Are-Both-Kiev-and-Moscow-Fighting-the-Wrong-Wars-Wikistrat-report
Are-Both-Kiev-and-Moscow-Fighting-the-Wrong-Wars-Wikistrat-report
Are-Both-Kiev-and-Moscow-Fighting-the-Wrong-Wars-Wikistrat-report
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
2<br />
<strong>Are</strong> <strong>Both</strong> <strong>Kiev</strong> Who <strong>and</strong> 3D <strong>Moscow</strong> Prints What <strong>Fighting</strong> in 2033? <strong>the</strong> <strong>Wrong</strong> <strong>Wars</strong>?<br />
With Russia <strong>and</strong> Ukraine deadlocked in <strong>the</strong> Donbass region, could it be that each is actually fighting <strong>the</strong> wrong war?<br />
The conflict has set back <strong>the</strong> Maidan Revolution’s European ambitions, pushed Ukraine’s economy to <strong>the</strong> brink <strong>and</strong><br />
severely tested its new leaders, many of whom came to power unprepared to rule.<br />
Russia is paying a heavy price as well. Economic sanctions imposed by Western countries after it annexed Crimea<br />
combined with low oil prices <strong>and</strong> governmental corruption to produce <strong>the</strong> worst economic crisis Russia has seen since<br />
Vladimir Putin came to power in 2000. Economic growth almost came to a st<strong>and</strong>still in 2014, <strong>and</strong> between 3.5 <strong>and</strong> 4<br />
percent negative growth is expected this year. The ruble lost 40 percent of its value against <strong>the</strong> dollar in six months.<br />
Inflation hit 16.7 percent in February.<br />
ABOUT US<br />
<strong>Wikistrat</strong> is <strong>the</strong> world’s first crowdsourced consultancy. It leverages a global network of subject-matter experts<br />
via a patent-pending “Collaborative Competition” methodology to provide a variety of analytic services. Scenario<br />
generation, policy planning, risk assessment <strong>and</strong> red-teaming exercises are conducted by <strong>Wikistrat</strong> on a realtime,<br />
interactive online platform.
3<br />
WIN THE WAR, LOSE THE PEACE<br />
Perhaps <strong>Kiev</strong> ought to hope it doesn’t win <strong>the</strong> war at all. Even if it wins on <strong>the</strong> battlefield, <strong>Kiev</strong> may <strong>the</strong>n lose<br />
<strong>the</strong> peace, being burdened with a war-ravaged region that needs to be rebuilt <strong>and</strong> an alienated local population to be<br />
reintegrated. Its economy is already in free fall. Ukraine’s gross domestic product tumbled 6.8 percent in 2014 <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong><br />
International Monetary Fund predicts it will shrink ano<strong>the</strong>r 5.5 percent this year. Its foreign reserves fell 64 percent in<br />
2014 <strong>and</strong> declined from $7.5 to $5.6 billion in <strong>the</strong> first quarter of 2015. At this rate, <strong>the</strong>y will be exhausted by <strong>the</strong> end<br />
of <strong>the</strong> year.<br />
It could even get worse, especially if <strong>Kiev</strong> holds on to <strong>the</strong> Donbass by acquiescing to <strong>Moscow</strong>’s dem<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> turns<br />
away from <strong>the</strong> West. How much authority would <strong>the</strong> leaders in <strong>Kiev</strong> have <strong>the</strong>n, as ultra-nationalists denounce <strong>the</strong>m as<br />
quislings – <strong>and</strong> local strongmen, populists <strong>and</strong> oligarchs marginalize <strong>the</strong> government in a country awash with illegal<br />
guns, refugees <strong>and</strong> traumatized veterans? Ukraine could start to look like a failed state on <strong>the</strong> edge of Europe.<br />
THE MAKING OF THE NEW UKRAINE<br />
The freezing of <strong>the</strong> conflict would be a devastating blow to <strong>the</strong> identity of <strong>the</strong> “new” Ukraine, but it offers perverse<br />
advantages. The war would grind to a stalemate, with Ukraine <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> Russian-backed “Novorossiyan People’s Republic”<br />
pseudo-state glowering at each o<strong>the</strong>r across an unrecognized but all-too-real border marked with barbed wire, trenches<br />
<strong>and</strong> mined no-man’s-l<strong>and</strong>s. Russia, suffering a serious economic crisis unlikely to soon resolve itself, would be forced to<br />
arm, guard, feed <strong>and</strong> support its puppet fiefdom.<br />
Admittedly, <strong>the</strong> worst case would be that Ukraine, haunted by its failure to hold its borders, slips into cycles of vicious<br />
political squabbles <strong>and</strong> intolerance. Politics in <strong>Kiev</strong> could become dominated by a new wave of nationalism, which<br />
would alarm its Western friends.<br />
But losing <strong>the</strong> Donbass could just as easily be <strong>the</strong> making of <strong>the</strong> new Ukraine. The rump state could gain a new cohesion<br />
through <strong>the</strong> shared experience of struggle, while <strong>the</strong> West – eager to teach <strong>Moscow</strong> a lesson – would both require<br />
<strong>and</strong> support <strong>the</strong> often-painful processes of political <strong>and</strong> economic reform <strong>the</strong> country so desperately needs. Ukraine<br />
would still be beset by problems of corruption <strong>and</strong> poor productivity, <strong>and</strong> – notwithst<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>the</strong> efforts to diversify<br />
its trading <strong>and</strong> energy partners – would need to maintain a relationship of some kind with <strong>Moscow</strong>. Yet, a younger<br />
generation of Ukrainians would have embraced an ambitious national identity in which <strong>the</strong> struggle to modernize <strong>and</strong><br />
join a democratic, free-market Europe takes center stage.<br />
In this context, <strong>the</strong> ideal for both Ukraine <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> West would appear to be as neat a bisection of <strong>the</strong> country as possible,<br />
leaving <strong>the</strong> aging industries <strong>and</strong> rubble-strewn cities of <strong>the</strong> Donbass for <strong>the</strong> Russians <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong>ir local proxies. Conversely,<br />
<strong>Moscow</strong>’s interests are best served by forcing <strong>the</strong> rebellious regions back into Ukraine, like a rusty nail to poison <strong>the</strong><br />
country’s bloodstream.<br />
What <strong>the</strong>n can <strong>the</strong> various actors do to attempt to drive events in <strong>the</strong> directions of <strong>the</strong>ir choosing?<br />
A FUTURE DEFINED BY ECONOMICS<br />
Any actor wishing to win hearts <strong>and</strong> minds in Ukraine must provide an economic alternative. For example, if <strong>the</strong><br />
Russian economy manages to rebound more quickly <strong>and</strong> vigorously than expected, <strong>the</strong>n it acquires new scope to win<br />
Ukraine back into its fold through <strong>the</strong> offer of cheaper energy or wider trading opportunities within Putin’s Eurasian<br />
Economic Union.<br />
However, without such soft-power options, <strong>the</strong> Kremlin is forced to stick to its playbook of subversion, destabilization<br />
<strong>and</strong> outright military intervention. It certainly has <strong>the</strong> capacity to maintain <strong>the</strong> current situation indefinitely, or even<br />
escalate it by streng<strong>the</strong>ning its own forces in <strong>the</strong> region or waging a campaign of terrorism in <strong>the</strong> rest of Ukraine.<br />
However, <strong>the</strong>se all have serious costs, from increased sanctions to <strong>the</strong> direct expense of fighting a war <strong>and</strong> supporting<br />
<strong>the</strong> Donbass.
Likewise, if Europe <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> United States want to reengineer Ukrainian politics, <strong>the</strong>y need to be willing to underwrite this<br />
process with very substantial aid <strong>and</strong> credit. There are historical models. A new “Marshall Plan,” inspired by <strong>the</strong> postwar<br />
reconstruction of Europe, would mean not just massive <strong>and</strong> targeted aid, but a parallel requirement that Ukraine adopts<br />
governance reforms to streng<strong>the</strong>n its democracy <strong>and</strong> address <strong>the</strong> serious problem of corruption.<br />
It is possible to conceive of a rump Ukraine taking real steps toward European Union membership, or <strong>the</strong> government<br />
taking <strong>the</strong> time to rebuild <strong>and</strong> restructure its army to be able to reconquer <strong>the</strong> Donbass – or even <strong>the</strong> Kremlin deciding<br />
to cut its losses <strong>and</strong> withdraw. In each case, though, <strong>the</strong>re is a great risk that o<strong>the</strong>r actors <strong>and</strong> events will interfere. The<br />
rebels could make it difficult for <strong>Moscow</strong> to disengage, for example, while Russia could respond to any government<br />
escalation with an escalation of its own.<br />
Absent <strong>the</strong> economic resources <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> political will for major, game-changing initiatives from any of <strong>the</strong> involved actors,<br />
<strong>Kiev</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Moscow</strong> are only locking <strong>the</strong>mselves into destructively counterproductive strategies.<br />
ATTRIBUTIONS<br />
[Cover] This work, “cover”, is a derivative of “LKJUKL” by MARIAJONER, under <strong>the</strong> Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license; “Map of<br />
Ukraine” by United Nations Cartographic Section, published into <strong>the</strong> public domain; “Adam Mickiewicz square in Lviv” by ru:Ipesin, under <strong>the</strong> Creative Commons<br />
Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license; “Visite officielle du Président de la République d’Ukraine Petro Porochenko au Conseil de l’Europe, Strasbourg 26 juin<br />
2014.” by Photo Claude TRUONG-NGOC under <strong>the</strong> Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license; “Flag of Ukraine with clear background (for portal<br />
banner)” by Alex Maisuradze based on 3d work by UP9 under <strong>the</strong> Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. “Cover” is licensed under CC BY<br />
by Daniella Mordehai.
June 2013