27.05.2017 Views

Cyprus 2000 Peace Project

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The Last Divided City<br />

The <strong>Cyprus</strong> Initiative -The Diary of<br />

Dominic Ryan and the <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />

27th of October until 3rd of December <strong>2000</strong>


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Contents<br />

Introduction to <strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

Synopsis: Israel, the Gaza Strip and<br />

the Checkpoint Charlie of the Middle<br />

East, 1997<br />

The historical background to<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

Cast of Characters: <strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

The Diary of <strong>Cyprus</strong> -<br />

27th of October until 3rd of<br />

December <strong>2000</strong>


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Introduction to <strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

I had returned from Kosovo and the Albanian<br />

concert in May 1999, shell shocked, traumatised but<br />

in one piece. After returning there was an invisible<br />

filth that seemed to cover my entire psyche that<br />

I could not wash off. Others could not see it but<br />

I could definitely feel it. The cure for this feeling<br />

was to recapitulate the experiences of the journey<br />

by editing a film about the <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong>. Whether<br />

the film succeeded after its completion or not, it<br />

was a tool to both heal myself while becoming and<br />

a mode of communication for others. It eased the<br />

horror of that experience. When I have encountered<br />

difficult or traumatic experiences in life,<br />

documentation is a way of consciously returning<br />

to those moments and then liberating me from the<br />

pain of their memory.<br />

I returned in 1999 and then decided to plan the<br />

<strong>2000</strong> campaign. With a group of volunteers we sent<br />

out many requests for sponsorship and support.<br />

A booklet was printed which promoted a tour of<br />

Israel, the Middle-East, <strong>Cyprus</strong> and finally Belfast.<br />

As it turned out no money or sponsorship<br />

was achieved and I was left yet again looking for<br />

finance for the journey. There are many facets to<br />

this process of conflict resolution which deserve<br />

documenting. There is the in-the-field event where<br />

the peace project is bringing people together who<br />

are in a war zone. There is the inspirational story.<br />

There is the diplomatic bridge building and there<br />

is the social bridge building. Finally there is the<br />

message which comes through the media and the<br />

event itself.<br />

But this time there were no finances<br />

forthcoming from others to help me and nobody<br />

seemed interested. They were more interested in<br />

their mortgages or what was happening in Australia.<br />

I had to resign myself once more with putting my<br />

own money into the project. Since my finances were<br />

becoming tight, I could not afford to take Firouz<br />

as much as his dedication and passion showed in<br />

Albania. Nonetheless I believe the last episode<br />

had tested both our patience. I had to make an<br />

executive decision.<br />

It was with great sadness that I told Firouz that<br />

I could not take him. I wrote to inform him after<br />

I had left for <strong>Cyprus</strong>, knowing that he would be<br />

disappointed by my decision.<br />

My replacement was Rebecca Prole—a film<br />

student who was strong, brave and perfect for the<br />

task. She was brash, funky, down to earth, with a<br />

double chin, beautiful crystal grey eyes who chain<br />

smoked. We became like brother and sister.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>, the Dead Zone and Nicosia,<br />

the Last Divided City - <strong>2000</strong><br />

In which the artist Dominic Ryan and The <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> visit <strong>Cyprus</strong> with a plan<br />

to erect a message in the Dead Zone. With support from the UN military and<br />

Civil Affairs they invite the two sides including the two mayors of the Divided City<br />

into the dead zone. After two months of protracted negotiation one side rejects<br />

the offer unless new political conditions are fulfilled. Instead Dominic Ryan brings<br />

students in the place of reluctant politicians into the dead zone at Pyle.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Historical Background to <strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

Prior to 1974, <strong>Cyprus</strong> experienced a long period of inter-communal strife between its Greek Cypriot and<br />

Turkish Cypriot communities. In response the United Nations Force in <strong>Cyprus</strong> (UNFICYP) began peacekeeping<br />

operations in March 1964.<br />

The island has been divided since the Turkish military intervention of 1974, following a coup d’etat directed<br />

from Greece. Since 1974 the southern part of the island has been under the control of the Government of the<br />

Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong>. The northern part is ruled by a Turkish Cypriot administration. In 1983 that administration<br />

proclaimed itself the ‘Turkish Republic of Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong>’ (TRNC). The TRNC is not recognised by the United<br />

States or any other country except Turkey. The two parts of the island are separated by a buffer zone patrolled<br />

by the UNFICYP. A substantial number of Turkish troops remain on the island. In both the Government of the<br />

Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong> controlled areas and in the Turkish Cypriot community democratic principles generally<br />

are respected. Glafcos Clerides was re-elected President of the Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong> in 1998; in April <strong>2000</strong> Rauf<br />

Denktash was declared ‘President’ after ‘Prime Minister’ Dervish Eroglu withdrew following the first round of<br />

Turkish Cypriot elections. The judiciary is independent in both communities.<br />

Police in the Government of the Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong> controlled (government-controlled) area and in the<br />

Turkish Cypriot community are responsible for law enforcement. Police forces operating in the governmentcontrolled<br />

area are under civilian control, while military authorities direct Turkish Cypriot police forces. In<br />

general the police forces of both sides respect the rule of law, but instances of police abuse of power continued.<br />

Both Cypriot economies operate on the basis of free market principles, although in each community there<br />

are significant administrative controls. The government-controlled part of the island has a robust, serviceoriented<br />

economy, with a declining manufacturing base and a small agricultural sector.<br />

Tourism and trade generate 22% of gross domestic product and employ 29% of the labour force. In <strong>2000</strong><br />

per capita income was approximately $12,902, inflation was 4.5 %, and unemployment was 3.5 %. Growth was<br />

4.8 %, compared with 4.5 % in 1999. The Turkish Cypriot economy is handicapped by restrictions imposed<br />

by the Government of the Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong> and other international institutions. In addition it relies heavily<br />

on subsidies from Turkey and is burdened by an overly large public sector. It too is basically service-oriented,<br />

but has a smaller tourism and trade base—accounting for 14 percent of gross domestic product employing 10<br />

percent of the workforce—and a larger agricultural sector. During the year, per capita income in the north was<br />

approximately $5,263, and inflation was 60%. Growth in the north was 5.3% in <strong>2000</strong>, compared with 4.9% in<br />

1999.<br />

The Government of the Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong> generally respected human rights, however instances of police<br />

brutality continued to be a problem.<br />

The Turkish Cypriot authorities generally respected human rights, however police abuse of suspects’ and<br />

detainees’ rights continued. The authorities also continued to restrict freedom of movement.<br />

Since December 1997, the Turkish Cypriot authorities have banned most bi-communal contacts between<br />

Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots, including previously frequent meetings in Nicosia’s buffer zone. They<br />

sometimes attempted to prevent Turkish Cypriots from travelling to bi-communal meetings off the island as<br />

well. In May of 1998 Turkish Cypriot officials lowered the ‘visa’ fees for crossing the buffer zone. The Turkish<br />

Cypriot authorities have taken some steps to improve the conditions of Greek Cypriots and Maronites living in<br />

the territory under their control, but the treatment of these groups still falls short of Turkish Cypriot obligations<br />

under the Vienna III Agreement of 1975.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Cast of Characters:<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

REBECCA PROLE cameraperson on <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> campaign <strong>2000</strong>-2001<br />

SIOBHAN RYAN<br />

MARTIN CANTOR<br />

PAUL HOLLEMAN<br />

SAMANTHA GATTON<br />

MICHELLE WILLIAMS<br />

DAPHNIS PANAGIDES<br />

MADELINE GARLICK<br />

MIRAN GARLICK<br />

ROB<br />

ALMA SAHBAZ<br />

SEMI BORA<br />

sculptor, artist and sister of Dominic Ryan, resident<br />

in Melbourne Australia<br />

Australian photographer, gallery director and at the time of <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

photographed The Tear of Joy mural for insertion as billboard<br />

friend, supporter and major collaborator of <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />

friend of Ryan and Michelle Williams. Lives in Queensland<br />

girlfriend of Dominic Ryan who in 1994-5 who accompanied Ryan to<br />

Moscow and stayed with him for 7 months<br />

Christian International <strong>Peace</strong> Service Adviser (gave Ryan details about<br />

Nikos Anastasios)<br />

Civil Affairs Political Officer United Nations <strong>Peace</strong> Keeping Forces in<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>. Met through Alma Sahbaz (See Sarajevo journal)<br />

husband of Madeline, Serbian who worked for the UN on reconstruction<br />

in North Nicosia<br />

an Australian friend of the Garlicks<br />

friend and Co Director of Exile in Sarajevo (See Sarajevo journal)<br />

Mayor of Nicosia in North <strong>Cyprus</strong> or The Turkish Representative<br />

of Nicosia. President of the Organisations of Turkish municipalities<br />

of <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

NATASHA JOURAVLEVA girlfriend of Dominic Ryan, <strong>2000</strong>–2001, resident in Novosibirsk in 2001.<br />

Subsequently moved to London<br />

KATIA<br />

SOPHIE<br />

VAN IS VANG<br />

SARAH RUSSELL<br />

NIKOS ANASTASIOS<br />

HARRIS ANASTASIOS<br />

IRENE Q<br />

RAKO<br />

MADEMOISELLE<br />

ANITA THOMAS<br />

VLODAK CIBOR<br />

Cultural and Public Relations Officer for Town Clerk at the Town Hall in<br />

Nicosia Greek <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

another secretary to the Mayor Of Nicosia<br />

Vietnamese mobile phone agent who sold me and made the contract in<br />

Clarendon Streeet Melbourne for the Nokia<br />

Spokesperson, Head Quarters United Nations FICYP<br />

Teacher and Director of Seeds of <strong>Peace</strong>, South <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

brother of Nikos Anastasios<br />

speaker about the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question<br />

Japanese tourist on a Lonely Planet tour we meet<br />

at Ledra Palace Checkpoint<br />

Rebecca Prole<br />

Civil Affairs Assistant to Garlick<br />

UN senior advisor United Nations FICYP


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

ALEXANDER BRATERSKI<br />

BULLANT KANOL<br />

MICHAEL BLUNDEN<br />

MUSTAFA EREULGEN<br />

LELOS DIMITRIADES<br />

AMELIA PARFIDES<br />

ANTOINE SALOME<br />

DONNA COLEMAN<br />

ANTONIOS<br />

(PAUL) AS IN PAUL HOLLEMAN<br />

ANDREAS ANDRIADES<br />

PROFESSOR MARIA HAJIPAVLO<br />

MARIOS KOULOVAC<br />

FATHER MICHAEL KELLY<br />

MIRIAM PERYCLAYOS<br />

TASHE<br />

ANDREOS POUYOUROS<br />

DAYA, MICHAELA, LITHA<br />

LUDA<br />

MONTY<br />

SUSANNA<br />

student at the Faculty of Journalism Later became the Washington<br />

correspondent for RTR. Assisted with the Millennium exhibition in 1994<br />

and was <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> volunteer (See Moscow journal)<br />

Undersecretary Ministry of State and Prime Ministry Turkish Republic of<br />

North <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Director of Big Fish Event Workshop in Melbourne. The Director was<br />

responsible for Ryan using the workshop to paint Millennium in the<br />

early 1990s<br />

Turkish Republic of Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong> Ministry of Foreign Affairs and<br />

Defence Information and Press Officer<br />

Mayor of Greek Nicosia<br />

Direct Secretary and Personal assistant to Mayor Lelos Dimitriades<br />

Lebanese Journalist who wrote political essays for French Figaro and<br />

numerous Egyptian, Lebanese and Parisian magazines. Currently reads<br />

on SBS the political reports in Australia<br />

Victorian College of the Arts Music administrator<br />

Representative of Eco organisation Friends of the Earth. Met with<br />

Daphnis Panagides in Limassol.<br />

friend, supporter and major collaborator of <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />

Secretary General The Town Hall Nicosia (South <strong>Cyprus</strong>)<br />

poet, Greek Academic, Professor of <strong>Peace</strong> and Reconciliation Studies at<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> University<br />

Concierge at the Excelsior Hotel Apartments 11–25th of March<br />

Street Nicosia<br />

Director of Catholic Communications, who was responsible for giving<br />

Ryan and Prole journalist accreditation. Subsequently became Director<br />

of the Dominic Ryan <strong>Peace</strong> Foundation<br />

colleague at United Nations <strong>Peace</strong> Keeping Forces in <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Poet and Turkish refugee wanted in Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong> for sedition.<br />

Friend of Maria Hajipavlos<br />

Mayor in absentia of Famagusta<br />

three Greek Cypriot women Rebecca and Ryan met at a night club<br />

Friend of Dominic Ryan, girlfriend of Hamish Appleby<br />

(See Moscow journals)<br />

Monty was storing Millennium sculptures in Warehouse in Fitzroy<br />

at the time<br />

Australian girl friend


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Cast of Characters:<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

OLGA<br />

(NATASHA) JOURAVLEVA<br />

(MAX) MAX EDIE WILCOCKS<br />

RANIA<br />

REV. DEMONSTHMONUS<br />

MELISSA RUSH<br />

MR TASHIN ERTUGRULOGLU<br />

MR SABATINI EGELI<br />

ANDREA<br />

TOGALU<br />

TOM GANNON<br />

GALIA AND TANYA<br />

Australian friend<br />

girlfriend of Dominic Ryan, <strong>2000</strong>–early 2002, resident in Novosibirsk in<br />

2001. Subsequently moved to London<br />

Graphic designer, musician, girlfriend in London. Singer in the band<br />

World Party in 1989<br />

Publlic Information Officer, Greek Nicosa<br />

Holy Archbishop Porik of <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

ran Rushdown Travel and was at this time my travel agent.<br />

The Minister of Foreign Affairs TRNC<br />

Acting Director Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Defence, Public<br />

Information Office Turkish Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

girl at Alpha Graphics in Nicosia<br />

the Minister of Foreign Affairs (not correct spelling)<br />

Entrepreneur who operates homewares shop in Brunswick Street,<br />

Fitzroy Australia<br />

two Bulgarian champagne Bar Girls in Greek <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Rebecca Orole abnd Mustafa Ereulgen and Semi Bora


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The Diary of <strong>Cyprus</strong>, the Dead Zone<br />

Nicosia, the Last Divided City – <strong>2000</strong><br />

27th of October until 3rd of December <strong>2000</strong><br />

Friday 27th October, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Larnacca, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

This is the <strong>Cyprus</strong>/Jerusalem journey and it is<br />

a spoken record of the journey which was begun<br />

by Dominic Ryan and Rebecca Prole on the day<br />

the 27th October in the year <strong>2000</strong>, a Friday. Our<br />

departure was a frenetic and excessive affair, as<br />

I was exhausted, consumed by each minor detail<br />

which had to be attended to. In the lead up to our<br />

departure there was the added speculation of what<br />

might happen on the journey and what we would<br />

need. I had<br />

only two hours<br />

sleep every<br />

night up until<br />

our departure<br />

on the 26th.<br />

My state was<br />

a walking<br />

somnambulist.<br />

But I was even<br />

surprised at<br />

how much<br />

stamina I had<br />

so that I could remain focused before our departure.<br />

The billboard was a tragic comedy of errors. We<br />

had engaged a friend of my sister, Martin Cantor,<br />

to photograph the painting, The Tear of Joy which<br />

would soon to be transformed into a 42 feet by 16<br />

billboard with 35 different translations of ‘peace on<br />

earth’ including Greek, Turkish, Arabic and Hebrew.<br />

Because of the urgency, Martin had photographed<br />

the painting in two halves. After getting drunk the<br />

Thursday night he photographed the mural, he had<br />

fallen over and broken his collar bone. Therefore<br />

he had been unable to scan the photographs. It was<br />

not until the following Monday that the scans had<br />

arrived. Viewing them on the computer through<br />

Photoshop I saw, much to my disappointment, that<br />

the three Byzantine women on the left side of the<br />

painting and the ribboned man on the right were<br />

engulfed in a white flare. Nevertheless after the<br />

billboard had been manufactured, the problem<br />

of the flaring seemed to retreat. Hopefully our<br />

attention to detail in the initial preparatory period<br />

has paid off.<br />

The comedy of errors proceeded as we realised<br />

that the computer could not read the disk with<br />

Martin’s image on it. We sent in a disk for printing<br />

at Colour Graphics and the disk could not read the<br />

‘peace on earth’ image, whereas it could read the<br />

war image. Colour Graphics rang two days before<br />

our departure to say that their printing machine<br />

had ceased operation. It would not be able to print<br />

the billboard. We therefore could not leave Australia<br />

with the two 35 kg sacks which Arab Emirates had<br />

graciously granted us a sponsorship deal to assist in.<br />

Paul Holleman, the graphic designer, colleague,<br />

and close mentor and friend took up the slack.<br />

He would be a human rubber band springing<br />

backwards and forwards helping us to get the<br />

project underway. So with this offset printing<br />

postponed by Colour Graphics, we prepared to<br />

leave at five o’clock in the morning for a departure<br />

at seven o’clock at the airport on Arab Emirates<br />

flight EK69 on 26th October <strong>2000</strong>.<br />

Samantha Gatton, my girl friend’s best friend<br />

and Rebecca Prole’s boyfriend accompanied us<br />

to the airport. Once through customs it was a<br />

long, arduous night in a cabin which resembled a<br />

soup can, with huddled figures, television screens<br />

gloaming in the dark and passengers shuffling<br />

backwards and forwards in their Adidas tracksuits.<br />

I could hear the odd snuffle and cough. As I stared<br />

out the cabin porthole I saw small fairy lights<br />

dotting a geography I could barely see.<br />

The Patriot film flickered on tiny quartz crystal<br />

screens and it<br />

repeated from<br />

Singapore to<br />

Dubai and<br />

then Dubai<br />

to Larnacca.<br />

We saw<br />

The Patriot<br />

repeated with<br />

Mel Gibson<br />

looking musty<br />

in a whole<br />

vaguery of<br />

poses—angst, vengeance and embrace. It was as if<br />

I was trapped in a memory feedback loop. I was a<br />

character in The Patriot and this was my hell, while<br />

simultaneously trapped in an aeroplane, 25,000 feet<br />

above the world, having to relive the moments of<br />

death in the film. Reliving moments of great pain<br />

and angst as people killed each other, and saw their<br />

wives or children massacred. That moment kept on<br />

repeating. At every chapter or leg of our journey I<br />

would flick the channel but it would return to that<br />

film.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

As we were driving we gazed across at this razorback of mountains which runs<br />

right across the island like a welt or scar. The driver was pointing to the mountains:<br />

‘There is the fl ag’.<br />

Our arrival occurred at 11am on Friday 27th<br />

October <strong>2000</strong> in Larnacca, <strong>Cyprus</strong> , a small<br />

provincial town on the coast where all international<br />

flights touch down. From the ovoid window the<br />

island appeared like a dagger pointing to Turkey<br />

and the Middle East. I could see small white washed<br />

houses on the rim of the coastline. Gingerbread<br />

houses with icing sugar appeared and grew in size as<br />

the aeroplane began its slow and efficient descent.<br />

There was a feeling of something impending,<br />

something about to happen, as the aeroplane lazily<br />

descended. Comparing the Kosovo experience a<br />

year ago I felt little trepidation or foreboding. Here<br />

it is one of optimism and faith that whatever will<br />

happen is meant to be. This journey is predestined<br />

and I must be steadfast, without flinching or veering<br />

to one side or the other. I must put the blinkers on<br />

trust, even though all the signs indicate negativity.<br />

Everything will repair itself at the final moment.<br />

I will be jumping out of an aeroplane without a<br />

parachute, knowing that the parachute will be there<br />

to prevent my imminent death. In placing my head<br />

inside a furnace, the furnace will be turned off. It<br />

is important to have a faith that is inhuman, a faith<br />

that will vibrate so that anything which surrounds<br />

me cannot touch me. From this core everything else<br />

will respond.<br />

At Larnacca airport with Rebecca expectant and<br />

happy we are soon pushing our baggage trolleys<br />

across the tarmac under a bright fearless sun with<br />

the Cypriot wind on our cheeks. We are going on a<br />

rollercoaster which is pulling us up to the top of the<br />

track. We have not yet descended. We are just going<br />

click, click, clack, click. I can hear the clicking as the<br />

rollercoaster is being pulled up on the tracks to the<br />

summit when soon it will begin its rapid descent.<br />

The taxi which picks us up is a chauffeur-driven,<br />

tinted window cream Mercedes with the three<br />

rows of seats. We negotiated a price of 14 pounds<br />

with the driver and drive from Larnacca to the<br />

Excelsior hotel. The drive was a 45 minute trip,<br />

through olive groves and white washed houses.<br />

We passed by crumbling Spanish style villas with<br />

arches, manicured plaster, masonry and very small<br />

cultivated gardens.<br />

There seems to be a redolence of cultivated<br />

wealth peppered by diminutive buildings. Here<br />

there is no poverty or chaos. Our entrance into<br />

the southern suburbs of Nicosia was without<br />

incident. The city grew on us slowly but surely. As<br />

we were driving we gazed across at this razorback<br />

of mountains which runs right across the island<br />

like a welt or scar. The driver was pointing to the<br />

mountains:<br />

‘There is the flag’.<br />

But I could not see any flag. I was not even aware<br />

of what such a flag meant. But apparently the flag<br />

was the Turkish flag, or the Turkish Cypriot flag,<br />

which had been painted with coloured rocks on to<br />

the side of the mountains across on the other side of<br />

the divided island, an island divided by war in 1974.<br />

Whenever the Greek Cypriots would gaze towards<br />

this mountain range they could see a white washed<br />

image of a star, the crescent, and two straight lines.<br />

The mountain range is called the Kyrenia Range.<br />

From the Greek perspective the area beginning<br />

with the mountains is inaccessible because of the<br />

Turkish occupation. In the north we could see the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

When every opinion tells me not to<br />

continue, I persevere.<br />

Wandering through boutique-filled<br />

Kennedy Avenue up towards the centre,<br />

the city appears to be a gamut of<br />

designer shops, perfumeries, fashion<br />

boutiques—a combination of Jean Paul<br />

Gaultier, Ralph Lauren, Yves St. Laurent,<br />

Yamaguchi and Dior labels.<br />

...another<br />

conscript from<br />

the same<br />

Frederico<br />

Fellini movie.<br />

the concierge, Marius was looking like an obese character out of<br />

a Frederico Fellini movie.<br />

villages of Kunicipos, Platani, Mandras, Cichari, Vouno, Kato, Krini, Kontemenos. The taxi driver’s conversation<br />

was garbled; punctuated with points of curiosity and then followed by moments of anger about the ‘<strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

question’ as he called it.<br />

This was to be the beginning of something new. We would discern the truth of this island as the weeks<br />

passed.<br />

It is preferable not knowing the future. If we were to fully know the future and its consequences we would<br />

not have the courage to step into that future. Had I known what was to be, I would not have had the courage or<br />

foolishness to proceed. Therefore not knowing what will be can sometimes help us to take the necessary steps<br />

towards our future. One of my strengths is the stamina to continue when my journey is wasted and everything<br />

is lost. When every opinion tells me not to continue, I persevere.<br />

As we arrive at the Excelsior Apartments, the name of the street is ‘25th of March!’ It veers off the Kennedy<br />

Avenue area. Next to the hotel is a derelict furnishings factory. After passing a few signs we enter the hotel<br />

foyer where the concierge, Marius was looking like an obese character out of a Frederico Fellini movie. But he<br />

is oh so sweet and generous. I felt a great empathy for him. Our room on the sixth floor of the Hotel Excelsior<br />

was room 601 with a panoramic view. We heaved our bags and walked out into the mid day sun like mad<br />

Englishmen. Wandering through boutique filled Kennedy Avenue up towards the centre, the city appears to be<br />

a gamut of designer shops, perfumeries, fashion boutiques—a combination of Jean Paul Gaultier, Ralph Lauren,


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Madeline appeared at the foyer of the Excelsior<br />

looking dapper with inquisitive eyes, long dark<br />

hair in a bob and an animated expression.<br />

Yves St. Laurent, Yamaguchi and Dior labels. We<br />

walked in towards the old city and had a pizza at<br />

a parlour where there was a woman who was yet<br />

another conscript from the same Frederico Fellini<br />

movie. She had long blonde hair, vermillion lipstick<br />

and raven black mascara. The lip line of her lipstick<br />

delineated a mouth that was four times the size<br />

of her actual mouth. Squinting from a distance<br />

there was extreme beauty or sexual attraction.<br />

She looked like a blown up kewpie doll with sweet<br />

eyes and a gawky, lollipop demeanour. We greedily<br />

guzzled our pizza and walked to the old city. As<br />

we walked through the centre the buildings grew<br />

increasingly older and more antique, almost as if<br />

like the rings on a tree we could see the trees age as<br />

we journeyed towards its centre. Here we filmed a<br />

63 year old man with a trolley, who told us that he<br />

had been selling fruit there, on this corner, for the<br />

last 50 years. Exhausted and slightly disconsolate<br />

we returned home to, how do you say, our not-sowelcoming<br />

apartment.<br />

28th October, Saturday, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Madeline Garlick who met us today, is a negotiator with the<br />

United Nations team facilitating in Geneva the recent talks<br />

throughout October <strong>2000</strong> ...<br />

And so to recount the day’s events—Madeline<br />

Garlick who met us today, is a negotiator with the<br />

United Nations team facilitating in Geneva the<br />

recent talks throughout October <strong>2000</strong> about a<br />

two-state, one-country plan for the divided island<br />

of <strong>Cyprus</strong>. She is the Assistant Director for Civil<br />

Affairs for both sides. She was also a friend of Alma<br />

Sahbaz, the woman who had made the film Exile in<br />

Sarajevo, whom I had encountered in Sarajevo. I<br />

had befriended Alma when she had separated from<br />

her partner Tamir Gambis, two years ago.<br />

Madeline appeared at the foyer of the Excelsior<br />

looking dapper with inquisitive eyes, long dark<br />

hair in a bob and an animated expression. She<br />

continually darted from topic to topic, dressed in an<br />

aqua blue pant suit—and drove us from the south


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

and the other one that says<br />

‘We Have All Suffered<br />

Enough - War and Violence<br />

Cannot Solve the Problems of<br />

Humanity’.<br />

One says ‘Let<br />

There be <strong>Peace</strong><br />

on Earth’<br />

of the island across to the north. We first travelled<br />

through the Ledra Palace Checkpoint which separates<br />

the two sides. The Turkish side in the north and the<br />

south side which is Greek are divided by what is called<br />

a Green line. This is a no man’s land/demilitarised<br />

zone which the UN have created as a buffer between<br />

the two sides in the case of continued or re-ignited<br />

conflict.<br />

The reason for this journey and my diary is that I<br />

and the <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> have created two billboards to<br />

erect in the no man’s land. One says ‘Let There be<br />

<strong>Peace</strong> on Earth’ and the other one that says ‘We<br />

Have All Suffered Enough - War and Violence<br />

Cannot Solve the Problems of Humanity’. One<br />

is an image of optimism, the other an image of the<br />

darkness and the shadow of war. My mission is to bring<br />

those two billboards from Australia into the no man’s<br />

land to exhibit them. My task is to engage the two<br />

mayors of the divided city to enter the no man’s land<br />

with the billboards and symbolically tell the world that<br />

war and violence cannot solve our problems. Lelos<br />

Dimitriades is the Mayor of the Greek city of Nicosia.<br />

Mr. Semi Bora is the mayor of the Turkish side to the<br />

divided city in Turkish <strong>Cyprus</strong>, the Republic of North<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>. The idea is to place the two billboards and<br />

have this message of peace, erected in the dead zone<br />

and then to ask the two mayors to enter into the no<br />

man’s land and have a ceremony acknowledging that<br />

war and violence cannot solve our problems. This<br />

would be a small fragile step towards reconciliation<br />

and is the purpose and nature of the trip that I have<br />

embarked upon.<br />

As we cross over through the checkpoint, the<br />

raw energy and frequency of this dividing land, is<br />

not a heavy frequency of fear. It is not as difficult<br />

as the Israeli checkpoint of the Erez Crossing.<br />

Nonetheless, in Nicosia, there is a quotient of<br />

fear, and as we pass through, the area seemed<br />

a miniature world that has been trapped in the<br />

period of the 1970s. Since the Turkish invasion or<br />

liberation, depending upon the point of view, the<br />

partition of the island and of Nicosia, nothing has<br />

been touched in the mile wide no man’s land. All the<br />

buildings in the dead zone are frozen and untouched<br />

since the invasion of 1974. We crossed the no man’s<br />

land through the checkpoint to witness haggard<br />

and disembowelled buildings a with two fluttering<br />

flags, Turkish flags and Greek Cypriot flags flying<br />

either side. As we ambled through, I could see a<br />

zone where the old wall turns at a ninety degree<br />

angle adjacent to a small football field. My thoughts<br />

suggest here could be an appropriate place to hang<br />

the billboard if the two mayors accept my invitation.<br />

Rebecca was quiet, even pensive in the crossing,<br />

absorbing the experience. Travelling through<br />

the holiday landscape of vulgar cement Greek<br />

architecture, we crossed over to the Turkish side<br />

where we were confronted by a poorer, laboured<br />

and sadder buildings. The Turkish bazaar and<br />

broken bitumen on the streets seemed to replace<br />

fast food signs and sprite umbrellas…The people<br />

here dressed casually in jeans and coloured T-shirts.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

During the drive Madeline gave us a of a history lesson, giving us some background to the division of the island in 1974:<br />

We had coffee in the centre of town, where we were met by Madeline’s husband Miran, a Serb-Croat,<br />

responsible for civic works on the north side, and Rob who was one of the assistants to De Soto, a negotiator for<br />

the United Nations. De Soto is Kofi Annan’s diplomatic emissary here on the island. Rob, is due to leave with<br />

Madeline the following Tuesday for negotiations with the two sides in Geneva. We drove to the three star hotel<br />

which was called the Saray Hotel. We climbed up to the top a balcony and then from that vantage we could see<br />

the city from the Turkish side across to the Greek. Since the city, has been divided like Berlin since 1974 over<br />

the dead zone of the Geeen line I looked across towards the south to see an eruption of new building whilst<br />

here everything remains in decay.<br />

From the Saray Hotel we walked through to various regions of the old city and saw a UN sponsored<br />

renovation—an old kahn, which means stables that the Turkish Cypriots had been restoring.<br />

The protocol from the south administration for transiting foreigners is that tall foreign nationals must be<br />

returned by 5 o’clock in the evening to the south Greek side. Since we were with UN, this day we returned at<br />

11 at night.<br />

Once across the border without her husband or Rob, Madeline Garlick drove us to the north. We drove<br />

across the mountains to Kyrenia and then from Kyrenia, we went to an old crusader or Venetian abbey at<br />

Belapais. During the drive Madeline gave us a of a history lesson, giving us some background to the division of<br />

the island in 1974:<br />

Dominic:...It is the back of some spine where the vertebrae meet.<br />

Madeline: A dinosaur.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The violence, the real problem started in ‘63, three years after the island had independence.<br />

Madeline:...You probably want to turn the camera off here<br />

because there’s going to be a military area a further up here.<br />

Dominic: Checkpoints.<br />

Madeline: Not checkpoints, but just camps.<br />

Dominic: I must admit I find the mountain scape absolutely beautiful in the way it is. It is the back of some<br />

spine where the vertebrae meet.<br />

Madeline: A dinosaur.<br />

Dominic: And this building on our left here coming up, these look like?<br />

Madeline: This is all housing, it’s all quite new.<br />

Dominic: It’s like little fairy villages for pixies.<br />

Madeline: It’s all quite newly built over here. I should tell you. The violence, the real problem started in<br />

‘63, three years after the island had independence. The island existed independently without problems for<br />

three years. And that began in December ‘63 when some of the Greek nationalist groups, they saw the destiny<br />

of <strong>Cyprus</strong> as being union with Greeks and they were forming militias that were attacking and perpetrating<br />

violence on a number of the Turkish Cypriot villages in both north and south. And that was the first time the<br />

Security Council authorised a peace keeping force to come in and that’s when the UN first arrived.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Dominic: And that was in ‘65?<br />

Madeline: That was ‘63. And that was about the time also when it fell apart politically. The constitution<br />

guaranteed that there was going to be 30% of the civil service appointed as Turkish Cypriots, 30% of police<br />

were going to be Turkish Cypriots, guaranteed seats in the house and sort of weighted voting rights in the<br />

parliament just to ensure that their rights were going to be recognised. A lot of the problems began when<br />

something like three quarters of those Turkish Cypriots received redundancy notices from the civil service.<br />

Dominic: And that sense of injustice seemed to boil on to the fire.<br />

Madeline: Absolutely. At one point tax measures were going to be voted which were going to impose heavier<br />

taxes on to the people and these would be central taxes. The Turkish Cypriots were concerned then because<br />

they were worried that their municipal administrations, which they were using to fund their mosques and their<br />

schools etc., would not have the same scope for taxing the people. So they voted against that Bill. And that was<br />

a veto measure, which in the end caused the government to collapse. So then the place fell apart politically as<br />

well. You probably want to turn the camera off here because there’s going to be a military area a further up<br />

here.<br />

Dominic: Checkpoints.<br />

Madeline: Not checkpoints, but just camps. In fact as we go over this range it’s best to put the camera back<br />

in the bag and leave it there. Yeah, but anyway, what I was getting around to, that road there, the UN used to.<br />

Dominic: Which road here?<br />

Madeline: Yeah this one we’re on here, just crossing the middle of the plain. The UN ended up having to<br />

conduct escorts on that road for people to come from Kyrenia down to Nicosia because in the ‘63 to ‘74 period<br />

both groups of people ended up putting together their-<br />

Dominic: Little militias.<br />

Madeline: That’s right. And it was dangerous for everyone in the area that was majority by the other. So for<br />

Greek Cypriots it was dangerous on the road from here, from Kyrenia where we’re going down to Nicosia, so<br />

the UN formed escorted convoys. So things were ill at ease for a long time even before the events of 1974, no<br />

doubt about that. …See it’s a lot more greener here, a lot more moist.<br />

Dominic: Why is it more greener here then?<br />

Madeline: This is the wet area, because when the clouds hit the mountains they tend to release the water.<br />

Dominic: Ok, beautiful. And is this side, although it’s very thin it obviously looks much lusher.<br />

Madeline: Yes it is definitely. So that sort of area to the south of the plain is pretty dry.<br />

Dominic: Perhaps the clouds come here and the rain goes on this side rather than on the other.<br />

Madeline: Exactly. Yeah it’s clouds coming from the north over the mountain. I started telling the history<br />

lesson, I might as well finish it, up to ‘74. So the violence started in ‘63 and that was when they first also<br />

divided the city. It wasn’t just actually ‘63, I think it might have been the late 60s. But there was so many<br />

attacks and small incidents going on. Grenades being thrown through car windows and shootings. Basically<br />

the UN in the end drew what is called the Green line, which is the line that divided the city and they patrolled<br />

that. And they enforced a curfew so that people were not allowed to go into the other sector, the other part<br />

inhabited by the other community after a certain hour at night because that was when the militias used to<br />

make trouble. Here we go, this is it, great view and there’s the sea. And if you strain your eye 40 miles in that<br />

direction is Turkey.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...that the Turks couldn’t possibly have amassed a force and the resources to invade at such short notice.<br />

To this day the argument is put that they attacked or they<br />

intervened after the coup in order to protect the Turkish<br />

Cypriot minority because they had reached the not<br />

unreasonable conclusion that if a military government<br />

took over in <strong>Cyprus</strong> that had the support of the<br />

nationalist movement...they would be exposed to danger<br />

greater than that with which they lived in for ten years...<br />

Dominic: Can you see Turkey? Perhaps because<br />

of the haze we can’t see it now, but on a clear day is<br />

it possible to see it?<br />

Madeline: Yes absolutely, you can see a mountain<br />

range. You can see a mass, but you can’t make it out<br />

very well.<br />

Dominic: I can see different shades to…wow.<br />

Madeline: So that’s Kyrenia. So Nicosia was first<br />

divided way back then. In the early 70s Greece, the<br />

government in Greece was taken over by a military<br />

coup. The colonels moved in and staged effectively a<br />

coup d’etat. And some of those forces were naturally<br />

sympathetic to the nationalist movements that had<br />

been causing trouble in <strong>Cyprus</strong>. In fact it got to a<br />

point in 1973 where a group of the nationalists with<br />

support of the Greek colonels with the Greek military<br />

government and the mainland sought to stage a<br />

coup here. That was what happened in July 1974.<br />

Archbishop Makarios was the president at the time,<br />

obviously a Greek Orthodox cleric. They arrived at<br />

his presidential palace, they came to take him and<br />

murder him basically but he escaped out the back door.<br />

As soon as the news of the coup reached the outside<br />

world Turkey almost immediately moved to launch<br />

an attack. To this day the argument is put that they<br />

attacked or they intervened after the coup in order<br />

to protect the Turkish Cypriot minority because they<br />

had reached the not unreasonable conclusion that if a<br />

military government took over in <strong>Cyprus</strong> that had the<br />

support of the nationalist movement and there would<br />

be no hope for the Turkish Cypriot population. They<br />

would be exposed to danger greater than that with<br />

which they lived in for ten years already and so they<br />

intervened. And we will go past later the beach where<br />

the troops first landed on the north of the island here.<br />

That’s one version of the story. There are others<br />

that say, and it seems within reason, that the Turks<br />

couldn’t possibly have amassed a force and the<br />

resources to invade at such short notice. And the<br />

argument is that they were just actually waiting for an<br />

excuse, which they had been planning all along. And<br />

so there is two versions of history on that one. In either<br />

case, here we are. The troops attacked at Kyrenia on<br />

the north and took one part of the island and three<br />

days later they came around and attacked another<br />

side out into the west of the island. That was a time<br />

where there was alleged a large number of atrocities<br />

committed on that second landing against Turkish<br />

Cypriots, a reprisal move. In any case the fighting<br />

lasted 12 days. The Turkish troops moved fast. From<br />

having nothing on day one, by day 12 they captured<br />

37% of the island.<br />

Dominic: By day 12?<br />

Madeline: Yes.<br />

Dominic: Was there much resistance? Were the<br />

Greek Cypriots or the Greek government prepared<br />

for this or was it completely unexpected?


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...by that time the UN was able to broker a ceasefire and that was what led to the definition of the ceasefire<br />

lines as they are now and the buffer zones and the points between them.<br />

Madeline: No it wasn’t. Well you see of course<br />

the Greek government was in disarray since, there<br />

had been a coup. The president was in hiding. The<br />

coupists had come there prepared to take over<br />

the government, they had not come there to fight<br />

another nation’s invading force. The militias which<br />

had been operating were not very well organised<br />

and certainly not as well equipped as a Turkish<br />

army at its full strength.<br />

Dominic: It could be argued that they did<br />

considerably well to retain as much as they did of<br />

the island under those circumstances.<br />

The figures from that<br />

time suggest that we are<br />

talking about 165,000<br />

Greek Cypriots that<br />

moved from the north to<br />

the south. 45,000 Turkish<br />

Cypriots were displaced<br />

the other way, from south<br />

to north. All of them<br />

of course leave their<br />

property, their businesses,<br />

their connections, their<br />

livelihoods behind.<br />

Madeline: Yeah, I don’t know, that’s for the<br />

military analysts to comment on I guess, probably<br />

true. Anyway, by that time the UN was able to<br />

broker a ceasefire and that was what led to the<br />

definition of the ceasefire lines as they are now<br />

and the buffer zones and the points between them.<br />

Over the course of that 12 days and in fact in the<br />

period leading up to it as well there had been<br />

huge population movements. Turkish Cypriots had<br />

started moving from mixed villages in the south to<br />

Turkish Cypriot villages in the south or to Turkish<br />

Cypriot areas in the north and they started that way<br />

back in 63. Naturally when the events of ‘74 took<br />

place Greek Cypriots were displaced in massive<br />

numbers. The figures from that time suggest that<br />

we are talking about 165,000 Greek Cypriots that<br />

moved from the north to the south. 45,000 Turkish<br />

Cypriots were displaced the other way, from south<br />

to north. All of them of course leave their property,<br />

their businesses, their connections, their livelihoods<br />

behind. So that is one of the sensitive and difficult<br />

issues for the settlement now to date. How are<br />

those losses now going to be either restored or<br />

compensated for? A very different view is put<br />

forward by the two parties on that question.<br />

Dominic: Would that be the most sensitive and<br />

difficult issue, the repatriation of the Greek and


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Turkish Cypriot refugees?<br />

Madeline: Arguably yes I believe so.<br />

Dominic: And that’s obviously your speciality as<br />

well or your area.<br />

Madeline: And it’s interesting because, if you<br />

compare it to a situation like in Bosnia, it’s both<br />

easier and harder to solve than Bosnia. In Bosnia<br />

you’re talking about a much, much larger number<br />

of people. There are two million displaced refugees<br />

from their homes. The conflict then was a massive<br />

scale by<br />

comparison,<br />

with years<br />

of war and<br />

unspeakable<br />

brutality. It<br />

did not exist<br />

in the same<br />

way here.<br />

All of that<br />

of course<br />

has a huge<br />

impact and<br />

makes it a more difficult and intricate problem to<br />

solve. But on the other hand one thing that arguably<br />

makes <strong>Cyprus</strong> harder is the passage of time.<br />

Because here there has been an entire generation<br />

now that has grown up not knowing what it is like<br />

going to live with, go to school with, work with<br />

those people on the other side. At least in Bosnia<br />

people remembered what things were like in the<br />

good old deep days five years ago and those who<br />

have goodwill to live together again can see it as<br />

a realistic prospect. Here there is a lot of people<br />

who have either totally forgotten or have never<br />

known what it is like to co-exist. So the resentment,<br />

the fear, the mistrust or the idea of going back or<br />

allowing them freely to circulate amongst us is much<br />

greater. So that definitely complicates things. On<br />

the property front of course the other things that<br />

complicates that is that the passage of time had<br />

lead to huge development, change in the physical<br />

nature of the place. There has been a lot of building,<br />

sometimes on areas and land that was owned by<br />

the other community. There has also been a lot of<br />

deterioration, so places that once were very valuable<br />

and desirable may not be that way. And you have<br />

also had the normal process occur of urbanisation<br />

where rural folks have moved to the towns. A lot of<br />

those people who were the children of olive farmers<br />

and goat herds on the Greek Cypriot side in the early<br />

1970s are today university educated stock brokers<br />

in an urban dwelling. So the idea of whether it’s<br />

just then to evict a Turkish Cypriot farmer from the<br />

farmland that belonged to that family in order to<br />

provide a nice holiday house for the stockbroker to<br />

go to on weekends is a difficult one.<br />

Dominic: I notice here that the houses, would<br />

these mostly be holiday houses for Turkish people or<br />

are these people who are resident on the island?<br />

Madeline: No, this is residents on the island.<br />

There are quite a few expatriates here however.<br />

There’s quite a lot of British and German people<br />

who come here to retire. British in particular<br />

because there are a lot of Brits who worked and<br />

lived here during the colonial administration time<br />

and have strong<br />

So the idea of whether it’s<br />

just then to evict a Turkish<br />

Cypriot farmer from the<br />

farmland that belonged<br />

to that family in order to<br />

provide a nice holiday<br />

house for the stockbroker<br />

to go to on weekends is a<br />

difficult one.<br />

sentimental<br />

attachments to<br />

it. The Turkish<br />

people and the<br />

settlers, are also<br />

up here. There<br />

is a lot of them<br />

in those quarters<br />

in the centre<br />

of Nicosia that<br />

you saw. There<br />

is a lot of them<br />

in the farming areas, the less desirable farmland<br />

that we drove through before. And also some of<br />

the more remote areas on the coast. The desirable<br />

areas like this tend to be for the elite or military up<br />

here. I would keep the microphone down right now<br />

because they are watching us. The Turkish Cypriot<br />

elite would be here inhabiting some of these more<br />

desirable and beautiful places.<br />

Dominic: It’s not the French Riviera, but it’s<br />

certainly not industrial wasteland either.<br />

Madeline: It’s very picturesque, and peaceful.<br />

Dominic: The view is stunning It is a very<br />

beautiful area and it is appropriate that you have<br />

houses to accommodate.<br />

Madeline: This is a village where Lawrence<br />

Durrell lived, who was this British author who wrote<br />

Bitter Lemons, about <strong>Cyprus</strong> of course.<br />

Dominic: My father was a great lover of Lawrence<br />

Durrrell. He met both him and Robert Graves.<br />

Madeline: Yes of course.<br />

Dominic: I’ve actually not read any of his books.<br />

The Tree of Idleness, we’re here.<br />

Madeline: Yes that’s the Faniente L.P And this is<br />

L.P, that’s the monastery that’s portrayed on your


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

He replied ‘yes!’ And she said ‘Would you like medium, soft or hard?’. He<br />

said, ‘Well what is a hard one?’ And her reply was, ‘It is terrorist!’.<br />

hotel host’s wall.<br />

Dominic:Ah it is sad that we are going there and<br />

they are not.<br />

Madeline: And they probably must have lived here<br />

and they are probably very attached to it.<br />

Dominic: And there’s nothing worse than rubbing<br />

salt into someone’s nostalgia—perhaps it was their<br />

home.<br />

Madeline: Well it depends, wait till you get to know<br />

them a bit better. They might love to hear about it.<br />

They might love to ask what it looks like now and see<br />

your photos or whatever, but don’t rush into it. They<br />

might also be angry and bitter and say how dare you go<br />

up there and eat food that those traitors are selling to<br />

you.<br />

At the abbey we lunched under what is referred to<br />

as The Tree of Idleness in one of the Lawrence Durrell<br />

novels. Durrell refers to the tree as the place where<br />

one could linger and never wish to return, a moment of<br />

distilled tranquillity. It possessed an energy and power,<br />

that allowed people to focus on the ‘not doing’ of their<br />

lives.<br />

We went to the Aqua Hotel from Belapais through<br />

to Karavas, which lies to the west, on the northern<br />

coast, with Rob and Miran, who had met up with<br />

us again. So including Madeline and Rebecca it was<br />

decided to visit a ‘hamam’. There a Romanian woman<br />

who was providing the services, asked Rob, whether<br />

he would like a massage? He replied ‘yes!’ And she said<br />

‘Would you like medium, soft or hard?’. He said, ‘Well<br />

what is a hard one?’ And her reply was, ‘It is terrorist!’.<br />

After the massage and hamman we went to the<br />

port of Kyrenia which was implacably beautiful,<br />

picturesque, and formidable in ways that could<br />

perhaps be explained best by visits to Portofino on<br />

the Italian Riviera. There is sadness to think that the<br />

Greek people, who had once lived here and had to<br />

flee, cannot visit their home—to know that their loved<br />

homeland<br />

cannot be<br />

returned to.<br />

The port<br />

was bespeckled<br />

by<br />

miniature<br />

candles<br />

like fairy<br />

lights which<br />

glimmered in<br />

the night air.<br />

Wandering<br />

through the port was impregnated by this magical and<br />

ethereal aspect. Taken up we felt its presence. But<br />

simultaneously there was a sense that we experiencing<br />

something that other people could not<br />

On our return in the night, we were blinded<br />

by glazed lights refracting in rear vision mirrors.<br />

Rebecca lay asleep in the back. But I had this sense<br />

of relief from the ‘hammam’ and then home to bed.<br />

Madeline said goodbye, and that she would see us<br />

on the 13th or 14th when she returns from Geneva.<br />

I believe it’s a form of synchronicity that I have come<br />

at this point, during these political talks. Maybe it’s<br />

only coincidence, but I believe events always seem<br />

to dovetail in ways that we least expect. Points of<br />

departure are integrally connected.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

And when I say the steadycam is ‘cool’, he says ‘no, it’s not cool, it’s hot.’ And then there is laughter.<br />

Sunday, 29th October, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

This Sunday was a quiet empty day in the downtown when all the shops here in Greek Nicosia are shut. We<br />

wander through empty streets and filmed with our steadycam in the old part of south Nicosia. We find a cheap<br />

place to eat right at the wall between the two sides. The security guard says ‘No’ to us filming.<br />

And when I say the steadycam is ‘cool’, he says ‘no, it’s not cool, it’s hot.’ And then there is laughter.<br />

We then went looking for an internet bar and find something called the ‘Mad Bar’. Bulgarian and Sri Lankan<br />

women have been imported for use as cleaners, laundry attendants and labourers. A social gathering of this<br />

people is occurring outside a church. We are not certain what the purpose of their gathering was, but they were<br />

all women, who possessed a coyness and sweetness. We returned home realising that there was actually a time<br />

change in the day, and that it was an hour earlier than what it originally had been. Here there has been a time<br />

change as a result of day light saving.<br />

In the evening we bought some Chinese take-away food and returned to the hotel. After eating the Chinese<br />

food I put it in the refrigerator and the next day I went to open it and there was the most suppurating,<br />

nauseous smell exuding from the refrigerator. Rather than keeping everything cold the refrigerator had failed<br />

to operate. When I opened the door of the refrigerator, the whole refrigerator was like a furnace. From these<br />

styrofoam packets hot steaming rotten Chinese food shed vapours. It was absolutely disgusting.<br />

When I opened the door of the refrigerator, the whole refrigerator was like a furnace. From these styrofoam<br />

packets hot steaming rotten Chinese food shed vapours.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

But the secretary at the other desk seems totally<br />

disinterested and with a disconsolate flick of her wrist<br />

and a weary nod of her head, acknowledges my paltry<br />

existence and then returns happily to her Xerox copied<br />

document 36A<br />

‘Dominic, it’s because you are<br />

an artist that I embrace your<br />

work. It is because you are what<br />

you are that I wish to help you,<br />

but I cannot help you in the sense<br />

of referring you to anybody.’<br />

Monday, 30th October, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

We arise early, while Rebecca my loyal faithful<br />

and beautiful assistant races out the door urgently<br />

looking for an apartment. We searching different<br />

options because the Hotel Excelsior is expensive.<br />

If we remain at the price we will be paying we will<br />

end up being frugal and uneconomic. Rebecca rings<br />

numerous real estate agents. But we soon discover<br />

that by contacting the owner of the hotel we can<br />

negotiate a price both comfortable for our pockets<br />

over an extended period we wish to remain.<br />

Meanwhile I walk to the old city where I<br />

have pre-ordained, rendezvous with Katia who<br />

is the Cultural Relations Representative at the<br />

Municipality of Nicosia, (the southern Nicosia) or<br />

as it is referred to The Republic of <strong>Cyprus</strong>. Katia<br />

opened the door and stared at me. There was a<br />

brief 20 seconds of mute staring, looking at me as<br />

if she has seen a ghost. When I introduced myself<br />

she realises at last that I am the person that she<br />

has communicated from afar through emails, and<br />

correspondence these last three months.<br />

And she indicates, pointing, to her colleagues<br />

as she walks in with me, ‘this is the Dominic Ryan,<br />

do you remember him? He is here, in person, after<br />

all of our correspondence’. But the secretary at the<br />

other desk seems totally disinterested and with a<br />

disconsolate flick of her wrist and a weary nod of<br />

her head, acknowledges my paltry existence and<br />

then returns happily to her Xerox copied document<br />

36A, while I return to Katia. Katia explains bluntly,<br />

without blinking that the exhibition has been<br />

rejected by the authorities here, the Municipal<br />

Council. End of story.<br />

The <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> <strong>2000</strong>, booklet and submission<br />

for a joint mayoral meeting which I had sent to her<br />

four months ago, had been referred to the Cultural<br />

Committee.<br />

One of her letters went:<br />

‘Thank you for your recent letter<br />

concerning for your proposal for the peace<br />

project <strong>2000</strong>. I would like to inform you<br />

that the matter has been forwarded to the<br />

Cultural Committee for discussion and we<br />

will revert in due course. Yours sincerely,<br />

Katia, Cultural and Public Relations Officer<br />

for Town Clerk.’<br />

That was on the 1st of March <strong>2000</strong>. Well, finally<br />

the information came through that the Cultural<br />

Committee had decided that my project was<br />

financially inoperable, even though we had provided<br />

them a budget and suggested that money need not<br />

to be paid by the Nicosia Municipality. Either they<br />

used that as a pretext by saying that it was too<br />

expensive, or they misunderstood.<br />

The only thing I can do is neither take it<br />

personally, nor presume that the municipality has<br />

said no, but to find another way of doing this.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

I then attempted to telephone Bullant Kanol from one of the telephone booths in the town square. He was<br />

the Undersecretary to the Deputy Prime Minister of the alleged government of the alleged country, or quasicountry,<br />

North <strong>Cyprus</strong> or the Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>. But the telephone did not work.<br />

I spoke to Katia: ‘So what do we do?’<br />

She replied: ‘Dominic, it’s because you are<br />

an artist that I embrace your work. It is because<br />

you are what you are that I wish to help you, but<br />

I cannot help you in the sense of referring you to<br />

anybody. Do it yourself and I suggest you speak to<br />

the mayor himself, Mr. Lelos Dimitriades. You must<br />

make the submission yourself alone and take it from<br />

there.’<br />

Which is exactly what I did. I crossed the<br />

hall with firm and even strides down two empty<br />

parquet corridors and finally encountered one of<br />

the secretaries responsible for the Mayor Lelos<br />

Demitriades. Her name was Sophie, and she was<br />

a diminutive Greek woman who sits like a moving<br />

statue at a brown formica desk with a bobbed<br />

haircut and mascared eyes. She does not know<br />

who I am or what I am. Not that I am important,<br />

I am literally unimportant. I explain in a few<br />

short sentences my request. She understands and<br />

perseveres and we get the fax number to send one<br />

message. My feeling was, and is, that the only way<br />

I can do such an event is to put on my blinkers and<br />

plough through heedless of what others say.<br />

I then attempted to telephone Bullant Kanol<br />

from one of the telephone booths in the town<br />

square. He was the Undersecretary to the Deputy<br />

Prime Minister of the alleged government of the<br />

alleged country, or quasi-country, North <strong>Cyprus</strong> or<br />

the Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>. But the telephone<br />

did not work. All I could hear after dialling the<br />

international and then city code was a white<br />

noise of static—then everything went quiet. The<br />

international dialling did not allow us to telephone<br />

across 600 metres from Greek Nicosia to Turkish<br />

Nicosia. The computers were programmed to not<br />

permit this transfer. Yet again I took out my Nokia<br />

mobile, the one that they used for the film The<br />

Matrix, with a flip and click opening a large screen,<br />

but it remains not working.<br />

Monday, 30th October, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Meanwhile back to Monday the 30th. I am having<br />

irritating technical problems with the mobile,<br />

because the pin number does not come through.<br />

The telephone has seized up. I have to telephone<br />

Van—the Vietnamese mobile phone dealer from<br />

Clarendon Street. in South Melbourne—on his<br />

mobile at three o’clock in the morning to clear this<br />

up—Australia time. I then telephone Antonios, who<br />

is Spanish and who works for the Friends of the<br />

Earth in Larnacca. It is possible that he may be of<br />

assistance in erecting the billboard. Rebecca was<br />

probably right, while I was initially dismissive of his<br />

help. Then I realised that he is just what we need.<br />

Telephone agenda: I telephone the spokesperson<br />

for the United Nations UNIFCYP, Sarah Russell,<br />

who coordinates press and public relations, and<br />

then Nikos Anastasios. Anastasios is one of the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“The United Nations resolutions which are endorsed by<br />

the European Union provide for the establishment of a<br />

bi-zonal, bi-communal federation. That is within one<br />

single sovereign and independent state where human<br />

rights will be respected.”<br />

“...the greatest challenge for Turkey now is to learn to become<br />

an ally of the west, not only on the military level, but also on<br />

the level of civil society and democratisation.”<br />

major coordinators of peace and reconciliation in the Pyle region, a buffer zone and Paphos region. He has done<br />

a lot to assist and establish many forms of reconciliation in the area. One of the emails that Rebecca sent me<br />

indicated information about Nikos, including Harris Anastasios, who is Nikos’s brother, a Harvard graduate.<br />

‘Well’, Harris Anastasios says, ‘well of course this is everybody’s hope that (reconciliation) indeed, this will<br />

take place. Of course one must remember that this area has a historical background to the Turkish style of<br />

politics. Of course we know that Turkey for many years, since the cold war has been a strong military ally to<br />

the west. Of course since the collapse of the Eastern block the rules have now been redefined. I think that the<br />

greatest challenge for Turkey now is to learn to become an ally of the west, not only on the military level, but<br />

also on the level of civil society and democratisation.’<br />

And then this woman Irene Q responds. ‘Now with regards to <strong>Cyprus</strong> in particular, the main bone of<br />

contention is that the United Nations resolutions which are endorsed by the European Union provide for the<br />

establishment of a bi-zonal, bi-communal federation. That is within one single sovereign and independent


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

One has to understand that historically these two positions reflect that on the one hand the Greek claim that<br />

the island is a unitary island and it makes no sense to divide an island so small into two states and on the<br />

other hand the Turkish position was based on security issues.<br />

Their position was that the best way to resolve security issues was to actually partition the island.<br />

state where human rights will be respected. Turkey<br />

on the other hand is insisting on a confederation<br />

of two separate states. Now the <strong>Cyprus</strong> House of<br />

Representatives have stressed very recently that it<br />

would reject any proposals and any ideas containing<br />

the seeds, as to put it, of confederation for the<br />

establishment of two states.’<br />

What’s the rationale behind these two very<br />

different visions and are they so different?<br />

Harris Anastasios : ‘It’s really a perennial<br />

problem of stressing state sovereignty on the one<br />

hand which aligns more with the Greek Cypriot<br />

position over against self-determination which aligns<br />

more with the Turkish Cypriot position. One has<br />

to understand that historically these two positions<br />

reflect that on the one hand the Greek claim that<br />

the island is a unitary island and it makes no sense<br />

to divide an island so small into two states and on<br />

the other hand the Turkish position was based<br />

on security issues. Their position was that the<br />

best way to resolve security issues was to actually<br />

partition the island. However one has to molest it<br />

further and place this dilemma in the European<br />

context. Because I think by placing this dilemma<br />

of federation on the one hand and confederation<br />

on the other in the European context, I think that<br />

paralysation eases off. It eases off because first of<br />

all the European position, which is aligned with the<br />

United States position makes it very clear that they<br />

will only accept <strong>Cyprus</strong> as a single state. However<br />

with that, and again they’re looking at the European<br />

models, federation with considerable autonomy to<br />

the respective states which make up federations,<br />

has been increasing in the European Union. We<br />

have seen the devolution of state or power. We have<br />

seen it with Wales and Scotland, we have seen it<br />

also in Spain. There is also a process whereby in a<br />

centralised state, state power loosens up, de-evolves.<br />

And there is also a fair bit of lateralisation in the<br />

power of central states vis a vis the European Union<br />

which is essentially a trans-national, trans-state<br />

system.<br />

And then it goes on. But there is also another<br />

dimension that has to do with the changing<br />

environment of the <strong>Cyprus</strong> problem, namely that<br />

Greece, Turkey and <strong>Cyprus</strong> are now within the<br />

European orbit. As you very well know Greece is<br />

now a member of the European Union. <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

and Turkey are both candidate members. This<br />

means that they are all travelling on the same road.<br />

Of course this does not show up directly in the<br />

negotiations, but it is a background factor.’ Then it<br />

goes on to Nikos Anastasios.<br />

‘My first response is that it comes from my<br />

family. She’s asking where this sort of sense of the<br />

divided homeland and wanting to bring it together<br />

came from. We grew up in a family environment<br />

where reconciliation and a peaceful way of resolving<br />

conflict was a way of life for us. So as we grew<br />

up and became members of a society which was<br />

suffering from so much conflict I suppose it was a<br />

natural continuation of our way of life. Nikos says<br />

that he works on a grass roots level trying to bring<br />

people together on an island that is divided:


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“And the only place where we can meet these<br />

days is the very small village which is in the<br />

buffer zone called Pyle where it is under UN<br />

control....There seems to be an increasing<br />

awareness of this deep need for the people to<br />

get together and discuss and understand each<br />

other’s fears and try to work out what on earth<br />

happened on this island where so many innocent<br />

people have suffered so unnecessarily.”<br />

‘I work with the younger people, I work with the older people and I feel that no matter what the politicians<br />

may decide, no matter how good or bad the solution may look on paper; unless on the grass roots level there<br />

is trust between the ordinary people, that there’s no possibility for a workable solution for something that<br />

would last for years to come. I would like to say that it is easier and more difficult at the same time, just given<br />

with just like the older generation there is a spectrum of people in each community, people who are heavily or<br />

violently—I might even say (a nationalistic) community. People who are in favour of this re-approchement as we<br />

save the two communities. So the spectrum can be found amongst the younger people also. What is relatively<br />

new in the sense of what people have expected in the Cypriot society is that these young people, the ones that<br />

are interested and come to the meeting and meet the enemy as it were for the first time; these encounters are<br />

dramatic experiences. They involve a shift and a transformation. And suddenly the enemy has a face. It is not<br />

just the image of the *, but rather it is a person with whom they have a lot more in common than they would<br />

have expected.<br />

‘It’s interesting. Now you are talking about meetings and encounters. How difficult is it to bring this about in<br />

the present climate? Well as you know the island of <strong>Cyprus</strong> is geographically divided with the Turkish Cypriots<br />

living in the north and the Greek Cypriots living in the south. And the only place where we can meet these days<br />

is the very small village which is in the buffer zone called Pyle where it is under UN control. Now under certain<br />

conditions people can enter in and out of that area. There seems to be an increasing awareness of this deep<br />

need for the people to get together and discuss and understand each other’s fears and try to work out what<br />

on earth happened on this island where so many innocent people have suffered so unnecessarily. It seems the<br />

meetings which started with a relatively small number of people are gathering momentum. They are becoming<br />

much larger in number. The media are no longer suspicious as they used to be at the beginning. There is a<br />

shift from being outright negative to being supportive and promoting the bi-communal effort and this is very<br />

encouraging for us. And he goes on to talk about his projects. I might continue that later. No it’s not too bad,<br />

it’s not that long.<br />

‘As you know the island of <strong>Cyprus</strong> is divided with the Turkish Cypriots in the north and the Greek Cypriots<br />

in the south. Well I can mention the immediate next event that we are planning. We are concentrating on<br />

one district in the south where at the moment mainly Greek Cypriots live, the district of Paphos, which was<br />

a district before the war in ‘74 and the separation of the population. It was an area where there were many<br />

mixed villages and the Greek and Turkish Cypriots used to live together. All of these people, the majority of<br />

which have good relationships with each other were good friends, very good neighbours and have not seen<br />

each other for 26 years. So we formed a group of teenagers, Greek Cypriots whose parents came from Paphos<br />

and Turkish Cypriots whose parents originally came from Paphos. And we met for a couple of days at the buffer<br />

zone in Pyle. And this group decided that it was the most important they could undertake in an effort to bring<br />

together all these parents of theirs and their friends and all these people from the district. So at the moment we<br />

are in the middle of a campaign where the young people are spearheading efforts to hold hands together and<br />

take the older people by the hand and bring them together and meet for the first time after 26 years. We are


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“There is an over-emphasis of the violence in the past and there<br />

is an under-emphasis or even ignorance of the good times that<br />

the majority of people had together.”<br />

preparing the ground for these meetings by going to villages and asking people, who are your friends that you<br />

would like to meet again, give us their names and we’ll send a message and ask them to come along.<br />

Irene says: ‘That sounds fantastic, but what extent of approval would you say that your project meets with<br />

in the general population?’<br />

‘I would say that in the general Cypriot community the approval rates are going up very, very positively.<br />

People are realising that the majority of people do not want war. They do not want our island to be partitioned<br />

in the north. Things are more different because of the official position of the Turkish Cypriot authorities that<br />

we must be separated, we cannot live together. There is an over-emphasis of the violence in the past and there<br />

is an under-emphasis or even ignorance of the good times that the majority of people had together. So in that<br />

sense the Turkish Cypriot peace builder is working in a more difficult environment compared with the Greek<br />

Cypriot. Having said that we are breaking new ground and more and more Turkish Cypriots are coming to these<br />

meetings. In fact and it is interesting to note that in most of the big galleries, the majority of the people who<br />

now come along are the Turkish Cypriots.<br />

Tuesday 31st October, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I awoke with my eyelids glued shut but managed to wash the debris out at approximately 7.30am. After<br />

coffee I raced to the bank to change money from travellers cheques. In the capital Nicosia. We arrived by taxi<br />

at the Ledra Palace Checkpoint by 10.30, crossed it onto the Turkish side of Nicosia, where we encountered a<br />

barrage of rusted barb wire, twisted metal kind crosses, and the remaining dead zone appeared as if it was a<br />

village sucked into the past calcified into the 1960s.<br />

We cross walking without appearing as if we are attempting to photograph the area. Here there are soldiers<br />

from both sides as well as a UN monitoring crew who monitor the passages through the dead zone—a no man’s<br />

land between the two sides.<br />

It is a 500 metre (half a kilometre) gauntlet where the zone froze after the ‘74 invasion/intervention by the<br />

Turks. Buildings, which are slow crumbling and shelled retain the period style of the1960s and 70s. Everything<br />

is frozen at that particular moment when the invasion/liberation occurred. The closer I approach the dead zone,<br />

the more the area decelerates and acclimatises to the 1970s.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Still in Turkish Nicosia, we hail a taxi and travel to see the Undersecretary of the Deputy Prime Minister Bullant<br />

Kanol of Turkish <strong>Cyprus</strong>—the republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>, who is not there.<br />

There is a tenseness at the checkpoint crossings,<br />

and I anticipate we will encounter ministers and<br />

mayors who may be frightened of being publicly<br />

ridiculed for this humanitarian initiative.<br />

... a cast of odd and snooping<br />

characters, from fat concierges with<br />

Cheshire cat grins, to lost itinerant<br />

journalists, who have never settled down<br />

to a domestic lifestyle, to refrigerators that<br />

microwave your food instead of freeze<br />

it, to massacre sites made to seem like<br />

tourist attractions, to flatulent tourists from<br />

Germany and England who have not a<br />

clue of where they are.<br />

Those affected as refugees from both sides also<br />

seem psychically trapped at that moment in time.<br />

They had abandoned a part of themselves and have<br />

since been unable to make the transition to crawl<br />

out of that time. Even if it has not occurred for all<br />

people, since one third of the Greek Cypriots were<br />

rendered homeless, it has formed a volatile and<br />

unhealing scar.<br />

Now there is no inherent danger for us in this<br />

region. There is only the psychological torture<br />

of dealing with both sides and the belief that<br />

both sides may exploit our project for their own<br />

purposes. There is a tenseness at the checkpoint<br />

crossings, and I anticipate we will encounter<br />

ministers and mayors who may be frightened of<br />

being publicly ridiculed for this humanitarian<br />

initiative. Another trap is the unholy regard<br />

ministers have for their correct titles or references.<br />

I also must be always prepared for others to misuse<br />

the project for their own purposes.<br />

As we journey through this land we are privy<br />

to a cast of odd and snooping characters, from fat<br />

concierges with Cheshire cat grins, to lost itinerant<br />

journalists, who have never settled down to a<br />

domestic lifestyle, to refrigerators that microwave<br />

your food instead of freeze it, to massacre sites<br />

made to seem like tourist attractions, to flatulent<br />

tourists from Germany and England who have<br />

not a clue of where they are. It is a homogenised<br />

international zone of KFC, McDonald’s and Holiday<br />

Inn, Ombre Solaire and sunscreens.<br />

So I have to keep my cool over events since<br />

circumstances evolve or change by the minute. For<br />

example a government official who says ‘no’ may<br />

mean ‘no’, but I can always see the next official.<br />

It is a complex chess game. If I am caught in this<br />

web of officials I can navigate through them. By<br />

always trusting the innate goodness of all people<br />

and giving each the benefit of the doubt, even when<br />

I am confronted by evil all alone, I remain able to<br />

operate.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We then met this woman, Reiko, who was<br />

doing a Lonely Planet guide of the world as she was<br />

also crossing to North <strong>Cyprus</strong>. Meeting her at the<br />

checkpoint, she was a frightened, needing to stick with<br />

us. We hail her a taxi and escort her half way through<br />

into the zone of no man’s land, past the billboards<br />

of horror and suffering, political images of blood and<br />

damaged<br />

bones, the<br />

softness<br />

of flesh<br />

rendered<br />

inviolable.<br />

Still in<br />

Turkish<br />

Nicosia, we<br />

hail a taxi<br />

and travel<br />

to see the<br />

Undersecretary of the Deputy Prime Minister Bullant<br />

Kanol of Turkish <strong>Cyprus</strong>—the republic of North<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>, who is not there. I scrawl a s message with<br />

his secretary and then I go to see the mayor, Semi<br />

Bora. As it so happens we walk straight into his office.<br />

Mademoiselle Rebecca is filming and all of a sudden<br />

he appears. We don’t even realise that he is there. His<br />

secretary briskly goes in and he sticks his head out like<br />

a jack in the box:<br />

‘Do you have an appointment with me?’<br />

“No, we just appeared’, we say.<br />

He’s very polite, urbane—a little shy. We make<br />

a new appointment for the next couple of days and<br />

before we know it we are out in the street, outside<br />

the mayory thinking, well yes. A little bit of luck, since<br />

normally such interviews are strained, postponed<br />

and juggled. But in this instance it is not the case. We<br />

then travel directly to the public information office, to<br />

present our journalistic credential and papers.<br />

The document from Catholic Telecommunications<br />

is necessary for the Press Office and says:<br />

‘To whom it may concern, 26th of October<br />

<strong>2000</strong>, Letter of Accreditation.<br />

This letter is to confirm that Catholic<br />

Telecommunications is commissioning Dominic<br />

Ryan and Rebecca Prole, both Australian citizens<br />

and Amar Sabar, a citizen of Bosnia to report<br />

for our media organization, both on the cultural<br />

peace initiatives in <strong>Cyprus</strong> and Israel and on<br />

the cultural life of the two countries in general<br />

for a series of articles with accompanying<br />

photographs.<br />

Yours sincerely, Reverend Michael Kelly, SJ,<br />

Executive Director.’<br />

So we are finally introduced to one of the<br />

gentlemen there. His name is Mustafa Ereulgen,<br />

(TRNC Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Defence<br />

Information and Press Officer). I gaze at his benign<br />

face. He stands 5ft, 9 inches tall, with colloidal<br />

scarring on his face, dressed in and a sheer<br />

pinstriped suit, polka-dot red tie. They are very<br />

small dots because they are pink dotes set against<br />

a red background. His English is impeccable, and<br />

he indicates that he will contact us through Sarah<br />

Russell because it is not possible to actually ring us<br />

from the other side. He will meet us tomorrow at<br />

the Turkish side to the Ledra Palace Checkpoint. At<br />

this point we realise he will become our guide and<br />

we then have lunch in the centre at a cafe where<br />

Rebecca films.<br />

By chance I glance at my watch realising that<br />

it is already fifteen minutes to five o’clock. The<br />

Checkpoint closes at 5. If we are late it will take us<br />

a week to return via Istanbul and then Athens to<br />

Nicosia. We are racing to get back across the Green<br />

line to Greek Nicosia by five o’clock—on foot. In<br />

other words if a tourist fails to cross that border<br />

after 5 o’clock, even though it is a mere 200 metre<br />

walk, they must fly to Istanbul, then Athens, then<br />

Larnacca and then by taxi to Nicosia. Nonetheless<br />

we seem to make<br />

the deadline and<br />

The Checkpoint<br />

closes at 5. If we<br />

are late it will<br />

take us a week to<br />

return via Istanbul<br />

and then Athens<br />

to Nicosia.<br />

we cross at four<br />

minutes to five.<br />

We have a brief<br />

Turkish…oops<br />

Greek coffee in<br />

the Greek sector<br />

of the city, in one<br />

of the fashion<br />

coffee boutiques<br />

on Macarius street<br />

and then I leave<br />

Mademoiselle Rebecca and return home alone.<br />

She leaves for the internet and I find myself<br />

wandering disoriented, lost on the way home. As<br />

a result I stumble on a second floor gallery called<br />

Arcamidis Stafolini Gallery, and the exhibition ‘Youth<br />

dreams and fairies’ by the artist Polys Peslikas who<br />

studied at the EB France. The gallery director<br />

is called Miss Pavlina and immediately it strikes<br />

me, the idea that it would be really beautiful to<br />

film me talking about my exhibition here. The<br />

paintings remind me of both Gustav Klimt and<br />

Fernard Khnopff—baubles iconic and florescent.<br />

Upon returning that evening there is a meeting<br />

downstairs—in the hotel foyer.<br />

I pay the majority of the rent for the next<br />

month. There is a meeting of Kyrenia people who<br />

were originally residents of Kyrenia which was the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

I explained how we wanted it erected in the centre of this No-Man’s-Land. Studying him intently, he appears open<br />

and refrains from negating the idea.<br />

The exact title is Mayor, Semi Bora, President<br />

of the Organisation of Turkish Municipalities of<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>, Turkish Municipality of Nicosia.<br />

In this conservative, plastic flowered,<br />

dead-beat, middle-of-the-road hotel for<br />

lost journalists the motor cycle clan meets,<br />

clinks glasses, smoke dark black hand rolled<br />

tobacco, loud cacophony of Greek voices,<br />

and a milling mist.<br />

northern town, which was where we went to the<br />

port that day we went to Belapais.<br />

Then a motley motorcycle group appear as if<br />

out of nowhere at the bar of the Hotel Excelsior.<br />

Kyros the manager was also a motorcycle aficionado<br />

which is why he permits them. But why is there<br />

a connection with these long-haired, pony-tailed,<br />

not exactly leather-clad hells angels, but softer<br />

teddy bear versions. In this conservative, plastic<br />

flowered, dead-beat, middle-of-the-road hotel for<br />

lost journalists the motor cycle clan meets, clinks<br />

glasses, smoke dark black hand rolled tobacco, loud<br />

cacophony of Greek voices, and a milling mist.<br />

So I am sitting in the middle of a motorcycle<br />

reunion night, with wafting vapours of hashish<br />

smoke and stale Heineken beer thinking of the<br />

curious and odd vignettes that have occurred here<br />

in the forgotten world of the Excelsior. There is<br />

the refrigerator that heats up in the hotel which<br />

is trapped thirty years ago in a time-warp, and the<br />

Moscovite lady with her elderly husband who is<br />

always complaining about her child—a hebefrenic<br />

who suffers from Tourette’s syndrome, and is always<br />

running around like a child who has eaten too much<br />

sugar. I speak to the Moscovite lady later and she<br />

says<br />

‘Thank God I am going home. This child is doing<br />

my head in. At least when I return to Russia, my<br />

Babushka, grandmother can look after her and I will<br />

have my freedom.’<br />

So what else? There are the cleaning lady and<br />

Marius the concierge, an 18-year-old computer geek<br />

with moles, like a shotgun pepper spray all over his<br />

face who is semi-obese. Marius is not overweight,<br />

but rather portly and actually older than his years.<br />

He has style, intelligence and is much more mature<br />

than his real age.<br />

Wednesday, 5th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Today we have visited Mr. Semi Bora, the Turkish<br />

Mayor in Turkish/north Nicosia with Mustafa, our<br />

erstwhile bodyguard, minder and Public Information<br />

Officer from the TRNC. We passed the checkpoint<br />

from the Greek side to the North but we were five<br />

minutes late. Mustafa was waiting for us and then<br />

from the checkpoint drove us directly to see Mr.<br />

Semi Bora.<br />

The exact title is Mayor, Semi Bora, President of<br />

the Organisation of Turkish Municipalities of <strong>Cyprus</strong>,<br />

Turkish Municipality of Nicosia. The meeting was<br />

at 11 o’clock on Wednesday the 5th of November.<br />

Mustafa was there again in his pin striped suit,<br />

his Brillcream-ed hair, a trace of lemon deodorant,<br />

or it could be citron after shave, I am not certain.<br />

Everyone is beatific and friendly on this side and we<br />

are treated with civil cordiality.<br />

We are served rich sweet Turkish coffee which<br />

is thick like mud afterwards in his office. I recount<br />

the story of God and the devil on the mountain top<br />

to the Mayor and there is the introduction of the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

billboard texts, our intentions and the purpose of the<br />

meeting betwen the two mayors is fully explained.<br />

I explained how we wanted it erected in the<br />

centre of this No-Man’s-Land. Studying him intently,<br />

he appears open and refrains from negating the<br />

idea. He simply says that we will need to wait until<br />

the next meeting. I presume by his position that<br />

he actually doesn’t want to say no, he likes the<br />

idea, but he is careful about saying yes. Diplomatic<br />

speak, for maybe he cannot say yes! As he reclines<br />

across the vast landscape, indeed sovereignty of his<br />

desk. I walk over and invade his space, as Rebecca<br />

says, by stepping over onto the other side of the<br />

desk. One moment I am crouching down, the next<br />

one I am standing up, the next one I am crouching<br />

down, and whether he is interested or not, he seems<br />

friendly and open<br />

to these eccentric<br />

proceedings.<br />

We have coffee<br />

and we leave.<br />

Mustafa takes us to<br />

Barbarlik Muzest,<br />

(The Museum of<br />

Barbarism) No. 2<br />

*Irfan Bey Sokak,<br />

Kumsal, which is<br />

the neighbourhood.<br />

It is a museum<br />

which honours, or at least is a memorial to the<br />

massacre of a Turkish family by Greek Terrorists.<br />

The documents in the building along with graphic<br />

photographs illustrate the atrocities which were<br />

committed there.<br />

‘On Christmas Eve 24th December, 1963 over<br />

150 armed Greeks descended on the Turkish<br />

suburb of Kumsal, north west of the old city<br />

walls of Nicosia. One of the first doors smashed<br />

down was the front door of the house belonging<br />

to Major Dr. Nihat Ilhan, the chief medical officer<br />

of a contingent of the mainland Turkish army.<br />

The major was away on duty that night with<br />

his unit. While he was away, his wife Murlivett<br />

and his three children were brutally murdered<br />

in their bathtub by EOK terrorists. Mr. Usif<br />

Hasan Goodam, the elderly Turkish Cypriot<br />

landlord was himself wounded in the bathroom.<br />

In his own words: “on the night of the 24th of<br />

December 1963 my wife Feride Hasan and I<br />

were paying a visit to the family of Major Dr.<br />

Nihat Ilhan. Neighbours Mrs. Ayse of Mora, her<br />

daughter Isin and Mrs. Ayse’s sister, Novber also<br />

with us. We were sitting having supper.<br />

“All of a sudden bullets from the direction<br />

of the Perieos River started to riddle the house,<br />

sounding like heavy rain. Thinking the dining<br />

room where we were sitting was dangerous we<br />

fled to the bathroom and toilet which we thought<br />

would be safer. Altogether we were nine persons.<br />

We all hid in the bathroom except for my wife<br />

who took refuge in the toilet. We waited in fear.<br />

Mrs. Ilhan the wife of the major doctor was<br />

standing in the bath with her three children<br />

Murat, Kutzi and Hakan in her arms. Suddenly<br />

with a great noise we heard the front door burst<br />

open. Greeks had<br />

come in spraying<br />

every corner of the<br />

house with their<br />

machinegun bullets.<br />

During these moments<br />

I heard voices saying<br />

in Greek, ‘you want<br />

to take from us<br />

partition A’ and then<br />

bullets started flying<br />

in the bathroom.<br />

Mrs. Ilhan and her<br />

three children fell into the bath. They were<br />

shot. At this moment the Greeks who broke into<br />

the bathroom emptied their guns on us again.<br />

I heard one of the major’s children moan and<br />

then I fainted. When I came to myself, two or<br />

three hours later, I saw Mrs. Ilhan and her<br />

three children lying dead in the bath. I and the<br />

rest of the neighbours in the bathroom were all<br />

seriously wounded. But what had happened to<br />

my wife? Then I remembered and immediately<br />

ran to the toilet where, in the doorway, I saw<br />

her body. She had been brutally murdered.<br />

“In the street in the midst sounds of shots I<br />

heard voices crying ‘help, help, is there no one<br />

to save us?’ I became terrified. I thought that<br />

if the Greeks came again and found that I was<br />

not dead, they would kill me. So I ran to the<br />

bedroom and hid myself under the double bed.<br />

And hour passed by. In the distance I could still<br />

hear shots. My mouth was dry, so I came out<br />

from under the bed and drank some water and<br />

I put my sweets in my pocket and went back<br />

to the bathroom which was exactly as I left it<br />

an hour before. There I offered sweets to Mrs.<br />

Ayse, her daughter, and Mrs. Novber who were<br />

all wounded. We waited in the bathroom until<br />

five o’clock in the morning. I thought morning<br />

would never come. We were all wounded and<br />

needed to be taken to the hospital. Finally, as<br />

we could walk, Mrs. Novber went out into the<br />

street hoping to find help and walked as far as<br />

Cos. There we met some people who took us to<br />

hospital where we were operated on. When I<br />

regained consciousness I said that there were<br />

more wounded in the house and they went and<br />

brought Mrs. Ayse and her daughter to the<br />

hospital. After three days in hospital I was<br />

sent by plane to Ankara for further treatment.<br />

There I had four months’ treatment but I still<br />

cannot use my arm. On my return to <strong>Cyprus</strong>,<br />

Greeks arrested me at the airport. All that I<br />

have related above I told the Greeks during my<br />

detention. They then released me.“


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“All of a sudden bullets from the<br />

direction of the Perieos River started<br />

to riddle the house, sounding like<br />

heavy rain. Thinking the dining room<br />

where we were sitting was dangerous<br />

we fl ed to the bathroom and toilet<br />

which we thought would be safer.”<br />

“I heard voices crying ‘help, help, is there no one to save us?’<br />

I became terrified. I thought that if the Greeks came again<br />

and found that I was not dead, they would kill me.”<br />

“Mrs. Ilhan and her<br />

three children fell into<br />

the bath. They were<br />

shot. At this moment the<br />

Greeks who broke into<br />

the bathroom emptied<br />

their guns on us again. I<br />

heard one of the major’s<br />

children moan and then<br />

I fainted.”<br />

“...I saw in a bathroom the bodies of a mother and three children murdered because<br />

their father was a Turkish officer...”


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

So I stood still and in the house which had become a shrine to injustice. It was deeply moving, yet a searing<br />

sadness seemed to swamp me. In spite of my understanding of the illegitimacy of such acts of murder and<br />

injustice I sensed it was also propaganda and part of their Disneyland fair of massacres. But nonetheless it was<br />

upsetting and touching. Upon entering the museum, I saw that the building at the point of the murders had<br />

been retained. I could see that the bathroom is still intact. Everything is a time capsule from that particular<br />

day. I know that and the events which occurred within the house on that fateful day are used for purposes<br />

of propaganda. It is also a valid tool to show the brutality of the Greek Cypriots. I am also sure that there<br />

are equally sad images on the Greek side of Turkish brutality. It is all a form of points gaining. Whatever the<br />

propaganda, that building was haunted and that bathroom had a deep ingrained unmoveable stain. Such<br />

sadness is difficult to erase. Perhaps it was erased, but the souls of those people are still lingering when I<br />

entered the bathroom. I saw under the glass, the matted dried bloodstains and the broken pale cream dirty tiles<br />

and the lime green walls. I felt the sadness, that I could understand and taste a morsel of what was drunk here.<br />

And what was drunk was death, what was drunk was sadness.<br />

From there, the house of the innocents in the Museum of Barbarism we drove to a village up in the<br />

mountains called Tashkent. Out of a scene from the Win Wender’s movie, Paris, Texas we drove through dry<br />

willow-parched landscapes in this Diplomatic TRNC Mercedes, four door with the mute driver, with wraparound<br />

tinted glasses and the PIO (Public Information Officer) aficionado Mustafa holding forth on the nature<br />

of ‘the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question’. As the village nestled on a hillside came into view, we realised that this was a village<br />

which had originally existed in the south where 73 men had been killed so that every wife, bar one, had lost a<br />

husband. It was called ‘the Village of the Widows’ and after the massacre in 1974, the remaining villagers were<br />

relocated, and this village had been relocated here.<br />

The only male who lived in the village to have survived was now the grocery store keeper. As we wove<br />

through mangy barking dogs and crumbling whitewashed houses with gnarled olive groves, we finally arrived at<br />

a nondescript, vine covered house like any other, and lazily parked the car under a hot dry sun.<br />

The driver waited out the front as we went in. We were soon introduced to an old slightly crumpled woman<br />

in her late 60s. She appeared wizened, and confirmed my thoughts by explaining that she had rheumatoid<br />

arthritis. Mustafa explained that she was one of the widows. Hung evenly almost symmetrically around the<br />

walls was a series of twelve sepia and faded colour photographs of her deceased family who had been lost,<br />

murdered in the massacre. Not only had she lost her husband, but all of her children. Mustafa explained<br />

proudly, standing a few meters with his legs confidently apart from all of us:<br />

‘She is a martyr to our country’.<br />

It could be argued that she was the icon of TRNC propaganda, the trump card that is always pulled out<br />

for hungry foreign journalists to salivate over or the press to depict the sufferings of a specific human being.<br />

Nonetheless there was something devastatingly sorrowful about this state of affairs. It was genuine beneath<br />

the theatre! She was a mother and wife who lived as a victim to the iniquities of the past. But the saddest<br />

ingredient was that she remained imprisoned by this past. She was a captive of the past, and it was difficult for<br />

her to step out of it. Nor did she wish to.<br />

Sometimes when an event has scarred us, we become frozen in the time of its occurrence and are incapable<br />

of stepping outside its milieu. When a person is so traumatised, a part of their soul is lost. It is a question<br />

of soul retrieval; that she must return to the south where her village once existed or to her memories and<br />

disengage. But for one so old such a task is impossible. I believe and these are but my mere opinions that<br />

she lost so much of her self that she would have to return to retrieve that lost portion in order to be healed.<br />

She finished our meeting by describing the events which had happened, and the moment that she did she<br />

immediately stepped back into that time. In doing so the massive hurt of the past was alive and there were<br />

tears in her eyes. Twenty-six years ago is yesterday.<br />

Rebecca was crying. Rebecca asked me, and it was something that I was probably about to do, I went over<br />

and put my arm around her and held her and then I started to philosophise about the nature of suffering, silly<br />

ridiculous Dom. There is a mystery to suffering and why people suffer.<br />

At this point while there was cascading tears, genuine compassion, and genuine misunderstanding, the widow’s<br />

son came in. There was one son who survived it now appeared. I think the only one who had survived. She then gave<br />

us boiled figs in a pink rose syrup to eat. The figs had nuts in them and we ate each one and sipped politely a glass of<br />

slightly brackish water. We thanked her and then went our different ways, to drive back silently without discussing<br />

our recapitulation—past the guards, the surly lights, the barbedwire checkpoint into the brassy wealth of Greek<br />

Nicosia. We went into the Holiday Inn on the side of the city near Lefcosha Square. I smashed my hand in one of<br />

the glass doors, but there was little blood, looking for Reiko the Japanese Lonely Planet girl and after not finding her<br />

with that we forlornly home to our two star Excelsior Apartments Hotel.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Out of a scene from the Win Wender’s movie, Paris, Texas we drove through dry willow-parched landscapes<br />

in this Diplomatic TRNC Mercedes, four door with the mute driver, with wrap-around tinted glasses and the<br />

PIO (Public Information Officer) aficionado Mustafa holding forth on the nature of ‘the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question’.<br />

Hung evenly almost symmetrically around the<br />

walls was a series of twelve sepia and faded<br />

colour photographs of her deceased family who<br />

had been lost, murdered in the massacre.<br />

‘She is a martyr to our country’.<br />

...this was a village which<br />

had originally existed in the<br />

south where 73 men had<br />

been killed so that every<br />

wife, bar one, had lost a<br />

husband. It was called ‘the<br />

Village of the Widows’ and<br />

after the massacre in 1974,<br />

the remaining villagers were<br />

relocated, and this village had<br />

been relocated here.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Thursday, 2nd November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Today was an anti-climax<br />

to the climax of the<br />

spectacular events which<br />

had accosted us yesterday.<br />

Natasha Jouravleva, my girlfriend or rather long<br />

distance girlfriend had always said to me is, ‘if<br />

you have a good day one day then you will have<br />

a less good day the next.’ It was her superstition.<br />

So it was a question of first nirvana, then the<br />

laundry, but with the heat, the benzine, the wait,<br />

the grumpiness, nothing really being resolved, but<br />

carrying plastic bags like reticent clochards and<br />

by George, it seemed to us that the odyssey was<br />

no longer becoming idyllic but elongated.<br />

I was saying to Rebecca the day before,<br />

something that Natasha Jouravleva, my girlfriend<br />

or rather long distance girlfriend had always said<br />

to me is, ‘if you have a good day one day then<br />

you will have a less good day the next.’ It was her<br />

superstition. But it occurred this day. Today was an<br />

anti-climax to the climax of the spectacular events<br />

which had accosted us yesterday. It was a day of<br />

ridiculous trivial events. We arrived at the mayory in<br />

the south of Nicosia and there was no Mayor Lelos<br />

Dimitriades. The woman said that he was going to<br />

be leaving in a couple of days and that perhaps we<br />

should put our submission in writing.<br />

Then we had coffee with Antoine Salome who is<br />

a Lebanese journalist for Le Figaro and also writes<br />

for a couple of Egyptian daily newspapers. Now<br />

staying also at the Excelsior Apartments he is tall<br />

but stooping, passive, maybe 5ft, 10 inches, wears<br />

suits rolled at their cuffs and is very articulate and<br />

generous. He told us, or rather than telling, such is<br />

Antoine’s manner, instructed us that we should seek<br />

out a laundromat. Unfortunately the laundromat is<br />

no where to be found. We ended up by carrying two<br />

baskets of laundry all the way from the outskirts of<br />

the city down to the old city. So it was a question<br />

of first nirvana, then the laundry, but with the heat,<br />

the benzine, the wait, the grumpiness, nothing<br />

really being resolved, but carrying plastic bags like<br />

reticent clochards and by George, it seemed to us<br />

that the odyssey was no longer becoming idyllic but<br />

elongated.<br />

Finally we found ourselves walking up<br />

Kennedy Avenue in pursuit of the un-pursuable, I<br />

surrendered to having dirty laundry for a week. So<br />

I rather selfishly told Rebecca to go in search out<br />

a laundry without carrying the clothes any further.<br />

At 1 o’clock that afternoon I had a meeting with<br />

Miss Pavlina at the gallery which I had spoken<br />

about earlier. It was the Arcamidis Staffolini Gallery.<br />

Basilicus’s first solo exhibition, ‘Youth, Dreams and<br />

Fairies’. I explained the situation of our mission<br />

to <strong>Cyprus</strong> and Miss Pavlina, pert and officious


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

immediately went into fear mode. I could see that<br />

she was totally frightened as her pupils enlarged,<br />

her features seemed to freeze in mid-sentence. I was<br />

requesting to film in front of her exhibition, with<br />

Dominic discussing the possibilities of doing the<br />

<strong>Peace</strong> Initiative in the Dead Zone. She believed that<br />

I talking in front of the paintings would compromise<br />

her exhibition. She felt that the art could be seen<br />

or misconstrued as being part of a sinister political<br />

statement. All I could reply was that this was not<br />

the case, that we were actually attempting to give a<br />

message of compassion and peace, which is nonpolitical.<br />

Her position was firm, even implacable,<br />

She would not respond positively. I walked away<br />

feeling disappointed. I said to her: ‘Even if you have<br />

a shadow of a doubt<br />

that my position<br />

is political and<br />

the filming would<br />

compromise you, I<br />

will not film. I do not<br />

a wish to give people<br />

fear, and I am here<br />

to create peace, not<br />

to create distrust. If<br />

there is one shadow<br />

of a doubt then I<br />

walk away. Even if<br />

...as her pupils<br />

enlarged, her<br />

features seemed<br />

to freeze in midsentence.<br />

you wish to reconsider, I do not wish to be involved.’<br />

So it was not a question of my pain about<br />

the situation, it was certainly not a question of a<br />

problem, but it certainly was a question of disdain<br />

on her behalf—not disdain, let me correct that. It<br />

was just her fear, and if someone steps into their<br />

fear, what can I do to convince them otherwise?<br />

What can I do to respond? Generally nothing. I<br />

must give them the support, even if that support is<br />

something which means I walk away.<br />

Right now I am sitting on this window sill at the<br />

Excelsior Hotel, looking out at Nicosia and it is a<br />

rich dark chocolate night. I can see people at their<br />

small lilliputian windows, figures and silhouettes<br />

in the ten-story buildings surrounding us. People<br />

engaging in their own lives. People performing<br />

domestic rituals. I walked away feeling disappointed.<br />

It reminded me when I had travelled in 1994 to<br />

Geneva to approached the UN Palais de Nations<br />

about the Millenium exhibition which included a<br />

human rights declaration. The curator had rejected<br />

the exhibition on the grounds of the Declaration.<br />

”You have a declaration for Human Rights and it may<br />

conflict with ours”. It was such a small insignificant<br />

rejection, but it is sometimes the small things which<br />

multiply . And when small effects add up, they<br />

undermine a person’s will like water on a rock. I do<br />

not despair completely because if I had I would have<br />

surrendered many centuries ago, many lifetimes ago,<br />

many universes ago, but nonetheless it makes me<br />

feel that the way is hard. The greater the challenge,<br />

the more spectacular and more interesting the<br />

experience is in surmounting it.<br />

The final document has been sent to Sarah<br />

Russell, spokesperson UN, it is dated 31st of<br />

October <strong>2000</strong>.<br />

‘Dear Ms. Russell,<br />

enclosed with this note is a letter of<br />

accreditation from Catholic Telecommunications.<br />

We will be visiting the North of <strong>Cyprus</strong> and<br />

after discussions with your colleague, Madeline<br />

Garlick, and a telephone call to you, I am<br />

addressing this in writing to you. We are hoping<br />

to visit most parts of the north, but my work will<br />

be concentrated in meetings in the central area<br />

of the city of Nicosia. Passport numbers, both<br />

Australian, of the two of us are Dominic Ryan ----<br />

. Rebecca Prole ---. I am also requesting a tour of<br />

the buffer zone for Tuesday, a week’s time.<br />

Thank you and sincerely Dominic Ryan,<br />

Excelsior apartments.<br />

The afternoon was a sultry with a south east mistral<br />

wind when Antoine, Rebecca and I, at about three<br />

o’clock, decided to drive off for lunch. We drove up into<br />

the outskirts of the city, in a taxi Antoine had selected<br />

into one of the<br />

suburbs searching for<br />

Japanese restaurant<br />

called “Montmatre”<br />

of all things, which,<br />

as Antoine effused<br />

had a spectacular<br />

view. As we drove up<br />

some guests were<br />

leaving who told<br />

us the restaurant<br />

was closed at three<br />

o’clock, so we<br />

drove back towards the old part of the city. We found<br />

on a very very small street close to Leforos Square a<br />

restaurant near the mayory on Aristokyprou where<br />

Antoine pulled out a bottle of Palomino, a bottle of<br />

dry white wine. And we engaged in a sort of long and<br />

extended afternoon where Antoine discussed the<br />

people that he had met, name dropping as he went.<br />

Whether it was Alain Delon, or Yasser Arafat, or Barak.<br />

The thing I liked most about what he said was when I<br />

asked him what a politician was and he said:<br />

‘A politician is a man that has many masks. Each<br />

mask shows a different face. On the one hand there is<br />

the face which he wears when he visits his family, the<br />

other hand the face when he visits his constituency,<br />

then the face he shows when he deals with his peers,<br />

and beneath all these masks, there is the mask of<br />

expediency and of predatory ambition.’


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Bone dry road, bouncing<br />

up and down with Mustafa<br />

in the back pontificating<br />

about the TRNC (Turkish<br />

republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>)<br />

and the political climate<br />

and the state of the<br />

country: ‘No, we are<br />

effectively not recognised<br />

by the rest of the world,<br />

but we are here.’<br />

Friday, 3rd November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

At 6.30 we awoke. It is early morning, dusk and a few trill birds are babbling at our window. There are<br />

problems with the batteries with the cameras since they did not seem to be able to be charged. This is for the<br />

two Sony VX100 cameras. We are suffering technical problems. We departed the hotel and went directly to the<br />

Sony shop where the technicians were very, very helpful and suggested they would assist in any possible Way.<br />

Financial remuneration is involved.<br />

I had also fears and nagging doubts about the Mayor, Mr. Dimitriades, as to whether he will reneg on our<br />

invitation. We met Mustafa, the TRNC guide, again at the checkpoint at 9.30, 15 minutes late by virtue of the<br />

batteries. We drove to Muraga which was on the road to Famagusta, and it was here that we wandered about,<br />

towards the village of ‘Trachoni’ and from there we went straight up to Digeni and then Kyados.<br />

And then from there we went back down to the town of Agostina and from Agostina to Famagusta. Again<br />

the road trip was reminiscent of Paris, Texas. Bone dry road, bouncing up and down with Mustafa in the back<br />

pontificating about the TRNC (Turkish republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>) and the political climate and the state of the<br />

country: ‘No, we are effectively not recognised by the rest of the world, but we are here.’ Sometimes he would<br />

turn to the camera and he would say: ‘we are here even though you do not see us.’ I liked his referrals and<br />

humour.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

I bought the book Karanlik, which contained the family photos and the gardener<br />

showed us one photograph of a tortured rotting body in the book and said almost<br />

matter of factly in a dead pan voice: ‘that is my wife’.<br />

“A politician is a man that has many<br />

masks. Each mask shows a different<br />

face. On the one hand there is the<br />

face which he wears when he visits his<br />

family, the other hand the face when<br />

he visits his constituency, then the face<br />

he shows when he deals with his peers,<br />

and beneath all these masks, there is the<br />

mask of expediency and of predatory<br />

ambition.”


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

As we pass along the Cypriot countryside,<br />

a gradual transition from one world to another<br />

occurs, from the spoilt wealth of the South to the<br />

economically deprived and embargoed North. Here<br />

is a dust bowl, of denuded trees, where everything<br />

is sadder or belittled. The car jolts as it passes<br />

over dry dead animals spread like pizza on the<br />

bitumen—road kill. A less wealthy Turkish culture<br />

has been transposed over the Greek. The past has<br />

been removed, to be replaced by a new present.<br />

I cannot speculate if it is justified or not. Soon we<br />

were passing emerald green and then fallow fields.<br />

After the sunshine and the rain, the grass has begun<br />

to sprout.<br />

We came to what looked like a park. There<br />

was a stone and cement monument with cracked<br />

plaster casts of people which had a semi-socialistic<br />

aesthetic. Beside the monument were two halfbuilt<br />

fountains, a few cypresses and a gardener who<br />

drove up in an old battered Mercedes from the other<br />

direction of the road. We parked, and as we got out,<br />

Mustafa indicated<br />

to us that this man,<br />

the gardener who<br />

was operating the<br />

sprinklers and<br />

just quietly being<br />

by himself, had<br />

lost his wife and<br />

all four children<br />

to the events of<br />

1974. We sat under<br />

the awnings to<br />

interviewed him. He<br />

I had also fears<br />

and nagging<br />

doubts about<br />

the Mayor, Mr.<br />

Dimitriades, as<br />

to whether he<br />

will reneg on our<br />

invitation.<br />

explained that he had now remarried with children<br />

from the second marriage. But it took him 15 years<br />

to be able to recover the loss, and the events which<br />

happened to him.<br />

From the Muratoga village we interviewed this<br />

man called Kunvil Meric, who had lost his four<br />

children and wife in one of the massacres of 1974.<br />

Mustafa was translating our questions and his<br />

answers and I was asking what happened.<br />

’What is his hope for the future?’<br />

There were images on the memorial stone and<br />

inscriptions explaining where 89 people who had<br />

died here at Muratoga, with their names, their<br />

ages of the people. It all could be found in the<br />

book Karanlik. A bee was silently making threedimensional<br />

flips and figures of eight beside the<br />

photos. I bought the book Karanlik, which contained<br />

the family photos and the gardener showed us one<br />

photograph of a tortured rotting body in the book<br />

and said almost matter of factly in a dead pan voice:<br />

‘that is my wife’.<br />

My god, my god, what can you do? What can you<br />

say? Nothing really, nothing at all.<br />

We then went to the site of this mass grave<br />

which was perhaps one hundred metres from the<br />

memorial, with a sign which said ‘massacre grave’.<br />

This is where the Greek Cypriots had buried all the<br />

people of that village who had been murdered by<br />

them. Mustafa explained: ‘The Greeks put them in<br />

this hole to hide them.’<br />

There was an eerie sadness to witnesses from<br />

these events. A stillness where time had stopped,<br />

where the moment was frozen and that man Kunvil<br />

Meric, again was frozen in the past. As he explained,<br />

he tended the garden in an attempt to heal, to<br />

absolve, to remember all that had been. He did<br />

not wish to be in this time, but to return to those<br />

events. When we are happiest and the happiness is<br />

taken away from us, then we no longer inhabit the<br />

body that we live in, but we chose instead to live in<br />

another time that has ceased to exist, except in our<br />

minds.<br />

The book was called Karanlik Dunyam. There<br />

was an eerieness about that afternoon as we drove<br />

off leaving the gardener and the bees and the<br />

monument with the dust streaming behind us.<br />

And again we felt the silence in a reserve of our<br />

own thoughts, memories, and experiences. But for<br />

Mustafa, it was a normal and customary procedure<br />

to show people—almost like a merry go round,<br />

the journalist, the<br />

specific places<br />

which were on the<br />

massacre merry-goround.<br />

From there we<br />

drove to Famagusta,<br />

the old port, which<br />

was enclosed by<br />

a very impressive<br />

and well preserved<br />

Venetian wall. We<br />

could see the victory monument, which is a huge<br />

black monstrosity depicting soldiers in battle.<br />

From Famagusta we were able to see St. Nicholas’s<br />

Cathedral which was now the Mustafa Pasha Mosque<br />

which really was the finest example to my mind of<br />

Cypriot gothic architecture. Rather incongruously<br />

a small minaret was perched on top of one of its<br />

ruined towers.<br />

There was also a chateau called Othello’s Castle<br />

which was part of the city wall embattlements and<br />

had been built by the Lusignans in the thirteenth<br />

century. According to the legend it was here that<br />

Christopher Moro the Venetian governor of <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

from 1506-1508 killed his wife Desdemona in a fit of<br />

jealous rage. It is said that Shakespeare confusing<br />

Moro’s surname with his race (Moor), based his<br />

Othello tragedy on this tower. There are good views<br />

from the ramparts and it is open daily. We stopped


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Antoine said: ‘Dominic we are two poets, but she is a pragmatist’.<br />

When we are happiest and the happiness is taken away from us, then we no longer inhabit the body that we<br />

live in, but we chose instead to live in another time that has ceased to exist, except in our minds.<br />

There was an eerie sadness to<br />

witnesses from these events.<br />

A stillness where time had<br />

stopped, where the moment<br />

was frozen and that man<br />

Kunvil Meric, again was frozen<br />

in the past.<br />

There were images on the memorial stone and<br />

inscriptions explaining where 89 people who had died<br />

here at Muratoga, with their names, their ages of the<br />

people. It all could be found in the book Karanlik.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...a vision of Mustafa’s fiancee,<br />

mother, father and granddaughter,<br />

who was absolutely beautiful in<br />

their small but frugal living room.<br />

The five-year-old granddaughter<br />

has the second lot of teeth<br />

coming through. And she would<br />

absentmindedly put her finger on<br />

one of the loose milk teeth and<br />

move it backwards and forwards.<br />

in Famagusta and were introduced to Mustafa’s fiancee’s family which we taped onto one of the DAT tapes, the<br />

interviews of what happened and what occurred when they became refugees twice, first in 1963 and then the<br />

second time in 1974.<br />

In my minds eye I can see the family as vividly as I saw them then—a vision of Mustafa’s fiancee, mother,<br />

father and granddaughter, who was absolutely beautiful in their small but frugal living room. The five-year-old<br />

granddaughter has the second lot of teeth coming through. And she would absentmindedly put her finger on<br />

one of the loose milk teeth and move it backwards and forwards. Almost hypnotically pressing on the nerves.<br />

She came into the house with tears in her eyes, maybe she had failed an exam—but there was an irony that<br />

she had failed an exam while they were talking about years of irresolute pain from homelessness and losing<br />

everything.<br />

From there we went to the university to interviews Mustafa’s fiancee’s brother who worked there. There<br />

was a ‘no comment’ on the <strong>Cyprus</strong> situation.<br />

On the way home we stopped in the Turkish side of Nicosia to visit Ivan Levant—the father of my friend<br />

Alexander Braterski’s wife.<br />

Sasha Alexander was a graduate of Moscow State University and a close friend, someone I love dearly. His<br />

wife’s father was the editor of Europa, a socialist newspaper in the TRNC. Apparently it is the second largest<br />

selling newspaper in Turkish Nicosia. We had sweet black Turkish coffee with him and I spoke in Russian about<br />

the current issues of Moscow, the Soviet Union, his daughter, of Sasha, the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question, his philosophies<br />

and views of what could be. He was embrasive and positive.<br />

After returning to the Greek side across the Ledra Palace Checkpoint by 5 o’clock that evening we went to<br />

the bar ‘Romulus’ in the city with Antoine in south Nicosia. There Rebecca and I met the bar lady Tina. Antoine<br />

said: ‘Dominic we are two poets, but she is a pragmatist’. From there we went to ‘Bar One’ where there were<br />

dancing women. It appeared to be a bordello, in fact. There was one dancer called Marie who I though was<br />

either inept, or curiously disembodied, not there; disenfranchised by marijuana, who knows? And the girls<br />

would stand on stools and people would surreptitiously place money in their vests. It was quite upsetting<br />

because the bar was congested with old, old men. As Antoine said: ‘I go there because the people are so sad<br />

and I feel happy because I am better off then them.’ I did not really think that that was the appropriate position<br />

to be in, but sadness has its place.<br />

Saturday, 4th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

So this Saturday morning we promenaded along the Nicosia shops in the south where smooth, smart dudes<br />

hang out here displaying their cod piece wares and smoked Sobrani cigarettes and played abstractly with their<br />

gold chains. Here are striking images of Greek café society. We went to the Sony shop and left the batteries<br />

with the technicians. Antoine came for dinner at our apartment where Rebecca cooked beautiful pasta. In the<br />

evening we wandered through Maraco Street. There were people in the cafés with Benetton signs.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The aim and purpose of the erection in the DMZ<br />

would be both a humanitarian gesture by the<br />

two parties of Nicosia to the world, that war and<br />

violence cannot solve our problems. The problems<br />

of humanity, whatever the political situation, can<br />

or cannot be obtained accordingly.<br />

Sunday, 5th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I wrote a quick letter to the mayor of Greek<br />

Nicosia, Lelos Dimitriades. It is my an assessment<br />

of all possible options which are available to us. It<br />

went like this:<br />

‘Mr. Lelos Dimitriades, the Mayor of Nicosia,<br />

6th of the 11th, 00, I have enclosed a booklet with<br />

outlines the history of past projects, a mission<br />

statement and current projects including <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

Number (1) the cost of the project will not be<br />

carried by either side, two colour billboards and<br />

air freight from Australia on Emirates $5,200<br />

already paid for, billboard size 14 feet by 42 feet.<br />

Other individual costs could be a public address<br />

system and invitations and could be carried by<br />

the artist. It is possible the PA system could be<br />

provided by the United Nations. The site of the<br />

outdoor ceremony is still being negotiated. Erection<br />

of the billboard would be for one to two weeks on<br />

the city walls/moat diagonally opposite the Ledra<br />

Palace Hotel next to the soccer field. Small cleaning<br />

of the area could be required. The buffer zone<br />

Green line is being controlled by the UN United<br />

Nations military and it would give them something<br />

to do. The aim and purpose of the erection in the<br />

DMZ would be both a humanitarian gesture by the<br />

two parties of Nicosia to the world, that war and<br />

violence cannot solve our problems. The problems<br />

of humanity, whatever the political situation, can<br />

or cannot be obtained accordingly. By bringing<br />

Mr. Dimitriades and Mr. Semi Bora into the DMZ<br />

will create a very powerful media event globally<br />

whose message is clear yet careful. I believe it is<br />

a symbolic act which can provide a positive step<br />

to the process of peace. The road to peace is made<br />

by taking many small steps on many fronts. This<br />

exhibition will be one of them. All the points must<br />

be agreed upon and are subject to change and<br />

discussion.<br />

‘Parties involved. Mr. Semi Bora from the<br />

Turkish area of Nicosia has been informed of<br />

the project and I and my assistant Rebecca have<br />

visited his office last week. We are due to meet<br />

tomorrow to inform him of what has occurred.<br />

Madeline Garlick, Assistant Director Civil Affairs<br />

of the political area of the UN who is currently in<br />

Geneva has supported the project and has referred<br />

me to the senior advisor Vlodak Cibor. The<br />

position taken by the UN is that if both parties are<br />

sympathetic to the project, the UN will provide and<br />

facilitate the event. Both parties interested seem<br />

cautious but open to proceed at this stage.’<br />

So it is 12 am, and I have spent the day dictating<br />

my journal, dribbling into the tape recorder just<br />

like I am now. 3 pm Rebecca interviewed one of the<br />

refugees whose name was Sotris Hadji Kyron who<br />

owned the ‘Orama Kiosk’, which means vision, on<br />

Kennedy Avenue in Nicosia. We then interviewed<br />

Antoine Salome in a beautiful area of garden and<br />

mosque about his thoughts of the situation in the<br />

Middle-East, the three faces of politicians again,<br />

how the middle east can be solved, it’s parallels with<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>, etc. The name of the hotel is Philoxenia.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

It is taxi hell. He insults the driver: ’Quelle horrible, you awful voleur!!’, because he presumes that the driver is<br />

taking us on the long way<br />

By bringing Mr. Dimitriades and Mr.<br />

Semi Bora into the DMZ will create a<br />

very powerful media event globally<br />

whose message is clear yet careful. I<br />

believe it is a symbolic act which can<br />

provide a positive step to the process<br />

of peace.<br />

We are due to meet tomorrow to inform him of<br />

what has occurred. Madeline Garlick, Assistant<br />

Director Civil Affairs of the political area of the<br />

UN who is currently in Geneva has supported the<br />

project and has referred me to the senior advisor<br />

Vlodak Cibor.<br />

On the way home Antoine loses it with the taxi driver. It is taxi hell. He insults the driver:<br />

’Quelle horrible, you awful voleur!!’, because he presumes that the driver is taking us on the long way<br />

around the labyrinth of Noicosia’s backstreets. Antoine starts abusing the driver, shouting that there will not<br />

be any further payment. The poor driver is gentle, timid and passively states, ‘I’ll just take whatever money you<br />

want to give me’. He was capable of rolling with the situation.<br />

Monday 6th, November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The moon is beginning to slip out of its fullness and evolve into a crescent. I can hear the roar of<br />

accelerating Ducatti motorcycles in the near distance. The night air is cool. It’s cool, and there is a lightness<br />

about everything. I am thinking about this apartment block and the people who live here and what they do. It is<br />

a bizarre hotel, like Fawlty Towers because everything breaks down. There is the refrigerator that is disguised<br />

as a microwave oven when we put in the chop souy or the take-away Chinese; the marble steps that are always<br />

broken, or the workmen that are always repairing things that never seem to operate, or the lights that don’t<br />

turn on. There is the toilet bowl that refuses to flush and the lift that freezes half-way. And all the furniture, is<br />

frozen in the 60s or 70s décor at the point when the Green line was created in 1974. A division just fell on this<br />

town, like a blanket or shutter. And at a particular points in this city it became one ghosted moment.<br />

The beginning of the day was begun by visiting Amelia Parfides who is the personal secretary of the Mayor,<br />

Lelos Dimitriades. Dimitriades is interested in our submission but requires further texts. He wants to know


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

And all the furniture, is frozen in the 60s or 70s décor at the point when the<br />

Green line was created in 1974. A division just fell on this town, like a blanket or<br />

shutter. And at a particular points in this city it became one ghosted moment.<br />

how much, who is involved in the costings, what<br />

is involved, who will be sponsoring the project—a<br />

whole series of questions have been forwarded. This<br />

is good news. Dimitriades also asked whether Semi<br />

Bora, the other mayor is interested. Dimitriades<br />

wants a description of the project, and he wants it<br />

now, so we race off into the darkened streets on a<br />

sunny day in search of the unsearchable.<br />

We need a word processor, and we need a<br />

printer. We start compiling the letter. We do that in<br />

a betting shop, but it does not have a printer, so I go<br />

off in search of a couple of discs. The betting shop<br />

is run by a couple of peroxided-hair Russian women<br />

who a very disgruntled and affronted frown, but are<br />

soft and genial inside. Finally I discovered a small<br />

newsagent and for two pounds I was able to locate<br />

the disks. From there we went to the Sony shop<br />

to see if the batteries had to be bought. I acquired<br />

a battery charger, which although it was an extra<br />

$200 basically has saved us any further problems.<br />

And at 2.30 we luckily delivered the letter. We<br />

could not print so we gave it to Amelia and she<br />

has printed it from the disks. We were no longer<br />

impotent.<br />

We then went to the ‘Paris Crepery’ to eat where<br />

there was this huge semi-sculptural image of the<br />

Eiffel Tower but decided instead to go to dinner<br />

at this Indian restaurant and then home. It was a<br />

beautiful night with Mademoiselle Rebecca. She told<br />

me about her first loves as we witnessed a poor man<br />

having an altercation at the bar. Costs and mistaken<br />

judgements about who paid what, where, and how.<br />

Tuesday, 7th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Ok, It is Tuesday the 7th of November. Another<br />

day another list, another ‘to-do’ list unfulfilled.<br />

The day began by travelling by taxi to the border<br />

from the Excelsior. Our money is running out, the<br />

politicians are saying that they do not know, because<br />

everybody is running scared.<br />

Today was the day that I suggested to Rebecca<br />

that she keep the camera on all the time. So right<br />

at the beginning of the checkpoint into the TRNC<br />

in the taxi with Mustafa. Mustafa was saying: ‘I<br />

am here, I exist, but you may not see me’. It was<br />

because of the fact that TRNC is not recognised as<br />

a country by any other country except for I think<br />

Turkey and Bangladesh in the United Nations.<br />

I meet with Semi Bora the mayor and tell him<br />

that the other mayor is interested. We say to him<br />

that positive steps have been initiated. This meeting<br />

with Semi Bora also appears quite positive.<br />

We talk with the Mayor Mr Semi Bora, about the<br />

notion of inschala, and about philosophy. The Mayor<br />

renders his philosophy as ‘service in relationship to<br />

his job’ which gives him great satisfaction. We then<br />

discuss religion, the state and how they should not<br />

be mixed. Then I discuss the nature of God, religion,<br />

and tell the story about God and the devil.<br />

The building he is housed in is nondescript,<br />

even small, and could be confused for the next<br />

door neighbour’s outdoor villa, or could be my


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Our money is running out,<br />

the politicians are saying that<br />

they do not know, because<br />

everybody is running scared.<br />

... in the taxi with Mustafa. Mustafa was saying:<br />

‘I am here, I exist, but you may not see me’.<br />

It was because of the fact that TRNC is not<br />

recognised as a country by any other country<br />

except for I think Turkey and Bagladesh....<br />

grandmother’s garden glass house. It could be someone’s holiday house, with its fading stucco. There is strange<br />

ivy hanging on the exterior wall of the mayory which is painted a salmon yellow. A rather pretty secretary who<br />

is always smiling beatifically at everybody leads us inside. The Mayor continues to talk about his philosophies—<br />

providing people with services gives them something. When you give something to them it makes people happy<br />

and they will appreciate it in time. The meeting seemed to be positive though Rebecca is insistent that I did<br />

not give the Mayor the option to say anything because I had done all the talking. From my perspective he did<br />

not seem to want to say anything. He did not want to say that he was not interested in the Initiative. It seems<br />

that he wants to wait for Mayor Dimitriades. He does not wish to pre-empt the situation. He has not said ‘No’.<br />

Rebecca had said that if he was not interested he would have said no.<br />

Then we make our taxi ride through the streets of TRNC. It was stated by our friend Mustafa that the<br />

mayor was a lecturer in business. We then go to meet the Undersecretary to the Deputy Prime Minister, Bullant<br />

Kanol, but he was not there. Mustafa talks about the 15th of November celebrations, then gives an explanation<br />

analysing the meeting with the Mayor, to Rebecca. Just as I explain that ‘no one is going to say no’, then one of<br />

Mustafa’s entourage quips rather aptly, ‘No one is going to say yes, as well’.<br />

We take the taxi at great cost through to the hills to see the Castle of St. Helarian which looks on towards<br />

Mersin. There are shots from up there, and as we’re driving up Mustafa says: ‘Drop the camera.’ And then we<br />

come through this massive group of paratroopers, and anti-personnel carriers. All the soldiers had blue caps<br />

and Mustafa very proudly says: ‘These are our commandos.’ But I thought it was very strange that commandos<br />

should have blue hats similar to the UN opposed to other colours. But anyhow it’s not my business to<br />

conjecture on such things.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

It seems that he wants to wait for Mayor Dimitriades. He does not<br />

wish to pre-empt the situation. He has not said ‘No’. Rebecca had<br />

said that if he was not interested he would have said no.<br />

Just as I explain that ‘no one<br />

is going to say no’, then one<br />

of Mustafa’s entourage quips<br />

rather aptly, ‘No one is going<br />

to say yes, as well’.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...that the parties share a common desire to bring about, through negotiations in<br />

which each represents its side and no one else, as the political equal of the other...<br />

The Secretary General stresses equal status of parties in <strong>Cyprus</strong> proximity talks. Following is the text of the<br />

statement of the Secretary General Kofi Annan read today to the participants in the <strong>Cyprus</strong> proximity talks:<br />

’The Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot parties have been participating, since December<br />

1999, in proximity talks to prepare the ground for meaningful negotiations leading to a<br />

comprehensive settlement. I believe the time has now come to move ahead. In the course<br />

of these talks I have ascertained that the parties share a common desire to bring about,<br />

through negotiations in which each represents its side and no one else, as the political equal<br />

of the other, a comprehensive settlement enshrining a new partnership in which to build a<br />

better future in peace, security and prosperity on a united island. In this spirit and with the<br />

purpose of expediting negotiations in good faith and without preconditions on all issues before<br />

them, I have concluded that the equal status of the parties must and should be recognised<br />

explicitly in the comprehensive settlement, which will embody the results of the detailed<br />

negotiations required to translate this concept into clear and practical provisions.’


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Two hours later we<br />

have returned to the<br />

city to see Bullant<br />

Kanol. He has a<br />

faceless office, in<br />

a faceless building<br />

but he is actually<br />

very, very sweet<br />

and says: ‘You<br />

Dominic, must be<br />

a very courageous<br />

and brave man to<br />

do what you are<br />

doing.’<br />

Anyhow there it was, the statement, and then we were climbing the hill to look at the most beautiful view<br />

from this fairy tale embattlements, crumbling masonry, green hills, strange misty scenery It is a beautiful, Castle<br />

St. Helarian with this view on high.<br />

We then drive to ‘the tree of idleness’ and I discussed the project in relationship to Catholic<br />

Telecommunications. Mustafa is defending the TRNC: ‘both of us, Turks and Greeks, have suffered during<br />

the war’. Then we interview the owner of ‘the tree of idleness’ who is a refugee, and then we interviewed<br />

another man whose son had died, and he speaks again about the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question. All the men are sitting down.<br />

The whole problem of 1974…it seems to go on and on! The Greek treatment. A gentleman talks about what<br />

happened to him and his treatment by the Greeks as he was in prison.<br />

In the corner there is this beautiful old London red telephone booth and I kept thinking of Dr. Who and the<br />

Tardis and wondering if Dr. Who was going to leap out at any moment or if we were going to step back into the<br />

Tardis and return back to 1974.<br />

We then go to Girne which is a small fishing village close to Kyrenia and wander through the fishing boats.<br />

English tourists, old and gentrified are just sitting back oblivious of any political repercussions, mere tourists<br />

idly frolicking, people kicking their legs, swimming, waiters like sharks patrolling backwards and forwards.<br />

Scuba diving <strong>Cyprus</strong> tourists, dogs on the boat, the reflection, the boats in the water. Dominic and Mustafa just<br />

hanging out, discussing the Berlin Wall, and always discussing the <strong>Cyprus</strong> question.<br />

Two hours later we have returned to the city to see Bullant Kanol. He has a faceless office, in a faceless<br />

building but he is actually very, very sweet and says: ‘You Dominic, must be a very courageous and brave man to<br />

do what you are doing.’ Rebecca films us shaking hands and we decide to make another meeting for the 17th of<br />

this month. He gives us presents before we leave, on the way back across the checkpoint.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

In the corner there is this beautiful old London<br />

red telephone booth and I kept thinking of<br />

Dr. Who and the Tardis and wondering if Dr.<br />

Who was going to leap out at any moment or<br />

if we were going to step back into the Tardis<br />

and return back to 1974.<br />

Wednesday, 8th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Then that afternoon we trooped to an<br />

amphitheatre in South Nicosia for an interview<br />

with Dominic.<br />

There is a business man opposite, who every<br />

evening works late. Rebecca and I conjecture<br />

whether he’s Mafia or whether this is the time that<br />

Americans are working so he is operating the fax<br />

machine.<br />

What happens on a Wednesday that does not<br />

happen on a Monday? Another day. My list says a<br />

million things—the list is executed, but the deeds<br />

are never done in the way I aspire to have them<br />

done. It’s just a list isn’t it?—not to be fulfilled.<br />

I needed to ring Natasha at seven. I must<br />

complete the tape journal as well. I need to contact<br />

the mayor Lelos Dimitriades or Amelia Parfides and<br />

I have to ring Sarah Russell’s spokesperson for the<br />

UN, who was in the oldest used airport, as regards<br />

the discs. So the majority of those deeds were<br />

fulfilled. And of course I am emailing Natasha and<br />

Samantha.<br />

Then that afternoon we trooped to an<br />

amphitheatre in South Nicosia for an interview<br />

with Dominic. It was the classic Grecian outdoor<br />

amphitheatre, which was close to the centre of<br />

the city of Leoforos Akropoleos. It was called the<br />

Macario Athletic Centre. I was in a white suit,<br />

holding forth on the ideas of the current situation<br />

and the two mayors’ responses while brass bells<br />

rang. While reciting this into the microphone, the<br />

moon is orange resembling a semi-sphere, close<br />

to the horizon, just spindling through. I am gazing<br />

across at all the houses and flats here. Occasionally<br />

a light will appear and like a Jacques Tati movie<br />

figures shuffle across window frames en route to<br />

fry a chop or make a bed. People, not trapped,<br />

but exercising the routes of their daily lives. From<br />

where I am perched on my balcony at the Excelsior<br />

you can hear a motorcycle in the distance. I can<br />

see a Chinese woman at the stove bending over a<br />

wok wearing a white T-shirt and a man strolling,<br />

whistling. There is a business man opposite, who<br />

every evening works late. Rebecca and I conjecture


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

whether he’s Mafia or whether this is the time that<br />

Americans are working so he is operating the fax<br />

machine. He gesticulates and is always bent over<br />

the computer. From where we are maybe it’s not the<br />

computer, maybe the computer is three feet in front<br />

of him. It is difficult<br />

to say because of the<br />

reduced perspective.<br />

He is not obese, but<br />

overweight with a<br />

blue cotton shirt. His<br />

apartment or office<br />

is half a kilometre,<br />

a quarter of a<br />

kilometre’s distance<br />

from our balcony.<br />

At the same height<br />

there is a bookshelf.<br />

He is on the one, two, three, fourth floor apartment.<br />

It’s an opulent office. Occasionally he’s gone on the<br />

telephone. Like Rear Window with James Stewart,<br />

the Alfred Hitchcock film the witness is able to step<br />

into, but not exactly know what each person’s lives<br />

is about.<br />

Thursday, 9th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I telephone Emirates airfreight with the<br />

consignment number for the billboard package. I<br />

also tried to ring Anastasious, the Friends of The<br />

Earth person and Antonios. Also I must contact<br />

Paul Holleman in relation to doing the invitations.<br />

I attempt to locate find Bullant Kanol the Under<br />

Secretary in TRNC but I cannot, the telephones<br />

here do not allow me to phone to North <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

We begin the day by having a meeting with<br />

the Secretary General of the Municipality of South<br />

Nicosia, his name is Andreas Andriades, in an<br />

attempt to meet the mayor Lelos Dimitriades, but<br />

he is yet to appear. While waiting outside the office<br />

suddenly a somewhat stooped, bald headed and<br />

bespectacled bureaucrat invites us to enter in a<br />

sing-song voice. It is Andreas.<br />

Then we catch a taxi to the travel airline<br />

Emirates where I present I show my passport. The<br />

customs building is near the Famagusta hotel. The<br />

building is Heliopolis street, number 17 near left<br />

area square. There is an Australian couple sitting<br />

waiting, maybe for tickets. You can hear them by<br />

their discordant strident accent. One of the parents<br />

is originally Greek or Greek Cypriot. Tanned and<br />

comfortable, with little Nike shoes and carry-ons<br />

with ticks on the backs of them.<br />

While walking to the perimeter of the old<br />

city, we seize a taxi. The driver is called Michael<br />

sporting faded tattoos on his upper arms. With<br />

Michael we drive to the customs house which is<br />

near the old disused airport in the buffer zone. As<br />

he drive he explains his life story: After a tour of<br />

duty with the French Foreign Legion In 1964, he<br />

discusses his Cockney wife and the joys of marriage,<br />

how even though he has grown fat and she has<br />

become mature he sees her differently. ‘When I<br />

look at her now I still see an eighteen-year-old year<br />

old nymphet. And that’s a beautiful thing.’ He is<br />

wearing a T-shirt which he pulls open to indicate<br />

a stencilled photograph of himself as a determined<br />

teenager. It almost appears like a gangster with a<br />

well quaffed moustache. ‘Deep down that’s what I<br />

still am.’<br />

On our arrival at the Customs house, Mr. Harris,<br />

the customs admin and logistics officer, who seems<br />

very un-English, tells us that we have to return<br />

tomorrow because, even though the documents<br />

have arrived, the parcel of the two billboards is<br />

yet to. So it is close, not yet here. It has landed on<br />

Cypriot soil, but that’s about it.<br />

We drive back, with Michael who takes us back<br />

to the city. We have lunch in one of the tourist<br />

restaurants close to the wall, and then we take a<br />

long, long, long wander through the dappled streets<br />

filming close to the Green line.<br />

We are<br />

He is wearing a T-shirt<br />

which he pulls open<br />

to indicate a stencilled<br />

photograph of himself as<br />

a determined teenager.<br />

It almost appears like<br />

a gangster with a well<br />

quaffed moustache.<br />

introduced to<br />

an old man in a<br />

cosmetic shop<br />

with putrified face<br />

and grey stubble<br />

as if he has been<br />

mummified. In the<br />

window are rows<br />

of glass jars of<br />

revivifying placenta<br />

cream which are<br />

supposed to relieve<br />

customers of wrinkles. Her appears as a flesh-like<br />

prune in the centre of 1950s apothecary vases.<br />

As I have repeated before, the closer we<br />

approach the Green line, the more the people<br />

become frozen at that particular period, in 1974<br />

when the island was divided. He is a really beautiful<br />

man who discusses his friendship with the Turks.<br />

‘Turks can be like a dog, your best friend.’ I did not<br />

think that was quite appropriate analogy, but he<br />

meant it in the nicest of way.<br />

We wander inside his shop. He likes the English<br />

and the Italians and afterwards we steer ourselves<br />

out of the shop to wander deeper towards the<br />

centre and closer to the Green line. All people<br />

close to the Green line seem trapped here, while<br />

nothing has changed. Time has frozen. We walk<br />

past men playing backgammon, past dilapidated,


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

As I have repeated before, the closer we approach the<br />

Green line, the more the people become frozen at that<br />

particular period, in 1974 when the island was divided.<br />

After a tour of duty with the French Foreign Legion In 1964, he discusses<br />

his Cockney wife and the joys of marriage, how even though he has<br />

grown fat and she has become mature he sees her differently.<br />

We are introduced to an<br />

old man in a cosmetic shop<br />

with putrified face and grey<br />

stubble as if he has been<br />

mummified.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The trip begins with Antoine explaining that he does not wish to be with the Sri Lankans in the service taxi.<br />

carcinogenic, cancerous masonry, barbed wire, and<br />

soldiers who continuously say: ‘don’t photograph<br />

here, photograph there’ As we continue we see<br />

an old man making straw chairs. That night I<br />

succumbed to the joys of the journal and I then fell<br />

quietly, genteelly heavily into the…embrace of sleep.<br />

Friday, 10th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Joyfully driving out to the customs, we used<br />

Michael again to pick up the billboards. One man<br />

there appears paradoxically brutish, but benign and<br />

benevolent—a gentle giant who has been moving<br />

boxes all of his life. But there is an acceptance<br />

and surrender which gives him his kindness and<br />

helpfulness. Generally customs bureaucrats resent<br />

the work they have to endure, although some<br />

minority ones find acceptance and flow with it. He<br />

was one such person. At the end of our meeting<br />

when I shook his hand and then he then turned<br />

happily to Rebecca and tried to shake Rebecca’s but<br />

she turned and walked away. It was just a sad event<br />

that happened.<br />

We had to open the package of the billboards for<br />

Mr. Harris and to explain with one of the booklets,<br />

“<strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> <strong>2000</strong>” showing him what it was.<br />

With the appropriate documents, and a statement I<br />

explained that it was my personal property.<br />

After convincing Mr. Harris of its integrity and<br />

as my personal possession we returned in the hot<br />

car through the sultry countryside. Afterwards we<br />

went out for lunch with Antoine who took u to<br />

a restaurant off Macarius Avenue. And I had sun<br />

stroke because I had been out that morning to pick<br />

up one of the telecards/phonecard and walked in the<br />

sun with insufficient water.<br />

Saturday, 11 November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

At three minutes to 11 as the evening quietens<br />

two bare bulbs flicker in a room without flowers.<br />

There are white walls that are scuffed surrounding<br />

us and a decision has been made to travel with<br />

Antoine Salamis, the Lebanese journalist to<br />

Limassol, the resort town on the <strong>Cyprus</strong> coast for a<br />

weekend holiday. The next day we depart with bags<br />

packed.<br />

Antoine Salamis is his name—journalist, poet,<br />

satirical correspondent is his occupation. He has<br />

written in numerous journals for Figaro, Paris<br />

journals, while he has also been confidante of<br />

Sophia Loren and Alain Delon. An itinerant traveller<br />

in his mid 60s, he is gaunt, handsome, stooped,<br />

with a cataract in one eye. I would describe<br />

him as debonair and often sports a cravat. He<br />

is simultaneously a Frenchman displaced in the<br />

Middle-East and a Middle Easterner displaced in<br />

France. He seems happier caught between countries


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

There are no young here. There<br />

are just middle-aged German<br />

tourists, who are fat.<br />

She is a beautiful human being<br />

despite her deluded belief that<br />

eating junk food and a triple<br />

chin makes her ugly.<br />

in this no man’s land. Someone who has been living in hotels for the last 25 years as a foreign correspondent<br />

and, like an addict, he cannot escape his errant bachelor life, whose stain of sadness never seems to evaporate.<br />

The trip begins with Antoine explaining that he does not wish to be with the Sri Lankans in the service taxi.<br />

Rebecca says to me: ‘Dominic, I really don’t want to sit in the back with this man.’<br />

We order another taxi and drive to Limassol, arriving at a derelict hotel called Geo/Tanya—a run down<br />

English bed and breakfast, circa 60s, on the outskirts of Limassol. Faux leather furnishings, crisp walls in flash


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Antoine sat sulking and irritated, tapping his<br />

little finger wanting to take us to a martini-clad<br />

lounge-lizard emporium where a balding Elton<br />

John look-alike on a white ebony piano would be<br />

languidly playing at two o’clock in the morning.<br />

They had a strange love-hate relationship which always<br />

corresponded with physical assaults on each other.<br />

Something like the ‘Treble Clef’. I kept on feeling<br />

that Aristotle Onassis or David Niven would be<br />

exhumed from their graves.<br />

white stucco, with a cracked kidney shaped pool with twenty-three fat bodies lying in the noon day sun baking<br />

themselves crisp like someone’s birthday cake where all the candles had fallen over.<br />

We go upstairs to unpack and decide to wander down from Geo/Tanya to the Appalonia Hotel. On the other<br />

side of the street it looks like the whole strip is vulgar, criss-crossed by street lights and lamps. Fat German<br />

tourists are waddling hither and there are people lackadaisically wandering and gawking. I hear the festooning<br />

of English accents. It does not even seem like it is <strong>Cyprus</strong>. It could be Costa Brava or it could be Brighton. A<br />

collision of English signs saying: Chips, Bed and Breakfast, & Cold Beer in Pounds, Shillings and Pence.<br />

It is sleepy hollow until the evening while I sit with Antoine and Rebecca goes swimming. He is a sweet<br />

man who is somehow lost in his own world. I do love our friendship which was begun with a melange of Arabic,<br />

English and smatterings of French.<br />

The Geo/Tanya hotel used to be called the Flora/Mara Hotel, just after the Taj Mahal restaurant up past<br />

Palonia. Sitting beside the lapping water of the swimming pool there is apart of me that refuses to relax but<br />

instead desires to work. To succumb to creative exploration, rather than solar crisping.<br />

There are no young here. There are just middle-aged German tourists, who are fat. But they are in their<br />

50s or 60s or even 40s, and even though they may have gone to seed, at least they wear their nakedness with<br />

candour. While squinting my eyes beside the water, all I can see a dancing grid of scintillating golden light that<br />

shoots out towards me. It was beautiful. Rebecca is a porpoise the way that she dives, careering into the sea,<br />

splashing. She is a beautiful human being despite her deluded belief that eating junk food and a triple chin<br />

makes her ugly. Earlier that evening I had met Davnes who was a beautiful, beautiful old man in his 60s and<br />

Antonios from the leftist organisation, Friends of The Earth. They gave me the telephone number of Maria<br />

Hajipavlo. She was Professor of <strong>Peace</strong> and Reconciliation Studies at <strong>Cyprus</strong> University. From this trip, from the<br />

perspective of the project, that piece of information was jettisoned into my lap.<br />

That evening we jump in a taxi to go off to the Old Harbour Ladas where there is the Ladas Fish Tavern.<br />

Here I pick up the bill because Antoine has been continually generous towards us, shouting us many a meal.<br />

This was certainly a meal to be remembered because it ended as $260 Australian for three people. We had


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The old guard was returning to sleep, to collect their Swiss visas, as Firouz would say.<br />

I sat with him. It’s a kind of<br />

boredom, it’s like he would<br />

just go from hotel to hotel. I<br />

call it the Salamis Syndrome.<br />

It’s just this person who’s<br />

locked into hotels, and can<br />

only address people as if they<br />

are waiters.<br />

We went to the Four Seasons; we went to<br />

the Meridian, we went to about 20 places.<br />

He took me on a kind of a guided tour of the<br />

hotels of Limassol and was able to explain to<br />

me which was the very best, which was the<br />

very worst, which was the cheapest, which<br />

was the most expensive, which had silver<br />

service, which had white tablecloths, which<br />

would be good and which he never stayed in.<br />

salad, dips, fresh calamari, octopus, prawns and<br />

red mullet. Plus a bottle of wine, a couple of<br />

cappuccinos and an espresso and that was it! And a<br />

groper, and that was not the waiter. So after reeling<br />

from the shock we veered off into the night like an<br />

odyssey of misjudged and misguided events through<br />

club after club.<br />

By this stage Rebecca and Antoine were locking<br />

horns. They had a strange love-hate relationship<br />

which always corresponded with physical assaults<br />

on each other. Gentle smacks. Whether it was him<br />

trying to make a pass at her, or her trying to deflect<br />

his passes, it was a curious combination. And then<br />

came a blurred tour through clubs, and bars, all of<br />

which were unsatisfactory.<br />

We finally found a club, although the music<br />

was loud, where there were young people. Antoine<br />

sat sulking and irritated, tapping his little finger<br />

wanting to take us to a martini-clad lounge-lizard<br />

emporium where a balding Elton John look-alike<br />

on a white ebony piano would be languidly playing<br />

at two o’clock in the morning. Something like the<br />

‘Treble Clef’. I kept on feeling that Aristotle Onassis<br />

or David Niven would be exhumed from their<br />

graves. Sorry, Antoine wrong era…rewind twentyfive<br />

years…this was not the French Riviera where<br />

Carey Grant would grace through the Monte Carlo<br />

Casino in a tuxedo in To Catch a Thief…here was<br />

overweight euro-trash AWOL from the Betty Ford<br />

clinic…Binge eating at Maccas! But no one was to<br />

be laid to rest or exhumed, and we finally walked<br />

up to the square at the top of Limassol. It was full<br />

of strip bars which is where he wanted to take us.<br />

Again we desisted, declined, and Rebecca drove<br />

home alone, and then I went with his Excellency (as<br />

we so called him), to what used to be the Churchill<br />

Hotel.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

He showed me where he stayed for three months; he showed<br />

me where he stayed for six months; he showed me where he<br />

stayed for two years.<br />

He had been there five years before. He kept on talking about David Hurst, the journalist. And of course the<br />

hotel had been renovated. It was now the Holiday Inn, and he enquired after the barman from that period. The<br />

bar had been cut back, the old barman had died, and the man who ran the cabaret had died. Everyone around<br />

him was passing away. The old guard was returning to sleep, to collect their Swiss visas, as Firouz would say.<br />

When we got home there were splashes in the pool that night, and people were diving into the swimming<br />

pool. I slept through it all.<br />

Sunday, 12th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

A strange day in Limassol again. By that stage, unbeknownst to me, Rebecca was beginning to get her<br />

period. Over the next three days she stepped into a distant fleshed-out, stressed-out ‘I’ll-kill-you-so-much-asyou-look-at-me’<br />

state of mind. But nonetheless Rebecca your beauty shone through, I can assure you.<br />

So it was a strange day of writing the journal, evading Antoine, engrossing myself in the environment of<br />

Limassol. I went off to a creperie to write and Antoine sauntered up the street and caught me,<br />

‘I need you just for one minute’.<br />

He was so alone and the only way he would connect with people was with his tentacles extended out:<br />

‘And we’ll just go up to the street here’, and we went to the Lada Hotel, and I sat with him. It’s a kind of<br />

boredom, it’s like he would just go from hotel to hotel. I call it the Salamis Syndrome. It’s just this person who’s<br />

locked into hotels, and can only address people as if they are waiters.<br />

From there we took a taxi up to another one. He wanted to find a friend who was not there. It was closed.<br />

We went to the Four Seasons; we went to the Meridian, we went to about 20 places. He took me on a kind of<br />

a guided tour of the hotels of Limassol and was able to explain to me which was the very best, which was the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

very worst, which was the cheapest, which was the<br />

most expensive, which had silver service, which had<br />

white tablecloths, which would be good and which<br />

he never stayed in.<br />

He showed me where he stayed for three<br />

months; he showed me where he stayed for six<br />

months; he showed me where he stayed for two<br />

years. It was a trip down the nostalgia of his past.<br />

So they are all expatriates here. It is the expatriate<br />

express here with Burger Kings. Everybody is<br />

either portly or antiquated. They are either British,<br />

German or maybe French if you’re lucky. So after<br />

our tours of hotels in search of the unsearchable,<br />

we are actually trying to find some kind of money<br />

exchange for him. He wanted to leave for Amman<br />

to interview Barach, who is Prime Minister of Israel.<br />

He had refused to interview Arafat because he said,<br />

they hated each other so much.<br />

Outside the Four Seasons this woman in a<br />

bus smiles, waves at me, beautiful girl in her mid<br />

20s— It is strange how one look and one smile,<br />

can lift your heart or lift your day. At last after a<br />

suitable length of time I managed to make my, how<br />

do you say, exit and with that I disappear off and go<br />

to a coffee shop where I sit and have a half-eaten<br />

crepe. Watch the men on their Harley-Davidsons<br />

cruise at 97 miles an hour, up and down the street<br />

like testosteroned<br />

chickens.<br />

I do not think<br />

that much was<br />

done, it was a<br />

slightly constipated,<br />

distracted and<br />

disrupted day. We<br />

finally leave at five<br />

to return to Nicosia<br />

or so and Antoine<br />

gives Rebecca a<br />

white plastic horse<br />

as a gift. Strange because in that moment, that time<br />

which we had spent together, I truly believed we<br />

touched him and he touched us. It was something<br />

that leapt across cultures, age brackets and just<br />

seem to impress us. On this trip, rather than<br />

encountering the young, we have encountered old<br />

people. Whereas when I was with Firouz it was<br />

always the young people that I would seek out and<br />

find.<br />

So we pay for our accommodation at the hotel<br />

that night. A shuttle taxi is waiting. I sit beside two<br />

Filipina women. The night surrounds us as the flash<br />

and flare of traffic careers past us. Nicosia emerges<br />

slowly, blearily after 45 minutes. Two English girls<br />

get in with dreadlock hair complaining about the<br />

size of their mobile phones. They are talking about<br />

their boyfriends and staying overnight from college<br />

at stranger’s houses. They were wearing khakis<br />

and they had that spoilt bratiness that comes from<br />

not really understanding the ways of the world, but<br />

understanding it enough. A chic bravado.<br />

Monday, 13th, November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Madeline Garlick is supposed to return this<br />

Monday from Switzerland. We passed a slow<br />

day where we did filming on the phone. There<br />

were pickups of recordings on the DAT to the<br />

Australian embassy. We are just attempting to get<br />

information. I was also talking to the assistant Mayor<br />

of Famagusta, leaving a message. We arranged<br />

some meetings for the UN with Madeleine, while<br />

waiting their response. I have also been speaking<br />

to Mr. Marios, and talking about the peace project<br />

initiative. The funniest part of the day were frappes<br />

which arrived at the hotel suite.<br />

Tuesday, 14th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The list is gargantuan, but scrawled out as usual.<br />

There is a series of conditions that we have to<br />

accommodate. But first I ring the Public Information<br />

officer there.<br />

Sarah Russell: Hello.<br />

Dominic:: Hello Sarah Russell it’s Dominic Ryan<br />

speaking.<br />

Sarah Russell: Yes, hi.<br />

Dominic:: I remember you said that you<br />

had some things on disc on the Green line. I was<br />

wondering whether we could access that.<br />

Sarah Russell: What you want some?<br />

Dominic: Photographs.<br />

Sarah Russell: Right well the best thing is<br />

if you come up and talk to my colleague Miriam<br />

Peryclayos, she’s got everything on CD.<br />

Dominic: Ok, Miriam Peryclayos.<br />

Sarah Russell: Yep.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Upon arriving in Larnacca we film a church and a man sitting in chair at car park. A whole retinue of images<br />

cascade in front of our eyes: decrepit facades, old tired men with dilapidated trolleys pushing them as they<br />

clack, clack down the street; pimply boys lingering outside old neon signs, while old senile Greek men sit<br />

clacking beads outside of shop windows.<br />

Dominic: And you are at the airport?<br />

Sarah Russell: That’s right yeah.<br />

Dominic: So what should we do? We’ve got our<br />

guest passes.<br />

Sarah Russell: Right. Well if you come up. Have<br />

you got a hire car?<br />

Dominic: No we can just come by taxi.<br />

Sarah Russell: Right, well if you come by taxi.<br />

If you were able to come. Miriam, oh good, I’ve<br />

got someone who wants to come and view some of<br />

Paul’s pictures. What time would suit you? Right if<br />

you wanted to come today that would be fine.<br />

Dominic: Today would be better than tomorrow<br />

correct?<br />

Sarah Russell: Either is fine.<br />

Dominic: Let’s just say that we came in the<br />

afternoon, what time would be appropriate?<br />

Sarah Russell: If you came at 2.<br />

Dominic: 2 o’clock.<br />

Sarah Russell: And then you come through.<br />

Have you been to the headquarters yet?<br />

Dominic: No the closest I’ve got is to the<br />

customs place and I saw the airport on the hill.<br />

Sarah Russell: Right, OK well tell the taxi that<br />

you want to come up at the old airport. You come up<br />

Foxtrot gate where you will have to show your pass,<br />

but say you’re coming to the public information<br />

office to see me. And then the taxi follows the sign<br />

posts to the headquarters.<br />

Dominic: OK past Foxtrot gate, public<br />

information office to see Sarah Russell and the taxi<br />

follows the signs. OK.<br />

Sarah Russell: And you turn left, there’s a sign<br />

post that goes left after the military police unit. You<br />

then have to go straight over a round about and<br />

then you come up to a T-junction at the top and<br />

you turn right at the T-junction. Then you’ll see<br />

some flags on your left and our office is immediately<br />

opposite the flags.<br />

Dominic: Is the PI?<br />

Sarah Russell: It’s signposted, there’s a sign<br />

outside.<br />

Dominic: With the PIO.<br />

We are now scheduled to go to the public<br />

information office in the old disused airport in<br />

the Green line which is now used by the United<br />

Nations. Sarah Russell, who is the spokesperson,<br />

has very generously allowed us to digitally copy a<br />

series of photographs, pictures of the Argentinean,<br />

Australian, Hungarian or British soldiers in the<br />

Green line. The photos have an ordinary quality to<br />

them, but by downloading them we may collect up<br />

information that may be of use to us. Like collecting


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

colours for a palate or finding torn magazine scraps,<br />

we can then amalgamate into a large fabricated<br />

collage.<br />

At the Public information Office at the UN,<br />

a stressed female keeps coming in every three<br />

minutes saying: ‘Have you finished; have you<br />

finished; are you alright?’<br />

I just did not want to be there. From one<br />

perspective since this is a UN area, there is a<br />

lightness about the area and it is a higher frequency<br />

energy than the war area. Nonetheless I felt<br />

irritated. It was difficult to put my finger on why.<br />

After downloading all the images we emailed them<br />

to ourselves at Rebecca’s address.<br />

Returning to the Excelsior apartments Marius,<br />

the concierge,<br />

telephoned for a<br />

serviced taxi to take<br />

us to Larnacca. Upon<br />

arriving in Larnacca<br />

we film a church and<br />

a man sitting in chair<br />

at car park. A whole<br />

retinue of images<br />

cascade in front of<br />

our eyes: decrepit<br />

facades, old tired<br />

men with dilapidated<br />

Why there has<br />

been so many<br />

problems is<br />

because there<br />

is so much at<br />

stake.<br />

trolleys pushing them as they clack, clack down<br />

the street; pimply boys lingering outside old neon<br />

signs, while old senile Greek men sit clacking beads<br />

outside of shop windows. Finally in a restaurant<br />

on the sea we are introduced to a genteel English<br />

couple, Jack and Marie. Jack Harding was his name,<br />

80 years of age who had lived on the island since<br />

the 1930s. Silver-haired Jack possessed a tranquil<br />

“I don’t give a fuck” fragility which 80-year-olds<br />

have. Because his peers had never really listened<br />

to him there was the desire to tell us his life story.<br />

In his shy retirement there was a bruised ego. Jack<br />

and Martie were dating as a couple. Two 80 year<br />

olds who dated. It was so cool. They met every six<br />

months. A fairly long-winded courtship but when<br />

you are eighty years of age…time has a different<br />

dynamic and who cares really…it seemed a perfect<br />

relationship… They were from different parts of the<br />

island and were going to go over to meet each other<br />

next St. Valentines Day. They had both lost their<br />

wives and husbands over the last twelve months.<br />

They discussed the history of their families. Jack<br />

whose wife had died, had lived with her for 70<br />

years. Maria discussed travelling to Africa, Turkey,<br />

Kuwait, and the antiques that she collected. They<br />

returned to the island to find, after the invasion, all<br />

the things which they had left were gone. Then Jack<br />

talked about his memoirs and invited us to Paphos.<br />

Meanwhile we stared out on to the ocean.<br />

Wednesday, 15th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Today I must travel to see Vlodak Cibor, the<br />

UN senior advisor of the United Nations FICYP<br />

for delivery of documents. There is also a festival<br />

in the north, Sarah was calling Mustafa to tell<br />

him we could not come, and Mayor Dimitriades is<br />

supposed to return soon and therefore we must<br />

schedule a brief meeting with him. I must also ring<br />

the secretary of Kate Klerrides (she is the Prime<br />

Minister’s daughter) today.<br />

Where does it begin? At 9 o’clock we had<br />

a meeting with Vlodak Cibor from the United<br />

Nation’s Civil Affairs Bureau. We walk along<br />

labyrinthine corridors, through wire meshed doors<br />

painted white in the UN enclave at the disused<br />

aerodrome. Madeline Garlick was responsible for<br />

our introduction.<br />

Finally we have the meeting with this Vlodak<br />

Cibor and Madeline Garlick who is his assistant<br />

at Civil Affairs. He seems a very appropriate and<br />

auspicious person. In his mid 40s Vlodak has a<br />

smooth, how do you say, American accent, even<br />

urbane. There were two military commanders who<br />

sat in on the meeting. One woman, the military<br />

commander of<br />

Sector Two, which<br />

They were very<br />

supportive, open<br />

and prepared to<br />

permit the event to<br />

occur, providing<br />

the two sides<br />

agree.<br />

was the Ledra<br />

Palace zone, and<br />

one other person<br />

who was the<br />

commander general<br />

of that particular<br />

area, both of whose<br />

names I did not<br />

catch. One of them<br />

spoke about having<br />

a bi-communal<br />

soccer match in that area, which I thought was<br />

pretty crazy and cool at the same time. Maybe that<br />

is one way of settling their differences. Ironically as<br />

I read into the Dictaphone I am watching a soccer<br />

match between I think Liverpool and <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

The meeting with Madeleine and Vlodak went<br />

according to plan. They were very supportive, open<br />

and prepared to permit the event to occur, providing<br />

the two sides agree. I presented to them all the<br />

necessary bound documents. The cost of binding at<br />

Alpha Graphics is excessive but necessary. They said<br />

that if the two mayors, or the two representatives<br />

of the two sides, Mr. Semi Bora and Mr. Lelos<br />

Demitriades were prepared to follow suit and come<br />

into the checkpoint for the ceremony then they<br />

would support the project wholeheartedly.<br />

My opinion is that if Semi Bora and Lelos<br />

Demitriades are to come into the no man‘s land,


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...we should respect there are both Greek Cypriots and<br />

Turkish Cypriots on this island and that we are both<br />

Cypriots.<br />

That night we had an appointment for Lelos<br />

Dimitriades, the Mayor of Nicosia at 6.30.<br />

Someone else with a tattoo of a butterfly is<br />

dancing in the streets, and then a fight erupts<br />

with the Che Guevara-type men. I witness the taut<br />

backs of police. The sound of the whistle...<br />

and this is something that I was unaware of until<br />

just recently, that even if those people will say that<br />

they will come, the ramifications of their entry<br />

into that zone are immense and far reaching—that<br />

it is possible that they will be seen as a symbol<br />

of reconciliation. As a result everybody is going<br />

to want a piece of the action. Everybody is going<br />

to want a piece of the pie. Why there has been<br />

so many problems is because there is so much at<br />

stake.<br />

At the PIO I can’t even stand in the building, I<br />

have to walk out because the neurosis. Miriam is<br />

there and the women are talking about the most<br />

ridiculous breakages and pointing blunt fingers in<br />

bespeckled blame. After having been at the PIO at<br />

the UN we ring from the Green line Michael, the<br />

taxi driver.<br />

Michael, our loyal taxi driver soon pulls up to<br />

collect us. We then walk to the demonstration that<br />

is happening at the Ledra Place gates. Because it is<br />

the 15th of the month this is a ‘celebration’ of the<br />

founding of the Turkish Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

There is a concert with loud speakers—a cacophany<br />

of gutteral voices, chaos of fluttering flags waving<br />

in the clear cloudless sky. There are singers, while<br />

the girls stand there, and the men holding are<br />

holding flags. There is one young 18-year-old man<br />

with a black mascarad moustache looking like a<br />

cross between Telly Sevalis, Rod Steiger and Marlon<br />

Brando. He begins by describing his fading tattoos,<br />

and then explains how he was in the catering<br />

industry.<br />

So after this demonstration at the Ledra<br />

Gateway, the remembrance of the Turkish invasion/<br />

intervention. The concert was held by the Greek<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> side of course. We interview some of the<br />

kids.<br />

One man says ‘we are here because the Turks<br />

took our houses, we will kill them all, because I am<br />

a Greek’.<br />

There’s a woman with a yellow flag, and the<br />

insignia of Che Guevara, torn but clear, is on the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

There’s a woman with a yellow flag, and the insignia<br />

of Che Guevara, torn but clear, is on the back of<br />

somebody’s bag.<br />

People chanting that they want to<br />

be returned to their homes. Denim<br />

jackets, women in pink, flashing<br />

something saying: ‘We shouldn’t say<br />

we are Turkish or Greeks, we are<br />

Cypriots’ and sticking a sticker on the<br />

camera and explaining.<br />

One man says ‘we are here because the Turks<br />

took our houses, we will kill them all, because I<br />

am a Greek’.<br />

We then walk to the demonstration that is happening<br />

at the Ledra Place gates. Because it is the 15th of the<br />

month this is a ‘celebration’ of the founding of the<br />

Turkish Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong>.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

He gives Rebecca some brandy and<br />

he says: ‘Yes, I will do everything that<br />

you require.’ He decides that he will<br />

support the project. We are absolutely<br />

relieved, beautific and happy.<br />

Dimitriades Lelos, who is waiting for us, is a man<br />

in his late 60s, 68 precisely. He says he has been<br />

the town mayor since he was 40. 2 years longer<br />

than Rebecca has been on this earth.<br />

He gives us a little ‘Nicosia <strong>2000</strong>’ medallion and says with a wink to<br />

Rebecca, ‘Of course the women get all the presents, not the men’.<br />

back of somebody’s bag. People chanting that they want to be returned to their homes. Denim jackets, women<br />

in pink, flashing something saying: ‘We shouldn’t say we are Turkish or Greeks, we are Cypriots’ and sticking a<br />

sticker on the camera and explaining. I ask her a few questions and she replies:<br />

’It’s been 15 years I think when the other side declared a Democratic Republic of Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong> and we<br />

just wanted to say that we’re not, we don’t agree with that and we want to fight so that <strong>Cyprus</strong> can be together<br />

united and that both Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots can live together. I don’t agree with those bringing<br />

Greek flags because we’re <strong>Cyprus</strong> and they don’t see that we’re <strong>Cyprus</strong>. They think we are Greeks and they are<br />

taking that into account. They’re taking the flag politically, I disagree with that. I think we should fight for the<br />

own good of <strong>Cyprus</strong> not the good of Greeks and we should respect there are both Greek Cypriots and Turkish<br />

Cypriots on this island and that we are both Cypriots. We shouldn’t say Turkish or Greek Cypriots and we can<br />

live together; it’s proven we can live together. We should seek a solution for us both.’<br />

Someone else with a tattoo of a butterfly is dancing in the streets, and then a fight erupts with the Che<br />

Guevara-type men. I witness the taut backs of police. The sound of the whistle, which I could hear suspiciously<br />

felt like a brain scrambler and then the demonstration ends, people disperse and walk away.<br />

Thursday, 16th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The itinerary for the day: 9.45am we check with Sarah Russell at the Ledra Palace roundabout, into the<br />

barracks, into the island briefing room. It was to be a two hour walking tour. I took a few notes. That night<br />

we had an appointment for Lelos Dimitriades, the Mayor of Nicosia at 6.30. We also had an appointment with<br />

Marios, our Concierge, who was also a refugee, but unfortunately because we had doubled up, I rang Marios<br />

and he cancelled his appointment. Lelos is not more important but more significant.<br />

That lazy, sun-filled afternoon we stumbled upon ‘Arte’ which is a privately funded music hall where the<br />

British Council and Trinity College of Music are giving violin lessons for students. Here we meet a woman called


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

So far to date Lelos Dimitriades, and the United Nations have accepted the<br />

project. Semi Bora is the last and most important piece of the puzzle. But<br />

Semi Bora is the wild card in the pack.<br />

I remember Michael the taxi driver saying, ‘Ah yes, Lelos, he<br />

is a franchise’. And we’re very happy that he had accepted.<br />

Patricia. Her full name is Patricia Davies. So we<br />

decided to return that night.<br />

We return home, shower and then reappear<br />

where Rebecca films. I race to the cyber cafe<br />

that has become our dilapidated office for grubby<br />

printouts. I am becoming more adept at using the<br />

software and Philip who is a South African Cypriot,<br />

assists in any problems that I have. There’s a boy<br />

called Georgios who’s playing the viola, was it or<br />

violin.<br />

The letter is put together adequately and we<br />

meet at 6.25pm on the front steps of the Mayory.<br />

Dimitriades Lelos, who is waiting for us, is a<br />

man in his late 60s, 68 precisely. He says he has<br />

been the town mayor since he was 40. 2 years<br />

longer than Rebecca has been on this earth. He<br />

appears charming, erudite, ingratiating and slightly<br />

endearing. He gives us a little ‘Nicosia <strong>2000</strong>’<br />

medallion and says with a wink to Rebecca, ‘Of<br />

course the women get all the presents, not the<br />

men’. And we sit and talk with him.<br />

He gives Rebecca some brandy and he says: ‘Yes,<br />

I will do everything that you require.’ He decides<br />

that he will support the project. We are absolutely<br />

relieved, beautific and happy. However he says<br />

there are two conditions. One is that we visit the<br />

Municipality Museum that he has put together. The<br />

second thing is that we visit the Famagusta gate and<br />

the moving pictures and the power house.<br />

He then talks about his relationship with<br />

Lyuzhkov, the mayor of Moscow. Nicosia and<br />

Moscow are sister cities. On the way to see<br />

Lyuzhkov in Moscow in 1998, he asked the taxi<br />

driver, why Lyuzhkov is such a good mayor and<br />

loved by his people. The taxi driver explains: ‘After<br />

the Mafia gives Lyuzhkov all the money in bribes, he<br />

gives it to the people.’<br />

Demitriades talks about the only time he has<br />

rest is when he is able to sit with his grandchildren,<br />

as opposed to his children. The grandchildren are<br />

the ones he has the most time for. He decides to<br />

give us a lift home en route to his office, in his black<br />

chauffeured limousine. We arrive at his second<br />

office where he works as a lawyer and ascend to<br />

the top floor in a private soundless lift. We stand on<br />

the balcony with the mayor and view the sparkling<br />

lights of the city. He says to us, ‘Do you believe in<br />

the supernatural? Because really I like you both, I<br />

don’t know why. There is something about you that


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We have met with Mr. Dimitriades on Thursday<br />

the 16th of November and he has expressed<br />

both careful interest and the desire to attend the<br />

ceremony.<br />

We have met both the military commander<br />

of sector two which controls the Ledra Palace<br />

and the area surrounding it and the senior<br />

advisor of civil affairs Mr. Vlodak Cibor. Both<br />

have expressed support for the project and<br />

will proceed with all details addressed below,<br />

provided the two parties attend.<br />

induces the sense of joy. Induces a sense that I feel<br />

that you and Rebecca are good people and I just<br />

want to be with you’.<br />

Rebecca, as is her wont, sits near the balcony.<br />

And both of us, Lelos and I get vertigo. Rebecca<br />

and Lelos are sharing cigarettes as we descend<br />

the stairs. I am waiting outside as he hits the lift,<br />

pressing all these special buttons for the codes to<br />

lock the lift and his offices. I gaze at the polished<br />

brass plaques on the doors. All the family are<br />

lawyers and share the same office block (it is like a<br />

geological chart), and then there are all the trading<br />

companies. I remember Michael the taxi driver<br />

saying, ‘Ah yes, Lelos, he is a franchise’. And we’re<br />

very happy that he had accepted.<br />

So far to date Lelos Dimitriades, and the United<br />

Nations have accepted the project. Semi Bora is the<br />

last and most important piece of the puzzle. But<br />

Semi Bora is the wild card in the pack. Part of the<br />

letter that I sent Mayor Semi Bora, from Turkish<br />

Nicosia goes like this:<br />

‘Dear Sir,<br />

I am writing in regards to the peace project<br />

<strong>2000</strong>. You will find that I’ve enclosed the <strong>Peace</strong><br />

<strong>Project</strong> <strong>2000</strong> booklet, which outlines the history<br />

of past peace projects achieved, current projects<br />

and the mission statement, including <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

Also included are two colour copies of each<br />

billboard.<br />

The purpose of the project is to erect two<br />

billboards in the DMZ as a humanitarian<br />

message to the world sent by the two parties<br />

of Nicosia. Through this symbol the people<br />

attending the event in Nicosia are expressing<br />

the understanding that war and violence cannot<br />

solve the problems of humanity. The idea is that<br />

Mr. Semi Bora and Mr. Lelos Dimitriades would<br />

meet in the Green line under the billboards as<br />

a symbol of the values inherent signified on the<br />

billboards.<br />

My assistant Ms. Rebecca Prole and I have<br />

attended three meetings with Mr. Semi Bora<br />

who we believe has expressed cautious but<br />

careful interest in the project. The peace project


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

has been submitted to Mr. Bullant Kanol, the<br />

Undersecretary of the Deputy Prime Minister. He<br />

has been aware of the project for a year and has<br />

corresponded with me on two occasions. We have<br />

met and two of our meetings have been recorded<br />

last week. The minutes were sent to the Deputy<br />

Prime Minister Mr. Akungi and support of the<br />

project and wishes for it to continue.<br />

We have also attended a meeting with Mr.<br />

Andreatous,<br />

the Secretary<br />

General of the<br />

South Nicosia<br />

municipality. He<br />

has spoken for<br />

Mr. Dimitriades<br />

who is also<br />

interested in<br />

participating in<br />

the project. We<br />

have met with<br />

Mr. Dimitriades<br />

on Thursday the 16th of November and he<br />

has expressed both careful interest and the<br />

desire to attend the ceremony. We have met<br />

both the military commander of sector two<br />

which controls the Ledra Palace and the area<br />

surrounding it and the senior advisor of civil<br />

affairs Mr. Vlodak Cibor. Both have expressed<br />

support for the project and will proceed with all<br />

details addressed below, provided the two parties<br />

attend.<br />

‘Following is an outline of the information for the<br />

peace project ceremony.<br />

‘A. Funds.<br />

The cost of the project is privately funded<br />

and through sponsorship, therefore neither side<br />

is responsible for any costs. The following has<br />

been financed in order to create this message of<br />

peace. Two colour billboards, return flights from<br />

Australia, accommodation expenses totalling<br />

$6,200, there may be incidental costs such as<br />

a public address system, billboards. I am the<br />

artist of these two billboards and the size of each<br />

billboard is 14 by 42 feet long. The total length<br />

of wall space required will be 82 feet. Items to<br />

be imported into the Green line, two billboard<br />

prints, one public address system, chairs, one<br />

podium, one small wooden dias. The suggested<br />

site of the erection of these two billboards for<br />

two weeks is on the city wall of the buffer zone,<br />

Green line in Nicosia diagonally opposite Ledra<br />

Palace Hotel, next to the old disused soccer field.<br />

It would be more presentable if some cleaning,<br />

ie: mowing of the lawns of this area is carried<br />

out. The wall is sufficient height and would be<br />

perfect for the display of these billboards.’<br />

‘B.Date and time of the event.<br />

‘Between the days of the 26th of November to<br />

the 7th of December in the afternoon for a period<br />

of two hours, at the discretion of the parties<br />

involved, the number of people who will attend<br />

shall be confirmed and agreed by both sides.<br />

Maximum of 100 people would be suitable. The<br />

billboard would be taken down one or two days<br />

after the ceremony.<br />

I would like to invite<br />

both you and Mr. Semi<br />

Bora to the small peace<br />

ceremony which will be<br />

held towards the end<br />

of November, early<br />

December <strong>2000</strong>, located<br />

in the buffer zone Green<br />

line, adjacent to the Ledra<br />

Palace Hotel.<br />

The ceremony will<br />

be conducted in<br />

the area specified<br />

above, provided all<br />

security measures<br />

are fulfilled. For<br />

security purposes<br />

a small elect group<br />

of VIPs would<br />

be invited from<br />

either side. Press<br />

and foreign media<br />

would be allowed.<br />

I’ve enclosed copies<br />

of letters proposed to the two parties. I’ve invited<br />

Mr. Dimitriades and Mr. Semi Bora to attend the<br />

ceremony, because I believe it will create a very<br />

powerful and important message to the people in<br />

Nicosia and the people of the world through the<br />

media globally. I believe it is a symbolic act and<br />

a positive steps towards the process of peace.<br />

The road to peace is made by taking many steps<br />

in different ways. This ceremony is but one of<br />

those. I understand that the points within this<br />

letter must be agreed upon by all parties, three<br />

parties involved, and are subject to change through<br />

further discussions, thank you.<br />

Sincerely, Dominic Ryan, <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />

Director <strong>2000</strong>’.<br />

Then I’m including a letter I wrote to Lelos and<br />

we are following that up with points of discussion.<br />

Mr. Lelos Dimitriades, the mayor of Nicosia,<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>. 14th of November:<br />

‘Dear Mr. Dimitriades, I felt that it is important<br />

to provide in writing documents of both our<br />

meetings, the nature of our project. The previous<br />

peace project booklet provides further information<br />

pertaining to the project. As you are aware I would<br />

like to invite both you and Mr. Semi Bora to the<br />

small peace ceremony which will be held towards<br />

the end of November, early December <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

located in the buffer zone Green line, adjacent to<br />

the Ledra Palace Hotel. I have met with Mr. Semi<br />

Bora and he has expressed interest in attending.<br />

I shall look forward to your comments and your<br />

resolve to be a part of this very important and<br />

significant event.<br />

Kind regards, Dominic Ryan,<br />

Director <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong>.’


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

There seem to be odd circumstances afoot.<br />

‘This event can be a serious affirmation<br />

that dialogue can only continue with the<br />

understanding that war and violence will not solve<br />

the problems inherent within any international,<br />

national or individual situation.’<br />

OK this is a separate page which is points of<br />

discussions.<br />

His interest is in the sharing of the message of<br />

human rights and that there is the respect for<br />

all forms of life and the care of all peoples,<br />

regardless of race, nation, creed or sex.<br />

‘Certain points have been raised in relation<br />

to gentle criticisms to the peace project. I will<br />

address them in point form. The points of<br />

criticism are: the second billboard ‘We Have All<br />

Suffered Enough’ may be deemed to be offensive<br />

to Muslim and Islam sensibilities because<br />

there is some small Christian iconography.<br />

The billboard was exhibited three times in<br />

Muslim areas, once to ethnic Albanians,<br />

second to Bosnians and thirdly to Palestinians<br />

and the Gaza Strip. The Palestinian people<br />

are predominantly fundamentalists. This did<br />

not present as a problem to the Palestinian<br />

authority. Any reference to newspaper articles<br />

can be found in my archives in Australia. This<br />

could take one week.


M I N U T E S T O WA R :The Last Divided City<br />

First there’s the weather talk, then there’s the<br />

drought talk, then there’s the water system talk,<br />

then there’s the update on the meeting.<br />

We have set the date for 27th of November and if not possible, that can be changed. Semi thinks, holding his<br />

left hand to his chin and then a shadow of doubt crosses his face:<br />

‘Yes, your idea is good, but the thing is the outcome. The last round of talks in Geneva, what was seen from<br />

the outside was not what was happening on the inside. And we have to be very cautious. I do not know. I must<br />

give it much time to think. I do not think it’s the right time, it’ll only be when positivity on their side exists, but I<br />

don’t want to be pessimistic and turn it down.’<br />

The second billboard ‘<strong>Peace</strong> On Earth’ will be the focus for attention for the ceremony. Because the<br />

billboards are written in 30 languages, the message is granted a universal tone, therefore it is not<br />

only for a French, Tibetan, Christian or a Greek Cypriot audience. The message is for the world. That<br />

the event could be exploited for purposes of propaganda and national betterment, any event under<br />

circumstances of this nature can be misused. But when the representatives are asked to refrain from<br />

political speeches, there will be no issue or problem. The correct terminology and protocol as conducted<br />

in Geneva at the United Nations will be adhered to in reference to all parties. The speech by the director<br />

of the peace project is available for inspection.<br />

‘The artist Dominic Ryan as a director has neither political nor national interest in any country,<br />

state, province or area or zone. The artist is aware that both sides will reflect their own perspectives<br />

on the peace ceremony through their respective medias. The international media will present a very<br />

powerful image of two sides standing under the banners that war and violence cannot solve the<br />

problems of humanity. This image is what the people of the world will see. There will be the views<br />

of the smaller media on the island and there will be the international media with the images of<br />

reaffirmation.<br />

‘This event can be a serious affirmation that dialogue can only continue with the understanding that<br />

war and violence will not solve the problems inherent within any international, national or individual<br />

situation. My experience has shown that ironically it is mostly the military arms of countries which<br />

appreciate this truth the most. That event is premature because the event has a symbolic nature that<br />

sharing of a universal message can only act as a positive addition to the process of peace. If dialogue<br />

between the parties has been misunderstood or slow, in Geneva an affirmation of peaceful dialogue as<br />

a means of solving disputes will assist in the implementation of all levels of conduct. A reaffirmation<br />

that war and violence cannot solve the problems of humanity, can only act as a benefit for both parties.<br />

The audience through the media of the world can only affirm the seriousness of intent of both parties<br />

to solve a very difficult problem which has remained because of the scar of events and their aftermath.<br />

That the artist is mpt serving any interest or lobby group. The artist comes from Australia where he<br />

lives. He carries an Australian passport. His country is far from the turmoil of the rest of the world.<br />

His country offers residency to both Greek and Turkish Cypriots. As such he’s a neutral facilitator.<br />

He has no interest in the political agendas of any side. His interest is in the sharing of the message


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

of human rights and that there is the respect<br />

for all forms of life and the care of all peoples,<br />

regardless of race, nation, creed or sex. If<br />

required the artist will provide the declaration of<br />

rights, which he read to Mr. Semi Bora.’<br />

After the meeting with Lelos we returned home<br />

to number 11 Nickitis Avenue, from 25 March<br />

Street, where we decided to celebrate. We walked<br />

to an Indian restaurant where Rebecca and I had<br />

beautiful savoury Indian food. It is certainly a rather<br />

appropriate place to celebrate, but as it turned out,<br />

that celebration was most premature. There seem to<br />

be odd circumstances afoot.<br />

Friday, 17th, November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I’m going to send an email message to Madeline<br />

Garlick very early in the morning, effectively saying<br />

the project is on track and everything is going very<br />

well. Then we travel across the checkpoint at 10am<br />

and we meet with<br />

Mustafa Ereulgen,<br />

our guide from the<br />

TRNC. Rebecca has<br />

bought him some<br />

chocolate biscuits. Of<br />

course they are from<br />

the south. And then<br />

we drive straight to<br />

our meeting with<br />

Mr. Semi Bora. And<br />

it actually turns<br />

into quite a heavy<br />

‘But they’re<br />

tricking us from<br />

all corners.<br />

They show us<br />

up at every<br />

opportunity.’<br />

thing. First there’s the weather talk, then there’s<br />

the drought talk, then there’s the water system talk,<br />

then there’s the update on the meeting. We tell him<br />

that Lelos has said ‘yes’ as of yesterday and that the<br />

UN military have met and are supportive.<br />

We have set the date for 27th of November and<br />

if not possible, that can be changed. Semi thinks,<br />

holding his left hand to his chin and then a shadow<br />

of doubt crosses his face:<br />

‘Yes, your idea is good, but the thing is the<br />

outcome. The last round of talks in Geneva, what<br />

was seen from the outside was not what was<br />

happening on the inside. And we have to be very<br />

cautious. I do not know. I must give it much time to<br />

think. I do not think it’s the right time, it’ll only be<br />

when positivity on their side exists, but I don’t want<br />

to be pessimistic and turn it down.’<br />

And then it’s my turn. I try to convince him that<br />

it is a public relations exercise. ‘The outside world<br />

will see two people standing together as equals.<br />

A step for the peace media. It’s a very climactic<br />

moment and attention is very important. We feel<br />

that.’<br />

Bora fidgets with a plastic icon on his desk. He<br />

says:<br />

‘But they’re tricking us from all corners. They<br />

show us up at every opportunity.’<br />

Dom replies: ‘We and you can use this to<br />

recognise, utilise the forces of acknowledgement.’<br />

Then he looks into his Semi diary, blah, blah,<br />

blah, maybe, showing us his schedules and says:<br />

‘Maybe, I’m not going away between the 24th and<br />

the 28th.’ We talked about the 15th of November<br />

celebrations. We also arrange a meeting to see<br />

Bullant Kanol next week, to have lunch on the 23rd<br />

at 1pm. He wants to take us for lunch and then we<br />

leave saying: ‘Well maybe that is a possible option.’<br />

Then he offers us drinks.<br />

One day it is positive and then next it is not. It is<br />

a rollercoaster and I roll with it rather than bail out.<br />

Understanding the process, this is the way it goes. It<br />

is something I can adjust to, and not fear when they<br />

say ‘no’, because it is the process. It is all part of the<br />

plan. And the plan is to step inside the centre; step<br />

inside the cyclone<br />

of fear while having<br />

I try to convince him<br />

that it is a public<br />

relations exercise.<br />

‘The outside world<br />

will see two people<br />

standing together as<br />

equals. A step for the<br />

peace media....We<br />

feel that.’<br />

the faith that it will<br />

happen. We will<br />

plant the seed of<br />

peace in the centre<br />

of a zone of war.<br />

Then I show<br />

Semi Bora some of<br />

the posters. The<br />

drinks are served. I<br />

say: ‘Your mind has<br />

a thousand different<br />

boxes.’ Semi says: ‘Exactly.’ I talk about my family,<br />

the governor general and Turkey.<br />

After having been to see Mayor Semi Bora we<br />

stop en route for a meeting with the journalist,<br />

Miss Asic, who is an editor from the North Kypros<br />

newspaper. I explain the project. She enquires why<br />

is it that it is mayors and not two presidents? ‘What<br />

are the billboards like?’ She writes down the names<br />

of the billboards. She is officious and interested.<br />

We view flag on the hillside, the one with ghosts,<br />

through the barb wire. We then drive to Tashkent,<br />

to see the old lady at Tashkent, Falim Sultan, who<br />

we had interviewed before. On the way we can see<br />

the flags on the hill near Tashkent village, and then<br />

we have the meeting with the old lady. We stop and<br />

talk and she gives us a pomegranate to eat while<br />

asking us questions whether she would be on TV in<br />

Australia. We say goodbye to her and the mountain<br />

with flags, as the car hurtles past. There is the<br />

Tashkent sign and that’s it.<br />

During our farcical trip to Limassol in search of<br />

a mummified Aristotle Onassis I had been given the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“How can I feel that I belong to only one side of this<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>? How can I identify with one half of what is<br />

actually a whole?”<br />

Andreos Pouyourous has been the mayor of Famagusta or the ‘shadow mayor’ since it has been occupied by<br />

TRNC or Turkish troops since 1974.<br />

contact number of Maria Hajipavlo who is a poet,<br />

and Professor of <strong>Peace</strong> and Reconciliation Studies at<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> University. I left a message on her cell phone.<br />

“Good morning, kalimera, Professor<br />

Hajipavlo, my name is Dominic Ryan. Mr. Davne<br />

Spanigides suggested that I telephone you. Now<br />

I’m at the Excelsior apartments at 317400 is the<br />

telephone number, room 601. I am interested in<br />

doing a peace project here and I have contacted<br />

both the mayors Mr. Dimitriades and Mr.<br />

Semi Bora who are very keen to participate in<br />

something inside the Green line opposite Ledra<br />

Palace. We’re looking at some time towards the<br />

end of this month. And Davne said that you had<br />

much experience in this area of bi-communal<br />

activities and would be an interesting person to<br />

speak to and it would be a pleasure to meet you.<br />

So I look forward to speaking to you and I may<br />

try and ring you later on this afternoon. Take<br />

care, bye.”<br />

She returned the call and that evening I meet<br />

with Maria Hajipavlo, the academic. Maria and I just<br />

go up into the mountains to a place called Skala, on<br />

a rocky enclave on the perimeter of Nicosia. It is a<br />

beautiful evening as she drives in her car to pick up<br />

a woman called Tashe, also involved in bi-communal<br />

peace issues. We sit at the restaurant while Maria<br />

and Tashe discuss the art on the walls.<br />

The restaurant named Scala is perched on<br />

a craggy sandstone cliff where caves with glass<br />

window bays have been dug out to accommodate<br />

the restaurant. Here is also an amphitheatre that<br />

overlooks the city and the Karpasian Mountains.<br />

Each of us spent the evening discussing our aims are<br />

in life. Maria tells me about her life as a PIO person.<br />

The dilemmas she experienced of both crossing<br />

over to the other side, and being a party to both.<br />

Tashe reminisces about her child in Ankara; how the<br />

secret service expelled her from Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong>;<br />

how she was arrested for 19 hours for harbouring a<br />

conscientious objector in the north. She came to the<br />

south and wrote a very famous pop song which asks<br />

the question:


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“My name is Andreos Pouyouros. I am the mayor of the town of Famagusta. I was first elected as the mayor<br />

in 1953 and I was continually re-elected and was mayor of this town until 1974, even after the Turkish<br />

invasion. And then in 1978 I was appointed by the Ministerial Council as Ambassador of <strong>Cyprus</strong> to the United<br />

Nations.”<br />

‘How can I feel that I belong to only one side of<br />

this <strong>Cyprus</strong>? How can I identify with one half of<br />

what is actually a whole?’<br />

She said that at the time when she was 18 it<br />

was a very famous song. She had strange eyes which<br />

seemed to pop out. Here in this world everybody<br />

seems to have a malignant cast in their eyes.<br />

Perhaps it has to do with an absence of thiamin<br />

in the water, or whether it is because of people’s<br />

inability to focus in their lives. Tashe talked about<br />

her poetry. She is a poet and now her poetry has<br />

become semi-erotic, semi-political. She has just<br />

recently had her dark hair cut, and is although a frail<br />

woman, is only in her mid 30s, maybe even as much<br />

as 40. Beautiful in a fragile manner.<br />

Saturday, 18th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Kyrenia- Famagusta and Nicosia<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I’m sitting in an Egyptian cafe in the Lamos<br />

square. I can hear the music, while people<br />

are walking around me sucking on cigarettes,<br />

gesticulating. The merchant with the fruit barrow<br />

is sitting waiting for someone to buy and orange<br />

while the UN personnel at the checkpoint are<br />

kicking stones. Today we had a meeting with the<br />

mayor of Famagusta at 1 o’clock near the border<br />

at the cultural centre in Derenyi which is on the<br />

buffer zone which overlooks Famagusta. It has been<br />

occupied or liberated by the Turks in 1974.<br />

He is the ‘ghost mayor’ or the ‘shadow mayor’<br />

of the city which from the South’s perspective has<br />

been occupied. So we took a service taxi to the old<br />

city of Larnacca and from Larnacca we caught a bus<br />

through the sovereign bases areas, occupied by the<br />

British military (the last enclave of land ceded to the<br />

British in the 70s in the south up to a small village,<br />

Derenyi with one traffic light). Andreos Pouyourous<br />

has been the mayor of Famagusta or the ‘shadow<br />

mayor’ since it has been occupied by TRNC or<br />

Turkish troops since 1974.<br />

Upon our arrival there we wander down to a<br />

very large strip of green pasture, denuded by sods<br />

of earth. We can see across to the Turkish TRNC<br />

outpost. Here between us from this observation<br />

deck in Derenyi which is the Cultural Centre and<br />

the outpost is the no man’s land. The Centre has<br />

a lift, beautiful binoculars while the children were<br />

running around with as if they are ochre eagles with<br />

deep encrusted plastic wings. We interviewed the<br />

mayor from the outlook observstion post of Cultural<br />

Centre and we could look out onto the areas which<br />

the Turkish has either intervened or occupied; from<br />

whatever perspective or side you were on.<br />

We interview Mayor Pouyourous at his desk. Half<br />

way through the first three minutes of the interview,<br />

his butler comes in and he gets disconsolate, even<br />

surprised and agitated and sends his butler out and<br />

says, ‘No I didn’t ask you to do that then, I said before’.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“Unfortunately 26 years has passed and we have not been allowed by the Turkish army to go back to our<br />

town, although we come here and see our town...”<br />

“We left with only our shirt and trousers, no<br />

belongings at all. We left with a hope that within<br />

two days or when the bombing had stopped, we<br />

would return to our homes and properties.”<br />

Rather than as a mayor, but<br />

as a human being. If you<br />

feel strong enough can you<br />

recount the tale of this drama.<br />

So he discussed the history of Famagusta,<br />

the 1974 intervention. The mayor is a man in his<br />

80s I think. He lives in Limassol and he has come<br />

especially for this interview. I think some Israeli<br />

journalists had just previously been interviewing<br />

him. He has been the Mayor uncontested for the<br />

last 26 years. It is something so surreal and strange<br />

about a mayor without a city, who has been the<br />

mayor for that time. Realistically I don’t think he<br />

will ever return to that city.<br />

There were flecks of dandruff on his suit which<br />

was shabby, and composed of a pale blue. He had<br />

been the UN representative for <strong>Cyprus</strong> for the<br />

municipalities here and he spoke with great passion<br />

and movement. His face was potato shaped, in a<br />

handsome manner—such a contradiction could<br />

actually occur.<br />

The interview with Andreos<br />

Pouyouros, Mayor in Absentia of<br />

Famagusta.<br />

Andreos: My name is Andreos Pouyouros. I am<br />

the mayor of the town of Famagusta. I was first<br />

elected as the mayor in 1953 and I was continually<br />

re-elected and was mayor of this town until 1974,<br />

even after the Turkish invasion. And then in 1978<br />

I was appointed by the Ministerial Council as<br />

Ambassador of <strong>Cyprus</strong> to the United Nations in<br />

Geneva and the United Nations in Vienna. And then<br />

I was Ambassador in Strasburg for another four<br />

years.<br />

And then I came back to <strong>Cyprus</strong> and when<br />

the first elections were held regarding the towns<br />

of <strong>Cyprus</strong> I was a candidate and I was re-elected<br />

by my core citizens. I was supported by all the<br />

parliamentary parties and I got 85% of the vote. And<br />

ever since then I have continued to be the mayor of<br />

this town.<br />

Before the Turkish invasion Famagusta was one<br />

of the most progressive towns of <strong>Cyprus</strong>. In 1974<br />

it was at it’s peak of development. We had the


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

orange plantations and we were exporting citrus<br />

fruit to all countries in the world. We were even<br />

exporting citrus fruit to New Zealand because at<br />

the time we had oranges, no other part of the world<br />

were there oranges, on the account of our climate<br />

and the sandy soil we have here in Famagusta. So<br />

a lot of wealth was being brought into Famagusta<br />

and Famagusta had the biggest port in <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

85% of the import/export trade of <strong>Cyprus</strong> was<br />

done through the port of Famagusta. And then we<br />

started just after the second world war the touristic<br />

development which began after I was elected the<br />

mayor of Famagusta.<br />

Our core citizens started building those beautiful<br />

and luxurious hotels that you can see along our<br />

sandy beach, which<br />

is one of the nicest<br />

sandy beaches in<br />

the world. And we<br />

had the 75% of the<br />

tourist dynamic of<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong> was here in<br />

Famagusta because<br />

of the climate,<br />

because of the very<br />

clean seas that we<br />

have, because of the<br />

fine, very fine sand<br />

that we have here and because of the Venetian walls<br />

and churches that we have; the Othello Tower and<br />

the ancient * which is the route of our civilisation<br />

and as you know during the time Famagusta was<br />

one of the most important Hellenistic kingdoms<br />

in the world. Well we were very happy until 1974<br />

when unfortunately Turkey invaded <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

It first invaded Kyrenia. That was the first phase<br />

of invasion, but even during the first phase of<br />

invasion we received intensive bombing of the town<br />

of Famagusta—a defenceless town. We had neither<br />

soldiers nor arms to defend it. And the aeroplanes<br />

were throwing their bombs indiscriminately and<br />

machine gunning the town. So the townsmen had<br />

to leave our town to return to neighbouring villages<br />

to save themselves. When the bombing stopped<br />

and there was a truce, we returned to our town.<br />

As you know that was the second artillery invasion.<br />

And then again the same thing happened. Again<br />

there was very indiscriminate bombing of our town,<br />

machine gunning of our people and when there<br />

was a stop then we tried to leave so we can save<br />

ourselves from the bombing. We left with only our<br />

shirt and trousers, no belongings at all. We left with<br />

a hope that within two days or when the bombing<br />

had stopped, we would return to our homes and<br />

properties.<br />

Unfortunately 26 years has passed and we have<br />

not been allowed by the Turkish army to go back to<br />

our town, although we come here and see our town.<br />

If we stretch our hand we can touch our homes,<br />

yet we are unable to go back. We are not allowed<br />

to even go and kindle a candle on the graves of our<br />

fathers and forefathers in Famagusta.<br />

Dominic: Can you actually tell me, Andreos,<br />

about the personal events which happened to you at<br />

the time of the invasion over the period of that ten<br />

days. Rather than as a mayor, but as a human being.<br />

If you feel strong enough can you recount the tale of<br />

this drama?<br />

Andreos: It’s one of the tragic moments of our<br />

lives, not only for myself and my families, but for the<br />

whole town and the whole people who have suffered<br />

as we suffered. You can imagine a good housekeeper<br />

with his wife and children staying in his house<br />

and working normally and doing what he can for<br />

himself and his family and his town. And then all of<br />

a sudden to have these aeroplanes flying even above<br />

our houses. They were flying so low and throwing<br />

their bombs while machine gunning our town.<br />

I was in my kitchen and I saw a big bullet that<br />

came on top of our heads and went through the<br />

wall of our kitchen. We were very happy not to have<br />

been killed, any<br />

one of us. And in<br />

this pandemonium<br />

you can understand<br />

how difficult it was<br />

that we cannot<br />

even find words<br />

to describe such<br />

barbarian acts<br />

against peaceful<br />

people, against<br />

peaceful men like<br />

ourselves. We got<br />

our car with no belongings and began taking the<br />

road outside our town and leaving our town and<br />

coming to a nearby village to save ourselves.<br />

We never thought that we would not return the<br />

next two or three days. But when we realised it was<br />

impossible for us to return, you can imagine this was<br />

the worst moments in our lives.<br />

Dominic: Yes, absolutely.<br />

Andreos: And I can say, many correspondents<br />

ask me how worse it is. I can only say that the worst<br />

thing in life is to die, so the one step before death is<br />

to become a refugee like we have become ourselves.<br />

That is the unfortunate situation which happened<br />

to us.<br />

Dominic: What are your feelings now after all<br />

these years? Do you still hold hope that you can<br />

return?


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“I was in my kitchen and I saw a big<br />

bullet that came on top of our heads<br />

and went through the wall of our<br />

kitchen.”<br />

“I can only say that the worst thing in<br />

life is to die, so the one step before<br />

death is to become a refugee like we<br />

have become ourselves.”<br />

“...then we ask ourselves, where is<br />

justice, where is truth, where are the<br />

human rights...”<br />

“We never thought that we would not return the next two or three days. But when we realised it was impossible<br />

for us to return, you can imagine this was the worst moments in our lives.”


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“So that means that when they intervened the first thing they<br />

should have done was to reinstate the constitutional order.”<br />

to isolate a place or a<br />

political entity, sometimes<br />

makes the entity stronger<br />

rather than weaker.<br />

Andreos: Well we never lost hope and we shall<br />

never lose hope to return because we cannot<br />

understand that being on the steps of the 21st<br />

century and after having two world wars and after<br />

having such havoc and destruction that happened<br />

in the past and after the formation of the United<br />

Nations and the charter of the United Nations and<br />

the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the<br />

statements of all the leaders of the world, that we<br />

shall not allow to be any other war again.<br />

We shall not allow people to be killed<br />

indiscriminately like it happened in the Second<br />

World War. And yet when we see these facts<br />

happening to ourselves then we ask ourselves,<br />

where is justice, where is truth, where are the<br />

human rights, where are our liberties and where are<br />

what we were taught to believe. I mean I studied<br />

in England and I was taught to believe the ideals of<br />

freedom and democracy and human rights. Well I<br />

am deprived of all of these. I have nothing of these<br />

and I am not allowed to exercise these.<br />

So in our memoranda which we sent to the<br />

various leaders of the world we ask them and we<br />

say you have a responsibility towards <strong>Cyprus</strong>. You<br />

have a responsibility because if you don’t exercise<br />

your duties as members of the United Nations and if<br />

you do not force Turkey to withdraw her troops and<br />

settlers from <strong>Cyprus</strong> so that <strong>Cyprus</strong> can be reunited<br />

and that people can go back to their homes,<br />

whether they’re Greek Cypriots or Turkish Cypriots<br />

or whatever denomination. When this is not done<br />

and when the human rights are not respected then<br />

I believe that terror and injustice will reign in the<br />

world and not peace and order.<br />

Dominic: Tell me I know that economic sanctions<br />

were one of the means that the UN has attempted<br />

to levy against northern <strong>Cyprus</strong>, but why were not<br />

economic sanctions levied against Turkey itself?<br />

Andreos: Yes that is the question that we often<br />

put to the United Nations.<br />

Dominic: And what was their response?<br />

Andreos: They say we are trying to find the<br />

solution. But this is not enough for us. This is<br />

not enough to hear that we are trying to find the<br />

solution. They have been trying for the last 26 years<br />

and not a single refugee has been able to return to<br />

his homes. So where is this solution, what kind of<br />

solution is it?<br />

They talk about the just and viable solution of<br />

the <strong>Cyprus</strong> problem but then it means that we are<br />

interpolating the word justice. Where is justice for<br />

us? In order that there shall be justice, the only<br />

thing that they can do is to tell Turkey that this is<br />

not the epoch of colonising people. This is not the<br />

epoch that one country, because it is stronger to find<br />

a weaker country and invade it and make it a colony.<br />

That’s what Turkey has done.<br />

Dominic: But the Turkish perspective is that<br />

they intervened to protect their people which were


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“the settlers, the Turkish settlers who were brought in from Turkey; if they leave I can tell you that that in<br />

24 hours in 48 hours we can find the solution and we can live together with the Turkish Cypriots provided<br />

of course that the elements which are recognised by the European Union, the human rights, the right of<br />

movement, the right of property and the civil liberties of every citizen of <strong>Cyprus</strong> are recognised, then there will<br />

be no difficulty at all.”<br />

a minority because they saw that there were human rights abuses that were being perpetrated against them.<br />

Now it can be argued that that was an excuse rather than a reason; a pretext rather than a truce. And I don’t<br />

wish to state one or the other.<br />

But at the same time they felt that there were human rights abuses that were being perpetrated. Kofi Annan<br />

has stated in one of his last statements that the two entities should be regarded as politically equal, but he has<br />

said that within that process there must be resettlement and exchange. And it seems that the north has had<br />

some reluctance to accept that. Do you feel that there will be headways or that it is a stalemate with these<br />

proximity talks?<br />

Andreos: Firstly I will say this. In 1974 Turkey did not intervene as she alleges that she intervened to save<br />

the Turkish Cypriot population and their human rights, because they said at the time that we intervened so as<br />

to reinstate the constitutional order. So that means that when they intervened the first thing they should have<br />

done was to reinstate the constitutional order. To bring back the president of the <strong>Cyprus</strong> republic, Archbishop<br />

Makarios and the vice-president and to bring back things to their normal, as it used to be before ‘74 so that<br />

people could live again in accordance with the Zurich and London agreements and the same constitution.<br />

But what have they done, they have themselves destroyed the principles of the Zurich London Agreements<br />

and the constitution, because as soon as they invaded they killed people, they raped women, they forced the<br />

Greek Cypriots to leave their homes and properties in all the Greek Cypriot villages and towns of the northern<br />

part of <strong>Cyprus</strong> and they reinstated Turkish settlers from Turkey.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“...one man escaped the United Nations who were there and he ran<br />

through the barbed wire and went on the other side where Turks were<br />

waiting for him.”<br />

“And he said I want to go back to my town, it’s<br />

not your town.”<br />

So is that true, therefore that they came here<br />

to protect the human rights of the Turkish Cypriot<br />

minority who was only 18% of the population. What<br />

have they done is that they have done the worst<br />

ethnic cleansing which is an international crime.<br />

They continue to prevent the Greek Cypriots to go<br />

back to their homes. So where is the intervention<br />

they have done in accordance with the Zurich<br />

agreements? They have done exactly the contrary<br />

and they violated the provisions of the constitution,<br />

the provisions of the London agreements, their<br />

obligations which they signed themselves. So they<br />

have done exactly the contrary and they have<br />

colonised that part of <strong>Cyprus</strong> and they consider<br />

it as their colony. Well this is something that is<br />

unacceptable. It should be unacceptable to all the<br />

civilised countries of the world, because if we accept<br />

this situation and such an erroneous justification<br />

then it means that we go back to the middle ages.<br />

Who is the stronger survives and the weaker dies.<br />

Dominic: I have one point and it’s a very<br />

interesting dilemma—to isolate a place or a political<br />

entity, sometimes makes the entity stronger rather<br />

than weaker. Do you believe in some form of<br />

dialogue or some form of communication with the<br />

other side or do you feel that there should be no<br />

dialogue and the rest of the world should pressure<br />

them into leaving?<br />

Andreos: Well I believe that if the United<br />

Nations have done their duty in accordance with<br />

the resolutions of the United Nations and of the<br />

Security Council which says that clearly the Turkish<br />

army must leave <strong>Cyprus</strong> and the foreign elements,<br />

the settlers, the Turkish settlers who were brought<br />

in from Turkey; if they leave I can tell you that that<br />

in 24 hours in 48 hours we can find the solution<br />

and we can live together with the Turkish Cypriots<br />

provided of course that the elements which are<br />

recognised by the European Union, the human<br />

rights, the right of movement, the right of property<br />

and the civil liberties of every citizen of <strong>Cyprus</strong> are<br />

recognised, then there will be no difficulty at all.<br />

And I’m sure that we have many Turkish Cypriot<br />

friends, the Turkish Cypriots have many Greek<br />

Cypriot friends will begin working together to build<br />

a better <strong>Cyprus</strong> and a peaceful <strong>Cyprus</strong>. But with the<br />

presence of the Turkish army and the continued<br />

statements of the prime minister of Turkey saying<br />

that we came here and this is the land which we<br />

won by force, by sacrifice of our soldiers and we’re<br />

not going to leave then you live nowhere.<br />

Dominic: Yes I understand. There is one further<br />

question which is we could discuss the problems<br />

of the buffer zone. What we were looking at before<br />

which was the Famagusta, the area where we can<br />

see the Turkish flags and how two of your people<br />

crossed over and what happened to them.<br />

Andreos: As you have seen, there is a short<br />

buffer zone from where we are, the free part of<br />

Famagusta and a place there which Turkey has


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...there are only one set of traffic lights at Kyrenia,<br />

and we were at them.<br />

I can see in wide arc of three or perhaps eight<br />

kilometres a dishevelled ghost town of buildings<br />

that cannot be entered, that are detached and<br />

uninhabited...<br />

said, this is the demarcation line that separates the<br />

northern part of <strong>Cyprus</strong> from the southern part of<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>. Now in between this is called the buffer<br />

zone which is under the control of the United<br />

Nations.<br />

Of course in this buffer zone you cannot go<br />

unless you have the permission of the United<br />

Nations and I can tell you that about four years ago<br />

when there was a small gathering here of young<br />

men, one man escaped the United Nations who<br />

were there and he ran through the barbed wire and<br />

went on the other side where Turks were waiting<br />

for him. And he said I want to go back to my town,<br />

it’s not your town. And then he was brutally killed<br />

by stones and sticks. This was one of the worst<br />

crimes which was seen on television by the whole<br />

world.<br />

Dominic: Is this the image exhibited when<br />

we cross over the Ledra Palace crossing at the<br />

checkpoint. Is that the one of the soldiers and the<br />

policeman with a shield beating somebody?<br />

So often when I gaze out into the city streets of<br />

Nicosia , I witness a culture inundated by Sri<br />

Lankans, Singalese or Indian.<br />

Andreos: Well there are photographs, there are<br />

many such photographs; policemen beating the<br />

man. But the place is here.<br />

Dominic: It is here yes.<br />

As the interview ends, we shake hands, depart,<br />

return to the lift and go upstairs to film from the<br />

balcony out across this no man’s land. I can see<br />

in wide arc of three or perhaps eight kilometres<br />

a dishevelled ghost town of buildings that cannot<br />

be entered, that are detached and uninhabited,<br />

controlled by the United Nations.<br />

We wander aimlessly down to a cafeteria<br />

adjacent to the observation deck to have lunch.<br />

The chef pulls out a list of photographs of the ghost<br />

city. Then a gaggle of laughing six year old children<br />

in the restaurant enter to have a birthday party<br />

outside and we were told we cannot stay. Then as<br />

suddenly as we were being dismissed they turn to


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

invite us. Rebecca who had never wished to partake<br />

of any food of a fattening nature (I remember John,<br />

her boyfriend, saying that her one vice is junk food)<br />

has this massive plate of sweets presented like the<br />

head of John the Baptist and the next moment she is<br />

consuming like in the film La Grande Bouef where<br />

people decide to eat themselves to death—pastries<br />

and chocolate bonbons, and bouchies, and slivers of<br />

weird caramel meringue.<br />

So often when I gaze out into the city streets<br />

of Nicosia, I witness a culture inundated by Sri<br />

Lankans, Singalese<br />

or Indian. There are<br />

some Pakistanis, but<br />

mostly Sri Lankans<br />

or Filipinos. The<br />

Cypriots use them<br />

for all menial labour.<br />

That induces in<br />

me great sadness,<br />

because there is<br />

not egalitarian<br />

structure—these<br />

are their imported<br />

slaves. This is what saddens me.<br />

From the Singhalese perspective, it is a good way<br />

to make money. From someone who comes from a<br />

very egalitarian country, it certainly is distasteful.<br />

These people are lucky, but on the other hand I do<br />

not think they are. From the country’s point it is<br />

not a just or recondite way of providing services for<br />

small wages.<br />

Meanwhile back at Famagusta, or Kyrenia I<br />

should say, we decide to exit. In spite of the fact that<br />

Rebecca is absolutely stonkered, a full stomach, we<br />

decide to trudge up one long street to the one set of<br />

traffic lights at the corner. The rosary clacking locals<br />

are staring at trudging silhouettes in the landscape<br />

as if we are a separate Darwinian species or pork<br />

chops at a Bahmitzva.<br />

We ring for a taxi and the taxi driver asks where<br />

shall we be and somebody says, ‘just say you are at<br />

the traffic lights at Kyrenia’, i.e. there are only one<br />

set of traffic lights at Kyrenia, and we were at them.<br />

So this man in a limousine, a three compartment<br />

Mercedes, picks us up and charges us an exorbitant<br />

amount to get to Larnacca. We decide instead to<br />

have the trip cut short by travelling directly into<br />

Nicosia. The taxi is streaming into the fading day—<br />

just passing endless Green line as we slide along this<br />

border in the divided city.<br />

It is late in the afternoon but the events of the<br />

last twenty four hours must be recorded. Maybe, as<br />

a result of past lives, I gravitate to curious Arabic<br />

environments. I can also smell thick fresh sewerage<br />

in my nostrils, but at least the coffee is good here.<br />

We arrive home, dress to go go to the ‘Gallery<br />

Bar’. I can hear Arabic in the background as I dictate<br />

this into the dictaphone. At the ‘Gallery Bar’ we<br />

listen to sort of wailing of sea shanty music of the<br />

Greek Cypriots. It is fascinating and very bohemian<br />

as we ended up being befriended by three lesbians:<br />

Daya, Michaela and Litha. Beautiful, funny, erudite,<br />

ironic women. Meanwhile back at the ‘Gallery Bar’<br />

the girls are knocking back gin and tonics. There<br />

is the wailing, unrequited music of the passionate<br />

Cypriots. It was a beautiful evening and Daya looks<br />

at me and says, ‘You must be Irish’.<br />

She smiles, and is slightly plump and reminded<br />

me of Catherine, an old friend of my sister’s.<br />

This was the first time for many months that I<br />

had met someone with whom I had a connection.<br />

Our conversation darted backwards and forwards.<br />

We talked of irrelevant topics and wandered as if<br />

we were drunken sailors zigzagging over unknown<br />

nameless topics for ten minutes. Then the next<br />

jiffy she abruptly turns her back on me, talking<br />

to someone else. Alone, I just stare at the blue<br />

lighted vodka bottles which look like traffic lights<br />

for drunks, thinking this night club etiquette is not<br />

my scene. As Rebecca would say, ‘Is that rudeness?’<br />

Or: ‘People are<br />

imperfect and<br />

relatively unevolved<br />

beings up to a<br />

point.’ As I stared<br />

around the room<br />

embarrassed but<br />

independent I<br />

soon noticed other<br />

aspects of the<br />

meshed gyrating<br />

mass of disco<br />

bunnies. There<br />

was one woman, an old gymnast who was dancing.<br />

She was with another man who appeared to be a<br />

womaniser. I presumed they had been lovers and<br />

there still remained a thread or a spark. Perhaps<br />

they had been lovers 15 or even 20 years ago. But<br />

there remained like a lingering whiff, a lingering<br />

memory. Now in their late 40s, she would poke her<br />

tongue out at him while she was dancing on the floor<br />

while he sat at the bar, grey-haired, silver stubble<br />

on his chin. There was this strange relationship that<br />

seemed to be going on.<br />

We then jumped into Litha’s car and drove off to<br />

her night club and we went to ‘Club Red’ which had<br />

these wild lights that went up the walls. It was an<br />

old renovated barn converted old stables that had<br />

been converted into a factory, and from a factory<br />

it had been converted again into something more<br />

interesting. Here I would conclude the evening by


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...he suggests I should contact Muhitt(dd)in<br />

Ikidereli. He was the Director of Consular Affairs<br />

and Minority Activities. If anything is to go into<br />

the Green line buffer zone it was to be under his<br />

auspice and with his permission.<br />

Marios Koulovac’s family are refugees, and his father is<br />

a missing person not known to be either dead nor alive.<br />

He has been missing for the last 26 years.<br />

I drop into Bullant Kanol’s office and his secretary says a letter has<br />

been sent to the Deputy Prime Minister Akungi pertaining to the idea.<br />

talking with Litha into the small hours at the ‘Club<br />

Red’ , on the border of the Green line. There is<br />

actually a big glass wall in the club through which I<br />

could see a factory that extends into the Dead Zone.<br />

On the other side is the Green line buffer zone. the<br />

‘Club Red’ thereby juts into the Dead Zone to the<br />

Turkish side. ‘Club Red’ has a big red neon sign<br />

out the front. I talked to Daya that night about the<br />

paranormal, about life after death. It was beautiful<br />

what she said. She said two things. One was: ‘I do<br />

not feel that my words are worth recording’ and<br />

‘I do not have anything intelligent to say. What is<br />

intelligent has already be.’<br />

Sunday, 19th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

It was a late night, ending up at two or three in<br />

the morning crawling down dark alleys. Somehow<br />

we find our way home with Litha’s car. We sleep<br />

all the next day, Sunday the 19th. It is just a day<br />

of zilch, totally. I cannot even remember this day<br />

shall we say. I crawl out that morning into the city<br />

and find a coffee shop on Macarius Street where I<br />

correct my book. That is the way that the day was<br />

spent, just as an editorial. We do a TV press release<br />

to Reuters, BBC, CNN, WTN, Australian ABC,<br />

SBS, CNN, BC America, list of Amelia’s invitees 50<br />

people from one side, and 50 people from the other,<br />

Semi Bora’s invitees. A list of requirements for<br />

the ceremony are written down—invitees, chairs,<br />

podiums, press release and musicians. The UN has<br />

to do PR, provide PA system, wooden structure,<br />

erect a billboard on the wall, clear the area, invites<br />

to the Australian High Commission.<br />

Monday, 20th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

There are series of meetings in the north, across<br />

the checkpoint. It is possible that we had to film<br />

the Green line, but we have to confirm with Rania.<br />

We telephone Amelia about the departure dates,<br />

and call for the cost of the ferry to Israel only<br />

to discover that the ferries have been cancelled<br />

because of the problems happening in Israel. The<br />

ferry company has shut everything down. 10 am the<br />

Holy Archbishop in <strong>Cyprus</strong> has scheduled a meeting<br />

with Rebecca, relating to iconography history. We<br />

then buy some screws for the plate for the VX1000<br />

Sony camera.<br />

I had to fax and deliver Semi Bora’s letter and<br />

see Bullant Kanol and to get military permission,<br />

confirming with Sarah Russell about the military<br />

tour. Also there is a more trivial a hair appointment<br />

for me. That evening outside the Excelsior<br />

apartments we travel to Marios Koulovac who is a<br />

Greek Cypriot refugee to his home with his family.<br />

Thus this morning, Rebecca goes to film<br />

the Holy Archbishop of <strong>Cyprus</strong>, the Reverend


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We then saw the Minister for Consular Affairs, a stooping man with grey hair and a cast in his eye. I showed<br />

him the documents and he says:<br />

‘Are you a rich man to be able to do this? Who supports your activities?’<br />

‘We’re a small country and we must fight for justice.’ I say to them ‘that even though there may not be justice<br />

in this life, there is justice in the next.’<br />

Demonsthmonus to discuss religion and the meaning of iconography and history. He is a restoration artist and<br />

he shows some of his icons. And they visit the Agios Dmitrios Church and they document the paintings. I have<br />

discovered that the cappuccinos here are little packet cappuccinos, but nonetheless the Egyptian music is just<br />

pumping in a mellifluous and undulating way. It is a contradiction of terms is it not—pumping and mellifluous<br />

and undulating way?<br />

It’s the 20th of November and I continue on with my tour into the north. My list for the day has to be<br />

provided. I have a couple of letters which I hand in first thing that Monday morning to Bullant Kanol. He is<br />

given a formal document which ascertains that the schedule is solid. So that letter has a list of statements, the<br />

legal invitation and stipulation of what the project constitutes. As a document it establishes that the event, is<br />

also reinforced through video documentation.<br />

I drop into Bullant Kanol’s office and his secretary says a letter has been sent to the Deputy Prime Minister<br />

Akungi pertaining to the idea.<br />

‘OK, that’s good. Is it good?’ I say.<br />

And she says she thought it might be good. She did not know.<br />

And then I return and look for a military representative of the TRNC, and so I go back to the checkpoint<br />

and an old man in an old coat appears. I sit with him in an office and he suggests I should contact Muhitt(dd)in<br />

Ikidereli. He was the Director of Consular Affairs and Minority Activities. If anything is to go into the Green line<br />

buffer zone it was to be under his auspice and with his permission. After being given his number I leave and<br />

return across the Green Line to the Excelsior Hotel apartments in Greek Nicosia where we prepared for the<br />

meeting with Marios that evening.<br />

Marios Koulovac’s family are refugees, and his father is a missing person not known to be either dead nor<br />

alive. He has been missing for the last 26 years. Marios with a slight disfigurement in his eye picks us up in<br />

his Jeep. He is a receptionist at a major hospital but the physical has not impaired his ability to work at the<br />

hospital. He is a beautiful and retiring soul. Picking us up he drove to his home, a faux refugee camp when they<br />

had been resettled indicating in the house major cracks. The woman on the other side, in North <strong>Cyprus</strong>, has


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We go to see Semi Bora very<br />

quickly and he effectively<br />

says; ‘Dominic I’ll do what<br />

I can do. I feel that it will<br />

be okay, but I just need<br />

permission.’<br />

cracks in her wall as well. They wish to justify their<br />

situation by saying to the government that they<br />

require recompense, rather than saying:<br />

‘Well I’ll just fill the cracks in.’ Maybe it will<br />

crack again, but is it a victim mentality? This does<br />

not deny the events which have beleaguered them,<br />

but there seems to be a victim mentality here.<br />

We interviewed Marios and his family at home<br />

as refugees. After having lived in north <strong>Cyprus</strong> they<br />

were resettled in Nicosia. The mother and the sister<br />

discuss the memory of the time and their hope<br />

of the future, going through family photographic<br />

albums.<br />

‘We’re a small country and we must fight for<br />

justice.’ I say to them ‘that even though there may<br />

not be justice in this life, there is justice in the<br />

next.’ They show photographs of their missing<br />

father and/or husband. I then speak with Flora the<br />

sister. She had been a doctor in Russia. We talk<br />

about Natasha’s illness, a Siberian variant of liver<br />

fluke worm.<br />

That night I go and type up another letter to<br />

the Director of the Ministry of Consular Affairs<br />

because that was to be delivered to him the next<br />

day. As it turned out it was to be a week of massive<br />

bureaucratic bungling.<br />

Rebecca accompanies me over to the other side<br />

to Turkish Nicosia. As it turns out we deliver the<br />

documents to the Minister for Consular Affairs<br />

and we see Bullant Kanol’s secretary in relation to<br />

our next Thursday appointment.<br />

Tuesday, 21st November, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Rebecca accompanies me over to the other side<br />

to Turkish Nicosia. As it turns out we deliver the<br />

documents to the Minister for Consular Affairs and<br />

we see Bullant Kanol’s secretary in relation to our<br />

next Thursday appointment.<br />

As we cross over the Ledra Palace Checkpoint<br />

back to the Greek side. I say to the UN soldiers: ‘I<br />

hope it is not too boring for you.’<br />

And they say: ‘Ah well, we get used to kicking<br />

the stones and making friends with the stray cats.’


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...We travelled<br />

across to the north,<br />

to try to deliver the<br />

documents again<br />

to the Minister of<br />

Foreign Affairs who<br />

was again nowhere<br />

to be found.<br />

...but simultaneously a sense of purging, and fulfilling the<br />

steps. We have to then cross over to the TRNC and go<br />

through the checkpoints past the dead zone and then to the<br />

Turkish side.<br />

But they did not say which names they had for which alley cats.<br />

We had this meeting with an aide of Acting Director of the Ministry of Defence. There was a man there<br />

who took us up there. Two days later he appears as one of the people in the passport office. It was an<br />

odd coincidence that they have the people who are in the Ministry of Defence suddenly appearing at the<br />

checkpoint.<br />

We then saw the Minister for Consular Affairs, a stooping man with grey hair and a cast in his eye. I showed<br />

him the documents and he says:<br />

‘Are you a rich man to be able to do this? Who supports your activities?’<br />

And I say to him, ‘Well I’m not exactly a poor person.’<br />

And he smiles and says, ‘Yeah well.’<br />

Then he says, ‘Look I can’t say anything about this, I’ll just pass it on to the authorities.’<br />

As we’re leaving he smiles and says that he found the Australian Federal Police have seven of their people<br />

stationed here in the Green line. He went out to lunch with one of them and they provided him with Australian<br />

beef and Australian wine. It was obviously a high point in his time. He gets a woman to see us to the front door,<br />

which was very sweet of him and we leave.<br />

We go to see Semi Bora very quickly and he effectively says;<br />

‘Dominic I’ll do what I can do. I feel that it will be okay, but I just need permission.’<br />

So my gut feeling was right. His caution and fear was not that he did not want to do it. But rather that he<br />

needs the people above him, the high authorities, to say yes.<br />

Slowly bit by bit the pieces fall into their respective place and the pattern becomes clear. We can see which<br />

politicians have power and control, and which do not, who are the puppets and who pay lip service. All of this<br />

to erect a simple billboard. It is a crazy time, is it not? But still…<br />

We then go to see some people outside who are singing. It’s just a family in the backyard; a woman<br />

introduces herself: ‘My name is Chikra,’ We meet the family. We then go off into the night.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

...we must wait there, in the middle of no man‘s<br />

land. We are not even allowed to pass through<br />

until someone from the PIO appears to take us<br />

and Rebecca looks at me as if this is something a<br />

little bit strange.<br />

It is not as if we are<br />

prisoners, but our<br />

movements are being<br />

curtailed.<br />

...eventually a woman in a small battle-grey<br />

Peugeot drives up and very politely takes us to the<br />

TRNC Ministry of Defence and Information where<br />

we have a meeting with the Acting Director of<br />

Public Relations Mr. Sabatini Egeli.<br />

Wednesday, 22nd November, <strong>2000</strong>, Turkish Republic of North <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The next day was Wednesday the 22nd at 10 am, Rebecca had a United Nations conference of both sides. It<br />

was a meeting of the leaders of the political parties in <strong>Cyprus</strong> organised by the embassy of the Slovak Republic,<br />

November 22nd, <strong>2000</strong> Ledra Palace, Nicosia. The list of participants I won’t mention them all, but there was<br />

Mr. Serder Denctash, he was the son of the president in the North and Mrs. Keti Cleridou who was the daughter<br />

of the president of the south.<br />

We travelled across to the north, to try to deliver the documents again to the Minister of Foreign Affairs who<br />

was again nowhere to be found. I presented myself at the front office and a woman, Fatima, from the Press and<br />

Information Office came out. I sat with her for an hour and she seemed understandably very reluctant to show<br />

me to the office of the Minister of Foreign Affairs, or even to his secretary.<br />

She telephoned the Director of the Press and Information Office and apparently everybody was at the<br />

parliament, to do with budget agendas. So I waited. She said he would be back in half an hour. I sat and flicked<br />

through the newspapers in the office where flocks of Turkish women or Turkish Cypriot women were chatting<br />

like magpies perched on stools or on top of their desks.<br />

The Minister of Foreign Affairs was Mr. Tashin Ertugruloglu. So Fatima would come in, go out, read a book,<br />

make a phone call, disappear, and then after an hour and a half of waiting she returned finally and said:<br />

‘No nobody is coming back until the end of the day and the director is not coming.’<br />

Then she said: ‘Will you give me the documents?’<br />

I hesitated and thought, no, if I give them the documents they will get lost. This was the important<br />

submission and the letter to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. Therefore I said: ‘Let’s make a compromise. If you<br />

photocopy them, then I will leap into the unknown of tomorrow with them and you can put them on his desk.<br />

Is that fair enough?’ And she said, ‘Yes.’ And with that I was out into the taxi and back across the checkpoint to<br />

Greek <strong>Cyprus</strong>.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

So it smacked me like a tonne of bessa bricks coming down<br />

from 15 stories. I was stunned and speechless for the first<br />

thirteen seconds.<br />

“...he thinks that the Greek Cypriot side should demonstrate some goodwill by responding to our step (we<br />

replaced all the billboards on our side by peaceful posters) at the Ledra Palace before we can take any further<br />

action on this matter.”<br />

Thursday, 23rd November, <strong>2000</strong>, Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

And it is a Thursday with bright skies. My first stop is Alpha Graphics. Andrea does her booklets for me,<br />

little printed fiascos with the clear plastic covers. It seems a ritual, a sacrament that we do every second day,<br />

the ritual of printing and binding documents. Something that at times has a boredom but simultaneously<br />

a sense of purging, and fulfilling the steps. We have to then cross over to the TRNC and go through the<br />

checkpoints past the dead zone and then to the Turkish side.<br />

This day is a strange one because when we arrived there was a confusion when we put in our papers<br />

and documents at the immigration office, because at that stage our documents are about to expire. On the<br />

computer it states there is information that the PIO (Public Information Office) has to escort us, and we must<br />

wait there, in the middle of no man‘s land. We are not even allowed to pass through until someone from the<br />

PIO appears to take us and Rebecca looks at me as if this is something a little bit strange.<br />

It is not as if we are prisoners, but our movements are being curtailed. Rather than seeing it in the light<br />

of conspiracy theory which I am sure it is not, it is just the way the computer has programmed our crossing,<br />

and the guards have to follow what is displayed on the computer. Come what may, we wait , and eventually a<br />

woman in a small battle-grey Peugeot drives up and very politely takes us to the TRNC Ministry of Defence and<br />

Information where we have a meeting with the Acting Director of Public Relations Mr. Sabatini Egeli.<br />

Mr. Egeli has a cast in his eye, and a beneficent smile. He asks for the documents which he says he will pass<br />

on to Ertugruloglu who is the Minister of Foreign Affairs. This is the letter that I have written as a submission<br />

to Mr. Tashin Ertugruloglu. From that point on we sit down in the customary position of dealing with public<br />

dignitaries: where the desk that the director sits behind is always 7cm higher than the couches that sit<br />

perpendicular to this large official desk. Coffees—the ubiquitous Turkish coffee—are placed before us and the<br />

minister then proceeds to tell us his story about his near-death experience, or out of the body OOB experience<br />

he had upon dying. He had open heart surgery and he said his heart was taken out of his body and placed in<br />

some sort of strange vat which sat at -30 centigrade. And for four hours he was, if not dead, then in this sort of<br />

bizarre comatose state. During that time he experienced the whole, almost cliche-ridden, gamut of experiences<br />

of passing through the tunnel. And he explained that he then found himself in a field where everyone was<br />

wearing purple gowns and they were a a brown/purple colour.<br />

In this bizarre green field the congregating group was comprised of only men. Mr Egeli believed it strange<br />

that they were only men and even more curious nobody there was a recognisable friend. But he explained he<br />

would have remained had he known somebody. Precisely because he did not know anybody he chose to return.<br />

He stressed he would have remained there had they been people he knew. Upon returning to his body in this


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

world, he recounted the experience to the doctors.<br />

He now no longer fears anything.<br />

From there we drove to the next door building<br />

which is the offices for Bullant Kanol who has a<br />

letter for me from the deputy Prime Minister or in<br />

reference to the project. It was waiting on the desk<br />

with the secretary but without Bullant Kanol being<br />

present.<br />

The letter went:<br />

‘Turkish Department of Northern <strong>Cyprus</strong>,<br />

Ministry of State and Deputy Prime Ministry.<br />

(23rd November <strong>2000</strong> which was the very day<br />

that I had picked it up.) Reference DB75/94/7-<br />

1153<br />

Subject, Dominic Ryan, <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> Director<br />

<strong>2000</strong>.<br />

‘Dear Dominic,<br />

Thank you for your letter of 17 November.<br />

I have informed my minister about your<br />

project. As I expressed to you in our meeting,<br />

he thinks that the Greek Cypriot side should<br />

demonstrate some goodwill by responding to our<br />

step (we replaced all the billboards on our side<br />

by peaceful posters) at the Ledra Palace before<br />

we can take any further action on this matter.<br />

Thank you for your interest and good luck with<br />

your peace building activities.<br />

Yours sincerely, (Turkish scribble),<br />

B Kanol, Undersecretary. 32392/2289629.<br />

So it smacked me like a tonne of bessa bricks<br />

coming down from 15 stories. I was stunned and<br />

speechless for the first thirteen seconds. I asked his<br />

secretary: ‘Is there anything I can do? Can I see him<br />

? Can we respond physically?’ But she replied with<br />

a perplexed yet apologetic smile as if she wanted<br />

to help but could do nothing, indeed had perhaps<br />

been instructed to keep us at a benign distance:<br />

‘Unfortunately Mr.<br />

Kanol is very busy<br />

now. He has many<br />

meetings. He cannot<br />

see you today, since<br />

he is going to be<br />

busy for the next<br />

two weeks.’<br />

And that was<br />

that! So immediately<br />

we were sucked<br />

into the whole<br />

bureaucratic war<br />

“Unfortunately Mr.<br />

Kanol is very busy<br />

now. He has many<br />

meetings. He cannot<br />

see you today, since<br />

he is going to be<br />

busy for the next two<br />

weeks.”<br />

which had been set up. A letter of rejection is given<br />

and the person who receives the letter is no longer<br />

allowed to physically or humanly intercede or meet<br />

with the official. Once the letter has been delivered<br />

all physical and human contact are avoided.<br />

And so there were images on the other side, the<br />

Greek side. The letter from B Kanol said that all<br />

images of violence had to be pulled down or we had<br />

to bail out. I either bail out or go to Israel or Pila. I<br />

suppose we row with it.<br />

I am still digesting the news as we move on into<br />

the rest of the day…We go to a restaurant in the<br />

old part of the Turkish sector of the city. There is<br />

an old Bulgarian<br />

A letter of rejection is<br />

given and the person<br />

who receives the letter<br />

is no longer allowed to<br />

physically or humanly<br />

intercede or meet with<br />

the official. Once the<br />

letter has been delivered<br />

all physical and human<br />

contact are avoided.<br />

Turk who is in the<br />

Lonely Planet called<br />

Hassan. He shows<br />

us his Australian<br />

flag and he has<br />

been here for a<br />

number of years<br />

and the restaurant<br />

is called ‘The<br />

European Cafe’. His<br />

wife was the cook.<br />

We then wander<br />

up to one of the<br />

jewellery shops where the Dutch soldiers were<br />

buying gold chains. One of the Dutch soldiers was<br />

choosing one for his girlfriend. He talked about his<br />

time here in the United Nations.<br />

We then simply walk the streets of the old city<br />

dodging grubby children and kids in chairs out the<br />

front past the Police building, walking past Turkish<br />

baths, facades, mosques, walking through the<br />

streets.<br />

That night the jazz bar we are at, after crossing<br />

into Greek Nicosia, the ‘Blue Bar’. Lina the singer,<br />

the club, its smoke, crowded, the clink of glasses,<br />

distance, people are hiding inside themselves,<br />

people are looking for something, people finding<br />

something, people finding nothing, query less.<br />

Smoke filled. Lonely, blessed, embracing, darkish.<br />

That night I go to the internet cafe at Philip’s place<br />

and I write the letter for the people in the TRNC,<br />

the Minister of Foreign Affairs and for Bullant<br />

Kanol—which I am to take tomorrow and give to<br />

them.<br />

This is the letter, this is how I wrote it:<br />

‘B Kanol, Undersecretary, Ministry of State<br />

and Department, Deputy Prime Minister’s Office<br />

Thursday, 23rd November, <strong>2000</strong>.<br />

Dear Mr. Kanol, I have received your letter<br />

dated 23rd November – it was with some<br />

surprise and disappointment that you are unable<br />

to co-operate in the peace project ceremony<br />

which I had outlined in my letter dated<br />

November 23rd. I may have misunderstood<br />

this letter, but my reading of it is that until the<br />

Greek Cypriot side undertakes further steps


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Therefore I see this as an opportunity for the peace ceremony to occur as such<br />

a request for the removal of the poster can be diplomatically voiced at the<br />

ceremony.<br />

A message of peace should be voiced precisely because of<br />

the senses of injustice which have arisen.<br />

...but my reading of it is that until the Greek Cypriot<br />

side undertakes further steps towards implementing<br />

measures of peace and reconciliation, you will not<br />

participate in attending the erection and ceremony<br />

that ‘violence and war cannot solve the problems of<br />

humanity’ in the DMZ near Ledra Palace.<br />

A message of peace, especially if<br />

the message is war and violence,<br />

cannot solve the problems of humanity<br />

should be affirmed and allowed<br />

to occur between two parties in a<br />

neutral demilitarised zone without<br />

preconditions of specific acts of<br />

political goodwill from either side.<br />

towards implementing measures of peace and<br />

reconciliation, you will not participate in attending<br />

the erection and ceremony that ‘violence and war<br />

cannot solve the problems of humanity’ in the<br />

DMZ near Ledra Palace.<br />

‘Mr. Kanol I support and understand<br />

your concern in this matter. I agree that the<br />

propagation of the images of blood and violence<br />

at the Ledra Palace checkpoint can only continue<br />

to leave the wound of suffering open. Therefore I<br />

see this as an opportunity for the peace ceremony<br />

to occur as such a request for the removal of<br />

the poster can be diplomatically voiced at the<br />

ceremony. Secondly when Tzvi Tzilker the mayor<br />

of Ashdot entered the no man’s land between the<br />

Palestinian authority and Israel in 1997 to meet<br />

the mayor of Gaza he created the opportunity of<br />

an opening to use his port facilities to ferry goods<br />

to Gaza. This event was a spark of good news in<br />

an otherwise blank climate. Two hundred and<br />

fifty million people saw it on television around<br />

the world. A message of peace should be voiced<br />

precisely because of the senses of injustice which<br />

have arisen. The only way to heal the past is to<br />

affirm a message in the present for the future.<br />

This often takes courage. If a message of peace<br />

cannot be affirmed by both parties in the neutral<br />

zone because one side has not exercised as a<br />

precondition, goodwill by a specific act, then<br />

there can be little hope for peace in the future. (I<br />

changed that to) A message of peace, especially<br />

if the message is war and violence, cannot solve<br />

the problems of humanity should be affirmed and<br />

allowed to occur between two parties in a neutral<br />

demilitarised zone without preconditions of specific<br />

acts of political goodwill from either side.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

If we wait for a specific act of goodwill to occur before<br />

embracing a universal truth there would be no way the<br />

peace ceremony can occur. <strong>Peace</strong>ful intent must come<br />

before political implementation.<br />

(Then I went on to say, we are bringing a humanitarian message that peace can only be realised through<br />

the human heart before it can come politically.)<br />

‘If politicians are seen to espouse this message it can only be of benefit for all parties, because of the<br />

media exposure it would bring from the truth which they share. Public relations benefits of the TRNC and<br />

the other side attending this message are both positive and will become global. If we wait for a specific act of<br />

goodwill to occur before embracing a universal truth there would be no way the peace ceremony can occur.<br />

<strong>Peace</strong>ful intent must come before political implementation. I am left with no other position than to believe<br />

that your Minister does not wish an image of peace in a neutral area for a brief period of five days because<br />

one side has kept an image of violence up on the other. It is like saying we do not wish a white flag to fly in<br />

the no mans land because there is already a flag of blood flying on the other side. This is the first time that<br />

a government or mayor or body has rejected this image of peace that I have brought to a country. I respect<br />

and honour the law of all countries and will respect and will abide by the wishes of your government. So<br />

I will return to Australia with the documentary film about my failed attempts to erect a message of peace<br />

at the Ledra Palace DMC. I have submitted the previous letter dated the 17th of November to both the<br />

Minister of Foreign Affairs and also to the Director of Consular Activities. I hope your Minister reconsiders.<br />

In the event that he does not my words above hold fast and I stand by them. Again I repeat I hope that<br />

you reconsider your position. I respect your minister’s position even if I do not agree that it is grounded<br />

on my perception of logic. I thank you for the time that we spent together Mr. Kanol and I appreciate your<br />

sentiments that I am a brave man.’<br />

So it was done and good to have written the letter, to have released any angst or frustration.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Friday, 24th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Greek<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

We then went to see very<br />

briefly Mustafa who said<br />

to us that it was probably<br />

incorrect of us to have<br />

submitted that letter to B<br />

Kanol...<br />

This morning I went to Alpha Graphics, had the<br />

letter printed and put into the little plastic binder. I<br />

don’t think Angela was there, I think someone else.<br />

Then we went to Bullant Kanol again on the north<br />

side. Rebecca also ended up getting food poisoning.<br />

We delivered the letter to B Kanol’s office. The<br />

secretary offered us some white chocolate.<br />

We then went to see very briefly Mustafa who<br />

said to us that it was probably incorrect of us to<br />

have submitted that letter to B Kanol, and perhaps<br />

in hindsight that may have been the case. I do not<br />

know. Had it not gone that way, then who knows.<br />

And then we filmed us wandering through the<br />

streets. Then we returned to the other side.<br />

We went to ‘Galactica’ and ‘Bar One’ to find out<br />

whether I could find one of the Russian women<br />

or Bulgarian women bars and get documentary<br />

statements about their situation here. There it is<br />

like bellydancers in Casablanca Morocco where<br />

these women perform spinning oriental dances, and<br />

old silver-haired men with frustrated sexual lives<br />

watched them. The women were paid immense<br />

amounts of money to talk to them. And that was it.<br />

I then went to Bar One and spoke to this woman<br />

called Galia who was from Bulgaria, and then spoke<br />

with a beautiful 24-year-old Bulgaria girl called<br />

Tanya, who I liked, although under the blue light<br />

the retinas of her eyes went milk white. And she<br />

had around her neck in gold, the word ‘Tanya’ in<br />

sloping calligraphic writing. I rang Natasha as well.<br />

Saturday, 25th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Greek Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

We have coffee at the strange cafe on Kennedy<br />

Avenue. It was only a shawami or souvlaki place<br />

downstairs opposite the telephone booth in<br />

Kennedy Avenue. The man in his mid 60s, with<br />

silver receding hairline, stubble, bored, with that<br />

sense of total disdain, reluctance, unenthusiastic for<br />

the life that they lead serves us. He is are unhappy<br />

doing what he does and therefore incapable of<br />

sharing with us any joy.<br />

I asked for a Nescafe with milk and he<br />

proceeded to give me one, but filled by stress,<br />

angst and existential dissatisfaction of his own life.<br />

I end up drinking not only his coffee, but his life<br />

problems.<br />

I rang Nikos last night, Nikos Anastasios<br />

(Teacher and Director of Seeds of <strong>Peace</strong>, South<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>) who has these youth groups where bicommunal,<br />

people from both sides, congregate in


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

If we could not do the ceremony in Ledra Palace to<br />

bring the politicians to make a humanitarian gesture<br />

then we could do it in Pyle as a bridge with students.<br />

If we could not get two politicians into the checkpoint,<br />

then we will bring two girls to say what the politicians<br />

could not say.<br />

Pyle is an<br />

isthmus which<br />

connects the two<br />

sides because it<br />

is connected via<br />

the sovereign<br />

bases controlled<br />

by the British.<br />

Nikos aims to bring into the<br />

peace process young people<br />

who have not attended such<br />

meetings before.<br />

the buffer zone, in the sovereign bases area on the<br />

Green line between Pyle and a Turkish town called<br />

Pergamus.<br />

Some of Nikos’s projects occur with students<br />

from both sides of the buffer zone in Pyle: one of<br />

them is a communal marathon which is a cycling<br />

and running marathon that raises funds for victims<br />

of leukemia. In communal drama groups, teenagers<br />

from both communities work together to write<br />

and perform their own plays following specific<br />

methodology,


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Nikos arrives and proceeds to show us using the objects<br />

on the table, the salt, the pepper, a couple of plates, the<br />

geography of the Pyle Isthmus and Buffer Zone.<br />

In the afternoon we pull out the billboards in the<br />

Excelsior Hotel, moving all the pieces of laminated<br />

furniture in the Hotel dining room to roll the billboards<br />

out, measure them to see they are appropriate.<br />

Nikos aims to bring into the peace process<br />

young people who have not attended such meetings<br />

before. A bi-communal band is a group of young<br />

musicians who are looking to form a communal rock<br />

band.<br />

It is suggested that we rendezvous in the town<br />

which is the second buffer zone between the two<br />

areas. We wait in Pyle. Pyle is an isthmus which<br />

connects the two sides because it is connected via<br />

the sovereign bases controlled by the British. There<br />

is an isthmus, a small pier of land which connects<br />

the two sides. It is possible Nikos explains for the<br />

people from the north to enter into this bottleneck<br />

area. They cannot go beyond Pyle just as the people<br />

in Pyle or from the south can enter this strange area<br />

but also cannot go beyond it.<br />

Nikos is a man in his 40s, with a slightly salt and<br />

pepper goatee, receding hairline, glasses, and bright<br />

blue azure eyes which are crystal clear for someone<br />

with such dark pigmentation. It’s a beautiful<br />

combination. A clean gentle aura of beneficence,<br />

just a cool beautiful state of being. He has an aura of<br />

purity about him and an aura of enthusiasm. As his<br />

wife says ‘If he does not do this, no one else would’.<br />

As such he has become the catalyst of enthusiasm to<br />

drive other people to be together.<br />

If we could not do the ceremony in Ledra Palace<br />

to bring the politicians to make a humanitarian<br />

gesture then we could do it in Pyle as a bridge with<br />

students. If we could not get two politicians into the<br />

checkpoint, then we will bring two girls to say what<br />

the politicians could not say.<br />

In Pyle there are two coffee shops, one is Greek,<br />

the other one is Turkish. We sit in the Greek one<br />

and as we begin the patron comes out and gives us<br />

this a squid to taste. We are having a marine lunch<br />

when Nikos arrives and proceeds to show us using<br />

the objects on the table, the salt, the pepper, a<br />

couple of plates, the geography of the Pyle Isthmus<br />

and Buffer Zone.<br />

We return to his house that night to canvas<br />

possible scenarios of how the event could be staged.<br />

We have a hasty black coffee which has cracked<br />

almonds in it. We then meet his three children,<br />

Mariana, Natasha, Stefanidis and his wife Sue who<br />

is beautiful Malaysian. We finally call a taxi to the<br />

urban sprawl Nicosia and return that night, tired<br />

but ultimately optimistic.<br />

Sunday, 26th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Rebecca still has food poisoning. She is still<br />

dealing with the effects of her experiences on<br />

Friday in the north, where she had eaten something<br />

toxic. That is where it began. Just a quiet day<br />

recuperating, Dominic is doing his journal and going<br />

to the internet cafe. Madeline has emailed me her<br />

condolences about the failed initiative.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We are just doing everything on automatic<br />

pilot, fulfilling, trying to pick up the pieces of the<br />

project, realising that we have been here a month<br />

and it has just hit this heartless brick wall.<br />

...there are no ferries leaving to Israel because of<br />

the conflict, the intifada which has been going on<br />

since September….<br />

Dear Dominic,<br />

I am crestfallen at the news, and sorry<br />

for you both after all of your efforts. You<br />

really did do a great job in the most trying of<br />

circumstances, however, and I congratulate you<br />

on your persistence and thoroughness. Let’s<br />

focus on Pyle and see what we can do. As for<br />

the scaffolding: maybe one possibility would still<br />

be to go back to your friend Lelos. Clearly he<br />

supports the idea. I know that his municipality<br />

has resources, and they may have something<br />

like scaffolding which could be loaned. Transport<br />

would need to be arranged, but ways could<br />

presumably be found. If finances (for hiring<br />

of scaffold or trucks or whatever) was the<br />

problem, Dinos Lordos might be a possibility.<br />

You could speak to Nikos Anastasios in case he<br />

has other ideas.<br />

On the press release: I looked at the<br />

draft you sent last week and it looks good.<br />

Presumably you would need a revised one for<br />

a Pyle venue. In preparing it, I would suggest<br />

simply that you or Rebecca speak again to Sarah<br />

before sending it out. You should check with her<br />

if she is able to act as the inquiry point for the<br />

journos; and to give her the late update/briefing<br />

so she is prepared to answer their queries.<br />

In that case, I would also suggest you put one<br />

name only for journalists’ queries in order not<br />

to confuse the matter (i.e. ensure that the one<br />

person is putting out one set of details only).<br />

Anita could be named on the invitations for<br />

VIPs to receive their replies<br />

(RSVPs). In that case she should also have a<br />

full list of those invited in order to be prepared<br />

for their calls. You must be out of the hotel for<br />

now; feel free to call me later if you need to. I<br />

am back in the country now and on the mobile<br />

for at least a few days!<br />

Cheers, M


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

We are actually playing a waiting game.<br />

The rain in Nicosia<br />

engulfs us. It’s kind<br />

of post- very, very,<br />

very, postmodern,<br />

post-industrialised,<br />

global warming,<br />

El Nino rain. It is<br />

a call-it-what-youwant,<br />

end-of-theworld<br />

rain or the<br />

beginning of the<br />

21st century rain or,<br />

“my the climate is<br />

changing” rain.<br />

I received a call from Mustafa, Sarah Russell has put him through<br />

from the north, it is impossible to actually ring directly. He is<br />

reiterating what Bullant Kanol and the Minister of State have said<br />

and that is that the other side have no option but to conform and<br />

replace the image of violence for the humanitarian ceremony to<br />

occur. They feel that they are incapable of doing anything but<br />

replying with the letter that I read.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

But the mere presence of two people acknowledging and affirming<br />

vows of non-violence and of peaceful co-existence was too much.<br />

I realise now that the writing<br />

is on the wall and that the little<br />

hope that we had held out for<br />

the two mayors to meet in the<br />

centre of a divided city has<br />

now disappeared.<br />

Monday, 27th November, <strong>2000</strong>, Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

In the afternoon we pull out the billboards in the Excelsior Hotel, moving all the pieces of laminated<br />

furniture in the Hotel dining room to roll the billboards out, measure them to see they are appropriate. Faroud<br />

and Tony who was the other concierge, remark on these huge massive images. I explain to Faroud the meaning<br />

of them and talk about the peace idea.<br />

The days are becoming list days now. We are just doing everything on automatic pilot, fulfilling, trying to<br />

pick up the pieces of the project, realising that we have been here a month and it has just hit this heartless<br />

brick wall. I am not certain what I can do. I am again in a strange shock of dealing with the events, taking one<br />

day at a time. I do not think that I can lay blame, I do not think that I can respond in any way, but respond to<br />

each event as it arrives.<br />

This afternoon I fax documents to Mr. Dimitriades, another Dimitriades who is the district supervisor of the<br />

Pyle region of the sovereign bases area. I spoke to him and I faxed them through.<br />

This evening I go again to Alpha Graphics and Rebecca and I see the film Any Given Sunday by Oliver<br />

Stone, which actually seems relevant.<br />

Afterwards with Rebecca we go to the cabaret. It’s raining, absolutely pouring now. It’s this mad experience<br />

of seeing oneself outside oneself jumping through the streets walking from puddle to puddle. I feel drenched.<br />

I feel like this wet engulfed drowned possum or rat. My coat is drenched and I get to ‘Bar One’ to see the two<br />

girls, Galia and Tanya. I have the tape recorder in order to document one of our conversations.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Sometimes like an ant crawling through a maze the<br />

ant is unaware that a maze has a design and route<br />

that is above and beyond the mere meanderings<br />

of this ant. So too it is with us and the destiny of<br />

our journey. We are trying to fulfil a design that is<br />

greater than the time and the days presume.<br />

He speaks with his arms crossed in his plain<br />

hounds tooth suit with black poker dot tie, clean<br />

shaven face, colloidal scaring, sweet beautific<br />

grin, a very, very sweet and benign human being<br />

who must voice the policies of his government as<br />

much as his own opinions.<br />

27th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

We called to find out the cost of a ferry to Israel,<br />

but it transpires there are no ferries leaving to Israel<br />

because of the conflict, the intifada which has been<br />

going on since September…Rebecca calls to find<br />

out about Amelia, Lelos secretary, to check whether<br />

Lelos is about and what his movements are. So it is<br />

still an option for us, we are still hanging in. There is<br />

still hope, especially after what we have spoken with<br />

Mustafa and the others. 10 am Rebecca has to see<br />

the Holy Archbishop of <strong>Cyprus</strong> to film the history<br />

segment and at 3.30 in the afternoon we have a hair<br />

appointment. But we then change it to Tuesday.<br />

Rebecca has to go to the Sony dealer to get the<br />

screws of the bottom plate of the VX100 repaired<br />

and we have to go to the other side, in North <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

to try to get military permission.<br />

Tuesday, 28th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The rain in Nicosia engulfs us. It’s kind of postvery,<br />

very, very, postmodern, post-industrialised,<br />

global warming, El Nino rain. It is a call-it-what-youwant,<br />

end of the world rain or the beginning of the<br />

21st century rain or, “my the climate is changing”<br />

rain. It used to be one way and now it is another<br />

end of the drought rain, crying rain, purging rain.<br />

Nonetheless we just film Dominic in Alpha Graphics<br />

walking the streets, meeting the mayor, dropping<br />

in the brochures, get a list of VIPs from Amelia. We<br />

buy my ticket to Israel as a one way and both of us<br />

get a haircut. We travel to Scali which is closed, we<br />

go to see Farmagusta at the gate for dinner.<br />

Wednesday, 29th November, <strong>2000</strong><br />

It is still raining and there seems little for us<br />

to do. We are actually playing a waiting game. I<br />

received a call from Mustafa, Sarah Russell has<br />

put him through from the north, it is impossible<br />

to actually ring directly. He is reiterating what<br />

Bullant Kanol and the Minister of State have said<br />

and that is that the other side have no option but to<br />

conform and replace the image of violence for the<br />

humanitarian ceremony to occur. They feel that they<br />

are incapable of doing anything but replying with<br />

the letter that I read.<br />

I realise now that the writing is on the wall<br />

and that the little hope that we had held out for<br />

the two mayors to meet in the centre of a divided<br />

city has now disappeared. It would’ve been such<br />

a magnificent and amazing event. A humanitarian<br />

event; But the mere presence of two people<br />

acknowledging and affirming vows of non-violence<br />

and of peaceful co-existence was too much. As a<br />

politician is not the words. As I said I respected<br />

their positions.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

I know it is always important to trust,<br />

even when that trust runs the chance<br />

of being aborted, then to trust again.<br />

But somehow there is like a big plate glass, bullet<br />

proof laminated screen that has just fallen in front<br />

of us. It is that in spite of the truth, in spite of the<br />

sadness, in spite of everything I wonder<br />

I may have misunderstood this letter, but my<br />

reading of it is that until the Greek Cyrpriot side<br />

undertakes further steps towards implementing<br />

measures of peace and reconciliation, you will<br />

not be participating and attending direction and<br />

ceremony that “violence and war cannot solve<br />

the problems of humanity” in the DMZ near Ledra<br />

Palace controlled by the UN.<br />

So Mustafa has to be supportive. These are<br />

his employers; this is his government. He is a<br />

public relations representative, he is in the Public<br />

Information Office and his loyalty lies with them,<br />

not with us. He speaks with his arms crossed in his<br />

plain hounds tooth suit with black poker dot tie,<br />

clean shaven face, colloidal scaring, sweet beautific<br />

grin, a very, very sweet and benign human being<br />

who must voice the policies of his government as<br />

much as his own opinions.<br />

As I said it is now apparent we have no other<br />

recourse but to see what we can do and in the light<br />

of what is happening—perhaps a new way will<br />

be found. Perhaps we will plot a different course.<br />

Sometimes like an ant crawling through a maze the<br />

ant is unaware that a maze has a design and route<br />

that is above and beyond the mere meanderings<br />

of this ant. So too it is with us and the destiny of<br />

our journey. We are trying to fulfil a design that is<br />

greater than the time and the days presume.<br />

We took a taxi and returned from the north<br />

across the checkpoint to the south. It is raining<br />

and sleeting. There are cars hurrying to and fro.<br />

We drive to a Sony store to buy more digital video<br />

cassettes. A taxi driver picks us up on the way back.<br />

The taxi driver then deposits us on a corner when<br />

he says he’s not going our way. He leaves us on a<br />

corner where there is a large kiosk and amusement<br />

cars. And a whole series of strange amusement<br />

machines all made out of fibreglass painted<br />

fluorescent and gangrenous gaudy colours—a jumbo<br />

elephant for five year olds or adult five year olds or<br />

prematurely ageing five year olds shall we say.<br />

I leap into one of them. Of course I can’t fit into


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

another. My mind, it’s sort of at one of those points<br />

where you look at the event or thing and say ‘no I<br />

can’t do this’ and then you realise that it is not as<br />

difficult as it seems or sounds or feels. The next<br />

moment the money is being deposited into the<br />

slot and I am clutching the wheel of an exploded<br />

roadster that looks like it is made out of chewing<br />

gum or molasses. It begins to roll and I am trapped<br />

in a cartoon movie.<br />

That night I traipse through the sleet and almost<br />

tropical rain, to ‘Bar One’ to invite the Bulgarian<br />

women to come and see Rebecca and I over the<br />

weekend: for them to visit us socially rather than<br />

under the auspices of a deep red neon glow or blue<br />

light, as women hitched up to a bar with their leg like<br />

a coat hanger, hanging<br />

over some man’s<br />

ribcage.<br />

I wonder whether<br />

these people are<br />

programmed to<br />

present us with a<br />

victim mentality<br />

or whether their<br />

sadness is a gambit,<br />

or stratagem to elicit<br />

sympathy. Maybe it<br />

began as one motive<br />

and then stepped into another. It is always difficult<br />

to find the essence of a person’s sadness. To discern<br />

whether it is the illegitimacy of a sadness that becomes<br />

an enslavement. So these women who step into this<br />

prostitution for reasons, of economy or greed, end up<br />

by convincing themselves of the truth of being part of<br />

this. Then it becomes a trap.<br />

But within the bigger picture, is it so bad that they<br />

actually do this? Is it so bad that they can become<br />

something beyond what they are? They try to escape<br />

from poverty in their own country. Granted they<br />

are exploited and exploit...This provides them with<br />

income—here they might make $100, $200 a week,<br />

$300 perhaps. But the problem is that like everything,<br />

when you give someone a little bit, they crave for more<br />

and more. And that growth initiates a thirst, a hunger<br />

which cannot be appeased.<br />

Two of the women from the other night I<br />

recognise, I see Galia briefly and then speak to<br />

Tanya. There is something artificially beautiful<br />

about her. She tells me that her hair has recently<br />

been coloured. Like a piece of mahogany which has<br />

been varnished, it has a reddish brown tint. I can<br />

see again the inscription Tanya, in sloping italicised<br />

calligraphic script, on a chain across her neck in<br />

gold. I give her the cards with our address—The<br />

<strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong> and I ask her for us to rendezvous<br />

tomorrow at Laba in Macarius Avenue at four<br />

o’clock. I am wondering whether she will come<br />

and I’m wondering whether I should invite her, her<br />

friends Lina and Galia to the exhibition.<br />

Tanya tells me about her child, Gloria who is now<br />

four and currently being looked after by her mother.<br />

She says that her greatest happiness would be able<br />

to spend Christmas with her child—to share time by<br />

being with her daughter. My heart goes out to her.<br />

But somehow there is like a big plate glass, bullet<br />

proof laminated screen that has just fallen in front<br />

of us. It is that in spite of the truth, in spite of the<br />

sadness, in spite of everything I wonder whether<br />

she is genuine or whether it is a stratagem. I know<br />

it is always important to trust, even when that trust<br />

runs the chance of being aborted, then to trust<br />

again. Tanya puts on a cheap white stole; I remark<br />

that I can only stay another five minutes and then<br />

I’m gone into the night.<br />

Thursday, 30th November, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Macarius Avenue, Nicosia<br />

The rendezvous scheduled for three with Rebecca<br />

and I waiting. We wait at three o’clock the next<br />

afternoon, in Macarius Avenue at an outside cafeteria<br />

bar. I turn to Rebecca as she sucks on her perennial<br />

Stuyvescent cigarette and I say:<br />

’I don’t think they will come.’<br />

’They will come. You have to be patient.’<br />

’It’s not that we’re bad people, it’s just that a<br />

card with an address and phone number in a bar late<br />

at night, is like a drink in the bar late at night. It is<br />

finished and then there is always another drink. And<br />

after that drink another. These are easily forgotten<br />

invitations.’<br />

Meeting people the circumstances upon which we<br />

meet people are important. A club or bar never elicits<br />

strong commitment.<br />

I was not entirely disappointed when after the third<br />

Margarita nobody came, I thought that it would have<br />

been good to have continued to see them. Maybe I<br />

will visit when I return from <strong>Cyprus</strong>. But it would have<br />

been good to have interviewed them, whether for the<br />

film or a sense of friendship, to have come to know<br />

these people with greater depth and sad intensity.<br />

Because they spoke Russian I felt that there was level<br />

of trust which could be built.<br />

Friday, 1st December, <strong>2000</strong>, Red Bar,<br />

Green Line, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

That night we go to one of the night clubs where<br />

we have been to before called the ‘Red Bar’. There<br />

is a big red glowing neon sign. The club is on the<br />

Green line, (not only is it very close, it is directly


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Yanis shows us the back area<br />

which is frozen in time. It sits<br />

at 1975. All the machinery<br />

is still untouched from that<br />

particular period. There was<br />

a big glass screen which<br />

separates the night club from<br />

the area which the public are<br />

not allowed to enter and this<br />

is effectively the boundary of<br />

the Green line.<br />

We spent the afternoon in the village with Nikos running<br />

through schedules and agenda for the ceremony in Pyle.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Yanis the cinematographer/journalist/bouncer from ‘Red Bar’, said that he often went across accompanying<br />

other journalists. He explained it was peculiar and frustrating to stand in front of his own house, ‘what had<br />

been his own house’, now occupied by other people—strangers—to hear laughter, children’s voices and the<br />

clink of glasses.<br />

Everyone asked me what it was like to be on the<br />

north side. My explanation was always the same,<br />

it’s like another world.<br />

sandwiched on the Green line) on Dionysus Street (very apt) in mid “the dead zone“. It is operated by a Greek<br />

Cypriot, called Pavlos who is 40ish, entrepreneurial, pert, focused, attractive, perhaps a little machiavellian and<br />

wears jeans. Has that kind of swaggering bravado that you would find in Tel Aviv. He allows us to film and as<br />

guests we film the nightclub. The lights are low, they are pointed up so that they go up the walls in a speckled<br />

fashion, very attractive as it lights the whole bar. Yanis, pigtailed camera man who is the bouncer at the front<br />

door initiates and plays host to us about ten o’clock as the thronging crowd begins to mass in the place.<br />

Kypruos the director of the hotel we are staying is there with his wife looking more relaxed and less officious,<br />

less distance. All of the sudden we are meeting on the same side of the counter rather than different sides of<br />

the counter. He has a nice smile and there is a little island on the top of his head; looks like it’s by a few more<br />

hairs. Yanis shows us the back area which is frozen in time. It sits at 1975. All the machinery is still untouched<br />

from that particular period. There was a big glass screen which separates the night club from the area which<br />

the public are not allowed to enter and this is effectively the boundary of the Green line.<br />

We walk outside to the UN boundary line where there is barbed wire. Yanis is discussing the perimeter and<br />

we then return to the crowd, the bar and Rebecca using the steady cam just follows us through.<br />

Saturday, 2nd December, <strong>2000</strong>, Larnacca, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Today, Saturday, we pick up a rent-a-car. There are two white scratches on it, and it’s an Opal. We drive<br />

to a small village close to Larnacca airport, a coastal town where Nikos and his wife are. The village is called<br />

Arabdipoo and never could you forget such a curious and quizzical name. All you have to think of is an Arab<br />

which did a pooh. And Sue, Nikos’s wife laughing said it was a very strange query less event precisely because<br />

when they were studying in Birmingham at university (and that was when Nikos 30 years ago met his wife),<br />

they got hold of a Greek Cypriot tourist book and looked up “Arabdipoo“. There were only two lines about the<br />

village, one was that it was fashionable and reputable for nothing, and secondly that the one smell that you<br />

could smell was the animal faeces from a mule.<br />

We spent the afternoon in the village with Nikos running through schedules and agenda for the ceremony<br />

in Pyle. We discuss the scaffolding. Sue is bringing in the tea and coffee. We are discussing organising whether<br />

Kate Clerides is going to come. Then there are some dumplings which we eat. Sue then talks about the<br />

destruction of the ozone forests.<br />

At one point Nikos attempts to phone through to his friend on the Turkish side of <strong>Cyprus</strong>, Ulus Irkad. He<br />

is the mirror teacher of Nikos in the Turkish Zone. The TRNC government has allegedly confiscated a part of<br />

his house. Whether that is as a result of his bi-communal activities or not, I am not clear. The family of Sue and


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Dear Mr. Dimitriades,<br />

the northern side has declined to accept our offer of a peace ceremony. They have used the matter of the<br />

Ledra Palace checkpoint billboards as an issue for declination. I enclose both my letters to the Minister of<br />

Foreign Affairs in the north and their letter.<br />

Nikos seems to feel that this is a way of making his<br />

activities untenable for Ulus to live in the country.<br />

We return home exhausted through the nightscape<br />

to Nicosia. Rebecca is quiet, while each of us lapse<br />

into our own thoughts. When we travel together<br />

there is a simultaneous yet individual depth that we<br />

each individually experience. We live apart but we<br />

live together. It has been a good relationship. In some<br />

ways deeper and stronger than that. But at the same<br />

time each of our relationships have different qualities<br />

and quantities, and like different circles touching<br />

at different points they create eclipses. A rich and<br />

invigorating experience. Although it’s a funny, funny<br />

thing because I do not believe we have had many<br />

arguments, we have had nothing. It has been a very<br />

placid and generous experience. So the night was<br />

cool and cold and the wind in our faces as we drove<br />

into Nicosia, got some take-away and watched some<br />

television and went to bed.<br />

Sunday, 3rd December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Ayanapa, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

We drove to Ayanapa, a coastal town famous for it’s<br />

dance parties during the summer season on the east<br />

of the island. A famed holiday resort, now with the<br />

tourist season finished, people are lapsing into their<br />

burrows and the place struck us as a vulgar ghost town<br />

of empty tourist hotels and the occasional European<br />

Union tourist striding alone down the street.<br />

Rebecca worked out that there would be<br />

perhaps one to two tourists to every restaurant.<br />

Perhaps 3000 restaurants. We found one place<br />

where there were a few people. A small bay harbour.<br />

I spoke to a couple of people who were Greek<br />

Cypriot residents. Everyone asked me what it was<br />

like to be on the north side. My explanation was<br />

always the same, it’s like another world.<br />

So often I finish up by defending the other<br />

side. From the north I defend the south, from the<br />

south I defend the north. I take a neutral position<br />

as if it is possible, as if it is realistic. One boy with<br />

dark glasses and a five o’clock shadow wearing a<br />

T-shirt that says “let me be free”, explained that he<br />

travelled over two years ago to the north as part of a<br />

peace mission and that he hated it because he was<br />

treated like a tourist.<br />

Yanis the cinematographer/journalist/bouncer<br />

from ‘Red Bar’, said that he often went across<br />

accompanying other journalists. He explained it<br />

was peculiar and frustrating to stand in front of his<br />

own house, ‘what had been his own house’, now<br />

occupied by other people—strangers—to hear<br />

laughter, children’s voices and the clink of glasses.<br />

That evening back in the city we drove to a<br />

poetry reading to the house of our friend Maria<br />

Hajipavlo. Apparently the name Haji means that the<br />

person has visited Jerusalem. It is like they have<br />

made the haj, the pilgrimage to Mecca (it’s actually<br />

an Islamic term). We listen to a series of poems by<br />

various people.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Each person introduces themselves in the<br />

evening. There is a New York boy who is gay, who<br />

talks about the death of friends from AIDS. And<br />

Andreas, a wizened octogenerian with a beautiful<br />

demeanour, suffering<br />

from Parkinson’s<br />

disease. I think<br />

someone must have<br />

read his poem,<br />

which is called ‘The<br />

Dream’, because he<br />

is to ill to read it. An<br />

English lady reads a<br />

poem called ‘Tragic<br />

Images’ and then<br />

‘Jerusalem’. And<br />

then another poem<br />

I feel like I<br />

am running a<br />

marathon and<br />

having to start<br />

again.<br />

says poem of Charambolidies Shopping Street. And<br />

then Dominic reads his poem ‘I Believe’. Then Lisa<br />

reads her own poem.<br />

I spent the evening also talking to Maria’s son.<br />

She is a professor who teaches reconciliation at the<br />

Greek Cypriot university with Nashe, her colleague,<br />

who also reads a poem.<br />

Monday, 4th December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

Is the peace ceremony a possibility? I must send<br />

a new letters to Lelos Dimitriades. I need to print<br />

out press release and also ring the other Dimitriades,<br />

the police constable in the morning. This is the<br />

Dimitriades who I have to send a statement of what,<br />

where, how and when. The letter I write to Mr. Lelos<br />

Dimitriades Mayor of Nicosia lies in the paragraph<br />

below:<br />

‘Mr. Lelos Dimitriades, Mayor of Nikosia,<br />

<strong>Cyprus</strong>, 30th of November <strong>2000</strong>, Nikosia.<br />

Dear Mr. Dimitriades,<br />

the northern side has declined to accept our<br />

offer of a peace ceremony. They have used the<br />

matter of the Ledra Palace checkpoint billboards<br />

as an issue for declination. I enclose both my<br />

letters to the Minister of Foreign Affairs in<br />

the north and their letter. This was reiterated<br />

by their Minister of Foreign Affairs. Mr. Semi<br />

Bora the Mayor of Turkish Nicosia, or as is also<br />

referred the Turkish representative could not<br />

act unless they had given him permission, it<br />

seems. I was disappointed but it has revealed at<br />

least the issue that I must come prepared with in<br />

future.<br />

A message of peace cannot be compromised<br />

in the future by either side’s political tit for<br />

tat. As I said, a message of peace between two<br />

parties should be affirmed and allowed to occur<br />

in a neutral zone without preconditions by<br />

specific acts of political goodwill from either side,<br />

especially if the message is that war and violence<br />

cannot solve the problems of humanity. We hope<br />

to be able to see you again. I have one small<br />

favour; a small interview for the film. We are<br />

hoping to do the peace event at the Pergamus at<br />

the SBAA on the 10th of December. Many, many<br />

thanks for your support and help.<br />

Sincerely, Dominic Ryan and Rebecca Prole.<br />

My list indicates that I must see Phillip about<br />

a public address system. I ask Nikos if we can<br />

telephone. I must contact Kate Claridis and Contact<br />

Nashe to read poem 318941 – that’s her phone<br />

number. I must ask Maria Hajipavlo for addresses<br />

of people I can contact. Ring Doxia re a press list.<br />

<strong>Peace</strong> ceremony is<br />

still a possibility.<br />

I then send letter<br />

to the Australian<br />

embassy with<br />

passport. It was a<br />

day of typing up<br />

letters.<br />

We travel to<br />

Romamour where<br />

Rebecca films me.<br />

It is cafe off Nickitis<br />

Avenue. I am<br />

talking how I am really over this ridiculous series of<br />

rejections. I feel like I am running a marathon and<br />

having to start again. We discuss the other side’s<br />

response. In Pyle we do not have a choir; we do not<br />

have a public address system, only a billboard. For<br />

the press it is not really any massive event. I want<br />

something to be there for the people. I want to go<br />

across and talk to Channal Lavant, my friend Alvan‘s<br />

father who operates the socialist newspaper in the<br />

Turkish zone.<br />

Wednesday, 6th December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Pyle Buffer Zone<br />

The invitation goes:<br />

‘You are invited to attend the peace project<br />

ceremony <strong>2000</strong> presented by the Australian<br />

artist Dominic Ryan, Pergamus Park near Pyle.<br />

Date, Sunday the 10th of December. Time, 1pm.<br />

Imagine you are driving towards the Pergamus<br />

Park and from the distance you see two massive<br />

paintings for peace 15 feet high and 84 feet long<br />

erected in the park. These paintings are images<br />

of peace and condemnations of violence.<br />

Their titles are ‘We have all Suffered Enough’<br />

and ‘<strong>Peace</strong> on Earth’. The vital message is that


M I N U T E S T O WA R :The Last Divided City<br />

‘Art is the opposite of war.’<br />

Pyle...is on the Green line maybe 125 kilometres away from the Ledra Palace checkpoint. It is within the buffer<br />

zone but because it is connected to the British sovereign bases area which is legally under international law,<br />

British soil and the three areas rub cheek to cheek, it allows for Greek Cypriots to enter up into it’s territory and<br />

for Turkish Cypriots to descend down also. As a result it is the one place in the area where Greeks and Turks<br />

can, congregate and relate.<br />

war and violence cannot solve the problems of humanity. Dominic Ryan’s work has been exhibited in<br />

areas of conflict around the world including Sarajevo, Kosovo and the Gaza Strip.’<br />

I have sent press releases to Dafnes and asked him to forward to various people the invitations of the<br />

exhibition. I must ring Madelaine and Lita who is helping with the scaffolding and thank god for that. I must<br />

also ring Anita. In the morning I need to send letters to embassies, find musicians from the other side. I also<br />

must inform media in north <strong>Cyprus</strong>.<br />

My first interview is with Tina at DNA, which is an artists restaurant close to the old city run by an Israeli<br />

at 10 o’clock. She’s a little bit late and she rings to say that her automobile is coming out of the automobile<br />

hospital and could we meet soon. At which she does. We saunter down to the area just below and at DNA<br />

where Aleni and her boyfriend are we conduct the interview. I show her the booklet about the paintings with<br />

my philosophy. I like the statement by a friend of mine, David Thomas:<br />

‘Art is the opposite of war.’<br />

We saw Mustafa on the day of the Paris, Texas drive and we said goodbye to him There was something soft,<br />

gentle and sad about our farewell. He was seeing our departure as a loss of a friend even though there were<br />

question marks. When I went to see Channal Lavant he would say: ‘Oh you don’t really want to see him, he’s<br />

busy now, theyare printing the press.’<br />

The meeting at the British police force with Superintendent Guy goes well. We require their cooperation<br />

since the Pyle Pergamus Park is part of the buffer zone which they technically control and officiate, rather than<br />

the UN. There are a few problems. I should begin first by explaining Pyle, as I said, is on the Green line maybe<br />

125 kilometres away from the Ledra Palace checkpoint. It is within the buffer zone but because it is connected<br />

to the British sovereign bases area which is legally under international law, British soil and the three areas rub<br />

cheek to cheek, it allows for Greek Cypriots to enter up into it’s territory and for Turkish Cypriots to descend


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

The rain is weeping, the rain is engulfing us ...<br />

down also. It is a little bottle neck from both ends. As a result it is the one place in the area where Greeks and Turks<br />

can, congregate and relate.<br />

The Turkish TRNC policy is not to encourage bi-communal events. Mustafa’s position was that he could not<br />

actively encourage, once his government had rejected the message of peace, that he could not really step any further<br />

towards us or our camp.<br />

Meanwhile back in Pyla, Superintendent Guy was saying to Mr Dominic Ryan: ‘There had been certain very, very<br />

strange events which had occurred in the region.’ There are two coffee shops, one is Turkish, one is Greek which<br />

sit opposite one another in the city square and the Pergamus Park is much closer in the dead zone to the Green line.<br />

Now one of the members of the Turkish coffee shop had been arrested with one and a half kilos of heroin and a<br />

threat had been sent from the embassy, not the embassy, because there was no diplomatic relations between the two<br />

zones. Between the Department of Foreign Affairs a representative saying if he was not returned to Turkish soil they<br />

could not guarantee the safety of any Greek Cypriots in the Pyle area. We were about to have a peace event while<br />

there were threats of kidnappings, and threats that people would be arrested. We believed that this was one reason<br />

why the event was going to be cancelled. Parents whose children might attend were going to be frightened away.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

So Superintendent Guy rang Madeline Garlick,<br />

the Civil Affairs Officer for the UN. Madeline said<br />

that her intelligence reports suggested that the<br />

area had settled down; people on both sides were<br />

more comfortable and relaxed. Superintendent<br />

Guy said that because they had both Turkish and<br />

Greek employed as police they would send out their<br />

intelligence sources to find out whether this was<br />

the case. If so, then they would allow the event to<br />

happen and if it was confirmed there would be no<br />

further postponement.<br />

Lita, our friend had already organised someone<br />

to help erect the scaffolding and we were now on<br />

track. So Superintendent Guy indicates he will ring<br />

me on Saturday morning to confirm whether their<br />

sources had been correct. And if it was affirmative<br />

it could go ahead and if it was not he could not tell<br />

us not to, but he would discourage us by generating<br />

his own opinion for the United Nations. He said<br />

it would not be in the interest of the safety of all<br />

persons concerned, if the intelligence had shown<br />

the area was volatile.<br />

Friday, 8th December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

I went to the ‘European’, a coffee shop in the<br />

north, and Hussein, a restaurateur had decided to<br />

escort me to the available media stations. We went<br />

to a couple of television stations, <strong>Cyprus</strong> television,<br />

and to some journalist stations with press releases,<br />

in preparation for the Sunday event.<br />

The city and it’s populace were in the middle of<br />

a strike. The inner-city was congested with traffic,<br />

funerals, and people waving banners, hand-painted<br />

on sheets of white linen in the city. We went from<br />

newspaper to media station in the confusion of this<br />

throng to give my grubby press releases to the press<br />

here. I gave Hussein 30 pounds which was probably<br />

significant, about $100 to pay for some musicians,<br />

but I did not feel that the musicians were going to<br />

come. In fact they didn’t and I never saw the money<br />

or the musicians or Hussein ever again.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

“We have an amazing opportunity here with a man called Dominic Ryan, this person from Australia, who has<br />

brought a message of peace. He wanted two politicians to enter a checkpoint and hold their hands for peace<br />

and what happens is that one of the politicians could not do it. And then what happened is the artist found<br />

two girls who could do what two politicians could not do.”<br />

Saturday, 9th December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Nicosia and Pyle<br />

Today is a day where it just pours and pours.<br />

The rain is weeping, the rain is engulfing us with a<br />

thousand million droplets. It is difficult to see the<br />

roads and Lita picks me up in the morning at ten<br />

o’clock. I start to measure the billboards. It seems<br />

to me a ridiculous experience that we are going<br />

to erect this billboard in this torrential rain, but I<br />

guess that is one thing I have to do. I have to take<br />

just one step at a time.<br />

We put the billboards into the back of Lita’s<br />

car. I have actually christened her dog Sabachka<br />

and we drive down to Pyle from the Excelsior<br />

Hotel apartments. Marius is being sardonic and<br />

attempting a crude Cypriot humour, and he has<br />

dubbed Rebecca Madame Lucifer. And he shouts<br />

out her new name we are off to Pyle and Pergamus<br />

Park.<br />

My list for the day says bring billboard to the<br />

area and erect scaffolding at nine o’clock in the<br />

morning. The boys from Nikos’s Seeds of <strong>Peace</strong><br />

were there and we managed to drive to the area<br />

where the scaffolding is to be erected. The car<br />

actually has to wade through sections of the road<br />

which are three feet under water. The water passes<br />

over as a torrential river. I do not know what it is<br />

going to be like for tomorrow. I think and pray and<br />

hope that all will be resolved.<br />

We go to a coffee shop in Pyle in the middle<br />

of the erection and Lita shows me this card trick<br />

which I perform against Stelios, the man who has<br />

the scaffolding firm.<br />

It was a really beautiful day driving down with<br />

Lita and I ask her if there is anything I can do to<br />

repay her and she says there is one thing you can<br />

put into your film at the very end. A memorial to a<br />

friend of mine. He was charged with embezzlement


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Of course the SBAA police arrive and of course there is the Turkish Mocrabrat (secret police) who arrive in<br />

plain clothes and want to know what is happening.<br />

It was just amazing to erect the poster. The wind was blowing so hard, I just did not really think it was going to<br />

work. It was so, so, so crazy ...


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

At least it was up, at least<br />

something had been done.<br />

Turkish police in their red Peugeot appeared and then<br />

disappeared, appearing and disappearing. Like a<br />

vaudevillian keystone cops that would appear and disappear<br />

throughout a play.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Then two students, one from North <strong>Cyprus</strong> and the other from South <strong>Cyprus</strong> in an island which has been<br />

divided by war where refugees have been unable to return to their homes hold hands on an isthmus in a no<br />

mans land in front of a billboard which says we have all suffered enough in front of the billboard.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

<strong>Peace</strong> is a human right for every man,<br />

woman and child on this planet. And peace


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

can only come first through the human<br />

heart before it can come politically.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

before the courts, found guilty, went to prison, his<br />

wife left him. He was a mechanic, and finally after<br />

years of trying he managed to clear his name, he<br />

went to the press and he said to them: ‘I was front<br />

page when I was guilty, but when I’m innocent I’m<br />

not even the back page’; and two years later he<br />

committed suicide.<br />

It is raining and Lita drops me at Friendship<br />

House near Pyle. The children here are from both<br />

sides, and there is the Turkish Cypriots, Greek<br />

Cypriots and a bi-communal workshop which is<br />

called Friendship House in Pyle.<br />

There were students of creative writing reading<br />

each other’s stories, girls reading Greek Cypriot<br />

writing and Turkish Cypriots confiding in their<br />

dreams, their deepest secrets—that they realise<br />

there was nothing dividing them because ‘we really<br />

are people that are willing to fight for peace in our<br />

country non-violently. There was a great monster<br />

which is propaganda, we must fight against it’.<br />

They would say things like, ‘I start to believe we<br />

can live together after this camp. The symbol of<br />

peace means a lot to us. Everyone talks about being<br />

strange and different and learn to live together<br />

we must love each other despite the differences.<br />

The teacher was telling them that was bad, it was<br />

OK to murder others’. And she said ‘piano lessons<br />

helps me escape the problems of the real world.<br />

I realise my family is there, my father, my mother,<br />

it is the most beautiful thing. I am trying to think<br />

what my life would be without them, nothing. This<br />

part would be much better if all the children of the<br />

world are taught that we are all one. I travelled to<br />

the Atlantic and I got to know people that were<br />

different to me’. Nashe is talking about erotic stories<br />

next door.<br />

Nikos explains: ‘We have an amazing opportunity<br />

here with a man called Dominic Ryan, this person<br />

from Australia, who has brought a message of peace.<br />

He wanted two politicians to enter a checkpoint<br />

and hold their hands for peace and what happens is<br />

that one of the politicians could not do it. And then<br />

what happened is the artist found two girls who<br />

could do what two politicians could not do.’<br />

We drove home having rented a car for two days,<br />

exhausted, drained, branched, numb, and mildly<br />

semi-conscious.<br />

Sunday, 10th December, <strong>2000</strong>,<br />

Pyle, <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

The next day is the peace ceremony at Pergamus<br />

Park in Pyle. I do not know what to think. I’m<br />

am frightened it is going to be a non-event. The<br />

scaffolding guys are there and we arrive. The<br />

strangest thing was waking up at three o’clock in<br />

the morning and looking out the window after all<br />

that rain and sleet and hail and there were stars in<br />

the sky. I knew that another miracle had happened<br />

and the day was going to be fine.<br />

Dominic, and Marius laid out the posters. We<br />

then pull them out of the plastic bag, the scaffolding<br />

is there and we tie it all together. A tribute to<br />

American Beauty. Of course the SBAA police arrive<br />

and of course there is the Turkish Mocrabrat (secret<br />

police) who arrive in plain clothes and want to<br />

know what is happening. They want to know how<br />

many people and I say we do not expect many if any<br />

because of the rain.<br />

It was just amazing to erect the poster. The wind<br />

was blowing so hard, I just did not really think it<br />

was going to work. It was so, so, so crazy and I knew<br />

that once we had tied it down, it would act as a<br />

sail to push the scaffolding tower down across the<br />

people. I got Kosta, a gentle giant, with his Pajero<br />

and we drove off to the United Nations command<br />

post, stopped the car and raced out. There was<br />

a Austrian soldier who could barely string three<br />

syllables together and we asked if he had any rope.<br />

We need it to tie the scaffolding to the trees so it<br />

would not blow over. And he was saying ‘oh I don’t<br />

think we have’ and then he rang the base and they<br />

did not have any rope either.<br />

Then we drove<br />

down to a medley<br />

of green grocers<br />

and supermarket<br />

shops and bought<br />

the most pathetic<br />

pieces of plastic<br />

that would not even<br />

be used for hanging<br />

washing. As long<br />

as we did not lose<br />

trust, lose faith in<br />

the situation. We<br />

drove around in search of a hardware store, but<br />

everything was locked. There was a man standing<br />

on the road whom I went straight up to and Kosta<br />

came out of the car following me. Mid-50s grey hair,<br />

stubble on his face, red face from presumably hung<br />

over from drinking the night before. And he was<br />

the proprietor, and the next moment we are in the<br />

shop buying the thickest rope for 20 pounds, $60,<br />

we were able to use that to tie the scaffolding to the<br />

trees. The ceremony started at one o’clock and we<br />

had 40, 30, 15 minutes to do it, and we screeched<br />

back, raced back, tied the ropes, and tied the<br />

images.<br />

There was one gust of wind and it blew out and<br />

the eyelet buttons burst along one eighth of one<br />

billboard. It was 80% there. At which the guests and<br />

people from Friendship House arrived and the event<br />

began.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

It was an ad hoc event and the thought which<br />

kept on running through my head was, at least we<br />

put it up. It did not matter that so few had come. At<br />

least it was up, at least something had been done.<br />

Turkish police in their red Peugeot appeared and<br />

then disappeared, appearing and disappearing. Like<br />

a vaudevillian keystone cops that would appear and<br />

disappear throughout a play.<br />

The painting just sailed up and down in the wind<br />

like a sail on a ship that just refused to be held in<br />

as a jive . Everyone from the bi-communal sections<br />

arrived. And there was no PA. Nikos arrived,<br />

brilliant to switch off the generator.<br />

And then there is the events as they transpire.<br />

Then two girls, one from North <strong>Cyprus</strong> and the<br />

other from South <strong>Cyprus</strong> in an island which has<br />

been divided by war where refugees have been<br />

unable to return to their homes hold hands on an<br />

isthmus in a no mans land in front of a billboard<br />

which says we have all suffered enough in front of<br />

the billboard. And one of the girls says:<br />

‘It’s beautiful that people from far away have got<br />

to show us something about peace, that we’ve been<br />

living apart from for so long. We are here to bring<br />

more teenagers together. Some people can be so<br />

blind. Youth is our hope.’<br />

I read my speech now:<br />

‘<strong>Peace</strong> is a human right for every man,<br />

woman and child on this planet. And peace<br />

can only come first through the human heart<br />

before it can come politically. I know others<br />

believe otherwise, but if governments wish to<br />

truly serve their people, then what they must<br />

serve is the source of humanity and that is<br />

peace and the right to peace. But still wars will<br />

continue to exist through the establishment<br />

of nation states. Wars of succession are often<br />

serviced by true and perceived injustices by<br />

both parties. When each side becomes the enemy<br />

and perpetrators of evil acts of barbarism, then<br />

the chain of suffering continues. The scars of<br />

each people from war and injustice carry a pain<br />

which cannot be erased easily with time. To lose<br />

sons and daughters, often innocent victims of<br />

events beyond their control and understanding<br />

leaves a stain on a nation’s psyche which is<br />

difficult to heal. But the removal of this stain<br />

must come through forgiveness as well as justice<br />

or not at all. The road to peace is a two way<br />

street and this peace can only be established<br />

through compromise which will be perceived by<br />

both sides as unfavourable, but to reach some<br />

degree of political consensus between deeply<br />

unreconciled political perspectives, there must be<br />

a will to sacrifice small pieces for a greater gain.<br />

Two cars driving in different directions, although<br />

they may be on the same road, perceive entirely<br />

different backgrounds. It is the same road<br />

nonetheless. This is not only a metaphor but<br />

the reality of a perspective of two different


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

individuals or masses. The representatives from<br />

both side must try and see that they must make<br />

deep, brave and difficult compromises if they<br />

are to live socially and economically together on<br />

one very small island. There must be the will<br />

to forgive, to learn to live together, to learn to<br />

heal the past and the will to build a new future<br />

together. That future may not be an easy one,<br />

but the seeds of peace can now be planted in the<br />

hearts of both people. If these people who have<br />

come here, both to affirm and acknowledge a<br />

simple message, why not the politicians? Was it<br />

so difficult to stand in the middle of a checkpoint<br />

and affirm that war and violence cannot solve<br />

our problems? I respect their reasons, but I<br />

disagree. Perhaps the children who are our<br />

future can show us a better way, that a simple<br />

way is now and here. I believe a politician<br />

is a human being and I honour them all and<br />

all I asked of them was to enter that zone as<br />

human beings. A nobility of sentiment would<br />

not have disgraced them before the world. Life<br />

is both precious and sacred and to affirm this<br />

between two enemies is a brave and noble act.<br />

To affirm a message that war and violence will<br />

not solve our problems is good. <strong>Peace</strong> on earth<br />

will come when we forgive each other. There<br />

is a new world where there are no boundaries,<br />

nor frontiers. <strong>Peace</strong> on earth will come when<br />

we experience unity of our brotherhood, of<br />

humanity, above the divisions of nationality,<br />

religion, ideology, sex, colour and religion. For<br />

someone to divide us is to separate us from the<br />

peace. <strong>Peace</strong> on earth will come when in our<br />

hearts we feel we are all one people. <strong>Peace</strong> on<br />

earth will come when we know that one other’s<br />

pain is our pain. Then there is true compassion<br />

and when there is true compassion there is true<br />

justice. With true justice there can be peace on<br />

earth.’<br />

are part of a world tour of conflict hot spots<br />

carrying the message that war and violence<br />

cannot solve the problems of humanity. Ryan’s<br />

work has already been exhibited in Sarajevo,<br />

Kosovo and the Gaza Strip and after the <strong>Cyprus</strong><br />

event, Jerusalem will be the next stop, followed<br />

by northern Ireland. The Greek Cypriot coordinator<br />

of the event Nikos Anastasios told the<br />

Sunday Mail that a heroic effort was underway<br />

in Pegamus to erect the giant paintings under<br />

this downpour. Under these circumstances it’s<br />

very difficult he said. Today’s event, weather<br />

permitting, will start at 1pm and involves<br />

young people from both sides of the Green<br />

line. Anastasios said politicians from the two<br />

sides had also been invited to the event, but<br />

organisers had not received a response yet. He<br />

added that the north is undergoing a serious<br />

upheaval at the moment because of the general<br />

strike which began last Monday.<br />

‘No matter how many people come we want<br />

to make a statement’, Anastasios said. ‘In<br />

parallel with the exhibition a group of Greeks<br />

and Turkish Cypriots who have never met will<br />

spend a week in Pyle as part of the ongoing bicommunal<br />

event to bring young people together<br />

from both sides. This will be the sixth group to<br />

take part in the program’ said Anastasios who<br />

describes himself as being passionate on the<br />

concept of citizen peace keeping.<br />

In today’s exhibition one of the images shows<br />

the futility of war and it’s inability to solve the<br />

problems of humanity. The second represents<br />

harmony. Erecting these billboards in no<br />

man’s land within disputed frontiers promotes<br />

tolerance and encourages new dialogue between<br />

countries, the organisers say. The exhibition<br />

does not excel any ideology over another, but<br />

request the understanding of the worth of<br />

humanity above divisions.<br />

That is followed by Nikos’s speech. He talks<br />

about one drop of peace and another drop and it<br />

still doesn’t change and then another drop and<br />

then finally there is a complete change. And this<br />

is something that happens in chemistry. It is a<br />

reality. ‘Thank you Dominic Ryan for coming from<br />

Australia.’<br />

And it is strange the more I look back on this<br />

event the more beautiful it is, the more kind of<br />

special, more magical, the whole thing was and is.<br />

We received this article on the 12th.<br />

This was written in the local paper:<br />

‘<strong>Peace</strong> Group Battles the Weather for Pyle<br />

Rally. Two giant paintings were being erected<br />

by De Jean Christou . Two giant paintings were<br />

being erected at Pegamus Park in Pyle yesterday<br />

as part of the ceremony for peace to be held<br />

there today. The 7.6 by 25.6 metre paintings<br />

by Australian artist Dominic Ryan titled ‘We<br />

Have All Suffered Enough’ and ‘<strong>Peace</strong> on Earth’


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

It is finished and because it is finished there is<br />

the relief of completion, a relief, a sense that what<br />

we did, we succeeded against all odds. On some<br />

level, a small historical event took place even though<br />

few people came. In looking to the future I hope<br />

that we are able to manifest something that would<br />

be beautiful. We can only step towards the future<br />

and embrace it with open arms, with trust and<br />

hope.<br />

These is the final we words we shared:<br />

Rebecca: What did we do?<br />

Dominic: When I look back on it, it feels better,<br />

more successful now. Even when we had the event<br />

in Gaza it took us a while to realise the success.<br />

Rebecca: The impact.<br />

Dominic: Because when we are inside it and<br />

we can cannot see what is happening. It is only<br />

afterwards that it takes on a different emphasis.<br />

Rebecca: It was great fun. We met some<br />

interesting people. The place at Pyle was odd. We<br />

were a bit hesitant at first because it was windy and<br />

then it came through. It was one of the clearest days<br />

on the last three days before it was raining. But for<br />

me it was like a little London. But crossing over to<br />

the other side was the most interesting part. Like<br />

being in Jerusalem. Very different, but that kind of<br />

adventure. Mustafa was the coolest guy I have met<br />

in a long time. But we hung around the hotel a lot<br />

kind of waiting, waiting, waiting. Dominic typing,<br />

typing, typing with one finger. However he achieved<br />

it. We ate loads, we had the most amazing foods. I<br />

am giving you the abstract non-political stuff. And<br />

we met two sexy mayors who were very charming.<br />

Dominic: The two sexy mayors. Maybe we have<br />

an inter cut between the cabaret women and the<br />

two sexy mayors. Maybe we could have them doing<br />

their little sort of husky voice on the telephone.<br />

Rebecca: It was cool. What else did we do there?<br />

It felt like we were there for three months in some<br />

ways and then when we left it was, like, have I done<br />

much here? We shot about 45 hours of filming so we<br />

must have done something. But the camera became<br />

attached to me like it was just there all the time, so I<br />

didn’t really notice it.


M I N U T E S T O WA R : The Last Divided City<br />

Minutes to War<br />

The Diary of a Gonzo Diplomat<br />

1. Moscow 1994<br />

2. Sarajevo 1995<br />

3. Israel-Palestine 1997<br />

4. Kosovo-Albania 1999<br />

5. <strong>Cyprus</strong> <strong>2000</strong><br />

6. Qaliya 2001 - Jerusalem 2002<br />

7. The <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />

Seven Diaries by Dominic Ryan<br />

Edited by Christopher Race<br />

Graphic Design by Walter Ochoa -<br />

Leigh Woodburgess - Pat<br />

Photographs by Dominic Ryan - Daniel Rosenthal -<br />

Tycho Sierra - Deaudeaux - Firouz Malekzadeh<br />

-UN forces <strong>Cyprus</strong> & Madeline Garlick–Tahir Gambis<br />

© Dominic Ryan 2005<br />

This is an inhouse publication for private purposes only.<br />

The <strong>Peace</strong> <strong>Project</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!