SRON_Spectrum_2016
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
SPECTRUM NO. 18<br />
MARCH <strong>2016</strong><br />
DISTANT PLANETS<br />
THROW LIGHT ON EARTH<br />
SEARCHING FOR ANSWERS<br />
IN THE HOT UNIVERSE<br />
AEROSOLS: MISSING LINK<br />
IN CLIMATE RESEARCH
Veni for research into cosmic structures<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> astronomer Hiroki Akamatsu has<br />
budget of clusters and the contribution this<br />
2<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Content<br />
received a Veni grant worth 250,000<br />
euros from the Netherlands Organisation<br />
for Scientific Research (NWO) to investigate<br />
the evolution of cosmic structures.<br />
For this, Akamatsu will make use of the<br />
new Japanese space telescope ASTRO-H<br />
(now called: Hitomi). In addition, he will<br />
contribute to the development of a new<br />
‘imaging spectrometer’ for the large successor<br />
of ASTRO-H, the space telescope<br />
ATHENA (ESA).<br />
makes to the formation of cosmic structures.<br />
Secondly he will focus on developing a<br />
power ful X-ray spectrometer for the space<br />
telescope ATHENA. The spectrometer can be<br />
used for astronomical missions but is also important<br />
for materials sciences, for example.<br />
Short news ............................................ 2<br />
Using small blocks to find<br />
large waves........................................... 6<br />
Distant planets shed light<br />
on earth............................................... 10<br />
OOne of the major questions in modern-day<br />
astronomy is how cosmic structures are<br />
formed. These largely evolve at the inter -<br />
sections of the cosmic web that also harbor<br />
large clusters of galaxies. In these clusters the<br />
most visible (baryonic) material in the universe<br />
is also found in the form of hot plasma<br />
(T~10 6 -10 8 K). This hot plasma emits a lot<br />
of X-rays and Akamatsu will study these.<br />
He will first of all concentrate on the energy<br />
Artist’s impression of ASTRO-H, also called Hitomi<br />
(Akihiro Ikeshita/JAXA).<br />
Tropomi ready for transport to Russia<br />
Searching for answers in<br />
the hot universe.................................. 12<br />
Aerosols: missing link in<br />
climate research .................................. 15<br />
SPEX-airborne ready for NASA<br />
test flight ............................................ 17<br />
Wouter blogs... From the South Pole<br />
to the edge of the universe .............. 20<br />
The missions to date........................... 28<br />
After a successful integration with the<br />
satellite, the Dutch earth observation<br />
instrument Tropomi is now ready for<br />
transport to Plesetsk in Russia. From<br />
the third quarter of <strong>2016</strong> onwards the<br />
European earth observation mission will<br />
collect very accurate data worldwide<br />
about our climate and air quality.<br />
2015 was a busy and exciting year for the<br />
Tropomi partners. After a successful assembly<br />
at Airbus Defence and Space in Stevenage the<br />
entire earth observation satellite was shipped<br />
to Toulouse in July last year where Intespace<br />
subjected it to an extensive test program.<br />
Both the satellite and instrument passed this<br />
with good marks. The satellite has now re -<br />
turned to Stevenage where it is being pre -<br />
pared for the transport to the launch base in<br />
Plesetsk, Russia. There, Tropomi will be<br />
launched this autumn onboard<br />
a Russian Rockot<br />
launcher.<br />
Tropomi detects sunlight<br />
that is reflected by the atmosphere<br />
and compares this<br />
with light directly from the
S H O R T N E W S<br />
sun. The sunlight is reflected via mirrors, un -<br />
rav eled by gratings and eventually recorded<br />
with a detector. Thanks to Dutch innovations<br />
like the immersed grating of <strong>SRON</strong> and TNO,<br />
the infrared spectrometer is 40 times smaller<br />
than its predecessor (which was equipped<br />
with a conventional grating) without compromising<br />
the precision.<br />
The data collected by Tropomi in space are<br />
processed by KNMI, <strong>SRON</strong>, and others and<br />
then made suitable for scientific research and<br />
other applications. Parallel to the preparations<br />
for the hardware, a Dutch team from Airbus<br />
Defence and Space and KNMI are working on<br />
the operational aspects of the ground segment<br />
of the mission at ESOC, the European Space<br />
Operations Centre in Darmstadt, Germany.<br />
3<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Millions for medium-sized black holes<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> researcher Peter Jonker has been<br />
awarded a prestigious grant worth<br />
2 million euros by the European Research<br />
Council for research into the existence<br />
of medium-sized black holes.<br />
With Whis group, Jonker will tackle one of the<br />
big mysteries of high-energy physics:<br />
do medium-sized black holes actually exist?<br />
Astronomers think that these elusive mediumsized<br />
black holes – with a mass of hundreds<br />
to hundreds of thousands of solar masses –<br />
must have evolved early in the history of the<br />
universe from the first generation of superstars<br />
or from enormous gas clouds that collapsed<br />
into black holes. Accordingly space<br />
around galaxies should be full of them, in -<br />
clud ing the space around our own Milky Way.<br />
There are now strong indications for the existence<br />
of medium-sized black holes but there<br />
is no direct evidence yet.<br />
Jonker therefore wants to use ESA’s new<br />
space telescope Gaia and the largest tele -<br />
scopes on earth to study objects and phe -<br />
nom ena that can only have arisen due to the<br />
activity of a medium-sized black hole. This<br />
concerns ultracompact receding clusters, red<br />
supergiant’s that feed extremely clear X-ray<br />
sources, and white dwarfs that are pulled<br />
apart by tidal forces. Jonker is searching for<br />
Artist’s impression of the Gaia space telescope (ESA/ATG<br />
medialab; background: ESO/S. Brunier).<br />
stars located in the sphere of influence of<br />
a candidate medium-sized black hole. By<br />
measuring their movements he can determine<br />
the mass of the black hole.<br />
Gelderland invests in Smart Space Cluster<br />
The Province of Gelderland is investing<br />
195,000 euros in establishing a Smart<br />
Space Cluster, which develops innovative<br />
products for the space sector. In the<br />
cluster – in which <strong>SRON</strong> is participating –<br />
companies are working together with<br />
knowledge institutions. The sophisticated<br />
space technology must also be usable in<br />
health care, nutrition, and the manufac -<br />
turing industry.<br />
I<br />
In the coming period the Smart Space Cluster<br />
partners will work on innovative space tech -<br />
niques that can subsequently also have spin-off<br />
applications on earth. This must result in new<br />
projects that generate extra jobs.<br />
Besides <strong>SRON</strong>, the Smart Space Cluster participants<br />
are the companies Q-Concepts, PMP,<br />
Prange, Veldlaser, Sumipro, Inspiro, and Mecon.<br />
NOVA, Radboud University, and the University<br />
of Twente are also taking part. The platform<br />
will be further expanded in the coming period.<br />
The project must result in five business cases<br />
that can be further developed and marketed<br />
and in a platform where the knowledge can<br />
be shared. <strong>SRON</strong> is acting as the launching cus-<br />
The project participants of the Smart Space Cluster with the<br />
representative of the Province of Gelderland (QConcepts).<br />
tomer in this cluster, in other words parts of<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> hardware projects will be contributed.
‘The second earth’ unveiled in NEMO<br />
4<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
On the afternoon of Wednesday, 27 Janu -<br />
ary <strong>2016</strong> ‘The second earth’ was officially<br />
opened at Science Center NEMO. <strong>SRON</strong> is<br />
sponsoring this exhibit, which is part of<br />
the exhibition ‘Searching for life’.<br />
T‘The second earth’ specifically focuses on the<br />
habitable zone around a star. In the exhibit,<br />
visitors can change the position of a planet<br />
in the habitable zone around a star like our<br />
sun and then experience what happens. On<br />
a screen they also receive information about<br />
the changed living conditions on the planet.<br />
The research into exoplanets, planets around<br />
stars other than our sun, is a new line of research<br />
for <strong>SRON</strong>. The institute is mainly focus -<br />
ing on analyzing exoplanet atmospheres in<br />
collaboration with other Dutch institutes and<br />
universities. The exhibit at NEMO brings this<br />
new focus area to life.<br />
After a word of welcome by <strong>SRON</strong> director<br />
Roel Gathier, three exoplanet researchers gave<br />
presentations. Michiel Min (<strong>SRON</strong>) considered<br />
whether we are alone in the universe, Frans<br />
Snik (Leiden University) said something about<br />
the research into rainbows on exoplanets, and<br />
Wim van Westrenen (VU University Amsterdam)<br />
compared planetary research within and<br />
outside of our solar system. Then ‘The second<br />
earth’ was ceremoniously opened by Amito<br />
Haarhuis (deputy director NEMO) and Roel<br />
Gathier (<strong>SRON</strong>).<br />
European grant for revolutionary red-shift machine<br />
With funding from the European Research<br />
Council (2.4 million euros) <strong>SRON</strong><br />
researcher Jochem Baselmans will<br />
de velop a revolutionary instrument to<br />
measure the red shift of so-called sub -<br />
milli meter galaxies.<br />
VVisible and/or ultraviolet light emitted by distant<br />
galaxies is visible in the infrared due to<br />
the red shift. These galaxies are known as<br />
submillimeter galaxies. The instrument that<br />
Baselmans will develop – MOSAIC (Multi<br />
Object Spectrometer with an Array of superconducting<br />
Integrated Circuits) – will soon be<br />
able to simultaneously measure the emission<br />
spectrum of no less than 25 of these galaxies<br />
over an enormous bandwidth. MOSAIC will<br />
therefore make it possible to realize a syste m -<br />
a tic study of the enormous number of submillimeter<br />
galaxies, something that is unfeasible<br />
at present.<br />
With the ‘red–shift machine’ Baselmans and<br />
his team hope to obtain a lot of new infor -<br />
mation about the evolution of galaxies. The<br />
instrument will also enable astronomers to<br />
measure the distance to these galaxies.<br />
The heart of MOSAIC consists of an array of<br />
25 pixels that capture infrared or submilli -<br />
meter radiation in a frequency range of 325-<br />
905 GHz. Each pixel has an antenna that can<br />
change its direction of observation. This<br />
means that MOSAIC can point each pixel<br />
independently to an individual galaxy.<br />
A high-resolution spectrometer (R=500)<br />
located behind the antenna measures the<br />
galaxy’s spectrum. All of these functionalities<br />
are combined in a single chip that is based<br />
on superconducting nanotechnology.<br />
MOSAIC is being developed in collaboration<br />
with Delft University of Technology and the<br />
Leiden Observatory. The observations will be<br />
made using the Japanese telescope ASTE in<br />
Chile.<br />
The heart of MOSAIC consists of an array of<br />
25 pixels. Each pixel has an antenna that can<br />
change its direction of observation.<br />
This means that MOSAIC can point each pixel (A)<br />
independently to an individual galaxy. A highresolution<br />
spectrometer (R=500) located behind<br />
the antennae measures the galaxy’s spectrum (B).
More collaboration with China<br />
In the past year several more important<br />
steps have been taken towards a structural<br />
collaboration with the Chinese<br />
space sector. <strong>SRON</strong> is involved in this<br />
together with TNO, NSO, the Dutch<br />
government, and other Dutch space organizations<br />
and institutes. A possible CO 2<br />
mission to be realized with Chinese fund -<br />
ing is of particular interest.<br />
CChina is already an important player in the<br />
international aerospace industry but the Chinese<br />
government wants to strengthen that<br />
position even further still. China is therefore<br />
seeking active collaboration with experienced<br />
international partners. The long-term goal is<br />
for the Netherlands and China to collaborate<br />
on the design and development of new space<br />
instruments and the use of these by science<br />
and society. In 2014, TNO and the Beijing<br />
Institute of Space Machinery and Electronics<br />
(BISME) established a joint China lab. In May<br />
2015 this led to the signing of a collaboration<br />
agreement (INSET) by a cluster of Dutch space<br />
companies and institutes that focus on the<br />
Chinese market and are therefore seeking a<br />
closer collaboration.<br />
The parties involved are TNO (official secretary),<br />
<strong>SRON</strong>, NLR, ISIS BV, VDL ETG, Nedinsco,<br />
ATG Europe, Hyperion Technologies, and<br />
Science & Technology. Delft University of<br />
Tech nology is involved in the cluster as a<br />
collaborating partner.<br />
At the end of May 2015, follow-up plans<br />
were discussed for a concrete collaboration<br />
between TNO, <strong>SRON</strong>, and BISME, and a<br />
Chinese CO 2 satellite mission with Dutch<br />
S H O R T N E W S<br />
A cluster of Dutch space companies and institutes<br />
that focus on the Chinese market – and are seeking<br />
closer ties – signed a collaboration agreement (INSET)<br />
on 22 May 2015.<br />
input is high on the agenda. The mission will<br />
specifically focus on making an inventory of<br />
sources and sinks of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ),<br />
which is an important factor in gaining a<br />
better understanding of climate change.<br />
The future CO 2 instrument must distinguish<br />
itself through a broad field of view.<br />
5<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Vidi grant for solving the primeval matter puzzle<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> researcher Elisa Costantini has received<br />
a Vidi grant from NWO. Costantini<br />
and her team will use that money to<br />
study primeval matter in the interstellar<br />
medium to throw more light on phenom -<br />
ena like the birth of stars and the formation<br />
of planets.<br />
XX-rays contain a wealth of information about<br />
this primeval matter. However this information<br />
has not yet been systematically disclosed with<br />
the help of the latest tools. Costantini and her<br />
team will now use high-resolution X-ray spectroscopy<br />
to systematically study the diffuse<br />
primeval matter in our Milky Way and other<br />
nearby galaxies. They will mainly focus on<br />
sources such as X-ray binaries. These X-rays<br />
are partly absorbed by the primeval matter<br />
and partly reflected by it. By analyzing these<br />
X-rays Costantini and her team can obtain<br />
information about the composition of the<br />
matter, for example. Costantini will make<br />
use of observations from the large space<br />
tele scopes Chandra (NASA) and XMM-<br />
Newton, and the Japanese space telescope<br />
ASTRO-H (now: Hitomi), which was launched<br />
in Febru ary <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
With the grant, which is worth a maximum of<br />
800,000 euros, Costantini can set up her own<br />
new line of research. Costantini: “For a long<br />
time I’ve been waiting for a chance to solve<br />
Artist’ s impression of an X-ray binary (NASA/GSFC).<br />
the primeval matter puzzle. Furthermore, this<br />
research could in turn be the key to solving<br />
other problems in astrophysics that can best<br />
be studied using X-rays. Therefore I cannot<br />
wait to start. We are going to explore an<br />
exciting new domain.”
6<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Using small blocks to find big waves<br />
In 2034, a pair of tiny gold-platinum blocks must give scientists more insight into the evolution of<br />
the universe and other big questions. They will do this by enabling scientists to analyze gravitational<br />
waves deep in space. Einstein predicted these waves and their existence was recently confirmed.<br />
The space probe LISA/Pathfinder is currently on its way to the ultimate test for the eLISA project.<br />
It is 2034. In a remote part of the solar system several gold-platinum<br />
blocks just a few centimeters in size float through space. The blocks<br />
are one million kilometers apart from each other. Nevertheless they<br />
move through space as if they were synchronized divers in a cosmic<br />
competition. But then something happens: one of the blocks wobbles<br />
and the symmetry is briefly broken. A minus point on the jury report<br />
but actually several months later this imperfection is welcomed with<br />
huge cheers by scientists on earth. They have then measured the most<br />
fundamental thing you can possibly measure: a change in the structure<br />
of space and time.<br />
Space and time are constant in everyday life. A meter is always just as<br />
long and a second always just as short. However physicists hold a very<br />
different view on this. One hundred years ago Albert Einstein discov -<br />
ered that the amount of matter in an area could influence the structure<br />
of space and time in that area. Around a heavy object, such as a planet
or star, space-time is curved. As a result of this everything in the vicinity<br />
is inclined to move towards the object. That is why the moon orbits<br />
the earth and the earth orbits the sun. Of course we have known<br />
about this phenomenon far longer under the name of gravity. Einstein,<br />
how ever, with his general theory of relativity, was the first to describe<br />
gravity as a curving of space-time.<br />
Ripple<br />
His theory gave rise to a hypothesis that was only proved one hundred<br />
years later. Rapid changes in the quantity of matter at a certain location<br />
cause space-time to ripple, which is comparable with the ripples<br />
that arise if you throw a stone in the pond. These space-time ripples<br />
are known as gravitational waves. They arise, for example, if neutron<br />
stars or black holes collide with each other. As such extreme phenomena<br />
provide insights into how gravity works and the formation of<br />
galaxies, scientists are very eager to study gravitational waves.<br />
With the small blocks experiment, in which <strong>SRON</strong> is playing an important<br />
role, they hope to be able to do that eventually. Whether that will<br />
actually happen largely depends on the test mission currently in progress.<br />
On 3 December the European Space Agency ESA launched the<br />
LISA/Pathfinder probe. In a piece<br />
According to Einstein of no man’s land in the solar system<br />
it will be examined whether<br />
rapid changes in the<br />
quantity of matter the two gold-platinum blocks on<br />
should cause ripples board can travel through space<br />
completely undisturbed. If that is<br />
in space-time<br />
the case then it will have been<br />
proven that the blocks in space can only be disturbed in one way: by<br />
gravitational waves. That will give the green light for the eLISA mission<br />
in 2034.<br />
are looking for gravitational waves with the help of laser beams.<br />
At these locations two laser beams constantly pass back-and-forth<br />
through tubes that are perpendicular<br />
to each other.<br />
The blocks move in<br />
exactly the same manner Upon their return the beams<br />
through space like<br />
merge. From the light wave<br />
synchronized divers in pattern of the resulting beam<br />
you can see whether a gravi -<br />
a cosmic competition<br />
tational wave has passed<br />
through in the intervening time. That is because the detector is set up<br />
in such a way that the two beams usually cancel each other out. How -<br />
ever, if a gravitational wave passes through the setup then this briefly<br />
deforms the setup as a result of which the waves will no longer cancel<br />
each other out.<br />
New era<br />
It took years before gravitational waves were finally unmasked using<br />
this method. On 11 February <strong>2016</strong> the world of physics threw a party<br />
when researchers announced that the Ligo detector had measured<br />
a passing wave on 14 September 2015. The wave had originated<br />
from two black holes that had merged 1.3 billion years ago. According<br />
to the scientists involved, the discovery marked a new era in physics<br />
and astronomy in which measurements of gravitational waves could<br />
7<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Why will such a delicate experiment be carried out in distant space?<br />
Although gravitational waves occur everywhere they are very difficult<br />
to observe. That is first and foremost because gravitational waves in -<br />
fluence everything in an identical manner. They can temporarily stretch<br />
a test object but because they stretch your ruler by exactly the same<br />
amount you will not measure the difference.<br />
There are many different ways to circumnavigate this problem. The<br />
Ligo detector in the US and the Virgo detector in Italy, for example,<br />
Simulation of gravitational waves during a collision between black holes (ESA).
8<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
LISA PATHFINDER IS ON ITS WAY TO TEST<br />
THE TECHNOLOGY FOR GRAVITATIONAL WAVES<br />
The European space probe LISA Pathfinder (ESA) was success -<br />
fully launched on 3 December 2015 from the Guiana Space<br />
Center in Kouro, French Guiana. The space probe was subsequently<br />
put into orbit around the earth and after that it set<br />
course for its final orbit around the sun. The probe’s mission is<br />
to test technology for measuring gravitational waves in space.<br />
LISA Pathfinder was launched at about 5 a.m. on 3 December<br />
on a Vega rocket. After two weeks the probe reached the<br />
highest point of its orbit around the earth and then set course<br />
to Lagrangian point 1, a relatively stable position at 1.5 million<br />
kilometers from earth in the direction of the sun. The European<br />
Space Agency ESA expects that LISA Pathfinder will arrive<br />
at this position in mid-February <strong>2016</strong>. After several tests<br />
Pathfinder will then start its scientific program at the beginning<br />
of March and this will last for six months.<br />
LISA Pathfinder will test the precision technology that is<br />
needed to measure gravitational waves from space. With this<br />
the space probe will provide the technological basis for the<br />
European eLISA mission (ESA, 2034). Dutch engineers and<br />
scientists are closely involved in international research into<br />
gravitational waves with experiments on the ground and<br />
via space probes. Important contributions are being made,<br />
for example, by <strong>SRON</strong>, Radboud University, Nikhef, TNO,<br />
NOVA, University of Twente, University of Amsterdam, Leiden<br />
University, University of Groningen, and the VU University<br />
Amsterdam.<br />
provide answers to big questions about black holes, the big bang, and<br />
the universe.<br />
However although it has now been proved that gravitational waves<br />
can be observed on earth such measurements will never answer all the<br />
questions. “On earth we can only<br />
In the future eLISA measure gravitational waves up to<br />
a few hundred kilometers in size.<br />
mission four to six<br />
Interesting objects in space produce<br />
blocks will float<br />
far larger waves,” says Gijs Nelemans,<br />
astrophysicist at Radboud<br />
in space about one<br />
million kilometers University in Nijmegen and physicist<br />
from each other at the Nikhef Institute in Amsterdam.<br />
Nelemans is one of the au thors of<br />
the publication that describes the first gravitational wave measurement<br />
and he is also the leader of the Dutch consortium working on the<br />
eLISA-project.<br />
The gold-platinum blocks of the future eLISA mission must, however,<br />
succeed in exposing the gravitational waves of cosmic mega systems.<br />
Four to six blocks will float in space at a distance of about one million<br />
kilometers from each other each protected by a satellite. A third satellite<br />
will monitor the distance between the blocks using laser beams.<br />
If a gravitational wave displaces one of the blocks by even by just a<br />
few billionths of a millimeter compared to the other block than that<br />
will be registered on earth.<br />
LISA/Pathfinder<br />
However the current test mission must first of all be successfully completed.<br />
The LISA/Pathfinder probe contains two blocks in the same<br />
satellite that are too close together to unmask gravitational waves.<br />
The aim of the mission is to demonstrate that the blocks can move<br />
through space completely undisturbed.<br />
Scientists will demon-<br />
Gravitational waves<br />
arise if neutron stars strate that by using laser beams<br />
or black holes collide to continuously monitor whether<br />
the distance between the blocks<br />
with each other<br />
changes. “The mission will be<br />
successful if the baseline measurement is perfect. In other words so<br />
small as is needed to be able to make gravitational measurements<br />
with eLISA,” says <strong>SRON</strong> researcher Martijn Smit, who is working on<br />
the measurement instruments of both missions.
Nevertheless, there are several factors that can spoil things. “The small<br />
blocks can only move undisrupted in a single dimension. In the other<br />
dimensions electric fields must keep them in place. These fields can,<br />
however, exert a force in the dimension that should not be disrupted,”<br />
says Smit. “And disruptive electric fields can occur during the readout<br />
out of the position of the blocks. In addition the particles can become<br />
electrically charged and the magnetic forces and tidal forces need to<br />
be allowed for.”<br />
Accidents can easily happen. What if the baseline measurement is not<br />
perfect? Will the eLISA mission then be cancelled? “That depends on<br />
the cause,” says Smit. “For example, if it turns out that the regulation<br />
of the satellite’s position did not completely work as thought then that<br />
can still be remedied by working on the codes. Whatever happens,<br />
everything possible will be done to ensure that eLISA does not experience<br />
the same shortcomings. So if LISA is not completely successful<br />
it will still provide very relevant information for eLISA.”<br />
And even if the eLISA mission proves to be infeasible then the test<br />
mission will almost certainly not have been a wasted effort. After all,<br />
space projects often lead to new technology that can also be used on<br />
earth. Smit: “TNO, for example, has designed two subsystems for<br />
eLISA in which a mirror can be very accurately moved. That almost<br />
certainly has other possible applications.”<br />
YANNICK FRITSCHY<br />
9<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Dutch contribution<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> scientists are excitedly looking forward to the first<br />
data from the test mission that will start coming in from<br />
March onwards. In a previous stage, researchers from the<br />
institute developed test equipment for LISA. <strong>SRON</strong> is now<br />
involved in the analysis of the results together with<br />
researchers from Nikhef, Radboud University, the University<br />
of Amsterdam, Leiden University, University of Groningen,<br />
and VU University Amsterdam.<br />
In addition, <strong>SRON</strong> is coordinating the Dutch contribution to the<br />
eLISA mission. TNO developed several systems for that mission.<br />
One of those systems ensures that the laser beams end up at<br />
exactly the right place even over a distance of millions of kilometers.<br />
Besides <strong>SRON</strong> and TNO, Nikhef, NOVA, and the University<br />
of Twente are collaborating on the technology for the eLISA<br />
mission.<br />
These research institutes are also searching for gravitational waves<br />
with instruments on earth. Those instruments are the Virgo detector<br />
in Italy, the BlackGEM telescope in Chile that was designed by<br />
the Netherlands, and the European Pulsar Timing Array, which<br />
combines measurements from five large radio telescopes.
Artist impression van PLATO-missie (illustratie: ESA - C.Carreau).<br />
10<br />
Distant planets shed light on earth<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Are we alone in the universe? Since the discovery of the first exoplanets<br />
in 1991 astronomers have feverishly been looking for habitable planets<br />
outside of our solar system. About 2000 exoplanets have already been<br />
identified and many thousands more will follow in the coming years.<br />
So you would expect to find a second earth among all those planets.<br />
Or is the earth actually quite unique? Recent<br />
discoveries have revealed that other planetary<br />
systems can be quite different from our solar<br />
system. “The statistics so far indicate that the<br />
most common planet in the universe is two<br />
to three times as big as earth. Interestingly<br />
we do not have such a super earth in our<br />
own solar system,” says Michiel Min, research<br />
leader of the exoplanets group at <strong>SRON</strong>. So it<br />
could well be the case that our solar system<br />
and the earth are utterly unique. Of course<br />
that would be a considerable setback in the<br />
search for life similar to that on earth.<br />
However, astronomers currently know too<br />
little about exoplanets to give an answer to<br />
that. Of the 2000 planets found we often<br />
know only the period it takes the planet<br />
to revolve around its star. In some cases<br />
astro nomers have an indication about the<br />
size or the mass but that is also not enough<br />
to state how similar they are to earth.<br />
Furthermore, the exoplanets found so far<br />
give a distorted picture. “Some of those<br />
planets have been found by observing<br />
wobbles of the star the planets orbit. However<br />
that phenomenon is only visible in the<br />
case of heavy planets,” says Min. “Other<br />
planets have been found because we saw<br />
them move in front of the star. Using this<br />
method you mainly find planets located<br />
close to the star.”<br />
To resolve the statistical shortcoming more<br />
exoplanets need to be found and character<br />
ised. <strong>SRON</strong> is therefore collaborating in<br />
two future missions of the European Space<br />
Agency ESA, in which space telescopes will<br />
be used to study exoplanets in detail.<br />
Dips in brightness<br />
The first is the PLATO mission (Planetary<br />
Transits and Oscillations of stars), which will<br />
be launched in 2024. During this mission a<br />
space probe with 34 telescopes onboard will<br />
search in the vicinity of about one million<br />
stars for exoplanets. It will do this by record -<br />
ing so-called transits. These are the regular<br />
dips in the brightness of a star, which can
indicate that a planet is moving in front of<br />
the star.<br />
Many exoplanets have already been discov -<br />
ered using this transit method, for example<br />
by the space telescope Kepler. However, the<br />
PLATO mission will go a step further. “Kepler<br />
can only map a very small piece of the sky.<br />
PLATO will examine almost the entire sky so<br />
that all bright stars can be studied at the<br />
same time,” says Min. “Furthermore PLATO<br />
will not just measure for a few months but<br />
for several years. That will make it possible<br />
to find exoplanets that take longer to orbit<br />
around their star. Such as the earth which<br />
takes one year to orbit the sun.”<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> is expected to contribute to the PLATO<br />
mission by providing test facilities. Min: “The<br />
34 telescope cameras must all be tested at<br />
extremely low temperatures for factors such<br />
as stability and precision. We want to carry<br />
out some of these tests at the institute in<br />
Groningen.”<br />
Eventually astronomers will collate all of the<br />
values measured in a catalogue of thousands<br />
of exoplanets. They will then be able to use<br />
this to determine which exoplanets merit fur -<br />
ther research. The next step will be to es tab -<br />
lish the exact composition of these plan ets’<br />
atmospheres. The ARIEL mission (Atmo spheric<br />
Remote-Sensing Infrared Exoplanet Large<br />
sur vey) has been proposed for that. In the<br />
first half of 2017 the ESA will have to make a<br />
choice between this and two other proposed<br />
missions. If the ARIEL mission is selected then<br />
it will be started in about 2025.<br />
Hot Jupiters and super earths<br />
“I think the time is ripe for a mission like<br />
ARIEL,” says Min. “There are already a lot of<br />
missions to identify exoplanets but few of the<br />
planets found are being characterised. This<br />
requires telescopes that can remain stable<br />
over a long period of time like the James<br />
Webb Space Telescope that will become oper -<br />
ational in 2018. However exoplanets will be<br />
Proposal for the ARIEL telescope (ESA).<br />
just one of the things it observes. Hopefully<br />
ARIEL will get the go-ahead and observe only<br />
exoplanets.”<br />
In the case of the ARIEL mission a telescope<br />
onboard a space probe will carry out mea -<br />
surements on about 500 exoplanets over a<br />
period of 3.5 years. Those will mainly be the<br />
There are many missions<br />
to identify exoplanets<br />
but few exoplanets are<br />
being characterised<br />
‘hot Jupiters’ and ‘super earths’: large planets<br />
with a temperature of several hundred<br />
degrees Celsius. “Only such planets have<br />
atmospheres thick enough to be measured,”<br />
says Min. If the ARIEL mission goes ahead<br />
and it uses European detectors then engineers<br />
from <strong>SRON</strong> will contribute by developing the<br />
readout electronics. <strong>SRON</strong> scientists are also<br />
eagerly looking forward to the moment that<br />
the results from this and the PLATO mission<br />
can be analysed. Min: “We still know little<br />
about the cloud formation on exoplanets.<br />
In addition, the measurements will give insight<br />
into the formation of planets. More data<br />
are needed to be able to statistically demonstrate<br />
where and how planets are formed in<br />
general.”<br />
Extraterrestrial life<br />
A better understanding of the formation and<br />
evolution of planets should also lead to an<br />
answer to the ultimate question concerning<br />
extraterrestrial life. According to Min, how -<br />
ever, the PLATO and ARIEL missions will get<br />
nowhere near to answering these questions.<br />
“We cannot characterise planets as small as<br />
earth yet. We can characterise super earths<br />
but only if they are located quite close to the<br />
star. As a result of that they are too warm to<br />
support life.”<br />
Min is cautiously optimistic about the chance<br />
that we are not alone. “Up until now everything<br />
that is physically possible also occurs in<br />
the universe. Billions of earth-like planets are<br />
therefore expected to exist. Then we need to<br />
ask: Is the chance of life evolving on such a<br />
planet greater than one in a billion? We don’t<br />
know and we are currently doing the statistics<br />
on a sample of one. That number needs to be<br />
bigger.”<br />
The question about life will therefore remain<br />
unanswered for the time being. Hopefully<br />
future missions will be able to demonstrate<br />
whether our solar system is commonplace or<br />
completely unique.<br />
YANNICK FRITSCHY<br />
11<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong>
How do black holes grow and how do they influence<br />
12<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
the galaxies they are a part of? How does matter<br />
conglomerate into galaxies? Where do the<br />
mysterious X-rays in clusters of galaxies come from?<br />
The X-ray telescopes ASTRO-H (now: Hitomi, <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
and ATHENA (2028) can answer these and other<br />
questions about the ‘hot’ and energy-rich universe.<br />
SEARCHING<br />
FOR ANSWERS<br />
IN THE HOT UNIVERSE<br />
Artist’s impression of ATHENA (ESA).<br />
The most extreme objects in the universe emit<br />
X-rays. Astronomers need space instruments<br />
in space to study those hot and energy-rich<br />
phenomena, because high-energy X-rays cannot<br />
penetrate the earth’s atmosphere. Therefore<br />
they make use of X-ray telescopes like<br />
XMM-Newton (ESA) and Chandra (NASA) and<br />
from this year onwards ASTRO-H (now called<br />
Hitomi, JAXA) – the launch of this Japanese<br />
telescope took place in February <strong>2016</strong>. How -<br />
ever to look far deeper and in greater detail<br />
into black holes and distant clusters of galaxies<br />
a next generation of X-ray instruments<br />
is needed. The European Space Agency ESA<br />
has therefore selected ATHENA (Advanced<br />
Telescope for High Energy Astrophysics) as the<br />
second large space mission for the following<br />
decade. The X-ray telescope will be fitted with<br />
two instruments: a camera/spectrometer<br />
(X-ray Integral Field Unit, X-IFU) and a wideangle<br />
space camera (Wide Field Imager, WFI).<br />
Detectors<br />
With a weight of about 5000 kg, a length of<br />
about 14 meters, and an X-ray lens with a<br />
diameter of three meters ATHENA will be the<br />
largest X-ray telescope ever. That is good<br />
news for Dutch space research: <strong>SRON</strong> will<br />
pro vide the ultrasensitive detectors for the<br />
camera/spectrometer X-IFU and thanks to this<br />
contribution <strong>SRON</strong> researchers will be given<br />
guaranteed observation time on the advanced<br />
telescope. They are looking forward with considerable<br />
interest to the answers that ATHENA<br />
It is a completely natural<br />
process and it does not<br />
involve any magical things<br />
or exotic particles<br />
will give to three important scientific questions:<br />
what is the composition of the elusive<br />
hot matter in clusters of galaxies, how does<br />
matter conglomerate into galaxies and clus-
ters of galaxies, and how do black holes grow<br />
and influence their surroundings? However,<br />
they will need to be patient because the<br />
launch of the space observatory is planned for<br />
2028.<br />
Matryoshka dolls<br />
One of the researchers is <strong>SRON</strong> astronomer<br />
Peter Jonker. Last year Jonker and his colleagues<br />
caught a supermassive black hole<br />
tearing a star apart. The black hole was quite<br />
bright in the radio spectrum – there was<br />
already an accretion disk with the flow of<br />
matter moving towards the black hole –<br />
but not so bright in the X-ray spectrum.<br />
“Until a star passed that was being torn<br />
apart,” explains Jonker. “Due to the new<br />
flow of matter into the black hole, it entered<br />
an entirely different mode.”<br />
After this powerful injection of gas, Peter<br />
Jonker and his team observed a strong in -<br />
crease in X-rays and visible light, while the<br />
radio emission became weaker. The radio<br />
emission most likely originates from a jet,<br />
a fast gas flow emitted by the black hole.<br />
This fits exactly in the pattern that is observed<br />
in much smaller stellar black holes. In general,<br />
these are quiet and occasionally experience<br />
an eruption during which they first become<br />
brighter in the X-ray and radio spectra until<br />
the flow of matter is so large that the X-ray<br />
spectrum becomes dimmer, whereas the radio<br />
spectrum decreases by factor of more than 50.<br />
Jonker: “And that pattern was also found for<br />
a supermassive black hole. We call this the<br />
Matryoshka principle, which predicts that all<br />
compact objects in universe that attract<br />
matter behave the same with a correction<br />
based on their mass.”<br />
Medium-sized black holes<br />
To gain a better understanding of this pro -<br />
cess es Jonker wants to use ATHENA to start<br />
hunting for black holes that are not extremely<br />
heavy but are also not stellar, so-called<br />
medium -sized black holes. Up until now the<br />
masses of the candidate medium-sized black<br />
holes are all based on rough estimates. Only<br />
a handful of good candidates are known<br />
but these are located so far away that as -<br />
tronomers cannot determine how large the<br />
orbits of the stars around the black hole are<br />
and therefore cannot calculate the mass of<br />
the black hole.<br />
If we can find a white<br />
dwarf that is being torn<br />
apart then the perpetrator<br />
has to be a medium-sized<br />
black hole<br />
Jonker: “Medium-sized black holes (a thousand<br />
to ten thousand solar masses) can also<br />
tear stars apart but that only happens if a star<br />
comes relatively near. And then the time scales<br />
are much shorter, so you have little time to<br />
make your observation.” Jonker is mainly interested<br />
in white dwarfs that are engulfed by<br />
such medium-size black holes. “Supermassive<br />
black holes can also do that but that only<br />
occurs after such a star has passed the observation<br />
horizon. Therefore we do not see it.”<br />
If we can find a white dwarf that is being<br />
torn apart then the perpetrator must be a<br />
medium-sized black hole. As soon as a radio<br />
or optical telescope has observed such an<br />
event we can then immediately observe it in<br />
the X-ray spectrum using ATHENA. Jonker<br />
also hopes that the intended wide-angle<br />
▶<br />
13<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
From top to bottom: Hot gas cloud as a consequence<br />
of the Tycho supernova (NASA/CXC/SAO);<br />
Black hole (NASA); supermassive black hole blows<br />
bubbles in the hot gas of the Perseus cluster<br />
(NASA/CXC/SAO/E. Bulbul, et al.).
14<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
camera (40x40 arc minutes imaging field) can Sulfur<br />
find many medium-sized black holes. “As Using ASTRO-H/Hitomi, Kaastra and other<br />
soon as ATHENA finds sources that suddenly <strong>SRON</strong> researchers will, amongst other things,<br />
flare up we will immediately send a message test whether the explanation that they recently<br />
found for elusive X-rays in clusters of<br />
so that other telescopes can observe this in<br />
the visible light and radio spectra.”<br />
galaxies is correct. Up until now some astronomers<br />
have ascribed this radiation to a<br />
ASTRO-H/Hitomi<br />
hypothetical particle, the sterile neutrino,<br />
For <strong>SRON</strong> astronomer Jelle Kaastra another which is possibly the source of dark matter.<br />
exciting X-ray mission has his attention first. However, Kaastra and his colleagues discov -<br />
That is the Japanese X-ray telescope ASTRO-H, ered that the X-rays could arise if cold hydrogen<br />
gas collides with hot sulfur ions.<br />
now renamed Hitomi, which was launched<br />
from the Tanegashima Space Center in Febru -<br />
ary. <strong>SRON</strong> has collaborated on the filter wheel Kaastra: “Those clusters of galaxies contain<br />
on ASTRO-H/Hitomi, which slightly dims a combination of lots of cold and warm gas.<br />
sources that are too bright. Some binary stars, If these mix then you can obtain those tran -<br />
in particular, are so bright that the detector sitions and nobody had realized that up until<br />
be comes saturated. The filter discards ninety now. It is a completely natural process and it<br />
per cent of the photons but still enables you to does not involve any magical things or exotic<br />
particles. As the signal<br />
is incredibly weak<br />
and there is a wide<br />
range of spectral lines<br />
in the vicinity, we initially<br />
had some<br />
doubts about it. Now<br />
we have elaborated<br />
our model and it<br />
corre sponds exactly.”<br />
ASTRO-H/Hitomi will<br />
provide high-resolution<br />
spectra for the<br />
high energies and it<br />
will make high-reso lu -<br />
tion spectra of elongated<br />
sources in<br />
ASTRO-H- satellites ready for launch at the Tanegashima Space Center (JAXA).<br />
space. “Up until now<br />
obtain a good spectrum. In collaboration with we did that using XMM with gratings but<br />
Photonis, <strong>SRON</strong> also supplied the calibration that only works well for point sources. For<br />
source that determines whether the energy elongated sources in space the signal is<br />
scale of the detector is still properly calibrated. spread out too much. ASTRO-H/Hitomi can,<br />
however, make these spectra for the first<br />
time.”<br />
Harvest<br />
From ASTRO-H/Hitomi to ATHENA is the next<br />
big step. ATHENA will have a far greater field<br />
of view and will be able to make far more<br />
detailed observations.<br />
“We call this the<br />
Matryoshka principle,<br />
which predicts that all<br />
compact objects in<br />
universe that attract<br />
matter behave the same”<br />
Hitomi has a resolving power of one arc<br />
minute but the discriminatory power of<br />
ATHENA will be twenty times better. Kaastra:<br />
“ATHENA will have a far larger effective surface<br />
and will therefore be far more sensitive,<br />
also compared with our own RGS spectrometer<br />
on the space telescope XMM-Newton.<br />
That covers one- hundred square centimeters,<br />
whereas with ATHENA that will be two square<br />
meters, which will allow the telescope to capture<br />
more light by a factor of two hundred.”<br />
ATHENA will therefore be able to observe<br />
extragalactic sources in the far red shift,<br />
back to the time in which they arose, at the<br />
‘boundary’ of the universe.<br />
Meanwhile however, Jonker and Kaastra will<br />
use other instruments as well. XMM-Newton<br />
and Chandra have about another ten years of<br />
service. And with Hitomi the first data will be<br />
harvested in the coming years.<br />
MARIEKE BAAN
Photo: NASA.<br />
In our atmosphere minuscule dust and<br />
fluid particles that influence our climate<br />
are floating around. Examples are sea salt<br />
or soot particles from traffic. Yet how<br />
these aerosols contribute to global<br />
warming is still a mystery. Where exactly<br />
are aerosols emitted? Are they harmful<br />
for us? NASA’s climate satellite PACE<br />
will search for answers to these and<br />
other questions, possibly with the help<br />
of a Dutch instrument.<br />
Aerosols: missing link in climate research<br />
15<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Global warming is one of the biggest challenges of this age. Models,<br />
however, differ considerably with respect to the speed and extent to<br />
which the climate is warming up. One of the reasons for this uncertainty<br />
is that we still do not know enough about the mechanisms<br />
under lying climate change. The influence of aerosols is one of the most<br />
important climate factors that we still know relatively little about.<br />
Aerosols are minuscule solid or liquid particles that float around in the<br />
atmosphere. They can come from natural sources, such as ash from<br />
volcanic eruptions, sand from the Sahara or sea salt from the oceans.<br />
However humans also emit large quantities of aerosols with the combustion<br />
of fossil fuels and wood. Dependent on their composition,<br />
the particles can exert either a warming up or cooling down effect on<br />
the climate. They influence the temperature through radiation effects<br />
and cloud formation. Some types of particles cool the climate by acting<br />
as tiny mirrors that reflect sunlight directly into space. Other types, how -<br />
ever, can absorb solar radiation or heat emitted by the earth and then<br />
emit this again as result of which the greenhouse effect is en hanced<br />
and the atmosphere warms up. Aerosols also play a role in the formation<br />
of clouds because water condenses on small aerosol particles and<br />
consequently forms clouds. In turn these clouds exert an influence on<br />
the climate system.<br />
There are many different types of aerosol particles and their interactions<br />
with the climate are complex. So at present we do not know how<br />
aerosols contribute to changes in our climate. We are not even entirely<br />
sure whether on balance aerosols enhance or mitigate global warming.<br />
With our current level of knowledge, the uncertainty regarding the<br />
worldwide effect of aerosols is just as big a factor as the total effect of<br />
the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide. <strong>SRON</strong> program leader Avri Selig:<br />
“To find out how aerosols influence the climate we must know exactly<br />
how many particles are<br />
“We are not even entirely<br />
located where in the atmo -<br />
sure whether on balance<br />
sphere, whether these<br />
aerosols enhance or mitigate<br />
particles absorb or reflect<br />
global warming...“<br />
radiation, and what the<br />
composition of these particles is. Furthermore, if we know the composition<br />
of the particles we can determine whether they are harmful for<br />
public health and how harmful they are. So far this knowledge is not<br />
available on a large scale.”<br />
The role of satellites<br />
Measurements of aerosol properties on a global scale are needed to<br />
understand the influence of aerosols on the climate and air quality.<br />
Such measurements can only be obtained with the help of satellites.
16<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
For the characterization of aerosols it is important that a satellite instrument<br />
measures both the intensity and polarization of the light reflected<br />
by the earth’s atmosphere. Up until now only one such instrument has<br />
been launched: the French POLDER instrument onboard the PARASOL<br />
satellite. Its successor, the 3MI instrument of ESA on the MetOp-SG<br />
satellite, is a similar measurement instrument that is expected to be<br />
operational from 2021 onwards. The aerosol measurements from these<br />
being developed by the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, and a<br />
polarimeter. Due to its technical and scientific specifications SPEX is<br />
NASA’s preferred choice for a polarimeter. The two measurement<br />
instruments complement each other: measurements from the polari -<br />
meter help to correct ocean measurements and the OCI instrument<br />
measures certain properties of clouds and aerosols. Together these<br />
instruments will provide data that are important for multidisciplinary<br />
satellite missions will mainly provide information about the quantity<br />
climate research.<br />
“There are many<br />
and size of the particles but will not reveal enough about the extent<br />
different types of<br />
to which the particles absorb or reflect light and almost nothing about<br />
If efforts to obtain sufficient national<br />
aerosol particles and<br />
their chemical composition.<br />
funding are successful then NASA<br />
their interactions<br />
will definitely select SPEX for PACE.<br />
A major step forward in aerosol research requires a new instrument<br />
that is far more accurate. <strong>SRON</strong> already has a prototype for that in -<br />
with the climate are<br />
complex“<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> would then become responsible<br />
for the construction of the instrument<br />
strument: SPEX. Otto Hasekamp, Principal Investigator for the SPEX<br />
instrument: “Thanks to an entirely new measurement principle, SPEX<br />
mea sures more accurately than its predecessors by more than a factor<br />
of ten. Therefore with SPEX we can determine the extent to which<br />
aerosols absorb and scatter light. We can also determine the chemical<br />
composition of aerosols. For example,<br />
the instrument will help us to distinguish<br />
sea salt from harmful soot.”<br />
and the processing of the data. Together with Dutch parties,<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> would then ensure the integration of the different subsystems<br />
and also carry out the various tests. Furthermore, <strong>SRON</strong> will produce<br />
part of the flight electronics, will perform the calibration, and will deliver<br />
the associated software. After the launch, <strong>SRON</strong> scientists will<br />
derive aerosol properties from the<br />
spectro-polarimeter data. The importance<br />
of SPEX for NASA is ap -<br />
parent from the major contribution<br />
The technology behind SPEX has already<br />
been successfully used for local groundbased<br />
that NASA wants to make to the<br />
SPEX instrument.<br />
aerosol measurements at the<br />
Dutch atmospheric measurement mast<br />
in Cabauw (the CESAR Observatory).<br />
Better climate predictions<br />
The measurement results from<br />
The SPEX technology was also used in<br />
PACE/SPEX will help climate researchers<br />
to gain a better under-<br />
Sea salt, dust, and volcanic ash are aerosols<br />
Leiden University’s citizen science project<br />
from natural sources (Katherine Mann).<br />
iSPEX, which won the Academische jaarprijs<br />
in 2012. Furthermore, <strong>SRON</strong> has constructed an airborne version of<br />
the SPEX instrument prototype for a flight under the NASA research aircraft<br />
ER-2, which performs measurements at an altitude of 21 kilometers.<br />
This instrument, called SPEX Airborne, first flew in February <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
standing of the role of aerosols in<br />
the earth’s climate and to quantify this. That will lead to better climate<br />
predictions, which in turn will help to determine the climate policy. For<br />
example, the results could contribute to a report from the Intergovernmental<br />
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which is published once every<br />
five to six years. In addition, with the arrival of PACE/SPEX, scientists<br />
PACE mission<br />
As SPEX is so accurate, NASA would like the instrument to fly onboard<br />
its climate satellite PACE (Pre-Aerosols, Clouds and ocean Ecosystems),<br />
will be able to accurately determine the origin of air pollution. This information<br />
is extremely valuable for government bodies when they take<br />
measures to improve air quality.<br />
the launch of which is planned for 2022. The PACE satellite will have<br />
two instruments onboard: the Ocean Color Instrument (OCI), which is<br />
EVELINE VAN DER LINDEN
THE EXPERTISE TRIANGLE / SPACE INSTRUMENTS<br />
SPEX airborne ready<br />
for scientific flights<br />
The SPEX technology has been designed to investigate aerosols<br />
(small particles) in the atmosphere from space. A prototype<br />
– SPEX airborne – has been converted to fly onboard a NASA<br />
research plane at an altitude of 21 kilometers. A team of <strong>SRON</strong><br />
engineers has assembled this instrument over the past months<br />
and prepared it for the harsh conditions found at that altitude.<br />
SPEX airborne has successfully completed more than five flight<br />
hours.<br />
17<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
The ER-2, the NASA research plane that carries SPEX airborne (NASA).<br />
EEach component looks the part. All of the components have been<br />
manufactured from aluminum and have a golden glow. Bolts have<br />
been placed with surgical precision at perfectly regular distance from<br />
each other. It is clear that the instrument has been produced by specia l -<br />
ists. SPEX airborne is ready for its first flight in Palmdale, Cali for nia. The<br />
SPEX instrument will be installed in the wing compartment of a NASA<br />
research plane (the ER-2). The instrument has been thoroughly tested<br />
over the past few months. In addition, SPEX airborne has successfully<br />
completed an extensive set of electrical tests.<br />
Extreme conditions<br />
At an altitude of 21 km it is just as cold as in the Antarctic winter and<br />
the pressure there is comparable with that of a vacuum. Via observation<br />
holes, SPEX airborne is in<br />
“At an altitude of 21 km<br />
direct contact with this outside<br />
air, as a window would<br />
it is just as cold as in<br />
the Antarctic winter and disrupt the incoming light.<br />
the pressure there is The instrument must therefore<br />
be able to carry out<br />
comparable with that<br />
measurements under these<br />
of a vacuum”<br />
conditions. Many standard<br />
electronic components are not suitable for this due to problems with<br />
the dissipation of heat as result of which electronics can burn out.<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> researchers therefore designed and built special components and<br />
systems, or purchased these. For the required accuracy of SPEX airborne<br />
it is vitally important that the optical system – the heart of SPEX<br />
airborne – does not vary in temperature too much. Heating elements<br />
ensure that the optics of SPEX and the associated camera remain at<br />
room temperature with a deviation of less than 0.1 °C even though the<br />
outside temperature is -55°C.<br />
T H E E X P E R T I S E T R I A N G L E<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> develops, builds and uses instruments that<br />
enable scientific breakthroughs in space research.<br />
This section in the <strong>Spectrum</strong> newsletter features<br />
a different aspect of <strong>SRON</strong>’s expertise triangle<br />
each time:<br />
▶ Science covers astrophysical and atmospheric research and<br />
spectroscopy.<br />
▶ Enabling Technology develops detectors, readout electronics,<br />
micro- mechanical systems in very cold conditions, lithography<br />
facilities, and cleanrooms.<br />
▶ Space Instruments concerns the system knowledge and the<br />
design, development, construction, and approval of flight<br />
instrumentation in international consortia.
18<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Photo top right: Engineers from <strong>SRON</strong><br />
and NASA carry out the last tests<br />
at NASA’s Armstrong Flight Research<br />
Center in Palmdale, California.<br />
Top and right: SPEX airborne in<br />
the wing compartment of the ER-2<br />
(view from below and from the side).<br />
From Mars to Earth<br />
SPEX was originally designed for a Mars mission. The sensitivity of the<br />
SPEX prototype, however, far exceeded all expectations during the<br />
tests in 2013 and 2014. SPEX was found to measure five times more<br />
accurately than the purpose for which the instrument had been designed.<br />
As a result of this SPEX immediately became interesting to use<br />
for measurements of fine particles (aerosols) and clouds in the earth’s<br />
atmosphere. <strong>SRON</strong> scientist Otto Hasekamp is leading the scientific<br />
studies that will be done using the data from SPEX airborne: “We<br />
already had a long-term collaboration with researchers from NASA in<br />
the area of aerosols, clouds, and the interactions between these.<br />
What does SPEX measure?<br />
SPEX measures the sunlight that is scattered by dust and<br />
other small particles in the atmosphere, so-called aerosols.<br />
The instruments can recognize these particles from their<br />
optical and micro-physical properties by measuring the<br />
degree of polarization under different angles. Aerosols have<br />
a lot of impact on the air quality and the climate. With the<br />
help of SPEX we can come a step closer to solving many of<br />
the unanswered questions about climate and air quality.<br />
From this collaboration the plan arose to place the SPEX prototype on<br />
an aircraft for a series of measurement campaigns. The ER-2 aircraft is<br />
a former spy plane and flies so high that almost the entire atmosphere<br />
lies beneath you. It is therefore almost like a satellite.”<br />
Heavy and independent<br />
An awful lot had to be done to make the SPEX prototype suitable for<br />
the research plane. As explained earlier, the instrument has to function<br />
well under the extreme conditions at an altitude of 21 km. However<br />
that is not everything. The system must be able to work entirely independently<br />
because there is nobody who can operate the instrument<br />
during the flight. The pilot can only switch the instrument on and off.<br />
Controlling the instrument from the ground is not possible either.<br />
To achieve this, not only the prototype and the camera are needed, but<br />
an Instrument Control Unit (ICU) and Instrument Power Unit (IPU) as<br />
well. The ICU is an onboard computer that ensures the control and<br />
readout of the camera, the storage of the raw data, the collection of<br />
relevant flight data, and the calculation of the temperature regulation.<br />
In a nutshell it keeps an eye on the instrument’s health. The IPU en -<br />
sures that each component receives enough electricity so that possible<br />
electrical problems in the instrument cannot damage the plane. An<br />
aluminum shield with small observation holes covers the instrument<br />
to make it easier to keep the temperature stable.<br />
SPEX airborne has been developed from the original Mars model by<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> engineers from Utrecht and Groningen. Hasekamp: “What<br />
makes this project so special is that <strong>SRON</strong> has not only developed the<br />
entire airborne system<br />
“SPEX airborne is hopefully and made nearly all of<br />
a dress rehearsal for larger the components, but the<br />
missions, such as the NASA/ instrument has been<br />
PACE mission”<br />
calibrated by our instrument<br />
scientists, and our<br />
scientists will shortly carry out the data analysis as well. The entire<br />
cycle therefore bears the <strong>SRON</strong> mark.”<br />
Deliberately making mistakes<br />
The instrument is tested by subjecting it to about one hundred tests<br />
in which simulations of various errors are performed. Examples are<br />
variable temperatures, currents or voltages that are too high or too
low, or a component in the system that does not respond or responds<br />
in a strange manner. In some cases the pilot can restart the system<br />
but after three restarts, the system switches itself off. Even that is<br />
simu lat ed in the testing phase with a box that simulates the on, off,<br />
and restart buttons of the pilot. The aim is to anticipate as many errors<br />
as possible so that the system can continue to function during flight.<br />
Instrument scientist<br />
“The instrument’s accuracy Martijn Smit was involved<br />
ensures that you can<br />
in testing SPEX airborne.<br />
distinguish between<br />
different types of aerosols, “Many of these tests<br />
for example desert dust, work automatically but<br />
generating errors can also<br />
sulfate, and soot”<br />
be very time-consuming,”<br />
explains Smit. “Although all of the components are individually tested,<br />
new problems always emerge as soon as the components become<br />
part of a larger system. Most of the problems are small in nature and<br />
quickly solved. A bug in the software, a small design error in an electronic<br />
circuit, or a component that proves to be unreliable. But a few<br />
persistent problems always take up the most time. Nevertheless we<br />
ultimately still manage to find a solution.”<br />
Successful test campaign<br />
At the end of January <strong>2016</strong> NASA mounted the SPEX instrument on<br />
the ER-2. Four <strong>SRON</strong> engineers and an instrument scientist were<br />
present in Palmdale to assemble the individual components and to<br />
perform tests with a special simulator that simulated all electronic<br />
connections with the plane. The first test flights with the SPEX instrument<br />
took place immediately afterwards. These enabled the team<br />
to fine-tune the instrument. During the third flight SPEX airborne<br />
flew together with the AirMSPI instrument of the Jet Propulsion Lab,<br />
a similar type of measuring instrument. During this flight SPEX airborne<br />
performed as expected. Now an exciting period follows in<br />
which scientists will analyze the data. This will include, for example,<br />
a comparison of the data from AirMSPI with that from SPEX airborne.<br />
The initial results look highly promising.<br />
From airborne to space<br />
The outcomes of the scientific measurement campaigns that will be<br />
obtained during these flights will hopefully provide us with a better<br />
understanding of the earth’s climate and air quality. Hasekamp:<br />
Photo top: SPEX airborne on<br />
the integration table in <strong>SRON</strong>’s<br />
cleanroom. The optical module<br />
with nine observation holes is<br />
in the semicircular part.<br />
Photo left: <strong>SRON</strong> instrument<br />
scientists measure the currents<br />
through the electrical connec -<br />
tions in the Instrument Power<br />
Unit, which has just been<br />
attached.<br />
“The instrument’s accuracy ensures that you can distinguish between<br />
different types of aerosols, for example desert dust, sulfate, and soot.<br />
Furthermore you can determine whether the aerosols mainly reflect<br />
radiation (cooling effect) or also absorb it (warming effect). That is very<br />
important information for understanding the effect of aerosols on the<br />
climate. By combining SPEX airborne with other instruments that measure<br />
from ER-2, we can also find out more about the effect of aerosols<br />
on cloud formation. Furthermore, the results from SPEX airborne will<br />
provide us with a lot of useful information about future aerosol space<br />
missions. The SPEX airborne mission is hopefully a dress rehearsal for<br />
larger missions, such as PACE, which will perform similar measurements<br />
from space.”<br />
EVELINE VAN DER LINDEN<br />
19<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong>
Wouter Laauwen in his ’big red’, the red jacket with the insulation and weight of a double duvet.<br />
20<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Wouter blogs...<br />
From the South Pole to the edge of the universe…<br />
At the end of 2015, Wouter Laauwen blogged about his work for the balloon mission STO2. The NASA mission was due to<br />
circle above the South Pole from the start of January onwards. Aim? To find out more about how stars and planets are born<br />
in molecular clouds from the edge of space. The launch has now been postponed until the end of <strong>2016</strong>/2017. Nevertheless,<br />
Laauwen’s experiences as a pole traveller are still worth reading...
2 November 2015, Los Angeles:<br />
How it started<br />
A<br />
Actually my mission to the South Pole started<br />
a long time ago. Snow, ice, and cold have<br />
fascinated me since I was very young. As a<br />
small boy I read about the polar explorations<br />
of Willem Barentsz, Roald Amundsen, and<br />
Ernest Shackleton, with glowing cheeks and<br />
I devour ed the books of Jack London (White<br />
Fang). Later series such as Game of Thrones<br />
were added to this list. As an engineer at<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> I therefore sometimes dreamed about<br />
scientific trips to the polar regions. To places<br />
where almost nobody comes, with endless<br />
snow and ice, and an all-powerful nature. If<br />
only I could get the chance. Wow.<br />
STO2 on time. We offered to develop a<br />
backup for it here in the Netherlands to<br />
ensure that the mission could go ahead. In<br />
just four weeks we managed to develop a<br />
detector block for four pixels, to coat lenses<br />
for the right frequencies, and select detectors<br />
for the four positions. Our developmental<br />
sprint resulted in us having a working backup<br />
for the detectors that we could show at an<br />
interim project review of NASA. This proved<br />
to be crucial: ultimately the <strong>SRON</strong> detectors<br />
were selected for STO2.<br />
5 November 2015, Christchurch:<br />
package one delivered!<br />
On the way to Antarctica my favorite guessing<br />
game became: Who else is going to Antarctica?<br />
That’s not easy, however, because how<br />
I need you to be the 2nd person<br />
to be in the Antarctic.<br />
Are you willing?<br />
can you tell? Clothes? Fitness? After all, we<br />
have all completed the same approval program.<br />
Meanwhile I am reading The Martian<br />
21<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
So when <strong>SRON</strong> project leader Jian-Rong Gao<br />
asked me whether I could help as a systems<br />
engineer with STO2 it was a dream come<br />
true. On 15 April 2015 the redeeming email<br />
eventually came from Gao. It was a bit James<br />
Bond-like and consisted of three short sen -<br />
tences: I need you to be the 2nd person to be<br />
in the Antarctic. Are you willing? If yes, I need<br />
to check with Pieter - Gao. My wife and son<br />
were both excited (“We are coming with you<br />
to America.”) whereas my daughter was in<br />
tears (“Papa is going away for a very long<br />
time.”).<br />
At LA International Airport the inevitable farewell<br />
came. You cuddle your wife and children<br />
once more, and a tiny bit of doubt creeps into<br />
by Andy Weir, which has now been filmed<br />
with Matt Damon in the leading role.<br />
To places where almost nobody<br />
comes, with endless snow and<br />
ice and an all-powerful nature.<br />
Wow<br />
Meanwhile on the other side of the pond the<br />
process was encountering problems. In the<br />
spring it became clear that the American Jet<br />
Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) was having difficulty<br />
in delivering the infrared detectors for<br />
your mind. So far away and for such a long<br />
time. What if something happens? And of<br />
course tears flow. And then all of a sudden<br />
they have passed through security and are on<br />
their way to the next step of their own small<br />
adventure. Back home without a husband<br />
and father. I return to the hotel to write my<br />
first blog in the lobby and to wait for my own<br />
flight to Sydney.<br />
An inspiring book if you need to write a blog<br />
on Antarctica. I had already planned to start<br />
one of my blogs with the words: “Captain’s<br />
log, star date 41153.7, our destination is<br />
McMurdo...” Now I just need to add an intro:<br />
“Log entry: Sol 7. Okay, I had a good night’s<br />
sleep and things don’t seem as hopeless as<br />
they did yesterday...” My plane to Sydney<br />
turns out to be an enormous Airbus A380.<br />
The video channel is playing Interstellar.
22<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
STO2 loses the race against the clock at the South Pole<br />
The balloon mission STO2 did not take off from the South Pole. The balloon,<br />
which is equipped with Dutch detectors, was meant to make a circular flight above<br />
Antarctica at the start of this year at an altitude of 40 km to make observations<br />
of the universe. However due to bad weather the balloon could not be launched<br />
on time to still benefit enough from the circular polar wind. The mission has,<br />
in principle, been deferred by NASA to the end of <strong>2016</strong>/start of 2017.<br />
Ultimately the weather gods proved unfavor - weather has been so unfavorable,” says project<br />
leader Jian Rong Gao (<strong>SRON</strong>/Delft Uni-<br />
able towards STO2. Until 21 January there<br />
was still the hope that the balloon could follow<br />
the GRIPS mission and be launched on test it was all systems go and the detectors<br />
versity of Technology). “After the hanging<br />
time. But a persistent strong wind eventually were functioning superbly. All of the teams<br />
made that impossible. Launching the balloon did exceptionally good work. But the weather<br />
now would mean that the balloon would not is one thing you cannot influence. Fortunate -<br />
be able to make a circular flight and would ly, NASA plans to make a new attempt at the<br />
probably end up in the sea instead of landing<br />
on the South Pole.<br />
end of this year or the start of next year.”<br />
Astronomers could have used STO2 to measure<br />
atomic oxygen for the first time from<br />
“A real shame. And also terribly bad luck<br />
because it is the first time in 20 years that the the edge of space. With those measurements<br />
they can directly detect the incubators<br />
of new stars: the oxygen line tells us which<br />
areas in the gas clouds between stars have<br />
been warmed up by recently formed stars.<br />
STO2 (NASA) has extremely sensitive detectors<br />
for three different frequencies (1.4, 1.9,<br />
and 4.7 terahertz). These detectors have<br />
been built by <strong>SRON</strong> and Delft University of<br />
Technology. <strong>SRON</strong> and Delft University of<br />
Technology have also developed a local oscillator<br />
(4.7 terhertz) in collaboration with MIT.<br />
This is essential for measuring the signal<br />
from space with respect to the frequency<br />
(position) and spectral information.<br />
The University of Arizona is leading the<br />
scientific aspects of the project, which is<br />
being funded by NASA, NWO, <strong>SRON</strong>, and<br />
the province of Groningen.<br />
A captivating and moving story, but not such<br />
a fine film if you have just taken leave of your<br />
wife and children for a long period of time.<br />
It has the same effect as a strong Fisherman’s<br />
Friend… tears in the eyes…<br />
9 November 2015, Antarctica:<br />
beautiful but merciless!<br />
On 7 November, at the Clothing Distribution<br />
Centre in Christchurch, it becomes serious.<br />
About 40 people have assembled in the<br />
briefing room. A video gives us an idea as to<br />
what we can expect on McMurdo. The main<br />
message: Antarctica is beautiful but merciless.<br />
After some checks – flu jab...check!,<br />
computer security certificate...check!, were<br />
are allowed to go to the dressing room.<br />
After a few days I find a routine<br />
but not one I can get use to, as<br />
Antarctica is too grand for that<br />
Here rows of orange bags have been put out<br />
that contain our Extreme Weather Clothing.<br />
We then somewhat awkwardly put on overalls,<br />
hats, thick jackets, and bunny boots:
shoe size Pipo de Clown. Air insulates really<br />
well, so the idea is to capture as much of it as<br />
possible in the clothing. And indeed we all<br />
look like Michelin men but then red ones.<br />
In the transport plane to McMurdo, a C17,<br />
I choose a jump seat opposite a pallet with oil<br />
drums. Even with my legs stretched out I do<br />
not touch them. Fantastic, so much space.<br />
As the plane taxis the pallets shift backwards<br />
and forwards on the roller track. Is that meant<br />
to happen?<br />
And then the engines go full throttle and we<br />
journey on a road across the ice it is surpri -<br />
singly bumpy. McMurdo turns out to be not<br />
particularly beautiful… but definitely special.<br />
It is far more than just<br />
the landscape: it is the light,<br />
the cold, the wind, and<br />
the unbelievable distances<br />
In a room we are given another briefing, this<br />
time about the dos and especially about the<br />
don’ts on Antarctica. The entire continent is<br />
protected by a series of treaties and one of<br />
After dinner I go for a short walk. With the<br />
wind from behind and the sun in my face it<br />
does not feel too cold. What a fantastic view<br />
across the Ross Sea. On the other side gigantic<br />
glaciers flow into the sea. The air is so clear<br />
and dry that you can easily see over a distance<br />
of 100 km. That is one of the reasons why<br />
we are here. However this makes estimating<br />
distances really difficult and it distorts your<br />
observation of the area. On the way back the<br />
wind picks up and then I suddenly realize<br />
what a difference a jacket can make. With<br />
my head buried inside the hood of my jacket<br />
23<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
take off. What a unique experience. After<br />
about five hours in the air the pilot brings the<br />
plane down softly on the ice. Once we have<br />
stopped, the large tailgate at the back of the<br />
plane opens. Outside an entirely new world<br />
beckons: white, clear, bright light, mountains,<br />
a smoking volcano, and a large red lorry with<br />
a people carrier that will bring us to McMurdo.<br />
We are on Antarctica!<br />
14 November 2015, Antarctica:<br />
First warning<br />
In the bus after the landing I notice that for a<br />
the most important is that it must remain undamaged.<br />
Everything that comes in must also<br />
go out again. Even spilling coffee on the snow<br />
must be reported as an incident and neatly<br />
cleaned up. This will ensure that the unspoiled<br />
character of the area will be con served for<br />
the future. I share my room with John, an<br />
American colleague from the Jet Propulsion<br />
Laboratory. The idea of sharing a room for<br />
5 weeks takes a bit of getting used to.<br />
The heater is on 10 and the sun shines into<br />
the bedroom. Yet outside it is -20˚C: long<br />
underwear weather.<br />
I keep walking. My cheeks quickly start sting -<br />
ing and then they go numb, which is not<br />
good. Fortunately I only have a short way to<br />
go but I got the message: at -20˚C things can<br />
go wrong quickly. Next time I must take the<br />
balaclava in my pocket. But what a fantastic<br />
landscape.<br />
Inside our hanger is the balloon gondola. It is<br />
almost ready for use. We are going to incorporate<br />
our instrument in the cryostat, a sort<br />
of large thermos flask filled with liquid helium<br />
that cools the entire instrument to about
24<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
- 270°C, or 4 Kelvin, 4° above absolute zero.<br />
Although everything in more primitive you<br />
can easily forget where you are because the<br />
lab has no windows. As soon as the door<br />
opens it becomes clear again, I really am on<br />
Antarctica.<br />
It is far more than just the landscape: it is the<br />
light, the cold, the wind, and the unbelievable<br />
distances, the knowledge that the nearest<br />
place with normal facilities is a 4000 km flight<br />
away. No telephone, scarcely any Internet<br />
(almost everything is blocked or highly restrict -<br />
20 November 2015, Antarctica:<br />
Scott’s hut...<br />
Another week has passed in McMurdo. Some<br />
things have become normal: sharing my room,<br />
three warm meals per day, and long woolen<br />
underwear. Other things remain special: the<br />
fantastic landscape, the weather that can<br />
change from pleasant to extreme in five min -<br />
utes if the wind picks up, and the sun that<br />
shines from the south at 12:30 at night. It’s<br />
still strange that when you leave the pub at<br />
night, you need to put on sunglasses.<br />
I sometimes still wake up at night with a<br />
making progress but as we are working with<br />
a unique instrument we also encounter unique<br />
problems. In combination with limited labora -<br />
tory equipment and the fact that the nearest<br />
The biggest problem is ESD,<br />
ElectroStatic Discharge<br />
shops are 4000 km away, that some times<br />
demands a healthy dose of creativity. And<br />
that is why we are here.<br />
My visit to the so-called OB tube, an observation<br />
post in the ice, is memorable. Or to be<br />
ed to keep the bandwidth available for the<br />
scientific projects), no television or newspaper,<br />
the world is really far away, and the nature<br />
Our instrument is still not<br />
working well enough and that is<br />
less good news. The tensions<br />
are starting to rise<br />
overwhelmingly close by. After a few days<br />
I find a routine, but not one I can get use to,<br />
as Antarctica is just too grand for that.<br />
shock because I think I’ve overslept.<br />
In the hangar the balloon gondola is being<br />
constructed on one side: telescope, star track -<br />
er, on-board computers, altitude control,<br />
communication et cetera. Under the telescope<br />
there is a free place for our cryostat, a gigantic<br />
thermos flask, which contains our cold<br />
optical instruments, detectors, and amplifiers.<br />
On the outside of the cryostat, the warm optics,<br />
signal generators (LOs), and electronics<br />
will be placed and a computer will control all<br />
of this as well. The integration is gradually<br />
more precise, the visit that my colleague<br />
Darren made. In the OB, you descend through<br />
more than two meters of ice into a small observation<br />
space surrounded by glass. When I<br />
tried to descend through the narrow tube into<br />
the observation space my claustrophobia got<br />
the better of me. You need to know your<br />
limits... Several days later they literally had to<br />
free somebody who could no longer move up<br />
or down. On YouTube you can find a film with<br />
the view underwater. Scott’s hut on Hut Point,<br />
constructed during his first expedition in 1902,<br />
still stands as if it were built yesterday. You
can only take a glimpse inside through the<br />
window: everything is still there as if he could<br />
return at any moment, including the halfbutchered<br />
animals. Really weird...<br />
The good news today is that we have just<br />
managed to get the entire signal chain of the<br />
4.7 THz receiver to work. A local signal enters,<br />
we see the sky and a desired signal emerges<br />
for the detector. Some optimization still needs<br />
to take place, but all of the stages work.<br />
The bad news is that the toilet is not working.<br />
cables are currently still exposed with a big<br />
risk of picking up undesirable signals. The<br />
biggest problem is ESD, ElectroStatic Dis -<br />
charge. Due to the desert environment and<br />
the low temperatures the air is extremely dry.<br />
Every movement that you make results in the<br />
build up of static electricity especially if you<br />
are wearing a fleece jumper. As soon as you<br />
touch something made of metal it sparks.<br />
These discharges are fatal for our instrument.<br />
Once everything has been incorporated there<br />
will be a reasonable degree of protection but<br />
that is not the case yet. We are all doing our<br />
reminds me of a story I read long ago about<br />
wildebeests if I remember correctly, (Google<br />
does not work). To determine which direction<br />
the herd should take, one of the animals occasionally<br />
stands up with its head in a certain<br />
direction, and then it goes and lies down<br />
again. If enough animals have looked in the<br />
same direction then the entire herd goes that<br />
way.<br />
Very indirectly, problems here are tackled in<br />
the same manner. Somebody says something,<br />
nobody appears to listen, somebody says<br />
25<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
From now on it is the long drop: the Antarctic<br />
version of a privy, including snow swirling<br />
around and -10˚ C in the toilet.<br />
2 December 2015, Antarctica:<br />
best: we wear wrist straps to discharge static<br />
electricity, avoid artificial clothing, touch metal<br />
before we get near the instrument but a mistake<br />
can easily be made of course.<br />
something else. A solution is repeated by a<br />
third and a fourth, and suddenly we have<br />
chosen that direction. Fascinating. It works,<br />
but back in the Netherlands we do things very<br />
differently.<br />
the tension is mounting...<br />
The toilet has been repaired and that is a relief.<br />
The short drop is better in the long term.<br />
However our instrument is still not working<br />
well enough and that is less good news. The<br />
tensions are rising. Ideally you want to get<br />
this integration phase over and done with as<br />
quickly as possible. Many components and<br />
Seeing penguins is apparently<br />
a spiritual experience<br />
that changes you mentally<br />
In a nutshell, the instrument must be closed<br />
quickly and it must also function properly. But<br />
what is the right way forward? And when is it<br />
good enough? The decision-making process<br />
And then suddenly several large steps follow:<br />
the cryostat must be integrated with the telescope<br />
gondola. This interferes with our own<br />
work. The most vulnerable part, the local oscillator<br />
located on the outside, is taken off<br />
again. The calibration will therefore have to<br />
be repeated and the mounting plate that now
26<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
already looks like a piece of Swiss cheese will<br />
probably have a few more holes added to it.<br />
However, a milestone has been achieved.<br />
We now have an almost completely working<br />
gondola in the hangar.<br />
10 December 2015, Antarctica:<br />
The Final Countdown?<br />
We are still steadily making progress. My<br />
current estimate is two to one: two days of<br />
progress and one day of setbacks. The date<br />
for the last big test, the hanging test, is<br />
20 December. According to the meteorologist<br />
apparently a spiritual experience that changes<br />
you mentally: people who have seen penguins<br />
will at convenient and not so convenient<br />
moments shove a phone under your nose<br />
with penguin photos and films. There is a<br />
sharp distinction, marked by jealousy and disbelief,<br />
between those who have seen and<br />
those who have not. I still belong to the latter<br />
group, as it appears that the penguins at<br />
Emmen Zoo do not count. Darren has seen<br />
them of course.<br />
the launch and I will even miss the hanging<br />
test.<br />
That is because no flights are made between<br />
17 December and 4 January, and then I would<br />
miss Christmas and New Year as well as<br />
several birthdays (including my daughter’s).<br />
STO-1 did not fly until 16 January. Very difficult.<br />
And I want to go home as I’ve been<br />
away since 17 October, but witnessing the<br />
launch is also a unique event of course. The<br />
final countdown: another four nights until<br />
the journey back. A 40-hour flight covering<br />
the desired airflow pattern at 40 km altitude<br />
has not developed yet. This is expected around<br />
18 December. So we are not losing any flight<br />
days yet. The balloon from our colleagues<br />
from GRIPS will probably be launched first and<br />
that will give us some extra breathing space.<br />
The sea ice is now starting to change. From<br />
vantage points in the neighborhood you can<br />
see the open sea coming closer on the horizon.<br />
The cracks in the ice are starting to move<br />
and penguins have been observed on the<br />
excursion to Cape Evans. Seeing penguins is<br />
During the past few weeks we have regularly<br />
said: it is Groundhog Day again (after the film<br />
with Bill Murray in the main role). Each day is<br />
more or less the same as the last, the same<br />
My current estimate is two<br />
to one: two days of progress<br />
and one day of setbacks<br />
daily routine, no change in routine due to<br />
weekend, clubs or other things that normally<br />
tell the days apart. But now the journey back<br />
home is approaching. So I will not experience<br />
31,000 km. What do I want, launch or<br />
family...<br />
4 Januari <strong>2016</strong>, the Netherlands:<br />
Readjustment<br />
I’m back home again. The last days on Antarctica<br />
were really demanding: the lack of a<br />
daylight rhythm (and privacy) considerably<br />
disturbed my sleep. And I really cannot survive<br />
on four hours of sleep a night. That’s another<br />
thing I’ve learnt. The journey back was a long<br />
one. The modern C-17 from the journey<br />
inward had been replaced with a Hercules
uilt in a year before I was even born. It took<br />
this monster on skis eight hours to make the<br />
flight, and it sounded and felt as if somebody<br />
had attached a petrol-driven lawnmower to<br />
my back. But it flew and in the right direction.<br />
After landing in Christchurch I was really<br />
struck by the colors and smells after five<br />
weeks on Antarctica: it was an attack on my<br />
senses. Because snow and ice have no smells.<br />
And there is life, an awful lot of life: plants,<br />
insects, and birds of course but also people,<br />
especially strange faces: five weeks is clearly<br />
left Christchurch. On the Thursday morning of<br />
17 December I was back again in the Netherlands,<br />
exactly 2 months after I had left. Train,<br />
taxi, and at last home again. Embraced my<br />
So I will not experience<br />
the launch and I will even<br />
miss the hanging test<br />
wife and son, with our dog barking that he<br />
wanted to join in too. I also quickly picked up<br />
my daughter from school. Everything was<br />
back to normal again.<br />
team, which may launch first. Then it is our<br />
turn.<br />
The circulation pattern at 40 km altitude has<br />
now developed at the right location. On the<br />
ground the weather is less favorable, as the<br />
wind is a bit too strong to launch safely.<br />
GRIPS has already made three attempts. Time<br />
is now starting to run out: to be able to make<br />
a complete circle around the South Pole with<br />
a reasonable degree of certainty the flight<br />
must start by mid-January. However now<br />
things are in the hands of the weather gods.<br />
27<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
enough to recognize and/or know a community<br />
of 1000 faces.<br />
I also acquired a completely new appreciation<br />
for comfort in the hotel room and a wellfunctioning<br />
Internet: click and it works, no<br />
more: click - coffee - check - more coffee -<br />
half a page. What a pleasure.<br />
The rest of the journey back seemed to take<br />
ages. Especially Tuesday, which I experienced<br />
twice due to crossing the International Date<br />
Line: I arrived earlier in Los Angeles than I had<br />
We are now two weeks further and it is the<br />
start of January. On Antarctica Darren Hayton<br />
and the rest of team have worked really hard.<br />
It is strange that I can now only follow them<br />
via email. The entire gondola works well and<br />
the last big hurdle, the hanging test, was<br />
successfully passed. During this test the<br />
gondola is hung outside and then it must be<br />
able to carry out all of the intended functions<br />
entirely autonomously. During the flight readiness<br />
review, the formal approval also came:<br />
we are allowed to fly! Now it is a case of<br />
waiting for good weather, first for the GRIPS<br />
And they are unpredictable: after a recordbreaking<br />
warm December my first workday<br />
after my Antarctic adventure starts with a<br />
white world in the Netherlands.<br />
That takes a bit of getting used to…<br />
WOUTER LAAUWEN<br />
(summarized and edited<br />
by Frans Stravers)
28<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
THE MISSIONS TO DATE<br />
The instruments that <strong>SRON</strong> is currently making are intended for missions in five, ten or even more<br />
than fifteen years’ time. The scientific publications from now are from missions that are often still<br />
underway or have already been completed. An overview of the current missions and instruments.
Mission <strong>SRON</strong> contribution Studies mainly Description Status<br />
Herschel<br />
ESA<br />
2009 - 2013<br />
HIFI<br />
Heterodyne Instrument<br />
for the Far Infrared<br />
Universe<br />
> infrared<br />
The scientists used the far infrared light that HIFI<br />
captured in the search for molecules in the ’cold<br />
universe’. They demonstrated, for example, that<br />
ended<br />
the water on earth originated from comets.<br />
29<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
XMM-Newton<br />
ESA<br />
1999 - ...<br />
RGS<br />
Reflection Grating<br />
Spectrometers<br />
Universe<br />
> X-rays<br />
The two ’M’s in XMM stand for multi-mirror.<br />
That refers to the hundreds of curved mirrors that<br />
capture the X-rays. <strong>SRON</strong> made the special spectrometers.<br />
operational<br />
Chandra<br />
NASA<br />
1999 - ...<br />
LETG<br />
Low-Energy Transmission<br />
Grating<br />
Universe<br />
> X-rays<br />
X-rays do not penetrate the earth’s atmosphere,<br />
so a satellite is needed to measure these. Chandra,<br />
for example, has a spectrometer for ‘soft X-rays’.<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> made the ring-shaped core of the spectrometer.<br />
operational<br />
INTEGRAL<br />
ESA, NASA<br />
and RKA<br />
2002 - ...<br />
Advice during<br />
construction, calibration,<br />
and research<br />
Universe<br />
> visible,<br />
X-rays,<br />
and gamma<br />
The name INTEGRAL is not just the acronym for<br />
INTErnational Gamma-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory.<br />
It also stands for the integral package of radiation<br />
that the satellite observes. Besides gamma<br />
radiation the satellite can also observe X-rays and<br />
visible light.<br />
operational<br />
ALMA (Chili)<br />
ESO<br />
2011 - ...<br />
High-frequency<br />
receivers<br />
Universe<br />
> (sub)millimeter<br />
ALMA in Chile is the largest astronomical project<br />
in the world. 66 radio antennae of 7 to 12 meters<br />
in diameter receive signals from the universe.<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> was the technical consultant during the<br />
development and construction of the highfrequency<br />
receivers and is assisting in their use.<br />
operational<br />
MetOp<br />
ESA and<br />
EUMETSAT<br />
2006, 2012,<br />
2017<br />
Calibration, data<br />
processing GOME-2<br />
Global Ozone<br />
Monitoring Experiment<br />
Earth<br />
> visible light<br />
The MetOp project is successively bringing three<br />
satellites into orbit around the poles. The satellites<br />
carry out measurements on the weather and the<br />
climate. <strong>SRON</strong> collaborated on the development<br />
of the ozone meter and is helping to analyze the<br />
results.<br />
under<br />
development/<br />
operational
30<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Mission <strong>SRON</strong> contribution Studies mainly Description Status<br />
APEX (Chili)<br />
ESO<br />
2014<br />
A-MKID-camera<br />
Apex Microwave<br />
Kinetic Induction<br />
Universe<br />
> between<br />
infrared and<br />
The core of the A-MKID consists of 20,000 pixels, i.e.<br />
detectors. The astronomers can read all of the pixels<br />
indi vi dually. From the ground they can see three times<br />
under<br />
development<br />
Detector<br />
radio<br />
more sharply than the detectors onboard the space<br />
telescope Herschel.<br />
ASTRO-H/<br />
Hitomi<br />
JAXA, NASA<br />
and ESA<br />
2015<br />
SXS<br />
Soft X-ray<br />
Spectrometer<br />
Universe<br />
> X-rays<br />
Sometimes X-rays are so strong that they overpower<br />
the sensitive spectrometers. <strong>SRON</strong> made the filter wheel<br />
that prevents overpowering due to strong radiation.<br />
The institute also developed the calibration source: an<br />
X-ray emitter on board with precisely known properties.<br />
operational<br />
Sentinel-5 -<br />
precursor<br />
ESA and EU<br />
<strong>2016</strong><br />
Immersed gratings,<br />
read out electronics<br />
TROPOMI, derivation<br />
specifications, calibration,<br />
data retrieval,<br />
TROPospheric Ozone<br />
Monitoring Instrument<br />
Earth<br />
> ultraviolet,<br />
visible,<br />
infrared<br />
Sentinel-5-precursor is the successor to the environmental<br />
satellite ENVISAT. The Tropomi instrument combines the<br />
large wavelength range of its predecessor SCIAMACHY<br />
with the wide observation angle of the OMI instrument.<br />
<strong>SRON</strong>/TNO made the ingenious ‘immersed grating’.<br />
ready for<br />
launch<br />
STO2<br />
NASA<br />
<strong>2016</strong>/2017<br />
Three THz receivers<br />
(4.7, 1.9 and 1.4 Thz)<br />
and the 4.7 terahertz<br />
local oscillator unit<br />
Universe<br />
> far infrared<br />
The balloon mission STO2 will map part of the cosmos<br />
during its flight 40 km above Antarctica. STO2 will observe<br />
the emission lines of carbon (CII) and nitrogen (NII)<br />
at a frequency of 1.9 and 1.4 terahertz respectively.<br />
With the new 4.7 terahertz technology STO2 will also<br />
observe the emission lines of electrically neutral oxygen.<br />
ready for<br />
launch<br />
SPICA<br />
JAXA and<br />
ESA 2028<br />
SAFARI<br />
SpicA FAR-infrared<br />
Instrument<br />
Universe<br />
> far infrared<br />
SAFARI is the successor to the molecule hunter HIFI.<br />
The spectrometer/camera will look deeper and in greater<br />
detail than ever before into the universe from an infrared<br />
perspective.<br />
under<br />
development<br />
ATHENA<br />
ESA<br />
2028<br />
Detectors and readout<br />
electronics X-ray<br />
Integral Field Unit<br />
Universe<br />
> X-rays<br />
ATHENA is the selected successor to ASTRO-H/Hitomi,<br />
which was launched in February <strong>2016</strong>. <strong>SRON</strong> is working<br />
together with groups from Japan and the United States,<br />
for example, to make a state-of-the-art, supercooled<br />
spectrometer.<br />
under<br />
development
31<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
Mission facts<br />
> Uncertainty: If the mission is planned far<br />
into the future then it is still often uncertain<br />
whether the mission will go ahead, when<br />
the launch will take place exactly, and which<br />
instruments will be allowed on board.<br />
Missions that are currently flying often have<br />
a far longer mission duration than planned.<br />
The mission duration is often estimated<br />
conservatively to prevent disappointments.<br />
Chandra was planned to do service from<br />
1999 until 2004 but it is still working in<br />
<strong>2016</strong>.<br />
> Specialism: astronomers distinguish<br />
seve ral types of light and radiation: radio,<br />
infrared, visible light, ultraviolet, X-rays,<br />
gamma. Each telescope has its own special -<br />
ism and views the universe through differ ent<br />
eyes.<br />
> International: JAXA is Japanese, RKA is<br />
Russian, ESA is European, NASA is American,<br />
ESO is the European Southern Observatory<br />
in Chile, and EUMETSAT is the European<br />
organization for meteorological satellites.
32<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong><br />
CREDITS<br />
<strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong> is the newsletter of <strong>SRON</strong> Netherlands Institute<br />
for Space Research<br />
<strong>SRON</strong>’s mission is to bring about breakthroughs in international<br />
space research. Therefore the institute develops pioneering<br />
technology and advanced space instruments, and uses them to<br />
pursue fundamental astrophysical research, earth science and<br />
exoplanetary research.<br />
As national expertise institute <strong>SRON</strong> gives counsel to the Dutch<br />
government and coordinates national scientific contributions to<br />
international space missions. <strong>SRON</strong> stimulates the implementation<br />
of space science in our society. <strong>SRON</strong> is part of the Netherlands<br />
Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO).<br />
To register for <strong>SRON</strong> <strong>Spectrum</strong> or to cancel your subscription<br />
please send an e-mail to info@sron.nl.<br />
Text Frans Stravers, Eveline van der Linden,<br />
Yannick Fritschy, Marieke Baan and<br />
Wouter Laauwen<br />
Photos <strong>SRON</strong>, NASA, ESA, JAXA<br />
Design Studio WW15<br />
Printed by Drukkerij Badoux, Houten<br />
Published by <strong>SRON</strong> Netherlands Institute for Space Research<br />
Address Sorbonnelaan 2<br />
3584 CA Utrecht<br />
+31 88 777 5600<br />
Landleven 12<br />
PO Box 800<br />
9700 AV Groningen<br />
+31 50 363 4074<br />
Mail info@sron.nl<br />
Web sron.nl<br />
Facebook facebook.com/sron.nl<br />
Twitter @<strong>SRON</strong>_Space<br />
Youtube youtube.com/<strong>SRON</strong>ruimteonderzoek