40Messenger (rasul) participating in <strong>the</strong> revelation (wahy) appropriate to that rank, at <strong>the</strong> request ofhis bro<strong>the</strong>r Moses....I said: "O Aaron, some people among <strong>the</strong> true Knowers have claimed that <strong>the</strong> existence(of <strong>the</strong> external world) disappeared with regard to <strong>the</strong>m, so that <strong>the</strong>y see nothing but God, <strong>and</strong> sothat nothing of <strong>the</strong> world remains with <strong>the</strong>m that might distract <strong>the</strong>m, in comparison with God.Nor is <strong>the</strong>re any doubt that <strong>the</strong>y (really) are in that (spiritual) rank, 139 as opposed to those likeyou. Now God has informed us that you said to your bro<strong>the</strong>r (Moses) when he was angry (withyou for having allowed <strong>the</strong> Israelites to worship <strong>the</strong> golden calf): '...so do not cause (our)enemies to gloat over me!' (Kor. 7:151). 140 Thus you posited <strong>the</strong>ir having a certain power (overyou in <strong>the</strong> external world), <strong>and</strong> this condition is different from <strong>the</strong> condition of those trueKnowers (who experience <strong>the</strong> 'disappearance' of <strong>the</strong> external world)."Then he replied: "They spoke sincerely (about <strong>the</strong>ir experience). However, <strong>the</strong>y did nothave any more than what was given <strong>the</strong>m by <strong>the</strong>ir immediate experience (dhawq). But look <strong>and</strong>see--did what disappeared from <strong>the</strong>m (in that state actually) disappear from <strong>the</strong> world?""No," I answered.He said: "Then <strong>the</strong>y were lacking in <strong>the</strong> knowledge of <strong>the</strong> way things are, to <strong>the</strong> extent ofwhat <strong>the</strong>y missed, since <strong>the</strong> world was non-existent for <strong>the</strong>m. So <strong>the</strong>y were lacking <strong>the</strong> TrueReality (al-Haqq) to <strong>the</strong> extent of that (aspect) of <strong>the</strong> world which was veiled from <strong>the</strong>m.Because <strong>the</strong> whole world is precisely <strong>the</strong> Self-manifestation (tajalli) of <strong>the</strong> Truly Real, for<strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>'s unique status as <strong>the</strong> "Seal of Muhammadan Sainthood." (See <strong>the</strong> similar greeting by Idris at<strong>the</strong> beginning of section IV-E, n. 111 above). For <strong>the</strong> central notion of <strong>the</strong> saints as "heirs" of <strong>the</strong>different prophets (<strong>and</strong> all ultimately as heirs of <strong>the</strong> "Muhammadan Reality"), see <strong>the</strong> references given inn. 49 above.139 I.e., <strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>'s question (<strong>and</strong> implicit criticism) concerns <strong>the</strong> relative evaluation of thatspiritual state, not <strong>the</strong> reality <strong>and</strong> importance of <strong>the</strong> experience itself. See his remarks in <strong>the</strong> followingsection (IV-G) on <strong>the</strong> necessity of fana' at a certain point on <strong>the</strong> path, in regard to Moses' initiatic "death"(sa'aqa) on Mt. Sinai, <strong>and</strong> his use of a similar <strong>Arabi</strong>c term (afna) in describing a decisive phase in his ownspiritual development in <strong>the</strong> key passage from <strong>the</strong> K. al-Isra' (pp. 13-14) translated in our article cited at n.13 above. More generally, <strong>the</strong> contrast between <strong>the</strong> lower, "immature" state of those "Knowers" ('arifun)who deny <strong>the</strong> reality of this world, <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> station of <strong>the</strong> warithun (<strong>the</strong> true "heirs" of <strong>the</strong> prophets) whoare always aware of God's <strong>the</strong>ophanic Presence throughout this world, is a recurrent subject in <strong>the</strong> K. al-Isra'.140 See <strong>the</strong> longer discussion of <strong>the</strong> inner meaning of this incident, from a very different st<strong>and</strong>point(i.e., Moses' <strong>and</strong> Aaron's differing awareness of <strong>the</strong> divine Mercy) at <strong>the</strong> beginning of <strong>the</strong> chapter onAaron (no. 24) in <strong>the</strong> Fusus (I, 191 ff.; Bezels, pp. 243 ff.).
41whoever really knows <strong>the</strong> Truly Real. So where are you going? It is only a reminder to <strong>the</strong>worlds (Kor. 81:26-27) of <strong>the</strong> way things are!"Perfection is nothing but its (or 'His') 141 existence,So whoever misses it is not <strong>the</strong> perfect one.... 142141 kawnuhu: <strong>the</strong> term kawn usually refers to <strong>the</strong> engendered, manifest state of being (translated as"existence" here), so <strong>the</strong> most obvious reference, given <strong>the</strong> preceding context, is to <strong>the</strong> external "world" orwhole manifest "universe" (al-'alam). But as so frequently in <strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>, <strong>the</strong> pronouns in this verse couldalso be taken, without any ultimate contradiction, to refer ei<strong>the</strong>r to God (al-haqq, <strong>the</strong> Truly Real) or evento <strong>the</strong> human "observer"--i.e., man in his ultimate reality as <strong>the</strong> "Perfect Man," which may well be what isindicated by "<strong>the</strong> perfect one" (al-kamil) at <strong>the</strong> end.142 The concluding, untranslated lines allude to <strong>the</strong> well-known dangers <strong>and</strong> illusions involved intaking <strong>the</strong> ecstatic experience of "extinction" (fana') of <strong>the</strong> self in contemplation of God as <strong>the</strong> ultimategoal <strong>and</strong> highest stage of <strong>the</strong> spiritual path, at least in this world. This caution, which is probablyconnected with <strong>the</strong> title of this chapter (see notes 27 <strong>and</strong> 39 above), is amplified <strong>and</strong> repeated in <strong>the</strong>following encounter with Moses (section IV-G), <strong>and</strong> it is also an important <strong>the</strong>me in <strong>the</strong> passage from <strong>the</strong>K. al-Isra' translated in our article cited at n. 13 above. Although <strong>the</strong> subject of Aaron's remark is aconstantly repeated <strong>the</strong>me in <strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>'s writing, it should be stressed that those dangers <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> ultimatesuperiority of <strong>the</strong> saints' subsequent "enlightened abiding" (baqa') in <strong>the</strong> world, as exemplified above allin <strong>the</strong> life of Muhammad, were likewise stressed almost unanimously in earlier Sufi literature <strong>and</strong>practice.The intensity <strong>and</strong> centrality of <strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>'s insistence on <strong>the</strong> realization of <strong>the</strong> nature <strong>and</strong>importance of this "world" as an essential aspect of human perfection (kamal)--<strong>and</strong> indeed as <strong>the</strong> essentialgrounds of man's superiority to <strong>the</strong> angels <strong>and</strong> purely spiritual beings--can best be measured bycomparing his writings to <strong>the</strong> familiar currents of "monistic" mysticism, such as <strong>the</strong> Sufism of <strong>Ibn</strong> '<strong>Arabi</strong>'sAndalusian contemporary, <strong>Ibn</strong> Sab'in. See, among o<strong>the</strong>rs, <strong>the</strong> careful comparison of <strong>the</strong>se twoperspectives--which have <strong>the</strong>ir parallels in many o<strong>the</strong>r mystical traditions--in <strong>the</strong> translation <strong>and</strong> study of<strong>the</strong> Epitre sur l'Unicite Absolue (R. al-Ahadiya) of Awhad al-Din Balyani (a 13th-century Persian Sufi in<strong>the</strong> school of <strong>Ibn</strong> Sab'in) by M. Chodkiewicz, Paris, 1982.