30.04.2016 Views

ANNUAL%20REPORT%202015%20eng

ANNUAL%20REPORT%202015%20eng

ANNUAL%20REPORT%202015%20eng

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

(Incorporated in the Cayman Islands with limited liability)<br />

Stock Code: 975<br />

Annual Report<br />

2015


Contents<br />

Company Profile 2<br />

Corporate Information 4<br />

Directors and Senior Management 6<br />

Group Structure 14<br />

Chairman’s Statement 15<br />

Management Discussion and Analysis 17<br />

Sustainability Report 52<br />

Corporate Governance Report 77<br />

Directors’ Report 88<br />

Independent Auditor’s Report 107<br />

Consolidated Statement of Profit or Loss 109<br />

Consolidated Statement of Profit or Loss and<br />

Other Comprehensive Income 110<br />

Consolidated Statement of Financial Position 111<br />

Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity 113<br />

Consolidated Cash Flow Statement 114<br />

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 116<br />

Financial Summary 197<br />

Glossary and Technical Terms 199<br />

Appendix I 204<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

1


Company Profile<br />

Mongolian Mining Corporation (“MMC”<br />

or the “Company” and together with its<br />

subsidiaries, the “Group”) (Stock Code:<br />

975) is the largest producer and exporter<br />

of washed hard coking coal (“HCC”) in<br />

Mongolia. MMC owns and operates the<br />

Ukhaa Khudag (“UHG”) and the Baruun<br />

Naran (“BN”) open-pit coking coal mines,<br />

both located in the Umnugobi aimag<br />

(South Gobi province), Mongolia.<br />

2<br />

Annual Report 2015


Company Profile<br />

MISSION, VISION AND VALUES<br />

Our mission:<br />

To undertake safe and profitable mining and processing of mineral resources while promoting the development of<br />

Mongolia, through combination of modern technology and human endeavor<br />

Our vision:<br />

We strive to become a leading mining company in the region by maximising value for our shareholders and for the<br />

communities where we operate<br />

Our values and objectives:<br />

We recognise that people are our key asset. Therefore:<br />

• MMC places the safety of our personnel the highest priority<br />

• As a responsible employer, MMC provides equal employment opportunities within a meritocratic workplace<br />

We believe that modern and cost-efficient technology will bring sustainable growth and prosperity. Therefore:<br />

• MMC aims to use technology and innovate in the same to produce quality products safely at the lowest cost<br />

• MMC continues to contribute to the development of technical standards in the global extractive industry<br />

We are committed to environmental sustainability in our operations. Therefore:<br />

• MMC strives to minimise the impact on the environment<br />

• MMC complies with all required environmental standards, and takes further measures to prevent and<br />

mitigate potential environmental impact<br />

We are committed to socially responsible mining practices. Therefore:<br />

• MMC strives to build mutually beneficial relationships with local communities and officials<br />

• MMC contributes to social development through community development initiatives and other programs<br />

We are committed to transparent and fair business practices. Therefore:<br />

• MMC fosters mutually beneficial relationships with our suppliers and contractors<br />

• MMC develops, maintains and values long-term relationships with our customers<br />

We believe sound corporate governance is a cornerstone of MMC’s management and operations. Therefore:<br />

• MMC complies with the best international practices<br />

• MMC continues to cultivate a culture of corporate governance as an integral part of its ongoing<br />

organisational development<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

3


Corporate Information<br />

BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />

Executive Directors<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts (Chairman)<br />

Battsengel Gotov (Chief Executive Officer)<br />

Non-Executive Directors<br />

Oyungerel Janchiv<br />

Od Jambaljamts<br />

Gankhuyag Adilbish<br />

Independent Non-Executive Directors<br />

Khashchuluun Chuluundorj<br />

Unenbat Jigjid<br />

Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius<br />

REGISTERED OFFICE<br />

Cricket Square, Hutchins Drive<br />

PO Box 2681<br />

Grand Cayman, KY1-1111<br />

Cayman Islands<br />

PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS<br />

IN HONG KONG<br />

Level 54, Hopewell Centre<br />

183 Queen’s Road East<br />

Hong Kong<br />

HEADQUARTERS AND PRINCIPAL<br />

PLACE OF BUSINESS<br />

IN MONGOLIA<br />

16th Floor, Central Tower<br />

Sukhbaatar District<br />

Ulaanbaatar 14200<br />

Mongolia<br />

COMPANY SECRETARY<br />

Ng Sin Yee, Clare<br />

INDEPENDENT AUDITOR<br />

KPMG<br />

8th Floor, Prince’s Building<br />

10 Chater Road<br />

Central, Hong Kong<br />

AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVES<br />

Battsengel Gotov<br />

Ng Sin Yee, Clare<br />

LEGAL ADVISERS<br />

Davis Polk & Wardwell<br />

18th Floor, The Hong Kong Club Building<br />

3A Chater Road, Hong Kong<br />

Economic & Legal Consultancy LLP<br />

6th Floor, Shonkhor Tower<br />

Genden Street 16<br />

Sukhbaatar District<br />

Ulaanbaatar 211213<br />

Mongolia<br />

Conyers Dill & Pearman<br />

2901, One Exchange Square<br />

8 Connaught Place<br />

Central, Hong Kong<br />

PRINCIPAL SHARE REGISTRAR<br />

AND TRANSFER OFFICE<br />

Royal Bank of Canada Trust Company (Cayman)<br />

Limited<br />

4th Floor, Royal Bank House<br />

24 Shedden Road, George Town<br />

Grand Cayman KY1-1110<br />

Cayman Islands<br />

4<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Information<br />

HONG KONG SHARE REGISTRAR<br />

Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited<br />

Shops 1712-1716, 17th Floor<br />

Hopewell Centre<br />

183 Queen’s Road East<br />

Wanchai, Hong Kong<br />

COMPANY WEBSITE<br />

www.mmc.mn<br />

STOCK CODE<br />

975<br />

PRINCIPAL BANKERS<br />

EBRD – European Bank for Reconstruction<br />

and Development, London, United Kingdom<br />

FMO – Nederlandse Financierings-Maatschappij voor<br />

Ontwikkelingslanden N.V.<br />

(Entrepreneurial Development Bank of Netherlands)<br />

DEG – Deutsche Investitions-und<br />

Entwicklungsgesellschaft mbH<br />

(The German Investment and Development Company)<br />

BNP Paribas, Singapore Branch<br />

Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited<br />

The Bank of East Asia, Limited, Hong Kong<br />

Standard Chartered Bank (Hong Kong) Limited<br />

Golomt Bank of Mongolia<br />

Khan Bank of Mongolia<br />

Trade and Development Bank of Mongolia<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

5


Directors and Senior Management<br />

BOARD OF DIRECTORS (THE “BOARD”)<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts, aged 50, is an executive Director and Chairman of the<br />

Board. Mr. Jambaljamts was appointed as an executive Director of the Company on<br />

18 May 2010. Mr. Jambaljamts is also the Chairman of the Nomination Committee<br />

and member of the Remuneration Committee. From 1993 to the present, Mr.<br />

Jambaljamts has been the Chairman of MCS Holding LLC (a controlling shareholder<br />

of the Company, and together with its subsidiaries, the “MCS Group”). Mr.<br />

Jambaljamts has been a director of Starain Limited since January 2011, director of<br />

Novel International Investment Limited and director of Novel Holdings Group Limited,<br />

a controlling shareholder of the Company, since March 2012. He was appointed as<br />

a director of MCS (Mongolia) Limited, MCS Mining Group Limited and MCS Global<br />

Limited since July 2012, all of which are controlling shareholders of the Company.<br />

Mr. Jambaljamts is the brother of Mr. Od Jambaljamts, a non-executive Director and<br />

controlling shareholder of the Company. From 1989 to 1991, Mr. Jambaljamts was<br />

an automation engineer at the Energy Authority of Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. From 1992<br />

to 1993, he was an economist at the Hydropower LLC for the Project of Egiin River.<br />

Mr. Jambaljamts was awarded a bachelor’s degree in cybernetics of electrical system<br />

by the Kiev Polytechnic Institute, Ukraine, and holds his master’s degree in business<br />

administration from the Maastricht School of Management, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia.<br />

Battsengel Gotov, aged 43, is an executive Director and Chief Executive Officer of<br />

the Company. Dr. Gotov was appointed as an executive Director of the Company<br />

on 18 May 2010. He joined the Group in June 2008 as the Chief Executive Officer<br />

of Energy Resources LLC. Since 2004, Dr. Gotov has served at various managerial<br />

positions in the MCS Group. He was appointed as the Chief Executive Officer of<br />

Khangad Exploration LLC on 7 December 2012. From 1996 to 2000, Dr. Gotov<br />

was an Assistant Professor at Comenius University in Bratislava. He moved to the<br />

University of Cologne, Germany in September 2000 as a research fellow sponsored<br />

by the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, and stayed at the University of Cologne<br />

from September 2000 until October 2003 as a postdoctoral fellow. Dr. Gotov is a<br />

board member of the Mongolian National Mining Association. He was appointed as<br />

a member of the Mineral Resources Policy Council on 7 October 2014. Dr. Gotov<br />

was awarded a master’s degree in science and a PhD in organic chemistry by the<br />

Comenius University, Slovakia.<br />

6<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Oyungerel Janchiv, aged 61, is a non-executive Director of the Company. She<br />

was appointed as a non-executive Director of the Company on 16 September 2010.<br />

Between 1979 and 1982, Dr. Janchiv served as a petroleum economist at the Oil<br />

Supply Management Authority. From 1982 to 1990, she served as an engineer and a<br />

chief economist at the Oil Supply Management Authority. From 1990 to 1996, she was<br />

the chief executive officer of the board of directors of the Neft Import Concern and<br />

was responsible for managing the importation and distribution of petroleum products.<br />

From 1996 to 2008, she was the chief executive officer of Petrovis LLC. Since 2008,<br />

Dr. Janchiv has been the chairperson of Petrovis LLC, the largest petroleum import<br />

and distribution company in Mongolia. She is also the largest shareholder of Petrovis<br />

Matad Inc. which is the largest shareholder of Petro Matad Limited which is listed on<br />

the Alternative Investment Market of the London Stock Exchange. Since September<br />

2012, Dr. Janchiv has been the deputy chair of Petro Matad Limited and she was<br />

appointed as the acting chairperson of Petro Matad Limited in November 2014 and<br />

non-executive director of the board of Petro Matad Limited in August 2015. Dr.<br />

Janchiv was awarded a diploma of engineer-economist for the petroleum and gas<br />

industry and a PhD by the Gubkin State University of Oil and Gas in Moscow, Russia.<br />

Od Jambaljamts, aged 51, is a non-executive Director of the Company. Mr.<br />

Jambaljamts was appointed as a non-executive Director of the Company on 4<br />

July 2012. He is also a member of the Corporate Governance Committee. Mr.<br />

Jambaljamts is the president of MCS Group and a director of a number of subsidiaries<br />

within the MCS Group. He was appointed as the president of Ulaanbaatar Chamber<br />

of Commerce in March 2015. He also works as the Honorary Council General of<br />

Denmark. Mr. Jambaljamts has over 20 years of experience in both private and public<br />

sectors and has extensive experience in working with companies in a diversity of<br />

fields. Mr. Jambaljamts is the brother of Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, the Chairman of<br />

the Board, an executive Director and a controlling shareholder of the Company. Mr.<br />

Jambaljamts is also a director of MCS (Mongolia) Limited, MCS Mining Group Limited<br />

and MCS Global Limited since July 2012 and director of Trimunkh Limited since July<br />

2011, all of which are controlling shareholders of the Company. Mr. Jambaljamts was<br />

awarded a bachelor’s degree in International Relations by the Institute for International<br />

Relations, Moscow, Russia in 1988 and master’s degree in arts majoring in foreign<br />

affairs by the University of Oxford, United Kingdom in 1993. Mr. Jambaljamts was<br />

awarded the Honorary Labour Medal of Mongolia in 1997, and twice awarded with<br />

the Polestar medal of Mongolia.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

7


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Gankhuyag Adilbish, aged 38, is a non-executive Director of the Company. Mr.<br />

Adilbish was appointed as a non-executive Director of the Company on 13 October<br />

2014. He is also a member of the Audit Committee. Mr. Adilbish joined the MCS<br />

Group in 1999 as a financial analyst of MCS International LLC, the former holding<br />

company of MCS Holding LLC, a controlling shareholder of the Company and was<br />

subsequently appointed as the deputy managing director of MCS Electronics LLC, a<br />

then subsidiary of MCS Holding LLC in 2000. Mr. Adilbish became the vice president<br />

and chief financial officer of MCS Holding LLC in 2005 and was appointed as the<br />

managing director of MCS Holding LLC from 2009 to September 2015. In 2011, Mr.<br />

Adilbish was appointed as a director of MCS (Mongolia) Limited and MCS Mining<br />

Group Limited, both of which are controlling shareholders of the Company. He also<br />

sits on the board of directors of a number of other subsidiaries of MCS Holding LLC<br />

and its joint venture companies. In addition, Mr. Adilbish has been the Chief Financial<br />

Officer of the Company between 2010 and 2011. Mr. Adilbish is the director of Tugs<br />

Investment Limited. He was awarded a bachelor’s degree in Finance and Economics<br />

by the National University of Mongolia in 1999.<br />

8<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Khashchuluun Chuluundorj, aged 49, is an independent non-executive Director<br />

of the Company. Dr. Khashchuluun was appointed as an independent non-executive<br />

Director on 8 January 2016. He is the Chairman of the Remuneration Committee and<br />

a member of the Audit Committee and Nomination Committee. Dr. Khashchuluun<br />

is a professor at the Department of Economics, a member of the Academic Council<br />

and the board of directors of the National University of Mongolia. He serves as an<br />

executive director of the Mongolia Oil Shale Association and is engaged in managing<br />

a number of non-governmental organizations and research consulting activities.<br />

Since 2015, Dr. Khashchuluun has been serving as a member of the working group<br />

on Long-term Development Strategy for Mongolia 2016-2030 and a member of the<br />

board of directors of Ulaanbaatar City Development Corporation. Dr. Khashchuluun<br />

was elected to the board of the National University of Mongolia in 2014 and served as<br />

a visiting professor at the Russian University of Economics, Russia in 2015. He joined<br />

the National University of Mongolia as a lecturer of Political Economy in 1989. He<br />

was a member of the National Committee for Millennium Challenge Account Mongolia<br />

from 2005 to 2007, a member of the Committee of Long-term Development Plan of<br />

Mongolia in 2006, a selected Eisenhower Fellowships Fellow from Mongolia in 2007,<br />

a member of board of Open Society Forum in 2008 and a member of the board of<br />

directors of Erdenes MGL LLC, a state owned enterprise for strategic mining deposits<br />

from 2011 to 2012. From 2009 to 2012, Dr. Khashchuluun worked as the chairman of<br />

National Development and Innovation Committee of Mongolia, a government agency<br />

in charge of national development strategy and investment policy. From 2010 to<br />

2011, he was appointed as the inaugural chairman of the board of directors to lead<br />

the establishment of Development Bank of Mongolia, and from 2006 to 2012, he<br />

was a member of the board of directors of the Central Bank of Mongolia. From 2004<br />

to 2009, Dr. Khashchuluun worked as a Dean of the School of Economic Studies<br />

of the National University of Mongolia, the largest national school of economics and<br />

business administration in Mongolia. He also served as a member of the President’s<br />

Economic Advisory Council from 2006 to 2008 and a member of the Policy Council<br />

of the Ministry of Trade and Industry from 2005 to 2007. Dr. Khashchuluun managed<br />

government efforts on the introduction of private-public partnership concept and<br />

adoption of the Law on Concession, Law on Innovation and Law on Economic<br />

Development Planning, and revision of Law on Budget to adopt development policies,<br />

introduction of Regional Development index for fiscal transfers, private sector support<br />

policies. Dr. Khashchuluun was awarded a bachelor’s degree in economics by the<br />

Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia in 1989, a master’s degree in economics<br />

from the Graduate School of Economics, Yokohama City University, Yokohama, Japan<br />

in 1996 and a PhD in international economics by the Graduate School of Economics,<br />

Keio University, Tokyo, Japan in 2003.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

9


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Unenbat Jigjid, aged 53, is an independent non-executive Director of the Company.<br />

Mr. Jigjid was appointed as an independent non-executive Director of the Company<br />

on 16 September 2010. Mr. Jigjid is the Chairman of the Corporate Governance<br />

Committee and member of the Audit Committee, Nomination Committee and<br />

Remuneration Committee. From 1990 to 2000, Mr. Jigjid held various positions in the<br />

Bank of Mongolia, including economist, senior economist, director of the monetary<br />

policy department and governor. During the period from 2000 to 2006, Mr. Jigjid<br />

was the executive director of the Mongolian Bankers Association. Mr. Jigjid was a<br />

director of Resources Investment Capital from October 2010 to November 2013.<br />

Mr. Jigjid has been an executive director of the Corporate Governance Development<br />

Center in Mongolia since 2009 and was appointed as the Head of the Center on 30<br />

March 2015. He is also a member of the supervisory board of the Bank of Mongolia<br />

and the board of Micro Finance Development Fund. From October 2010, Mr. Jigjid<br />

serves as a director of Golomt Bank. He has been the board member of Open Society<br />

Forum in Mongolia since March 2011. On 26 April 2013, Mr. Jigjid was appointed as<br />

an independent non-executive director of APU Company, a company listed on the<br />

Mongolian Stock Exchange. On 30 April 2015, Mr. Jigjid was appointed as a nonexecutive<br />

director of Mongolia Telecom JSC, a company listed on the Mongolian<br />

Stock Exchange and on 6 November 2015, he was appointed as the executive<br />

director and secretary general of the Mongolian Bankers Association. Mr. Jigjid was<br />

awarded a master’s degree in economics by the Moscow Institute of Economics<br />

and Statistics, Russia, and a master’s degree in international affairs by Columbia<br />

University, United States.<br />

10<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius, aged 59, is an independent non-executive Director of<br />

the Company. Mr. Chan was appointed as an independent non-executive Director<br />

of the Company on 16 September 2010. He is the Chairman of the Audit Committee<br />

and member of the Corporate Governance Committee. From 1980 to 2007, Mr.<br />

Chan held various positions in Citigroup, including management associate, country<br />

treasurer and head of sales and trading, head of corporate banking business for Hong<br />

Kong, country officer for Taiwan, chief operating officer for Greater China, country<br />

officer for Hong Kong and head of corporate and investment banking business for<br />

Greater China. Mr. Chan was appointed as a member of the board of directors of<br />

the Community Chest of Hong Kong in September 1999. From 28 November 2012<br />

to 20 June 2014, Mr. Chan was appointed as an independent non-executive director<br />

of Larry Jewelry International Company Limited, the shares of which are listed on<br />

The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “SEHK” or “Stock Exchange”). Mr.<br />

Chan was appointed as a member of the Sponsorship and Development Fund of<br />

The Open University of Hong Kong in March 2011. He was appointed as the deputy<br />

chief executive of the Bank of China (Hong Kong) Limited in 2008, senior advisor of<br />

The Bank of East Asia Limited in March 2009, member of the Council of Hong Kong<br />

Red Cross in April 2010, senior advisor of CVC Capital Partners Limited in November<br />

2010, member of the Executive Committee of the Investor Education Centre (IEC)<br />

of the Securities and Futures Commission in October 2012, member of the Hong<br />

Kong Tourism Board in April 2013, Deputy Chairman of the Council of the Hong<br />

Kong Polytechnic University in April 2014 and was further appointed as Chairman of<br />

the council on 1 January 2016. Mr. Chan was appointed as Board Adviser of Hong<br />

Kong New Territories General Chamber of Commerce on 28 May 2013. He is also<br />

an Honorary Advisory Vice President of The Hong Kong Institute of Bankers from 14<br />

February 2011. Mr. Chan was appointed as a Member of the Standing Commission<br />

on Civil Service Salaries and Conditions of Service of the Government of the Hong<br />

Kong Special Administrative Region on 1 January 2014 and a member of the<br />

Financial Reporting Council (FRC) on 1 December 2014. Mr. Chan is a member of<br />

the Disciplinary Appeals Committee of the Hong Kong Securities Clearing Company<br />

Limited from 11 December 2009 and an independent non-executive director of Hong<br />

Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited from 23 April 2009, the shares of which are<br />

listed on the Stock Exchange. Mr. Chan was appointed as a non-executive director<br />

of Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation (RCBC) on 28 November 2011, the shares<br />

of which are listed on the Philippines Stock Exchange. He was also appointed as a<br />

non-independent non-executive director of Affin Holdings Berhad on 6 August 2013,<br />

the shares of which are listed on Bursa Malaysia. Mr. Chan was awarded bachelor’s<br />

and master’s degrees in business administration by the University of Hawaii, United<br />

States, and is a Certified Public Accountant with the American Institute of Certified<br />

Public Accountants.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

11


Directors and Senior Management<br />

SENIOR MANAGEMENT<br />

Oyunbat Lkhagvatsend, aged 39, is the President and Deputy Chief Executive<br />

Officer of the Company. Mr. Lkhagvatsend was appointed as the Deputy Chief<br />

Executive Officer of the Company on 10 May 2013 and the Chief Executive Officer<br />

of Energy Resources Rail LLC on 8 February 2011. Mr. Lkhagvatsend has about 14<br />

years of experience in the business sector of Mongolia, holding senior positions in<br />

various businesses in the country. From 2003 to 2005, Mr. Lkhagvatsend was the<br />

chief executive officer of Newcom Group and was responsible for strategy planning<br />

and business development. From May 2005 to December 2006, he was the president<br />

and chief executive officer of Eznis Airways and was in charge of strategy planning,<br />

project management and other corporate affairs. He joined the Group in 2008 as the<br />

chief executive officer of Energy Resources Rail LLC and was responsible for overall<br />

business strategy and planning. Mr. Lkhagvatsend was awarded a bachelor’s degree<br />

in law by the National University of Mongolia, Mongolia. He also underwent executive<br />

trainings held by the Michigan Business School, United States.<br />

Ulemj Baskhuu, aged 37, is an Executive Vice President and the Chief Financial<br />

Officer of the Company. Ms. Baskhuu was appointed as the Company’s Chief<br />

Financial Officer responsible for the overall financial management, liquidity, asset<br />

management and investor relations of the Company on 27 August 2013. Ms. Baskhuu<br />

joined the Group as vice president responsible for investment of Energy Resources<br />

Rail LLC in December 2008. Ms. Baskhuu has worked for major banks and held<br />

various senior positions such as director of Financial Institutions at the Trade and<br />

Development Bank of Mongolia and head of investment banking at Khan Bank. Ms.<br />

Baskhuu was awarded a bachelor’s degree in business administration from the<br />

Mercer University, United States.<br />

Samuel Bowles, aged 34, is an Executive Vice President and the Chief Operating<br />

Officer of the Company. Mr. Bowles was appointed as the Company’s Chief<br />

Operating Officer on 1 October 2012 and Chief Executive Officer of Enrestechnology<br />

LLC on 27 September 2012. Mr. Bowles has over 10 years of experience in the<br />

coal mining industry, and has held various technical, operational and management<br />

positions previously with Leighton Asia, Rio Tinto Coal Australia and Anglo Coal<br />

Australia. He has extensive coking and thermal coal industry knowledge and<br />

expertise, including short and long term mine planning, capital and operating cost<br />

estimations, surface and underground coal mining operations and management of<br />

technical and operational personnel. Mr. Bowles holds a bacherlor’s degree in mining<br />

engineering from the University of New South Wales, Australia, and is a member of<br />

the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy.<br />

12<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors and Senior Management<br />

Uurtsaikh Dorjgotov, aged 52, is an Executive Vice President and the Chief Legal<br />

Officer of the Company. Ms. Dorjgotov joined the Group in December 2009. Prior to<br />

joining the Company, Ms. Dorjgotov was the director of the legal and administration<br />

department and chief legal counsel of MCS Holding LLC. She also worked for 6 years<br />

on the USAID-funded Mongolia Privatisation Program of Barents Group of Bearing<br />

Point, Inc. as in-house lawyer and for 9 years at the Prosecutor General Office of<br />

Mongolia as a supervising prosecutor. Ms. Dorjgotov was awarded a master’s degree<br />

(LLM) by the University of Waikato, New Zealand, and also a diploma of lawyer by the<br />

University of Irkutsk, Russia.<br />

COMPANY SECRETARY<br />

NG Sin Yee, Clare, aged 55, was appointed as the Company Secretary of the Company in July 2010. Ms. Ng<br />

is a director of the Corporate Services Department of Tricor Services Limited. She is a Fellow of the Hong Kong<br />

Institute of Chartered Secretaries and the Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators in the UK. Before<br />

joining the Tricor Group, Ms. Ng has worked in the Company Secretarial Department of Secretaries Limited,<br />

a professional service company wholly owned by Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. Ms. Ng has more than 28 years<br />

of experience in company secretarial field and has been providing corporate services to both multi-national<br />

companies and listed companies in Hong Kong.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

13


Group Structure<br />

14<br />

Annual Report 2015


Chairman’s Statement<br />

Dear Shareholders,<br />

The global coking coal markets continue to face persisting imbalance<br />

between supply and demand, which led to coking coal prices dropping<br />

to the lowest levels seen in the decade. In the fourth quarter of 2015,<br />

benchmark prices of coking coal settled at the lowest since 2005. Industry<br />

research reports estimate that it may take at least two years for coking<br />

prices to rise above current levels, provided that around 30 million tonnes<br />

(“Mt”) of annual supply is removed from the seaborne market to offset<br />

receding Chinese demand and new supply from ongoing mine expansions.<br />

In China, the Group’s principal market, the crude steel output fell last<br />

year for the first time since 1981, amid a wider slowdown in the country’s<br />

economy. According to the National Bureau of Statistics (“NBS”), Chinese<br />

crude steel production declined 2.3% year-on-year to 803.8 Mt in 2015.<br />

The steel sector, the main consumer of coking coal, has been plagued<br />

by overcapacity in China and the rest of the world for several years, and<br />

global steel prices have plummeted in the face of oversupply.<br />

It was reported by the NBS that in 2015 China’s coal output dropped 3.5%<br />

year-on-year to 3.7 billion tonnes, the second consecutive year-on-year<br />

decline, and China’s coke output dropped 6.2% year-on-year to 448 Mt. Chinese import of all types of coal fell<br />

30.0% in 2015 to 204.2 Mt, having fallen by 10.8% in 2014. Decreasing Chinese coal consumption is the major<br />

factor behind the fall, although softer prices in the domestic market also contributed to weaker imports, along<br />

with the acceleration of Chinese currency depreciation from the third quarter of 2015 onward that made imports<br />

more costly.<br />

The coal industry within China is subject to fierce competition between producers from various regions. It is<br />

expected in near future to result in accelerated mine closures among high-cost producers. Recently, the Chinese<br />

government revealed plans to tackle chronic overcapacity in the coal sector by closing 4,300 small and inefficient<br />

coal mines, and to cut total industry annual coal production capacity by 700 Mt over the next three years.<br />

In recent years, in order to improve the Company’s competitive position, the management has successfully<br />

achieved significant cost reductions through improvements to operational efficiency and productivity.<br />

Unfortunately, these improvements were not sufficient to offset the continued sharp decline in product prices.<br />

Therefore, the management has prioritized resolving financial issues with a focus on preserving liquidity and<br />

managing its balance sheet.<br />

In light of the adverse market conditions, and to better protect the interests of all stakeholders, the Company<br />

has initiated a dialogue with its lenders, and the financial and legal advisors of the steering committee of its<br />

noteholders about a possible restructuring arrangement in relation to its debt facilities. The Company is committed<br />

to transparent communication with broader investment community with the ultimate goal to achieve outcomes<br />

acceptable, and in long term, beneficial to all its stakeholders.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

15


Chairman’s Statement<br />

I believe that with the support of all our stakeholders, the Company will be able to maintain pursuit of its long<br />

term development objectives, including the opportunity to engage in coal exploration, mining, processing, and<br />

transportation activities at Tavan Tolgoi coalfield in Mongolia. This is evidenced from the Group forming and<br />

leading a consortium jointly with China Shenhua Energy Company Limited and Sumitomo Corporation and the ongoing<br />

negotiation process with the Government of Mongolia (the “GoM”) in relation to the conclusion of definitive<br />

agreements with the GoM and its consortium partners in connection with the Tavan Tolgoi coalfield development.<br />

The ultimate benefit to Mongolia as a result of this will be significant improvement of the competitive position of<br />

Mongolian coal in international markets by consolidating commercial operations within the Tavan Tolgoi coalfield<br />

under a public private partnership (“PPP”) model. However, any final outcomes of this transaction remain highly<br />

uncertain given the complex nature of negotiations involving multiple parties.<br />

On behalf of the Board, I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the continuing long-term support of our<br />

shareholders. Also, I would like to convey my appreciation of all efforts made by our staff to pursue our vision to<br />

become a leading mining company in the region.<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts<br />

Chairman<br />

24 March 2016<br />

16<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

In 2015, the global coking coal markets continue to face persisting imbalance between supply and demand,<br />

which led to the coking coal prices dropping to the lowest levels seen in a decade. In the fourth quarter of 2015,<br />

benchmark prices of coking coal settled at the lowest since 2005. The industry report estimates that it may take<br />

at least two years for coking prices to rise above current levels, provided that around 30 Mt of annual supply<br />

is required to be taken off the seaborne market to offset the receding Chinese demand and new supply from<br />

ongoing mine expansions.<br />

In China, the Group’s principal market, the crude steel output fell last year for the first time since 1981, amid<br />

a wider slowdown in the country’s economy. According to the NBS, Chinese crude steel production declined<br />

2.3% year-on-year to 803.8 Mt in 2015. The steel sector, the main consumer of coking coal, has been plagued<br />

by overcapacity in China and the rest of the world for years, and global steel prices have plummeted in the face<br />

of oversupply. Cooling Chinese coal consumption is the major factor behind the fall, although softer prices in the<br />

domestic market also contributed to weaker imports. The acceleration of the RMB depreciation from the third<br />

quarter of 2015 also made imports more costly.<br />

The coal mining industry is experiencing severe competition between producers from various regions. It is<br />

expected in the near future to result in accelerated mine closures among high-cost producers. Recently, the<br />

Chinese government revealed plans to tackle chronic overcapacity in the coal sector by closing 4,300 small and<br />

inefficient coal mines and cutting annual coal production capacity by 700 Mt over the next three years.<br />

In the last several years, in order to improve the Company’s competitive position, the Company’s management<br />

was able to achieve significant cost reductions by improvements in operational efficiency and productivity.<br />

Unfortunately this was insufficient to offset the continued sharp decline in product prices. Therefore, the<br />

management has prioritized resolving financial issues with a focus on preserving liquidity and managing its<br />

balance sheet.<br />

In light of the adverse market conditions, and to better protect the interests of all the stakeholders of the<br />

Company, the Company started a dialogue with its lenders, and the financial and legal advisors of the steering<br />

committee of its noteholders about a possible restructuring arrangement in relation to its debt facilities. The<br />

Company is committed to transparent communication with broader investment community with the ultimate goal<br />

to achieve outcomes acceptable, and in the long term, beneficial to all its stakeholders.<br />

THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT ANY DISCUSSIONS WITH ANY NOTEHOLDER AND LENDER WILL<br />

LEAD TO A PROPOSAL ACCEPTABLE TO THE NOTEHOLDERS AND THE LENDERS MORE GENERALLY<br />

OR THAT DISCUSSIONS WITH THE NOTEHOLDERS AND THE LENDERS CAN BE PROGRESSED TO ANY<br />

POSITIVE CONCLUSION. ACCORDINGLY, THE COMPANY OFFERS NO ASSURANCE THAT THE PROPOSED<br />

RESTRUCTURING WILL BE SUCCESSFULLY CONCLUDED. SHAREHOLDERS OF THE COMPANY, THE<br />

NOTEHOLDERS, HOLDERS OF OTHER SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY AND POTENTIAL INVESTORS IN THE<br />

SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY ARE ADVISED TO EXERCISE EXTREME CAUTION WHEN DEALING IN THE<br />

SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

17


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

INDUSTRY OVERVIEW<br />

Chinese Steel, Coke and Coking Coal Sectors’ Performance<br />

According to World Steel Association, China remains the largest crude steel producer in the world with 49.5%<br />

share in the global production, but in 2015 its steel output posted its first annual contraction in a quarter of<br />

a century. China’s crude steel output decreased 2.3% to 803.8 Mt in 2015, according to the data from NBS.<br />

That compared with a growth of 0.9% in 2014 and 12.5% in 2013, reflects a weak downstream demand amid a<br />

slowdown in the Chinese economy.<br />

Demand for steel is weakening as policy makers seek to steer the economy away from an investment to<br />

consumption-led growth. The economy expanded 6.9% last year, the slowest pace since 1990. As a result, the<br />

domestic steel consumption declined to 689.8 Mt in 2015, representing 5.3% year-on-year drop according to<br />

China Coal Resource estimates.<br />

China’s steel product exports have increased for six straight years and jumped 20% to 112.4 Mt last year, topping<br />

100 Mt for the first time, according to trade statistics reported by China’s General Administration of Customs<br />

(“China Customs”). The surge in 2015 was caused by steelmakers looking for markets overseas due to surplus<br />

production and softer domestic demand accompanying a slowdown in the Chinese economy. However, China’s<br />

massive exports have caused steel prices to fall throughout the world, and it was reported that the European<br />

Union, USA and India considered imposing protectionist measures according to the media reports.<br />

The Chinese government recently announced that it is determined to continue undertaking supply side reform<br />

by cutting back industrial overcapacity faced by steel, coal and cement producers. Officials reported that China<br />

cut crude steel production by about 90 Mt in recent years and will target to cut a further 100-150 Mt without<br />

specifying an exact timeframe.<br />

Following the weak performance of the steel industry, China’s coke production declined to 447.8 Mt in 2015 from<br />

476.9 Mt recorded in 2014, representing a 6.1% decrease. Similarly, Chinese coke consumption was 440.7 Mt in<br />

2015, which is 3.0% lower compared to 454.5 Mt reported in 2014. With domestic excess production and lower<br />

demand, Chinese coke exports continued to grow in 2015 and reached 9.9 Mt from 8.5 Mt recorded in 2014,<br />

representing a 15.8% year-on-year increase.<br />

Chinese coal production fell by 3.5% year-on-year to 3.7 billion tonnes according to NBS, resulting in a decline for<br />

two consecutive years. Chinese coking coal production was 483.8 Mt, representing a 3.6% decrease from 502.1<br />

Mt recorded in previous year, and coking coal consumption fell by 5.8% to 528.6 Mt from 561.3 Mt in 2014.<br />

The fixed asset investment in China’s coal mining and washing industry continued to drop to RMB400.8 billion in<br />

2015, representing a 14.4% fall compared to the preceding year. Also, China’s coal mining and washing industry<br />

profit fell to RMB44.1 billion, or down by 65% year-on-year according to NBS. During the same period, the coal<br />

mining and washing industry realised a revenue of RMB2.5 trillion, a decline of 14.8% year-on-year.<br />

In order to fight air pollution and overcapacity faced by the coal industry, the Chinese government recently<br />

announced that it will halt issuing approvals for new coal mines for the next three years, cut annual coal<br />

production capacity by 700 Mt and also allocate RMB30 billion to support the relocation of employees affected by<br />

the closure of 4,300 small and inefficient coal mines.<br />

18<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Chinese Coking Coal Imports and Mongolian Coal Exports Dynamics<br />

With declining demand in 2015, Chinese coking coal imports fell to 47.8 Mt, representing 23.3% year-on-year<br />

decline compared to 62.4 Mt imported in 2014, according to China Customs. For imported coking coal, Australia<br />

increased its market share to 53.4% from 50.1% in 2014. Mongolia preserved its position as the second largest<br />

supplier and also increased its market share to 26.6% from 23.7% in 2014.<br />

Table 1. China’s annual coking coal import volume (Mt) (Note):<br />

Countries 2015 2014 Change<br />

Australia 25.5 31.3 -18.3 %<br />

Mongolia 12.7 14.8 -13.8 %<br />

Canada 5.7 7.2 -20.7%<br />

Russia 3.2 5.8 -44.0 %<br />

USA 0.1 2.1 -94.5 %<br />

Others 0.5 1.3 -60.9 %<br />

Total 47.8 62.4 -23.3%<br />

Source: China Coal Resource<br />

Notes:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

Imports from Mongolia include raw unprocessed, dry and wet processed coking coal.<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between summary of volumes of individual countries with total volume and yearon-year<br />

percentage change.<br />

According to the data from Mongolian National Statistics Office, Mongolian coal exports to China reached 14.5 Mt<br />

in 2015, representing a 25.8% decrease compared to 19.5 Mt reported in previous year. The Group remains as<br />

the only major producer and exporter of washed coking coal in Mongolia.<br />

OPERATING ENVIRONMENT<br />

Legal Framework<br />

Mining and Exploration related legislation<br />

In 2015, the Parliament of Mongolia (“Parliament”) adopted the following amendments to the Minerals Law (the<br />

“Amendments”), which were relevant to the Group’s operations in Mongolia. The Group does not expect any<br />

material impact on its financials from the Amendments described below.<br />

On 23 January 2015, license fees previously expressed in USD were changed such that they are now expressed in<br />

MNT. For coal deposits, an annual mining license fee payable by license holder was previously USD5 per hectare<br />

and it has been changed to MNT7,250 per hectare after the Amendment. Our Mongolian operating subsidiaries<br />

holding mining licenses are in compliance with the license fee payment obligations as stipulated under relevant<br />

provisions in the Minerals Law.<br />

On 18 February 2015, a concept of a special royalty for mineral deposits of strategic importance was introduced.<br />

It provides an option for the GoM either to exercise its right to take an equity interest in such deposits as<br />

stipulated under the Minerals Law or to, in lieu of such interest, impose a special royalty of up to 5% in addition to<br />

the base and progressive royalties applicable universally to all mining licenses under the Minerals Law.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

19


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Labour Relations, Occupational Health and Safety related legislation<br />

On 17 February 2015, the GoM, Geology and Mining Sector Labour Union and representatives of the mining<br />

sector employers entered into a collective bargaining agreement for 2015 and 2016 (the “Collective Bargaining<br />

Agreement”). Under this agreement, it was stipulated that the industry’s minimum wage for 2015 and 2016 shall<br />

be doubled to the national minimum wage set by the GoM, which currently equals to MNT192,000 per month.<br />

The Group does not expect any impact on its financials for entering into the Collective Bargaining Agreement. Its<br />

existing internal remuneration policies are in line with the Collective Bargaining Agreement.<br />

On 14 May 2015, the Parliament amended the Law on Occupational Safety and Hygiene. In light of this<br />

amendment, the GoM adopted Resolution No.269 on investigation and registration of industrial accidents, and<br />

acute poisonings on 29 June 2015.<br />

Pursuant to these changes, the criteria for the consideration of accidents was further specified and its scope<br />

was widened. In accordance with these changes, the Group has undertaken required changes to its internal<br />

regulations related to the investigation and registration of any workplace accidents.<br />

Taxation, Accounting and Financial Reporting related legislation<br />

On 9 July 2015, the Law on value-added tax (“VAT”) was revised by the Parliament and it has become effective<br />

since 1 January 2016. Under this revision, the VAT rate of 10% payable with respect to all goods sold, works<br />

performed and services provided within Mongolia continue to be applied and most importantly, the zero-rate<br />

regime for the exported “finished mineral products” continue to be applied, and the list of “finished mineral<br />

products” will be adopted by the GoM. Based on the revised Law on VAT, Government Resolution No.502<br />

was issued on 21 December 2015, which replaced Resolution No.286 that was adopted in 2010 and the list<br />

of exported “finished mineral products” was redefined. The processed coals, those comprise of processed<br />

anthracite, semi anthracite, HCC, washed semi-soft coking coal (“SSCC”) and non-coking coal continue to be<br />

classified as “finished mineral products”.<br />

Therefore, the Group will continue to be entitled to claim its VAT paid during its operation in Mongolia, whereas<br />

a producer of other mineral products that are not included in the list of “finished minerals products” will be<br />

excluded from VAT payment refunding. This list is in compliance with other resolutions and standards such as<br />

Government Resolution No. 193 of 2011 on Requirements, Types, Main Principles and Methodology of Mineral<br />

Ore, Concentrate and Products and Mongolian National Standard 6457:2014 on Coal Products and Classification.<br />

With regard to other changes made by the revised Law on VAT, the revenue threshold for VAT payer registration<br />

was revised from MNT10 million to MNT50 million. VAT will be imposed on all types of works and services<br />

imported to Mongolia, regardless of whether or not the works and services are performed and rendered within the<br />

territory of Mongolia. The list of deductibles from the VAT taxable was shortened.<br />

20<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

On 19 June 2015, the Law on Accounting and Law on Auditing were revised by the Parliament and have became<br />

effective since 1 January 2016. Under the revised Law on Accounting, a legal entity or any of its representatives<br />

who operate in Mongolian territory can record its financial transactions in a currency other than MNT, if agreed<br />

by the government authority in charge of finance and accounting. However, financial statements submitted to<br />

the relevant government authority shall be denominated only in MNT. Under the revised Law on Accounting,<br />

a company with one or more subsidiaries shall be required to submit consolidated financial statements. If its<br />

ultimate parent company is registered in a foreign country, the top parent company registered in Mongolia is<br />

obliged to issue consolidated financial statements. On the Law on Auditing, the main change was that the term<br />

for conducting audit service provided by an audit firm to a legal entity is extended to five consecutive years from<br />

three consecutive years.<br />

In accordance with these changes, the Group has undertaken required changes to its internal regulations and<br />

procedures related to taxation reporting in Mongolia.<br />

During 2015, the excise and customs duties of imported gasoline and diesel were increased by the GoM which<br />

has the authority to set the excise duty on imported gasoline and diesel within the range defined under the Law<br />

on Excise Tax and Parliament Resolution No.27, 1999. The changes include:<br />

(a)<br />

(b)<br />

(c)<br />

On 19 January 2015, the GoM issued Resolution No.18 and increased excise duty for imported diesel<br />

from MNT30,000 to MNT265,000 per tonne, and increased excise duty for gasoline with octane rate up<br />

to 90 from MNT30,000 to MNT252,000 per tonne and gasoline with octane rate above 90 from zero to<br />

MNT259,000 per tonne, which are imported through Sukhbaatar, Zamiin Uud, Ereentsav and Altanbulag<br />

border ports of Mongolia. Such resolution has become effective on 20 January 2015.<br />

On 16 February 2015, the GoM issued Resolution No. 65 and increased the customs duty for imported<br />

diesel and gasoline from 1% to 5%. This resolution has become effective from 18 February 2015.<br />

On 9 November 2015, the GoM issued Resolution No.438 and increased the excise duty of imported diesel<br />

via Sukhbaatar, Zamiin-Uud, Altanbulag at MNT520,000 per tonne and at MNT390,000 per tonne for diesel<br />

imported via Ereentsav. It also increased the excise duty for gasoline at MNT400,000 per tonne which are<br />

imported through Sukhbaatar, Zamiin Uud, and Altanbulag and MNT270,000 per tonne for gasoline imported<br />

via Ereentsav border ports of Mongolia. This resolution has become effective since 10 November 2015.<br />

Investment related legislation<br />

On 14 May 2015, the Parliament amended the Law on Investment such that certain powers vested in other<br />

government ministerial level body have been shifted to the Investment Agency.<br />

Pursuant to the relevant clauses under the Law on Investment, Energy Resources LLC (“ER”), an indirectly whollyowned<br />

subsidiary of the Company, has applied for the Stabilization Certificate according to the procedures<br />

prescribed by this Law. On 13 August 2015, the Stabilization Certificate was issued by the Investment Agency<br />

to ER. Effectively, ER now has four main taxes namely, corporate income tax, customs tax, VAT and royalty,<br />

stabilized for the period until 17 April 2033.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

21


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

BUSINESS OVERVIEW<br />

Coal Resources and Exploration Activities<br />

Ukhaa Khudag (UHG) deposit<br />

The UHG deposit sits within the 2,960 hectare Mining License MV-11952 (“UHG mining license”), granted to<br />

the Group effective for 30 years from 29 August 2006, extendable twice by 20-year periods. Since acquiring the<br />

UHG mining license, the Group has prepared three JORC compliant Coal Resource estimates, the most recent<br />

of which, stated as of 30 November 2015, represents only a minor update from the second estimate stated<br />

previously as of 31 December 2014.<br />

This most recent Coal Resource update has been made in accordance with the requirements of the JORC Code<br />

(2012), including in compliance with the most recent Australian Guidelines for the Estimation and Classification<br />

of Coal Resources (2014). Compared to the previous JORC Coal Resource estimate stated as at 31 December<br />

2014, this update was made only on the basis of revised surface topography, to account for depletion as a result<br />

of mining activity between 1 January 2015 and 30 November 2015. No further exploration data was incorporated.<br />

Exploration activities conducted in the process of preparing the two preceding JORC compliant Coal Resource<br />

estimates and used by the Group to prepare the structural and coal quality geological models supporting the<br />

latest Coal Resource estimate as at 30 November 2015, included:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

1,556 individual boreholes drilled for 191,275 metres (“m”), including 104,369m of HQ-3 (63.1 millimetres<br />

(“mm”) core, 96.0mm hole diameter) and 86,906m of 122mm diameter open hole drilling;<br />

37,548 individual analytical samples collected and analysed;<br />

71 kilometres (“km”) of high resolution 2D seismic in-field measurements, collected by Polaris Seismic<br />

International Ltd (“Polaris”) and analysed by Velseis Processing Pty Ltd (“Velseis”); and<br />

results from large-diameter, bulk-sample drilling samples analysed at the ALS Group laboratories in<br />

Ulaanbaatar.<br />

Internal peer audit of these latest structural and coal quality geological models was conducted by Mr. Gary<br />

Ballantine, employed by the Group as Executive General Manager of Exploration and Geology. This confirmed that<br />

the Group’s work to update the UHG geological model, and thus the Coal Resource estimate for the UHG mining<br />

license area, was in compliance with requirements of the JORC Code (2012).<br />

Figures reported based upon an in situ density at an as-received moisture basis are summarised in Table 2. By<br />

mine survey measurement, it is calculated that production activity between 1 December 2015 and 31 December<br />

2015 has depleted the stated JORC Coal Resource by less than 1 Mt, and it is thus considered that such<br />

production activity has imparted no material change.<br />

With updated surface topography being the only new information used in preparation of the updated JORC Coal<br />

Resource estimate, and all other information and methodology remaining consistent with the previous JORC<br />

Coal Resource estimate, Appendix I of the Company’s 2014 Annual Report can be referred to for the detailed<br />

information required to be presented under the JORC Code (2012) upon release of a JORC (2012) Coal Resource<br />

estimate.<br />

22<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 2. UHG mining license JORC (2012) compliant Coal Resource estimate, by depth and category, as at 30<br />

November 2015 (Note):<br />

Total Coal Resource<br />

Resource Category (Mt)<br />

Depth limit from topographic surface Measured Indicated Inferred<br />

Total<br />

(M+I)<br />

Total<br />

(M+I+I)<br />

Subcrop to Base Horizon of<br />

Weathering Elevation (“BHWE”) 2 3 5 5 10<br />

BHWE to 100m 73 23 17 97 114<br />

From 100m to 200m 94 48 26 141 168<br />

From 200m to 300m 91 64 21 155 176<br />

From 300m to 400m 57 35 15 92 108<br />

Below 400m 40 44 30 84 114<br />

Sub-Total above 300m 260 138 70 398 468<br />

Sub-Total below 300m 97 79 45 177 222<br />

Total 357 217 115 575 689<br />

Total (Rounded) 360 220 120 580 690<br />

Notes:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

Technical information in the UHG Coal Resource estimation report has been compiled by Mr. Lkhagva-Ochir Said,<br />

General Manager of Technical Services, Mongolian Mining Corporation. Mr. Said is a member of the Australasian Institute<br />

of Mining and Metallurgy (Member #316005) and has over 8 years of experience relevant to the style and type of coal<br />

deposit under consideration and to the activity which is being undertaken to qualify as a Competent Person as defined<br />

by the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Minerals Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code<br />

(2012). Mr. Said consents to the inclusion in the release of the matters based on this information in the form and context<br />

in which it appears. The estimate of the Coal Resource set out in Table 2 presented in this annual report are considered<br />

to be a true reflection of the UHG Coal Resource as at 30 November 2015, and have been carried out in accordance with<br />

the principles and guidelines of the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore<br />

Reserves. The JORC Code (2012).<br />

Mr. Gary Ballantine is employed by the Group as Executive General Manager for Exploration and Geology. Mr. Ballantine<br />

is a member of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (Member #109105) and has over 25 years of experience<br />

relevant to the style and type of coal deposit under consideration and to the activity which is being undertaken to qualify<br />

as a Competent Person as defined by the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and<br />

Ore Reserves, The JORC Code (2012).<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between sub-totals and totals. Rounding rules refer to Clause 25 of the JORC<br />

Code (2012).<br />

In 2015, 16 boreholes were drilled within the UHG mining license, comprising 636m of HQ-3 drilling and 368m of<br />

122mm diameter open hole drilling, outside of the northern pit limit. The purpose of this drilling was to improve<br />

the geotechnical knowledge related to the boundaries of basement rock on the northern periphery of the UHG<br />

deposit. The information obtained allowed the revision to be made to the life-of-mine (“LOM”) pit slope design,<br />

subsequently allowing the revision of ex-pit dump design and the facilitation of shorter overburden haulage<br />

distances than previously determined during LOM planning. Data obtained from this drilling was not included<br />

in the JORC Coal Resource updated as of 30 November 2015, and is unlikely to have any bearing upon future<br />

updates.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

23


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Baruun Naran (BN) deposit<br />

The BN deposit is covered by two mining licenses. Mining License 14493A (“BN mining license”) of 4,482<br />

hectares area was obtained through the acquisition of Baruun Naran Limited, formerly known as QGX Coal<br />

Limited on 1 June 2011, and is effective for 30 years from 1 December 2008. Mining License MV-017336 (“THG<br />

mining license”) of 8,340 hectares area was granted to the Group on 24 June 2013, effective for 30 years. Both<br />

licenses are extendable twice, by 20-year periods.<br />

During 2015, the Group’s geological team updated the JORC (2012) Coal Resource estimations as at 30 June<br />

2015 for the BN and THG mining licenses. The estimation process applied more stringent requirements under the<br />

Australian Guidelines for the Estimation and Classification of Coal Resources (2014), as compared to the previous<br />

JORC (2012) Coal Resource estimates prepared by McElroy Bryan Geological Services Pty Ltd (“MBGS”), stated<br />

as of 30 June 2012 and 30 April 2013 for the BN mining license and the THG mining licenses respectively.<br />

No further drilling was conducted at the BN deposit in 2015, however the updated JORC (2012) Coal Resource<br />

stated as at 30 June 2015 did incorporate additional exploration data gained from the exploration drilling program<br />

conducted in 2014. The following information provided the basis for updating the structural and coal quality<br />

geological models underpinning the updated JORC (2012) Coal Resource statement:<br />

total of 92 exploration boreholes at BN, with a total of 28,540m drilled, of which 14,780m were HQ-3, 9,640m<br />

PQ-3 (83.0mm core, 122.6mm hole diameter) and 4,120m were 122mm open hole;<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

total of 32 exploration boreholes at Tsaikhar Khudag (“THG”), with a total of 9,970m drilling at THG, of which<br />

5,900m were HQ-3, 3,610m PQ-3 and 460m were 122mm open hole;<br />

total of 8,720 (BN) and 3,824 (THG) coal samples collected and analysed; and<br />

total of 75km of 2D seismic survey captured by Polaris over the BN mining license, and analysed by Velseis.<br />

Internal peer review was conducted by Mr. Gary Ballantine, Executive General Manager of Exploration and<br />

Geology. External peer review was provided by Mr. Todd Sercombe of GasCoal Pty Ltd. Mr. Brett Larkin from<br />

Geocheck Pty Ltd was also involved in external peer review, specifically with regard to the geostatistical analysis<br />

required to be prepared under the Australian Guidelines for the Estimation and Classification of Coal Resources<br />

(2014). These peer reviews confirmed compliance of the Group’s work to update the Coal Resource estimations<br />

in compliance with requirements of the JORC Code (2012).<br />

Summary of the updated JORC (2012) Coal Resources for BN and THG mining license areas are shown in Table<br />

3 and Table 4. The figures in these tables represent calculation based upon in situ density at an assumed 5%<br />

moisture basis.<br />

24<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 3. BN mining license JORC (2012) compliant Coal Resource estimate, by depth and category, as at 30 June<br />

2015 (Note):<br />

Total Coal Resource<br />

Resource Category (Mt)<br />

Depth limit from topographic surface Measured Indicated Inferred<br />

Total<br />

(M+I)<br />

Total<br />

(M+I+I)<br />

Subcrop to BHWE 10 2 1 12 13<br />

BHWE to 100m 42 9 3 51 54<br />

From 100m to 200m 62 11 5 73 78<br />

From 200m to 300m 67 13 7 80 87<br />

From 300m to 400m 70 16 9 86 95<br />

Below 400m — — — — —<br />

Sub-Total above 300m 181 35 16 216 232<br />

Sub-Total below 300m 70 16 9 86 95<br />

Total 251 51 25 302 327<br />

Total (Rounded) 250 50 30 300 330<br />

Table 4. THG mining license JORC (2012) compliant Coal Resource estimate, by depth and category, as at 30<br />

June 2015 (Note):<br />

Total Coal Resource<br />

Resource Category (Mt)<br />

Total Total<br />

Depth limit from topographic surface Measured Indicated Inferred (M+I) (M+I+I)<br />

Subcrop to BHWE — — 2 — 2<br />

BHWE to 100m — — 14 — 14<br />

From 100m to 200m — — 19 — 19<br />

From 200m to 300m — — 19 — 19<br />

From 300m to 400m — — 18 — 18<br />

Below 400m — — — — —<br />

Sub-Total above 300m — — 54 — 54<br />

Sub-Total below 300m — — 18 — 18<br />

Total — — 72 — 72<br />

Total (Rounded) — — 70 — 70<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

25


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Notes:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

Technical information in the BN deposit Coal Resource estimation report has been compiled by Mr. Lkhagva-Ochir Said,<br />

General Manager of Technical Services, Mongolian Mining Corporation. Mr. Said is a member of the Australasian Institute<br />

of Mining and Metallurgy (Member #316005) and has over 8 years of experience relevant to the style and type of coal<br />

deposit under consideration and to the activity which is being undertaken to qualify as a Competent Person as defined<br />

by the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Minerals Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code<br />

(2012). Mr. Said consents to the inclusion in the release of the matters based on this information in the form and context<br />

in which it appears. The estimate of the Coal Resource set out in Table 3 and Table 4 presented in this annual report<br />

are considered to be a true reflection of the BN deposit Coal Resource as at 30 June 2015, and has been carried out<br />

in accordance with the principles and guidelines of the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral<br />

Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code (2012).<br />

Mr. Gary Ballantine is employed by the Group as Executive General Manager for Exploration and Geology. Mr. Ballantine<br />

is a member of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (Member #109105) and has over 25 years of experience<br />

relevant to the style and type of coal deposit under consideration and to the activity which is being undertaken to qualify<br />

as a Competent Person as defined by the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and<br />

Ore Reserves, The JORC Code (2012).<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between sub-totals and totals. Rounding rules refer to Clause 25 of the JORC<br />

Code (2012).<br />

Coal Reserves<br />

Ukhaa Khudag (UHG) deposit<br />

During 2015, the Group engaged RungePincockMinarco Limited (“RPM”) to prepare an updated JORC (2012)<br />

Coal Reserve statement as at 30 November 2015 for the UHG deposit. Much of the work conducted represented<br />

an update to work previously completed by RPM in 2013 to produce the previous JORC (2012) Coal Reserve<br />

statement as at 31 December 2012. This update, however, focused solely on UHG stand-alone operation, given<br />

the continued non-operational status of the BN mine.<br />

The process used was the same as that used to prepare the previous JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate, with<br />

the updated JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate again based on open cut, multi seam, truck and excavator<br />

mining methods. Pit optimization software was used to generate a series of nested pit shells corresponding to<br />

varying revenue factors, simulating incrementally different economic scenarios as impacted by mining cost or coal<br />

price variance. The pit algorithms used included for incorporation of:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

geotechnical constraints, including limitation of overall slope angles within the pit by sector, ex-pit dump<br />

offset from LOM pit shell crest and maximum pit depth, with updates on basis of research and analyses<br />

made since timing of the previous JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate, as provided by Mr. John Latilla of<br />

AMC Consultants Pty Ltd (“AMC”);<br />

washability curves on seam ply basis, as prepared previously by Mr. John Trygstad of Norwest Corporation<br />

(“Norwest”) for inclusion in the previous JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate, to individual coal seams based<br />

upon propensity for processing into coking and/or thermal products, with update made to reassign portion<br />

of Seam 0B from thermal to coking coal production, based upon results observed during production trials in<br />

2015;<br />

updated assumptions with regard to (i) coal losses and dilution, and (ii) manual re-assignment of proportion<br />

of coal mined from coking to thermal product streams, based upon survey reconciliation of actual production<br />

performance at UHG as well as allowing for unadjusted presentation of Proved and Probable categorisation<br />

of Coal Reserves as per JORC Code (2012) specification;<br />

26<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

<br />

<br />

updated cost input assumptions, derived from recent historical operating performance at UHG mine on the<br />

basis of sustainable cost reductions made in response to difficult market conditions, and as forecasted<br />

based upon negotiated reductions in cost for mining and blasting contractor services; and<br />

updated revenue input assumptions, derived from an updated market study commissioned from Shanxi<br />

Fenwei Energy Consulting Co. Ltd (“Shanxi Fenwei”) in October 2015, which provided for medium to long<br />

term forecasting of expected Free-on-Transport (“FOT”) pricing at UHG mine for hard coking, semi-soft<br />

coking and thermal coal products planned for production.<br />

Within the economical pit shell limit determined as a result of this optimisation process, pit designs were then<br />

designed to account for practicalities such as ramp accesses and minimum operating pit dimensions. Modifying<br />

Factors were then applied enabling determination of the mineable in situ coal within the pit shell and conversion<br />

to run-of-mine (“ROM”) and product coal quantities.<br />

Tonnages based upon an as-received basis with 5% total moisture, resulting from the updated statement of<br />

the JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate for the UHG deposit as at 30 November 2015 are shown in Table 5.<br />

It is considered that no material change to the stated Coal Reserve has resulted from depletion on account of<br />

production activity, with less than 1 Mt of coal extracted between 1 December 2015 and 31 December 2015<br />

according to mine survey measurement.<br />

Table 5. UHG mining license JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate, as at 30 November 2015 (Note):<br />

ROM Coal Reserve<br />

Reserve Category (Mt)<br />

Coal Type Proved Probable Total<br />

Coking 119 52 171<br />

Thermal 52 4 55<br />

Total 171 55 226<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

The estimate of Coal Reserve presented in Table 5 has been carried out in accordance with the Australasian Code for<br />

Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code (2012). Technical information<br />

in the UHG Coal Reserve estimation report has been compiled by Mr. Greg Eisenmenger, who is a Member of the<br />

Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. He is a full time employee of RungePincockMinarco Limited and has<br />

extensive experience in the mining industry, working for over 30 years with major mining companies, mining contractors<br />

and consultants. During this time he has either managed or contributed significantly to numerous mining studies related to<br />

the estimation, assessment, evaluation and economic extraction of coal in Australia, New Zealand, Indonesia, Mozambique<br />

and Mongolia. He has sufficient experience which is relevant to the style of mineralization and type of deposit under<br />

consideration and to the activity he is undertaking to qualify him as a Competent Person as defined in the JORC Code<br />

(2012). Mr. Eisenmenger consents to the inclusion in the release of the matters based on this information in the form and<br />

context in which it appears.<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between sub-totals and totals.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

27


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Excluding for depletion of approximately 16 Mt as a result of mining activity since release of the previous JORC<br />

(2012) Coal Reserve estimate, the updated JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate as of 30 November 2015 has<br />

resulted in reduction of Total Coal Reserve by approximately 24.4%. This is largely due in part to 50.7%, 56.7%<br />

and up to 64.0% reduction in forecasted mine gate revenue assumptions for HCC, SSCC and thermal coal<br />

respectively, compared to assumptions made in the previous Coal Reserve estimate, in line with medium term<br />

market conditions forecasted by Shanxi Fenwei.<br />

The application of forecasted sustainable reductions with regard to mining, processing, site administration<br />

and other unit costs of 24.7%, 26.2%, 51.3% and 32.4% respectively, largely possible on the basis of actual,<br />

sustainable reductions achieved since 2012, as well as on the basis of successful contract negotiations with<br />

mining and blasting contractors in 2015, has ensured that the Coal Reserve has not decreased so significantly<br />

in lieu of the significantly reduced revenue assumptions. As a result, there has been 6.5% proportional increase<br />

to the content of coking coal within the Total Coal Reserve, as well as reduction in the forecasted remaining<br />

LOM stripping ratio by 23.7% to 4.5 bank cubic metres (“bcm”) per ROM for the minable quantities in the LOM<br />

schedule.<br />

Baruun Naran (BN) deposit<br />

A JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate was most recently prepared for the BN deposit as part of an integrated<br />

LOM study prepared by RPM in 2013, with the resulting statement dated 31 December 2012. This study was<br />

completed on the previous JORC (2012) Coal Resource estimate within the BN mining license prepared by MBGS<br />

with statement dated 30 June 2012. Further update to this has not been prepared as of yet, pending completion<br />

of the most recent JORC (2012) Coal Resource estimate across the BN mining license and THG mining license as<br />

at 30 June 2015, but there are plans to review it in 2016.<br />

The LOM plan prepared underpinning the current JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate for the BN deposit was<br />

based upon open cut, multi seam, truck and excavator mining methods. Pit optimization software was used to<br />

generate a series of nested pit shells corresponding to varying revenue factors, simulating incrementally different<br />

economic scenarios as impacted by operating cost and coal revenue variance.<br />

The pit optimisation algorithms used included for implementation of the following:<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

limitation of open pit depth to 350m from surface, and overall slope angle restrictions, based upon<br />

geotechnical advice received from Mr. John Latilla from AMC;<br />

categorisation of coal seams for scheduling purposes on basis of propensity for coking or thermal coal<br />

production, based upon recommendations made by Mr. John Trygstad of Norwest;<br />

cost input assumptions based upon historical operating performances at both the UHG and BN mines, up<br />

until end of 2012; and<br />

revenue input assumptions derived from a market study of the principal coking and thermal coal markets in<br />

China, completed by Shanxi Fenwei in March 2012.<br />

The JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate for the BN deposit prepared on basis of above is summarised in Table<br />

6, with tonnage estimation based on an as-received basis with 6% total moisture. Production activity between<br />

1 January 2013 and 31 December 2015 has depleted the stated BN ROM Coal Reserve by less than 1 Mt,<br />

according to mine survey measurement, and is considered to impart no material change.<br />

28<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 6. BN mining license JORC (2012) Coal Reserve estimate, as at 30 June 2012 (Note):<br />

ROM Coal Reserve<br />

Reserve Category (Mt)<br />

Coal Type Proved Probable Total<br />

Coking 118 22 140<br />

Thermal 23 2 25<br />

Total 141 24 165<br />

Notes:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

The estimate of Coal Reserve presented in Table 6 has been carried out in accordance with the Australasian Code for<br />

Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code (2012). Technical information in<br />

the BN Coal Reserve estimation report has been compiled by Mr. Greg Eisenmenger, who is a Member of the Australasian<br />

Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. He is a full time employee of RungePincockMinarco Limited and has extensive<br />

experience in the mining industry, working for over 30 years with major mining companies, mining contractors and<br />

consultants. During this time he has either managed or contributed significantly to numerous mining studies related to the<br />

estimation, assessment, evaluation and economic extraction of coal in Australia, New Zealand, Indonesia, Mozambique<br />

and Mongolia. He has sufficient experience which is relevant to the style of mineralization and type of deposit under<br />

consideration and to the activity he is undertaking to qualify him as a Competent Person as defined under the JORC Code<br />

(2012). Mr. Eisenmenger consents to the inclusion in the release of the matters based on this information in the form and<br />

context in which it appears.<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between sub-totals and totals.<br />

Production and Transportation<br />

Coal Mining<br />

As part of a deliberate strategy to adjust production output lower in view of reduced market demand, the Group’s<br />

annual ROM coal mining output decreased to 2.7 Mt, as can be seen in Figure 1. All ROM coal output in 2015<br />

was sourced from the UHG mine, whilst production activities at the BN mine remained suspended. This was<br />

achieved at a stripping ratio of 4.6 bcm per ROM tonne, with total of 12.6 million bank cubic metres (“Mbcm”) of<br />

overburden material removed to access the coal mined.<br />

Some of the reduction in stripping ratio is largely attributable to the successful introduction of Seam 0B in feed<br />

blend to the coal handling and preparation plant (“CHPP”) during the production of HCC. Approximately 219<br />

thousand tonnes (“kt”) of Seam 0B, representing 8.0% of the total ROM tonnes delivered to CHPP, was sourced<br />

in 2015 from this incrementally low stripping ratio seam that lies partially uncovered at the bottom of the existing<br />

pit, that previously was considered only as a source for thermal coal production.<br />

Following a more thorough investigation by the Group’s technical services personnel, including drill hole chip<br />

sampling and trench sampling, a significant proportion of Seam 0B has been identified as suitable for HCC<br />

production. Subsequently, there is now intention that discrete portions of this seam be included in CHPP feed, in<br />

blend ratios of up to 50%, in the production of HCC.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

29


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Figure 1. The Group’s historical annual ROM coal production volumes (in thousand tonnes) and actual stripping<br />

ratio (in bcm of overburden per ROM tonne of coal):<br />

Following a successful, small scale geotechnical drilling exercise completed in the first half of 2015, the<br />

subsequent analysis of results has proven the initial predictions intended to be evaluated, and has led to the<br />

revision of the geotechnical recommendations regarding overall slope angle and distance required between<br />

pit crest and ex-pit overburden dump to the north of the UHG pit. This has allowed for the ex-pit waste dump<br />

location to be safely moved closer to the pit, with the resulting decrease to vertical and horizontal haulage<br />

distances allowing for reduction in required truck hours, and hence haulage cost.<br />

During the second half of 2015, negotiation with mining and blasting contractors has led to significant reductions<br />

in the forecasted cost of services going forward in respective contract extension periods. The contract revisions<br />

became effective in late 2015, during a period of reduced mining activity, and thus the positive impact resulting<br />

from these contract revisions on overall unit cost per bcm of material mined will be more pronounced from 2016<br />

onward.<br />

Coal Processing<br />

In response to the reduced market demand and lower mine production output, the volume of ROM coal processed<br />

was also reduced, with total CHPP feed of 2.6 Mt in 2015 achieved, including 49 kt from third parties under fee<br />

for service arrangements. From the feed of ROM coal owned by the Group, a total of 1.3 Mt of HCC primary<br />

product and 0.7 Mt of secondary by-product washed thermal coal (“middlings”) were produced at yields of<br />

50.9% and 26.9% respectively. Figure 2 displays the historical annual washed production volumes of the Group.<br />

Production trials that had commenced in the first half of 2015 with regard to inclusion of Seam 0B in the ROM<br />

feed blend to CHPP when producing HCC were expanded in the second half of 2015 with continued positive<br />

results. During the second half of 2015, on average the ROM feed blend to CHPP comprised 29.0% of Seam 0B,<br />

whilst meeting customer product specifications and achieving 51.7% primary and 21.1% secondary yields.<br />

30<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Figure 2. The Group’s historical annual total primary processed coal production volumes (in thousand tonnes):<br />

Transportation and Logistics<br />

In 2015, the Group’s transportation and logistics operations within Mongolia were reduced in line with<br />

decreased CHPP output according to forecasted market demand. Operations were scheduled to meet customer<br />

requirements whilst maintaining low primary product inventory. Domestic transportation activity was solely<br />

concentrated on haulage of HCC product between the UHG CHPP and the Tsagaan Khad (“TKH”) coal stockpile<br />

and trans-shipping facility adjacent to the Gashuun Sukhait (“GS”) and Ganqimaodu (“GM”) Sino-Mongolian<br />

border crossing. This was achieved using only the Group’s own coal transportation fleet, compromised of doubletrailer<br />

heavy haulage trucks, without reliance upon any third party haulage contractors. All middlings thermal coal<br />

production was rehandled onsite at UHG from the CHPP to a nearby satellite stockpile location, reducing short<br />

term cost of operation by way of not hauling to TKH when customer demand did not require it.<br />

Management has remained focused on improving operational efficiencies throughout the year, with the main<br />

achievement being increasing the average number of round trips per utilised truck per month. Previously, when<br />

operating on the gravel road between UHG and TKH, a maximum fleet average of approximately 13 round trips<br />

per truck per month was possible. In the calendar year following construction of the paved road, this fleet average<br />

increased to 20 round trips per truck per month. In 2015 the fleet average has been increased to 42 round trips<br />

per utilised truck per month, through further systematic improvements being made to remove system bottlenecks.<br />

Occupational Health, Safety and Environment<br />

Within the reporting period of 2015, approximately 3.3 million man-hours were recorded as worked by employees,<br />

contractors and sub-contractors of the Group. During this period, 2 occurrences of Lost Time Injury (“LTI”)<br />

were recorded, resulting in a Lost Time Injury Frequency Rate (“LTIFR”) of 0.6 LTIs per million man-hours<br />

worked equivalent being recorded, the lowest for any annual period that the Group has achieved since the<br />

commencement of public reporting.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

31


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Whilst the reduced LTIFR has been influenced by lower production activity, the result is also attributable to the<br />

focus of the Group’s management efforts and commitment to the goal of Zero Harm. This has been maintained<br />

through a difficult period operationally, during which there has been proportionally more man-hours of exposure<br />

to tasks with typically higher potential for LTI. During 2015, the Group continued to deliver Occupational Health,<br />

Safety and Environment (“OHSE”) specific training to employees, contractors, sub-contractors and visitors, with<br />

delivery of 5,149 training sessions to individuals, totalling 12,598 man-hours.<br />

The Group’s safety performance continues to compare favourably in terms of LTIFR against publicly reported<br />

mining safety statistics, such as those from the Queensland Government Department of Natural Resources and<br />

Mines (Surface Coal Mines, 2.3, 2014-2015) and the New South Wales Department of Resources and Energy<br />

(Surface Coal Mines, 1.9, 2014-2015).<br />

Sales and Marketing<br />

Challenging market conditions in steel and steelmaking raw materials industry were further exacerbated in 2015.<br />

Intense competition remained amongst Chinese domestic and international coal exporters to the China market.<br />

HCC prices dropped to the lowest levels seen in many years, and signs of a slowing economy in China put further<br />

downward pressure on an ongoing global coking coal supply and demand imbalance.<br />

The Group pursued a strategy to maintain relationship with its existing customer base, which includes key endusers<br />

with long term strategic value, while maintaining prudent management of liquidity in sales arrangements.<br />

On 3 April 2015, the Group signed a sales agreement with Shenhua Bayannoer Energy Co., Ltd., a subsidiary of<br />

China Shenhua Group, under which the Group committed to supply 1.2 Mt of HCC to China Shenhua Group.<br />

Furthermore, on 8 May 2015, the Group signed a long-term cooperation agreement with Baotou Iron and Steel<br />

Co., Ltd. (“Baogang Group”) to supply coking coal products, as such reinforcing the direct relationship with the<br />

Baogang Group, which is the largest steel mill in Inner Mongolia, China.<br />

The Tianjin Zhengcheng Import and Export Trade Co., Ltd. (“TZ JV”), the Group’s subsidiary in China, which<br />

operates as a joint venture with Risun Mining Co., Ltd, continued to maintain its relationship with its existing endusers’<br />

base mostly comprised of steel mills and coke plants located in Hebei, Shandong and the surrounding<br />

coastal area in China. The Group developed and maintained a product mix of coking coal products produced by<br />

the Group with supplementary third party coal products from Chinese origins in order to keep a proper balance<br />

of efficient cost structure as well as maintaining its market share. The variety of coal such as SSCC, weak caking<br />

coal, gas coal and lean coal was sourced from third parties from different regions of Shanxi and resold by TZ JV<br />

to customers located in Hebei, namely Jianlong Janeboat Steel Co., Ltd, Qiananshi Jiujiang Wire Co., Ltd and<br />

Tangshan Dafeng Coking Co., Ltd.<br />

The Group sold a total of 1.5 Mt of coal products in 2015, out of which 1.2 Mt was exported from the HCC<br />

originated from Mongolia, and 0.3 Mt of other types of coal products originated from third parties in China which<br />

included SSCC, lean coal, weak caking coal and gas coal. Out of the sales volume of 1.2 Mt HCC that was<br />

originated from Mongolia 0.7 Mt, 0.3 Mt, and 0.2 Mt were sold under Delivery-at-Place (“DAP”) GM, FOT and<br />

Cost-and-Freight (“C&F”) terms, respectively. Exported HCC volume in 2015 represents a 64.6% year-on-year<br />

decrease compared to 3.4 Mt HCC sold in China in 2014.<br />

32<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 7. Mongolian HCC sales volume by terms (Note):<br />

# Delivery terms Sales volume Volume share<br />

(Mt) (%)<br />

1 DAP 0.7 58.9%<br />

2 FOT 0.3 28.5%<br />

3 C&F 0.2 12.6%<br />

TOTAL 1.2 100%<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

Due to rounding, discrepancy may exist between sub-totals, totals and volume shares.<br />

OUTLOOK AND BUSINESS STRATEGIES IN 2016<br />

The global coking coal markets continue to face persisting imbalance between supply and demand, which led to<br />

the coking coal prices dropping to the lowest levels seen in a decade with benchmark prices in the fourth quarter<br />

of 2015 to settled at the lowest since 2005. The industry report estimates that it may take at least two years for<br />

coking prices to rise above current levels, provided that around 30 Mt of annual supply is required to be taken off<br />

the seaborne market to offset receding Chinese demand and new supply from ongoing mine expansions.<br />

The industry is experiencing severe competition between producers from various regions, which is expected in the<br />

near future to result in an accelerated pace of mine closures among high-cost producers. Recently, the Chinese<br />

government has revealed plans to tackle prolonged overcapacity in the coal sector by closing 4,300 small and<br />

cutting inefficient coal mines and cutting annual production capacity by 700 Mt over the next three years.<br />

The Company intends to pursue the following key strategies in order to maintain and enhance its competitive<br />

position as a major washed coking coal producer in Mongolia: (i) adjusting the capital structure and its debt to<br />

adequate and sustainable levels; (ii) maximizing assets utilization to lower unit fixed costs; (iii) supporting initiatives<br />

to improve logistics infrastructure providing access to Chinese railway network to reach its customers in China<br />

and beyond; (iv) exploring opportunities for expanding and diversifying its business operations through potential<br />

strategic cooperation and joint ventures arrangements; and (v) maintaining its strong commitment to safety,<br />

environment and socially responsible operations.<br />

During the past several years, in order to improve the Company’s competitive position, the Company’s<br />

management was able to achieve significant cost reductions by improving its operational efficiency and<br />

productivity, but unfortunately this was insufficient to offset the continued sharp decline in product prices.<br />

Therefore, the management has prioritized resolving financial issues with a focus on preserving liquidity and<br />

balance sheet management.<br />

In light of the adverse market conditions, and to better protect the interests of all the stakeholders of the<br />

Company, the Company started a dialogue with its lenders, and the financial and legal advisors of the steering<br />

committee of its noteholders about a possible restructuring arrangement in relation to its debt facilities. The<br />

Company is committed to transparent communication with broader investment community with ultimate goal to<br />

achieve outcomes acceptable and in the long term beneficial to all its stakeholders.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

33


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT ANY DISCUSSIONS WITH ANY NOTEHOLDER AND LENDER WILL<br />

LEAD TO A PROPOSAL ACCEPTABLE TO THE NOTEHOLDERS AND THE LENDERS MORE GENERALLY<br />

OR THAT DISCUSSIONS WITH THE NOTEHOLDERS AND THE LENDERS CAN BE PROGRESSED TO ANY<br />

POSITIVE CONCLUSION. ACCORDINGLY, THE COMPANY OFFERS NO ASSURANCE THAT THE PROPOSED<br />

RESTRUCTURING WILL BE SUCCESSFULLY CONCLUDED. SHAREHOLDERS OF THE COMPANY, THE<br />

NOTEHOLDERS, HOLDERS OF OTHER SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY AND POTENTIAL INVESTORS IN THE<br />

SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY ARE ADVISED TO EXERCISE EXTREME CAUTION WHEN DEALING IN THE<br />

SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY.<br />

The Company will continue to pursue its long term development objectives, including the opportunity to engage in<br />

coal mining, processing, and transportation and exploration activities at Tavan Tolgoi coalfield in Mongolia. This is<br />

evidenced from the Group forming and leading a consortium jointly with China Shenhua Energy Company Limited<br />

and Sumitomo Corporation (the “Consortium”) and the on-going negotiation process with the GoM in relation to<br />

the conclusion of definitive agreements with the GoM and its Consortium partners in connection with the Tavan<br />

Tolgoi coalfield development. The ultimate benefit to Mongolia is seen from the significant improvement of the<br />

competitive position of Mongolian coal in international markets by consolidating commercial operations within the<br />

Tavan Tolgoi coalfield under PPP model. However, any final outcomes of this transaction remain highly uncertain<br />

given the complex nature of negotiations, involving multiple stakeholders and including the regulators.<br />

SHAREHOLDERS AND POTENTIAL INVESTORS SHOULD NOTE THAT THE COMPANY MAY OR MAY NOT ENTER<br />

INTO ANY DEFINITIVE AGREEMENTS WITH ITS CONSORTIUM PARTNERS, THE GOM AND/OR ITS DESIGNATED<br />

ENTITIES. EVEN IF DEFINITIVE AGREEMENTS ARE ENTERED INTO, COMPLETION AND FULFILLMENT OF<br />

SUCH AGREEMENTS WILL BE SUBJECT TO SATISFACTION OF THE CONDITIONS PRECEDENT SET OUT<br />

THEREIN. ACCORDINGLY, THE COMPANY MAY OR MAY NOT BENEFIT FROM THE TAVAN TOLGOI COALFIELD<br />

DEVELOPMENT. SHAREHOLDERS AND POTENTIAL INVESTORS ARE ADVISED TO EXERCISE CAUTION WHEN<br />

DEALING IN THE SECURITIES OF THE COMPANY.<br />

FINANCIAL REVIEW<br />

Revenue<br />

Sluggish coking coal demand growth kept the market oversupplied with further downward pressure on prices<br />

during 2015. China’s slowing economy and poor appetite for steel making components pushed coking coal<br />

benchmark prices to the lowest levels in a decade. The Group continued to focus strictly on controlling<br />

operational costs and limiting capital outflow in 2015.<br />

34<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

The Group’s total sales volume for the year ended 31 December 2015 was approximately 1.5 Mt of coal products<br />

generating total revenue of USD99.5 million, whilst in 2014 the total sales volume was 5.4 Mt of coal products<br />

with total revenue of USD328.3 million. For the year ended 31 December 2015, approximately 0.7 Mt of HCC was<br />

sold at DAP GM terms, representing 48.4% of total sales volume which generated revenue of USD37.6 million.<br />

Approximately 0.8 Mt of coal products was sold at FOT and C&F terms under inland China sales generating<br />

revenue of USD61.9 million. The sales includes approximately 0.3 Mt of coal products procured from Chinese<br />

third party sources which generated revenue of USD23.9 million. The lower total revenue compared to the<br />

corresponding period in 2014 was essentially attributable to the continuing further downward pressure on coking<br />

coal price due to the oversupplied market, which ultimately led to a lower sales volume of HCC.<br />

The Group’s pricing reflected the current deteriorating price trend apparent to all coking coal products in the<br />

global market. The average selling price (“ASP”) of HCC achieved on a combined basis at all selling points was<br />

USD63.2 per tonne for the year ended 31 December 2015, supported by higher HCC selling prices of inland<br />

China sales. The ASP of HCC under FOT and C&F terms sales were USD66.3 per tonne and USD104.4 per tonne,<br />

respectively for the year ended 31 December 2015, compared to USD91.4 per tonne and USD119.4 per tonne in<br />

2014 respectively. It is worth noting that the ASP of sales under C&F terms is an average price of sold quantity<br />

across different locations in China, therefore year-on-year comparison may not depict the true trend as selling<br />

quantity and locations will differ each year. The ASP of HCC of sales under DAP GM terms was USD53.2 per<br />

tonne for the year ended 31 December 2015 which was approximately 23.2% lower compared to USD69.3 per<br />

tonne in 2014.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group derived individually more than 10.0% of its revenue from four<br />

customers, with the purchase amounts of approximately USD26.1 million, USD15.1 million, USD11.6 million and<br />

USD11.2 million, respectively, whilst in 2014 the Group derived individually more than 10.0% of its revenue from<br />

two customers, with purchase amounts of approximately USD117.7 million and USD34.4 million, respectively.<br />

Cost of Revenue<br />

The Group’s cost of revenue consists primarily of mining costs, processing and handling costs, transportation<br />

and logistics costs, and costs related to site administration, stockpile and transportation loss, and governmental<br />

royalties and fees.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the total cost of revenue was USD165.6 million, compared to<br />

USD335.5 million in 2014. The cost of revenue of self-produced coal was reduced by 59.4% from USD326.6<br />

million to USD132.7 million mainly as a result of lower sales volume.<br />

The cost of revenue of procured coal for the year ended 31 December 2015 consisted of USD23.4 million relating<br />

to trading of coal procured from Chinese third parties, which generated revenue of USD23.9 million, and USD3.4<br />

million cost relating to HCC procured from Mongolia. For the year ended 31 December 2014, the cost of revenue<br />

of procured coal was USD8.9 million relating to trading of HCC procured from Mongolia.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

35


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

As of 31 December 2015, USD6.1 million inventory provision was booked due to continuous weakening prices of<br />

coal products. The provision was made based on the assessment of the net realizable value of coal inventories.<br />

Table 8. Total and individual costs of revenue of self-produced coal:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015<br />

(USD’000)<br />

2014<br />

(USD’000)<br />

Cost of self-produced coal 132,701 326,577<br />

Idling cost 52,872 40,621<br />

Cost of self-produced coal excluding idling cost 79,829 285,956<br />

Mining cost 34,830 126,841<br />

Variable cost 15,960 66,599<br />

Fixed cost 16,598 45,883<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 2,272 14,359<br />

Processing cost 13,084 31,596<br />

Variable cost 5,216 12,448<br />

Fixed cost 2,664 3,716<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 5,204 15,432<br />

Handling cost 1,185 5,975<br />

Transportation cost 15,387 74,383<br />

Logistic cost 2,690 9,763<br />

Variable cost 1,416 3,549<br />

Fixed cost 1,169 5,215<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 105 999<br />

Site administration cost 6,261 12,992<br />

Transportation and stockpile loss 862 3,542<br />

Royalties and fees 5,530 20,864<br />

Royalty 3,509 13,656<br />

Air pollution fee 1,127 2,719<br />

Customs fee 894 4,489<br />

In accordance with the Group’s policy to conserve cash outflow during the current state of the market when ASP<br />

is trending lower, it made tactical sense for the Group to temporarily suspend operations at certain times during<br />

the period under review for conservation and efficiency purposes. In relation to this, idling costs arose during<br />

such periods when production was held at a limited level, which incurred associated costs of USD52.9 million,<br />

including depreciation and amortisation of USD18.5 million.<br />

36<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

The mining cost during mine operations consists of costs associated with overburden and topsoil removal<br />

and ROM coal extraction, including the costs related to mining staff and equipment, together with base and<br />

performance fees paid to the mining contractor, blasting contractor fees, and costs paid to fuel suppliers. For<br />

the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s total mining costs were approximately USD34.8 million (2014:<br />

USD126.8 million). Mining unit cost was USD15.5 per ROM tonne for 2015, compared to USD19.7 per ROM<br />

tonne in 2014.<br />

Table 9. Total unit mining cost per ROM tonne:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015 2014<br />

(USD/<br />

(USD/<br />

ROM tonne) ROM tonne)<br />

Mining cost 15.5 19.7<br />

Blasting 1.3 1.4<br />

Plant cost 3.5 5.5<br />

Fuel 2.3 3.4<br />

National staff cost 1.4 1.2<br />

Expatriate staff cost 0.6 0.5<br />

Contractor fee 5.2 5.1<br />

Ancillary and support cost 0.2 0.4<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 1.0 2.2<br />

Note: The above mining cost table does not include idling cost<br />

The Group identified components of the mine in accordance with the mine plan, and accounting of mining unit<br />

costs is based on the stripping ratio applicable to each component of the mine. Average accounting stripping<br />

ratio for components mined during the year ended 31 December 2015 was 2.5 bcm per tonne, compared to<br />

2.7 bcm per tonne for the year ended 31 December 2014. The mining cost is not only recorded in the income<br />

statement, but also the costs of pre-stripped overburden, which is associated with the coal to be mined,<br />

processed, transported and sold in the future, in excess of the average stripping ratio, which is capitalised in the<br />

balance sheet as mining structure.<br />

The processing cost during mine operations primarily includes the costs associated with the operations of CHPP<br />

including power and water costs. During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s processing cost was<br />

approximately USD13.1 million (2014: USD31.6 million), of which approximately USD5.2 million is related to<br />

the depreciation and amortisation of the CHPP, USD3.0 million incurred in the UHG Power Plant for the power<br />

generation and distribution, and USD0.8 million incurred in the UHG Water Supply Facility for the water extraction<br />

and distribution related to the washed coal sold during the period.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

37


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Unit processing cost calculated per ROM coal in-feed tonne increased by USD0.9 or 18.4% from USD4.9 per<br />

ROM tonne for the year ended 31 December 2014 to USD5.8 per ROM tonne for 2015. The increase was mainly<br />

attributable to the lower utilisation of CHPP module capacity.<br />

Table 10. Total processing cost and unit processing cost per ROM tonne:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015 2014 2015 2014<br />

(USD/ROM (USD/ROM<br />

(USD’000) (USD’000) tonne) tonne)<br />

Total processing costs 13,084 31,596 5.8 4.9<br />

Consumables 671 1,652 0.3 0.3<br />

Maintenance and spares 812 3,293 0.4 0.5<br />

Power 2,956 5,640 1.3 0.9<br />

Water 777 1,863 0.3 0.3<br />

Staff 1,767 2,636 0.8 0.4<br />

Ancillary and support 897 1,080 0.4 0.1<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 5,204 15,432 2.3 2.4<br />

Note: The above total processing cost table does not include idling cost<br />

The handling cost is related to feeding ROM coal from ROM coal stockpiles to the CHPP, and also the removal<br />

of reject (primarily rock and sediment separated from coal) after coal processing. During the year ended 31<br />

December 2015, the Group’s handling cost was approximately USD1.2 million (2014: USD6.0 million). Unit<br />

handling cost decreased by USD0.1 or 9.1% from USD1.1 per tonne in 2014 to USD1.0 per tonne for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015. The decrease was mainly attributable to cost savings arising from lower fuel prices.<br />

Transportation costs include costs related to the transportation of coal products from UHG to TKH, and the<br />

transportation of coal products from TKH to GM, including fees paid to third party transportation contractors.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s transportation costs, excluding idling cost, were USD15.4<br />

million (2014: USD74.4 million), of which USD8.4 million was related to long-haul (UHG-TKH) transportation, and<br />

USD6.9 million was related to short-haul (TKH-GM) cross-border transportation. On a unit cost basis, the Group’s<br />

overall transportation cost decreased in the UHG-GM section by USD0.6 per tonne or 4.3% from USD14.1 per<br />

tonne in 2014 to USD13.5 per tonne in 2015. The transportation cost in the long haul section (UHG-TKH) was<br />

increased from USD6.5 per tonne in 2014 to USD7.4 per tonne in 2015. Long-haul transportation costs increased<br />

due to lower transportation volume. For the short-haul (TKH- GM) section, where the Group utilised third-party<br />

contractors, the Group’s transportation costs were reduced by 19.7% from USD7.6 per tonne in 2014 to USD6.1<br />

per tonne in 2015 as a result of effective negotiations on haulage fees with the contractors.<br />

The logistics costs are mainly related to costs associated with operating product stockpiles at UHG and TKH. For<br />

the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s logistics cost was approximately USD2.7 million (2014: USD9.8<br />

million). The reduction in logistics costs is attributable to lower sales volume of coal products.<br />

The site administration cost during mine operations is primarily related to the site support facilities and<br />

consolidated management of the Group’s mining, processing, transportation and logistics operations. For the<br />

year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s site administration cost was approximately USD6.3 million (2014:<br />

USD13.0 million).<br />

38<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, total transportation loss was negligible compared to USD1.3 million loss<br />

in 2014. During 2015, the Group recorded unrealized inventory loss of USD0.8 million for ROM coal and washed<br />

HCC stockpiles at UHG compared to unrealised loss of USD2.3 million recorded in 2014. The inventory losses<br />

or gains are assessed based on periodic survey measurements of the Group’s ROM coal stockpile inventories<br />

at the UHG and BN mines, and product coal stockpile inventories at UHG and TKH. Survey of coal quantity is a<br />

measurement of volume, and as for every bulk commodity, the conversion to tonnage requires the application of<br />

density assumption, which involves natural variance. Subsequently, the measurement of stockpile quantities is an<br />

estimation in which errors are inherent. Therefore, variations within 5% are tolerated, and any tonnages above/<br />

below this limit are recorded as stockpile gain/loss. The management expects that by maintaining lower levels of<br />

inventory and improving overall inventory management, the Company will be in a position to keep inventory losses<br />

under control.<br />

Table 11. Transportation and stockpile gains and losses by amounts and volumes:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015 2014 2015 2014<br />

(USD’000) (USD’000) tonne’000 tonne’000<br />

Transportation and stockpile losses 862 3,542 0.3 51.7<br />

Transportation loss 21 1,283 2.0 23.4<br />

Washed coal 21 1,283 2.0 23.4<br />

Stockpile loss/(gain) 841 2,259 (1.7) 28.3<br />

Washed coal 1,660 3,867 44.7 126.0<br />

Raw coal (819) (1,608) (46.4) (97.7)<br />

Governmental royalties and fees are related to royalties, air pollution fees and custom fees paid according to the<br />

applicable laws and regulations in Mongolia. The progressive royalty rate is applied in the range of 5 - 8% for<br />

processed coal products and 5 - 10% for raw coal products based on monthly reference price determined by<br />

the Ministry of Mining of Mongolia. The Group’s effective royalty rate for the year ended 31 December 2015 was<br />

approximately 5.4% for coal exported from Mongolia based on customs clearance documentation (2014: 5.0%).<br />

Gross Loss<br />

The Group’s gross loss for the year ended 31 December 2015 was approximately USD66.1 million, representing<br />

an increase of approximately USD58.9 million from the gross loss of approximately USD7.2 million recorded for<br />

the year ended 31 December 2014. The gross loss was driven by (i) decrease in ASP of coking coal products<br />

supplied by the Group under the current state of the market, as coking coal pricing continued to be affected<br />

negatively by the global supply and demand imbalances; and (ii) lower HCC sales volume.<br />

Selling and Distribution Costs<br />

The Group’s selling and distribution costs of USD8.6 million for the year ended 31 December 2015 (2014:<br />

USD56.4 million) are associated with the inland China market penetration strategy and include expenses relating<br />

to fees and charges incurred for importing coal into China, logistics, transportation, governmental fees and<br />

charges and fixed agent fees. The selling and distribution cost is notably lower compared to 2014 due to lower<br />

sales volume.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

39


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

General and Administration Expenses<br />

The Group’s general and administrative expenses relate primarily to head office staff costs, share option<br />

expenses, allowance for doubtful debts, consultancy and professional fees, depreciation and amortisation of office<br />

equipment and other expenses. For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group’s general and administrative<br />

expenses was USD30.5 million which was similar to the level of USD30.9 million incurred for the year ended 31<br />

December 2014.<br />

Net Finance Costs<br />

Net finance costs for the year ended 31 December 2015 was approximately USD99.0 million (2014: USD94.5<br />

million). Net finance costs for the year ended 31 December 2015 comprised of (i) interest expense and other<br />

credit facilities related expenses, and (ii) USD21.9 million foreign exchange loss due to the depreciating MNT<br />

against the USD.<br />

Income Tax Expenses<br />

The Group did not have income tax expense for the year ended 31 December 2015 due to the loss incurred<br />

during the period, but had income tax credit of USD16.9 million due to the recognition of deferred tax asset. The<br />

Group’s income tax credit for the year ended 31 December 2014 was approximately USD59.0 million.<br />

Loss for the Period<br />

As a result of the costs listed above, losses attributable to equity shareholders of the Company for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015 amounted to approximately USD187.8 million (2014: USD282.8 million). The major<br />

contributing factor of the Group’s net loss position is the decrease of ASP and sales volume of coking coal<br />

products due to challenging market conditions in China, as coking coal price continued to be affected by global<br />

supply and demand imbalances.<br />

Impairment Loss<br />

In accordance with IAS 36 Impairment of Assets, entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether<br />

its assets are carried at value no more than their recoverable amount. Thus, the Company has undertaken an<br />

impairment assessment on the carrying amount of the Group’s property, plant and equipment, construction in<br />

progress and intangible assets; and the carrying amount of the cash generating unit (“CGU”) has not exceeded its<br />

recoverable amount as at 31 December 2015, and has not resulted in the identification of an impairment loss for<br />

the year ended 31 December 2015. The Directors are of the opinion that the impairment provision is adequate as<br />

at 31 December 2015 and no additional or reversal of impairment provision is needed in respect of the Group’s<br />

non-financial assets in this regard. For the year ended 31 December 2014, impairment loss of USD190 million<br />

was recognized, considering the prolonged weakening global coking coal prices due to the supply and demand<br />

imbalances.<br />

Liquidity and Capital Resources<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Company’s cash needs were primarily related to working capital<br />

requirements and debt repayments.<br />

The Company’s cash resources were mainly funded by proceeds of approximately Hong Kong Dollar (“HKD”) 1,556<br />

million from rights shares issued on 29 December 2014 and revenue generated from sales of coal products.<br />

40<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 12. Combined cash flows:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from operating activities (14,184) 41,173<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from investing activities (36,236) 25,782<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from financing activities (151,709) 109,524<br />

Net (decrease)/increase in cash and cash equivalents (202,129) 176,479<br />

Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of the year 202,856 26,535<br />

Effect of foreign exchange rate changes (25) (158)<br />

Time deposits with original maturity over three months 50,000 50,000<br />

Cash and cash equivalents at end of the year 50,702 252,856<br />

Note: USD36.2 million used in investing activities comprises of USD42.5 million incurred for payments for deferred stripping<br />

activity, USD5.4 million generated from interest income and USD0.9 million generated from disposal of property, plant and<br />

equipment.<br />

The gearing ratio (calculated as total bank and other borrowings divided by total assets) of the Company as at<br />

31 December 2015 was 57.0% (31 December 2014: 51.9% after considering provision for impairment loss on<br />

non-financial assets). All borrowings are denominated in USD. Cash and cash equivalents are held in MNT, USD,<br />

RMB, Euro and HKD. The Company’s policy is to regularly monitor current and expected liquidity requirements<br />

and compliance with debt covenants to ensure that the Company maintains sufficient reserves of cash to meet its<br />

liquidity requirements in the short and long term.<br />

Use of Proceeds from the Rights Issue of the Company<br />

On 29 December 2014, the Company issued 5,557,554,750 rights shares to qualifying shareholders by way<br />

of rights issue at the subscription price of HKD0.28 per rights share on the basis of three rights shares for<br />

every two existing shares held by qualifying shareholders whose names appeared on the register of members<br />

of the Company on 2 December 2014. Approximately HKD1,556 million was raised from the issuance of the<br />

rights shares, net proceeds of which after deducting associated transaction costs was HKD1,516 million or<br />

approximately USD195.5 million.<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company had used the proceeds from the rights issue as follows:<br />

— approximately USD108.0 million for repayment of existing indebtedness and related interest payments; and<br />

— approximately USD47.5 million for general working capital needs.<br />

Indebtedness<br />

As of 31 December 2015, the Company had USD799.8 million in outstanding short-term and long-term<br />

borrowings, including indebtedness incurred under (i) USD600 million Senior Notes, (ii) USD150 million from BNP<br />

Paribas, Singapore Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited (the “BNP and ICBC Facility”),<br />

(iii) USD180 million from European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Nederlandse Financierings-<br />

Maatschappij voor Ontwikkelingslanden N.V., and Deutsche Investitions-und Entwicklungsgesellschaft mbH (the<br />

“EBRD, FMO and DEG Loan Agreements”), (iv) USD40 million revolving credit line from Trade and Development<br />

Bank of Mongolia, (v) USD10 million short-term loan from Golomt Bank of Mongolia, and (vi) USD5 million shortterm<br />

loan.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

41


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

The Senior Notes bear a fixed interest rate of 8.875% per annum payable semi-annually. The Senior Notes will<br />

mature in March 2017, unless redeemed earlier. As of 31 December 2015, the outstanding principal amount<br />

was USD600 million. Upon the sale, transfer, conveyance or other disposition (other than by way of merger<br />

or consolidation) in one or a series of related transactions of all or substantially all of the properties or assets<br />

of the Company to any person other than one or more of the beneficial owners of less than 30% of the total<br />

voting power of the Company, the Company must make an offer to repurchase all outstanding Senior Notes at<br />

a purchase price equal to 101% of their principal amount plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to (but not<br />

including) the date of repurchase.<br />

On 5 March 2014, the Company as a borrower entered into the BNP and ICBC Facility Agreement for a coal preexport<br />

loan facility of USD150 million. The loan bears an interest rate of LIBOR plus 6.00% per annum, and is<br />

repayable in 10 quarterly installments starting from September 2014 and ending in December 2016. As of 31<br />

December 2015, the outstanding principal amount of such BNP and ICBC Facility was USD93.0 million. Under the<br />

BNP and ICBC Facility, the Company shall not issue any shares if such issue results in (i) the creation of a new<br />

share class of the issued share capital of the Company, and (ii) a change of control by controlling shareholder of<br />

the Company ceases to beneficially hold (directly or indirectly) at least 30% of the total issued share capital of the<br />

Company.<br />

Under the EBRD, FMO and DEG Loan Agreements, interest were initially based on six-month LIBOR plus 3.75%-<br />

4.25% margin per annum. The USD120 million principal amount of the loan is repayable in 11 semi-annual<br />

installments ending on 15 May 2016, and the USD60 million principal amount of the loan is repayable in two equal<br />

installments on 15 May 2015 and 15 May 2016, respectively. Pursuant to amendments to the EBRD, FMO and<br />

DEG Loan Agreements, starting from September 2015, the interest rate was decreased to one-month LIBOR plus<br />

3.5%-3.75% margin per annum and outstanding principal amount and interest is payable on a monthly basis until<br />

the maturity date of 15 May 2016.<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the outstanding principal amount was USD51.8 million. Under the EBRD, FMO and<br />

DEG Loan Agreements, the controlling shareholder of the Company may not cease at any time to own directly<br />

or indirectly more shares of the ER than any other shareholder, or at least 30% plus one share of the issued and<br />

outstanding shares of the ER, or the ER may not cease to be directly majority owned by entities domiciled in<br />

Mongolia, in each case without the prior written consent of EBRD, FMO and DEG.<br />

The loan granted by Trade and Development Bank of Mongolia is a revolving credit facility maturing on 20 March<br />

2016. The loan initially bore interest of 10% per annum, which was subsequently changed to 11.2% per annum<br />

from March 2015. As of 31 December 2015, the outstanding principal amount was USD40 million. Subsequent to<br />

the balance sheet date, the Group had entered into extension agreement on 21 March 2016 which deferred the<br />

maturity date to 20 June 2016.<br />

On 23 March 2015, the Group obtained a short-term loan of USD10 million maturing in January 2016 from Golomt<br />

Bank of Mongolia. Subsequently the term of the loan was extended to May 2016. Such loan bears interest of 8.80%<br />

per annum. As of 31 December 2015, the outstanding principal amount was USD10 million.<br />

As of 31 December 2015, the Group has USD5 million outstanding short-term loan, which bears interest of 1.25%<br />

per month and subsequent to the balance sheet date the loan has been repaid in February 2016 by converting to<br />

coal pre-payment facility.<br />

42<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Credit Risk<br />

The Group closely monitors its credit exposure. Credit risk is primarily attributable to trade and other receivables.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group had approximately USD2.0 million in trade receivables,<br />

USD92.3 million in other receivables and USD0.4 million for allowance of doubtful debts. For the year ended 31<br />

December 2014, the Group had USD37.0 million in trade receivables and USD125.4 million in other receivables,<br />

as well as USD10.1 million for allowance of doubtful debts.<br />

According to the Group’s internal credit policy (the “Credit Policy”), the Company holds quarterly Credit<br />

Committee meetings to review, assess and evaluate Company’s overall credit quality and the recoverable amount<br />

of each individual trade credit based on quantitative and qualitative analysis. The purpose of the Credit Policy is to<br />

set limits for and monitor the unsecured credit provided to customers at an aggregated Group level and to single<br />

customer, and the maximum contractual term for unsecured limit. As of 31 December 2015, in accordance with<br />

the Credit Policy and based on the Credit Committee’s assessment, certain debts in the amount of approximately<br />

USD18.2 million aged over one year, recoverability of which was assessed as doubtful, were written off against<br />

the existing allowance for doubtful debts and provision of additional USD8.5 million was made for allowance for<br />

doubtful debts, in line with the overall ageing analysis of trade receivables balance as at 31 December 2015 to<br />

USD2.0 million. The management continues to monitor, on an ongoing basis, the exposure, including but not<br />

limited to the current ability to pay, and takes into account information specific to the customer and pertaining to<br />

the economic environment in which the customer operates on an ongoing basis.<br />

With regard to other receivables of USD92.3 million, this amount is mainly related to USD20.8 million VAT and<br />

other tax receivables, USD42.0 million from GoM for railway project related reimbursement and other deposits and<br />

prepayments. For the VAT receivables, based on the Tax Authority inspection and approval of the VAT tax refund,<br />

the Group offset USD28.0 million against its other tax payments and payables to certain suppliers. The remaining<br />

amounts are deposits, advances, prepayments and other receivables in the ordinary course of business. The<br />

management believes that there is no issue in the collectability of such receivables.<br />

Substantially all of the Group’s cash at bank are deposited in the reputable banks, which management assessed<br />

the credit risk to be insignificant.<br />

Foreign Exchange Risk<br />

During the two years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014, 100% and 100% of the revenue and 61.4% and 87.6%<br />

of the purchases in each respective year were denominated in currencies other than MNT, the functional currency<br />

of the Group’s Mongolian entities.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, 0.4% and 99.6% of the revenues were denominated in USD and RMB<br />

respectively. For the year ended 31 December 2014, 19.8% and 80.2% of the revenues were denominated in USD<br />

and RMB respectively.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, 98.2% and 63.8% of the finance costs and operating expenditures,<br />

respectively, were denominated in USD, while 0.7% and 2.1% of the finance costs and operating expenditures<br />

were denominated in RMB; 1.0% of the operating expenditures were denominated in other currencies than the<br />

USD, RMB and MNT with the remainder denominated in MNT. For the year ended 31 December 2014, 99.9%,<br />

27.1% and 34.8% of the finance costs, operating expenditures and capital expenditures, respectively, were<br />

denominated in USD; while 20.2% and 0.3% of the operating expenditures and capital expenditures, respectively,<br />

were denominated in RMB; 0.3% and 5.7% of the operating expenditures and capital expenditures, respectively,<br />

were denominated in other currencies than the USD, RMB and MNT; and the remainder was denominated in MNT.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

43


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Although the majority of the Group’s assets and operating expenses are denominated in MNT, a large portion of<br />

expenses, including fuel and capital expenditures, are import costs and are thus linked to USD and RMB prices.<br />

Also, the majority of the Group’s finance costs are denominated in USD. Therefore, the Group believes that there<br />

is a natural hedge that partially offsets foreign exchange risk.<br />

Cash and cash equivalents denominated in the currency other than the functional currency of the entity to which<br />

they relate as at 31 December 2015 and 2014 amounted to USD50.2 million and USD245.8 million, respectively.<br />

Total borrowings denominated in the currency other than the functional currency of the entity to which they relate<br />

as at 31 December 2015 and 2014 amounted to USD101.8 million and USD143.6 million, respectively.<br />

The Group has not entered into any derivative instruments to manage foreign exchange fluctuations. However, the<br />

management monitors foreign exchange exposure and will consider hedging significant foreign currency exposure<br />

should the need arise.<br />

Pledge of Assets of the Group<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company pledged ER’s current accounts held with Trade and Development Bank of<br />

Mongolia, Khan Bank of Mongolia, Golomt Bank of Mongolia and XacBank of Mongolia, its Debt Reserve Account<br />

held with BNP Paribas London; Collection and Cash Collateral accounts held with BNP Paribas Hong Kong;<br />

cooperation contract with Inner Mongolia Qinghua Group of China, coal sales contracts with certain customers;<br />

coal mining agreement with Thiess Mongolia LLC (formerly known as Leighton LLC); engineering, procurement<br />

and construction management contract for the CHPP constructed at the UHG site with Sedgman LLC; CHPP<br />

modules 1 and 2; UHG Power Plant; water facilities and certain coal stockpiles for bank borrowings.<br />

Share pledges of Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited and Mongolian Coal Corporation S.à.r.l. are shared among<br />

the BNP and ICBC Facility and the USD600 million Senior Notes.<br />

ER pledged its 4,207,500 common shares, being 16.46% common shares held by it in International Medical<br />

Centre LLC (“IMC”) to secure loan repayment obligation of IMC in proportion to its equity interest in IMC.<br />

The total amount of indebtedness covered with above pledges is USD744.8 million as at 31 December 2015.<br />

Contingent Liabilities<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company has contingent liability in respect of the consideration adjustments for the<br />

acquisition of BN mine pursuant to the share purchase agreement (the “Share Purchase Agreement”) entered<br />

into by the Company and its subsidiary Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited with Quincunx (BVI) Ltd. and its<br />

parent, Kerry Mining (Mongolia) Limited (collectively the “Seller”) on 31 May 2011 in relation to the acquisition of<br />

the entire share capital of QGX Coal Ltd (the “Acquisition”), which may arise from the royalty provision. Under<br />

the royalty provision, an additional LOM payment of USD6 per tonne may be payable in the event that the actual<br />

amount of coal extracted from the BN mine exceeds a specified semi-annual production target fixed on the date<br />

of the determination of the total reserves in each semi-annual period after 1 June 2011 commencing on 1 January<br />

and ending on 30 June and commencing on 1 July and ending on 31 December.<br />

Under the royalty provisions for excessive coal production at the BN mine pursuant to the Share Purchase<br />

Agreement and the Settlement Agreement dated 27 November 2012 between the Company and the Seller, the<br />

specified semi-annual ROM coal production has to exceed approximately 5.0 Mt. Therefore, the probability of<br />

royalty provision is considered to be very low.<br />

44<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Financial Instruments<br />

The Company has a share option scheme, adopted on 17 September 2010 (“Share Option Scheme”), in which<br />

the Board is authorised, at its discretion, to grant to eligible participants options to subscribe for shares (“Share<br />

Options” or “Options”) subject to the terms and conditions stipulated therein as incentives or rewards for their<br />

contributions to the Company.<br />

Under the Share Option Scheme, the Company granted three batches of Share Options to its director and<br />

employees. On 12 October 2011, the Company granted 3,000,000 and 32,200,000 Share Options to a director<br />

and employees respectively, at the exercise price of HKD6.66 (which was adjusted to HKD4.53 due to rights<br />

issue in December 2014). On 28 November 2012, the Company granted another 5,000,000 and 17,750,000<br />

Share Options to a director and employees respectively, at the exercise price of HKD3.92 (which was adjusted<br />

to HKD2.67 due to rights issue in December 2014). On 10 June 2015, the Company granted another 60,000,000<br />

and 94,750,000 Share Options to a director and employees respectively, at the exercise price of HKD0.445.<br />

The fair value of services received in return for Share Options granted is measured with reference to the fair<br />

value of Share Options granted. For the year ended 31 December 2015, USD3.3 million was recognised in<br />

administrative expenses and capital reserves in relation to the equity-settled share-based transactions.<br />

The USD600 million Senior Notes have been accounted for as a hybrid financial instrument containing both a<br />

derivative component and a liability component. The derivative component was initially recognised at its fair value<br />

of USD4.9 million, and the attributable transactions costs of USD0.1 million were charged to the profit or loss for<br />

the year ended 31 December 2012.<br />

The fair value of the derivative component of the Senior Notes as at 31 December 2015 was nil. The liability<br />

component was initially recognised at an amortised cost of USD591.7 million after taking into account USD13.2<br />

million as attributable costs.<br />

Capital Commitments and Capital Expenditures<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Group had USD0.5 million of contracted for capital commitments (as at 31<br />

December 2014: USD0.6 million):<br />

Table 13. Capital commitments:<br />

As at<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

USD’000<br />

As at<br />

31 December<br />

2014<br />

USD’000<br />

Contracted for 525 560<br />

Authorized but not contracted for — —<br />

Total 525 560<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

45


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Table 14. The Group’s historical capital expenditure for the periods indicated:<br />

Year ended 31 December<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

CHPP 59 1,441<br />

Water supply facility 124 2,391<br />

Fleet management system — 1,023<br />

Others 277 1,093<br />

Total 460 5,948<br />

Operating Lease Commitments<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company had contracted obligations consisting of operating leases which totalled<br />

approximately USD1.6 million due within one year. Lease terms range from one to five years, with fixed rentals.<br />

Significant Investments Held<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company did not hold any significant investments. Save as disclosed in this annual<br />

report, the Company has no future plans for material investment or capital assets in the coming year.<br />

Material Acquisitions and Disposals of Subsidiaries and Associated Companies<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Company did not have any material acquisitions and disposals of<br />

subsidiaries and associated companies.<br />

Other and Subsequent Events<br />

(a)<br />

(b)<br />

On 11 March 2016, the Group entered into the Deed of Termination and Release (the “DTR”) with EBRD,<br />

FMO, and DEG (the “Parallel Lenders”) regarding the repayment of secured interest bearing borrowings.<br />

Pursuant to the DTR, the Group shall endorse to the Parallel Lenders certain promissory notes issued<br />

by Ministry of Finance (“MOF”) with total amount of approximately MNT105.6 billion, and in return the<br />

obligations under the borrowings will be discharged in their entirety and the relevant security thereunder will<br />

be released after 121 calendar days plus 2 business days from the signing of the DTR. Until the issuance of<br />

the consolidated financial statements, the Group had completed the endorsement of promissory notes as<br />

required by the DTR.<br />

Pursuant to a temporary waiver letter granted by the Lenders of the BNP and ICBC Facility on 14 March<br />

2016, the Group is due to repay principal installments of approximately USD36.8 million together with<br />

applicable interest payment on 22 March 2016. As of the issuance of the consolidated financial statements,<br />

the Group had neither made the payment to the Lenders nor been able to secure any waiver or forbearance<br />

from the Lenders in this regard. As such, an event of default under the BNP and ICBC Facility has taken<br />

place, which also constitutes an event of default under certain of the Group’s other indebtedness that<br />

contain cross-default provisions, including the Senior Notes issued by the Group with a principal amount of<br />

USD600 million due on 29 March 2017.<br />

46<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

The Group has proposed to enter forbearance agreements with both the Lenders and the steering committee<br />

of the holders of the Senior Notes (the “Steering Committee”). The Group is in discussion with and intends<br />

to continue dialogue with the Lenders and the Steering Committee and their respective advisers. Also, until<br />

the issuance of the consolidated financial statements, the Group had not obtained corresponding waivers<br />

from BNP Paribas Singapore Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited in respect of<br />

the financial covenants breach of the BNP and ICBC Facility. As such, an event of default under the BNP<br />

and ICBC Facility has taken place. The Group has initiated discussions with the Lenders for revised terms<br />

of the debt facility. Given the material amount of the BNP and ICBC Facility and also existing Intercreditor<br />

Agreement between Lenders and the holders of the Senior Notes in relation to the shared securities and<br />

guarantees, the discussions to revise the BNP and ICBC Facility are undertaken in connection with the debt<br />

restructuring in respect of the Senior Notes. The Group continues discussion with the Lenders regarding<br />

waivers on breach of certain security coverage ratio and financial covenants under the BNP and ICBC<br />

Facility.<br />

Until the issuance of the consolidated financial statements, the Group has not received any notice from<br />

any of the Lenders demanding immediate repayment of any outstanding amount under the BNP and ICBC<br />

Facility or any holder of the Senior Notes or any other creditors.<br />

Employees<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the number of employees of the Group was 1,797 compared with 1,950 employees as<br />

at 31 December 2014.<br />

The Group’s employees are remunerated with reference to the individual performance, experience, qualification<br />

and the prevailing salary trends in the local market, which is subject to review from time to time. With reference to<br />

the Group’s financial and operational performance, employees may also enjoy other benefits such as discretionary<br />

bonus and Share Options pursuant to the Company’s Share Option Scheme.<br />

The Group believes that the foundation of its progress is to build employee capabilities. Hence, having a sound<br />

training and development mechanism is an important part of developing its employee capabilities. Employees<br />

have the opportunity to further develop their skills and competencies through ongoing training and development<br />

based on business needs of the Company and job specifications.<br />

Training and development programs shall be designed for the interest and welfare of the Company and<br />

employees. An employee who has completed his/her training is expected to put the knowledge into practice,<br />

and share the newly gained experience with co-workers. The immediate management shall be responsible for<br />

the support and supervision of the process. During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Company focused on<br />

internally sourced trainings rather than trainings provided by external parties. As at 31 December 2015, a total<br />

of 231 employees attended different professional trainings, out of which 96 employees attended mining heavy<br />

equipment operator training, 91 employees attended mine maintenance training and 44 employees attended<br />

professional development training.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the amount of staff costs was USD26.6 million, compared to USD31.7<br />

million in 2014.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

47


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

NON-EXEMPT CONTINUING CONNECTED TRANSACTIONS<br />

The Company has entered into the following continuing connected transactions (the “CCTs”) in the ordinary<br />

course of its business with certain of its connected persons. Set out below is a summary of the CCTs entered by<br />

the Company in compliance with the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the Stock Exchange (the “Listing<br />

Rules”) recorded for the year ended 31 December 2015 and are required to be disclosed in the annual report of<br />

the Company pursuant to Chapter 14A of the Listing Rules.<br />

(1) Power System Operation and Maintenance Agreement<br />

Principal Terms<br />

On 30 December 2014, Energy Resources LLC, an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company,<br />

entered into an agreement with MCS International LLC, a subsidiary of MCS Holding LLC, whereby MCS<br />

International LLC agreed to provide services including: (i) UHG Power Plant and electricity distribution<br />

facilities operation and maintenance; (ii) heating facilities operation and maintenance; (iii) diesel generators<br />

operation and maintenance; and (iv) supply of electricity and heating to end customers and contractors<br />

of the Group and billing for the consumption to the Group. The agreement is for a term of three years<br />

commencing from 1 January 2015 to 31 December 2017.<br />

Connected Person<br />

As at the date of this annual report, MCS International LLC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of MCS Holding<br />

LLC which directly owns a 57.76% shareholding interest in MCS Mining Group Limited, a controlling<br />

shareholder of the Company. As such, MCS International LLC is a connected person of the Company.<br />

Consideration<br />

The total consideration payable under this agreement, which equals to the sum of the annual caps for<br />

the three years ending 31 December 2017, is MNT86,332,146,634 (then equivalent to approximately<br />

USD45,815,832) payable on a monthly basis within 60 days upon receipt of valid invoice from MCS<br />

International LLC. The annual caps were determined on an arm’s length basis between the Group and MCS<br />

International LLC after taking into account (i) the negotiated fixed and variable charges; (ii) negotiated energy<br />

tariff; (iii) anticipated electricity production volume after considering production and business expansion; (iv)<br />

scheduled major overhauls of the power plant equipment; (v) VAT and other taxes; and (vi) contingencies<br />

that would be applicable and payable for the services of MCS International LLC under the agreement. Annual<br />

cap for this agreement is MNT26,877,569,129 (then equivalent to approximately USD14,263,727) for the<br />

year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Transactions (excluding VAT) in the total amount of MNT16,196,949,494 (equivalent to approximately<br />

USD8,222,720) was made by the Group for the year ended 31 December 2015 under this agreement.<br />

48<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

(2) Fuel Supply Agreement with NIC LLC<br />

Principal Terms<br />

On 18 October 2013, Energy Resources LLC, an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company, entered<br />

into a fuel supply agreement with NIC LLC, pursuant to which NIC LLC agreed to supply fuel products<br />

including diesel fuel, lubricants and other types of fuel to the Group and provide other related services at the<br />

UHG mine site and BN mine site. The agreement is for a term of three years commencing from 1 January<br />

2014 to 31 December 2016.<br />

Connected Person<br />

NIC LLC is an associate of Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv, a non-executive Director and therefore, NIC LLC is a<br />

connected person of the Company.<br />

Consideration<br />

The maximum consideration payable under this agreement is USD784,369,936 payable on a monthly<br />

basis within 60 days upon receipt of valid invoice from NIC LLC. The consideration was determined by the<br />

tender proposal submitted by NIC LLC which is based on market rate of fuel products. Annual cap for this<br />

agreement is USD254,580,068 for the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Transactions (excluding VAT) in the total amount of USD12,975,749 was made by the Group for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015 under the agreement.<br />

(3) Fuel Supply Agreement with Shunkhlai LLC<br />

Principal Terms<br />

On 18 October 2013, Transgobi LLC, an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company, entered into a<br />

fuel supply agreement with Shunkhlai LLC, pursuant to which Shunkhlai LLC agreed to supply fuel products<br />

including diesel fuel, gasoline and other types of fuel to the Group and provide other related services at the<br />

UHG mine site and TKH site for the Group’s coal transportation and logistics operations. The agreement is<br />

for a term of three years commencing from 1 January 2014 to 31 December 2016.<br />

Connected Person<br />

Shunkhlai LLC is an associate of Mr. Batsaikhan Purev, who has resigned from his position as non-executive<br />

Director with effect from 30 November 2015. As at the date of this annual report, Mr. Batsaikhan Purev is<br />

considered as a person who was a director of the Company in the last 12 months and therefore, Shunkhlai<br />

LLC is a connected person of the Company.<br />

Consideration<br />

The maximum consideration payable under this agreement is USD169,373,021 payable on a monthly basis<br />

within 60 days upon receipt of valid invoice from Shunkhlai LLC. The consideration was determined by the<br />

tender proposal submitted by Shunkhlai LLC which is based on market rate of fuel products. Annual cap for<br />

this agreement is USD56,144,383 for the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Transactions (excluding VAT) in the total amount of USD1,831,699 was made by Transgobi LLC for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015 under the agreement.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

49


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

(4) Service Agreement<br />

Principal Terms<br />

On 18 October 2013, Energy Resources LLC, an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company, entered<br />

into a service agreement with Uniservice Solution LLC, a subsidiary of MCS Holding LLC, pursuant to which<br />

Uniservice Solution LLC agreed to provide office and camp supporting services to the Group for a term of<br />

three years commencing from 1 January 2014 to 31 December 2016.<br />

Connected Person<br />

As at the date of this annual report, Uniservice Solution LLC is a subsidiary of MCS Holding LLC which<br />

directly owns a 57.76% shareholding interest in MCS Mining Group Limited, a controlling shareholder of the<br />

Company. As such, Uniservice Solution LLC is a connected person of the Company.<br />

Consideration<br />

The maximum consideration payable under this agreement is MNT72,957,978,408 (then equivalent to<br />

approximately USD43,026,555) payable on a monthly basis within 60 days upon receipt of valid invoice from<br />

Uniservice Solution LLC. The consideration was determined based on the size of the location where services<br />

are to be provided, the number of employees utilising the camp site, the temporary ger camp located at<br />

the UHG mine site and BN mine site, and on an arm’s length basis between the Company and Uniservice<br />

Solution LLC based on the bid submitted by Uniservice Solution LLC. Annual cap for this agreement is<br />

MNT24,319,326,136 (then equivalent to approximately USD14,342,185) for the year ended 31 December<br />

2015.<br />

Transactions (excluding VAT) in the total amount of MNT6,859,431,072 (equivalent to approximately<br />

USD3,482,333) was made by the Group for the year ended 31 December 2015 under the agreement.<br />

(5) Security Services Agreement<br />

Principal Terms<br />

On 18 October 2013, Energy Resources LLC, an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company,<br />

entered into a security service agreement with M Armor LLC (previously MCS Armor LLC), a subsidiary of<br />

MCS Holding LLC, pursuant to which M Armor LLC agreed to provide security services, safeguarding and<br />

services for prevention of unlawful conducts and violations at the Ulaanbaatar office, UHG mine site, BN<br />

mine site, TKH site and other premises of the Group and vehicle inspection and safety assurance services<br />

for the Ulaanbaatar office of the Company on a day-to-day basis. The agreement is for a term of three years<br />

commencing from 1 January 2014 to 31 December 2016.<br />

Connected Person<br />

As at the date of this annual report, M Armor LLC is a subsidiary of MCS Holding LLC which directly owns<br />

a 57.76% shareholding interest in MCS Mining Group Limited, a controlling shareholder of the Company. As<br />

such, M Armor LLC is a connected person of the Company.<br />

50<br />

Annual Report 2015


Management Discussion and Analysis<br />

Consideration<br />

The maximum consideration payable under this agreement is MNT12,933,103,680 (then equivalent to<br />

approximately USD7,627,225) payable on a monthly basis within 60 days upon receipt of valid invoice<br />

from M Armor LLC. The consideration was determined on an arm’s length basis between the Company<br />

and M Armor LLC based on the bid submitted by M Armor LLC. Annual cap for this agreement is<br />

MNT4,311,034,560 (then equivalent to approximately USD2,542,408) for the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Transactions (excluding VAT) in the total amount of MNT3,415,210,168 (equivalent to approximately<br />

USD1,733,803) was made by the Group for the year ended 31 December 2015 under the agreement.<br />

The independent non-executive Directors reviewed the CCTs of the Group pursuant to Rule 14A.55 of the<br />

Listing Rules.<br />

In the opinion of the independent non-executive Directors, the CCTs were entered into by the Group:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

in the ordinary and usual course of business of the Group;<br />

on normal commercial terms or better; and<br />

according to the agreement governing them on terms that are fair and reasonable and in the interests<br />

of the shareholders of the Company as a whole.<br />

The Board has received a letter from the auditor of the Company confirming the matters set out in Rule<br />

14A.56 of the Listing Rules that in respect of the disclosed CCTs:<br />

(a)<br />

(b)<br />

(c)<br />

(d)<br />

nothing has come to the attention of the auditor that causes them to believe that the disclosed CCTs<br />

have not been approved by the Board;<br />

for the transactions involving the provision of goods and services by the Group, nothing has come to<br />

the attention of the auditor that causes them to believe that the disclosed CCTs were not, in all material<br />

respects, in accordance with the pricing policies of the Group;<br />

nothing has come to the attention of the auditor that causes them to believe that the disclosed CCTs<br />

were not entered into, in all material respects, in accordance with the relevant agreements governing<br />

such transactions; and<br />

with respect to the aggregate amount of each of the CCTs set out in items (1) to (5), nothing has come<br />

to the attention of the auditor that causes them to believe that the disclosed CCTs have exceeded the<br />

annual cap disclosed in the announcements made by the Company in respect of each of the disclosed<br />

CCTs.<br />

In respect of the aforesaid CCTs, the Company has complied with the disclosure requirements under the<br />

Listing Rules.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

51


Sustainability Report<br />

OUR APPROACH TO SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT<br />

We integrate sustainability into the core of our business strategy and are committed to ensure that our operations<br />

appropriately account for their respective social and environmental consequences. We have Sustainable<br />

Development Policy and Corporate Social Responsibility (“CSR”) Policy, which alongside with our corporate<br />

documents and guidelines in the relevant fields, define our approach and responsibility towards diverse<br />

stakeholder groups.<br />

Effective and proper utilization of natural resources and continual strengthening of sustainable development<br />

practices are crucial for our long-term business success. We work in compliance with all applicable international<br />

and local standards at each and every level of our operation, ensure we put the health and safety of our<br />

employees and communities first, and seek to minimize our environmental impact. We also strive to be an integral<br />

part of the communities in which we operate, and foster sustainable and fruitful relationships with them in order to<br />

create lasting value.<br />

Our governance framework clearly defines the role and approaches our board and management should take in<br />

overseeing the performance in sustainability. Transparency, accountability, respect for the rule of law and respect<br />

for human rights are all deemed crucial in sustaining meaningful and long-term engagement with our stakeholders.<br />

BUSINESS INTEGRITY<br />

Code of conduct<br />

Integrity and accountability are core values at MMC and are central to our reputation as a socially responsible<br />

mining company. We have a Code of Conduct (the “Code”) that restates our commitment to responsible<br />

action and establishes good governance and CSR as essential principles for valuing employees, preserving<br />

the environment and contributing to development of the communities in which we operate. A set of desirable<br />

behaviours are embedded in the Code which promote a positive and responsible professional attitude among<br />

employees and leaders. Employees at all levels, including executives and contractors must strictly follow the<br />

Code and act with responsibility, honesty, trust, respect, and loyalty, obeying all laws and regulations in effect.<br />

Violations of the Code are taken seriously and can result in disciplinary actions. No disciplinary actions were<br />

recorded in the reporting period.<br />

Human rights<br />

At every level of our operations, we respect the human rights of our employees, host communities and partners.<br />

We uphold the United Nations (“UN”) Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Labour Organisation<br />

(“ILO”) Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work and The UN Guiding Principles for Business<br />

and Human Rights. We are committed to equal opportunity and freedom from all forms of discrimination for our<br />

employees and their rights to freedom of association and collective bargaining.<br />

In line with the above, we promote human rights within our sphere of influence in the following ways:<br />

•<br />

At our operational sites and offices, we aim to ensure that equal opportunity is afforded to all our employees<br />

irrespective of race, gender, nationality, age, religious belief, social origin, political views, union affiliation,<br />

pregnancy, disability or any other basis. Our employees are free to exercise freedom of association and<br />

freedom of speech. We have feedback boxes at our mine sites to allow employees to express their opinions<br />

and report any breaches of ethical conduct and behaviour. We also endeavour to maintain a working<br />

environment free from workplace harassment and discrimination which promotes professional and personal<br />

growth;<br />

52<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

• In the value chain, we seek to establish relationships with suppliers and contractors which share our<br />

principles and values while promoting awareness and application of human rights protection; and<br />

• With local communities, we maintain continuous engagement based on dialogue and mutual respect for their<br />

rights to access land, access to water, freedom of movement and freedom of expression.<br />

Our community grievance handling mechanism allows the host community members to freely submit their<br />

complaints and grievances to the Company’s management and respective departments. We established a<br />

Human Rights Task Force in 2010 and subsequently developed the Human Rights Program which addresses<br />

our corporate sustainability policy in the area of human rights. Within the framework of the program, we provide<br />

customised training on Voluntary Principles on Security and Human Rights to our security service providers.<br />

In this way, we ensure that they are aware of our commitment to upholding human rights and any violations or<br />

workplace-related risks are duly prevented. In the reporting period, we recorded no such violations.<br />

Forced or compulsory labour<br />

We do not employ or support any type of forced, compulsory or child labour as defined by the ILO as “all work<br />

or service which is extracted from any person under the menace of any penalty and for which the said person<br />

has not offered himself voluntarily”. We strictly adhere to our principles that an employee should have the right<br />

to leave the work premises after completing the standard workday and to terminate employment after giving<br />

reasonable notice. MMC does not employ a person who is under the national legal age of employment and in line<br />

with our recruitment policy, we employ people aged 18 or older. In the year under review, the Company has not<br />

employed any people aged under 18.<br />

Transparency<br />

We report our financial statements and the results of our operational and sustainable development performance in<br />

accordance with all applicable rules and legislations, to ensure maximum transparency that is commercially viable.<br />

We are one of the active supporters of the Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative (“EITI”) in Mongolia and have<br />

been disclosing our payments to the government since the start of our mining operations in 2009.<br />

The National EITI Council in Mongolia operates at national, regional and local levels to expand its outreach<br />

to aimags and soums with active mining operations. In 2015, MMC had an active participation in sub-council<br />

meetings in both Umnugobi aimag and Tsogttsetsii soum and disclosed its payments to the government, spending<br />

on community development projects, tax payments to the local government, sponsorships and environmental<br />

issues, among others. The meetings were attended by representatives of the National EITI Council as well as<br />

local civil society organizations, local administration and local council members. We believe that direct and twoway<br />

communication with all of the above participants is essential in ensuring that our information reaches various<br />

stakeholders in a transparent manner.<br />

Our project related information is disclosed to our host communities every year as part of our Public Consultation<br />

and Disclosure Plan.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

53


Sustainability Report<br />

Fair operating practices<br />

We are committed to high-level governance and ethical business conducts, and strongly believe that bribery,<br />

corruption, unfair supply chain practices and other similar behaviour that violate the rule of fair play would<br />

negatively affect the Company’s image and undermine its future performance. The Code and other guidelines<br />

clearly prohibit bribery and corruption in all forms of business dealings. We also strive to implement socially<br />

responsible supply chain practices and anti-corruption practices by working closely with our suppliers, host<br />

communities and relevant government agencies. A system is in place to ensure that our procurement practices<br />

are free from unfair business dealings.<br />

We have an independent internal audit function as well as a donation/sponsorship committee which prevent<br />

from all kinds of unfair dealings or making of payments in kind (gifts or favours) to influence individuals to award<br />

business opportunities to us or to make a business decision in our favour.<br />

We are committed to cooperative, respectful and positive dialogue with policymakers and government agencies<br />

of Mongolia. We believe this should be based on genuine consultation and accountability. In doing so, MMC<br />

participates in and contributes to all major public policy discussions and initiatives through proactive engagement<br />

with policymakers on a wide range of issues including dialogue on the operational and legal environment<br />

surrounding the mining industry in Mongolia.<br />

We recorded no cases of bribery, corruption or unethical business conduct in the reporting period.<br />

OUR PEOPLE<br />

A skilled and motivated workforce is central to our successful business operation. We engage our people over<br />

the long term and in line with our overall business strategy. We believe that it is essential to encourage diversity<br />

while providing a safe, challenging and exciting working environment where our employees can realize their full<br />

potential. Fair opportunities are provided at every level of our business operation and good performance and<br />

leadership are rewarded accordingly. As one of the largest private employers at both local and national level, we<br />

seek to:<br />

• Provide equal employment opportunities and respect the rights of our people;<br />

• Recruit based on skills and experience and support local employment wherever possible, within the<br />

framework of our community development strategy. Our aim is to recruit and maintain at least 30% of our<br />

workforce from the local communities;<br />

• Offer compensation and benefit schemes that are competitive within the Mongolian mining industry; and<br />

• Ensure that our employees are aware of and follow the ethical working standards and other internal<br />

procedures of the Company through the Code.<br />

Our human resources (“HR”) activities are in full compliance with the Mongolian Labour Law and other relevant<br />

legislation. We have passed the state labour inspections with outstanding results compared to other mining<br />

companies operating in Mongolia since 2012. In 2014, we were officially informed that no formal labour<br />

inspections will be carried out in 2015 to 2017 due to our exceptional HR performance. Nonetheless, we continue<br />

to have a strong focus on development at all levels within the Company and strengthening our HR system.<br />

54<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Highlights of 2015<br />

• Focused on optimizing the Company’s organizational structure and operational productivity through analysis<br />

of job position performance, merger of job duties in certain areas and upgrading of job descriptions;<br />

• Updated our relocation policy under which all of our site employees are enabled to buy an apartment with<br />

financial assistance from the Company;<br />

• Commenced the process of introducing a payroll administration system via our integrated Oracle Enterprise<br />

Resource Planning software in order to improve staff payroll accuracy and efficiency; and<br />

• Transferred more authority to our site based management resulting in faster decision making and increased<br />

productivity at all levels of business.<br />

Non-discrimination and equal opportunity<br />

In line with the Company’s effort to build productive and diverse workforce, we do not tolerate discrimination<br />

based on race, gender, nationality, age, religious belief, social origin, political views, union affiliation, pregnancy,<br />

disability or any other nature and abide by Mongolian Labour Law and all applicable legislation with respect to<br />

non-discrimination. We strive to engage in good practice efforts that go beyond the legal obligations. Our internal<br />

rules and guidelines clearly reflect the policy to conduct all types of HR activities based on principles of nondiscrimination.<br />

All of our employees enter into written employment contracts with the Company which detail, among other things,<br />

their duties and responsibilities, remuneration, as well as the grounds for termination of employment. We employ<br />

people on the basis of job requirements and matching skills, but seek to provide preferential employment to local<br />

people where possible in order to make tangible economic contributions to the communities in which we operate.<br />

As of 31 December 2015, we had a total of 1,797 employees of which approximately 45% were hired from the<br />

local communities. The percentage of our local employees has steadily increased over the recent years (see Table<br />

15), signifying our strong commitment to the host communities.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

55


Sustainability Report<br />

Figure 3. HR statistics<br />

Table 15. HR statistics<br />

MMC 12/31/2013 12/31/2014 12/31/2015<br />

Total number of employees 2,272 1,950 1,797<br />

Number of female employees 324 296 259<br />

Number of female employees in management position 9 15 40<br />

Percentage of local employees 43.3% 40.6% 45%<br />

As part of providing equal opportunity to all employees, role based remuneration is determined on an “equal work,<br />

equal pay” basis. Accordingly, equal base salaries are paid to employees working in the same position under the<br />

same conditions. Within this system, wage discrimination on any basis, such as gender or employee domicile, is<br />

not possible. Variation in remuneration is, however, applied on basis of a transparent grading system developed<br />

to objectively account for variation in employee skill, experience and performance.<br />

In 2015, approximately 15% of our total employees were female. Of those female employees, approximately 10%<br />

hold technical positions, 75% hold professional positions (analysts, engineers, geologists, etc.) and 15% are<br />

managers and executives.<br />

During the year under review, we recorded no cases of discrimination at our mine sites and offices.<br />

56<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Employee remuneration and benefits<br />

As a responsible employer, we offer competitive compensation packages and welfare benefits to all of our<br />

employees consistent with the Mongolian Labour Law and other relevant legislation. Our remuneration and<br />

compensation strategy aims to provide employees with competitive remuneration packages that comprise<br />

monetary remuneration, various types of benefits and a safe and pleasant work environment. Salary reviews<br />

are conducted on an annual basis as part of the performance review cycle and account for the individual’s role,<br />

performance and local market trends.<br />

Our employee benefits include:<br />

• Bonus and incentives schemes;<br />

• Parental and other types of paid leave;<br />

• Stand-by allowance;<br />

• Resettlement and local allowances;<br />

• Free-of-charge comprehensive medical check-ups;<br />

• Assistance with housing costs;<br />

• Assistance accessing low interest housing loans;<br />

• Monetary allowances for phone use and transportation;<br />

• Subsidies for a range of health and wellness activities;<br />

• Personal accident insurance;<br />

• International health insurance; and<br />

• Others (events, celebrations, gifts, one-off allowances, etc.).<br />

These benefits are offered to all employees irrespective of their position and length of employment. In the<br />

reporting period, the Company spent approximately MNT3 billion for employee benefits and allowances.<br />

Employee performance incentive plans designed relative to Company, department and individual performance are<br />

maintained by the Company, providing mechanism to reward and retain high performing employees.<br />

Employee turnover<br />

The employee turnover rate within the Group decreased from 18% in 2014 to 10% in 2015. In line with our overall<br />

HR policy, special focus has been given to those who leave the Company on a voluntary basis and appropriate<br />

measures are taken regarding the reasons for leaving.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

57


Sustainability Report<br />

The Company’s relocation policy plays an important role in keeping the turnover rate at minimum. It enables all<br />

of our employees working on site to have access to a housing project and get financial assistance from us where<br />

appropriate. Since 2013, approximately 650 employees have been relocated to Tsogttsetsii soum with their<br />

families. We pay special attention to the families of resettled employees, providing them with all kinds of direct<br />

and indirect assistance and carry out targeted social development programs.<br />

In addition to the above, all of our employees undergo periodic performance reviews which serve as a conduit for<br />

professional development and help them achieve career targets.<br />

Training and development<br />

The development of our people is recognized as a vital aspect of our achievements, and we believe that the<br />

performance of each employee effectively impacts the Company’s performance as a whole. We aim to choose the<br />

best people for the right positions and provide them with access to on-going career development opportunities.<br />

We invest consistently in the training of mining professionals due to the lack of suitably skilled personnel both<br />

at the local and national level, thus job specific training form a big part of our overall training platform. The<br />

Company focuses mainly on conducting in-house trainings rather than outsourcing, with an aim to reduce costs<br />

and improve operational efficiency. During the year under review, we conducted 18 types of training programs,<br />

of which, 3 were in professional and vocational fields such as heavy equipment operation and maintenance while<br />

the remaining 15 involved general corporate skills training. A total of 145 employees participated in corporate and<br />

vocational skills training for approximately 7,788 man-hours. The average training hours per employee was 53.7<br />

hours.<br />

In 2015, we adopted a new “On boarding policy” to better assist new employees to settling in MMC and adapt<br />

to the business culture. It also enables new employees to understand daily priorities and get familiar with the<br />

corporate policies and guidelines in the shortest possible time.<br />

Table 16. Training highlights<br />

2015 Training highlights<br />

Total number of participants in heavy machinery operator training 96<br />

Total number of participants in mine maintenance training 91<br />

HEALTH, SAFETY & ENVIRONMENT<br />

We pursue excellence in Heath, Safety and Environmental (“HSE”) practices to ensure an incident-free, safe<br />

and healthy workplace where our employees can realise their full potential. As such, we have developed and<br />

implemented an integrated Health, Safety and Environmental Management System (“HSE MS”) to help achieve<br />

the objectives and targets set out in our HSE policy. Our systems and processes seek to provide our employees<br />

and contractors the necessary directions to practise safe work behaviours and make each individual accountable<br />

for the implementation of the HSE MS and its accompanying elements, rules and procedures.<br />

The HSE performance is driven by our commitment of ‘Zero harm’ to our people and communities and minimal<br />

adverse impacts on the environment. Within the framework of the HSE policy, we are committed to the following<br />

objectives:<br />

• Identify, assess and manage risks to employees, contractors, communities and the environment;<br />

• Comply with the applicable national legal, and target international best practice requirements;<br />

58<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

• Enforce accountability mechanisms that ensure each employee contributes to providing a safe and healthy<br />

workplace and prevent all types of environmental pollution;<br />

• Provide relevant HSE training for employees, contractors and local communities;<br />

• Ensure that the Company management at all levels are HSE role models and lead by example;<br />

• Take all necessary measures to prevent industrial accidents and environmental incidents. In the event of<br />

any accidents or incidents, investigate the root cause and take swift action to rectify the risk to prevent reoccurrence;<br />

• Ensure that assessment, reporting and management of any potential HSE risks are duties of all employees;<br />

• Review and continually improve the HSE MS implementing learnings from any accidents, incidents or nonconformances;<br />

• Review and assess the HSE performance of individual employees; and<br />

• Support and reward the practice of receiving HSE risk reports from local community members and actively<br />

cooperate with them to eliminate potential risks.<br />

The HSE policy aims to strengthen the leadership of managers at all levels and involve all employees in the<br />

implementation of the policy. Accordingly, we have a formally approved HSE structure and HR in place to<br />

ensure the continual improvement of the HSE MS according to the requirements of ISO 14001:2004 and OHSAS<br />

18001:2007 standards.<br />

HSE MS review and improvement<br />

As part of the HSE MS requirements, a pack of HSE MS documents was approved by the Company’s CEO<br />

Order A/31 dated June 2013 and has been effective since then. The review and improvement of the integrated<br />

documentation continued throughout the reporting period to ensure that it meets Mongolian applicable legislative<br />

requirements.<br />

In 2015, the following parts of the document were reviewed and updated in dual languages:<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-01.00 Legal and other relevant requirements;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-02.00 Objectives and planning;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-03.00 Roles, responsibilities and accountability;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-04.00 Risk management;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-05.00 Training awareness and competence;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-06.00 Communication, consultation and participation;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-07.00 Emergency preparedness and response;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-08.00 Incident investigation and reporting;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-09.00 Documented information;<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-10.00 Audits, inspections and compliance; and<br />

• ER-SS-HSE-EL-11.00 Management review.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

59


Sustainability Report<br />

In September 2015, the ISO 14001:2004 standard was upgraded to ISO 14001:2015, thus a review process is<br />

underway to reflect amendments of the new standard into the integrated documents.<br />

Occupational health and safety (“OHS”)<br />

To achieve and maintain incident free workplaces, it is required to identify and mitigate potential risks. Hence,<br />

core management objectives include identifying and evaluating hazards, and introducing appropriate mitigation<br />

measures to control risks to appropriate levels. The main occupational health challenges that pose threats to our<br />

employee’s well-being are fatigue, muscular-skeletal injuries, noise induced hearing loss, dust related respiratory<br />

illnesses and infectious diseases. In accordance with our Occupational Health and Disease Policy, we identify job<br />

positions in which our people are exposed to occupational health hazards, and actions are in place to prevent and<br />

mitigate discovered hazards. Other preventative measures include building awareness and knowledge of disease<br />

and other health hazards through internal training and awareness campaigns.<br />

At our workplaces, medical and emergency response teams are maintained on a 24-hour basis to ensure that<br />

any accidents and emergencies are responded to immediately. The site-based emergency response team also<br />

responds to fire and other emergency calls within the local community. Our employees form a part of the local<br />

communities in which we operate, hence any public health issues confronting the community affect our workforce<br />

as well. We also work in partnerships with local communities, public health authorities and other stakeholders to<br />

improve education on, protection from and prevention of public health risks and widespread diseases.<br />

In 2015, the Company continued with its efforts to prevent workplace related illnesses, injuries and environmental<br />

incidents by continuing to monitor and review HSE performance and applying new standards and procedures into<br />

the integrated documents, where required.<br />

Highlights of 2015<br />

• No fatality was recorded;<br />

• No occupational illnesses were recorded;<br />

• No complaints on environment related issues were received;<br />

• No fines were imposed for OHS compliance breaches; and<br />

• Achieved a record low LTIFR.<br />

OHS performance<br />

In 2015, we aimed to reduce the OHS incident rate by 20% from the previous year and set the targets as below:<br />

Class 1 incidents (Fatality or permanent disability) 0<br />

LTIFR 1.0<br />

Total recordable injury frequency rate (“TRIFR”) 4.3<br />

The below table and corresponding graphs show our performance on the set OHS incident targets.<br />

60<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Table 17. 2015 Safety statistics<br />

2014 2015<br />

Total man-hours worked 5,643,141 3,330,938<br />

Fatalities 2 0<br />

TRIFR 5.32 2.70<br />

LTIFR 1.24 0.60<br />

Legal compliance 87.25% 87.2%<br />

Severity (total lost workdays/total hours worked*1000000) 158 28.2<br />

Safety inductions (number of employees and contractors covered) 12,681 5,202<br />

Figure 4. Injury Frequency Rates, 2011 - 2015<br />

Within all operations under the management of the Group, approximately 3.3 million man-hours were worked by<br />

employees, contractors and sub-contractors in 2015. During this period, 2 LTIs were recorded, resulting in an<br />

overall LTIFR of 0.6.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

61


Sustainability Report<br />

Figure 5. LTIFR (year-to-date) and 12-month rolling average<br />

The recorded LTIFR during the 2015 calendar year represents the Group’s best reported performance in any half<br />

or full year of operation thus far, and demonstrates its on-going commitment to achieve and sustain the goal of<br />

“Zero harm”. It also compares favourably in comparison to publicly available international mining industry safety<br />

statistics, such as those from the Queensland Government Department of Natural Resources and Mines (Surface<br />

Coal Mines, 2.3, 2014-2015) and the New South Wales Department of Resources and Energy (Surface Coal<br />

Mines, 2.9, 2014-2015). This performance was underpinned by the development, implementation and continual<br />

improvement of the Group’s HSE MS. During the reporting period, safety training and inductions were delivered to<br />

5,149 employees, contractors and visitors, and OHSE specific training man-hours totalled 12,598.<br />

A total of 54 incidents and near misses were recorded during the reporting period with all required investigations<br />

were completed. Out of 212 planned corrective actions, 185 were completed for 87% compliance. Within the<br />

framework of incident prevention measures, a total of 131 hazards were identified, of which 120 were corrected,<br />

for completion rate of 92% against target of 80%.<br />

Workplace occupational hygiene monitoring was conducted across all operational areas on a regularly scheduled<br />

basis. The types of monitoring included thermal environmental factors, noise, lighting, vibration, general and small<br />

particulate airborne dust, oxygen and other gases in the air, and all of the results were in compliance with the<br />

national standards.<br />

As part of the occupational hygiene, safety and environmental inspections, a total of 115 individual inspections<br />

were carried out at various workplaces. All identified hazards and HSE MS non-conformances were investigated<br />

to discover and eliminate root causes. Accordingly, 73.8% of the non-conformance were corrected.<br />

Each operational department conducted risk assessments to identify Class 1 Risks (risks that could result<br />

in fatality) and developed suitable control measures to manage the risks. Chemical risk assessments were<br />

also carried out and control measures were taken accordingly. Through the emergency medical service and<br />

rehabilitation function, a total of 15 emergency calls were received and appropriate medical services were<br />

provided, in addition to monthly operational check-ups and maintenance of first aid facilities distributed at<br />

strategic locations at the workplaces. Overall, the medical service team provided site diagnosis and routine<br />

check-up services for a total of 1,234 employees.<br />

62<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Environmental stewardship<br />

Responsibility for environmental stewardship is taken seriously by the Group, and it is central to our sustainability<br />

approach. We have robust environmental management systems and practices through which we assess and<br />

identify potential environmental risks, conduct routine monitoring, and report the performance results to minimize<br />

the adverse impact of our operations on the environment.<br />

Major environmental challenges for MMC operations are the reduction of dust emissions, the efficient use of water<br />

and land resources, responsible management and handling of biodiversity issues and the prevention of all forms<br />

of environmental pollution and incidents.<br />

Individual management plans are devised based on the results of the Environmental and Social Impact<br />

Assessment conducted previously during project development. The following six environmental management<br />

plans are in place to ensure that we are accountable for our environmental footprint: dust management plan,<br />

erosion and sediment control plan, waste management plan, hazardous waste management plan, tailings storage<br />

facility (“TSF”) management plan, mining closure and reclamation plan, and monitoring plan. The implementation<br />

of environmental management plans are reviewed annually against various KPIs. Based on the outcomes of the<br />

review, corrective actions are taken for continuous improvement.<br />

Highlights of 2015<br />

• No critical environmental incidents were recorded at our operations in the reporting period;<br />

• 1.3 hectares of stockpiled topsoil was re-vegetated as part of our top soil handling management activities, in<br />

order to maintain microbe and nutrient content of the soil and prevent potential risks in plant performance;<br />

• 0.5 hectares of dust generating bare ground was landscaped around the Tsetsii apartment complex, with<br />

approximately 2,500 trees planed, gardens established and grass seed sown in collaboration with employees<br />

in the local community; and<br />

• Performance against the annual environmental management plan was audited by an environmental<br />

inspection commission of the Umnugobi aimag government and was assessed as being sufficient at 89.5%.<br />

Environmental incidents<br />

The main types of potential environmental incidents applicable to our operations are noise and dust exceeding<br />

allowed limits, hydrocarbon spills, improper use and storage of chemical substances and hazardous materials,<br />

wildlife deaths, improper disposal of waste and other incidents that negatively impact the environment. All<br />

occurrences of environmental incidents are investigated, remedied, monitored and reported by our environment<br />

team to prevent re-occurrence in the future. We have an internal rating scale for incidents based on their severity,<br />

which was last updated in April 2015. Accordingly, the risk rating scale uses 5 classifications which are low,<br />

minor, moderate, high and extreme. More specific classifications are developed for each environmental risk<br />

subjects including spills, waste disposal, land disturbance, air emissions, fauna injury and others.<br />

In 2015, we recorded no environmental incidents with “high” or above classifications. Two incidents occurred<br />

with “low” classifications which were spillage of waste water and usage of anticorrosive substance for truck tires.<br />

For both incidents, full investigations were carried out to identify the root causes and corrective and preventive<br />

actions were taken to prevent re-occurrences.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

63


Sustainability Report<br />

Biodiversity<br />

Coal mining activities have potential to impact on the surrounding flora and fauna throughout the mine life cycle.<br />

Therefore, we find it crucial to understand the biodiversity elements of the region in which we operate and plan our<br />

actions. Our aim is to minimize and manage the potential environmental impacts based on our project Biodiversity<br />

Action Plan (“BAP”). It is a regulatory requirement to have in place active biodiversity management plans which<br />

are reviewed annually and inclusive of a set of budgets for planned activities. We have been conducting flora and<br />

fauna monitoring since 2011.<br />

As part of the BAP, the Company has organized wild animal conservation activities every year since 2009. In<br />

February 2015, the Company’s environmental team placed 20m 3 of ice in several locations in “Tsetsii” mountain to<br />

prevent dehydration of hoofed mountain animals in the region, including the Siberian ibex and argali (wild sheep)<br />

in snowless periods throughout the winter months.<br />

As part of the conservation of endangered and endemic plant species in Gobi region, trial plantings were<br />

conducted since 2013. A plant unique to the region Olgaea leucophylla was planted in 2014 and has been<br />

growing well since then. In the reporting period, we planted one more critically endangered plant Caryoptheris<br />

mongolica in our nursery area. The purpose of our experimental trials is to cultivate the rare species of plant<br />

native to the Gobi region and ensure further use in mine reclamation activities.<br />

Land<br />

We support sustainable development of land resources through effective planning and cooperation with respective<br />

stakeholders. Securing access to land and managing it responsibly are essential components of our commitment<br />

to sustainable development and our ability to maintain social license to operate. We want to ensure that in the<br />

future, disturbed land becomes available for other uses such as grazing and housing. Our land management plan<br />

provides a sound framework for undertaking rehabilitation and other land management activities which involve<br />

levelling and contouring, reshaping, adding topsoil and re-vegetating land to restore the land for future use.<br />

In the reporting period, 1.3 hectares of stockpiled topsoil was re-vegetated as part of our topsoil management<br />

activities, in order to maintain microbe and nutrient content of the soil and prevent potential risks to plant<br />

performance. Certain types of rare plant species were used for re-vegetation which include Medicago falcata<br />

and Sand Esparsette , perennial plant species that support soil nutrition and Sudan grass , species that support<br />

perennial plant growing. Ulmus pumila and Elaeagnus moorcrofti , endemic trees specific to Gobi region, were<br />

planted on top soil stockpiles for cultivation of green area.<br />

We introduced a new irrigation system with effective water consumption for our top soil stockpile vegetation to<br />

increase and support the moisture content of the top soil. Overall care for and maintenance of the re-vegetated<br />

areas were carried out continuously from June to October 2015.<br />

64<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Preparation of topsoil stockpile for vegetation<br />

Re-vegetated topsoil stockpile<br />

At the initiative of our employees, a green park was created in an area near Tsetsii apartment complex in the<br />

summer of 2015. Approximately 0.5 hectares of dust generating bare ground was re-vegetated and approximately<br />

2,500 trees were planted. Our employees also made fences and flowerbeds for the planted area using recycled<br />

materials.<br />

Green areas being created by the Company employees<br />

The Company organizes voluntary environmental protection activities on a regular basis. On National Tree Planting<br />

Day, the Company employees planted over 2,445 trees in and around the UHG project mine site and 1,740<br />

seedlings were donated to local organizations.<br />

In 2015, soil restoration activities continued on the disturbed land near the site power plant and disused earth<br />

road located next to the paved road to Tavantolgoi airport. A total of approximately 300 region specific trees<br />

including silverberry and elm were planted in the areas. This type of land rehabilitation offers numerous benefits<br />

including the absorption of emissions and noise created by vehicles and provision of shelter and habitat for small<br />

mammals and invertebrates.<br />

The 2.5 hectare nursery field established by the Company in 2009 continues to serve as a good source of<br />

environmental protection and reclamation activities. By continually nurturing the field, we aim to determine the<br />

most suitable trees and plants for re-vegetation in the Gobi region and use for reclamation and other landscaping<br />

projects around the project site and the soum centre in the future. Currently, we have around 30,000 shrubs,<br />

trees and perennial plants of 20 different endemic and non-endemic species growing in the nursery field. The<br />

species include elm, tamarisk, aspen tree, pine, spruce, saxaul and sea buckthorn.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

65


Sustainability Report<br />

In 2015, approximately 7,000 seedlings were harvested from the nursery field for use in various tree planting,<br />

landscaping and gardening projects. Plants like elm, silverberry, tamarisk and saxaul were planted by seed and<br />

cuttings for later use in seedling preparations.<br />

Water<br />

Water is a scarce and highly valuable resource in the arid Gobi region. Access to water is critical to our ongoing<br />

operations and effective water management is considered an essential factor of our project and operational<br />

sustainability. A comprehensive Water Management Plan guides the actions of our management, employees and<br />

contractors with regard to the use and re-use of water. This especially includes the effective management of<br />

groundwater, taking into consideration its use by local herders. The ecological and economic value of water has<br />

led to greater scrutiny of responsible water use and increased expectations from our stakeholders for improved<br />

water stewardship.<br />

The Company uses a combination of both groundwater and recycled water at the mine sites. As part of our water<br />

use and management, we have provided filtered water for the local communities at a subsidized rate since 2011,<br />

and welcome their participation in our water monitoring activities.<br />

At our operations, water is sourced from groundwater boreholes and is stored in two water reservoirs with a total<br />

storage volume of 56,000 m 3 , covered by synthetic membrane to prevent evaporation. In 2015, a total of 465<br />

megalitres (“ML”) of groundwater was extracted and 190 ML of water was recovered during coal processing by<br />

the Belt Filter Press facility for re-use in further coal processing.<br />

We continue to undertake activities that are aimed at preventing and reducing potential impacts on groundwater.<br />

These include:<br />

• Monitoring of herder wells around the mine and Tsogttsetsii soum centre is conducted on a monthly basis.<br />

There are 10 groundwater boreholes installed in the UHG mine licensed area for groundwater monitoring,<br />

which allows us to control the level of groundwater and monitor for potential contamination that may result<br />

from our operations. In partnership with the authority of Galba Uush Dolood Gobi water basin, we equipped<br />

2 groundwater monitoring boreholes around our water extracting area with remote data loggers.<br />

• In 2013, the Company established a waste water treatment plant in the soum center which has a capacity to<br />

treat 1,200 m 3 of waste water per day. The facility’s treatment capacity of contaminated water stands at up<br />

to 96%, making the treated water quality fully in compliance with the requirements of the national standards.<br />

In 2015, over 80 ML of domestic waste water was treated and re-used for purposes such as road and tree<br />

watering.<br />

• In June 2015, a solid waste clean-up campaign was organized in the surrounding area of six natural springs<br />

located within a 30 km radius of the UHG mine site.<br />

66<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Waste<br />

Our mine sites operate within the framework of a comprehensive waste management system which involves<br />

handling and management of all kinds of day-to-day and industrial waste streams. In 2015, the total amount of<br />

solid waste generated from the mine site activities was reduced by 44.7% compared to 2014.<br />

2014 2015<br />

Solid waste, m 3 12,261 6,768.7<br />

Proportion recycled, % 68 60<br />

The Company continues to operate a small scale waste recycling facility established in 2013 where scrap<br />

materials are used in making products such as garbage bins, metal fences, sliding doors, wooden benches,<br />

blocks, insect protection nets and horse rugs.<br />

Hazardous non-mineral waste is delivered back to the suppliers for re-use or appropriate disposal. Plastic waste,<br />

waste metal and waste paper are sent to designated recycling facilities in other provinces. Printer cartridges<br />

are sent back to suppliers for refill and reuse. Collecting and recycling used oil is crucial for preventing oil<br />

contamination to soil and groundwater. Used oil is collected in a dedicated tank, prior to be being sent to a<br />

recycling facility which produces fuel and other raw materials.<br />

Air quality and noise<br />

Dust and air quality are significant issues for our neighbouring communities, and minimising the effects of these<br />

impacts from our operations will remain a key focus for us. For the reporting period, the Company continued to<br />

take appropriate measures to reduce the amount of dust generated in the vicinity of the mine site and the coal<br />

haul road in accordance with the dust management plan of the project environmental and social management<br />

plan. These measures include:<br />

• Regular spraying of the haulage roads at the mine site with treated waste water;<br />

• Improved construction methodology of mine haulage roads, in particular using carefully selected materials,<br />

to reduce propensity for dust generation;<br />

• Trial usage of two types of dust suppressing substances on the surface of the TSF;<br />

• Usage of various substances for dust suppression on the ROM coal haul roads;<br />

• Building and maintenance of dedicated facilities for dust reduction, such as a 10-metre high special wire<br />

fence which surrounds our coal stockpile at TKH. These and other similar facilities reduce wind speed and<br />

dust dispersion in the area;<br />

• Better management of vehicle speeds; and<br />

• Covering of truck loads.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

67


Sustainability Report<br />

There are number of sources of noise that are typically associated with our mining operations. They include dump<br />

trucks, large earth-moving equipment such as excavators and coal transportation trucks. Blasting activities, which<br />

are an essential component of our mine operations, cause ground vibration as well as overpressure, and may on<br />

occasion be felt or heard by our closest neighbouring communities. We understand and acknowledge that noise<br />

and vibrations can impact the communities and take constructive measures to mitigate the potential impacts. We<br />

have a noise management plan according to which we identify and evaluate sources of noise and vibration on a<br />

regular basis. Some of the practical steps we undertake to minimize noise and vibration include:<br />

• Regular maintenance of machinery to ensure it operates with minimal noise;<br />

• Cooperation with suppliers to provide machinery that is designed to work with minimal noise;<br />

• Keep operation and storage of heavy equipment as far as possible from the residential areas;<br />

• Provision of a community hotline service with which residents can report concerns over noise and vibration;<br />

and<br />

• Blasting only when weather conditions are deemed favourable.<br />

Air quality monitoring is an integral part of our dust management plan. Dust concentration, dust deposition, noise<br />

level and pollutant gases are main parameters for the monitoring. Portable tools such as Dust trak 8530, Casella<br />

Cel 240 and Testo XL 350 are used to monitor the air quality. Air quality monitoring measurements are conducted<br />

throughout the project area on a monthly basis.<br />

We monitor PM2.5 dust levels at 22 different sites in and around the UHG mine and TKH area. Other types of air<br />

emissions such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide are regularly measured by the Central Environmental and<br />

Metrological Laboratory against the national air quality standards (MNS 4585:2007), and measurements of other<br />

gases such as sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide at the UHG power plant are performed<br />

against the national air quality standards (MNS 5919:2008).<br />

During the reporting period, PM2.5 measurements were conducted 42 times against the national MNS 4585:2007<br />

standard in Tsogttsetsii soum and TKH area. The average level of PM2.5 stood below the acceptable value<br />

of national air quality standard (0.05 mg/m 3 ) at most of the measuring points. To improve the transparency of<br />

operations, our dust monitoring report is published on the UHG monthly bulletin for public viewing.<br />

Noise levels were measured at 10 monitoring points around the UHG mine site and the results were in compliance<br />

with the national standard.<br />

Environmental monitoring<br />

Environmental monitoring activities play an important role in our proactive approach towards environmental<br />

sustainability. It also serves as a tool for us in creating an effective dialogue with the host communities and<br />

communicating our performance in environmental management area. Regular monitoring and measuring of the<br />

impact of our activities on the environment are conducted at 94 specific points within the project impact area to<br />

ensure that they are within the nationally-accepted levels. Our monitoring activities include biodiversity studies and<br />

the monitoring of dust emissions, noise levels, air pollution, soil erosion, groundwater pollution and shallow water<br />

pollution. Every year, our environmental monitoring plans are approved by the national environmental authorities<br />

and monitoring activities are conducted on a monthly, quarterly and annual basis depending on their types. The<br />

sampling and measurements are performed in compliance with national environmental standards using the latest<br />

equipment and measurement devices. Samples are tested at accredited national and international laboratories.<br />

68<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Monitoring results are incorporated into our annual environmental reports which are submitted to national and<br />

local environmental authorities. We also involve the local community members in our environmental monitoring<br />

activities throughout the year. For example, monitoring of herder wells around the UHG mine and Tsogttsetsii<br />

soum centre are conducted on a monthly basis.<br />

Environmental protection awareness<br />

We organize voluntary environmental protection activities and awareness campaigns for our employees on a<br />

regular basis. On the National Tree Planting Day, employees of MMC planted over 2,400 trees in and around the<br />

UHG mine site and the miners’ camp.<br />

A dedicated training and development unit provides comprehensive training to all of our employees on the<br />

Company’s HSE policies, procedures and guidelines, and emergency prevention and response measures. The<br />

trainings also cover environmental protection topics such as waste management, spill control, dust control, and<br />

water and energy consumption.<br />

Besides general induction, thematic trainings are organized to provide additional information on environmental<br />

protection for specific tasks such as topsoil stripping for dozer operators, and storage and handling of cleansing<br />

and disinfecting agents for cleaners. During the reporting period, environmental induction was organized for a<br />

total of 660 man-hours. In order to improve environmental awareness of our employees, information graphics<br />

were posted regularly on special information boards.<br />

External audit<br />

In 2015, a number of external audits were performed by the relevant authorities on the Company’s HSE<br />

performances at the UHG mine site, and all of the results ensured that our activities in applicable fields were in full<br />

compliance with national standards and relevant legislation.<br />

In May 2015, all areas of UHG operations were audited by the Local Specialized Inspection Agency of Umnugobi<br />

aimag to ensure effective implementation of the legislation on occupational safety and hygiene. According to the<br />

audit results, our performances were assessed as sufficient at 99.47 % for safety and 93.3% for occupational<br />

hygiene, respectively.<br />

The same agency also performed an environmental compliance audit on our relevant areas of operation and the<br />

assessments came out as below:<br />

• Waste water treatment plant – Low risk; Performance at 76.0%;<br />

• Power plant – Low risk; Performance at 93.3%.<br />

Two non-compliances were identified during the audit of which one was related to the concentration of treated<br />

water and the other one being related to sulphur dioxide content of fume exceeding the national standard<br />

requirements. Accordingly, corrective actions were taken and completed for both cases.<br />

In December 2015, a team appointed by the Environmental and Tourism Agency of Umnugobi aimag conducted<br />

an inspection on the implementation of our Environmental Management Plan (“EMP”) for 2015. The audit results<br />

on EMP were 89.5% and assessed as sufficient.<br />

In February 2015, an external audit on the emergency compliance was performed by the local Emergency<br />

Response Agency and covered all areas of UHG operation. As a result of the audit, our operations were assessed<br />

as sufficient at 63.0%. Several non-conformances were identified and suitable corrective actions were taken<br />

accordingly to prevent re-occurrences.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

69


Sustainability Report<br />

OUR COMMUNITY<br />

Effective community engagement is essential to our on-going commitment as a socially responsible miner. We<br />

strive to build quality relationships with our host communities in all relevant fields of operation and seek to create<br />

lasting benefits. Relationships based on transparency, open communication and mutual trust are vital for us in<br />

ensuring meaningful contribution to the local economy and well-being. We aim to deliver long-term sustainable<br />

outcomes for the communities in which we operate by assisting them in developing independently of mining<br />

activities and company support.<br />

Our policy requires us to identify and assess the level of impact the Company has on the host communities and<br />

their level of interest in engaging with us. Accordingly, socio-economic baseline studies as well as impact and<br />

risk assessments are conducted by us to determine both the positive and negative impacts of our operations on<br />

the community. Based on the findings of these assessments, we develop individual plans to mitigate any adverse<br />

impacts associated with our activities, and at the same time, initiate projects and programs that support positive<br />

impacts to the sustainable development of the region. Below are our management plans in the area of community<br />

engagement:<br />

• Public Consultation and Disclosure Plan;<br />

• Resettlement Action Plan;<br />

• Grievance Management Plan;<br />

• Cultural Heritage Management Plan;<br />

• Economic and Physical Displacement Management Plan; and<br />

• Community Health and Safety Management Plan.<br />

We generate economic value for our host communities through employment, taxes and royalties, purchase of<br />

local goods and services and community development programs. Over the course of the reporting period, we<br />

purchased goods and services worth of over MNT450 million from the local communities, provided wages and<br />

benefits to local employees in excess of MNT16 billion, made payments to local taxes and fees in excess of<br />

MNT15 billion and spent over MNT400 million for community development programmes.<br />

Highlights of 2015<br />

• “Dream” secondary school, kindergarten and dormitory complex financed and established by the Company<br />

had its first graduation in 2015 and showcased exemplary academic performance by having the highest<br />

average graduation test scores in Umnugobi aimag;<br />

• Continued our participation in the South Gobi Water and Mining Industry roundtable project implemented by<br />

the International Finance Corporation (“IFC”), shared from our active community engagement practices and<br />

made a joint commitment to promote a responsible use of water, alongside with fellow mining companies<br />

who operate in the South Gobi region; and<br />

• The “Wind belt” project of the Company successfully continued for the fourth consecutive year and over 160<br />

local community members were enabled to grow vegetables in the project area.<br />

70<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Community engagement<br />

Maintaining robust relationships and building trust with relevant stakeholders including local community members<br />

and local government are pivotal in sustaining a successful business operation. We acknowledge that our mining<br />

operations have significant economic, social and environmental impacts on local communities and in turn, the<br />

communities’ concerns, needs, aspirations and activities impact our business in a multitude of ways. We provide<br />

factual and reliable information to the local communities about the Company’s operations and future plans/<br />

projects, and foster face-to-face interactions with project affected communities to understand their concerns and<br />

expectations. Since its inception, MMC has strived to develop effective ways to engage with its local stakeholders.<br />

Our consultation and engagement with the host community members take many forms including, but are not<br />

limited to the following:<br />

• Regular communications of our dedicated community engagement staff with affected herder households and<br />

resettled families;<br />

• Regular meetings with local government administration;<br />

• Monthly meetings with Community Development Advisory Councils established in each impact soum to<br />

provide a better platform for dialogues between the Company and the local communities;<br />

• Annual public consultation and disclosure activities (open ger events);<br />

• Community surveys (socio-economic baseline studies, satisfaction surveys);<br />

• Community site tours;<br />

• Community development programs;<br />

• Operation of information centres and hotlines;<br />

• Publication of monthly environmental monitoring data on our monthly bulletin;<br />

• Annual reports/CSR reports; and<br />

• News bulletins.<br />

We pride ourselves in pioneering the first public consultation and discussion event in South Gobi prior to the<br />

start of our mining operations and maintain our active engagement with the local communities on a regular basis.<br />

These practices, especially two-way communication on responsible water management practices in particular, are<br />

considered as exemplary by local and international experts.<br />

In 2015, we continued our active involvement in the IFC financed South Gobi Water and Mining Industry<br />

roundtable discussions and shared our experience with fellow mining companies which operate in the region. A<br />

voluntary code of practice was developed based on the outcome of the discussions and MMC, alongside with the<br />

participating companies, made a voluntary commitment to responsible, legally compliant and sustainable use of<br />

water.<br />

Grievance management<br />

We have a formal process to accept, assess and resolve community concerns, complaints and grievances about<br />

the performance or behaviour of the Company and the employees. Accordingly, we established the Grievance<br />

Management Plan, in order to assess whether the Company is responsive to community and worker complaints<br />

and to assess whether these complaints are handled in a comprehensive and consistent manner.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

71


Sustainability Report<br />

We receive grievances via the internet, telephone, face-to-face interviews and in writing. Upon receiving<br />

complaints and grievances, appropriate actions must be taken and the complainants should be advised of the<br />

outcome. In line with the Grievance Handling Mechanism, we aim to respond to all complaints within 30 days<br />

of submission, and more quickly in urgent cases. All complaints are treated in a confidential manner, and in all<br />

cases, grievances are addressed without prejudice. The resolutions of community complaints and grievances are<br />

reported to the public through our annual/CSR reports.<br />

In 2015, we received and handled a total of 3 complaints and 30 requests. All of the received 3 complaints<br />

were of random nature. The first complaint was related to a fire incident at a local family house. As Tsogttsetsii<br />

soum does not have fire/emergency services, the complainant had called our mine emergency rescue service for<br />

assistance, and his complaint was that he could not get timely assistance. Upon analysis of the complaint, it was<br />

explained to the complainant that although we are committed to respond to local fire/emergency calls whenever<br />

possible, the Company is not formally obliged to receive all emergency calls and that it is possible to have cases<br />

of delay where our rescue team might be handling multiple calls. The second complaint was related to a cattle<br />

belonging to a local herdsman being attacked by a dog. This complaint was dismissed since the Company does<br />

not keep any animals.<br />

The third complaint was in connection to some of the third-party suppliers/contractors using multiple dirt roads<br />

when transporting goods from other provinces to Tsogtsetsii, Umnugobi on a few occasions due to no existing<br />

paved road in such directions. Although this was not our direct responsibility, we made careful analysis of the<br />

situation following the receipt of the complaint and formally notified the responsible suppliers to discuss and agree<br />

on the routes with the local administration.<br />

Of all 30 requests we received via our grievance mechanism, about 40% were requests for financial and material<br />

assistance, approximately 10% were requests to supply goods and services to the Company, 9% were related to<br />

UHG mine-site visits while the remaining were on various subjects including internship opportunities at the minesite,<br />

a possibility to build a new water well and a possibility to source spare parts and scrap materials from the<br />

mine operations.<br />

Community investment<br />

As part of our policy to help bringing long-term sustainability to our host communities, we make investments<br />

through community development programs, infrastructure developments, local donations, sponsorships and<br />

partnerships. Job creation, local procurement, implementation of targeted programs for impacted herders, the<br />

“Good Neighbourhood” initiative and community health support also bring sustained positive impact on our local<br />

communities, including herdsmen. In 2015, the Company spent approximately MNT2.4 billion on community<br />

investment activities.<br />

72<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Table 18. Community investment in 2015<br />

Areas of community investment<br />

MNT<br />

Local infrastructure development (water, power supply, etc.) 1,372,742,750<br />

Community development programs 403,455,576<br />

— Support in education 100,000,000<br />

— Health support programs 54,292,500<br />

— Environmental protection 10,374,000<br />

— Sustainability livelihood 10,415,051<br />

— Cultural heritage preservation 176,400,000<br />

— “Good neighbourhood” initiative 51,974,025<br />

Grants and sponsorships 166,000,000<br />

Local procurement (Umnugobi aimag) 449,194,800<br />

TOTAL 2,391,393,126<br />

Community development programs<br />

Our community development programs focus on improving the quality of life for the people and create lasting<br />

benefits. We support a wide range of community projects in the areas of education, health and well-being, cultural<br />

heritage and local business development in order to build stronger and more sustainable communities. Based on<br />

the needs of the community as identified through regional plans, consultation and our socio-economic baseline<br />

studies, we design and prioritize our community development programs.<br />

“Dream” secondary school, kindergarten and dormitory complex<br />

The secondary educational complex co-financed and established by the Company 3 years ago had the highest<br />

average graduation test scores in 2015 among all secondary schools in Umnugobi aimag, showing visible<br />

improvement in the quality of rural education. In addition to meeting both the national and international standards<br />

in terms of the learning environment and quality of facilities, the school has been receiving management support<br />

by the Company on the provision of trained teachers and introduction of advanced teaching methodologies.<br />

2015 marked the first official graduation of the “Dream” school. With an obvious improvement in all areas of<br />

academic performance, the vast majority of the graduates became eligible for acceptance to reputable national or<br />

international tertiary institutions.<br />

“Green belt” project<br />

The Company continued its “Green belt” project for the fourth consecutive year, which aims to support the<br />

vegetable gardening initiatives of the local community members and assist them in generating an additional source<br />

of income. In 2015, the project area was expanded by 4 hectares and a new irrigation system was introduced,<br />

enabling over 100 community members to start vegetable gardening in the area. Over the past 3 years, more than<br />

180 local people grew 18 types of fruits and vegetables for home use or market.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

73


Sustainability Report<br />

As part of the “Good Neighbourhood” initiative, the Company provides various types of in-kind assistance to the<br />

host communities. During the period under review, the Company carried out the following activities in support of<br />

the local communities:<br />

• We provided free-of-charge supply of thermal coal to a power plant in the provincial capital Dalanzadgad as<br />

well as power plants in nearby soums of Tsogttsetsii, Bayan-Ovoo and Khanbogd. In total, 25 kt of thermal<br />

coal was supplied.<br />

• To assist local hurders overcome the challenges of harsh winter conditions, 3,680 bundles of hay and 1,360<br />

packages of wheat bran were provided;<br />

• Free-of-charge seedlings were provided to Tsogttsetsii soum administration and the local residents for their<br />

use in various landscaping projects in and around the soum;<br />

• The Company hosted a welcoming event on the occasion of the Lunar new year each year to pay respect to<br />

senior citizens in the local communities. In 2015, we welcomed over 390 senior citizens from the impacted<br />

soums of Tsogtsetsii, Bayan-Ovoo, Khanbogd and Khankhongor; and<br />

• During an annual herders’ forum hosted by Umnugobi aimag local government, the Company rewarded the<br />

best 15 young herders from all 15 soums of the aimag with commemorative notes and gifts.<br />

Sustainable Livelihood Development Program<br />

To create additional economic opportunities for affected and resettled herders, the Company is implementing a<br />

three-year program that focuses on supporting start-ups and small-and-medium enterprises of local herders. The<br />

program was developed based on a comprehensive socio-economic household survey conducted in 2011 among<br />

64 herder households in the UHG project direct impact area. The results of the survey highlighted the possibility<br />

of herder households to start a new business or expand their existing enterprises in livestock husbandry and crop<br />

farming to improve their livelihood.<br />

The Company is collaborating with XacBank to issue interest-free loans to these households to support their<br />

business initiatives. Trainings were organized for the participants on topics including business management,<br />

marketing, development of cooperatives and intensive livestock farming, based on which they were able to define<br />

their business objectives and develop plans. As of the end of 2015, a total of 14 herder households received<br />

interest-free business loans from XacBank and loan repayments were made on time. In the reporting period, we<br />

continued to provide professional support to the participants through our partnering local Non-Governmental<br />

Organisations (“NGOs”) and monitored their business performance. In April 2015, we organized a tripartite project<br />

performance assessment meeting in Tsogttsetsii soum, involving the local NGOs, local representatives of XacBank<br />

and the project participants. The event served as a platform for us to hear the participants’ opinions and concerns<br />

with regard to the project outcome and make further improvements or modifications, if required.<br />

74<br />

Annual Report 2015


Sustainability Report<br />

Case Study<br />

Successful graduation of the Company<br />

scholarship recipients<br />

As part of its educational support program, the Company<br />

has funded a scholarship program for the Cambridge<br />

international academic program, jointly with “Orchlon”<br />

secondary school since 2010. The aim of the scholarship<br />

program was to provide quality educational opportunities<br />

to the best performing students of the country who<br />

lacked adequate financial resources. In the spring of<br />

2015, the first 6 recipients of the scholarship successfully<br />

completed their Cambridge program at “Orchlon” school<br />

and received their diploma of secondary education. The<br />

Company representatives attended the graduation ceremony and shared their impression on the program<br />

results and outcome. All of the 6 graduates showed exceptional academic performance throughout the<br />

program period and topped national and international Olympiads in various subjects. Moreover, all of them<br />

were accepted into high-ranking colleges and universities in the United States and Western Europe, an<br />

indication that the program succeeded in achieving its goal.<br />

SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONTRIBUTION<br />

We believe that as a good corporate citizen, we must continuously contribute to the country’s socio-economic<br />

development, community well-being and sustainability. While keeping our position as one of the major employers<br />

and tax contributors of Mongolia, we remain committed to continue our cooperation with local governments,<br />

communities and other stakeholders and play a part in improving local development and living standards.<br />

Job creation<br />

Despite the challenging market and economic conditions, we continued our efforts to retain our employees and<br />

hired and trained local people whenever possible during the reporting period. As of the year ended 2015, MMC<br />

employed 1,797 employees, approximately 45% of whom were locally hired. In the reporting period, the Company<br />

spent approximately MNT37 billion for employee wages and remuneration and MNT3 billion for employee benefits<br />

and allowances, respectively.<br />

Tax contribution<br />

During the reporting period, MMC contributed MNT74 billion to the state and local budget through direct taxes<br />

and commissions, a substantial amount given the size of the country’s economy.<br />

Community support<br />

In addition to our wider economic contribution, we aim to provide a strong base for the local economic growth<br />

and cooperate with our host community members in multiple ways. In 2015, we invested about MNT2.4 billion in<br />

support of community development through various projects, targeted programs and grants and sponsorships.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

75


Sustainability Report<br />

Procurement<br />

We follow ethical business practices in our purchasing and supply management and give priority to local<br />

businesses. In the reporting period, MMC cooperated with about 320 suppliers and contractors of which over<br />

85% were local businesses in Mongolia. We support host community businesses through our sustainability<br />

livelihood development program and aim to create market opportunities by making them aware of our standards,<br />

procedures and performance expectations. In 2015, we sourced products and services from 13 local businesses<br />

in Umnugobi aimag and our operation expenditures on goods and services such as transport, utilities,<br />

construction, food, etc. from the local suppliers totalled approximately MNT450 million.<br />

76<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

The Board of the Company is pleased to present this Corporate Governance Report in the annual report for the<br />

year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PRACTICES<br />

The Company is committed to achieving high corporate governance standards. The Board believes that high<br />

corporate governance standards are essential in providing a framework for the Company to safeguard the<br />

interests of shareholders and to enhance corporate value and accountability.<br />

The Company’s corporate governance practices are based on the principles and code provisions as set out in the<br />

Corporate Governance Code (the “CG Code”) contained in Appendix 14 to the Listing Rules.<br />

In the opinion of the Directors, throughout the year under review, the Company has complied with all the code<br />

provisions as set out in the CG Code, save and except for code provision E.1.2 which states that the Chairman<br />

of the Board should attend the annual general meeting (“AGM”) of the Company. The relevant details are set out<br />

under “Communication with Shareholders and Investor Relations” below.<br />

The Company will continue to review and enhance its corporate governance practices to ensure that it will<br />

continue to meet the requirements of the CG Code and the rising expectation of the Shareholders and investors.<br />

MODEL CODE FOR SECURITIES TRANSACTIONS<br />

The Company has adopted the Model Code for Securities Transactions by Directors of Listed Issuers (the “Model<br />

Code”) as set out in Appendix 10 to the Listing Rules.<br />

Specific enquiry has been made of all the Directors and the Directors have confirmed that they have complied with<br />

the Model Code throughout the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

The Company has also established written guidelines on no less exacting terms than the Model Code (the<br />

“Employees Written Guidelines”) for securities transactions by employees who are likely to possess inside<br />

information of the Company. No incident of non-compliance of the Employees Written Guidelines by the<br />

employees was noted by the Company throughout the financial year.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

77


Corporate Governance Report<br />

BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />

The Board currently comprises eight members, including two executive Directors, three non-executive Directors<br />

and three independent non-executive Directors.<br />

EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS:<br />

Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts (Chairman of the Board, Chairman of<br />

the Nomination Committee and member of the Remuneration Committee)<br />

Dr. Battsengel Gotov (Chief Executive Officer)<br />

NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS:<br />

Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv<br />

Mr. Od Jambaljamts (member of the Corporate Governance Committee)<br />

Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish (member of the Audit Committee)<br />

INDEPENDENT NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS:<br />

Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj (Chairman of the Remuneration Committee and member of<br />

the Audit Committee and the Nomination Committee)<br />

Mr. Unenbat Jigjid (Chairman of the Corporate Governance Committee and member of<br />

the Audit Committee, the Nomination Committee and the Remuneration Committee)<br />

Mr. Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius (Chairman of the Audit Committee and member of<br />

the Corporate Governance Committee)<br />

During the year, Mr. Batsaikhan Purev resigned from the position as non-executive Director of the Company<br />

with effect from 30 November 2015. Subsequently, Mr. Orchirbat Punsalmaa resigned from the position as<br />

independent non-executive Director and ceased to be a member of the Audit Committee and Nomination<br />

Committee and the Chairman of the Remuneration Committee with effect from 8 January 2016. Dr. Khashchuluun<br />

Chuluundorj was appointed as independent non-executive Director and also a member of the Audit Committee<br />

and Nomination Committee and the Chairman of the Remuneration Committee on 8 January 2016.<br />

The relationship between the members of the Board and the biographical information of the Directors are set<br />

out in the section headed “Directors and Senior Management” on pages 6 to 13 of the annual report for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Chairman and Chief Executive Officer<br />

The positions of Chairman and Chief Executive Officer are held by Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts and Dr. Battsengel<br />

Gotov respectively. The Chairman provides leadership and is responsible for the effective functioning and<br />

leadership of the Board. The Chief Executive Officer focuses on the Company’s business development and daily<br />

management and operations generally. Their respective responsibilities are clearly defined and set out in writing.<br />

78<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

Independent Non-Executive Directors<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the Board at all times met the requirements of the Listing Rules relating<br />

to the appointment of at least three independent non-executive Directors which represented at least one-third of<br />

the Board with one of them possessing appropriate professional qualifications or accounting or related financial<br />

management expertise.<br />

The Company has received written annual confirmation from each of the independent non-executive Directors in<br />

respect of his independence in accordance with the independence guidelines set out in Rule 3.13 of the Listing<br />

Rules. The Company is of the view that all independent non-executive Directors are independent.<br />

Non-Executive Directors and Directors’ Re-election<br />

Code provision A.4.1 of the CG Code stipulates that non-executive Directors shall be appointed for a specific<br />

term, subject to re-election, whereas code provision A.4.2 states that all directors appointed to fill a casual<br />

vacancy shall be subject to election by shareholders at the first general meeting after appointment and that every<br />

director, including those appointed for a specific term, shall be subject to retirement by rotation at least once<br />

every three years.<br />

Each of the non-executive Directors and independent non-executive Directors is appointed for a specific term of<br />

two years.<br />

Pursuant to the Articles of Association of the Company (the “Articles”), all Directors of the Company are subject<br />

to retirement by rotation once every three years and any new director appointed to fill a casual vacancy or as an<br />

addition to the Board shall submit himself/herself for re-election by shareholders at the first general meeting or<br />

next AGM after appointment as the case may be.<br />

Responsibilities, Accountabilities and Contributions of the Board and Management<br />

The Board is responsible for the overall management of the Company’s business. The Board provides leadership<br />

and control of the Company and is collectively responsible for promoting the success of the Company by directing<br />

and supervising its affairs. All Directors make decisions objectively in the interests of the Company.<br />

The Board reserves for its decision all major matters of the Company, including the approval and monitoring<br />

of all policy matters, overall strategies and budgets, internal control and risk management systems, material<br />

transactions (in particular those that may involve a conflict of interest), financial information, appointment of<br />

directors and other significant financial and operational matters.<br />

The day-to-day management, administration and operation of the Company are delegated to the Chief Executive<br />

Officer and the senior management. The delegated functions and work tasks are periodically reviewed. Approval<br />

has to be obtained from the Board prior to any significant transactions entered into by the abovementioned<br />

officers.<br />

All Directors, including non-executive Directors and independent non-executive Directors, have brought a wide<br />

spectrum of valuable business experience, knowledge and professionalism to the Board for its efficient and<br />

effective functioning.<br />

All Directors have full and timely access to all relevant information of the Company. The Directors may seek<br />

independent professional advice under appropriate circumstances at the Company’s expense, upon making<br />

request to the Board, for discharging their duties to the Company.<br />

The Directors shall disclose to the Company details of other offices held by them and the Board regularly reviews<br />

the contribution required from each director to perform his responsibilities to the Company.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

79


Corporate Governance Report<br />

Continuous Professional Development of Directors<br />

The existing Directors are continually kept up-to-date with the legal and regulatory developments, and business<br />

and market changes to facilitate the discharge of their responsibilities.<br />

Newly appointed Director will receive formal, comprehensive and tailored induction on the first occasion of<br />

his/her appointment to ensure appropriate understanding of the business and operations of the Company<br />

and full awareness of director’s responsibilities and obligations under the Listing Rules and relevant statutory<br />

requirements. Such induction shall be supplemented by visits to the Company’s key plant sites and meetings with<br />

senior management of the Company.<br />

Directors are encouraged to participate in appropriate continuous professional development to develop and<br />

refresh their knowledge and skills to ensure that their contribution to the Board remains informed and relevant.<br />

Internally-facilitated briefings for Directors will be arranged and reading material on relevant topics will be issued<br />

to Directors where appropriate. All Directors are encouraged to attend relevant training courses at the Company’s<br />

expenses.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Company provided to all Directors training materials prepared<br />

by qualified professionals for the Directors and links to video released by the Stock Exchange on topics such as<br />

Updates on the New CG Code on Internal Controls and the New ESG Reporting Guide; Review of Listing Rules<br />

on Disclosure of Financial Information; Integrity Management and Corruption Prevention, Listing Enforcement<br />

Strategies: Current Themes and Case Studies; Listing Compliance Update. Directors (including outgoing directors)<br />

namely Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, Dr. Battsengel Gotov, Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv, Mr. Batsaikhan Purev, Mr. Od<br />

Jambaljamts, Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish, Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa, Mr. Unenbat Jigjid and Mr. Chan Tze Ching,<br />

Ignatius have read the relevant training materials. The Company also organised an internal induction session for<br />

and provided training materials provided by qualified professionals to Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj on topics<br />

such as Continuing Obligations of the Company and its Directors, Connection Transactions and Company’s<br />

Operations and Business.<br />

Mr. Unenbat Jigjid attended a training session on Economic Policy in Mongolia as Resource Rich Country<br />

conducted by the Japan International Cooperation Agency, and Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa attended training<br />

sessions including Coal Mongolia, International Coal Investors Conference; and Mongolia Mining 2015,<br />

International Mining and Oil Expo conducted by various authorities and qualified professionals last year. Mr. Chan<br />

Tze Ching, Ignatius also attended various training sessions including Economic & Market Outlook 2015, Asian<br />

Financial Forum; HKEX Board Offsite 2015: HKEX – Where to Next?; Global Risk Report 2015: A Perspective;<br />

Shadow Banking in China Event; The political and economic climate in the Mainland China and Hong Kong<br />

after the 2015 National People’s Congress (NPC) & the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference<br />

(CPPCC) by Mr. Lau Yui-siu 2015; China’s Financial Future; Occupying the Excess “Danger”, “Opportunities”<br />

about the Future Discussion Forum; RMB Fixed Income and Currency (FIC) Conference; Non-Executive Director<br />

Programme: Corporate Governance Code update – Is your board ready to respond?; HKEX Board Offsite 2015:<br />

Group Strategic Plan 2016-18: “Extending the Mutual Market”; Hong Kong Directors Forum – the Peer-to-Peer<br />

Network: The Board’s Role in Strategy and Facilities; International Seminar on University Social Responsibility<br />

cum Inauguration Ceremony of the University Social Responsibility Network; Multilaw Annual Conference; Tricor<br />

Seminar 2015 – Corporate Governance and Regulatory Updates: Panel Discussion; The 32nd ABA General<br />

Meeting and Conference in Taipei; and Hong Kong Economic Summit 2016 conducted by various authorities and<br />

qualified professionals last year.<br />

In addition, relevant reading materials including legal and regulatory update and seminar handouts have been<br />

provided to the Directors for their reference and studying.<br />

80<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

BOARD COMMITTEES<br />

The Board has established four committees, namely, the Audit Committee, Remuneration Committee, Nomination<br />

Committee and Corporate Governance Committee, for overseeing particular aspects of the Company’s affairs. All<br />

Board committees of the Company are established with defined written terms of reference. The terms of reference<br />

of the Board committees are posted on the Company’s website and the Stock Exchange’s website and are<br />

available to shareholders upon request.<br />

Audit Committee<br />

The Audit Committee comprises four members which includes one independent non-executive Director who<br />

possesses the appropriate professional qualifications or accounting or related financial management expertise.<br />

There are three independent non-executive Directors, namely Mr. Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius (chairman), Mr.<br />

Ochirbat Punsalmaa and Mr. Unenbat Jigjid, and one non-executive Director, namely Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish in<br />

the Committee. Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj has been appointed as a member of the Audit Committee when<br />

Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa resigned as a member of the Audit Committee of the Company on 8 January 2016.<br />

The principal duties of the Audit Committee include the following:<br />

• To review the financial statements and reports and to consider any significant or unusual items raised by<br />

the staff responsible for the accounting and financial reporting function, the internal auditor or the external<br />

auditor before submission to the Board;<br />

• To review the relationship with the external auditor by reference to the work performed by the auditor,<br />

their fees and terms of engagement, and to make recommendations to the Board on the appointment,<br />

reappointment and removal of the external auditor;<br />

• To review the adequacy and effectiveness of the Company’s financial reporting system, risk management<br />

and internal control systems and associated procedures; and<br />

• To review arrangements to enable employees of the Company to raise, in confidence, concerns about<br />

possible improprieties in financial reporting, internal control or other matters of the Company.<br />

The Audit Committee held three meetings during the year ended 31 December 2015 to review the annual financial<br />

results and report in respect of the year ended 31 December 2014 and the interim financial results and report<br />

for the six months ended 30 June 2015, the significant issues on financial reporting and compliance procedures,<br />

the major internal audit issues, internal control and risk management systems, scope of work, remuneration<br />

and appointment of external auditors, CCTs, arrangements for employees to raise concerns about possible<br />

improprieties and the appointment of the Head of Internal Audit.<br />

The Audit Committee also met with the external auditor twice during the year.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

81


Corporate Governance Report<br />

Remuneration Committee<br />

The Remuneration Committee comprises three members, with a majority of independent non-executive Directors.<br />

The members are Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa (chairman) and Mr. Unenbat Jigjid, being independent non-executive<br />

Directors, and Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, executive Director. Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj has been appointed<br />

as the chairman of the Remuneration Committee when Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa resigned as the chairman of the<br />

Remuneration Committee of the Company on 8 January 2016.<br />

The primary functions of the Remuneration Committee include determining the remuneration packages of<br />

individual executive Directors and senior management, making recommendation on the remuneration policy and<br />

structure for all Directors and senior management, assessing performance of executive Directors, approving<br />

the terms of executive Directors’ service contracts, and establishing transparent procedures for developing<br />

such remuneration policy and structure to ensure that no Director or any of his/her associates will participate in<br />

deciding his/her own remuneration.<br />

The Remuneration Committee held one meeting during the year ended 31 December 2015 to make<br />

recommendations to the Board on the overall remuneration policy and structure of the Company. The<br />

Remuneration Committee had reviewed and determined the remuneration packages of the executive Directors<br />

and senior management and made recommendations on the grant of share options. Where appropriate, decisions<br />

were also taken by way of circulated resolutions.<br />

The Company has established a formal and transparent procedure for formulating policies on the remuneration of<br />

the Directors and senior management of the Group. Pursuant to code provision B.1.5 of the CG Code, the annual<br />

remuneration of the members of the senior management by band for the year ended 31 December 2015 is set out<br />

below:<br />

Table 19. Remuneration band of the senior management<br />

HKD2,000,001 to HKD2,500,000 1<br />

HKD5,000,001 to HKD5,500,000 1<br />

HKD5,500,001 to HKD6,000,000 2<br />

2015<br />

Details of the remuneration of each of the Directors for the year ended 31 December 2015 are set out in note 9 to<br />

the consolidated financial statements.<br />

Nomination Committee<br />

The Nomination Committee comprises three members, with a majority of independent non-executive Directors.<br />

The members are Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts (chairman), executive Director, and Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa and Mr.<br />

Unenbat Jigjid, being independent non-executive Directors. Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj has been appointed as<br />

a member of the Nomination Committee when Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa resigned as a member of the Nomination<br />

Committee of the Company on 8 January 2016.<br />

The principal duties of the Nomination Committee include the following:<br />

• To review the structure, size and composition of the Board and to make recommendations regarding any<br />

proposed changes;<br />

82<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

• To develop and formulate relevant procedures for nomination and appointment of directors;<br />

• To identify suitable candidates for appointment as Directors;<br />

• To make recommendations to the Board on appointment or re-appointment of and the succession planning<br />

of Directors; and<br />

• To assess the independence of independent non-executive Directors.<br />

In assessing the Board composition, the Nomination Committee would take into account various aspects set out<br />

in the Board diversity policy, including but not limited to skills, industry experience, background, race, gender<br />

and other qualities. The Nomination Committee would discuss and agree on measurable objectives for achieving<br />

diversity on the Board, where necessary, and recommend them to the Board for adoption.<br />

In identifying and selecting suitable candidates for directorships, the Nomination Committee would consider<br />

the candidate’s character, qualifications, experience, independence and other relevant criteria necessary<br />

to complement the corporate strategy and achieve Board diversity, where appropriate, before making<br />

recommendation to the Board.<br />

The Nomination Committee held one meeting during the year ended 31 December 2015 to review the structure,<br />

size, composition and diversity of the Board and the independence of the independent non-executive Directors,<br />

and to consider the qualifications of the retiring directors standing for re-election at the AGM. The Nomination<br />

Committee also reviewed the succession plan of the Company last year. Where appropriate, decisions were<br />

also taken by way of circulated resolutions. The Nomination Committee reviewed and discussed the measurable<br />

objectives for implementing diversity on the Board and considered that an appropriate balance of diversity<br />

perspectives of the Board is maintained.<br />

Corporate Governance Committee<br />

The Corporate Governance Committee comprises three members with a majority of independent non-executive<br />

Directors. The members are Mr. Unenbat Jigjid (chairman) and Mr. Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius, being independent<br />

non-executive Directors, and Mr. Od Jambaljamts, executive Director.<br />

The Corporate Governance Committee was established by the Board for performing the functions set out in the<br />

code provision D.3.1 of the CG Code. The principal duties of the Corporate Governance Committee include the<br />

following:<br />

• To develop and review the Company’s policies and practices on corporate governance and make<br />

recommendations to the Board;<br />

• To review and monitor the training and continuous professional development of Directors and senior<br />

management;<br />

• To review and monitor the Company’s policies and practices on compliance with legal and regulatory<br />

requirements;<br />

• To develop, review and monitor the code of conduct and compliance manual (if any) applicable to employees<br />

and Directors; and<br />

• To review the Company’s compliance with the code and disclosure in the Corporate Governance Report.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

83


Corporate Governance Report<br />

The Corporate Governance Committee held one meeting during the year ended 31 December 2015. The<br />

Company’s corporate governance policies and practices on compliance with legal and regulatory requirements,<br />

continuous professional development of directors and senior management, directors’ time commitments,<br />

compliance of the Model Code, the Employees’ Written Guidelines and the CG Code, the effectiveness of<br />

the shareholders’ communication policy, functions reserved to the board of directors and those delegated to<br />

management and disclosure in the Corporate Governance Report were reviewed.<br />

ATTENDANCE RECORD OF DIRECTORS AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS<br />

The attendance record of each Director at the Board and Board Committee meetings and the general meetings of<br />

the Company held during the year ended 31 December 2015 is set out in Table 20 below:<br />

Table 20. Attendance records<br />

Attendance/Number of meetings<br />

Name of Director<br />

Board<br />

Nomination<br />

Committee<br />

Remuneration<br />

Committee<br />

Audit<br />

Committee<br />

Corporate<br />

Governance<br />

Committee<br />

Annual<br />

General<br />

Meeting<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts 4/4 1/1 1/1 N/A N/A 0/1<br />

Battsengel Gotov 4/4 N/A N/A N/A N/A 0/1<br />

Oyungerel Janchiv 2/4 N/A N/A N/A N/A 0/1<br />

Batsaikhan Purev (resigned on 30 November 2015) 3/4 N/A N/A N/A N/A 0/1<br />

Od Jambaljamts 4/4 N/A N/A N/A 1/1 0/1<br />

Gankhuyag Adilbish 3/4 N/A N/A 2/3 N/A 0/1<br />

Ochirbat Punsalmaa 3/4 1/1 1/1 2/3 N/A 0/1<br />

Unenbat Jigjid 4/4 1/1 1/1 3/3 1/1 0/1<br />

Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius 4/4 N/A N/A 3/3 1/1 1/1<br />

Apart from regular Board meetings, the Chairman also held meetings with the non-executive Directors (including<br />

independent non-executive Directors) without the presence of executive Directors during the year.<br />

DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITY IN RESPECT OF THE FINANCIAL<br />

STATEMENTS<br />

The Directors acknowledge their responsibility for preparing the financial statements of the Company for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015.<br />

The Directors have reviewed trading and cash flow forecasts which take into consideration the uncertainties in<br />

the current operating environment. The material uncertainties considered by the Directors are set out on note<br />

2(b) to the consolidated financial statements. The Directors are in the opinion that it is appropriate to prepare the<br />

consolidated financial statements on a going concern basis.<br />

The statement of the independent auditor of the Company about their reporting responsibilities on the financial<br />

statements is set out in the Independent Auditor’s Report on pages 107 to 108.<br />

84<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

AUDITOR’S REMUNERATION<br />

The remuneration paid to the external auditor of the Company in respect of audit services and non-audit services<br />

for the year ended 31 December 2015 amounted to USD536,000 and USD9,161.52 respectively.<br />

An analysis of the remuneration paid to the external auditor of the Company, KPMG, in respect of audit services<br />

and non-audit services for the year ended 31 December 2015 is set out below:<br />

Table 21. Remuneration paid to the external auditor of the Company<br />

Service Category<br />

Audit Services<br />

Non-audit Services 1<br />

Fees Paid/<br />

Payable<br />

USD536,000<br />

USD9,161<br />

USD545,161<br />

1 including the fees for tax services<br />

INTERNAL CONTROLS<br />

During the year under review, the Board conducted a review of the effectiveness of the internal control system<br />

of the Company and its subsidiaries, including financial, operational and compliance controls, risk management<br />

functions, the adequacy of resources, staff qualifications and experience, training programmes and budget of the<br />

Company’s accounting and financial reporting function.<br />

COMPANY SECRETARY<br />

Ms. Ng Sin Yee, Clare of Tricor Services Limited, external service provider, has been engaged by the Company<br />

as the Company Secretary. Her primary contact persons in the Company are Dr. Battsengel Gotov, executive<br />

Director and Chief Executive Officer and Ms. Uurtsaikh Dorjgotov, Executive Vice President and Chief Legal Officer<br />

of the Company.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, Ms. Ng has complied with the professional training requirement of<br />

taking no less than 15 hours of relevant professional training as set out in Rule 3.29 of the Listing Rules.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

85


Corporate Governance Report<br />

SHAREHOLDERS’ RIGHTS<br />

To safeguard shareholder interests and rights, separate resolution is proposed for each substantially separate<br />

issue at shareholder meetings, including the election of individual directors. All resolutions put forward at<br />

shareholder meetings will be voted on by poll pursuant to the Listing Rules and poll results will be posted on the<br />

websites of the Company and of the Stock Exchange after each shareholder meeting.<br />

Convening an Extraordinary General Meeting by Shareholders<br />

Pursuant to Article 58 of the Articles, any one or more members of the Company holding on the date of deposit of<br />

the requisition not less than one-tenth of the paid up capital of the Company carrying the right of voting at general<br />

meetings of the Company shall at all times have the right, by written requisition to the Board or the Secretary of<br />

the Company, to require an extraordinary general meeting to be called by the Board for the transaction of any<br />

business specified in such requisition. If within 21 days of such deposit the Board does not to proceed to convene<br />

such meeting, the requisitionist(s) himself (themselves) may do so in the same manner, and all reasonable<br />

expenses incurred by the requisitionist(s) shall be reimbursed to the requisitionist(s) by the Company.<br />

Putting Forward Proposals at General Meetings<br />

Pursuant to Article 85 of the Articles, any member duly qualified to attend and vote at a general meeting who wish<br />

to propose a person other than a retiring director at the meeting for election as Director of the Company may<br />

lodge a notice signed by the member (other than the person to be proposed) of his intention to propose such<br />

person for election and also a notice signed by the person to be proposed of his willingness to be elected at the<br />

Company’s head office at 16th Floor, Central Tower, Sukhbaatar District, Ulaanbaatar 14200, Mongolia or at the<br />

Registration Office at Shops 1712-1716, 17th Floor, Hopewell Centre, 183 Queen’s Road East, Wanchai, Hong<br />

Kong, provided that the minimum length of the period, during which such notice(s) are given, shall be at least<br />

7 days, and that (if the notices are submitted after the despatch of the notice of the general meeting appointed<br />

for such election) the period for lodgment of such notice(s) shall commence on the day after the despatch of the<br />

notice of the general meeting appointed for such election and end no later than 7 days prior to the date of such<br />

general meeting.<br />

Shareholders who wish to put forward other proposals at general meetings may follow the procedures set out<br />

in the previous paragraph to request the Company to convene an extraordinary general meeting for business<br />

specified in the written requisition.<br />

Putting Forward Enquiries to the Board<br />

For putting forward any enquiries to the Board of the Company, shareholders may send written enquiries to the<br />

Company. The Company will not normally deal with verbal or anonymous enquiries.<br />

86<br />

Annual Report 2015


Corporate Governance Report<br />

Contact Details<br />

Shareholders may send their enquiries or requests as mentioned above to the following:<br />

Address:<br />

Email:<br />

16th Floor, Central Tower<br />

Sukhbaatar District<br />

Ulaanbaatar 14200<br />

Mongolia<br />

(For the attention of the Board of Directors/Chief Investment Officer)<br />

contact@mmc.mn<br />

For the avoidance of doubt, shareholder(s) must deposit and send the original duly signed written requisition,<br />

notice or statement, or enquiry (as the case may be) to the above address apart from other specified address, if<br />

any, and provide their full name, contact details and identification in order to give effect thereto. Shareholders’<br />

information may be disclosed as required by law.<br />

COMMUNICATION WITH SHAREHOLDERS AND INVESTOR RELATIONS<br />

The Company considers that effective communication with shareholders is essential for enhancing investor<br />

relations and investor understanding of the Group’s business performance and strategies. The Company<br />

endeavours to maintain an on-going dialogue with shareholders and in particular, through AGMs and other general<br />

meetings. All members of the Board including non-executive Directors, independent non-executive Directors, and<br />

the chairmen of all Board committees (or their delegates) will use their best efforts to make themselves available<br />

at the AGMs to meet shareholders and answer their enquiries.<br />

According to CG Code Provision E.1.2, the chairman of the board should attend the AGM. Mr. Odjargal<br />

Jambaljamts, Chairman of the Board was unable to attend the 2015 AGM held on 29 May 2015 due to a business<br />

engagement. He will use his best endeavours to attend all future shareholders’ meetings of the Company.<br />

During the year under review, the Company has not made any changes to its Articles. An up to date version of the<br />

Company’s Articles is also available on the Company’s website and the Stock Exchange’s website.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

87


Directors’ Report<br />

The Directors submit herewith their annual report together with the audited consolidated financial statements of<br />

the Group for the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS<br />

The Company is incorporated in the Cayman Islands with its registered office at Cricket Square, Hutchins Drive,<br />

PO Box 2681, Grand Cayman, KY1-1111, Cayman Islands, its headquarters and principal place of business<br />

in Mongolia is located at 16th Floor, Central Tower, Sukhbaatar District, Ulaanbaatar 14200, Mongolia, and its<br />

principal place of business in Hong Kong is located at Level 54, Hopewell Centre, 183 Queen’s Road East, Hong<br />

Kong.<br />

PRINCIPAL ACTIVITIES<br />

The principal activities of the Company are mining, production, transportation and sale of coking coal products.<br />

The principal activities and other particulars of the subsidiaries and associates are set out in note 17 and note 18<br />

to the consolidated financial statements.<br />

The analysis of the principal activities and geographical locations of the operations of the Group during the<br />

financial year are set out in note 12 to the consolidated financial statements.<br />

BUSINESS REVIEW<br />

Overview and performance of the Year<br />

A review of the business of the Group and analysis of the Group’s performance using financial KPIs is provided<br />

in the Management Discussion and Analysis section on pages 34 to 47 and Financial Summary section on pages<br />

197 and 198 of this annual report.<br />

The Group’s total sales volume for the year ended 31 December 2015 was approximately 1.5 Mt of coal products<br />

generating total revenue of USD99.5 million, whilst in 2014 the total sales volume was 5.4 Mt of coal products<br />

with total revenue of USD328.3 million. The lower total revenue compared to the corresponding period in<br />

2014 was essentially attributable to the continuing further downward pressure on coking coal price due to the<br />

oversupplied market, which ultimately led to a lower sales volume of HCC.<br />

The Group’s pricing reflected the current deteriorating price trend apparent to all coking coal products in the<br />

global market. The ASP of HCC achieved on a combined basis at all selling points was USD63.2 per tonne for<br />

the year ended 31 December 2015, supported by higher HCC selling prices of inland China sales. The ASP of<br />

HCC under FOT and C&F terms sales were USD66.3 per tonne and USD104.4 per tonne, respectively for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015, compared to USD91.4 per tonne and USD119.4 per tonne in 2014 respectively. It is<br />

worth noting that the ASP of sales under C&F terms is an average price of sold quantity across different locations<br />

in China, therefore year-on-year comparison may not depict the true trend as selling quantity and locations will<br />

differ each year. The ASP of HCC sales under DAP GM term was USD53.2 per tonne for the year ended 31<br />

December 2015 which was approximately 23.2% lower compared to USD69.3 per tonne in 2014.<br />

88<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the total cost of revenue was USD165.6 million, compared to<br />

USD335.5 million in 2014. The cost of revenue of self-produced coal was reduced by 59.4% from USD326.6<br />

million to USD132.7 million mainly as a result of lower sales volume. In effort to decrease operational costs,<br />

negotiation with mining and blasting contractors during the second half of 2015 has led to significant reductions<br />

in the forecasted cost of services going forward in respective contract extension periods. The contract revisions<br />

became effective in late 2015, during a period of reduced mining activity, and thus the positive impact resulting<br />

from these contract revisions on overall unit cost per bcm of material mined will be more pronounced from 2016<br />

onward.<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the basic loss per share and diluted loss per share was 2.03 cents,<br />

decreased by 65.9% compared to the basic loss per share and diluted loss per share of 5.95 cents for the year<br />

ended 31 December 2014.<br />

Environmental Policies and Performance<br />

We are committed to comply with Mongolian environmental laws, regulations and applicable international<br />

standards as part of our effort to minimize the adverse impact of our operations on the environment. Our<br />

integrated HSE MS helps achieve the targets set out in our HSE policy. These systems and processes provide<br />

our employees and contractors the necessary directions to practice safe work behaviours and make them<br />

accountable for the implementation of the HSE MS. Our environmental team continually upgrades the HSE MS<br />

and its accompanying elements and procedures and ensures that our activities in relevant fields comply with<br />

national legislations and international standards. The HSE MS has been developed to align with requirements<br />

under the international management system standards ISO 14001:2004 (Environmental management system<br />

standard) and OHSAS 18001:2007 (Occupational health and safety management system standard).<br />

We are required to comply with applicable national legislations including the Law on Environmental Protection<br />

(1995), Law on Environmental Impact Assessment (2012), Law on Natural Resources Use Fee (2012), Law on<br />

Water and Water Pollution Fee (2012), Law on Air (2012) and Law on Air Pollution Fee (2010), Law on Land (2002),<br />

Law on Soil Protection and Desertification Prevention (2012) and Law on Toxic and Hazardous Chemicals (2006).<br />

In line with these legislations, we submit an environmental management plan followed by an implementation<br />

report to the GoM on an annual basis. We get comprehensive inspections on environmental and occupational<br />

health activities by local, provincial and state inspection agencies on a regular basis and our compliance rate<br />

has been assessed to be satisfactory since the start of our mining operations. The details on our environmental<br />

management activities, compliance with relevant legislations and environmental impact mitigation measures can<br />

be found in the subsection headed “Health, Safety & Environment” set out in the Sustainability Report section on<br />

pages 58 to 69 of this annual report.<br />

Compliance with relevant Laws and Regulations<br />

Discussions on compliance with relevant laws and regulations which have a significant impact on the Group<br />

are set out in the subsection headed “OPERATING ENVIRONMENT - Legal Framework” under the Management<br />

Discussion and Analysis section on pages 19 to 21 of this annual report.<br />

Key Relationships with Stakeholders<br />

In relation to the Company’s key relationships with its employees, customers and suppliers, discussions on the<br />

Company’s policies on human resources management, community involvement and contribution in relation to<br />

environmental concerns and social responsibility are provided in Management Discussion and Analysis section on<br />

page 47 and the Sustainability Report section on pages 54 to 76 of this annual report.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

89


Directors’ Report<br />

Risk Management, Key Risks and Uncertainties<br />

A description of possible risks and uncertainties that the Group may be facing is provided in the Management<br />

Discussion and Analysis section on pages 43 to 44 of this annual report.<br />

The Group’s management is responsible for establishing and maintaining an effective risk management system.<br />

The management team aims at efficient and effective operations, reliable financial reporting and compliance with<br />

regulations. The Group’s operations, financial condition and prospects may be affected by a number of risks and<br />

uncertainties. Key risks and uncertainties relating to our business and industry are categorized into (i) routine<br />

operational and technical risks; (ii) corporate risks; and (iii) external risks.<br />

Operational risks are risks arising within the organization, that are controllable and ought to be minimized with<br />

its consequences mitigated. Operational risks include, but not limited to, risks related to mining, processing,<br />

transportation activities; technical compliance risks; health, safety and environmental risks; project related risks;<br />

and procurement and contract management risks. The objective of our risk management is to avoid or minimize<br />

occurrence through a compliance based approach and active prevention by monitoring operational processes<br />

and guiding people’s behaviors and decisions toward desired norms. This is implemented via the establishment of<br />

standard operating procedures and internal controls, and extensive training of personnel.<br />

Corporate risks that arise within the organization mainly include legal compliance risks; financial compliance<br />

risks; financial risks such as liquidity, credit risks, financial planning and reporting risks; sales and trading related<br />

risks, such as customer, brand, reputation and supply chain risk; and public relations and communications risks.<br />

Our risk management’s objective is to reduce the likelihood and impact of such risks, through implementation of<br />

appropriate procedures and internal control processes that protect the Company from fraud, negligence, legal<br />

and other potential regulatory liabilities. Moreover, the management shall identify the major plausible risks inherent<br />

in the decision making process, and will endeavor to mitigate and manage those risks, with the subsequent<br />

continuous monitoring of the accepted risk exposures.<br />

External risks arising from events outside the Company and are beyond our influence and control, include,<br />

but not limited to, industry related risks; and macroeconomic risks, such as foreign currency exposure risks,<br />

inflation, economical shifts; political risks; natural disaster risks and others. These types of risks can be the most<br />

devastating should they occur and ought to be projected through risk assessment, stress testing and scenario<br />

planning tools.<br />

Corporate and external risks require distinct risk management processes that encourage the management to<br />

identify, openly discuss and find cost effective ways to reduce the likelihood of occurrence of such risk events and<br />

to mitigate the consequences should they occur.<br />

A notable achievement in 2015 is the stabilization of part of our taxation exposure. On 13 August 2015, the<br />

Stabilization Certificate was issued by the Investment Agency to ER. Consequently, ER now has four main taxes<br />

namely, corporate income tax, customs tax, VAT and royalty, stabilized for the period until 17 April 2033 in<br />

accordance with the Law on Investment.<br />

Furthermore, with the purpose of liquidity and balance sheet management in light of the current adverse market<br />

conditions, and to better protect the interests of all the stakeholders of the Company, the Company started a<br />

dialogue with its lenders, and the financial and legal advisors of the steering committee of its noteholders about<br />

a possible restructuring arrangement in relation to its debt facilities. The Company is committed to transparent<br />

communication with broader investment community with ultimate goal to achieve outcomes acceptable and in the<br />

long term beneficial to all its stakeholders.<br />

90<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

Prospects<br />

A description of the likely future development in the Company’s business is provided in the subsection headed<br />

“OUTLOOK AND BUSINESS STRATEGIES IN 2016” under the Management Discussion and Analysis section on<br />

pages 33 to 34 of this annual report.<br />

Subsequent Events<br />

A description of particulars of important events affecting the Company that have occurred since the end of the<br />

financial period can be found in the paragraph headed “Other and Subsequent Events” under the Management<br />

Discussion and Analysis section on pages 46 and 47 of this annual report.<br />

Save as disclosed above, there have been no events subsequent to 31 December 2015 which require adjustment<br />

to or disclosure in the annual report.<br />

MAJOR CUSTOMERS AND SUPPLIERS<br />

The information in respect of the Group’s sales and purchases attributable to the major customers and suppliers<br />

respectively during the financial year is set out in Table 22.<br />

Table 22. Sales and purchases attributable to the major customers and suppliers<br />

Percentage of<br />

the Group’s total<br />

Revenue<br />

from sales<br />

of goods and<br />

rendering of<br />

services Purchases<br />

The largest customer 26.3%<br />

Five largest customers in aggregate 73.7%<br />

The largest supplier 57.9%<br />

Five largest suppliers in aggregate 81.9%<br />

Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv, Director of the Company, holds interests in NIC LLC which is one of the five largest<br />

suppliers disclosed above. Each of MCS Mining Group Limited, the controlling shareholder of the Company and<br />

Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts and Mr. Od Jambaljamts, Directors of the Company, has interests in MCS International<br />

LLC and Uniservice Solution LLC which are two of the five largest suppliers disclosed above.<br />

Save as disclosed above, to the best knowledge of the Directors, none of the Directors nor any of their close<br />

associates nor any shareholder who holds more than 5% of the Shares has any interests in the customers or<br />

suppliers disclosed above.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

91


Directors’ Report<br />

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS<br />

The results of the Group for the year ended 31 December 2015 and the state of the Group’s affairs as at that date<br />

are set out in the consolidated financial statements on pages 109 to 196.<br />

TRANSFER TO RESERVES<br />

Loss attributable to equity shareholders, before dividend, of USD187,763,000 (2014: loss of USD282,837,000)<br />

have been transferred to reserves. Other movements in reserves are set out in the consolidated statement of<br />

changes in equity on page 113.<br />

DIVIDEND<br />

No dividend has been declared and paid by the Group during the year ended 31 December 2015. The Board does<br />

not recommend the payment of a dividend for the year ended 31 December 2015 (dividend for the year ended 31<br />

December 2014: nil).<br />

CHARITABLE DONATIONS<br />

Charitable donations made by the Group during the year ended 31 December 2015 amounted to USD84,000<br />

(2014: USD21,000).<br />

PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT<br />

During the year, the Group acquired property, plant and equipment for approximately USD21,509,000. Details of<br />

these acquisitions and other movements in the property, plant and equipment of the Group are set out in note 13<br />

to the consolidated financial statements.<br />

SHARE CAPITAL<br />

Details of the movements in share capital of the Company during the year are set out in note 29 to the<br />

consolidated financial statements.<br />

BANK LOANS AND OTHER BORROWINGS<br />

Particulars of bank loans and other borrowings of the Group as at 31 December 2015 are set out in note 23 to<br />

the consolidated financial statements. The borrowing amount totals USD197.6 million (2014: USD276.8 million)<br />

and all of it is in USD. The borrowing of USD55 million is at fixed rate and the remaining borrowings are at variable<br />

rate (with a fixed margin over LIBOR).<br />

92<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

FINANCIAL SUMMARY<br />

A summary of the results and of the assets and liabilities of the Group for the last five financial years is set out on<br />

pages 197 and 198.<br />

DIRECTORS<br />

The Directors during the financial year and up to the date of this annual report are:<br />

Executive Directors<br />

Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts (Chairman of the Board)<br />

Dr. Battsengel Gotov (Chief Executive Officer)<br />

Non-executive Directors<br />

Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv<br />

Mr. Batsaikhan Purev (resigned on 30 November 2015)<br />

Mr. Od Jambaljamts<br />

Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish<br />

Independent non-executive Directors<br />

Mr. Ochirbat Punsalmaa (resigned on 8 January 2016)<br />

Dr. Khashchuluun Chuluundorj (appointed on 8 January 2016)<br />

Mr. Unenbat Jigjid<br />

Mr. Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius<br />

In accordance with the Articles, Dr. Battsengel Gotov, being an executive Director, Mr. Od Jambaljamts, being<br />

a non-executive Director, and Mr. Unenbat Jigjid, being an independent non-executive Director, will retire from<br />

directorship by rotation at the forthcoming AGM and, being eligible, offer themselves for re-election and Dr.<br />

Khashchuluun Chuluundorj, whose appointment took effect from 8 January 2016, should hold office until the<br />

forthcoming AGM and will retire and then be eligible for re-election. Biographical details of the Directors are set<br />

out in the section headed “Directors and Senior Management” on pages 6 to 13.<br />

The Company has received from each of the independent non-executive Directors an annual confirmation of<br />

independence pursuant to Rule 3.13 of the Listing Rules and considers all the independent non-executive<br />

Directors to be independent in accordance with the guidelines set out under the Listing Rules.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

93


Directors’ Report<br />

DIRECTORS’ SERVICE CONTRACTS<br />

Each of the executive Directors has entered into a service agreement with the Company for a fixed term of three<br />

years. Each of the non-executive Directors and independent non-executive Directors is engaged on a letter of<br />

appointment with the Company for a term of two years.<br />

None of the Directors proposed for re-election at the forthcoming AGM has entered into any service agreement<br />

with the Company which is not determinable by the Group within one year without payment of compensation (other<br />

than statutory compensation).<br />

DIRECTORS’ INTERESTS IN TRANSACTIONS, ARRANGEMENTS OR<br />

CONTRACTS<br />

Saved as disclosed in this annual report, as at 31 December 2015 or during the year, none of the Directors or<br />

entities connected with the Directors was materially interested, either directly or indirectly, in any transaction,<br />

arrangement or contract that is significant in relation to the business of the Group to which the Company or any<br />

of its subsidiaries was a party.<br />

DIRECTORS’ PERMITTED INDEMNITY PROVISION<br />

Under the Company’s Articles, every Director or other officer of the Company acting in relation to any of the<br />

affairs of the Company shall be indemnified and secured harmless out of the assets and profits of the Company<br />

from and against all actions, costs, charges, losses, damages and expenses which he may sustain or incur in or<br />

about the execution of the duties of his office or otherwise in relation thereto provided that such indemnity shall<br />

not extend to any matter in respect of any fraud or dishonesty which may attach to the Director or other officer.<br />

The Company has arranged appropriate directors’ and officers’ liability insurance coverage for the Directors and<br />

officers of the Group.<br />

MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS<br />

Other than the service contracts of the Directors, the Company has not entered into any contract with any<br />

individual, firm or body corporate to manage or administer the whole or any substantial part of any business of the<br />

Company during the year.<br />

DIRECTORS’ INTERESTS IN COMPETING BUSINESS<br />

None of the Directors or their associates had any interest in a business that competes or may compete with the<br />

business of the Group.<br />

94<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

NON-COMPETITION UNDERTAKING<br />

Pursuant to a deed of non-competition dated 20 September 2010, and as amended on 3 April 2012 and 4 July<br />

2012 (the “Deed of Non-competition”) executed by Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, Mr. Od Jambaljamts, MCS Mining<br />

Group Limited and MCS (Mongolia) Limited (collectively the “Undertakers”) in favour of the Company (for itself<br />

and on behalf of the Group), the Undertakers undertake, among other things, that at any time when the shares of<br />

the Company are listed on the SEHK and for so long as the Undertakers and its associates together hold, whether<br />

individually or taken together, 30% or more of the issued share capital or are otherwise regarded as a controlling<br />

shareholder of the Company under the Listing Rules, the Undertakers will not, and will procure that its associates<br />

(excluding the Group) will not, directly or indirectly, either on its own account or with each other or in conjunction<br />

with or on behalf of any person, firm or company, except through a member of the Group, among other things,<br />

carry on, participate or be interested or engaged in, acquire or hold (in each case whether as a shareholder,<br />

partner, agent, employee or otherwise) any business (except for their aggregate 10% interest in Quincunx (BVI)<br />

Ltd) which is or may be in competition with the Restricted Mining Business (as defined in the prospectus of the<br />

Company dated 28 September 2010) of any member of the Group from time to time. In the event that a business<br />

opportunity in relation to the Restricted Mining Business (as defined in the prospectus of the Company dated<br />

28 September 2010) is made available to the Undertakers and/or any of their associates, the Undertakers shall<br />

promptly notify the Company in writing and refer such business opportunity for the Company’s consideration<br />

and the Undertakers shall not and procure his/their associates shall not, invest or participate in any project or<br />

business opportunity unless such project or business opportunity has been rejected by the Company and the<br />

principal terms on which the Undertakers or his/their associates invest or participate are no more favourable than<br />

those made available to the Company.<br />

Each of the Undertakers has reviewed his/their respective business (excluding the business of the Group) and<br />

advised that during the year ended 31 December 2015, his/their respective business did not compete with the<br />

Group and there was no opportunity made available to the Undertakers to invest or participate in any such project<br />

or business opportunity that is governed by the Deed of Non-competition.<br />

Each of the Undertakers has given a written confirmation to the Company that it has fully complied with the terms<br />

of the Deed of Non-competition. The independent non-executive Directors have also reviewed the confirmations<br />

by each of the Undertakers and concluded that each of the Undertakers has been in compliance with the Deed of<br />

Non-competition during the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

95


Directors’ Report<br />

DIRECTORS’ AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE’S INTERESTS AND SHORT<br />

POSITIONS IN SHARES, UNDERLYING SHARES AND DEBENTURES OF<br />

THE COMPANY OR ITS ASSOCIATED CORPORATIONS<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the interest and short positions of the Directors and chief executive of the Company<br />

in the shares and underlying shares or debentures of the Company or its associated corporations (within the<br />

meaning of Part XV of the Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571 of the Laws of Hong Kong) (“SFO”) as<br />

recorded in the register required to be kept pursuant to section 352 of the SFO, or as otherwise notified to the<br />

Company and the Stock Exchange pursuant to the Model Code were as follows:<br />

Table 23. Interests in Shares<br />

Name of Director<br />

Nature of interest<br />

Ordinary shares of USD0.01 each<br />

Total number<br />

of Shares held<br />

Approximate<br />

percentage of<br />

total issued<br />

share capital<br />

Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation 3,693,241,531 (L) 39.87%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

Mr. Od Jambaljamts (Note 2) Interest of controlled corporation 3,497,356,251 (L) 37.76%<br />

2,921,761,960 (S) 31.54%<br />

Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv (Note 3) Interest of controlled corporation 112,833,333 (L) 1.22%<br />

Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish (Note 4) Interest of controlled corporation 11,819,579 (L) 0.13%<br />

11,819,579 (S) 0.13%<br />

(L) - Long position (S) - Short position<br />

Notes:<br />

1. Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts holds the entire interest of Novel Holdings Group Limited. Novel Holdings Group Limited directly<br />

holds 461,647,547 shares in the Company and is also interested in approximately 49.84% of MCS (Mongolia) Limited.<br />

MCS (Mongolia) Limited holds the entire interest of MCS Global Limited which in turn holds the entire interest of MCS<br />

Holding LLC. MCS Holding LLC is interested in approximately 57.76% of MCS Mining Group Limited which in turn holds<br />

3,231,593,984 shares in the Company. MCS (Mongolia) Limited also directly holds approximately 42.24% interest of MCS<br />

Mining Group Limited. MCS Mining Group Limited had a short position in 2,815,457,053 shares of the Company.<br />

2. Mr. Od Jambaljamts holds the entire interest of Trimunkh Limited. Trimunkh Limited directly holds 265,762,267 shares<br />

in the Company and is also interested in approximately 28.69% of MCS (Mongolia) Limited. MCS (Mongolia) Limited<br />

holds the entire interest of MCS Global Limited which in turn holds the entire interest of MCS Holding LLC. MCS Holding<br />

LLC is interested in approximately 57.76% of MCS Mining Group Limited which in turn holds 3,231,593,984 shares in<br />

the Company. MCS (Mongolia) Limited also directly holds approximately 42.24% interest of MCS Mining Group Limited.<br />

MCS Mining Group Limited had a short position in 2,815,457,053 shares and Trimunkh Limited had a short position in<br />

106,304,907 shares of the Company.<br />

3. Dr. Oyungerel Janchiv, through Lotus Amsa Limited which is 100% owned by her, held 112,833,333 shares in the<br />

Company.<br />

4. Mr. Gankhuyag Adilbish, through Tugs Investments Limited which is 100% owned by him, held 11,819,579 shares and<br />

had a short position in 11,819,579 shares in the Company.<br />

96<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

Table 24. Interest in underlying Shares<br />

Name of Director<br />

Nature of interest<br />

Ordinary shares of USD0.01 each<br />

Total number of<br />

underlying Shares<br />

held pursuant to<br />

Share Options under<br />

the Share<br />

Option Scheme<br />

Approximate<br />

percentage of<br />

total issued<br />

share capital<br />

Dr. Battsengel Gotov Beneficial owner 71,764,707 (L) 0.77%<br />

(L) - Long position<br />

Save as disclosed above, as at 31 December 2015, so far as was known to any Director or chief executive of<br />

the Company, neither the Directors nor the chief executive had any interests or short positions in any Shares,<br />

underlying Shares or debentures of the Company or any of its associated corporations (within the meaning of Part<br />

XV of SFO).<br />

SHARE OPTION SCHEME<br />

The Share Option Scheme was adopted by the Company on 17 September 2010, which became effective on the<br />

Listing Date on 13 October 2010 (the “Adoption Date”). Share Options could be granted within a period of 10<br />

years from the Adoption Date. Therefore, as at 31 December 2015, the remaining life of the Share Option Scheme<br />

was approximately 4 years and 9 months. The purpose of the Share Option Scheme is to provide an opportunity<br />

for employees of the Group to acquire an equity participation in the Company and to encourage them to work<br />

towards enhancing the value of the Company for the benefit of the Company and its shareholders as a whole.<br />

Eligibility<br />

The Directors may invite any person belonging to any of the following classes of participants to take up options to<br />

subscribe for Shares:<br />

a) any employee or proposed employee (whether full time or part-time and including any executive Director),<br />

consultants or advisers of or to the Company, any of its subsidiaries or any entity (“Invested Entity”) in<br />

which the Group holds an equity interest;<br />

b) any non-executive directors (including independent non-executive directors) of the Company, any of its<br />

subsidiaries or any Invested Entity;<br />

c) any supplier of goods or services to any member of the Group or any Invested Entity;<br />

d) any customer of the Group or any Invested Entity;<br />

e) any person or entity that provides research, development or other technological support to the Group or any<br />

Invested Entity; and<br />

f) any shareholder of any member of the Group or any Invested Entity or any holder of any securities issued by<br />

any member of the Group or any Invested Entity.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

97


Directors’ Report<br />

The basis of eligibility of any of the classes of participants to the grant of any options shall be determined by the<br />

Directors from time to time on the basis of the participants’ contribution to the development and growth of the<br />

Company.<br />

Grant of options<br />

Unless terminated by a resolution adopted at general meeting, the Directors shall be entitled at any time within a<br />

period of 10 years commencing on the Adoption Date to make an offer to such participant as the Directors may<br />

select to subscribe for such number of Shares at the subscription price as the Directors shall determine.<br />

The option period of an option within which the Shares must be taken up may not end later than 10 years from<br />

the date of offer (“Offer Date”), while the Directors may fix any minimum period for which an option must be held,<br />

any performance targets that must be achieved and any other conditions that must be fulfilled before the option<br />

can be exercised upon the grant of an option to participant. HKD1.00 is payable on acceptance of the option<br />

within 28 days from the Offer Date.<br />

Subscription price<br />

The subscription price in respect of any option must be at least the highest of:<br />

a) the closing price of the Shares as stated in the SEHK’s daily quotations sheet on the Offer Date;<br />

b) the average closing price of the Shares as stated in the SEHK’s daily quotations sheet for the five business<br />

days immediately preceding the Offer Date; and<br />

c) the nominal value of the Shares.<br />

Exercise of options<br />

An option shall be exercisable in whole or in part by giving notice in writing to the Company accompanied by a<br />

payment for the full amount of the subscription price for the shares. An option shall be personal to the grantee<br />

and shall not be transferable or assignable.<br />

Maximum number of shares available for subscription<br />

The total number of Shares which may be issued upon exercise of all options to be granted under the Share<br />

Option Scheme and any other share option schemes of the Group must not in aggregate exceed 10% of the total<br />

number of Shares in issue on the Listing Date. The total number of Shares available for issue under the Share<br />

Option Scheme is 359,712,250 Shares (including those granted but yet to be exercised), representing 3.88% of<br />

the issued Shares of the Company as at the date of this annual report.<br />

The maximum number of Shares to be issued upon exercise of all outstanding options granted and yet to be<br />

exercised under the Share Option Scheme and any other share option schemes of the Company must not in<br />

aggregate exceed 30% of the issued share capital from time to time. No option may be granted under any<br />

schemes of the Company (or the subsidiary of the Company) if such grant will result in the maximum number<br />

being exceeded.<br />

98<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

Maximum entitlement of each participant<br />

Unless approved by the Shareholders, the total number of Shares issued and to be issued upon exercise of<br />

all outstanding options granted under the Share Option Scheme and any other share option schemes of the<br />

Company (including both exercised and outstanding options) to each participant in any 12-month period must not<br />

exceed 1% of the Shares in issue. Each grant of options to a Director, chief executive or substantial Shareholder<br />

or any of their respective associates must be approved by the independent non-executive Directors (excluding<br />

any independent non-executive Director who is the grantee of the options).<br />

Under the Share Option Scheme, the Company granted three batches of Share Options to its Director and<br />

employees. On 12 October 2011, the Company offered 3,000,000 and 34,500,000 Share Options to a Director<br />

and employees respectively, at the exercise price of HKD6.66 and 3,000,000 and 32,200,000 Share Options<br />

were accepted by a Director and employees respectively. On 28 November 2012, the Company granted another<br />

5,000,000 and 17,750,000 Share Options to a Director and employees respectively at the exercise price of<br />

HKD3.92.<br />

As a result of the rights issue completed on 29 December 2014, adjustments were made to the exercise prices<br />

and the number of shares falling to be issued upon the exercise of the Share Options in accordance with<br />

the terms of the Share Option Scheme and the supplementary guidance issued by the Stock Exchange on 5<br />

September 2005 regarding the adjustment of share options under rule 17.03(13) of the Listing Rules.<br />

A total of 48,100,000 Options were outstanding under the Share Option Scheme as at the completion of the rights<br />

issue. The exercise prices and the number of the shares falling to be issued under the outstanding Share Options<br />

were adjusted pursuant to Clause 11 of the Share Option Scheme (the “Option Adjustments”) with effect from 1<br />

January 2015, and such adjustments have been reviewed and confirmed by the independent financial adviser of<br />

the Company, Somerley Capital Limited. Details of the adjustments are set out in Tables 25 and 26 below.<br />

On 10 June 2015, the Company granted another 60,000,000 and 94,750,000 Share Options to a Director and<br />

employees respectively at the exercise price of HKD0.445. The closing price of the shares immediately before the<br />

grant of Share Options on 10 June 2015 was HKD0.52 per Share. Further details of the grant are set out in note<br />

27 to the consolidated financial statements.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

99


Directors’ Report<br />

Details of the movements in Share Options of the Company during the year ended 31 December 2015 are as<br />

follows:<br />

Table 25. Director<br />

Name of Director<br />

Date of grant<br />

Exercise<br />

period<br />

Exercise<br />

price<br />

per share<br />

Adjusted<br />

exercise<br />

price per<br />

share<br />

(Note 4)<br />

Balance as<br />

at<br />

1 January<br />

2015<br />

Adjusted<br />

balance on<br />

1 January<br />

2015<br />

due to<br />

Rights<br />

Issue<br />

(Note 4)<br />

Granted<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Number of Share Options<br />

Lapsed<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Cancelled<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Exercised<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Balance as<br />

at<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Dr. Battsengel Gotov 12 October 2011 (Note 1) HKD6.66 HKD4.53 3,000,000 4,411,765 — — — — 4,411,765<br />

28 November 2012 (Note 2) HKD3.92 HKD2.67 5,000,000 7,352,941 — — — — 7,352,941<br />

10 June 2015 (Note 3) HKD0.445 — — — 60,000,000 — — — 60,000,000<br />

Table 26. Employees of the Group other than the Directors<br />

Date of grant<br />

Exercise period<br />

Exercise<br />

price per share<br />

Adjusted<br />

exercise<br />

price<br />

per share<br />

(Note 4)<br />

Balance<br />

as at<br />

1 January<br />

2015<br />

Adjusted<br />

balance on<br />

1 January<br />

2015<br />

due to<br />

Rights<br />

Issue<br />

(Note 4)<br />

Granted<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Number of Share Options<br />

Lapsed<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Cancelled<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Exercised<br />

during the<br />

year ended<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

Balance<br />

as at<br />

31 December<br />

2015<br />

12 October 2011 (Note 1) HKD6.66 HKD4.53 23,350,000 34,338,235 — 275,735 — — 34,062,500<br />

28 November 2012 (Note 2) HKD3.92 HKD2.67 16,750,000 24,632,353 — — — — 24,632,353<br />

10 June 2015 (Note 3) HKD0.445 — — — 94,750,000 — — — 94,750,000<br />

100<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

Notes:<br />

1. The Share Options are subject to vesting scale in four tranches of 25% each. The exercise periods are as follows:<br />

(1) first 25% of the Share Options granted – 12 October 2012 to 12 October 2019<br />

(2) second 25% of the Share Options granted – 12 October 2013 to 12 October 2019<br />

(3) third 25% of the Share Options granted – 12 October 2014 to 12 October 2019<br />

(4) fourth 25% of the Share Options granted – 12 October 2015 to 12 October 2019<br />

2. The Share Options are subject to vesting scale in three tranches. The exercise periods are as follows:<br />

(1) first 25% of the Share Options granted – 28 November 2013 to 28 November 2020<br />

(2) second 25% of the Share Options granted – 28 November 2014 to 28 November 2020<br />

(3) third 50% of the Share Options granted – 28 November 2015 to 28 November 2020<br />

3. The Share Options are subject to vesting scale in four tranches of 25% each. The exercise periods are as follows:<br />

(1) first 25% of the Share Options granted – 10 June 2015 to 10 June 2020<br />

(2) second 25% of the Share Options granted – 10 June 2016 to 10 June 2020<br />

(3) third 25% of the Share Options granted – 10 June 2017 to 10 June 2020<br />

(4) fourth 25% of the Share Options granted – 10 June 2018 to 10 June 2020<br />

4. As a result of the rights issue completed on 29 December 2014, the exercise prices and the number of the shares<br />

falling to be issued upon full exercise of the outstanding Share Options were adjusted in accordance with the Option<br />

Adjustments with effect from 1 January 2015. Please refer to the 2014 Annual Report of the Company for details.<br />

Treatment of lapse of the share options<br />

Pursuant to the Share Option Scheme, in the event that an employee ceases to be an employee of the Company<br />

before exercising the option in full, the option (to the extent not already exercised) shall lapse on the date of<br />

cessation or termination and not be exercisable unless the Directors otherwise determine. The offer letter to<br />

grantees also states that any option shares that have not yet vested according to the vesting scales shall be<br />

considered “Unvested Shares”, and upon cessation of employment or services on behalf of the Company for any<br />

reason, no further vesting of the option will occur and any unvested portion of the option will terminate.<br />

The Directors determined that in the event that an employee ceases to be an employee of the Company before<br />

exercising the option in full, only unvested Share Options (but not all the outstanding Share Options) will lapse<br />

effective from 1 August 2013.<br />

EQUITY-LINKED AGREEMENTS<br />

Save as disclosed under the section headed “Share Option Scheme” above, for the year ended 31 December<br />

2015, the Company has not entered into any equity-linked agreement.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

101


Directors’ Report<br />

RIGHTS TO PURCHASE SHARES OR DEBENTURES OF DIRECTORS AND<br />

CHIEF EXECUTIVE<br />

Save as disclosed under the section headed “Share Option Scheme” above, at no time during the year ended<br />

31 December 2015 had the Company or any of its subsidiaries or any fellow subsidiaries entered into any<br />

arrangement which enables the Directors or chief executive to have the right to acquire benefits by means of<br />

acquisition of shares or debentures in the Company or any associated corporations.<br />

SUBSTANTIAL SHAREHOLDERS’ INTERESTS AND SHORT POSITIONS<br />

IN SHARES AND UNDERLYING SHARES<br />

As at 31 December 2015, so far as was known to any Director or chief executive of the Company and based on<br />

the information publicly available, shareholders (other than a Director or chief executive of the Company) who<br />

had an interest or short position in the shares or underlying shares of the Company as recorded in the register<br />

required to be kept pursuant to section 336 of the SFO were as follows:<br />

Table 27. Interest in the Shares and underlying Shares<br />

Name of substantial shareholder<br />

Nature of interest<br />

Ordinary shares of USD0.01 each<br />

Total<br />

number of<br />

Shares held<br />

Approximate<br />

percentage of<br />

total issued<br />

share capital<br />

MCS Mining Group Limited (Note 1) Beneficial owner 3,231,593,984 (L) 34.89%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

MCS (Mongolia) Limited (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation 3,231,593,984 (L) 34.89%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

MCS Global Limited (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation 3,231,593,984 (L) 34.89%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

MCS Holding LLC (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation 3,231,593,984 (L) 34.89%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

Novel Holdings Group Limited (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation/ 3,693,241,531 (L) 39.87%<br />

Beneficial owner 2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

Trimunkh Limited (Note 1) Interest of controlled corporation/ 3,497,356,251 (L) 37.76%<br />

Beneficial owner 2,921,761,960 (S) 31.54%<br />

Ms. Batmunkh Dashdeleg (Note 1) Interest of spouse 3,693,241,531 (L) 39.87%<br />

2,815,457,053 (S) 30.40%<br />

Ms. Munkhsuren Surenkhuu (Note 1) Interest of spouse 3,497,356,251 (L) 37.76%<br />

2,921,761,960 (S) 31.54%<br />

Kerry Mining (UHG) Limited (“KMUHG”) (Note 2) Beneficial owner 750,000,000 (L) 8.10%<br />

KMM (Note 2) Interest of controlled corporation 750,000,000 (L) 8.10%<br />

Fexos Limited (“Fexos”) (Note 2) Interest of controlled corporations 756,890,120 (L) 8.17%<br />

Kerry Holdings Limited (“KHL”) (Note 2) Interest of controlled corporations 756,890,120 (L) 8.17%<br />

Kerry Group Limited (“KGL”) (Notes 2 and 3) Interest of controlled corporations 1,197,461,111 (L) 12.93%<br />

Trade and Development Bank of Mongolia Beneficial owner 507,749,999 (L) 5.48%<br />

(L) - Long position (S) - Short position<br />

102<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

Notes:<br />

1) MCS Mining Group Limited is owned as to approximately 57.76% by MCS Holding LLC and approximately 42.24% by<br />

MCS (Mongolia) Limited. MCS Holding LLC is wholly-owned by MCS Global Limited which in turn is wholly-owned by MCS<br />

(Mongolia) Limited. MCS (Mongolia) Limited is owned as to approximately 49.84% by Novel Holdings Group Limited which<br />

in turn is wholly-owned by Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, and 28.69% by Trimunkh Limited which in turn is wholly-owned by<br />

Mr. Od Jambaljamts. MCS Mining Group Limited holds 3,231,593,984 shares and had a short position in 2,815,457,053<br />

shares in the Company. Novel Holdings Group Limited and Trimunkh Limited each also directly held 461,647,547 shares<br />

and 265,762,267 shares in the Company, and Trimunkh Limited had a short position in 106,304,907 shares in the<br />

Company. Ms. Batmunkh Dashdeleg is the spouse of Mr. Odjargal Jambaljamts, and Ms. Munkhsuren Surenkhuu is the<br />

spouse of Mr. Od Jambaljamts.<br />

2) (a) KMUHG is a direct wholly-owned subsidiary of KMM. Fexos controls more than one-third of the voting power of<br />

KMM. Fexos is a direct wholly-owned subsidiary of KHL which in turn is a direct wholly-owned subsidiary of KGL.<br />

Accordingly, KMM, Fexos, KHL and KGL were deemed to be interested in the 750,000,000 shares that KMUHG was<br />

interested.<br />

(b)<br />

Fexos controls more than one-third of the voting power of Kerry Asset Management Limited (“KAM”). Fexos, KHL<br />

and KGL were deemed to be interested in the 6,890,120 shares that KAM was interested.<br />

3) Out of KGL’s corporate interest in 1,197,461,111 shares of the Company, KGL’s wholly-owned subsidiaries (other than<br />

KHL) were interested in 440,570,991 shares of the Company, KHL (through companies that it controls more than onethird<br />

of the voting power) was interested in 756,890,120 shares of the Company.<br />

Save as disclosed above, as at 31 December 2015, the Company has not been notified by any person (other than<br />

the Directors or chief executive of the Company) who had interests or short position in the shares or underlying<br />

shares of the Company.<br />

CONTINUING CONNECTED TRANSACTIONS<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, the non-exempt CCTs of the Group were USD28,246,304.<br />

The details of non-exempt CCTs for the year ended 31 December 2015 are set out on pages 48 to 51 of this<br />

annual report.<br />

PLEDGE OF ASSETS OF THE GROUP<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Company pledged ER’s current accounts held with Trade and Development Bank of<br />

Mongolia, Khan Bank of Mongolia, Golomt Bank of Mongolia and XacBank of Mongolia, its Debt Reserve Account<br />

held with BNP Paribas London; Collection and Cash Collateral accounts held with BNP Paribas Hong Kong;<br />

cooperation contract with Inner Mongolia Qinghua Group of China, coal sales contracts with certain customers;<br />

coal mining agreement with Thiess Mongolia LLC (formerly known as Leighton LLC); engineering, procurement<br />

and construction management contract for the CHPP constructed at the UHG site with Sedgman LLC; CHPP<br />

modules 1 and 2; UHG Power Plant; water facilities and certain coal stockpiles for bank borrowings.<br />

Share pledges of Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited and Mongolian Coal Corporation S.à.r.l. are shared among<br />

the BNP and ICBC Facility and the USD600 million Senior Notes.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

103


Directors’ Report<br />

ER pledged its 4,207,500 common shares, being 16.46% of the common shares held by it in IMC pursuant to<br />

the Share Pledge between Energy Resources LLC and EBRD dated 24 June 2013 to secure loan repayment<br />

obligation of IMC in proportion to its equity interest in IMC.<br />

The total amount of indebtedness covered with the above pledges is USD744.8 million as at 31 December 2015.<br />

EMOLUMENT POLICY<br />

The emolument policy of the Group is set to (1) recruit, retain and motivate qualified and experienced staff,<br />

including directors and senior management, (2) apply a responsible and sustainable remuneration practice that is<br />

determined by reference to the performance of the individual, the operational and financial results of the Group,<br />

and is in line with the market practice and conditions, (3) ensure that no individual participates in deciding his/her<br />

own remuneration, and (4) ensure that the base salary levels and annual incentives are competitive in the market<br />

and comparable to the similar jobs in the peer companies.<br />

The emolument of executive directors and senior management of the Group is determined by the remuneration<br />

committee of the Board, the emolument of non-executive directors and independent non-executive directors is<br />

recommended by the remuneration committee of the Board and determined by the Board and the emolument of<br />

staff is determined by the group management.<br />

In addition to a base salary, the emolument of staff and directors and senior management is structured to include<br />

bonuses (such as a discretionary bonus), and benefits.<br />

The Company has a Share Option Scheme to provide a long-term incentive and an opportunity for employees of<br />

the Group to acquire an equity participation in the Company. On 10 June 2015, the Company granted another<br />

60,000,000 and 94,750,000 Share Options to a Director and employees respectively at the exercise price of<br />

HKD0.445.<br />

The required competencies, skills and performance of the individual concerned and the specific role and<br />

responsibilities of the relevant position are considered in determining the emolument of an individual director or<br />

member of senior management.<br />

RETIREMENT SCHEME<br />

The Group participates in retirement benefit schemes pursuant to the relevant labour rules and regulations<br />

of Mongolia, the country of operation, whereby the Group is required to make contributions to the retirement<br />

schemes at a rate of 7% of the eligible employees’ salaries. Based on collective agreement signed in 2013 and<br />

outcome of meeting with officials from Ministry of Mining, Labour Union and the employers’ representatives of<br />

mining industry, each employee who retires from mining industry shall receive payment equal to double of the<br />

minimum wage of the industry multiplied by the number of years worked in the mining industry.<br />

The Group has no other retirement schemes beyond the retirement contributions described above. Particulars of<br />

the retirement scheme are set out in note 6 to the consolidated financial statements.<br />

PRE-EMPTIVE RIGHTS<br />

There are no provisions for pre-emptive rights under the Articles or relevant laws of the Cayman Islands where<br />

the Company is incorporated which would oblige the Company to offer new shares on a pro-rata basis to existing<br />

shareholders.<br />

104<br />

Annual Report 2015


Directors’ Report<br />

CHARGE OF SHARES BY CONTROLLING SHAREHOLDER<br />

On 9 June 2011, MCS Mining Group Limited, the controlling shareholder of the Company, entered into a share<br />

charge over the Shares with Standard Bank Plc (“SB Charged Shares”) in respect of 334,483,750 Shares of<br />

the Company and on 27 November 2012, 15 March 2013, 5 April 2013, 10 April 2013 and on 3 December 2013<br />

entered into further share charge of 465,516,250, 83,337,955, 100,000,000, 83,000,000 and 45,172,994 Shares,<br />

respectively, in respect of the SB Charged Shares, whereby MCS Mining Group Limited granted security over<br />

the SB Charged Shares in favour of Standard Bank Plc. On 18 December 2013, Standard Bank Plc resigned<br />

as security agent and BNP Paribas Hong Kong Branch was appointed as replacement security agent. On 17<br />

December 2014, MCS Mining Group Limited entered into a share charge over the Shares with BNP Paribas Hong<br />

Kong Branch in respect of 1,667,266,423 Shares of the Company.<br />

On 18 November 2011, MCS Mining Group Limited entered into a share charge over the Shares with IFC in<br />

respect of 36,679,681 Shares of the Company and on 28 December 2011, IFC exercised its conversion right to<br />

convert loan into 19,706,308 Shares, whereby MCS Mining Group Limited granted shares in favour of IFC.<br />

ISSUE OF EQUITY SECURITIES<br />

No additional shares were issued during the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

PURCHASE, SALE OR REDEMPTION OF THE COMPANY’S LISTED<br />

SECURITIES<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015, neither the Company nor any of its subsidiaries purchased, sold or<br />

redeemed any of the listed securities of the Company.<br />

RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS<br />

Details of the related party transactions undertaken in the normal course of business are set out in note 32 to the<br />

consolidated financial statements. In respect of those related party transactions that constitute CCTs under the<br />

Listing Rules, they have complied with applicable requirements in accordance with the Listing Rules.<br />

SUFFICIENCY OF PUBLIC FLOAT<br />

Rules 8.08(1) (a) and (b) of the Listing Rules require there to be an open market in the securities for which listing<br />

is sought and for a sufficient public float of an issuer’s listed securities to be maintained. This normally means<br />

that (i) at least 25% of the issuer’s total issued share capital must at all times be held by the public; and (ii) where<br />

an issuer has more than one class of securities apart from the class of securities for which listing is sought, the<br />

total securities of the issuer held by the public (on all regulated market(s) including the SEHK) at the time of listing<br />

must be at least 25% of the issuer’s total issued share capital. However, the class of securities for which listing is<br />

sought must not be less than 15% of the issuer’s total issued share capital, and must have an expected market<br />

capitalisation at the time of listing of not less than HKD50 million.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

105


Directors’ Report<br />

At the time of listing, the Group applied to the SEHK to request the SEHK to exercise, and the SEHK exercised<br />

its discretion under Rule 8.08(1) (d) of the Listing Rules to accept a lower public float percentage of the Company<br />

of 20% or such higher percentage of the issued share capital as would be held by the public in the event that<br />

the whole or a part of the over-allotment option is exercised (which discretion may be exercised in respect of<br />

issuers with an expected market capitalization at the time of listing of over HKD10,000 million) on the basis that<br />

the SEHK was satisfied that the number of the shares concerned and the extent of their distribution would enable<br />

the market to operate properly with the lower percentage, and on the condition that the Company would make<br />

appropriate disclosure of the lower prescribed percentage of public float in the prospectus of the Company dated<br />

28 September 2010 and confirm sufficiency of public float in the successive annual reports after listing. At the<br />

time of the listing of the Company on 13 October 2010, the market capitalization exceeded HKD10,000 million.<br />

The over-allotment option was fully exercised on 18 October 2010 in respect of an aggregate of 107,914,000<br />

shares and accordingly the lower public float percentage of the Company accepted by the SEHK is approximately<br />

22.3%. Based on the information that is publicly available to the Company and within the knowledge of the<br />

Directors as at the latest practicable date prior to the issue of this annual report, the Directors confirm that the<br />

Company has maintained the amount of public float as required under the Listing Rules.<br />

DISCLOSURE UNDER RULE 13.20 OF THE LISTING RULES<br />

The Directors are not aware of any circumstances resulting in the responsibility of disclosure under Rule 13.20 of<br />

the Listing Rules regarding the provision of advances by the Company to an entity.<br />

CHANGES IN DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION<br />

Change of information of Directors which is required to be disclosed pursuant to Rule 13.51B(1) of the Listing<br />

Rules since the date of the 2015 Interim Report of the Company is set out below:<br />

The director’s fee for all Directors, under the respective director’s service agreements and letters of appointments<br />

attributable for the fourth quarter of the year 2015 was decreased by 50%.<br />

AUDITOR<br />

Messrs. KPMG was engaged as auditor of the Company for the year ended 31 December 2015. Messrs. KPMG<br />

has audited the accompanying financial statements which were prepared in accordance with International<br />

Financial Reporting Standards.<br />

The Company has retained Messrs. KPMG since the date of listing. Messrs. KPMG was re-appointed as auditor of<br />

the Company at the AGM held on 29 May 2015.<br />

Messrs. KPMG will retire and, being eligible, offer itself for re-appointment. A resolution for the re-appointment of<br />

Messrs. KPMG as auditor of the Company will be proposed at the forthcoming AGM.<br />

On behalf of the Board<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts<br />

Chairman<br />

106<br />

Hong Kong, 24 March 2016<br />

Annual Report 2015


Independent Auditor’s Report<br />

Independent auditor’s report<br />

to the shareholders of Mongolian Mining Corporation<br />

(Incorporated in the Cayman Islands with limited liability)<br />

We have audited the consolidated financial statements of Mongolian Mining Corporation (“the Company”) and<br />

its subsidiaries (together “the Group”) set out on pages 109 to 196, which comprise the consolidated statement<br />

of financial position as at 31 December 2015, the consolidated statement of profit or loss, the consolidated<br />

statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income, the consolidated statement of changes in equity and<br />

the consolidated cash flow statement for the year then ended and a summary of significant accounting policies<br />

and other explanatory information.<br />

DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL<br />

STATEMENTS<br />

The directors of the Company are responsible for the preparation of consolidated financial statements that give<br />

a true and fair view in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International<br />

Accounting Standards Board and the disclosure requirements of the Hong Kong Companies Ordinance and for<br />

such internal control as the directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of consolidated financial<br />

statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.<br />

AUDITOR’S RESPONSIBILITY<br />

Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these consolidated financial statements based on our audit. This<br />

report is made solely to you, as a body, and for no other purpose. We do not assume responsibility towards or<br />

accept liability to any other person for the contents of this report.<br />

We conducted our audit in accordance with Hong Kong Standards on Auditing issued by the Hong Kong Institute<br />

of Certified Public Accountants. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and<br />

perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free<br />

from material misstatement.<br />

An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the<br />

consolidated financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the auditor’s judgement, including the<br />

assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to fraud or<br />

error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the entity’s preparation<br />

of the consolidated financial statements that give a true and fair view in order to design audit procedures that are<br />

appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the<br />

entity’s internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the<br />

reasonableness of accounting estimates made by the directors, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of<br />

the consolidated financial statements.<br />

We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our audit<br />

opinion.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

107


Independent Auditor’s Report<br />

OPINION<br />

In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements give a true and fair view of the financial position of the Group<br />

as at 31 December 2015 and of the Group’s financial performance and cash flows for the year then ended in<br />

accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards and have been properly prepared in accordance with<br />

the disclosure requirements of the Hong Kong Companies Ordinance.<br />

EMPHASIS OF MATTER<br />

Without qualifying our opinion, we draw your attention to note 2(b) to the consolidated financial statements which<br />

describes that the Group had net current liabilities of approximately USD220,761,000 as at 31 December 2015<br />

and made a loss of USD187,713,000 for the year then ended. These conditions, along with other matters set forth<br />

in note 2(b), indicate the existence of material uncertainties which may cast significant doubt about the Group’s<br />

ability to continue as a going concern.<br />

The consolidated financial statements have been prepared on a going concern basis, the validity of which is<br />

dependent on the availability of the ongoing financial support from the Group’s bankers, lenders, creditors and<br />

shareholders to enable the Group to operate as a going concern and meet its financial liabilities as they fall due<br />

for the foreseeable future. The consolidated financial statements do not include any adjustments that would result<br />

should the Group be unable to continue to operate as a going concern.<br />

KPMG<br />

Certified Public Accountants<br />

8th Floor, Prince’s Building<br />

10 Chater Road<br />

Central, Hong Kong<br />

24 March 2016<br />

108<br />

Annual Report 2015


Consolidated Statement of Profit or Loss<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Revenue 4 99,485 328,307<br />

Cost of revenue 5 (165,604) (335,510)<br />

Gross loss (66,119) (7,203)<br />

Other revenue 848 3,319<br />

Other net (loss)/income (1,082) 34,171<br />

Selling and distribution costs 6(c) (8,589) (56,445)<br />

General and administrative expenses (30,520) (30,916)<br />

Impairment loss 6(c) — (190,000)<br />

Loss from operations (105,462) (247,074)<br />

Finance income 6(a) 5,084 3,911<br />

Finance costs 6(a) (104,106) (98,431)<br />

Net finance costs 6(a) (99,022) (94,520)<br />

Share of losses of associates (15) (19)<br />

Share of losses of joint venture (87) (70)<br />

Loss before taxation 6 (204,586) (341,683)<br />

Income tax 7 16,873 58,978<br />

Loss for the year (187,713) (282,705)<br />

Attributable to:<br />

Equity shareholders of the Company (187,763) (282,837)<br />

Non-controlling interests 50 132<br />

Loss for the year (187,713) (282,705)<br />

Basic loss per share 8 (2.03) cents (5.95) cents<br />

Diluted loss per share 8 (2.03) cents (5.95) cents<br />

The notes on pages 116 to 196 form part of these financial statements. Details of dividends payable to equity<br />

shareholders of the company attributable to the profit for the year are set out in Note 29(b).<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

109


Consolidated Statement of Profit or Loss and Other Comprehensive Income<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Loss for the year (187,713) (282,705)<br />

Other comprehensive income for the year<br />

(after reclassification adjustments) 11<br />

Items that may be reclassified subsequently to profit or loss:<br />

Exchange differences on re-translation (22,632) (80,512)<br />

Total comprehensive income for the year (210,345) (363,217)<br />

Attributable to:<br />

Equity shareholders of the Company (210,395) (363,349)<br />

Non-controlling interests 50 132<br />

Total comprehensive income for the year (210,345) (363,217)<br />

The notes on pages 116 to 196 form part of these financial statements.<br />

110<br />

Annual Report 2015


Consolidated Statement of Financial Position<br />

At 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Non-current assets<br />

Property, plant and equipment, net 13 540,714 594,926<br />

Construction in progress 14 55,164 58,421<br />

Lease prepayments 15 68 73<br />

Intangible assets 16 510,380 511,089<br />

Interest in associates 18 45 63<br />

Interest in joint venture 95 15<br />

Other non-current assets 19 50,582 25,823<br />

Deferred tax assets 25(b) 46,629 37,968<br />

Total non-current assets 1,203,677 1,228,378<br />

Current assets<br />

Assets held for sale 55 484<br />

Inventories 20 45,829 48,900<br />

Trade and other receivables 21 93,857 152,207<br />

Cash and cash equivalents 22 50,702 252,856<br />

Total current assets 190,443 454,447<br />

Current liabilities<br />

Short-term borrowings and current portion of<br />

long-term borrowings 23(b) 197,631 114,818<br />

Trade and other payables 24 213,429 298,118<br />

Current taxation 25(a) 144 68<br />

Obligations under finance leases — 8<br />

Total current liabilities 411,204 413,012<br />

Net current (liabilities)/assets (220,761) 41,435<br />

Total assets less current liabilities 982,916 1,269,813<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

111


Consolidated Statement of Financial Position<br />

At 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Non-current liabilities<br />

Long-term borrowings, less current portion 23(a) — 161,978<br />

Senior notes 26 597,634 595,906<br />

Provisions 28 13,567 12,995<br />

Deferred tax liabilities 25(b) 102,483 101,640<br />

Other non-current liabilities 79,441 456<br />

Total non-current liabilities 793,125 872,975<br />

NET ASSETS 189,791 396,838<br />

CAPITAL AND RESERVES<br />

Share capital 29(d) 92,626 92,626<br />

Reserves 96,823 303,920<br />

Total equity attributable to<br />

equity shareholders of the Company 189,449 396,546<br />

Non-controlling interests 342 292<br />

TOTAL EQUITY 189,791 396,838<br />

Approved and authorised for issue by the board of directors on 24 March 2016.<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts<br />

Chairman<br />

Battsengel Gotov<br />

Chief Executive Officer<br />

The notes on pages 116 to 196 form part of these financial statements.<br />

112<br />

Annual Report 2015


Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

Attributable to equity shareholders of the Company<br />

Retained<br />

Share<br />

capital<br />

Share<br />

premium<br />

Other<br />

reserve<br />

Exchange<br />

reserve<br />

earnings/<br />

(accumulated<br />

losses) Total<br />

Noncontrolling<br />

interest Total equity<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Note (Note 29<br />

(c))<br />

(Note 29(e)<br />

(i))<br />

(Note 29(e)<br />

(ii))<br />

(Note 29(e)<br />

(iii))<br />

At 1 January 2014 37,050 608,650 27,050 (231,650) 119,867 560,967 — 560,967<br />

Changes in equity for 2014:<br />

Loss for the year — — — — (282,837) (282,837) 132 (282,705)<br />

Other comprehensive income — — — (80,512) — (80,512) — (80,512)<br />

Total comprehensive income — — — (80,512) (282,837) (363,349) 132 (363,217)<br />

Issuance of shares under rights issue 55,576 139,877 — — — 195,453 — 195,453<br />

Contribution from non-controlling interests — — — — — — 160 160<br />

Equity-settled share-based transactions 27 — — 3,475 — — 3,475 — 3,475<br />

Appropriation to statutory surplus reserve — — 14 — (14) — — —<br />

At 31 December 2014 92,626 748,527 30,539 (312,162) (162,984) 396,546 292 396,838<br />

At 1 January 2015 92,626 748,527 30,539 (312,162) (162,984) 396,546 292 396,838<br />

Changes in equity for 2015:<br />

Loss for the year — — — — (187,763) (187,763) — (187,763)<br />

Other comprehensive income — — — (22,632) — (22,632) — (22,632)<br />

Total comprehensive income — — — (22,632) (187,763) (210,395) — (210,395)<br />

Issuance of shares under rights issue — — — — — — — —<br />

Contribution from non-controlling interests — — — — — — 50 50<br />

Equity-settled share-based transactions 27 — — 3,298 — — 3,298 — 3,298<br />

Appropriation to statutory surplus reserve — — — — — — — —<br />

At 31 December 2015 92,626 748,527 33,837 (334,794) (350,747) 189,449 342 189,791<br />

The notes on pages 116 to 196 form part of these financial statements.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

113


Consolidated Cash Flow Statement<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Cash flows from operating activities<br />

Loss before taxation (204,586) (341,683)<br />

Adjustments for:<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 6(c) 39,179 46,145<br />

Impairment loss on trade and other receivables 6(c) 8,512 8,806<br />

Impairment loss on non-financial assets 6(c) — 190,000<br />

Provision losses on coal inventories 6,122 —<br />

Share of losses of associates and joint venture 102 89<br />

Gain on disposal of property, plant and equipment<br />

and assets held for sale 6(c) (62) (36,881)<br />

Net finance costs 6(a) 99,022 94,520<br />

Equity-settled share-based payment expenses 6(b) 3,298 3,475<br />

Employee benefit accrued 520 59<br />

Changes in working capital:<br />

(Increase)/decrease in inventories (7,562) 42,061<br />

Decrease in trade and other receivables 42,298 10,427<br />

(Decrease)/increase in trade and other payables (50,893) 48,195<br />

Decrease/(increase) in other non-current assets<br />

and other non-current liabilities 50,270 (23,865)<br />

Cash (used in)/generated from operations (13,780) 41,348<br />

Income tax paid 25(a) (404) (175)<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from operating activities (14,184) 41,173<br />

Investing activities<br />

Payments for acquisition of property, plant and equipment<br />

and construction in progress (42,459) (67,465)<br />

Proceeds from disposal of property, plant and equipment and<br />

assets held for sale 884 92,664<br />

Payment for acquisition of an associate, net of cash acquired (84) (107)<br />

Interest received 5,423 690<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from investing activities (36,236) 25,782<br />

114<br />

Annual Report 2015


Consolidated Cash Flow Statement<br />

For the year ended 31 December 2015<br />

(Expressed in United States dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Financing activities<br />

Proceeds from issue of shares — 195,453<br />

Proceeds from borrowings 15,000 146,200<br />

Repayment of borrowings (96,818) (163,818)<br />

Interest paid (69,891) (68,471)<br />

Contributions from non-controlling interest — 160<br />

Net cash (used in)/generated from financing activities (151,709) 109,524<br />

Net (decrease)/increase in cash and cash equivalents (202,129) 176,479<br />

Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of the year 202,856 26,535<br />

Effect of foreign exchange rate changes (25) (158)<br />

Cash and cash equivalents at end of the year 22 702 202,856<br />

The notes on pages 116 to 196 form part of these financial statements.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

115


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

1 CORPORATE INFORMATION<br />

Mongolian Mining Corporation (“the Company”) was incorporated in the Cayman Islands on 18 May<br />

2010 as an exempted company with limited liability under the Companies Law, Cap 22 (Law 3 of 1961, as<br />

consolidated and revised) of the Cayman Islands. The Company and its subsidiaries (together referred to as<br />

“the Group”) are principally engaged in the mining, processing, transportation and sale of coal.<br />

Pursuant to a group reorganisation completed on 17 September 2010 (the “Reorganisation”) to rationalise<br />

the group structure for the public listing of the Company’s shares on the Main Board of The Stock Exchange<br />

of Hong Kong Limited (the “Stock Exchange”), the Company’s shares were listed on the Stock Exchange<br />

on 13 October 2010. Details of the Reorganisation are set out in the prospectus of the Company dated 28<br />

September 2010.<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES<br />

(a)<br />

Statement of compliance<br />

These financial statements have been prepared in accordance with all applicable International Financial<br />

Reporting Standards (“IFRSs”), promulgated by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”).<br />

IFRSs include all applicable individual International Financial Reporting Standards, International<br />

Accounting Standards (“IASs”) and related interpretations. These financial statements also comply<br />

with the applicable disclosure requirements of the Hong Kong Companies Ordinance. These financial<br />

statements also comply with the applicable disclosure provisions of the Rules Governing the Listing<br />

of Securities on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited. A summary of the significant accounting<br />

policies adopted by the Group is set out below.<br />

The IASB has issued certain new and revised IFRSs that are first effective or available for early adoption<br />

for the current accounting period of the Group and the Company. Note 2(c) provides information on<br />

any changes in accounting policies resulting from initial application of these developments to the extent<br />

that they are relevant to the Group for the current and prior accounting periods reflected in these<br />

financial statements.<br />

(b)<br />

Basis of preparation of the financial statements<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Group had net current liabilities of approximately USD220,761,000 and<br />

made a loss of USD187,713,000 for the year then ended. The Group is in the process of requesting<br />

waivers, consents and extensions of its borrowings as part of its potential restructuring of the Notes (see<br />

below for definition and more details). These conditions indicate the existing of material uncertainties<br />

which may cast significant doubt about the Group’s ability to continue as a going concern.<br />

In view of such circumstances, the Directors have given careful consideration to the future liquidity<br />

and performance of the Group and its available resources of financing in evaluating whether the going<br />

concern basis in preparing the consolidated financial statements is appropriate. The Directors have<br />

reviewed trading and cash flow forecasts which take into consideration the uncertainties in the current<br />

operating environment. The Directors have concluded that there are material uncertainties surrounding<br />

going concern as below:<br />

116<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Basis of preparation of the financial statements (Continued)<br />

– Future trading may not be in line with the assumption in the Group’s latest forecasts, the<br />

achievability of which is dependent upon the current economic environment and the price of<br />

coking coal market;<br />

– The Group is due to redeem the senior notes (the “Notes”) issued by the Company with a<br />

principal amount of USD600,000,000 on 29 March 2017 (see Note 26). As announced by<br />

the Company on 26 January 2016, 14 March 2016 and 23 March 2016, the Group has been<br />

actively seeking for the potential restructuring of the Notes (the “Notes Restructuring”) with<br />

the holders of the Notes (the “Holders”). Management maintains regular discussions with the<br />

appointed restructuring advisers, the legal advisers, the financial advisers and the Holders. These<br />

discussions remain constructive, and considering the commercial basis of this restructuring, the<br />

Directors have no reason to believe that the restructuring will not be achieved after formulating<br />

and agreeing a detailed plan protecting the interests of all stakeholders of the Group in this<br />

regard;<br />

– The Group is due to repay the secured interest-bearing borrowings from BNP Paribas, Singapore<br />

Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited (collectively, the “Lenders”) (the<br />

“Facility”) with a principal amount of USD93,000,000 within the year ending 31 December 2016<br />

(see Note 23). Management has initiated discussions with the Lenders for revised terms of the<br />

debt facility. Given the material amount of the Facility and also existing Intercreditors Agreement<br />

between Lenders and Holders in relation to the shared securities and guarantees, the discussions<br />

to revise the Facility are undertaken in connection with the Notes Restructuring. The Directors<br />

continue to maintain regular discussion with the Lenders and to seek for constructive resolutions;<br />

– The Group is due to repay the secured interest-bearing borrowings from European Bank<br />

for Reconstruction and Development, Nederlandse Financierings-Maatschappij voor<br />

Ontwikkelingslanden N.V., and Deutsche Investitions-und Entwicklungsgesellschaft mbH<br />

(the “Parallel Lenders”) with a principal amount of USD51,818,000 within the year ending<br />

31 December 2016 (see Note 23). On 11 March 2016, the Group had entered into Deed of<br />

Termination and Release (the “DTR”) with the Parallel Lenders. Pursuant to the DTR, the Group<br />

shall endorse to the Parallel Lenders certain promissory notes issued by GoM (see Note 36(a))<br />

with an amount totalling approximately MNT105.6 billion, the obligations under the borrowings<br />

will be discharged in their entirety and the relevant security thereunder will be released after 121<br />

calendar days plus 2 business days from the signing of the DTR. The Group had completed the<br />

endorsement of promissory notes as required by the DTR as of the date of these consolidated<br />

financial statements;<br />

– The Group is due to repay promissory notes of USD72,000,000 to QGX Holding Ltd. (“QGX”)<br />

on 31 March 2016 (see Note 24(iv)). Throughout year ended 31 December 2015, extension of<br />

the outstanding promissory note payables had been granted by QGX on a quarterly basis. The<br />

Directors are seeking to extend such support from QGX into upcoming future in a contractual<br />

form. With full awareness of the Notes Restructuring, the reaching of such contract is on the<br />

condition of the achievability of the restructuring of the Notes, and meanwhile, the Directors<br />

continue to maintain regular and constructive discussions with QGX.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

117


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Basis of preparation of the financial statements (Continued)<br />

The Directors consider that, among all the above-mentioned matters and conditions, the key<br />

determining factor lies with the Notes Restructuring and it is the material uncertainty in the going<br />

concern assumption.<br />

Based on the Group’s business plan and cash flow forecast, and assuming having the ongoing support<br />

from its bankers, lenders, creditors and shareholders, the Director expect to have sufficient financial<br />

resources to cover its operating costs and to meet its financing commitments. The Directors have<br />

identified a number of management initiatives that the business could pursue and which they are<br />

confident these can be achieved to mitigate the liquidity and solvency pressure including:<br />

– The Group had updated the service agreement with the mining contractor by taking decreased<br />

charge rates; such cost saving effect is expected to be revealed during year ending 31 December<br />

2016 and thereafter;<br />

– The Group manages capital expenditure to minimum levels;<br />

– Even the progress is not as rapid as originally envisaged, The Group remains focused on<br />

pursuing the opportunity to engage in coal mining, processing, transportation and exploration<br />

activities at Tavan Tolgoi coal deposit in Mongolia. The ultimate benefit is expected from the<br />

significant improvement of the competitive position of Mongolian coal in international markets<br />

by consolidating commercial operations within the Tavan Tolgoi coalfield under public private<br />

partnership (“PPP”) model;<br />

– The Group is seeking prepayments at reaching new coal off-take agreements, and negotiating<br />

business terms with suppliers to ease cash flow demands.<br />

Given expectation of having ongoing financial support from its bankers, lenders, creditors and<br />

shareholders, the Directors are satisfied that the Group will be able to meet its financial obligations as<br />

and when they fall due for the twelve months from 31 December 2015. Accordingly, the Directors are<br />

of the opinion that it is appropriate to prepare the consolidated financial statements on a going concern<br />

basis. The consolidated financial statements do not include any adjustments that would result from the<br />

going concern basis of preparation being inappropriate.<br />

The consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2015 comprise the Company<br />

and its subsidiaries (together referred to as “the Group”) and the Group’s interest in associates and a<br />

joint venture.<br />

118<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Basis of preparation of the financial statements (Continued)<br />

The measurement basis used in the preparation of the financial statements is the historical cost<br />

basis except that the following assets and liabilities are stated at their fair value as explained in the<br />

accounting policies set out below:<br />

– Financial instruments classified as available-for-sale or as trading securities (see Note 2(f));<br />

– Derivative financial instruments (see Note 2(g)).<br />

Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale are stated at the lower of carrying amount and<br />

fair value less costs to see (see Note 2(x)).<br />

The preparation of financial statements in conformity with IFRSs requires management to make<br />

judgements, estimates and assumptions that affect the application of policies and reported amounts<br />

of assets, liabilities, income and expenses. The estimates and associated assumptions are based<br />

on historical experience and various other factors that are believed to be reasonable under the<br />

circumstances, the results of which form the basis of making the judgements about carrying values of<br />

assets and liabilities that are not readily apparent from other sources. Actual results may differ from<br />

these estimates.<br />

The estimates and underlying assumptions are reviewed on an ongoing basis. Revisions to accounting<br />

estimates are recognised in the period in which the estimate is revised if the revision affects only that<br />

period, or in the period of the revision and future periods if the revision affects both current and future<br />

periods.<br />

Judgements made by management in the application of IFRSs that have significant effect on the<br />

financial statements and major sources of estimation uncertainty are discussed in Note 3.<br />

(c)<br />

Changes in accounting policies<br />

The IASB has issued a number of new IFRSs and amendments to IFRSs that are first effective for the<br />

current accounting period of the Group and the Company. Of these, the following developments are<br />

relevant to the Group’s financial statements:<br />

• Annual Improvements to IFRSs 2010-2012 Cycle<br />

• Annual Improvements to IFRSs 2011-2013 Cycle<br />

The Group has not applied any new standard or interpretation that is not yet effective for the current<br />

accounting period. Impacts of the adoption of the amended IFRSs are discussed below:<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

119


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Changes in accounting policies (Continued)<br />

Annual Improvements to IFRSs 2010-2012 Cycle and 2011-2013 Cycle<br />

These two cycles of annual improvements contain amendments to nine standards with consequential<br />

amendments to other standards. Among them, IAS 24, Related party disclosures has been amended<br />

to expand the definition of a “related party” to include a management entity that provides key<br />

management personnel services to the reporting entity, and to require the disclosure of the amounts<br />

incurred for obtaining the key management personnel services provided by the management entity.<br />

These amendments do not have an impact on the Group’s related party disclosures as the Group does<br />

not obtain key management personnel services from management entities.<br />

(d)<br />

Subsidiaries and non-controlling interests<br />

Subsidiaries are entities controlled by the Group. The Group controls an entity when it is exposed,<br />

or has rights, to variable returns from its involvement with the entity and has the ability to affect<br />

those returns through its power over the entity. When assessing whether the Group has power, only<br />

substantive rights (held by the Group and other parties) are considered.<br />

An investment in a subsidiary is consolidated into the consolidated financial statements from the date<br />

that control commences until the date that control ceases. Intra-group balances, transactions and cash<br />

flows and any unrealised profits arising from intra-group transactions are eliminated in full in preparing<br />

the consolidated financial statements. Unrealised losses resulting from intra-group transactions are<br />

eliminated in the same way as unrealised gains but only to the extent that there is no evidence of<br />

impairment.<br />

Non-controlling interests represent the equity in a subsidiary not attributable directly or indirectly to the<br />

Company, and in respect of which the Group has not agreed any additional terms with the holders of<br />

those interests which would result in the Group as a whole having a contractual obligation in respect<br />

of those interests that meets the definition of a financial liability. For each business combination, the<br />

Group can elect to measure any non-controlling interests either at fair value or at the non-controlling<br />

interests’ proportionate share of the subsidiary’s net identifiable assets.<br />

Non-controlling interests are presented in the consolidated statement of financial position within equity,<br />

separately from equity attributable to the equity shareholders of the Company. Non-controlling interests<br />

in the results of the Group are presented on the face of the consolidated statement of profit or loss<br />

and the consolidated statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income as an allocation of<br />

the total profit or loss and total comprehensive income for the year between non-controlling interests<br />

and the equity shareholders of the Company. Loans from holders of non-controlling interests and other<br />

contractual obligations towards these holders are presented as financial liabilities in the consolidated<br />

balance sheet in accordance with Notes 2(n) or (o) depending on the nature of the liability.<br />

Changes in the Group’s interests in a subsidiary that do not result in a loss of control are accounted<br />

for as equity transactions, whereby adjustments are made to the amounts of controlling and noncontrolling<br />

interests within consolidated equity to reflect the change in relative interests, but no<br />

adjustments are made to goodwill and no gain or loss is recognised.<br />

120<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(d)<br />

Subsidiaries and non-controlling interests (Continued)<br />

When the Group loses control of a subsidiary, it is accounted for as a disposal of the entire interest<br />

in that subsidiary, with a resulting gain or loss being recognised in profit or loss. Any interest retained<br />

in that former subsidiary at the date when control is lost is recognised at fair value and this amount is<br />

regarded as the fair value on initial recognition of a financial asset or, when appropriate, the cost on<br />

initial recognition of an interest in an associate (see Note 2(e)) or joint venture.<br />

In the Company’s statement of financial position, an investment in a subsidiary is stated at cost less<br />

impairment losses (see Note 2(k)), unless the investment is classified as held for sale (or included in a<br />

disposal group that is classified as held for sale) (see Note 2(x)).<br />

(e)<br />

Associates and joint ventures<br />

An associate is an entity in which the Group or Company has significant influence, but not control<br />

or joint control, over its management, including participation in the financial and operating policy<br />

decisions.<br />

A joint venture is an arrangement whereby the Group and other parties contractually agree to share<br />

control of the arrangement, and have rights to the net assets of the arrangement.<br />

An investment in an associate or a joint venture is accounted for in the consolidated financial<br />

statements under the equity method, unless it is classified as held for sale (or included in a disposal<br />

group that is classified as held for sale (see Note 2(x)). Under the equity method, the investment is<br />

initially recorded at cost, adjusted for any excess of the Group’s share of the acquisition-date fair<br />

values of investee’s identifiable net assets over the cost of the investment (if any). Thereafter, the<br />

investment is adjusted for the post acquisition change in the Group’s share of the investee’s net assets<br />

and any impairment loss relating to the investment (see Note 2(k)). Any acquisition-date excess over<br />

cost, the Group’s share of the post-acquisition, post-tax results of the investees and any impairment<br />

losses for the year are recognised in the consolidated statement of profit or loss, whereas the<br />

Group’s share of the post-acquisition post-tax items of the investees’ other comprehensive income is<br />

recognised in other comprehensive income in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income.<br />

When the Group’s share of losses exceeds its interest in the associate or the joint venture, the Group’s<br />

interest is reduced to nil and recognition of further losses is discontinued except to the extent that the<br />

Group has incurred legal or constructive obligations or made payments on behalf of the investee. For<br />

this purpose, the Group’s interest is the carrying amount of the investment under the equity method<br />

together with the Group’s long-term interests that in substance form part of the Group’s net investment<br />

in the associate or the joint venture.<br />

Unrealised profits and losses resulting from transactions between the Group and its associates<br />

and joint venture are eliminated to the extent of the Group’s interest in the investee, except where<br />

unrealised losses provide evidence of an impairment of the asset transferred, in which case they are<br />

recognised immediately in profit or loss.<br />

If an investment in an associate becomes an investment in a joint venture or vice versa, retained<br />

interest is not remeasured. Instead, the investment continues to be accounted for under the equity<br />

method.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

121


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(e)<br />

Associates and joint ventures (Continued)<br />

In all other cases when the Group ceases to have significant influence over an associate or joint control<br />

over a joint venture, it is accounted for as a disposal of the entire interest in that investee, with a<br />

resulting gain or loss being recognised in profit or loss. Any interest retained in that former investee at<br />

the date when significant influence or joint control is lost is recognised at fair value and this amount is<br />

regarded as the fair value on initial recognition of a financial asset (see Note 2(f)).<br />

(f)<br />

Other investments in debt and equity securities<br />

The Group’s and the Company’s policies for investments in debt and equity securities, other than<br />

investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures, are as follows:<br />

Investments in debt and equity securities are initially stated at fair value, which is their transaction price<br />

unless it is determined that the fair value at initial recognition differs from the transaction price and<br />

that fair value is evidenced by a quoted price in an active market for an identical asset or liability or<br />

based on a valuation technique that uses only data from observable markets. Cost includes attributable<br />

transaction costs, except where indicated otherwise below. These investments are subsequently<br />

accounted for as follows, depending on their classification.<br />

Investments in securities which do not fall into categories of investments in securities held for<br />

trading neither dated debt securities are classified as available-for-sale securities. At the end of each<br />

reporting period the fair value is remeasured, with any resultant gain or loss being recognised in other<br />

comprehensive income and accumulated separately in equity in the fair value reserve. As an exception<br />

to this, investments in equity securities that do not have a quoted price in an active market for an<br />

identical instrument and whose fair value cannot otherwise be reliably measured are recognised in the<br />

statement of financial position as cost less impairment losses (see note 2(k)).<br />

When the investments are derecognised or impaired (see note 2(k)), the cumulative gain or loss<br />

recognised in equity is reclassified to profit or loss. Investments are recognised/derecognised on the<br />

date the Group commits to purchase/sell the investments or they expire.<br />

(g)<br />

Derivative financial instruments<br />

Derivative financial instruments are recognised initially at fair value. At the end of each reporting period<br />

the fair value is remeasured. The gain or loss on remeasurement to fair value is recognised immediately<br />

in profit or loss.<br />

122<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(h)<br />

Property, plant and equipment<br />

Property, plant and equipment, which consist of buildings, plant and equipment, motor vehicles,<br />

office equipment, mining properties are stated at cost less accumulated depreciation and impairment<br />

losses (see Note 2(k)). The cost of an asset comprises its purchase price, any directly attributable<br />

costs of bringing the asset to its present working condition and location for its intended use, the<br />

cost of borrowed funds used during the period of construction and, when relevant, the costs of<br />

dismantling and removing the items and restoring the site on which they are located, and changes in<br />

the measurement of existing liabilities recognised for these costs resulting from changes in the timing<br />

or outflow of resources required to settle the obligation or from changes in the discount rate.<br />

The Group recognises in the carrying amount of an item of property, plant and equipment the cost<br />

of replacing part of such an item when that cost is incurred if it is probable that the future economic<br />

benefits embodied with the item will flow to the Group and the cost of the item can be measured<br />

reliably. All other cost is recognised as an expense in profit or loss in the period in which it is incurred.<br />

In open pit mining operations, the removal of overburden and waste materials, referred to as stripping,<br />

is required to obtain access to the ore body. Stripping costs incurred during the development phase<br />

of a mine are capitalised as stripping activity asset forming part of the cost of constructing the mining<br />

properties.<br />

Stripping costs incurred during the production phase of a surface mine are variable production costs<br />

that are included in the costs of inventory produced during the period that the stripping costs are<br />

incurred (Note 2(l)), unless the stripping activity can be shown to give rise to probably future economic<br />

benefits from the mineral property by improving the access to the ore body, the component of the ore<br />

body for which assess has been improved is identifiable and the costs associated with that component<br />

can be reliably measured, in which case the stripping costs would be capitalised as stripping activity<br />

asset included in property, plant and equipment – mining properties.<br />

All other expenditures, including the cost of repairs and maintenance and major overhaul, are expensed<br />

as they are incurred.<br />

Construction in progress represents property, plant and equipment under construction and equipment<br />

pending installation, and is initially recognised at cost less impairment losses (Note 2(k)). Cost<br />

comprises cost of materials, direct labour and an appropriate proportion of production overheads and<br />

borrowing costs (Note 2(w)). Capitalisation of these costs ceases and the construction in progress is<br />

transferred to property, plant and equipment when the asset is substantially ready for its intended use.<br />

No depreciation is provided in respect of construction in progress until it is completed and substantially<br />

ready for its intended use.<br />

Gains or losses arising from the retirement or disposal of an item of property, plant and equipment are<br />

determined as the difference between the net disposal proceeds and the carrying amount of the item<br />

and are recognised in profit or loss on the date of retirement or disposal.<br />

Depreciation is calculated to write off the cost of items of property, plant and equipment, other than<br />

mining properties, over their estimated useful lives using the straight-line method, after taking into<br />

account the estimated residual values.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

123


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(h)<br />

Property, plant and equipment (Continued)<br />

The estimated useful lives of property, plant and equipment are as follows:<br />

Depreciable<br />

life<br />

– Buildings and plants 10 - 40 years<br />

– Machinery and equipment 10 years<br />

– Motor vehicles 5 - 10 years<br />

– Office equipment 3 - 10 years<br />

Mining properties, except for stripping activity assets related to capitalised stripping costs incurred<br />

during the production phase, are depreciated on the units-of-production method utilising only proven<br />

and probable coal reserves in the depletion base.<br />

Stripping activity assets related to stripping costs incurred during the production phase are depreciated<br />

using a units-of-production basis over the proven and probable coal reserves of the component to<br />

which they relate.<br />

No depreciation is provided in respect of construction in progress until it is substantially completed and<br />

ready for its intended use.<br />

Where parts of an item of property, plant and equipment have different useful lives, the cost of the item<br />

is allocated on a reasonable basis between parts and each part is depreciated separately. Both the<br />

useful life of an asset and its residual value, if any, are reviewed annually.<br />

(i)<br />

Intangible assets<br />

Intangible assets (acquired mining rights and softwares) acquired separately are measured on initial<br />

recognition at cost. The cost of intangible assets acquired in a business combination is their fair value<br />

as at the date of acquisition. Following the initial recognition, intangible assets are stated at cost less<br />

accumulated amortisation (where the estimated useful life is finite) and impairment losses (see Note<br />

2(k)).<br />

Intangible assets (acquired mining rights) are depreciated on the units-of-production method utilising<br />

only proven and probable coal reserves in the depletion base.<br />

Amortisation of other intangible assets with finite useful lives is recognised in profit or loss on a<br />

straight-line basis over the expected useful lives. The softwares are amortised over 10 years from the<br />

date they are available for use.<br />

Both the period and method of amortisation are reviewed annually.<br />

124<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(j)<br />

Leased assets<br />

An arrangement, comprising a transaction or a series of transactions, is or contains a lease if the<br />

Group determines that the arrangement conveys a right to use a specific asset or assets for an agreed<br />

period of time in return for a payment or a series of payments. Such a determination is made based on<br />

an evaluation of the substance of the arrangement and is regardless of whether the arrangement takes<br />

the legal form of a lease.<br />

(i)<br />

Classification of assets leased to the Group<br />

Assets that are held by the Group under leases which transfer to the Group substantially all the<br />

risks and rewards of ownership are classified as being held under finance leases. Leases which<br />

do not transfer substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership to the Group are classified as<br />

operating leases.<br />

(ii)<br />

Assets acquired under finance leases<br />

Where the Group acquires the use of assets under finance leases, the amounts representing the<br />

fair value of the leased asset, or, if lower, the present value of the minimum lease payments, of<br />

such assets are included in property, plant and equipment and the corresponding liabilities, net<br />

of finance charges, are recorded as obligations under finance leases. Depreciation is provided<br />

at rates which write off the cost or valuation of the assets over the term of the relevant lease or,<br />

where it is likely the Group will obtain ownership of the asset, the life of the asset, as set out<br />

in note 2(h). Impairment losses are accounted for in accordance with the accounting policy as<br />

set out in Note 2(k). Finance charges implicit in the lease payments are charged to profit or loss<br />

over the period of the leases so as to produce an approximately constant periodic rate of charge<br />

on the remaining balance of the obligations for each accounting period. Contingent rentals are<br />

charged to profit or loss in the accounting period in which they are incurred.<br />

(iii) Operating lease charges<br />

Where the Group has the use of assets held under operating leases, payments made under the<br />

leases are charged to profit or loss in equal instalments over the accounting periods covered by<br />

the lease term, except where an alternative basis is more representative of the pattern of benefits<br />

to be derived from the leased asset. Lease incentives received are recognised in profit or loss as<br />

an integral part of the aggregate net lease payments made. Contingent rentals are charged to<br />

profit or loss in the accounting period in which they are incurred.<br />

(iv) Lease prepayments<br />

Lease prepayments represent the costs of acquiring the land use rights. Land use rights<br />

are carried at cost less accumulated amortisation and impairment losses (see Note 2(k) (ii)).<br />

Amortisation is charged to profit or loss on a straight-line basis over the period of the land use<br />

rights.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

125


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(k)<br />

Impairment of assets<br />

(i)<br />

Impairment of investment in debt and equity securities and other receivables<br />

Investment in debt and equity securities and other current and non-current receivables that are<br />

stated at cost or amortised cost or are classified as available-for-sale securities are reviewed at<br />

the end of each reporting period to determine whether there is objective evidence of impairment.<br />

Objective evidence of impairment includes observable data that comes to the attention of the<br />

Group about one or more of the following loss events:<br />

– significant financial difficulty of the debtor;<br />

– a breach of contract, such as a default or delinquency in interest or principal payments;<br />

– it becoming probable that the debtor will enter bankruptcy or other financial reorganisation;<br />

– significant changes in the technological, market, economic or legal environment that have an<br />

adverse effect on the debtor; and<br />

– a significant or prolonged decline in the fair value of an investment in an equity instrument<br />

below its cost.<br />

If any such evidence exists, any impairment loss is determined and recognised as follows:<br />

– For investments in associate and joint ventures accounted for under the equity method in<br />

the consolidated financial statements (see Note 2(e)), the impairment loss is measured by<br />

comparing the recoverable amount of the investment with its carrying amount in accordance<br />

with Note 2(k) (ii). The impairment loss is reversed if there has been a favourable change in<br />

the estimates used to determine the recoverable amount in accordance with Note 2(k) (ii).<br />

– For trade and other current receivables carried at amortised cost, the impairment loss is<br />

measured as the difference between the asset’s carrying amount and the present value of<br />

estimated future cash flows, discounted at the financial asset’s original effective interest<br />

rate (i.e. the effective interest rate computed at initial recognition of these assets), where the<br />

effect of discounting is material. This assessment is made collectively where these financial<br />

assets share similar risk characteristics, such as similar past due status, and have not been<br />

individually assessed as impaired. Future cash flows for financial assets which are assessed<br />

for impairment collectively are based on historical loss experience for assets with credit risk<br />

characteristics similar to the collective group.<br />

If in a subsequent period the amount of an impairment loss decreases and the decrease can<br />

be linked objectively to an event occurring after the impairment loss was recognised, the<br />

impairment loss is reversed through profit or loss. A reversal of an impairment loss shall not<br />

result in the asset’s carrying amount exceeding that which would have been determined had<br />

no impairment loss been recognised in prior years.<br />

126<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(k)<br />

Impairment of assets (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Impairment of investment in debt and equity securities and other receivables (Continued)<br />

– For available-for-sale securities, the cumulative loss that has been recognised in the fair<br />

value reserve is reclassified to profit or loss. The amount of the cumulative loss that is<br />

recognised in profit or loss is the difference between the acquisition cost (net of any principal<br />

repayment and amortisation) and current fair value, less any impairment loss on that asset<br />

previously recognised in profit or loss.<br />

Impairment losses recognised in profit or loss in respect of available-for-sale equity<br />

securities are not reversed through profit or loss. Any subsequent increase in the fair value<br />

of such assets is recognised in other comprehensive income.<br />

Impairment losses are written off against the corresponding assets directly, except for impairment<br />

losses recognised in respect of trade and other receivables, whose recovery is considered<br />

doubtful but not remote. In this case, the impairment losses for doubtful debts are recorded<br />

using an allowance account. When the Group is satisfied that recovery is remote, the amount<br />

considered irrecoverable is written off against trade and other receivables directly and any<br />

amounts held in the allowance account relating to that debt are reversed. Subsequent recoveries<br />

of amounts previously charged to the allowance account are reversed against the allowance<br />

account. Other changes in the allowance account and subsequent recoveries of amounts<br />

previously written off directly are recognised in profit or loss.<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of other assets<br />

Internal and external sources of information are reviewed at the end of each reporting period to<br />

identify indications that the following assets may be impaired or an impairment loss previously<br />

recognised no longer exists or may have decreased:<br />

– property, plant and equipment;<br />

– construction in progress;<br />

– lease prepayments;<br />

– intangible assets;<br />

– other non-current assets (excluding receivables); and<br />

– investment in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures in the Company’s statement of<br />

financial position.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

127


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(k)<br />

Impairment of assets (Continued)<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of other assets (Continued)<br />

If any such indication exists, the asset’s recoverable amount is estimated.<br />

– Calculation of recoverable amount<br />

The recoverable amount of an asset is the greater of its fair value less costs of disposal and<br />

value in use. In assessing value in use, the estimated future cash flows are discounted to<br />

their present value using a pre-tax discount rate that reflects current market assessments of<br />

time value of money and the risks specific to the asset. Where an asset does not generate<br />

cash inflows largely independent of those from other assets, the recoverable amount is<br />

determined for the smallest group of assets that generates cash inflows independently (i.e. a<br />

cash-generating unit).<br />

– Recognition of impairment losses<br />

An impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss whenever the carrying amount of an asset,<br />

or the cash-generating unit to which it belongs, exceeds its recoverable amount. Impairment<br />

losses recognised in respect of cash-generating units are allocated to reduce the carrying<br />

amount of the assets in the cash-generating unit (or group of units) on a pro rata basis,<br />

except that the carrying value of an asset will not be reduced below its individual fair value<br />

less costs of disposal (if measurable), or value in use (if determinable).<br />

– Reversals of impairment losses<br />

An impairment loss is reversed if there has been a favourable change in the estimates used<br />

to determine the recoverable amount.<br />

A reversal of an impairment loss is limited to the asset’s carrying amount that would<br />

have been determined had no impairment loss been recognised in prior years. Reversals<br />

of impairment losses are credited to profit or loss for the year in which the reversals are<br />

recognised.<br />

(iii) Interim financial reporting and impairment<br />

Under the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong (the<br />

“Listing Rules”), the Group is required to prepare an interim financial report in compliance<br />

with IAS 34, Interim financial reporting, in respect of the first six months of the financial year. At<br />

the end of the interim period, the Group applies the same impairment testing, recognition, and<br />

reversal criteria as it would at the end of the financial year (see Notes 2(k) (i) and (ii)).<br />

128<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(l)<br />

Inventories<br />

Coal inventories are physically measured or estimated and valued at the lower of cost and net realisable<br />

value.<br />

Cost is calculated using the weighted average cost formula and comprises all costs of purchase, an<br />

appropriate portion of fixed and variable overhead costs, including the stripping costs incurred during<br />

the production phase, and other costs incurred in bringing the inventories to their present location and<br />

condition.<br />

Net realisable value is the estimated future sales price of the product the Group expects to realise<br />

when such item is sold or processed, less estimated costs to complete and bring the product to sale.<br />

When coal inventories are sold, the carrying amount of those inventories is recognised as an expense in<br />

the period in which the related revenue is recognised. The amount of any write-down of inventories to<br />

net realisable value and all losses of inventories are recognised as an expense in the period the writedown<br />

or loss occurs. The amount of any reversal of any write-down of inventories is recognised as a<br />

reduction in the amount of inventories recognised as an expense in the period in which the reversal<br />

occurs.<br />

Inventories of ancillary materials, spare parts and small tools used in production are stated at cost less<br />

impairment losses for obsolescence.<br />

(m) Trade and other receivables<br />

Trade and other receivables are initially recognised at fair value and thereafter stated at amortised<br />

cost using the effective interest method, less allowance for impairment of doubtful debts (see Note<br />

2(k) (i)), except where the receivables are interest-free loans made to related parties without any fixed<br />

repayment terms or the effect of discounting would be immaterial. In such cases, the receivables are<br />

stated at cost less allowance for impairment of doubtful debts.<br />

(n)<br />

Interest-bearing borrowings<br />

Interest-bearing borrowings are recognised initially at fair value less attributable transaction costs.<br />

Subsequent to initial recognition, interest-bearing borrowings are stated at amortised cost with any<br />

difference between the amount initially recognised and redemption value being recognised in profit or<br />

loss over the period of the borrowings, together with any interest and fees payable, using the effective<br />

interest method.<br />

(o)<br />

Trade and other payables<br />

Trade and other payables are initially recognised at fair value and subsequently stated at amortised<br />

cost unless the effect of discounting would be immaterial, in which case they are stated at cost.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

129


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(p)<br />

Cash and cash equivalents<br />

Cash and cash equivalents comprise cash at bank and in hand, demand deposits with banks and other<br />

financial institutions, and short-term, highly liquid investments that are readily convertible into known<br />

amounts of cash and which are subject to an insignificant risk of changes in value, having been within<br />

three months of maturity at acquisition.<br />

(q)<br />

Employee benefits<br />

(i)<br />

Short-term employee benefits and contributions to defined contribution retirement plans<br />

Salaries, annual bonuses, paid annual leave, contributions to defined contribution retirement plans<br />

and the cost of non-monetary benefits are accrued for the year in which the associated services<br />

are rendered by employees. Where payment or settlement is deferred and the effect would be<br />

material, these amounts are stated at their present values.<br />

(ii)<br />

Share-based payments<br />

The fair value of share options granted to employees is recognised as an employee cost with a<br />

corresponding increase in an other reserve within equity. The fair value is measured at grant date<br />

using Black-Scholes option pricing model, taking into account the terms and conditions upon<br />

which the options were granted. Where the employees have to meet vesting conditions before<br />

becoming unconditionally entitled to the options, the total estimated fair value of the options is<br />

spread over the vesting period, taking into account the probability that the options will vest.<br />

During the vesting period, the number of share options that is expected to vest is reviewed. Any<br />

resulting adjustment to the cumulative fair value recognised in prior years is charged/credited<br />

to the profit or loss for the year of the review, unless the original employee expenses qualify for<br />

recognition as an asset, with a corresponding adjustment to the other reserve. On vesting date,<br />

the amount recognised as an expense is adjusted to reflect the actual number of options that<br />

vest (with a corresponding adjustment to the other reserve) except where forfeiture is only due<br />

to not achieving vesting conditions that relate to the market price of the Company’s shares. The<br />

equity amount is recognised in the other reserve until either the option is exercised (when it is<br />

transferred to the share premium account) or the option expires (when it is released directly to<br />

retained earnings).<br />

(iii) Termination benefits<br />

Termination benefits are recognised at the earlier of when the Group can no longer withdraw<br />

the offer of those benefits and when it recognises restructuring costs involving the payment of<br />

termination benefits.<br />

130<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(r)<br />

Income tax<br />

Income tax for the year comprises current tax and movements in deferred tax assets and liabilities.<br />

Current tax and movements in deferred tax assets and liabilities are recognised in profit or loss except<br />

to the extent that they relate to items recognised in other comprehensive income or directly in equity,<br />

in which case the relevant amounts of tax are recognised in other comprehensive income or directly in<br />

equity, respectively.<br />

Current tax is the expected tax payable on the taxable income for the year, using tax rates enacted<br />

or substantively enacted at the balance sheet date, and any adjustment to tax payable in respect of<br />

previous years.<br />

Deferred tax assets and liabilities arise from deductible and taxable temporary differences respectively,<br />

being the differences between the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities for financial reporting<br />

purposes and their tax bases. Deferred tax assets also arise from unused tax losses and unused tax<br />

credits.<br />

Apart from certain limited exceptions, all deferred tax liabilities, and all deferred tax assets to the extent<br />

that it is probable that future taxable profits will be available against which the asset can be utilised,<br />

are recognised. Future taxable profits that may support the recognition of deferred tax assets arising<br />

from deductible temporary differences include those that will arise from the reversal of existing taxable<br />

temporary differences, provided those differences relate to the same taxation authority and the same<br />

taxable entity, and are expected to reverse either in the same period as the expected reversal of the<br />

deductible temporary difference or in periods into which a tax loss arising from the deferred tax asset<br />

can be carried back or forward. The same criteria are adopted when determining whether existing<br />

taxable temporary differences support the recognition of deferred tax assets arising from unused tax<br />

losses and credits, that is, those differences are taken into account if they relate to the same taxation<br />

authority and the same taxable entity, and are expected to reverse in a period, or periods, in which the<br />

tax loss or credit can be utilised.<br />

The limited exceptions to recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities are those temporary<br />

differences arising from the initial recognition of assets or liabilities that affect neither accounting nor<br />

taxable profit (provided they are not part of a business combination), and temporary differences relating<br />

to interests in subsidiaries to the extent that, in the case of taxable differences, the Group controls the<br />

timing of the reversal and it is probable that the differences will not reverse in the foreseeable future, or<br />

in the case of deductible differences, unless it is probable that they will reverse in the future.<br />

The amount of deferred tax recognised is measured based on the expected manner of realisation or<br />

settlement of the carrying amount of the assets and liabilities, using tax rates enacted or substantively<br />

enacted at the balance sheet date. Deferred tax assets and liabilities are not discounted.<br />

The carrying amount of a deferred tax asset is reviewed at the end of each reporting period and is<br />

reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable that sufficient taxable profit will be available to allow<br />

the related tax benefit to be utilised. Any such reduction is reversed to the extent that it becomes<br />

probable that sufficient taxable profit will be available.<br />

Additional income taxes that arise from the distribution of dividends are recognised when the liability to<br />

pay the related dividend is recognised.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

131


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(r)<br />

Income tax (Continued)<br />

Current tax balances and deferred tax balances, and movements therein, are presented separately from<br />

each other and are not offset. Current tax assets are offset against current tax liabilities, and deferred<br />

tax assets against deferred tax liabilities if, the Company or the Group have the legally enforceable right<br />

to set off current tax assets against current tax liabilities and the following additional conditions are<br />

met:<br />

– in the case of current tax assets and liabilities, the Company or the Group intends either to settle<br />

on a net basis, or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously; or<br />

– in the case of deferred tax assets and liabilities, if they relate to income taxes levied by the same<br />

taxation authority on either:<br />

– the same taxable entity; or<br />

– different taxable entities, which, in each future period in which significant amounts of<br />

deferred tax liabilities or assets are expected to be settled or recovered, intend to realise<br />

the current tax assets and settle the current tax liabilities on a net basis or realise and settle<br />

simultaneously.<br />

(s)<br />

Provisions and contingent liabilities<br />

Provisions are recognised for liabilities of uncertain timing or amount when the Group has a legal or<br />

constructive obligation arising as a result of a past event, it is probable that an outflow of economic<br />

benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate can be made. Where the time<br />

value of money is material, provisions are stated at the present value of the expenditure expected to<br />

settle the obligation.<br />

Where it is not probable that an outflow of economic benefits will be required, or the amount cannot be<br />

estimated reliably, the obligation is disclosed as a contingent liability, unless the probability of outflow<br />

of economic benefits is remote. Possible obligations, whose existence will only be confirmed by the<br />

occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more future events are also disclosed as contingent liabilities<br />

unless the probability of outflow of economic benefits is remote.<br />

132<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(t)<br />

Obligations for reclamation<br />

The Group’s obligations for reclamation consist of spending estimates at its mines in accordance with<br />

the relevant rules and regulations in Mongolia. The Group estimates its liabilities for final reclamation<br />

and mine closure based upon detailed calculations of the amount and timing of the future cash<br />

spending to perform the required work. Spending estimates are escalated for inflation, then discounted<br />

at a discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks<br />

specific to the liability such that the amount of provision reflects the present value of the expenditures<br />

expected to be required to settle the obligation. The Group records a corresponding asset associated<br />

with the liability for final reclamation and mine closure, which is included in the mining properties.<br />

The obligation and corresponding asset are recognised in the period in which the liability is incurred.<br />

The asset is depreciated on the units-of-production method over its expected life and the liability is<br />

accreted to the projected spending date. As changes in estimates occur (such as mine plan revisions,<br />

changes in estimated costs, or changes in timing of the performance of reclamation activities), the<br />

revisions to the obligation and the corresponding asset are recognised at the appropriate discount rate.<br />

(u)<br />

Revenue recognition<br />

Revenue is measured at the fair value of the consideration received or receivable. Provided it is<br />

probable that the economic benefits will flow to the Group and the revenue and costs, if applicable,<br />

can be measured reliably, revenue is recognised in profit or loss as follows:<br />

(i)<br />

Sale of goods<br />

Revenue associated with the sale of coal is recognised when the risks and rewards of ownership<br />

of the goods have been passed to the customer. Revenue excludes value added tax or other<br />

sales taxes and is after deduction of any trade discounts and volume rebates.<br />

(ii)<br />

Interest income<br />

Interest income is recognised as it accrues using the effective interest method.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

133


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(v)<br />

Translation of foreign currencies<br />

The presentation currency of the Group is USD. The functional currency of the Company and the<br />

investment holding companies is USD and the functional currency of other group entities located in<br />

Mongolia is Mongolian Togrog (“MNT”). Foreign currency transactions during the year are translated at<br />

the foreign exchange rates ruling at the transaction dates. Monetary assets and liabilities denominated<br />

in foreign currencies are translated at the foreign exchange rates ruling at the balance sheet date.<br />

Exchange gains and losses are recognised in profit or loss.<br />

Non-monetary assets and liabilities that are measured in terms of historical cost in a foreign currency<br />

are translated using the foreign exchange rates ruling at the transaction dates.<br />

The results of operations in Mongolia are translated into USD at the exchange rates approximating the<br />

foreign exchange rates ruling at the dates of the transactions. Balance sheet items are translated into<br />

USD at the foreign exchange rates ruling at the balance sheet date. The resulting exchange differences<br />

are recognised in other comprehensive income and accumulated separately in equity in the exchange<br />

reserve.<br />

On disposal of a foreign operation, the cumulative amount of the exchange differences relating to<br />

that foreign operation is reclassified from equity to profit or loss when the profit or loss on disposal is<br />

recognised.<br />

(w) Borrowing costs<br />

Borrowing costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of an<br />

asset which necessarily takes a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale are<br />

capitalised as part of the cost of that asset. Other borrowing costs are expensed in the period in which<br />

they are incurred.<br />

The capitalisation of borrowing costs as part of the cost of a qualifying asset commences when<br />

expenditure for the asset is being incurred, borrowing costs are being incurred and activities that are<br />

necessary to prepare the asset for its intended use or sale are in progress. Capitalisation of borrowing<br />

costs is suspended or ceases when substantially all the activities necessary to prepare the qualifying<br />

asset for its intended use or sale are interrupted or complete.<br />

134<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(x)<br />

Non-current assets held for sale<br />

A non-current asset is classified as held for sale if it is highly probable that its carrying amount will be<br />

recovered through a sale transaction rather than through continuing use and the asset is available for<br />

sale in its present condition.<br />

Immediately before classification as held for sale, the measurement of the non-current assets is<br />

brought up-to-date in accordance with the accounting policies before the classification. Then, on initial<br />

classification as held for sale and until disposal, the non-current assets (except for certain assets as<br />

explained below) are recognised at the lower of their carrying amount and fair value less costs to sell.<br />

The principal exceptions to this measurement policy so far as the financial statements of the Group<br />

and the Company are concerned are deferred tax assets, assets arising from employee benefits,<br />

financial assets (other than investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures) and investment<br />

properties. These assets, even if held for sale, would continue to be measured in accordance with the<br />

policies set out elsewhere in Note 2.<br />

Impairment losses on initial classification as held for sale, and on subsequent remeasurement while<br />

held for sale, are recognised in profit or loss. As long as a non-current asset is classified as held for<br />

sale the non-current asset is not depreciated or amortised.<br />

(y)<br />

Related parties<br />

(a)<br />

A person, or a close member of that person’s family, is related to the Group if that person:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

has control or joint control over the Group;<br />

has significant influence over the Group; or<br />

is a member of the key management personnel of the Group or the Group’s parent.<br />

(b)<br />

An entity is related to the Group if any of the following conditions applies:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

(iv)<br />

(v)<br />

(vi)<br />

The entity and the Group are members of the same group (which means that each parent,<br />

subsidiary and fellow subsidiary is related to the others).<br />

One entity is an associate or joint venture of the other entity (or an associate or joint venture<br />

of a member of a group of which the other entity is a member).<br />

Both entities are joint ventures of the same third party.<br />

One entity is a joint venture of a third entity and the other entity is an associate of the third<br />

entity.<br />

The entity is a post-employment benefit plan for the benefit of employees of either the Group<br />

or an entity related to the Group.<br />

The entity is controlled or jointly controlled by a person identified in (a).<br />

(vii) A person identified in (a) (i) has significant influence over the entity or is a member of the key<br />

management personnel of the entity (or of a parent of the entity).<br />

Close members of the family of a person are those family members who may be expected to influence,<br />

or be influenced by, that person in their dealings with the entity.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

135


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

2 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES (Continued)<br />

(z)<br />

Segment reporting<br />

Operating segments, and the amounts of each segment item reported in the financial statements,<br />

are identified from the financial information provided regularly to the Group’s most senior executive<br />

management for the purposes of allocating resources to, and assessing the performance of, the<br />

Group’s various lines of business and geographical locations.<br />

Individually material operating segments are not aggregated for financial reporting purposes unless the<br />

segments have similar economic characteristics and are similar in respect of the nature of products<br />

and services, the nature of production processes, the type or class of customers, the methods used to<br />

distribute the products or provide the services, and the nature of the regulatory environment. Operating<br />

segments which are not individually material may be aggregated if they share a majority of these<br />

criteria.<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES<br />

In determining the carrying amounts of certain assets and liabilities, the Group makes assumptions of<br />

the effects of uncertain future events on those assets and liabilities at the balance sheet date. These<br />

estimates involve assumptions about such items as risk adjustment to cash flows or discount rates used,<br />

future changes in salaries and future changes in prices affecting other costs. The Group’s estimates and<br />

assumptions are based on the expectations of future events and are reviewed periodically. In addition to<br />

assumptions and estimations of future events, judgements are also made during the process of applying<br />

the Group’s accounting policies. In addition to those disclosed in Note 27 about equity-settled share-based<br />

payment transactions and in Note 31(c) about the environmental contingencies, other significant accounting<br />

estimates and judgements were summarised as follows:<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies<br />

(i)<br />

Reserves<br />

The Group estimates and reports Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, commonly referred to<br />

as Coal Resources and Coal Reserves in the coal mining industry, meeting requirements of the<br />

Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves (“the<br />

JORC Code”), and subsequently the Australian Guidelines for the Estimation and Classification of<br />

Coal Resources (2014) to which are referred.<br />

The JORC Code is a professional code of practice that sets minimum standards for Public<br />

Reporting of minerals Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves. The JORC<br />

Code provides a mandatory system for the classification of minerals Exploration Results, Mineral<br />

Resources and Ore Reserves according to the levels of confidence in geological knowledge and<br />

technical and economic considerations in Public Reports.<br />

136<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Reserves (Continued)<br />

Responsibility for demonstrating the required transparency and materiality in the estimation of<br />

Coal Resources and/or Coal Reserves required by the JORC Code lies with the “Competent<br />

Person”. A Competent Person is a minerals industry professional who is a Member or Fellow of<br />

The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (“the AusIMM”), or of the Australian Institute<br />

of Geoscientists (“the AIG”), or of a Recognised Professional Organisation, as included in a list<br />

available on the JORC website. These organisations have enforceable codes of ethics, including<br />

disciplinary processes with powers to suspend or expel a member. A Competent Person must<br />

have a minimum of five years relevant experience in the style of mineralisation or type of deposit<br />

under consideration and in the activity which that person is undertaking.<br />

A “Coal Reserve” is the economically mineable part of a Measured and/or Indicated Coal<br />

Resource. It includes diluting materials and allowances for losses, which may occur when the<br />

material is mined or extracted and is defined by studies at Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility level as<br />

appropriate that include application of Modifying Factors. Such studies demonstrate that, at the<br />

time of reporting, extraction could reasonably be justified.<br />

A “Probable Coal Reserve” is the economically mineable part of an Indicated, and in some<br />

circumstances, a Measured Coal Resource. The confidence in the Modifying Factors applying to<br />

a Probable Coal Reserve is lower than that applying to a Proved Coal Reserve. A “Proved Coal<br />

Reserve” is the economically mineable part of a Measured Mineral Resource. A Proved Coal<br />

Reserve implies a high degree of confidence in the Modifying Factors.<br />

“Modifying Factors” are considerations used to convert Coal Resources to Coal Reserves. These<br />

include, but are not restricted to, mining, processing, metallurgical, infrastructure, economic,<br />

marketing, legal, environmental, social and governmental factors. Modifying Factors may change<br />

from one estimation to the next, where the materiality of such changes are demonstrable.<br />

Such changes may be as result of variation to any of the mining, processing, metallurgical,<br />

infrastructure, economic, marketing, legal, environmental, social, governmental or other factors.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

137


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Reserves (Continued)<br />

Because the Modifying Factors used to estimate Coal Reserves may change from one estimate<br />

to the next, estimates of Coal Reserves may change from one period to another. Changes in<br />

reported Coal Reserves thus may affect the Group’s financial results and financial position in a<br />

number of ways, including the following:<br />

• Asset recoverable amounts may be affected due to changes in estimated future cash flows.<br />

• Depreciation, depletion and amortisation charged in the income statement may change<br />

where such charges are determined on the units of production basis, or where the useful<br />

economic lives of assets change.<br />

• Overburden removal costs recorded on the balance sheet or charged to the income<br />

statement may change due to changes in stripping ratios or the units of production basis of<br />

depreciation.<br />

• Reclamation and mine closure provisions may change where changes in estimated reserves<br />

affect expectations about the timing or cost of these activities.<br />

• The carrying amount of deferred tax assets may change due to changes in estimates of the<br />

likely recovery of the tax benefits.<br />

(ii)<br />

Useful lives of property, plants and equipment<br />

Management determines the estimated useful lives of and related depreciation charges for its<br />

property, plant and equipment. This estimate is based on the actual useful lives of assets of<br />

similar nature and functions. It could change significantly as a result of significant technical<br />

innovations and competitor actions in response to industry cycles. Management will increase the<br />

depreciation charges where useful lives are less than previously estimated lives, or will write-off or<br />

write-down technically obsolete or non-strategic assets that have been abandoned or sold.<br />

(iii) Impairment of assets<br />

The Group reviews the carrying amounts of the assets at each balance sheet date to determine<br />

whether there is objective evidence of impairment. When indication of impairment is identified,<br />

management prepares discounted future cashflow to assess the differences between the carrying<br />

amount and value in use and provided for impairment loss. Any change in the assumptions<br />

adopted in the cash flow forecasts would increase or decrease in the provision of the impairment<br />

loss and affect the Group’s net asset value.<br />

In relation to trade and other receivables (including the value-added tax (“VAT”) receivables), a<br />

provision for impairment is made and an impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss when there<br />

is objective evidence (such as the probability of insolvency or significant financial difficulties of the<br />

debtor) that the Group will not be able to collect all of the amounts due under the original terms of<br />

the invoice. Management uses judgment in determining the probability of insolvency or significant<br />

financial difficulties of the debtor.<br />

138<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies (Continued)<br />

(iii) Impairment of assets (Continued)<br />

An increase or decrease in the above impairment loss would affect the net profit in future years.<br />

(iv) Obligation for reclamation<br />

The estimation of the liabilities for final reclamation and mine closure involves the estimates of the<br />

amount and timing for the future cash spending as well as the discount rate used for reflecting<br />

current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the liability.<br />

The Group considers the factors including future production volume and development plan, the<br />

geological structure of the mining regions and reserve volume to determine the scope, amount<br />

and timing of reclamation and mine closure works to be performed. Determination of the effect<br />

of these factors involves judgements from the Group and the estimated liabilities may turn out<br />

to be different from the actual expenditure to be incurred. The discount rate used by the Group<br />

may also be altered to reflect the changes in the market assessments of the time value of money<br />

and the risks specific to the liability, such as change of the borrowing rate and inflation rate in the<br />

market. As changes in estimates occur (such as mine plan revisions, changes in estimated costs,<br />

or changes in timing of the performance of reclamation activities), the revisions to the obligation<br />

will be recognised at the appropriate discount rate.<br />

(v)<br />

Recognition of deferred tax assets<br />

Deferred tax assets in respect of unused tax losses and tax credit carried forward and deductible<br />

temporary differences are recognised and measured based on the expected manner of realisation<br />

or settlement of the carrying amount of the assets, using tax rates enacted or substantively<br />

enacted at the balance sheet date. In determining the carrying amounts of deferred assets,<br />

expected taxable profits are estimated which involves a number of assumptions relating to the<br />

operating environment of the Group and require a significant level of judgement exercised by the<br />

directors. Any change in such assumptions and judgement would affect the carrying amounts of<br />

deferred tax assets to be recognised and hence the net profit in the future years.<br />

(vi) Derivative financial instruments<br />

In determining the fair value of the derivative financial instruments, considerable judgement is<br />

required to interpret market data used in the valuation techniques. The use of different market<br />

assumptions and/or estimation methodologies may have a material effect on the estimated fair<br />

value amounts.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

139


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies (Continued)<br />

(vii) Exploration and evaluation expenditure<br />

The application of the Group’s accounting policy for exploration and evaluation expenditure<br />

requires judgement in determining whether it is likely that future economic benefits will flow to the<br />

Group. It requires management to make certain estimates and assumptions about future events<br />

or circumstances, in particular, whether an economically viable extraction operation can be<br />

established. Estimates and assumptions made may change if new information becomes available.<br />

If, after expenditure is capitalised, information becomes available suggesting that the recovery of<br />

expenditure is unlikely, the amount capitalised is written off in profit or loss in the period when the<br />

new information becomes available.<br />

(viii) Capitalised stripping costs<br />

The process of removing overburden and other mine waste materials to access mineral deposits<br />

is referred to as stripping. In open-pit mining, stripping costs are accounted for separately for<br />

each component of an ore body unless the stripping activity provides improved access to the<br />

whole of the ore body. A component is a specific section within an ore body that is made more<br />

accessible by the stripping activity. The identification of components is dependent on the mine<br />

plan.<br />

There are two types of stripping activity:<br />

• Development stripping is the initial overburden removal during the development phase to<br />

obtain access to a mineral deposit that will be commercially produced; and<br />

• Production stripping is the interburden removal during the normal course of production<br />

activity.<br />

Development stripping costs are capitalised as a stripping activity asset, in construction in<br />

progress and forming part of the cost of constructing the mine, when:<br />

• It is probable that future economic benefits associated with the asset will flow to the entity;<br />

and<br />

• The costs can be measured reliably.<br />

Capitalisation of development stripping costs ceases and these costs are transferred to mine<br />

properties in property, plant and equipment when the ore body or component of ore body is ready<br />

for its intended use.<br />

140<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Critical accounting judgements in applying the Group’s accounting policies (Continued)<br />

(viii) Capitalised stripping costs (Continued)<br />

Production stripping can give rise to two benefits being the extraction of ore in the current period<br />

and improved access to the ore body or component of ore body in future periods. To the extent<br />

that the benefit is the extraction of ore, the stripping costs are recognised as an inventory cost.<br />

To the extent the benefit is improved access to the ore body or component of ore body in future<br />

periods, the stripping costs are capitalised as mine properties in property, plant and equipment, if<br />

the following criteria are met:<br />

• It is probable that the future economic benefit (improved access to ore) will flow to the<br />

Group;<br />

• The ore body or component of the ore body for which access has been improved can be<br />

identified; and<br />

• The costs relating to the stripping activity can be measured reliably.<br />

Production stripping costs are allocated between the inventory produced and the mine properties<br />

capitalised using a life-of-component waste to ore strip ratio. When the current strip ratio is<br />

greater than the life-of-component ratio, a portion of the stripping costs is capitalised to the<br />

existing mine properties.<br />

The development and production stripping assets are depreciated using the units of production<br />

method based on the proven and probable mineral reserves of the relevant ore body or<br />

component of ore body.<br />

(ix) Taxation<br />

The Group is subject to various taxes and levies in the jurisdictions where it has operations. The<br />

Group makes payments and determines the provision for tax and levy liabilities primarily based on<br />

the computations as prepared by the Group. Nevertheless, judgement is required in determining<br />

the provision for taxes and levies as there are many transactions and calculations for which the<br />

ultimate determination is uncertain during the ordinary course of business, there are possible<br />

cases of disagreements with the relevant authorities on treatment of certain items included in<br />

the computations and certain non-routine transactions. The Group uses its best judgement to<br />

determine the probability although it is typically very difficult to determine the timing and ultimate<br />

outcome of each case. If the Group considers it probable that these judgement will result in<br />

different positions, the most likely amounts of the outcome will be estimated and adjustments to<br />

the liabilities will be made in the period in which such determination is made. Due to the inherent<br />

uncertainties related to the eventual outcome of each case, it is probable that certain matters may<br />

be resolved for amounts materially different from any estimated provisions or previous disclosures.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

141


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

3 ACCOUNTING JUDGEMENTS AND ESTIMATES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Sources of estimation uncertainty<br />

Other than requiring critical accounting judgements, assumptions concerning the future and other<br />

major sources of estimation uncertainty at the end of the reporting period are required in relation to the<br />

Group’s accounting policies on “obligations for reclamation”, “recognition of deferred tax assets” and<br />

“derivative financial instruments”. Information about the assumptions and their risk factors are set out<br />

in Notes 3(a) (iv), (v) and (vi).<br />

4 REVENUE<br />

The Group is principally engaged in the mining, processing, transportation and sale of coal products.<br />

Revenue represents the sales value of goods sold to customers exclusive of value added or sales taxes<br />

and after deduction of any trade discounts and volume rebates. The amount of each significant category of<br />

revenue recognised in revenue during the year is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Self-produced coal<br />

Washed hard-coking coal (“HCC”) 75,594 280,081<br />

Washed semi-soft coking coal (“SSCC”) — 4,277<br />

Washed thermal coal (“middlings”) 1 43,925<br />

Raw coal (“ROM coal”) — 24<br />

Trading of coal procured from Chinese third party sources 23,890 —<br />

99,485 328,307<br />

Revenue during the year ended 31 December 2015 include approximately USD37,997,000 (year ended<br />

31 December 2014: USD130,602,000) which arose from sales of washed hard coking coal to customers<br />

through agent sales arrangements for diversifying and expanding the Group’s sales channels.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group had four customers that individually exceeded 10% of<br />

the Group’s revenue from sales of goods and referring of services, being USD26,119,000, USD15,097,000,<br />

USD11,564,000 and USD11,243,000, respectively. During the year ended 31 December 2014, the Group<br />

had two customers that individually exceeded 10% of the Group’s revenue from sales of goods and referring<br />

of services, being USD117,673,000 and USD34,427,000, respectively.<br />

Details of concentrations of credit risk arising from these customers are set out in Note 30(b).<br />

142<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

5 COST OF REVENUE<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Mining costs 34,830 126,841<br />

Processing costs 13,084 31,596<br />

Transportation costs 15,387 74,383<br />

Provision losses on coal inventories (Note 20) 6,122 —<br />

Others (Note (i)) 43,309 62,069<br />

Cost of revenue during mine operations 112,732 294,889<br />

Cost of revenue during idled mine period (Note (ii)) 52,872 40,621<br />

Cost of revenue 165,604 335,510<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

Others include cost of coal procured from Chinese third party sources and royalty tax for the coal exported from<br />

Mongolia.<br />

(ii) Cost of revenue during idled mine period for the year ended 31 December 2015 includes USD34,390,000. (2014:<br />

USD27,954,000) of mining contractor costs and depreciation expense related to idled plant and equipment.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

143


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION<br />

Loss before taxation is arrived at after charging/(crediting):<br />

(a)<br />

Net finance costs:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Interest income (5,084) (3,911)<br />

Finance income (5,084) (3,911)<br />

Net change in fair value of derivative component of<br />

senior notes (Note 26) — 700<br />

Interest on bank and other borrowings 22,276 22,575<br />

Interest on liability component of senior notes (Note 26) 54,978 54,827<br />

Transaction costs 4,136 3,440<br />

Unwinding interest on<br />

– Obligations under finance lease — 8<br />

– Accrued reclamation obligations (Note 28) 854 808<br />

Less: Interest expense capitalised into construction in progress* — (8,617)<br />

Net interest expense 82,244 73,741<br />

Foreign exchange loss, net 21,862 24,690<br />

Finance costs 104,106 98,431<br />

Net finance costs 99,022 94,520<br />

* No borrowing costs have been capitalised for the year ended 31 December 2015; borrowing costs have been<br />

capitalised at a rate of 8.1% per annum for the year ended 31 December 2014.<br />

(b)<br />

Staff costs:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Salaries, wages, bonuses and benefits 20,961 25,167<br />

Retirement scheme contributions 2,322 3,015<br />

Equity-settled share-based payment expenses (Note 27) 3,298 3,475<br />

26,581 31,657<br />

144<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Staff costs: (Continued)<br />

Pursuant to the relevant labor rules and regulations in Mongolia, the Group participates in defined<br />

contribution retirement benefit schemes (the “Schemes”) organised by the GoM whereby the Group<br />

is required to make contributions to the Schemes at a rate of 7% of the eligible employees’ salaries.<br />

Contributions to the Schemes vest immediately.<br />

The Group has no other material obligation for the payment of pension benefits beyond the annual<br />

contributions described above.<br />

(c)<br />

Other items:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Selling and distribution costs (Note(i)) 8,589 56,445<br />

Depreciation and amortisation 39,179 46,145<br />

Provision for impairment losses on trade and other<br />

receivables (Note 21(b)) 8,512 8,806<br />

Provision for impairment loss on non-financial assets (Note (ii)) — 190,000<br />

8,512 198,806<br />

Operating lease charges:<br />

minimum lease payments<br />

– hire of plant and machinery 705 2,224<br />

– hire of other assets (including property rentals) 962 2,006<br />

1,667 4,230<br />

Net gain on disposal of property, plant and equipment and<br />

assets held for sale (62) (36,881)<br />

Auditors’ remuneration<br />

– audit services 536 536<br />

– tax and other services (Note(iii)) 9 272<br />

545 808<br />

Cost of inventories (Note(iv)) 165,604 335,510<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

145


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Other items: (Continued)<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

Selling and distribution costs<br />

Selling and distribution costs represent fees and charges incurred for importing coal into the People’s<br />

Republic of China (“PRC”), logistics and transportation costs, governmental fees and charges and fixed agent<br />

fees associated with the new market penetration strategy to diversify and expand sales channels in inland<br />

PRC.<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of non-financial assets<br />

Given the fact that coking coal market experienced continuing price decline and the operating losses<br />

sustained by the Group during the year ended 31 December 2015, according to IAS 36, Impairment of assets,<br />

management has performed impairment assessment on the carrying amount of the Group’s property, plant<br />

and equipment, construction in progress, intangible assets and long-term prepayments related to the UHG<br />

Mine and BN Mine operations (collectively referred to as “UHG and BN Assets”). For the purpose of this, the<br />

UHG and BN Assets are treated as a cash generating unit (“CGU”).<br />

The recoverable amount of the CGU was based on value in use, determined by discounting the future cash<br />

flows to be generated from the continuing use of the UHG and BN Assets. The key assumptions used in the<br />

estimation of value in use were as follows:<br />

– Recoverable reserves and resources<br />

Economically recoverable reserves and resources represent management’s expectations at the time of<br />

completing the impairment testing, based on reserves and resource statements and exploration and<br />

evaluation work undertaken by appropriately qualified persons.<br />

Compared with the one used at the year end of 2014, economically recoverable reserves and resources<br />

applied in the estimation made for the year end of 2015 had incorporated the latest JORC (2012) Coal<br />

Reserve estimate for UHG issued at a post balance sheet date.<br />

– Growth rate<br />

Instead of using a steady growth rate over the estimation period longer than five years, the cash flow<br />

projection made at the year end of 2015 and the year end of 2014 followed the same mechanism as<br />

coal product price multiplied by sales quantity, which was consistent throughout the whole life-of-mine<br />

(“LOM”) time.<br />

146<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Other items: (Continued)<br />

Note: (Continued)<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of non-financial assets (Continued)<br />

– Coal prices<br />

The coal price assumptions are management’s best estimate of the future price of coal in China. Coal<br />

price assumptions for the next five years are built on past experience of the industry and consistent with<br />

external sources. These prices are adjusted to arrive at appropriately consistent price assumptions for<br />

the difference qualities and type of coal.<br />

Coal price for the next five years estimated at the year end of 2015 declined by approximately 9% than<br />

that at the year end of 2014, which was updated with reference to the latest market forecast. The coal<br />

price estimation over a period longer than five years contains no growth rate, except for annual inflation<br />

rate. The treatment was consistent among estimations made at the year end of 2014 and the year end<br />

of 2015.<br />

– Sales quantity/production profile<br />

Sales quantity is in line with production profile. Estimated production volumes are based on detailed<br />

LOM plans and take into account development plans for the mines agreed by management as part of<br />

the long-term planning process. Production volumes are dependent on a number of variables, such<br />

as the recoverable quantities, the production profile, the cost of the development of the infrastructure<br />

necessary to extract the reserves, the production costs, the contractual duration of mining rights and<br />

the selling price of the coal extracted. The production profiles used were consistent with the reserves<br />

and resource volumes approved as part of the Group’s process for the estimation of proved and<br />

probable reserves.<br />

Compared with the estimated production volumes as at the year end of 2014, changes were made in<br />

2015 assumption to reflect updated production plan standing on the latest economically recoverable<br />

reserve and resource statements and exploration and evaluation work undertaken by appropriately<br />

qualified persons.<br />

– Operating costs<br />

Operating cost assumptions are based on management’s best estimation of the costs to be incurred at<br />

the date of impairment testing. Costs are determined after considering current operating costs, future<br />

cost expectations, as well as the nature and location of the operation. The estimation also takes future<br />

mining contractor arrangements into consideration; and the Directors are of the opinion that such<br />

mining contractor arrangements are in line with the Group’s business plan.<br />

– Capital expenditure<br />

Future capital expenditure is based on management’s best estimate of required future capital<br />

requirements. It has been determined by taking into account all committed and anticipated capital<br />

expenditure adjusted for future cost estimates.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

147


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Other items: (Continued)<br />

Note: (Continued)<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of non-financial assets (Continued)<br />

– Discount rate<br />

This discount rate is derived from the Group’s weighted average cost of capital (“WACC”), with<br />

appropriate adjustments made to reflect the risks specific to the CGU. The WACC takes into account<br />

both debt and equity, weighted based on the Group and comparable peer companies’ average capital<br />

structure. The cost of equity is derived from the expected return on investment by the Group’s investors<br />

based on publicly available market data of comparable peer companies. The cost of debt is based on<br />

the borrowing cost of interest-bearing borrowings of the Group that reflects the credit rating of the<br />

Group.<br />

Post-tax discount rate of 20% was applied to the future cash flows projection at the year end of 2015<br />

(2014: 20%). The directors believe that the post-tax discount rate was match with the latest cash flow<br />

projection modeling.<br />

Based on above-mentioned impairment assessment, the carrying amount of the CGU has not<br />

exceeded its recoverable amount as at 31 December 2015, and has not resulted in the identification<br />

of an impairment loss for the year ended 31 December 2015.The Directors are of the opinion that the<br />

impairment provision is adequate as at 31 December 2015 and no additional or reversal of impairment<br />

provision is needed in respect of the Group’s non-financial assets in this regard. The Directors believe<br />

that the estimates and assumptions incorporated in the impairment assessment are reasonable;<br />

however, the estimates and assumptions are subject to significant uncertainties and judgements. It is<br />

estimated that adverse changes in the key assumptions would lead to the recognition of an impairment<br />

provision against the CGU as follows:<br />

USD’000<br />

7% decrease in long-term coal price 12,000<br />

7% decrease in the estimated production volume 3,000<br />

One percentage point increase in pre-tax discount rate 13,000<br />

2% increase in the estimated operating costs 2,000<br />

45% increase in the estimated capital expenditure 5,000<br />

This assumes that the adverse change in the key assumption occurs in isolation of changes to other key<br />

assumptions and that no mitigating action is taken by management.<br />

148<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

6 LOSS BEFORE TAXATION (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Other items: (Continued)<br />

Note: (Continued)<br />

(ii)<br />

Impairment of non-financial assets (Continued)<br />

– Discount rate (Continued)<br />

In light of a regular portfolio review, inflation pressures on operating costs, different product quality<br />

different mine has, and also following the latest coal price environment at the year end of 2014, the<br />

impairment loss of USD190,000,000 had been recognised as at 31 December 2014 in relation to the<br />

mining rights of BN Mine to reflect significant downward pressure on coal prices due to persisting<br />

oversupply situation in the coal industry (see Note 16). The BN Mine was acquired by the Company<br />

on 31 May 2011 when the Group entered into a share purchase agreement (“Share Purchase<br />

Agreement”) with Quincunx (BVI) Ltd. and its parent, Kerry Mining (Mongolia) Limited (collectively the<br />

“Seller”) in relation to the acquisition of the entire issued share capital of Baruun Naran Limited (formerly<br />

known as QGX Coal Ltd.) (the “Acquisition”). Baruun Naran Limited ultimately owns the BN Mine. The<br />

Acquisition was completed on 1 June 2011. In order to rationalise the Seller’s structure which was<br />

not cost-effective for the Group, Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited, a wholly-owned subsidiary of<br />

the Company which acted as the buyer of the Acquisition, decided to wind up Baruun Naran Limited<br />

voluntarily on 21 June 2012. Accordingly, Baruun Naran Limited (a Gibraltar registered company) was<br />

liquidated and all of its assets were transferred to Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited on 16 July 2012.<br />

(iii)<br />

Tax and other services<br />

Tax and other services fees for the year ended 31 December 2014 include the fees for tax services and<br />

professional fees in relation to the rights issue.<br />

(iv)<br />

Cost of inventories<br />

Cost of inventories includes USD50,475,000 (2014: USD79,333,000) relating to personnel expenses,<br />

depreciation and amortisation and operating lease charges which are also included in the respective amounts<br />

disclosed separately above for each of these types of expenses. Also included in cost of inventories was<br />

transportation and stockpile losses amounted to USD862,000 (2014: USD3,542,000).<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

149


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

7 INCOME TAX<br />

(a)<br />

Income tax in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income represents:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Current tax<br />

Provision for the year (Note 25(a)) 647 8,492<br />

Exemption of withholding tax obligation in prior years (Note (v)) (7,647) —<br />

Deferred tax<br />

Origination and reversal of temporary difference (Note 25(b)) (9,873) (67,470)<br />

(16,873) (58,978)<br />

(b)<br />

Reconciliation between tax expense and accounting loss at applicable tax rates:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Loss before income tax (204,586) (341,683)<br />

Notional tax on loss before taxation (21,504) (62,580)<br />

Tax effect of non-deductible items (Note (iii)) (5,880) 3,436<br />

Tax effect of non-taxable items (Note (iv)) 15,819 (677)<br />

Tax losses not recognised 2,339 843<br />

Exemption of withholding tax obligation in prior years (Note (v)) (7,647) —<br />

Actual tax expenses (16,873) (58,978)<br />

150<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

7 INCOME TAX (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Reconciliation between tax expense and accounting loss at applicable tax rates: (Continued)<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

(iv)<br />

(v)<br />

Pursuant to the prevailing income tax rules and regulations of Mongolia, the Group is liable to Mongolian<br />

Enterprise Income Tax at a rate of 10% of first MNT3 billion taxable income and 25% of the remaining taxable<br />

income for the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014. According to the Corporate Income Tax Law of<br />

China, the Company’s subsidiary in China is subject to statutory income tax rate of 25%.<br />

Pursuant to the rules and regulations of the Cayman Islands, the Group is not subject to any income tax in the<br />

Cayman Islands. The Group is not subject to Hong Kong and Luxembourg profits tax as it has no assessable<br />

income arising in or derived from Hong Kong and Luxembourg during the years ended 31 December 2015 and<br />

2014.<br />

Non-deductible items mainly represent the non-deductible expenses and the unrealised exchange losses<br />

which are non-deductible pursuant to the income tax rules and regulations of Mongolia during the years ended<br />

31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

Non-taxable items mainly represent the unrealised exchange gains which are non-taxable pursuant to the<br />

income tax rules and regulations of Mongolia during the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

The waiving is pursuant to the adoption of the new law on Economic Transparency on 7 August 2015 as<br />

approved by Mongolian Parliament for amnesty from tax obligations and administrative penalties.<br />

8 LOSS PER SHARE<br />

(a)<br />

Basic loss per share<br />

The calculation of basic loss per share is based on the loss attributable to ordinary equity shareholders<br />

of the Company of USD187,763,000 (2014: USD282,837,000) and the 9,262,591,250 ordinary shares<br />

(2014: 4,751,758,537 ordinary shares after adjusting for the rights issue in 2014) in issue during the<br />

year. In calculating basic loss per share, the weighted average number of shares outstanding during<br />

the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014 were calculated as if the bonus elements without<br />

consideration included in the rights issue had existed from the beginning of the comparative year.<br />

(b)<br />

Diluted loss per share<br />

For the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014, basic and diluted loss per share are the same as<br />

the effect of the potential ordinary shares outstanding is anti-dilutive.<br />

The equity-settled share-based payment transactions (see Note 27) are anti-dilutive and therefore not<br />

included in calculating diluted loss per share for the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

151


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

9 DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION<br />

Details of the directors’ remuneration disclosed are as follows:<br />

Year ended 31 December 2015<br />

Directors’<br />

fee<br />

Salaries,<br />

allowances<br />

and benefits<br />

in kind<br />

Discretionary<br />

bonuses<br />

Retirement<br />

scheme<br />

contributions<br />

Equity-settled<br />

share-based<br />

payment<br />

expenses<br />

Total<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Executive directors<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts (Chairman) 16 251 328 40 — 635<br />

Battsengel Gotov 16 205 328 37 833 1,419<br />

Non-executive directors<br />

Oyungerel Janchiv 16 — — — — 16<br />

Batsaikhan Purev 15 — — — — 15<br />

Od Jambaljamts 16 — — — — 16<br />

Gankhuyag Adilbish 16 — — — — 16<br />

Independent non-executive directors<br />

Ochirbat Punsalmaa 21 — — — — 21<br />

Unenbat Jigjid 24 — — — — 24<br />

Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius 51 — — — — 51<br />

Total 191 456 656 77 833 2,213<br />

152<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

9 DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION (Continued)<br />

Year ended 31 December 2014<br />

Directors’<br />

fee<br />

Salaries,<br />

allowances<br />

and benefits<br />

in kind<br />

Discretionary<br />

bonuses<br />

Retirement<br />

scheme<br />

contributions<br />

Equity-settled<br />

share-based<br />

payment<br />

expenses<br />

Total<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Executive directors<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts (Chairman) 18 229 — 17 — 264<br />

Battsengel Gotov 18 175 18 14 639 864<br />

Non-executive directors<br />

Enkhtuvshin Gombo<br />

(resigned on 13 October 2014) 14 — — — — 14<br />

Oyungerel Janchiv 18 — — — — 18<br />

Batsaikhan Purev 18 — — — — 18<br />

Od Jambaljamts 18 — — — — 18<br />

Gankhuyag Adilbish<br />

(appointed on 13 October 2014) 4 — — — — 4<br />

Independent non-executive directors<br />

Ochirbat Punsalmaa 24 — — — — 24<br />

Unenbat Jigjid 27 — — — — 27<br />

Chan Tze Ching, Ignatius 58 — — — — 58<br />

Total 217 404 18 31 639 1,309<br />

No emoluments have been paid to the directors as an inducement to join or upon joining the Group or as<br />

compensation for loss of office during the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

153


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

10 INDIVIDUALS WITH HIGHEST EMOLUMENTS<br />

The number of directors and non-directors included in the five highest paid individuals is set forth below:<br />

2015 2014<br />

Directors 2 1<br />

Non-directors 3 4<br />

5 5<br />

The emoluments of the directors are disclosed in Note 9. The aggregate of the emoluments in respect of the<br />

remaining highest paid individuals are as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

Basic salaries, allowances and benefits in kind 645 735<br />

Discretionary bonuses 714 167<br />

Retirement scheme contributions 92 61<br />

Equity-settled share-based payment expenses (Note 27) 689 1,789<br />

2,140 2,752<br />

The emoluments of the remaining individuals with the highest emoluments are within the following band:<br />

2015 2014<br />

HKD2,100,001 to HKD2,500,000 — —<br />

HKD4,500,001 to HKD5,000,000 — 1<br />

HKD5,000,001 to HKD5,500,000 1 2<br />

HKD5,500,001 to HKD6,000,000 2 1<br />

No emoluments have been paid to these individuals as an inducement to join or upon joining the Group or as<br />

compensation for loss of office during the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

154<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

10 INDIVIDUALS WITH HIGHEST EMOLUMENTS (Continued)<br />

Note:<br />

These represent the estimated value of share options granted to the key management under the Group’s share option<br />

scheme. The value of these share options is measured according to the Group’s accounting policies for share-based<br />

payment transactions as set out in Note 2(q) (ii) and, in accordance with that policy, included adjustments to reverse<br />

amounts accrued in previous years where grants of equity instruments are forfeited prior to vesting.<br />

The details of these benefits in kind, including the principal terms and number of options granted, are disclosed under the<br />

paragraph “Share Option Scheme” in the Directors’ Report and Note 27.<br />

11 OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME<br />

2015 2014<br />

Exchange differences on translation of:<br />

– financial statements of overseas subsidiaries (3,822) 8,523<br />

– net investment 41,646 75,788<br />

Reclassification adjustments for amounts transferred to profit or loss:<br />

– disposal of net investment (15,192) (3,799)<br />

22,632 80,512<br />

The components of other comprehensive income do not have any significant tax effect for the years ended<br />

31 December 2015 and 2014.<br />

12 SEGMENT REPORTING<br />

The Group has one business segment, the mining, processing, transportation and sale of coal. The majority<br />

of its customers are located in China. Based on information reported to the chief operating decision maker<br />

for the purpose of resource allocation and performance assessment, the Group’s only operating segment<br />

is the mining, processing, transportation and sales of coal. Accordingly, no additional business and<br />

geographical segment information are presented.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

155


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

13 PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT, NET<br />

Buildings<br />

and<br />

plants<br />

Machinery<br />

and<br />

equipment<br />

Motor<br />

vehicles<br />

Office<br />

equipment<br />

Mining<br />

properties<br />

Total<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Cost:<br />

At 1 January 2014 233,961 122,999 49,035 6,626 257,997 670,618<br />

Additions 128 3,287 823 84 56,700 61,022<br />

Transfer from construction in progress<br />

(Note 14) 40,252 46,603 — — — 86,855<br />

Transfer to assets held for sale (2,910) — — — — (2,910)<br />

Disposals (470) (363) (5,456) (373) — (6,662)<br />

Exchange adjustments (33,927) (16,462) (5,456) (1,745) (33,746) (91,336)<br />

At 31 December 2014 237,034 156,064 38,946 4,592 280,951 717,587<br />

At 1 January 2015 237,034 156,064 38,946 4,592 280,951 717,587<br />

Additions — 1,521 621 23 19,344 21,509<br />

Transfer to assets held for sale (55) — — — — (55)<br />

Disposals (4,033) (2,695) (1,404) (322) — (8,454)<br />

Exchange adjustments (12,509) (7,933) (2,143) (277) (15,773) (38,635)<br />

At 31 December 2015 220,437 146,957 36,020 4,016 284,522 691,952<br />

Accumulated amortisation and depreciation:<br />

At 1 January 2014 16,415 29,818 24,781 3,341 21,796 96,151<br />

Charge for the year 10,408 16,286 7,764 997 10,686 46,141<br />

Transfer to assets held for sale (87) — — — — (87)<br />

Written back on disposals (31) (99) (5,078) (181) — (5,389)<br />

Exchange adjustments (3,700) (4,222) (2,734) (462) (3,037) (14,155)<br />

At 31 December 2014 23,005 41,783 24,733 3,695 29,445 122,661<br />

At 1 January 2015 23,005 41,783 24,733 3,695 29,445 122,661<br />

Charge for the year 9,658 16,807 7,262 290 4,708 38,725<br />

Transfer to assets held for sale (1) — — — — (1)<br />

Written back on disposals (243) (1,352) (1,110) (283) — (2,988)<br />

Exchange adjustments (842) (2,514) (1,445) (674) (1,684) (7,159)<br />

At 31 December 2015 31,577 54,724 29,440 3,028 32,469 151,238<br />

Carrying amount:<br />

At 31 December 2015 188,860 92,233 6,580 988 252,053 540,714<br />

At 31 December 2014 214,029 114,281 14,213 897 251,506 594,926<br />

156<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

13 PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT, NET (Continued)<br />

Note:<br />

(a)<br />

(b)<br />

(c)<br />

(d)<br />

(e)<br />

Majority part of the Group’s property, plant and equipment are located in Mongolia.<br />

Mining properties as at 31 December 2015 include stripping activity assets carrying book value of USD225,233,000<br />

(2014: USD223,451,000) and application fee for the mining rights of USD770,000 (2014: USD627,000) in relation to<br />

the Group’s mine deposits.<br />

The addition of mining properties for the year ended 31 December 2015 include the increase in reclamation<br />

provision of USD454,000 (2014: increase in reclamation provision of USD3,467,000) (see Note 28).<br />

As at 31 December 2015, certain of the Group’s borrowings were secured by the Group’s coal handling and<br />

preparation plant-modules I and II, power plant and water supply infrastructure assets-phase I with net book values<br />

of USD91,100,000, USD23,519,000 and USD2,532,000, respectively (31 December 2014: USD105,290,000,<br />

USD27,629,000 and USD3,008,000, respectively) (see Note 23).<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Group is in the process of applying for the ownership certificates for certain of its<br />

buildings. The aggregate carrying value of such properties of the Group as at 31 December 2015 is approximately<br />

USD6,467,000. The Directors are of the opinion that the Group is entitled to lawfully occupy or use of these<br />

properties.<br />

14 CONSTRUCTION IN PROGRESS<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

At 1 January 58,421 148,371<br />

Additions 184 6,314<br />

Transfer to property, plant and equipment (Note 13) — (86,855)<br />

Transfer to intangible assets (Note 16) — (4,909)<br />

Disposal (443) —<br />

Exchange adjustments (2,998) (4,500)<br />

At 31 December 55,164 58,421<br />

The construction in progress is mainly related to water supply facility and other mining related machinery and<br />

equipment.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

157


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

15 LEASE PREPAYMENTS<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Cost:<br />

At 1 January 83 93<br />

Exchange adjustments (5) (10)<br />

At 31 December 78 83<br />

Accumulated amortisation:<br />

At 1 January 10 8<br />

Charge for the year 2 1<br />

Exchange adjustments (2) 1<br />

At 31 December 10 10<br />

Net book value: 68 73<br />

Lease prepayments comprise interests in leasehold land held for own use under operating leases located in<br />

Mongolia, with original lease period from 15 years to 60 years.<br />

158<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

16 INTANGIBLE ASSETS<br />

Acquired<br />

mining right Softwares Total<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Cost:<br />

At 1 January 2014 701,557 — 701,557<br />

Addition for the year — 7 7<br />

Transfer from Construction in progress (Note 14) — 4,909 4,909<br />

Exchange adjustments — (178) (178)<br />

At 31 December 2014 701,557 4,738 706,295<br />

At 1 January 2015 701,557 4,738 706,295<br />

Exchange adjustments — (263) (263)<br />

At 31 December 2015 701,557 4,475 706,032<br />

Accumulated amortisation and impairment loss:<br />

At 1 January 2014 5,203 — 5,203<br />

Amortisation charge for the year — 3 3<br />

Impairment loss (Note 6(c)) 190,000 — 190,000<br />

Exchange adjustments — — —<br />

At 31 December 2014 195,203 3 195,206<br />

At 1 January 2015 195,203 3 195,206<br />

Amortisation charge for the year — 452 452<br />

Impairment loss (Note 6(c)) — — —<br />

Exchange adjustments — (6) (6)<br />

At 31 December 2015 195,203 449 195,652<br />

Carrying amount:<br />

At 31 December 2015 506,354 4,026 510,380<br />

At 31 December 2014 506,354 4,735 511,089<br />

Acquired mining right represents the mining right acquired during the acquisition of BN mine.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

159


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

17 INTERESTS IN SUBSIDIARIES<br />

The following list contains only the particulars of subsidiaries which principally affected the results, assets or<br />

liabilities of the Group. The class of shares held is ordinary unless otherwise stated.<br />

Name of company<br />

Place of<br />

incorporation<br />

and business<br />

Particulars of<br />

issued and paid<br />

up capital<br />

Equity attributable<br />

to the Company<br />

Direct Indirect<br />

Principal activities<br />

Mongolian Coal<br />

Corporation Limited<br />

Hong Kong<br />

1 share of<br />

HKD1 each<br />

100% — Investment holding<br />

Mongolian Coal<br />

Corporation S.à.r.l.<br />

Luxembourg<br />

6,712,669 shares<br />

of USD10 each<br />

— 100% Investment holding<br />

Energy Resources<br />

Corporation LLC<br />

Mongolia<br />

103,800,000 shares<br />

of USD1 each<br />

— 100% Investment holding<br />

Energy Resources LLC Mongolia 75,000,185 shares<br />

of USD2 each<br />

Energy Resources Rail LLC Mongolia 15,300,000 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

Transgobi LLC Mongolia 9,122,642 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

Tavan Tolgoi Airport LLC Mongolia 5,795,521 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

Enrestechnology LLC Mongolia 374,049,073 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

— 100% Mining and trading<br />

of coals<br />

— 100% Railway project<br />

management<br />

— 100% Coal haulage and<br />

logistics management<br />

— 100% Airport operation and<br />

management<br />

— 100% Coal plant<br />

management<br />

Ukhaa Khudag Water<br />

Supply LLC<br />

Mongolia<br />

96,016,551 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

— 100% Water exploration and<br />

supply management<br />

United Power LLC Mongolia 100,807,646 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

Gobi Road LLC Mongolia 50,000 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

Khangad Exploration LLC Mongolia 34,532,399 shares<br />

of USD1 each<br />

Baruun Naran S.à.r.l. Luxembourg 24,918,394 shares<br />

of EUR1 each<br />

— 100% Power supply project<br />

management<br />

— 100% Construction of road<br />

— 100% Exploration and<br />

development of coal<br />

mine<br />

— 100% Investment holding<br />

160<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

17 INTERESTS IN SUBSIDIARIES (Continued)<br />

Name of company<br />

Place of<br />

incorporation<br />

and business<br />

Particulars of<br />

issued and paid<br />

up capital<br />

Equity attributable<br />

to the Company<br />

Direct Indirect<br />

Principal activities<br />

Energy Resources Mining LLC Mongolia 72,001,000 shares<br />

of USD1 each<br />

— 100% Mining and technical<br />

management<br />

*Tianjin Zhengcheng Import<br />

and Export Trade Co., Ltd.<br />

China<br />

2,035,998 shares<br />

of RMB1 each<br />

— 51% Trading of coals and<br />

machinery equipment<br />

Tavan Tolgoi Power Plant<br />

Water Supply LLC<br />

Mongolia<br />

1,000 shares<br />

of MNT1,000 each<br />

— 100% Overseas Trading<br />

* Company not audited by KPMG. The financial statements of the subsidiary not audited by KPMG reflect total net<br />

assets and total revenue constituting approximately 0.2% (2014: 0.1%) and 27.5% (2014: 7.0%) respectively of the<br />

corresponding consolidated totals.<br />

The following table lists out the information relating to Tianjin Zhengcheng Import and Export Trade Co.,Ltd,<br />

the only subsidiary of the Group which has material non-controlling interest (NCI). Tianjin Zhengcheng<br />

Import and Export Trade Co.,Ltd is a sino-foreign equity joint venture established under the PRC law.<br />

The summarised financial information presented below represents the amounts before any inter-company<br />

elimination.<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

NCI percentage 49% 49%<br />

Current assets 1,619 13,475<br />

Non-current assets 6 8<br />

Current liabilities (1,233) (12,888)<br />

Non-current liabilities — —<br />

Net assets 392 595<br />

Carrying amount of NCI 342 292<br />

Revenue 27,322 23,131<br />

Profit for the year 101 270<br />

Total comprehensive income (203) 263<br />

Profit allocated to NCI 50 132<br />

Dividend paid to NCI — —<br />

Cash flows from operating activities 323 3,249<br />

Cash flows from investing activities — (6)<br />

Cash flows from financing activities — 331<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

161


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

18 INTEREST IN ASSOCIATES<br />

The following list contains only the particulars of material associates, all of which are unlisted corporate<br />

entities whose quoted market price is not available:<br />

Equity attributable<br />

to the Company<br />

Name of associate<br />

Form of<br />

business<br />

structure<br />

Place of<br />

incorporation<br />

and business<br />

Particulars of<br />

issued and paid<br />

up capital<br />

Group’s<br />

effective<br />

interest<br />

Held by a<br />

subsidiary<br />

Principal activity<br />

International Technical<br />

College LLC<br />

Incorporated Mongolia 913,500 shares of<br />

MNT1,000 each<br />

33.33% 33.33% T e c h n i c a l e d u c a t i o n<br />

service (Note 1)<br />

Gashuun Sukhait Road LLC Incorporated Mongolia 100,000 shares of<br />

MNT1,000 each<br />

40.00% 40.00% Paved road maintenance<br />

service (Note 2)<br />

Note 1: The investment in International Technical College LLC enables the Group to be equipped with the long-term<br />

availability of skilled technical workforce.<br />

Note 2: The principal activities of Gashuun Sukhait Road LLC are supplying safety, readiness, protection, repair and<br />

maintenance service for paved road operations from Ukhaa Khudag to Gashuun Sukhait. The investment in<br />

Gashuun Sukhait Road LLC enables the Group to monitor the usage situation of the aforementioned paved road.<br />

All of the above associates are accounted for using the equity method in the consolidated financial<br />

statements.<br />

162<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

18 INTEREST IN ASSOCIATES (Continued)<br />

Summarised financial information of the associates, adjusted for any differences in accounting policies, and<br />

reconciled to the carrying amounts in the consolidated financial statements, are disclosed below:<br />

International Technical<br />

College LLC<br />

Gashuun Sukhait<br />

Road LLC<br />

2015 2014 2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Gross amounts of the associates:<br />

Current assets 4 9 937 1,429<br />

Non-current assets 83 275 12 12<br />

Current liabilities 13 160 899 1,388<br />

Non-current liabilities — — — —<br />

Equity 74 124 50 53<br />

Revenue 22 199 2,669 2,189<br />

(Loss)/profit from continuing operations (44) (57) 4 1<br />

Post-tax profit or loss from discontinued — — — —<br />

Other comprehensive income — — — —<br />

Total comprehensive income (44) (57) 4 1<br />

Dividend received from the associate — — — —<br />

Reconciled to the group’s interests<br />

in the Associates:<br />

Gross amounts of net assets<br />

of the associate 75 124 50 53<br />

Group’s effective interest 33% 33% 40% 40%<br />

Group’s share of net assets<br />

of the associate 25 42 20 21<br />

Carrying amount in the consolidated<br />

financial statements 25 42 20 21<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

163


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

19 OTHER NON-CURRENT ASSETS<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Prepayments in connection with construction work,<br />

equipment purchases and others 48,813 23,951<br />

Financial assets available-for-sale (Note (i)) 1,769 1,872<br />

50,582 25,823<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

On 14 January 2011, the Group invested in International Medical Centre LLC (the “International Medical Centre”)<br />

and had 25.5% interest in International Medical Centre, an entity incorporated in Mongolia with issued and paid<br />

up capital of MNT22,522,500,000 (16,500,000 shares of MNT1,365 each). The principal activities of International<br />

Medical Centre are the provision of health care, diagnostic and treatment services. As the capital injection by other<br />

investors in January 2014, interest had by the Group in International Medical Centre changed to 16.46%. With<br />

no significant influence thereafter, the Group accounted for its interest in International Medical Centre as financial<br />

assets available-for-sale at using the cost method in the consolidated financial statements.<br />

20 INVENTORIES<br />

(a)<br />

Inventories in the consolidated balance sheet comprise:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Coal 39,434 34,222<br />

Materials and supplies 12,517 14,678<br />

51,951 48,900<br />

Less: Provision on coal inventories (6,122) —<br />

45,829 48,900<br />

164<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

20 INVENTORIES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

The analysis of the amount of inventories recognised as an expense and included in profit or<br />

loss is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Carrying amount of inventories sold 106,610 294,889<br />

Write down of inventories 6,122 —<br />

112,732 294,889<br />

As at 31 December 2015, certain of the Group’s borrowings were secured by the Group’s coal<br />

inventory of USD33,276,000 (31 December 2014: USD21,745,000) (see Note 23).<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, USD6,122,000 (year ended 31 December 2014: nil) has<br />

been recognised as provision for coal inventories and expensed in profit or loss as cost of revenue.<br />

This provision was due to the decrease in the estimated net realisable value of coal products as a<br />

result of decreasing selling price.<br />

21 TRADE AND OTHER RECEIVABLES<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Trade receivables (Note (a)) 1,976 36,952<br />

Other receivables (Note (c)) 92,317 125,390<br />

94,293 162,342<br />

Less: allowance for doubtful debts (Note (b)) (436) (10,135)<br />

93,857 152,207<br />

(a)<br />

Ageing analysis<br />

As of the end of the reporting period, the ageing analysis of trade debtors and bills receivable (which<br />

are included in trade and other receivables), based on the invoice date and net of allowance for<br />

doubtful debts, is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Within 90 days 631 12,093<br />

90 to 180 days 734 9,998<br />

180 to 365 days 175 4,726<br />

1,540 26,817<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

165


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

21 TRADE AND OTHER RECEIVABLES (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Impairment of trade receivables<br />

Impairment losses in respect of trade receivables are recorded using an allowance account unless the<br />

Group is satisfied that recovery of the amount is remote, in which case the impairment loss is written<br />

off against trade receivables directly (Note 2(k) (i)).<br />

The movement in the allowance for doubtful debts during the year is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

At 1 January 10,135 5,029<br />

Provision for impairment losses 8,512 8,806<br />

Amounts written off (18,211) (3,700)<br />

At 31 December 436 10,135<br />

As at 31 December 2015, an allowance for doubtful debts amounting to USD436,000 (2014:<br />

USD10,135,000) was made on a collective basis in respect of the Group’s trade receivable balances<br />

outstanding at the balance sheet date, which have been included in “general and administrative<br />

expenses” in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, management assessed that the recoverability of trade<br />

receivables due from certain customers is remote, and USD18,211,000 have been written off against<br />

allowance for doubtful debts.<br />

(c)<br />

Other receivables<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Amounts due from related parties (Note (i)) 456 607<br />

Prepayments and deposits (Note (ii)) 25,462 31,448<br />

VAT and other tax receivables (Note (iii)) 20,752 35,786<br />

Amounts due from the GoM in relation to the<br />

termination of the Concession Agreement (Note (iv)) 41,952 44,408<br />

Others (Note (v)) 3,695 13,141<br />

92,317 125,390<br />

166<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

21 TRADE AND OTHER RECEIVABLES (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Other receivables (Continued)<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

(iv)<br />

Amount due from related parties are unsecured, interest-free and have no fixed repayment terms (see Note<br />

32(a)).<br />

At 31 December 2015 and 2014, prepayments and deposits mainly represent the prepayments made to the<br />

Group’s mining contractor.<br />

VAT and other tax receivables include amounts that have been accumulated to date in certain subsidiaries<br />

and were due from the GoM Taxation Authority. Based on current available information the Group anticipates<br />

full recoverability of such amounts. Further details are stated in Note 30(b).<br />

It represented the compensation amount receivable from the GoM upon the termination of a Build-Operate-<br />

Transfer Concession Agreement (the “Concession Agreement”) signed on 6 May 2013, relating to the<br />

railway base infrastructure between Ukhaa Khudag coking coal mine and Gashuun Sukhait border check point<br />

of Mongolia (the “UHG-GS Railway”), after taking into account of liabilities assumed by the GoM. The Group<br />

has been negotiating with the GoM regarding the potential investment in a railway project of the GoM and the<br />

compensation amount could be converted into equity of a special purpose enterprise to be established by the<br />

GoM to implement the railway project and/or reimbursed.<br />

Subsequent to the balance sheet date, and based on the contracted exchange rate, the Ministry of Finance<br />

(“MOF”), representative designated by GoM, issued MNT denominated promissory notes with total face<br />

value of approximately MNT120.6 billion (equivalent to USD60,336,000) to the Group with regards to the<br />

settlement of this receivables in relation to the termination of the Concession Agreement. Until the issue of<br />

the consolidated financial statements, the Group has received all the above mentioned MNT denominated<br />

promissory notes, and as such its rights for equity conversion into the railway project shall deemed as<br />

terminated.<br />

(v) At 31 December 2015, this item mainly represented the interest receivables on deposit. At 31 December 2014<br />

this item mainly represented the reimbursement receivables due from Erdenes MGL LLC of USD8.4 million.<br />

All other receivables were aged within one year and expected to be recovered or expensed off within<br />

one year.<br />

22 CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Cash in hand 13 48<br />

Cash at bank 50,689 252,808<br />

Cash at bank and in hand 50,702 252,856<br />

Less: time deposits with original maturity over three months (50,000) (50,000)<br />

Cash and cash equivalents in the consolidated cash flow statement 702 202,856<br />

As at 31 December 2015, certain of the Group’s borrowings were secured by the Group’s cash at bank of<br />

USD39,000 (31 December 2014: USD7,297,000) (see Note 23).<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

167


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

23 BORROWINGS<br />

(a)<br />

The Group’s long-term interest-bearing borrowings comprise:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Bank loan<br />

– secured 144,818 241,636<br />

– unsecured 40,000 40,000<br />

Less: Current portion of long-term borrowings<br />

less amortised transaction costs (182,631) (114,818)<br />

Less: Unamortised transaction costs (2,187) (4,840)<br />

— 161,978<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Group’s long-term interest-bearing borrowings from European Bank for<br />

Reconstruction and Development, Nederlandse Financierings-Maatschappij voor Ontwikkelingslanden<br />

N.V., and Deutsche Investitions-und Entwicklungsgesellschaft mbH were due within one year, which<br />

were with principal amount of USD40,909,000 (2014: USD81,818,000), USD6,545,000 (2014:<br />

USD13,091,000) and USD4,364,000 (2014: USD8,727,000), respectively, bearing interest of one month<br />

LIBOR + 3.5%~3.75% per annum, and were secured by the Group’s property, plant and equipment (see<br />

Note 13) and cash at bank (see Note 22).<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the Group’s long-term interest-bearing borrowings from BNP Paribas,<br />

Singapore Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited (the “BNP and ICBC<br />

Facility”) of USD93,000,000 (2014: USD138,000,000) were due within one year, which were with<br />

principal amount, bearing interest of 3 months LIBOR + 6.00% per annum, and were secured by the<br />

Group’s cash at bank (see Note 22) and inventories (see Note 20). The attributable transaction cost<br />

amounts to USD2,008,000 as at 31 December 2015. The BNP Paribas facility was initially contracted<br />

with Standard Bank Plc. On 18 December 2013, the Standard Bank Plc transferred all of its rights,<br />

title and interest in (and obligations under) the facility to BNP Paribas, Singapore Branch. On 5 March<br />

2014, the facility was refinanced to a facilities agreement with two international banks as arrangers and<br />

original lenders, BNP Paribas Singapore Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited.<br />

The BNP and ICBC Facility is a coal pre-export loan facility of USD150,000,000 bearing interest of<br />

LIBOR + 6.00% per annum.<br />

In March 2014, the Group refinanced short-term loans of USD40,000,000 into a revolving credit<br />

facility, and extended its maturity date to 20 March 2015 with an interest of 10.0% per annum. On 31<br />

December 2014, the maturity date was extended to 20 March 2016, and interest for the extension<br />

period is 11.20% per annum. On 21 March 2016, the maturity date was further extended to 20 June<br />

2016, and interest for the extension period is 11.20% per annum.<br />

168<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

23 BORROWINGS (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

The Group’s long-term interest-bearing borrowings comprise: (Continued)<br />

The Group’s long-term borrowings are repayable as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Within 1 year or on demand 184,818 114,818<br />

After 1 year but within 2 years — 166,818<br />

184,818 281,636<br />

(b)<br />

The Group’s short-term interest-bearing borrowings comprise:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Bank loans<br />

– Unsecured 15,000 —<br />

Current portion of long-term borrowings<br />

– Bank loan 184,818 114,818<br />

Less: Unamortised transaction costs (2,187) —<br />

197,631 114,818<br />

On 24 February 2016, the Group had repaid the USD5,000,000 short-term loan by converting it into<br />

coal pre-payment facility.<br />

Certain bank loans of the Group are subject to the fulfilment of covenants relating to certain of the<br />

Group’s financial ratios, as are commonly found in lending arrangements with financial institutions.<br />

The Group was in breach of certain security coverage ratio and financial covenants under the BNP and<br />

ICBC Facility as at 31 December 2015.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

169


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

24 TRADE AND OTHER PAYABLES<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Trade payables (Note (i)) 39,287 125,217<br />

Receipts in advance (Note (ii)) 40,016 16,866<br />

Amounts due to related parties (Note (iii)) 11,565 8,102<br />

Payables for purchase of equipment 2,691 4,858<br />

Security deposit on construction work 978 1,340<br />

Interest payable 18,961 18,081<br />

Other taxes payables 3,310 20,782<br />

Promissory notes (Note (iv)) 72,230 66,601<br />

Others (Note (v)) 24,391 36,271<br />

213,429 298,118<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

As of the end of the reporting period, the ageing analysis of trade creditors and bills payable (which are included in<br />

trade and other payables), based on the invoice date, is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Within 90 days 14,122 40,958<br />

90 to 180 days 2,153 22,410<br />

180 to 365 days 14,019 58,380<br />

Over 365 days 8,993 3,469<br />

39,287 125,217<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

Receipts in advance represent payments in advance made by third party customers in accordance with the terms<br />

set out in respective sales agreements.<br />

Amounts due to related parties represent contractual service fee payable and payables for equipment and<br />

construction work, which are unsecured, interest-free and have no fixed terms of repayments (see Note 32(a)).<br />

170<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

24 TRADE AND OTHER PAYABLES (Continued)<br />

Note: (Continued)<br />

(iv)<br />

On 27 November 2012, the Company issued two promissory notes to QGX Holdings Ltd., each in the amount of<br />

USD52,500,000, and shall bear interest at a rate of 3.0% per annum commencing on the issue date to the maturity<br />

date. The original maturity date was 22 November 2013. On 8 February 2013, an amendment agreement was signed<br />

by the Company and QGX Holdings Ltd. to extend the maturity date of two promissory notes from 22 November<br />

2013 to 31 March 2014 and 31 December 2014, respectively.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2014, based on the new amendment agreements, the Group offset<br />

USD45,174,000 of promissory notes principal and accrued interest with the trade receivables due from affiliated<br />

company of QGX Holdings Ltd. On 31 December 2014, the maturity date of two promissory notes was extended to<br />

31 March 2015, with a rate of 8.0% per annum to the maturity date.<br />

On 31 March 2015, the maturity date of two promissory notes was further extended to 30 June 2015, with a rate<br />

of 8.0% per annum to the maturity date. On 30 June 2015, the maturity date of two promissory notes was further<br />

extended to 30 September 2015, with a rate of 8.0% per annum to the maturity date. On 30 September 2015, the<br />

maturity date of two promissory notes was further extended to 31 December 2015, with a rate of 8.0% per annum<br />

to the maturity date. On 31 December 2015, the maturity date of two promissory notes was extended to 31 March<br />

2016, with a rate of 8.0% per annum to the maturity date.<br />

(v)<br />

Others represent mainly accrued expenses, payables for staff related costs and other deposits.<br />

All of the other payables and receipts in advance are expected to be settled or recognised in profit or loss<br />

within one year or are repayable on demand.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

171


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

25 INCOME TAX IN THE CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL<br />

POSITION<br />

(a)<br />

Tax payable in the consolidated statement of financial position represents:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

At 1 January 68 3,426<br />

Provision for the year (Note 7(a)) 647 8,492<br />

Offsetting with other tax receivables (321) (11,369)<br />

Income tax paid (404) (175)<br />

Exchange adjustments 154 (306)<br />

At 31 December 144 68<br />

(b)<br />

Deferred tax assets and liabilities recognised<br />

The components of deferred tax assets/(liabilities) recognised in the consolidated balance sheet and<br />

the movements during the year are as follows:<br />

Unrealised<br />

foreign<br />

exchange<br />

differences<br />

on long-term<br />

borrowings<br />

Fair value<br />

adjustments<br />

in relation<br />

to the<br />

Acquisition<br />

Tax losses<br />

Unrealised<br />

profits on<br />

intra-group<br />

transactions<br />

Depreciation<br />

and<br />

amortisation<br />

Allowance<br />

for doubtful<br />

debts<br />

Total<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Deferred tax arising from:<br />

At 1 January 2014 9,462 (532) 4,742 5,986 1,256 (148,760) (127,846)<br />

Credited to profit or loss<br />

(Note 7(a)) 13,893 332 1,372 2,520 1,277 48,076 67,470<br />

Exchange adjustments (1,667) 53 (702) (827) (153) — (3,296)<br />

At 31 December 2014 21,688 (147) 5,412 7,679 2,380 (100,684) (63,672)<br />

At 1 January 2015 21,688 (147) 5,412 7,679 2,380 (100,684) (63,672)<br />

Credited/(charged) to profit<br />

or loss (Note 7(a)) 14,440 (657) 888 (3,107) (1,691) — 9,873<br />

Exchange adjustments (1,389) 94 (336) (386) (38) — (2,055)<br />

At 31 December 2015 34,739 (710) 5,964 4,186 651 (100,684) (55,854)<br />

172<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

25 INCOME TAX IN THE CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL<br />

POSITION (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Deferred tax assets and liabilities recognised (Continued)<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Net deferred tax assets recognised in<br />

the consolidated balance sheet 46,629 37,968<br />

Net deferred tax liabilities recognised in<br />

the consolidated balance sheet (102,483) (101,640)<br />

(55,854) (63,672)<br />

(c)<br />

Deferred tax assets not recognised<br />

In accordance with the accounting policy set out in Note 2(r), the Group has not recognised deferred<br />

tax assets in respect of cumulative tax losses of USD341,188,000 as at 31 December 2015 (2014:<br />

USD252,460,000) as it is not probable that future taxable profits against which the losses can be<br />

utilised will be available in the relevant tax jurisdiction and entity. According to the new amendment<br />

to Mongolian Corporate Income Tax Law which is effective on 1 January 2010, for entities engaged in<br />

mining or infrastructure construction, the tax losses generated after 1 January 2010 will expire in four<br />

to eight years after the tax losses generated under current tax legislation. Tax losses of other entities<br />

will expire in two years after the tax losses generated.<br />

Expiry of unrecognised tax losses of group entities located in Mongolia:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Year of expiry<br />

2016 7,646 8,094<br />

2017 13,303 —<br />

2018 31 33<br />

2019 125 —<br />

21,105 8,127<br />

In relation to group entities located in the jurisdictions other than Mongolia, the tax losses amounting to<br />

USD320,083,000 as at 31 December 2015 do not expire under current tax legislations (31 December<br />

2014: USD239,687,000).<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

173


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

25 INCOME TAX IN THE CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL<br />

POSITION (Continued)<br />

(d)<br />

Deferred tax liabilities not recognised<br />

At 31 December 2015, temporary differences relating to the undistributed profits of subsidiaries<br />

amounted to nil (2014: nil). Deferred tax liabilities of nil (2014: nil) have not been recognised in respect<br />

of the tax that would be payable on the distribution of these retained profits as the Company controls<br />

the dividend policy of these subsidiaries and it has been determined that it is probable that profits will<br />

not be distributed in the foreseeable future.<br />

26 SENIOR NOTES<br />

USD’000<br />

At 1 January 2014 594,329<br />

Interest charged during the year (Note 6(a)) 54,827<br />

Interest payable (53,250)<br />

At 31 December 2014 595,906<br />

At 1 January 2015 595,906<br />

Interest charged during the year (Note 6(a)) 54,978<br />

Interest payable (53,250)<br />

At 31 December 2015 597,634<br />

On 29 March 2012, the Company issued guaranteed senior notes in the aggregate principal amount of<br />

USD600,000,000 which were listed on the Singapore Exchange Securities Trading Limited. The senior notes<br />

bear interest at 8.875% per annum, payable semi-annually in arrears, and will be due in 2017.<br />

The senior notes may be redeemed at the option of the Company upon giving not less than 30 days or no<br />

more than 60 days notice to the holders.<br />

The Company has agreed, for the benefit of the holders of the senior notes, to pledge all of the capital stock<br />

of Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited owned by the Company and to cause Mongolian Coal Corporation<br />

Limited to pledge all of the capital stock of Mongolian Coal Corporation S.à.r.l. owned by Mongolian Coal<br />

Corporation Limited. The senior notes are guaranteed by some of the Company’s subsidiaries, namely<br />

Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited, Mongolian Coal Corporation S.à.r.l., Energy Resources Corporation<br />

LLC, Energy Resources LLC, Energy Resources Mining LLC and Transgobi LLC.<br />

174<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

26 SENIOR NOTES (Continued)<br />

The senior notes have been accounted for as a hybrid financial instrument containing both a derivative<br />

component and a liability component.<br />

The derivative component was initially recognised at its fair value of USD4,920,000, and the attributable<br />

transaction cost of USD107,000 was charged to profit or loss for the year ended 31 December 2012. The<br />

fair value of the derivative component as at 31 December 2015 was nil (2014: nil) which was presented as<br />

derivative financial instruments.<br />

The liability component was initially recognised at amortised cost of USD591,707,000, after taking into<br />

account attributable transaction costs of USD13,213,000.<br />

Fair value of the derivative component was valued by the directors with the reference to a valuation report<br />

issued by an independent business valuer based on the Binomial model.<br />

The Group is seeking a potential restructuring of the US$600,000,000 8.875% senior notes. The Group<br />

has appointed restructuring advisers to assist with negotiations with the holders of the senior notes and to<br />

achieve the debt restructuring in respect of the senior notes. Further details are set out in Note 2(b).<br />

27 EQUITY-SETTLED SHARE-BASED PAYMENT TRANSACTIONS<br />

The Company has a share option scheme (“Share Option Scheme”) which was adopted on 17 September<br />

2010 whereby the board of directors of the Group are authorised, at their discretion, invites eligible<br />

participants to receive options to subscribe for shares subject to the terms and conditions stipulated therein<br />

as incentives or rewards for their contributions to the Group.<br />

Under the Share Option Scheme, the Company may grant options to employees and directors, suppliers,<br />

customers and professional advisers of the Group to subscribe for shares of the Company. The exercise<br />

price of the options is determined by the board of directors of the Company at the time of grant, and shall<br />

be the highest of the nominal value of the shares, the closing price of the shares at the date of grant and the<br />

average closing price of the shares for the five business days immediately preceding the date of grant. The<br />

Share Option Scheme remains in force for a period of 10 years commencing on its adoption date and will<br />

expire on 12 October 2020.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

175


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

27 EQUITY-SETTLED SHARE-BASED PAYMENT TRANSACTIONS<br />

(Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

The terms and conditions of the grants are as follows:<br />

Grant Date<br />

Number of<br />

options<br />

’000<br />

Vesting conditions<br />

Contractual life<br />

of options<br />

12 October 2011 8,800 12 October 2011 12 October 2011<br />

to 12 October 2012 to 12 October 2019<br />

12 October 2011 8,800 12 October 2011 12 October 2011<br />

to 12 October 2013 to 12 October 2019<br />

12 October 2011 8,800 12 October 2011 12 October 2011<br />

to 12 October 2014 to 12 October 2019<br />

12 October 2011 8,800 12 October 2011 12 October 2011<br />

to 12 October 2015 to 12 October 2019<br />

28 November 2012 5,688 28 November 2012 28 November 2012<br />

to 28 November 2013 to 28 November 2020<br />

28 November 2012 5,688 28 November 2012 28 November 2012<br />

to 28 November 2014 to 28 November 2020<br />

28 November 2012 11,374 28 November 2012 28 November 2012<br />

to 28 November 2015 to 28 November 2020<br />

10 June 2015 38,688 10 June 2015 10 June 2015<br />

to 10 June 2020<br />

10 June 2015 38,688 10 June 2015 10 June 2015<br />

to 10 June 2016 to 10 June 2020<br />

10 June 2015 38,687 10 June 2015 10 June 2015<br />

to 10 June 2017 to 10 June 2020<br />

10 June 2015 38,687 10 June 2015 10 June 2015<br />

to 10 June 2018 to 10 June 2020<br />

Total share options 212,700<br />

176<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

27 EQUITY-SETTLED SHARE-BASED PAYMENT TRANSACTIONS<br />

(Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

The movement of the number and weighted average exercise prices of share options are as<br />

follows:<br />

Weighted<br />

average<br />

exercise<br />

Price<br />

2015 2014<br />

Number of<br />

options<br />

Weighted<br />

average<br />

exercise<br />

Price<br />

Number of<br />

options<br />

HKD ’000 HKD ’000<br />

Outstanding at 1 January (Note (i)) 3.09 70,735 5.42 50,113<br />

Granted during the year 0.45 154,750 — —<br />

Forfeited during the year 4.53 (275) 5.30 (2,013)<br />

Outstanding at 31 December 1.21 225,210 5.42 48,100<br />

Exercisable at 31 December 2.09 102,530 5.69 32,038<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

As a result of the rights issue completed on 29 December 2014, adjustments were required to be<br />

made to the exercise price and the number of Shares falling to be issued upon the exercise of the<br />

Share Options in accordance with the terms of the Share Option Scheme and the supplementary<br />

guidance issued by the Stock Exchange on 5 September 2005 regarding the adjustment of share<br />

options under Rule 17.03(13) of the Listing Rules.<br />

A total of 48,100,000 Options are outstanding under the Share Option Scheme as at the completion<br />

of the rights issue. The exercise price and the number of the Shares falling to be issued under the<br />

outstanding Share Options have been adjusted pursuant to Clause 11 of the Share Option Scheme (the<br />

“Option Adjustments”), with effect from 1 January 2015, and such adjustments have been reviewed<br />

and confirmed by the independent financial adviser of the Company, Somerley Capital Limited, as<br />

follows:<br />

Date of grant<br />

Exercise period<br />

Original<br />

Subscription<br />

Price (HKD)<br />

Original<br />

number of<br />

Shares<br />

subject to<br />

Options<br />

Adjusted<br />

Subscription<br />

Price (HKD)<br />

Adjusted<br />

number of<br />

Shares<br />

subject to<br />

Options<br />

Basis of<br />

additional<br />

Shares pursuant<br />

to the Option<br />

Adjustments<br />

12 October 2011 12 October 2012 to 12 October 2019 6.66 26,350,000 4.53 38,750,000 8 additional Shares<br />

12 October 2013 to 12 October 2019 for every 17 Shares<br />

12 October 2014 to 12 October 2019 subject to Options<br />

12 October 2015 to 12 October 2019<br />

28 November 2012 28 November 2013 to 12 October 2020 3.92 21,750,000 2.67 31,985,294 8 additional Shares<br />

28 November 2014 to 12 October 2020 for every 17 Shares<br />

28 November 2015 to 12 October 2020 subject to Options<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

177


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

27 EQUITY-SETTLED SHARE-BASED PAYMENT TRANSACTIONS<br />

(Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

The movement of the number and weighted average exercise prices of share options are as<br />

follows: (Continued)<br />

The options outstanding at 31 December 2015 had an exercise price of HKD4.53 or HKD2.67 or<br />

HKD0.445 (2014: HKD6.66 or HKD3.92) per share and a weighted average remaining contractual life of<br />

4.4 years (2014: 5.3 years).<br />

(c)<br />

Fair value of share options and assumptions<br />

The fair value of services received in return for share options granted is measured by reference to<br />

the fair value of share options granted. The estimate of the fair value of the share options granted is<br />

measured based on the Black-Scholes option pricing model. The variables of the models included<br />

expected life of the options, risk-free interest rate, expected volatility and expected dividend of the<br />

shares of the Company.<br />

Fair value of share options and assumptions<br />

10 June 2015 28 November 2012 12 October 2011<br />

Fair value at measurement date HKD0.160 HKD1.8155 HKD3.3793<br />

~HKD0.220 ~ HKD2.0303 ~ HKD3.7663<br />

Share price HKD0.445 HKD3.92 HKD6.66<br />

Exercise price HKD0.445 HKD3.92 HKD6.66<br />

Expected life 5 years 4.5-5.5 years 4.5-6 years<br />

Risk-free interest rate 1.19% 0.249%~0.298% 0.755%~1.054%<br />

Expected volatility 60% 57.71%~59.43% 61.87%~63.43%<br />

Expected dividends — — —<br />

The expected volatility is based on the historic volatility of entities in the same industry (calculated<br />

based on the weighted average remaining life of the share options), adjusted for any expected<br />

changes to future volatility based on publicly available information. Expected dividends are based on<br />

management’s estimates. The risk-free interest rate is based on the yield of Hong Kong Exchange Fund<br />

Notes corresponding to the expected life of the options as at the grant date. Changes in the subjective<br />

input assumptions could materially affect the fair value estimate.<br />

Share options were granted under a service condition. The condition has not been taken into account<br />

in the grant date fair value measurement of the services received. There was no market condition<br />

associated with the share option grants.<br />

178<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

28 PROVISIONS<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Accrued reclamation obligations 13,567 12,995<br />

Others 1,500 1,500<br />

15,067 14,495<br />

Less: Current portion (1,500) (1,500)<br />

13,567 12,995<br />

The accrual for reclamation costs has been determined based on management’s best estimates. The<br />

estimate of the associated costs may be subject to change in the near term when the reclamation on<br />

the land from current mining activities becomes apparent in future periods. At the end of each reporting<br />

period, the Group reassessed the estimated costs and adjusted the accrued reclamation obligations, where<br />

necessary. The Group’s management believes that the accrued reclamation obligations at 31 December<br />

2015 are adequate and appropriate. The accrual is based on estimates and therefore, the ultimate liability<br />

may exceed or be less than such estimates. The movement of the accrued reclamation cost is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

At 1 January 12,995 10,118<br />

Increase for reassessment of estimated costs (Note 13(c)) 454 3,467<br />

Accretion expense (Note 6(a)) 854 808<br />

Exchange adjustments (736) (1,398)<br />

At 31 December 13,567 12,995<br />

Accrued reclamation costs change during the years ended 31 December 2015 and 2014 result from the<br />

reassessment of estimated costs.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

179


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

29 CAPITAL, RESERVES AND DIVIDENDS<br />

(a)<br />

Movements in components of equity<br />

The reconciliation between the opening and closing balances of each component of the Group’s<br />

consolidated equity is set out in the consolidated statement of changes in equity. Details of the<br />

changes in the Company’s individual components of equity between the beginning and the end of the<br />

year are set out below:<br />

Note Share capital Share premium Other reserve<br />

Accumulated<br />

losses Total equity<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

(Note 29(c)) (Note 29(e) (i)) (Note 29(e) (ii))<br />

At 1 January 2014 37,050 608,650 12,481 (164,084) 494,097<br />

Changes in equity for 2014:<br />

Total comprehensive income — — — (68,442) (68,442)<br />

Issuance of shares under rights issue 29(d) 55,576 139,877 — — 195,453<br />

Equity-settled share-based transactions 27 — — 3,475 — 3,475<br />

At 31 December 2014 92,626 748,527 15,956 (232,526) 624,583<br />

At 1 January 2015 92,626 748,527 15,956 (232,526) 624,583<br />

Changes in equity for 2015::<br />

Total comprehensive income — — — (74,562) (74,562)<br />

Equity-settled share-based transactions 27 — — 3,298 — 3,298<br />

At 31 December 2015 92,626 748,527 19,254 (307,088) 553,319<br />

(b)<br />

Dividends<br />

The board of directors of the Company does not recommend the payment of a final dividend in respect<br />

of the year ended 31 December 2015.<br />

(c)<br />

Share capital<br />

The Company was incorporated on 18 May 2010 with an authorised share capital of USD50,000<br />

comprising 5,000,000 ordinary shares of USD0.01 each. On 18 May 2010, MCS Mining Group<br />

Limited acquired its initial share of one share of USD0.01. By an ordinary resolution passed at the<br />

annual general meeting held on 23 August 2010, the Company’s authorised ordinary share capital<br />

was increased to USD60,000,000 by the creation of an additional 5,995,000,000 ordinary shares of<br />

USD0.01 each, ranking pari passu with the existing ordinary shares of the Company in all respects.<br />

180<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

29 CAPITAL, RESERVES AND DIVIDENDS (Continued)<br />

(d)<br />

Issuance of shares under rights issue<br />

On 29 December 2014, 5,557,554,750 ordinary shares were issued pursuant to the rights issue on<br />

the basis of three rights shares for every two existing shares at HKD0.28 each. Total net consideration<br />

amounted to USD195,453,000, of which USD55,576,000 was credited to share capital and the<br />

remaining proceeds of USD139,877,000 was credited to the share premium account. The Company’s<br />

authorised ordinary share capital was increased to USD150,000,000 by the creation of an additional<br />

9,000,000,000 ordinary shares of USD0.01 each, raking pair with the existing ordinary shares of the<br />

Company in all respects.<br />

The aggregate amount of share capital of the companies now comprising the Group, after elimination<br />

of interests in subsidiaries, was included in other reserve during the years ended 31 December 2015<br />

and 2014 (Note 29(e) (ii)).<br />

The Company<br />

No of<br />

shares’000<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000<br />

No of<br />

shares’000<br />

USD’000<br />

Authorised:<br />

Ordinary shares 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 150,000<br />

Ordinary shares, issued and fully paid:<br />

At 31 December 2015 At 31 December 2014<br />

No of<br />

shares’000<br />

USD’000<br />

No of<br />

shares’000<br />

USD’000<br />

Ordinary shares 9,262,591 92,626 9,262,591 92,626<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

181


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

29 CAPITAL, RESERVES AND DIVIDENDS (Continued)<br />

(e)<br />

Nature and purpose of reserves<br />

(i)<br />

Share premium<br />

Under the Companies Law of the Cayman Islands, the share premium account of the Company<br />

may be applied for payment of distributions or dividends to shareholders provided that<br />

immediately following the date on which the distribution or dividend is proposed to be paid, the<br />

Company is able to pay its debts as they fall due in the ordinary courses of business.<br />

(ii)<br />

Other reserve<br />

The other reserve comprises the following:<br />

– the aggregate amount of share capital and other reserves of the companies now comprising<br />

the Group after elimination of the investments in subsidiaries; and<br />

– the portion of the grant date fair value of unexercised share options granted to directors and<br />

employees of the Company that has been recognised in accordance with the accounting<br />

policy adopted for share-based payments in Note 2(q) (ii).<br />

(iii) Exchange reserve<br />

The exchange reserve comprises all foreign exchange adjustments arising from the translation of<br />

the MNT denominated financial statements of the Group’s operations to the Group’s presentation<br />

currency. The reserve is dealt with in accordance with the accounting policy set out in Note 2(v).<br />

(f)<br />

Distributability of reserves<br />

Pursuant to the Companies Law, Cap.22 (Law 3 of 1961, as consolidated and reserved) of the Cayman<br />

Islands, share premium of the Company is distributable to the shareholders. Other than the share<br />

premium, there is no other amount available for distribution to equity shareholders of the Company as<br />

at 31 December 2015.<br />

(g)<br />

Capital management<br />

The Group’s primary objectives when managing capital are to safeguard the Group’s ability to continue<br />

as a going concern, so that it can continue to provide returns for shareholders and benefits for other<br />

stakeholders. The Group defines the capital as total shareholders’ equity plus loans and borrowings.<br />

The Group actively and regularly reviews and manages its capital structure to maintain a balance<br />

between the higher shareholder returns that might be possible with higher levels of borrowings and the<br />

advantages and security afforded by a sound capital position.<br />

The gearing ratio (calculated as total bank and other borrowings divided by total assets) of the Group<br />

as at 31 December 2015 was 57.0% (2014: 46.6% before considering provision for impairment loss on<br />

non-financial assets, and 51.9% after considering it).<br />

182<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS<br />

(a)<br />

Financial risk management objectives and policies<br />

Management has adopted certain policies on financial risk management with the objective of:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

ensuring that appropriate funding strategies are adopted to meet the Group’s short-term and<br />

long-term funding requirements taking into consideration the cost of funding, gearing levels and<br />

cash flow projections of each project and that of the Group; and<br />

ensuring that appropriate strategies are also adopted to manage related interest and currency risk<br />

funding.<br />

(b)<br />

Credit risk<br />

The Group’s credit risk is primarily attributable to cash at bank, trade and other receivables.<br />

Management monitors the exposures to these credit risks on an ongoing basis.<br />

Substantially all of the Group’s cash at bank are deposited in the reputable banks which management<br />

assessed the credit risk to be insignificant.<br />

Trade receivables are presented net of allowance for doubtful debts. In order to minimise the credit<br />

risk, the credit management committee, comprising the senior management team of the Group, has<br />

established a policy for determining credit limits, credit approvals and other monitoring procedures<br />

to ensure that follow-up action is taken to recover overdue debts. The credit management committee<br />

also evaluates and reviews the credit quality and the recoverable amount of each individual trade<br />

debt on an ongoing basis. These evaluations and reviews focus on the customer’s past history of<br />

making payments when due and current ability to pay, and take into account information specific to<br />

the customer as well as pertaining to the economic environment in which the customer operates. The<br />

Group establishes an allowance for doubtful debts that represents its estimate of losses in respect<br />

of trade receivables. The components of this allowance are a specific loss component that relates to<br />

individually significant exposures, and a collective loss component established for groups of similar<br />

assets. At the balance sheet date, the Group believes that adequate allowance for doubtful debts has<br />

been made in the consolidated financial statements. In this regard, the directors consider that the<br />

Group’s credit risk is significantly reduced. The Group does not hold any collateral as security for these<br />

receivables. The Group has a certain concentration credit risk as three customers accounted for 90.5%<br />

(2014: 56.5%) of the total trade receivables as at 31 December 2015.<br />

The Group closely monitors the amount due from related parties.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

183


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(b)<br />

Credit risk (Continued)<br />

VAT receivables include amounts that have been accumulated to date in various subsidiaries.<br />

According to the prevailing tax rules and regulations in Mongolia, a taxpayer may offset future taxes<br />

and royalties payable to the Government against VAT amounts receivable from the Government of<br />

Mongolia. In July 2009, the Mongolian Tax Laws were amended to preclude producers and exporters<br />

of unfinished mineral products from claiming back VAT and any VAT amounts impacted is prospective<br />

from the effective date of the law on 16 August 2009. On 10 November 2010, the Government defined<br />

finished mineral products as products which qualify for claiming back VAT. During the year ended 31<br />

December 2015, the Group offset current income tax payable, air pollution fee, royalty tax payable and<br />

payables due to suppliers owing of USD244,000, USD1,271,000, USD4,162,000 and USD22,349,000,<br />

respectively, against its VAT receivable balance. Based on currently available information, the Group<br />

anticipates full recoverability of amounts due on account primarily relating to finished mineral products<br />

at 31 December 2015. Verification by the Mongolian Government Taxation Authority of the collectability<br />

of the funds is conducted on a regular basis and any outstanding VAT receivable amounts at 31<br />

December 2015 will be available to the Group to offset future taxes and royalty tax or will be refunded<br />

by the Government of Mongolia Taxation Authority.<br />

Further quantitative disclosures in respect of the Group’s exposure to credit risk arising from trade and<br />

other receivables are set out in Note 21.<br />

(c)<br />

Foreign currency exchange risk<br />

The Group is exposed to currency risk primarily through sales, purchases and borrowings which<br />

give rise to receivables, payables, borrowings and cash balances that are denominated in a foreign<br />

currency, i.e. a currency other than the functional currency of the operations to which the transactions<br />

relate. The functional currency of the Group’s Mongolian entities is MNT and of the Group’s overseas<br />

entities is USD. The currencies giving rise to this risk are primarily RMB, USD and HKD.<br />

184<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(c)<br />

Foreign currency exchange risk (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Exposure to currency risk<br />

The following table details the Group’s exposure at the balance sheet date to currency risk arising<br />

from recognised assets or liabilities denominated in a currency other than the functional currency<br />

of the entity to which they relate. For presentation purpose, the amounts of the exposure are<br />

shown in USD, translated using the spot rate at the year end date.<br />

Exposure to foreign currencies (expressed in United States Dollars)<br />

2015 2014<br />

United<br />

United<br />

States Hong Kong States Hong Kong<br />

Renminbi Dollars Dollars Renminbi Dollars Dollars<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Trade and other receivables 2,103 — — 8,921 45,620 —<br />

Cash at bank and in hand 9 50,141 — 149 236,966 8,657<br />

Trade and other payables (9,519) (110,470) (588) (11,498) (89,863) (3,350)<br />

Short-term borrowings and<br />

current portion of long-term<br />

borrowings — (101,818) — — (51,818) —<br />

Long-term borrowings, less<br />

current portion — — — — (91,818) —<br />

Net exposure arising from<br />

Recognised assets<br />

and liabilities (7,407) (162,147) (588) (2,428) 49,087 5,307<br />

(ii)<br />

Sensitivity analysis<br />

An 5% strengthening/weakening of other currency against functional currencies defined in Note<br />

2(v) as at the respective balance sheet dates would decrease/(increase) loss after taxation by the<br />

amount shown below. This analysis assumes that all other risk variables remained constant.<br />

2015 2014<br />

Loss/profit for the year USD’000 USD’000<br />

5% increase in RMB (284) (8)<br />

5% decrease in RMB 284 8<br />

5% increase in USD (6,095) 3,228<br />

5% decrease in USD 6,095 (3,228)<br />

5% increase in HKD (29) 264<br />

5% decrease in HKD 29 (264)<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

185


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(d)<br />

Interest rate risk<br />

The Group’s interest rate risk arises primarily from short-term borrowings, long-term borrowings and<br />

convertible bond. Borrowings issued at variable rates expose the Group to cash flow interest rate risk<br />

and fair value interest rate risk, respectively.<br />

The following table details the profile of the Group’s net borrowings (interest-bearing financial liabilities<br />

less interest-bearing financial assets) at the balance sheet date. The detailed interest rates and maturity<br />

information of the Group’s and the Company’s borrowings are disclosed in Note 23.<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Net fixed rate borrowings:<br />

Borrowings 55,000 40,000<br />

Obligations under finance lease — 8<br />

Senior notes 597,634 595,906<br />

Promissory notes 72,230 66,601<br />

Less: Bank deposits (50,000) (50,000)<br />

674,864 652,515<br />

Net floating rate borrowings:<br />

Borrowings 142,631 236,796<br />

Less: Bank deposits (689) (202,808)<br />

141,942 33,988<br />

Total net borrowings: 816,806 686,503<br />

At 31 December 2015, it is estimated that a general increase/decrease of 100 basis points in interest<br />

rates, with all other variables held constant, would have increased/decreased the Group’s loss after<br />

taxation and decreased/increased retained earnings by approximately USD1,737,000 (31 December<br />

2014: USD332,000).<br />

The sensitivity analysis above indicates the instantaneous change in the Group’s loss after tax that<br />

would arise assuming that the change in interest rates had occurred at the balance sheet date and had<br />

been applied to re-measure those financial instruments held by the Group which expose the Group to<br />

fair value interest rate risk at the balance sheet date. In respect of the expose to cash flow interest rate<br />

risk arising from floating rate non-derivative instruments held by the Group at the balance sheet date,<br />

the impact on the Group’s loss after tax and retained profits and other components of consolidated<br />

equity is estimated as an annualised impact on interest expense or income of such a change in interest<br />

rates.<br />

186<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(e)<br />

Liquidity risk<br />

The Group has to maintain a suitable level of liquidity to finance the daily operation, capital expenditure<br />

and repayment of borrowings. The Group’s policy is to regularly monitor current and expected liquidity<br />

requirements to ensure that it maintains sufficient reserves of cash and adequate committed lines of<br />

funding from major financial institutions to meet its liquidity requirements in the short and longer term.<br />

The following table details the remaining contractual maturities at the balance sheet date of the<br />

Group’s financial liabilities, which are based on contractual undiscounted cash flows (including interest<br />

payments computed using contractual rates or, if floating, based on rates current at the balance sheet<br />

date) and the earliest date the Group can be required to pay:<br />

2015<br />

Contractual undiscounted cash outflow<br />

After After Total Balance<br />

1 year but 2 years but contractual sheet<br />

within within within After undiscounted carrying<br />

1 year 2 years 5 years 5 years cash flow amount<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Borrowings (Note 23) 199,818 — — — 199,818 197,631<br />

Trade and other payables (Note 24) 218,930 — — — 218,930 213,429<br />

Senior notes (Note 26) 53,250 626,625 — — 679,875 597,634<br />

471,998 626,625 — — 1,098,623 1,008,694<br />

2014<br />

Contractual undiscounted cash outflow<br />

After After Total Balance<br />

1 year but 2 years but contractual sheet<br />

within within within After undiscounted carrying<br />

1 year 2 years 5 years 5 years cash flow amount<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Borrowings (Note 23) 129,807 175,482 — — 305,289 276,796<br />

Trade and other payables (Note 24) 299,432 — — — 299,432 298,118<br />

Senior notes (Note 26) 53,250 53,250 626,625 — 733,125 595,906<br />

482,489 228,732 626,625 — 1,337,846 1,170,820<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

187


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(f)<br />

Fair value measurement<br />

(i)<br />

Financial assets and liabilities measured at fair value<br />

Fair value hierarchy<br />

The following table presents the fair value of the Group’s financial instruments measured at the<br />

balance sheet date on a recurring basis, categorised into the three-level fair value hierarchy as<br />

defined in IFRS 13, Fair value measurement. The level into which a fair value measurement is<br />

classified is determined with reference to the observability and significance of the inputs used in<br />

the valuation technique as follows:<br />

• Level 1 valuations: Fair value measured using only Level 1 inputs i.e. unadjusted quoted<br />

prices in active markets for identical assets or liabilities at the measurement date.<br />

• Level 2 valuations: Fair value measured using Level 2 inputs i.e. observable inputs which<br />

fail to meet Level 1, and not using significant unobservable inputs. Unobservable inputs are<br />

inputs for which market data are not available.<br />

• Level 3 valuations: Fair value measured using significant unobservable inputs.<br />

Fair value of the Group’s financial instruments, including redemption option embedded in senior<br />

notes and conversion option embedded in convertible notes which is categorised into Level 3 of<br />

the fair value hierarchy was valued by the directors with the reference to a valuation report issued<br />

by an independent business valuer.<br />

Fair value at<br />

31 December<br />

Fair value measurements<br />

as at 31 December<br />

2015 categorised into<br />

2015 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Recurring fair<br />

value measurement<br />

Assets<br />

– Redemption option<br />

embedded in senior notes — — — —<br />

188<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(f)<br />

Fair value measurement (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Financial assets and liabilities measured at fair value (Continued)<br />

Fair value at<br />

31 December<br />

Fair value measurements<br />

as at 31 December<br />

2014 categorised into<br />

2014 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3<br />

USD’000 USD’000 USD’000 USD’000<br />

Recurring fair<br />

value measurement<br />

Assets<br />

– Redemption option<br />

embedded in senior notes — — — —<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015 and 2014, there were no transfers between Level 1 and<br />

Level 2, or transfers into or out of Level 3. The Group’s policy is to recognise transfers between<br />

levels of fair value hierarchy as at the balance sheet date in which they occur.<br />

Information about Level 3 fair value measurements<br />

Significant<br />

Valuation unobservable Expected<br />

techniques inputs volatility<br />

Redemption option<br />

embedded in senior notes Binomial model Expected volatility 38%<br />

The fair value of redemption option embedded in senior notes is determined using binomial model<br />

and the significant unobservable input used in the fair value measurement is expected volatility.<br />

The fair value measurement is positively correlated to the expected volatility. As at 31 December<br />

2015, it is estimated that with all other variables held constant, an increase/decrease in the<br />

expected volatility by 1% would have decreased/increased the Group’s loss by USD100,000.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

189


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

30 FINANCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL<br />

INSTRUMENTS (Continued)<br />

(f)<br />

Fair value measurement (Continued)<br />

(i)<br />

Financial assets and liabilities measured at fair value (Continued)<br />

The movement during the period in the balance of Level 3 fair value measurements is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Redemption option embedded in senior notes:<br />

At 1 January — 700<br />

Changes in fair value recognised<br />

in profit or loss during the period — (700)<br />

At 31 December — —<br />

The changes in fair value arising from the remeasurement of the redemption option and<br />

conversion option embedded in senior notes are presented in “finance costs/income” in the<br />

consolidated statement of comprehensive income.<br />

(ii)<br />

Fair value of financial assets and liabilities carried at other than fair value<br />

In respect of cash and cash equivalents, trade and other receivables, and trade and other<br />

payables, the carrying amounts approximate fair value due to the relatively short-term nature of<br />

these financial instruments.<br />

In respect of borrowings, the carrying amounts are not materially different from their fair values as<br />

at 31 December 2015. The fair values of borrowings are estimated as the present value of future<br />

cash flows, discounted at current market interest rates for similar financial instruments.<br />

The aggregate carrying values of other financial liabilities carried on the consolidated balance<br />

sheet are not materially different from their fair values as at 31 December 2015.<br />

190<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

31 COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES<br />

(a)<br />

Capital commitments<br />

Capital commitments outstanding at respective balance sheet dates not provided for in the financial<br />

statements were as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Contracted for 525 560<br />

Authorised but not contracted for — —<br />

525 560<br />

(b)<br />

Operating lease commitments<br />

(i)<br />

At 31 December 2015, the total future minimum lease payments under non-cancellable operating<br />

leases are payable as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Within 1 year 1,570 1,604<br />

After 1 year but within 5 years 123 121<br />

1,693 1,725<br />

(ii)<br />

The Group leases certain buildings through operating leases. These operating leases do not<br />

contain provisions for contingent lease rentals. None of the agreements contain escalation<br />

provisions that may require higher future rental payments.<br />

(c)<br />

Environmental contingencies<br />

Historically, the Group has not incurred any significant expenditure for environmental remediation.<br />

Further, except for the accrued reclamation obligations as disclosed in Note 28 and amounts incurred<br />

pursuant to the environment compliance protection and precautionary measures in Mongolia, the<br />

Group has not incurred any other significant expenditure for environmental remediation, is currently<br />

not involved in any other environmental remediation, and has not accrued any other amounts for<br />

environmental remediation relating to its operations. Under existing legislation, the directors believe<br />

that there are no probable liabilities that will have a material adverse effect on the financial position<br />

or operating results of the Group. Environmental liabilities are subject to considerable uncertainties<br />

which affect the Group’s ability to estimate the ultimate cost of remediation efforts. The outcome of<br />

environmental liabilities under future environmental legislations cannot be estimated reasonably at<br />

present and which could be material.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

191


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

32 MATERIAL RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS<br />

(a)<br />

Transactions with related parties<br />

Related parties refer to enterprises over which the Group is able to exercise significant influence or<br />

control during the year. During the year, the Group entered into transactions with the following related<br />

parties.<br />

Name of party<br />

MCS (Mongolia) Limited (“MCS Mongolia”)<br />

MCS Holding LLC (“MCS”)<br />

Uniservice Solution LLC (“Uniservice Solution”)<br />

MCS Property LLC (“MCS Property”)<br />

MCS Energy LLC (“MCS Energy”)<br />

MCS International LLC (“MCS International”)<br />

M Armor LLC (previously MCS Armor LLC)<br />

Relationship<br />

Shareholder<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Subsidiary of MCS Mongolia<br />

Particulars of significant transactions between the Group and the above related parties during the year<br />

ended 31 December 2015 are as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Ancillary services (Note (i)) 13,650 16,997<br />

Purchases of equipment and construction work (Note (ii)) 25 1,667<br />

Sales of property, plant and equipment (Note (iii)) 46 89<br />

Lease of property, plant and equipment (Note (iv)) 703 729<br />

Finance lease of equipment (Note (v)) — 16<br />

Note:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

(iv)<br />

(v)<br />

Ancillary services represent expenditures for support services such as cleaning and canteen expense paid to<br />

Uniservice Solution, MCS International, MCS and its affiliates. The service charges are based on comparable<br />

or prevailing market rates, were applicable.<br />

Purchases of equipment and construction work represent expenditure relating to equipment and construction<br />

service provided by MCS and its affiliates. The purchases are carried out at comparable or prevailing market<br />

rates, where applicable.<br />

Sales of property, plant and equipment represent sale to GS Road LLC, MCS and its affiliates. The sales are<br />

carried out at comparable or prevailing market rates, where applicable.<br />

Lease of property, plant and equipment represents rental paid or payable in respect of properties and office<br />

equipment leased from Shangri-La Ulaanbaatar LLC, MCS and its affiliates. The rental charges are based on<br />

comparable or prevailing market rates, where applicable.<br />

Finance leases of equipment represent expenditure relating to the lease of equipment from MCS and its<br />

affiliates through finance lease. The rental charges are based on comparable or prevailing market rates, where<br />

applicable.<br />

192<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

32 MATERIAL RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS (Continued)<br />

(a)<br />

Transactions with related parties (Continued)<br />

The directors of the Company are of the opinion that the above transactions were conducted in the<br />

ordinary course of business, on normal commercial terms and in accordance with the agreements<br />

governing such transactions.<br />

Amounts due from/(to) related parties<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Other receivables (Note 21(c) (i)) 456 607<br />

Other accruals and payables (Note 24(iii)) (11,565) (8,102)<br />

(b)<br />

Key management personnel remuneration<br />

Key management personnel are those persons holding positions with authority and responsibility<br />

for planning, directing and controlling the activities of the Group, directly or indirectly, including the<br />

Group’s directors.<br />

Remuneration for key management personnel, including amounts paid to the Company’s directors as<br />

disclosed in Note 9, and certain of the highest paid employees as disclosed in Note 10, is as follows:<br />

2015 2014<br />

USD’000 USD’000<br />

Salaries and other emoluments 1,537 2,203<br />

Discretionary bonus 1,369 397<br />

Retirement scheme contributions 185 163<br />

Equity-settled share-based payment expenses 1,568 2,896<br />

4,659 5,659<br />

(c)<br />

Applicability of the Listing Rules relating to connected transactions<br />

Certain related party transactions in respect of (a) above constitute connected transactions or<br />

continuing connected transactions as defined in Chapter 14A of the Listing Rules. The disclosures<br />

required by Chapter 14A of the Listing Rules are provided in section headed “Continuing Connected<br />

Transactions” of the Directors’ Report.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

193


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

33 ULTIMATE CONTROLLING PARTY<br />

As at 31 December 2015, the directors consider the ultimate controlling party of the Group to be MCS<br />

(Mongolia) Limited, which was incorporated in British Virgin Islands. This entity does not produce financial<br />

statements available for public use.<br />

34 COMPANY-LEVEL STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION<br />

2015 2014<br />

Note USD’000 USD’000<br />

Non-current assets<br />

Interests in subsidiaries 1,329,033 1,428,668<br />

Total non-current assets 1,329,033 1,428,668<br />

Current assets<br />

Trade and other receivables 300 7<br />

Cash at bank and in hand 19 14,506<br />

Total current assets 319 14,513<br />

Current liabilities<br />

Short-term borrowings and current portion of<br />

long-term borrowings 90,992 63,000<br />

Trade and other payables 87,407 88,887<br />

Total current liabilities 178,399 151,887<br />

Net current liabilities (178,080) (137,374)<br />

Total assets less current liabilities 1,150,953 1,291,294<br />

Non-current liabilities<br />

Long-term borrowings, less current portion — 70,805<br />

Senior notes 597,634 595,906<br />

Total non-current liabilities 597,634 666,711<br />

NET ASSETS 553,319 624,583<br />

CAPITAL AND RESERVES<br />

29(a)<br />

Share capital 92,626 92,626<br />

Reserves 460,693 531,957<br />

TOTAL EQUITY 553,319 624,583<br />

Approved and authorised for issue by the board of directors on 24 March 2016.<br />

Odjargal Jambaljamts<br />

Chairman<br />

Battsengel Gotov<br />

Chief Executive Officer<br />

194<br />

Annual Report 2015


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

35 MAJOR NON-CASH TRANSACTIONS<br />

According to the relevant tax regulations in Mongolia, the income tax payable can be offset by the VAT<br />

receivables. During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group offset the VAT receivables of USD244,000<br />

(2014: USD3,729,000), USD1,271,000 (2014: USD2,452,000), USD4,162,000 (2014: USD7,195,000) and<br />

USD22,349,000 (2014: USD23,759,000) with income tax payable, air pollution fee, royalty tax payable and<br />

payables due to suppliers, respectively.<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, the Group offset no promissory notes payable (2014:<br />

USD45,174,000) with trade receivables due from QGX Holding Ltd. (see Note 24(iv)).<br />

During the year ended 31 December 2015, according to the agreement with Thiess Mongolia LLC<br />

(previous Leighton LLC), the Group offset prepayment of maintenance due from Thiess Mongolia LLC of<br />

USD10,000,000 (2014: USD12,408,000) with trade payables due to Thiess Mongolia LLC.<br />

36 SUBSEQUENT EVENTS AFTER THE BALANCE SHEET DATE<br />

(a)<br />

On 11 March 2016, the Group entered into the Deed of Termination and Release (the “DTR”) with<br />

EBRD, FMO, and DEG (the “Parallel Lenders”) regarding the repayment of secured interest-bearing<br />

borrowings (see Note 23). Pursuant to the DTR, the Group shall endorse to the Parallel Lenders certain<br />

promissory notes issued by MOF (see Note 21(c) (iv)) with total amount of approximately MNT105.6<br />

billion and in return the obligations under the borrowings will be discharged in their entirety and<br />

the relevant security thereunder will be released after 121 calendar days plus 2 business days from<br />

the signing of the DTR (the “Timing Condition”). Until the issuance of the consolidated financial<br />

statements, the Group had completed the endorsement of promissory notes as required by the DTR.<br />

(b) Pursuant to a temporary waiver letter granted by the Lenders of the BNP and ICBC Facility on 14<br />

March 2016, the Group is due to repay principal installments of approximately USD36.8 million together<br />

with applicable interest payment on 22 March 2016. As of the issuance of the consolidated financial<br />

statements, the Group had neither made the payment to the Lenders nor been able to secure any<br />

waiver or forbearance from the Lenders in this regard. As such, an event of default under the BNP and<br />

ICBC Facility has taken place, which also constitutes an event of default under certain of the Group’s<br />

other indebtedness that contain cross-default provisions, including the Senior Notes issued by the<br />

Group with a principal amount of USD600 million due on 29 March 2017.<br />

The Group has proposed to enter forbearance agreements with both the Lenders and the steering<br />

committee of the holders of the Senior Notes (the “Steering Committee”). The Group is in discussion<br />

with and intends to continue dialogue with the Lenders and the Steering Committee and their respective<br />

advisers. Also, until the issuance of the consolidated financial statements, the Group had not obtained<br />

corresponding waivers from BNP Paribas Singapore Branch and Industrial and Commercial Bank of<br />

China Limited in respect of the financial covenants breach of the BNP and ICBC Facility. As such, an<br />

event of default under the BNP and ICBC Facility has taken place. The Group has initiated discussions<br />

with the Lenders for revised terms of the debt facility. Given the material amount of the BNP and ICBC<br />

Facility and also existing Intercreditor Agreement between Lenders and the holders of the Senior Notes<br />

in relation to the shared securities and guarantees, the discussions to revise the BNP and ICBC Facility<br />

are undertaken in connection with the debt restructuring in respect of the Senior Notes. The Group<br />

continues discussion with the Lenders regarding waivers on breach of certain security coverage ratio<br />

and financial covenants under the BNP and ICBC Facility.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

195


Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements<br />

36 SUBSEQUENT EVENTS AFTER THE BALANCE SHEET DATE (Continued)<br />

Until the issuance of the consolidated financial statements, the Group has not received any notice from<br />

any of the Lenders demanding immediate repayment of any outstanding amount under the BNP and ICBC<br />

Facility or any holder of the Senior Notes or any other creditors.<br />

37 POSSIBLE IMPACT OF AMENDMENTS, NEW STANDARDS AND<br />

INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE FOR THE<br />

YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2015<br />

Up to the date of issue of these financial statements, the IASB has issued a number of amendments and<br />

new standards which are not yet effective for the year ended 31 December 2015 and which have not been<br />

adopted in these financial statements. These include the following which may be relevant to the Group.<br />

Effective for<br />

accounting periods<br />

beginning on or after<br />

Annual Improvements to IFRSs 2012-2014 Cycle 1 January 2016<br />

Amendments to IFRS 10 and IAS 28, Sale or contribution of assets between<br />

an investor and its associate or joint venture 1 January 2016<br />

Amendments to IFRS 11, Accounting for acquisitions of interests<br />

in joint operations 1 January 2016<br />

Amendments to IAS 1, Disclosure initiative 1 January 2016<br />

Amendments to IAS 16 and IAS 38, Clarification of acceptable<br />

methods of depreciation and amortisation 1 January 2016<br />

IFRS 15, Revenue from contracts with customers 1 January 2017<br />

IFRS 9, Financial instruments 1 January 2018<br />

The Group is in the process of making an assessment of what the impact of these amendments, new<br />

standards and new interpretations is expected to be in the period of initial application. So far it has<br />

concluded that the adoption of them is unlikely to have a significant impact on the Group’s results of<br />

operations and financial position.`<br />

196<br />

Annual Report 2015


Financial Summary<br />

S U M M A R Y D A T A O F C O N D E N S E D C O N S O L I D A T E D I N C O M E<br />

STATEMENTS<br />

2015 2014 2013 2012 2011<br />

USD'000 USD'000 USD'000 USD'000 USD'000<br />

Revenue 99,485 328,307 437,339 474,480 542,568<br />

Cost of revenue (165,604) (335,510) (361,485) (420,400) (336,368)<br />

Gross (loss)/profit (66,119) (7,203) 75,854 54,080 206,200<br />

Other revenue 848 3,319 592 1,121 435<br />

Other net (expense)/income (1,082) 34,171 7,073 5,418 76<br />

Selling and distribution expenses (8,589) (56,445) — — —<br />

Administrative expenses (30,520) (30,916) (52,410) (48,183) (60,303)<br />

Impairment loss — (190,000) — — —<br />

(Loss)/profit from operations (105,462) (247,074) 31,109 12,436 146,408<br />

Finance income 5,084 3,911 9,551 39,561 22,236<br />

Finance costs (104,106) (98,431) (95,095) (50,994) (13,785)<br />

Share of losses of associates (15) (19) (1,087) (362) (119)<br />

Share of losses of joint venture (87) (70) — — —<br />

(Loss)/profit before taxation (204,586) (341,683) (55,522) 641 154,740<br />

Income tax 16,873 58,978 (2,551) (3,183) (35,650)<br />

(Loss)/profit for the year (187,713) (282,705) (58,073) (2,542) 119,090<br />

Attributable to:<br />

Equity shareholders of the Company (187,763) (282,837) (58,073) (2,542) 119,090<br />

Non-controlling interests 50 132 — — —<br />

Basic (loss)/earnings per share (2.03) cents (5.95) cents (1.26) cents (0.07) cents 3.21 cents<br />

Diluted (loss)/earnings per share (2.03) cents (5.95) cents (1.26) cents (0.07) cents 3.07 cents<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

197


Financial Summary<br />

SUMMARY DATA OF CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF<br />

FINANCIAL POSITION<br />

2015 2014 2013 2012 2011<br />

USD'000 USD'000 USD'000 USD'000 USD'000<br />

Assets and liabilities<br />

Total assets 1,394,120 1,682,825 1,898,870 2,177,277 1,628,015<br />

Total liabilities 1,204,329 1,285,987 1,337,903 1,425,264 859,151<br />

Net assets 189,791 396,838 560,967 752,013 768,864<br />

Total equity 189,791 396,838 560,967 752,013 768,864<br />

Equity attributable to equity shareholders<br />

of the Company 189,449 396,546 560,967 752,013 768,864<br />

Non-controlling interests 342 292 — — —<br />

198<br />

Annual Report 2015


Glossary and Technical Terms<br />

“Adoption date”<br />

“AGM”<br />

“AMC”<br />

“ASP”<br />

“Baogang Group”<br />

“BAP”<br />

“bcm”<br />

“BHWE”<br />

“BN”<br />

“BN deposit”<br />

“BN mine”<br />

“Board”<br />

“C&F”<br />

“CG Code”<br />

“China Customs”<br />

“CHPP”<br />

“coke”<br />

“coking coal”<br />

13 O c t o b e r 2010, t h e d a t e t h e S h a r e O p t i o n S c h e m e b e c a m e<br />

unconditional and effective<br />

Annual general meeting<br />

AMC Consultants Pty Ltd<br />

Average selling price<br />

Baotou Iron and Steel Co., Ltd.<br />

Biodiversity Action Plan<br />

Bank cubic metres<br />

Base Horizon of Weathering Elevation<br />

Baruun Naran<br />

BN coal deposit located in the Tavan Tolgoi formation<br />

The area of the BN deposit that can be mined by open pit mining<br />

methods<br />

The Board of Directors of the Company<br />

Cost-and-Freight<br />

The Corporate Governance Code<br />

China’s General Administration of Customs<br />

Coal handling and preparation plant<br />

Bituminous coal from which the volatile components have been removed<br />

Coal used in the process of manufacturing steel. It is also known as<br />

metallurgical coal<br />

“Company”, “our Company”,<br />

Mongolian Mining Corporation, a company incorporated in the Cayman<br />

“we “us”, “our” or Islands with limited liability on 18 May 2010<br />

“Mongolian Mining Corporation”<br />

“CSR”<br />

“DAP”<br />

“Director(s)”<br />

“EITI”<br />

“EMP”<br />

“EUR”<br />

“Fexos”<br />

Corporate Social Responsibility<br />

Delivery-at-place<br />

Director(s) of the Company<br />

Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative<br />

Environmental Management Plan<br />

Euro, the currency unit of the European Monetary Union<br />

Fexos Limited<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

199


Glossary and Technical Terms<br />

“FOT”<br />

“Ganqimaodu” or “GM”<br />

“Gashuun Sukhait” or “GS”<br />

“GoM”<br />

“Group”, “our Group”<br />

“HCC”<br />

“HKD”<br />

“HR”<br />

“HSE”<br />

“HSE MS”<br />

“IASs”<br />

“IASB”<br />

“IFC”<br />

“IFRSs”<br />

“ILO”<br />

“JORC”<br />

“JORC Code”<br />

“KAM”<br />

“KGL”<br />

“KHL”<br />

“km”<br />

“KMM”<br />

“KMUHG”<br />

“KPI”<br />

“kt”<br />

Free-on-Transport<br />

The China side of the China-Mongolia border crossing<br />

The Mongolia side of the China-Mongolia border crossing<br />

Government of Mongolia<br />

The Company together with its subsidiaries<br />

Hard coking coal<br />

Hong Kong Dollar<br />

Human Resources<br />

Health, Safety and Environmental<br />

Health, Safety and Environmental Management System<br />

International Accounting Standards<br />

International Accounting Standards Board<br />

International Finance Corporation<br />

International Financial Reporting Standards<br />

International Labour Organisation<br />

Joint Ore Reserves Committee of The Australasian Institute of Mining and<br />

Metallurgy, Australian Institute of Geoscientists and Minerals Council of<br />

Australia<br />

A professional code of practice that sets minimum standards for Public<br />

Reporting of minerals Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore<br />

Reserves<br />

Kerry Asset Management Limited<br />

Kerry Group Limited<br />

Kerry Holdings Limited<br />

Kilometres<br />

Kerry Mining (Mongolia) Limited<br />

Kerry Mining (UHG) Limited<br />

Key performance indicator<br />

Thousand tonnes<br />

“Listing Date” 13 October 2010<br />

“Listing Rules”<br />

The Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the Stock Exchange of<br />

Hong Kong Limited<br />

200<br />

Annual Report 2015


Glossary and Technical Terms<br />

“LTIFR”<br />

“LTI”<br />

“Mbcm”<br />

“MBGS”<br />

“middlings”<br />

“Mineral Resource”<br />

“mining rights”<br />

“ML”<br />

“mm”<br />

“MNT”<br />

“Model Code”<br />

“Modifying Factors”<br />

“Mt”<br />

“NBS”<br />

“NGOs”<br />

“Norwest”<br />

“OHS”<br />

“OHSE”<br />

“open-pit”<br />

“ore”<br />

Lost Time Injury Frequency Rate<br />

Lost Time Injury<br />

Million bank cubic metres<br />

McElroy Bryan Geological Services Pty Ltd<br />

Thermal coal by-product of washed coking coal production<br />

As defined by the JORC Code, a concentration or occurrence of<br />

material of intrinsic economic interest in or on the earth’s crust in such<br />

form, quality and quantity that there are reasonable prospects for<br />

eventual economic extraction. The location, quantity, quality, geological<br />

characteristics and continuity of a mineral resource are known, estimated<br />

or interpreted from specific geological evidence and knowledge. Mineral<br />

resources are sub-divided, in order of increasing geological confidence,<br />

into Inferred, Indicated and Measured categories<br />

The rights to mine mineral resources and obtain mineral products in areas<br />

where mining activities are licensed<br />

Megalitres<br />

Millimetres<br />

Togrog or tugrik, the lawful currency of Mongolia<br />

The Model Code for Securities Transactions by Directors of Listed Issuers<br />

As defined by the JORC Code, are considerations used to convert<br />

Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves. These include, but are not restricted<br />

to, mining, processing, metallurgical, infrastructure, economic, marketing,<br />

legal, environmental, social and governmental factors<br />

Million tonnes<br />

National Bureau of Statistics of China<br />

Non-Governmental Organisations<br />

Norwest Corporation<br />

Occupational health and safety<br />

Occupational Health, Safety and Environment<br />

The main type of mine designed to extract minerals close to the surface;<br />

also known as “open cut”<br />

A naturally occurring solid material from which a metal or valuable mineral<br />

can be extracted profitably<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

201


Glossary and Technical Terms<br />

“Ore Reserve”<br />

“Parliament”<br />

“Polaris”<br />

“PPP”<br />

“Probable Reserve”<br />

“Proved Reserve”<br />

“raw coal”<br />

“RMB”<br />

“ROM”<br />

“RPM”<br />

“seam”<br />

“SEHK” or “Stock Exchange”<br />

“SFO”<br />

“share(s)”<br />

“Share Options” or “Options”<br />

As defined by the JORC Code, the economically mineable part of a<br />

Measured or Indicated Mineral Resource demonstrated by at least a<br />

preliminary feasibility study. This study must include adequate information<br />

on mining, processing, economic and other relevant factors that<br />

demonstrate, at the time of reporting, that economic extraction can be<br />

justified. An Ore Reserve includes diluting materials and allowances for<br />

losses that may occur when the material is mined<br />

Parliament of Mongolia<br />

Polaris Seismic International Ltd<br />

Public private partnership<br />

As defined by the JORC Code, the economically mineable part of an<br />

indicated and, in some circumstances, a measured mineral resource<br />

demonstrated by at least a preliminary feasibility study. This study must<br />

include adequate information on mining, processing, metallurgical,<br />

economic and other relevant factors that demonstrate, at the time of<br />

reporting, that economic extraction can be justified<br />

As defined by the JORC Code, is the economically mineable part of a<br />

Measured Mineral Resource. A Proved Ore Reserve implies a high degree<br />

of confidence in the Modifying Factors<br />

Generally means coal that has not been washed and processed<br />

Renminbi<br />

Run-of-mine, the as-mined material during room and pillar mining<br />

operations as it leaves the mine site (mined glauberite ore and out-ofseam<br />

dilution material)<br />

RungePincockMinarco Limited<br />

A stratum or bed of coal or other mineral; generally applied to large<br />

deposits of coal<br />

The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited<br />

Securities and Futures Ordinance<br />

Ordinary share(s) of USD0.01 each in the share capital of the Company<br />

The share options which were granted under the Share Option Scheme to<br />

eligible participants to subscribe for Shares of the Company<br />

“Share Option Scheme” A share option scheme which was adopted by the Company on 17<br />

September 2010<br />

“Share Purchase Agreement”<br />

Share purchase agreement entered by the Company and its subsidiary<br />

Mongolian Coal Corporation Limited with Quincunx (BVI) Ltd and Kerry<br />

Mining (Mongolia) Limited in relation to the acquisition of the entire issued<br />

share capital of QGX Coal Ltd<br />

202<br />

Annual Report 2015


Glossary and Technical Terms<br />

“soum”<br />

“SSCC”<br />

“strip ratio” or “stripping ratio”<br />

“Tavan Tolgoi”<br />

“the Schemes”<br />

“thermal coal”<br />

“THG”<br />

“TKH”<br />

“tonne”<br />

“TRIFR”<br />

“Tsogttsetsii”<br />

“UHG”<br />

“UHG deposit”<br />

“UHG mine”<br />

“USD”<br />

“VAT”<br />

“Velseis”<br />

“washed coal”<br />

“WSA”<br />

The second level of Mongolian administrative subdivisions (essentially<br />

equivalent to a sub-province)<br />

Semi-soft coking coal<br />

The ratio of the amount of waste removed (in bank cubic metres) to<br />

the amount of coal or minerals (in tonnes) extracted by open-pit mining<br />

methods<br />

The coal formation located in South Gobi, Mongolia which includes our<br />

UHG and BN deposits<br />

The Group participates in defined contribution retirement benefit schemes<br />

Also referred to as “steam coal” or “steaming coal” thermal coal is used<br />

in combustion processes by power producers and industrial users to<br />

produce steam for power and heat. Thermal coal tends not to have the<br />

carbonisation properties possessed by coking coals and generally has<br />

lower heat value and higher volatility than coking coal<br />

Tsaikhar Khudag<br />

Tsagaan Khad<br />

Metric tonne, being equal to 1,000 kilograms<br />

Total recordable injury frequency rate<br />

Tsogttsetsii soum is the location where Tavan Tolgoi sits<br />

Ukhaa Khudag<br />

Ukhaa Khudag deposit located in the Tavan Tolgoi coalfield which<br />

includes both aboveground (300m) deposits<br />

The aboveground (


Appendix I<br />

Technical details of the UHG Coal Reserve estimate provided in accordance with the JORC Code (2012) in<br />

the form of ‘JORC Table 1’ detailed in Section 4. Similar technical details relevant to the underlying UHG Coal<br />

Resource estimate were previously published in the form of ‘JORC Table 1’ Sections 1, 2 and 3 in the MMC<br />

Annual Report 2014.<br />

JORC (2012) TABLE 1<br />

Section 4: Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserves<br />

Criteria<br />

Mineral Resource<br />

estimate for conversion<br />

to Ore Reserves<br />

Commentary<br />

• Description of the Mineral Resource estimate used as a basis for the<br />

conversion to an Ore Reserve.<br />

• Clear statement as to whether the Mineral Resources are reported<br />

additional to, or inclusive of, the Ore Reserves.<br />

• The Mineral Resource estimate used as the basis for this Coal Reserves<br />

Statement is “JORC (2012) Standard Resource Estimation Ukhaa Khudag Coal<br />

Mine (Licence 11952A)”, prepared by Mongolian Mining Corporation, Energy<br />

Resources LLC, Geology Department, November 2015.<br />

• The Competent Person for the Mineral Resource estimate was Mr. Lkhagva-<br />

Ochir Said, a full time employee of Mongolian Mining Corporation in the position<br />

of General Manager of Technical Services. Mr. Said graduated in 2005 with a<br />

“Bachelor of Geology” from the “School of Geology and Petroleum Engineering,<br />

Mongolian University of Science and Technology”, and is a Member of the<br />

Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (#316005).<br />

• The Coal Resources are reported inclusive of those Coal Resources modified to<br />

produce the Coal Reserves.<br />

Site visits • Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the<br />

outcome of those visits.<br />

• If no site visits have been undertaken indicate why this is the case.<br />

• A site visit to the UHG Mine was undertaken by the Competent Person in<br />

February 2012 and in January 2013. The outcome of these site visits was<br />

observation of site and mining conditions and discussion with site operating<br />

personnel that contributed to the determination of project parameters used in<br />

the UHG Life of Mine (LOM) plan update study, equivalent to a Feasibility Study<br />

update, completed in May 2013.<br />

• The competent person did not believe a further site visit was warranted in 2015,<br />

as site conditions had not materially changed with mining progress that had<br />

occurred since the site visit of January 2013.<br />

204<br />

Annual Report 2015


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

Study status • The type and level of study undertaken to enable Mineral Resources to<br />

be converted to Ore Reserves.<br />

• The Code requires that a study to at least Pre-Feasibility Study level has<br />

been undertaken to convert Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves. Such<br />

studies will have been carried out and will have determined a mine plan<br />

that is technically achievable and economically.<br />

• A LOM study update, equivalent to a Feasibility Study update was completed in<br />

May 2013.<br />

• A further update to the LOM plan was completed in February 2016, comprising<br />

pit optimization, strategic options scheduling, mine planning, scheduling and<br />

economic analysis of the preferred strategic option.<br />

Cut-off parameters • The basis of the cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.<br />

• There are no coal quality cut-off parameters used to eliminate the conversion<br />

of Coal Resources to Coal Reserves. Coal Resources have already been<br />

determined with an ash cut off of 50% (DRY basis). Pit Optimisation and LOM<br />

planning has been used to determine whether Coal Resources will convert to<br />

Coal Reserves.<br />

Mining factors<br />

or assumptions<br />

• The method and assumptions used as reported in the Pre-Feasibility<br />

or Feasibility Study to convert the Mineral Resource to an Ore Reserve<br />

(i.e. either by application of appropriate factors by optimisation or by<br />

preliminary or detailed design).<br />

• The choice, nature and appropriateness of the selected mining method(s)<br />

and other mining parameters including associated design issues such as<br />

pre-strip, access, etc.<br />

• The assumptions made regarding geotechnical parameters (e.g. pit<br />

slopes, stope sizes, etc.), grade control and pre-production drilling.<br />

• The major assumptions made and Mineral Resource model used for pit<br />

and stope optimisation (if appropriate).<br />

• The mining dilution factors used.<br />

• The mining recovery factors used.<br />

• Any minimum mining widths used.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

205


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

• The manner in which Inferred Mineral Resources are utilised in mining<br />

studies and the sensitivity of the outcome to their inclusion.<br />

• The infrastructure requirements of the selected mining methods.<br />

• Pit Optimisation and LOM planning has been used as the basis of converting<br />

Coal Resources to Coal Reserves.<br />

• The selected mining method is that in use in the operating mine, i.e. open cut<br />

truck and excavator mining for both waste mining and coal mining, with out of<br />

pit and in pit dumping of waste.<br />

• Geotechnical parameters for the design of stable slopes have been provided by<br />

Australian Mining Consultants (“AMC”).<br />

• The mining factors used were:<br />

– Minimum coal mining thickness of 0.5 m.<br />

– Minimum parting mining thickness of 0.5 m.<br />

– Mineable coal section roof and floor loss of 100 mm.<br />

– Mineable coal section roof and floor dilution of 100 mm.<br />

– Global mining and geological loss 1%.<br />

– The quality of diluting material is relative density of 2.46 t/m 3 , and ash of<br />

92%.<br />

– Relative density data in the geological model is based on an average in-situ<br />

moisture of 3.2% (ar). ROM moisture is assumed to be 5% (ar), coking coal<br />

product moisture 8% (ar), middlings product moisture 9% (ar) and thermal<br />

product coal moisture 5% (ar).<br />

• The application of “Affected Zones” with higher global losses, as per the 2013<br />

LOM Study, were discontinued on the basis of actual mining coal recovery<br />

reconciliation results supplied by MMC for an 18 month period of sampling<br />

undertaken by MMC from January 2014 to June 2015.<br />

• Inferred Coal Resources are assigned revenue in the LOM study pit optimiser<br />

and included in the LOM production schedule as mineable coal, but are not<br />

converted to Coal Reserves.<br />

• The infrastructure requirements are in place at the operating mine comprising<br />

offices, workshops, service station and shared CHPP facilities with the BN mine.<br />

The infrastructure will be expanded as UHG production expands.<br />

Metallurgical factors<br />

or assumptions<br />

• The metallurgical process proposed and the appropriateness of that<br />

process to the style of mineralisation.<br />

• Whether the metallurgical process is well-tested technology or novel in<br />

nature.<br />

206<br />

Annual Report 2015


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

• The nature, amount and representativeness of metallurgical test work<br />

undertaken, the nature of the metallurgical domaining applied and the<br />

corresponding metallurgical recovery factors applied.<br />

• Any assumptions or allowances made for deleterious elements.<br />

• The existence of any bulk sample or pilot scale test work and the degree<br />

to which such samples are considered representative of the orebody as a<br />

whole.<br />

• For minerals that are defined by a specification, has the ore reserve<br />

estimation been based on the appropriate mineralogy to meet the<br />

specifications?<br />

• The metallurgical process for washing the coking coal seams is already in place<br />

and being used. It is a low cut high cut dense media processing plant at the<br />

UHG mine site. The process is well tested and robust. Coking coal seams 0C,<br />

3A and 4 have been mined and processed through this plant and the ash-yield<br />

curves for these seams have been reconciled and adjusted with the laboratory<br />

generated curves from the back analysis of results when these seams were<br />

washed.<br />

• The process generates primary coking coal product from a low cut point that will<br />

produce a 10.5% (ad) ash HCC and 9.5% (ad) SSCC product, and a secondary<br />

middlings product of 18% (ad) ash is produced from a variable high cut.<br />

• International coal processing consultant Norwest Corporation has generated<br />

ash-yield curves for all the coking coal seams.<br />

• A conventional Jig washing plant is planned for processing thermal coal seams<br />

to produce a relatively high ash low energy thermal coal product suitable for<br />

export or domestic use.<br />

Environmental • The status of studies of potential environmental impacts of the mining<br />

and processing operation. Details of waste rock characterisation and the<br />

consideration of potential sites, status of design options considered and,<br />

where applicable, the status of approvals for process residue storage<br />

and waste dumps should be reported.<br />

• An Environmental Impact Statement has been prepared and all environmental<br />

approvals obtained.<br />

• Waste rock characterisation results do not require special placement<br />

requirements or procedures in the dumps.<br />

• Coal processing plant reject is stored appropriately in the waste dumps or<br />

storage cells in accordance with the environmental approvals.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

207


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

Infrastructure • The existence of appropriate infrastructure: availability of land for<br />

plant development, power, water, transportation (particularly for bulk<br />

commodities), labour, accommodation; or the ease with which the<br />

infrastructure can be provided, or accessed.<br />

• All necessary infrastructure to support the UHG mine is in place at either the<br />

mine site or at the UHG mine industrial area. Power is supplied from an onsite<br />

coal fired power station, and also from the transmission line connected to the<br />

Mongolian power grid. Water is supplied from a nearby bore field. The workforce<br />

is accommodated in a purpose built camp or in housing provided in the nearby<br />

communities.<br />

Costs • The derivation of, or assumptions made, regarding projected capital<br />

costs in the study.<br />

• The methodology used to estimate operating costs.<br />

• Allowances made for the content of deleterious elements.<br />

• The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for<br />

the principal minerals and co- products.<br />

• The source of exchange rates used in the study.<br />

• Derivation of transportation charges.<br />

• The basis for forecasting or source of treatment and refining charges,<br />

penalties for failure to meet specification, etc.<br />

• The allowances made for royalties payable, both Government and private.<br />

• Project capital cost estimates for mining plant and equipment have been<br />

provided by MMC.<br />

• Operating cost estimates have been provided from MMC’s assessment of<br />

existing operating costs incurred in the operation and also from MMC’s mining<br />

contractor.<br />

— Actual mining contractor coal mining costs were provided and applied in<br />

the study in $/bcm; however for presentation in Table 5.8 (in Report No.<br />

ADV-MN-00132 ‘Statement of Open Cut Coal Reserves as at 30 November<br />

2015 dated March 2016) RPM converted to $/t ROM using the weight<br />

average relative density of coal in the pit shells).<br />

• Coal processing costs are based on those actually being incurred in the existing<br />

CHPP operation.<br />

• Government royalty costs are based on currently legislated rates applicable to<br />

the forecast sales prices of UHG product coal. There are no private royalties<br />

payable.<br />

208<br />

Annual Report 2015


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

Revenue factors • The derivation of, or assumptions made regarding revenue factors<br />

including head grade, metal or commodity price(s) exchange rates,<br />

transportation and treatment charges, penalties, net smelter returns, etc.<br />

• The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for<br />

the principal metals, minerals and co-products.<br />

• Shanxi Fenwei Energy Consulting Co Ltd (“Shanxi Fenwei”) completed an<br />

independent market study for UHG products and identified principal coking and<br />

thermal coal markets in Mongolia and China.<br />

• Based on the Shanxi Fenwei study and MMC’s assessment of the current market<br />

prices for hard coking coal, semi soft coking coal, middlings coal product (6,300<br />

kcal/kg nar) and thermal coal product (6,300 kcal/kg nar), long term (2021 –<br />

2025) real prices of USD$78/t, USD$56/t, USD$18/t and USD$18/t respectively<br />

have been assessed and used in the study.<br />

Market assessment • The demand, supply and stock situation for the particular commodity,<br />

consumption trends and factors likely to affect supply and demand into<br />

the future.<br />

• A customer and competitor analysis along with the identification of likely<br />

market windows for the product.<br />

• Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.<br />

• For industrial minerals the customer specification, testing and<br />

acceptance requirements prior to a supply contract.<br />

• Shanxi Fenwei completed an independent market study for UHG and identified<br />

principal coking and thermal coal markets in Mongolia and China.<br />

Economic • The inputs to the economic analysis to produce the net present value<br />

(NPV) in the study, the source and confidence of these economic inputs<br />

including estimated inflation, discount rate, etc.<br />

• NPV ranges and sensitivity to variations in the significant assumptions<br />

and inputs. Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.<br />

• The inputs to the economic analysis of UHG are the project derived capital and<br />

operating cost estimates outlined above. The source of the inputs is real and the<br />

confidence satisfactory. The economic modelling is in real terms and a range of<br />

discount factors between 8% and 12% have been used in assessing NPV.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

209


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

• The NPV results produced from the economic modelling using a range of<br />

discount factors, as outlined above, have generated positive NPVs indicating the<br />

viability of the UHG mine.<br />

• The NPV has been assessed for variations of ±10% and ±20% in revenue. The<br />

results indicate that the project is not robust and that project value becomes<br />

stressed with decreases in the base coal sales prices.<br />

Social • The status of agreements with key stakeholders and matters leading to<br />

social licence to operate.<br />

• All key stakeholder agreements are in place providing a social license to operate.<br />

Other • To the extent relevant, the impact of the following on the project and/or<br />

on the estimation and classification of the Ore Reserves:<br />

• Any identified material naturally occurring risks.<br />

• The status of material legal agreements and marketing arrangements.<br />

• The status of governmental agreements and approvals critical to the<br />

viability of the project, such as mineral tenement status, and government<br />

and statutory approvals. There must be reasonable grounds to expect<br />

that all necessary Government approvals will be received within the<br />

timeframes anticipated in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility study.<br />

Highlight and discuss the materiality of any unresolved matter that<br />

is dependent on a third party on which extraction of the reserve is<br />

contingent.<br />

• All material legal agreements, marketing agreements and government<br />

agreements are in place to allow the UHG mine to successfully operate. As<br />

expansion proceeds it is reasonably expected any modifications to existing<br />

agreements or additional agreements that may be required can be obtained in a<br />

timely manner.<br />

210<br />

Annual Report 2015


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

Classification • The basis for the classification of the Ore Reserves into varying<br />

confidence categories.<br />

• Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent Person’s view of<br />

the deposit.<br />

• The proportion of Probable Ore Reserves that have been derived from<br />

Measured Mineral Resources (if any).<br />

• Measured Resources have been classified as Proved Reserves, Indicated<br />

Resources have been classified as Probable Reserves. No Probable Reserves<br />

have been derived from Measured Resources.<br />

• No Inferred Resources have been converted to Reserves (although Inferred<br />

Resource was assigned revenue in the pit optimiser and reported as mineable<br />

ROM coal in the LOM schedule).<br />

• The result reflects the Competent Persons view of the deposit.<br />

Audits or reviews • The results of any audits or reviews of the Ore Reserve estimates.<br />

• Internal peer by RPM of the Reserves estimate has been completed.<br />

Discussion of relative<br />

accuracy/confidence<br />

• Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence<br />

level in the Ore Reserve estimate using an approach or procedure<br />

deemed appropriate by the Competent Person. For example, the<br />

application of statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the<br />

relative accuracy of the reserve within stated confidence limits, or, if<br />

such an approach is not deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of<br />

the factors which could affect the relative accuracy and confidence of<br />

the estimate.<br />

• The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local<br />

estimates, and, if local, state the relevant tonnages, which should be<br />

relevant to technical and economic evaluation. Documentation should<br />

include assumptions made and the procedures used.<br />

• Accuracy and confidence discussions should extend to specific<br />

discussions of any applied Modifying Factors that may have a material<br />

impact on Ore Reserve viability, or for which there are remaining areas<br />

of uncertainty at the current study stage.<br />

Annual Report 2015<br />

211


Appendix I<br />

Criteria<br />

Commentary<br />

• It is recognised that this may not be possible or appropriate in all<br />

circumstances. These statements of relative accuracy and confidence of<br />

the estimate should be compared with production data, where available.<br />

• Coal production at UHG commenced in April 2009, and since this time some<br />

202 Mbcm of waste and 37 Mt of ROM coal has been mined to date until 30<br />

November 2015.<br />

• Since the preparation of the last Reserves estimate effective as of 31 December<br />

2012 the UHG mine has completed reconciliations of actual coal mined against<br />

the geological model for the period January 2014 to June 2015.<br />

• As a result of the reconciliations that have been undertaken and the observations<br />

made associated with the mining activities over this period of time, the mining<br />

modifying factors in this Reserves estimate have been adjusted to be less<br />

conservative particularly with respect to assumed losses incurred in the “affected<br />

zones”, and in the assumed reassignment of coking coal to thermal coal.<br />

212<br />

Annual Report 2015


Annual Report 2015

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!