11.07.2015 Views

Annual Report 2006/07 - ETH - North-South Centre North-South ...

Annual Report 2006/07 - ETH - North-South Centre North-South ...

Annual Report 2006/07 - ETH - North-South Centre North-South ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

An introduction to ZILThe ZIL project framework links the programme components to the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)same as in the preceding phase, with three to four independentpeer reviews of each project, and a final recommendation ofthe Selection Committee.* The ultimate decision on project selectionwas with the ZIL Board. The composition of the SelectionCommittee has remained the same since the beginning of thelivestock systems research programme in 2002. This has provedvery valuable, because of the positive group dynamics andthe institutional memory in this body . Beyond the quality ofscience, main criteria of the Selection Committee were developmentrelevance and programme coherence.Five projects were submitted on the first call, four in the livestocksystems programme, and one independent project. InMarch <strong>2006</strong>, three of these projects were accepted with minorrevisions, one was returned for re-submission, and one wasrequested to re-orient its focus. The ZIL Board followed theserecommendations with the exception of the last one, and suggestedthat the applicants get in touch with the SelectionCommittee to discuss the re-orientation in more detail. Thisinteraction finally proved very constructive and yielded a fullyconvincing proposal in the second call which could evenmobilise additional resources for a complementary projectcomponent.Six projects were submitted at the second call, four in the livestocksystems programme – among them the resubmissionand the re-oriented proposal of the first call – and two independentproposals. In October <strong>2006</strong>, the Selection Committeerecommended five proposals for funding – partially with minorrevisions – and rejected one project. The ZIL Board unanimouslyfollowed these recommendations. However, due to the limitationof remaining funds, all accepted projects of the second* The Selection Committee is composed of Klaus Apel (IPW, former member of the <strong>ETH</strong> research commission), Barbara Becker (ex officio), Giancarlo de Picciotto(Agronomist, Latin America Section, SDC), Mathias Egloff (ZIL Programme Facilitator, ex officio), Felix Escher (Chair, ZIL President), Irene Hoffmann (Chief, FAO AnimalProduction Service), Rolf Kappel (NADEL, former member of the <strong>ETH</strong> research commission), and Fritz Schneider (Livestock expert, Director of Research, SHL, Zollikofen).5

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!