Rethink Runoff Research Essay Score Sheet

2012–2013Rethink Runoff Research EssayScore Sheet (0-75 points)Directions: Check the appropriate box and thenplace score in right hand score column.Judge’s Name:Future City Name:Organization Name:0 No PointsRequirements missing.1 PoorFulfills less than 50% ofrequirements.2 GoodFulfills at least 90% ofrequirements.3 ExcellentFulfills 100% of requirements.Additional distinctivefeatures.I. DEFINE THE PROBLEM (9 points) 0 1 2 3 SCORE1. Describe current situation: Describe runoff situation and factors affecting runoff:geographic and man-made2. Identify the problem to solve: Identify most significant problem3. Why choose this problem: Impact on city development (residential, commercial,industrial); why is this importantII. Propose Solution, Technology (9 points) 0 1 2 3 SCORE4. Propose solution: Describe at least one solution/process to manage runoff5. Describe technology involved6. Community Outreach and buy-in: Educational programs and incentivesIII. ANAYLZE THE SOLUTION (17 points) 0 1 2 3 SCORE7. How are two issues affected by solution: Consider infiltration, impervious surfaces,water quality, water conservation, sustainability8. Benefits – environment: Reduce runoff, increase filtration; improve water quality,reduce pollution9. Benefits – sustainability: Water conservation, supporting population and developmentgrowth10. Risks associated with solution11. Tradeoffs: Discuss & analyze tradeoffs (e.g., cost efficiency, appearance)IV. ASSESS THE TECHNOLOGY (21 points) 0 1 2 3 SCORE12. Innovative solution13. Futuristic solution14. Plausibility of Solution: Based on sound scientific principles15. Accounting for identified risks2012–2013 Future City Judges Manual