimming pools 

b Supply circuits to work-sites, caravans, pleasure boats, and travelling fairs 

See 2.2 and chapter P, section 3 

F19 


F20 



Fig. F32 : Fire-risk location 

Fire-risk 

location 


In high fire risk locations (see Fig. F32) 

RCD protection at the circuit-breaker controlling all supplies to the area at risk is 

necessary in some locations, and mandatory in many countries. 

The sensitivity of the RCD must be y 500 mA, but a 300 mA sensitivity is 

recommended. 

Protection when exposed conductive parts are not connected 

to earth (see Fig. F33) 

(In the case of an existing installation where the location is dry and provision of 

an earthing connection is not possible, or in the event that a protective earth wire 

becomes broken). 

RCDs of high sensitivity (y 30 mA) will afford both protection against indirect-contact 

hazards, and the additional protection against the dangers of direct-contact. 

Fig. F33 : Unearthed exposed conductive parts (A) 

5.2 Coordination of residual current protective 

devices 

Discriminative-tripping coordination is achieved either by time-delay or by subdivision 

of circuits, which are then protected individually or by groups, or by a combination of 

both methods. 

Such discrimination avoids the tripping of any RCD, other than that immediately 

upstream of a fault position: 

b With equipment currently available, discrimination is possible at three or four 

different levels of distribution : 

v At the main general distribution board 

v At local general distribution boards 

v At sub-distribution boards 

v At socket outlets for individual appliance protection 

b In general, at distribution boards (and sub-distribution boards, if existing) and on 

individual-appliance protection, devices for automatic disconnection in the event of 

an indirect-contact hazard occurring are installed together with additional protection 

against direct-contact hazards. 

Discrimination between RCDs 

The general specification for achieving total discrimination between two RCDs is as 

follow: 

b The ratio between the rated residual operating currents must be > 2 

b Time delaying the upstream RCD 

Discrimination is achieved by exploiting the several levels of standardized sensitivity: 

30 mA, 100 mA, 300 mA and 1 A and the corresponding tripping times, as shown 

opposite page in Figure F34. 



10,000 

1,000 

500 

300 

250 

200 

150 

130 

100 

60 

40 

10 

t (ms) 

15 

30 

Fig. F34 : Total discrimination at 2 levels 

Fig. F35 : Total discrimination at 2 levels 

A 

A 

60 

100 

RCD 300 mA 

type S 

Relay with separate 

toroidal CT 3 A 

delay time 500 ms 

RCD 

30 mA 

Fig. F36 : Total discrimination at 3 or 4 levels 

B 

RCCB 1 A 


C 

150 

B 

RCCB 300 A 


or type S 

D 

RCCB 

30 mA 

300 

500 

600 

1,000 


Discrimination at 2 levels (see Fig. F35) 

Protection 

b Level A: RCD time-delayed setting I (for industrial device) or type S (for domestic 

device) for protection against indirect contacts 

b Level B: RCD instantaneous, with high sensitivity on circuits supplying socketoutlets 

or appliances at high risk (washing machines, etc.) See also Chapter P 

Clause 3 

Schneider Electric solutions 

b Level A: Compact or Multi 9 circuit-breaker with adaptable RCD module 

(Vigi NS160 or Vigi NC100), setting I or S type 

b Level B: Circuit-breaker with integrated RCD module (DPN Vigi) or adaptable 

RCD module (e.g. Vigi C60 or Vigi NC100) or Vigicompact 

Note: The setting of upstream RCCB must comply with selectivity rules and take into 

account all the downstream earth leakage currents. 

Discrimination at 3 or 4 levels (see Fig. F36) 

Protection 

b Level A: RCD time-delayed (setting III) 

b Level B: RCD time-delayed (setting II) 

b Level C: RCD time-delayed (setting I) or type S 

b Level D: RCD instantaneous 

Schneider Electric solutions 

b Level A: Circuit-breaker associated with RCD and separate toroidal transformer 

(Vigirex RH54A) 

b Level B: Vigicompact or Vigirex 

b Level C: Vigirex, Vigicompact or Vigi NC100 or Vigi C60 

b Level D: 

v Vigicompact or 

v Vigirex or 

v Multi 9 with integrated or adaptable RCD module : Vigi C60 or DPN Vigi 

Note: The setting of upstream RCCB must comply with selectivity rules and take into 

account all the downstream earth leakage currents 


Current 

(mA) 

1 1.5 10 100 500 1,000 (A) 

II 

I 

selective RCDs 

domestic S 

and industrial 

(settings I and II) 

RCD 30 mA 

general domestic 

and industrial setting 0 

F21 


F22 



MV/LV 

NC100 

diff. 

300 mA 

selective 

S 


Discriminative protection at three levels (see Fig. F37) 

Withdrawable Masterpact 

or Visucompact 

NC100L MA 

intantaneous 

300 mA 

Vigicompact 

NS100 

Setting 1 

300 mA 

Leakage current 

of the filter: 20 mA Terminal 

board 

Fig. F37 : Typical 3-level installation, showing the protection of distribution circuits in a TT-earthed system. One motor is provided with specific protection 


Discont. 

Leakage current equal to 3,5 mA per 

socket outlet (Information technology 

equipement): max 4 sockets outlets. 

NS100 MA


Three methods of calculation are commonly 

used: 

b The method of impedances, based on the 

trigonometric addition of the system resistances 

and inductive reactances 

b The method of composition 

b The conventional method, based on an 

assumed voltage drop and the use of prepared 

tables 

6 Implementation of the TN system 

6.1 Preliminary conditions 

At the design stage, the maximum permitted lengths of cable downstream of a 

protective circuit-breaker (or set of fuses) must be calculated, while during the 

installation work certain rules must be fully respected. 

Certain conditions must be observed, as listed below and illustrated in Figure F38. 

1. PE conductor must be regularly connected to earth as much as possible. 

2. The PE conductor must not pass through ferro-magnetic conduit, ducts, etc. or 

be mounted on steel work, since inductive and/or proximity effects can increase the 

effective impedance of the conductor. 

3. In the case of a PEN conductor (a neutral conductor which is also used as a 

protective conductor), connection must be made directly to the earth terminal of an 

appliance (see 3 in Figure F38) before being looped to the neutral terminal of the 

same appliance. 

4. Where the conductor y 6 mm 2 for copper or 10 mm 2 for aluminium, or where a 

cable is movable, the neutral and protective conductors should be separated (i.e. a 

TN-S system should be adopted within the installation). 

5. Earth faults may be cleared by overcurrent-protection devices, i.e. by fuses and 

circuit-breakers. 

The foregoing list indicates the conditions to be respected in the implementation of a 

TN scheme for the protection against indirect contacts. 

RpnA 

PEN 

Notes: 

b The TN scheme requires that the LV neutral of the MV/LV transformer, the exposed 

conductive parts of the substation and of the installation, and the extraneous conductive 

parts in the substation and installation, all be earthed to a common earthing system. 

b For a substation in which the metering is at low-voltage, a means of isolation is required at 

the origin of the LV installation, and the isolation must be clearly visible. 

b A PEN conductor must never be interrupted under any circumstances. Control and 

protective switchgear for the several TN arrangements will be: 

v 3-pole when the circuit includes a PEN conductor, 

v Preferably 4-pole (3 phases + neutral) when the circuit includes a neutral with a separate 

PE conductor. 

Fig. F38 : Implementation of the TN system of earthing 


1 

5 

2 2 

3 

5 

PE N 

4 

TN-C system TN-C-S system 

6.2 Protection against indirect contact 

Methods of determining levels of short-circuit current 

In TN-earthed systems, a short-circuit to earth will, in principle, always provide 

sufficient current to operate an overcurrent device. 

The source and supply mains impedances are much lower than those of the 

installation circuits, so that any restriction in the magnitude of earth-fault currents 

will be mainly caused by the installation conductors (long flexible leads to appliances 

greatly increase the “fault-loop” impedance, with a corresponding reduction of shortcircuit 

current). 

The most recent IEC recommendations for indirect-contact protection on TN earthing 

systems only relates maximum allowable tripping times to the nominal system 

voltage (see Figure F12 in Sub-clause 3.3). 

5 

F23 


F24 



For calculations, modern practice is to use 

software agreed by National Authorities, and 

based on the method of impedances, such as 

Ecodial 3. National Authorities generally also 

publish Guides, which include typical values, 

conductor lengths, etc. 

(1) This results in a calculated current value which is less than 

that it would actually flow. If the overcurrent settings are based 

on this calculated value, then operation of the relay, or fuse, is 

assured. 


The reasoning behind these recommendations is that, for TN systems, the current 

which must flow in order to raise the potential of an exposed conductive part to 50 V 

or more is so high that one of two possibilities will occur: 

b Either the fault path will blow itself clear, practically instantaneously, or 

b The conductor will weld itself into a solid fault and provide adequate current to 

operate overcurrent devices 

To ensure correct operation of overcurrent devices in the latter case, a reasonably 

accurate assessment of short-circuit earth-fault current levels must be determined at 

the design stage of a project. 

A rigorous analysis requires the use of phase-sequence-component techniques 

applied to every circuit in turn. The principle is straightforward, but the amount of 

computation is not considered justifiable, especially since the zero-phase-sequence 

impedances are extremely difficult to determine with any reasonable degree of 

accuracy in an average LV installation. 

Other simpler methods of adequate accuracy are preferred. Three practical methods 

are: 

b The “method of impedances”, based on the summation of all the impedances 

(positive-phase-sequence only) around the fault loop, for each circuit 

b The “method of composition”, which is an estimation of short-circuit current at 

the remote end of a loop, when the short-circuit current level at the near end of the 

loop is known 

b The “conventional method” of calculating the minimum levels of earth-fault 

currents, together with the use of tables of values for obtaining rapid results 

These methods are only reliable for the case in which the cables that make up the 

earth-fault-current loop are in close proximity (to each other) and not separated by 

ferro-magnetic materials. 

Method of impedances 

This method summates the positive-sequence impedances of each item (cable, PE 

conductor, transformer, etc.) included in the earth-fault loop circuit from which the 

short-circuit earth-fault current is calculated, using the formula: 

U 

I = 

2 2 

( R) + ( X) 

� � 

where 

(ΣR) 2 = (the sum of all resistances in the loop) 2 at the design stage of a project. 

and (ΣX) 2 = (the sum of all inductive reactances in the loop) 2 

and U = nominal system phase-to-neutral voltage. 

The application of the method is not always easy, because it supposes a knowledge 

of all parameter values and characteristics of the elements in the loop. In many 

cases, a national guide can supply typical values for estimation purposes. 

Method of composition 

This method permits the determination of the short-circuit current at the end of 

a loop from the known value of short-circuit at the sending end, by means of the 

approximate formula: 

U 

I = Isc 

U+ Zs. Isc 

where 

Isc where = upstream short-circuit current 

I = end-of-loop short-circuit current 

U = nominal system phase voltage 

Zs = impedance of loop 

Note: in this method the individual impedances are added arithmetically (1) as 

opposed to the previous “method of impedances” procedure. 

Conventional method 

This method is generally considered to be sufficiently accurate to fix the upper limit 

of cable lengths. 

Principle 

The principle bases the short-circuit current calculation on the assumption that the 

voltage at the origin of the circuit concerned (i.e. at the point at which the circuit 

protective device is located) remains at 80% or more of the nominal phase to neutral 

voltage. The 80% value is used, together with the circuit loop impedance, to compute 

the short-circuit current. 



The maximum length of any circuit of a 

TN-earthed installation is: 0.8 Uo Sph 

max = 

� 1+ m Ia 

( ) 

The following tables give the length of circuit 

which must not be exceeded, in order that 

persons be protected against indirect contact 

hazards by protective devices 

Id 

A B 

SPE Sph 

C 

Imagn 

Fig. F39 : Calculation of L max. for a TN-earthed system, using 

the conventional method 

L 

PE 

(1) For the definition of type B, C, D circuit-breakers, refer to 

chapter H, clause 4.2 


This coefficient takes account of all voltage drops upstream of the point considered. 

In LV cables, when all conductors of a 3-phase 4-wire circuit are in close proximity 

(which is the normal case), the inductive reactance internal to and between 

conductors is negligibly small compared to the cable resistance. 

This approximation is considered to be valid for cable sizes up to 120 mm 2 . 

Above that size, the resistance value R is increased as follows: 

Core size (mm 2 ) Value of resistance 

S = 150 mm 2 R+15% 

S = 185 mm 2 R+20% 

S = 240 mm 2 R+25% 

The maximum length of a circuit in a TN-earthed installation is given by the formula: 

0.8 Uo Sph 

Lmax 

= 

� 1+ m Ia 

( ) 

where: 

Lmax = maximum length in metres 

Uo = phase volts = 230 V for a 230/400 V system 

ρ = resistivity at normal working temperature in ohm-mm2 /metre 

(= 22.5 10-3 for copper; = 36 10-3 for aluminium) 

Ia = trip current setting for the instantaneous operation of a circuit-breaker, or 

Ia = the current which assures operation of the protective fuse concerned, in the 

specified time. 

m Sph 

= 

SPE 

Sph = cross-sectional area of the phase conductors of the circuit concerned in mm 2 

SPE = cross-sectional area of the protective conductor concerned in mm 2 . 

(see Fig. F39) 

Tables 

The following tables, applicable to TN systems, have been established according to 

the “conventional method” described above. 

The tables give maximum circuit lengths, beyond which the ohmic resistance of the 

conductors will limit the magnitude of the short-circuit current to a level below that 

required to trip the circuit-breaker (or to blow the fuse) protecting the circuit, with 

sufficient rapidity to ensure safety against indirect contact. 

Correction factor m 

Figure F40 indicates the correction factor to apply to the values given in Figures F41 

to F44 next pages, according to the ratio Sph/SPE, the type of circuit, and the 

conductor materials. 

The tables take into account: 

b The type of protection: circuit-breakers or fuses 

b Operating-current settings 

b Cross-sectional area of phase conductors and protective conductors 

b Type of system earthing (see Fig. F45 page F27) 

b Type of circuit-breaker (i.e. B, C or D) (1) 

The tables may be used for 230/400 V systems. 

Equivalent tables for protection by Compact and Multi 9 circuit-breakers (Merlin 

Gerin) are included in the relevant catalogues. 

Circuit Conductor m = Sph/SPE (or PEN) 

material m = 1 m = 2 m = 3 m = 4 

3P + N or P + N Copper 1 0.67 0.50 0.40 

Aluminium 0.62 0.42 0.31 0.25 

Fig. F40 : Correction factor to apply to the lengths given in tables F40 to F43 for 

TN systems 


F25 


F26 



Circuits protected by general purpose circuit-breakers (Fig. F41) 

Nominal Instantaneous or short-time-delayed tripping current Im (amperes) 

cross- 

sectional 

area 


conductors 

mm 2 50 63 80 100 125 160 200 250 320 400 500 560 630 700 800 875 1000 1120 1250 1600 2000 2500 3200 4000 5000 6300 8000 10000 12500 

1.5 100 79 63 50 40 31 25 20 16 13 10 9 8 7 6 6 5 4 4 

2.5 167 133 104 83 67 52 42 33 26 21 17 15 13 12 10 10 8 7 7 5 4 

4 267 212 167 133 107 83 67 53 42 33 27 24 21 19 17 15 13 12 11 8 7 5 4 

6 400 317 250 200 160 125 100 80 63 50 40 36 32 29 25 23 20 18 16 13 10 8 6 5 4 

10 417 333 267 208 167 133 104 83 67 60 53 48 42 38 33 30 27 21 17 13 10 8 7 5 4 

16 427 333 267 213 167 133 107 95 85 76 67 61 53 48 43 33 27 21 17 13 11 8 7 5 4 

25 417 333 260 208 167 149 132 119 104 95 83 74 67 52 42 33 26 21 17 13 10 8 7 

35 467 365 292 233 208 185 167 146 133 117 104 93 73 58 47 36 29 23 19 15 12 9 

50 495 396 317 283 251 226 198 181 158 141 127 99 79 63 49 40 32 25 20 16 13 

70 417 370 333 292 267 233 208 187 146 117 93 73 58 47 37 29 23 19 

95 452 396 362 317 283 263 198 158 127 99 79 63 50 40 32 25 

120 457 400 357 320 250 200 160 125 100 80 63 50 40 32 

150 435 388 348 272 217 174 136 109 87 69 54 43 35 

185 459 411 321 257 206 161 128 103 82 64 51 41 

240 400 320 256 200 160 128 102 80 64 51 

Fig. F41 : Maximum circuit lengths (in metres) for different sizes of copper conductor and instantaneous-tripping-current settings for general-purpose circuit-breakers 

in 230/240 V TN system with m = 1 

Circuits protected by Compact (1) or Multi 9 (1) circuit-breakers for industrial or 

domestic use (Fig. F42 to Fig. F44) 

Sph Rated current (A) 

mm 2 1 2 3 4 6 10 16 20 25 32 40 50 63 80 100 125 

1.5 1200 600 400 300 200 120 75 60 48 37 30 24 19 15 12 10 

2.5 1000 666 500 333 200 125 100 80 62 50 40 32 25 20 16 

4 1066 800 533 320 200 160 128 100 80 64 51 40 32 26 

6 1200 800 480 300 240 192 150 120 96 76 60 48 38 

10 800 500 400 320 250 200 160 127 100 80 64 

16 800 640 512 400 320 256 203 160 128 102 

25 800 625 500 400 317 250 200 160 

35 875 700 560 444 350 280 224 

50 760 603 475 380 304 

Fig. F42 : Maximum circuit lengths (in meters) for different sizes of copper conductor and rated currents for type B (2) circuit-breakers in a 230/240 V single-phase or 

three-phase TN system with m = 1 

(1) Merlin Gerin products. 

(2) For the definition of type B and C circuit-breakers refer to 

chapter H clause 4.2. 



mm 2 1 2 3 4 6 10 16 20 25 32 40 50 63 80 100 125 

1.5 600 300 200 150 100 60 37 30 24 18 15 12 9 7 6 5 

2.5 500 333 250 167 100 62 50 40 31 25 20 16 12 10 8 

4 533 400 267 160 100 80 64 50 40 32 25 20 16 13 

6 600 400 240 150 120 96 75 60 48 38 30 24 19 

10 667 400 250 200 160 125 100 80 63 50 40 32 

16 640 400 320 256 200 160 128 101 80 64 51 

25 625 500 400 312 250 200 159 125 100 80 

35 875 700 560 437 350 280 222 175 140 112 

50 760 594 475 380 301 237 190 152 

Fig. F43 : Maximum circuit lengths (in metres) for different sizes of copper conductor and rated currents for type C (2) circuit-breakers in a 230/240 V single-phase or 






mm 2 1 2 3 4 6 10 16 20 25 32 40 50 63 80 100 125 

1.5 429 214 143 107 71 43 27 21 17 13 11 9 7 5 4 3 

2.5 714 357 238 179 119 71 45 36 29 22 18 14 11 9 7 6 

4 571 381 286 190 114 71 80 46 36 29 23 18 14 11 9 

6 857 571 429 286 171 107 120 69 54 43 34 27 21 17 14 

10 952 714 476 286 179 200 114 89 71 57 45 36 29 23 

16 762 457 286 320 183 143 114 91 73 57 46 37 

25 714 446 500 286 223 179 143 113 89 71 57 

35 625 700 400 313 250 200 159 125 80 100 

50 848 543 424 339 271 215 170 136 109 

Fig. F44 : Maximum circuit lengths (in metres) for different sizes of copper conductor and rated currents for type D (1) circuit-breakers in a 230/240 V single-phase or 


Fig. F45 : Separate earth electrode 

RA1 RA2 

Fig. F46 : Circuit supplying socket-outlets 

Distant location 

(1) For the definition of type D circuit-breaker refer to chapter H 

Sub-clause 4.2. 

Example 

A 3-phase 4-wire (230/400 V) installation is TN-C earthed. A circuit is protected by a 

type B circuit-breaker rated at 63 A, and consists of an aluminium cored cable with 

50 mm 2 phase conductors and a neutral conductor (PEN) of 25 mm 2 . 

What is the maximum length of circuit, below which protection of persons against 

indirect-contact hazards is assured by the instantaneous magnetic tripping relay of 

the circuit-breaker? 

Figure F42 gives, for 50 mm2 and a 63 A type B circuit-breaker, 603 metres, to which 

must be applied a factor of 0.42 (Figure F40 for m Sph 

= = 2). 

SPE 

The maximum length of circuit is therefore: 

603 x 0.42 = 253 metres. 

Particular case where one or more exposed conductive part(s) 

is (are) earthed to a separate earth electrode 

Protection must be provided against indirect contact by a RCD at the origin of any 

circuit supplying an appliance or group of appliances, the exposed conductive parts 

of which are connected to an independent earth electrode. 

The sensitivity of the RCD must be adapted to the earth electrode resistance (RA2 in 

Figure F45). See specifications applicable to TT system. 

6.3 High-sensitivity RCDs (see Fig. F31) 








See 2.2 and chapter P, al section 3. 


F27 


F28 




2 y Irm y 4In 

Great length of cable 

Fire-risk 

location 

PE or PEN 

Fig. F48 : Circuit-breaker with low-set instantaneous magnetic 

tripping 

Phases 

Neutral 

PE 

6.4 Protection in high fire-risk location 

According to IEC 60364-422-3.10, circuits in high fire-risk locations must be 

protected by RCDs of sensitivity y 500 mA. This excludes the TN-C arrangement and 

TN-S must be adopted. 

A preferred sensitivity of 300 mA is mandatory in some countries (see Fig. F47). 

6.5 When the fault current-loop impedance is 

particularly high 

When the earth-fault current is limited due to an inevitably high fault-loop impedance, 

so that the overcurrent protection cannot be relied upon to trip the circuit within the 

prescribed time, the following possibilities should be considered: 

Suggestion 1 (see Fig. F48) 

b Install a circuit-breaker which has a lower instantaneous magnetic tripping level, for 

example: 

2In y Irm y 4In 

This affords protection for persons on circuits which are abnormally long. It must 

be checked, however, that high transient currents such as the starting currents of 

motors will not cause nuisance trip-outs. 

b Schneider Electric solutions 

v Type G Compact (2Im y Irm y 4Im) 

v Type B Multi 9 circuit-breaker 


b Install a RCD on the circuit. The device does not need to be highly-sensitive 

(HS) (several amps to a few tens of amps). Where socket-outlets are involved, the 

particular circuits must, in any case, be protected by HS (y 30 mA) RCDs; generally 

one RCD for a number of socket outlets on a common circuit. 


v RCD Multi 9 NG125 : IΔn = 1 or 3 A 

v Vigicompact REH or REM: IΔn = 3 to 30 A 


Fig. F49 : RCD protection on TN systems with high earth-faultloop 

impedance Fig. F50 : Improved equipotential bonding 


Suggestion 3 

Increase the size of the PE or PEN conductors and/or the phase conductors, to 

reduce the loop impedance. 

Suggestion 4 

Add supplementary equipotential conductors. This will have a similar effect to that 

of suggestion 3, i.e. a reduction in the earth-fault-loop resistance, while at the same 

time improving the existing touch-voltage protection measures. The effectiveness 

of this improvement may be checked by a resistance test between each exposed 

conductive part and the local main protective conductor. 

For TN-C installations, bonding as shown in Figure F50 is not allowed, and 

suggestion 3 should be adopted. 



(1) On systems where the neutral is distributed, as shown in 

Figure F56. 

7 Implementation of the IT system 

The basic feature of the IT earthing system is that, in the event of a short-circuit to 

earth fault, the system can continue to operate without interruption. Such a fault is 

referred to as a “first fault”. 

In this system, all exposed conductive parts of an installation are connected via 

PE conductors to an earth electrode at the installation, while the neutral point of the 

supply transformer is: 

b Either isolated from earth 

b Or connected to earth through a high resistance (commonly 1,000 ohms or more) 

This means that the current through an earth fault will be measured in milli-amps, 

which will not cause serious damage at the fault position, or give rise to dangerous 

touch voltages, or present a fire hazard. The system may therefore be allowed to 

operate normally until it is convenient to isolate the faulty section for repair work. This 

enhances continuity of service. 

In practice, the system earthing requires certain specific measures for its satisfactory 

exploitation: 

b Permanent monitoring of the insulation with respect to earth, which must signal 

(audibly or visually) the occurrence of the first fault 

b A device for limiting the voltage which the neutral point of the supply transformer 

can reach with respect to earth 

b A “first-fault” location routine by an efficient maintenance staff. Fault location is 

greatly facilitated by automatic devices which are currently available 

b Automatic high-speed tripping of appropriate circuit-breakers must take place in 

the event of a “second fault” occurring before the first fault is repaired. The second 

fault (by definition) is an earth fault affecting a different live conductor than that of the 

first fault (can be a phase or neutral conductor) (1) . 

The second fault results in a short-circuit through the earth and/or through 

PE bonding conductors. 

7.1 Preliminary conditions (see Fig. F51 and Fig. F52) 

Minimum functions required Components and devices Examples 

Protection against overvoltages (1) Voltage limiter Cardew C 

at power frequency 

Neutral earthing resistor (2) Resistor Impedance Zx 

(for impedance earthing variation) 

Overall earth-fault monitor (3) Permanent insulation Vigilohm TR22A 

with alarm for first fault condition monitor PIM with alarm feature or XM 200 

Automatic fault clearance (4) Four-pole circuit-breakers Compact circuit-breaker 

on second fault and (if the neutral is distributed) or RCD-MS 

protection of the neutral all 4 poles trip 

conductor against overcurrent 

Location of first fault (5) With device for fault-location Vigilohm system 

on live system, or by successive 

opening of circuits 

Fig. F51 : Essential functions in IT schemes and examples with Merlin Gerin products 

HV/LV 

2 1 3 

Fig. F52 : Positions of essential functions in 3-phase 3-wire IT-earthed system 


4 

4 

5 

4 

L1 

L2 

L3 N 

F29 


F30 



Modern monitoring systems greatly facilitate 

first-fault location and repair 

Fault-location systems comply with 

IEC 61157-9 standard 

MERLIN GERIN 

XM100 

XM100 

(1) On a 230/400 V 3-phase system. 

GR10X 

Fig. F53 : Non-automatic (manual) fault location 


7.2 Protection against indirect contact 

First-fault condition 

The earth-fault current which flows under a first-fault condition is measured in milliamps. 

The fault voltage with respect to earth is the product of this current and the 

resistance of the installation earth electrode and PE conductor (from the faulted 

component to the electrode). This value of voltage is clearly harmless and could 

amount to several volts only in the worst case (1,000 Ω earthing resistor will pass 

230 mA (1) and a poor installation earth-electrode of 50 ohms, would give 11.5 V, for 

example). 

An alarm is given by the permanent insulation monitoring device. 

Principle of earth-fault monitoring 

A generator of very low frequency a.c. current, or of d.c. current, (to reduce the 

effects of cable capacitance to negligible levels) applies a voltage between the 

neutral point of the supply transformer and earth. This voltage causes a small current 

to flow according to the insulation resistance to earth of the whole installation, plus 

that of any connected appliance. 

Low-frequency instruments can be used on a.c. systems which generate transient 

d.c. components under fault conditions. Certain versions can distinguish between 

resistive and capacitive components of the leakage current. 

Modern equipment allow the measurement of leakage-current evolution, so that 

prevention of a first fault can be achieved. 

Examples of equipment 

b Manual fault-location (see Fig. F53) 

The generator may be fixed (example: XM100) or portable (example: GR10X 

permitting the checking of dead circuits) and the receiver, together with the magnetic 

clamp-type pick-up sensor, are portable. 

RM10N 

P12 P50 

P100 ON/OFF 

b Fixed automatic fault location (see Fig. F54 next page) 

The monitoring relay XM100, together with the fixed detectors XD1 or XD12 (each 

connected to a toroidal CT embracing the conductors of the circuit concerned) 

provide a system of automatic fault location on a live installation. 

Moreover, the level of insulation is indicated for each monitored circuit, and two 

levels are checked: the first level warns of unusually low insulation resistance so that 

preventive measures may be taken, while the second level indicates a fault condition 

and gives an alarm. 



MERLIN GERIN 

XM100 

XM100 

Fig. F54 : Fixed automatic fault location 

MERLIN GERIN 

XM100 

XD1 

XM100 

Fig. F55 : Automatic fault location and insulation-resistance data logging 


XD1 XD1 XD12 


Toroidal CTs 

1 to 12 circuits 

b Automatic monitoring, logging, and fault location (see Fig. F55) 

The Vigilohm System also allows access to a printer and/or a PC which provides 

a global review of the insulation level of an entire installation, and records the 

chronological evolution of the insulation level of each circuit. 

The central monitor XM100, together with the localization detectors XD08 and XD16, 

associated with toroidal CTs from several circuits, as shown below in Figure F55, 

provide the means for this automatic exploitation. 

MERLIN GERIN 

XL08 

897 

MERLIN GERIN 

XD08 XD16 

XL16 

678 

F31 


F32 



Three methods of calculation are commonly 

used: 

b The method of impedances, based on the 

trigonometric addition of the system resistances 

and inductive reactances 

b The method of composition 

b The conventional method, based on an 

assumed voltage drop and the use of prepared 

tables 


Implementation of permanent insulation-monitoring (PIM) devices 

b Connection 

The PIM device is normally connected between the neutral (or articificial neutral) 

point of the power-supply transformer and its earth electrode. 

b Supply 

Power supply to the PIM device should be taken from a highly reliable source. In 

practice, this is generally directly from the installation being monitored, through 

overcurrent protective devices of suitable short-circuit current rating. 

b Level settings 

Certain national standards recommend a first setting at 20% below the insulation 

level of the new installation. This value allows the detection of a reduction of the 

insulation quality, necessitating preventive maintenance measures in a situation of 

incipient failure. 

The detection level for earth-fault alarm will be set at a much lower level. 

By way of an example, the two levels might be: 

v New installation insulation level: 100 kΩ 

v Leakage current without danger: 500 mA (fire risk at > 500 mA) 

v Indication levels set by the consumer: 

- Threshold for preventive maintenance: 0.8 x 100 = 80 kΩ 

- Threshold for short-circuit alarm: 500 Ω 

Notes: 

v Following a long period of shutdown, during which the whole, or part of the installation 

remains de-energized, humidity can reduce the general level of insulation resistance. 

This situation, which is mainly due to leakage current over the damp surface of 

healthy insulation, does not constitute a fault condition, and will improve rapidly as the 

normal temperature rise of current-carrying conductors reduces the surface humidity. 

v The PIM device (XM) can measure separately the resistive and the capacitive 

current components of the leakage current to earth, thereby deriving the true 

insulation resistance from the total permanent leakage current. 

The case of a second fault 

A second earth fault on an IT system (unless occurring on the same conductor 

as the first fault) constitutes a phase-phase or phase-to-neutral fault, and whether 

occurring on the same circuit as the first fault, or on a different circuit, overcurrent 

protective devices (fuses or circuit-breakers) would normally operate an automatic 

fault clearance. 

The settings of overcurrent tripping relays and the ratings of fuses are the basic 

parameters that decide the maximum practical length of circuit that can be 

satisfactorily protected, as discussed in Sub-clause 6.2. 

Note: In normal circumstances, the fault current path is through common 

PE conductors, bonding all exposed conductive parts of an installation, and so the 

fault loop impedance is sufficiently low to ensure an adequate level of fault current. 

Where circuit lengths are unavoidably long, and especially if the appliances of a 

circuit are earthed separately (so that the fault current passes through two earth 

electrodes), reliable tripping on overcurrent may not be possible. 

In this case, an RCD is recommended on each circuit of the installation. 

Where an IT system is resistance earthed, however, care must be taken to ensure 

that the RCD is not too sensitive, or a first fault may cause an unwanted trip-out. 

Tripping of residual current devices which satisfy IEC standards may occur at values 

of 0.5 ΙΔn to ΙΔn, where ΙΔn is the nominal residual-current setting level. 

Methods of determining levels of short-circuit current 

A reasonably accurate assessment of short-circuit current levels must be carried out 

at the design stage of a project. 

A rigorous analysis is not necessary, since current magnitudes only are important for 

the protective devices concerned (i.e. phase angles need not be determined) so that 

simplified conservatively approximate methods are normally used. Three practical 

methods are: 

b The method of impedances, based on the vectorial summation of all the (positivephase-sequence) 

impedances around a fault-current loop 

b The method of composition, which is an approximate estimation of short-circuit 

current at the remote end of a loop, when the level of short-circuit current at the near 

end of the loop is known. Complex impedances are combined arithmetically in this 

method 

b The conventional method, in which the minimum value of voltage at the origin of 

a faulty circuit is assumed to be 80% of the nominal circuit voltage, and tables are 

used based on this assumption, to give direct readings of circuit lengths. 



The software Ecodial is based on the “method 

of impedance” 

The maximum length of an IT earthed circuit is: 

b For a 3-phase 3-wire scheme 

0.8 Uo 3 Sph 

Lmax 

= 

2 �I a 1+ 

m 

( ) 

b For a 3-phase 4-wire scheme 

0.8 Uo S1 

Lmax 

= 

2 �I a 1+ 

m 

( ) 

N 

PE 

Id 

C 

D 

Non distributed neutral 

(1) Reminder: There is no length limit for earth-fault protection 

on a TT scheme, since protection is provided by RCDs of high 

sensitivity. 


These methods are reliable only for the cases in which wiring and cables which 

make up the fault-current loop are in close proximity (to each other) and are not 

separated by ferro-magnetic materials. 

Methods of impedances 

This method as described in Sub-clause 6.2, is identical for both the IT and 

TN systems of earthing. 

Methods of composition 

This method as described in Sub-clause 6.2, is identical for both the IT and 

TN systems of earthing. 

Conventional method (see Fig. F56) 

The principle is the same for an IT system as that described in Sub-clause 6.2 for a 

TN system : the calculation of maximum circuit lengths which should not be exceeded 

downstream of a circuit-breaker or fuses, to ensure protection by overcurrent devices. 

It is clearly impossible to check circuit lengths for every feasible combination of two 

concurrent faults. 

All cases are covered, however, if the overcurrent trip setting is based on the 

assumption that a first fault occurs at the remote end of the circuit concerned, 

while the second fault occurs at the remote end of an identical circuit, as already 

mentioned in Sub-clause 3.4. This may result, in general, in one trip-out only 

occurring (on the circuit with the lower trip-setting level), thereby leaving the system 

in a first-fault situation, but with one faulty circuit switched out of service. 

b For the case of a 3-phase 3-wire installation the second fault can only cause a 

phase/phase short-circuit, so that the voltage to use in the formula for maximum 

circuit length is 3 Uo. 

The maximum circuit length is given by: 

0.8 Uo 3 Sph 

Lmax 

= 

metres 

2 �I a 1+ 

m 

( ) 

b For the case of a 3-phase 4-wire installation the lowest value of fault current will 

occur if one of the faults is on a neutral conductor. In this case, Uo is the value to use 

for computing the maximum cable length, and 

0.8 Uo S1 

Lmax 

= 

2 �I a 1+ 

m 

( ) 

metres 

i.e. 50% only of the length permitted for a TN scheme (1) 

Fig. F56 : Calculation of Lmax. for an IT-earthed system, showing fault-current path for a double-fault condition 

Id 

A 

B 

N 

PE 


Id 

Id 

Distributed neutral 

F33 


F34 



The following tables (1) give the length of circuit 

which must not be exceeded, in order that 

persons be protected against indirect contact 

hazards by protective devices 

Fig. F62 : Circuit supplying socket-outlets 

(1) The tables are those shown in Sub-clause 6.2 (Figures 

F41 to F44). However, the table of correction factors (Figure 

F57) which takes into account the ratio Sph/SPE, and of the 

type of circuit (3-ph 3-wire; 3-ph 4-wire; 1-ph 2-wire) as well 

as conductor material, is specific to the IT system, and differs 

from that for TN. 


In the preceding formulae: 

Lmax = longest circuit in metres 

Uo = phase-to-neutral voltage (230 V on a 230/400 V system) 

ρ = resistivity at normal operating temperature (22.5 x 10-3 ohms-mm2 /m for copper, 

36 x 10-3 ohms-mm2 /m for aluminium) 

Ia = overcurrent trip-setting level in amps, or Ia = current in amps required to clear 

the fuse in the specified time 

m Sph 

= 

SPE 

SPE = cross-sectional area of PE conductor in mm 2 

S1 = S neutral if the circuit includes a neutral conductor 

S1 = Sph if the circuit does not include a neutral conductor 

Tables 

The following tables have been established according to the “conventional method” 

described above. 

The tables give maximum circuit lengths, beyond which the ohmic resistance of 

the conductors will limit the magnitude of the short-circuit current to a level below 

that required to trip the circuit-breaker (or to blow the fuse) protecting the circuit, 

with sufficient rapidity to ensure safety against indirect contact. The tables take into 

account: 

b The type of protection: circuit-breakers or fuses, operating-current settings 

b Cross-sectional area of phase conductors and protective conductors 

b Type of earthing scheme 

b Correction factor: Figure F57 indicates the correction factor to apply to the lengths 

given in tables F40 to F43, when considering an IT system 

Circuit Conductor m = Sph/SPE (or PEN) 

material m = 1 m = 2 m = 3 m = 4 

3 phases Copper 0.86 0.57 0.43 0.34 

Aluminium 0.54 0.36 0.27 0.21 

3ph + N or 1ph + N Copper 0.50 0.33 0.25 0.20 

Aluminium 0.31 0.21 0.16 0.12 

Fig. F57 : Correction factor to apply to the lengths given in tables F41 to F44 for TN systems 

Example 

A 3-phase 3-wire 230/400 V installation is IT-earthed. 

One of its circuits is protected by a circuit-breaker rated at 63 A, and consists of an 

aluminium-cored cable with 50 mm 2 phase conductors. The 25 mm 2 PE conductor 

is also aluminum. What is the maximum length of circuit, below which protection of 

persons against indirect-contact hazards is assured by the instantaneous magnetic 

tripping relay of the circuit-breaker? 

Figure F42 indicates 603 metres, to which must be applied a correction factor of 0.36 

(m = 2 for aluminium cable). 

The maximum length is therefore 217 metres. 

7.3 High-sensitivity RCDs 








See 2.2 and chapter P, al section 3 




2 y I rm y 4I n 

Great length of cable 

PE 

Fig. F60 : A circuit-breaker with low-set instantaneous 

magnetic trip 

Fire-risk 

location 

Phases 

Neutral 

PE 


7.4 Protection in high fire-risk locations 

Protection by a RCD of sensitivity y 500 mA at the origin of the circuit supplying the 

fire-risk locations is mandatory in some countries (see Fig. F59). 

A preferred sensitivity of 300 mA may be adopted. 

7.5 When the fault current-loop impedance is 

particularly high 

When the earth-fault current is restricted due to an inevitably high fault-loop 

impedance, so that the overcurrent protection cannot be relied upon to trip the circuit 

within the prescribed time, the following possibilities should be considered: 


b Install a circuit-breaker which has an instantaneous magnetic tripping element with 

an operation level which is lower than the usual setting, for example: 

2In y Irm y 4In 

This affords protection for persons on circuits which are abnormally long. It must 

be checked, however, that high transient currents such as the starting currents of 

motors will not cause nuisance trip-outs. 


v Type G Compact (2Im y Irm y 4Im) 



Install a RCD on the circuit. The device does not need to be highly-sensitive (HS) 

(several amps to a few tens of amps). Where socket-outlets are involved, the 

particular circuits must, in any case, be protected by HS (y 30 mA) RCDs; generally 

one RCD for a number of socket outlets on a common circuit. 


v RCD Multi 9 NG125 : ΙΔn = 1 or 3 A 

v Vigicompact REH or REM: ΙΔn = 3 to 30 A 

Fig. F61 : RCD protection Fig. F62 : Improved equipotential bonding 

Suggestion 3 

Increase the size of the PE conductors and/or the phase conductors, to reduce the 

loop impedance. 


Add supplementary equipotential conductors. This will have a similar effect to that 

of suggestion 3, i.e. a reduction in the earth-fault-loop resistance, while at the same 

time improving the existing touch-voltage protection measures. The effectiveness 

of this improvement may be checked by a resistance test between each exposed 

conductive part and the local main protective conductor. 


F35 


F36 



Industrial circuit-breakers with an integrated 

RCD are covered in IEC 60947-2 and its 

appendix B 

Household or domestic circuit-breakers with 

an integrated RCD are covered in IEC 60898, 

IEC 61008 and IEC 61009 

8 Residual current devices (RCDs) 

8.1 Types of RCDs 

Residual current devices (RCD) are commonly incorporated in or associated with the 

following components: 

b Industrial-type moulded-case circuit-breakers (MCCB) conforming to IEC 60947-2 

and its appendix B and M 

b Industrial type miniature circuit-breakers (MCB) conforming to IEC 60947-2 and its 

appendix B and M 

b Household and similar miniature circuit-breakers (MCB) complying with IEC 60898, 

IEC 61008, IEC 61009 

b Residual load switch conforming to particular national standards 

b Relays with separate toroidal (ring-type) current transformers, conforming to 

IEC 60947-2 Appendix M 

RCDs are mandatorily used at the origin of TT-earthed installations, where their 

ability to discriminate with other RCDs allows selective tripping, thereby ensuring the 

level of service continuity required. 

Industrial type circuit-breakers with integrated or adaptable 

RCD module (see Fig. F63) 

Industrial type circuit-breaker 

Vigi Compact 

Fig. F63 : Industrial-type CB with RCD module 

Fig. F64 : Domestic residual current circuit-breakers 

(RCCBs) for earth leakage protection 


Multi 9 DIN-rail industrial 

Circuit-breaker with adaptable Vigi RCD module 

Adaptable residual current circuit-breakers, including DIN-rail mounted units (e.g. 

Compact or Multi 9), are available, to which may be associated an auxiliary RCD 

module (e.g. Vigi). 

The ensemble provides a comprehensive range of protective functions (isolation, 

protection against short-circuit, overload, and earth-fault. 

Household and similar miniature circuit-breakers with RCD 

(see Fig. F64) 

The incoming-supply circuitbreaker 

can also have timedelayed 

characteristics and 

integrate a RCD (type S). 

“Monobloc” Déclic Vigi residual current circuit-breakers 

intended for protection of terminal socket-outlet circuits 

in domestic and tertiary sector applications.


Residual current load break switches are 

covered by particular national standards. 

RCDs with separate toroidal current 

transformers are standardized in IEC 60947-2 

appendix M 

I1 I2 

Fig. F66 : The principle of RCD operation 

I3 


Residual current circuit-breakers and RCDs with separate 

toroidal current transformer (see Fig. F65) 

RCDs with separate toroidal CTs can be used in association with circuit-breakers or 

contactors. 

Fig. F65 : RCDs with separate toroidal current transformers 

8.2 Description 

Principle 

The essential features are shown schematically in Figure F66 below. 

A magnetic core encompasses all the current-carrying conductors of an electric 

circuit and the magnetic flux generated in the core will depend at every instant on 

the arithmetical sum of the currents; the currents passing in one direction being 

considered as positive (Ι1), while those passing in the opposite direction will be 

negative (Ι2). 

In a normally healthy circuit Ι1 + Ι2 = 0 and there will be no flux in the magnetic core, 

and zero e.m.f. in its coil. 

An earth-fault current Ιd will pass through the core to the fault, but will return to the 

source via the earth, or via protective conductors in a TN-earthed system. 

The current balance in the conductors passing through the magnetic core therefore 

no longer exists, and the difference gives rise to a magnetic flux in the core. 

The difference current is known as the “residual” current and the principle is referred 

to as the “residual current” principle. 

The resultant alternating flux in the core induces an e.m.f. in its coil, so that a current 

I3 flows in the tripping-device operating coil. If the residual current exceeds the value 

required to operate the tripping device either directly or via an electronic relay, then 

the associated circuit-breaker will trip. 

8.3 Sensitivity of RDCs to disturbances 

In certain cases, aspects of the environment can disturb the correct operation of 

RCDs: 

b “nuisance” tripping: Break in power supply without the situation being really 

hazardous. This type of tripping is often repetitive, causing major inconvenience and 

detrimental to the quality of the user's electrical power supply. 

b non-tripping, in the event of a hazard. Less perceptible than nuisance tripping, 

these malfunctions must still be examined carefully since they undermine user safety. 

This is why international standards define 3 categories of RCDs according to their 

immunity to this type of disturbance (see below). 


F37 


F38 



100% 

90% 

10% 

60% 

Umax 

0.5U 

U 

1.2 s 50 s 

Fig. F68 : Standardized 1.2/50 µs voltage transient wave 

1 

0.9 

0.5 

0.1 

I 

I 

ca.0.5 s 

10 s (f = 100 kHz) 

Fig. F67 : Standardized 0.5 µs/100 kHz current transient wave 

Fig. F69 : Standardized current-impulse wave 8/20 µs 

t 

t 

t 


Main disturbance types 

Permanent earth leakage currents 

Every LV installation has a permanent leakage current to earth, which is either due 

to: 

b Unbalance of the intrinsic capacitance between live conductors and earth for threephase 

circuits or 

b Capacitance between live conductors and earth for single-phase circuits 

The larger the installation the greater its capacitance with consequently increased 

leakage current. 

The capacitive current to earth is sometimes increased significantly by filtering 

capacitors associated with electronic equipment (automation, IT and computerbased 

systems, etc.). 

In the absence of more precise data, permanent leakage current in a given 

installation can be estimated from the following values, measured at 230 V 50 Hz: 

Single-phase or three-phase line: 1.5 mA /100m 

b Heating floor: 1mA / kW 

b Fax terminal, printer: 1 mA 

b Microcomputer, workstation: 2 mA 

b Copy machine: 1.5 mA 

Since RCDs complying with IEC and many national standards may operate under, 

the limitation of permanent leakage current to 0.25 IΔn, by sub-division of circuits 

will, in practice, eliminate any unwanted tripping. 

For very particular cases, such as the extension, or partial renovation of extended 

IT-earthed installations, the manufacturers must be consulted. 

High frequency components (harmonics, transients, etc.), are found in computer 

equipment power supplies, converters, motors with speed regulators, fluorescent 

lighting systems and in the vicinity of high power switching devices and reactive 

energy compensation banks. 

Part of these high frequency currents may flow to earth through parasite 

capacitances (line, units, etc.). Although not hazardous for the user, these currents 

can still cause the tripping of differential devices. 

Energization 

The initial energization of the capacitances mentioned above gives rise to high 

frequency transient currents of very short duration, similar to that shown in 

Figure F67. 

The sudden occurrence of a first-fault on an IT-earthed system also causes transient 

earth-leakage currents at high frequency, due to the sudden rise of the two healthy 

phases to phase/phase voltage above earth. 

Common mode overvoltages 

Electrical networks are subjected to overvoltages due to lightning strikes or to abrupt 

changes of system operating conditions (faults, fuse operation, switching, etc.). 

These sudden changes often cause large transient voltages and currents in inductive 

and capacitive circuits. Records have established that, on LV systems, overvoltages 

remain generally below 6 kV, and that they can be adequately represented by the 

conventional 1.2/50 μs impulse wave (see Fig. F68). 

These overvoltages give rise to transient currents represented by a current impulse 

wave of the conventional 8/20 μs form, having a peak value of several tens of 

amperes (see Fig. F69). 

The transient currents flow to earth via the capacitances of the installation. 

Non-sinusoidal fault currents 

An RCD must be selected taking into account the type of supplied load. This applies 

in particular to semiconductor-based devices for which fault currents are not always 

sinusoidal. 

Type AC, A, B 

Standard IEC 60755 (General requirements for residual current operated protective 

devices) defines three types of RCD depending on the characteristics of the fault 

current: 

b Type AC 

RCD for which tripping is ensured for residual sinusoidal alternating currents. 

b Type A 

RCD for which tripping is ensured: 

v for residual sinusoidal alternating currents, 

v for residual pulsating direct currents, 




b Type B 

RCD for which tripping is ensured: 

v as for type A, 

v for pure direct residual currents which may result from three-phase rectifying 

circuits. 

Cold: in the cases of temperatures under - 5 °C, very high sensitivity 

electromechanical relays in the RCD may be “welded” by the condensation – freezing 

action. 

Type “Si” devices can operate under temperatures down to - 25 °C. 

Atmospheres with high concentrations of chemicals or dust: the special alloys 

used to make the RCDs can be notably damaged by corrosion. Dust can also block 

the movement of mechanical parts. 

See the measures to be taken according to the levels of severity defined by 

standards in Fig. F70. 

Regulations define the choice of earth leakage protection and its implementation. 

The main reference texts are as follows: 

b Standard IEC 60364-3: 

v This gives a classification (AFx) for external influences in the presence of corrosive 

or polluting substances. 

v It defines the choice of materials to be used according to extreme influences. 

Disturbed 

network 

Influence of 

the electrical 

network 

Clean network 

Superimmunized 

residual current 

protections 

Type A if: k 

Standard 

immunized 


protections 

Type AC 

Fig. F70 : External influence classification according to IEC 60364-3 standard 


SiE k 


protections 

SiE k 


protections 

+ 

Appropriate 

additional 

protection 

(sealed cabinet 

or unit) 

AF1 AF2 AF3 AF4 

b External 

influences: 

negligible, 

b Equipment 

characteristics: 

normal. 

b External 

influences: 

presence 

of corrosive 

or polluting 

atmospheric 

agents, 

b Equipment 


e.g. conformity 

with salt mist 

or atmospheric 

pollution tests. 

b External 

influences: 

intermittent 

or accidental 

action of 

certain 

common 

chemicals, 

b Equipment 


corrosion 

protection. 

Examples of exposed sites External influences 

SiE k 


protections 

+ 

Appropriate 

additional 

protection 

(sealed cabinet 

or unit + 

overpressure) 

b External 

influences: 

permanent 

action of 

corrosive 

or polluting 

chemicals 

b Equipment 


specifically 

studied 

according to 

the type of 

products. 

Iron and steel works. Presence of sulfur, sulfur vapor, hydrogen 

sulfide. 

Marinas, trading ports, boats, sea edges, naval 

shipyards. 

Salt atmospheres, humid outside, low 

temperatures. 

Swimming pools, hospitals, food & beverage. Chlorinated compounds. 

Petrochemicals. Hydrogen, combustion gases, nitrogen 

oxides. 

Breeding facilities, tips. Hydrogen sulfide. 

F39 


F40 




Immunity level for Merlin Gerin residual current devices 

The Merlin Gerin range comprises various types of RCDs allowing earth leakage 

protection to be adapted to each application. The table below indicates the choices to 

be made according to the type of probable disturbances at the point of installation. 

Device type Nuisance 

trippings 

High 

frequency 

leakage 

current 

AC b 


Non-trippings 

Fault current Low 

Rectified 

alternating 

Pure direct 

temperatures 

(down to 

- 25 °C) 

A b b b 

SI b b b b b 

Corrosion 

Dust 

SiE b b b b b b 

B b b b b b b 

Fig. F71 : Immunity level of Merlin Gerin RCDs 

Immunity to nuisance tripping 

Type Si/SiE RCDs have been designed to avoid nuisance tripping or non-tripping in 

case of polluted network , lightning effect, high frequency currents, RF waves, etc. 

Figure F72 below indicates the levels of tests undergone by this type of RCDs. 

Disturbance type Rated test wave Immunity 

Continuous disturbances 

Multi9 : 

ID-RCCB, DPN Vigi, Vigi C60, Vigi 

C120, Vigi NG125 

SI / SiE type 

Harmonics 1 kHz Earth leakage current = 8 x I∆n 

Transient disturbances 

Lightning induced overvoltage 1.2 / 50 μs pulse 

(IEC/EN 61000-4-5) 

Lightning induced current 8 / 20 μs pulse 

(IEC/EN 61008) 

Switching transient, indirect 

lightning currents 

Downstream surge arrester 

operation, capacitance loading 

Electromagnetic compatibility 

Inductive load switchings 

fluorescent lights, motors, etc.) 

Fluorescent lights, thyristor 

controlled circuits, etc. 

RF waves (TV& 

radio, broadcact, 

telecommunications,etc.) 

0.5 μs / 100 kHz 

“ ring wave ” 

(IEC/EN 61008) 

4.5 kV between conductors 5.5 kV / 

earth 

5 kA peak 

400 A peak 

10 ms pulse 500 A 

Repeated bursts 

(IEC 61000-4-4) 

RF conducted 

waves 

(IEC 61000-4-6) 

RF radiated waves 

80 MHz to 1 GHz 

(IEC 61000-4-3) 

4 kV / 400 kHz 

66 mA (15 kHz to 150 kHz) 

30 V (150 kHz to 230 MHz) 

30 V / m 

Fig. F72 : Immunity to nuisance tripping tests undergone by Merlin Gerin RCDs



Recommendations concerning the installation of RCDs with 

separate toroidal current transformers 

The detector of residual current is a closed magnetic circuit (usually circular) of 

very high magnetic permeability, on which is wound a coil of wire, the ensemble 

constituting a toroidal (or ring-type) current transformer. 

Because of its high permeability, any small deviation from perfect symmetry of 

the conductors encompassed by the core, and the proximity of ferrous material 

(steel enclosure, chassis members, etc.) can affect the balance of magnetic forces 

sufficiently, at times of large load currents (motor-starting current, transformer 

energizing current surge, etc.) to cause unwanted tripping of the RCD. 

Unless particular measures are taken, the ratio of operating current Ι∆n to maximum 

phase current Ιph (max.) is generally less than 1/1,000. 

This limit can be increased substantially (i.e. the response can be desensitized) by 

adopting the measures shown in Figure F73 , and summarized in Figure F74. 


L = twice the diameter of 

the magnetic ring core 

Fig. F73 : Three measures to reduce the ratio Ι∆n/Ιph (max.) 

Measures Diameter Sensitivity 

(mm) diminution factor 

Careful centralizing of cables through the ring core 3 

Oversizing of the ring core ø 50 → ø 100 2 

ø 80 → ø 200 2 

ø 120 → ø 300 6 

Use of a steel or soft-iron shielding sleeve ø 50 4 

b Of wall thickness 0.5 mm ø 80 3 

b Of length 2 x inside diameter of ring core ø 120 3 

b Completely surrounding the conductors and ø 200 2 

overlapping the circular core equally at both ends 

These measures can be combined. By carefully centralizing the cables in a ring core 

of 200 mm diameter, where a 50 mm core would be large enough, and using a sleeve, 

the ratio 1/1,000 could become 1/30,000. 

Fig. F74 : Means of reducing the ratio IΔn/Iph (max.) 

L 

F41 


F42 



a b 

In 

In1 

Fig. F75 : Residual current circuit-breakers (RCCBs) 

In 

In1 In2 In3 In4 

Choice of characteristics of a residual-current circuit-breaker 

(RCCB - IEC 61008) 

Rated current 

The rated current of a RCCB is chosen according to the maximum sustained load 

current it will carry. 

b If the RCCB is connected in series with, and downstream of a circuit-breaker, the 

rated current of both items will be the same, i.e. Ιn u Ιn1 (1) (see Fig. F75a) 

b If the RCCB is located upstream of a group of circuits, protected by circuitbreakers, 

as shown in Figure F75b, then the RCCB rated current will be given by: 

Ιn u ku x ks (Ιn1 + Ιn2 + Ιn3 + Ιn4) 

Circuit-breaker and RCCB association – maxi Ιsc (r.m.s) value in kA 

Electrodynamic withstand requirements 

Protection against short-circuits must be provided by an upstream SCPD (Short- 

Circuit Protective Device) but it is considered that where the RCCB is located in the 

same distribution box (complying with the appropriate standards) as the downstream 

circuit-breakers (or fuses), the short-circuit protection afforded by these (outgoingcircuit) 

SCPDs is an adequate alternative. Coordination between the RCCB and the 

SCPDs is necessary, and manufacturers generally provide tables associating RCCBs 

and circuit-breakers or fuses (see Fig. F76). 

Upstream circuit-breaker DT40 DT40N C60N C60H C60L C120N C120H NG125N NG125H 

Downstream 2P I 20A 6.5 6.5 6.5 6.5 6.5 3 4.5 4.5 4.5 

RCCB 230V IN-A 40A 6 10 20 30 30 10 10 15 15 

IN-A 63A 6 10 20 30 30 10 10 15 15 

I 100A 15 15 15 15 

4P I 20A 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 2 3 3 3 

400V IN-A 40A 6 10 10 15 15 7 7 15 15 

IN-A 63A 6 10 10 15 15 7 7 15 15 

NG 125NA 10 16 25 50 

Fuses and RCCB association – maxi Ιsc (r.m.s) value in kA 

gG upstream fuse 20A 63A 100A 125A 

Downstream 2P I 20A 8 

RCCB 230V IN-A 40A 30 20 

IN-A 63A 30 20 

I 100A 6 

4P I 20A 8 

400V IN-A 40A 30 20 

IN-A 63A 30 20 

NG 125NA 50 

Fig. F76 : Typical manufacturers coordination table for RCCBs, circuit-breakers, and fuses (Merlin Gerin products) 



2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

Chapter G 

Sizing and protection of conductors 

Contents 

General G2 

1.1 Methodology and definition G2 

1.2 Overcurrent protection principles G4 

1.3 Practical values for a protective scheme G4 

1.4 Location of protective devices G6 

1.5 Conductors in parallel G6 

Practical method for determining the smallest allowable G7 

cross-sectional area of circuit conductors 

2.1 General G7 

2.2 General method for cables G7 

2.3 Recommended simplified approach for cables G16 

2.4 Busbar trunking systems G18 

Determination of voltage drop G20 

3.1 Maximum voltage drop limit G20 

3.2 Calculation of voltage drop in steady load conditions G21 

Short-circuit current G24 

4.1 Short-circuit current at the secondary terminals of G24 

a MV/LV distribution transformer 

4.2 3-phase short-circuit current (Isc) at any point within G25 

a LV installation 

4.3 Isc at the receiving end of a feeder in terms of the Isc G28 

at its sending end 

4.4 Short-circuit current supplied by an alternator or an inverter G29 

Particular cases of short-circuit current G30 

5.1 Calculation of minimum levels of short-circuit current G30 

5.2 Verification of the withstand capabilities of cables under G35 

short-circuit conditions 

Protective earthing conductor G37 

6.1 Connection and choice G37 

6.2 Conductor sizing G38 

6.3 Protective conductor between MV/LV transformer and G40 

the main general distribution board (MGDB) 

6.4 Equipotential conductor G41 

The neutral conductor G42 

7.1 Sizing the neutral conductor G42 

7.2 Protection of the neutral conductor G42 

7.3 Breaking of the neutral conductor G44 

7.4 Isolation of the neutral conductor G44 

Worked example of cable calculation G46 


G 



G2 


Component parts of an electric circuit and its 

protection are determined such that all normal 

and abnormal operating conditions are satisfied 

(1) The term “cabling” in this chapter, covers all insulated 

conductors, including multi-core and single-core cables and 

insulated wires drawn into conduits, etc. 


. Methodology and definition 

Methodology (see Fig. G ) 

Following a preliminary analysis of the power requirements of the installation, as 

described in Chapter B Clause 4, a study of cabling (1) and its electrical protection is 

undertaken, starting at the origin of the installation, through the intermediate stages 

to the final circuits. 

The cabling and its protection at each level must satisfy several conditions at the 

same time, in order to ensure a safe and reliable installation, e.g. it must: 

b Carry the permanent full load current, and normal short-time overcurrents 

b Not cause voltage drops likely to result in an inferior performance of certain loads, 

for example: an excessively long acceleration period when starting a motor, etc. 

Moreover, the protective devices (circuit-breakers or fuses) must: 

b Protect the cabling and busbars for all levels of overcurrent, up to and including 

short-circuit currents 

b Ensure protection of persons against indirect contact hazards, particularly in 

TN- and IT- earthed systems, where the length of circuits may limit the magnitude 

of short-circuit currents, thereby delaying automatic disconnection (it may be 

remembered that TT- earthed installations are necessarily protected at the origin by 

a RCD, generally rated at 300 mA). 

The cross-sectional areas of conductors are determined by the general method 

described in Sub-clause 2 of this Chapter. Apart from this method some national 

standards may prescribe a minimum cross-sectional area to be observed for reasons 

of mechanical endurance. Particular loads (as noted in Chapter N) require that the 

cable supplying them be oversized, and that the protection of the circuit be likewise 

modified. 

Fig. G1 : Flow-chart for the selection of cable size and protective device rating for a given circuit 


Power demand: 

- kVA to be supplied 

- Maximum load current I B 

Conductor sizing: 

- Selection of conductor type and insulation 

- Selection of method of installation 

- Taking account of correction factors for 

different environment conditions 

- Determination of cross-sectional areas using 

tables giving the current carrying capability 

Verification of the maximum voltage drop: 

- Steady state conditions 

- Motor starting conditions 

Calculation of short-circuit currents: 

- Upstream short-circuit power 

- Maximum values 

- Minimum values at conductor end 

Selection of protective devices: 

- Rated current 

- Breaking capability 

- Implementation of cascading 

- Check of discrimination



Definitions 

Maximum load current: IB 

b At the final circuits level, this current corresponds to the rated kVA of the load. 

In the case of motor-starting, or other loads which take a high in-rush current, 

particularly where frequent starting is concerned (e.g. lift motors, resistance-type 

spot welding, and so on) the cumulative thermal effects of the overcurrents must be 

taken into account. Both cables and thermal type relays are affected. 

b At all upstream circuit levels this current corresponds to the kVA to be supplied, 

which takes account of the factors of simultaneity (diversity) and utilization, ks and ku 

respectively, as shown in Figure G2. 

80 A 60 A 100 A 

Fig. G2 : Calculation of maximum load current IB 

Maximum permissible current: Iz 


Main distribution 

board 

Combined factors of simultaneity 

(or diversity) and utilization: 

ks x ku = 0.69 

IB = (80+60+100+50) x 0.69 = 200 A 

M 

Sub-distribution 

board 

50 A 

Normal load 

motor current 

50 A 

This is the maximum value of current that the cabling for the circuit can carry 

indefinitely, without reducing its normal life expectancy. 

The current depends, for a given cross sectional area of conductors, on several 

parameters: 

b Constitution of the cable and cable-way (Cu or Alu conductors; PVC or EPR etc. 

insulation; number of active conductors) 

b Ambient temperature 

b Method of installation 

b Influence of neighbouring circuits 

Overcurrents 

An overcurrent occurs each time the value of current exceeds the maximum load 

current IB for the load concerned. 

This current must be cut off with a rapidity that depends upon its magnitude, if 

permanent damage to the cabling (and appliance if the overcurrent is due to a 

defective load component) is to be avoided. 

Overcurrents of relatively short duration can however, occur in normal operation; two 

types of overcurrent are distinguished: 

b Overloads 

These overcurrents can occur in healthy electric circuits, for example, due to a 

number of small short-duration loads which occasionally occur co-incidentally: motor 

starting loads, and so on. If either of these conditions persists however beyond a 

given period (depending on protective-relay settings or fuse ratings) the circuit will be 

automatically cut off. 

b Short-circuit currents 

These currents result from the failure of insulation between live conductors or/and 

between live conductors and earth (on systems having low-impedance-earthed 

neutrals) in any combination, viz: 

v 3 phases short-circuited (and to neutral and/or earth, or not) 

v 2 phases short-circuited (and to neutral and/or earth, or not) 

v 1 phase short-circuited to neutral (and/or to earth) 

G3 



G4 


t 

Fig. G3 : Circuit protection by circuit-breaker 

t 

Maximum 

load 

current 

Temporary 

overload 

Temporary 

overload 

I 2 t cable 


IB Ir Iz 

ISCB 

IB Ir cIz Iz 

Fig. G4 : Circuit protection by fuses 

Circuit-breaker 

tripping curve 

ICU 

I 2 t cable 


Fuse curve 

(1) Both designations are commonly used in different 

standards. 

I 

I 


.2 Overcurrent protection principles 

A protective device is provided at the origin of the circuit concerned (see Fig. G3 and 

Fig. G4). 

b Acting to cut-off the current in a time shorter than that given by the I 2 t 

characteristic of the circuit cabling 

b But allowing the maximum load current IB to flow indefinitely 

The characteristics of insulated conductors when carrying short-circuit currents 

can, for periods up to 5 seconds following short-circuit initiation, be determined 

approximately by the formula: 

I 2 t = k 2 S 2 which shows that the allowable heat generated is proportional to the 

squared cross-sectional-area of the condutor. 

where 

t: Duration of short-circuit current (seconds) 

S: Cross sectional area of insulated conductor (mm 2 ) 

I: Short-circuit current (A r.m.s.) 

k: Insulated conductor constant (values of k 2 are given in Figure G52 ) 

For a given insulated conductor, the maximum permissible current varies according 

to the environment. For instance, for a high ambient temperature (θa1 > θa2), Iz1 is 

less than Iz2 (see Fig. G5). θ means “temperature”. 

Note: 

v ISC: 3-phase short-circuit current 

v ISCB: rated 3-ph. short-circuit breaking current of the circuit-breaker 

v Ir (or Irth) (1) : regulated “nominal” current level; e.g. a 50 A nominal circuit-breaker 

can be regulated to have a protective range, i.e. a conventional overcurrent tripping 

level (see Fig. G6 opposite page) similar to that of a 30 A circuit-breaker. 

.3 Practical values for a protective scheme 

The following methods are based on rules laid down in the IEC standards, and are 

representative of the practices in many countries. 

General rules 

A protective device (circuit-breaker or fuse) functions correctly if: 

b Its nominal current or its setting current In is greater than the maximum load 

current IB but less than the maximum permissible current Iz for the circuit, i.e. 

IB y In y Iz corresponding to zone “a” in Figure G6 

b Its tripping current I2 “conventional” setting is less than 1.45 Iz which corresponds 

to zone “b” in Figure G6 

The “conventional” setting tripping time may be 1 hour or 2 hours according to local 

standards and the actual value selected for I2. For fuses, I2 is the current (denoted 

If) which will operate the fuse in the conventional time. 

5 s 


t 

1 2 

Iz1 < Iz2 

θa1 > θa2 

I 2 t = k 2 S 2 

Fig. G5 : I 2 t characteristic of an insulated conductor at two different ambient temperatures 

I


0 


Loads Circuit cabling 

Maximum load current IB 

IB 

Nominal current In or 

its regulated current Ir 

I n 

zone a 

Fig. G6 : Current levels for determining circuir breaker or fuse characteristics 

Criteria for circuit-breakers: 

IB y In y Iz and ISCB u ISC. 

Criteria for fuses: 

IB y In y Iz/k3 and ISCF u ISC. 

Iz 

Maximum load current Iz 

zone b 

Protective device 


I2 

Conventional overcurrent 

trip current I2 

1.45 Iz 

1.45 Iz Isc 

ISCB 

zone c 

3-ph short-circuit 

fault-current breaking rating 

IB y In y Iz zone a 

I2 y 1.45 Iz zone b 

ISCB u ISC zone c 

b Its 3-phase short-circuit fault-current breaking rating is greater than the 3-phase 

short-circuit current existing at its point of installation. This corresponds to zone “c” in 

Figure G6. 

Applications 

b Protection by circuit-breaker 

By virtue of its high level of precision the current I2 is always less than 1.45 In (or 

1.45 Ir) so that the condition I2 y 1.45 Iz (as noted in the “general rules” above) will 

always be respected. 

v Particular case 

If the circuit-breaker itself does not protect against overloads, it is necessary to 

ensure that, at a time of lowest value of short-circuit current, the overcurrent device 

protecting the circuit will operate correctly. This particular case is examined in Subclause 

5.1. 

b Protection by fuses 

The condition I2 y 1.45 Iz must be taken into account, where I2 is the fusing (melting 

level) current, equal to k2 x In (k2 ranges from 1.6 to 1.9) depending on the particular 

fuse concerned. 

A further factor k3 has been introduced ( k = k2 

3 ) such that I2 y 1.45 Iz 

1.45 

will be valid if In y Iz/k3. 

For fuses type gG: 

In < 16 A → k3 = 1.31 

In u 16 A → k3 = 1.10 

Moreover, the short-circuit current breaking capacity of the fuse ISCF must exceed 

the level of 3-phase short-circuit current at the point of installation of the fuse(s). 

b Association of different protective devices 

The use of protective devices which have fault-current ratings lower than the fault 

level existing at their point of installation are permitted by IEC and many national 

standards in the following conditions: 

v There exists upstream, another protective device which has the necessary shortcircuit 

rating, and 

v The amount of energy allowed to pass through the upstream device is less than 

that which can be withstood without damage by the downstream device and all 

associated cabling and appliances. 

G5 



G6 


A protective device is, in general, required at the 

origin of each circuit 

a 

b 

c 

B 

Fig. G7 : Location of protective devices 

P 

P2 P3 P4 

50 mm 2 10 mm 2 25 mm 2 

< 3 m 

P2 

A 

B 

P 1 

P3 

Case (1) Case (2) 

P 1: C60 rated 15 A 

2.5 mm 2 

sc 

Short-circuit 

protective 

device 

B 

s 

Overload 

protective 

device 

Case (3) 

S 2: 

1.5 mm2 


In pratice this arrangement is generally exploited in: 

v The association of circuit-breakers/fuses 

v The technique known as “cascading” or “series rating” in which the strong 

current-limiting performance of certain circuit-breakers effectively reduces the 

severity of downstream short-circuits 

Possible combinations which have been tested in laboratories are indicated in certain 

manufacturers catalogues. 

.4 Location of protective devices 

General rule (see Fig. G7a) 

A protective device is necessary at the origin of each circuit where a reduction of 

permissible maximum current level occurs. 

Possible alternative locations in certain circumstances 

(see Fig. G7b) 

The protective device may be placed part way along the circuit: 

b If AB is not in proximity to combustible material, and 

b If no socket-outlets or branch connections are taken from AB 

Three cases may be useful in practice: 

b Consider case (1) in the diagram 

v AB y 3 metres, and 

v AB has been installed to reduce to a practical minimum the risk of a short-circuit 

(wires in heavy steel conduit for example) 

b Consider case (2) 

v The upstream device P1 protects the length AB against short-circuits in 

accordance with Sub-clause 5.1 

b Consider case (3) 

v The overload device (S) is located adjacent to the load. This arrangement is 

convenient for motor circuits. The device (S) constitutes the control (start/stop) and 

overload protection of the motor while (SC) is: either a circuit-breaker (designed for 

motor protection) or fuses type aM 

v The short-circuit protection (SC) located at the origin of the circuit conforms with 

the principles of Sub-clause 5.1 

Circuits with no protection (see Fig. G7c) 

Either 

b The protective device P1 is calibrated to protect the cable S2 against overloads 

and short-circuits 

Or 

b Where the breaking of a circuit constitutes a risk, e.g. 

v Excitation circuits of rotating machines 

v circuits of large lifting electromagnets 

v the secondary circuits of current transformers 

No circuit interruption can be tolerated, and the protection of the cabling is of 

secondary importance. 

.5 Conductors in parallel 

Conductors of the same cross-sectional-area, the same length, and of the same 

material, can be connected in parallel. 

The maximum permissible current is the sum of the individual-core maximum 

currents, taking into account the mutual heating effects, method of installation, etc. 

Protection against overload and short-circuits is identical to that for a single-cable 

circuit. 

The following precautions should be taken to avoid the risk of short-circuits on the 

paralleled cables: 

b Additional protection against mechanical damage and against humidity, by the 

introduction of supplementary protection 

b The cable route should be chosen so as to avoid close proximity to combustible 

materials 



2 Practical method for determining 

the smallest allowable crosssectional 

area of circuit conductors 


The reference international standard for the study of cabling is IEC 60364-5-52: 

“Electrical installation of buildings - Part 5-52: Selection and erection of electrical 

equipment - Wiring system”. 

A summary of this standard is presented here, with examples of the most commonly 

used methods of installation. The current-carrying capacities of conductors in all 

different situations are given in annex A of the standard. A simplified method for use 

of the tables of annex A is proposed in informative annex B of the standard. 

2.2 General method for cables 

Possible methods of installation for different types of 

conductors or cables 

The different admissible methods of installation are listed in Figure G8, in 

conjonction with the different types of conductors and cables. 

Conductors and cables Method of installation 

Without Clipped Conduit Cable trunking Cable Cable ladder On Support 

fixings direct (including ducting Cable tray insulators wire 

skirting trunking, Cable brackets 

flush floor trunking) 

Bare conductors – – – – – – + – 

Insulated conductors – – + + + – + – 

Sheathed Multi-core + + + + + + 0 + 

cables 

(including 

armoured Single-core 0 + + + + + 0 + 

and 

mineral 

insulated) 

+ Permitted. 

– Not permitted. 

0 Not applicable, or not normally used in practice. 

Fig. G8 : Selection of wiring systems (table 52-1 of IEC 60364-5-52) 


G 



G8 


Fig. G9 : Erection of wiring systems (table 52-2 of IEC 60364-5-52) 




Possible methods of installation for different situations: 

Different methods of installation can be implemented in different situations. The 

possible combinations are presented in Figure G9. 

The number given in this table refer to the different wiring systems considered. 

(see also Fig. G10) 

Situations Method of installation 

Without With Conduit Cable trunking Cable Cable ladder On Support 

fixings fixings (including ducting cable tray, insulators wire 

skirting trunking, 

flush floor trunking) 

cable brackets 

Building voids 40, 46, 0 15, 16, – 43 30, 31, 32, – – 

15, 16 41, 42 33, 34 

Cable channel 56 56 54, 55 0 44, 45 30, 31, 32, 

33, 34 

– – 

Buried in ground 72, 73 0 70, 71 – 70, 71 0 – 

Embedded in structure 57, 58 3 1, 2, 

59, 60 

50, 51, 52, 53 44, 45 0 – – 

Surface mounted – 20, 21 4, 5 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14 6, 7, 30, 31, 32, 36 – 

22, 23 8, 9 33, 34 

Overhead – – 0 10, 11 – 30, 31, 32 

33, 34 

36 35 

Immersed 

– Not permitted. 

80 80 0 – 0 0 – – 

0 Not applicable, or not normally used in practice. 



Fig. G10 : Examples of methods of installation (part of table 52-3 of IEC 60364-5-52) (continued on next page) 




Examples of wiring systems and reference methods of 


An illustration of some of the many different wiring systems and methods of 

installation is provided in Figure G10. 

Several reference methods are defined (with code letters A to G), grouping 

installation methods having the same characteristics relative to the current-carrying 

capacities of the wiring systems. 

Item No. Methods of installation Description Reference method of 

installation to be used to 

obtain current-carrying 

capacity 

1 Insulated conductors or single-core 

cables in conduit in a thermally 

insulated wall 

A1 

Room 

2 Multi-core cables in conduit in a A2 

thermally insulated wall 

4 Insulated conductors or single-core B1 

cables in conduit on a wooden, or 

masonry wall or spaced less than 

0,3 x conduit diameter from it 

5 Multi-core cable in conduit on a B2 

wooden, or mansonry wall or spaced 

less than 0,3 x conduit diameter 

from it 

20 Single-core or multi-core cables: C 

- fixed on, or sapced less than 0.3 x cable 

diameter from a wooden wall 

30 On unperforated tray C 

0.3 De 

0.3 De 

Room 


G9 


G10 



Item No. Methods of installation Description Reference method of 

installation to be used to 

obtain current-carrying 

capacity 

31 0.3 De 

On perforated tray E or F 

0.3 De 

36 Bare or insulated conductors on G 

insulators 

70 Multi-core cables in conduit or in cable D 

ducting in the ground 

71 Single-core cable in conduit or in cable D 

ducting in the ground 

Fig. G10 : Examples of methods of installation (part of table 52-3 of IEC 60364-5-52) 




Maximum operating temperature: 

The current-carrying capacities given in the subsequent tables have been 

determined so that the maximum insulation temperature is not exceeded for 

sustained periods of time. 

For different type of insulation material, the maximum admissible temperature is 

given in Figure G11. 

Type of insulation Temperature limit °C 

Polyvinyl-chloride (PVC) 70 at the conductor 

Cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) and ethylene 90 at the conductor 

propylene rubber (EPR) 

Mineral (PVC covered or bare exposed to touch) 70 at the sheath 

Mineral (bare not exposed to touch and not in 105 at the seath 

contact with combustible material) 

Fig. G11 : Maximum operating temperatures for types of insulation (table 52-4 of IEC 60364-5-52) 

Correction factors: 

In order to take environnement or special conditions of installation into account, 

correction factors have been introduced. 

The cross sectional area of cables is determined using the rated load current I B 

divided by different correction factors, k1, k2, ...: 

I 

I' B 

B = 

k1⋅k 2 ... 

I’ B is the corrected load current, to be compared to the current-carrying capacity of 

the considered cable. 






b Ambient temperature 

The current-carrying capacities of cables in the air are based on an average air 

temperature equal to 30 °C. For other temperatures, the correction factor is given in 

Figure G12 for PVC, EPR and XLPE insulation material. 

The related correction factor is here noted k 1. 

Ambient temperature °C Insulation 

PVC XLPE and EPR 

10 1.22 1.15 

15 1.17 1.12 

20 1.12 1.08 

25 1.06 1.04 

35 0.94 0.96 

40 0.87 0.91 

45 0.79 0.87 

50 0.71 0.82 

55 0.61 0.76 

60 0.50 0.71 

65 - 0.65 

70 - 0.58 

75 - 0.50 

80 - 0.41 

Fig. G12 : Correction factors for ambient air temperatures other than 30 °C to be applied to the 

current-carrying capacities for cables in the air (from table A.52-14 of IEC 60364-5-52) 

The current-carrying capacities of cables in the ground are based on an average 

ground temperature equal to 20 °C. For other temperatures, the correction factor is 

given in Figure G13 for PVC, EPR and XLPE insulation material. 

The related correction factor is here noted k 2. 

Ground temperature °C Insulation 

PVC XLPE and EPR 

10 1.10 1.07 

15 1.05 1.04 

25 0.95 0.96 

30 0.89 0.93 

35 0.84 0.89 

40 0.77 0.85 

45 0.71 0.80 

50 0.63 0.76 

55 0.55 0.71 

60 0.45 0.65 

65 - 0.60 

70 - 0.53 

75 - 0.46 

80 - 0.38 

Fig. G13 : Correction factors for ambient ground temperatures other than 20 °C to be applied to 

the current-carrying capacities for cables in ducts in the ground (from table A.52-15 of 

IEC 60364-5-52) 


G11 


G12 






b Soil thermal resistivity 

The current-carrying capacities of cables in the ground are based on a ground 

resistivity equal to 2.5 K.m/W. For other values, the correction factor is given in 

Figure G14. 

The related correction factor is here noted k3. 

Thermal resistivity, K.m/W 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 

Correction factor 1.18 1.1 1.05 1 0.96 

Fig. G14 : Correction factors for cables in buried ducts for soil thermal resistivities other than 2.5 

K.m/W to be applied to the current-carrying capacities for reference method D (table A52.16 of 

IEC 60364-5-52) 

Based on experience, a relationship exist between the soil nature and resistivity. 

Then, empiric values of correction factors k3 are proposed in Figure G15, depending 

on the nature of soil. 

Fig. G15 : Correction factor k3 depending on the nature of soil 

b Grouping of conductors or cables 


Nature of soil k3 

Very wet soil (saturated) 1.21 

Wet soil 1.13 

Damp soil 1.05 

Dry soil 1.00 

Very dry soil (sunbaked) 0.86 

The current-carrying capacities given in the subsequent tables relate to single 

circuits consisting of the following numbers of loaded conductors: 

v Two insulated conductors or two single-core cables, or one twin-core cable 

(applicable to single-phase circuits); 

v Three insulated conductors or three single-core cables, or one three-core cable 

(applicable to three-phase circuits). 

Where more insulated conductors or cables are installed in the same group, a group 

reduction factor (here noted k4) shall be applied. 

Examples are given in Figures G16 to G18 for different configurations (installation 

methods, in free air or in the ground). 

Figure G16 gives the values of correction factor k4 for different configurations of 

unburied cables or conductors, grouping of more than one circuit or multi-core 

cables. 

Arrangement Number of circuits or multi-core cables Reference methods 

(cables touching) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 12 16 20 

Bunched in air, on a 1.00 0.80 0.70 0.65 0.60 0.57 0.54 0.52 0.50 0.45 0.41 0.38 Methods A to F 

surface, embedded or 

enclosed 

Single layer on wall, floor 1.00 0.85 0.79 0.75 0.73 0.72 0.72 0.71 0.70 No further reduction Method C 

or unperforated tray factor for more than 

Single layer fixed directly 0.95 0.81 0.72 0.68 0.66 0.64 0.63 0.62 0.61 nine circuits or 

under a wooden ceiling multi-core cables 

Single layer on a 1.00 0.88 0.82 0.77 0.75 0.73 0.73 0.72 0.72 Methods E and F 

perforated horizontal or 

vertical tray 

Single layer on ladder 1.00 0.87 0.82 0.80 0.80 0.79 0.79 0.78 0.78 

support or cleats etc. 

Fig. G16 : Reduction factors for groups of more than one circuit or of more than one multi-core cable (table A.52-17 of IEC 60364-5-52)





Figure G1 gives the values of correction factor k 4 for different configurations of 

unburied cables or conductors, for groups of more than one circuit of single-core 

cables in free air. 

Method of installation Number Number of three-phase Use as a 

of tray circuits multiplier to 

rating for 

1 2 3 

Perforated 31 Touching 1 0.98 0.91 0.87 Three cables in 

trays horizontal 

2 0.96 0.87 0.81 formation 

20 mm 

3 0.95 0.85 0.78 

Vertical 31 Touching 1 0.96 0.86 Three cables in 

perforated vertical 

trays 

225 mm 

2 0.95 0.84 formation 

Ladder 32 1 1.00 0.97 0.96 Three cables in 

supports, Touching 

horizontal 

cleats, etc... 33 2 0.98 0.93 0.89 formation 

34 3 0.97 0.90 0.86 

20 mm 

Perforated 

trays 

31 

2De 

De 1 1.00 0.98 0.96 Three cables in 

trefoil formation 

2 0.97 0.93 0.89 

20 mm 

3 0.96 0.92 0.86 

Vertical 

perforated 

31 De 

Spaced 1 1.00 0.91 0.89 

trays 

225 mm 

2 1.00 0.90 0.86 

2De 

Ladder 

supports, 

32 2De 

De 

1 1.00 1.00 1.00 

cleats, etc... 33 2 0.97 0.95 0.93 

34 20 mm 3 0.96 0.94 0.90 

Fig. G17 : Reduction factors for groups of more than one circuit of single-core cables to be applied to reference rating for one circuit of single-core cables in free air 

- Method of installation F. (table A.52.21 of IEC 60364-5-52) 


G13 


G14 






Figure G18 gives the values of correction factor k4 for different configurations of 

cables or conductors laid directly in the ground. 

Number Cable to cable clearance (a) a 

of circuits Nil (cables One cable 0.125 m 0.25 m 0.5 m 

touching) diameter 

2 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.90 

3 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 

4 0.60 0.60 0.70 0.75 0.80 

5 0.55 0.55 0.65 0.70 0.80 

6 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.70 0.80 

a Multi-core cables 

a Single-core cables 

Fig. G18 : Reduction factors for more than one circuit, single-core or multi-core cables laid 

directly in the ground. Installation method D. (table 52-18 of IEC 60364-5-52) 

b Harmonic current 


a a 

a a 

The current-carrying capacity of three-phase, 4-core or 5-core cables is based on 

the assumption that only 3 conductors are fully loaded. 

However, when harmonic currents are circulating, the neutral current can be 

significant, and even higher than the phase currents. This is due to the fact that the 

3 rd harmonic currents of the three phases do not cancel each other, and sum up in 

the neutral conductor. 

This of course affects the current-carrying capacity of the cable, and a correction 

factor noted here k5 shall be applied. 

In addition, if the 3 rd harmonic percentage h 3 is greater than 33%, the neutral current 

is greater than the phase current and the cable size selection is based on the neutral 

current. The heating effect of harmonic currents in the phase conductors has also to 

be taken into account. 

The values of k5 depending on the 3 rd harmonic content are given in Figure G19. 

Third harmonic content Correction factor 

of phase current % Size selection is based Size selection is based 

on phase current on neutral current 

0 - 15 1.0 

15 - 33 0.86 

33 - 45 0.86 

> 45 1.0 

Fig. G19 : Correction factors for harmonic currents in four-core and five-core cables (table D.52.1 

of IEC 60364-5-52) 

Admissible current as a function of nominal cross-sectional 

area of conductors 

IEC standard 60364-5-52 proposes extensive information in the form of tables 

giving the admissible currents as a function of cross-sectional area of cables. Many 

parameters are taken into account, such as the method of installation, type of 

insulation material, type of conductor material, number of loaded conductors.





As an example, Figure G20 gives the current-carrying capacities for different 

methods of installation of PVC insulation, three loaded copper or aluminium 

conductors, free air or in ground. 

Nominal Installation methods 

cross-sectional A1 A2 B1 B2 C D 

area of conductors 

(mm 2 ) 

1 2 3 4 5 6 

Copper 

1.5 13.5 13 15.5 15 17.5 18 

2.5 18 17.5 21 20 24 24 

4 24 23 28 27 32 31 

6 31 29 36 34 41 39 

10 42 39 50 46 57 52 

16 56 52 68 62 76 67 

25 73 68 89 80 96 86 

35 89 83 110 99 119 103 

50 108 99 134 118 144 122 

70 136 125 171 149 184 151 

95 164 150 207 179 223 179 

120 188 172 239 206 259 203 

150 216 196 - - 299 230 

185 245 223 - - 341 258 

240 286 261 - - 403 297 

300 328 298 - - 464 336 

Aluminium 

2.5 14 13.5 16.5 15.5 18.5 18.5 

4 18.5 17.5 22 21 25 24 

6 24 23 28 27 32 30 

10 32 31 39 36 44 40 

16 43 41 53 48 59 52 

25 57 53 70 62 73 66 

35 70 65 86 77 90 80 

50 84 78 104 92 110 94 

70 107 98 133 116 140 117 

95 129 118 161 139 170 138 

120 149 135 186 160 197 157 

150 170 155 - - 227 178 

185 194 176 - - 259 200 

240 227 207 - - 305 230 

300 261 237 - - 351 260 

Fig. G20 : Current-carrying capacities in amperes for different methods of installation, PVC insulation, three loaded conductors, copper or aluminium, conductor 

temperature: 70 °C, ambient temperature: 30 °C in air, 20 °C in ground (table A.52.4 of IEC 60364-5-52) 


G15 


G16 



2.3 Recommended simplified approach for cables 

In order to facilitate the selection of cables, 2 simplified tables are proposed, for 

unburied and buried cables. 

These tables summarize the most commonly used configurations and give easier 

access to the information. 

b Unburied cables: 

Fig. G21a : Current-carrying capacity in amperes (table B.52-1 of IEC 60364-5-52) 




Reference Number of loaded conductors and type of insulation 

methods 

A1 2 PVC 3 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

A2 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

B1 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

B2 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

C 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

E 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

F 3 PVC 2 PVC 3 XLPE 2 XLPE 

1 2 3 4 5 6 8 9 10 11 12 13 

Size (mm 2 ) 

Copper 

1.5 13 13 .5 14.5 15.5 17 18.5 19.5 22 23 24 26 - 

2.5 17.5 18 19.5 21 23 25 27 30 31 33 36 - 

4 23 24 26 28 31 34 36 40 42 45 49 - 

6 29 31 34 36 40 43 46 51 54 58 63 - 

10 39 42 46 50 54 60 63 70 75 80 86 - 

16 52 56 61 68 73 80 85 94 100 107 115 - 

25 68 73 80 89 95 101 110 119 127 135 149 161 

35 - - - 110 117 126 137 147 158 169 185 200 

50 - - - 134 141 153 167 179 192 207 225 242 

70 - - - 171 179 196 213 229 246 268 289 310 

95 - - - 207 216 238 258 278 298 328 352 377 

120 - - - 239 249 276 299 322 346 382 410 437 

150 - - - - 285 318 344 371 395 441 473 504 

185 - - - - 324 362 392 424 450 506 542 575 

240 - - - - 380 424 461 500 538 599 641 679 

Aluminium 

2.5 13.5 14 15 16.5 18.5 19.5 21 23 24 26 28 - 

4 17.5 18.5 20 22 25 26 28 31 32 35 38 - 

6 23 24 26 28 32 33 36 39 42 45 49 - 

10 31 32 36 39 44 46 49 54 58 62 67 - 

16 41 43 48 53 58 61 66 73 77 84 91 - 

25 53 57 63 70 73 78 83 90 97 101 108 121 

35 - - - 86 90 96 103 112 120 126 135 150 

50 - - - 104 110 117 125 136 146 154 164 184 

70 - - - 133 140 150 160 174 187 198 211 237 

95 - - - 161 170 183 195 211 227 241 257 289 

120 - - - 186 197 212 226 245 263 280 300 337 

150 - - - - 226 245 261 283 304 324 346 389 

185 - - - - 256 280 298 323 347 371 397 447 

240 - - - - 300 330 352 382 409 439 470 530 






Correction factors are given in Figure G21b for groups of several circuits or multicore 

cables: 

Arrangement Number of circuits or multi-core cables 

1 2 3 4 6 9 12 16 20 

Embedded or enclosed 1.00 0.80 0.70 0.70 0.55 0.50 0.45 0.40 0.40 

Single layer on walls, floors 1.00 0.85 0.80 0.75 0.70 0.70 - - - 

or on unperforatedtrays 

Single layer fixed directly 0.95 0.80 0.70 0.70 0.65 0.60 - - - 

under a ceiling 

Single layer on perforated 1.00 0.90 0.80 0.75 0.75 0.70 - - - 

horizontal trays or on vertical trays 

Single layer on cable 1.00 0.85 0.80 0.80 0.80 0.80 - - - 

ladder supports or cleats, etc... 

Fig. G21b : Reduction factors for groups of several circuits or of several multi-core cables 

(table B.52-3 of IEC 60364-5-52) 

b Buried cables: 

Installation Size Number of loaded conductors and type of insulation 

method mm 2 Two PVC Three PVC Two XLPE Three XLPE 

D Copper 

1.5 22 18 26 22 

2.5 29 24 34 29 

4 38 31 44 37 

6 47 39 56 46 

10 63 52 73 61 

16 81 67 95 79 

25 104 86 121 101 

35 125 103 146 122 

50 148 122 173 144 

70 183 151 213 178 

95 216 179 252 211 

120 246 203 287 240 

150 278 230 324 271 

185 312 258 363 304 

240 361 297 419 351 

300 408 336 474 396 

D Aluminium 

2.5 22 18.5 26 22 

4 29 24 34 29 

6 36 30 42 36 

10 48 40 56 47 

16 62 52 73 61 

25 80 66 93 78 

35 96 80 112 94 

50 113 94 132 112 

70 140 117 163 138 

95 166 138 193 164 

120 189 157 220 186 

150 213 178 249 210 

185 240 200 279 236 

240 277 230 322 272 

300 313 260 364 308 

Fig. G22 : Current-carrying capacity in amperes (table B.52-1 of IEC 60364-5-52) 


G1 


G18 






2.4 Busbar trunking systems 

The selection of busbar trunking systems is very straightforward, using the data 

provided by the manufacturer. Methods of installation, insulation materials, correction 

factors for grouping are not relevant parameters for this technology. 

The cross section area of any given model has been determined by the manufacturer 

based on: 

b The rated current, 

b An ambient air temperature equal to 35 °C, 

b 3 loaded conductors. 

Rated current 

The rated current can be calculated taking account of: 

b The layout, 

b The current absorbed by the different loads connected along the trunking system. 

Ambient temperature 

A correction factor has to be applied for temperature higher than 35 °C. The 

correction factor applicable to medium and high power range (up to 4,000 A) is given 

in Figure G23a. 

°C 35 40 45 50 55 

Correction factor 1 0.97 0.93 0.90 0.86 

Fig. G23a : Correction factor for air temperature higher than 35 °C 

Neutral current 

Where 3 rd harmonic currents are circulating, the neutral conductor may be carrying a 

significant current and the corresponding additional power losses must be taken into 

account. 

Figure G23b represents the maximum admissible phase and neutral currents (per 

unit) in a high power busbar trunking system as functions of 3 rd harmonic level. 

Maximum admissible current (p.u) 

1.4 

1.2 

1 

0.8 

0.6 

0.4 

0.2 

0 

0 10 20 30 40 

Fig. G23b : Maximum admissible currents (p.u.) in a busbar trunking system as functions of the 

3 rd harmonic level. 


50 60 70 

3 rd harmonic current level (%) 

Neutral conductor 

Phase conductor 

80 90





The layout of the trunking system depends on the position of the current consumers, 

the location of the power source and the possibilities for fixing the system. 

v One single distribution line serves a 4 to 6 meter area 

v Protection devices for current consumers are placed in tap-off units, connected 

directly to usage points. 

v One single feeder supplies all current consumers of different powers. 

Once the trunking system layout is established, it is possible to calculate the 

absorbed current I n on the distribution line. 

I n is equal to the sum of absorbed currents by the current I n consumers: I n = Σ I B. 

The current consumers do not all work at the same time and are not permanently on 

full load, so we have to use a clustering coefficient k S : I n = Σ (I B . k S). 

Application Number of current consumers Ks Coefficient 

Lighting, Heating 1 

Distribution (engineering 

workshop) 

2...3 

4...5 

6...9 

10...40 

40 and over 


0.9 

0.8 

0.7 

0.6 

0.5 

Note : for industrial installations, remember to take account of upgrading of the machine 

equipment base. As for a switchboard, a 20 % margin is recommended: 

I n ≤ I B x k s x 1.2. 

Fig G24 : Clustering coefficient according to the number of current consumers 

G19 


G20 



3 Determination of voltage drop 

The impedance of circuit conductors is low but not negligible: when carrying 

load current there is a voltage drop between the origin of the circuit and the load 

terminals. The correct operation of a load (a motor, lighting circuit, etc.) depends 

on the voltage at its terminals being maintained at a value close to its rated value. 

It is necessary therefore to determine the circuit conductors such that at full-load 

current, the load terminal voltage is maintained within the limits required for correct 

performance. 

This section deals with methods of determining voltage drops, in order to check that: 

b They comply with the particular standards and regulations in force 

b They can be tolerated by the load 

b They satisfy the essential operational requirements 

3.1 Maximum voltage drop 

Maximum allowable voltage-drop vary from one country to another. Typical values for 

LV installations are given below in Figure G25. 

Type of installations Lighting Other uses 

circuits (heating and power) 

A low-voltage service connection from 3% 5% 

a LV public power distribution network 

Consumers MV/LV substation supplied 6% 8% 

from a public distribution MV system 

Fig. G25 : Maximum voltage-drop between the service-connection point and the point of utilization 

These voltage-drop limits refer to normal steady-state operating conditions and do 

not apply at times of motor starting, simultaneous switching (by chance) of several 

loads, etc. as mentioned in Chapter A Sub-clause 4.3 (factor of simultaneity, etc.). 

When voltage drops exceed the values shown in Figure G25, larger cables (wires) 

must be used to correct the condition. 

The value of 8%, while permitted, can lead to problems for motor loads; for example: 

b In general, satisfactory motor performance requires a voltage within ± 5% of its 

rated nominal value in steady-state operation, 

b Starting current of a motor can be 5 to 7 times its full-load value (or even higher). 

If an 8% voltage drop occurs at full-load current, then a drop of 40% or more will 

occur during start-up. In such conditions the motor will either: 

v Stall (i.e. remain stationary due to insufficient torque to overcome the load torque) 

with consequent over-heating and eventual trip-out 

v Or accelerate very slowly, so that the heavy current loading (with possibly 

undesirable low-voltage effects on other equipment) will continue beyond the normal 

start-up period 

b Finally an 8% voltage drop represents a continuous power loss, which, for continuous 

loads will be a significant waste of (metered) energy. For these reasons it is 

recommended that the maximum value of 8% in steady operating conditions should not 

be reached on circuits which are sensitive to under-voltage problems (see Fig. G26). 

Load 

Fig. G26 : Maximum voltage drop 

LV consumer 


5% (1) 

MV consumer 

8% (1) 

(1) Between the LV supply point and the load



3.2 Calculation of voltage drop in steady load 

conditions 

Use of formulae 

Figure G27 below gives formulae commonly used to calculate voltage drop in a 

given circuit per kilometre of length. 

If: 

b IB: The full load current in amps 

b L: Length of the cable in kilometres 

b R: Resistance of the cable conductor in Ω/km 

2 

22.5 Ω mm / km 

R = 

for copper 

2 

S c.s.a. in mm 

( ) 

2 

36 Ω mm / km 

R = 

for aluminium 

2 

S c.s.a. in mm 

( ) 

Note: R is negligible above a c.s.a. of 500 mm 2 

b X: inductive reactance of a conductor in Ω/km 

Note: X is negligible for conductors of c.s.a. less than 50 mm 2 . In the absence of any 

other information, take X as being equal to 0.08 Ω/km. 

b ϕ: phase angle between voltage and current in the circuit considered, generally: 

v Incandescent lighting: cos ϕ = 1 

v Motor power: 

- At start-up: cos ϕ = 0.35 

- In normal service: cos ϕ = 0.8 

b Un: phase-to-phase voltage 

b Vn: phase-to-neutral voltage 

For prefabricated pre-wired ducts and bustrunking, resistance and inductive 

reactance values are given by the manufacturer. 

Circuit Voltage drop (ΔU) 

in volts in % 

Single phase: phase/phase ∆U = 2I B R cos ϕ + X sin ϕ L 

Fig. G27 : Voltage-drop formulae 


( ) 

100 ∆U 

Un 

Single phase: phase/neutral ∆U = 2I B( R cos ϕ + X sin ϕ) L 

100 ∆ U 

Vn 

Balanced 3-phase: 3 phases ∆U = 3 I B( R cos ϕ + X sin ϕ) L 100 ∆ U 

Un 

(with or without neutral) 

Simplified table 

Calculations may be avoided by using Figure G28 next page, which gives, with 

an adequate approximation, the phase-to-phase voltage drop per km of cable per 

ampere, in terms of: 

b Kinds of circuit use: motor circuits with cos ϕ close to 0.8, or lighting with a cos ϕ 

close to 1. 

b Type of cable; single-phase or 3-phase 

Voltage drop in a cable is then given by: 

K x IB x L 

K is given by the table, 

IB is the full-load current in amps, 

L is the length of cable in km. 

The column motor power “cos ϕ = 0.35” of Figure G28 may be used to compute the 

voltage drop occurring during the start-up period of a motor (see example no. 1 after 

the Figure G28). 

G21 


G22 



c.s.a. in mm 2 Single-phase circuit Balanced three-phase circuit 

Motor power Lighting Motor power Lighting 

Normal service Start-up Normal service Start-up 

Cu Al cos ϕ = 0.8 cos ϕ = 0.35 cos ϕ = 1 cos ϕ = 0.8 cos ϕ = 0.35 cos ϕ = 1 

1.5 24 10.6 30 20 9.4 25 

2.5 14.4 6.4 18 12 5.7 15 

4 9.1 4.1 11.2 8 3.6 9.5 

6 10 6.1 2.9 7.5 5.3 2.5 6.2 

10 16 3.7 1.7 4.5 3.2 1.5 3.6 

16 25 2.36 1.15 2.8 2.05 1 2.4 

25 35 1.5 0.75 1.8 1.3 0.65 1.5 

35 50 1.15 0.6 1.29 1 0.52 1.1 

50 70 0.86 0.47 0.95 0.75 0.41 0.77 

70 120 0.64 0.37 0.64 0.56 0.32 0.55 

95 150 0.48 0.30 0.47 0.42 0.26 0.4 

120 185 0.39 0.26 0.37 0.34 0.23 0.31 

150 240 0.33 0.24 0.30 0.29 0.21 0.27 

185 300 0.29 0.22 0.24 0.25 0.19 0.2 

240 400 0.24 0.2 0.19 0.21 0.17 0.16 

300 500 0.21 0.19 0.15 0.18 0.16 0.13 

Fig. G28 : Phase-to-phase voltage drop ΔU for a circuit, in volts per ampere per km 

1,000 A 

400 V 

Fig. G29 : Example 1 

50 m / 35 mm 2 Cu 

IB = 100 A 

(500 A during start-up) 


Examples 

Example 1 (see Fig. G29) 

A three-phase 35 mm 2 copper cable 50 metres long supplies a 400 V motor taking: 

b 100 A at a cos ϕ = 0.8 on normal permanent load 

b 500 A (5 In) at a cos ϕ = 0.35 during start-up 

The voltage drop at the origin of the motor cable in normal circumstances (i.e. with 

the distribution board of Figure G29 distributing a total of 1,000 A) is 10 V phase-tophase. 

What is the voltage drop at the motor terminals: 

b In normal service? 

b During start-up? 

Solution: 

b Voltage drop in normal service conditions: 

∆ 

∆U% 

100 U 

= 

Un 

Table G28 shows 1 V/A/km so that: 

ΔU for the cable = 1 x 100 x 0.05 = 5 V 

ΔU total = 10 + 5 = 15 V = i.e. 

15 

x 100 3.75% 

400 = 

This value is less than that authorized (8%) and is satisfactory. 

b Voltage drop during motor start-up: 

ΔUcable = 0.52 x 500 x 0.05 = 13 V 

Owing to the additional current taken by the motor when starting, the voltage drop at 

the distribution board will exceed 10 Volts. 

Supposing that the infeed to the distribution board during motor starting is 

900 + 500 = 1,400 A then the voltage drop at the distribution board will increase 

approximately pro rata, i.e. 

10 x 1,400 

= 14 V 

1,000 

ΔU distribution board = 14 V 

ΔU for the motor cable = 13 V 

ΔU total = 13 + 14 = 27 V i.e. 

27 

x 100 6.75% 

400 = 

a value which is satisfactory during motor starting. 




Example 2 (see Fig. G30) 

A 3-phase 4-wire copper line of 70 mm 2 c.s.a. and a length of 50 m passes a current 

of 150 A. The line supplies, among other loads, 3 single-phase lighting circuits, each 

of 2.5 mm 2 c.s.a. copper 20 m long, and each passing 20 A. 

It is assumed that the currents in the 70 mm 2 line are balanced and that the three 

lighting circuits are all connected to it at the same point. 

What is the voltage drop at the end of the lighting circuits? 

Solution: 

b Voltage drop in the 4-wire line: 

∆ 

∆U% 

100 U 

= 

Un 

Figure G28 shows 0.55 V/A/km 

ΔU line = 0.55 x 150 x 0.05 = 4.125 V phase-to-phase 

4 . 125 

which gives: = 2.38 V phase to neutral. 

3 

b Voltage drop in any one of the lighting single-phase circuits: 

ΔU for a single-phase circuit = 18 x 20 x 0.02 = 7.2 V 

The total voltage drop is therefore 

7.2 + 2.38 = 9.6 V 

9.6 V 

x 100 = 4.2% 

230 V 

This value is satisfactory, being less than the maximum permitted voltage drop of 6%. 

Fig. G30 : Example 2 


50 m / 70 mm2 Cu 

IB = 150 A 

20 m / 2.5 mm2 Cu 

IB = 20 A 

G23 


G24 



Knowing the levels of 3-phase symmetrical 

short-circuit currents (Isc) at different points 

in an installation is an essential feature of its 


Isc1 

Isc2 

Fig. G32 : Case of several transformers in parallel 

Isc3 

Isc1 + Isc2 + Isc3 

4 Short-circuit current 

A knowledge of 3-phase symmetrical short-circuit current values (Isc) at strategic 

points of an installation is necessary in order to determine switchgear (fault current 

rating), cables (thermal withstand rating), protective devices (discriminative trip 

settings) and so on... 

In the following notes a 3-phase short-circuit of zero impedance (the so-called bolted 

short-circuit) fed through a typical MV/LV distribution transformer will be examined. 

Except in very unusual circumstances, this type of fault is the most severe, and is 

certainly the simplest to calculate. 

Short-circuit currents occurring in a network supplied from a generator and also in 

DC systems are dealt with in Chapter N. 

The simplified calculations and practical rules which follow give conservative results 

of sufficient accuracy, in the large majority of cases, for installation design purposes. 

4.1 Short-circuit current at the secondary terminals 

of a MV/LV distribution transformer 

The case of one transformer 

b In a simplified approach, the impedance of the MV system is assumed to be 

In 

negligibly small, so that: Isc 

In 

Usc 

P 

3 

x 100 x 10 

= where = and: 

U20 

3 

P = kVA rating of the transformer 

U20 = phase-to-phase secondary volts on open circuit 

In = nominal current in amps 

Isc = short-circuit fault current in amps 

Usc = short-circuit impedance voltage of the transformer in %. 

Typical values of Usc for distribution transformers are given in Figure G31. 

Fig. G31 : Typical values of Usc for different kVA ratings of transformers with MV windings y 20 kV 

b Example 

Transformer rating Usc in % 

(kVA) Oil-immersed Cast-resin 

dry type 

50 to 750 4 6 

800 to 3,200 6 6 

400 kVA transformer, 420 V at no load 

Usc = 4% 

400 

x 10 

55 0 x 100 

In = = 550 A I sc = = 13. 7 kA 

420 x 3 

4 


3 

The case of several transformers in parallel feeding a busbar 

The value of fault current on an outgoing circuit immediately downstream of 

the busbars (see Fig. G32) can be estimated as the sum of the Isc from each 

transformer calculated separately. 

It is assumed that all transformers are supplied from the same MV network, in which 

case the values obtained from Figure G31 when added together will give a slightly 

higher fault-level value than would actually occur. 

Other factors which have not been taken into account are the impedance of the 

busbars and of the circuit-breakers. 

The conservative fault-current value obtained however, is sufficiently accurate for 

basic installation design purposes. The choice of circuit-breakers and incorporated 

protective devices against short-circuit fault currents is described in Chapter H Subclause 

4.4.


Fig. G33 : Impedance diagram 

Z 

(1) Short-circuit MVA: 3 E L Isc where: 

b E L = phase-to-phase nominal system voltage expressed in 

kV (r.m.s.) 

b Isc = 3-phase short-circuit current expressed in kA (r.m.s.) 

(2) up to 36 kV 

R 

X 


4.2 3-phase short-circuit current (Isc) at any point 

within a LV installation 

In a 3-phase installation Isc at any point is given by: 

U 

Isc = 20 where 

3 ZT 

U 20 = phase-to-phase voltage of the open circuited secondary windings of the power 

supply transformer(s). 

Z T = total impedance per phase of the installation upstream of the fault location (in Ω) 

Method of calculating Z T 

Each component of an installation (MV network, transformer, cable, circuit-breaker, 

busbar, and so on...) is characterized by its impedance Z, comprising an element 

of resistance (R) and an inductive reactance (X). It may be noted that capacitive 

reactances are not important in short-circuit current calculations. 

The parameters R, X and Z are expressed in ohms, and are related by the sides of a 

right angled triangle, as shown in the impedance diagram of Figure G33. 

The method consists in dividing the network into convenient sections, and to 

calculate the R and X values for each. 

Where sections are connected in series in the network, all the resistive elements in 

the section are added arithmetically; likewise for the reactances, to give R T and X T. 

The impedance (Z T) for the combined sections concerned is then calculated from 

2 

Z = R + X 2 

T T T 

Any two sections of the network which are connected in parallel, can, if 

predominantly both resistive (or both inductive) be combined to give a single 

equivalent resistance (or reactance) as follows: 

Let R1 and R2 be the two resistances connected in parallel, then the equivalent 

resistance R3 will be given by: 

R1 

x R2 

X1 

x X2 

R3 

= or for reactances X3 

= 

R 1 + R2 

X 1 + X2 

It should be noted that the calculation of X3 concerns only separated circuit without 

mutual inductance. If the circuits in parallel are close togother the value of X3 will be 

notably higher. 

Determination of the impedance of each component 

b Network upstream of the MV/LV transformer (see Fig. G34) 

The 3-phase short-circuit fault level P SC, in kA or in MVA (1) is given by the power 

supply authority concerned, from which an equivalent impedance can be deduced. 

Psc Uo (V) Ra (mΩ) Xa (mΩ) 

250 MVA 420 0.07 0.7 

500 MVA 420 0.035 0.351 

Fig. G34 : The impedance of the MV network referred to the LV side of the MV/LV transformer 

A formula which makes this deduction and at the same time converts the impedance 

to an equivalent value at LV is given, as follows: 

Zs U 

= 

Psc 

02 

where 

Zs = impedance of the MV voltage network, expessed in milli-ohms 

Uo = phase-to-phase no-load LV voltage, expressed in volts 

Psc = MV 3-phase short-circuit fault level, expressed in kVA 

The upstream (MV) resistance Ra is generally found to be negligible compared with 

the corresponding Xa, the latter then being taken as the ohmic value for Za. If more 

accurate calculations are necessary, Xa may be taken to be equal to 0.995 Za and 

Ra equal to 0.1 Xa. 

Figure G36 gives values for Ra and Xa corresponding to the most common MV (2) 

short-circuit levels in utility power-supply networks, namely, 250 MVA and 500 MVA. 


G25 


G26 



(1) For 50 Hz systems, but 0.18 mΩ/m length at 60 Hz 


b Transformers (see Fig. G35) 

The impedance Ztr of a transformer, viewed from the LV terminals, is given by the 

formula: 

Ztr U Usc 

= x 

Pn 202 

100 

where: 

U 20 = open-circuit secondary phase-to-phase voltage expressed in volts 

Pn = rating of the transformer (in kVA) 

Usc = the short-circuit impedance voltage of the transformer expressed in % 

The transformer windings resistance Rtr can be derived from the total losses as 

follows: 

2 

Pcu x 10 

Pcu = 3I 

n x Rtr so that Rtr = 

2 

3I 

n 

3 

in milli-ohms 

where 

Pcu = total losses in watts 

In = nominal full-load current in amps 

Rtr = resistance of one phase of the transformer in milli-ohms (the LV and 

corresponding MV winding for one LV phase are included in this resistance value). 

2 2 

Xtr = Ztr −Rtr 

Rated Oil-immersed Cast-resin 

For an approximate calculation Rtr may be ignored since X ≈ Z in standard 

distribution type transformers. 

Power Usc (%) Rtr (mΩ) Xtr (mΩ) Ztr (mΩ) Usc (%) Rtr (mΩ) Xtr (mΩ) Ztr (mΩ) 

(kVA) 

100 4 37.9 59.5 70.6 6 37.0 99.1 105.8 

160 4 16.2 41.0 44.1 6 18.6 63.5 66.2 

200 4 11.9 33.2 35.3 6 14.1 51.0 52.9 

250 4 9.2 26.7 28.2 6 10.7 41.0 42.3 

315 4 6.2 21.5 22.4 6 8.0 32.6 33.6 

400 4 5.1 16.9 17.6 6 6.1 25.8 26.5 

500 4 3.8 13.6 14.1 6 4.6 20.7 21.2 

630 4 2.9 10.8 11.2 6 3.5 16.4 16.8 

800 6 2.9 12.9 13.2 6 2.6 13.0 13.2 

1,000 6 2.3 10.3 10.6 6 1.9 10.4 10.6 

1,250 6 1.8 8.3 8.5 6 1.5 8.3 8.5 

1,600 6 1.4 6.5 6.6 6 1.1 6.5 6.6 

2,000 6 1.1 5.2 5.3 6 0.9 5.2 5.3 

Fig. G35 : Resistance, reactance and impedance values for typical distribution 400 V transformers with MV windings y 20 kV 

b Circuit-breakers 

In LV circuits, the impedance of circuit-breakers upstream of the fault location must 

be taken into account. The reactance value conventionally assumed is 0.15 mΩ per 

CB, while the resistance is neglected. 

b Busbars 

The resistance of busbars is generally negligible, so that the impedance is practically 

all reactive, and amounts to approximately 0.15 mΩ/metre (1) length for LV busbars 

(doubling the spacing between the bars increases the reactance by about 10% only). 

b Circuit conductors 

L 

The resistance of a conductor is given by the formula: Rc = ρ 

S 

where 

ρ = the resistivity constant of the conductor material at the normal operating 

temperature being: 

v 22.5 mΩ.mm 2 /m for copper 

v 36 mΩ.mm 2 /m for aluminium 

L = length of the conductor in m 

S = c.s.a. of conductor in mm 2 



Cable reactance values can be obtained from the manufacturers. For c.s.a. of less 

than 50 mm 2 reactance may be ignored. In the absence of other information, a value 

of 0.08 mΩ/metre may be used (for 50 Hz systems) or 0.096 mΩ/metre (for 60 Hz 

systems). For prefabricated bus-trunking and similar pre-wired ducting systems, the 

manufacturer should be consulted. 

b Motors 

At the instant of short-circuit, a running motor will act (for a brief period) as a 

generator, and feed current into the fault. 

In general, this fault-current contribution may be ignored. However, for more precise 

calculation, particularly in the case of large motors and/or numerous smaller motors, 

the total contribution can be estimated from the formula: 

Iscm = 3.5 In from each motor i.e. 3.5mIn for m similar motors operating concurrently. 

The motors concerned will be the 3-phase motors only; single-phase-motor 

contribution being insignificant. 

b Fault-arc resistance 

Short-circuit faults generally form an arc which has the properties of a resistance. 

The resistance is not stable and its average value is low, but at low voltage this 

resistance is sufficient to reduce the fault-current to some extent. Experience has 

shown that a reduction of the order of 20% may be expected. This phenomenon will 

effectively ease the current-breaking duty of a CB, but affords no relief for its faultcurrent 

making duty. 

b Recapitulation table (see Fig. G36) 

Parts of power-supply system R (mΩ) X (mΩ) 

M 

Supply network 

Figure G34 

Transformer 

Figure G35 

Rtr is often negligible compared to Xtr 

for transformers > 100 kVA 

with Ztr 

Circuit-breaker Negligible XD = 0.15 mΩ/pole 

U Usc 

= x 

Pn 202 

100 

Busbars Negligible for S > 200 mm2 in the formula: XB = 0.15 mΩ/m 

(1) 

Circuit conductors (2) (1) L 

R = ρ 

S 

L 

R = ρ 

S 

Cables: Xc = 0.08 mΩ/m 

Motors See Sub-clause 4.2 Motors 

(often negligible at LV) 

Three-phase short 

circuit current in kA Isc = 

3 

U20 

2 2 

RT + XT 

U 20: Phase-to-phase no-load secondary voltage of MV/LV transformer (in volts). 

Psc: 3-phase short-circuit power at MV terminals of the MV/LV transformers (in kVA). 

Pcu: 3-phase total losses of the MV/LV transformer (in watts). 

Pn: Rating of the MV/LV transformer (in kVA). 

Usc: Short-circuit impedance voltage of the MV/LV transfomer (in %). 

R T : Total resistance. X T: Total reactance 

(1) ρ = resistivity at normal temperature of conductors in service 

b ρ = 22.5 mΩ x mm 2 /m for copper 

b ρ = 36 mΩ x mm 2 /m for aluminium 

(2) If there are several conductors in parallel per phase, then divide the resistance of one conductor by the number of 

conductors. The reactance remains practically unchanged. 

Fig. G36 : Recapitulation table of impedances for different parts of a power-supply system 


Pcu 

= 

3 n 

2 

x 10 

Rtr 

I 

3 

Ra 

= 0.1 

Xa 

U 

Xa = 0 995 Za Za = 20 

Psc 

2 2 

Ztr −Rtr 

2 

. ; 


G27 


G28 



LV installation R (mΩ) X (mΩ) RT (mΩ) XT (mΩ) 

MV network 

Psc = 500 MVA 

0.035 0.351 

Transformer 

20 kV/420 V 

Pn = 1000 kVA 

Usc = 5% 

Pcu = 13.3 x 10 

2.24 8.10 

3 watts 

Single-core cables 

5 m copper 

4 x 240 mm 

Xc = 0.08 x 5 = 0.40 2.41 8.85 Isc1 = 26 kA 

2 /phase 

Main 

circuit-breaker 

RD = 0 XD = 0.15 

Busbars 

10 m 

RB = 0 XB = 1.5 2.41 10.5 Isc2 = 22 kA 

Three-core cable 

100 m 

95 mm 

Xc = 100 x 0.08 = 8 26.1 18.5 Isc3 = 7.4 kA 

2 copper 

Three-core cable 

20 m 

10 mm 

Xc = 20 x 0.08 = 1.6 71.1 20.1 Isc4 = 3.2 kA 

2 22.5 5 

Rc = x = 0.12 

4 240 

100 

Rc = 22.5 x = 2 3.68 

95 

copper 

final circuits 

Rc = 22.5 x = 

20 

45 

10 

Fig. G37 : Example of short-circuit current calculations for a LV installation supplied at 400 V (nominal) from a 1,000 kVA MV/LV transformer 

400 V 

47,5 mm 2 , Cu 

20 m 

IB = 55 A IB = 160 A 

Isc = 28 kA 

Isc = ? 

Fig. G38 : Determination of downstream short-circuit current 

level Isc using Figure G39 


b Example of short-circuit calculations (see Fig. G37) 

4.3 Isc at the receiving end of a feeder as a function 

of the Isc at its sending end 

The network shown in Figure G38 typifies a case for the application of Figure G39 

next page, derived by the «method of composition» (mentioned in Chapter F Subclause 

6.2). These tables give a rapid and sufficiently accurate value of short-circuit 

current at a point in a network, knowing: 

b The value of short-circuit current upstream of the point considered 

b The length and composition of the circuit between the point at which the shortcircuit 

current level is known, and the point at which the level is to be determined 

It is then sufficient to select a circuit-breaker with an appropriate short-circuit fault 

rating immediately above that indicated in the tables. 

If more precise values are required, it is possible to make a detailled calculation 

(see Sub-Clause 4.2) or to use a software package, such as Ecodial. In such a case, 

moreover, the possibility of using the cascading technique should be considered, 

in which the use of a current limiting circuit-breaker at the upstream position would 

allow all circuit-breakers downstream of the limiter to have a short-circuit current 

rating much lower than would otherwise be necessary (See chapter H Sub-Clause 4.5). 

Method 

Select the c.s.a. of the conductor in the column for copper conductors (in this 

example the c.s.a. is 47.5 mm 2 ). 

Search along the row corresponding to 47.5 mm 2 for the length of conductor equal 

to that of the circuit concerned (or the nearest possible on the low side). Descend 

vertically the column in which the length is located, and stop at a row in the middle 

section (of the 3 sections of the Figure) corresponding to the known fault-current 

level (or the nearest to it on the high side). 

In this case 30 kA is the nearest to 28 kA on the high side. The value of short-circuit 

current at the downstream end of the 20 metre circuit is given at the intersection of 

the vertical column in which the length is located, and the horizontal row corresponding 

to the upstream Isc (or nearest to it on the high side). 

This value in the example is seen to be 14.7 kA. 

The procedure for aluminium conductors is similar, but the vertical column must be 

ascended into the middle section of the table. 

In consequence, a DIN-rail-mounted circuit-breaker rated at 63 A and Isc of 25 kA 

(such as a NG 125N unit) can be used for the 55 A circuit in Figure G38. 

A Compact rated at 160 A with an Isc capacity of 25 kA (such as a NS160 unit) can 

be used to protect the 160 A circuit. 


Isc = 

420 

2 2 

3 RT + XT



Copper 230 V / 400 V 

c.s.a. of phase Length of circuit (in metres) 

conductors (mm 2 ) 

1.5 1.3 1.8 2.6 3.6 5.2 7.3 10.3 14.6 21 

2.5 1.1 1.5 2.1 3.0 4.3 6.1 8.6 12.1 17.2 24 34 

4 1.2 1.7 2.4 3.4 4.9 6.9 9.7 13.7 19.4 27 39 55 

6 1.8 2.6 3.6 5.2 7.3 10.3 14.6 21 29 41 58 82 

10 2.2 3.0 4.3 6.1 8.6 12.2 17.2 24 34 49 69 97 137 

16 1.7 2.4 3.4 4.9 6.9 9.7 13.8 19.4 27 39 55 78 110 155 220 

25 1.3 1.9 2.7 3.8 5.4 7.6 10.8 15.2 21 30 43 61 86 121 172 243 343 

35 1.9 2.7 3.8 5.3 7.5 10.6 15.1 21 30 43 60 85 120 170 240 340 480 

47.5 1.8 2.6 3.6 5.1 7.2 10.2 14.4 20 29 41 58 82 115 163 231 326 461 

70 2.7 3.8 5.3 7.5 10.7 15.1 21 30 43 60 85 120 170 240 340 

95 2.6 3.6 5.1 7.2 10.2 14.5 20 29 41 58 82 115 163 231 326 461 

120 1.6 2.3 3.2 4.6 6.5 9.1 12.9 18.3 26 37 52 73 103 146 206 291 412 

150 1.2 1.8 2.5 3.5 5.0 7.0 9.9 14.0 19.8 28 40 56 79 112 159 224 317 448 

185 1.5 2.1 2.9 4.2 5.9 8.3 11.7 16.6 23 33 47 66 94 133 187 265 374 529 

240 1.8 2.6 3.7 5.2 7.3 10.3 14.6 21 29 41 58 83 117 165 233 330 466 659 

300 2.2 3.1 4.4 6.2 8.8 12.4 17.6 25 35 50 70 99 140 198 280 396 561 

2x120 2.3 3.2 4.6 6.5 9.1 12.9 18.3 26 37 52 73 103 146 206 292 412 583 

2x150 2.5 3.5 5.0 7.0 9.9 14.0 20 28 40 56 79 112 159 224 317 448 634 

2x185 2.9 4.2 5.9 8.3 11.7 16.6 23 33 47 66 94 133 187 265 375 530 749 

553x120 3.4 4.9 6.9 9.7 13.7 19.4 27 39 55 77 110 155 219 309 438 619 

3x150 3.7 5.3 7.5 10.5 14.9 21 30 42 60 84 119 168 238 336 476 672 

3x185 4.4 6.2 8.8 12.5 17.6 25 35 50 70 100 141 199 281 398 562 

Isc upstream Isc downstream 

(in kA) (in kA) 

100 93 90 87 82 77 70 62 54 45 37 29 22 17.0 12.6 9.3 6.7 4.9 3.5 2.5 1.8 1.3 0.9 

90 84 82 79 75 71 65 58 51 43 35 28 22 16.7 12.5 9.2 6.7 4.8 3.5 2.5 1.8 1.3 0.9 

80 75 74 71 68 64 59 54 47 40 34 27 21 16.3 12.2 9.1 6.6 4.8 3.5 2.5 1.8 1.3 0.9 

70 66 65 63 61 58 54 49 44 38 32 26 20 15.8 12.0 8.9 6.6 4.8 3.4 2.5 1.8 1.3 0.9 

60 57 56 55 53 51 48 44 39 35 29 24 20 15.2 11.6 8.7 6.5 4.7 3.4 2.5 1.8 1.3 0.9 

50 48 47 46 45 43 41 38 35 31 27 22 18.3 14.5 11.2 8.5 6.3 4.6 3.4 2.4 1.7 1.2 0.9 

40 39 38 38 37 36 34 32 30 27 24 20 16.8 13.5 10.6 8.1 6.1 4.5 3.3 2.4 1.7 1.2 0.9 

35 34 34 33 33 32 30 29 27 24 22 18.8 15.8 12.9 10.2 7.9 6.0 4.5 3.3 2.4 1.7 1.2 0.9 

30 29 29 29 28 27 27 25 24 22 20 17.3 14.7 12.2 9.8 7.6 5.8 4.4 3.2 2.4 1.7 1.2 0.9 

25 25 24 24 24 23 23 22 21 19.1 17.4 15.5 13.4 11.2 9.2 7.3 5.6 4.2 3.2 2.3 1.7 1.2 0.9 

20 20 20 19.4 19.2 18.8 18.4 17.8 17.0 16.1 14.9 13.4 11.8 10.1 8.4 6.8 5.3 4.1 3.1 2.3 1.7 1.2 0.9 

15 14.8 14.8 14.7 14.5 14.3 14.1 13.7 13.3 12.7 11.9 11.0 9.9 8.7 7.4 6.1 4.9 3.8 2.9 2.2 1.6 1.2 0.9 

10 9.9 9.9 9.8 9.8 9.7 9.6 9.4 9.2 8.9 8.5 8.0 7.4 6.7 5.9 5.1 4.2 3.4 2.7 2.0 1.5 1.1 0.8 

7 7.0 6.9 6.9 6.9 6.9 6.8 6.7 6.6 6.4 6.2 6.0 5.6 5.2 4.7 4.2 3.6 3.0 2.4 1.9 1.4 1.1 0.8 

5 5.0 5.0 5.0 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.8 4.7 4.6 4.5 4.3 4.0 3.7 3.4 3.0 2.5 2.1 1.7 1.3 1.0 0.8 

4 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 3.9 3.9 3.9 3.8 3.7 3.6 3.5 3.3 3.1 2.9 2.6 2.2 1.9 1.6 1.2 1.0 0.7 

3 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 2.9 2.9 2.9 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.3 2.1 1.9 1.6 1.4 1.1 0.9 0.7 

2 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.9 1.9 1.9 1.8 1.8 1.7 1.6 1.4 1.3 1.1 1.0 0.8 0.6 

1 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.5 

Aluminium 230 V / 400 V 

c.s.a. of phase Length of circuit (in metres) 

conductors (mm 2 ) 

2.5 1.4 1.9 2.7 3.8 5.4 7.6 10.8 15.3 22 

4 1.1 1.5 2.2 3.1 4.3 6.1 8.6 12.2 17.3 24 35 

6 1.6 2.3 3.2 4.6 6.5 9.2 13.0 18.3 26 37 52 

10 1.9 2.7 3.8 5.4 7.7 10.8 15.3 22 31 43 61 86 

16 2.2 3.1 4.3 6.1 8.7 12.2 17.3 24 35 49 69 98 138 

25 1.7 2.4 3.4 4.8 6.8 9.6 13.5 19.1 27 38 54 76 108 153 216 

35 1.7 2.4 3.4 4.7 6.7 9.5 13.4 18.9 27 38 54 76 107 151 214 302 

47.5 1.6 2.3 3.2 4.6 6.4 9.1 12.9 18.2 26 36 51 73 103 145 205 290 410 

70 2.4 3.4 4.7 6.7 9.5 13.4 19.0 27 38 54 76 107 151 214 303 428 

95 2.3 3.2 4.6 6.4 9.1 12.9 18.2 26 36 51 73 103 145 205 290 411 

120 2.9 4.1 5.8 8.1 11.5 16.3 23 32 46 65 92 130 184 259 367 

150 3.1 4.4 6.3 8.8 12.5 17.7 25 35 50 71 100 141 199 282 399 

185 2.6 3.7 5.2 7.4 10.4 14.8 21 30 42 59 83 118 167 236 333 471 

240 1.2 1.6 2.3 3.3 4.6 6.5 9.2 13.0 18.4 26 37 52 73 104 147 208 294 415 

300 1.4 2.0 2.8 3.9 5.5 7.8 11.1 15.6 22 31 44 62 88 125 177 250 353 499 

2x120 1.4 2.0 2.9 4.1 5.8 8.1 11.5 16.3 23 33 46 65 92 130 184 260 367 519 

2x150 1.6 2.2 3.1 4.4 6.3 8.8 12.5 17.7 25 35 50 71 100 141 200 282 399 

2x185 1.9 2.6 3.7 5.2 7.4 10.5 14.8 21 30 42 59 83 118 167 236 334 472 

2x240 2.3 3.3 4.6 6.5 9.2 13.0 18.4 26 37 52 74 104 147 208 294 415 587 

3x120 2.2 3.1 4.3 6.1 8.6 12.2 17.3 24 34 49 69 97 138 195 275 389 551 

3x150 2.3 3.3 4.7 6.6 9.4 13.3 18.8 27 37 53 75 106 150 212 299 423 598 

3x185 2.8 3.9 5.5 7.8 11.1 15.7 22 31 44 63 89 125 177 250 354 500 707 

3x240 3.5 4.9 6.9 9.8 13.8 19.5 28 39 55 78 110 156 220 312 441 623 

Note: for a 3-phase system having 230 V between phases, divide the above lengths by 3 

Fig. G39 : Isc at a point downstream, as a function of a known upstream fault-current value and the length and c.s.a. of the intervening conductors, 

in a 230/400 V 3-phase system 

4.4 Short-circuit current supplied by a generator or 

an inverter: Please refer to Chapter N 


G29 


G30 



If a protective device in a circuit is intended 

only to protect against short-circuit faults, it is 

essential that it will operate with certainty at the 

lowest possible level of short-circuit current that 

can occur on the circuit 

Circuit breaker with 

instantaneous magnetic 

short-circuit protective relay only 

Load breaking contactor 

with thermal overload relay 

Fig. G41 : Circuit protected by circuit-breaker without thermal 

overload relay 

S1 

Load with 

incorporated 

overload 

protection 

Circuit breaker D 

S2 < S1 

Fig. G42a : Circuit-breaker D provides protection against shortcircuit 

faults as far as and including the load 

5 Particular cases of short-circuit 

current 

5.1 Calculation of minimum levels of short-circuit 

current 

In general, on LV circuits, a single protective device protects against all levels of 

current, from the overload threshold through the maximum rated short-circuit currentbreaking 

capability of the device. 

In certain cases, however, overload protective devices and separate short-circuit 

protective devices are used. 

Examples of such arrangements 

Figures G40 to G42 show some common arrangements where overload and 

short-circuit protections are achieved by separate devices. 

Fig. G40 : Circuit protected by aM fuses 


aM fuses 

(no protection 

against overload) 

Load breaking contactor 

with thermal overload relay 

As shown in Figures G40 and G41, the most common circuits using separate 

devices control and protect motors. 

Figure G42a constitutes a derogation in the basic protection rules, and is generally 

used on circuits of prefabricated bustrunking, lighting rails, etc. 

Variable speed drive 

Figure G42b shows the functions provided by the variable speed drive, and if 

necessary some additional functions provided by devices such as circuit-breaker, 

thermal relay, RCD. 

Protection to be provided Protection generally provided Additional protection 

by the variable speed drive 

Cable overload Yes = (1) Not necessary if (1) 

Motor overload Yes = (2) Not necessary if (2) 

Downstream short-circuit Yes 

Variable speed drive overload Yes 

Overvoltage Yes 

Undervoltage Yes 

Loss of phase Yes 

Upstream short-circuit Circuit-breaker 

(short-circuit tripping) 

Internal fault Circuit-breaker 

(short-circuit and 

overload tripping) 

Downstream earth fault (self protection) RCD u 300 mA 

(indirect contact) 

Direct contact fault RCD y 30 mA 

Figure G42b : Protection to be provided for variable speeed drive applications


The protective device must fulfill: 

b instantaneous trip setting Im < Isc min for a 


b fusion current Ia < Isc min for a fuse 


current 

Conditions to be fulfilled 

The protective device must therefore satisfy the two following conditions: 

b Its fault-current breaking rating must be greater than Isc, the 3-phase short-circuit 

current at its point of installation 

b Elimination of the minimum short-circuit current possible in the circuit, in a time tc 

compatible with the thermal constraints of the circuit conductors, where: 

2 2 

K S (valid for tc < 5 seconds) 

tc i 

I 2 

sc min 

Comparison of the tripping or fusing performance curve of protective devices, with 

the limit curves of thermal constraint for a conductor shows that this condition is 

satisfied if: 

b Isc (min) > Im (instantaneous or short timedelay circuit-breaker trip setting current 

level), (see Fig. G45) 

b Isc (min) > Ia for protection by fuses. The value of the current Ia corresponds to 

the crossing point of the fuse curve and the cable thermal withstand curve 

(see Fig. G44 and G45) 

Fig. G45 : Protection by circuit-breaker 

Fig. G46 : Protection by aM-type fuses 

Fig. G47 : Protection by gl-type fuses 


t 

t 

t 

Im 

Ia 

Ia 

t = k2 S 2 

I 2 

t = k2 S 2 

I 2 

t = k2 S 2 

I 2 

I 

I 

I 

G31 


G32 



In practice this means that the length of circuit 

downstream of the protective device must not 

exceed a calculated maximum length: 

0.8 U Sph 

Lmax 

= 

2ρI m 

(1) For larger c.s.a.’s, the resistance calculated for the 

conductors must be increased to account for the non-uniform 

current density in the conductor (due to “skin” and “proximity” 

effects) 

Suitable values are as follows: 

150 mm 2 : R + 15% 

185 mm 2 : R + 20% 

240 mm 2 : R + 25% 

300 mm 2 : R + 30% 

(2) Or for aluminium according to conductor material 

(3) The high value for resistivity is due to the elevated 

temperature of the conductor when passing short-circuit 

current 


current 

Practical method of calculating Lmax 

The limiting effect of the impedance of long circuit conductors on the value of 

short-circuit currents must be checked and the length of a circuit must be restricted 

accordingly. 

The method of calculating the maximum permitted length has already been 

demonstrated in TN- and IT- earthed schemes for single and double earth faults, 

respectively (see Chapter F Sub-clauses 6.2 and 7.2). Two cases are considered 

below: 

1 - Calculation of L max for a 3-phase 3-wire circuit 

The minimum short-circuit current will occur when two phase wires are shortcircuited 

at the remote end of the circuit (see Fig. G46). 


P 

0.8 U 

Fig G46 : Definition of L for a 3-phase 3-wire circuit 

L 

Load 

Using the “conventional method”, the voltage at the point of protection P is assumed 

to be 80% of the nominal voltage during a short-circuit fault, so that 0.8 U = Isc Zd, 

where: 

Zd = impedance of the fault loop 

Isc = short-circuit current (ph/ph) 

U = phase-to-phase nominal voltage 

For cables y 120 mm2 , reactance may be neglected, so that 

2L 

Zd = ρ (1) 

Sph 

where: 

ρ = resistivity of copper (2) at the average temperature during a short-circuit, 

Sph = c.s.a. of a phase conductor in mm 2 

L = length in metres 

The condition for the cable protection is Im y Isc with Im = magnetic trip current 

setting of the CB. 

This leads to Im y 

0.8 U 

which gives L y 0.8 U Sph 

Zd 

Lmax 

= 

2ρI m 

with U = 400 V 

ρ = 1.25 x 0.018 = 0.023 Ω.mm 2 /m (3) 

Lmax = maximum circuit length in metres 

k Sph 

L 

m 

max = I 

2 - Calculation of Lmax for a 3-phase 4-wire 230/400 V circuit 

The minimum Isc will occur when the short-circuit is between a phase conductor and 

the neutral. 

A calculation similar to that of example 1 above is required, but using the following 

formulae (for cable y 120 mm2 (1) ). 

b Where Sn for the neutral conductor = Sph for the phase conductor 

3,333 Sph 

Lmax 

= 

Im 

b If Sn for the neutral conductor < Sph, then 

L 6,666 Sph 1 

max = 

where m = 

Im 

1+ m 

Sph 

Sn 

For larger c.s.a.’s than those listed, reactance values must be combined with those of 

resistance to give an impedance. Reactance may be taken as 0.08 mΩ/m for cables 

(at 50 Hz). At 60 Hz the value is 0.096 mΩ/m.



current 

Tabulated values for Lmax 

Figure G47 below gives maximum circuit lengths (Lmax) in metres, for: 

b 3-phase 4-wire 400 V circuits (i.e. with neutral) and 

b 1-phase 2-wire 230 V circuits 

protected by general-purpose circuit-breakers. 

In other cases, apply correction factors (given in Figure G53) to the lengths obtained. 

The calculations are based on the above methods, and a short-circuit trip level within 

± 20% of the adjusted value Im. 

For the 50 mm 2 c.s.a., calculation are based on a 47.5 mm 2 real c.s.a. 

Operating current c.s.a. (nominal cross-sectional-area) of conductors (in mm 2 ) 

level Im of the 

instantaneous 

magnetic tripping 

element (in A) 1.5 2.5 4 6 10 16 25 35 50 70 95 120 150 185 240 

50 100 167 267 400 

63 79 133 212 317 

80 63 104 167 250 417 

100 50 83 133 200 333 

125 40 67 107 160 267 427 

160 31 52 83 125 208 333 

200 25 42 67 100 167 267 417 

250 20 33 53 80 133 213 333 467 

320 16 26 42 63 104 167 260 365 495 

400 13 21 33 50 83 133 208 292 396 

500 10 17 27 40 67 107 167 233 317 

560 9 15 24 36 60 95 149 208 283 417 

630 8 13 21 32 63 85 132 185 251 370 

700 7 12 19 29 48 76 119 167 226 333 452 

800 6 10 17 25 42 67 104 146 198 292 396 

875 6 10 15 23 38 61 95 133 181 267 362 457 

1000 5 8 13 20 33 53 83 117 158 233 317 400 435 

1120 4 7 12 18 30 48 74 104 141 208 283 357 388 459 

1250 4 7 11 16 27 43 67 93 127 187 253 320 348 411 

1600 5 8 13 21 33 52 73 99 146 198 250 272 321 400 

2000 4 7 10 17 27 42 58 79 117 158 200 217 257 320 

2500 5 8 13 21 33 47 63 93 127 160 174 206 256 

3200 4 6 10 17 26 36 49 73 99 125 136 161 200 

4000 5 8 13 21 29 40 58 79 100 109 128 160 

5000 4 7 11 17 23 32 47 63 80 87 103 128 

6300 5 8 13 19 25 37 50 63 69 82 102 

8000 4 7 10 15 20 29 40 50 54 64 80 

10000 5 8 12 16 23 32 40 43 51 64 

12500 4 7 9 13 19 25 32 35 41 51 

Fig. G47 : Maximum circuit lengths in metres for copper conductors (for aluminium, the lengths must be multiplied by 0.62) 

Figures G48 to G50 next page give maximum circuit length (Lmax) in metres for: 

b 3-phase 4-wire 400 V circuits (i.e. with neutral) and 

b 1-phase 2-wire 230 V circuits 

protected in both cases by domestic-type circuit-breakers or with circuit-breakers 

having similar tripping/current characteristics. 

In other cases, apply correction factors to the lengths indicated. These factors are 

given in Figure G51 next page. 


G33 


G34 



Fig. G48 : Maximum length of copper-conductor circuits in metres protected by B-type circuit-breakers 

Fig. G49 : Maximum length of copper-conductor circuits in metres protected by C-type circuit-breakers 

Fig. G50 : Maximum length of copper-conductor circuits in metres protected by D-type circuit-breakers 

Fig. G51 : Correction factor to apply to lengths obtained from Figures G47 to G50 


current 

Rated current of c.s.a. (nominal cross-sectional-area) of conductors (in mm 2 ) 

circuit-breakers (in A) 1.5 2.5 4 6 10 16 25 35 50 

6 200 333 533 800 

10 120 200 320 480 800 

16 75 125 200 300 500 800 

20 60 100 160 240 400 640 

25 48 80 128 192 320 512 800 

32 37 62 100 150 250 400 625 875 

40 30 50 80 120 200 320 500 700 

50 24 40 64 96 160 256 400 560 760 

63 19 32 51 76 127 203 317 444 603 

80 15 25 40 60 100 160 250 350 475 

100 12 20 32 48 80 128 200 280 380 

125 10 16 26 38 64 102 160 224 304 

Rated current of c.s.a. (nominal cross-sectional-area) of conductors (in mm2) 


6 100 167 267 400 667 

10 60 100 160 240 400 640 

16 37 62 100 150 250 400 625 875 

20 30 50 80 120 200 320 500 700 

25 24 40 64 96 160 256 400 560 760 

32 18.0 31 50 75 125 200 313 438 594 

40 15.0 25 40 60 100 160 250 350 475 

50 12.0 20 32 48 80 128 200 280 380 

63 9.5 16.0 26 38 64 102 159 222 302 

80 7.5 12.5 20 30 50 80 125 175 238 

100 6.0 10.0 16.0 24 40 64 100 140 190 

125 5.0 8.0 13.0 19.0 32 51 80 112 152 

Rated current of c.s.a. (nominal cross-sectional-area) of conductors (in mm2) 


1 429 714 

2 214 357 571 857 

3 143 238 381 571 952 

4 107 179 286 429 714 

6 71 119 190 286 476 762 

10 43 71 114 171 286 457 714 

16 27 45 71 107 179 286 446 625 848 

20 21 36 57 86 143 229 357 500 679 

25 17.0 29 46 69 114 183 286 400 543 

32 13.0 22 36 54 89 143 223 313 424 

40 11.0 18.0 29 43 71 114 179 250 339 

50 9.0 14.0 23 34 57 91 143 200 271 

63 7.0 11.0 18.0 27 45 73 113 159 215 

80 5.0 9.0 14.0 21 36 57 89 125 170 

100 4.0 7.0 11.0 17.0 29 46 71 100 136 

125 3.0 6.0 9.0 14.0 23 37 57 80 109 

Circuit detail 

3-phase 3-wire 400 V circuit or 1-phase 2-wire 400 V circuit (no neutral) 1.73 

1-phase 2-wire (phase and neutral) 230 V circuit 1 

3-phase 4-wire 230/400 V circuit or 2-phase 3-wire 230/400 V circuit Sph / S neutral = 1 1 

(i.e with neutral) Sph / S neutral = 2 0.67 

Note: IEC 60898 accepts an upper short-circuit-current tripping range of 10-50 In for 

type D circuit-breakers. European standards, and Figure G50 however, are based on 

a range of 10-20 In, a range which covers the vast majority of domestic and similar 

installations. 



In general, verification of the thermal-withstand 

capability of a cable is not necessary, except in 

cases where cables of small c.s.a. are installed 

close to, or feeding directly from, the main 

general distribution board 


current 

Examples 

Example 1 

In a 1-phase 2-wire installation the protection is provided by a 50 A circuit-breaker 

type NS80HMA, the instantaneous short-circuit current trip, is set at 500 A (accuracy 

of ± 20%), i.e. in the worst case would require 500 x 1,2 = 600 A to trip. The cable 

c.s.a. = 10 mm 2 and the conductor material is copper. 

In Figure G47, the row Im = 500 A crosses the column c.s.a. = 10 mm 2 at the value 

for Lmax of 67 m. The circuit-breaker protects the cable against short-circuit faults, 

therefore, provided that its length does not exceed 67 metres. 

Example 2 

In a 3-phase 3-wire 400 V circuit (without neutral), the protection is provided by a 

220 A circuit-breaker type NS250N with an instantaneous short-circuit current trip 

unit type MA set at 2,000 A (± 20%), i.e. a worst case of 2,400 A to be certain of 

tripping. The cable c.s.a. = 120 mm 2 and the conductor material is copper. 

In Figure G47 the row Im = 2,000 A crosses the column c.s.a. = 120 mm 2 at the 

value for Lmax of 200 m. Being a 3-phase 3-wire 400 V circuit (without neutral), a 

correction factor from Figure G51 must be applied. This factor is seen to be 1.73. 

The circuit-breaker will therefore protect the cable against short-circuit current, 

provided that its length does not exceed 200 x 1.73= 346 metres. 

5.2 Verification of the withstand capabilities of 

cables under short-circuit conditions 

Thermal constraints 

When the duration of short-circuit current is brief (several tenths of a second 

up to five seconds maximum) all of the heat produced is assumed to remain in 

the conductor, causing its temperature to rise. The heating process is said to be 

adiabatic, an assumption that simplifies the calculation and gives a pessimistic result, 

i.e. a higher conductor temperature than that which would actually occur, since in 

practice, some heat would leave the conductor and pass into the insulation. 

For a period of 5 seconds or less, the relationship I 2 t = k 2 S 2 characterizes the 

time in seconds during which a conductor of c.s.a. S (in mm 2 ) can be allowed to 

carry a current I, before its temperature reaches a level which would damage the 

surrounding insulation. 

The factor k 2 is given in Figure G52 below. 

Insulation Conductor copper (Cu) Conductor aluminium (Al) 

PVC 13,225 5,776 

XLPE 20,449 8,836 

Fig. G52 : Value of the constant k 2 

The method of verification consists in checking that the thermal energy I 2 t per 

ohm of conductor material, allowed to pass by the protecting circuit-breaker (from 

manufacturers catalogues) is less than that permitted for the particular conductor (as 

given in Figure G53 below). 

S (mm 2 ) PVC XLPE 

Copper Aluminium Copper Aluminium 

1.5 0.0297 0.0130 0.0460 0.0199 

2.5 0.0826 0.0361 0.1278 0.0552 

4 0.2116 0.0924 0.3272 0.1414 

6 0.4761 0.2079 0.7362 0.3181 

10 1.3225 0.5776 2.0450 0.8836 

16 3.3856 1.4786 5.2350 2.2620 

25 8.2656 3.6100 12.7806 5.5225 

35 16.2006 7.0756 25.0500 10.8241 

50 29.839 13.032 46.133 19.936 

Fig. G53 : Maximum allowable thermal stress for cables I 2 t (expressed in ampere 2 x second x 10 6 ) 


G35 


G36 




current 

Example 

Is a copper-cored XLPE cable of 4 mm 2 c.s.a. adequately protected by a 

C60N circuit-breaker? 

Figure G53 shows that the I 2 t value for the cable is 0.3272 x 10 6 , while the maximum 

“let-through” value by the circuit-breaker, as given in the manufacturer’s catalogue, is 

considerably less (< 0.1.10 6 A 2 s). 

The cable is therefore adequately protected by the circuit-breaker up to its full rated 

breaking capability. 

Electrodynamic constraints 

For all type of circuit (conductors or bus-trunking), it is necessary to take 

electrodynamic effects into account. 

To withstand the electrodynamic constraints, the conductors must be solidly fixed 

and the connection must be strongly tightened. 

For bus-trunking, rails, etc. it is also necessary to verify that the electrodynamic 

withstand performance is satisfactory when carrying short-circuit currents. The peak 

value of current, limited by the circuit-breaker or fuse, must be less than the busbar 

system rating. Tables of coordination ensuring adequate protection of their products 

are generally published by the manufacturers and provide a major advantage of such 

systems. 



PE 

PE 

Correct 

Incorrect 

Fig. G54 : A poor connection in a series arrangement will leave 

all downstream appliances unprotected 

PEN 

Fig. G55 : Direct connection of the PEN conductor to the earth 

terminal of an appliance 

6 Protective earthing conductor 

(PE) 

6.1 Connection and choice 

Protective (PE) conductors provide the bonding connection between all exposed 

and extraneous conductive parts of an installation, to create the main equipotential 

bonding system. These conductors conduct fault current due to insulation failure 

(between a phase conductor and an exposed conductive part) to the earthed neutral 

of the source. PE conductors are connected to the main earthing terminal of the 


The main earthing terminal is connected to the earthing electrode (see Chapter E) 

by the earthing conductor (grounding electrode conductor in the USA). 

PE conductors must be: 

b Insulated and coloured yellow and green (stripes) 

b Protected against mechanical and chemical damage 

In IT and TN-earthed schemes it is strongly recommended that PE conductors 

should be installed in close proximity (i.e. in the same conduits, on the same cable 

tray, etc.) as the live cables of the related circuit. This arrangement ensures the 

minimum possible inductive reactance in the earth-fault current carrying circuits. 

It should be noted that this arrangement is originally provided by bus-trunking. 

Connection 

PE conductors must: 

b Not include any means of breaking the continuity of the circuit (such as a switch, 

removable links, etc.) 

b Connect exposed conductive parts individually to the main PE conductor, i.e. in 

parallel, not in series, as shown in Figure G54 

b Have an individual terminal on common earthing bars in distribution boards. 

TT scheme 

The PE conductor need not necessarily be installed in close proximity to the live 

conductors of the corresponding circuit, since high values of earth-fault current are 

not needed to operate the RCD-type of protection used in TT installations. 

IT and TN schemes 

The PE or PEN conductor, as previously noted, must be installed as close as 

possible to the corresponding live conductors of the circuit and no ferro-magnetic 

material must be interposed between them. A PEN conductor must always be 

connected directly to the earth terminal of an appliance, with a looped connection 

from the earth terminal to the neutral terminal of the appliance (see Fig. G55). 

b TN-C scheme (the neutral and PE conductor are one and the same, referred to as 

a PEN conductor) 

The protective function of a PEN conductor has priority, so that all rules governing 

PE conductors apply strictly to PEN conductors 

b TN-C to TN-S transition 

The PE conductor for the installation is connected to the PEN terminal or bar (see 

Fig. G56) generally at the origin of the installation. Downstream of the point of 

separation, no PE conductor can be connected to the neutral conductor. 

Fig. G56 : The TN-C-S scheme 


PEN PE 

N 

G37 


G38 



Fig. G57 : Choice of protective conductors (PE) 

Fig. G58 : Minimum cross section area of protective conductors 

Types of materials 

Materials of the kinds mentioned below in Figure G57 can be used for PE conductors, 

provided that the conditions mentioned in the last column are satisfied. 

Type of protective earthing conductor (PE) IT scheme TN scheme TT scheme Conditions to be respected 

Supplementary In the same cable Strongly Strongly recommended Correct The PE conductor must 

conductor as the phases, or in recommended be insulated to the same 

the same cable run level as the phases 

Independent of the Possible (1) Possible (1) (2) Correct b The PE conductor may 

phase conductors be bare or insulated (2) 

Metallic housing of bus-trunking or of other Possible (3) PE possible (3) Correct b The electrical continuity 

prefabricated prewired ducting (5) PEN possible (8) must be assured by protection 

External sheath of extruded, mineral- insulated Possible (3) PE possible (3) Possible against deterioration by 

conductors (e.g. «pyrotenax» type systems) PEN not recommended (2)(3) Certain extraneous conductive elements 

mechanical, chemical and 

(6) Possible (4) PE possible (4) Possible 

electrochemical hazards 

such as: PEN forbidden b Their conductance 

b Steel building structures 

b Machine frames 

b Water pipes 

must be adequate 

(7) 

Metallic cable ways, such as, conduits (9) , Possible (4) PE possible (4) Possible 

ducts, trunking, trays, ladders, and so on… PEN not recommended (2)(4) 

Forbidden for use as PE conductors, are: metal conduits (9) , gas pipes, hot-water pipes, cable-armouring tapes (9) or wires (9) 

(1) In TN and IT schemes, fault clearance is generally achieved by overcurrent devices (fuses or circuit-breakers) so that the impedance 

of the fault-current loop must be sufficiently low to assure positive protective device operation. The surest means of achieving a low loop 

impedance is to use a supplementary core in the same cable as the circuit conductors (or taking the same route as the circuit conductors). 

This solution minimizes the inductive reactance and therefore the impedance of the loop. 

(2) The PEN conductor is a neutral conductor that is also used as a protective earth conductor. This means that a current may be flowing 

through it at any time (in the absence of an earth fault). For this reason an insulated conductor is recommended for PEN operation. 

(3) The manufacturer provides the necessary values of R and X components of the impedances (phase/PE, phase/PEN) to include in the 

calculation of the earth-fault loop impedance. 

(4) Possible, but not recomended, since the impedance of the earth-fault loop cannot be known at the design stage. Measurements on the 

completed installation are the only practical means of assuring adequate protection for persons. 

(5) It must allow the connection of other PE conductors. Note: these elements must carry an indivual green/yellow striped visual indication, 

15 to 100 mm long (or the letters PE at less than 15 cm from each extremity). 

(6) These elements must be demountable only if other means have been provided to ensure uninterrupted continuity of protection. 

(7) With the agreement of the appropriate water authorities. 

(8) In the prefabricated pre-wired trunking and similar elements, the metallic housing may be used as a PEN conductor, in parallel with the 

corresponding bar, or other PE conductor in the housing. 

(9) Forbidden in some countries only. Universally allowed to be used for supplementary equipotential conductors. 

6.2 Conductor sizing 

Figure G58 below is based on IEC 60364-5-54. This table provides two methods of 

determining the appropriate c.s.a. for both PE or PEN conductors. 

c.s.a. of phase Minimum c.s.a. of Minimum c.s.a. of 

conductors Sph (mm2 ) PE conductor (mm2 ) PEN conductor (mm2 ) 

Cu Al 

Simplified Sph y 16 S (2) 

ph Sph 

(3) 

Sph 

(3) 

method (1) 16 < Sph y 25 16 16 

25 < Sph y 35 25 

35 < Sph y 50 Sph /2 Sph /2 

Sph > 50 S Sph /2 

Adiabatic method Any size 


(PE) 

SPE/PEN 

= 

(1) Data valid if the prospective conductor is of the same material as the line conductor. Otherwise, a correction factor must be applied. 

(2) When the PE conductor is separated from the circuit phase conductors, the following minimum values must be respected: 

b 2.5 mm 2 if the PE is mechanically protected 

b 4 mm 2 if the PE is not mechanically protected 

(3) For mechanical reasons, a PEN conductor, shall have a cross-sectional area not less than 10 mm 2 in copper or 16 mm 2 in aluminium. 

(4) Refer to table G53 for the application of this formula. 

I ⋅t 

k 

2 

(3) (4) 

(3) (4) 



(1) Grounding electrode conductor 


(PE) 

The two methods are: 

b Adiabatic (which corresponds with that described in IEC 60724) 

This method, while being economical and assuring protection of the conductor 

against overheating, leads to small c.s.a.’s compared to those of the corresponding 

circuit phase conductors. The result is sometimes incompatible with the necessity 

in IT and TN schemes to minimize the impedance of the circuit earth-fault loop, to 

ensure positive operation by instantaneous overcurrent tripping devices. This method 

is used in practice, therefore, for TT installations, and for dimensioning an earthing 

conductor (1) . 

b Simplified 

This method is based on PE conductor sizes being related to those of the 

corresponding circuit phase conductors, assuming that the same conductor material 

is used in each case. 

Thus, in Figure G58 for: 

Sph y 16 mm 2 SPE = Sph 

16 < Sph y 35 mm2 SPE = 16 mm2 Sph > 35 mm2 Sph 

Sph > 35 mm2 SPE 

= 

2 

: when, in a TT scheme, the installation earth electrode is beyond the zone of 

Note: when, in a TT scheme, the installation earth electrode is beyond the zone of 

influence of the source earthing electrode, the c.s.a. of the PE conductor can be 

limited to 25 mm2 (for copper) or 35 mm2 (for aluminium). 

The neutral cannot be used as a PEN conductor unless its c.s.a. is equal to or larger 

than 10 mm 2 (copper) or 16 mm 2 (aluminium). 

Moreover, a PEN conductor is not allowed in a flexible cable. Since a PEN conductor 

functions also as a neutral conductor, its c.s.a. cannot, in any case, be less than that 

necessary for the neutral, as discussed in Subclause 7.1 of this Chapter. 

This c.s.a. cannot be less than that of the phase conductors unless: 

b The kVA rating of single-phase loads is less than 10% of the total kVA load, and 

b Imax likely to pass through the neutral in normal circumstances, is less than the 

current permitted for the selected cable size. 

Furthermore, protection of the neutral conductor must be assured by the protective 

devices provided for phase-conductor protection (described in Sub-clause 7.2 of this 

Chapter). 

Values of factor k to be used in the formulae 

These values are identical in several national standards, and the temperature rise 

ranges, together with factor k values and the upper temperature limits for the different 

classes of insulation, correspond with those published in IEC 60724 (1984). 

The data presented in Figure G59 are those most commonly needed for LV installation 

design. 

k values Nature of insulation 

Polyvinylchloride (PVC) Cross-linked-polyethylene 

(XLPE) 

Ethylene-propylene-rubber 

(EPR) 

Final temperature (°C) 160 250 

Initial temperature (°C) 30 30 

Insulated conductors Copper 143 176 

not incoporated in 

cables or bare 

conductors in contact 

with cable jackets 

Aluminium 

Steel 

95 

52 

116 

64 

Conductors of a Copper 115 143 

multi-core-cable Aluminium 76 94 

Fig. G59 : k factor values for LV PE conductors, commonly used in national standards and 

complying with IEC 60724 


G39 


G40 



These conductors must be sized according to 

national practices 


(PE) 

6.3 Protective conductor between MV/LV transformer 

and the main general distribution board (MGDB) 

All phase and neutral conductors upstream of the main incoming circuit-breaker 

controlling and protecting the MGDB are protected by devices at the MV side of the 

transformer. The conductors in question, together with the PE conductor, must be 

dimensioned accordingly. Dimensioning of the phase and neutral conductors from 

the transformer is exemplified in Sub-clause 7.5 of this chapter (for circuit C1 of the 

system illustrated in Fig. G65). 

Recommended conductor sizes for bare and insulated PE conductors from the 

transformer neutral point, shown in Figure G60, are indicated below in Figure G61. 

The kVA rating to consider is the sum of all (if more than one) transformers 

connected to the MGDB. 


PE 

Main earth bar 

for the LV installation 

Fig. G60 : PE conductor to the main earth bar in the MGDB 

MGDB 

The table indicates the c.s.a. of the conductors in mm 2 according to: 

b The nominal rating of the MV/LV transformer(s) in kVA 

b The fault-current clearance time by the MV protective devices, in seconds 

b The kinds of insulation and conductor materials 

If the MV protection is by fuses, then use the 0.2 seconds columns. 

In IT schemes, if an overvoltage protection device is installed (between the 

transformer neutral point and earth) the conductors for connection of the device 

should also be dimensioned in the same way as that described above for 

PE conductors. 

Transformer Conductor Bare PVC-insulated XLPE-insulated 

rating in kVA material conductors conductors conductors 

(230/400 V Copper t(s) 0.2 0.5 - 0.2 0.5 - 0.2 0.5 - 

output) Aluminium t(s) - 0.2 0.5 - 0.2 0.5 - 0.2 0.5 

y100 c.s.a. of PE 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 

160 conductors 25 25 35 25 25 50 25 25 35 

200 SPE (mm 2 ) 25 35 50 25 35 50 25 25 50 

250 25 35 70 35 50 70 25 35 50 

315 35 50 70 35 50 95 35 50 70 

400 50 70 95 50 70 95 35 50 95 

500 50 70 120 70 95 120 50 70 95 

630 70 95 150 70 95 150 70 95 120 

800 70 120 150 95 120 185 70 95 150 

1,000 95 120 185 95 120 185 70 120 150 

1,250 95 150 185 120 150 240 95 120 185 

Fig. G61 : Recommended c.s.a. of PE conductor between the MV/LV transformer and the MGDB, 

as a function of transformer ratings and fault-clearance times.



(PE) 

6.4 Equipotential conductor 

The main equipotential conductor 

This conductor must, in general, have a c.s.a. at least equal to half of that of the 

largest PE conductor, but in no case need exceed 25 mm 2 (copper) or 35 mm 2 

(aluminium) while its minimum c.s.a. is 6 mm 2 (copper) or 10 mm 2 (aluminium). 

Supplementary equipotential conductor 

This conductor allows an exposed conductive part which is remote from the nearest 

main equipotential conductor (PE conductor) to be connected to a local protective 

conductor. Its c.s.a. must be at least half of that of the protective conductor to which 

it is connected. 

If it connects two exposed conductive parts (M1 and M2 in Figure G62) its c.s.a. 

must be at least equal to that of the smaller of the two PE conductors (for M1 and 

M2). Equipotential conductors which are not incorporated in a cable, should be 

protected mechanically by conduits, ducting, etc. wherever possible. 

Other important uses for supplementary equipotential conductors concern the 

reduction of the earth-fault loop impedance, particulary for indirect-contact protection 

schemes in TN- or IT-earthed installations, and in special locations with increased 

electrical risk (refer to IEC 60364-4-41). 

Between two exposed conductive parts 

if SPE1 y SPE2 

then SLS = SPE1 

M1 

SPE1 SPE2 

SPE1 

M2 

Fig. G62 : Supplementary equipotential conductors 


Between an exposed conductive part 

and a metallic structure 

SLS = 

SPE 

SLS SLS 

2 

M1 

Metal structures 

(conduits, girders…) 

G41 


G42 



(1) Harmonics of order 3 and multiple of 3 

I 1 H1 

Fig. G63a : Triplen harmonics are in phase and cumulate in the Neutral 

7 The neutral conductor 

The c.s.a. and the protection of the neutral conductor, apart from its current-carrying 

requirement, depend on several factors, namely: 

b The type of earthing system, TT, TN, etc. 

b The harmonic currents 

b The method of protection against indirect contact hazards according to the 

methods described below 

The color of the neutral conductor is statutorily blue. PEN conductor, when insulated, 

shall be marked by one of the following methods : 

b Green-and-yellow throughout its length with, in addition, light blue markings at the 

terminations, or 

b Light blue throughout its length with, in addition, green-and-yellow markings at the 

terminations 

7.1 Sizing the neutral conductor 

Influence of the type of earthing system 

TT and TN-S schemes 

b Single-phase circuits or those of c.s.a. y 16 mm 2 (copper) 25 mm 2 (aluminium): the 

c.s.a. of the neutral conductor must be equal to that of the phases 

b Three-phase circuits of c.s.a. > 16 mm 2 copper or 25 mm 2 aluminium: the c.s.a. of 

the neutral may be chosen to be: 

v Equal to that of the phase conductors, or 

v Smaller, on condition that: 

- The current likely to flow through the neutral in normal conditions is less than the 

permitted value Iz. The influence of triplen (1) harmonics must be given particular 

consideration or 

- The neutral conductor is protected against short-circuit, in accordance with the 

following Sub-clause G-7.2 

- The size of the neutral conductor is at least equal to 16 mm 2 in copper or 25 mm 2 in 

aluminium 

TN-C scheme 

The same conditions apply in theory as those mentioned above, but in practice, 

the neutral conductor must not be open-circuited under any circumstances since 

it constitutes a PE as well as a neutral conductor (see Figure G58 “c.s.a. of PEN 

conductor” column). 

IT scheme 

In general, it is not recommended to distribute the neutral conductor, i.e. a 3-phase 

3-wire scheme is preferred. When a 3-phase 4-wire installation is necessary, 

however, the conditions described above for TT and TN-S schemes are applicable. 

Influence of harmonic currents 

Effects of triplen harmonics 

Harmonics are generated by the non-linear loads of the installation (computers, 

fluorescent lighting, rectifiers, power electronic choppers) and can produce high 

currents in the Neutral. In particular triplen harmonics of the three Phases have a 

tendency to cumulate in the Neutral as: 

b Fundamental currents are out-of-phase by 2π/3 so that their sum is zero 

b On the other hand, triplen harmonics of the three Phases are always positioned in 

the same manner with respect to their own fundamental, and are in phase with each 

other (see Fig. G63a). 

+ 

I 1 H3 

I 2 H1 + I 2 H3 

I 3 H1 

I N = 

3 

1 

I k H1 

+ 

+ 

I 3 H3 

I k H3 

0 + 3 

IH3 Schneider Electric - Electrical installation guide 2008 

3 

1



Figure G63b shows the load factor of the neutral conductor as a function of the 

percentage of 3 rd harmonic. 

In practice, this maximum load factor cannot exceed 3. 

2.0 

1.8 

1.6 

1.4 

1.2 

1.0 

0.8 

0.6 

0.4 

0.2 

I Neutral 

I Phase 

Fig. G63b : Load factor of the neutral conductor vs the percentage of 3 rd harmonic 

Reduction factors for harmonic currents in four-core and five-core cables with 

four cores carrying current 

The basic calculation of a cable concerns only cables with three loaded conductors 

i.e there is no current in the neutral conductor. Because of the third harmonic current, 

there is a current in the neutral. As a result, this neutral current creates an hot 

environment for the 3 phase conductors and for this reason, a reduction factor for 

phase conductors is necessary (see Fig. G63). 

Reduction factors, applied to the current-carrying capacity of a cable with three 

loaded conductors, give the current-carrying capacity of a cable with four loaded 

conductors, where the current in the fourth conductor is due to harmonics. The 

reduction factors also take the heating effect of the harmonic current in the phase 

conductors into account. 

b Where the neutral current is expected to be higher than the phase current, then the 

cable size should be selected on the basis of the neutral current 

b Where the cable size selection is based on a neutral current which is not 

significantly higher than the phase current, it is necessary to reduce the tabulated 

current carrying capacity for three loaded conductors 

b If the neutral current is more than 135% of the phase current and the cable size is 

selected on the basis of the neutral current then the three phase conductors will not 

be fully loaded. The reduction in heat generated by the phase conductors offsets the 

heat generated by the neutral conductor to the extent that it is not necessary to apply 

any reduction factor to the current carrying capacity for three loaded conductors. 


0 

0 20 40 60 80 100 

i3 (%) 

Third harmonic content Reduction factor 

of phase current Size selection is based on Size selection is based on 

(%) phase current neutral current 

0 - 15 1.0 - 

15 - 33 0.86 - 

33 - 45 - 0.86 

> 45 - 1.0 

Fig. G63 : Reduction factors for harmonic currents in four-core and five-core cables 

(according to IEC 60364-5-52) 

G43 


G44 




Examples 

Consider a three-phase circuit with a design load of 37 A to be installed using fourcore 

PVC insulated cable clipped to a wall, installation method C. From Figure G24, 

a 6 mm 2 cable with copper conductors has a current-carrying capacity of 40 A and 

hence is suitable if harmonics are not present in the circuit. 

b If 20 % third harmonic is present, then a reduction factor of 0,86 is applied and the 

design load becomes: 37/0.86 = 43 A. 

For this load a 10 mm 2 cable is necessary. 

b If 40 % third harmonic is present, the cable size selection is based on the neutral 

current which is: 37 x 0,4 x 3 = 44,4 A and a reduction factor of 0,86 is applied, 

leading to a design load of: 44.4/0.86 = 51.6 A. 

For this load a 10 mm 2 cable is suitable. 

b If 50 % third harmonic is present, the cable size is again selected on the basis of 

the neutral current, which is: 37 x 0,5 x 3 = 55,5 A .In this case the rating factor is 

1 and a 16 mm 2 cable is required. 

7.2 Protection of the neutral conductor 

(see Fig. G64 next page) 

Protection against overload 

If the neutral conductor is correctly sized (including harmonics), no specific 

protection of the neutral conductor is required because it is protected by the phase 

protection. 

However, in practice, if the c.s.a. of the neutral conductor is lower than the phase 

c.s.a, a neutral overload protection must be installed. 

Protection against short-circuit 

If the c.s.a. of the neutral conductor is lower than the c.s.a. of the phase conductor, 

the neutral conductor must be protected against short-circuit. 

If the c.s.a. of the neutral conductor is equal or greater than the c.s.a. of the phase 

conductor, no specific protection of the neutral conductor is required because it is 

protected by the phase protection. 

7.3 Breaking of the neutral conductor 


The need to break or not the neutral conductor is related to the protection against 

indirect contact. 

In TN-C scheme 

The neutral conductor must not be open-circuited under any circumstances since it 

constitutes a PE as well as a neutral conductor. 

In TT, TN-S and IT schemes 

In the event of a fault, the circuit-breaker will open all poles, including the neutral 

pole, i.e. the circuit-breaker is omnipolar. 

The action can only be achieved with fuses in an indirect way, in which the operation 

of one or more fuses triggers a mechanical trip-out of all poles of an associated 

series-connected load-break switch. 

7.4 Isolation of the neutral conductor 


It is considered to be the good practice that every circuit be provided with the means 

for its isolation. 



Single-phase 

(Phase-Neutral) 

Single-phase 

(Phase-Phase) 

Three-phase 

four wires 

Sn u Sph 

Three-phase 

four wires 

Sn < Sph 

Fig. G64 : The various situations in which the neutral conductor may appear 

TT TN-C TN-S IT 

N N N N 

or or 

N 


(A) (A) 

or or 

N N N 

N 

or 

N N N 

or 

(A) Authorized for TT or TN-S systems if a RCD is installed at the origin of the circuit or upstream of it, and if no artificial 

neutral is distributed downstream of its location 

(B) The neutral overcurrent protection is not necessary: 

b If the neutral conductor is protected against short-circuits by a device placed upstream, or, 

b If the circuit is protected by a RCD which sensitivity is less than 15% of the neutral admissible current. 


N 

N 

N 

(B) 

(B) 

(B) 

G45 


G46 



Q9 

C9 

L9 

B8 

x1 

Fig. G65 : Example of single-line diagram 

Q6 

C6 

T6 

Q7 

C7 

B2 

Circuit 9 

T1 

C1 

Q1 

Circuit 6 

P = 400 kVA 

U = 400 V 

Circuit 7 

ku = 1.0 

ib = 250.00 A 

P = 147.22 kW 

8 Worked example of cable 

calculation 

Worked example of cable calculation (see Fig. G65) 

The installation is supplied through a 1,000 kVA transformer. The process requires 

a high degree of supply continuity and this is provided by the installation of a 500 kVA 

400 V standby generator and the adoption of a 3-phase 3-wire IT system at the main 

general distribution board. The remainder of the installation is isolated by a 400 kVA 

400/400 V transformer. The downstream network is a TT-earthed 3-phase 4-wire 

system. Following the single-line diagram shown in Figure G65 below, a reproduction 

of the results of a computer study for the circuit C1, the circuit-breaker Q1, the circuit 

C6 and the circuit-breaker Q6. These studies were carried out with ECODIAL 3.3 

software (a Merlin Gerin product). 

This is followed by the same calculations carried out by the method described in this 

guide. 

1000 kVA 400 V 50 Hz 

Circuit 1 

Q10 

C10 

L10 

Q3 

B4 

x1 

Switchboard 2 

Ks = 1.00 

ib = 826.8 A 

Q12 

C12 

L12 

Circuit 10 

ku = 1.0 

ib = 160.00 A 

P = 94.22 kW 

x1 


G5 

C5 

Q5 

Circuit 12 

G 

ku = 1.0 

ib = 250.00 A 

P = 147.22 kW 

Q11 

C11 

L11 

x1 

P = 500 kVA 

U = 400 V 

Circuit 5 

Switchboard 8 

Ks = 1.00 

ib = 490.0 A 

Circuit 11 

Switchboard 4 

Ks = 1.00 

ib = 250.0 A 

ku = 1.0 

ib = 80.00 A 

P = 47.11 kW


General network characteristics 

Earthing system IT 

Neutral distributed No 

Voltage (V) 400 

Frequency (Hz) 50 

Transformer T1 

Number of transformers 1 

Upstream fault level (MVA) 500 

Rating (kVA) 1,000 

Short-circuit impedance voltage (%) 6 

Resistance of MV network (mΩ) 0.0351 

Reactance of MV network (mΩ) 0.351 

Transformer resistance RT (mΩ) 2.293 

Transformer reactance XT (mΩ) 10.333 

3-phase short-circuit current Ik3 (kA) 23.3 

Cable C1 

Maximum load current (A) 1,374 

Type of insulation PVC 

Conductor material Copper 

Ambient temperature (°C) 30 

Single-core or multi-core cable Single 

Installation method F 

Number of circuits in close proximity (table G21b) 1 

Other coefficient 1 

Selected cross-sectional area (mm 2 ) 6 x 95 

Protective conductor 1 x 120 

Length (m) 5 

Voltage drop ΔU (%) .122 

Voltage drop ΔU total (%) .122 

3-phase short-circuit current Ik3 (kA) 23 

1-phase-to-earth fault current Id (kA) 17 

Circuit-breaker Q1 

3-ph short-circuit current Ik3 upstream 

of the circuit-breaker (kA) 23 


Number of poles and protected poles 3P3D 

Circuit-breaker NT 16 

Type H 1 – 42 kA 

Tripping unit type Micrologic 5 A 

Rated current (A) 1,600 

Fig. G66 : Partial results of calculation carried out with Ecodial software (Merlin Gerin) 


calculation 

Calculation using software Ecodial 3.3 

The same calculation using the simplified method 

recommended in this guide 

Dimensioning circuit C1 

The MV/LV 1,000 kVA transformer has a rated no-load voltage of 420 V. Circuit C1 

must be suitable for a current of 

3 

1,000 x 10 

IB = = 1,374 A per phase 

3 x 420 

Six single-core PVC-insulated copper cables in parallel will be used for each phase. 

These cables will be laid on cable trays according to method F. The “k” correction 

factors are as follows: 

k 1 = 1 (see table G12, temperature = 30 °C) 

k 4 = 0.87 (see table G17, touching cables, 1 tray, u 3 circuits) 

Other correction factors are not relevant in this example. 

The corrected load current is: 

IB 

1,374 

I' B = = = 1,579 A 

k1⋅k4 0. 87 

Each conductor will therefore carry 263 A. Figure G21a G23 indicates that the the c.s.a. is is 

95 mm2 . 


Busbars B2 


Type Standard on 

edge 


Dimensions (m and mm) 1 m 

2x5 mm x 63 mm 

Material Copper 

3-ph short-circuit current Ik3 (kA) 23 

3-ph peak value of short-circuit current Ik (kA) 48 

Resistance of busbar R (mΩ) 2.52 

Reactance of busbar X (mΩ) 10.8 

Circuit-breaker Q6 

3-ph short-circuit current upstream 

of the circuit-breaker Ik3 (kA) 23 

Maximum load current (A) 560 

Number of poles and protected poles 3P3D 

Circuit-breaker NS800 

Type N – 50 kA 

Tripping unit type Micrologic 2.0 

Rated current (A) 800 

Limit of discrimination (kA) Total 

Cable C6 

Maximum load current (A) 560 

Type of insulation PVC 

Conductor material Copper 


Single-core or multi-core cable Single 

Installation method F 

Number of circuits in close proximity (table G20) 1 

Other coefficient 1 

Selected cross-sectional area (mm 2 ) 1 x 300 

Protective conductor 1 x 150 

Length (m) 15 

Voltage drop ΔU (%) .38 

Voltage drop ΔU total (%) .54 

3-phase short-circuit current Ik3 (kA) 20 

1-phase-to-earth fault current Id (kA) 13.7 

Specific sizing constraint Overloads 

G47 


G48 




calculation 

The resistances and the inductive reactances for the six conductors in parallel are, 

for a length of 5 metres: 

for a length of 5 metres: 

22.5 x 5 

R = = 0.20 mΩ (cable resistance: 22.5 22.5 m mΩ.mm 

95 x 6 

Ω 

2 /m) 

X = 0.08 x 5 = 0.40 mΩ (cable reactance: 0.08 mΩ/m) 

Dimensioning circuit C6 

Circuit C6 supplies a 400 kVA 3-phase 400/400 V isolating transformer 

3 

400. 10 

Primary current = = 550 A 

420. 3 

A single-core cable laid laid on on a a cable cable tray tray (without (without any any other other cable) cable) in an in ambient an ambient air air 

temperature of 30 °C is proposed. The circuit-breaker is set at 560 A 

The method of installation is characterized by the reference letter F, and the “k” 

correcting factors are all equal to 1. 

A c.s.a. of 240 mm 2 is appropriate. 

The resistance and inductive reactance are respectively: 

22.5 x 15 

R = = 1.4 mΩ 

240 

X = 0.08 x 15 = 1.2 mΩ 

Calculation of short-circuit currents for the selection of circuit-breakers 

Q 1 and Q 6 (see Fig. G67) 

Circuits components R (mΩ) X (mΩ) Z (mΩ) Ikmax (kA) 

parts 

500 MVA at 0.04 0.36 

the MV source network 

1 MVA transformer 2.2 9.8 10.0 23 

Cable C1 0.20 0.4 

Sub-total for Q1 2.44 10.6 10.9 23 

Busbar B2 3.6 7.2 

Cable C6 1.4 1.2 

Sub-total for Q6 4.0 8.4 9.3 20 

Fig. G67 : Example of short-circuit current evaluation 

The protective conductor 

Thermal requirements: Figures G58 and G59 show that, when using the adiabatic 

method the c.s.a. for for the the protective earth earth (PE) (PE) conductor conductor for circuit for C1 circuit will be: C1 will be: 

34,800 x 0.2 

143 

2 

= 108 mm 

A single 120 mm 2 conductor dimensioned for other reasons mentioned later is 

therefore largely sufficient, provided that it also satisfies the requirements for indirectcontact 

protection (i.e. that its impedance is sufficiently low). 

For the circuit C6, the c.s.a. of its PE conductor should be: 

29,300 x 0.2 

2 

= 92 mm 

143 

In this case a 95 mm2 conductor may be adequate if the indirect-contact protection 

conditions are also satisfied. 




calculation 

Protection against indirect-contact hazards 

For circuit C6 of Figure G65, Figures F45 and F61, or the formula given page F27 

may be used for a 3-phase 3-wire circuit. 

The maximum permitted length of the circuit is given by : 

0.8 x 240 x 230 3 x 1,000 

Lmax 

2 x 22.5 1+ 240 

= 

= 70 m 

⎛ ⎞ 

x 630 x 11 

⎝ 95 ⎠ 

(The value in the denominator 630 x 11 I= 

Im i.e. the current level at which the 

instantaneous short-circuit magnetic trip of the 630 A circuit-breaker operates). 

The length of 15 metres is therefore fully protected by “instantaneous” overcurrent 

devices. 

Voltage drop 

From Figure G28 it can be seen that: 

b For the cable C1 (6 x 95mm2 per phase) 

-1 -1 

∆U 

0.42 (V A km ) x 1,374 (A) x 0.008 = = 1.54 V 

3 

∆U% 

100 = 1.54 = 0.38% 

400 x 

b For the circuit C6 

∆U 

0.21 (V A km ) x 433 (A) x 0.015 -1 -1 

= = 1.36 V 

3 

∆U% 

100 = 1.36 = 0.34% 

400 x 

At the circuit terminals of the LV/LV transformer the percentage volt-drop 

ΔU% = 0.72% 


G49 


2 

3 

4 

Chapter H 

LV switchgear: functions & 

selection 

Contents 

The basic functions of LV switchgear H2 

1.1 Electrical protection H2 

1.2 Isolation H3 

1.3 Switchgear control H4 

The switchgear H5 

2.1 Elementary switching devices H5 

2.2 Combined switchgear elements H9 

Choice of switchgear H 0 

3.1 Tabulated functional capabilities H10 

3.2 Switchgear selection H10 

Circuit-breaker H 

4.1 Standards and description H11 

4.2 Fundamental characteristics of a circuit-breaker H13 

4.3 Other characteristics of a circuit-breaker H15 

4.4 Selection of a circuit-breaker H18 

4.5 Coordination between circuit-breakers H22 

4.6 Discrimination MV/LV in a consumer’s substation H28 


H 



H2 


The role of switchgear is: 

b Electrical protection 

b Safe isolation from live parts 

b Local or remote switching 

Electrical protection assures: 

b Protection of circuit elements against the 

thermal and mechanical stresses of short-circuit 

currents 

b Protection of persons in the event of 

insulation failure 

b Protection of appliances and apparatus being 

supplied (e.g. motors, etc.) 

The basic functions of 

LV switchgear 

National and international standards define the manner in which electric circuits of 

LV installations must be realized, and the capabilities and limitations of the various 

switching devices which are collectively referred to as switchgear. 

The main functions of switchgear are: 

b Electrical protection 

b Electrical isolation of sections of an installation 

b Local or remote switching 

These functions are summarized below in Figure H . 

Electrical protection at low voltage is (apart from fuses) normally incorporated in 

circuit-breakers, in the form of thermal-magnetic devices and/or residual-currentoperated 

tripping devices (less-commonly, residual voltage- operated devices 

- acceptable to, but not recommended by IEC). 

In addition to those functions shown in Figure H1, other functions, namely: 

b Over-voltage protection 

b Under-voltage protection 

are provided by specific devices (lightning and various other types of voltage-surge 

arrester, relays associated with contactors, remotely controlled circuit-breakers, and 

with combined circuit-breaker/isolators… and so on) 

Electrical protection Isolation Control 

against 

b Overload currents b Isolation clearly indicated b Functional switching 

b Short-circuit currents by an authorized fail-proof b Emergency switching 

b Insulation failure mechanical indicator b Emergency stopping 

b A gap or interposed insulating b Switching off for 

barrier between the open mechanical maintenance 

contacts, clearly visible 

Fig. H1 : Basic functions of LV switchgear 

. Electrical protection 

The aim is to avoid or to limit the destructive or dangerous consequences of 

excessive (short-circuit) currents, or those due to overloading and insulation failure, 

and to separate the defective circuit from the rest of the installation. 

A distinction is made between the protection of: 

b The elements of the installation (cables, wires, switchgear…) 

b Persons and animals 

b Equipment and appliances supplied from the installation 

The protection of circuits 

v Against overload; a condition of excessive current being drawn from a healthy 

(unfaulted) installation 

v Against short-circuit currents due to complete failure of insulation between 

conductors of different phases or (in TN systems) between a phase and neutral (or 

PE) conductor 

Protection in these cases is provided either by fuses or circuit-breaker, in the 

distribution board at the origin of the final circuit (i.e. the circuit to which the load 

is connected). Certain derogations to this rule are authorized in some national 

standards, as noted in chapter H1 sub-clause 1.4. 

The protection of persons 

v Against insulation failures. According to the system of earthing for the installation 

(TN, TT or IT) the protection will be provided by fuses or circuit-breakers, residual 

current devices, and/or permanent monitoring of the insulation resistance of the 

installation to earth 

The protection of electric motors 

v Against overheating, due, for example, to long term overloading, stalled rotor, 

single-phasing, etc. Thermal relays, specially designed to match the particular 

characteristics of motors are used. 

Such relays may, if required, also protect the motor-circuit cable against overload. 

Short-circuit protection is provided either by type aM fuses or by a circuit-breaker 

from which the thermal (overload) protective element has been removed, or 

otherwise made inoperative. 



A state of isolation clearly indicated by an 

approved “fail-proof” indicator, or the visible 

separation of contacts, are both deemed to 

satisfy the national standards of many countries 

(1) the concurrent opening of all live conductors, while not 

always obligatory, is however, strongly recommended (for 

reasons of greater safety and facility of operation). The neutral 

contact opens after the phase contacts, and closes before 

them (IEC 60947-1). 


LV switchgear 

.2 Isolation 

The aim of isolation is to separate a circuit or apparatus (such as a motor, etc.) from 

the remainder of a system which is energized, in order that personnel may carry out 

work on the isolated part in perfect safety. 

In principle, all circuits of an LV installation shall have means to be isolated. 

In practice, in order to maintain an optimum continuity of service, it is preferred to 

provide a means of isolation at the origin of each circuit. 

An isolating device must fulfil the following requirements: 

b All poles of a circuit, including the neutral (except where the neutral is a PEN 

conductor) must open (1) 

b It must be provided with a locking system in open position with a key (e.g. by 

means of a padlock) in order to avoid an unauthorized reclosure by inadvertence 

b It must comply with a recognized national or international standard 

(e.g. IEC 60947-3) concerning clearance between contacts, creepage distances, 

overvoltage withstand capability, etc.: 

Other requirements apply: 

v Verification that the contacts of the isolating device are, in fact, open. 

The verification may be: 

- Either visual, where the device is suitably designed to allow the contacts to be seen 

(some national standards impose this condition for an isolating device located at the 

origin of a LV installation supplied directly from a MV/LV transformer) 

- Or mechanical, by means of an indicator solidly welded to the operating shaft 

of the device. In this case the construction of the device must be such that, in the 

eventuality that the contacts become welded together in the closed position, the 

indicator cannot possibly indicate that it is in the open position 

v Leakage currents. With the isolating device open, leakage currents between the 

open contacts of each phase must not exceed: 

- 0.5 mA for a new device 

- 6.0 mA at the end of its useful life 

v Voltage-surge withstand capability, across open contacts. The isolating device, 

when open must withstand a 1.2/50 μs impulse, having a peak value of 6, 8 or 12 kV 

according to its service voltage, as shown in Figure H2. The device must satisfy 

these conditions for altitudes up to 2,000 metres. Correction factors are given in 

IEC 60664-1 for altitudes greater than 2,000 metres. 

Consequently, if tests are carried out at sea level, the test values must be increased 

by 23% to take into account the effect of altitude. See standard IEC 60947. 


Service (nominal Impulse withstand 

voltage peak voltage category 

(V) (for 2,000 metres) 

(kV) 

III IV 

230/400 4 6 

400/690 6 8 

690/1,000 8 12 

Fig. H2 : Peak value of impulse voltage according to normal service voltage of test specimen. 

The degrees III and IV are degrees of pollution defined in IEC 60664-1 

H3 



H4 


Switchgear-control functions allow system 

operating personnel to modify a loaded system 

at any moment, according to requirements, 

and include: 

b Functional control (routine switching, etc.) 

b Emergency switching 

b Maintenance operations on the power system 

(1) One break in each phase and (where appropriate) one 

break in the neutral. 

(2) Taking into account stalled motors. 

(3) In a TN schema the PEN conductor must never be 

opened, since it functions as a protective earthing wire as well 

as the system neutral conductor. 


LV switchgear 

.3 Switchgear control 

In broad terms “control” signifies any facility for safely modifying a load-carrying 

power system at all levels of an installation. The operation of switchgear is an 

important part of power-system control. 

Functional control 

This control relates to all switching operations in normal service conditions for 

energizing or de-energizing a part of a system or installation, or an individual piece 

of equipment, item of plant, etc. 

Switchgear intended for such duty must be installed at least: 

b At the origin of any installation 

b At the final load circuit or circuits (one switch may control several loads) 

Marking (of the circuits being controlled) must be clear and unambiguous. 

In order to provide the maximum flexibility and continuity of operation, particularly 

where the switching device also constitutes the protection (e.g. a circuit-breaker or 

switch-fuse) it is preferable to include a switch at each level of distribution, i.e. on 

each outgoing way of all distribution and subdistribution boards. 

The manœuvre may be: 

b Either manual (by means of an operating lever on the switch) or 

b Electric, by push-button on the switch or at a remote location (load-shedding and 

reconnection, for example) 

These switches operate instantaneously (i.e. with no deliberate delay), and those 

that provide protection are invariably omni-polar (1) . 

The main circuit-breaker for the entire installation, as well as any circuit-breakers 

used for change-over (from one source to another) must be omni-polar units. 

Emergency switching - emergency stop 

An emergency switching is intended to de-energize a live circuit which is, or could 

become, dangerous (electric shock or fire). 

An emergency stop is intended to halt a movement which has become dangerous. 

In the two cases: 

b The emergency control device or its means of operation (local or at remote 

location(s)) such as a large red mushroom-headed emergency-stop pushbutton must 

be recognizable and readily accessible, in proximity to any position at which danger 

could arise or be seen 

b A single action must result in a complete switching-off of all live conductors (2) (3) 

b A “break glass” emergency switching initiation device is authorized, but in 

unmanned installations the re-energizing of the circuit can only be achieved by 

means of a key held by an authorized person 

It should be noted that in certain cases, an emergency system of braking, may 

require that the auxiliary supply to the braking-system circuits be maintained until 

final stoppage of the machinery. 

Switching-off for mechanical maintenance work 

This operation assures the stopping of a machine and its impossibility to be 

inadvertently restarted while mechanical maintenance work is being carried out 

on the driven machinery. The shutdown is generally carried out at the functional 

switching device, with the use of a suitable safety lock and warning notice at the 

switch mechanism. 



Fig. H5 : Symbol for a disconnector (or isolator) 

Fig. H6 : Symbol for a load-break switch 

2 The switchgear 

2.1 Elementary switching devices 

Disconnector (or isolator) (see Fig. H ) 

This switch is a manually-operated, lockable, two-position device (open/closed) 

which provides safe isolation of a circuit when locked in the open position. Its 

characteristics are defined in IEC 60947-3. A disconnector is not designed to make 

or to break current (1) and no rated values for these functions are given in standards. 

It must, however, be capable of withstanding the passage of short-circuit currents 

and is assigned a rated short-time withstand capability, generally for 1 second, 

unless otherwise agreed between user and manufacturer. This capability is normally 

more than adequate for longer periods of (lower-valued) operational overcurrents, 

such as those of motor-starting. Standardized mechanical-endurance, overvoltage, 

and leakage-current tests, must also be satisfied. 

Load-breaking switch (see Fig. H6) 

This control switch is generally operated manually (but is sometimes provided with 

electrical tripping for operator convenience) and is a non-automatic two-position 

device (open/closed). 

It is used to close and open loaded circuits under normal unfaulted circuit conditions. 

It does not consequently, provide any protection for the circuit it controls. 

IEC standard 60947-3 defines: 

b The frequency of switch operation (600 close/open cycles per hour maximum) 

b Mechanical and electrical endurance (generally less than that of a contactor) 

b Current making and breaking ratings for normal and infrequent situations 

When closing a switch to energize a circuit there is always the possibility that 

an unsuspected short-circuit exists on the circuit. For this reason, load-break 

switches are assigned a fault-current making rating, i.e. successful closure against 

the electrodynamic forces of short-circuit current is assured. Such switches are 

commonly referred to as “fault-make load-break” switches. Upstream protective 

devices are relied upon to clear the short-circuit fault 

Category AC-23 includes occasional switching of individual motors. The switching 

of capacitors or of tungsten filament lamps shall be subject to agreement between 

manufacturer and user. 

The utilization categories referred to in Figure H7 do not apply to an equipment 

normally used to start, accelerate and/or stop individual motors. 

Example 

A 100 A load-break switch of category AC-23 (inductive load) must be able: 

b To make a current of 10 In (= 1,000 A) at a power factor of 0.35 lagging 

b To break a current of 8 In (= 800 A) at a power factor of 0.45 lagging 

b To withstand short duration short-circuit currents when closed 

Utilization category Typical applications Cos ϕ Making Breaking 

Frequent Infrequent current x In current x In 

operations operations 

AC-20A AC-20B Connecting and disconnecting - - - 

under no-load conditions 

AC-21A AC-21B Switching of resistive loads 0.95 1.5 1.5 

including moderate overloads 

AC-22A AC-22B Switching of mixed resistive 0.65 3 3 

and inductive loads, including 

moderate overloads 

AC-23A AC-23B Switching of motor loads or 0.45 for I y 100 A 10 8 

other highly inductive loads 0.35 for I > 100 A 

Fig. H7 : Utilization categories of LV AC switches according to IEC 60947-3 

(1) i.e. a LV disconnector is essentially a dead system 

switching device to be operated with no voltage on either side 

of it, particularly when closing, because of the possibility of an 

unsuspected short-circuit on the downstream side. Interlocking 

with an upstream switch or circuit-breaker is frequently used. 


H 



H6 


Fig. H8 : Symbol for a bistable remote control switch 

Control 

circuit 

Fig. H9 : Symbol for a contactor 

Power 

circuit 

Two classes of LV cartridge fuse are very 

widely used: 

b For domestic and similar installations type gG 

b For industrial installations type gG, gM or aM 

Fig. H10 : Symbol for fuses 

(1) This term is not defined in IEC publications but is commonly 

used in some countries. 


Remote control switch (see Fig. H8) 

This device is extensively used in the control of lighting circuits where the depression 

of a pushbutton (at a remote control position) will open an already-closed switch or 

close an opened switch in a bistable sequence. 

Typical applications are: 

b Two-way switching on stairways of large buildings 

b Stage-lighting schemes 

b Factory illumination, etc. 

Auxiliary devices are available to provide: 

b Remote indication of its state at any instant 

b Time-delay functions 

b Maintained-contact features 

Contactor (see Fig. H9) 

The contactor is a solenoid-operated switching device which is generally held 

closed by (a reduced) current through the closing solenoid (although various 

mechanically-latched types exist for specific duties). Contactors are designed to 

carry out numerous close/open cycles and are commonly controlled remotely by 

on-off pushbuttons. The large number of repetitive operating cycles is standardized in 

table VIII of IEC 60947-4-1 by: 

b The operating duration: 8 hours; uninterrupted; intermittent; temporary of 3, 10, 30, 

60 and 90 minutes 

b Utilization category: for example, a contactor of category AC3 can be used for the 

starting and stopping of a cage motor 

b The start-stop cycles (1 to 1,200 cyles per hour) 

b Mechanical endurance (number of off-load manœuvres) 

b Electrical endurance (number of on-load manœuvres) 

b A rated current making and breaking performance according to the category of 

utilization concerned 

Example: 

A 150 A contactor of category AC3 must have a minimum current-breaking capability 

of 8 In (= 1,200 A) and a minimum current-making rating of 10 In (= 1,500 A) at a 

power factor (lagging) of 0.35. 

Discontactor (1) 

A contactor equipped with a thermal-type relay for protection against overloading 

defines a “discontactor”. Discontactors are used extensively for remote push-button 

control of lighting circuits, etc., and may also be considered as an essential element 

in a motor controller, as noted in sub-clause 2.2. “combined switchgear elements”. 

The discontactor is not the equivalent of a circuit-breaker, since its short-circuit 

current breaking capability is limited to 8 or 10 In. For short-circuit protection 

therefore, it is necessary to include either fuses or a circuit-breaker in series with, 

and upstream of, the discontactor contacts. 

Fuses (see Fig. H10) 

The first letter indicates the breaking range: 

b “g” fuse-links (full-range breaking-capacity fuse-link) 

b “a” fuse-links (partial-range breaking-capacity fuse-link) 

The second letter indicates the utilization category; this letter defines with accuracy 

the time-current characteristics, conventional times and currents, gates. 

For example 

b “gG” indicates fuse-links with a full-range breaking capacity for general application 

b “gM” indicates fuse-links with a full-range breaking capacity for the protection of 

motor circuits 

b “aM” indicates fuse-links with a partial range breaking capacity for the protection of 

motor circuits 

Fuses exist with and without “fuse-blown” mechanical indicators. Fuses break a 

circuit by controlled melting of the fuse element when a current exceeds a given 

value for a corresponding period of time; the current/time relationship being 

presented in the form of a performance curve for each type of fuse. Standards define 

two classes of fuse: 

b Those intended for domestic installations, manufactured in the form of a cartridge 

for rated currents up to 100 A and designated type gG in IEC 60269-1 and 3 

b Those for industrial use, with cartridge types designated gG (general use); and gM 

and aM (for motor-circuits) in IEC 60269-1 and 2 



gM fuses require a separate overload relay, as 

described in the note at the end of sub-clause 2.1. 

1 hour 

t 

Inf I2 

Minimum 

pre-arcing 

time curve 

Fuse-blow 

curve 

Fig. H12 : Zones of fusing and non-fusing for gG and gM fuses 

(1) Ich for gM fuses 

I 


The main differences between domestic and industrial fuses are the nominal 

voltage and current levels (which require much larger physical dimensions) and 

their fault-current breaking capabilities. Type gG fuse-links are often used for the 

protection of motor circuits, which is possible when their characteristics are capable 

of withstanding the motor-starting current without deterioration. 

A more recent development has been the adoption by the IEC of a fuse-type gM for 

motor protection, designed to cover starting, and short-circuit conditions. This type of 

fuse is more popular in some countries than in others, but at the present time the 

aM fuse in combination with a thermal overload relay is more-widely used. 

A gM fuse-link, which has a dual rating is characterized by two current values. The 

first value In denotes both the rated current of the fuse-link and the rated current of 

the fuseholder; the second value Ich denotes the time-current characteristic of the 

fuse-link as defined by the gates in Tables II, III and VI of IEC 60269-1. 

These two ratings are separated by a letter which defines the applications. 

For example: In M Ich denotes a fuse intended to be used for protection of 

motor circuits and having the characteristic G. The first value In corresponds to 

the maximum continuous current for the whole fuse and the second value Ich 

corresponds to the G characteristic of the fuse link. For further details see note at the 

end of sub-clause 2.1. 

An aM fuse-link is characterized by one current value In and time-current 

characteristic as shown in Figure H14 next page. 

Important: Some national standards use a gI (industrial) type fuse, similar in all main 

essentails to type gG fuses. 

Type gI fuses should never be used, however, in domestic and similar installations. 

Fusing zones - conventional currents 

The conditions of fusing (melting) of a fuse are defined by standards, according to 

their class. 

Class gG fuses 

These fuses provide protection against overloads and short-circuits. 

Conventional non-fusing and fusing currents are standardized, as shown in 

Figure H12 and in Figure H13. 

b The conventional non-fusing current Inf is the value of current that the fusible 

element can carry for a specified time without melting. 

Example: A 32 A fuse carrying a current of 1.25 In (i.e. 40 A) must not melt in less 

than one hour (table H13) 

b The conventional fusing current If (= I2 in Fig. H12) is the value of current which 

will cause melting of the fusible element before the expiration of the specified time. 

Example: A 32 A fuse carrying a current of 1.6 In (i.e. 52.1 A) must melt in one hour 

or less 

IEC 60269-1 standardized tests require that a fuse-operating characteristic lies 

between the two limiting curves (shown in Figure H12) for the particular fuse under 

test. This means that two fuses which satisfy the test can have significantly different 

operating times at low levels of overloading. 

Rated current (1) Conventional non- Conventional Conventional 

In (A) fusing current fusing current time (h) 

Inf I2 

In y 4 A 1.5 In 2.1 In 1 

4 < In < 16 A 1.5 In 1.9 In 1 

16 < In y 63 A 1.25 In 1.6 In 1 

63 < In y 160 A 1.25 In 1.6 In 2 

160 < In y 400 A 1.25 In 1.6 In 3 

400 < In 1.25 In 1.6 In 4 

Fig. H13 : Zones of fusing and non-fusing for LV types gG and gM class fuses (IEC 60269-1 

and 60269-2-1) 


H7 



H8 


Class aM fuses protect against short-circuit 

currents only, and must always be associated 

with another device which protects against 

overload 

4 I n 

x I n 

Fig. H14 : Standardized zones of fusing for type aM fuses (all 

current ratings) 

I 

t 

Tf Ta 

Ttc 

0.005 s 

0.02 s 

0.01 s 

Tf: Fuse pre-arc fusing time 

Ta: Arcing time 

Ttc: Total fault-clearance time 

Fig. H15 : Current limitation by a fuse 

Mini m um 

pre-arcing 

time cu r v e 

Fuse- b l o wn 

cu r v e 

Prospective 

fault-current peak 

rms value of the AC 

component of the 

prospective fault curent 

Current peak 

limited by the fuse 

(1) For currents exceeding a certain level, depending on the 

fuse nominal current rating, as shown below in Figure H16. 

t 


b The two examples given above for a 32 A fuse, together with the foregoing notes 

on standard test requirements, explain why these fuses have a poor performance in 

the low overload range 

b It is therefore necessary to install a cable larger in ampacity than that normally 

required for a circuit, in order to avoid the consequences of possible long term 

overloading (60% overload for up to one hour in the worst case) 

By way of comparison, a circuit-breaker of similar current rating: 

b Which passes 1.05 In must not trip in less than one hour; and 

b When passing 1.25 In it must trip in one hour, or less (25% overload for up to one 

hour in the worst case) 

Class aM (motor) fuses 

These fuses afford protection against short-circuit currents only and must necessarily 

be associated with other switchgear (such as discontactors or circuit-breakers) in 

order to ensure overload protection < 4 In. They are not therefore autonomous. Since 

aM fuses are not intended to protect against low values of overload current, no levels 

of conventional non-fusing and fusing currents are fixed. The characteristic curves for 

testing these fuses are given for values of fault current exceeding approximately 4 In 

(see Fig. H14), and fuses tested to IEC 60269 must give operating curves which fall 

within the shaded area. 

Note: the small “arrowheads” in the diagram indicate the current/time “gate” values 

for the different fuses to be tested (IEC 60269). 

Rated short-circuit breaking currents 

A characteristic of modern cartridge fuses is that, owing to the rapidity of fusion 

in the case of high short-circuit current levels (1) , a current cut-off begins before 

the occurrence of the first major peak, so that the fault current never reaches its 

prospective peak value (see Fig. H1 ). 

This limitation of current reduces significantly the thermal and dynamic stresses 

which would otherwise occur, thereby minimizing danger and damage at the fault 

position. The rated short-circuit breaking current of the fuse is therefore based on the 

rms value of the AC component of the prospective fault current. 

No short-circuit current-making rating is assigned to fuses. 

Reminder 

Short-circuit currents initially contain DC components, the magnitude and duration of 

which depend on the XL/R ratio of the fault current loop. 

Close to the source (MV/LV transformer) the relationship Ipeak / Irms (of 

AC component) immediately following the instant of fault, can be as high as 2.5 

(standardized by IEC, and shown in Figure H16 next page). 

At lower levels of distribution in an installation, as previously noted, XL is small 

compared with R and so for final circuits Ipeak / Irms ~ 1.41, a condition which 

corresponds with Figure H15. 

The peak-current-limitation effect occurs only when the prospective rms 

AC component of fault current attains a certain level. For example, in the Figure H16 

graph, the 100 A fuse will begin to cut off the peak at a prospective fault current 

(rms) of 2 kA (a). The same fuse for a condition of 20 kA rms prospective current 

will limit the peak current to 10 kA (b). Without a current-limiting fuse the peak 

current could attain 50 kA (c) in this particular case. As already mentioned, at lower 

distribution levels in an installation, R greatly predominates XL, and fault levels are 

generally low. This means that the level of fault current may not attain values high 

enough to cause peak current limitation. On the other hand, the DC transients (in this 

case) have an insignificant effect on the magnitude of the current peak, as previously 

mentioned. 

Note: On gM fuse ratings 

A gM type fuse is essentially a gG fuse, the fusible element of which corresponds to 

the current value Ich (ch = characteristic) which may be, for example, 63 A. This is 

the IEC testing value, so that its time/ current characteristic is identical to that of a 

63 A gG fuse. 

This value (63 A) is selected to withstand the high starting currents of a motor, the 

steady state operating current (In) of which may be in the 10-20 A range. 

This means that a physically smaller fuse barrel and metallic parts can be used, 

since the heat dissipation required in normal service is related to the lower figures 

(10-20 A). A standard gM fuse, suitable for this situation would be designated 32M63 

(i.e. In M Ich). 

The first current rating In concerns the steady-load thermal performance of the 

fuselink, while the second current rating (Ich) relates to its (short-time) startingcurrent 

performance. It is evident that, although suitable for short-circuit protection, 



Prospective fault 

current (kA) peak 

100 

50 

20 

10 

5 

2 

(a) 

Maximum possible current 

peak characteristic 

i.e. 2.5 Irms (IEC) 

Fig. H17 : Symbol for an automatic tripping switch-fuse 

(c) 

(b) 

160A 

100A 

50A 

1 

1 2 5 10 20 50 100 

AC component of prospective 

fault current (kA) rms 

Fig. H16 : Limited peak current versus prospective rms values 

of the AC component of fault current for LV fuses 

Fig. H18 : Symbol for a non-automatic fuse-switch 

Nominal 

fuse 

ratings 

Peak current 

cut-off 


curves 

Fig. H20 : Symbol for a fuse disconnector + discontactor 

Fig. H21 : Symbol for a fuse-switch disconnector + discontactor 


overload protection for the motor is not provided by the fuse, and so a separate 

thermal-type relay is always necessary when using gM fuses. The only advantage 

offered by gM fuses, therefore, when compared with aM fuses, are reduced physical 

dimensions and slightly lower cost. 

2.2 Combined switchgear elements 

Single units of switchgear do not, in general, fulfil all the requirements of the three 

basic functions, viz: Protection, control and isolation. 

Where the installation of a circuit-breaker is not appropriate (notably where the 

switching rate is high, over extended periods) combinations of units specifically 

designed for such a performance are employed. The most commonly-used 

combinations are described below. 

Switch and fuse combinations 

Two cases are distinguished: 

b The type in which the operation of one (or more) fuse(s) causes the switch to open. 

This is achieved by the use of fuses fitted with striker pins, and a system of switch 

tripping springs and toggle mechanisms (see Fig. H17) 

b The type in which a non-automatic switch is associated with a set of fuses in a 

common enclosure. 

In some countries, and in IEC 60947-3, the terms “switch-fuse” and “fuse-switch” 

have specific meanings, viz: 

v A switch-fuse comprises a switch (generally 2 breaks per pole) on the upstream 

side of three fixed fuse-bases, into which the fuse carriers are inserted (see Fig. H18) 

v A fuse-switch consists of three switch blades each constituting a double-break per 

phase. 

These blades are not continuous throughout their length, but each has a gap in the 

centre which is bridged by the fuse cartridge. Some designs have only a single break 

per phase, as shown in Figure H19. 

Fig. H19 : Symbol for a non-automatic switch-fuse 

The current range for these devices is limited to 100 A maximum at 400 V 3-phase, 

while their principal use is in domestic and similar installations. To avoid confusion 

between the first group (i.e. automatic tripping) and the second group, the term 

“switch-fuse” should be qualified by the adjectives “automatic” or “non-automatic”. 

Fuse – disconnector + discontactor 

Fuse - switch-disconnector + discontactor 

As previously mentioned, a discontactor does not provide protection against shortcircuit 

faults. It is necessary, therefore, to add fuses (generally of type aM) to perform 

this function. The combination is used mainly for motor control circuits, where the 

disconnector or switch-disconnector allows safe operations such as: 

b The changing of fuse links (with the circuit isolated) 

b Work on the circuit downstream of the discontactor (risk of remote closure of the 

discontactor) 

The fuse-disconnector must be interlocked with the discontactor such that no opening 

or closing manœuvre of the fuse disconnector is possible unless the discontactor is 

open ( Figure H20), since the fuse disconnector has no load-switching capability. 

A fuse-switch-disconnector (evidently) requires no interlocking (Figure H21). 

The switch must be of class AC22 or AC23 if the circuit supplies a motor. 

Circuit-breaker + contactor 

Circuit-breaker + discontactor 

These combinations are used in remotely controlled distribution systems in which the 

rate of switching is high, or for control and protection of a circuit supplying motors. 


H9 


H10 



3 Choice of switchgear 

3.1 Tabulated functional capabilities 

After having studied the basic functions of LV switchgear (clause 1, Figure H1) and 

the different components of switchgear (clause 2), Figure H22 summarizes the 

capabilities of the various components to perform the basic functions. 

Isolation Control Electrical protection 

Switchgear Functional Emergency Emergency Switching for Overload Short-circuit Electric 

item switching stop mechanical shock 

(mechanical) maintenance 

Isolator (or b 

disconnector) (4) 

Switch (5) b b b (1) b (1) (2) b 

Residual b b b (1) b (1) (2) b b 

device 

(RCCB) (5) 

Switch- b b b (1) b (1) (2) b 

disconnector 

Contactor b b (1) b (1) (2) b b (3) 

Remote control b b (1) b 

switch 

Fuse b b b 

Circuit b b (1) b (1) (2) b b b 

breaker (5) 

Circuit-breaker b b b (1) b (1) (2) b b b 

disconnector (5) 

Residual b b b (1) b (1) (2) b b b b 

and overcurrent 


(RCBO) (5) 

Point of Origin of each All points where, In general at the At the supply At the supply Origin of each Origin of each Origin of circuits 

installation circuit for operational incoming circuit point to each point to each circuit circuit where the 

(general reasons it may to every machine machine earthing system 

principle) be necessary distribution and/or on the is appropriate 

to stop the board machine TN-S, IT, TT 

process concerned 

(1) Where cut-off of all active conductors is provided 

(2) It may be necessary to maintain supply to a braking system 

(3) If it is associated with a thermal relay (the combination is commonly referred to as a “discontactor”) 

(4) In certain countries a disconnector with visible contacts is mandatory at the origin of a LV installation supplied directly from a MV/LV transformer 

(5) Certain items of switchgear are suitable for isolation duties (e.g. RCCBs according to IEC 61008) without being explicitly marked as such 

Fig. H22 : Functions fulfilled by different items of switchgear 

3.2 Switchgear selection 

Software is being used more and more in the field of optimal selection of switchgear. 

Each circuit is considered one at a time, and a list is drawn up of the required 

protection functions and exploitation of the installation, among those mentioned in 

Figure H22 and summarized in Figure H1. 

A number of switchgear combinations are studied and compared with each other 

against relevant criteria, with the aim of achieving: 

b Satisfactory performance 

b Compatibility among the individual items; from the rated current In to the fault-level 

rating Icu 

b Compatibility with upstream switchgear or taking into account its contribution 

b Conformity with all regulations and specifications concerning safe and reliable 

circuit performance 

In order to determine the number of poles for an item of switchgear, reference is 

made to chapter G, clause 7 Fig. G64. Multifunction switchgear, initially more costly, 

reduces installation costs and problems of installation or exploitation. It is often found 

that such switchgear provides the best solution. 



The circuit-breaker/disconnector fulfills all of the 

basic switchgear functions, while, by means of 

accessories, numerous other possibilities exist 

Industrial circuit-breakers must comply with 

IEC 60947-1 and 60947-2 or other equivalent 

standards. 

Domestic-type circuit-breakers must comply with 

IEC standard 60898, or an equivalent national 

standard 

Fig. H24 : Main parts of a circuit-breaker 

Power circuit terminals 

Contacts and arc-diving 

chamber 

Fool-proof mechanical 

indicator 

Latching mechanism 

Trip mechanism and 

protective devices 

4 Circuit-breaker 

As shown in Figure H23 the circuit-breaker/ disconnector is the only item of 

switchgear capable of simultaneously satisfying all the basic functions necessary in 

an electrical installation. 

Moreover, it can, by means of auxiliary units, provide a wide range of other functions, 

for example: indication (on-off - tripped on fault); undervoltage tripping; remote 

control… etc. These features make a circuit-breaker/ disconnector the basic unit of 

switchgear for any electrical installation. 

Functions Possible conditions 

Isolation b 

Control Functional b 

Emergency switching b (With the possibility of a tripping 

coil for remote control) 

Switching-off for mechanical b 

maintenance 

Protection Overload b 

Short-circuit b 

Insulation fault b (With differential-current relay) 

Undervoltage b (With undervoltage-trip coil) 

Remote control b Added or incorporated 

Indication and measurement b (Generally optional with an 

electronic tripping device) 

Fig. H23 : Functions performed by a circuit-breaker/disconnector 

4.1 Standards and description 

Standards 

For industrial LV installations the relevant IEC standards are, or are due to be: 

b 60947-1: general rules 

b 60947-2: part 2: circuit-breakers 

b 60947-3: part 3: switches, disconnectors, switch-disconnectors and fuse 

combination units 

b 60947-4: part 4: contactors and motor starters 

b 60947-5: part 5: control-circuit devices and switching elements 

b 60947-6: part 6: multiple function switching devices 

b 60947-7: part 7: ancillary equipment 

For domestic and similar LV installations, the appropriate standard is IEC 60898, or 

an equivalent national standard. 

Description 

Figure H24 shows schematically the main parts of a LV circuit-breaker and its four 

essential functions: 

b The circuit-breaking components, comprising the fixed and moving contacts and 

the arc-dividing chamber 

b The latching mechanism which becomes unlatched by the tripping device on 

detection of abnormal current conditions 

This mechanism is also linked to the operation handle of the breaker. 

b A trip-mechanism actuating device: 

v Either: a thermal-magnetic device, in which a thermally-operated bi-metal strip 

detects an overload condition, while an electromagnetic striker pin operates at 

current levels reached in short-circuit conditions, or 

v An electronic relay operated from current transformers, one of which is installed on 

each phase 

b A space allocated to the several types of terminal currently used for the main 

power circuit conductors 

Domestic circuit-breakers (see Fig. H25 next page) complying with IEC 60898 and 

similar national standards perform the basic functions of: 

b Isolation 

b Protection against overcurrent 


H11 


H12 



Fig. H25 : Domestic-type circuit-breaker providing overcurrent 

protection and circuit isolation features 

Fig. H26 : Domestic-type circuit-breaker as above (Fig. H25) 

with incorparated protection against electric shocks 

OF1 SD SDE OF2 

OF2 

SDE 

SD 

OF1 

Fig. H28 : Example of a modular (Compact NS) industrial type 

of circuit-breaker capable of numerous auxiliary functions 


Some models can be adapted to provide sensitive detection (30 mA) of earthleakage 

current with CB tripping, by the addition of a modular block, while other 

models (RCBOs, complying with IEC 61009 and CBRs complying with IEC 60947-2 

Annex B) have this residual current feature incorporated as shown in Figure H26. 

Apart from the above-mentioned functions further features can be associated with 

the basic circuit-breaker by means of additional modules, as shown in Figure H27; 

notably remote control and indication (on-off-fault). 

5 

4 


3 

2 

O-OFF O-OFF - O-OFF - 

Fig. H27 : “Multi 9” system of LV modular switchgear components 

Moulded-case type industrial circuit-breakers complying with IEC 60947-2 are now 

available, which, by means of associated adaptable blocks provide a similar range of 

auxiliary functions to those described above (see Figure H28). 

Heavy-duty industrial circuit-breakers of large current ratings, complying with 

IEC 60947-2, have numerous built-in communication and electronic functions 

(see Figure H29). 

In addition to the protection functions, the Micrologic unit provides optimized 

functions such as measurement (including power quality functions), diagnosis, 

communication, control and monitoring. 

Fig. H29 : Examples of heavy-duty industrial circuit-breakers. The “Masterpact” provides many 

automation features in its “Micrologic” tripping module 

1


0.4 In 

Adjustment 

range 

Overload trip 

current setting 

Ir 

Rated current of 

the tripping unit 

160 A 360 A 400 A 630 A 

(1) Current-level setting values which refer to the currentoperated 

thermal and “instantaneous” magnetic tripping 

devices for over-load and short-circuit protection. 

In 


frame-size rating 

Fig. H30 : Example of a NS630N circuit-breaker equipped with 

a STR23SE trip unit adjusted to 0.9, to give Ir = 360 A 


4.2 Fundamental characteristics of a circuit-breaker 

The fundamental characteristics of a circuit-breaker are: 

b Its rated voltage Ue 

b Its rated current In 

b Its tripping-current-level adjustment ranges for overload protection (Ir (1) or Irth (1) ) 

and for short-circuit protection (Im) (1) 

b Its short-circuit current breaking rating (Icu for industrial CBs; Icn for domestic- 

type CBs). 

Rated operational voltage (Ue) 

This is the voltage at which the circuit-breaker has been designed to operate, in 

normal (undisturbed) conditions. 

Other values of voltage are also assigned to the circuit-breaker, corresponding to 

disturbed conditions, as noted in sub-clause 4.3. 

Rated current (In) 

This is the maximum value of current that a circuit-breaker, fitted with a specified 

overcurrent tripping relay, can carry indefinitely at an ambient temperature stated by 

the manufacturer, without exceeding the specified temperature limits of the current 

carrying parts. 

Example 

A circuit-breaker rated at In = 125 A for an ambient temperature of 40 °C will be 

equipped with a suitably calibrated overcurrent tripping relay (set at 125 A). The 

same circuit-breaker can be used at higher values of ambient temperature however, 

if suitably “derated”. Thus, the circuit-breaker in an ambient temperature of 50 °C 

could carry only 117 A indefinitely, or again, only 109 A at 60 °C, while complying 

with the specified temperature limit. 

Derating a circuit-breaker is achieved therefore, by reducing the trip-current setting 

of its overload relay, and marking the CB accordingly. The use of an electronic-type 

of tripping unit, designed to withstand high temperatures, allows circuit-breakers 

(derated as described) to operate at 60 °C (or even at 70 °C) ambient. 

Note: In for circuit-breakers (in IEC 60947-2) is equal to Iu for switchgear generally, 

Iu being the rated uninterrupted current. 

Frame-size rating 

A circuit-breaker which can be fitted with overcurrent tripping units of different current 

level-setting ranges, is assigned a rating which corresponds to the highest currentlevel-setting 

tripping unit that can be fitted. 

Example 

A NS630N circuit-breaker can be equipped with 4 electronic trip units from 150 A to 

630 A. The size of the circuit-breaker is 630 A. 

Overload relay trip-current setting (Irth or Ir) 

Apart from small circuit-breakers which are very easily replaced, industrial circuitbreakers 

are equipped with removable, i.e. exchangeable, overcurrent-trip relays. 

Moreover, in order to adapt a circuit-breaker to the requirements of the circuit 

it controls, and to avoid the need to install over-sized cables, the trip relays are 

generally adjustable. The trip-current setting Ir or Irth (both designations are 

in common use) is the current above which the circuit-breaker will trip. It also 

represents the maximum current that the circuit-breaker can carry without tripping. 

That value must be greater than the maximum load current IB, but less than the 

maximum current permitted in the circuit Iz (see chapter G, sub-clause 1.3). 

The thermal-trip relays are generally adjustable from 0.7 to 1.0 times In, but when 

electronic devices are used for this duty, the adjustment range is greater; typically 0.4 

to 1 times In. 

Example (see Fig. H30) 

A NS630N circuit-breaker equipped with a 400 A STR23SE overcurrent trip relay, set 

at 0.9, will have a trip-current setting: 

Ir = 400 x 0.9 = 360 A 

Note: For circuit-breakers equipped with non-adjustable overcurrent-trip relays, 

Ir = In. Example: for C60N 20 A circuit-breaker, Ir = In = 20 A. 


H13 


H14 



Short-circuit relay trip-current setting (Im) 

Fig. H31 : Tripping-current ranges of overload and short-circuit protective devices for LV circuit-breakers 

t (s ) 

Ir Im Icu 

I(A 

Fig. H32 : Performance curve of a circuit-breaker thermalmagnetic 

protective scheme 


Type of Overload Short-circuit protection 

protective protection 

relay 

Short-circuit tripping relays (instantaneous or slightly time-delayed) are intended to 

trip the circuit-breaker rapidly on the occurrence of high values of fault current. Their 

tripping threshold Im is: 

b Either fixed by standards for domestic type CBs, e.g. IEC 60898, or, 

b Indicated by the manufacturer for industrial type CBs according to related 

standards, notably IEC 60947-2. 

For the latter circuit-breakers there exists a wide variety of tripping devices which 

allow a user to adapt the protective performance of the circuit-breaker to the 

particular requirements of a load (see Fig. H31, Fig. H32 and Fig. H33). 

Domestic Thermal- Ir = In Low setting Standard setting High setting circuit 

breakers magnetic type B type C type D 

IEC 60898 3 In y Im y 5 In 5 In y Im y 10 In 10 In y Im y 20 In (1) 

Modular Thermal- Ir = In Low setting Standard setting High setting 

industrial (2) magnetic fixed type B or Z type C type D or K 

circuit-breakers 3.2 In y fixed y 4.8 In 7 In y fixed y 10 In 10 In y fixed y 14 In 

Industrial (2) Thermal- Ir = In fixed Fixed: Im = 7 to 10 In 

circuit-breakers magnetic Adjustable: Adjustable: 

IEC 60947-2 0.7 In y Ir y In - Low setting : 2 to 5 In 

- Standard setting: 5 to 10 In 

Electronic Long delay Short-delay, adjustable 

0.4 In y Ir y In 1.5 Ir y Im y 10 Ir 

Instantaneous (I) fixed 

I = 12 to 15 In 

(1) 50 In in IEC 60898, which is considered to be unrealistically high by most European manufacturers (Merlin Gerin = 10 to 14 In). 

(2) For industrial use, IEC standards do not specify values. The above values are given only as being those in common use. 

t (s ) 


Ir Im Ii Icu 

Fig. H33 : Performance curve of a circuit-breaker electronic protective scheme 

I(A 

Ir: Overload (thermal or long-delay) relay trip-current 

setting 

Im: Short-circuit (magnetic or short-delay) relay tripcurrent 

setting 

Ii: Short-circuit instantaneous relay trip-current setting. 

Icu: Breaking capacity


The short-circuit current-breaking performance 

of a LV circuit-breaker is related (approximately) 

to the cos ϕ of the fault-current loop. Standard 

values for this relationship have been 

established in some standards 

Familiarity with the following less-important 

characteristics of LV circuit-breakers is, 

however, often necessary when making a final 

choice. 


Isolating feature 

A circuit-breaker is suitable for isolating a circuit if it fulfills all the conditions 

prescribed for a disconnector (at its rated voltage) in the relevant standard (see 

sub-clause 1.2). In such a case it is referred to as a circuit-breaker-disconnector and 

marked on its front face with the symbol 

All Multi 9, Compact NS and Masterpact LV switchgear of Merlin Gerin manufacture 

is in this category. 

Rated short-circuit breaking capacity (Icu or Icn) 

The short-circuit current-breaking rating of a CB is the highest (prospective) value 

of current that the CB is capable of breaking without being damaged. The value 

of current quoted in the standards is the rms value of the AC component of the 

fault current, i.e. the DC transient component (which is always present in the worst 

possible case of short-circuit) is assumed to be zero for calculating the standardized 

value. This rated value (Icu) for industrial CBs and (Icn) for domestic-type CBs is 

normally given in kA rms. 

Icu (rated ultimate s.c. breaking capacity) and Ics (rated service s.c. breaking 

capacity) are defined in IEC 60947-2 together with a table relating Ics with Icu for 

different categories of utilization A (instantaneous tripping) and B (time-delayed 

tripping) as discussed in subclause 4.3. 

Tests for proving the rated s.c. breaking capacities of CBs are governed by 

standards, and include: 

b Operating sequences, comprising a succession of operations, i.e. closing and 

opening on short-circuit 

b Current and voltage phase displacement. When the current is in phase with the 

supply voltage (cos ϕ for the circuit = 1), interruption of the current is easier than 

that at any other power factor. Breaking a current at low lagging values of cos ϕ is 

considerably more difficult to achieve; a zero power-factor circuit being (theoretically) 

the most onerous case. 

In practice, all power-system short-circuit fault currents are (more or less) at lagging 

power factors, and standards are based on values commonly considered to be 

representative of the majority of power systems. In general, the greater the level of 

fault current (at a given voltage), the lower the power factor of the fault-current loop, 

for example, close to generators or large transformers. 

Figure H34 below extracted from IEC 60947-2 relates standardized values of cos ϕ 

to industrial circuit-breakers according to their rated Icu. 

b Following an open - time delay - close/open sequence to test the Icu capacity of a 

CB, further tests are made to ensure that: 

v The dielectric withstand capability 

v The disconnection (isolation) performance and 

v The correct operation of the overload protection 

have not been impaired by the test. 

4.3 Other characteristics of a circuit-breaker 

Rated insulation voltage (Ui) 

This is the value of voltage to which the dielectric tests voltage (generally greater 

than 2 Ui) and creepage distances are referred to. 

The maximum value of rated operational voltage must never exceed that of the rated 

insulation voltage, i.e. Ue y Ui. 


Icu cos ϕ 

6 kA < Icu y 10 kA 0.5 

10 kA < Icu y 20 kA 0.3 

20 kA < Icu y 50 kA 0.25 

50 kA < Icu 0.2 

Fig. H34 : Icu related to power factor (cos ϕ) of fault-current circuit (IEC 60947-2) 

H15 


H16 



t (s) 

Im 

Fig. H35 : Category A circuit-breaker 

t (s ) 

Im 

Fig. H36 : Category B circuit-breaker 

In a correctly designed installation, a circuitbreaker 

is never required to operate at its 

maximum breaking current Icu. For this reason 

a new characteristic Ics has been introduced. 

It is expressed in IEC 60947-2 as a percentage 

of Icu (25, 50, 75, 100%) 

(1) O represents an opening operation. 

CO represents a closing operation followed by an opening 

operation. 

I 

Icw 

Icu 

I(A) 

I(A ) 


Rated impulse-withstand voltage (Uimp) 

This characteristic expresses, in kV peak (of a prescribed form and polarity) the value 

of voltage which the equipment is capable of withstanding without failure, under test 

conditions. 

Generally, for industrial circuit-breakers, Uimp = 8 kV and for domestic types, 

Uimp = 6 kV. 

Category (A or B) and rated short-time withstand current (Icw) 

As already briefly mentioned (sub-clause 4.2) there are two categories of 

LV industrial switchgear, A and B, according to IEC 60947-2: 

b Those of category A, for which there is no deliberate delay in the operation of the 

“instantaneous” short-circuit magnetic tripping device (see Fig. H35), are generally 

moulded-case type circuit-breakers, and 

b Those of category B for which, in order to discriminate with other circuit-breakers 

on a time basis, it is possible to delay the tripping of the CB, where the fault-current 

level is lower than that of the short-time withstand current rating (Icw) of the CB 

(see Fig. H36). This is generally applied to large open-type circuit-breakers and 

to certain heavy-duty moulded-case types. Icw is the maximum current that the B 

category CB can withstand, thermally and electrodynamically, without sustaining 

damage, for a period of time given by the manufacturer. 

Rated making capacity (Icm) 

Icm is the highest instantaneous value of current that the circuit-breaker can 

establish at rated voltage in specified conditions. In AC systems this instantaneous 

peak value is related to Icu (i.e. to the rated breaking current) by the factor k, which 

depends on the power factor (cos ϕ) of the short-circuit current loop (as shown in 

Figure H37 ). 


Icu cos ϕ Icm = kIcu 

6 kA < Icu y 10 kA 0.5 1.7 x Icu 

10 kA < Icu y 20 kA 0.3 2 x Icu 

20 kA < Icu y 50 kA 0.25 2.1 x Icu 

50 kA y Icu 0.2 2.2 x Icu 

Fig. H37 : Relation between rated breaking capacity Icu and rated making capacity Icm at 

different power-factor values of short-circuit current, as standardized in IEC 60947-2 

Example: A Masterpact NW08H2 circuit-breaker has a rated breaking capacity 

Icu of 100 kA. The peak value of its rated making capacity Icm will be 

100 x 2.2 = 220 kA. 

Rated service short-circuit breaking capacity (Ics) 

The rated breaking capacity (Icu) or (Icn) is the maximum fault-current a circuitbreaker 

can successfully interrupt without being damaged. The probability of such 

a current occurring is extremely low, and in normal circumstances the fault-currents 

are considerably less than the rated breaking capacity (Icu) of the CB. On the other 

hand it is important that high currents (of low probability) be interrupted under good 

conditions, so that the CB is immediately available for reclosure, after the faulty 

circuit has been repaired. It is for these reasons that a new characteristic (Ics) has 

been created, expressed as a percentage of Icu, viz: 25, 50, 75, 100% for industrial 

circuit-breakers. The standard test sequence is as follows: 

b O - CO - CO (1) (at Ics) 

b Tests carried out following this sequence are intended to verify that the CB is in a 

good state and available for normal service 

For domestic CBs, Ics = k Icn. The factor k values are given in IEC 60898 table XIV. 

In Europe it is the industrial practice to use a k factor of 100% so that Ics = Icu.


Many designs of LV circuit-breakers feature 

a short-circuit current limitation capability, 

whereby the current is reduced and prevented 

from reaching its (otherwise) maximum peak 

value (see Fig. H38). The current-limitation 

performance of these CBs is presented in 

the form of graphs, typified by that shown in 

Figure H39, diagram (a) 

Current limitation reduces both thermal and 

electrodynamic stresses on all circuit elements 

through which the current passes, thereby 

prolonging the useful life of these elements. 

Furthermore, the limitation feature allows 

“cascading” techniques to be used (see 4.5) 

thereby significantly reducing design and 

installation costs 

Icc 

Prospectice 

fault-current peak 

Limited 

current peak 

Limited 

current 

tc 

Fig. H38 : Prospective and actual currents 

Prospectice 

fault-current 

t 


Fault-current limitation 

The fault-current limitation capacity of a CB concerns its ability, more or less 

effective, in preventing the passage of the maximum prospective fault-current, 

permitting only a limited amount of current to flow, as shown in Figure H38. 

The current-limitation performance is given by the CB manufacturer in the form of 

curves (see Fig. H39). 

b Diagram (a) shows the limited peak value of current plotted against the rms 

value of the AC component of the prospective fault current (“prospective” faultcurrent 

refers to the fault-current which would flow if the CB had no current-limiting 

capability) 

b Limitation of the current greatly reduces the thermal stresses (proportional I 2 t) and 

this is shown by the curve of diagram (b) of Figure H39, again, versus the rms value 

of the AC component of the prospective fault current. 

LV circuit-breakers for domestic and similar installations are classified in certain 

standards (notably European Standard EN 60 898). CBs belonging to one class (of 

current limiters) have standardized limiting I 2 t let-through characteristics defined by 

that class. 

In these cases, manufacturers do not normally provide characteristic performance 

curves. 

a) 

Limited 

current 

peak 

(kA) 

22 

Non-limited current 


Prospective AC 

component (rms) 


150 kA 

b) 

4,5.105 

2.105 

Limited 

current peak 

(A2 x s) 

Fig. H39 : Performance curves of a typical LV current-limiting circuit-breaker 

Prospective AC 

component (rms) 

150 kA 

The advantages of current limitation 

The use of current-limiting CBs affords numerous advantages: 

b Better conservation of installation networks: current-limiting CBs strongly attenuate 

all harmful effects associated with short-circuit currents 

b Reduction of thermal effects: Conductors (and therefore insulation) heating is 

significantly reduced, so that the life of cables is correspondingly increased 

b Reduction of mechanical effects: forces due to electromagnetic repulsion are lower, 

with less risk of deformation and possible rupture, excessive burning of contacts, etc. 

b Reduction of electromagnetic-interference effects: 

v Less influence on measuring instruments and associated circuits, 

telecommunication systems, etc. 

These circuit-breakers therefore contribute towards an improved exploitation of: 

b Cables and wiring 

b Prefabricated cable-trunking systems 

b Switchgear, thereby reducing the ageing of the installation 

Example 

On a system having a prospective shortcircuit current of 150 kA rms, a Compact L 

circuit-breaker limits the peak current to less than 10% of the calculated prospective 

peak value, and the thermal effects to less than 1% of those calculated. 

Cascading of the several levels of distribution in an installation, downstream of a 

limiting CB, will also result in important savings. 

The technique of cascading, described in sub-clause 4.5 allows, in fact, substantial 

savings on switchgear (lower performance permissible downstream of the limiting 

CB(s)) enclosures, and design studies, of up to 20% (overall). 

Discriminative protection schemes and cascading are compatible, in the Compact 

NS range, up to the full short-circuit breaking capacity of the switchgear. 

H17 


H18 



The choice of a range of circuit-breakers is 

determined by: the electrical characteristics of 

the installation, the environment, the loads and 

a need for remote control, together with the type 

of telecommunications system envisaged 

Circuit-breakers with uncompensated thermal 

tripping units have a trip current level that 

depends on the surrounding temperature 

Ambient 

temperature 

Single CB 

in free air 

Fig. H40 : Ambient temperature 

Temperature of air 

surrouding the 

circuit breakers 

Circuit breakers installed 

in an enclosure 

Ambient 

temperature 


4.4 Selection of a circuit-breaker 

Choice of a circuit-breaker 

The choice of a CB is made in terms of: 

b Electrical characteristics of the installation for which the CB is intended 

b Its eventual environment: ambient temperature, in a kiosk or switchboard 

enclosure, climatic conditions, etc. 

b Short-circuit current breaking and making requirements 

b Operational specifications: discriminative tripping, requirements (or not) for 

remote control and indication and related auxiliary contacts, auxiliary tripping coils, 

connection 

b Installation regulations; in particular: protection of persons 

b Load characteristics, such as motors, fluorescent lighting, LV/LV transformers 

The following notes relate to the choice LV circuit-breaker for use in distribution 

systems. 

Choice of rated current in terms of ambient temperature 

The rated current of a circuit-breaker is defined for operation at a given ambient 

temperature, in general: 

b 30 °C for domestic-type CBs 

b 40 °C for industrial-type CBs 

Performance of these CBs in a different ambient temperature depends mainly on the 

technology of their tripping units (see Fig. H40). 

Uncompensated thermal magnetic tripping units 

Circuit-breakers with uncompensated thermal tripping elements have a trippingcurrent 

level that depends on the surrounding temperature. If the CB is installed 

in an enclosure, or in a hot location (boiler room, etc.), the current required to trip 

the CB on overload will be sensibly reduced. When the temperature in which the 

CB is located exceeds its reference temperature, it will therefore be “derated”. For 

this reason, CB manufacturers provide tables which indicate factors to apply at 

temperatures different to the CB reference temperature. It may be noted from typical 

examples of such tables (see Fig. H41) that a lower temperature than the reference 

value produces an up-rating of the CB. Moreover, small modular-type CBs mounted 

in juxtaposition, as shown typically in Figure H27, are usually mounted in a small 

closed metal case. In this situation, mutual heating, when passing normal load 

currents, generally requires them to be derated by a factor of 0.8. 

C60a, C60H: curve C. C60N: curves B and C (reference temperature: 30 °C) 

Rating (A) 20 °C 25 °C 30 °C 35 °C 40 °C 45 °C 50 °C 55 °C 60 °C 

1 1.05 1.02 1.00 0.98 0.95 0.93 0.90 0.88 0.85 

2 2.08 2.04 2.00 1.96 1.92 1.88 1.84 1.80 1.74 

3 3.18 3.09 3.00 2.91 2.82 2.70 2.61 2.49 2.37 

4 4.24 4.12 4.00 3.88 3.76 3.64 3.52 3.36 3.24 

6 6.24 6.12 6.00 5.88 5.76 5.64 5.52 5.40 5.30 

10 10.6 10.3 10.0 9.70 9.30 9.00 8.60 8.20 7.80 

16 16.8 16.5 16.0 15.5 15.2 14.7 14.2 13.8 13.5 

20 21.0 20.6 20.0 19.4 19.0 18.4 17.8 17.4 16.8 

25 26.2 25.7 25.0 24.2 23.7 23.0 22.2 21.5 20.7 

32 33.5 32.9 32.0 31.4 30.4 29.8 28.4 28.2 27.5 

40 42.0 41.2 40.0 38.8 38.0 36.8 35.6 34.4 33.2 

50 52.5 51.5 50.0 48.5 47.4 45.5 44.0 42.5 40.5 

63 66.2 64.9 63.0 61.1 58.0 56.7 54.2 51.7 49.2 

NS250N/H/L (reference temperature: 40 °C) 

Rating (A) 40 °C 45 °C 50 °C 55 °C 60 °C 

TM160D 160 156 152 147 144 

TM200D 200 195 190 185 180 

TM250D 250 244 238 231 225 

Fig. H41 : Examples of tables for the determination of derating/uprating factors to apply to CBs 

with uncompensated thermal tripping units, according to temperature 



Electronic tripping units are highly stable in 

changing temperature levels 


Example 

What rating (In) should be selected for a C60 N? 

b Protecting a circuit, the maximum load current of which is estimated to be 34 A 

b Installed side-by-side with other CBs in a closed distribution box 

b In an ambient temperature of 50 °C 

A C60N circuit-breaker rated at 40 A would be derated to 35.6 A in ambient air at 

50 °C (see Fig. H41). To allow for mutual heating in the enclosed space, however, the 

0.8 factor noted above must be employed, so that, 35.6 x 0.8 = 28.5 A, which is not 

suitable for the 34 A load. 

A 50 A circuit-breaker would therefore be selected, giving a (derated) current rating 

of 44 x 0.8 = 35.2 A. 

Compensated thermal-magnetic tripping units 

These tripping units include a bi-metal compensating strip which allows the overload 

trip-current setting (Ir or Irth) to be adjusted, within a specified range, irrespective of 

the ambient temperature. 

For example: 

b In certain countries, the TT system is standard on LV distribution systems, and 

domestic (and similar) installations are protected at the service position by a circuitbreaker 

provided by the supply authority. This CB, besides affording protection 

against indirect-contact hazard, will trip on overload; in this case, if the consumer 

exceeds the current level stated in his supply contract with the power authority. The 

circuit-breaker (y 60 A) is compensated for a temperature range of - 5 °C to + 40 °C. 

b LV circuit-breakers at ratings y 630 A are commonly equipped with compensated 

tripping units for this range (- 5 °C to + 40 °C) 

Electronic tripping units 

An important advantage with electronic tripping units is their stable performance 

in changing temperature conditions. However, the switchgear itself often imposes 

operational limits in elevated temperatures, so that manufacturers generally provide 

an operating chart relating the maximum values of permissible trip-current levels to 

the ambient temperature (see Fig. H42). 

Masterpact NW20 version 40°C 45°C 50°C 55°C 60°C 

H1/H2/H3 Withdrawable with In (A) 2,000 2,000 2,000 1,980 1,890 

horizontal plugs Maximum 1 1 1 0.99 0.95 

adjustment Ir 

L1 Withdrawable with In (A) 2,000 200 1,900 1,850 1,800 

on-edge plugs Maximum 1 1 0.95 0.93 0.90 

adjustment Ir 

Coeff. 

1 2,000 

0.95 1,890 

0.90 1,800 

In (A) 


NW20 withdrawable with 

horizontal plugs 

NW20 L1 withdrawable 

with on edge plugs 

20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 

Fig. H42 : Derating of Masterpact NW20 circuit-breaker, according to the temperature 

θ°C 

H19 


H20 



The installation of a LV circuit-breaker requires 

that its short-circuit breaking capacity (or that of 

the CB together with an associated device) be 

equal to or exceeds the calculated prospective 

short-circuit current at its point of installation 

The circuit-breaker at the output of the smallest 

transformer must have a short-circuit capacity 

adequate for a fault current which is higher 

than that through any of the other transformer 

LV circuit-breakers 


Selection of an instantaneous, or short-time-delay, tripping 

threshold 

Figure H43 below summarizes the main characteristics of the instantaneous or 

short-time delay trip units. 

Type Tripping unit Applications 

t 

Low setting 

type B 

b Sources producing low short-circuitcurrent 

levels 

(standby generators) 

b Long lengths of line or cable 

t 

t 

t 

Fig. H43 : Different tripping units, instantaneous or short-time-delayed 

Selection of a circuit-breaker according to the short-circuit 

breaking capacity requirements 

The installation of a circuit-breaker in a LV installation must fulfil one of the two 

following conditions: 

b Either have a rated short-circuit breaking capacity Icu (or Icn) which is equal to or 

exceeds the prospective short-circuit current calculated for its point of installation, or 

b If this is not the case, be associated with another device which is located 

upstream, and which has the required short-circuit breaking capacity 

In the second case, the characteristics of the two devices must be co-ordinated 

such that the energy permitted to pass through the upstream device must not 

exceed that which the downstream device and all associated cables, wires and other 

components can withstand, without being damaged in any way. This technique is 

profitably employed in: 

b Associations of fuses and circuit-breakers 

b Associations of current-limiting circuit-breakers and standard circuit-breakers. 

The technique is known as “cascading” (see sub-clause 4.5 of this chapter) 

The selection of main and principal circuit-breakers 

A single transformer 

If the transformer is located in a consumer’s substation, certain national standards 

require a LV circuit-breaker in which the open contacts are clearly visible such as 

Compact NS withdrawable circuit-breaker. 

Example (see Fig. H44 opposite page) 

What type of circuit-breaker is suitable for the main circuit-breaker of an installation 

supplied through a 250 kVA MV/LV (400 V) 3-phase transformer in a consumer’s 

substation? 

In transformer = 360 A 

Isc (3-phase) = 8.9 kA 

A Compact NS400N with an adjustable tripping-unit range of 160 A - 400 A and a 

short-circuit breaking capacity (Icu) of 45 kA would be a suitable choice for this duty. 


I 

I 

I 

I 

Standard setting b Protection of circuits: general case 

type C 

High setting b Protection of circuits having high initial 

type D or K transient current levels 

(e.g. motors, transformers, resistive loads) 

12 In b Protection of motors in association with 

type MA discontactors 

(contactors with overload protection)


250 kVA 

20 kV/400 V 

Compact 

NS400N 

Fig. H44 : Example of a transformer in a consumer’s substation 

A1 

B1 

MV 

LV 

Tr1 

CBM 

CBP 

A2 

B2 

Fig. H45 : Transformers in parallel 

E 

MV 

LV 

Tr2 

CBM 

CBP 

A3 

B3 

MV 

LV 

Tr3 

CBM 


Several transformers in parallel (see Fig. H45) 

b The circuit-breakers CBP outgoing from the LV distribution board must each be 

capable of breaking the total fault current from all transformers connected to the 

busbars, viz: Isc1 + Isc2 + Isc3 

b The circuit-breakers CBM, each controlling the output of a transformer, must be 

capable of dealing with a maximum short-circuit current of (for example) Isc2 + Isc3 

only, for a short-circuit located on the upstream side of CBM1. 

From these considerations, it will be seen that the circuit-breaker of the smallest 

transformer will be subjected to the highest level of fault current in these 

circumstances, while the circuit-breaker of the largest transformer will pass the 

lowest level of short-circuit current 

b The ratings of CBMs must be chosen according to the kVA ratings of the 

associated transformers 

Note: The essential conditions for the successful operation of 3-phase transformers 

in parallel may be summarized as follows: 

1. the phase shift of the voltages, primary to secondary, must be the same in all units 

to be paralleled. 

2. the open-circuit voltage ratios, primary to secondary, must be the same in all units. 

3. the short-circuit impedance voltage (Zsc%) must be the same for all units. 

For example, a 750 kVA transformer with a Zsc = 6% will share the load correctly 

with a 1,000 kVA transformer having a Zsc of 6%, i.e. the transformers will be loaded 

automatically in proportion to their kVA ratings. For transformers having a ratio of kVA 

ratings exceeding 2, parallel operation is not recommended. 

Figure H46 indicates, for the most usual arrangement (2 or 3 transformers of 

equal kVA ratings) the maximum short-circuit currents to which main and principal 

CBs (CBM and CBP respectively, in Figure H45) are subjected. It is based on the 

following hypotheses: 

b The short-circuit 3-phase power on the MV side of the transformer is 500 MVA 

b The transformers are standard 20/0.4 kV distribution-type units rated as listed 

b The cables from each transformer to its LV circuit-breaker comprise 5 metres of 

single core conductors 

b Between each incoming-circuit CBM and each outgoing-circuit CBP there is 

1 metre of busbar 

b The switchgear is installed in a floormounted enclosed switchboard, in an ambientair 

temperature of 30 °C 

Moreover, this table shows selected circuit-breakers of M-G manufacture 

recommended for main and principal circuit-breakers in each case. 

Example (see Fig. H47 next page) 

b Circuit-breaker selection for CBM duty: 

For a 800 kVA transformer In = 1.126 A; Icu (minimum) = 38 kA (from Figure H46), 

the CBM indicated in the table is a Compact NS1250N (Icu = 50 kA) 

b Circuit-breaker selection for CBP duty: 

The s.c. breaking capacity (Icu) required for these circuit-breakers is given in the 

Figure H46 as 56 kA. 

A recommended choice for the three outgoing circuits 1, 2 and 3 would be currentlimiting 

circuit-breakers types NS400 L, NS250 L and NS100 L. The Icu rating in 

each case = 150 kA. 

Number and kVA ratings Minimum S.C breaking Main circuit-breakers (CBM) Minimum S.C breaking Rated current In of 

of 20/0.4 kV transformers capacity of main CBs total discrimination with out capacity of principal CBs principal circuit-breaker 

(Icu) kA going circuit-breakers (CBP) (Icu) kA (CPB) 250A 

2 x 400 14 NW08N1/NS800N 27 NS250H 

3 x 400 28 NW08N1/NS800N 42 NS250H 

2 x 630 22 NW10N1/NS1000N 42 NS250H 

3 x 630 44 NW10N1/NS1000N 67 NS250H 

2 x 800 19 NW12N1/NS1250N 38 NS250H 

3 x 800 38 NW12N1/NS1250N 56 NS250H 

2 x 1,000 23 NW16N1/NS1600N 47 NS250H 

3 x 1,000 47 NW16N1/NS1600N 70 NS250H 

2 x 1,250 29 NW20N1/NS2000N 59 NS250H 

3 x 1,250 59 NW20N1/NS2000N 88 NS250L 

2 x 1,600 38 NW25N1/NS2500N 75 NS250L 

3 x 1,600 75 NW25N1/NS2500N 113 NS250L 

2 x 2,000 47 NW32N1/NS3200N 94 NS250L 

3 x 2,000 94 NW32N1/NS3200N 141 NS250L 

Fig. H46 : Maximum values of short-circuit current to be interrupted by main and principal circuit-breakers (CBM and CBP respectively), for several transformers in 

parallel 


H21 


H22 



Short-circuit fault-current levels at any point in 

an installation may be obtained from tables 

400 A 

CBP1 

100 A 

Fig. H47 : Transformers in parallel 

CBP2 

3 Tr 

800 kVA 

20 kV/400 V 

CBM 

200 A 

CBP3 

The technique of “cascading” uses the 

properties of current-limiting circuit-breakers 

to permit the installation of all downstream 

switchgear, cables and other circuit components 

of significantly lower performance than would 

otherwise be necessary, thereby simplifying and 

reducing the cost of an installation 


These circuit-breakers provide the advantages of: 

v Absolute discrimination with the upstream (CBM) breakers 

v Exploitation of the “cascading” technique, with its associated savings for all 

downstream components 

Choice of outgoing-circuit CBs and final-circuit CBs 

Use of table G40 

From this table, the value of 3-phase short-circuit current can be determined rapidly 

for any point in the installation, knowing: 

b The value of short-circuit current at a point upstream of that intended for the CB 

concerned 

b The length, c.s.a., and the composition of the conductors between the two points 

A circuit-breaker rated for a short-circuit breaking capacity exceeding the tabulated 

value may then be selected. 

Detailed calculation of the short-circuit current level 

In order to calculate more precisely the short-circuit current, notably, when the shortcircuit 

current-breaking capacity of a CB is slightly less than that derived from the 

table, it is necessary to use the method indicated in chapter G clause 4. 

Two-pole circuit-breakers (for phase and neutral) with one protected pole only 

These CBs are generally provided with an overcurrent protective device on the 

phase pole only, and may be used in TT, TN-S and IT schemes. In an IT scheme, 

however, the following conditions must be respected: 

b Condition (B) of table G67 for the protection of the neutral conductor against 

overcurrent in the case of a double fault 

b Short-circuit current-breaking rating: A 2-pole phase-neutral CB must, by 

convention, be capable of breaking on one pole (at the phase-to-phase voltage) the 

current of a double fault equal to 15% of the 3-phase short-circuit current at the point 

of its installation, if that current is y 10 kA; or 25% of the 3-phase short-circuit current 

if it exceeds 10 kA 

b Protection against indirect contact: this protection is provided according to the 

rules for IT schemes 

Insufficient short-circuit current breaking rating 

In low-voltage distribution systems it sometimes happens, especially in heavy-duty 

networks, that the Isc calculated exceeds the Icu rating of the CBs available for 

installation, or system changes upstream result in lower level CB ratings being 

exceeded 

b Solution 1: Check whether or not appropriate CBs upstream of the CBs affected 

are of the current-limiting type, allowing the principle of cascading (described in subclause 

4.5) to be applied 

b Solution 2: Install a range of CBs having a higher rating. This solution is 

economically interesting only where one or two CBs are affected 

b Solution 3: Associate current-limiting fuses (gG or aM) with the CBs concerned, on 

the upstream side. This arrangement must, however, respect the following rules: 

v The fuse rating must be appropriate 

v No fuse in the neutral conductor, except in certain IT installations where a double 

fault produces a current in the neutral which exceeds the short-circuit breaking rating 

of the CB. In this case, the blowing of the neutral fuse must cause the CB to trip on 

all phases 

4.5 Coordination between circuit-breakers 

Cascading 

Definition of the cascading technique 

By limiting the peak value of short-circuit current passing through it, a currentlimiting 

CB permits the use, in all circuits downstream of its location, of switchgear 

and circuit components having much lower short-circuit breaking capacities, and 

thermal and electromechanical withstand capabilities than would otherwise be 

necessary. Reduced physical size and lower performance requirements lead to 

substantial economy and to the simplification of installation work. It may be noted 

that, while a current-limiting circuit-breaker has the effect on downstream circuits 

of (apparently) increasing the source impedance during short-circuit conditions, it 

has no such effect in any other condition; for example, during the starting of a large 

motor (where a low source impedance is highly desirable). The range of Compact 

NS current-limiting circuit-breakers with powerful limiting performances is particularly 

interesting. 



In general, laboratory tests are necessary to 

ensure that the conditions of implementation 

required by national standards are met and 

compatible switchgear combinations must be 

provided by the manufacturer 

Discrimination may be total or partial, and 

based on the principles of current levels, or 

time-delays, or a combination of both. A more 

recent development is based on the logic 

techniques. 

A (patented) system by Merlin Gerin takes 

advantages of both current-limitation and 

discrimination 


Conditions of implementation 

Most national standards admit the cascading technique, on condition that the 

amount of energy “let through” by the limiting CB is less than the energy all 

downstream CBs and components are able to withstand without damage. 

In practice this can only be verified for CBs by tests performed in a laboratory. Such 

tests are carried out by manufacturers who provide the information in the form of 

tables, so that users can confidently design a cascading scheme based on the 

combination of recommended circuit-breaker types. As an example, Figure H48 

indicates the cascading possibilities of circuit-breaker types C60, DT40N, C120 and 

NG125 when installed downstream of current-limiting CBs NS 250 N, H or L for a 

230/400 V or 240/415 V 3-phase installation. 

kA rms 

Short-circuit 150 NS250L 

breaking capacity 50 NS250H 

of the upstream 35 NS250N 

(limiter) CBs 

Possible short-circuit 150 NG125L 

breaking capacity of 70 NG125L 

the downstream CBs 40 C60L y 40 A C60L y 40 A 

(benefiting from the 36 NG125N NG125N 

cascading technique) 30 C60H C60N/H/L C60N/H 

C60L C60L 50-63 A 

25 C60N C120N/H 

C120N/H C120N/H 

20 DT40N DT40N DT40N 

Fig. H48 : Example of cascading possibilities on a 230/400 V or 240/415 V 3-phase installation 

Advantages of cascading 

The current limitation benefits all downstream circuits that are controlled by the 

current-limiting CB concerned. 

The principle is not restrictive, i.e. current-limiting CBs can be installed at any point in 

an installation where the downstream circuits would otherwise be inadequately rated. 

The result is: 

b Simplified short-circuit current calculations 

b Simplification, i.e. a wider choice of downstream switchgear and appliances 

b The use of lighter-duty switchgear and appliances, with consequently lower cost 

b Economy of space requirements, since light-duty equipment have generally a 

smaller volume 

Principles of discriminative tripping (selectivity) 

Discrimination is achieved by automatic protective devices if a fault condition, occurring 

at any point in the installation, is cleared by the protective device located immediately 

upstream of the fault, while all other protective devices remain unaffected (see 

Fig. H49). 


B 

Isc 

0 

Total discrimination 

Ir B 

Partial discrimination 

Isc B 

Isc 

0 

B only opens A and B open 

Ir B Is Isc B 

Isc 

Fig. H49 : Total and partial discrimination 

A 

Is = discrimination limit 

H23 


H24 



t 

t 

Ir B 

Ir B 

Ir A 

Ir A 

B A 

B A 

B only opens 

Isc B Im A 

Fig. H50 : Total discrimination between CBs A and B 

Im A Is c B 

A and B open 

Is c A 

Fig. H51 : Partial discrimination between CBs A and B 

a) 

b) 

c) 

t 

t 

t 

B 

Ir B 

B A 

A 

Fig. H52 : Discrimination 

Ir A 

B A 

Im A 

delayed 

B 

A 

Isc B 

Isc B 

∆t 

Ii A 

instantaneous 

I 

I 

I 

I 

I 


Discrimination between circuit-breakers A and B is total if the maximum value of 

short-circuit-current on circuit B (Isc B) does not exceed the short-circuit trip setting 

of circuit-breaker A (Im A). For this condition, B only will trip (see Fig. H50). 

Discrimination is partial if the maximum possible short-circuit current on circuit B 

exceeds the short-circuit trip-current setting of circuit-breaker A. For this maximum 

condition, both A and B will trip (see Fig. H51). 

Protection against overload : discrimination based on current levels 

(see Fig. H52a) 

This method is realized by setting successive tripping thresholds at stepped levels, 

from downstream relays (lower settings) towards the source (higher settings). 

Discrimination is total or partial, depending on particular conditions, as noted above. 

As a rule of thumb, discrimination is achieved when: 

b IrA/IrB > 2: 

Protection against low level short-circuit currents : discrimination based on 

stepped time delays (see Fig. H52b) 

This method is implemented by adjusting the time-delayed tripping units, such that 

downstream relays have the shortest operating times, with progressively longer 

delays towards the source. 

In the two-level arrangement shown, upstream circuit-breaker A is delayed 

sufficiently to ensure total discrimination with B (for example: Masterpact with 

electronic trip unit). 

Discrimination based on a combination of the two previous methods 

(see Fig. H52c) 

A time-delay added to a current level scheme can improve the overall discrimination 

performance. 

The upstream CB has two high-speed magnetic tripping thresholds: 

b Im A: delayed magnetic trip or short-delay electronic trip 

b Ii: instantaneous strip 

Discrimination is total if Isc B < Ii (instantaneous). 

Protection against high level short-circuit currents: discrimination based on 

arc-energy levels 

This technology implemented in the Compact NS range (current limiting circuit- 

breaker) is extremely effective for achievement of total discrimination. 

Principle: When a very high level short-circuit current is detected by the two circuits- 

breaker A and B, their contacts open simultaneously. As a result, the current is highly 

limited. 

b The very high arc-energy at level B induces the tripping of circuit-breaker B 

b Then, the arc-energy is limited at level A and is not sufficient to induce the tripping 

of A 

As a rule of thumb, the discrimination between Compact NS is total if the size ratio 

between A and B is greater than 2.5. 

Current-level discrimination 

Current-level discrimination is achieved with stepped current-level settings 

of the instantaneous magnetic-trip elements 

Current-level discrimination is achieved with circuits breakers, preferably currentlimiting, 

and stepped current-level settings of the instantaneous magnetic-trip 

elements. 

b The downstream circuit-breaker is not a current-limiter device 

Total discrimination in this situation is practically impossible because 

Isc A ≈ Isc B, so that both circuit-breakers will generally trip simultaneously. In this 

case discrimination is partial, and limited to the Im of the upstream circuit-breaker. 

See fig. H51. 

b The downstream circuit-breaker is a current-limiting device 

Improvement in discriminative tripping can be obtained by using a current limiter 

for circuit-breaker B. For a short-circuit downstream of B, the limited level of peak 

current IB would operate the (suitably adjusted) magnetic trip unit of B, but would be 

insufficient to cause circuit-breaker A to trip. 

Note: All LV breakers (considered here) have some inherent degree of current 

limitation, even those that are not classified as current-limiting. This accounts for 

the curved characteristic shown for the standard circuit-breaker A in Figure H53 

opposite page. Careful calculation and testing is necessary, however, to ensure 

satisfactory performance of this arrangement. 



Discrimination based on time-delayed tripping 

uses CBs referred to as “selective” (in some 

countries). 

Implementation of these CBs is relatively simple 

and consists in delaying the instant of tripping 

of the several series-connected circuit-breakers 

in a stepped time sequence 

(1) Short-delay 


Fault 

upstream 

of B 

Fault 

downstream 

of B 

b The upstream circuit-breaker is a high speed device with a short-delay (SD) feature 

These circuit-breakers are fitted with trip units which include a non-adjustable 

mechanical short-time-delay feature. The delay is sufficient to ensure total 

discrimination with any downstream high-speed CB at any value of short-circuit 

current up to Ii A (see Fig. H54). 


I peak 

Fig. H53 : Downstream limiting circuit-breaker B 

t 

A 

Is c 

Fig. H54 : Use of a “selective” circuit-breaker upstream 

B 

A 

Current limitation 

curves 

(see note) 

B 

Only B opens A and B open 

Im A 

delayed 

Is c 

prospective (rms) 

Ii A 

instantaneous 

Example 

Circuit-breaker A: Compact NS250 N fitted with a trip unit which includes a SD 

feature. 

Ir = 250 A, magnetic trip set at 2,000 A 

Circuit-breaker B: Compact NS100N 

Ir = 100 A 

The Merlin Gerin distribution catalogue indicates a discrimination limit of 3,000 A (an 

improvement over the limit of 2,500 A obtained when using a standard tripping unit). 

Time-based discrimination 

This technique requires: 

b The introduction of time-delays into the tripping mechanisms of CBs 

b CBs with adequate thermal and mechanical withstand capabilities at the high 

current levels and time delays considered 

Two circuit-breakers A and B in series (i.e. carrying the same current) are 

discriminative if the current-breaking period of downstream circuit-breaker B is less 

than the non-tripping time of circuit-breaker A. 

I 

H25 


H26 




Practical example of discrimination at several levels with Merlin Gerin 

Masterpact circuit-breakers (with electronic trip units) 

These CBs can be equipped with adjustable time-delays which allow 4 time-step 

selections, such as: 

b The delay corresponding to a given step is greater than the total current breaking 

time of the next lower step 

b The delay corresponding to the first step is greater than the total current-breaking 

time of a high-speed CB (Compact NS for example) or of fuses (see Fig. H55) 


t 

Ir B 

Fig. H55 : Discrimination by time delay 

B 

A 

Only B opens 

Non tripping 

time of A 

Current-breaking 

time for B 

Icc B 

Energy discrimination with current limitation 

I 

Icc 

Cascading between 2 devices is normally achieved by using the tripping of the 

upstream circuit-breaker A to help the downstream circuit-breaker B to break the 

current. The discrimination limit Is is consequently equal to the ultimate breaking 

current Icu B of circuit-breaker B acting alone, as cascading requires the tripping of 

both devices. 

The energy discrimination technology implemented in Compact NS circuit-breakers 

allows to improve the discrimination limit to a value higher than the ultimate breaking 

current Icu B of the downstream circuit-breaker. The principle is as follows: 

b The downstream limiting circuit-breaker B sees a very high short-circuit current. 

The tripping is very fast ( 1.6 

b The ratio of rated currents of the two circuit-breakers is > 2.5


Discrimination schemes based on logic 

techniques are possible, using CBs equipped 

with electronic tripping units designed for the 

purpose (Compact, Masterpact by MG) and 

interconnected with pilot wires 


Logic discrimination or “Zone Sequence Interlocking – ZSI” 

This discrimination system requires CBs equipped with electronic tripping units, 

designed for this application, together with interconnecting pilot wires for data 

exchange between the CBs. With 2 levels A and B (see Fig. H56), circuit-breaker A 

is set to trip instantaneously, unless the relay of circuit-breaker B sends a signal to 

confirm that the fault is downstream of B. This signal causes the tripping unit of A to 

be delayed, thereby ensuring back-up protection in the event that B fails to clear the 

fault, and so on… 

This system (patented by Merlin Gerin) also allows rapid localization of the fault. 

Fig. H56 : Logic discrimination 


A 

B 

Inter-locking 

order 

Pilot wire 

4.6 Discrimination MV/LV in a consumer’s 

substation 

In general the transformer in a consumer’s substation is protected by MV fuses, 

suitably rated to match the transformer, in accordance with the principles laid down 

in IEC 60787 and IEC 60420, by following the advice of the fuse manufacturer. 

The basic requirement is that a MV fuse will not operate for LV faults occurring 

downstream of the transformer LV circuit-breaker, so that the tripping characteristic 

curve of the latter must be to the left of that of the MV fuse pre-arcing curve. 

This requirement generally fixes the maximum settings for the LV circuit-breaker 

protection: 

b Maximum short-circuit current-level setting of the magnetic tripping element 

b Maximum time-delay allowable for the short-circuit current tripping element 

(see Fig. H57) 

Fig. H57 : Example 

Full-load current 

1,760 A 

3-phase 

short-circuit 

current level 

31.4 kA 

63 A 

1,250 kVA 

20 kV / 400 V 

Compact 

NS2000 

set at 1,800 A 

H27 


H28 




b Short-circuit level at MV terminals of transformer: 250 MVA 

b Transformer MV/LV: 1,250 kVA 20/0.4 kV 

b MV fuses: 63 A 

b Cabling, transformer - LV circuit-breaker: 10 metres single-core cables 

b LV circuit-breaker: Compact NS 2000 set at 1,800 A (Ir) 

What is the maximum short-circuit trip current setting and its maximum time delay 

allowable? 

The curves of Figure H58 show that discrimination is assured if the short-time delay 

tripping unit of the CB is set at: 

b A level y 6 Ir = 10.8 kA 

b A time-delay setting of step 1 or 2 

1,000 

200 

100 

10 

0.2 

0.1 

0.50 

0.01 

t 

(s) 

1,800 A 

Ir 


NS 2000 

set at 

1,800 A 

1 4 6 

10 kA 

Fig. H58 : Curves of MV fuses and LV circuit-breaker 

8 

Minimum pre-arcing 

curve for 63 A HV fuses 

(current referred to the 

secondary side of the 

transformer) 

Isc maxi 

31.4 kA 

Step 4 

Step 3 

Step 2 

Step 1 

I

2 

3 

4 

Chapter J 

Protection against voltage surges 

in LV 

Contents 

General J2 

1.1 What is a voltage surge? J2 

1.2 The four voltage surge types J2 

1.3 Main characteristics of voltage surges J4 

1.4 Different propagation modes J5 

Overvoltage protection devices J6 

2.1 Primary protection devices (protection of installations J6 

against lightning) 

2.2 Secondary protection devices (protection of internal J8 

installations against lightning) 

Protection against voltage surges in LV J 

3.1 Surge protective device description J11 

3.2 Surge protective device standards J11 

3.3 Surge protective device data according to IEC 61643-1 standard J11 

3.4 Lightning protection standards J13 

3.5 Surge arrester installation standards J13 

Choosing a protection device J 4 

4.1 Protection devices according to the earthing system J14 

4.2 Internal architecture of surge arresters J15 

4.3 Installation rules J16 

4.4 Selection guide J17 

4.5 Choice of disconnector J22 

4.6 End-of-life indication of the surge arrester J22 

4.7 Application example: supermarket J23 


J 



J2 

J - Protection against voltage surges in LV 


. What is a voltage surge? 

A voltage surge is a voltage impulse or wave which is superposed on the rated 

network voltage (see Fig. J ). 

Voltage 

Fig. J1 : Voltage surge examples 


Lightning type impulse 

(duration = 100 µs) 

"Operating impulse" 

type dumped ring wave 

(F = 100 kHz to 1 MHz) 

This type of voltage surge is characterised by ( see Fig. J2): 

b The rise time (tf) measured in μs 

b The gradient S measured in kV/μs 

A voltage surge disturbs equipment and causes electromagnetic radiation. 

Furthermore, the duration of the voltage surge (T) causes a surge of energy in the 

electrical circuits which is likely to destroy the equipment. 

U max 

50 % 

Voltage (V or kV) 

Fig. J2 : Main overvoltage characteristics 

Rise time (tf) 

Voltage surge duration (T) 

.2 The four voltage surge types 

There are four types of voltage surges which may disturb electrical installations and 

loads: 

b Atmospheric voltage surges 

b Operating voltage surges 

b Transient overvoltage at industrial frequency 

b Voltage surges caused by electrostatic discharge 

Atmospheric voltage surges 

Lightning risk – a few figures 

Between 2,000 and 5,000 storms are constantly forming around the earth. These 

storms are accompanied by lightning which constitutes a serious risk for both people 

and equipment. Strokes of lightning hit the ground at a rate of 30 to 100 strokes per 

second. Every year, the earth is struck by about 3 billion strokes of lightning. 

t 

Irms


Lightning comes from the discharge of electrical 

charges accumulated in the cumulo-nimbus 

clouds which form a capacitor with the ground. 

Storm phenomena cause serious damage. 

Lightning is a high frequency electrical 

phenomenon which produces voltage surges 

on all conductive elements, and especially on 

electrical loads and wires. 


b Throughout the world, every year, thousands of people are struck by lightning and 

countless animals are killed 

b Lightning also causes a large number of fires, most of which break out on farms 

(destroying buildings or putting them out of use) 

b Lightning also affects transformers, electricity meters, household appliances, and 

all electrical and electronic installations in the residential sector and in industry. 

b Tall buildings are the ones most often struck by lightning 

b The cost of repairing damage caused by lightning is very high 

b It is difficult to evaluate the consequences of disturbance caused to computer or 

telecommunications networks, faults in PLC cycles and faults in regulation systems. 

Furthermore, the losses caused by a machine being put out of use can have financial 

consequences rising above the cost of the equipment destroyed by the lightning. 

Characteristics of lightning discharge 

Figure J3 shows the values given by the lighting protection committee (Technical 

Committee 81) of the I.E.C. As can be seen, 50 % of lightning strokes are of a force 

greater than 33 kA and 5 % are greater than 85 kA. The energy forces involved are 

thus very high. 

Beyond peak Current Gradient Total Number of 

probability peak duration discharges 

P% I (kA) S (kA/μs) T (s) n 

95 7 9.1 0.001 1 

50 33 24 0.01 2 

5 85 65 1.1 6 

Fig. J3 : Lightning discharge values given by the IEC lightning protection committee 

It is important to define the probability of adequate protection when protecting a site. 

Furthermore, a lightning current is a high frequency (HF) impulse current reaching 

roughly a megahertz. 

The effects of lightning 

A lightning current is therefore a high frequency electrical current. As well as 

considerable induction and voltage surge effects, it causes the same effects as any 

other low frequency current on a conductor: 

b Thermal effects: fusion at the lightning impact points and joule effect, due to the 

circulation of the current, causing fires 

b Electrodynamic effects: when the lightning currents circulate in parallel conductors, 

they provoke attraction or repulsion forces between the wires, causing breaks or 

mechanical deformations (crushed or flattened wires) 

b Combustion effects: lightning can cause the air to expand and create overpressure 

which stretches over a distance of a dozen metres or so. A blast effect breaks windows 

or partitions and can project animals or people several metres away from their original 

position. This shock wave is at the same time transformed into a sound wave: thunder 

b Voltage surges conducted after an impact on overhead electrical or telephone lines 

b Voltage surges induced by the electromagnetic radiation effect of the lightning 

channel which acts as an antenna over several kilometres and is crossed by a 

considerable impulse current 

b The elevation of the earth potential by the circulation of the lightning current in the 

ground. This explains indirect strokes of lightning by step voltage and the breakdown 

of equipment 

Operating voltage surges 

A sudden change in the established operating conditions in an electrical network 

causes transient phenomena to occur. These are generally high frequency or 

damped oscillation voltage surge waves (see Fig. J1). 

They are said to have a slow gradient: their frequency varies from several ten to 

several hundred kilohertz. 

Operating voltage surges may be created by: 

b The opening of protection devices (fuse, circuit-breaker), and the opening or 

closing of control devices (relays, contactors, etc.) 

b Inductive circuits due to motors starting and stopping, or the opening of 

transformers such as MV/LV substations 

b Capacitive circuits due to the connection of capacitor banks to the network 

b All devices that contain a coil, a capacitor or a transformer at the power supply 

inlet: relays, contactors, television sets, printers, computers, electric ovens, filters, etc. 


J3 



J4 


Three points must be kept in mind: 

b A direct or indirect lightning stroke may 

have destructive consequences on electrical 

installations several kilometres away from 

where it falls 

b Industrial or operating voltage surges also 

cause considerable damage 

b The fact that a site installation is underground 

in no way protects it although it does limit the 

risk of a direct strike 


Transient overvoltages at industrial frequency (see Fig. J4) 

These overvoltages have the same frequency as the network (50, 60 or 400 Hz); and 

can be caused by: 

b Phase/frame or phase/earth insulating faults on a network with an insulated or 

impedant neutral, or by the breakdown of the neutral conductor. When this happens, 

single phase devices will be supplied in 400 V instead of 230 V. 

b A cable breakdown. For example, a medium voltage cable which falls on a low 

voltage line. 

b The arcing of a high or medium voltage protective spark-gap causing a rise in earth 

potential during the action of the protection devices. These protection devices follow 

automatic switching cycles which will recreate a fault if it persists. 

Normal voltage 

230/400 V 

Fig. J4 : Transient overvoltage at industrial frequency 

Voltage surges caused by electrical discharge 

In a dry environment, electrical charges accumulate and create a very strong 

electrostatic field. For example, a person walking on carpet with insulating soles 

will become electrically charged to a voltage of several kilovolts. If the person walks 

close to a conductive structure, he will give off an electrical discharge of several 

amperes in a very short rise time of a few nanoseconds. If the structure contains 

sensitive electronics, a computer for example, its components or circuit boards may 

be damaged. 

.3 Main characteristics of voltage surges 

Figure J5 below sums up the main characteristics of voltage surges. 

Type of voltage surge Voltage surge Duration Front gradient 

coefficient or frequency 

Industrial frequency y 1.7 Long Industrial frequency 

(insulation fault) 30 to 1,000 ms (50-60-400 Hz) 

Operation 2 to 4 Short Average 

1 to 100 ms 1 to 200 kHz 

Atmospheric > 4 Very short Very high 

1 to 100 μs 1 to 1,000 kV/μs 

Fig. J5 : Main characteristics of voltage surges 


Transient overvoltage 

Normal voltage 

230/400 V 

t



.4 Different propagation modes 

Common mode 

Common mode voltage surges occur between the live parts and the earth: 

phase/earth or neutral/earth (see Fig. J6). 

They are especially dangerous for devices whose frame is earthed due to the risk of 

dielectric breakdown. 

Fig. J6 : Common mode 

Differential mode 

Fig. J7 : Differential mode 

Ph 

Ph 


N 

N 

Imc 

Voltage surge 

common mode 

Imd 

U voltage surge 

differential mode 

Imd 

Equipment 

Differential mode voltage surges circulate between live conductors: Phase to phase 

or phase to neutral (see Fig. J7). They are especially dangerous for electronic 

equipment, sensitive computer equipment, etc. 

Imc 

Equipment 

J5 



J 


2 Overvoltage protection devices 

Two major types of protection devices are used to suppress or limit voltage surges: 

they are referred to as primary protection devices and secondary protection devices. 

2.1 Primary protection devices (protection of 

installations against lightning) 

The purpose of primary protection devices is to protect installations against direct 

strokes of lightning. They catch and run the lightning current into the ground. The 

principle is based on a protection area determined by a structure which is higher 

than the rest. 

The same applies to any peak effect produced by a pole, building or very high 

metallic structure. 

There are three types of primary protection: 

b Lightning conductors, which are the oldest and best known lightning protection 

device 

b Overhead earth wires 

b The meshed cage or Faraday cage 

The lightning conductor 

The lightning conductor is a tapered rod placed on top of the building. It is earthed by 

one or more conductors (often copper strips) (see Fig. J8). 

Copper strip 

down conductor 

Test clamp 

Fig. J8 : Example of protection using a lightning conductor 


Crow-foot earthing



The design and installation of a lightning conductor is the job of a specialist. 

Attention must be paid to the copper strip paths, the test clamps, the crow-foot 

earthing to help high frequency lightning currents run to the ground, and the 

distances in relation to the wiring system (gas, water, etc.). 

Furthermore, the flow of the lightning current to the ground will induce voltage 

surges, by electromagnetic radiation, in the electrical circuits and buildings to be 

protected. These may reach several dozen kilovolts. It is therefore necessary to 

symmetrically split the down conductor currents in two, four or more, in order to 

minimise electromagnetic effects. 

Overhead earth wires 

These wires are stretched over the structure to be protected (see Fig. J9). They are 

used for special structures: rocket launch pads, military applications and lightning 

protection cables for overhead high voltage power lines (see Fig. J10). 


h 

Fig. J9 : Example of lightning protection using overhead earth wires 

Fig. J10 : Lightning protection wires 

Tin plated copper 25 mm 2 

Frame grounded earth belt 

i/2 

d > 0.1 h 

i/2 

i 

Metal post 

Lightning 

protection 

cables 

J 



J8 


Primary lightning conductor protection devices 

such as a meshed cage or overhead earth 

wires are used to protect against direct strokes 

of lighting.These protection devices do not 

prevent destructive secondary effects on 

equipment from occurring. For example, rises 

in earth potential and electromagnetic induction 

which are due to currents flowing to the earth. 

To reduce secondary effects, LV surge arresters 

must be added on telephone and electrical 

power networks. 

Secondary protection devices are classed in 

two categories: Serial protection and parallel 

protection devices. 

Serial protection devices are specific to a 

system or application. 

Parallel protection devices are used for: Power 

supply network, telephone network, switching 

network (bus). 


The meshed cage (Faraday cage) 

This principle is used for very sensitive buildings housing computer or integrated 

circuit production equipment. It consists in symmetrically multiplying the number of 

down strips outside the building. Horizontal links are added if the building is high; for 

example every two floors (see Fig. J11). The down conductors are earthed by frog’s 

foot earthing connections. The result is a series of interconnected 15 x 15 m or 

10 x 10 m meshes. This produces better equipotential bonding of the building and 

splits lightning currents, thus greatly reducing electromagnetic fields and induction. 

Fig. J11 : Example of protection using the meshed cage (Faraday cage) principle 

2.2 Secondary protection devices (protection of 

internal installations against lightning) 

These handle the effects of atmospheric, operating or industrial frequency voltage 

surges. They can be classified according to the way they are connected in an 

installation: serial or parallel protection. 

Serial protection device 

This is connected in series to the power supply wires of the system to be protected 

(see Fig. J12). 

Power supply 

Fig. J12 : Serial protection principle 


Serial 

protection 

Installation to be protected 

Transformers 

They reduce voltage surges by inductor effect and make certain harmonics 

disappear by coupling. This protection is not very effective. 

Filters 

Based on components such as resistors, inductance coils and capacitors they 

are suitable for voltage surges caused by industrial and operation disturbance 

corresponding to a clearly defined frequency band. This protection device is not 

suitable for atmospheric disturbance. 

Up



Wave absorbers 

They are essentially made up of air inductance coils which limit the voltage surges, 

and surge arresters which absorb the currents. They are extremely suitable for 

protecting sensitive electronic and computing equipment. They only act against 

voltage surges. They are nonetheless extremely cumbersome and expensive. 

Network conditioners and static uninterrupted power supplies (UPS) 

These devices are essentially used to protect highly sensitive equipment, such as 

computer equipment, which requires a high quality electrical power supply. They 

can be used to regulate the voltage and frequency, stop interference and ensure a 

continuous electrical power supply even in the event of a mains power failure (for 

the UPS). On the other hand, they are not protected against large, atmospheric type 

voltage surges against which it is still necessary to use surge arresters. 

Parallel protection device 

The principle 

The parallel protection is adapted to any installation power level (see Fig. J13). 

This type of overvoltage protection is the most commonly used. 

Power supply 

Parallel 

protection 

Fig. J13 : Parallel protection principle 


b The rated voltage of the protection device must correspond to the network voltage 

at the installation terminals 

b When there is no voltage surge, a leakage current should not go through the 

protection device which is on standby 

b When a voltage surge above the allowable voltage threshold of the installation 

to be protected occurs, the protection device abruptly conducts the voltage surge 

current to the earth by limiting the voltage to the desired protection level Up 

(see Fig. J14). 

Up 

U (V) 


Up 

0 I (A) 

Fig. J14 : Typical U/I curve of the ideal protection device 

Installation to 

be protected 

When the voltage surge disappears, the protection device stops conducting and 

returns to standby without a holding current. This is the ideal U/I characteristic curve: 

b The protection device response time (tr) must be as short as possible to protect the 

installation as quickly as possible 

b The protection device must have the capacity to be able to conduct the energy 

caused by the foreseeable voltage surge on the site to be protected 

b The surge arrester protection device must be able to withstand the rated current In. 

J9 


J10 




The products used 

b Voltage limiters 

They are used in MV/LV substations at the transformer output, in IT earthing scheme. 

They can run voltage surges to the earth, especially industrial frequency surges 

(see Fig. J15) 

Fig. J15 : Voltage limiter 

Overvoltage 

limiter 

b LV surge arresters 

This term designates very different devices as far as technology and use are 

concerned. Low voltage surge arresters come in the form of modules to be installed 

inside LV switchboard. There are also plug-in types and those that protect power 

outlets. They ensure secondary protection of nearby elements but have a small flow 

capacity. Some are even built into loads although they cannot protect against strong 

voltage surges 

b Low current surge arresters or overvoltage protectors 

These protect telephone or switching networks against voltage surges from the 

outside (lightning), as well as from the inside (polluting equipment, switchgear 

switching, etc.) 

Low current voltage surge arresters are also installed in distribution boxes or 

built into loads. 


MV/LV 

PIM 

Permanent 

insulation 

monitor


3 Protection against voltage 

surges in LV 

3.1 Surge protective device description 

A surge protective device (SDP) is a device that limits transient voltage surges and 

runs current waves to ground to limit the amplitude of the voltage surge to a safe 

level for electrical installations and equipment. 

The surge protective device includes one or several non linear components. 

The surge protective device eliminates voltage surges: 

b In common mode: Phase to earth or neutral to earth 

b In differential mode: Phase to phase or phase to neutral 

When a voltage surge exceeds the Uc threshold, the surge protective device (SDP) 

conducts the energy to earth in common mode. In differential mode the diverted 

energy is directed to another active conductor. 

The surge protective device has an internal thermal protection device which protects 

against burnout at its end of life. Gradually, over normal use after withstanding 

several voltage surges, the Surge Protective Device degrades into a conductive 

device. An indicator informs the user when end-of-life is close. 

Some Surge Protective Devices have a remote indication. 

In addition, protection against short-circuits is ensured by an external circuit-breaker. 

3.2 Surge protective device standards 

International standard IEC 61643-1 ed. 02/2005 

Surge protective devices connected to low-voltage power distribution systems. 

Three test classes are defined: 

b Class I tests: They are conducted using nominal discharge current (In), voltage 

impulse with 1.2/50 μs waveshape and impulse current Iimp. 

The class I tests is intended to simulate partial conducted lightning current impulses. 

SPDs subjected to class I test methods are generally recommended for locations 

at points of high exposure, e.g., line entrances to buildings protected by lightning 

protection systems. 

b Class II tests: They are conducted using nominal discharge current (In), voltage 

impulse with 1.2/50 μs waveshape 

b Class III tests: They are conducted using the combination waveform (1.2/50 and 

8/20 μs). 

SPDs tested to class II or III test methods are subjected to impulses of shorter 

duration. These SPDs are generally recommended for locations with lesser exposure. 

These 3 test classes cannot be compared, since each originates in a country and 

each has its own specificities. Moreover, each builder can refer to one of the 3 test 

classes. 

European standard EN 61643-11 2002 

Some requirements as per IEC 61643-1. Moreover SPDs are classified in three 

categories: 

Type 1: SPD tested to Class I 

Type 2: SPD tested to Class II 

Type 3: SPD tested to Class III 

3.3 Surge protective device data according to 

IEC 61643-1 standard 

b Surge protective device (SPD): A device that is intended to limit transient 

overvoltages and divert surge currents. It contains at least one nonlinear component. 

b Test classes: Surge arrester test classification. 

b In: Nominal discharge current; the crest value of the current through the SPD 

having a current waveshape of 8/20. This is used for the classification of the SPD for 

the class II test and also for preconditioning of the SPD for class I and II tests. 

b Imax: Maximum discharge current for class II test; crest value of a current through 

the SPD having an 8/20 waveshape and magnitude according to the test sequence 

of the class II operating duty test. Imax is greater than In. 

b Ic: Continuous operating current; current that flows in an SPD when supplied at 

its permament full withstand operating voltage (Uc) for each mode. Ic corresponds 

to the sum of the currents that flow in the SPD’s protection component and in all the 

internal circuits connected in parallel. 


J11 


J12 



Maxi 

100 % 

50 % 

1,2 

V 

Fig. J17 : 1.2/50 μs wave 

50 

t 


surges in LV 

b Iimp: Impulse current, it is defined by a current peak value Ipeak and the charge 

Q. Tested according to the test sequence of the operating duty test. This is used for 

the classification of the SPD for class I test. 

b Un: Rated network voltage. 

b Uc: Maximum continuous operating voltage; the maximum r.m.s. or d.c. voltage 

which may be continuously applied to the SPDs mode of protection. This is equal to 

the rated voltage. 

b Up: Voltage protection level; a parameter that characterizes the performance of 

the SPD in limiting the voltage across its terminals, which is selected from a list of 

preferred values. This value shall be greater than the highest value of the measured 

limiting voltages. 

The most common values for a 230/400 V network are: 

1 kV - 1.2 kV - 1.5 kV - 1.8 kV - 2 kV - 2.5 kV. 

b Ures: Residual voltage, the peak value of the voltage that appears between the 

terminals of an SPD due to the passage of discharge current. 

The SPD is characterised by Uc, Up, In and Imax (see Fig. J16) 

b To test the surge arrester, standardized voltage and current waves have been 

defined that are specific to each country: 

v Voltage wave 

e.g. 1.2/50 μs (see Fig. J17) 

v Current wave 

Example 8/20 μs (see Fig. J18) 

Fig. J18 : 8/20 μs wave 

U p 

U c 

Maxi 

100 % 

50 % 


U 

I 

< 1 mA 

Fig. J16 : Voltage/current characteristics 

8 

20 

I n I max 

v Other possible wave characteristics: 

4/10 μs, 10/1000 μs, 30/60 μs, 10/350 μs... 

Comparison between different surge protective devices must be carried out using the 

same wave characteristics, in order to get relevant results. 

t 

I


(1) According to IEC 60038 

(2) In Canada and USA for voltages to earth higher than 300 V, 

the impulse withstand voltage corresponding to the 

next higher voltage in column one applies. 

Category I is addressed to particular equipment engineering. 

Category II is addressed to product committees for equipment 

for connection to the mains. 

Category III is addressed to product committees of installation 

material and some special product committees. 

Category IV is addressed to supply authorities and system 

engineers (see also 443.2.2). 


surges in LV 

3.4 Lightning protection standards 

The IEC 62305 series (part 1 to 5) restructures and updates the publications of 

IEC 61024 series, IEC 61312 series and IEC 61663 series. 

The need for protection, the economic benefits of installing protection measures and 

the selection of adequate protection measures should be determined in terms of risk 

management. Risk management is the subject of IEC 62305-2. 

The criteria for design, installation and maintenance of lightning protection measures 

are considered in three separate groups: 

b The first group concerning protection measures to reduce physical damage and life 

hazard in a structure is given in IEC 62305-3. 

b The second group concerning protection measures to reduce failures of electrical 

and electronic systems in a structure is given in IEC 62305-4. 

b The third group concerning protection measures to reduce physical damage and 

failures of services connected to a structure (mainly electrical and telecommunication 

lines) is given in IEC 62305-5. 

3.5 Surge arrester installation standards 

b International: IEC 61643-12 selection and application principles 

b International: IEC 60364 Electrical installations of buildings 

v IEC 60364-4-443: protection for safety 

When an installation is supplied by, or includes, an overhead line, a protection device 

against atmospheric overvoltages must be foreseen if the keraunic level of the site 

being considered corresponds to the external influences condition AQ 1 (more than 

25 days per year with thunderstorms). 

v IEC 60364-4-443-4: selection of equipment in the installation. 

This section helps with the choice of the protection level Up for the surge arrester in 

function of the loads to be protected. 

Rated residual voltage of protection devices must not be higher than the value in the 

voltage impulse withstand category II (see Fig. J19): 

Nominal voltage of Required impulse withstand voltage for 

the installation (1) V kV 

Three-phase Single-phase Equipment at Equipment of Appliances Specially 

systems (2) systems with the origin of distribution and protected 

middle point the installation final circuits equipment 

(impulse (impulse (impulse (impulse 

withstand withstand withstand withstand 

category IV) category III) category II) category I) 

120-240 4 2.5 1.5 0.8 

230/400 (2) - 6 4 2.5 1.5 

277/480 (2) 

400/690 - 8 6 4 2.5 

1,000 - Values subject to system engineers 

Fig. J19 : Choosing equipment for the installation according to IEC 60364 


J13 


J14 



(1) These values are related to worst case fault conditions, 

therefore the tolerance of 10 % is not taken into account 


surges in LV 

v IEC 60364-5-534: choosing and implementing electrical equipment 

This section describes surge arrester installation conditions: 

- According to earthing systems: The maximum continuous operating voltage Uc 

of SPDs shall be equal to or higher than shown in Fig. J20. 

SPDs connected 

between 

Line conductor and 

neutral conductor 

Each line conductor and 

PE conductor 

Neutral conductor and PE 

conductor 

Each line conductor and 

PEN conductor 

- At the origin of the installation: if the surge arrester is installed at the source of 

an electrical installation supplied by the utility distribution network, its rated discharge 

current may be lower than 5 kA. 

If a surge arrester is installed downstream from an earth leakage protection device, 

an RCD of the s type, with immunity to impulse currents of less than 3 kA (8/20 μs), 

must be used. 

- Protection against overcurrent at 50 Hz and consequences of a SPD failure: 

protection against SPDs short-circuits is provided by the overcurrent protective 

devices F2 which are to be selected according to the maximum recommended rating 

for the overcurrent protective device given in the manufacturer's SPD instructions. 

- In the presence of lightning conductors: a surge arrester must be installed, 

additional specifications for surge arresters must be applied (see IEC 62305 part 4). 


System configuration of distribution network 

TT TN-C TN-S IT with 

distributed 

neutral 

IT without 

distributed 

neutral 

1.1 Uo NA 1.1 Uo 1.1 Uo NA 

1.1 Uo NA 1.1 Uo 3Uo (1) Line-to-line 

voltage (1) 

Uo (1) NA Uo (1) Uo (1) NA 

NA 1.1 Uo NA NA NA 

NA: not applicable 

NOTE 1: Uo is the line-to-neutral voltage of the low-voltage system. 

NOTE 2: This table is based on IEC 61643-1 amendment 1. 

Fig. J20 : Minimum required Uc of the SPD dependent on supply system configuration


4 Choosing a protection device 

When installing surge arresters, several elements must be considered, such as: 

b Cascading 

b Positioning with respect to residual current devices 

b The choice of disconnection circuit breakers 

The earthing system must also be taken into account. 

4.1 Protection devices according to the earthing 

system 

b Common mode overvoltage: basic protection involves the installation of a common 

mode surge arrester between phase and PE or phase and PEN, whatever type of 

earthing system is used. 

b Differential mode overvoltage: in the TT and TN-S earthing systems, earthing the 

neutral leads to dissymmetry due to earthing impedances, which causes differential 

mode voltages to appear, whereas the overvoltage induced by a lightning strike is a 

common mode voltage. 

For example, let us consider a TT earthing system. A two-pole surge arrester is 

installed in common mode to protect the installation (see Fig. J21). 

Fig. J21 : Common mode protection only 


I 

I 

The neutral earthing resistor R1 used for the pylons has a lower resistance than the 

earthing resistor R2 used for the installation. The lightning current will flow through 

circuit ABCD to earth via the easiest path. It will pass through varistors V1 and V2 in 

series, causing a differential voltage equal to twice the residual voltage of the surge 

arrester (Up1 + Up2) to appear at the terminals of A and C at the entrance to the 

installation in extreme cases. 

To protect the loads between Ph and N effectively, the differential mode voltage 

(between A and C) must be reduced. 

Another earthing system is therefore used (see Fig. J22). 

The lightning current flows through circuit ABH which has a lower impedance than 

circuit ABCD, as the impedance of the component used between B and H is null (gas 

filled spark gap). 

In this case, the differential voltage is equal to the residual voltage of the surge 

arrester (Up2). 

Fig. J22 : Common + differentiel mode protection 

I 

I 

I 

I 

I 

J15 


J16 



PE 

Main earth terminal 

Fig. J26 : Connection example 

Earthing conductor 


Mode Between TT TN-S TN-C IT 

Differential phase and neutral yes yes - - 

Common phase and earth yes yes yes yes 


phase and earth yes yes - yes (if distributed 

neutral) 

Fig. J23 : Connections to be made according to the earthing systems used, in the case of 

atmospheric overvoltages 

4.2 Internal architecture of surge arresters 

b 2P, 3P, 4P surge arresters (see Fig. J24): 

v They provide protection against common-mode overvoltages only 

v They are appropriate for TN-C and IT earthing systems. 

Fig. J24 : 2P, 3P, 4P surge arresters 

b 1P+N, 3P+N surge arresters (see Fig. J25): 

v They provide protection against common-mode and differential-mode overvoltages 

v They are appropriate for TT, TN-S, and IT earthing systems. 

Fig. J25 : 1P+N, 3P+N surge arresters 

b Single-pole (1P) surge arresters (see Fig. J26): 

v They are used to satisfy the demand of different assemblies (according to the 

manufacturer’s instructions) by supplying only one product. 

However, special dimensioning will be required for N - PE protection 

(for example 1+N and 3P+N) 

v The assembly must be validated by means of the tests specified in EN 61643-11.


Cascading protection requires a minimum 

distance of at least 10 m between the two 

protection devices. 

This is valid, whatever the field of application: 

domestic, tertiary or industrial. 

Fig. J27 : Cascading of surge arresters 


4.3 Installation rules 

The overvoltage protection study of an installation may show that the site is highly 

exposed and that the equipment to be protected is sensitive. The surge arrester 

must be able to discharge high currents and have a low level of protection. This dual 

constraint cannot always be handled by a single surge arrester. A second one will 

therefore be required (see Fig. J27). 

The first device, P1 (incoming protection) will be placed at the incoming end of the 


Its purpose will be to discharge the maximum amount of energy to earth with a 

level of protection y 2000 V that can be withstood by the electrotechnical equipment 

(contactors, motors, etc.). 

The second device (fine protection) will be placed in a distribution enclosure, as 

close as possible to the sensitive loads. It will have a low discharge capacity and a 

low level of protection that will limit overvoltages significantly and therefore protect 

sensitive loads (y 1500 V). 

Coordination of surge arresters 

I 

The fine-protection device P2 is installed in parallel with the incoming protection 

device P1. 

If the distance L is too small, at the incoming overvoltage, P2 with a protection 

level of U2 = 1500 V will operate before P1 with a level of U1 = 2000 V. P2 will not 

withstand an excessively high current. The protection devices must therefore be 

coordinated to ensure that P1 activates before P2. To do this, we shall experiment 

with the length L of the cable, i.e. the value of the self-inductance between the two 

protection devices. This self-inductance will block the current flow to P2 and cause a 

certain delay, which will force P1 to operate before P2. A metre of cable gives a selfinductance 

of approximately 1μH. 

The rule ∆U= Ldi 

causes a voltage drop of approximately 100 V/m/kA, 8/20 μs 

dt 

wave. 

For L = 10 m, we get UL1 = UL2 ≈ 1000 V. 

To ensure that P2 operates with a level of protection of 1500 V requires 

U1 = UL1 + UL2 + U2 = 1000 + 1000 + 1500 V = 3500 V. 

Consequently, P1 operates before 2000 V and therefore protects P2. 

Note: if the distance between the surge arrester at the incoming end of the 

installation and the equipment to be protected exceeds 30 m, cascading the surge 

arresters is recommended, as the residual voltage of the surge arrester may rise 

to double the residual voltage at the terminals of the incoming surge arrester; as in 

the above example, the fine protection surge arrester must be placed as close as 

possible to the loads to be protected. 

The first rule to be observed is to ensure that the connection between the surge 

arrester and its disconnection circuit breaker does not exceed 50 cm. 


I 

Fig. J28 : Coordination of surge arresters 

I 

J17 


J18 



1 

2 

3 


4.4 Selection guide 

Estimate the value of the equipment to be protected 

To estimate its value, consider: 

b The cost of the equipment in financial terms 

b The economic impact if the equipment goes down. 

b Domestic equipment: 

v audio-video, computers 

v household appliances 

v burglar alarm. 

b Sensitive equipment: 

v burglar alarm 

v fire alarm 

v access control 

v video surveillance. 

b Professional equipment: 

v programmable machine 

v computer server 

v sound or light control system. 


b Building equipment: 

v automated heating or 

air-conditioning 

v lift. 

Determine the electrical architecture of buildings 

b Heavy equipment: 

v medical infrastructure 

v production infrastructure 

v heavy computer processing. 

Lightning protection can be calculated for an entire building or for part of a 

building that is electrically independent 

Depending on the size of the building and the extent of its electrical system, one or 

more surge arresters must be used in the various switchboards in the installation. 

b Detached house. 

b Apartment, small semi-detached house. 

b Communal part of a building. 

b Professional premises. 

b Tertiary and industrial buildings: 

v single switchboard, main switchboard 

v distribution board 

v sensitive equipment more than 30 m from the switchboard. 

Understand the risk of the impact of lightning on the site 

Lightning is attracted by high points that conduct electricity. They can be: 

b Natural: tall trees, mountain crest, wet areas, ferrous soil 

b Artificial: chimney, aerial, pylon, lightning conductor. 

Indirect effects can be incurred within a fifty metre radius around the point of impact. 

Location of the building 

In an urban, peri-urban, 

grouped housing area. 

In an area where there is a 

particular hazard (pylon, tree, 

mountainous region, mountain 

crest, wet area or pond). 

In flat open country. In an exceptionally exposed area 

(lightning conductor on a building 

less than 50 metres away).


1 

Equipment to be 

protected 

2 

Determine the 

architecture of the 

building 

3 

Risk level of 

the impact of a 

lightning strike 

Choice of type of 

surge arrester 

Domestic equipment 

Type 2 

10 kA 

Detached house, 

Professional 

premises 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Type 1 

25 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Audio-video, computers, 

household appliances, 

burglar alarm, etc. 

Type 1 

25 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Apartment, small 

semi-detached 

house 

Type 2 

10 kA 


Communal part of a 

building 

Note: 

Type 1: very high discharge capacity surge arrester used with a lightning conductor with an impact level of and . 

Type 2: surge arrester used in cascade behind a type 1 surge arrester or alone in zone and . 

Fig. J32 : Domestic equipment 

Lightning also propagates through 

telecommunications networks. 

It can damage all the equipment connected to 

these networks. 


Type 2 

40 kA 

Protection of telecommunications equipment 

Type 2 

65 kA 

Choice of surge arresters PRC 

Analogue telephone networks < 200 V b 

Type 1 

25 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Type 1 

25 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

J19 


J20 



1 


protected 

2 

Determine the 


building 

3 






Sensitive equipment: Building equipment: 

Type 2 

20 kA 

Single 

switchboard, 

main 

switchboard 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Burglar alarm, 

fire alarm, 

access control, 

video-surveillance, etc. 

Type 1 

25 kA 

or 

35 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Distribution 

board 

Type 2 

20 kA 


Automated heating or 

air-conditioning, 

lift, etc. 

Dedicated 

protection, 

more than 

30 m from a 

switchboard 

Note: 



Fig. J33 : Sensitive equipment, Building equipment 


Type 2 

8 kA


1 


protected 

2 

Determine the 


building 

3 






Note: 



Fig. J34 : Professional equipment 

Professional equipment 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Single 

switchboard, 

main 

switchboard 

Type 2 

65 kA 

Type 2 

65 kA 

Programmable machine, 

server, 

sound or light control system, 

etc. 

Type 1 

25 kA 

or 

35 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 


Distribution 

board 

Type 2 

20 kA 


Dedicated 

protection, 

more than 

30 m from a 

switchboard 

Type 2 

8 kA 

J21 


J22 



1 


protected 

2 

Determine the 


building 

3 






Heavy equipment 

Type 2 

65 kA 

Single 

switchboard, 

main 

switchboard 

Type 1 

25 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Type 1 

25 kA 

or 

35 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Medical, production, 

or heavy computer 

processing infrastructure, 

etc. 

Type 1 

25 kA 

or 

35 kA 

+ 

Type 2 

40 kA 

Distribution 

board 

Type 2 

20 KA 


Dedicated 

protection, 

more than 

30 m from a 

switchboard 

Note: 



Fig. J35 : Heavy equipment 

Lightning can also propagate through 

telecommunications and computer networks. 

It can damage all the equipment connected 

to these networks: telephones, modems, 

computers, servers, etc. 


Type 2 

8 kA 

Protection of telecommunications and computer equipment 

Choice of surge arresters PRC PRI 

Analogue telephone networks < 200 V b 

Digital networks, analogue lines < 48 V 

Digital networks, analogue lines < 6 V 

VLV load supply < 48 V 

b 

b


4.5 Choice of disconnector 

The disconnector is necessary to ensure the safety of the installation 

b One of the surge arrester parameters is the maximum current (Imax 8/20 μs 

wave) that it can withstand without degradation. If this current is exceeded, the surge 

arrester will be destroyed; it will be permanently short circuited and it is essential to 

replace it. 

The fault current must therefore be eliminated by an external disconnector installed 

upstream. 

The disconnector provides the complete protection required by a surge arrester 

installation, i.e.: 

v It must be able to withstand standard test waves: 

- it must not trip at 20 impulses at In 

- it can trip at Imax without being destroyed 

v the surge arrester disconnects if it short-circuits. 

b The ready-to-cable surge arresters with an integrated disconnection circuit breaker 

are: 

v Combi PRF1 

v Quick PF 

v Quick PRD. 

Surge arrester / disconnection circuit breaker correspondence 

table 

Types Isc Surge arresters 6 kA 10 kA 15 kA 25 kA 36 kA 50 kA 70 kA 

Type 1 

Type 2 

35 kA (1) PRF1 Master NH 160 A gL/gG fuse 

25 kA (1) PRF1 D125 NH 125 A gL/gG fuse 

65 kA (2) PF65, PRD65 C60N 

50 A 

Curve C 

40 kA (2) PF40, PRD40 C60N 

40 A 

Curve C 

20 kA (2) PF20, PRD20 C60N 

25 A 

Curve C 

8 kA (2) C60N 

20 A 

Curve C 

Isc: prospective short-circuit current at the point of installation. 

(1) Iimp. 

(2) Imax. 

Fig. J36 : Correspondence between surge arrester / disconnection circuit breaker 


NS160N 160 A NS160H 

160 A 

C60H 

50 A 

Curve C 

C60H 

40 A 

Curve C 

C60H 

25 A 

Curve C 

C60H 

20 A 

Curve C 


Contact us 

Contact us 

Contact us 

4.6 End-of-life indication of the surge arrester 

Various indication devices are provided to warn the user that the loads are no longer 

protected against atmospheric overvoltages. 

Type 1 surge arresters (with gas filled spark gap) 

PRF1 1P 260 V, Combi 1P+N and 3P+N and PRF1 Master 

These surge arresters have a light indicating that the module is in good working 

order. This indicator light requires a minimum operating voltage of 120 V AC. 

b The light does not come on: 

v if the operating voltage is y 120 V AC 

v if there is no network voltage 

v if the spark-over electronics are defective. 

J23 


J24 



Fig. J37 : Example of indication for PRD 

Fig. J39 : Example of indication for Quick PRD 


Type 2 surge arresters (varistor, varistor + gas filled spark gap) 

PF, PRD 

At end of life, the surge arrester or the cartridge are destroyed. 

b This can occur in two ways: 

v internal end-of-life disconnection: the accumulated electric shocks cause the 

varistors to age, resulting in an increase in leakage current. 

Above 1 mA, a thermal runaway occurs and the surge arrester disconnects. 

v external end-of-life disconnection: this occurs in the event of an excessive 

overvoltage (direct lightning strike on the line); above the discharge capacity of the 

surge arrester, the varistor(s) are dead short-circuited to earth (or possibly between 

phase and neutral). This short-circuit is eliminated when the mandatory associated 

disconnection circuit breaker opens. 

Quick PRD and Quick PF 

Whatever the hazards of the power supply network, Quick PRD and Quick PF 

incorporate a perfectly coordinated disconnector. 

b In the event of lightning strikes < Imax: like all surge arresters, they have internal 

anti-ageing protection. 

b In the event of a lightning strike > Imax: Quick PRD and Quick PF are selfprotected 

by their integrated disconnector. 

b In the event of neutral disconnection or phase-neutral reversal occurring on the 

power supply: 

Quick PRD and Quick PF are self-protected by their integrated disconnector. 

To simplify maintenance work, Quick PRD is fitted with local indicators and draw-out 

cartridges that are mechanically combined with the disconnector. 

Quick PRD has indicator lights on the cartridges and on the integrated disconnector, 

so that the work to be carried out can quickly be located. 

For safety reasons, the disconnector opens automatically when a cartridge is 

removed. It cannot be set until the cartridge is plugged in. 

When changing the cartridge, a phase/neutral failsafe system ensures that it can be 

plugged in safely. 

Operating state continuous display 

Quick PRD has an integrated reporting contact to send information about the 

operating state of the surge arrester from a remote location. 

Monitoring the surge arresters installed throughout the installation makes it possible 

to be continuously aware of their operating state and to ensure that the protection 

devices are always in good working order. 

b A reporting contact gives the alert: 

v at end of life of a cartridge 

v if a cartridge is missing, as soon as it has been removed 

v if a fault occurs on the line (short-circuit, neutral disconnection, phase-neutral 

reversal) 

v in the event of local manual operation (handle down). 

Quick PF has an optional indication reporting auxiliary (SR) that sends information 

about the operating state of the surge arrester from a remote location. 

4.7 Application example: supermarket 

Solutions and schematic diagram 

b The surge arrester selection guide has made it possible to determine the precise 

value of the surge arrester at the incoming end of the installation and that of the 

associated disconnection circuit breaker. 

b As the sensitive devices (Uimp < 1.5 kV) are located more than 30 m from the 

incoming protection device, the fine protection surge arresters must be installed as 

close as possible to the loads. 

b To ensure better continuity of service for cold room areas: 

v"si" type residual current circuit breakers will be used to avoid nuisance tripping 

caused by the rise in earth potential as the lightning wave passes through. 

b For protection against atmospheric overvoltages: 

v install a surge arrester in the main switchboard 

v install a fine protection surge arrester in each switchboard (1 and 2) supplying the 

sensitive devices situated more than 30 m from the incoming surge arrester 

v install a surge arrester on the telecommunications network to protect the devices 

supplied, for example fire alarms, modems, telephones, faxes. 



Fig. J40 : Telecommunications network 


Main 

switchboard 

C60 

20 A 

PRD 

8 kA 

C60 

40 A 

PRD 

40 kA 

MV/LV transformer 

160 kVA 

Switchboard 1 Switchboard 

2 


ID 

"si" 

ID 

"si" 

Heating Lighting Freezer Refrigerator 

Storeroom lighting Power outlets 

Fig. J39 : Application example : supermarket 

Function of the surge arrester protection 

C60 

20 A 

PRD 

8 kA 

Fire-fighting system Alarm 

IT system Checkout 

b Conduct the lightning current to earth, ensuring a level of protection Up compatible 

with the electrical equipment to be protected. 

b Limit the rise in earth potential and the magnetic field induced. 

Cabling recommendations 

b Ensure the equipotentiality of the earth terminations of the building. 

b Reduce the looped power supply cable areas. 

Installation recommendations 

b Install a surge arrester, Imax = 40 kA (8/20 μs) and a C60 disconnection circuit 

breaker rated at 20 A. 

b Install fine protection surge arresters, Imax = 8 kA (8/20 μs) and the associated 

C60 disconnection circuit breakers rated at 20 A. 

J25 


2 

3 

4 

5 

Chapter K 

Energy Efficiency in electrical 

distribution 

Contents 

Introduction K2 

Energy efficiency and electricity K3 

2.1 The world is now ready for energy-efficient actions and programs. K3 

2.2 A new challenge: electrical data K4 

One process, several players K5 

3.1 Energy Efficiency needs an Enterprise approach K5 

3.2 Economic competitiveness study K6 

3.3 The varied profiles and missions of players in the company K8 

From electrical measurement to electrical information K 0 

4.1 Physical value acquisition K10 

4.2 Electrical data for real objectives K12 

4.3 Measurement starts with the "stand alone product" solution K13 

Communication and Information System k 6 

5.1 Communication network at product, equipment and site level 

5.2 From Network Monitoring and Control System 

K16 

to Intelligent Power Equipment K19 

5.3 e-Support becomes accessible K21 


K 



K2 

K - Energy Efficiency in electrical distribution 

Certain information in this chapter is taken 

from guides published by Carbon Trust 

(www.carbontrust.co.uk) GPG119 and GPG231. 

Introduction 

Power monitoring and control system may be of high benefice for the owner of an 

electrical network as a strategic piece in the global “Energy Efficiency” approach. 

Calculating Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of an electrical network not only includes 

the initial equipment investment but also its economic performance in operation. 

Safety staff, the electrical billing manager, the chief site electrician or the facility 

manager, are all becoming increasingly concerned. The profiles vary, but each of 

these people's mission includes careful management of electricity, its procurement 

and the network that distributes it. 

Fewer expensive power outages for the company’s business, less consumption 

wastage, no more maintenance operations than necessary, these are the objectives 

that a decision making assistance system focused on Energy Efficiency must satisfy 

and make available to each person, whatever their profile. 

Nowadays, entering the “Energy Efficiency” approach doesn’t mean setting-up a 

complex and expensive system. Some simple features are really affordable with a 

very good payback because they can be directly embedded in the power equipment. 

Once the electrical installation is equipped with measurement functions, it can share 

the communication medium of the user’s Intranet site. In addition operation won’t 

need specific skills and training. It will only require the use of license-free software 

such as Intranet browsers. 

Upgradeability or e-services through Internet are also now a reality, based on new 

technologies that come from the Office and Communication world. Then being in 

a position of taking advantages of these new possibilities will be more and more a 

differentiating behavior. 

Forecasting - Anticipation 

Extensions 

Improvement 


New Design Retrofit 

End of life 

Design installation 

Maintenance optimization 

MV 

LV 

ASI 

Sheddable Offices 

HVAC 

MV 

LV 

MLVS 1 MLVS 2 

PROCESS 

Trunking 

Operation 

e-services


2 Energy efficiency and electricity 

2.1 The world is now ready for energy-efficient 

actions and programs. 

The first big movement was initiated by the Kyoto protocol in 1997, updated in 2006. 

This well known world wide agreement requires participating countries to collectively 

reduce greenhouse gas emissions to an annual average of about 5 percent below 

the 1990 level over the 2008-2012 period. 

The protocol is based on three primary market mechanisms: 

b The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), arrangement for reductions to be 

"sponsored" in countries not bound by emission targets 

b Joint Implementation, program that allows industrialized countries to meet part 

of their required cuts in greenhouse-gas emissions by implementing projects that 

reduce emissions in other countries. 

b Emissions trading, mechanism through which Parties with emission commitments 

may trade units of their emission allowances with other Parties because they are 

ahead of their target. This is the so called “carbon market”. 

All geographic areas at country, regional and federal level have launched 

programs, actions, regulations: 

b regulations and standards enforced in Europe (Fig. K1), 

b vision and strong initiatives in Asia. 

b strong programs in the US 

Fig. K1 : European parliament and counsel directive 2006/32/CE dated 5 April 2006 relative to 

the energy efficiency for end users and energy services 

ISO 14001 that defines principles and processes to permanently reduce energy consumption 

and waste emission in any organization. 

Drivers to develop energy efficiency programs – especially on the electrical form of 

energy - are getting stronger and stronger. Energy Efficiency plan is at the top of the 

agenda for a growing number of companies: 

b Buildings are the biggest energy consumers and a priority target, 

b With cost of energy multiplied by 2 in the last 3 years, electricity saving is 

becoming a significant source of productivity gain for the industry, 

b Saving energy is now a part of the Corporate Social Responsibility commitment of 

most listed companies, 

b With production and distribution networks under increased pressure from rising 

demand and scarce resources, availability of electricity is a rising concern for 

Industry heavily impacted by the consequences of outages, 

b The residential sector is a key sector and more and more impacted. 


K 



K 


Fig. K2 : The Schneider Electric Solutions for Power & Control 

2 Energy efficiency and electricity 

2.2 A new challenge: electrical data 

All of the features of the current developments lead to the appearance of a “New 

Electrical World” in which the key considerations will be: 

b controlling risks related to power outages 

b energy yield or efficiency and control of costs: MWh price increased between 2003 

and 2006 from 30€ up to 60€ for deregulated markets in Europe 

b renewable energy 

b the environment and sustainable development. 

Electricity usage will become smarter and more rational to contribute both to the 

competitiveness of companies, their energy independence and protection of the 

environment. These new ground-rules mean that corporate decision makers have 

to implement new resources, and in particular products and services to accompany 

electricity consumers in this approach. 

In particular, the setting up of a global information system in the company will allow 

comprehensive electrical performance data to be streamed, in real time and remotely 

for (Fig. K2): 

b Predicting electrical network non-availability, 

b Recording electrical quality, 

b Optimizing consumption per building, sector, unit, workshop, site, excessive 

consumption or abnormal variations. We will therefore have all of the data required 

to make direct savings on electricity billing. End users can therefore take advantage 

of electrical network monitoring to avoid any wastage and to supply energy where it 

is really necessary. 

b Organizing electrical equipment maintenance. 

b Better purchasing of electrical energy and in certain cases, better resale. 



Fig. K3 : Step by step approach to organizing energy 

management 

Level 

4 

2 

0 

b Gain commitment 

b Identify stakeholder needs 

b Establish policy 

b Set objectives and targets 

b Prepare action plan 

b Allocate roles and 

responsabilities 

b Prioritise investments 

b Train 

b Consider business 

integration and barriers 

to implementation 

b Audit process 

b Distribute audit findings 

3 One process, several players 

3.1 Energy Efficiency needs an Enterprise approach 

An information system must be integrated in a global approach in the company. 

The following step by step approach to organizing energy management (as shown 

in figure K1) is a structured method for managing projects and achieving results. It 

can be applied to very simple as well as complex tasks and has proved itself to be 

both robust and practical. 

Refer to 6 Sigma philosophy - Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control - you 

cannot fix what you do not measure. 

Gain commitment 

In order to achieve action towards lasting energy efficiency, it is essential to gain the 

commitment of the most senior members of the management team as individuals 

and part of the corporate body. 

Understanding begins with: 

b learning about current energy consumption levels and costs 

b mapping the ways in which energy is used 

b determining the standards for efficient consumption in the organization 

b analyzing the possibilities for saving costs through reducing energy consumption 

so that realistic targets can be set 

b recognizing the environmental effects of energy consumption. 

Plan and organize 

The first step should be to produce a suitable energy policy for the organization. By 

developing and publishing such a policy, senior managers promote their commitment 

to achieving excellence in energy management. They should do this in a way that 

harnesses the culture of the organization to best effect. 

Implement 

Everyone must have some involvement in implementing the energy policy. However, 

to facilitate a structured approach, start by assigning special responsibilities to some 

individuals and groups. 

Control and monitor 

Each project should have an owner – an individual or a team with overall 

responsibility for monitoring efforts and steering it to a successful conclusion. Again 

Information System linked to electrical energy use and its impact on the core activity 

of the company will support the owner’s actions. 

Senior executives should underline the importance of projects by requiring regular 

progress reports, and by publicizing and endorsing success, which can further 

support individual motivation and commitment. 

The energy management matrix: 

Energy policy Organising Motivation Informations systems Marketing Investment 

Energy policy, action 

plan and regular review 

have commitment of top 

management as part 

of an environmental 

strategy 

Unadopted energy policy 

set by energy manager 

or senior departmental 

manager 

Get 

commitment 

Understand 

Plan and 

organize 

Implement 

Control and 

monitor 

Energy management 

fully integrated into 

management structure. 

Clear delegation of 

responsability for energy 

consumption 

Energy manager in 

post, reporting to 

ad-hoc committee, but 

line management and 

authority are unclear 

No explicit policy No energy management 

or any format delegation 

of responsibility for 

energy consumption 

Formal and informal Comprehensive system 

channels of 

sets targets, monitors 

communication regularity consumption, identifies 

exploited by energy faults, quantifies savings 

manager and energy staff and provides budget 

at all levels 

tracking 

Contact with major 

users through ad-hoc 

committee chaired by 

senior departmental 

manager 

Monitoring and targeting 

reports based on supply 

meter data. Energy unit 

has ad-doc involvement 

in budget setting 

No contact with users No information system. 

No accounting for energy 

consumption 


Marketing the value of 

energy efficiency and the 

performance of energy 

management both within 

the organisation and 

outside it 

Some ad-doc staff 

awareness training 

No promotion of energy 

efficiency 

Positive discrimination 

in favour of "green" 

schemes with detailed 

investment appraisal 

of all new-build 

and refurbishment 

opportunities 

Investment using short 

term pay back criteria 

only 

No investment in 

increasing energy 

efficiency in premises 

K 



K 


3.2 Economic competitiveness study 

Company data 00000 Automatic calculation Contributing factors Savings per Item 

Fig. K4 : Example for calculating the return on investment 


An information system on energy efficiency related to electrical usage must also 

be looked at in terms of an economic study to ensure the growth of economic 

competitiveness. 

This study basically depends on allocating financial value to electricity consumption, 

to operating losses related to the non-availability of energy and to maintenance costs 

in order to better manage the electrical installation. 

Preliminary stage: review the current situation and build a financial study 

(Figure K4). 

The need for a measurement installation is justified by the gains that this generates. 

A solution that covers the full installation represents a major improvement in the 

company’s competitiveness, but it requires the team concerned to actually use this 

capacity. 

Example : 

The figure below is an example for calculating the return on investment – available in 

Excel on www.transparentready.com. 


Savings / Investment per 

category 

Total savings or 

investment 

Background: your organisation’s characteristics 

Annual revenues 100,000,000 

Net profit (%) 10 % 

Annual work hours (hours/day x days/week x weeks/year) 1.950 hrs 

Average hourly wage (loaded rate) 75 

Annual electrical energy costs 1,000,000 

Interest rate 15 % 

Corporate tax rate 30 % 

Annual energy cost savings potential 

Reduction in energy usage (% estimated) 10 % 

Reduction in energy usage 100,000 

Reduction in demand charges 20,000 

Power factor penalties avoided 20,000 

Energy billing errors avoided 5,000 

Energy costs allocated to tenants 0 

Annual energy cost savings 145,000 

Downtime cost avoidance potential 

Number of downtime events per year 2 

Hours of downtime per event 1.5 hrs 

Hours to recovery per downtime event 2 hrs 

Employees idled per downtime event 250 

Manufacturing employees required for line start-up 10 

IS employees required for computer system recovery 2 

Reduction in equipment replacements (e.g., transformers) 25,000 

Reduction in scrapped products or parts 50,000 

Corporate profit increase 15,385 

Increase in productive work hours 56,250 

Reduction in computer system recovery hours 600 

Reduction in manufacturing line start-up costs 3,000 

Annual downtime cost avoidance 150,235 

Operations & maintenance savings potential 

Employees assigned to manually read meters 3 

Employees assigned to maintenance 2 

Employees assigned to energy data analysis 2 

Activity-based costing savings (e.g., equipment or process removal) 50,000 

Equipment maintenance savings 10,000 

Automatic meter reading 7,875 

Fewer maintenance inspections 2,250 

Fewer hours for data analysis 10,500 

Operations & maintenance savings 80,625 

Total annual gross savings potential 375,860 

Transparent Ready system investment 

Number of buildings where energy is to be managed 2 

Metering devices, main/critical feeders, per building 10 

Metering devices, non-critical feeders, per building 15 

Metering devices, simple energy usage, per building 15 

Device costs 125,000 

Software costs 15,000 

Computer equipment costs 8,000 

Installation 160,000 

Configuration 8,000 

Training 3,500 

Support contract 14,338 

Total system investment 333,838 

ROI summary 

Invested capital -333,838 

Gross annual savings 375,860 

Yearly depreciation -66,768 

Corporate tax -112,758 

Net annual savings (after taxes and depreciation) 196,334 

Payback period (before tax & dep) (in months) 11 

Payback period (after tax & dep) (in months) 20 

Net present value 324,304 

Discounted return on investment (NPV / Invested Capital) 97 %


Invest in three steps 

1- Formulate priorities 

2- Define key electrical values 

3- Select components 


Step 1 : formulate priorities 

Each industrial or tertiary site has its own requirements and a specific electrical 

distribution architecture. According to the site’s requirements, determine the 

appropriate energy efficiency applications (Figure K ): 

Objective Application 

Consumption optimization Cost allocation 


Energy usage analysis 

Pumps & fans for Industry & Infrastructure 

Pumps & fans for Buildings 

Lighting control 

Energy purchasing optimization Peak demand reduction 

Improving the efficiency of 

teams in charge of electrical 

installation operation 

Improving energy availability 

and quality 

Electricity procurement optimization 

Sub-billing 

Electrical Distribution alarming and event logging 

Electrical Distribution network remote control 

Electrical Distribution network automation 

Asset optimization Statistical analysis of equipment usage - Power Factor 

Correction 

Fig. K5 : Objective and application 

Step 2 : define key electrical values 

b once we have formulated the priorities, we can define the key electrical values to 

be included in the measurement system 

b the parameters to take into account must allow us to detect a disturbance or a 

phenomenon as soon as it appears, in other words before it has a detrimental effect 

to the electrical installation and its current consumers 

b the method includes installing an appropriate device on each feeder concerned so 

as to be as ready as possible for requirements, and another at the site installation 

head so as to have an overview. However, we also need to identify vital feeders for 

the company’s business and feeders on costly processes so as to take account of 

this information in the solution. 

Example: if the application consumes a lot of electricity and is not sensitive to quality, the 

metering system involves the appropriate measurement products. In the same way, a highly 

sensitive application in terms of energy quality requires a different type of metering product. 

Step 3 : select components 

For existing installations: some of your electrical equipment already includes 

measurement products. 

Example: protection relays often include measurement functions. You simply have to make them 

communicate via a Modbus series link to the intranet site. 

K 



K 


Profile Org Skill Role Data display When? Data format 

Security staff Site No specific technical 

electrical skills. 

Maintenance 

Manager 

Safety of people and 

property. 

Via an alarm screen 

in the central security 

station. By DECT*, GSM 

or general circulation. 

Site People management, With his team, ensuring MMS/SMS, PC on 

overall electrical network the correct technical Intranet, email. 

skills, has been in his operation in all areas 

position for 3 to 8 years, (refrigeration, air 

technician level with conditioning, electricity, 

strong decision making security, public safety 

independence. Delegates etc.). Priority is given 

electrotechnical problems to availability, he is 

to outside organizations challenged on overheads 

(e.g.: calculating and therefore on electrical 

protection settings). consumption, decides 

on the involvement of 

outside companies and 

contributes to investment 

dossiers. 

Site Manager Site Competency in corporate 

management and in 

executive management. 

EE Manager for 

a multinational 

company 

Site/HQ Buyer/ global energy 

purchasing contract 

negotiator. 

Fig. K6 : The varied profiles and missions of players in the company 


3.3 The varied profiles and missions of players in 

the company 

The setting up of an information system allows access to important data from 

electrical equipment and must involve staff with a IT and electrical knowledge profile 

which by definition is very varied in the company. (Figures K and K ). 

Example : the table below shows a few examples of the profiles in a hypermarket. There are 

others such as Facility Management staff, workshop production managers or factory production 

managers. 

Responsible for a 

profit centre. Ensures 

compliance with 

procedures by staff via a 

management chart with 

performance indicators. 

Challenged on margin 

and turnover and 

therefore on overheads. 

Responsible for the 

global energy bill for the 

company via subsidiaries 

throughout the world and 

challenges entities with 

one another. 


Rarely, on event Application order for 

planned procedures 

according to the type of 

electrical event and a 

warning to site managers 

according to a predefined 

list. 

Rarely, on event, periodic 

consultation of reports, 

frequent consultation of 

information on request. 

The data is shared with 

his team: 

- measurement screens 

with assistance as to 

possible interpretation 

(limits etc.) 

- consumption screens 

(KWh and Euro), 

- time-stamped events, 

- address book for outside 

players, 

- electrical single-line 

diagram of the site, 

drawings of electrical 

cabinets and a link to 

manufacturing notices, 

- financial report, data 

used for the investment 

dossier, 

- indicators to be filled 

in on electrical network 

performance. 

Economic report Monthly Financial aspects 

including electrical 

consumption, the link 

between the turnover 

generating business 

and electricity, the cost 

of maintenance of the 

electrical network. 

Economic report Monthly Financial features 

including electrical 

consumption for each of 

the multinational entities.


- Major faults 

- Security 

- Shop 

Digital 

inputs 


- Minor faults 

- Maintenance 

- Shop 

Communication 

Modbus 

Shop i 

PSTN 

Meters 

for kWh 

and kVAh 

- Data collection 

- Local communication to users (critical) 

- Communication to data Centre 


- kWh 

- kWh1 

- kWh2 

- kWh3 

- Tariff alarm 


- Minor faults 

- Tech. Mngr. 

- Shop 

- Finance shop 


- Shop Mngr. 

- Shop 

Fig. K7 : Example: configuration of a shopping centre with various players in place 

- Finance 

shops 

- Cost CTRL 

- Country 


WEB 

- Finance 

shops 

- Cy Mngr. 

- Country 

Data 

center 

- Tariff structure 

- Profiles Mngt 

- Bills computation 

- Compounded data 

- Report generation & mailing 

- Storage 

- kWh shops 

- Finance shops 

- All (Pulled) 

- Energy Mngr. 

- Country 

- Kwh Cy 

- Finance 

Country 

- Finance Cies 

- Cost CTRL 

- Corporate 

Country i, n shops 

- Energy 

purchaser 

- Country 

K 


K10 



4 From electrical measurement to 

electrical information 

The energy efficiency performance in terms of electricity can only be expressed in 

terms of fundamental physical measurements – voltage, current, harmonics, etc. 

These physical measurements are then reprocessed to become digital data and then 

information. 

In the raw form, data are of little use. Unfortunately, some energy managers become 

totally immersed in data and see data collection and collation as their primary task. 

To gain value from data they must be transformed into information (used to support 

the knowledge development of all those managing energy) and understanding (used 

to action energy savings). 

The operational cycle is based on four processes: data collection; data analysis; 

communication; and action (Fig. K8). These elements apply to any information 

system. The cycle works under condition that an adequate communication network 

has been set up. 

Data analysis 

(data to information) 

Fig. K8 : The operational cycle 

The data processing level results in information that can be understood by the 

recipient profile: the ability to interpret the data by the user remains a considerable 

challenge in terms of decision making. 

The data is then directly linked to loads that consume electricity – industrial process, 

lighting, air conditioning, etc. – and the service that these loads provide for the 

company – quantity of products manufactured, comfort of visitors to a supermarket, 

ambient temperature in a refrigerated room, etc. 

The information system is then ready to be used on a day to day basis by users to 

achieve energy efficiency objectives set by senior managers in the company. 

4.1 Physical value acquisition 

The quality of data starts with the measurement itself: at the right place, the right 

time and just the right amount. 

Basically, electrical measurement is based on voltage and current going through the 

conductors. These values lead to all the others: power, energy, power factor, etc. 

Firstly we will ensure consistency of the precision class of current transformers, 

voltage transformers and the precision of the measurement devices themselves. The 

precision class will be lower for higher voltages: an error in the measurement of high 

voltage for example represents a very large amount of energy. 

The total error is the quadratic sum of each error. 

2 2 2 

∑of 

error = error + error + ... + error 

Example: 

a device with an error of 2% connected on a CT ’s with an error of 2% that means: 

2 2 

∑of 

error = ( 2) + ( 2) 

= 2,828% 

That could mean a loss of 2 828 kWh for 100 000 kWh of consumption. 


Communication 

(information to 

understanding) 

Data collection 

Action 

(understanding 

to results)


A CT is defined by: 

b its transformation ratio. For example: 50/5A 

b precision class Cl. Example: Cl=0.5 generally 

b precision power in VA to supply power to 

the measurement devices on the secondary. 

Example: 1.25 VA 

b limit precision factor indicated as a factor 

applied to In before saturation. 

Example: FLP (or Fs) =10 for measurement 

devices with a precision power that is in 

conformity. 

PM700 measurement unit 



Voltage measurement 

In low voltage, the voltage measurement is directly made by the measurement 

device. When the voltage level becomes incompatible with the device capacity, for 

example in medium voltage, we have to put in voltage transformers. 

A VT (Voltage transformer) is defined by: 

b its primary voltage and secondary voltage 

b its apparent power 

b its precision class 

Current measurement 

Current measurement is made by split or closed-core CT’s placed around the phase 

and neutral conductors as appropriate. 

According to the required precision for measurement, the CT used for the protection 

relay also allows current measurement under normal conditions. 

In particular, to measure energy, we consider two objectives: 

b A contractual billing objective, e.g. between an electricity company and its client 

or even between an airport manager (sub-billing) and stores renting airport surface 

areas. In this case IEC 62053-21 for Classes 1 and 2 and IEC 62053-22 for Classes 

0.5S and 0.2S become applicable to measure active energy. 

The full measurement chain – CT, VT and measurement unit – can reach a precision 

class Cl of 1 in low voltage, Cl 0.5 in medium voltage and 0.2 in high voltage, or even 

0.1 in the future. 

b An internal cost allocation objective for the company, e.g. to break-down the 

cost of electricity for each product produced in a specific workshop. In this case of 

a precision class between 1 and 2 for the whole chain (CT, VT and measurement 

station) is sufficient. 

It is recommended to match the full measurement chain precision with actual 

measurement requirements: there is no one single universal solution, but a good 

technical and economic compromise according to the requirement to be satisfied. 

Note that the measurement precision also has a cost, to be compared with the return 

on investment that we are expecting. 

Generally gains in terms of energy efficiency are even greater when the electrical 

network has not been equipped in this way until this point. In addition, permanent 

modifications of the electrical network, according to the company’s activity, mainly 

cause us to search for significant and immediate optimizations straight away. 

Example: 

A class 1 analogue ammeter, rated 100 A, will display a measurement of +/-1 A 

at 100 A. However if it displays 2 A, the measurement is correct to within 1 A and 

therefore there is uncertainty of 50%. 

A class 1 energy measurement station such as PM710 Merlin Gerin – like all other 

Merlin Gerin Power Meter and Circuit Monitor Measurement Units – is accurate to 

1% throughout the measurement range as described in IEC standards 62053. 

Other physical measurements considerably enhance the data: 

b on/off, open/closed operating position of devices, etc. 

b energy metering impulse 

b transformer, motor temperature 

b hours operation, quantity of switching operations 

b motor load 

b UPS battery load 

b event logged equipment failures 

b etc 

4.2 Electrical data for real objectives 

Electrical data is transformed into information that is usually intended to satisfy 

several objectives: 

b It can modify the behaviour of users to manage energy wisely and finally lowers 

overall energy costs. 

b It can contribute to field staff efficiency increase 

b It can contribute to decrease the cost of Energy 

b It can contribute to save energy by understanding how it is used and how assets 

and process can be optimized to be more energy efficient 


K11 


K12 



Fig. K9 : Facility utility costs parallel the visualisation of an 

iceberg 



b It may help in optimizing and increasing the life duration of the assets associated to 

the electrical network 

b And finally it may be a master piece in increasing the productivity of the associated 

process (industrial process or even office, building management), by preventing, or 

reducing downtime, or insuring higher quality energy to the loads. 

Facility utility costs parallel the visualization of an iceberg (Fig. K9). While an iceberg 

seems large above the surface, the size is completely overwhelming beneath the 

surface. Similarly, electrical bills are brought to the surface each month when your 

power provider sends you a bill. Savings in this area are important and can be 

considerable enough to be the only justification needed for a power monitoring 

system. However, there are other less obvious yet more significant savings 

opportunities to be found below the surface if you have the right tools at your 

disposal. 

Modify the behaviour of energy users 

Using cost allocation reports, you can verify utility billing accuracy, distribute bills 

internally by department, make effective fact-based energy decisions and drive 

accountability in every level of your organization. Then providing ownership of 

electricity costs to the appropriate level in an organization, you modify the behaviour 

of users to manage energy wisely and finally lowers overall energy costs. 

Increase field staff efficiency 

One of the big challenges of field staff in charge of the electrical network is to make 

the right decision and operate in the minimum time. 

The first need of such people is then to better know what happens on the network, 

and possibly to be informed everywhere on the concerned site. 

This site-wise transparency is a key feature that enables a field staff to: 

b Understand the electrical energy flows – check that the network is correctly set-up, 

balanced, what are the main consumers, at what period of the day, or the week… 

b Understand the network behaviour – a trip on a feeder is easier to understand 

when you have access to information from downstream loads. 

b Be spontaneously informed on events, even outside the concerned site by using 

today’s mobile communication 

b Going straight forward to the right location on the site with the right spare part, and 

with the understanding of the complete picture 

b Initiate a maintenance action taking into account the real usage of a device, not too 

early and not too late 

b Therefore, providing to the electrician a way to monitor the electrical network can 

appear as a powerful mean to optimize and in certain case drastically reduce the 

cost of power. 

Here are some examples of the main usage of the simplest monitoring systems: 

b Benchmark between zones to detect abnormal consumption. 

b Track unexpected consumption. 

b Ensure that power consumption is not higher that your competitors. 

b Choose the right Power delivery contract with the Power Utility. 

b Set-up simple load-shedding just focusing on optimizing manageable loads such 

as lights. 

b Be in a position to ask for damage compensation due to non-quality delivery 

from the Power Utilities – The process has been stopped because of a sag on the 

network. 

Implementing energy efficiency projects 

The Power monitoring system will deliver information that support a complete 

energy audit of a factility. Such audit can be the way to cover not only electricity 

but also Water, Air, Gas and Steam. Measures, benchmark and normalized energy 

consumption information will tell how efficient the industrial facilities and process 

are. Appropriate action plans can then be put in place. Their scope can be as wide 

as setting up control lighting, Building automation systems, variable speed drive, 

process automation, etc. 

Optimizing the assets 

One increasing fact is that electrical network evolves more and more and then a 

recurrent question occurs : Will my network support this new evolution? 

This is typically where a Monitoring system can help the network owner in making 

the right decision. 

By its logging activity, it can archive the real use of the assets and then evaluate 

quite accurately the spare capacity of a network, or a switchboard, a transformer… 

A better use of an asset may increase its life duration. 

Monitoring systems can provide accurate information of the exact use of an asset 

and then the maintenance team can decide the appropriate maintenance operation, 

not too late, or not too early. 

In some cases also, the monitoring of harmonics can be a positive factor for the life 

duration of some assets (such as motors or transformers). 



Micrologic tripping unit for 

Masterpact 

TeSys U motor controller 



Increasing the productivity by reducing the downtime 

Downtime is the nightmare of any people in charge of an electrical network. It may 

cause dramatic loss for the company, and the pressure for powering up again in the 

minimum time – and the associated stress for the operator – is very high. 

A monitoring and control system can help reducing the downtime very efficiently. 

Without speaking of a remote control system which are the most sophisticated 

system and which may be necessary for the most demanding application, a simple 

monitoring system can already provide relevant information that will highly contribute 

in reducing the downtime: 

b Making the operator spontaneously informed, even remote, even out of the 

concerned site (Using the mobile communication such as DECT network or GSM/ 

SMS) 

b Providing a global view of the whole network status 

b Helping the identification of the faulty zone 

b Having remotely the detailed information attached to each event caught by the field 

devices (reason for trip for example) 

Then remote control of a device is a must but not necessary mandatory. In many 

cases, a visit of the faulty zone is necessary where local actions are possible. 

Increasing the productivity by improving the Energy Quality 

Some loads can be very sensitive to electricity quality, and operators may face 

unexpected situations if the Energy quality is not under control. 

Monitoring the Energy quality is then an appropriate way to prevent such event and / 

or to fix specific issue. 

4.3 Measurement starts with the “stand alone 

product” solution 

The choice of measurement products in electrical equipment is made according to 

your energy efficiency priorities and also current technological advances: 

b measurement and protection functions of the LV or MV electrical network are 

integrated in the same device, 

Example: Sepam metering and protection relays, Micrologic tripping unit for 

Masterpact, TeSys U motor controller, NRC12 capacitor bank controller, Galaxy 

UPSs 

b the measurement function is in the device, separate from the protection function, 

e.g. built on board the LV circuit breaker. 

Example: PowerLogic Circuit Monitor high performance metering unit 

The progress made in real time industrial electronics and IT are used in a single 

device: 

b to meet requirements for simplification of switchboards 

b to reduce acquisition costs and reduce the number of devices 

b to facilitate product developments by software upgrade procedures 


K13 


K14 



Examples Power Meter, Circuit 

Monitor 

Keep control over power consumption 

Measurement units MV protection and 

measurement relays 

Below we give examples of measurements available via Modbus, RS485 or Ethernet 

Fig. K10: 

LV protection and 

measurement relays 

SEPAM Masterpact & 

Compact Micrologic 

trip units 


Capacitor bank 

regulators 

Insulation monitors 

Varlogic Vigilohm System 

Power, inst., max., min. b b b b - 

Energy, reset capability b b b - - 

Power factor, inst. b b b - - 

Cos φ inst. - - - b - 

Improve power supply availability 

Current, inst., max., min., unbalance b b b b - 

Current, wave form capture b b b - - 

Voltage, inst., max., min., unbalance b b b b - 

Voltage, wave form capture b b b - - 

Device status b b b b - 

Faults history b b b - - 

Frequency, inst., max., min. b b b - - 

THDu, THDi b b b b - 

Manage electrical installation better 

Load temperature, load and device 

thermal state 

b b - b - 

Insulating resistance - - - - b 

Motor controllers LV speeddrives LV softstarters MV softstarters UPSs 

Examples TeSys U ATV.1 ATS.8 Motorpact RVSS Galaxy 

Keep control over power consumption 

Power, inst., max., min. - b - b b 

Energy, reset capability - b b b - 

Power factor, inst. - - b b b 

Improve power supply availability 

Current, inst., max., min., unbalance b b b b b 

Current, wave form capture - - - b b 

Device status b b b b b 

Faults history b b b b - 

THDu, THDi - b - - - 

Manage electrical installation better 

Load temperature, load and device 

thermal state 

b b b b b 

Motor running hours - b b b - 

Battery follow up - - - - b 

Fig. K10 : Examples of measurements available via Modbus, RS485 or Ethernet 


electrical information


Fig. K11 : Example of electrical network protected and 

monitored via the Intranet site 

Fig. K12 : A Test to stop all lighting B Test to stop air conditioning 

Here consumption during non-working hours seems excessive, consequently two decisions were taken: 

b reducing night time lighting 

b stopping air conditioning during weekends 

The new curve obtained shows a significant drop in consumption. 



Example of solutions for a medium-sized site: 

Analysesample Ltd. is a company specialized in analyzing industrial samples from 

regional factories: metals, plastics, etc., to certify their chemical characteristics. 

The company wants to carry out better control of its electrical consumption for the 

existing electrical furnaces, its air conditioning system and to ensure quality of 

electrical supply for high-precision electronic devices used to analyze the samples. 

Electrical network protected and monitored via the Intranet site 

The solution implemented involves recovering power data via metering units that 

also allows measurement of basic electrical parameters as well as verification of 

energy power quality. Connected to a web server, an Internet browser allows to use 

them very simply and export data in a Microsoft Excel type spreadsheet. Power 

curves can be plotted in real time by the spreadsheet (Fig. K11). 

Therefore no IT investment, either in software or hardware, is necessary to use the 

data. 

For example to reduce the electricity bill and limit consumption during nighttime 

and weekends, we have to study trend curves supplied by the measurement units 

(Fig. K12). 


K15 


K16 



5 Communication and Information 

System 

Most organisations will already have some level of energy information system, even 

if it is not identified or managed as one. It should be appreciated that in a changing 

working world, any information system will need to develop to meet its prime 

objective - supporting management decision making: a key point is to make the 

energy information visible at any level of the organization through the communication 

infrastructure. 

Energy data is important data, it is one of the company’s assets. The company has 

IT managers who are already in charge of managing its other IT systems. These 

are important players in the power monitoring system and above all in that for data 

exchange within the corporate organization. 

5.1 Communication network at product, equipment 

and site level 

The day-to-day working of the energy information system can be illustrated by a 

closed loop diagram (Fig. K13). 

Modbus* 

Data 

* Communication network 

Fig. K13 : System hierarchy 

Various resources are used to send data from metering and protection devices 

installed in the user’s electrical cabinets, e.g. via Schneider ElectricTransparent 

Ready. 

The Modbus communication protocol 

Modbus is an industrial messaging protocol between equipment that is 

interconnected via a physical transmission link e.g. RS 485 or Ethernet (via TCP/IP) 

or modem (GSM, Radio etc). This protocol is very widely implemented on metering 

and protection products for electrical networks. 

Initially created by Schneider Electric, Modbus is now a public resource managed 

by an independent organization Modbus-IDA – enabling total opening up of its 

specification. An industrial standard since 1979, Modbus allows millions of products 

to communicate with one another. 

The IETF, international authority managing the Internet, has approved the creation 

of a port (502) for products connected to the Internet/Intranet and using the Ethernet 

Modbus TCP/IP communication protocol. 

Modbus is a query/reply process between two pieces of equipment based on data 

reading and writing services (function codes). 

The query is emitted by a single “master”, the reply is sent only by the “slave” 

equipment identified in the query (Fig. K14). 

Each “slave” product connected to the Modbus network is set by the user with an ID 

number, called the Modbus address, between 1 and 247. 

The “master” – for example a web server included in an electrical cabinet 

– simultaneously queries all of the products with a message comprising its target’s 

address, function code, memory location in the product and quantity of information, 

at most 253 octets. 

Only a product set with the corresponding address answers the request for data. 

Exchange is only carried out on the initiative of the master (here the web server): this 

is the master-slave Modbus operating procedure. 


Intranet* 

Information 

Communicating 

measurement device* 

Energy information systems 

Understanding



System 

This query procedure followed by a reply, implies that the master will have all of the 

data available in a product when it is queried. 

The “master” manages all of the transaction queries successively if they are intended 

for the same product. This arrangement leads to the calculation of a maximum 

number of products connected to the master to optimize an acceptable response 

time for the query initiator, particularly when it is a low rate RS485 link. 

Fig. K14 : The function codes allow writing or reading of data. 

A transmission error software detection mechanism called CRC16 allows a message with an 

error to be repeated and only the product concerned to respond. 

Your Intranet network 

Data exchange from industrial data basically uses web technologies implemented 

permanently on the corporate communication network, and more particularly on its 

Intranet. 

The IT infrastructure manages the cohabitation of software applications: the 

company uses it to operate applications for the office, printing, data backup, for the 

corporate IT system, accounting, purchasing, ERP, production facility control, API, 

MES, etc. The cohabitation of data on the same communication network does not 

pose any particular technological problem. 

When several PC’s, printers and servers are connected to one another in the 

company’s buildings, very probably using the Ethernet local network and web 

services: this company is then immediately eligible to have energy efficiency data 

delivered by its electrical cabinets. Without any software development, all they need 

is an Microsoft Internet Explorer type Internet browser. 

The data from these applications cross the local broadband Ethernet network up to 

1 Gb/s: the communication media generally used in this world is copper or optic fiber, 

which allows connection everywhere, in commercial or industrial buildings and in 

electrical premises. 

If the company also has an internal Intranet communication network for emailing 

and sharing web servers data, it uses an extremely common standardized 

communication protocol: TCP/IP. 

The TCP/IP communication protocol is designed for widely used web services such 

as HTTP to access web pages, SMTP for electronic messaging between other 

services. 

Applications SNMP NTP RTPS DHCP TFTP FTP HTTP SMTP Modbus 

Transport UDP TCP 

Link IP 

Physical Ethernet 802.3 and Ethernet II 


K17 


K18 




System 

Electrical data recorded in industrial web servers installed in electrical cabinets are 

sent using the same standardized TCP/IP protocol in order to limit the recurrent IT 

maintenance costs that are intrinsic in an IT network. This is the operating principle 

of Schneider Electric Transparent Ready TM for communication of data on energy 

efficiency. The electrical cabinet is autonomous without the need for any additional 

IT system on a PC, all of the data related to energy efficiency is recorded and can be 

circulated in the usual way via the intranet, GSM, fixed telephone link, etc. 

Security 

Employees that are well informed, more efficient and working in complete electrical 

safety: they no longer need to go into electrical rooms or make standard checks 

on electrical devices - they just have to consult data. Under these conditions, 

communicative systems give the company’s employees immediate and significant 

gains and avoid worrying about making mistakes. 

It becomes possible for electricians, maintenance or production technicians, on-site 

or visiting managers to work together in complete safety. 

According to the sensitivity of data, the IT manager will simply give users the 

appropriate access rights. 

Marginal impact on local network maintenance 

The company’s IT manager has technical resources to add and monitor equipment 

to the local company network. 

Based on standard web services including the Modbus protocol on TCP/IP, and 

due to the low level of bandwidth requirement characteristic in electrical network 

monitoring systems as well as the use of technologies that are not impacted by 

viruses and worldwide IT standards, the IT manager does not have to make any 

specific investment to preserve the local network performance level or to protect 

against any additional security problems (virus, hacking, etc.). 

Empowering external partners 

According to the company’s security policy, it becomes possible to use support 

services of the usual partners in the electrical sector: contractors, utilities managers, 

panelbuilders, systems integrators or Schneider Electric Services can provide 

remote assistance and electrical data analysis to the company consuming electricity. 

The messaging web service can regularly send data by email or web pages can be 

remotely consulted using the appropriate techniques. 



Function 

levels 


purpose 

site 

monitoring 

Specialised 

network 

monitoring 

Basic 

monitoring 

1 

Eqt server 

Intelligent 

Power 

Equipment 

Web 

browser 

standard 

Other 

utilities 

Fig. K15 : Monitoring system positioning 

2 

Eqt server 

Power 

Equipment 


System 

5.2 From Network Monitoring and Control System to 

Intelligent Power Equipment 

Traditionally and for years, monitoring and control systems have been centralized 

and based on SCADA (Supervisory, Control and Data acquisition) automation 

systems. 

Deciding on investing in such system – noted (3) in Figure K15 – was really 

reserved for high demanding installation, because either they were big power 

consumers, or their process was very sensitive to Power non quality. 

Based on automation technology, such systems were very often designed, 

customised by a system integrator, and then delivered on site. However the initial 

cost, the skills needed to correctly operate such system, and the cost of upgrades to 

follow the evolutions of the network may have discouraged potential users to invest. 

Then based on a dedicated solution for electrician, the other approach noted (2) 

is much more fitting the electrical network specific needs and really increases the 

payback of such system. However, due to its centralised architecture, the level cost 

of such solution may still appear high. 

On some sites Type (2) and (3) can cohabit, providing the most accurate information 

to the electrician when needed. 

Nowadays, a new concept of intelligent Power equipment – noted (1) – has come. 

considered as an entering step for going to level 2 or 3, due the ability of these 

solutions to co-exist on a site. 

Specialised 

monitoring 

such as 

Power Logic 

SMS 

Eqt gateway 

Power 

Equipment 


3 

Other 

utilities Process 

Standard network Sensitive electrical networks High demanding sites 


purpose 

monitoring 

system 

System 

complexity 

K19 


K20 




System 

Intelligent equipment based architecture (see Fig. K16) 

This new architecture has appeared recently due to Web technology capabilities, and 

can really be positioned as an entry point into monitoring systems. 

Based on Web technologies it takes the maximum benefits of standard 

communication services and protocols, and license-free software. 

The access to electricity information can be done from everywhere in the site, and 

electrical staff can gain a lot in efficiency. 

Openness to the Internet is also offered for out of the site services. 

Standard remote 

Web browser 

Internet 

Equipment server 

Gateway 

Electrician specialized centralised architecture (see Fig. K17) 

Dedicated to electrician, this architecture is based on a specific supervision 

centralised mean that fully match the needs for monitoring an electrical network. 

Then it offers naturally a lower level of skill to set up and maintain it – all Electrical 

Distribution devices are already present in a dedicated library. Finally its purchase 

cost is really minimized, due the low level of system integrator effort. 

Fig. K17 : ED specialist monitoring system 


1 2 3 

Circuit breakers 

Fig. K16 : Intelligent equipment architecture 

Gateway 

1 2 3 


Modbus 

Standard local 

Web browser 

Intranet (Ethernet/IP) 

Modbus 

Meter 1 

Dedicated supervisor 

for electrician 

Modbus (SL or Ethernet/IP) 

Intelligence Power Equipment 

Meter 2 Meter 3 

Communicating Power Equipment 

Meter 1 Meter 2 Meter 3



System 

Conventional general purpose centralised architecture (see Fig. K18) 

Here is a typical architecture based on standard automation pieces such as SCADA 

systems, and gateways. 

Despite its real efficiency, such architecture suffered from some drawbacks such as : 

b The level of skills needed to operate it 

b The poor upgradability 

b And at the end the risky payback of such solutions 

They have however no equivalent for high demanding sites, and appears very 

relevant for central operation rooms. 

Gateway 

1 2 3 


Fig. K18 : Real-time conventional monitoring and control system 

5.3 e-Support becomes accessible 

The setting up of an information system to support a global energy efficiency 

approach very quickly leads to economic gains, in general with an ROI of less than 2 

years for electricity. 

An additional benefit, that is still underestimated today, is the leverage that this leads 

to in terms of information technologies in the electrical sector. The electrical network 

can be analyzed from time to time by third parties – in particular using external 

competencies via the internet for very specific issues: 

b Electricity supply contracts. Changing of supplier at a given point in time, e.g. 

permanent economic analysis of the costs related to consumption becomes possible 

without having to wait for an annual review. 

b Total management of electrical data – via internet – to transform it into relevant 

information that is fed back via a personalized web portal. Consumer usage 

information is now a value-added commodity, available to a wide range of users. It's 

easy to post customer usage data on the Internet – making it useful to the users is 

another matter. 

b Complex electrical fault diagnosis to call in an electrotechnical expert, a rare 

resource that is easily accessible on the web. 

b Monitoring of consumption and generating alerts in the case of abnormal 

consumption peaks. 

b A maintenance service that is no more than necessary to meet pressure on 

overheads via facility management services. 

Energy efficiency is no longer an issue that the company has to face on its own, 

many e-partners can back up the approach as necessary – in particular when the 

measurement and decision making assistance stage is reached, on condition that 

the electrical network is metered and communicative via internet. 

Implementation can be gradual starting by making a few key pieces of equipment 

communicative and gradually extending the system so as to be more accurate or to 

give wider coverage of the installation. 


Modbus 

Conventional 

supervisor 

Modbus (SL or Ethernet/IP) 

Communicating Power Equipment 

Meter 1 Meter 2 Meter 3 

K21 


K22 




System 

The company can choose its policy: ask one or more partners to analyze the data, 

do it itself or combine these options. 

The company may decide to manage its electrical energy itself, or ask a partner to 

monitor the quality to ensure active monitoring of performances in terms of aging. 

Example: 

Schneider Electric proposes e-Services that offers load data visualization and analysis 

application in ASP mode. It simplifies processes for tenants with geographically diverse locations 

by providing convenient integrated billing and usage information for all locations combined. 

The system turns customer usage data into useful information, easily accessible to all internal 

users. It helps control costs by showing customers how their organizations use power. 

A wide range of functionality serves the needs of staff from the same platform: 

Data Access and Analysis , Historical and Estimated Bills, Rate Comparison, What-if Analysis 

- Assess the impact of operational changes, such as shifting energy between time periods or 

reducing usage by fixed amounts or percentages, Automatic Alarming, Memorized Reports, 

Benchmarking - Benchmark usage data from multiple facilities by applying normalization factors 

such as square footage, operating hours, and units of production. Multiple Commodities - Access 

usage data for gas and water as well as electricity etc. 

New York Chicago Los Angeles Seattle 

Ethernet/VPN Ethernet/VPN 

Reports 

Fig. K19 : Typical solution exemple 

Electricity 

Water & Gas 

Power Quality 


WEB 

Energy Cost 

Analysis 

Normalize data using: 

- Temperature 

- Occupancy rates 

- Rooms 

- Other parameters 

WEB 

XML 

Corporate 

Database 

ODBC 

Weather info 

Utility tariffs & rates 

Real-time pricing 

Stores data including: 

- Occupancy rates 

- Square footage 

- Other parameters

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

0 

Chapter L 

Power factor correction and 


Contents 

Reactive energy and power factor L2 

1.1 The nature of reactive energy L2 

1.2 Equipment and appliances requiring reactive energy L2 

1.3 The power factor L3 

1.4 Practical values of power factor L4 

Why to improve the power factor? L5 

2.1 Reduction in the cost of electricity L5 

2.2 Technical/economic optimization L5 

How to improve the power factor? L7 

3.1 Theoretical principles L7 

3.2 By using what equipment? L7 

3.3 The choice between a fixed or automatically-regulated bank L9 

of capacitors 

Where to install power factor correction capacitors? L 0 

4.1 Global compensation L10 

4.2 Compensation by sector L10 

4.3 Individual compensation L11 

How to decide the optimum level of compensation? L 2 

5.1 General method L12 

5.2 Simplified method L12 

5.3 Method based on the avoidance of tariff penalties L14 

5.4 Method based on reduction of declared maximum apparent 

power (kVA) L14 

Compensation at the terminals of a transformer L 5 

6.1 Compensation to increase the available active power output L15 

6.2 Compensation of reactive energy absorbed by the transformer L16 

Power factor correction of induction motors L 8 

7.1 Connection of a capacitor bank and protection settings L18 

7.2 How self-excitation of an induction motor can be avoided L19 

Example of an installation before and L20 

after power-factor correction 

The effects of harmonics L2 

9.1 Problems arising from power-system harmonics L21 

9.2 Possible solutions L21 

9.3 Choosing the optimum solution L23 

Implementation of capacitor banks L24 

10.1 Capacitor elements L24 

10.2 Choice of protection, control devices and connecting cables L25 


L 



L2 

L - Power factor correction and 


Alternating current systems supply two forms of 

energy: 

b “Active” energy measured in kilowatt hours 

(kWh) which is converted into mechanical work, 

heat, light, etc 

b “Reactive” energy, which again takes two 

forms: 

v “Reactive” energy required by inductive 

circuits (transformers, motors, etc.), 

v “Reactive” energy supplied by capacitive 

circuits (cable capacitance, power capacitors, 

etc) 

Fig. L2 : Power consuming items that also require reactive 

energy 

Reactive energy and power 

factor 

. The nature of reactive energy 

All inductive (i.e. electromagnetic) machines and devices that operate on AC systems 

convert electrical energy from the power system generators into mechanical work 

and heat. This energy is measured by kWh meters, and is referred to as “active” 

or “wattful” energy. In order to perform this conversion, magnetic fields have to be 

established in the machines, and these fields are associated with another form of 

energy to be supplied from the power system, known as “reactive” or “wattless” 

energy. 

The reason for this is that inductive circuit cyclically absorbs energy from the system 

(during the build-up of the magnetic fields) and re-injects that energy into the system 

(during the collapse of the magnetic fields) twice in every power-frequency cycle. 

An exactly similar phenomenon occurs with shunt capacitive elements in a power 

system, such as cable capacitance or banks of power capacitors, etc. In this case, 

energy is stored electrostatically. The cyclic charging and discharging of capacitive 

circuit reacts on the generators of the system in the same manner as that described 

above for inductive circuit, but the current flow to and from capacitive circuit in exact 

phase opposition to that of the inductive circuit. This feature is the basis on which 

power factor correction schemes depend. 

It should be noted that while this “wattless” current (more accurately, the “wattless” 

component of a load current) does not draw power from the system, it does cause 

power losses in transmission and distribution systems by heating the conductors. 

In practical power systems, “wattless” components of load currents are invariably 

inductive, while the impedances of transmission and distribution systems are 

predominantly inductively reactive. The combination of inductive current passing 

through an inductive reactance produces the worst possible conditions of voltage 

drop (i.e. in direct phase opposition to the system voltage). 

For these reasons (transmission power losses and voltage drop), the power-supply 

authorities reduce the amount of “wattless” (inductive) current as much as possible. 

“Wattless” (capacitive) currents have the reverse effect on voltage levels and produce 

voltage-rises in power systems. 

The power (kW) associated with “active” energy is usually represented by the letter P. 

The reactive power (kvar) is represented by Q. Inductively-reactive power is 

conventionally positive (+ Q) while capacitively-reactive power is shown as a 

negative quantity (- Q). 

The apparent power S (kVA) is a combination of P and Q (see Fig. L ). 

Sub-clause 1.3 shows the relationship between P, Q, and S. 

Q 

(kvar) 


S 

(kVA) 

P 

(kW) 

Fig. L1 : An electric motor requires active power P and reactive power Q from the power system 

.2 Equipement and appliances requiring reactive 

energy 

All AC equipement and appliances that include electromagnetic devices, or depend 

on magnetically-coupled windings, require some degree of reactive current to create 

magnetic flux. 

The most common items in this class are transformers and reactors, motors and 

discharge lamps (with magnetic ballasts) (see Fig. L2). 

The proportion of reactive power (kvar) with respect to active power (kW) when an 

item of equipement is fully loaded varies according to the item concerned being: 

b 65-75% for asynchronous motors 

b 5-10% for transformers



The power factor is the ratio of kW to kVA. 

The closer the power factor approaches its 

maximum possible value of 1, the greater the 

benefit to consumer and supplier. 

PF = P (kW) / S (kVA) 

P = Active power 

S = Apparent power 


factor 

.3 The power factor 

Definition of power factor 

The power factor of a load, which may be a single power-consuming item, or a 

number of items (for example an entire installation), is given by the ratio of P/S i.e. 

kW divided by kVA at any given moment. 

The value of a power factor will range from 0 to 1. 

If currents and voltages are perfectly sinusoidal signals, power factor equals cos ϕ. 

A power factor close to unity means that the reactive energy is small compared with 

the active energy, while a low value of power factor indicates the opposite condition. 

Power vector diagram 

b Active power P (in kW) 

v Single phase (1 phase and neutral): P = V I cos ϕ 

v Single phase (phase to phase): P = U I cos ϕ 

v Three phase (3 wires or 3 wires + neutral): P = 3U I cos ϕ 

b Reactive power Q (in kvar) 

v Single phase (1 phase and neutral): P = V I sin ϕ 

v Single phase (phase to phase): Q = U I sin ϕ 

v Three phase (3 wires or 3 wires + neutral): P = 3 U I sin ϕ 

b Apparent power S (in kVA) 

v Single phase (1 phase and neutral): S = V I 

v Single phase (phase to phase): S = U I 

v Three phase (3 wires or 3 wires + neutral): P = 3 U I 

where: 

V = Voltage between phase and neutral 

U = Voltage between phases 

I = Line current 

ϕ = Phase angle between vectors V and I. 

v For balanced and near-balanced loads on 4-wire systems 

Current and voltage vectors, and derivation of the power diagram 

The power “vector” diagram is a useful artifice, derived directly from the true rotating 

vector diagram of currents and voltage, as follows: 

The power-system voltages are taken as the reference quantities, and one phase 

only is considered on the assumption of balanced 3-phase loading. 

The reference phase voltage (V) is co-incident with the horizontal axis, and the 

current (I) of that phase will, for practically all power-system loads, lag the voltage by 

an angle ϕ. 

The component of I which is in phase with V is the “wattful” component of I and is 

equal to I cos ϕ, while VI cos ϕ equals the active power (in kW) in the circuit, if V is 

expressed in kV. 

The component of I which lags 90 degrees behind V is the wattless component of 

I and is equal to I sin ϕ, while VI sin ϕ equals the reactive power (in kvar) in the 

circuit, if V is expressed in kV. 

If the vector I is multiplied by V, expressed in kV, then VI equals the apparent power 

(in kVA) for the circuit. 

The simple formula is obtained: S 2 = P 2 + Q 2 

The above kW, kvar and kVA values per phase, when multiplied by 3, can therefore 

conveniently represent the relationships of kVA, kW, kvar and power factor for a total 

3-phase load, as shown in Figure L3 . 


ϕ 

Fig. L3 : Power diagram 

Q = VI sin ϕ (kvar) 

P = VI cos ϕ (kW) 

S = VI (kVA) 

V 

P = Active power 

Q = Reactive power 

S = Apparent power 

L3 



L4 



ϕ 

P = 56 kW 

S = 65 kVA 

Fig. L5 : Calculation power diagram 

Q = 33 kvar 


factor 

An example of power calculations (see Fig. L4 ) 

Type of Apparent power Active power Reactive power 

circuit S (kVA) P (kW) Q (kvar) 

Single-phase (phase and neutral) S = VI P = VI cos ϕ Q = VI sin ϕ 

Single-phase (phase to phase) S = UI P = UI cos ϕ Q = UI sin ϕ 

Example 5 kW of load 10 kVA 5 kW 8.7 kvar 

cos ϕ = 0.5 

Three phase 3-wires or 3-wires + neutral S = 3 UI P = 3 UI cos ϕ Q = 3 UI sin ϕ 

Example Motor Pn = 51 kW 65 kVA 56 kW 33 kvar 

cos ϕ = 0.86 

ρ = 0.91 (motor efficiency) 

Fig. L4 : Example in the calculation of active and reactive power 

.4 Practical values of power factor 

The calculations for the three-phase example above are as follows: 

Pn = delivered shaft power = 51 kW 

P = active power consumed 

P = Pn 

ρ 

51 

= = 

0. 91 

56 kW 

S = apparent power 

S = P 56 

= = 6 5 kVA 

cos ϕ 0. 86 

So that, on referring to diagram Figure L5 or using a pocket calculator, the value of 

tan ϕ corresponding to a cos ϕ of 0.86 is found to be 0.59 

Q = P tan ϕ = 56 x 0.59 = 33 kvar (see Figure L15). 

Alternatively 

2 2 2 2 

Q = S -P = 65 - 56 = 33 kvar 

Average power factor values for the most commonly-used equipment and 

appliances (see Fig. L6) 

Equipment and appliances cos ϕ tan ϕ 

b Common loaded at 0% 0.17 5.80 

induction motor 25% 0.55 1.52 

50% 0.73 0.94 

75% 0.80 0.75 

100% 0.85 0.62 

b Incandescent lamps 1.0 0 

b Fluorescent lamps (uncompensated) 0.5 1.73 

b Fluorescent lamps (compensated) 0.93 0.39 

b Discharge lamps 0.4 to 0.6 2.29 to 1.33 

b Ovens using resistance elements 1.0 0 

b Induction heating ovens (compensated) 0.85 0.62 

b Dielectric type heating ovens 0.85 0.62 

b Resistance-type soldering machines 0.8 to 0.9 0.75 to 0.48 

b Fixed 1-phase arc-welding set 0.5 1.73 

b Arc-welding motor-generating set 0.7 to 0.9 1.02 to 0.48 

b Arc-welding transformer-rectifier set 0.7 to 0.8 1.02 to 0.75 

b Arc furnace 0.8 0.75 

Fig. L6 : Values of cos ϕ and tan ϕ for commonly-used equipment 




An improvement of the power factor of an 

installation presents several technical and 

economic advantages, notably in the reduction 

of electricity bills 

Power factor improvement allows the use of 

smaller transformers, switchgear and cables, 

etc. as well as reducing power losses and 

voltage drop in an installation 

2 Why to improve the power 

factor? 

2.1 Reduction in the cost of electricity 

Good management in the consumption of reactive energy brings economic 

advantages. 

These notes are based on an actual tariff structure commonly applied in Europe, 

designed to encourage consumers to minimize their consumption of reactive energy. 

The installation of power-factor correction capacitors on installations permits the 

consumer to reduce his electricity bill by maintaining the level of reactive-power 

consumption below a value contractually agreed with the power supply authority. 

In this particular tariff, reactive energy is billed according to the tan ϕ criterion. 

As previously noted: 

tan ϕ = 

Q (kvarh) 

P (kWh) 

The power supply authority delivers reactive energy for free: 

b If the reactive energy represents less than 40% of the active energy (tan ϕ < 0.4) 

for a maximum period of 16 hours each day (from 06-00 h to 22-00 h) during the 

most-heavily loaded period (often in winter) 

b Without limitation during light-load periods in winter, and in spring and summer. 

During the periods of limitation, reactive energy consumption exceeding 40% of 

the active energy (i.e. tan ϕ > 0.4) is billed monthly at the current rates. Thus, the 

quantity of reactive energy billed in these periods will be: 

kvarh (to be billed) = kWh (tan ϕ > 0.4) where: 

v kWh is the active energy consumed during the periods of limitation 

v kWh tan ϕ is the total reactive energy during a period of limitation 

v 0.4 kWh is the amount of reactive energy delivered free during a period of 

limitation 

tan ϕ = 0.4 corresponds to a power factor of 0.93 so that, if steps are taken to ensure 

that during the limitation periods the power factor never falls below 0.93, 

the consumer will have nothing to pay for the reactive power consumed. 

Against the financial advantages of reduced billing, the consumer must balance 

the cost of purchasing, installing and maintaining the power factor improvement 

capacitors and controlling switchgear, automatic control equipment (where stepped 

levels of compensation are required) together with the additional kWh consumed by 

the dielectric losses of the capacitors, etc. It may be found that it is more economic 

to provide partial compensation only, and that paying for some of the reactive energy 

consumed is less expensive than providing 100% compensation. 

The question of power-factor correction is a matter of optimization, except in very 

simple cases. 

2.2 Technical/economic optimization 

A high power factor allows the optimization of the components of an installation. 

Overating of certain equipment can be avoided, but to achieve the best results, the 

correction should be effected as close to the individual inductive items as possible. 

Reduction of cable size 

Figure L7 shows the required increase in the size of cables as the power factor is 

reduced from unity to 0.4, for the same active power transmitted. 


Multiplying factor 1 1.25 1.67 2.5 

for the cross-sectional 

area of the cable core(s) 

cos ϕ 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 

Fig. L7 : Multiplying factor for cable size as a function of cos ϕ 

L 



L 



(1) Since other benefits are obtained from a high value of 

power factor, as previously noted. 

2 Why to improve the power 

factor? 

Reduction of losses (P, kW) in cables 

Losses in cables are proportional to the current squared, and are measured by the 

kWh meter of the installation. Reduction of the total current in a conductor by 10% for 

example, will reduce the losses by almost 20%. 

Reduction of voltage drop 

Power factor correction capacitors reduce or even cancel completely the (inductive) 

reactive current in upstream conductors, thereby reducing or eliminating voltage 

drops. 

Note: Over compensation will produce a voltage rise at the capacitor level. 

Increase in available power 

By improving the power factor of a load supplied from a transformer, the current 

through the transformer will be reduced, thereby allowing more load to be added. In 

practice, it may be less expensive to improve the power factor (1) , than to replace the 

transformer by a larger unit. 

This matter is further elaborated in clause 6. 




Improving the power factor of an installation 

requires a bank of capacitors which acts as a 

source of reactive energy. This arrangement is 

said to provide reactive energy compensation 

a) Reactive current components only flow pattern 

IL - IC IC IL IL 

C L 

Load 

b) When IC = IL, all reactive power is supplied from the 

capacitor bank 

IL - IC = 0 IC IL IL 

C L 

c) With load current added to case (b) 

Load 

IR IC IR + IL IL IR 

C L 

Load 

Fig. L8 : Showing the essential features of power-factor 

correction 

ϕ' 

ϕ 

Qc 

Fig. L9 : Diagram showing the principle of compensation: 

Qc = P (tan ϕ - tan ϕ’) 

S' 

S 

Q' 

P 

R 

R 

R 

Q 

3 How to improve the power factor? 

3.1 Theoretical principles 

An inductive load having a low power factor requires the generators and 

transmission/distribution systems to pass reactive current (lagging the system 

voltage by 90 degrees) with associated power losses and exaggerated voltage 

drops, as noted in sub-clause 1.1. If a bank of shunt capacitors is added to the 

load, its (capacitive) reactive current will take the same path through the power 

system as that of the load reactive current. Since, as pointed out in sub-clause 

1.1, this capacitive current Ic (which leads the system voltage by 90 degrees) is 

in direct phase opposition to the load reactive current (IL), the two components 

flowing through the same path will cancel each other, such that if the capacitor bank 

is sufficiently large and Ic = IL there will be no reactive current flow in the system 

upstream of the capacitors. 

This is indicated in Figure L8 (a) and (b) which show the flow of the reactive 

components of current only. 

In this figure: 

R represents the active-power elements of the load 

L represents the (inductive) reactive-power elements of the load 

C represents the (capacitive) reactive-power elements of the power-factor correction 

equipment (i.e. capacitors). 

It will be seen from diagram (b) of Figure L9, that the capacitor bank C appears 

to be supplying all the reactive current of the load. For this reason, capacitors are 

sometimes referred to as “generators of lagging vars”. 

In diagram (c) of Figure L9, the active-power current component has been added, 

and shows that the (fully-compensated) load appears to the power system as having 

a power factor of 1. 

In general, it is not economical to fully compensate an installation. 

Figure L9 uses the power diagram discussed in sub-clause 1.3 (see Fig. L3) to 

illustrate the principle of compensation by reducing a large reactive power Q to a 

smaller value Q’ by means of a bank of capacitors having a reactive power Qc. 

In doing so, the magnitude of the apparent power S is seen to reduce to S’. 

Example: 

A motor consumes 100 kW at a power factor of 0.75 (i.e. tan ϕ = 0.88). To improve 

the power factor to 0.93 (i.e. tan ϕ = 0.4), the reactive power of the capacitor bank 

must be : Qc = 100 (0.88 - 0.4) = 48 kvar 

The selected level of compensation and the calculation of rating for the capacitor 

bank depend on the particular installation. The factors requiring attention are 

explained in a general way in clause 5, and in clauses 6 and 7 for transformers and 

motors. 

Note: Before starting a compensation project, a number of precautions should be 

observed. In particular, oversizing of motors should be avoided, as well as the noload 

running of motors. In this latter condition, the reactive energy consumed by a 

motor results in a very low power factor (≈ 0.17); this is because the kW taken by the 

motor (when it is unloaded) are very small. 

3.2 By using what equipment? 

Compensation at LV 

At low voltage, compensation is provided by: 

b Fixed-value capacitor 

b Equipment providing automatic regulation, or banks which allow continuous 

adjustment according to requirements, as loading of the installation changes 

Note: When the installed reactive power of compensation exceeds 800 kvar, and the 

load is continuous and stable, it is often found to be economically advantageous to 

instal capacitor banks at the medium voltage level. 


L 



L8 



Compensation can be carried out by a 

fixed value of capacitance in favourable 

circumstances 

Compensation is more-commonly effected by 

means of an automatically-controlled stepped 

bank of capacitors 


Fixed capacitors (see Fig. L10) 

This arrangement employs one or more capacitor(s) to form a constant level of 

compensation. Control may be: 

b Manual: by circuit-breaker or load-break switch 

b Semi-automatic: by contactor 

b Direct connection to an appliance and switched with it 

These capacitors are applied: 

b At the terminals of inductive devices (motors and transformers) 

b At busbars supplying numerous small motors and inductive appliance for which 

individual compensation would be too costly 

b In cases where the level of load is reasonably constant 

Fig. L10 : Example of fixed-value compensation capacitors 

Automatic capacitor banks (see Fig. L11) 

This kind of equipment provides automatic control of compensation, maintaining the 

power factor within close limits around a selected level. Such equipment is applied at 

points in an installation where the active-power and/or reactive-power variations are 

relatively large, for example: 

b At the busbars of a general power distribution board 

b At the terminals of a heavily-loaded feeder cable 

Fig. L11 : Example of automatic-compensation-regulating equipment 




Automatically-regulated banks of capacitors 

allow an immediate adaptation of compensation 

to match the level of load 


The principles of, and reasons, for using automatic 

compensation 

A bank of capacitors is divided into a number of sections, each of which is controlled 

by a contactor. Closure of a contactor switches its section into parallel operation with 

other sections already in service. The size of the bank can therefore be increased or 

decreased in steps, by the closure and opening of the controlling contactors. 

A control relay monitors the power factor of the controlled circuit(s) and is arranged 

to close and open appropriate contactors to maintain a reasonably constant 

system power factor (within the tolerance imposed by the size of each step of 

compensation). The current transformer for the monitoring relay must evidently 

be placed on one phase of the incoming cable which supplies the circuit(s) being 

controlled, as shown in Figure L12. 

A Varset Fast capacitor bank is an automatic power factor correction equipment 

including static contactors (thyristors) instead of usual contactors. Static correction 

is particularly suitable for a certain number of installations using equipment with fast 

cycle and/or sensitive to transient surges. 

The advantages of static contactors are : 

b Immediate response to all power factor fluctuation (response time 2 s or 40 ms 

according to regulator option) 

b Unlimited number of operations 

b Elimination of transient phenomena on the network on capacitor switching 

b Fully silent operation 

By closely matching compensation to that required by the load, the possibility of 

producing overvoltages at times of low load will be avoided, thereby preventing 

an overvoltage condition, and possible damage to appliances and equipment. 

Overvoltages due to excessive reactive compensation depend partly on the value of 

source impedance. 

CT In / 5 A cl 1 

Fig. L12 : The principle of automatic-compensation control 


Varmetric 

relay 

3.3 The choice between a fixed or automaticallyregulated 

bank of capacitors 

Commonly-applied rules 

Where the kvar rating of the capacitors is less than, or equal to 15% of the supply 

transformer rating, a fixed value of compensation is appropriate. Above the 15% 

level, it is advisable to install an automatically-controlled bank of capacitors. 

The location of low-voltage capacitors in an installation constitutes the mode of 

compensation, which may be global (one location for the entire installation), partial 

(section-by-section), local (at each individual device), or some combination of the 

latter two. In principle, the ideal compensation is applied at a point of consumption 

and at the level required at any instant. 

In practice, technical and economic factors govern the choice. 

L9 


L10 




Where a load is continuous and stable, global 

compensation can be applied 

Compensation by sector is recommended 

when the installation is extensive, and where the 

load/time patterns differ from one part of 

the installation to another 

no. 1 

no. 2 no. 2 

M M M M 

Fig. L14 : Compensation by sector 

4 Where to install correction 

capacitors? 

4.1 Global compensation (see Fig. L13) 

Principle 

The capacitor bank is connected to the busbars of the main LV distribution board for 

the installation, and remains in service during the period of normal load. 

Advantages 

The global type of compensation: 

b Reduces the tariff penalties for excessive consumption of kvars 

b Reduces the apparent power kVA demand, on which standing charges are usually 

based 

b Relieves the supply transformer, which is then able to accept more load if 

necessary 

Comments 

b Reactive current still flows in all conductors of cables leaving (i.e. downstream of) 

the main LV distribution board 

b For the above reason, the sizing of these cables, and power losses in them, are 

not improved by the global mode of compensation. 

Fig. L13 : Global compensation 

4.2 Compensation by sector (see Fig. L14) 

Principle 

Capacitor banks are connected to busbars of each local distribution board, as shown 

in Figure L14. 

A significant part of the installation benefits from this arrangement, notably the feeder 

cables from the main distribution board to each of the local distribution boards at 

which the compensation measures are applied. 

Advantages 

The compensation by sector: 


b Reduces the apparent power kVA demand, on which standing charges are usually 

based 

b Relieves the supply transformer, which is then able to accept more load if 

necessary 

b The size of the cables supplying the local distribution boards may be reduced, or 

will have additional capacity for possible load increases 

b Losses in the same cables will be reduced 

Comments 

b Reactive current still flows in all cables downstream of the local distribution boards 

b For the above reason, the sizing of these cables, and the power losses in them, 

are not improved by compensation by sector 

b Where large changes in loads occur, there is always a risk of overcompensation 

and consequent overvoltage problems 


M M M M 

no.1



Individual compensation should be considered 

when the power of motor is significant with 

respect to power of the installation 

4 Where to install correction 

capacitors? 

4.3 Individual compensation 

Principle 

Capacitors are connected directly to the terminals of inductive circuit (notably motors, 

see further in Clause 7). Individual compensation should be considered when the 

power of the motor is significant with respect to the declared power requirement 

(kVA) of the installation. 

The kvar rating of the capacitor bank is in the order of 25% of the kW rating of the 

motor. Complementary compensation at the origin of the installation (transformer) 

may also be beneficial. 

Advantages 

Individual compensation: 


b Reduces the apparent power kVA demand 

b Reduces the size of all cables as well as the cable losses 

Comments 

b Significant reactive currents no longer exist in the installation 


L11 


L12 




5 How to decide the optimum level 

of compensation? 

5.1 General method 

Listing of reactive power demands at the design stage 

This listing can be made in the same way (and at the same time) as that for the 

power loading described in chapter A. The levels of active and reactive power 

loading, at each level of the installation (generally at points of distribution and subdistribution 

of circuits) can then be determined. 

Technical-economic optimization for an existing installation 

The optimum rating of compensation capacitors for an existing installation can be 

determined from the following principal considerations: 

b Electricity bills prior to the installation of capacitors 

b Future electricity bills anticipated following the installation of capacitors 

b Costs of: 

v Purchase of capacitors and control equipment (contactors, relaying, cabinets, etc.) 

v Installation and maintenance costs 

v Cost of dielectric heating losses in the capacitors, versus reduced losses in cables, 

transformer, etc., following the installation of capacitors 

Several simplified methods applied to typical tariffs (common in Europe) are shown 

in sub-clauses 5.3 and 5.4. 

5.2 Simplified method 

General principle 

An approximate calculation is generally adequate for most practical cases, and may 

be based on the assumption of a power factor of 0.8 (lagging) before compensation. 

In order to improve the power factor to a value sufficient to avoid tariff penalties (this 

depends on local tariff structures, but is assumed here to be 0.93) and to reduce 

losses, volt-drops, etc. in the installation, reference can be made to Figure L15 next 

page. 

From the figure, it can be seen that, to raise the power factor of the installation from 

0.8 to 0.93 will require 0.355 kvar per kW of load. The rating of a bank of capacitors 

at the busbars of the main distribution board of the installation would be 

Q (kvar) = 0.355 x P (kW). 

This simple approach allows a rapid determination of the compensation capacitors 

required, albeit in the global, partial or independent mode. 

Example 

It is required to improve the power factor of a 666 kVA installation from 0.75 to 0.928. 

The active power demand is 666 x 0.75 = 500 kW. 

In Figure L15, the intersection of the row cos ϕ = 0.75 (before correction) with 

the column cos ϕ = 0.93 (after correction) indicates a value of 0.487 kvar of 

compensation per kW of load. 

For a load of 500 kW, therefore, 500 x 0.487 = 244 kvar of capacitive compensation 

is required. 

Note: this method is valid for any voltage level, i.e. is independent of voltage. 






Before kvar rating of capacitor bank to install per kW of load, to improve cos ϕ (the power factor) or tan ϕ, 

compensation to a given value 

tan ϕ 0.75 0.59 0.48 0.46 0.43 0.40 0.36 0.33 0.29 0.25 0.20 0.14 0.0 

tan ϕ cos ϕ cos ϕ 0.80 0.86 0.90 0.91 0.92 0.93 0.94 0.95 0.96 0.97 0.98 0.99 1 

2.29 0.40 1.557 1.691 1.805 1.832 1.861 1.895 1.924 1.959 1.998 2.037 2.085 2.146 2.288 

2.22 0.41 1.474 1.625 1.742 1.769 1.798 1.831 1.840 1.896 1.935 1.973 2.021 2.082 2.225 

2.16 0.42 1.413 1.561 1.681 1.709 1.738 1.771 1.800 1.836 1.874 1.913 1.961 2.022 2.164 

2.10 0.43 1.356 1.499 1.624 1.651 1.680 1.713 1.742 1.778 1.816 1.855 1.903 1.964 2.107 

2.04 0.44 1.290 1.441 1.558 1.585 1.614 1.647 1.677 1.712 1.751 1.790 1.837 1.899 2.041 

1.98 0.45 1.230 1.384 1.501 1.532 1.561 1.592 1.628 1.659 1.695 1.737 1.784 1.846 1.988 

1.93 0.46 1.179 1.330 1.446 1.473 1.502 1.533 1.567 1.600 1.636 1.677 1.725 1.786 1.929 

1.88 0.47 1.130 1.278 1.397 1.425 1.454 1.485 1.519 1.532 1.588 1.629 1.677 1.758 1.881 

1.83 0.48 1.076 1.228 1.343 1.370 1.400 1.430 1.464 1.497 1.534 1.575 1.623 1.684 1.826 

1.78 0.49 1.030 1.179 1.297 1.326 1.355 1.386 1.420 1.453 1.489 1.530 1.578 1.639 1.782 

1.73 0.50 0.982 1.232 1.248 1.276 1.303 1.337 1.369 1.403 1.441 1.481 1.529 1.590 1.732 

1.69 0.51 0.936 1.087 1.202 1.230 1.257 1.291 1.323 1.357 1.395 1.435 1.483 1.544 1.686 

1.64 0.52 0.894 1.043 1.160 1.188 1.215 1.249 1.281 1.315 1.353 1.393 1.441 1.502 1.644 

1.60 0.53 0.850 1.000 1.116 1.144 1.171 1.205 1.237 1.271 1.309 1.349 1.397 1.458 1.600 

1.56 0.54 0.809 0.959 1.075 1.103 1.130 1.164 1.196 1.230 1.268 1.308 1.356 1.417 1.559 

1.52 0.55 0.769 0.918 1.035 1.063 1.090 1.124 1.156 1.190 1.228 1.268 1.316 1.377 1.519 

1.48 0.56 0.730 0.879 0.996 1.024 1.051 1.085 1.117 1.151 1.189 1.229 1.277 1.338 1.480 

1.44 0.57 0.692 0.841 0.958 0.986 1.013 1.047 1.079 1.113 1.151 1.191 1.239 1.300 1.442 

1.40 0.58 0.665 0.805 0.921 0.949 0.976 1.010 1.042 1.076 1.114 1.154 1.202 1.263 1.405 

1.37 0.59 0.618 0.768 0.884 0.912 0.939 0.973 1.005 1.039 1.077 1.117 1.165 1.226 1.368 

1.33 0.60 0.584 0.733 0.849 0.878 0.905 0.939 0.971 1.005 1.043 1.083 1.131 1.192 1.334 

1.30 0.61 0.549 0.699 0.815 0.843 0.870 0.904 0.936 0.970 1.008 1.048 1.096 1.157 1.299 

1.27 0.62 0.515 0.665 0.781 0.809 0.836 0.870 0.902 0.936 0.974 1.014 1.062 1.123 1.265 

1.23 0.63 0.483 0.633 0.749 0.777 0.804 0.838 0.870 0.904 0.942 0.982 1.030 1.091 1.233 

1.20 0.64 0.450 0.601 0.716 0.744 0.771 0.805 0.837 0.871 0.909 0.949 0.997 1.058 1.200 

1.17 0.65 0.419 0.569 0.685 0.713 0.740 0.774 0.806 0.840 0.878 0.918 0.966 1.007 1.169 

1.14 0.66 0.388 0.538 0.654 0.682 0.709 0.743 0.775 0.809 0.847 0.887 0.935 0.996 1.138 

1.11 0.67 0.358 0.508 0.624 0.652 0.679 0.713 0.745 0.779 0.817 0.857 0.905 0.966 1.108 

1.08 0.68 0.329 0.478 0.595 0.623 0.650 0.684 0.716 0.750 0.788 0.828 0.876 0.937 1.079 

1.05 0.69 0.299 0.449 0.565 0.593 0.620 0.654 0.686 0.720 0.758 0.798 0.840 0.907 1.049 

1.02 0.70 0.270 0.420 0.536 0.564 0.591 0.625 0.657 0.691 0.729 0.769 0.811 0.878 1.020 

0.99 0.71 0.242 0.392 0.508 0.536 0.563 0.597 0.629 0.663 0.701 0.741 0.783 0.850 0.992 

0.96 0.72 0.213 0.364 0.479 0.507 0.534 0.568 0.600 0.634 0.672 0.712 0.754 0.821 0.963 

0.94 0.73 0.186 0.336 0.452 0.480 0.507 0.541 0.573 0.607 0.645 0.685 0.727 0.794 0.936 

0.91 0.74 0.159 0.309 0.425 0.453 0.480 0.514 0.546 0.580 0.618 0.658 0.700 0.767 0.909 

0.88 0.75 0.132 0.82 0.398 0.426 0.453 0.487 0.519 0.553 0.591 0.631 0.673 0.740 0.882 

0.86 0.76 0.105 0.255 0.371 0.399 0.426 0.460 0.492 0.526 0.564 0.604 0.652 0.713 0.855 

0.83 0.77 0.079 0.229 0.345 0.373 0.400 0.434 0.466 0.500 0.538 0.578 0.620 0.687 0.829 

0.80 0.78 0.053 0.202 0.319 0.347 0.374 0.408 0.440 0.474 0.512 0.552 0.594 0.661 0.803 

0.78 0.79 0.026 0.176 0.292 0.320 0.347 0.381 0.413 0.447 0.485 0.525 0.567 0.634 0.776 

0.75 0.80 0.150 0.266 0.294 0.321 0.355 0.387 0.421 0.459 0.499 0.541 0.608 0.750 

0.72 0.81 0.124 0.240 0.268 0.295 0.329 0.361 0.395 0.433 0.473 0.515 0.582 0.724 

0.70 0.82 0.098 0.214 0.242 0.269 0.303 0.335 0.369 0.407 0.447 0.489 0.556 0.698 

0.67 0.83 0.072 0.188 0.216 0.243 0.277 0.309 0.343 0.381 0.421 0.463 0.530 0.672 

0.65 0.84 0.046 0.162 0.190 0.217 0.251 0.283 0.317 0.355 0.395 0.437 0.504 0.645 

0.62 0.85 0.020 0.136 0.164 0.191 0.225 0.257 0.291 0.329 0.369 0.417 0.478 0.620 

0.59 0.86 0.109 0.140 0.167 0.198 0.230 0.264 0.301 0.343 0.390 0.450 0.593 

0.57 0.87 0.083 0.114 0.141 0.172 0.204 0.238 0.275 0.317 0.364 0.424 0.567 

0.54 0.88 0.054 0.085 0.112 0.143 0.175 0.209 0.246 0.288 0.335 0.395 0.538 

0.51 0.89 0.028 0.059 0.086 0.117 0.149 0.183 0.230 0.262 0.309 0.369 0.512 

0.48 0.90 0.031 0.058 0.089 0.121 0.155 0.192 0.234 0.281 0.341 0.484 

Value selected as an example on section 5.2 

Value selected as an example on section 5.4 

Fig. L15 : kvar to be installed per kW of load, to improve the power factor of an installation 


L13 


L14 




In the case of certain (common) types of 

tariff, an examination of several bills covering 

the most heavily-loaded period of the year 

allows determination of the kvar level of 

compensation required to avoid kvarh (reactiveenergy) 

charges. The pay-back period of a 

bank of power-factor-correction capacitors 

and associated equipment is generally about 

18 months 

For 2-part tariffs based partly on a declared value 

of kVA, Figure L17 allows determination of the 

kvar of compensation required to reduce the 

value of kVA declared, and to avoid exceeding it 

ϕ' 

ϕ 

Cos ϕ = 0.7 

Cos ϕ'= 0.95 

S = 122 kVA 

S' = 90 kVA 

Q = 87.1 kvar 

Qc = 56 kvar 

Q' = 28.1 kvar 

P = 85.4 kW 

Fig. L16 : Reduction of declared maximum kVA by powerfactor 

improvement 

(1) In the billing period, during the hours for which 

reactive energy is charged for the case considered above: 

15,996 kvarh 

Qc = = 

73 kvar 

220 h 

S' 

S 

Q' 

Qc 

Q 



5.3 Method based on the avoidance of tariff 

penalties 

The following method allows calculation of the rating of a proposed capacitor bank, 

based on billing details, where the tariff structure corresponds with (or is similar to) 

the one described in sub-clause 2.1 of this chapter. 

The method determines the minimum compensation required to avoid these charges 

which are based on kvarh consumption. 

The procedure is as follows: 

b Refer to the bills covering consumption for the 5 months of winter (in France these 

are November to March inclusive). 

Note: in tropical climates the summer months may constitute the period of heaviest 

loading and highest peaks (owing to extensive air conditioning loads) so that a 

consequent variation of high-tariff periods is necessary in this case. The remainder of 

this example will assume Winter conditions in France. 

b Identify the line on the bills referring to “reactive-energy consumed” and “kvarh 

to be charged”. Choose the bill which shows the highest charge for kvarh (after 

checking that this was not due to some exceptional situation). 

For example: 15,966 kvarh in January. 

b Evaluate the total period of loaded operation of the installation for that month, for 

instance: 220 hours (22 days x 10 hours). The hours which must be counted are 

those occurring during the heaviest load and the highest peak loads occurring on 

the power system. These are given in the tariff documents, and are (commonly) 

during a 16-hour period each day, either from 06.00 h to 22.00 h or from 07.00 h to 

23.00 h according to the region. Outside these periods, no charge is made for kvarh 

consumption. 

b The necessary value of compensation in kvar = kvarh billed/number of hours of 

operation (1) = Qc 

The rating of the installed capacitor bank is generally chosen to be slightly larger 

than that calculated. 

Certain manufacturers can provide “slide rules” especially designed to facilitate 

these kinds of calculation, according to particular tariffs. These devices and 

accompanying documentation advice on suitable equipment and control schemes, 

as well as drawing attention to constraints imposed by harmonic voltages on the 

power system. Such voltages require either over dimensioned capacitors (in terms of 

heat-dissipation, voltage and current ratings) and/or harmonic-suppression inductors 

or filters. 

5.4 Method based on reduction of declared 

maximum apparent power (kVA) 

For consumers whose tariffs are based on a fixed charge per kVA declared, plus a 

charge per kWh consumed, it is evident that a reduction in declared kVA would be 

beneficial. The diagram of Figure L16 shows that as the power factor improves, the 

kVA value diminishes for a given value of kW (P). The improvement of the power 

factor is aimed at (apart from other advantages previously mentioned) reducing the 

declared level and never exceeding it, thereby avoiding the payment of an excessive 

price per kVA during the periods of excess, and/or tripping of the the main circuitbreaker. 

Figure L15 (previous page) indicates the value of kvar of compensation per 

kW of load, required to improve from one value of power factor to another. 

Example: 

A supermarket has a declared load of 122 kVA at a power factor of 0.7 lagging, i.e.an 

active-power load of 85.4 kW. The particular contract for this consumer was based on 

stepped values of declared kVA (in steps of 6 kVA up to 108 kVA, and 12 kVA steps 

above that value, this is a common feature in many types of two-part tariff). In the 

case being considered, the consumer was billed on the basis of 

132 kVA. Referring to Figure L15, it can be seen that a 60 kvar bank of capacitors 

will improve the power factor of the load from 0.7 to 0.95 (0.691 x 85.4 = 59 kvar 

in the figure). The declared value of kVA will then be 85.4 

= 9 0 kVA , i.e. an 

improvement of 30%. 

0.95 




The installation of a capacitor bank can avoid 

the need to change a transformer in the event of 

a load increase 

6 Compensation at the terminals 

of a transformer 

6.1 Compensation to increase the available active 

power output 

Steps similar to those taken to reduce the declared maximum kVA, i.e. improvement 

of the load power factor, as discussed in subclause 5.4, will maximise the available 

transformer capacity, i.e. to supply more active power. 

Cases can arise where the replacement of a transformer by a larger unit, to overcome 

a load growth, may be avoided by this means. Figure L17 shows directly the power 

(kW) capability of fully-loaded transformers at different load power factors, from 

which the increase of active-power output can be obtained as the value of power 

factor increases. 

Fig. L17 : Active-power capability of fully-loaded transformers, when supplying loads at different values of power factor 

Q 

P1 

tan ϕ cos ϕ Nominal rating of transformers (in kVA) 

100 160 250 315 400 500 630 800 1000 1250 1600 2000 

0.00 1 100 160 250 315 400 500 630 800 1000 1250 1600 2000 

0.20 0.98 98 157 245 309 392 490 617 784 980 1225 1568 1960 

0.29 0.96 96 154 240 302 384 480 605 768 960 1200 1536 1920 

0.36 0.94 94 150 235 296 376 470 592 752 940 1175 1504 1880 

0.43 0.92 92 147 230 290 368 460 580 736 920 1150 1472 1840 

0.48 0.90 90 144 225 284 360 450 567 720 900 1125 1440 1800 

0.54 0.88 88 141 220 277 352 440 554 704 880 1100 1408 1760 

0.59 0.86 86 138 215 271 344 430 541 688 860 1075 1376 1720 

0.65 0.84 84 134 210 265 336 420 529 672 840 1050 1344 1680 

0.70 0.82 82 131 205 258 328 410 517 656 820 1025 1312 1640 

0.75 0.80 80 128 200 252 320 400 504 640 800 1000 1280 1600 

0.80 0.78 78 125 195 246 312 390 491 624 780 975 1248 1560 

0.86 0.76 76 122 190 239 304 380 479 608 760 950 1216 1520 

0.91 0.74 74 118 185 233 296 370 466 592 740 925 1184 1480 

0.96 0.72 72 115 180 227 288 360 454 576 720 900 1152 1440 

1.02 0.70 70 112 175 220 280 350 441 560 700 875 1120 1400 

S1 

S 

S2 Q2 

Q1 

P2 

Q 

Q m 

Fig. L18 : Compensation Q allows the installation-load 

extension S2 to be added, without the need to replace the 

existing transformer, the output of which is limited to S 

P 

Example: (see Fig. L18 ) 

An installation is supplied from a 630 kVA transformer loaded at 450 kW (P1) with a 

450 

mean power factor of 0.8 lagging. The apparent power S1= 

= 5 62 kVA 

0.8 

The corresponding reactive power 

2 2 

Q1= S1 − P1 = 337 kvar 

The anticipated load increase P2 = 100 kW at a power factor of 0.7 lagging. 

The apparent power 100 

S2 

= = 143 kVA 

The corresponding reactive 0.7 power 

2 2 

Q2 = S2 − P2 = 1 02 kvar 

What is the minimum value of capacitive kvar to be installed, in order to avoid a 

change of transformer? 

Total power now to be supplied: 

P = P1 + P2 = 550 kW 

The maximum reactive power capability of the 630 kVA transformer when delivering 

550 kW is: 

2 2 

2 2 

Qm = S − P Qm = 630 − 550 = 307 kvar 

Total reactive power required by the installation before compensation: 

Q1 + Q2 = 337 + 102 = 439 kvar 

So that the minimum size of capacitor bank to install: 

Qkvar = 439 - 307 = 132 kvar 

It should be noted that this calculation has not taken account of load peaks and their 

duration. 

The best possible improvement, i.e. correction which attains a power factor of 

1 would permit a power reserve for the transformer of 630 - 550 = 80 kW. 

The capacitor bank would then have to be rated at 439 kvar. 


L15 


L16 




Where metering is carried out at the MV side 

of a transformer, the reactive-energy losses in 

the transformer may need to be compensated 

(depending on the tariff) 

Perfect transformer 

Primary 

winding 

Secondary 

winding 

Fig. L19 : Transformer reactances per phase 

Leakage reactance 

Magnetizing 

reactance 

The reactive power absorbed by a transformer 

cannot be neglected, and can amount to (about) 

5% of the transformer rating when supplying 

its full load. Compensation can be provided by 

a bank of capacitors. In transformers, reactive 

power is absorbed by both shunt (magnetizing) 

and series (leakage flux) reactances. Complete 

compensation can be provided by a bank of 

shunt-connected LV capacitors 

I sin 

' 

I sin 

' 

I 

E 

Source 

XL 

V 

Load 

Fig. L20 : Reactive power absorption by series inductance 

I 

V 

E 

IXL 



6.2 Compensation of reactive energy absorbed by 

the transformer 

The nature of transformer inductive reactances 

All previous references have been to shunt connected devices such as those used 

in normal loads, and power factor-correcting capacitor banks etc. The reason for 

this is that shunt connected equipment requires (by far) the largest quantities of 

reactive energy in power systems; however, series-connected reactances, such as 

the inductive reactances of power lines and the leakage reactance of transformer 

windings, etc., also absorb reactive energy. 

Where metering is carried out at the MV side of a transformer, the reactive-energy 

losses in the transformer may (depending on the tariff) need to be compensated. As 

far as reactive-energy losses only are concerned, a transformer may be represented 

by the elementary diagram of Figure L19. All reactance values are referred to 

the secondary side of the transformer, where the shunt branch represents the 

magnetizing-current path. The magnetizing current remains practically constant (at 

about 1.8% of full-load current) from no load to full load, in normal circumstances, 

i.e. with a constant primary voltage, so that a shunt capacitor of fixed value can be 

installed at the MV or LV side, to compensate for the reactive energy absorbed. 

Reactive-power absorption in series-connected 

(leakage flux) reactance XL 

A simple illustration of this phenomenon is given by the vector diagram of 

Figure L20. 

The reactive-current component through the load = I sin ϕ so that QL = VI sin ϕ. 

The reactive-current component from the source = I sin ϕ’ so that QE = EI sin ϕ’. 

It can be seen that E > V and sin ϕ’ > sin ϕ. 

The difference between EI sin ϕ’ and VI sin ϕ gives the kvar per phase absorbed 

by XL. 

It can be shown that this kvar value is equal to I2XL (which is analogous to the I2R active power (kW) losses due to the series resistance of power lines, etc.). 

From the I2XL formula it is very simple to deduce the kvar absorbed at any load value 

for a given transformer, as follows: 

If per-unit values are used (instead of percentage values) direct multiplication of I 

and XL can be carried out. 

Example: 

A 630 kVA transformer with a short-circuit reactance voltage of 4% is fully loaded. 

What is its reactive-power (kvar) loss? 

4% = 0.04 pu Ipu = 1 

loss = I 2 XL = 1 2 x 0.04 = 0.04 pu kvar 

where 1 pu = 630 kVA 

The 3-phase kvar losses are 630 x 0.04 = 25.2 kvar (or, quite simply, 4% of 630 kVA). 

At half load i.e. I = 0.5 pu the losses will be 

0.5 2 x 0.04 = 0.01 pu = 630 x 0.01 = 6.3 kvar and so on... 

This example, and the vector diagram of Figure L20 show that: 

b The power factor at the primary side of a loaded transformer is different (normally 

lower) than that at the secondary side (due to the absorption of vars) 

b Full-load kvar losses due to leakage reactance are equal to the transformer 

percentage reactance (4% reactance means a kvar loss equal to 4% of the kVA rating 

of the transformer) 

b kvar losses due to leakage reactance vary according to the current 

(or kVA loading) squared 






To determine the total kvar losses of a transformer the constant magnetizing-current 

circuit losses (approx. 1.8% of the transformer kVA rating) must be added to the 

foregoing “series” losses. Figure L21 shows the no-load and full-load kvar losses for 

typical distribution transformers. In principle, series inductances can be compensated 

by fixed series capacitors (as is commonly the case for long MV transmission lines). 

This arrangement is operationally difficult, however, so that, at the voltage levels 

covered by this guide, shunt compensation is always applied. 

In the case of MV metering, it is sufficient to raise the power factor to a point where 

the transformer plus load reactive-power consumption is below the level at which a 

billing charge is made. This level depends on the tariff, but often corresponds to a 

tan ϕ value of 0.31 (cos ϕ of 0.955). 

Rated power (kVA) Reactive power (kvar) to be compensated 

No load Full load 

100 2.5 6.1 

160 3.7 9.6 

250 5.3 14.7 

315 6.3 18.4 

400 7.6 22.9 

500 9.5 28.7 

630 11.3 35.7 

800 20 54.5 

1000 23.9 72.4 

1250 27.4 94.5 

1600 31.9 126 

2000 37.8 176 

Fig. L21 : Reactive power consumption of distribution transformers with 20 kV primary windings 

As a matter of interest, the kvar losses in a transformer can be completely 

compensated by adjusting the capacitor bank to give the load a (slightly) leading 

power factor. In such a case, all of the kvar of the transformer is being supplied from 

the capacitor bank, while the input to the MV side of the transformer is at unity power 

factor, as shown in Figure L22. 

Load 

current 

I 

ϕ 


E (Input voltage) 

V (Load voltage) 

I0 Compensation current 

Fig. L22 : Overcompensation of load to completely compensate transformer reactive-power losses 

In practical terms, therefore, compensation for transformer-absorbed kvar is included 

in the capacitors primarily intended for powerfactor correction of the load, either 

globally, partially, or in the individual mode. Unlike most other kvar-absorbing items, 

the transformer absorption (i.e. the part due to the leakage reactance) changes 

significantly with variations of load level, so that, if individual compensation is applied 

to the transformer, then an average level of loading will have to be assumed. 

Fortunately, this kvar consumption generally forms only a relatively small part of the 

total reactive power of an installation, and so mismatching of compensation at times 

of load change is not likely to be a problem. 

Figure L21 indicates typical kvar loss values for the magnetizing circuit (“no-load 

kvar” columns), as well as for the total losses at full load, for a standard range of 

distribution transformers supplied at 20 kV (which include the losses due to the 

leakage reactance). 

IXL 

L17 


L18 




Individual motor compensation is recommended 

where the motor power (kVA) is large with 

respect to the declared power of the installation 

Before 

compensation 

Transformer 

Active 

power 

Motor 

M M 

After 

compensation 

Power 

made 

available 

C 

Reactive 

power 

supplied 

by capacitor 

7 Power factor correction of 

induction motors 

7.1 Connection of a capacitor bank and protection 

settings 

General precautions 

Because of the small kW consumption, the power factor of a motor is very low at noload 

or on light load. The reactive current of the motor remains practically constant at 

all loads, so that a number of unloaded motors constitute a consumption of reactive 

power which is generally detrimental to an installation, for reasons explained in 

preceding sections. 

Two good general rules therefore are that unloaded motors should be switched off, 

and motors should not be oversized (since they will then be lightly loaded). 

Connection 

The bank of capacitors should be connected directly to the terminals of the motor. 

Special motors 

It is recommended that special motors (stepping, plugging, inching, reversing motors, 

etc.) should not be compensated. 

Effect on protection settings 

After applying compensation to a motor, the current to the motor-capacitor 

combination will be lower than before, assuming the same motor-driven load 

conditions. This is because a significant part of the reactive component of the motor 

current is being supplied from the capacitor, as shown in Figure L23. 

Where the overcurrent protection devices of the motor are located upstream of the 

motor capacitor connection (and this will always be the case for terminal-connected 

capacitors), the overcurrent relay settings must be reduced in the ratio: 

cos ϕ before compensation / cos ϕ after compensation 

For motors compensated in accordance with the kvar values indicated in Figure L24 

(maximum values recommended for avoidance of self-excitation of standard 

induction motors, as discussed in sub-clause 7.2), the above-mentioned ratio 

will have a value similar to that indicated for the corresponding motor speed in 

Figure L25. 


3-phase motors 230/400 V 

Nominal power kvar to be installed 

Speed of rotation (rpm) 

kW hp 3000 1500 1000 750 

22 30 6 8 9 10 

30 40 7.5 10 11 12.5 

37 50 9 11 12.5 16 

45 60 11 13 14 17 

55 75 13 17 18 21 

75 100 17 22 25 28 

90 125 20 25 27 30 

110 150 24 29 33 37 

132 180 31 36 38 43 

160 218 35 41 44 52 

200 274 43 47 53 61 

250 340 52 57 63 71 

280 380 57 63 70 79 

355 482 67 76 86 98 

400 544 78 82 97 106 

450 610 87 93 107 117 

Figure L24 : Maximum kvar of power factor correction applicable to motor terminals without risk 

of self excitation 

Speed in rpm Reduction factor 

750 0.88 

1000 0.90 

1500 0.91 

3000 0.93 

Fig. L23 : Before compensation, the transformer supplies all 

the reactive power; after compensation, the capacitor supplies 

a large part of the reactive power Fig. L25 : Reduction factor for overcurrent protection after compensation



When a capacitor bank is connected to the 

terminals of an induction motor, it is important 

to check that the size of the bank is less than 

that at which self-excitation can occur 

Fig. L26 : Connection of the capacitor bank to the motor 

7 Power factor correction of 

induction motors 

7.2 How self-excitation of an induction motor can be 

avoided 

When a motor is driving a high-inertia load, the motor will continue to rotate (unless 

deliberately braked) after the motor supply has been switched off. 

The “magnetic inertia” of the rotor circuit means that an emf will be generated in the 

stator windings for a short period after switching off, and would normally reduce to 

zero after 1 or 2 cycles, in the case of an uncompensated motor. 

Compensation capacitors however, constitute a 3-phase “wattless” load for this 

decaying emf, which causes capacitive currents to flow through the stator windings. 

These stator currents will produce a rotating magnetic field in the rotor which acts 

exactly along the same axis and in the same direction as that of the decaying 

magnetic field. 

The rotor flux consequently increases; the stator currents increase; and the voltage 

at the terminals of the motor increases; sometimes to dangerously-high levels. This 

phenomenon is known as self-excitation and is one reason why AC generators 

are not normally operated at leading power factors, i.e. there is a tendency to 

spontaneously (and uncontrollably) self excite. 

Notes: 

1. The characteristics of a motor being driven by the inertia of the load are not 

rigorously identical to its no-load characteristics. This assumption, however, is 

sufficiently accurate for practical purposes. 

2. With the motor acting as a generator, the currents circulating are largely reactive, 

so that the braking (retarding) effect on the motor is mainly due only to the load 

represented by the cooling fan in the motor. 

3. The (almost 90° lagging) current taken from the supply in normal circumstances by 

the unloaded motor, and the (almost 90° leading) current supplied to the capacitors 

by the motor acting as a generator, both have the same phase relationship 

to the terminalvoltage. It is for this reason that the two characteristics may be 

superimposed on the graph. 

In order to avoid self-excitation as described above, the kvar rating of the capacitor 

bank must be limited to the following maximum value: 

Qc y 0.9 x Io x Un x 3 where Io = the no-load current of the motor and Un = 

phase-to-phase nominal voltage of the motor in kV. Figure L24 previous page gives 

appropriate values of Qc corresponding to this criterion. 

Example 

A 75 kW, 3,000 rpm, 400 V, 3-phase motor may have a capacitor bank no larger 

than 17 kvar according to Figure L24. The table values are, in general, too small to 

adequately compensate the motor to the level of cos ϕ normally required. Additional 

compensation can, however, be applied to the system, for example an overall bank, 

installed for global compensation of a number of smaller appliances. 

High-inertia motors and/or loads 

In any installation where high-inertia motor driven loads exist, the circuit-breakers or 

contactors controlling such motors should, in the event of total loss of power supply, 

be rapidly tripped. 

If this precaution is not taken, then self excitation to very high voltages is likely to 

occur, since all other banks of capacitors in the installation will effectively be in 

parallel with those of the high-inertia motors. 

The protection scheme for these motors should therefore include an overvoltage 

tripping relay, together with reverse-power checking contacts (the motor will feed 

power to the rest of the installation, until the stored inertial energy is dissipated). 

If the capacitor bank associated with a high inertia motor is larger than that 

recommended in Figure L24, then it should be separately controlled by a circuitbreaker 

or contactor, which trips simultaneously with the main motor-controlling 

circuit-breaker or contactor, as shown in Figure L26. 

Closing of the main contactor is commonly subject to the capacitor contactor being 

previously closed. 


L19 


L20 




Installation before P.F. correction 

� � � (1) 

kVA=kW+kvar b kvarh are billed heavily above the declared 

level 

b Apparent power kVA is significantly greater 

� � � 

kVA=kW+kvar 

kVA than the kW demand 

kVA 

kW kvar 

b The corresponding excess current causes 

losses (kWh) which are billed 

b The installation must be over-dimensioned 

kW 

630 kVA 

400 V 

cos ϕ = 0.75 

workshop 

Characteristics of the installation 

500 kW cos ϕ = 0.75 

b Transformer is overloaded 

b The power demand is 

S = P = 500 = 665 kVA 

cos ϕ 0.75 

S = apparent power 

b The current flowing into the installation 

downstream of the circuit breaker is 

I = P = 960 A 

3U cos ϕ 

b Losses in cables are calculated as a 

function of the current squared: 960 2 

P=I 2 R 

cos ϕ = 0.75 

b Reactive energy is supplied through the 

transformer and via the installation wiring 

b The transformer, circuit breaker, and cables 

must be over-dimensioned 

8 Example of an installation 

before and after power-factor 

correction 


Installation after P.F. correction 

630 kVA 

400 V 

cos ϕ = 0.75 

workshop 

Fig. K27 : Technical-economic comparison of an installation before and after power-factor correction 

(1) The arrows denote vector quantities. 

(2) Particularly in the pre-corrected case. 

b The consumption of kvarh is 

v Eliminated, or 

v Reduced, according to the cos ϕ required 

b The tariff penalties 

v For reactive energy where applicable 

v For the entire bill in some cases are 

eliminated 

b The fixed charge based on kVA demand is 

adjusted to be close to the active power kW 

demand 

Characteristics of the installation 

500 kW cos ϕ = 0.928 

b Transformer no longer overloaded 

b The power-demand is 539 kVA 

b There is 14% spare-transformer capacity 

available 

b The current flowing into the installation 

through the circuit breaker is 778 A 

250 kvar 

b The losses in the cables are 

reduced to 7782 = 65% of the former value, 

960 2 

thereby economizing in kWh consumed 

cos ϕ = 0.928 

b Reactive energy is supplied by the capacitor 

bank 

Capacitor bank rating is 250 kvar 

in 5 automatically-controlled steps of 50 kvar. 

Note: In fact, the cos ϕ of the workshop remains at 0.75 but cos ϕ for all the 

installation upstream of the capacitor bank to the transformer LV terminals 

is 0.928. 

As mentioned in Sub-clause 6.2 the cos ϕ at the HV side of the transformer 

will be slightly lower (2) , due to the reactive power losses in the transformer.



Harmonics are taken into account mainly by 

oversizing capacitors and including harmonicsuppression 

reactors in series with them 

Harmonic 

generator 

Ihar 

Filter 

Fig. L28 : Operation principle of passive filter 

9 The effects of harmonics 

9.1 Problems arising from power-system harmonics 

Equipment which uses power electronics components (variable-speed motor 

controllers, thyristor-controlled rectifiers, etc.) have considerably increased the 

problems caused by harmonics in power supply systems. 

Harmonics have existed from the earliest days of the industry and were (and still 

are) caused by the non-linear magnetizing impedances of transformers, reactors, 

fluorescent lamp ballasts, etc. 

Harmonics on symmetrical 3-phase power systems are generally odd-numbered: 3 rd , 

5 th , 7 th , 9 th ..., and the magnitude decreases as the order of the harmonic increases. 

A number of features may be used in various ways to reduce specific harmonics to 

negligible values - total elimination is not possible. In this section, practical means of 

reducing the influence of harmonics are recommended, with particular reference to 

capacitor banks. 

Capacitors are especially sensitive to harmonic components of the supply voltage 

due to the fact that capacitive reactance decreases as the frequency increases. 

In practice, this means that a relatively small percentage of harmonic voltage can 

cause a significant current to flow in the capacitor circuit. 

The presence of harmonic components causes the (normally sinusoidal) wave form 

of voltage or current to be distorted; the greater the harmonic content, the greater the 

degree of distortion. 

If the natural frequency of the capacitor bank/ power-system reactance combination 

is close to a particular harmonic, then partial resonance will occur, with amplified 

values of voltage and current at the harmonic frequency concerned. In this particular 

case, the elevated current will cause overheating of the capacitor, with degradation 

of the dielectric, which may result in its eventual failure. 

Several solutions to these problems are available. This can be accomplished by 

b Shunt connected harmonic filter and/or harmonic-suppression reactors or 

b Active power filters or 

b Hybrid filters 

9.2 Possible solutions 

Passive filter (see Fig. L28) 

Countering the effects of harmonics 

The presence of harmonics in the supply voltage results in abnormally high current 

levels through the capacitors. An allowance is made for this by designing for an r.m.s. 

value of current equal to 1.3 times the nominal rated current. All series elements, 

such as connections, fuses, switches, etc., associated with the capacitors are 

similarly oversized, between 1.3 to 1.5 times nominal rating. 

Harmonic distortion of the voltage wave frequently produces a “peaky” wave form, 

in which the peak value of the normal sinusoidal wave is increased. This possibility, 

together with other overvoltage conditions likely to occur when countering the effects 

of resonance, as described below, are taken into account by increasing the insulation 

level above that of “standard” capacitors. In many instances, these two counter 

measures are all that is necessary to achieve satisfactory operation. 

Countering the effects of resonance 

Capacitors are linear reactive devices, and consequently do not generate harmonics. 

The installation of capacitors in a power system (in which the impedances are 

predominantly inductive) can, however, result in total or partial resonance occurring 

at one of the harmonic frequencies. 

The harmonic order ho of the natural resonant frequency between the system 

inductance and the capacitor bank is given by 

h o = Ssc 

Q 

where 

Ssc = the level of system short-circuit kVA at the point of connection of the capacitor 

Q = capacitor bank rating in kvar; and ho = the harmonic order of the natural 

frequency fo i.e. fo 

for a 50 Hz system, or fo 

for a 60 Hz system. 

50 

60 


L21 


L22 




Harmonic 

generator 

Fig. L29 : Operation principle of active filter 

Ihar 

Ihar 

Harmonic 

generator 

Active 

filter 

Active 

filter 

Iact 

Hybride filter 

Fig. L30 : Operation principle of hybrid filter 

Is 

Iact 

Linear 

load 

Is 

Linear 

load 


For example: h o = Ssc 

Q may give a value for h o of 2.93 which shows that the 

natural frequency of the capacitor/system-inductance combination is close to the 3rd harmonic frequency of the system. 

f 

From ho 

= o it can be seen that fo = 50 ho = 50 x 2.93 = 146.5 Hz 

50 

The closer a natural frequency approaches one of the harmonics present on the 

system, the greater will be the (undesirable) effect. In the above example, strong 

resonant conditions with the 3rd harmonic component of a distorted wave would 

certainly occur. 

In such cases, steps are taken to change the natural frequency to a value which will 

not resonate with any of the harmonics known to be present. This is achieved by the 

addition of a harmonic-suppression inductor connected in series with the capacitor 

bank. 

On 50 Hz systems, these reactors are often adjusted to bring the resonant frequency 

of the combination, i.e. the capacitor bank + reactors to 190 Hz. The reactors are 

adjusted to 228 Hz for a 60 Hz system. These frequencies correspond to a value 

for h o of 3.8 for a 50 Hz system, i.e. approximately mid-way between the 3 rd and 5 th 

harmonics. 

In this arrangement, the presence of the reactor increases the fundamental 

frequency (50 Hz or 60 Hz) current by a small amount (7-8%) and therefore the 

voltage across the capacitor in the same proportion. 

This feature is taken into account, for example, by using capacitors which are 

designed for 440 V operation on 400 V systems. 

Active filter (see Fig. L29) 

Active filters are based on power electronic technology. They are generally installed 

in parallel with the non linear load. 

Active filters analyse the harmonics drawn by the load and then inject the same 

harmonic current to the load with the appropriate phase. As a result, the harmonic 

currents are totally neutralised at the point considered. This means they no longer 

flow upstream and are no longer supplied by the source. 

A main advantage of active conditioners is that they continue to guarantee efficient 

harmonic compensation even when changes are made to the installation. They are 

also exceptionally easy to use as they feature: 

b Auto-configuration to harmonic loads whatever their order of magnitude 

b Elimination of overload risks 

b Compatibility with electrical generator sets 

b Connection to any point of the electrical network 

b Several conditioners can be used in the same installation to increase depollution 

efficiency (for example when a new machine is installed) 

Active filters may provide also power factor correction. 

Hybrid filter (see Fig. L30) 

This type of filter combines advantages of passive and active filter. One frequency 

can be filtered by passive filter and all the other frequencies are filtered by active 

filter. 





9.3 Choosing the optimum solution 

Figure L31 below shows the criteria that can be taken into account to select the 

most suitable technology depending on the application. 

Passive filter Active filter Hybrid filter 

Applications Industrial Tertiary Industrial 

… with total power of non greater than lower than greater than 

linear loads (variable speed 200 kVA 200 kVA 200 kVA 

drive, UPS, rectifier…) 

Power factor correction No 

Necessity of reducing the 

harmonic distorsion in 

voltage for sensitive loads 

Necessity of reducing 

the harmonic distorsion 

in current to avoid cable 

overload 

Necessity of being in No 

accordance with strict 

limits of harmonic 

rejected 

Fig. L31 : Selection of the most suitable technology depending on the application 

For passive filter, a choice is made from the following parameters: 

b Gh = the sum of the kVA ratings of all harmonic-generating devices (static 

converters, inverters, speed controllers, etc.) connected to the busbars from which 

the capacitor bank is supplied. If the ratings of some of these devices are quoted in 

kW only, assume an average power factor of 0.7 to obtain the kVA ratings 

b Ssc = the 3-phase short-circuit level in kVA at the terminals of the capacitor bank 

b Sn = the sum of the kVA ratings of all transformers supplying (i.e. directly 

connected to) the system level of which the busbars form a part 

If a number of transformers are operating in parallel, the removal from service of one 

or more, will significantly change the values of Ssc and Sn. From these parameters, 

a choice of capacitor specification which will ensure an acceptable level of operation 

with the system harmonic voltages and currents, can be made, by reference to 

Figure L32. 

b General rule valid for any size of transformer 

Ssc 

Gh i 

120 

Ssc Ssc 

i Gh i 

120 70 

Ssc 

Gh > 

70 

Standard capacitors Capacitor voltage rating Capacitor voltage rating 

increased by 10% increased by 10% 

(except 230 V units) + harmonic-suppression reactor 

b Simplified rule if transformer(s) rating Sn y 2 MVA 

Gh i 0.15 Sn 0.15 Sn < Gh i 0.25 Sn 0.25 Sn < Gh i 0.60 Sn Gh > 0.60 Sn 

Standard capacitors Capacitor voltage rating Capacitor voltage rating Filters 

increased by 10% increased by 10% 

(except 230 V units) + harmonic suppression 

reactor 

Fig. L32 : Choice of solutions for limiting harmonics associated with a LV capacitor bank supplied 

via transformer(s) 


L23 


L24 




(1) Merlin-Gerin designation 

10 Implementation of capacitor 

banks 

10.1 Capacitor elements 

Technology 

The capacitors are dry-type units (i.e. are not impregnated by liquid dielectric) 

comprising metallized polypropylene self-healing film in the form of a two-film roll. 

They are protected by a high-quality system (overpressure disconnector used with 

a high breaking capacity fuse) which switches off the capacitor if an internal fault 

occurs. 

The protection scheme operates as follows: 

b A short-circuit through the dielectric will blow the fuse 

b Current levels greater than normal, but insufficient to blow the fuse sometimes 

occur, e.g. due to a microscopic flow in the dielectric film. Such “faults” often re-seal 

due to local heating caused by the leakage current, i.e. the units are said to be “selfhealing” 

b If the leakage current persists, the defect may develop into a short-circuit, and the 

fuse will blow 

b Gas produced by vaporizing of the metallisation at the faulty location will gradually 

build up a pressure within the plastic container, and will eventually operate a 

pressure-sensitive device to short-circuit the unit, thereby causing the fuse to blow 

Capacitors are made of insulating material providing them with double insulation and 

avoiding the need for a ground connection (see Fig. L33). 

a) 

b) 

HRC fuse 

Discharge 

resistor 

Metallic 

disc 

Overpressure disconnect 

device 


Standard IEC 60439-1, NFC 54-104, VDE 0560 CSA 

Standards, UL tests 

Operating range Rated voltage 400 V 

Rated frequency 50 Hz 

Capacitance tolerance - 5% to + 10% 

Temperature range Maximum temperature 55 °C 

(up to 65 kvar) Average temperature over 

24 h 

45 °C 

Average annual 

temperature 

35 °C 

Minimum temperature - 25 °C 

Insulation level 50 Hz 1 min withstand voltage : 6 kV 

1.2/50 μs impulse withstand voltage : 25 kV 

Permissible current overload Classic range (1) Comfort range (1) 

30% 50% 

Permissible voltage overload 10% 20% 

Fig. L33 : Capacitor element, (a) cross-section, (b) electrical characteristics 




(1) Merlin-Gerin designation 

(2) Harmony capacitor banks are equipped with a harmonic 

suppression reactor. 


banks 

10.2 Choice of protection, control devices and 

connecting cables 

The choice of upstream cables and protection and control devices depends on the 

current loading. 

For capacitors, the current is a function of: 

b The applied voltage and its harmonics 

b The capacitance value 

The nominal current In of a 3-phase capacitor bank is equal to: 

In = 

Un 3 

Q 

with: 

v Q: kvar rating 

v Un: Phase-to-phase voltage (kV) 

The permitted range of applied voltage at fundamental frequency, plus harmonic 

components, together with manufacturing tolerances of actual capacitance (for a 

declared nominal value) can result in a 50% increase above the calculated value of 

current. Approximately 30% of this increase is due to the voltage increases, while a 

further 15% is due to the range of manufacturing tolerances, so that 

1.3 x 1.15 = 1.5 

All components carrying the capacitor current therefore, must be adequate to cover 

this “worst-case” condition, in an ambient temperature of 50 °C maximum. In the 

case where temperatures higher than 50 °C occur in enclosures, etc. derating of the 

components will be necessary. 

Protection 

The size of the circuit-breaker can be chosen in order to allow the setting of long 

time delay at: 

b 1.36 x In for Classic range (1) 

b 1.50 x In for Comfort range (1) 

b 1.12 x In for Harmony range (1) (tuned at 2.7 f) (2) 

b 1.19 x In for Harmony range (1) (tuned at 3.8 f) 

b 1.31 x In for Harmony range (1) (tuned at 4.3 f) 

Short time delay setting (short-circuit protection) must be insensitive to inrush 

current. The setting will be 10 x In for Classic, Comfort and Harmony range (1) . 

Example 1 

50 kvar – 400V – 50 Hz – Classic range 

50, 000 

In = = 72 A 

( 400 x 1.732) 

Long time delay setting: 1.36 x 72 = 98 A 

Short time delay setting: 10 x In = 720 A 

Example 2 

50 kvar – 400V – 50 Hz – Harmony range (tuned at 4.3 f) 

In = 72 A 

Long time delay setting: 1.31 x 72 = 94 A 

Short time delay setting: 10 x In = 720 A 

Upstream cables 

Figure L34 next page gives the minimum cross section area of the upstream cable 

for Rectiphase capacitors. 

Cables for control 

The minimum cross section area of these cables will be 1.5 mm 2 for 230 V. 

For the secondary side of the transformer, the recommended cross section 

area is u 2.5 mm 2 . 


L25 


L26 




(1) Minimum cross-section not allowing for any correction 

factors (installation mode, temperature, etc.). The calculations 

were made for single-pole cables laid in open air at 30 °C. 


banks 

Fig L34 : Cross-section of cables connecting medium and high power capacitor banks (1) 

Voltage transients 


Bank power Copper Aluminium 

(kvar) cross- section cross- section 

230 V 400 V (mm 2 ) (mm 2 ) 

5 10 2.5 16 

10 20 4 16 

15 30 6 16 

20 40 10 16 

25 50 16 25 

30 60 25 35 

40 80 35 50 

50 100 50 70 

60 120 70 95 

70 140 95 120 

90-100 180 120 185 

200 150 240 

120 240 185 2 x 95 

150 250 240 2 x 120 

300 2 x 95 2 x 150 

180-210 360 2 x 120 2 x 185 

245 420 2 x 150 2 x 240 

280 480 2 x 185 2 x 300 

315 540 2 x 240 3 x 185 

350 600 2 x 300 3 x 240 

385 660 3 x 150 3 x 240 

420 720 3 x 185 3 x 300 

High-frequency voltage and current transients occur when switching a capacitor 

bank into service. The maximum voltage peak does not exceed (in the absence of 

harmonics) twice the peak value of the rated voltage when switching uncharged 

capacitors. 

In the case of a capacitor being already charged at the instant of switch closure, 

however, the voltage transient can reach a maximum value approaching 3 times the 

normal rated peak value. 

This maximum condition occurs only if: 

b The existing voltage at the capacitor is equal to the peak value of rated voltage, 

and 

b The switch contacts close at the instant of peak supply voltage, and 

b The polarity of the power-supply voltage is opposite to that of the charged 

capacitor 

In such a situation, the current transient will be at its maximum possible value, viz: 

Twice that of its maximum when closing on to an initially uncharged capacitor, as 

previously noted. 

For any other values of voltage and polarity on the pre-charged capacitor, the 

transient peaks of voltage and current will be less than those mentioned above. 

In the particular case of peak rated voltage on the capacitor having the same polarity 

as that of the supply voltage, and closing the switch at the instant of supply-voltage 

peak, there would be no voltage or current transients. 

Where automatic switching of stepped banks of capacitors is considered, therefore, 

care must be taken to ensure that a section of capacitors about to be energized is 

fully discharged. 

The discharge delay time may be shortened, if necessary, by using discharge 

resistors of a lower resistance value.

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

Chapter M 


Contents 

The problem: why is it necessary to detect M2 

and eliminate harmonics? 

Standards M3 

General M4 

Main effects of harmonics in installations M6 

4.1 Resonance M6 

4.2 Increased losses M6 

4.3 Overloads on equipment M7 

4.4 Disturbances affecting sensitive loads M9 

4.5 Economic impact M10 

Essential indicators of harmonic distortion M 

and measurement principles 

5.1 Power factor M11 

5.2 Crest factor M11 

5.3 Power values and harmonics M11 

5.4 Harmonic spectrum and harmonic distortion M12 

5.5 Total harmonic distortion (THD) M12 

5.6 Usefulness of the various indicators M13 

Measuring the indicators M 4 

6.1 Devices used to measure the indicators M14 

6.2 Procedures for harmonic analysis of distribution networks M14 

6.3 Keeping a close eye on harmonics M15 

Detection devices M 6 

Solutions to attenuate harmonics M 7 

8.1 Basic solutions M17 

8.2 Harmonic filtering M18 

8.3 The method M20 

8.4 Specific products M20 


M 



M2 


The problem: why is it necessary 

to detect and eliminate harmonics? 

Disturbances caused by harmonics 

Harmonics flowing in distribution networks downgrade the quality of electrical power. 

This can have a number of negative effects: 

b Overloads on distribution networks due to the increase in rms current 

b Overloads in neutral conductors due to the cumulative increase in third-order 

harmonics created by single-phase loads 

b Overloads, vibration and premature ageing of generators, transformers and motors 

as well as increased transformer hum 

b Overloads and premature ageing of power-factor correction capacitors 

b Distortion of the supply voltage that can disturb sensitive loads 

b Disturbances in communication networks and on telephone lines 

Economic impact of disturbances 

Harmonics have a major economic impact: 

b Premature ageing of equipment means it must be replaced sooner unless 

oversized right from the start 

b Overloads on the distribution network can require higher subscribed power levels 

and increase losses 

b Distortion of current waveforms provokes nuisance tripping that can stop 

production 

Increasingly serious consequences 

Only ten years ago, harmonics were not yet considered a real problem because 

their effects on distribution networks were generally minor. However, the massive 

introduction of power electronics in equipment has made the phenomenon far more 

serious in all sectors of economic activity. 

In addition, the equipment causing the harmonics is often vital to the company or 

organisation. 

Which harmonics must be measured and eliminated? 

The most frequently encountered harmonics in three-phase distribution networks 

are the odd orders. Harmonic amplitudes normally decrease as the frequency 

increases. Above order 50, harmonics are negligible and measurements are no 

longer meaningful. Sufficiently accurate measurements are obtained by measuring 

harmonics up to order 30. 

Utilities monitor harmonic orders 3, 5, 7, 11 and 13. Generally speaking, harmonic 

conditioning of the lowest orders (up to 13) is sufficient. More comprehensive 

conditioning takes into account harmonic orders up to 25. 



Fig. M1 : Maximum permissible harmonic levels 

2 Standards 

Harmonic emissions are subject to various standards and regulations: 

b Compatibility standards for distribution networks 

b Emissions standards applying to the equipment causing harmonics 

b Recommendations issued by utilities and applicable to installations 

In view of rapidly attenuating the effects of harmonics, a triple system of standards 

and regulations is currently in force based on the documents listed below. 

Standards governing compatibility between distribution networks and 

products 

These standards determine the necessary compatibility between distribution 

networks and products: 

b The harmonics caused by a device must not disturb the distribution network 

beyond certain limits 

b Each device must be capable of operating normally in the presence of 

disturbances up to specific levels 

b Standard IEC 61000-2-2 for public low-voltage power supply systems 

b Standard IEC 61000-2-4 for LV and MV industrial installations 

Standards governing the quality of distribution networks 

b Standard EN 50160 stipulates the characteristics of electricity supplied by public 

distribution networks 

b Standard IEEE 519 presents a joint approach between Utilities and customers 

to limit the impact of non-linear loads. What is more, Utilities encourage preventive 

action in view of reducing the deterioration of power quality, temperature rise and the 

reduction of power factor. They will be increasingly inclined to charge customers for 

major sources of harmonics 

Standards governing equipment 

b Standard IEC 61000-3-2 or EN 61000-3-2 for low-voltage equipment with rated 

current under 16 A 

b Standard IEC 61000-3-12 for low-voltage equipment with rated current higher than 

16 A and lower than 75 A 

Maximum permissible harmonic levels 

International studies have collected data resulting in an estimation of typical 

harmonic contents often encountered in electrical distribution networks. Figure M1 

presents the levels that, in the opinion of many utilities, should not be exceeded. 

Odd harmonic orders Odd harmonic orders Even harmonic orders 

non-multiples of multiples of 

Order h LV MV EMV Order h LV MV EMV Order h LV MV EMV 

5 6 6 2 3 5 2.5 1.5 2 2 1.5 1.5 

7 5 5 2 9 1.5 1.5 1 4 1 1 1 

11 3.5 3.5 1.5 15 0.3 0.3 0.3 6 0.5 0.5 0.5 

13 3 3 1.5 21 0.2 0.2 0.2 8 0.5 0.2 0.2 

17 2 2 1 > 21 0.2 0.2 0.2 10 0.5 0.2 0.2 

19 1.5 1.5 1 12 0.2 0.2 0.2 

23 1.5 1 0.7 > 12 0.2 0.2 0.2 

25 1.5 1 0.7 

> 25 0.2 0.2 0.1 

+ 25/h + 25/h + 25/h 


M 



M 


3 General 

The presence of harmonics indicates a distorted current or voltage wave. The 

distortion of the current or voltage wave means that the distribution of electrical 

energy is disturbed and power quality is not optimum. 

Harmonic currents are caused by non-linear loads connected to the distribution 

network. The flow of harmonic currents causes harmonic voltages via distributionnetwork 

impedances and consequently distortion of the supply voltage. 

Origin of harmonics 

Devices and systems that cause harmonics are present in all sectors, i.e. industrial, 

commercial and residential. Harmonics are caused by non-linear loads (i.e. loads 

that draw current with a waveform that is not the same as that of the supply voltage). 

Examples of non-linear loads are: 

b Industrial equipment (welding machines, arc furnaces, induction furnaces, 

rectifiers) 

b Variable-speed drives for asynchronous or DC motors 

b UPSs 

b Office equipment (computers, photocopy machines, fax machines, etc.) 

b Home appliances (television sets, micro-wave ovens, fluorescent lighting) 

b Certain devices involving magnetic saturation (transformers) 

Disturbances caused by non-linear loads: harmonic current and voltage 

Non-linear loads draw harmonic currents that flow in the distribution network. 

Harmonic voltages are caused by the flow of harmonic currents through the 

impedances of the supply circuits (transformer and distribution network for situations 

similar to that shown in Figure M2). 


A 

Z h B 

I h 

Non-linear 

load 

Fig. M2 : Single-line diagram showing the impedance of the supply circuit for a harmonic of order h 

The reactance of a conductor increases as a function of the frequency of the current 

flowing through the conductor. For each harmonic current (order h), there is therefore 

an impedance Zh in the supply circuit. 

When the harmonic current of order h flows through impedance Zh, it creates a 

harmonic voltage Uh, where Uh = Zh x Ih (Ohm law). The voltage at point B is 

therefore distorted. All devices supplied via point B receive a distorted voltage. 

For a given harmonic current, the distortion is proportional to the impedance in the 

distribution network. 

Flow of harmonic currents in distribution networks 

The non-linear loads can be considered to reinject the harmonic currents upstream 

into the distribution network, toward the source. 

Figures M3 and M next page show an installation disturbed by harmonics. Figure 

M3 shows the flow of the current at 50 Hz in the installation and Figure M4 shows 

the harmonic current (order h).


3 General 

Fig. M3 : Installation supplying a non-linear load, where only the phenomena concerning the 

50 Hz frequency (fundamental frequency) are shown 


Z h 

Z l 

I 50 Hz 

Non-linear 

load 

Fig. M4 : Same installation, where only the phenomena concerning the frequency of harmonic 

order h are shown 

V h 

I h 

Non-linear 

load 

V h = Harmonic voltage 

= Z h x I h 

Supply of the non-linear load creates the flow of a current I 50Hz (shown in 

figure M3), to which is added each of the harmonic currents Ih (shown in figure M4), 

corresponding to each harmonic order h. 

Still considering that the loads reinject harmonic current upstream into the 

distribution network, it is possible to create a diagram showing the harmonic currents 

in the network (see Fig. M ). 

Backup power 

supply 

G 

Power-factor 

correction 

MV/LV 

Harmonic 

disturbances to 


and other users 

A 

Ih a 

Ih b 

Ih d 

Ih e 

(do not create 

harmonics) 

Rectifier 

Arc furnace 

Welding machine 

Variable-speed drive 

Fluorescent or 

discharge lamps 

Devices drawing rectified 

current (televisions, 

computer hardware, etc.) 

Linear loads 

Note in the diagram that though certain loads create harmonic currents in the distribution 

network, other loads can absorb the harmonic currents. 

Fig. M5 : Flow of harmonic currents in a distribution network 

Harmonics have major economic effects in installations: 

b Increases in energy costs 

b Premature ageing of equipment 

b Production losses 

M 



M 


I h 

Non-linear 

load 

C 

Capacitor 

bank 

Fig. M6 : Diagram of an installation 

Ls C R Ih 

Z 

Linear 

load 

Fig. M7 : Equivalent diagram of the installation shown in 

Figure M6 

4 Main effects of harmonics in 


4.1 Resonance 

The simultaneous use of capacitive and inductive devices in distribution networks 

results in parallel or series resonance manifested by very high or very low 

impedance values respectively. The variations in impedance modify the current and 

voltage in the distribution network. Here, only parallel resonance phenomena, the 

most common, will be discussed. 

Consider the following simplified diagram (see Fig. M ) representing an installation 

made up of: 

b A supply transformer 

b Linear loads 

b Non-linear loads drawing harmonic currents 

b Power factor correction capacitors 

For harmonic analysis, the equivalent diagram (see Fig. M7) is shown below. 

Impedance Z is calculated by: 

jLs 

Z = 

1-LsC 2 

ω 

ω 

neglecting R and where: 

Ls = Supply inductance (upstream network + transformer + line) 

C = Capacitance of the power factor correction capacitors 

R = Resistance of the linear loads 

Ih = Harmonic current 

Resonance occurs when the denominator 1-LsCw 2 tends toward zero. The 

corresponding frequency is called the resonance frequency of the circuit. At that 

frequency, impedance is at its maximum and high amounts of harmonic voltages 

appear with the resulting major distortion in the voltage. The voltage distortion is 

accompanied, in the Ls+C circuit, by the flow of harmonic currents greater than 

those drawn by the loads. 

The distribution network and the power factor correction capacitors are subjected to 

high harmonic currents and the resulting risk of overloads. To avoid resonance, antiharmonic 

coils can be installed in series with the capacitors. 

4.2 Increased losses 

Losses in conductors 

The active power transmitted to a load is a function of the fundamental component I1 

of the current. 

When the current drawn by the load contains harmonics, the rms value of the 

current, Irms, is greater than the fundamental I1. 

The definition of THD being: 

THD = 

2 

⎛ Irms⎞ 

⎜ ⎟ −1 

⎝ I1 

⎠ 

it may be deduced that: Irms = I1 

+ THD 2 

1 

Figure M8 (next page) shows, as a function of the harmonic distortion: 

b The increase in the rms current Irms for a load drawing a given fundamental 

current 

b The increase in Joule losses, not taking into account the skin effect 

(The reference point in the graph is 1 for Irms and Joules losses, the case when 

there are no harmonics) 

The harmonic currents provoke an increase in the Joule losses in all conductors in 

which they flow and additional temperature rise in transformers, devices, cables, etc. 

Losses in asynchronous machines 

The harmonic voltages (order h) supplied to asynchronous machines provoke in the 

rotor the flow of currents with frequencies higher than 50 Hz that are the cause of 

additional losses. 





2.2 

2 

1.8 

1.6 

1.4 

1.2 

1 

0.8 

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 

Joules losses 

Irms 

Fig. M8 : Increase in rms current and Joule losses as a function of the THD 

Orders of magnitude 

b A virtually rectangular supply voltage provokes a 20% increase in losses 

b A supply voltage with harmonics u5 = 8% (of U1, the fundamental voltage), 

u7 = 5%, u11 = 3%, u13 = 1%, i.e. total harmonic distortion THDu equal to 10%, 

results in additional losses of 6% 

Losses in transformers 

Harmonic currents flowing in transformers provoke an increase in the “copper” 

losses due to the Joule effect and increased “iron” losses due to eddy currents. The 

harmonic voltages are responsible for “iron” losses due to hysteresis. 

It is generally considered that losses in windings increase as the square of the THDi 

and that core losses increase linearly with the THDu. 

In utility-distribution transformers, where distortion levels are limited, losses increase 

between 10 and 15%. 

Losses in capacitors 

The harmonic voltages applied to capacitors provoke the flow of currents 

proportional to the frequency of the harmonics. These currents cause additional 

losses. 

Example 

A supply voltage has the following harmonics: 

Fundamental voltage U1, harmonic voltages u5 = 8% (of U1), u7 = 5%, u11 = 3%, 

u13 = 1%, i.e. total harmonic distortion THDu equal to 10%. The amperage of the 

current is multiplied by 1.19. Joule losses are multiplied by 1.19 2 , i.e. 1.4. 

4.3 Overloads on equipment 

Generators 

Generators supplying non-linear loads must be derated due to the additional losses 

caused by harmonic currents. 

The level of derating is approximately 10% for a generator where the overall load 

is made up of 30% of non-linear loads. It is therefore necessary to oversize the 

generator. 

Uninterruptible power systems (UPS) 

The current drawn by computer systems has a very high crest factor. A UPS sized 

taking into account exclusively the rms current may not be capable of supplying the 

necessary peak current and may be overloaded. 


THD 

(%) 

M7 



M8 


(1) In fact, the current waveform is similar to a rectangular 

waveform. This is the case for all current rectifiers (three-phase 

rectifiers, induction furnaces). 



Transformers 

b The curve presented below (see Fig. M9) shows the typical derating required for a 

transformer supplying electronic loads 

100 

90 

80 

70 

60 

50 

40 

30 

20 

10 

Example 

If the transformer supplies an overall load comprising 40% of electronic loads, it must 

be derated by 40%. 

b Standard UTE C15-112 provides a derating factor for transformers as a function of 

the harmonic currents. 

k = 

kVA 

(%) 

0 

Th = Ih 


1 

⎛ 40 ⎞ 

1.6 2 

1+ 0.1 ⎜ ∑h Th ⎟ 

⎝ h= 2 ⎠ 

I 

1 

Typical values: 

b Current with a rectangular waveform (1/h spectrum (1) ): k = 0.86 

b Frequency-converter current (THD ≈ 50%): k = 0.80 

Asynchronous machines 

Standard IEC 60892 defines a weighted harmonic factor (Harmonic voltage factor) 

for which the equation and maximum value are provided below. 

HVF = 

0 20 40 60 80 100 

Fig. M9 : Derating required for a transformer supplying electronic loads 

13 U h 

∑ 0.02 

2 

h i 

h= 2 

Example 

A supply voltage has a fundamental voltage U1 and harmonic voltages u3 = 2% of 

U1, u5 = 3%, u7 = 1%. The THDu is 3.7% and the MVF is 0.018. The MVF value 

is very close to the maximum value above which the machine must be derated. 

Practically speaking, for supply to the machine, a THDu of 10% must not be 

exceeded. 

Capacitors 

% 

Electronic 

load 

According to IEC 60831-1 standard, the rms current flowing in the capacitors must 

not exceed 1.3 times the rated current. 

Using the example mentioned above, the fundamental voltage U1, harmonic voltages 

voltages u5 = 8% u5 (of = U1), 8% u7 (of = U1), 5%, u7 u11 = 5%, = 3%, u11 u13 = 3%, = 1%, u13 i.e. = total 1%, harmonic i.e. total harmonic 

distortion THDu equal to 10%, the result is Irms 

= 1. 19, 

, at the rated voltage. For a 

I1 

, at the rated voltage. For a 

voltage equal equal to to 1.1 1.1 times the the rated voltage, the current limit Irms 

= 1. 3 is reached 

and it is necessary to resize the capacitors. 

I1


I r 

I s 

I t 

I n 

Load 

Load 

Load 

Fig. M10 : Flow of currents in the various conductors 

connected to a three-phase source 



Neutral conductors 

Consider a system made up of a balanced three-phase source and three identical 

single-phase loads connected between the phases and the neutral (see Fig. M10). 

Figure M11 shows an example of the currents flowing in the three phases and the 

resulting current in the neutral conductor. 

In this example, the current in the neutral conductor has an rms value that is higher 

than the rms value of the current in a phase by a factor equal to the square root of 3. 

The neutral conductor must therefore be sized accordingly. 

Ir 

Is 

It 

In 

(A) 

Fig. M11 : Example of the currents flowing in the various conductors connected to a three-phase 

load (In = Ir + Is + It) 


0 

20 40 

4.4 Disturbances affecting sensitive loads 

Effects of distortion in the supply voltage 

t 

t 

t 

t 

t (ms) 

Distortion of the supply voltage can disturb the operation of sensitive devices: 

b Regulation devices (temperature) 

b Computer hardware 

b Control and monitoring devices (protection relays) 

Distortion of telephone signals 

Harmonics cause disturbances in control circuits (low current levels). The level of 

distortion depends on the distance that the power and control cables run in parallel, 

the distance between the cables and the frequency of the harmonics. 

M9 


M10 





4.5 Economic impact 

Energy losses 

Harmonics cause additional losses (Joule effect) in conductors and equipment. 

Higher subscription costs 

The presence of harmonic currents can require a higher subscribed power level and 

consequently higher costs. 

What is more, utilities will be increasingly inclined to charge customers for major 

sources of harmonics. 

Oversizing of equipment 

b Derating of power sources (generators, transformers and UPSs) means they must 

be oversized 

b Conductors must be sized taking into account the flow of harmonic currents. 

In addition, due the the skin effect, the resistance of these conductors increases 

with frequency. To avoid excessive losses due to the Joule effect, it is necessary to 

oversize conductors 

b Flow of harmonics in the neutral conductor means that it must be oversized as well 

Reduced service life of equipment 

When the level of distortion in the supply voltage approaches 10%, the duration 

of the service life of equipment is significantly reduced. The reduction has been 

estimated at: 

b 32.5% for single-phase machines 

b 18% for three-phase machines 

b 5% for transformers 

To maintain the service lives corresponding to the rated load, equipment must be 

oversized. 

Nuisance tripping and installation shutdown 

Circuit-breakers in the installation are subjected to current peaks caused by 

harmonics. 

These current peaks cause nuisance tripping with the resulting production losses, as 

well as the costs corresponding to the time required to start the installation up again. 

Examples 

Given the economic consequences for the installations mentioned below, it was 

necessary to install harmonic filters. 

Computer centre for an insurance company 

In this centre, nuisance tripping of a circuit-breaker was calculated to have cost 

100 k€ per hour of down time. 

Pharmaceutical laboratory 

Harmonics caused the failure of a generator set and the interruption of a longduration 

test on a new medication. The consequences were a loss estimated at 

17 M€. 

Metallurgy factory 

A set of induction furnaces caused the overload and destruction of three 

transformers ranging from 1500 to 2500 kVA over a single year. The cost of the 

interruptions in production were estimated at 20 k€ per hour. 

Factory producing garden furniture 

The failure of variable-speed drives resulted in production shutdowns estimated at 

10 k€ per hour. 



5 Essential indicators of harmonic 

distortion and measurement 

principles 

A number of indicators are used to quantify and evaluate the harmonic distortion 

in current and voltage waveforms, namely: 

b Power factor 

b Crest factor 

b Distortion power 

b Harmonic spectrum 

b Harmonic-distortion values 

These indicators are indispensable in determining any necessary corrective action. 

5.1 Power factor 

Definition 

The power factor PF is the ratio between the active power P and the apparent 

power S. 

PF P 

= 

S 

Among electricians, there is often confusion with: 

P1 

cos 

ϕ = 

S1 

Where 

Where 

P1 = active power of the fundamental 

S1 = apparent power of the fundamental 

The cos ϕ concerns exclusively the fundamental frequency and therefore differs 

from the power factor PF when there are harmonics in the installation. 

Interpreting the power factor 

An initial indication that there are significant amounts of harmonics is a measured 

power factor PF that is different (lower) than the measured cos ϕ. 

5.2 Crest factor 

Definition 

The crest factor is the ratio between the value of the peak current or voltage (Im or 

Um) and its rms value. 

b For a sinusoidal signal, the crest factor is therefore equal to 2. 

b For a non-sinusoidal signal, the crest factor can be either greater than or less 

than 2. 

In the latter case, the crest factor signals divergent peak values with respect to the 

rms value. 

Interpretation of the crest factor 

The typical crest factor for the current drawn by non-linear loads is much higher 

than 2. It is generally between 1.5 and 2 and can even reach 5 in critical cases. 

A high crest factor signals high transient overcurrents which, when detected by 

protection devices, can cause nuisance tripping. 

5.3 Power values and harmonics 

Active power 

The active power P of a signal comprising harmonics is the sum of the active 

powers resulting from the currents and voltages of the same order. 

Reactive power 

Reactive power is defined exclusively in terms of the fundamental, i.e. 

Q = U1 x I1 x sinϕ1 Distortion power 

When harmonics are present, the distortion power D is defined as 

D = (S 2 - P 2 - Q 2 ) 1/2 where S is the apparent power. 


M11 


M12 



1 

100 

33 

20 

U(t) 

H % 

0 

1 

2 3 4 5 6 

Fig. M12 : Harmonic spectrum of a rectangular signal, for a 

voltage U (t) 

t 

h 



principles 

5.4 Harmonic spectrum and harmonic distortion 

Principle 

Each type of device causing harmonics draws a particular form of harmonic current 

(amplitude and phase displacement). 

These values, notably the amplitude for each harmonic order, are essential for 

analysis. 

Individual harmonic distortion (or harmonic distortion of 

order h) 

The individual harmonic distortion is defined as the percentage of harmonics for 

order h with respect to the fundamental. 

u % 100 Uh 

h( 

) = 

U1 

or 

I 

i h % 100 h 

( ) = 

I1 

Harmonic spectrum 

By representing the amplitude of each harmonic order with respect to its frequency, it 

is possible to obtain a graph called the harmonic spectrum. 

Figure M12 shows an example of the harmonic spectrum for a rectangular signal. 

Rms value 

The rms value of the voltage and current can be calculated as a function of the rms 

value of the various harmonic orders. 

∞ 

∑ h 

= 

2 

h 1 

Irms = I 

and 

∞ 

rms = ∑ h 

= 

2 

U U 

h 1 

5.5 Total harmonic distortion (THD) 

The term THD means Total Harmonic Distortion and is a widely used notion in 

defining the level of harmonic content in alternating signals. 

Definition of THD 

For a signal y, the THD is defined as: 

∞ 

∑yh 

h= 

THD = 

y 

2 

2 

1 

This complies with the definition given in standard IEC 61000-2-2. 

Note that the value can exceed 1. 

According to the standard, the variable h can be limited to 50. The THD is the means 

to express as a single number the distortion affecting a current or voltage flowing at a 

given point in the installation. 

The THD is generally expressed as a percentage. 

Current or voltage THD 

For current harmonics, the equation is: 

∞ 

∑Ih 

h= 

THDi = 

I 

2 

2 

1 



1.2 

1 

0.8 

0.6 

0.4 

0.2 

PF 

cos ϕ 

0 

50 

Figure L13 Fig. shows M13 : a Variation graph of in 

PF 

THDu = 0 

cosϕ 

100 

150 

THDi 

(%) 

as a function of THDI. 

as a function of the THDi, where 



principles 

The equation below is equivalent to the above, but easier and more direct when the 

total rms value is available: 

THDi = ⎛ ⎞ 

⎜ ⎟ 

⎝ ⎠ 

− 

2 

Irms 

1 

I1 

For voltage harmonics, the equation is: 

THDu 

= 

∞ 

∑Uh h= 

U 

2 

2 

1 

Relation between power factor and THD (see Fig. M13) 

When the voltage is sinusoidal or virtually sinusoidal, it may be said that: 

P ≈ P1 = U 1. I1.cosϕ1 Consequently : PF = P 

S 

as: 

I 

I 

1 = 

rms 

U 1. I1.cosϕ 

≈ 

1 

U 1. Irms 


1 

2 

1+ THDi 

cosϕ 

hence: PF ≈ 1 

2 

1+ THDi 

Figure M13 L13 shows a graph of PF 

as a function of THDi. THDI. 

cosϕ 

5.6 Usefulness of the various indicators 

The THDu characterises the distortion of the voltage wave. 

Below are a number of THDu values and the corresponding phenomena in the 

installation: 

b THDu under 5% - normal situation, no risk of malfunctions 

b 5 to 8% - significant harmonic pollution, some malfunctions are possible 

b Higher than 8% - major harmonic pollution, malfunctions are probable. In-depth 

analysis and the installation of attenuation devices are required 

The THDi characterises the distortion of the current wave. 

The disturbing device is located by measuring the THDi on the incomer and each 

outgoer of the various circuits and thus following the harmonic trail. 

Below are a number of THDi values and the corresponding phenomena in the 

installation: 

b THDi under 10% - normal situation, no risk of malfunctions 

b 10 to 50% - significant harmonic pollution with a risk of temperature rise and the 

resulting need to oversize cables and sources 

b Higher than 50% - major harmonic pollution, malfunctions are probable. In-depth 

analysis and the installation of attenuation devices are required 

Power factor PF 

Used to evaluate the necessary oversizing for the power source of the installation. 

Crest factor 

Used to characterise the aptitude of a generator (or UPS) to supply high 

instantaneous currents. For example, computer equipment draws highly distorted 

current for which the crest factor can reach 3 to 5. 

Spectrum (decomposition of the signal into frequencies) 

It provides a different representation of electrical signals and can be used to evaluate 

their distortion. 

M13 


M14 



6 Measuring the indicators 

6.1 Devices used to measure the indicators 

Device selection 

The traditional observation and measurement methods include: 

b Observations using an oscilloscope 

An initial indication on the distortion affecting a signal can be obtained by viewing the 

current or the voltage on an oscilloscope. 

The waveform, when it diverges from a sinusoidal, clearly indicates the presence of 

harmonics. Current and voltage peaks can be viewed. 

Note, however, that this method does not offer precise quantification of the harmonic 

components 

b Analogue spectral analysers 

They are made up of passband filters coupled with an rms voltmeter. They offer 

mediocre performance and do not provide information on phase displacement. 

Only the recent digital analysers can determine sufficiently precisely the 

values of all the mentioned indicators. 

Functions of digital analysers 

The microprocessors in digital analysers: 

b Calculate the values of the harmonic indicators (power factor, crest factor, 

distortion power, THD) 

b Carry out various complementary functions (corrections, statistical detection, 

measurement management, display, communication, etc.) 

b In multi-channel analysers, supply virtually in real time the simultaneous spectral 

decomposition of the currents and voltages 

Analyser operation and data processing 

The analogue signals are converted into a series of numerical values. 

Using this data, an algorithm implementing the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) 

calculates the amplitudes and the phases of the harmonics over a large number of 

time windows. 

Most digital analysers measure harmonics up to order 20 or 25 when calculating the 

THD. 

Processing of the successive values calculated using the FFT (smoothing, 

classification, statistics) can be carried out by the measurement device or by external 

software. 

6.2 Procedures for harmonic analysis of distribution 

networks 

Measurements are carried out on industrial or commercial site: 

b Preventively, to obtain an overall idea on distribution-network status (network map) 

b In view of corrective action: 

v To determine the origin of a disturbance and determine the solutions required to 

eliminate it 

v To check the validity of a solution (followed by modifications in the distribution 

network to check the reduction in harmonics) 

Operating mode 

The current and voltage are studied: 

b At the supply source 

b On the busbars of the main distribution switchboard (or on the MV busbars) 

b On each outgoing circuit in the main distribution switchboard (or on the 

MV busbars) 

For the measurements, it is necessary to know the precise operating conditions 

of the installation and particularly the status of the capacitor banks (operating, not 

operating, the number of disconnected steps). 

Analysis results 

b Determine any necessary derating of equipment in the installation or 

b Quantify any necessary harmonic protection and filtering systems to be installed in 

the distribution network 

b Enable comparison between the measured values and the reference values of the 

utility (maximum harmonic values, acceptable values, reference values) 



6 Measuring the indicators 

Use of measurement devices 

Measurement devices serve to show both the instantaneous and long-term effects of 

harmonics. Analysis requires values spanning durations ranging from a few seconds 

to several minutes over observation periods of a number of days. 

The required values include: 

b The amplitudes of the harmonic currents and voltages 

b The individual harmonic content of each harmonic order of the current and voltage 

b The THD for the current and voltage 

b Where applicable, the phase displacement between the harmonic voltage and 

current of the same harmonic order and the phase of the harmonics with respect to a 

common reference (e.g. the fundamental voltage) 

6.3 Keeping a close eye on harmonics 

The harmonic indicators can be measured: 

b Either by devices permanently installed in the distribution network 

b Or by an expert present at least a half day on the site (limited perception) 

Permanent devices are preferable 

For a number of reasons, the installation of permanent measurement devices in the 

distribution network is preferable. 

b The presence of an expert is limited in time. Only a number of measurements at 

different points in the installation and over a sufficiently long period (one week to a 

month) provide an overall view of operation and take into account all the situations 

that can occur following: 

v Fluctuations in the supply source 

v Variations in the operation of the installation 

v The addition of new equipment in the installation 

b Measurement devices installed in the distribution network prepare and facilitate the 

diagnosis of the experts, thus reducing the number and duration of their visits 

b Permanent measurement devices detect any new disturbances arising following 

the installation of new equipment, the implementation of new operating modes or 

fluctuations in the supply network 

Take advantage of built-in measurement and detection devices 

Measurement and detection devices built into the electrical distribution equipment: 

b For an overall evaluation of network status (preventive analysis), avoid: 

v Renting measurement equipment 

v Calling in experts 

v Having to connect and disconnect the measurement equipment. 

For the overall evaluation of network status, the analysis on the main low-voltage 

distribution switchboards (MLVS) can often be carried out by the incoming device 

and/or the measurement devices equipping each outgoing circuit 

b For corrective action, are the means to: 

v Determine the operating conditions at the time of the incident 

v Draw up a map of the distribution network and evaluate the implemented solution 

The diagnosis is improved by the use of equipment intended for the studied problem. 


M15 


M16 



PowerLogic System with Power Meter and 

Circuit Monitor, Micrologic offer a complete 

range of devices for the detection of harmonic 

distortion 

Fig. M14 : Circuit monitor 

Fig. M15 : Micrologic H control unit with harmonic metering for 

Masterpact NT and NW circuit-breakers 

7 Detection devices 

Measurements are the first step in gaining control over harmonic pollution. 

Depending on the conditions in each installation, different types of equipment 

provide the necessary solution. 

Power-monitoring units 

Power Meter and Circuit Monitor in the PowerLogic System 

These products offer high-performance measurement capabilities for low and 

medium-voltage distribution networks. They are digital units that include powerquality 

monitoring functions. 

PowerLogic System is a complete offer comprising Power Meter (PM) and Circuit 

Monitor (CM). This highly modular offer covers needs ranging from the most simple 

(Power Meter) up to highly complex requirements (Circuit Monitor). These products 

can be used in new or existing installations where the level of power quality must be 

excellent. The operating mode can be local and/or remote. 

Depending on its position in the distribution network, a Power Meter provides an initial 

indication on power quality. The main measurements carried out by a Power Meter are: 

b Current and voltage THD 

b Power factor 

Depending on the version, these measurements can be combined with timestamping 

and alarm functions. 

A Circuit Monitor (see Fig. M14) carries out a detailed analysis of power quality 

and also analyses disturbances on the distribution network. The main functions of a 

Circuit Monitor are: 

b Measurement of over 100 electrical parameters 

b Storage in memory and time-stamping of minimum and maximum values for each 

electrical parameter 

b Alarm functions tripped by electrical parameter values 

b Recording of event data 

b Recording of current and voltage disturbances 

b Harmonic analysis 

b Waveform capture (disturbance monitoring) 

Micrologic - a power-monitoring unit built into the circuit-breaker 

For new installations, the Micrologic H control unit (see Fig. M15), an integral part 

of Masterpact power circuit-breakers, is particularly useful for measurements at the 

head of an installation or on large outgoing circuits. 

The Micrologic H control unit offers precise analysis of power quality and detailed 

diagnostics on events. It is designed for operation in conjunction with a switchboard 

display unit or a supervisor. It can: 

b Measure current, voltage, active and reactive power 

b Measure current and voltage THD 

b Display the amplitude and phase of current and voltage harmonics up to the 51 st order 

b Carry out waveform capture (disturbance monitoring) 

The functions offered by the Micrologic H control unit are equivalent to those of a 

Circuit Monitor. 

Operation of power-monitoring units 

Software for remote operation and analysis 

In the more general framework of a distribution network requiring monitoring, 

the possibility of interconnecting these various devices can be offered in a 

communication network, thus making it possible to centralise information and obtain 

an overall view of disturbances throughout the distribution network. 

Depending on the application, the operator can then carry out measurements in real 

time, calculate demand values, run waveform captures, anticipate on alarms, etc. 

The power-monitoring units transmit all the available data over either a Modbus, 

Digipact or Ethernet network. 

The essential goal of this system is to assist in identifying and planning maintenance 

work. It is an effective means to reduce servicing time and the cost of temporarily 

installing devices for on-site measurements or the sizing of equipment (filters). 

Supervision software SMS 

SMS is a very complete software used to analyse distribution networks, in conjunction 

with the products in the PowerLogic System. Installed on a standard PC, it can: 

b Display measurements in real time 

b Display historical logs over a given period 

b Select the manner in which data is presented (tables, various curves) 

b Carry out statistical processing of data (display bar charts) 



8 Solutions to attenuate 

harmonics 

There are three different types of solutions to attenuate harmonics: 

b Modifications in the installation 

b Special devices in the supply system 

b Filtering 

8.1 Basic solutions 

To limit the propagation of harmonics in the distribution network, different solutions 

are available and should be taken into account particularly when designing a new 


Position the non-linear loads upstream in the system 

Overall harmonic disturbances increase as the short-circuit power decreases. 

All economic considerations aside, it is preferable to connect the non-linear loads as 

far upstream as possible (see Fig. M16). 

Fig. M16 : Non-linear loads positioned as far upstream as possible (recommended layout) 

Group the non-linear loads 

When preparing the single-line diagram, the non-linear devices should be separated 

from the others (see Fig. M17). The two groups of devices should be supplied by 

different sets of busbars. 

Yes 


Z 1 

Non-linear 

loads 

Line impedances 

No 

Sensitive 

loads 

Non-linear 

load 1 

Non-linear 

load 2 

Fig. M17 : Grouping of non-linear loads and connection as far upstream as possible 

(recommended layout) 

Create separate sources 

In attempting to limit harmonics, an additional improvement can be obtained by 

creating a source via a separate transformer as indicated in the Figure M18 next 

page. 

The disadvantage is the increase in the cost of the installation. 

Z 2 

Where impedance 

Z 1 < Z 2 

Sensitive 

loads 

M17 


M18 




harmonics 

MV 

network 

Fig. M18 : Supply of non-linear loads via a separate transformer 

Transformers with special connections 


Non-linear 

loads 

Linear 

loads 

Different transformer connections can eliminate certain harmonic orders, as 

indicated in the examples below: 

b A Dyd connection suppresses 5 th and 7 th harmonics (see Fig. M19) 

b A Dy connection suppresses the 3 rd harmonic 

b A DZ 5 connection suppresses the 5 th harmonic 

h11, h13 

h5, h7, h11, h13 

h5, h7, h11, h13 

Fig. M19 : A Dyd transformer blocks propagation of the 5 th and 7 th harmonics to the upstream 

network 

Install reactors 

When variable-speed drives are supplied, it is possible to smooth the current 

by installing line reactors. By increasing the impedance of the supply circuit, the 

harmonic current is limited. 

Installation of harmonic suppression reactors on capacitor banks increases the 

impedance of the reactor/capacitor combination for high-order harmonics. 

This avoids resonance and protects the capacitors. 

Select the suitable system earthing arrangement 

TNC system 

In the TNC system, a single conductor (PEN) provides protection in the event of an 

earth fault and the flow of unbalance currents. 

Under steady-state conditions, the harmonic currents flow in the PEN. The latter, 

however, has a certain impedance with as a result slight differences in potential (a 

few volts) between devices that can cause electronic equipment to malfunction. 

The TNC system must therefore be reserved for the supply of power circuits at the 

head of the installation and must not be used to supply sensitive loads. 

TNS system 

This system is recommended if harmonics are present. 

The neutral conductor and the protection conductor PE are completely separate and 

the potential throughout the distribution network is therefore more uniform. 

8.2 Harmonic filtering 

In cases where the preventive action presented above is insufficient, it is necessary 

to equip the installation with filtering systems. 

There are three types of filters: 

b Passive 

b Active 

b Hybrid


I har 

Non-linear 

load 

Fig. M20 : Operating principle of a passive filter 

I har 

Non-linear 

load 

Filter 

AHC 

Fig. M22 : Operating principle of a hybrid filter 

Is 

Iact 

Fig. M21 : Operating principle of an active filter 

I har 

Non-linear 

load 

AHC 

Iact 

Hybride filter 

Linear 

load 

Is 

Linear 

load 


harmonics 

Passive filters 

Typical applications 

b Industrial installations with a set of non-linear loads representing more than 

200 kVA (variable-speed drives, UPSs, rectifiers, etc.) 

b Installations requiring power-factor correction 

b Installations where voltage distortion must be reduced to avoid disturbing sensitive 

loads 

b Installations where current distortion must be reduced to avoid overloads 

Operating principle 

An LC circuit, tuned to each harmonic order to be filtered, is installed in parallel with 

the non-linear load (see Fig. M20). This bypass circuit absorbs the harmonics, thus 

avoiding their flow in the distribution network. 

Generally speaking, the passive filter is tuned to a harmonic order close to the order 

to be eliminated. Several parallel-connected branches of filters can be used if a 

significant reduction in the distortion of a number of harmonic orders is required. 

Active filters (active harmonic conditioner) 


b Commercial installations with a set of non-linear loads representing less than 

200 kVA (variable-speed drives, UPSs, office equipment, etc.) 

b Installations where current distortion must be reduced to avoid overloads. 


These systems, comprising power electronics and installed in series or parallel with 

the non-linear load, compensate the harmonic current or voltage drawn by the load. 

Figure M21 shows a parallel-connected active harmonic conditioner (AHC) 

compensating the harmonic current (Ihar = -Iact). 

The AHC injects in opposite phase the harmonics drawn by the non-linear load, such 

that the line current Is remains sinusoidal. 

Hybrid filters 


b Industrial installations with a set of non-linear loads representing more than 

200 kVA (variable-speed drives, UPSs, rectifiers, etc.) 

b Installations requiring power-factor correction 

b Installations where voltage distortion must be reduced to avoid disturbing sensitive 

loads 

b Installations where current distortion must be reduced to avoid overloads 

b Installations where strict limits on harmonic emissions must be met 


Passive and active filters are combined in a single system to constitute a hybrid filter 

(see Fig. M22). This new filtering solution offers the advantages of both types of 

filters and covers a wide range of power and performance levels. 

Selection criteria 

Passive filter 

It offers both power-factor correction and high current-filtering capacity. 

Passive filters also reduce the harmonic voltages in installations where the supply 

voltage is disturbed. If the level of reactive power supplied is high, it is advised to turn 

off the passive filter at times when the percent load is low. 

Preliminary studies for a filter must take into account the possible presence of a 

power factor correction capacitor bank which may have to be eliminated. 

Active harmonic conditioners 

They filter harmonics over a wide range of frequencies and can adapt to any type of 

load. 

On the other hand, power ratings are low. 


They combine the performance of both active and passive filters. 


M19 


M20 



A complete set of services can be offered to 

eliminate harmonics: 

b Installation analysis 

b Measurement and monitoring systems 

b Filtering solutions 


harmonics 

8.3 The method 

The best solution, in both technical and financial terms, is based on the results of an 

in-depth study. 

Harmonic audit of MV and LV networks 

By calling on an expert, you are guaranteed that the proposed solution will produce 

effective results (e.g. a guaranteed maximum THDu). 

A harmonic audit is carried out by an engineer specialised in the disturbances 

affecting electrical distribution networks and equipped with powerful analysis and 

simulation equipment and software. 

The steps in an audit are the following: 

b Measurement of disturbances affecting current and phase-to-phase and phaseto-neutral 

voltages at the supply source, the disturbed outgoing circuits and the 

non-linear loads 

b Computer modelling of the phenomena to obtain a precise explanation of the 

causes and determine the best solutions 

b A complete audit report presenting: 

v The current levels of disturbances 

v The maximum permissible levels of disturbances (IEC 61000, IEC 34, etc.) 

b A proposal containing solutions with guaranteed levels of performance 

b Finally, implementation of the selected solution, using the necessary means and 

resources. 

The entire audit process is certified ISO 9002. 

8.4 Specific products 

Passive filters 

Passive filters are made up of coils and capacitors set up in resonant circuits tuned 

to the specific harmonic order that must be eliminated. 

A system may comprise a number of filters to eliminate several harmonic orders. 

Suitable for 400 V three-phase voltages, the power ratings can reach: 

b 265 kvar / 470 A for harmonic order 5 



Passive filters can be created for all voltage and current levels. 

Active filters 

b SineWave active harmonic conditioners 

v Suitable for 400 V three-phase voltages, they can deliver between 20 and 120 A 

per phase 

v SineWave covers all harmonic orders from 2 to 25. Conditioning can be total or 

target specific harmonic orders 

v Attenuation: THDi load / THDi upstream greater than 10 at rated capacity 

v Functions include power factor correction, conditioning of zero-sequence 

harmonics, diagnostics and maintenance system, parallel connection, remote 

control, Ibus/RS485 communication interface 

b Accusine active filters 

v Suitable for 400 and 480 V three-phase voltages, they can filter between 50 and 30 

A per phase 

v All harmonic orders up to 50 are filtered 

v Functions include power factor correction, parallel connection, instantaneous 

response to load variations 


These filters combine the advantages of both a passive filter and the SineWave 

active harmonic conditioner in a single system. 


N - Characteristics of particular sources and loads 

a - 

b - 

Fig. N35 : Compact fluorescent lamps [a] standard, 

[b] induction 

4 Lighting circuits 

A source of comfort and productivity, lighting represents 15% of the quantity of 

electricity consumed in industry and 40% in buildings. The quality of lighting (light 

stability and continuity of service) depends on the quality of the electrical energy 

thus consumed. The supply of electrical power to lighting networks has therefore 

assumed great importance. 

To help with their design and simplify the selection of appropriate protection devices, 

an analysis of the different lamp technologies is presented. The distinctive features 

of lighting circuits and their impact on control and protection devices are discussed. 

Recommendations relative to the difficulties of lighting circuit implementation are given. 

4.1 The different lamp technologies 

Artificial luminous radiation can be produced from electrical energy according to two 

principles: incandescence and electroluminescence. 

Incandescence is the production of light via temperature elevation. The most 

common example is a filament heated to white state by the circulation of an electrical 

current. The energy supplied is transformed into heat by the Joule effect and into 

luminous flux. 

Luminescence is the phenomenon of emission by a material of visible or almost 

visible luminous radiation. A gas (or vapors) subjected to an electrical discharge 

emits luminous radiation (Electroluminescence of gases). 

Since this gas does not conduct at normal temperature and pressure, the discharge 

is produced by generating charged particles which permit ionization of the gas. The 

nature, pressure and temperature of the gas determine the light spectrum. 

Photoluminescence is the luminescence of a material exposed to visible or almost 

visible radiation (ultraviolet, infrared). 

When the substance absorbs ultraviolet radiation and emits visible radiation which 

stops a short time after energization, this is fluorescence. 

Incandescent lamps 

Incandescent lamps are historically the oldest and the most often found in common 

use. 

They are based on the principle of a filament rendered incandescent in a vacuum or 

neutral atmosphere which prevents combustion. 

A distinction is made between: 

b Standard bulbs 

These contain a tungsten filament and are filled with an inert gas (nitrogen and 

argon or krypton). 

b Halogen bulbs 

These also contain a tungsten filament, but are filled with a halogen compound 

and an inert gas (krypton or xenon). This halogen compound is responsible for the 

phenomenon of filament regeneration, which increases the service life of the lamps 

and avoids them blackening. It also enables a higher filament temperature and 

therefore greater luminosity in smaller-size bulbs. 

The main disadvantage of incandescent lamps is their significant heat dissipation, 

resulting in poor luminous efficiency. 

Fluorescent lamps 

This family covers fluorescent tubes and compact fluorescent lamps. Their 

technology is usually known as “low-pressure mercury”. 

In fluorescent tubes, an electrical discharge causes electrons to collide with 

ions of mercury vapor, resulting in ultraviolet radiation due to energization of the 

mercury atoms. The fluorescent material, which covers the inside of the tubes, then 

transforms this radiation into visible light. 

Fluorescent tubes dissipate less heat and have a longer service life than 

incandescent lamps, but they do need an ignition device called a “starter” and a 

device to limit the current in the arc after ignition. This device called “ballast” is 

usually a choke placed in series with the arc. 

Compact fluorescent lamps are based on the same principle as a fluorescent tube. 

The starter and ballast functions are provided by an electronic circuit (integrated in 

the lamp) which enables the use of smaller tubes folded back on themselves. 

Compact fluorescent lamps (see Fig. N35) were developed to replace incandescent 

lamps: They offer significant energy savings (15 W against 75 W for the same level of 

brightness) and an increased service life. 

Lamps known as “induction” type or “without electrodes” operate on the principle of 

ionization of the gas present in the tube by a very high frequency electromagnetic 

field (up to 1 GHz). Their service life can be as long as 100,000 hrs. 


N27 


N28 



Fig. N36 : Discharge lamps 

Discharge lamps (see Fig. N36) 

The light is produced by an electrical discharge created between two electrodes within 

a gas in a quartz bulb. All these lamps therefore require a ballast to limit the current in 

the arc. A number of technologies have been developed for different applications. 

Low-pressure sodium vapor lamps have the best light output, however the color 

rendering is very poor since they only have a monochromatic orange radiation. 

High-pressure sodium vapor lamps produce a white light with an orange tinge. 

In high-pressure mercury vapor lamps, the discharge is produced in a quartz or 

ceramic bulb at high pressure. These lamps are called “fluorescent mercury discharge 

lamps”. They produce a characteristically bluish white light. 

Metal halide lamps are the latest technology. They produce a color with a broad color 

spectrum. The use of a ceramic tube offers better luminous efficiency and better color 

stability. 

Light Emitting Diodes (LED) 

The principle of light emitting diodes is the emission of light by a semi-conductor 

as an electrical current passes through it. LEDs are commonly found in numerous 

applications, but the recent development of white or blue diodes with a high light 

output opens new perspectives, especially for signaling (traffic lights, exit signs or 

emergency lighting). 

LEDs are low-voltage and low-current devices, thus suitable for battery-supply. 

A converter is required for a line power supply. 

The advantage of LEDs is their low energy consumption. As a result, they operate 

at a very low temperature, giving them a very long service life. Conversely, a simple 

diode has a weak light intensity. A high-power lighting installation therefore requires 

connection of a large number of units in series and parallel. 

Technology Application Advantages Disadvantages 

Standard - Domestic use - Direct connection without - Low luminous efficiency and 

incandescent - Localized decorative intermediate switchgear high electricity consumption 

lighting - Reasonable purchase price - Significant heat dissipation 

- Compact size - Short service life 

- Instantaneous lighting 

- Good color rendering 

Halogen - Spot lighting - Direct connection - Average luminous efficiency 

incandescent - Intense lighting - Instantaneous efficiency 

- Excellent color rendering 

Fluorescent tube - Shops, offices, workshops - High luminous efficiency - Low light intensity of single unit 

- Outdoors - Average color rendering - Sensitive to extreme temperatures 

Compact - Domestic use - Good luminous efficiency - High initial investment 

fluorescent lamp - Offices - Good color rendering compared to incandescent lamps 

- Replacement of 

incandescent lamps 

HP mercury vapor - Workshops, halls, hangars - Good luminous efficiency - Lighting and relighting time 

- Factory floors - Acceptable color rendering of a few minutes 

- Compact size 

- Long service life 

High-pressure - Outdoors - Very good luminous efficiency - Lighting and relighting time 

sodium - Large halls of a few minutes 

Low-pressure - Outdoors - Good visibility in foggy weather - Long lighting time (5 min.) 

sodium - Emergency lighting - Economical to use - Mediocre color rendering 

Metal halide - Large areas - Good luminous efficiency - Lighting and relighting time 

- Halls with high ceilings - Good color rendering of a few minutes 

- Long service life 

LED - Signaling (3-color traffic - Insensitive to the number of - Limited number of colors 

lights, “exit” signs and switching operations - Low brightness of single unit 

emergency lighting) - Low energy consumption 

- Low temperature 

Technology Power (watt) Efficiency (lumen/watt) Service life (hours) 

Standard incandescent 3 – 1,000 10 – 15 1,000 – 2,000 

Halogen incandescent 5 – 500 15 – 25 2,000 – 4,000 

Fluorescent tube 4 – 56 50 – 100 7,500 – 24,000 

Compact fluorescent lamp 5 – 40 50 – 80 10,000 – 20,000 

HP mercury vapor 40 – 1,000 25 – 55 16,000 – 24,000 

High-pressure sodium 35 – 1,000 40 – 140 16,000 – 24,000 

Low-pressure sodium 35 – 180 100 – 185 14,000 – 18,000 

Metal halide 30 – 2,000 50 – 115 6,000 – 20,000 

LED 0.05 – 0.1 10 – 30 40,000 – 100,000 

Fig. N37 : Usage and technical characteristics of lighting devices 




a] 

300 

200 

100 

0 

-100 

-200 

-300 

0 

b] 

300 

200 

100 

0 

-100 

-200 

0.01 0.02 

-300 

0 0.01 0.02 

t (s) 

t (s) 

Fig. N38 : Shape of the voltage supplied by a light dimmer at 

50% of maximum voltage with the following techniques: 

a] “cut-on control” 

b] “cut-off control” 


4.2 Electrical characteristics of lamps 

Incandescent lamps with direct power supply 

Due to the very high temperature of the filament during operation (up to 2,500 °C), 

its resistance varies greatly depending on whether the lamp is on or off. As the cold 

resistance is low, a current peak occurs on ignition that can reach 10 to 15 times the 

nominal current for a few milliseconds or even several milliseconds. 

This constraint affects both ordinary lamps and halogen lamps: it imposes a 

reduction in the maximum number of lamps that can be powered by devices such as 

remote-control switches, modular contactors and relays for busbar trunking. 

Extra Low Voltage (ELV) halogen lamps 

b Some low-power halogen lamps are supplied with ELV 12 or 24 V, via a 

transformer or an electronic converter. With a transformer, the magnetization 

phenomenon combines with the filament resistance variation phenomenon at 

switch-on. The inrush current can reach 50 to 75 times the nominal current for a few 

milliseconds. The use of dimmer switches placed upstream significantly reduces this 

constraint. 

b Electronic converters, with the same power rating, are more expensive than 

solutions with a transformer. This commercial handicap is compensated by a greater 

ease of installation since their low heat dissipation means they can be fixed on a 

flammable support. Moreover, they usually have built-in thermal protection. 

New ELV halogen lamps are now available with a transformer integrated in their 

base. They can be supplied directly from the LV line supply and can replace normal 

lamps without any special adaptation. 

Dimming for incandescent lamps 

This can be obtained by varying the voltage applied to the lampere 

This voltage variation is usually performed by a device such as a Triac dimmer 

switch, by varying its firing angle in the line voltage period. The wave form of the 

voltage applied to the lamp is illustrated in Figure N38a. This technique known 

as “cut-on control” is suitable for supplying power to resistive or inductive circuits. 

Another technique suitable for supplying power to capacitive circuits has been 

developed with MOS or IGBT electronic components. This techniques varies the 

voltage by blocking the current before the end of the half-period (see Fig. N38b) and 

is known as “cut-off control”. 

Switching on the lamp gradually can also reduce, or even eliminate, the current peak 

on ignition. 

As the lamp current is distorted by the electronic switching, harmonic currents 

are produced. The 3 

N29 

rd harmonic order is predominant, and the percentage of 3rd harmonic current related to the maximum fundamental current (at maximum power) 

is represented on Figure N39. 

Note that in practice, the power applied to the lamp by a dimmer switch can only vary 

in the range between 15 and 85% of the maximum power of the lampere 

50.0 

45.0 

40.0 

35.0 

30.0 

25.0 

20.0 

15.0 

10.0 

5.0 

0 

i3 (%) 

0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 80.0 90.0 100.0 

Fig. N39 : Percentage of 3 rd harmonic current as a function of the power applied to an 

incandescent lamp using an electronic dimmer switch 


Power (%) 


N30 



Fig. N40 : Magnetic ballasts 


According to IEC standard 61000-3-2 setting harmonic emission limits for electric or 

electronic systems with current y 16 A, the following arrangements apply: 

b Independent dimmers for incandescent lamps with a rated power less than or 

equal to 1 kW have no limits applied 

b Otherwise, or for incandescent lighting equipment with built-in dimmer or dimmer 

built in an enclosure, the maximum permissible 3 rd harmonic current is equal to 

2.30 A 

Fluorescent lamps with magnetic ballast 

Fluorescent tubes and discharge lamps require the intensity of the arc to be limited, 

and this function is fulfilled by a choke (or magnetic ballast) placed in series with the 

bulb itself (see Fig. N40). 

This arrangement is most commonly used in domestic applications with a limited 

number of tubes. No particular constraint applies to the switches. 

Dimmer switches are not compatible with magnetic ballasts: the cancellation of the 

voltage for a fraction of the period interrupts the discharge and totally extinguishes 

the lampere 

The starter has a dual function: preheating the tube electrodes, and then generating 

an overvoltage to ignite the tube. This overvoltage is generated by the opening of a 

contact (controlled by a thermal switch) which interrupts the current circulating in the 

magnetic ballast. 

During operation of the starter (approx. 1 s), the current drawn by the luminaire is 

approximately twice the nominal current. 

Since the current drawn by the tube and ballast assembly is essentially inductive, the 

power factor is very low (on average between 0.4 and 0.5). In installations consisting 

of a large number of tubes, it is necessary to provide compensation to improve the 

power factor. 

For large lighting installations, centralized compensation with capacitor banks is a 

possible solution, but more often this compensation is included at the level of each 

luminaire in a variety of different layouts (see Fig. N41). 

a] Ballast b] C Ballast c] 

a 

C Lamp a 


Lamp 

a 

C 

Ballast 

Lamp 

Ballast Lamp 

Compensation layout Application Comments 

Without compensation Domestic Single connection 

Parallel [a] Offices, workshops, 

superstores 

Risk of overcurrents for control devices 

Series [b] Choose capacitors with high 

operating voltage (450 to 480 V) 

Duo [c] Avoids flicker 

Fig. N41 : The various compensation layouts: a] parallel; b] series; c] dual series also called 

“duo” and their fields of application 

The compensation capacitors are therefore sized so that the global power factor is 

greater than 0.85. In the most common case of parallel compensation, its capacity 

is on average 1 µF for 10 W of active power, for any type of lampere However, this 

compensation is incompatible with dimmer switches. 

Constraints affecting compensation 

The layout for parallel compensation creates constraints on ignition of the lampere 

Since the capacitor is initially discharged, switch-on produces an overcurrent. 

An overvoltage also appears, due to the oscillations in the circuit made up of the 

capacitor and the power supply inductance. 

The following example can be used to determine the orders of magnitude.



Assuming an assembly of 50 fluorescent tubes of 36 W each: 

b Total active power: 1,800 W 

b Apparent power: 2 kVA 

b Total rms current: 9 A 

b Peak current: 13 A 

With: 

b A total capacity: C = 175 µF 

b A line inductance (corresponding to a short-circuit current of 5 kA): L = 150 µH 

The maximum peak current at switch-on equals: 

-6 

C 

x 10 

Ic = Vmax 

= 230 2 = A 

L 

-6 

x 10 

175 

350 

150 

The theoretical peak current at switch-on can therefore reach 27 times the peak 

current during normal operation. 

The shape of the voltage and current at ignition is given in Figure N42 for switch 

closing at the line supply voltage peak. 

There is therefore a risk of contact welding in electromechanical control devices 

(remote-control switch, contactor, circuit-breaker) or destruction of solid state 

switches with semi-conductors. 

600 

400 

200 

0 

-200 

-400 

-600 

0 

300 

200 

100 

0 

-100 

-200 

(V) 

(A) 

-300 

0 

Fig. N42 : Power supply voltage at switch-on and inrush current 


0.02 0.04 0.06 

0.02 0.04 0.06 

In reality, the constraints are usually less severe, due to the impedance of the cables. 

Ignition of fluorescent tubes in groups implies one specific constraint. When a group 

of tubes is already switched on, the compensation capacitors in these tubes which 

are already energized participate in the inrush current at the moment of ignition of 

a second group of tubes: they “amplify” the current peak in the control switch at the 

moment of ignition of the second group. 

t (s) 

t (s) 

N31 


N32 



Fig. N44 : Electronic ballast 


The table in Figure N43, resulting from measurements, specifies the magnitude of 

the first current peak, for different values of prospective short-circuit current Isc. It is 

seen that the current peak can be multiplied by 2 or 3, depending on the number of 

tubes already in use at the moment of connection of the last group of tubes. 

Number of tubes Number of tubes Inrush current peak (A) 

already in use connected Isc = 1,500 A Isc = 3,000 A Isc = 6,000 A 

0 14 233 250 320 

14 14 558 556 575 

28 14 608 607 624 

42 14 618 616 632 

Fig. N43 : Magnitude of the current peak in the control switch of the moment of ignition of a 

second group of tubes 

Nonetheless, sequential ignition of each group of tubes is recommended so as to 

reduce the current peak in the main switch. 

The most recent magnetic ballasts are known as “low-loss”. The magnetic circuit has 

been optimized, but the operating principle remains the same. This new generation 

of ballasts is coming into widespread use, under the influence of new regulations 

(European Directive, Energy Policy Act - USA). 

In these conditions, the use of electronic ballasts is likely to increase, to the 

detriment of magnetic ballasts. 

Fluorescent lamps with electronic ballast 

Electronic ballasts are used as a replacement for magnetic ballasts to supply power 

to fluorescent tubes (including compact fluorescent lamps) and discharge lamps. 

They also provide the “starter” function and do not need any compensation capacity. 

The principle of the electronic ballast (see Fig. N44) consists of supplying the lamp 

arc via an electronic device that generates a rectangular form AC voltage with a 

frequency between 20 and 60 kHz. 

Supplying the arc with a high-frequency voltage can totally eliminate the flicker 

phenomenon and strobe effects. The electronic ballast is totally silent. 

During the preheating period of a discharge lamp, this ballast supplies the lamp with 

increasing voltage, imposing an almost constant current. In steady state, it regulates 

the voltage applied to the lamp independently of any fluctuations in the line voltage. 

Since the arc is supplied in optimum voltage conditions, this results in energy 

savings of 5 to 10% and increased lamp service life. Moreover, the efficiency of the 

electronic ballast can exceed 93%, whereas the average efficiency of a magnetic 

device is only 85%. 

The power factor is high (> 0.9). 

The electronic ballast is also used to provide the light dimming function. Varying the 

frequency in fact varies the current magnitude in the arc and hence the luminous 

intensity. 

Inrush current 

The main constraint that electronic ballasts bring to line supplies is the high 

inrush current on switch-on linked to the initial load of the smoothing capacitors 

(see Fig. N45). 

Technology Max. inrush current Duration 

Rectifier with PFC 30 to 100 In y 1 ms 

Rectifier with choke 10 to 30 In y 5 ms 

Magnetic ballast y 13 In 5 to 10 ms 

Fig. N45 : Orders of magnitude of the inrush current maximum values, depending on the 

technologies used 




In reality, due to the wiring impedances, the inrush currents for an assembly of lamps 

is much lower than these values, in the order of 5 to 10 In for less than 5 ms. 

Unlike magnetic ballasts, this inrush current is not accompanied by an overvoltage. 

Harmonic currents 

For ballasts associated with high-power discharge lamps, the current drawn from 

the line supply has a low total harmonic distortion (< 20% in general and < 10% for 

the most sophisticated devices). Conversely, devices associated with low-power 

lamps, in particular compact fluorescent lamps, draw a very distorted current 

(see Fig. N46). The total harmonic distortion can be as high as 150%. In these 

conditions, the rms current drawn from the line supply equals 1.8 times the current 

corresponding to the lamp active power, which corresponds to a power factor of 0.55. 

0.6 

0.4 

0.2 

0 

-0.2 

-0.4 

(A) 

-0.6 

0 

Fig. N46 : Shape of the current drawn by a compact fluorescent lamp 


0.02 

In order to balance the load between the different phases, lighting circuits are usually 

connected between phases and neutral in a balanced way. In these conditions, 

the high level of third harmonic and harmonics that are multiple of 3 can cause an 

overload of the neutral conductor. The least favorable situation leads to a neutral 

current which may reach 3 times the current in each phase. 

Harmonic emission limits for electric or electronic systems are set by IEC standard 

61000-3-2. For simplification, the limits for lighting equipment are given here only for 

harmonic orders 3 and 5 which are the most relevant (see Fig. N47). 

Harmonic Active input Active input power y 25W 

order power > 25W one of the 2 sets of limits apply: 

% of fundamental % of fundamental Harmonic current relative 

current current to active power 

3 30 86 3.4 mA/W 

5 10 61 1.9 mA/W 

Fig. N47 : Maximum permissible harmonic current 

Leakage currents 

Electronic ballasts usually have capacitors placed between the power supply 

conductors and the earth. These interference-suppressing capacitors are responsible 

for the circulation of a permanent leakage current in the order of 0.5 to 1 mA per 

ballast. This therefore results in a limit being placed on the number of ballasts that 

can be supplied by a Residual Current Differential Safety Device (RCD). 

At switch-on, the initial load of these capacitors can also cause the circulation of a 

current peak whose magnitude can reach several amps for 10 µs. This current peak 

may cause unwanted tripping of unsuitable devices. 

t (s) 

N33 


N34 




High-frequency emissions 

Electronic ballasts are responsible for high-frequency conducted and radiated 

emissions. 

The very steep rising edges applied to the ballast output conductors cause current 

pulses circulating in the stray capacities to earth. As a result, stray currents circulate 

in the earth conductor and the power supply conductors. Due to the high frequency 

of these currents, there is also electromagnetic radiation. To limit these HF emissions, 

the lamp should be placed in the immediate proximity of the ballast, thus reducing 

the length of the most strongly radiating conductors. 

The different power supply modes (see Fig. N48) 

Technology Power supply mode Other device 

Standard incandescent Direct power supply Dimmer switch 

Halogen incandescent 

ELV halogen incandescent Transformer Electronic converter 

Fluorescent tube Magnetic ballast and starter Electronic ballast 

Electronic dimmer + 

ballast 

Compact fluorescent lamp Built-in electronic ballast 

Mercury vapor Magnetic ballast Electronic ballast 

High-pressure sodium 

Low-pressure sodium 

Metal halide 

Fig. N48 : Different power supply modes 

4.3 Constraints related to lighting devices and 

recommendations 

The current actually drawn by luminaires 

The risk 

This characteristic is the first one that should be defined when creating an 

installation, otherwise it is highly probable that overload protection devices will trip 

and users may often find themselves in the dark. 

It is evident that their determination should take into account the consumption of 

all components, especially for fluorescent lighting installations, since the power 

consumed by the ballasts has to be added to that of the tubes and bulbs. 

The solution 

For incandescent lighting, it should be remembered that the line voltage can be more 

than 10% of its nominal value, which would then cause an increase in the current 

drawn. 

For fluorescent lighting, unless otherwise specified, the power of the magnetic 

ballasts can be assessed at 25% of that of the bulbs. For electronic ballasts, this 

power is lower, in the order of 5 to 10%. 

The thresholds for the overcurrent protection devices should therefore be calculated 

as a function of the total power and the power factor, calculated for each circuit. 

Overcurrents at switch-on 

The risk 

The devices used for control and protection of lighting circuits are those such as 

relays, triac, remote-control switches, contactors or circuit-breakers. 

The main constraint applied to these devices is the current peak on energization. 

This current peak depends on the technology of the lamps used, but also on the 

installation characteristics (supply transformer power, length of cables, number of 

lamps) and the moment of energization in the line voltage period. A high current 

peak, however fleeting, can cause the contacts on an electromechanical control 

device to weld together or the destruction of a solid state device with semiconductors. 




Two solutions 

Because of the inrush current, the majority of ordinary relays are incompatible with 

lighting device power supply. The following recommendations are therefore usually 

made: 

b Limit the number of lamps to be connected to a single device so that their total 

power is less than the maximum permissible power for the device 

b Check with the manufacturers what operating limits they suggest for the devices. 

This precaution is particularly important when replacing incandescent lamps with 

compact fluorescent lamps 

By way of example, the table in Figure N49 indicates the maximum number of 

compensated fluorescent tubes that can be controlled by different devices with 

16 A rating. Note that the number of controlled tubes is well below the number 

corresponding to the maximum power for the devices. 

Tube unit power Number of tubes Maximum number of tubes that can be 

requirement corresponding controlled by 

(W) to the power Contactors Remote Circuit- 

16 A x 230 V GC16 A control breakers 

CT16 A switches C60-16 A 

TL16 A 

18 204 15 50 112 

36 102 15 25 56 

58 63 10 16 34 

Fig. N49 : The number of controlled tubes is well below the number corresponding to the 

maximum power for the devices 

But a technique exists to limit the current peak on energization of circuits with 

capacitive behavior (magnetic ballasts with parallel compensation and electronic 

ballasts). It consists of ensuring that activation occurs at the moment when the line 

voltage passes through zero. Only solid state switches with semi-conductors offer 

this possibility (see Fig. N50a). This technique has proved to be particularly useful 

when designing new lighting circuits. 

More recently, hybrid technology devices have been developed that combine a solid 

state switch (activation on voltage passage through zero) and an electromechanical 

contactor short-circuiting the solid state switch (reduction of losses in the semiconductors) 

(see Fig. N50b). 


a b c 

Fig. N50 : “Standard” CT+ contactor [a], CT+ contactor with manual override, pushbutton for 

selection of operating mode and indicator lamp showing the active operating mode [b], and TL + 

remote-control switch [c] (Merlin Gerin brand) 

N35 


N36 



Modular contactors and impulse relays do 

not use the same technologies. Their rating is 

determined according to different standards. 

For example, for a given rating, an impulse 

relay is more efficient than a modular 

contactor for the control of light fittings with 

a strong inrush current, or with a low power 

factor (non-compensated inductive circuit). 

Type 

of lamp 

Unit power 

and capacitance of power factor 

correction capacitor 


Choice of relay rating according to lamp type 

b Figure 51 below shows the maximum number of light fittings for each relay, 

according to the type, power and configuration of a given lamp. As an indication, the 

total acceptable power is also mentioned. 

b These values are given for a 230 V circuit with 2 active conductors (single-phase 

phase/neutral or two-phase phase/phase). For 110 V circuits, divide the values in the 

table by 2. 

b To obtain the equivalent values for the whole of a 230 V three-phase circuit, 

multiply the number of lamps and the total acceptable power: 

v by 3 (1.73) for circuits without neutral; 

v by 3 for circuits with neutral. 

Note: The power ratings of the lamps most commonly used are shown in bold. 

Maximum number of light fittings for a single-phase circuit 

and maximum power output per circuit 

TL impulse relay CT contactor 

16 A 32 A 16 A 25 A 40 A 63 A 

Basic incandescent lamps 

LV halogen lamps 

Replacement mercury vapour lamps (without ballast) 

40 W 40 1500 W 106 4000 W 38 1550 W 57 2300 W 115 4600 W 

60 W 25 to 66 to 30 to 45 to 85 to 125 

75 W 20 1600 W 53 4200 W 25 2000 W 38 2850 W 70 5250 W 100 

100 W 16 42 19 28 50 73 

150 W 10 28 12 18 35 50 

200 W 8 21 10 14 26 37 

300 W 5 1500 W 13 4000 W 7 2100 W 10 3000 W 18 5500 W 

500 W 3 8 4 6 10 to 15 

1000 W 1 4 2 3 6 6000 W 8 

1500 W 

ELV 12 or 24 V halogen lamps 

1 2 1 2 4 5 

With ferromagnetic transformer 20 W 70 1350 W 180 3600 W 15 300 W 23 450 W 42 850 W 

50 W 28 to 74 to 10 to 15 to 27 to 42 

75 W 19 1450 W 50 3750 W 8 600 W 12 900 W 23 1950 W 35 

100 W 14 37 6 8 18 27 

With electronic transformer 20 W 60 1200 W 160 3200 W 62 1250 W 90 1850 W 182 3650 W 

50 W 25 to 65 to 25 to 39 to 76 to 114 

75 W 18 1400 W 44 3350 W 20 1600 W 28 2250 W 53 4200 W 78 

100 W 

Fluorescent tubes with starter and ferromagnetic ballast 

14 33 16 22 42 60 

1 tube 

15 W 83 1250 W 213 3200 W 22 330 W 30 450 W 70 1050 W 

without compensation (1) 

18 W 

20 W 

70 

62 

to 

1300 W 

186 

160 

to 

3350 W 

22 

22 

to 

850 W 

30 

30 

to 

1200 W 

70 

70 

to 

2400 W 

100 

100 

36 W 35 93 20 28 60 90 

40 W 31 81 20 28 60 90 

58 W 21 55 13 17 35 56 

65 W 20 50 13 17 35 56 

80 W 16 41 10 15 30 48 

115 W 11 29 7 10 20 32 

1 tube 

15 W 5 µF 60 900 W 160 2400 W 15 200 W 20 300 W 40 600 W 

with parallel compensation (2) 18 W 5 µF 50 133 15 to 20 to 40 to 60 

20 W 5 µF 45 120 15 800 W 20 1200 W 40 2400 W 60 

36 W 5 µF 25 66 15 20 40 60 

40 W 5 µF 22 60 15 20 40 60 

58 W 7 µF 16 42 10 15 30 43 

65 W 7 µF 13 37 10 15 30 43 

80 W 7 µF 11 30 10 15 30 43 

115 W 16 µF 7 20 5 7 14 20 

2 or 4 tubes 

2 x 18 W 56 2000 W 148 5300 W 30 1100 W 46 1650 W 80 2900 W 

with series compensation 

4 x 18 W 

2 x 36 W 

28 

28 

74 

74 

16 

16 

to 

1500 W 

24 

24 

to 

2400 W 

44 

44 

to 

3800 W 

68 

68 

2 x 58 W 17 45 10 16 27 42 

2 x 65 W 15 40 10 16 27 42 

2 x 80 W 12 33 9 13 22 34 

2 x 115 W 8 23 6 10 16 25 

Fluorescent tubes with electronic ballast 

1 or 2 tubes 18 W 80 1450 W 212 3800 W 74 1300 W 111 2000 W 222 4000 W 

36 W 40 to 106 to 38 to 58 to 117 to 176 

58 W 26 1550 W 69 4000 W 25 1400 W 37 2200 W 74 4400 W 111 

2 x 18 W 40 106 36 55 111 166 

2 x 36 W 20 53 20 30 60 90 

2 x 58 W 13 34 12 19 38 57 

Fig. N51 : Maximum number of light fittings for each relay, according to the type, power and configuration of a given lamp (Continued on opposite page) 


172 6900 W 

to 

7500 W 

25 7500 W 

to 

8000 W 

63 1250 W 

to 

2850 W 

275 5500 W 

to 

6000 W 

100 1500 W 

to 

3850 W 

60 900 W 

to 

3500 W 

123 4450 W 

to 

5900 W 

333 6000 W 

to 

6600 W


Type 

of lamp 

Unit power 

and capacitance of power factor 

correction capacitor 


Maximum number of light fittings for a single-phase circuit 

and maximum power output per circuit 

TL impulse relay CT contactor 

16 A 32 A 16 A 25 A 40 A 63 A 

Compact fluorescent lamps 

With external electronic ballast 5 W 240 1200 W 630 3150 W 210 1050 W 330 1650 W 670 3350 W not tested 

7 W 171 to 457 to 150 to 222 to 478 to 

9 W 138 1450 W 366 3800 W 122 1300 W 194 2000 W 383 4000 W 

11 W 118 318 104 163 327 

18 W 77 202 66 105 216 

26 W 55 146 50 76 153 

With integral electronic ballast 5 W 170 850 W 390 1950 W 160 800 W 230 1150 W 470 2350 W 710 3550 W 

(replacement for incandescent 7 W 121 to 285 to 114 to 164 to 335 to 514 to 

lamps) 

9 W 100 1050 W 233 2400 W 94 900 W 133 1300 W 266 2600 W 411 3950 W 

11 W 86 200 78 109 222 340 

18 W 55 127 48 69 138 213 

26 W 40 92 34 50 100 151 

High-pressure mercury vapour lamps with ferromagnetic ballast without ignitor 

Replacement high-pressure sodium vapour lamps with ferromagnetic ballast with integral ignitor (3) 

Without compensation (1) 50 W not tested, 

15 750 W 20 1000 W 34 1700 W 53 2650 W 

80 W infrequent use 

10 to 15 to 27 to 40 to 

125 / 110 W (3) 8 1000 W 10 1600 W 20 2800 W 28 4200 W 

250 / 220 W (3) 4 6 10 15 

400 / 350 W (3) 2 4 6 10 

700 W 1 2 4 6 

With parallel compensation (2) 50 W 7 µF 10 500 W 15 750 W 28 1400 W 43 2150 W 

80 W 8 µF 9 to 13 to 25 to 38 to 

125 / 110 W (3) 10 µF 9 1400 W 10 1600 W 20 3500 W 30 5000 W 

250 / 220 W (3) 18 µF 4 6 11 17 

400 / 350 W (3) 25 µF 3 4 8 12 

700 W 40 µF 2 2 5 7 

1000 W 60 µF 0 1 3 5 

Low-pressure sodium vapour lamps with ferromagnetic ballast with external ignitor 

Without compensation (1) 35 W not tested, 

5 270 W 9 320 W 14 500 W 24 850 W 

55 W infrequent use 

5 to 9 to 14 to 24 to 

90 W 3 360 W 6 720 W 9 1100 W 19 1800 W 

135 W 2 4 6 10 

180 W 2 4 6 10 

With parallel compensation (2) 35 W 20 µF 38 1350 W 102 3600 W 3 100 W 5 175 W 10 350 W 15 550 W 

55 W 20 µF 24 63 3 to 5 to 10 to 15 to 

90 W 26 µF 15 40 2 180 W 4 360 W 8 720 W 11 1100 W 

135 W 40 µF 10 26 1 2 5 7 

180 W 45 µF 7 18 1 2 4 6 

High-pressure sodium vapour lamps 

Metal-iodide lamps 

With ferromagnetic ballast with 35 W not tested, 

16 600 W 24 850 W 42 1450 W 64 2250 W 

external ignitor, without 70 W infrequent use 

8 12 to 20 to 32 to 

compensation (1) 

150 W 4 7 1200 W 13 2000 W 18 3200 W 

250 W 2 4 8 11 

400 W 1 3 5 8 

1000 W 0 1 2 3 

With ferromagnetic ballast with 35 W 6 µF 34 1200 W 88 3100 W 12 450 W 18 650 W 31 1100 W 50 1750 W 

external ignitor and parallel 70 W 12 µF 17 to 45 to 6 to 9 to 16 to 25 to 

compensation (2) 

150 W 20 µF 8 1350 W 22 3400 W 4 1000 W 6 2000 W 10 4000 W 15 6000 W 

250 W 32 µF 5 13 3 4 7 10 

400 W 45 µF 3 8 2 3 5 7 

1000 W 60 µF 1 3 1 2 3 5 

2000 W 85 µF 0 1 0 1 2 3 

With electronic ballast 35 W 38 1350 W 87 3100 W 24 850 W 38 1350 W 68 2400 W 102 3600 W 

70 W 29 to 77 to 18 to 29 to 51 to 76 to 

150 W 14 2200 W 33 5000 W 9 1350 W 14 2200 W 26 4000 W 40 6000 W 

(1) Circuits with non-compensated ferromagnetic ballasts consume twice as much current for a given lamp power output. This explains the small number of lamps in this 

configuration. 

(2) The total capacitance of the power factor correction capacitors in parallel in a circuit limits the number of lamps that can be controlled by a contactor. The total 

downstream capacitance of a modular contactor of rating 16, 25, 40 or 63 A should not exceed 75, 100, 200 or 300 µF respectively. Allow for these limits to calculate the 

maximum acceptable number of lamps if the capacitance values are different from those in the table. 

(3) High-pressure mercury vapour lamps without ignitor, of power 125, 250 and 400 W, are gradually being replaced by high-pressure sodium vapour lamps with integral 

ignitor, and respective power of 110, 220 and 350 W. 

Fig. N51 : Maximum number of light fittings for each relay, according to the type, power and configuration of a given lamp (Concluded) 


N37 


N38 



Lamp 

power (W) 

Fig. N52 : Fluorescent tubes with electronic ballast - Vac = 230 V 

Protection of lamp circuits: Maximum number of lamps and MCB rating versus 

lamp type, unit power and MCB tripping curve 

During start up of discharge lamps (with their ballast), the inrush current drawn by 

each lamp may be in the order of: 

b 25 x circuit start current for the first 3 ms 

b 7 x circuit start current for the following 2 s 

For fluorescent lamps with High Frequency Electronic control ballast, the protective 

device ratings must cope with 25 x inrush for 250 to 350 µs. 

However due to the circuit resistance the total inrush current seen by the MCB is 

lower than the summation of all individual lamp inrush current if directly connected to 

the MCB. 

The tables below (see Fig. N52 to NXX) take into account: 

b Circuits cables have a length of 20 meters from distribution board to the first lamp 

and 7 meters between each additional fittings. 

b MCB rating is given to protect the lamp circuit in accordance with the cable cross 

section, and without unwanted tripping upon lamp starting. 

b MCB tripping curve (C = instantaneous trip setting 5 to 10 In, D = instantaneous 

trip setting 10 to 14 In). 

Number of lamps per circuit 

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 

MCB rating C & D tripping curve 

14/18 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

14 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

14 x3 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 

14 x4 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

18 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

18 x4 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

21/24 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

21/24 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

28 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

28 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 

35/36/39 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

35/36 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 

38/39 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

40/42 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

40/42 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 

49/50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

49/50 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 

54/55 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 

54/55 x2 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 

60 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

Lamp 

power (W) 


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 

MCB rating C & D tripping curve 

6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

9 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

11 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

13 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

14 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

15 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

16 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

17 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

18 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

20 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

21 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

23 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

25 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 

Fig. N53 : Compact fluorescent lamps - Vac = 230 V 




Lamp 

power (W) 



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 

MCB rating C tripping curve 

50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

80 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

125 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 

250 6 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 6 16 20 25 25 32 32 32 32 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 16 32 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 

MCB rating D tripping curve 

50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

80 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

125 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 

250 6 6 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 6 10 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 10 20 25 32 40 40 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 

Fig. N54 : High pressure mercury vapour (with ferromagnetic ballast and PF correction) - Vac = 230 V 

Lamp 

power (W) 


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 


Ferromagnetic ballast 

18 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

26 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

35/36 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

55 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

91 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 

131 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 

135 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 

180 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 20 25 25 25 25 

Electronic ballast 

36 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

55 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

66 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 

91 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 



18 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

26 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

35/36 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

55 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 

91 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 

131 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 

135 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 

180 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 20 25 25 25 25 


36 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

55 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

66 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 

91 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 

Fig. N55 : Low pressure sodium (with PF correction) - Vac = 230 V 


N39 


N40 



Lamp 

power (W) 


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 



50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

100 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 

150 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 6 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 25 25 

250 6 10 16 16 16 20 20 20 20 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 10 16 20 25 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 16 32 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 


35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

100 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 



50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

100 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 

150 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 25 25 

250 6 6 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 6 10 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 10 20 32 32 40 40 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 


35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

50 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

100 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 

Fig. N56 : High pressure sodium (with PF correction) - Vac = 230 V 

Lamp 

power (W) 


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 



35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

150 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 25 25 

250 6 10 16 16 16 20 20 20 20 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 6 16 20 25 25 32 32 32 32 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 16 32 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 63 

1800/2000 25 50 63 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 


35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

150 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 



35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 

150 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 25 25 

250 6 6 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 32 32 40 40 

400 6 10 16 16 20 20 25 25 25 32 32 40 40 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 

1000 16 20 32 32 40 50 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 

1800 16 32 40 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 

2000 20 32 40 50 63 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 


35 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 

70 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 

150 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 10 10 10 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 20 20 20 

Fig. N57 : Metal halide (with PF correction) - Vac = 230 V 

Lamp 

power (W) 

Fig. N58 : Metal halide (with ferromagnetic ballast and PF correction) - Vac = 400 V 



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 


1800 16 32 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 

2000 16 32 40 50 50 50 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 


1800 16 20 32 32 32 32 50 63 63 - - - - - - - - - - - 

2000 16 25 32 32 32 32 50 63 - - - - - - - - - - - - 



Fig. N60 : s.i. residual current devices with immunity against 

impulse currents (Merlin Gerin brand) 


Overload of the neutral conductor 

The risk 

In an installation including, for example, numerous fluorescent tubes with electronic 

ballasts supplied between phases and neutral, a high percentage of 3 rd harmonic 

current can cause an overload of the neutral conductor. Figure N59 below gives an 

overview of typical H3 level created by lighting. 

Lamp type Typical power Setting mode Typical H3 level 

Incandescend lamp 100 W Light dimmer 5 to 45 % 

with dimmer 

ELV halogen lamp 25 W Electronic ELV 5 % 

transformer 

Fluorescent tube 100 W Magnetic ballast 10 % 

< 25 W Electronic ballast 85 % 

> 25 W + PFC 30 % 

Discharge lamp 100 W Magnetic ballast 10 % 

Electrical ballast 30 % 

Fig. N59 : Overview of typical H3 level created by lighting 

The solution 

Firstly, the use of a neutral conductor with a small cross-section (half) should be 

prohibited, as requested by Installation standard IEC 60364, section 523–5–3. 

As far as overcurrent protection devices are concerned, it is necessary to provide 

4-pole circuit-breakers with protected neutral (except with the TN-C system for which 

the PEN, a combined neutral and protection conductor, should not be cut). 

This type of device can also be used for the breaking of all poles necessary to supply 

luminaires at the phase-to-phase voltage in the event of a fault. 

A breaking device should therefore interrupt the phase and Neutral circuit 

simultaneously. 

Leakage currents to earth 

The risk 

At switch-on, the earth capacitances of the electronic ballasts are responsible for 

residual current peaks that are likely to cause unintentional tripping of protection 

devices. 

Two solutions 

The use of Residual Current Devices providing immunity against this type of impulse 

current is recommended, even essential, when equipping an existing installation 


For a new installation, it is sensible to provide solid state or hybrid control devices 

(contactors and remote-control switches) that reduce these impulse currents 

(activation on voltage passage through zero). 

Overvoltages 

The risk 

As illustrated in earlier sections, switching on a lighting circuit causes a transient state 

which is manifested by a significant overcurrent. This overcurrent is accompanied by a 

strong voltage fluctuation applied to the load terminals connected to the same circuit. 

These voltage fluctuations can be detrimental to correct operation of sensitive loads 

(micro-computers, temperature controllers, etc.) 

The Solution 

It is advisable to separate the power supply for these sensitive loads from the lighting 

circuit power supply. 

Sensitivity of lighting devices to line voltage disturbances 

Short interruptions 

b The risk 

Discharge lamps require a relighting time of a few minutes after their power supply 

has been switched off. 

b The solution 

Partial lighting with instantaneous relighting (incandescent lamps or fluorescent 

tubes, or “hot restrike” discharge lamps) should be provided if safety requirements so 

dictate. Its power supply circuit is, depending on current regulations, usually distinct 

from the main lighting circuit. 


N41 


N42 




Voltage fluctuations 

b The risk 

The majority of lighting devices (with the exception of lamps supplied by electronic 

ballasts) are sensitive to rapid fluctuations in the supply voltage. These fluctuations 

cause a flicker phenomenon which is unpleasant for users and may even cause 

significant problems. These problems depend on both the frequency of variations 

and their magnitude. 

Standard IEC 61000-2-2 (“compatibility levels for low-frequency conducted 

disturbances”) specifies the maximum permissible magnitude of voltage variations as 

a function of the number of variations per second or per minute. 

These voltage fluctuations are caused mainly by high-power fluctuating loads (arc 

furnaces, welding machines, starting motors). 

b The solution 

Special methods can be used to reduce voltage fluctuations. Nonetheless, it is 

advisable, wherever possible, to supply lighting circuits via a separate line supply. 

The use of electronic ballasts is recommended for demanding applications 

(hospitals, clean rooms, inspection rooms, computer rooms, etc). 

Developments in control and protection equipment 

The use of light dimmers is more and more common. The constraints on ignition are 

therefore reduced and derating of control and protection equipment is less important. 

New protection devices adapted to the constraints on lighting circuits are being 

introduced, for example Merlin Gerin brand circuit-breakers and modular residual 

current circuit-breakers with special immunity, such as s.i. type ID switches and 

Vigi circuit-breakers. As control and protection equipment evolves, some now offer 

remote control, 24-hour management, lighting control, reduced consumption, etc. 

4.4 Lighting of public areas 

Normal lighting 

Regulations governing the minimum requirements for buildings receiving the public in 

most European countries are as follows: 

b Installations which illuminates areas accessible to the public must be controlled 

and protected independently from installations providing illumination to other areas 

b Loss of supply on a final lighting circuit (i.e. fuse blown or CB tripped) must not 

result in total loss of illumination in an area which is capable of accommodating more 

than 50 persons 

b Protection by Residual Current Devices (RCD) must be divided amongst several 

devices (i.e. more than on device must be used) 

Emergency lighting and other systems 

When we refer to emergency lighting, we mean the auxiliary lighting that is triggered 

when the standard lighting fails. 

Emergency lighting is subdivided as follows (EN-1838): 

Safety lighting 

It originates from the emergency lighting and is intended to provide lighting for people to 

evacuate an area safely or for those who try to fi nish a potentially dangerous operation before 

leaving the area. It is intended to illuminate the means of evacuation and ensure continuous 

visibility and ready usage in safety when standard or emergency lighting is needed. 

Safety lighting may be further subdivided as follows: 

Safety lighting for escape routes 

It originates from the safety lighting, and is 

intended to ensure that the escape means 

can be clearly identifi ed and used safely 

when the area is busy. 


Anti-panic lighting in extended areas 

It originates from the safety lighting, and is 

intended to avoid panic and to provide the 

necessary lighting to allow people to reach 

a possible escape route area. 

Emergency lighting and safety signs for escape routes 

The emergency lighting and safety signs for escape routes are very important for all 

those who design emergency systems. Their suitable choice helps improve safety 

levels and allows emergency situations to be handled better.



Standard EN 1838 ("Lighting applications. Emergency lighting") gives some 

fundamental concepts concerning what is meant by emergency lighting for escape 

routes: 

"The intention behind lighting escape routes is to allow safe exit by the occupants, 

providing them with suffi cient visibility and directions on the escape route …" 

The concept referred to above is very simple: 

The safety signs and escape route lighting must be two separate things. 

Functions and operation of the luminaires 

The manufacturing specifi cations are covered by standard EN 60598-2-22, 

"Particular Requirements - Luminaires for Emergency Lighting", which must be read 

with EN 60598-1, "Luminaires – Part 1: General Requirements and Tests". 

Duration 

A basic requirement is to determine the duration required for the emergency lighting. 

Generally it is 1 hour but some countries may have different duration requirements 

according to statutory technical standards. 

Operation 

We should clarify the different types of emergency luminaires: 

b Non-maintained luminaires 

v The lamp will only switch on if there is a fault in the standard lighting 

v The lamp will be powered by the battery during failure 

v The battery will be automatically recharged when the mains power supply is 

restored 

b Maintained luminaires 

v The lamp can be switched on in continuous mode 

v A power supply unit is required with the mains, especially for powering the lamp, 

which can be disconnected when the area is not busy 

v The lamp will be powered by the battery during failure. 

Design 

The integration of emergency lighting with standard lighting must comply strictly with 

electrical system standards in the design of a building or particular place. 

All regulations and laws must be complied with in order to design a system which is 

up to standard (see Fig. N61). 

The main functions of an emergency lighting system 

when standard lighting fails are the following: 

b Provide sufficient emergency 

lighting along the escape paths 

so that people can safely find 

their ways to the exits. 

Fig. N61 : The main functions of an emergency lighting system 

European standards 

The design of emergency lighting systems is regulated by a number of legislative 

provisions that are updated and implemented from time to time by new 

documentation published on request by the authorities that deal with European and 

international technical standards and regulations. 

Each country has its own laws and regulations, in addition to technical standards 


b Clearly show the escape 

route using clear signs. 

b Ensure that alarms and 

the fire safety equipment 

present along the way out 

are easily identifiable. 

N43 


N44 




which govern different sectors. Basically they describe the places that must be 

provided with emergency lighting as well as its technical specifi cations. The 

designer's job is to ensure that the design project complies with these standards. 

EN 1838 

A very important document on a European level regarding emergency lighting is the 

Standard EN 1838, "Lighting applications. Emergency lighting". 

This standard presents specifi c requirements and constraints regarding the 

operation and the function of emergency lighting systems. 

CEN and CENELEC standards 

With the CEN (Comité Européen de Normalisation) and CENELEC standards 

(Comité Européen de Normalisation Electrotechnique), we are in a standardised 

environment of particular interest to the technician and the designer. A number 

of sections deal with emergencies. An initial distinction should be made between 

luminaire standards and installation standards. 

EN 60598-2-22 and EN-60598-1 

Emergency lighting luminaires are subject to European standard EN 60598-2- 

22, "Particular Requirements - Luminaires for Emergency Lighting", which is an 

integrative text (of specifi cations and analysis) of the Standard EN-60598-1, 

Luminaires – "Part 1: General Requirements and Tests". 



The asynchronous (i.e. induction) motor is 

robust and reliable, and very widely used. 

95% of motors installed around the world are 

asynchronous. The protection of these motors 

is consequently a matter of great importance 

in numerous applications. 

td 

1 to 10s 

20 to 

30 ms 

t 

I" = 8 to 12 In 

Id = 5 to 8 In 

In = rated current of the motor 

In Id I" 

Fig. N62 : Direct on-line starting current characteristics of an 

induction motor 

I 

5 Asynchronous motors 

The consequence of an incorrectly protected motor can include the following: 

b For persons: 

v Asphyxiation due to the blockage of motor ventilation 

v Electrocution due to insulation failure in the motor 

v Accident due to non stopping of the motor following the failure of the control circuit 

in case of incorrect overcurrent protection 

b For the driven machine and the process 

v Shaft couplings and axles, etc, damaged due to a stalled rotor 

v Loss of production 

v Manufacturing time delayed 

b For the motor 

v Motor windings burnt out due to stalled rotor 

v Cost of dismantling and reinstalling or replacement of motor 

v Cost of repairs to the motor 

Therefore, the safety of persons and goods, and reliability and availability levels are 

highly dependant on the choice of protective equipment. 

In economic terms, the overall cost of failure must be considered. This cost 

is increasing with the size of the motor and with the difficulties of access and 

replacement. Loss of production is a further, and evidently important factor. 

Specific features of motor performance influence the power supply circuits required 

for satisfactory operation 

A motor power-supply circuit presents certain constraints not normally encountered 

in other (common) distribution circuits, owing to the particular characteristics, specific 

to motors, such as: 

b High start-up current (see Fig. N62) which is mostly reactive, and can therefore be 

the cause of important voltage drop 

b Number and frequency of start-up operations are generally high 

b The high start-up current means that motor overload protective devices must have 

operating characteristics which avoid tripping during the starting period 

5.1 Functions for the motor circuit 

Functions generally provided are: 

b Basic functions including: 

v Isolating facility 

v Motor control (local or remote) 

v Protection against short-circuits 

v Protection against overload 

b Complementary protections including: 

v Thermal protection by direct winding temperature measurement 

v Thermal protection by indirect winding temperature determination 

v Permanent insulation-resistance monitoring 

v Specific motor protection functions 

b Specific control equipment including: 

v Electromechanical starters 

v Control and Protective Switching devices (CPS) 

v Soft-start controllers 

v Variable speed drives 

Basic functions 

Isolating facility 

It is necessary to isolate the circuits, partially or totally, from their power supply 

network for satety of personnel during maintenance work. “Isolation” function is 

provided by disconnectors. This function can be included in other devices designed 

to provide isolation such as disconnector/circuit-breaker. 

Motor control 

The motor control function is to make and break the motor current. In case of manual 

control, this function can be provided by motor-circuit-breakers or switches. 

In case of remote control, this function can be provided by contactors, starters or CPS. 

The control function can also be initiated by other means: 

b Overload protection 

b Complementary protection 

b Under voltage release (needed for a lot of machines) 

The control function can also be provided by specific control equipment. 


N45 


N46 




Protection against short-circuits 

b Phase-to-phase short-circuit 

This type of fault inside the machine is very rare. It is generally due to mechanical 

incident of the power supply cable of the motor. 

b Phase-to-earth short-circuit 

The deterioration of winding insulation is the main cause. The resulting fault current 

depends on the system of earthing. For the TN system, the resulting fault current is 

very high and in most cases the motor will be deteriorated. For the other systems of 

earthing, protection of the motor can be achieved by earth fault protection. 

For short-circuit protection, it is recommended to pay special attention to avoid 

unexpected tripping during the starting period of the motor. The inrush current of a 

standard motor is about 6 to 8 times its rated current but during a fault the current 

can be as high as 15 times the rated current. So, the starting current must not be 

seen as a fault by the protection. In addition, a fault occuring in a motor circuit must 

not disturb any upstream circuit. As a consequence, discrimination/selectivity of 

magnetic protections must be respected with all parts of the installation. 

Protection against overload 

Mechanical overloads due to the driven machine are the main origins of the overload 

for a motor application. They cause overload current and motor overheating. The life 

of the motor can be reduced and sometimes, the motor can be deteriorated. So, it is 

necessary to detect motor overload. This protection can be provided by: 

b Specific thermal overload relay 

b Specific thermal-magnetic circuit-breaker commonly referred to as “motor circuitbreaker” 

b Complementary protection (see below) like thermal sensor or electronic 

multifunction relay 

b Electronic soft start controllers or variable speed drives (see below) 

Complementary protections 

b Thermal protection by direct winding temperature measurement 

Provided by thermal sensors incorporated inside the windings of the motor and 

associated relays. 

b Thermal protection by indirect winding temperature determination 

Provided by multifunction relays through current measurement and taking into 

account the characteristics of the motors (e.g.: thermal time constant). 

b Permanent insulation-resistance monitoring relays or residual current differential 

relays 

They provide detection and protection against earth leakage current and short-circuit 

to earth, allowing maintenance operation before destruction of the motor. 

b Specific motor protection functions 

Such as protection against too long starting period or stalled rotor, protection 

against unbalanced, loss or permutation of phases, earth fault protection, no load 

protection, rotor blocked (during start or after)…; pre alarm overheating indication, 

communication, can also be provided by multifunction relays. 

Specific control equipment 

b Electromechanical starters (star-delta, auto-transformer, rheostatic rotor 

starters,…) 

They are generally used for application with no load during the starting period (pump, 

fan, small centrifuge, machine-tool, etc.) 

v Advantages 

Good torque/current ratio; great reduction of inrush current. 

v Disadvantages 

Low torque during the starting period; no easy adjustment; power cut off during the 

transition and transient phenomenon; 6 motor connection cables needed. 

b Control and Protective Switching devices (CPS) 

They provide all the basic functions listed before within a single unit and also some 

complementary functions and the possibility of communication. These devices also 

provide continuity of service in case of short-circuit. 

b Soft-start controllers 

Used for applications with pump, fan, compressor, conveyor. 

v Advantages 

Reduced inrush current, voltage drop and mechanical stress during the motor start; 

built-in thermal protection; small size device; possibility of communication 


Low torque during the starting period; thermal dissipation. 




b Variable speed drives 

They are used for applications with pump, fan, compressor, conveyor, machine with 

high load torque, machine with high inertia. 

v Advantages 

Continuous speed variation (adjustment typically from 2 to 130% of nominal speed), 

overspeed is possible; accurate control of acceleration and deceleration; high 

torque during the starting and stopping periods; low inrush current, built-in thermal 

protection, possibility of communication. 


Thermal dissipation, volume, cost. 

5.2 Standards 

The motor control and protection can be achieved in different way: 

b By using an association of a SCPD (Short-Circuit-Protective-Device) and 

electromechanical devices such as 

v An electromechanical starters fulfilling the standard IEC 60947-4-1 

v A semiconductor starter fulfilling the standard IEC 60947-4-2 

v A variable speed drives fulfilling the standard series IEC 61800 

b By using a CPS, single device covering all the basic functions, and fulfilling the 

standard IEC 60947-6-2 

In this document, only the motor circuits including association of electromechanical 

devices such as, starters and protection against short-circuit, are considered. The 

devices meeting the standard 60947-6-2, the semiconductor starters and the variable 

speed drives will be considered only for specific points. 

A motor circuit will meet the rules of the IEC 60947-4-1 and mainly: 

b The co-ordination between the devices of the motor circuit 

b The tripping class of the thermal relays 

b The category of utilization of the contactors 

b The insulation co-ordination 

Note: The first and last points are satisfied inherently by the devices meeting the 

IEC 60947-6-2 because they provide a continuity of service. 

Standardization of the association circuit-breaker + contactor 

+ thermal relay 

Utilization category of the contactors 

Standard IEC 60947-4-1 gives utilization categories which considerably facilitate 

the choice of a suitable contactor for a given service duty. The utilization categories 

advise on: 

b A range of functions for which the contactor must be adapted 

b The required current breaking and making capabilities 

b Standard values for on-load durability tests, according to the utilization category. 

Figure N63 gives some typical examples of the utilization categories covered. 

Utilization category Application characteristics 

AC-1 Non-inductive (or slightly inductive) loads: 

cos ϕ u 0.95 (heating, distribution) 

AC-2 Starting and switching off of slip-ring motors 

AC-3 Cage motors: Starting, and switching off motors 

during running 

AC-4 Cage motors: Starting, plugging, inching 

Fig. N63 : Utilization categories for contactors 

Note: These utilization categories are adapted to the devices meeting the other 

standards. For example AC-3 becomes AC-53 for the semiconductor starters 

(IEC 60947-4-2) and becomes AC-43 for CPS’s (IEC 60947-6-2). 


N47 


N48 



Among the many possible methods of 

protecting a motor, the association of a 

circuit breaker + contactor + thermal relay (1) 

provides many advantages 

(1) The combination of a contactor with a thermal relay is 

commonly referred to as a “discontactor” 


The types of co-ordination 

For each association of devices, a type of co-ordination is given, according to the 

state of the constituant parts following a circuit-breaker trip out on fault, or the 

opening of a contactor on overload. 

The standard IEC 947-4-1 defines two types of co-ordination, type 1 and type 2, 

which set maximum allowable limits of deterioration of switchgear, in case of shortcircuit. 

Whatever the type of co-ordination, it is required that the contactor or the starter must 

never present a danger for the personnel and for the installation. The specificities of 

each type are: 

b Type 1 

Deterioration of the starter is acceptable after a short-circuit and the operation of the 

starter may be recovered after reparing or replacing some parts. 

b Type 2 

Burning and the risk of welding of the contacts of the contactor are the only risks 

allowed. 

Which type to choose? 

The type of co-ordination to adopt depends on the parameters of exploitation and must 

be chosen to satisfy (optimally) the needs of the user and the cost of installation. 

b Type 1 

v Qualified maintenance service 

v Volume and cost of switchgear reduced 

v May not be suitable for further service without repair or replacement of parts after 

a short-circuit 

b Type 2 

v Only light maintenance measures for further use after a short-circuit 

5.3 Applications 

The control and protection of a motor can consist of one, two, three or four different 

devices which provide one or several functions. 

In the case of the combination of several devices, co-ordination between them 

is essential in order to provide optimized protection of the motor application. 

To protect a motor circuit, many parameters must be taken into account. They 

depend on: 

b The application (type of driven machine, safety of operation, number of operations, 

etc.) 

b The continuity performance requested by the application 

b The standards to be enforced to provide security and safety. 

The electrical functions to be provided are quite different: 

b Start, normal operation and stop without unexpected tripping while maintaining 

control requirements, number of operations, durability and safety requirements 

(emergency stops), as well as circuit and motor protection, disconnection (isolation) 

for safety of personnel during maintenance work. 

Basic protection schemes: circuit-breaker + contactor 

+ thermal relay 

Avantages 

The combination of devices facilitates installation work, as well as operation and 

maintenance, by: 

b The reduction of the maintenance work load: the circuit-breaker avoids the need to 

replace blown fuses and the necessity of maintaining a stock (of different sizes and 

types) 

b Better continuity performance: the installation can be re-energized immediately 

following the elimination of a fault and after checking of the starter 

b Additional complementary devices sometimes required on a motor circuit are 

easily accomodated 

b Tripping of all three phases is assured (thereby avoiding the possibility of “single 

phasing”) 

b Full load current switching possibility (by circuit-breaker) in the event of contactor 

failure, e.g. contact welding 

b Interlocking 

b Diverse remote indications 



Circuit 

breaker 

Magnetic 

relay 

Contactor 

Thermal 

relay 

Cable 

Motor 

End of 

start-up 

period 

1 to 

10 s 

20 to 

30 ms 

Fig. N64 : Tripping characteristics of a circuit-breaker + contactor + thermal relay (1) 

(1) In the majority of cases, short-circuit faults occur at the 

motor, so that the current is limited by the cable and the wiring 

of the starter and are called impedant short-circuits 

t 

In Is 


b Better protection for the starter in case of overcurrent and in particular for impedant 

short-circuit (1) corresponding to currents up to about 30 times In of motor (see Fig. N64). 

b Possibility of adding RCD: 

v Prevention of risk of fire (sensitivity 500 mA) 

v Protection against destruction of the motor (short-circuit of laminations) by the 

early detection of earth fault currents (sensitivity 300 mA to 30 A) 

I" magn. 


1.05 to 1.20 In 

Operating curve 

of thermal relay 

Cable thermal withstand limit 

Limit of thermal relay constraint 

Short circuit current breaking capacity 

of the association (CB + contactor) 

Operating curve of the 

MA type circuit breaker 

I 

Short circuit current breaking capacity 

of the CB 

Conclusion 

The combination of a circuit-breaker + contactor + thermal relay for the control and 

protection of motor circuits is eminently appropriate when: 

b The maintenance service for an installation is reduced, which is generally the case 

in tertiary and small and medium sized industrial sites 

b The job specification calls for complementary functions 

b There is an operational requirement for a load breaking facility in the event of need 

of maintenance. 

Key points in the successful combination of a circuit-breaker 

and a discontactor 

Standards define precisely the elements which must be taken into account to 

achieve a correct coordination of type 2: 

b Absolute compatibility between the thermal relay of the discontactor and the 

magnetic trip of the circuit-breaker. In Figure N65 the thermal relay is protected if 

its limit boundary for thermal withstand is placed to the right of the circuit-breaker 

magnetic trip characteristic curve. In the case of a motor control circuit-breaker 

incorporating both magnetic and thermal relay devices, coordination is provided by 

design. 

Compact 

type MA 

Icc ext. 

t 

2 

1 

1 Operating curve of the MA type circuit breaker 

2 Operating curve of thermal relay 

3 Limit of thermal relay constraint 

Fig. N65 : The thermal-withstand limit of the thermal relay must be to the right of the CB 

magnetic-trip characteristic 

3 

I 

N49 


N50 



It is not possible to predict the short-circuit 

current-breaking capacity of a circuit-breaker 

+ contactor combination. Only laboratory tests 

by manufacturers allow to do it. So, Schneider 

Electric can give table with combination of 

Multi 9 and Compact type MA circuit-breakers 

with different types of starters 

M 

Fig. N66 : Circuit-breaker and contactor mounted side by side 

M 

Fig. N67 : Circuit-breaker and contactor mounted separately 

Fig. N68 : Overheating protection by thermal sensors 


b The overcurrent breaking capability of the contactor must be greater than the 

current corresponding to the setting of the circuit-breaker magnetic trip relay. 

b When submitted to a short-circuit current, the contactor and its thermal relay must 

perform in accordance with the requirements corresponding to the specified type of 

co-ordination. 

Short-circuit current-breaking capacity of a circuit-breaker 

+ contactor combination 

At the selection stage, the short-circuit current-breaking capacity which must be 

compared to the prospective short-circuit current is: 

b Either, that of the circuit-breaker + contactor combination if the circuit-breaker 

and the contactor are physically close together (see Fig. N66) (same drawer or 

compartment of a motor control cabinet). A short-circuit downstream of the 

combination will be limited to some extent by the impedances of the contactor and 

the thermal relay. The combination can therefore be used on a circuit for which 

the prospective short-circuit current level exceeds the rated short-circuit currentbreaking 

capacity of the circuit-breaker. This feature very often presents a significant 

economic advantage 

b Or that of the circuit-breaker only, for the case where the contactor is separated 

(see Fig. N67) with the risk of short-circuit between the contactor and the circuitbreaker. 

Choice of instantaneous magnetic-trip relay for the circuitbreaker 

The operating threshold must never be less than 12 In for this relay, in order to avoid 

unexpected tripping due to the first current peak during motor starting. 

Complementary protections 

Complementary protections are: 

b Thermal sensors in the motor (windings, bearings, cooling-air ducts, etc.) 

b Multifunction protections (association of functions) 

b Insulation-failure detection devices on running or stationary motor 

Thermal sensors 

Thermal sensors are used to detect abnormal temperature rise in the motor by direct 

measurement. The thermal sensors are generally embedded in the stator windings 

(for LV motors), the signal being processed by an associated control device acting to 

trip the contactor or the circuit-breaker (see Fig. N68). 

Mutifunction motor protection relay 

The multifunction relay, associated with a number of sensors and indication modules, 

provides protection for motor and also for some functions, protection of the driven 

machine such as: 

b Thermal overload 

b Stalled rotor, or starting period too long 

b Overheating 

b Unbalanced phase current, loss of one phase, inverse rotation 

b Earth fault (by RCD) 

b Running at no-load, blocked rotor on starting 

The avantages are essentially: 

b A comprehensive protection, providing a reliable, high performance and permanent 

monitoring/control function 

b Efficient monitoring of all motor-operating schedules 

b Alarm and control indications 

b Possibility of communication via communication buses 

Example: Telemecanique LT6 relay with permanent monitoring/control function 

and communication by bus, or multifunction control unit LUCM and communication 

module for TeSys model U. 

Preventive protection of stationary motors 

This protection concerns the monitoring of the insulation resistance level of a 

stationary motor, thereby avoiding the undesirable consequences of insulation failure 

during operation such as: 

b Failure to start or to perform correctly for motor used on emergency systems 

b Loss of production 

This type of protection is essential for emergency systems motors, especially when 

installed in humid and/or dusty locations. Such protection avoids the destruction of 

a motor by short-circuit to earth during starting (one of the most frequently-occuring 

incidents) by giving a warning informing that maintenance work is necessary to 

restore the motor to a satisfactory operationnal condition. 




Example of application: 

Motors driving pumps for “sprinklers” fire-protection systems or irrigation pumps for 

seasonal operation. 

A Vigilohm SN21 (Merlin Gerin) monitors the insulation of a motor, and signals 

audibly and visually any abnormal reduction of the insulation resistance level. 

Furthermore, this relay can prevent any attempt to start the motor, if necessary 



SM21 

MERLIN GERIN 

Fig. N69 : Preventive protection of stationary motors 

Fig. N70 : Example using relay RH99M 

RH99M 

SM20 

M E R L IN G E R IN 

IN OUT 

Limitative protections 

Residual current diffential protective devices (RCDs) can be very sensitive and 

detect low values of leakage current which occur when the insulation to earth of an 

installation deteriorates (by physical damage, contamination, excessive humidity, 

and so on). Some versions of RCDs, with dry contacts, specially designed for such 

applications, provide the following: 

b To avoid the destruction of a motor (by perforation and short-circuiting of the 

laminations of the stator) caused by an eventual arcing fault to earth. This protection 

can detect incipient fault conditions by operating at leakage currents in the range of 

300 mA to 30 A, according to the size of the motor (approx sensitivity: 5% In) 

b To reduce the risk of fire: sensitivity y 500 mA 

For example, RH99M relay (Merlin Gerin) provides (see Fig. N70): 

b 5 sensitivities (0.3; 1; 3; 10; 30 A) 

b Possibility of discrimination or to take account of particular operation by virtue of 3 

possible time delays (0, 90, 250 ms) 

b Automatic breaking if the circuit from the current transformer to the relay is broken 

b Protection against unwanted trippings 

b Protection against DC leakage currents (type A RCD) 

N51 


N52 




The importance of limiting the voltage drop at the motor terminals during 

start-up 

In order to have a motor starting and accelerating to its normal speed in the 

appropriate time, the torque of the motor must exceed the load torque by at least 

70%. However, the starting current is much higher than the full-load current of 

the motor. As a result, if the voltage drop is very high, the motor torque will be 

excessively reduced (motor torque is proportional to U 2 ) and it will result, for extreme 

case, in failure to start. 

Example: 

b With 400 V maintained at the terminals of a motor, its torque would be 2.1 times 

that of the load torque 

b For a voltage drop of 10% during start-up, the motor torque would be 

2.1 x 0.9 2 = 1.7 times the load torque, and the motor would accelerate to its rated 

speed normally 

b For a voltage drop of 15% during start-up, the motor torque would be 

2.1 x 0.85 2 = 1.5 times the load torque, so that the motor starting time would 

be longer than normal 

In general, a maximum allowable voltage drop of 10% is recommended during 

start-up of the motor. 

5.4 Maximum rating of motors installed for 

consumers supplied at LV 

The disturbances caused on LV distribution networks during the start-up of large 

direct-on-line AC motors can cause considerable nuisance to neighbouring 

consumers, so that most power-supply utilities have strict rules intended to limit such 

disturbances to tolerable levels. The amount of disturbance created by a given motor 

depends on the “strength” of the network, i.e. on the short-circuit fault level at the 

point concerned. The higher the fault level, the “stronger” the system and the lower 

the disturbance (principally voltage drop) experienced by neibouring consumers. For 

distribution networks in many countries, typical values of maximum allowable starting 

currents and corresponding maximum power ratings for direct-on-line motors are 

shown in Figures N71 and N72 below. 

Type of motor Location Maximum starting current (A) 

Overhead-line network Underground-cable network 

Single phase Dwellings 45 45 

Others 100 200 

Three phase Dwellings 60 60 

Others 125 250 

Fig. N71 : Maximum permitted values of starting current for direct-on-line LV motors (230/400 V) 

Location Type of motor 

Single phase 230 V Three phase 400 V 

(kW) Direct-on-line starting Other methods 

at full load (kW) of starting (kW) 

Dwellings 1.4 5.5 11 

Others Overhead 3 11 22 

line network 

Underground 5.5 22 45 

cable network 

Fig. N72 : Maximum permitted power ratings for LV direct-on-line starting motors 

Since, even in areas supplied by one power utility only, “weak” areas of the network 

exist as well as “strong” areas, it is always advisable to secure the agreement of the 

power supplier before acquiring the motors for a new project. 

Other (but generally more costly) alternative starting arrangements exist, which 

reduce the large starting currents of direct-on-line motors to acceptable levels; for 

example, star-delta starters, slip-ring motor, “soft start” electronic devices, etc. 

5.5 Reactive-energy compensation (power-factor 

correction) 

The method to correct the power factor is indicated in chapter L. 


2 

3 

Chapter P 

Residential and other special 

locations 

Contents 

Residential and similar premises P 

1.1 General P1 

1.2 Distribution boards components P1 

1.3 Protection of people P4 

1.4 Circuits P6 

1.5 Protection against overvoltages and lightning P7 

Bathrooms and showers P8 

2.1 Classification of zones P8 

2.2 Equipotential bonding P11 

2.3 Requirements prescribed for each zone P11 

Recommendations applicable to special installations P 2 

and locations 


P 



P2 


Electrical installations for residential premises 

need a high standard of safety and reliability 

The power distribution utility connects the LV 

neutral point to its MV/LV distribution tranformer 

to earth. 

All LV installations must be protected by RCDs. 

All exposed conductive parts must be bonded 

together and connected to the earth. 

The quality of electrical equipment used in 

residential premises is commonly ensured by a 

mark of conformity situated on the front of each 

item 

Fig. P1 : Presentation of realizable functions on a consumer unit 

Enclosure 

Residential and similar premises 

. General 

Related standards 

Most countries have national regulations and-or standards governing the rules 

to be strictly observed in the design and realization of electrical installations for 

residential and similar premises. The relevant international standard is the publication 

IEC 60364. 

The power network 

The vast majority of power distribution utilities connect the low voltage neutral point 

of their MV/LV distribution transformers to earth. 

The protection of persons against electric shock therefore depends, in such case, on 

the principle discussed in chapter F. The measures required depend on whether the 

TT, TN or IT scheme of earthing is adopted. 

RCDs are essential for TT and IT earthed installations. For TN installations, high 

speed overcurrent devices or RCDs may provide protection against direct contact 

of the electrical circuits. To extend the protection to flexible leads beyond the fixed 

socket outlets and to ensure protection against fires of electrical origin RCDs shall 

be installed. 

.2 Distribution boards components (see Fig. P ) 

Distribution boards (generally only one in residential premises) usually include 

the meter(s) and in some cases (notably where the supply utilities impose a TT 

earthing system and/or tariff conditions which limit the maximum permitted current 

consumption) an incoming supply differential circuit-breaker which includes an 

overcurrent trip. This circuit-breaker is freely accessible to the consumer. 

Service connection 

Lightning protection 

Overcurrent 

protection 

and isolation 

Protection against 

direct and indirect 

contact, 


against fire 

Remote control 

Energy management 

Incoming-supply 

circuit breaker 

MCB phase and neutral 

Remote control switch 

TL 16 A 

Programmable thermostat 

THP 

Programmable time switch 

IHP 


Differential 

MCB 

Distribution board 

Combi surge arrester 

Differential load 

switch 

Load shedding switch 

CDSt 

Contactors, off-peak 

or manual control CT


Fig. P3 : Incoming-supply circuit-breaker 

Fig. P4 : Control and distribution board 

If, in a TT scheme, the value of 80 Ω for the 

resistance of the electrode can not be met then, 

30 mA RCDs must be installed to take over the 

function of the earth leakage protection of the 

incoming supply circuit-breaker 


On installations which are TN earthed, the supply utilities usually protect the 

installation simply by means of sealed fuse cut-outs immediately upstream of the 

meter(s) (see Fig. P2). The consumer has no access to these fuses. 

Fuse … or … 

The incoming supply circuit-breaker (see Fig. P3) 

The consumer is allowed to operate this CB if necessary (e.g to reclose it if the 

current consumption has exceeded the authorized limit; to open it in case of 

emergency or for isolation purposes). 

The rated residual current of the incoming circuit-breaker in the earth leakage 

protection shall be 300 mA. 

If If the installation is TT, the earth electrode resistance shall be less than 

50 V 

R 

300 mA 166 

� � � .. . In practice, the earth electrode resistance of a new installation 

shall be less than 80 Ω Ω� Ω ( R 

2 ).. 

The control and distribution board (consumer unit) (see Fig. P4) 

This board comprises: 

b A control panel for mounting (where appropriate) the incoming supply circuitbreaker 

and other control auxiliaries, as required 

b A distribution panel for housing 1, 2 or 3 rows (of 24 multi 9 units) or similar MCBs 

or fuse units, etc. 

b Installation accessories for fixing conductors, and rails for mounting MCBs, fuses 

bases, etc, neutral busbar and earthing bar, and so on 

b Service cable ducts or conduits, surface mounted or in cable chases embedded in 

the wall 

Note: to facilitate future modifications to the installation, it is recommended to keep 

all relevant documents (photos, diagrams, characteristics, etc.) in a suitable location 

close to the distribution board. 

The board should be installed at a height such that the operating handles, 

indicating dials (of meters) etc., are between 1 metre and 1.80 metres from the floor 

(1.30 metres in situations where handicapped or elderly people are concerned). 

Lightning arresters 

The installation of lightning arresters at the service position of a LV installation is 

strongly recommended for installations which include sensitive (e.g electronic) 

equipment. 

These devices must automatically disconnect themselves from the installation in 

case of failure or be protected by a MCB. In the case of residential installations, the 

use of a 300 mA differential incoming supply circuit-breaker type S (i.e slightly timedelayed) 

will provide effective earth leakage protection, while, at the same time, will 

not trip unnecessarily each time a lightning arrester discharges the current (of an 

overvoltage-surge) to earth. 

Resistance value of the earth electrode 

In the case where the resistance to earth exceeds 80 Ω, one or several 30 mA RCDs 

should be used in place of the earth leakage protection of the incoming supply 

circuit-breaker. 


Meter 


depending on 

earthing system 

Fig. P2 : Components of a control and distribution board 

Distribution 

board 

P3 



P4 


Where utility power supply systems and 

consumers’ installations form a TT earthed 

system, the governing standards impose the use 

of RCDs to ensure the protection of persons 


.3 Protection of people 

On TT earthed systems, the protection of persons is ensured by the following 

measures: 

b Protection against indirect contact hazards by RCDs (see Fig. P5) of medium 

sensitivity (300 mA) at the origin of the installation (incorporated in the incoming 

supply circuit-breaker or, on the incoming feed to the distribution board). This 

measure is associated with a consumer installed earth electrode to which must be 

connected the protective earth conductor (PE) from the exposed conductive parts of 

all class I insulated appliances and equipment, as well as those from the earthing 

pins of all socket outlets 

b When the CB at the origin of an installation has no RCD protection, the protection 

of persons shall be ensured by class II level of insulation on all circuits upstream 

of the first RCDs. In the case where the distribution board is metallic, care shall be 

taken that all live parts are double insulated (supplementary clearances or insulation, 

use of covers, etc.) and wiring reliably fixed 

b Obligatory protection by 30 mA sensitive RCDs of socket outlet circuits, and 

circuits feeding bathroom, laundry rooms, and so on (for details of this latter 

obligation, refer to clause 3 of this chapter) 

Diverse 

circuits 


Socket-outlets 

circuit 

300 mA 

30 mA 30 mA 

Bathroom and/or 

shower room 

Fig. P5 : Installation with incoming-supply circuit-breaker having instantaneous differential 

protection 

Incoming supply circuit-breaker with instantaneous differential 

relay 

In this case: 

b An insulation fault to earth could result in a shutdown of the entire installation 

b Where a lightning arrester is installed, its operation (i.e. discharging a voltage 

surge to earth) could appear to an RCD as an earth fault, with a consequent 

shutdown of the installation 

Recommendation of suitable Merlin Gerin components 

b Incoming supply circuit-breaker with 300 mA differential and 

b High sensitivity 30 mA RCD (for example differential circuit-breaker 1P + N type 

Declic Vigi) on the circuits supplying socket outlets 

b High sensitivity 30 mA RCD (for example differential load switch type ID’clic) on 

circuits to bathrooms, shower rooms, laundry rooms, etc. (lighting, heating, socket 

outlets) 

Incoming supply circuit-breaker with type S time delayed 

differential relay 

This type of CB affords protection against fault to earth, but by virtue of a short time 

delay, provides a measure of discrimination with downstream instantaneous RCDs. 

Tripping of the incoming supply CB and its consequences (on deep freezers, for 

example) is thereby made less probable in the event of lightning, or other causes of 

voltage surges. The discharge of voltage surge current to earth, through the surge 

arrester, will leave the type S circuit-breaker unaffected.


1 

Diverse 

circuits 

2 

5 3 4 

300 mA 30 mA 30 mA 30 mA 

High-risk circuit 

(dish-washing 

machine) 

Socket-outlet 

circuit 


shower room 

Fig. P7 : Installation with incoming-supply circuit-breaker 

having no differential protection 


Recommendation of suitable Merlin Gerin components (see Fig. P6) 

b Incoming supply circuit-breaker with 300 mA differential type S and 

b High sensitivity 30 mA RCD (for example differential circuit-breaker 1P + N type 

Declic Vigi) on the circuits supplying washing machines and dish-washing machine 

b High sensitivity 30 mA RCD (for example differential load switch type ID’clic) on 

circuits to bathrooms, shower rooms, laundry rooms, etc. (lighting, heating, socket 

outlets) 

Diverse 

circuits 


High-risk location 

(laundry room) 

300 mA - type S 

30 mA 30 mA 30 mA 

Socketoutlet 

circuit 


shower room 

Fig. P6 : Installation with incoming-supply circuit-breaker having short time delay differential 

protection, type S 

Incoming supply circuit-breaker without differential protection 

In this case the protection of persons must be ensured by: 

b Class II level of insulation up to the downstream terminals of the RCDs 

b All outgoing circuits from the distribution board must be protected by 30 mA or 

300 mA RCDs according to the type of circuit concerned as discussed in chapter F. 

Where a voltage surge arrester is installed upstream of the distribution board 

(to protect sensitive electronic equipment such as microprocessors, videocassette 

recorders, TV sets, electronic cash registers, etc.) it is imperative that the 

device automatically disconnects itself from the installation following a rare (but 

always possible) failure. Some devices employ replaceable fusing elements; the 

recommended method however as shown in Figure P7, is to use a circuit-breaker. 

Recommendation of suitable Merlin Gerin components 

Figure P7 refers: 

1. Incoming-supply circuit-breaker without differential protection 

2. Automatic disconnection device (if a lightning arrester is installed) 

3. 30 mA RCD (for example differential circuit-breaker 1P + N type Declic Vigi) on 

each circuit supplying one or more socket-outlets 

4. 30 mA RCD (for example differential load swith type ID’clic) on circuits to 

bathrooms and shower rooms (lighting, heating and socket-outlets) or a 30 mA 

differential circuit-breaker per circuit 

5. 300 mA RCD (for example differential load swith) on all the other circuits 

P5 



P6 


The distribution and division of circuits provides 

comfort and facilitates rapid location of fault 

Socketoutlets 

Lighting Heating 

Washing 

machine 

Cooking 

apparatus 

.4 Circuits 

Subdivision 

National standards commonly recommend the subdivision of circuits according to the 

number of utilization categories in the installation concerned (see Fig. P8): 

b At least 1 circuit for lighting. Each circuit supplying a maximum of 8 lighting points 

b At least 1 circuit for socket-outlets rated 10/16 A, each circuit supplying a maximum 

of 8 sockets. These sockets may be single or double units (a double unit is made up 

of two 10/16 A sockets mounted on a common base in an embedded box, identical 

to that of a single unit 

b 1 circuit for each appliance such as water heater, washing machine, dish-washing 

machine, cooker, refrigerator, etc. Recommended numbers of 10/16 A (or similar) 

socket-outlets and fixed lighting points, according to the use for which the various 

rooms of a dwelling are intended, are indicated in Figure P9 

Fig. P8 : Circuit division according to utilization Fig P9 : Recommended minimum number of lighting and power points in residential premises 

The inclusion of a protective conductor in all 

circuits is required by IEC and most national 

standards 


Room function Minimum number Minimum number 

of fixed lighting points of 0/ 6 A socket-outlets 

Living room 1 5 

Bedroom, lounge, 1 3 

bureau, dining room 

Kitchen 2 4 (1) 

Bathroom, shower room 2 1 or 2 

Entrance hall, box room 1 1 

WC, storage space 1 - 

Laundry room - 1 

(1) Of which 2 above the working surface and 1 for a specialized circuit: in addition 

an independent socket-outlet of 16 A or 20 A for a cooker and a junction box or 

socket-outlet for a 32 A specialized circuit 

Protective conductors 

IEC and most national standards require that each circuit includes a protective 

conductor. This practice is strongly recommended where class I insulated appliances 

and equipment are installed, which is the general case. 

The protective conductors must connect the earthing-pin contact in each socketoutlet, 

and the earthing terminal in class I equipment, to the main earthing terminal 

at the origin of the installation. 

Furthermore, 10/16 A (or similarly sized) socket-outlets must be provided with 

shuttered contact orifices. 

Cross-sectional-area (c.s.a.) of conductors (see Fig. P 0) 

The c.s.a. of conductors and the rated current of the associated protective device 

depend on the current magnitude of the circuit, the ambient temperature, the kind of 

installation, and the influence of neighbouring circuits (refer to chapter G) 

Moreover, the conductors for the phase wires, the neutral and the protective 

conductors of a given circuit must all be of equal c.s.a. (assuming the same material 

for the conductors concerned, i.e. all copper or all aluminium). 

Fig. P10 : Circuit-breaker 1 phase + N - 2 x 9 mm spaces 




Figure P indicates the c.s.a. required for commonly-used appliances 

Protective devices 1 phase + N in 2 x 9 mm spaces comply with requirements for 

isolation, and for marking of circuit current rating and conductor sizes. 

Type of circuit c. s. a. of the Maximum power Protective device 

single-phase 230 V conductors 

ph + N or ph + N + PE 

Fixed lighting 1.5 mm 2 2,300 W Circuit-breaker 16 A 

(2.5 mm 2 ) Fuse 10 A 

10/16 A 2.5 mm 2 4,600 W Circuit-breaker 25 A 

(4 mm 2 ) Fuse 20 A 

Individual-load circuits 

Water heater 2.5 mm 2 4,600 W Circuit-breaker 25 A 

(4 mm 2 ) Fuse 20 A 

Dish-washing machine 2.5 mm 2 4,600 W Circuit-breaker 25 A 

(4 mm 2 ) Fuse 20 A 

Clothes-washing machine 2.5 mm 2 4,600 W Circuit-breaker 25 A 

(4 mm 2 ) Fuse 20 A 

Cooker or hotplate (1) 6 mm 2 7,300 W Circuit-breaker 40 A 

(10 mm 2 ) Fuse 32 A 

Electric space heater 1.5 mm 2 2,300 W Circuit-breaker 16 A 

(2.5 mm 2 ) Fuse 10 A 

(1) In a 230/400 V 3-phase circuit, the c. s. a. is 4 mm 2 for copper or 6 mm 2 for aluminium, and protection is provided by a 32 A 

circuit-breaker or by 25 A fuses. 

Fig. P11 : C. s. a. of conductors and current rating of the protective devices in residential installations (the c. s. a. of aluminium conductors are shown in brackets) 

.5 Protection against overvoltages and lightning 

The choice of surge arrester is described in chapter J 

Installation rules 

Three principal rules must be respected: 

1 - It is imperative that the three lengths of cable used for the installation of the surge 

arrester each be less than 50 cm i.e.: 

b the live conductors connected to the isolating switch 

b from the isolating switch to the surge arrester 

b from the surge arrester to the main distribution board (MDB) earth bar (not 

to be confused with the main protective-earth (PE) conductor or the main earth 

terminal for the installation.The MDB earth bar must evidently be located in the 

same cabinet as the surge arrester. 

2 - It is necessary to use an isolating switch of a type recommended by the 

manufacturer of the surge arrester. 

3 - In the interest of a good continuity of supply it is recommended that the 

circuit-breaker be of the time-delayed or selective type. 


P7 



P 


2 Bathrooms and showers 

Bathrooms and showers rooms are areas of high risk, because of the very low 

resistance of the human body when wet or immersed in water. 

Precaution to be taken are therefore correspondingly rigorous, and the regulations 

are more severe than those for most other locations. 

The relevant standard is IEC 60364-7-701. 

Precautions to observe are based on three aspects: 

b The definition of zones, numbered 0,1, 2, 3 in which the placement (or exclusion) 

of any electrical device is strictly limited or forbidden and, where permitted, the 

electrical and mechanical protection is prescribed 

b The establishment of an equipotential bond between all exposed and extraneous 

metal parts in the zones concerned 

b The strict adherence to the requirements prescribed for each particular zones, as 

tabled in clause 3 

2.1 Classification of zones 

Sub-clause 701.32 of IEC 60364-7-701 defines the zones 0, 1, 2, 3 as shown in the 

following diagrams (see Fig. P12 below to Fig P1 opposite and next pages): 

Zone 1* 

Zone 0 

Zone 1 

Zone 1 

Zone 0 

Zone 2 Zone 3 

0.60 m 2.40 m 

Zone 2 

0.60 m 

(*) Zone 1 is above the bath as shown in the vertical cross-section 

Fig. P12 : Zones 0, 1, 2 and 3 in proximity to a bath-tub 


Zone 1* 

Zone 0 

Zone 3 

2.40 m 

0.60 m 

Zone 2 Zone 3 

2.25 m 

2.40 m



Zone 0 

Zone 1 

0.60 m 

Zone 3 

2.40 m 

Zone 1 Zone 2 

Zone 3 

Zone 1 

Zone 0 

Zone 2 

0.60 m 


2.40 m 

Zone 0 

Zone 1 

0.60 m 

2.25 m 

Fig. P13 : Zones 0, 1, 2 and 3 in proximity of a shower with basin 

Zone 1 

Zone 2 

Zone 3 

Zone 1 

0.60 m 

Fixed shower 

head (1) 

0.60 m 

Zone 

2 

2.40 m 

Zone 3 

Zone 2 

Fixed shower 

head (1) 

0.60 m 

Zone 1 

0.60 m 

Zone 2 

Zone 3 

2.25 m 

2.40 m 

Zone 3 

2.40 m 

(1) When the shower head is at the end of a flexible tube, the vertical central axis of 

a zone passes through the fixed end of the flexible tube 

Fig. P14 : Zones 0, 1, 2 and 3 in proximity of a shower without basin 

Prefabricated 

shower 

cabinet 

0.60 m 

0.60 m 

Fig. P15 : No switch or socket-outlet is permitted within 60 cm of the door opening of a shower 

cabinet 

P 


P10 



Classes 

of external 

influences 

AD 3 

BB 2 

BC 3 

AD 3 

BB 3 

BC 3 

AD 7 

BB 3 

BC 3 

Fig. P16 : Individual showers with dressing cubicles 

Classes 


influences 

h < 1.10m 

AD 5 

1.10m < h < 2.25m 

AD 3 

BB 3 

BC 3 

AD 7 

BB 3 

BC 3 

Zone 3 

Dressing cubicles (zone 2) 

Shower cabinets (zone 1) 

Dressing cubicles 

Zone 1 

Fig. P17 : Individual showers with separate individual dressing cubicles 

Classes 


influences 

AD 3 

BB 2 

BC 3 

h < 1.10m 

AD 5 

1.10m < h < 2.25m 

AD 3 

BB 3 

BC 3 

Fig. P18 : Communal showers and common dressing room 

Zone 2 


Zone 2 

Dressing room 

Zone 2 

Zone 1 


Classes 


influences 

AD 3 

BB 2 

BC 3 

WC 

WC 

AD 3 

BB 2 

BC 3 

Classes 


influences 

h < 1.10m 

AD 5 

1.10m < h < 2.25m 

AD 3 

BB 3 

BC 3 

Classes 


influences 

AD 7 

BB 3 

BC 3 

Note: Classes of external influences (see Fig. E46). 

AD 3 

BB 2 

BC 3 

h < 1.10m 

AD 5 

1.10m < h < 2.25m 

AD 3 

BB 3 

BC 3



2.2 Equipotential bonding (see Fig. P1 ) 

Water-drainage 

piping 

Socket-outlet 

Lighting 

Gaz 


To the earth 

electrode 

Metal bath Equipotential conductors 

for a bathroom 

Fig. P19 : Supplementary equipotential bonding in a bathroom 

Metal 

door-frame 

2.3 Requirements prescribed for each zone 

Metallic pipes 

h i 2 m 

Radiator 

The table of clause 3 describes the application of the principles mentioned in the 

foregoing text and in other similar or related cases 

P11 


P12 



3 Recommendations applicable to 

special installations and locations 

Figure P20 below summarizes the main requirements prescribed in many national 

and international standards. 

Note: Section in brackets refer to sections of IEC 60364-7 

Locations Protection principles IP Wiring Switchgear Socket-outlets Installation 

level and cables materials 

Domestic dwellings b TT or TN-S systems 20 Switch operating handles Protection by 

and other habitations b Differential protection and similar devices on 30 mA RCDs 

v 300 mA if the earth electrode distribution panels, 

resistance is y 80 ohms instantaneous to be mounted 

or short time delay (type S) between 1 metre and 

v 30 mA if the earth electrode 1.80 metre above the floor 

resistance is u 500 ohms 

b surge arrester at the origin of the 

installation if 

v supply is from overhead line with bare 

conductors, and if 

v the keraunic level > 25 

b a protective earth (PE) conductor 

on all circuits 

Bathrooms or shower Supplementary equipotential bonding 

rooms (section 701) in zones 0, 1, 2 and 3 

Zone 0 SELV 12 V only 27 Class II Special appliances 

limited to 

strict minimum 

Zone 1 SELV 12 V 25 Class II Special aplliances 

limited to Water heater 


Zone 2 SELV 12 V or 30 mA RCD 24 Class II Special appliances 

limited to Water heater 

strict minimum Class II luminaires 

Zone 3 21 Only socket-outlets protected by : 

b 30 mA RCD or 

b Electrical separation or 

b SELV 50 V 

Swimming baths Supplementary equipotential bonding 

(section 702) in zones 0, 1, and 2 

Zone 0 SELV 12 V 28 Class II Special appliances 

limited to 


Zone 1 25 Class II Special appliances 

limited to 


Zone 2 22 Only socket-outlets protected by : 

(indoor) b 30 mA RCD or 

24 b electrical separation or 

(outdoor) b SELV 50 V 

Saunas 24 Class II Adapted to temperature 

(section 703) 

Work sites Conventional voltage limit UL 44 Mechanically Protection by 

(section 704) reduced to 25 V protected 30 mA RCDs 

Agricultural and Conventional voltage limit UL 35 Protection by 

horticultural reduced to 25 V 30 mA RCDs 

establishments Protection against fire risks 

(section 705) by 500 mA RCDs 

Restricted conductive 2x Protection of: 

locations (section 706) b Portable tools by: 

v SELV or 

v Electrical separation 

b Hand-held lamps 

v By SELV 

b Fixed equipement by 

v SELV 

v Electrical separation 

v 30 mA RCDs 

v Special supplementary 

equipotential bonding 

Fig. P20 : Main requirements prescribed in many national and international standards (continued on opposite page) 



3 Recommendations applicable to 

special installations and locations 

Locations Protection principles IP Wiring Switchgear Socket-outlets Installation 

level and cables materials 

Fountains Protection by 30 mA RCDs and 

(section 702) equipotential bonding of all exposed 

and extraneous conductive parts 

Data processing TN-S system recommended 

(section 707) TT system if leakage current is limited. 

Protective conductor 10 mm 2 minimum 

in aluminium. Smaller sizes (in copper) 

must be doubled. 

Caravan park 55 Flexible cable of Socket-outlets 

(section 708) 25 metres shall be placed 

length at a height of 

0.80 m to 1.50 m 

from the ground. 

Protection of 

circuits by 

30 mA RCDs 

(one per 6 

socket-outlets) 

Marinas and pleasure The cable length for connection to Protection of 

craft (section 709) pleasure craft must not exceeded 25 m circuits by 

30 mA RCDs 

(one per 6 

socket-outlets) 

Medical locations IT medical system equipotential bonding Protection by 

(section 710) 30 mA RCDs 

Exhibitions, shows and TT or TN-S systems 4x Protection by 

stands (section 711) 30 mA RCDs 

Balneotherapy Individual: see section 701 

(cure-centre baths) (volumes 0 and 1) 

Collective: see section 702 

(volumes 0 and 1) 

Motor-fuel filling Explosion risks in security zones Limited to the 

stations necessary minimum 

Motor vehicules Protection by RCDs or by 

electrical separation 

External lighting 23 Protection by 

installations 30 mA RCDs 

(section 714) 

Mobile or transportable The use of TN-C system is not 30 mA RCDs 

units (section 717) permitted inside any unit must be used for 

all socket-outlets 

supplying 

equipment 

outside the unit 

Fig. P20 : Main requirements prescribed in many national and international standards (concluded) 


P13 


2 

3 

4 

5 

Chapter Q 


Contents 

Electrical distribution Q2 

Earthing principles and structures Q3 

Implementation Q5 

3.1 Equipotential bonding inside and outside buildings Q5 

3.2 Improving equipotential conditions Q5 

3.3 Separating cables Q7 

3.4 False floor Q7 

3.5 Cable running Q8 

3.6 Implementation of shielded cables Q11 

3.7 Communication networks Q11 

3.8 Implementation of surge arrestors Q12 

3.9 Cabinet cabling Q13 

3.10 Standards Q13 

Coupling mechanisms and counter-measures Q 4 

4.1 General Q14 

4.2 Common-mode impedance coupling Q15 

4.3 Capacitive coupling Q16 

4.4 Inductive coupling Q17 

4.5 Radiated coupling Q18 

Wiring recommendations Q20 

5.1 Signal classes Q20 

5.2 Wiring recommendations Q20 


Q 



Q2 

Q - EMC guidelines 

Fig. Q1 : Main characteristics of system earthing 

Electrical distribution 

The system earthing arrangement must be properly selected to ensure the 

safety of life and property. The behaviour of the different systems with respect 

to EMC considerations must be taken into account. Figure Q below presents a 

summary of their main characteristics. 

European standards (see EN 50174-2 § 6.4 and EN 50310 § 6.3) recommend the 

TN-S system which causes the fewest EMC problems for installations comprising 

information-technology equipment (including telecom equipment). 

TT TN-S IT TN-C 

Safety of persons Good Good 

RCD mandatory Continuity of the PE conductor must be ensured throughout the installation 

Safety of property Good Poor Good Poor 

Medium fault current High fault current Low current for first fault High fault current 

(< a few dozen amperes) (around 1 kA) (< a few dozen mA), (around 1 kA) 

but high for second fault 

Availability of energy Good Good Excellent Good 

EMC behaviour Good Excellent Poor (to be avoided) Poor 

- Risk of overvoltages - Few equipotential - Risk of overvoltages (should never be used) 

- Equipotential problems - Common-mode filters - Neutral and PE are 

problems - Need to manage and surge arrestors the same 

- Need to manage devices with high must handle the phase- - Circulation of disturbed 

devices with high leakage currents to-phase voltages currents in exposed 

leakage currents - High fault currents - RCDs subject to conductive parts (high 

(transient disturbances) nuisance tripping if magnetic-field radiation) 

common-mode - High fault currents 

capacitors are present (transient disturbances) 

- Equivalent to 

TN system for second 

fault 

When an installation includes high-power equipment (motors, air-conditioning, lifts, 

power electronics, etc.), it is advised to install one or more transformers specifically 

for these systems. Electrical distribution must be organised in a star system and all 

outgoing circuits must exit the main low-voltage switchboard (MLVS). 

Electronic systems (control/monitoring, regulation, measurement instruments, etc.) 

must be supplied by a dedicated transformer in a TN-S system. 

Figure Q2 below illustrate these recommendations. 

Disturbing 

devices 

Transformer 

Sensitive 

devices 

Disturbing 

devices 

Not recommended Preferable Excellent 


Sensitive 

devices 

Fig. Q2 : Recommendations of separated distributions 

Lighting 

Air conditioning 

Disturbing 

devices 

Sensitive 

devices


2 Earthing principles and 

structures 

This section deals with the earthing and equipotential bonding of information-technology 

devices and other similar devices requiring interconnections for signalling purposes. 

Earthing networks are designed to fulfil a number of functions. They can be 

independent or operate together to provide one or more of the following: 

b Safety of persons with respect to electrical hazards 

b Protection of equipment with respect to electrical hazards 

b A reference value for reliable, high-quality signals 

b Satisfactory EMC performance 

The system earthing arrangement is generally designed and installed in view of 

obtaining a low impedance capable of diverting fault currents and HF currents away 

from electronic devices and systems. There are different types of system earthing 

arrangements and some require that specific conditions be met. These conditions 

are not always met in typical installations. The recommendations presented in this 

section are intended for such installations. 

For professional and industrial installations, a common bonding network (CBN) may 

be useful to ensure better EMC performance with respect to the following points: 

b Digital systems and new technologies 

b Compliance with the EMC requirements of EEC 89/336 (emission and immunity) 

b The wide number of electrical applications 

b A high level of system safety and security, as well as reliability and/or availability 

For residential premises, however, where the use of electrical devices is limited, an 

isolated bonding network (IBN) or, even better, a mesh IBN may be a solution. 

It is now recognised that independent, dedicated earth electrodes, each serving a 

separate earthing network, are a solution that is not acceptable in terms of EMC, 

but also represent a serious safety hazard. In certain countries, the national building 

codes forbid such systems. 

Use of a separate “clean” earthing network for electronics and a “dirty” earthing 

network for energy is not recommended in view of obtaining correct EMC, even 

when a single electrode is used (see Fig. Q and Fig. Q4). In the event of a lightning 

strike, a fault current or HF disturbances as well as transient currents will flow in the 

installation. Consequently, transient voltages will be created and result in failures or 

damage to the installation. If installation and maintenance are carried out properly, 

this approach may be dependable (at power frequencies), but it is generally not 

suitable for EMC purposes and is not recommended for general use. 

"Clean" 

earthing network 

Fig. Q3 : Independent earth electrodes, a solution generally not acceptable for safety and EMC 

reasons 

"Clean" 


Fig. Q4 : Installation with a single earth electrode 


Electrical 


Separate earth electrodes 

Electrical 


Single earth electrode 

Surge arrestors 


Q 


© Schneider Electric - all rights reserved Q4 


Fig. Q6 : Each level has a mesh and the meshes are 

interconnected at several points between levels. Certain 

ground-floor meshes are reinforced to meet the needs of 

certain areas 

2 Earthing principles and 

structures 

The recommended configuration for the earthing network and electrodes is two or 

three dimensional (see Fig. Q5). This approach is advised for general use, both 

in terms of safety and EMC. This recommendation does not exclude other special 

configurations that, when correctly maintained, are also suitable. 

Fig. Q5 : Installation with multiple earth electrodes 


Equipotential bonding required for 

multi-level buildings 

"Electrical" and "communication" 

earthing as needed 


Multiple interconnected earth electrodes 

In a typical installation for a multi-level building, each level should have its 

own earthing network (generally a mesh) and all the networks must be both 

interconnected and connected to the earth electrode. At least two connections are 

required (built in redundancy) to ensure that, if one conductor breaks, no section of 

the earthing network is isolated. 

Practically speaking, more than two connections are made to obtain better symmetry 

in current flow, thus reducing differences in voltage and the overall impedance 

between the various levels in the building. 

The many parallel paths have different resonance frequencies. If one path has a high 

impedance, it is most probably shunted by another path with a different resonance 

frequency. On the whole, over a wide frequency spectrum (dozens of Hz and MHz), a 

large number of paths results in a low-impedance system (see Fig. Q6). 

Each room in the building should have earthing-network conductors for equipotential 

bonding of devices and systems, cableways, trunking systems and structures. This 

system can be reinforced by connecting metal pipes, gutters, supports, frames, etc. 

In certain special cases, such as control rooms or computers installed on false floors, 

ground reference plane or earthing strips in areas for electronic systems can be used 

to improve earthing of sensitive devices and protection interconnection cables.


3 Implementation 

3.1 Equipotential bonding inside and outside 

buildings 

The fundamental goals of earthing and bonding are the following: 

b Safety 

By limiting the touch voltage and the return path of fault currents 

b EMC 

By avoiding differences in potential and providing a screening effect. 

Stray currents are inevitably propagated in an earthing network. It is impossible to 

eliminate all the sources of disturbances for a site. Earth loops are also inevitable. 

When a magnetic field affects a site, e.g. the field created by lightning, differences in 

potential are created in the loops formed by the various conductors and the currents 

flowing in the earthing system. Consequently, the earthing network is directly 

affected by any counter-measures taken outside the building. 

As long as the currents flow in the earthing system and not in the electronic circuits, 

they do no damage. However, when earthing networks are not equipotential, e.g. 

when they are star connected to the earth electrode, the HF stray currents will flow 

wherever they can, including in control wires. Equipment can be disturbed, damaged 

or even destroyed. 

The only inexpensive means to divide the currents in an earthing system and 

maintain satisfactory equipotential characteristics is to interconnect the earthing 

networks. This contributes to better equipotential bonding within the earthing 

system, but does not remove the need for protective conductors. To meet legal 

requirements in terms of the safety of persons, sufficiently sized and identified 

protective conductors must remain in place between each piece of equipment and 

the earthing terminal. What is more, with the possible exception of a building with a 

steel structure, a large number of conductors for the surge-arrestor or the lightningprotection 

network must be directly connected to the earth electrode. 

The fundamental difference between a protective conductor (PE) and a surgearrestor 

down-lead is that the first conducts internal currents to the neutral of the 

MV/LV transformer whereas the second carries external current (from outside the 

installation) to the earth electrode. 

In a building, it is advised to connect an earthing network to all accessible conducting 

structures, namely metal beams and door frames, pipes, etc. It is generally sufficient 

to connect metal trunking, cable trays and lintels, pipes, ventilation ducts, etc. at 

as many points as possible. In places where there is a large amount of equipment 

and the size of the mesh in the bonding network is greater than four metres, an 

equipotential conductor should be added. The size and type of conductor are not of 

critical importance. 

It is imperative to interconnect the earthing networks of buildings that have shared 

cable connections. Interconnection of the earthing networks must take place via a 

number of conductors and all the internal metal structures of the buildings or linking 

the buildings (on the condition that they are not interrupted). 

In a given building, the various earthing networks (electronics, computing, telecom, 

etc.) must be interconnected to form a single equipotential bonding network. 

This earthing-network must be as meshed as possible. If the earthing network is 

equipotential, the differences in potential between communicating devices will be low 

and a large number of EMC problems disappear. Differences in potential are also 

reduced in the event of insulation faults or lightning strikes. 

If equipotential conditions between buildings cannot be achieved or if the distance 

between buildings is greater than ten metres, it is highly recommended to use 

optical fibre for communication links and galvanic insulators for measurement and 

communication systems. 

These measures are mandatory if the electrical supply system uses the IT or 

TN-C system. 

3.2 Improving equipotential conditions 

Bonding networks 

Even though the ideal bonding network would be made of sheet metal or a fine 

mesh, experience has shown that for most disturbances, a three-metre mesh size is 

sufficient to create a mesh bonding network. 

Examples of different bonding networks are shown in Figure Q7 next page. The 

minimum recommended structure comprises a conductor (e.g. copper cable or strip) 

surrounding the room. 


Q 



Q 


Trunk 

BN: Bonding network 

CBN: Common bonding network 

IBN: Isolated bonding network 

Fig. Q7 : Examples of bonding networks 

IBN 

Mesh IBN 

Tree structure 

Star (IBN) 


PE 


IBN 

CBN 

Mesh BN 

Mesh BN 

Local mesh Local mesh 

IBN 

The length of connections between a structural element and the bonding network 

does not exceed 50 centimetres and an additional connection should be installed 

in parallel at a certain distance from the first. The inductance of the connection 

between the earthing bar of the electrical enclosure for a set of equipment and the 

bonding network (see below) should be less than one µHenry (0.5 µH, if possible). 

For example, it is possible to use a single 50 cm conductor or two parallel conductors 

one meter long, installed at a minimum distance from one another (at least 50 cm) to 

reduce the mutual inductance between the two conductors. 

Where possible, connection to the bonding network should be at an intersection to 

divide the HF currents by four without lengthening the connection. The profile of the 

bonding conductors is not important, but a flat profile is preferable. The conductor 

should also be as short as possible. 

Parallel earthing conductor (PEC) 

The purpose of a parallel earthing conductor is to reduce the common-mode current 

flowing in the conductors that also carry the differential-mode signal (the commonmode 

impedance and the surface area of the loop are reduced). 

The parallel earthing conductor must be designed to handle high currents when it 

is used for protection against lightning or for the return of high fault currents. When 

cable shielding is used as a parallel earthing conductor, it cannot handle such high 

currents and the solution is to run the cable along metal structural elements or 

cableways which then act as other parallel earthing conductors for the entire cable. 

Another possibility is to run the shielded cable next to a large parallel earthing 

conductor with both the shielded cable and the parallel earthing conductor connected 

at each end to the local earthing terminal of the equipment or the device. 

For very long distances, additional connections to the network are advised for 

the parallel earthing conductor, at irregular distances between the devices. These 

additional connections form a shorter return path for the disturbing currents flowing 

through the parallel earthing conductor. For U-shaped trays, shielding and tubes, the 

additional connections should be external to maintain the separation with the interior 

(“screening” effect). 

Bonding conductors 

Bonding conductors may be metal strips, flat braids or round conductors. For highfrequency 

systems, metal strips and flat braids are preferable (skin effect) because a 

round conductor has a higher impedance than a flat conductor with the same cross 

section. Where possible, the length to width ratio should not exceed 5.



3.3 Separating cables 

The physical separation of high and low-current cables is very important for EMC, 

particularly if low-current cables are not shielded or the shielding is not connected 

to the exposed conductive parts (ECPs). The sensitivity of electronic equipment is in 

large part determined by the accompanying cable system. 

If there is no separation (different types of cables in separate cableways, minimum 

distance between high and low-current cables, types of cableways, etc.), 

electromagnetic coupling is at its maximum. Under these conditions, electronic 

equipment is sensitive to EMC disturbances flowing in the affected cables. 

Use of busbar trunking systems such as Canalis or busbar ducts for high power 

ratings is strongly advised. The levels of radiated magnetic fields using these types of 

trunking systems is 10 to 20 times lower than standard cables or conductors. 

The recommendations in the “Cable running” and “Wiring recommendations” 

sections should be taken into account. 

3.4 False floors 

The inclusion of the floors in the mesh contributes to equipotentiality of the area and 

consequently to the distribution and dilution of disturbing LF currents. 

The screening effect of a false floor is directly related to its equipotentiality. If the 

contact between the floor plates is poor (rubber antistatic joints, for example) or if 

the contact between the support brackets is faulty (pollution, corrosion, mildew, etc. 

or if there are no support brackets), it is necessary to add an equipotential mesh. In 

this case, it is sufficient to ensure effective electrical connections between the metal 

support columns. Small spring clips are available on the market to connect the metal 

columns to the equipotential mesh. Ideally, each column should be connected, but 

it is often sufficient to connect every other column in each direction. A mesh 1.5 to 

2 metres is size is suitable in most cases. The recommended cross-sectional area of 

the copper is 10 mm2 or more. In general, a flat braid is used. To reduce the effects of 

corrosion, it is advised to use tin-plated copper (see Fig. Q8). 

Perforated floor plates act like normal floor plates when they have a cellular steel 

structure. 

Preventive maintenance is required for the floor plates approximately every five years 

(depending on the type of floor plate and the environment, including humidity, dust 

and corrosion). Rubber or polymer antistatic joints must be maintained, similar to the 

bearing surfaces of the floor plates (cleaning with a suitable product). 

Spring clips 

Metal support columns 

Fig. Q8 : False floor implementation 


u 10 mm 2 

False floor 

Q7 



Q8 



3. Cable running 

Selection of materials and their shape depends on the following criteria: 

b Severity of the EM environment along cableways (proximity of sources of 

conducted or radiated EM disturbances) 

b Authorised level of conducted and radiated emissions 

b Type of cables (shielded?, twisted?, optical fibre?) 

b EMI withstand capacity of the equipment connected to the wiring system 

b Other environmental constraints (chemical, mechanical, climatic, fire, etc.) 

b Future extensions planned for the wiring system 

Non-metal cableways are suitable in the following cases: 

b A continuous, low-level EM environment 

b A wiring system with a low emission level 

b Situations where metal cableways should be avoided (chemical environment) 

b Systems using optical fibres 

For metal cableways, it is the shape (flat, U-shape, tube, etc.) rather than the crosssectional 

area that determines the characteristic impedance. Closed shapes are 

better than open shapes because they reduce common-mode coupling. Cableways 

often have slots for cable straps. The smaller the better. The types of slots causing 

the fewest problems are those cut parallel and at some distance from the cables. 

Slots cut perpendicular to the cables are not recommended (see Fig. Q9). 

Fig. Q10 : Installation of different types of cables 


Mediocre OK Better 

Fig. Q9 : CEM performance of various types of metal cableways 

In certain cases, a poor cableway in EMI terms may be suitable if the 

EM environment is low, if shielded cables or optical fibres are employed, or separate 

cableways are used for the different types of cables (power, data processing, etc.). 

It is a good idea to reserve space inside the cableway for a given quantity of 

additional cables. The height of the cables must be lower than the partitions of the 

cableway as shown below. Covers also improve the EMC performance of cableways. 

In U-shaped cableways, the magnetic field decreases in the two corners. 

That explains why deep cableways are preferable (see Fig. Q10). 

NO! 

YES! 

Area protected against external EM field 

Different types of cables (power and low-level connections) should not be installed in 

the same bundle or in the same cableway. Cableways should never be filled to more 

than half capacity.



It is recommended to electromagnetically separate groups from one another, either 

using shielding or by installing the cables in different cableways. The quality of the 

shielding determines the distance between groups. If there is no shielding, sufficient 

distances must be maintained (see Fig. Q11). 

The distance between power and control cables must be at least 5 times the radius 

of the larger power cable. 

Forbidden Correct Ideal 

Power cables 

Auxiliary circuits (relay contacts) 

Control (digital) 

Measurements (analogue) 

Note: All metal parts must be electrically interconnected 

Fig. Q11 : Recommendation to install groups of cables in metal cableways 

Metal building components can be used for EMC purposes. Steel beams (L, H, U 

or T shaped) often form an uninterrupted earthed structure with large transversal 

sections and surfaces with numerous intermediate earthing connections. Cables 

should if possible be run along such beams. Inside corners are better than the 

outside surfaces (see Fig. Q12). 

Fig. Q12 : Recommendation to install cables in steel beams 


Recommended 

Acceptable 

Not recommended 

Both ends of metal cableways must always be connected to local earth electrodes. 

For very long cableways, additional connections to the earthing system are 

recommended between connected devices. Where possible, the distance between 

these earthing connections should be irregular (for symmetrical wiring systems) to 

avoid resonance at identical frequencies. All connections to the earthing system 

should be short. 

Metal and non-metal cableways are available. Metal solutions offer better 

EMC characteristics. A cableway (cable trays, conduits, cable brackets, etc.) must 

offer a continuous, conducting metal structure from beginning to end. 

An aluminium cableway has a lower DC resistance than a steel cableway of the 

same size, but the transfer impedance (Zt) of steel drops at a lower frequency, 

particularly when the steel has a high relative permeability µ r. Care must be taken 

when different types of metal are used because direct electrical connection is not 

authorised in certain cases to avoid corrosion. That could be a disadvantage in terms 

of EMC. 

When devices connected to the wiring system using unshielded cables are not 

affected by low-frequency disturbances, the EMC of non-metal cableways can be 

improved by adding a parallel earthing conductor (PEC) inside the cableway. Both 

ends must be connected to the local earthing system. Connections should be made 

to a metal part with low impedance (e.g. a large metal panel of the device case). 

The PEC should be designed to handle high fault and common-mode currents. 

Q9 


Q10 




Implementation 

When a metal cableway is made up of a number of short sections, care is required to 

ensure continuity by correctly bonding the different parts. The parts should preferably 

be welded along all edges. Riveted, bolted or screwed connections are authorised as 

long as the contact surfaces conduct current (no paint or insulating coatings) and are 

protected against corrosion. Tightening torques must be observed to ensure correct 

pressure for the electrical contact between two parts. 

When a particular shape of cableway is selected, it should be used for the entire 

length. All interconnections must have a low impedance. A single wire connection 

between two parts of the cableway produces a high local impedance that cancels its 

EMC performance. 

Starting at a few MHz, a ten-centimetre connection between two parts of the cableway 

reduces the attenuation factor by more than a factor of ten (see Fig. Q13). 

Fig. Q13 : Metal cableways assembly 


NO! 

NOT RECOMMENDED 

YES! 

Each time modifications or extensions are made, it is very important to make sure 

they are carried out according to EMC rules (e.g. never replace a metal cableway by 

a plastic version!). 

Covers for metal cableways must meet the same requirements as those applying to 

the cableways themselves. A cover should have a large number of contacts along the 

entire length. If that is not possible, it must be connected to the cableway at least at 

the two ends using short connections (e.g. braided or meshed connections). 

When cableways must be interrupted to pass through a wall (e.g. firewalls), lowimpedance 

connections must be used between the two parts (see Fig. Q14). 

Mediocre OK Better 

Fig. Q14 : Recommendation for metal cableways assembly to pass through a wall


Fig. Q15 : Implementation of shielded cables 

All bonding connections must be made to bare metal 

Not acceptable 

Bonding wire 

Poorly connected shielding = reduced effectiveness 

Correct 

Equipotential metal panel 


3. Implementation of shielded cables 

When the decision is made to use shielded cables, it is also necessary to determine 

how the shielding will be bonded (type of earthing, connector, cable entry, etc.), 

otherwise the benefits are considerably reduced. To be effective, the shielding should 

be bonded over 360°. Figure Q1 below show different ways of earthing the cable 

shielding. 

For computer equipment and digital links, the shielding should be connected at each 

end of the cable. 

Connection of the shielding is very important for EMC and the following points should 

be noted. 

If the shielded cable connects equipment located in the same equipotential bonding 

area, the shielding must be connected to the exposed conductive parts (ECP) at 

both ends. If the connected equipment is not in the same equipotential bonding area, 

there are a number of possibilities. 

b Connection of only one end to the ECPs is dangerous. If an insulation fault occurs, 

the voltage in the shielding can be fatal for an operator or destroy equipment. In 

addition, at high frequencies, the shielding is not effective. 

b Connection of both ends to the ECPs can be dangerous if an insulation fault 

occurs. A high current flows in the shielding and can damage it. To limit this problem, 

a parallel earthing conductor (PEC) must be run next to the shielded cable. The size 

of the PEC depends on the short-circuit current in the given part of the installation. 

It is clear that if the installation has a well meshed earthing network, this problem 

does not arise. 

Collar, clamp, etc. 

Acceptable 

Ideal 


Collar, clamp, etc. 

Bonding bar 

connected 

to the chassis 

Cable gland = circumferential contact to 

equipotential metal panel 

3.7 Communication networks 

Communication networks cover large distances and interconnect equipment 

installed in rooms that may have distribution systems with different system earthing 

arrangements. In addition, if the various sites are not equipotential, high transient 

currents and major differences in potential may occur between the various devices 

connected to the networks. As noted above, this is the case when insulation 

faults and lightning strikes occur. The dielectric withstand capacity (between live 

conductors and exposed conductive parts) of communication cards installed in 

PCs or PLCs generally does not exceed 500 V. At best, the withstand capacity can 

reach 1.5 kV. In meshed installations with the TN-S system and relatively small 

communication networks, this level of withstand capacity is acceptable. In all cases, 

however, protection against lightning strikes (common and differential modes) is 

recommended. 

Q11 


Q12 



i 

VL1 

V arrestor 

VL2 

i 

Earthing bar 

Protected 

device 

Fig. Q16 : The protected device must be connected to the surge-arrestor terminals 

Earthing bar 

SA 

Isc 

prot 

SA 


The type of communication cable employed is an important parameter. It must 

be suited to the type of transmission. To create a reliable communication link, the 

following parameters must be taken into account: 

b Characteristic impedance 

b Twisted pairs or other arrangement 

b Resistance and capacitance per unit length 

b Signal attenutation per unit length 

b The type(s) of shielding used 

In addition, it is important to use symmetrical (differential) transmission links because 

they offer higher performance in terms of EMC. 

In environments with severe EM conditions, however, or for wide communication 

networks between installations that are not or are only slightly equipotential, in 

conjunction with IT, TT or TN-C systems, it is highly recommended to use optical 

fibre links. 

For safety reasons, the optical fibre must not have metal parts (risk of electric shock 

if the fibre links two areas with different potentials). 

3.8 Implementation of surge arrestors 

The wiring of surge arrestors is as important as the selection of the surge arrestor 

itself. Figures Q1 and Q17a below shows that the connection cables of the surge 

arrestor and its disconnection circuit-breaker must not exceed 50 centimetres to 

ensure effective protection. 

Common mode 

impedance 

1 m of cable = 1 µH 

L1 = 0.5 m = 0.5 µH 

L2 = 1.5 m = 1.5 µH 

di lightning = 10 kA 

dt = 10 µs 

V arrestor = 1,200 V 

Protected 

outgoers 

Common-mode impedance length y 50 cm 

Surge Arrestor 


Device withstand in common mode: 2,000 V 

V PROT = VL1 + VL2 + V arrestor 

where 

di 

10 kA 

VL1 = L1 = 0.5 µH x = 500 V 

dt 

10 µs 

di 

10 kA 

VL2 = L2 = 1.5 µH x = 1,500 V 

dt 

10 µs 

V PROT = 500 V + 1,500 V + 1,200 V = 3,200 V ! 

L1 + L2 must therefore not exceed 0.5 m 

Protected 

outgoers 

Earthing bar 

Fig. Q17a : Examples of assemblies combining surge arrestors (SA) and disconnection circuit-breakers to reduce the common-mode impedances and the area of 

upstream-downstream loops 

Isc 

prot 

SA


Fig. Q17b : The protected device must be connected to the surge-arrestor terminals 


3.9 Cabinet cabling (Fig. Q18) 

Each cabinet must be equipped with an earthing bar or a ground reference metal 

sheet. All shielded cables and external protection circuits must be connected to this 

point. Anyone of the cabinet metal sheets or the DIN rail can be used as the ground 

reference. 

Plastic cabinets are not recommended. In this case, the DIN rail must be used as 

ground reference. 

3.10 Standards 


Potential 

Reference Plate 

It is absolutely essential to specify the standards and recommendations that must be 

taken into account for installations. 

Below are several documents that may be used: 

b EN 50174-1 Information technology - Cabling installation. Part 1: 

Specification and quality assurance 

b EN 50174-2 Information technology - Cabling installation. Part 2: Installation 

planning and practices inside buildings 

Q13 


Q14 



4 Coupling mechanisms and 

counter-measures 


An EM interference phenomenon may be summed up in Figure Q18 below. 

Source Coupling 

Victim 

Origin of 

emitted disturbances 

Example: 

Walkie-talkie TV set 

Fig. Q18 : EM interference phenomenon 


Means by which 

disturbances are 

transmitted 

Radiated waves 

Equipment likely 

to be disturbed 

The different sources of disturbances are: 

b Radio-frequency emissions 

v Wireless communication systems (radio, TV, CB, radio telephones, remote controls) 

v Radar 

b Electrical equipment 

v High-power industrial equipment (induction furnaces, welding machines, stator 

control systems) 

v Office equipment (computers and electronic circuits, photocopy machines, large 

monitors) 

v Discharge lamps (neon, fluorescent, flash, etc.) 

v Electromechanical components (relays, contactors, solenoids, current interruption 

devices) 

b Power systems 

v Power transmission and distribution systems 

v Electrical transportation systems 

b Lightning 

b Electrostatic discharges (ESD) 

b Electromagnetic nuclear pulses (EMNP) 

The potential victims are: 

b Radio and television receivers, radar, wireless communication systems 

b Analogue systems (sensors, measurement acquisition, amplifiers, monitors) 

b Digital systems (computers, computer communications, peripheral equipment) 

The different types of coupling are: 

b Common-mode impedance (galvanic) coupling 

b Capacitive coupling 

b Inductive coupling 

b Radiated coupling (cable to cable, field to cable, antenna to antenna)




4.2 Common-mode impedance coupling 

Definition 

Two or more devices are interconnected by the power supply and communication 

cables (see Fig. Q19). When external currents (lightning, fault currents, disturbances) 

flow via these common-mode impedances, an undesirable voltage appears between 

points A and B which are supposed to be equipotential. This stray voltage can 

disturb low-level or fast electronic circuits. 

All cables, including the protective conductors, have an impedance, particularly at 

high frequencies. 

Stray 

overvoltage 

Z1 

Fig. Q19 : Definition of common-mode impedance coupling 

Examples (see Fig. Q20) 

Device 1 

b Devices linked by a common reference conductor (e.g. PEN, PE) affected by fast 

or intense (di/dt) current variations (fault current, lightning strike, short-circuit, load 

changes, chopping circuits, harmonic currents, power factor correction capacitor 

banks, etc.) 

b A common return path for a number of electrical sources 


Z sign. 

I2 

A B 

I1 

Z2 

Device 2 

ECPs ECPs 

Signal line 

The exposed conductive parts (ECP) of devices 1 and 2 are connected to a common 

earthing terminal via connections with impedances Z1 and Z2. 

The stray overvoltage flows to the earth via Z1. The potential of device 1 increases 

to Z1 I1. The difference in potential with device 2 (initial potential = 0) results in the 

appearance of current I2. 

I2 

Z1 

Z1 I1= ( Zsign + Z2) 

I2 

⇒ = 

I1 

Zsign + Z2 

( ) 

I 

Current I2, present on the signal line, disturbs device 2. 

Device 1 Device 2 

Signal cable 

Disturbing 

current 

Difference in 

potential 

ZMC 

Disturbed 

cable 

Fig. Q20 : Example of common-mode impedance coupling 

Fault 

currents 

Lightning 

strike 

Q15 


Q16 



U 

Vsource 

Vvictim 

Fig. Q22 : Typical result of capacitive coupling (capacitive 

cross-talk) 

t 

t 



Counter-measures (see Fig. Q21) 

If they cannot be eliminated, common-mode impedances must at least be as low as 

possible. To reduce the effects of common-mode impedances, it is necessary to: 

b Reduce impedances: 

v Mesh the common references, 

v Use short cables or flat braids which, for equal sizes, have a lower impedance than 

round cables, 

v Install functional equipotential bonding between devices. 

b Reduce the level of the disturbing currents by adding common-mode filtering and 

differential-mode inductors 

Stray 

overvoltage 

Z1 

Device 1 

If the impedance of the parallel earthing conductor PEC (Z sup) is very low 

compared to Z sign, most of the disturbing current flows via the PEC, i.e. not 

via the signal line as in the previous case. 

The difference in potential between devices 1 and 2 becomes very low and the 

disturbance acceptable. 


I1 

Z sign. 

I2 

Z sup. 

Fig. Q21 : Counter-measures of common-mode impedance coupling 

4.3 Capacitive coupling 

Definition 

Z2 

Device 2 

The level of disturbance depends on the voltage variations (dv/dt) and the value of 

the coupling capacitance between the disturber and the victim. 

Capacitive coupling increases with: 

b The frequency 

b The proximity of the disturber to the victim and the length of the parallel cables 

b The height of the cables with respect to a ground referencing plane 

b The input impedance of the victim circuit (circuits with a high input impedance are 

more vulnerable) 

b The insulation of the victim cable (ε r of the cable insulation), particularly for tightly 

coupled pairs 

Figure Q22 shows the results of capacitive coupling (cross-talk) between two cables. 

Examples (see Fig. Q23 opposite page) 

b Nearby cables subjected to rapid voltage variations (dv/dt) 

b Start-up of fluorescent lamps 

b High-voltage switch-mode power supplies (photocopy machines, etc.) 

b Coupling capacitance between the primary and secondary windings of 

transformers 

b Cross-talk between cables 

PEC


Source 

Metal shielding 

Fig. Q24 : Cable shielding with perforations reduces capacitive 

coupling 

C 

Victim 



Differential mode Common mode 

Vs 

DM 

Source 

Counter-measures (see Fig. Q24) 

b Limit the length of parallel runs of disturbers and victims to the strict minimum 

b Increase the distance between the disturber and the victim 

b For two-wire connections, run the two wires as close together as possible 

b Position a PEC bonded at both ends and between the disturber and the victim 

b Use two or four-wire cables rather than individual conductors 

b Use symmetrical transmission systems on correctly implemented, symmetrical 

wiring systems 

b Shield the disturbing cables, the victim cables or both (the shielding must be 

bonded) 

b Reduce the dv/dt of the disturber by increasing the signal rise time where possible 

4.4 Inductive coupling 

Definition 

Iv 

DM 

Victim 

Vs DM: Source of the disturbing voltage (differential mode) 

Iv DM: Disturbing current on victim side (differential mode) 

Vs CM: Source of the disturbing voltage (common mode) 

Iv CM: Disturbing current on victim side (common mode) 

Fig. Q23 : Example of capacitive coupling 

The disturber and the victim are coupled by a magnetic field. The level of disturbance 

depends on the current variations (di/dt) and the mutual coupling inductance. 

Inductive coupling increases with: 

b The frequency 

b The proximity of the disturber to the victim and the length of the parallel cables, 

b The height of the cables with respect to a ground referencing plane, 

b The load impedance of the disturbing circuit. 

Examples (see Fig. Q25 next page) 

b Nearby cables subjected to rapid current variations (di/dt) 

b Short-circuits 

b Fault currents 

b Lightning strikes 

b Stator control systems 

b Welding machines 

b Inductors 


Vs 

CM 

Source Victim 

Iv 

CM 

Q17 


Q18 





Counter-measures 

b Limit the length of parallel runs of disturbers and victims to the strict minimum 

b Increase the distance between the disturber and the victim 

b For two-wire connections, run the two wires as close together as possible 

b Use multi-core or touching single-core cables, preferably in a triangular layout 

b Position a PEC bonded at both ends and between the disturber and the victim 

b Use symmetrical transmission systems on correctly implemented, symmetrical 

wiring systems 

b Shield the disturbing cables, the victim cables or both (the shielding must be 

bonded) 

b Reduce the dv/dt of the disturber by increasing the signal rise time where possible 

(series-connected resistors or PTC resistors on the disturbing cable, ferrite rings on 

the disturbing and/or victim cable) 

4.5 Radiated coupling 

Definition 

i 

Disturbing 

cable 

H 

Victim pair 

Victim loop 

Differential mode Common mode 

Fig. Q25 : Example of inductive coupling 

The disturber and the victim are coupled by a medium (e.g. air). The level of 

disturbance depends on the power of the radiating source and the effectiveness 

of the emitting and receiving antenna. An electromagnetic field comprises both an 

electrical field and a magnetic field. The two fields are correlated. It is possible to 

analyse separately the electrical and magnetic components. 

The electrical field (E field) and the magnetic field (H field) are coupled in wiring 

systems via the wires and loops (see Fig. Q26). 

E field 


i 

i 

Disturbing 

cable 

Field-to-cable coupling Field-to-loop coupling 

Fig. Q26 : Definition of radiated coupling 

H 

H field 

V 

Victim loop




When a cable is subjected to a variable electrical field, a current is generated in the 

cable. This phenomenon is called field-to-cable coupling. 

Similarly, when a variable magnetic field flows through a loop, it creates a counter 

electromotive force that produces a voltage between the two ends of the loop. This 

phenomenon is called field-to-loop coupling. 

Examples (see Fig. Q27) 

b Radio-transmission equipment (walkie-talkies, radio and TV transmitters, mobile 

services) 

b Radar 

b Automobile ignition systems 

b Arc-welding machines 

b Induction furnaces 

b Power switching systems 

b Electrostatic discharges (ESD) 

b Lighting 

Device 


h 

Ground reference plane 

i 

EM field 

Signal 

cable 

Device 1 Device 2 

Example of field-to-cable coupling Example of field-to-loop coupling 

Fig. Q27 : Examples of radiated coupling 

Counter-measures 

E field 

h 

Area of the 

earth loop 

To minimise the effects of radiated coupling, the measures below are required. 

For field-to-cable coupling 

b Reduce the antenna effect of the victim by reducing the height (h) of the cable with 

respect to the ground referencing plane 

b Place the cable in an uninterrupted, bonded metal cableway (tube, trunking, cable 

tray) 

b Use shielded cables that are correctly installed and bonded 

b Add PECs 

b Place filters or ferrite rings on the victim cable 

For field-to-loop coupling 

b Reduce the surface of the victim loop by reducing the height (h) and the length 

of the cable. Use the solutions for field-to-cable coupling. Use the Faraday cage 

principle. 

Radiated coupling can be eliminated using the Faraday cage principle. A possible 

solution is a shielded cable with both ends of the shielding connected to the metal 

case of the device. The exposed conductive parts must be bonded to enhance 

effectiveness at high frequencies. 

Radiated coupling decreases with the distance and when symmetrical transmission 

links are used. 

Q19 


Q20 



Unshielded cables of 

different groups 

NO! 

h 

YES! 

Risk of cross-talk in common mode if e < 3 h 

Sensitive 

cable 

Disturbing 

cable 

e 

Shielded cables of 

different groups 

Sensitive 

cable 

Disturbing 

cable 

30 cm u 1 m 

NO! YES! 

Ground 

reference 

plane 

Cross incompatible 

cables at right angles 

Fig. Q29 : Wiring recommendations for cables carrying 

different types of signals 

NO! YES! 

Standard cable 

Poorly implemented 

ribbon cable 

Digital connection 

Analogue pair 

Bonding wires 

Fig. Q30 : Use of cables and ribbon cable 

Two distinct pairs 

Correctly implemented 

ribbon cable 

5 Wiring recommendations 

5.1 Signal classes (see Fig. Q28) 

1 - Power connections 

(supply + PE) 

4 - Analogue link 

(sensor) 


Device 

Fig. Q28 : Internal signals can be grouped in four classes 

2 - Relay 

connections 

3 - Digital link 

(bus) 

Four classes of internal signals are: 

b Class 1 

Mains power lines, power circuits with a high di/dt, switch-mode converters, powerregulation 

control devices. 

This class is not very sensitive, but disturbs the other classes (particularly in 

common mode). 

b Class 2 

Relay contacts. 

This class is not very sensitive, but disturbs the other classes (switching, arcs when 

contacts open). 

b Class 3 

Digital circuits (HF switching). 

This class is sensitive to pulses, but also disturbs the following class. 

b Class 4 

Analogue input/output circuits (low-level measurements, active sensor supply 

circuits). This class is sensitive. 

It is a good idea to use conductors with a specific colour for each class to 

facilitate identification and separate the classes. This is useful during design and 

troubleshooting. 

5.2 Wiring recommendations 

Cables carrying different types of signals must be physically separated 

(see Fig. Q29 above) 

Disturbing cables (classes 1 and 2) must be placed at some distance from the 

sensitive cables (classes 3 and 4) (see Fig. Q29 and Fig. Q30) 

In general, a 10 cm separation between cables laid flat on sheet metal is sufficient 

(for both common and differential modes). If there is enough space, a distance of 

30 cm is preferable. If cables must be crossed, this should be done at right angles to 

avoid cross-talk (even if they touch). There are no distance requirements if the cables 

are separated by a metal partition that is equipotential with respect to the ECPs. 

However, the height of the partition must be greater than the diameter of the cables.


Power + 

analogue 

NO! YES! 

Digital + 

relay contacts 

Power connections 

Relay I/O connections 

Power + 

relay contacts 

Shielding 

Fig. Q31 : Incompatible signals = different cables 

NO! YES! 

Digital connections 

Analogue connections 

Digital + 

analogue 

Digital connections 

Analogue connections 

Fig. Q33 : Segregation applies to connectors as well! 


A cable should carry the signals of a single group (see Fig. Q31) 

If it is necessary to use a cable to carry the signals of different groups, internal 

shielding is necessary to limit cross-talk (differential mode). The shielding, preferably 

braided, must be bonded at each end for groups 1, 2 and 3. 

It is advised to overshield disturbing and sensitive cables (see Fig. Q32) 

The overshielding acts as a HF protection (common and differential modes) if it 

is bonded at each end using a circumferential connector, a collar or a clampere 

However, a simple bonding wire is not sufficient. 

Electronic 

control 

device 

Electronic 

control 

device 

Shielded pair 


NO! 

Unshielded cable for stator control 

YES! 

Shielded pair + overshielding 

Shielded cable for stator control 

Electromechanical 

device 

Electromechanical 

device 

Fig. Q32 : Shielding and overshielding for disturbing and/or sensitive cables 

Sensor 

Bonded using a clamp 

Sensor 

Avoid using a single connector for different groups (see Fig. Q33) 

Except where necessary for groups 1 and 2 (differential mode). If a single connector 

is used for both analogue and digital signals, the two groups must be separated by at 

least one set of contacts connected to 0 V used as a barrier. 

All free conductors (reserve) must always be bonded at each end 

(see Fig. Q34) 

For group 4, these connections are not advised for lines with very low voltage 

and frequency levels (risk of creating signal noise, by magnetic induction, at the 

transmission frequencies). 

Wires not 

equipotentially 

bonded 

NO! YES! 

Electronic 

system 

Equipotential sheet metal panel 

Fig. Q34 : Free wires must be equipotentially bonded 

Electronic 

system 

Equipotential sheet metal panel 

Q21 


Q22 



NO! YES! 

Power or disturbing cables 

Relay cables 

Measurement or sensitive cables 

Fig. Q37 : Cable distribution in cable trays 

Metal tray 


The two conductors must be installed as close together as possible 

(see Fig. Q35) 

This is particularly important for low-level sensors. Even for relay signals with a 

common, the active conductors should be accompanied by at least one common 

conductor per bundle. For analogue and digital signals, twisted pairs are a minimum 

requirement. A twisted pair (differential mode) guarantees that the two wires remain 

together along their entire length. 

PCB with 

relay contact 

I/Os 

- + 

Power supply 


NO! YES! 

Area of 

loop too large 

PCB with 

relay contact 

I/Os 

Fig. Q35 : The two wires of a pair must always be run close together 

- + 

Power supply 

Group-1 cables do not need to be shielded if they are filtered 

But they should be made of twisted pairs to ensure compliance with the previous 

section. 

Cables must always be positioned along their entire length against the bonded 

metal parts of devices (see Fig. Q36) 

For example: Covers, metal trunking, structure, etc. In order to take advantage of the 

dependable, inexpensive and significant reduction effect (common mode) and anticross-talk 

effect (differential mode). 

Power 

supply 

NO! YES! 

Chassis 1 

Chassis 2 

Chassis 3 

I/O interface 

Power 

supply 

Chassis 1 

Chassis 2 

Chassis 3 

I/O interface 

All metal parts (frame, structure, enclosures, etc.) are equipotential 

Fig. Q36 : Run wires along their entire length against the bonded metal parts 

The use of correctly bonded metal trunking considerably improves 

internal EMC (see Fig. Q37)

Schneider Electric Industries SAS 

Head Office 

89, bd Franklin Roosevelt 

92506 Rueil-Malmaison Cedex 

FRANCE 

EIGED306001EN 

ART. 822690 

As standards, specifications and designs change from time, please ask for confirmation of the 

information given in this publication. 

ISBN 978-2-9531643-0-5 

This document has been 

printed on ecological paper 

9 782953 164305 

03/2008

Chapter A General rules of electrical installation design

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?