30.11.2012 Views

Falabella - BICE Inversiones

Falabella - BICE Inversiones

Falabella - BICE Inversiones

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Renta Company Variable Update<br />

Local – Informe Empresas Retail<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong><br />

Lowering Target Price on conservative D-Stores view<br />

Target Price: CLP4,800 (Dec. 2012)<br />

Current Price: CLP4,662<br />

Financial Summary<br />

Bloomberg FALAB CI<br />

Credit Rating (Feller/Fitch) AA/AA<br />

52 weeks Hi/Lo ($) 5,282-3,716<br />

Current Price ($) 4,662<br />

Upside Potential 3.0%<br />

Stocks (million) 2,404.4<br />

Market Cap (US$ million) 23,110.6<br />

Float (%) 16.5%<br />

Average Daily Volume Traded 6M (US$ million)<br />

Estimates<br />

7.1<br />

2010 2011 2012E 2013E<br />

Revenues 4,430,429 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920<br />

Operating Income 594,942 649,920 733,154 810,358<br />

EBITDA 704,737 778,899 872,772 980,547<br />

Net Income 413,347 423,046 473,190 525,402<br />

EPS (CLP/Share) 171.9 176.0 196.8 218.5<br />

D/E<br />

Ratios<br />

0.9 1.0 0.9 0.9<br />

2010 2011 2012E 2013E<br />

FV/EBITDA 25.8x 17.9x 18.5x 16.8x<br />

FV/Revenue 4.1x 2.7x 2.8x 2.5x<br />

P/E 30.5x 23.0x 23.7x 21.3x<br />

Price/book 5.3x 3.4x 3.7x 3.3x<br />

FCF yield 3.1% 0.5% 1.8% 0.5%<br />

Dividend yield 0.7% 2.5% 1.4% 1.6%<br />

Relative Performance IPSA - <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

120<br />

110<br />

100<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

Jan-11<br />

Mar-11<br />

May-11<br />

Jul-11<br />

Aldo Morales<br />

562 692-3481<br />

amoralese@bice.cl<br />

Rodrigo Jacob<br />

562 692-2576<br />

rjacob@bice.cl<br />

Sep-11<br />

Nov-11<br />

IPSA <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

Jan-12<br />

Mar-12<br />

May-12<br />

Sell<br />

We are updating our year-end 2012 target price of <strong>Falabella</strong>, reducing it<br />

from CLP5,000 to CLP4,800 and downgrading from Hold to Sell.<br />

Considering an estimated dividend yield of 1.4% and an upside potential<br />

of 3.0%, we arrive at a total return of 4.4% per share. This compares to a<br />

10.2% estimated upside for the IPSA index over the same period.<br />

Investment thesis. We are basing our view on the following key factors:<br />

� New organic CAPEX. We are factoring in US$3,307 million in<br />

investments in fixed assets over the 2012-2015 period, destined to<br />

open 204 new Stores and 16 new Shopping Centers in the Region.<br />

This is in line with the company’s new announcement made in<br />

January 2012 (US$3,411 million) and will allow the company to<br />

reach 4,522,000 m 2 of sales space in 2015, a 67.2% increase<br />

compared to 2011.<br />

� A more conservative view on Chilean D-Store margins. After<br />

disappointing industry-wide results in Chilean Department stores in<br />

2H11 and 1Q12, we are lowering our EBITDA margin estimates for<br />

2012 and 2013 by 70bp and 90bp, respectively.<br />

� Postponing the expected reduction of the interest rate ceiling.<br />

In our last report, we considered the implementation of this<br />

regulatory change during 2012. After 5 months in Congress, there<br />

have been no new developments on this bill. We now see it coming<br />

into effect in 1Q13.<br />

� Pension Funds no longer overinvested. Last March, the pension<br />

funds eliminated their excess investments in <strong>Falabella</strong>. As of May<br />

2012 Pension Funds had a margin of US$250.7 million to invest in<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong>.<br />

� Limited impact from Argentine operations. As of December 2011,<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong>’s Argentine operations represented 7.4% of the company’s<br />

consolidated revenues and 3.4% of its EBITDA. In our view, the<br />

difficult outlook for retail companies in Argentina does not represent<br />

a serious threat to a diversified company like <strong>Falabella</strong>, given that, in<br />

terms of valuation, Argentina represents only a 0.6% of our<br />

estimated value of the shares.<br />

� Fair valuations. <strong>Falabella</strong> is currently trading at 2012E FV/EBITDA<br />

and 2012E P/E of 18.5x and 23.7x, which is 9.4% and 10.3% below<br />

its historical levels, respectively, being the lowest discount of our<br />

Chilean Retail sample. We think the market fairly values <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />

shares.<br />

Risk factors. The main risks related to our recommendation are: (i) a<br />

slowdown in global economic growth impacting Chilean consumer<br />

confidence; (ii) execution risks, including delays in store openings and<br />

lower-than-expected margin improvements; and (iii) larger-thananticipated<br />

effects on the interest ceiling reduction in Chile.<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong> June 20, 2012


We are factoring in<br />

14 new stores and<br />

1 additional<br />

Shopping Center<br />

when compared to<br />

our last report.<br />

We are forecasting<br />

the entire CAPEX<br />

for the next four<br />

years, in line with<br />

the announces<br />

made by the<br />

company.<br />

Investment Thesis<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

We are updating our year-end 2012 target price of <strong>Falabella</strong> from CLP5,000 to CLP4,800 and<br />

downgrading from Hold to Sell. Our investment thesis has changed essentially introducing a<br />

more conservative view on Chilean Department Store margins, an updated CAPEX and a delay<br />

in the implementation of a new, lower interest rate ceiling in Chile. We illustrate this with the<br />

following points:<br />

Introducing new organic CAPEX. We are factoring in US$3.307 million in fixed assets<br />

investments over the 2012-2015 period, to open 204 new stores and 16 new Shopping Centers in<br />

the Region. This is in line with the investment plan update announced by <strong>Falabella</strong> in January<br />

2012, which should allow the company to reach 4,522,000 m 2 in total space by 2015, an<br />

impressive 67.2% increase when compared to 2011. This CAPEX implies 14 new stores and 1<br />

additional Shopping Center with regard to our last report as of October 19 th , 2011.<br />

� Re-arranging CAPEX. After a weak investment performance through the last three<br />

years (2009-2011), when the company announced a total CAPEX of US$1,683 million,<br />

but only executing 49.4% of it, we are factoring in the company’s entire CAPEX for the<br />

next four years, given that management explained that the worsening in the<br />

macroeconomic environment observed in 2H11 forced them to be more cautious in the<br />

near-term investment program, thus deciding to re-arrange the CAPEX program. In<br />

particular, if we analyze <strong>Falabella</strong>’s track record over a longer time period, since 2006<br />

we see that over the entire period the company announced investments of US$2,794<br />

million, executing total investments of US$2,609 million, so we think there would<br />

probably be an accelerated process of store-openings.<br />

� Chile: focus on supermarkets and home Improvement. We are introducing a 141.5%<br />

and 40.5% increase in total square meters in the supermarket and home improvement<br />

formats in Chile for the 2012-2015 period. Regarding supermarkets (Tottus), we still<br />

have a cautious opinion about SMU’s acquisition of Supermercados del Sur, which<br />

would put pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s growth intentions. In particular, we are increasing<br />

Tottus’s EBITDA margin from the current 2.5% (2011) to 3.6% in 2015, still below<br />

average industry levels (4.5%). On the other hand, we share the company’s view about<br />

the possibility of expanding the home improvement operations to the extreme north and<br />

south regions in Chile.<br />

Figure 1. Expected Number of Store by Country<br />

2012 2013 2014 2015 Total %<br />

Expected Openings<br />

New Stores 45 56 53 50 204<br />

Malls 2 6 6 2 16<br />

Department Stores 10 12 11 10 43 19.5%<br />

Home Improvement 17 18 16 16 67 30.5%<br />

Supermarkets 18 26 26 24 94 42.7%<br />

Malls 2 6 6 2 16 7.3%<br />

Total 47 62 59 52 220 100%<br />

Chile 20 28 25 21 94 42.7%<br />

Argentina 2 2 2 2 8 3.6%<br />

Peru 19 24 25 22 90 40.9%<br />

Colombia 6 8 7 7 28 12.7%<br />

Total 47 62 59 52 220 100%<br />

2


<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

Figure 2. Mall Plaza’s announced Projects<br />

Mall Plaza m2 US$ Ex.Opening Date US$/m2<br />

Announced projects<br />

Chile<br />

Mall Plaza Bio Bio 30,000 80 3T12 2,667<br />

Mall Plaza Egaña 80,000 175 1T13 2,188<br />

Mall Plaza Copiapó 37,000 75 1S13 2,027<br />

Mall Plaza Los Domínicos 87,000 218 2S14 2,506<br />

Peru<br />

Mall Plaza Sta. Anita (1) 57,000 69 2S12 1,211<br />

Colom bia<br />

Mall Plaza El Castillo (2) 26,000 80 1S12 3,077<br />

(1) Perú is a related company w ith a 20% share.<br />

(2) Colombia is a subsidiary w here Plaza S.A. controlls 70% of the shares.<br />

Figure 3. Expected m 2 Growth<br />

m 2 Grow th 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />

M2 Retail 1,643,397 1,932,697 2,271,897 2,588,097 2,888,797<br />

M2 Malls 1,061,000 1,166,000 1,465,000 1,558,000 1,633,000<br />

Retail m2 Grow th 17.6% 17.6% 13.9% 11.6%<br />

Malls m2 Grow th 9.9% 25.6% 6.3% 4.8%<br />

Accum. grow th Retail 17.6% 38.2% 57.5% 75.8%<br />

Accum. grow th Malls 9.9% 38.1% 46.8% 53.9%<br />

Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

� Foreign operations: taking advantage of good consumption perspectives in Peru<br />

and Colombia. We continue to have a positive view on the consumption outlook in<br />

Peru and Colombia. We think lower penetration levels compared to Chile, give the<br />

company an attractive environment to expand its current operations. In this way, we<br />

forecast a 141.6% and an 87.3% expansion in total m 2 for the 2012-2015 period in<br />

Peru and Colombia, respectively.<br />

Figure 4. <strong>Falabella</strong>’s expected EBITDA<br />

Breakdown<br />

1,600,000<br />

1,400,000<br />

1,200,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

800,000<br />

600,000<br />

400,000<br />

200,000<br />

0<br />

2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />

Chile Plaza Perú<br />

Argentina Colombia Banco Chile<br />

Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

3


We are lowering<br />

by 50bp and 70bp<br />

the gross margin<br />

of Chilean<br />

Department<br />

Stores in 2012<br />

and 2013<br />

compared to our<br />

previous<br />

estimate,<br />

reaching EBITDA<br />

margin of 7.3% in<br />

each year.<br />

We quantify the<br />

impact of this<br />

likely regulatory<br />

change in<br />

approximately<br />

CLP156 per share<br />

As of May,<br />

Pension Funds<br />

had a US$207.7<br />

million room to<br />

invest in <strong>Falabella</strong>.<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

A more conservative view on performance of Chilean Department Stores. We are including<br />

a more conservative view of the Chilean Department Store margins given the disappointing<br />

results showed by local companies in 2H11 and 1Q12. In particular, we are lowering the gross<br />

margin by 50bp and 70bp in 2012 and 2013 when compared to our previous estimates, reaching<br />

an EBITDA margin of 7.3% in each year. Our forecast still represents a 40bp improvement<br />

versus year-end 2011 levels, when the company reached a 6.9%. This is because we still see the<br />

recent performance as a baseline to the industry, as a result of a deficient inventory<br />

management, made with a six-month anticipation, considering higher consumption perspectives<br />

for 2H11, which did not materialize causing excess inventory liquidation. In addition, higher<br />

competence in Electronics and climate disturbance affected the Department Stores performance.<br />

Figure 5. Chilean D-Stores gross margin<br />

evolution<br />

32.0%<br />

31.0%<br />

30.0%<br />

29.0%<br />

28.0%<br />

27.0%<br />

26.0%<br />

25.0%<br />

24.0%<br />

23.0%<br />

22.0%<br />

21.0%<br />

20.0%<br />

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 1T12<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong> Paris Ripley<br />

Source: Company Reports, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

Postponing the reduction of the interest rate ceiling in Chile. We consider a CLP156 per<br />

share value erosion due to the implementation of this regulatory change in 1Q13.<br />

To quantify the impact of this bill on <strong>Falabella</strong> we considered the following:<br />

� 7.6% of CMR’s (<strong>Falabella</strong>’s Branch Credit) 2011 revenues came from charges not linked<br />

to the interest rate. Therefore, they should remain unaffected by the new bill.<br />

� We estimate that 70.4% of CMR’s 2011 revenues came from all loans excepting those<br />

that were less than 90 days overdue. We estimate that these loans charge an average<br />

interest rate of 23.5%, significantly below the reduced ceiling contemplated in the new<br />

bill.<br />

� <strong>Falabella</strong> charges the interest rate ceiling on loans that have been subject to loans that<br />

were less than 90 days overdue (before they are eventually written off). We estimate<br />

that this group of loans accounted for 22.1% of CMR’s 2011 revenues, and should be<br />

affected by the lowered interest rate ceiling.<br />

We are estimating a 140bp interest rate drop in 2013 on loans that were less than 90 days<br />

overdue, and further 50bp drop in progressive fashion. In addition, we apply a 5% decrease in<br />

loans in 2013. We quantify the impact of this likely regulatory change in approximately CLP156<br />

per share.<br />

Investment flows have also something to say. After particular non recurring events in the near<br />

term, we think it is important to highlight some additional pressures to the stock, produced by<br />

investment flows.<br />

� After the excess reduction, Pension Funds have room to invest. Last March,<br />

the pension funds reduced their excess investment in <strong>Falabella</strong>, after a regulatory<br />

change in March 2011 forced them to divest US$372.0 million over a 12-month<br />

period. In spite of that, pension funds now have room to invest in the company. In<br />

this regard, by May 2012 pension funds jointly held US$1,164.1 million in <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

shares, a 0.8% of their combined funds. Thus, as of May, Pension Funds had a<br />

US$250.7 million room to invest in the company<br />

4


<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

Figure 6. Pension Fund’s Room to invest in <strong>Falabella</strong> (May 2012)<br />

US$ million A B C D E Total<br />

AFP <strong>Falabella</strong> Holding 249.8 250.0 518.8 134.9 10.6 1,164.1<br />

AFP AUM 25,178.5 25,779.5 56,781.5 21,235.7 12,510.9 141,486.1<br />

% of Fund 1.0% 1.0% 0.9% 0.6% 0.1% 0.8%<br />

AFP posible Investment 2.0 7.8 49.0 77.5 114.5 250.7<br />

Source: SAFP, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

� Additional pressure given the Cencosud capital increase. In our opinion, the<br />

large capital increase of approximately US$1,500 million announced by Cencosud<br />

will probably put additional pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares, due to the important<br />

amount of cash that investors will need in order to finance its participation. Finally, it<br />

is important to mention that last April, the Bethia Holding, one of <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />

controllers, part of the Solari family, made an important sell of 25,333,333 shares or<br />

1.05% of the company, which would put pressure on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s investment flows in<br />

the short term too.<br />

A note about Argentine operation. We consider that further deterioration of the Argentine<br />

economic climate would not have important effects on <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares.<br />

� Limited impact in terms of valuation. As of December 2011, the Argentine operations<br />

represented 7.4% of the consolidated revenues and 3.4% of EBITDA. In addition, given<br />

the internal restrictions and difficulties, the Argentine government limited the ability of<br />

international companies to take the cash flows out of Argentina. According to<br />

management, at this time cash flow generation in Argentina is not transferred to Chile,<br />

and will be reinvested domestically to finance the conservative investment plan. In this<br />

regard, we are estimating that only 3.3% of <strong>Falabella</strong>’s total CAPEX is destined to<br />

Argentina (US$100 million in the 2012-2015 period). In our model, Argentina accounts<br />

for only 0.6% of the company’s fair value, given the 19.4% WACC used to discount<br />

Argentine flows, compared to 10.8% in Chile.<br />

� Devaluation exercise. We are forecasting an exchange rate of AR$4.5 per one US<br />

dollar in 2012, and reaching AR$6.8 in the long term. In this regard, as an exercise, if<br />

we assume a devaluation from current AR$4.5 per US dollar to AR$7.0 from then on,<br />

we would have a negative impact of CLP5, reflecting the Argentine’s lower importance<br />

in our valuation.<br />

Potential changes to Chilean corporate tax rate. For a couple of years now, the idea of an<br />

increase in corporate tax rate has grown strong in Chilean politics. In particular, the government<br />

is proposing a comprehensive reform to the Chilean tax system, including a permanent increase<br />

in corporate taxes from the current 18.5%, to 20%. According to our estimates, an increase of<br />

150bp in the tax rate would have a negative impact of 0.6% in <strong>Falabella</strong>’s target price.<br />

Figure 7. Target Price’s sensitivity to Corporate Tax rate<br />

Tax Chile<br />

15.5% 4,855<br />

17.0% 4,827<br />

18.5% 4,800<br />

20.0% 4,772<br />

21.5% 4,743<br />

Source: SAFP, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

5


Shares would offer<br />

an expected 4.4%<br />

total return.<br />

Valuation<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

To value <strong>Falabella</strong>’s shares we used a DCF model, in which we calculated the value of its<br />

different operations in Chile, Argentina, Peru and Colombia, discounting each operating cash<br />

flow between 2013 and 2022 and making adjustments for investments in fixed assets and<br />

working capital requirements. In this way, we reached a 2012 year-end target price of CLP4,800.<br />

Our calculation considers a nominal WACC rate of 10.8% for operations in Chile, based on a<br />

debt rate of 7.4% (using an unleveraged beta of 0.9) and a perpetuity growth of 4.0%. For the<br />

Argentinean operations we discounted the flows at a nominal WACC rate of 19.4%, with a<br />

nominal perpetuity growth of 11.1%, while Peruvian and Colombian operations were discounted<br />

at a nominal WACC rate of 10.7% and 10.6%, respectively, with perpetuity growth rates of 5.3%<br />

and 6.3%, respectively. Finally we valued Banco <strong>Falabella</strong>’s flows at a 12.9% rate with a<br />

dividend discount model. Our target price reflects a 3.0% upside over the current price, which in<br />

addition to the shares’ estimated dividend yield, results in a total return of 4.4% until December<br />

2012.<br />

Using a similar DCF model, but discounting cash flows between 2012 and 2021, we arrive at the<br />

current fair value of the shares of CLP4,500. This suggests that at current levels, the market<br />

fairly values the shares.<br />

Figure 8. Free Cash Flow<br />

$ millions 2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E<br />

Operating Revenues 4,430,429 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351<br />

Total Expenses -3,835,487 -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564<br />

Net Operating Income 594,942 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787<br />

Tax -93,482 -114,155 -152,532 -172,093 -197,788 -236,786<br />

Depreciation 109,796 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547<br />

EBITDA 704,737 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334<br />

Change in Working Capital -72,432 -286,606 -127,428 -143,412 -425,197 -512,425<br />

Capex -148,688 -177,483 -386,507 -604,835 -609,140 -441,070<br />

Free Cash Flow 363,663 35,833 206,304 60,208 -102,025 147,053<br />

Source: <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates<br />

Figure 9. Valuation<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong> Chile Mall Plaza Peru Argentina Colombia Total<br />

VNA FC 2,700,876 201,140 478,352 -53,607 -165,429 3,161,332<br />

Perpetuity 4,566,928 578,295 3,407,834 130,651 1,729,704 10,413,412<br />

Cost of Equity 12.9% 12.9% 13.1% 22.9% 13.0%<br />

Cost of Debt 7.4% 7.4% 7.5% 17.3% 7.5%<br />

WACC 10.8% 10.8% 10.7% 19.4% 10.6% 11.1%<br />

Nominal Perpetuity Growth 4.0% 4.0% 5.3% 11.1% 6.3%<br />

Banco <strong>Falabella</strong> Chile 221,951<br />

Related Companies* 452,785<br />

Cash and Equivalents 181,618<br />

Financial Debt 2,464,171<br />

Minority Interes t 426,735<br />

Total Equity Value 11,540,193<br />

Shares Outstanding (million) 2,404<br />

Target Price <strong>Falabella</strong> (Dec-12) 4,800<br />

Source: <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates<br />

6


<strong>Falabella</strong><br />

currently<br />

trades at<br />

18.5x 2012E<br />

FV/EBITDA<br />

and at 23.7x<br />

2012E P/E.<br />

Looking at valuation multiples, we note that <strong>Falabella</strong> currently trades at 18.5x 2012E FV/EBITDA<br />

and at 23.7x 2012E P/E, which represents discounts of 9.4% and 10.3% respectively, compared to<br />

the company’s historical averages (20.4x FV/EBITDA and 26.4x P/E). In this regard, <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />

discount is the lowest of our Chilean Retail sample.<br />

In addition, compared with our 2012E target IPSA P/E ratio of 15.2x, which is 17.3% below the<br />

historical average, we can observe that again <strong>Falabella</strong> trades with a lower discount.<br />

Furthermore, the share’s average premium over its large cap Chilean peers is currently at 23.0% in<br />

FV/EBITDA 2012E, which is higher than the historical level of 17.1%. This, combined with the fact<br />

that the shares have outperformed the IPSA index by 11.6% YTD, are clear signs that <strong>Falabella</strong>’s<br />

expansion plan and its positive growth outlook in the Region have already been priced in by the<br />

market, thus leaving little room for any further upsides. This is consistent with our DCF valuation and<br />

target price as <strong>Falabella</strong>’s target multiples are already fair valued in this scenario.<br />

Figure 10. Retail Comparison Table<br />

Mkt Cap<br />

P/E FV/EBITDA<br />

Name MMUS$ Country LTM 2012E 2013E LTM 2012E 2013E<br />

<strong>Falabella</strong> Department Stores 22,631 Chile 28.1x 23.7x 21.3x 19.0x 18.5x 16.8x<br />

Cencosud Hypermarkets & Super Centers 14,307 Chile 22.3x 19.0x 15.4x 14.2x 11.5x 9.7x<br />

Ripley Department Stores 1,818 Chile 18.5x 14.3x 10.9x - 10.5x 8.8x<br />

Forus Footwear 1,019 Chile 17.7x 16.5x 13.9x 11.8x 11.9x 10.6x<br />

Hites Department Stores 274 Chile 11.0x 9.4x 8.3x 7.8x 6.9x 7.2x<br />

Chile Average 3,687 19.5x 16.4x 13.9x 12.8x 11.5x 9.9x<br />

Walmex Hypermarkets & Super Centers 47,618 Mexico 29.3x 25.9x 22.0x 17.2x 15.1x 13.0x<br />

Pao Acucar Hypermarkets & Super Centers 9,990 Brazil 26.6x 20.2x 16.2x 0.0x 7.7x 6.9x<br />

Liverpool Department Stores 10,333 Mexico 20.6x 20.0x 17.5x 14.2x 13.1x 11.8x<br />

Almacenes Éxito Hypermarkets & Super Centers 7,326 Colombia 27.5x 28.9x 24.8x 0.0x 12.2x 10.6x<br />

Lojas Americanas General Merchandise Stores 5,881 Brazil 37.3x 27.0x 19.4x 0.0x 9.3x 7.5x<br />

Soriana Hypermarkets & Super Centers 4,969 Mexico 21.1x 17.9x 15.6x 10.3x 9.4x 8.6x<br />

Lojas Renner Department Stores 3,665 Brazil 22.7x 19.5x 16.3x 13.8x 11.3x 9.3x<br />

Cia. Hering Apparel Retail 3,428 Brazil 21.8x 18.9x 15.5x 0.0x 13.4x 10.8x<br />

Famsa Department Stores 380 Mexico 15.3x 16.2x 12.0x 11.6x 10.2x 9.1x<br />

LatAm Average 10,399 24.7x 21.6x 17.7x 13.4x 11.3x 9.7x<br />

Walmart Hypermarkets & Super Centers 229,438 EE.UU. 14.7x 13.8x 12.7x 8.0x 7.7x 7.4x<br />

Home Depot Home Improvement Retail 81,079 EE.UU. 20.3x 18.0x 15.9x 10.3x 9.7x 9.1x<br />

Target General Merchandise Stores 38,813 EE.UU. 13.3x 13.5x 12.0x 7.4x 7.4x 7.0x<br />

Lowe's Home Improvement Retail 33,584 EE.UU. 16.3x 15.6x 12.8x 8.0x 7.4x 6.9x<br />

TJX Apparel Retail 32,217 EE.UU. 20.2x 18.0x 16.1x 9.8x 9.0x 8.4x<br />

Macy's Department Stores 15,357 EE.UU. 12.3x 11.0x 9.7x 5.8x 5.5x 5.2x<br />

Kohls Corp Department Stores 10,654 EE.UU. 10.3x 9.5x 8.5x 4.8x 4.7x 4.6x<br />

J.C. Penney Department Stores 4,864 EE.UU. - 18.1x 8.9x 11.5x 6.6x 4.6x<br />

EE.UU. Average 55,751 15.3x 14.7x 12.1x 8.2x 7.2x 6.7x<br />

Golden Eagle Retail-Regnl Dept Store 3,958 China 20.8x 17.9x 14.5x 13.7x 11.4x 9.1x<br />

Intime Retail-Major Dept Store 1,959 China 14.5x 12.9x 11.3x 14.6x 10.2x 8.3x<br />

Parkson Retail-Major Dept Store 2,550 China 14.4x 13.1x 11.2x 8.1x 7.5x 6.4x<br />

Shoprite Food-Retail 10,695 South Africa 27.9x 24.9x 21.0x 15.2x 15.4x 13.2x<br />

Asia & Africa Average<br />

Source: Bloomberg and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> Estimates.<br />

4,791 19.4x 17.2x 14.5x 12.9x 11.1x 9.3x<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

7


<strong>Falabella</strong> – Financial Statements<br />

Income Statement<br />

$ m illions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />

Operating Revenues 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351 10,394,846<br />

Total Expenses -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564 -9,151,996<br />

Net Operating Income 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787 1,242,849<br />

Net Operating Margin 12.6% 12.9% 12.4% 11.8% 11.7% 12.0%<br />

Non Operational Results -68,093 -68,123 -69,218 -70,668 -80,587 -79,895<br />

Income before taxes 581,827 665,031 741,140 837,965 987,199 1,162,954<br />

Tax -114,155 -152,532 -172,093 -197,788 -236,786 -282,152<br />

Minority Interest -44,626 -39,309 -43,646 -49,102 -57,557 -67,558<br />

Net Incom e 423,046 473,190 525,402 591,075 692,857 813,245<br />

Net Margin 8.2% 8.3% 8.0% 7.7% 7.6% 7.8%<br />

EBITDA 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334 1,539,431<br />

EBITDA Margin 15.1% 15.4% 15.0% 14.7% 14.7% 14.8%<br />

Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates.<br />

Balance Sheet<br />

$ millions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />

Current Assets 2,451,316 2,592,932 2,720,167 3,018,616 3,263,145 3,438,640<br />

Non Current Assets 1,647,793 1,939,420 2,428,601 2,887,238 3,145,133 3,258,783<br />

Total Assets 7,764,096 8,359,951 9,030,767 10,021,641 10,648,208 10,995,799<br />

Current Liabilities 2,267,951 2,398,974 2,516,691 2,792,815 3,019,053 3,181,421<br />

Financial Liabilities 3,306,108 3,422,704 3,567,810 4,040,301 4,110,634 3,933,978<br />

Total Liabilities 4,465,203 4,714,782 5,002,153 5,664,653 5,953,008 5,972,355<br />

Minority Interest 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916 579,916<br />

Total Equity 2,718,976 3,065,253 3,448,697 3,777,072 4,115,284 4,443,528<br />

Total Liabilities + Equity 7,764,096 8,359,951 9,030,767 10,021,641 10,648,208 10,995,799<br />

Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates<br />

Cash Flow<br />

$ m illions 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E<br />

Operating Revenues 5,163,995 5,675,947 6,534,920 7,708,081 9,115,351 10,394,846<br />

Total Expenses -4,514,075 -4,942,793 -5,724,561 -6,799,448 -8,047,564 -9,151,996<br />

Net Operating Income 649,920 733,154 810,358 908,633 1,067,787 1,242,849<br />

Depreciation and Amortization 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547 296,582<br />

EBITDA 778,899 872,772 980,547 1,130,101 1,337,334 1,539,431<br />

Net Income 423,046 473,190 525,402 591,075 692,857 813,245<br />

+ Depreciation and Amortization 128,978 139,618 170,189 221,469 269,547 296,582<br />

+ Financial Expenses 68,774 88,606 91,731 95,620 108,283 110,168<br />

- Financial Income -6,729 -7,396 -8,516 -10,044 -11,878 -13,545<br />

+ Monetary Adjustments 35,590 0 0 0 0 0<br />

- Profit/Loss Related Companies -13,087 -13,087 -13,997 -14,907 -15,817 -16,727<br />

- Minoritary Interest 44,626 39,309 43,646 49,102 57,557 67,558<br />

- Investment in Fixed Assets -177,483 -386,507 -604,835 -609,140 -441,070 -315,197<br />

- Change in Working Capital* -286,606 66,377 11,249 14,662 16,683 15,171<br />

- Financial Working Capital 0 -193,805 -154,661 -439,860 -529,109 -499,117<br />

- Investment in Other Assets -164,823 0 0 0 0 0<br />

Free Cash Flow 52,287 206,304 60,208 -102,025 147,053 458,135<br />

* No n Financial<br />

Source: Company Reports and <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> estimates<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

8


Research Team<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

Rodrigo Jacob G.<br />

Head of Research<br />

rjacob@bice.cl<br />

Mabel Weber A.<br />

Senior Analyst<br />

mweber@bice.cl<br />

Aldo Morales E.<br />

Analyst<br />

amoralese@bice.cl<br />

<strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> – Equities Report – <strong>Falabella</strong><br />

Cristóbal Doberti D.<br />

Chief Economist<br />

cdoberti@bice.cl<br />

Sebastián Senzacqua B.<br />

Economist<br />

ssenzacqua@bice.cl<br />

Claudia Cavada S.<br />

Analyst<br />

ccavada@bice.cl<br />

The analyst or analysts involved in the creation of this document hereby certify that the views expressed in this document<br />

accurately reflect their personal opinions and that they have not and will not receive direct or indirect compensation for<br />

expressing specific recommendations or views in this report. This report has been prepared by <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and is<br />

subject to change without notice. <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and employees shall have no obligation to update or amend any<br />

information contained herein. This report is for informational purposes only, based upon publicly available information, which<br />

we believed is reliable, but its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> makes no express or<br />

implied representations or warranties that such information is accurate or complete and, therefore, <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong> and<br />

employees shall not in any way be liable for related claims. The information and analyses contained herein are not intended<br />

as tax, legal, or investment advice and may not be suitable for your specific circumstances. Each investor shall make their<br />

own determination of the suitability of an investment of any securities referred to herein and should consult their own tax,<br />

legal, investment, or other advisors, to determine such suitability. This report may discuss numerous securities, some of<br />

which may not be qualified for sale in certain countries or states therein and may therefore not be offered to investors in<br />

such countries or states. This report or any portion hereof may not be reproduced, reprinted, sold or distributed without the<br />

written consent of <strong>BICE</strong> <strong>Inversiones</strong>.<br />

9

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!