SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGYdo in conventional air-conditioning systems.In a thermoelectric cooling application,for example, the IR detector, circuitcomponent, or other item that needs tobe cooled sits in contact with one face ofthe cooling device. Electrons at that faceshuttle heat away from the item that’s beingcooled through the thermoelectric materialand deposit it at the thermoelectricmaterial’s other face. There, the heat dissipates—sometimeswith the help of a fan.Kanatzidis likens the processto electrons carrying bundles ofheat down a corridor. When thecorridor is mostly empty, eachelectron can deliver its load easily,which is good for cooling applications.But if the corridor hasa few electrons milling about, thematerial’s electrical conductivitywill be low. Raising the electricalconductivity means gettingmore electrons moving throughthe corridor. But as Kanatzidisexplains, all that activity leads tocongestion and causes electronsto bump into each other, scatter,and drop their bundles ofheat. As a result, the material equilibratesther mally.THE TRICKY THING is finding materialsthat can maintain a large temperature differenceacross the two sides of a slab of thematerial. If the thermal conductivity is toohigh, the temperature difference goes awayand the thermoelectric effect becomes toosmall to be useful. “Optimizing the parametersin a thermoelectric material is a matterof compromise,” Kanatzidis says. “Youneed to find a happy medium.”Bismuth telluride is one of the first materialsfound to strike the necessary compromise.Its so-called thermoelectric figure ofmerit— ZT, a dimensionless quantity thatindicates how intensely a material exhibitsthe thermoelectric effect—is about 1.0 atroom temperature. To put the materialto use practically, for example in a powergenerator, small chunks of the material thathave been doped to render them positiveandnegative-charge-carrying semiconductors(p-type and n-type, respectively) areMARLOW INDUSTRIESjoined electrically to form a circuit. Largenumbers of these p-type and n-type pairs areconnected in series, forming thermoelectricarrays that can provide large voltages andmediate substantial heat flow.Although decades ago proponentswere able to point to a select number ofimpressive accomplishments in the fieldof thermoelectrics, such as reliable powergenerators for U.S. and Soviet deep-spacevehicles, few advances were made between“Thermoelectrics could well play acrucial role in addressing some of thesustainability issues we face today.”WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG 34 JUNE <strong>20</strong>, <strong>20</strong>11CHILL OUT Easilyhidden in thepalm of a hand,thermoelectricmodules such asthe four-stagedevice shownhere are usedto cool sensitiveelectronics.1960 and the early 1990s. AsMildred S. Dresselhaus recountsthe story, one of the key eventsthat helped reawaken the fieldgrew out of an early-1990s dinnerconversation at a restaurant inBelgium.Dresselhaus, a professor ofphysics and electrical engineeringat Massachusetts Instituteof Technology, recalls how shechatted over dinner that evening with Jean-Paul Issi of Belgium’s Catholic Universityof Louvain and others, including a seniorrepresentative of the French Navy, aboutstrategies to improve the performance ofthermoelectric materials. At that time, theU.S. and French Navies were both lookinginto new ways to power submarines, andthe dinner conversation soon turned tothermoelectrics. Dresselhaus hit upon theidea that nanoscale materials might havepromising thermoelectric properties anddecided to look into the topic.A year or so later, she published a paperwith graduate student Lyndon D.Hicks in which they showed theoreticallythat decreasing the thickness of a threedimensionalmaterial—that is, makingthinner and thinner films—increases thematerial’s ZT ( Phys. Rev. B, DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.47.12727).“Since the idea worked so well in 2-D, wedecided to do the same calculation in 1-D,”meaning on a nanowire, Dresselhaus says.The pair found that the additional confinementimposed by a nanowirerelative to a thin film led to evenbetter results and again publishedtheir findings in Physical Review B(DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.47.16631).Progress was slow because fewpeople were working in the fieldat that time, Dresselhaus says. Sheadds that eventually others pickedup on the nanoscale-confinementidea and produced experimentalresults supporting the theoreticalpredictions.Meanwhile, Kanatzidis continuedworking to discover new bulkthermoelectric materials. His aimwas to use solid-state synthesismethods to customize the compositionof promising materials andthereby tune their thermoelectricproperties. Eventually, that approachpaid off. In <strong>20</strong>04, Kanatzidis’group found that samplesof lead telluride containing antimonyand silver (AgPb m SbTe 2+ m )are characterized by remarkablyhigh figures of merit—up to 2.2at around 500 °C, which is nearlytwice the value of previous record holders( Science, DOI: 10.1126/science.1092963).Although the findings were exciting,Kanatzidis and coworkers were initially ata loss to explain them. The breakthroughcame from transmission electron microscopy(TEM) results indicating that thehigh-performance materials were ratherinhomogeneous and full of nanometersizedcrystallites or precipitates rich insilver and antimony embedded in a leadtelluride-rich matrix. Because of theirstructures and electronic properties, theprecipitates block the propagation ofheat-carrying lattice vibrations known asphonons, thereby reducing the material’sthermal conductivity, Kanatzidis explains.Building on those results, Kanatzidis’group devised synthesis methods thatcause numerous nanocrystals of SrTe toprecipitate inside a PbTe matrix such that
+ MANUFACTURING EXCELLENCE +NANO LETT.SLOPPY CRYSTALS The randomorientation of microscopic grains(colored patches at left) in this bismuthantimony telluride specimen andnanometer-wide bismuth-rich regionsin between the grains (yellow area atright) play a key role in this material’sthermoelectric properties.both sets of lattices match perfectly in 3-D. As reported in a paperpublished earlier this year, the structure and composition of these“perfect” synthetic lattices block the propagation of phonons, butthey do not impede the transport of charge typically caused byembedded crystallites. This “rational design” approach led to a ZTvalue of 1.7 near 500 °C ( Nat. Chem., DOI: 10.1038/nchem.955).Investigations by Kanatzidis, Dresselhaus, and others havestimulated a recent rise in thermoelectrics research that is helpinguncover new structural and electronic phenomena as well asnovel types of promising materials. For example, in a TEM studyof bismuth antimony telluride samples with a ZT of 1.4, YuchengLan and Zhifeng Ren of Boston College, working with MIT’s GangChen, found that the bulk material contains numerous randomlyoriented nanosized grains dotted with precipitates. They also detectedbismuth-rich regions several nanometers thick in betweenthe grains ( Nano Lett., DOI: 10.1021/nl803235n).And just recently, a group led by California Institute of Technologymaterials science professor G. Jeffrey Snyder showed thatZT values as high as 1.8 could be coaxed from lead telluride (oftencharacterized by ZT below 1.0) by selectively doping the materialwith sodium and selenium in a way that customizes the material’selectronic structure. Specifically, the group reports that samplesof Pb 0.98 Na 0.02 Te 1– x Se x benefit from a high “valley degeneracy.” Interms of the electrons-in-the-corridor analogy, this material can bethought of as having multiple parallel corridors, which helps avoidelectronic congestion (C&EN, May 9, page 38).IN ADDITION to the commonly studied materials—ones basedon bismuth telluride, lead telluride, and related compounds—other classes of materials also figure into today’s research onthermoelectrics. At the University of California, Berkeley, forexample, chemistry professor Peidong Yang has shown thatIn 2- x Ga x O 3 (ZnO)n nanowires and holey silicon membranes, bothof which can be prepared via straightforward synthesis methods,show promise as thermoelectric materials.Yet another group of materials, skutterudites, which are cobaltantimony-basedcompounds containing rare-earth elements, figureprominently into research aimed at generating electricity fromwaste heat. Skutterudites appear to be well suited for this applicationbecause, unlike bismuth telluride, they have high ZT s at the hightemperatures typical of industrial and automobile exhaust systems.As part of a multiyear project partly sponsored by the Departmentof Energy, Gregory P. Meisner, James R. Salvador, and coworkers atGeneral Motors have been developing prototype devices that use automobileexhaust heat to produce electricity for onboard use.The team’s work, carried out withvarious partners including Dallas-basedMarlow Industries, shows that such devicescan readily provide fuel-economyimprovements of several percent. Withfurther development of hybrid cars andother types of electric vehicles, even greater benefits can be realizedfrom such a system, Meisner says.“Discovery of new materials has really propelled this field forward,”Meisner asserts. He adds that progress is now being madequickly across all of thermoelectrics. Yet he injects a note of cautionby pointing out that key engineering problems still need to be solved.In the case of exhaust-heat recovery, for example, the thermoelectricsystem must be highly robust and heat resistant. Furthermore, itsweight, volume, and cost all must be optimized, he adds.As Amerigon and BSST’s founder, Bell, sees it, if those types of limitationscan be overcome, “thermoelectrics could well play a crucialrole in addressing some of the sustainability issues we face today.” ■100% cGMP Manufacturedin the U.S.A.JOST CHEMICAL CO.PhosphatesUÊAmmonium Phosphate Monobasic/Dibasic NF/ACSUÊPotassium Phosphate Monobasic/Dibasic USP/NF/EP/BP/ACSUÊSodium Phosphate Monobasic USP/BP/ACSUÊSodium Phosphate Dibasic USP/EP/ACSUÊSodium Phosphate Tribasic ACSCarbonatesUÊSodium Carbonate NF/EP/JP/ACSJost Chemical Co. manufactures over 250high purity chemical salts that meet yourspecifications. All of our products are BSE/TSEfree and available in custom packaging.Pharmaceutical / Biotech Product OfferingsSulfatesUÊAmmonium Sulfate NF/ACSUÊCupric Sulfate USPUÊFerrous Ammonium Sulfate PurifiedUÊManganese Sulfate USP/EP/ACSUÊPotassium Sulfate EP/ACSUÊSodium Sulfate USP/ACSWWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG 35 JUNE <strong>20</strong>, <strong>20</strong>11