02.05.2015 Views

September 2005 Newsletter - Milwaukee Academy of Medicine

September 2005 Newsletter - Milwaukee Academy of Medicine

September 2005 Newsletter - Milwaukee Academy of Medicine

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ILWAUKEE ACADEMY<br />

OF MEDICINE<br />

Vo l u m e X I I I / S e p t e m b e r 20 0 5<br />

<strong>September</strong> 20 th , <strong>2005</strong>:<br />

Bedside Rationing:<br />

Inevitable or Immoral?<br />

Bedside rationing - deciding to withhold a treatment<br />

from one patient because another patient might need it<br />

more - is not all that distant a memory as a common problem<br />

in medicine. When the first dialysis machine was made available<br />

for patients, Life Magazine described the difficult decisions<br />

that a selection committee had to make in deciding who<br />

would be chosen to have the precious resource <strong>of</strong> dialysis in<br />

an article titled “They Decide Who Lives and Who Dies.”<br />

Contemporary physicians have <strong>of</strong>ten been taught that<br />

rationing at the bedside is immoral. We are to be patient<br />

advocates, not guardians <strong>of</strong> society’s resources. We have also<br />

been taught that saving resources on one patient will not<br />

necessarily result in the availability for more resources for<br />

another patient.<br />

But Susan Dorr Goold, MD, MHSA, MA, our <strong>September</strong><br />

guest speaker, doesn’t agree that bedside rationing is necessarily<br />

immoral. Dr. Dorr Goold is Director <strong>of</strong> the University <strong>of</strong><br />

Michigan’s Bioethics Program and Associate Pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong> Internal<br />

<strong>Medicine</strong> and Health Management and Policy. She will explain how<br />

rationing currently occurs in multiple ways and at multiple levels in the<br />

U.S. health care system, why rationing is inevitable and how it should<br />

be done openly and with moral integrity. Once you hear Dr. Dorr<br />

Goold, you won’t think about the “R” word the same way again. <br />

October 18 th , <strong>2005</strong> :<br />

AIDS: Are We Losing<br />

the Fight?<br />

The incidence rate <strong>of</strong> Human<br />

Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) infection<br />

is rising in Wisconsin and the United<br />

States for the first time in a decade.<br />

Meanwhile, the pandemic advances rapidly in<br />

Africa, Eastern Europe and Asia. Why has US<br />

progress stalled, and how did we fail to prevent<br />

a global pandemic <strong>of</strong> enormous human<br />

and economic impact?<br />

James Vergeront, MD is the Director <strong>of</strong><br />

the Wisconsin HIV/AIDS program, overseeing<br />

surveillance, prevention and treatment<br />

programs since 1979. He will provide an<br />

overview <strong>of</strong> past lessons and future opportunities. He<br />

will be followed by 3 panelists (Bevan Baker, CHE,<br />

David Fisk, MD and Karen Ivantic-Doucette, MSN,<br />

APN-BC, ACRN) exploring international, urban public<br />

health and medical care practice implications <strong>of</strong> the<br />

pandemic.<br />

Come and consider your role in the fight<br />

against a pandemic that the WHO’s<br />

Director General has called “the benchmark<br />

by which our generation will be judged.” <br />

<strong>2005</strong>-2006 MEETING DATES <br />

Fall <strong>2005</strong>: <strong>September</strong> 20 • October 18 • November 15<br />

Winter/Spring 2006: January 17 • February 21 • March 21 • April 18 • May 16<br />

MEETING LOCATION: University Club <strong>of</strong> <strong>Milwaukee</strong> • 924 East Wells Street • 6:00 p.m. cocktails • 6.30 p.m. dinner • 7:30 p.m. speaker presentation<br />

8701 Watertown Plank Road • <strong>Milwaukee</strong>, WI 53226 • 414.456.8249 • fax 414.456.6537 • email milwacademy<strong>of</strong>med@execpc.com • website www.milwacademy<strong>of</strong>medicine.org


From the <strong>Academy</strong>’s Rare Book Collection<br />

William Beaumont (1785-1853).<br />

Experiments and Observations<br />

on the Gastric Juice, and the<br />

Physiology <strong>of</strong> Digestion.<br />

Plattsburgh, F.P. Allen, 1833.<br />

Jesse S. Myer (1873-1913).<br />

The Life and Letters <strong>of</strong><br />

Dr. William Beaumont,<br />

Including Hitherto Unpublished<br />

Data Concerning the Case <strong>of</strong><br />

Alexis St. Martin.<br />

St. Louis, C.V. Mosby Company, 1912.<br />

Andrew Combe (1797-1847).<br />

The Principles <strong>of</strong> Physiology<br />

Applied to the Preservation <strong>of</strong> Health,<br />

and to the Improvement <strong>of</strong> Physical<br />

and Mental Education: From the<br />

Seventh Edinburgh Edition.<br />

New York, Fowlers and Wells, 1854.<br />

Review by H.D. Kerr, M.D.<br />

Three <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Academy</strong>’s holdings<br />

intertwine on the subject <strong>of</strong> early<br />

explorations in digestive physiology.<br />

William Beaumont’s celebrated work<br />

describing his investigations<br />

is well known to<br />

most physicians<br />

and is one <strong>of</strong> the<br />

cornerstones<br />

<strong>of</strong> medical<br />

physiology.<br />

It is also<br />

a fine<br />

example<br />

to all <strong>of</strong><br />

how to<br />

m a k e<br />

the most<br />

<strong>of</strong> a bad<br />

situation.<br />

With the<br />

m e d i c a l<br />

know ledge<br />

<strong>of</strong> the times<br />

he could not<br />

“cure” or “fix”<br />

Alexis St. Martin’s<br />

gastrocutaneous fistula, a large<br />

tangential wound produced by<br />

an accidental gunshot blast <strong>of</strong><br />

“powder and duck shot”<br />

received from a distance <strong>of</strong><br />

three feet. In the next eleven<br />

years at a series <strong>of</strong> army posts,<br />

he assembled an impressive<br />

body <strong>of</strong> information about the<br />

details <strong>of</strong> his patient’s digestive<br />

processes. His book was published<br />

in his adopted hometown,<br />

Plattsburgh, NY, with the help <strong>of</strong><br />

his brother, Dr. Samuel Beaumont,<br />

a former newspaper publisher. The<br />

text described the entire series <strong>of</strong><br />

238 experiments in detail. From the<br />

beginning isolated on Mackinac<br />

Island, 100 miles from any other<br />

physician, Beaumont sought<br />

help and advice in this unique<br />

research opportunity by correspondence<br />

and personal meetings<br />

with his superiors in the<br />

Army and with faculty members at<br />

Yale, Columbia and the University <strong>of</strong><br />

Virginia. His initial experiments were<br />

published in the Medical Recorder and<br />

were well received. “Life and Letters” is<br />

well worth reading for views <strong>of</strong> those<br />

times and as a study in determination.<br />

Combe’s work, first published in<br />

1831, went through numerous editions<br />

and was a very popular reference covering<br />

areas related especially to the brain,<br />

circulation, lungs, muscle, and skin. He<br />

continued this work with “The<br />

Physiology <strong>of</strong> Digestion” (1837 and not<br />

part <strong>of</strong> the Rare Book Collection), giving<br />

a “current status” approach to the<br />

subject <strong>of</strong> human digestion (1) He<br />

reviewed theories <strong>of</strong> the digestive<br />

process from ancient times to the<br />

present day. These included the<br />

Hippocratic view that digestion was<br />

accomplished by heat and was a kind <strong>of</strong><br />

concoction or stewing. Others advocated<br />

fermentation, or a putrefication<br />

process, or triturition (reduction to fine<br />

particles by grinding or rubbing), or<br />

“chymical” solution <strong>of</strong> the food in the<br />

gastric juice. He provided a useful historical<br />

perspective for Renaissance<br />

investigations on digestion as well as<br />

Beaumont’s work. He noted that<br />

Beaumont’s work was “scarcely known”<br />

in Britain and summarized the experiments<br />

in full and enthusiastic detail.<br />

He gave Beaumont full credit for making<br />

a giant step forward in expanding<br />

knowledge <strong>of</strong> human digestion. His<br />

book undoubtedly explained and popularized<br />

Beaumont’s work to a large<br />

European pr<strong>of</strong>essional readership and<br />

enhanced Beaumont’s reputation.<br />

Beaumont, educated in Vermont in<br />

the system prevalent in those days <strong>of</strong><br />

reading medicine followed by apprenticeship,<br />

was aware <strong>of</strong> the digestive<br />

experiments <strong>of</strong> the Italian scientist,<br />

Lazarro Spallanzani (1729-1799).<br />

These are described in Combe’s book.<br />

Spallanzani, after preliminary animal<br />

experiments, swallowed already chewed<br />

bread enclosed in sewn cloth bags, then<br />

recovered the bags and found them<br />

intact but empty. Suspecting a chemical<br />

process, he next encased chewed<br />

bread in tiny perforated wooden capsules.<br />

He swallowed several to examine<br />

whether grinding was involved in the<br />

primary process. The capsules were<br />

recovered undamaged. The bread was<br />

2


again gone. His method may have<br />

inspired Beaumont. Although gastric<br />

fluid investigations <strong>of</strong> three European<br />

patients with gastrocutaneous fistulas<br />

had been described, no one had<br />

approached digestion with the comprehensive<br />

and thorough manner<br />

employed by Beaumont.<br />

Combe died at a young age <strong>of</strong> consumption<br />

but made good on his childhood<br />

goal that “I’ll no be naething” .<br />

His name is found on the lists <strong>of</strong><br />

“Significant Scots” (2). His clear comprehensible<br />

writing reflected his own<br />

desire to live a life <strong>of</strong> “thorough and<br />

benevolent usefulness.” St. Martin, far<br />

from being disabled, worked as a woodcutter<br />

and a farmer and died at age 86.<br />

After one visit to see Dr. Beaumont at<br />

Ft. Crawford on the Mississippi near<br />

Prairie du Chien, the former voyageur<br />

paddled his wife and children back to<br />

Montreal by canoe. Beaumont is<br />

memorialized in several medical museums<br />

and a number <strong>of</strong> institutions<br />

including the William Beaumont Army<br />

Medical Center in El Paso, Texas. The<br />

medical center cafeteria is named the<br />

“St Martin Dining Facility.” <br />

References:<br />

1. The Physiology <strong>of</strong> Digestion,<br />

Andrew Combe, 1837.<br />

http://www.gastolab.net/ghe1.htm<br />

2. Significant Scots, Andrew Combe.<br />

http://www.electricscotland.com/<br />

history/other/combe_andrew.htm<br />

3


The Father <strong>of</strong> Endocrinology<br />

By James M. Cerletty, M.D.<br />

George Washington is <strong>of</strong>ten referred to<br />

as the “father <strong>of</strong> our country”. He<br />

married Martha Custis, a widow, who had<br />

borne four children in her first marriage.<br />

Martha had no children in her marriage to<br />

George. Some have deduced that he was<br />

sterile. So George was not literally the<br />

father <strong>of</strong> our country.<br />

The “father” <strong>of</strong> the field <strong>of</strong><br />

Endocrinology also deserves mixed credit<br />

for his title as the “father.” He is the nineteenth<br />

century physician, Dr. Charles<br />

Brown-Sequard. He was born in 1817 in<br />

Mauritius <strong>of</strong> French and American parents.<br />

He taught at Harvard in the 1860s<br />

and practiced medicine in New York the<br />

following decade. 1<br />

He was interested in the nervous system,<br />

and is remembered by an eponym for a<br />

syndrome remembered only by a handful<br />

<strong>of</strong> physicians, invariably neurologists. To<br />

spare you from looking it up, a unilateral<br />

spinal cord lesion leads to ipsilateral motor<br />

disturbance with impairment <strong>of</strong> proprioception<br />

and contralateral loss <strong>of</strong> pain and<br />

temperature appreciation below the lesion.<br />

Because <strong>of</strong> his respected reputation in<br />

clinical medicine and research, he was<br />

invited to present a paper in Paris in June<br />

1889. Dr. Brown-Sequard presented this<br />

paper at the Societe de Biologie <strong>of</strong> Paris.<br />

“He reported that he had injected himself<br />

with aqueous extracts <strong>of</strong> guinea pig and<br />

dog testes and had experienced enhancement<br />

<strong>of</strong> physical strength, a heightened<br />

intellectual capacity and an increased sexual<br />

potency.” 2<br />

His sensational presentation added spice<br />

to the Paris meeting. The French newspaper,<br />

“Le Matin,” said that the doctor<br />

claimed “he looked 30 years younger than<br />

his stated age.” 2 Brown-Sequard also told<br />

the audience that he could urinate at least<br />

one-third distance farther than before. A<br />

modern skeptic would ask whether he<br />

could write his initials in the snow. Was this<br />

the fountain <strong>of</strong> youth?<br />

“Pleas for injections poured into<br />

Brown-Sequard’s <strong>of</strong>fice from elderly men<br />

all over Europe. The more excited the public<br />

became about the ‘elixir’, the more bitter<br />

and indignant were the sc<strong>of</strong>fers.” 2<br />

The rage for such treatment quickly<br />

spread throughout France and the continent.<br />

Not everyone joined the bandwagon.<br />

A German Medical Journal writer said his<br />

“fantastic experiments must best be<br />

regarded as senile aberrations.” 2 Critics<br />

said that any benefit from the dogs’ gonads<br />

was a fantasy. In later years, he was castigated<br />

as a charlatan for his views.<br />

Brown-Sequard’s paper led to the start<br />

<strong>of</strong> organo-therapy, which flourished in the<br />

mid-twentieth century. Switzerland was<br />

the center <strong>of</strong> treatment with extracts <strong>of</strong><br />

gonads <strong>of</strong> animals. Many celebrities, royalty,<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficials <strong>of</strong> various governments and<br />

church leaders were said to have sought<br />

such treatment. This “therapy” still is used,<br />

administered by modern day charlatans.<br />

But his paper was not in vain. It indirectly<br />

led the way to effective treatments.<br />

Serendipity played a major role. In the<br />

spring <strong>of</strong> 1888, the report <strong>of</strong> the Clinical<br />

Society <strong>of</strong> London’s “Committee on<br />

Myxedema” (severe hypothyroidism) was<br />

published. 3,4 The symptoms and findings<br />

<strong>of</strong> severe hypothyroidism had been known<br />

for years, but the cause was unclear. In earlier<br />

years, some thought the thyroid was a<br />

filter to remove “impurities” from the system;<br />

that the gland produced a beneficial<br />

material was never suspected. However, the<br />

Committee on Myxedema strongly<br />

inferred that this disease appeared to be<br />

associated with destruction or loss <strong>of</strong> function<br />

<strong>of</strong> the thyroid gland. 3,4<br />

George R. Murray, a young British<br />

physician, had been a student <strong>of</strong> Victor<br />

Horsley, another prominent neurologist,<br />

who had been a member <strong>of</strong> the Committee<br />

on Myxedema. Horsely surgically removed<br />

the thyroid gland from dogs, which died in<br />

a few days, most likely from tetany due to<br />

surgical hypoparathroidism. 3 Sheep who<br />

had thyroidectomies “became even dumber<br />

than they were before the surgery.” 3<br />

Monkeys, the only primates studied, lived<br />

much longer but over time, developed apathy,<br />

hypothermia and “imbecility.” 2<br />

In 1888, likely moved by these studies<br />

and Brown-Sequard’s treatments, the 26<br />

year-old George Murray injected an extract<br />

<strong>of</strong> a sheep’s thyroid into a patient with<br />

myxedema with gradual, but eventually<br />

dramatic improvement in the patient’s<br />

condition. Three years later, he treated<br />

another patient with injections <strong>of</strong> extract<br />

<strong>of</strong> sheep thyroid. The before and after<br />

treatment photos are below.<br />

Dr. Brown-Sequard<br />

4


Within a short period <strong>of</strong> time, it was<br />

realized that injections <strong>of</strong> thyroid extract<br />

were not required. A quarter <strong>of</strong> a cup <strong>of</strong><br />

diced sheep thyroid orally led to the<br />

treatment and resolution <strong>of</strong> severe<br />

hypothyroidism.<br />

In some ways, it was fortunate that<br />

the problem was the thyroid. In general<br />

the endocrine glands are constantly producing<br />

their hormones to insure physiologic<br />

response, <strong>of</strong>ten with a diurnal<br />

surge. There is a very small reservoir <strong>of</strong><br />

hormone in most <strong>of</strong> the endocrine<br />

glands. For example, the two adrenal<br />

glands, if removed, contain less than<br />

three or four milligrams <strong>of</strong> cortisone,<br />

minute compared to the 30 milligrams<br />

required to treat adrenal insufficiency.<br />

The thyroid gland has slightly more <strong>of</strong> a<br />

reservoir <strong>of</strong> hormone than the other<br />

endocrine glands, so positive effects<br />

could be expected. Testicles <strong>of</strong> dogs,<br />

taken orally or by injection might have<br />

“helped” Brown-Sequard, but they will<br />

not help you or anyone else hit 73 home<br />

runs this year. <br />

References:<br />

1. The Columbia Encyclopedia, 5 th<br />

edition Houghton Mifflin Co. 1975,<br />

p. 379<br />

2. Wilson, Jean. Charles Edouard<br />

Brown-Sequard and the Centennial<br />

<strong>of</strong> Endocrinology. J Clin Endo &<br />

Metabolism Vol 71, No. 6, 1990<br />

3. Murray, G. Note on the treatment <strong>of</strong><br />

myxoedema by hypodermic injections<br />

<strong>of</strong> an extract <strong>of</strong> the thyroid<br />

gland <strong>of</strong> a sheep. British Med Journal.<br />

Feb 8, 1890 p. 287<br />

4. V.C. Medvei, G. MTP press. Brown-<br />

Sequard and his Organotherapy.<br />

Limited. International Medical<br />

Publishers. 1982, page 289-295<br />

To Sleep<br />

By James M. Cerletty, M.D.<br />

o sleep, perchance to dream; aye,<br />

“Tthere’s the rub.” Thus spoke<br />

Hamlet, and thus do I. The Sabbath is<br />

the day <strong>of</strong> rest. The goldfinches outside<br />

my open bedroom window waken me<br />

briefly on early spring Sunday mornings<br />

with their chatter. But the sweet<br />

songs <strong>of</strong> the robins and cardinals<br />

soon lull me back to sleep. A<br />

barking dog interrupts my slumber<br />

only long enough to note<br />

that it is 7 a.m., and I can lie<br />

abed for another two hours.<br />

Not true in Brookfield!<br />

No serenity in this suburb!<br />

It’s eight o’clock on this<br />

sleepy morning, and the<br />

cacophony emitting from<br />

lawn mowers, power saws and<br />

a variety <strong>of</strong> other multi-decibel<br />

producing machines begins! The dew has<br />

not yet left the grass, and the monsters<br />

are out in force. This somnolent one lays<br />

in bed, rubbing his eyes and picturing<br />

Lucifer himself atop a John Deere. I pray<br />

for a thunderstorm to drive these devils<br />

back to their launching pads, but the<br />

Almighty does not intervene. The Sabbath<br />

is not a day <strong>of</strong> rest in this community.<br />

If silence is golden, there<br />

is no gold in my neighborhood<br />

on Sunday mornings.<br />

By the way, another <strong>of</strong><br />

Shakespeare’s characters said that<br />

he heard a voice cry “Sleep no more!<br />

Macbeth does murder sleep, the innocent<br />

sleep, the sleep that knits up the raveled sleeve <strong>of</strong> care.”<br />

This guy Macbeth must live in Brookfield! <br />

5


S.A.M. – Our Man in Beirut<br />

by Wayne Boulanger, M.D.<br />

Former Columbia Hospital<br />

Chief <strong>of</strong> Staff<br />

The other day I was going through<br />

a stack <strong>of</strong> my memorabilia and I<br />

came across a letter from S.A.M. It<br />

had been written in Beirut in January,<br />

1965, having been inspired by a discovery<br />

he had made while roaming<br />

the Lebanese countryside. Re-reading<br />

that letter immediately brought to<br />

mind a serious omission on my part –<br />

that <strong>of</strong> never having written about<br />

this remarkable Columbia leader <strong>of</strong><br />

long ago.<br />

S.A.M.: Sylvanus Archibald Morton<br />

– born in Halifax, Nova Scotia, in<br />

1901, he attended Dalhousie<br />

University and received his M.D. there<br />

in 1926. After a year’s internship at<br />

Victoria General Hospital, he practiced<br />

for a year in Halifax and then<br />

came to the United States for a fellowship<br />

in Radiology at the Mayo Clinic,<br />

eventually ending up in <strong>Milwaukee</strong><br />

and at Columbia.<br />

How that came about I have never<br />

heard, but <strong>Milwaukee</strong> was the beneficiary<br />

<strong>of</strong> his restless presence for more<br />

than 30 years, until the mid-60’s when<br />

he left to take over the Radiology<br />

Department at the American<br />

University in Beirut.<br />

I first met SAM in 1952 , at which<br />

time he was at the height <strong>of</strong> his career<br />

– Chairman <strong>of</strong> Columbia’s Radiology<br />

Department, as well as <strong>of</strong> Marquette<br />

School <strong>of</strong> <strong>Medicine</strong> where he held the<br />

rank <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essor. Columbia Hospital<br />

at that time <strong>of</strong>fered a residency in radiology<br />

and a school for training radiology<br />

technicians, but even that hardly<br />

kept him busy. It certainly didn’t keep<br />

him from getting involved in just<br />

about every activity in and around the<br />

hospital.<br />

For example: in other hospitals the<br />

report <strong>of</strong> an x-ray examination as dictated<br />

by the radiologists would simply<br />

list the diagnostic possibilities and<br />

stop right there. Not SAM’s reports.<br />

When abnormalities were noted, he<br />

would not only make the diagnosis<br />

without equivocation – he would also<br />

list treatment options in the order <strong>of</strong><br />

his personal preference, and heaven<br />

help you, when you walked into the x-<br />

ray department the next morning, if<br />

you hadn’t followed through on his<br />

recommendations explicitly.<br />

Another example <strong>of</strong> SAM’s involvement<br />

– some <strong>of</strong> you are old enough to<br />

remember the blizzard <strong>of</strong> ’47, a late<br />

January fall <strong>of</strong> heavy, wet snow, which<br />

literally shut down the city for several<br />

days. Buses didn’t run. As a matter <strong>of</strong><br />

fact, they stayed wherever they were<br />

stuck, and hospital functions were<br />

limited to surviving until the streets<br />

were cleared. It was several days<br />

before even Maryland Avenue was<br />

navigable. But SAM, the hardy<br />

Canadian that he was, and who lived<br />

in Fox Point, made it to the hospital on<br />

skis every day, not to function as a<br />

radiologist, but as the only licensed<br />

physician in the house, making<br />

rounds, writing orders, and just plain<br />

taking over.<br />

He loved every minute <strong>of</strong> it.<br />

Under SAM, the Radiology<br />

Department functioned as the staff<br />

gathering place on a daily basis –<br />

almost like a staff lounge with x-ray<br />

view boxes, and when you pulled out<br />

the films you wanted to see that morning,<br />

SAM was there to look over your<br />

shoulder, point out the lesions, and tell<br />

you how to handle them. He also ran<br />

radiation therapy in the days before<br />

cobalt and the linear accelerator. I<br />

<strong>of</strong>ten wondered how he could do all<br />

that work and still be in on all the gossip<br />

within miles. And on top <strong>of</strong> that,<br />

his wanderlust kept him traveling<br />

extensively in his other life as a blue<br />

water sailor. Fortunately, Bob Byrne,<br />

his longtime associate, was able to fill<br />

in for him during his prolonged<br />

absences.<br />

But eventually even his sailing trips<br />

were inadequate to satisfy him, and in<br />

the early 60’s he accepted a position<br />

as Chairman <strong>of</strong> the Radiology<br />

Department at the American University<br />

in Beirut. From then on he used<br />

Lebanon as his sort <strong>of</strong> home base for<br />

his travels to Libya, Rhodesia,<br />

Pakistan, Kashmir, and God knows<br />

where.<br />

The subject <strong>of</strong> that letter he wrote to<br />

me in January, 1965, was a side trip he<br />

made (with Elizabeth in tow as always)<br />

to a small Lebanese village. He<br />

describes his visit to an ancient<br />

church:<br />

“We entered through a door in the<br />

west wall <strong>of</strong> the now useable church<br />

and came into a good-sized area, say<br />

about twenty by twenty feet square,<br />

with high arched ceiling. The stone<br />

columns that held the ro<strong>of</strong> were old;<br />

several stones lay about with Greek<br />

inscriptions, and in the side <strong>of</strong> the<br />

north wall was a stone tomb, allegedly<br />

all that was mortal <strong>of</strong> a Frankish lady,<br />

Anne Boulanger, who was buried there<br />

in the year 1343. It was built up<br />

against the wall, and the sloping cover<br />

is decorated by an ornate Crusader<br />

cross within a circle <strong>of</strong> arabesques.<br />

The last <strong>of</strong> the Crusaders were driven<br />

from Lebanon by the Mamluks by<br />

about 1300, but a few stayed on as private<br />

citizens; at any rate, here she lived<br />

and here she died and was buried in<br />

1343.<br />

I climbed up on the ro<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong> the<br />

church and the view was superb. To<br />

the west and south was the village <strong>of</strong><br />

Maad, to the north and west lay the<br />

blue sea and coastline extending north<br />

to Tripoli, and in the near distance was<br />

the old town <strong>of</strong> Betroon where Anne<br />

was supposed to have come from. It is<br />

a town that was ancient when<br />

Columbus discovered America. To the<br />

east and north one looked over the rising<br />

foothills with numerous villages,<br />

and in the far distance rose the brilliantly<br />

white snow-covered range <strong>of</strong><br />

the mountains on which stand the<br />

Cedars <strong>of</strong> Lebanon. <br />

The Boulangers get around.<br />

Regards to all.<br />

S.A.M.”<br />

This article originally appeared in the<br />

Columbia St. Mary’s Physician Staff<br />

<strong>Newsletter</strong>, December 2004<br />

6


Book Reviews<br />

by Nick Owen, M.D.<br />

Cancer and the Kidney<br />

edited by Eric P. Cohen, Oxford University Press, <strong>2005</strong><br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Leon G. Fine, Royal Free and University<br />

College, London Medical School, London, UK in his<br />

encomium (entitled Forward), sums up Cancer and the<br />

Kidney as describing the totality <strong>of</strong> the ways that the kidney<br />

reacts to cancer anywhere in the body and its treatment<br />

and yet serves as a series <strong>of</strong> monographs suitable<br />

both to practicing physicians and biomedical scientists.<br />

A series <strong>of</strong> well-referenced mountains <strong>of</strong> information<br />

encased in a slim volume; the epitome <strong>of</strong> reference.<br />

Population 485<br />

Michael Perry, Harper-Collins, N.Y., 2002<br />

For those <strong>of</strong> you with ambivalence toward paramedics,<br />

on the one hand positive for comfortgiving,<br />

life-saving missions, on the other for transporting<br />

patients to the wrong hospital or resuscitating<br />

no-code patients, Michael Perry’s little book will<br />

give you a different perspective.<br />

Like physicians, paramedics relate to individual<br />

patients rather than considering themselves as a community<br />

resource and in New Auburn, Wisconsin, (population<br />

485) most patients or their families are personally<br />

known to the paramedics with the resulting<br />

increased intensity <strong>of</strong> emotions over “wins and losses”.<br />

An educational and delightful twist to healthcare<br />

delivery.<br />

The Status Syndrome: How Social Standing<br />

Affects Our Health and Longevity<br />

Michael Marmot, Times Books, New York, 2004<br />

The Status Syndrome: How Social Standing Affects Our<br />

Health and Longevity is an elaborate evaluation <strong>of</strong><br />

the factors which determine quality and length <strong>of</strong> life<br />

which include genetic, birth and life trauma, nurture<br />

(caloric and attentive), education, social cohesion, wealth,<br />

and position in society. How one feels about one’s self<br />

(one’s standing) is critically affected by employment, by<br />

the degree that one is trusted, and by the degree <strong>of</strong> stress<br />

associated with the job (high demand-low control; high<br />

effort-low reward).<br />

Marmot examines the importance <strong>of</strong> these and other<br />

factors in varied populations and demographic experiments.<br />

He shows how the interplay <strong>of</strong> various factors<br />

contribute to the longevity <strong>of</strong> populations and to the<br />

health <strong>of</strong> members <strong>of</strong> each group.<br />

An interesting exploration <strong>of</strong> how “we” got to be who<br />

we are. <br />

7


Officers and Members<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Council for <strong>2005</strong><br />

George Walcott, M.D., President<br />

Ralph Schapira, M.D., President-Elect<br />

James Woods, M.D.,<br />

Immediate Past President<br />

Rajiv Varma, M.D., Secretary<br />

Rita Hanson, M.D., Treasurer<br />

Council<br />

Matthew Lee, M.D.<br />

Donald Beaver, D.O.<br />

Committee Chairs<br />

Bioethics<br />

Art Derse, M.D., J.D.<br />

Finance<br />

Rita Hanson, M.D.<br />

Fund Development<br />

James Stiehl, M.D.<br />

History<br />

Jeffrey Jentzen, M.D.<br />

Raymond C. Zastrow,Jr., M.D.<br />

Membership<br />

Jerome Van Ruiswyk, M.D.<br />

<strong>Newsletter</strong><br />

Nicholas Owen, M.D.<br />

H. David Kerr, M.D.<br />

Program<br />

Seth Foldy, M.D.<br />

Executive Director<br />

Amy L. John<br />

Board <strong>of</strong> Trustees<br />

Physicians<br />

Elaine Drobny, M.D.<br />

Kesavan Kutty, M.D.<br />

John Petersen, M.D.<br />

Peter Sigmann, M.D.<br />

Lay Trustees<br />

Robert Karlman<br />

Carl Knauer<br />

Walt J. Wojcik<br />

Mary Wolverton, J.D.<br />

President’s Comments<br />

Distinguished Achievement Award<br />

Elizabeth Jacobs, M.D. will receive<br />

the <strong>Milwaukee</strong> <strong>Academy</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Medicine</strong>’s <strong>2005</strong> Distinguished<br />

Achievement Award at the October<br />

18 th <strong>Academy</strong> program. The award<br />

is presented annually in recognition<br />

<strong>of</strong> outstanding contributions to the<br />

Each year the <strong>Milwaukee</strong><br />

<strong>Academy</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Medicine</strong> selects a<br />

recipient for our Humanitarian<br />

Award. The Humanitarian Award is<br />

given annually to “an exemplary<br />

individual or group who has significantly<br />

improved the welfare <strong>of</strong> our<br />

community by virtue <strong>of</strong> their<br />

courage, tirelessness, compassion<br />

and vision.” The <strong>Academy</strong> council is<br />

by George Walcott, M.D.<br />

President <strong>2005</strong><br />

The debate over teaching <strong>of</strong> evolution<br />

and teaching <strong>of</strong> creationism<br />

is heating up. School is<br />

opening shortly, medical school.<br />

Medical students and doctors have a<br />

front row seat on evolutionary<br />

dynamics. Those <strong>of</strong> us who have<br />

been in practice for a while have<br />

been witness, could we observe, to<br />

hundreds <strong>of</strong> thousands <strong>of</strong> generations<br />

<strong>of</strong> staphylococcus aureus and<br />

some fewer generations <strong>of</strong> tuberculosis<br />

organisms. Are we seeing creationism<br />

at work in a “hate “ relationship<br />

with the pharmaceutical<br />

industry, infectious disease specialists,<br />

and the doctors who prescribe<br />

antibiotics? At the time <strong>of</strong><br />

Alexander Fleming’s discovery <strong>of</strong><br />

penicillin, virtually all staphyloccocal<br />

organisms were exquisitely sensitive.<br />

Younger resident doctors now<br />

refer to their teaching hospitals as<br />

MERSAcenters, methicillin resistant<br />

staph aureus. That single cell organism<br />

without a nucleus, some RNA,<br />

and a cell wall frustrates the scientists<br />

devising ever more powerful<br />

antibiotics and multi-drug programs.<br />

We’re finding that the tuberculosis<br />

organism in immunocompromised<br />

patients and those with<br />

prior tuberculosis treatment are<br />

more likely to be multi-drug resistant,<br />

evolution in action. The<br />

Darwinians would claim most persuasively<br />

that the fittest organisms<br />

mutate, adjust to their environment,<br />

survive and multiply. Many bacteria<br />

succumb to the antibiotic onslaught<br />

but a few because <strong>of</strong> the hosts’s weak<br />

immunological defenses and perhaps<br />

low antibiotic tissue penetration<br />

endure, spreading through tissue<br />

fluids, respiratory secretions,<br />

and to hospital carriers beyond the<br />

host. While some organisms like the<br />

polio virus are on the brink <strong>of</strong><br />

extinction, others such as avian flu<br />

viruses appear abruptly from an<br />

occult reservoir to take their place in<br />

the infectious challenge to mankind,<br />

creationism in action? <br />

advancement <strong>of</strong> knowledge and<br />

practice <strong>of</strong> medicine by a Wisconsin<br />

physician. Dr. Jacobs is Pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Medicine</strong> and Physiology and Chief,<br />

Division <strong>of</strong> Pulmonary and Critical<br />

Care <strong>Medicine</strong> at the Medical<br />

College <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin.<br />

Humanitarian Award Nominees Needed<br />

seeking letters <strong>of</strong> nomination (by<br />

November 1 st ) for this award which<br />

will be presented at the Annual<br />

Meeting on January 17 th , 2006.<br />

Please contact Amy John in the<br />

<strong>Academy</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice if you would like a<br />

listing <strong>of</strong> past recipients or more<br />

information on the nomination<br />

process.<br />

<br />

To The Membership<br />

We have three requests <strong>of</strong> all<br />

members <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Academy</strong>:<br />

1) Have you heard an outstanding<br />

talk lately at a meeting or course<br />

which ought to be shared with fellow<br />

<strong>Academy</strong> members? If so, please let<br />

the program committee know.<br />

2) Likewise, have you read a great<br />

book? Tell us and we’ll read it and<br />

review it or better yet, write a review<br />

and we’ll publish it.<br />

3) We’re always looking for original<br />

writing whether medical or general;<br />

send anything you are interested in<br />

sharing.<br />

All communications should be<br />

directed to: Amy John at the<br />

<strong>Academy</strong>.<br />

<br />

<br />

Email Reminder<br />

If you have not already done so,<br />

please email your current email<br />

address to the <strong>Academy</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice,<br />

amyjohn@execpc.com, so that you<br />

can be easily contacted for general<br />

correspondence and feedback gathering.<br />

You will not receive program<br />

announcements or the newsletter via<br />

email unless you specifically make<br />

that request. Thank you.<br />

<br />

The editors would be happy<br />

to consider any original<br />

submissions from members<br />

for publication.<br />

<br />

8701 Watertown Plank Road • <strong>Milwaukee</strong>, WI 53226 • 414.456.8249 • fax 414.456.6537 • email milwacademy<strong>of</strong>med@execpc.com • website www.milwacademy<strong>of</strong>medicine.org<br />

8

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!