Paul Bollenbackand John HartDueling Guitars 1ARKADIA DVD 72021AAA 1 /2This one’s not just for guitarfreaks. Old friends andcomplementary stylists,Paul Bollenback and JohnHart don’t so much duelas deal on this set of 10standards and originals.Recorded in front of anintimate crowd, the two sit side by side, conversationallyplaying to the audience’s delight.Primarily flat-pickers, both guitarists knoweach other’s moves to the point where you haveto be watching closely to see who is soloing andwho plays backup. In fact, there are a number ofinstances where roles are interchanged at amoment’s notice. The camera work can be distractingat times—close-ups, fadeouts and splitscreensused more than necessary. That said,there is also a fair amount of visual recording thatenhances the various moods created, as whenBollenback is isolated for an extended periodduring his engaging solo on “But Not For Me.”The viewer can be transported by the elegantsound of his classic Guild, free to concentrate onhis finger work, his visual expressions or theJudi SilvanoCleome: Live TakesJSL 007AAAVocalist Judi Silvanohas guts and takes bigrisks: singing in thenew music arena, creatingoriginal materialand functioning as aninstrument in theensemble. If her excavations don’t always strikegold, well, that’s the price of the ticket. Herworking band circa 2000—with reedmanGeorge Garzone, alternating bassists MichaelFormanek and John Lindberg, and drummerGerry Hemingway—provide a solid yet malleableplatform for Silvano’s high dives.She often sings wordlessly, with octavejumpingflexibility and rhythmic snap. Silvano,a soprano, likes to sing in unison with the instruments;she’s smart enough to vary her timbreand attack. Against Formanek’s quicksilver,microtonal arco work on “Bougainvillea,” hervoice becomes liquid. On “Yapi Credi,” sheaffects an altered state, and her soaring upperregisterflights may top off with a bird trill. Theboppish, fleet “Boscarob” has her scatting thehead with Garzone’s tenor. The extended bassand drum exchange is a bit of a relief from hersomewhat stringent upper range.overall mood he creates. Played witha bouncy demeanor, “But Not ForMe” also features a clever arrangementof the theme using the chordchanges to John Coltrane’s “GiantSteps.” There’s fun to be had whenthe two stand together for StevieWonder’s “Superstition,” Hart channelinga little Wes Montgomeryalong the way. Ditto TheloniousMonk’s “I Mean You,” a song thatcomes off sounding like it was writtenfor two hollow-bodied guitars tojam on.Like “But Not For Me,” other songs suggest afair amount of rehearsal/time spent away fromthe camera. Hart’s “Scenes From A Song” andBollenback’s “Reflections Of Jaco” includeinvolved arrangements and thematic materialalong with well-placed solos. Featuring a touchingrendition of “You Must Believe In Spring”as a bonus track, with Bollenback on nylonstringedguitar and Hart playing a modified hollow-bodiedelectric, the DVD also includes biosand interviews.—John EphlandDueling Guitars 1: Alone Together; Scenes From A Song;Superstition; I Mean You; Reflections Of Jaco; From ThisMoment On; Double Gemini; But Not For Me; Trio (Duo) Slant.(79:52)Personnel: Paul Bollenback, John Hart, guitar.»Ordering info: arkadiadvd.comThe liner notes offer norecording information andmost of the tracks suffer froma poor balance. Silvanosounds as though she’s in adifferent room from the band.Higher frequencies aresquashed and Hemingway’stom toms sound like emptyoil drums. A thoughtful, ifelementary, alto flute featureby Silvano, “Hand AndHeart,” is barely audible.Sun Ra’s “Love In Outer Space,” from hisSaturn period, is a spacey waltz, taken at a fluidtempo. Silvano contributes suitably spaceysound effects and, if this were the late 1950s,she’d be a visionary. Now it sounds naïve.These are a series of audio snapshots ofSilvano, circa 2000. Unlike formal portraits,where angles and stances can be chosen toadvantage and blemishes can be obscured, thesecandids are raw. As such, those qualities caneither be exciting in their spontaneity or scattershotin their success.—Kirk SilsbeeCleome: Live Takes: Cleome; Bougainvillea; Yapi Credi; HandAnd Heart; Boscarob; Cocolalla Land; Love In Outer Space;Dobranotz; Sakura. (48:10)Personnel: Judi Silvano, vocals, alto flute; George Garzone, clarinet,soprano and tenor saxophones; Michael Formanek (1–6, 8),John Lindberg (7, 8), bass; Gerry Hemingway, drums, vocal (9).Grace Kelly/Lee KonitzGRACEfulLEEPAZZ 15-8AAAA 1 /2I love this record. It’s about as inter-generationalas a band can get. Lee Konitz is 80, Rufus Reidis 64, Matt Wilson and Russell Malone in theirmid-40s, and Grace Kelly is ... 15. They all playlike family, which is not to say they all stringalong in file. Take Kelly’s solo on Konitz’s classic“Subconscious Lee”—rather than mimic hermentor’s mellifluous lines, she stems the flowwith an audacious sequence of half-note punctuation.Immediately, Wilson and Malone are oncreative alert and respond accordingly. Thisyoung lady has bags of talent, even Konitz concedesamusingly in the liners: “I gave her permissionto play better than me, if she justcouldn’t stand it any more.”However, Konitz’s influence is not to beunderestimated. Kelly is not a riffsmith, but a listener,an interactive improviser. The two altossynch sweetly on the undulating linear head tothe opener, as well as on their eponymous compositionalcollaboration. But the big surprise isKelly’s ballad playing. Her duet with Malone on“Just Friends” is stunning in its simplicity andfeeling—how can a teenager communicate thisdepth of expression? Taken at an unusuallydoleful pace, Kelly picks up attentively fromMalone’s atmospheric intro. She does not throwout an agenda; she’s open-eared but knows whatshe wants to communicate on a tonal level.“No Greater Love” pitches Kelly with Reid’sarco bass; Kelly takes part of the melody into thealtissimo range without fanfare and includes anunexpected cartwheeling phrase. Konitz is afeathery foil on “You Don’t Know What LoveIs,” with Kelly clocking Konitz and Malone’sphrases while confident about her own ideas.Konitz loves “Alone Together” as a duo; herethe altos puff perfect smoke rings together. Thissession isn’t all standard fare, as there are severalimprovised miniatures, including the intensecloser, “NY At Noon.” —Michael JacksonGRACEfulLEE: Subconscious Lee; Just Friends; GRACEfulLEE;There Is No Greater Love; You Don’t Know What Love Is; AloneTogether; Buzzing Around; Thingin’; Call Of The Spirits; NY AtNoon. (54:14)Personnel: Grace Kelly, Lee Konitz, alto saxophone; MattWilson, drums; Rufus Reid, bass; Russell Malone, guitar.» Ordering info: jslrecords.com» Ordering info: gracekellymusic.com86 DOWNBEAT November 2008
BOOKSby John McDonoughHow EllingtonPersonifiedGrace UnderPressure atNewportA relatively new genre in seriousjazz literature is the albumbiography. Ashley Kahn’squests on the making of KindOf Blue and A Love Supremesealed their iconic status inhardcover eternity. But thereare not many albums so incontrovertibly immortal that they couldsustain such book-length micro-histories. In Backstory In Blue:Ellington At Newport ’56 (Rutgers University Press), John FassMorton has claimed one of the bellwether prizes. Duke Ellington’ssui generis turn at the 1956 Newport Jazz Festival on“Diminuendo And Crescendo In Blue” was, in Morton’s words,“postwar pop culture’s first certified and recorded happening.”One difficulty in telling a small story casting a large shadow isbackground creep. Morton piles on a bit more than his mandaterequires. The book doesn’t arrive at the actual happening untilPage 101. But Morton ultimately delivers a gripping account of theriotous and dramatic night.The Ellington band was in decline, and he was unsure what thefuture held. Morton presents the Newport gig as a moment oftruth in which that future would be decided. Newport had becomethe epicenter of the jazz world, and the media was out in force tocover it. Time was looking for a peg for an Ellington cover story.Columbia was to record Newport, marking the band’s return towhat was the richest, most powerful promotional force in music.Ellington was worried that Saturday. He had prepared an originalwork in recognition of the evening’s importance, but it wasstill under-rehearsed and messy. Meanwhile, an overbooked lineupof musicians chewed up stage time and audience patience. Itwas 15 minutes before midnight when Ellington finally rallied hisweary men with a pep talk and led them to their date with fate.At that point, Morton’s book gets down to real business.Chapter 10 gives a detailed account of Ellington’s early set and theendless procession of players that followed. Chapter 11 retreatsfor a bio of hero-soloist Paul Gonsalves and a brief history of “D &C.” Chapter 12 goes through “Diminuendo” and into Gonsalves’early choruses, and Chapter 13 introduces readers to Morton’sother hero, or heroine, Elaine Anderson. With this book, she istransformed from an urban legend to a real person.Unfortunately, the LP of this landmark performance is out ofprint today. Morton might have probed a bit more deeply into thereissue purist Phil Schaap assembled in 1999. Declaring the original“phony” and a “subterfuge” because it mixed live performancewith studio remakes made to sound live, he combined theoriginal Columbia mono tape with a version recorded simultaneouslyby the Voice of America and produced a stereo master witha clearer rendering of the Gonsalves solo.If you want to understand why Backstory In Blue was written inthe first place, listen to George Avakian’s original mono LP for thetorrent and the spectacle. Then go to Schaap’s CD for the musicaldetail. Then read the book.DBOrdering info: rutgerspress.rutgers.eduNovember 2008 DOWNBEAT 87