JEWISH AFFAIRS ROSH HASHANAH 2012to generate a commercial revival. 8 Soon after thecity’s capture, therefore, he ordered the Jews inthe empire to relocate there. At the time the Jewsresented this forced relocation and to pacify themMehmet II, according to tradition, issued thefollowing proclamation using phrases from thebooks <strong>of</strong> Genesis and Ezra:Who among you <strong>of</strong> all my people that is with me,may his God be with him, let him ascend toConstantinople, the site <strong>of</strong> my royal throne. Lethim dwell in the best <strong>of</strong> the land, each beneathhis vine and beneath his fig tree, with silver andwith gold, with wealth and with cattle. Let himdwell in the land, trade in it, and take possession<strong>of</strong> it. 9As a result <strong>of</strong> this proclamation many Jewscame to Constantinople, which became the capital<strong>of</strong> the Ottoman Empire. Whenever the sultancaptured a town, he transferred its Jews to there.The Jews’ economic and religious situationimproved greatly by comparison with theircondition during the Byzantine era: “There cameinto being in Constantinople splendidcommunities; Torah, wealth and glory increasedin the congregation.” 10The original Jews who lived in Turkey fromByzantine times are known as Romaniot – GreekspeakingJews. Although some had been residents<strong>of</strong> Constantinople prior to the Ottoman conquest,most were settled there subsequently. Whilst theyplayed an important role in the <strong>Jewish</strong> communityduring the early years <strong>of</strong> Ottoman rule theirposition <strong>of</strong> influence was gradually eroded by theinflux <strong>of</strong> new <strong>Jewish</strong> communities. 11Rabbi Isaac Tzarfati moved to the OttomanEmpire from Europe and became the chief rabbi.He wrote a letter (dated by Heinrich Graetz to1456) 12 to the Jews <strong>of</strong> Germany, who at the timewere subject to cruel persecution, encouragingthem to settle in Turkey:I Isaac Tzarfati…proclaim to you that Turkey isa land wherein nothing is lacking….Is it notbetter for you to live under Muslims than underChristians? Here every man may dwell at peaceunder his own vine and fig-tree…. Arise! Andleave this accursed land for ever! 13This letter stimulated an influx <strong>of</strong> AshkenaziJews, who established communities in manyTurkish towns. 14 By 1478, Constantinople’s Jewsnumbered 10 000, comprising some 10% <strong>of</strong> thecity’s population. 15In 1492, more than 160 000 Jews were expelledfrom Spain, 16 and <strong>of</strong> these approximately 100000 17 ultimately settled in Turkey. Sultan BayazidII (1481-1512) not only permitted these Jews tosettle in the Ottoman Empire but according toBernard Lewis they were “encouraged, assistedand sometimes compelled.” 18 Bayazid II is reputedto have said about King Ferdinand <strong>of</strong> Spain “Canyou call such a king wise and intelligent? He isimpoverishing his country and enriching mykingdom.” 19The migration <strong>of</strong> Sephardi Jews did not stopafter the Spanish and subsequent Portugueseexpulsion. It continued into the 15 th and 16 thCenturies as Marranos left Spain and Portugaland settled in various countries before ultimatelyestablishing themselves in Turkey, which provedto be the safest place to return to Judaism. 20Among the Sephardi Jews expelled from Portugalwere Ephraim Caro and his young son JosephCaro, who later settled in Safed and wrote theShulchan Aruch.The arrival <strong>of</strong> Sephardi Jews significantlychanged the composition <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Jewish</strong>community. According to certain calculations, 40000 Jews migrated to Constantinople and 20 000to Salonika. 21 Constantinople soon became thelargest <strong>Jewish</strong> settlement in Europe. In time, itwas rivalled and then outstripped by Salonika(now part <strong>of</strong> Greece) which became apredominantly <strong>Jewish</strong> city and remained so forfour centuries.The Jews were a heterogeneous communityand the Romaniots, Ashkenazim and Sephardimkept separate congregations. The Sephardim evenkept separate sub-communities, withcongregations from different Iberian townsfunctioning separately. The Sephardicommunities, writes Zimmels, exhibited twospecial features, viz. an inclination to domineerover others and to quarrel amongst themselves.The former characteristic led to the absorption <strong>of</strong>many non-Sephardi communities by theSephardim, and the latter frequently led tosecession from an existing congregation and theformation <strong>of</strong> a rival one. 22Sephardi immigrants made an importantcontribution from the mercantile perspective andinternational trade in the eastern Mediterraneanwas largely <strong>Jewish</strong> controlled. They also providedthe Turks with armaments and gunpowder, whichaccording to Graetz thereby suppliedChristendom’s arch enemy with the weapons thatenabled them to inflict on the Christians “defeatafter defeat” and “humiliation on humiliation.” 23Sephardi Jews were conversant with Europeanpolitics and had knowledge <strong>of</strong> Europeanlanguages. Turkey was the most powerful state inEurope and for the first time since Hasdai ibnShaprut in 10 th Century Cordoba, Jews played aprominent role in international politics.No case was more striking than that <strong>of</strong> DonJoseph Nasi (1524-79), who became one <strong>of</strong> themost influential individuals in the Turkish Empire.His aunt and mother-in-law Dona Gracia Nasi(1510-69) was the most benevolent and adored<strong>Jewish</strong> woman <strong>of</strong> her day. They were PortugueseMarranos whose significant business interestswere managed by Gracia Nasi after the death <strong>of</strong>her husband with Don Joseph’s assistance.Together, they built and expanded the House <strong>of</strong>20
JEWISH AFFAIRS ROSH HASHANAH 2012Nasi into one <strong>of</strong> the richest merchant houses inEurope. After leaving Portugal, they were unableto find a secure place to practice their Judaismand eventually sought refuge in Turkey. It wouldbe three centuries before another <strong>Jewish</strong> dynasty,the Rothschild’s, would make a similar impact oninternational affairs.Perhaps Dona Gracia and Don Joseph’s mostmemorable legacy was in relation to Palestine.Dona Gracia provided substantial funding forlearning and for the first time in centuries Palestinebecame a truly great centre <strong>of</strong> rabbinic learning. 24Don Joseph obtained a grant <strong>of</strong> the ruined city <strong>of</strong>Tiberius, which he rebuilt to be a place not only <strong>of</strong>refuge for persecuted Jews but as the kernel <strong>of</strong> a<strong>Jewish</strong> state. 25 Cecil Roth observed, however,that although not a failure, the Tiberius experimentcertainly did not live up to its enthusiastic hopes. 26The Ottoman Empire and its <strong>Jewish</strong> citizensboth reached their high point during the reign <strong>of</strong>Suleiman (1520-1566). Although the situationfor the Jews was generally favourable even underthe relatively sympathetic sultans as Bayazid II,Suleiman, Selim I and Selim II, Jews wereperiodically reminded <strong>of</strong> their dhimmi status. ButJews were invariably grateful and thankful fortheir circumstances. 27By the close <strong>of</strong> the 16 th Century, the 300 years<strong>of</strong> Turkish vitality began to show signs <strong>of</strong>deterioration and the shift in the historic traderoutes from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic hada major negative consequence. The decline in theempire coincided with the decline <strong>of</strong> the goldenage <strong>of</strong> the Jews in Turkey, who no longer producedrepresentatives <strong>of</strong> outstanding quality. Thedeterioration <strong>of</strong> the Jews’ economic and politicalcircumstances ultimately reflected in theircommunal and cultural life. 28The 1648 Chmielnicki pogroms in EasternEurope unleashed messianic expectations.Gershom Scholem observed that in the mid-17 thCentury, the belief that the world was on the brink<strong>of</strong> great events was universally accepted. 29 Theperiod produced a number <strong>of</strong> aspirant messiahs,<strong>of</strong> whom Shabbetai Tzvi (1626-1676) was themost significant. Shabbetai Tzvi was born inSmyrna (now Izmir) in Turkey. He came underthe influence <strong>of</strong> the kabbalah and exhibited signs<strong>of</strong> what today would probably be diagnosed asmanic depressive. Amongst other acts, heproclaimed 18 June 1666 to be the Day <strong>of</strong>Redemption. He violated <strong>Jewish</strong> law, includingpronouncing the name <strong>of</strong> God, but his undoingwas his announcement that the Turkish sultanwas about to be deposed. The sultan had himarrested and given the choice between theconverting to Islam and death he chose conversion.The majority <strong>of</strong> rabbis were taken in by Tzvi.Later, when the charade was exposed, manyinsisted that they had been opposed to him, but asScholem points out, the documents tell a differentstory. 30 Some <strong>of</strong> Tzvi’s followers also convertedto Islam but retained their <strong>Jewish</strong> identity insecret. Their descendants have survived to thisday as a recognised group known as Donmeh andplayed a significant political and economic rolein Turkey. The Donmeh are referred to by some as“<strong>Jewish</strong> Muslims” and follow certain <strong>Jewish</strong>practices such as lighting candles for Shabbat. 31Only in Istanbul does a remnant still survive.Estimates <strong>of</strong> their numbers vary between 20 000and 50 000, such is the veil <strong>of</strong> secrecy thatsurrounds this group. 32Rabbi Berel Wein is <strong>of</strong> the view that this failedmovement had long term tragic consequences forthe <strong>Jewish</strong> people. He considers that “ShabbetaiTzvi was a factor in setting in motion those forces<strong>of</strong> history that introduced the onset <strong>of</strong> ReformJudaism, secularization, and assimilation <strong>of</strong>European Jewry.” 33The history <strong>of</strong> the Jews in Turkey in the 17 th ,18 th and 19 th Centuries is principally a chronicle<strong>of</strong> decline <strong>of</strong> influence and power exacerbated byincreasing competition from the Greek andArmenian communities.Until the Damascus Blood Libel in 1840,accusations <strong>of</strong> ritual murder were very rare in theOttoman Empire, and where they did briefly appearthe sources were blood libels in Christiancountries. 34 There are a number <strong>of</strong> instances wherethe sultan himself intervened to clamp down firmlyand put a stop to the baseless allegations. 35 In the19 th Century, Turkey introduced reforms whichextended equal rights to non-Muslims, includingto Jews. These reforms, which are known inTurkish history as Tanzimat, initiated in the late19 th and early 20 th Centuries a period <strong>of</strong> <strong>Jewish</strong>cultural and economic revival. 36 Over time,however, Turkey had been gradually losing much<strong>of</strong> the territories it had conquered. By thecommencement <strong>of</strong> the 20 th Century, it had becomeknown as the “Sick Man <strong>of</strong> Europe.”The diaries <strong>of</strong> Theodor Herzl contain afascinating account <strong>of</strong> Herzl’s effort to meet withSultan Abdul Hamid II (1876-1909) in order topromote the case for a <strong>Jewish</strong> homeland inPalestine. Herzl’s first attempt to meet the sultanin 1896, a year before the First Zionist Conference,ended in failure. He was already in Constantinoplein anticipation <strong>of</strong> the meeting when Nevlinski(his go between) “returned from Yildiz Kioskwith a long face and bad news” reporting “It’s all<strong>of</strong>f! The great lord will not hear <strong>of</strong> it! ....TheSultan told me: if Mr Herzl is your friend … thenadvise him not to go a single step further in thismatter. I cannot sell even a foot <strong>of</strong> land, for it doesnot belong to me but to my people. They have wonthis Empire and fertilized it with their blood….Ican dispose no part <strong>of</strong> it. The Jews may spare theirmillions. When my Empire is divided, perhapsthey will get Palestine for nothing. But only ourcorpse can be divided. I will never consent tovivisection.” 37Herzl recorded, “I was touched and moved bythe truly l<strong>of</strong>ty words <strong>of</strong> the Sultan, although forthe time being they put an end to all my hopes.21