21.07.2017 Views

e-flight-Journal01-2017

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotor wings, Fixed Wing, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making news, Test Reports * Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotorwings, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making News,<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

Quarterly Vol. 1-<strong>2017</strong><br />

www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-journal.com<br />

supported by<br />

UBER Elevate<br />

The Industry Booster<br />

Zunum & Co<br />

When will airliners be electric ?<br />

Overview<br />

VTOL Aircraft<br />

Lilium Jet<br />

German VTOL takes off<br />

Siemens EXTRA Power<br />

& more at<br />

AERO & Paris Airshow<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro<br />

E-<strong>flight</strong> training around the World


E-Flight.<br />

An An exciting future.<br />

“By entering<br />

“By entering<br />

the<br />

the<br />

field<br />

field<br />

of highly<br />

of highly<br />

innovative<br />

innovative<br />

aircraft<br />

aircraft<br />

propulsion<br />

propulsion<br />

technology,<br />

technology,<br />

we‘re<br />

we‘re<br />

opening<br />

opening<br />

a new<br />

a new<br />

chapter<br />

chapter<br />

in E-Mobility.<br />

in E-Mobility.<br />

Collaboration<br />

Collaboration<br />

with<br />

with<br />

Airbus<br />

Airbus<br />

Group<br />

Group<br />

will<br />

will<br />

create<br />

create<br />

new<br />

new<br />

perspectives<br />

perspectives<br />

for<br />

for<br />

our<br />

our<br />

company<br />

company<br />

and<br />

and<br />

open<br />

open<br />

us up<br />

us<br />

even<br />

up even<br />

more<br />

more<br />

to disruptive<br />

to disruptive<br />

innovation.“<br />

innovation.“<br />

Siemens<br />

Siemens<br />

President<br />

President<br />

and<br />

and<br />

CEO<br />

CEO<br />

Joe<br />

Joe<br />

Kaeser<br />

Kaeser<br />

siemens.com/innovation<br />

siemens.com/innovation


e ditorial<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong> Needs a Platform to Take off<br />

EElectric aviation-related technologies and products have<br />

been developing quickly in the past decade. More innovative<br />

concepts occur in the electric aviation area than any other<br />

aerospace sector. New electric aircraft take maiden <strong>flight</strong>s on<br />

a regular basis. Due to the announcement of the electric aircraft<br />

projects of Siemens, Airbus, Uber, Kitty Hawk, Zunum<br />

and many others, we will very likely witness hybrid passenger<br />

airplanes and electric on-demand VTOL in service in the<br />

next decade.<br />

However, this is also the critical time for the growing electric<br />

aviation industry. The application of electric aircraft in <strong>flight</strong><br />

training, recreational <strong>flight</strong> and specific operations like aerobatics<br />

and glider towing are imminent, but the rules must be<br />

developed and the manufacturers and most importantly the<br />

pilots and future customers must want this new e-Aviation.<br />

Due to this, the aviation community and the general public<br />

must be informed and be kept up-to-date.<br />

Some great designs evoked are possible by electric aviation<br />

technologies such as multi-rotor manned VTOL aircraft and<br />

on-demand aerial mobility and may still seem exotic to policy<br />

makers, but the success of the new designs and operation<br />

business models depends on their critical understanding<br />

and support. Moreover, electric aviation has significant<br />

cross-over effect in many relevant industries such as microchip,<br />

sensor, software, synthetic materials, battery, automation,<br />

and so on, but some of these industries or companies<br />

have not been well aware of the new market development<br />

opportunities.<br />

Therefore, we believe that this is the critical time for this new<br />

aviation to take off and to do this there needs to be a platform.<br />

The e Flight Journal strives to be the communication part<br />

of this platform. Dedicated to electric aviation, which effectively<br />

consolidates all communication and marketing channels<br />

concerning e-<strong>flight</strong> and promotes the whole industry. It<br />

is urgently necessary for the exponent and long-term growth<br />

of the electric aviation market and industry.<br />

This journal will serve as a good communication channel between<br />

industry players, regulators, investors, market - the<br />

general public and last but not least politicians. It will be a<br />

loudspeaker, a bridge, a platform and any other roles necessary<br />

to help propel forward electric aviation innovation.<br />

The e Flight Journal is committed to raise the awareness of<br />

electric aviation among the public, pilots and politicians<br />

(PPP) so that the readers learn that electric aviation is an imminent<br />

technology able to be deployed commercially in the<br />

near future instead of a far-fetched phenomenon. To spearhead<br />

the electric aviation market trend so that GA community<br />

including manufacturers and operators know how they<br />

could prepare for the advent of the electric aviation, to showcase<br />

the contemporary state-of-the-art electric aviation technologies<br />

from leading players in the industry, to review the<br />

policymaking situation related to electric aviation and autonomous<br />

<strong>flight</strong> certification and operation from key policymaking<br />

agencies, i.e. FAA, EASA, CAAC etc.<br />

We will do this in every possible way printed (at special occasions<br />

like Airventure and AERO), and of course online, with<br />

the website and social media channels. The difference from<br />

the Journal opposed to many existing blogs is its filtered information<br />

designated and condensed by experienced aviation<br />

editors so that professionals can access the info in a<br />

short time and the public will understand as well.<br />

Electric aviation is more than aviation technology innovation.<br />

It will have a profound social and economic impact, just similar<br />

to what jet aircraft did to the society over 60 years ago,<br />

making flying accessible to “normal” people.<br />

Electric aviation will create more and new types of jobs,<br />

more technology innovation in many other industries, a bigger<br />

market for aviation products, and most importantly, make<br />

aviation more friendly to the environment and flying more accessible<br />

to people. Especially when electric aircraft is bundled<br />

with renewable energy. No more noise complaints from<br />

the neighboring communities, no more concern about the<br />

fuel cost at the end of <strong>flight</strong>. Commuting between and inside<br />

cities would be much easier and quicker. Flying long<br />

distance would be at lower cost and more accessible. Even<br />

the flying experience itself will be more easy (assisted), and<br />

pleasant in a quieter cabin. Electric aviation will make flying<br />

do better what was invented for: to overcome obstacles and<br />

to bring people together.<br />

But until the bright future of electric aviation arrives, we need<br />

your help to get it done.<br />

Here are 3 ways you can help:<br />

First, share as much news with our editorial staff so that we<br />

can investigate and edit the info to accelerate the communication<br />

in the scene by helping eliminate issues and solve<br />

problems together. For example, when new infrastructure is<br />

built in several countries at the same time with little coordination.<br />

By solving problems together we can help eliminate issues<br />

along the way.<br />

Second, share your news with us so that we can inform pilots,<br />

the public and politicians by keeping them up-to-date<br />

and motivated to work for the e-revolution.<br />

Thirdly, support the magazine by distributing the access<br />

links to get the info to as many persons as possible. If possible,<br />

by commercial support as well because to get the info<br />

mass distributed the magazine must be free and also from<br />

the advertising side, there will not be much income as the<br />

markets still have to develop. So as long as there are not<br />

many e-aircraft sold there are no marketing budgets and no<br />

advertising.<br />

So support us and together we can make electric aviation<br />

take off faster and fly higher while everyone enjoys the ride.<br />

Willi Tacke<br />

Xin Gou<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

2


i<br />

lt<br />

Content / Imprint<br />

Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotor wings,<br />

Fixed Wing, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule making news, Test Reports * Electric Aviation, VTOLS, Multicopter, Rotorwings, Hybrid Technoilogy, Rule<br />

Quarterly rly Vol. 1-<strong>2017</strong><br />

www.e-fl ight-journal.com<br />

supported by<br />

UBER Elevate<br />

The Industry Booster<br />

Zunum & Co<br />

When will airliners be electric ?<br />

Siemens EXTRA Power<br />

Overview<br />

& more at<br />

VTOL Aircraft<br />

AERO & Paris Airshow<br />

Lilium Jet<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro<br />

German VTOL takes off<br />

E-ight training around the World<br />

Categories<br />

editorial 2<br />

Imprint 3<br />

eNews 4<br />

eDates 7<br />

9 • eTraining & more: One of the best time<br />

in aeronautical history?<br />

13 • AERO & e-<strong>flight</strong> expo & e-<strong>flight</strong> show /<br />

Germany, 25th anniversary:<br />

A Celebration of Electric Aviation<br />

17 • From e-<strong>flight</strong> to „on-demand mobility“<br />

Is the UBER-plane Coming Next?<br />

21 • Fight Training in Whisper Mode<br />

Around he World<br />

24 • Ivo Boscarol – Mr. Electric<br />

27 • Le Bourget Airshow <strong>2017</strong><br />

Paris in the sign of big e<br />

31 • GAMA: The Early Days of a Revolution<br />

Increased Electrification & Automation<br />

We the e Flight Journal (e FJ) founders are<br />

a team of aviation journalists and enthusiasts<br />

who created Flying-Pages.<br />

Publishing several aviation publications<br />

around the world. It started with<br />

the interest in electric flying in 2009.<br />

We co-founded the e-Flight-Expo in<br />

Friedrichshafen/Germany as part of the<br />

AERO, and established it as the largest<br />

show for electric aviation worldwide.<br />

The e FJ is supported by the GAMA EPIC<br />

committee and many others.<br />

33 • Zunum Aero - Think BIG<br />

35 • eVTOL to be in trial use in Dubai<br />

37 • Aurora’s eVTOL approach<br />

39 • Electric Flight Plans of the Norwegian<br />

Government: e-Flight Up North<br />

41 • e-Visions Become Reality<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

www.flying-pages.com<br />

Publisher, Flying-pages GmbH, Buttersteig 11,<br />

D-16831 Rheinsberg OT Zühlen<br />

• phone: D-033931/80 60 27, Fax.: D-030/34 70 91 24<br />

• info@flying-pages.com • www.flying-pages.com<br />

ADVERTISING<br />

Worldwide Willi Tacke, • phone :+49 (0)8841 / 487 515,<br />

mob:+49 (0)171 69 808 71, fax:+49(0)8841 / 496 012,<br />

US Cell: +1 920 385 8495 • willi@flying-pages.com<br />

Germany & other Countries, Rosi Berkemeier<br />

• phone: +49 (0)33931/80 60 27 • Fax +49 (0)30 / 3470 9124<br />

• rosi@flying-pages.com<br />

USA, Bettina C. Larrarte • phone.: +1 970 310 1410<br />

Fax: +1 970 449 0566 • bc@flying-pages.com<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

Robby Bayerl, Marino Boric, Greg Bowls, René Coulon, Dimitri Delemarle, Jan<br />

Fridrich, Mike Friend, Xin Guo, Martin Hardung, Dan Johnson, Klaus Köhmstedt,<br />

Germán Larrarte, Werner Pfändler, Peter Raab, Jan Otto Reimers, Torkell<br />

Saetervade, Christian Tacke, Julia Tacke, Willi Tacke, Dave Unwin; Qinyin<br />

Zhang, Markus Villinger, Jean-Marie Urlacher (Photo).<br />

Managing Editor, Design: Bettina Cosima Larrarte<br />

Technical Proofreader/USA: Renée Larrarte<br />

Online: Achim Holzmann<br />

© <strong>2017</strong> Flying-Pages GmbH. No part of this publication may be reproduced,<br />

stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by any means,<br />

electrical, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior<br />

permission of the copyright owner.<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

This publication consists largely of information supplied by traders and<br />

manufacturers. Flying-Pages GmbH and its associates do not take any<br />

responsibility for the data, facts, wording, addresses, prices and spelling of<br />

the items published and do not claim the market survey to be complete. The<br />

publisher has made every effort to ensure its accuracy and completeness, and<br />

has queried many facts during its compilation, but cannot be held responsible<br />

for errors or omissions, or for any problems arising from them, or for the use<br />

to which the information is put.<br />

3 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

E-Flight Formation: two Magnus e-Fusion taking off<br />

Electric airplane for 3D mapping<br />

over a populated area<br />

The first demonstration using an electric airplane for 3D mapping<br />

over a populated area was carried out in June. PC Aero’s Elektra One<br />

Solar aircraft flew at 300 m over the old town of Landshut in Southern<br />

Germany in order to map the entire city in three dimensions at very<br />

high resolution using the German company Vialight’s laser transmission<br />

equipment. The Elektra One Solar flew autonomously on a predetermined<br />

path over Landshut while carrying a complex payload<br />

of sensors, cameras and high-speed data links, which transmitted<br />

the data to a ground station. The system was able to transmit real<br />

time video in 4K resolution up to 40 km and subsequently map the<br />

entire town in three dimensions to an accuracy of 2 cm. The obvious<br />

advantage of using a solar electric aircraft for such mission is that it<br />

can fly within a few hundred meters of any city without disturbing the<br />

residents. The direct operational costs are also very low.<br />

SolarStratos’ solar plane made<br />

the maiden <strong>flight</strong> in May<br />

The prototype was made by PC Aero. In late 2016, PC-Aero and<br />

Elektra UAS merged to form Elektra Solar GmbH with a particular<br />

emphasis on electric propulsion and robotic concepts. SolarStratos<br />

plans for manned stratospheric <strong>flight</strong> (up to 80,000ft) with an<br />

unmanned version for day-night solar stratospheric <strong>flight</strong>s under<br />

construction. The original Elektra single seater has been flying<br />

since 2011, with that aircraft now developed as the Elektra One<br />

Solar with solar panels on the much longer wings.<br />

Embry-Riddle formed Hybrid<br />

Consortium<br />

in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory, Airbus, Boeing,<br />

GE Aviation, Textron, Rolls Royce, Hartzell and Cape Air in June. Led<br />

by the university’s Eagle Flight Research Center (EFRC) based at its<br />

Daytona Beach, FL. campus, the Embry-Riddle Hybrid Consortium<br />

explored the design space for turbine/electric aircraft propulsion systems<br />

that reduce noise, emissions and operating costs. The ultimate<br />

goal is to produce a commercially viable, nine-passenger hybrid turboprop<br />

by 2025, and a large hybrid-electric jet by 2035.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

4


e News<br />

Zenair STOL CH750 transfers<br />

into electric bush plane<br />

Solar Ship and Zenair have reached an agreement in June<br />

to convert the Zenair STOL CH750 into an electric bush<br />

plane with ground solar charge stations. This new aircraft<br />

will provide extreme short takeoff and landing (XSTOL)<br />

capability enabling pilots to takeoff in areas without runways.<br />

The aircraft is recharged by either a battery swap<br />

or electric vehicle rechargers. It will not use any fossil fuel<br />

and will be available as a bush plane, float or amphibious.<br />

The Zenair electric planes are part of Solar Ship’s selfreliant<br />

infrastructure package to support critical cargo and<br />

air ambulance service in remote areas. The electric bush<br />

plane project is part of Zenair and Solar Ship’s ongoing<br />

partnership since 2011 when Zenair developed the fuselage<br />

for Solar Ship’s Zenship 11, a hybrid aircraft able to<br />

takeoff and land from a soccer field to deliver critical cargo<br />

for disaster relief.<br />

Joby Aviation is developing VTOL<br />

drone<br />

Fixed wing eVTOL aircraft developer Joby Aviation is developing a novel<br />

VTOL drone called Lotus, which has unique configuration with 2-bladed<br />

rotors mounted on the wingtip providing thrust in takeoff and landing, but<br />

scissor close in <strong>flight</strong> to become part of the wing. Lotus project is under contract<br />

with NASA and has its roots in the NASA “Dos Samara” UAV concept.<br />

Lotus project intends to develop a fixed wing VTOL with better cruising efficiency<br />

and lower noise. A future 275 lb-class hybrid-electric model development<br />

of this configuration has the potential to become the first VTOL aircraft<br />

to achieve 24-hour endurance.<br />

First World Future Sports Games in<br />

Dubai end of December <strong>2017</strong><br />

Dubai Museum of the Future Foundation announced that it will organize<br />

World Future Sports Games in December <strong>2017</strong> as the first initiative of its<br />

kind in the world featuring innovation and futuristic technology based<br />

sports competitions including manned drones. The World Future Sports<br />

Games was unveiled as Dubai announced Future Sports as a new innovation<br />

driven economic sector. The first edition of the World Future Sports<br />

Games will be hosted in Dubai from December 28-30, <strong>2017</strong>. The games<br />

will be held over three days once every two years, and will be open for participation<br />

from individuals, companies, academic institutions and research<br />

centers from around the world. The Games will feature nine competitions<br />

that employ modern technology and artificial intelligence: driverless car<br />

racing, robotic soccer, robotic running competitions, manned drones racing,<br />

robotic swimming, robotic table tennis, robotic wrestling, drones races<br />

and cybathlon competition.<br />

Echodyne with $ 29 million in<br />

new funding<br />

Echodyne, a Seattle startup<br />

building compact beam<br />

scanning radar units to<br />

help drones/automatic flying<br />

air taxi detect and avoid<br />

terrains and obstacles, has<br />

$ 29 million in new funding<br />

from Bill Gates and<br />

Paul Allen in May. Echodyne’s<br />

major product is<br />

the Metamaterial Electronically<br />

Scanning<br />

Array (MESA), a radar array that is small enough to mount<br />

on a drone or a manned autonomous aerial mobility vehicle.<br />

In November 2016, Echodyne demonstrated a MESA system<br />

that can automatically detect and evade oncoming aircraft<br />

and other obstacles. Their latest version can pick out<br />

a small Cessna aircraft from the equivalent of thirty football<br />

fields away, and a hobbyist DJI Phantom drone from 750<br />

meters.<br />

Electric aircraft fly-in in<br />

Switzerland<br />

The Swiss electric aviation advocate group Smartflyer Challenge<br />

is going to hold an electric aircraft fly-in on 9-10 September<br />

<strong>2017</strong> at Grenchen airport (LSZG) in Switzerland.<br />

There will be a static and air display for a variety of different<br />

electric- or hybrid powered aircraft including aerobatic airplanes,<br />

gliders, multicopters and so on.<br />

Pipistrel formed MAHEPA<br />

(Modular Approach to Hybrid-Electric Propulsion Architecture)<br />

in cooperation with Compact Dynamics, DLR, University<br />

of Ulm, H2Fly, Politecnico di Milano, TU Delft and University<br />

of Maribor. The main result of MAHEPA project will<br />

be novel, modular and scalable hybrid-electric powertrains<br />

capable of running on alternative fuels or on hydrogen with<br />

zero emissions.<br />

5 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

Toyota use wind turbine power to generate<br />

hydrogen from water<br />

Toyota began a new trial program with updated equipment to use wind turbine power<br />

to generate hydrogen from water in July. The trial program started in 2015 and has produced<br />

hydrogen to power 2 test forklift trucks. This new updated program will produce<br />

enough hydrogen to power 12 forklift trucks. Besides the energy program, Toyota has direct<br />

participation in electric aviation by providing about $ 35,0000 USD financial support<br />

to a flying car project that intends to be used to light the torch at the opening ceremony<br />

of the Tokyo Olympic Games in Summer 2018. Toyota also sent senior engineers to the<br />

UBER Elevate Summit conference in Dallas.<br />

The future of Transportation<br />

First US state governor to ride<br />

autonomously piloted aircraft<br />

Terry McAuliffe, the Virginia Governor, became the first US<br />

state governor to ride an autonomously piloted aircraft when<br />

he was the passenger in a Diamond DA-42 of the Aurora<br />

company in May. Terry McAuliffe has been heavily promoting<br />

the drone and autonomous <strong>flight</strong> technologies business in<br />

Virginia. Aurora’s DA-42 can be flown as an optional piloted<br />

airplane (OPA) with full autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control capability<br />

including autonomous takeoff and landings. In addition, Aurora’s<br />

robotic co-pilot rig has successfully landed a Boeing<br />

737 simulator. The robotic co-pilot rig can be adoptable and<br />

fitted in existing airplane models fairly quickly. Aurora is also<br />

one of the five current partner companies of UBER’s Elevate<br />

eVTOL on-demand aerial mobility project.<br />

At the “Future of Transportation World Conference” (July 5-6, in Cologne /<br />

Germany) in the session on “Getting Transportation Off the Ground” there<br />

were next to known players also some new e-<strong>flight</strong> concepts presented:<br />

Alma Flexcraft: The Portuguese company Almadesign works on a very-<br />

Short Take-Off and Landing (vSTOL) Flexcraft, with hybrid-electric power<br />

plant, 2 fan-in-wings and a pusher engine in the back between the two<br />

booms. This 8-passenger concept is part of the NewFACE, a cooperation<br />

of Almadesign, INEGI, SET and Embraer Compósitos, and the Technical<br />

University of Lisbon. Different propulsion schemes are being considered,<br />

as well as fuel cells for energy storage. Also there is the Israeli company Urban<br />

Aeronautics whose subsidiary Aurora Aircraft GmbH (founded in June<br />

<strong>2017</strong>) works on the Falcon XP, a 14-passenger version of the 4-passenger<br />

Urban Aeronautics/Metro Skyways CityHawk. “The aircraft will first run on<br />

jet fuel, later a hydrogen electric version is planed”.<br />

Geely acquired flying car<br />

company Terrafugia<br />

The Chinese car manufacturer Geely announced in July that<br />

they have acquired the flying car company Terrafugia. Chris<br />

Jaran, a former Vice President-China for Bell Helicopters and<br />

COO-Sikorsky Global Helicopters, was appointed as CEO of<br />

Terrafugia as of July <strong>2017</strong>. Geely is the owner of Volvo and<br />

Lotus and is active in electric mobility and autonomous technology<br />

development. Besides the Transition flying car that<br />

Terrafugia has been developing light sports aircraft qualified,<br />

in May 2013 Terrafugia announced the successor of the Transition<br />

called the TF-X which would be a plug-in hybrid tilt-rotor<br />

VTOL vehicle and would be a fully autonomous flying car.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

6


e News<br />

RX1E is getting upgrade with<br />

battery rescue system<br />

​The Chinese electric light sports airplane RX1E is developing<br />

an upgrade model with large battery capacity and BRS’<br />

whole airframe rescue parachute system. Issued with a LSA<br />

type approval and production certificate by the Chinese<br />

civil aviation administrator, RX1E was the first type certified<br />

electric airplane model in the world. The current production<br />

model has a <strong>flight</strong> time of about one hour.<br />

NASA Cafe EAS in Oshkosh<br />

The Comparative Aircraft Flight Efficiency (CAFE) foundation will hold the<br />

<strong>2017</strong> Electric Aircraft Symposium on 22-23 July <strong>2017</strong> at the University of<br />

Wisconsin Oshkosh. The subject of this year will be “Urban Air Mobility:<br />

Emerging Technologies and Early Market Opportunities”. Keynote speakers<br />

from NASA, GAMA, Siemens, Pipistrel, Zee Aero, Eviation, and various investor<br />

groups and other companies will cover all relevant issues of electric<br />

aviation from regulation and policy to electric airplane model update and<br />

implementation programs. Beginning in 2007, CAFE foundation’s Electric<br />

Aircraft Symposium is the earliest electric aviation event in the US. This<br />

year’s conference will coincide with EAA Airventure’s date and location so<br />

as to make it easier to participate.<br />

Electric Flight Forum in November in<br />

Beijing<br />

The first global e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum, organized by Flying Pages GmhH and local<br />

partners, will be held in Beijing China in November <strong>2017</strong>. This will be the first<br />

electric aviation themed event in China. Besides the global players in electric<br />

aviation, Chinese high-profile participants will include the Chinese policymakers,<br />

national research groups, major general aviation operators and<br />

various investor groups. As the Chinese central government has set a high<br />

goal for the general aviation development in China by 2020 and explicitly<br />

supports new energy aircraft designs and e-mobility at large, electric aviation<br />

has drawn significant attention in China, for example, the Chinese RX1E<br />

LSA became the first type certified electric airplane in the world in 2015.<br />

Kitty Hawk and more e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

at Airventure<br />

Kitty Hawk, the electric aviation startup founded by Google’s<br />

Larry Page, is going to present its single seat eVTOL preproduction<br />

model to the public for the first time at EAA Airventure<br />

this month. Kitty Hawk may also make demo <strong>flight</strong>s<br />

at the seaplane base at Lake Winnebago. Kitty Hawk has<br />

begun accepting order deposits for this single seat FAR103<br />

compliant ultralight eVTOL which, if launched at the end of<br />

this year as planned, will be the world’s first commercially<br />

available eVTOL.<br />

At the EAA Airventure in July, aerospace innovation products<br />

will be on display at Aviation Gateway Park, home of the Innovation<br />

Center at AirVenture Oshkosh. Presenting products<br />

will include the Workhorse SureFly eVTOL aircraft, Kitty Hawk<br />

single seat eVTOL and a Detroit Flying Cars prototype as<br />

well as Pipistrels Alpha elektro the sunflyer and much more..<br />

7 e Flight Journal


e News<br />

Tecnam delivered P2006T Twin NASA X-57<br />

electric powered propulsion program<br />

Tecnam delivered the second P2006T Twin for NASA X-57<br />

electric powered propulsion program in July. X-57 is the first<br />

NASA X-plane to feature a fully distributed electric propulsion<br />

system, which researchers will use to demonstrate an<br />

increase in cruise energy efficiency, as well as reductions in<br />

carbon emission and aircraft noise. The wing will be manufactured<br />

and integrated on the P2006T fuselage by the US<br />

based company Xperimental. Researchers hope to fly an<br />

early version of the modified Tecnam P2006T piloted X-plane<br />

early next year, enabling NASA engineers to easily compare<br />

the performance of the X-57 version with the standard production<br />

Tecnam P2006T Twin.<br />

Man flying an electric multicopter<br />

delivered soccer ball<br />

At the Portuguese Soccer Cup Final game in May, a man<br />

flying an electric multicopter delivered the soccer ball to the<br />

referee. Footage of the amazing futuristic stunt shows a man<br />

riding an obvious electric multicopter at around a 70 m height<br />

in rain before landing by the match official near the halfway<br />

line and handing the ball over and then flying away. The editor’s<br />

warning: do not attempt this at home. The rider’s feet<br />

were only centimeters away from spinning propellers and in<br />

case of a crash landing the flying height was too high without<br />

causing serious injury or worse too low to use a parachute.<br />

For those who are more curious about the game, Benfica<br />

won the game 2-1, beating Vitória de Guimarães and they<br />

completed their 11th league and cup double.<br />

MAKS:<br />

Electric aircraft from Russia<br />

At the Russian MAKS Airshow Sergey Korotkov, chief designer<br />

of the Russian United Aircraft Corporation (UAC),<br />

announced on Thursday, July 20th, <strong>2017</strong> that “UAC is proceeding<br />

with the development of electric aircraft for civil and<br />

military use. Yesterday, for example, a range of agreements<br />

on batteries were signed that will provide planes with new<br />

energy.”<br />

Lilium Jet test flew two-seat<br />

prototype of eVTOL<br />

Lilium Jet successfully test flew its two-seat prototype of the<br />

eVTOL by remote control in April. The novel feature of the<br />

design is the setup of the series of electric fans on the flaps<br />

of the main wing and the canard wing so that it can generate<br />

lift with small wing area to reach high cruising speed while<br />

maintain low speed controllability. The near full wing span<br />

electric fans blowing over the wing surface at cruising stage<br />

also help maintain laminar flow to lower the drag. Lilium Jet<br />

plans to develop up to 5-seater model to be used for ondemand<br />

aerial mobility.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

8


e Training & more<br />

ONE OF THE BEST TIME<br />

in aeronautical history?<br />

Zunum, the company financed by<br />

Boeing and Jetblue, wants to fly hybrid<br />

electric with passengers soon.<br />

XTI starts vertically and then flies quick like a jet - thanks<br />

to e-fans which you can swivel.<br />

Now may be the best time for aircraft designers ever<br />

since the jet age. Taking the advantages of smaller, faster<br />

and cheaper computer chips and sensors, cheaper<br />

and more powerful batteries and motors, autonomous<br />

software from smart phones, consumer drones, and automobile<br />

industries, electric aircraft and new concepts<br />

for electric vertical <strong>flight</strong> are mushrooming. In fact there<br />

are so many new electric vertical takeoff and landing<br />

(eVTOL) designs showing up since the last issue of WDLA,<br />

that a newly added “multirotor” category in the WDLA issue<br />

of this year says for itself.<br />

This eVTOL concept became a hot topic when Uber released<br />

its white paper on an on-demand eVTOL urban mobility called<br />

“Elevate” last October, and became viral after the Elevate Summit<br />

conference in Dallas, USA this April. When anything draws the attention<br />

of Silicon Valley, it is on the fast track. Silicon Valley has the<br />

passion, determination, capital(lots of), and the desire to succed.<br />

Kitty Hawk’s eVTOL is now open for pre-order. Elon Musk has<br />

mentioned the supersonic (that’s correct) eVTOL aircraft at a dozen<br />

occasions. Even Airbus set up its eVTOL branch at Silicon<br />

Valley. The Elevate Summit is a gathering of who’s who in the<br />

aerospace community. Almost all the names you have heard of<br />

or are about to hear of in the industry showed up. Uber ended up<br />

forming partnerships with five aircraft manufacturers to design, build<br />

and test eVTOL prototypes by 2020. Dubai has partnered with<br />

Volocopter to test fly their X2 multirotor in the Dubai city by the end<br />

of year. Dallas, US is also eager to try out the urban aerial mobility<br />

concept. Tilt wings, tilt rotors, multirotor, multi electric ducted fans<br />

(EDF), fixed wings, helicopters are all the indicators of the diversity,<br />

possibilities and excitement brought about by electric aviation.<br />

Startups and Sillicon Valley are not the only players in this game.<br />

Incumbant are all in. Just look at the member companies of electric<br />

population and innovation committee (EPIC) of GAMA. Airbus has<br />

set up two separate entities for electric aviation research, in silicon<br />

Valley developing the Vahana eVTOL planned for test <strong>flight</strong> within the<br />

year, and the Urban Air Mobility division at the head office respectively.<br />

Airbus has decided to upgrade its F-Fan fixed wing project to E-Fan X,<br />

a hybrid/electric regional passenger airplane. Boeing, jointly with Jet<br />

Blue, invested in Zunum Aero to develop hybrid/electric regional aircraft<br />

as well. Bell helicopter and Embraer signed up with Uber to develop<br />

eVTOL technologies.<br />

9 e Flight Journal


e Training & more<br />

This e-heli flew in 2016 - now<br />

the French manufacturer<br />

Aquinea wants to build a<br />

two seater as well.<br />

The “Workhorse” of the US manufacturer Surefly was<br />

shown in Paris airshow <strong>2017</strong> and flies hybrid-electric.<br />

Electric aviation shows a powerful cross-over application among<br />

different industries. The collaboration between Airbus and<br />

Siemens have proved that. Many technologies and products<br />

such as autonomous vehicle control, detect and avoid, battery<br />

and motor, advanced composite manufacturing progress can be<br />

utilized by many other industries. The line between aviation and<br />

other industries becomes so blurred. Some electric aviation startups<br />

have already hired much more electric engineers than aeronautical<br />

engineers.<br />

For pilots and especially for new pilots who are just about to begin<br />

training, the cheaper, quieter and more environmental and neighbor<br />

community friendly electric <strong>flight</strong> now becomes more practical<br />

and closer to reality than ever. Not only several electric airplanes<br />

have obtained certification such as Pipistrel’s Alpha Electro (UL/<br />

LSA in Australia) and the Chinese RX1E (LSA).<br />

But although the situation light –electric Aircraft in many countries<br />

is still unclear for the Microlight in Europe (demand for weight increase<br />

pending) and LSA in USA (no electric motors allowed in<br />

LSA class) several electric <strong>flight</strong> training programs have been set<br />

up.<br />

The Swiss company AlpinAirPlanes is going to deploy ten Alpha<br />

Electro at ten trial airfields with <strong>flight</strong> schools, Each airfield has a<br />

solar power recharging station and the distance between the airfields<br />

is so that with the 1.5 hours of endurance of the aircraft<br />

you always can reach at least 1 of the other fields. A similar project<br />

will start this summer in Fresno county in California (USA) a team<br />

around Joseph Oldham.<br />

They will purchase 4 Alpha electro and use it in <strong>flight</strong>shools from 4<br />

airfields. Interresting that both projects are financed by sponsors and<br />

state support and in both countries the authorities allowed to fly in<br />

this Testphase in the <strong>flight</strong> Training with permit to fly.<br />

Pipistrels´ Alpha Electro is going<br />

to be used in <strong>flight</strong> training<br />

programs around the world -<br />

France, Switzerland and USA are<br />

starting this summer.<br />

Two more <strong>flight</strong> trainings using the Alpha electro one is organized<br />

by SpaceX because after an old US law all astronauts must have<br />

a pilots licence. So the private space travel organizer is going<br />

to train the future space tourist on the 2 Alpha Electro which will<br />

be delivered at Oshkosh <strong>2017</strong>. And finally the French Aeroclub<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

10


e Training & more<br />

Siemens Power for the Extra: The aerobatic aircraft tows the glider with a speed of 9.5 m/s.<br />

Federation Française Aeronautique (FFA) announced at the Paris<br />

Airshow <strong>2017</strong> that they purchased 3 Alpha electro which will fly with<br />

first Permit to Fly and than later CS-VLA The French authorities will<br />

handle the operations and Pipistrel do the certification with EASA.<br />

In all cases also standard Rotax Alphas will be available to assure<br />

that the new pilots also can fly with combustion engine aircraft.<br />

The most exciting news about electric <strong>flight</strong> training came at the<br />

Paris Airshow when the French Federation of Aeronautics announced<br />

they will using Alpha Electro as a private pilot training<br />

program. Now that’s serious stuff.<br />

Another example for e-development getting practice news has<br />

been the worlds first e-<strong>flight</strong>-show which accompanied the e-<strong>flight</strong>expo<br />

at the AERO exhibition.<br />

The diversity and implementation of electric aviation is more<br />

than eVTOL and <strong>flight</strong> training. The Swiss company H55, is<br />

now working with the Solar Impulse project co-founder and pilot<br />

André Borschberg, they used the Silence Aircraft Twister and<br />

with Siemens they developed a single seat aerobatic airplane. At<br />

the AERO <strong>2017</strong> another Siss company MSW presented the project<br />

Evolaris an electric aerobatic plane with an empty weight of<br />

500 KG and 221 Kw e engine power.<br />

Finally at the moment the most impressive e-Plane<br />

the Extra 330 LE, another high performance electric<br />

aerobatic airplane jointly developed by Extra Aircraft and Siemens,<br />

have successfully demonstrated the aerobatic performance as<br />

well as the capacity of glider towing and has beaten several world<br />

Nikhil Goel from UBER at “Elevate” conference<br />

in Dallas April <strong>2017</strong> which gave a big<br />

push to the VTOL scene.<br />

11 e Flight Journal


e Training & more<br />

eVolos 2X will start passenger transport test in Dubai in <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

records. At Paris Airshow the aircraft towed up an aerobatic glider<br />

to 1000 Meter (with an average climb rate of 9.5 Meters per second)<br />

than the glider performed aerobatics while the Extra landed<br />

and then after the glider landed the Extra, without recharging, took<br />

off again and for an impressive aerobatic show with 260 Kw on<br />

the prop.<br />

Even more serious is when a national government wants to explore<br />

the possibility of using electric aircraft and wants to become<br />

a leading country in this fiel, like the Norwegian Government has<br />

announced in spring <strong>2017</strong>. The country which achieved the highest<br />

density of electric cars per inhabitant in the past 10 years over<br />

a government program is evaluating the possibilities of electrifying<br />

the network of state owned Airfields around the country. The<br />

conditions are ideal. As Norway has money in the budget from the<br />

oil, and a production of electric energy from water turbines which<br />

exceeds its consumption. It also has a net of airfield from which a<br />

lot of commuter <strong>flight</strong>s with mostly under 300 KM distance are operated<br />

as part of the state transport plan, because the road network is<br />

very loose and ground transport out of the centers slow.<br />

The brave new world of electric aviation is forming. We sincerely<br />

hope that you are as excited as we are to read the intriguing new<br />

electric aircraft designs in the following pages in nearly all categories<br />

and the new VTOL - aviation section of WDLA, and to look forward<br />

even just five years from today.<br />

The Multicopter Whisper<br />

from France flies with eight<br />

Plettenberg motors.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

12


Expo<br />

Market Watch<br />

25 th ANNIVERSARY<br />

„<br />

A Celebration of<br />

Electric Aviation<br />

For the celebration of the 25th AERO in Friedrichshafen/Germany, there was<br />

not only an in-house celebration but also a series of world premieres which<br />

included the largest scale e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo to date as well as the world’s first e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-show with e-Aerobatic and the first electric formation <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

In 25 years AERO has developed into the largest<br />

general aviation trade show in Europe,<br />

as well as the leading fair for innovative aviation<br />

technologies in the world. The best showcase<br />

of AERO’s innovative nature is e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo<br />

which AERO founded together with Flying<br />

Pages GmbH in 2009. In its 9th year, the e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-expo was bigger than ever. It has grown<br />

so much that it no longer fits into its original location<br />

in the Forum West, but instead now occupies<br />

the entire hall A7 spanning 6200 square<br />

meters. A7 hall is conveniently located directly<br />

at the East entrance and thus is also at Forum<br />

East, where the e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo lectures occur.<br />

The move to the hall A7 was also necessary<br />

The pilots of the worlds first e-<strong>flight</strong>-show with its organization<br />

team Willi Tacke (left) and Roland Bosch (3rd from left).<br />

13 e Flight Journal


e F light expo & E F light show<br />

Market Watch<br />

because the hall has large hangar doors and access to the<br />

airfield. This is important because the e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo also had<br />

wings in <strong>2017</strong> and launched for the world’s first time the e-<br />

<strong>flight</strong>-show celebrating the premiere of AERO!<br />

In addition to the NASA-awarding hybrid touring motor glider<br />

E-Genius, three aircraft powered by Siemens electric motors<br />

took off at e-<strong>flight</strong>-show: an E-Extra 330LE and two e-<br />

Fusions showed the world’s first e-formation <strong>flight</strong>. The Extra<br />

completed an aerobatics sequence, along with the aerobatic<br />

performance of Hangar 55 Hamilton aEro, an E-robatic<br />

aircraft from Switzerland. The Antares of Lange Aviation,<br />

the most sold and so far the only series produced e-plane,<br />

also participated in the e-<strong>flight</strong>-show. The pure electric flying<br />

show took place twice during AERO, on Tuesday, for the<br />

press day for media representatives and invited guests and<br />

on Saturday to celebrate the 25th anniversary of AERO, a<br />

mixed <strong>flight</strong> show with electric and conventionally driven<br />

engines.<br />

Day one of the AERO experience was a review of the electric<br />

aircraft innovations. This is a rapidly changing technology<br />

with both motors and applications showing up all over<br />

the place. The main concentration of electric systems is in<br />

Hall A7, where everyone from small startups with small motor<br />

solutions all the way up to the heavyweight in the industry,<br />

Siemens, are all in this location. Just as the show has<br />

many prototype aircraft, which may have never flown before,<br />

Hall A7 has prototype motors that may have never been installed<br />

on a production aircraft.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

14


Expo<br />

Of course it takes a while for prototype motors to make their<br />

way onto production aircraft. So a walk around the halls<br />

quickly reveals that the motors from another German company,<br />

Geiger Engineering, are becoming popular. Geiger is<br />

currently producing five motors ranging from 12 KW to 50<br />

KW (16 hp - 68 hp) making them popular for a variety of airframes.<br />

Even more appealing is that Geiger is one of the<br />

companies offering complete systems from battery packs<br />

designed for aviation all the way through propellers.<br />

Many of the motors are for very light applications such as<br />

light weight shift control trikes or gliders. But motors are becoming<br />

more powerful with the increase in power; new technical<br />

problems need to become overcome. For example, the<br />

larger the power capability of the motor, the more cooling is<br />

required for the motor. Smaller motors are mostly air-cooled,<br />

but some of the medium and larger motors require liquid<br />

cooling. This doesn’t mean that the motors have radiators,<br />

but liquid is built into the motor to help keep heat away from<br />

hot spots that are created when electricity is converted to<br />

mechanical power. This seems to parallel thermal engines,<br />

where small engines are air cooled, but larger engines need<br />

more complex cooling systems. There are three components<br />

to electrical power systems. You have the motor itself,<br />

the batteries, and the controller. The controller makes sure<br />

that the proper amount of electricity is delivered to the motor.<br />

Most of the electric motor developers are also developing<br />

controllers for their motors since the two work with each other<br />

so closely. Some companies, such as the German company<br />

Geiger, are offering complete systems from batteries to<br />

motor, and sometimes even propellers.<br />

Furthermore, in Hall A7 the improved Volocopter, the world’s<br />

most advanced electric gyrocopter and the world’s most advanced<br />

hybrid amphibian can be seen. A detailed list can be<br />

found on the following pages. The lecture and forum program<br />

is also bigger and more meaningful than ever.<br />

The e-<strong>flight</strong> lecture program took place again in the Forum<br />

East. After Tom Gunnarson’s first talks about “Electric<br />

Propulsion Standard Development”, Tom Gunnarson<br />

opened the round at Wednesday, 1.45 pm, with a high-profile<br />

panel discussion on “From Today’s Electric Aircraft - to<br />

Electric On Demand Mobility.” In addition to leading managers<br />

of aircraft and engine manufacturers, EASA and the<br />

well-known American transport-on-demand company UBER<br />

were also present. Ever since UBER released the Elevate<br />

program whitepaper last October, on-demand electric vertical<br />

takeoff and landing (eVTOL) became a phenomenal concept<br />

in the mass media. For your information, Daimler is also<br />

involved in the company. At the e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum Mark Moore<br />

of UBER gave an extensive presentation of the Elevate program.<br />

Mark Moore is a NASA veteran who was the head of<br />

the NASA Electric Xplane program before joining UBER. On<br />

the final day of e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum, the prestigious e-<strong>flight</strong>-award<br />

was announced and presented to AlpinAirPlanes, an electric<br />

airplane training program in Swiss using Pipiestral’s Alpha<br />

Electric.<br />

One company is not only developing a motor and controller,<br />

Qinetix, a German company, is placing the controller in<br />

the case along with the engine. It means that aircraft builders<br />

only have to mount the motor and run power leads to it. The<br />

QPD-40 is an integrated system that is actually designed to<br />

be an electric replacement for the old Rotax 503 2-stroke engine.<br />

The designer explained that he had a trike with that<br />

engine and wanted the replacement for himself. He figured<br />

others would want it, too. The motor is still being tested and<br />

should be available later this year. Expected specs are: 40<br />

KW (53 hp) power and 12 Kg (26 lbs) weight.<br />

15 e Flight Journal


Expo<br />

h<br />

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE e-FLIGHT-EXPO IN <strong>2017</strong> ARE:<br />

Siemens: the leading e-aviation technology developer<br />

Votec221: new electric aerobatic airplane from Swiss.<br />

The engine almost matches Siemens’ power/weight ratio.<br />

Ground tested, not flown yet. Unusual paint scheme done<br />

by an artist.<br />

aEro: electric aerobatic airplane jointly developed by<br />

Silence, Siemens, Hamilton and Hanger 55. Test flown last<br />

year. Serial production down the road.<br />

Eurosport Crossover: new hybrid power system this year<br />

with new combustion engine as generator.<br />

Equator P2 Xcursion: hybrid amphibian new design from Norway,<br />

full electric version and another hybrid/electric four-seat cruiser airplane<br />

in vision.<br />

Pipistrel: the leading<br />

company in electric aviation<br />

is going to begin several<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong> training programs<br />

in Switzerland, US<br />

and France.<br />

Autogyro eCavalon: the first electric gyroplane jointly developed<br />

with Bosch.<br />

Nirvana driving motor: an innovative electric driving front<br />

wheel design for existing gyroplane models. Already certified<br />

for road drive in Czech Republic. Retrofit available now<br />

for various gyroplane models. Turn your gyroplane into a flying<br />

car simply and easily.<br />

Senkel flying bicycle: an innovative electric flying bicycle<br />

design. Combining the light weight of both a bicycle and<br />

a powered parachute, it is an easy and simply conversion<br />

from an electric-assisted incumbent bicycle to an electric<br />

powered parachute. The designer also proposed an open<br />

source program for electric motor design.<br />

e-genius: the winner of multiple e-aviation competition and<br />

the holder of several e-aviation world record. It presents a<br />

new hybrid power system. University of Stuttgart / Germany,<br />

where this e-airplane is born, also presented.<br />

Comos Ikarus e-C42: an<br />

electric version of the popular<br />

C-42 using Geiger<br />

motor.<br />

Engiro motor: new hybrid<br />

power system. 30kw generator<br />

model in production,<br />

60kw down the road<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

16


Uber UBER Elevate<br />

UBER Elevate chief engineer Mark Moor (ex NASA X-plane developer) with VTOL designers from all over the world.<br />

From e-<strong>flight</strong> to „on-demand mobility“<br />

Is the UBER-plane<br />

Coming Next?<br />

In recent years, hardly has an event has inspired the imagination of<br />

aircraft developers, pilots and investors like the announcement of<br />

the online co-driver company UBER with its program ELEVATE to<br />

create a worldwide platform for a passenger service with a vertical<br />

air taxi.<br />

If designers are fantasizing about fantastic<br />

new aircraft ideas, then usually only a few insiders<br />

move. Even for serious world conglomerates<br />

such as Airbus or Siemens and others from electric aviation,<br />

“that is still years away” but UBER may have a different<br />

mindset. After all, Uber has managed to catapult its stock<br />

market value to more than $60 billion US in less than 5 years.<br />

What is significant in terms of business model is that Uber<br />

is still in a deficit today, but it thrives solely due to the vision<br />

that makes the almost impossible possible. This mindset is<br />

certainly necessary for the Elevate program, because Uber<br />

not only needs to overcome the technical obstacles of the<br />

low battery density, but also needs to find a way to convince<br />

the certification regulators and traffic control authorities.<br />

At the end of April at the UBER Elevate meeting in Dallas, not<br />

only companies that wanted to share the vision and make<br />

technology possible were there, but also the air traffic authorities.<br />

The FAA has teamed with a whole team, which together<br />

with the GAMA (the General Aviation Manufacturers<br />

Association), to hold a full day seminar on how to integrate<br />

the new electric aircraft with a vertical takeoff option<br />

into the new Part 23 registration requirements that the FAA<br />

are currently working on. Especially, when looking into the<br />

17 e Flight Journal


Uber UBER elevate Elevate<br />

Ivo Boscarol, CEO of Pipistrel and one of the UBER partners, explains his Vision of WTOL: flying from window at home to the<br />

window at work.<br />

future, these eVTOL aircraft can also be used as computer-controlled<br />

“on demand” air taxis. All possible options<br />

were considered, from the construction of the power supply<br />

for the inner city landing places for these machines<br />

to the noise problem. And why - at least in the opinion of<br />

the UBER-Elevate chief technician, multi-rotor concepts<br />

are preferable in any case to conventional helicopters.<br />

Illustrate list of partners<br />

The list of participating company representatives is somewhat<br />

like the “Who’s Who” of modern technology: car and<br />

motorcycle manufacturers such as Toyota, Yamaha, And<br />

Kawasaki, Boeing Embrair and Airbus, tech companies like<br />

Siemens and GE - it was all represented for what the future<br />

wants to design. Larry Page has already put more than 100<br />

million dollars in the companies Zee AERO and Kitty Hawk.<br />

Amazon has long established its department of drones and<br />

next to Intel is now also Microsoft due to its purchase of<br />

Skype, which has the European VTOL company Lilium.<br />

At the same time, the requirements of UBER are very specific<br />

when one looks at the capabilities that the machines<br />

should have. Besides vertical takeoff capability the aircraft<br />

should fly only with battery, can carry four people,<br />

and can cover a distance of up to 80 miles with up to 160<br />

mph. “In my opinion, just because of the range, pure multicopter<br />

sets are excluded,” explains Mark Moore, the UBER<br />

Elevate chief who has served a long career at NASA where<br />

he studied distributed propulsion systems, which produced<br />

an effective interplay between propellers and fixed<br />

wings to make an optimization aerodynamic solution.<br />

It was noted that Volocopter was not invited to the presentation,<br />

but Daniel Wiegand head of Lilium was.<br />

Just three days before the conference, Lilium’s unmanned<br />

prototype had its first <strong>flight</strong>. Interestingly, although<br />

the requirements are very specific, the concepts<br />

are very different. Also interesting is the selection<br />

of the partners that UBER presented at the conference.<br />

There was the American helicopter manufacturer Bell<br />

Helicopter along with the general aviation manufacturer<br />

Mooney. Another partner was Gyrocopter pioneer Jay Carter<br />

that has a gyrocopter concept, which starts and lands by<br />

means of the electric drive of the main rotor and the thrust propeller.<br />

Uber’s third partner is AURORA, an American technology<br />

developer and defense contractor who has recently been<br />

developing a huge unmanned electrically driven transporter.<br />

The concept, which AURORA presented at the UBER conference<br />

in Dallas, is a multicopter with eight rotors and<br />

wings. “The wings are necessary, because they consume<br />

much less energy than the multicopter to generate<br />

the boost during the cruise <strong>flight</strong> or helicopter.”<br />

The fourth manufacturer at the presentation was the<br />

Brazilian airline and military aircraft manufacturer Embraer.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

18


UBER Elevate<br />

After the<br />

successful<br />

first <strong>flight</strong>,<br />

Daniel<br />

Wiegand<br />

from Lilium<br />

explaines the<br />

concept of<br />

the Lilium<br />

Jet, which is<br />

a VTOL with<br />

300 km/h<br />

top speed.<br />

Greg Bowls from GAMA explains how the manufacturers<br />

association is already working with the FAA and others on<br />

certification guidelines.<br />

Pipistrel is on board<br />

The actual surprise for most of those present was the fifth<br />

of Uber’s chosen partners. It is the company Pipistrel from<br />

Slovenia! They are mostly previously known for ultra-light<br />

aircraft with high performance and good processing, as<br />

for the electrification. Pipistrel chief engineer Tine Tomaciz<br />

gave the technical presentation of the company. He was,<br />

as usual brilliant, but in the end he gave no answer to the<br />

question as to what Pipistrel’s VTOL project would look<br />

like.<br />

Jay Carter of Carter Copter works - together with Mooney -<br />

on a electrical operated gyro with vertical takeoff capabilities<br />

and fixedwings.<br />

From VTOL to WTOL<br />

On the other hand, Ivo Boscaroll, who also gave a presentation<br />

on the best plan of a transport system with taxis. One<br />

more thing: At the end of his presentation, he said: “We do<br />

not need VTOL but WTOL.” The “W” stands for Windows<br />

and means that the <strong>flight</strong> taxis will in the future pick up<br />

their passengers directly at the window of their apartment<br />

on the floor of a high-rise building and then fly directly to<br />

the window of their office. He ended his entertaining PPT<br />

by saying that although a large investment from China had<br />

been received last year, it was certainly necessary for the<br />

The AirspaceX MOBi from Airspace Experience Technologies<br />

in Birmingham, Michigan, USA.<br />

Olaf Otto<br />

from<br />

Siemens<br />

explains in a<br />

discussion,<br />

how e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

will be able<br />

to reduce<br />

noise in<br />

flying.<br />

Pipistrels Ivo Boscarol together with Yuneec boss Tian Yu<br />

(right), who also presented VTOL concepts in Dallas which<br />

he is evaluating for manned and unmanned purpose.<br />

19 e Flight Journal


UBER Elevate<br />

development of WTOL and that this was a good investment.<br />

Investors, this was an interesting point at the Dallas conference!<br />

On the evening of the first day, there was a panel<br />

discussion of five bosses from major investment firms<br />

who expressed their willingness to provide good technical<br />

developments in this area with capital, and one investment<br />

project was also immediately announced: an e-<strong>flight</strong><br />

VTOL-UBER-fund.<br />

From Siemens to Yuneec<br />

It was also interesting to see who else was among the<br />

speakers. Siemens, for example, showed the latest development<br />

of the Extra 300 LE. Though the electric version<br />

might look otherwise identical to the combustion version,<br />

the electrical variant is not only significantly quieter, but also<br />

even the noise also felt more pleasant.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The development at UBER is certainly to be observed closely<br />

for various reasons. Due to the fact that many top companies<br />

from different areas with money and developments,<br />

UBER Elevate will in any case promote the development<br />

of e-mobility and assist the autonomous flying. One aspect<br />

that needs to be considered is that it has a potentially<br />

negative note alongside all the positive ones in the context<br />

of environmental protection. If, indeed, some taxis and delivery<br />

trucks are going to fly through the cities and cities,<br />

will there still be room for human pilots who simply want to<br />

fly? Probably not possible, because human-controlled airplanes<br />

are just as disruptive as pedestrians and cyclists to<br />

a self-driving car on the open road. For the complete presentation<br />

and panel discussion, you can watch the videos<br />

of the UBER event at www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com.<br />

Aurora - a<br />

UBER partner<br />

- has<br />

experience<br />

in VTOL<br />

design and<br />

is working<br />

on its eVTOL<br />

(left photo).<br />

Investor<br />

panel: five<br />

venture<br />

capital investors<br />

showed<br />

that they<br />

are willing<br />

to invest in<br />

a “Demand<br />

Air Vehicle”<br />

(right<br />

photo).<br />

Large presence<br />

from<br />

the media:<br />

Mark Moore<br />

from UBER<br />

explains to a<br />

TV journalist<br />

the UBER<br />

approach.<br />

German Arne Stoschek from Silicon Valley Airbus subsidiary<br />

A³, explains how Vahana will revolutionize passenger<br />

transportation.<br />

The first test<br />

scenarios<br />

are already<br />

planned<br />

for 2020 in<br />

Dallas and<br />

Dubai.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

20


e Training<br />

Fight Training<br />

in Whisper Mode<br />

Around the World<br />

The training of pilots and the resulting high number of takeoff’s and<br />

landings are increasingly perceived as very disturbing by the neighbors<br />

of the airport. Several initiatives around the world try to solve<br />

the issue by using electric airplanes.<br />

AlpinAirPlanes GmbH in Switzerland:<br />

Jean-Luc Charron<br />

(middle),<br />

Christian Stuck<br />

(right) and<br />

Ivo Boscarol<br />

(left) at Paris<br />

Airshow <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

A new approach from Switzerland now wants to take the<br />

wind out of the sails. The company AlpinAirPlanes GmbH is<br />

based on the fully electric Alpha Electro airplane of Pipistrel,<br />

an advancement of the Pipistrel Alpha trainer. With a secured<br />

<strong>flight</strong> time of 45 minutes Alpha Electro is very suitable<br />

for the training <strong>flight</strong>. Now the photovoltaic specialist<br />

SolSystems GmbH became the focus of AlpinAirPlanes<br />

and the project. The idea of a whole network of e-airfields in<br />

Switzerland was born.<br />

21 e Flight Journal


e Training<br />

SOLAR EQUIPMENT FOR E-Airfields<br />

Specifically, this project will look like this: First of all, a fleet<br />

of Alpha Electro airplanes will be distributed across this alpine<br />

republic among 10 flying schools under the leadership<br />

of «Eco<strong>flight</strong>» in Mollis. In addition, each of these e-<strong>flight</strong> bases<br />

will receive a charging station with a solar system for the<br />

ecological generation of electricity. This would allow the stations<br />

to recharge the e-airplanes at the airfields.<br />

All FOCO-registered <strong>flight</strong> schools in Switzerland are invited<br />

to participate in this project. The corresponding applications<br />

have to be submitted by the end of April. The cost for the aircraft,<br />

charging stations and solar power add up to around<br />

200,000 Swiss francs, but a leasing model is also possible<br />

on a per hour basis, in particular for the solar system. In principle,<br />

<strong>flight</strong> school partners should operate their e-airplane<br />

for at least 300 hours per year. The corresponding monthly<br />

reports will be collected and evaluated by the project initiator<br />

AlpinAirPlanes GmbH, since the project also aims to improve<br />

and further develop the technology.<br />

Beginning in Summer <strong>2017</strong><br />

The project will start in summer <strong>2017</strong> and will run until<br />

September 30, 2018. The delivery of the e-aircraft will be with<br />

a frequency of one airplane per month. Therefore, the last<br />

<strong>flight</strong> school partner will not receive their aircraft until spring<br />

2018. They are, of course, not obligated until September<br />

2018 to reach the planned 300 hours of use. Rather, the project<br />

tends to bring all ten aircraft together to 2500 <strong>flight</strong> hours.<br />

The maintenance and upgrades of the fleet are organized<br />

and implemented by AlpinAirPlanes in collaboration with<br />

local certified CAMOs. In this first phase, AlpinAirPlanes will<br />

incur the maintenance costs. A replacement aircraft, which<br />

is based at the base of AlpinAirPlanes, will ensure the permanent<br />

availability of ten aircraft from spring 2018 onwards.<br />

The AlpinAirPlanes will also draw up a curriculum for the<br />

<strong>flight</strong> schools. The necessary permits in Switzerland have<br />

already been obtained.<br />

Fresno, California<br />

Subsidized by local funds from Fresno County, a fleet of four<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro trainers will be made available for primary<br />

training in California’s Central Valley late this year, program<br />

organizers hope. Fresno County will be installing chargers<br />

for the aircraft at four local airports: Mendota, Reedley,<br />

Fresno Chandler and a fourth airport is to be determined.<br />

The Alpha Electro has an 85-knot cruising speed making<br />

round-trip, cross-country <strong>flight</strong>s a stretch. Joseph Oldham,<br />

Sustainability Manager for the City of Fresno, said that the<br />

fourth airport will ideally be just over 50 NM, permitting the<br />

Alphas to make one-way <strong>flight</strong>s meeting private pilot crosscountry<br />

training requirements, recharge in about 45 minutes<br />

and return home. The fallback plan is for students to<br />

do cross-country training in the piston-powered version of<br />

the Alpha.<br />

Fresno county hopes to have the new aircraft on hand and<br />

high-voltage chargers installed at the four chosen airports<br />

by the fall of this year. The FAA has not yet released a paradigm<br />

for approving electric propulsion airplanes, either in<br />

certified aircraft or in light sports, as Pipistrel plans for the<br />

Alpha Electro. Oldham is working with the FAA about approval<br />

of electric LSAs, the last major hurdle in Fresno’s<br />

Pipistrel Alpha‘s<br />

electric<br />

identity is<br />

distinctive,<br />

indicating the<br />

company‘s<br />

faith in the<br />

technology.<br />

All four of the<br />

current training<br />

programs<br />

chose Alpha<br />

as the trainer.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

22


e Training<br />

race to get the Alpha Electros into service. The aircraft will<br />

likely be available for rent by area pilots, but the priority users<br />

of the aircraft will be veterans and low-income youth<br />

seeking primary <strong>flight</strong> training.<br />

SpaceX’s electric <strong>flight</strong> training program<br />

SpaceX, the private space company founded by Elon Musk,<br />

is seeking to provide <strong>flight</strong> training for its space tourism clients<br />

with Pipiestral’s Electro Alpha. Due to an existing requirement<br />

by NASA, all space travelers launched in the US<br />

must be licensed pilot in the first place. Obviously NASA did<br />

not envision the advent of private space tourism open to<br />

general public back then when the requirement policy was<br />

drafted. No less a disruptive technology innovator than its<br />

peer companies Tesla and SolarCity, which are also founded<br />

by Elon Musk, it is only natural for SpaceX to want its<br />

<strong>flight</strong> training to be as innovative and environmentally friendly<br />

as Tesla’s electric cars. It is reported that Pipietral is going<br />

to delivery two Electro Alpha trainers to SpaceX’s designated<br />

<strong>flight</strong> training partners at Oshkosh Airventure in July<br />

<strong>2017</strong>. It remains to be quite interesting to be seen what the<br />

participation of SpaceX in electric <strong>flight</strong> will do to the industry.<br />

Do not forget that Elon Musk has explicitly mentioned in<br />

at least a dozen occasions that he might want to design an<br />

electric VTOL supersonic jet if no one else comes up with<br />

such an airplane. Now that’s exciting!<br />

Alpha Electro‘s specially designed propeller can recharge the battery<br />

to extend the <strong>flight</strong> time. A very useful feature in <strong>flight</strong> training<br />

when most <strong>flight</strong>s are in takeoff and landing pattern.<br />

France<br />

During the Paris Air Show, a letter of intent was signed between<br />

Mr. Jean-Luc Charron, representing the French<br />

Federation of Aeronautics (FFA), Finesse Max S.a.r.l, represented<br />

by Mr. Christian Stuck, and Ivo Boscarol, the General<br />

Manager of Pipistrel, regarding great future of electric aircraft<br />

in France: for the first time in European history it will<br />

be possible to do the legal training for a private pilot license<br />

– on an electric aircraft. More details about this project is in<br />

the Paris Air Show article of this issue.<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro is the first electric airplane in the world<br />

whose <strong>flight</strong> time is longer than the battery charging time. The battery<br />

compartment is easily accessible for quick change if needed.<br />

23 e Flight Journal


e Personality<br />

Ivo Boscarol – Mr. Electric<br />

No company has had more innovative projects<br />

in the past 10 years than the Slovenian<br />

ultralight and LSA manufacturer Pipistrel.<br />

Starting with the first serial 2 seater Motorglider<br />

Taurus-e, then winning the Nasa Green<br />

Flight Challenge with the Pipistrel G4, the four<br />

Seater Panthera which is planned to have a<br />

hybrid powertrain which Pipistrel is developing<br />

with partners like Siemens, the Alpha<br />

Elektro a 2 Seat electric trainer, up to the participation<br />

in the Hy4 Program of the German<br />

DLR and a firewall forward kit for electrification<br />

of existing Light Sport and ultralight Aircraft.<br />

The Mastermind behind all this is Ivo<br />

Boscarol.<br />

WWhen the now 62-year-old started his aviation business UL<br />

flying was forbidden in Yugoslavia so he tested his flying<br />

machines at dawn when it was nearly dark, that’s why the<br />

neighbors called them Pipistrelle (meaning bat). The company<br />

kept this name and is now one of the leading Ultralight<br />

and LSA manufacturers of the world.<br />

The Taurus G4 won the Nasa Green<br />

Flight Challenge<br />

In the end of the 2000’s Ivo started to take interest in electric<br />

alternatives. First came the electrification of his two seater<br />

Motorglider Taurus, which soon after was certified not<br />

only in Slovenia but also in other countries like France as<br />

an Ultralight.<br />

Ivo Poscarol pulls the political strings - here with EU commissioner<br />

Violetta Bulc from Slovenia and BW-Minister from<br />

Germany Winfried Hermann at the AERO.<br />

Ivo receives the first Chinese validated for the certification<br />

of his Viruy directly from the Chinese Vice-transport<br />

Minister Feng Zhenglin.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

24


e Personality<br />

Pipistrel also offers a firewall forward modification kit for existing<br />

aircraft which has been sold to several manufacturers.<br />

The Emrax motor in this kit comes from the Slovenian<br />

company ENSTROJ d.o.o and has 40 or 60 kW. Pipistrel<br />

produces the engine and battery controller as well as the<br />

battery pack which are produced from cells which are combined<br />

and controlled in the Pipistrel factory.<br />

One of the secrets to so much innovation and many new<br />

products is Ivo’s team of engineers like his Chief Developer<br />

Tine Tomacic and the Hybrid Program Leader Igor Perkon<br />

which are not only brilliant but also know how to sell their<br />

ideas to others.<br />

Fuel Cell - The Alternative<br />

Fast and elegant: the Panthera is Pipistrels first 4-seat aircraft which will<br />

be offered with combustion engine and as a Hybrid.<br />

The ranking of the challenge was dependent on the fuel per<br />

passenger, so he combined 2 Taurus fuselages with an electric<br />

motor on a middle piece between the fuselages therefore<br />

beating all other competitors which only carried 2 persons.<br />

Also, the second placed E-Genius was based on<br />

the Taurus Motorglider. In 2014 Ivo surprised the aviation<br />

world again at the French Ultralight Tradeshow in Blois in<br />

September when he released the Watts-Up (later called the<br />

Alpha Electro.<br />

Although the energy density has grown a lot over the last<br />

decade the batteries are still the biggest problem in realizing<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> for everybody. Hybrid with a combustion<br />

engine as a powersource is an option but the aircraft loses<br />

its green footprint because fuel is burned.<br />

Also, here Ivo Boscarol is active with the German National<br />

Aromautic Research Institute when it started the Hy4<br />

Project in October 2015. Partnered with the other companies<br />

is again Pipistrel.<br />

The DLR Aircraft is based on the NASA Green Flight<br />

Challenge winner G4 which is basically two fuselages of<br />

the Taurus Motorglider combined with 2 reinforced Taurus<br />

wings with extended wingspan and a middle part which<br />

Two fathers and a baby: Ivo Boscarol (right) and his<br />

Chief developer Tine Tomazic with the Alpha Electro<br />

When German president Joachim Gauk (left) visited, the Slovenian counterpart<br />

Borut Pahor (right) brought him to Pipistrel.<br />

25 e Flight Journal


e Personality<br />

carries the HY4’s electric motor and has an output of 80 kW<br />

and allows for a maximum speed of approximately 200 kilometers<br />

per hour and a cruising speed of 145 kilometers<br />

per hour. Depending on velocity, altitude and load, a range<br />

of between 750 and 1500 kilometers is possible. The most<br />

striking feature of the HY4 is the two fuselages, which are<br />

firmly connected to each other by the wing. This twin fuselage<br />

design allows an optimal distribution of the drive components<br />

and a higher total loading capacity. Each one can<br />

seat two occupants. The maximum weight of the HY4 is<br />

1500 kilograms. Maiden Flight took place in Autumn 2016,<br />

in Stuttgart. Pipistrel is planning further so the next step after<br />

the Panthera Hybrid is a planned version where a combustion<br />

engine isn’t but rather a fuel cell is delivering the<br />

energy. In the future, there is also a project for a 19-seater<br />

electric Commuter aircraft where one version will have a fuel<br />

cell that will deliver the energy.<br />

Certifications and Political Connections.<br />

As Pipistrel comes from the small Slovenia, with all its technology,<br />

it is now a flagship company of the country. So, for<br />

example when the German President Joachim Gauk visited<br />

his Slovenian counterpart Borut Pahor he was taken to visit<br />

Ivo’s factory in Ajdovscina not far from the Italian Border.<br />

This factory is worth a visit itself. The high-tech bulking<br />

with solar cells produces so much energy that it is not only<br />

enough for the production buts also pays all the building<br />

maintenance costs.<br />

In the last year, they now opened a new RND center in<br />

Slovenia and as Ivo is a true European a production plant<br />

for the Panthera in Italy is under construction.<br />

The EU Commissioner Viloetta Bulc, also from Slovenia,<br />

has been at Pipistrel several times. Ivo also managed that<br />

the Chinese Vice Transport Minister Feng Zhenglin, was<br />

hosted by the Slovenian government and in the end visited<br />

Pipistrel and signed a bilateral agreement for validation<br />

of Ultralight type certifications between Slovenia and<br />

China (in Europe only the Czech Republic has a similar<br />

agreement).<br />

Now who would wonder why the first aircraft validated were<br />

three planes from Pipistrel, which surely will also help with<br />

the certification of Pipistrel’s electro planes in China.<br />

China Connection and UBER Partner<br />

With all these innovations, it is not surprising that Chinese<br />

investors partnered with Pipistrel. There was a deal made<br />

for more than $350 Million Euros announced in which the<br />

Sino GA Company around Danny Wu signed a contract<br />

for a license production and partnership with Pipistrel. The<br />

interesting point: the first aircraft that will be produced in<br />

China will be the Alpha Electro followed by the Panthera<br />

Hybrid Two electric aircraft and when UBER was looking<br />

for partners for its Elevate Program there was not only giants<br />

like Bell Helicopters and Embrair but as well as the little<br />

Pipistrel from Slovenia was chosen. So overall in the future<br />

we can expect many coups from Mr. Electric.<br />

Chief developer Tine Tomazic explains the Panthera Hybrid<br />

to Vice-Minister and the Chinese Pipistrel partner Danny Wu.<br />

Taja Boscarol, Ivos daughter, is giving an overview<br />

on Pipistrels Green Factory.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

26


e-personality<br />

e Airshow<br />

Le Bourget Airshow <strong>2017</strong><br />

Paris in the Sign of Big<br />

e<br />

Ultralight aircraft made big news for<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> during this year’s Paris<br />

Airshow and it was not the Ultralight<br />

Association that made the announcement,<br />

it was the French Aeroclub!<br />

The Alpha Electro in front of the Ariane rocket in Paris.<br />

27 e Flight Journal


e Airshow<br />

FFA President Jean Luc Charron signed a “Letter of Intent”<br />

together with the Pipistrel Importer Christian Stuck and<br />

Ivo Boscarol CEO of Pipistrel that FFA will purchase three<br />

Pipistrel Alpha Electro aircraft to use for <strong>flight</strong> training in the<br />

French Federation. The interesting thing is that the aircraft,<br />

which the Aeroclub has chosen, is designed as an ultralight<br />

but will now fly with “Permit to fly” and later as a LSA. Two<br />

years ago the e-Fan was the big hype at the Le Bourget show.<br />

Dr Mueller-Wiesner, Project Manager of the e-Fan Program,<br />

stated in Le Bourget: “We already talked with DGAC and the<br />

French Aeroclubs and we want to establish private pilot <strong>flight</strong><br />

training on an electric aircraft as soon as possible,” but then<br />

the Airbus program stopped so the Aeroclub was left on its<br />

e-plans without a plane.<br />

Profit from Airbus work<br />

The French Pipistrel importer Christian Stuck explains the electric<br />

Flight Trainer to the pilots from tomorrow.<br />

On the other hand is Pipistrel: they developed the Alpha<br />

Electro and presented it as an e-Flight-trainer 2014 in Blois.<br />

However, Pipistrel´s Alpha is an ultralight, although it is flying<br />

in the US with 600 Kg as an LSA, in Europe it’s limited<br />

to the 475.5 Kg MTOW as all ultralights are. Ivo Boscarol<br />

and several other manufacturers tried to get the EU institutions<br />

to raise the weight limit to 600 Kg but the rule change<br />

is still pending. The European Council, European Parliament<br />

and European Commission have differing opinions on this<br />

so they are still negotiating. So for Pipistrel, which has the<br />

Alpha Electro ready for production and even sold a production<br />

license to China, the aircraft could not be sold in Europe.<br />

Airbus announced that - after the end of the EFAB 1 and 2 - they are working<br />

on the e-Fanx (passenger plan) and showed the city airbus as model.<br />

eViation showed a scaled model of its all-electric airplane.<br />

It’s designed to fly 600 nautical miles at a price similar to<br />

travel by airliner over the same distance.<br />

Next year the Israeli startup plans to build a prototype of<br />

the three-engine distributed-propulsion aircraft that would<br />

feature one electric motor at the tail and one on each<br />

wingtip for more aerodynamic efficiency. The motors on the<br />

wingtips are designed to enable significant drag reduction<br />

and the motors can also be used for controlling the aircraft<br />

(this engine control will be managed by a computer).<br />

The company wants to show the first full size prototype<br />

at AERO next year and the production model is planned to<br />

arrive in 2020.<br />

The goal is six to nine passengers maximum. The engines<br />

will mostly likely come from the German Siemens e-aircraft.<br />

The aircraft shall fly fully electric and shall carry 6,000<br />

pounds of batteries. The planned MTOW is about 12,000<br />

pounds, (cruise speed 240 ktas).<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

28


e-Airshow<br />

Franchois Chopard was with his investment company<br />

Starbust Accelerator, which was one of the organizers of<br />

the Paris Airlab; several innovative companies like XTI from<br />

USA presented their projects under the wing of an old<br />

Concord.<br />

The initiative of Pipistrel’s Importer for France Christian<br />

Stuck was in the interest of several players so they all<br />

agreed to work out a test program.<br />

Pipistrel will deliver three aircraft: the first will start to fly under<br />

an LSA “Permit to Fly” from EASA. Meantime Pipistrel<br />

starts the EASA CSA certification with the Alpha the next aircraft<br />

can fly under CS-LSA later. That means, at the same<br />

time the DGAC will coordinate the operations of the aircraft,<br />

EASA will do the certification and the French Aeroclub will<br />

operate the aircraft in several different clubs so that several<br />

<strong>flight</strong> instructors can gather experience.<br />

Like in other e-Programs, for example in Switzerland, there<br />

will also be Alpha’s with conventional Rotax motors available<br />

so that the students in the end will receive a fully compatible<br />

private pilots license.<br />

Siemens demonstrated<br />

the Extra in glider<br />

towing action in Paris<br />

in public for the first<br />

time. The 260 kW<br />

strong motor did pull<br />

the French aerobatics<br />

champion up to<br />

1000 meters and then<br />

both aircraft performed one after the other an aerobatics<br />

show.<br />

Comment<br />

The Alpha Electro is an ultralight but because several associations<br />

(for example the French UL Association FFPLUM)<br />

are fighting against a weight increase for ultralights in<br />

Europe, due to the higher weight electric aircraft cannot be<br />

operated in the UL-class and the technology and development<br />

will move to GA and LSA.<br />

With all its advantages like low noise, general public and<br />

politicians acceptance the French UL Association hinders<br />

electric ultralights coming to use in all Europe by blocking<br />

the weight increase.<br />

The UK drone company presented next to new<br />

drone technology their ideas for a manned<br />

“Motorbike-drone” the Airquadone.<br />

The Slovakian Flying Car AEROmobil is on the ground<br />

driven by electric motors in the wheels; a later model could<br />

be hybrid electric.<br />

29 e Flight Journal


e-personality<br />

Seen . in public for the first time was the Surefly Workhorse<br />

in Le Bourget. The manufacturer of electric vehicles for delivery<br />

services from the US has developed a delivery drone<br />

for Amazon. On this basis they presented the prototype of<br />

this double-seat multicopter, which has been publicly presented.<br />

The two-seater is powered by eight Emrax e-motors<br />

from Slovenia. In their workhorse the Americans aren’t<br />

fully set on a hybrid as there are some lithium ion batteries<br />

in the four foldable rotor arms, but these are only for<br />

short <strong>flight</strong>s. The main energy source is a two-cylinder fourstroke<br />

engine in the back of the machine and with almost<br />

200 hp it powers a generator. The first <strong>flight</strong> is planned for<br />

the end of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

The Event to bring your products and ideas to China<br />

&<br />

Electrify China’s sky and your business<br />

The first forum on<br />

electric aviation<br />

in China:<br />

VTOL-, LSA-, Hybrid,<br />

Engine-,<br />

Battery-<br />

Manufacturers,<br />

Regulators,<br />

Investors<br />

from<br />

around the World<br />

Where: Beijing downtown<br />

When:Early November <strong>2017</strong><br />

Who: The who is who<br />

in electric <strong>flight</strong><br />

www.e-ight-forum.com<br />

America & Europe: Willi@e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum.com<br />

China & Asia: Xin@e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum.com<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

30


e Organizations<br />

The Early Days of a Revolution:<br />

Increased Electrification & Automation<br />

tTraditionally, technology flows into aviation once it has matured<br />

in other sectors because the level of safety we all expect<br />

and the time and resource investments to bring aviation<br />

innovation has required a methodical approach to development.<br />

Over the last decade, developments in micro-electronics,<br />

software and battery capacities have resulted in significant<br />

societal changes which are beginning to take shape<br />

within the aviation domain. Two general technology vectors<br />

seem to be oriented in a manner that will have a profound<br />

impact on aviation as we know it: increased automation & increased<br />

electrification. These technological advancements<br />

along with new efficiencies gained as EASA implements<br />

the new CS-23 are resulting in beneficial alignment like we<br />

haven’t seen since the early days of aviation.<br />

Increased Automation<br />

Increased levels of automation which are becoming common<br />

in everyday life (smart home technology, simplified<br />

weather information, navigation with traffic information,<br />

smart cruise control, drone stability control, etc.) are beginning<br />

to find their way into integrated aviation applications. A<br />

major shift in society is expected as all the major car manufacturers<br />

have indicated plans to include significant levels of<br />

automation in the next 2-3 years.<br />

As any certified <strong>flight</strong> engineer could tell you, aviation has pioneered<br />

automation since the early days. The levels of information<br />

and technology in light general aviation and business<br />

jets has grown tremendously in the last several decades but<br />

for the most part, these systems are always supplementary<br />

and backed up by the pilot or <strong>flight</strong> crew. In most of<br />

these modern aircraft, the takeoff and landing are nearly always<br />

flown manually while the climb, cruise and approach<br />

are typically flown by automation based on pilot or crew<br />

Pete Bunce, President and CEO<br />

of GAMA, with a business delegation<br />

from Shenyang / China.<br />

31 e Flight Journal


e Organizations<br />

management. Current automation relies on cross checking<br />

and validation which defaults to a manual mode in the event<br />

of anything out of the ordinary.<br />

There is growing interest in more robust levels of automation<br />

which continue to operate across more portions of the<br />

<strong>flight</strong> envelope (including takeoff and landing) and automation<br />

systems that will continue to operate even during certain<br />

failure or out of the ordinary conditions. At the farther end of<br />

increased automation, there is a significant level of interest<br />

among a number of manufacturers in the “on-demand mobility”<br />

space. Conceptually, aircraft (both conventional takeoff<br />

and landing and vertical takeoff and landing) can become<br />

more integrated into day to day life as the reliability and simplified<br />

operation of increased automation takes hold. While<br />

technologically, these are steps forward, beginning to take<br />

operational credit for these technologies (less training burden<br />

on pilots and <strong>flight</strong> crews, simplified ratings and licensing,<br />

etc.) will require a bit of a leap.<br />

In the coming year, the GAMA Electric Propulsion Innovation<br />

Committee (EPIC) will take on the task of identifying and addressing<br />

areas where increased automation will likely contribute<br />

to the safety and utility of aviation to assure pilots and<br />

<strong>flight</strong> crew training and licensing can be appropriately adjusted<br />

and simplified.<br />

Increased Electrification<br />

In the larger segments of aviation (commercial airlines and<br />

business jets) the strong desire for longer distances and<br />

more efficient operations has pushed many of the traditionally<br />

mechanical or pneumatic systems to become electrified<br />

(electric environmental systems, electric anti-ice, electric actuation,<br />

etc.). As experience is gained with these systems<br />

and as battery energy densities continue to grow, this trend<br />

for increased electrification is speeding up. In most aviation<br />

design circles, concepts for hybrid and electric propulsion<br />

are the next obvious step forward and there is much activity<br />

in this space. In the lighter segments of general aviation,<br />

there are already all electric aircraft flying with second generation<br />

designs following immediately after.<br />

The pressures moving the industry towards increased electrification<br />

(range, efficiency, reliability, etc.) are certain to increase<br />

and the benefits of this direction will continue to grow.<br />

Reliable data indicates that Lithium Ion battery energy density<br />

has increased by 3% for each of the last 10-years and<br />

this trend is expected to accelerate or continue into the foreseeable<br />

future. While approaching the energy density of liquid<br />

fuel is still many decades out, the efficiencies and design<br />

characteristics of electric propulsion already make sense for<br />

lighter aircraft today.<br />

These are truly the exciting early days of hybrid and electric<br />

propulsion and increased automation in aviation. The new<br />

degrees of freedom enabled by these technologies and the<br />

more nimble and responsive design certification environment<br />

have invigorated what was once a sleepy aviation community<br />

into an exciting incubator for growing the not too distant<br />

future of aviation.<br />

Greg Bowles<br />

GAMA’s Vice President for Global Innovation & Policy,<br />

Manager of GAMA Electric Propulsion and Innovation<br />

Committee (EPIC)<br />

For more information on<br />

GAMA and EPIC, contact<br />

Greg Bowles at gbowles@gama.aero<br />

or +32 (2)0 550 39 00<br />

Greg Bowles, Vice President GAMA and<br />

Manager of EPIC presenting at the Dallas<br />

UBER Elevate conference in April <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

32


e Visions<br />

Zunum Aero - Think BIG<br />

Siemens and Airbus are convinced that the next generation of mid<br />

range passenger airliners will be hybrid electric. They announced<br />

their partnership with UBER so everybody was asking where is Boeing<br />

in this technology field …the answer is Zunum. The company announced<br />

in early April <strong>2017</strong> that with funding from Boeing HorizonX<br />

and JetBlue Technology Ventures they would develop a regional hybrid<br />

electric airliner, which will fly in early 2020.<br />

ZZunum Aero was founded in 2013 by Ashish Kumar (former<br />

Microsoft and Google manager). Their dream is to create a<br />

“regional electric air network,” offering travellers other options<br />

besides highways and high-speed rails. So it’s not only<br />

making small airliners electric but as well revitalizing aviation<br />

for short and middle transport distances.<br />

The electric planes would fly up to 700 miles when it launches<br />

and could go more than 1,000 miles by 2030. The aircraft<br />

would have 10 to 50 seats and will make electric air travel<br />

“fast and affordable,” Zunum Aero said.<br />

The company, which is based in Kirkland, Washington, plans<br />

to utilize more than 5,000 underused U.S. airports.<br />

“The shift in the industry to large aircraft and long ranges<br />

driven by gas turbines has concentrated almost all air traffic<br />

to just two percent of our airports, creating a massive transport<br />

gap over regional distances where there is no highspeed<br />

alternative,” says CEO of Zunum Aero Ashish Kumar,<br />

“As a result, door-to-door times for most journeys are no better<br />

than they were 50 years ago. Hybrid propulsion is an industry-changing<br />

solution, enabling mid-sized aircraft on regional<br />

routes to have better cost efficiencies than airliners.”<br />

He gives the example that travellers would be able to fly from<br />

regional airports in Boston to Washington D.C. for half the<br />

fare and in half the time it currently takes door-to-door by using<br />

closer by regional airports.<br />

The hybrid electric aircraft would lower emissions by 80<br />

33 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

percent and could drop to zero when battery densities improve<br />

and renewable energy is used. Short distance <strong>flight</strong>s<br />

could be done fully electric sooner and reducing the noise<br />

and emissions in metropolitan areas dramatically.<br />

Technically the aircraft would be driven by two ducted fans,<br />

which will be driven by electric motors. As an energy source<br />

there will be batteries (mainly for takeoff) and a gas turbine<br />

that sits in the middle of the V-tail.<br />

For the question of why they use ducted fans, as there is<br />

no successful aircraft in history with this concept and Airbus<br />

just stopped it’s e-Fan project, Mike Friend a retired former<br />

Technical Director of Boeing and now Zunum consultant explains<br />

the reason, “ Zunum believes that ducted fans are the<br />

right answer for several reasons. The first is noise, as use<br />

of small airports close in to cities will require an airplane quiet<br />

enough not to raise objections from those living close to<br />

those airports. The second is the robust low speed static<br />

thrust generated by a ducted fan that will help the Zunum airplanes<br />

use short runways of 2,500 to 3,500 ft. Several years<br />

ago, a study was made with potential passengers with images<br />

of the same aircraft one time with ducted fans one time<br />

with open propellers and asked the question, which aircraft<br />

you find more safe and in which aircraft you would like<br />

to board.? The answer was very clear the large majority preferred<br />

the Fan Type.”<br />

Attractive Operating Costs<br />

The operating costs with Zunum Aero would be at 40 percent<br />

to 80 percent lower than current airplanes operated by<br />

small regional airlines, the company says.<br />

Together with other electric Aviation companies Zunum has<br />

worked with the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)<br />

since 2014 to create the certification standards for electric<br />

aircraft (now based in the ASTM). The company said it expects<br />

a complete set of standards for electric aircraft by next<br />

year, with the first electrics likely to be certified in 2020 when<br />

Zunum planes go on the market.<br />

Ambitious Plans<br />

Zunum plans to start that process with smaller, 10-passenger<br />

aircraft and then scale up the airframes as technology<br />

improves.<br />

It’ll still be a while until consumers can buy those $100 fares<br />

though. As a venture-backed startup, Zunum undoubtedly<br />

has years of prototyping and developing to endure as well as<br />

lengthy inspection and oversight by the FAA.<br />

There is a good chance that Zunum become Boeing’s horse<br />

in the international race with Airbus Embraer and Co in the<br />

for the world first electric airliner<br />

The time schedule of Zunum is ambitious “The first <strong>flight</strong> of<br />

the proof of concept for a 10 passenger e-Jet should be done<br />

in only 2 years” says Mike Friend a retired former Director of<br />

new Technologies at Boeing and now Zunum consultant.<br />

Despite the challenges that lie ahead, Zunum seems to have<br />

attracted a solid series of investors and is entering the market<br />

at a point when electric vehicles are really gaining traction<br />

and electric aviation gets more new players every day.<br />

One day Zunum may become “The Tesla of Aircraft” like<br />

Forbes magazine said and like Tesla’s stock exchange value<br />

in <strong>2017</strong> exceeded Ford’s; Zunum may some day overtake<br />

Boeing.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

34


e Visions<br />

eVTOL to be in trial use in Dubai<br />

Volocopter and Dubai’s Road and Transport Authority (RTA) announced<br />

that they signed a deal to begin testing Volocopter’s 18-rotor VC200<br />

multicopters as a flying taxi service later this year. The news cements<br />

the city’s reputation as a testing ground for some of the transportation<br />

world’s more futuristic and outlandish ideas.<br />

AAccording to the plan, Volocopter’s Dubai experiment will<br />

start in the fourth quarter of <strong>2017</strong>, and is scheduled to last<br />

five years under the agreement with the RTA, said Alexander<br />

Zosel, co-founder of Volocopter, in a statement. “We are very<br />

grateful and proud that the RTA has selected us as their partner<br />

after rigorous testing,” he added, citing his company’s<br />

“stringent safety standards” as among the reasons his company<br />

was selected.<br />

RTA expects the trial run to continue and follow up the issuance<br />

of the legislation required for operating such kind<br />

of vehicles for about five years during which all operational<br />

aspects would be assessed and security & safety issues<br />

verified. The official operation hinges on the readiness of<br />

companies and the availability of legislation governing this<br />

type of autonomous aerial vehicles. As air traffic control of<br />

autonomous aircraft either manned or unmanned and the<br />

certification of eVTOL aircraft are new and are imminent issues<br />

for regulators around the world. Dubai’s trial program<br />

may well pave the ground for eVTOL’s certification framework<br />

in the world.<br />

Volocopter’s prototype VC200 took its first crewed <strong>flight</strong> last<br />

year and at the AERO trade show in April, the company revealed<br />

its first production model, the 2X. It has a maximum<br />

range of 17 miles when flying at a speed of 43 mph. Its maximum<br />

<strong>flight</strong> time is 27 minutes at an optimal cruise speed of<br />

31 mph. The maximum speed is 62 mph.<br />

35 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

1<br />

2<br />

In May 2016 Volocopter VC200 two-seat multicopter made the successful<br />

maiden manned <strong>flight</strong> in Germany (top and bottom photo)<br />

3<br />

1. Volocopter uses 18 motors to provide redundant lifting power.<br />

2. The propeller of Volocopter’s each motor is fixed pitch for simplicity.<br />

3. Soon this scene may become a normal reality in Dubai, an eVTOL ondemand<br />

aerial mobility vehicle.<br />

Actually Volocopter VC200 is not the first eVTOL signing a<br />

deal with Dubai RTA. The Chinese consumer drone company<br />

Ehang signed a deal with RTA last year to test its singleperson<br />

Ehang 184 in Dubai. However, Ehang 184 has not<br />

yet demonstrated a practical <strong>flight</strong> performance. In addition,<br />

the Chinese media reported that Ehang has been in financial<br />

trouble so it is hard to tell how far Ehang 184 or even the<br />

company can go in the near future.<br />

Though Volocopter is not a partner (yet) with UBER’s Elevate<br />

program, UBER has already been in talks with Dubai to publicly<br />

demonstrate its own flying taxi service planned in 2020.<br />

If Volocopter’s demo program could go well as planned, it<br />

will be big propulsion for UBER’s efforts as well.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

36


e Visions<br />

Aurora’s eVTOL approach<br />

Photos: Aurora Flight Sciences<br />

Aurora Flight Sciences is an American aviation, aeronautics research<br />

company which primarily specializes in the design and construction<br />

of special-purpose Unmanned aerial vehicles. Founded in 1989 Aurora<br />

has a heritage of highly efficient aerodynamic designs and innovative<br />

projects including human-powered airplane and solar airplanes.<br />

NNot a newcomer to the VTOL arena, Aurora has developed<br />

its own line of small vertical takeoff UAVs known as<br />

GoldenEye, but XV-24A lightning is really what catches people’s<br />

eyes. XV-24A is created by Aurora along with partners<br />

Rolls-Royce and Honeywell. It is funded by the Defense<br />

Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and is developed<br />

for the Vertical Take-Off and Landing Experimental<br />

Aircraft (VTOL X-Plane) program. LightningStrike is the first<br />

aircraft designed to demonstrate the distributed hybrid-electric<br />

propulsion ducted fans, innovative synchronous electricdrive<br />

system, both tilt wing and canard for vertical takeoff<br />

and landing and high efficiency in both hover and highspeed<br />

forward <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

Aurora is not only experienced in VTOL designs, but also is<br />

a leading company in autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control. As early as<br />

in 2012, Aurora has successfully demonstrated fully autonomous<br />

takeoff and landing capability in a converted Diamond<br />

DA42 optional piloted aircraft (OPA). In May <strong>2017</strong>, Aurora<br />

trumpeted the fact that one of its robots has successfully<br />

landed a simulated Boeing 737. What Aurora has built in the<br />

form of the robot rig uses “in-cockpit machine vision, robotic<br />

components to actuate the <strong>flight</strong> controls, an advanced tablet-based<br />

user interface, speech recognition and synthesis”<br />

to do the job. This accomplishment makes readers wonder<br />

if an auto robot arm could land a passenger jet, how easily<br />

would it be to land a small aircraft?<br />

Aurora’s advantages are obvious: they have experiences in<br />

airframe design, autonomous <strong>flight</strong> control and VTOL. These<br />

three elements are really a perfect combo when designing<br />

an autonomous eVTOL. This is perhaps the reason why<br />

UBER partnered with Aurora at the UBER Elevate conference<br />

in April of this year.<br />

Aurora’s design principles of their eVTOL are: keep it simple,<br />

design for efficient cruise, and base design on existing technology.<br />

If these requirement may sound too conservative,<br />

perhaps it also indicates Aurora’s intention to get the eVTOL<br />

prototype airborne as soon as possible. After all, according<br />

to UBER’s plan, the first test bed <strong>flight</strong>s are scheduled to begin<br />

in 2020, only three years from now. To achieve the goal,<br />

Aurora’s initial prototypes may only have 25 miles range at<br />

the beginning, and the commercial available models may<br />

37 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

have up to 40 miles range, which is sufficient<br />

in inter-urban environment. Aurora plans to<br />

have the eVTOL fly fully autonomously, even<br />

beginning from taxiing, but it will accommodate<br />

a safety human pilot at the beginning.<br />

A technology-oriented company with solid<br />

project development record, a simple design<br />

approach, a highly capable and motivated<br />

business partner. Aurora’s eVTOL<br />

prototype deserves to be watched closely.<br />

Now the only thing remains uncertain is<br />

what actual name Aurora will give to the eV-<br />

TOL project.<br />

Infrastructure<br />

• Aurora’s eVTOL aircraft will provide on-demand transportation<br />

to minimize long commutes due to heavy traffic and<br />

urbanization in populated areas.<br />

• The infrastructure plan includes urban “vertiports” for passenger<br />

boarding and vehicle servicing.<br />

• eVTOL aircraft will operate a “hub-to-hub” service between<br />

designated vertiports.<br />

• The first test bed <strong>flight</strong>s are scheduled to begin in 2020<br />

in Dallas, Texas USA and Dubai, The United Arab Emirates.<br />

Capabilities<br />

• The eVTOL will be used for short-haul transport of passengers<br />

or cargo.<br />

• Current configuration allows for two passengers including<br />

the pilot plus luggage.<br />

• Offerings will include specific configuration options to address<br />

mission requirements for civil and military operations.<br />

Operational Overview<br />

• The eVTOL aircraft includes eight lift rotors for vertical takeoff<br />

and cruise propeller and wing to transition to high-speed<br />

forward cruise.<br />

• At destination hub, the aircraft transitions back to rotorborne<br />

<strong>flight</strong> for vertical landing.<br />

• Fully electric operation decreases or eliminates emissions<br />

and noise pollution for a quieter <strong>flight</strong>.<br />

• While initially operated with a safety pilot, the eVTOL aircraft<br />

is designed for fully autonomous operations.<br />

• The <strong>flight</strong> capability for eVTOL aircraft is three times more<br />

efficient than a multi-copter aircraft.<br />

Aurora Corporate Headquater<br />

9950 Wakeman Dr<br />

Manassas, VA 20110<br />

phone: 703.369.3633<br />

eMail: info@aurora.aero<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

38


e Visions<br />

Electric Flight Plans of the Norwegian Government<br />

e-Flight Up North<br />

Despite<br />

many legal<br />

restrictions,<br />

sea planes<br />

are popular<br />

in the<br />

Norwegian<br />

general aviation<br />

community.<br />

The first<br />

Norwegian<br />

built electric<br />

aircraft is an<br />

amphibian.<br />

In many parts of the world developers are working on electric aircraft<br />

of all kind. But nowhere do governments make eAviation as part of<br />

the national transport plan, however a little country in Europe’s North<br />

wants to change this …Norway. The Government published a whitepaper<br />

and the Transport Ministry and the national airport operator<br />

Avinor are evaluating the possibility of electrifying all airports and using<br />

electric aircraft for the grid of short distance Flights that are part<br />

of the national transport system in the less populated country.<br />

TThe conditions are ideal, Norway has money from oil, a<br />

strong production of renewable electricity by waterpower<br />

and a grid of state owned small airfields. This grid is owned<br />

by the state through the state owned operator Avinor. Many<br />

short and medium distance commuter <strong>flight</strong>s are part of the<br />

national transport system by aircraft like the Dash 8. That’s<br />

because the country is in most parts only sparsely populated<br />

and the roadnet around the fiords and mountains is very<br />

dense so sometimes it may take you half a day on the road<br />

for an air-distance of only 50 kilometres.<br />

There is one more factor, which predestines Norway as testbed.<br />

In the last 10 years Norway pushed the use of electric<br />

cars by a government program, so that now it is the country<br />

with the highest density of electric cars per person in the<br />

world.<br />

Together with Norges Luftsportforbund (NLF) (The<br />

Norwegian Air Sports Federation) Avinor (the state-owned<br />

Norwegian airport operator and air navigation service provider)<br />

has initiated a long-term project aimed at introducing<br />

electric <strong>flight</strong> in Norway. Avinor states that their airport infrastructure<br />

is an ideal platform for research and testing within<br />

the field of electric aviation, and is willing to offer expertise<br />

and financial development support.<br />

The Norwegian government has for the first time in the national<br />

transport plan context promoted its own innovation initiative.<br />

It was published in National Plan for Transport (2018–<br />

2029) issued by the Norwegian government on April 5th this<br />

year:<br />

39 e Flight Journal


e Visions<br />

Photos (3): Lars Brede Grøndahl / Flynytt<br />

Norway has<br />

a vibrant general<br />

aviation<br />

community,<br />

and Norges<br />

Luftsportforbund<br />

(The<br />

Norwegian<br />

Air Sports<br />

Federation) is<br />

now seeking<br />

to introduce<br />

electric<br />

aircraft.<br />

The reason for the initiative is that the transport sector is expected<br />

to change in a number of ways at the same time as<br />

new business models; new players and changes in user behavior<br />

accompany new technology. The government will facilitate<br />

the rapid adoption of new technology in the transport<br />

sector through the development of new solutions and by<br />

adapting existing solutions suited to Norwegian conditions.<br />

Norway should be well suited for early use and use of electric<br />

aircraft for commercial traffic. The short field and narrow<br />

distance network of airports in Norway seems to fit well with<br />

expected performance on the first electric aircraft, both in<br />

terms of passenger capacity, distances, short-circuit characteristics<br />

and infrastructure for electrical energy.<br />

So what is the plan now and what are the next steps? Avinor<br />

assigned Jan Otto Reimers to do a study on “How the conversion<br />

to an electric aviation is possible” and how Norway<br />

can be one of the leading countries in this development.<br />

Jan Otto is ideal for this Job, even though he is not a pilot<br />

he is former president of the Norges Luftsportsforbund<br />

(Norwegian Aero Club) and was also leading the introduction<br />

of electric cars in Norwegian cities.<br />

After he delivered his first Report in May <strong>2017</strong>, Avinor and the<br />

government are now evaluating the options and will decide<br />

by the end of September which way the development will go.<br />

The following options are possible:<br />

A - Establish a sketch for cooperation with development organizations<br />

for electric aircraft to ensure that development<br />

also fit Norwegian conditions. (The short field and narrow<br />

distance network of airports in Norway may be interesting as<br />

an early user scenario.)<br />

B - Investigate possible collaboration with Norwegian companies<br />

and development organizations to build expertise in<br />

Norway, such as establishing a testing and competence center<br />

for electric aircraft.<br />

C - Details of the consequences of electrification of the short<br />

field and narrow distance network of airports, including the<br />

need for development, operation on short field airports, electrical<br />

infrastructure, passenger basis, aircraft sizes, energy<br />

consumption, emissions, approaches, noise, digitalized air<br />

traffic control, autonomous systems, etc.<br />

D - Prepare details for electrification of sport aviation: installations,<br />

infrastructure for charging, noise, energy consumption,<br />

emissions, etc.<br />

E - Assessing incentives and grants/funding schemes for the<br />

introduction of electric aircraft, operation of electric aircraft<br />

at an early stage and development of facilities/infrastructure.<br />

We will keep you updated.<br />

Ketil Solvik-Olsen (left), Norway’s minister of transport,<br />

Didier Esteyne (middle), designer and test pilot of Airbus<br />

E-Fan, and Dag Falk-Petersen, Avinor’s CEO, at the 2016 Zero<br />

Emission Resource Organization Conference in Oslo.<br />

Aircraft designer<br />

Tomas<br />

Brødreskrift (left)<br />

is demonstrating<br />

Norway’s first<br />

hybrid electric<br />

aircraft, Equator<br />

P2 Xcursion,<br />

to secretary<br />

general of the<br />

Norwegian Air<br />

Sports Federation<br />

John Eirik Laupsa<br />

(middle) during<br />

Aero <strong>2017</strong> in<br />

Friedrichshafen.<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

40


Market Watch<br />

The EAC Whisper is a multicopter<br />

that has 8 arms with<br />

one Prop each of this props is<br />

driveb by a Plettenberg motor<br />

with a 30 kW power and 6 kg<br />

weight.<br />

Visions Become Reality<br />

In science fiction movies such as The Fifth Element (1997) or Minority<br />

Report (2002), countless autonomous flying cars flit through<br />

the gullies of the skyscrapers of future megacities. At the moment<br />

it looks as if these impressive visions of Hollywood about the inner<br />

city traffic of the future will soon become reality.<br />

We are in the year <strong>2017</strong>: The development of the inner city individual<br />

air traffic is in a gold rush mood. Almost 20 companies are<br />

currently working on various VTOL (Vertical TakeOff and Landing)<br />

concepts, starting from aeronautical industry giants like Airbus and<br />

Bell to small innovative start-ups such as eVolo, Lilium and Zee-<br />

Aero. A few designs have already been flown and other maiden<br />

<strong>flight</strong>s are planned for <strong>2017</strong>, but most of these VTOL concepts are<br />

still in the early stage of the development. Aerospace experts believe<br />

that the electrification of the propulsion will enable many innovative<br />

designs. The rapid development in the electric propulsions<br />

and the automatic <strong>flight</strong> controls brought the era of fully-automatic<br />

on-demand flying taxis within reach. The development in <strong>2017</strong><br />

was boosted by the «Elevate» initiative of the car-sharing service<br />

UBER. The favorite of the US stock market (over 60 billion US Dollar<br />

market value) works concretely on ride-sharing concepts with<br />

VTOL taxis. The criteria for the vehicles are: full electric, 60 miles<br />

range and 160 mph maximum speed.<br />

In order to reflect this development, we have introduced an<br />

independent class «Multicopter and VTOL». Only some of these<br />

models flew already and many are still in the early project stage.<br />

For this reason, the technical data of the aircraft part are still<br />

mostly not complete. Nevertheless, we are sure this class will<br />

grow in the coming years.<br />

Qinyin Zhang<br />

NAME OF THE MANUFACTURER<br />

Short description<br />

NAME OF THE MODEL<br />

Photo of the model<br />

FULL NAME OF THE MANUFACTURER<br />

Address<br />

E-mail • Homepage<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

« EW »<br />

Empty weight<br />

kilograms<br />

(1kg = 2.20lb)<br />

« MTOW »<br />

Maximum all-up<br />

weight<br />

kilograms<br />

(1kg = 2.20lb)<br />

« PA »<br />

Number of<br />

Propellers<br />

« BA »<br />

Number of<br />

propeller<br />

blades<br />

« PD »<br />

Diameter of<br />

propeller<br />

« Engine »<br />

Engine<br />

« Power »<br />

(Hp or kW)<br />

« St »<br />

Number of<br />

seats<br />

« Vmax »<br />

Maximum<br />

speed<br />

kilometres per<br />

hour<br />

(km/h)<br />

(km/h)<br />

« Vz »<br />

Climb rate<br />

metres per second<br />

(m/s)<br />

(1m/s = 197ft/min)<br />

« Vc »<br />

Cruise speed<br />

kilometres per hour<br />

(in Litre or kWh)<br />

« Endurance »<br />

Max Endurance<br />

(in hours - h)<br />

« ES »<br />

Energy storage<br />

« Kit »<br />

Kit price<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

« Price (estimate) »<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

« Plan »<br />

Plan price<br />

Excluding local and<br />

national taxes<br />

41 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

A3<br />

Vahana is a full-electric VTOL vehicle designed by A3 based in Santa Clara, California. The venture capital company<br />

A3 is founded in 2015 by Airbus Group as an innovation outpost in Silicon Valley. Vahana is a tandem tiltwing<br />

aircraft, where four variable-speed, variable-pitch propellers are mounted both on the forward and the main wing.<br />

The propellers and the wings tilt up during vertical takeoff and tilt horizontal for cruise <strong>flight</strong>. The demonstrator uses<br />

45-kW motors and Lithium Polymer batteries. The current version of Vahana is a single-seater designed for autonomous<br />

ride-sharing or air taxi services. The first fully autonomous <strong>flight</strong>s will be performed before end of <strong>2017</strong>. Yet it<br />

is planned for 2020 to have a certifiable and producible vehicle with two seats.<br />

VAHANA<br />

A3 AIRBUS 3000 Sand Hill Road - 1-120 • Menlo Park 94025 • California • USA • Phone : +1 703 889-0535<br />

hello@airbus-sv.comm • www.airbus-sv.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

725 8 2 8x45 kW 360 kW 1 173 1/2h - -<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE<br />

At the Uber Elevate Summit in April <strong>2017</strong>, Aurora Flight Science unveiled its two-seat eVTOL air vehicle concept for<br />

Uber’s flying taxi service. Aurora Flight Science has more than 20 years of experience in developing special-purpose<br />

unmanned aerial vehicle (more than 30 unmanned aircraft developed). For this aircraft, Aurora’s design logic was to<br />

keep the architecture simple and emphasizes the cruise efficiency. For this reason, its eVTOL aircraft features eight<br />

lift propellers distributed along two booms for the vertical takeoff, while a single pusher propeller delivers the propulsion<br />

for the horizontal <strong>flight</strong>. For the cruise <strong>flight</strong>, the lift propellers will be stopped and the lift is generated by three<br />

aerodynamic surfaces, i.e. the canard, wing and tail. Even the aircraft is designed for fully autonomous <strong>flight</strong>s, the<br />

two-seater can provide place for a safety pilot due to current certification constraints. The first full-scale <strong>flight</strong> tests of<br />

the aircraft are scheduled to 2020 in Dallas and Dubai.<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE CORPORATION 9950 Wakeman Drive • Manassas, Virginia 20110 • USA •<br />

Phone : +1 703 369 3633<br />

info@aurora.aero • http://www.aurora.aero<br />

AURORA FLIGHT SCIENCE 1<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - 8 + 1 2 - - 2 - - - - - - - -<br />

E-VOLO<br />

The VC200 made by the e-volo team in Germany had its unmanned maiden <strong>flight</strong> on November 17, 2013, and its<br />

first manned <strong>flight</strong> in March 2016. It is a world exclusive design, and so far the only two-seat multicopter. It is a sideby-side<br />

450kg MTOW ultralight ‘volocopter’ with 18 electric motors and 18 rotors with each rotor 1.8 m in diameter.<br />

It comes with fly-by-wire technology, and is a fully carbon built aircraft. The rotor arms are detachable for transport<br />

and hangar storage. In <strong>2017</strong>, e-volo signed an agreement with Dubai’s transport authority to begin testing VC200<br />

as part of a flying taxi service in the fourth quarter of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

VC200<br />

E-VOLO GMBH Oestliche Rheinbrueckenstr. 50 • 76187 Karlsruhe • GERMANY • Phone : +49 (0)721 754 000-0, Fax : +49<br />

(0)721 754 000-99<br />

info@volocopter.com • www.e-volo.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

290 450 18 2 1.8 18x3 kW 54 kW 2 100 50 17.5 kWh 30 min - -<br />

EHANG INC.<br />

The EHang 184 is an Autonomous Aerial Vehicle (AAV) designed by Guangzhou EHang Inc. and it was first shown<br />

to the public on CES 2016. The designator “184” stands for “1 passenger, 8 propellers, and 4 arms”. The EHang<br />

184 has eight unducted 1.6 m diameter propellers arranged in a quadcopter configuration, where two counter-rotating<br />

propellers are mounted on each of the four so called “propulsion arms”. According to the manufacturer, the<br />

empty weight of EHang 184 is about 240 kg and a maximum gross takeoff weight is 360 kg. The lithium polymer<br />

batteries enable the drone a cruise speed of 60 km/h and an endurance of about 30 minutes. Currently, EHang<br />

184 is performing test <strong>flight</strong>s in Dubei and Nevada (USA).<br />

EHANG 184<br />

EHANG INC. Building No.3 of Yixiang Science Park,No.72 • 510700 Huangpu District, Guangzhou Guangdong •<br />

Guangdong • CHINA • Phone : +86 020-29028899<br />

service@ehang.com • www.ehang.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

240 360 8 2 1.6 8x19 kW 152 kW 1 60 17 kWh 30 - -<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

42


Market Watch<br />

ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT CONCEPT (EAC)<br />

On AERO <strong>2017</strong> a small and relatively unknown company from France, EAC (Electric Aircraft Concept)<br />

presented a multicopter. The development started three and a half years ago and the multicopter is<br />

shown to the public for the first time. The Multicopter has eight propellers from the company E-Props,<br />

and they are each driven by a Plettenberg engine (30 kW power and 6 kg weight). The power is supplied<br />

by Li-Po batteries. The Multicopter has an empty weight of 350 kg, with a load of 200 kg. The<br />

MTOW is thus 550 kg.<br />

WHISPER<br />

ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT CONCEPT (EAC) 1002 Route du Barroux • 84330 CAROMB • FRANCE • Phone :<br />

+33 0033(0)6-03-48-28-37<br />

info@eac-whisper.com • www.eac-whisper.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

KITTY HAWK CORPORATION<br />

Kitty Hawk Corporation is a flying car company financially backed by Google founder Larry Page. In April <strong>2017</strong>,<br />

a video of its Kitty Hawk Flyer was first time released. The Flyer is a full-electric VTOL aircraft within the Ultralight<br />

category (empty weight about 100 kg). It has 8 propellers and is designed to be flown over water. In USA, it can be<br />

flown over uncongested areas without pilot license. The official sale start is planned for the end of <strong>2017</strong>, and the<br />

go-to-market Flyer will have a different design than the working prototype in the video footage.<br />

KITTY HAWK FLYER<br />

KITTY HAWK CORPORATION 2700 Broderick Way • Mountain View, 94043 • California • USA • Phone :<br />

+1 650)265-0451<br />

hello@kittyhawk.aero • https://kittyhawk.aero<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

100 - 8 2 - - 1 - 40 - - - - - -<br />

LILIUM AVIATION<br />

Lilium Eagle is full-electric VTOL vehicle designed by a start-up company Lilium Aviation located in Gilching near<br />

Munich. The maiden <strong>flight</strong> of the full-scale 2-seater prototype “Eagle” was performed on April 20, <strong>2017</strong>. As the<br />

wording “Jet” implies, the air stream is accelerated by 36 impellers located on the wings (12 on the forward wing<br />

and 24 on the main wing). During takeoff, the impellers point downward to provide vertical lift (helicopter mode),<br />

while the impellers are tilted into the <strong>flight</strong> direction to provide propulsion force for the cruise <strong>flight</strong> (airplane mode).<br />

The yaw control is achieved with variating the impeller differently left and right, therefore, no vertical stabilizer is<br />

needed. After the successful first <strong>flight</strong> of the 2-seater, the maiden <strong>flight</strong> of a 5-seater version is planned for 2019.<br />

LILIUM EAGLE<br />

LILIUM GMBH Friedrichshafener Strasse 1 • 82205 Gilching, • GERMANY • Phone : +49 0)81 0577 277 87<br />

info@lilium-aviation.com • www.lilium-aviation.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

400 600 36 12 0.25 - 2 400 300 - - 1 h - - -<br />

SUREFLY WORKHORSE<br />

The manufacturer of electric vehicles for delivery services has developed a delivery drone for Amazon. On this<br />

base they now presented the prototype of this double-seat multicopter, which has been publicly presented at the<br />

Paris Airshow <strong>2017</strong> for the first time. The two-seater is powered by 8 Emrax e-motors from Slovenia. In their workhorse<br />

the Americans fully set on hybrid. There are some Licium, ion batteries in the four foldable rotor arms, but<br />

these only for short <strong>flight</strong>s. The main energy source is a two-cylinder four-stroke engine in the back of the machine<br />

with its almost 200 hp it drives a generator. First <strong>flight</strong> planned for end of <strong>2017</strong>.<br />

WORKHORSE<br />

SUREFLY 100 Commerce Dr. • Loveland, Ohio 45140 • USA • Phone : +1 513-360-4704<br />

http://workhorse.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

500 680 4 2 - 8 * 30 kW Emrax - - - - - - - - - -<br />

43 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

WATERS TRUST<br />

The Vision VTOL (Vertical Take-off and Landing) from the U.S. is designed by Mike Waters specifically for the<br />

imminent evolution of electric power storage and energy breakthroughs. The Vision is the beginning of a new<br />

breed of transportation that is specifically designed for ultra long range electric power and storage - point to point<br />

transportation. First designed over 10 years ago, all technologies required are now almost fully developed. This is<br />

the single seat prototype. It uses a slightly modified, sailplane fuselage with two pairs of tilting and canalized fans.<br />

VISION VTOL<br />

WATERS TRUST Fairfield, PA • USA • Phone : +1 574 849 6236<br />

hpcconcepts@yahoo.com • http://visionvtol.weebly.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -<br />

XTI AIRCRAFT<br />

The American Company lead by founder David Brody and Rober Labelle (Former CEO of Agusta Westland North<br />

Amerika) started developing this 6 seat VTOL Aircraft in 2012 . The three electric Motors (with 250 KW each) are<br />

driving multi blade ducted Fans and receive their energy from two turboshaft engines. After vertical take off the<br />

two front Rotors are turned into <strong>flight</strong> direction. The third fan is covered for reducing the drag. The aimed maximum<br />

speed is 350 Miles per hour. And the max Cruise altitude shall be 30 000 feet. For the electric Integration<br />

Gorge Bye from the Sunflyer project is part of the Team.<br />

TRIFAN 600<br />

XTI AIRCRAFT 13000 East Control Tower Road • Englewood Colorado 80112 • USA • Phone : +1 303 503<br />

5660<br />

LiftUp@xtiaircraft.com • http://www.xtiaircraft.com<br />

EW MTOW PA BA PD Engine Power St Vmax Vc Vz ES Endurance Price (estimate) Kit Plan<br />

- - - - - 3 x 250 max 2600 6 >700 630 - - - - - -<br />

MORE VTOL PROJECTS AROUND THE WORLD<br />

MBesides these concrete projects above, of which several are already flying, there are many more companies around the globe<br />

working on private VTOL projects. Some work very silent while others make a big wave. As we do not have reliable data on<br />

these VTOLs, in the following we give an overview with a name, image and web address. Info is changing quickly and there<br />

will be more projects every month, this is where we stand as of July <strong>2017</strong>. More info always on www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com.<br />

ZEEAREO / ZP1 www.zee.aero<br />

JOBY AVIATION / S2 S4 www.JobyAviation.com<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

44


Market Watch<br />

AIRSPACEX / MOBI www.airspacex.com<br />

NEVA AERO / AIRQUAD 1 www.neva-aero.com<br />

AIRBUS / CITYAIRBUS www.airbus-xo.com<br />

EMBRAER / VTOL http://www.embraer.com<br />

DELOREAN AER. / DR-7 www.deloreanaerospace<br />

CARTER-MOONEY / SR/C www.cartercopters.com<br />

45 e Flight Journal


Market Watch<br />

BELL HELI. / EVTOL www.bellhelicopter.com<br />

TECHNOPLANE SAS / MINI-BEE www.technoplane.com<br />

PIPISTREL / PROJECT VTOL www.pipistrel.si<br />

JETPACK AVIATION / EVTOL www.jetpackaviation.com<br />

This chapter was taken from the new edition of the<br />

World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 lists with images, descriptions<br />

and technical data over 1000 aircraft: ultralights, microlights,<br />

LSA, gyrocopter, ul-helicopters, certified aircraft, kitplanes, trikes, ultralight<br />

and certified gliders & motor-gliders, VTOLs and multicopters, instruments,<br />

engines, propellers and accessories.<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 is available in four languages:<br />

English, French and German. The Chinese version will be on the<br />

market at the end of September.<br />

* The World Directory of Light Aviation <strong>2017</strong>/18 is now available at all<br />

EAA merchandise outlets at AirVenture or online at http://lightaviationguide.com<br />

(in USA) or www.flying-pages.com (worldwide).<br />

Guide<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > Australia $15.50 • USA $16.99 • UK £6.99<br />

Buyer's<br />

Marktübersicht<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > alle Euroländer 9,95 E • CH 16,50 SFr<br />

8 Zugelassene Flugzeuge 8 Trikes 8 Gyrokopter 8 Helikopter 8 Motorsegler...<br />

FLÜGEL Welt Index<br />

8 Certified Aircraft 8 Trikes 8 Gyroplanes 8 Helicopters 8 Motorgliders...<br />

World Directory of<br />

Light AviAtion<br />

special issue of<br />

Flügel<br />

flügel - das Magazin<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

2018<br />

1000 AircrAft...<br />

Microlights & LSA<br />

ULtraLEIcht<br />

Sonderausgabe von<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

Flügel<br />

Flügel - das Magazin 2018 & FLUGzEUG<br />

1000 FLUgzeUge...<br />

LSA & Ultraleichte<br />

,<br />

+motors<br />

instruments<br />

ul m + l s a<br />

Guide d achat<br />

Hors-série Vol Moteur <strong>2017</strong>-18 > France/Andorre/Belgique 9.95 E • DOM 11,30 E • Lux 11,30 E • CH 16,90 FS • CAN 15,99 $ca • ITA/PORT CONT 11,30 E • TOM 1850 xpf<br />

,<br />

8 Avions certifiés 8 Pendulaires 8 Autogires 8 Hélicos 8 Motoplaneurs...<br />

instrumente<br />

+motoren<br />

ProPeller - funk<br />

avionik - gPs und mehr!<br />

hors-série<br />

2 0 1 7 - 1 8<br />

Guide d achat ul m + l s a<br />

MAGAZINE<br />

propellers - radio<br />

avionics - gps & more!<br />

new<br />

VTOL & multicopter<br />

Neu<br />

1000<br />

ULM & LSA<br />

VTOL & muLTicOpTer<br />

instruMents<br />

+Moteurs<br />

hélices - radios<br />

avioniques - gps...<br />

nouveau<br />

VTOL & multicoptEres<br />

L 14258 - 24 H - F: 9,95 € - RD<br />

e Flight Journal<br />

46


Guide<br />

8 Certified Aircraft 8 Trikes 8 Gyroplanes 8 Helicopters 8 Motorgliders...<br />

World Directory of<br />

Light AviAtion<br />

special issue of<br />

Flügel<br />

flügel - das Magazin<br />

<strong>2017</strong><br />

2018<br />

MAGAZINE<br />

+motors<br />

instruments<br />

1000 AircrAft...<br />

propellers - radio<br />

avionics - gps & more!<br />

Microlights & LSA<br />

<strong>2017</strong>-18 > Australia $15.50 • USA $16.99 • UK £6.99<br />

Buyer's<br />

new<br />

AVAILABLE AT ALL EAA SALES<br />

OUTLETS - AIRVENTURE <strong>2017</strong><br />

VTOL & multicopter<br />

EAA MEMBERS<br />

save $ 2<br />

Reg. $ 16.99<br />

EAA price $ 14.99


The Future ofAviation<br />

April, 18.- 21. 2018<br />

Friedrichshafen - Germany<br />

即 将 开 启<br />

coming soon<br />

The e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo is part of the annual AERO in Friedrichshafen /<br />

Germany.<br />

You will find the most advanced electric, hybrid, fuel-cell and solar<br />

aircraft and propulsion systems.<br />

e-<strong>flight</strong>-forum<br />

China <strong>2017</strong><br />

www.e-<strong>flight</strong>-expo.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!