17.11.2012 Views

Central Coast Rocky Shore Biodiversity Assessment

Central Coast Rocky Shore Biodiversity Assessment

Central Coast Rocky Shore Biodiversity Assessment

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Central</strong> <strong>Coast</strong> <strong>Rocky</strong> <strong>Shore</strong><br />

<strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong><br />

FINAL REPORT (PROJECT CAE 06017)<br />

December 2007<br />

Prepared by<br />

Dr William Gladstone, Ms Aude Loisier, and Mr Chris Herbert


Table of Contents<br />

1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS .........6<br />

2 INTRODUCTION............................................................................10<br />

3 METHODS .......................................................................................11<br />

3.1 Habitat <strong>Assessment</strong>......................................................................................11<br />

3.2 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Intertidal Organisms...........................................11<br />

3.2.1 Sampling Locations .............................................................................12<br />

3.2.2 Sampling Methods ...............................................................................12<br />

3.2.3 Data analysis ........................................................................................13<br />

3.3 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Birds ...................................................................16<br />

4 RESULTS .........................................................................................16<br />

4.1 Habitat <strong>Assessment</strong>......................................................................................16<br />

4.2 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Intertidal Organisms...........................................19<br />

4.2.1 Species Richness and Rare Species .....................................................19<br />

4.2.2 Species Assemblages ...........................................................................20<br />

4.2.3 Simulated Reserve Selection................................................................21<br />

4.2.4 Benchmarking Against Other Rock Platforms ....................................22<br />

4.2.5 Size of Species .....................................................................................24<br />

4.3 Birds.............................................................................................................34<br />

5 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS .............................36<br />

6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................40<br />

7 REFERENCES.................................................................................41<br />

8 APPENDICES ..................................................................................43<br />

8.1 Study Locations ...........................................................................................44<br />

8.2 Species of Intertidal Organisms Recorded...................................................52<br />

8.3 Cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera) .......................................................................67<br />

8.4 Bird Survey Results .....................................................................................68<br />

8.5 Significant Roost and Foraging Sites for Birds ...........................................74<br />

2


List of Figures<br />

Figure 1 <strong>Shore</strong>s at which the assessments of biodiversity of intertidal organisms and<br />

birds were undertaken..................................................................................................15<br />

Figure 2 Cluster dendrogram derived from the species presence-absence data. The<br />

shore codes are Blue lagoon (BL), Snapper Point (SP), Norah Head (NH), The<br />

Skillion (TS), Spoon Bay (SB), The Entrance (TE), Swansea Heads (SH), Soldiers<br />

Reef (SR), Maitland Bay (MB), Catherine Hill Bay (CHB), Little Beach (LB), Pearl<br />

Beach (PB), Leggies (Le), Caves Beach (CB), Dudley (Du). .....................................20<br />

Figure 3 non-metric multidimensional scaling (MDS) ordination plot depicting<br />

groupings of rocky shores according to similarity in their species assemblages (at the<br />

level of 75% similarity). The location codes are shown in Figure 2. ..........................21<br />

Figure 4 Species accumulation curve showing the percentage of all species<br />

accumulated in shores selected during a simulated reserve selection process by a<br />

minimum-set algorithm in C-Plan to achieve the conservation goal of each species<br />

being represented at least once in a reserve.................................................................22<br />

Figure 5 Size frequency distribution of Cellana tramoserica at the different locations.<br />

Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at<br />

sexual maturity.............................................................................................................26<br />

Figure 6 Size frequency distribution of Bembicium nanum at the different locations.<br />

Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at<br />

sexual maturity.............................................................................................................28<br />

Figure 7 Size frequency distribution of Nerita atramentosa at the different locations.<br />

Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at<br />

sexual maturity.............................................................................................................30<br />

Figure 8 Size frequency distribution of Austrocochlea porcata at the different<br />

locations. Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates<br />

the size at sexual maturity............................................................................................32<br />

3


List of Tables<br />

Table 1 Habitats present (indicated by X) at 26 rocky shores surveyed in the Gosford,<br />

Wyong and Lake Macquarie Local Government Areas (LGAs) (* rocky shores<br />

surveyed in the biodiversity assessments for intertidal organisms and birds).............17<br />

Table 2 Habitats and sub-habitats present (indicated by X) at each of the 15 rocky<br />

shores at which detailed biodiversity assessments were undertaken (HS high-shore<br />

platform, MS mid-shore platform, Ba mid-shore platform dominated by barnacles, LS<br />

low-shore platform, Cr crevice, Bo boulders, Co cobbles, RP rock pools).................18<br />

Table 3 Number of replicate sites sampled for each habitat/sub-habitat at each shore<br />

(see Table 2 for abbreviations of habitats/sub-habitats). .............................................18<br />

Table 4 Number of species and rare species and summed irreplaceability (Summ IRR)<br />

value of each shore for intertidal organisms and the number of bird species recorded<br />

at each shore.................................................................................................................19<br />

Table 5 Comparison of total number of species and total number of mollusc species<br />

recorded in other studies on intertidal rocky platforms between Nobbys and Pearl<br />

Beach............................................................................................................................23<br />

Table 6 Presence (1) and absence (0) of bird species at each rocky shore. The shore<br />

codes are Blue lagoon (BL), Snapper Point (SP), Norah Head (NH), The Skillion<br />

(TS), Spoon Bay (SB), The Entrance (TE), Swansea Heads (SH), Soldiers Reef (SR),<br />

Maitland Bay (MB), Catherine Hill Bay (CHB), Little Beach (LB), Pearl Beach (PB),<br />

Leggies (Le), Caves Beach (CB), Dudley (Du)...........................................................35<br />

4


List of Appendices<br />

Appendix 8.1.1: The 3 study sites at Pearl Beach........................................................44<br />

Appendix 8.1.2: The 3 study sites at Maitland Bay.....................................................44<br />

Appendix 8.1.3: The 3 study sites at Little Beach .......................................................45<br />

Appendix 8.1.4: The 3 study sites at The Skillion.......................................................45<br />

Appendix 8.1.5: The 3 study sites at Spoon Bay .........................................................46<br />

Appendix 8.1.6: The 3 study sites at Blue Lagoon......................................................46<br />

Appendix 8.1.7: The 3 study sites at The Entrance .....................................................47<br />

Appendix 8.1.8: The 3 study sites at Soldiers Reef .....................................................47<br />

Appendix 8.1.9: The 3 study sites at Norah Head .......................................................48<br />

Appendix 8.1.10: The 3 study sites at Snapper Point ..................................................48<br />

Appendix 8.1.11: The 3 study sites of Catherine Hill Bay ..........................................49<br />

Appendix 8.1.12: The 3 study sites at Caves Beach....................................................49<br />

Appendix 8.1.13: The 3 study sites at Swansea Head .................................................50<br />

Appendix 8.1.14: The 3 study sites at Dudley.............................................................50<br />

Appendix 8.1.15: The 3 study sites at Leggies ............................................................51<br />

Appendix 8.2.1: Pearl Beach species list.....................................................................52<br />

Appendix 8.2.2: Maitland Bay species list ..................................................................53<br />

Appendix 8.2.3: Little Beach species list.....................................................................54<br />

Appendix 8.2.4: The Skillion species list ....................................................................55<br />

Appendix 8.2.5: Spoon Bay species list.......................................................................56<br />

Appendix 8.2.6: Blue Lagoon species list ...................................................................57<br />

Appendix 8.2.7: The Entrance species list...................................................................58<br />

Appendix 8.2.8: Soldiers Reef species list...................................................................59<br />

Appendix 8.2.9: Norah Head species list.....................................................................60<br />

Appendix 8.2.10: Snapper Point species list................................................................61<br />

Appendix 8.2.11: Catherine Hill Bay species list........................................................62<br />

Appendix 8.2.12: Caves Beach species list .................................................................63<br />

Appendix 8.2.13: Swansea Head species list...............................................................64<br />

Appendix 8.2.14: Dudley species list ..........................................................................65<br />

Appendix 8.2.15: Leggies species list..........................................................................66<br />

Appendix 8.3.1: Measurements of cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera). Range sizes (mm),<br />

average inner and outer diameters (mm) of the 50 cunjevoi were measured at each<br />

site. The mean and standard error were measured for each location at each site; also<br />

the total mean diameter ± standard error was given for each location. .......................67<br />

Appendix 8.5.1: Significant roost and foraging sites for birds at The Entrance..........74<br />

Appendix 8.5.2: Gull and Tern roost and foraging site for shorebirds at Norah Head74<br />

Appendix 8.5.3: Significant roost and foraging sites for birds at Soldiers Reef ........75<br />

5


1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS<br />

The aims of this project were: (i) to undertake a habitat assessment at a minimum of<br />

25 rocky shores in the Gosford, Wyong, and Lake Macquarie Local Government<br />

Areas, (ii) to undertake a detailed biodiversity assessment (intertidal organisms, birds)<br />

at 15 rocky shores in the same area, (iii) to train Project Aware volunteers in<br />

techniques of biodiversity assessment, and (iv) to engage Project Aware volunteers in<br />

the collection of data for the biodiversity assessment. The biodiversity assessment<br />

methods used for intertidal organisms were the same as those used by NSW DPI.<br />

Habitat assessment<br />

The presence-absence of five habitats (platform, crevice, rock pools, boulder areas,<br />

cobble areas) was recorded at 26 rocky shores (10 Gosford LGA, 11 Wyong LGA, 5<br />

Lake Macquarie LGA): 6 rocky shores had 4 habitats present and 20 rocky shores had<br />

5 habitats present.<br />

A more detailed comparison of habitat presence-absence was done at the 15 rocky<br />

shores used for the detailed biodiversity assessment by recording the presenceabsence<br />

of crevices, rock pools, boulder areas, cobble areas and 4 sub-habitats within<br />

the platform habitat (low shore platform, mid-shore platform dominated by barnacles,<br />

mid-shore platform dominated by grazers, high-shore platform): 10 shores had 8<br />

habitats/sub-habitats present, 5 shores had 7 habitats/sub-habitats present.<br />

Both habitat assessments indicate that there was little discrimination among shores on<br />

the basis of both a coarse and a fine habitat classification.<br />

<strong>Biodiversity</strong> assessment: intertidal organisms<br />

Fifteen rocky shores were selected from the 26 rocky shores that had been surveyed<br />

for habitats, representing the range of habitat numbers present. These 15 rocky shores<br />

included 5 from each LGA. The most southern rocky shore surveyed was Pearl Beach<br />

and the most northern was Leggies.<br />

A total of 230 species were recorded across the 15 rocky shores sampled. The highest<br />

number of species occurred at Swansea Head (127 species) and the smallest number<br />

of species was recorded at Norah Head and Snapper Point (91 species).<br />

Seventy one species (31% of all species recorded) were classified as ‘rare’ (i.e.<br />

occurring at only 1-2 shores). The greatest numbers of rare species were recorded at<br />

Blue Lagoon (15 species) and Swansea Head (12 species).<br />

The species assemblages across all rocky shores were more than 60% similar with the<br />

most distinctive assemblage occurring at Blue Lagoon. When grouped at a level of<br />

75% similarity, the rocky shores formed 7 groups consisting of shores with a<br />

distinctive assemblage (Blue Lagoon, Snapper Point, Norah Head, The Skillion,<br />

Swansea Heads), 2 shores sharing an assemblage (Spoon Bay, The Entrance) and a<br />

group of 8 shores sharing a similar assemblage (Maitland Bay, Soldiers Reef,<br />

Catherine Hill Bay, Little Beach, Pearl Beach, Leggies, Caves Beach, Dudley).<br />

6


The relative conservation value of shores was quantified by their summed<br />

irreplaceability, which measured the relative contribution of each shore towards the<br />

conservation goal of representing all species. Swansea Heads had the highest summed<br />

irreplaceability value (28.5) and the Entrance the lowest (11.3). Thirteen shores (87%<br />

of all shores) were required to achieve the goal of representing all the species at least<br />

once in the simulated reserve network. However, selection of a single shore, Swansea<br />

Head, included 55.2% of all species and selection of 3 shores (Swansea Heads, Blue<br />

Lagoon, Little Beach) included 79% of all species<br />

Benchmarking of the results of this study with other studies found the range in the<br />

number of species per shore and the range in the number of mollusc species per shore<br />

were within the range of values reported for other shores in the region.<br />

All shores contained reproductively mature and immature individuals of the 4<br />

measured species Cellana tramoserica, Bembicium nanum, Nerita atramentosa and<br />

Austrocochlea porcata. All shores are therefore potentially capable of acting as<br />

sources of recruits for other shores, and all shores are being replenished with recruits<br />

from other shores.<br />

Cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera) were present at all shores except Snapper Point, and<br />

were absent from 1 or more sites at Spoon Bay, Caves Beach and Dudley. The<br />

smallest and largest mean sizes of cunjevoi occurred, respectively, at The Entrance<br />

and Dudley, although all shores (except Snapper Point) contained small and large<br />

individuals.<br />

<strong>Biodiversity</strong> assessment: birds<br />

Twenty-two bird species were recorded with the greatest number of species observed<br />

at Norah Head (10 species) and Blue Lagoon (7 species). No birds were observed at<br />

Little Beach or Spoon Bay and only 1 species was observed at each of Pearl Beach,<br />

Maitland Bay, Caves Beach, and Leggies.<br />

The rarest, most rock-platform dependant bird observed was a single sighting of a pair<br />

of Eastern Reef Egrets (dark phase) at Swansea Heads.<br />

Norah Head was particularly important for birds, being recognized as a significant<br />

high-tide roost for gulls and terns, and a significant low-tide foraging site for<br />

migratory shorebirds and a roost for gulls and terns.<br />

Community participation<br />

Volunteers contributed greatly to this project by undertaking (with training and<br />

supervision) the monitoring of mollusc species. Sixteen volunteers were trained in the<br />

methods and a total of 30 person days (by 10 individuals) were contributed by Project<br />

Aware participants. An additional 13 person days (by 6 individuals) were contributed<br />

by other community volunteers.<br />

7


Recommendations<br />

As a basis for further discussion about the preferred number of protected areas the<br />

following sub-set of shores are recommended as priorities for protection: Swansea<br />

Heads (Lake Macquarie LGA), Blue Lagoon (Wyong LGA), and Norah Head<br />

(Wyong LGA).<br />

The protection of these 3 shores would achieve:<br />

• Representation of 74% of intertidal species and 48% of rare species<br />

• Representation of multiple examples of all habitats/sub-habitats<br />

• Representation of 3 types of species assemblage (an example of another<br />

assemblage type is currently protected within the Bouddi Marine Extension)<br />

• Protection of the most important shore for birds (Norah Head) and overall for<br />

17 species (77% of total species) of birds<br />

• Protection of viable populations of the 5 measured species<br />

Consideration of the need to protect these 3 shores should be assessed in conjunction<br />

with the following:<br />

• Protection is recommended despite evidence of limited impacts from current<br />

human activities at any rocky shore. However, experiences from terrestrial<br />

ecosystems and from other marine ecosystems have shown that human uses<br />

and impacts change through time and frequently increase in response to<br />

changing patterns of population settlement, recreational activities, and<br />

commercial interests. Pre-emptive protection is an effective preventive<br />

measure, maintains option values, and avoids the high costs of remediation<br />

that may be required in the future if shores remained unprotected<br />

• Although the recommendation for protection of three shores does not include<br />

any shore within the Gosford LGA the Bouddi National Park Marine<br />

Extension is wholly within the boundaries of Gosford LGA and includes a<br />

substantial stretch of coastline within the Gosford LGA in which intertidal<br />

rocky shores are protected<br />

• An earlier study by Otway (1999) recommended consideration of Tudibaring<br />

Head (at Copacabana, Gosford LGA) and Toowoon Point (Wyong LGA) as<br />

candidate aquatic reserves<br />

• Inclusion of Tudibaring Head and expansion of protection to encompass<br />

Toowoon Point and Blue Lagoon would address the priority sites of both<br />

studies<br />

In addition to recommending protection for Swansea Heads, Blue Lagoon, and Norah<br />

Head it is also recommended that programs of community awareness and education<br />

be established by local councils to promote wider awareness of the significance of<br />

these rocky shores. These awareness and education programs should be an integral<br />

part of a management plan developed for each shore by local councils.<br />

Human use studies should be undertaken at the 3 candidate priority shores to confirm<br />

the assumption of minimal human impacts currently occurring. The study should use<br />

the same methodology that was used in the human use study of Newcastle rocky<br />

shores and the sampling should address times of expected highest usage (weekends,<br />

low tide, school holidays, spring-summer). Project Aware volunteers should be<br />

invited to participate in the human use study and trained in the techniques.<br />

8


Planning of future similar studies that require participation by community volunteers<br />

should address the inevitable likelihood of delays and the consequences of this for the<br />

scope of the project (e.g. number of shores able to be surveyed for the time and<br />

financial resources available).<br />

All local governments should be advised about the findings of this study. In particular,<br />

Lake Macquarie City Council should be advised about the importance of the Swansea<br />

Heads rocky shore; Wyong Shire Council should be advised about the importance of<br />

Norah Head and Soldiers Reef for birds and encouraged to develop community<br />

education programs to minimize human and dog disturbance of the birds, and to<br />

consider these important values in future environmental management activities in the<br />

area of these shores; Gosford City Council should be advised about the significance of<br />

the Bouddi National Park Marine Extension as a representative of assemblage<br />

diversity and the findings of the 1999 study by NSW Fisheries about the importance<br />

of Tudibaring Head.<br />

All councils should be encouraged to enforce regulations that prohibit dogs being off<br />

the leash on rocky shores.<br />

Research should be encouraged to understand the importance of the rocky shore<br />

environment (e.g. as a source of food, shelter, roosting) for birds.<br />

9


2 INTRODUCTION<br />

The intertidal rocky shores of south-eastern Australia are inhabited by a distinctive<br />

biodiversity of animals and plants, many of which have high levels of endemism<br />

(Ponder et al. 2002). Existing at the boundary of marine and terrestrial biomes, this<br />

biodiversity is subjected to extremes of the physical environment (e.g. temperature,<br />

desiccation, wave turbulence) as well the ecological interactions that commonly occur<br />

in biotic communities (e.g. competition, predation). <strong>Rocky</strong> intertidal shores are easily<br />

accessed by humans and provide an enjoyable opportunity for passive recreation and<br />

for science and environmental education.<br />

The IUCN’s Red List of Threatened Species for 2007 includes 1,530 marine species<br />

of which 80 are threatened with extinction and 31 have a high risk of extinction. A<br />

particular concern is the rate of new additions to the list of threatened marine species.<br />

Intertidal collecting of organisms occurs in Australia (Underwood 1993) and<br />

historical evidence suggests that Aboriginal Australians harvested for food (Sullivan<br />

1987, Catterall and Poiner 1987). Collecting for bait is a more common activity in<br />

contemporary Australian culture (Keough et al 1993, Kingsford et al 1991,<br />

Underwood 1993). Other forms of anthropogenic disturbance include habitat<br />

disturbance; trampling; pollution; climate change, and invasions of exotic species<br />

(Kingsford et al. 1991; Underwood, 1993). These disturbances reduce species richness<br />

and abundance of particular species, which can lead to changes in the entire intertidal<br />

biotic community (Keough and Quinn, 1998, 2000). Such impacts compromise the<br />

biodiversity values, human-use value, and ecosystem functions of intertidal rocky<br />

shores. Protected areas incorporating rocky intertidal habitat have been suggested as<br />

tools to conserve biodiversity and to ensure a viable breeding population remains to<br />

potentially replenish adjacent depleted areas (Underwood 1993).<br />

The protection of coastal tropical ecosystems and maintenance of the services<br />

provided by these ecosystems (with all the associated social and economic benefits) is<br />

a highly desirable though complex aim. Conservation and management are more<br />

likely to succeed when they are planned with reference to goals or guiding principles<br />

that are based on ecological and socio-economic understanding. Marine protected<br />

areas (MPAs) are areas of coast or seabed managed for the conservation and<br />

sustainable use of the biotic and abiotic environments. Intertidal Protected Areas<br />

(IPAs) are a type of MPA established in many parts of the world to conserve intertidal<br />

rocky shores and manage human activities in these habitats. Where establishment of<br />

an IPA (or of MPAs where the intertidal is included) includes the exclusion of<br />

extractive activities, it is usually followed by an increase in species richness and<br />

abundance of species (that had been reduced by human activities) and a return to a<br />

community resembling an undisturbed condition (Keough and Quinn, 2000).<br />

Selection of protected areas within Australia is guided by the principles of<br />

comprehensiveness, adequacy and representativeness (ANZECC 1998).<br />

Comprehensiveness aims to ensure inclusion of the full range of ecosystems present<br />

within the planning region. Adequacy aims to provide ecological viability, resilience<br />

and integrity of each ecosystem. Representativeness ensures that the areas selected<br />

10


easonably reflect the biotic diversity of the ecosystems from which they derive<br />

(http://www.environment.gov.au/parks/publications/nrs/directions/chapter2.html)<br />

The use of representativeness to select MPAs requires an ecologically meaningful<br />

target such as representing each habitat in the reserve network in at least two<br />

locations. Efficient representativeness means that the feature is sampled within the<br />

reserve network with little ‘over-achievement’ relative to the nominated target<br />

(Pressey and Taffs 2001) and allows maximum biodiversity conservation for the<br />

resources available. Thus, protection of areas representative of a specified facet of<br />

biodiversity is seen to be a particularly effective tool for systematic conservation<br />

planning in marine systems (Ray and Grassle 1991, McNeill 1994, Banks et al 2005).<br />

For selection of MPAs or IPAs to be effective in creating long-term self-sustaining<br />

ecological units and maximising the persistence of biodiversity, it should include<br />

conservation of the biodiversity hierarchy (i.e. species, assemblages, habitats,<br />

ecosystems).<br />

The aims of this project were: (i) to undertake a habitat assessment at a minimum of<br />

25 rocky shores in the Gosford, Wyong, and Lake Macquarie Local Government<br />

Areas, (ii) to undertake a detailed biodiversity assessment (intertidal organisms, birds)<br />

at 15 rocky shores in the same area, (iii) to train Project Aware volunteers in<br />

techniques of biodiversity assessment, and (iv) to engage Project Aware volunteers in<br />

the collection of data for the biodiversity assessment.<br />

3 METHODS<br />

3.1 Habitat <strong>Assessment</strong><br />

Habitat assessments were undertaken in April-May 2007 at 26 rocky shores in the<br />

study area distributed in the following manner: 10 Gosford LGA, 10 Wyong LGA, 6<br />

Lake Macquarie LGA (Table 1). The number of rocky shores surveyed reflected the<br />

relative availability of rocky shores in each LGA. The following habitat types were<br />

scored for their presence-absence at each rocky shore: platform, crevice, rock pools,<br />

boulder areas, cobble areas (Otway 1999).<br />

3.2 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Intertidal Organisms<br />

The methods used to assess the biodiversity of intertidal organisms were based on the<br />

methods used by Dr Nic Otway (NSW DPI) in previous assessments of rocky shore<br />

biodiversity in the Manning Shelf bioregion and elsewhere (Otway 1999). An<br />

electronic copy of the methods was provided by Dr Otway and discussed with him in<br />

subsequent phone conversations and personal meetings.<br />

The contract included a flow diagram (prepared by Dr Otway) showing the steps<br />

involved for a protocol to identify candidate Aquatic Reserves. It was requested that<br />

these steps be followed for this project. The first steps involved a habitat assessment<br />

of the candidate shores to quantify habitat diversity. A decision-tree follows in which<br />

11


the selection of candidate shores for detailed biodiversity assessments depends upon<br />

the existence of a correlation between number of habitats and number of species. This<br />

correlation is to be tested in the early stages of a project.<br />

Sufficient information existed from other studies undertaken at the University of<br />

Newcastle for this decision to be made without surveys: (i) data from the biodiversity<br />

surveys of Newcastle rocky shores (undertaken for Newcastle City Council) found the<br />

number of species at locations with 3 habitats varied between 64 and 87 (mean±SE =<br />

75.5 ± 11.50, n=2) and the number of species at locations with 5 habitats present<br />

varied between 73 and 103 (86.3 ± 3.70, n=7) (Gladstone 2005); (ii) data from Ms<br />

Aude Loisier’s research found, for molluscs, that there was no significant correlation<br />

between number of habitats and number of species (R=-0.10, P=0.68, n=20 locations)<br />

(Loisier 2007). There is considerable overlap in the number of species recorded at<br />

Newcastle locations with different number of habitats. Loisier’s (2007) result of no<br />

correlation between number of habitats and number of mollusc species is likely to<br />

apply to all other species on rocky shores because of published research (Gladstone<br />

2002) showing that molluscs are a very good indicator of the number of other species<br />

present on rocky shores. It was therefore recommended that the rocky shores be<br />

selected for detailed biodiversity assessments on the assumption of no correlation<br />

between numbers of habitats and species richness. However, sampling will be<br />

undertaken in each habitat present on each shore because it is highly likely that the<br />

types of species present in each habitat will differ.<br />

3.2.1 Sampling Locations<br />

Under the scenario of no correlation between number of habitats and number of<br />

species Dr Otway recommended random selection of a subset of shores with varying<br />

numbers of habitats for detailed biodiversity assessment. Given the limited range in<br />

habitat number per shore (4 or 5 habitats present), 15 rocky shores were selected for<br />

the detailed biodiversity assessment representing 13 shores with 5 habitats and 2<br />

shores with 4 habitats (Table 1, Figure 1, Appendix 8.1). This split was roughly<br />

proportional to the overall distribution of habitat numbers among the different shores<br />

(20 shores with 5 habitats, 6 shores with 4 habitats).<br />

3.2.2 Sampling Methods<br />

Sampling occurred in each habitat (from the list in section 3.1) that was present on<br />

each rocky shore. For the purposes of sampling consistency each habitat was defined<br />

in the following way: (1) crevices were any cracks equal or greater than 20 cm in<br />

depth; (2) rock pools were any pools between 30 and 100 cm in depth; (3) boulder<br />

areas consisting of rocks of maximal length between 2 and 4 m; and (4) cobble areas<br />

consisting of rocks between 30 and 100 cm maximal length. The platform habitat was<br />

further stratified into the following sub-habitats: (5.1) low shore platform at the<br />

water’s edge where high density of algal community can be observed (e.g. Ulva<br />

lactuca, Sargassum spp. and Colpomenia peregrina); (5.2) mid-shore dominated by<br />

barnacles (e.g. Tesseropora rosea) with other species being abundant (e.g. Morula<br />

marginalba); (5.3) mid-shore dominated by grazers (e.g. Cellana tramoserica,<br />

Austrocochlea porcata and Nerita atramentossa); and (5.4) high-shore which was the<br />

12


high and dry part of the rock platform dominated by Nodilittorina spp. This<br />

stratification reflected differences in the species composition of each sub-habitat. The<br />

species occurring in each sub-platform habitat were combined, for analysis, to give a<br />

total count for platform habitat species.<br />

Replicate sites of each habitat and platform sub-habitat were sampled (when<br />

available) within each shore, and sites were separated by 50-100 m. Each platform<br />

sub-habitat was sampled using four replicate 0.1 m 2 quadrats in each of 3 sites. Four<br />

replicates 50 cm lengths of crevice were sampled in 3 sites at each shore. To record<br />

the species richness of crevices, walls as well as the base of the crevice were assessed.<br />

Rock pools were surveyed in 3 sites at each shore. Four replicate rock pools were<br />

randomly chosen in each site and all species observed during a 5-minute timed search<br />

of each pool were recorded l. Two replicates of 5 m x 5 m quadrats of boulders were<br />

assessed in 2 replicate sites at each shore. All species present on the top, sides and<br />

undersides of each boulder were recorded. Cobbles were searched for 20 min at each<br />

site during which species inhabiting the top and underneath sides, as well as the<br />

sediment below each cobble, were recorded. Two replicate sites of cobbles were<br />

sampled at each location where possible (Otway 1999).<br />

Sizes of 4 species were measured with vernier callipers (to the nearest 1 mm) to<br />

provide information on the potential for each shore to support viable populations.<br />

Four species were sampled at 3 sites at each shore: Cellana tramoserica, Bembicium<br />

nanum, Nerita atramentosa and Austrocochlea porcata. One hundred individuals of<br />

each species were measured at each site, thus 400 shells where measured per site and<br />

1,200 shells per location. These species were chosen because of their regional<br />

distribution on rock platforms, their relative abundance, the importance of some<br />

species as a target for collectors (Gladstone 2005), the availability of biological<br />

information, and because of the existence of comparable data from other shores in the<br />

region (Otway 1999, Gladstone 2005). For each species the longest section of the<br />

shell base was measured.<br />

Measurements of the 4 species were done by volunteers at the same time as the<br />

biodiversity assessments were being done, following detailed instruction by Ms Aude<br />

Loisier. Volunteers were trained to identify correctly each species, to recognize the<br />

habitat of each species, to measure each species, and to record the data. The accuracy<br />

of each volunteer’s method was checked by Ms Loisier. Sixteen volunteers were<br />

trained in the methods and a total of 30 person days (by 10 individuals) were<br />

contributed by Project Aware participants. An additional 13 person days (by 6<br />

individuals) were contributed by other community volunteers.<br />

Another species, the cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera), was measured at two sites per<br />

shore. Fifty individuals were measured at each site. The internal and external<br />

diameters of the tunic at the level of the siphon were measured using vernier callipers;<br />

subsequently the mean diameter (± standard error) of each individual was calculated<br />

(Otway 1999).<br />

3.2.3 Data analysis<br />

13


The total number of species (i.e. species richness) was calculated for each shore by<br />

summing the species richness of each site. The number of rare species occurring at<br />

each shore was also determined. Rare species were those species whose occurrence<br />

(i.e. the number of shores where a species was recorded) was within the lower quartile<br />

of the frequency distribution of occurrences for all species (Gaston 1994).<br />

Species assemblages were defined by multivariate analysis using Primer 5 software<br />

(Primer-E Ltd, Plymouth; Clarke and Warwick, 2001) from a matrix of species<br />

presence-absence at each of the 15 shores. A Bray-Curtis similarity matrix was<br />

calculated from the presence-absence data to produce a non-metric multidimensional<br />

scaling (nMDS) ordination plot and a hierarchical clustering dendogram. nMDS plot<br />

and cluster dendogram were then used to group shores on the basis of similarity in<br />

their species assemblages.<br />

Reserve selection techniques were also used to evaluate the relative conservation<br />

value of each shore for intertidal organisms. A simulated reserve selection procedure<br />

was undertaken, using the conservation planning software C-Plan (New South Wales<br />

National Parks and Wildlife Service; Pressey, 1998, 1999), for the conservation goal<br />

of representing each species at least once in a reserve. Summed irreplaceability was<br />

used as a quantitative measure of each shore’s relative contribution to that goal<br />

(Ferrier et al., 2000). <strong>Shore</strong>s with a higher summed irreplaceability value have a<br />

higher conservation priority. <strong>Shore</strong>s were progressively selected in order of their<br />

summed irreplaceability by a minimum-set algorithm in C-Plan. The algorithm firstly<br />

selected the shore with the highest summed irreplaceability and re-calculated the<br />

summed irreplaceability of the remaining unselected shores. Then, from the remaining<br />

unselected shores the algorithm selected the shore with the highest summed<br />

irreplaceability and re-calculated the summed irreplaceability value of the remaining<br />

unselected shores. This iterative process continued until all the species were<br />

represented at least once in the set of selected reserves. If there was a tie between two<br />

shores, the algorithm selected the shore with the highest initial summed<br />

irreplaceability value (i.e. before selection had begun). The percentage of all species<br />

progressively accumulated in the set of selected shores was used to plot a species<br />

accumulation curve to represent the progressive achievement of the conservation goal.<br />

Total species richness and mollusc species richness were compared with records from<br />

previous studies conducted on the same section of coastline (Otway, 1999; Alexander<br />

2002; Gladstone 2002; Morton 2002; Loisier 2007) and other studies conducted in the<br />

Newcastle LGA (Otway, 1999; Gladstone 2005). However, comparisons should be<br />

done with caution as different sampling scales, efforts and methods were used by the<br />

different studies.<br />

Length-frequency distributions of the species were compared with existing published<br />

information on the size of reproductive maturity of these species (Underwood, 1974,<br />

1975). This comparison provided valuable information on the potential population<br />

viability of the 4 species at the different shores, the likely connectivity of a shore with<br />

other shores (based on the presence of small, recently settled individuals), and the<br />

potential for a shore to act as a source population (based on the presence of<br />

reproductively mature individuals) (Otway 1999).<br />

14


Gosford<br />

Brisbane water<br />

Pearl Beach<br />

Tuggerah Lake<br />

Little Beach<br />

Maitland Bay<br />

The Skillion<br />

Lake Macquarie<br />

Munmorah Lake<br />

Blue Lagoon<br />

Spoon Bay<br />

The Entrance<br />

Soldiers Reef<br />

Figure 1 <strong>Shore</strong>s at which the assessments of biodiversity of intertidal organisms and birds<br />

were undertaken.<br />

15<br />

Norah Head<br />

Newcastle<br />

Swansea Head<br />

Caves beach<br />

Catherine Hill Bay<br />

Snapper Point<br />

Leggies<br />

Dudley<br />

Tasman Sea<br />

0 5 10<br />

Kilometres<br />

N


3.3 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Birds<br />

Each rocky shore was visited twice – once during a high tide period (2 hours either side of<br />

high tide) and once during a low tide period (2 hours either side of low tide). Mostly this<br />

was achieved for each rocky shore on the same day. Because of the exceptional diversity of<br />

Norah Head and Soldiers Reef a second inspection was carried out to confirm the avian<br />

usage of those rock platforms.<br />

Each rocky shore was examined for 20 minutes using 10x42 Swarovski binoculars and,<br />

where necessary, a 30x high-definition Swarovski spotting telescope. <strong>Shore</strong>s were<br />

inspected from vantage points and by foot where appropriate. As each shore was divided<br />

into three sites for the purpose of studying the rock platform invertebrates the birds<br />

identified were also listed within each site wherever possible.<br />

4 RESULTS<br />

4.1 Habitat <strong>Assessment</strong><br />

Based on the habitat classification scheme of five habitat types (platform, crevice, rock<br />

pools, boulder areas, cobble areas) the habitat assessment revealed very little difference<br />

between rocky shores in their habitat composition: 6 shores had 4 habitats present, 20<br />

shores had 5 habitats present (Table 1). This lack of difference among shores was also<br />

apparent when the 15 shores surveyed for the detailed biodiversity assessment were<br />

assessed using the more detailed habitat classification scheme that included the platform<br />

sub-habitats (Table 2): 10 shores had 8 habitats/sub-habitats present, 5 shores had 7<br />

habitats/sub-habitats present.<br />

Although the sampling methodology required a number of replicate sites for each<br />

habitat/sub-habitat to be surveyed at each shore, the required number of sites was not<br />

always present at each shore (Table 3). For example, only 1 site containing high-shore<br />

platform was present at Spoon Bay and there was no high-shore platform at Dudley.<br />

16


Table 1 Habitats present (indicated by X) at 26 rocky shores surveyed in the Gosford, Wyong and Lake Macquarie Local Government Areas<br />

(LGAs) (* rocky shores surveyed in the biodiversity assessments for intertidal organisms and birds).<br />

Habitat<br />

LGA<br />

<strong>Shore</strong> Platform Crevice Rock pool Cobbles Boulders No.<br />

habitats<br />

Gosford Pearl Beach* X X X X 4<br />

Gosford Box Head X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Putty Beach South X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Putty Beach X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Maitland Bay* X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Little Beach* X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Copacabana X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford The Skillion* X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Spoon Bay* X X X X X 5<br />

Gosford Wamberal X X X X 4<br />

Wyong Crackneck X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Blue Lagoon* X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Toowoon Bay X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Blue Bay X X X X 4<br />

Wyong The Entrance* X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Pelican Reef X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Soldiers Reef* X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Norah Head* X X X X X 5<br />

Wyong Birdie Beach X X X X 4<br />

Wyong Snapper Point* X X X X 4<br />

Wyong Flat Rock Point X X X X X 5<br />

Lake Macquarie Catherine Hill Bay* X X X X X 5<br />

Lake Macquarie Swansea Heads* X X X X 4<br />

Lake Macquarie Dudley* X X X X X 5<br />

Lake Macquarie Caves Beach North* X X X X X 5<br />

Lake Macquarie Leggies* X X X X X 5<br />

17


Table 2 Habitats and sub-habitats present (indicated by X) at each of the 15 rocky shores at<br />

which detailed biodiversity assessments were undertaken (HS high-shore platform, MS<br />

mid-shore platform, Ba mid-shore platform dominated by barnacles, LS low-shore<br />

platform, Cr crevice, Bo boulders, Co cobbles, RP rock pools).<br />

Habitat/sub-habitat<br />

<strong>Shore</strong> HS MS Ba LS Cr Bo Co RP Total no.<br />

Pearl Beach X X X X X X X 7<br />

Maitland Bay X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Little Beach X X X X X X X X 8<br />

The Skillion X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Spoon Bay X X X X X X X X 7<br />

Blue Lagoon X X X X X X X X 8<br />

The Entrance X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Soldiers Reef X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Norah Head X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Snapper Point X X X X X X X 7<br />

Catherine Hill Bay X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Caves Beach X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Swansea Heads X X X X X X X 7<br />

Dudley X X X X X X X 7<br />

Leggies X X X X X X X X 8<br />

Table 3 Number of replicate sites sampled for each habitat/sub-habitat at each shore (see<br />

Table 2 for abbreviations of habitats/sub-habitats).<br />

Habitat/sub-habitat<br />

<strong>Shore</strong> HS MS Ba LS Cr Bo Co RP<br />

Pearl Beach 3 1 3 3 3 1 0 3<br />

Maitland Bay 2 3 3 3 3 2 2 3<br />

Little Beach 2 2 2 2 3 2 2 2<br />

The Skillion 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 1<br />

Spoon Bay 1 3 3 3 3 2 2 2<br />

Blue Lagoon 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 3<br />

The Entrance 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2<br />

Soldiers Reef 3 3 2 3 2 2 2 2<br />

Norah Head 3 2 2 3 3 2 2 2<br />

Snapper Point 3 2 3 3 2 1 0 3<br />

Catherine Hill Bay 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2<br />

Caves Beach 2 3 3 3 3 2 2 3<br />

Swansea Heads 3 3 3 3 1 0 2 3<br />

Dudley 0 3 2 3 2 2 2 1<br />

Leggies 2 3 3 3 2 2 2 3<br />

18


4.2 <strong>Biodiversity</strong> <strong>Assessment</strong>: Intertidal Organisms<br />

4.2.1 Species Richness and Rare Species<br />

A total of 230 species were recorded across the 15 rocky shores representing the following<br />

phyla/divisions: Mollusca (88 species); Rhodophyta (27 species); Phaeophyta (24 species);<br />

Arthropoda (23 species); Chlorophyta (13 species); Echinodermata (11 species); Annelida<br />

(11 species); Chordata (10 species); Cnidaria (9 species); Porifera (7 species); Bryozoa (3<br />

species); Platyhelminthes (2 species); Nemertean (1 species); Cyanobacteria (1 species).<br />

The highest number of species were recorded at Swansea Head (127 species) and the<br />

smallest numbers of species (91 species) were recorded at Norah Head and Snapper Point<br />

(Table 4). There was no difference (t=0.36, P=0.73) in the mean number of species<br />

between shores with 7 habitats/sub-habitats (mean ± standard error = 111.0 ± 7.23 species)<br />

and shores with 8 habitats/sub-habitats (108.1 ± 3.74 species).<br />

Rare species were those that were recorded at 1-2 shores and on this basis 71 species (31%<br />

total species) were classified as rare. The greatest numbers of rare species occurred at Blue<br />

Lagoon (15 species) and Swansea Heads (12 species) (Table 4). Catherine Hill Bay was the<br />

only shore where no rare species were recorded.<br />

Table 4 Number of species and rare species and summed irreplaceability (Summ IRR)<br />

value of each shore for intertidal organisms and the number of bird species recorded at each<br />

shore.<br />

Intertidal organisms Birds<br />

<strong>Shore</strong> No. species Rare species Summ IRR No. species<br />

Pearl Beach 124 8 24.2 1<br />

Maitland Bay 125 10 25.9 1<br />

Little Beach 123 9 23.1 0<br />

The Skillion 107 8 19.7 2<br />

Spoon Bay 97 8 17.9 0<br />

Blue Lagoon 102 15 26.5 7<br />

The Entrance 93 2 11.3 6<br />

Soldiers Reef 103 3 14.4 6<br />

Norah Head 91 7 17.1 10<br />

Snapper Point 91 3 14.6 4<br />

Catherine Hill Bay 121 0 19.2 6<br />

Caves Beach 108 2 14.9 1<br />

Swansea Heads 127 12 28.6 2<br />

Dudley 116 4 18.3 2<br />

Leggies 108 3 15.9 1<br />

19


4.2.2 Species Assemblages<br />

The hierarchical clustering dendrogram revealed: (i) the species assemblages across all<br />

rocky shores were more than 60% similar, and (ii) there was a general trend for shores to<br />

be more similar to one another moving from left to right on the dendrogram (Figure 2). The<br />

most dissimilar assemblage occurred at Blue Lagoon (although it was still at least 60%<br />

similar to all other shores). When grouped at a level of 75% similarity, the rocky shores<br />

formed 7 groups (Figure 3) consisting of shores with a distinctive assemblage (Blue<br />

Lagoon, Snapper Point, Norah Head, The Skillion, Swansea Heads), 2 shores sharing an<br />

assemblage (Spoon Bay, The Entrance) and a group of 8 shores sharing a similar<br />

assemblage (Maitland Bay, Soldiers Reef, Catherine Hill Bay, Little Beach, Pearl Beach,<br />

Leggies, Caves Beach, Dudley). The latter group included the most southern (Pearl Beach,<br />

Maitland Bay) and northern shores (Dudley, Leggies). Interestingly, the only shore<br />

currently protected (Maitland Bay, within the Bouddi Marine Extension) was not clearly<br />

distinguished from other shores.<br />

Similarity<br />

60<br />

70<br />

80<br />

90<br />

100<br />

BL<br />

SP<br />

NH<br />

TS<br />

SB<br />

TE<br />

Figure 2 Cluster dendrogram derived from the species presence-absence data. The shore<br />

codes are Blue lagoon (BL), Snapper Point (SP), Norah Head (NH), The Skillion (TS),<br />

Spoon Bay (SB), The Entrance (TE), Swansea Heads (SH), Soldiers Reef (SR), Maitland<br />

Bay (MB), Catherine Hill Bay (CHB), Little Beach (LB), Pearl Beach (PB), Leggies (Le),<br />

Caves Beach (CB), Dudley (Du).<br />

20<br />

SH<br />

SR<br />

MB<br />

CHB<br />

LB<br />

PB<br />

Le<br />

CB<br />

Du


SP<br />

SH<br />

PB<br />

MB<br />

Du<br />

CB<br />

Le<br />

CHB<br />

LB<br />

SR<br />

TS<br />

TE<br />

Figure 3 non-metric multidimensional scaling (MDS) ordination plot depicting groupings<br />

of rocky shores according to similarity in their species assemblages (at the level of 75%<br />

similarity). The location codes are shown in Figure 2.<br />

4.2.3 Simulated Reserve Selection<br />

<strong>Shore</strong>s varied greatly in their summed irreplaceabilty values, with Swansea Heads having<br />

the greatest value (28.5) and the Entrance the lowest (11.3) (Table 4). Thirteen shores (87%<br />

of all shores in the study area) were required to achieve the goal of representing all the<br />

species at least once in the simulated reserve network (Figure 4). However, selection of a<br />

single shore, Swansea Head, included 55.2% of all species and selection of 3 shores<br />

(Swansea Heads, Blue Lagoon, Little Beach) included 79% of all species. Selection of 6<br />

shores (40% of all shores) as a reserve network would include more than 90% of the<br />

species.<br />

21<br />

SB<br />

NH<br />

Stress: 0.11<br />

BL


Percentage of species accumulated<br />

100<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Swansea Head<br />

Blue Lagoon<br />

Little Beach<br />

Maitland Bay<br />

The Skillion<br />

Pearl Beach<br />

Dudley<br />

Spoon Bay<br />

Norah Head<br />

Leggies<br />

Soldiers Reef<br />

Caves Beach<br />

The Entrance<br />

Snapper Point<br />

Catherine Hill Bay<br />

Selected Locations<br />

Figure 4 Species accumulation curve showing the percentage of all species accumulated in<br />

shores selected during a simulated reserve selection process by a minimum-set algorithm in<br />

C-Plan to achieve the conservation goal of each species being represented at least once in a<br />

reserve.<br />

4.2.4 Benchmarking Against Other Rock Platforms<br />

The range in the total number of species per shore recorded in this study (91-127 species) is<br />

within the range of total number of species recoded at other shores between Pearl Beach<br />

(<strong>Central</strong> <strong>Coast</strong>) and Newcastle by Otway (1999) (66-144), Gladstone (2002) (70-119) and<br />

Gladstone 2005 (64-103) (Table 5). The number of species of molluscs recorded during<br />

this study varied between 28 and 52, which is comparable to other studies such as Otway<br />

(1999) (25-51); Alexander (2002) (26-46); Gladstone (2002) (18-42); Morton (2002) (14-<br />

64); Gladstone (2005) (25-44) and Loisier (2007) (32-53).<br />

22


Table 5 Comparison of total number of species and total number of mollusc species<br />

recorded in other studies on intertidal rocky platforms between Nobbys and Pearl Beach.<br />

Platform Group<br />

Otway<br />

1999<br />

Alexander<br />

2002<br />

23<br />

Gladstone<br />

2002<br />

Morton<br />

2002<br />

Gladstone<br />

2005<br />

Soldiers Baths All species 72 92<br />

Molluscs 27 34 35 44<br />

Cowrie Hole All species 86<br />

Molluscs 28<br />

Newcastle Ocean<br />

Baths All species 87<br />

Molluscs 31<br />

Bogey Hole All species 64<br />

Molluscs 25<br />

Shepherds Hill All species 103<br />

Molluscs 44<br />

Susan Gilmore All species 82 78<br />

Molluscs 26 29 37<br />

Ladies Baths All species 83<br />

Molluscs 35<br />

Merewether Shelf All species 89<br />

Molluscs 37 48<br />

Burwood Shelf All species 73<br />

Molluscs 29<br />

Dudley All species 89<br />

Molluscs 29 25 16 47<br />

Red Head All species<br />

Molluscs 19<br />

Swansea All species<br />

Molluscs 28 49<br />

Catherine Hill Bay All species<br />

Molluscs 27 17 46<br />

Ghosties All species<br />

Molluscs 30 25 45<br />

Frazer All species 80<br />

Molluscs 30 18 14 34<br />

Birdie All species 70<br />

Molluscs 25 22 32<br />

Norah Head All species 100<br />

Molluscs 32 37 21 53<br />

Entrance All species<br />

Molluscs 34 24 43<br />

Blue Bay All species<br />

Molluscs 48<br />

Toowoon All species 135<br />

Molluscs 42 44 58 49<br />

Bateau Bay All species<br />

Molluscs 28<br />

Crackneck All species 88<br />

Molluscs 46 34 53<br />

Yumbool Point All species 66<br />

Molluscs 24<br />

Loisier<br />

2007


Table 5 (cont’d) Comparison of total number of species and total number of mollusc<br />

species recorded in other studies on intertidal rocky platforms between Nobbys and Pearl<br />

Beach.<br />

Platform Group<br />

Otway<br />

1999<br />

Alexander<br />

2002<br />

24<br />

Gladstone<br />

2002<br />

Morton<br />

2002<br />

Gladstone<br />

2005<br />

Wamberal All species<br />

Molluscs 26<br />

Terrigal All species 119<br />

Molluscs 30 42 42<br />

Winney All species<br />

Molluscs 28 25<br />

Copacabana All species 144<br />

Molluscs 51 37 61 40<br />

Little Beach All species<br />

Molluscs 34 41<br />

Sunnies All species<br />

Molluscs 26<br />

Maitland Bay All species 102<br />

Molluscs 41 41 48<br />

Bullimah Beach All species<br />

Molluscs 31 42<br />

Killcare All species 95<br />

Molluscs 30 24<br />

Pearl Beach All species<br />

Molluscs 37<br />

4.2.5 Size of Species<br />

4.2.5.1 Molluscs<br />

All shores had reproductively mature individuals of Cellana tramoserica, Bembicium<br />

nanum, Nerita atramentosa and Austrocochlea porcata. All shores also contained<br />

individuals below the size of reproductively maturity (recent recruits).<br />

For C. tramoserica, different cohorts appeared at different locations indicating different<br />

recruitments over the different seasons (Figure 5). The minimum size was 2 mm (Leggies<br />

and Caves Beach) and the max size was 64 mm, observed at Maitland Bay. The largest<br />

individuals (>50 mm) were recorded at Maitland Bay, Blue Lagoon, The Entrance and<br />

Dudley. The greatest numbers of large individuals were recorded at Maitland Bay (within<br />

the Bouddi Marine Extension).<br />

Distinct cohorts were not apparent for B. nanum (Figure 6). There appeared to be no<br />

differences between shores in the numbers of large individuals although the largest size<br />

class (21-24 mm) was only recorded at Dudley. Very few small individuals were present at<br />

Snapper Point. Distinct cohorts of N. atramentosa were present at Maitland Bay and<br />

Catherine Hill Bay (Figure 7). The largest size class was present at Maitland Bay, Little<br />

Beach, Spoon Bay, Blue Lagoon and Soldiers Reef.<br />

Loisier<br />

2007


Different cohorts of A. porcata appeared to be present at Blue Lagoon, The Entrance and<br />

The Skillion (Figure 8). Individuals from the largest size class (25-28 mm) were present at<br />

Dudley, Spoon Bay, Soldiers Reef, Caves Beach and Swansea Head with the greatest<br />

numbers of large individuals occurring at Dudley. Numbers of immature individuals<br />

exceeded mature individuals at most shores except The Entrance, Catherine Hill Bay and<br />

Dudley.<br />

25


Figure 5 Size frequency distribution of Cellana tramoserica at the different locations. Size<br />

class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at sexual<br />

maturity.<br />

26


Figure 5 (cont’d) Size frequency distribution of Cellana tramoserica at the different<br />

locations. Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the<br />

size at sexual maturity.<br />

27


Figure 6 Size frequency distribution of Bembicium nanum at the different locations. Size<br />

class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at sexual<br />

maturity.<br />

28


Figure 6 (cont’d) Size frequency distribution of Bembicium nanum at the different<br />

locations. Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the<br />

size at sexual maturity.<br />

29


Figure 7 Size frequency distribution of Nerita atramentosa at the different locations. Size<br />

class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at sexual<br />

maturity.<br />

30


Figure 7 (cont’d) Size frequency distribution of Nerita atramentosa at the different<br />

locations. Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the<br />

size at sexual maturity.<br />

31


Figure 8 Size frequency distribution of Austrocochlea porcata at the different locations.<br />

Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the size at<br />

sexual maturity.<br />

32


Figure 8 (cont’d) Size frequency distribution of Austrocochlea porcata at the different<br />

locations. Size class are in mm and n=300 individuals per shore. The arrow indicates the<br />

size at sexual maturity.<br />

33


4.2.5.2 Ascidians (Pyura stolonifera)<br />

Cunjevoi were present at all shores except Snapper Point and 1 site at Spoon Bay, Caves<br />

Beach and Dudley (Appendix 8.3). All shores had small individuals with a diameter of the<br />

internal tunic smaller than 18 mm and large individuals with an external diameter greater<br />

than 67 mm. These results suggest that all locations had juveniles (new recruits) and large<br />

individuals that may be reproductively mature.<br />

The smallest internal siphon diameter was 6 mm (Leggies) and the largest internal siphon<br />

diameter was 66 mm (Leggies). The smallest external siphon diameter was 12 mm (The<br />

Entrance) and the greater external siphon diameter was 90 mm (Leggies and Swansea<br />

Heads). The smallest mean size of cunjevoi (between internal and external siphons) was<br />

27.5 ± 1.5 mm recorded at The Entrance (site 2). The largest mean size of cunjevoi was<br />

47.4 ± 2.4 mm recorded at Soldiers Reef. Overall, across both sites at each shore, The<br />

Entrance and Dudley had the smallest and greatest mean size of cunjevoi (33.4 ± 1.1 and<br />

45.7 ± 1.4 mm respectively).<br />

4.3 Birds<br />

The species of birds observed at each shore, and their abundance, are shown in Appendix<br />

8.4 and the locations of significant roosting sites are shown in Appendix 8.5. A total of 22<br />

species were recorded (Table 6). The greatest number of species were observed at Norah<br />

Head (10 species) and Blue Lagoon (7 species) (Table 4). No birds were observed at Little<br />

Beach or Spoon Bay and only 1 species was observed at each of Pearl Beach, Maitland<br />

Bay, Caves Beach, and Leggies. The most abundant species observed was the Silver Gull<br />

with as many as 700 birds recorded roosting at Norah Head. The rarest, most rock-platform<br />

dependant bird observed was a single sighting of a pair of Eastern Reef Egrets (dark phase)<br />

at Swansea Heads.<br />

Additional observations further revealed the importance of 2 shores. A further 3 species<br />

were recorded at Soldiers Reef (whimbrel, crested tern, common tern) and 2 species were<br />

recorded at Norah Head (little black cormorant, sooty oystercatcher) (Appendix 8.4).<br />

The surveys revealed that Norah Head was particularly important for birds. It was observed<br />

to be a significant high-tide roost for gulls and terns, and a significant low-tide foraging site<br />

for migratory shorebirds and a roost for gulls and terns (see comments in Appendix 8.4 and<br />

8.5).<br />

34


Table 6 Presence (1) and absence (0) of bird species at each rocky shore. The shore codes are Blue lagoon (BL), Snapper Point (SP), Norah<br />

Head (NH), The Skillion (TS), Spoon Bay (SB), The Entrance (TE), Swansea Heads (SH), Soldiers Reef (SR), Maitland Bay (MB), Catherine<br />

Hill Bay (CHB), Little Beach (LB), Pearl Beach (PB), Leggies (Le), Caves Beach (CB), Dudley (Du).<br />

<strong>Shore</strong><br />

Common name Species name PB MB LB TS SB BL TE SR NH SP CHB CB SH Du Le<br />

Chestnut Teal Anas castanea 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Little Pied Cormorant Phalacrocorax<br />

melanoleucos<br />

0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0<br />

Pied Cormorant Phalacrocorax varius 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Little Black Cormorant Phalacrocorax sulcirostris 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Great Cormorant Phalacrocorax carbo 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 0<br />

Australian Pelican Pelicanus conspicillatus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

White-faced Heron Egretta novaehollandiae 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1<br />

Eastern Reef Egret Egretta sacra 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0<br />

Whistling Kite Haliastur sphenurus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0<br />

White-bellied Sea-Eagle Haliaeetus leucogaster 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Whimbrel Numenius phaeopus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0<br />

Grey-tailed Tattler Heteroscelus brevipes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Ruddy Turnstone Arenaria interpres 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Red-necked Stint Calidris ruficollis 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Pied Oystercatcher Haematopus longirostris 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0<br />

Sooty Oystercatcher Haematopus fuliginosus 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0<br />

Pacific Golden Plover Pluvialis fulva 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Masked Lapwing Vanellus miles 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Silver Gull Larus novaehollandiae 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Crested Tern Sterna bergii 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Common Tern Sterna hirundo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Australian Raven Corvus coronoides 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0<br />

Total no. species 1 1 0 2 0 7 6 6 10 4 6 1 2 2 1<br />

35


5 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS<br />

Conservation of intertidal biodiversity<br />

The global biodiversity crisis stresses the need for samples of the variety of species and<br />

assemblages to be conserved in perpetuity so that future generations can share the same<br />

experiences as ourselves and to fulfil human society’s moral responsibilities towards<br />

biodiversity. A further rationale is that different ecosystems and habitats within ecosystems<br />

(all of which contain different species and assemblages) have different functional values<br />

and therefore conservation of representative examples of each will ensure maintenance of a<br />

suite of ecological functions and processes that will support other conservation aims (such<br />

as connectivity, resilience) and the continued provision of ecosystem goods and services.<br />

Properly managed marine protected areas (MPAs) are the most appropriate management<br />

tool to achieve this aim and they vary from large multiple-use marine parks (within which<br />

areas are zoned for different levels of use with no-take reserves buffered by a zone of less<br />

restrictive usage) to networks of smaller no-take aquatic reserves.<br />

Selection of candidate MPAs requires the clear delineation of a set of selection criteria that<br />

normally fulfil a nation’s agenda for biodiversity conservation. Selection of MPAs within<br />

Australia, for example, is guided by the criteria of comprehensiveness, adequacy and<br />

representatives (ANZECC 1998). When these criteria are combined with criteria for<br />

connectivity, population replenishment and resilience conservation planning can achieve<br />

multiple objectives for biodiversity conservation and maintenance of ecological functions.<br />

Deficiencies resulting from a history of ad hoc selection of MPAs are nowadays addressed<br />

by the use of automated and objective reserve selection software that aim to achieve the<br />

selection criteria for the minimum cost.<br />

Conservation planning to represent samples of the variety of biodiversity should ideally be<br />

based on accurate spatial data, such as databases of the distributions of species,<br />

assemblages and habitats. The results of this study provide a basis for assigning relative<br />

conservation value to shores and recommending candidates for future protection (e.g. as<br />

intertidal protected areas, aquatic reserves, fishing exclusions). The following summary of<br />

the major results of this study is relevant:<br />

• Species richness: greatest at Swansea Heads<br />

• Rare species: greatest at Blue Lagoon and Swansea Heads<br />

• Assemblage diversity: distinctive species assemblages occurred at Blue Lagoon,<br />

Swansea, Snapper Point, Norah Head, and the Skillion; at Spoon Bay and the<br />

Entrance; and across all remaining shores<br />

• Summed irreplaceability: greatest at Swansea Heads<br />

• Simulated reserve selection: the 3 most important shores were Swansea Heads, Blue<br />

Lagoon, and Little Beach<br />

• Birds: the most important shores were Norah Head and Soldiers Reef<br />

• All shores contained reproductively mature individuals and recent recruits of the 5<br />

measured species (4 molluscs and cunjevoi)<br />

• There was little differentiation among shores in their habitat composition (a<br />

difference of 4 or 5 habitats and 7 or 8 habitats/sub-habitats) with no difference in<br />

average species richness between shores with 7 and 8 habitats/sub-habitats<br />

36


Achieving the protected area selection principles of comprehensiveness and<br />

representativeness would require 14 rocky shores to be nominated as protected areas. This<br />

set of 14 shores would include the 13 shores identified by the irreplaceability analysis<br />

required to include all species as well as Snapper Point (not required by the irreplaceability<br />

analysis) because it contains a distinct species assemblage. This would ensure protection of<br />

the range of ecosystem types (assuming the rocky shores with different numbers of habitats<br />

represented different ecosystem types), and representation of all species and assemblage<br />

types. The latter would ensure that the principle of representativeness is achieved because<br />

the full range of biotic diversity of species and assemblages would be represented. It is<br />

unknown whether this number of shores would ensure adequacy because of a lack of<br />

understanding for most species of intertidal organisms about the population sizes required<br />

to ensure population viability and to maintain resilience and integrity (see next paragraph<br />

also).<br />

All shores contained new recruits and reproductively mature individuals of the four species<br />

of gastropods and all shores (except Snapper Point) also contained small and large<br />

individuals of Pyura stolonifera. The co-occurrence on shores of recent recruits and<br />

reproductively mature individuals indicates that shores may be resilient to a certain amount<br />

of disturbance (because local populations may be replenished by recruitment from other<br />

shores) and that shores can potentially contribute to the recovery and resilience of other<br />

shores.<br />

P. stolonifera is also important in terms of monitoring as it is often used for bait. However,<br />

considerable variation was noted in the measured diameters. Variations in the measured<br />

diameter of P. stolonifera may be due to the height of sampling on the platform which<br />

would induce a variation in the amount of water retained by cunjevoi at low tide. The<br />

variation in diameter sizes could also be due to the weather (temperature/humidity) on the<br />

sampling day as well as the duration of aerial exposure prior to measurement.<br />

Birds<br />

Avian diversity was generally low for most shores. However, three shores were exceptional<br />

as rock platform avian diversity hotspots: Norah Head (strong promontory), Soldiers Reef<br />

(semi-detached reef/headland), The Entrance (moderate promontory). As many as five<br />

species of migratory shorebirds were observed on these rock platforms. These localities<br />

have many commonalities to the Newcastle rock platform which also had the greatest avian<br />

diversity in the Newcastle City Council area. Those features include: prominent seaward<br />

projecting shoreline (promontory), lack of close, high backing cliffs, low wave-washed<br />

shoreface, and proximity to large coastal lake for additional foraging opportunities.<br />

For most rock platforms where birds were observed it was evident that the birds chose<br />

areas that were somewhat isolated from or not directly on the usual human access routes<br />

onto the rock platforms. This may be a geographic location or because the state of the tide<br />

precluded easy human access. Some areas such as Soldiers Reef had the greatest diversity<br />

and abundance of birds at mid to high tide times when the headland became an island and<br />

people could not gain access. However, when the tide fell and the area should have been<br />

ideal for foraging, virtually no birds were present because people could access the headland<br />

in large numbers.<br />

37


It is highly unlikely that greater avian diversity than recorded herein would be found on<br />

other rock platforms in the region with steep or abrupt shorefaces and closely backed by<br />

high cliffs. However, it is possible that there may be additional rock platforms, especially<br />

promontories with similar characteristic to Norah Head and, in particular, Soldiers Reef,<br />

that may also host greater than average avian diversity.<br />

Community participation<br />

This project’s aim to involve community volunteers in the assessment of rocky shores was<br />

achieved. A number of Project Aware and other volunteers were educated about the value<br />

of monitoring and were trained to identify the measured species, to measure accurately<br />

their length, and to record the data. Community volunteerism (e.g. in monitoring activities)<br />

is a powerful means of educating people and enhancing community support for coastal<br />

zone management (Gladstone in press) and there is government support (at all levels) for<br />

engaging the community where possible in such activities.<br />

The value of community participation can be compromised if the information collected<br />

cannot be used for monitoring or other purposes because of doubts about data quality. The<br />

accuracy of the community volunteers’ data collection was likely to be very high, given the<br />

training that occurred prior to data collection, the checking during data collection, and the<br />

presence of at least 1 expert at all times during data collection. Accuracy is also likely to be<br />

high because only a limited number of easily identified, conspicuous species were assessed.<br />

In addition, most volunteers participated in more than one monitoring session.<br />

The only constraint emerging in this study from engaging community volunteers was the<br />

unexpected delays caused in completing the field surveys for the detailed biodiversity<br />

assessment. Delays in the progress of the project arose from difficulties in scheduling<br />

volunteers, unexpected withdrawals, and the need to re-visit shores several times (after the<br />

biodiversity assessments had been completed) to finalize the monitoring of the measured<br />

species. These delays are inevitable in volunteerism when people are freely contributing<br />

their own time to an additional non-essential (i.e. non-family, non-livelihood) activity.<br />

While not negating the desirability of community participation, such logistical constraints<br />

should be addressed in the planning for similar studies in the future.<br />

Current impacts<br />

There was minimal evidence of human impacts on the intertidal organisms of the rocky<br />

shores, based on benchmarking of the numbers of species on shores with other studies and<br />

examination of the size distributions of the 4 measured species. However, it is possible that<br />

disturbance is occurring by the collection of other species (e.g. sea urchins) or habitat<br />

damage (e.g. over-turning of cobbles), or that impacts are affecting density rather than sizes<br />

of individuals. The survey methods provided data on species presence-absence not on the<br />

abundance of individual species. Disturbance of birds by people, many with off–leash dogs,<br />

was commonly observed at shores in all Local Government Areas. At low tide Soldiers<br />

Reef was accessible to people and dogs and the entire area was untenable for birds.<br />

Much of the study was done during weekdays when and in autumn-winter (for intertidal<br />

organisms) and spring (for birds). It is therefore possible that human disturbances may be<br />

greater at other times and the anecdotal observations recorded during the field work may<br />

under-estimate the amount of human disturbance occurring.<br />

38


RECOMMENDATIONS<br />

Despite the desirability of protecting 14 of the 15 rocky shores surveyed to achieve the<br />

planning principles of comprehensiveness, adequacy and representativeness, this is highly<br />

unlikely to occur. Therefore, as a basis for further discussion about the preferred number of<br />

protected areas the following sub-set of shores are recommended as priorities for<br />

protection: Swansea Heads (Lake Macquarie LGA), Blue Lagoon (Wyong LGA), and<br />

Norah Head (Wyong LGA). The protection of these 3 shores would achieve:<br />

• Representation of 74% of intertidal species and 48% of rare species<br />

• Representation of multiple examples of all habitats/sub-habitats<br />

• Representation of 3 types of species assemblage (an example of another assemblage<br />

type is currently protected within the Bouddi National Park Marine Extension)<br />

• Protection of the most important shore for birds (Norah Head) and overall for 17<br />

species (77% of total species) of birds<br />

• Protection of viable populations of the 5 measured species<br />

In addition to recommending protection for Swansea Heads, Blue Lagoon, and Norah Head<br />

it is also recommended that programs of community awareness and education be<br />

established by local councils to promote wider awareness of the significance of these rocky<br />

shores. These awareness and education programs should be an integral part of a<br />

management plan developed for each shore by local councils.<br />

Protection is recommended despite evidence of limited impacts from current human<br />

activities at any rocky shore in the study area (with the qualifications discussed above).<br />

Experiences from terrestrial ecosystems and from other marine ecosystems has shown that<br />

human uses and impacts change through time and frequently increase in response to<br />

changing patterns of population settlement, recreational activities, and commercial<br />

interests. Pre-emptive protection is also a means of maintaining the option values of<br />

ecosystems and of avoiding the high costs of future remediation that may be required to<br />

address human impacts.<br />

The recommendation for protection of Swansea Heads, Blue Lagoon, and Norah Head<br />

should be assessed in conjunction with the following:<br />

• The recommendation for protection of three shores does not include any shore<br />

within the Gosford LGA. However, the Bouddi National Park Marine Extension is<br />

wholly within the boundaries of Gosford LGA and includes a substantial stretch of<br />

coastline within the Gosford LGA in which intertidal rocky shores are protected<br />

• An earlier study by Otway (1999) recommended consideration of Tudibaring Head<br />

(at Copacabana, Gosford LGA) and Toowoon Point (Wyong LGA) as candidate<br />

aquatic reserves<br />

• Inclusion of Tudibaring Head and expansion of protection to encompass Toowoon<br />

Point and Blue Lagoon would address the priority sites of both studies<br />

Human use studies should be undertaken at the priority candidate shores (Norah Head,<br />

Swansea, Blue Lagoon) as a basis for informing future management of these shores and as<br />

a baseline to assess the effectiveness of future management. The study should use the same<br />

methodology that was used in the human use study of Newcastle rocky shores (Gladstone<br />

2006) and the sampling should address times of expected highest usage (weekends, low<br />

tide, school holidays, spring-summer). Given the high level of volunteer participation in<br />

39


this study it is further recommended that Project Aware volunteers be invited to participate<br />

in the human use study and trained in the techniques.<br />

Planning of future similar studies that require participation by community volunteers<br />

should address the inevitable likelihood of delays and the consequences of this for the<br />

scope of the project (e.g. number of shores able to be surveyed for the time and financial<br />

resources available).<br />

All local governments should be advised about the findings of this study. In particular,<br />

Lake Macquarie City Council should be advised about the importance of the Swansea<br />

Heads rocky shore; Wyong Shire Council should be advised about the importance of Norah<br />

Head and Soldiers Reef for birds and encouraged to develop community education<br />

programs to minimize human and dog disturbance of the birds, and to consider these<br />

important values in future environmental management activities in the area of these shores;<br />

Gosford City Council should be advised about the significance of the Bouddi National Park<br />

Marine Extension as a representative of assemblage diversity and the findings of the 1999<br />

study by NSW Fisheries about the importance of Tudibaring Head.<br />

All councils should be encouraged to enforce regulations that prohibit dogs being off the<br />

leash on rocky shores.<br />

Research should be encouraged to understand the importance of the rocky shore<br />

environment (e.g. as a source of food, shelter, roosting) for birds.<br />

6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS<br />

This study was funded by the Hunter <strong>Central</strong> Rivers Catchment Management Authority.<br />

The authors gratefully acknowledge the CMA’s support for this project and for our ongoing<br />

work, and in particular thank Brian Hughes for his overall project management and<br />

valuable advice and input at all stages of the project. We especially thank the Project<br />

Aware and other volunteers for their invaluable assistance in the field, and also thank<br />

Jeannie Lawson (Ocean and <strong>Coast</strong>al Care Initiative) for her role in facilitating the<br />

involvement of volunteers and her coordination of Project Aware. Thanks to CMA staff for<br />

comments on the draft report. Laboratory, library and computer facilities used as part of the<br />

intertidal biodiversity assessment were provided by the University of Newcastle (Ourimbah<br />

Campus).<br />

40


7 REFERENCES<br />

Alexander T. 2002. Assessing the contribution of the Bouddi National Park Marine<br />

Extension to the conservation of <strong>Central</strong> <strong>Coast</strong> rocky intertidal biodiversity BSc Hons<br />

thesis (School of Applied Sciences, University of Newcastle, Ourimbah Campus).<br />

ANZECC. 1998. Guidelines for Establishing the National Representative System of Marine<br />

Protected Areas. Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council,<br />

Task Force on Marine Protected Areas. Environment Australia, Canberra.<br />

Banks SA, Skilleter GA, Possingham HP. 2005. Intertidal habitat conservation: identifying<br />

conservation targets in the absence of detailed biological information. Aquatic<br />

Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Research 15: 271-288.<br />

Catterall CP, Poiner IR. 1987. The potential impact of human gathering on shellfish<br />

populations, with reference to some NE Australian intertidal flats. Oikos 50: 114-122.<br />

Clarke KR, Warwick RM. 2001. Change in marine communities: an approach to statistical<br />

analysis and interpretation, 2 nd ed. Plymouth Marine Laboratory: Plymouth.<br />

Ferrier S, Pressey RL, Barrett TW. 2000. A new predictor of the irreplaceability of areas<br />

for achieving a conservation goal, its application to real-world planning, and a research<br />

agenda for further refinement. Biological Conservation 93: 303-325.<br />

Gaston KJ. 1994. Rarity. Chapman and Hall, Melbourne.<br />

Gladstone W. 2002. The potential value of indicator groups in the selection of marine<br />

reserves. Biological Conservation 104: 211-220.<br />

Gladstone W. 2005. <strong>Biodiversity</strong> Values of <strong>Coast</strong>al Rock Platforms in Newcastle (Report<br />

to Newcastle City Council).<br />

Gladstone W. 2006. Human Uses of <strong>Coast</strong>al Rock Platforms in Newcastle (Report to<br />

Newcastle City Council).<br />

Gladstone W. In press. Management and conservation of tropical ecosystem interactions IN<br />

Ecological Interactions Between Tropical <strong>Coast</strong>al Ecosystems (ed I Nagelkerken).<br />

Springer, London.<br />

Keough MJ, Quinn GP. 1998. Effects of periodic disturbances from trampling on rocky<br />

intertidal algal beds. Ecological Applications 8: 141-161.<br />

Keough MJ, Quinn GP. 2000. Legislative vs. practical protection of an intertidal shoreline<br />

in southeastern Australia. Ecological Applications 10: 871-881.<br />

Keough MJ, Quinn GP, King A. 1993. Correlations between human collecting and<br />

intertidal mollusc populations on rocky shores. Conservation Biology 7: 378-390.<br />

41


Kingsford MJ, Underwood AJ, Kennelly SJ. 1991. Humans as predators on rocky reefs in<br />

New South Wales, Australia. Marine Ecology Progress Series 72: 1-14.<br />

Loisier A. 2007. A test of the potential effectiveness of rapid biodiversity assessment and<br />

environmental diversity for the selection of intertidal protected areas (Master of Science<br />

thesis, University of Newcastle).<br />

M c Neil SE. 1994. The selection and design of marine protected areas: Australia as a case<br />

study. <strong>Biodiversity</strong> and Conservation 3: 586-605.<br />

Morton J. 2002. A test of the potential use of shore type as a surrogate for biological<br />

diversity on coastal intertidal rocky shores. BSc Hons thesis (School of Applied Sciences,<br />

University of Newcastle, Ourimbah Campus).<br />

Otway N. 1999. Identification of candidate sites for declaration as aquatic reserves for the<br />

conservation of rocky intertidal communities in the Hawkesbury Shelf and Batemans Shelf<br />

bioregions. NSW Fisheries Final Report Series No.28.<br />

Ponder W, Hutchings P, Chapman R. 2002. Overview of the Conservation of Australian<br />

Marine Invertebrates. Environment Australia, Canberra.<br />

Pressey RL. 1998. Algorithms, politics and timber: an example of the role of science in a<br />

public, political negotiation process over new conservation areas in production forests. In:<br />

Wills R, Hobbs R (eds.) Ecology for Everyone: Communicating Ecology to Scientists, the<br />

Public and the Politicians. Surrey Beatty and Sons, Sydney.<br />

Pressey RL. 1999. Applications of irreplaceability analysis to planning and management<br />

problems. Parks 9: 42-51.<br />

Pressey RL, Taffs KH. 2001. Sampling of land types by protected areas: three measures of<br />

effectiveness applied to western New South Wales. Biological Conservation 101: 105-117.<br />

Ray GC, Grassle JF. 1991. Marine biological diversity: a scientific program to help<br />

conserve marine biological diversity is urgently required. Bioscience 41: 453-457.<br />

Sullivan ME. 1987. A recent prehistoric exploitation of edible mussel in Aboriginal shell<br />

middens in southern NSW. Archaeology in Oceania 22: 107-111.<br />

Underwood AJ. 1974. The reproductive cycles and geographical distribution of some<br />

common eastern Australian prosobranchs (Mollusca: Gastropoda). Australian Journal of<br />

Marine and Freshwater Research 25:63-88.<br />

Underwood AJ. 1975. Comparative studies on the biology of Nerita atramentosa (Reeve),<br />

Bembicium nanum (Lamarck) and Cellana tramoserica (Sowerby) (Gastropoda:<br />

Prosobranchia) in S.E. Australia. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology<br />

18:153-172.<br />

Underwood AJ. 1993. Exploitation of species on the rocky coast of New South Wales<br />

(Australia) and options for its management. Ocean and <strong>Coast</strong>al Management 20: 41-62.<br />

42


8 APPENDICES<br />

43


8.1 Study Locations<br />

Appendix 8.1.1: The 3 study sites at Pearl Beach<br />

Maitlad Bay<br />

3<br />

Appendix 8.1.2: The 3 study sites at Maitland Bay<br />

2<br />

2<br />

3<br />

1<br />

44<br />

1<br />

Pearl Beach


3<br />

2<br />

Appendix 8.1.3: The 3 study sites at Little Beach<br />

Appendix 8.1.4: The 3 study sites at The Skillion<br />

1<br />

1<br />

3 2<br />

45<br />

Little Beach<br />

The Skillion


Appendix 8.1.5: The 3 study sites at Spoon Bay<br />

Blue Lagoon<br />

3<br />

Appendix 8.1.6: The 3 study sites at Blue Lagoon<br />

3<br />

2<br />

2<br />

1<br />

1<br />

46<br />

Spoon Bay


Appendix 8.1.7: The 3 study sites at The Entrance<br />

Soldiers Reef<br />

Appendix 8.1.8: The 3 study sites at Soldiers Reef<br />

3<br />

1<br />

3<br />

2<br />

47<br />

1<br />

2<br />

The Entrance


Norah Head<br />

1<br />

Appendix 8.1.9: The 3 study sites at Norah Head<br />

3<br />

Appendix 8.1.10: The 3 study sites at Snapper Point<br />

2<br />

2<br />

1<br />

3<br />

48<br />

Snapper Point


1<br />

Catherine Hill Bay<br />

Appendix 8.1.11: The 3 study sites of Catherine Hill Bay<br />

Appendix 8.1.12: The 3 study sites at Caves Beach<br />

2<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

3<br />

Caves Beach<br />

49


Swansea Head<br />

Appendix 8.1.13: The 3 study sites at Swansea Head<br />

Appendix 8.1.14: The 3 study sites at Dudley<br />

3<br />

1<br />

2<br />

2<br />

50<br />

1<br />

Dudley<br />

3


Appendix 8.1.15: The 3 study sites at Leggies<br />

3<br />

1<br />

2<br />

51<br />

Leggies


8.2 Species of Intertidal Organisms Recorded<br />

Appendix 8.2.1: Pearl Beach species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Cardiata excavata<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Cellana tramoserica<br />

Clypidina rugosa<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Conus alpustre<br />

CNIDARIA Cronia aurantiaca<br />

Codium fragile Cronia margiticola<br />

Codium lucasii Anthothoe albocincta Dicathais orbita<br />

Codium spongiosum Aulactinia veratra Electroma georgiana<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Cnidopus verater Hinea brasiliana<br />

Enteromorpha sp Corynactis australis Ischnochiton australis<br />

Ulva lactuca Holopneustes pycnotilus Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Oulactis muscosa Lasaea australis<br />

Mitrella pulla<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Mitrella semicovexa<br />

PLATYHELMINTHES Morula marginalba<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Nerita atramentosa<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Notoplana australis Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Cystophora sp Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Dictyota dichotoma ANNELIDA Notoacmea flammea<br />

Dilophus marginatus Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Ecklonia radiata Diopatra dentata Octopus tetricus<br />

Hormosira banksii Filograna implexa Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Leathesia difformis Galeoleria caespitosa Patella chapmanii<br />

Lobophora variegata Idanthyrsus pennatus Patella peronii<br />

Sargassum sp Serpula sp Patelloida alticostata<br />

Sargassum vestitum Spirorbid sp Patelloida insignis<br />

Zonaria angustata Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Zonaria sp Plaxiphora albida<br />

ARTHROPODA Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Scutus antipodes<br />

RHODOPHYTA (red algae) Amphipods sp Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Austromegabalanus nigrescens Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Amphiroa anceps Chamaesipho tasmania Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Asparagopsis armata Chtamalus antennatus Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Champia sp Epopella simplex Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Corallina officinalis Ligia australiensis Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Delisea pulchra Plagusia chabrus Turbo imperialis<br />

Gelidium pusillum Plagusia glabra Turbo undulatus<br />

Griffithsia ovalis Tesseropora rosea<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Tetraclitella purpurascens ECHINODERMATA<br />

Laurencia botryoides Centrostephanus rodgersii<br />

Porphyra columbina MOLLUSCA Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Porphyra lucasii Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Ralfsia sp Acanthochitona sp Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Agnewia tritoniformis Patiriella calcar<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Astralium tentoriiforme Patiriella exigua<br />

Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Bedeva hanleyi CHORDATA<br />

PORIFERA Bembicium auratum Herdmania momus<br />

Bembicium nanum Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Cabestana spengleri Pyura gibbosa gibbosa<br />

Dendrilla rosea Callochiton crocinus Pyura stolonifera<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Cantharidella picturata Tetractenos hamiltoni<br />

52


Appendix 8.2.2: Maitland Bay species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA CNIDARIA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Actinia tenebrosa Elysia australis<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Haliotis rubra<br />

Aulactinia veratra Ischnochiton australis<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (green algae) Cnidopus verater Ischnochiton cariosus<br />

Holopneustes pycnotilus Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Codium fragile Oulactis muscosa Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Enteromorpha sp Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Mitrella glabra<br />

Ulva lactuca Morula marginalba<br />

Nerita atramentosa<br />

ANNELIDA Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Nodilittorina pyramidali<br />

Diopatra dentata Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Eunice sp Notoacmea flammea<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Filograna implexa Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Galeoleria caespitosa Octopus tetricus<br />

Cystophora sp Idanthyrsus pennatus Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Serpula sp Patella chapmanii<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Spirorbid sp Patella peronii<br />

Ecklonia radiata Patelloida alticostata<br />

Hormosira banksii Patelloida insignis<br />

Leathesia difformis ARTHROPODA Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Lobophora variegata Plaxiphora albida<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Amphipods sp Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Austromegabalanus nigrescens Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Sargassum sp Catomerus polymerus Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Sargassum vestitum Chamaesipho tasmania Siphonaria diemenensi<br />

Scitosiphon lomentaria Chtamalus antennatus Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Zonaria angustata Epopella simplex Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Zonaria sp Leptograpsus variegatus Sypharochiton pelliserp<br />

Ovalipes australiensis Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Plagusia chabrus Turbo imperialis<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Plagusia glabra Turbo torquatus<br />

Tesseropora rosea Turbo undulatus<br />

Amphiroa anceps Tetraclitella purpurascens Umbraculum sinicum<br />

Asparagopsis armata<br />

Corallina officinalis<br />

Gelidium australe MOLLUSCA ECHINODERMATA<br />

Gelidium pusillum<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Amblychilepas nigrita Centrostephanus rodge<br />

Laurencia filiformis Astralium tentoriiforme Coscinasterias muricat<br />

Porphyra columbina Austrocochlea concamerata Heliocidaris erythrogra<br />

Ralfsia sp Austrocochlea porcata Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Bembicium auratum Ophiopeza cylindrica<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Bembicium nanum Ophiura kinbergi<br />

Bittium granarium Patiriella calcar<br />

Cabestana spengleri Patiriella exigua<br />

PORIFERA Cantharidella picturata<br />

Cellana tramoserica<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Ceratosoma brevicaudatum CHORDATA<br />

Dendrilla rosea Clypidina rugosa Didemnum mosleyi<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Cronia margiticola Herdmania momus<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Cryptoplax mystica Pyura gibbosa gibbosa<br />

Dicathais orbita Pyura stolonifera<br />

Electroma georgiana Tetractenos hamiltoni<br />

53


Appendix 8.2.3: Little Beach species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Ralfsia verrucosa Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Bembicium auratum<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Bembicium nanum<br />

PORIFERA Cabestana spengleri<br />

Caulerpa filiformis Callochiton crocinus<br />

Caulerpa geminata Chondrilla australiensis Cantharidella picturata<br />

Codium fragile Dendrilla rosea Cellana tramoserica<br />

Codium lucasii Sponge2, orange, encrusting smooth Clypidina rugosa<br />

Enteromorpha sp Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Dicathais orbita<br />

Ulva lactuca Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Ischnochiton australis<br />

Spongia sp Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Morula marginalba<br />

CNIDARIA Nerita atramentosa<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Actinia tenebrosa Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Anthothoe albocincta Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Cystophora sp Aulactinia veratra Notoacmea flammea<br />

Cystophora subfarcinata Cnidopus verater Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Holopneustes pycnotilus Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Oulactis muscosa Patella chapmanii<br />

Dilophus marginatus Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Patella peronii<br />

Ecklonia radiata Phlyctenanthus australis Patelloida alticostata<br />

Hormosira banksii Patelloida insignis<br />

Leathesia difformis Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Lobophora variegata ANNELIDA Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Padina crassa Scutus antipodes<br />

Phyllospora comosa Diopatra dentata Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Filograna implexa Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Galeoleria caespitosa Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Sargassum sp Idanthyrsus pennatus Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Sargassum vestitum Spirorbid sp Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Zonaria angustata Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Zonaria sp Turbo imperialis<br />

ARTHROPODA Turbo torquatus<br />

Turbo undulatus<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Alope orientalis<br />

Amphipods sp<br />

Amphiroa anceps Austromegabalanus nigrescens ECHINODERMATA<br />

Ceramium sp Catomerus polymerus<br />

Corallina officinalis Chamaesipho tasmania Centrostephanus rodgersii<br />

Delisea pulchra Cyclograpsus audouinii Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Gelidium australe Epopella simplex Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Gelidium pusillum Leptograpsus variegatus Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

gracilaria halogena Pagurus sinuatus Ophionereis schayeri<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Plagusia chabrus Patiriella calcar<br />

Laurencia botryoides Plagusia glabra Patiriella exigua<br />

Laurentia elata Tesseropora rosea<br />

Plocomium cartilagineum Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Plocomium dilatum CHORDATA<br />

Porphyra columbina<br />

Porphyra lucasii Gymnothorax prasinus<br />

Pterocladia capillacea Herdmania momus<br />

Ralfsia sp Pyura stolonifera<br />

54


Appendix 8.2.4: The Skillion species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA CNIDARIA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Actinia tenebrosa Notoacmea alta<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Notoacmea flammea<br />

Aulactinia veratra Notoacmea petterdi<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Cnidopus verater Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Oulactis muscosa Patella peronii<br />

Cladophora rugulosa Patelloida alticostata<br />

Codium lucasii Patelloida insignis<br />

Enteromorpha sp ANNELIDA Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Ulva lactuca Pinctada fucata<br />

Filograna implexa Pinctada maculata<br />

Galeoleria caespitosa Plaxiphora albida<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Idanthyrsus pennatus Polinices conicus<br />

Odontosyllis sp Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Spirorbid sp Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Scutus antipodes<br />

Cystophora sp Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Dictyota ciliolata ARTHROPODA Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Dilophus marginatus Amphipods sp Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Ecklonia radiata Austromegabalanus nigrescens Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Ectocarpus sp Catomerus polymerus Turbo torquatus<br />

Hormosira banksii Chamaesipho tasmania Turbo undulatus<br />

Lobophora variegata Chtamalus antennatus<br />

Phyllospora comosa Cyclograpsus audouinii<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Epopella simplex BRYOZOA<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Leptograpsus variegatus<br />

Sargassum sp Ozius truncatus Bryozoans, white, encrusting<br />

Sargassum vestitum Plagusia glabra Mucropetraliella ellerii<br />

Zonaria angustata Tesseropora rosea<br />

Zonaria sp Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

ECHINODERMATA<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) MOLLUSCA Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Amphiroa anceps Austrocochlea porcata Ophionereis schayeri<br />

Corallina officinalis Bembicium auratum Patiriella calcar<br />

Gelidium australe Bembicium nanum Patiriella exigua<br />

Gelidium pusillum Cabestana spengleri Patiriella gunnii<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Callistochiton antiquus<br />

Laurencia botryoides Cantharidella picturata<br />

Porphyra columbina Cellana tramoserica CHORDATA<br />

Ralfsia sp Clypidina rugosa<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Cronia aurantiaca Pyura stolonifera<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Dicathais orbita<br />

Electroma georgiana<br />

Ischnochiton australis<br />

PORIFERA Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Lasaea australis<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Mitrella pulla<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Morula marginalba<br />

Nerita atramentosa<br />

Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

55


Appendix 8.2.5: Spoon Bay species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA ANNELIDA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Galeoleria caespitosa Phasianotrochus eximinus<br />

Idanthyrsus pennatus Plaxiphora albida<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Spirorbid sp Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Cladophora rugulosa Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Codium spongiosum ARTHROPODA Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Ulva lactuca Alope orientalis Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Amphipods sp Tellina botanica<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Austromegabalanus nigrescens Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Balanus variegatus Turbo undulatus<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Catomerus polymerus<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Cystophora sp Cyclograpsus audouinii BRYOZOA<br />

Cystophora subfarcinata Heliograpsus haswellianus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Leptograpsus variegatus Bryozoans, white, encrusting<br />

Ecklonia radiata Paragrapsus sp<br />

Hormosira banksii Plagusia chabrus<br />

Padina crassa Tesseropora rosea ECHINODERMATA<br />

Sargassum sp Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Sargassum vestitum Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Zonaria angustata Ophiura kinbergi<br />

Zonaria sp MOLLUSCA Patiriella calcar<br />

Amblychilepas nigrita<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Austrocochlea porcata CHORDATA<br />

Bembicium auratum<br />

Corallina officinalis Bembicium nanum Bovichtus angustifons<br />

Gelidium pusillum Cabestana spengleri Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Callochiton crocinus Pyura stolonifera<br />

Laurencia botryoides Cantharidella picturata<br />

Laurencia filiformis Cellana tramoserica<br />

Ralfsia sp Clypidina rugosa<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Dicathais orbita<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Ischnochiton lineolatus<br />

Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

PORIFERA Mitrella pulla<br />

Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Morula marginalba<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Nerita atramentosa<br />

Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

CNIDARIA Notoacmea alta<br />

Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Actinia tenebrosa Octopus tetricus<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Aulactinia veratra Patella chapmanii<br />

Holopneustes pycnotilus Patella peronii<br />

Oulactis muscosa Patelloida alticostata<br />

Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Patelloida insignis<br />

Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Patelloida mimula<br />

56


Appendix 8.2.6: Blue Lagoon species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PLATYHELMINTHES MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Callioplana marginata Notoacmea flammea<br />

Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Onitochiton quercinus<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) ANNELIDA Patella chapmanii<br />

Patella peronii<br />

Caulerpa brachypus Diopatra dentata Patelloida alticostata<br />

Chaetomorpha aerea Galeoleria caespitosa Patelloida insignis<br />

Cladophora rugulosa Hydroides elegans Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Codium fragile Odontosyllis sp Phasianotrochus eximi<br />

Codium spongiosum Idanthyrsus pennatus Pinctada albida<br />

Ulva lactuca Spirorbid sp Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Scutus antipodes<br />

Siphonaria denticulata<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) ARTHROPODA Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Alope orientalis Sypharochiton pelliserp<br />

Dictyopteris muelleri Amphipods sp Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Ecklonia radiata Chamaesipho tasmania Tugali parmophoidea<br />

Ectocarpus sp Chtamalus antennatus Turbo torquatus<br />

Hormosira banksii Cyclograpsus audouinii Turbo undulatus<br />

Padina fraseri Heliograpsus haswellianus<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Leptograpsus variegatus<br />

Sargassum vestitum Ligia australiensis ECHINODERMATA<br />

Zonaria angustata Pilumnopeus serratifrons<br />

Zonaria sp Tesseropora rosea Coscinasterias muricat<br />

Tetraclitella purpurascens Heliocidaris erythrogra<br />

Patiriella calcar<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Patiriella exigua<br />

MOLLUSCA<br />

Corallina officinalis Aplysia dactylomela<br />

Gelidium pusillum Astralium tentoriiforme CHORDATA<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Austrocochlea concamerata<br />

Martensia pavonia Austrocochlea porcata Bovichtus angustifons<br />

Polisiphonia sp Bembicium auratum Pyura sacciformis<br />

Porphyra lucasii Bembicium nanum Pyura stolonifera<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Cabestana spengleri<br />

Callochiton crocinus<br />

Cantharidella picturata<br />

PORIFERA Cellana tramoserica<br />

Clypidina rugosa<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting Dicathais orbita<br />

Songe3, purple, encrusting, undulating Euchelus aspersus<br />

Granata imbricata<br />

Ischnochiton australis<br />

CNIDARIA Ischnochiton cariosus<br />

Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Actinia tenebrosa Marikellia solida<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Mitrella pulla<br />

Aulactinia veratra Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Oulactis muscosa Morula marginalba<br />

Balanophyllia bairdiana Nerita atramentosa<br />

Corynactis australis Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Notoacmea alta<br />

57


Appendix 8.2.7: The Entrance species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA ANNELIDA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Diopatra dentata Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Galeoleria caespitosa Scutus antipodes<br />

Idanthyrsus pennatus Siphonaria denticulata<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Serpula sp Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Spirorbid sp Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Codium lucasii Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Codium spongiosum Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Enteromorpha linza ARTHROPODA Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Enteromorpha sp Turbo undulatus<br />

Ulva lactuca Amphipods sp<br />

Austromegabalanus nigrescens<br />

Catomerus polymerus BRYOZOA<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Heliograpsus haswellianus Bryozoans, white, encrusting<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Leptograpsus variegatus<br />

Cystophora sp Plagusia chabrus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Plagusia glabra ECHINODERMATA<br />

Dilophus marginatus Tesseropora rosea<br />

Ecklonia radiata Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Hormosira banksii Patiriella calcar<br />

Padina crassa MOLLUSCA Patiriella exigua<br />

Padina fraseri<br />

Sargassum sp Acanthochitona sp<br />

Sargassum vestitum Agnewia tritoniformis CHORDATA<br />

Zonaria angustata Aplysia gigantea<br />

Zonaria sp Austrocochlea porcata Pyura stolonifera<br />

Bembicium auratum<br />

Bembicium nanum<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Cabestana spengleri<br />

Callochiton crocinus<br />

Corallina officinalis Cantharidella picturata<br />

Gelidium pusillum Cellana tramoserica<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Clypidina rugosa<br />

Laurencia botryoides Dicathais orbita<br />

Porphyra lucasii Ischnochiton cariosus<br />

Ralfsia sp Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Morula marginalba<br />

Nerita atramentosa<br />

Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

PORIFERA Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting smooth Notoacmea alta<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Octopus tetricus<br />

Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Patella chapmanii<br />

CNIDARIA Patella peronii<br />

Patelloida alticostata<br />

Actinia tenebrosa Patelloida insignis<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Aulactinia veratra Plaxiphora albida<br />

Oulactis muscosa Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

58


Appendix 8.2.8: Soldiers Reef species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA CNIDARIA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Aulactinia veratra Patella chapmanii<br />

Cnidopus verater Patella peronii<br />

Holopneustes pycnotilus Patelloida alticostata<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Oulactis muscosa Patelloida insignis<br />

Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Enteromorpha sp ANNELIDA Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Ulva lactuca Scutus antipodes<br />

Diopatra dentata Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Galeoleria caespitosa Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Idanthyrsus pennatus Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Spirorbid sp Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Sypharochiton pelliserpen<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Cystophora sp ARTHROPODA Turbo torquatus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Turbo undulatus<br />

Ecklonia radiata Amphipods sp Umbraculum sinicum<br />

Hormosira banksii Austromegabalanus nigrescens<br />

Padina crassa Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Padina fraseri Chtamalus antennatus ECHINODERMATA<br />

Phyllospora comosa Leptograpsus variegatus<br />

Sargassum sp Plagusia glabra Centrostephanus rodgers<br />

Sargassum vestitum Tesseropora rosea Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Zonaria angustata Tetraclitella purpurascens Heliocidaris erythrogramm<br />

Zonaria sp Ophiura kinbergi<br />

Patiriella calcar<br />

MOLLUSCA Patiriella exigua<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae)<br />

Amblychilepas nigrita<br />

Corallina officinalis Aplysia dactylomela CHORDATA<br />

Delisea pulchra Astralium tentoriiforme<br />

Gelidium pusillum Austrocochlea porcata Herdmania momus<br />

Griffithsia ovalis Bembicium auratum Pyura stolonifera<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Bembicium nanum<br />

Laurencia botryoides Cabestana spengleri<br />

Laurentia brongniartil Callochiton crocinus<br />

Martensia pavonia Cantharidella picturata<br />

Porphyra columbina Cellana tramoserica<br />

Porphyra lucasii Clypidina rugosa<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Cyprae vitellus<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Dicathais orbita<br />

Ischnochiton australis<br />

PORIFERA Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Mitrella pulla<br />

Dendrilla rosea Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Morula marginalba<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Nerita atramentosa<br />

Spongia sp Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

CNIDARIA Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Actinia tenebrosa Octopus tetricus<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Onitochiton quercinus<br />

59


Appendix 8.2.9: Norah Head species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA ARTHROPODA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Austromegabalanus nigrescens Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Catomerus polymerus Turbo torquatus<br />

Chamaesipho tasmania Turbo undulatus<br />

CHLOROPHYTA Cyclograpsus audouinii<br />

Epopella simplex<br />

Ulva lactuca Leptograpsus variegatus BRYOZOA<br />

Plagusia chabrus<br />

Plagusia glabra Mucropetraliella ellerii<br />

PHAEOPHYTA Tesseropora rosea<br />

Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa ECHINODERMATA<br />

Dilophus marginatus<br />

Ecklonia radiata MOLLUSCA Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Ectocarpus sp Ophiura kinbergi<br />

Hormosira banksii Amblychilepas nigrita Patiriella calcar<br />

Padina fraseri Austrocochlea concamerata Patiriella exigua<br />

Phyllospora comosa Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Sargassum vestitum Bembicium auratum<br />

Zonaria angustata Bembicium nanum CHORDATA<br />

Cabestana spengleri<br />

Callochiton crocinus Pyura sacciformis<br />

RHODOPHYTA Cantharidella picturata Pyura stolonifera<br />

Cellana tramoserica<br />

Chondria armata Clypidina rugosa<br />

Corallina officinalis Dicathais orbita<br />

Gelidium australe Granata imbricata<br />

Gelidium glandulaefolium Ischnochiton australis<br />

Gelidium pusillum Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Ralfsia sp Morula marginalba<br />

Nerita atramentosa<br />

Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

PORIFERA Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Notoacmea alta<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Notoacmea flammea<br />

Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Onitochiton quercinus<br />

CNIDARIA Patella chapmanii<br />

Patella peronii<br />

Anthothoe albocincta Patelloida alticostata<br />

Aulactinia veratra Patelloida insignis<br />

Corynactis australis Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Oulactis muscosa Phyllocoma speciosa<br />

Pinctada fucata<br />

Pinctada maculata<br />

ANNELIDA Plaxiphora albida<br />

Diopatra dentata Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Galeoleria caespitosa Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Hydroides elegans Scutus antipodes<br />

Idanthyrsus pennatus Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Odontosyllis sp Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Sabellastarte sp Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Spirorbid sp Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

60


Appendix 8.2.10: Snapper Point species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Chondrilla australiensis Scutus antipodes<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Spongia sp Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Caulerpa geminata CNIDARIA Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Chaetomorpha aerea Turbo undulatus<br />

Codium lucasii Actinia tenebrosa<br />

Codium spongiosum Anthothoe albocincta<br />

Enteromorpha sp Aulactinia veratra ECHINODERMATA<br />

Microdictyon umbilicatum Cnidopus verater<br />

Ulva lactuca Oulactis muscosa Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Patiriella calcar<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) ANNELIDA<br />

CHORDATA<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Filograna implexa<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Galeoleria caespitosa Pyura gibbosa gibbosa<br />

Cystophora sp<br />

Dictyopteris muelleri<br />

Pyura stolonifera<br />

Dictyota ciliolata ARTHROPODA<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Amphipods sp<br />

Dilophus marginatus Austromegabalanus nigrescens<br />

Ecklonia radiata Catomerus polymerus<br />

Ectocarpus sp Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Hormosira banksii Plagusia chabrus<br />

Lobophora variegata Plagusia glabra<br />

Padina fraseri Tesseropora rosea<br />

Phyllospora comosa<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium<br />

Sargassum linearifolium<br />

Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Sargassum sp<br />

Sargassum vestitum<br />

MOLLUSCA<br />

Zonaria angustata Acanthochitona sp<br />

Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Bembicium nanum<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Callochiton crocinus<br />

Cellana tramoserica<br />

Amphiroa anceps Clypidina rugosa<br />

Asparagopsis armata Cronia aurantiaca<br />

Corallina officinalis Dicathais orbita<br />

Gelidium australe Morula marginalba<br />

Gelidium pusillum Nerita atramentosa<br />

gracilaria halogena Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Griffithsia ovalis Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Laurencia botryoides Notoacmea flammea<br />

Laurentia elata Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Porphyra columbina Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Porphyra lucasii Patella peronii<br />

Ralfsia sp Patelloida insignis<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Phyllocoma speciosa<br />

Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

61


Appendix 8.2.11: Catherine Hill Bay species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Sponge3, purple, encrusting, ondulating Cellana tramoserica<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Clypidina rugosa<br />

Spongia sp Dicathais orbita<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Haliotis rubra<br />

Ischnochiton australis<br />

Caulerpa geminata CNIDARIA Ischnochiton cariosus<br />

Codium lucasii Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Enteromorpha sp Actinia tenebrosa Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Ulva lactuca Anthothoe albocincta Mitrella pulla<br />

Aulactinia veratra Morula marginalba<br />

Holopneustes pycnotilus Nerita atramentosa<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Oulactis muscosa Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Phlyctenanthus australis Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Octopus tetricus<br />

Cystophora sp ANNELIDA Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Patella chapmanii<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Diopatra dentata Patella peronii<br />

Hormosira banksii Filograna implexa Patelloida alticostata<br />

Leathesia difformis Galeoleria caespitosa Patelloida insignis<br />

Lobophora variegata Idanthyrsus pennatus Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Padina crassa Serpula sp Pinctada maculata<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Spirorbid sp Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Sargassum sp Scutus antipodes<br />

Sargassum vestitum ARTHROPODA Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Scitosiphon lomentaria Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Zonaria angustata Amphipods sp Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Zonaria sp Austromegabalanus nigrescens Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Chamaesipho tasmania Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Epopella simplex Trichomya hirsuta<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Leptograpsus variegatus Turbo imperialis<br />

Plagusia chabrus Turbo torquatus<br />

Amphiroa anceps Plagusia glabra Turbo undulatus<br />

Asparagopsis armata Tesseropora rosea Umbraculum sinicum<br />

Corallina officinalis Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Gelidium australe<br />

Gelidium pusillum ECHINODERMATA<br />

Griffithsia ovalis MOLLUSCA<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Centrostephanus rodgersii<br />

Laurencia botryoides Amblychilepas nigrita Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Laurentia elata Aplysia dactylomela Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Porphyra lucasii Aplysia gigantea Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Ralfsia sp Astralium tentoriiforme Patiriella calcar<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Austrocochlea concamerata Patiriella exigua<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Bedeva hanleyi<br />

Bembicium auratum CHORDATA<br />

PORIFERA Bembicium nanum<br />

Cabestana spengleri Herdmania momus<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Callochiton crocinus Pyura stolonifera<br />

Dendrilla rosea Cantharidella picturata<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Cardiata excavata<br />

62


Appendix 8.2.12: Caves Beach species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Notoacmea petterdi<br />

CNIDARIA Octopus tetricus<br />

Caulerpa filiformis Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Codium fragile Actinia tenebrosa Patella chapmanii<br />

Codium lucasii Anthothoe albocincta Patella peronii<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Aulactinia veratra Patelloida alticostata<br />

Enteromorpha sp Cnidopus verater Patelloida insignis<br />

Ulva lactuca Oulactis muscosa Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Phyllocoma speciosa<br />

Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) ANNELIDA Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Scutus antipodes<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Diopatra dentata Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Filograna implexa Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Galeoleria caespitosa Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Cystophora sp Idanthyrsus pennatus Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Dictyopteris muelleri Spirorbid sp Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Turbo torquatus<br />

Ecklonia radiata ARTHROPODA Turbo undulatus<br />

Hormosira banksii<br />

Leathesia difformis Amphipods sp<br />

Lobophora variegata Austromegabalanus nigrescens ECHINODERMATA<br />

Padina crassa Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Phyllospora comosa Chtamalus antennatus Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Epopella simplex Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Sargassum sp Plagusia glabra Patiriella calcar<br />

Sargassum vestitum Tesseropora rosea<br />

Zonaria angustata Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Zonaria sp CHORDATA<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red Algae) MOLLUSCA Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

Pyura stolonifera<br />

Amphiroa anceps Acanthochitona sp Tetractenos hamiltoni<br />

Asparagopsis armata Amblychilepas nigrita<br />

Corallina officinalis Aplysia gigantea<br />

Delisea pulchra Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Gelidium pusillum Bembicium nanum<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Cabestana spengleri<br />

Laurencia botryoides Callochiton crocinus<br />

Plocomium cartilagineum Cantharidella picturata<br />

Porphyra columbina Cellana tramoserica<br />

Porphyra lucasii Clypidina rugosa<br />

Ralfsia sp Dicathais orbita<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Haliotis rubra<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Ischnochiton australis<br />

Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

PORIFERA Mitrella pulla<br />

Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Dendrilla rosea Morula marginalba<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Nerita atramentosa<br />

63


Appendix 8.2.13: Swansea Head species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Sponge2, orange, encrusting smooth Cronia margiticola<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Cryptoplax mystica<br />

Spongia sp Dicathais orbita<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Electroma georgiana<br />

Eurytrochus strangei<br />

Caulerpa filiformis CNIDARIA Granata imbricata<br />

Codium fragile Haliotis rubra<br />

Codium lucasii Actinia tenebrosa Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Codium spongiosum Anthothoe albocincta Ischnochiton lineolatus<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Aulactinia veratra Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Enteromorpha linza Cnidopus verater Mitrella australis<br />

Enteromorpha sp Corynactis australis Mitrella pulla<br />

Ulva lactuca Oulactis muscosa Mitrella semicovexa<br />

Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Morula marginalba<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) ANNELIDA Neodoris chrysoderma<br />

Nerita atramentosa<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Diopatra dentata Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Filograna implexa Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Galeoleria caespitosa Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Cystophora sp Idanthyrsus pennatus Notoacmea flammea<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Odontosyllis sp Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Spirorbid sp Patella chapmanii<br />

Dilophus marginatus Patella peronii<br />

Ecklonia radiata Patelloida alticostata<br />

Hormosira banksii ARTHROPODA Patelloida insignis<br />

Lobophora variegata Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Padina crassa Alope orientalis Plaxiphora albida<br />

Padina fraseri Austromegabalanus nigrescens Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Phyllospora comosa Chtamalus antennatus Scutus antipodes<br />

Sargassum sp Dittosa undecimspinosa Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Sargassum vestitum Heliograpsus haswellianus Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Scitosiphon lomentaria Leptograpsus variegatus Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Zonaria angustata Ovalipes australiensis Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Zonaria sp Plagusia chabrus Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Plagusia glabra Turbo torquatus<br />

Tesseropora rosea Turbo undulatus<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

BRYOZOA<br />

Amphiroa anceps Bryozoans, white, encrusting<br />

Asparagopsis armata MOLLUSCA<br />

Corallina officinalis Acanthochitona sp<br />

Gelidium pusillum Amblychilepas nigrita ECHINODERMATA<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Astralium tentoriiforme Centrostephanus rodgersii<br />

Laurencia botryoides Austrocochlea porcata Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Porphyra columbina Bedeva hanleyi Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Porphyra lucasii Bembicium nanum Patiriella calcar<br />

Ralfsia sp Berthellina citrina Patiriella exigua<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Bittium granarium<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Brachidontes rostratus CHORDATA<br />

Cabestana spengleri Gymnothorax prasinus<br />

PORIFERA Callochiton crocinus Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

Cantharidella picturata Pyura stolonifera<br />

Chondrilla australiensis Cellana tramoserica Tetractenos hamiltoni<br />

Dendrilla rosea Clypidina rugosa<br />

64


Appendix 8.2.14: Dudley species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA PORIFERA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Cellana tramoserica<br />

Sponge3, purple, encrusting, undulating Clypidina rugosa<br />

Sponge4, yellow, encrusting, ruffled Cyprae xanthodon<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Spongia sp Dicathais orbita<br />

Electroma georgiana<br />

Caulerpa filiformis Ischnochiton australis<br />

Codium fragile CNIDARIA Ischnochiton cariosus<br />

Codium lucasii Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Enteromorpha intestinalis Actinia tenebrosa Mitrella pulla<br />

Enteromorpha sp Anthothoe albocincta Mitrella tayloriana<br />

Ulva lactuca Aulactinia veratra Morula marginalba<br />

Cnidopus verater Nerita atramentosa<br />

Holopneustes pycnotilus Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Oulactis muscosa Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Notoacmea flammea<br />

Chordoria cladosiphon Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa ANNELIDA Patella peronii<br />

Cystophora sp Patelloida insignis<br />

Dictyota ciliolata Diopatra dentata Phasianotrochus eximinus<br />

Dictyota dichotoma Filograna implexa Plaxiphora albida<br />

Dilophus marginatus Galeoleria caespitosa Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Ecklonia radiata Idanthyrsus pennatus Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Hormosira banksii Spirorbid sp Scutus antipodes<br />

Leathesia difformis Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Lobophora variegata Siphonaria diemenensis<br />

Padina crassa ARTHROPODA Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Amphipods sp Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Sargassum sp Austromegabalanus nigrescens Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Sargassum vestitum Chamaesipho tasmania Turbo imperialis<br />

Zonaria angustata Chtamalus antennatus Turbo undulatus<br />

Zonaria sp Dittosa undecimspinosa<br />

Heliograpsus haswellianus<br />

Leptograpsus variegatus BRYOZOA<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) Plagusia chabrus<br />

Plagusia glabra Bryozoans, orange, encrusting<br />

Amphiroa anceps Tesseropora rosea<br />

Asparagopsis armata Tetraclitella purpurascens<br />

Corallina officinalis ECHINODERMATA<br />

Gelidium pusillum<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus MOLLUSCA Coscinasterias muricata<br />

Laurencia botryoides Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Porphyra columbina Acanthochitona sp Patiriella calcar<br />

Porphyra lucasii Amblychilepas javanicensis Patiriella exigua<br />

Ralfsia sp orange Austrocochlea concamerata<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa brown Austrocochlea porcata<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Bedeva hanleyi CHORDATA<br />

Bembicium auratum<br />

Bembicium nanum Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

PORIFERA Cabestana spengleri Pyura stolonifera<br />

Callochiton crocinus<br />

Sponge1, black, encrusting, smooth Cantharidella picturata<br />

Dendrilla rosea Cardiata excavata<br />

65


Appendix 8.2.15: Leggies species list<br />

CYANOBACTERIA CNIDARIA MOLLUSCA<br />

Symploca sp Actinia tenebrosa Morula marginalba<br />

Aulactinia veratra Nerita atramentosa<br />

Cnidopus verater Nodilittorina acutispara<br />

CHLOROPHYTA (Green algae) Holopneustes pycnotilus Nodilittorina pyramidalis<br />

Oulactis muscosa Nodilittorina unifasciata<br />

Caulerpa filiformis Phlyctenactis tuberculosa Notoacmea flammea<br />

Codium fragile Phlyctenanthus australis Notoacmea petterdi<br />

Codium lucasii Octopus tetricus<br />

Codium spongiosum Onitochiton quercinus<br />

Enteromorpha sp ANNELIDA Patella peronii<br />

Ulva lactuca Patelloida insignis<br />

Diopatra dentata Patelloida latistrigata<br />

Filograna implexa Phasianotrochus eximinus<br />

PHAEOPHYTA (Brown algae) Galeoleria caespitosa Rhyssoplax jugosa<br />

Idanthyrsus pennatus Saccostrea glomerata<br />

Colpomenia peregrina Spirorbid sp Scutus antipodes<br />

Colpomenia sinuosa Siphonaria denticulata<br />

Cystophora sp Siphonaria funiculata<br />

Dilophus marginatus ARTHROPODA Siphonaria zelandica<br />

Ecklonia radiata Sypharochiton pelliserpentis<br />

Hormosira banksii Amphipods sp Trichomya hirsuta<br />

Leathesia difformis Catomerus polymerus Turbo undulatus<br />

Lobophora variegata Chamaesipho tasmania<br />

Padina crassa Chtamalus antennatus<br />

Padina fraseri Dittosa undecimspinosa ECHINODERMATA<br />

Sargassum lacerifolium Epopella simplex<br />

Sargassum linearifolium Leptograpsus variegatus Centrostephanus rodgersii<br />

Sargassum sp Plagusia glabra Heliocidaris erythrogramma<br />

Sargassum vestitum Tesseropora rosea Heliocidaris tuberculata<br />

Zonaria angustata tetraclitella purpurascens Patiriella calcar<br />

Zonaria sp Uca vomeris Patiriella exigua<br />

RHODOPHYTA (Red algae) MOLLUSCA CHORDATA<br />

Amphiroa anceps Amblychilepas nigrita Botrylloides leachi<br />

Corallina officinalis Astralium tentoriiforme Lepidoblennius haplodactylus<br />

Gelidium pusillum Austrocochlea porcata Pyura stolonifera<br />

Hildenbrandia prototypus Bembicium auratum Tetractenos hamiltoni<br />

Laurentia elata Bembicium nanum<br />

Porphyra columbina Cabestana spengleri<br />

Porphyra lucasii Callochiton crocinus<br />

Ralfsia sp Cantharidella picturata<br />

Ralfsia verrucosa Cardiata excavata<br />

Unknow red algae1, brown, smooth Cellana tramoserica<br />

Clypidina rugosa<br />

Conus alpustre<br />

PORIFERA Dicathais orbita<br />

Ischnochiton australis<br />

Dendrilla rosea Ischnochiton elongatus<br />

Sponge2, orange, encrusting, smooth Ischnochtion versicolor<br />

Mitrella pulla<br />

Mitrella tayloriana<br />

66


8.3 Cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera)<br />

Appendix 8.3.1: Measurements of cunjevoi (Pyura stolonifera). Range sizes (mm), average inner and outer diameters (mm) of the 50 cunjevoi<br />

were measured at each site. The mean and standard error were measured for each location at each site; also the total mean diameter ± standard<br />

error was given for each location.<br />

Location Range Inner Ø Range Outer Ø<br />

1st site 2nd site Total<br />

MEAN ±<br />

Standard<br />

Error<br />

Range Inner Ø Range Outer Ø<br />

67<br />

MEAN ±<br />

Standard<br />

Error<br />

Range<br />

MEAN ±<br />

Standard<br />

Error<br />

Pearl Beach 12;39 28.4 ± 1.5 22;66 42.7 ± 1.4 35.5 ± 1.3 12;42 27.9 ± 1.2 22;67 45.8 ± 1.7 37.2 ± 1.4 16;67 36.4 ± 0.9<br />

Maitland Bay 12;41 34.1 ± 1.4 22;75 53.8 ± 2.1 44.2 ± 1.7 12;42 30.9 ± 1.5 24;88 51.6 ± 2.1 41.2 ± 1.7 12;88 42.7 ± 1.2<br />

Little Beach 12;44 30.1 ± 1.1 25;72 50.4 ± 1.4 40.3 ± 1.2 11;49 33.3 ± 1.1 24;78 55.7 ± 1.6 44.4 ± 1.3 11;78 42.4 ± 0.9<br />

The Skillion 15;34 26.3 ± 1.0 25;67 43.7 ± 1.3 35.0 ± 1.1 14;40 25.4 ± 0.9 20;65 39.4 ± 1.3 32.4 ± 1.0 14;67 33.7 ± 0.7<br />

Spoon Bay 12;48 28.8 ± 1.5 22;71 45.7 ± 2.1 37.2 ± 1.8 _ _ _ _ _ 12;71 37.2 ± 0.7<br />

Bateau Bay 9;45 26.0 ± 1.2 20;71 48.1 ± 2.2 37.1 ± 1.8 11;53 26.4 ± 1.5 19;81 43.7 ± 2.2 35.1 ± 1.8 9;81 36.1 ± 1.2<br />

The Entrance 15;60 30.4 ± 1.1 24;70 48.2 ± 1.6 39.3 ± 1.3 7;42 20.9 ± 1.3 12;61 34 ± 1.7 27.5 ± 1.5 7;70 33.4 ± 1.1<br />

Soldiers Reef 16;62 33.8 ± 1.9 26;71 50.8 ± 2.4 42.3 ± 2.2 14;62 37.7 ± 2.0 24;82 57.1 ± 2.8 47.4 ± 2.4 14;82 44.9 ± 1.6<br />

Norah Head 12;46 28.8 ± 1.1 30;78 50.2 ± 1.6 39.5 ± 1.3 14;46 31.8 ± 1.1 34;71 54.5 ± 1.5 43.2 ± 1.2 12;78 41.3 ± 0.9<br />

Snapper Point _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _<br />

Catherine Hill Bay 12;47 29.7 ± 1.3 25;74 47.3 ± 1.7 38.4 ± 1.5 15;47 31.7 ± 1.1 27;74 50.8 ± 1.5 40.9 ± 1.3 12;74 39.7 ± 1.0<br />

Caves Beach 10;46 31.9 ± 1.4 17;73 49.7 ± 2.1 41.1 ± 1.7 _ _ _ _ _ 10;73 41.1 ± 1.7<br />

Swansea Heads 11;52 27 ± 1.6 18;86 43.1 ± 2.2 35.7 ± 1.9 14;62 34.2 ± 1.8 26;90 55.0 ± 2.7 45.1 ± 2.3 11;90 40.4 ± 1.5<br />

Dudley 18;59 35.4 ± 1.2 30;82 55.9 ± 1.7 45.7 ± 1.4 _ _ _ _ _ 18;82 45.7 ± 1.4<br />

Leggies 6;66 31.1 ± 1.4 20;90 50.1 ± 1.9 40.6 ± 1.7 12;44 31.0 ± 1.0 23;69 50.2 ± 1.4 40.6 ± 1.2 6;90 40.6 ± 1.0


8.4 Bird Survey Results<br />

Tuesday 9 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide (7.01am) Low tide (1.01pm)<br />

Swansea 7.10‐7.30am 1.20‐1.40pm<br />

Site 1 No birds 2 Eastern Reef Egrets Foraging 100m north of Area 1<br />

Site 2 No birds<br />

No birds Family groups & a dog all over Areas<br />

1, 2 & 3<br />

Site 3 7 Whimbrel foraging & resting No birds<br />

Caves Beach 7.50‐8.10am 12.20‐12.40pm<br />

Site 1 No birds 8.05am Wave washed No birds<br />

Site 2 1 Great Cormorant Wave washed No birds<br />

Site 3 No birds Wave washed No birds<br />

68<br />

Several family groups in Areas 1 & 2<br />

Catherine Hill<br />

Bay 8.55‐9.15am 11.35‐11.45am<br />

Site 1 No birds 1 Pied Oystercatcher Foraging<br />

Site 2 1 White‐faced Heron Foraging<br />

1 Whimbrel Resting & foraging<br />

1 Great Cormorant Resting<br />

1 Little Pied Cormorant Foraging in rock pools<br />

Site 3 1 Whistling Kite (flying) No birds 2 fishermen on shoreline<br />

Coal loader jetty 9.15am 11.45am<br />

4 Great Cormorants 4 Great Cormorants<br />

2 Little Black Cormorants 3 Little Black Cormorants<br />

2 Pied Cormorants


Wednesday High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

10‐Oct High tide 7.33am Low tide 1.40pm<br />

Snapper Point 7.30‐7.50am 2.10‐2.30pm<br />

Site 1 No birds 1 fisherman<br />

1 Little Pied Cormorant Resting and preening<br />

5 Silver Gulls Watching a fisherman<br />

Site 2 1 Sooty Oystercatcher Foraging No birds<br />

Site 3 1 Sooty Oystercatcher Same bird as in Area 2 1 White‐faced Heron Foraging<br />

Norah Head 8.25‐8.45am 1.40‐2.00pm<br />

Site 1 1 Great Cormorant, 4 Pied<br />

Cormorant<br />

Site 2 1 Common Tern, 22 Crested<br />

Tern, 300 Silver Gull<br />

Significant high‐tide roost for<br />

gulls and terns. Gulls arriviving<br />

and departing constantly<br />

69<br />

8 Great Cormorant, 5 Pied<br />

Cormorant, 2 Australian<br />

Pelican,<br />

5 Pacific Golden Plover,<br />

12 Ruddy Turnstone, 12<br />

Red‐necked Stint, 2 Grey‐<br />

tailed Tattler, 24 Crested<br />

Tern, 700 Silver Gull<br />

Site 3 No birds No birds 1 fisherman<br />

Soldiers Point 8.55‐9.15am 12.05‐12.25pm<br />

Site 1 1 Great Cormorant, 6 Red‐<br />

necked Stints, 1 Ruddy<br />

Turnstone<br />

<strong>Shore</strong>birds foraging No birds<br />

Site 2 35 Red‐necked Stint, 5<br />

Ruddy Turnstone, 5 Pacific<br />

Golden Plover<br />

Site 3 1 Silver Gull, 1 Little Black<br />

Cormorant<br />

Most birds roosting, a few<br />

foraging. Significant neap high‐<br />

tide roost (at spring high tides<br />

the point would be completely<br />

inundated).<br />

1 Silver Gull<br />

No birds<br />

Significant low‐tide foraging site for<br />

migratory shorebirds and roost for<br />

gulls and terns<br />

At low tide Soldiers point is<br />

accessible to people and dogs and<br />

the entire area was untenable for<br />

birds


Thursday 11 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide 8.05am Low tide 2.17pm<br />

Pearl Beach 8.35‐8.55am 12.30‐12.50pm<br />

Site 1 No birds 3 fishermen, 2 walkers, 2 dogs 1 White‐faced Heron<br />

70<br />

Foraging. 13 people walking on<br />

platform<br />

Site 2 No birds 1 White‐faced Heron<br />

Same birds as in Area 1. 1 fisherman,<br />

1 walker<br />

Site 3 No birds No birds 1 walker<br />

Maitland Bay See Wed 17 Oct below 2.00‐2.20pm<br />

Site 1 No birds No people<br />

Site 2 No birds No people<br />

Site 3 No birds No people<br />

Monday 15 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide 10.14am Low tide 4.51pm<br />

The Entrance 8.10‐8.30am 5.10‐5.30pm<br />

Site 1 No birds 1 Pacific Golden Plover Foraging<br />

Site 2 60 Red‐necked Stint Roosting<br />

2 Chestnut Teal<br />

Flew into rockpool between Areas 2<br />

10 Pacific Golden Plover<br />

5 Ruddy Turnstone<br />

Roosting<br />

Roosting<br />

& 3 briefly before disturbed by kids.<br />

5 people and 1 fisherman<br />

2 Silver Gull Roosting<br />

Site 3 42 Silver Gull Roosting 1 Ruddy Turnstone Foraging<br />

1 Masked Lapwing Landed on platform but foraged in<br />

freshwater stream above rocks


Monday 15 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide 10.14am Low tide 4.51pm<br />

Bateau Bay 8.50‐9.10am 4.30‐4.50pm<br />

Site 1 No birds<br />

Mostly awash<br />

2 Great Cormorants Resting<br />

2 Little Black Cormorant Resting<br />

1 Australian Raven Foraging<br />

Site 2 2 Great Cormorant 1 White‐faced Heron Foraging<br />

2 Little Black Cormorant 1 Sooty Oystercatcher Flew in disturbed by my presence<br />

and flew on to Area 3<br />

Site 3 No birds<br />

1 Sooty Oystercatcher From Area 2. Foraging<br />

1 Little Pied Cormorant Resting<br />

1 Silver Gull Resting<br />

Spoon Bay 9.20‐9.40am 3.45‐4.05pm<br />

Site 1 No birds Several beach walkers No birds<br />

Site 2 No birds Several beach walkers No birds 2 people<br />

Site 3 No birds Several beach walkers No birds 1 person<br />

The Skillion 10.10‐10.30am 2.50‐3.10pm<br />

Site 1 1 Little Pied Cormorant No birds 1 fisherman & 2 walkers<br />

3 Sooty Oystercatcher Foraging and resting<br />

Site 2 No birds Mostly awash, 1 fisherman 3 Sooty Oystercatcher Foraging<br />

Site 3 No birds No birds Family group of 13 & 1 fisherman<br />

between Area 1 & 2 at 3.20pm<br />

Little Beach 11.30‐11.50am see Wed 17 Oct below<br />

Site 1 No birds No people<br />

Site 2 No birds No people<br />

Site 3 No birds No people<br />

71


Wednesday 17 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide 11.36am Low tide 6.31pm<br />

Maitland Bay 1.10‐1.30pm see Thurs 11 Oct above<br />

Sites<br />

1,2,3<br />

No birds Most of platform awash. A<br />

pair of Sea‐Eagles overflying<br />

the area ‐ one carrying food<br />

into valley behind beach.<br />

Little Beach see Mon 15 Oct above 4.05‐4.25pm<br />

Site 1 No birds<br />

Site 2 No birds<br />

Site 3 No birds<br />

Additional 2nd<br />

inspection of<br />

Norah Head<br />

10.30‐10.50am<br />

Site 1 3 Little Black Cormorant Roosting<br />

Site 2 1 Little Black Cormorant<br />

50 Crested Tern<br />

2 Common Tern<br />

29 Silver Gull<br />

All roosting<br />

Site 3 2 Sooty Oystercatcher Foraging<br />

72


Wednesday 17 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

Additional 2nd<br />

inspection of<br />

Soldiers Reef<br />

High tide 11.36am Low tide 6.31pm<br />

11.10‐11.30am<br />

Site 1<br />

& 3 20 Red‐necked Stint<br />

19 Ruddy Turnstone<br />

5 Pacific Golden Plover<br />

1 Whimbrel<br />

3 Silver Gull<br />

16 Crested Tern<br />

1 Common Tern<br />

1 Great Cormorant<br />

Site 2 1 Little Black Cormorant<br />

Most of the area was awash<br />

except for a zone between<br />

Area 1 & 3 where the birds<br />

were foraging on the wave<br />

washed sand and roosting on<br />

adjacent emergent rock<br />

platform.<br />

Thursday 18 October High tide Observations Comments Low Tide Observations Comments<br />

High tide 12.29am Low tide 7.35pm<br />

Leggies (Little Redhead Pt) 12.10‐12.30pm 4.20‐4.40pm<br />

Site 1 No birds Occasional surfer walking No birds<br />

Site 2 No birds rocks<br />

No birds<br />

Site 3 No birds<br />

1 White‐faced Heron<br />

1.25‐1.45pm 5.10‐5.30pm<br />

Dudley Site 1 No birds 2 Sooty Oystercatchers & 1 No birds<br />

Site 2<br />

Site 3<br />

No birds<br />

No birds<br />

Australian Raven on rock<br />

platforms to immediate north<br />

of Areas 1‐3<br />

No birds<br />

No birds<br />

73<br />

1 walker in area. 1 Sooty<br />

Oystercatcher on rock platform to<br />

north of Areas 1‐3.


8.5 Significant Roost and Foraging Sites for Birds<br />

Appendix 8.5.1: Significant roost and foraging sites for birds at The Entrance<br />

Norah Head<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

1<br />

2<br />

Gull<br />

3<br />

Appendix 8.5.2: Gull and Tern roost and foraging site for shorebirds at Norah Head<br />

74<br />

<strong>Shore</strong>bird<br />

The Entrance<br />

Gull & Tern roost and<br />

foraging site for shorebirds


Soldiers Reef<br />

<strong>Shore</strong>bird foraging<br />

3<br />

Appendix 8.5.3: Significant roost and foraging sites for birds at Soldiers Reef<br />

75<br />

1<br />

2<br />

<strong>Shore</strong>bird roost

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!