09.06.2015 Views

Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...

Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...

Kimberly Zarate - Undergraduate Research, Scholarship and ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Spiritual Sustenance: The History, Ritual <strong>and</strong> Significance<br />

of the Bulol Figures of the Philippine Ifugao People<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> 1 , Jennifer Hughes 2<br />

1<br />

Department of Media <strong>and</strong> Cultural Studies, 2 Department of Religious Studies<br />

University of California, Riverside<br />

A B S T R A C T<br />

This paper examines the ritual uses <strong>and</strong> history of the bulol rice god figures of the Ifugao<br />

people in northern Luzon, Philippines. Anthropological <strong>and</strong> ethnographic studies of the<br />

Ifugao stress the traditional cultural <strong>and</strong> economic gravity of rice as sustenance but<br />

neglect to explicitly acknowledge how external, non-indigenous forces impact the<br />

religious significance of rice – particularly the use of bulol figures in agricultural religious<br />

rituals. By examining the colonial history of <strong>and</strong> recent economics <strong>and</strong> tourism in the<br />

Ifugao province, as described in anthropological, historical <strong>and</strong> conservationist sources,<br />

I clarify how foreign cultures <strong>and</strong> religions influence those of the Ifugao. I argue that the<br />

increasing prevalence of Christianity <strong>and</strong> contemporary economic pressures have driven<br />

a decrease in the religious potency of the bulol figures by allowing the tourism market to<br />

prioritize the figures’ commercial value as cultural curios rather than their religious value<br />

as representations of an agriculturally efficacious deity.<br />

F A C U L T Y<br />

M E N T O R<br />

Jennifer Hughes<br />

Department of Religious Studies<br />

The UCR CHASS Connect program gives our incoming first year students<br />

a liberal arts college experience within a large, public university setting.<br />

Here they learn not only broad interdisciplinary content <strong>and</strong> methods but<br />

also garner skills to succeed throughout their undergraduate career.<br />

Freshman <strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> enrolled in the CHASS first year sequence “Manifestations<br />

of Spirituality.” Her major project for my class on religious images (Winter 09) represented<br />

original research on the Philippine Ifugao images called bulol. Ms. <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

adopted key analytical categories <strong>and</strong> questions from course lecture <strong>and</strong> reading <strong>and</strong><br />

applied these to formulate a religious studies interpretation of the figures. Already an<br />

exceptional writer <strong>and</strong> careful thinker, she consistently sought to test <strong>and</strong> explore her<br />

ideas <strong>and</strong> theses with me over the course of the quarter. The result is this impressive<br />

piece on the changing significance of these traditional objects of material religion from<br />

a student only just beginning her undergraduate studies.<br />

A U T H O R<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

Film <strong>and</strong> Visual Culture<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong> is a first year<br />

student with a double major in<br />

Anthropology <strong>and</strong> Film <strong>and</strong> Visual<br />

Culture. Her main areas of research<br />

interest include twentieth-century<br />

<strong>and</strong> contemporary visual media,<br />

visual anthropology/ethnography,<br />

journalistic documentation, religion<br />

in media <strong>and</strong> popular culture <strong>and</strong><br />

popular culture trends. In particular,<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> is interested photographic<br />

representation <strong>and</strong> propag<strong>and</strong>a of<br />

social conflict/revolutions as well as<br />

the material culture of religion. She<br />

hopes to further pursue her interests<br />

in graduate school. She also<br />

expresses great gratitude to her<br />

faculty mentor for her encouragement,<br />

support, patience <strong>and</strong><br />

guidance.<br />

U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />

57


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

Designated a World Heritage Site by the United<br />

Nations Educational, Scientific <strong>and</strong> Cultural Organization<br />

(UNESCO) in 1995, the rice terraces in the<br />

Philippines have also been unofficially dubbed the<br />

Eighth Wonder of the World. 1 Carved into the steep<br />

faces of the Cordillera Mountains in northern Luzon,<br />

Philippines, the rice terraces exhibit agricultural<br />

ingenuity unaided by the use of modern technology.<br />

Also constructed into these highl<strong>and</strong> terraces, however,<br />

is the identity of the Ifugao – a people rich with<br />

indigenous <strong>and</strong> colonial history, an elaborately<br />

ritualized religion <strong>and</strong> a way of life trademarked by the<br />

ancestral tradition of rice cultivation. Evidenced by a<br />

deeply rooted spiritual <strong>and</strong> physical connection to the<br />

earth, the religious ritual aspects of the Ifugao culture<br />

are as complex <strong>and</strong> diverse as the terraces are<br />

numerous. The bulol images have figured prominently<br />

in this religious <strong>and</strong> agricultural l<strong>and</strong>scape; the carved,<br />

wooden statues representing the rice deity Bulol have<br />

acted as domestic <strong>and</strong> shamanic ritual objects essential<br />

to Ifugao collective religion for at least several<br />

centuries. 2 However, the growing prevalence of Christianity<br />

<strong>and</strong> contemporary economic pressures have<br />

beckoned the Ifugao away from their maintenance of<br />

the rice terraces <strong>and</strong> belief in the power of the bulol<br />

figures. In 2001 – just six years following its UNESCO<br />

designation as a World Heritage Site – the rice terraces<br />

in the Ifugao province have been placed on the<br />

UNESCO List of World Heritage in Danger. 3 Subsequently,<br />

the bulol rice god figures face an equal endangerment<br />

as their religious <strong>and</strong> cultural significance<br />

deteriorates.<br />

In this paper, I argue that while the bulol figures<br />

maintain some of their historical significance through<br />

the ongoing practice of nearly twenty distinct rice<br />

rituals, the religious significance of the bulol figures to<br />

the Ifugao ultimately continues to erode as participation<br />

in these (now erratic <strong>and</strong> “optional”) rituals no<br />

longer possesses the agricultural urgency it once held<br />

<strong>and</strong> as the figures themselves acquire a new commercial<br />

value in the tourism market driven by contemporary<br />

economic pressures. This phenomenon was first<br />

suggested to me in Fruto Corre’s Mountains of Water:<br />

The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of the Ifugao (1998), an<br />

ethnographic film briefly discussing the bulol figures as<br />

part of a general study of the cultural deterioration of<br />

Ifugao rice rituals. This paper provides more a detailed<br />

examination than Corre’s film by taking the figures<br />

themselves <strong>and</strong> the rituals in which they are involved<br />

as the central focus. I have therefore accumulated<br />

disparate sources to assemble an underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the<br />

changing religious <strong>and</strong> ritual significance of the bulol<br />

figures in Ifugao culture. My investigation revealed that<br />

the bulol figures have been commonly discussed as part<br />

of ethnographic or cultural conservationist studies but<br />

are infrequently studied in their own right <strong>and</strong> even<br />

more rarely analyzed within a specifically religious or<br />

devotional framework. Bringing together early <strong>and</strong><br />

mid-twentieth century ethnographic works on the<br />

Ifugao, recent scholarly literature on the spiritual significance<br />

of rice in Asia <strong>and</strong> ecological writings on cultural<br />

<strong>and</strong> environmental erosion among the Ifugao, my<br />

additional research confirms Corre’s hypothesis of<br />

cultural degradation but highlights the issue of religious<br />

belief <strong>and</strong> practice with respect to the bulol figures. I<br />

will first review the mythology <strong>and</strong> physical qualities<br />

of the bulol figures, discuss their use in rice rituals,<br />

examine the general impact of Spanish <strong>and</strong> American<br />

influence on Ifugao religion <strong>and</strong> finally, explore the<br />

impact of economics <strong>and</strong> tourism on the bulol figures’<br />

religious significance.<br />

The Imagery <strong>and</strong> Mythology of the Bulol<br />

Ifugao mythology explains the origin <strong>and</strong> ubiquity of<br />

the figures in Ifugao culture. The origin myth of the<br />

bulol figures involves the Ifugao deity Humidhid. 4 As<br />

Humidhid walked upon the earth, he heard the loud<br />

moans of a large narra tree <strong>and</strong> cut the tree down. In an<br />

attempt to assuage the tree, Humidhid asked if it<br />

desired to be carved in to a human figure; at this<br />

suggestion, the tree fell silent. Humidhid carved four<br />

human figures from the tree <strong>and</strong> placed the figures into<br />

a river to flow to the Downstream Region <strong>and</strong><br />

multiply. 5 These were the first bulol. Traditionally, the<br />

figures are typically involved in annual rice rituals<br />

invoking the rice deity, Bulol, but they are also placed<br />

inside household granaries in the belief that their<br />

presence will multiply harvested rice. 6 The abundant<br />

58 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

presence of these figures among the Ifugao is thus<br />

accounted for in their religious mythology <strong>and</strong> the care,<br />

maintenance, <strong>and</strong> ritual celebration of the bulol were<br />

traditionally understood to be essential for the sustenance<br />

<strong>and</strong> survival of the Ifugao themselves.<br />

In contrast to the progressive change in the figures’<br />

significance, the physical characteristics of the bulol<br />

figures have remained largely consistent. Bulol figures<br />

may only be carved from narra tree wood obtained<br />

from the Downstream Region. 7 Ranging from 20 to 60<br />

centimeters in height, the figures are typically carved in<br />

pairs – one each in male <strong>and</strong> female human likeness.<br />

The carvings commonly depict the nude human figure<br />

st<strong>and</strong>ing with arms crossed over the chest or sitting<br />

with arms hugging bent knees. While clearly anthropomorphic<br />

in nature, some bulol exhibit basic human<br />

features (such as a head, arms <strong>and</strong> legs) but more<br />

specific anatomical characteristics (such as facial<br />

features, fingers <strong>and</strong> toes) can be distinguished in other<br />

figures. The wooden figures will gradually acquire a<br />

smooth surface <strong>and</strong> black color akin to rich loam –<br />

which is believed to represent a relationship between<br />

rice <strong>and</strong> human fertility – as rice cakes <strong>and</strong> blood from<br />

sacrificed animals are rubbed on the figures to appease<br />

Bulol. 8 The figures undergo a six-week long series of<br />

rites performed by shamans in order to activate the<br />

figures for use in rice rituals. 9<br />

Today, the bulol figures retain their ubiquity in Ifugao<br />

culture; largely owning to their recently attained<br />

commercial value as souvenirs. At the same time, the<br />

ritual celebrations that reinforced the religious potency<br />

of the bulol figures have lost a sense of agricultural<br />

urgency (to ensure bountiful harvest <strong>and</strong> therefore<br />

physical sustenance) as Christianity has become the<br />

most prevalent religion.<br />

Ritual Uses of the Bulol<br />

The rice rituals performed by the Ifugao are numerous<br />

<strong>and</strong> elaborate: there are at least seventeen rice rituals<br />

throughout eleven of the twelve months (October to<br />

August) of the Gregorian calendar. 10 However, these<br />

rituals now suffer from infrequent performance as the<br />

shamanic ritual infrastructure weakens to the point of<br />

potential obsolescence. I will discuss particular rituals<br />

U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />

– as described by Barton (1946), Hamilton (2003) <strong>and</strong><br />

Nozawa (2008) – such as the first <strong>and</strong> last rituals of the<br />

rice cycle <strong>and</strong> rituals directly invoking Bulol <strong>and</strong>/or the<br />

granary idols.<br />

In October, shamans perform the first ritual, Lukat, <strong>and</strong><br />

ask deities to resist consuming the rice crop <strong>and</strong> permit<br />

the women to repair <strong>and</strong> weed fields so fresh water will<br />

flood the terraces. 11 Kulpi is performed after rice is<br />

transplanted from December to January <strong>and</strong> shamans<br />

request that the bulol figures repel pests <strong>and</strong> cause rice<br />

stalks to sprout. 12 In April or May, the Ifugao perform<br />

Paad <strong>and</strong> ask Bulol to prevent rice from “dying in<br />

sympathy” with pulled weeds so rice wine can be<br />

produced for future rituals. 13 On the day of the harvest<br />

in May or June, the four- to seven-hour long ritual<br />

Ingngilin is executed by every field owner, who must<br />

implore Bulol to spare people from illness, debt <strong>and</strong> evil<br />

spirits <strong>and</strong> foster the growth of rice, children, <strong>and</strong> sacrificial<br />

animals. 14 The final ritual, Kahiw occurs during<br />

August <strong>and</strong> households are ceremoniously swept clean<br />

to mark the end of the rice agriculture period <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Ifugao calendar. 15<br />

Although physical use of the bulol rice god figures is<br />

primarily confined to rituals of rice cultivation stages,<br />

the far-reaching significance of the bulol figures is seen<br />

in ritual charges invoking the rice deity, Bulol. Shamans<br />

request that Bulol safeguard fields <strong>and</strong> encourage crop<br />

growth, yet shamans also implore Bulol for the growth<br />

<strong>and</strong> health of the Ifugao people in Ingngilin, one of<br />

lengthiest <strong>and</strong> most intricately involving rituals. The<br />

bulol figures act as physical manifestations representative<br />

of an intangible, supernatural being who not only<br />

oversees the protection <strong>and</strong> growth of the annual single<br />

rice crop, but the well-being of the people who cultivate<br />

the rice for physical sustenance. The extensive spiritual<br />

<strong>and</strong> economic involvement resulting from the acutely<br />

intertwined Ifugao culture <strong>and</strong> religion has compelled<br />

an increasing number of Ifugao to pursue alternative,<br />

less dem<strong>and</strong>ing religious <strong>and</strong> cultural paths.<br />

The Impact of Spanish <strong>and</strong> American Presence<br />

in the Ifugao Province<br />

The eroding impact of foreigners on the significance of<br />

the bulol figures in religious practice began during the<br />

59


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

colonial period with Spanish arrival in the Ifugao<br />

province during the 1750s. However, Spanish attempts<br />

to comm<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> catechize the Ifugao during the next<br />

century <strong>and</strong> a half are generally considered unsuccessful,<br />

“never more than a tenuous military occupation<br />

of the highl<strong>and</strong>s by lowl<strong>and</strong>-based soldiers.” 16 The first<br />

American-Ifugao encounter occurred in 1899, during<br />

the Philippine-American War. 17 The Ifugao developed a<br />

more relatively positive relationship with the<br />

Americans, who were perceived to have a less<br />

aggressive <strong>and</strong> more tolerant attitude toward Ifugao<br />

cultural <strong>and</strong> religious practices; this is evidenced in the<br />

Americans’ adoption of bulol figures “to win<br />

acceptance of or reinforce American authority.” 18<br />

Initial attempts at religious <strong>and</strong> cultural conversions<br />

ultimately floundered because the Ifugao culture<br />

seemed to be “wholly ruled by the tribal religion <strong>and</strong><br />

the supreme ‘law of [ancestral] custom.’” 19 However,<br />

contemporary Ifugao increasingly embrace Christianity<br />

<strong>and</strong> the influences of the Western world. Some Ifugao<br />

have chosen Christianity because of the perception that<br />

its practice is less burdensome: Christianity requires<br />

devotion to a single deity, omits the Ifugao<br />

memorization (for purposes of ritual recitation) of<br />

mythology, pantheon, <strong>and</strong> genealogy, <strong>and</strong> eliminates<br />

frequent <strong>and</strong> costly animal sacrifice. 20 Consequently,<br />

today few Ifugao males undergo shaman training <strong>and</strong><br />

the frequency of rituals coordinated by shamans<br />

progressively wanes. Additionally, some Ifugao have<br />

come to see shamans as beneficial only for the sake of<br />

tracing Ifugao ancestry. 21 Gambuk Ballogan, a former<br />

shaman, now attests that a plentiful rice harvest<br />

depends more on farming methods than on religious<br />

rituals that “[protect] the crop from envious spirits by<br />

sacrificing a chicken.” 22 However, in a few instances<br />

Ifugao resist exclusive devotion to Christianity <strong>and</strong><br />

instead integrate the new faith with indigenous<br />

religious practices; in what may be a sentimental<br />

attempt to maintain some aspects of traditional Ifugao<br />

rituals, the Ifugao have not synchronized the two<br />

religions <strong>and</strong> have rather persisted in celebrating<br />

distinct ritual aspects of each religion. 23 In one example,<br />

Christian prayers are recited during a traditional<br />

animal sacrifice. 24 Yet, even Ifugao who insist the sole<br />

practice of their indigenous religion are not immune to<br />

Western influence; audio <strong>and</strong> video recordings of ritual<br />

chants <strong>and</strong> oral literature are sometimes used during<br />

religious rituals due to the shortage of trained<br />

shamans. 25 A decrease in the potency <strong>and</strong> influence of<br />

Ifugao religion has included a decline in attributing<br />

agricultural authority to the bulol figures.<br />

The Influence of Economics <strong>and</strong> Tourism on the<br />

Significance of the Bulol Figures<br />

In addition to Christian conversion, economics have<br />

unintentionally contributed to a growing rift between<br />

some Ifugao <strong>and</strong> their intensely agricultural <strong>and</strong><br />

religious culture. As part of this process, the bulol have<br />

lost much of their religious meaning <strong>and</strong> have obtained<br />

a commercial significance as local cultural curios<br />

offered for sale to tourists <strong>and</strong> art collectors.<br />

Furthermore, the seventeen rice rituals involved during<br />

the harvest cycle account for a single crop of rice cultivated<br />

during the entire Ifugao year. Within the new<br />

economic system, this single rice crop is no longer sufficient<br />

to sustain the community. The Ifugao have begun<br />

to sell surplus rice (if any), purchase imported rice, <strong>and</strong><br />

grow alternative crops with greater yield from each<br />

harvest cycle. 26 As a result of harvesting crops multiple<br />

times during the year, the rice rituals lose attunement<br />

with the traditional harvest cycle, further eroding the<br />

religious meanings of the bulol figures. The contemporary<br />

significance of the bulol figures as marketed<br />

curios has principally superseded the figures’ religious<br />

instrumental ability to mediate with the rice god Bulol,<br />

who provides <strong>and</strong> maintains physical sustenance for the<br />

Ifugao.<br />

Commonly, Ifugao men seek temporary odd jobs to<br />

supplement family income <strong>and</strong> women prepare for the<br />

summer wave of tourists visiting the province by<br />

producing <strong>and</strong> selling crafts. 27 Other Ifugao either leave<br />

the province to marry, seek further education at universities<br />

or pursue careers in urbanized areas of the Philippines.<br />

28 While these actions may increase income for<br />

the Ifugao, the rice terraces are largely ignored: the<br />

walls of unmaintained terraces crack <strong>and</strong> drain water<br />

from the fields, which must be kept constantly flooded<br />

even out of the cultivation season. Many Ifugao cannot<br />

60 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

afford to maintain their terraces <strong>and</strong> often leave them<br />

to deteriorate to a point where they can no longer be<br />

salvaged for suitable farming conditions. 29<br />

Furthermore, tourism does not directly mitigate the<br />

economic issues of the farmers, but instead benefits<br />

those hungry for a portion of the lucrative tourism<br />

market. Tourists marvel at the gr<strong>and</strong> sight of the<br />

expansive rice terraces blanketing the sides of the<br />

Cordillera mountains, but fundamentally fail to appreciate<br />

the endeavors to preserve these agricultural<br />

wonders <strong>and</strong> their cultural magnitude. It is not<br />

uncommon for the Ifugao to auction family heirlooms<br />

such as the bulol figures to art collectors <strong>and</strong> tourists. 30<br />

Merch<strong>and</strong>ise orders for souvenirs result in the<br />

production of woven blankets <strong>and</strong> carved bulol figures<br />

stripped of their original religious <strong>and</strong> cultural contexts<br />

<strong>and</strong> significance. These souvenirs are purchased<br />

without realizing the item’s genuine cultural meaning;<br />

woven cloths would normally be used to swaddle<br />

infants or wrap the deceased <strong>and</strong> wooden bulol figures<br />

would be used to worship deities that the Ifugao believe<br />

contributed to the history <strong>and</strong> creation of their culture<br />

<strong>and</strong> are directly responsible for the very sustenance of<br />

their people. 31<br />

What may have most impacted the yield of the rice<br />

terraces are the dying ritual traditions, including,<br />

importantly, the ritual use of the bulol figures. Although<br />

programs such as the Highl<strong>and</strong> Agricultural Development<br />

Program focus on the ecological welfare of the<br />

rice fields, little is being done to preserve the culture<br />

responsible for the creation <strong>and</strong> maintenance of the<br />

terraces. 32 Advocates for Ifugao cultural preservation<br />

support programs aiming to foster tourist appreciation<br />

of the farmers’ endeavors in terrace maintenance as<br />

well as instill cultural pride in Ifugao drawn to Western<br />

urban lifestyles. 33 With these efforts, cultural <strong>and</strong><br />

environmental conservationists – Ifugao <strong>and</strong> non-<br />

Ifugao alike – hope to preserve all aspects of a culture<br />

based on the mutual interdependence of the bulol<br />

figures <strong>and</strong> these agricultural masterpieces.<br />

CONCLUSION<br />

In this paper, I have aimed to explain the transforming<br />

significance of the bulol figures in the Ifugao culture<br />

that has historically valued religious rituals corresponding<br />

to rice cultivation <strong>and</strong> harvest. In addition to<br />

detailing the bulol figures’ physical qualities <strong>and</strong> ritual<br />

purposes, I have attempted to underscore the impact of<br />

Christianity <strong>and</strong> contemporary economics in Ifugao<br />

culture, which have shifted the meaning of the bulol<br />

figures from firm religious belief in their agricultural<br />

efficacy to a new association with commercial value.<br />

Of the several ethnic groups that reside in the<br />

Cordillera mountain/highl<strong>and</strong> region in northern<br />

Luzon, Philippines, scholars have most frequently<br />

written on the culture of the Ifugao people. However,<br />

ethnocentrism is evident in the dated works of scholars<br />

– particularly Roy F. Barton <strong>and</strong> Francis Lambrecht –<br />

that discuss Ifugao resistance to acculturation <strong>and</strong><br />

Christianity; attempts to detail these areas of Ifugao<br />

history with the highest objectivity are comparatively<br />

scarce. Much of the recent literature on the contemporary<br />

Ifugao stems from outsiders’ ecological <strong>and</strong><br />

cultural conservationist points-of-view rather than<br />

from the perspectives of Ifugao experiencing these<br />

issues firsth<strong>and</strong>. Moreover, most scholars have not<br />

written on the bulol figures in their own right, nor have<br />

they sought to explain how <strong>and</strong> why the Ifugao are<br />

moved to interact with the figures. Another remaining<br />

question is whether Ifugao rituals to Bulol have lost<br />

their devotional gravity <strong>and</strong> sense of efficacy, <strong>and</strong> are<br />

solely continued due to a sentimental attachment to<br />

ancestral tradition (as opposed to an obligatory<br />

urgency to maintain agricultural order). Furthermore,<br />

scholars have not taken the religious/devotional context<br />

as the primary point of reference. Thus, this paper has<br />

represented an initial effort to grapple with some of<br />

these shortcomings in the existing scholarly literature.<br />

U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />

61


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

REFERENCES<br />

Barton, Roy F. The Mythology of the Ifugaos.<br />

Philadelphia: American Folklore Society, 1955.<br />

Barton, Roy F. The Religion of the Ifugaos. Menasha:<br />

American Anthropological Association, 1946.<br />

Bingham, Annette. “New Rice for Old?.”<br />

History Today. July 1990, 2-3.<br />

Dumia, Mariano A. The Ifugao World. Quezon City,<br />

Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1979.<br />

Peralta, Jesus T. “Local to Global Dimension of the<br />

Sacred.” Museum International. September 2003,<br />

18-24.<br />

Roth, Dennis. “Notes on the Ethnohistory of Northern<br />

Luzon.” Ethnohistory, no. 21 (1947): 371-378.<br />

Yuson, Alfred A. “Dancing Anew on the Stairways<br />

to Heaven.” UNESCO Courier. December 2000,<br />

31-33.<br />

Goda, Toh. Cordillera: Diversity in Culture Change:<br />

Social Anthropology of Hill People in Northern<br />

Luzon, Philippines. Quezon City, Philippines:<br />

New Day Publishers, 2001.<br />

Hamilton, Roy W. The Art of Rice: Spirit <strong>and</strong> Suste<br />

nance in Asia. Los Angeles: UCLA Fowler<br />

Museum of Cultural History, 2003.<br />

Hamilton, Roy W. “Using Art to Teach Culture: Rice<br />

in Asia.” Education about Asia, no. 9 (2004): 21-26.<br />

Jenista, Frank L. The White Apos: American Governors<br />

on the Cordillera Central. Quezon City, Philippines:<br />

New Day Publishers, 1987.<br />

Johansson, Philip. “Stairway to Sustainability.”<br />

Earthwatch: The Journal of Earthwatch Institute,<br />

no. 18 (1998): 28-37.<br />

Lambrecht, Francis. “The Main Factors of Resistance<br />

to Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation<br />

in the Philippines; Essays on Changing Societies.<br />

A Selection of Papers Presented at the Baguio<br />

Religious Acculturation Conferences from 1958<br />

to 1968, (1971): 83-89.<br />

Mountains of Water: The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of the<br />

Ifugao. VHS. Directed by Fruto Corre. 1998;<br />

Manila: Bookmark Video, 1998.<br />

Nozawa, Cristi, Melissa Malingan, Anabelle Plantilla,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Je-el Ong. “Evolving Culture, Evolving<br />

L<strong>and</strong>scapes: The Philippine Rice Terraces.” Values<br />

of Protected L<strong>and</strong>scapes <strong>and</strong> Seascapes, no. 1<br />

(2008): 71-93.<br />

ENDNOTES<br />

1<br />

Alfred A. Yuson, “Dancing Anew on the Stairways to<br />

Heaven.” UNESCO Courier, December 2000, 31.<br />

2<br />

Mountains of Water: The Terraces <strong>and</strong> Traditions of<br />

the Ifugao. VHS. Directed by Fruto Corre. 1998;<br />

Manila: Bookmark Video, 1998.<br />

3<br />

Roy W. Hamilton, The Art of Rice: Spirit <strong>and</strong> Sustenance<br />

in Asia (Los Angeles: UCLA Fowler Museum<br />

of Cultural History, 2003), 456.<br />

4<br />

The following origin myth of the bulol figures accords<br />

with the myth as told by Corre (1998). Humidhid is<br />

the deity of covering in the sense that something<br />

exp<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> covers, as irrigated water floods a rice<br />

terrace. Corre, VHS.<br />

5<br />

The Ifugao cosmology generally divides the universe<br />

into five regions: the Skyworld, the Upstream Region,<br />

the human-inhabited earth, the Downstream Region<br />

<strong>and</strong> the Underworld (including its sub-level). The<br />

Upstream <strong>and</strong> Downstream Regions are remote areas<br />

believed to be accessed by traveling up or down the<br />

geographic river running through the Ifugao province.<br />

Corre, VHS.<br />

62 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

6<br />

Corre, VHS.<br />

7<br />

Roy F. Barton, The Religion of the Ifugao (Menasha:<br />

American Anthropological Association, 1946), 80.<br />

8<br />

Roy W. Hamilton, “Using Art to Teach Culture: Rice<br />

in Asia.” Education about Asia, no. 9 (2004): 24.<br />

Barton, 81.<br />

9<br />

The series of rituals to activate the bulol begin with<br />

the journey to obtain narra wood from the<br />

Downstream Region <strong>and</strong> conclude with a two- to<br />

three-day long feast in which the shamans are believed<br />

to be possessed by the rice god Bulol. Barton, 80.<br />

Corre, VHS.<br />

10<br />

Most rice rituals invoke a combination of Ifugao<br />

ancestors <strong>and</strong> deities, who then possess shamans<br />

performing rituals. The shamans sit on reed mats<br />

with rice stalks <strong>and</strong> betel nuts, chant myths, drink rice<br />

wine, dance <strong>and</strong> kill animals raised for sacrificial<br />

purposes during the ritual. Hamilton, 2003, 453-454.<br />

Barton, 110-126.<br />

11<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 453. Barton, 110.<br />

12<br />

Cristi Nozawa, Melissa Malingan, Anabelle Plantilla,<br />

Je-el Ong, “Evolving Culture, Evolving L<strong>and</strong>scapes:<br />

The Philippine Rice Terraces.” Values of Protected<br />

L<strong>and</strong>scapes <strong>and</strong> Seascapes, no. 1 (2008): 88.<br />

13<br />

Barton, 112-113.<br />

14<br />

Barton, 117-122.<br />

15<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 454.<br />

16<br />

Frank L. Jenista, The White Apos: American<br />

Governors on the Cordillera Central (Quezon City,<br />

Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1987), 4, 12.<br />

Mariano A. Dumia, The Ifugao World (Quezon City,<br />

Philippines: New Day Publishers, 1979), 28. Francis<br />

Lambrecht, “The Main Factors of Resistance to<br />

Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation in the<br />

Philippines: Essays on Changing Societies. A Selection<br />

of Papers Presented at the Baguio Religious Acculturation<br />

Conferences from 1958 to 1968, (1971): 83.<br />

17<br />

American military troops drove the Filipino General<br />

Emilio Aguinaldo into the Cordillera mountains <strong>and</strong><br />

then settled in the Banaue region of the Ifugao<br />

province. Jenista, 14.<br />

18<br />

Jenista, 161.<br />

19<br />

The issue for the Ifugao lay not in unwanted presence of<br />

foreign cultures; they instead struggled with comprehending<br />

which of their cultural/spiritual practices fit<br />

missionaries’ definition of ethics. Also, the Ifugao<br />

experienced difficulty accepting a supreme, singular god.<br />

Francis Lambrecht, “The Main Factors of Resistance<br />

to Culture Change in Ifugaol<strong>and</strong>.” Acculturation in the<br />

Philippines: Essays on Changing Societies. A Selection<br />

of Papers Presented at the Baguio Religious Acculturation<br />

Conferences from 1958 to 1968, (1971): 83.<br />

20<br />

The Ifugao raise animals purely for sacrificial<br />

purposes <strong>and</strong> only consume them in a ritual context.<br />

They are rarely, if ever, solely used for non-ritual<br />

sustenance or even physical labor. Corre, VHS.<br />

21<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 463.<br />

22<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 462.<br />

23<br />

Nozawa, et. al., 75.<br />

24<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 465.<br />

2<br />

Hamilton, 2003, 465. Corre, VHS.<br />

26<br />

Philip Johansson, “Stairway to Sustainability.” Earthwatch:<br />

The Journal of Earthwatch Institute, no. 18<br />

(1998): 29.<br />

27<br />

Corre, VHS.<br />

28<br />

Toh Goda, Cordillera: Diversity in Culture Change:<br />

Social Anthropology of Hill People in Northern<br />

Luzon, Philippines (Quezon City, Philippines: New<br />

Day Publishers, 2001), 69-70.<br />

29<br />

Philip Johansson, “Stairway to Sustainability.” Earthwatch:<br />

The Journal of Earthwatch Institute, no. 18<br />

(1998): 37.<br />

30<br />

Yuson, 32.<br />

31<br />

Corre, VHS.<br />

U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L<br />

63


SPIRITUAL SUSTENANCE: THE HISTORY, RITUAL AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BULOL FIGURES OF THE PHILIPPINE IFUGAO PEOPLE<br />

<strong>Kimberly</strong> <strong>Zarate</strong><br />

32<br />

Annette Bingham, “New Rice for Old?.” History<br />

Today, July 1990, 2.<br />

33<br />

Johansson, 37. Nozawa, et. al., 71-81.<br />

64 U C R U N D E R G R A D U A T E R E S E A R C H J O U R N A L

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!