Vol 3 | Issue 3 | July 2016
fDPDQxH
fDPDQxH
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | <strong>July</strong> <strong>2016</strong><br />
QUARTERLY NEWSLETTER OF IBS GURGAON | FOR PRIVATE CIRCULATION ONLY
GUEST SEMINARS @ IBS GURGAON<br />
Dr. Kulwant Singh, Hony. Advisor, Urban Basic Services,<br />
UN-Habitat on “Role of Private Sector in Delivery of<br />
Public Services” on 8th April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
IN THIS ISSUE...<br />
Director’s Message 1<br />
From The Editor’s Desk 2<br />
GST - State’s Perspective 3<br />
GST: When and Why? 4<br />
Interaction With : Mr. Arvind Kumar, IRS 5<br />
Campus Buzz 7<br />
Convocation <strong>2016</strong> 9<br />
Faculty Forum 12<br />
Celebrity Watch : Raghuram Rajan 16<br />
All About GST Bill 17<br />
GST Bill - A Panacea For Indian<br />
Economy 18<br />
Alumni Success Story :<br />
Karan Bhujbal, Class of 2010 19<br />
Book Review : Rebooting India 20<br />
Prof. C. L. Bansal, Professor, Public Policy and<br />
Governance, MDI, Gurgaon on “Challenges and<br />
Opportunities before Startups: Theory and Practice” on<br />
20th April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Chief Editor<br />
Prof. S. C. Sharma<br />
Managing Editor<br />
Dr. Shalini Khandelwal<br />
Associate Editor<br />
Dr. Nidhi Tak<br />
Editorial Team<br />
Dr. Tavleen Kaur, Akshita Maheshwari, Vasudha<br />
Dada, Tushar Sharma, Megha Goyal,<br />
Priyanka Aggarwal<br />
Mr. Arvind Kumar, Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Heavy<br />
Industries & Public Enterprises, Govt of India on “Goods<br />
and Services Tax (GST) - It’s Impact on Indian Economy”<br />
on 5th <strong>July</strong>, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Cover Design<br />
Rudra Pratap Singh<br />
Publisher<br />
Mr. Prashant Singh, Manager, Admn.<br />
B SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
DIRECTOR’S MESSAGE<br />
GOODS & SERVICES TAX: WILL IT TRANSFORM<br />
INDIAN ECONOMY<br />
Goods and Services Tax (GST) has been in news since<br />
2000 when Prime Minister Mr Atal Bihari Vajpayee appointed<br />
a Committee headed by the then Finance Minister of<br />
Government of West Bengal to design a model for GST. Since<br />
then, it has passed through several stages of deliberations,<br />
debates and diatribes, both inside and outside the Parliament.<br />
On 14th June <strong>2016</strong>, in its long and winding journey,<br />
GST reached an important milestone when the Empowered<br />
Committee of State Finance Ministers approved the model GST<br />
Bill and the Ministry of Finance released the draft document for<br />
public debate.<br />
The discussion in electronic and print media suggests<br />
that almost all state governments have arrived at consensus<br />
on several contentious issues, even though enough evidence<br />
exists to the contrary as well.<br />
GST is defined as “any tax on goods and services other than alcohol for human consumption.” It<br />
is expected to subsume all indirect taxes imposed by central and state governments such as central<br />
excise duties, additional excise duties, service tax, custom duties; state taxes like VAT or sales tax,<br />
central sales tax, entertainment tax, entry tax, purchase tax, luxury tax, entry tax etc. In all, it is likely<br />
to replace 17 taxes.<br />
Considering the fact that India is a federal country, the model Bill provides for dual GST wherein<br />
both the centre and states will concurrently levy central and state GST respectively. It is expected that<br />
the base and other essential design features would be common between central GST and state GST.<br />
For inter-state trade, only the central government will be authorized to impose and collect GST and<br />
the proceeds would be shared in accordance with the provisions of the Act, as and when it comes into<br />
existence. The Bill proposes an additional levy of 1% on inter- state trade in goods and services.<br />
The primary purpose of bringing GST is to create a unified All - India market for businesses<br />
engaged in the production, financing and trading of goods and services with a single tax rate, and<br />
providing comfortable business environment to foreign firms which have to incur huge compliance<br />
costs because of multiplicity of taxes, wide variations in tax rates, scale and extent of exemptions etc.<br />
The major benefits of GST will emanate from increase in the size of the market brought about by hassle<br />
free movement of goods transported by road, and streamlining of procedures for payments of GST<br />
and availing tax credits in different locations. In final analysis, GST will contribute significantly towards<br />
making of one India through economic, financial and commercial integration.<br />
It is expected that GST will also help in checking generation of black money in the economy<br />
through plugging of loopholes and effective compliance. The economic and administrative measures<br />
coupled with improved coordination amongst tax authorities would result in raising the rate of<br />
economic growth and employment generation..<br />
At the same time, there are many unanswered questions at this stage: What would be the impact<br />
of GST on inflation? Which sectors and industries are likely to gain? Who will be the losers and why?<br />
How will it influence the smaller firms as against the large firms? What is the rationale of keeping liquor,<br />
tobacco, petroleum, electricity and perhaps real estate out of the ambit of GST?<br />
Answers to these questions are not straight or simple and would unfold themselves several years<br />
after the introduction of GST. It would be a real test of Indian federal structure and the institutions<br />
governing it.<br />
I am sure you will enjoy reading this issue of Samvaad which attempts to address some of these<br />
issues.<br />
Prof. S C Sharma | Director, IBS Gurgaon<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 1
FROM THE EDITOR’S DESK<br />
This issue of Samvaad focuses on the various aspects of Goods and<br />
Services Tax (GST) and its implementation in India. The GST is the biggest<br />
indirect tax reform in India since 1947 and aims to transform India into a<br />
uniform market by subsuming all the indirect taxes and by breaking the<br />
current fiscal barrier between states. A uniform GST across the country<br />
will remove the cascading effect of various taxes and improve the ease of<br />
doing business by creating a seamless national market. It will result into less<br />
paperwork and hopefully will translate into a lower tax burden by removing<br />
distortions from the system. With the bill being discussed in the parliament since 2009, and with the<br />
great momentum built over the years, it is high time that all parties arrive at a consensus to pass the<br />
bill. Any further delay in GST’s implementation may impact India’s industrial growth and send wrong<br />
signals to global investors keen to invest in world’s fastest growing major economy.<br />
Adding to the momentum of research activities at IBS Gurgaon, the last quarter (April-June)<br />
was a time for faculty members to focus on their research work, share their progress, learn from<br />
each other and get inspired. A series of faculty research seminars were organised where 12 faculty<br />
members took the initiative to present their research findings with the faculty group at IBS Gurgaon.<br />
It was an opportunity to feel proud of the expertise and competencies of institute’s highly diverse<br />
and experienced pool of committed faculty members.<br />
Convocation Ceremony for the Class of <strong>2016</strong> saw eminent guests from the industry sparing<br />
time to address and motivate our young leaders to step into the corporate world with confidence<br />
and determination. The knowledge and skills acquired by them at IBS during the last two years will<br />
certainly be instrumental in shaping their careers.<br />
IBS Gurgaon welcomed the new class of 2018 with much enthusiasm and cheerfulness.<br />
Orientation and induction classes were held to bring all students on a common learning platform.<br />
It was encouraging to see students coming in large numbers to attend the very first session on the<br />
campus. Their eagerness and quest for learning was obvious during the orientation classes and I<br />
am sure will continue during the regular classes as we constantly endeavour to provide intellectual<br />
stimulation through discussions, debates and experiential activities.<br />
I am happy that this issue of Samvaad brings out the debate surrounding GST and includes<br />
carefully selected faculty and student articles on the theme along with regular columns of Campus<br />
Buzz, Faculty Forum, Interaction With, Celebrity Watch, Alumni Success Story and Book Review. I<br />
invite all readers to explore the contents and share with us ways and means to enhance the impact<br />
of Samvaad.<br />
Happy Reading!<br />
Dr. Shalini Khandelwal | Associate Dean (Research), IBS Gurgaon<br />
E-mail : shalinik@ibsindia.org<br />
“Little else is requisite to carry a state to the highest degree of opulence from<br />
the lowest barbarism but peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of<br />
justice: all the rest being brought about by the natural course of things.”<br />
Adam Smith<br />
2 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
GST - STATE’S PERSPECTIVE<br />
Prof. Arun Kumar Agarwal*<br />
The Goods and Service Tax or GST is a system of taxation where<br />
there is a single tax for goods as well as services. GST is a consumption<br />
based tax/levy which is applicable on goods and services at the place<br />
where final/actual consumption happens.GST is collected on valueadded<br />
goods and services at each stage of sale or purchase in the<br />
supply chain. GST paid on the procurement of goods and services<br />
can be set off against that payable on the supply of goods or services. The manufacturer or<br />
wholesaler or retailer will pay the applicable GST rate but will claim back through tax credit<br />
mechanism until the final stage of sale to the end consumer is reached.<br />
Worries or concerns for states<br />
1. The foremost worry for states is the loss of revenues, which is perceived to arise from two<br />
factors. First, it is the manufacturing states that are more worried than the others because<br />
value added tax, or VAT, the current taxation regime in states, is an origin-based tax while the<br />
good and services tax (GST) is a destination-based tax. In the origin-based tax system, tax is<br />
collected where the supplier of good is located while in the destination based system, tax in<br />
collected where the consumer of a product is located. Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and Gujarat<br />
are among the more industrialized states and they fear big losses of revenues on movement<br />
of goods made in their states.Secondly, loss of revenue may arise from GST replacing the<br />
plethora of state taxes as they exist today.<br />
2. Risk of Loss of fiscal autonomy. States will not be allowed to introduce any new tax at will,<br />
change the rate of tax or give exemptions to any class of goods or service provider. They will<br />
also not be allowed to unilaterally levy cess or surcharge or increase tax rate to raise resource<br />
in the event of a natural calamity. Any change to tax rates will have to be within a narrow<br />
band prescribed by the GST Council. Any changes to the tax rate will need to be agreed to<br />
with three-fourth majority at the GST Council. While states together have weightage of twothird<br />
in any decision and Centre will retain the balance one-third. This effectively means<br />
that states together will not be able to act on their own or take any decision, consent of the<br />
Centre will be necessary. This is akin to giving the Centre veto power.<br />
Assurances from the Central Government<br />
a. Compensation for losses suffered in the first five years: States have been assured 100 per cent<br />
compensation for losses suffered in the first three years and 75 per cent in the fourth year and<br />
50 per cent in the fifth year. However, the finance ministry expects that all states will not need<br />
compensation for five years. Consuming states in particular may see their revenues increase with<br />
the implementation of GST.<br />
b. Further, to address the fears of revenue loss of manufacturing states, the union government has<br />
said additional tax of up to one per cent would be collected on inter-state trade of goods for two<br />
years or longer period if the centre-state body, the GST Council, so decides and be transferred<br />
to the states. This is in lieu of the central sales tax (CST) that stands abolished when GST is<br />
implemented. Tamil Nadu, for instance, estimates its losses from scrapping CST will be Rs 3,500<br />
crore annually.<br />
c. The Finance ministry expects that revenues generated by states from taxing services will more<br />
than make up for losses they suffer when octroi and entry tax, entertainment tax, luxury tax and<br />
other state level taxes are withdrawn and that the concerns of the States are too premature..<br />
*Prof. Arun Kumar Agarwal is an Adjunct Faculty in the area of Finance at IBS Gurgaon<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 3
GST: WHEN AND WHY?<br />
Dr. Mandeep Mahendru*<br />
Goods and services tax (GST) is India’s most ambitious indirect<br />
tax reform plan so far, aiming at making it comprehensive as nearly all<br />
goods and services will be taxable, with minimum exemptions. GST may<br />
prove out to be a game changer by creating seamless uniform market,<br />
dismantling fiscal barriers between states, which in turn will help reduce<br />
the cascading effect of tax on goods and services.<br />
GST which got through Lok Sabha on 6th May, 2015, is a tax levy on<br />
manufacture, sale and consumption of goods and services at a national level. GST is a value-added tax<br />
levied on goods and services (except the list of exempted goods and services) that is paid by the final<br />
consumer while the retailer takes credit of the tax he has paid when buying the goods for retailing. In<br />
this way, all the services of retailer or the chain behind him are taxed apart from the actual value of<br />
production of the commodity. It is proposed to be implemented as a dual GST. At central level, it will<br />
be called CGST and at the State level, it will be known as SGST. The rate levy will be decided mutually.<br />
A lot of debate is going on the need for GST. As another level of tax reform, GST is going to screw<br />
up the tax system in the country. Tax policy of any country plays vital role in bringing efficiency and<br />
effectiveness in the economy. In the past, India has relied too much on the indirect taxation system<br />
because of agrarian economy, low level of income and lack of reliable system to track personal income.<br />
From time to time, Government comes out with various policies to bring tax reform to simplify and<br />
strengthen the tax structure. One such step towards the simplification and rationalization of Indirect<br />
tax structure was taken by introducing VAT. Citizens of India welcomed this step and VAT has become<br />
a very popular tax. Very soon, people identified shortcomings in the structure while levying VAT at<br />
both centre and state level. CENVAT also has a limitation of non inclusion of several taxes such as VAT,<br />
Surcharge and the like.<br />
To address such issues, GST as a part of comprehensive tax reform to ignite the harmonized<br />
consumption system, has been proposed to which the lower house has given its nod, but is still waiting<br />
in upper house. GST has been well accepted around the world with more than 140 countries in<br />
agreement where GST rate ranges between 15 to 20%. Going to be a single tax levied on goods<br />
and services being sold, GST will eliminate multiple taxes like CENVAT, Central sales tax, State sales<br />
tax, Octroi etc which will help in reducing tax evasion and lead country towards economic growth.<br />
The single taxation is going to put rest to the debate about republic and federation of the states<br />
where goods can freely move within the country broadening the thinking of the corporate to pan<br />
India level. The single tax system will lead towards increased transparency, less paper work and less<br />
accounting complications, leading to more competition among the manufacturing sector proving<br />
beneficial for the consumer. The efficiency will increase as a result of uniform taxation system since<br />
state specific advantages will go. The simpler the tax, more will be the compliance. By removing the<br />
cascading effect, layers of taxes and simplifying structures, GST will bring simplicity, more compliance<br />
and will help in widening the tax base. With GST, the cost of the production in domestic economy will<br />
fall leading to global competitiveness of manufacturers. According to expert bodies, GST will boost<br />
India’s economic growth by nearly 1 to 1.7%..<br />
In terms of growth, the macroeconomic impact of introduction of GST will really be significant.<br />
A shift from income to consumption-based taxation will surely increase the revenue of the country<br />
which in turn will increase the investment. In turbulent times when the fiscal deficit management is<br />
critical, a complete failure to implement GST will surge the fiscal deficit to around 4% during FY16-17.<br />
The need of the hour is to take care of certain issues including taxation on interstate services, stock<br />
transfers, and integration of central and state taxes before moving further.<br />
*Dr. Mandeep Mahendru is a Faculty Member in the area of Economics at IBS Gurgaon<br />
4 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
INTERACTION WITH :-<br />
Mr. Arvind Kumar, Deputy Secretary, Ministry of<br />
Heavy Industries & Public Enterprises, Govt of India<br />
Q: How difficult and challenging would it be to<br />
implement GST in a large federal system like India?<br />
A federal polity like India is characterised by diverse socio-economic and cultural ethos. While<br />
states like Maharashtra, Gujarat and Tamilnadu are at one end of the development continuum;<br />
North eastern states, Hill states stand at the other end. Implementation of a uniform GST across all<br />
states becomes challenging to that extent. GST implementation envisages a robust IT platform.<br />
Each participating state has to provide IT support on real time basis. In other words, the most<br />
laggard state will decide the pace of GST implementation and its functioning. Nevertheless,<br />
India is determined to take up the challenge and put GST in place very soon.<br />
Q: GST being a destination based tax, what will be its impact on the<br />
revenues of manufacturing states?<br />
GST, by virtue of being destination based tax, does not encompass in its fold the origin based<br />
tax like Central Sales Tax (CST). It is true that in the GST regime the manufacturing states or<br />
the producing states may lose CST revenue, but it is also true that generally these are the very<br />
states that also have large volume of service transactions. Under GST, these states will collect<br />
enough revenue by taxing services. It is also a fact that buoyancy of service tax is much more<br />
than that of CST, VAT (Value Added Tax) or Excise duty. In any case, Central Govt has promised<br />
to compensate those states which report fall in revenue by implementation of GST.<br />
Q: GST will make India one common market. How will it affect our<br />
international trade?<br />
A common market under GST would mean that one buys some inputs from one state, some<br />
from other and sells it in third state, yet he is reimbursed his ITC (Input Tax Credit). In a similar<br />
fashion, one can produce in any state, export from any port and can claim reimbursement from<br />
any state. Under GST, with the removal of cascading effect, the net indirect tax ceteris peribus<br />
will be lower than before, hence the product pricing becomes more competitive in international<br />
market. As far as imports are concerned, GST envisages abolition of CVD (Countervailing Duties)<br />
and SAD (Special Additional Duty) on imports, hence it may be the case that in the short run<br />
imports would rise but in the long run it will adjust to market forces since the Excise duty too is<br />
abolished and manufacturing becomes cheaper.<br />
Q: Will there be less corruption once GST is implemented? What are your<br />
views?<br />
The genesis of corruption perhaps lies in the human interface and exercise of discretionary<br />
powers. GST is expected to avoid human interface and is to work mainly though IT module, for<br />
which Government is designing GST network. The taxes can be filed objectively while sitting at<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 5
office/home. There will be a lot of automation in GST system which will act as check against<br />
scrupulous activities. In such a paradigm, there should not be place for corruption.<br />
Q: What is the tax rate structure proposed under GST?<br />
GST envisages two rate structures: (i) Central GST (ii) State GST. IGST will be charged on interstate<br />
transactions which would be roughly the addition of these two taxes. At present, there is no<br />
consensus on tax rates. The Constitution (Amendment) Bill has provision for formation of GST<br />
council headed by Union FM. This council is entrusted with the task of deciding the rates of GST,<br />
the exemption turnover threshold etc.<br />
Q: Will prices go up or down with GST? How will it benefit the common<br />
consumer?<br />
Generally price of a good is a function of demand quantity, quality, taste etc. and not tax rate.<br />
However, under GST the net indirect tax on inputs will become lower, with reduced transaction<br />
cost etc. the supply side economics will be eased up and with competitive market, the benefits<br />
are expected to be passed on to the common consumer.<br />
Q: What will be the impact of GST on the Indian economy?<br />
There are studies to show that with GST in place the GDP of India would grow between 0.9<br />
to 1.7%. With the rationalisation of indirect taxes and business entities having to report to less<br />
number of tax authorities, there will be a positive impact on ease of doing business in India.<br />
GST being familiar tax regime for the international business communities, the prospects of FDIs<br />
and other forms of investment will increase greatly, which will have an accelerator effect on the<br />
economy. Interplay of all these factors will boost the Indian economy.<br />
Interacted with:- Samvaad Team, IBS, Gurgaon on 5th <strong>July</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />
GST is 'Brahmastra' for country: Assocham<br />
(Source: The Economic Times, Jul 12, <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
CHENNAI: Terming the Goods and Services Tax Bill "Brahmastra" for the country,<br />
industry body Assocham said the country needs to have a simple platform to<br />
move goods within states.<br />
"GST is a Brahmastra for the country. Actually, we need to have a simple<br />
platform to move goods within India than we move goods outside the country,"<br />
Assocham president Sunil Kanoria told reporters.<br />
Stating that the present movement of goods within the country involves multiple<br />
processes, he said "it is more difficult to move trade within the country than<br />
moving it externally (outside India)".<br />
"We believe GST is possible and expect it to be passed during the monsoon<br />
session of Parliament. It (GST Bill) will have a multiplier effect across states in<br />
the country.” he said<br />
6 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
CAMPUS BUZZ<br />
Orientation Classes<br />
The orientation classes for the students of<br />
Class of 2018 started from 2nd June, <strong>2016</strong>. It was<br />
a 3 day program. During these three days, Prof.<br />
S.C. Sharma, Director, IBS Gurgaon addressed the<br />
students giving them the future vision and how IBS<br />
will play a major role in shaping their personality<br />
and career in upcoming two years; Dr. Anupama<br />
Raina, Dean, Placements made the students aware<br />
about the placement process and gave them<br />
guidelines for effective performance; Dr. Renu Verma, Academic Coordinator shared the details and<br />
guidelines about the academic functioning of PGPM program; Dr. Shalini Khandelwal, Associate<br />
Dean conducted Personality Development sessions and talked to students about the impact of<br />
different personality dimensions on managerial effectiveness; Dr. Vikas Gautam, Advisor - Student<br />
Council, Prof. Ekta Chauhan and Dr. Nidhi Tak, Joint Coordinators, Student Council exposed the<br />
students to the outside classroom activities at IBS which play a major role in overall development of<br />
students at the campus. Prof. Sangeeta Shahane, Area Coordinator, Soft Skills briefed students about<br />
the importance of Soft skills and how it helps in developing the personality and improving career<br />
opportunities for students.<br />
Talk by Director, Prof. S. C. Sharma on “Exit of Raghuram Rajan as the Governor<br />
of RBI”<br />
Prof. S. C. Sharma, Director, IBS Gurgaon, delivered a lecture<br />
on “Exit of Raghuram Rajan as the Governor of RBI” on 21st<br />
June, <strong>2016</strong> in the campus auditorium. Prof. Sharma highlighted<br />
the initiatives taken by Mr. Raghuram Rajan as the Governor of<br />
RBI and the past and current situation of Indian economy. As the<br />
news of Mr. Rajan’s exit made people fear about the crashing of<br />
the economy, Prof. S.C. Sharma shared the other side of the story<br />
stating the loopholes in the system while emphasizing on the<br />
leadership qualities a person should have to take everybody along.<br />
In-house Excel Workshop<br />
During 2-3 May, <strong>2016</strong>, Prof. Shweta Sharma, Prof. Shweta<br />
Agarwal, Prof. Sudarshan Burari and Prof. Vandana Jangid<br />
conducted Excel Workshop for ACC, Library & Admin staff<br />
members of IBS Gurgaon. Key deliverables were lookup functions,<br />
conditional formatting, pivot tables, go to function, text functions<br />
like concatenate, data validation google forms, google sheets,<br />
google drive, Mail merge, labels and email messages, twitter<br />
account and social media, followed by problem solving.<br />
From 10th May to 13th May <strong>2016</strong> an in-house excel workshop<br />
for all the faculty members was conducted. Key deliverables were conditional formatting, sorting<br />
&filtering; custom sort, advance filtering, cell referencing, dashboard, power pivot, pivot tables, data<br />
validation, Installation of data analysis tool pack and its practical implementation, Advance Excel tools<br />
likegoal seek, scenario, solver, etc.<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 7
One Day Management Development Programme on “Financial Orientation for<br />
Non- Finance Business Executives”<br />
IBS Gurgaon organised a One Day MDP on “Financial Orientation for Non- Finance Business<br />
Executive on 14th May, <strong>2016</strong>. The programme was coordinated by Dr.Sombala N, Faculty & MDP<br />
Coordinator and Prof. Ranika Chaudhary, Area Cordinator, Finance, IBS Gurgaon under the guidance<br />
of Director, Prof. S. C. Sharma and Dean, Prof. Gautam Kaul.<br />
The Programme was specially designed and structured with an<br />
objective of imparting basic skill-sets in understanding of the<br />
principles of finance and costing in business to non-finance<br />
business executives so that the key decisions can be evaluated<br />
in the light of financial implications. The various interactive<br />
sessions with hands on learning experience were conducted<br />
by Dr. Daryab Singh, Prof. Arun Agarwal and Prof. Vivek Bhatia,<br />
Faculty, IBS Gurgaon<br />
English Language Proficiency Classes<br />
Soft Skills department at IBS Gurgaon organized English Language Proficiency Classes for the<br />
Class of 2018 from 13th June, <strong>2016</strong> to 25th June, <strong>2016</strong>. The main objective of these sessions was to<br />
build functional grammar and business vocabulary along with enhancing the oral presentation skills.<br />
Emphasis was placed on structured thinking, coherent sentence formulation, linking paragraphs and<br />
honing students’ reading skills by way of analyzing caselets, newspaper articles and situations.<br />
More than 60 students enrolled for the classes. Students were divided into 2 batches which<br />
were being taken up by Prof. Deepa Diddi and Prof. Shikha Gupta respectively. Activities like group<br />
discussions, public speaking, presentations were the part of classes and handouts on how to improve<br />
communication skills were provided to the students for future reference.<br />
Club Activities @ IBS Gurgaon<br />
Under the aegis of Student Council of IBS Gurgaon, 20 student clubs operate and coordinate<br />
various academic and non - academic activities and events on the campus. The clubs consist of<br />
representatives from I & II year who are responsible for ideation, creation and management of year<br />
round competitions and activities at IBS Gurgoan.<br />
CLIPPIT<br />
“CLIPPIT” was organized by ETHNOS CLUB - the HR Club<br />
of IBS Gurgaon on 24th June, <strong>2016</strong> under the guidance of Dr.<br />
Reshmi Manna. The activity consisted of teams with 4 members<br />
each aiming at relationship building within the team in spite of<br />
external interference. The event saw huge participation of 120<br />
students from Ist & IInd yr. The 3 winning teams were awarded<br />
with certificates of appreciation and trophies.<br />
LOGO HUNT<br />
“LOGO HUNT” was organised by MARK!T CLUB - the Marketing Club of<br />
IBS Gurgaon on 24th June, <strong>2016</strong>. The event<br />
examined the awareness of different ‘logos’<br />
among the students. The competition was<br />
held under the supervision of Dr. Ranjita<br />
Gupta and Prof. Vineeta Jha. 64 teams of 2<br />
members each registered for the competition and after 4 rounds,<br />
only 5 teams proceeded to the finals. There were 3 winning teams<br />
who were awarded with certificates and trophies by the Director.<br />
8 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
CONVOCATION <strong>2016</strong><br />
IBS Business School. Gurgaon organised its Convocation <strong>2016</strong> on 18th June. <strong>2016</strong>, at Air Force<br />
Auditorium, New Delhi. The occasion was graced by business honchos from corporate world,<br />
viz. Mr. Vikram Pawah, Managing Director, Harley-Davidson, the Chief Guest for the ceremony;<br />
Mr. Bhaskar Pramanik, Chairman, Microsoft Corporation (India) Pvt. Ltd., the Distinguished Guest;<br />
and Mr. B.N. Puri, Executive Director & CEO, Asian Institute of Transport Development, the Guest<br />
of Honour. Prof. S. C. Sharma, Director, IBS Gurgaon, presided over the function.<br />
At the commencement, the Director, IBS Gurgaon, Prof. S.C. Sharma welcomed the<br />
distinguished guests, faculty members, graduating students and accompanying parents to the<br />
momentous occasion. During his address, Prof. Sharma shared the journey and accomplishments<br />
of IBS. He emphasized, that to be a successful professional, an individual should always be keen<br />
to add value by being an effective team player, a leader and a researcher. He advised students<br />
to develop themselves as an individual and professional with an infinite capacity to adjust,<br />
negotiate, reconcile, innovate, and also unlearn and relearn. Prof. S.C. Sharma congratulated<br />
the students and their parents for successful completion of the two years of the PGPM program<br />
and with this note, he declared the convocation open!<br />
Distinguished Guest, Mr. Bhaskar Pramanik presented the medals and plaques to the<br />
meritorious students of the Class of <strong>2016</strong>. In his address to the students, Mr. Pramanik spoke<br />
on making of India, stages through which the country has passed and period that the country<br />
has witnessed in the last 50-60 years. He also spoke on the demographic dividend that<br />
India presently has in terms of its young and talented population which needs to be skilled,<br />
particularly in rural areas and smaller towns.<br />
Mr. B.N. Puri, Guest of Honour distributed certificates to the graduating students and in his<br />
address to the students, he spoke at considerable length on the need for ethical conduct by<br />
various stake holders, in promotion and management of businesses. He relied heavily on the<br />
Indian scriptures to support his viewpoint that the meaning of Dharma is contextual and different<br />
forces in the society pursue dharma from their individual or sectional view. He administered the<br />
oath to the graduates of batch 2014-16.<br />
The convocation address was delivered by Mr. Vikram Pawah, Managing Director,<br />
Harley-Davidson, the Chief Guest of the ceremony. Mr. Pawah connected with the students<br />
in his energetic and vibrant demeanour. He spoke about the challenges faced by the present<br />
generation in the corporate. He drew attention of students towards three major factors, which<br />
make the current business scenario different from the preceding periods. In his view, the three<br />
major challenges which have to be managed by the present generation are handling highly<br />
accelerated speed, complexity and enhanced level of uncertainty. He distributed certificates to<br />
the graduates and congratulated them for their success.<br />
At the closure of the event, Dr. Renu Verma, Associate Dean & Academic Coordinator<br />
proposed the vote of thanks to all the reverent guests, Director, faculty members, students and<br />
their parents for making the event a great success with their benign presence!<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 9
CONVOCATION <strong>2016</strong><br />
Lighting of Lamp ceremony<br />
Saraswati Vandana by 2nd year students<br />
Dignitaries on the Dais<br />
Academic Coordinator, Dr. Renu Verma welcoming<br />
the Chief Guest, Mr. Vikram Pawah<br />
Prof. S.C. Sharma, Director, IBS Gurgaon, delivering<br />
the Welcome Address<br />
Mr. Vikram Pawah, MD, Harley Davidson, delivering the<br />
Convocation Address<br />
10 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
CONVOCATION <strong>2016</strong><br />
Mr. B.N Puri, Executive Director & CEO, Asian Institute<br />
of Transport Development administering the oath to<br />
the graduating students<br />
Captivated audience at the convocation ceremony<br />
Dr. Renu Verma delivering the Vote of Thanks<br />
Prof. S. C. Sharma felicitating the Guest of Honor,<br />
Mr. Bhaskar Pramanik, Chairman, Microsoft<br />
Corporation (India) Pvt Ltd<br />
Prof. S.C. Sharma with the distinguished guests<br />
IBS Gurgaon Faculty Members<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 11
FACULTY FORUM<br />
Faculty Research Seminars at IBS Gurgaon.<br />
A series of 12 faculty research seminars were organized during<br />
April-May, <strong>2016</strong> with the objective of knowledge sharing and promoting<br />
a research culture at IBS Gurgaon. The seminars were coordinated by<br />
Associate Dean & Research Coordinator, Dr. Shalini Khandelwal.<br />
Dr. Vikas Gautam on “Impact of Corporate Reputation and Consumer Trust on<br />
Perceived Risks and Purchase Intentions in Online Shopping Context” on 13th<br />
April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Vikas Gautam’s study explored the relationship between reputation management activities<br />
and consumers’ intentions to purchase through perceived corporate image, consumer trust and<br />
perceived risk. The study concluded that intention to purchase behavior<br />
can be predicted as a dependent variable with a rate of 74 % through<br />
antecedent constructs triggered by RM activities. The empirical results<br />
of this study show that perceived risk can be decreased by increasing<br />
consumer trust and positive corporate reputation based on RM activities<br />
(i.e. making high-volume and continuous commitments to the market<br />
for superior customer satisfaction, announcing the famous people preferring the offering of the firm,<br />
sponsoring important events in social life) of the firm.<br />
Dr. Shalini Khandelwal on “The Impact of Self Efficacy, Need for Achievement<br />
and Demographic Variables on Management Students’ Perception Regarding<br />
Web Based Learning Resources (WBLR)” on 13th April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Shalini Khandelwal discussed the growing importance and usage of Web Based Learning<br />
Resources in management education. Her research focused on the demographic and personality<br />
differences among students that may affect their perception of the various dimensions of WBLR. Her<br />
study concluded that students’ self efficacy has a significant impact on<br />
their perception of easiness and availability with respect to WBLR. The<br />
other personality variable of need for achievement affects the perception<br />
of usefulness and quality in relation to WBLR. However, the demographic<br />
variables of age, gender, graduation stream, rural-urban background did<br />
not have any significant impact on students’ perception regarding WBLR.<br />
Dr. Jyoti Ahluwalia on “Technology Enabled Finance” on 27th April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
In her talk, Dr. Jyoti Ahluwalia explained the concepts of Fintech firms, Bitcoin, Digital Currency<br />
and the Blockchain technology. She mentioned how technology is<br />
taking finance to new frontiers and changing the face of the industry.<br />
The digitalization process is creating a revolution and providing newer<br />
solutions to the finance industry. The talk explained the process of<br />
creating the digital coin using the Blockchain approach and how<br />
Blockchain as a technology was now being used in almost every industry.<br />
12 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
Prof. Vineeta Jha on “Branding of Hospitals in Healthcare Sector” on 27th<br />
April <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Prof. Vineeta Jha discussed about the Indian health sector which<br />
has been at vanguard of growth in the past decade. The main propellers<br />
of growth have been increasing health awareness, disposable income,<br />
increasing population, growing lifestyle related health issues, thrust in<br />
medical tourism, improved health insurance penetration, private and<br />
public sector initiatives etc. The role of private sector is accentuated by the increased demand being<br />
nominally met by government sector plagued by resource crunch and delayed decision making.<br />
Prof. Gautam Kaul on the book “Man’s Search for Meaning” by the famous<br />
Austrian Psychoanalyst Viktor Frankl on 11th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Prof. Gautam kaul discussed the fundamental theme of Frankl’s<br />
book and emphasized on the issue of survival. Although Frankl witnessed<br />
and experienced horror, Man’s Search for Meaning focuses less on the<br />
details of his own experience and more on how his time under Nazi rule<br />
showed him the human ability to survive and endure against all odds.<br />
Frankl believed that meaning can be derived from purposeful work, love<br />
and courage in face of difficulties. In coping with situations of utter helplessness, Frankl explained<br />
that everything can be taken from a man but one thing: the last of the human freedoms - to choose<br />
one’s attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one’s own way.<br />
Dr. Sombala N. on “Self Compassion” on 11th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Sombala talked about developing self compassion and self esteem among management<br />
students. Self-compassion refers to the ability to hold, understand and acknowledge one’s feelings<br />
of suffering with a sense of warmth, connection, and concern and<br />
accepting that one’s negative life experiences are an inevitable part of<br />
human life. People, who are characterized as compassionate, embrace<br />
others’ weaknesses and shortcomings without judging themselves.<br />
Ways to develop self compassion is through: extending kindness and<br />
understanding to oneself rather than harsh self-criticism and judgment;<br />
seeing one’s experiences as part of the larger human experience rather<br />
than as separating and isolating; and holding one’s painful thoughts and feelings in balanced<br />
awareness rather than over-identifying with them<br />
Dr. Ranjita Gupta on “Disruptive Marketing and Brand Building – A Case study<br />
of Patanjali Ayurveda Limited” on 13th May, 2015.<br />
Disruptive markets are overturning old market certainties. Most companies still follow a traditional<br />
marketing strategy that is good for existing markets, but it cannot predict the emergence of new<br />
markets. Marketers need to learn how to create markets where none<br />
exist. The case study aims to understand the tremendous success of<br />
Patanjali Ayurveda Limited, an FMCG company established in 2006 and<br />
its foray into Ayurvedic, herbs, food, cosmetics & juices, that touched an<br />
annual turnover of 2500 crore (US$370 million) in 2014-15.<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 13
Dr. Mandeep Kaur on “Impact of Advertisement Expenditure on Firm’s<br />
Performance: A Case of FMCG Industry in India” on 13th April, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Mandeep Kaur shared her research on a sample of 100 FMCG<br />
companies in India where she studied the impact of advertising and firm’s<br />
performance for the period ranging from 2005-06 to 2014-15. The study<br />
used sales, profits and firm value as measures of firm’s performance.<br />
Tobin’s Q ratio was used as a proxy for firm value. The study found a<br />
positive impact of advertisement expenditure on sales, profitability and<br />
firm value. The study further observed that sales revenue and profitability<br />
have a positive impact on firm value.<br />
Prof. Jean Saldanha on “Compostwali of the Daily Dump” on 19th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Prof Jean Saldanha shared the case study that she had presented in Mumbai at the CII Western<br />
Region Edgefarm HR case writing competition 2015 <strong>2016</strong>, co authored with IBS student Hempriya<br />
Banga, for which they had been awarded the first prize in the primary<br />
data category, on Feb 26, <strong>2016</strong>. The presentation focused on a category,<br />
not often covered by business case studies, i.e. the waste industry which<br />
has a value of over US $ 1.5 billion in India. Prof. Saldanha emphasized<br />
how a case study with a good story must be backed with a clear learning<br />
objective and strong teaching notes.<br />
Dr. Tavleen Kaur on “Employee Reviews on Company Independent Websites’<br />
on 19th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Tavleen Kaur’s seminar presented a conceptual framework on<br />
how job seekers perceive company independent websites as a tool for<br />
providing recruitment communication and their impact on organizational<br />
attractiveness using Information Realism, Person-Environment fit<br />
framework and Source Credibility framework. She shared that apart from<br />
company websites, job seekers are now using company independent websites, forums or online<br />
communities to gather a more truthful picture and information about the job and organizational<br />
attributes.<br />
Dr. Anupama Raina on “Challenging Field Situation and the Making of a True<br />
Leader: Takeaway from Abduction and Release of an IAS officer” on 20th May,<br />
<strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Anupama Raina’s presented her case on the making of a leader, a hard task master, a young<br />
IAS officer, who was posted as a district collector and the circumstances that led to his abduction.<br />
She discussed how someone who is highly committed, enjoys power,<br />
can make a difference in the lives of others, yet remains grounded<br />
and fearlessly works to achieve the set targets. This case had a lesson<br />
for everyone aspiring to be a leader and showed how to demonstrate<br />
leadership in the most challenging field situations.<br />
14 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
Prof. S. K. Baurai on “The Google File System” on 20th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Prof. S. K. Baurai made a presentation on the research paper written by Sanjay Ghemawat,<br />
Howard Gobioff, and Shun-Tak Leung of Google. Google has pioneered in the art of processing the<br />
big data in a distributed environment and that also with the cost effective<br />
commodity computers. The File System is widely deployed within Google<br />
as the storage platform for the processing of data used by their service<br />
as well as research and development teams that require large data sets.<br />
This research paper and few more from Google have been the basis that<br />
helped in developing the Hadoop platform for Big Data Analytics.<br />
IBS Gurgaon congratulates Dr. Ranjita Gupta and Dr. Nidhi Tak on successfully completing<br />
their Ph.D. from Banasthali University.<br />
Paper Publications<br />
The following 3 papers were published in Advances in Economics & Business Management,<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>ume 3, <strong>Issue</strong> 2/3, April-June, <strong>2016</strong>:-<br />
• “Disruptive Marketing and Brand Building – a Case Study of Patanjali, Ayurveda Limited”<br />
by Dr. Ranjita Gupta<br />
• “Social Media brings Paradigm Shift in Brand Management” by Prof. Vineeta Jha<br />
• “A Review of Profitability and Performance of Major Sectors of Small and Medium<br />
Enterprises in India” by Prof. Vineeta Mishra<br />
Dr. Shalini Khandelwal’s case study “ iDreamCareer.com: A Case on Social Entrepreneurship<br />
in Education” was published in 8M - International Journal of Indian Management and<br />
Strategy, <strong>Vol</strong>ume 21, <strong>Issue</strong> 2, April – June, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Dr. Sombala N’s article “Floods in Kashmir Valley: A Note on the Disaster and Conflict Interface”<br />
was published in World Focus: Indo-centric Foreign Affairs Journal, <strong>Issue</strong> May <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
Paper Presentations<br />
The following 3 papers were presented at Conference on Brand Management (CBM <strong>2016</strong>),<br />
IIT Delhi held during 16 -17 April, <strong>2016</strong>:-<br />
• “Branding of Hospitals in Health Care Sector” by Prof. Vineeta Jha<br />
• “Patanjali, Ayurveda & Ramdev- Redefining Brand Building - The Indian Way” by<br />
Dr. Ranjita Gupta<br />
• “Dimensions of Service Quality and their Impact on Customer Loyalty: A Study of Major<br />
Telecom Players in Delhi NCR Region” by Dr. Ranjita Gupta<br />
Dr. Ranjita Gupta presented her case study “Disruptive Marketing and Brand Building – a Case<br />
Study of Patanjali Ayurveda Limited” at the International Conference on Leadership Strategies<br />
for Management of Marketing, Accounting, Business, Entrepreneurship, Economics and<br />
Tourism, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi on 15th May, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 15
CELEBRITY WATCH : Raghuram Rajan<br />
Born on February 3, 1963, in a Tamil Brahmin family, Raghuram<br />
Rajan is well known as an economic reformist and is largely loved by<br />
the industry and market participants for his consistent and transparent<br />
communication.<br />
Rajan did his schooling from Delhi Public School, RK Puram, where he learnt Hindi for the first<br />
time. Before this, he had attended a French school at Belgium, where his father, R Govindarajan, an IPS<br />
topper and a staff officer of Research and Analysis Wing was posted. During his graduation at IIT- Delhi,<br />
he was awarded with the Director’s Gold Medal as the best all-round student. In 1987, he earned a Post<br />
Graduate Diploma in Business Administration from the Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad<br />
where he was a gold medalist. Apart from being a brilliant academician, he is an author, avid quizzer<br />
and runs marathon.<br />
After graduation, Rajan joined Tata Administrative Services as a management trainee but left after a<br />
few months to join the doctoral program in management at the MIT Sloan School of Management. In<br />
1991, he received a PhD for his thesis titled Essays on Banking, where he realized his research interests<br />
in banking, corporate finance, and economic development.<br />
Raghuram Rajan has earned several awards in his career, starting from ‘Fischer Black Prize’,<br />
awarded by the American Finance Association for his contribution to the theory and practice of finance.<br />
NASSCOM, in 2010, named him ‘The Global Indian’. He was even awarded for his book “Fault Lines:<br />
How Hidden Fractures Still Threaten the World Economy’ in the same year. In the following year, he<br />
received the Infosys Prize for Social Sciences – Economics for his work on analyzing the contribution<br />
of financial development to economic growth. In 2013, he received an award for his ground-breaking<br />
research work, which influenced the macro-economic policies around the world. Subsequently, in the<br />
year 2014, he was conferred with the Central Banker of the year Award by various publications.<br />
Rajan was the youngest chief economist at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) from 2003 to<br />
2006 and was a Professor of Finance at the University of Chicago, Booth School of Business from<br />
1991 to 2013. He is also a visiting professor for the World Bank, Federal Reserve Board, and Swedish<br />
Parliamentary Commission. He joined the Indian government as Chief Economic Advisor to the Ministry<br />
of Finance and prepared the economic survey for India for the year 2012 - 13 before heading the RBI.<br />
At the helm of RBI, serving as the 23rd Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, Rajan has<br />
contributed immensely for improving the country’s economic scenario and led profuse developments<br />
in the Indian financial system. Under his governorship, RBI came out with a new monetary framework<br />
that focused on bringing down inflation, the lowest since 90’s and rising of Foreign Currency Non-<br />
Resident (B) deposits to bolster foreign exchange reserves. Today, the Forex Reserves are high as that<br />
of $363 billion, all due to his pragmatic approach. His presence made our currency stable. Moreover,<br />
he released on-tap licensing to ease the process of banking. Lower inflation and stability in currency<br />
markets helped bring down key repo rate to a five-year low, which enhanced the economic growth<br />
and consumer spending as well.<br />
In a recent interaction with the students at Kolkata Presidency University, Raghuram Rajan<br />
batted for the federal government on the GST bill, describing it as an “absolutely good thing” for<br />
the country as it will expand the tax net, shore up revenues for the exchequer and reduce the state<br />
barriers, making the country a common market place.<br />
Raghuram Rajan’s practices, principles and contribution towards our economy are commendable,<br />
making our country reach new heights and compete strongly in the global financial ecosystem.<br />
Compiled By:- Priyanka Agarwal, Class of 2017, IBS Gurgaon<br />
16 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
ALL ABOUT GST BILL<br />
Robin Manocha*<br />
GST or the Goods and Services Tax is an indirect tax that brings<br />
together most of the taxes that are imposed on all goods and<br />
services (except a few) under a single banner. This is in contrast<br />
to the current system, where taxes are levied separately on goods<br />
and services. The GST is a comprehensive form of tax based on a uniform rate of tax for both<br />
goods and services. However, the GST is payable only at the final point of consumption.<br />
Touted as the “single most important tax reform since 1947”, the Goods and Service<br />
Tax (GST) has been in the offing for a decade and continues to be the top priority on the<br />
economic agenda of the government. Although GST has been the subject of wide scrutiny<br />
and debate, most of the discussions have been centered on its road to passage or on its<br />
larger form and structure.<br />
Much emphasis has been placed on the benefits of uniformity that the GST would<br />
usher in. Accordingly, GST would comprise an equal Central GST (CGST) and State GST<br />
(SGST), with no deviations from the rates/exemption lists, so as to obviate potential “rate<br />
wars” between States. Even in terms of the model law, the potential for deviation stems<br />
from the concurrent powers of the Centre and States to enact their own GST legislation,<br />
compounded by the inheritance of the existing disjointed tax structure. It may be recalled<br />
that even the Value Added Tax regime began with a pledge of uniformity, but devolved over<br />
time as each State formulated different tax events, rates and exemptions.<br />
Most crucially, the GST Dispute Settlement Authority, which would have reined in any<br />
deviations affecting the harmonized structure of the GST, has been done away with. The<br />
existing tax system has typically followed a model of rewarding States where production<br />
activity is based (origin States), as opposed to States where consumption is high (destination<br />
States). Accordingly, most States have incentivized the setting up of local industries in order<br />
to drive growth and augment tax collections. While origin States may chalk out measures to<br />
redress the imbalance, consumption and production patterns will not alter overnight, and<br />
industrialized States could be left in the lurch, at least in the immediate aftermath of the<br />
GST. Interestingly, there seems to be no globally available precedent which offers a solution<br />
to such an imbalance. In the inevitable shift which the Indian GST necessitates, destination<br />
States such as Bihar and Kerala clearly stand to gain in terms of revenue, while origin States<br />
such as Gujarat and Maharashtra stand to lose, and had expectedly put up more initial<br />
opposition to GST. In order to partially level the playing field, the Centre proposed a 1 per<br />
cent origin-based additional GST.<br />
Along the road to GST, it is also critical that these issues are subjected to the same level<br />
of governmental and public scrutiny so that the implementation of GST is a success in letter<br />
as well as in spirit.<br />
*Robin Manocha is a student of Class of 2017 at IBS Gurgaon<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 17
GST BILL - A PANACEA FOR INDIAN<br />
ECONOMY<br />
Aditi Shukla*<br />
There has been a big rush to push GST bill into action. Goods and<br />
Services tax is a tax levied when a consumer buys a good or service. It is<br />
designed to subsume with a single comprehensive tax which brings all the<br />
other taxes under one umbrella. It aims to eliminate the cascading effect of<br />
taxes on production and distribution prices on goods and services.<br />
Previously, excise duty and service tax were levied by central government while value added tax was<br />
levied by state government which was one of the reasons why such a cross utilization of credits was not<br />
allowed. However, GST aims to solve the issue of cascading of taxes. It never made any difference to<br />
people whether the tax is levied by the state or center. A tax is a tax and there is a tax on a tax currently.<br />
GST is designed to combat this problem. Solving the problem of cascading of taxes will be a win- win<br />
situation for the citizens of the country and the government.<br />
The question still remains unanswered whether it would be implemented in India? There is a dual<br />
view as today states have autonomy in collecting taxes, they are also worried about central government<br />
sharing the tax revenues with them. If India becomes a common market, then the states will have to<br />
share their power of taxing with the union government. It would mean that states will not have the<br />
power of increasing or decreasing the taxes as much as they want. On the other hand, the consensus<br />
of opinion is that the implementation of GST would lower prices of goods, thereby benefiting both<br />
consumers and manufacturers. It would also simplify the tax code, which currently is a disaster. It<br />
would also reduce the compliance and procedural costs as returns and reporting will be comfortable<br />
under GST. According to some experts, it would also add approximately 100 to 200 basis points to GDP.<br />
Though there are three models of GST which would be levied for state, center or both. According<br />
to some experts, India should adopt a dual GST model administered by central and state governments<br />
in order to abate the differences between state and central governments. Keeping these differences in<br />
mind, the bill has proposed to have a GST council where in the state and central minister of finance will<br />
have equal powers followed by a Dispute Settlement authority to mitigate the issues between both the<br />
governments. Also, it would encourage the small businesses to come into action as the location bias will<br />
be removed through this comprehensive bill and the youth will be able to come up with more startups<br />
without worrying about the tax differences in different states.<br />
Interestingly, according to the Joint Working Group appointed by the empowered committee in<br />
2007, India would have a quadruple tax structure having components namely- Central tax on goods<br />
extending up to retail level, Central service tax, State VAT goods, State VAT on services. All these matters<br />
are still being figured out and worked upon by the state and central governments so that they come out<br />
with the best and calibrated GST bill. This “dual v/s quadruple” matter of abundant complications and<br />
entanglements has acquired urgency for the government. April 2017 is seen as the last window for rolling<br />
out GST. For GST to be implemented from next April, the government will have to pass the central GST<br />
legislation once the Constitution amendment bill is cleared by Parliament and state legislatures.<br />
GST has been subject to lot of opposition. “All parties other than Congress are supporting GST and<br />
even Congress chief ministers are in favor of it,” said a top government source, adding that the Centre<br />
was confident of successfully pushing the legislation through Rajya Sabha .West Bengal CM Mamta<br />
Banerjee’s support for GST has also buoyed them, sparking optimism that CMs of other ‘consuming’<br />
states, such as Bihar, Odisha, Kerala and UP, will also back the GST bill since they stand to gain through<br />
higher tax collection. This would be the first tax of a kind in India and if laid out legislatively correct and<br />
publicly beneficial, it will definitely be a panacea for our country’s economy.<br />
*Aditi Shukla is a student of Class of 2017 at IBS Gurgaon<br />
18 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
ALUMNI SUCCESS STORY<br />
4 Tenets for Professional Success<br />
By: Karan Bhujbal, Class of 2010, IBS Gurgaon<br />
‘Dilon mein tum apni betabian leke chal rahe ho, to zinda ho tum’.<br />
This line from Javed Akthar, from the movie Zindagi Na Milegi<br />
Doobara, sums up the constant fears and apprehensions I had while<br />
doing an MBA. Where was I going to get placed? What would be the<br />
right career start for me? Would it be interesting enough? And above all,<br />
how much would I earn in the short and long term?<br />
That was 6.5years back and fast forwarding to the present, I currently work for Vuclip, a Silicon<br />
Valley originated company in the digital media entertainment space. I’m a part of the global corporate<br />
marketing team, and I look at marketing communications across various regions. Prior to this, I worked<br />
for the MSL Group, Publicis Groupe’s Strategic Communications and Engagement Company, for 5.5<br />
years. My core functional areas were Public Relations (PR), Social Media and Experiential Campaigns.<br />
My professional journey is just 1% done, but there sure have been some lessons, that essentially<br />
made my mental make-up and have helped me grow in the corporate world.<br />
Everything counts<br />
From the way you dress, to the way you talk, to every presentation<br />
you give and every point you make in a meeting, everything counts.<br />
Your bosses, your colleagues, your clients, your investors and your<br />
customers, all are judging you, consciously or unconsciously, at each<br />
moment.<br />
In 2014, I made it to the list of India’s top 30 Under 30 PR professionals by PRmoment.in. The<br />
achievement was special, because one, my employer nominated me and two, I made it to the final<br />
list. The achievements cited to file my nomination included strategic thinking for my clients, creative<br />
execution, innovative approach, impact in terms of marketing and business impact of campaigns.<br />
But what made these achievements possible was a day-on-day relentless drive for excellence,<br />
to deliver meaningful results and an always-on conversation with internal and external stakeholders.<br />
Without this, I wouldn’t ever come up with any creative solution, I wouldn’t have ever been able<br />
to discover a problem, let alone solve it and I most certainly wouldn’t have got the trust from my<br />
employer and my clients to execute things.<br />
Attitude is everything<br />
I think, over the years I’ve built a strict work regime for myself, be it reaching office on time,<br />
having a ‘yes, can’ attitude, to focusing on results and not efforts and a perpetual self-improvement<br />
drive.<br />
At the end of 2014, my client Opera Software’s Global CEO was visiting Delhi. We wanted to<br />
make big news. So we decided to do a flash mob, with our global CEO dancing in it, with his senior<br />
leadership team and 50 professional dancers, at one of the biggest malls in Delhi. And this was<br />
just one of the activities scheduled for him, within the 24 hours he was here for. We got all experts<br />
together, a dance school, an events agency, our PR act and social media, in no time and got things<br />
going. The result - the flash mob was a huge success; it made news not just in India, but in global<br />
publications too.<br />
A week later, we got a mail informing us that Opera’s stock prices rose by a few basis points and<br />
since no other event had happened in the past week, it was probably our flash mob that did it. We<br />
didn’t plan for is; but I guess our attitude made it happen.<br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong> | SAMVAAD 19
Articulation is victory<br />
There are many ways to say this, like ‘Begin with an end in mind’, or ‘Ambition without knowledge<br />
is like a boat on dry land’. This applies to an idea you’re about to pitch, a point you’re about to make<br />
or an interview you’re about to give. You need to know what you want to achieve out of it and you<br />
need to appropriately communicate it.<br />
At the beginning of 2015, I was clear that I needed a new challenge; something that was in the<br />
consumer space; that built on my current skill set and more, and that gave me international exposure.<br />
In that pursuit, I got a role with Vuclip, my current employer, where I’m working in international<br />
markets. I now have done campaigns across Malaysia, Indonesia and UAE and all of that has been an<br />
enriching experience. But if I hadn’t articulated to myself what I wanted, this experience would never<br />
have happened.<br />
Camp is what you make out of it<br />
At the end of 2010, I was given a client Evernote, which was a US based productivity app. I was<br />
apprehensive of what could I do to promote an app and being a good performer, why was my<br />
employer giving me such an unknown brand to work with.<br />
But with strategic communications and a great team, we managed to organically increase the<br />
user base of the app from 20,000 in December 2010 to 5 million in September 2015. I also won<br />
6 Indian and international industry awards for our work on the brand, such as Gold – Marketing<br />
campaign of the year at the 2014 International Business Awards, Technology campaign of the year<br />
award at 2014 PR Week Asia awards, Best use of social media for crowdsourcing at the 2013 PR Daily<br />
Social Media awards, Gold Stevie at the 2013 International Business Awards and Best PR campaign in<br />
the technology category at the 2013 Indian PR and Corporate Communications awards.<br />
For any questions or comments, feel free to ping me on Twitter @KB_Ideabaker.<br />
BOOK REVIEW<br />
Rebooting India: Realizing a Billion Aspirations<br />
Author: Nandan Nilekani and Viral Shah<br />
Publisher: Penguin Books India, 2015<br />
Rebooting India reconnoiters the faults in India’s road to effective governance<br />
and imagines patching these problems with technology. An audacious premise<br />
and prescription to this book is that, one hundred people contained in 10 startups<br />
can append government and can essentially transform India. As a pioneering<br />
example this book uses AADHAR, the world’s largest social identity program on<br />
which Nilekani and Shah worked and created a startup with in the government.<br />
Nandan Nilekani, who is called as “ the Bill Gates of Bangalore” the cofounder and former<br />
CEO of Infosys along with Viral Shah, the co-inventor of the Julia programming language, and cofounder<br />
of FourthLion Technologies , says that the book is a combination of things they have done<br />
and the things they have extrapolated in future with similar approach. Beyond the potential of the<br />
AADHAR card, the book also sketches how vital area of governance such as health, education,<br />
the legal system can be transformed with the help of technology. The book also highlights 12<br />
challenges where technology can make a difference and a bang of the buck for using technology.<br />
It will also be a critical part for the effectiveness of GST, which has been put forward as the<br />
next big thing in the country. Once accepted, its implementation will depend on how technology<br />
is able to pilot the tie up of things so as to bring an ideal solution.<br />
Rebooting India pictures a new governance paradigm shift, via access to a data network that<br />
has every single Indian on it.<br />
Reviewed By:- Komudi Arora, Class of 2018, IBS Gurgaon<br />
20 SAMVAAD | <strong>Vol</strong>. 3 | <strong>Issue</strong> 3 | JULY <strong>2016</strong>
AWARD WINNERS<br />
Ms. Hempriya Banga, receiving NJ Yasaswy Gold Medal & Sumanta Dutta Memorial Award<br />
Ms. Jaspreet Kaur, receiving NJ Yasaswy Gold Medal & Sumanta Dutta Memorial Award<br />
Ms. Kalpana Yadav, receiving Manu BhatnagarMemorial Award
IBS, Gurgaon<br />
IDPL Complex<br />
Old Delhi Gurgaon Road<br />
Dundahera<br />
Gurgaon–12<strong>2016</strong><br />
Haryana<br />
Tel : 0124-4980950 (Board)<br />
Fax : 0124-4980999<br />
Printed at : www.sitafinearts.com<br />
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced without<br />
prior permission in writing from IBS Gurgaon. The views expressed by the<br />
authors are purely personal and do not reflect the views of the institute or the<br />
organization with which they are associated.