20.04.2016 Views

Societal Monthly

Take a look at societies fears and desires represented through the hit TV show "Game of Thrones".

Take a look at societies fears and desires represented through the hit TV show "Game of Thrones".

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

In this issue:<br />

SOCIETAL MONTHLY<br />

<strong>Societal</strong> Fears and Desires Represented in<br />

Game of Thrones<br />

Fears<br />

Xenophobia and Racism<br />

-Mexico, Illegal Aliens and Syrian Refugees in America<br />

War<br />

- America vs. Muslims after 9/11, The War on Terror,<br />

People of color vs. the Police<br />

Desires<br />

Freedom<br />

-The human need for autonomy, the American want/right of<br />

freedom, fear of losing our freedom (freedom of speech,<br />

freedom to carry guns).<br />

Stability<br />

-America’s desire for a stable job, home, income, life and<br />

mind.<br />

Justice & Revenge<br />

-Jails, school shooting and the eye for an eye mentality.


Fear tends to change the way that<br />

we think so that we can avoid things<br />

that will make us even more fearful.<br />

It leads us to shut others out who do<br />

not look or act like us, and can drive<br />

us to irrational thinking and stereotyping.<br />

These consequences of fear<br />

are why xenophobia and racism are<br />

so prevalent in our society and why<br />

our fear of others unlike us is one of<br />

our biggest societal aversions.<br />

<strong>Societal</strong> Representations:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

The arguments being used in some of the current<br />

political campaigns as well as the notion to keep<br />

out Syrian refugees.<br />

The societal attitude towards Mexico and illegal<br />

aliens has become increasingly hostile. Many feel<br />

as if they should not be helped or cared for, but<br />

simply sent home “where they belong”.<br />

An us versus them attitude has begun to emerge<br />

through the idea of a literal wall being built between<br />

America and Mexico. This shows we are<br />

“us” and they are “them”, and we do not welcome<br />

or want “them”, which feeds into our xenophobia<br />

as a society.<br />

Representations in Game of Thrones:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Those in Game of Thrones literally took a page<br />

out of Donald Trump’s book and built a massive<br />

wall to keep the “others” (white walkers and wildlings)<br />

out.<br />

The night’s watch are extremely xenophobic towards<br />

the wildlings and would rather let them die<br />

than help them and let them onto their land, much<br />

like with illegal aliens and the Syrian refugees.<br />

At one point Jon Snow asks his men to allow the<br />

wildlings to pass through because otherwise thousands<br />

of them will die, to which one man replies<br />

“Let them die, we have our own to worry<br />

about”.<br />

Watch a video showing the xenophobic relationship between the Night’s Watch and the Wildlings here:<br />

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wnKlAb4ODKg&nohtml5=False


W<br />

A<br />

R<br />

Our fear of war is both literal and figurative, and has<br />

been brought about by the multiple types of “war” going<br />

on within our society for decades. When given cause,<br />

whether it be through attacks of radicals, media hype, or<br />

an unnecessary<br />

death, hate and fear<br />

erupts throughout<br />

society which leads<br />

to war. We have<br />

seen these types of<br />

war break out time<br />

and time again,<br />

striking fear into the<br />

heart of society.<br />

<strong>Societal</strong> Representations:<br />

<br />

<br />

One example would be America versus Muslims after 9/11. This lead to the<br />

“War on Terror” which caused great terror in itself. Rather than looking at the<br />

situation as America versus Al Qaeda, it became “real Americans” versus Muslims<br />

as attacks on Muslims and Mosques skyrocketed.<br />

Another example would be the Black Lives Matter movement which represents<br />

Black Americans against the police and unequal treatment. There has been an<br />

outcry from both sides of this war with people of color being upset over their<br />

treatment and many whites wanting to silence the movement by saying that all<br />

lives matter. People in America often fear these “wars” because war often<br />

leads to change depending on who wins, and those who are on top often want<br />

to stay on top.<br />

Representations in Game of Thrones:<br />

<br />

One of the biggest representations of the societal fear of war in Game of<br />

Thrones happened with the beheading of Ned Stark. Things had finally seemed<br />

to be stable in the seven kingdoms, and Ned was doing what he knew was best<br />

for his family and his kingdom. His untimely death at the hands of Joffrey the<br />

irrational and clearly mad king sent the kingdom into an uproar. Everyone<br />

feared for the worst, especially his privileged family who no longer felt safe in<br />

a place where they had once been on top because they were now the disadvantaged<br />

group. This is the exact fear that most privileged white people in today’s<br />

society have, played out on the screen for them to see.


<strong>Societal</strong> Representations:<br />

<br />

<br />

Freedom is in our constitution and is a<br />

part of our everyday lives. It is a right<br />

that we cling to desperately, and it is often<br />

the infringement of freedom in one<br />

form or another that leads to the wars<br />

that society fears as a whole<br />

The topics of freedom to marry who we<br />

want (gay rights) and the freedom for<br />

women to do what they want with their<br />

bodies (abortion and the de-funding of<br />

planned parenthood) are a<br />

few topics that illustrate our<br />

desire for freedom.<br />

Representations in Game of Thrones:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

Daenerys– In the beginning of her story<br />

she was controlled by her brother and<br />

wished for her freedom. She was forced<br />

into an unwanted marriage and was given<br />

no autonomy in her life. However<br />

she is now a queen who grants others<br />

their freedom by liberating slave states.<br />

Tyrion– He wants to be free of the responsibilities<br />

and stigma that come with<br />

his last name and wants to be free of his<br />

father and sister.<br />

Jamie and Cersei– They simply want to<br />

be free to love each other and live their<br />

lives.<br />

Freedom<br />

There are three fundamental psychological human needs: relatedness,<br />

competence and autonomy. Although they are all important to be<br />

happy and fulfilled, autonomy is the most important of the three. Therefore,<br />

one of our strongest societal desires is freedom. There is a reason<br />

why America is referred to as the land of the free and the home of the<br />

brave, and Americans take their freedom very seriously. As Americans<br />

this desire is closely tied with our fears, because we hold the right to be<br />

free above all else and therefore fear losing our freedom.


Stability<br />

The stability that we desire as a society can also be abstract or concrete.<br />

As Americans we desire a stable government and job as well as a<br />

stable income. As humans we also desire a stable mind, a stable life and<br />

stable health. We search for stability in<br />

our relationships with other people because<br />

we want the comfort and ease of<br />

mind that often comes with it. According<br />

to the Bhagavad Gita the outcome of<br />

mental stability is immediate clarity of<br />

thought and intelligence and therefore if<br />

we have stability of mind it will bring<br />

about “undisturbed peace and unending<br />

calm” which does not allow sorrow to<br />

bother you.<br />

<strong>Societal</strong> Representations:<br />

<br />

America is not too far out of a recession in<br />

which many people’s stable lives were<br />

turned upside down. Jobs and homes that<br />

were once stable were shattered and lost,<br />

and people not only fear that loss again, but<br />

desire to keep the stability that they have<br />

rebuilt. Therefore as a society we are<br />

searching for stability in our lives and in our<br />

mind to bring us peace in this ever changing<br />

time. Even our environment has become<br />

unstable with the threat of global warming<br />

and mass extinction. We also have candidates<br />

like Trump and Sanders running for<br />

president who want to change so much<br />

about our country and society.<br />

Representations in Game of Thrones:<br />

<br />

Stability seems to be an elusive desire for<br />

Margaery, with her first seeking it in marrying<br />

King Joffrey and securing herself in the<br />

secure position as queen. However, when he<br />

dies on their wedding day she is forced to<br />

work her way back into the marriage bed<br />

with his younger brother Tommen. This<br />

same incident uprooted the little bit of stability<br />

that Cersei had built for herself in King’s<br />

Landing, as the death of her oldest son left<br />

her mental state in shambles. Margaery’s<br />

foundation is once again shaken when she is<br />

arrested for knowing that her brother Loris is<br />

gay, which finally begins to chip away at her<br />

mental stability.


<strong>Societal</strong> Representations:<br />

<br />

We have seen this concept played out in school<br />

shootings such as Columbine and others where<br />

kids felt bullied or that they had been labeled as an<br />

outcast, and so they exacted their revenge. As a<br />

whole, our society wants to see people get what<br />

they deserve and pay for what they have done.<br />

This is why jails and the death penalty still exist,<br />

and why we love movies like Taken and Braveheart.<br />

We root for justice and revenge, and we<br />

want to see the bad guy get taken down.<br />

Representations in Game of Thrones:<br />

<br />

<br />

The death of Joffrey was one death that felt so deserved<br />

and had so much revenge behind it that all<br />

who have been emotionally invested in the show<br />

gave a standing ovation. The bad guy had finally<br />

gotten what was coming to him, and everyone was<br />

elated. It seemed that Joffrey had done so much<br />

wrong that the only right thing to do was to kill<br />

him. His death was revenge for Ned Stark, and<br />

for all of his wrong doings that had made audiences<br />

and characters in the show love to hate him.<br />

Rob Stark, Ned’s son, set out to exact revenge on<br />

Joffrey and take his throne. He knew there would<br />

be no justice for his father unless he made it for<br />

himself, and in the end Rob’s murder along with<br />

the murder of his pregnant wife and the majority<br />

of his family made Joffrey even more hated and<br />

fueled our want for revenge as viewers, as well as<br />

for those in the show.<br />

These two concepts are linked in numerous<br />

ways, and in our society it is seldom<br />

to find one without the other. Justice<br />

refers to the concept of giving someone<br />

what they deserve, and is related to<br />

revenge in the sense that through justice<br />

comes revenge. When justice is not<br />

served to our liking, or we do not feel<br />

satisfied with the justice that was served,<br />

that is when we turn to revenge. Many<br />

within our society have the eye for an<br />

eye viewpoint, and when the mob mentality<br />

kicks in or when people feel they<br />

have been wronged justice and revenge<br />

are concepts that almost anyone would<br />

be on board for.


In Conclusion<br />

Why do we need to see these fears and desires played out on our<br />

screen for us to view?<br />

For some of these desires and fears the answer is quite obvious, we<br />

cannot always achieve them in real life, thus we feel the need to satisfy our<br />

desires and fears by finding them in our entertainment. For example, revenge<br />

or justice may not always be applicable in the way that we would prefer so<br />

watching the characters in Game of Thrones exact their revenge on those in<br />

the show that we hate can help to satisfy our thirst for these societal desires.<br />

Expressing xenophobia and racism is not always considered acceptable within<br />

our society and therefore we feel that we need this show in our politically correct<br />

world to satisfy us. As humans we tend to search for connection and relatedness,<br />

thus through watching our own desires and fears in Game of<br />

Thrones we are able to relate to the characters and their struggles. Our societal<br />

fears and desires are the inspiration for the types of shows that are presented<br />

to us, with some like Game of Thrones being better representations that<br />

others making them more likely to be popular. People see their own fears and<br />

desires played out before them in Game of Thrones, and can consequently satisfy<br />

the freedom, stability and justice/revenge that they desire and the xenophobia/racism<br />

and war that they fear.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!