03.12.2012 Views

December 2011 council meeting minutes - part - City of Wodonga

December 2011 council meeting minutes - part - City of Wodonga

December 2011 council meeting minutes - part - City of Wodonga

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

APPENDICES<br />

Page 125 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 126 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 127 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 128 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 129 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 130 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 131 <strong>of</strong> 304


Baranduda
Recreation
Reserve
<br />

Long
Term
Precinct
Master
Plan
<br />

Prepared
by
Simon
Leisure
Consulting
<br />

July
<strong>2011</strong>
<br />

Page 132 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

1.
 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................1
<br />

2.
 CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND ......................................................................................................2
<br />

2.1.
 Baranduda Township..................................................................................................................................2
<br />

2.2.
 Baranduda Recreation Reserve Existing Conditions.................................................................................. 2
<br />

2.2.1.
 Sports Field and Associated Facilities...................................................................................................................3
<br />

2.2.2.
 Tennis Courts ........................................................................................................................................................3
<br />

2.2.3.
 Baranduda Skate Park ..........................................................................................................................................3
<br />

2.2.4.
 Baranduda Community Centre..............................................................................................................................4
<br />

2.2.5.
 Other Areas / Facilities ..........................................................................................................................................4
<br />

2.2.6.
 Traffic Management ..............................................................................................................................................4
<br />

2.3.
 Planning Reports and Strategies................................................................................................................ 4
<br />

2.3.1.
 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Municipal Recreation Plan (2007).........................................................................................................4
<br />

2.3.2.
 Baranduda Community Facilities Community Consultation (2006) .......................................................................5
<br />

2.3.3.
 Baranduda Future Needs Survey (2009) ..............................................................................................................5
<br />

2.3.4.
 Other References ..................................................................................................................................................5
<br />

3.
 CONSULTATION ...............................................................................................................................6
<br />

4.
 ANALYSIS OF ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES ..............................................................................8
<br />

5.
 BARANDUDA RESEVE PRECINCT MASTER PLAN ....................................................................10
<br />

5.1.
 Plan Development ....................................................................................................................................10
<br />

5.2.
 Key Directions <strong>of</strong> the Master Plan ............................................................................................................ 10
<br />

5.3.
 Other Recommendations.......................................................................................................................... 11
<br />

5.4.
 Cost Plan .................................................................................................................................................. 11
<br />

6.
 CONCLUSION .................................................................................................................................15
<br />

APPENDICES<br />

Appendix 1 – 2007 Draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan<br />

Appendix 2 – Groups and People Consulted<br />

Appendix 3 – Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Addendum 1 – March <strong>2011</strong><br />


<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page i<br />

Page 133 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

1. INTRODUCTION<br />

The Baranduda Recreation Reserve Precinct is the main sporting, recreational, social and commercial<br />

node supporting the expanding Baranduda community. Existing facilities and spaces within the precinct<br />

provide for and support a range <strong>of</strong> sporting activities, health and wellbeing programs, and family<br />

recreation (playground, picnicking and BBQ).<br />

In 2001, the <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council completed and endorsed a master plan to guide the future<br />

development and use <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Recreation Reserve. Whilst some <strong>of</strong> the recommendations from<br />

the master plan have been actioned, strong population growth in Baranduda and changing community<br />

needs have seen the progressive development <strong>of</strong> facilities at the reserve that are not in accordance with<br />

the 2001 master plan. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Municipal Recreation Plan (2007) confirmed the need to review and<br />

update the original master plan and a revised master plan was subsequently prepared for the reserve later<br />

that year (see Appendix 1) but was not fully completed or endorsed by Council.<br />

It was therefore timely for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council to commence a review <strong>of</strong> the 2007 draft master plan<br />

in late 2009 to ensure a new direction for the future use and development <strong>of</strong> the reserve is established<br />

that not only considers the likely future needs <strong>of</strong> the community but also considers the implications <strong>of</strong> the<br />

planned use <strong>of</strong> land immediately surrounding the reserve. As a result, the Council commissioned the<br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan study in <strong>December</strong> 2009 and appointed<br />

sport and recreation planning firm, Simon Leisure Consulting, to undertake the study.<br />

This report provides an overview <strong>of</strong> the study process, describes the key findings from the study, and<br />

outlines a new ‘Vision’ for Baranduda Recreation Reserve and its environs.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 1<br />

Page 134 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

2. CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND<br />

The Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan, was informed by a number <strong>of</strong><br />

research and planning considerations. This section provides a summary <strong>of</strong> the key planning and<br />

contextual factors which were important to be assessed and considered during the preparation <strong>of</strong> the new<br />

master plan.<br />

2.1. Baranduda Township<br />

Baranduda is located approximately 8km southeast <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>, in the area where the Kiewa Valley<br />

Highway, the Yackandandah-<strong>Wodonga</strong> Road and the Baranduda Boulevard intersect.<br />

It is the main township <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Growth Corridor and currently has a population <strong>of</strong> approximately<br />

1,800 people 1 . Compared to all <strong>of</strong> the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>, the age pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> Baranduda is ‘young’ and there<br />

is a higher proportion <strong>of</strong> the population that is Australia-born.<br />

The population <strong>of</strong> Baranduda is projected to grow by approximately 25 houses (or 70 people) per annum<br />

for the next 30 years 2 , so whilst relatively small in size now, Baranduda is projected to continue to grow<br />

and expand.<br />

2.2. Baranduda Recreation Reserve Existing Conditions<br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve is a<br />

Council-owned reserve managed by<br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council.<br />

The reserve is 3.0 hectares in size<br />

and is zoned Public Park And<br />

Recreation Zone. The site is not<br />

subject to any planning overlays.<br />

The reserve is shown at right and is<br />

denoted by the area inside the inner<br />

green and red lines.<br />

Figure 1 – Baranduda Recreation<br />

Reserve Precinct<br />

1 Source: Council’s Strategic Planning Manager (2010).<br />

2 Source: Ibid.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 2<br />

Page 135 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

2.2.1. Sports Field and Associated Facilities<br />

The sports field is approximately 235m<br />

long x 170m wide (see picture right). In<br />

summer, the sports field is configured to<br />

provide two cricket ovals – the northern<br />

oval being the designated main oval with a<br />

turf centre wicket and the southern oval<br />

being the junior oval with a synthetic turf<br />

wicket. The distance between the turf<br />

centre wicket and the northern boundary <strong>of</strong><br />

the main oval (approximately 52m) is right<br />

on the minimum required for senior cricket<br />

matches.<br />

A water tank was recently installed by the Baranduda Rangers Cricket Club to provide an onsite<br />

water supply for watering the turf wicket and immediate surrounds. Three synthetic cricket<br />

practice wickets – all in good condition - are located in the southwest corner <strong>of</strong> the reserve.<br />

In winter, the southern section <strong>of</strong> the sports field is divided into three small ovals to accommodate<br />

the Baranduda Auskick program held at the reserve.<br />

At the time <strong>of</strong> inspection, the surface <strong>of</strong> the sports field was good, and consultation with user<br />

groups and Council representatives confirmed this to be the case all year round.<br />

There is no pavilion or clubroom facility at the reserve. However, a permanent wooden shelter<br />

located on what would be the western boundary <strong>of</strong> the main cricket oval provides shade and<br />

shelter for cricketers. There is also a three-bay storage shed located on the southern edge <strong>of</strong> the<br />

sports field.<br />

2.2.2. Tennis Courts<br />

Two sand-filled synthetic grass tennis courts are located on the southern boundary <strong>of</strong> the<br />

reserve. Both courts are floodlit and are in good condition.<br />

There is no dedicated tennis clubroom facility, however, a small room on the western side <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Baranduda Community Centre and adjacent to the courts has been upgraded to provide the<br />

Baranduda Tennis Club with a secure store and small <strong>meeting</strong> area.<br />

2.2.3. Baranduda Skate Park<br />

The Baranduda Skate Park is a large<br />

concrete facility located along the southern<br />

boundary <strong>of</strong> the reserve and comprises <strong>of</strong><br />

a combination <strong>of</strong> a concrete bowl with an<br />

eight foot corner, two grind rails, a fun box,<br />

ramps and a recently added street-style<br />

space for beginners (February 2009). The<br />

skate park is in good condition<br />

(see picture right).<br />

There a number <strong>of</strong> concrete seats around<br />

the skate park.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 3<br />

Page 136 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

2.2.4. Baranduda Community Centre<br />

The Baranduda Community Centre is a substantial<br />

brick building that comprises <strong>of</strong> a multipurpose hall<br />

with capacity to accommodate approximately 80<br />

people for theatre-style seating and 70 people for<br />

table seating (see picture right). The hall is<br />

equipped with a commercial kitchen.<br />

The Centre also has a playgroup area that has a<br />

dedicated outdoor playground and play area.<br />

2.2.5. Other Areas / Facilities<br />

There is a ‘Neighbourhood’ level playground adjacent to the tennis courts and it is in good<br />

condition.<br />

There is a combined picnic shelter, BBQ facility<br />

and four picnic tables close by (see picture right),<br />

and an additional BBQ facility outside the<br />

Community Centre hall.<br />

A basketball half-court is situated between the<br />

skate park and the tennis courts. All <strong>of</strong> these<br />

facilities are in good condition.<br />

The main parkland area within the reserve is situated south <strong>of</strong> the cricket practice nets and along<br />

the southeastern edge <strong>of</strong> the reserve. There is no formal pedestrian path network throughout the<br />

reserve, except for some commuter links connecting the Community Centre to Baranduda<br />

Boulevard.<br />

2.2.6. Traffic Management<br />

There is an informal, unsealed car park located between the skate park and the cricket practice<br />

nets. It is well shaded with mature gums, and bollards have been recently installed to contain<br />

cars within the designated car parking area. Half <strong>of</strong> this existing car park lies within the confines<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Recreation Reserve and half outside. On-street car parking is also available on<br />

Pro Hart Drive.<br />

2.3. Planning Reports and Strategies<br />

The following Council research and strategy reports provide valuable base information relating to local<br />

residents’ sporting and recreational needs and aspirations.<br />

2.3.1. <strong>Wodonga</strong> Municipal Recreation Plan (2007)<br />

In 2007, <strong>Wodonga</strong> Council developed and adopted a new municipal recreation plan. During the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the plan, there was extensive consultation and data collection conducted,<br />

including input from Baranduda residents and sporting groups. The following recommendations<br />

relevant to the reserve are contained in the Recreation Plan:<br />

• Review the reserve master plan.<br />

• Consider installing a tennis rebound wall.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 4<br />

Page 137 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

• Construct a maximum <strong>of</strong> two additional tennis courts.<br />

• Consider options to make the tennis courts multi-use.<br />

• Develop a new sports pavilion.<br />

• Provide 2 – 3 soccer fields.<br />

• Investigate establishing a new soccer club, or relocating an existing one.<br />

• Facilitate the introduction <strong>of</strong> Goalkick and Auskick programs to the reserve.<br />

• Review the functionality and adequacy <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Community Centre.<br />

2.3.2. Baranduda Community Facilities Community Consultation (2006)<br />

The report outlines the research undertaken to determine community priorities for the continued<br />

development <strong>of</strong> community facilities in Baranduda.<br />

The findings relevant to the master plan study are:<br />

• Redesign / extend the Baranduda Community Centre to create more indoor spaces.<br />

• Clubrooms required for the cricket club and tennis club.<br />

• Storage and other amenities required by most user groups.<br />

• Relocation <strong>of</strong> the playground to a closer proximity to the Community Centre.<br />

• Add skate elements to the skate park suitable for beginner level.<br />

• Pedestrian and cycling linkages into and throughout the precinct.<br />

2.3.3. Baranduda Future Needs Survey (2009)<br />

Council conducts an annual Future Needs Survey in Baranduda to identify which activities and<br />

services are working well in the community and which could be improved. The purpose <strong>of</strong> the<br />

survey is to undertake research that can be used to improve the operations <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda<br />

Community Centre and other community facilities to enhance their usability and relevance for<br />

local residents.<br />

The 2009 survey was distributed to approximately 800 households in Baranduda, and resulted in<br />

35 responses. The key findings relevant to the master plan study are:<br />

• The highest <strong>part</strong>icipation activity by respondents was skating (34%), followed by tennis and<br />

cricket.<br />

• Future desired sporting activities by respondents included beach volleyball, local football<br />

club, touch football, and little athletics.<br />

• There was a strong desire for community events / activities, such as ‘backyard cricket’,<br />

music/jazz, community BBQs, market, and movie nights.<br />

2.3.4. Other References<br />

The following report and plan were also reviewed and assessed as background material to inform<br />

the new master plan:<br />

• Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan Report, Lacey Management Services (2001).<br />

• Draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan, Whitefield McQueen Pty Ltd (2007).<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 5<br />

Page 138 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

3. CONSULTATION<br />

The initial consultation carried out for the study included two <strong>meeting</strong>s with Council staff and separate<br />

telephone interviews with each <strong>of</strong> the reserve user groups during the period <strong>December</strong> 2009 to February<br />

2010. It is important to note, however, that other ideas and suggestions from reserve user groups and<br />

other Baranduda residents for the development <strong>of</strong> the reserve were also captured whilst reviewing some<br />

<strong>of</strong> the reports listed in Section 2.3.<br />

Follow-up discussions were carried out with Council staff during the preparation <strong>of</strong> the preliminary concept<br />

plans prepared for the reserve.<br />

A summary <strong>of</strong> the key outcomes from the preliminary consultation with stakeholders is provided in the<br />

following table.<br />

(The names <strong>of</strong> the representatives from each group consulted or who attended <strong>meeting</strong>s are shown in Appendix 2).<br />

Group Comments / Input<br />

Baranduda Auskick Usage <strong>of</strong> the reserve is Friday evenings during the winter season<br />

Baranduda Rangers<br />

Cricket Club<br />

Baranduda Tennis<br />

Club<br />

Centre has approximately 85 – 90 children <strong>part</strong>icipating<br />

Key need is flood lighting for the southern areas <strong>of</strong> the reserve<br />

A secondary need is additional security lighting to illuminate the paths to the car park<br />

Club has three senior teams and four junior teams<br />

Club uses the cricket practice nets and divides the playing area into two ovals for<br />

matches, with the northern oval having a turf centre wicket and the southern oval a<br />

synthetic centre wicket<br />

Senior A, B & C Grade teams use the turf wicket oval, with the U17s, U15s, U13s and<br />

U11s using the synthetic wicket oval<br />

Key need is the provision <strong>of</strong> a pavilion at the reserve<br />

A secondary need in the medium to long term is for the second oval to also become a<br />

turf wicket field<br />

Club members use the courts on Friday and Wednesday evenings, whilst a tennis coach<br />

uses the courts on Monday and Tuesday evenings<br />

Club membership has fluctuated between 20 – 30, however, popularity appears to be<br />

declining, which is impacting upon the financial sustainability <strong>of</strong> the Club<br />

Presently, there is little demand for additional courts<br />

Club believes that a multipurpose court surface may increase overall usage, and that a<br />

new a rebound wall would be beneficial for young children who are learning tennis and<br />

as an informal recreational opportunity at the reserve<br />

Baranduda CFA Several calls were made to the Baranduda CFA representatives for input, however, no<br />

response was received<br />

Council staff A plan showing the strategic overview <strong>of</strong> future land use in Baranduda has been<br />

prepared (and a copy was provided to Simon Leisure Consulting), and it shows that in<br />

the future, new housing will be developed along the eastern side <strong>of</strong> the reserve on either<br />

side <strong>of</strong> an Environmental Reserve<br />

Council’s Playground Strategy classifies the Baranduda Recreation Reserve playground<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 6<br />

Page 139 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Group Comments / Input<br />

as a ‘Neighbourhood’ level playground<br />

Council’s long-term plan to develop a new sporting and recreational precinct at Middle<br />

Creek Reserve to support the projected new population throughout the Baranduda<br />

Growth Corridor is still supported with a likely commencement date post 2020<br />

Key requirements identified for the reserve by Council staff include:<br />

� Increased provision <strong>of</strong> car parking<br />

� Provision <strong>of</strong> a pavilion and public toilets<br />

� Continued use <strong>of</strong> the reserve as a multi-functional and flexible recreation and<br />

sporting hub<br />

� Provision <strong>of</strong> a recreational path network throughout the reserve<br />

� Installation <strong>of</strong> a three-phase power supply to support outdoor community events<br />

� Importance <strong>of</strong> retaining a link between the school and the reserve<br />

All <strong>of</strong> the above information was considered during the preparation <strong>of</strong> the draft master plan.<br />

Public Exhibition Process<br />

The draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan was approved to go to public<br />

exhibition by the <strong>council</strong> at the <strong>council</strong> <strong>meeting</strong> held on 18 April <strong>2011</strong>. The main purpose <strong>of</strong> the public<br />

exhibition period was to seek feedback on the draft master plan from reserve user groups, local residents,<br />

and other stakeholders. The public exhibition process can be summarised as follows:<br />

• The draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan and accompanying study<br />

report were available for viewing for a period <strong>of</strong> 28 days at the following public facilities:<br />

− Baranduda Community Centre<br />

− Council’s Customer Service Reception<br />

− <strong>Wodonga</strong> Library<br />

− Baranduda General Store<br />

• The draft master plan was available for viewing and downloading from <strong>council</strong>’s website.<br />

• Advice to residents about the public exhibition period and information on the master plan were<br />

provided via <strong>council</strong> notice boards and <strong>council</strong>’s monthly newspaper (<strong>City</strong>Life).<br />

• A Public Meeting was held at the Baranduda Community Centre on 2 May <strong>2011</strong>. Councillor<br />

Wangman and <strong>council</strong>’s Team Leader <strong>of</strong> Recreation facilitated the <strong>meeting</strong> which was attended by<br />

seven people, including three people who were representing three <strong>of</strong> the reserve user groups.<br />

No formal written submissions were received during the public exhibition period, however, the verbal<br />

feedback from user groups and residents was positive and in support <strong>of</strong> the proposed directions outlined<br />

in the draft master plan. As a result, no changes were necessary to the draft master plan to produce the<br />

final master plan.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 7<br />

Page 140 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

4. ANALYSIS OF ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES<br />

The key issues and opportunities identified for the Baranduda Recreation Reserve Precinct are discussed<br />

and assessed in the following table, with potential options on how the master planning process may<br />

respond to issues raised being noted.<br />

Issue / Opportunity Discussion<br />

1. The provision <strong>of</strong> additional tennis<br />

courts<br />

Various reports, plans and community feedback reviewed during<br />

this study advocate for the expansion <strong>of</strong> the existing two-court<br />

facility by up to two courts. The main justification cited has been to<br />

accommodate increase demand for courts resulting from increased<br />

population growth.<br />

When using a recognised benchmark <strong>of</strong> 1 court being required for<br />

every 1,000 people, the current provision <strong>of</strong> two courts is<br />

satisfactory for the short to medium term based on the current<br />

population <strong>of</strong> Baranduda (1,800 people) and the small annual<br />

growth.<br />

Feedback from the President <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Tennis Club<br />

received during this study has confirmed that the current two courts<br />

are satisfactorily <strong>meeting</strong> the current needs <strong>of</strong> members and are<br />

likely to for the next few years. It appears that the popularity <strong>of</strong><br />

tennis in the town has stabilised.<br />

Notwithstanding this, any master plan should consider the future<br />

needs <strong>of</strong> a community and allow for the appropriate provision <strong>of</strong><br />

facilities that may be required beyond current needs. Master<br />

planning allows for such facilities to be planned for in a way that<br />

will integrate and coordinate new or upgraded facilities with the<br />

existing provision and layout <strong>of</strong> facilities at a reserve.<br />

The recent extension <strong>of</strong> the skate park no longer makes it possible<br />

to fit a third tennis court west <strong>of</strong> the two existing courts. This option<br />

is shown in previous plans. The only option, therefore, to expand<br />

the current footprint is to locate a court(s) north <strong>of</strong> the two existing<br />

courts, or to build a new facility at a different location on the<br />

reserve. The second option is not feasible as the entire playing<br />

field area is required, and the location <strong>of</strong> the tennis facility next to<br />

the Baranduda Community Centre provides good access to<br />

necessary support amenities.<br />

The impact <strong>of</strong> constructing an additional one or two courts in the<br />

southern area <strong>of</strong> the reserve would be significant:<br />

� The existing playground would need to be relocated.<br />

� A single or double court expansion would effectively ‘cut in<br />

half’ the southern recreational hub by becoming a physical<br />

and visual barrier between the eastern facilities (i.e. the<br />

pergola, crèche and Community Centre) and the western<br />

facilities (i.e. the skate park, basketball half-court and the car<br />

park).<br />

� A single or double court expansion would encroach<br />

somewhat onto the playing surface <strong>of</strong> the sports field, thereby<br />

compromising its effectiveness.<br />

� A single or double court expansion would create a significant<br />

impact on the overall landscape amenity <strong>of</strong> the reserve as a<br />

result <strong>of</strong> the high chain-mesh perimeter fencing.<br />

The current Middle Creek Recreation Precinct Master Plan<br />

incorporates a new multi-court tennis complex into its layout, and<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 8<br />

Page 141 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Issue / Opportunity Discussion<br />

2. Need for a second turf oval at the<br />

reserve<br />

that location is considered a much more viable option to cater for<br />

the long-term tennis needs <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda community, albeit in<br />

accordance with a timeframe <strong>of</strong> 10+ years.<br />

It is recommended that the current two-court tennis complex on the<br />

reserve be contained to this size and configuration, with the longterm<br />

tennis needs <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda community being<br />

accommodated with a new facility within the future Middle Creek<br />

Recreation Precinct.<br />

Turf centre wickets require considerable ongoing maintenance<br />

before and during the cricket season and a sustainable water<br />

source for irrigation. Converting an existing centre wicket from a<br />

synthetic surface to a turf surface can ultimately reduce the<br />

opportunities for a community to <strong>part</strong>icipate in both informal and<br />

formal cricket activities.<br />

Synthetic wickets are the nominated surface for junior competition,<br />

certainly competition matches for all players up to the age <strong>of</strong> 16, 17<br />

and 18 years. In addition, synthetic wickets provide opportunities<br />

for families and larger groups to engage in ‘social’ or informal<br />

cricket matches. Due to the very stringent maintenance practices<br />

required to ‘bring up’ a turf wicket each weekend for competition,<br />

they provide no realistic opportunity for broad community use<br />

during a cricket season.<br />

The proposal by the Baranduda Rangers Cricket Club to convert<br />

the second (or southern) oval from synthetic to turf needs to be<br />

considered carefully. The Club is expanding its senior and junior<br />

player numbers, so with continued population growth in Baranduda<br />

there will be a need for additional cricket facilities.<br />

The options to accommodate additional senior (turf) grounds<br />

include the conversion <strong>of</strong> the southern oval at the Baranduda<br />

Recreation Reserve, the development <strong>of</strong> a turf centre wicket on<br />

one <strong>of</strong> the current or future local school ovals, or the development<br />

<strong>of</strong> turf ovals at the Middle Creek Recreation Precinct. In the longterm,<br />

additional cricket clubs will be formed in the Leneva Valley as<br />

the population continues to increase and the distribution <strong>of</strong> the<br />

population widens, and the opportunity will exist for these clubs to<br />

utilise planned ovals at the Middle Creek Recreation Precinct. The<br />

local schools will no doubt prefer to retain the low maintenance and<br />

more flexible use option <strong>of</strong> synthetic wickets. Therefore, the longterm<br />

solution for the incumbent cricket club at the Baranduda<br />

Recreation Reserve to accommodate growth may be to have two<br />

turf wickets at the reserve for senior teams, with its juniors playing<br />

on the local school ovals. Whilst this may be a desired long-term<br />

solution, it should only be considered if alternate community<br />

accessible synthetic wickets are available at future new parks and<br />

reserves in the township.<br />

The Baranduda Rangers Cricket Club is experienced in preparing<br />

and maintaining turf wickets, and has installed a water tank at the<br />

reserve, so these two potential issues have been resolved.<br />

It is suggested that the master plan should show how a second turf<br />

centre wicket could be accommodated at Baranduda Recreation<br />

Reserve, without recommending it as a priority project.<br />

Further, prior to approving the conversion <strong>of</strong> the existing synthetic<br />

wicket to turf, Council should ensure that the community has<br />

reasonable access to other grounds where synthetic centre wickets<br />

are available for general use.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 9<br />

Page 142 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

5. BARANDUDA RESEVE PRECINCT MASTER PLAN<br />

5.1. Plan Development<br />

The Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan was developed through<br />

consideration and analysis <strong>of</strong> information collected during the study from the following sources:<br />

• The 2007 draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan and the outcomes and recommendations<br />

from the Baranduda Future Needs Survey (2009) and the Baranduda Community Facilities<br />

Community Consultation undertaken in 2006.<br />

• The findings and directions <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Municipal Recreation Plan (2007).<br />

• Site analysis and research by the consultant team.<br />

• Consultation with reserve user groups and with relevant Council staff.<br />

• Assessment <strong>of</strong> various options and scenarios to improve and upgrade the reserve.<br />

• Feedback from Council staff on the preliminary concept master plans.<br />

The key elements and directions identified in the Master Plan are described below, and should be read in<br />

conjunction with the illustrated Master Plan in Appendix 3.<br />

5.2. Key Directions <strong>of</strong> the Master Plan<br />

1. Upgrade and Improve the Sports Field<br />

− Remove the existing shelter to enable a full-size soccer field to be configured in the<br />

northwestern corner <strong>of</strong> the sports field (100m long x 65m wide).<br />

− Install two floodlights on the western side <strong>of</strong> the northern soccer field.<br />

− Configure a second senior soccer field in the southwestern corner <strong>of</strong> the reserve and a<br />

junior soccer field in the northeastern corner.<br />

− Install two floodlights along the southern boundary <strong>of</strong> the sports field for use by the<br />

Auskick program, and to be available for use during community events and activities<br />

conducted at the reserve in the evening.<br />

− Install bench seating at strategic locations around the sports field (allow 6 bench seats).<br />

− Realign the southern cricket oval if a second turf centre wicket is installed.<br />

2. New Sports Pavilion<br />

− Provide a new sports pavilion (also available for broad community use) on the western<br />

edge <strong>of</strong> the sports field to service the changing and social needs <strong>of</strong> sporting groups, and<br />

to provide covered external spectator viewing areas.<br />

− Relocate the equipment storage shed from the southwestern corner <strong>of</strong> the reserve to a<br />

location adjacent to the new pavilion.<br />

3. Upgrade and Improve the Recreation Facility Hub<br />

− Install a new pergola, BBQ and picnic tables on the western edge <strong>of</strong> the recreation hub.<br />

− Upgrade the existing playground to meet the full requirements <strong>of</strong> a ‘Neighbourhood’<br />

standard playground.<br />

− Install a tennis rebound wall adjacent to the existing basketball half-court.<br />

− Install 2 bench seats in the area bound by the skate park, the basketball half-court and<br />

the proposed new tennis rebound wall.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 10<br />

Page 143 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

4. Improve the Traffic Management<br />

− Close the vehicle entry <strong>of</strong>f Baranduda Boulevard and downgrade the access road to a<br />

pedestrian path only.<br />

− Formalise the existing car park servicing the recreation facility hub (26 car parks),<br />

however, construct a new car park entry <strong>of</strong>f Pro Hart Drive.<br />

− Construct new indented angled car parking along Pro Hart Drive to service the sport<br />

pavilion and reserve users (34 car parks). This work may require some sections <strong>of</strong> the<br />

existing path to be realigned to accommodate the parking bays.<br />

5. Upgrade the Amenity <strong>of</strong> Baranduda Recreation Reserve Precinct<br />

− Plant trees along the western edge and northern edge <strong>of</strong> Baranduda Recreation<br />

Reserve to frame the sports field and to provide shade.<br />

− Strengthen the planting around the recreation facility hub.<br />

− Construct an unsealed pedestrian path network around the sports field to encourage<br />

walkers and joggers into the reserve.<br />

− Formalise the pedestrian path network throughout the recreation facility hub to link-up<br />

the school, the sports field, the recreational facilities and Baranduda Boulevard.<br />

5.3. Other Recommendations<br />

The following two recommendations have emanated from the master planning study, but do not directly<br />

relate to the proposed physical upgrade projects at the Baranduda Recreation Reserve.<br />

5.4. Cost Plan<br />

1. That Council consider acquiring the land beyond the southeast corner <strong>of</strong> the reserve up to the<br />

alignment <strong>of</strong> the proposed new north-south road. This will ensure that the reserve has<br />

appropriate buffers and transition zones between the open space areas and any new housing.<br />

Should this not be possible, it is strongly recommended that Council require any new plan <strong>of</strong> subdivision<br />

to show a local (or service) road to be constructed by the developer parallel to the<br />

alignment <strong>of</strong> the southeast boundary <strong>of</strong> the reserve. This condition <strong>of</strong> planning will ensure that<br />

any new housing or commercial buildings will overlook (or face) the reserve rather than the<br />

reserve having ‘back fences’ form its edge in this location. The outcome will be similar to that<br />

which is evident along the western boundary with the new housing fronting both Pro Hart Drive<br />

and the reserve. This outcome will improve the general security at the reserve as householders<br />

will be looking out over the reserve, and will reduce the impact <strong>of</strong> housing on the overall look and<br />

amenity <strong>of</strong> the reserve in the southeast corner.<br />

2. That no chain-mesh perimeter fencing <strong>of</strong> the reserve be permitted for the explicit purpose <strong>of</strong><br />

enabling sporting groups to charge an admittance fee to enter the reserve.<br />

The Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan recommends more than 30<br />

separate but interconnected projects for the reserve. The total estimated cost for full implementation <strong>of</strong><br />

the Master Plan was $1,385,000 in July <strong>2011</strong> when the cost plan was initially finalised.<br />

Subsequent to this date, Council has undertaken some <strong>of</strong> the recommended works. The cost plan that<br />

appears on pages 13 & 14 is the revised cost plan (as at November <strong>2011</strong>), and notes those projects that<br />

have been completed since July <strong>2011</strong>, and which shows the revised implementation cost now at $394,460.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 11<br />

Page 144 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

The practicality and order <strong>of</strong> implementation <strong>of</strong> all projects has been and will continue to be subject to a<br />

number <strong>of</strong> factors and criteria before proceeding, including:<br />

Important Notes:<br />

− Availability <strong>of</strong> funding.<br />

− Current and future priorities <strong>of</strong> Council.<br />

− Stakeholder and community needs.<br />

− Further investigation, research and consultation.<br />

• All capital cost estimates shown in the table are based on works being undertaken by<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essional contractors, and consultant fees associated with design development and<br />

administration have been averaged at 10% <strong>of</strong> construction costs.<br />

• The cost estimates have been provided as indicative costs, based on similar projects undertaken<br />

in the past 18 months. No detailed plans have been prepared for any <strong>of</strong> the proposed upgrades,<br />

which are typically required to identify more accurate estimated costs from a Quantity Surveyor.<br />

Cost exclusions include:<br />

− Construction contingencies.<br />

− Any costs/loss <strong>of</strong> income, which may be incurred by user groups or Council during<br />

construction <strong>of</strong> improvement projects.<br />

− Goods and Services Tax (GST).<br />

• It should be noted that some capacity might exist for cost savings during the implementation <strong>of</strong><br />

the capital improvement program, by combining/packaging projects into one larger contract.<br />

• The directions contained within the Master Plan do not commit Council or any other organisation<br />

to a responsibility for funding projects.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 12<br />

Page 145 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 13<br />

Page 146 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 14<br />

Page 147 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

6. CONCLUSION<br />

The Baranduda Recreation Reserve Precinct is the key sporting, recreation and social hub for the small<br />

but expanding Baranduda township. Whilst <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council has an endorsed master plan for the<br />

reserve that was prepared in 2001, it has been timely for Council to review and update the master plan as<br />

the broad recreational needs <strong>of</strong> the local community have changed, as have the needs and aspirations <strong>of</strong><br />

the reserve user groups.<br />

The planning process undertaken during this study has enabled Council and the existing reserve user<br />

groups to jointly assess the impact on the layout and provision <strong>of</strong> facilities within the precinct from recent<br />

population growth and the changing needs <strong>of</strong> the community.<br />

The resultant master plan has established a new long-term “Vision” for the Baranduda Recreation<br />

Reserve and the surrounding area. It provides practical solutions to a number <strong>of</strong> existing constraints and<br />

issues that are impeding the growth and viability <strong>of</strong> some <strong>of</strong> the user groups.<br />

The progressive implementation <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

will ensure that this important community space will be better utilised as a community sporting and<br />

recreation area for the ongoing benefit <strong>of</strong> the residents <strong>of</strong> Baranduda.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Page 15<br />

Page 148 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Appendix 1<br />

2007 Draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Appendices<br />

Page 149 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 150 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Appendix 2<br />

Groups and People Consulted<br />

Council Staff<br />

Name Position / De<strong>part</strong>ment<br />

Jenelle Williamson Team Leader Recreation and Community Projects<br />

Merryn Deslandes Recreation Officer<br />

Debbie Mackinlay Manager Aged Services<br />

Debra Mudra Manager Early Years<br />

Peter McLarty Parks Services<br />

Lynda Paterson Co-ordinator Baranduda Community Centre<br />

Darren Rudd Strategic Planning Manager<br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve User Groups<br />

Name Position Organisation<br />

Kade Butters President Baranduda Auskick Centre<br />

Stephen Hession President Baranduda Rangers Cricket Club<br />

Ron Donohue President Baranduda Tennis Club<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Appendices<br />

Page 151 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Appendix 3<br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Appendices<br />

Page 152 <strong>of</strong> 304


A<br />

B<br />

F3<br />

BARANDUDA BLVD<br />

PRO HART DRV<br />

D7<br />

C3<br />

A4<br />

F1<br />

D3<br />

B3<br />

A Cricket Ovals<br />

A1 Existing main cricket oval (turf wicket).<br />

A2 Existing second cricket oval (synthetic<br />

wicket).<br />

A3 New alignment for second cricket<br />

oval, if turf wicket installed<br />

A4 Existing cricket practice nets (3 No.).<br />

B Soccer Fields<br />

B1 Proposed senior soccer fields (2 No.).<br />

B2 Proposed junior soccer field.<br />

B3 Install soccer field floodlights (2 No.).<br />

C<br />

C1<br />

B3<br />

D1<br />

D5<br />

C2<br />

D4<br />

F2<br />

B1<br />

D2<br />

B1<br />

C<br />

D<br />

D6<br />

A3<br />

F3<br />

E1 E2<br />

COMMUNITY<br />

CENTRE<br />

Sept 2010<br />

Baranduda Recreation Page 153 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Reserve Precinct Master Plan<br />

A2<br />

A1<br />

F4<br />

B2<br />

E<br />

F<br />

0 10 20 m<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESERVE<br />

INDOOR<br />

POOL BARANDUDA<br />

SCHOOL<br />

C Sports Pavilion<br />

C1 Equipment shed relocated from<br />

southern end <strong>of</strong> reserve.<br />

C2 Existing shelter to be removed.<br />

C3 New indented car parking (34 spaces)<br />

will require minor re-alignment <strong>of</strong> path.<br />

D Recreation Facility Hub<br />

D1 New pergola and picnic tables.<br />

D2 Upgrade existing playground to<br />

Neighbourhood standard.<br />

D3 Existing skate park.<br />

D4 New tennis rebound wall.<br />

D5 Existing basketball half-court.<br />

D6 Existing Baranduda tennis courts.<br />

D7 Proposed new car park (26 spaces).<br />

E<br />

F3<br />

F3<br />

E1<br />

FUTURE NEW ROAD<br />

FUTURE<br />

HOUSING<br />

E Auskick Area<br />

E1 Install floodlights for Auskick and<br />

community events (2 No.).<br />

E2 Retain existing BBQ and picnic shelter.<br />

F Path Network<br />

F1 Existing sealed pedestrian path.<br />

F2 Existing unsealed paths.<br />

F3 New 1.5m unsealed path around the<br />

reserve.<br />

F4 New 1.5m unsealed path connecting<br />

school to the reserve.<br />

.<br />

l a n d s c a p e a r c h i t e c t s


<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan<br />

Addendum 1 - March <strong>2011</strong><br />

Introduction<br />

During the compilation <strong>of</strong> this report Council was in the process <strong>of</strong> seeking funding for implementation <strong>of</strong> some <strong>of</strong><br />

the projects/ recommendations identified in the Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan.<br />

This addendum provides an update on the implementation <strong>of</strong> the recommendations as documented in Section 5 <strong>of</strong><br />

the Baranduda Recreation Reserve Long Term Precinct Master Plan.<br />

Recommendation Update<br />

1. In January <strong>2011</strong> Council confirmed it had received $378,000 in state and federal funding for the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> a new pavilion and small car park. The proposed location <strong>of</strong> this infrastructure is based<br />

on the draft Baranduda Recreation Reserve Master Plan.<br />

2. In <strong>December</strong> 2010 Council confirmed it had received Australian Government funding <strong>of</strong> $80,000 for the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> flood lighting at Baranduda Reserve. Works are scheduled for completion by June <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

3. The implementation <strong>of</strong> the pavilion, car park works and sports flood lighting has reduced the cost plan for<br />

the master plan from $1,383,910 to $461,910.<br />

Final Report (<strong>2011</strong>).doc Appendices<br />

Page 154 <strong>of</strong> 304


MINISTERIAL POWERS OF INTERVENTION IN PLANNING<br />

AND HERITAGE MATTERS<br />

REASONS FOR DECISION TO EXERCISE POWER OF<br />

INTERVENTION<br />

WONDONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

AMENDMENT C92<br />

The Planning and Environment Act 1987, the Heritage Act 1995 and the Victorian Civil and<br />

Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 provide for the intervention <strong>of</strong> the Minister for Planning in planning<br />

and heritage processes.<br />

In exercising my powers <strong>of</strong> intervention, in accordance with the Ministerial Powers <strong>of</strong> Intervention in<br />

Planning and Heritage Matters Practice Note, I have agreed to:<br />

� Make publicly available written reasons for each decision.<br />

� Provide a report to Parliament at least every twelve months detailing the nature <strong>of</strong> each<br />

intervention.<br />

REQUEST FOR INTERVENTION<br />

1. Places Victoria has requested the Minister for Planning to intervene in this matter by<br />

preparing and expediting Amendment C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

WHAT POWER OF INTERVENTION IS BEING USED?<br />

2. I have decided to exercise my powers to prepare and expedite Amendment C92 to the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme and to exempt myself from all the requirements <strong>of</strong> sections 17, 18<br />

and 19 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act 1987 and the regulations in respect <strong>of</strong> this<br />

Amendment.<br />

3. Section 20(4) <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act 1987 enables the Minister for Planning to<br />

exempt an amendment which the Minister prepares from any <strong>of</strong> the requirements <strong>of</strong> sections<br />

17, 18 and 19 <strong>of</strong> the Act or the regulations.<br />

4. In seeking to exercise this power, section 20(4) <strong>of</strong> the Act requires that the Minister must<br />

consider that compliance with any <strong>of</strong> those requirements is not warranted or that the interests<br />

<strong>of</strong> Victoria or any <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> Victoria make such an exemption appropriate.<br />

BACKGROUND<br />

5. The amendment applies to land in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> formerly comprising the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station and associated rail land, as well as a number <strong>of</strong> parcels owned by <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

<strong>City</strong> Council. The amendment seeks to:<br />

� Rezone the majority <strong>of</strong> the land (comprising the former Railway Station and rail yards)<br />

from the Public Use Zone 4 (PUZ4) to a Comprehensive Development Zone – Schedule 1<br />

(CDZ1).<br />

Page 155 <strong>of</strong> 304


� Rezone the remaining areas <strong>of</strong> the land (along <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> South Street, Elgin Boulevard,<br />

High Street) from the Residential 1 zone, Business 1 Zone and Road Zone 2 to the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 1 (CDZ1).<br />

� Remove the Design and Development Overlay 4 (DDO4) from the land.<br />

� Apply the Environmental Audit Overlay (EAO) to the land.<br />

� Apply the Heritage Overlay HO10 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>’ to a portion <strong>of</strong> the land.<br />

� Include the Comprehensive Development Zone and Schedule 1 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan’ in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

� Include the corresponding Incorporated Document in the Schedule to Clause 81.01 and<br />

undertake minor consequential modifications to the Local Planning Policy Framework at<br />

Clause 21.11, Clause 21.12 and Clause 22.09.<br />

� Include Places Victoria as a referral authority under s.55 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment<br />

Act, for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permit applications under the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone 1.<br />

6. The land subject <strong>of</strong> Amendment C92 substantially comprises the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station and associated rail land. The land is no longer required for transport purposes due to<br />

the relocation <strong>of</strong> Wondonga Railway Station as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the realignment <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to<br />

Sydney Rail passenger rail route. The land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment is an area in excess <strong>of</strong><br />

100,000 square metres and comprises <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

7. The relocation <strong>of</strong> the Station and associated infrastructure has provided the opportunity to<br />

redevelop the land in a manner which complements the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. The<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land will enable improved connectivity within Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> and<br />

includes the provision for road projects which are <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy. Road<br />

links provided by the rezoning and redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land will enable diversion <strong>of</strong><br />

‘through’ traffic associated with the Hume Highway from the Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business<br />

Area.<br />

8. The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former rail land in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> is considered a project <strong>of</strong><br />

State significance as it will provide the opportunity for substantial investment in Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>. The delivery <strong>of</strong> development will be overseen by Places Victoria who will set the<br />

Framework for redevelopment and will be actively involved in guiding development through<br />

their identification as a statutory referral authority for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permit<br />

applications under the zone. <strong>Wodonga</strong> is one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest growing regional towns<br />

and the release <strong>of</strong> the land for redevelopment will provide a significant opportunity for<br />

commercial and residential development which serves the existing and future communities <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> and the surrounding region.<br />

9. Investigations into environmental contamination <strong>of</strong> the land have identified no significant<br />

impediment to the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land. The Environmental Audit Overlay is proposed to<br />

ensure that appropriate assessment and remediation <strong>of</strong> land is undertaken prior to the<br />

commencement <strong>of</strong> any sensitive use.<br />

10. Reports prepared in relation to the environmental status <strong>of</strong> the land with respect to flora and<br />

fauna species, remnant native vegetation and Aboriginal Cultural Heritage indicate that the<br />

land is substantially free from environmental constraints.<br />

11. The Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1 includes the Incorporated Document<br />

‘Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> – Comprehensive Development Plan’ and makes provision for:<br />

Page 156 <strong>of</strong> 304


o Future road links which will integrate the site with the existing urban fabric and support<br />

the division <strong>of</strong> high volumes <strong>of</strong> through vehicle associated with the Hume Freeway away<br />

from the Central Business Area.<br />

o New public open space areas and pedestrian links, including the provision <strong>of</strong> an Urban<br />

Square at the corner <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard.<br />

o The incorporation <strong>of</strong> the former Railway Station Buildings in future redevelopment.<br />

o The preparation <strong>of</strong> a Framework Plan outlining the future development <strong>of</strong> the land prior<br />

to more detailed preparation <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and planning permit applications by third<br />

<strong>part</strong>ies.<br />

o Exemptions from Notice and Review <strong>of</strong> permit applications generally in accordance with<br />

the Framework Plan and any approved Precinct Plan.<br />

o Development <strong>of</strong> the land with a wide range <strong>of</strong> land uses consistent with the vision for the<br />

land to comprise <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s Central Business Area.<br />

o Referral <strong>of</strong> applications to approve Precinct Plans and Permits to Places Victoria.<br />

BENEFITS OF EXEMPTION<br />

12. Intervening in this matter will enable the appropriate use and development <strong>of</strong> the land to be<br />

realised without unnecessary delays. The Amendment has arisen as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a long term<br />

strategy for Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> and is the result <strong>of</strong> significant investment in regional transport<br />

infrastructure. The Amendment provides the appropriate statutory tools for achieving the<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land in a manner which is consistent with the vision for the land<br />

projected by the Local Planning Policy Framework.<br />

13. The Amendment will achieve the objectives <strong>of</strong> planning in Victoria in section 4 <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic), in <strong>part</strong>icular section 4(1)(a), by providing for<br />

economic and sustainable use and development <strong>of</strong> land in a fair manner, section 4(1)(e), by<br />

facilitating development in accordance with the objectives in the preceding subsections, and<br />

section 4(1)(g), in that it also balances the present, and, in <strong>part</strong>icular, future interests <strong>of</strong> all<br />

Victorians. It also balances the objectives <strong>of</strong> the planning framework, including the<br />

objectives in section 4(2)(c), 4(2)(e), 4(2)(g) and 4(2)(h).<br />

14. The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the site for commercial and mixed use purposes will further State policy by<br />

supporting the sustainable growth <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> as one <strong>of</strong> the key Regional Centres identified<br />

in the Regional Victoria Settlement Framework Plan at clause 11.05-1. The project has<br />

considerable economic benefit in terms <strong>of</strong> employment and flow on investment to Victoria,<br />

both in the short and long term. The amendment is consistent with State and Local Planning<br />

Policies, in <strong>part</strong>icular the ‘Regional Planning Strategies and Principles’ <strong>of</strong> Clause 11.05-4<br />

which:<br />

o Support a network <strong>of</strong> integrated and regional settlements;<br />

o Encourage the utilisation <strong>of</strong> redundant urban land with limited environmental or heritage<br />

constraints;<br />

o Support the strategic relocation <strong>of</strong> transport infrastructure consistent with regional plans;<br />

o Support the increased growth <strong>of</strong> regional townships through provision for employment,<br />

community facilities and services that are connected in central locations.<br />

Page 157 <strong>of</strong> 304


15. The proposal to rezone the land to allow for its future commercial redevelopment is<br />

anticipated within the Local Policy Framework <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme at Clause<br />

21.12- 02 and Clause 21.11-02 which acknowledges that ‘The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area<br />

Masterplan provides a strategic framework for the future redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

CBA and its periphery, with the knowledge that the relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney<br />

Railway line is a funded project and will proceed’. The approval <strong>of</strong> Amendment C92 will<br />

facilitate the timely rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land in a manner which is generally consistent with the<br />

land uses and development opportunities depicted in the Framework Plan for <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Central Business Area at Clause 21.11.02.<br />

16. The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to accommodate commercial and residential land uses:<br />

o Consolidates the role <strong>of</strong> Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> as the primary centre and activity node for<br />

retail, commerce and entertainment use and development. (Clause21.11.-1)<br />

o Contributes to <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s sub regional role for retailing and services (Clause 21.03-3)<br />

o Assist the transition <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s Central Business Area to one which is appropriate for<br />

a major regional Centre in terms <strong>of</strong> its size and commercial <strong>of</strong>fer (Clause 21.05-1)<br />

o Provides for a network <strong>of</strong> interconnected streets within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and the<br />

realignment and upgrade <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard at its intersection with High Street. (Clause<br />

21.12 - 01)<br />

o Contributes to the diversion <strong>of</strong> vehicle traffic associated with the Hume Freeway from<br />

Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> (Clause 21.12-01).<br />

o Will act as a catalyst for revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the Central Business Area (Clause 21.05-6).<br />

o Encourage the provision <strong>of</strong> residential accommodation within the Central Business Area<br />

(Cluse 21.06-1 and Clause 21.10-3) through supporting environmental and aesthetic<br />

improvements.<br />

o Recognises the importance <strong>of</strong> ongoing contribution <strong>of</strong> the Former Railway Station and<br />

Goods Shed buildings as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the civic identity through application <strong>of</strong> the Heritage<br />

Overlay HO10.<br />

17. The Amendment will facilitate the release <strong>of</strong> the land to enable its redevelopment consistent<br />

with its identified strategic role and provides a net community benefit which supports the<br />

existing and future population <strong>of</strong> the Region. The development <strong>of</strong> the site is expected to<br />

generate a significant number <strong>of</strong> jobs within the construction industry as well as local<br />

employment through long term commercial uses and the opportunities provided to<br />

accommodate high density residential use in a Central and well serviced area. These positive<br />

impacts support the expedition <strong>of</strong> the development and balance the present and future<br />

interests <strong>of</strong> all Victorians.<br />

EFFECTS OF EXEMPTION ON THIRD PARTIES<br />

18. Key considerations for Amendment C92 include its potential impact on local amenity.<br />

19. While there has been no direct public consultation on the form <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone extensive public consultation has occurred in relation to the<br />

redevelopment potential <strong>of</strong> the land. This includes a large scale consultation process<br />

incorporating market research, community engagement (telephone and interview), public<br />

display and media campaign, community and commerce focus groups. A description <strong>of</strong> the<br />

public consultation undertaken by Victorian Rail Track is included as an attachment to this<br />

Page 158 <strong>of</strong> 304


document. Community Feedback from the public consultation phase expressed a desire for<br />

the development <strong>of</strong> the site to be realised without ongoing delays supporting expeditious<br />

approval <strong>of</strong> the Amendment.<br />

20. Since the land was identified as an Urban Renewal project to be overseen by Places Victoria a<br />

number <strong>of</strong> refinements were made to the proposed precincts and concepts emphasising the<br />

connection <strong>of</strong> the land with the Sumsion Gardens (through the purchase <strong>of</strong> No. 27 South<br />

Street), and the provision <strong>of</strong> varied public open space areas more central to the site. These<br />

changes are reflected in the Comprehensive Development Plan and Zone schedule but do not<br />

represent a significant de<strong>part</strong>ure from the concepts presented to the community in land use or<br />

development terms.<br />

21. The proposed redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land is expected to have positive impacts on the<br />

revitalisation <strong>of</strong> Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> by facilitating road upgrades which will divert significant<br />

through traffic volumes, improve connectivity and remove the current significant physical<br />

barrier. The proposed amendment will also have the effect <strong>of</strong> facilitating the provision <strong>of</strong> an<br />

Urban Square at the intersection <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard.<br />

22. The purpose <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone are consistent with the broad vision<br />

for the land articulated by the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area Plan and the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road<br />

Strategy which are documents comprising <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme. The <strong>City</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> have been consulted directly with respect to the drafting <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone.<br />

23. The Comprehensive Development Zone requires that a Framework Plan and Precinct Plans be<br />

prepared prior to the consideration <strong>of</strong> any permit application. The <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> will<br />

remain the Responsible Authority for the consideration <strong>of</strong> the Framework Plan, Precinct Plans<br />

and Planning Permits. The Comprehensive Development Zone sets out requirements for the<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> supporting documentation in preparation <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong><br />

the Responsible Authority. The inclusion <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria as a referral authority in the<br />

Zone (and at Clause 66.04) will aid the co-ordinated redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land through<br />

contribution to the Framework Plan and subsequent Precinct Plans as well as permit<br />

applications.<br />

24. The land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment does not have any sensitive abuttals and is separated from<br />

residential uses by roadways. Impacts on the amenity <strong>of</strong> the area are expected to be<br />

consistent with those anticipated in the Central Business Area and justify exemption from<br />

notice and review. Localised amenity impacts are also able to be assessed in any the planning<br />

permit application made under an approved Precinct Plan.<br />

ASSESSMENT AS TO WHETHER BENEFITS OF EXEMPTION OUTWEIGH<br />

EFFECTS ON THIRD PARTIES<br />

25. The benefits to the community through facilitating the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the site and the<br />

associated construction related, and long term commercial employment justify the exemption<br />

and outweigh any perceived potential negative effects on third <strong>part</strong>ies. In <strong>part</strong>icular I am<br />

satisfied that the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land is consistent with the long term strategy for the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area and allows key road and public open space projects to<br />

proceed without unnecessary delay.<br />

26. Accordingly, after weighing all <strong>of</strong> the benefits and effects described above, I consider that the<br />

benefits <strong>of</strong> exempting myself from sections 17, 18 and 19 <strong>of</strong> the Act outweigh any effects <strong>of</strong><br />

the exemption on third <strong>part</strong>ies.<br />

Page 159 <strong>of</strong> 304


DECISION<br />

27. I have decided to exercise my power to exempt myself from all the requirements <strong>of</strong> sections<br />

17, 18 and 19 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act 1987 and the regulations in respect <strong>of</strong><br />

Amendment C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

REASONS FOR INTERVENTION<br />

28. In accordance with the Ministerial Powers <strong>of</strong> Intervention in Planning and Heritage Matters<br />

Practice Note I provide the following reasons for my decision to exercise my power under<br />

section 20(4) <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act 1987.<br />

29. I am satisfied that –<br />

The interests <strong>of</strong> this <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> Victoria make such an exemption appropriate because:<br />

� The benefits <strong>of</strong> this Amendment in ensuring the future use and development <strong>of</strong> the site in<br />

a manner which is consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area outweigh any<br />

perceived negative impacts <strong>of</strong> bringing the Amendment forward.<br />

� The Amendment will facilitate the completion <strong>of</strong> key regional road projects and the<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> public open space and pedestrian connections within Central <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

which are a priority for revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the Centre.<br />

� The Amendment supports economic investment <strong>of</strong> Regional significance identified in the<br />

Local Planning Policy Framework pending divestment <strong>of</strong> the former Railway Land.<br />

� The Amendment supports the sustainable growth <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> as one <strong>of</strong> the key Regional<br />

Centres identified in the Regional Settlement Framework Plan <strong>of</strong> the State Planning<br />

Policy.<br />

� The amendment avoids unnecessary delays and will allow redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land in a<br />

manner which is <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a long term strategy for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area and<br />

is supported by the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� The amendment provides for the ongoing involvement <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria as a referral<br />

authority aiding delivery <strong>of</strong> a co-ordinated and high quality design and land use outcome.<br />

MATHEW GUY MLC<br />

Minister for Planning<br />

Date: November, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 160 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 161 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Town Planning Report -Amendment<br />

C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme<br />

Rezoning <strong>of</strong> the Former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station and associated Land<br />

Prepared on behalf <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria<br />

Reference: 0146635_R01<br />

November <strong>2011</strong><br />

www.erm.com


1 INTRODUCTION<br />

This submission has been prepared on behalf <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria and<br />

accompanies a request to the Minister for Planning to undertake Amendment<br />

C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme. The amendment seeks to rezone land<br />

comprising the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land in<br />

Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The amendment also proposes the rezoning <strong>of</strong> a number <strong>of</strong><br />

Council owned land parcels in South Street and High Street, <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The amendment has arisen as a result <strong>of</strong> the relocation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> V-Line<br />

Passenger Railway Station to Melrose Drive, <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The relocation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Station and associated diversion <strong>of</strong> the rail line has rendered the land vacant<br />

and surplus to operational requirements.<br />

The rezoning seeks to facilitate the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> land in this manner<br />

has been contemplated as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the strategic plan for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business Area. It is broadly reflected in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area<br />

Masterplan, 2006 which comprises <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Local Policy Framework <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme<br />

It is proposed that the land be rezoned from the Public Use Zone 4 (and<br />

Residential 1 Zone, Business 1 Zone and Road Zone 2) to the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone 1. In addition it is proposed to apply the Environmental<br />

Audit Overlay, and delete the Design and Development Overlay which<br />

applies to the land. It is also proposed to apply a site specific Heritage<br />

Overlay HO10 to the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station.<br />

This report describes the proposed amendments and supporting background<br />

documentation and the relevant policy context <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning<br />

Scheme.<br />

The following reports have been consulted in reparation <strong>of</strong> this report;<br />

• Supplementary Environmental Site Assessment, <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Rail<br />

Precinct, Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>, Senversa, Final 14 January, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

• Archaeological Heritage Assessment for VicTrack <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Corridors,<br />

Stages 1-7, Biosis Research, August 2010.<br />

• CBRE, Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Land Use Study.<br />

• Draft Development Plan prepared by Katsieris Origami Architecture.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Masterplan, Urban Design Principles, The Buchan Group,<br />

September, 2003.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Arterial Network Study, Development <strong>of</strong> a Strategic Transport<br />

Model, CPG 4 April, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA Masterplan, 2006 Strategic Planning Report and Associated<br />

Urban Design Guidelines, Macroplan Australia, 2007.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

1<br />

Page 162 <strong>of</strong> 304


• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex, Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development<br />

Options, Heritage issues, Bryce Raworth Conservation and Urban Design,<br />

September, 2010.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway station Heritage Assessment, Context Heritage<br />

Consultants, Draft 21 November, <strong>2011</strong><br />

• Ecological Assessment, Aecom <strong>Wodonga</strong> Parts 1 to 7, Victoria, September,<br />

2010.<br />

• Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Strategic Land Use Study, May 2010, CBRE Richard Ellis,<br />

May 2010.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre, Market Scope for Future Growth, Pitney Bowes<br />

Business Insight, Draft May 2010.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

2<br />

Page 163 <strong>of</strong> 304


2 SUBJECT LAND AND LOCALITY<br />

2.1 REGIONAL CONTEXT<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> is a regional centre located on the Murray River in North East<br />

Victoria, approximately 300 kilometres from Melbourne. <strong>Wodonga</strong> adjoins<br />

the town <strong>of</strong> Albury, New South Wales and is a significant inland regional<br />

Centre. The combined population for the centres was around 105,000 in 2006<br />

and is projected to grow to 126,000 by the year 2051 (Clause 21.04 <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Planning Scheme).<br />

The land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment principally comprises the former<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>, as<br />

well as adjoining land parcels owned by the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The rail land is<br />

no longer required for transport purposes due to the relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a regional project to realign the Melbourne to<br />

Sydney Rail corridor outside <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> is located on the Hume Highway which forms <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the National<br />

Highway route and connects Albury and <strong>Wodonga</strong> to Sydney in the North,<br />

and Melbourne in the South. The Hume Highway route passes to the east<br />

(High Street) and south (Elgin Boulevard) <strong>of</strong> the subject land. Diversion <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Hume Freeway Route is a key component <strong>of</strong> upgrading the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business District.<br />

2.2 SUBJECT LAND<br />

The subject land is generally bound by Elgin Boulevard to the south, Watson<br />

Street to the west, High Street and Church Street to the east, and Bond Street<br />

and South Street to the north. The land formerly comprised the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station and associated rail corridor. The irregular parcel follows the<br />

rail yards from the intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street, west to<br />

Watson Street adjoining South Street. The land parcel comprises an area in<br />

excess <strong>of</strong> 100,000sqm and is located at the northern edge <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Central Business Area. The extent <strong>of</strong> land affected by Amendment C92 is<br />

depicted in Figure 2.1 below.<br />

The land includes parcels <strong>of</strong> land owned by the <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council at No.<br />

35 to 51 South Street and No. 107 High Street as well as Elgin Boulevard<br />

between Smythe Street and High Street, <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

A Title Compilation plan prepared by Reeds Consulting is contained at<br />

Appendix A. Copies <strong>of</strong> the corresponding Certificates <strong>of</strong> Title have been<br />

submitted as a separate document and include a range <strong>of</strong> restrictions in terms<br />

<strong>of</strong> easements (drainage, sewerage, carriageway) and conditions.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

3<br />

Page 164 <strong>of</strong> 304


(Source: www.land.vic.gov.au (scale unknown) )<br />

Figure 2.1 Land Subject to Amendment C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme<br />

The land is developed with the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building,<br />

Goods Shed, redundant rail infrastructure and signalling boxes. The eastern<br />

end <strong>of</strong> the land adjoining High Street comprises retail buildings and an open<br />

lot car saes yard on the corner <strong>of</strong> Bond Street and High Street. A commuter<br />

car park is located on the northern side <strong>of</strong> the land adjoining Bond Street.<br />

Scattered trees are located across the land, a number <strong>of</strong> which have been<br />

identified as indigenous. The land is relatively flat with areas <strong>of</strong> built up land<br />

associated with the former rail platform and station area. A steep<br />

embankment is located along the South Street frontage at the western end, so<br />

that the adjoining area <strong>of</strong> South Street is elevated above the subject land. The<br />

Council owned land parcels in South Street are vacant.<br />

The land is relatively unconstrained in terms <strong>of</strong> its built form and<br />

environmental context. A summary <strong>of</strong> the <strong>part</strong>icular conditions <strong>of</strong> the land<br />

identified in consultant reports is contained in the assessment section <strong>of</strong> this<br />

report.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

4<br />

Page 165 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Subject Site<br />

N


2.3 LOCALITY<br />

The land is located at the northern edge <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business<br />

Area. High Street and Elgin Boulevard form <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Hume Freeway route<br />

through <strong>Wodonga</strong>. High Street south <strong>of</strong> its intersection with Elgin Boulevard<br />

forms <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s traditional retail High Street. Land broadly to the north <strong>of</strong><br />

South Street is residential, while land to the south and east forms Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>’s retail areas. Land to the west over Watson Street is industrial in<br />

nature. The site’s context relative to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area is<br />

shown in the aerial photograph at Figure 2.2.<br />

Adjoining land use and development includes:<br />

To the South<br />

• Elgin Boulevard is a key arterial currently supporting vehicle traffic from<br />

the Hume Freeway/High Street.<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> High Street (south <strong>of</strong> the intersection with Elgin Boulevard),<br />

is the principal retail and commercial core and principally comprises one<br />

and two storey retail buildings with <strong>of</strong>fice or storage at the first floor level.<br />

• Safeway Supermarket and car park is located south <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard,<br />

(between High Street and Church Street).<br />

• Kentucky Fried Chicken Convenience Restaurant and car park is located at<br />

the south western corner <strong>of</strong> Church Street and Elgin Boulevard.<br />

• The former Municipal Swimming Pool Reserve is located on the south side<br />

<strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard (between Smythe Street and Church Street).<br />

• Adjoining and to the south at the site’s western end is vacant and<br />

developed commercial land (on the northern side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard)<br />

including ALDI Supermarket at the corner <strong>of</strong> Watson Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard.<br />

• Centro Shopping Centre and associated car park is located on the southern<br />

side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard (between Smythe and Watson Street).<br />

To the East<br />

• Is High Street which is the key north south route <strong>of</strong> the Hume Highway<br />

through <strong>Wodonga</strong> and the main retail street (south <strong>of</strong> the Elgin Boulevard<br />

intersection).<br />

• The future ‘Manns’ Shopping Centre redevelopment site (comprising<br />

approximately 24600 m sq <strong>of</strong> retail floor area) is located to the east over<br />

High Street.<br />

• Development addressing the east side <strong>of</strong> High Street (north <strong>of</strong> the Elgin<br />

Boulevard intersection) includes one and two storey retail buildings.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

5<br />

Page 166 <strong>of</strong> 304


To the West<br />

• Is Watson Street which is a local street, terminating at the subject land.<br />

• To the west over Watson Street is low level industrial and commercial land<br />

and an Electricity sub station on corner <strong>of</strong> Watson Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard.<br />

• The rail corridor continues to the west adjoining South Street.<br />

To the North<br />

• South Street is a two way local street running along the northern side <strong>of</strong><br />

the railway land.<br />

• Single dwellings and units are located along the northern side <strong>of</strong> South<br />

Street opposite the land.<br />

• Bond Street at the land’s eastern end connects to High Street in the east<br />

and Church Street in the north and forms <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the northern boundary <strong>of</strong><br />

the land.<br />

• On the opposite (northern side <strong>of</strong> Bond Street) land is used for low level<br />

commercial purposes.<br />

• High Street further to the north comprises restricted retail uses and lower<br />

order commercial uses.<br />

• Immediately adjoining to the north at the corner <strong>of</strong> Church Street and<br />

South Street is the Carrion Hotel and car park.<br />

• Immediately adjoining to the north along South Street are an<br />

<strong>of</strong>fice/medical centre building, <strong>Wodonga</strong> Ambulance Station.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVEMBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

6<br />

Page 167 <strong>of</strong> 304


(Source: nearmap.com)<br />

Figure 2.2 Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business Area, Showing Location <strong>of</strong> Land Subject to Amendment C92<br />

Subject Site<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT/ 25 NOVEMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

7<br />

Page 168 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Am C92<br />

N


3 PROPOSAL<br />

The amendment proposes to rezone the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and<br />

associated rail land to allow for its future mixed use and development, and<br />

delivery <strong>of</strong> key public roads and public open space in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The amendment:<br />

• Rezones the land from the Public Use Zone 4, Road Zone 2, Residential 1<br />

Zone and Business 1 Zone to the Comprehensive Development Zone,<br />

Schedule 1.<br />

• Introduces the Comprehensive Development Zone – Schedule 1 ‘Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> - Redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the Former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and<br />

Rail Land’.<br />

• Applies the Environmental Audit Overlay to the Land.<br />

• Applies the Heritage Overlay HO10 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin<br />

Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ to the places <strong>of</strong> heritage significance.<br />

• Deletes the Design and Development Overlay 4 ‘Elgin Boulevard’ which<br />

applies to the land.<br />

• Undertakes consequential minor modifications to the Municipal Strategic<br />

Statement and Local Planning Policy at Clause 21.11, Clause 21.12 and<br />

Clause 22.09.<br />

• Inserts reference to Maps 6EAO and 7EAO in the Schedule to Clause 61.03<br />

‘Maps which Comprise Part <strong>of</strong> this Scheme.’<br />

• Includes Places Victoria as a referral authority for approval <strong>of</strong> permit<br />

applications and Precincts Plans under the Comprehensive Development<br />

Zone 1 in the schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

• Includes reference to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development<br />

Plan’ (‘Map 1’) in the Schedule at Clause 81.01 ‘Documents Incorporated<br />

Into this Scheme’.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT/25 NOVEMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

8<br />

Page 169 <strong>of</strong> 304


4 WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

The following sets out the relevant strategic context <strong>of</strong> the subject land within<br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning scheme.<br />

4.1 EXISTING ZONING AND OVERLAY CONTROLS<br />

The land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment principally comprises the former<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land. An extract from the<br />

zoning map <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme is contained at Figure 4.1.<br />

Figure 4.1 Extract from Existing Zoning Map, <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme<br />

The existing zoning <strong>of</strong> land subject <strong>of</strong> the amendment is summarised as:<br />

• Victorian Rail Track Land associated with the former use <strong>of</strong> the land for<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and rail corridor is zoned Public Use Zone 4<br />

‘Transport’. The Public Use Zone 4 is specific to the site’s former use. The<br />

Zone is no longer relevant and prevents use and development <strong>of</strong> the land<br />

consistent with its role in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business area.<br />

• Elgin Boulevard between Smythe Street and High Street is zoned Road<br />

Zone 2 on account <strong>of</strong> its designation in the local road network. It is noted<br />

that the alignment <strong>of</strong> the Road Zone 2 along Elgin Boulevard reflects its<br />

future alignment.<br />

• Parcels <strong>of</strong> land on the northern and southern side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and<br />

adjoining High Street are zoned Business 1. This includes land currently<br />

comprising Elgin Boulevard at its intersection with High Street.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 170 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

9<br />

Subject Site<br />

N


• Parcels <strong>of</strong> vacant land in South Street which are owned by <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong><br />

Council are zoned Residential 1.<br />

• The land at No. 27 South Street zoned Business 4 recently acquired by<br />

Places Victoria to provide a link to Bank Street and Sumsion Gardens to the<br />

north.<br />

All land (excluding roadways) subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment is affected by the<br />

Design and Development Overlay 4 ‘Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ as depicted<br />

in the extract from the corresponding Overlay Map in Figure 4.2.<br />

DDO4<br />

Subject Site<br />

Figure 4.2 Extract from Existing Design and Development Overlay Map, <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Planning Scheme<br />

The Design and Development Overlay 4 (DDO4) applies within Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> to land either side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard between Watson Street and<br />

High Street. The overlay provides design based objectives and requirements<br />

focussed on providing high quality streetscapes and active frontages. The<br />

proposed amendment includes deletion <strong>of</strong> the DDO4 from the land. Key<br />

principals from the Overlay are incorporated within the proposed<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

4.2 PARTICULAR PROVISIONS<br />

A range <strong>of</strong> <strong>part</strong>icular provisions are applicable to proposals to use and<br />

develop land. Of note is that the schedule to Clause 52.06 includes a ‘Precinct<br />

Parking Plan’ for Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> which includes the subject land. This Plan<br />

sets out parking rates which apply across the nominated area and have been<br />

derived with specific reference to parking demand and policy for Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>. Clause 52.17 ‘Native Vegetation’ requires a permit to remove<br />

native vegetation.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 171 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

DDO4<br />

10<br />

N


5 PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

5.1 PROPOSED ZONING AND OVERLAY CONTROLS<br />

It is proposed to rezone the land to the Comprehensive Development Zone, a<br />

new zone at Clause 37.02 the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme. It is proposed that<br />

the Comprehensive Development Zone be applied to all <strong>of</strong> the land identified<br />

in Figure 4.1. The purposes <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone (Clause<br />

37.02) are:<br />

‘To implement the State Planning Policy Framework and the Local Planning Policy<br />

Framework, including the Municipal Strategic Statement and local planning policies.’<br />

‘To provide for a range <strong>of</strong> uses and the development <strong>of</strong> land in accordance with a<br />

comprehensive development plan incorporated in this scheme.’<br />

Schedule 1 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan’ has been<br />

prepared to apply to the land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment. The schedule has<br />

been drafted to reflect the <strong>part</strong>icular opportunities for the use and<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the land.<br />

The implementation <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone rests on the<br />

inclusion <strong>of</strong> a Comprehensive Development Plan in the Schedule to the Zone.<br />

The plan depicts precincts and key components <strong>of</strong> the site’s development to be<br />

read in conjunction with precinct objectives contained in the zone schedule.<br />

A permit is required for buildings and works pursuant to Clause 37.02-4 <strong>of</strong><br />

the Zone. The zone makes provision for exemption from notice and review<br />

for development which is generally in accordance with a ‘Comprehensive<br />

Development Plan’ and exemptions may also be granted for the construction<br />

<strong>of</strong> buildings and works through the zone schedule.<br />

It is proposed that a site specific Heritage Overlay HO10 (Clause 43.01) be<br />

applied to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’. The<br />

purposes <strong>of</strong> the Heritage Overlay are to:<br />

To implement the State Planning Policy Framework and the Local Planning Policy<br />

Framework, including the Municipal Strategic Statement and local planning policies.<br />

To conserve and enhance heritage places <strong>of</strong> natural or cultural significance.<br />

To conserve and enhance those elements which contribute to the significance <strong>of</strong><br />

heritage places.<br />

To ensure that development does not adversely affect the significance <strong>of</strong> heritage<br />

places.<br />

To conserve specifically identified heritage places by allowing a use that would<br />

otherwise be prohibited if this will demonstrably assist with the conservation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

significance <strong>of</strong> the heritage place.<br />

The overlay requires a permit for construction <strong>of</strong> buildings and works<br />

(including demolition).<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 172 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

11


It is proposed that the Environmental Audit Overlay (Clause 45.03) be applied<br />

to all <strong>of</strong> the land. Pursuant to Clause 45.03-1 it is a requirement that:<br />

‘Before a sensitive use (residential use, child care centre, pre-school centre or primary<br />

school) commences or before the construction or carrying out <strong>of</strong> buildings and works<br />

in association with a sensitive use commences, either:<br />

• A certificate <strong>of</strong> environmental audit must be issued for the land in accordance with<br />

Part IXD <strong>of</strong> the Environment Protection Act 1970, or<br />

• An environmental auditor appointed under the Environment Protection Act 1970<br />

must make a statement in accordance with Part IXD <strong>of</strong> that Act that the<br />

environmental conditions <strong>of</strong> the land are suitable for the sensitive use.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 173 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

12


6 STATE PLANNING POLICY FRAMEWORK<br />

The State Planning Policy Framework sets out principals for the use and<br />

development <strong>of</strong> land across Victoria. The following elements are <strong>of</strong> relevance<br />

in consideration <strong>of</strong> the proposed amendment:<br />

Clause 11.01-2 ‘Activity Centre Planning’ has the objective to: ‘To encourage the<br />

concentration <strong>of</strong> major retail, residential, commercial, administrative, entertainment<br />

and cultural developments into activity centres which provide a variety <strong>of</strong> land uses<br />

and are highly accessible to the community.’<br />

Clause 11.02-1 ‘Supply <strong>of</strong> Urban Land’ has the objective to ‘ensure a sufficient<br />

supply <strong>of</strong> land is available for residential, commercial, retail, industrial, recreational,<br />

institutional and other community uses’ and should consider ‘opportunities for the<br />

consolidation, redevelopment and intensification <strong>of</strong> existing urban areas’.<br />

Clause 11.05-1 ‘Regional Settlement Networks’ identifies <strong>Wodonga</strong> as a key<br />

regional location in which to encourage sustainable development consistent<br />

with the Regional Victoria Settlement Framework Plan. An integrated<br />

planning response is sought between settlements, within regions and in<br />

adjoining regions and States. Growth in regional settlements is to be directed<br />

to where it can be provided in the most ‘efficient and sustainable’.<br />

Clause 11.05-4 sets out Planning Strategies and Principles for Regional Areas<br />

including:<br />

• ‘Support[ing] a network <strong>of</strong> integrated and prosperous regional settlements.<br />

• Utilis[ing] redundant urban land with limited environmental or heritage<br />

constraints.<br />

• Support[ing] the strategic relocation <strong>of</strong> transport infrastructure consistent with<br />

regional plans.<br />

• Support[ing] the increased growth <strong>of</strong> the regional township through provision <strong>of</strong><br />

opportunities for employment, community facilities and services that are<br />

connected in central locations.<br />

• Encouraging high quality urban and architectural design which enhances the<br />

character <strong>of</strong> the existing township.<br />

• Improving opportunities for a diverse range <strong>of</strong> accommodation in a well serviced<br />

location.’<br />

Clause 12.01-1 ‘Protection <strong>of</strong> Habitat’ seeks to protect biodiversity and utilise<br />

land for urban development which minismises disruption to native vegetation<br />

and plant and animal habitat.<br />

Clause 12.01-2 Native Vegetation Management provides for the retention <strong>of</strong><br />

remnant native vegetation and seeks to achieve ‘net gain in the extent and<br />

quality <strong>of</strong> native vegetation’. ‘Victoria’s Native Vegetation Framework<br />

Management Plan’ is to be used in assessment <strong>of</strong> native vegetation.<br />

Clause 13.03-1 ‘Use <strong>of</strong> Contaminated and Potentially Contaminated Land’<br />

seeks to ensure that potentially contaminated land is suitable for its future use<br />

through application <strong>of</strong> the Environmental Audit Overlay.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 174 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

13


Cause 15.01-1 ‘Urban Design’ has the objective to ‘create urban environments<br />

that are safe, functional and provide good quality environments with a sense <strong>of</strong> place<br />

and cultural identity’.<br />

Clause 15.03 ‘Heritage’ has the objective to ‘ensure the conservation <strong>of</strong> places <strong>of</strong><br />

heritage significance,’ while Clause 15.03-2 ‘Aboriginal Cultural Heritage’ seeks<br />

to ensure the protection and conservation <strong>of</strong> places <strong>of</strong> Aboriginal cultural<br />

heritage significance.<br />

Clause 17.01-1 ‘Business’ encourages ‘development which meets the communities<br />

needs for retail, entertainment, <strong>of</strong>fice and other commercial services and provides net<br />

community benefit in relation to accessibility, efficient infrastructure use and the<br />

aggregation and sustainability <strong>of</strong> commercial facilities.’<br />

Clause 17.03-1 ‘Facilitating Tourism’ seeks to support the development <strong>of</strong><br />

regional tourism through planning for facilities.<br />

Clause 18.01-1 ‘Land Use and Transport Planning’ seeks to ‘create a safe and<br />

sustainable transport system by integrating land-use and transport’ and<br />

development corridors which support radial and circumferential radial<br />

movements.<br />

Clause 18.02-4 ‘Management <strong>of</strong> the Road System’ seeks to support the<br />

strategic upgrade <strong>of</strong> transport routes.<br />

Clause 18.02-5 ‘Car Parking’ has the objective to ‘ensure an adequate supply <strong>of</strong><br />

car parking that is appropriately designed and located’ and to encourage the efficient<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> car parking through consolidation.’<br />

Clause 19 Infrastructure seeks to plan for social and physical infrastructure in<br />

a way that is ‘efficient, equitable, accessible and timely’.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 175 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

14


7 LOCAL PLANNING POLICY FRAMEWORK<br />

7.1 MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>’s Municipal Strategic Statement (MSS) sets out the future strategic<br />

direction for the municipality at Clause 21 <strong>of</strong> the Planning Scheme.<br />

Clause 21.01 ‘Planning for the Future‘ identifies that ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> has experienced<br />

strong growth over the past thirty-five years and will continue to grow at close to 2%<br />

per annum over the next 15 years. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Council has addressed the need to<br />

plan for the future by completing the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Growth Strategy Plan, which<br />

demonstrates how <strong>Wodonga</strong> will cater for urban growth well beyond 2050’. The<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Growth Strategy plans for growth beyond 2036 and plans for the<br />

development and implementation <strong>of</strong> several key infrastructure projects,<br />

including:<br />

• ‘The Hume Freeway;<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail By-pass project;<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan;<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area (CBA) upgrade;<br />

• Reinforcement <strong>of</strong> the role and potential improvement <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA as a mixed<br />

use centre and the city’s major retail, civic, entertainment and community centre.<br />

• The planning approach will continue to build on the strength <strong>of</strong> a well planned and<br />

effective road network in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan.’<br />

In the Regional Context (Clause 21.03-3) <strong>Wodonga</strong> is strategically placed in<br />

the context <strong>of</strong> North East Victoria and Southern New South Wales. It provides<br />

a ‘sub regional role for retailing and services’ and its location makes it a central<br />

point for access to surrounding tourist attractions.<br />

Clause 21.04 :’Pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ identifies<br />

• ‘Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> is one <strong>of</strong> Australia’s fastest growing inland regional centre.’<br />

• ‘In 2006, the total population <strong>of</strong> the Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> statistical area was estimated<br />

at 105,000.<br />

• ‘By the year 2021, Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> will have an estimated population <strong>of</strong> 126,000<br />

and by 2051, the population will exceed 150,000.’<br />

• ‘The ABS estimated the resident population <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> to be 34,776, as <strong>of</strong> June<br />

2007. The population is expected to increase to 37,440 by <strong>2011</strong>, 43,640 by 2021<br />

and 50,600 by 2031.<br />

• ‘The total population increase in <strong>Wodonga</strong> from 1996-2031 is estimated to exceed<br />

the combined increase <strong>of</strong> Albury, Hume, Indigo and Towong <strong>council</strong>s.’<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 176 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

15


Clause 21.05-1 ‘Facilities and Presentation’ identifies that <strong>Wodonga</strong> ‘lacks the<br />

range <strong>of</strong> facilities and level <strong>of</strong> presentation in the CBA that is typically representative<br />

<strong>of</strong> a regional centre. This is due to the rapid transition <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> from a small<br />

country town to one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest growing regional centres’<br />

Clause 21.05-6 relates to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area (CBA) and<br />

notes:<br />

• The revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the CBA is a community priority.<br />

• The removal <strong>of</strong> the railway is viewed as an essential element and catalyst in<br />

achieving the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the CBA.<br />

• Visionary planning and a proactive approach are required to improve the CBA and<br />

provide a framework to facilitate development.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> needs to develop a stronger and more vibrant retail base.<br />

• The CBA should <strong>of</strong>fer a location for a vibrant mixed use environment, integrating<br />

retail business and residential uses.<br />

• Traffic management works are required to improve the amenity <strong>of</strong> the CBA for<br />

pedestrians and shoppers.<br />

• The funding <strong>of</strong> additional road and parking infrastructure required to support the<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the Central Business Area.<br />

21.06-2 ‘Regional Influences’ indicates that Council will recognise that the:<br />

• ‘Economy and development <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> should not be planned in isolation to<br />

Albury;<br />

• Duplication <strong>of</strong> facilities will be avoided to minimise costs, whilst respecting the<br />

need to provide an adequate range <strong>of</strong> facilities for a growing population; and,<br />

• A <strong>part</strong>nership approach will be undertaken (with the Commonwealth and State<br />

governments) to strategically plan for <strong>Wodonga</strong>.’<br />

Clause 21.06-3 ‘Environment’ seeks to identify environmental constraints<br />

prior to the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land.<br />

Clause 21.06-4 ‘Urban Design’ notes the importance <strong>of</strong> protecting the public<br />

realm and providing activated streets and ‘sleeving’ <strong>of</strong> car parking within<br />

retail development.<br />

Clause 21.06-5 ‘Infrastructure Provision’ notes that ‘Infrastructure will be<br />

provided in a timely, effective and cost efficient manner’ taking into account<br />

approved Structure and Development Contribution Plans.<br />

Clause 21.10-3 ‘Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ in relation to residential development,<br />

notes that ‘With the removal <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney railway line and the<br />

subsequent revitalization <strong>of</strong> the CBA, the attractiveness <strong>of</strong> living in central <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

will continue to increase.’<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 177 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

16


Clause 21.11-01 Activity Centres Strategy identifies that ‘The continued<br />

population growth in <strong>Wodonga</strong> has increased the potential for retail expansion in the<br />

CBA.’ The main retail strategies for <strong>Wodonga</strong> can be summarised as follows:<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is the primary centre and activity node for retail, commerce<br />

and entertainment use and development, the type <strong>of</strong> retail development to be<br />

encouraged is detailed in clause 21.11-02.<br />

• Bulky goods and large format retail uses are encouraged in central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan 2006;<br />

• Bulky goods retailing will be generally discouraged in other locations.<br />

Clause 21.11-02 ‘Redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ notes that:<br />

‘The upgrade and revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is one <strong>of</strong> the Council’s key<br />

strategic initiatives. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan provides a strategic<br />

framework for the future redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and its periphery, with<br />

the knowledge that the relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney railway line is a funded<br />

project and will proceed.’<br />

The Central Area Master Plan recognises the unique opportunity this provides for the<br />

positive transformation <strong>of</strong> the entire central area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. … The master plan is<br />

supported by research into important elements including urban design,<br />

economic/market analysis, traffic management, social/community aspirations and<br />

environmental constraints.<br />

Strategic Actions include (selected):<br />

• ‘Implement the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan 2006 and adopted urban<br />

design guidelines for the built form <strong>of</strong> development within the central area <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

• Continue to plan for the relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney Railway Line and<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former railway land.<br />

• Dispersion <strong>of</strong> through traffic away from High St and establishment <strong>of</strong> a permeable<br />

interconnected road and pedestrian network across the former railway land and<br />

throughout the CBA.<br />

• The intensification <strong>of</strong> the CBA will be encouraged within the Business 1, Business<br />

2 and Mixed Use Zones concentrated around the CBA through multi storeyed<br />

mixed use development encouraged up to six storeys in preference to single storey<br />

development sprawling beyond the core area <strong>of</strong> central <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

• Encourage core retailing activities to develop along Elgin Boulevard between<br />

Smythe St and High St including the former railway land, including discount<br />

de<strong>part</strong>ment stores, full range supermarkets, large format retail outlets and<br />

speciality retail shops<br />

• Encourage supporting retail and mixed uses north <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard between<br />

Watson and Smythe Streets.<br />

• Active promotion <strong>of</strong> mixed use development opportunities that encourage retail<br />

activity at the street level with commercial and residential uses on upper floor<br />

levels.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 178 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

17


• Through traffic will be dispersed away from High St and the street redeveloped to<br />

provide additional car parking, improved safety, accessibility and amenity for<br />

pedestrians.<br />

• Opportunities will be provided for large format/bulky goods retailing to occur in<br />

and around the periphery <strong>of</strong> the CBA as identified in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area<br />

Master Plan.<br />

• Encourage high quality medium density residential units to be developed in the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA.<br />

• Support private and public investment in the CBA that contributes towards<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> becoming a regional centre <strong>of</strong> significance.<br />

Clause 21.11-03 ‘Tourism’ seeks to facilitate the expansion <strong>of</strong> tourism<br />

opportunities that have regard to the environmental objectives <strong>of</strong> the MSS.<br />

Clause 21.12 identifies key infrastructure projects and includes<br />

• ‘The relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney rail line from the CBA...;<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> an outer ring roads’ system and other roads’ projects in<br />

accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan;<br />

• The upgrade <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA;’<br />

Clause 21.12-01 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan notes that Traffic management<br />

works are a major component toward the improvement and revitalisation <strong>of</strong><br />

the CBA. Features <strong>of</strong> the Road Strategy Plan include:<br />

• An inter-connected network <strong>of</strong> streets in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA will aid in the<br />

distribution <strong>of</strong> traffic and spread traffic loads across a number <strong>of</strong> road routes rather<br />

than a <strong>part</strong>icular designated route.<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> a permeable central road network in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Central Area Master Plan 2006 will allow for the dispersion <strong>of</strong> through traffic<br />

away from High St and the conversion <strong>of</strong> the street into a car parking, shopping<br />

and pedestrian precinct;<br />

• Elgin St will continue to be developed into a tree lined boulevard and realigned at<br />

High St to link with the eastern leg <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard;<br />

Clause 21.12-02 relates to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Facilities Upgrade’ and notes<br />

‘…in addition to providing up to 19 hectares <strong>of</strong> land for future commercial<br />

development, the project will be instrumental to the upgrade <strong>of</strong> the CBA, removing the<br />

physical barrier and traffic delays experienced ….<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Council will continue to work in <strong>part</strong>nership with the State and Federal<br />

governments to plan for and maximise the opportunities arising from this project.’<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 179 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

18


Clause 21.13-07 ‘Cultural and Built Heritage’ plans for the protection <strong>of</strong><br />

Heritage Places noting that a Heritage Study is to be undertaken to consider<br />

the relevant planning scheme protection required for identified places.<br />

Clause 21.15 ‘Reference Documents’ identifies the following relevant<br />

documents:<br />

• Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> Regional Planning Strategy (Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> Region Planning<br />

Committee 1991).<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA Strategic Planning Report – Master Plan 2006 and associated<br />

Urban Design Guidelines, August 2007.<br />

• Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> the Gateway to Growth (Macroplan 1998).<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Car Parking Strategy, Ratio Consultants, April 2003.<br />

• Rural <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Statement <strong>of</strong> Policy in Respect to Developer Contributions,<br />

1994.<br />

7.2 LOCAL PLANNING POLICIES<br />

Clause 22.09 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area’<br />

This local planning policy applies in the Central Business area and notes that:<br />

‘The city centre will be retained and consolidated as the municipality’s primary retail<br />

and business centre. This policy guides decision making in regard to the urban design<br />

and location <strong>of</strong> development in the Central Business Area, with the aim <strong>of</strong> supporting<br />

strategies to enhance the general levels <strong>of</strong> activity and the overall appearance <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>City</strong> centre. ‘<br />

Key policies include:<br />

• ‘The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area be planned and developed as the <strong>City</strong>’s<br />

primary retail, business, commercial and community centre.<br />

• The planning <strong>of</strong> the Central Business Area be generally in accordance with the<br />

adopted version <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan and its supporting<br />

guidelines.<br />

Clause 22.06 ‘Urban Design Along Main Roads’<br />

This policy applies to land adjoining the Road Zone Category 1 or 2 and seeks<br />

to encourage development which makes a positive contribution to built form<br />

through buildings and landscaping.<br />

Clause 22.17 ‘Public Open Space’<br />

This policy applies to the provision <strong>of</strong> open space in all zones <strong>of</strong> the planning<br />

scheme and seeks open space areas to be set aside at approximately 15% <strong>of</strong> the<br />

developed open space.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 180 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

19


8 ASSESSMENT<br />

The following is an assessment <strong>of</strong> the proposed amendment which<br />

incorporates the considerations <strong>of</strong> Ministerial Direction No. 11 ‘Strategic<br />

Assessment Guidelines’. A copy <strong>of</strong> the completed Guidelines is contained at<br />

Appendix B.<br />

8.1 CONSISTENCY WITH THE STATE AND LOCAL PLANNING POLICY FRAMEWORK<br />

The State Planning Policy Framework aims to strengthen the network <strong>of</strong><br />

Regional Centres across Victoria and provide for the concentration <strong>of</strong> retail,<br />

residential, commercial, administrative, entertainment and cultural<br />

developments within Activity Centres which provide a variety <strong>of</strong> land uses.<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

Regionally Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> is the main gateway between Victoria and New<br />

South Wales and is the largest regional provincial centre on the national<br />

transport route. <strong>Wodonga</strong> provides a sub regional role for retailing and<br />

services and a regional role for education. It is also well located with respect<br />

to surrounding regional tourism attractions. The proposal rezoning supports<br />

growth <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area and seeks to attract new<br />

investment opportunities in housing, residential use, tourism development,<br />

education and retail consistent with these roles.<br />

Having regard to this context the proposed amendment supports and<br />

implements the objectives, strategies and policies <strong>of</strong> the State Planning Policy<br />

Framework. In <strong>part</strong>icular:<br />

• Clause 11.01-2 ‘Activity Centre Planning’ by developing the Central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Business Area in a manner which directs land use and built<br />

form outcomes through the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

• Clause 11.05-1 ‘Regional Settlement Networks’ by supporting the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> facilities and services and utilising redundant<br />

infrastructure land.<br />

• Clause 11.05-4 ‘Regional Planning Strategies and Principles’<br />

o Supporting the role <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a network <strong>of</strong> integrated and<br />

prosperous regional settlements.<br />

o Utilising redundant urban land with limited environmental or heritage<br />

constraints.<br />

o Supporting the strategic relocation <strong>of</strong> transport infrastructure<br />

consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Growth Strategy.<br />

o Supporting the increased growth <strong>of</strong> the regional township through<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> opportunities for employment, accommodation<br />

community facilities and services that are connected in central<br />

locations.<br />

o Providing opportunities to encourage high quality urban and<br />

architectural design which enhances the character <strong>of</strong> the existing<br />

township.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 181 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

20


• Clause 13.03-1 ‘Use <strong>of</strong> Contaminated and Potentially Contaminated Land’<br />

- Ensuring that potentially contaminated land is suitable for its future use<br />

through application <strong>of</strong> the Environmental Audit Overlay.<br />

• Cause 15.01-1 ‘Urban Design’ - Providing for urban environments that are<br />

safe, functional and <strong>of</strong> good quality through incorporation <strong>of</strong> design<br />

objectives in the Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1.<br />

• Clause 15.03-1 ‘Heritage Conservation’ - Planning for inclusion <strong>of</strong> former<br />

Railway buildings and the adoption <strong>of</strong> thematic history in public open<br />

space through the Comprehensive Development Zone and through the<br />

application <strong>of</strong> the Heritage Overlay ‘HO10’ to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station, Elgin Boulevard, <strong>Wodonga</strong>’.<br />

• Clause 18.01-1 ‘Land use and Transport Planning’ - Supporting<br />

improvements to the road network which allow the diversion <strong>of</strong> through<br />

traffic from <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre and planning for pedestrian and<br />

cyclist links integrated with the existing township fabric.<br />

The amendment and the land’s long term redevelopment support the future<br />

vision for the consolidation and revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business District. Clause 21.01 ‘Planning for the Future’ projects continued<br />

urban growth <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> beyond the year 2050 while Clause 21.03-3<br />

identifies <strong>Wodonga</strong> as one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest growing regional centres<br />

sustaining continued population growth and further growth in economic<br />

prosperity.<br />

The implementation <strong>of</strong> key infrastructure projects identified in the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Growth Strategy are central to the proposed amendment and include the<br />

diversion <strong>of</strong> the Hume Freeway, The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail By-pass project and the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area (CBA) upgrade. In <strong>part</strong>icular the relocation<br />

<strong>of</strong> the railway is a project which has been anticipated as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the growth<br />

strategy for <strong>Wodonga</strong> on the proviso at Clause 21.12 that it would enable as<br />

‘land to be set aside for commercial development...’<br />

The long term redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the subject land as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the upgrade <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is noted at Clause 21.11-02 as ‘a unique opportunity this provides<br />

for the positive transformation <strong>of</strong> the entire central area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>...’. Clause<br />

21.05-5 identifies that ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> lacks the range <strong>of</strong> facilities and level <strong>of</strong> presentation<br />

in the CBA that is typically representative <strong>of</strong> a regional centre. This is due to the<br />

rapid transition <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> for a small country town to one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest<br />

growing regional centres.’ In this context, the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the subject land is<br />

justified as it provides the significant opportunity required to elevate<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> to fulfil its strategic regional role within Victoria.<br />

The framework for development <strong>of</strong> the land will be established by Places<br />

Victoria and will be facilitated through their ongoing involvement as a referral<br />

authority for the approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permit applications under the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1. This will aid the delivery <strong>of</strong> a<br />

co-ordinated and high quality design and land use outcome which is reflective<br />

<strong>of</strong> the strategic importance <strong>of</strong> the land.<br />

The proposed rezoning delivers the vision for the priority revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Master<br />

Plan (and Clause 21.05-6, Clause 21.11.02 Clause 21.06-1) through:<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 182 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

21


• Planning for road projects consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan<br />

that support the dispersion <strong>of</strong> through traffic away from High Street, the<br />

creation <strong>of</strong> a pedestrian network across the former railway land and better<br />

links throughout the CBA.<br />

• Supporting the continued upgrade <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and its realignment<br />

at High Street.<br />

• Providing opportunities for hotel accommodation, education uses cinema<br />

entertainment facilities and the development <strong>of</strong> a ‘stronger and more vibrant<br />

retail base’.<br />

• Supporting the location <strong>of</strong> core retail activities along Elgin Boulevard<br />

between Smythe Street and High Street (including discount de<strong>part</strong>ment<br />

stores, full range supermarkets, large format retail outlets and specialty<br />

retail shops) as identified in the Central Business Area Masterplan.<br />

• Allowing discretion in relation to the location, size and type <strong>of</strong> retail uses<br />

away from the key frontages <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard and the<br />

requirement for Economic Analysis to be undertaken.<br />

• Supporting the location <strong>of</strong> retail and mixed uses north <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard<br />

between Watson and Smythe Streets.<br />

• Providing a framework to facilitate development by providing flexibility in<br />

land use and built form and encouraging a streamlined approvals process.<br />

• Giving priority to design for new development to ensure that it contributes<br />

to streetscape character and accommodates glazed shop fronts consistent<br />

with the Urban Design principles at Clause 21.06-4.<br />

• Allowing for the integration <strong>of</strong> retail, business and residential uses and<br />

designation <strong>of</strong> Precinct No. 4 on South Street where residential<br />

redevelopment is specifically encouraged attracting a greater diversity <strong>of</strong><br />

housing types and provision <strong>of</strong> residential and aged care (Clause 21.05-9<br />

and Clause 21.06-1 and Clause 21.13-1 ‘Housing’).<br />

• Providing for the car parking rates consistent with the local variation to<br />

Clause 52.06.<br />

• Promoting ‘active’ uses at ground level and commercial and residential<br />

uses on upper floors.<br />

• Providing for landscape improvements and the creation <strong>of</strong> an Urban<br />

Square at the intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

8.2 USE OF THE VICTORIAN PLANNING PROVISIONS – APPROPRIATENESS OF THE<br />

PROPOSED CONTROLS<br />

8.2.1 Selection and context <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone<br />

It is proposed to apply the Comprehensive Development Zone and site<br />

specific Schedule 1 to the land in order to facilitate the future use and<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the land in a manner which is consistent with the inclusion <strong>of</strong><br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 183 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

22


the land within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. The Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone recognises that this significant parcel <strong>of</strong> land provides a<br />

unique opportunity to contribute to elevating <strong>Wodonga</strong> to <strong>meeting</strong> its role<br />

within the Regional network. In <strong>part</strong>icular:<br />

• It enables provision <strong>of</strong> purposes which relate specifically to the<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land;<br />

• It provides flexibility in relation to land use and development controls<br />

and can incorporate a wide range <strong>of</strong> site specific permissions such as<br />

demolition <strong>of</strong> buildings or access to a road;<br />

• It can incorporate requirements for the preparation <strong>of</strong> a Framework Plan<br />

for the entire site and Precinct Plans to be approved prior to the issuing<br />

<strong>of</strong> any Planning Permit;<br />

• It can utilise a plan incorporated into the Scheme and in the schedule to<br />

direct key road or public open space projects (a priority outcome in this<br />

instance).<br />

• It proposes to permit land uses and new roadways which are broadly<br />

similar to those contemplated by the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area<br />

within the Local Planning Policy Framework <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning<br />

Scheme.<br />

• It applies to land which does not have sensitive abuttals with respect to<br />

amenity expectations and is relatively unencumbered in terms <strong>of</strong><br />

environmental considerations.<br />

• It can incorporate exemptions from notice and review for development<br />

which is generally in accordance with an Approved Precinct Plan.<br />

• It can allow for the ongoing involvement <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria as a referral<br />

authority under s.55 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act for approval<br />

<strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and Planning Permit Applications.<br />

Having regard to the above Schedule 1 to the Comprehensive Development<br />

Zone has been prepared to:<br />

• Set out the <strong>part</strong>icular purposes <strong>of</strong> redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land –<br />

principally;<br />

o Redevelopment and revitalisation;<br />

o Uses which support the existing <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area<br />

and radiate out from the corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin and High Streets in terms<br />

<strong>of</strong> ‘intensity’ <strong>of</strong> land use and built form;<br />

o The realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and creation <strong>of</strong> a pedestrian<br />

priority area and retail location.<br />

o Provision <strong>of</strong> high quality public open space and pedestrian links<br />

along the rail corridor.<br />

o Buildings <strong>of</strong> high quality and active frontages.<br />

o Reuse <strong>of</strong> the former Railway Station Building and Goods shed as a<br />

centre piece to future development and pedestrian links/ public<br />

open space.<br />

• The table <strong>of</strong> uses (Clause 1) has been constructed to facilitate<br />

development. It has the following features:<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 184 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

23


o The majority <strong>of</strong> uses are as <strong>of</strong> right with some restrictions<br />

encouraging their location in <strong>part</strong>icular precincts. This is<br />

consistent with the local policy vision for the land as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning<br />

Scheme.<br />

o Restrictions on some land uses (i.e. <strong>of</strong>fice, residential) only in so far<br />

as to require their location above street level to ensure active uses<br />

are maintained at the ground floor level.<br />

o Space intensive ‘low grade’ uses and ‘<strong>of</strong>fensive’ uses have been<br />

contained in Section 3 ‘Prohibited’ on account <strong>of</strong> the desire to<br />

encourage residential use across the site.<br />

The Comprehensive Development Plan is proposed to be contained as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

the Schedule to provide a ‘fixed’ view <strong>of</strong> major roads and public open space to<br />

be delivered as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the land’s redevelopment, as well as the identification<br />

<strong>of</strong> Precincts. Because the Schedule can only be varied by a Planning Scheme<br />

amendment, only those items which are certain, and <strong>of</strong> the highest priority to<br />

the land’s redevelopment have been included as a framework for land use<br />

development.<br />

Clause 4 <strong>of</strong> the Zone schedule sets out requirements for the preparation <strong>of</strong><br />

Precinct Plans and requires that a permit not be granted until an overarching<br />

Framework Plan and Precinct Plan (for the relevant land parcel) has been<br />

approved. Clause 4 also makes provision for amendment <strong>of</strong> the Framework<br />

Plan or for permits to be granted prior to preparation <strong>of</strong> a Precinct Plan,<br />

provided it would not prejudice the purposes <strong>of</strong> the zone, or implementation<br />

<strong>of</strong> the outcomes under the Comprehensive Development Plan and Framework<br />

Plan.<br />

The requirements for Precinct Plans at Clause 4 include detail in relation to<br />

land use, building and works, reuse <strong>of</strong> the Railway Station and Goods Shed<br />

buildings, provision for new pedestrian and road links, car parking consistent<br />

with Council’s schedule to Clause 52.06, loading and unloading, public open<br />

space and landscaping and staging <strong>of</strong> development. The preparation <strong>of</strong><br />

Precinct Plans is to be supported by reports relating to traffic and vehicle<br />

access, landscaping and economic analysis as necessary.<br />

Design principles for preparation and assessment <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and<br />

Planning permits are set out at Clause 9.<br />

All buildings and works require a permit under Clause 8 <strong>of</strong> the zone, save for<br />

anything otherwise exempted under Clause 62 <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning<br />

Scheme. A requirement for a planning permit has also be incorporated for the<br />

creation or alteration <strong>of</strong> access to Elgin Boulevard or Watson Street in<br />

recognition <strong>of</strong> their strategic importance to the road network, and the desire to<br />

maintain priority pedestrian environments.<br />

Proposals which are generally in accordance with an approved Precinct Plan<br />

are exempt from the Notice and Review requirements <strong>of</strong> the Planning and<br />

Environment Act under Clause 12 <strong>of</strong> the zone. This exemption extends to<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 185 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

24


other provisions <strong>of</strong> the Scheme, including those relating to native vegetation<br />

and car parking or loading.<br />

Places Victoria will prepare the Framework Plan for future development and<br />

will be involved with future applications for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and<br />

permits through identification as a referral authority within the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone and in the Schedule to Clause 66.04<br />

8.2.2 Compliance with Ministerial Directions<br />

The Ministerial Direction on the ‘Form and Content’ <strong>of</strong> Planning Schemes<br />

(17.9.2009) sets out the requirements for the format <strong>of</strong> Planning Schemes<br />

across Victoria. The proposed amendment is consistent with this direction<br />

and proposes to include an existing VPP Zone and new schedule within the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

The proposed zoning and revisions to the Local Planning Policy Framework<br />

remain consistent with the State Planning Policy Framework and include the<br />

specified land uses under Section 1 <strong>of</strong> the Zone. Minor consequential<br />

modifications are proposed to the local policy framework at Clause 21.11,<br />

Clause 21.12 and the policy for the Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business Area at Clause<br />

22.09. These modifications refer to the relocation <strong>of</strong> the railway station and<br />

the Comprehensive Development Zone, but do not make policy changes per<br />

se.<br />

It is proposed that the Environmental Audit Overlay (EAO) be applied to the<br />

land consistent with Ministerial Direction No 1 ‘Potentially Contaminated<br />

Land’. The proposed rezoning would have the affect <strong>of</strong> facilitating the future<br />

residential use <strong>of</strong> the land, and accordingly it is a requirement <strong>of</strong> this<br />

Ministerial Direction that the overlay be applied. Investigation into<br />

environmental contamination across the rail land is addressed at section 8.3.1<br />

<strong>of</strong> this report.<br />

As noted an assessment against Ministerial Direction 11 ‘Strategic Assessment<br />

<strong>of</strong> Amendments’ is include at Appendix B and cross references with the<br />

content <strong>of</strong> this report.<br />

8.3 CONSIDERATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS<br />

8.3.1 Environmental Contamination<br />

An Environmental Site Assessment has been undertaken by Senversa<br />

Environmental for the ‘Central Precinct’ <strong>of</strong> the rail land in January, <strong>2011</strong>.<br />

Portions <strong>of</strong> the land have been identified as contaminated as a result <strong>of</strong> the<br />

former rail related operations and the location <strong>of</strong> a former Police Station and<br />

Service Station.<br />

The Report prepared for the eastern half <strong>of</strong> the Railway land to accompany the<br />

amendment indicates that (Executive Summary p. i-iii):<br />

• ‘Although the contamination issues identified are unlikely to significantly<br />

preclude the long term redevelopment objectives <strong>of</strong> the site, the site investigation<br />

works identified contamination issues that will require site management and/or<br />

remediation, and some additional assessment’.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 186 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

25


• Ground water contains elevated metal (including arsenic, copper, nickel and zinc),<br />

sodium chloride, nitrate, ammonic and petroleum hydrocarbon concentrations<br />

that potentially preclude the protected beneficial uses maintenance <strong>of</strong> ecosystems,<br />

potable water supply, primary contact recreation, and agriculture, parks and<br />

gardens. None <strong>of</strong> these beneficial uses presently exist on site, and are unlikely to<br />

be realised in the future.<br />

• ‘A remediation action plan (RAP) should be developed and implemented that<br />

considers the infrastructure removal works and proposed development objectives<br />

and addresses adoption <strong>of</strong> risk based remedial objectives’.<br />

• Further soil investigation works should be undertaken in the proposed public open<br />

space areas (ie town square) to further assess the extent <strong>of</strong> metal and PAH<br />

contamination and beneath the former employee car park, <strong>Wodonga</strong> Station and<br />

kerosene lamp store to delineate the extent <strong>of</strong> identified contamination’.<br />

• A ground water monitoring well should be installed in the former employee car<br />

park to investigate potential groundwater impacts associated with the identified<br />

hydrocarbon soil contamination in the area.<br />

• A soil contamination management plan (SCMP) will also be required to manage<br />

residual risk associated with soil contamination during the proposed development<br />

works. A management plan is also likely to be required to be developed for the<br />

long term management <strong>of</strong> residual soil contaminants where it is appropriate to<br />

leave contaminates in situ as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the overall development <strong>of</strong> the site. ‘<br />

It is proposed that the Environmental Audit Overlay be applied to the land to<br />

ensure the safety <strong>of</strong> future sensitive uses. Requirements relating to the<br />

preparation <strong>of</strong> an Environmental Audit or Statement have also been included<br />

at Clause 10 <strong>of</strong> the proposed Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule to<br />

ensure that environmental contamination is suitably remediated for land to be<br />

developed for public open space.<br />

8.3.2 Ecological Assessment <strong>of</strong> Native Flora and Fauna<br />

An ecological assessment <strong>of</strong> the land was prepared for the former rail corridor<br />

by Eacom Consultants in September, 2010. The detailed ecological assessment<br />

has been prepared for the land which is being ‘decommissioned’ as a result <strong>of</strong><br />

the relocation <strong>of</strong> the rail corridor. The land subject <strong>of</strong> the amendment is<br />

contained in Precinct 5 which is noted as comprising the <strong>Wodonga</strong> V-Line<br />

Railway Station and disused train yards. The assessment included analysis <strong>of</strong><br />

the potential for:<br />

• Matters <strong>of</strong> National Environmental Significance;<br />

• The presence <strong>of</strong> flora or fauna clarified as threatened under commonwealth<br />

or state legislation.<br />

• The presence and distribution <strong>of</strong> mapped endangered or vulnerable<br />

Ecological Vegetation Classes (EVC); and<br />

• An on site ecological assessment <strong>of</strong> flora and fauna.<br />

In summary there were:<br />

• No recorded threatened (Commonwealth or State listed) species <strong>of</strong> flora or<br />

fauna identified in the site assessment which require protection;<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 187 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

26


• Of the threatened (Commonwealth or State listed) flora and fauna species<br />

identified as possibly occurring within 1 km <strong>of</strong> the site, an assessment <strong>of</strong><br />

the habitat requirements <strong>of</strong> the species revealed that none <strong>of</strong> them are likely<br />

to occur within Precinct 5.<br />

• EVC class vegetation ‘Plains Grassy Woodland (55)’ and ‘Floodplain<br />

Riparian Woodland (56)’ were identified as being present within 1 km <strong>of</strong><br />

the site, however no remnant patches <strong>of</strong> native vegetation were identified<br />

on site which require protection;<br />

• Thirteen scattered indigenous trees were identified on the land. Removal<br />

<strong>of</strong> the trees requires a planning permit under Clause 52.17 <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Planning Scheme and would require assessment under ‘Victoria’s Native<br />

Vegetation Framework Management Plan’ which seeks to avoid, minimise<br />

and <strong>of</strong>fset the removal <strong>of</strong> native vegetation.<br />

Having regard to this assessment the conditions <strong>of</strong> the land do not present any<br />

significant impediment to its rezoning to facilitate future redevelopment. The<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone requires any Precinct Plan to show the<br />

retention and protection <strong>of</strong> remnant indigenous trees across the site where<br />

possible. A range <strong>of</strong> mature trees <strong>of</strong> varying quality are present across the site<br />

and appear to have been planted or introduced as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the railway<br />

occupation <strong>of</strong> the land. Given the land is to be the subject <strong>of</strong> substantial<br />

renewal it is not proposed that these trees necessarily be retained. The<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone variously includes requirement for the<br />

consideration <strong>of</strong> landscape plans to accompany approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans.<br />

8.3.3 Archaeological Heritage Assessment<br />

An archaeological Heritage Assessment <strong>of</strong> the land was undertaken by Biosis<br />

research in August 2010. The assessment includes consideration <strong>of</strong> land<br />

contained in the former rail corridor and was based on review <strong>of</strong> previous<br />

archaeological studies in the area, identification and discussion <strong>of</strong> known<br />

recorded Aboriginal and historical sites in the study area and management<br />

recommendations for areas <strong>of</strong> archaeological potential. Field assessments<br />

were also undertaken across the corridor study area to identify the nature <strong>of</strong><br />

land forms, implications <strong>of</strong> prior soil disturbance and the presence <strong>of</strong> surface<br />

historic archaeological material and features.<br />

The land subject <strong>of</strong> the amendment is contained in Parts 5 and 6 <strong>of</strong> the Study<br />

area (<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central and Western Rail Corridor). The Report includes a<br />

description <strong>of</strong> the Study area at p.16 and notes:<br />

‘Given that much <strong>of</strong> the study area is associated with an area already highly disturbed<br />

through railway line construction and other features within the permanent way<br />

(including the track embankment), the potential for in situ (original) cultural heritage<br />

places to occur within the majority <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central (Part 5) and the Western<br />

Rail Corridor (Part 6) can be considered low.<br />

During the field survey there was also evidence <strong>of</strong> large scale construction activities<br />

for the purposes <strong>of</strong> creating a causeway across the creek, as well as a bridge to facilitate<br />

the rail crossing and also a track and embankment within the permanents way. There<br />

is very little to no undisturbed land surfaces within Part 6 within a distance <strong>of</strong> 200<br />

metres <strong>of</strong> House Creek. In general, the potential for in situ (original) Aboriginal<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 188 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

27


archaeological sites to occur within the majority <strong>of</strong> Parts 5 and 6 <strong>of</strong> the study can be<br />

considered low.<br />

Under the Aboriginal heritage Act 2006, any proposed development within Parts 5<br />

(<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central) or Part 6 (Western Rail corridor) will not require the preparation<br />

<strong>of</strong> a mandatory Cultural Heritage Management Plan, as although the project<br />

constitutes a high impact activity, it will not impact on recorded VAHR sites or other<br />

area <strong>of</strong> cultural heritage sensitivity’.<br />

As noted in the assessment, although future redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land will<br />

constitute a ‘high impact activity’ there is no further requirement for<br />

preparation <strong>of</strong> a Cultural Heritage Management Plan.<br />

8.3.4 Traffic and Transport Impact<br />

The relocation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and the impending<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land is a key component <strong>of</strong> Council’s transport<br />

strategies and a key to the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> through<br />

improving road connectivity, implementing diversion <strong>of</strong> through freeway<br />

bound traffic from the Central Business Area and the consequent<br />

‘downgrading’ <strong>of</strong> certain roads in terms <strong>of</strong> their traffic capacity.<br />

In this context consideration has been given to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Arterial<br />

Network Study’ (4 April, <strong>2011</strong>) prepared by CPG Consultants on behalf <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> and Vic Roads. This study reinforces the committed road<br />

network improvements including:<br />

• ‘Relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney railway line away form the <strong>City</strong> Centre;<br />

• Modifications to local entry roads into the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA such as the downgrading<br />

<strong>of</strong> High Street, the upgrading <strong>of</strong> Havelock Street, the extension <strong>of</strong> Watson Street to<br />

South Street and making Hovell Street one way between the Civic Centre and<br />

Lawrence Road resulting in an inner Ring Road and less motorised traffic through<br />

the centre <strong>of</strong> town and promoting a pedestrian friendly environment; and<br />

• Realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard (approximately Hume Street to High Street).’<br />

The report was prepared with the acknowledgement that the realignment <strong>of</strong><br />

the rail corridor would result in the divestment <strong>of</strong> the former broad gauge rail<br />

corridor. The future rail re-alignment project and future ring roads are<br />

addressed in s.3.5 and 3.6 which notes respectively:<br />

‘A key component in both the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s economic development and transport<br />

strategies has been the removal <strong>of</strong> the rail line to an alignment north <strong>of</strong> the Hume<br />

Freeway which will eliminate the rail infrastructure in <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The relocation <strong>of</strong><br />

the rail line and <strong>Wodonga</strong> railway Station to the vicinity <strong>of</strong> Melrose Drive will<br />

provide <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> with the impetus to develop the land and facilitate the full<br />

implementation <strong>of</strong> the Inner Ring Road.’<br />

‘The objective <strong>of</strong> the Inner Ring Road is to divert traffic away from the busy CBA,<br />

<strong>part</strong>icularly in High Street. The modification <strong>of</strong> local entry streets into the CBA and<br />

the removal <strong>of</strong> the railway line from the <strong>City</strong> Centre will assist <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> to<br />

achieve its vision with <strong>of</strong> a fully developed inner ring road link. The Inner Ring Road<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 189 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

28


also provides <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> with scope to better manage land uses in the CBA and<br />

to help increase the economic and commercial prosperity <strong>of</strong> the <strong>City</strong>.’<br />

The Study includes modelled traffic movement data projecting to the year<br />

2030. Recommendations in relation to the Inner Ring Road set out at Page 83<br />

note:<br />

‘The sections <strong>of</strong> Watson Street, South Road, Hovell Street, Havelock Street and<br />

Lawrence Street should be developed as the Inner Ring Road and developed to<br />

Municipal Arterial road standards. Streets within this Ring Road can be reclassified<br />

with emphasis on being ‘pedestrian friendly’.<br />

In addition it is recommend that:<br />

• High Street’s classification as a VicRoads Arterial Road be revoked.<br />

• Watson Street and South Street which form respectively the western and<br />

northern legs <strong>of</strong> the Inner Ring Road will need upgrading within 5 to 10<br />

years.<br />

• Smythe Street could be used to form the western leg <strong>of</strong> the Inner Ring Road<br />

and that this could be considered as an alternative to using Watson Street.<br />

• Traffic management treatments should be considered along High Street to<br />

encourage traffic to re-route by the proposed ring road.<br />

The proposed amendment is a key component in realising the strategic<br />

objectives <strong>of</strong> traffic and transport in <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The proposed Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone Schedule includes a Plan which identifies the key road<br />

projects forming <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy and which are identified<br />

as necessary for the completion <strong>of</strong> the Inner Ring Road.<br />

The provision <strong>of</strong> north south links through the site through the extension <strong>of</strong><br />

Smythe Street and the provision <strong>of</strong> a north south ‘laneway’ from South Street<br />

to will improve connectivity within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. In<br />

recognition <strong>of</strong> the importance <strong>of</strong> these road links to the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the<br />

amendment land and Central Business Area the Schedule ascribes priority to<br />

their construction.<br />

The requirements for preparation <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans <strong>of</strong> the CDZ1 schedule<br />

include the preparation <strong>of</strong> traffic and car parking analysis for any stage <strong>of</strong><br />

development. A traffic report prepared by Cardno engineers has undertaken<br />

a preliminary assessment <strong>of</strong> potential traffic and car parking impacts based on<br />

assumptions regarding residential and commercial redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land.<br />

It is also required that Precinct Plans show car parking provision at a rate<br />

generally in accordance with that <strong>of</strong> the Schedule to Clause 52.06 for the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area, and that the consolidation <strong>of</strong> car parking<br />

areas be encouraged.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 190 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

29


8.4 CONSIDERATION OF SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC IMPACTS<br />

The <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> has commissioned a number <strong>of</strong> studies into the future<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA<br />

Strategic Assessment Report prepared by Macroplan Australia (2006)<br />

informed the Municipal Strategic Statement and Local Planning Policies<br />

implemented as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the MSS Review (Amendment C57 gazetted 11<br />

<strong>December</strong>, 2008) and the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area Masterplan<br />

contained at Clause 21.11. For the purposes <strong>of</strong> this study the future alignment<br />

<strong>of</strong> the intersection <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard was identified as the<br />

key intersection <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The land subject <strong>of</strong> the proposed Amendment falls within various precincts <strong>of</strong><br />

the Study. Key principals to be drawn from this study included:<br />

• A hierarchy <strong>of</strong> retail radiating from more intensive uses at the intersection<br />

<strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard;<br />

• A desire to maintain High Street as the main street;<br />

• Restaurants and cafes located in proximity to key retail areas to encourage<br />

24 hour activity;<br />

• Retail uses to be developed along Elgin Boulevard with a desire for<br />

‘peripheral retail’ further west;<br />

• Residential uses along South Street;<br />

• Encouragement for large format bulk goods retailing to occur in Elgin<br />

Boulevard beyond the core retail precinct and in <strong>part</strong>icular on the large<br />

blocks along Watson street;<br />

• Mixed use located centrally within the land and encouragement to<br />

residential and <strong>of</strong>fice uses generally at the first floor level.<br />

Staging <strong>of</strong> timing for development is projected with a view to encouraging<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the corner <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard and along a<br />

Boulevard as a priority (2007 - 2016). The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land will enable<br />

future uses to establish on the land in a manner which is broadly consistent<br />

with the Central Business Area Masterplan. While ‘peripheral’ retail and<br />

bulky goods retailing is proposed by the Masterplan for land along the<br />

northern side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard the aspiration to elevate the street<br />

environment to a primary tree lined boulevard (plus the existence <strong>of</strong> existing<br />

retail centres) on the southern side <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard has the potential to<br />

attract core retail investment beyond the nominated area.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 191 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

30


An analysis <strong>of</strong> future market growth for <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre prepared by<br />

Pitney Bowes on behalf <strong>of</strong> Victrack and <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council has identified<br />

supportable additional retail floor space, as well as demand for residential<br />

hotel accommodation to service the tourist and local business market within<br />

the surrounding region. In <strong>part</strong>icular the VicTrack land was identified as<br />

attractive for a discount de<strong>part</strong>ment store and supermarket and a range <strong>of</strong><br />

specialty stores, along with the possibility <strong>of</strong> some scope for Bulky Goods with<br />

a suitable location being the site’s Watson Street frontage.<br />

Within the Study it was anticipated that ongoing improvements to the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre and the release <strong>of</strong> the VicTrack land would result in:<br />

• Generally continued self containment <strong>of</strong> spending on food and groceries<br />

within the respective centres <strong>of</strong> Albury and <strong>Wodonga</strong>;<br />

• An increase in the proportion <strong>of</strong> food and retail service spending from<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> residents in <strong>Wodonga</strong> could be anticipated with ongoing<br />

improvement <strong>of</strong> the provision and quality <strong>of</strong> retail facilities;<br />

• A substantial increase in non food shopping spending by <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

residents within <strong>Wodonga</strong> to be achieved with major improvements to the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre and an increase in the available retail <strong>of</strong>fer. At<br />

present the estimated non food spending by <strong>Wodonga</strong> residents in<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> is approximately 47%. It is projected that this will increase to<br />

around 70% by 2016 with the potential for redevelopment on the VicTrack<br />

land.<br />

• An increase <strong>of</strong> non food spending from residents in the surrounding<br />

communities who have more convenient access to <strong>Wodonga</strong> than Albury.<br />

• A slight increase in non food spending by Albury residents, however it is<br />

anticipated that the attraction <strong>of</strong> an improved retail <strong>of</strong>fer in <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

would be matched by ongoing improvements in Albury.<br />

• Opportunities for significant improvements in the retail <strong>of</strong>fer in <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

On this basis and in consideration <strong>of</strong> retail turnover the ‘Supportable<br />

Additional Floorspace’ within <strong>Wodonga</strong> was identified as in the order <strong>of</strong><br />

56,000 by 2016 and 74,000 by 2021. These estimates were considered to be<br />

positive (rather than conservative) and require a significant shift in the<br />

perception and <strong>of</strong>fer <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> as a retail centre. In <strong>part</strong>icular it was noted<br />

that:<br />

‘As a corollary, it follows that the regional role <strong>of</strong> the Albury Town Centre in<br />

<strong>part</strong>icular would be reduced, since at present the Albury Town Centre is filling the<br />

gap, for residents <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> and <strong>Wodonga</strong> surrounds, which has been left by the<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> modern retail facilities within <strong>Wodonga</strong>’.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 192 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

31


The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land provides a significant opportunity to redress the<br />

imbalance presently observed between the non food retail <strong>of</strong>fer <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

and Albury. Importantly it will enable goods and services to be more<br />

accessible to the local community and reduce unnecessary vehicle travel. it<br />

will also service to provide more convenient access to surrounding rural<br />

townships.<br />

The <strong>part</strong>icular opportunities for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre identified within<br />

the Pitney Bowes Report included:<br />

• A current gap in the provision and quality <strong>of</strong> major and specialty floor<br />

space.<br />

• Demand for additional discount de<strong>part</strong>ment floor space.<br />

• The former VicTrack land would provide an obvious location for provision<br />

<strong>of</strong> at least one <strong>of</strong> the three major discount de<strong>part</strong>ment store retailers.<br />

• Limited scope for additional food and grocery shopping facilities although<br />

some prospect that the existing stores may look to relocate and a likelihood<br />

that such a store would be bigger than existing retail <strong>of</strong>fer (ie: an increase <strong>of</strong><br />

around 1,500 to 2,000 sq m above the current store sizes <strong>of</strong> 2000 to 2500 sq<br />

m).<br />

• The likelihood that speciality stores will accompany the location <strong>of</strong> a<br />

Discount De<strong>part</strong>ment Store and supermarket on the former VicTrack land.<br />

This would provide an opportunity for a range <strong>of</strong> national chain tenants<br />

not presently represented in the surrounding retail environment.<br />

• Scope for location <strong>of</strong> bulky goods retailing on the former Vic Track land,<br />

although this may be limited by the presence <strong>of</strong> most major retailers within<br />

Albury already and the likelihood that they would have only one store for<br />

the catchment area;<br />

• The desirability <strong>of</strong> providing a ‘town square’ as a focal point <strong>of</strong> the<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former VicTrack land.<br />

• Some potential that existing retailers would relocate to the former VicTrack<br />

land, however it was noted that ‘if the standard <strong>of</strong> the existing strip can be<br />

brought up to a higher standard, we consider that any vacated space would be filled<br />

by tenants as the <strong>Wodonga</strong> market is large enough to support this level <strong>of</strong><br />

floorspace.’<br />

• An observation that ‘in practice, the nature and extent <strong>of</strong> retail development in<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> will depend largely on potential anchor tenants, and floorspace may be<br />

provided earlier in anticipation <strong>of</strong> growth’.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 193 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

32


The demand for retail and non retail uses has been considered in the ‘Strategic<br />

Land Use Study’ prepared by CBRE Richard Ellis 2010. Broadly the study<br />

identified:<br />

• Demand for short term accommodation in the form <strong>of</strong> a residential Hotel to<br />

accommodate short term business stays associated with <strong>Wodonga</strong> as a<br />

growing regional corporate centre’.<br />

• Opportunities to capture a greater share <strong>of</strong> the business and recreational<br />

conference market.<br />

• Additional Bulky goods floor space <strong>of</strong> 10,000 m sq supportable over the<br />

next ten years.<br />

• Additional retail floor space <strong>of</strong> 15,000 sq m supportable over the next ten<br />

years (accounting for the Mann site redevelopment <strong>of</strong> around 20,000 m sq).<br />

• Limited short term demand for residential use on account <strong>of</strong> the<br />

availability <strong>of</strong> reasonably priced suburban land, and the lack <strong>of</strong> attraction<br />

to the CBA presently.<br />

• A large area required for the location <strong>of</strong> a retirement village, with strong<br />

demand building.<br />

• A low demand but strategic desire to accommodate aged care beds.<br />

• A limited demand for <strong>of</strong>fice accommodation <strong>of</strong> around 2,000 m sq in the<br />

medium term, to be increased with revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the Centre.<br />

• Low demand for education land on account <strong>of</strong> existing supply.<br />

• Low prospect <strong>of</strong> student housing development given the consultation costs<br />

versus the rate <strong>of</strong> return.<br />

It is noted that the report identified that ‘it will be critical that the CBA<br />

masterplan be sufficiently flexible and dynamic to be able to respond to the<br />

changing market conditions. For example the proposed development <strong>of</strong><br />

residential commercial and retirement could be realised earlier should all the<br />

key elements underpinning a well presented and vibrant city centre come to<br />

fruition. On this basis, it is recommended that the draft masterplan be<br />

continually reviewed in the context <strong>of</strong> evolving market trends over the market<br />

life.’<br />

Rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to the Comprehensive Development Zone enables a wide<br />

range <strong>of</strong> land uses to be established while providing direction for the<br />

consolidation <strong>of</strong> more intensive land uses adjoining High Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard and providing a precinct with a focus for Mixed Use and High<br />

Density residential use.<br />

Evidently the area <strong>of</strong> land to be rezoned is substantial and its development<br />

will be demand based rather than sequential. Given the land’s central context<br />

and strategic designation for this purpose a relatively flexible approach<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 194 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

33


should be taken to its future use. Ultimately there is a wide range <strong>of</strong> uses<br />

which would be appropriately located and well serviced by this land. The<br />

outcomes need to be managed in terms <strong>of</strong> the location and design <strong>of</strong> core retail<br />

activities, the provision <strong>of</strong> active frontages along High Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard and the avoidance <strong>of</strong> large low activity generating uses within the<br />

Central Business Area.<br />

Shop floor space ‘triggers’ <strong>of</strong> 2,5000 m sq and 1000 m sq have been<br />

incorporated in Precincts 3 and 4 and 5 respectively to require a permit for use<br />

<strong>of</strong> the land for a ‘shop’ (which includes supermarket and de<strong>part</strong>ment store)<br />

and direct land uses in accordance with precinct objectives. These objectives<br />

(at Clause 2) include encouragement for core retail uses to be located in<br />

Precincts 1, 2 and 3 principal <strong>of</strong> avoiding retail uses in Precincts 4 and 5 which<br />

would have the effect <strong>of</strong> dispersing core retail away from the intersection <strong>of</strong><br />

High Street and Elgin Boulevard.<br />

Over time significant economic benefits are expected to be derived from<br />

construction jobs and the flow on effects to the Regional economy from<br />

rezoning the land. The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land and its future redevelopment will<br />

have positive social effects removing a sizable vacant land parcel and<br />

providing an improved public experience in the Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business<br />

Area.<br />

8.5 DESIGN AND BUILT FORM<br />

The land is largely vacant with the exception <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station and Goods Shed and remnant rail infrastructure as well as some<br />

commercial development <strong>of</strong> limited quality at the corner <strong>of</strong> High Street and<br />

Bond Street.<br />

An analysis <strong>of</strong> proposed Development Options for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station Complex undertaken by Bryce Raworth. An analysis <strong>of</strong> development<br />

options was assessed involving the demolition <strong>of</strong> elements <strong>of</strong> each buildings.<br />

In these analysis the Railway Station and Goods Shed were noted to be <strong>of</strong><br />

primary and contributory significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

complex respectively. It is noted that<br />

‘The station building is <strong>of</strong> primary significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

complex. It has aesthetic, architectural and historical value, as well as potential<br />

technological value, to an understanding <strong>of</strong> the heritage significance <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station complex. It is recommended that any proposal retails and conserves<br />

the railway station building and its platform and canopies.<br />

The good shed is <strong>of</strong> contributory significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

complex. Despite its altered condition, it contributes to an understanding and<br />

interpretation <strong>of</strong> the complex. It is preferable that the shed is retained, however there is<br />

scope in any adaptive reuse <strong>of</strong> the shed for modification or <strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> original<br />

or early fabric, <strong>part</strong>icularly given the extent to which it has been previously altered.’<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 195 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

34


The proposed Comprehensive Development Zone encourages development<br />

which incorporates and re-uses the Station and Goods Shed Buildings as <strong>part</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> the open space linkage diagonally across the site.<br />

A subsequent study undertaken by Context Heritage Consultants <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Railway Station identified the following elements <strong>of</strong> primary and secondary<br />

heritage significance:<br />

‘Primary Significance’<br />

• The Station buildings to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and<br />

detailing including any remnants <strong>of</strong> the 1874 structure, the 1184 additions<br />

including the (now truncated) two sided open verandah, and the whole <strong>of</strong> the<br />

platform as extended in 1884.<br />

• The goods shed to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and<br />

detailing.<br />

• The visual relationship between the two buildings ….the physical space<br />

between the buildings that contains the dual track alignment is significant as<br />

an expression <strong>of</strong> the function <strong>of</strong> two buildings.<br />

‘Secondary Significance’<br />

• The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed, constructed c.1950.<br />

• The turntable, constructed c.1962.<br />

• <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A, constructed c. 1962.<br />

• Remnant signalling and safe working equipment.<br />

• The layout <strong>of</strong> the tracks within the station yard, which assist in understanding<br />

the size and importance <strong>of</strong> the complex.<br />

It is proposed that the elements <strong>of</strong> primary heritage significance be identified<br />

through the application <strong>of</strong> a site specific Heritage Overlay Schedule HO10<br />

with the exception <strong>of</strong> the full eastern extent <strong>of</strong> the 1884 platform. The<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan has been prepared to guide extensive<br />

urban renewal <strong>of</strong> the land. As <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> this a key road linkage (although not<br />

necessarily a vehicle link) has been identified in the extension <strong>of</strong> Church Street<br />

from South Street to the re-aligned Elgin Boulevard. Therefore the practical<br />

retention <strong>of</strong> the platform to its full extent would not be possible and would<br />

also potentially compromise the delivery <strong>of</strong> usable open space areas within<br />

the renewal area.<br />

Given these factors and given the desire to encourage intensive development<br />

<strong>of</strong> the strategic land parcel it is proposed that the eastern extent <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Heritage Overlay be limited to the future alignment <strong>of</strong> Church Street. The<br />

permit application process will enable consideration <strong>of</strong> how the platform and<br />

the eastern end <strong>of</strong> the goods shed are incorporated into redevelopment and<br />

how the objectives <strong>of</strong> the Heritage Overlay are met.<br />

The Overlay indicates that the Heritage Place is ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station,<br />

Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ and that ‘the heritage place comprises the station<br />

building, platform and goods shed and associated land’. A copy <strong>of</strong> the Heritage<br />

Assessment identifying the extent <strong>of</strong> the proposed Heritage Overlay is<br />

contained at Appendix C.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 196 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

35


The proposed Comprehensive Development Zone 1 encourages development<br />

which incorporates and re-uses the Station and Goods Shed Buildings as <strong>part</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> the open space linkage diagonally across the site. It is also proposed that<br />

the elements <strong>of</strong> secondary heritage significance be incorporated or interpreted<br />

as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a thematic history for development and public open space. Potential<br />

for the presence <strong>of</strong> archaeological remains was also identified by the report.<br />

The incorporation <strong>of</strong> the former railway buildings provides an opportunity to<br />

enhance the character <strong>of</strong> redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land and give meaning and a<br />

‘rich’ aesthetic to the future pedestrian link across the land.<br />

The Comprehensive Development Plan sets down the necessary provision <strong>of</strong><br />

new road infrastructure and makes provision for a public open space at the<br />

corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street and open space linkages along the<br />

former rail corridor leading to an open space centrally within Precinct 3 and 4.<br />

Urban Design Principles included within the Zone provide a focus on built<br />

form outcomes which support active street frontages and pedestrian activity<br />

throughout the precinct as well as improved connectivity with the<br />

surrounding urban fabric. The Urban Design Principles have been derived<br />

from the existing Design and Development Overlay 4 (DD04) which applies to<br />

Elgin Boulevard and surrounds as well as with reference to the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Town Centre Master Plan prepared by the Buchan Group and included as a<br />

reference document within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

The land generally presents limited character constraints and priority should<br />

be given to developing active frontages and facilitating pedestrian<br />

connectivity and access. The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land provides an<br />

opportunity to design streetscapes and public landscaping with strong<br />

landscaping themes. Further, provision is made for the presence <strong>of</strong> sizeable<br />

public open space areas (‘urban square’ and ‘green square’) which will service<br />

the future development <strong>of</strong> the Central Business Area. These areas have been<br />

nominated within the Comprehensive Development Plan providing certainty<br />

around their ultimate delivery. The guidelines for the Framework Plan also<br />

require that these areas be identified and well connected with surrounding<br />

development.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 197 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

36


8.6 AMENITY IMPACTS<br />

The land subject <strong>of</strong> the Amendment does not have any sensitive abuttals and<br />

is separated from residential uses by roadways. While the majority <strong>of</strong> the land<br />

is presently contained within the Public Use Zone 4 the local policy<br />

framework anticipates that its ultimate use and development will comprise a<br />

range <strong>of</strong> commercial or mixed uses.<br />

In this context impacts on the amenity <strong>of</strong> the area are expected to be consistent<br />

with those anticipated in the Central Business Area and justify the exemption<br />

from notice and review which has been incorporated within the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone. Localised amenity impacts are also able<br />

to be assessed in any the planning permit application made under an<br />

approved Precinct Plan.<br />

The Amendment will have long term positive amenity impacts on the<br />

community through facilitating the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land and providing<br />

key road and public open space projects.<br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 198 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

37


9 CONCLUSION<br />

The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land<br />

in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> is a strategic component <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s ongoing growth.<br />

The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> land in this manner has been contemplated as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

the strategic plan for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area and is reflected in<br />

the Local Planning Policy Framework. The unique opportunity provided by<br />

the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the sizeable land parcel will enable <strong>Wodonga</strong> to more fully<br />

service its role within the State’s Regional Settlement Network. The proposed<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone plans for the delivery <strong>of</strong> important<br />

infrastructure projects and aims to facilitate investment in the Central<br />

Business Area in a manner that will enable this strategic role to be achieved.<br />

Environmental Resources Management Australia Pty Ltd<br />

November <strong>2011</strong><br />

ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT AUSTRALIA 0137199_R01/REPORT /25 NOVERMBER, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Page 199 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

38


Appendix A<br />

A TITLE COMPILATION PLAN, REEDS<br />

CONSULTING<br />

Title Compilation Plan, Reeds<br />

Consulting<br />

Page 200 <strong>of</strong> 304


Appendix B<br />

B MINISTERIAL DIRECTION NO. 11<br />

'STRATEGIC ASSESSMENT OF<br />

AMENDMENTS'<br />

Ministerial Direction No. 11<br />

'Strategic Assessment <strong>of</strong><br />

Amendments'<br />

Page 201 <strong>of</strong> 304


Strategic Assessment Guidelines Checklist<br />

This checklist is a tool that provides a quick snapshot <strong>of</strong> the abovementioned information. It may be useful to use while<br />

preparing an amendment assessment.<br />

Note: In the ‘Comment’ field, you must click in the top left <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the field to enter any comments.<br />

Strategic Consideration Yes No N/A Comment<br />

Why is an<br />

amendment<br />

required?<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

implement the<br />

objectives <strong>of</strong><br />

planning<br />

and any<br />

environmental,<br />

social and<br />

economic<br />

• What does the amendment intend to<br />

do and what is its desired outcome?<br />

Refer to s.1, 5 and 8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

• How does it intend to do it? Refer to s.1, 5 and 8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

• Is it supported by or is it a result <strong>of</strong><br />

any strategic study or report?<br />

• Will the planning policy, provision or<br />

control result in the desired planning<br />

outcome?<br />

• Will the amendment have a net<br />

community benefit?<br />

• Will the community benefit outweigh<br />

the cost <strong>of</strong> the new control?<br />

• Does the amendment repeat<br />

provisions already in the scheme?<br />

• Is the planning scheme the most<br />

appropriate means <strong>of</strong> controlling the<br />

issue or can other existing regulatory<br />

or process mechanisms deal with the<br />

issue?<br />

• Is the matter already dealt with under<br />

other regulations?<br />

• Does the amendment implement the<br />

objectives <strong>of</strong> planning in Victoria?<br />

(Refer section 4 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and<br />

Environment Act 1987.)<br />

• Does the amendment adequately<br />

address any environmental effects?<br />

effects? • Does the amendment adequately<br />

address the relevant social and<br />

economic effects?<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

comply with all<br />

the relevant<br />

Minister’s<br />

Directions?<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

support or<br />

implement the<br />

SPPF?<br />

• Does the amendment comply with the<br />

requirements <strong>of</strong> the Ministerial<br />

Direction on the Form and Content <strong>of</strong><br />

Planning Schemes?<br />

• Do any other Minister’s Directions<br />

apply to the amendment? If so, have<br />

they been complied with?<br />

• Is the amendment accompanied by all<br />

<strong>of</strong> the information required by a<br />

Minister’s Direction?<br />

• Does the amendment support or give<br />

effect to the SPPF?<br />

• Are there any competing SPPF<br />

objectives and how are they<br />

Page 202 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Refer to analysis in S. 8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

Refer to analysis in S.8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

Refer to analysis in s.8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

and in Explanatory Report.<br />

Refer to analysis in s.8 <strong>of</strong> Report<br />

and in Explanatory Report.<br />

Refer to s.8.2 Use <strong>of</strong> Planning<br />

Controls in Report<br />

Refer to s.8.2 <strong>of</strong> Report Use <strong>of</strong><br />

Planning Controls in Report<br />

Refer to analysis in explanatory<br />

report.<br />

Refer to analysis at s. 8.3 <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Report and explantory report.<br />

Refer to anlalysis at s.8.4 <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Report and explanatory report.<br />

Refer to s.8.2.2 <strong>of</strong> the Report and<br />

explanatory report.<br />

Refer to s.8.2.2 <strong>of</strong> the Report.<br />

Refer to s.8.2.2 <strong>of</strong> the Report.<br />

Referf to s.8.1 <strong>of</strong> the Report<br />

Refer to s.8.1 <strong>of</strong> the Report


Strategic Consideration Yes No N/A Comment<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

support or<br />

implement the<br />

LPPF?<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

make proper<br />

use <strong>of</strong> the<br />

VPP?<br />

balanced?<br />

• Does the amendment support or give<br />

effect to any relevant adopted State<br />

policy?<br />

• Does the amendment implement or<br />

support the MSS?<br />

• Does the amendment seek to change<br />

the objectives or strategies <strong>of</strong> the<br />

MSS? If so, what is the change?<br />

• What effect will any change to the<br />

MSS have on the rest <strong>of</strong> the MSS:<br />

− Is the amendment<br />

consistent/inconsistent with<br />

strategic directions elsewhere in<br />

the MSS?<br />

− Has the cumulative effect <strong>of</strong> this<br />

amendment on the strategic<br />

directions in the MSS been<br />

considered?<br />

• Does the new or amended local<br />

planning policy:<br />

− respond to a demonstrated need?<br />

− implement an objective or strategy<br />

in the MSS?<br />

− relate to a specific discretion or<br />

group <strong>of</strong> discretions in the<br />

scheme?<br />

− assist the responsible authority to<br />

make a decision?<br />

− assist any other person to<br />

understand whether a proposal is<br />

likely to be supported?<br />

• Does the amendment affect any<br />

existing local planning policy?<br />

• Is a local planning policy necessary<br />

OR is the issue covered by another<br />

planning tool?<br />

• Does the amendment use the most<br />

appropriate VPP tool to achieve the<br />

strategic objective <strong>of</strong> the scheme?<br />

• Does the amendment affect conflict<br />

with or duplicate another existing<br />

provision in the planning scheme that<br />

deals with the same land, use or<br />

development?<br />

• If so, have the provisions been<br />

reconciled?<br />

• Does the control capture matters that<br />

do not specifically relate to the<br />

purpose or objectives <strong>of</strong> the control or<br />

matters that should not be dealt with<br />

under planning?<br />

• Does the amendment make any<br />

existing provision in the planning<br />

Page 203 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Refer to s.8.1 <strong>of</strong> the Report<br />

Refer to s.8.1 <strong>of</strong> the Report<br />

Refer to s.8.1 <strong>of</strong> the Report<br />

Consistent with MSS, refer to s.8.1<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Report. Minor modifications<br />

to MSS and local policy required.<br />

Consistent with MSS , refer to s.8.1<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Report. Minor modifications<br />

to MSS and local policy required.<br />

Yes, minor modifications proposed<br />

to Clause 22.12<br />

Refer to s.8.2 Use <strong>of</strong> Planning<br />

Controls in Report<br />

Refer to s.8.2 Use <strong>of</strong> Planning<br />

Controls in Report<br />

Refer to s.8.2 Use <strong>of</strong> Planning<br />

Controls in Report<br />

Refer to s.8.2 Use <strong>of</strong> Planning<br />

Controls in Report<br />

It is proposed to delete DDO4 from


Strategic Consideration Yes No N/A Comment<br />

How does the<br />

amendment<br />

address the<br />

views <strong>of</strong> any<br />

relevant<br />

agency?<br />

Does the<br />

amendment<br />

address the<br />

requirements<br />

<strong>of</strong> the<br />

Transport<br />

Integration Act<br />

2010?<br />

What impact<br />

will the new<br />

planning<br />

provisions<br />

have on the<br />

resource and<br />

administrative<br />

costs <strong>of</strong> the<br />

responsible<br />

authority?<br />

scheme redundant? the land to avoid duplication.<br />

• Is the amendment consistent with any<br />

relevant planning practice note?<br />

• Have the views <strong>of</strong> any relevant<br />

agency been addressed?<br />

• Does the amendment explain the<br />

reasons and purpose for the new<br />

referral or notice requirement?<br />

• Should the views <strong>of</strong> the referral<br />

authority govern the outcome <strong>of</strong> the<br />

application?<br />

• Can the referral be served by other<br />

means, for example:<br />

− a mandatory notice under Section<br />

52(1)(c) <strong>of</strong> the Planning and<br />

Environment Act 1987<br />

− a mandatory condition on every<br />

permit under Section 62(1)(a)<br />

− an agreement between the <strong>council</strong><br />

and the referral authority to identify<br />

standard conditions, requirements<br />

or designs for certain uses or<br />

development that are not required<br />

to be referred.<br />

• Is the amendment likely to have a<br />

significant impact on the transport<br />

system as defined by section 3 <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Transport Integration Act 2010?<br />

If so, explain how the amendment<br />

addresses the transport system<br />

objectives and decision-making<br />

principles set out in Part 2, Divisions<br />

2 and 3 <strong>of</strong> the TIA.<br />

• Are there any applicable statements<br />

<strong>of</strong> policy principles prepared under<br />

section 22 <strong>of</strong> the Transport<br />

Integration Act 2010?<br />

If so, assess how the amendment<br />

addresses any specified policy<br />

principles that apply to the proposal.<br />

• Has the <strong>council</strong> considered the cost<br />

implications in implementing and<br />

administrating the new planning<br />

provisions including:<br />

− estimated increase in number <strong>of</strong><br />

planning permit applications<br />

− planning staff resources<br />

− other miscellaneous costs<br />

Page 204 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Meets the requirement <strong>of</strong> the<br />

planning practice note relating to<br />

contaminated land.<br />

It is proposed to identify Places<br />

Victoria as a referral authority under<br />

s.55 <strong>of</strong> the Act through Schedule 1<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Comprehnsive Devlepoment<br />

Zone and Clause 66.04.<br />

It is not expected that the proposed<br />

controls will have any significant<br />

impact on the resources <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Responsible Authority.


Strategic Consideration Yes No N/A Comment<br />

including legal or other<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essional advice, for example,<br />

heritage advisers<br />

− capacity to consider the new<br />

application within the prescribed<br />

time?<br />

Page 205 <strong>of</strong> 304


Appendix C<br />

C WODONGA RAILWAY STATION HERITAGE<br />

ASSESSMENT<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

Heritage Assessment,<br />

Context, Draft 21 November,<br />

<strong>2011</strong>.<br />

Page 206 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

Heritage Assessment<br />

Draft<br />

21 November, <strong>2011</strong><br />

Prepared for<br />

Places Victoria<br />

Page 207 <strong>of</strong> 304


ii<br />

Page 208 <strong>of</strong> 304


� Context Pty Ltd<br />

Project team:<br />

David Helms, Senior Heritage Consultant<br />

Report Register<br />

This report register documents the development and issue <strong>of</strong> the report entitled <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station Heritage Assessment undertaken by Context Pty Ltd in accordance with our<br />

internal quality management system.<br />

Project<br />

No.<br />

Issue<br />

No.<br />

Notes/description Issue date Issued to<br />

1554 1 Draft 1 21 November <strong>2011</strong> Kate Kraft<br />

Context Pty Ltd<br />

22 Merri Street, Brunswick 3056<br />

Phone 03 9380 6933<br />

Facsimile 03 9380 4066<br />

Email context@contextpl.com.au<br />

Web www.contextpl.com.au<br />

Page 209 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

iii


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

iv<br />

CONTENTS<br />

1 INTRODUCTION 1<br />

1.1 Purpose 1<br />

Background 1<br />

Acknowledgements 1<br />

1.2 Study area and scope 1<br />

1.3 Terminology 2<br />

2. METHODOLOGY 3<br />

2.1 Approach 3<br />

2.2 Fieldwork and research 3<br />

2.3 Assessment <strong>of</strong> significance 3<br />

2.4 Statutory recommendations 3<br />

3. HISTORY AND DESCRIPTION 5<br />

3.1 Introduction 5<br />

3.2 Summary history 5<br />

3.3 Former Locomotive Enginemen’s shed 6<br />

3.4 Turntable 6<br />

3.5 Signalling and safe working 6<br />

3.6 Other buildings 9<br />

3.7 References 9<br />

Newspapers 9<br />

4 HERITAGE ASSESSMENT 10<br />

4.1 Basis <strong>of</strong> assessment 10<br />

Existing heritage listings 10<br />

4.2 Comparative analysis 10<br />

4.3 Assessment against Hercon criteria 11<br />

4.4 Statement <strong>of</strong> significance 12<br />

What is significant? 13<br />

How is it significant? 13<br />

Why is it significant? 13<br />

4.5 Levels <strong>of</strong> significance 14<br />

Primary significance 14<br />

Secondary significance 14<br />

Limited or no significance 15<br />

Potential significance 15<br />

5. KEY FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS 16<br />

5.1 Conservation management 16<br />

Table 5.1 – Conservation guidelines 16<br />

Demolition and recording guidelines 16<br />

5.2 Statutory controls 16<br />

Page 210 <strong>of</strong> 304


Heritage overlay 16<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 17<br />

Figure 5.1 – Recommended HO extent 17<br />

APPENDIX A – RECOMMENDED CDZ MODIFICATIONSAPPENDIX B - ESTABLISHING<br />

A THRESHOLD OF LOCAL SIGNIFICANCE 18<br />

APPENDIX B - ESTABLISHING A THRESHOLD OF LOCAL SIGNIFICANCE 19<br />

What is a threshold? 19<br />

How is a threshold defined? 19<br />

What is the role <strong>of</strong> the thematic history? 20<br />

What constitutes a precinct? 20<br />

Approach used by this study 21<br />

APPENDIX C – 2010 RAWORTH HERITAGE ASSESSMENT REPORT 23<br />

Page 211 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

v


Page 212 <strong>of</strong> 304


1 INTRODUCTION<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

1.1 Purpose<br />

This report has been prepared for Places Victoria (formerly Vicurban) and provides an<br />

assessment <strong>of</strong> the heritage significance <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex<br />

(hereafter referred to as the railway station – see also section 1.3 terminology).<br />

The purpose is to:<br />

� Assess and document the cultural significance <strong>of</strong> the railway station and provide a statement<br />

<strong>of</strong> cultural heritage significance.<br />

� Recommend planning controls to protect the significant features <strong>of</strong> the railway station. This<br />

may include application <strong>of</strong> the heritage overlay and/or additional provisions in the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone proposed to be applied to the site (see Background).<br />

This report details the methodology, key findings and recommendations <strong>of</strong> the study. It<br />

includes:<br />

� A description <strong>of</strong> the methodology used in the assessment process (Chapter 2).<br />

� An overview history and description <strong>of</strong> previously undocumented features (Chapter 3)<br />

� An assessment <strong>of</strong> significance and statement <strong>of</strong> significance (Chapter 3).<br />

� The key findings and recommendations (Chapter 4) including:<br />

- The relative significance <strong>of</strong> the surviving features associated with the railway station<br />

- Recommended planning controls for the railway station.<br />

Background<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, situated at the north-west corner <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard, became redundant in 2010 upon completion <strong>of</strong> the railway bypass, which included<br />

a new railway station situated to the north <strong>of</strong> the town. The decommissioned railway station<br />

site now represents a strategic development opportunity within <strong>Wodonga</strong> and Places Victoria<br />

has prepared a master plan for the site. To facilitate the implementation <strong>of</strong> the master plan<br />

Amendment C92 to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme has been prepared. Amongst other things,<br />

Amendment C92 proposes to:<br />

� Apply the Comprehensive Development Zone to the railway station site.<br />

� Apply the heritage overlay to significant buildings and features.<br />

The findings <strong>of</strong> this report will inform the application <strong>of</strong> the heritage overlay.<br />

Acknowledgements<br />

We acknowledge the kind assistance <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society and in <strong>part</strong>icular Jean<br />

Whitla, Rex McDonnell, and Uta Wiltshire who provided additional historical information<br />

about the railway station, including an early photograph that is reproduced in this report.<br />

1.2 Study area and scope<br />

The study area is the whole <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station site, which is situated<br />

generally to the north-west <strong>of</strong> the intersection <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard. The focus,<br />

however, is upon the railway station building and its platform, the goods shed and the<br />

immediate environs <strong>of</strong> these two buildings.<br />

The assessment carried out for this report considers only above-ground built historic heritage.<br />

It does not provide an assessment <strong>of</strong> historic archaeology.<br />

Page 213 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

1


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

2<br />

1.3 Terminology<br />

The terminology used in this report is consistent with the The Burra Charter: The Australia<br />

ICOMOS Charter for Places <strong>of</strong> Cultural Significance (1999). ‘Hercon’ is the name given to the<br />

standard National heritage assessment criteria that were recently adopted by Heritage Victoria.<br />

As noted above the term ‘railway station’ is used in this report to refer to the whole <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex. The term ‘railway station building’ refers to the main<br />

passenger building containing the waiting rooms, former refreshment rooms etc. Other<br />

buildings and features are referred by their common name or function (e.g., goods shed).<br />

Page 214 <strong>of</strong> 304


2. METHODOLOGY<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

2.1 Approach<br />

The approach taken in the preparation <strong>of</strong> this report generally follows the principles and<br />

procedures set out in The Burra Charter: The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places <strong>of</strong> Cultural<br />

Significance (1999).<br />

The methodology also draws on relevant guidelines for the preparation <strong>of</strong> heritage studies as<br />

well as other relevant Independent Panel reports and, in <strong>part</strong>icular, the Advisory Committee<br />

report in relation to the Review <strong>of</strong> Heritage Provisions in Planning Schemes (The Advisory<br />

Committee Report), which was completed in August 2007 (Please refer to Appendix A for<br />

further detail).<br />

The methodology included the following key steps:<br />

� Fieldwork and historical research<br />

� Assessment <strong>of</strong> significance<br />

� Statutory recommendations<br />

2.2 Fieldwork and research<br />

An inspection <strong>of</strong> the railway station was carried out in October <strong>2011</strong>. All buildings and<br />

features were examined from the outside only.<br />

The timing and scope <strong>of</strong> this project did not allow for examination <strong>of</strong> available primary<br />

records. In researching the history <strong>of</strong> the railway station this report has largely relied upon the<br />

information contained in the following secondary sources.<br />

� ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex. Analysis <strong>of</strong> proposed development options. Heritage<br />

issues’, prepared for Victrack in September 2010 by Bryce Raworth.<br />

� Citation for the railway station from the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Heritage Study 2004, prepared by Peter<br />

Freeman & Associates.<br />

� A ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Lines Historical Extract 11903’, author unknown, copy provided by<br />

Places Victoria.<br />

Additional information about specific buildings and features has been obtained from the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society, and from newspaper articles now available on-line via the Trove<br />

website. Please refer to the full list <strong>of</strong> references in section 3.6.<br />

2.3 Assessment <strong>of</strong> significance<br />

In accordance with Heritage Victoria (HV) guidelines the assessment <strong>of</strong> significance was<br />

carried out in accordance with the Burra Charter using the Hercon criteria (Refer to section<br />

4.3).<br />

The assessment <strong>of</strong> significance uses the threshold <strong>of</strong> local significance, using the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> as the local area. (HV guidelines note that ‘local’ can also refer to a place or area, not<br />

just a municipality). Please refer to Appendix B for further discussion about establishing a<br />

threshold <strong>of</strong> local significance.<br />

2.4 Statutory recommendations<br />

The statutory recommendations are made in accordance with relevant policies and guidelines<br />

including the Local Government Heritage Guidelines (1991) and the VPP practice note Applying<br />

Page 215 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

3


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

4<br />

the Heritage Overlay, and The Heritage Victoria ‘Model Consultants Brief for Heritage<br />

Studies’, which amongst other things provides guidelines for defining an appropriate curtilage<br />

or boundary around a heritage place. It is noted that the practice note states that:<br />

The Heritage Overlay map, like all overlay maps, is intended to show which places are subject to<br />

a control. The Heritage Overlay map is not intended to indicate those buildings, structures, trees<br />

or other features considered to be important within a significant area. The only instance where<br />

an individual property within a significant area should be scheduled and mapped is in instances<br />

where it is proposed to trigger a variation to the control.<br />

On this basis, it is noted that the heritage place boundary (i.e. what is significant) may differ<br />

from the HO boundary (i.e. what is proposed to be subject to control). This is discussed<br />

further in Chapter 5.<br />

Page 216 <strong>of</strong> 304


3. HISTORY AND DESCRIPTION<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

3.1 Introduction<br />

The project scope and timing did not allow the preparation <strong>of</strong> a complete history <strong>of</strong> the railway<br />

station. However, it is considered that the existing secondary sources provide an adequate<br />

account <strong>of</strong> the early development <strong>of</strong> the railway station, as well as descriptions <strong>of</strong> the station<br />

building and the goods shed – in <strong>part</strong>icular, the Raworth report prepared for Victrack (Refer<br />

Appendix C), which was completed one year ago, provides a relatively recent assessment <strong>of</strong> the<br />

site, including a detailed description <strong>of</strong> the station building and goods shed. The analysis in<br />

this report has relied on those descriptions, as well as observations made during the site<br />

inspection carried out for this project.<br />

The focus, therefore, <strong>of</strong> additional research and investigation in the report has been the other<br />

buildings and features not specifically addressed by the Raworth report. They are:<br />

� The former Locomotive Enginemen’s shed.<br />

� The turntable.<br />

� Signalling and safe working buildings and features.<br />

3.2 Summary history<br />

The following dot points provide a summary <strong>of</strong> the development <strong>of</strong> the railway station since its<br />

opening, focussing in <strong>part</strong>icular on the key dates <strong>of</strong> construction <strong>of</strong> buildings and features.<br />

� 1870-73 - North East Railway built in stages from Essendon to <strong>Wodonga</strong> (Various).<br />

� 1873 – Goods shed constructed (Matthews, WHS)<br />

� 1874 – Goods shed extended (Matthews)<br />

� 1875 - First <strong>Wodonga</strong> railway station building constructed (Various).<br />

� 1881 – Railway line from Sydney to Albury completed (Various).<br />

� 1883 – Albury and <strong>Wodonga</strong> railway stations joined by two tracks, one <strong>of</strong> each gauge<br />

(Various)<br />

� 1884 – <strong>Wodonga</strong> railway station building and platform considerably enlarged to allow<br />

trains from Melbourne and from Albury to be loaded/unloaded simultaneously (Various,<br />

Kilmore Free Press, 16 August, 1883, p.4)<br />

� 1889 – First stage <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> to Cudgewa branch railway completed<br />

� c.1900s? – Engine shed and carriage constructed (Matthews, WHS)<br />

� 1904 – 50 ft turntable provided (Matthews)<br />

� 1906 – Turntable replaced by a reversing loop, which was generally referred to as ‘the<br />

triangle’ (Matthews)<br />

� 1907 – Carriage shed enlarged (The Argus, 2 November, 1907, p.17)<br />

� 1910 – Engine shed enlarged (Matthews)<br />

� c.1940 – alterations and additions to Goods Shed (Raworth, p.4)<br />

� c.1950 – Locomotive Engine Drivers’ shed constructed (McDonnell)<br />

� 1962 – Standard gauge railway built from the border to Melbourne. New signal box A and<br />

70ft timetable constructed (Matthews)<br />

� 1963 – ‘The triangle’ system <strong>of</strong> reversing trains decommissioned in April (Matthews)<br />

� 1964 – Signal Box B demolished (Matthews)<br />

Page 217 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

5


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

6<br />

� c.1966 – Carriage shed and engine shed demolished (Matthews)<br />

� 2008 – Work begins on upgrade <strong>of</strong> North East Railway, which includes a five kilometre<br />

bypass around <strong>Wodonga</strong> and a new railway.<br />

� 2010 – New railway bypass and station opened, and old railway station closed and line<br />

decommissioned.<br />

3.3 Former Locomotive Enginemen’s shed<br />

As noted above the station building and the goods shed directly opposite were the first<br />

buildings constructed. By 1911 an engine shed and a car (or carriage) shed had been<br />

constructed to the north and west <strong>of</strong> the goods shed. These buildings can be seen in Figure 3.1.<br />

About c.1950 a Locomotive Enginemen’s shed was constructed just to the east <strong>of</strong> the Engine<br />

Shed and north <strong>of</strong> the goods shed (WHS, McDonnell). This is the unmarked rectangular<br />

building shown in the undated (but c.1960) plan in Figure 3.2.<br />

This building provided facilities for various railway staff including enginemen, drivers, the<br />

depot foreman, storemen, and also contained the ‘turnery’, which housed the ‘tools <strong>of</strong> the<br />

trade’ like lathes, machines, etc. for fitting and turning (WHS, McDonnell).<br />

The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed survives today. It is a long gabled building clad in<br />

corrugated iron. There is one brick chimney on the south side. The windows have been<br />

covered over. The building appears to be in poor condition (Refer to images below Figure 3.2).<br />

3.4 Turntable<br />

The turntable is situated just to the north-east <strong>of</strong> the Locomotive Enginemen’s shed. It was<br />

constructed by 1962 as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the works associated with the building <strong>of</strong> the standard goods<br />

line. It was needed to turn the engines ‘more efficiently’ and replaced a system whereby trains<br />

would reverse in the ‘triangle’ <strong>of</strong> rail lines that once existed to the east <strong>of</strong> the High Street<br />

crossing. As explained by Jean Whitla <strong>of</strong> the WHS:<br />

The engine would leave <strong>Wodonga</strong> Station as if to travel to Albury, up the left (north) side <strong>of</strong> the<br />

triangle; when clear <strong>of</strong> the relevant points it would back across the top <strong>of</strong> the traingle to the south<br />

to another set <strong>of</strong> points and then head down the right (south) side <strong>of</strong> the triangle back into<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> – and then to Melbourne.<br />

The turntable is 70 ft in diameter and is constructed <strong>of</strong> concrete with several roads leading in<br />

and out (Refer Figure 3.3).<br />

3.5 Signalling and safe working<br />

Remnants <strong>of</strong> signalling and safe working buildings and equipment are found throughout the<br />

site, as follows:<br />

� The former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A, situated to the west <strong>of</strong> the station building, which was<br />

constructed c.1962 as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the standard gauge project (Refer Image 3.4). This is a plain<br />

weatherboard building with a low skillion ro<strong>of</strong> and high set timber windows. It appears to<br />

have replaced (or is a reconstruction <strong>of</strong>) the original signal box A shown in Figure 3.1. Until<br />

recently, there was cantilevered lattice-frame signal post with 9 semaphore signals<br />

immediately to the west <strong>of</strong> this building, but this has now been removed. Another signal<br />

box, known as Signal Box B was once located just to the east <strong>of</strong> the High Street crossing,<br />

but has been demolished.<br />

Page 218 <strong>of</strong> 304


Figure 3.1: <strong>Wodonga</strong> looking towards Albury circa 1911 (Source: WHS)<br />

From Left: Carriage Shed, Engine Shed, Goods Shed, Station and original Signal Box A<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

Figure 3.2: Undated c.1960 plan <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> railway station (Source: PROV – reproduced in WRLHE)<br />

Note: Locomotive enginemen’s shed is the unmarked rectangular building just to the right <strong>of</strong> the engine<br />

shed. Views below (Left) <strong>of</strong> south elevation looking east and (right) <strong>of</strong> north elevation looking east.<br />

Page 219 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

7


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

8<br />

Page 220 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Figure 3.3: Turntable (Source: Context PL <strong>2011</strong>)<br />

Figure 3.4: <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A (Source: Context<br />

PL <strong>2011</strong>)<br />

Figure 3.5 (Left): Remnant signal masts to the northwest<br />

<strong>of</strong> Signal Box A (Source: Context PL <strong>2011</strong>)<br />

Figure 3.6 (Below left): Former guards/goods vans<br />

used for storage (Source: Context PL <strong>2011</strong>)<br />

Figure 3.7 (Below right): Lever associated with<br />

operation <strong>of</strong> roads to turntable (Source: Context PL<br />

<strong>2011</strong>)


HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

� Several iron lattice signal posts, now stripped <strong>of</strong> signals, are found throughout the station<br />

yard (Refer Image 3.5). Generally, the lattice style posts are <strong>of</strong> pre-1945 date, while other<br />

the other larger wide-span structures (e.g. at the down end <strong>of</strong> the station platform) are more<br />

recent.<br />

� Various points and lever switches– e.g. near the turntable as shown in Figure 3.7).<br />

3.6 Other buildings<br />

Other buildings include:<br />

� Several former guards/goods vans converted to sheds, date unknown (Figure 3.6).<br />

� The former Diesel fuel point, date unknown – approximately on site <strong>of</strong> former Engine<br />

Shed, so presumably post-1966.<br />

3.7 References<br />

Bryce Raworth, ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex. Analysis <strong>of</strong> proposed development<br />

options. Heritage issues’, prepared in September 2010 for Victrack<br />

Peter Freeman & Associates, Citation for the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Complex’ from the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Heritage Study Inventory, May 2004<br />

Mathews, Lloyd, ‘History <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station’, copy <strong>of</strong> one page extract provided<br />

by <strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society.<br />

Pearson, M & Sullivan, S, Looking after heritage places. The basics <strong>of</strong> heritage planning for<br />

managers, landowners and administrators, Melbourne, 1995<br />

Rex McDonnell, pers. comm. 16 November <strong>2011</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society (WHS) - Historical notes provided by Jean Whitla on 11<br />

November <strong>2011</strong><br />

‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Lines Historical Extract 11903’ (WRLHE), author unknown, copy provided<br />

by Places Victoria.<br />

Newspapers<br />

The Argus, Kilmore Free Press, viewed online at Trove, http//trove.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/home<br />

Page 221 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

9


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

4 HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

10<br />

4.1 Basis <strong>of</strong> assessment<br />

The Burra Charter defines ‘cultural significance’ as:<br />

‘aesthetic, historic, scientific, social or spiritual value for past, present or future generations’<br />

The Burra Charter further clarifies that:<br />

‘Cultural significance is embodied in the place itself, its fabric, setting, use, associations,<br />

meanings, records, related places and related objects. Places may have a range <strong>of</strong> values for<br />

different individual or groups’<br />

This section reproduces a brief comparative analysis prepared for the Raworth report. On this<br />

basis, it provides an assessment using the Hercon criteria and concludes with a statement <strong>of</strong><br />

cultural heritage significance for the whole <strong>of</strong> the system.<br />

Existing heritage listings<br />

Heritage Victoria<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not listed on the Heritage Victoria Victorian<br />

Heritage Register.<br />

Heritage Overlay<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not listed on the heritage overlay schedule <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

A statement <strong>of</strong> significance for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex was prepared in the<br />

‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Heritage Study Inventory’ (2004). The study identified the complex to be <strong>of</strong> local<br />

significance and recommended that it be included in the local planning scheme.<br />

National Trust <strong>of</strong> Australia (Victoria)<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not classified by the National Trust <strong>of</strong> Australia<br />

(Victoria).<br />

Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station is listed as an Indicative Place on the Australian Heritage<br />

Council Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate (Place ID 102835). A decision has yet to be made by<br />

the Australian Heritage Council as to whether to add the railway station to the Register <strong>of</strong> the<br />

National Estate. There are no statutory constraints arising from its current status with the<br />

Australian Heritage Council.<br />

4.2 Comparative analysis<br />

The railway station compares with other Victorian era stations along the North East line. The<br />

Raworth report (2010:12) notes that:<br />

Other railway station complexes on the North East Railway Line <strong>of</strong> a similar scale include<br />

Seymour and Wangaratta, which are both identified by Heritage Victoria to be <strong>of</strong> State<br />

significance. Both <strong>of</strong> these stations are contemporaneous with <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station. The<br />

Wangaratta Railway Station contains a wide array <strong>of</strong> elements <strong>of</strong> early origin including a brick<br />

water tower and its original timber frame good shed (similar to the original shed at <strong>Wodonga</strong>).<br />

The Chiltern Railway Station Complex, on the upside <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>, is also identified by Heritage<br />

Victoria to be <strong>of</strong> State significance. Although the railway station complex at Chiltern is<br />

considerably smaller than the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, its goods shed, <strong>of</strong> a similar design<br />

(albeit smaller) to the shed at <strong>Wodonga</strong>, demonstrates a greater level <strong>of</strong> detailing (bluestone base<br />

Page 222 <strong>of</strong> 304


HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

and greater use <strong>of</strong> bluestone dressings on brickwork) and is more intact (retains arcading on end<br />

walls, fire place and internal timber platform.<br />

The former Barnawartha Railway Station, which is the next station on the up side <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station, has a brick goods shed <strong>of</strong> a similar style and scale to Chiltern. The<br />

Barnawartha shed is included on the Heritage Victoria Heritage Inventory.<br />

What sets the railway station at <strong>Wodonga</strong> a<strong>part</strong> are features such as the Locomotive<br />

Enginemen’s Shed and the turntable, which illustrates the importance and role <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> as<br />

a terminus station. The goods shed is also notable for its size as is the length <strong>of</strong> the platform,<br />

which illustrates the role <strong>of</strong> the railway station as both a terminus for the inter-capital railway<br />

and later as a junction for transfer from the main line to the Cudgewa branch.<br />

4.3 Assessment against Hercon criteria<br />

This section provides an assessment <strong>of</strong> the railway station using the Hercon criteria.<br />

Criterion A<br />

Importance to the course, or pattern, <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s cultural history.<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is considered to meet Criterion A as a railway station<br />

that was established and developed as a result <strong>of</strong> the inter-colonial trade rivalries <strong>of</strong> the midnineteenth<br />

century, and the railway developments that resulted from, and further stimulated<br />

those rivalries. The history <strong>of</strong> tariff and railway rivalry were among the stimuli <strong>of</strong> the federation<br />

movement in the Riverina region, and the <strong>Wodonga</strong> station, together with the Albury station,<br />

and the Murray River rail bridge are important places in the federation story, which saw the<br />

several colonies combine into the Commonwealth <strong>of</strong> Australia. The historical significance is<br />

reflected in the size and layout <strong>of</strong> the station building, with long, two sided platforms and<br />

relatively commodious station facilities which are expressive <strong>of</strong> its former role as the principal<br />

Victorian based interchange point for traffic on this nation’s first inter-capital railway, opened<br />

in 1883, and later as a junction station. The goods shed is significant as a reminder <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong><br />

the principal arguments presented for the construction <strong>of</strong> the north-eastern railway; to capture<br />

the Riverina trade. Its size is especially expressive <strong>of</strong> this role.<br />

It is historically significant as a representative example <strong>of</strong> a major terminus/junction station<br />

that is associated with the significant expansion <strong>of</strong> the Victorian railway network in the late<br />

nineteenth century. The importance <strong>of</strong> the station is reflected in the size <strong>of</strong> the complex and<br />

the range <strong>of</strong> facilities provided for staff and passengers. The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed is<br />

significant as an example <strong>of</strong> the facilities provided by the Victorian Railways for staff at major<br />

railway stations. Signal Box A and the turntable are historically significant as evidence <strong>of</strong><br />

changes arising from the standard gauge project.<br />

Criterion B<br />

Possession <strong>of</strong> uncommon, rare or endangered aspects <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s cultural history<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building and goods shed are considered to meet Criterion B as<br />

two <strong>of</strong> the oldest surviving buildings in <strong>Wodonga</strong>. As much <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s nineteenth century<br />

heritage has been lost they buildings are considered to meet Criterion B as rare surviving<br />

evidence <strong>of</strong> the early development <strong>of</strong> the town.<br />

Criterion C<br />

Potential to yield information that will contribute to an understanding <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s cultural history.<br />

Not assessed.<br />

Criterion D<br />

Importance in demonstrating the principal characteristics <strong>of</strong> a class <strong>of</strong> cultural places and objects.<br />

Page 223 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

11


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

12<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is considered to meet Criterion D as it contains<br />

representative examples <strong>of</strong> many <strong>of</strong> the features associated with major terminus/junction<br />

railway stations in Victoria. A<strong>part</strong> from the station building and goods shed, the complex also<br />

contains the Locomotive Enginemen’s shed, which provides evidence <strong>of</strong> the facilities provided<br />

by Victorian Railways for staff at major stations. The turntable is also typical <strong>of</strong> the facilities<br />

provided to facilitate the turning around <strong>of</strong> trains at terminus and junction stations.<br />

Criterion E<br />

Importance in exhibiting <strong>part</strong>icular aesthetic characteristics.<br />

The station building is considered to meet Criterion E as a major mid-late Victorian station in<br />

the bi-chromatic style, which is a local landmark in <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The aesthetic qualities <strong>of</strong> the<br />

station building are enhanced by the complementary brick goods shed that creates a setting<br />

evocative <strong>of</strong> a nineteenth century railway complex.<br />

Criterion F<br />

Importance in demonstrating a high degree <strong>of</strong> creative or technical achievement at a <strong>part</strong>icular<br />

period.<br />

Not relevant.<br />

Criterion G<br />

Strong or special association with a <strong>part</strong>icular community or cultural group for social, cultural or<br />

spiritual reasons. This includes the significance <strong>of</strong> a place to Indigenous peoples as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> their<br />

continuing and developing cultural traditions.<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is considered to meet Criterion G as a place that was<br />

used by generations <strong>of</strong> local people and also provided a source <strong>of</strong> employment for many people<br />

in the town.<br />

Criterion H<br />

Special association with the life or works <strong>of</strong> a person, or group <strong>of</strong> persons, <strong>of</strong> importance in Victoria’s<br />

history.<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is considered to meet Criterion H for its associations<br />

with the Victorian Railways. It provides tangible evidence <strong>of</strong> the important role played by VR<br />

in the development <strong>of</strong> Victoria in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries.<br />

4.4 Statement <strong>of</strong> significance<br />

The following statement <strong>of</strong> significance is for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Complex. The statement<br />

<strong>of</strong> significance provides a description <strong>of</strong>:<br />

� What is significant (in terms <strong>of</strong> the features that demonstrate the historic development <strong>of</strong><br />

the Maroondah system);<br />

� How it is significant (in terms <strong>of</strong> its historic, aesthetic, technical, scientific or social values);<br />

and<br />

� Why it is significant (in terms <strong>of</strong> what the Maroondah system demonstrates or reveals about<br />

the historical development <strong>of</strong> Melbourne and the State <strong>of</strong> Victoria)<br />

The statement <strong>of</strong> significance is based upon the detailed history found in Volume 2, and the<br />

assessment and comparative analysis contained in this chapter. It briefly and clearly states the<br />

principal basis for the significance <strong>of</strong> the place or object. It is intended to be:<br />

‘... a brief, pithy but comprehensive statement <strong>of</strong> all the ways in which the place is significant. It<br />

should not just be a list <strong>of</strong> every conceivable reason for significance that the assessor can think up,<br />

however, it must state clearly and unequivocally the major reasons why the place is important. It<br />

Page 224 <strong>of</strong> 304


HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

must be supported by the presentation <strong>of</strong> sufficient evidence to justify the assessment judgement.’<br />

(Pearson & Sullivan 1995)<br />

What is significant?<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station was opened in 1873 and was originally the terminus for the<br />

North Eastern Railway. In 1883 it was connected to Albury by two lines, one <strong>of</strong> each gauge,<br />

and became <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the first inter-capital railway in Australia. For a brief time was the changeover<br />

station for trains arriving from Sydney (while trains from Melbourne terminated at<br />

Albury), however, in 1885 Albury became the principal passenger change station, while<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> would become the principal livestock change station. From 1889 it was the starting<br />

point for the line to Cudgewa, built in stages and completed in 1921. In 2008 work<br />

commenced on a new railway by-pass, which included a new railway station to the north <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> that opened in 2010. By that time the old railway station had been decommissioned.<br />

The following buildings and features are <strong>of</strong> primary significance:<br />

� The railway station building to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century fabric comprising any<br />

remnants <strong>of</strong> the 1874 building and the 1884 additions. Later alterations and additions are<br />

not significant.<br />

� The whole <strong>of</strong> the platform including the 1884 additions.<br />

� The goods shed to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century fabric. Later alterations and<br />

additions are not significant.<br />

� The visual relationship between the two buildings – while the fabric associated with the<br />

surviving tracks is not important the physical space between the buildings that contains the<br />

dual track alignment is significant as an expression <strong>of</strong> the function <strong>of</strong> two buildings.<br />

The following buildings and features are <strong>of</strong> secondary significance:<br />

� The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed, constructed c.1950.<br />

� The turntable, constructed c.1962.<br />

� <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A, constructed c.1962.<br />

� Remnant signalling and safe working equipment dating from prior to 1945.<br />

� The layout <strong>of</strong> the tracks within the station yard, which assist in understanding the size and<br />

importance <strong>of</strong> the complex.<br />

Other buildings and features are <strong>of</strong> limited or no significance.<br />

How is it significant?<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is <strong>of</strong> historic, social, architectural and aesthetic<br />

significance to the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

Why is it significant?<br />

It is historically significant as a railway station that was established and developed as a result <strong>of</strong><br />

the inter-colonial trade rivalries <strong>of</strong> the mid-nineteenth century, and the railway developments<br />

that resulted from, and further stimulated those rivalries. The history <strong>of</strong> tariff and railway<br />

rivalry were among the stimuli <strong>of</strong> the federation movement in the Riverina region, and the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> station, together with the Albury station, and the Murray River rail bridge are<br />

important places in the federation story, which saw the several colonies combine into the<br />

Commonwealth <strong>of</strong> Australia. The historical significance is reflected in the size and layout <strong>of</strong> the<br />

station building, with long, two sided platforms and relatively commodious station facilities<br />

which are expressive <strong>of</strong> its former role as the principal Victorian based interchange point for<br />

traffic on this nation’s first inter-capital railway, opened in 1883, and later as a junction<br />

Page 225 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

13


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

14<br />

station. The goods shed is significant as a reminder <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the principal arguments presented<br />

for the construction <strong>of</strong> the north-eastern railway; to capture the Riverina trade. Its size is<br />

especially expressive <strong>of</strong> this role. (Criteria A & D)<br />

It is historically significant as a representative example <strong>of</strong> a major terminus/junction station<br />

that is associated with the significant expansion <strong>of</strong> the Victorian railway network in the late<br />

nineteenth century. The importance <strong>of</strong> the station is reflected in the size <strong>of</strong> the complex and<br />

the range <strong>of</strong> facilities provided for staff and passengers. The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed is<br />

significant as an example <strong>of</strong> the facilities provided by the Victorian Railways for staff at major<br />

railway stations. Signal Box A and the turntable are historically significant as evidence <strong>of</strong><br />

changes arising from the standard gauge project. (Criteria A, D & H)<br />

It is also historically and socially significant as a facility that played an important role in the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> and the surrounding region in the nineteenth and early twentieth<br />

century. As much <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s nineteenth century heritage has been lost the significance <strong>of</strong><br />

the station building, platforms and goods shed is enhanced by the rarity value <strong>of</strong> the complex.<br />

The railway station is socially significant as a place that was used by generations <strong>of</strong> local people<br />

and also provided a source <strong>of</strong> employment for many people in the town. (Criteria A & G)<br />

The station building is architecturally and aesthetically significant as a major mid-late Victorian<br />

station in the bi-chromatic style, which is a local landmark in <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The aesthetic qualities<br />

<strong>of</strong> the station building are enhanced by the complementary brick goods shed that creates a<br />

setting evocative <strong>of</strong> a nineteenth century railway complex. (Criteria D & E)<br />

4.5 Levels <strong>of</strong> significance<br />

Primary significance<br />

These are features and attributes that are integral to the significance <strong>of</strong> the place. They include<br />

elements that provide important evidence <strong>of</strong> its historical development and are directly<br />

associated with the key historic period <strong>of</strong> development and use from the opening <strong>of</strong> the station<br />

in 1873 until 1911 when the major components including the station, platforms, goods shed,<br />

engine shed, carriage shed were in place.<br />

The elements <strong>of</strong> primary significance are:<br />

� The station building to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and detailing<br />

including any remnants <strong>of</strong> the 1874 structure, the 1884 additions including the (now<br />

truncated) two-sided open verandah, and the whole <strong>of</strong> the platform as extended in 1884.<br />

� The goods shed to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and detailing.<br />

� The visual relationship between the two buildings – while the fabric associated with the<br />

surviving tracks is not in itself important, the physical space between the buildings that<br />

contains the dual track alignment is significant as an expression <strong>of</strong> the function <strong>of</strong> two<br />

buildings.<br />

Secondary significance<br />

These are features and attributes that are important as evidence <strong>of</strong> the development <strong>of</strong> the<br />

railway station from the mid twentieth century until the mid-1960s when the standard gauge<br />

railway was completed. These elements are <strong>of</strong> secondary significance in the context <strong>of</strong> the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the railway station.<br />

The elements <strong>of</strong> secondary significance are:<br />

� The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed, constructed c.1950.<br />

� The turntable, constructed c.1962.<br />

� <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A, constructed c.1962.<br />

Page 226 <strong>of</strong> 304


� Remnant signalling and safe working equipment.<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

� The layout <strong>of</strong> the tracks within the station yard, which assist in understanding the size and<br />

importance <strong>of</strong> the complex.<br />

Limited or no significance<br />

The elements <strong>of</strong> limited significance, but which are <strong>of</strong> some interest in demonstrating the<br />

continuing development <strong>of</strong> the railway station are largely those that date from after c.1962 –<br />

that is, the completion <strong>of</strong> the standard gauge railway. These include alterations and additions<br />

to the buildings <strong>of</strong> primary or secondary significance and new buildings and infrastructure.<br />

Features <strong>of</strong> limited or no significance include:<br />

� The additions made to the station building c.1980s<br />

� The fuel point<br />

Potential significance<br />

As noted above an archaeological survey was not carried out as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> this assessment. The site<br />

is considered, however, to have potential for archaeological remains – for example, ash pits in<br />

the track bed area (<strong>of</strong>ten situated adjacent to the main platform, or associated with the now<br />

demolished engine shed and carriage shed buildings and other nineteenth century features.<br />

Page 227 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

15


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

5. KEY FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS<br />

16<br />

5.1 Conservation management<br />

Table 5.1 sets out the recommended management guidelines to conserve or interpret the<br />

significance <strong>of</strong> the railway station, having regard to the significance <strong>of</strong> the building or feature.<br />

Table 5.1 – Conservation guidelines<br />

Significance level Guidelines<br />

Primary Buildings <strong>of</strong> primary significance should be conserved in accordance with<br />

the Burra Charter (1999) procedures and principles. There is potential for<br />

adaptive re-use. Non-original alterations and additions dating from the<br />

twentieth century may be removed. Ideally, future works should be<br />

guided by a conservation management plan.<br />

Secondary Conservation <strong>of</strong> buildings or features <strong>of</strong> secondary significance is<br />

desirable, but not essential. Prior to removal the building or feature<br />

should be appropriately recorded and documented (See below).<br />

Limited/no significance These features do not need to be retained. Features should be<br />

photographed prior to removal.<br />

Demolition and recording guidelines<br />

As noted in Table 5.1, it would be desirable for future works to buildings and features <strong>of</strong><br />

primary significance to be guided by a conservation management plan. This would include<br />

policy and guidelines for demolition <strong>of</strong> all or <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a significant building or feature. Until<br />

such a conservation management plan is prepared the following guidelines are recommended<br />

for buildings and features <strong>of</strong> either primary or secondary significance:<br />

� Prior to demolition the building or features should be appropriately recorded and<br />

documented. This may include the preparation <strong>of</strong> measured drawings and archival-quality<br />

images.<br />

� The opportunity to retain specific features or objects for use in interpretation on the site, or<br />

for donation to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society (For example, notice boards, signs,<br />

furniture etc. associated with the operation <strong>of</strong> the station) or to any other relevant body<br />

(e.g. Seymour Railway Heritage Centre, who may be interested in infrastructure such the<br />

turntable or former goods/guard vans) should be explored. Consultation at least with the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Historical Society is recommended prior to any demolition being carried out.<br />

5.2 Statutory controls<br />

The statutory recommendations have been developed having regard to the significance <strong>of</strong><br />

buildings and features within the railway station site, and the planning scheme controls<br />

proposed to be introduced by Amendment C92.<br />

Heritage overlay<br />

It is recommended that the heritage overlay is applied to the buildings and features <strong>of</strong> primary<br />

significance, as follows (Refer to Figure 5.1, which shows an approximate extent <strong>of</strong> the HO):<br />

� The railway station building and the whole <strong>of</strong> the platform structure.<br />

� The goods shed.<br />

Page 228 <strong>of</strong> 304


� The land containing the track formation between the two structures.<br />

The recommended HO schedule entry is as follows:<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone<br />

A copy <strong>of</strong> the draft CDZ prepared for Amendment C92 has been reviewed. As drafted, it<br />

already includes specific reference to the need to retain and integrate the station building and<br />

the goods shed. Minor changes are recommended to ensure that any future Framework Plans<br />

and Precinct Plans:<br />

� Also consider the retention and adaptive re-use <strong>of</strong> the platform structure, which is <strong>of</strong><br />

primary significance.<br />

� Respond to the opportunity to adaptively re-use or interpret the historic buildings and<br />

features <strong>of</strong> secondary significance.<br />

The recommended changes are shown in Appendix A.<br />

Figure 5.1 – Recommended HO extent<br />

The recommended HO boundary is indicated by the red line<br />

Page 229 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

17


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

APPENDIX A – RECOMMENDED CDZ MODIFICATIONS<br />

18<br />

Page 230 <strong>of</strong> 304


--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

SCHEDULE 1 TO THE COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE<br />

Shown on the planning scheme map as CDZ1.<br />

WODONGA CENTRAL COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT PLAN<br />

Land<br />

This schedule applies to land generally comprising the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

and associated rail land, <strong>Wodonga</strong> as depicted in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive<br />

Development Plan at Plan 1 <strong>of</strong> this Schedule.<br />

Purpose<br />

• To facilitate redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former rail land in <strong>Wodonga</strong> for a mix <strong>of</strong> uses that<br />

support and enhance the consolidation <strong>of</strong> core retail and commercial activity within the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

• To facilitate use and development that encourages social interaction and walkable<br />

neighbourhoods and contributes to a sense <strong>of</strong> place and identity.<br />

• To encourage development <strong>of</strong> buildings with ‘active frontages’ to create a vibrant<br />

pedestrian environment, <strong>part</strong>icularly along Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

• To discourage development where the presentation <strong>of</strong> car parking is dominant.<br />

• To ensure that the construction <strong>of</strong> key road and pedestrian connections and open spaces<br />

integrates the land with the existing urban areas.<br />

• To support the realignment and upgrade <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard as a priority pedestrian<br />

area and retail location.<br />

• To encourage good quality architecture and urban design which contributes to a defined<br />

identity for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

• To encourage a design response that retains or interprets the historic buildings and<br />

features on the site.<br />

1.0 Table <strong>of</strong> uses<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Section 1 - Permit not required<br />

USE CONDITION<br />

Accommodation (other than Residential<br />

hotel, Corrective institution, Camping and<br />

caravan Park)<br />

Betting agency<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 1 OF 9<br />

Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 2 metres, except in Precinct 4 on<br />

‘Plan 1’ where it may exceed 2 metres.<br />

Must not be located in Precinct 5 on 'Plan 1'.<br />

Child care centre Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 2 metres and access must not be<br />

shared with a dwelling (other than a<br />

Caretaker’s house).<br />

Page 231 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

David Helms 19/11/11 1:49 PM<br />

Formatted: Bullets and Numbering


Cinema<br />

Cinema based entertainment facility<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 2 OF 9<br />

In Precincts 1 to 2 and 3 on 'Plan 1', must not<br />

have a frontage at ground level exceeding 15<br />

metres.<br />

Must not be located in Precinct 5 on 'Plan 1'.<br />

Education centre Except in Precinct 5, any frontage at ground<br />

floor level must not exceed 10 metres.<br />

Must not be a primary or secondary school.<br />

Electoral <strong>of</strong>fice May be used for only 4 months before an<br />

election and 2 weeks after an election<br />

Food and drink premises (other than Hotel<br />

and Tavern)<br />

Home occupation<br />

Informal outdoor recreation<br />

Landscape gardening supplies Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Plan 1'.<br />

Minor utility installation<br />

Office (other than Electoral <strong>of</strong>fice) Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 2 metres unless the <strong>of</strong>fice is a bank,<br />

real estate agency, travel agency, or any<br />

other <strong>of</strong>fice where the floor space adjoining<br />

the frontage is a customer service area<br />

accessible to the public.<br />

Postal agency<br />

Residential hotel Must be located in Precincts 1, 2, 3 or 4 on<br />

'Plan 1'.<br />

Restricted retail premises Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Plan 1'.<br />

Shop (other than Adult sex bookshop and<br />

Restricted retail premises)<br />

In Precincts 1 and 2 on ‘Plan 1’, the maximum<br />

combined leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> shop is<br />

unrestricted in each precinct.<br />

In Precinct 3 on ‘Plan 1’, the combined<br />

leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> shop must not exceed<br />

2500 m².<br />

In Precinct 4 and 5 on ‘Plan 1’, the combined<br />

leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> shop in each precinct<br />

must not exceed 1000 m²<br />

Trade supplies (other than Timber yard) Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Plan 1'.<br />

Any use listed in Clause 62.01 Must meet the requirements <strong>of</strong> Clause 62.01.<br />

Page 232 <strong>of</strong> 304


Section 2 – Permit required<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

USE CONDITION<br />

Agriculture (other than Apiculture and<br />

Intensive animal husbandry)<br />

Car wash Must be in Precinct 5 on ‘Plan 1’.<br />

Hotel<br />

Tavern<br />

Industry (other than Car wash and Refuse<br />

disposal)<br />

Leisure and recreation facility (other than<br />

Informal outdoor recreation, Major sports<br />

and recreation facility, Motor racing track<br />

and Outdoor recreation facility)<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 3 OF 9<br />

Must not be for a purpose listed in the table to<br />

Clause 52.10.<br />

Motor vehicle, boat or caravan sales Must be in Precinct 5 on ‘Plan 1’.<br />

Place <strong>of</strong> assembly (other than Carnival,<br />

Cinema and Circus,)<br />

Renewable energy facility<br />

Retail premises (other than Betting<br />

agency, Food and drink premises, Hotel,<br />

Landscape gardening supplies, Motor<br />

vehicle, boat or caravan sales, Postal<br />

agency, Shop, Tavern and Trade supplies)<br />

Warehouse (other than Fuel depot)<br />

Any other use not in Section 1 or 3<br />

Section 3 – Prohibited<br />

USE<br />

Adult sex bookshop<br />

Camping and caravan park<br />

Corrective institution<br />

Crematorium<br />

Fuel depot<br />

Intensive animal husbandry<br />

Major sports and recreation facility<br />

Motor racing track<br />

Outdoor recreation facility<br />

Pleasure boat facility<br />

Refuse disposal<br />

Page 233 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Must not be a purpose listed in the table to<br />

Clause 52.10.


Saleyard<br />

Timber yard<br />

Transport terminal<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

2.0 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

The following objectives correspond with the precincts in ‘Plan 1’<strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

• To encourage Shop and intensive retail uses in Precincts 1, 2 and 3.<br />

• To avoid retail uses in Precincts 4 and 5 which would have the effect <strong>of</strong> dispersing the<br />

concentration <strong>of</strong> retail uses away from the intersection <strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard.<br />

• To encourage the development <strong>of</strong> Residential Hotel in any <strong>of</strong> Precincts 1, 2, 3 and 4,<br />

which is supported by an associated Conference centre.<br />

• To retain and integrate the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building, platform, railway track<br />

location and Goods Shed as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the open space areas <strong>of</strong> Precinct 3 and 4.<br />

• To encourage Accommodation and complementary uses in Precinct 4.<br />

• To encourage health and education uses, and discourage core retail uses in Precinct 5.<br />

• To encourage residential and <strong>of</strong>fice uses above ground floor level in all precincts and to<br />

allow Accommodation in Precinct 5 subject to residential amenity considerations.<br />

3.0 Framework Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit must not be granted to use or subdivide land, construct a building or construct or<br />

carry out works, other than for works required to remediate the site, until a Framework<br />

Plan for the entire site has been prepared to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

The Framework Plan must be generally consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan and objectives and must include the following to the<br />

satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

• The boundary <strong>of</strong> the site and precincts.<br />

• The realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard through the intersection with High Street.<br />

• The northern extension <strong>of</strong> Smythe Street and Watson Street through to South Street.<br />

• The connection <strong>of</strong> Hume Street north to Church Street. This connection may not be a<br />

vehicle link for its full extent.<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> public open space central to Precinct 3 and 4 and at the North West<br />

corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> an open space link following the former rail corridor from the<br />

intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street to the open space in Precinct 4.<br />

• A pedestrian connection linking Elgin Street to Bank Street and the Sumsion Gardens.<br />

• Other vehicle, bicycle and pedestrian links through the site to the surrounding streets.<br />

• The land uses and building height ranges anticipated in each precinct.<br />

• The historic buildings and features that are to be retained, adaptively re-used or<br />

interpreted in each precinct.<br />

The Framework Plan may be amended to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 4 OF 9<br />

Page 234 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

David Helms 19/11/11 3:19 PM<br />

Formatted: Bullets and Numbering


4.0 Precinct Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

A permit should not be granted to use or subdivide land, construct a building or construct<br />

or carry out works, until a Precinct Plan for the relevant precinct has been prepared and<br />

approved to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority. The Precinct Plan must be<br />

generally consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan and the<br />

endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

A permit may be granted before the endorsement <strong>of</strong> a Precinct Plan provided that the<br />

responsible authority is satisfied that the use, subdivision or development will not prejudice<br />

the future use or development <strong>of</strong> the land consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Development Plan and the endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

A Precinct Plan must show or include the following (in the form <strong>of</strong> reports or plans), as<br />

appropriate to the precinct, to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

Buildings and works and land use<br />

• The location, height, dimension, floor area and use <strong>of</strong> all buildings and works.<br />

Former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station historic buildings and features<br />

• The conservation and adaptive re-use <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building,<br />

platform and Goods Shed and their integration with surrounding buildings and open<br />

space.<br />

• The interpretation or adaptive reuse <strong>of</strong> other historic railway buildings and features<br />

including the former Locomotive Enginemen’s building, turntable, signal box,<br />

signalling masts and location <strong>of</strong> tracks.<br />

Transport<br />

• Any proposed traffic management and traffic control works.<br />

• The provision for waste storage, collection and loading.<br />

Car Parking<br />

• The location <strong>of</strong> and access to car parking, including the consolidation <strong>of</strong> car parking in<br />

central areas between land uses, as appropriate.<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> car parking generally in accordance with the Schedule to Clause 52.06<br />

‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area Parking Precinct Plan 2003’ or alternative provision<br />

supported by empirical analysis.<br />

Vehicle, bicycle and pedestrian links<br />

• The location <strong>of</strong> vehicle, bicycle and pedestrian links.<br />

• Typical cross sections <strong>of</strong> vehicle links.<br />

Open space network and landscaping<br />

• The location <strong>of</strong> all open spaces available to the public.<br />

• A landscape concept plan, including landscaping proposed for vehicle, bicycle and<br />

pedestrian links and open spaces.<br />

• Landscaped areas to include adaptive reuse <strong>of</strong> the former railway infrastructure.<br />

• Consideration <strong>of</strong> the retention and protection <strong>of</strong> remnant indigenous trees.<br />

Staging <strong>of</strong> development<br />

• The stages in which the precinct is to be developed.<br />

Infrastructure and servicing<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 5 OF 9<br />

Page 235 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

David Helms 19/11/11 2:43 PM<br />

Deleted: building and Goods Shed<br />

David Helms 19/11/11 2:56 PM<br />

Deleted: and restoration<br />

David Helms 19/11/11 2:43 PM<br />

Formatted: Bullets and Numbering


5.0 Use <strong>of</strong> land<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> a reticulated water supply, sewerage, electricity and<br />

telecommunications.<br />

A Precinct Plan may be amended to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

The use <strong>of</strong> land must be generally consistent with the purposes <strong>of</strong> the schedule and the<br />

precinct objectives at Clause 2.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule, the endorsed Framework Plan and any<br />

relevant endorsed Precinct Plan to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

6.0 Subdivision<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

An application to use land must be accompanied by the following information.<br />

• A description <strong>of</strong> the proposed use and the types <strong>of</strong> activities which will be carried out<br />

and any proposed staging <strong>of</strong> use and activities on the land.<br />

• Plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the siting and use <strong>of</strong> buildings;<br />

° areas not required for immediate use;<br />

° adjacent buildings and uses.<br />

• The likely effects, if any, on adjoining land, including noise levels, traffic, the hours <strong>of</strong><br />

delivery and despatch <strong>of</strong> goods and materials, hours <strong>of</strong> operation and light spill, solar<br />

access, glare, air-borne emissions and emissions to land and water.<br />

• If an industry or warehouse:<br />

° the type and quantity <strong>of</strong> goods to be stored, processed or produced;<br />

° whether a Works Approval or Waste Discharge Licence is required from the<br />

Environment Protection Authority;<br />

° whether a notification under the Occupational Health and Safety (Major Hazard<br />

Facilities) Regulations 2000 is required, a licence under the Dangerous Goods Act<br />

1995 is required, or a fire protection quantity under the Dangerous Goods (Storage<br />

and Handling) Regulations 2000 is exceeded.<br />

A permit is required to subdivide land.<br />

7.0 Creation <strong>of</strong> access to Elgin Boulevard<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit is required to create or alter access to Elgin Boulevard.<br />

8.0 Buildings and works<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit is required to construct a building or to construct or carry out works.<br />

An application to construct a building or construct or carry out works must be accompanied<br />

by the following information, as appropriate.<br />

• Plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the boundaries and dimensions <strong>of</strong> the site;<br />

° adjoining roads;<br />

° the location, height and use <strong>of</strong> buildings and works on adjoining land;<br />

° levels <strong>of</strong> the site and the difference in levels between the site and surrounding<br />

properties to a defined point at the site boundaries or to Australian Height Datum<br />

(AHD);<br />

° any contaminated soils and filled areas, where known;<br />

° the layout <strong>of</strong> existing and proposed buildings and works;<br />

° the internal layout and use <strong>of</strong> the proposed development;<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 6 OF 9<br />

Page 236 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

° all access and pedestrian areas;<br />

° all driveway, car parking and loading areas;<br />

° existing vegetation and proposed landscape areas;<br />

° all external storage and waste treatment areas;<br />

° the location <strong>of</strong> easements and services.<br />

• Elevation plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the building form and scale;<br />

° setbacks to property boundaries;<br />

° finished floor levels and building heights to a defined point at the site boundaries or<br />

to Australian Height Datum (AHD).<br />

• Shadow diagrams based on the equinox shown for existing conditions and the proposed<br />

development.<br />

• A schedule <strong>of</strong> finishes for the proposed development detailing materials and colours <strong>of</strong><br />

external surfaces including walls, ro<strong>of</strong>s and fences.<br />

• A landscape plan which includes the description <strong>of</strong> vegetation to be planted, the<br />

surfaces to be constructed, site works specification and method <strong>of</strong> preparing, draining,<br />

watering and maintaining the landscape area.<br />

• Construction details <strong>of</strong> all drainage works, driveways, vehicle parking and loading<br />

areas.<br />

9.0 Design principles<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Any planning permit application should meet the following principles, as appropriate, to<br />

the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

Building design<br />

• Development which reinforces the intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street as<br />

an entry point and axis to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area lined with buildings.<br />

• Higher built form along Elgin Boulevard and at the intersection <strong>of</strong> High Street and<br />

Elgin Boulevard.<br />

• Buildings to be constructed along High Street and Elgin Boulevard with a zero setback,<br />

except where it can be demonstrated that a positive urban design outcome will be<br />

achieved.<br />

• Awnings or verandas to be provided along building edges to <strong>of</strong>fer shade and weather<br />

protection to pedestrians, in <strong>part</strong>icular along Elgin Boulevard.<br />

• Building facades to existing or new streets, or major pedestrian links, to have active<br />

frontages with a minimum <strong>of</strong> 60% transparent glazed frontages at ground level.<br />

• Building entrances and facade design to respond to and integrate with any adjacent<br />

open spaces and pedestrian street crossings.<br />

• Large facades to incorporate windows, varied external materials and architectural<br />

features to provide visual interest.<br />

• Buildings to achieve a high standard <strong>of</strong> architectural design.<br />

• Facade design to incorporate sufficient space for advertising signs.<br />

Car parking and service areas<br />

• Provision <strong>of</strong> safe, convenient and accessible car parking which does not dominate the<br />

streetscape presentation <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard, High Street, and the northern extension <strong>of</strong><br />

Smythe Street.<br />

• Large car parking areas to be concealed behind active uses or within buildings, in<br />

<strong>part</strong>icular along Elgin Boulevard, High Street and the northern extension <strong>of</strong> Smythe<br />

Street.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 7 OF 9<br />

Page 237 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

• At grade car parking to incorporate landscape treatments and provision for pedestrian<br />

access that enhances the streetscape presentation.<br />

• Service areas and loading bays to be incorporated in the building design, and screened<br />

from public view.<br />

10.0 Requirement for an environmental audit<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Before a sensitive use commences or before the construction or carrying out <strong>of</strong> buildings<br />

and works in association with a sensitive use commences, either:<br />

• a certificate <strong>of</strong> environment audit must be issued for the land in accordance with Part<br />

IXD <strong>of</strong> the Environment Protection Act, 1970; or<br />

• an environmental auditor appointed under the Environment Protection Act, 1970 must<br />

make a statement in accordance with Part IXD <strong>of</strong> that Act that the environmental<br />

conditions <strong>of</strong> the land are suitable for the sensitive use.<br />

In this schedule, a sensitive use means a residential use, childcare centre, a pre-school, a<br />

primary school or public open space.<br />

11.0 Referral <strong>of</strong> applications<br />

An application to approve a Precinct Plan or for a permit to use, develop or subdivide land<br />

identified within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Comprehensive Development Plan <strong>2011</strong> must be referred,<br />

in accordance with Section 55 <strong>of</strong> the Act, to the referral authority (the Urban Renewal<br />

Authority) specified in the Schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

12.0 Exemption from notice and review<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

An application under any provision <strong>of</strong> this scheme which is generally in accordance with<br />

an endorsed Precinct Plan is exempt from the notice requirements <strong>of</strong> Section 52(1)(a), (b)<br />

(c) and (d), the decision requirements <strong>of</strong> Section 64(1), (2) and (3) and the review rights <strong>of</strong><br />

Section 82(1) <strong>of</strong> the Act.<br />

13.0 Decision guidelines<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Before deciding on an application for approval <strong>of</strong> a Precinct Plan or a permit, in addition to<br />

the decision guidelines at Clauses 37.02-2, 37.02-3 and 37.02-4, and the decision<br />

guidelines <strong>of</strong> Clause 65 the responsible authority must consider, as appropriate.<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan.<br />

• The purpose <strong>of</strong> the zone and schedule.<br />

• The precinct objectives at Clause 2.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

• The endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

• Any relevant endorsed Precinct Plan.<br />

• The design principles at Clause 9.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

• The provisions <strong>of</strong> Clause 54 and 55.<br />

14.0 Advertising signs<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Advertising sign requirements are at Clause 52.05. The land in this schedule is in Category<br />

1.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 8 OF 9<br />

Page 238 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

15.0 Plan 1 to Schedule 1 to the Comprehensive Development Zone: <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Central Comprehensive Development Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 9 OF 9<br />

Page 239 <strong>of</strong> 304


APPENDIX B - ESTABLISHING A THRESHOLD OF LOCAL<br />

SIGNIFICANCE<br />

HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

What is a threshold?<br />

The Heritage Victoria standard brief for Stage 2 heritage studies notes that local significance<br />

can include places <strong>of</strong> significance to a town or locality, however, whether the ‘threshold’ <strong>of</strong><br />

local significance is achieved depends how relevant heritage criteria are applied and interpreted.<br />

The Advisory Committee Report notes that the related questions <strong>of</strong> the application <strong>of</strong><br />

appropriate heritage criteria and establishing ‘thresholds’ that provide practical guidance to<br />

distinguish places <strong>of</strong> ‘mere heritage interest from those <strong>of</strong> heritage significance’ have been the<br />

subject <strong>of</strong> continuing debate in recent times. While there was agreement that the AHC criteria<br />

(which were used in the 2006 Study) may be appropriate for use at the local level, the question<br />

<strong>of</strong> what establishes a threshold remains open to interpretation.<br />

The Advisory Committee Report defines ‘threshold’ as follows:<br />

Essentially a ‘threshold’ is the level <strong>of</strong> cultural significance that a place must have before it can be<br />

recommended for inclusion in the planning scheme. The question to be answered is ‘Is the place<br />

<strong>of</strong> sufficient import that its cultural values should be recognised in the planning scheme and<br />

taken into account in decision‐making?’ Thresholds are necessary to enable a smaller group <strong>of</strong><br />

places with special architectural values, for example, to be selected out for listing from a group <strong>of</strong><br />

perhaps hundreds <strong>of</strong> places with similar architectural values. (Advisory Committee Report,<br />

2007: 2-41).<br />

How is a threshold defined?<br />

The Advisory Committee Report cites the Bayside C37 and C38 Panel report, which notes<br />

that:<br />

With respect to defining thresholds <strong>of</strong> significance, it was widely agreed by different experts<br />

appearing before this Panel that there is a substantial degree <strong>of</strong> value judgment required to assess<br />

a place’s heritage value, so that there is always likely to be legitimate, differing pr<strong>of</strong>essional views<br />

about the heritage value <strong>of</strong> some places.<br />

There is a wide range <strong>of</strong> matters that can be taken into account in making any assessment (e.g. a<br />

place’s value in relation to historic, social, aesthetic, cultural factors, its fabric’s integrity and so<br />

on), leading to further grounds for differences between judgments. (Advisory Committee<br />

Report, 2007: 2-32)<br />

While there are application guidelines for the use <strong>of</strong> the AHC criteria (Developed in 1990<br />

these are known as the AHC Criteria for the Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate: Application<br />

Guidelines), they are designed for application at the regional or National level and the Advisory<br />

Committee Report cited a report prepared by Ian Wight for Heritage Victoria, which noted<br />

that they may require rewriting to ‘make them clearly applicable to places <strong>of</strong> local significance’.<br />

On this basis, the Panel made the following conclusions:<br />

As also discussed, a fundamental threshold is whether there is something on the site or forming<br />

<strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the heritage place that requires management through the planning system.<br />

As we have commented, we see the development <strong>of</strong> thresholds as something which responds to the<br />

<strong>part</strong>icular characteristics <strong>of</strong> the area under investigation and its heritage resources. Nevertheless<br />

the types <strong>of</strong> factors that might be deployed to establish local thresholds can be specified<br />

State‐wide. They would include rarity in the local context, condition/degree <strong>of</strong> intactness,<br />

age, design quality/aesthetic value, their importance to the development sequence<br />

documented in the thematic environmental history. (Emphasis added)<br />

Page 240 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

19


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

20<br />

This process is essentially a comparative one within the local area. That area may not coincide<br />

with the municipal area. Its definition should be informed by the thematic environmental<br />

history. (Advisory Committee Report, 2007: 2-45).<br />

What is the role <strong>of</strong> the thematic history?<br />

The previous comments highlight the important role played by thematic environmental<br />

histories in providing a context for the identification and assessment <strong>of</strong> places. As noted earlier,<br />

Context is in the process <strong>of</strong> preparing an updated thematic history for the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> Whittlesea<br />

and the Peter Lalor Co-operative Estate is specifically identified as a place that is associated<br />

with two sub-themes 5.4 Suburban development in the twentieth century and 5.5 Responding to<br />

post-war housing shortages.<br />

However, while it would be expected that the majority <strong>of</strong> places <strong>of</strong> local significance would be<br />

associated with a theme in the thematic history not all places are and there may be some that<br />

are individually significant for reasons that are independent <strong>of</strong> the themes identified by the<br />

Study. The chair <strong>of</strong> the Advisory Committee Report, Jenny Moles, made the following<br />

comment in the Panel report prepared for the Warrnambool Planning Scheme Amendment<br />

C57:<br />

The Panel also does not see it as inimical to the significance <strong>of</strong> this building that there is currently<br />

no mention <strong>of</strong> a guest house theme in the Gap Study Thematic History. It is simply not the case<br />

that every building typology will be mentioned in such a study. (Emphasis added)<br />

The C57 Panel Report also once again highlighted that thematic histories are not ‘static’<br />

documents and should be reviewed once more detailed assessments are carried out for places<br />

and precincts. This iterative approach allows a ‘more complete and more pertinent history <strong>of</strong> a<br />

municipality to be developed in terms <strong>of</strong> providing a basis for managing heritage stock and<br />

allows individual buildings to be placed in their historical context’ (Warrnambool Planning<br />

Scheme. Amendment C57 Panel Report: <strong>December</strong> 2008, Jennifer A. Moles, Chair). The<br />

detailed research carried out for this study may therefore be used to revise or refine the<br />

information in the draft thematic history for Whittlesea.<br />

What constitutes a precinct?<br />

At present there are no definitive guidelines that provide assistance in identifying and defining<br />

a heritage precinct. This was acknowledged by the Advisory Committee appointed to<br />

undertake the Review <strong>of</strong> Heritage Provisions in Planning Schemes, which made the follow<br />

comments in the final report submitted in August 2007:<br />

Various Ministerial Panels have considered the question <strong>of</strong> the conceptualisation <strong>of</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong><br />

a significant heritage place, <strong>part</strong>icularly in relation to heritage areas or precincts, industrial sites<br />

and large rural properties. The Greater Geelong Planning Scheme Amendment C49 Ministerial<br />

Panel (February 2004) pointed out that the Practice Note Applying the Heritage Overlay does<br />

not provide any guidance on identification <strong>of</strong> heritage precincts. It noted that practice within the<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>ession suggested that precincts should contain a substantial proportion <strong>of</strong> buildings that were<br />

assessed as being <strong>of</strong> precinct heritage significance, as defined in the statement <strong>of</strong> significance. A<br />

statement <strong>of</strong> significance should outline what is significant, why it is significant and how the<br />

place demonstrates the heritage significance. (Advisory Committee Report, 2007: 2-48).<br />

The Advisory Committee Report considered a number <strong>of</strong> submissions and various relevant<br />

Independent Panel reports. The final conclusions and recommendations suggested that the<br />

criteria for the definition <strong>of</strong> a precinct should take into account:<br />

� the geographic distribution <strong>of</strong> the important elements <strong>of</strong> the place, including buildings and<br />

works, vegetation, open spaces and the broader landscape setting.<br />

� whether the place illustrates historic themes or a <strong>part</strong>icular period or type <strong>of</strong> development.<br />

� whether it is a defined <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the municipality recognised by the community.<br />

Page 241 <strong>of</strong> 304


HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

� whether non-built elements such as the subdivision pattern contribute to its significance.<br />

The Panel went on to note that criteria suggested by the Hobsons Bay C34 Panel, ‘may be<br />

appropriate for inner urban, relatively homogenous precincts but appear to us to be too<br />

prescriptive for application in other situations’. It concluded that:<br />

Thematically related buildings or sites that do not adjoin each other or form a geographic<br />

grouping should, where appropriate, be able to be treated as a single heritage place and share<br />

a statement <strong>of</strong> significance and HO number. (Advisory Committee Report, 2007: 2-55)<br />

(Emphasis added)<br />

Finally, with regard to the proportion <strong>of</strong> significant (or significant and contributory) buildings<br />

that is desirable within precincts, the Advisory Panel considered that:<br />

..the stress on built fabric inherent in this question is misleading. Precincts need to be coherent,<br />

thematically and/or in terms <strong>of</strong> design, and need to be justifiable in relation to protection <strong>of</strong><br />

significant components. It is neither possible nor desirable to set hard and fast rules about<br />

percentages.( Advisory Committee Report, 2007: 2-54)<br />

Approach used by this study<br />

In accordance with the Advisory Committee comments and other guidelines a series <strong>of</strong> local<br />

‘tests’ have been developed to determine whether the railway station meets the threshold <strong>of</strong><br />

local significance to the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> using the Hercon criteria. It is noted that either<br />

precinct need only meet one ‘test’ or criteria in order to meet the threshold <strong>of</strong> local<br />

significance. Meeting more than one ‘test’ does not make the precinct more significant – it<br />

simply means that the precinct is significant for a variety <strong>of</strong> reasons. The tests are:<br />

� The places is associated with a key theme identified in the thematic environmental history.<br />

It contains significant or contributory buildings and features that individually or as a group<br />

have a strong association with the theme and this will be clearly demonstrated by the fabric,<br />

when compared with other places. The contributory or significant buildings may or may<br />

not adjoin one another. Where they do not form a contiguous grouping they will have a<br />

strong and demonstrated thematic association. (Criterion A).<br />

� The place may be rare within the municipality or to a township or locality. It may contain<br />

very early buildings, or be <strong>of</strong> a type that is under-represented within the <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

(Criterion B).<br />

� Places that are historically significant as a representative or typical example or type will<br />

usually have the typical range <strong>of</strong> features normally associated with that type – i.e. it will be a<br />

benchmark example – and it will usually have a high degree <strong>of</strong> integrity when compared to<br />

other places (Criterion D).<br />

� Places <strong>of</strong> aesthetic significance will be distinguished by the high or exceptional quality <strong>of</strong> the<br />

design and features when compared to other examples (Criterion E).<br />

� The place is an exemplar <strong>of</strong> an architectural style or represents significant technical or<br />

artistic/architectural innovation or achievement when compared to other similar places in<br />

the municipality. The places will usually have a high degree <strong>of</strong> integrity when compared to<br />

other precincts (Criterion F).<br />

� The place has strong social or historic associations to an area (Criterion G) or to an<br />

individual or organisation (Criterion H) and, in <strong>part</strong>icular:<br />

� There is continuity <strong>of</strong> use or association, meanings, or symbolic importance over a<br />

period <strong>of</strong> 25 years or more (representing transition <strong>of</strong> values beyond one generation).<br />

� The association has resulted in a deeper attachment that goes beyond utility value.<br />

� The connection between a place and a person/s or organisations is not short or<br />

incidental and may have been documented – for example in local histories, other<br />

heritage studies or reports, local oral histories etc.<br />

Page 242 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

21


WODONGA RAILWAY STATION<br />

22<br />

� The association may be demonstrated by the fabric.<br />

By comparison, a place that does not meet the threshold <strong>of</strong> local significance will generally be<br />

one where:<br />

� Historical associations are not well established or are not reflected in the fabric because <strong>of</strong><br />

low integrity, or<br />

� The place is common within the municipality or already well-represented in the Heritage<br />

Overlay, or<br />

� It is a typical, rather than outstanding example <strong>of</strong> a style or type and there are better<br />

comparative examples in the municipality, or<br />

� The social or historical associations are not well established or demonstrated.<br />

Page 243 <strong>of</strong> 304


HERITAGE ASSESSMENT<br />

APPENDIX C – 2010 RAWORTH HERITAGE ASSESSMENT REPORT<br />

Page 244 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

23


Page 245 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

Complex<br />

September 2010<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed<br />

Development Options<br />

Heritage Issues<br />

bryce raworth • conservation urban design<br />

19 Victoria Street St Kilda Vic 3182


1.0 Introduction<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed<br />

Development Options<br />

– Heritage Issues<br />

September 2010<br />

The North East Rail Revitalisation Project includes a rail bypass <strong>of</strong> central<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>, which has made the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex redundant. A<br />

new railway station for the township has been built on the new rail corridor that<br />

skirts the northern edge <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. As a result <strong>of</strong> this, 50 hectares <strong>of</strong> land<br />

occupied by the old station at <strong>Wodonga</strong> has become available for development.<br />

VicTrack, who have commissioned this report, have been given the responsibility<br />

to develop this land and its infrastructure.<br />

Several buildings and items <strong>of</strong> railway infrastructure occupy the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station complex. This report, however, will only assess the devlopment<br />

options with regard to their perceived impact upon the station building and the<br />

goods shed on the subject site. Other elements <strong>of</strong> railway infrastructure on the site<br />

including a signal box, carriage cleaning facility, locomotive turntable, railway<br />

tracks and other elements have not been assessed as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> this report.<br />

This report provides discussion and analysis in relation to the following:<br />

• the cultural significance and intactness <strong>of</strong> the station building and good<br />

shed;<br />

• a review <strong>of</strong> nine redevelopment options that are proposed for the subject<br />

site, in terms <strong>of</strong> their impacts upon the heritage value <strong>of</strong> the railway<br />

station and goods shed;<br />

• recommendations in relation to the preferred option(s) for the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex in terms <strong>of</strong><br />

heritage considerations.<br />

Reference in this report to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex means the<br />

entire site and its individual buildings and elements. Where individual buildings<br />

are discussed they are referred to by their common name and/or function eg<br />

station building, goods shed, signal box etc.<br />

Page 246 <strong>of</strong> 304


2.0 Sources <strong>of</strong> Information<br />

3.0 History & Description<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

The analysis <strong>of</strong> the proposed development options for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station complex are based upon schematic diagrams supplied by AECOM.<br />

An inspection <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex was undertaken on 11<br />

September 2010. The description <strong>of</strong> the fabric and condition <strong>of</strong> the buildings in<br />

this report derives from that inspection.<br />

This report also draws upon heritage citations including the Australian Heritage<br />

Council Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate and the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Heritage Study<br />

Inventory’ (May 2004), and other heritage studies including the Andrew Ward,<br />

‘Victoria’s Railway Stations: An Architectural Survey’ (1982 and 1988).<br />

Historical newspaper articles about the railway station and historical photographs<br />

have also been reviewed in the preparation <strong>of</strong> the history <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station complex.<br />

History<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the North East Railway Line,<br />

which was originally built to link Melbourne with the Murray River in northeast<br />

Victoria. The North East Railway Line was built in stages between Essendon and<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> between 1870 and 1873. It was the second railway built between the<br />

Murray River and Melbourne, to provide railway facilities for the Murray River<br />

trade.<br />

At the time <strong>of</strong> its completion, the North East Railway Line was the most<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>itable railway in Victoria. Despite no ongoing railway to Sydney at that time,<br />

the shipment <strong>of</strong> goods between the Murray River and Melbourne provided a<br />

significant amount <strong>of</strong> revenue. 1<br />

Within a decade <strong>of</strong> the completion <strong>of</strong> the North East Railway Line, aspirations <strong>of</strong><br />

an inter-colonial link between Sydney and Melbourne were realised, when the<br />

line between Albury and Sydney was completed in 1881. 2 A link between the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> and Albury railway stations was completed in 1883, but due to<br />

differing gauges in each colony, at the border passengers were required to change<br />

trains and freight was transhipped.<br />

1 Robert Lee, The Railways <strong>of</strong> Victoria 1854-2004, p 65.<br />

2 Robert Lee, The Railways <strong>of</strong> Victoria 1854-2004, pp 66-67.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 2<br />

Page 247 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 1 (left) Celebrations at <strong>Wodonga</strong> on the completion <strong>of</strong> the North East<br />

Railway Line in 1873. The illustration shows the original smaller<br />

timber frame shed, replaced by the current brick shed the<br />

following year (State Library <strong>of</strong> Victoria Picture Collection).<br />

Figure 2 (right) Goods shed c1880 (Public Record Office Victoria Collection).<br />

Initially, a complicated system worked where Melbourne-bound travellers<br />

changed trains at <strong>Wodonga</strong>, and Sydney bound travellers changed trains at<br />

Albury. Goods were also transhipped with a similar arrangement. The complexity<br />

<strong>of</strong> this process, added with the expense <strong>of</strong> operating two stations for inter-colonial<br />

travelers, saw by the mid 1880s all passengers and goods changing trains at<br />

Albury. The iconic Sydney Limited and Spirit <strong>of</strong> Progress <strong>of</strong> the early and midtwentieth<br />

century continued to use Albury as the stopping place at the New South<br />

Wales/Victoria border.<br />

The railway station building at <strong>Wodonga</strong> was, at the time the North East Railway<br />

Line was completed, considerably smaller. The contract for the station building<br />

was awarded in March 1875 to James Richardson. 3 With the completion <strong>of</strong> the<br />

link between Albury and <strong>Wodonga</strong>, the station was enlarged to give it suitable<br />

facilities as an inter-colonial passenger terminal. The Argus reported in January<br />

1884 that the works to the station were almost completed and included:<br />

…an extension <strong>of</strong> the platforms, additional refreshment rooms, and<br />

other accommodation, and the construction <strong>of</strong> customs shelter<br />

sheds on the railway platform, so as to allow <strong>of</strong> the passengers’<br />

luggage being examined under cover in hot and rainy weather<br />

instead <strong>of</strong> in the open as formerly. The main station building has<br />

been largely increased to provide adequate refreshment room<br />

accommodation… 4<br />

The refreshment rooms were <strong>of</strong> a type used in larger stations that consisted <strong>of</strong> set<br />

tables, rather than counter service. 5 Throughout the twentieth century there have<br />

been many alterations to the interior <strong>of</strong> the station building, which has altered its<br />

original planning. In recent years an addition has been completed that created a<br />

new entrance to the station and waiting room. 6<br />

3 Andrew C Ward & Associates, ‘Study <strong>of</strong> Historic Railway Buildings and Structures for<br />

V/Line’, Appendcies, Vol 2, pp 195-197.<br />

4 Argus, 16 January 1884, p 5.<br />

5 Argus, 2 May 1884, p 3.<br />

6 Alan Nelson, <strong>of</strong>ficer <strong>of</strong> VLine, pers com to Peter Barrett on 11 September 2010.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 3<br />

Page 248 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 3 (left) Railway station building (up side) after additions were<br />

completed in 1884 (Public Record Office Victoria)<br />

Figure 4 (right) Railway station building (down side) after the 1884 additions<br />

were completed (State Library <strong>of</strong> News South Wales).<br />

Figure 5 (left) Looking east along the platform c1900 (State Library <strong>of</strong> New<br />

South Wales).<br />

Figure 6 (right) Looking west along the platform c1900 (State Library <strong>of</strong><br />

Victoria).<br />

The goods shed at <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station completed as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the original<br />

works, was most probably timber frame. The shed was <strong>of</strong> a similar size and type<br />

to that built at Wangaratta (extant). 7 The shed was used to hold a ball celebrating<br />

the opening <strong>of</strong> the line to <strong>Wodonga</strong> in November 1873, which was attended by<br />

500-600 people. 8 The shed was rebuilt in brick in 1874, and it was said to be the<br />

second largest in the Colony. 9 By the mid-twentieth century the exterior loading<br />

dock <strong>of</strong> the shed had been extended on its east and west ends, 10 and at least one<br />

<strong>of</strong> the wall openings <strong>of</strong> the shed (east end) had been enlarged removing the<br />

original arcading. 11<br />

After Albury became the inter-colonial terminal, <strong>Wodonga</strong> was given a more<br />

modest role, handing intrastate passengers and goods. However, shunting <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Spirit <strong>of</strong> Progress occurred at yards at <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The station became the junction<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Cudgewa Railway Line opened in stages from 1889. The military camp and<br />

7 Argus, 19 November 1873, p 4.<br />

8 Argus, 20 November 1873, p 4.<br />

9 The shed at Spencer Street Station was the largest in Victoria. Andrew C Ward &<br />

Associates, ‘Study <strong>of</strong> Historic Railway Buildings and Structures for V/Line’,<br />

Appendcies, Vol 2, pp 199.<br />

10 Victorian Railways, drawing titled ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Proposed Locker & Meal room For<br />

Female Car Cleaners’, dated 21 October 1942, held by Public Record Office Victoria.<br />

11 Victorian Railways, drawing titled ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Additional Goods Shed’, dated 6 May<br />

1943, held by Public Record Office Victoria.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 4<br />

Page 249 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

later the migrant hostel at Bonegilla had a station on this line. The remaining<br />

section <strong>of</strong> this line between <strong>Wodonga</strong> and Bandiana was closed in 2009.<br />

Figure 7 (left) <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex c1900 (Public Record Office<br />

Victoria).<br />

Figure 8 (right) Goods shed c1960 (Public Record Office Victoria).<br />

In 1962, a standard gauge railway line was built from the border to Melbourne.<br />

This provided faster freight services along the east coast <strong>of</strong> Australia and gave<br />

passengers a faster and greater level <strong>of</strong> comfort, without the inconvenience <strong>of</strong><br />

having to change trains at Albury. The standard gauge line was built immediately<br />

to the south <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station. None <strong>of</strong> the passenger trains used on<br />

the standard gauge, including the iconic Southern Aurora, made scheduled stops<br />

at <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The popularity <strong>of</strong> air travel by the 1990s saw the passenger services<br />

on the route between Sydney and Melbourne discontinued and replaced with an<br />

XPT service, again stopping only at Albury.<br />

In May 2008 work commenced on the upgrade <strong>of</strong> the North East Railway Line,<br />

replacing 200 kilometres <strong>of</strong> broad gauge track with standard gauge. As <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

these works a five kilometre bypass around <strong>Wodonga</strong>, including a new station for<br />

the township, have been built, which has made the original <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station complex redundant.<br />

Physical Description<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is situated to the north <strong>of</strong> Elgin<br />

Boulevard, a short distance from High Street, one <strong>of</strong> the main commercial streets<br />

in the city. Up side <strong>of</strong> the railway station is House Creek and to the north <strong>of</strong> the<br />

station is South Street. A level crossing at High Street is situated a short distance<br />

on the down side <strong>of</strong> the complex. Motor vehicles access the complex from Elgin<br />

Boulevard via a level crossing for the standard gauge railway line, which skirts<br />

the station to its south. This line was built in the 1960s and has created a physical<br />

barrier between the station complex and its environs.<br />

The railway station building is best viewed from the west (track side), where its<br />

length can be fully appreciated. It is built upon a long platform that has a brick<br />

retaining wall with bluestone coping. The island platform at the east end/down<br />

side (built for inter-colonial trains and later used for Cudgewa Railway Line<br />

trains) is still discernible. Part <strong>of</strong> the brick retaining wall <strong>of</strong> the island platform<br />

(south side) is visible from the car park.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 5<br />

Page 250 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 9 (left) <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex looking from the southeast.<br />

The standard gauge railway line and its level crossing is visible<br />

in the foreground.<br />

Figure 10 (right) <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex looking from the northwest.<br />

Figure 11 (left) <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building looking from the northwest.<br />

Figure 12 (right) South side <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station building. The<br />

original entrance to the station is visible at centre (now disused).<br />

Figure 13 (left) Railway station platform looking east.<br />

Figure 14 (right) Railway station platform looking west. The gabled canopy is a<br />

remnant <strong>of</strong> a canopy added in the 1884 works to provide shelter<br />

for inter-colonial passengers changing trains and customs<br />

<strong>of</strong>ficers’ inspecting luggage.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 6<br />

Page 251 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 15 (left) Remnant <strong>of</strong> the former island platform for trains originating at<br />

Albury and Sydney, and later used for Cudgewa Railway Line<br />

trains.<br />

Figure 16 (right) Waiting room and ticketing <strong>of</strong>fice built as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the c1990<br />

works.<br />

Figure 17 (left) Interior <strong>of</strong> the former refreshment rooms, later used as gangers’<br />

quarters.<br />

Figure 18 (right) Ro<strong>of</strong> lantern in the station building.<br />

The railway station building is <strong>of</strong> the St Arnaud Style, 12 and has had several<br />

alterations and additions, which mostly have been complementary in scale, style<br />

and material. In its existing condition it is a long single-storey polychromatic<br />

brick building with a hip ro<strong>of</strong> clad in corrugated galvanised steel cladding, with<br />

eaves brackets. Chimneys have been removed, but a timber and glass lantern is<br />

extant on the central portion <strong>of</strong> the ro<strong>of</strong>. A long concave pr<strong>of</strong>ile verandah projects<br />

from the north side <strong>of</strong> the building over the platform. Original timber frame<br />

double-hung sash windows are rectangular in form. There have been some<br />

alterations made to window and door openings.<br />

12 Andrew Ward & A Donnelly, ‘Victoria’s railway Stations. An Architectural Survey. The<br />

Formative Years: 1854-1880’, p 137.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 7<br />

Page 252 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Significant alterations have been made to the west end <strong>of</strong> the building (1884),<br />

including the former refreshment rooms (later used as accommodation for<br />

gangers and other railway staff), and <strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> the gable ro<strong>of</strong> canopy<br />

(1884) used to provide shelter over the island platform. The existing waiting room<br />

and ticketing area was built in c1990 and although sympathetic in style and<br />

materials, it did remove some early fabric on this <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the complex. Internally,<br />

much <strong>of</strong> the original fabric has been removed, obliterated or concealed in later<br />

works. Floors are concrete with various finishes, and original ceilings have either<br />

been removed or are concealed by newer lower ceilings.<br />

The goods shed is built opposite the station building. It is rectangular in plan and<br />

has a steel truss gable ro<strong>of</strong>, clad in corrugated galvanised steel. A clerestory<br />

extends along the ridge <strong>of</strong> the shed. The exterior brick walls on the north and<br />

south side are divided into 24 bays by plain brick piers with a trabeated treatment.<br />

The east and west ends <strong>of</strong> the building had an arcuated treatment in their<br />

brickwork, but this has been removed in the early twentieth century when the wall<br />

openings on these elevations were enlarged. The brickwork and the concrete<br />

lintels <strong>of</strong> the new openings are unsympathetic. The corner piers have been dressed<br />

in bluestone (midway). Circular wall openings for ventilation are extant but their<br />

timber louvres have been removed/altered.<br />

Figure 19 (left) Goods Shed looking northwest.<br />

Figure 20 (right) Goods Shed looking northeast.<br />

Figure 21 (left) Goods Shed looking southeast from the goods yard.<br />

Figure 22 (right) Bluestone dressing on pilaster <strong>of</strong> the goods shed.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 8<br />

Page 253 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 23 (left) Decorative iron downpipe on the north side <strong>of</strong> the goods shed.<br />

Figure 24 (right) Northeast corner <strong>of</strong> the goods shed. The late twentieth century<br />

brick addition is visible at left.<br />

Figure 25 (left) Interior <strong>of</strong> the goods shed.<br />

Figure 26 (right) Office in the goods shed.<br />

A loading dock for trucks etc extends along the north elevation. It is built <strong>of</strong><br />

concrete with a timber coping and is <strong>of</strong> later origin. Some bays have sliding<br />

doors that access the interior <strong>of</strong> the shed, but these have been reclad in corrugated<br />

steel. Fitted on another bay is an unsympathetic aluminium frame sliding door. A<br />

series <strong>of</strong> decorative metal downpipes on the north elevation are now disused. At<br />

the east end <strong>of</strong> the shed is a brick Modernist addition, which has concealed much<br />

<strong>of</strong> the east elevation <strong>of</strong> the Victorian goods shed.<br />

Internally, a concrete platform extends along the north side <strong>of</strong> the shed. The<br />

platform is <strong>of</strong> mid-twentieth century origins. A railway track extends beside the<br />

platform. Train wagons and vans entered the shed through the openings at the east<br />

and west end. The shed is mostly one space, except at the east end where the<br />

platform has been built across the entire depth <strong>of</strong> the shed at its west end, and this<br />

portion has been <strong>part</strong>itioned into <strong>of</strong>fice space. The east end <strong>of</strong> the platform is<br />

<strong>part</strong>itioned and these rooms contain toilets. The twentieth century brick addition<br />

contains <strong>of</strong>fice space.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 9<br />

Page 254 <strong>of</strong> 304


4.0 Listing and Controls<br />

5.0 Significance<br />

Australian Heritage Council<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station is listed as an Indicative Place on the Australian<br />

Heritage Council Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate (Place ID 102835). A decision<br />

has yet to be made by the Australian Heritage Council as to whether to add the<br />

railway station to the Register <strong>of</strong> the National Estate. There are no statutory<br />

constraints arising from its current status with the Australian Heritage Council.<br />

Heritage Victoria<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not listed on the Heritage Victoria<br />

Victorian Heritage Register.<br />

<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not listed on the heritage overlay<br />

schedule <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

National Trust <strong>of</strong> Australia (Victoria)<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is not classified by the National Trust <strong>of</strong><br />

Australia (Victoria).<br />

A statement <strong>of</strong> significance for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station has been prepared<br />

by the Australian Heritage Council for its citation on the Register <strong>of</strong> the National<br />

Estate. This statement <strong>of</strong> significance is limited to the association <strong>of</strong> the place<br />

with Federation themes. Other aspects <strong>of</strong> its significance have not been<br />

researched and assessed:<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Station is historically significant because <strong>of</strong> its role in the intercolonial<br />

trade rivalries <strong>of</strong> the mid-nineteenth century, and the railway<br />

developments that resulted from, and further stimulated those rivalries. The<br />

history <strong>of</strong> tariff and railway rivalry were among the stimuli <strong>of</strong> the federation<br />

movement in the Riverina region, and the <strong>Wodonga</strong> station, together with<br />

the Albury station, and the Murray River rail bridge are important places in<br />

the federation story, which saw the several colonies combine into the<br />

Commonwealth <strong>of</strong> Australia. (RNE Criterion A.4; Vic Criterion A). The<br />

historical significance is reflected in the size and layout <strong>of</strong> the station<br />

precinct, with long platforms and relatively commodious station facilities<br />

necessary to deal with the transfer <strong>of</strong> passengers from NSW to Victorian<br />

trains. (RNE Criterion B.2; Vic Criteria B, C)<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 10<br />

Page 255 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

A statement <strong>of</strong> significance for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex was<br />

prepared in the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Heritage Study Inventory’. The study identified the<br />

complex to be <strong>of</strong> local significance and recommended that it be included in the<br />

local planning scheme. The statement <strong>of</strong> significance prepared for the complex<br />

states:<br />

Typical railway construction for station (albeit modified). Goods shed<br />

<strong>part</strong>icularly noteworthy. Historical role as border station and transit point<br />

for military and migrant use. High social significance.<br />

Station Buildings: The <strong>Wodonga</strong> station building remains as a major midlate<br />

Victorian station building in the bi-chromatic style. Its importance is<br />

derived in <strong>part</strong>icular from the way in which it is expressive <strong>of</strong> its former<br />

role as the principal Victorian based interchange point for traffic on this<br />

nation’s first intercapital railway, opened in 1883.<br />

The remnant island platform verandah and 1883 additions are, as a<br />

consequence, important elements. Other important elements include the<br />

goods shed.<br />

Goods shed: The <strong>Wodonga</strong> goods shed is important as a reminder <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong><br />

the principal arguments presented for the construction <strong>of</strong> the north-eastern<br />

railway, to capture the Riverina trade. Its size is especially expressive <strong>of</strong><br />

this role.<br />

Andrew Ward in his assessment <strong>of</strong> the complex notes, in regard to the railway<br />

station building:<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> station building remains as a major mid-late Victorian<br />

station building in the bi-chromatic style. Its importance is derived in<br />

<strong>part</strong>icular from the way in which it is expressive <strong>of</strong> its former role as the<br />

principal Victorian based interchange point for traffic on this nation’s first<br />

intercapital railway, opened in 1883.<br />

The remnant island platform verandah and 1883 additions are, as a<br />

consequence, important elements. Other elements include the goods shed. 13<br />

In regard to the goods shed, Ward also states:<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> goods shed is important as a reminder <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the principal<br />

arguments presented for the construction <strong>of</strong> the north-eastern railway; to<br />

capture the Riverina trade. Its size is especially expressive <strong>of</strong> this role. 14<br />

13 Andrew Ward & Associates, ‘Study <strong>of</strong> Historic railway Buildings and Structures for<br />

V/Line’, vol 2, p 197.<br />

14 Andrew Ward & Associates, ‘Study <strong>of</strong> Historic railway Buildings and Structures for<br />

V/Line’, vol 2, p 199.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 11<br />

Page 256 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex was built in several stages from 1873. It<br />

was the terminus <strong>of</strong> the second railway line built from Melbourne to the Murray<br />

River, post-dating the opening <strong>of</strong> the Echuca Railway Station by close to a<br />

decade. The North East Railway Line was primarily built to service the Murray<br />

River trade and settlements in this region, with its use as an inter-colonial termini<br />

only becoming apparent years later when a line from Sydney to Albury was<br />

constructed.<br />

As a consequence <strong>of</strong> differing gauges in New South Wales and Victoria,<br />

passengers travelling between Sydney and Melbourne, depending on the direction<br />

<strong>of</strong> travel, would change trains at either <strong>Wodonga</strong> or Albury. However, the use <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station as an inter-colonial terminus was shortlived, as the<br />

transfer <strong>of</strong> passengers and the transhipment <strong>of</strong> freight was soon after relocated to<br />

the larger and more grander station complex at Albury. From the 1890s until<br />

recently the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station has served primarily for intrastate freight<br />

and passenger services.<br />

Other railway station complexes on the North East Railway Line <strong>of</strong> a similar<br />

scale include Seymour and Wangaratta, which are both identified by Heritage<br />

Victoria to be <strong>of</strong> State significance. Both <strong>of</strong> these stations are contemporaneous<br />

with <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station. The Wangaratta Railway Station contains a wide<br />

array <strong>of</strong> elements <strong>of</strong> early origin including a brick water tower and its original<br />

timber frame good shed (similar to the original shed at <strong>Wodonga</strong>).<br />

The Chiltern Railway Station Complex, on the upside <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>, is also<br />

identified by Heritage Victoria to be <strong>of</strong> State significance. Although the railway<br />

station complex at Chiltern is considerably smaller than the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station, its goods shed, <strong>of</strong> a similar design (albeit smaller) to the shed at<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>, demonstrates a greater level <strong>of</strong> detailing (bluestone base and greater<br />

use <strong>of</strong> bluestone dressings on brickwork) and is more intact (retains arcading on<br />

end walls, fire place and internal timber platform.<br />

The former Barnawartha Railway Station, which is the next station on the up side<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, has a brick goods shed <strong>of</strong> a similar style and scale<br />

to Chiltern. The Barwnawartha shed is included on the Heritage Victoria Heritage<br />

Inventory.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 12<br />

Page 257 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 27 (left) Albury Railway Station, completed in 1881.<br />

Figure 28 (right) Island platform at Albury Railway Station. The platform at left is<br />

for through trains between Melbourne and Sydney, and the<br />

platform at right is for trains originating in Melbourne. A similar<br />

platform arrangement existed at <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

Figure 29 (left) Wangaratta Railway Station complex. The station retains the<br />

original timber frame good shed, similar to the shed that was<br />

originally built at <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Figure 30 (right) Chiltern Railway Station Complex.<br />

Figure 31 (left) Goods shed at Chiltern Railway Station complex retains its<br />

arcading at its ends.<br />

Figure 32 (right) The interior <strong>of</strong> the Chiltern goods shed retains much <strong>of</strong> its<br />

original fabric including its timber platform and fireplace<br />

(Heritage Victoria Photograph).<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 13<br />

Page 258 <strong>of</strong> 304


6.0 Analysis <strong>of</strong><br />

Proposals<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Figure 33 (left) Goods shed at Barnawartha Railway Station<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex is <strong>of</strong> architectural, aesthetic, historical<br />

and social significance. In its fabric is reflected the various phases <strong>of</strong> the station’s<br />

growth, from a small station to an inter-colonial terminus in the late nineteenth<br />

century, and its subsequent decline in the twentieth century. In addition to its<br />

aesthetic qualities, the station building is <strong>of</strong> primary value to understanding the<br />

history <strong>of</strong> this complex. The goods shed, with some <strong>of</strong> its original fabric removed<br />

or altered, is <strong>of</strong> contributory value to the complex in understanding <strong>of</strong> the<br />

station’s role in the movement <strong>of</strong> freight in this region.<br />

The station building is <strong>of</strong> primary significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

complex. It has aesthetic, architectural and historical value, as well as potential<br />

technological value, to an understanding <strong>of</strong> the heritage significance <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station complex. It is recommended that any proposal retains<br />

and conserves the railway station building and its platform and canopies.<br />

The goods shed is <strong>of</strong> contributory significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

complex. Despite its altered condition, it contributes to an understanding and<br />

interpretation <strong>of</strong> the complex. It is preferable that the shed is retained, however<br />

there is scope in any re-adaptive reuse <strong>of</strong> the shed for modification or <strong>part</strong>ial<br />

removal <strong>of</strong> original or early fabric, <strong>part</strong>icularly given the extent to which it has<br />

previously been altered.<br />

The railway station building and goods shed are situated within Development Site<br />

B within the Development Plan that has been provided to the authors <strong>of</strong> this<br />

report. 15 Development Site B extends south to Elgin Boulevard and north<br />

towards the rear boundaries <strong>of</strong> properties in South Street. It contains 14,800<br />

square metres <strong>of</strong> land. The following options for Development Site B propose to<br />

retain and/or remove buildings on the site. Each option has been assessed below<br />

individually to establish their appropriateness from a heritage perspective in<br />

relation to the station building and the goods shed.<br />

15 AECOM, drawing titled ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> VicTrack Development Plan – Draft Plan’, Drawing<br />

No 9, Issue C, dated 4 June 2010.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 14<br />

Page 259 <strong>of</strong> 304


Option A1<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

This option will retain both the entire railway station building and the entire<br />

goods shed. From a heritage perspective this is a sound and preferred approach, as<br />

it will conserve elements <strong>of</strong> both primary value (railway station building) and<br />

contributory value (goods shed). However, a suitable re-adaptive use for the two<br />

buildings should be decided upon before proceeding with this option.<br />

While retention <strong>of</strong> the two buildings is preferred, given the lower heritage value<br />

<strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be possible<br />

without diminishing its heritage value.<br />

Much <strong>of</strong> the interior <strong>of</strong> the railway station and some <strong>of</strong> its exterior has been<br />

altered. Reinstatement <strong>of</strong> lost elements, based upon historical records, and<br />

removal <strong>of</strong> later fabric <strong>of</strong> little or no significance, could be permitted and are<br />

encouraged.<br />

Option A1 [ii]<br />

This option will remove the railway station building and retain the goods shed.<br />

From a heritage perspective this is not a preferred option as it will remove an<br />

element <strong>of</strong> primary significance to this site (railway station building).<br />

While the railway station building is recommended to be retained, it is<br />

acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> exterior are altered and /or is<br />

fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong> little or no significance, and this fabric could be<br />

could be modified or removed sympathetically.<br />

Given the lower, contributory, value <strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification or<br />

<strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be permitted. A suitable readaptive<br />

use <strong>of</strong> the good shed should be determined prior to any redevelopment <strong>of</strong><br />

the site.<br />

Option A2<br />

This option will retain both the entire railway station building and the entire<br />

goods shed. The goods shed is to be used as an annexe to a hotel proposed for an<br />

adjoining site to the southeast <strong>of</strong> the railway station and good shed. From a<br />

heritage perspective this is a sound approach, as it will conserve elements <strong>of</strong> both<br />

primary value (railway station building) and contributory value (goods shed).<br />

However, a suitable re-adaptive use for the railway station building should also be<br />

decided upon prior to proceeding with this development.<br />

While retention <strong>of</strong> the two buildings is preferred, given the lower heritage value<br />

<strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be possible<br />

without diminishing its heritage value.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 15<br />

Page 260 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Much <strong>of</strong> the interior <strong>of</strong> the railway station and some <strong>of</strong> the exterior <strong>of</strong> the railway<br />

station have been altered, and/or is fabric <strong>of</strong> recent origin. Reinstatement <strong>of</strong> lost<br />

elements, based upon historical records, and removal <strong>of</strong> later fabric <strong>of</strong> little or no<br />

significance, could be permitted.<br />

Option A2 [ii]<br />

This option will remove the railway station building and retain the goods shed as<br />

an annexe to the proposed hotel to be built on adjacent site to the southeast <strong>of</strong> the<br />

good shed. From a heritage perspective this is not a preferred option as it will<br />

remove an element <strong>of</strong> primary significance to this site (railway station building).<br />

While the railway station building is recommended to be retained, it is<br />

acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> exterior are altered and /or is<br />

fabric <strong>of</strong> later origin and <strong>of</strong> little or no significance, and this fabric could be could<br />

be modified or removed sympathetically in any development.<br />

Given the lower, contributory, value <strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification or<br />

<strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be permitted in the works to<br />

incorporate it into the hotel development.<br />

Option B<br />

This option will retain the railway station building and will retain the<br />

‘superstructure/frame’ as a piece <strong>of</strong> ‘railway industrial art’. While modification<br />

and/or even <strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> original/early fabric <strong>of</strong> the good shed would be<br />

acceptable in some instances, the proposal seems unworkable from a heritage<br />

perspective, given the nature <strong>of</strong> the structure <strong>of</strong> the building. It would also be<br />

undesirable ins<strong>of</strong>ar as the building would be largely demolished. While this<br />

option would hold some interpretive value, it would be similar to full demolition<br />

in effect.<br />

The goods shed is constructed <strong>of</strong> load bearing brick walls, which support an iron<br />

frame truss ro<strong>of</strong>. Retention <strong>of</strong> the ‘superstructure’ would involve retaining large<br />

areas <strong>of</strong> wall. Some additional wall openings could be incorporated into bays on<br />

its walls, <strong>part</strong>icularly the south elevation that has no existing wall openings.<br />

Reinstatement <strong>of</strong> the arcaded treatment <strong>of</strong> the end bays (east and west elevations)<br />

should be also be considered.<br />

The goods shed is in relatively good condition and should preferably be retained<br />

as a functioning building on this site. There are several other elements on the site<br />

including the locomotive turntable and other sheds that may be more appropriate<br />

for use as railway industrial art/relics.<br />

While the railway station building would be retained in this proposal, it is<br />

acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> exterior are altered and /or is<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 16<br />

Page 261 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong> little or no significance. This fabric could be could<br />

be modified or removed sympathetically in any development.<br />

Option C<br />

This option will demolish the railway station building and relocate and/or reuse<br />

materials from the good shed in a sculptural surface treatment. The option may<br />

also include re-use as an architectural feature or wall façade. From a heritage<br />

perspective this is not a preferred option as it will remove an element <strong>of</strong> primary<br />

significance to this site (railway station building).<br />

While the railway station building is recommended to be retained, it is<br />

acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> exterior are altered and /or is<br />

fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong> little or no significance, and this fabric could be<br />

could be modified or removed sympathetically.<br />

Given the lower, contributory, value <strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification or<br />

<strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be permitted, however removal <strong>of</strong><br />

the entire building and the proposed reuse <strong>of</strong> the building’s materials on another<br />

building, is not recommended.<br />

Option D1<br />

This option will retain the railway station and <strong>part</strong>ially demolish the shed.<br />

Retention <strong>of</strong> the railway station building is desirable, as it is an element <strong>of</strong><br />

primary significance to this site. However, it is acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its<br />

interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> exterior are altered and /or is fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong><br />

little or no significance. This fabric could be could be modified or removed<br />

sympathetically in any development.<br />

Partial demolition <strong>of</strong> the shed could be permitted, if there was a clearer indication<br />

<strong>of</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong> demolition that is proposed. Any <strong>part</strong>ial demolition should not<br />

remove the ability to interpret the original form and scale <strong>of</strong> the shed. Another<br />

option would be retention <strong>of</strong> the shed, with some modification to its existing<br />

fabric.<br />

Option D 2<br />

This option will retain the railway station and retain <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the structure <strong>of</strong> the<br />

goods shed. Retention <strong>of</strong> the railway station building is desirable, as it is an<br />

element <strong>of</strong> primary significance. However, it is acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> its<br />

interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> its exterior are altered and /or is fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong><br />

little or no significance. This fabric could be could be modified or removed<br />

sympathetically in any development.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 17<br />

Page 262 <strong>of</strong> 304


<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

Partial demolition <strong>of</strong> the shed could be permitted, if there was a clearer indication<br />

<strong>of</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong> demolition that is proposed. Any <strong>part</strong>ial demolition should not<br />

remove the ability to interpret the original form and scale <strong>of</strong> the shed. Another<br />

option would be retention <strong>of</strong> the shed, with some modification to its existing<br />

fabric.<br />

Option E<br />

This option will demolish the entire railway station building and the entire goods<br />

shed. Notes on the drawing suggest the possibility <strong>of</strong> full or <strong>part</strong>ial relocation <strong>of</strong><br />

buildings could be considered as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> this option.<br />

The railway station building is <strong>of</strong> primary significance to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station complex, and its removal, added to the removal <strong>of</strong> the goods shed, which<br />

is <strong>of</strong> contributory value, would significantly impact upon the heritage value <strong>of</strong><br />

this site.<br />

It is acknowledged that much <strong>of</strong> the interior and <strong>part</strong>s <strong>of</strong> the exterior <strong>of</strong> the<br />

railway station building are altered and /or is fabric <strong>of</strong> later origins and <strong>of</strong> little or<br />

no significance. This fabric could be could be modified or removed<br />

sympathetically in any development.<br />

Given the lower, contributory, value <strong>of</strong> the goods shed, some modification or<br />

<strong>part</strong>ial removal <strong>of</strong> its original/early fabric could be permitted, however removal <strong>of</strong><br />

the entire building and the proposed reuse <strong>of</strong> the building’s materials as industrial<br />

art, as proposed, is not recommended.<br />

Relocation <strong>of</strong> the railway station building and/or the goods shed to another site is<br />

contrary to the Burra Charter (1999) principles and is generally discredited as a<br />

method <strong>of</strong> conservation <strong>of</strong> a building. The physical location <strong>of</strong> a building is <strong>part</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> its cultural significance, and for this reason it should remain on this site, unless<br />

relocation is the sole means <strong>of</strong> ensuring the survival <strong>of</strong> these buildings.<br />

At this stage there is no evidence that only relocation can ensure the conservation<br />

<strong>of</strong> these buildings. For this reason, this option is not recommended.<br />

Moreover, given the heavy masonry construction <strong>of</strong> the buildings in question,<br />

relocation would be both impractical and expensive.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 18<br />

Page 263 <strong>of</strong> 304


7.0 Conclusion<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station Complex<br />

Analysis <strong>of</strong> Proposed Development Options<br />

It has been established in the foregoing that the railway station is a significant<br />

building and is <strong>of</strong> primary significance to this complex. The goods shed is also<br />

significant, but can be seen to be <strong>of</strong> a somewhat lesser importance, in <strong>part</strong><br />

because <strong>of</strong> the extent <strong>of</strong> alterations that have been made to the fabric.<br />

The options that have been supplied for review in this report are schematic and<br />

would require further development before precise recommendations about their<br />

suitability can be given. However, having undertaken a physical investigation <strong>of</strong><br />

the site, and reviewed historical information relating to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway<br />

Station complex, it is recommended that any future development proposal for this<br />

site should retain the railway station building, with some scope for modification<br />

and removal <strong>of</strong> interior and exterior fabric <strong>of</strong> more recent origin. It is also<br />

strongly to be preferred that the goods shed be retained, with scope for<br />

modification <strong>of</strong> its original fabric, but only to an extent that enables its original<br />

form and scale to be interpreted, and its original use discernable. Should it be<br />

determined that the goods shed is to be demolished, in whole or in <strong>part</strong>, a detailed<br />

archival quality photographic record should be prepared in accordance with the<br />

standards required by Heritage Victoria prior to any works being commenced on<br />

the site.<br />

An archival quality photographic record should in any case be considered for the<br />

complex as a whole, including those components that are not the subject <strong>of</strong> this<br />

report, prior to any redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land associated with the complex.<br />

bryce raworth pty ltd conservation•urban design 19<br />

Page 264 <strong>of</strong> 304


Who is the planning authority?<br />

Planning and Environment Act 1987<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

AMENDMENT C92<br />

EXPLANATORY REPORT<br />

This amendment has been prepared by the Minister for Planning (the Minister) who is the planning authority for<br />

this amendment. The amendment has been made at the request <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria and includes land owned by<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council.<br />

Land affected by the amendment<br />

The amendment affects land generally comprising the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land<br />

in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The land is generally bound by Smyth Street, Elgin Boulevard, Watson Street, High Street,<br />

Bond Street and Church Street in as shown on ‘Map 1’. The land includes No. 27 South Street, parcels <strong>of</strong> land<br />

owned by the <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council at No. 35 to 51 South Street and No. 107 High Street, <strong>Wodonga</strong> as well as<br />

Elgin Boulevard between Smythe Street and High Street.<br />

Map 1. Location <strong>of</strong> Land Subject to Amendment C92 (source lad.vic.gov.au)<br />

What the amendment does<br />

The amendment proposes to rezone the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land to allow for its<br />

future mixed use and development and delivery <strong>of</strong> key public roads and public open space in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The amendment:<br />

� Rezones the land from the Public Use Zone 4, Road Zone 2 and the Residential 1 Zone to the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone, Schedule 1.<br />

� Introduces the Comprehensive Development Zone – Schedule 1 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive<br />

Development Plan’.<br />

� Applies the Environmental Audit Overlay to the Land.<br />

� Applies the Heritage Overlay HO10 to the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’.<br />

� Deletes the Design and Development Overlay 4 ‘Elgin Boulevard’ which applies to the land.<br />

Page 265 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

N


� Undertakes consequential modifications to the Municipal Strategic Statement and Local Planning Policy at<br />

Clause 21.11, Clause 21.12 and Clause 22.09.<br />

� Includes the Incorporated Document ‘Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> – Comprehensive Development Plan’ in the<br />

Schedule at Clause 81.01 ‘Documents Incorporated Into this Scheme’.<br />

� Includes Places Victoria as a referral authority for approval <strong>of</strong> permit applications and Precincts Plans under<br />

the Comprehensive Development Zone 1 in the schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

� Inserts reference to Maps 6EAO and 7EAO in the Schedule to Clause 61.03 ‘Maps which Comprise Part <strong>of</strong><br />

this Scheme.’<br />

Strategic assessment <strong>of</strong> the amendment<br />

� Why is the amendment required?<br />

Places Victoria has requested that the Minister for Planning amend the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme under the<br />

powers pursuant to section 20(4) <strong>of</strong> the Planning and Environment Act, 1987 to rezone the land comprising<br />

the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and rail land from the Public Use Zone 4, Business 1 Zone, Residential<br />

1 Zone and Road Zone 2 to the Comprehensive Development Zone – Schedule 1.<br />

The land parcel comprises an area in excess <strong>of</strong> 100,000 square metres and is located at the northern edge <strong>of</strong><br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area. The land is no long required for transport purposes due to the<br />

relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and comprises the former rail station building, goods shed, redundant<br />

rail infrastructure and signalling boxes as well as some commercial buildings in Bond and High Streets.<br />

A number <strong>of</strong> parcels <strong>of</strong> Council owned land are located along the northern boundary <strong>of</strong> the rail land adjoining<br />

South Street, and are proposed to be rezoned from the Residential 1 Zone to the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone 1 to facilitate more intensive residential or mixed use.<br />

As <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the amendment it is proposed to apply the Environmental Audit Overlay to ensure that land is<br />

suitable for a future sensitive use. It is also proposed to remove the Design and Development Overlay 4 as its<br />

urban design principals are incorporated by the Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

The retention and adaptive re-use <strong>of</strong> the Former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and Goods Shed is proposed to be<br />

facilitated through the application <strong>of</strong> a site specific Heritage Overlay HO10.<br />

The amendment is required to facilitate the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business Area and provides a significant opportunity for investment in regional Victoria. The proposed<br />

rezoning will enable the land to be used and developed for a wide range <strong>of</strong> purposes consistent with its<br />

location within the Central Business Area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. The rezoning proposes to introduce an Incorporated<br />

Document in the Schedule to Clause 81.1 which identifies key road and public open space projects to be<br />

delivered in association with the future use and development <strong>of</strong> the land. The Incorporated Document will<br />

match ‘Map 1’ contained in the Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

� How does the amendment implement the objectives <strong>of</strong> planning in Victoria?<br />

The amendment achieves the objectives <strong>of</strong> planning in Victoria as set out in Section 4 <strong>of</strong> the Planning and<br />

Environment Act, 1987 by providing for the fair, economic and sustainable use and development <strong>of</strong> land and<br />

facilitating development in accordance with the objectives <strong>of</strong> planning in Victoria.<br />

a) To provide for the fair, orderly, economic and sustainable use and development <strong>of</strong> land.<br />

The Amendment affects a large and strategically located land parcel which will have a significant impact on<br />

the urban form <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to the Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1 allows for an Incorporated<br />

Document to be introduced into the Planning Scheme which sets out key road and public open space projects<br />

associated with the land’s future redevelopment consistent with the Road Strategy for Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

This will facilitate urban renewal and reintegration <strong>of</strong> the former rail land into the Central Business Area in a<br />

manner that will support the future growth <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> by providing land for commercial and residential<br />

redevelopment.<br />

b) To provide for the protection <strong>of</strong> natural and man-made resources and the maintenance <strong>of</strong> ecological<br />

processes and genetic diversity.<br />

The former use <strong>of</strong> the land for rail related operations has rendered this section <strong>of</strong> the rail corridor<br />

substantially disturbed. Reports prepared in relation to the environmental condition <strong>of</strong> the land have<br />

Page 266 <strong>of</strong> 304


identified that there are no recognised species <strong>of</strong> flora or fauna <strong>of</strong> significance that are required to be<br />

protected.<br />

Trees remaining on the site have been identified as largely introduced and planted species. Areas <strong>of</strong> scattered<br />

remnant trees are identified across the site and it is sought that these be incorporated in the future<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land through the Schedule to the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

c) To secure a pleasant, efficient and safe working, living and recreational environment for all Victorians<br />

and visitors to Victoria.<br />

Portions <strong>of</strong> the land have been identified as contaminated as a result <strong>of</strong> the former rail related operations and<br />

the location <strong>of</strong> a former Police Station and Service Station. Reports prepared in support <strong>of</strong> the amendment<br />

indicate that the level <strong>of</strong> contamination identified would be unlikely to significantly preclude the long term<br />

redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the site but require further investigation. It is proposed that the Environmental Audit<br />

Overlay be applied to the land to ensure the safety <strong>of</strong> future sensitive uses.<br />

The Comprehensive Development Plan contained in the Schedule sets down the necessary provision <strong>of</strong> new<br />

road infrastructure and makes provision for a new urban square at the corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High<br />

Street and open space linkages along the former rail corridor. Urban Design Principles included within the<br />

Zone provide a focus on built form outcomes which support active street frontages and pedestrian activity<br />

throughout the precinct as well as improved connectivity with the surrounding urban fabric.<br />

d) To conserve and enhance those buildings, areas or other places which are <strong>of</strong> scientific, aesthetic,<br />

architectural or historical interest, or otherwise <strong>of</strong> special cultural value.<br />

The land is largely vacant with the exception <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and Goods Shed and<br />

remnant rail infrastructure and some commercial development. A Heritage Assessment <strong>of</strong> the former<br />

Railway Station buildings and associated infrastructure has been undertaken by Context Heritage Consultants<br />

and has identified elements <strong>of</strong> primary and secondary significance as follows:<br />

‘Primary Significance’<br />

� The Station buildings to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and detailing<br />

including any remnants <strong>of</strong> the 1874 structure, the 1184 additions including the (now truncated)<br />

two sided open verandah, and the whole <strong>of</strong> the platform as extended in 1884.<br />

� The goods shed to the extent <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century form, fabric and detailing.<br />

� The visual relationship between the two buildings ….the physical space between the buildings<br />

that contains the dual track alignment is significant as an expression <strong>of</strong> the function <strong>of</strong> two<br />

buildings.<br />

‘Secondary Significance’<br />

� The Locomotive Enginemen’s shed, constructed c.1950.<br />

� The turntable, constructed c.1962.<br />

� <strong>Wodonga</strong> Signal Box A, constructed c. 1962.<br />

� Remnant signalling and safe working equipment.<br />

� The layout <strong>of</strong> the tracks within the station yard, which assist in understanding the size and<br />

importance <strong>of</strong> the complex.<br />

It is proposed that the elements <strong>of</strong> primary heritage significance be identified through the application <strong>of</strong> a site<br />

specific Heritage Overlay Schedule HO10 with the exception <strong>of</strong> the full eastern extent <strong>of</strong> the 1884 platform.<br />

The retention <strong>of</strong> the full eastern extent <strong>of</strong> the platform would compromise the ability to best achieve the urban<br />

renewal objectives <strong>of</strong> the land and in <strong>part</strong>icular the provision <strong>of</strong> the Church Street road link in the<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan.<br />

The Overlay indicates that the Heritage Place is ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ and<br />

that ‘the heritage place comprises the station building, platform and goods shed and associated land’. The<br />

proposed Comprehensive Development Zone 1 encourages development which incorporates and re-uses the<br />

Station and Goods Shed Buildings as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the open space linkage diagonally across the site. It is also<br />

proposed that the elements <strong>of</strong> secondary heritage significance be encouraged to be incorporated or interpreted<br />

as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a thematic history for development and public open space through the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone. Potential for the presence <strong>of</strong> archaeological remains was also identified.<br />

An Archaeological Heritage Assessment prepared by Biosis Research for the rail corridor has identified with<br />

respect to the land subject <strong>of</strong> this amendment that there has been a high degree <strong>of</strong> disturbance and that a<br />

mandatory Cultural Heritage Management Plan will not be required under the Aboriginal Heritage Act, 2006.<br />

Page 267 <strong>of</strong> 304


e) To protect public utilities and other assets and enable the orderly provision and coordination <strong>of</strong> public<br />

utilities and other facilities for the benefit <strong>of</strong> the community.<br />

The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land has been facilitated by the relocation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station as <strong>part</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> the realignment <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney Rail line. Consequently the land has been identified as<br />

surplus to transport needs and its location and significant size in Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> provide an excellent<br />

opportunity to provide a range <strong>of</strong> commercial, residential and community uses.<br />

Provision is made through the Incorporated Document for the creation <strong>of</strong> new public open spaces and road<br />

extensions, north south through the site. The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land identifies the priority <strong>of</strong> the Watson Street<br />

extension and realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan. This<br />

will enable the diversion <strong>of</strong> through traffic from Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> contributing positively to street activity.<br />

f) To facilitate development in accordance with the objectives set out in the points above.<br />

g) To balance the present and future interests <strong>of</strong> all Victorians.<br />

The amendment has the specific purpose <strong>of</strong> allowing the land to be redeveloped in a manner which supports<br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area and provides a positive contribution to community activity. <strong>Wodonga</strong> is<br />

one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest growing regional towns and forms an important <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Regional Victoria<br />

Settlement Framework. The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land will provide a significant opportunity for commercial and<br />

residential redevelopment which services the existing and future communities <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> and the<br />

surrounding region. The redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land in this manner supports the present and future interest <strong>of</strong><br />

Victorians. The framework for development <strong>of</strong> the land will be set by Places Victoria and will be facilitated<br />

through their ongoing involvement as a referral authority for the approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permit<br />

applications under the Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1. This will aid the delivery <strong>of</strong> a coordinated<br />

and high quality design and land use outcome.<br />

� How does the amendment address the environmental effects and any relevant social and economic<br />

effects?<br />

Rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to the Comprehensive Development Zone enables a wide range <strong>of</strong> land uses to be<br />

established while providing direction for the consolidation <strong>of</strong> more intensive land uses adjoining High Street<br />

and Elgin Boulevard and providing a precinct with a focus for Mixed Use and Medium Density residential<br />

use.<br />

An analysis <strong>of</strong> future market growth for <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre prepared by Pitney Bowes on behalf <strong>of</strong> the<br />

former land owner Victrack and <strong>Wodonga</strong> <strong>City</strong> Council has identified supportable additional retail floor<br />

space, as well as demand for residential hotel accommodation to service the tourist and local business market<br />

within the surrounding region. In <strong>part</strong>icular the former Railway land was identified as attractive for a<br />

discount de<strong>part</strong>ment store and supermarket and a range <strong>of</strong> specialty stores, along with the possibility <strong>of</strong> some<br />

scope for Bulky Goods with a suitable location being the site’s Watson Street frontage.<br />

Over time significant economic benefits are expected to be derived from construction jobs and the flow on<br />

effects to the Regional economy.<br />

The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land and its future redevelopment will have positive social effects removing a sizable<br />

vacant land parcel and providing an improved public experience in the Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business Area.<br />

The environmental effects <strong>of</strong> redeveloping the land have been considered in the amendment through:<br />

� Application <strong>of</strong> the Environmental Audit Overlay to ensure that environmental contamination is suitably<br />

remediated in the event that the land is developed for a sensitive use (including public open space).<br />

� There are no recorded threatened flora or fauna species or remnant patches <strong>of</strong> native vegetation identified<br />

across the site which require protection.<br />

� A number <strong>of</strong> (13 No.) scattered indigenous trees identified across the site and provision has been made<br />

for their possible retention through reference in the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

� Does the amendment comply with the requirements <strong>of</strong> any Minister’s Direction applicable to the<br />

amendment?<br />

The amendment complies with Ministerial Direction 1 – ‘Potentially Contaminated Land’ through the<br />

application <strong>of</strong> the Environmental Audit Overlay.<br />

The amendment is consistent with the Ministerial Direction on the Form and Content <strong>of</strong> Planning Schemes<br />

under Section 7(5) <strong>of</strong> the Act.<br />

The amendment complies with Ministerial Direction 11 – Strategic Assessment <strong>of</strong> Amendments.<br />

Page 268 <strong>of</strong> 304


� How does the amendment support or implement the State Planning Policy Framework?<br />

The State Planning Policy Framework aims to strengthen the network <strong>of</strong> Regional Centres across Victoria<br />

and provide for the concentration <strong>of</strong> retail, residential, commercial, administrative, entertainment and cultural<br />

developments within Activity Centres which provide a variety <strong>of</strong> land uses.<br />

The proposed amendment supports and implements the objectives, strategies and policies <strong>of</strong> the State<br />

Planning Policy Framework. In <strong>part</strong>icular:<br />

� Clause 11.01-2 Activity Centre Planning – Developing the Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> Business Area in a manner<br />

which directs land use and built form outcomes through the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

� Clause 11.05-1 Regional Settlement Networks<br />

o Supporting the development <strong>of</strong> facilities and services.<br />

o Utilising redundant infrastructure land.<br />

� Clause 11.05-4 Regional Planning Strategies and Principles<br />

o Supporting a network <strong>of</strong> integrated and prosperous regional settlements.<br />

o Utilising redundant urban land with limited environmental or heritage constraints.<br />

o Supporting the strategic relocation <strong>of</strong> transport infrastructure consistent with regional plans.<br />

o Supporting the increased growth <strong>of</strong> the regional township through provision <strong>of</strong> opportunities for<br />

employment, community facilities and services that are connected in central locations.<br />

o Encouraging high quality urban and architectural design which enhances the character <strong>of</strong> the<br />

existing township.<br />

o Improving opportunities for a diverse range <strong>of</strong> accommodation in a well serviced location.<br />

o Providing for delivery <strong>of</strong> future development as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> a co-ordinated Framework Plan to be set by<br />

Places Victoria and the ongoing involvement <strong>of</strong> Places Victoria as a referral authority for<br />

applications for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and Permits under the Comprehensive Development<br />

Zone 1.<br />

� Clause 12.01-1 Protection <strong>of</strong> Habitat -Utilising land for urban development which minismises disruption<br />

to native vegetation and plant and animal habitat.<br />

� Clause 12.01-2 Native Vegetation Management - Providing for retention <strong>of</strong> remnant native vegetation<br />

through retention and incorporation in redevelopment.<br />

� Clause 13.03-1 Use <strong>of</strong> Contaminated and Potentially Contaminated Land. - Ensuring that potentially<br />

contaminated land is suitable for its future use through application <strong>of</strong> the Environmental Audit Overlay.<br />

� Cause 15.01-1 Urban Design - Providing for urban environments that are safe, functional and <strong>of</strong> good<br />

quality through incorporation <strong>of</strong> design objectives in the Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1.<br />

� Clause 15.03-1 Heritage Conservation - Planning for inclusion <strong>of</strong> former Railway buildings and the<br />

adoption <strong>of</strong> thematic history in public open space through the Comprehensive Development Zone and<br />

application <strong>of</strong> a site specific Heritage Overlay to the buildings and land <strong>of</strong> identified heritage<br />

significance.<br />

� Clause 15.03-2 Aboriginal Cultural Heritage - Through early assessment <strong>of</strong> Cultural Heritage<br />

Significance.<br />

� Clause 17.01-1 Business - Meeting the communities needs for retail, entertainment, <strong>of</strong>fice and other<br />

community services within the existing activity centre.<br />

� Clause 18.01-1 Land use and transport planning - Supporting improvements to the road network which<br />

allow the diversion <strong>of</strong> through traffic from <strong>Wodonga</strong> Town Centre and planning for pedestrian and<br />

cyclist links integrated with the existing township fabric.<br />

How does the amendment support or implement the Local Planning Policy Framework?<br />

The amendment and the land’s long term redevelopment support the future vision for the consolidation and<br />

revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business District.<br />

Implementation <strong>of</strong> key infrastructure projects identified in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Growth Strategy are central to the<br />

proposed amendment and include the diversion <strong>of</strong> the Hume Freeway, The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail By-pass project<br />

and the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area (CBA) upgrade. In <strong>part</strong>icular the relocation <strong>of</strong> the railway is a<br />

Page 269 <strong>of</strong> 304


project which has been anticipated as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the growth strategy <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> and at Clause 21.05-6 is<br />

identified as ‘an essential element and catalyst in achieving the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the CBA’ and at Clause<br />

21.12 as ‘enabling land to be set aside for commercial development consistent with Clause 21.12.02.’<br />

The proposal to rezone the land contributes to the revitalisation <strong>of</strong> Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> which is identified at<br />

Clause 21.05-1 and Clause 21.05-6 as a key issue. More specifically the MSS at Clause 21.05-5 identifies<br />

that ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> lacks the range <strong>of</strong> facilities and level <strong>of</strong> presentation in the CBA that is typically<br />

representative <strong>of</strong> a regional centre. This is due to the rapid transition <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> for a small country town<br />

to one <strong>of</strong> Victoria’s fastest growing regional centres.’<br />

The long term redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the subject land as <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the upgrade <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is specifically<br />

addressed at Clause 21.11-02 ‘Redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA’ which notes:<br />

‘The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan provides a strategic framework for the future redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and its periphery, with the knowledge that the relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney railway<br />

line is a funded project and will proceed. The Central Area Master Plan recognises the unique opportunity<br />

this provides for the positive transformation <strong>of</strong> the entire central area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. Approximately 19<br />

hectares <strong>of</strong> land will be made available for redevelopment in central <strong>Wodonga</strong> when the rail line is removed.<br />

The master plan is supported by research into important elements including urban design, economic/market<br />

analysis, traffic management, social/community aspirations and environmental constraints. A key principle<br />

for the development <strong>of</strong> the CBA is the need to provide active street frontages ensuring new developments are<br />

street rather pedestrian mall based.’<br />

The proposed rezoning delivers the vision for the priority revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business<br />

Area consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Master Plan (and Clause 21.05-6, Clause 21.11.02 Clause 21.06-<br />

1) through:<br />

� Planning for road projects consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan that support the dispersion<br />

<strong>of</strong> through traffic away from High Street, the creation <strong>of</strong> a pedestrian network across the former railway<br />

land and better links throughout the CBA.<br />

� Supporting the continued upgrade <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and its realignment at High Street.<br />

� Providing opportunities for hotel accommodation and cinema entertainment facilities and the<br />

development <strong>of</strong> a ‘stronger and more vibrant retail base’.<br />

� Supporting the location <strong>of</strong> core retail activities along Elgin Boulevard between Smythe Street and High<br />

Street (including discount de<strong>part</strong>ment stores, full range supermarkets, large format retail outlets and<br />

specialty retail shops) as identified in the Central Business Area Masterplan.<br />

� Allowing discretion in relation to the location, size and type <strong>of</strong> retail uses away from the key frontages<br />

<strong>of</strong> High Street and Elgin Boulevard.<br />

� ‘Supporting retail and mixed uses north <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard between Watson and Smythe Streets’.<br />

� Providing a framework to facilitate development by providing flexibility in land use and built form and<br />

encouraging a streamlined approvals process.<br />

� Giving priority to design for new development to ensure that it contributes to streetscape character and<br />

accommodates glazed shop fronts consistent with the Urban Design principles at Clause 21.06-4.<br />

� Allowing for the integration <strong>of</strong> retail, business and residential uses and the designation <strong>of</strong> a precinct<br />

where residential redevelopment is encouraged attracting a greater diversity <strong>of</strong> housing types and<br />

provision <strong>of</strong> residential aged care (Clause 21.05-9 and Clause 21.06-1 and Clause 21.13-1 ‘Housing’)<br />

� Providing for the car parking rates consistent with the local variation to Clause 52.06.<br />

� Promoting ‘active’ uses at ground level and commercial and residential uses on upper floors.<br />

� Providing for landscape improvements and the creation <strong>of</strong> an Urban Square at the intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin<br />

Boulevard and High Street.<br />

� Does the amendment make proper use <strong>of</strong> the Victoria Planning Provisions?<br />

The amendment proposes to utilise the Comprehensive Development Zone to facilitate the future use and<br />

development <strong>of</strong> the land in a manner which:<br />

o Introduces an Incorporated Document in the Schedule to Clause 81.1 (and the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone) which identifies key road and public open space projects and precinct<br />

objectives and sits within the Framework <strong>of</strong> the Planning Scheme.<br />

Page 270 <strong>of</strong> 304


o Allows for <strong>part</strong>icular land uses to be facilitated or controlled specific to the redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the<br />

subject site.<br />

o Provides for the further preparation <strong>of</strong> a Framework Plans which identify land use and development<br />

in accordance with the Comprehensive Development Plan and purposes <strong>of</strong> the Zone, and which are<br />

supported by reports relating to traffic and vehicle access, landscaping and economic analysis as<br />

necessary.<br />

o Sets out design principals for the preparation <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and for consideration in permit<br />

applications.<br />

o Provides for the adaptive reuse <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and Goods Shed through<br />

the application <strong>of</strong> a site specific Heritage Overlay (HO10).<br />

o Makes Places Victoria a referral authority for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permits under the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

It is proposed that the Design and Development Overlay 4 be deleted from the land subject <strong>of</strong> rezoning in<br />

order to avoid duplication <strong>of</strong> design principles which have been substantially incorporated within the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

It is also proposed to apply the Environmental Audit Overlay to the land consistent with the requirements <strong>of</strong><br />

Ministerial Direction No. 1.<br />

� How does the amendment address the views <strong>of</strong> any relevant agency?<br />

The amendment affects the views <strong>of</strong> Vic Roads with respect to the undertaking <strong>of</strong> road works at the<br />

intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street, and the Watson Street extension. Watson Street and Elgin<br />

Boulevard are both contained in the Road Zone Category 2, while High Street is zoned Road Zone Category<br />

1 for which Vic Roads is the nominated authority. The modifications to Watson Street and realignment <strong>of</strong><br />

Elgin Boulevard are <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the diversion <strong>of</strong> through vehicle traffic away from Central <strong>Wodonga</strong>. In this<br />

context the proposed Incorporated Document and Comprehensive Development Zone enable delivery <strong>of</strong><br />

roads consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy.<br />

The views <strong>of</strong> the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) are relevant with respect to the application <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Environmental Audit Overlay across the land.<br />

The <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> remains the Responsible Authority for administering the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme<br />

and for the consideration Precinct Plans and Planning Permits under the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

The <strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> has been consulted in the preparation <strong>of</strong> the Amendment and through consultation<br />

regarding the preparation <strong>of</strong> a preliminary Framework Plan.<br />

Places Victoria are made a referral authority for approval <strong>of</strong> Precinct Plans and permit applications under the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 1 and through the schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

� Does the amendment address relevant requirements <strong>of</strong> the Transport Integration Act 2010?<br />

The rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land is <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the strategic divestment <strong>of</strong> former rail land (and associated infrastructure)<br />

by the Victorian De<strong>part</strong>ment <strong>of</strong> Transport. The amendment also makes provision for the delivery <strong>of</strong> key road<br />

projects which are <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Regional Transport Plan and will enable the diversion <strong>of</strong> through traffic from<br />

the Hume Highway away from the Central Business Area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>. Consideration has also been given to<br />

the provision <strong>of</strong> new streets connecting to the existing street network through the Incorporated Document and<br />

the planning for pedestrian and cyclist links in preparation <strong>of</strong> the Framework Plan and individual Precinct<br />

Plans.<br />

Resource and administrative costs<br />

� What impact will the new planning provisions have on the resource and administrative costs <strong>of</strong> the<br />

responsible authority?<br />

The amendment will have limited impacts on the resource and administrative costs <strong>of</strong> the responsible<br />

authority. As <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the usual planning process, detail plans and other information submitted in accordance<br />

with the incorporated document and Comprehensive Development Zone will require assessment and<br />

approval.<br />

Page 271 <strong>of</strong> 304


Where you may inspect this Amendment<br />

The amendment is available for public inspection, free <strong>of</strong> charge, during <strong>of</strong>fice hours at the following places:<br />

<strong>City</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

104 Hovell Street<br />

WODONGA 3690<br />

The amendment can also be inspected free <strong>of</strong> charge at the De<strong>part</strong>ment <strong>of</strong> Planning and Community<br />

Development website at www.dpcd.vic.gov.au/planning/publicinspection.<br />

Page 272 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

AMENDMENT C92 INSTRUCTION SHEET<br />

The planning authority for this amendment is the Minister for Planning.<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme is amended as follows:<br />

Planning Scheme Maps<br />

The Planning Scheme Maps are amended by a total <strong>of</strong> 6 attached maps.<br />

Zoning Maps<br />

1. Planning Scheme Map No.s 6 and 7 are amended in the manner shown on the attached maps<br />

marked <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme, Amendment C92.<br />

Overlay<br />

2. Planning Scheme Map No.6 and 7 Design and Development Overlay (DDO) are amended to delete<br />

DDO4 in the manner shown on the attached maps marked <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme,<br />

Amendment C92.<br />

3. Planning Scheme Map No.7 Heritage Overlay (HO) is amended to show HO9 on the maps marked<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme Amendment C92.<br />

4. Insert new Planning Scheme Map No 6 and 7 Environmental Audit Overlay in the manner shown on<br />

the attached maps marked <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme, Amendment C92.<br />

Planning Scheme Ordinance<br />

The Planning Scheme Ordinance is amended as follows:<br />

� Through revisions to the Table <strong>of</strong> Contents to add the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

� Through the introduction <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone Schedule 1 ‘’<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan’ at Clause 37.02.<br />

� Through consequential modifications to Clause 21.11, Clause 21.12 and Clause 22.09 to include<br />

reference to the relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and rezoning <strong>of</strong> the rail land to the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

� Through addition <strong>of</strong> HO10 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard <strong>Wodonga</strong>’ to the Heritage<br />

Overlay Schedule (Clause 43.01).<br />

� Through reference to the inclusion <strong>of</strong> Maps 6 and 7 EAO in the schedule to Clause 61.03 ‘Maps<br />

Comprising Part <strong>of</strong> this Scheme’.<br />

� Through inclusion <strong>of</strong> ‘Places Victoria’ as a referral authority in the schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

� Through inclusion <strong>of</strong> the ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan’ as an incorporated<br />

document in the schedule to Clause 81.01<br />

5. Replace the Table <strong>of</strong> Contents with a new Table <strong>of</strong> Contents in the form <strong>of</strong> the attached document.<br />

6. In Local Planning Policy Framework – replace Clause 21.11 with a new Clause 21.11 in the form <strong>of</strong><br />

the attached document. The changes are contained in Clause 21.11-02 ‘Redevelopment <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA’ as follows:<br />

� Add reference to the relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station.<br />

� Add reference to the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to the Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

Page 273 <strong>of</strong> 304


� Add reference to land being developed generally in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business Area Masterplan and the Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

� Add reference to the realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and the creation <strong>of</strong> an urban square on<br />

land zoned CDZ1 at the corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

7. In Local Planning Policy Framework – replace Clause 21.12 with a new Clause 21.12 in the form <strong>of</strong><br />

the attached document. The changes are contained in Clause 21.12-02 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Facilities<br />

Upgrade’ as follows:<br />

� Add reference to the relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and the rezoning <strong>of</strong> the land to the<br />

Comprehensive Development Zone.<br />

� Add reference to the delivery <strong>of</strong> key road and public open space projects.<br />

8. In Local Planning Policy Framework – replace Clause 22.09 with a new Clause 22.09 in the form <strong>of</strong><br />

the attached document. The changes are as follows:<br />

� Add reference to the Comprehensive Development Zone 1 under where the policy applies.<br />

� Add reference to the relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station.<br />

� Add a policy objective relating to the development <strong>of</strong> the former railway land consistent with the<br />

purposes <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

9. In Zones - insert a new Clause 37.01 ‘Comprehensive Development Zone’ in the form <strong>of</strong> the<br />

attached document.<br />

10. In Zones – following Clause 37.02, insert a new Schedule 1 ‘<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive<br />

Development Plan’ in the form <strong>of</strong> the attached document.<br />

11. In Overlays – following Clause 43.01 ‘Heritage Overlay’, insert a revised Schedule in the form <strong>of</strong> the<br />

attached document.<br />

12. In General Provisions – Clause 61.03 ‘Maps Comprising Part <strong>of</strong> this Scheme’, replace the schedule<br />

with a new schedule in the form <strong>of</strong> the attached document to note the inclusion <strong>of</strong> new Maps 6 and<br />

7 EAO.<br />

13. In General Provisions – Clause 66.04 replace the schedule ‘Referral <strong>of</strong> Permit Applications Under<br />

Local Provisions’ with a new schedule in the form <strong>of</strong> the attached document to include ‘Places’<br />

Victoria as a referral authority<br />

14. In Incorporated Documents – Clause 81.01, replace the schedule with a new schedule in the form<br />

<strong>of</strong> the attached document.<br />

Page 274 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

End <strong>of</strong> document


--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

SCHEDULE 1 TO THE COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE<br />

Shown on the planning scheme map as CDZ1.<br />

WODONGA CENTRAL COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT PLAN<br />

Land<br />

This schedule applies to land generally comprising the former <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station<br />

and associated rail land, <strong>Wodonga</strong> as depicted in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive<br />

Development Plan at Map 1 <strong>of</strong> this Schedule.<br />

Purpose<br />

• To facilitate redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former rail land in <strong>Wodonga</strong> for mixed use<br />

development that supports and enhances the consolidation <strong>of</strong> core retail and<br />

commercial activity within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

• To facilitate use and development in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan objectives and Precinct objectives.<br />

• To facilitate use and development that encourages social interaction, day and night<br />

activity, street surveillance for safety and contributes to the city identity.<br />

• To encourage development <strong>of</strong> buildings with ‘active frontages’ to create a vibrant<br />

pedestrian environment, <strong>part</strong>icularly along Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

• To discourage development where the presentation <strong>of</strong> car parking is dominant.<br />

• To ensure that the construction <strong>of</strong> key road and pedestrian connections and open spaces<br />

integrates the land with the existing urban areas.<br />

• To support the realignment and upgrade <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard as a priority pedestrian<br />

area and retail location.<br />

• To encourage good quality architecture and urban design which contributes to a defined<br />

identity for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

1.0 Table <strong>of</strong> uses<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Section 1 - Permit not required<br />

USE CONDITION<br />

Accommodation (other than Residential Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

hotel, Host Farm, Corrective institution, exceed 2 metres, except in Precinct 4 on<br />

Camping and caravan Park)<br />

‘Map 1’ where it may exceed 2 metres.<br />

Betting agency<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 1 OF 9<br />

Page 275 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Must not be located in Precinct 5 on 'Map 1'.<br />

Child care centre Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 2 metres and access must not be<br />

shared with a dwelling (other than a<br />

Caretaker’s house).


Cinema<br />

Cinema based entertainment facility<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 2 OF 9<br />

In Precincts 1, 2 and 3 on 'Map 1', must not<br />

have a frontage at ground level exceeding 15<br />

metres.<br />

Must not be located in Precinct 5 on 'Map 1'.<br />

Education centre Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 10 metres, except in Precinct 5 on<br />

Map 1 where it may exceed 10 metres.<br />

Must not be a primary or secondary school.<br />

Electoral <strong>of</strong>fice May be used for only 4 months before an<br />

election and 2 weeks after an election<br />

Food and drink premises (other than Hotel<br />

and Tavern)<br />

Home occupation<br />

Informal outdoor recreation<br />

Landscape gardening supplies Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Map 1'.<br />

Minor utility installation<br />

Office (other than Electoral <strong>of</strong>fice) Any frontage at ground floor level must not<br />

exceed 2 metres unless the <strong>of</strong>fice is a bank,<br />

real estate agency, travel agency, or any<br />

other <strong>of</strong>fice where the floor space adjoining<br />

the frontage is a customer service area<br />

accessible to the public.<br />

Postal agency<br />

No restriction on ground floor frontage applies<br />

to a medical centre in precinct 5.<br />

Residential hotel Must be located in Precincts 1, 2, 3 or 4 on<br />

'Map 1'.<br />

Restricted retail premises Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Map 1'.<br />

Shop (other than Adult sex bookshop and In Precinct 1 on ‘Map 1’, the maximum<br />

restricted retail premises<br />

combined leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> a shop<br />

fronting the urban square must not exceed<br />

240 m 2 . In all other areas <strong>of</strong> precinct 1 the<br />

combined leasable floor area must not exceed<br />

2500 m 2<br />

In Precincts 2 and 3 on ‘Map 1’, the combined<br />

leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> shop must not exceed<br />

2500 m².<br />

In Precincts 4 and 5 on ‘Map 1’, the combined<br />

leasable floor area <strong>of</strong> shop in each precinct<br />

must not exceed 1000 m²<br />

Trade supplies (other than Timber yard) Must be located in Precinct 5 on 'Map 1'.<br />

Any use listed in Clause 62.01 Must meet the requirements <strong>of</strong> Clause 62.01.<br />

Page 276 <strong>of</strong> 304


Section 2 – Permit required<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

USE CONDITION<br />

Car wash Must be in Precinct 5 on ‘Map 1’.<br />

Hotel<br />

Industry (other than Car wash and Refuse Must not be for a purpose listed in the table to<br />

disposal)<br />

Clause 52.10.<br />

Leisure and recreation facility (other than Must be located at first floor level in Precincts<br />

Informal outdoor recreation, Major sports 1 and 2 on ‘Map 1’.<br />

and recreation facility, Motor racing track<br />

and Outdoor recreation facility)<br />

Motor vehicle, boat or caravan sales Must be in Precinct 5 on ‘Map 1’.<br />

Place <strong>of</strong> assembly (other than Carnival,<br />

Cinema and Circus,)<br />

Renewable energy facility<br />

Retail premises (other than Betting<br />

agency, Food and drink premises, Hotel,<br />

Landscape gardening supplies, Motor<br />

vehicle, boat or caravan sales, Postal<br />

agency, , Tavern and Trade supplies)<br />

Shop<br />

Tavern<br />

Warehouse (other than Fuel depot)<br />

Any other use not in Section 1 or 3<br />

Section 3 – Prohibited<br />

USE<br />

Adult sex bookshop<br />

Agriculture (other than Apiculture)<br />

Brothel<br />

Camping and caravan park<br />

Cemetery<br />

Corrective institution<br />

Crematorium<br />

Fuel depot<br />

Intensive animal husbandry<br />

Major sports and recreation facility<br />

Motor racing track<br />

Outdoor recreation facility<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 3 OF 9<br />

Page 277 <strong>of</strong> 304<br />

Must not be a purpose listed in the table to<br />

Clause 52.10.


Pleasure boat facility<br />

Refuse disposal<br />

Saleyard<br />

Timber yard<br />

Transport terminal<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

2.0 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

The following objectives correspond with the precincts in ‘Map 1’<strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

Precinct 1<br />

This precinct provides a new urban square with a centre <strong>of</strong> town character. Development<br />

with higher built form and innovative design will define the corner and enhance the urban<br />

square. Ground level activation to the south and east edges <strong>of</strong> new built form will promote<br />

pedestrian activity and integration with the urban square and the intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin<br />

Boulevard and High Street.<br />

Precinct 2<br />

Together with Precinct 1, Precinct 2 is the southern edge to the gateway <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard<br />

and High Street where higher built form, innovative design and and a landmark building is<br />

encouraged. Ground level retail including food and drink premises will take advantage <strong>of</strong><br />

the northern aspect and reinforce the pedestrian focus and transition to High Street.<br />

Precinct 3<br />

This Precinct will <strong>of</strong>fer mixed use development that responds to and enhances the amenity<br />

<strong>of</strong> the central Green Square and heritage buildings as a place for passive recreation and<br />

events. The former rail heritage buildings will be a key focal point through adaptive re-use<br />

and integration with contemporary architecture to enhance <strong>Wodonga</strong>’s identity, amenity<br />

and tourism. Higher built form is encouraged with articulation to protect ground level<br />

amenity.<br />

Precinct 4<br />

This Precinct is to <strong>of</strong>fer mixed use development <strong>of</strong> two to four levels which is<br />

predominantly residential and designed to address and enhance the Green Square. New<br />

development and the Green Square are to respond to and enhance the rail heritage buildings<br />

in Precinct 3.<br />

Precinct 5<br />

Precinct 5 is to provide opportunity for large format mixed use development with<br />

landscaped setbacks. Vehicle, pedestrian and bicycle permeability is to be provide through<br />

the precinct with good connections to the other precincts.<br />

3.0 Framework Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit must not be granted to use or subdivide land, construct a building or construct or<br />

carry out works, other than for works required to remediate the site, until a Framework<br />

Plan for the entire site has been prepared and approved to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible<br />

authority. No public exhibition <strong>of</strong> the Framework Plan is required prior to consideration<br />

by the Responsible Authority.<br />

The Framework Plan must be generally consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan and the objectives at Clause 2.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule and<br />

must include the following to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 4 OF 9<br />

Page 278 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

� The boundary <strong>of</strong> the site and precincts.<br />

� The realignment <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard through the intersection with High Street.<br />

� The northern extension <strong>of</strong> Smythe Street and Watson Street through to South<br />

Street.<br />

� The connection <strong>of</strong> Church Street from Elgin Boulevard to South Street.This<br />

connection may not be a vehicle link for its full extent.<br />

� The provision <strong>of</strong> an open space link following the former rail corridor from the<br />

intersection <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street to the open space in Precinct 4.<br />

� The provision <strong>of</strong> open space central to Precinct 3 and 4 and at the North West<br />

corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street.<br />

� A pedestrian connection linking Elgin Boulevard to Bank Street and the Sumsion<br />

Gardens.<br />

� Other vehicle, bicycle and pedestrian links through the site to the surrounding<br />

streets.<br />

The Framework Plan may be amended to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

4.0 Precinct Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit should not be granted to use or subdivide land, construct a building or construct<br />

or carry out works, until a Precinct Plan for the relevant precinct has been prepared and<br />

approved to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority. The Precinct Plan must be<br />

generally consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan and the<br />

endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

A permit may be granted before the endorsement <strong>of</strong> a Precinct Plan provided that the<br />

responsible authority is satisfied that the use, subdivision or development will not prejudice<br />

the future use or development <strong>of</strong> the land consistent with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Comprehensive Development Plan and the endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

Any precinct plan shall be made available for public inspection at the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Shire<br />

Council for 14 days prior to its consideration by the responsible authority. Before<br />

approving a precinct plan the responsible authority must consider any written comments<br />

received in response to the display <strong>of</strong> the precinct plan.<br />

A Precinct Plan must show or include the following (in the form <strong>of</strong> reports or plans), as<br />

appropriate to the precinct, to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority:<br />

• The location, height, dimension, floor area and use <strong>of</strong> all buildings and works.<br />

• The provision for car parking, public transport facilities, loading requirements waste<br />

storage, collection and loading<br />

• The location <strong>of</strong> all open spaces available to the public.<br />

• A landscape concept plan, including landscaping proposed for vehicle, bicycle and<br />

pedestrian links and open spaces.<br />

• The location <strong>of</strong> all open spaces available to the public<br />

• In Precincts 3 and 4 the conservation and adaptive re-use <strong>of</strong> the former <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Railway Station building and Goods Shed and their integration with surrounding<br />

buildings and open space.<br />

• The stages in which the precinct is to be developed.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 5 OF 9<br />

Page 279 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

• The provision <strong>of</strong> a reticulated water supply, sewerage, electricity and<br />

telecommunications.<br />

A Precinct Plan may be amended to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

The land use and development objectives <strong>of</strong> each Precinct are:<br />

Precinct 1<br />

The land use and development objectives <strong>of</strong> this Precinct are:<br />

• To create an urban square with a centre <strong>of</strong> town identity with high quality urban<br />

design that incorporates rail heritage and urban art.<br />

• The urban square to be designed to be a central <strong>meeting</strong> place which has good<br />

pedestrian linkages to other precincts and High Street, <strong>of</strong>fers good solar amenity<br />

and weather protection and encourages day and night activity.<br />

• To provide innovative design and higher built form <strong>of</strong> a minimum <strong>of</strong> two storeys<br />

height with ground level activation to the south and east to define the corner and<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer a distinctive entry to town.<br />

• Built form is to protect and enhance the amenity <strong>of</strong> the urban square through<br />

ground level activation and integration with the square.<br />

• Slow traffic movement encourage along Church Street to enhance pedestrian<br />

connection between Precinct 1 and 3.<br />

Precinct 2<br />

• To provide higher built form <strong>of</strong> a minimum <strong>of</strong> two storeys to define the corner and<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer a distinctive gateway entry to town.<br />

• To encourage a landmark development with ground level retailing which responds<br />

to the northern aspect.<br />

• New built form and public open spaces to be designed to encourage pedestrian<br />

transition into the Precinct 2 and Precinct 1.<br />

Precinct 3<br />

• Built form, open space and road design to reinforce a pedestrian priority character<br />

to the precinct and encourage slow traffic movements.<br />

• To provide vehicle and pedestrian linkages to South Street.<br />

• Development to be orientated to address open spaces and minimise the extent <strong>of</strong><br />

blank walls.<br />

• To encourage mixed use development that responds to and enhances:<br />

- the pedestrian link to the Urban Square;<br />

- the Green Square<br />

- the rail heritage buildings<br />

• Open space and the heritage buildings to be designed to integrate with and provide<br />

a setting for the heritage buildings.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 6 OF 9<br />

Page 280 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

• Heritage buildings to be used and viewed in the round.<br />

• Rear loading areas <strong>of</strong> commercial and retail is to be located away from and<br />

screened to the Green Square.<br />

• Higher Built form with zero street setbacks and ground level activation to Elgin<br />

Boulevard.<br />

Precinct 4<br />

• To encourage development <strong>of</strong> 2-3 storeys which has landscaped setbacks and is<br />

orientated to address the Green Square.<br />

• The Green Square to <strong>of</strong>fer passive recreation, a place for large events and good<br />

vehicle and pedestrian linkages to South Street and Smythe Street.<br />

• Development facing South Street to have a rear vehicle access.<br />

Precinct 5<br />

5.0 Use <strong>of</strong> land<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

• A location for large format buldings.<br />

• New development to address Watson, South and Smythe Streets.<br />

• Lalor Place to be used for loading access.<br />

• Vehicle access is encouraged from Watson Street and Smyth Street and Lalor<br />

Place.<br />

• Pedestrian and bicycle permeability through the site encouraged.<br />

The use <strong>of</strong> land must be generally consistent with the purposes <strong>of</strong> the schedule and, the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan, the precinct objectives at Clause 2.0<br />

<strong>of</strong> this schedule, the endorsed Framework Plan and any relevant endorsed Precinct Plan to<br />

the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

An application to use land must be accompanied by the following information.<br />

• A description <strong>of</strong> the proposed use and the types <strong>of</strong> activities which will be carried out<br />

and any proposed staging <strong>of</strong> use and activities on the land.<br />

• Plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the siting and use <strong>of</strong> buildings;<br />

° areas not required for immediate use;<br />

° adjacent buildings and uses.<br />

• The likely effects, if any, on adjoining land, including noise levels, traffic, the hours <strong>of</strong><br />

delivery and despatch <strong>of</strong> goods and materials, hours <strong>of</strong> operation and light spill, solar<br />

access, glare, air-borne emissions and emissions to land and water.<br />

• If an industry or warehouse:<br />

° the type and quantity <strong>of</strong> goods to be stored, processed or produced;<br />

° whether a Works Approval or Waste Discharge Licence is required from the<br />

Environment Protection Authority;<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 7 OF 9<br />

Page 281 <strong>of</strong> 304


6.0 Subdivision<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

° whether a notification under the Occupational Health and Safety (Major Hazard<br />

Facilities) Regulations 2000 is required, a licence under the Dangerous Goods Act<br />

1995 is required, or a fire protection quantity under the Dangerous Goods (Storage<br />

and Handling) Regulations 2000 is exceeded.<br />

A permit is required to subdivide land.<br />

7.0 Creation <strong>of</strong> access to Elgin Boulevard<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit is required to create or alter access to Elgin Boulevard.<br />

8.0 Buildings and works<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

A permit is required to construct a building or to construct or carry out works.<br />

Any permit granted must be generally consistent with the purposes <strong>of</strong> the zone and<br />

schedule, the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan, the precinct objectives<br />

at Clause 3.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule, the endorsed Framework Plan and any relevant endorsed<br />

Precinct Plan to the satisfaction <strong>of</strong> the responsible authority.<br />

An application to construct a building or construct or carry out works must be accompanied<br />

by the following information, as appropriate.<br />

• Plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the boundaries and dimensions <strong>of</strong> the site;<br />

° adjoining roads;<br />

° the location, height and use <strong>of</strong> buildings and works on adjoining land;<br />

° levels <strong>of</strong> the site and the difference in levels between the site and surrounding<br />

properties to a defined point at the site boundaries or to Australian Height Datum<br />

(AHD);<br />

° any contaminated soils and filled areas, where known;<br />

° the layout <strong>of</strong> existing and proposed buildings and works;<br />

° the internal layout and use <strong>of</strong> the proposed development;<br />

° all access and pedestrian areas;<br />

° all driveway, car parking and loading areas;<br />

° existing vegetation and proposed landscape areas;<br />

° all external storage and waste treatment areas;<br />

° the location <strong>of</strong> easements and services.<br />

• Elevation plans drawn to scale and dimensioned which show:<br />

° the building form and scale;<br />

° setbacks to property boundaries;<br />

° finished floor levels and building heights to a defined point at the site boundaries or<br />

to Australian Height Datum (AHD).<br />

• Shadow diagrams based on the equinox shown for existing conditions and the proposed<br />

development.<br />

• A schedule <strong>of</strong> finishes for the proposed development detailing materials and colours <strong>of</strong><br />

external surfaces including walls, ro<strong>of</strong>s and fences.<br />

• A landscape plan which includes the description <strong>of</strong> vegetation to be planted, the<br />

surfaces to be constructed, site works specification and method <strong>of</strong> preparing, draining,<br />

watering and maintaining the landscape area.<br />

• Construction details <strong>of</strong> all drainage works, driveways, vehicle parking and loading<br />

areas.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 8 OF 9<br />

Page 282 <strong>of</strong> 304


9.0 Car parking<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

The design and provision <strong>of</strong> parking should assist in the overall function, safety and<br />

appearance <strong>of</strong> all Precincts.<br />

The design <strong>of</strong> car parks will contribute to the amenity <strong>of</strong> the area by:<br />

• Car parks not being the dominant visual presentation <strong>of</strong> new development.<br />

• Large car parking areas to be concealed behind active uses or within buildings, in<br />

<strong>part</strong>icular along Elgin Boulevard, High Street and the northern extension <strong>of</strong> Smythe<br />

Street.<br />

• Sensitively locating car park entries.<br />

• Providing well designed exteriors to multi-deck car parks that do not detrimentally<br />

effect adjacent streetscapes.<br />

• At grade car parking to incorporate landscape treatments and provision for pedestrian<br />

access that enhances the streetscape presentation.<br />

• Service areas and loading bays to be incorporated in the building design, and screened<br />

from public view.<br />

• Being safe and secure both internally and externally.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 9 OF 9<br />

Page 283 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

10.0 Requirement for an environmental audit<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Before a sensitive use commences or before the construction or carrying out <strong>of</strong> buildings<br />

and works in association with a sensitive use commences, either:<br />

• a certificate <strong>of</strong> environment audit must be issued for the land in accordance with Part<br />

IXD <strong>of</strong> the Environment Protection Act, 1970; or<br />

• an environmental auditor appointed under the Environment Protection Act, 1970 must<br />

make a statement in accordance with Part IXD <strong>of</strong> that Act that the environmental<br />

conditions <strong>of</strong> the land are suitable for the sensitive use.<br />

In this schedule, a sensitive use means a residential use, childcare centre, a pre-school, a<br />

primary school or public open space.<br />

11.0 Referral <strong>of</strong> applications<br />

An application to approve a Precinct Plan or for a permit to use, develop or subdivide land<br />

identified within the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan must be referred,<br />

in accordance with Section 55 <strong>of</strong> the Act, to the referral authority (Places Victoria)<br />

specified in the Schedule to Clause 66.04.<br />

12.0 Exemption from notice and review<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

An application under any provision <strong>of</strong> this scheme which is generally in accordance with<br />

an endorsed Precinct Plan is exempt from the notice requirements <strong>of</strong> Section 52(1)(a), (b)<br />

(c) and (d), the decision requirements <strong>of</strong> Section 64(1), (2) and (3) and the review rights <strong>of</strong><br />

Section 82(1) <strong>of</strong> the Act.<br />

13.0 Decision guidelines<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Before deciding on an application for approval <strong>of</strong> a Precinct Plan or a permit, in addition to<br />

the decision guidelines at Clauses 37.02-2, 37.02-3 and 37.02-4, the responsible authority<br />

must consider, as appropriate.<br />

• The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Comprehensive Development Plan.<br />

• The purpose <strong>of</strong> the zone and schedule.<br />

• The precinct objectives at Clause 2.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

• The endorsed Framework Plan.<br />

• Any relevant endorsed Precinct Plan.<br />

• The design principles at Clause 9.0 <strong>of</strong> this schedule.<br />

• The provisions <strong>of</strong> Clause 54 and 55.<br />

14.0 Advertising signs<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

Advertising sign requirements are at Clause 52.05. The land in this schedule is in Category<br />

1.<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 10 OF 9<br />

Page 284 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

15.0 Map 1 to Schedule 1 to the Comprehensive Development Zone: <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Central Comprehensive Development Plan<br />

--/--/20--<br />

C--<br />

COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT ZONE – SCHEDULE1 PAGE 11 OF 9<br />

Page 285 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 286 <strong>of</strong> 304


21.11 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT<br />

23/09/2010<br />

C76<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

The economic development vision for <strong>Wodonga</strong> is to be a leading national centre for<br />

industry, commerce and tourism. To implement this vision, a number <strong>of</strong> planning<br />

strategies in key areas are being actively pursued.<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> has enjoyed sustained economic growth over the last twenty-five years. This<br />

growth has been generated through an expanded employment base, <strong>part</strong>icularly<br />

manufacturing, retail, education, construction, tourism, commerce, recreation and personal<br />

services.<br />

Continued strengthening <strong>of</strong> the economic base is necessary so the city can adjust to<br />

structural economic changes in both the national and global economy. The city will<br />

continue to work towards building an economic and business environment conducive to<br />

stimulating growth opportunities for local business, growing tourism and attracting new<br />

employment. Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong>'s strategic location on the Hume corridor between Sydney<br />

and Melbourne in a quality lifestyle and environmental region provides sustainable growth<br />

potential for <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

21.11-01 Activity Centres Strategy<br />

23/09/2010<br />

C76<br />

The continued population growth in <strong>Wodonga</strong> has increased the potential for retail<br />

expansion in the CBA. In recent years, there has been modest expansion in retail floor<br />

space in <strong>Wodonga</strong> with the expansion <strong>of</strong> the Birallee Shopping Centre and expansion <strong>of</strong><br />

bulky goods outlets. Peripheral sales/bulky goods and service industries have proliferated<br />

along the major arterial roads including the northern precinct <strong>of</strong> High St, Melbourne Rd,<br />

Osburn St and sections <strong>of</strong> Thomas Mitchell Drive.<br />

The main retail strategies for <strong>Wodonga</strong> can be summarised as follows:<br />

� The <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is the primary centre and activity node for retail, commerce and<br />

entertainment use and development, the type <strong>of</strong> retail development to be encouraged is<br />

detailed in clause 21.11-02.<br />

� The Birallee Shopping Centre will remain a neighbourhood shopping centre providing<br />

retail and commercial services that serve the convenience requirements <strong>of</strong> West<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� A neighbourhood activity centre has been identified to service the Enterprise Park area<br />

in North West <strong>Wodonga</strong> inclusive <strong>of</strong> a supermarket. The centre is required to be a street<br />

based centre, where the buildings are developed to the street edge with <strong>of</strong>f street parking<br />

areas and a proposed supermarket sleeved behind the premises fronting the street. This<br />

may include buildings <strong>of</strong> two or more storeys, generally providing for smaller<br />

businesses rather than larger occupancies. The centre will also include a mix <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fice<br />

and business uses between the retail uses and La Trobe University. In supporting the<br />

vibrancy <strong>of</strong> this centre the Council will encourage a mix <strong>of</strong> cafés and restaurants to<br />

support the residents, employees and students in the area.<br />

� A future town centre has been identified for development prior to 2016 at North Leneva,<br />

north <strong>of</strong> the intersection <strong>of</strong> Beechworth Rd and Baranduda Boulevard. During its initial<br />

stages <strong>of</strong> development, the centre will be limited to the scale <strong>of</strong> a neighbourhood<br />

activity centre and will be reviewed to increase in size commensurate with the growth<br />

<strong>of</strong> its immediate catchment. The centre is required to be a street based centre, where the<br />

buildings are developed to the street edge with <strong>of</strong>f street parking areas and the proposed<br />

supermarket sleeved behind the premises fronting the street.<br />

� A neighbourhood activity centre has been identified for the former defence land known<br />

as the White Box Rise Estate to service the south eastern neighbourhoods <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

The centre is required to be a street based centre, where the buildings are developed to<br />

the street edge with <strong>of</strong>f street parking areas and a supermarket sleeved behind the<br />

premises fronting the street.<br />

� Additional neighbourhood activity centres have been identified to service the planned<br />

residential growth <strong>of</strong> East <strong>Wodonga</strong> and Killara when these areas are developed. The<br />

centres identified for both Killara and East <strong>Wodonga</strong> will be the subject <strong>of</strong> further<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 1 OF 9<br />

Page 287 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

analysis undertaken through the preparation <strong>of</strong> more detailed structure plans and<br />

economic analysis. Each <strong>of</strong> these proposed centres will be limited in scale to serve their<br />

respective neighbourhood clusters and ensure they are developed to fulfil a daily<br />

convenience role.<br />

� A small range supermarket may be permitted in the Mixed Use Zone within the<br />

Baranduda township to service the convenience needs <strong>of</strong> this community.<br />

� The zoning <strong>of</strong> land in High St north from South St to the Lincoln Causeway will be<br />

reviewed to provide the opportunity for a more mixed form <strong>of</strong> development<br />

incorporating commercial <strong>of</strong>fices, residential development and peripheral retailing<br />

activities. A policy is to be applied to ensure that shops are limited in this area and the<br />

area is maintained for peripheral rather than core retailing activities.<br />

� A second town centre is planned for the Leneva growth corridor and is indicated on the<br />

Leneva Structure Plan on the southern side Middle Creek. This future commercial area<br />

will serve as the secondary centre to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and will not be developed until<br />

there is a minimum <strong>of</strong> 4,000 dwellings in the Leneva Valley to ensure the North Leneva<br />

centre remains viable. Development <strong>of</strong> this secondary centre and its adjacent land will<br />

occur in accordance with, and only after, a detailed master plan prepared specifically for<br />

the Baranduda Town Centre and its surrounding land.<br />

� New freestanding shopping centres, including free standing supermarkets or<br />

neighbourhood centres (excluding convenience shops) will only be supported in the<br />

locations specified in this clause.<br />

For the purpose <strong>of</strong> this clause:<br />

� A neighbourhood activity centre is described as a local convenience based shopping<br />

precinct with a limited commercial catchment and no larger than 3000 square metres in<br />

combined trade-able floor area or as otherwise specified in the schedule to clauses 32.04<br />

and 34.01.<br />

Bulky goods and large format retail uses will be encouraged in the following locations:<br />

� the <strong>Wodonga</strong> central area in accordance with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan<br />

2006;<br />

� Anzac Parade/Murray Valley Highway at the intersection with the Bandiana Link Rd<br />

and adjoining land on the proposed extension <strong>of</strong> Pearce St.<br />

Bulky goods retailing will be generally discouraged in locations other than those specified<br />

in this clause.<br />

Peripheral retail outlets, trade supplies and showrooms are located at the northern end <strong>of</strong><br />

High Street, sections <strong>of</strong> Thomas Mitchell Drive and Melbourne Road. Expansion <strong>of</strong> these<br />

land uses will be investigated in the following locations:<br />

� The north side <strong>of</strong> Melbourne Road from Kelly Street to Melrose Drive.<br />

� Osburn Street from Hovell Street through to the Bandiana Link Road<br />

21.11-02 Redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA (Refer to Figure 9)<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

The upgrade and revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA is one <strong>of</strong> the Council’s key strategic<br />

initiatives. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan provides a strategic framework for the<br />

future redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and its periphery. Following the , with the<br />

knowledge that the relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney railway line the former<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land were rezoned to facilitate redevelopment<br />

<strong>of</strong> the land consistent with the broad objectives for the Central Business Areais a funded<br />

project and will proceed. The Central Area Master Plan and Comprehensive Development<br />

Zone 1 ‘Central <strong>Wodonga</strong> - Redevelopment <strong>of</strong> Former Rail Land’ recognises the unique<br />

opportunity this provides for the positive transformation <strong>of</strong> the entire central area <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>. Approximately 19 hectares <strong>of</strong> land will be made available for redevelopment in<br />

central <strong>Wodonga</strong> when the rail line is removed. The master plan is supported by research<br />

into important elements including urban design, economic/market analysis, traffic<br />

management, social/community aspirations and environmental constraints. A key principle<br />

for the development <strong>of</strong> the CBA is the need to provide active street frontages ensuring new<br />

developments are street rather pedestrian mall based.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 2 OF 9<br />

Page 288 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

Strategic Actions<br />

� Implement the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan 2006 and adopted urban design<br />

guidelines for the built form <strong>of</strong> development within the central area <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� Continue to plan for the relocation <strong>of</strong> theRezone the Melbourne to Sydney Railway<br />

Line and redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the former railway land to the Comprehensive Development<br />

Zone 1 (CDZ1) to facilitate redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land in a manner generally consistent<br />

with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan and support the delivery <strong>of</strong> key road<br />

projects.<br />

� Dispersion <strong>of</strong> through traffic away from High St and establishment <strong>of</strong> a permeable<br />

interconnected road and pedestrian network across the former railway land and<br />

throughout the CBA.<br />

� The intensification <strong>of</strong> the CBA will be encouraged within the Business 1, Business 2<br />

and Mixed Use Zones concentrated around the CBA through multi storeyed mixed use<br />

development encouraged up to six storeys in preference to single storey development<br />

sprawling beyond the core area <strong>of</strong> central <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� Encourage core retailing activities to develop along Elgin Boulevard between Smythe<br />

St and High St including the former railway land, including discount de<strong>part</strong>ment stores,<br />

full range supermarkets, large format retail outlets and speciality retail shops<br />

� Encourage supporting retail and mixed uses north <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard between Watson<br />

and Smythe Streets.<br />

� Active promotion <strong>of</strong> mixed use development opportunities that encourage retail activity<br />

at the street level with commercial and residential uses on upper floor levels.<br />

� All streets in the CBA will provide a continuous active edge at the street frontage, with<br />

buildings built to the property line and car parking sleeved behind development.<br />

� Buildings in Elgin Boulevard and High St (as shown on the master plan) should be built<br />

to a minimum two storey scale to provide an attractive architectural scale to these street<br />

frontages.<br />

� All buildings in High St and Elgin Boulevard must have a frontage to those streets and<br />

have a minimum 60% glazed and transparent shopfront.<br />

� Landmark styled buildings as detailed in urban design guidelines supporting the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan and the Comprehensive Development Zone 1 are to<br />

be developed at the intersections <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and Watson St and Elgin<br />

Boulevard and High St.<br />

� Good public transport linkages between the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA and the new railway station<br />

on Melrose Drive, <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� Through traffic will be dispersed away from High St and the street redeveloped to<br />

provide additional car parking, improved safety, accessibility and amenity for<br />

pedestrians.<br />

� Realign Elgin Boulevard at its intersection with High Street and develop the north west<br />

corner (within the land zoned CDZ1) for an urban square.<br />

� The presence and pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the civic precinct will be reinforced through redevelopment<br />

and landscape improvements.<br />

� Car parking areas will be consolidated into large parking areas within each retail<br />

precinct, in preference to small site specific car parks.<br />

� Multi storey development will be supported by strategically located deck car parking<br />

provided in locations sleeved behind development.. Car parking including deck car<br />

parking may be located at the street edge where it is incorporated into the façade <strong>of</strong> a<br />

building and located at the first floor level or above (as detailed in urban design<br />

guidelines for the CBA).<br />

� Opportunities will be provided for large format/bulky goods retailing to occur in and<br />

around the periphery <strong>of</strong> the CBA as identified in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master<br />

Plan and the Comprehensive Development Zone 1.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 3 OF 9<br />

Page 289 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

� Pedestrian linkages between car parks and activity nodes will be improved and actively<br />

fronted where practical.<br />

� Encourage high quality medium density residential units to be developed in the<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA.<br />

� Ensure good urban design and architectural quality in the built for with the CBA to<br />

assist in creating ‘a sense <strong>of</strong> place’ and making <strong>Wodonga</strong> an attractive centre.<br />

� Support private and public investment in the CBA that contributes towards <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

becoming a regional centre <strong>of</strong> significance.<br />

� Encourage good urban design to develop the centre with active streets incorporating<br />

public art and cultural themes into the CBA.<br />

� Encourage two and three storey residential development within the precinct bounded by<br />

Watson/Stanley/Hume and Lawrence streets, in preference to single storey residential<br />

development options.<br />

� Implement design and streetscape improvement plans to provide an effective pedestrian<br />

linkage and actively fronted linear park connection from Elgin Boulevard to South St<br />

through to the Sumsion Gardens.<br />

� The zones and overlays in this planning scheme will be reviewed to ensure the delivery<br />

<strong>of</strong> the directions provided in this clause in respect <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master<br />

Plan 2006.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 4 OF 9<br />

Page 290 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

Figure 9 - <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 5 OF 9<br />

Page 291 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.11 PAGE 6 OF 9<br />

Page 292 <strong>of</strong> 304


21.12 INFRASTRUCTURE<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

The city will take a leading role in planning and facilitating the provision <strong>of</strong> infrastructure<br />

which satisfies the needs <strong>of</strong> a growing city. This strategy outlines a number <strong>of</strong><br />

infrastructure projects planned or under implementation by the <strong>council</strong> and other public<br />

sector agencies.<br />

These projects reinforce the vision and land use strategy for <strong>Wodonga</strong> and include:<br />

� The relocation <strong>of</strong> the Melbourne to Sydney rail line from the CBA, the closure <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Bandiana Rail line and the construction <strong>of</strong> a new freight node at Logic <strong>Wodonga</strong>;<br />

� The provision <strong>of</strong> an outer ring roads’ system and other roads’ projects in accordance<br />

with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan;<br />

� The upgrade <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA; and,<br />

� The continued development and expansion <strong>of</strong> Logic <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

21.12-01 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan (Refer to Figure 12)<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

The completion <strong>of</strong> the $40 million ring roads’ project and improvement <strong>of</strong> the major road<br />

network will improve the efficiency, safety and amenity <strong>of</strong> traffic movement in <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

Traffic management works are a major component toward the improvement and<br />

revitalisation <strong>of</strong> the CBA. The road strategy recognises roads as an essential element <strong>of</strong> the<br />

city which is best planned in advance <strong>of</strong> development. Arterial or main roads throughout<br />

the city where they adjoin urban development are to be actively fronted with development<br />

rather than lined with sound mounds or rear <strong>of</strong> lot fencing.<br />

Features <strong>of</strong> the Road Strategy Plan include:<br />

� An inter-connected network <strong>of</strong> streets in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA will aid in the distribution<br />

<strong>of</strong> traffic and spread traffic loads across a number <strong>of</strong> road routes rather than a <strong>part</strong>icular<br />

designated route. The provision <strong>of</strong> a permeable central road network in accordance with<br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan 2006 will allow for the dispersion <strong>of</strong> through<br />

traffic away from High St and the conversion <strong>of</strong> the street into a car parking, shopping<br />

and pedestrian precinct;<br />

� Feature roundabouts will be used throughout the city as the preferred intersection<br />

treatment;<br />

� Elgin St will continue to be developed into a tree lined boulevard and realigned at High<br />

St to link with the eastern leg <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard;<br />

� The Murray Valley Highway will be redirected to the Hume Freeway via the Bandiana<br />

Link Rd to Anzac Parade;<br />

� The Hume Freeway extension through Albury provides strategic advantages for<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> providing a second river crossing and improved access to and from Albury<br />

and Lavington;<br />

� As <strong>part</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> Hume Highway Bypass, a link to the Murray Valley<br />

Highway has been provided through the Bandiana Link Rd. The extension <strong>of</strong> Osburn St<br />

(including William Page Drive) is proposed to provide an east-west link from the<br />

Bandiana Link Rd, improving access to the Kendall Industrial Estate and facilitating<br />

residential development east <strong>of</strong> the Bandiana Link Rd and Light Industrial development<br />

to the west <strong>of</strong> Bandiana Link Road. Funding for this road will be provided by these<br />

benefiting properties;<br />

� Pearce St will be extended to link with the Bandiana Link Rd via Victoria Cross Parade,<br />

serving as the eastern leg <strong>of</strong> the outer ring road and providing for traffic travelling to<br />

and from Beechworth Rd to Albury. This will provide further relief to the CBA and<br />

address the traffic requirements resulting from growth in the Leneva (Middle Creek)<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 1 OF 6<br />

Page 293 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

growth corridor. Improved access to the Bandiana Link Rd and Hume Freeway will<br />

provide opportunities for further light industrial development at the eastern end <strong>of</strong><br />

Victoria Cross Parade;<br />

� Felltimber Creek Rd, Parkers Rd and Moorefield Park Rd will continue to provide main<br />

road linkages to the outer ring roads, Hume Freeway and CBD;<br />

� Linkage from the Hume Freeway to West <strong>Wodonga</strong> will be improved by the<br />

realignment and extension <strong>of</strong> Drages Rd to the McKoy St/Hume Freeway intersection.<br />

This new western link road will be provided in conjunction with the establishment <strong>of</strong><br />

Enterprise Park in West <strong>Wodonga</strong>;<br />

� Access to Baranduda has been upgraded through the construction <strong>of</strong> the Baranduda<br />

Boulevard that reinforces Leneva as the principle growth corridor for <strong>Wodonga</strong>. This<br />

road will be duplicated to provide four traffic lanes when future traffic loads warrant a<br />

major upgrade to the road;<br />

� Yarralumla Drive will be extended to Beechworth Rd to link West <strong>Wodonga</strong> to the<br />

Leneva growth corridor;<br />

� A major initiative <strong>of</strong> the Road Strategy plan is to beautify all major entry roads into<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> and major intersections;<br />

� Main road classifications are to be consistent with the Road Strategy Plan and VicRoads<br />

Access Management Strategies;<br />

� Further planning work is required in consultation with Vicroads to make provision for<br />

the future duplication <strong>of</strong> the Kiewa Valley Highway from the Murray Valley Highway<br />

to Baranduda Drive;<br />

� Commensurate with the development <strong>of</strong> Logic <strong>Wodonga</strong> and growth in traffic volumes,<br />

the Murray Valley Highway will eventually require duplication (in approximately 20 to<br />

30 years time)south <strong>of</strong> Logic Boulevard to the Hume Freeway Interchange; and,<br />

� As identified on the Leneva Structure Plan, Beechworth Rd is proposed to be duplicated<br />

from Huon Creek Rd to Yarralumla Drive/Streets Rd roundabout to cater for future<br />

increases in traffic generated by growth in the Leneva Valley and Indigo Shire.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 2 OF 6<br />

Page 294 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

FIGURE 12: <strong>Wodonga</strong> Road Strategy Plan<br />

21.12-02 <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Facilities’ Upgrade<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

At an estimated cost <strong>of</strong> $70 million, the rail project is a major initiative that the <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Council has received federal and state government funding commitments for. Figure 13<br />

illustrates the major components <strong>of</strong> the rail project and the new alignment proposed for the<br />

rail line. The new rail alignment is now in the ownership <strong>of</strong> the Victorian Rail Track<br />

Corporation and is identified in the planning scheme as a Public Use Zone. Following<br />

relocation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, the former Station and associated rail land (in the<br />

Central Business Area) were rezoned to the Comprehensive Development Zone 1 to<br />

facilitate redevelopment <strong>of</strong> the land and provide for delivery <strong>of</strong> key road and public open<br />

space projects.<br />

In addition to providing up to 19 hectares <strong>of</strong> land for future commercial development, the<br />

project will be instrumental to the upgrade <strong>of</strong> the CBA, removing the physical barrier and<br />

traffic delays experienced due to approximately 40 daily train movements.<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Council will continue to work in <strong>part</strong>nership with the state and federal<br />

governments to plan for and maximise the opportunities arising from this project.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 3 OF 6<br />

Page 295 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

Figure 13 – Albury <strong>Wodonga</strong> Rail Facilities’ Upgrade<br />

21.12-03 Water and Waste Water Services<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

The region’s water and wastewater services are managed by North East Region Water<br />

Corporation, which has a shared approach with the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Council on the future growth<br />

and servicing requirements for <strong>Wodonga</strong> and its outlying areas.<br />

The Corporation regularly carries out investigations into water supply and wastewater<br />

demand, and develops master plans and strategies for <strong>meeting</strong> those demands. The<br />

authority’s Water Supply Demand Strategy, 2007 (WSDS) and the State Government White<br />

Paper, Our Water Our Future, provide policy direction for provision <strong>of</strong> water resources.<br />

Water<br />

The <strong>Wodonga</strong> water supply system services more than 14,000 connections and includes<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>, Kiewa, Tangambalanga, Ebden, Bonegilla, Baranduda and Killara. The supply is<br />

sourced from the regulated Murray-Darling Basin system. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> water treatment<br />

plant is situated at East <strong>Wodonga</strong>, with its intake located at the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Creek, an<br />

anabranch <strong>of</strong> the Murray River.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 4 OF 6<br />

Page 296 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

North East Region Water Corporation recently constructed additional water storage tanks in<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> to cater for growing demand and increase to water security. The <strong>Wodonga</strong> water<br />

treatment plant is being enlarged and additional water entitlement is being purchased to<br />

provide for increased demand.<br />

State government water reform requirements (Our Water Our Future) to conserve water are<br />

being applied by North East Region Water Corporation. This is being facilitated by the<br />

implementation <strong>of</strong> conservation measures recommended in the Authority’s Water Supply<br />

Demand Strategy 2007 (WSDS). The <strong>council</strong> supports North East Water in the<br />

implementation <strong>of</strong> initiatives for the better use and re-use <strong>of</strong> water. This includes<br />

additional infrastructure in existing areas and in new developments for the future supply <strong>of</strong><br />

reclaimed water for non-potable reuse.<br />

These actions and strategies are addressed in the following reports:<br />

1. Master Plan for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Water Supply System – Final Report and Volume II -<br />

Appendices – Gordon Gibson Nominees Pty Ltd - March 2002. (The Master Plan identifies<br />

optimum strategies to resolve existing system problems and provides for the servicing <strong>of</strong><br />

projected growth in urban development).<br />

2. Leneva Valley Development – Servicing Strategies and Functional Design for Water<br />

and Wastewater – Kellogg Brown & root Pty Ltd – <strong>December</strong> 2005. (The report provides<br />

water supply and sewerage servicing strategies and functional design for the various stages<br />

<strong>of</strong> the proposed Leneva Valley development).<br />

3. Water Supply Demand Strategy (WSDS) PBJ & Associates Pty Ltd – April 2007. (This<br />

strategy is a key outcome <strong>of</strong> the Victorian Government’s Our Water Our Future action plan.<br />

It aims to secure urban water supplies throughout the region, meet increase demand for<br />

water arising from population and industry growth and effectively manage the effects <strong>of</strong><br />

climate change and other environmental factors. The strategy has a 50 year perspective and<br />

will be reviewed every five years.<br />

Waste Water and Recycled Water<br />

Currently <strong>Wodonga</strong> is serviced by two wastewater treatment plants, at <strong>Wodonga</strong> West and<br />

Baranduda. The major capacity exists at <strong>Wodonga</strong> West which, with progressive<br />

upgrading in line with loading requirements, has the potential capacity to service long term<br />

residential and industrial growth demands. The Baranduda plant will have a minor role in<br />

wastewater service demands. North East Region Water Corporation is continually<br />

investigating the beneficial uses <strong>of</strong> recycled water and bio-solids.<br />

These actions and strategies are addressed in the following reports:<br />

1. <strong>Wodonga</strong> Wastewater Management Strategy – Master Plan – Summary Report, Volume<br />

1 and Volume 2 – Kinhill Pty Ltd – March 1999. (The intent <strong>of</strong> the Master Plan is to<br />

provide a comprehensive plan for augmentation <strong>of</strong> the sewerage system to service growth<br />

in the existing and developing areas, and to meet EPA requirements for wastewater<br />

treatment and effluent disposal or re-use <strong>of</strong> reclaimed water).<br />

2. Leneva Valley Development – Servicing Strategies and Functional Design for Water<br />

and Wastewater – Kellogg Brown & Root Pty Ltd – <strong>December</strong> 2005. (The report provides<br />

water supply and sewerage servicing strategies and functional design for the various stages<br />

<strong>of</strong> the proposed Leneva Valley development).<br />

3. <strong>Wodonga</strong> Water Recycling Strategy – EarthTech – Volume 1, 2 & 3 – June 2005. (This<br />

report identifies opportunities for the reuse <strong>of</strong> the recycled water from the West <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Wastewater Treatment Plant).<br />

21.12-04 Development Contributions and Community Facilities<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

To ensure the timely provision <strong>of</strong> infrastructure and fair apportionment <strong>of</strong> infrastructure<br />

costs amongst the public and private sector, the <strong>council</strong> will prepare a development<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 5 OF 6<br />

Page 297 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

contribution plan/s for <strong>Wodonga</strong>. This will be implemented by agreement or through a<br />

future amendment to the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Planning Scheme.<br />

� The plans will apply a charge for physical infrastructure and community facilities and<br />

relate to all urban and future urban areas.<br />

� Components <strong>of</strong> the Development Contributions’ Plan will apply to specific areas and<br />

charges will vary depending on the location and infrastructure requirements.<br />

� All future growth areas will be affected by a Development Contributions’ Plan.<br />

The Development Contributions’ Plan will be completed once appropriate guidelines by the<br />

State Government have been provided that include the opportunity for ‘<strong>of</strong>f the shelf’<br />

infrastructure contributions to be required.<br />

MUNICIPAL STRATEGIC STATEMENT - CLAUSE 21.12 PAGE 6 OF 6<br />

Page 298 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

22.09 WODONGA CENTRAL BUSINESS AREA<br />

11/12/2008<br />

C57<br />

This policy applies to all land zoned Business and Comprehensive Development Zone 1<br />

(CDZ1) included in the plan referred to in clause 21.11 in regard to the redevelopment <strong>of</strong><br />

the Central Business Area.<br />

Car parking policy applies to the area bounded by Watson Street, South Street, Hovell<br />

Street, Havelock Street, Lawrence Street, Hume Street and Stanley Street.<br />

Policy Basis<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>’s future development and prosperity is fundamental to the <strong>City</strong>’s continuing role<br />

as a major regional centre <strong>of</strong> North East Victoria. The Council aims to strengthen<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong>’s role in the regional economy by facilitating improved economic development<br />

opportunities and job creation.<br />

The city centre will be retained and consolidated as the municipality’s primary retail and<br />

business centre. This policy guides decision making in regard to the urban design and<br />

location <strong>of</strong> development in the Central Business Area, with the aim <strong>of</strong> supporting strategies<br />

to enhance the general levels <strong>of</strong> activity and the overall appearance <strong>of</strong> the <strong>City</strong> centre.<br />

The existing <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area has a consolidated commercial precinct, with<br />

substantial expansion opportunities. Parking surveys have demonstrated that the current<br />

commercial precinct has an overall surplus <strong>of</strong> car parking supply over demand although this<br />

varies throughout the Central Business Area.<br />

The significant redevelopment and expansion opportunities for the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central<br />

Business Area create the ability to provide further consolidated car parking areas that can<br />

be shared between a range <strong>of</strong> different uses, with parking supply rates reflecting the<br />

opportunities for the shared use <strong>of</strong> facilities and parking demand rates <strong>of</strong> major regional<br />

centres, rather than on parking rates that are historically based and apply across the state.<br />

Objectives<br />

� To implement guidelines for the urban design and siting <strong>of</strong> development in the Central<br />

Business Area.<br />

� To recognise the role and function <strong>of</strong> High Street as the main retail and business street<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>Wodonga</strong>.<br />

� To support the strategy directions in clause 21.11 and to clarify the extent <strong>of</strong> discretion<br />

available with these directions.<br />

� To recognise the significance and primary importance <strong>of</strong> streets and public spaces in<br />

regard to building design.<br />

� To facilitate activities that will contribute towards the economic, social and physical<br />

integration <strong>of</strong> the city centre.<br />

� Implement the findings and recommendations <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area<br />

Parking Precinct Plan, Ratio Consultants Pty Ltd, April 2003.<br />

� Implement the findings and recommendations <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA Master plan<br />

Strategic Planning Report, August 2007.<br />

� Provide an equitable and consistent approach to car parking at a rate which is<br />

appropriate to the use <strong>of</strong> the land in the context <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area.<br />

LOCAL PLANNING POLICIES - CLAUSE 22.09 PAGE 1 OF 2<br />

Page 299 <strong>of</strong> 304


WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

� Provide clear direction on the amount <strong>of</strong> parking likely to be required <strong>of</strong> applicants in<br />

the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area, including the application <strong>of</strong> ‘cash-in-lieu’<br />

payments.<br />

Implementation<br />

It is policy that:<br />

� The <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area be planned and developed as the <strong>City</strong>’s primary<br />

retail, business, commercial and community centre.<br />

� The planning <strong>of</strong> the Central Business Area be generally in accordance with the adopted<br />

version <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Area Master Plan and its supporting guidelines.<br />

� Land formerly comprising the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station and associated rail land be<br />

developed in a manner which is consistent with the purposes <strong>of</strong> the Comprehensive<br />

Development Zone 1.<br />

� Streets and public spaces will be actively fronted with retail and <strong>of</strong>fice uses to occupy<br />

the street level, with the frontage <strong>of</strong> the premises to be a minimum 60% transparent<br />

(glazed). Solid wall treatments abutting streets or public spaces (excluding intra block<br />

car parking areas) will not be supported.<br />

� Development will be encouraged to facilitate the practical integration <strong>of</strong> land uses in<br />

preference to single use development. This will be encouraged through the active<br />

support <strong>of</strong> multi level formats with three or more storeys.<br />

� Development at the corner <strong>of</strong> Elgin Boulevard and High Street, be designed in a manner<br />

that supports the significance <strong>of</strong> this intersection as the heart <strong>of</strong> the Central Business<br />

Area. These corner buildings must address the corner, being a minimum <strong>of</strong> two storeys,<br />

as shown in the design guidelines for the central business area.<br />

� The Civic Precinct will be encouraged to develop as a commercial <strong>of</strong>fice, entertainment<br />

and cultural hub <strong>of</strong> the central business area. Proposals that reinforce this role will be<br />

actively facilitated.<br />

� Off street car parking areas are to be sleeved at the rear <strong>of</strong> buildings in preference to be<br />

located at the street boundary <strong>of</strong> a lot. In considering an application the responsible<br />

authority will place a priority on ensuring the frontage <strong>of</strong> any site is for a building, as<br />

opposed to parking or landscape treatments. The responsible authority may in some<br />

instances permit car parking at the frontage <strong>of</strong> site as an interim treatment as provided<br />

through an Agreement under Section 173 <strong>of</strong> the Planning Environment Act (1987).<br />

� Where available detailed precinct plans applying to specific areas <strong>of</strong> the central business<br />

and as adopted by the responsible authority will be considered in regard to the siting<br />

and design <strong>of</strong> development. These plans will be used to guide specific locations <strong>of</strong><br />

buildings, public spaces, car park areas and pedestrian links.<br />

� An appropriate rate <strong>of</strong> car parking provision be made for commercial, industrial and<br />

community uses in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> Central Business Area in accordance with Clause<br />

52.06 <strong>of</strong> this planning scheme.<br />

� That urban design guidelines included in the <strong>Wodonga</strong> CBA Master plan Strategic<br />

Planning Report, August 2007, be considered and applied.<br />

LOCAL PLANNING POLICIES - CLAUSE 22.09 PAGE 2 OF 2<br />

Page 300 <strong>of</strong> 304


11/06/2009<br />

C46<br />

PS<br />

Map<br />

Ref<br />

SCHEDULE TO THE HERITAGE OVERLAY<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

The requirements <strong>of</strong> this overlay apply to both the heritage place and its associated land.<br />

Heritage Place External<br />

Paint<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

Victorian Heritage Register<br />

Internal<br />

Alteration<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

Tree<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

Outbuildin<br />

gs or<br />

fences<br />

which are<br />

not<br />

exempt<br />

under<br />

Clause<br />

43.01-4<br />

Included<br />

on the<br />

Victorian<br />

Heritage<br />

Register<br />

under<br />

the<br />

Heritage<br />

Act<br />

1995?<br />

HO7 Block 19, Bonegilla Road, Bonegilla - - - - Yes Ref<br />

No H1835<br />

HO1 Cambourne, 2 High Street, <strong>Wodonga</strong> - - - - Yes Ref<br />

No H233<br />

HO3 De Kerilleau Homestead, end <strong>of</strong> Milos Boulevard<br />

and Lawrence Street, <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

HO9 Former Clyde Cameron College, 41-69<br />

Nordsvan Drive, <strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

Local significance<br />

HO2 Butter Factory<br />

(Lincoln Causeway, <strong>Wodonga</strong>)<br />

- - - - Yes Ref<br />

No H381<br />

- - - - Yes Ref<br />

No H2192<br />

Prohibite<br />

d uses<br />

may be<br />

permitte<br />

d?<br />

Name <strong>of</strong><br />

Incorporated<br />

Plan under<br />

Clause 43.01-2<br />

Yes No<br />

Yes No<br />

No No<br />

Yes No<br />

No No No No No No None specified No<br />

HO4 Machinery Room No No No No No No None specified No<br />

HO5 Old custom & custom <strong>of</strong>fice No No No No No No None specified No<br />

HO6 Powder Magazine No No No No No No None specified No<br />

HO8 Bonegilla Hall (Murray Valley Highway,<br />

Bonegilla)<br />

Yes No No No No No None Specified No<br />

Aboriginal<br />

heritage<br />

place?<br />

HERITAGE OVERLAY - SCHEDULE PAGE 1 OF 1<br />

Page 301 <strong>of</strong> 304


PS<br />

Map<br />

Ref<br />

HO1<br />

0<br />

Heritage Place External<br />

Paint<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong> Railway Station, Elgin Boulevard<br />

<strong>Wodonga</strong><br />

The heritage place comprises the station<br />

building, platforms and goods shed and<br />

associated land.<br />

WODONGA PLANNING SCHEME<br />

Internal<br />

Alteration<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

Tree<br />

Controls<br />

Apply?<br />

Outbuildin<br />

gs or<br />

fences<br />

which are<br />

not<br />

exempt<br />

under<br />

Clause<br />

43.01-4<br />

Included<br />

on the<br />

Victorian<br />

Heritage<br />

Register<br />

under<br />

the<br />

Heritage<br />

Act<br />

1995?<br />

Prohibite<br />

d uses<br />

may be<br />

permitte<br />

d?<br />

Name <strong>of</strong><br />

Incorporated<br />

Plan under<br />

Clause 43.01-2<br />

No No No No No No None specified No<br />

Aboriginal<br />

heritage<br />

place?<br />

HERITAGE OVERLAY - SCHEDULE PAGE 2 OF 1<br />

Page 302 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 303 <strong>of</strong> 304


Page 304 <strong>of</strong> 304

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!