13.07.2017 Views

Acne and Rosacea Charity Training Manual

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

A R A U K<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Rosacea</strong> Association UK


Module - 1<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> Pathogenesis


<strong>Acne</strong> - Pathogenesis<br />

The pathogenesis of acne is really very simple but new discoveries have demonstrated novel mechanisms that may improve our underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the disease<br />

<strong>and</strong> lead to better treatments.<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> is frequently a familial condition <strong>and</strong> severe or persistent acne may be seen in successive generations. It is a very common condition presenting a<br />

spectrum from very mild disease with a few comedones to fulminant nodulocystic acne. As it is so common, it is deemed by some to be almost physiological.<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> occurs in the pilosebaceous follicles which are present over the whole surface of the skin, apart from the palms <strong>and</strong> soles. It is a specific disease <strong>and</strong> is the<br />

commonest disease within the spectrum of the follicular occlusion syndrome which includes hidradenitis suppurativa <strong>and</strong> dissecting folliculitis.<br />

It is essential to underst<strong>and</strong> the pathogenesis of acne to be able to treat it properly. There are essentially 4 main steps in the pathway to inflammatory acne<br />

(Figure 1):<br />

1. Increased sebum secretion<br />

2. Follicular hypercornification with the development of the primary<br />

lesion of acne, the microcomedone<br />

3. Proliferation of the commensal anaerobic bacterium,<br />

Propioibacterium acnes<br />

4. Inflammation that is mediated by a T cell immunological<br />

mechanism<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> eventually resolves with the advent of development of immune<br />

tolerance to the agents that are inducing the inflammatory response.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Pilosebaceous unit – Anatomical structure comprising the hair follicle <strong>and</strong> attached sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong> with its exit onto the surface of the skin as the skin pore.<br />

• Hidradenitis suppurativa – An inflammatory condition affecting specific sites of the body – mainly axillae, groins <strong>and</strong> under the breasts in women - where the apocrine<br />

sweat gl<strong>and</strong> arises from the hair follicle above the sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>. Occlusion of the follicle leads to buildup of apocrine secretions which lead to deep inflammation <strong>and</strong><br />

scarring.<br />

• Dissecting folliculitis – Inflammatory condition of the pilosebceous unit in the scalp with multiple adjacent units becoming inflamed <strong>and</strong> the follicles rupture together to<br />

form deep inflamed lesions with sinuses onto the scalp<br />

• Hypercornifiaction – buildup of dead skin cells forming a partial blockage of the hair follicle<br />

• Anaerobic – an organism that grows in the absence of oxygen


Sebum excretion<br />

The sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong> is one of the first gl<strong>and</strong>s to become active in foetal development. It is mainly controlled by <strong>and</strong>rogens (male hormones) that after puberty are<br />

produced by the gonads <strong>and</strong> the adrenal gl<strong>and</strong>s. In foetal life, <strong>and</strong>rogens are derived from the maternal bloods supply <strong>and</strong> sebum produced solidifies as vernix<br />

caseosum in the newborn.<br />

Sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s gradually atrophy during infancy but in the infant sebum production is responsible for seborrheic dermatitis (cradle cap in the infant) <strong>and</strong><br />

neonatal acne. This stops in the second or third year of life.<br />

Sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s are stimulated with the onset of adrenarche which may occur as early as 9 years in girls. This is heralded by the onset of oily skin <strong>and</strong> the<br />

development of open comedones, particularly on the nose. With puberty, oil production increases <strong>and</strong> may lead to the onset of inflammatory acne. Ambient<br />

temperature may have an effect on sebum production <strong>and</strong> most people with acne notice that their skin is oilier when they go on a sunny holiday.<br />

With advancing age the oil gl<strong>and</strong> become less active <strong>and</strong> sebum production reduces. As sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s are holacrine gl<strong>and</strong>s – i.e. the sebaceous cells accumulate<br />

oil <strong>and</strong> the rupture <strong>and</strong> disgorge their contents into the hair follicle – as sebum production reduces, the cells accumulate <strong>and</strong> the gl<strong>and</strong>s get bigger. From being<br />

microscopic <strong>and</strong> not visible, they enlarge to become pale or slightly yellowish papules, often with a central dip – at this stage they are called sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong><br />

hyperplasia.<br />

In acne, sebum production is increased leading to an oily skin. This is generally the hallmark of acne. Some patients, however, have a combination skin, with areas of<br />

dryness <strong>and</strong> areas of oiliness.<br />

Oil production is controlled by <strong>and</strong>rogens but it is important to realize that in the majority of patients with acne, <strong>and</strong>rogen levels are normal. Increase oil production<br />

is due to an end organ response to the normal <strong>and</strong>rogen levels <strong>and</strong> is an integral part of the disease. In men, <strong>and</strong>rogen levels are always normal. In women, 30% may<br />

have elevated levels of free testosterone as part of the polycystic ovary syndrome.<br />

In addition to sebum levels being increased, the excess oil changes its normal constituents. <strong>Acne</strong> sebum is deficient in linoleic acid, an essential fatty acid, which may<br />

be responsible for some of the morphological changes seen in acne (see section 2).<br />

Glossary<br />

• Androgen – male hormone, initially produced as testosterone by the gonads <strong>and</strong> adrenal gl<strong>and</strong>s but this the converted to its more active form in the sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong> by the<br />

enzyme 5-α-reductase. Testosterone is held in an inactive form in the blood by a protein called sex hormone binding globulin<br />

• Adrenache – maturation of the adrenal gl<strong>and</strong>s which occurs before puberty<br />

• Polycystic ovary syndrome – ovaries develop multiple cysts <strong>and</strong> generate increased levels of testosterone or low levels of sex hormone binding globulin which means that<br />

more free/active testosterone is circulating. This syndrome may be manifest by increased weight gain, facial hirsutism <strong>and</strong> irregular periods.<br />

• Essential fatty acid – this is a fatty acid that the body cannot manufacture <strong>and</strong> must be acquired from dietary sources.


Follicular Hypercornification<br />

The ostium of the hair follicle or skin pore is lined with keratinocytes.<br />

Keratinocytes are the major cell of the epidermis <strong>and</strong> continually divide <strong>and</strong> as<br />

they push to the surface of the skin they mature to squames or dead skin cells<br />

(Figure 1), which are then shed <strong>and</strong> removed by the flow of oil. The hair follicle<br />

thus remains open allowing sebum to freely escape onto the surface of the<br />

skin.<br />

In acne, this changes with the cells growing abnormally <strong>and</strong> accumulating<br />

within the follicle leading to the formation of a partial blockage – the<br />

microcomedone. This is the primary lesion of acne <strong>and</strong> for successful<br />

treatment it is essential to target this lesion.<br />

Figure 1- Maturation of keratinocytes from pluripotent stem cells to<br />

dead squames which are shed.<br />

The development of the microcomedone has been extensively studied <strong>and</strong> two possible mechanisms have been suggested:<br />

1. The change in the growth of the keratinocyte is due to an immunological reaction, possibly due to the local production of interleukin (IL)1. Studies looking at<br />

isolated human pilosebaceous follicles stimulated with IL1. develop follicular hypercornification.<br />

2. The growth change in keratinocytes is the result of alteration in the constituents of sebum. In rats made deficient in linoleic acid, they develop follicular<br />

hypercornification. As stated before, the oil in sebum from acne sufferers is deficient in linoleic acid.<br />

The microcomedone is a time bomb, waiting to go off, <strong>and</strong> when it does the inflammatory lesion of acne develops. They are microscopic which means that when you<br />

target them, you need to treat the whole area of affected skin not just spots that you can see. With time, the blockages become bigger <strong>and</strong> visible. If they are close to the<br />

surface, oxidation of surface lipids leads to pigmentation – the black of the blackhead. If deeper in the follicle they bulge giving rise to the closed comedone.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Interleukin (IL)1. – Interleukins are chemical produced by a variety of cells, particularly those involved in immunological reactions. IL1 is produced by a number of cells<br />

including keratinocytes when they are stimulated by an immunological reaction.


Proliferation of P acnes<br />

P acnes is a normal commensal bacterium in the skin which resides in active pilosebaceous follicles. Everyone has this bacterium in the skin, whether you have<br />

spots or not. What causes the body’s immune system to react to it is not fully understood although there are a number of theories that have been proposed:<br />

1. It has been shown that T lymphocytes isolated from early acne lesions are reactive to P acnes. Why the immune system should react to P acnes in<br />

some people <strong>and</strong> not others have been a matter of debate. One possibility is that the milieu of the acne follicle with altered sebum constituents leads<br />

to a change in the surface antigens on the bacteria <strong>and</strong> induce the immunological reactivity.<br />

2. Keratinocytes express specific receptors called Toll-like receptors. These are analogous to the Toll receptor first identified in fruit flies or Drosophila.<br />

These receptors recognize highly conserved antigens on the surface of certain bacteria <strong>and</strong> this triggers an immunological response as part of the<br />

innate immune response to prevent infection. It has been shown that P acnes is recognized by Toll-like receptors in the skin <strong>and</strong> it has been suggested<br />

that this can lead to the inflammation seen in acne. Why this does not occur in everyone, as we all carry the bacterium, is up for further investigation.<br />

P acnes is an anaerobe, meaning that it grows in the absence of oxygen <strong>and</strong> is inhibited or killed by oxygen. The bacterium produces a protoporphyrin which<br />

fluoresces in polarized black light <strong>and</strong> can be used as a target with forms of light therapy (see Module 5)<br />

P acnes forms a biofilm, an amorphous goo that protects it from antibiotics <strong>and</strong> may contribute to follicular obstruction, contributing to the formation of the<br />

microcomedone.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Milieu – environment<br />

• Innate immune response – an ancient part of the immune system that reacts to infection <strong>and</strong> injury in a nonspecific manner <strong>and</strong> helps the body to prevent infection<br />

• Protoporphyrin – a complex chemical related to the protein involved in Haem synthesis. It is a potent photosensitizer <strong>and</strong> when excited with light of specific<br />

wavelengths, will lead to the production of free radicals <strong>and</strong> singlet oxygen, which are destructive


Inflammation<br />

The inflammatory response in acne is very specific. The initial inflammatory response leads to recruitment of neutrophils within the follicle which leads to pus<br />

formation.<br />

Studies, as discussed in section 3, have shown that T cells in early acne lesions are reactive to P acnes. A typical type 4 immunological response would lead to an<br />

eczematous reaction if on the surface of the skin or an itchy papule if deep in the skin, so the response in acne must lead to a specific cascade which induces the<br />

infiltration of neutrophils, possibly due to local production of cytokines.<br />

Stimulation of Toll-like receptors by P acnes could result in a pustular reaction but the unanswered question is why do people with acne respond in this way<br />

while people without acne who are still exposed to the bacterium do not?<br />

A number of early studies suggested that the breakdown of sebum into free fatty acids by P acnes could trigger an inflammatory response. But studies in which<br />

free fatty acids are injected into the skin have failed to demonstrate an inflammatory response.<br />

Morphological studies have shown rupture of follicles which would allow highly inflammatory constituents of the follicle to escape into the dermis where they<br />

could induce an acute inflammatory response.<br />

Summary<br />

Simplistically, in the acne sufferer, sebum production is abnormally high. Follicular hyperkeratosis restricts oil flow onto the surface of the skin with oil retained in<br />

the follicle which solidifies. This is the cheesy material that you squeeze out when you squeeze blackheads. Follicular occlusion leads to pooling of oil in the<br />

follicle which stimulates proliferation of P acnes <strong>and</strong> this leads to an inflammatory response with ultimate pus formation. The pus takes the path of least<br />

resistance <strong>and</strong> in most will point to the surface <strong>and</strong> bust onto the surface of the skin. If the inflammation is deeper in the follicle it may be retained within the<br />

follicle <strong>and</strong> slowly resolve leading to clinical nodules, or may rupture into the dermis with damage to collagen <strong>and</strong> eventual scarring. Cystic lesion result from<br />

fusion of adjacent inflamed follicles leading to lakes of pus with multiple heads.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Neutrophils – also known as polymorphs are white blood cells that will be induced to migrate into areas of inflammation or infection <strong>and</strong> lead to pus formation<br />

• Type 4 response – immunological reactions have been classified into 4 types – type 4 is where the immune system reacts to a local antigen with a response of T<br />

lymphocytes which leads to an eczema if it is on the surface of the skin or an itchy lump in the skin if it is deep in the skin.


<strong>Acne</strong> – Exacerbating factors<br />

A number of factors can lead to an exacerbation of acne or may induce the development of acne in a susceptible person:<br />

Hormonal changes<br />

The onset of acne frequently coincides with the onset of puberty, with the first bursts of <strong>and</strong>rogens comings from the gonads.<br />

In women, exacerbations are often seen premenstrually. As a woman comes up to the period, oestrogen levels fall. Oestrogen induces sex hormone binding<br />

globulin, which inactivates testosterone <strong>and</strong> has a direct anti-<strong>and</strong>rogen effect. The fall of oestrogen can thus lead to a flare of acne.<br />

Contraceptives<br />

All contraceptive drugs are based on progesterones with or without oestrogens. Second generation progesterones are the commonest used in contraceptives<br />

including oral <strong>and</strong> depot contraceptives <strong>and</strong> also present in the Mirena coil. Unfortunately, these progesterones have <strong>and</strong>rogenic properties <strong>and</strong> can<br />

exacerbate acne.<br />

In the acne prone woman, contraceptive containing third generation progesterones should be used. The third generation progesterones include desogestrel<br />

(contained in Marvalon) <strong>and</strong> norgestimate (present in Cliest).<br />

Two contraceptive pills contain progesterones that have anti-<strong>and</strong>rogenic effects. These contain cyproterone acetate (contained in Dianette) <strong>and</strong> drospirenone<br />

(contained in Yasmin). Drospirenone is less effective as an anti-<strong>and</strong>rogen than cyproterone acetate having only about 33% of the activity of cyproterone<br />

acetate. In the UK Dianette is not licensed as an oral contraceptive but only as an anti-acne treatment.


High humidity<br />

The comedone is formed in part by follicular hyper-cornification. The dead skin cells are a bit like dried<br />

leaves <strong>and</strong> with sweat retention against the skin, or high humidity, the cells can swell <strong>and</strong> lead to an<br />

acute blockage of the follicle <strong>and</strong> an intense inflammatory response. A major medical problem during<br />

the Vietnam War was fulminant, tropical acne. High humidity in Vietnam led to acute follicular<br />

occlusion in the young American GIs. Patients with acne should avoid saunas <strong>and</strong> steam rooms <strong>and</strong><br />

should be warned of the possibility of an exacerbation if they travel to the tropics.<br />

Stress<br />

Stress, whether physical or mental will stimulate the adrenal gl<strong>and</strong>, leading to production of<br />

adrenaline <strong>and</strong> steroids but also <strong>and</strong>rogens. This will lead to exacerbation of acne. This is frequently<br />

seen in students coming up to exams. Stress in the workplace has also been implicated in the<br />

development of acne in older women who have high powered stressful jobs.<br />

Unrecognized stress to the body may be responsible for exacerbation of acne in people who have a low<br />

level, non-clinical sensitivity to certain foods including gluten <strong>and</strong> lactose. It is not unusual for patients<br />

to report that when they go on a gluten or milk free diet their acne improves.<br />

Stress in modern life may also be responsible for the persistence of acne in older age groups.


Drugs<br />

A number of drugs may exacerbate acne. In some the mechanism of action is obvious, in others it is unknown.<br />

• Corticosteroids – steroids are widely used in medicine to reduce inflammation. In the<br />

non-acne individual, steroids can induce a follicular reaction called steroid acne (Figure<br />

2). This is not true acne as comedones are not present <strong>and</strong> the inflamed papules are<br />

fairly monomorphous. In the acne patient, steroids will exacerbate existing acne.<br />

• Anabolic steroids – these drugs are used by bodybuilders <strong>and</strong> athletes <strong>and</strong> have<br />

<strong>and</strong>rogenic properties. These can cause <strong>and</strong> exacerbate acne.<br />

• Second generation progesterones – see above section on oral contraceptives<br />

• Lithium – this drug used for bi-polar disease can cause a very severe exacerbation of<br />

acne leading to nodulocystic acne developing. The mechanism underlying thus is<br />

unknown.<br />

Figure 2 - Steroid acne due to oral prednisolone<br />

Figure 3 - Chloracne caused by Dioxin poisoning<br />

• Anti-convulsant drugs – all anti-epilepsy drugs can exacerbate acne which can be<br />

very difficult to manage. Mechanism behind this is unknown<br />

• Historically, bromides, iodides <strong>and</strong> other halogens have been associated with<br />

exacerbation of acne, partly by stimulating aggressive comedogenesis.<br />

• Halogenated hydrocarbons - In well documented industrial disasters, halogenated<br />

hydrocarbons such as chlorinated dioxins <strong>and</strong> dibenzofurans used in the<br />

manufacture of herbicides such as Agent Orange have been released into the<br />

atmosphere causing a severe form of acne called Chloracne. In 1949, 226 workers<br />

became ill after a container of herbicide exploded at a Monsanto Company plant<br />

in Nitro, West Virginia. [5] Many were diagnosed with chloracne (Figure 3).


Psychological impact of acne<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> is generally a very visible disease affecting the face <strong>and</strong> causing considerable psychological problems for the sufferer. The acne sufferer is often made to feel<br />

guilty about their skin <strong>and</strong> made to feel that it is their fault that they have the condition. This is perpetuated by a number of myths that surround acne:<br />

1. It is a teenage disease - clinical experience <strong>and</strong> recent publications have demonstrated that acne can persist throughout adult life <strong>and</strong> may occur for the first<br />

time in adult life, induced by stress. A recent publication of a population in the USA showed that the incidence of acne over 50 years of age was 15% in women<br />

<strong>and</strong> 7% in men (Figure 4). Adults with acne are often misdiagnosed as a skin infection or folliculitis <strong>and</strong> are embarrassed to have a ‘childhood’ disease.<br />

Figure 4<br />

J Am Acad Dermatol. 2008 Jan;58(1):56-9..<br />

The prevalence of acne in adults 20 years <strong>and</strong> older.<br />

Collier CN 1 , Harper JC, Cafardi JA, Cantrell WC, Wang W, Foster KW, Elewski BE


2 <strong>Acne</strong> is caused by poor diet, too much fried food <strong>and</strong> sweets - extensive studies in USA in children with acne have shown that the severity of acne<br />

correlated with only 2 dietary factors – high dairy <strong>and</strong> high sugar. Such diets induce the formation of a hormone called insulin like growth factor which<br />

has male hormone effects. Most people can eat a good balanced diet without problem. An occasional patient will report that giving up wheat or other<br />

food stuffs led to an improvement of their acne. In such individuals, a low-grade sensitivity to those food stuffs could induce a degree of stress which<br />

in turn will stimulate the adrenal gl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> lead to higher <strong>and</strong>rogen production (see section on stress)<br />

3 <strong>Acne</strong> is due to poor cleanliness - patients with acne often have oily skin <strong>and</strong> will wash excessively to get rid of this. This will often make the skin too<br />

sensitive for the use of the topical treatments they need to use. <strong>Acne</strong> sufferers should wash only twice a day. Blackheads are not caused by poor<br />

cleanliness or dirt.<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> can cause anxiety, depression, reclusiveness <strong>and</strong> suicidal ideation. It may be the cause of failure to achieve at school or university <strong>and</strong> has been<br />

shown to increase the risk of unemployment.<br />

Some patients with acne develop dysmorphophobia – an abnormal image of their body <strong>and</strong> the severity of their acne <strong>and</strong> even very mild acne will result<br />

in them not going to school or work <strong>and</strong> staying hidden at home.<br />

An unusual form of acne has been termed –‘acne excoriee des jeune filles’.<br />

This is predominantly seen in young women who are convinced that the<br />

cause of their acne is an abnormality deep in the skin <strong>and</strong> will pick <strong>and</strong><br />

excoriate the skin in an attempt to get rid of this abnormality <strong>and</strong> this leads<br />

to severe scarring of the skin (Figure 5). This can be very difficult to manage.<br />

All physicians treating acne should be aware <strong>and</strong> sensitive to the<br />

psychological impact that this disease can have on the sufferer. Referral for<br />

psychiatric evaluation should always be considered.<br />

Figure 5 – <strong>Acne</strong> excoriee des jeune filles


Module - 2<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> - Clinical


<strong>Acne</strong> – Clinical<br />

The clinical lesions of acne can be divided into non-inflammatory <strong>and</strong> inflammatory. All clinical lesions arise from the micro-comedone, which is the primary<br />

lesion of acne (see Module 1).<br />

Non-inflammatory lesions of acne<br />

Micro-comedones, as the name suggests are microscopic <strong>and</strong> are not clinically visible. These develop into open comedones – blackheads (Figure 1a), <strong>and</strong><br />

closed comedones – white heads (Figure 1b). In these lesions, the follicular cornification restricts oil flow to the surface with accumulation of sebum in the<br />

follicle solidifies <strong>and</strong> gives rise to the toothpaste like substance that you squeeze out with blackheads. Blockage of the skin pore is compounded by the<br />

formation of biofilm by P acnes.<br />

Figure 1a - Open Comedones<br />

Figure 1b - Mainly Closed Comedones <strong>and</strong> Papules<br />

Glossary<br />

• Biofilm – a matrix of extracellular polymeric substance produced by P acnes which sticks the bacteria together <strong>and</strong> to the follicular wall.


In some patients, comedones can be deep <strong>and</strong> so large that they totally<br />

obliterate the skin pore. These are called macro-comedones (Figure 2).<br />

These lesions do not respond to medical treatment <strong>and</strong> are often<br />

responsible for the deeper nodular inflammatory lesions of acne.<br />

Topical retinoids can loosen the blockage but the plug cannot get to<br />

the surface. The only way of getting rid of them is to lightly cauterize the<br />

surface of the skin which allows them to escape (see Module 4). Macrocomedones<br />

are a contraindication to oral isotretinoin as they have the<br />

potential to generate severe inflammatory lesions with the drug leading<br />

to scarring.<br />

Figure 2 – Macro-comedones<br />

On the nose, the follicles are different to the follicles on general<br />

glabrous skin often containing multiple hairs. With follicular hyper<br />

cornification, the multiple hairs compound the follicular blockage<br />

<strong>and</strong> blackheads are generally larger. This leads to a condition known<br />

as Trichostasis spinulosa (Figure 3). Cosmetically this causes<br />

problems <strong>and</strong> is more difficult to treat than normal comedones <strong>and</strong><br />

requires longer treatment with topical retinoids.<br />

Figure 3 Trichostasis spinulosa


Inflammatory <strong>Acne</strong><br />

The clinical lesions of inflammatory acne are analogous to the Staphylococcus aureus infection of the hair follicle. Superficial infections of the hair follicle with S<br />

aureus give rise to folliculitis with a superficial pustule developing which ruptures easily. In acne, superficial inflammatory lesions lead to papules <strong>and</strong> pustules<br />

(Figure 4). These are normally painless <strong>and</strong> resolve quickly. Comedones are always present (Figure 5).<br />

Figure 5 – Superficial Inflammatory <strong>Acne</strong> with Obvious<br />

Comedones<br />

Figure 4 – superficial inflammatory acne


With deeper lesion developing the deeper inflammatory lesions of acne<br />

are analogous to furuncles in S aureus infections. These nodular lesions<br />

are often painful <strong>and</strong> may last weeks before resolving. Some may not<br />

come to a head <strong>and</strong> the pus takes time to be absorbed by the immune<br />

system. Rupture of the follicle could lead to damage to collagen <strong>and</strong><br />

scarring (Figure 6)<br />

Figure 6 – Deeper inflammatory acne with some<br />

scarring<br />

Cystic acne develops when adjacent nodules rupture together<br />

analogous to a S aureus carbuncle. This leads to a large cavity<br />

under the skin that is full of pus with multiple heads representing<br />

the follicular openings. These are often persistent or recurrent<br />

<strong>and</strong> generally lead to scarring (Figure 7).<br />

Figure 7 – Multiple cysts with evidence of deep scarring


Skin changes depending of skin type<br />

In skin Phototype 2 <strong>and</strong> 3, acne will resolve to leave normal skin or scarring.<br />

However, in Phototype 1 skin, acne lesions may result in persistent<br />

erythematous macules which look like active disease. In the inflammatory<br />

process, cytokine cause vascular proliferation. In most individuals, the<br />

vessels are remodeled <strong>and</strong> cleared fairly quickly. However, in Phototype 1<br />

skin, the vessels may persist for many months. (Figure 8)<br />

Figure 8. Persistent erythematous macules with active<br />

papules <strong>and</strong> pustules making the acne look more severe<br />

In Phototype 5 <strong>and</strong> 6 skin, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation may<br />

follow an inflammatory spot. These hyper-pigmented macules can last<br />

for months or even years are some patients feel they are as bad as the<br />

active acne (Figure 9)<br />

Glossary<br />

Figure 9 – Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation in a patient with<br />

Phototype 6 skin with mild active acne<br />

• Phototype – this is a classification of human skin developed by an American Dermatologist called Fitzpatrick which describes the skin response to ultraviolet light. There<br />

are 6 Phototypes, Type 1 is the blond or redheaded Celt with freckles who burns in the sun; Type 6 is Afrocaribean skin.


Module - 3<br />

Conventional Treatments of <strong>Acne</strong>


Conventional treatment of acne<br />

As you will have learnt from module 1, acne can be divided into two parts:<br />

1. Follicular hypercornification leading to the formation of the micro-comedone <strong>and</strong> the non-inflammatory lesions of acne<br />

2. Inflammatory lesion of acne resulting from a type VI immunological reaction to proliferating P acnes<br />

In patients with predominantly non-inflammatory acne the main target is the follicular hypercornification. In the majority of patients, however, there is a mix of<br />

lesions <strong>and</strong> it is important to target both types of lesion.<br />

Non-inflammatory acne<br />

Follicular hypercornification is due to an abnormal growth of follicular keratinocytes leading to a partial blockage of the skin pore. The two main ways in which<br />

this can be treated are to correct the keratinocytes growth or to dissolve the blockage.


Topical retinoids<br />

Retinoids work by normalizing keratinocyte growth <strong>and</strong> are therefore used in conditions in which keratinocyte growth is abnormal. Systemic retinoids are use in<br />

psoriasis, the ichthyoses <strong>and</strong> acne. Topical retinoids are the agents generally used in acne.<br />

In the UK we have a limited number of topical retinoids <strong>and</strong> the majority of them are only available on prescription:<br />

0.1% isotretinoin – marketed as Isotrex gel or in combination with 2%erythromycin as Isotrexin<br />

gel.<br />

0.025% tretinoin – marketed with 4% erythromycin as Aknemycin plus lotion or with 1%<br />

clindamycin as Treclin gel. Retin A was discontinued some years ago but still can be<br />

purchased online.<br />

0.1%adapelene – marketed as Differin gel or cream or with 3% benzoyl peroxide marketed as<br />

Epiduo<br />

0.05% tretinoin is available on private prescriptions marketed Airol cream or Ketrel cream. Beware of on line products which may not have the same effect.


Topical Retinoids<br />

A topical retinoid should be an essential part of any anti-acne regime. They are potentially photosenistisers so should only be used at night <strong>and</strong> washed off in<br />

the morning. They may cause dryness <strong>and</strong> irritation of the skin – part of hyper-vitaminosis syndrome <strong>and</strong> must be used cautiously. A dollop the size of a pea is<br />

enough to cover the whole face. It is very important to instruct your patient how to use the retinoid properly <strong>and</strong> to use it to all parts of the body affected. It is<br />

really common to find a patient has been using the retinoid to the face but not chest, back, arms etc.<br />

Some patients have very sensitive skin <strong>and</strong> may not tolerate the topical retinoid, even when used properly. In such patients, try using it short contact. Apply for<br />

3 hours in the evening <strong>and</strong> wash off <strong>and</strong> moisturize.<br />

The worst skin type for topical retinoids tends to be Indian Asian skin <strong>and</strong> many patients in this ethnic group are unable to tolerate the retinoid even when used<br />

short contact.<br />

Topical retinoids should not be used in women who are trying to conceive or are pregnant. Vitamin A is teratogenic <strong>and</strong> could affect a developing foetus.<br />

Absorption of topical retinoids is minimal <strong>and</strong> the risk to the foetus is very small but women of child bearing age should be warned of this potential risk.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Photosensitiser – an agent that increases the sensitivity of the skin to sunlight leading to an exaggerated sunburn reaction<br />

• Teratogenic – causing birth defects in a developing foetus


Alternative agents for non-inflammatory lesions of acne<br />

Salicylic acid<br />

Salicylic acid is keratolytic i.e. it dissolves keratin <strong>and</strong> can help to clear follicular blockage. It is usually available as a 2% product in washes<br />

<strong>and</strong> gels. Always warn patients to try it in a test area first as salicylic acid is a sensitizer <strong>and</strong> allergy to salicylic acid is not uncommon.<br />

Azeleic acid<br />

Azeleic acid is available as a 20% cream (Skinoren cream) marketed for the<br />

treatment of acne or as a 15% cream (Finacea cream) marketed for the treatment<br />

of rosacea. Azeleic acid is comedolytic so can help to unseat comedones but is<br />

not as effective as a topical retinoid. It does have some anti-inflammatory activity<br />

so will treat inflammatory lesions of acne as well. It can be irritant so patients<br />

should be warned to use it with caution.<br />

Benzoyl Peroxide<br />

Benzoyl peroxide has very mild comedolytic activity which is not sufficient on its own to treat non-inflammatory acne.


Tebiskin OSK <strong>and</strong> UV OSK (clinic version of retail <strong>and</strong> prescription Aknicare Lotion <strong>and</strong> Cream)<br />

These products contains triethyl citrate <strong>and</strong> ethyl linoleate in a formulation that contains a number of other active ingredients including 0.5% salicylic acid. Aknicare is<br />

available on prescription <strong>and</strong> can also be purchased over the counter or on line. Tebiskin OSK is the stronger private clinic only medical device range with greater antiinflammatory<br />

activity <strong>and</strong> a higher concentration of the key active ingredients<br />

It works in two ways, the first activity is on hyper-cornification <strong>and</strong> secondly it has a an antimicrobial action on P acnes without using antibiotics<br />

1. As you will have learnt from Module 1, one possible mechanism for the development of the follicular hyper-cornification is a relative deficiency of acne sebum of<br />

linoleic acid. OSK/Aknicare preparations increase linoleic acid concentrations in the follicle <strong>and</strong> thus suppress follicular hyper-cornification. Ethyl lineolate which<br />

is digested by follicular bacteria <strong>and</strong> cutaneous enzymes into linoleic acid which can influence skin sensitivity to di-hydro-testosterone a key trigger of the acne<br />

process.<br />

2. Antimicrobial effect. Bacteria in the blocked follicle release enzymes to break down sebum to glycerol which they absorb as nutrient <strong>and</strong> the remaining free fatty<br />

acids left from the enzyme breakdown exacerbate the immune response <strong>and</strong> inflammation. Also the bacteria congregate together for protection into a biofilm<br />

which makes them more resistant to the body’s defense mechanisms <strong>and</strong> also to antibiotics designed to reduce or eradicate them. OSK/Aknicare utilises triethyl<br />

citrate which is a preferential substrate for the bacterial enzyme (lipase). This means the bacterial enzyme (lipase) has a greater affinity to triethyl citrate hydrolysis<br />

than for sebum hydrolysis. This has three effects<br />

a. Glycerol availability is reduced (bacteria receive no nutrients) <strong>and</strong> sebum triglycerides remain intact.<br />

b. Free fatty acid levels are reduced helping to control inflammation<br />

c. The bacterial enzyme breaks down triethyl citrate sequentially into three molecules of citric acid. This lowers the pH in a sustained way in the follicle to a<br />

level which kills the bacteria. The bacteria are more protected when enclosed in a biofilm, but OSK/Aknicare also contains a special peptide (GT Peptide)<br />

which opens channels into the biofilm allowing the citric acid to also<br />

kill the bacteria effectively within the biofilm <strong>and</strong> rapidly.<br />

OSK/Aknicare products can be used in patients who are unable to tolerate topical retinoids or can be<br />

used with topical retinoids – using the retinoid at night <strong>and</strong> OSK/Aknicare in the morning. It is safe to<br />

use during conception <strong>and</strong> pregnancy.


Inflammatory acne<br />

In mild to moderate acne, start with topical agents which can be very effective. In all patients apart from those with mild acne, always combine treatment<br />

with a topical retinoid or other anti-comedonal treatment.<br />

Topical treatment for inflammatory acne<br />

Benzoyl peroxide<br />

Benzoyl peroxide is used commercially to bleach flour. When applied to the skin it will enter the hair follicle <strong>and</strong> release oxygen. This is toxic<br />

to the anaerobic bacteria living in the follicle including P acnes <strong>and</strong> kills them. It is a very effective treatment for inflammatory acne <strong>and</strong> the<br />

bacteria cannot develop resistance to it.<br />

Benzoyl peroxide is available in a number of different formulations from 2.5% to 10% in creams, gels <strong>and</strong> washes. It can be applied in the<br />

morning to affected areas. It is very effective but does have a number of problems:<br />

1. It is a bleaching agent <strong>and</strong> will bleach clothes, towels <strong>and</strong> bedding. Warn patients of this <strong>and</strong> advise to use white towels <strong>and</strong> white<br />

pillowcases. If used on the trunk, white T-shirts<br />

2. Benzoyl peroxide can be very drying <strong>and</strong> irritating. Some patients can only tolerate the lower concentrations. Advise care when using<br />

benzoyl peroxide washes as they may make the skin too sensitive to use topical retinoids or other topical products.<br />

3. Benzoyl peroxide is a sensitizer <strong>and</strong> patients may become allergic to it. Tell patients to use to a test area for a few days before using it<br />

all over.<br />

Benzoyl peroxide is also available in combination with adaplene (marketed as Epiduo, 0.1% adapalene with 3% benzoyl peroxide), targeting<br />

inflammatory <strong>and</strong> non-inflammatory lesions at the same time.<br />

A number of the benzoyl peroxide products came off the shelves due to manufacturing problems. Thankfully, they are now available on<br />

prescription <strong>and</strong> over the counter.


Topical antibiotics<br />

The main topical antibiotics used in acne are erythromycin <strong>and</strong> clindamycin. Both are very effective in treating inflammatory acne but the development of<br />

antibiotic drug resistance may limit their usefulness.<br />

Clindamycin<br />

Clindamycin is available in a number of preparations:<br />

1% alcoholic solution or lotion (marketed as Dalacin T) was the first topical antibiotic used in<br />

acne. Usefulness is now limited by high antibiotic drug resistance.<br />

1% clindamycin available as a gel with 3% or 5% benzoyl peroxide (marketed as Duac 3% or<br />

5%). The benzoyl peroxide limits antibiotic drug resistance <strong>and</strong> will kill resistant bacteria.<br />

Problems may occur with benzoyl peroxide as detailed on section of benzoyl peroxide<br />

1% clindamycin with 1.2% zinc gel (marketed as Zindaclin gel). Zinc is supposed to reduce<br />

drug resistance .Useful for treatment of the trunk or in patients where benzoyl peroxide needs<br />

to be avoided.<br />

1% clindamycin with 0.025% tretinoin (marketed as Treclin gel), this is a useful combination targeting inflammatory <strong>and</strong> non-inflammatory<br />

lesions.


Erythromycin<br />

Erythromycin is available in a number of preparations:<br />

2% alcoholic solution (marketed as Steimycin), there are now issue with this solution due to antibiotic drug resistance.<br />

4% alcoholic solution with 1.2% zinc (marketed as Zineryt lotion). The high concentration of erythromycin gives<br />

good results in inflammatory lesions.<br />

2% erythromycin is also available with 0.1% isotretinoin (marketed as Isotrexin) where the antibiotic reduces the irritancy of the retinoid <strong>and</strong><br />

targets inflammatory <strong>and</strong> non-inflammatory lesions at the same time.


Alternative topical therapy<br />

Tebiskin OSK <strong>and</strong> UV OSK (clinic version of retail <strong>and</strong> prescription Aknicare Lotion <strong>and</strong> Cream) are also indicated in the<br />

treatment of inflammatory acne<br />

This preparation contains triethyl citrate <strong>and</strong> ethyl linolate in a carrier base that has a number of additional active ingredients. The triethyl citrate is<br />

digested by follicular bacteria to diethyl citrate, monoethyl citrate <strong>and</strong> then to citric acid. This lowers the pH in the follicle which inhibits bacterial growth<br />

<strong>and</strong> inhibits 5a-reductase, which in turn reduced sebum secretion.<br />

The ethyl linolate is digested to linoleic acid which reduces follicular hypercornification <strong>and</strong> also has potent anti-inflammatory properties.<br />

This product thus has anti-bacterial <strong>and</strong> anti-inflammatory effects <strong>and</strong> can reduce sebum production. It is well tolerated <strong>and</strong> a spray preparation is<br />

available for use on back <strong>and</strong> chest.<br />

See previous information in this section for more detail<br />

Nicotinamide<br />

This product was initially marketed as Papulex gel, then relaunched as Nicam gel <strong>and</strong> an OTC product is now<br />

available as Freederm gel. It is anti-inflammatory <strong>and</strong> has its main effect on inflammatory lesions. Initial studies<br />

showed that its efficacy was similar to benzoyl peroxide.


Systemic Antibiotics<br />

Tetracyclines<br />

The tetracyclines are the most commonly used antibiotics in acne. They have good activity against P acnes <strong>and</strong> have<br />

potent ant-inflammatory activity. All tetracyclines can photosenitise but in practice, this is only a problem with<br />

doxycycline, where 25% of patients can develop a significant photosensitization. A rare side effect of tetracyclines is<br />

benign intracranial hypertension – this presents with severe headaches <strong>and</strong> the drug should be stopped immediately.<br />

Tetracycline will colour developing secondary dentition <strong>and</strong> should be avoided in children under the age of 13 years.<br />

Oxytetracycline –dose 250mg QDS. This is the most commonly used tetracycline as it is the cheapest. It has a half-life of 8 hours <strong>and</strong> thus should be used<br />

QDS <strong>and</strong> it is inhibited by food in the stomach, so should be taken on an empty stomach <strong>and</strong> the patient instructed not to eat for 1 hours after taking it. In<br />

my experience, this makes it almost impossible to take properly.<br />

Lymecycline – dose 408mg OD or BD. This tetracycline is has a long half-life <strong>and</strong> is not affected by food in the stomach. The manufacturer suggests a once<br />

daily dose but I find a BD dose more effective. Once clearance has been achieved, the dose can be reduced.<br />

Doxycycline – dose 100mg OD. This drug has a long half-life <strong>and</strong> is not affected by food in the stomach. 25% of patients may develop significant<br />

photosensitivity. The capsule of Doxycycline is very sticky <strong>and</strong> patients must be warned to take it with food <strong>and</strong> not just with a swallow of water. It can<br />

adhere to the lining of the esophagus <strong>and</strong> cause a painful burn. One of my patients was hospitalized for 3 days following esophageal ulceration caused by<br />

doxycycline.<br />

Minocycline – dose 100mg OD. Minocycline was a very popular drug in acne as it had a long half-life <strong>and</strong> was not<br />

inhibited by food in the stomach. There have been reports of a rare side effect – lupus like syndrome with severe<br />

arthropathy <strong>and</strong> hepatotoxicity has now limited its use. It is still a very effective drug but if used long term, patients<br />

should be tested for ANA. If used long term, minocycline can be deposited as a complex with melanin in scarred areas<br />

leaving a bluish pigmentation. If this occurs the drug should be stopped immediately otherwise the pigmentation may<br />

become permanent.<br />

Minocycline pigmentation


Macrolide antibiotics<br />

Erythromycin – dose 250mg QDS. This is possibly the second most commonly prescribed antibiotic in acne. It has a very short half-life of 2.5 hours <strong>and</strong><br />

should be taken QDS <strong>and</strong> it is inhibited by carbohydrate in the stomach so should be taken on an empty stomach. It is, however, a gastric irritant <strong>and</strong> may<br />

not be tolerated if taken properly. It is the only antibiotic that can safely be taken in a woman who is trying to conceive or who is pregnant.<br />

Clarithromycin – dose 250 – 500mg BD. This is a much better macrolide with a longer half-life than erythromycin <strong>and</strong> causes less gastric irritation<br />

Trimethoprim<br />

Trimethoprim – dose 200 – 300mg BD. This is a very good second line antibiotics for acne <strong>and</strong> has the advantage of working very quickly. It can be taken<br />

with food <strong>and</strong> is generally well tolerated. A drug rash may occasionally occur – starts about 10 days after starting the drug <strong>and</strong> presents as an itchy<br />

exanthema. The drug should be stopped immediately <strong>and</strong> the rash treated with mild topical steroids or calamine lotion. It settles after a few days.<br />

Occasionally, dermatologist will use clindamycin (dose 150mg BD) or rifampicin (does 150mg BD) in severe acne,<br />

not responsive to conventional antibiotics.<br />

Trimethoprim induced drug rash<br />

Other systemic antibiotics


Hormonal therapy in women<br />

In women with severe acne, not responding to conventional antibiotics with a topical retinoid, hormonal therapy may be indicated. This may be due to<br />

polycystic ovarian syndrome where women produce excess free testosterone which may lead to severe <strong>and</strong> or persistent acne.<br />

Dianette<br />

Dianette is licensed for the treatment of acne but is also an effective oral contraceptive agent. The oestrogen, ethyl-oestradiol will increase sex hormone<br />

binding globulin which will bind to <strong>and</strong> inactivate testosterone. The progesterone, cyproterone acetate, inhibits 5-reductase <strong>and</strong> inhibits the activation<br />

of testosterone to di-hydro-testosterone in the sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>. It is successful in treating acne in about 40% of women but due to increased risk of<br />

thromboembolic phenomenon, should be used only short term i.e. 6 months. It has a number of side effects <strong>and</strong> is not well tolerated by some women.<br />

In practice, Dianette is poorly used <strong>and</strong> is often given as a contraceptive agent in women who have acne of any severity <strong>and</strong> often continued for years. A<br />

major problem is that acne will often flare significantly 2-3 months after the drug is stopped.<br />

Yasmin<br />

Yasmin is marketed as an oral contraceptive but is often given to women who have acne. The oestrogen is the same as Dianette but the progesterone is<br />

drospirenone, an analogue of spironolactone, which amongst other anti-<strong>and</strong>rogenic effects, inhibits 5-reductase. In practice, it is not as effective in<br />

treating acne as Dianette <strong>and</strong> may have the same problem of rebound of acne after treatment is stopped.


Spironolactone<br />

Spironolactone is a loop diuretic. It antagonizes the <strong>and</strong>rogen receptor, inhibits 5a-reductase <strong>and</strong> has anti-<strong>and</strong>rogen effects. Prior to the<br />

advent of antibiotics it was commonly used to treat acne in women.<br />

In the older woman it can be a very effective drug, reducing sebum production <strong>and</strong> controlling acne. It should be used at 100 to 200mg daily. I<br />

find it very useful in younger women who have significant premenstrual exacerbations of their acne. 100mg daily for the 7 days before their<br />

period can be effective in preventing this flare.<br />

Spironolactone can affect the menstrual cycle giving very short cycles, spotting between periods <strong>and</strong> even amenorrhea. It should not be used<br />

in women who are trying to conceive as they could affect a developing male foetus.<br />

Dapsone<br />

Dapsone is a suphone antibiotic which has potent anti-inflammatory action against polymorphs <strong>and</strong> thus inhibit pus formation. It is commonly use for the<br />

treatment of leprosy in combination with other antibiotics. In dermatology, it is generally use in condition in which activated polymorphs play an<br />

important role – dermatitis herpetiformis <strong>and</strong> vasculitis.<br />

It can be very useful in acne, used at 50mg/day, suppressing inflammation, particularly deep seated nodules <strong>and</strong> cysts. I generally use it in combination<br />

with other antibiotics.<br />

In patients with glucose-6 -phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency, it may cause haemolysis <strong>and</strong> anaemia <strong>and</strong> patients should be tested for this before<br />

given the drug.


Oral Isotretinoin<br />

Oral isotretinoin is the most powerful drug we have for the treatment of acne. It reduces sebum production by up to 90%, normalizes keratinocyte growth so clears<br />

follicular hyper-cornification, kills P acnes <strong>and</strong> has powerful anti-inflammatory effects. It thus is the only drug that targets the 4 principal pathological changes in<br />

acne.<br />

It is generally started at a dose of 0.5mg/kg/day for the first month <strong>and</strong> then increased to 1mg/kg/day until the skin is clear. Early studies showed that a cumulative<br />

dose of 120mg/kg i.e. 1mg/kg/day for 4 months, reduced the risk of recurrence after stopping the drug. This had led to the misconception that the drug should only<br />

be used for 4 months which is wrong. It should be used for at least 4 months even if the skin is clear, but should be used until the skin is totally clear of spots, which<br />

in some patients may be 9 months or more.<br />

In some patients, there can be a flare of acne in the first month of treatment, <strong>and</strong> if patients have particularly inflammatory acne, it is often started with a course of<br />

systemic prednisolone or systemic antibiotics for the first month.<br />

Isotretinoin is potentially hepatotoxic <strong>and</strong> can elevated serum triglycerides. It is also diabetogenic. Baseline blood tests must be performed on all patients <strong>and</strong><br />

repeated every month – these include:<br />

• Full blood count<br />

• Electrolytes <strong>and</strong> urea<br />

• Liver function tests<br />

• Fasting lipids <strong>and</strong> glucose<br />

If liver functions are abnormal, the drug should be avoided. If lipids are high, patients should be put onto a low-fat diet <strong>and</strong> the fasting lipids carefully monitored.<br />

Oral isotretinoin is a potent teratogen <strong>and</strong> women of childbearing age should be warned that they cannot get pregnant while on the drug or for 1 month after<br />

stopping. An EU directive means that women of childbearing age can only be prescribed 4 weeks treatment at a time <strong>and</strong> must have a negative pregnancy test<br />

before a further prescription can be given.<br />

Symptomatic side effects are universal <strong>and</strong> all patients should be warned about them:<br />

1. Cheilitis which may be severe- lip balms <strong>and</strong> Vaseline<br />

2. Dry skin which may become eczematised – lots of moisturisers<br />

3. Dry eyes may occur – avoid the use of contact lenses <strong>and</strong> use artificial tears<br />

4. Myalgia <strong>and</strong> arthropathy –if these occur reduce exercise<br />

5. Nose bleeds – apply Vaseline to nares<br />

6. Photosenisitivity – occurs in about 25% of patients <strong>and</strong> can be severe <strong>and</strong> SPF 50+<br />

sunblocks should be used<br />

Severe cheilitis in a patient on Roaccutane<br />

Rare or unusual side effects


Glossary<br />

Other side effects<br />

Concentration<br />

Oral isotretinoin can impair concentration so should be avoided in patients studying for exams<br />

Night blindness<br />

This may be of major importance in patients who are pilots as they may not be able to fly while on the drug <strong>and</strong> there is legislation in the USA<br />

that if you have ever had oral isotretinoin that you are prohibited from flying<br />

Severe depression <strong>and</strong> suicide<br />

This is a rare side effect but is now well documented. The effects start after about 4 week of treatment <strong>and</strong> will occur in patients with no past<br />

history of depression. Suicides have been documented in these patients <strong>and</strong> the depression seems to persist even when the drug is<br />

withdrawn.<br />

Fatigue syndrome<br />

Is a very rare side effect which seems to start about 4 weeks after starting the drug. It mimics ME <strong>and</strong> may well be ME that is in some way<br />

precipitated by the isotretinoin. It does not improve when the drug is stopped.<br />

Acute schizophrenia<br />

This is a very rare side effect of isotretinoin <strong>and</strong> comes on fairly quickly after the drug has started. It generally affects young men <strong>and</strong> there has<br />

been an argument that the occurrence is only coincidental.<br />

Persistent symptomatic side effects<br />

An early paper suggested that persistent, symptomatic side effects affected up to 10% of patients treated with oral isotretinoin <strong>and</strong> were mild.<br />

This may present with generally dry skin which needs regular moisturizing or persistently dry lips or eyes. I have certainly treated patients who<br />

have suffered severe chronic cheilitis for 7-8 years after oral isotretinoin. In such patients, normal oil production on the skin does not turn<br />

back on.<br />

• Myalgia – muscle pains • Cheilitis – inflammation of the lips


Module - 4<br />

Additional Treatments of <strong>Acne</strong>


Peels<br />

A number of peels are available for use in the acne patient. Most have their effect by their keratolytic action, removing the<br />

top dead skin layers of the skin <strong>and</strong> unseating comedones <strong>and</strong> freeing the flow of sebum <strong>and</strong> reducing the occurrence of<br />

inflammatory lesions.<br />

The Enerpeel range is very useful as these peels are very easy to use <strong>and</strong> have been shown to be effective.


Salicylic Acid Peel (Enerpeel SA)<br />

Enerpeel is a carrier system whereby carrier molecules attach to the acid molecules rendering them inactive <strong>and</strong> there is no water in the Enerpeel vials.<br />

This allows the addition of acne treatment ingredients in this case, but other ingredients can be added to the other peels depending on their focus.<br />

This particular peel delivers a 30% salicylic acid <strong>and</strong> the carrier releases the acid in <strong>and</strong> on the<br />

stratum corneum. The skin if first cleaned with surface lipid dissolving wipe which allows the peel<br />

to better ‘engage’ with the skin when the peel is applied with an applicator brush which attaches<br />

directly to the end of the Enerpeel vial. There is usually some stinging which is noticed about 30<br />

seconds post application. This continues for up to 2 minutes <strong>and</strong> then fades away as the salicylic<br />

acid converts to an analgesic powder. The peel is left for 5 minutes <strong>and</strong> then removed using a<br />

remover wipe.<br />

Skin following Enerpeel SA application<br />

powder present on the skin<br />

The other key ingredients are carried into the blocked sebaceous duct where the P acnes bacteria have colonised. These ingredients are the same as<br />

found in OSK/Aknicare <strong>and</strong> therefore the peel acts like a loading dose of the key antibacterial <strong>and</strong> anti-inflammatory properties of the creams. The creams<br />

are used b.d. between the peels, which are normally repeated four times with a gap between peels of between two to four weeks<br />

Elegant studies have shown that after treatment there is a significant reduction of the stratum corneum <strong>and</strong> removal of comedones. There is no real down<br />

time - some dryness the next day although the associated Tebiskin OSK UV or Aknicare Cream are designed to counter that. If there is a significant build-up<br />

of dead skin on the surface, some area may become white <strong>and</strong> this will persist for an hour or so.<br />

Always take a history of salicylic acid sensitivity <strong>and</strong> avoid use in these patients.


Pyruvic Acid Peel (Enerpeel PA)<br />

Pyruvic acid is an alpha keto acid <strong>and</strong> so has different properties to alpha <strong>and</strong> beta hydroxyl acids. It interacts with the skin <strong>and</strong> causes less irritation<br />

compared with say a comparable strength glycolic acid. Also as it is lipophilic like salicylic <strong>and</strong> also has a sebum slowing effect again like salicylic <strong>and</strong> so<br />

will penetrate into blocked pilo-sebaceous ducts. It is also the alternative acne treatment for those allergic to salicylic acid - aspirin. Last but not least it is<br />

more skin penetrating than salicylic <strong>and</strong> so is more skin remodelling <strong>and</strong> is very useful for post acne oiliness <strong>and</strong> superficial post acne damage <strong>and</strong> scars.<br />

This peel is very useful if the patient has very oily skin with a lot of congestion. After application it is left for 3 minutes for one layer. The clinician can apply<br />

another layer for a further 2 minutes taking the total exposure time to 5 minutes, but this will also increase discomfort <strong>and</strong> for many one three minute layer<br />

is adequate. This peel should always be neutralised <strong>and</strong> because of the Enerpeel carriers taking the peel deeper into the skin than with a normal peel it is<br />

recommended that the skin is quenched with an Enerpeel neutralizer wipe which contains a 12% arginine solution (amino acid) which leads to a chemical<br />

reaction <strong>and</strong> a steam like cloud coming off the skin, but with no heat. If left too long, there can be significant desquamation. Arginine can also be<br />

combined with the Enerpeel carrier <strong>and</strong> so this neutraliser will ‘hunt down’ the acid, whereas a bicarbonate of soda style neutraliser will only act<br />

superficially.


Jessners Peel (Enerpeel JR)<br />

Jessners based peels contain salicylic acid <strong>and</strong> so can also assist in the management of post acne oiliness but the two other ingredients of lactic acid <strong>and</strong><br />

resorcinol can impact upon hyper pigmentation by interfering with the melanin production. This peel is applied for five minutes <strong>and</strong> then a remover wipe,<br />

not a neutralizer is used to remove the salicylic acid powder from the surface, while leaving the lactic acid <strong>and</strong> resorcinol to continue to target the<br />

pigmentation. There are creams such as Tebiskin Lightening Cream which also contain versions of resorcinol <strong>and</strong> other ingredients to continuously work<br />

to suppress pigment production <strong>and</strong> these creams have shown comparable efficacy to 4% hydroquinone.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Melanin – skin pigment produced by melanocytes in the epidermis involving the enzyme tyrosinase. Melanin production is increased by ultraviolet light<br />

exposure <strong>and</strong> by inflammation in the skin.<br />

• Hydroquinone – is a powerful reducing agent used medically to whiten the skin


Treatment of Macrocomedones<br />

Macrocomedones are deep seated comedones that have become so big that they have obliterated the skin ‘pore’. They do<br />

not respond to topical retinoids as even if the retinoid loosens the blockage, it cannot get out of the follicle. They are a<br />

potential contraindication to systemic retinoids as they may develop into deep cystic, inflammatory lesions.<br />

Macrocomedones are treated by light cautery to the skin above the lesions using a hyfrecator at level 2-3. This leaves a<br />

pinpoint scab that falls off after a few days, carrying the macrocomedone with it.<br />

Treatment of Cystic Lesions<br />

Cysts in acne can last for several weeks <strong>and</strong> are painful <strong>and</strong> disfiguring. An intra-lesions steroid injection will help to resolve this more quickly. Use a fixedneedle,<br />

diabetic syringe <strong>and</strong> Depomedrone – 40mg/ml. It is important not to inject too much into the cyst as this could lead to skin atrophy <strong>and</strong> a<br />

depressed area of skin/ scar. Inject until there is slight blanching of the lesion. If the cyst is very large, try to evacuate some of the pus using a syringe <strong>and</strong><br />

needle before injecting the steroid into it.


Light <strong>and</strong> Laser Treatment<br />

Sunlight<br />

Most patient say that their acne is better after a hot sunny holiday. Occasionally, patient holidaying in a hot humid environment may get an exacerbation<br />

of their acne (see high humidity in Module 1).<br />

Ultraviolet (UV) light will provide a sun tan, which will have a cosmetic effect on the skin. In vitro, UV will inhibit the growth of P acnes <strong>and</strong> will suppress the<br />

immune function on the skin, so it should have an effect on acne. However, studies in the 1970’s showed that UV light had no effect on tar induced<br />

comedones <strong>and</strong> a clinical study showed little effect of UV light on inflammatory acne. Historically, UV light was used in acne but poor results resulted in<br />

loss of interest <strong>and</strong> it is no longer used.<br />

Blue Light<br />

Blue light at 440 nm has been used to treat acne with some success. P acne contains protophorphyrins (see Proliferation of P acnes in Module 1) which<br />

can be excited by light at 440 nm resulting in release of free radicles which will kill the bacteria. Initial studies by Meffert H et al in Berlin in the late 80’s<br />

using a blue light-type high pressure lamp<br />

Small studies showed improvement in acne <strong>and</strong> reduction of acne lesions following treatment with blue light but as this works as an anti-bacterial agent,<br />

it needs to be used on a daily basis.<br />

Red <strong>and</strong> Blue Light<br />

In 2000, we published the results of a trial using strip lights producing light at 440 nm (blue light) <strong>and</strong> 66 nm (red light). The hypothesis was that the blue<br />

light would kill bacteria <strong>and</strong> the red light would suppress inflammation <strong>and</strong> aid healing. The results showed that the treatment was effective with 65%<br />

patients achieving a marked improvement of their inflammatory acne.<br />

The main problem was compliance. Patient had to sit with goggles on in front the unit for 5 minutes every day – which a number of our younger patients<br />

found very difficult. A commercial unit was produced but may no longer be available.


Red <strong>and</strong> Blue LEDs<br />

Omnilux have developed red <strong>and</strong> blue LED systems for the treatment of acne which require twice weekly treatment in a clinic.<br />

Small studies have shown good efficacy<br />

Photodynamic therapy<br />

This involves the application of topical 5-aminolaevulinic acid as a photosensitizer. This is cconcentrated in sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s.<br />

The skin is then Illuminated with coherent or laser light with the reduction of reactive oxygen species which destroy P acnes <strong>and</strong> alter sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong><br />

function. This is a painful procedure <strong>and</strong> results in a severe inflammatory reaction in the skin which can last for up to 2 weeks.<br />

Severe inflammatory reaction following<br />

PDT for acne


Lasers<br />

1450 nm Laser with Cooling Spray<br />

Study published in 2002 showed the effect of 1450nm (mid infra-red) laser/ cooling spray in treating truncal acne. Initial animal studies suggested that<br />

the laser would cause short term disruption <strong>and</strong> rupture of sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s. Patients were given 4 treatments over 3 weeks, follow up for 24 weeks.<br />

Results showed a statistically significant reduction in number of inflammatory lesions compared to control.<br />

NLite (Regenlite) Laser – 585nm Pulsed Dye<br />

Laser This is a pulse Dye Laser with unique features. It is excellent in its vascular mode to destroy blood vessels but has additional important<br />

medical properties which provide treatment for a range of inflammatory dermatoses – Bio stimulation.<br />

Its unique features are due to the immediate energy rise with the start of the pulse, which is very different to most pulse dye lasers.<br />

Unique pulse of the NLite/Regenlite laser compared to conventional pulse dye<br />

lasers


The NLite also differs from most pulsed dye lasers in being 585nm as opposed to the normal 595 nm. This leads to 300% more absorption by its target,<br />

oxyhaemaglobin<br />

Graph showing absorption of different light wavelengths by oxyhaemaglobin<br />

A clinical study by out group in 2002 <strong>and</strong> published in the Lancet showed the effectiveness of a single treatment of the face with the NLite laser with follow<br />

up for 3 months during which time no other treatment was allowed. Results showed a fall of 2 grades using the Leeds grading system by the end of the<br />

study.<br />

We have continued to use the NLite laser as monotherapy or in combination with conventional therapy for the last 15 years with good effect.


Scientific studies have shown that the NLite laser has no effects on bacterial numbers in the skin <strong>and</strong> no effect on sebum production. A single treatment,<br />

however, increases local production of transforming growth factor (TGF)by 1500%.<br />

TGF has three main biological effects:<br />

• Down regulates inflammatory cytokine in the skin<br />

• Up-regulates collagen production by fibroblasts<br />

• Induces regulatory T cells<br />

Increase in TGF at 3 <strong>and</strong> 24 hours after a single<br />

treatment with NLite laser<br />

It thus reduces inflammation, can increase collagen production, which would help scarring <strong>and</strong> could eventually induce regulatory T cell which could lead<br />

to tolerisation of the antigens that are causing the acne <strong>and</strong> result in resolution of the acne.


Module - 6<br />

Advice for the <strong>Acne</strong> Sufferer


Advice for the <strong>Acne</strong> Sufferer<br />

A large number of factors will exacerbate acne <strong>and</strong> patients should be warned about these <strong>and</strong> given advice<br />

on what they can <strong>and</strong> cannot use.<br />

Moisturisers<br />

The acne friendly moisturisers that we recommend are Aknicare Cream, Cetaphil lotion <strong>and</strong> Efficlar lotion.<br />

These are acne friendly <strong>and</strong> will not induce comedogenesis. All have different characteristics <strong>and</strong> patients<br />

need to find which one they like to use.<br />

It is important to tell patients that it is not necessarily the oil content that is bad for the skin as even oil free<br />

moisturisers can induce comedogenesis <strong>and</strong> worsen acne. Tell patients always to look for the sign ‘noncomedogenic’<br />

on any product that they buy.<br />

Sunblocks<br />

Sunblocks are possibly one of the most common causes in terms of exacerbation of acne. A number of my patients have bought sunblocks at the beach<br />

while on holiday to return home with a significant exacerbation of acne. Warn patients to look for non-comedogenic on their sunblock <strong>and</strong> to avoid those<br />

that do not exhibit this sign. The sunblocks that I recommend is Sunsense SPF 50+ <strong>and</strong> the Aknicare SPF 30.


Cosmetics<br />

The price <strong>and</strong> oil free are not good indicators that a makeup is safe to use for the acne sufferer. Even eye<br />

shadow can be comedogenic <strong>and</strong> many hair products – waxes, gels <strong>and</strong> pomades can induce blackheads<br />

affecting the forehead – so called pomade acne (Figure 1) Warn patients to look for the label – noncomedogenic<br />

<strong>and</strong> to avoid all make up that does not show this label.<br />

Washes<br />

Figure 1. Pomade acne in a young man using waxes<br />

on his hair<br />

Patients will often ask advice about an appropriate wash to use. A pH balanced cleanser is all that is required <strong>and</strong> indeed ordinary soap <strong>and</strong> water would<br />

be OK. Avoid harsh washes as they can dry the skin <strong>and</strong> make it too sensitive for the use of topical treatments.<br />

Scrubs<br />

Scrubs do have a place in the management of acne. My favourite for the last 3 decades was Brasivol 1but GSK have<br />

recently discontinued this. Hopefully a smaller company will be able to take it on.<br />

The only equivalent that I have been able to find in Boot's No7 aluminium oxide scrub – Total Renewal. This should<br />

be used after normal cleansing while the skin is still wet. Rub the scrub into areas for 30 seconds <strong>and</strong> then wash off.<br />

It is marketed as a home micro-dermabrasion <strong>and</strong> removes the top dead skin cell layers of the skin allowing<br />

comedones to unseat.<br />

Contraceptives in women.<br />

Most hormone based contraceptives employ as part of the preparation, progesterone (See section on oral contraceptives in Module 1). The mini pill, <strong>and</strong><br />

all depot contraceptives are progesterone only <strong>and</strong> the Mirena coil incorporates a slow release progesterone. The majority of progesterones, however, are<br />

second generation progesterones <strong>and</strong> have <strong>and</strong>rogenic effects which may worsen acne. Third generation progesterones, desogestrel, norgestimate, or<br />

gestodene have no <strong>and</strong>rogenic effects <strong>and</strong> are thus acne friendly. Studies have shown a higher risk of thromboembolic phenomenon in the third<br />

generation progesterones compared to second generation progesterones at 1.7 to 2.5 times risk but a lower risk of myocardial infarction <strong>and</strong> possibly of<br />

stroke. Obviously, women need to be counselled about oral contraception.<br />

Avoid Dinette <strong>and</strong> Yasmin unless there is a clinical need for them as they are often associated with an exacerbation of acne when the pill is stopped.


Module - 7<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> Scarring


<strong>Acne</strong> Scarring<br />

<strong>Acne</strong> scarring can occur with even mild acne. The severity of the scarring appears to correlate more to the individual response to the inflammatory<br />

response in acne than to the severity of the acne.<br />

Scarring in acne is permanent unless it is treated <strong>and</strong> causes considerable psychological distress to the sufferer. Some feel that the scarring is worse than<br />

the acne.<br />

I will frequently see patients who complain about bad scarring in acne but on examination, they have no<br />

scarring, only post inflammatory hyperpigmentation or post inflammatory hyperemia. These are both selflimiting<br />

conditions, with post inflammatory hyperpigmentation seen mainly in patients with darker skin <strong>and</strong><br />

post inflammatory hyperemia seen in patients with very pale skin. There is no way to predict how long these<br />

skin changes will last for but always reassure patients that they are self-limiting.<br />

In patients who want treatment for post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, they need to be told that there are no very effective treatments available.<br />

Creams containing hydroquinone do not work. Intralesional injections with tranexamic acid (100mg/ml) may be effective but must be repeated every 6-8<br />

weeks.<br />

Post-inflammatory hyperemia can be treated with ablative pulsed dye laser. It will often require several treatments to clear the erythema <strong>and</strong> each<br />

treatment will result in bruising which can last for up to 2 weeks.


Types of scarring<br />

Scarring in acne can be hypertrophic/ keloidal or atrophic.<br />

Keloid scars<br />

In surgical practice, keloid scars are most commonly seen in patients of Afro-Caribbean decent. In acne, however, the unique inflammatory response leads<br />

to keloid formation in all ethnic groups involving the face, back, chest <strong>and</strong> upper arms.<br />

Keloids are the result of overactive healing response leading to a raised lumpy scar that<br />

goes beyond the boundary of the initial tissue injury. A 1mm inflammatory pustule can<br />

result in a 5cm keloid. Keloids may be itchy or painful, red or pigmented but cause<br />

major cosmetic problems. They are very visible <strong>and</strong> if large <strong>and</strong> on the trunk, will limit<br />

the clothes that the patients can wear as anything tight will show the lumps in the skin.<br />

Treatment of keloids involves the intralesional injection of a depot steroid. I generally use<br />

depomedrome, 40mg/ml. Use a fixed-needle diabetic syringe as you often need to use a lot of<br />

pressure to inject into the keloids <strong>and</strong> a detachable needle will often pop off. Make sure you are<br />

within the body of the keloid – if you inject under the keloids all you get is atrophy of the lower<br />

dermis <strong>and</strong> fat <strong>and</strong> the keloid sinks into a pit but is still present, painful <strong>and</strong> ugly. Inject until you see<br />

blanching of the keloids. Repeat injections every 6-8 week. There is no way to predict how quickly<br />

keloids will respond. Some respond quickly, others seem to do nothing for months <strong>and</strong> then<br />

suddenly involute. Ablative pulsed dye laser treatment may accelerate response to intra-lesional<br />

steroids. Very large keloids can be excised but only if followed by local radiotherapy. Excision alone<br />

will lead to recurrence of an even bigger keloids.


Atrophic scars<br />

A large number of treatments have been used to treat atrophic scarring with varying degrees of success. All treatments work in the same principle of<br />

causing an injury to the dermis which leads to a healing response with the induction of new collagen which fills the defect.<br />

Older treatments with dermabrasion <strong>and</strong> CO 2 laser resurfacing <strong>and</strong> now rarely used as the success rate was poor <strong>and</strong> there was considerable down time.<br />

Modern techniques include the Derma roller, automated needling devices <strong>and</strong> Fraxel laser.<br />

Before deciding on treatment it is important to properly document the type of scar that is present. There are 3 types of atrophic scars that we see in the<br />

acne sufferer:<br />

1. Rolling scars – these look like someone has pressed on the skin <strong>and</strong> left a dent<br />

2. Box scars – these have sharp edges like a box <strong>and</strong> can be very small, looking like large skin pores or large looking like craters<br />

3. Ice pick scars – these are deep <strong>and</strong> fibrotic so feel very hard, <strong>and</strong> as the name suggests, looks like someone has punctured the skin with a sharp<br />

pick.<br />

Ice pick scars are thankfully rare as the only effective way of getting rid of them is to remove them with a skin punch <strong>and</strong> repair with a suture. This will leave<br />

a small linear scar.<br />

Rolling <strong>and</strong> box scars can be free <strong>and</strong> will flatten completely if the skin is lightly stretched or tethered by scar tissue to deeper areas of the dermis <strong>and</strong> will<br />

not flatten when the skin is stretched. In such tethered scars additional treatment with subcision may be needed to give good results.<br />

Rolling Scars<br />

Box scars<br />

Ice pick scars


Needling Devices (dermal rollers <strong>and</strong> automated needling devices)<br />

The Medical Dermal roller <strong>and</strong> the newer automated needling devices work on the principle of needling. The needles are fine acupuncture<br />

needles which are too thin to leave a permanent mark on the skin but when pushed into the skin will induce a healing response with the<br />

induction of new collagen which will fill the scar <strong>and</strong> stretch the skin.<br />

Dermarollers<br />

Dermal rollers were developed in Germany <strong>and</strong> were introduced to the UK by myself in 2009 – prior to that, patients<br />

travelled to Germany to have treatment. The whole affected area is treated i.e. the whole face or back or chest, not just<br />

the scars. The skin is first treated with EMLA cream for 1 hour under occlusion then cleaned <strong>and</strong> swabbed with alcohol.<br />

The skin treated is with 4 repetitions in 3 different directions – horizontal, vertical <strong>and</strong> diagonal to optimize the number<br />

of individual piercings that occur. Medical Dermal Roller will produce 250 channels/cm2. The Medical Dermal Roller<br />

comes in a range of fixed needle lengths from 0.5 to 2mm. For acne scarring you need to use 1.5mm needle length.<br />

Treatment will lead to pinpoint bleeding <strong>and</strong> may be painful. After treatment, clean the skin with sterile normal saline, apply clean gauze <strong>and</strong> a cold pack<br />

for 10 minutes. After this, any serous exudate will have dried up <strong>and</strong> the patients can be allowed home. Light moisturizer can be use that night <strong>and</strong> the<br />

patients can go back to a normal regime the next day. The skin will remain red for up to 4 days.


Automated Needling Device<br />

The automated needling devices are next generation needling systems <strong>and</strong> have major advantages over the manual rollers. It is an electric pen with 9<br />

acupuncture needles. The needles can be adjusted to varying lengths on a continuous dial from 0.1mm through over 2mm. The speed can also be<br />

adjusted to a maximum speed that will produce 70,000 holes/minute. As the needles go straight in <strong>and</strong> out, rather than the cycling motion with rollers,<br />

then the automated needling devices are much less painful <strong>and</strong> redness dissipates much faster.


Fraxel Laser<br />

The Fraxel laser is effectively a CO 2 laser where the laser beam has been fractionated into multiple beamlets. The energy can be adjusted to allow different<br />

depths of the skin to be treated. The basic principle is the same as the Automated needling devices but uses laser rather than needles to injure the skin<br />

<strong>and</strong> induce a healing response with new collagen induction. The treatment is painful <strong>and</strong> downtime can be up to 1 week<br />

Trichloracetic Acid (TCA) Chemical Reconstruction of Scarred Skin (CROSS).<br />

This technique was developed in Korea <strong>and</strong> is particularly useful for small box scars. Up to 100% TCA is used<br />

<strong>and</strong> carefully applied to the base of the scar using a sharpened orange stick. As soon as frosting occurs, wash off<br />

with normal saline. The TCA causes a very local injury which induces new collagen production <strong>and</strong> allows the<br />

scar to fill <strong>and</strong> obliterate the sharp edges. After treatment, frosting lasts for about 30 minutes <strong>and</strong> is followed by<br />

the development of a soft scab which falls off after a few days. Treatment should be repeated every 6-12 weeks.<br />

Combining this with needling facilitates good results<br />

Frosting following TCA-CROSS<br />

Subcision<br />

Subcision is a very powerful technique that is needed when scars are tethered to deeper structures or in deeper rolling scars where the injury from the<br />

subcision gives good filling of the scar.<br />

Subcision can be performed as an isolated procedure or following automated needling devices treatment.<br />

The scar is marked with a surgical marker <strong>and</strong> the area infiltrated with lignocaine – if the scars are not<br />

marked before infiltration the local anesthetic will fill the area <strong>and</strong> it may not be possible to see where the<br />

scar is. Subcision is performed with a 19 gauge NorKor needle which has a cutting blade on the end. This is<br />

inserted into the mid-dermis <strong>and</strong> pushed back <strong>and</strong> forth across the scarred area. The needle is then swept<br />

crosswise in a fanning technique with the cutting blade at the advancing edge. Heavy pressure is the applied<br />

to the area to prevent hematoma formation. If hematomas form, they can give a palpable or even visible<br />

lump in the skin that can persist for several weeks.<br />

NorKor Needle


Module - 8<br />

<strong>Rosacea</strong>


<strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

<strong>Rosacea</strong> is a relatively common disease but is surrounded by misconceptions <strong>and</strong> controversy:<br />

1. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is a disease of the elderly, occurring around menopause – WRONG – there are two age peaks for rosacea, one in the late teens <strong>and</strong><br />

twenties <strong>and</strong> a second in the 40s <strong>and</strong> 50s. It can, however, occur at any age.<br />

2. If you have a red face you have rosacea – WRONG – there are a number of skin conditions that will lead to a red face – seborrheic dermatitis, acne,<br />

atopic eczema, <strong>and</strong> lupus erythematosus. The hallmark of rosacea is facial flushing, which unlike physiological flushing lasts for longer than 10<br />

minutes <strong>and</strong> can last for hours or day. It may be asymptomatic or cause severe burning sensation or pain.<br />

3. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is only seen in Celts <strong>and</strong> people with pale complexions – WRONG – although commonest in Type I skin it can occur in any ethnic group.<br />

The hallmark of rosacea is facial flushing. This affects the concave areas of the face including the cheeks, forehead, chin <strong>and</strong> nose. Extra-facial involvement<br />

is unusual but may affect the ears <strong>and</strong> neck. Some patients only have the flushing or Erythematotelangiectatic rosacea but others will progress to develop<br />

acneiform inflammatory lesions – the Papulopustular rosacea. In some patients, excessive growth of gl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> fibrous tissue will lead to swelling of<br />

various parts of the face – Phytomatous rosacea, <strong>and</strong> up to 50% of patients will develop eye involvement – Ocular rosacea.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Type I skin – this is the Fitzpatrick classification relating to response to sunlight. Type I skin is Celtic skin, people with pale skin, blue eyes <strong>and</strong> fre3ckles with blond or red<br />

hair. Their skin does not tolerate sun exposure <strong>and</strong> burns <strong>and</strong> rarely tans


Types of <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

National <strong>Rosacea</strong> Society Expert Committee on the Classification <strong>and</strong> Staging of <strong>Rosacea</strong> 2004 has reclassified rosacea<br />

into 4 types. In some ways, this is a rather artificial grouping as phytomatous change <strong>and</strong> ocular involvement are really<br />

sequelae of rosacea rather than being individual entities:<br />

Type I<br />

Erythematotelangiectatic rosacea. In my practice this is the most common form. In some patients it may<br />

progress to Type II, Papulopustular rosacea but it may only manifests as vascular response. Flushing<br />

may be spontaneous or may be precipitated by a trigger factor. The flushing, unlike physiological<br />

flushing, lasts more than 10 minutes <strong>and</strong> can last hours or days. It may be asymptomatic or cause a<br />

burning sensation or even pain, which may be severe. Trigger factors are very individual to the patient.<br />

Never impose an exclusion diet without first ascertaining what triggers flushing in that patient. In a large<br />

survey conducted in USA the commonest trigger factor was sun exposure, but I have patients who<br />

improve with a sunny holiday. I have patients who can eat a Vindaloo curry but spring onions will cause<br />

a flush <strong>and</strong> I have patients who can drink beer or white wine but not red wine or spirits. Get your patient<br />

to keep a diary <strong>and</strong> if they identify something that triggers a flush, try to avoid it.<br />

Type 1 <strong>Rosacea</strong> in a 22 year old woman<br />

Type II<br />

Papulopustular rosacea. This occurs following a period of flushing or concurrent with flushing. The spots<br />

look like acne which is why rosacea was previously, erroneously called acne rosacea, but in pure rosacea<br />

there are no comedones <strong>and</strong> the spots may be follicular or interfollicular. Spots may be of any severity <strong>and</strong><br />

may become nodulocystic.<br />

Type 2 <strong>Rosacea</strong> in a 35 year old man


Type III<br />

Phytomatous rosacea. This generally occurs in long st<strong>and</strong>ing rosacea <strong>and</strong> is more common in men but can<br />

occur in women. The increased blood flow through the skin leads to hypertrophic growth of sebaceous gl<strong>and</strong>s<br />

<strong>and</strong> fibrous tissue leading to lumpy swelling of the skin. The commonest is rhinophyma, affecting the nose,<br />

which becomes lumpy <strong>and</strong> bulbous, often mistaken for the alcoholic nose. It may also occur on the cheeks,<br />

chin <strong>and</strong> forehead. The swelling is firm <strong>and</strong> persistent.<br />

Type 3 <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

Rhynophyma in a 60 year old man<br />

Type IV<br />

Ocular rosacea. This can occur with even very mild rosacea <strong>and</strong> affects up to 50% of rosacea sufferers. Initially the<br />

eyes become dry <strong>and</strong> gritty, followed by chemosis <strong>and</strong> red eyes. In severe cases this may lead to keratitis <strong>and</strong> is a<br />

recognized cause of blindness.<br />

Type 4 <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

Moderate ocular involvement with<br />

chemosis


Pathogenesis of <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

The pathogenesis of rosacea is unclear but a number of hypotheses have been proposed.<br />

1. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is associated with Helicobacter pylori infections <strong>and</strong> may be associated with gastrointestinal symptoms. It has been shown that type II<br />

rosacea will improve when patients are treated for H pylori eradication, but this is most likely to be due to the anti-inflammatory effects of the<br />

antibiotics used in this condition <strong>and</strong> the rosacea relapses once the antibiotics are stopped<br />

2. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is caused by the demodex mite, Demodex folliculorum. Demodex are a commensal in the skin. In some situations, the density of demodex<br />

increases, mainly due to the use of cream cleansers of the skin <strong>and</strong> avoidance of soap <strong>and</strong> water which would normally reduce the level of<br />

demodex. Studies have shown that systemic ivermectin, which clears the skin of demodex mites led to no improvement in rosacea.<br />

3. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is caused by an abnormality of one of the skin’s antimicrobial peptides. The skin produces a series of naturally occurring antibiotics, the<br />

antimicrobial peptides. These are the cathelicidins <strong>and</strong> the human defensins. Only one cathelicidin is found in human skin LL37. Studies have<br />

shown in patients with rosacea that cathelicidin processing is disturbed resulting in peptide fragments causing inflammation, erythema <strong>and</strong><br />

telangiectasias. More work need to be performed on this.<br />

4. <strong>Rosacea</strong> is caused by an abnormal vascular response in the skin <strong>and</strong> can be associates with migraine. This is the most plausible proposal. Blood<br />

vessels in the skin form two plexuses parallel to the surface of the skin – the superficial <strong>and</strong> deep plexuses. Their primary function is to feed <strong>and</strong><br />

oxygenate the skin but the maximal blood flow through the skin is very much higher that the metabolic needs of the skin. The second important<br />

function of the skin vasculature is to cool the body. This is orchestrated via the sympathetic nervous system via receptors in the brain, heart, large<br />

vessels <strong>and</strong> stomach, which stimulate receptors on the blood vessels – receptors cause vasoconstriction <strong>and</strong> receptors cause vasodilation. In<br />

rosacea, this system is abnormal leading to flushing. With time, the skin blood vessels become leaky with serous fluid escaping into the dermis,<br />

causing swelling <strong>and</strong> acting as a focus for inflammation <strong>and</strong> spot formation.<br />

The fourth proposal is the most likely <strong>and</strong> gives some direction as to the management of rosacea. The primary abnormality is the vascular instability, with<br />

flushing being the first <strong>and</strong> cardinal sign of rosacea. This needs to be addressed if rosacea is to be treated properly.<br />

Patient with rosacea have very sensitive skin <strong>and</strong> patients will often not tolerate a vast array of topical agents including moisturizers <strong>and</strong> cosmetics. It is<br />

important for patients to try different products to find what their skin will tolerate.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Peptide – a molecule composed of 2 or more amino acids – may result from the breakdown of protein


Module - 9<br />

Treatment of <strong>Rosacea</strong>


Treatment of <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

Most clinical trials in rosacea have concentrated on the inflammatory lesions of rosacea, mainly ignoring the flushing <strong>and</strong><br />

facial redness. The only exceptions are Synchrorose (Rosacure) <strong>and</strong> topical bromonidine (marketed as Mirvaso gel).<br />

Treatment of type I rosacea<br />

The only medications licensed for the treatment of type I rosacea are Synchrorose (Rosacure) <strong>and</strong> topical bromonidine. A number of drugs are effective in<br />

controlling flushing but these are used off license.<br />

adrenergic agonists<br />

Systemic adrenergic agonists are very useful in controlling flushing <strong>and</strong> preventing fixed facial redness. Stimulation of the<br />

causes vasoconstriction.<br />

receptor on blood vessels<br />

Clonidine<br />

Start at 50mcg BD <strong>and</strong> slowly increase to 75mcg TDS. It is impossible to predict what dose an individual will need to control flushing so start at a low dose<br />

<strong>and</strong> slowly increase this. The maximal dose that I will use is 75mcg TDS after which I will add in a adrenergic blocker or other drugs – listed below.<br />

At higher doses, clonidine is used to treat hypertension. It works in rosacea by causing vasoconstriction. I have a high success rate with clonidine with<br />

about 60% of patients responding to it as monotherapy or in combination with other drugs.<br />

It can cause tiredness in some patients <strong>and</strong> may cause problems in patients with concurrent Raynaud’s phenomenon.<br />

Moxonidine<br />

Start at 200mcg OD <strong>and</strong> slowly increase to 200mcg TDS. This is a good alternative to clonidine <strong>and</strong> can be tried if the clonidine is not working or causes<br />

unacceptable side effects.


adrenergic blockers (antagonists)<br />

The receptors on the blood vessel cause vasodilation <strong>and</strong> this can be inhibited by blockers. adrenergic blockers can be used in type I rosacea either<br />

as monotherapy or in combination with an adrenergic agonists. A number of these drugs have been used in rosacea with varying success. These include<br />

propranolol – dose of up to 80mg TDS, atenolol – dose up to 100mg OD <strong>and</strong> carvedilol – dose up to 25mg BD.<br />

I do not find them as successful as monotherapy compared to adrenergic agonists <strong>and</strong> they cannot be used in patients who give a history of asthma or<br />

bronchospasm. If used with an adrenergic agonists, the drugs should be withdrawn slowly – never stop suddenly as this could precipitate a hypertensive<br />

episode.<br />

Mirtazapine<br />

This is a centrally acting α 2 adrenergic auto- <strong>and</strong> heteroreceptors (enhancing norepinephrine release), <strong>and</strong> selectively antagonizes the 5-HT 2 serotonin<br />

receptors in the central <strong>and</strong> peripheral nervous system used as an anti-depressant. When used at low dosage, i.e. 15mg/day, it can synergize with the<br />

adrenergic agonists to improve control of flushing. Some patients develop severe with this drug <strong>and</strong> cannot tolerate it <strong>and</strong> it may cause weight gain by<br />

increasing appetite.<br />

Topical Bromonidine (Mirvaso gel)<br />

Bromonidine is an adrenergic agonists. It is used for the treatment of glaucoma <strong>and</strong> for some years, rosacea sufferers have obtained supplies of the eye<br />

preparation, mixed it with h<strong>and</strong> cream <strong>and</strong> applied it to the face with varying success. A major problem in these patients was severe rebound that<br />

occurred when the vasoconstrictive effect of the rug wore off.<br />

A commercial product, Mirvaso gel, has been formulated <strong>and</strong> has undergone extensive tests in USA. The<br />

preparation works very quickly with reduction of facial redness in the first 30 minutes <strong>and</strong> this effect lasted up to 12<br />

hours.<br />

Since its launch in UK it has given variable results. Some patients find that it does what it says it should do <strong>and</strong> are<br />

happy to use it. Others find that it does not last as long as 12 hours, <strong>and</strong> others have problem with rebound flushing<br />

as the drug wears off.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Glaucoma – a condition in which the pressure within the eye increases which can affect vision


Laser <strong>and</strong> Intense Pulsed Light (IPL)<br />

The only way to remove fixed redness is to ablate the underlying blood vessels using the pulsed dye laser or intense pulsed light (IPL). To be effective, both<br />

will induce bruising of varying intensity. My personal feeling is that laser <strong>and</strong> IPL will remove ectatic vessels but will not treat Type I rosacea <strong>and</strong> with<br />

continual flushing, ectatic vessels will reform. There have, however, been reports of pulsed dye laser <strong>and</strong> IPL use in the treatment of Type I rosacea <strong>and</strong><br />

this is an option many patients explore.<br />

I use the RegenLite in the ablative phjase to treat telangiectasias, using a fluence of 6.5j/cm2<br />

In USA a preferred laser is the V-beam Perfecta Laser by C<strong>and</strong>ela, which is a pulsed-dye laser that very good at removing linear spider veins as well as<br />

diffuse redness <strong>and</strong> also reduces enlarged pores <strong>and</strong> sagging skin.<br />

The Excel-V Laser by Cutera, is a dual wavelength laser offering versatility to the operator to effectively treat spider veins on the face without damaging the<br />

surrounding skin.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Ectatic – permanently dilated blood vessels or thread veins<br />

V beam Perfecta Laser


Synchrorose<br />

This product contains four synergistic ingredients <strong>and</strong> is a medically licensed product only available to clinics. A novel ingredient known at a Tryp-2 receptor<br />

antagonist called 4-t-butylcyclohexanol which is the first agent to stop nerve stimulated peptide production irritating the skin by triggering stinging <strong>and</strong> burning<br />

by activating receptors on skin cells.<br />

4-t-butylcycloheaxanol<br />

Various physiological triggers like food, liquids, temperature change can stimulate nerves which in turn activate receptors on keratinocytes (epidermal skin cells)<br />

which release peptides (protein fragments) which cause a stinging <strong>and</strong> burning sensation. <strong>Rosacea</strong> sufferers receptors are much more reactive to these stimuli.<br />

4-t-butylcyclohexanol inhibits the effect of these nerve stimulated peptides thereby calming <strong>and</strong> soothing rosacea symptoms before they show. Regular use of<br />

these agents can have a profound effect on rosacea symptoms <strong>and</strong> also other nerve stimulated redness.<br />

Dimethly Sulfone<br />

Also known as methyl sulfonyl methane (MSM) is the second ingredient <strong>and</strong> works synergistically with the butylcyclohexabol in that it suppresses the activity of<br />

key skin inflammatory agents including the key cytokine interleukin 1 alpha which triggers erythema <strong>and</strong> swelling. MSM also reduces the activity of vaso<br />

endothelial growth factor <strong>and</strong> tumour necrosis factor1 alpha. <strong>Rosacea</strong> sufferers may be hyper-reactive to these skin chemicals which may exacerbate<br />

telangiectasia <strong>and</strong> phymatous development. In combination these agents have a synergistic effect on rosacea symptoms <strong>and</strong> development as each is beneficial<br />

to the other.<br />

Polyglutamic Acid<br />

The third ingredient is Polyglutamic Acid which is a long chain of repeating units of glutamic acid, <strong>and</strong> creates a<br />

physical smooth, elastic, self moisturising <strong>and</strong> soft film for improved sensory perception <strong>and</strong> protection of the outer<br />

layer of the skin, a reinforcement of the skin’s support structure, stimulates the production of skin lipids improving skin<br />

sensitivity (less sensitive), stimulates the renewal of the epidermis (also improves sensitivity), raises the tolerance<br />

threshold to rosacea triggers especially external ones (raises TTT (Trigger Tolerance Thresholds)).<br />

Silymarin<br />

A bioflavanoid complex from milk thistle known as Silymarin in the fourth ingredient in Synchrorose <strong>and</strong> this works in<br />

synergy with MSM to suppress erythema. The retail version of Synchrorose does not contain silymarin, but is the<br />

updated formula <strong>and</strong> should not be confused with the old MSM/silymarin only formula.


Treatment of Type II <strong>Rosacea</strong><br />

Topical antibiotics<br />

Metronidazole - Topical metronidazole<br />

Available as 0.75% <strong>and</strong> 1% gels <strong>and</strong> creams. Some gels contain cellulose <strong>and</strong> this leaves a surface film which some<br />

patients find unacceptable<br />

Topical metronidazole is marketed for the treatment of rosacea <strong>and</strong> is successful in treating the inflammatory<br />

spots in rosacea but will have no effect on flushing or facial redness.<br />

Topical erythromycin <strong>and</strong> clindamycin<br />

Topical erythromycin <strong>and</strong> clindamycin are effective in treating inflammatory rosacea but the alcoholic solutions <strong>and</strong> gels may be too irritant to be<br />

tolerated by the rosacea sufferer. Dalacin T lotion (1% clindamycin) may be better tolerated.<br />

Topical pimicrolimus<br />

Topical azaleic acid<br />

The 15% azaleic acid cream (marketed as Finacea ) is effective in treating inflammatory lesions of rosacea <strong>and</strong><br />

may have a very mild effect on facial redness. The 20% azaleic acid preparation (marketed as Skinoren) is<br />

generally too irritant for the rosacea sufferer.<br />

Topical pimicrolimus (marketed as Elidel cream) is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agent. One study has shown that it<br />

is effective in treating inflammatory lesions of rosacea <strong>and</strong> gave similar results to topical metronidazole. Neither gave<br />

response to flushing or telangiectasia.<br />

Topical Ivermectin<br />

Topical ivermectin (marketed as Soolantra) has potent anti-inflammatory effects <strong>and</strong> is very effective in Type 2<br />

rosacea, suppressing the inflammatory lesions but with little effect on the redness. I find that it is more effective than<br />

topical metronidazole.


Systemic antibiotics<br />

Tetracyclines<br />

The tetracyclines are generally reported to be the most effective treatment for rosacea. It should be noted, that tetracyclines, as with all systemic<br />

antibiotics, have their main effect in inflammatory lesions of rosacea <strong>and</strong> have little or no effect on flushing <strong>and</strong> redness. As bacteria are not implicated in<br />

the pathogenesis of rosacea, the main effect of the tetracyclines is their potent anti-inflammatory effect. Oxytetracycline at 250-500mg BD would be a<br />

suitable dose.<br />

Doxycycline, at 100mg OD is a popular choice in rosacea as it is frequently used in ocular rosacea. Always warn<br />

patients to take this drug with food, as the capsule of the antibiotic can adhere to the oesophagus causing a<br />

chemical burn. It can also cause significant photosensitivity.<br />

A low dose, slow release doxycycline (40mg/day marketed as Efracea) has been developed for the treatment of<br />

inflammatory rosacea. The blood levels with this preparation never reach antibiotic levels, so should have no effect<br />

on the gastrointestinal tract <strong>and</strong> should not induce vagina c<strong>and</strong>idiasis.<br />

Trimethoprim<br />

Trimethoprim is a good second line antibiotic for the treatment of inflammatory rosacea. It can be prescribed at 200-300mg BD. It is generally well<br />

tolerated but there is a low incidence of allergic reaction to the drug, with the development of a widespread itchy rash after 10 days of taking the drug. If<br />

this happens, the drug should be stopped <strong>and</strong> the rash will settle after a few days. If itching is severe it can be treated with a mild topical steroid or<br />

calamine lotion.<br />

Oral metronidazole<br />

Oral metronidazole – dose 200mg TDS, is very effective in severe inflammatory rosacea not responding to other antibiotics. Patients should be advised to<br />

avoid alcohol while taking this antibiotic as it can have an Antabuse effect.<br />

Glossary<br />

• Antabuse – a drug used to treat alcoholism – it leads to alcohol being converted into formaldehyde which causes severe vomiting


Oral Isotretinoin<br />

Oral isotretinoin is used to treat Type 2 rosacea which has failed to respond to conventional antibiotics. It does seem to work but rapid relapses when the drug is<br />

withdrawn is the norm. Indeed, in my experience oral isotretinoin seems to precipitate rosacea in susceptible patients who are being treated for acne <strong>and</strong> I have a<br />

number of patients whose rosacea started when they took oral isotretinoin.<br />

Laser treatment<br />

As in acne, the bio-stimulatory effect of the NLite (Regenlite) laser, used at low fluencies – 2.5-3.5J/cm 2 can be very effective in inflammatory rosacea. Treatments need<br />

to be repeated every 3 months.<br />

Treatment of type III rosacea<br />

Phytomatous change in the skin will not respond to medical treatment. Oral isotretinoin (1mg/kg/day) will reduce the swelling but it relapses when the drug is<br />

withdrawn.<br />

It is important to treat the active rosacea so that the disease does not progress, but the only effective treatments are surgical, debulking changes on the cheeks,<br />

forehead <strong>and</strong> chin. The nose can be carved back to its original shape <strong>and</strong> size.<br />

Treatment of Type IV rosacea<br />

There seems to be poor correlation between severity of rosacea or response to treatment of Type I <strong>and</strong> Type II rosacea <strong>and</strong> the severity of ocular rosacea. Always ask<br />

patients with rosacea if they have any ocular problems. Some patients will respond to oral doxycycline but I generally refer patients to the ophthalmologist for<br />

treatments which will often involve eye toilet <strong>and</strong> use of artificial tears.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!