Responses to Comments<strong>Idaho</strong> <strong>Power</strong> CompanyRESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-161Dissolved oxygen (DO) levels measured in the tailrace of Hells Canyon Dam are suboptimal forwhite sturgeon during brief summer periods. The river receives considerable aeration afterentering a series of rapids some 8 miles downstream; however, it may not achieve 100%saturation or meet Oregon’s standard for salmonid spawning as far downstream as theSalmon River. IPC is not aware of any sturgeon mortalities related to water quality (includinglow DO) that have been recorded in the reach below Hells Canyon Dam. IPC has proposedupstream measures to improve DO conditions in the tailrace of Hells Canyon Dam, which areexpected to benefit white sturgeon.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-162Comment noted.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-163IPC agrees that the effects of low DO levels on native resident salmonids are uncertain butlimited spatially and temporally. IPC studies of redband and bull trout showed that fish utilizecoldwater refuge areas when temperature and DO conditions become less than suitable in projectreservoirs.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-164IPC appreciates the <strong>Shoshone</strong>-<strong>Bannock</strong> <strong>Tribes</strong>’ support for its proposed measures.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-165This comment appears to accurately reflect the conclusion in the DLA.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-166Thank you for the comment. No response is required.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-167IPC appreciates the <strong>Shoshone</strong>-<strong>Bannock</strong> <strong>Tribes</strong>’ support of its proposed measure to install flowdeflectors on Hells Canyon Dam.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-168Thank you for the comment. No response is required.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-169IPC agrees with the <strong>Shoshone</strong>-<strong>Bannock</strong> <strong>Tribes</strong>.Page 72Hells Canyon Complex
<strong>Idaho</strong> <strong>Power</strong> CompanyResponses to CommentsRESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-170As to alleged off-reservation treaty rights, see Response to Comment SBT1-2. Moreover, traditionalplant resources have been identified in the oral history reports completed by the Confederated <strong>Tribes</strong>of the Warm Springs Reservation (confidential Technical Report E.4-13, Chapter 2) and the BurnsPaiute Tribe (confidential Technical Report E.4-13, Chapter 1). See Response to CommentSBT1-58.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-171None of the transmission lines discussed in either the DLA or the FLA are located on theFort Hall Indian Reservation. In addition, IPC has decided to remove all transmission linesassociated with the HCC, except the Pine Creek–Hells Canyon 69-kV line (Line 945), from theFLA. These lines will not be relicensed by FERC as a part of the HCC because they are nolonger primary lines subject to FERC licensing jurisdiction. The Pine Creek–Hells Canyon line(Line 945) parallels the Oxbow–Hells Canyon road and typically occurs in the road verge. Itdoes not have service roads associated with it.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-172As to alleged off-reservation treaty rights, see Response to Comment SBT1-2. None of thetransmission lines discussed in either the DLA or the FLA are located on the Fort Hall IndianReservation.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-173Impacts to botanical resources, in some cases at the species level, are described in the licenseapplication, Exhibit E.3.3. As to alleged “tribal plant resources,” see Response to CommentSBT1-2.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-174As to alleged off-reservation treaty rights, see Response to Comment SBT1-2.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-175Participation of all entities involved in the HCC relicensing process is summarized in the FLA,Consultation Appendix, section I, Attachment G. See also Response to Comment SBT1-170.RESPONSE TO COMMENT SBT1-176In a meeting held in February 1998, IPC discussed the 100-meter width of the APE with the<strong>Idaho</strong> State Historic Preservation Office (<strong>Idaho</strong> SHPO) staff, U.S. Forest Service (USFS) staff,and principal investigators from Applied Paleoscience and Rain Shadow Research. The staff ofthe Oregon SHPO were invited to the meeting, but they could not attend. The <strong>Idaho</strong> and OregonSHPOs and the USFS were notified of the APE definition in a letter from Mark Druss, IPCarchaeologist, dated March 5, 1998. Dr. Robert Yohe, the <strong>Idaho</strong> Deputy State HistoricHells Canyon Complex Page 73