03.05.2017 Views

WWBA May 2017 Newsletter

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Westchester Women’s Bar Association<br />

MAY <strong>2017</strong><br />

<strong>WWBA</strong><br />

~ IN MEMORY OF ~<br />

HONORABLE SHEILA ABDUS-SALAAM<br />

Associate Judge of the New York Court of Appeals<br />

It is with deep regret and sadness that the Westchester<br />

Women’s Bar Association notes the passing of Honorable<br />

Sheila Abdus-Salaam.<br />

Judge Abdus-Salaam began her legal career as a legal<br />

services attorney, served as an Assistant Attorney General<br />

for New York State, and served as General Counsel of the<br />

New York City Office of Labor Services. In 1991, she was<br />

elected a Judge of the New York City Civil Court, the first<br />

Muslim to serve as a judge of any court in the United States.<br />

She was later elected and re-elected as a Justice of the New<br />

York Supreme Court. In 2009, she was appointed as an Associate<br />

Justice of the New York Supreme Court’s Appellate<br />

Division for the First Department. In 2013, she was appointed<br />

to serve as Associate Judge of the New York State Court of Appeals, becoming<br />

the first black woman to serve on New York’s highest court.<br />

Judge Abdus-Salaam was a gifted jurist who dedicated her life to public service.<br />

We celebrate her extraordinary life, kindness and unmistakable impact on<br />

the entire legal community. Our sincerest condolences to her family and many<br />

friends. Her presence will be terribly missed. ◗<br />

INSIDE THIS ISSUE<br />

MAY <strong>2017</strong><br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Women’s History<br />

Month Program: Diversity<br />

and Inclusion<br />

(page 4)<br />

An Interview with<br />

Judge Shelley S. <strong>May</strong>er<br />

(page 7)<br />

<strong>May</strong> Litigation Tip<br />

(page 9)<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Upcoming Events<br />

(page 12)<br />

SAVE THE DATE<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

news<br />

www.wwbany.org<br />

Honorable Sheila<br />

Abdus-Salaam<br />

ABCs ON THE<br />

AMERICANS WITH<br />

DISABILITIES ACT<br />

<strong>May</strong> 9, <strong>2017</strong><br />

Sterling National Bank<br />

Tuckahoe, New York<br />

WESTCHESTER<br />

WOMEN’S BAR<br />

ASSOCIATION<br />

ANNUAL DINNER<br />

June 7, <strong>2017</strong><br />

Mamaroneck Beach<br />

and Yacht Club<br />

Mamaroneck, New York<br />

PRESIDENT’S<br />

MESSAGE<br />

It’s <strong>May</strong>. This time of<br />

year begins a series<br />

of festivities, remembrances,<br />

and soon,<br />

graduations. As the<br />

flowers start to bloom<br />

and we are reminded<br />

that summer is just<br />

around the corner,<br />

we pause to celebrate<br />

our accomplishments<br />

and note what might<br />

Susan Edwards<br />

Colson<br />

have led us to those achievements. We<br />

begin with our very own lawyer’s commemorative:<br />

Law Day.<br />

President Eisenhower established<br />

Law Day on February 3, 1958 by declaring:<br />

“the principle of guaranteed fundamental<br />

rights of individuals under the<br />

law is the heart and sinew of our Nation,<br />

and distinguishes our governmental<br />

systems from the type of government<br />

that rules by might alone” and “a day of<br />

national dedication to the principle of<br />

government under laws would afford us<br />

an opportunity better to understand and<br />

appreciate the manifold virtues of such<br />

a government and to focus the attention<br />

of the world upon them.”<br />

Each year, the ABA selects a theme<br />

for Law Day to highlight a specific aspect<br />

of the rule of law. This year the<br />

focus is: The 14th Amendment: Transforming<br />

American Democracy. As the<br />

ABA notes:<br />

This theme provides the opportunity<br />

to explore the many ways that<br />

the Fourteenth Amendment has reshaped<br />

American law and society.<br />

Through its Citizenship, Due Process<br />

and Equal Protection clauses,<br />

continued on page 3 ➥<br />

Page 1<br />

The Westchester Women’s Bar Association is a Chapter of the Women’s Bar Association of the State of New York


<strong>WWBA</strong> Member <strong>Newsletter</strong><br />

MAY Y <strong>2017</strong><br />

Published Monthly by the<br />

Westchester Women’s<br />

Bar Association, a Chapter of<br />

the Women’s Bar Association<br />

of the State of New York<br />

~ 2016/<strong>2017</strong> Officers and Directors ~<br />

President SUSAN EDWARDS COLSON<br />

Vice Presidents<br />

LISA M. DENIG JOELLE M. BURTON JENNIFER N. NETROSIO<br />

Treasurer<br />

AMANDA C. FRIED Recording Secretary ANGELA MORCONE GIANNINI<br />

Corresponding Secretary KIM BERG<br />

Immediate Past ast President<br />

ROBIN D. CARTON<br />

Elected Directors Westchester Board<br />

GAIL M. BOGGIO HÉLÈNE CÔTÉ AMY E. GEWIRTZ<br />

LONYA A. GILBERT SHARI R. GORDON<br />

State Directors Women’s Bar Association of the State of New York<br />

ROBIN D. CARTON KITLEY S. COVILL DONNA E. FROSCO<br />

MARIAN GENIO THERESA A. GIROLAMO ANNETTE G. HASAPIDIS JAMIESON L. KEISER<br />

ADRIENNE J. ORBACH SUSAN MILLS RICHMOND JANE SILVERMAN<br />

Executive Director ELISABETH CAMPOS<br />

© Copyright 2016 Westchester Women’s Bar Association. All rights reserved.<br />

The opinions expressed herein are those of the author(s) only and do not reflect the official position of the Association.<br />

Editor-in-Chief: Kim Berg • Designed and Printed by IPM Media Group, Inc. (516) 809-0501<br />

2016-<strong>2017</strong> <strong>WWBA</strong> Committee Chairs<br />

S T A N D I N G C O M M I T T E E S<br />

By-Laws .................................................................. Anna L. Georgiou<br />

Corporate & Commercial ........................ Lisa M. Bluestein, Eva David<br />

Criminal Law ....... Kitley S. Covill, Lisa M. Denig, Hon. Sandra A. Forster<br />

Families’, Children & the Courts .......... Shari R. Gordon, Joy S. Joseph,<br />

Lauren Morrissey, Hon. Irene Ratner<br />

Grievance/Ethics ............................ Kitley S. Covill, Deborah A. Scalise<br />

Judicial Screening ............... Hon. Sandra A. Forster, Loren I. Glassman<br />

Judiciary .......... Hon. Delores Scott Brathwaite, Hon. Linda S. Jamieson<br />

Lawyering & Parenting ............................................... Joelle M. Burton,<br />

Jana Kosberg-Kleidman<br />

Legislation ................................................. Angela Morcone Gianinni<br />

Matrimonial .......... Robin Carton, Dolores Gebhardt, Lonya A. Gilbert<br />

Annual Dinner ......... Robin D. Carton, Lisa M. Denig, Jennifer L. Gray,<br />

Stephanie Melowsky, Jennifer N. Netrosio<br />

Annual Dinner Souvenir Journal ................................................. TBD<br />

Appellate Practice ....................... Lisa M. Denig, Hon. Mark C. Dillon,<br />

Hon. Sondra M. Miller, Hon. Robert A. Spolzino<br />

Archive & Historian ..................................................... Susan L. Pollet<br />

Awards ............................................. Elizabeth M. Barnhard, Kim Berg<br />

Bankruptcy ................... Susan Mills Richmond, Wendy Marie Weathers<br />

Breast Cancer Awareness ...................................... Adrienne J. Orbach<br />

Collaborative Law ........................... Kathleen Donelli, John J. Grimes,<br />

Lynn J. Maier, Hon. Sondra M. Miller<br />

Community Outreach ... Deborah A. Scalise, Hon. Lisa Margaret Smith<br />

Continuing Legal Education ..................................... Ann M. McNulty<br />

Diversity in Membership ........... Jacqueline Hattar, Stephanie Melowsky<br />

Domestic Violence ...................... Natanya L. Briendel, Audrey E. Stone<br />

Education Law ....................... Adrienne J. Arkontaky, Julie P. Passman,<br />

Susan Mills Richmond<br />

Elder & Health Law ............. Patricia L. Angley, Elizabeth A. Cumming,<br />

Shari R. Gordon<br />

Employment Law ...................................... Kim Berg, Hillary Raimondi<br />

Environmental & Land Use .......... Lucia Chiocchio, Anna L. Georgiou,<br />

Jennifer L. Gray, Katherine Zalantis<br />

Gender Dynamics ...................................... Hon. Terry Jane Ruderman<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

A D H O C C O M M I T T E E S<br />

Membership ............................................... Sherry Bishko, Hélène Côté<br />

Networking ................................... Jennifer L. Gray, Patricia McCluskey<br />

New Lawyers ............................. Elizabeth Marcus, Jennifer N. Netrosio<br />

Professional Development .............. Adam J. Krim, Stephanie Melowsky<br />

Programs ........................................... Lucia Chiocchio, Amanda Fried<br />

Public Relations ............................... Joelle M. Burton, Jennifer L. Gray<br />

Real Property ............................ Melanie Finkel, Hon. Sandra A. Forster<br />

Sponsorship .................................. Lisa M. Bluestein, Lucia Chiocchio,<br />

Joelle M. Burton<br />

Taxation ....................................................................................... TBD<br />

Trusts & Estates ................................... Gail M. Boggio, Anna B. Parker,<br />

Nancy J. Rudolph, Karen J. Walsh<br />

Golf & Tennis Outing ................................................................ TBD<br />

Holiday Party and Boutique ...... Dolores Gebhardt, Jennifer N. Netrosio<br />

Immigration ................................................................. Henry Mascia<br />

Insurance ..................................................................... Dawn Warren<br />

Intellectual Property .............. Elizabeth M. Barnhard, Donna E. Frosco,<br />

Theresa O’Rourke Nugent<br />

Judgment Enforcement & Collections .............. Christopher T. Bonante,<br />

Daniel F. Florio, Jr.<br />

Litigation ...................... Angela Morcone Giannini, Jacqueline Hattar<br />

Kimberly Sheehan<br />

Long Range Planning ............... Lisa M. Bluestein, Carla D. Glassman,<br />

Linda Markowitz, Ann M. McNulty<br />

Mediation ............................ Amy Carron Day, Hon. Sondra M. Miller,<br />

Lauren S. Morrissey, Abby Rosmarin<br />

Network of Bar Leaders ............................................. Donna E. Frosco<br />

Pace Board of Visitors ....................... Gail M. Boggio, Lonya A. Gilbert<br />

Past Presidents ........... Jane Bilus Gould, Mary F. Kelly, Linda Markowitz<br />

Practice Management ......... Jamieson L. Keiser, Wendy Marie Weathers<br />

Pro Bono .................................................. Marcia Levy, Marian Genio<br />

Technology/Website .......... Donna E. Frosco, Theresa O’Rourke Nugent<br />

WCA Board Delegate ............................................ Anthony Morando<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Foundation President ....................................... Julie S. Kattan<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Representative Director to the WCBA Board .. Dolores Gebhardt<br />

Page 2<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

President’s Message<br />

from page 1<br />

“[T]he rights and<br />

freedoms we enjoy,<br />

and consider second<br />

nature . . . are just<br />

distant ideals unless<br />

we, as lawyers,<br />

make them more<br />

understandable.”<br />

this transformative amendment advanced<br />

the rights of all Americans. It<br />

also played a pivotal role in extending<br />

the reach of the Bill of Rights to<br />

the states. Ratified during Reconstruction<br />

a century and a half ago, the<br />

Fourteenth Amendment serves as the<br />

cornerstone of landmark civil rights<br />

legislation, the foundation for numerous<br />

federal court decisions protecting<br />

fundamental rights, and a source<br />

of inspiration for all those who advocate<br />

for equal justice under law.<br />

This theme reminds us that many of<br />

the rights and freedoms we enjoy, and consider<br />

second nature – are derived from the<br />

Fourteenth Amendment. Of course, these<br />

are just distant ideals unless we, as lawyers,<br />

make them more understandable. Many<br />

thanks to Past President Deborah Scalise<br />

for providing the leadership and coordination<br />

of the <strong>WWBA</strong>’s local celebration this<br />

year on <strong>May</strong> 23, <strong>2017</strong>. Year after year, the<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong>, through the efforts of the long-serving<br />

members of this committee, have made<br />

Law Day a real local celebration and an<br />

experience of what the rule-of-law promises<br />

and involves.<br />

While Law Day is a one day reminder<br />

to celebrate our rights under the law, THE<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> is constantly teaching about the legal<br />

process through our various programs<br />

and initiatives. Natanya Briendel, Pace<br />

Women’s Justice Center, has recently been<br />

instrumental in coordinating a series of volunteer<br />

training workshops in conjunction<br />

with the Community Resource Center in<br />

Mamaroneck. These workshops are offered<br />

continued on page 10 ➥<br />

Editor’s Note<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

The fastest way to break the cycle of perfectionism and become a fearless mother<br />

is to give up the idea of doing it perfectly – indeed to embrace uncertainty and<br />

imperfection.<br />

~ Arianna Huffington<br />

Making Dates and Getting Published<br />

NEWSLETTER SUBMISSIONS<br />

❑ Deadline for newsletter submissions is the 12th of the month prior to publication (submissions<br />

received after the deadline are subject to the discretion of the editor).<br />

❑ Send submissions as email attachments to Kim Berg at kberg@gouldberglaw.com.<br />

❑ Articles should be 1,000 words or fewer. Remove all pagination, headers, footers or other<br />

formatting, other than bold, underline or italics. Authors are encouraged to submit photographs<br />

for publication with their submissions and include a short biographical statement with<br />

their submissions.<br />

❑ Materials submitted allow the <strong>WWBA</strong> a limited copyright and full permission to reprint the<br />

material in any <strong>WWBA</strong> publication or on its website without additional consent.<br />

❑ Photographs must be high-resolution (150 dpi or more) and the subject and all persons in<br />

each photograph must be fully identified.<br />

PROGRAM SCHEDULING<br />

❑ First visit the <strong>WWBA</strong> website: www.wwbany.org and click on the calendar at the home page to<br />

view scheduled programs. Conflicts in scheduling will be assessed on a case by case basis, with<br />

priority for early submissions.<br />

❑ Contact Kim Berg at kberg@gouldberglaw.com to schedule a <strong>WWBA</strong> sponsored or cosponsored<br />

program, including committee meetings, CLE programs, etc.<br />

❑ Once you have reserved the date with Kim Berg, proceed with planning your program and<br />

creating your flyer.<br />

❑ Flyers must be approved by the Programs Committee. In advance of the 12th of the month,<br />

please send your flyer to the Program Committee Co-chairs for review and copy the Executive<br />

Director. Once approved, please send your final flyer to the Executive Director, Kim Berg and the<br />

President for publication on the website calendar and the newsletter calendar. The final flyer will<br />

also be emailed to the membership.<br />

❑ We will also consider publicizing programs from outside organizations that may be of interest<br />

to our members.<br />

❑ Post-event: You may report on the success of your program and provide photographs of the<br />

speakers and participants that can be included in an upcoming newsletter. Send your submission<br />

to Lisa M. Denig, following the guidelines above.<br />

Contacts<br />

Kim Berg, Corresponding Secretary and <strong>Newsletter</strong> Editor-in-Chief: kberg@gouldberglaw.com<br />

Lucia Chiocchio, Programs Committee Co-Chair: lchiocchio@cuddyfeder.com<br />

Amanda Fried, Programs Committee Co-Chair: afried@cartonrosoff.com<br />

Susan Edwards Colson, President: president@wwbany.org<br />

Ann M. McNulty, CLE Chair: ann.m.mcnulty@morganstanley.com<br />

Elisabeth Campos, Executive Director: executivedirector@wwbany.org<br />

A d v e r t i s i n g R a t e s<br />

Full Page Display Ad<br />

5-10 Issues - $525.00 per issue<br />

1-4 Issues - $575.00 per issue<br />

Half Page Display Ad<br />

5-10 Issues - $275.00 per issue<br />

1-4 Issues - $300.00 per issue<br />

Quarter Page Display Ad<br />

5-10 Issues - $165.00 per issue<br />

1-4 Issues - $180.00 per issue<br />

Business Card Ad<br />

5-10 Issues - $60.00 per issue<br />

1-4 Issues - $75.00 per issue<br />

Classified – office space, furniture/equipment, employment & situation wanted (up to 5 lines)<br />

Members - $50.00 first issue; $25.00 each succeeding issue; Non-Members - $75.00 per issue<br />

Back Cover (3/4 page)<br />

5-10 Issues - $650.00 per issue; 1-4 Issues - $700.00 per issue<br />

Deadline for all ads is the 12th of the month prior to publication. Ads are subject to space limitations.<br />

Call Kim Berg at (914) 397-1050 or kberg@gouldberglaw.com for any questions regarding advertising.<br />

Page 3


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

A DISCUSSION ON DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION:<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Pesents Women’s History Month Program<br />

Featuring NYSBA President Claire Gutekunst<br />

Diversity Program<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

Stephanie Melowsky and<br />

Jacqueline Hattar<br />

Claire Gutekunst, the<br />

president of the New York<br />

State Bar Association<br />

(NYSBA), was the guest<br />

speaker at a lecture on “A<br />

Discussion on Diversity and<br />

Inclusion” that was held on<br />

March 28, <strong>2017</strong> at Wilson<br />

Elser’s office in White Plains.<br />

The program, held in celebration<br />

of Women’s History<br />

Month, was presented by the<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong>’s Diversity and Litigation<br />

Committees and the<br />

Ninth Judicial District’s Committee<br />

on Gender Fairness in<br />

the Courts, and was supported<br />

by Wilson Elser.<br />

The program, which was<br />

very-well attended, is part of<br />

the <strong>WWBA</strong>’s Continuing Lecture<br />

Series on Diversity in the<br />

Legal Profession. The authors<br />

were proud to serve as panelists<br />

at this program.<br />

Ms. Gutekunst, whose<br />

achievements are truly impressive,<br />

has been active in<br />

the State Bar for approximately<br />

30 years. She has<br />

served as the NYSBA’s treasurer<br />

from 2011 to 2013 and<br />

is currently a member of the<br />

Commercial and Federal Litigation<br />

Section’s Executive<br />

Committee, the Legislative<br />

Policy Committee and the<br />

Membership Committee. She<br />

previously served on the Executive<br />

Committee as vice<br />

president for the First Judicial<br />

District and as a member-atlarge.<br />

Ms. Gutekunst chaired<br />

the Membership Committee,<br />

Committee on Women in the<br />

Law and Strategic Planning<br />

Advisory Committee. She was<br />

vice chair of the Dispute<br />

Resolution Section and cochaired<br />

the President’s Committee<br />

on Access to Justice.<br />

She also was a longtime<br />

member of the Committee on<br />

Diversity and Inclusion. She<br />

previously worked for approximately<br />

30 years at<br />

Proskauer Rose, first as an<br />

associate and then as a partner.<br />

After leaving Proskauer<br />

Rose in 2012, Ms. Gutekunst<br />

established her own practice<br />

and is currently an independent<br />

arbitrator and mediator.<br />

During the March 28th<br />

lecture, Ms. Gutekunst discussed<br />

her journey through<br />

the NYSBA and the various<br />

diversity and inclusion initia-<br />

continued on page 6 ➥<br />

A Leader in Serving the<br />

Legal Services Community.<br />

That’s Sterling.<br />

Expect the highest caliber of personal<br />

service and banking expertise.<br />

Expect extraordinary.<br />

Contact banking professionals<br />

experienced in serving your<br />

unique needs 914-367-9000:<br />

Michael Henderson,<br />

Senior Managing Director<br />

Larry McElroen, Managing Director<br />

Anthony Forgione, Managing Director<br />

Moira Kiernan, Managing Director<br />

To learn about Sterling’s full suite<br />

of services, visit snb.com<br />

Stephanie Melowsky, Claire Gutekunst, Jaqueline Hattar<br />

Page 4<br />

Member<br />

FDIC<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong>’S FOURTH GENERAL MEMBERSHIP MEETING<br />

A Conversation with the Federal Judges in White Plains<br />

Kim Berg<br />

Members of the <strong>WWBA</strong> and the Federal<br />

Bar Association were privileged to attend<br />

“A Conversation with the Federal<br />

Judges in White Plain”" on April 4, <strong>2017</strong> at<br />

the lovely LaBocca restaurant in White<br />

Plains. This was the <strong>WWBA</strong>’s fourth and<br />

final General Membership Meeting this year.<br />

The Honorable Nelson S. Roman,<br />

United States District Judge, and Honorable<br />

Lisa M. Smith, United States Magistrate<br />

Judge, candidly answered questions<br />

posed by moderator Donna Frosco. The<br />

topics covered procedural and substantive<br />

content for all facets of federal court litigation,<br />

from pleadings to discovery and<br />

through trial. Topics included:<br />

❑ attorney preparedness and the importance<br />

of having a good, working knowledge<br />

about matters on which they appear<br />

in court;<br />

❑ resolution of discovery disputes and the<br />

Court’s rules governing expeditious resolution<br />

of disputes by the Magistrate Judges;<br />

❑ motion practice, including effective strategies<br />

for making or defending motions, pit-<br />

Hon. Lisa Margaret Smith, Hon. Nelson S.<br />

Roman, Donna Frosco<br />

falls to avoid when writing memoranda of<br />

law, and the importance of citations, both<br />

to the record for support of any factual assertions<br />

and to statutes and case law for<br />

legal arguments;<br />

❑ the critical importance of laying a proper<br />

foundation for the admission of evidence<br />

at a trial and how failure to do so could<br />

result in the exclusion of evidence; and<br />

❑ strategies used in mediating/settling<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

claims.<br />

The practical tips provided from the<br />

esteemed panel of Judges provided practitioners<br />

with excellent guidance on how to<br />

approach all phases of litigation and<br />

stressed the importance of narrowing the<br />

issues before the court.<br />

Judge Roman and Judge Smith also<br />

both aptly focused on maintaining a high<br />

standard of professionalism in what is usually<br />

an adversarial setting – not only when<br />

appearing before the Court but also toward<br />

colleagues, clients, and courthouse staff.<br />

In sum, maintaining one’s credibility, not<br />

only in presenting an accurate version of<br />

the “facts” and the “law” with supporting<br />

cites to the record and case law, but also<br />

pointing out that the manner in which you<br />

interact with judges, their staff, attorneys,<br />

and litigants can also impact your credibility.<br />

Those <strong>WWBA</strong> members in attendance<br />

also voted to accept the amended by laws<br />

and the slate of officers and directors for<br />

WBASNY and the Westchester Chapter for<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-2018 (see page 10). ◗<br />

Matrimonial Committee Presents CLE on Counsel Fees<br />

Dolores Gebhardt<br />

My much-anticipated CLE program,<br />

“Whatever Happened to Prichep: Counsel<br />

Fees in Matrimonial Actions and in<br />

Family Court” was held on March 22,<br />

<strong>2017</strong> at Sterling National Bank in Tuckahoe.<br />

I was very grateful to have as my<br />

fellow panelists Hon. Linda Christopher,<br />

J.S.C., Supervising Judge of the Matrimonial<br />

Part, and Hon. Sherri Eisenpress,<br />

J.F.C., Acting Supreme Court Justice in<br />

Rockland County.<br />

The name Prichep refers to a landmark<br />

2008 Appellate Division, Second<br />

Department decision on interim counsel<br />

fees written by former Presiding Judge A.<br />

Gail Prudenti. The decision made it considerably<br />

easier for the less-monied spouse<br />

to get an award of interim counsel fees<br />

from the monied spouse in a timely manner.<br />

Two years later, in 2010, Domestic<br />

Relations Law § 237, which provides for<br />

counsel fee awards, was revised to reflect<br />

the holding in Prichep – allegedly! One<br />

of the goals of this lecture was to demonstrate<br />

via an analysis of the language of<br />

the statute that the 2010 amendments to<br />

DRL § 237 are actually not a codification<br />

of Prichep.<br />

A second goal was to show how<br />

Prichep and the 2010 amendments solved<br />

a significant problem for practitioners –<br />

interim fee awards are now largely made<br />

right away, rather than deferred to trial.<br />

However, neither the case nor the revised<br />

statute help matrimonial attorneys with our<br />

other problem: the fees awarded are usually<br />

less – sometimes far less – than the<br />

amount requested. My third goal was to<br />

show how both Prichep and the 2010<br />

amendments have been eroded by several<br />

recent decisions.<br />

Also featured were: the different<br />

analysis the Courts use for determining<br />

requests for final counsel fees; methods<br />

of getting paid from one’s own client;<br />

and how to get counsel fees in enforcement<br />

cases, modification cases, Family<br />

Court cases, and on appeal. I explained<br />

the difference between seeking a counsel<br />

fee award pursuant to DRL § 237 and<br />

pursuant to 22 NYCRR § 130-1.1 (the<br />

“sanctions” rule).<br />

Justices Christopher and Eisenpress<br />

explained what they are looking for in a<br />

fee application, as well as their rationale<br />

for determining the amount to award.<br />

The Justices and I led a spirited discussion<br />

with the audience, which consisted<br />

of many of the field’s prominent<br />

practitioners, as well as matrimonial<br />

judges and law secretaries. It was a great<br />

evening, and we all learned useful information.<br />

I extend my grateful thanks to the<br />

Justices, to our host, Sterling National<br />

Bank, and to our sponsor, Family Law<br />

Software. ◗<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

Page 5


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

WWA’s Launch Event for Report on the Status of<br />

Women in Westchester County<br />

Jacqueline Hattar<br />

The Westchester<br />

Women’s Agenda (WWA)<br />

held a launch event on<br />

March 21, <strong>2017</strong> at the<br />

Eileen Fisher Learning Lab in<br />

Irvington, New York, on its<br />

“2016 Report on the Status<br />

of Women in Westchester<br />

County.” The event included<br />

a panel discussion regarding<br />

the key findings contained<br />

in the report. The panelists<br />

included WWA Board<br />

members Colleen<br />

Braithwaite, Sheila Klatzky<br />

and Maria Imperial. The<br />

panel discussion was moderated<br />

by Robi Schlaff, the<br />

executive director of the<br />

Westchester County Office<br />

for Women. WWA’s cochair,<br />

Antoinette Klatzky, provided<br />

introductory remarks.<br />

The panel discussed the challenges<br />

facing women and<br />

families in the county, including<br />

the high cost of child<br />

care, a growing elderly<br />

population which strains their<br />

resources, and wage disparities<br />

which continue to<br />

favor men.<br />

The WWA commissioned<br />

the report to advise<br />

on the social and economic<br />

status of women, and to further<br />

a climate that offers<br />

equal access and opportunity<br />

for women in Westchester<br />

County. The report aims to<br />

provide local data that will<br />

create a baseline on issues<br />

which are of concern to<br />

women. The report also<br />

strives to inspire the public to<br />

join in efforts to create programs<br />

for women and, therefore,<br />

improve the quality of<br />

life for everyone in<br />

Westchester.<br />

According to the report,<br />

the poverty in Westchester has<br />

worsened over the last five<br />

years for women, men and<br />

families. Poverty is higher for<br />

woman-headed families in<br />

Westchester, and it has gotten<br />

worse. The report also<br />

noted that educational levels<br />

have improved over the last<br />

five years, for both women<br />

and men. The educational<br />

levels of women slightly exceed<br />

those of men at the current<br />

time; however, at all levels<br />

of education, women still<br />

make less money than men.<br />

Based upon the U.S. Census<br />

data, the report stated that in<br />

2014, median earnings for<br />

women over the age of 25<br />

were $42,895. In comparison,<br />

for men over the age of<br />

25, the median earnings were<br />

$59,433.<br />

Additionally, the report<br />

stated that men outnumber<br />

women as Westchester<br />

County officials by a factor<br />

of 1.7 to 1. Of the seven<br />

largest corporations head-<br />

continued on page 9 ➥<br />

from page 4<br />

tives, including the Diversity<br />

reception that is held at the<br />

NYSBA Annual Meeting. She<br />

shared her experiences when<br />

she was an associate at<br />

Proskauer Rose, including<br />

how she was encouraged to<br />

participate in bar associations.<br />

She also expressed the<br />

value of diversity and inclusion<br />

and how it makes a law<br />

practice more beneficial and<br />

attractive for clients. Ms.<br />

Gutekunst encouraged looking<br />

at and improving one’s<br />

Maria Imperial, Sheila Klatsky, Colleen Braithwaite, and Robi Schlaff<br />

A Discussion in Diversity and Inclusion<br />

individual implicit bias and<br />

discussed bias interrupters<br />

which can mitigate the negative<br />

effects that this bias may<br />

have on peers. She also<br />

noted that those in positions<br />

of leadership have the ability<br />

and duty to mentor, sponsor<br />

and include less experienced<br />

associates.<br />

Ms. Hattar discussed<br />

Wilson’s Elser’s national<br />

Women’s Initiative (Women<br />

Attorneys Valued and Empowered),<br />

in connection with<br />

which she serves on its Steering<br />

Committee and helped<br />

to launch in 2015. She explained<br />

that its mission is to<br />

attract, develop and retain<br />

women attorneys by enhancing<br />

and strengthening their<br />

skills and by providing careeradvancing<br />

opportunities in<br />

client service, business development<br />

and leadership. It<br />

was a truly excellent program<br />

that included a lively and interesting<br />

discussion by the attendees.<br />

We wish to thank<br />

Wilson Elser for their generous<br />

support. ◗<br />

Page 6<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

An Interview with Hon. Shelley S. <strong>May</strong>er<br />

Susan L. Pollet<br />

Chair of the Archive and<br />

Historian Committee<br />

Q: You are a long-time<br />

member of the Westchester<br />

Women’s Bar Association.<br />

When did you join, and<br />

what prompted you to become<br />

a member?<br />

A: I was a “Founding Member”<br />

of the Western New<br />

York Chapter of the<br />

Women’s Bar Association<br />

in about 1979 when I<br />

graduated law school, and<br />

have been a member ever<br />

since. When I moved back<br />

to Westchester in 1985, I<br />

joined the Westchester<br />

Women’s Bar Association,<br />

and became active in the<br />

chapter. I have long believed<br />

that women lawyers<br />

had a unique and valuable<br />

perspective on the profession<br />

and on specific issues<br />

affecting women, and the<br />

Women’s Bar Association<br />

has been a major voice in<br />

that effort.<br />

Q: Tell us about your entire<br />

legal career, and why<br />

you became a member of<br />

the New York State Assembly.<br />

A: I graduated from SUNY<br />

Buffalo Law School in<br />

1979, and was already an<br />

activist on behalf of issues<br />

involving women and<br />

families. I joined a small<br />

Buffalo law firm right out<br />

of law school, handling<br />

family law and civil rights<br />

litigation, and then in 1982<br />

I started as an Assistant Attorney<br />

General in Attorney<br />

General Bob Abrams office<br />

in Buffalo. I began<br />

handling fascinating civil<br />

rights cases on behalf of<br />

“Childcare, quality after<br />

school, paid leave, and a<br />

higher minimum wage –<br />

these are the key economic<br />

challenges for women in<br />

the work force. I believe<br />

that we need to do more<br />

to ensure all workers,<br />

especially women, have a<br />

path to good paying jobs<br />

with room for growth<br />

and advancement.”<br />

the Attorney General, and in<br />

1983 my husband and I<br />

moved to NYC and I continued<br />

in the Civil Rights Bureau<br />

of the Attorney<br />

General’s office. I spent 12<br />

years with the Attorney General,<br />

specializing on issues involving<br />

women, families, reproductive<br />

health care and<br />

legislative advocacy, including<br />

several years as the head<br />

of the Westchester Regional<br />

Office. Later, I spent 7 years<br />

as the Vice President of Government<br />

and Community Affairs<br />

for St. Luke’s-Roosevelt<br />

Hospital and then Continuum<br />

Health Partners, handling<br />

their very challenging<br />

community affairs in New<br />

York City as well as all their<br />

legislative issues on the local,<br />

state and federal level.<br />

I then worked for 3 years at<br />

the law firm Manatt, Phelps<br />

and Phillips handling advocacy<br />

for non- profits in the<br />

health care sector.<br />

Having grown up in Yonkers,<br />

and having cared<br />

deeply about politics all my<br />

life, I was anxious to return<br />

home and see how I could<br />

contribute to the large, diverse<br />

and challenging city<br />

that was my home. In 2006,<br />

I ran for the Assembly in Yonkers<br />

and lost by a narrow<br />

margin. I knew I would run<br />

again, and after 4 years as<br />

General Counsel to the NYS<br />

Senate Democrats in Albany,<br />

I ran again in 2012 in a special<br />

election after Mike<br />

Spano left the Assembly to<br />

become <strong>May</strong>or. I was<br />

elected in a Special Election<br />

on March 20, 2012 and<br />

subsequently re-elected in<br />

2012 and 2014. I am running<br />

again this November.<br />

While in the Assembly, I<br />

have fought to increase the<br />

minimum wage and pass<br />

paid family leave, increase<br />

Hon. Shelley S. <strong>May</strong>er<br />

state funding for the Yonkers<br />

Public Schools, obtain<br />

funding for afterschool services,<br />

pass legislation to<br />

protect vulnerable senior<br />

citizens, and pushed for<br />

increased attention and resources<br />

for child care.<br />

Among my Committee assignments<br />

are the Assembly<br />

Labor, Education, Children<br />

& Families, and Social<br />

Services committees,<br />

where I pride myself on my<br />

commitment to New York’s<br />

working families as well as<br />

those whose voices are often<br />

unheard. I serve as<br />

chair of the Assembly Education<br />

Sub-Committee on<br />

Students with Special<br />

Needs and each year I<br />

advocate for additional<br />

state funding for the special<br />

schools that serve disabled<br />

children. I believe in<br />

responsive, respectful civil<br />

engagement with all of our<br />

communities, and work on<br />

a bi-partisan basis with legislators<br />

from all of NYS to<br />

achieve my goals, if possible.<br />

Q: What do you think are<br />

continued on page 8 ➥<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

Page 7


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

An Interview with Hon. Shelley S. <strong>May</strong>er<br />

from page 7<br />

the most pressing issues of<br />

the day regarding women,<br />

children and families?<br />

A: Childcare, quality after<br />

school, paid leave, and a<br />

higher minimum wage –<br />

these are the key economic<br />

challenges for women in the<br />

work force. I believe that we<br />

need to do more to ensure<br />

all workers, especially<br />

women, have a path to<br />

good paying jobs with<br />

room for growth and advancement.<br />

I have also introduced<br />

and passed legislation<br />

to ensure parents<br />

have greater access to information<br />

about after<br />

school and child care providers,<br />

so they can make<br />

the best decision for themselves<br />

and their children. I<br />

strongly support small business<br />

growth and economic<br />

opportunity, and know that<br />

for many women, that is the<br />

path to economic self-sufficiency.<br />

I continue to be<br />

concerned that we have not<br />

adequately addressed the<br />

financial needs of seniors,<br />

particularly women and<br />

men without pensions, and<br />

I will be focused on that in<br />

the coming term.<br />

Q: What do you think the<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar<br />

Association should do going<br />

forward to work on<br />

those issues?<br />

A: Westchester Women’s<br />

Bar Association (<strong>WWBA</strong>)<br />

has a tremendous platform<br />

from which to educate the<br />

public and advocate for the<br />

advancement of women. It<br />

needs to continue to work<br />

in partnership and coalitions<br />

to further these issues<br />

in Albany and locally and<br />

remain committed to<br />

women’s issues, however<br />

they are defined.<br />

Q: What are your priority issues<br />

in the Assembly at this<br />

time?<br />

A: As an Assembly member<br />

representing only the City of<br />

Yonkers, my primary work<br />

each year is to to secure<br />

more education funding for<br />

the Yonkers Public Schools.<br />

As a district constantly struggling<br />

to provide students the<br />

services and programming<br />

they need and deserve,<br />

funding for the Yonkers Public<br />

Schools is an annual priority<br />

for me. I have also<br />

worked hard to ensure Yonkers<br />

residents and all New<br />

Yorkers have greater access<br />

to quality affordable housing,<br />

child care and after<br />

school programming, as<br />

well as reliable public transportation.<br />

On each of these<br />

issues, I work to secure resources<br />

through the budget<br />

process, as well as work in<br />

coalitions with other members<br />

and advocates to improve<br />

programming and<br />

services. I also work to support<br />

cities throughout the<br />

state, focus on economic<br />

growth and public transportation,<br />

and am an active<br />

advocate for unions and<br />

working people throughout<br />

New York.<br />

Q: What activities are you involved<br />

in, both professional,<br />

and personal, when you are<br />

not working on Assembly matters?<br />

A: I work full-time as an Assembly<br />

member, and no<br />

longer actively practice law.<br />

When I am not working on<br />

Assembly matters, narrowly<br />

defined, I am working to<br />

ensure Yonkers residents are<br />

informed, engaged and the<br />

strongest advocates they can<br />

be. In my personal life, when<br />

I am not working, I enjoy<br />

spending time with my husband,<br />

three adult children<br />

and their spouses and my<br />

granddaughter as well as a<br />

wonderful group of friends.<br />

I am a big Yonkers booster,<br />

and encourage all<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar<br />

Association members to visit,<br />

enjoy our restaurants and<br />

wonderful downtown on the<br />

River.<br />

Q: How have you managed<br />

to balance work and family<br />

all of these years?<br />

A: It has always been difficult<br />

to balance work and<br />

family, yet I was very fortunate<br />

to have had a supportive<br />

family, and flexible employers.<br />

There were times<br />

when my career took precedence<br />

over my husband’s,<br />

and my husband took on the<br />

role as primary caregiver,<br />

and there were times when<br />

both of us had demanding<br />

careers, and we relied on<br />

childcare support. We were<br />

always fortunate to have<br />

high quality childcare. I<br />

jumped between full time<br />

and part time many times,<br />

and did my best to make it<br />

work. I was blessed to have<br />

wonderful, supportive parents<br />

who lived nearby while<br />

our children were younger,<br />

and they provided emotional<br />

support for the ups and<br />

downs of work and family.<br />

I always counsel working<br />

women that the notion of<br />

balance is greatly exaggerated<br />

– you simply do<br />

the best you can.<br />

Q: What advice would you<br />

give to women lawyers entering<br />

the profession?<br />

A: Be open and flexible<br />

about the issues that motivate<br />

you. You may change<br />

your priorities over time,<br />

and that’s great. I found<br />

that money was never the<br />

most important thing in my<br />

job choices - rewarding<br />

and challenging work was<br />

far more important to me.<br />

My husband and I managed<br />

to get by in good<br />

times, and bad, including<br />

when we both lost our jobs<br />

on the same night as our<br />

elected Democratic bosses<br />

lost their election on the<br />

same day.<br />

Being a lawyer is a<br />

wonderful career and provides<br />

enormous opportunities<br />

beyond the courtroom.<br />

I encourage women lawyers<br />

to consider running for<br />

office – we need them in<br />

government!<br />

Q: What would you like to<br />

achieve in the coming<br />

years?<br />

A: I appreciate my current<br />

work in the NYS Assembly,<br />

and I look forward to continuing<br />

to serve the people<br />

of Yonkers and New York<br />

State for the next two years.<br />

I am focused on winning in<br />

November, but I am open<br />

to bigger challenges and<br />

the opportunity to have<br />

greater impact on New<br />

Yorkers in the future. ◗<br />

Page 8<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News


○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

<strong>May</strong> Litigation Tip<br />

✦ CPLR 1412 AND BURDEN OF PROOF ON SUMMARY<br />

JUDGMENT MOTIONS<br />

In the mid-1970’s New York joined the majority of other jurisdictions and rejected a<br />

plaintiff’s contributory negligence as a total bar to recovery. A system of comparative fault was<br />

adopted when the Legislature enacted CPLR 1412 which provides that culpable conduct shall<br />

be an affirmative defense to be pleaded and proved by the party asserting it. Thus, the party that<br />

seeks to diminish damages by pleading that plaintiff was negligent has the parallel burden of<br />

proving the comparable negligence.<br />

Despite CPLR 1412, case law in the Second Department has held where the summary judgment<br />

motion is on liability only, the plaintiff must establish that he or she is free of comparative<br />

fault. Day v. MTA, 94 AD3d 940 (2d Dept 2012); Roman v. A1 Limousine, Inc., 76 AD3d 552 (2d<br />

Dept. 2010). While the First Department, in Tselebis v. Ryder Truck Rental ,Inc., 72 AD3d 198<br />

(1st Dept. 2010) followed the plain intent of CPLR 1412 and held no such showing was required<br />

by the plaintiff, in the more recent decision of Rodriguez v City of New York, 142 AD3d 778 (1st<br />

Dept. 2016) the Court imposed the burden of proof of being free from comparative fault on the<br />

plaintiff. The decisions imposing the burden upon the plaintiff to prove freedom from comparative<br />

fault appear to rely on the Court of Appeals decision in Thoma v. Ronai, 82 NY2d 736<br />

(1993). The Thoma decision has raised much discussion. The decision held plaintiff did not<br />

satisfy her burden of demonstrating the absence of any material fact for summary judgment and<br />

therefore, the lower court properly denied summary judgment. Notably, the Thoma court did not<br />

address whether it was plaintiff’s prima facie burden to establish that she was free from comparative<br />

fault. Yet, after Thoma, the courts seem to have placed that burden upon the plaintiff.<br />

The NYSBA Committee on Civil Practice Law and Rules recognizing the need to clarify<br />

CPLR 1412, proposed an amendment that has been introduced in both the Senate (S.7779) and<br />

Assembly (A.02776). The amendment adds language to CPLR 1412 whereby the party asserting<br />

the affirmative defense “shall have the burden of interposing proof of culpable conduct when<br />

asserting such a defense on a motion for summary judgment or at trial.”<br />

Since the bills remain in committee, a plaintiff moving for summary judgment on liability in<br />

cases in the Second and First Departments should be aware of the present burden of proof and<br />

be prepared to demonstrate freedom from culpable fault in order to be successful on the motion.<br />

Written by Angela Morcone Giannini, Co-Chair, Litigation Committee<br />

Other Co-Chairs: Jacqueline Hattar & Kimberly Sheehan<br />

Report on the Status of Women in Westchester County<br />

from page 6<br />

quartered in Westchester, three are<br />

headed by women. The percentage of<br />

women in executive leadership positions<br />

in the largest seven corporations<br />

in Westchester County is 32%. The report<br />

further stated that of the ten largest<br />

non-profit organizations in<br />

Westchester, three are headed by<br />

women. Women hold 78% of senior<br />

leadership positions, but only 30% of<br />

chief executive officer positions. Interestingly,<br />

the report also noted that<br />

women are more likely than men to be<br />

○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○<br />

registered to vote and are more likely<br />

to vote. Overall, the WWA study generated<br />

a lively discussion on various<br />

important issues affecting women in<br />

Westchester County.<br />

To read the full report, please visit:<br />

www.wwagenda.org ◗<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

Page 9


Chapter News and Announcements<br />

Announcements & Notes on Members<br />

❑ Donna Frosco<br />

has been appointed to the Executive Committee of Entertainment<br />

Art & Sports Law (“EASL”) Section of the New York State Bar Association. Donna will<br />

Co-chair the Copyright & Trademark Committee for EASL. Donna is a <strong>WWBA</strong> Board<br />

Member and Past President of our parent association, WBASNY. She is a Partner with<br />

Dunnington Bartholow & Miller LLC where she focuses on matters relating to protection,<br />

transfer and licensing of intellectual property; issues relating to technology, data<br />

and cyber-security; construction law; general business matters and litigation and dispute<br />

resolution. Donna can be reached at dfrosco@dunnington.com and<br />

www.dunnington.com. ◗<br />

President’s Message<br />

from page 3<br />

to train volunteers to assist immigrant families to prepare documents for unexpected<br />

detention by Immigration and Customs Enforcement. It is easy to forget the human<br />

suffering caused by divisive policy issues such as Immigration and I am grateful to Natanya<br />

Briendel for offering our members a way to work closely on this issue. Several workshops<br />

have taken place in April and I am certain there will be more to come.<br />

At the General Membership Meeting on April 4th, titled “A Converation with District<br />

Judges in White Plains,” attendees learned best practices from S.D.N.Y. Judges Hon.<br />

Nelson S, Roman and Hon. Lisa Margaret Smith. Special thanks to Donna Frosco, Past<br />

President of WBASNY, for coordinating this program and moderating the panel of judges.<br />

Many thanks also to Lucia Chiocchio, <strong>WWBA</strong> Past President and Amanda Fried, Program<br />

Co-chairs for organizing the venue and registration. Thank you also to our program<br />

co-sponsors, the Federal Bar Association and the White Plains Bar Association.<br />

At our Fourth and Final General Membership Meeting of the current program year,<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> members voted on the <strong>2017</strong>- 2018 <strong>WWBA</strong> slate of officers and directors as well<br />

as our incoming WBASNY officers. Congratulations to all on the slate! Don’t miss your<br />

opportunity to congratulate them in person at our Annual Dinner on June 7th at the<br />

Mamaroneck Beach and Yacht Club.<br />

On a final note, I would like to add my personal condolences to the family and<br />

friends of Judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam. Her sudden death just a few shorts weeks ago left<br />

us shocked and stunned. In past years, Judge Abdus-Salaam appeared on <strong>WWBA</strong><br />

panels and attended as a guest at <strong>WWBA</strong> events. Each time we met her she was a<br />

generous and gracious woman, lawyer, and perhaps most strikingly, a role model. Her<br />

life story and very presence motivated us to try harder, taught us to uncover our true<br />

potential, and led us to overcome personal and professional barriers. She moved us<br />

from what could have just been our mediocre and inspired us instead to become our<br />

best. A heartfelt thank you to Judge Abdus-Salaam. <strong>May</strong> we remember your legacy and<br />

honor it by becoming the finest lawyers we can be. ◗<br />

~ <strong>2017</strong>-2018 <strong>WWBA</strong> SLATE OF OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS ~<br />

President: Lisa M. Denig<br />

President-Elect: Kim Berg<br />

Vice Presidents:<br />

Amanda Fried, Jennifer Gray, Hon. Lisa M. Smith<br />

Treasurer:<br />

Angela Morcone Giannini<br />

Corresponding Secretary: Elizabeth Marcus<br />

Recording Secretary: Natanya Briendel<br />

Directors: Gail M. Boggio, Helene Cote, Lonya Gilbert, Shari R. Gordon<br />

Adrienne Orbach<br />

State Directors: Robin D. Carton, Kitley Covill, Susan Edwards Colson,<br />

Donna Frosco, Marion Genio, Teresa A. Girolamo, Annette G. Hasapidis,<br />

Jane Silverman<br />

Become a New<br />

Member Today<br />

RENEW YOUR<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> MEMBERSHIP TODAY<br />

FOR THE PERIOD<br />

JUNE 1, 2016 TO MAY 31, <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

RENEW NOW! DON’T WAIT!<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Membership includes<br />

membership to the Women’s Bar<br />

Association of the State of New York<br />

(WBASNY).<br />

January 31, <strong>2017</strong> is the closing date in<br />

order to count the <strong>WWBA</strong> members<br />

towards our certification to WBASNY and<br />

assure our number of delegates.<br />

Renewing before this date will allow our<br />

Westchester Chapter (<strong>WWBA</strong>) to continue<br />

to be a strong presence in our statewide<br />

organization (WBASNY) while you will<br />

enjoy its many benefits, events,<br />

newsletter and CLE programming.<br />

Hélène Côté, Sherry A. Bishko,<br />

Elisabeth Campos<br />

It is easy to renew by going to the<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Website at www.<strong>WWBA</strong>NY.org.<br />

You can use a credit card or<br />

PayPal to make payment.<br />

Page 10<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News


Westchester Women’s Bar Association New Members<br />

The Westchester Women’s Bar Association proudly welcomes our newest members:<br />

TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF OUR MEMBERS,<br />

THIS INFORMATION IS AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS OF THE <strong>WWBA</strong> ONLY.<br />

The Westchester Women’s Bar Association<br />

requests the pleasure of your company at its<br />

ANNUAL DINNER<br />

AND INSTALLATION OF OFFICERS<br />

Our Distinguished Keynote Speaker:<br />

CAROL ROBLES-ROMÁN<br />

President and CEO, The Women’s Legal Defense and Education Fund<br />

Wednesday, June 7, <strong>2017</strong><br />

Mamaroneck Beach & Yacht Club<br />

Mamaroneck, New York<br />

<br />

We also welcome your ad in our Souvenir Journal:<br />

Outside Back Cover - $1,000; Inside Back Cover - $600<br />

Inside Front Cover - $600; Gold Page - $400<br />

Full Page - $350: Half Page - $200; Quarter Page - $150<br />

Please contact Amanda C. Fried, Esq. at afried@cartonrosoff.com<br />

You can also place your ad order online at www.wwbany.org<br />

Westchester Women’s Bar Association News<br />

Page 11


<strong>WWBA</strong> Schedule of Upcoming Events<br />

COMMITTEE DATE/TIME PLACE TOPIC RSVP (also online at www.wwbany.org)<br />

Board of Directors<br />

Meeting<br />

Elder/Health Law and<br />

Trusts & Estates<br />

Committees<br />

Corporate and<br />

Commercial<br />

5/3/17<br />

5:30-7:30 p.m.<br />

5/4/17<br />

5:30-6:00 p.m.<br />

Registration and<br />

6:00-8:00 p.m.<br />

Program<br />

5/9/17<br />

5:30-8:00 p.m.<br />

BNY Mellon<br />

701 Westchester Ave<br />

White Plains, New York<br />

Sterling National Bank<br />

21 Scarsdale Road<br />

Tuckahoe, New York<br />

Sterling National Bank<br />

21 Scarsdale Road<br />

Tuckahoe, New York<br />

WBASNY 5/18-5/20/17 Water’s Edge Resort and<br />

Spa<br />

1525 Boston Post Road<br />

Westbrook, CT 06498<br />

Community Outreach 5/23/17 United States District Court<br />

300 Quarropas Street<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> Annual Dinner 6/7/17<br />

5:30 p.m. Cocktails<br />

7:00 p.m. Dinner<br />

White Plains, New York<br />

Mamaroneck Beach and<br />

Yacht Club<br />

Mamaroneck, New York<br />

Guardians Ad Litem and<br />

Court Evaluators: A<br />

Comparison of Ethical<br />

and Procedural<br />

Obligations under the<br />

Part 36 Rules<br />

ABCs of ADA –<br />

Protecting Your Client<br />

and Expanding Your<br />

Practice under the<br />

Americans with<br />

Disabilities Act<br />

Convention <strong>2017</strong><br />

Law Day and Take Your<br />

Children to Work Day<br />

Annual Dinner and<br />

Installation of Officers<br />

Susan Edwards Colson<br />

president@wwbany.org<br />

if you are unable to attend<br />

Register online at<br />

www.wwbany.org<br />

or email<br />

executivedirector@wwbany.org<br />

Register online at<br />

www.wwbany.org<br />

or email<br />

executivedirector@wwbany.org<br />

For information email<br />

dscalise@scaliseethics.com<br />

Register online at www.wwba.org<br />

or email lisadenig@yahoo.com<br />

Unless otherwise indicated, events are for <strong>WWBA</strong> members and invited guests only.<br />

The opinions expressed by any program presenter are the presenter’s own, and do not reflect<br />

the official position of the <strong>WWBA</strong>.<br />

<strong>WWBA</strong> is a chapter of WBASNY, which is an approved provider of CLE credit. Full and partial scholarships for CLE programs based<br />

on financial need are available. For information on the guidelines and procedures for applying, please contact the person running<br />

the program. All requests are strictly confidential. All programs are for transitional credit unless the program states otherwise.<br />

REMEMBER, YOU CAN FIND THE WBASNY WEB PAGE<br />

AT WWW.WBASNY.ORG.<br />

PLEASE REMEMBER TO RECYCLE<br />

Connect<br />

with<br />

us<br />

THE <strong>WWBA</strong> MEMBERSHIP PERIOD FOR<br />

2016-<strong>2017</strong> BEGAN ON JUNE 1, 2016.<br />

PLEASE RENEW YOUR MEMBERSHIP TOD<br />

ODAY AT<br />

WWW.<strong>WWBA</strong>NY<br />

.<strong>WWBA</strong>NY.ORG<br />

.ORG

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!