08.05.2015 Views

VUTEk GS3200 Super-wide Format Printer - IT Enquirer

VUTEk GS3200 Super-wide Format Printer - IT Enquirer

VUTEk GS3200 Super-wide Format Printer - IT Enquirer

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Product Report<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

<strong>Super</strong>-<strong>wide</strong> <strong>Format</strong><br />

<strong>Printer</strong>


Full legal disclaimer and copyright Notices<br />

This Report has three components: this document, the matrix PDF and the diagram PDF. These three components<br />

will be referred to hencewith as “The Report”.<br />

The Report and all of its content are the property of Erik Vlietinck, Ll.D., hereafter “The Author”. The Report and all<br />

materials published therein, including but not limited to text, graphical and photographic images are protected by<br />

copyright and owned by The Author or its licensors. For Information on all <strong>IT</strong> <strong>Enquirer</strong> Content, send an email to<br />

erik@it-enquirer.com.<br />

All material here present is © E. Vlietinck, Ll.D. - 2008 - 2009. All Rights Reserved.<br />

The report was prepared by The Author. The information contained in The Report is given in good faith and has<br />

been derived from sources believed to be reliable and accurate at the time of writing. Neither The Author nor any<br />

agency thereof, nor any of their employees, nor any of their contractors, subcontractors or their employees, makes<br />

any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or<br />

any third party’s use or the results of such use of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents<br />

that its use would not infringe privately owned rights.<br />

Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or<br />

otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by The Author or<br />

any agency thereof or its contractors or subcontractors.<br />

The Author recommends you seek professional advice for your own circumstances before you take any action related<br />

to all topics, technologies, and products covered in The Report.<br />

All corrections and edits, additions and the decision about listing specific vendors and/or systems are in the sole and<br />

absolute discretion of The Author.<br />

Permissions<br />

i<br />

You may not modify the Report or re-publish, re-transmit, or otherwise distribute directly or via links the Report<br />

to any third person. This report has been copy-protected using different technologies and methods, including<br />

password protection, visible and invisible tokens. You must not remove any of these tokens.<br />

All requests for licensing, reprints, linking and other usage of the Report should be addressed to The Author via<br />

e-mail at erik@it-enquirer.com. Read the full copyright information on http://www.it-enquirer.com.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


Contents<br />

Executive Summary<br />

iii<br />

INTRODUCTION The printer 2<br />

FINDINGS/ANALYSIS Flexibility 4<br />

Performance 6<br />

Three Resolution/Smoothing/Curing combinations 7<br />

Resolution 8<br />

Colour Accuracy 8<br />

Creative capabilities / Vertical Markets 9<br />

Environment 10<br />

Conclusion 11<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


Executive Summary<br />

Specialised printing is a growing market. Together with short runs and print-on-demand,<br />

super <strong>wide</strong> format printing has strong appeal to advertisers. <strong>Super</strong> <strong>wide</strong> format technology<br />

has reached the point that it is also attractive to the art reproduction market. Some<br />

vendors in the super <strong>wide</strong> format printer market focus on high speed and offer low to<br />

decent quality.<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> has always claimed it focuses on quality first, and only then on high performance.<br />

In the report that follows we had the opportunity to test a <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> for a<br />

day.<br />

We could see the machine produce photo/art quality on any type of medium. We measured<br />

the machine’s throughput speed and were impressed to find that it performs closely<br />

to what <strong>VUTEk</strong> claims in its marketing collateral.<br />

We found the <strong>GS3200</strong> to be equipped for efficiency — strictly speaking, one operator<br />

can control this printer, although we would like to think an extra hand will be welcome<br />

when large and heavy rolls of media must be handled — and a minimal need for technical<br />

support.<br />

Finally — and judging from the data sheets that were made available to us — <strong>VUTEk</strong><br />

goes to great lengths to ensure the environmental burden of printing with UV curable<br />

inks is kept at an absolute minimum.<br />

iii<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


<strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

Introduction


1<br />

With the iPad, iPhone, Kindle and other<br />

digital reading devices, some analysts<br />

seem to believe the entire printing market<br />

is as good as extinct. Publishers complain<br />

about not finding advertisers and therefore<br />

losing income.<br />

Analysts seem to think advertisers have<br />

abandoned printed advertisements altogether,<br />

and many of them are investing all of<br />

their money into videoclips, animation and<br />

Flash content. Print — for the umpteenth<br />

time in recent history — has been declared<br />

dead.<br />

All of this couldn’t be further from the<br />

truth. Advertisers are still printing, but they<br />

no longer focus exclusively on printed magazines<br />

and newspapers as the ultimate outlets<br />

for high-quality, attention-grabbing ads.<br />

Instead, advertisers are using large format<br />

ads to help shape our environment visually.<br />

Besides advertisers, print will always appeal<br />

to artists because the combination of media,<br />

colour, and print medium (ink, paint...) allows<br />

them to create effects that are impossible<br />

with digital media. Art photographers,<br />

graphic designers, fashion photographers,<br />

package designers of fashion products — all<br />

of them prefer high-quality printed displays<br />

with high enough resolution so people can<br />

see detail without having to squint.<br />

Currently only printed media can deliver<br />

such high resolutions together with the necessary<br />

colour accuracy to guarantee a company’s<br />

logo will be presented the way it<br />

should.<br />

For prints with dramatic impact, such as<br />

large banners, displays, see-through images,<br />

etc., screen printing used to be the only option.<br />

Screen printing is very labour-intensive<br />

and often environmentally aggressive, and<br />

there is a digital alternative: inkjet based<br />

printing technologies.<br />

Inkjet printing technology, and super <strong>wide</strong><br />

format inkjet printers to be more specific<br />

have come to a point where they can replace<br />

screen printing technology in 99% of<br />

the cases. <strong>Super</strong> <strong>wide</strong> format printing takes<br />

about 20% of the labour involved with<br />

screen printing and can be environment<br />

friendly.<br />

<strong>Super</strong> <strong>wide</strong> format printers can also print<br />

to larger media, and with the continuous<br />

evolution of inkjet technology, output resolution<br />

and colour quality becomes better<br />

every year.<br />

When we were given the opportunity to<br />

thoroughly test a <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> super<br />

<strong>wide</strong> format printer, we paid particular attention<br />

to output quality and performance.<br />

These are the features EFI claims to focus<br />

on — in that order.<br />

Hence, our testing revolved around the following<br />

issues:<br />

Flexibility. We wanted to know if the<br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> is capable of printing on multiple<br />

media from third party suppliers. We also<br />

focused on the ways we could lay down<br />

the ink on the media.<br />

Different usage patterns. We examined<br />

the markets in which the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

can be used.<br />

Quality of output. We focused on colour<br />

accuracy and resolution.<br />

Speed. How fast printed media leaves the<br />

printer was our next subject of analysis.<br />

Environment. We analysed the environment<br />

friendliness of this printer.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


2<br />

The printer<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is a 3.2 meter <strong>wide</strong><br />

combination flatbed/roll (also called “hybrid”<br />

by some) UV printer with a moving<br />

transport belt that gives the printer a maximum<br />

speed of 223 square meters per hour.<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Ink composition<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Waste control<br />

These characteristics also influence the operating<br />

costs, keeping those to a minimum,<br />

and therefore ensuring a shorter pay-back<br />

time of the investment in a <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong>.<br />

Unique characteristics of the <strong>VUTEk</strong><br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> are its photo quality resolution at<br />

1000 dpi, its selectable 12pl or 24pl ink<br />

drop sizes, and its multiple zero points.<br />

Further features that characterise the<br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> are its switching capability between<br />

8 colour and 4 colour printing — both with<br />

the addition of two white ink print channels,<br />

with each channel representing two<br />

heads.<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> print head features two<br />

UV lamps that can be opened in various<br />

configurations, giving the operator multiple<br />

ways to finish a print job and obtain subtle<br />

and different effects. The intensity of the<br />

lamps can be set to 5 pre-defined levels or<br />

a custom mode for critical media.<br />

Multiple vacuum zones make media — especially<br />

roll media — less susceptible to<br />

wrinkling, giving a better ‘tack’ and an easier<br />

positioning than with super <strong>wide</strong> format<br />

printers lacking this feature.<br />

Finally, the printer has been built with an<br />

eye for easy handling of all parts. A good<br />

example of this principle is the side-door<br />

that allows operators to self-service the<br />

print head, e.g. the exchange of a defect<br />

UV-lamp for a new one.<br />

Finally, the printer has been designed to be<br />

as environmental friendly as possible. Features<br />

that show care for the environment<br />

include:<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Power requirements<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


<strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

Analysis & Findings


4<br />

Most super <strong>wide</strong> format printers will<br />

print on a large range of media. The<br />

capability to print on many different media<br />

from many different suppliers improves a<br />

<strong>wide</strong> format printer’s ROI.<br />

Flexibility<br />

During our tests, we saw the <strong>VUTEk</strong><br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> being used for printing on materials<br />

such as:<br />

It allows the printer to be used in many different<br />

vertical markets without being locked<br />

in by the printer manufacturer when it<br />

comes to media. There is always a lock-in<br />

on the level of ink, but this is understandable<br />

as a manufacturer can only guarantee<br />

quality results when using the standard<br />

inks.<br />

However, in super <strong>wide</strong> format printing a<br />

lock-in at the level of ink and media makes<br />

a printer less flexible<br />

and more expensive (in<br />

operating cost terms;<br />

manufacturer branded<br />

media is usually sold<br />

at a premium) than it<br />

should be.<br />

Media flexibility is of<br />

crucial importance as<br />

users will need to exploit<br />

the printer for as<br />

many vertical markets<br />

as possible. This benefits<br />

the printer’s TCO<br />

(Total Cost of Ownership)<br />

and rapid payback<br />

of the investment.<br />

It also benefits TCO<br />

because — in cases<br />

where media quality<br />

is less important — it<br />

enables users to shop<br />

around for the best price/quality ratio materials<br />

available.<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Construction materials such as concrete<br />

and stone tiles<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Glass plates and film<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Plastics, Polypropylene, Vinyl, and<br />

other synthetic rigid and roll-based<br />

materials<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Wood, metal, mesh<br />

The range of materials that can be used with a super<br />

<strong>wide</strong> format printer partly depends on drying time and<br />

the curing system used.<br />

A water based ink such as Latex will use a lot of energy<br />

(heat) to create the necessary bonding between<br />

the inks and the media. A UV curable ink does not need<br />

heat but UV light to make the ink polymerize. This<br />

process is much faster and more energy efficient..<br />

In order to keep curing times within efficiency ranges,<br />

the applied heat is higher with water-soluble inks.<br />

Many materials will deform or melt at high temperatures<br />

even if they are only exposed for a couple of seconds.<br />

Hence the need for either drastically reducing the<br />

number of materials a water based inkjet printer can<br />

use or the introduction of media that has been made to<br />

the printer’s specifications.<br />

The latter are usually not to be readily found with materials<br />

suppliers. Vendors will regard these branded<br />

materials as “consumables” for which they can charge<br />

extra.<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Fabrics, including curtain, materials,<br />

losely woven fabrics, etc. (Open media<br />

needs backing aka.<br />

“liner” to avoid printing<br />

on the belt).<br />

All of the materials<br />

we tested were supplied<br />

by third party<br />

suppliers —none were<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> branded or<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> sold. Given<br />

the fact that ‘media’ in<br />

a super <strong>wide</strong> format<br />

printing environment<br />

can mean anything, the<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> therefore<br />

doesn’t lock in the<br />

user at all.<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

uses a temperature<br />

point at which practically<br />

all materials are<br />

unaffected.<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> proved to be a flexible<br />

device in more ways than just media independence.<br />

For example, the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

can be equipped with multiple zero points.<br />

This requires the operator to install up to<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


5<br />

four additional “break points” at the front<br />

end of the printer’s feed mechanism, after<br />

which the <strong>GS3200</strong> will treat these points<br />

as size limits to the flat media fed into the<br />

printer. This allows the operator to feed the<br />

printer with up to five separate sheets of<br />

the same media, which will all be printed<br />

simultaneously.(*)<br />

The <strong>GS3200</strong> can also handle two rolls<br />

of media simultaneously, using two zero<br />

points. In all of these use cases, the operator<br />

can choose to print the same image/layout/design<br />

on all plates/rolls, or a different<br />

layout on each plate/roll.<br />

Another example of the flexibility of the<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is its vacuum system,<br />

which is divided into zones. Most printers<br />

have one vacuum zone stretching the entire<br />

width of the device. The <strong>GS3200</strong> has<br />

three vacuum zones. When media does not<br />

stretch along the entire printer width, only<br />

one or two vacuum zones will kick in. This<br />

decreases power draw and enhances the<br />

operation of the media as a large enough<br />

vacuum can be created, even when the entire<br />

width of the printer is not in use.<br />

Finally, the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is capable of<br />

printing in high quality, 8 colour mode, but<br />

also in lower quality 4 colour mode. Whereas<br />

some competing products force the operator<br />

to physically change the ink supply to<br />

the print heads in order to only use 4 colours,<br />

the <strong>GS3200</strong> provides software switchable<br />

4/8 colour printing.<br />

In 8 colour mode the <strong>GS3200</strong> prints using<br />

light cyan, light magenta, light yellow and<br />

grey. The heads that carry these light inks<br />

are equipped with two input channels and<br />

The print job is RIPped in EFI Fiery XF, then sent to the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong>’s Control panel,<br />

which has its own workflow and job settings. When the operator decides the job can<br />

be sent to the printer, he loads the media, hits the Print button and the job starts printing.<br />

(*): Actually, one can insert as many zero points as one wants. Theoretically, one could feed the<br />

printer with A4 sheets — placing as many on the vacuum table as will fit.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


6<br />

can from the operator panel be switched<br />

over to dark inks. This will double the<br />

available nozzles for the dark colours and<br />

will therefore have following benefits:<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Double the speed of the printer<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Low waste when switching from 4 to<br />

8 colours or the other way around<br />

ÃÃ<br />

A quicker return to printing.<br />

exclude media handling before the actual<br />

print run starts.<br />

For our tests, we used two different parameters.<br />

First is handling a job: positioning a<br />

roll of media of 3.2 meters <strong>wide</strong> by an operator<br />

and an assistant. Secondly, we measured<br />

the time it took to switch from roll to<br />

plate. Finally, we also measured the time it<br />

took for an actual print run to finish.<br />

Flexibility in terms of control<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is controlled by a<br />

machine control panel, but the actual<br />

printing job is sent to the printer through<br />

an EFI Fiery XF RIP controller.<br />

The advantage of this workflow is that<br />

the Fiery RIP acts as<br />

a colour capabilities<br />

controller as much<br />

as a (Postscript) print<br />

job controller. The<br />

Fiery RIP will for<br />

example detect errors<br />

in the print file<br />

before it ends up at<br />

the printer’s control<br />

panel. These errors<br />

can therefore be corrected<br />

before the job<br />

gets queued, leaving<br />

the operator with a<br />

‘clean list’ of jobs that are guaranteed to<br />

print correctly.<br />

Performance<br />

Speed on super <strong>wide</strong> format printers is<br />

expressed in square meters per hour, but<br />

almost no vendor will explain how they<br />

measure. For example, tests can include or<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> uses a proprietary technique,<br />

called ‘smoothing’ by the EFI/<strong>VUTEk</strong> people. This is<br />

a software controlled technique of firing ink droplets.<br />

Without smoothing reflective banding can occur as a<br />

result of the print head firing droplets from left to right,<br />

and from right to left.<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> has solved this problem by developing an algorithm<br />

that mixes some of the droplets from the leftto-right<br />

firing sequence with the right-to-left sequence.<br />

This effectively and efficiently produces smooth transitions.<br />

We used two different speed setups, both<br />

with 8 colours: one with 600 dpi and the<br />

other with 1000 dpi.<br />

At 1000 dpi and heavy smoothing applied<br />

(highest possible quality, identical to photo<br />

print), we witnessed the <strong>GS3200</strong> providing<br />

a sustained throughput speed of 30 square<br />

meters per hour on a solid area of blue,<br />

including changing<br />

the media in-between<br />

printing jobs, which<br />

took 45 seconds to be<br />

exact. The test was<br />

performed using one<br />

3.2 meter roll printing<br />

a landscape fill of 180<br />

cm x 140 cm.<br />

At 600 dpi and light<br />

smoothing, performance<br />

rose to 84 square<br />

meters/hour.<br />

In real-world circumstances,<br />

these figures are quite high. Although<br />

some manufacturers will advertise<br />

much higher speeds, the top speed at<br />

which a super <strong>wide</strong> format printer is capable<br />

of producing usable quality results is<br />

sometimes 50% lower than the brochure<br />

text promises.<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> isn’t a speed demon,<br />

but the quality level at which this printer<br />

outputs a job is far higher than what one<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


7<br />

would expect from a super <strong>wide</strong> format<br />

printer of which most prints will be viewed<br />

from a distance. We therefore wouldn’t hesitate<br />

to call this printer capable of art photo<br />

printing.<br />

We did not test the <strong>GS3200</strong> with 4 colours<br />

and at highest throughput speed — in this<br />

lower quality mode the <strong>GS3200</strong> should be<br />

capable of speeds in excess of 200 square<br />

meters or 44 rigid media plates per hour.<br />

Changeover to print on flexible from rigid<br />

substrates happened in less than a minute<br />

(45 seconds to be exact).<br />

Furthermore, the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is capable<br />

of printing directly to substrate, eliminating<br />

Three Resolution/Smoothing/Curing combinations<br />

The leftmost image shows the best obtainable quality with the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong>. This is<br />

pure photo quality. By playing with shutter, smoothing, curing and resolution, different<br />

patterns of usage emerge: from banners hanging from buildings to accurate reproduction<br />

of art that may be viewed from close-up.<br />

Resolution: 1000 dpi<br />

Smoothing: Heavy<br />

Curing: Low<br />

Resolution: 600 dpi<br />

Smoothing: Light<br />

Curing: Medium<br />

Resolution: 600 dpi<br />

Smoothing: Light<br />

Curing: Low<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


8<br />

the need for mounting and lamination of<br />

flexible materials for rigid applications.<br />

Print quality can be expressed in different<br />

parameters. Three of them define<br />

the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong>:<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Resolution<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Colour accuracy<br />

ÃÃ<br />

Creative capabilities.<br />

To test resolution and colour accuracy, we<br />

used two methods: a visual assessment of<br />

the quality of a photo shot and the evaluation<br />

of an Altona chart with and without<br />

ICC profile loaded.<br />

To further test the printer’s minimal colour<br />

gamut, we measured its standard ICC colour<br />

profile. Creative possibilities were tested<br />

with the help of an experienced operator<br />

who has a degree in graphic design and<br />

who has worked in the graphical/printing<br />

industry.<br />

Resolution is independent of the colour<br />

mode the printer is in, i.e. in 4-colour mode<br />

(actually, 5-colour mode, white included,<br />

which is why <strong>VUTEk</strong> calls this “Fast-5”) the<br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> can still print at 1000 dpi or 600<br />

dpi.<br />

The highest resolution prints that we saw<br />

coming out of the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> were<br />

photo quality resolution prints with smooth<br />

gradients and skin tones. We feel the resolution<br />

and colour capabilities of the <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

are very close to making this printer fit for<br />

art reproduction.<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> prints on any medium<br />

and on some the ink must be dried quickly<br />

in order to create a good bonding between<br />

ink and medium. A test photo of a Chinese<br />

gate was printed in 1000 and 600 dpi<br />

modes. Even at the highest possible speed<br />

— when the operator can make the printer<br />

fire solid streaks of the image with no<br />

feathering in-between onto the medium —<br />

we never saw any banding occur at all.<br />

Resolution<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> can handle 1000 dpi<br />

output by setting the ink droplet size to<br />

12pL — a setting which can be changed at<br />

the control panel in software. At 12pL/1000<br />

dpi, the <strong>GS3200</strong> is capable of printing at a<br />

4-point character size.<br />

The printer will use the smallest droplet to<br />

print with a vertical resolution of 1000 dpi<br />

and a horizontal resolution of 720dpi. The<br />

bigger droplet will be used with a vertical<br />

resolution of 600 dpi and a horizontal resolution<br />

of 360 dpi.<br />

The horizontal resolution is defined by the<br />

linear encoder and the vertical resolution is<br />

defined by the jetpack.<br />

Colour Accuracy<br />

To visually evaluate the <strong>GS3200</strong>’s colour accuracy,<br />

we printed an Altona 1.2a chart.<br />

Without its standard ICC colour profile loaded,<br />

the Altona chart showed discernable<br />

colour banding on he gradient discs, as well<br />

as a clearly visible colour shift in the skin<br />

tones and the yellow to red colour range.<br />

However, printed with the default ICC colour<br />

profile turned on, the <strong>GS3200</strong> printed<br />

the Altona chart with all colour shifts corrected.<br />

Gradient banding had gone and skin<br />

tones were beautifully rendered, with good<br />

detail in skin tone gradients.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


9<br />

Especially the red-on-green patches of the<br />

chart showed considerable improvement<br />

when the ICC profile was loaded.<br />

The colour gamut of the <strong>GS3200</strong>’s default<br />

profile is fairly large. It is about 50% of the<br />

AdobeRGB gamut and about 90% of a professional<br />

inkjet photo printer. We expect the<br />

default profile to have been created with a<br />

rather conservative approach, so we expect<br />

a colour management expert to be capable<br />

of squeezing a larger gamut out of the<br />

<strong>GS3200</strong> without giving in on accuracy or<br />

quality.<br />

A large colour gamut is interesting because<br />

it makes the printer more attractive to a<br />

larger number of vertical markets. Especially<br />

the profile’s skewness towards the yellow<br />

and red areas make the <strong>GS3200</strong> exceptionally<br />

well suited for printing gradients and<br />

portraits such as those used in fashion advertisements.<br />

We also tested the <strong>GS3200</strong>’s Pantone colour<br />

accuracy, and the printer passed the test<br />

with flying colours.<br />

Creative capabilities / Vertical<br />

Markets<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> has three-layering capabilities<br />

which enables white to be printed<br />

in six variations (overprint, underprint, spot,<br />

underspot, fill and overspot). All three layers<br />

can be printed in a single pass.<br />

This allows the <strong>GS3200</strong>’s white ink to be<br />

used in creative ways, e.g.:<br />

ÃÃ<br />

as a “primer” on coloured materials<br />

ÃÃ<br />

to provide depth to a colour image<br />

ÃÃ<br />

to play with see-through characteristics<br />

on transparent or translucent materials.<br />

The <strong>GS3200</strong> operator has more creative<br />

capabilities than just 8 colour or 4 colour<br />

printing with or without whites.<br />

He/she can also combine images at the<br />

control panel to be printed onto one medium.<br />

Furthermore, the UV-lamps can be<br />

operated on individually. By opening them<br />

The white area represents the <strong>GS3200</strong>. The red area in the image on the left shows a medium-format<br />

professional photo printer’s gamut. The blue area in both images shows the AdobeRGB colour space.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


10<br />

at different times while printing, the lamps<br />

can be used to influence Tonal Value Increase<br />

(dot gain), so the image can be<br />

made to appear lighter.<br />

logo banners, art exhibition promotional<br />

banners, large photograph prints, fashion<br />

photographs, and many more.<br />

The <strong>GS3200</strong> Control Panel, where the operator can be creative in view of the desired results.<br />

“Playing” with the UV lamps can also influence<br />

the ink’s brilliance.<br />

Combined with the large range of materials<br />

the <strong>GS3200</strong> can print on, the printer can be<br />

used for a great many purposes, from traditional<br />

advertisement board printing over<br />

printing a logo on a short-fibre carpet, to<br />

see-through or sandwich prints attached to<br />

windows, etc.<br />

We saw the <strong>GS3200</strong> used for jewelry, perfume<br />

ads, one-colour filled areas, Pantone<br />

Environment<br />

The <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong> is relatively environment<br />

friendly in that it is conservative with<br />

respect to power and ink consumption.<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> also shows care for ink composition<br />

and waste management.<br />

The <strong>GS3200</strong>’s power consumption can be<br />

kept to an absolute minimum by using the<br />

printer’s capabilities, e.g. the capability to<br />

set multiple zero points, to load multiple<br />

rolls of the same or different media.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.


11<br />

An efficient use of the <strong>GS3200</strong> can also<br />

bring costs down.<br />

In terms of waste management, the <strong>GS3200</strong><br />

has built-in capture capabilities for cleaning<br />

cycle ink. To keep ink waste at a minimum,<br />

the operator should plan printing jobs as<br />

much as possible, and avoid too many<br />

switches between 4 colour and 8 colour<br />

mode.<br />

<strong>VUTEk</strong> made sure the ink composition<br />

is among the least polluting and the least<br />

health risky. Contrary to common belief,<br />

water based inks such as Latex inks are not<br />

better for the environment or less dangerous<br />

than traditional UV curable inks.<br />

In fact, in the technical data sheets of manufacturers<br />

that use Latex inks, the user will<br />

read the level of solvents to be near 20%.<br />

We also did not expect the operator of such<br />

a printer being capable of adding a creative<br />

touch to the output, which essentially<br />

means there will be differences between<br />

the output of one <strong>GS3200</strong> operated by a<br />

skilled user and one operated by someone<br />

who only adheres to the user guide.<br />

Even without experience and talent, however,<br />

the <strong>GS3200</strong> can output great looking<br />

prints no matter who is at the printer console.<br />

Business wise, the <strong>GS3200</strong> has many characteristics<br />

and parameters that allow for a<br />

quick pay back on investment and a nice<br />

ROI. The printer has plenty of features that<br />

allow it to operate at very low TCO as well.<br />

In contrast, <strong>VUTEk</strong>’s UV curable inks contain<br />

solvent levels of below 3%. As it was<br />

correctly stated in an article in Print Action<br />

dating from April 2010 by Danny Ionescu:<br />

“There are a lot of questions about solvent<br />

and eco-solvent, but, no matter how<br />

you classify it, solvent is solvent — period.<br />

There are VOCs being emitted from ecosolvent<br />

technology.”<br />

All the more reason then not to fall for the<br />

marketing talk of some companies that<br />

claim their water based inks do not contain<br />

solvents.<br />

Conclusion<br />

When we set out to test the <strong>VUTEk</strong> <strong>GS3200</strong>,<br />

we did not expect a super <strong>wide</strong> format<br />

printer to be capable of printing high resolution<br />

images that can successfully compete<br />

with dedicated photo printers targeted at<br />

the professional photographers’ market.<br />

© <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>Enquirer</strong> Reports – Erik Vlietinck 2010-2011 - All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information<br />

contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. E. Vlietinck disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although E. Vlietinck’s<br />

research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, he does not provide legal advice or services and his research should not be construed or used as such. E. Vlietinck<br />

shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.<br />

For information contact: info@it-enquirer.com.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!