11.07.2015 Views

Rupert Yorke - College of Social Sciences and International Studies

Rupert Yorke - College of Social Sciences and International Studies

Rupert Yorke - College of Social Sciences and International Studies

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong><strong>College</strong> <strong>of</strong> William <strong>and</strong> Mary, VirginiaContentsLearning Log 1 - Statement <strong>of</strong> Expectations ........................................................................................... 2Learning Log 2 - Experiences in settling into my new environment ....................................................... 4Learning Log 3 - Reflections about host university ................................................................................. 6Learning Log Assignment 4 - Survey <strong>of</strong> the treatment <strong>of</strong> British news in the media <strong>of</strong> the student’shost country ............................................................................................................................................ 8Learning Log 5 - Reactions to the teaching <strong>of</strong> <strong>and</strong> approach taken to the student’s academicdisciplines at their host university ........................................................................................................ 10Learning Log 6 - Reflection on the student's period abroad <strong>and</strong> what they have gained from it,together with a guide for other students visiting the same institution ............................................... 12


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log 1 - Statement <strong>of</strong> ExpectationsThe single question I have been bombarded with to an inordinate degree over the past few monthsregards my decision to ab<strong>and</strong>on the plush hills <strong>and</strong> legendary pubs <strong>of</strong> Exeter <strong>and</strong> study abroad for ayear. Why? It would be fallacious to suggest that the relative luxury <strong>of</strong> “time out” is what I need – Ihave just finished what has emerged to be a reassuringly successful second year studying Politics<strong>and</strong> Philosophy under the auspices <strong>of</strong> HuSS <strong>and</strong> feel in pole position to tackle the rapidlyapproaching final year. Yet I can discern an inherent desire for a vastly different perspective on life, adesire for more acute socio-cultural awareness <strong>and</strong> most <strong>of</strong> all a fundamentally more challenging<strong>and</strong> vibrant educational atmosphere. Despite my happiness <strong>and</strong> satisfaction with Exeter,opportunities to engage in a totally alien culture seldom arise under the liberal rubric <strong>of</strong> “StudentExchange” <strong>and</strong> therefore it is with a great sense <strong>of</strong> enthusiasm <strong>and</strong> eagerness that I keenly await mydeparture for the prestigious <strong>College</strong> <strong>of</strong> William <strong>and</strong> Mary in the U.S.A. in mid-August.Nestled within the historical delights <strong>of</strong> Colonial Williamsburg in the bucolic state <strong>of</strong> Virginia, I mustconsider myself fortunate on three broad accounts compared to my slightly more apprehensiveErasmus colleagues. Firstly, I have no language barrier to overcome. The intricacies <strong>of</strong> learning <strong>and</strong>studying within an alien language seem to pre-suppose to me incredible bravery <strong>and</strong> stoicism; I canindeed count myself lucky in dealing with the familiar wonders <strong>of</strong> the English language (despite theconsiderable degree <strong>of</strong> transatlantic vagaries seemingly adopted across ‘The Pond’!) I say this withrelative trepidation however – Virginia’s status as a Southern state suggests a frightening tendency<strong>of</strong> slow speech allied with the incorporation <strong>of</strong> certain ‘hic’ phrases. Having suffered perennialcastigation from my mother <strong>and</strong> her disdain for my habit to “mumble”, I recognise a pr<strong>of</strong>oundrequirement for more coherent elocution. Secondly, organising accommodation has betrayed theEuropean norm <strong>of</strong> onerous bureaucratic obstacles – the <strong>College</strong> has simply allocated me a roomconveniently right in the centre <strong>of</strong> campus amongst the American students. A signature was all thatwas required (as well as the not-so-insignificant joy <strong>of</strong> a not-so-small cheque!) Thirdly, choosingcourses <strong>and</strong> other such administrative tasks have similarly been h<strong>and</strong>led by the <strong>College</strong> withineluctable helpfulness. The American collegiate system’s reputation for organisation <strong>and</strong> systematiccoherency is certainly no myth – my remarkable lack <strong>of</strong> effort <strong>and</strong> input rests somewhat uneasilywith me considering the burden my Erasmus friends have endured 1 !It is my intention that this first diary entry is characterised by positive ambition <strong>and</strong> unwaveringoptimism, <strong>and</strong> it is true that I genuinely do have a paucity <strong>of</strong> ‘fears’ <strong>and</strong> apprehension for theforthcoming year. However, the emotional upheaval may perhaps take its toll as the year progresses– as my Mother continually reminds me, I am a long, long way from the delightful (or not!) towns <strong>of</strong>innocent Berkshire <strong>and</strong> our fragmented family may even grant me the luxury <strong>of</strong> lamenting myabsence! I will also leave behind what has become an incredibly close-knit group <strong>of</strong> friends at Exeter<strong>and</strong> it is with deep sadness that I shall not be able to graduate with them. But returning with hasteto practical matters, the financial commitments will doubtless prove also to be a significant strain.The costs <strong>of</strong> transatlantic flights, accommodation, food (the American approach to dining is the stuff<strong>of</strong> legends), m<strong>and</strong>atory health insurance <strong>and</strong> what I’d ideally like to ‘live’ <strong>of</strong>f appear precipitous at1 I must make one crucial exception here – the application for my Visa has been nothing short <strong>of</strong> long, tiresome<strong>and</strong> utterly exhausting.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>first glance. However, the messianic capabilities <strong>of</strong> Student Finance Engl<strong>and</strong> will hopefully intervenefrom above <strong>and</strong> I won’t be graced with multiple bank statements cheerfully caked in too much redink.Much is made <strong>of</strong> the American educational system <strong>and</strong> its well-earned <strong>and</strong> virtuoso reputation isnaturally accompanied by a more stringent daily approach to learning. My meagre eight hours <strong>of</strong>contact time per week looks set to be more than doubled <strong>and</strong> it is with great eagerness that I lookforward to the high levels <strong>of</strong> encouraged <strong>and</strong> expected participation inherent in the American ‘class’system 2 . This will be <strong>of</strong> huge relief given the slight monotony I have <strong>of</strong>ten found in Exeter’slecture/tutorial approach, <strong>and</strong> the occasional lack <strong>of</strong> scope for individual contribution. Havingspoken to current William <strong>and</strong> Mary students at Exeter, they laud their home institution’s propensityfor student-pr<strong>of</strong>essor interaction <strong>and</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong> familiarity which one can build up with theirinstructors. I intend to cultivate this avenue to the highest possible degree. I have been reliablyinformed also that the Americans nurture an emphatically different style <strong>of</strong> writing; sacrificingambiguity <strong>and</strong> subjective awareness for a more definitive, one-dimensional <strong>and</strong> conclusiveapproach. Whilst hoping to add this new technique to my essay-writing arsenal, I also intend toundertake considerable research for a potentially titillating dissertation topic on American politicalphilosophy when back in Exeter. By combining the two, I am confident I will return to Exeter heavilyarmoured <strong>and</strong> more than ready to launch the final assault on my degree.Educational adaptation aside, there is also the need to culturally assimilate myself with the variousidiosyncrasies <strong>and</strong> colloquialisms <strong>of</strong> Virginians. Although I have been to the country several timesbefore, social etiquette will refreshingly take on a rather different form from some <strong>of</strong> the alcoholfuelledrelationships I seem to have fostered at Exeter <strong>and</strong> I am sure my cultural awareness <strong>and</strong>appreciation will improve to no end. Being situated just one hundred <strong>and</strong> fifty miles south <strong>of</strong>Washington D.C. is mouth-watering for a student <strong>of</strong> politics or ‘government’ <strong>and</strong> I will thus frequentmyself on the excursions north to the political capital <strong>of</strong> the liberty-loving Western world. Indeed, Ihope to meet young people at William <strong>and</strong> Mary who share my drive <strong>and</strong> zeal for politicalappreciation <strong>and</strong> I will doubtless consider seriously the U.S.A. in a career-minded light upongraduation.The possibility for personal development is therefore what I crave most <strong>and</strong> feel somewhatincapable <strong>of</strong> cultivating at Exeter at the present time. Although I will miss certain aspects <strong>of</strong> homelife, I am not apprehensive in the slightest <strong>and</strong> am looking forward with excitement <strong>and</strong> optimism tothe coming year. The scale <strong>of</strong> opportunity <strong>and</strong> potential on <strong>of</strong>fer, the chance to really flourish <strong>and</strong>undergo a unique experience amidst an entirely different, liberal culture is simply too good anopening to turn down – I am merely counting down the days now.2 I refer to their use <strong>of</strong> the term ‘class’ in the educational sense - not the social hierarchical connotation!


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log 2 - Experiences in settling into my new environmentAs I recline innocently on the verdant lawns <strong>of</strong> William <strong>and</strong> Mary’s much-frequented SunkenGardens, oblivious to the tempestuous battle <strong>of</strong> the elements apparently raging above me, I findsolitude, tranquillity, <strong>and</strong> serenity – three qualities I craved more than any when I elicited myexpectations for this year back in June. The past three <strong>and</strong> a half months have been nothing short <strong>of</strong>challenging, refreshing, <strong>and</strong> at times, utterly “awesome”, to employ by far the most regularly citedAmerican adjective.Setting my present sentiments against the expectations <strong>and</strong> desires I felt in June seems the mostexpedient way to evaluate my first semester in the U.S.A. There has <strong>of</strong> course, been absolutely noinsurmountable language barrier to overcome unlike my Erasmus colleagues – however myrecognition for improved coherent elocution has become a salient issue, especially in class. What Ihad previously dismissed as a media-exaggerated myth regarding American’s compulsion towardsthe British accent <strong>and</strong> British culture in general has proved to be a source <strong>of</strong> great pride, borderingon quasi-jingoism at times. I have even found myself defending the monarchy at times. Routinelyreferred to as “the Brit” certainly has its merits in terms <strong>of</strong> pseudo-favouritism displayed by theextremely amicable pr<strong>of</strong>essors (I am positive this is predicated on fascination with British lifestyle asopposed to my own personality). Having established myself within a diverse yet brilliant group <strong>of</strong>(mostly) American friends, their fierce patriotism <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>ten-dogmatic zealotry has revealed manyqualities about the American character which I feel only the British are sufficiently able to match – atleast in their eyes. Sharing with a rather regimented German who befriended two Frenchmen veryquickly only accentuated the extremely high regard young Americans hold for British people.The classroom certainly has the warmer, more liberated atmosphere comparable to A-Level schoolclasses; yet whilst the content may be slightly lighter compared to Exeter, the workload <strong>and</strong> readingrequired every day makes the overall working day tougher indeed. Many Americans I have met‘transferred’ in to William & Mary after one or two years at community colleges throughout Virginia(broadly equivalent to our “poly’s”) <strong>and</strong> both anticipated <strong>and</strong> emphatically confirmed the extremelyhigh workload its students endure. Being a “Public Ivy”, I am assured they work ‘us’ nearly as hard asthe likes <strong>of</strong> Harvard <strong>and</strong> Yale! The lack <strong>of</strong> administrative <strong>and</strong> bureaucratic obstacles has certainlymade life relatively easy in terms <strong>of</strong> personal organization – as long as one turns up to classregularly, on-time, prepared to participate <strong>and</strong> willing to learn, it is hard not to succeed. Such areflection seems emblematic <strong>of</strong> the American educational system as a whole – extremelymethodical, rigorously planned, <strong>and</strong> forever willing to nurture their eager students towards fruitfulrewards. Without attesting to impertinence, English universities could certainly learn a thing or two!From a social perspective, I have had a lot <strong>of</strong> fun since my arrival in August. Whilst flirting with theinfamous fraternity culture has provided many unforgettable memories, the general affability <strong>and</strong>hospitality exuded by almost every student brings such a positive, embracing atmosphere to everysingle day. I have thrown myself vigorously into supporting the ‘Tribe’ football team (Americanfootball) <strong>and</strong> having befriended one <strong>of</strong> the biggest twenty-one year olds I have ever seen who playsin a much-magnified equivalent <strong>of</strong> prop in rugby union, have enjoyed a pretty personal insight into agreat game characterized by competitive bonhomie. However, Williamsburg is not quite the


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>hedonistic utopia I fully expected crossing the Atlantic in August. It is a terrifically small ‘city’ whosenightlife options are restricted to just three fairly tawdry bars <strong>and</strong> where owning a car is anabsolutely prerogative in order to cultivate alternative entertainment pursuits. Whilst I endeavournot to lie to myself that I am a clubbing guru, a college town without a club <strong>of</strong> any sort mildlyresembles any American building without the stars <strong>and</strong> stripes majestically surfing the wind–incomplete. I have managed to tame my yearning to ‘flee the nest’ by visiting the irresistiblystunning Washington D.C. as much as possible, being only three hours away on the impressiveAmtrak. I have even managed (somehow) to keep in touch with a few students studying atGeorgetown University in D.C., which always provide a welcome tonic for the occasionally insularWilliamsburg.As I look forward to flying home next week to recharge the batteries amidst the fineries <strong>of</strong> homecookedfood, ‘real’ beer, <strong>and</strong> the festive harmony <strong>of</strong> one’s friends <strong>and</strong> family, I am holding no regretswhatsoever in electing to study for a year <strong>and</strong> not a semester at William & Mary. I know I will wantto return come January, such is the warmth <strong>and</strong> allure <strong>of</strong> Virginia, <strong>and</strong> the U.S.A. itself. Whilst I havemissed friends, home <strong>and</strong> my Mum particularly (to whom I am very close), I feel very much part <strong>of</strong> aloving, caring community in America – something perhaps I lacked last year in Exeter. This wassurprisingly recognised by my mother when she visited me in D.C. <strong>and</strong> Williamsburg for five days orso in October – the seven hour or so flight really isn’t all that unsettling as it is made out to be. Thework is tough, but by no means impossible. The food is desperate at times, but by no meansinedible.I desired first <strong>and</strong> foremost for this year an improved socio-cultural awareness allied with a renewedperspective on life, <strong>and</strong> one event in particular on October 14 th managed to deliver this goal in asingle h<strong>and</strong>shake. Having spontaneously <strong>and</strong> wildly applied via email to ‘An MTV Conversation withPresident Obama’ in Washington D.C.’, I found myself being invited to an interview in the capitalover Fall Break which culminated in a seat in the audience for a live question-<strong>and</strong>-answer sessionwith the much berated President. And so the dream come true – following the nation-wide livebroadcast, the most powerful man in the world perused the flabbergasted audience with hiseffortless swagger, shaking ‘shaking’ h<strong>and</strong>s. I am relatively confident that little in life can compare tolooking the President <strong>of</strong> the United States in the eye <strong>and</strong> exchanging h<strong>and</strong>shakes – life is going wellacross the pond.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log 3 - Reflections about host universityRegrettably entering the final quarter <strong>of</strong> my year in America places me in an ideal position to reflecton the most salient similarities <strong>and</strong> differences between life at William & Mary <strong>and</strong> Exeter. On thewhole, a comparison between two Western, liberal academic institutions would likely yield aplethora <strong>of</strong> resemblances (<strong>and</strong> there are indeed many), yet there is a significantly larger proportion<strong>of</strong> crucial differences in everyday college life which both enhance the American educationalatmosphere <strong>and</strong> highlight the considerable contrast in basic values between Americans <strong>and</strong>Europeans 3 . By placing these differences in the context <strong>of</strong> the general American system <strong>of</strong>education, my reflections provide me with a safe reminder that although I do inevitably miss certainaspects <strong>of</strong> British life, I certainly feel I made the right decision in choosing to apply to study here.In terms <strong>of</strong> administrative <strong>and</strong> bureaucratic functions, William & Mary would appear to have theupper h<strong>and</strong> over a frequently gridlocked Exeter. Admittedly, the latter has gone under sweepinginfrastructural changes during my year away which have almost certainly contributed to the decline<strong>of</strong> regular communications with the relevant departments. However, it is a testament to theenhanced role American institutions play in the lives <strong>of</strong> their students that William & Mary appearsbetter organized <strong>and</strong> more willing to clarify difficulties swiftly. This quasi-platonic bond betweencollege <strong>and</strong> student is manifested in so many more ways such as the myriad college traditions 4throughout the year <strong>and</strong> the zealous adherence to the William & Mary Honour Code – such respect<strong>and</strong> adulation for one’s college is simply lacking in Exeter, <strong>and</strong> seems to be in European institutionsas a whole. The college life for American students is a very large part <strong>of</strong> their lives – by no means amere three years under the umbrella <strong>of</strong> an academic establishment in order to garner some sort <strong>of</strong>career-magnetising degree.In terms <strong>of</strong> facilities <strong>and</strong> the infrastructures <strong>of</strong> the two universities, Exeter <strong>and</strong> William & Mary sharevery comparable libraries, IT access, recreational facilities, student clubs, <strong>and</strong> campus-wide WIFIconnectivity. Whilst it appears some European destinations have recently emerged into the moderntechnological classroom arena, American institutions as a whole are extremely well-funded 5 <strong>and</strong>enjoy very liberal access to the exact same sort <strong>of</strong> facilities we enjoy at home. This has proved to bea major relief during my time abroad – the relative lack <strong>of</strong> bureaucratic <strong>and</strong> logistical obstacles topotentially hinder my enjoyment <strong>of</strong> what American education has to <strong>of</strong>fer.One could argue that this lack <strong>of</strong> bureaucratic difficulty underlines the far superior challenges myErasmus colleagues are facing closer to home. However, the rigorous academic methods employedby William & Mary certainly vindicate such a theory; the most discernible <strong>and</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>ound differencesbetween the two universities centre around their radically different approaches to classroomteaching. Exeter’s lecture-tutorial system for Politics <strong>and</strong> Philosophy requires relatively littlepreparation, a usually manageable amount <strong>of</strong> reading <strong>and</strong> no pressure to participate if one does notfeel the desire to. Two years <strong>of</strong> such an environment in large lecture halls with little input from an3 Judging by Learning Logs submitted by previous Study Abroad <strong>and</strong> Erasmus students.4 Charter Day on February 4 th was a particular highlight being British – a celebration <strong>of</strong> the <strong>College</strong>’s foundingback in 1693 under British royal charter.5 Having said this, word around campus is that William & Mary is reputedly “running out <strong>of</strong> cash”.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong><strong>of</strong>ten muted audience was radically thrown out the window upon arrival at William & Mary.Conducive to the general feeling that American colleges are more like schools (in the British sense)than universities, I have been engaging in far smaller ‘classes’ as opposed to lectures, where studentinput is both encouraged <strong>and</strong> in fact m<strong>and</strong>atory in order to foster a high participation grade – usuallynot more than 10%. In Exeter such a requirement is totally alien, <strong>and</strong> in places such as the Institutd'Etudes Politiques d'Aix-en-Provence, it seems participation is even frowned upon. This providesyet a further reflection <strong>of</strong> this deep underlying trend is American academics – greater reliance onfrequent interaction <strong>and</strong> thus a closer college-student association.Forsaking the actual learning method, the content <strong>of</strong> the courses <strong>and</strong> what is required during theregular assessments is certainly on the slightly easier side than Exeter. Despite an extremely heavyreading list, barely manageable at certain times6, what is required in papers (‘essays’ in Britishvernacular) is <strong>of</strong> a far lower st<strong>and</strong>ard – no secondary sources <strong>and</strong> a far more objective summary <strong>of</strong> acertain argument certainly proved a welcome relief from Exeter’s comprehensive essay criteria. Theexam format also differs remarkably – gone is the formal rigmarole <strong>of</strong> being escorted to yourallocated desk in a designated hall under strict silence complete with a student ID card, pen <strong>and</strong> theperennial threat <strong>of</strong> a £25 fine if your mobile phone should emit even the slightest sound. Instead, atWilliam & Mary, one just waltzes to the classroom like any other day, takes a seat <strong>and</strong> completes theexam with the pr<strong>of</strong>essor absent for the full hour or so. It is perhaps another remarkable reflection onthe sincerity <strong>and</strong> affection American students have for their studies that with full capacity <strong>and</strong>opportunity to cheat (via oral or cellular means) – they do not even consider it. I have yet to evaluatewhich method I ultimately favour but I do miss Exeter’s system where students are not constantlyassessed <strong>and</strong> held accountable for daily study.William & Mary is a publicly-funded liberal arts college <strong>and</strong> enjoys a rich history steeped in prestige,tradition <strong>and</strong>, as far as Americans can do it, sublime pomposity. It enjoys a hugely respectedacademic st<strong>and</strong>ing in the US educational system <strong>and</strong> thus being able to tell locals <strong>and</strong> strangers thatone studies there is an <strong>of</strong>ten unexpected source <strong>of</strong> pride <strong>and</strong> satisfaction. My fellow students escapethe much exported <strong>and</strong> hugely perpetuated image <strong>of</strong> the quintessential American college student –spoilt, regularly inebriated <strong>and</strong> not particularly work-minded. Instead, I find myself mixing withextremely bright students7 who are by no means all from wealthy families but instead retainrealistically big ambitions <strong>and</strong> have a penchant for hard work <strong>and</strong> optimism for their future careers.Most seem to graduate <strong>and</strong> seek employment in the Washington D.C. area, being only two or sohours away, making the study <strong>of</strong> government an extremely insightful opportunity here.I would strongly recommend studying at William & Mary to anyone – it is a challenging yet warm,embracing environment where making friends is not hard <strong>and</strong> where it is impossible not to feelvalued by someone or some body within the community. Although the academic requirements mayappear tough <strong>and</strong> somewhat tedious at times, the liberal, unrestrained atmosphere which the values<strong>of</strong> the college foster provide a harmonious learning environment <strong>and</strong> a great way to appreciate atruly great country. I look forward to spending a large part <strong>of</strong> the summer months travelling the USAin greater depth, on the back <strong>of</strong> an incredibly enjoyable time at William & Mary.6 Whilst writing this entry I am being stared at by a large copy <strong>of</strong> Mill’s On Liberty looking menacingly on,needing to be read.7 The overwhelming majority <strong>of</strong> which are from Virginia, as William & Mary is a ‘state’ or ‘public’ school <strong>and</strong> sohas requirements to admit mostly in-state students, unlike private colleges - such as the University <strong>of</strong> Virginia.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log Assignment 4 - Survey <strong>of</strong> the treatment <strong>of</strong> British newsin the media <strong>of</strong> the student’s host countryWhilst forever conscious <strong>of</strong> over-generalizing <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>fering a rudimentary conclusion to a relativelycomprehensive question, I can safely report that the coverage <strong>of</strong> British news in American media,nationwide, is virtually non-existent. Such a statement could easily be prone to excessive hyperbole,but British affairs <strong>and</strong> developments are seldom covered by the self-obsessed, insular leviathan thatis the US media. Such an approach was actually not much <strong>of</strong> a surprise when I arrived out here – Ihad previously gathered that American reporting tends to be characterized by an incredible degree<strong>of</strong> self-centeredness <strong>and</strong> constant harking back to how America is directly affected. The newswebsites online such as the ‘objective’ CNN site would possibly provide the best (if veryrudimentary) British news stories, but these will be strictly limited to monumental political oreconomic developments such as the election <strong>of</strong> a new Prime Minister or government sc<strong>and</strong>al 8 . Theywould certainly examine isolated events <strong>and</strong> rarely address on-going social issues. The impressiverange <strong>of</strong> daily newspapers will similarly neglect to report exclusively British news, instead opting toclump us together with the rest <strong>of</strong> Europe <strong>and</strong> remind Americans <strong>of</strong> the general distrust <strong>and</strong>antipathy for European affairs. American TV is notoriously poor, comprising either American sports 9 ,inane chat shows, or lengthy news programmes – the latter <strong>of</strong> which only approaches anythingBritish when the Royal family seem to be attracting headline news. Americans seem obsessed withour monarchy <strong>and</strong> its individuals – when the announcement <strong>of</strong> Prince William’s engagement to KateMiddleton emerged, our quaint isl<strong>and</strong> was at last granted a few precious <strong>and</strong> saturated minutes <strong>of</strong>national televised coverage.In terms <strong>of</strong> my experience <strong>of</strong> American media, I try <strong>and</strong> purchase a daily broadsheet every other daycombined with listening to NPR (National Public Radio) online every morning, providing I wake up intime. USA Today <strong>and</strong> The Washington Post are supposedly pretty impartial, objective newspaperswhich report on mostly national <strong>and</strong> federal issues, along with no more than one or two doublepages <strong>of</strong> international news. The recent political unrest in the Middle East was reported in quitesome detail, yet in a recurring theme in American journalism, the nuances <strong>of</strong> the developments arealways linked back to the varying connotations for the US – speculation as to how much aid theObama administration should be preparing or whether or not every US citizen is safe <strong>and</strong> out <strong>of</strong> theregion. NPR is extremely informative <strong>of</strong> US news, but will only delve into international issues ifAmerica is directly involved. This is testament to the still very much active element <strong>of</strong> isolationism inAmerican culture – news about their own culture comes before anything else.In a further reflection on American media in general, it cannot be disputed that the st<strong>and</strong>ard <strong>of</strong> theirreporting <strong>and</strong> worldwide coverage (when it involves them) is first-class. Despite the chronicinsularity <strong>and</strong> quasi-jingoistic tone, both local <strong>and</strong> national newspapers are <strong>of</strong> an extremely highquality in terms <strong>of</strong> reporting <strong>and</strong> opinions. The more liberal New York Times seems to garner mostrespect <strong>and</strong> following amongst young students at William & Mary, but students in general seem torefrain from purchasing a daily paper, relying on Internet-based sources instead. However, the8 I have read next to nothing concerning how the David Cameron-led coalition government is settling in togoverning the UK.9 British, <strong>and</strong> indeed European sports, are seldom ever reported in the states.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>various columnists, such as The Washington Post’s Harold Meyerson, will consistently promulgatetheir unwavering dogmatism that the world continues to revolve around the USA. During thecatastrophic Japanese earthquake disaster, Meyerson was all too quick to reflect on what Americacan take from the disaster – his March 16 th column asked “Our Lisbon moment? What Japan’sdevastation teaches us?” 10 . In a nation where freedom <strong>of</strong> speech is so cradled <strong>and</strong> enshrined in theinerrant Constitution, it appears that Americans can write on absolutely anything they wish, safelyprotected by their extant founding documents.It therefore remains to be asked how the lack <strong>of</strong> British affairs reported in US media reflects on ourposition in the twenty-first century, at least from an American point <strong>of</strong> view. Despite this neglect foraffairs en Bretagne, it does appear that Britain in fact receives far more favourable reporting thanmost other European countries. Through a combination <strong>of</strong> our intertwined historical connections,the “special relationship” accentuated through the close alliance between Tony Blair 11 <strong>and</strong> GeorgeW. Bush during the Iraq/Afghanistan wars <strong>and</strong> a general affection for each other’s cultures, Britain<strong>and</strong> America do indeed enjoy a unique relationship which is manifested in daily interactions here inVirginia. Being British is a source <strong>of</strong> extreme pride <strong>and</strong> satisfaction. Americans bizarrely value ouridiosyncrasies <strong>and</strong> eccentricities hugely <strong>and</strong> view our culture <strong>and</strong> our comparably rich history withconsiderable envy. This appears to be in stark contrast to Germany’s modern opinion <strong>of</strong> the Brits asarrogant <strong>and</strong> supercilious – this however must similarly be tainted by historical vicissitudes too.Americans have considerable respect <strong>and</strong> admiration for the Brits, justified by the extent to which somany are desperate to visit London at some point in the future. Nevertheless, despite this affinitybetween our two cultures, they still neglect to report our news to any substantial degreewhatsoever.It is with a fair degree <strong>of</strong> reluctance <strong>and</strong> hesitance when I therefore inform Americans that US affairs<strong>and</strong> the Obama administration in particular is followed closely <strong>and</strong> reported almost daily back in theUK. Perhaps we must accept that the ramifications <strong>of</strong> American socio-political movements are(regrettably) far greater than those <strong>of</strong> twenty-first century Britain. Or perhaps they are just toowound up in their own elevated spirit <strong>of</strong> die-hard patriotism. Either way, the BBC website providesan incredibly satisfying escape from the Americanization that my eyes have endured in recentmonths – I do not feel cut <strong>of</strong>f from home at all when I can’t help but read how Kate Middleton’scatwalk dress fetched £65,000 at a recent auction – lets just hope her marriage to the future King <strong>of</strong>Engl<strong>and</strong> can at least receive 60 seconds or so before Glenn Beck gets going.10 The Washington Post, March 16 th 2011, p. 21.11 Tony Blair has done us the great favour <strong>of</strong> l<strong>and</strong>ing the UK with the not so humiliating “lap dog <strong>of</strong> America”tag.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log 5 - Reactions to the teaching <strong>of</strong> <strong>and</strong> approach taken tothe student’s academic disciplines at their host universityWilliam & Mary alumnus Thomas Jefferson once remarked that “a mind always employed is alwayshappy”; it is clear from a Founding Father as prominent as he that his sentiments have illustrated theAmerican approach to education since the founding <strong>of</strong> the nation. The UK <strong>and</strong> the USA are regularlyadvertised as <strong>of</strong>fering the best higher education in the world 12 with Oxford, Cambridge, Harvard <strong>and</strong>Yale constantly exchanging incumbency <strong>of</strong> the much coveted ‘Number 1’ spot in myriad surveys <strong>and</strong>university guides. As I approach the end <strong>of</strong> my second semester at William & Mary, my expectationsat the beginning <strong>of</strong> the year in terms <strong>of</strong> what to expect academically have all been fulfilled; it is easyto see why thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> international students now choose full-time American education at collegelevel.Sending one’s child to college is the biggest source <strong>of</strong> pride for American parents – it is endemic inthe American Dream <strong>and</strong> a major indicator <strong>of</strong> vindication <strong>and</strong> success for the upbringing <strong>of</strong> theirprogeny. Whereas in the UK going to university can <strong>of</strong>ten be seen as merely putting the ‘icing on thecake’ in terms <strong>of</strong> finishing one’s education, admittance to a prestigious American college is viewed asthe passport to unbridled optimism <strong>and</strong> eventual prosperity. Such a significant advancement in anAmerican student’s life is reflected in both the attitude they adopt to learning <strong>and</strong> simultaneously,the attitude the college atmosphere fosters towards every single <strong>of</strong> its students. The formal, once-aweek,hour-long lecture system whereby the lecturer dictates to a fifty plus group <strong>of</strong> students in theUK is replaced in the US by frequent classes <strong>of</strong> no more than thirty students meeting for no morethan forty minutes or so. Such an informal method requires regular participation by each student (somuch that it is nearly always an assessment criteria), <strong>and</strong> most importantly, opportunity for one’sown merit to shine through unhindered by the pr<strong>of</strong>essor’s personal judgment. Pr<strong>of</strong>essors are held inextremely high regard by their students – some even revered with obeisance given their impressivequalifications, passion <strong>and</strong> knowledge <strong>of</strong> their subject area. Whereas Exeter’s style does not placetoo much emphasis on who the module instructor is due to the outside reading requirements <strong>and</strong>less contact time per week, at William & Mary it is <strong>of</strong> huge importance which instructor you receive.During registration for classes for the spring semester, students will choose classes solely on thebasis <strong>of</strong> who will be teaching it – even if they do not care much for the content nor need it for theirdegree program. 13In terms <strong>of</strong> daily academic dem<strong>and</strong>s, there is certainly a greater <strong>and</strong> therefore harder workload thanthe average British student would endure - far less time for independent study <strong>and</strong> a considerablybroader range <strong>of</strong> assessment criteria. Oral presentations are both frequent <strong>and</strong> valued extremelyhighly by pr<strong>of</strong>essors; essays or ‘papers’ <strong>of</strong>ten require less secondary reading than what Exeterrequires but a similar level <strong>of</strong> analysis; exams or ‘finals’ emerged as wholly unpredictable in regard totheir content <strong>and</strong> style <strong>of</strong> examination – some requested a ten-page specific essay whilst othersinvolved maps <strong>and</strong> solely multiple choice questions! One palpable bonus which this multifarious12 Indeed, many American students view higher-level education elsewhere as significantly inferior to their own– with the exception <strong>of</strong> the UK.13 Unlike in the UK where one is relatively confined to one’s subject area (i.e. History), Americans are allowedto study all manner <strong>of</strong> subjects until their penultimate year at college when they have to ‘declare their major’.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>range <strong>of</strong> assessments demonstrates is that there is less pressure on any one particular component <strong>of</strong>the course – at Exeter, some modules require solely a two-hour unseen exam for the entireassessment. However, deadlines <strong>and</strong> attendance are treated with equal stringency for the most part– although there is perhaps greater occasion for pr<strong>of</strong>essorial sympathy if an assessed task is a day ortwo late, characteristic <strong>of</strong> the more personal pedagogic atmosphere in general. Yet whilst the hugereading lists <strong>and</strong> regular assessment may put <strong>of</strong>f the slightly indolent European, 14 this is <strong>of</strong>fset byconsiderable resources; the online learning resource ‘Blackboard’, Swem library <strong>and</strong> bookshop atWilliam & Mary provide the students with truly world-class facilities with which to conduct theirstudies – as long as one is prepared to put in the hard work, there is little excuse for failure.The William & Mary website states that “research is at the heart <strong>of</strong> a unique academic culture whereevery facet <strong>of</strong> student, faculty <strong>and</strong> institutional life is infused with original scholarship <strong>and</strong> h<strong>and</strong>s-oninquiry.” 15 Whilst trying to avoid excessive obsequiousness, William & Mary’s prestige <strong>and</strong>reputation justify such a claim <strong>and</strong> render it as a leading institution in which world-class research inacademia is conducted. This vibrant scholastic atmosphere, engendered through its liberal artsstatus 16 <strong>and</strong> proximity to Washington, D.C., filters through to the classroom where what one learnscan be readily applied to world affairs, such is the stimulating content <strong>and</strong> depth <strong>of</strong> analysis. Havingsaid this, one criticism which can certainly be recognized is the slight lack <strong>of</strong> impartiality as regardsto content. I mainly studied Government classes this year <strong>and</strong> the heavy bias towards US opinion,policy, <strong>and</strong> sentiments is pervasive throughout the courses. It is difficult to even study courses whichdon’t relate to America at all, such as anything relating to the European Union, <strong>and</strong> when one doesget into a course with a slightly more international twist (<strong>International</strong> Politics), the students wastelittle time in shifting the tone <strong>of</strong> discussion back to America <strong>and</strong> its particular involvement. Whilstthis may seem underst<strong>and</strong>able given American values <strong>and</strong> their occasional hubris, it did get slightlyweary after a while. Approaches to philosophy differed also; concrete substantive knowledge was<strong>of</strong>ten replaced by continuous subjective opinion <strong>and</strong> discussion – I <strong>of</strong>ten felt that, as useful as mycolleague’s opinions are, I needed something slightly more in depth.But this minor criticism, probably buried under the banner <strong>of</strong> post-colonial jealousy, cannot detractfrom a remarkable educational institution. The dem<strong>and</strong>s are high <strong>and</strong> the going is tough – more sothan in the UK – yet if one can tackle the copious tasks <strong>and</strong> get to grips with the strenuous academicrigors, the rewards are fruitful <strong>and</strong> the horizons seem far-reaching.14 It seems clear that, unlike in Europe, one has to be far more proactive <strong>and</strong> resourceful to succeed in Americagiven their higher dem<strong>and</strong>s.15 http://www.wm.edu/research/index.php.16 A liberal arts college is one in which students must study a broad range <strong>of</strong> subjects until they can specialise –maths, science <strong>and</strong> literature are included.


<strong>Yorke</strong>, <strong>Rupert</strong>Learning Log 6 - Reflection on the student's period abroad <strong>and</strong> whatthey have gained from it, together with a guide for other studentsvisiting the same institution

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!