17.02.2017 Views

pieghevole

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR FORENSIC PSYCHOTHERAPY<br />

ANNUAL CONFERENCE<br />

RAGE<br />

AND<br />

MOURNING<br />

MAY 25 | 28 2017<br />

Catania | Aula Magna - Palazzo Univesità<br />

Catania | Benedictine Monastery<br />

SCIENTIFIC PROGRAM<br />

con il patrocinio di


SCIENTIFIC COMMETEE<br />

RICHARD CUREN<br />

RONALD DOCTOR<br />

REENA KAPOOR<br />

TILMAN KLUTTIG<br />

LESLIE LOTHSTEIN<br />

CATERINA MARCHETTI<br />

DAVID MILLER<br />

ELENA MUNDICI<br />

KATYA ORRELL<br />

FRANCESCO SPADARO<br />

ESTELA WELLDON<br />

LOCAL ORGANIZERS<br />

FEDERICA GUAGLIARDO<br />

FRANCESCO SPADARO


INDEX<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING............................................................... pag. 4<br />

ATTENDEES............................................................................... pag. 5<br />

IAFP INFORMATION................................................................... pag. 6<br />

IAFP PRESIDENT'S WELCOME..................................................... pag. 7<br />

IAFP BOARD MEMBERS.............................................................. pag. 8<br />

GILL MCGAULEY AWARD............................................................. pag. 10<br />

IAFP PAST CONFERENCE............................................................. pag. 13<br />

IAFP ONE-DAY SEMINARS........................................................... pag. 14<br />

MAIN TOPICS............................................................................ pag. 16<br />

KEYNOTE SPEAKERS.................................................................. pag. 17<br />

SPEAKERS................................................................................ pag. 18<br />

CHAIRS.................................................................................... pag. 19<br />

GENERAL INFORMATION............................................................. pag. 20<br />

INFORMATION FOR PRESENTERS................................................ pag. 21<br />

BENEDECTINE MONASTERY........................................................ pag. 22<br />

SCIENTIFIC PROGRAM............................................................... pag. 27<br />

ABSTRACTS.............................................................................. pag. 35<br />

PARALLEL SESSION................................................................... pag. 45


RAGE AND MOURNING<br />

Rage and Mourning are powerful affects that deeply disturb the human<br />

soul and interrupt the course of our existence. They are difficult to manage,<br />

to contain, to elaborate, and to overcome. They often underlie the<br />

principal suffering that human beings experience or inflict on others at<br />

an individual, group, or societal level.<br />

These affects are interconnected, and this interconnection is at the<br />

source of serious psychopathologies, as well as violent uncontrolled<br />

and/or uncontrollable acts. The Conference aim is to investigate the<br />

presence of these psychopathological and deviant behaviours, to try to<br />

understand their origin, to consider how to handle them, and to identify<br />

possible ways to prevent them.<br />

For the ancients, it was impossible to avoid rage and mourning (and<br />

their consequences) even for the Gods: Greek tragedies always deal<br />

with these issues. They were and are still performed in Syracuse, which<br />

is close to Catania, and we invite you to join us in a unique opportunity<br />

to elaborate on and experience, at a cultural and emotional level, the<br />

wealth of topics we will discuss at the Conference panels.<br />

4


ATTENDEES<br />

The 26 th IAFP Conference is an international scientific event focused<br />

on bringing together clinicians and also any professional or volunteer<br />

that works and/or collaborates in the forensic field, such as in the<br />

forensic academic world. We anticipate attendees coming from many<br />

different countries of the world, including psychiatrists, psychotherapists<br />

(group, individual and art therapists), psychologists, trainees, social<br />

workers. But also lawyers, judges and nurses interested in this area<br />

and in the issue and in the topics of the Conference.<br />

5


IAFP INFORMATION<br />

WHO WE ARE<br />

The International Association for Forensic Psychotherapy (IAFP) exists to<br />

promote the health of offenders and victims through the use of psychotherapeutic<br />

understanding, risk assessment and treatment techniques and to<br />

advance understanding about forensic psychotherapeutic practice. The International<br />

Association for Forensic Psychotherapy was formed in June 1991<br />

in Leuven, Belgium at a meeting held during the 17th International Congress<br />

on Law and Mental Health.<br />

The formation of the IAFP was based upon the true roots of psychoanalytic<br />

psychotherapy with offenders, which started at the Portman Clinic in London<br />

with its foundation over 70 years ago.<br />

The first President of the IAFP, Estela Welldon, and her colleagues were a<br />

small group of European psychiatrists trained in analytic psychotherapy and<br />

working within forensic settings. They decided to meet regularly to discuss<br />

the difficulties encountered daily in their work in terms of the treatment of<br />

patients, policy making and working with colleagues from other disciplines.<br />

The organisation grew from this small body into an international society<br />

with members from all disciplines.<br />

The IAFP has held 21 international conferences to date.<br />

MEMBERSHIP<br />

Membership of the Association will be open to any person over the age of<br />

18 interested in furthering the work of the Association and is available by<br />

annual subscription to the IAFP at the subscription rate fixed at the business<br />

meeting and thereafter fixed by resolution carried at each Annual General<br />

Meeting or Special General Meeting. Membership will lapse if the annual<br />

subscription is not maintained.<br />

The Association reserves the right to remove from membership any individual<br />

who may be deemed by the Executive Board of the Association to have<br />

brought the work of the Association into disrepute.<br />

www.forensicpsychotherapy.com<br />

6


IAFP PRESIDENT'S WELCOME<br />

Over 26 years of hosting conferences, the IAFP<br />

has earned a reputation for holding unique, intimate<br />

events in spectacular locations around the<br />

world. This year's conference in beautiful Catania<br />

certainly lives up to that reputation. Approximately<br />

40 presenters, from psychotherapists to<br />

literary scholars and legal experts, will spend two<br />

days exploring the theme of "Rage and Mourning"<br />

in the forensic context, placing particular<br />

emphasis on a psychodynamic understanding of<br />

these complex processes. As IAFP President, I am proud of our organization's<br />

long-standing commitment to preserving the role of psychodynamic expertise<br />

in forensic settings.<br />

The 2017 conference offers an important opportunity for clinicians, scholars,<br />

and service users to examine the often-overlooked interplay between grief<br />

and violence, with the ultimate goal of improving both our understanding<br />

and our therapeutic technique.<br />

On a personal note, I should also say that many Americans, myself included,<br />

have learned more about rage and mourning since our 2016 presidential<br />

election than we cared to know.<br />

We are mourning the loss of our first African-American president, and on<br />

many days it feels as though we are also mourning the loss of important ideals:<br />

multiculturalism, tolerance, and equality. We are filled with rage, but we<br />

are also told that our ignorance of other (poor, white) Americans' rage is<br />

responsible for the election of our new president. Our emotions are difficult<br />

to contain and even more difficult to sort through. I know that many others<br />

around the world - in Britain, France, and elsewhere - are struggling with<br />

similar dilemmas in this uncertain political context.<br />

Although a long road lies ahead, I am so grateful for the opportunity to gather<br />

with an international community of peers - even if just for a few days - to<br />

commiserate and face the challenges of our complicated world together.<br />

Thank you for participating in the 2017 conference, and welcome to the IAFP!<br />

Reena Kapoor, MD<br />

7


IAFP BOARD MEMBERS<br />

ESTELA WELLDON<br />

HONORARY LIFE PRESIDENT<br />

REENA KAPOOR<br />

PRESIDENT<br />

CARINE MINNE<br />

VICE PRESIDENT<br />

RICHARD CUREN<br />

TREASURER<br />

COLIN CAMPBELL<br />

SECRETARY<br />

FRANCESCO SPADARO<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

LOCAL ORGANIZER<br />

GWEN ADSHEAD<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

RONALD DOCTOR<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

ANGELA FOSTER<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

8


IAFP BOARD MEMBERS<br />

GABRIEL KIRCHUK<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

TILMAN KLUTTIG<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

LESLIE LOTHSTEIN<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

CATERINA MARCHETTI<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

DAVID MILLAR<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

ELENA MUNDICI<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

KATYA ORRELL<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

EMMA WENT<br />

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL<br />

BARBARA JACOBS<br />

ADMINISTRATOR AND<br />

COMMUNICATIONS<br />

ASSISTANT TO THE IAFP BOARD<br />

9


GILL MCGAULEY AWARD OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION<br />

FOR FORENSIC PSYCHOTHERAPY FOR YOUNG PROFESSIONALS<br />

IN FORENSIC PSYCHOTHERAPY<br />

This award granted by the International Association<br />

for Forensic Psychotherapy should<br />

encourage newcomers and trainees from all<br />

forensic professional disciplines to present at<br />

IAFP conferences and recognize outstanding<br />

scholarly contributions to the field of forensic<br />

psychotherapy.<br />

The award is granted by the IAFP in memory<br />

of our friend and colleague, Professor Gill<br />

McGauley, former secretary and past president of the International<br />

Association for Forensic Psychotherapy, who died unexpectedly on<br />

the 14th July 2016. Gill’s contribution to forensic psychotherapy and<br />

to our association is unique. She was the first Professor of Forensic<br />

Psychotherapy and Medical Education and Head of the Center for Clinical<br />

Education at St George’s University of London and a Consultant<br />

in Forensic Psychotherapy in Central and North West London Foundation<br />

NHS Trust (CNWL).<br />

She developed psychotherapy services for women in prison (HMP<br />

Holloway and YOI Bronzefield) and worked in the High Secure Hospital<br />

Broadmoor where she established the first forensic psychotherapy<br />

service in a high secure hospital. Gill has developed forensic<br />

psychotherapy through teaching, scholarship and research. In 2009<br />

she was awarded a National Teaching Fellowship by The Higher Education<br />

Academy for excellence in teaching.<br />

She gave an outstanding contribution to the research on the application<br />

of Attachment Theory and the development of Mentalization Based<br />

Treatment (MBT) for personality disordered offender patients.<br />

10


STATUTES OF THE GILL MCGAULEY AWARD<br />

PROCEEDINGS AND CONDITIONS:<br />

1. The award shall be granted once per year.<br />

2. Eligibility criteria for the award include:<br />

a. First-time presenters at an IAFP conference; or<br />

b. Presenters who are still in training; or<br />

c. Self-described newcomers in the field of forensic psychotherapy<br />

3. Candidates will be asked about their eligibility and interest in being considered<br />

for the award when submitting a conference abstract.<br />

In addition, candidates can be nominated by the scientificcommittee on the<br />

basis of their abstracts.<br />

4. The award will be open to candidates from every profession.<br />

5. If a presentation is given by more than one individual, the first author of the<br />

abstract will be presented with the award. The content of the presentations may<br />

be research work, theoretical contributions, reports on innovative practice,<br />

or case reports with a relevant link to therapeuticmethods and/or theory.<br />

JURY:<br />

1. A committee will attend the presentations and assess their quality, their scientific<br />

and/or clinical relevance and the quality and originality of the presentation.<br />

2. The award committee will be three persons – a member from the local scientific<br />

committee, a member from the board of IAFP, and (given that this will develop)<br />

the editor of the Journal for Forensic Psychotherapy or the board member<br />

responsible for the one-day seminars.<br />

3. The committee decides unanimously or by a majority on the award winner.<br />

The decision of the committee is final and not subject to legal recourse.<br />

THE AWARD MAY INCLUDE EITHER FOR SINGLE AUTHORS:<br />

1. A one year free membership to IAFP<br />

2. Participation at the next IAFP conference<br />

(IAFP will cover the conference feeonly).<br />

3. Support for the publication of a paper based on the presentation by a prominent<br />

tutorship through IAFP members. The family of Professor Gill Mc Gauley, Tim,<br />

Sarah and Jessica Hucker will be informed each year by the president of IAFP<br />

who has been given the award.<br />

11


IAFP PAST CONFERENCE<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2016 (GENT)<br />

Families: how to survive them - or not…<br />

An analysis of the dangerous family<br />

and societal response<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2015 (YALE)<br />

Recovering from Violence.<br />

Victims, Perpetrators and Communities<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2014 (UTRECHT)<br />

Understanding Justifications and<br />

Excuses for Criminal Behavior<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2013 (KONSTANZ)<br />

Forensic Psychotherapy in the<br />

Community - Between Inclusion<br />

and Exclusion<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2012 (VENICE)<br />

Corruption, Deception and<br />

Collusion – Attacks on the Mind<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2011 (EDINBURGH)<br />

Murder In Mind<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2010 (OXFORD)<br />

Tales of Transgression<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2009 (KONSTANZ)<br />

Ruptures and Relations – Group<br />

Dynamics and Forensic<br />

Psychotherapy<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2008 (VENICE)<br />

Security and Terror: A State of Mind<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2007 (OXFORD)<br />

Hope and Hate – Working With<br />

the Forensic Patient<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2006 (OXFORD)<br />

Revenge, Justice or Treatment.<br />

Forensic Psychotherapy and the<br />

Criminal Law<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2005 (DUBLIN)<br />

After Trauma - Within Families<br />

and Between Strangers<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2004 (EDINBURGH)<br />

Understanding Persecution<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2003 (ARNHEM)<br />

Process or Protocol?<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2002 (STUTTGART)<br />

Trauma and Delinquency<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 2000 (BOSTON)<br />

Learning from Violence<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1999 (SHEFFIELD)<br />

Forensic psychotherapy and<br />

thepublic sphere<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1998 (COPENHAGEN)<br />

Forensic Psychotherapy - Boundaries<br />

and Relations<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1997 (LONDON)<br />

Intoxification, Crime and the<br />

Forensic Patient<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1996 (ULM)<br />

Freedom and Coercion.<br />

Forensic Psychotherapy under Scrutiny<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1995 (GLASGOW)<br />

Violence and Death<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1994 (THE HAGUE)<br />

Personality Disorders.<br />

The Challenge for Forensic Psychotherapy<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1993 (LONDON)<br />

Psychodynamics and the<br />

Adolescent and Female Offender<br />

IAFP CONFERENCE 1992 (LONDON)<br />

Forensic Psychotherapy - Identity,<br />

Network and Future<br />

13


IAFP ONE-DAY SEMINARS 2005 - 2016<br />

05/05/2006<br />

IAFP AND HENDERSON<br />

BODILY HARM<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

07/07/2006<br />

IAFP AND ESRC<br />

FIRE STARTING AS A SYMPTOM<br />

OF PERSONALITY DISORDER<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

25/01/2008<br />

IAFP AND CO<br />

THE THERAPEUTIC MILIEU<br />

UNDER FIRE: ATTACHMENT,<br />

ATTRITION AND REGENERATION<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

17/09/2010<br />

IAFP AND MILLFIELDS<br />

ON BEING HATED BY THE PATIENT:<br />

THE MEANING OF AND RESPONSES<br />

TO RUPTURES IN THE<br />

THERAPEUTIC ALLIANCE<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

21/05/2010<br />

IAFP AND BROADMOOR<br />

"BRUTAL CULTURES":<br />

BULLYING AND SCAPEGOATING<br />

IN FORENSIC SETTINGS<br />

CROWTHORNE, UK<br />

11/02/2011<br />

IAFP AND RESPOND<br />

STRANGE FASCINATION: DISABILITY<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPY IN FORENSIC<br />

SETTINGS<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

21/10/2011<br />

IAFP AND CO<br />

DESTRUCTIVE THINKING AND<br />

THINKING ABOUT DESTRUCTIVENESS:<br />

THEORY-PRACTICE GAPS IN<br />

PSYCHO-SOCIAL STUDIES,<br />

CRIMINOLOGY AND FORENSIC<br />

MENTAL HEALTH<br />

PRESTON, UK<br />

25/05/2012<br />

IAFP AND SCOTTISH PD<br />

NETWORK AND NHS SCOTLAND<br />

TREATMENT OF PERSONALITY<br />

DISORDER IN FORENSIC SETTINGS<br />

STIRLING, UK<br />

01/05/2013<br />

IAFP AND NOTTINGHAM<br />

SHIRE HEALTHCARE<br />

EVIDENCE FOR THE ARTS<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPIES IN FORENSIC<br />

PRACTICEIN PRACTICE: SETTING<br />

TARGETS OR BEING TARGETED?<br />

RAMPTON, UK<br />

24/05/2013<br />

IAFP<br />

CRIME IN MIND CRIME IN ACTION<br />

CATANIA, ITALY<br />

07/06/2013<br />

IAFP TREATING EVILPHILOSOPHICAL,<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC AND<br />

LEGAL PERSPECTIVES<br />

TREATING EVILPHILOSOPHICAL,<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC AND LEGAL<br />

PERSPECTIVES<br />

OXFORD, UK<br />

14


06/12/2013<br />

IAFP AND TFP INSTITUTES MÜNCHEN<br />

IN KOOPERATION MIT DER<br />

DAS STATIONÄRE SETTING IN DER<br />

FORENSISCHEN PSYCHOTHERAPIE<br />

MUNICH, GERMANY<br />

05/12/2014<br />

AFP AND TFPINSTITUTES MÜNCHEN<br />

IN KOOPERATION MIT DER<br />

PERVERSION UND PÄDOPHILIE<br />

IN DER FORENSISCHEN<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPIE<br />

STIRLING, UK<br />

17/10/2015<br />

IAFP AND CONFER<br />

WHY ARE WE MURDEROUS?<br />

THE PSYCHODYNAMIC TREATMENT<br />

OF THE FORENSIC PATIENT<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

28/11/2015<br />

AFP AND MEDIA AND THE INNER<br />

WORLD NETWORK, UNIVERSITY<br />

OF ROEHAMPTON AND<br />

UNIVERSITY OF BOURNEMOUTH<br />

BOX SET, MIND SET’ THE FORENSICS<br />

OF POPULAR CULTURE<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

11/12/2015<br />

IAFP<br />

MOTHER IN MIND; IMPROVING<br />

SERVICES FOR MOTHERS<br />

WITH COMPLEX MENTAL<br />

HEALTH NEEDS<br />

OXFORD, UK<br />

04/12/2015<br />

IAFP AND TFPINSTITUTES<br />

MÜNCHEN IN KOOPERATION<br />

MIT DER<br />

MALIGNER NARZISSMUS<br />

ANTISOZIALE<br />

PERSÖNLICHKEITSSTÖRUNG<br />

PSYCHOPATHIE PSYCHODYNAMIK<br />

UND BEHANDLUNGSTECHNIK<br />

MUNICH, GERMANY<br />

12/03/2016<br />

IAFP AND CONFER<br />

UNRAVELLING PSYCHOPATHY:<br />

PSYCHODYNAMIC<br />

PERSPECTIVES ON<br />

WORKING WITH<br />

PERSONALITY DISORDERS<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

01/10/2016<br />

IAFP AND CONFER<br />

PSYCHODYNAMIC<br />

PERSPECTIVES ON SEXUAL<br />

PERVERSIONS<br />

LONDON, UK<br />

07/10/2017<br />

IAFP AND SIPFO<br />

IAFP AND SIPFO<br />

CATANIA, ITALY<br />

09/12/2016<br />

IAFP<br />

CREATING CONTAINMENT:<br />

WORKING THERAPEUTICALLY<br />

WITH PARENTS IN CRISIS<br />

OXFORD, UK<br />

15


MAIN TOPICS<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING IN FAMILY AND GENDER DYNAMICS<br />

ACTS OF RAGE AGAINST SOCIETY BY INDIVIDUAL<br />

AND BY GROUPS<br />

THE DARK WEB: CYBERBULLYING AND OTHER FORMS OF<br />

ONLINE VIOLENCE<br />

VIOLENCE BY CAREGIVERS AGAINST VULNERABLE PEOPLE:<br />

CHILDREN, THE ELDERLY, AND INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES<br />

SEARCHING FOR RELIEF THROUGH DRUG USE<br />

THE MATTE BLANCO AND BI - LOGIC BASED PERSPECTIVE ON<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING<br />

PERVERSION, RAGE, AND MOURNING<br />

THERAPEUTIC PERSPECTIVES: INDIVIDUAL, GROUP, AND<br />

SOCIAL THERAPIES FOR GRIEF AND RAGE<br />

DEALING WITH RAGE AND MOURNING IN THE COURT<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING IN CHILDHOOD AND ADOLESCENCE<br />

THE HUMAN BEING IN THE GREEK TRAGEDIES: FATE,<br />

FAMILY INHERITANCE, PASSIONS AND WILL<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING: THE DANGEROUS LIASON<br />

16


KEYNOTE SPEAKERS<br />

VINCENZO CARETTI (ROME)<br />

SALVATORE CASTORINA (CATANIA)<br />

JAMES GILLIGAN (USA)<br />

REENA KAPOOR (YALE)<br />

GIUSEPPINA MENDORLA (CATANIA)<br />

CARINE MINNE (LONDON)<br />

KONSTANTIN NEMIROVSKY (MOSCOW)<br />

ADRIANO SCHIMMENTI (ENNA)<br />

FRANCESCO SPADARO (CATANIA)<br />

GIUSEPPE SPECIALE (CATANIA)<br />

17


SPEAKERS AND CO-AUTHORS<br />

AGNESE ALBERIO<br />

EMMA ALLEN<br />

STELLA DICKINSON COMPTON<br />

ANGELO COSTANZO<br />

TAMSIN COTTIS<br />

RICHARD CUREN<br />

GIULIA CUSUMANO<br />

ROBERTA DESIDERIO<br />

RONALD DOCTOR<br />

FRANK FARNHAM<br />

MARKUS G. FEIL<br />

LISA FIRESTONE<br />

ANGELA FOSTER<br />

VINCENZINA FRAGASSO<br />

JONATHAN GARABETTE<br />

LISA GARDINER<br />

SANDRA GRANT<br />

MARY HAMER<br />

ROSA INGIULLA<br />

MANZA KAMAL<br />

PAM KLEINOT<br />

FRANS KOENRAADT<br />

KAREL'T LAM<br />

RAVI LINGAM<br />

LESLIE LOTHSTEIN<br />

ALEX MAGUIRE<br />

CATERINA MARCHETTI<br />

DAVID MILLAR<br />

CARINE MINNE<br />

CHRISTINE MONTROSS<br />

ELENA MUNDICI<br />

KATYA ORRELL<br />

FOTEINI PAPOULI<br />

ANDREW PERRY<br />

ARIANNA PULSONI<br />

SIMONA RAMELLA PAIA<br />

MOUSTAFA SAOUD<br />

SANDRA SCOTT<br />

IOANNIS SFYRAKIS<br />

CHRISTOS SIDERAS<br />

PENNY STOPFORTH<br />

CELIA TAYLOR<br />

JAN VAN DER LEEUW<br />

RACHEL WOODWARD<br />

GERALD WOOSTER<br />

NADYA WYNCHANK<br />

MANFREDI ZAMMATARO<br />

18


CHAIRS<br />

GWEN ADSHEAD<br />

COLIN CAMPBELL<br />

FELICE CARABELLESE<br />

RICHARD CUREN<br />

RONALD DOCTOR<br />

ANGELA FOSTER<br />

REENA KAPOOR<br />

PAM KLEINOT<br />

TILMAN KLUTTING<br />

FRANS KOENRAADT<br />

LESLIE LOTHSTEIN<br />

DAVID MILLAR<br />

CARINE MINNE<br />

ELENA MUNDICI<br />

KATYA ORREL<br />

JOHN SCHLAPOBERSKY<br />

FRANCESCO SPADARO<br />

ESTELA WELLDON<br />

EMMA WENT<br />

19


GENERAL INFORMATION<br />

ONSITE REGISTRATION DESK<br />

Thursday May 25 th , 19.00-20:00 (terrazza Museo Diocesano)<br />

Friday May 26 th , 07.50-08:20 (Aula Magna - Palazzo Università)<br />

NAME BADGES<br />

All participants must wear their name badges during the meeting.<br />

Badges allow admission to all sessions, breaks, lunches, receptions and the banquet.<br />

ACCOMPANYING PERSONS<br />

Accompanying persons are not allowed to attend the Scientific Sessions and the<br />

Exhibition area. There is no registration fees for accompanying persons. However they are<br />

required to purchase tickets to tour events: https://form.jotform.com/63352357979975,<br />

and social dinner: https://form.jotform.com/63351685462965<br />

WELCOME RECEPTION<br />

The welcome reception will be held on Thursday May 25 th at 20.00<br />

(terrazza Museo Diocesano)<br />

IAFP GENERAL MEETING<br />

The IAFP general meeting will be held on Saturday May 27 th from 13.15 to 14.15.<br />

All IAFP members are encouraged to attend.<br />

IAFP GALA DINNER<br />

The IAFP gala dinner will be held on Saturday May 27 th from 21.00 at "Palazzo Biscari".<br />

Partecipants are required to purchase tickets: https://form.jotform.com/63351685462965<br />

CLOTHING<br />

Clothing in business casual for all occasion.<br />

LIABILITY AND PERSONAL INSURANCE<br />

The IAFP 2017 organizers can not accept liability for personal accidents or loss of or<br />

damage to private property of participants and accompanying persons.<br />

SAFETY AND SECURITY<br />

We kindly request you not to leave bags, suitcases or backpacks unattended at any time<br />

during the meeting.<br />

20


INFORMATION FOR PRESENTERS<br />

LANGUAGE<br />

The official language of the IAFP 2017 Meeting is english.<br />

ORAL PRESENTATION<br />

Presenters using a powerpoint presentation should bring it on memory stick (usb) and<br />

load between 08,00-08,30 for morning sessions during the luch for afternoon sessions.<br />

Presenters with powerpoint and video are requested to check their presentation to be<br />

sure they work properly.<br />

Macintosh users must convert their files to powerpoint in order to be used on the pc,<br />

otherwise must bring their own computer and VGA adaptor.<br />

RECORDING POLICY<br />

Recording any presentation or poster is prohibited, except by IAFP agent,<br />

or by authors.<br />

21


HISTORY<br />

THE VENUE:<br />

BENEDICTINE MONASTERY<br />

The Benedictine Monastery of Catania is a jewel of the late Sicilian Baroque.<br />

A Cassinese congregation founded the complex in 1558.<br />

The original structure was modified by two natural calamities the lava eruption<br />

of 1669 and the earthquake of 1693. It was destroyed and re-built and it<br />

is now an example of the integration of different historical periods. Visiting it,<br />

you can see the changes due to the lava eruption and the earthquake, but also<br />

to the civil uses to which it was destined after the Italian Unification.<br />

The first Monastery had a square floor plan with a cloister in the middle,<br />

called the “marble cloister” (renamed Western cloister) because of the presence<br />

of a refined colonnade from the XVIII century and a four-leaved clover<br />

shaped fountain in the middle with elegant decorations typical of the Renaissance<br />

period both made with precious marble from Carrara.<br />

The lava eruption of 1669 and the catastrophic earthquake of 1693 marked<br />

the destiny of Catania during the XVII century. On March 8, 1669 the Volcano<br />

Etna exploded, at the end of April, the lava flow reached the city walls, the


monastery was saved, but not the Church attached to it, which was completely<br />

destroyed by the lava, leaving behind a lunar landscape.<br />

Eighteen years after the eruption, in 1687, the reconstruction of the Church<br />

started, probably based on a project of the roman architect Contini.<br />

In the night between the 10th and 11th of January of 1693 the city of Catania<br />

was shacked. The earthquake of 1693 was one of the most devastating catastrophes<br />

in Eastern Sicily. According to researchers, the earthquake reached<br />

a magnitude of 7,7 degrees on the Richter scale. The day after the earthquake,<br />

the city was destroyed and most of the citizens were buried under the ruins.<br />

The basement and part of the first floor of the Monastery , were still safe.<br />

Only 14 columns of the cloister were still standing, the others were destroyed.<br />

In 1702, nine years after the earthquake, the reconstruction of the monastery<br />

started. On top of the lava ‘wall’, were built two gardens: the botanical garden<br />

– the wonders garden – and the novices’ garden.<br />

The church of San Nicolò l’Arena was conceived as a small Sicilian Saint Peter,<br />

but its facade remained unfinished. Extended and enriched with decorations,<br />

the monastery became one of the biggest in Europe, following the other<br />

Benedictine Monastery of Mafra in Portugal.<br />

Various famous Sicilian architects took part in the reconstruction: Ittar, Battaglia,<br />

Battaglia Santangelo, and Palazzotto. Craftsmen came from various Sicilian<br />

towns: Palermo, Messina, Siracusa. Giovan Battista Vaccarini.<br />

In 1866, the state confiscated the Benedictine Monastery, which passed under<br />

the state’s property. From 1868, the monastery was re-used for civil scopes.


There were mostly schools, but also a barrack and the Astrophysics laboratory<br />

with the laboratory of meteorology and geodynamics. These new uses caused<br />

a deep and, sometimes, irreversible change of the monastery structure.<br />

Most of the frescos were cancelled, the corridors were divided, and other divisions<br />

added to create offices, training rooms, and toilets.<br />

In 1977, within a project of regeneration of the historical centre of the town,<br />

the Municipality donated the Monastery to the University of Catania that<br />

used it for the Faculty of Humanities. The architect Giancarlo De Carlo supervised<br />

the restoration works that brought to the recognition of the value of<br />

the monastery as an example of Contemporary Architecture from the Sicilian<br />

Regional Government.<br />

In 2002, UNESCO included the monastery, together with other sites representative<br />

of the late Baroque of South-Eastern Sicily, in the World Heritage<br />

List.The restoration of the Monastery lasted thirty years and has led to the discovery<br />

of the history of the town from the Roman period to the present day.<br />

An entire Roman neighbourhood with the two main axes the Cardum and<br />

the Decumanus Maximus, houses of the late Hellenistic and imperial time<br />

has been found under the monastery.<br />

It is possible to see the remains in the main court and under what used to be<br />

the stables of the monastery (where now are the classrooms of the faculty).<br />

In particular, a domus (Roman house) with its peristilio (court) is still visible<br />

within the university library, perfectly integrated in the structure of the<br />

16th century monastery and in the contemporary ‘hanging’ structures that<br />

allow students to access and use this space.<br />

Using architect De Carlo words, today the monastery, “with its real structure,<br />

of a three-dimensional space, has character of a place where young people<br />

move from one point to the other: a place full of air, light, communication,<br />

expectations and promises.<br />

Through different readings of the place and tentative projects the old meanings<br />

have been substituted by a new one that allows the old architecture to get<br />

a new structure, and an important role for the contemporary world”.


SCIENTIFIC<br />

PROGRAM<br />

27


MAY 25 th<br />

TERRAZZA MUSEO DIOCESANO<br />

19:15-19:30 Welcome of the Major of Catania Enzo Bianco<br />

19:30-21:00 Welcome Party and Opening Ceremony<br />

by Reena Kapoor (President IAFP) and<br />

James Gilligan (Past President IAFP)<br />

MAY 26 th<br />

SCIENTIFIC PROGRAM<br />

AULA MAGNA - PALAZZO CENTRALE UNIVERSITÀ<br />

07:50-08:20 Registration<br />

08:20-08:30 Greetings<br />

Marina Paino (Head of the Department of Human Sciences)<br />

08:30-08:45 Opening and Welcome Remarks<br />

Francesco Spadaro (Catania)<br />

The Achilles Paradigm<br />

Chair: Reena Kapoor (Yale)<br />

08:45-09:30 Keynote speakers: Konstantin Nemirovsky (Moscow)<br />

Silence is violence: social and personal consequences<br />

of psychic trauma and it’s working-through<br />

09:30-10:15 Keynote speakers: Carine Minne (London)<br />

Rage, not Mourning: A child's loss becomes a young<br />

man's violence<br />

10:15-10:40 Discussion<br />

10:40-11:00 Coffee Break<br />

11:00-13:00 Parallel Session: The Clinical Field (1)<br />

13:00-14:00 Lunch<br />

13:30-14:00 A possibility: paid tour of the Benedictine Monastery<br />

“Archaeological Tour”<br />

14:00-16:00 Parallel Session: Family, Groups and Society<br />

16:00-17:00 Large Group<br />

Group Conductor: John Schlapobersky (London)<br />

17:15 Transfer for the paid tour to the Greek Theatre of Syracuse<br />

to assist to the Greek tragedy “The Seven againt Thebes”


MAY 27 th<br />

BENEDICTINE MONASTERY AUDITORIUM DE CARLO<br />

Chair: Estela Welldon (London)<br />

08:30-09:15 Keynote speakers: Salvatore Castorina and<br />

Giuseppina Mendorla (Catania)<br />

Tiresia, an interpeter of violence: about the violation of<br />

borders and the desolation of the word<br />

09:15-10:00 Keynote speakers: Giuseppe Speciale (Catania)<br />

But one can't live with hate. I know that.<br />

We have to forget if we are to go on living.<br />

The rage and mourning of the winners and the losers<br />

10:00-10:15 Discussion<br />

10:15-10:30 Coffee Break<br />

10:30-12:30 Parallel Session: The Clinical Field (2)<br />

12:30-13:15 Lunch<br />

12:45-13:15 A possibility: paid tour of the Benedictine Monastery<br />

“Eighteenth-Century Tour”<br />

13:15-14:15 Annual General Meeting IAFP<br />

Chair: Reena Kapoor (New Haven)<br />

Chair: Felice Carabellese (Bari)<br />

14:15-15:00 Keynote speakers:Vincenzo Caretti (Roma)<br />

and Adriano Schimmenti (Enna)<br />

Trauma and Psychopathy<br />

15:00-15:15 Discussion<br />

15:15-17:15 Parallel Session: Organizations and Institutions<br />

17:15-17:30 Coffee Break<br />

17:30-19:00 Large Group<br />

Group Conductor: John Schlapobersky (London)<br />

19:00-19:30 Closing Ceremony and Gill McGauley Award<br />

21:00 Gala Dinner at "Palazzo Biscari"<br />

SOCIAL EVENTS<br />

MAY 28 th<br />

09:00 Transfer for the paid tour “Visiting Etna”<br />

26 May<br />

Seven Against Thebes<br />

Greek theatre of Syracuse


PARALLEL SESSION<br />

MAY 26 th<br />

AULA MAGNA - PALAZZO CENTRALE UNIVERSITÀ<br />

11:00-13:00 Parallel Session: The Clinical Field (1)<br />

Personality disorders (Room 1) Chair: Felice Carabellese<br />

Celia Taylor:<br />

Creative processes in forensic psychotherapy and psychiatry: high-risk offenders<br />

with personality disorder<br />

Ravi Lingam, Rachel Woodward, Foteini Papouli:<br />

Pragmatic and Systemic Management and Containment of Interpersonal<br />

Aggression in Complex Personality Disorders<br />

Clinical experiences (Room 2) Chair: Ronald Doctor<br />

Jonathan Garabette, Carine Minne:<br />

Resurrecting the dead –Psychosis, Rage and Mourning in Pseudopsychopathic<br />

Schizophrenia<br />

Elena Mundici, Katya Orrell:<br />

Terror and wonder: Whose choice is it anyway?<br />

Children and violence (Room 3) Chair: Reena Kapoor<br />

Nadya E. J. N. Wynchank, Penny Stopforth:<br />

Under-age, under-rage: an exploration of South African children who commit<br />

sexual violence<br />

Arianna Pulsoni:<br />

The cathartic process in therapy:From the Cave to Earth<br />

The human soul: light and darkness (Room 4) Chair: Elena Mundici<br />

J. David Millar:<br />

Grief to rage: from darkness into darkness<br />

Alex Maguire:<br />

Carlo Gesualdo: music, murder and mourning in Renaissance Italy


14:00-16:00 Parallel Sessions: Family, Groups and Society<br />

The cultural approach (Room 1) Chair: Colin Campbell<br />

Christine Montross:<br />

The Rage of Isolation: Aggression and Self-Injury in Solitary Confinement<br />

Mary Hamer:<br />

Rage and mourning in Euripides’ Medea<br />

Rage and mourning: group therapy (Room 2) Chair: Angela Foster<br />

Leslie M. Lothstein:<br />

Mourning and Rage in a Long Term Psychodynamic Outpatient Group of<br />

Male Sex Offenders<br />

Vincenzina Fragasso, Simona Ramella Paia:<br />

The Psychoeducational group for abusive men as a way to interrupt the cycle of<br />

violence and his social return of impact (SROI)<br />

Destructiveness, individuals and institutions (Room 3) Chair: Frans Koenraadt<br />

Caterina Marchetti:<br />

A psychoanalytic psychotherapy group with women criminals in a Northern<br />

Italian Prison<br />

Moustafa Saoud:<br />

Rage, Narcissism and the Search for Mourning at the Extremes of Age<br />

Sandra Scott, Manza Kamal:<br />

IDC on a patient<br />

Rage and mourning: the creative arts therapies (Room 4) Chair: Pam Kleinot<br />

Stella Compton Dickinson:<br />

Journey's End: Rage or Reconciliation<br />

Andrew Perry:<br />

Permission to come alongside?<br />

Personality and family (Room 5) Chair: Richard Curen<br />

Markus G. Feil:<br />

Personality organization as major responsivity factor<br />

Ronald Doctor,<br />

Rage and Mourning in family and gender dynamics: fate, passion and will


MAY 27 th<br />

BENEDICTIN MONASTRY AUDITORIUM DE CARLO<br />

10:30-12:30 Parallel Session: The Clinical Field (2)<br />

The dark web (Room 1) Chair: Emma Went<br />

Foteini Papouli, Ioannis Sfyrakis, Ravi Lingam:<br />

The Dark Web: The hideout of the identity<br />

Giulia Cusumano, Rosa Ingiulla, Roberta Desiderio, Agnese Alberio:<br />

Bullying and cyberbullying in Sicilian adolescents<br />

Jealousy (Room2) Chair: Tilman Kluttig<br />

Karel‘t Lam:<br />

A case of attempted rapes and sexual stalking: Forensic psychotherapeutic<br />

reflections on jealousy in perversions<br />

Frans Koenraadt:<br />

Jealousy penetrating into the family domain: Considerations from forensic<br />

mental health assessment and research<br />

Jan van der Leeuw:<br />

The presence and absence of jealousy in two cases in relationship to rage<br />

Learning disabilities (Room 3) Chair: Katya Orrell<br />

A Special Session Dedicated To The Memory Of Dr. Alan Corbett<br />

Tamsin Cottis:<br />

You Don’t Give A Shit About Me!: Rejection, Rage and the Growth of Love<br />

Richard Curen:<br />

“I spit on your grave”: a psychodynamic perspective on intellectual<br />

disability, rage, mourning and sado-masochistic states of mind<br />

The bi-logic thinking: the Matte-Blanco perspective (Room 4)<br />

Chair: Francesco Spadaro<br />

Christos Sideras, Gerald Wooster:<br />

Emotions and infinity: The contributions of Ignacio Matte Blanco to<br />

understanding emotions<br />

Angelo Costanzo:<br />

Bi-logic and Argumentation<br />

15:15-17:15 Parallel Session: Organizations And Institutions<br />

Terrorism and mafia (Room 1) Chair: Carine Minne<br />

Pam Kleinot and Sandra Grant:<br />

Terrorism: rage and longing<br />

Manfredi Zammataro, Giulia Cusumano:<br />

Mafia: psychological functioning between traditional business and<br />

new opportunities<br />

32


Rage and mourning dynamics in the institutions and<br />

organizations (1) (Room 2) Chair: Leslie Lothstein<br />

Angela Foster:<br />

Staff accused and abused; Managing pain and distress in the system of care<br />

Lisa Gardiner:<br />

Forensic Hospitals and Pathological Organizations:<br />

destructive narcissism in the internal world and in the social defence system<br />

Long term segregation (Room 3) Chair: Gwen Adshead<br />

Katya Orrell, Elena Mundici:<br />

Swansong: Can hope survive an indeterminate prison sentence?<br />

Emma Allen:<br />

The Boy Who Cried Wolf: A Collaborative Approach to Long Term Segregation


ABSTRACTS<br />

35


Francesco Spadaro<br />

Psichiatrist, Psychoanalytic Psychotherapist.<br />

President of the Italian Society of Forensic Psychoterapy (SIPFO) and Board Member IAFP and EFPP.<br />

Department of Mental Healt, Catania<br />

THE ACHILLES PARADIGM<br />

“Muse, sing the rage of Peleus’s son Akhilleus, deadly rage that brought the<br />

Akhaians endless pain, that hurled down to Hades many strong souls of heroes<br />

and made their bodies meat for dogs and vultures […]” (Homer, Iliad). Thus<br />

begins Homer’s Iliad, in the recent translation of Richard Whitaker in South African<br />

English. But The Iliad, an epic poem that is the first masterpiece of Western<br />

Literature, is not only about the rage of Achilles, but also about his mourning. His<br />

rage due to the Briseide abduction and his mourning for the death of his beloved<br />

friend Patroclus. Neither the mass killings of his enemies that he perpetrates, nor<br />

their humiliations, nor the killing of Hector, the one who had killed Patroclus<br />

relieved his fury or his grief. To help him overcome his rage and mourning is a<br />

dream. A dream in which his dead, and already avenged, friend Patroclus talks to<br />

him and asks to be finally buried. Otherwise, he wouldn't be able to reach Hades.<br />

At the same time, predicting the future death of Achilles, Patroclus asks him to<br />

put both of them in the same cinerary urn, in order to be hugged for eternity.<br />

The Iliad, is, of course, a poem full of tragedy and in this sense it is a precursor of<br />

the Greek Tragedies. But also, in more contemporary forms of art, like Cinema,<br />

for example, I am thinking of a movie that has been suggested to be used in this<br />

conference, as has been done in past ones, Truly, Madly Deeply, or the recent<br />

Manchester by the Sea, rage and mourning have been able to be overcome after<br />

and by virtue of dreams. In other forms of cultural imaginary, like painting, the<br />

creative description has the same function as dreams, such as in the art of Marc<br />

Chagall, in which pogroms and his lost Jewish childhood home world are evoked<br />

and transformed into oneiric visual tales.<br />

But Achilles dreaming of Patroclus talking to him is a precious synthesis of the<br />

elements necessary for the human being to overcome rage and mourning. I emphasize<br />

here two of them. The role and the changes of superego and the destiny of<br />

bonds. A human being is in the position of facing and overcoming his or her rage<br />

and their mourning only when they have found their solution for reestablishing a<br />

true and evident continuity between the superego and the principles that regulate<br />

the world. A continuity that had been broken by the experience of a crime or of<br />

a loss, but now means a reestablished order of his or her inner world compatible<br />

with the established order of the external world, and when they have found a<br />

personal solution to restore a lost bond.<br />

36


Konstantin Nemirovsky<br />

Moscow Psychoanalytic Society,<br />

Society for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, Russia<br />

SILENCE IS VIOLENCE: SOCIAL AND PERSONAL CONSEQUENCES OF<br />

PSYCHIC TRAUMA AND IT’S WORKING-THROUGH<br />

One-hundred years ago Freud set mourning against melancholia in the belief<br />

that endured losses lead to depression. The dramatic events that took place<br />

during the following century (wars, revolutions, rise and fall of political systems)<br />

as well as personal histories of that generation, confirmed this belief.<br />

Not only unmourned grief, but unworked-through violence leads to destruction,<br />

that enables the victim the possibility of ridding themselves of unbearable<br />

psychic pain.<br />

The solutions of this predicament are different - from identification with the<br />

aggressor, when the former victim projects his own suffering onto others and<br />

attacks them, to turning this pain against himself resulting in depression,<br />

self-injuries and suicide.<br />

These actions arise at social and personal level. For instance, conducted denazification<br />

enabled Germany to recover after the WWII and become the<br />

locomotive of EC economic development. On the contrary, uncompleted decommunization<br />

in Russia gave rise to reappearance of society authoritarian<br />

governance limiting further development of the country. The same phenomenon<br />

can be observed in the life of people facing the violence - those who<br />

come for psychotherapy would have the chance for recovery and development;<br />

those who refused/cut off of this help would be forced into a reenactment<br />

of this violence and ultimately found themselves either in jail or at six<br />

feet under.<br />

Psychic trauma is like the Lernean hydra capable of poisoning clear water<br />

just with its toxic breath. Hercules could not overcome it on his own - each<br />

time he cut its head off, new ones grew immediately up. It was only with the<br />

help of Elaeus that he could defeat the monster. Similarly, it is only consolidated<br />

efforts of different parties - psychotherapist and patient, government<br />

and citizens - that could set the victim of violence free (either individual or<br />

whole generation) from unconscious enactment of old dramas and offers the<br />

opportunity to live, thive and develop.<br />

37


Carine Minne<br />

Consultant Psychiatrist in Forensic Psychotherapy at Broadmoor Hospital, West London Mental Health<br />

Trust and the Portman Clinic, Tavistock & Portman NHS Foundation Trust, UK<br />

RAGE, NOT MOURNING: A CHILD'S LOSS BECOMES<br />

A YOUNG MAN'S VIOLENCE<br />

In this paper, I will present two patients diagnosed as suffering from severe<br />

Personality Disorders with psychotic episodes. I will illustrate the changes<br />

that can arise during the course of several years’ psychoanalytic treatment in<br />

high security hospital. Progress was monitored using the Operationalised<br />

Psychodynamic Diagnostics (OPD) system. The clinical presentations will<br />

indicate how earlier childhood losses contributed to these adolescent boys’<br />

homicidal violence. I also hope to show that it is more helpful to consider<br />

such patients as suffering from a single entity diagnosis where, at times, their<br />

mental states are more manifestly personality disordered and, at other times,<br />

more manifestly psychotic. At each end of that diagnostic spectrum, a different<br />

set of anxieties is being defended against. The psychoanalytic treatment,<br />

as one part of the overall treatment, is described to show how the secluded<br />

parts of the patients’ minds can be approached, including references to the<br />

regular regressions that arise, provoked by ‘getting better’.<br />

38


Salvatore Castorina 1 / Giuseppina Mendorla 2<br />

1<br />

Full professor of Dynamic Psychology, Department of Humanities, Catania University<br />

2<br />

Associate professor of Dynamic Psychology, at the Department of the Human Sciences, University of Catania<br />

TIRESIA, AN INTERPETER OF VIOLENCE: ABOUT THE VIOLATION OF<br />

BORDERS AND THE DESOLATION OF THE WORD<br />

In Euripedes’ The Phoenicean Women, and in the myth of the children of<br />

Oedipus, already brought to the stage by Aeschylus, there appears a new and<br />

surprising character: the seer Tiresias.<br />

He brings to light a story regarding the origins marked by the violence that<br />

breaks out within the same grouping, the same family: Cadmus, the founder<br />

of Thebes, kills the dragon, son of Ares, who therefore seeks revenge; the<br />

teeth of the dragon (the oral violence that devours), on being planted grow<br />

into giant warriors who kill each other in a fratricidal fight, almost an anticipation<br />

of the mortal duel of Oedipus’s children.<br />

Oedipus himself kills his father and curses the children, born of incest.<br />

The conclusion is predictable for Tiresias, the parricide turns into its opposite:<br />

the filicide must be repeated in the present generation (Creon must<br />

sacrifice his son Menoeceus), just as the fratricidal coaction will re-present.<br />

Where does all this violence come from? Tiresias is the protagonist of a drama<br />

described in the Yakto (Antioch, Turkey) mosaic: he himself is among<br />

the heroes (Narcissus, Adonis, Actaeon, Meleagrus), who, in the throes of<br />

Megalopsychia, a relentless feeling of omnipotence, have violated the limits<br />

set for humans and by so doing have rendered themselves similar to the gods.<br />

This shift has been made possible by the denial of limits: the denial of the loss<br />

of omnipotence.<br />

Violence, therefore, homicidal or suicidal, is the direct consequence of the incapacity<br />

or the impossibility of surpassing the persecutory vision of the world<br />

and of setting out on the painful path of the work of mourning.<br />

Tiresias is the interpreter of this drama, which, although resolved in mortal<br />

outcomes, is nevertheless narrable.<br />

The figure of the interpreter, albeit contested by Creon, is able to process the<br />

message of the gods.<br />

Tiresias remains in any case a determining, reliable mediator between human<br />

and divine discourse. Only the unfolding of the dramatic narration allows,<br />

in The Phoenicean Women, a conclusion in which Oedipus and Antigone<br />

attempt a difficult depressive task.<br />

We have sought to trace the figure of Tiresias in contemporary poetry and<br />

art, in Guillaume Apollinaire and in Thomas Stearns Eliot.<br />

39


Salvatore Castorina / Giuseppina Mendorla<br />

TIRESIA, AN INTERPETER OF VIOLENCE: ABOUT THE VIOLATION OF BORDERS AND THE DESOLATION OF THE WORD<br />

In this world Tiresias appears uncertain, old, “withered”; forced to observe not<br />

a universe enclosed in the myth populated by heroes, but a sad bourgeois reality<br />

of the urban periphery.<br />

The great wisdom that comes to him from being in possession of both genders<br />

is transformed into fragility, omnipotent delirium.<br />

The gift of seeing with one’s eyes degraded into a card reader’s trick.<br />

Is Tiresias, at least in part, a metaphor for the difficulties of narrating and interpreting<br />

in many psychopathologies of the contemporary clinical panorama?<br />

40


Giuseppe Speciale<br />

Department of jurisprudence, Catania<br />

BUT ONE CAN'T LIVE WITH HATE. I KNOW THAT.<br />

WE HAVE TO FORGET IF WE ARE TO GO ON LIVING<br />

1. The protagonists of the trial - judges, defendants, victims, and people - are<br />

like moving pieces in a kaleidoscope that reflect their feelings of anger and<br />

mourning on the mirrors. In the kaleidoscope we can see the complex and<br />

tormented image of the human condition. In the kaleidoscope it may also<br />

happen that the pieces change their nature: so the winners become the losers<br />

and the losers winners.<br />

2. It is interesting to note how the victim, as an individual, after some time,<br />

tends to forget why he needs to start a new life without the burden of sorrow<br />

and mourning. On the contrary, societies ordered in states or in other<br />

forms of association, tend to institutionalize memory, and promote initiatives<br />

to eternalize memory, because they think that memory serves to keep the<br />

collective consciousness alive and to avoid repeating the same facts. But the<br />

institutionalization of memory leads to the risk of banality, and the repetition<br />

of the lowest rhetoric, with devastating effects on younger generations.<br />

41


Vincenzo Caretti / Adriano Schimmenti 1<br />

1<br />

PhD, DClinPsy, Faculty of Human and Social Sciences,<br />

UKE - Kore University of Enna<br />

TRAUMA AND PSYCOPATHY<br />

From a biopsychosocial perspective, it is likely that the inborn vulnerabilities<br />

of psychopaths interact with negative environmental experiences to determine<br />

the severity of the psychopathic traits.<br />

Especially in childhood, when the child's brain is particularly sensitive to experiences<br />

for its development, traumatic experiences in the attachment relationships<br />

are able to deviate the typical development of basic capacities such<br />

as empathy, mentalization, affect regulation in the child. This may lead to the<br />

development of severe psychopathic traits in vulnerable individuals.<br />

The empirical evidences linking psychopathic traits with childhood experiences<br />

of abuse and neglect will be reviewed. Research findings from different<br />

countries show that psychopaths are often exposed to a number of traumatic<br />

experiences during their childhood, and among these neglect, rejection and<br />

different types of abuse in the family. Such findings on the relationship between<br />

traumatic experiences and psychopathy have significant implications<br />

for prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of psychopathic personalities.<br />

42


43


PARALLEL<br />

SESSION<br />

45


Personality disorders (Room 1)<br />

Celia Taylor<br />

Millfields Unit, John Howard Centre, East London NHS Foundation Trust,<br />

Hackney, London, UK<br />

CREATIVE PROCESSES IN FORENSIC PSYCHOTHERAPY AND PSYCHIATRY:<br />

HIGH-RISK OFFENDERS WITH PERSONALITY DISORDER<br />

The successful psychodynamic treatment of high-risk offenders with severe<br />

personality disorder is a highly complex endeavour. It requires the therapist<br />

to help these individuals explore, confront and integrate many facets – both<br />

destructive and healthy – of their emotional and social ways of being. In this<br />

presentation I will discuss my experience of working psycho-dynamically<br />

with such patients in a medium secure, modified therapeutic community, in<br />

such a way as to foster the core creative processes of change – including curiosity,<br />

storytelling, and recognition of the potential new self. In many ways,<br />

these processes resemble the fundamental paradigmatic shifts described by<br />

Kuhn in 1962, which underpin major scientific discoveries. I will illustrate<br />

the nature and meaning of these transformative stages with case material<br />

from perpetrators of patricide.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

46


Personality disorders (Room 1)<br />

Ravi Lingam / Rachel Woodward, Foteini Papouli<br />

Forensic Services, Bamburgh Clinic, Northumberland Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust,<br />

Newcastle-on-Tyne, UK<br />

PRAGMATIC AND SYSTEMIC MANAGEMENT AND CONTAINMENT OF<br />

INTERPERSONAL AGGRESSION IN COMPLEX PERSONALITY DISORDERS<br />

Operational and relational management of risk are cornerstones in the safe<br />

and effective running of secure hospital units. This challenge is compounded<br />

by internal, external factors and pressures.<br />

The Oswin Medium Secure Unit in Newcastle-on-Tyneis a specialist service<br />

for offender-patients screened to the Offender Personality Disorder (OPD)<br />

pathway. The service model was re-designed and embedded within OPD<br />

pathway in 2015, meetingcommissioning specifications, offering primarily<br />

high risk personality disordered offenders a pathway of care from prison<br />

to hospital. These individuals are recognized to be‘stuck’ within the prison<br />

system. They are difficult to engage, in part because of co-occurring mental<br />

health problems, and pose considerable disturbances, aggression, violence in<br />

prison and are a risk to themselves.<br />

Individuals are engaged in focused and relatively brief assessment and treatment.<br />

This is, in most cases,followed by a return to sign-posted prison pathways<br />

for ongoing care and treatment and relies on sound partnership work<br />

with probation, psychology and commissioning colleagues in the OPD Pathway<br />

and the Prison system.<br />

This paper is an overview of a model of care paying particular attention to<br />

the quality of interpersonal engagement and resilience in multi-professional<br />

staff. A key aspect in engaging difficult-to-engage individuals is to develop<br />

systemic awareness of the case formulation and how this relates to criminogenic<br />

risks. Expectations are re-framed in the delivery of ‘care’ to maintaining<br />

‘ambition’ for patient-offenders, and viewing the work of engagement<br />

as one,relatively narrow part in a pathway of change and progression that<br />

includes prison and community services.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

47


Clinical experiences (Room 2)<br />

Jonathan Garabette 1 / Carine Minne 1,2<br />

1<br />

Broadmoor Hospital, West London Mental Health Trust, Berkshire, UK<br />

2<br />

Portman Clinic, Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK<br />

RESURRECTING THE DEAD –PSYCHOSIS, RAGE AND MOURNING IN<br />

PSEUDOPSYCHOPATHIC SCHIZOPHRENIA<br />

Purpose:<br />

Here we suggest the benefit of resurrecting a forgotten nosological entity –<br />

“pseudopsychopathic schizophrenia” as a way of better understanding a subgroup<br />

of severely disturbed forensic patients. We suggest that, through the<br />

oscillations between psychopathic and psychotic states of mind, these individuals<br />

avoid mourning and the unbearable reality of a painful and fragmented<br />

internal world. A brief overview of the history of the diagnosis is given,<br />

with suggested modifications for resurrecting its use, together with clinical<br />

examples from high secure and community forensic settings. Implications for<br />

assessment, risk and treatment are discussed.<br />

Methods:<br />

Literature review and case series.<br />

Results:<br />

Despite its original description in 1955, there has been very little uptake of<br />

the category for Pseudopsychopathic schizophrenia, and little research into<br />

the epidemiology and treatment of patients meeting this diagnosis. Our case<br />

series demonstrates that the potential utility of resurrecting this category to<br />

better describe and understand a small subgroup of forensic patients.<br />

Conclusion:<br />

Pseudopsychopathic schizophrenia is a mostly forgotten nosological entity<br />

but can be a useful diagnosis for a number of forensic patients. Resurrecting<br />

its use could have significant clinical and legal implications.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

48


Clinical experiences (Room 2)<br />

Elena Mundici / Katya Orrell<br />

Panoptikon,<br />

London, UK<br />

TERROR AND WONDER: WHOSE CHOICE IS IT ANYWAY?<br />

‘Many things cause terror and wonder, yet nothing is more terrifying and wonderful<br />

than man’ (Sophocles). Greek tragedy defines man as deinós, terrible<br />

and great -an ambiguous word for an ambiguous being.<br />

Concerned with the investigation of the role of man in his destiny, one element<br />

of the Tragic is the conflict between éthos, character, and daímon, a<br />

spiritual force often interpreted as fate. If éthos belongs to the realm of the<br />

conscious, daímon from the psychoanalytic perspective could be understood<br />

as the unconscious.<br />

Tragedy in its more classic form explores the tension between man’s deeds<br />

and his progressive acquisition of self-knowledge. This is where he learns<br />

who he really is and what his actions mean in relation to his identity.<br />

As forensic psychotherapists, we are spectators of the tragic events that get<br />

told and re-enacted in the therapeutic process. However, we are also actors,<br />

in that we help our patients to unravel the meaning of their actions. Why did<br />

they come to prison? Who were they trying to destroy? Or were they actually<br />

trying to mourn?<br />

In their being at the crossroad between ethical, political and spectacular, forensic<br />

institutions present many analogies with the Greek tragic phenomenon.<br />

Like tragedy, prisons contain those who enacted society’s most obscure<br />

phantasies and those who look after them. Both are the source of terror and<br />

wonder. In this paper we explore the conflicts that emerge in our clinical<br />

work with staff and prisoners, through the juxtaposition of tragedy and forensic<br />

psychotherapy.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

49


Children and violence (Room 3)<br />

Nadya E. J. N. Wynchank / Penny Stopforth<br />

Juvenile Forensic Service of the Western Cape, Valkenberg Tertiary Hospital,<br />

Cape Town, South Africa<br />

UNDER-AGE, UNDER-RAGE: AN EXPLORATION OF SOUTH AFRICAN<br />

CHILDREN WHO COMMIT SEXUAL VIOLENCE<br />

Recent research has demonstrated a steady increase in sexual violence committed<br />

by children in South Africa. In terms of the Child Justice Act of South<br />

Africa, children between the ages of 10-14 who have committed acts of sexual<br />

violence are referred for a psychological assessment to determine their criminal<br />

capacity. Against the background of South Africa’s political history and<br />

its pervasive socio-economic inequalities, this paper briefly explores some of<br />

the factors contributing to the prevalence of sexual violence and the power<br />

relations implicated in constructing violent masculinities.<br />

In addition, distinct beliefs and gendered social constructs informing normalisations<br />

of sexual violence will be outlined. Examples of such phenomena<br />

include “Ukuthwala” (child abductions leading to forced marriage), “corrective<br />

rape” and “virgin cleansing” myths.<br />

The paper also focusses on children we have assessed, who have expressed<br />

an apparent absence of subjective aggression during the commission of these<br />

decidedly aggressive acts, and shall attempt to explore their behaviour using<br />

a psychoanalytic lens. The role of attachment and mentalisation in the genesis<br />

of sexually violent behaviour will be examined alongside developmental factors<br />

that distinguish child perpetrators from adult perpetrators.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

50


Children and violence (Room 3)<br />

Arianna Pulsoni<br />

The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust,<br />

Research Fund Clinical Workshopon Intergenerational family difficulties,<br />

London UK<br />

THE CATHARTIC PROCESS IN THERAPY:FROM THE CAVE TO EARTH<br />

This clinical paper describes some parent-child work and psychotherapy with<br />

a three-year-old boy who had a traumatic historyand who at the beginning of<br />

the treatment presented with severe autistic traits.<br />

The paper draws on and elaborates upon links between the boy’s traumatic<br />

experiences of abuse and neglect, his autistic defences and his developmental<br />

delay.The narrative tracks the development of the relationship with the<br />

therapist and the consequent “birth” of this boy, that is, the emergence of his<br />

persona once the autistic defences began to fade away.<br />

The paper also explores the parallel parent work with the boy’s adoptive parents.<br />

In the last section, the paper discusses the boy’s development of spacetime<br />

categories in the context of more depressive functioning.Once he acquired<br />

a sense of time as duration and then as memory, the patient began to<br />

remember, in therapy, the traumas he had experienced.<br />

When the resulting anger and pain emerged, so did life: the seemingly autistic<br />

child came out of his cave and began to read, learn and to understand the<br />

world around him.<br />

Recollection of past facts and the acquisition of memory occurred at first<br />

as a Greek tragedy of sorts, where pain and baleful anger alternated as if in<br />

a dance. In the cathartic process of experiencing anger and pain,they were<br />

also understood deeply and then a sense of mourning was born, through<br />

which defences gave way to development, curiosity and the emergence of the<br />

experience of beauty within the relationship with the ‘object.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

51


The human soul: light and darkness (Room 4)<br />

J. David Millar<br />

Centre for Psychoanalytic Studies, University of Essex,<br />

Colchester Essex, UK<br />

GRIEF TO RAGE: FROM DARKNESS INTO DARKNESS<br />

My paper will be largely theoretical. I have chosen grief and rageas my starting<br />

points rather than mourning and rage as I believe the former arethe<br />

emotionally unprocessed starting points in our most extreme reactions to<br />

life. I intend to show how griefcan either progress through mourning and<br />

end in sadness and meaning (darkness into light); or alternatively how it can<br />

lead through emptiness to depression and despair (darkness into darkness).<br />

Similarly, I proffer howrage can either progress through anger to acceptance<br />

(darkness into light) or through retribution and revenge ending in bitterness<br />

and spite (darkness into darkness). In both cases, grief and rage can either be<br />

‘worked though’ to become a stabilising influence in life or ‘stumbled through’<br />

to become a disruptive and malign influence.<br />

My presentation will consist mainly of a spoken paper butblended with a<br />

striking musical video that I believe ‘shadows’ my arguments with its own<br />

moving interpretation.<br />

Purpose: To show how fundamental human responses can lead either to<br />

emotional wellbeing or psychological ill-health.<br />

Method: A mixture of oral presentation with a music video backdrop.<br />

Results: I will be attempting to refine the theoretical position on the bifurcated<br />

emotional development of grief and rage.<br />

Conclusion: Sometimes even in darkness there is light.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

52


The human soul: light and darkness (Room 4)<br />

Alex Maguire<br />

Arts Therapies Department,Broadmoor Hospital,<br />

Crowthorne, UK<br />

CARLO GESUALDO: MUSIC, MURDER AND MOURNING IN<br />

RENAISSANCE ITALY<br />

On 16 th October 1590 Carlo Gesualdo put his wife and her lover to the sword<br />

in his Naples residence. Whilst the revenge of the cuckold was a matter of<br />

honour at this time, Gesualdo (1560-1613) was no ordinary Neapolitan; born<br />

into the aristocracy, one of his uncles was Cardinal Carlo Borromeo, a leading<br />

figure in the counter-Reformation and supporter of Caravaggio. Having<br />

inherited his father’s titles and land upon his death, from that point on Gesualdo<br />

gave himself over totally to his overriding passion: the composition of<br />

vocal music.<br />

This music, particularly his settings of religious texts, is many years ahead of<br />

its time; indeed it is not until Richard Wagner that we hear again such complex<br />

chromaticism and unsettling shifts of harmonic context.<br />

The only extant music from Gesualdo’s pen was written after the double murder,<br />

and is thus the expression of a man with this experience in his mind.<br />

Can we say that Gesualdo is mourning the double murder of his wife and lover<br />

in his music? Can the forensic patient ever leave the offence behind him?<br />

Or does such a patient inevitably bring his offence into the room with him?<br />

In a Music Therapy setting, will this then be played out in some way in the<br />

patient’s own music? This paper considers such ideas using examples from<br />

Gesualdo’s final compositions, the Tenebrae Responsories (composed in 1611<br />

for Holy Week) where his extravagant treatment of elements of the New Testament<br />

murder story reaches a level of extraordinary intensity.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (1)<br />

53


The cultural approach (Room 1)<br />

Christine Montross<br />

MD, MFA Assistant Professor of Psychiatry and Human Behavior Brown University,<br />

Rhode Island, U.S.A.<br />

THE RAGE OF ISOLATION: AGGRESSION AND SELF-INJURY IN<br />

SOLITARY CONFINEMENT<br />

Acts of aggression and self-injury committed by incarcerated men and women<br />

in solitary confinement are often interpreted as evidence of the detainees’<br />

dangerous natures, and as justification for their continued isolation and<br />

detention. “Of course they’re animals and they’re monsters,” a correctional<br />

officer at Northern Correctional Institute in Connecticut, U.S.A. says of men<br />

detained for months to years in twenty-three hour-per-day isolation cells. “If<br />

they weren’t, they wouldn’t be there.” Yet studies in various scientific disciplines<br />

on topics ranging from aviation to polar exploration to blindness have<br />

shown that sensory deprivation and isolation can, in fact, give rise to violent<br />

fantasies andaggressive actions, even in people who were previously psychologically<br />

well. In this session, psychiatrist and author Dr. Christine Montross<br />

willexamine the relationship between violence and isolation in essay form.<br />

Montross, a 2015 Guggenheim fellow in nonfiction, will read from and discuss<br />

her essay On Isolation, which is a chapter from her current book project,<br />

Acquainted With the Night: Mental Illness in America’s Prisons. The discussion<br />

of the essay—which draws on the scientific studies mentioned above as<br />

well as on descriptions of paranoia in Korean prisoners of war; accounts of<br />

disorientation in free divers who descend ever deeper into the ocean’s depths;<br />

studies of self-injury in non-human primates; and analyses of Pip floating<br />

lost at sea in Moby Dick—will launch questions not only on the rage of isolation,<br />

but also as to what role interdisciplinary research in the arts and sciences<br />

might have in deepening our understanding of forensic psychiatric work.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

54


The cultural approach (Room 1)<br />

Mary Hamer<br />

Harvard University, USA<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING IN EURIPIDES’ MEDEA<br />

It’s easy to write off Medea as a witch, deranged, a rejected wife who takes out<br />

her jealousy by killing her children. That’s the lazy version.<br />

But the story of Medea, as conceived and staged by Euripides more than two<br />

thousand years ago offers a different take. It presents the rage of a wife who<br />

has been replaced, an experience that is still familiar today.<br />

Rather than accepting the husband’s betrayal as a commonplace, the act of<br />

a single individual, Euripides identifies it as a practice, one that is bound up<br />

in maintaining a particular social order. The action of his play demonstrates<br />

how this order imposes psychological damage and death on men too.<br />

My paper will examine the process by which the playright situates Medea in a<br />

culture where ‘the hero’ is the only model for aspiration. Underpinning that,<br />

however, the play suggests, is a refusal to recognize or give a place to human<br />

vulnerability and failure.<br />

Getting it so wrong, argues the play, requires a change of direction. Critics<br />

have always puzzled over the way Euripides chose to end, with a total disregard<br />

of dramatic convention or psychological consistency.<br />

In this provocative finale Medea announces her project of community<br />

mourning and expiation: the knowledge of weakness and loss, suppressed<br />

under the culture of Athens, is retrieved and brought forcibly to the attention<br />

of the audience.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

55


Rage and mourning: group therapy (Room 2)<br />

Leslie M. Lothstein<br />

Ph.D. ABPP, West Hartford CT, USA<br />

MOURNING AND RAGE IN A LONG TERM PSYCHODYNAMIC OUTPATIENT<br />

GROUP OF MALE SEX OFFENDERS<br />

The therapist’s capacity for treating violent sex offenders (VSO) in outpatient<br />

group therapy varies according to how comfortable the group therapist is<br />

with having very strong feelings enacted in an outpatient VSO group.<br />

For most VSOs intense rage is often followed by intense shame as complex<br />

transference and countertransference states emerge that need to be attended<br />

to if change is to occur. Two prototypical cases serve as examples of how<br />

therapeutic change occurs in the context of boundary crossings in the group.<br />

Carl, a violent sex offender, viciously raped a 15 year old boy, abducting him,<br />

tying him up and sodomizing him. At times he speaks violently in the group<br />

and once sat in the therapist’s chair and took over the group. The group asks,<br />

“Is it safe to be here?”<br />

Bob wrote a highly intellectualized suicide note that arrived a day after he violently<br />

suicided by jumping off a 100 foot overpass. Over the ensuring months<br />

the group’s mourning and rage take on many forms. During one group Stan’s<br />

boundaries become con-fused with those of the deceased Bob. Stan misses<br />

Bob and wants to die and join him. The group is confused by Stan’s words that<br />

Bob is inside him. They ask, “What’s wrong with his/our boundaries? Are we<br />

safe from his/our feelings? Can the group survive this experience?”<br />

The parallel process between the VSO enactments in the group and change is<br />

discussed as at the core of therapeutic work in relationally focused psychoanalytically<br />

informed group therapy with VSOs.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

56


Rage and mourning: group therapy (Room 2)<br />

Vincenzina Fragasso / Simona Ramella Paia<br />

Forensis Psychologist, Psychoterapist,<br />

Biella, Italy<br />

THE PSYCHOEDUCATIONAL GROUP FOR ABUSIVE MEN AS A WAY TO<br />

INTERRUPT THE CYCLE OF VIOLENCE AND HIS SOCIAL RETURN OF IMPACT<br />

(SROI)<br />

PAVIOL is an Association that promotes social health operating in Biella,<br />

Piedmont from 2013.<br />

In 2015 PAVIOL started with a new project: to offer free psychoterapy to<br />

abusing adults; this is a group therapy based on the model of CAM in Florence,<br />

the first private center in Italy .<br />

The group therapy is organized on two levels:<br />

a 18 sessions focused group in wich people talk about violence, family, parenting,<br />

sexuality, women;<br />

a psychoterapeutic group with the model of transactional analysis .<br />

This presentation will offer a reflection about the prevention of future violence<br />

by the intervention on adults : the positive modelling is a good way to<br />

prevent future; it’s true actually that a lot of abusing adults were abused children<br />

in the past (Liotti, Farina, 2011; Cornell, Olio 1992).<br />

One of the missions of the Association is changing culture and preventing<br />

violent behaviors working with all the actors of the abused families.<br />

The social costs of violence are very high if we think, as example, about health<br />

costs, legal costs, loss of work…<br />

The mission of PAVIOL is to stop the cycle of violence in order to introduce<br />

a new way to think about social costs (SROI)<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

57


Destructiveness, individuals and institutions (Room 3)<br />

Caterina Marchetti<br />

Forensic Psychologist Psychotherapist,<br />

Turin, Italy<br />

A PSYCHOANALYTIC PSYCHOTHERAPY GROUP WITH WOMEN CRIMINALS<br />

IN A NORTHERN ITALIAN PRISON<br />

This presentation tells the story of a therapy group in a prison where a total<br />

of 350 men and women are incarcerated, 40 of whom are women who have<br />

committed crimes of a range of severities.<br />

The group began in 2013 and was composed originally of 12 women. As with<br />

any forensic psychotherapeutic group, the initial objective was to try to understand<br />

what was behind the crimes and to activate the women’s thinking<br />

in order to reduce acting out. The group meet weekly for an hour and a half.<br />

During the three years the group ran, I was supervised by Estela Welldon, and<br />

despite the fact there were many interpretations made about my reluctance to<br />

interpret any negative transference made by the group to the therapist, I didn't<br />

feel easy making them. At times I forgot my therapeutic role and behaved in<br />

a friendly and kind way to the extent that I was unable to interpret the hidden<br />

fear and anger that some of the women experienced. This especially applied<br />

to one woman who'd killed both her parents in cold blood, and behaved in<br />

the most seductive of ways in the group. Actually she psychologically hijacked<br />

the group and was extremely successful in getting rid of, one by one,<br />

the other group members, so that eventually, she had a one-to-one session<br />

with me. We were able to discuss some unresolved mourning processes in my<br />

own family, which had completely obliterated my capacity to think. Also, I<br />

clung firmly to the belief that this woman was suffering from schizophrenia<br />

although EW was of the opinion that she displayed psychopathic personality<br />

structures. The suggestion was that this enabled me to dismiss my own sense<br />

of fear of this dangerous woman. At this point, having consulted with the<br />

supervisor EW, after three years, it was decided to terminate the group as it<br />

was no longer a group. Paradoxical to its purpose, this group failed because<br />

it did not achieve the capacity to think. Following the last supervision, it<br />

became clear that the involvement of the therapist had played a role in the<br />

disintegration of the group. The blindness of the therapist is comparable to<br />

an unwillingness to see the obvious signs of a group that doesn’t function.<br />

The presentation wishes to examine the parallels between the therapist in the<br />

group and Jocasta in the myth of Oedipus. Both did not recognize in time a<br />

truth which was right before their eyes.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

58


Destructiveness, individuals and institutions (Room 3)<br />

Moustafa Saoud<br />

Sussex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust,<br />

Sussex, UK<br />

RAGE, NARCISSISM AND THE SEARCH FOR MOURNING AT THE<br />

EXTREMES OF AGE<br />

These case presentations vividly illustrate the impact of unprocessed feelings<br />

of rage on the existence of the human soul. The first case is of a man in his<br />

seventies who has no history of involvement with forensic or mental health<br />

services. He commits murder and his crime was described as ‘surprisingly<br />

ruthless and puzzling’. It is not however until he is admitted to hospital that<br />

staff are faced with his severe psychopathology and inability to mourn. The<br />

team also struggles to cope with a range of difficult emotions aroused by their<br />

daily interaction with him, and with the wider rehabilitation system.<br />

The second case is of a very young man who has managed by openly communicating<br />

his violent fantasies, and without actually committing any physical<br />

violent acts, to put the local criminal justice and mental health systems on<br />

high alert. It demonstrates that fragility of our systems when faced with unprocessed<br />

feelings of rage, especially when disowned and projected into the<br />

wider system.<br />

Specific areas of relevance to the conference theme that will be highlighted<br />

include the role of psychodynamic thinking with regard to: risk assessment<br />

and management and the prevention of future offending; and the interface<br />

between forensic services and outside agencies.<br />

The relationship between violence acts and narcissism as a defence against<br />

threats to self-existence will also also be explored.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

59


Destructiveness, individuals and institutions (Room 3)<br />

Sandra Scott / Manza Kamal<br />

West London Mental health NHS Trust,<br />

London UK<br />

IDC ON A PATIENT<br />

Mr K is a 42-year-old man originally from Jamaica. He experienced a number<br />

of significant losses in his early life. He was admitted to Broadmoor Hospital<br />

from prison on 20 th March 2014. His index offence was Manslaughter of a<br />

sex worker in London in January 2014, and Sexual Assault and False Imprisonment<br />

of another sex worker ten days earlier . Mr K’s account of the index<br />

offence indicated that the offence was not directly sexually motivated. Prior<br />

to the index offence Mr K had a 5 year history of contact with mental health<br />

services associated with multiple admissions to psychiatric hospital under<br />

the Mental Health Act, and periods of non-compliance with medication necessitating<br />

depot antipsychotic medication.<br />

Mr K was transferred to an MSU from Broadmoor Hospital in January 2016.<br />

Superficially Mr K appeared to be generally settled on the MSU ward and was<br />

not involved in any untoward incidents. However it was noted that he socialised<br />

with few patients and was very guarded with staff; that during his interactions<br />

with staff although outwardly compliant there was no depth or detail<br />

to his communications. In addition, a number of female staff members noted<br />

that Mr K had a habit of sitting in a chair with a bird’s eye view of the nurses’<br />

station, staring intently inside. It made several members uncomfortable.<br />

Other members of staff observed that there appeared to be a sense of suppressed<br />

rage and hostility in Mr K which was at odds with his superficial<br />

cooperation and politeness. The MDT concluded that after several months<br />

that they felt that they were making no real progress in understanding Mr<br />

K psychologically. It was felt that he had put up a barrier and that this and<br />

the discomfort some staff felt in his presence was hindering their ability to<br />

manage him generally and assess his risk to others. The MDT decided to<br />

undertake an Interpersonal Dynamic Consultation. This is a whole team<br />

approach. There are facilitated discussions used to look at how individual<br />

patients interact with staff and engage with treatment. How the patient’s behaviour<br />

is impacting on the relationship with staff and the ability to deliver<br />

effective care. The aim is to create an understanding of the patient’s relationship<br />

patterns, allowing for an effective strategy for care. The team’s treatment<br />

plan and approach to the patient is revised in light of this information. Dr<br />

Kamal and I shall carry out an IDC workshop based on this case.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

60


Rage and mourning: the creative arts therapies (Room 4)<br />

Stella Compton Dickinson<br />

Instiute of Mental Health,<br />

Nottingham, UK<br />

JOURNEY'S END: RAGE OR RECONCILIATION<br />

Adshead (2012) states that forensic patients have frequently suffered psychological<br />

harm in their childhood. Compton Dickinson (2006; 2013, pp.154–<br />

166) demonstrates howperverse adult responses develop from damaging<br />

childhood experiences which lead to dissociation from painful emotions, the<br />

blunting of emotional recognition, the formation of dysfunctional patterns<br />

of relating and callous responses, ultimately leading to harm through enactments<br />

of rage and the inability to mourn.<br />

Mourning is a process that involves emotional relatedness to self and others.<br />

The catalyst for coming to terms with feelings of loss can be elicited through<br />

music. Music therapy is an expressive psychotherapy to help patients improve<br />

their mental health; within a therapeutic relationship, patient and therapist<br />

collaborate in jointly-creating music to enable the expression of troubled<br />

thoughts, memories and feelings (Davis, Gfeller&Thaut, 2008). For patients<br />

receiving treatment in forensic psychiatric settings there are risks of offence<br />

re-enactment that are symbolically enacted and visibly witnessed during<br />

jointly –created musical improvisation. Perseveration is a common phenomenon<br />

because of unconscious avoidance of endings and the associations with<br />

killing and death. Thus, there are risks of harm to Music Therapists and the<br />

need for an evidence –based, context specific model which can be integrated<br />

into Multi-disciplinary treatment pathways.<br />

This paper willprovides guidance on the general use of music in forensic<br />

settings towards resolving grief, withdescription of risks and what works in<br />

terms of structures and freedom in an evidence-based, time-limitedmanualised<br />

model called Group Cognitive Analytic Music Therapy(Compton Dickinson<br />

(2006; 2013; 2015; 2017)<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

61


Rage and mourning: the creative arts therapies (Room 4)<br />

Andrew Perry<br />

Chartered Clinical Psychologist, UK<br />

PERMISSION TO COME ALONGSIDE?<br />

Purpose: Cultural change provides new opportunities and threats for mental<br />

health practitioners in forensic services. There are opportunities to play<br />

a seminal role in practice development. There is also the threat of indistinguishable<br />

roles. This submission outlines a contemporary useful relational<br />

model and a technology to deliver it.<br />

Methods: Co-producing reciprocal outcomes, making your dependence on<br />

other people an asset. Accepting invitations to come alongside other people,<br />

to spend time with them, be influenced by their world, to talk and to play<br />

music. That shared power gives us an insight into another person’s world,<br />

equalising the experience, the meaning of the relationship, the level of commitment,<br />

openness to new experiences, risk, and respect. It feels like we are<br />

doing something new together. In this way both parties allow themselves to<br />

be transformed ethically by someone else. A ‘co-productive relationship.<br />

Results: a) A ward talking group is a place for conversation. A simple analogy<br />

from popular culture would be a group of colleagues meeting over lunch<br />

where spontaneous interactions occur within a commonly understood<br />

framework.<br />

b) Social music groups. Patients to get to know staff better through music. In<br />

turn they allow us to get to know them better through music. Taking turns in<br />

being vulnerable by trying new things. Enjoy making musical mistakes with<br />

pace, pitch, timing, and or volume.<br />

Conclusions: A good enough practitioner promotes effective clinical and<br />

non clinical relationships. I have a successful model to do just that in contemporary<br />

forensic services.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

62


Personality and family (Room 5)<br />

Markus G. Feil<br />

Psychotherapeutic Clinic for Violent and Sexual Offenders<br />

Munich/Germany<br />

PERSONALITY ORGANIZATION AS MAJOR RESPONSIVITY FACTOR<br />

Men who sexually offend against children frequently meet the criteria of pedophiliaaccording<br />

to DSM-IV-TRresp. DSM-5. However, it remains unclear<br />

how many men with pedophilia actually commit an offence and reoffend.<br />

Also more research is needed to clarify the typological differences between<br />

hands on und hand off child offenders.<br />

This paper examines clinically relevant commonalities and differences of<br />

men with pedophilia with the help of the Structured Interview for Personality<br />

Organization(STIPO)according to the psychodynamicconceptualization<br />

of Kernberg. Variables of this study consisted of hands-on- vs. hands-off-offence,<br />

the sex of the victimsas well as violence in any offence.<br />

Results show that child sexual offenders function on different levels of personality<br />

organization.Although there was no statistical significance the personality<br />

of child sexual abusers wasmore often organized on a borderline level,<br />

while there was a greater variance in the levels of personality organization<br />

in consumers of child pornography.Violent offenders significantly more likely<br />

to function on a lower level of personality organization.<br />

Although there is little immediate prognostic relevance, the diagnostic and<br />

therapeutic value of personality organization should be considered as an important<br />

responsivity factor.Treatment of pedophilic offenders with a borderline<br />

structure can only be effective if the treatment is adjusted to the level of<br />

personality organization.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

63


Personality and family (Room 5)<br />

Ronald Doctor<br />

British Psychoanalytical Society,<br />

London UK<br />

RAGE AND MOURNING IN FAMILY AND GENDER DYNAMICS:<br />

FATE, PASSION AND WILL<br />

Rage and Mourning are powerful affects that deeply disturb the human<br />

soul and interrupt the course of their existence.<br />

In the Psychopath the object relationship which results is not with a person<br />

truly seen as separate but with the self projected into another person and<br />

related to as if it were someone else. This is the position of the mythical Narcissus<br />

who fell in love with a strange youth he did not consciously connect<br />

to himself. The way I think of all personality disorder is to think of the patient’s<br />

narcissism, which is usually most obstinately resistant to treatment. In<br />

narcissistic object relations, defences against any recognition of separateness<br />

between self and object play a predominant part. Awareness of separation<br />

would lead to feelings of dependence on an object and therefore to anxiety.<br />

Dependence implies love for and recognition of the value of the object, which<br />

leads to aggression, anxiety and pain because of the inevitable frustration in<br />

relationships and their consequences.<br />

The process of regaining parts of the self lost through projective identification<br />

involves facing the reality of what belongs to the object and what belongs to<br />

the self. This is established most clearly through the experience of loss and the<br />

process of mourning where those parts of the self are regained.<br />

This achievement may require much working through in therapy.<br />

With the help of clinical material, this presentation will explore the transference<br />

and counter transference in relation to the personality disorder and in<br />

particular the psychopath. It is possible to classify the responses aroused by<br />

such patients under three headings: collusion, disbelief and condemnation.<br />

In treatment of the personality disorder, and in particular the psychopath,<br />

projective identification stirs our own sadism and this leads to two-fold response:<br />

either disbelief or condemnation. The psychopath despises the person<br />

who holds onto an illusion that he is good. Unconsciously he knows that<br />

it is a rejection of an important part of him, and will always give a strong clue<br />

about the hidden side of his character.<br />

If we accept what we see in the psychopath then we have to accept our own<br />

sadism. It may be more comfortable to believe that he and I are good.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Family, Groups and Society<br />

64


The dark web (Room 1)<br />

Foteini Papouli 1 / Ioannis Sfyrakis 2 / Ravi Lingam 1<br />

1<br />

Specility Doctor in Forensic Services. Currently working for a medium secure personality disorder unit in UK.<br />

Trained in Psychiatry in Greece and UK<br />

2<br />

School of Computing Science, Newcastle University, UK<br />

THE DARK WEB: THE HIDEOUT OF THE IDENTITY<br />

Purpose: The preservation of the identity in the fast-changing world of social<br />

media is a topic that appears to be of increasing interest for scientists and<br />

public. Research is available for thepsychological profile of the users usingthe<br />

unencrypted internet where, despite usernames and passwords, the user can<br />

be identified.<br />

We aim to find published research on the psychological profile of the “Dark<br />

Web” user. The “Dark Web” is a collection of anonymous and hidden websites<br />

using an encrypted network. It attracts a wide variety of people who want to<br />

keep their activities secret.<br />

Methods: Search of the online databases of “Pubmed” and “Google Scholar”.<br />

We used “dark web”, “dark net”, “psychology”, “identity” as key words.<br />

RESULTS: Pubmed did not produce results for our topic. Google Scholar offers<br />

more research on the Dark web, however the focus is mainly on its nature<br />

and the links to specific criminal acts, rather on the psychological characteristics<br />

of its users.<br />

Conclusions: The Dark Web is seen as a tool for those who want to be anonymous,<br />

for the better or worse. As the experience with mainstream web has<br />

shown, the internet can be powerful; itcan split an identity, form personae,<br />

shake the links with the outer world.<br />

Those who need to be anonymous may already struggle with being regardedas<br />

disturbing by others and/or by themselves. Further research is required<br />

to shed light to a topic that is by definition Dark.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

65


The dark web (Room 1)<br />

Giulia Cusumano 1,2,3 / Rosa Ingiulla 1 , Roberta Desiderio 1 , Agnese Alberio 1,3<br />

1<br />

Dipartimento di Scienze Umanistiche, Università degli Studi di Catania, Catania, Italia;<br />

2<br />

Associazione Antiusura Antiracket Obiettivo Legalità, Catania, Italia;<br />

3<br />

AssociazioneCODICI – Centro per i diritti del cittadino – Sicilia, Palermo, Italia<br />

BULLYING AND CYBERBULLYING IN SICILIAN ADOLESCENTS<br />

Cyberbullying is today an extensive phenomenon especially prevalent among<br />

adolescents and preadolescents, encouraged by the widespread use of new<br />

technologies and the communication revolution due to chat, social networks<br />

and file sharing. The consequences for victims must not be undervalued because<br />

the impact of this kind of persecutory violence, perpetrated in a context<br />

of a space physically and temporarily non limited, is considerable: from the<br />

analysis of research conducted in literature, nationally and internationally, we<br />

find, for example, high percentages of suicide ideation by cyberbullied youth.<br />

After a review and a study of the main national and international tests and<br />

questionnaires on bullying and cyberbullying, examined evaluating their<br />

construction and validity, in the present study we propose an instrument that<br />

– on the basis of past scientific experience about this phenomenon – has the<br />

purpose of finding some quantitative data on the diffusion and influence of<br />

cyberbullying; a further aim of the study is the analysis of the different behavior<br />

acted out in the victimization context.<br />

We observed bully and cyberbully behavior: attitudes that can easily change<br />

into acts of sexting or sextortion favored by the ease of sharing files, and that<br />

are often acted out in a less overt way (because of the opportunity offered by<br />

Internet and technology) than traditional bullying. Our data shows furthermore<br />

how the fact of belonging to certain social classes does not change the<br />

quality of bullying and cyberbullying behaviors.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

66


Jealousy (Room 2)<br />

Karel‘t Lam<br />

Forensic Psychiatric Hospital Assen,<br />

The Netherlands<br />

A CASE OF ATTEMPTED RAPES AND SEXUAL STALKING: FORENSIC<br />

PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC REFLECTIONS ON JEALOUSY IN PERVERSIONS<br />

In the case we present we reflect on the specific role of jealousy – besides other<br />

emotions - in a case of multiple rapes and sexual stalking.<br />

The patient we will reflect upon is born with a physical abnormality, limiting<br />

his speech and in his physical appearance. These abnormalities resulted in a<br />

special position in his family of origin. Later in life the patient felt seriously<br />

limited in efforts to make contact, especially with the members of the other<br />

gender. Jealousy is a central theme in his relation with his siblings. At a more<br />

fundamental level: his mother treated him as special, delivering care that was<br />

humiliating for him, at the same time giving him a special position.<br />

The patient is convicted for attempted rape on different occasions the last<br />

fifteen years, hunting for victims that looked similar to his first victim. In<br />

treatment he revealed he’s still aching for his first victim. Central is his feeling<br />

of jealousy and rage about definitely having no place in her life.<br />

Aim is to deepen our understanding of jealousy, its role in understanding<br />

sexual perverse behaviour and how we came across this theme in diverse<br />

aspects of treatment.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

67


Jealousy (Room 2)<br />

Frans Koenraadt<br />

Utrecht University, NIFP & Forensic Psychiatric Hospital,<br />

Assen The Netherlands<br />

JEALOUSY PENETRATING INTO THE FAMILY DOMAIN: CONSIDERATIONS<br />

FROM FORENSIC MENTAL HEALTH ASSESSMENT AND RESEARCH<br />

As a sensitive emotion jealousy might destabilise the family area. Among siblings<br />

and spouses, but even among parents and their children jealousy might<br />

interfere, sometimes resulting in domestic violence and in some cases with a<br />

lethal outcome: uxoricide, infanticide and siblicide.<br />

Based on cases from forensic mental health assessment and research in this<br />

presentation we will discuss and differentiate between the pathological jealousy<br />

and the non-pathological jealousy and the consequences for forensic<br />

mental health experts' recommendations for the court and the decisions by<br />

the judges.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

68


Jealousy (Room 2)<br />

Jan van der Leeuw<br />

Private practice Maastricht,<br />

The Netherlands<br />

THE PRESENCE AND ABSENCE OF JEALOUSY IN TWO CASES IN<br />

RELATIONSHIP TO RAGE<br />

In this presentation I like to present two short clinical vignettes. One showing<br />

the evident presence of jealousy in a case of a man accused of trying to kill<br />

his wife. The other case of a pervert man, condemned of rape in former times<br />

and nowadays accused of child-pornography.<br />

In this case I will explore the harmful consequences of the absence or denial<br />

of jealousy in (the relationship of) the patient and his partner. Jealousy as a<br />

defence against oral aggression is missing.<br />

By creating a shared fantasy about sexual abuse of a daughter who still is to<br />

beget, a triangular situation is introduced. The third one is a necessary condition<br />

for the development of jealousy feelings. Jealousy refers to love and<br />

possession and the fear of losing this. L’ amour captative.<br />

Where jealousy cannot find the normal pathways of discharge, hate and envy<br />

can raise as sadistic projections by despising the third one.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

69


Learning disabilities (Room 3)<br />

This parallel session is dedicated to the memory of our colleague Dr Alan Corbett the IAFP<br />

who sadly died in December last year when he still had so much to offer. Thankfully we have<br />

the legacy of his wonderful writings. As a tribute to his ground breaking work in the field of<br />

forensic psychotherapy the IAFP is proud to announce the first of an annual conference parallel<br />

session dedicated to the theme of intellectual disability, autism and social exclusion. At<br />

subsequent annual conferences the Board will ask for contributions under this theme. At this<br />

years event we are delighted to have 2 of Alan's closest colleagues, Tamsin Cottis and Richard<br />

Curen, who will present papers that build on Alan's thinking and practice.<br />

Tamsin Cottis<br />

UKCP registered Child Psychotherapist.<br />

Primary school and private practice at SW1 Child Psychotherapy, London, uk<br />

YOU DON’T GIVE A SHIT ABOUT ME!: REJECTION, RAGE AND THE<br />

GROWTH OF LOVE<br />

This case-based presentation will describe the long-term psychotherapeutic<br />

treatment of a woman with learning disabilities who was a victim of childhood<br />

sexual abuse and a sexual risk to others. Drawing on theories of Trauma<br />

and Attachment, Winnicottian object relations, and Alvarez’s Levels of Work,<br />

the paper will explore how the patient moved from a position of extreme<br />

anger, hostility and rejection to the therapy, to being able to make positive<br />

use of it. Over the course of the treatment, despite episodes of acute crisis, the<br />

patient became able to mourn profound early losses, often through the use of<br />

metaphor and transitional objects. With support, she became able to form a<br />

mutually loving relationship with a partner.<br />

The treatment took place atRespond, a specialist clinic for people with learning<br />

disabilities, and was case managed by Dr Alan Corbett. His role in the<br />

work was pivotal to the therapy and reflective of the case management model<br />

pioneered at Respond. This aspect of the therapy will also be highlighted and<br />

its clinical impact explored.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

70


Learning disabilities (Room 3)<br />

This parallel session is dedicated to the memory of our colleague Dr Alan Corbett the IAFP<br />

who sadly died in December last year when he still had so much to offer. Thankfully we have<br />

the legacy of his wonderful writings. As a tribute to his ground breaking work in the field of<br />

forensic psychotherapy the IAFP is proud to announce the first of an annual conference parallel<br />

session dedicated to the theme of intellectual disability, autism and social exclusion. At<br />

subsequent annual conferences the Board will ask for contributions under this theme. At this<br />

years event we are delighted to have 2 of Alan's closest colleagues, Tamsin Cottis and Richard<br />

Curen, who will present papers that build on Alan's thinking and practice.<br />

Richard Curen<br />

Respond Group,<br />

London UK<br />

“I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE”: A PSYCHODYNAMIC PERSPECTIVE ON<br />

INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY, RAGE, MOURNING AND SADO-MASOCHISTIC<br />

STATES OF MIND<br />

The psychodynamic treatment of people with intellectual disabilities and sexual<br />

perversions is still in its infancy. Using a case-based material this presentation<br />

will explore some of the ways in which the pioneering work of Dr Alan<br />

Corbett provides a richer understanding of the intersection of psychodynamic<br />

theory and ‘forensic disability psychotherapy.’ Material from the treatment<br />

of a number of patients with intellectual disabilities will explore the impact<br />

of early losses on the development of sado-masochistic preoccupations. The<br />

turning inwards and outwards of psychic pain will be explored in the light of<br />

Dr Corbett’s ground-breaking theories.<br />

71


The bi-logic thinking: the matte-blanco perspective (Room 4)<br />

Christos Sideras 1 / Gerald Wooster 2<br />

1<br />

University of Athens, University College Hospitals London, Royal Society of Medicine, London UK<br />

2<br />

Retired Consultant Psychiatrist and Psychotherapist, London UK<br />

EMOTIONS AND INFINITY: THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF IGNACIO MATTE<br />

BLANCO TO UNDERSTANDING EMOTIONS<br />

Being firmly stuck in states of rage or mourning is an experience found in<br />

some extreme mental states, which is often accompanied by similarly extreme<br />

behavior that leads people to the attention of professionals, often against their<br />

own volition.<br />

This "stuckness" offers a good starting point to consider the ideas of chilean<br />

psychoanalyst Ignacio Matte Blanco on emotions and the eternal now they<br />

are experienced in. Matte Blanco describes, along the axis of a polarity of<br />

symmetry to assymetry, a number of levels where this infinity of emotional<br />

experience is varied and structured, and thus differently experienced and<br />

acted upon. He describes the importance of the faculty enabling this move<br />

through the different structurations of the symmetric to assymetric, what<br />

some could call different levels of symbolization.<br />

Re-experiencing the bodily state of an infinite emotional now, with the maturity<br />

of either an inner, or in the case of such a lack, an outer guide, may be a<br />

good way to practice the facility of shifting between the stages. Whether the<br />

guide is somewhat out of sync or, in some cases, frankly dissociated from the<br />

emotional self, there is still in this process the possibility of re-engagement, in<br />

some cases even offering the possibility of a transformation of the emotional<br />

experience, and the behavior outpouring from it. Time permitting we may<br />

also offer some clinical vignettes, to consider, and initiate the discussion.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

72


The bi-logic thinking: the matte-blanco perspective (Room 4)<br />

Angelo Costanzo<br />

Magistrato della Cassazione<br />

BI-LOGIC AND ARGUMENTATION<br />

La psicologia si occupa delle condizioni soggettive di vario genere che influenzano<br />

i pensieri. Invece, la logica riguarda le regole necessarie del pensiero:<br />

è un'etica del pensiero non riducibile a una descrizione psicologica e i suoi<br />

principi appaiono come se fossero indipendenti delle condizioni mentali. Gli<br />

psicologi descrivono il pensiero effettivo. Invece, il ragionamento logico corretto<br />

dipende da criteri che non possono essere analizzati empiricamente.<br />

Nello sviluppo di una argomentazione logica e psicologia sono come i due<br />

fuochi di un'ellisse.Mirando a una gestione razionale della conoscenza incerta,<br />

l’argomentazione segue strategie di pensiero, complementari a quelle della<br />

dimostrazione. A questa ampliata concezione della argomentazione, la logica<br />

del Novecento ha fornito due potenti strumenti di affinamento.<br />

Le logiche non-classiche hanno dato forma a quelle deviazioni dai principi<br />

logici che la tradizione ha inteso come fondamentali, ma che nelle argomentazioni<br />

sono frequentemente relativizzati.<br />

La bi-logica ha fornito strumenti per capire la parte inconscia dei ragionamento<br />

discorsivi [MATTE-BLANCO].<br />

Analizzare mediante la bi-logica un determinato argomento o addirittura<br />

una argomentazione completa è un lavoro non facile e, in ogni caso, destinato<br />

a rimanere incompiuto. Tuttavia anche alcuni passi in questa direzione possono<br />

chiarire alcune delle radici psicologiche del ragionamento, i loro gradi<br />

di forza di persuasione e le loro fallace.<br />

La forza persuasiva di una argomentazione è determinata dalla combinazione<br />

tra asimmetria e simmetria, tra logica (dell'identità) e analogia (somiglianza).<br />

Questa combinazione è efficace se si rispetta un canone fondamentale: la cogenza<br />

logica ha (se riconosciuta) una efficacia persuasiva in sé, alla quale può<br />

essere aggiunta la forza delle varie forme di emozioni. Tuttavia, poiché l'argomentazione<br />

rimane un discorso segmentato, con una successione di passaggi,<br />

la pura emozione (simmetria) non può valere oltre misura: lucem demonstrat<br />

umbra, umbram demonstrat lux.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / The clinical field (2)<br />

73


Terrorism and mafia (Room 1)<br />

Pam Kleinot 1 / Sandra Grant 2<br />

1<br />

Member of The Group Analytic Society International, Institute of Group Analysis, London, UK<br />

2<br />

Board Member of the Scottish Association of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapists, UK<br />

TERRORISM: RAGE AND LONGING<br />

There is increasing alarm about the increase in terrorist activities and threats,<br />

almost universally seen at present as being in an Islamist cause. One consequence<br />

has been a focus on trying to understand‘radicalisation’, where extremist<br />

ideas may lead to violent action. A source of puzzlement has been the<br />

motivation of “homegrown terrorists” who have grown up and been educated<br />

in a developed western country who have themselves identified with terrorist<br />

groups such as Daesh, commonly known as Isis. What are they raging and<br />

killing for? After all, haven’t they had it good, been raised well, in a liberal<br />

democracy?<br />

The authors take a psychoanalytic and group analytic perspective to contribute<br />

to this debate, calling on both theory and recent research. Remembering<br />

their own ‘radical’ youths in the 1960s and ‘70s, when “One man’s terrorist<br />

was another man’s freedom fighter”, they consider,apart from the negative<br />

anger and rage, what the positive ‘pull’factors for terrorism are, such as hope<br />

to make the world a better place.<br />

These themes will be illustrated with examples from Pam growing up in<br />

South Africa under state terrorism as well as her work with the families of<br />

suicide bombers in Palestine and Israel and Sandra’s work in a mosque with<br />

men traumatised by accusations of being potential terrorists.<br />

Pam Kleinot, a former journalist, is a psychoanalytic psychotherapist and<br />

group analyst who has worked in the National Health Service, Women’s Therapy<br />

Centre and Women’s prison. Sandra is a psychiatrist and psychoanalytic<br />

psychotherapist, who has worked as an NHS consultant and manager at local<br />

and national levels within Scotland.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

74


Terrorism and mafia (Room 1)<br />

Manfredi Zammataro 1,2 / Giulia Cusumano 1,2,3<br />

1<br />

Associazione Antiusura Antiracket Obiettivo Legalità, Catania, Sicilia, Italia<br />

2<br />

CODICI – Centro per i diritti del cittadino – Sicilia, Palermo, Sicilia, Italia<br />

3<br />

Università degli Studi di Catania, Dipartimento di Scienze Umanistiche, Catania, Sicilia, Italia<br />

MAFIA: PSYCHOLOGICAL FUNCTIONING BETWEEN TRADITIONAL<br />

BUSINESS AND NEW OPPORTUNITIES<br />

The Sicilian mafia appears nowadays as a reality strongly rooted in our territory<br />

despite the fact that Police and other Forces of the Law today fight incessantly<br />

against criminal clans, often reporting good results.<br />

So it is natural to wonder why the mafia phenomenon is still so alive. After<br />

a review of newspapers articles, investigations and other studies on mafia<br />

psychology, in addition to the examination of penal proceedings in which<br />

the Anti-racket and Anti-usury association “Obiettivo Legalità” has been involved<br />

against people accused of affiliation to the clans of East Sicily, an important<br />

characteristic has emerged: the mafia has an enormous capacity to<br />

adapt, transforming itself when new historic-economic exigencies manifest<br />

themselves, asking of the clan a change (but maintaining traditional family<br />

laws) that allows them to survive despite adverse conditions.<br />

A concrete sign of this is the current tendency of mafia groups (in addition to<br />

traditional business like extortion, usury and narcotraffic that today involves<br />

new recruits such as people in conditions of extreme poverty who see in dealing<br />

drugs the opportunity to earn the money they need to live) to use European<br />

or State funds: clean money (obtained illicitly) available for the family.<br />

The mafia has today many entrepreneurs among its ranks, experts in economic<br />

mechanisms who are conscious of the possibilities of financing offered<br />

by the European reality; if necessary, it uses professionals to easily achieve the<br />

family aims and illicitly earn money for the clan.<br />

A new social class of white-collar mafia that, even if it kills less than in the<br />

past, still damages the economic reality of our country.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

75


Rage and mourning dynamics in the institutions and organizations (1) (Room 2)<br />

Angela Foster / Manza Kamal<br />

FRC consultants Organisational consultancy & professional development,<br />

London UK<br />

STAFF ACCUSED AND ABUSED; MANAGING PAIN AND DISTRESS IN THE<br />

SYSTEM OF CARE<br />

Much has been written about the impact of forensic patients on those who<br />

care for them while relatively little attention has been paid to the impact of<br />

the political climate - the culture of blame. When Bion omitted to address the<br />

anxiety his first Northfield experiment generated in his seniors their response<br />

was to close it down. When Baby P died (London 2007), Sharon Shoesmith<br />

the service director was publicly vilified. In both these cases it can be argued<br />

that the extreme response was punishment for failing to protect other from<br />

seeing things they preferred to remain ignorant of i.e. that soldiers become<br />

disturbed and mothers can kill their babies.<br />

The duty of care requires professionals to look after those deemed to be at<br />

risk and risky and to protect others from harm. This dual responsibility can<br />

place staff in a sandwich of persecutory anxiety in which they are also likely<br />

to experience depressive and existential anxieties. When a patient or client<br />

does something particularly alarming we worry about how to manage the<br />

immediate clinical situation, how to manage our managers and the external<br />

system and about our own abilities and our survival.<br />

While some degree of anxiety may be helpful as a motivator, too much is anxiety<br />

inhibits our ability to think hence the management of anxiety is crucial<br />

to good practice. Reference will be made to the theme of rage and mourning<br />

in clinical teams.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

76


Rage and mourning dynamics in the institutions and organizations (1) (Room 2)<br />

Lisa Gardiner<br />

Presenter Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist and Forensic Psychotherapist,<br />

Ravenswood House, Knowle, Hampshire, UK<br />

FORENSIC HOSPITALS AND PATHOLOGICAL ORGANIZATIONS:<br />

DESTRUCTIVE NARCISSISM IN THE INTERNAL WORLD AND IN THE<br />

SOCIAL DEFENCE SYSTEM<br />

PDestructive narcissism is an important feature of the internal worlds of patients<br />

in Forensic Hospital settings. The development of this idea has led to<br />

concepts such as the claustrum, the claustro-agoraphobic dilemma and the<br />

psychic retreat. These further help to understand the murderous internal<br />

worlds of our patients.<br />

However, patients are often held in a hospital setting. The development of<br />

theories around social defence systems as a means of managing anxiety in<br />

institutions has high relevance to the task of caring for Forensic in-patients.<br />

These also help to focus our attention on the internal worlds of the staff working<br />

in these settings.<br />

There is a great deal of resonance between the concept of the Pathological<br />

Organisation and the Social Defence Systems that evolve in Forensic Institutions.<br />

This presentation aims to consider the two theoretical models and<br />

their relevance – not only to working in a Forensic Hospital setting but in<br />

how these interplay to prevent the work of mourning as an essential task for<br />

patients and staff in an institution set up to contain the most frightening and<br />

dangerous individuals in society.<br />

Methods: PowerPoint presentation / workshop with participant discussion of<br />

theoretical and clinical material<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

77


Long term segregation (Room 3)<br />

Katya Orrell / Elena Mundici<br />

Panoptikon, London, UK<br />

SWANSONG: CAN HOPE SURVIVE AN INDETERMINATE PRISON SENTENCE?<br />

‘Piles of junk. …an overturned stool. Night. Darkness.’<br />

These stage directions from Chekhov’s ‘Swansong’ could be describing the<br />

prison wing, both physically and metaphorically. His play depicts a drunk,<br />

elderly comic actor who has fallen asleep after the performance is over and<br />

awakes to a deserted theatre. He speaks, and is answered by the prompter<br />

responding from the darkness, an image not unlike the therapeutic dyad.<br />

Over the past year, perhaps more than ever before, working psychodynamically<br />

in a man’s prison has felt dangerous. For the man serving an IPP sentence,<br />

a sentence with no finite ending, the threat of psychic death, the death<br />

of hope, is the sword of Damocles which hangs over his every day. In this<br />

paper, we examine what it means to adapt our work with a man who never<br />

knows when he will leave prison and how he manages those feelings.<br />

Using the concept of the swansong, a song considered to be more beautiful<br />

because of the fragility of a life that is about to end, we ask what is happening<br />

when a prisoner whose unprocessed grief and rage threatens to destroy all<br />

creativity.<br />

We explore how the danger of his internal destructiveness meets, and is also<br />

reflected by, the actual threat of our own extinction as forensic psychotherapists.<br />

What happens to the work, to the ability to contain, when the relationship<br />

with the prison itself feels like a dangerous liaison, when each session<br />

feels like a Swansong?<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

78


Long term segregation (Room 3)<br />

Emma Allen<br />

Art Psychotherapist at Rampton Hospital & Senior Lecturer in Art Psychotherapy<br />

at the University of South Wales, UK<br />

THE BOY WHO CRIED WOLF: A COLLABORATIVE APPROACH TO LONG<br />

TERM SEGREGATION<br />

This paper presents a unique account of a transdisciplinary approach, combining<br />

dialectical behavioural therapy (DBT) and art psychotherapy to longterm<br />

segregation and seclusion in a National High Secure Learning Disability<br />

Service. The rationale for joint psychology and art psychotherapy sessions<br />

with both a female and male therapist is discussed, along with how risk was<br />

managed.<br />

Purpose: The paper describes the clinical work with one patient, and discusses<br />

both advantages and challenges of ‘re-parenting’ through the seclusion<br />

hatch, whilst exploring transference and countertransference difficulties of<br />

defectiveness, shame, rage and mourning.<br />

Methods: A collaborative, cross-disciplinary, dialectical behavioural therapy<br />

(DBT) and art psychotherapy approach to long term segregation (LTS) in the<br />

National High Secure Learning Disability Service; Usingthe ‘I Can Feel Good<br />

(ICFG) Programme: Skills for training people with intellectual disabilities<br />

and problems managing emotions’ (Ingamells and Morrissey, 2014),mindfulness,<br />

image-making and schema therapy supervision.<br />

Results: Identifying the benefits and challenges of transdisciplinary work<br />

(DBT, Art Psychotherapy, Schema) whilst also contributing to the sparse literature<br />

on LTS and engaging with patients ‘through the seclusion hatch’.<br />

Conclusions: Athree-way therapeutic relationship offers an alternative sense<br />

of containment to that offered by seclusion. A transdisciplinary ‘re-parenting’<br />

process for patients’ ‘victim’ and ‘perpetrator’ identities allows therapists to<br />

work with both the ‘boy’ and the ‘wolf ‘’, surviving ongoing allegations and<br />

threats of violence.<br />

PARALLEL SESSION / Organizations and Institutions<br />

79


Notes


Notes


Local PCO<br />

www.medeacom.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!