Falabella - BICE Inversiones
Falabella - BICE Inversiones
Falabella - BICE Inversiones
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Renta Company Variable Update<br />
Local – Informe Empresas Retail<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong><br />
Lowering Target Price on conservative D-Stores view<br />
Target Price: CLP4,800 (Dec. 2012)<br />
Current Price: CLP4,662<br />
Financial Summary<br />
Bloomberg FALAB CI<br />
Credit Rating (Feller/Fitch) AA/AA<br />
52 weeks Hi/Lo ($) 5,282-3,716<br />
Current Price ($) 4,662<br />
Upside Potential 3.0%<br />
Stocks (million) 2,404.4<br />
Market Cap (US$ million) 23,110.6<br />
Float (%) 16.5%<br />
Average Daily Volume Traded 6M (US$ million)<br />
Estimates<br />
7.1<br />
2010 2011 2012E 2013E<br />
Revenues 4,430,429 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920<br />
Operating Income 594,942 649,920 733,154 810,358<br />
EBITDA 704,737 778,899 872,772 980,547<br />
Net Income 413,347 423,046 473,190 525,402<br />
EPS (CLP/Share) 171.9 176.0 196.8 218.5<br />
D/E<br />
Ratios<br />
0.9 1.0 0.9 0.9<br />
2010 2011 2012E 2013E<br />
FV/EBITDA 25.8x 17.9x 18.5x 16.8x<br />
FV/Revenue 4.1x 2.7x 2.8x 2.5x<br />
P/E 30.5x 23.0x 23.7x 21.3x<br />
Price/book 5.3x 3.4x 3.7x 3.3x<br />
FCF yield 3.1% 0.5% 1.8% 0.5%<br />
Dividend yield 0.7% 2.5% 1.4% 1.6%<br />
Relative Performance IPSA - <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
120<br />
110<br />
100<br />
90<br />
80<br />
70<br />
Jan-11<br />
Mar-11<br />
May-11<br />
Jul-11<br />
Aldo Morales<br />
562 692-3481<br />
amoralese@bice.cl<br />
Rodrigo Jacob<br />
562 692-2576<br />
rjacob@bice.cl<br />
Sep-11<br />
Nov-11<br />
IPSA <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
Jan-12<br />
Mar-12<br />
May-12<br />
Sell<br />
We are updating our year-end 2012 target price of <strong>Falabella</strong>, reducing it<br />
from CLP5,000 to CLP4,800 and downgrading from Hold to Sell.<br />
Considering an estimated dividend yield of 1.4% and an upside potential<br />
of 3.0%, we arrive at a total return of 4.4% per share. This compares to a<br />
10.2% estimated upside for the IPSA index over the same period.<br />
Investment thesis. We are basing our view on the following key factors:<br />
� New organic CAPEX. We are factoring in US$3,307 million in<br />
investments in fixed assets over the 2012-2015 period, destined to<br />
open 204 new Stores and 16 new Shopping Centers in the Region.<br />
This is in line with the company’s new announcement made in<br />
January 2012 (US$3,411 million) and will allow the company to<br />
reach 4,522,000 m 2 of sales space in 2015, a 67.2% increase<br />
compared to 2011.<br />
� A more conservative view on Chilean D-Store margins. After<br />
disappointing industry-wide results in Chilean Department stores in<br />
2H11 and 1Q12, we are lowering our EBITDA margin estimates for<br />
2012 and 2013 by 70bp and 90bp, respectively.<br />
� Postponing the expected reduction of the interest rate ceiling.<br />
In our last report, we considered the implementation of this<br />
regulatory change during 2012. After 5 months in Congress, there<br />
have been no new developments on this bill. We now see it coming<br />
into effect in 1Q13.<br />
� Pension Funds no longer overinvested. Last March, the pension<br />
funds eliminated their excess investments in <strong>Falabella</strong>. As of May<br />
2012 Pension Funds had a margin of US$250.7 million to invest in<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong>.<br />
� Limited impact from Argentine operations. As of December 2011,<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong>’s Argentine operations represented 7.4% of the company’s<br />
consolidated revenues and 3.4% of its EBITDA. In our view, the<br />
difficult outlook for retail companies in Argentina does not represent<br />
a serious threat to a diversified company like <strong>Falabella</strong>, given that, in<br />
terms of valuation, Argentina represents only a 0.6% of our<br />
estimated value of the shares.<br />
� Fair valuations. <strong>Falabella</strong> is currently trading at 2012E FV/EBITDA<br />
and 2012E P/E of 18.5x and 23.7x, which is 9.4% and 10.3% below<br />
its historical levels, respectively, being the lowest discount of our<br />
Chilean Retail sample. We think the market fairly values <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />
shares.<br />
Risk factors. The main risks related to our recommendation are: (i) a<br />
slowdown in global economic growth impacting Chilean consumer<br />
confidence; (ii) execution risks, including delays in store openings and<br />
lower-than-expected margin improvements; and (iii) larger-thananticipated<br />
effects on the interest ceiling reduction in Chile.<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong> June 20, 2012
We are factoring in<br />
14 new stores and<br />
1 additional<br />
Shopping Center<br />
when compared to<br />
our last report.<br />
We are forecasting<br />
the entire CAPEX<br />
for the next four<br />
years, in line with<br />
the announces<br />
made by the<br />
company.<br />
Investment Thesis<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
We are updating our year-end 2012 target price of <strong>Falabella</strong> from CLP5,000 to CLP4,800 and<br />
downgrading from Hold to Sell. Our investment thesis has changed essentially introducing a<br />
more conservative view on Chilean Department Store margins, an updated CAPEX and a delay<br />
in the implementation of a new, lower interest rate ceiling in Chile. We illustrate this with the<br />
following points:<br />
Introducing new organic CAPEX. We are factoring in US$3.307 million in fixed assets<br />
investments over the 2012-2015 period, to open 204 new stores and 16 new Shopping Centers in<br />
the Region. This is in line with the investment plan update announced by <strong>Falabella</strong> in January<br />
2012, which should allow the company to reach 4,522,000 m 2 in total space by 2015, an<br />
impressive 67.2% increase when compared to 2011. This CAPEX implies 14 new stores and 1<br />
additional Shopping Center with regard to our last report as of October 19 th , 2011.<br />
� Re-arranging CAPEX. After a weak investment performance through the last three<br />
years (2009-2011), when the company announced a total CAPEX of US$1,683 million,<br />
but only executing 49.4% of it, we are factoring in the company’s entire CAPEX for the<br />
next four years, given that management explained that the worsening in the<br />
macroeconomic environment observed in 2H11 forced them to be more cautious in the<br />
near-term investment program, thus deciding to re-arrange the CAPEX program. In<br />
particular, if we analyze <strong>Falabella</strong>’s track record over a longer time period, since 2006<br />
we see that over the entire period the company announced investments of US$2,794<br />
million, executing total investments of US$2,609 million, so we think there would<br />
probably be an accelerated process of store-openings.<br />
� Chile: focus on supermarkets and home Improvement. We are introducing a 141.5%<br />
and 40.5% increase in total square meters in the supermarket and home improvement<br />
formats in Chile for the 2012-2015 period. Regarding supermarkets (Tottus), we still<br />
have a cautious opinion about SMU’s acquisition of Supermercados del Sur, which<br />
would put pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s growth intentions. In particular, we are increasing<br />
Tottus’s EBITDA margin from the current 2.5% (2011) to 3.6% in 2015, still below<br />
average industry levels (4.5%). On the other hand, we share the company’s view about<br />
the possibility of expanding the home improvement operations to the extreme north and<br />
south regions in Chile.<br />
Figure 1. Expected Number of Store by Country<br />
2012 2013 2014 2015 Total %<br />
Expected Openings<br />
New Stores 45 56 53 50 204<br />
Malls 2 6 6 2 16<br />
Department Stores 10 12 11 10 43 19.5%<br />
Home Improvement 17 18 16 16 67 30.5%<br />
Supermarkets 18 26 26 24 94 42.7%<br />
Malls 2 6 6 2 16 7.3%<br />
Total 47 62 59 52 220 100%<br />
Chile 20 28 25 21 94 42.7%<br />
Argentina 2 2 2 2 8 3.6%<br />
Peru 19 24 25 22 90 40.9%<br />
Colombia 6 8 7 7 28 12.7%<br />
Total 47 62 59 52 220 100%<br />
2
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
Figure 2. Mall Plaza’s announced Projects<br />
Mall Plaza m2 US$ Ex.Opening Date US$/m2<br />
Announced projects<br />
Chile<br />
Mall Plaza Bio Bio 30,000 80 3T12 2,667<br />
Mall Plaza Egaña 80,000 175 1T13 2,188<br />
Mall Plaza Copiapó 37,000 75 1S13 2,027<br />
Mall Plaza Los Domínicos 87,000 218 2S14 2,506<br />
Peru<br />
Mall Plaza Sta. Anita (1) 57,000 69 2S12 1,211<br />
Colom bia<br />
Mall Plaza El Castillo (2) 26,000 80 1S12 3,077<br />
(1) Perú is a related company w ith a 20% share.<br />
(2) Colombia is a subsidiary w here Plaza S.A. controlls 70% of the shares.<br />
Figure 3. Expected m 2 Growth<br />
m 2 Grow th 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />
M2 Retail 1,643,397 1,932,697 2,271,897 2,588,097 2,888,797<br />
M2 Malls 1,061,000 1,166,000 1,465,000 1,558,000 1,633,000<br />
Retail m2 Grow th 17.6% 17.6% 13.9% 11.6%<br />
Malls m2 Grow th 9.9% 25.6% 6.3% 4.8%<br />
Accum. grow th Retail 17.6% 38.2% 57.5% 75.8%<br />
Accum. grow th Malls 9.9% 38.1% 46.8% 53.9%<br />
Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
� Foreign operations: taking advantage of good consumption perspectives in Peru<br />
and Colombia. We continue to have a positive view on the consumption outlook in<br />
Peru and Colombia. We think lower penetration levels compared to Chile, give the<br />
company an attractive environment to expand its current operations. In this way, we<br />
forecast a 141.6% and an 87.3% expansion in total m 2 for the 2012-2015 period in<br />
Peru and Colombia, respectively.<br />
Figure 4. <strong>Falabella</strong>’s expected EBITDA<br />
Breakdown<br />
1,600,000<br />
1,400,000<br />
1,200,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
800,000<br />
600,000<br />
400,000<br />
200,000<br />
0<br />
2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />
Chile Plaza Perú<br />
Argentina Colombia Banco Chile<br />
Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
3
We are lowering<br />
by 50bp and 70bp<br />
the gross margin<br />
of Chilean<br />
Department<br />
Stores in 2012<br />
and 2013<br />
compared to our<br />
previous<br />
estimate,<br />
reaching EBITDA<br />
margin of 7.3% in<br />
each year.<br />
We quantify the<br />
impact of this<br />
likely regulatory<br />
change in<br />
approximately<br />
CLP156 per share<br />
As of May,<br />
Pension Funds<br />
had a US$207.7<br />
million room to<br />
invest in <strong>Falabella</strong>.<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
A more conservative view on performance of Chilean Department Stores. We are including<br />
a more conservative view of the Chilean Department Store margins given the disappointing<br />
results showed by local companies in 2H11 and 1Q12. In particular, we are lowering the gross<br />
margin by 50bp and 70bp in 2012 and 2013 when compared to our previous estimates, reaching<br />
an EBITDA margin of 7.3% in each year. Our forecast still represents a 40bp improvement<br />
versus year-end 2011 levels, when the company reached a 6.9%. This is because we still see the<br />
recent performance as a baseline to the industry, as a result of a deficient inventory<br />
management, made with a six-month anticipation, considering higher consumption perspectives<br />
for 2H11, which did not materialize causing excess inventory liquidation. In addition, higher<br />
competence in Electronics and climate disturbance affected the Department Stores performance.<br />
Figure 5. Chilean D-Stores gross margin<br />
evolution<br />
32.0%<br />
31.0%<br />
30.0%<br />
29.0%<br />
28.0%<br />
27.0%<br />
26.0%<br />
25.0%<br />
24.0%<br />
23.0%<br />
22.0%<br />
21.0%<br />
20.0%<br />
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 1T12<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong> Paris Ripley<br />
Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
Postponing the reduction of the interest rate ceiling in Chile. We consider a CLP156 per<br />
share value erosion due to the implementation of this regulatory change in 1Q13.<br />
To quantify the impact of this bill on <strong>Falabella</strong> we considered the following:<br />
� 7.6% of CMR’s (<strong>Falabella</strong>’s Branch Credit) 2011 revenues came from charges not linked<br />
to the interest rate. Therefore, they should remain unaffected by the new bill.<br />
� We estimate that 70.4% of CMR’s 2011 revenues came from all loans excepting those<br />
that were less than 90 days overdue. We estimate that these loans charge an average<br />
interest rate of 23.5%, significantly below the reduced ceiling contemplated in the new<br />
bill.<br />
� <strong>Falabella</strong> charges the interest rate ceiling on loans that have been subject to loans that<br />
were less than 90 days overdue (before they are eventually written off). We estimate<br />
that this group of loans accounted for 22.1% of CMR’s 2011 revenues, and should be<br />
affected by the lowered interest rate ceiling.<br />
We are estimating a 140bp interest rate drop in 2013 on loans that were less than 90 days<br />
overdue, and further 50bp drop in progressive fashion. In addition, we apply a 5% decrease in<br />
loans in 2013. We quantify the impact of this likely regulatory change in approximately CLP156<br />
per share.<br />
Investment flows have also something to say. After particular non recurring events in the near<br />
term, we think it is important to highlight some additional pressures to the stock, produced by<br />
investment flows.<br />
� After the excess reduction, Pension Funds have room to invest. Last March,<br />
the pension funds reduced their excess investment in <strong>Falabella</strong>, after a regulatory<br />
change in March 2011 forced them to divest US$372.0 million over a 12-month<br />
period. In spite of that, pension funds now have room to invest in the company. In<br />
this regard, by May 2012 pension funds jointly held US$1,164.1 million in <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
shares, a 0.8% of their combined funds. Thus, as of May, Pension Funds had a<br />
US$250.7 million room to invest in the company<br />
4
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
Figure 6. Pension Fund’s Room to invest in <strong>Falabella</strong> (May 2012)<br />
US$ million A B C D E Total<br />
AFP <strong>Falabella</strong> Holding 249.8 250.0 518.8 134.9 10.6 1,164.1<br />
AFP AUM 25,178.5 25,779.5 56,781.5 21,235.7 12,510.9 141,486.1<br />
% of Fund 1.0% 1.0% 0.9% 0.6% 0.1% 0.8%<br />
AFP posible Investment 2.0 7.8 49.0 77.5 114.5 250.7<br />
Source: SAFP, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
� Additional pressure given the Cencosud capital increase. In our opinion, the<br />
large capital increase of approximately US$1,500 million announced by Cencosud<br />
will probably put additional pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares, due to the important<br />
amount of cash that investors will need in order to finance its participation. Finally, it<br />
is important to mention that last April, the Bethia Holding, one of <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />
controllers, part of the Solari family, made an important sell of 25,333,333 shares or<br />
1.05% of the company, which would put pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s investment flows in<br />
the short term too.<br />
A note about Argentine operation. We consider that further deterioration of the Argentine<br />
economic climate would not have important effects on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares.<br />
� Limited impact in terms of valuation. As of December 2011, the Argentine operations<br />
represented 7.4% of the consolidated revenues and 3.4% of EBITDA. In addition, given<br />
the internal restrictions and difficulties, the Argentine government limited the ability of<br />
international companies to take the cash flows out of Argentina. According to<br />
management, at this time cash flow generation in Argentina is not transferred to Chile,<br />
and will be reinvested domestically to finance the conservative investment plan. In this<br />
regard, we are estimating that only 3.3% of <strong>Falabella</strong>’s total CAPEX is destined to<br />
Argentina (US$100 million in the 2012-2015 period). In our model, Argentina accounts<br />
for only 0.6% of the company’s fair value, given the 19.4% WACC used to discount<br />
Argentine flows, compared to 10.8% in Chile.<br />
� Devaluation exercise. We are forecasting an exchange rate of AR$4.5 per one US<br />
dollar in 2012, and reaching AR$6.8 in the long term. In this regard, as an exercise, if<br />
we assume a devaluation from current AR$4.5 per US dollar to AR$7.0 from then on,<br />
we would have a negative impact of CLP5, reflecting the Argentine’s lower importance<br />
in our valuation.<br />
Potential changes to Chilean corporate tax rate. For a couple of years now, the idea of an<br />
increase in corporate tax rate has grown strong in Chilean politics. In particular, the government<br />
is proposing a comprehensive reform to the Chilean tax system, including a permanent increase<br />
in corporate taxes from the current 18.5%, to 20%. According to our estimates, an increase of<br />
150bp in the tax rate would have a negative impact of 0.6% in <strong>Falabella</strong>’s target price.<br />
Figure 7. Target Price’s sensitivity to Corporate Tax rate<br />
Tax Chile<br />
15.5% 4,855<br />
17.0% 4,827<br />
18.5% 4,800<br />
20.0% 4,772<br />
21.5% 4,743<br />
Source: SAFP, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
5
Shares would offer<br />
an expected 4.4%<br />
total return.<br />
Valuation<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
To value <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares we used a DCF model, in which we calculated the value of its<br />
different operations in Chile, Argentina, Peru and Colombia, discounting each operating cash<br />
flow between 2013 and 2022 and making adjustments for investments in fixed assets and<br />
working capital requirements. In this way, we reached a 2012 year-end target price of CLP4,800.<br />
Our calculation considers a nominal WACC rate of 10.8% for operations in Chile, based on a<br />
debt rate of 7.4% (using an unleveraged beta of 0.9) and a perpetuity growth of 4.0%. For the<br />
Argentinean operations we discounted the flows at a nominal WACC rate of 19.4%, with a<br />
nominal perpetuity growth of 11.1%, while Peruvian and Colombian operations were discounted<br />
at a nominal WACC rate of 10.7% and 10.6%, respectively, with perpetuity growth rates of 5.3%<br />
and 6.3%, respectively. Finally we valued Banco <strong>Falabella</strong>’s flows at a 12.9% rate with a<br />
dividend discount model. Our target price reflects a 3.0% upside over the current price, which in<br />
addition to the shares’ estimated dividend yield, results in a total return of 4.4% until December<br />
2012.<br />
Using a similar DCF model, but discounting cash flows between 2012 and 2021, we arrive at the<br />
current fair value of the shares of CLP4,500. This suggests that at current levels, the market<br />
fairly values the shares.<br />
Figure 8. Free Cash Flow<br />
$ millions 2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />
Operating Revenues 4,430,429 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351<br />
Total Expenses -3,835,487 -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564<br />
Net Operating Income 594,942 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787<br />
Tax -93,482 -114,155 -152,532 -172,093 -197,788 -236,786<br />
Depreciation 109,796 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547<br />
EBITDA 704,737 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334<br />
Change in Working Capital -72,432 -286,606 -127,428 -143,412 -425,197 -512,425<br />
Capex -148,688 -177,483 -386,507 -604,835 -609,140 -441,070<br />
Free Cash Flow 363,663 35,833 206,304 60,208 -102,025 147,053<br />
Source: <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates<br />
Figure 9. Valuation<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong> Chile Mall Plaza Peru Argentina Colombia Total<br />
VNA FC 2,700,876 201,140 478,352 -53,607 -165,429 3,161,332<br />
Perpetuity 4,566,928 578,295 3,407,834 130,651 1,729,704 10,413,412<br />
Cost of Equity 12.9% 12.9% 13.1% 22.9% 13.0%<br />
Cost of Debt 7.4% 7.4% 7.5% 17.3% 7.5%<br />
WACC 10.8% 10.8% 10.7% 19.4% 10.6% 11.1%<br />
Nominal Perpetuity Growth 4.0% 4.0% 5.3% 11.1% 6.3%<br />
Banco <strong>Falabella</strong> Chile 221,951<br />
Related Companies* 452,785<br />
Cash and Equivalents 181,618<br />
Financial Debt 2,464,171<br />
Minority Interes t 426,735<br />
Total Equity Value 11,540,193<br />
Shares Outstanding (million) 2,404<br />
Target Price <strong>Falabella</strong> (Dec-12) 4,800<br />
Source: <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates<br />
6
<strong>Falabella</strong><br />
currently<br />
trades at<br />
18.5x 2012E<br />
FV/EBITDA<br />
and at 23.7x<br />
2012E P/E.<br />
Looking at valuation multiples, we note that <strong>Falabella</strong> currently trades at 18.5x 2012E FV/EBITDA<br />
and at 23.7x 2012E P/E, which represents discounts of 9.4% and 10.3% respectively, compared to<br />
the company’s historical averages (20.4x FV/EBITDA and 26.4x P/E). In this regard, <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />
discount is the lowest of our Chilean Retail sample.<br />
In addition, compared with our 2012E target IPSA P/E ratio of 15.2x, which is 17.3% below the<br />
historical average, we can observe that again <strong>Falabella</strong> trades with a lower discount.<br />
Furthermore, the share’s average premium over its large cap Chilean peers is currently at 23.0% in<br />
FV/EBITDA 2012E, which is higher than the historical level of 17.1%. This, combined with the fact<br />
that the shares have outperformed the IPSA index by 11.6% YTD, are clear signs that <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />
expansion plan and its positive growth outlook in the Region have already been priced in by the<br />
market, thus leaving little room for any further upsides. This is consistent with our DCF valuation and<br />
target price as <strong>Falabella</strong>’s target multiples are already fair valued in this scenario.<br />
Figure 10. Retail Comparison Table<br />
Mkt Cap<br />
P/E FV/EBITDA<br />
Name MMUS$ Country LTM 2012E 2013E LTM 2012E 2013E<br />
<strong>Falabella</strong> Department Stores 22,631 Chile 28.1x 23.7x 21.3x 19.0x 18.5x 16.8x<br />
Cencosud Hypermarkets & Super Centers 14,307 Chile 22.3x 19.0x 15.4x 14.2x 11.5x 9.7x<br />
Ripley Department Stores 1,818 Chile 18.5x 14.3x 10.9x - 10.5x 8.8x<br />
Forus Footwear 1,019 Chile 17.7x 16.5x 13.9x 11.8x 11.9x 10.6x<br />
Hites Department Stores 274 Chile 11.0x 9.4x 8.3x 7.8x 6.9x 7.2x<br />
Chile Average 3,687 19.5x 16.4x 13.9x 12.8x 11.5x 9.9x<br />
Walmex Hypermarkets & Super Centers 47,618 Mexico 29.3x 25.9x 22.0x 17.2x 15.1x 13.0x<br />
Pao Acucar Hypermarkets & Super Centers 9,990 Brazil 26.6x 20.2x 16.2x 0.0x 7.7x 6.9x<br />
Liverpool Department Stores 10,333 Mexico 20.6x 20.0x 17.5x 14.2x 13.1x 11.8x<br />
Almacenes Éxito Hypermarkets & Super Centers 7,326 Colombia 27.5x 28.9x 24.8x 0.0x 12.2x 10.6x<br />
Lojas Americanas General Merchandise Stores 5,881 Brazil 37.3x 27.0x 19.4x 0.0x 9.3x 7.5x<br />
Soriana Hypermarkets & Super Centers 4,969 Mexico 21.1x 17.9x 15.6x 10.3x 9.4x 8.6x<br />
Lojas Renner Department Stores 3,665 Brazil 22.7x 19.5x 16.3x 13.8x 11.3x 9.3x<br />
Cia. Hering Apparel Retail 3,428 Brazil 21.8x 18.9x 15.5x 0.0x 13.4x 10.8x<br />
Famsa Department Stores 380 Mexico 15.3x 16.2x 12.0x 11.6x 10.2x 9.1x<br />
LatAm Average 10,399 24.7x 21.6x 17.7x 13.4x 11.3x 9.7x<br />
Walmart Hypermarkets & Super Centers 229,438 EE.UU. 14.7x 13.8x 12.7x 8.0x 7.7x 7.4x<br />
Home Depot Home Improvement Retail 81,079 EE.UU. 20.3x 18.0x 15.9x 10.3x 9.7x 9.1x<br />
Target General Merchandise Stores 38,813 EE.UU. 13.3x 13.5x 12.0x 7.4x 7.4x 7.0x<br />
Lowe's Home Improvement Retail 33,584 EE.UU. 16.3x 15.6x 12.8x 8.0x 7.4x 6.9x<br />
TJX Apparel Retail 32,217 EE.UU. 20.2x 18.0x 16.1x 9.8x 9.0x 8.4x<br />
Macy's Department Stores 15,357 EE.UU. 12.3x 11.0x 9.7x 5.8x 5.5x 5.2x<br />
Kohls Corp Department Stores 10,654 EE.UU. 10.3x 9.5x 8.5x 4.8x 4.7x 4.6x<br />
J.C. Penney Department Stores 4,864 EE.UU. - 18.1x 8.9x 11.5x 6.6x 4.6x<br />
EE.UU. Average 55,751 15.3x 14.7x 12.1x 8.2x 7.2x 6.7x<br />
Golden Eagle Retail-Regnl Dept Store 3,958 China 20.8x 17.9x 14.5x 13.7x 11.4x 9.1x<br />
Intime Retail-Major Dept Store 1,959 China 14.5x 12.9x 11.3x 14.6x 10.2x 8.3x<br />
Parkson Retail-Major Dept Store 2,550 China 14.4x 13.1x 11.2x 8.1x 7.5x 6.4x<br />
Shoprite Food-Retail 10,695 South Africa 27.9x 24.9x 21.0x 15.2x 15.4x 13.2x<br />
Asia & Africa Average<br />
Source: Bloomberg and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />
4,791 19.4x 17.2x 14.5x 12.9x 11.1x 9.3x<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
7
<strong>Falabella</strong> – Financial Statements<br />
Income Statement<br />
$ m illions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />
Operating Revenues 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351 10,394,846<br />
Total Expenses -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564 -9,151,996<br />
Net Operating Income 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787 1,242,849<br />
Net Operating Margin 12.6% 12.9% 12.4% 11.8% 11.7% 12.0%<br />
Non Operational Results -68,093 -68,123 -69,218 -70,668 -80,587 -79,895<br />
Income before taxes 581,827 665,031 741,140 837,965 987,199 1,162,954<br />
Tax -114,155 -152,532 -172,093 -197,788 -236,786 -282,152<br />
Minority Interest -44,626 -39,309 -43,646 -49,102 -57,557 -67,558<br />
Net Incom e 423,046 473,190 525,402 591,075 692,857 813,245<br />
Net Margin 8.2% 8.3% 8.0% 7.7% 7.6% 7.8%<br />
EBITDA 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334 1,539,431<br />
EBITDA Margin 15.1% 15.4% 15.0% 14.7% 14.7% 14.8%<br />
Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates.<br />
Balance Sheet<br />
$ millions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />
Current Assets 2,451,316 2,592,932 2,720,167 3,018,616 3,263,145 3,438,640<br />
Non Current Assets 1,647,793 1,939,420 2,428,601 2,887,238 3,145,133 3,258,783<br />
Total Assets 7,764,096 8,359,951 9,030,767 10,021,641 10,648,208 10,995,799<br />
Current Liabilities 2,267,951 2,398,974 2,516,691 2,792,815 3,019,053 3,181,421<br />
Financial Liabilities 3,306,108 3,422,704 3,567,810 4,040,301 4,110,634 3,933,978<br />
Total Liabilities 4,465,203 4,714,782 5,002,153 5,664,653 5,953,008 5,972,355<br />
Minority Interest 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916<br />
Total Equity 2,718,976 3,065,253 3,448,697 3,777,072 4,115,284 4,443,528<br />
Total Liabilities + Equity 7,764,096 8,359,951 9,030,767 10,021,641 10,648,208 10,995,799<br />
Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates<br />
Cash Flow<br />
$ m illions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />
Operating Revenues 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351 10,394,846<br />
Total Expenses -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564 -9,151,996<br />
Net Operating Income 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787 1,242,849<br />
Depreciation and Amortization 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547 296,582<br />
EBITDA 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334 1,539,431<br />
Net Income 423,046 473,190 525,402 591,075 692,857 813,245<br />
+ Depreciation and Amortization 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547 296,582<br />
+ Financial Expenses 68,774 88,606 91,731 95,620 108,283 110,168<br />
- Financial Income -6,729 -7,396 -8,516 -10,044 -11,878 -13,545<br />
+ Monetary Adjustments 35,590 0 0 0 0 0<br />
- Profit/Loss Related Companies -13,087 -13,087 -13,997 -14,907 -15,817 -16,727<br />
- Minoritary Interest 44,626 39,309 43,646 49,102 57,557 67,558<br />
- Investment in Fixed Assets -177,483 -386,507 -604,835 -609,140 -441,070 -315,197<br />
- Change in Working Capital* -286,606 66,377 11,249 14,662 16,683 15,171<br />
- Financial Working Capital 0 -193,805 -154,661 -439,860 -529,109 -499,117<br />
- Investment in Other Assets -164,823 0 0 0 0 0<br />
Free Cash Flow 52,287 206,304 60,208 -102,025 147,053 458,135<br />
* No n Financial<br />
Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
8
Research Team<br />
DISCLAIMER<br />
Rodrigo Jacob G.<br />
Head of Research<br />
rjacob@bice.cl<br />
Mabel Weber A.<br />
Senior Analyst<br />
mweber@bice.cl<br />
Aldo Morales E.<br />
Analyst<br />
amoralese@bice.cl<br />
<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />
Cristóbal Doberti D.<br />
Chief Economist<br />
cdoberti@bice.cl<br />
Sebastián Senzacqua B.<br />
Economist<br />
ssenzacqua@bice.cl<br />
Claudia Cavada S.<br />
Analyst<br />
ccavada@bice.cl<br />
The analyst or analysts involved in the creation of this document hereby certify that the views expressed in this document<br />
accurately reflect their personal opinions and that they have not and will not receive direct or indirect compensation for<br />
expressing specific recommendations or views in this report. This report has been prepared by <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and is<br />
subject to change without notice. <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and employees shall have no obligation to update or amend any<br />
information contained herein. This report is for informational purposes only, based upon publicly available information, which<br />
we believed is reliable, but its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> makes no express or<br />
implied representations or warranties that such information is accurate or complete and, therefore, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and<br />
employees shall not in any way be liable for related claims. The information and analyses contained herein are not intended<br />
as tax, legal, or investment advice and may not be suitable for your specific circumstances. Each investor shall make their<br />
own determination of the suitability of an investment of any securities referred to herein and should consult their own tax,<br />
legal, investment, or other advisors, to determine such suitability. This report may discuss numerous securities, some of<br />
which may not be qualified for sale in certain countries or states therein and may therefore not be offered to investors in<br />
such countries or states. This report or any portion hereof may not be reproduced, reprinted, sold or distributed without the<br />
written consent of <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong>.<br />
9