Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...
Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...
Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Spiritual Sustenance: The History, Ritual <strong>and</strong> Significance<br />
of the Bulol Figures of the Philippine Ifugao People<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> 1 , Jennifer Hughes 2<br />
1<br />
Department of Media <strong>and</strong> Cultural Studies, 2 Department of Religious Studies<br />
University of California, Riverside<br />
A B S T R A C T<br />
This paper examines the ritual uses <strong>and</strong> history of the bulol rice god figures of the Ifugao<br />
people in northern Luzon, Philippines. Anthropological <strong>and</strong> ethnographic studies of the<br />
Ifugao stress the traditional cultural <strong>and</strong> economic gravity of rice as sustenance but<br />
neglect to explicitly acknowledge how external, non-indigenous forces impact the<br />
religious significance of rice – particularly the use of bulol figures in agricultural religious<br />
rituals. By examining the colonial history of <strong>and</strong> recent economics <strong>and</strong> tourism in the<br />
Ifugao province, as described in anthropological, historical <strong>and</strong> conservationist sources,<br />
I clarify how foreign cultures <strong>and</strong> religions influence those of the Ifugao. I argue that the<br />
increasing prevalence of Christianity <strong>and</strong> contemporary economic pressures have driven<br />
a decrease in the religious potency of the bulol figures by allowing the tourism market to<br />
prioritize the figures’ commercial value as cultural curios rather than their religious value<br />
as representations of an agriculturally efficacious deity.<br />
F A C U L T Y<br />
M E N T O R<br />
Jennifer Hughes<br />
Department of Religious Studies<br />
The UCR CHASS Connect program gives our incoming first year students<br />
a liberal arts college experience within a large, public university setting.<br />
Here they learn not only broad interdisciplinary content <strong>and</strong> methods but<br />
also garner skills to succeed throughout their undergraduate career.<br />
Freshman <strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> enrolled in the CHASS first year sequence “Manifestations<br />
of Spirituality.” Her major project for my class on religious images (Winter 09) represented<br />
original research on the Philippine Ifugao images called bulol. Ms. <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
adopted key analytical categories <strong>and</strong> questions from course lecture <strong>and</strong> reading <strong>and</strong><br />
applied these to formulate a religious studies interpretation of the figures. Already an<br />
exceptional writer <strong>and</strong> careful thinker, she consistently sought to test <strong>and</strong> explore her<br />
ideas <strong>and</strong> theses with me over the course of the quarter. The result is this impressive<br />
piece on the changing significance of these traditional objects of material religion from<br />
a student only just beginning her undergraduate studies.<br />
A U T H O R<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
Film <strong>and</strong> Visual Culture<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> is a first year<br />
student with a double major in<br />
Anthropology <strong>and</strong> Film <strong>and</strong> Visual<br />
Culture. Her main areas of research<br />
interest include twentieth-century<br />
<strong>and</strong> contemporary visual media,<br />
visual anthropology/ethnography,<br />
journalistic documentation, religion<br />
in media <strong>and</strong> popular culture <strong>and</strong><br />
popular culture trends. In particular,<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> is interested photographic<br />
representation <strong>and</strong> propag<strong>and</strong>a of<br />
social conflict/revolutions as well as<br />
the material culture of religion. She<br />
hopes to further pursue her interests<br />
in graduate school. She also<br />
expresses great gratitude to her<br />
faculty mentor for her encouragement,<br />
support, patience <strong>and</strong><br />
guidance.<br />
U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />
57
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
Designated a World Heritage Site by the United<br />
Nations Educational, Scientific <strong>and</strong> Cultural Organization<br />
(UNESCO) in 1995, the rice terraces in the<br />
Philippines have also been unofficially dubbed the<br />
Eighth Wonder of the World. 1 Carved into the steep<br />
faces of the Cordillera Mountains in northern Luzon,<br />
Philippines, the rice terraces exhibit agricultural<br />
ingenuity unaided by the use of modern technology.<br />
Also constructed into these highl<strong>and</strong> terraces, however,<br />
is the identity of the Ifugao – a people rich with<br />
indigenous <strong>and</strong> colonial history, an elaborately<br />
ritualized religion <strong>and</strong> a way of life trademarked by the<br />
ancestral tradition of rice cultivation. Evidenced by a<br />
deeply rooted spiritual <strong>and</strong> physical connection to the<br />
earth, the religious ritual aspects of the Ifugao culture<br />
are as complex <strong>and</strong> diverse as the terraces are<br />
numerous. The bulol images have figured prominently<br />
in this religious <strong>and</strong> agricultural l<strong>and</strong>scape; the carved,<br />
wooden statues representing the rice deity Bulol have<br />
acted as domestic <strong>and</strong> shamanic ritual objects essential<br />
to Ifugao collective religion for at least several<br />
centuries. 2 However, the growing prevalence of Christianity<br />
<strong>and</strong> contemporary economic pressures have<br />
beckoned the Ifugao away from their maintenance of<br />
the rice terraces <strong>and</strong> belief in the power of the bulol<br />
figures. In 2001 – just six years following its UNESCO<br />
designation as a World Heritage Site – the rice terraces<br />
in the Ifugao province have been placed on the<br />
UNESCO List of World Heritage in Danger. 3 Subsequently,<br />
the bulol rice god figures face an equal endangerment<br />
as their religious <strong>and</strong> cultural significance<br />
deteriorates.<br />
In this paper, I argue that while the bulol figures<br />
maintain some of their historical significance through<br />
the ongoing practice of nearly twenty distinct rice<br />
rituals, the religious significance of the bulol figures to<br />
the Ifugao ultimately continues to erode as participation<br />
in these (now erratic <strong>and</strong> “optional”) rituals no<br />
longer possesses the agricultural urgency it once held<br />
<strong>and</strong> as the figures themselves acquire a new commercial<br />
value in the tourism market driven by contemporary<br />
economic pressures. This phenomenon was first<br />
suggested to me in Fruto Corre’s Mountains of Water:<br />
The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of the Ifugao (1998), an<br />
ethnographic film briefly discussing the bulol figures as<br />
part of a general study of the cultural deterioration of<br />
Ifugao rice rituals. This paper provides more a detailed<br />
examination than Corre’s film by taking the figures<br />
themselves <strong>and</strong> the rituals in which they are involved<br />
as the central focus. I have therefore accumulated<br />
disparate sources to assemble an underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the<br />
changing religious <strong>and</strong> ritual significance of the bulol<br />
figures in Ifugao culture. My investigation revealed that<br />
the bulol figures have been commonly discussed as part<br />
of ethnographic or cultural conservationist studies but<br />
are infrequently studied in their own right <strong>and</strong> even<br />
more rarely analyzed within a specifically religious or<br />
devotional framework. Bringing together early <strong>and</strong><br />
mid-twentieth century ethnographic works on the<br />
Ifugao, recent scholarly literature on the spiritual significance<br />
of rice in Asia <strong>and</strong> ecological writings on cultural<br />
<strong>and</strong> environmental erosion among the Ifugao, my<br />
additional research confirms Corre’s hypothesis of<br />
cultural degradation but highlights the issue of religious<br />
belief <strong>and</strong> practice with respect to the bulol figures. I<br />
will first review the mythology <strong>and</strong> physical qualities<br />
of the bulol figures, discuss their use in rice rituals,<br />
examine the general impact of Spanish <strong>and</strong> American<br />
influence on Ifugao religion <strong>and</strong> finally, explore the<br />
impact of economics <strong>and</strong> tourism on the bulol figures’<br />
religious significance.<br />
The Imagery <strong>and</strong> Mythology of the Bulol<br />
Ifugao mythology explains the origin <strong>and</strong> ubiquity of<br />
the figures in Ifugao culture. The origin myth of the<br />
bulol figures involves the Ifugao deity Humidhid. 4 As<br />
Humidhid walked upon the earth, he heard the loud<br />
moans of a large narra tree <strong>and</strong> cut the tree down. In an<br />
attempt to assuage the tree, Humidhid asked if it<br />
desired to be carved in to a human figure; at this<br />
suggestion, the tree fell silent. Humidhid carved four<br />
human figures from the tree <strong>and</strong> placed the figures into<br />
a river to flow to the Downstream Region <strong>and</strong><br />
multiply. 5 These were the first bulol. Traditionally, the<br />
figures are typically involved in annual rice rituals<br />
invoking the rice deity, Bulol, but they are also placed<br />
inside household granaries in the belief that their<br />
presence will multiply harvested rice. 6 The abundant<br />
58 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
presence of these figures among the Ifugao is thus<br />
accounted for in their religious mythology <strong>and</strong> the care,<br />
maintenance, <strong>and</strong> ritual celebration of the bulol were<br />
traditionally understood to be essential for the sustenance<br />
<strong>and</strong> survival of the Ifugao themselves.<br />
In contrast to the progressive change in the figures’<br />
significance, the physical characteristics of the bulol<br />
figures have remained largely consistent. Bulol figures<br />
may only be carved from narra tree wood obtained<br />
from the Downstream Region. 7 Ranging from 20 to 60<br />
centimeters in height, the figures are typically carved in<br />
pairs – one each in male <strong>and</strong> female human likeness.<br />
The carvings commonly depict the nude human figure<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ing with arms crossed over the chest or sitting<br />
with arms hugging bent knees. While clearly anthropomorphic<br />
in nature, some bulol exhibit basic human<br />
features (such as a head, arms <strong>and</strong> legs) but more<br />
specific anatomical characteristics (such as facial<br />
features, fingers <strong>and</strong> toes) can be distinguished in other<br />
figures. The wooden figures will gradually acquire a<br />
smooth surface <strong>and</strong> black color akin to rich loam –<br />
which is believed to represent a relationship between<br />
rice <strong>and</strong> human fertility – as rice cakes <strong>and</strong> blood from<br />
sacrificed animals are rubbed on the figures to appease<br />
Bulol. 8 The figures undergo a six-week long series of<br />
rites performed by shamans in order to activate the<br />
figures for use in rice rituals. 9<br />
Today, the bulol figures retain their ubiquity in Ifugao<br />
culture; largely owning to their recently attained<br />
commercial value as souvenirs. At the same time, the<br />
ritual celebrations that reinforced the religious potency<br />
of the bulol figures have lost a sense of agricultural<br />
urgency (to ensure bountiful harvest <strong>and</strong> therefore<br />
physical sustenance) as Christianity has become the<br />
most prevalent religion.<br />
Ritual Uses of the Bulol<br />
The rice rituals performed by the Ifugao are numerous<br />
<strong>and</strong> elaborate: there are at least seventeen rice rituals<br />
throughout eleven of the twelve months (October to<br />
August) of the Gregorian calendar. 10 However, these<br />
rituals now suffer from infrequent performance as the<br />
shamanic ritual infrastructure weakens to the point of<br />
potential obsolescence. I will discuss particular rituals<br />
U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />
– as described by Barton (1946), Hamilton (2003) <strong>and</strong><br />
Nozawa (2008) – such as the first <strong>and</strong> last rituals of the<br />
rice cycle <strong>and</strong> rituals directly invoking Bulol <strong>and</strong>/or the<br />
granary idols.<br />
In October, shamans perform the first ritual, Lukat, <strong>and</strong><br />
ask deities to resist consuming the rice crop <strong>and</strong> permit<br />
the women to repair <strong>and</strong> weed fields so fresh water will<br />
flood the terraces. 11 Kulpi is performed after rice is<br />
transplanted from December to January <strong>and</strong> shamans<br />
request that the bulol figures repel pests <strong>and</strong> cause rice<br />
stalks to sprout. 12 In April or May, the Ifugao perform<br />
Paad <strong>and</strong> ask Bulol to prevent rice from “dying in<br />
sympathy” with pulled weeds so rice wine can be<br />
produced for future rituals. 13 On the day of the harvest<br />
in May or June, the four- to seven-hour long ritual<br />
Ingngilin is executed by every field owner, who must<br />
implore Bulol to spare people from illness, debt <strong>and</strong> evil<br />
spirits <strong>and</strong> foster the growth of rice, children, <strong>and</strong> sacrificial<br />
animals. 14 The final ritual, Kahiw occurs during<br />
August <strong>and</strong> households are ceremoniously swept clean<br />
to mark the end of the rice agriculture period <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Ifugao calendar. 15<br />
Although physical use of the bulol rice god figures is<br />
primarily confined to rituals of rice cultivation stages,<br />
the far-reaching significance of the bulol figures is seen<br />
in ritual charges invoking the rice deity, Bulol. Shamans<br />
request that Bulol safeguard fields <strong>and</strong> encourage crop<br />
growth, yet shamans also implore Bulol for the growth<br />
<strong>and</strong> health of the Ifugao people in Ingngilin, one of<br />
lengthiest <strong>and</strong> most intricately involving rituals. The<br />
bulol figures act as physical manifestations representative<br />
of an intangible, supernatural being who not only<br />
oversees the protection <strong>and</strong> growth of the annual single<br />
rice crop, but the well-being of the people who cultivate<br />
the rice for physical sustenance. The extensive spiritual<br />
<strong>and</strong> economic involvement resulting from the acutely<br />
intertwined Ifugao culture <strong>and</strong> religion has compelled<br />
an increasing number of Ifugao to pursue alternative,<br />
less dem<strong>and</strong>ing religious <strong>and</strong> cultural paths.<br />
The Impact of Spanish <strong>and</strong> American Presence<br />
in the Ifugao Province<br />
The eroding impact of foreigners on the significance of<br />
the bulol figures in religious practice began during the<br />
59
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
colonial period with Spanish arrival in the Ifugao<br />
province during the 1750s. However, Spanish attempts<br />
to comm<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> catechize the Ifugao during the next<br />
century <strong>and</strong> a half are generally considered unsuccessful,<br />
“never more than a tenuous military occupation<br />
of the highl<strong>and</strong>s by lowl<strong>and</strong>-based soldiers.” 16 The first<br />
American-Ifugao encounter occurred in 1899, during<br />
the Philippine-American War. 17 The Ifugao developed a<br />
more relatively positive relationship with the<br />
Americans, who were perceived to have a less<br />
aggressive <strong>and</strong> more tolerant attitude toward Ifugao<br />
cultural <strong>and</strong> religious practices; this is evidenced in the<br />
Americans’ adoption of bulol figures “to win<br />
acceptance of or reinforce American authority.” 18<br />
Initial attempts at religious <strong>and</strong> cultural conversions<br />
ultimately floundered because the Ifugao culture<br />
seemed to be “wholly ruled by the tribal religion <strong>and</strong><br />
the supreme ‘law of [ancestral] custom.’” 19 However,<br />
contemporary Ifugao increasingly embrace Christianity<br />
<strong>and</strong> the influences of the Western world. Some Ifugao<br />
have chosen Christianity because of the perception that<br />
its practice is less burdensome: Christianity requires<br />
devotion to a single deity, omits the Ifugao<br />
memorization (for purposes of ritual recitation) of<br />
mythology, pantheon, <strong>and</strong> genealogy, <strong>and</strong> eliminates<br />
frequent <strong>and</strong> costly animal sacrifice. 20 Consequently,<br />
today few Ifugao males undergo shaman training <strong>and</strong><br />
the frequency of rituals coordinated by shamans<br />
progressively wanes. Additionally, some Ifugao have<br />
come to see shamans as beneficial only for the sake of<br />
tracing Ifugao ancestry. 21 Gambuk Ballogan, a former<br />
shaman, now attests that a plentiful rice harvest<br />
depends more on farming methods than on religious<br />
rituals that “[protect] the crop from envious spirits by<br />
sacrificing a chicken.” 22 However, in a few instances<br />
Ifugao resist exclusive devotion to Christianity <strong>and</strong><br />
instead integrate the new faith with indigenous<br />
religious practices; in what may be a sentimental<br />
attempt to maintain some aspects of traditional Ifugao<br />
rituals, the Ifugao have not synchronized the two<br />
religions <strong>and</strong> have rather persisted in celebrating<br />
distinct ritual aspects of each religion. 23 In one example,<br />
Christian prayers are recited during a traditional<br />
animal sacrifice. 24 Yet, even Ifugao who insist the sole<br />
practice of their indigenous religion are not immune to<br />
Western influence; audio <strong>and</strong> video recordings of ritual<br />
chants <strong>and</strong> oral literature are sometimes used during<br />
religious rituals due to the shortage of trained<br />
shamans. 25 A decrease in the potency <strong>and</strong> influence of<br />
Ifugao religion has included a decline in attributing<br />
agricultural authority to the bulol figures.<br />
The Influence of Economics <strong>and</strong> Tourism on the<br />
Significance of the Bulol Figures<br />
In addition to Christian conversion, economics have<br />
unintentionally contributed to a growing rift between<br />
some Ifugao <strong>and</strong> their intensely agricultural <strong>and</strong><br />
religious culture. As part of this process, the bulol have<br />
lost much of their religious meaning <strong>and</strong> have obtained<br />
a commercial significance as local cultural curios<br />
offered for sale to tourists <strong>and</strong> art collectors.<br />
Furthermore, the seventeen rice rituals involved during<br />
the harvest cycle account for a single crop of rice cultivated<br />
during the entire Ifugao year. Within the new<br />
economic system, this single rice crop is no longer sufficient<br />
to sustain the community. The Ifugao have begun<br />
to sell surplus rice (if any), purchase imported rice, <strong>and</strong><br />
grow alternative crops with greater yield from each<br />
harvest cycle. 26 As a result of harvesting crops multiple<br />
times during the year, the rice rituals lose attunement<br />
with the traditional harvest cycle, further eroding the<br />
religious meanings of the bulol figures. The contemporary<br />
significance of the bulol figures as marketed<br />
curios has principally superseded the figures’ religious<br />
instrumental ability to mediate with the rice god Bulol,<br />
who provides <strong>and</strong> maintains physical sustenance for the<br />
Ifugao.<br />
Commonly, Ifugao men seek temporary odd jobs to<br />
supplement family income <strong>and</strong> women prepare for the<br />
summer wave of tourists visiting the province by<br />
producing <strong>and</strong> selling crafts. 27 Other Ifugao either leave<br />
the province to marry, seek further education at universities<br />
or pursue careers in urbanized areas of the Philippines.<br />
28 While these actions may increase income for<br />
the Ifugao, the rice terraces are largely ignored: the<br />
walls of unmaintained terraces crack <strong>and</strong> drain water<br />
from the fields, which must be kept constantly flooded<br />
even out of the cultivation season. Many Ifugao cannot<br />
60 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
afford to maintain their terraces <strong>and</strong> often leave them<br />
to deteriorate to a point where they can no longer be<br />
salvaged for suitable farming conditions. 29<br />
Furthermore, tourism does not directly mitigate the<br />
economic issues of the farmers, but instead benefits<br />
those hungry for a portion of the lucrative tourism<br />
market. Tourists marvel at the gr<strong>and</strong> sight of the<br />
expansive rice terraces blanketing the sides of the<br />
Cordillera mountains, but fundamentally fail to appreciate<br />
the endeavors to preserve these agricultural<br />
wonders <strong>and</strong> their cultural magnitude. It is not<br />
uncommon for the Ifugao to auction family heirlooms<br />
such as the bulol figures to art collectors <strong>and</strong> tourists. 30<br />
Merch<strong>and</strong>ise orders for souvenirs result in the<br />
production of woven blankets <strong>and</strong> carved bulol figures<br />
stripped of their original religious <strong>and</strong> cultural contexts<br />
<strong>and</strong> significance. These souvenirs are purchased<br />
without realizing the item’s genuine cultural meaning;<br />
woven cloths would normally be used to swaddle<br />
infants or wrap the deceased <strong>and</strong> wooden bulol figures<br />
would be used to worship deities that the Ifugao believe<br />
contributed to the history <strong>and</strong> creation of their culture<br />
<strong>and</strong> are directly responsible for the very sustenance of<br />
their people. 31<br />
What may have most impacted the yield of the rice<br />
terraces are the dying ritual traditions, including,<br />
importantly, the ritual use of the bulol figures. Although<br />
programs such as the Highl<strong>and</strong> Agricultural Development<br />
Program focus on the ecological welfare of the<br />
rice fields, little is being done to preserve the culture<br />
responsible for the creation <strong>and</strong> maintenance of the<br />
terraces. 32 Advocates for Ifugao cultural preservation<br />
support programs aiming to foster tourist appreciation<br />
of the farmers’ endeavors in terrace maintenance as<br />
well as instill cultural pride in Ifugao drawn to Western<br />
urban lifestyles. 33 With these efforts, cultural <strong>and</strong><br />
environmental conservationists – Ifugao <strong>and</strong> non-<br />
Ifugao alike – hope to preserve all aspects of a culture<br />
based on the mutual interdependence of the bulol<br />
figures <strong>and</strong> these agricultural masterpieces.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
In this paper, I have aimed to explain the transforming<br />
significance of the bulol figures in the Ifugao culture<br />
that has historically valued religious rituals corresponding<br />
to rice cultivation <strong>and</strong> harvest. In addition to<br />
detailing the bulol figures’ physical qualities <strong>and</strong> ritual<br />
purposes, I have attempted to underscore the impact of<br />
Christianity <strong>and</strong> contemporary economics in Ifugao<br />
culture, which have shifted the meaning of the bulol<br />
figures from firm religious belief in their agricultural<br />
efficacy to a new association with commercial value.<br />
Of the several ethnic groups that reside in the<br />
Cordillera mountain/highl<strong>and</strong> region in northern<br />
Luzon, Philippines, scholars have most frequently<br />
written on the culture of the Ifugao people. However,<br />
ethnocentrism is evident in the dated works of scholars<br />
– particularly Roy F. Barton <strong>and</strong> Francis Lambrecht –<br />
that discuss Ifugao resistance to acculturation <strong>and</strong><br />
Christianity; attempts to detail these areas of Ifugao<br />
history with the highest objectivity are comparatively<br />
scarce. Much of the recent literature on the contemporary<br />
Ifugao stems from outsiders’ ecological <strong>and</strong><br />
cultural conservationist points-of-view rather than<br />
from the perspectives of Ifugao experiencing these<br />
issues firsth<strong>and</strong>. Moreover, most scholars have not<br />
written on the bulol figures in their own right, nor have<br />
they sought to explain how <strong>and</strong> why the Ifugao are<br />
moved to interact with the figures. Another remaining<br />
question is whether Ifugao rituals to Bulol have lost<br />
their devotional gravity <strong>and</strong> sense of efficacy, <strong>and</strong> are<br />
solely continued due to a sentimental attachment to<br />
ancestral tradition (as opposed to an obligatory<br />
urgency to maintain agricultural order). Furthermore,<br />
scholars have not taken the religious/devotional context<br />
as the primary point of reference. Thus, this paper has<br />
represented an initial effort to grapple with some of<br />
these shortcomings in the existing scholarly literature.<br />
U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />
61
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
REFERENCES<br />
Barton, Roy F. The Mythology of the Ifugaos.<br />
Philadelphia: American Folklore Society, 1955.<br />
Barton, Roy F. The Religion of the Ifugaos. Menasha:<br />
American Anthropological Association, 1946.<br />
Bingham, Annette. “New Rice for Old?.”<br />
History Today. July 1990, 2-3.<br />
Dumia, Mariano A. The Ifugao World. Quezon City,<br />
Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1979.<br />
Peralta, Jesus T. “Local to Global Dimension of the<br />
Sacred.” Museum International. September 2003,<br />
18-24.<br />
Roth, Dennis. “Notes on the Ethnohistory of Northern<br />
Luzon.” Ethnohistory, no. 21 (1947): 371-378.<br />
Yuson, Alfred A. “Dancing Anew on the Stairways<br />
to Heaven.” UNESCO Courier. December 2000,<br />
31-33.<br />
Goda, Toh. Cordillera: Diversity in Culture Change:<br />
Social Anthropology of Hill People in Northern<br />
Luzon, Philippines. Quezon City, Philippines:<br />
New Day Publishers, 2001.<br />
Hamilton, Roy W. The Art of Rice: Spirit <strong>and</strong> Suste<br />
nance in Asia. Los Angeles: UCLA Fowler<br />
Museum of Cultural History, 2003.<br />
Hamilton, Roy W. “Using Art to Teach Culture: Rice<br />
in Asia.” Education about Asia, no. 9 (2004): 21-26.<br />
Jenista, Frank L. The White Apos: American Governors<br />
on the Cordillera Central. Quezon City, Philippines:<br />
New Day Publishers, 1987.<br />
Johansson, Philip. “Stairway to Sustainability.”<br />
Earthwatch: The Journal of Earthwatch Institute,<br />
no. 18 (1998): 28-37.<br />
Lambrecht, Francis. “The Main Factors of Resistance<br />
to Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation<br />
in the Philippines; Essays on Changing Societies.<br />
A Selection of Papers Presented at the Baguio<br />
Religious Acculturation Conferences from 1958<br />
to 1968, (1971): 83-89.<br />
Mountains of Water: The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of the<br />
Ifugao. VHS. Directed by Fruto Corre. 1998;<br />
Manila: Bookmark Video, 1998.<br />
Nozawa, Cristi, Melissa Malingan, Anabelle Plantilla,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Je-el Ong. “Evolving Culture, Evolving<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scapes: The Philippine Rice Terraces.” Values<br />
of Protected L<strong>and</strong>scapes <strong>and</strong> Seascapes, no. 1<br />
(2008): 71-93.<br />
ENDNOTES<br />
1<br />
Alfred A. Yuson, “Dancing Anew on the Stairways to<br />
Heaven.” UNESCO Courier, December 2000, 31.<br />
2<br />
Mountains of Water: The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of<br />
the Ifugao. VHS. Directed by Fruto Corre. 1998;<br />
Manila: Bookmark Video, 1998.<br />
3<br />
Roy W. Hamilton, The Art of Rice: Spirit <strong>and</strong> Sustenance<br />
in Asia (Los Angeles: UCLA Fowler Museum<br />
of Cultural History, 2003), 456.<br />
4<br />
The following origin myth of the bulol figures accords<br />
with the myth as told by Corre (1998). Humidhid is<br />
the deity of covering in the sense that something<br />
exp<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> covers, as irrigated water floods a rice<br />
terrace. Corre, VHS.<br />
5<br />
The Ifugao cosmology generally divides the universe<br />
into five regions: the Skyworld, the Upstream Region,<br />
the human-inhabited earth, the Downstream Region<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Underworld (including its sub-level). The<br />
Upstream <strong>and</strong> Downstream Regions are remote areas<br />
believed to be accessed by traveling up or down the<br />
geographic river running through the Ifugao province.<br />
Corre, VHS.<br />
62 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
6<br />
Corre, VHS.<br />
7<br />
Roy F. Barton, The Religion of the Ifugao (Menasha:<br />
American Anthropological Association, 1946), 80.<br />
8<br />
Roy W. Hamilton, “Using Art to Teach Culture: Rice<br />
in Asia.” Education about Asia, no. 9 (2004): 24.<br />
Barton, 81.<br />
9<br />
The series of rituals to activate the bulol begin with<br />
the journey to obtain narra wood from the<br />
Downstream Region <strong>and</strong> conclude with a two- to<br />
three-day long feast in which the shamans are believed<br />
to be possessed by the rice god Bulol. Barton, 80.<br />
Corre, VHS.<br />
10<br />
Most rice rituals invoke a combination of Ifugao<br />
ancestors <strong>and</strong> deities, who then possess shamans<br />
performing rituals. The shamans sit on reed mats<br />
with rice stalks <strong>and</strong> betel nuts, chant myths, drink rice<br />
wine, dance <strong>and</strong> kill animals raised for sacrificial<br />
purposes during the ritual. Hamilton, 2003, 453-454.<br />
Barton, 110-126.<br />
11<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 453. Barton, 110.<br />
12<br />
Cristi Nozawa, Melissa Malingan, Anabelle Plantilla,<br />
Je-el Ong, “Evolving Culture, Evolving L<strong>and</strong>scapes:<br />
The Philippine Rice Terraces.” Values of Protected<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scapes <strong>and</strong> Seascapes, no. 1 (2008): 88.<br />
13<br />
Barton, 112-113.<br />
14<br />
Barton, 117-122.<br />
15<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 454.<br />
16<br />
Frank L. Jenista, The White Apos: American<br />
Governors on the Cordillera Central (Quezon City,<br />
Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1987), 4, 12.<br />
Mariano A. Dumia, The Ifugao World (Quezon City,<br />
Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1979), 28. Francis<br />
Lambrecht, “The Main Factors of Resistance to<br />
Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation in the<br />
Philippines: Essays on Changing Societies. A Selection<br />
of Papers Presented at the Baguio Religious Acculturation<br />
Conferences from 1958 to 1968, (1971): 83.<br />
17<br />
American military troops drove the Filipino General<br />
Emilio Aguinaldo into the Cordillera mountains <strong>and</strong><br />
then settled in the Banaue region of the Ifugao<br />
province. Jenista, 14.<br />
18<br />
Jenista, 161.<br />
19<br />
The issue for the Ifugao lay not in unwanted presence of<br />
foreign cultures; they instead struggled with comprehending<br />
which of their cultural/spiritual practices fit<br />
missionaries’ definition of ethics. Also, the Ifugao<br />
experienced difficulty accepting a supreme, singular god.<br />
Francis Lambrecht, “The Main Factors of Resistance<br />
to Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation in the<br />
Philippines: Essays on Changing Societies. A Selection<br />
of Papers Presented at the Baguio Religious Acculturation<br />
Conferences from 1958 to 1968, (1971): 83.<br />
20<br />
The Ifugao raise animals purely for sacrificial<br />
purposes <strong>and</strong> only consume them in a ritual context.<br />
They are rarely, if ever, solely used for non-ritual<br />
sustenance or even physical labor. Corre, VHS.<br />
21<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 463.<br />
22<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 462.<br />
23<br />
Nozawa, et. al., 75.<br />
24<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 465.<br />
2<br />
Hamilton, 2003, 465. Corre, VHS.<br />
26<br />
Philip Johansson, “Stairway to Sustainability.” Earthwatch:<br />
The Journal of Earthwatch Institute, no. 18<br />
(1998): 29.<br />
27<br />
Corre, VHS.<br />
28<br />
Toh Goda, Cordillera: Diversity in Culture Change:<br />
Social Anthropology of Hill People in Northern<br />
Luzon, Philippines (Quezon City, Philippines: New<br />
Day Publishers, 2001), 69-70.<br />
29<br />
Philip Johansson, “Stairway to Sustainability.” Earthwatch:<br />
The Journal of Earthwatch Institute, no. 18<br />
(1998): 37.<br />
30<br />
Yuson, 32.<br />
31<br />
Corre, VHS.<br />
U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />
63
SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />
<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />
32<br />
Annette Bingham, “New Rice for Old?.” History<br />
Today, July 1990, 2.<br />
33<br />
Johansson, 37. Nozawa, et. al., 71-81.<br />
64 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L