News From Around the WoodsDean SullivanAnnounces DepartureAl Sullivan, dean of theUniversity of <strong>Minnesota</strong>’s Collegeof Natural Resources, announcedthat he will step down as dean inSeptember 2002. Sullivan will haveserved as dean for 10 years. Anative of Mississippi who came to<strong>Minnesota</strong> from Penn StateUniversity, Dean Sullivan playedan active role inside the universitystructure. He also chaired theMinn. <strong>Forest</strong> Resources Council’sResearch Advisory Committee andserved on the GEIS ImplementationRoundtable.Zumeta AppointedMFRC ExecutiveDirectorThe Minn. <strong>Forest</strong> ResourcesCouncil appointed Dave Zumetaexecutive dsirector at its <strong>Nov</strong>embermeeting at the Cloquet <strong>Forest</strong>ryCenter. Zumeta is a 20-yearemployee of the Minn. DNR withprevious work experience in theprivate sector and with the state ofIndiana. He holds a Ph.D in forestpolicy and economics from theUniversity of <strong>Minnesota</strong>. Zumetaprovided primary staff support forthe Division of <strong>Forest</strong>ry directorduring the GEIS study, the GEISImplementation Roundtable andthe early stages of the Minn. <strong>Forest</strong>Resources Council. “I am verypleased that someone of Dave’saccomplishment would accept thisposition. He is fair, balanced andknowledgeable. We’re verycomfortable with this choice,” saidTPA Executive Vice PresidentWayne Brandt. Zumeta succeedsMike Kilgore who is now anassistant professor in the U of M’sCollege of Natural Resources.Chelseth DepartsPotlatchArchie Chelseth has retired fromPotlatch after 22 years as thecompany’s Public Affairs directorin <strong>Minnesota</strong>. During his yearswith Potlatch Chelseth shepherdedpermitting for the company’smassive pulp mill rebuild inCloquet as well as permitting forOSB and sawmill construction andexpansion projects. A Duluthnative, Chelseth was a frequentattendee at TPA Annual Meetingsand was long an advocate forloggers and labor in industrydeliberations. <strong>Minnesota</strong> <strong>Forest</strong><strong>Industries</strong> has announced that it isretaining him to providegovernment relations services.German Lumber atDuluth Port<strong>Nov</strong>ember saw the first shipmentof German lumber into the Port ofDuluth. Some 5 million board feetof lumber, enough to build 300homes, arrived on its way to LakeStates Lumber in Aitkin. “It’s a sadday when people are forced toimport wood at the same timewe’ve seen sawmills in the regionclosing. Importing 2 x 4s fromEurope seems a little ridiculouswhen we’ve got some of the mostproductive forest in the world righthere,” said TPA Executive VicePresident Wayne Brandt.Flax Paper Draws FlackThe Minot, N.D., paper hasreported that plans are underwayfor a “treeless” paper mill inWalhalla. The $53 million projectintends to use flax straw formaking paper. Dr. Patrick Moore,the keynote speaker at TPA’s 2001Annual Meeting, spoke about usingagricultural products to makepaper and indicated that it mightmake sense environmentally if wehad a spare continent layingaround to grow crops on.Virtual RecreationistsThis week, Michael Milstein at thePortland Oregonian broke a storythat the <strong>Forest</strong> Service has beenoverestimating annual recreationvisitors by as much as 70-80 percent.Instead of almost a billion forestvisitors, the new figures show thatonly about 209 million peopleactually visit our national forestseach year. The previousadministration used the large forestvisitor numbers as the justificationfor a dramatic shift in themanagement emphasis on thenational forests. It was the sameflawed data and projections thatwere used to justify drastic reductionsin timber management programsand to claim that recreation jobswould replace forest products jobsin our rural communities. Now weknow why those service jobs neverappeared, the recreationists werejust numbers on budget requestsfrom the agency.What seems to have beenhappening is that recreation staffwere inflating numbers, basedmostly on guess work, and werecounting some visitors as many asfour or five times. It turns out thatback in the FY98 InteriorAppropriations, Congress asked the<strong>Forest</strong> Service to reassess the visitoruse numbers. Now the question iswill the agency revise all thoseforest plan decisions thatemphasized recreation over timbermanagement and will they justifyall the funds they have beenappropriating based on only 20percent of the forest visitors? Mybet is that Congress will hold a fewoversight hearings on this issue.from Chris West, AFRC NEWS,<strong>Nov</strong>ember 16, 2001Sierra Club HitsAnother Branch on theStupid TreeThe <strong>Timber</strong> <strong>Bulletin</strong> reprinted anarticle in the July/August issuewhich observed that the Sierra Clubhad fallen out of the stupid treeand hit every branch on the waydown. The Sierra Club has now hitanother branch on its organizationalstupid tree with a lawsuit filed in(continued on page 20)18 <strong>Timber</strong> <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Nov</strong>ember/<strong>Dec</strong>ember 2001
(continued from page 18)Michigan challenging the YabaEnvironmental Assessment on theOttawa National <strong>Forest</strong>. The suitchallenges the decision but asks thejudge to suspend all aspen sales onnational forests in Michigan,Wisconsin and <strong>Minnesota</strong> pendinga region wide study of aspenmanagement. Counsel for theSierra Club in this suit is the sameattorney who has filed most of theunsuccessful appeals and lawsuitson the Superior National <strong>Forest</strong> inrecent years.Lawsuit Proceeds toSupreme CourtAn appeal of the <strong>Minnesota</strong>Center for EnvironmentalAdvocacy’s (MCEA) lawsuitagainst the Minn. Pollution ControlAgency and Boise Cascade hasbeen accepted by the <strong>Minnesota</strong>Supreme Court. MCEA lost inKoochiching County District Courtand then won their appeal in theMinn. Court of Appeals. TheMPCA and Boise Cascade thenappealed to the Supreme Court.TPA, <strong>Minnesota</strong> <strong>Forest</strong>ryAssociation, Wood Fiber EmployeesJoint Legislative Council and<strong>Minnesota</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Industries</strong> wereallowed to file an amicus briefsupporting the MPCA and BoiseCascade. Trout Unlimited, TheIzaak Walton League, TheAudubon Society, Sawbill CanoeOutfitters, Piragos NorthwoodsCo., Clean Water Action, Friends ofthe Boundary Waters Wildernessand Northeastern <strong>Minnesota</strong>ns forWilderness were also allowed tofile an amicus brief in support ofMCEA.The core of the MCEA suit is achallenge to the use of voluntaryforest management guidelines in<strong>Minnesota</strong>. MCEA prefersregulations and seeks to have themimplemented through air and waterpermits.Potlatch CorporationNames Frank Carroll<strong>Minnesota</strong> PublicAffairs DirectorPotlatch Corporation (NYSE:PCH) has named Franklin O.Carroll regional director of publicaffairs, headquartered in Cloquet,Minn. Carroll succeeds Archie D.Chelseth, who has elected to takeearly retirement after 22 years withthe company.Carroll has been the company’scommunications manager for thewestern region, headquartered inLewiston, Idaho, since 1997. In hisnew position, Carroll will beresponsible for communityrelations and communications forPotlatch pulp, paper and woodproducts operations in <strong>Minnesota</strong>,and will serve as governmentalrelations counsel for the companyin northern <strong>Minnesota</strong> and St. Paul.Prior to joining Potlatch, Carrollserved in a variety of public affairspositions with the U.S. <strong>Forest</strong>Service in the western UnitedStates. A native of Arizona, heholds a bachelor’s degree from theUniversity of New Mexico and amaster’s degree in publicadministration from Boise StateUniversity in Boise, Idaho. He haswritten extensively on the subjectof natural resource managementand is accredited by the PublicRelations Society of America.Chelseth joined the company asdirector of public affairs in <strong>Minnesota</strong>in 1979 after a distinguishedpolitical career in <strong>Minnesota</strong> thatincluded work with both thelegislature and the governor’soffice as well as the <strong>Minnesota</strong>Department of Natural Resources.During his tenure with Potlatch,Chelseth served as a member andpresident of the <strong>Minnesota</strong> HigherEducation Coordinating Board andas a founding member of the<strong>Minnesota</strong> State Colleges andUniversities Board of Trustees, inaddition to serving on the CloquetSchool Board.Potlatch Corporation is adiversified wood and paperproducts company with operationsin seven states and 1.5 million acresof forestland in Arkansas, Idahoand <strong>Minnesota</strong>.20 <strong>Timber</strong> <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Nov</strong>ember/<strong>Dec</strong>ember 2001