Aelex Report
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
#aelex2016<br />
project report<br />
ÆLEX<br />
TH<br />
11 ANNUAL LECTURE
#aelex2016<br />
project report<br />
Compiled by<br />
Development Diaries LTD/GTE<br />
7 Raymond Street, Off Commercial Avenue,<br />
Sabo - Yaba, Lagos, Nigeria<br />
www.developmentdiaries.com
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />
With an es mated popula on of 180 million people, Nigeria<br />
is reckoned as Africa's biggest democracy, opera ng a<br />
federal system of governance which recognises the Federal,<br />
State and Local ers of government. This structure leaves<br />
the most populous Black Country in the world with a<br />
Federal Government at the centre, 36 State Governments<br />
and the Federal Capital Territory, FCT, and 774 Local<br />
Governments Areas across Nigeria.<br />
According to<br />
recent<br />
sta s cs, only<br />
three (Lagos,<br />
Rivers and Akwa-Ibom)<br />
out of Nigeria's 36<br />
States are currently<br />
economically viable and<br />
are mee ng up with<br />
their financial<br />
obliga ons especially,<br />
payment of wage bill.<br />
Accordingly, over 90<br />
percent of the States in<br />
Nigeria can be deemed<br />
insolvent and therefore<br />
categorised as a failed<br />
state.
From high worker<br />
indebtedness to<br />
widespread ci zens<br />
complaints and protests,<br />
there have been<br />
fledging concerns on<br />
the state of States in<br />
Nigeria, demonstrated<br />
through ques onable<br />
thoughts on their<br />
existence, framework<br />
and effec veness in<br />
delivering core<br />
responsibili es and<br />
qualita ve public<br />
service delivery for the<br />
growth and<br />
development of the<br />
country.<br />
These, amongst many<br />
concerns, informed the<br />
choice of 'Making States<br />
Work' as the topic of<br />
th<br />
discourse for the 11<br />
AELEX Annual Lecture<br />
held on November 9,<br />
2016. For over a<br />
decade, the AELEX<br />
annual lecture has<br />
evolved into a first-rate<br />
pla orm for exploring<br />
emerging issues of<br />
socio-economic and<br />
poli cal relevance in<br />
Nigeria.<br />
This year set out to<br />
engage relevant<br />
stakeholders on<br />
a aining self-reliance,<br />
effec veness and<br />
sustainability for<br />
Nigerian States.<br />
This report<br />
quintessen ally<br />
highlights the series of
ac vi es, engagements<br />
and deliverables<br />
undertaken by<br />
Development Diaries<br />
LTD/GTE, culmina ng<br />
in the success of the<br />
event held at the<br />
MUSON Centre, Marina<br />
Lagos. The report also<br />
documents various<br />
successful elements of<br />
the event, learning<br />
outcomes from the<br />
project and<br />
opportuni es for<br />
considera on in<br />
subsequent edi ons.
PROJECT OVERVIEW<br />
Development Diaries LTD/GTE was contracted to<br />
handle two aspects of the event;<br />
Ÿ Digital Communica on<br />
Ÿ Stage Design & Management<br />
The table below highlights the services, ac vi es and<br />
results from each of the two highlighted services;<br />
S/N SERVICES/TASKS ACTIVITIES CARRIED OUT ACHIEVED<br />
1<br />
Digital Communica ons:<br />
Ÿ<br />
Create online knowledge,<br />
awareness and engagement<br />
on #AELEX2016 through<br />
robust media coverage and<br />
circula on.<br />
Ÿ<br />
Ÿ<br />
11 Publicity banners<br />
designed<br />
Pre & Neo Event social<br />
media coverage (LinkedIn,<br />
Facebook and Twi er)<br />
Ÿ<br />
9.7 million impressions;<br />
816,768 Reach; Trends in<br />
Nigeria, USA, Canada,<br />
Malawi, Ghana, Turkey,<br />
France and Germany.
S/N SERVICES/TASKS ACTIVITIES CARRIED OUT ACHIEVED<br />
Ÿ<br />
Repor ng of engagements<br />
and resolu ons from<br />
previous edi ons of the<br />
event.<br />
Ÿ<br />
Ÿ<br />
Live Online Photo-Ops<br />
Sponsored Ads on<br />
Facebook and Twi er<br />
Ÿ<br />
Four publica ons of press<br />
release on omojuwa.com,<br />
naijanewshub.com,<br />
thenewsguru.com x 2.<br />
Ÿ<br />
Capture event proceedings<br />
in real me sequence<br />
through s ll images.<br />
Ÿ<br />
Ÿ<br />
Pre and Post Press releases<br />
Photography<br />
Ÿ<br />
#AELEX2016 Photobook<br />
(So & Hard copies)<br />
2<br />
Stage Design & Management<br />
Ÿ<br />
Ÿ<br />
Stage design<br />
Bucket seats<br />
Ÿ<br />
Ÿ<br />
Approved design<br />
implemented<br />
Back up PAS provided<br />
Ÿ<br />
Monitor & Projector screen<br />
provided
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
With the theme 'Making States Work', the 11th Annual<br />
AELEX Lecture was held at the Agip Recital Hall of the<br />
Muson Centre, Marina, Lagos on Wednesday, November 9,<br />
2016.<br />
The annual discussion<br />
forum<br />
played host to<br />
diverse stakeholders<br />
including Ex-<br />
Ministers, Ex-<br />
Governors, MDs/CEOs,<br />
Legal prac oners,<br />
Business Execu ves,<br />
Students, et al.<br />
Se ng off the event<br />
with a iconic welcome<br />
address was Mr.<br />
Theophilus Emuwa<br />
(Managing Partner,<br />
AELEX), who welcomed<br />
and appreciated the<br />
audience for keeping<br />
faith in the annual lecture<br />
for over a decade.<br />
He, however, clarified<br />
that the gathering was<br />
th<br />
AELEX's 12 Anniverth<br />
sary and 11 Annual<br />
Lecture. He said the<br />
annual lecture had<br />
become a pla orm for<br />
highligh ng topical<br />
na onal issues of socioeconomic<br />
and poli cal<br />
relevance whilst forging<br />
solid reasoning and
solu ons for Nigeria,<br />
showcasing analy cal<br />
strengths and weaknesses<br />
of opposing<br />
perspec ves on<br />
Na onal issues. Mr.<br />
Emuwa highlighted the<br />
relevance of the topic<br />
and panel of discussion,<br />
given the current realies<br />
of State management<br />
in Nigeria. He<br />
expressed confidence<br />
that the panel would<br />
proficiently engage the<br />
topic of discourse for<br />
be er na onal interest.<br />
The panel discussions<br />
started in earnest and<br />
featued; Mr. Donald<br />
Duke (CON), Former<br />
Governor, Cross River<br />
State; Mr. Peter Obi,<br />
Former Governor,<br />
Anambra State; Mr.<br />
Aigboje Aig-<br />
Imoukhuede, Council<br />
President , Nigeria Stock<br />
Exchange; Professor<br />
Chidi Anselm Odinkalu,<br />
Director, Africa Program,<br />
Open Society<br />
Jus ce Ini a ve and Mr.<br />
Isaac Babatunde, Execuve<br />
Director, Corporate<br />
& Sub-Sovereign<br />
Ra ngs, Agusto & Co.<br />
Moderator of the panel<br />
discussion, Mr. Donald<br />
Duke started off by<br />
congratula ng the<br />
AELEX team for the<br />
concept and con nuity<br />
of the vision of an<br />
annual lecture for over a<br />
decade in spite of chal-
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
How can<br />
we Make<br />
States Work<br />
in Nigeria?<br />
lenges. He related some<br />
of his personal experiences<br />
in and out of<br />
office as a Governor. He<br />
also stressed the importance<br />
of having a collecve<br />
vision as a<br />
state/na on, whilst<br />
poin ng out the need<br />
for leaders to be tenacious<br />
with a vision that<br />
surpasses all cri cisms<br />
made by people.<br />
Taking on the ques on<br />
on “How can we Make<br />
States Work in Nigeria?”, ,<br />
Mr. Peter Obi said that<br />
the vision of the leader<br />
is expedient to the<br />
development of the<br />
state. According to him,<br />
the vision must be clear,<br />
that way, the leader can<br />
drive the state to success.<br />
The reason for<br />
most failure is the<br />
absence of a plan, he<br />
added.<br />
Using Anambra State as<br />
a case study, Mr. Obi
Basically, the<br />
assignments, at<br />
that me, were to<br />
alleviate poverty,<br />
improve on health<br />
standards as well<br />
as educa on.<br />
These gave birth<br />
to the Anambra<br />
State Integrated<br />
Development<br />
Strategy.<br />
related his experiences<br />
upon assump on as<br />
Execu ve Governor. He<br />
said there were no<br />
structures at the me,<br />
hence, he immediately<br />
swung into ac on by<br />
adop ng a clear vision<br />
and developing a strategy<br />
for execu ng each<br />
goal in the stated vision.<br />
“Basically, the assignments,<br />
at that me, were<br />
to alleviate poverty,<br />
improve on health standards<br />
as well as educaon.<br />
These gave birth to<br />
the Anambra State Integrated<br />
Development<br />
Strategy.”<br />
One of the key points<br />
he made was that governance<br />
is just a PRO-<br />
CESS; simply look at<br />
achieving a goal, plan<br />
properly, budget appropriately<br />
and finally<br />
deliver. He described<br />
how his administra on<br />
adopted a demand-
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
driven style of governance<br />
as against the<br />
supply-driven style.<br />
This, he said was about<br />
giving what is important<br />
to those who required<br />
it. He made references<br />
to his school projects<br />
and how funds were<br />
used in the state.<br />
Mr Obi stressed on the<br />
need to improve on<br />
prudency in governance<br />
despite the exposure to<br />
huge amounts of<br />
money.<br />
In his submission, Mr.<br />
Aigboje Aig-<br />
Imoukhuede, noted that<br />
everything that goes<br />
wrong in a State is<br />
hinged on governance.<br />
Governance, according<br />
to him, “is a state of<br />
dynamics that involves<br />
agreeing on how<br />
resources are allocated in<br />
a state.” He gave a formula<br />
that Bad Governance<br />
equals<br />
Weak/Poor/Unacceptab<br />
le Outcomes and vice<br />
versa.<br />
He said there are basically<br />
two problems in<br />
Nigeria; “The electoral<br />
processes and how states<br />
are created,” making<br />
reference to 1967 when<br />
state crea on began in<br />
Nigeria.<br />
He opined that government<br />
should go beyond<br />
the state alloca on
amounts to have a<br />
greater vision that is<br />
beyond that limit. He<br />
said it was expedient for<br />
leaders to create an<br />
enabling environment.<br />
He pointed out that<br />
only 6 States are economically<br />
independent<br />
in Nigeria; Lagos,<br />
Kaduna, Kano, Rivers,<br />
Oyo and the FCT. Mr<br />
Aig-Imoukhuede also<br />
revealed that 54% of<br />
total output in Nigeria<br />
comes from these<br />
states likewise 30% of<br />
na onal income. However,<br />
most of the<br />
na on's expenditures<br />
are incurred by states<br />
that are not significantly<br />
contribu ng to the<br />
na on's wealth.<br />
With this thought from<br />
Mr Aig-Imoukhuede, the<br />
moderator added that<br />
most states do not have<br />
a global vision or SWOT<br />
analysis and that it is<br />
important that there is a<br />
federal system that<br />
unifies all Nigerian<br />
States.<br />
In addressing the queson<br />
on how to establish<br />
and sustain a longlas<br />
ng rela onship<br />
between the Federal<br />
and State governments,<br />
Professor Chidi<br />
Odinkalu took the floor<br />
as the third discussant,<br />
no ng that the knowledge<br />
of the legacy of<br />
state crea on and
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
State crea on<br />
in Nigeria lasted<br />
from 1967 to 1996.<br />
This somewhat<br />
faulty founda onal<br />
reason for state<br />
crea on was<br />
fundamental to<br />
its failure. Possibly,<br />
the reason 80%<br />
of States are<br />
currently in<br />
debt.<br />
governance in Nigeria<br />
has not been well conveyed.<br />
“There is a lack of<br />
historical awareness<br />
which ought to be taught<br />
to the younger generaon,”<br />
he said.<br />
Odinkalu gave details of<br />
the history of state<br />
crea on from the postindependence<br />
era.<br />
Northern Nigeria occupies<br />
79% of Nigeria's<br />
territorial state and<br />
according to him what<br />
triggered state crea on,<br />
in July 1967, was an<br />
a empt to secure the<br />
North central region.<br />
“State crea on in Nigeria<br />
lasted from 1967 to<br />
1996. This somewhat<br />
faulty founda onal<br />
reason for state crea on<br />
was fundamental to its<br />
failure. Possibly, the reason<br />
80% of States are<br />
currently in debt.”
While rounding up,<br />
Professor Odinkalu<br />
submi ed that Nigeria<br />
lacked four crucial<br />
things: processes, management,<br />
details and<br />
priori es. He further<br />
stated that States in<br />
Nigeria were basically<br />
irra onal and that<br />
reflects in their decision<br />
making. He bemoaned<br />
the lack of con nuity in<br />
vision and in office.<br />
The fourth discussant,<br />
Mr. Isaac Babatunde<br />
treated the ques on,<br />
“What are the horrors<br />
experienced in the Stock<br />
Exchange with connecon<br />
to States?” He<br />
began by iden fying<br />
state sources of revenue<br />
as being basically<br />
from statutory allocaons.<br />
This, he said,<br />
formed 75% of each<br />
state's total revenue.<br />
However, he pointed<br />
out that revenue in<br />
many states had<br />
dropped and they were<br />
defaul ng in their<br />
payroll obliga ons. He<br />
considered the availability<br />
of IGR (Internal Generated<br />
Revenue); how<br />
much of the total state's<br />
revenue was from IGR<br />
and how much of the<br />
IGR was used to se le<br />
debts. Babatunde also<br />
said that some states<br />
usually borrowed from<br />
the Nigerian Stock<br />
Exchange (NSE) to
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
se le their payroll<br />
obliga ons.<br />
Whilst using Lagos as a<br />
case study, he listed<br />
some effec ve measures<br />
that the Lagos<br />
State government had<br />
in place which currently<br />
aided its smooth running.<br />
In terms of revenue,<br />
he explained how<br />
Lagos had widened the<br />
tax net to accommodate<br />
ar sans and smaller<br />
entrepreneurs.<br />
Babtunde also explained<br />
that PPP (Public-Private<br />
Partnership) was a best<br />
prac ce model as visible<br />
in waste management in<br />
the state.<br />
Three other areas which<br />
he believed some states<br />
could emulate Lagos in,<br />
included property tax<br />
inclusion in revenue,<br />
blocking of financial<br />
leakages as well as idenfying<br />
and providing<br />
specific needs of the<br />
people. Towards expenditure,<br />
he urged other<br />
states to adopt the<br />
Zero-base budge ng<br />
system, like Lagos, as<br />
this would ensure that<br />
only necessary projects<br />
are funded. In his conclusion,<br />
Babatunde<br />
advised that, like Lagos,<br />
other states should<br />
ensure that their Ministries,<br />
Departments and<br />
Agencies (MDAs) are<br />
capable of selfsustenance.<br />
He stressed
the importance of<br />
proper record keeping<br />
as well as a reduc on of<br />
cost of governance; all<br />
derived from the model<br />
of governance prac ced<br />
by Lagos state..<br />
There were concluding<br />
thoughts from all the<br />
discussants and the<br />
moderator, a er audience<br />
contribu ons and<br />
ques ons were entertained.<br />
One of the crucial<br />
issues raised during the<br />
Q&A session was on<br />
how to ensure public<br />
office holders are held<br />
accountable to the<br />
ci zenry.<br />
In his response, Mr.<br />
Peter Obi said that the<br />
quality of Nigerian leadership<br />
is low, hence, he<br />
urged government and<br />
poli cal leaders to<br />
create an enabling environment<br />
for feedback.<br />
He also pleaded that<br />
ci zens learn to speak<br />
out and shun sycophancy.<br />
Mr. Duke, in his opinion,<br />
said that the pa ern of<br />
leadership in Nigeria is<br />
simply a reflec on of<br />
the Nigerian State and<br />
who we are as Nigerians.<br />
He also reiterated<br />
that leaders should<br />
provide a wide pla orm<br />
where all types of quesons<br />
can come in
#AELEX2016:<br />
EVENT REPORT<br />
bordering on state<br />
issues.<br />
Mr. Aig-Imoukhuede<br />
emphasized the fact<br />
that socie es are built<br />
on the contribu ons of<br />
every member. On the<br />
opera onal style of<br />
governments through<br />
the Civil Service, Mr Obi<br />
highlighted that States<br />
require the best of<br />
minds to drive essen al<br />
developmental agenda.<br />
He said that 16-17% of<br />
corrup on cases in<br />
Nigeria emanate from<br />
the Civil Service, hence,<br />
the need to engage<br />
persons of high moral<br />
standing, track record<br />
and competence.<br />
Also, there was emphasis<br />
on the need to have<br />
consequence structures<br />
which will reward people<br />
for good public<br />
conduct as well as<br />
shame and punish for<br />
bad public behaviour.<br />
This, everyone agreed<br />
would foster an enviable<br />
society in the longterm.<br />
As expressed by a endees,<br />
the #AELEX2016<br />
lecture lived up to its<br />
billing of s mula ng<br />
healthy conversa ons<br />
and thoughts on making<br />
states work. According<br />
to them, the lecture was<br />
enlightening as they<br />
look forward to the next<br />
edi on with hopes that
the proffered solu ons<br />
on making states work<br />
would become effec ve<br />
at various levels of the<br />
society.<br />
The lecture was<br />
rounded off with a<br />
convergence of thought<br />
on the need for all state<br />
and non-state actors to<br />
be proac ve and posive<br />
towards na onbuilding.<br />
In a wi y yet pithy style,<br />
the vote of thanks was<br />
rendered, apprecia ng<br />
all lecture par cipants,<br />
discussants, partners<br />
and team members for a<br />
successful ou ng.<br />
The #AELEX2016<br />
Annual Lecture con n-<br />
ued with a grand cocktail<br />
session at the foyer<br />
of the venue, providing<br />
a endees with a networking<br />
cum refreshment<br />
opportunity.
SOCIAL MEDIA<br />
REPORT FOR #AELEX2016<br />
From the preevent<br />
phase to<br />
the neo and<br />
post-event<br />
phases, the official<br />
hashtag of the 2016<br />
Annual AELEX Lecture,<br />
#AELEX2016, received<br />
an overwhelming global<br />
engagement through<br />
social media (LinkedIn,<br />
Facebook and Twi er)<br />
ac vi es culmina ng in;<br />
Ÿ 9.7 million impressions<br />
[Number of<br />
accounts that<br />
received communicaons<br />
with the<br />
hashtag<br />
#AELEX2016]<br />
Ÿ 816,768 Reach [Total<br />
persons that clicked<br />
on the communicaons]<br />
Ÿ #AELEX2016 had a<br />
global presence,<br />
touching base with<br />
over 7 countries<br />
including the USA,<br />
Canada, Malawi,<br />
Ghana, Turkey, France<br />
and Germany<br />
Ÿ The hashtag also<br />
trended on Nigeria's<br />
Twi er Timeline for<br />
over two hours,<br />
dus ng over 10 other<br />
hashtags to comth<br />
mence at the 10<br />
posi on, moving up<br />
th<br />
to the 8 posi on of<br />
the na onal trend list.
IMPRESSION<br />
/ REACH<br />
#AELEX2016<br />
PREVIEW<br />
ADVANCED FILTERS<br />
372 113<br />
POSTS<br />
USERS<br />
816,768<br />
REACH<br />
9,695,675<br />
IMPRESSIONS<br />
Timeline
GLOBAL<br />
FOOTPRINT<br />
Loca on<br />
World<br />
USA
NATIONAL<br />
TREND ON TWITTER
PRE-EVENT<br />
Promo ons received massive engagements across major social media<br />
pla orms – LinkedIn, Twi er and Facebook.
NEO/POST EVENT<br />
SOCIAL MEDIA PROMO
DESIGN<br />
PROMOTIONAL BANNERS:
KEY<br />
LEARNING POINTS<br />
Ÿ Need for ins tu onal<br />
memory for the project<br />
to guide communica<br />
on for future<br />
events: As an agelong<br />
event, there is<br />
the need for living<br />
memory of event<br />
annual lecture event<br />
through conscious<br />
collec on of facts,<br />
concepts, experiences<br />
and know-how. This<br />
feat transcends individuals<br />
but with<br />
organisa onal value<br />
aiding ongoing transmission<br />
of memories<br />
between team members<br />
and vendors and<br />
ul mately serving as<br />
a guide for communica<br />
ons.<br />
Ÿ Repor ng and documenta<br />
on of outcomes:<br />
Every event<br />
presents unique perspec<br />
ve on socioeconomic<br />
and poli -<br />
cal issues within Nigeria<br />
and Africa, hence,<br />
the need to explicitly<br />
capture every proceeding<br />
and event<br />
outcome using innova<br />
ve digital tools<br />
and proficient personnel.<br />
Achieving<br />
this, creates easily<br />
accessible track for<br />
the annual lecture.<br />
Ÿ ü Pay-it-forward<br />
ini a ve to contribute<br />
to the solu ons<br />
proffered at the event<br />
such as: publishing a
white paper, engaging<br />
stakeholders and<br />
offering exper se.<br />
Ÿ ü Socio-poli cal<br />
conversa ons are<br />
be er projected and<br />
engaged by ci zens in<br />
real- me value, as<br />
observed with the<br />
level of interac on<br />
with #AELEX2016<br />
across various social<br />
media pla orms,<br />
hence, the need for<br />
digital integra on into<br />
all phases of future<br />
lecture events.<br />
Ÿ ü Delivering a sterling<br />
digital media<br />
campaign is requires<br />
me and planning,<br />
therefore, a clear-cut<br />
communica on and<br />
agreement should be<br />
reached on promoons<br />
and engagements.
LOOKING AHEAD<br />
Undoubtedly,<br />
#AELEX2016 has<br />
achieved impressive<br />
milestones both online<br />
and offline, hence, the<br />
need to consolidate the<br />
gains of the event.<br />
To this end, Development<br />
Diaries LTD/GTE<br />
proposes the following<br />
Digital Services to further<br />
establish your<br />
brand as a tech-savvy<br />
thought-leader in the<br />
legal industry.<br />
Ÿ E-Newsle er producon<br />
and disseminaon<br />
Ÿ Social Media Content/Management<br />
Ÿ Online Reputa on<br />
Management<br />
We look forward to<br />
discussing these opportuni<br />
es with the relevant<br />
team(s) and thank<br />
the Annual Lecture<br />
Team for the opportunity<br />
to add value.
Development Diaries LTD/GTE<br />
7 Raymond Street, Off Commercial Avenue,<br />
Sabo - Yaba, Lagos, Nigeria<br />
Contact Team<br />
Femi Aderibigbe<br />
Project Lead<br />
femi@developmentdiaries.com<br />
+234 803 424 1889<br />
Office Contact<br />
info@developmentdiaries.com<br />
+234 818 003 9899<br />
Tayo Elegbede<br />
Support/Feedback<br />
tayojet@gmail.com<br />
+234 706 331 0858<br />
www.developmentdiaries.com