13.07.2015 Views

Encyclopedia of Utopian Literature - Programs and Courses ...

Encyclopedia of Utopian Literature - Programs and Courses ...

Encyclopedia of Utopian Literature - Programs and Courses ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ENCYCLOPEDIA OF UTOPIANLITERATURE


BIBLIOGRAPHICCITATIONSnodgrass, Mary Ellen. <strong>Encyclopedia</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Utopian</strong><strong>Literature</strong>. Santa Barbara, CA.: ABC‐CLIO. 1995.It is available in the reference section <strong>of</strong> theBothell Regional Library, KCLS system.The Aeneid, written by Virgil in Roman times,may be the first real example <strong>of</strong> <strong>Utopian</strong>literature in Western literature <strong>and</strong> thought .It concerns the travels <strong>of</strong> Aeneas <strong>and</strong> in someways resembles earlier Greek epics by Homersuch as The Iliad <strong>and</strong> The Odyssey. Kumar(1987), in Utopia <strong>and</strong> Anti‐Utopia in ModernTimes also remarks in his first chapter thatVirgil’s Fourth Eclogue, evoking “the return <strong>of</strong>the ‘reign <strong>of</strong> Saturn’, an age <strong>of</strong> peace <strong>and</strong>prosperity…” (Kumar, 1987,p. 3), may be anearly creation <strong>of</strong> a utopia. (Pictures:Snodgrass (1995), p. 8)


ARRANGEMENTIt is arranged in alphabetical order containing “…numerous cross‐references to significant studies,particularly conditioning, women in utopia,synergy, totalitarianism, sexual reproduction,economics, syncretism, prophecy disillusion, <strong>and</strong>technology.” (Snodgrass, 1995, p. xi.) Briefbibliographies at the end <strong>of</strong> each section alsopoint to primary <strong>and</strong> secondary sources.Camelot is perhaps also one <strong>of</strong> the earliest examples <strong>of</strong> Utopiafound in literature. The idea <strong>of</strong> Camelot being an ideal societywhere all knights were equal resonates with the idea <strong>of</strong> aUtopia as it has been represented in modern times. (Picture:Snodgrass (1995), p. 30., originally reproduced from MS Royal14, E.III f. 89, Department <strong>of</strong> Manuscripts, British Library.)


INDEXINGThere is a table <strong>of</strong> contents , but it does not listspecific ‘subjects’ in the reference item <strong>and</strong> it hasan index in the back.Sir Thomas More: More was a diplomat, theologian, <strong>and</strong> socialist who wroteUtopia (1516). He lived 1477 – 1535. His “… Latin manuscript Utopia, animaginative social <strong>and</strong> moral idyll that detailed the visit <strong>of</strong> Raphael Hythloday, afictional mariner, to an imaginary isl<strong>and</strong> he called Nusquania or ‘nowhere.’,”(Ibid. p. 362) that coined the term “utopia” <strong>and</strong> gave birth to utopian literature.Commenting on the book Snodgrass (1995) gives a brief summary stating that“As a character, More functions as a devil’s advocate, arguing for privateproperty against Hythloday’s contention that pure communism assures a fairerdistribution <strong>of</strong> goods. More blames a “conspiracy <strong>of</strong> the rich”, for exploiting thepoor while sating their hedonistic urges. “(Ibid., p. 362) More went on to writemany other books including the unfinished History <strong>of</strong> King Richard III <strong>and</strong> theDialogue <strong>of</strong> Comfort Against Tribulation. In Kumar (1987), he points to the factthat More may have been influenced by accounts <strong>of</strong> travels <strong>and</strong> discoveries madein the New world, such as those by Amerigo Vespucci. (Kumar, 1987, p. 23).More, later famously opposed Henry VII’s divorce <strong>of</strong> Catherine <strong>of</strong> Aragorn <strong>and</strong>was imprisoned in the Tower <strong>of</strong> London due to the stance he took on this issue<strong>and</strong> later executed. Later he was made a saint by the Vatican. (Picture from Ibid.p. 363, originally reproduced from Painting by Hans Holbein the Younger. TheFrick collection 12.1.77, New York.)


SCOPEThis reference is wide‐ranging <strong>and</strong> covers all sorts <strong>of</strong>information on utopias in literature including “… authors,characters, setting , themes, literary styles, <strong>and</strong> belief systems.”(p. xi) Some example authors are Jack London, George Orwell,Aldous Huxley, Margaret Atwood, Karl Capek. Some examples<strong>of</strong> texts mentioned are William Shakespeare’s “As You Like It”,Sir Thomas More’s Utopia, Henry David Thoreau’s Walden,Orwell’s Animal Farm <strong>and</strong> 1984 <strong>and</strong> many others. Somesubjects concerning utopia are also present such as women inutopia for example.William Shakespeare’s play As You Like It which takes place in the “forest <strong>of</strong> Arden” may beanother example <strong>of</strong> an early utopia. Much <strong>of</strong> the debate over whether or not Arden merelyreferred to the French Ardennes or whether or not it referred to an imaginary place issummarized at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/As_You_Like_It#Synopsis, where it states: Otheeditions keep Shakespeare's 'Arden' spelling, since it can be argued that the pastoral modedepicts a fantastical world in which geographical details are irrelevant. The Arden edition <strong>of</strong>Shakespeare makes the suggestion that the name 'Arden' comes from a combination <strong>of</strong> theclassical region <strong>of</strong> Arcadia <strong>and</strong> the biblical garden <strong>of</strong> Eden, as there is a strong interplay <strong>of</strong>classical <strong>and</strong> Christian belief systems <strong>and</strong> philosophies within the play.” Snodgrass (1995)seems to hold to the view that Arden is an example <strong>of</strong> a utopia. (Pictures from Snodgrass(1995), pgs 28, 30, originally reproduced From Polybion by Michael Drayton, 1613. Rare bookcollection, Library <strong>of</strong> Congress, Photograph by Florence V<strong>and</strong>amm. Performing Arts CollectionNew York Public Library.)


CURRENCYIt is only current up to 1995. As dealt withsubsequently under Authority/Review <strong>and</strong>Complementary Sources this means the book isnot real current, <strong>and</strong> it would be nice to see morein certain areas <strong>of</strong> the reference. It does,however, contain valid information for 1995,when it was published.Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra: He was born in 1547 <strong>and</strong> died in 1646. Hewrote Don Quixote de La Mancha (1604, 1615) which was about the exploits<strong>of</strong> Alonso Quixana, a retired gentleman who has an obsession with chivalricworks. I can see why Snodgrass (1995) included him in her reference work,due to the fact there are certain similarities inherent in Don Quixote de laMancha to some <strong>of</strong> the other works that Snodgrass (1995) seesrepresentative <strong>of</strong> early utopias. There is a single character who is trying tohearken back to something ‘ideal’ that has been lost, similar perhaps in someways to the w<strong>and</strong>ering main characters <strong>of</strong> the Aenied <strong>and</strong> Utopia. (Picturefrom Ibid., p. 104, reproduced from Culver Pictures.)


INTENDED PURPOSEIt is meant primarily as a guide to the use <strong>of</strong> the utopia connectedwith literature. Mainly probably aimed at a student <strong>of</strong> literaturealthough also containing a wide variety <strong>of</strong> somewhat anecdotalinformation on authors, themes, <strong>and</strong> styles. It presupposes to be aguide to utopias, dystopias, characters in utopias, etc. Yet it isperhaps unclear who exactly the book is aimed at. As is pointed outby Kristine J. Anderson in her review <strong>of</strong> this book in vol. 7 Iss. 2 in thejournal <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies, a review that I will also refer to later inReview/Authority although I will not quote directly from due to itscopyrighted re, the fact that in Books in Print it is listed asappropriate for young adults or a 14 <strong>and</strong> up audience indicates thatperhaps the intended purpose is for use by a younger audience thatmight not be as interested in a wide, comprehensive, <strong>and</strong> up to datetext on Utopias, as something that presents the subject in asomewhat simplistic manner. Perhaps this is why in defining thesubject <strong>of</strong> the utopia, as Anderson points out in her review there is apreponderance <strong>of</strong> reliance on lists, lists which are <strong>of</strong> a mostlyarbitrary nature regarding those texts Snodgrass (1995) thinks <strong>of</strong> as‘utopias’ or ‘utopian’ in nature. The book also has much relevancefor those looking for examples <strong>of</strong> ‘dystopian’ literature, yet thismaterial is presented without being grouped in a separate section.


ADDITIONAL PURPOSESSERVEDThis reference item could serve many additionalpurposes beyond the general purpose which has beenexamined. It could easily serve as the basis for a reportor perhaps even lecture, on some <strong>of</strong> themes therein. Itcan also serve as just interesting reading for someoneacquainted with the literature who is looking for moreinformation.Capek Karl: His writing, R.U.R. (Rossum’s Universal Robots) (1921)which was astage play coined the use <strong>of</strong> the term ‘robot’. Interestingly, according to the U<strong>of</strong> T at Austin as explained athttp://www.robotics.utexas.edu/rrg/learn_more/history/, the robots wereoriginally thought <strong>of</strong> as being created through chemical, not mechanical means.I don’t think Snodgrass (1995) mentions this fact nor the fact that it wasactually Karl’s brother Josef who originally coined the term (again seehttp://www.robotics.utexas.edu/rrg/learn_more/history/). Snodgrass’s (1995)inclusion <strong>of</strong> Capek Karl in her encyclopedia could be seen as indicative <strong>of</strong> theinclusion <strong>of</strong> dystopias or ‘utopias gone wrong’ in this text. (Picture: Snodgrass(1995), p. 99, reproduced from UPI/Bettmann.


FORMAT (S) It is in book form only. Its trim size is 27 cm. 817different copies are listed on Worldcat.Jack London: Well known for his writings about wolves <strong>and</strong> dogs, what is lessknown is that Jack London was also a writer who wrote several dystopias, The IronHeel (1907) <strong>and</strong> the novelette the Red One (1978) (published posthumously). Jackwas born in San Francisco in 1876 <strong>and</strong> grew up reading adventure authors such asRudyard Kipling. In adolescence he quit school <strong>and</strong> w<strong>and</strong>ered Oakl<strong>and</strong>’s slums insearch <strong>of</strong> his adolescent father. He later completed his education with theassistance <strong>of</strong> a library director <strong>of</strong> the Oakl<strong>and</strong> Public Library who had him read theclassics. As a teenager he sailed the Pacific on a tramp steamer, applying what hesaw <strong>and</strong> experienced to a later novel, The Sea Wolf (1904) He then went on tostudy philosophy at the University <strong>of</strong> California at Berkeley, becoming extremelyacquainted with the Communist Manifesto (1848) , Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels,Friedrich Nietzche, Charles Darwin, <strong>and</strong> Herbert Spencer. He went on to writemany books including the popular series which began with The Call <strong>of</strong> the Wild(1903). Comparing The Iron Heel (1907) with Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward,Kumar (1987) points out that “A markedly similar future society, based oncapitalist oligarchy, was pictured for America in Jack London’s... There too asocialist rising is defeated ; <strong>and</strong> although the book looks ahead to an eventualsocialist future, its strength lies in London’s remarkable anticipation <strong>of</strong> thetechniques <strong>of</strong> totalitarian fascism…” (Kumar, p. 128). This is the kind <strong>of</strong> criticalcommentary that Snodgrass’ (1995) text could use more <strong>of</strong> <strong>and</strong> is sorely lackingfrom the entry in that text on Jack London. (Picture from Snodgrass (1995), p. 321,originally reproduced from UPI/Bettman.)


SPECIAL FEATURES It contains a Preface, Introduction, Appendix A:Primary sources, Appendix B; Titles Featured inText, Appendix C; titles Featured in the Text,Listed by Date, Bibliography, <strong>and</strong> Illus. credits.


AUTHORITY/REVIEWOPINIONSI found several reviews <strong>of</strong> this text, primary amongst them was Anderson, Kristine J.,“<strong>Encyclopedia</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Utopian</strong> <strong>Literature</strong> (Book Review)” <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies , Vol. 7, Issue 2, 1996.which I will paraphrase from as the article itself is copyrighted by the Society for <strong>Utopian</strong>Studies . Anderson (1996) begins her review by looking at the fact that the <strong>Encyclopedia</strong> <strong>of</strong><strong>Utopian</strong> <strong>Literature</strong> is part <strong>of</strong> a series called “ABC‐CLIO Literary Companions” with the onlyother work she could find in the series being called The <strong>Encyclopedia</strong> <strong>of</strong> Traditional Epics byGuide M. Jackson which has subsequently been republished by Oxford paperbacks asTraditional Epics: A Literary Companion. Anderson then turns to remarking on the fact thatthe definition <strong>of</strong> a ‘utopia’ is somewhat lacking in Snodgrass’s (1995) work <strong>and</strong> that ratherthan a definition the subject <strong>of</strong> the ‘utopia’ is constructed by Snodgrass (1995), primarily inthe form <strong>of</strong> a list, thus favoring an approach which canonizes specific literature. (cont.)Animal Farm: This novel by George Orwell is a classic portrait <strong>of</strong> dystopia or an anti‐utopia orutopia gone wrong. Snodgrass (1995) does an excellent job <strong>of</strong> providing a summary <strong>and</strong>exploration <strong>of</strong> the themes <strong>of</strong> this lesser known <strong>and</strong> subsequently very controversial example <strong>of</strong>Orwell’s works. The novel concerns a primarily socialist revolution which takes place on a farm.Certain principles, known as the Seven comm<strong>and</strong>ments <strong>of</strong> Animalism are set up. Soon afterthe revolution the pigs take over although in the original novel initially it is snowball who leadsthe animals, <strong>and</strong> there is a countermove by the humans to retake control <strong>of</strong> the farm, duringwhich Boxer, the horse, strikes <strong>and</strong> kills a young boy. During subsequent events, Napoleonunseats Snowball using nine savage dogs, <strong>and</strong> what was to be utopian becomes anything but.At this point, the pigs basically take over, mimicking the things the humans previously did.Snodgrass (1995) in her analysis <strong>of</strong> this text makes the interesting point that “Orwell impliesthat the children born after world War II will lack a clear <strong>and</strong> honest picture <strong>of</strong> the dangers <strong>of</strong>totalitarianism <strong>and</strong> fascism , the destructive forces that propelled world leaders into global waragainst Hitler, Mussolini, <strong>and</strong> Tojo.” (Ibid, p. 22). Subsequently, two versions <strong>of</strong> the story weremade as popular films, one in 1954, which was animated <strong>and</strong> subsequently banned for release,<strong>and</strong> a later adaptation made in 1999 released on TNT. Picture from Snodgrass (1995), p. 20,originally reproduced from Orwell Archive, London.)


AUTHORITY/REVIEWS(CONT.)“Vigorously specific, the text is packed with details <strong>of</strong> plot, biography,publishing history, social context, <strong>and</strong> critical response. Each essay ends with astring <strong>of</strong> cross‐references to related articles within the work. The illustrationsare excellent… this is a useful source for public libraries. A somewhat moregeneral but related work <strong>of</strong> good reference value is Alberto Manguel’sDictionary <strong>of</strong> Imaginary Places.” (D’Aless<strong>and</strong>ro, 1980, p.62)Two additional works that Snodgrass has subsequently written are the<strong>Encyclopedia</strong> <strong>of</strong> Southern <strong>Literature</strong> (1997) <strong>and</strong> Signs <strong>of</strong> the Zodiac: A ReferenceGuide to Historical, Mythological, <strong>and</strong> cultural Associations (1997).1984: Rather than summarizing this novel, which Snodgrass (1995) does an excellent job <strong>of</strong> in herentry on this work, I’d like to suggest some other sources which provide interesting takes on theanti‐fascism <strong>and</strong> ‘socialism’ which stood behind Orwell’s famous work <strong>and</strong> are perhaps leading itto have increasing relevance today. In Kumar (1987) in “George Orwell <strong>and</strong> Nineteen Eighty‐Four” in Utopia & Anti‐Utopia in Modern Times it is argued effectively that the writing <strong>of</strong> 1984was not a move by Orwell away from socialism <strong>and</strong> the views <strong>of</strong> the British Labour Party butrather was meant as a critique <strong>of</strong> the “… perversions to which a centralized economy is liable <strong>and</strong>which have already been partly realized in Communism <strong>and</strong> Fascism…” (Orwell, 16 June 1949,Letter to Francis A Henson <strong>of</strong> the UAW, from Kumar (1987), p. 290) . Kumar (1987) attempts topoint to ways in which 1984 can be seen as ‘satire’ rather than ‘prophecy' with the purpose <strong>of</strong>the text being self‐evident in the words “don’t let it happen.” which were used by literary criticsin the late 1940s when the book came out. Kumar (1987), writing several years after 1984 intime, sees the satyrical aspects <strong>of</strong> the work to make it clear that the future <strong>of</strong> “doublethink” <strong>and</strong>“newsspeak” can be fought against because <strong>of</strong> the fact the work is not a prophetic work whichmakes many <strong>of</strong> the questions asked in 1984 as to whether society had become or was tending tobecome like Orwell’s novel, exactly the sort <strong>of</strong> ‘thought’ which Orwell wished to provoke.Another point <strong>of</strong> view, also from the 1980s ‐1990sis found in “Rethinking the Modernist Legacy inNineteen Eighty‐Four’ (cont.) (Picture from Snodgrass (1995), p. 385, originally reproduced fromFilm Stills Archive, Museum <strong>of</strong> Modern Art, New York.)


AUTHORITY/REVIEWS(CONT.)(1984 cont.)in The Revised Orwell, ed Jonathan Rose. Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, MI. 1992.Alex Zwerdling looks at why Orwell’s work has had an almost universalist appeal as opposed to Orwell’s lesswidely received previous works. Again, the issue <strong>of</strong> whether Orwell is trying to suggest something that couldhappen rather than will happen comes up which Zwerdling (1992) tries to deal with in terms <strong>of</strong> looking at why1984 has both popular appeal at the same time that it is <strong>of</strong> interest to highbrow readers as well. Zwerdling states:“The same strategic thinking went into Orwell’s decisions about the fictional technique <strong>and</strong> the language <strong>of</strong>Nineteen Eighty‐Four. A novel designed for a popular audience must have a strong plot, a sense <strong>of</strong> suspense, asingle continuous narrative line… On the other h<strong>and</strong>, intellectual readers have considerable contempt for a workthat does not allow them the leisure to think, that moves along too breathlessly <strong>and</strong> appeals to their childlikeeagerness to find out what happens next … Orwell’s solution to this problem is to write his novel in two differentfictional languages that are, in effect, interlaced in the text. There is the strong, narrative line… <strong>and</strong> there is thecool analytic line concerning the principles <strong>of</strong> the regime expounded in the two extracts from Goldstein’s book<strong>and</strong> in the appendix on the Principles <strong>of</strong> Newspeak.” (Zwerdling, 1992, p. 17). A more current analysis <strong>of</strong> Orwell’scommitment to lifelong socialism can be found in “George Orwell: Socialism <strong>and</strong> Utopia” by Richard White in<strong>Utopian</strong> Studies19.1 (Wntr 2008): 73(23) Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP.Gale.King County Library System. 28 May2008 . Which attempts to provide examples <strong>of</strong> the many instances in Orwell’s life <strong>and</strong> writings inwhich he was influenced by wanted to better the conditions <strong>of</strong> the working poor <strong>and</strong> the benefits <strong>of</strong> socialism forthe masses in general . A recent writing on current ramifications 1984 may have for the present can be found in abook review <strong>of</strong> Steve Cohen’s book Deportation is Freedom! The Orwellian World <strong>of</strong> Immigration Controls byJustin Nordstrom in <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies 18.2 (Spring 2007) 270(4) Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP. Gale. King CountyLibrary System 30 May 2008 which is a balancedreview which looks at what ways Cohen is applying ideas found in Orwell to what he perceives as the dystopi<strong>and</strong>ilemma <strong>of</strong> increasing immigration restrictions.


PERSONAL IMPRESSIONMy personal impression is that while at first glance this seems to bea comprehensive reference on utopian literature, upon furtherperusal it is lacking in some aspects <strong>and</strong> there are areas where I wishit went further. In preparing this powerpoint presentation, in theareas that accompany <strong>and</strong> explain the pictures, in some cases I havetried to supplement the text Snodgrass (1995) supplies with more upto date references <strong>and</strong> information. I think, the fact I have had to dothis perhaps points to what in fact is needed is a more currentreference or the creation <strong>of</strong> a new edition <strong>of</strong> this work to reflectcurrent research being done in the area <strong>of</strong> utopian literary studies,including topics such as feminism <strong>and</strong> utopia, postmodernism <strong>and</strong>utopia, <strong>and</strong> studies <strong>of</strong> other anti‐utopianism in modern literatureincluding more recent works <strong>of</strong> science fiction with anti‐utopias likeThe Running Man (1985) by Stephen King for example, or examples<strong>of</strong> cyberpunk dystopias which are nowhere present in the text <strong>of</strong>Snodgrass (1995) as found for example, in the book Neuromancer(1984) by Canadian science fiction writer William Gibson. However,Snodgrass (1995) does have some good areas where some <strong>of</strong> theentries are concerned. There are good summaries <strong>of</strong> 1984 <strong>and</strong>Fahrenheit 451 <strong>and</strong> there is useful information on many otherutopian writers <strong>and</strong> concepts as well.


Fahrenheit 451 which originally appeared as “The Fireman” in Galaxy Science Fictionis about guy Montag, a fireman in the future who burns books for the state ratherthan helping to save people’s homes. His helmet has the number 451 on it, which isthe temperature at which paper burns. Guy meets Clarisse McClellan , a neighborwho is 17 years old <strong>and</strong> asks if Guy is happy. The same evening, when Guy returnshome to his estranged wife, he discovers that she has taken 30 or 40 pills <strong>and</strong> has tohave her blood purified. This all challenges his perceptions <strong>of</strong> himself <strong>and</strong> leads himto turn to books in response to the changes he sees in his society <strong>and</strong> in his own life.While performing his job , in a disquieting scene, Mrs. Blake sets herself afire with akitchen‐match. Amongst her books, the book‐burners have come to destroy. Guyfinds out the Clarisse was hit by a car <strong>and</strong> that her family moved away. Guy becomessick <strong>and</strong> receives a visit from his boss Beatty. Guy quits his job as a book‐burner <strong>and</strong>reveals to his wife his cache <strong>of</strong> books, but does not receive the response heexpected. Montag then goes to visit a retired English pr<strong>of</strong>essor named Faber. Theyconcoct a scheme to get at the book‐burners by using their own tactics against them.Faber gives Guy an electronic hearing device. Guy avoids going back to his job, untilnear the end <strong>of</strong> the novel he has another confrontation with Beatty, which results(cont.)PERSONAL IMPRESSIONRay Bradbury <strong>and</strong> Fahrenheit 451: Ray Bradbury, a science fiction writer who is asSnodgrass (1995) points out a “… writer, fantasist, visionary, <strong>and</strong> moralist…” (p. 73) isa publishing author <strong>of</strong> “… short stories, screen <strong>and</strong> stage plays, poems, novels,criticism, social commentary, children’s literature, <strong>and</strong> television adaptations.”(p.73). He was born Raymond Douglas Bradbury, but has also written under thepseudonyms <strong>of</strong> Leonard Spaulding, the name <strong>of</strong> his father, <strong>and</strong> Douglas Spaulding<strong>and</strong> his writings can be found in over 700 anthologies (as <strong>of</strong> when Snodgrass (1995)was published, now possibly more). He wrote many novels <strong>and</strong> stories including“there Will Come s<strong>of</strong>t Rains” (1950), The Martian Chronicles (1950), The IllustratedMan (1951), D<strong>and</strong>elion Wine (1957), Something Wicked this Way Comes (12962), R isfor Rocket (1962), I Sing the Body Electric (1969), <strong>and</strong> Fahrenheit 451 (1953).


PERSONAL IMPRESSIONRay Bradbury <strong>and</strong> Fahrenheit 451 (cont.) in Montag accompanying thefiremen to his own house where Guy burns his own house <strong>and</strong> his ownbooks. When Beatty arrests Guy, Guy uses his flamethrower on his owncaptain, <strong>and</strong> flees. He later watches an innocent man be captured in place<strong>of</strong> him on television then merges with a group <strong>of</strong> individuals whomemorize books so as to preserve their ideas for the future.The story associated with the book’s creation which Snodgrass (1995)relates has long been that Bradbury produced the work working on a rentaltypewriter in the Los Angeles Public Library. However, a recent book whichhas come out called Match to Flame: The Fictional Paths to Fahrenheit 451Albright, Donn <strong>and</strong> Jon Eller ed. which collects earlier writings by Bradburywhich may have had some influence <strong>and</strong> share some <strong>of</strong> the themes <strong>of</strong>Fahrenheit 451. There was also a version filmed by Francois Truffaut in1966. (Pictures on previous slide: Snodgrass (1995), pgs. 74, 211,originally reproduced from UPI/Bettmann <strong>and</strong> Film Stills Archive, Museum<strong>of</strong> Modern Art, New York.)


EXAMPLES TYPIFYINGREFERENCE USESStudent: I’m doing a report on George Orwell.What can I look at about Orwell that will tell meabout his life, work, <strong>and</strong> further adaptationsbased on his work.Researcher: I need a reference that will give mean overview <strong>of</strong> the use <strong>of</strong> utopia in literature,from its earliest use to modern times.Interested Reader: I just read Fahrenheit 451. I’minterested in knowing more about Ray Bradbury.Where can I look?


COMPLEMENTARYSOURCESOne book that Snodgrass (1995) seems to be <strong>of</strong>t compared to, as it was in one review Imentioned, is Alberto Manguel &Gianni Guadalupi’s Dictionary <strong>of</strong> Imaginary Places. NewYork: Harcourt Brace. 2000.However, there are many other resources which can easily be accessed which can provideinformation on utopian literature <strong>and</strong> can be useful in supplementing one’s underst<strong>and</strong>ing<strong>of</strong> the subject beyond what is presented in Snodgrass’s text. One <strong>of</strong> these is KrishanKumar’s Utopia & Anti‐Utopia in Modern Times. Great Britain. Basil Blackwell Ltd. 1987,which is not a reference book, but is an excellent introduction <strong>and</strong> analysis <strong>of</strong> the topiccovering the presence <strong>of</strong> the ‘Utopia’ in literature over time. In this presentation, I haveused Kumar (1987) in order to supplement the information presented by Snodgrass (1995)in some respects.Another excellent source <strong>of</strong> information is the reviews <strong>and</strong> articles contained in <strong>Utopian</strong>Studies, presented <strong>and</strong> copyrighted by the Center For <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. For example, in theSpring 1998 issue there are several articles on postmodern applications <strong>of</strong> ‘utopia’ as foundin the works <strong>of</strong> Fredric Jameson, postmodernism <strong>and</strong> ‘utopia’ being something thatSnodgrass (1995) never covers in her text.MOYLAN, TOM. "Jameson <strong>and</strong> Utopia. " <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. (Spring 1998): 1(1). Exp<strong>and</strong>edAcademic ASAP.Gale.King County Library System. 28 May 2008.


COMPLEMENTARYSOURCESFITTING, PETER. "The Concept <strong>of</strong> Utopia in the Work <strong>of</strong> Fredric Jameson. " <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. (Spring1998): 8(1). Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP.Gale.King County Library System. 28 May 2008.BUCHANAN, IAN. "Metacommentary on Utopia, or Jameson's dialectic <strong>of</strong> hope. " <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. (Spring1998): 18(1). Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP.Gale.King County Library System. 28 May 2008.VON BOECKMANN, STACI L. "Marxism, Morality, <strong>and</strong> the Politics <strong>of</strong> Desire: <strong>Utopian</strong>ism in Fredric Jameson'sThe Political Unconscious. " <strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. (Spring 1998): 31(1). Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP.Gale.KingCounty Library System. 28 May 2008.Finally, the following article also compares 1984 to the novel The Running Man by Stephen King which isnowhere mentioned or given an entry in Snodgrass (1995):TEXTER, DOUGLAS W. .""A funny thinghappened on the way to the dystopia": the culture industry's neutralization <strong>of</strong> Stephen King's The RunningMan.(Critical essay).."<strong>Utopian</strong> Studies. 18.1 (Wntr 2007): 43(30). Exp<strong>and</strong>ed Academic ASAP.Gale.KingCounty Library System. 28 May 2008 .


COMPLEMENTARYSOURCESWomen in Utopia: The section on Women in Utopia in Snodgrass (1995) looks at many <strong>of</strong> thewomen who have appeared in utopian literature. Snodgrass begins by stating that, “<strong>Utopian</strong>literature… has made no formal gesture toward real women’s needs or the need for real womenas planners <strong>and</strong> equal partners in a perfect world. “(p. 561) She presents “goddesses(Persephone… expendable wives… daughters… mistresses… consorts to wise philosopher –kings…dreamy‐eyed seers… Cumaean Sibyl… h<strong>and</strong>maids… shepherdesses… camp followers <strong>and</strong>barkeeps…. Or unnamed slaves” (Ibid.) as all examples <strong>of</strong> women found in utopias in the heroicliterature. She then looks at some examples <strong>of</strong> women drawn from religious literature. Then, shestates that “A separate class <strong>of</strong> idolized women provides a romantic focus in utopian lore <strong>of</strong> theRenaissance …stories <strong>of</strong> Queen Guinevere <strong>and</strong> Elaine tread the predetermined patriarchal path <strong>of</strong>the elevated “lady” … Women in Arthurian settings lack policy‐making power <strong>and</strong> expend theirtalents in subservient roles, e. g., as nurses aboard King Arthur’s barge, bargaining chips formarriage agreements, <strong>and</strong> producers <strong>of</strong> male heirs, an accomplishment denied to Arthur’s ill‐fatedqueen.” (p. 562) Snodgrass (1995) then looks at womens’ roles in Pilgrim’s Progress (1678) <strong>and</strong>Thomas More’s Utopia (1516) Dona Dulcinea sdel Toboso in Don Quixote (1604, 1615), examples<strong>of</strong> women drawn from such diverse the coming Race (1871), A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’sCourt (1886), <strong>and</strong> the time Machine (1895). Snodgrass (1995) then looks at the fact that womenfeature prominently in many anti‐utopia stories such as Helena Glory Domin in R.U.R. O inZamyatin’s We, a forerunner <strong>of</strong> Orwell’s 1984 in which one finds Julia turning her charms onWinston, not to mention Mollie in Animal Farm (1945), Linda <strong>and</strong> Lenina Crowe in Brave NewWorld (1932) <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> course, Clarisse, in Fahrenheit 451. Snodgrass (1995) does not limit heranalysis merely to female characters in utopian literature though, but also looks at one prominentfemale writer, Margaret Atwood <strong>and</strong> her book The H<strong>and</strong>maid’s Tale 1985) which has within it inher words, “… the twentieth‐century’s most enduringly feminist survivalist heroine.” (p. 566).(Pictures from Snodgrass (1995), pgs 40, 567, originally reproduced from Reuters/Bettmann, LaBelle Iseult (Queen Guinevere) by William Morris (1858). Tate Gallery, London/Art Resource/NewYork.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!