een well established (Benecke 1999), theirrespective ecological niches and any overlap is stillunclear, particularly as many have been removedfrom European ecosystems for centuries or evenmillennia in some regions.However, recent ecological research has providedsome insight into inter-species competition.Solitary species such as elk and roe deer generallyavoid herd animals, although under predationpressure they have been known to seek protectionclose to herds of other large herbivores (WouterHelmer, personal communication, 2013). Ecologicalstudies have also suggested that in resource-richareas species will overlap, whereas in resource-poorareas species such as red deer and bison, as closeecological competitors, will demonstrate avoidancebehaviour (van de Vlasakker 2008). There arerecorded events of fighting between red deer andbison in the autumn during the rutting season(Catanoiu 2012), although these are rare. There mayalso be some resource competition between wildboar and bison during the autumn when acornsbecome readily available.Domestic cattle are used for grazingmanagement on many nature reserves acrossEurope, and it is often assumed that cattle and bisonare interchangeable in terms of their ecological role.However, although they are both generalist herbivores,their ecology does differ in several importantfeatures. <strong>Bison</strong> browse more than cattle and aremore selective in their forage choice (Heijn 2012),consuming more herbs, forbs, browse and bark. Astudy of a herd of bison in the Netherlands with noadditional feeding year-round showed four feedingpeaks (increased feeding activity) in contrast tocattle which have two (Leo Linnartz, personalcommunication, 2012). <strong>Bison</strong> can break throughvegetation and open up scrubland to reach theirfavoured food (Leo Linnartz, personal communication,2012), and also display a higher seasonalbehavioural variation than cattle, including rutting,migration and exploitation of seasonal variationin vegetation, which produces a higher degree ofspatial heterogeneity in the landscape. In terms ofhabitat, cattle seem to prefer open, wet environmentssuch as grasslands, whereas European bisontend to be found in open, dry areas (Heijn 2012). Therelative ecological impact of the presence of bothcattle and bison in the European landscape underno human management is unknown; however asEurope’s other large bovid, aurochs, was present inHolocene landscapes alongside European bison for16RUUD MAASKANT / ARK NATURE
GRZEGORZ LEŚNIEWSKI / WILD WONDERS OF EUROPEmany millennia, it is likely that they have distinctniches. Furthermore as domestic cattle rely onhumans they lack a role in the ecosystem as prey forpredators and scavengers.Recent accounts of predation on Europeanbison have generally been few and sporadic due tothe small numbers of large predators in areas suchas the Bialowieza forest. Following reintroductionof bison into the Polish Carpathians during the1960s, accounts of wolf (Canis lupus) and brownbear (Ursus arctos) eating bison began to appear,although it was not clear whether they had activelyhunted bison or were scavenging. There werereports in the Ukraine of four bison killed by bear,but due to the lack of evidence elsewhere for suchbehaviour, these incidents most likely involvedisolated, sick or injured bison (Cantanoiu 2012).Previous studies have shown that in areas withsufficient alternative prey, wolves will generallyavoid large herbivores, whereas in areas wherebison is the predominant herbivore, wolves canspecialise in hunting bison by forming largepacks, as is also known from North America e.g.Wood Buffalo National Park (Carbyn et al. 1993;van de Vlasakker 2008). Therefore, if wolf andbison numbers increase sufficiently, this couldbecome a possibility in Europe. In the Bialowiezaforest research showed that bison carcasses weremainly scavenged by ravens (Corvus corax), red fox(Vulpus vulpes), wolf and common buzzard (Buteobuteo) (Selva et al. 2003). Avian scavengers morefrequently visited bison carcasses placed in gladesthan those located in the forest (Selva et al. 2003;Catanoiu 2012), probably to avoid attacks fromother predators (e.g. goshawk (Accipiter gentilis),Eurasian eagle owl (Bubo bubo)).17