National Awards for ExcellenceSummary of Winning Entries in theNational Awards for Excellence inHuman Resource Managementreorganisation project; AbbottIreland whose Ballytivnan plantwon its award for a LifelongLearning programme andHibernian Life and Pensionswhose entry described a culturechange programme. Theseawards were sponsored byArthur Cox, Solicitors; FASExcellence Through <strong>People</strong> andCPL Resources respectively.general defect. AIB have spent some yearsdeveloping and improving their staff opinionsurveys but have also used them to devise apowerful tool which is now an integral part oftheir strategic management decision makingstructures. Using the information gathered fromthe staff opinion surveys they have created anIndex which assesses the impact on staff of arange of management practices and behaviours.The Watson Wyatt Supreme Award winner! Grace Perrott of AIBholds the Supreme Award in the company of Pat Lunny, Chairman<strong>CIPD</strong>I; Kevin Empey, Watson Wyatt; Paul Donovan, Vodafone;Michael McDonnell, <strong>CIPD</strong>I and Rachel Armstrong of IndependentNewspapers, who were the media partners for the Awards.The <strong>CIPD</strong> presented a SpecialAchievement Award to the FlourConfectioners and BakersAssociation for their work indeveloping a Skillnet project.The <strong>CIPD</strong>/Watson Wyatt Awards for Excellencein Human Resource Management werepresented at a Gala Awards Dinner in theGuinness Storehouse, Dublin on November11th, 2003. The Awards were made after anexhaustive judging process which commencedin March 2003 with invitations to submitentries. The final date for entries wasAugust 24th, 2003 and a total of 50entries were received.This total was shortlisted down to 15finalists, all of whom were invited to theAwards Dinner. The identity of the Awardwinners was kept secret until theirannouncement at the Dinner. TheSupreme Award, sponsored by WatsonWyatt, was presented to AIB Bank fortheir Employee Survey and the use theyhave made of it in developing the <strong>People</strong><strong>Focus</strong> Index.There were three Special Merit Awardwinners. They were The Civil Service andLocal Appointments Commissionerswhose entry dealt with a downsizing andIn commenting on the Awards Mr. PaulDonovan, C.E.O. of Vodafone who chaired thejudging panel, said that in general the entrieslacked a credible measurement of theeffectiveness of the HR function as an “adder ofvalue”. The supreme award winning entry fromAIB was an honourable exception to thisPictured at the Awards were Pat Lunny of Greencore Group plc(Chairman of the <strong>CIPD</strong> Ireland); Paul Donovan, Chief ExecutiveOfficer of Vodafone who chaired the panel of judges for theAwards; Brenda Morris and Kevin Empey of Watson Wyatt,principal sponsors of the Awards; Michael McDonnell, Director of<strong>CIPD</strong>; Frank Brennan, Awards Co-ordinator for <strong>CIPD</strong> and SarahReynolds, Awards Administrator, <strong>CIPD</strong>.John McAteer is pictured receiving the FASSpecial Merit Award from Patricia Curtin of FASand Paul Donovan of Vodafone.This <strong>People</strong> <strong>Focus</strong> Index provides HR and linemanagement with information enablingthem to target remedial work and support,thus influencing, in a positive way, thediscretionary behaviour of employees. TheIndex has become a strategic tool whichinforms decision-making throughout theAIB Group and places people managementissues at the heart of the business. Thejudges were impressed with the constantsearch for ways of improving anddeveloping the survey process and thecompany’s willingness to benchmark itagainst best international practice.The entry from the Civil Service andLocal Appointments Commissionersdealt with a downsizing and reorganisationproject with theCommission’s staff. Faced with the usualpg14 Autumn 20<strong>04</strong>
National Awards for ExcellencePaul Donovan of Vodafone and Pat Lunny, <strong>CIPD</strong>I Chairmanpresent the <strong>CIPD</strong>I Special Achievement Award to Patrick Garveyof the Flour Confectioners and Bakers Association.Public Service constraints of centrally controlled,inflexible pay and rewards structures theCommissioners found themselves with areduced budget and therefore the need todownsize. The management set out to ensurethat those who left the organisation would do sowith a feeling of goodwill towards their formeremployer, that they would be uniquely preparedto identify new career paths and that they wouldhave the skills and competencies to succeed inthose careers. In addition, the managementwished to ensure that the retained staff wouldfeel equally valued with a consequentcommitment to meet the increasing demandsplaced on them. In solving the problem with acombination of personal development and careerplacement initiatives theCommissioners showed aninnovative and very peoplecentredapproach whichcommended itself to the judgingpanel.The second Special Merit Awardwent to Abbott Ireland’sBallytivnan plant. Through aseries of initiatives based on theprinciples of Lifelong Learningthey use the untapped potentialof their workforce to movetogether up the value chaincreating the opportunity for newinvestment and increasedemployment.The core of the company’sstrategy is to give each employeethe chance to create and owntheir own personal developmentprogramme. This demonstratedto the parent corporation thatIreland’s workforce is highlyeducated, flexible andresponsive to change resulting infurther multi-million dollarinvestment and 200 new jobs.Furthermore, in 2002 theBallytivnan plant was awardedthe title of Premier Large Manufacturing Plant inAbbott’s International Division, coming top of40 plants worldwide and justifying the successof the focus on learning and development.Hibernian Life and Pensions were the winners ofthe third Special Merit Award. In the view of thejudges they had recognised the existence of amultiplicity of problems, determined to learn fromthem and developed a new and unique culture.Their unpromising starting point was a merger ofthree companies with widely different cultures anda customer perception of poor customer service.The staff and management of Hibernian workedtogether to create a new and unique culture thathas resulted in remarkable improvements in theirPresenting the CPL Special Merit Award to Alastair McMenaminof Hibernian Life and Pensions are Paul Donovan of Vodafoneand Paul Carroll of CPL Resources plc.