aluminum melting and metal quality processing ... - FPGA-FAQ
aluminum melting and metal quality processing ... - FPGA-FAQ
aluminum melting and metal quality processing ... - FPGA-FAQ
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ALUMINUM MELTING AND METAL QUALITY PROCESSING TECHNOLOGY<br />
FOR CONTINUOUS HIGH QUALITY CASTINGS<br />
Copyright©2001 American Foundry Society<br />
ABSTRACT<br />
Scott Kennedy<br />
Inductotherm International<br />
Aluminum Group<br />
The <strong>aluminum</strong> industry has moved more towards complete integrated melt <strong>and</strong> <strong>metal</strong> treatment systems as a total process in<br />
order to provide continuous <strong>quality</strong> <strong>metal</strong> for casting operations. In years past new <strong>aluminum</strong> casting plant layouts were<br />
approached by purchasing a number of system requirements such as <strong>melting</strong>, degassing, filtering <strong>and</strong> <strong>metal</strong> transfer from a<br />
number of suppliers. Today high technology equipment OEM’s are offering complete turnkey systems for individually<br />
engineered casting needs. This in turn takes a burden off the foundry engineers to spend more time in careful selection of the<br />
critical casting equipment to achieve high <strong>quality</strong> <strong>aluminum</strong> parts. Eliminating <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong> issues from the equation allows<br />
for a smooth start-up transition with a reduced number of equipment suppliers. This paper will address the <strong>melting</strong> system<br />
concept approach allowing for careful consideration for new plant casting facilities.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
The world market growth in <strong>aluminum</strong> castings has increased dramatically over the past thirty years. In conjunction with this<br />
growth increased emphasis on casting <strong>quality</strong> <strong>and</strong> energy conservation has been key issues. The world energy problems have<br />
resulted in increased costs <strong>and</strong> reduced availability of resources. Aluminum <strong>processing</strong> equipment that reduces energy<br />
consumption per ton cast is of prime importance to all foundries in today’s competitive market. Environmental m<strong>and</strong>ates<br />
also are an important factor on more efficient methods of <strong>aluminum</strong> <strong>melting</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>processing</strong>. The dem<strong>and</strong> to provide high<br />
<strong>quality</strong> castings has caused <strong>aluminum</strong> foundries to look at more integrated <strong>melting</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>metal</strong> treatment process systems to<br />
provide continuous controlled <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong> output. This paper will address the <strong>melting</strong> equipment available in the world<br />
market with inclusion of in line <strong>metal</strong> treatment systems.<br />
ADDRESSING METAL QUALITY ISSUES<br />
As the <strong>aluminum</strong> foundry industry grows it is necessary to return to the basic roots. Achieving high <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong> is not a<br />
new art it is returning to the basics of controlling the process. Pick up a Kaiser Casting book from 1945 <strong>and</strong> review <strong>metal</strong><br />
treatment practices <strong>and</strong> they differ very slightly from today. So why do so many foundries constantly deal with <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong><br />
problems, the answer goes back to the written word of our foundry pioneers. We have become sloppy <strong>and</strong> careless on how<br />
the <strong>metal</strong> process is treated. The new foundry personnel are not being taught the basics of good foundry practices.<br />
Management must pass on valuable training on how to h<strong>and</strong>le the fastest growing casting <strong>metal</strong> in the world today.<br />
MELTING EQUIPMENT<br />
Melting equipment offered today must meet a number of important criteria including energy efficiency, <strong>metal</strong> loss, <strong>metal</strong><br />
<strong>quality</strong> <strong>and</strong> of course be worker friendly. Many of the furnace concepts being offered are not new like many of us are led to<br />
believe. Furnace designs such as stack charge melters <strong>and</strong> furnaces with regenerative burners have been around for over<br />
thirty years. So we ask ourselves why did we ignore them, but the answer is quite simple we are driven by profit not energy<br />
conservation. The idea of us paying three times the cost for a furnace to use reduced energy ten or twenty years ago was not<br />
a practical investment. The European <strong>and</strong> Asian market was forced into energy conservation more than a decade before<br />
North <strong>and</strong> South American. Since the energy <strong>and</strong> environmental situation will only worsen worldwide the future selection of<br />
furnace equipment will be more costly up front, but return on investment due to energy costs <strong>and</strong> environmental restrictions<br />
will be more attractive. We therefore need to underst<strong>and</strong> the equipment available to the <strong>aluminum</strong> casting market in order to<br />
make wise investment decisions for future casting growth.
The <strong>melting</strong> equipment available in today’s market includes crucibles, reverbs, dry hearths, induction, <strong>and</strong> stack melters.<br />
Each of these categories has a number of different approaches offered.<br />
CRUCIBLE FURNACE<br />
Many small jobbing foundries that melt a number of different alloys use these furnaces. The crucible furnaces are also<br />
popular in holding applications such as at die cast stations <strong>and</strong> used in many foundries as <strong>metal</strong> transfer ladles. The crucible<br />
concept was the backbone to the start of the foundry industry. They are the least expensive in purchase price of the <strong>melting</strong><br />
furnaces for the small volume user. These furnaces are available in fossil fuel, electric resistance <strong>and</strong> induction.<br />
GAS FIRED CRUCIBLES<br />
The furnace consists of an outer steel shell with 6” to 9” of insulation with a silicon carbide crucible set in the center.<br />
Today’s gas crucible furnaces are normally heated with compact package burners or high velocity burners. Unfortunately,<br />
they are the least efficient method of <strong>melting</strong> due to the compact combustion space <strong>and</strong> price restrictions on recuperative<br />
burners. The use of proportioning burners with high turn down <strong>and</strong> good insulation can improve efficiency from the old<br />
premix approach.<br />
1000# Gas Crucible Furnace<br />
1000# GAS CRUCIBLE FURNACE<br />
ELECTRIC RESISTANCE CRUCIBLES<br />
The electric resistance crucible furnace mostly commonly heated with <strong>metal</strong>lic elements or silicon carbide. These furnaces<br />
are well insulated with ceramic fiber <strong>and</strong> are available in a number of configurations such as stationary, tilt <strong>and</strong> bail transfer.<br />
The life of the heating elements are depending on the gauge of the element <strong>and</strong> operating temperature. The heavier gauge<br />
elements have demonstrated two to three times the life of the thin gauge element in <strong>melting</strong> applications. These furnaces are<br />
also commonly used in holding applications at the casting machine.
150kw/2000# Electric Crucible Furnace Line<br />
DIRECT HEAT CRUCIBLE FURNACE<br />
This is a new design concept, which transfers the electrical energy directly into the crucible resulting in the highest efficiency<br />
available in crucible <strong>melting</strong>. Since the majority of electrical energy (upwards of 90%) goes into the crucible all other<br />
furnace components stay cool. Due to low furnace losses air-cooling is all that is required for the induction coil. Quick<br />
<strong>melting</strong> is achieved without the temperature over shoot commonly found in crucible furnaces.<br />
Direct Heat Crucible Furnace
DRY HEARTH FURNACES<br />
The dry hearth furnace is popular choice for foundries that re-melt castings with ferrous inserts or screens. They also provide<br />
flexibility in <strong>melting</strong> all forms of scrap <strong>and</strong> large sows <strong>and</strong> T-bars. The furnace design allows all <strong>melting</strong> to be done on a<br />
sloping hearth from where the <strong>metal</strong> flows into a separate hold chamber. This furnace eliminates the chance of <strong>metal</strong><br />
explosions caused by moisture present in the charge material being directly placed into the molten <strong>metal</strong>. Since both the melt<br />
chamber <strong>and</strong> hold chamber are separately controlled it allows for close <strong>metal</strong> temperature control. The furnace also holds<br />
half the <strong>metal</strong> capacity of traditional wet bath reverbs <strong>and</strong> the melt chamber can be put on idle during non-production hours.<br />
The more efficient dry hearth designs incorporate roof radiant burners eliminating flame impingement on the <strong>metal</strong> reducing<br />
<strong>metal</strong> loss. These furnaces typical use conventional burners but also can be provided with regenerative burners.<br />
2000#/Hr. Dry Hearth Furnace<br />
Radiant Roof Burners
WET BATH REVERBS<br />
The wet bath reverb melts the <strong>metal</strong> by direct charge into the bath. They can also include a sow hearth for placing sows, tbars,<br />
or ingot stacks for preheating prior to charging into the bath. Since their ratio of melt to hold runs about 10 to 1 side<br />
well re-circulation on the larger furnace is quite common improving melt efficiency <strong>and</strong> temperature uniformity. This to date<br />
has been the most common furnace approach in the large casting foundry. The burners used have typically been conventional<br />
with high velocity or radiant roof design. The applications of regenerative burners are becoming more common with the<br />
increasing energy costs. The regenerative burners can in some cases increase the base cost of the furnace by 60 to 80%.<br />
These furnaces are also good application for chip <strong>melting</strong> systems <strong>and</strong> attaching to launder integrated casting lines.<br />
4000#/Hr. Gas Wet Bath Reverb With Sow Hearth<br />
BARREL WET BATH REVERB FURNACE<br />
The barrel wet bath-<strong>melting</strong> furnace has been around for a number of years. It is used mainly as a central melt furnace for<br />
fast <strong>and</strong> efficient <strong>metal</strong> transfer to bull ladles. Today’s barrel furnace use high velocity burners for improved melt efficiency<br />
<strong>and</strong> are offered with sow preheat hearths. Direct scrap charge can be placed in the end well. The circular locking high<br />
alumina brick construction provides good refractory furnace life.
5000#/Hr. Gas Barrel Furnace<br />
ELECTRIC REVERB FURNACE<br />
The electric reverb was brought into the market in the early 70’s during the Midwest energy crisis. The furnace<br />
was heated with silicon carbide elements <strong>and</strong> was offered in sizes upward 3000#/Hr. The design is still popular in<br />
high <strong>quality</strong> casting applications such as the electric motor market. Where melt rates are required in excess of<br />
crucible <strong>melting</strong>, this furnace style is a good option.<br />
1200#/Hr. Electric Reverb
CORELESS INDUCTION<br />
The coreless induction furnace has been a very popular melt concept from the small jobbing foundries to the large remelt<br />
shops. Low to medium frequency induction coils transfer energy directly into the melt. The small foundries that<br />
batch melt a variety of alloys find these furnaces fast <strong>and</strong> efficient. The large foundries use them in scrap <strong>and</strong> chip<br />
<strong>melting</strong> applications. They are the most efficient way to melt chips with upwards of a 98% yield.<br />
Coreless Induction<br />
STACK MELTERS<br />
The stack melter has had more presence to date in the Europe <strong>and</strong> Asia market due to high-energy costs. The North<br />
American market is paying a lot more attention to this efficient method of <strong>melting</strong>. The original stack or tower melter<br />
accepts all charges through the exhaust stack. The heat normally exhausted is used to pre-heat the scrap or ingot being<br />
charged reducing the fuel usage per pound melted. The drawback of these furnaces is the inability to melt sows or t-bars, but<br />
a stack melt dry hearth furnace is available that can accept all the alternate charge materials.
2000#/Hr. Stack Melter<br />
4000#/Hr. Stack Charge Dry Hearth Furnace
CHART OF FURNACE EFFICIENCIES<br />
TYPE OF FURNACE RANGE OF BTU’S/POUND RANGE OF METAL LOSS<br />
GAS CRUCIBLE 2500 – 4000 1 - 3%<br />
ELECTRIC CRUCIBLE 716 - 887 1 – 1.5%<br />
ACUTRAK DIRECT HEAT 560 - 590 .5 – 1%<br />
CORELESS INDUCTION 785 - 887 1 – 1.5%<br />
DRY HEARTH 1500 – 2000 2 – 4%<br />
WET BATH REVERB 1500 – 1800 1.5 – 3%<br />
BARREL MELTER 1500 – 1800 1.5 – 3%<br />
STACK MELTER 1100 – 1300 1 – 2%<br />
STACK DRY HEARTH MELTER 1200 – 1400 1.5 – 3%<br />
REGENERATIVE WET BATH 1000 – 1300 1.5 – 3%<br />
ELECTRIC REVERB 716 – 853 1 – 1.5%<br />
*The use of regenerative burners in the wet bath <strong>and</strong> dry hearth furnaces can result in an average of 500 BTU’s per<br />
pound savings.<br />
METAL PROCESS SYSTEMS<br />
The control of the casting process starts from the <strong>quality</strong> of <strong>metal</strong> being charged to how we treat the <strong>metal</strong> in its final stage<br />
before casting. From the small jobbing foundry to the large automotive casting facility an integrated melt <strong>and</strong> process system<br />
is needed to ensure <strong>metal</strong> control. The training of foundry personnel in the basics of <strong>metal</strong> h<strong>and</strong>ling <strong>and</strong> treatment on an<br />
ongoing basis is very important. In over 70% of casting shops the foundry personnel have no real underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the basics<br />
such as why we flux, degas, grain refine or modify <strong>aluminum</strong> alloys. There are no good excuses for this with the information<br />
that is so freely available through AFS <strong>and</strong> other organizations.<br />
SMALL JOBBING FOUNDRIES<br />
An up to date continuous crucible <strong>melting</strong> approach would include an ingot charger with a pivotal rotary degasser followed<br />
by an automatic ladle. Grain refiners <strong>and</strong> modifiers would be introduced by h<strong>and</strong> to meet desired <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong>. Filtering in<br />
this process is usually accomplished by flux injection through the degasser or by h<strong>and</strong> application.<br />
In a batch melt system the furnace would be loaded <strong>and</strong> after complete meltdown <strong>and</strong> <strong>metal</strong> at temperature the degassing <strong>and</strong><br />
fluxing process would take place. The crucible melt shop does not lend itself to the advantages of more integrated <strong>metal</strong><br />
treatment controls due to furnace size <strong>and</strong> numbers of alloys. Once a foundry gets into high melt rate of singular alloys a<br />
review of melt systems should be considered.<br />
Crucible Auto Ladle Station Ingot Charger
MEDIUM SIZE MELT SHOPS<br />
The medium size foundry has a number of systems to choose from in control of <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong>. The use of rotary degassers<br />
<strong>and</strong> filters allows for good <strong>metal</strong> treatment when applied correctly. Many foundries have used gate style filtering in exit<br />
wells of melt <strong>and</strong> holding furnaces. The foundry management likes the ability to change these filters without draining the<br />
furnace. Unfortunately the majority of these applications do not assure proper placement of the filter causing <strong>metal</strong> to bypass<br />
the filter media resulting in no <strong>metal</strong> cleaning. The other problem is the filters are not probably preheated <strong>and</strong> block over<br />
50% when placed into the <strong>metal</strong>. The result is a significant temperature drop between one side <strong>and</strong> the other of the filter.<br />
This has an adverse effect by causing the melt chamber to run excessively hot resulting in increased oxidation <strong>and</strong> hydrogen<br />
absorption into the <strong>metal</strong>. A solution to this problem is to use a silicon carbide filter box in the well, which provides a lot of<br />
surface area <strong>and</strong> reduced <strong>metal</strong> temperature gradient. Since all sides <strong>and</strong> bottom are filter media they assure complete <strong>metal</strong><br />
filtering with no bypass. When the filter box starts to block or accidentally broken it can be replaced within 20 to 30 minutes.<br />
Automatic ladling should also be considered when possible to assure continuously pour rates.<br />
4000#/Hr. Wet Bath Reverb With Degassing And Filtration
Ladling Furnace With Inset Silicon Carbide Filter Boxes<br />
LARGE FOUNDRY INTEGRATED SYSTEMS<br />
Today’s large foundries have the option of laying out the casting shop for complete continuous <strong>metal</strong> control. The<br />
availability of efficient <strong>melting</strong> systems connected to heated launder, degassing, filtering <strong>and</strong> holding furnaces allows for<br />
constant high <strong>metal</strong> <strong>quality</strong> castings. The ability to melt <strong>and</strong> cast without any manual <strong>metal</strong> transfer over the floor can be<br />
achieved with a complete integrated melt facility.<br />
DEGASSING FURNACE<br />
The degassing furnace is electric heated <strong>and</strong> can be installed with an inlet <strong>and</strong> outlet rotary degassing station. This approach<br />
allows for independent degassing outside of the melt furnace achieving controllable levels downwards of .07cc/100gm.<br />
hydrogen content. The levels of hydrogen can be increased or decreased depending on your casting requirements with the<br />
use of inert gas such as nitrogen <strong>and</strong> argon with proper RPM <strong>and</strong> dispersion head design.<br />
HEATED LAUNDER SYSTEMS<br />
The intent of high efficiency electric heated launder systems allows us to connect from the melter to the casting furnace<br />
without subjecting the <strong>metal</strong> to unwanted turbulence. This closed loop approach completely changes the conditions inherent<br />
in a st<strong>and</strong>ard <strong>aluminum</strong> foundry. In some of the modern installations it is hard to detect that liquid <strong>metal</strong> exists in the facility.<br />
The melt furnace can be connected directly to the launder or the <strong>metal</strong> can be transferred by pressure pump well to the<br />
launder with laser level control. The launders normally have 1-1/2KW hooked up per linear foot <strong>and</strong> have nitrogen purge to<br />
minimize <strong>metal</strong> oxidation. Since they are very well insulated the power usage is minimal. The launder system allows for a<br />
modular concept allowing for additional casting cells to be added as the foundry grows. Some plants will have as many as 20<br />
to 30 casting stations fed by a launder system.
FILTRATION FURNACE<br />
The electric heated filtration furnace assures all <strong>metal</strong> going though the line is filtered. Different from the gate filter approach<br />
the use of filter bowl seating makes for a sure seal between incoming <strong>and</strong> outgoing <strong>metal</strong>. The filter furnace allows for up to<br />
12,000 lbs. per hour of treated <strong>metal</strong> <strong>and</strong> an average of two weeks prior to filter replacement. The furnace has a typical input<br />
of 30K to maintain <strong>metal</strong> temperature.<br />
CASTING FURNACE<br />
The launder system will eventually feed a number of electric heated holding/casting furnaces. Since the launder can supply a<br />
continuous source of <strong>metal</strong> the casting furnace does not have to hold a large capacity of <strong>metal</strong> reducing the space needed at<br />
each casting station. The furnace wells can be designed to accommodate either ladles or pumps.<br />
4000#/Hr. Lost Foam Automated Line With Complete Metal Treatment System And Casting Furnace. The<br />
Casting Line Provides Metal Gas Levels Of .10cc/100gm. And Inclusion Removals Of 80% Or More.
Electric Degassing Furnace Connected To Outlet Of 4000#/Hr. Melter<br />
30 Kw Filter Furnace Connected To The Launder Line
12,000# Electric Ladling Furnace Completes The Integrated Casting Line<br />
high efficiency electric launder system for connecting system
Automated Casting Line Including Two Melters, Degassing, Filtration, Launder And Casting Furnaces<br />
10,000#/Hr. 120,000# Hold Capacity Regenerative Melter Connected To A Complete Integrated Metal<br />
Delivery System
Completely Automated Piston Line With Over 400 Ft. Of Electric Launder Connecting To Central Melters<br />
With Laser Level Control And 12 Casting Cells<br />
TOTAL INTEGRATED SYSTEM CONCEPT<br />
A complete casting facility would have a series of melters feeding a central launder system. Metal treatment though<br />
degassing <strong>and</strong> filtering would feed continuous high <strong>quality</strong> temperature controlled <strong>metal</strong> to each casting station. The entire<br />
transfer system would be nitrogen purged to minimize gas <strong>and</strong> oxide pickup through the system. Automatic rod feeding for<br />
grain refinement <strong>and</strong> modification can be an additional feature of the feed line. The integrated system concept minimizes the<br />
chance of human error allowing for continuous high <strong>quality</strong> <strong>metal</strong> resulting in lower scrap rates <strong>and</strong> castings of high integrity.<br />
The future high production foundries will eliminate all manual means of <strong>metal</strong> transfer increasing plant safety <strong>and</strong> <strong>metal</strong><br />
<strong>quality</strong> control.