DISCRETE MATHEMATICS THROUGH GUIDED DISCOVERY ...
DISCRETE MATHEMATICS THROUGH GUIDED DISCOVERY ...
DISCRETE MATHEMATICS THROUGH GUIDED DISCOVERY ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
In the last few problems, you began with a set of lists and first you had<br />
to decide when two lists were equivalent representations of the objects you<br />
were trying to count. Then you drew the directed graph for that particular<br />
relation of equivalence. Go back to your digraphs and check that each vertex<br />
has an arrow to itself. This is what is meant when it is said that a relation is<br />
reflexive. Also, check that whenever you have an arrow from one vertex to<br />
a second, there is an arrow from the second back to the first. This is what is<br />
meant when a relation is said to be symmetric. There is another property<br />
of those relations you have graphed. Namely, whenever you have an arrow<br />
from L1 to L2 and an arrow from L2 to L3, then there is an arrow from<br />
L1 to L3. This is what is meant when a relation is said to be transitive.<br />
A relation on a set is called an equivalence relation on the set when it<br />
satisfies all three of these properties.<br />
91. If R is a relation on a finite set, how can the digraph be used to check<br />
whether or not the relation is reflexive? To check symmetry? To check<br />
transitivity?<br />
92. The matrix of a relation R on an n-element set {x1, . . . , xn} is defined<br />
to be the n × n matrix A whose (i, j) entry equals the number of edges<br />
from xi to xj in the associated digraph. For at least three relations<br />
on the set [4], find the adjacency matrix A and calculate A 2 . Use this<br />
information to formulate a conjecture about what is recorded in the<br />
entries of A 2 .<br />
93. Let B be the matrix obtained from the matrix A 2 by changing every<br />
positive entry to 1. Explain how the matrix A−B can be used to determine<br />
whether the relation is transitive. If the relation is not transitive,<br />
explain how the matrix A − B can be used to find a counterexample to<br />
transitivity.<br />
Check that each relation of equivalence in Problems 88, 89 and 90 satisfies<br />
the three properties, and so each is an equivalence relation. Carefully<br />
visualize the same three properties in the relations of equivalence that you<br />
use in the remaining problems of this chapter. Work through Appendix C<br />
if you would like more practice with checking whether or not a relation is<br />
an equivalence relation.<br />
You undoubtedly have noticed that for each of the equivalence relations<br />
you’ve considered so far, the digraph is divided into clumps of mutually<br />
connected vertices. In the next section you will show that this “clumping”<br />
property holds for all equivalence relations, and that it is exactly this<br />
property which makes equivalence relations a powerful tool for counting.<br />
41