APR24_HighRes
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
PP18617/05/2016(034488)<br />
MCI (P) 046/07/2017<br />
PP18617/10/2014(034059)<br />
MICA (P) 125/07/2015
EDITOR’S NOTE<br />
TROPHY ASSETS<br />
IS THE NEW GAME<br />
In recent years, very niche products in the market are attracting the<br />
interest of a select group of investors – High Net Worth Individuals<br />
(HNWIs) from Asia. It hasn’t gone unnoticed – more branded residences<br />
are being built all over Asia. And as in all things branded, price is not the<br />
main consideration. Thus, selling these prized assets even when the market<br />
is screaming ‘oversupply’ and ‘overhang’ is not an issue as demonstrated<br />
by some of the projects we present here as examples. We have interviewed<br />
developers, architects and consultants on this growing trend.<br />
Across from Abu Simbel temple, Egypt<br />
The other niche product attracting a fair amount of attention is heritage<br />
shophouses - this is particularly so in Singapore where there is an acute<br />
shortage of supply; as a result, shophouses in Singapore have attained the<br />
status of a trophy acquisition. We delve deeper into the situation and include<br />
Melaka, Penang and Kuala Lumpur too due to the many shophouses there<br />
sharing the same characteristics as those in Singapore.<br />
For those interested in Japan, we have two consultants, one of whom has<br />
authored 4 books on investing in property in Japan, China, Hong Kong and<br />
globally, all of which come with many case studies. They will give a better idea<br />
of the investing environment in the next Olympic destination.<br />
From the Land of the Rising Sun, we go west to the Land of the Midnight<br />
Sun – Sweden. When it comes to property, Sweden is famed for its IKEA<br />
furniture and furnishings. But the iconic brand is much more than that – it<br />
embraces sustainability and community, and increasingly technology as its<br />
core guiding principles when growing roots across its global destinations. We<br />
dig dipper into some little-known facts about this popular brand.<br />
The closure of Boracay Island for 6 months as of 26th April might get some<br />
investors jittery about investing in the Philippines. Whatever the speculated<br />
reasons for the closure are, one thing is clear – it doesn’t spell the end of<br />
tourism for the Philippines or Boracay. With over 7,000 islands, there is no<br />
shortage of beaches meaning visitors thinking about retiring there should<br />
carry on with their plans as the Philippines has one of the most relaxed<br />
residency programmes in the world. Check out our story in this issue.<br />
JAN YONG<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
editor@asianpropertyreview.com
May - June 2018<br />
5 NEWS SNIPPETS<br />
6 Drastic changes for Thai tenancy laws<br />
14<br />
COVER STORY<br />
8 Branded residences on the ascent in Asia –<br />
Not a new thing, but they are coveted by HNWIs all<br />
over Asia now.<br />
14 Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad and<br />
Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd<br />
talks about 8 Conlay and Kempinski, their<br />
maiden project.<br />
20 Chris Graham (Founder and MD of Graham<br />
Associates), who is regarded as one of the world’s<br />
foremost specialists on branded residences reveals<br />
an insider’s view.<br />
26 Bill Barnett, Managing Director at C9 Hotelworks<br />
talks about the branded residences scenario<br />
in Asia.<br />
28 SB Architects gives their view on how they go<br />
about designing branded residences.<br />
28<br />
HERITAGE SHOPHOUSES<br />
34 Heritage shophouses are trophy assets in<br />
Singapore as interest grows among HNWIs, family<br />
offices and funds in owning them.<br />
40 Simon Monteiro, who specialises in heritage<br />
buildings, gives an account of his experience<br />
from the time interest in heritage shophouses in<br />
Singapore started gaining ground.<br />
44 In Malaysia, the interest is not as obsessive but<br />
is still considered high in UNESCO-designated<br />
areas like Melaka and George Town. KL See,<br />
director of Metro Homes gives his view on the<br />
investability of shophouses in Malaysia.<br />
34
64<br />
INVESTMENT<br />
50 Christopher Dillon narrates how he bought his<br />
first apartment in Tokyo.<br />
52 The new Malaysian Act extends the limitation<br />
period for negligence suits to either 6 years<br />
from the date when the cause of action accrues, or<br />
within three years from the date on which the<br />
claimant knew about the material facts (if that<br />
period expires after the 6-year period).<br />
56 Buy a property and retire in the Philippines?<br />
Why not, says Nick Stuart, Founder & MD of<br />
exclusivehotproperties.com<br />
84<br />
24<br />
76<br />
WORLDVIEW<br />
64 IKEA’s expansion plans in Asia<br />
70 Understanding Japan’s counter-intuitive real<br />
estate market<br />
72 Writer and entrepreneur Christopher Dillon<br />
explains about the impact of earthquakes and<br />
infrastructure on the Japanese property market.<br />
DESIGN<br />
76 A ‘home-made oasis’ in KL – Tiny Garden<br />
transports you to a magical world amid the rows<br />
of drab terrace houses in a Kuala Lumpur suburb.<br />
80 From a small design firm in Nottinghamshire, UK,<br />
71 years ago, Benoy’s footprint now spans the<br />
entire globe including an increasing number in Asia.<br />
Asian Property Review interviews Qin Pang,<br />
Director and Head of Benoy’s Shanghai Studio.<br />
INNOVATION<br />
84 Singou’s ‘Butler 1’ robot is the first of many<br />
Mandarin-speaking robots that will be deployed<br />
worldwide to cater to international property<br />
buyers from China.
www.asianpropertyreview.com<br />
May - June 2018<br />
EDITORIAL<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
Contributors<br />
JAN YONG<br />
CHRISTOPHER DILLON<br />
PRITI DONNELLY<br />
DISTRIBUTION TO OVER<br />
500 DIRECT POINTS<br />
Bookstores<br />
Designers<br />
IVY LO<br />
THAM SOOK TENG<br />
CORPORATE<br />
Publisher<br />
DATO’ SRI GAVIN TEE<br />
Accounts executive SHARON LAI<br />
Sales & Marketing ERIC LEE, Senior Manager +6012 376 0020<br />
KHALIL ADIS (Singapore Rep) +65 8201 9254<br />
Department Stores<br />
SUBSCRIBE @<br />
www.asianpropertyreview.com<br />
or email us at info@asianpropertyreview.com<br />
For enquiries or to give feedback, please contact us @<br />
Tel: +603 2288 8588<br />
e-mail: editor@asianpropertyreview.com<br />
Café<br />
PUBLISHED BI-MONTHLY BY:<br />
Genetic Media Sdn Bhd (1056451 M)<br />
29-7, The Boulevard,<br />
Lingkaran Syed Putra,<br />
Mid Valley City,<br />
59200 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia<br />
PRINTED BY:<br />
Unipress Printer Sdn Bhd (731378-P)<br />
117-G, Jln Tiaj 1/4<br />
Tmn Industri Alam Jaya<br />
42300 Selangor<br />
Tel: +603 6038 5578<br />
Any content of Asian Property Review may only be reproduced, in any shape or format, with the<br />
expressed permission of Genetic Media Sdn Bhd. For reprints, please consult the Chief Editor.<br />
DISCLAIMER<br />
The materials in this publication and its related online sites including<br />
Facebook have no regard to the specific investment objectives,<br />
financial situation, or particular needs of any visitor. The materials<br />
are published solely for informational and educational purposes and<br />
are not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any<br />
properties or related financial instruments. You are advised to consult<br />
with a licensed, qualified professional before making any investment<br />
decisions.<br />
The content of contributed articles does not necessarily represent<br />
the views of this publication/its staff or advertisers. We make no<br />
representation, warranty, or guarantee as to the completeness and/<br />
or accuracy of the information here. Any opinions expressed here are<br />
subject to change without notice and we and our contributors are<br />
not under any obligation to update or keep current the information<br />
contained herein.<br />
References made to third parties are based on information obtained<br />
from sources believed to be reliable, but are not guaranteed as being<br />
accurate, complete or updated. We accept no liability whatsoever for<br />
any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part<br />
of the materials herein or on our affiliate sites.<br />
Currencies quoted are for information purposes.
May - June 2018<br />
5<br />
YONG TAI, KOF HLDGS TO JOINTLY DEVELOP<br />
U-THANT CONDO<br />
Tourism and cultural property developer<br />
Yong Tai Berhad will jointly develop<br />
a high-end low-density condominium<br />
Impression U-Thant together with KOF<br />
Holdings Sdn Bhd and RISDA Berhad.<br />
Impression U-Thant, which later will be officially<br />
known as “Residensi Mutiara U-Thant”, will be<br />
Yong Tai’s maiden high-end development bearing its<br />
signature Impression trademark amid the lush greenery.<br />
With an estimated gross development value (GDV)<br />
of about RM200 mil, the 1.2-acre freehold project<br />
comprises a 10-storey condominium.<br />
There are six different types of layout occupying builtups<br />
of between 782 sq ft and 1,632 sq ft. Prices for<br />
the 108 units start from RM1.3 mil.<br />
Yong Tai’s Chief Executive Officer Datuk Wira<br />
Boo Kuang Loon said there is a growing trend of<br />
higher-end buyers who appreciate living within a<br />
low-density green enclave while at the same time<br />
seeking the exclusivity.<br />
Impression U-Thant features innovative architectural<br />
designs, dual-key features and amenities and is<br />
expected to be completed by 2021.<br />
The development is strategically located along Jalan<br />
U-Thant overlooking the Royal Selangor Golf Club<br />
and is near the Embassy Row. It is well connected to<br />
major city roads such as Jalan Tun Razak.<br />
The recent Groundbreaking Ceremony at the site<br />
was officiated by Her Royal Highness Sultanah of<br />
Pahang, Duli Yang Maha Mulia Sultanah Hajjah<br />
Kalsom who was accompanied by Yang Amat Mulia<br />
Tengku Fahad Mua’adzam Shah Ibni Sultan Haji<br />
Ahmad Shah as the Chairman of KOF Holdings<br />
Sdn Bhd. Also present at the event were the<br />
Chairman of Yong Tai Berhad Dato’ Indera Syed<br />
Norulzaman Syed Kamarulzaman; Deputy Director<br />
General of RISDA Abdullah Bin Zainal and the<br />
Director of City Planning Department DBKL<br />
Sulaiman bin Mohamad representing The Mayor of<br />
Kuala Lumpur.
6 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW NEWS<br />
NEW THAI LAWS<br />
FAVOUR TENANTS<br />
From 1st May, there will be sweeping changes<br />
affecting tenancy laws in Thailand. The main<br />
changes which fall under the ambit of the<br />
Consumer Protection Act are as follows:<br />
1. 30 DAYS’ NOTICE TO QUIT ANYTIME<br />
Tenants can give 30 days’ notice to move out<br />
anytime as long as their reason is reasonable.<br />
Tenants are not obligated to find another<br />
tenant to take over. Acceptable reasons include<br />
job transfer or moving abroad. However, it is<br />
not clear what the yardstick is for determining<br />
what is ‘reasonable’. This poses potentially<br />
a big problem for landlords who would face<br />
uncertainties in their rental income flow. This is<br />
however mitigated by the fact that this new law<br />
applies only to landlords leasing out 5 or more<br />
residential units which is considered a ‘residential<br />
lease business’. But if caught flouting the rules,<br />
landlords face jail time which is unduly harsh for<br />
what is essentially a civil offence.<br />
2. NON-COMPLIANT LEASES NULL<br />
AND VOID<br />
All existing leases which do not comply with<br />
the new law will be considered null and void;<br />
and their terms replaced by the new law. This<br />
retrospective piece of legislation again is a<br />
dramatic annulment of all non-compliant leases.<br />
It is however unclear whether the entire existing<br />
contract is null or void or only those terms which<br />
do not comply with the new law. If the latter,<br />
then theoretically, existing contracts do not need<br />
to be replaced because the new terms would<br />
automatically replace the non-compliant terms.<br />
3. 2 + 1 ILLEGAL<br />
The typical 2 months security deposit plus 1<br />
month advance rental is now illegal. Landlords<br />
can only ask for one month’s security deposit<br />
and one month’s advance rental. Landlords will<br />
have difficulty recouping their losses if the tenant<br />
leaves behind unpaid bills or damages amounting<br />
to more than one month’s rental.<br />
This amount cannot be used to top up any unpaid<br />
rent or damages. This begs the question as to why<br />
a security deposit is required at all if the landlord<br />
can’t utilise it.<br />
Landlords in Thailand tend to pass on the repairs<br />
and maintenance even of a routine nature to<br />
the tenant. This is now considered illegal along<br />
with marking up the charges for utilities such<br />
as electricity, water, telephone, internet, etc.<br />
Landlords must now charge at cost otherwise it is<br />
considered profiteering and hence illegal.<br />
4. 7 DAYS’ REFUND OF DEPOSIT<br />
Security deposits must be returned within 7 days<br />
instead of the current 30 days. This allows very<br />
little time for landlords to assess the damages to<br />
the unit when tenants leave.<br />
5. 30-DAY WAIT<br />
In the event of non-payment of rental, the<br />
landlord cannot change the locks or remove the<br />
tenant’s belongings. This is considered a criminal<br />
act of trespass and the landlord can be prosecuted.<br />
Instead, the landlord must give 30 days’ notice of<br />
the breach, and if not rectified, then only can the<br />
landlord terminate the lease. This is in line with<br />
international practice.
May - June 2018<br />
7<br />
SWHENGTEE PROPERTY<br />
EXPO IS BACK<br />
The long-anticipated Swhengtee Property Expo<br />
KL 2018 (Swhengtee EXPO) is back! To be held<br />
at Mid Valley Mall from 23 -24th June, the expo<br />
as always promises exciting new developments on<br />
top of lots of activities.<br />
With a solid track record of more than 20,000 visitors<br />
during the 3-day EXPO 2016 and 16,000 visitors during<br />
the 2-day EXPO 2017, the group has proven itself to be a<br />
successful organizer of big scale events. Exhibitors obtained<br />
thousands of quality sales leads and even concluded a<br />
number of sales on the spot during the last two expos.<br />
Investors come from all over Malaysia including Penang,<br />
Johor Bahru, Sabah, Sarawak as well as from overseas<br />
including China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, Singapore, etc.<br />
Through Dato Sri Gavin Tee’s overseas network and<br />
connections with the Malaysia-China Chamber of<br />
Commerce (MCCC) and Malaysia- Xiamen Chamber<br />
of Commerce (MXCC), hundreds of visitors from China<br />
will also be coming to visit the 2018 Swhengtee EXPO<br />
in groups.<br />
Based on the Visitors Demographics Survey in 2017,<br />
Swhengtee EXPO attracted more than 3,000 visitors<br />
from outstation and about 1,000 visitors from overseas.<br />
Additionally, based on research conducted by REM and<br />
Asian Property Review magazines, developers, professionals<br />
and readers affirmed that Mid Valley Kuala Lumpur is the<br />
most coveted venue to conduct property exhibitions.<br />
The said magazines have also interviewed property experts,<br />
Feng Shui Masters and readers, all of whom concluded that<br />
the Malaysian property market would perform better in the<br />
second half of 2018.<br />
A FINE FINALE<br />
Malaysia’s first of its kind Chinese<br />
Reality TV Show “Anyone Can<br />
Be A Property Millionaire” held<br />
its Finale shooting at Connexion<br />
Conference & Event Centre, Kuala Lumpur, which<br />
attracted over 200 guests on 22nd April.<br />
Produced by Swhengtee Group at a cost of RM3<br />
million, the show took 5 years of planning, 2 years<br />
of preparation and 45 days of filming.<br />
During the finale, the 8 Property Millionaire Stars<br />
shared their property investment knowledge gained<br />
from the guidance of Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee and the<br />
other experts in the Reality TV Show.
8 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
BRANDED<br />
RESIDENCES<br />
ASIA’S ULTIMATE TROPHY PROPERTIES<br />
The rising number of HNWIs is fuelling demand for globally recognised branded<br />
residences with all its accompanying prestige and bespoke services.<br />
There are now 2,000 billionaires in the world,<br />
growing at 13% per annum, according to Forbes.<br />
Many of them have homes all over the world and<br />
typically stay in different countries in a year. Their<br />
choice of homes – global branded residences. This is why<br />
the number of such residences has increased tenfold over<br />
the past decade.<br />
These are homes in prime locations that offer bespoke<br />
luxury services and prestige associated with an established<br />
brand. Branded residences started about 100 years ago<br />
in New York but only became a trend in the mid-1980s<br />
beginning with Four Seasons followed by Ritz-Carlton.<br />
When it became a success, other hotel brands came in such<br />
as Starwood, Fairmont, Kempinski, Aman, St. Regis, Hyatt<br />
Regency, Six Senses, Banyan Tree, W Hotels, Viceroy and<br />
Mandarin Oriental.<br />
However, it is in Southeast Asia and the Far East that<br />
resort branded residences have reached a matured phase and<br />
become the ultimate in luxurious accommodation.<br />
In Southeast Asia, Thailand leads the way with Amanpuri<br />
Phuket in 1988 followed by The Four Seasons Chiang Mai<br />
in 1995. Thailand still leads today with the biggest number<br />
of such residences in the entire SEA region.<br />
According to Bill Barnett, Managing Director at C9<br />
Hotelworks, large luxury hotel brands like Ritz-Carlton<br />
and Four Seasons are seeing a high proportion of their<br />
hotel pipeline being generated in mixed use or project with<br />
branded residences; they tend to favour gateway cities and<br />
key well-known leisure destinations with strong airlift.<br />
topped US$16 bil and is still growing at an unprecedented<br />
rate. Across the region, C9 Hotelworks estimates there are<br />
about 94 mainstream hotel residence projects with more<br />
than 21,000 units on line, with 78 properties expected to<br />
complete between 2018 and 2020, representing an 83%<br />
increase over the inventory in 2015.<br />
“Asia is also the testing ground for pioneering iterations of the<br />
concept with regards to scale, business models and levels of<br />
servicing/supporting amenities,” according to Bruce Wright,<br />
Senior Vice President and Principal of SB Architects.<br />
BRANDED RESIDENCE DEVELOPMENTS BY REGION<br />
Asia, Indian Ocean<br />
& South Pacific<br />
16%<br />
54%<br />
US & Canada<br />
BRAND AFFILIANT VS. INDEPENDENT<br />
Number of Projects<br />
Europe<br />
11%<br />
Latin America<br />
& Caribbean<br />
10%<br />
9%<br />
Middle East & Africa<br />
Branded<br />
Independent<br />
“Japan has been active in top end projects like the Four<br />
Seasons Kyoto or Park Hyatt Hanazono near Niseko.<br />
Overall, the urban push is strong, interestingly two key<br />
Asian resort brands, Aman and Six Senses, have city<br />
branded residences coming up in New York City.”<br />
According to research by Barnett’s C9 Hotelworks, the<br />
hotel branded residences market in Southeast Asia has now<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
Thailand<br />
Indonesia<br />
Vietnam<br />
Malaysia<br />
Philippines<br />
Singapore<br />
Cambodia
May - June 2018<br />
9<br />
Room angle, Anantara Phuket Layan<br />
Joanne Kua Bill Barnett Bruce Wright<br />
Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee<br />
WHY BRANDED?<br />
Branded residences tick all the right boxes – for the buyers,<br />
there is assurance of quality in construction, design and<br />
service; secure environment, bragging rights, “Lock up and<br />
leave” capability and the potential for investment returns<br />
from a rental pool (notably in a resort context).<br />
Says Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad and<br />
Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd: “Ultimately,<br />
when people buy a branded residence, they are looking<br />
at buying more than just a property, they want unique<br />
experiences that are often anchored on four key attributes –<br />
o<br />
o<br />
o<br />
o<br />
Opulent design by a renowned designer<br />
Luxury services and facilities offered by a 5-star hotel<br />
brand<br />
Unique architecture by a celebrated architect<br />
Brands associated with a level of quality and trust<br />
these brands can deliver”<br />
“Expatriates or HNWIs prefer branded residences,<br />
particularly famous international brands because these<br />
brands inspire confidence<br />
and provide the kind of<br />
bespoke services that they<br />
are used to. The brand carries<br />
the guarantee of quality and<br />
services as well as safety<br />
and security,” affirms Dato’<br />
Sri Gavin Tee, President of<br />
Swhengtee Group.<br />
Adds Wright of SB<br />
Architects: “Usually the<br />
access to ownership comes<br />
at a higher cost, but the<br />
return is a deep emotional<br />
connection to the brand<br />
philosophy, culture and often<br />
the related hotel amenities.”<br />
Other reasons include hassle-free ownership, owner<br />
benefits, e.g. residents’ discount card, access to the operator’s<br />
properties in other locations and like-minded neighbours.<br />
Indeed, some leading designers such as Luciano Mazza at<br />
HKS and John Hitchcox at YOO are talking about creating<br />
“modern day communities” of like-minded people – a sort of<br />
exclusive residents club.<br />
From the standpoint of the developer, having a brand<br />
associated with its property enhances sales by as much as<br />
30%. The resale value is higher or maintained while at the<br />
same time, it can fetch higher rentals.<br />
Furthermore, these residences yield a typical premium of<br />
between 20% - 40% with some fetching as much as 50%<br />
- 100% more, for example, the branded residences at The<br />
Ritz-Carlton Dorado Beach in Puerto Rico sold at up to<br />
250% above the average per sq foot price of non-branded<br />
units in the same development. The Armani Penthouses<br />
in Dubai were selling at more than 50% higher than<br />
when they were launched five years previously, according<br />
Hotel Branded Residences: Market Participants<br />
1 Banyan Tree Hyatt Place One & Only Shangri-La<br />
Accor Bulgari Hyatt Regency Onyx Sheraton<br />
Address Canyon Ranch Independent Paramount Six Senses<br />
Aloft Chedi Intercontinental Park Hyatt Starwood<br />
Alila Conrad JW Marriott Plaza St. Regis<br />
Aman Dusit Thani Kempinski Radisson Blu Sukhothai<br />
Amari Edition Kimpton Taj<br />
Anantara Fairmont Le Meridien Regent Thompson<br />
Andaz Four Seasons Louvre Renaissance Trump<br />
Angsana Gansevoort Mandarin Oriental Ritz-Carlton Versace<br />
Armani Golden Tulip Millennium Rock Resorts Viceroy<br />
Atlantis Grand Hyatt Mondrian Rosewood Vida<br />
Baccarat Hard Rock Montage SLS W<br />
Baglioni Hyatt Movenpick Setai Waldorf-Astoria<br />
Westin
10 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
Chris Graham<br />
Glen Chan<br />
Arianna Leopard<br />
to a report by Chris Graham, Founder and MD of<br />
Graham Associates.<br />
Interestingly, it is not just hotel brands which are the<br />
players, luxury brands from the fashion and jewellery<br />
industry such as Bulgari, Versace, Moschino and Armani<br />
and those from the automotive sector such as Porsche and<br />
Mercedes Benz have also licensed their names to developers.<br />
Royalty fees typically range between 3-5%, according to<br />
HVS and Savills.<br />
According to data from Savills, 65% of branded residences<br />
around the world are located in urban locations and 35%<br />
are in beach/resort locations. Many experts believe that this<br />
urban-dominant trend will continue. “Prime urban branded<br />
developments have greater appeal because they are perceived<br />
as less risky,” observes an insider.<br />
However, Wright from SB Architects believes that despite<br />
the urban-centric focus, there is a growing number<br />
of thriving ultra-luxury branded resort real estate in<br />
destinations like the Maldives, Caribbean or Turks & Caicos.<br />
THE DESIGN FACTOR<br />
Apart from location which is the most important factor<br />
for branded residences, architects and interior designers<br />
are also a critical part of the mix. “Branded residences need<br />
to have a high-degree of personalization and the accent is<br />
on interiors that tag the buyer’s lifestyle and wrap around<br />
emotion and feelings. We seamlessly merge architecture,<br />
interior design, and lifestyle in a way that speaks to the<br />
aspirations of the buyer, explains Arianna Leopard, Director<br />
of SB Architects.<br />
Wright concurs: “Consumers are more design conscious than<br />
ever before; they want to work in creative spaces and holiday<br />
in unique hotels. They want that bespoke design aesthetic to<br />
continue through their personal lives into their homes.”<br />
Yoo’s founder John Hitchcox says: “This can really be<br />
attributed to the growth of the design savvy consumer, the<br />
ever increasing importance of brand trust in our society and<br />
ultimately, developers recognising the importance of the<br />
home as a high involvement purchase.”<br />
Yoo is a leading designer in this sector with a portfolio<br />
of over 80 projects around the world and a stable of top<br />
designers including Philippe Starck, Jade Jagger and<br />
Kelly Hoppen.<br />
The ultimate design differentiation is of course to<br />
engage “starchitects” for example WATG’s St. Regis<br />
Hotel & Residences in Singapore and the residences<br />
by Norman Foster and Frank Gehry at Battersea Power<br />
Station in London.<br />
BRANDED RESIDENCES - DRIVERS OF PREMIUM<br />
Factors comanding price premium above unbranded residential product<br />
Medium premium<br />
• Prime global city / destination<br />
• Ultra - prime area & very good access<br />
• Star architect / renowned building<br />
• Famous designers & excellent fit out<br />
• Excellent views / higher floors<br />
HIGH PREMIUM: 25% +<br />
• Exceptional five - star hotel services<br />
• Luxury spa & wellness<br />
• Extensive luxury leisure facilities<br />
• High end restaurants & bars<br />
• Unique experience / facilities<br />
• ‘Above and beyond’ service<br />
• Conciege for tailored experiences<br />
• Other residents are ‘people like us’<br />
• Facilities exclusively for residents’ use<br />
• Association with the brand’s values<br />
• Hightly desired destination<br />
• Prime location with good access<br />
• High quality building & fit out<br />
• Recognised architect / designers<br />
• Good views<br />
MEDIUM PREMIUM: 15% - 25%<br />
• High quality hotel services<br />
• Spa facilities<br />
• Health and leisure facilities<br />
• Good quality restaurants and bars<br />
• Desirable experiences<br />
• Concierge, security & management<br />
• Residents-only area<br />
• Recognition and priority for residents<br />
• Discounts for residents<br />
• Cachet & confidence from the brand<br />
• Desirable destination<br />
• Good location and access<br />
• Well-designed<br />
• Attractive fit out<br />
• Lesser views / lower floors<br />
Location and<br />
product context<br />
MODEST PREMIUM: UP TO 15%<br />
• Quality services and facilities<br />
• Or high quality hotel services but<br />
where the wider managed destination<br />
brand experience is already delivering<br />
notable premium<br />
Associated brand<br />
experience<br />
• Some extra benefits<br />
• Similiar experience as hotel guests<br />
• Security & management<br />
• Reassurance of a brand<br />
Additional benefits<br />
for residents
May - June 2018<br />
11<br />
STRUCTURE OF A TYPICAL BRANDED RESIDENCES PROJECT<br />
Marketing Licence Agreement<br />
Operator permits Developer to use the Residential Trademarks in<br />
connection with the sale and marketing of Residential Units<br />
Technical Services Agreement<br />
Operator to the render technical services in connection with the<br />
planning, building, furnishing, equipping and decorating of the<br />
hotel and the residential component<br />
Operator<br />
Trademark Licence Agreement<br />
Operator grants to HotelCo the right to<br />
use the Trademarks in the operation<br />
and management of hotels<br />
Hotels Management Agreement<br />
For management of Hotel and provision of<br />
services to Residential Component<br />
*<br />
1. appoint as agent of his unit<br />
2. appoint as agent for common area<br />
3. grant proxy for owners’ meetings<br />
HotelCo<br />
(Associated<br />
With<br />
Developer)<br />
*<br />
Lease Units<br />
Buyers joining the<br />
Rental program<br />
Developer<br />
Sell Units<br />
Buyers<br />
Appoint<br />
HotelCo as<br />
agent for<br />
common area<br />
Buyers NOT joining<br />
the program<br />
*<br />
Owners’ Association<br />
appoint<br />
Consultancy Agreement + Residential Services & Facilities Agreement<br />
© 2014 Baker & McKenzie<br />
Property Management<br />
Company & Resort<br />
Management Company<br />
Clearly, the quest to differentiate is a constant race to imbue<br />
the residences with the best and most unique qualities – this<br />
has shifted to more experiential lifestyle.<br />
Says Graham: “Whilst buyers’ priorities remain consistent<br />
in terms of location, design and access to world-class<br />
amenities, very much in line with trends in the hospitality<br />
sector, it is increasingly more about the intangible ‘added<br />
value’ lifestyle benefits associated with a brand. Increasingly,<br />
the shift is towards creating an emotional connection with<br />
residents through experiences. ”<br />
An example is a residence with access to a private marina a<br />
few steps away. Pan Pacific Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour<br />
together with Puteri Cove Residences and Quayside, are<br />
the only luxury waterfront project with both private-marina<br />
(300 berths) and sea views in Iskandar. Developed by Pearl<br />
Discovery, a joint venture by Singapore-based real estate<br />
developers Pacific Star and DB2, the 205-suite Pan Pacific<br />
Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour is scheduled to open in the<br />
third quarter of 2018. The marina facility will be managed<br />
by Singapore’s award-winning Marina and Lifestyle<br />
operator, One 15 Marina.<br />
WHAT’S NEXT?<br />
The supply of branded residences is currently limited<br />
around the world. However, given that more and more of<br />
such residences are being built, it runs the risk of oversupply.<br />
That has already happened in Thailand and Vietnam, where<br />
branded residences are now becoming so engrained and<br />
numerous in the market that they risk being the norm<br />
rather than the exception, cautions Graham. Barnett agrees<br />
saying that there will be more and greater diversity in real<br />
estate grade from luxury to entry level. “Even budget chain<br />
YOTEL is talking branded residences.”<br />
This then is the challenge for the branded residences<br />
segment today – to push that differentiation factor even<br />
further as competition begins to heat up.<br />
Unless otherwise stated, all charts and tables are courtesy of Chris Graham.<br />
In fact, says Glen Chan, President and CEO of Pacific<br />
Star Development: “The private marina in Iskandar will<br />
be modelled after the one in Sentosa Cove which is also<br />
managed by One 15 Marina.”<br />
Pan Pacific Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour
12 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
8 Conlay by Kempinski under construction.<br />
THE BRANDED FACTOR<br />
IN KL’S GLOBALISATION<br />
As an emerging market, Malaysia has seen a steady uptick in branded residences<br />
taking root particularly in its capital city, Kuala Lumpur. Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee,<br />
President of Swhengtee Group shares his prediction of this niche market segment.<br />
“When a city becomes globalised, it will attract<br />
more multinational companies (MNCs) and<br />
international travellers who are used to the<br />
high quality of certain brands and will naturally<br />
gravitate towards such branded establishments<br />
including international 5-star hotels and residences.<br />
That’s why branded residences command a higher<br />
premium than residences that do not have a<br />
prestigious brand attached to it.<br />
Expatriates or HNWIs prefer branded residences,<br />
particularly famous international brands because<br />
these brands inspire confidence and provide the kind<br />
of bespoke services that they are used to. The brand<br />
carries the guarantee of quality and services as well as<br />
safety and security.<br />
Not surprisingly, international branded residences<br />
have the potential to command half the market.<br />
A branded property can enhance its value by 30%,<br />
for example, a property without brand may sell at<br />
The unique thing about Malaysia’s<br />
branded residences is that prices are<br />
at a much lower level for the same<br />
bespoke services compared to other<br />
countries. So, there is a lot of room<br />
for price appreciation.<br />
RM2,00 psf, but if it is branded with a famous<br />
international hotel chain, it can fetch RM3,000 psf.<br />
Further, when a popular or famous brand enters<br />
a market, it can even make the place popular, for<br />
example, when Air Asia flies to a little known<br />
destination, it can make the place popular and<br />
when more people visit the destination, the value of<br />
properties there will rise in tandem (provided other<br />
favourable conditions exist as well).
May - June 2018<br />
13<br />
BRANDED RESIDENTIAL EFFECT<br />
Kuala Lumpur was supposed to have globalised<br />
since 2007 when a lot of Middle Eastern, Korean<br />
and other foreign investors beat a path to its doors.<br />
However when the Global Financial Crisis hit in<br />
2009, it slowed down the globalisation process to a<br />
large extent.<br />
It took some 10 years before KL got back into<br />
international investors’ radar. The influx of China’s<br />
investments especially in infrastructure such as<br />
railways, ports and finance, as well as the siting<br />
of key regional headquarters in Malaysia such<br />
as China Communications Construction Co<br />
Ltd (CCCC) , Ali Baba’s Digital Free Trade<br />
Zone (DFTZ) kickstarted the second wave of<br />
investments into Malaysia.<br />
This was followed by a number of other foreign<br />
companies setting up their regional headquarters in<br />
Kuala Lumpur and its surrounding areas. Several<br />
critical transportation infrastructure such as the<br />
MRT1 and the LRT extension were also completed.<br />
Seeing a gap in supply, a number of branded<br />
residences were set up and were completed in<br />
2017/2018 such as Four Seasons and W Hotel.<br />
Around the same time, a few others were launched<br />
such as 8 Conlay by Kempinski and Ascott Star<br />
KLCC Residences.<br />
With the rising number of such residences, we can<br />
expect 2018 – 2020 to see a lot of activities in this<br />
segment – either some will be completed, new ones<br />
launched or being constructed.<br />
It’s only now that we can expect to see a significant<br />
price appreciation. In the last few years, high end<br />
properties were hovering around the RM1.5K –<br />
RM2K price level. We can now see price levels<br />
jumping to RM2.5K – RM3.5K level, for example,<br />
Four Seasons. This is the beginning of what I would<br />
term as the ‘branded residential effect’.<br />
PRICING ADVANTAGE<br />
The unique thing about Malaysia’s branded<br />
residences is that prices are at a much lower<br />
level for the same bespoke services compared to<br />
other countries. So, there is a lot of room for<br />
price appreciation.<br />
Previously, I have forecasted that prices of high end<br />
residence could reach RM5K psf, but due to many<br />
unforeseen circumstances such as the Malaysia<br />
Airlines (MAS) disasters and the 1MDB issue,<br />
the progress has been slow. However, I believe the<br />
price level will still hit RM5K by 2020 for branded<br />
residences not only in the city centre but in resort<br />
areas like Penang and Kota Kinabalu.<br />
Currently, a major concern in Malaysia is the delay<br />
in the setup of more international corporations and<br />
the arrival of expatriates in Malaysia. However, I<br />
predict properties completed within the next 3 years<br />
should enjoy the fruits of right timing – being first<br />
in the market; thus having the advantage of quick<br />
occupancy with high rental yield and a possible fast<br />
price appreciation.<br />
For example, 8 Conlay by Kempinski in KL will<br />
enjoy good returns because by the time<br />
it’s completed by 2020, more foreign<br />
investments would have poured into the<br />
city centre.<br />
The competition is also not intense<br />
as there aren’t too many of such super<br />
branded residentials setting up in<br />
Malaysia. The ones that immediately<br />
come to mind are Four Seasons, St<br />
Regis and Ritz-Carlton.<br />
I believe the price<br />
level will still hit<br />
RM5K by 2020<br />
for branded<br />
residences not<br />
only in the<br />
city centre<br />
but in resort<br />
areas like<br />
Penang<br />
and Kota<br />
Kinabalu.
14 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
1<br />
BRANDED<br />
IN THE TRUEST SENSE<br />
Asian Property Review chats with Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad<br />
and Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd on branded residences and<br />
their 8 Conlay debut project.
May - June 2018<br />
15<br />
1<br />
What was the inspiration behind 8 Conlay<br />
development?<br />
8 Conlay is KSK Land’s debut project, and we<br />
want to construct something new and exciting,<br />
an iconic development that becomes a distinct<br />
part of KL city centre. The birth of 8 Conlay<br />
was based on one revolutionary mission – that<br />
is to bring together A-list brand partners to<br />
curate one-of-its kind living spaces through<br />
three main elements – liveable architecture,<br />
world-class designs and bespoke personalised<br />
services. We want to bring luxury living in<br />
Malaysia to the next level.<br />
Unlike other developers that bring in designers,<br />
landscape and service partners at the end<br />
stages, we brought in our partners right at the<br />
beginning and work together to map out every<br />
detail and offering of 8 Conlay. We have never<br />
looked back since then, and today 8 Conlay<br />
has become this massive project - an integrated<br />
development offering lush living experience<br />
with the highest level of service.<br />
With an estimated GDV of RM5.4 bil, it<br />
sits on a 4-acre piece of land at Jalan Conlay,<br />
comprising two branded residence towers<br />
called YOO8 serviced by Kempinski, a five-star<br />
Kempinski Hotel and serviced residences, and a<br />
lifestyle retail quarters.<br />
Just some quick facts about our brand partners<br />
– some of them are making their debut<br />
appearance in Malaysia through 8 Conlay:<br />
• Liveable architecture – We brought in<br />
Ar Hud Bakar from RSP Architects,<br />
a visionary Malaysian architect. Hud’s<br />
designs emphasise liveable architecture<br />
that focuses on local content and the<br />
human aspects of buildings.<br />
• We have entrusted the landscape design<br />
elements to award-winning Bangkokbased<br />
design studio, Terrains+ Open<br />
Space (TROP). We are transforming<br />
the common amenity floors of YOO8<br />
serviced by Kempinski on Level 26<br />
(Water Lounge) and Level 44 (Green<br />
Refuge) into retreats that encapsulate<br />
2<br />
Every city needs a gem development<br />
that will put the city on the world’s<br />
map, and branded residences have<br />
the capability to give Kuala Lumpur a<br />
different character that will put it on par<br />
with other top cities in the world.<br />
the idea of a futuristic vertical park that<br />
blends architecture and nature, something<br />
Malaysians have yet to experience.<br />
• Interior designs – For designs, we have<br />
YOO, an international design studio<br />
working with high-profile designers<br />
including Philippe Starck, Marcel<br />
Wanders, Jade Jagger and Kelly Hoppen.<br />
YOO started designing branded residences<br />
since 1999. For Tower A of YOO8<br />
serviced by Kempinski, we partner with<br />
Steve Leung & YOO, to transform the<br />
branded residences experience through<br />
design of living spaces.<br />
• Personalised luxury services – Kempinski<br />
Hotels is Europe’s oldest luxury hotelier<br />
with a 121-year rich heritage. We believe<br />
Kempinski will be able to redefine<br />
hospitality for our guests and residents at<br />
8 Conlay with impeccable, personalised<br />
services. We are so proud to host the first<br />
and only Kempinski Hotel in Malaysia at<br />
8 Conlay.<br />
What is the stage of development currently?<br />
What is the take-up rate so far? When is the<br />
estimated completion date?<br />
Tower A of YOO8 serviced by Kempinski<br />
was launched at the start of 2016, and we<br />
have sold 80% of the units to-date. In terms<br />
of construction progress, the foundation and<br />
basements works were completed mid last year,<br />
and we have proceeded with the superstructure<br />
construction works. We are currently on track<br />
for completion in 2020. We are planning to roll<br />
out Tower B of YOO8 serviced by Kempinski<br />
mid this year, and will definitely share details<br />
once ready.
16 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
3<br />
What is it about branded residences that<br />
makes them in demand among High Net<br />
Worth Individuals (HNWIs)? Share with us<br />
what are the unique features that made YOO8<br />
serviced by Kempinski stand out?<br />
Globally, branded residences are perceived to be<br />
at a level above high-end luxury properties and<br />
increasingly popular among wealthy investors<br />
as they offer both five-star luxuries and capital<br />
protection/hedging tool. According to Knight<br />
Frank, branded residences command 31%<br />
higher capital yield compared to non-branded<br />
luxury property segment.<br />
Ultimately, when people buy a branded<br />
residence, they are looking at buying more than<br />
just a property, they want unique experiences<br />
that are often anchored on four key attributes –<br />
• Opulent design by a renowned designer<br />
• Luxury services and facilities offered by a<br />
5-star hotel brand<br />
• Unique architecture by a celebrated<br />
architect<br />
• Brands associated with a level of quality<br />
and trust these brands can deliver<br />
When you curate branded residences, you need<br />
to have a very good location, good design and<br />
a consistent level of bespoke, luxury service. 8<br />
Conlay is situated at a prime location within KL<br />
city’s Golden Triangle. It is within five minutes’<br />
walking distance of Pavilion KL and Jalan<br />
Bukit Bintang’s shopping district, Conlay MRT<br />
station, High Speed Rail, and is 20 minutes’<br />
walking distance to Petronas Twin Towers.<br />
Although branded developments are not<br />
new in Malaysia, it is still at an infancy<br />
stage. In fact, many of the KL branded<br />
residence developments are branded solely<br />
by a hotel partner.<br />
For now, we see opportunities in<br />
prime locations in Malaysia.<br />
4<br />
The supply of branded<br />
residences is limited around the<br />
world. People who buy them<br />
don’t generally want to sell<br />
because these are limited and<br />
priceless possessions they are<br />
proud to own.<br />
If I were to pin point the single most important<br />
value proposition of 8 Conlay, it would be the<br />
values and trust associated with our brand<br />
partners. We have Ar Hud Bakar, an awardwinning<br />
architect; Europe’s oldest luxury<br />
hotelier, Kempinski for bespoke, personalised<br />
luxury service; and YOO for the highest<br />
standard designs.<br />
In Tower A of our branded residences, YOO8<br />
serviced by Kempinski, the interior design is<br />
by Steve Leung & YOO. Steve Leung is a<br />
world-renowned design guru who has won over<br />
130 awards worldwide, and he was awarded<br />
the Andrew Martin International Designer of<br />
the Year Award in 2015 (which is equivalent<br />
to the Academy Awards in design). His works<br />
reflect a sophisticated and unique character of<br />
minimalism, with skillful adoption of Asian<br />
culture and arts. In addition, we also have the<br />
renowned Pok Kobkongsanti, TROP’s lead<br />
design director, to manage the landscape which<br />
plays a vital role in enhancing city living quality.<br />
Simply put, each of our brand partners brings<br />
to 8 Conlay unique qualities that ultimately<br />
become a tangible benefit for our buyers and<br />
investors. We want our residents to proudly say<br />
they are buying a gem in KL and it’s worth it!<br />
What is the ratio of local and foreign buyers?<br />
Where do the foreigners come from?<br />
Currently, our buyers’ profile are about 80%<br />
foreign and 20% local. We have buyers from<br />
Tier 1 cities in China, Hong Kong, Singapore,<br />
Taiwan, Indonesia, Middle East and more.
May - June 2018<br />
17<br />
5<br />
What is the percentage of price premium of<br />
your branded residence over a comparable<br />
non-branded residence? Why would buyers<br />
pay the premium?<br />
As mentioned earlier, Knight Frank reported<br />
that branded residences commanded an average<br />
uplift of 31% compared to non-branded<br />
property segment. In addition, according to<br />
a market update report by Horwath HTL<br />
published in January 2018, a property with<br />
hotel affiliation could translate to a 25–35%<br />
uplift in pricing.<br />
8 Conlay was launched at RM2,700 psf in 2016<br />
and reached RM3,200 psf in 2017.<br />
6<br />
Our premium price can be fetched due to:<br />
• Quality of the brands delivered;<br />
• Central prime location;<br />
• Luxury service and trust that brands like<br />
Kempinski will maintain the property and<br />
ensure the uplift of capital appreciation;<br />
• Good design – Good designers help design<br />
and optimise spaces that are easier to live in<br />
or to rent out.<br />
What is the built-up range for the units and<br />
their price psf?<br />
The branded residence units of Tower A of<br />
YOO8 serviced by Kempinski range from 700<br />
to 1,308 sq feet. They are priced at RM3,200<br />
Despite soft market sentiments and the<br />
oversupply issues facing the Malaysian<br />
property market, we remain upbeat about<br />
the long-term prospect of the Kuala<br />
Lumpur property market.<br />
Bedroom - Type B layout, Tower A by Steve Leung & Yoo
18 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
7<br />
If I were to pin point the single<br />
most important value proposition<br />
of 8 Conlay, it would be the values<br />
and trust associated with our<br />
brand partners.<br />
psf or an average price of only RM2.3 mil<br />
per unit. All units are fully-furnished with<br />
furniture selected by Steve Leung & YOO and<br />
offer views of the Royal Selangor Golf Club<br />
and KLCC, in addition to receiving the same<br />
Kempinski service.<br />
Why choose Kempinski?<br />
8 Conlay was created with the idea of providing<br />
service excellence in liveable, design-led<br />
architecture. We wanted people to know that<br />
living at 8 Conlay is more than having a shelter<br />
over their heads. It is an experience which<br />
allows each resident to create their own story.<br />
For this, 8 Conlay needed a brand partner who<br />
could provide the top-notch services that would<br />
reflect hospitality at its best and simultaneously<br />
allow residents to form incredible memories.<br />
We know Kempinski Hotels will be able to<br />
meet our guests’ and residents’ expectations as<br />
every aspect of Kempinski’s 121 years of luxury<br />
bespoke services is geared towards serving guests<br />
who expect excellence and value individuality.<br />
Each Kempinski hotel is unique<br />
to its location and local cultures;<br />
providing a sense of place but<br />
maintaining the same consistent<br />
bespoke service standard<br />
throughout its hotels.<br />
Dining room - Type E layout, Tower A by Steve Leung & Yoo
May - June 2018<br />
19<br />
8<br />
9<br />
Kempinski does not adopt a one-size-fitsall<br />
approach. They try to incorporate what is<br />
distinct about the location where the hotel<br />
will be built. That’s why each Kempinski hotel<br />
is unique to its location and local cultures;<br />
providing a sense of place but maintaining<br />
the same consistent bespoke service standard<br />
throughout its hotels. This uniqueness sets<br />
Kempinski apart from other luxury hoteliers.<br />
We hope that more Malaysians will find<br />
meaning in luxury living as a reflection of their<br />
passion to achieve excellence.<br />
What is your view on the competition from<br />
other branded residences in KL?<br />
The supply of branded residences is limited<br />
around the world. People who buy them don’t<br />
generally want to sell them because these are<br />
limited and priceless possessions they are proud<br />
to own. We believe 8 Conlay offers buyers<br />
and investors a good investment opportunity<br />
as it will command better capital yield for the<br />
longer term. Besides, prices of luxury properties<br />
in Malaysia are considered among the cheapest<br />
in Asia. We are also the only branded residence<br />
in Kuala Lumpur to bring a luxury five-star<br />
hotel brand and a world class branded designer,<br />
Steve Leung & YOO into the mix, rather than<br />
just a hotel brand.<br />
What is the market outlook for such branded<br />
residences in Malaysia, particularly in KL?<br />
Despite soft market sentiments and the<br />
oversupply issues facing the Malaysian<br />
property market, we remain upbeat about<br />
the long-term prospect of the Kuala Lumpur<br />
property market. Furthermore, there is<br />
not much land left in the KLCC area and<br />
therefore supply is finite and limited.<br />
Firstly, Kuala Lumpur is still a key investment<br />
destination for businesses and investors.<br />
Secondly, the property market will enjoy the<br />
spillover effects of major mega infrastructure<br />
projects such as the High Speed Rail and<br />
MRT project, because once these projects are<br />
completed, they will change the city, just like any<br />
other major city in the world. By then, Kuala<br />
10<br />
8 Conlay was launched at<br />
RM2,700 psf in 2016 and reached<br />
RM3,200 psf in 2017.<br />
Lumpur will transform into a more vibrant and<br />
liveable city, and property prices are set to rise.<br />
So, the immediate need is to rebuild buyers’<br />
confidence. We cannot overlook the fact<br />
that today’s discerning buyers have high<br />
expectations and are very selective. In addition<br />
to pricing, their buying decisions are affected<br />
by factors like services, quality, location and<br />
capital appreciation.<br />
Buyers will continue to invest if they see the<br />
right property – developments offering the<br />
right concept, location (within the Kuala<br />
Lumpur city centre) and long-term rental yield<br />
potential. For example, they prefer branded<br />
residences due to its characteristics of better<br />
capital yield, quality hotel servicing and<br />
consistent maintenance of the property.<br />
As Kuala Lumpur transforms into a worldclass<br />
city, there is definitely greater demand<br />
for branded residences. Every city needs a<br />
gem development that will put the city on the<br />
world’s map, and branded residences have the<br />
capability to give Kuala Lumpur a different<br />
character that will put it on par with other top<br />
cities in the world.<br />
What other projects are in the pipeline in<br />
Malaysia for KSK Land?<br />
For the rest of 2018, we will remain<br />
focused on developing 8 Conlay, nurturing it<br />
to completion.<br />
11<br />
Any plans to expand overseas?<br />
If opportunity presents itself, KSK Land is<br />
open. However, for now, we see opportunities in<br />
prime locations in Malaysia.
20 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
BRANDED<br />
RESIDENCES<br />
THE INSIDER’S VIEW<br />
Asian Property Review talks to Chris Graham (Founder and MD of<br />
Graham Associates), who is regarded as one of the world’s foremost<br />
specialists on branded residences.<br />
1<br />
2<br />
Does the shift of consumer preference for<br />
more independence through branded serviced<br />
apartment spell the beginning of the demise<br />
for the pure stand-alone hotel set-up?<br />
There will always be strong demand for<br />
stand-alone hotels. Whilst branded residences<br />
and serviced apartments certainly add to the<br />
range of accommodation choices available<br />
to travellers, in reality these still represent a<br />
relatively small percentage of the market. In<br />
many cases – notably prime urban locations –<br />
the lack of availability and the high cost of land<br />
are key factors that can inhibit the opportunities<br />
to include a branded residential component<br />
alongside a hotel. Many travellers seeking<br />
greater independence are of course turning to<br />
AirBnB – although currently most branded<br />
operators do not permit their homeowners to<br />
use this platform to rent out their residences,<br />
which must instead be put into the operator’s<br />
managed rental programme.<br />
Apart from concierge and butler services,<br />
celebrity or Michelin chef restaurants, inhouse<br />
cinemas, branded spas, golf simulator,<br />
wine storage, award-winning designers and<br />
even starchitects, what other distinctive<br />
services or characteristics mark the branded<br />
service residence?<br />
100 Las Olas<br />
There is a long list of facilities and services that<br />
developers are incorporating in their branded<br />
residences (including those listed above). In<br />
addition, there is the convenience of owning a
May - June 2018<br />
21<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
I have seen cases where<br />
high-end developments use<br />
celebrities such as footballers<br />
to promote ‘the exclusiveness’<br />
of their offer, yet in reality<br />
many HNWIs do not wish<br />
to have these types of high<br />
profile individuals as their<br />
neighbours, so this can in fact<br />
sometimes have a negative<br />
impact.<br />
3<br />
“lock up and go” home, that will be kept secure<br />
and professionally maintained – and possibly<br />
earn valuable income - when the owner is not<br />
in residence.<br />
Above all, rather than simply providing more<br />
5*+ facilities, the focus is more about creating<br />
a personal and emotional engagement with<br />
customers. Some leading branded residences<br />
designers such as Luciano Mazza at HKS and<br />
John Hitchcox at YOO talk about creating<br />
“modern day communities” of like-minded<br />
people – a sort of exclusive residents club.<br />
Whilst buyers’ priorities remain consistent in<br />
terms of location, design and access to worldclass<br />
amenities, very much in line with trends<br />
in the hospitality sector, it is increasingly more<br />
about the intangible ‘added value’ lifestyle<br />
benefits associated with a brand. Increasingly,<br />
the shift is towards creating an emotional<br />
connection with residents through experiences.<br />
What are the most common challenges<br />
faced by developers when building a branded<br />
residence?<br />
There are innumerable challenges that a<br />
developer faces and every project brings its<br />
own unique set. I would say generally that<br />
securing the best locations and ensuring<br />
that branded residences are designed for the<br />
local marketplace rank quite high. On this<br />
second point, most branded operators have<br />
rigid guidelines about FF&E, room sizes<br />
and facilities so in some cases these may, for<br />
Chris Graham<br />
example, require that units will be too large –<br />
and therefore expensive - for the local market,<br />
when priced on a per sq m basis. Many<br />
developers today will appoint an operator once<br />
the design concept for the residences is already<br />
well developed, so marrying up the design to<br />
the brand guidelines in such circumstances can<br />
be an issue. Another challenge is financial –<br />
notably achieving sufficient off-plan pre-sales,<br />
since construction is often only triggered once a<br />
specified number of units has been sold.
22 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
Increasingly, the shift is towards<br />
creating an emotional connection<br />
with residents through experiences.<br />
4<br />
5<br />
In terms of the buyers, are they filtered to<br />
create an exclusive community of persons<br />
of a certain standing, yet free of scandals or<br />
drama – for some developments that you are<br />
aware of?<br />
When there is a committed buyer with<br />
money on the table sitting in front of a sales<br />
negotiator, it is very difficult for him or her to<br />
find reasons not to make a deal! However, I<br />
certainly know of situations where potential<br />
buyers have been politely turned away. In<br />
upper-upscale developments especially, most<br />
developers and their sales teams recognise<br />
the importance of maintaining an exclusive<br />
residential community and are well aware of<br />
the negative sentiment that one ‘less-thandesirable’<br />
resident can attract.<br />
Similarly, I have seen cases where high-end<br />
developments use celebrities such as footballers<br />
to promote ‘the exclusiveness’ of their offer, yet<br />
in reality many HNWIs do not wish to have<br />
these types of high profile individuals as their<br />
neighbours, so this can in fact sometimes have a<br />
negative impact.<br />
How much higher can we raise the bar for<br />
luxury or is it a meaningless word now, being<br />
overused and made up of standard offerings?<br />
Interbrand’s Rebecca Robins was spot on<br />
when she observed that the definition of<br />
luxury has become so diluted that it is<br />
becoming meaningless. This is particularly<br />
true in real estate, as almost every residential<br />
development that launches is promoted as<br />
“luxury”. Design, technology and innovation<br />
all continue to expand the boundaries and<br />
6<br />
7<br />
opportunities for developers, notably around<br />
sustainability and Smart Homes, which are<br />
fast becoming standard.<br />
Should branded residences adapt to<br />
their local environment by incorporating<br />
local elements such as local design and<br />
architecture, and materials - without diluting<br />
the world class standard of the branded hotel<br />
operator?<br />
There is no right or wrong way, as every<br />
situation is different. It depends on several<br />
things, for example the location, the intended<br />
target audience, and the brand. Some brands<br />
such as W have a very distinctive design<br />
style, which is either suited to a particular<br />
location and lifestyle or it isn’t. Generally,<br />
architects are pretty sympathetic to the local<br />
environment and prefer to use locally-sourced<br />
materials. I recently heard about an extreme<br />
example in which a developer moved an<br />
entire village across to his new resort site for<br />
total authenticity.<br />
What are the common challenges faced by<br />
luxury hotel brands when dealing with local<br />
developers as their partners?<br />
Ensuring that the developer designs and builds<br />
the property to satisfy its brand standards, and<br />
then subsequently maintaining the property<br />
to the highest standards. It is important<br />
to remember that a local developer may be<br />
seeking an earlier exit from the project than<br />
the international brand operator, so the<br />
operator needs to ensure that its interests<br />
– and those of the residence owners – are<br />
adequately protected over the longer term.
May - June 2018<br />
23<br />
8<br />
Upper Deck Sala View, Anantara Phuket Layan<br />
“80% of CEOs believe their brand differs from<br />
the competition, but only 20% of customers<br />
agree with that.” - Ricco de Blank, CEO of<br />
SHKP Hotels (owns two Ritz-Carltons, a St.<br />
Regis and a W Hotel)<br />
The above seems like a big disconnect in<br />
perception. How should the hotel CEOs<br />
rethink their brand differentiation?<br />
Yes, this quote neatly emphasises a key point<br />
I highlighted in my report. There is such a<br />
proliferation of brands competing at various<br />
levels of the market and to different audience<br />
segments, all trying to differentiate themselves<br />
by carving out a unique identity and positioning<br />
in the marketplace. Yet reading through<br />
many brand positioning statements is pretty<br />
confusing, even to industry professionals - and<br />
if we cannot understand what a particular hotel<br />
8<br />
Anantara Phuket Layan
24 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
Ocean Drive Residences<br />
I recently heard about an extreme<br />
example in which a developer moved<br />
an entire village across to his new resort<br />
site for total authenticity.<br />
brand represents, then how can consumers<br />
and potential purchasers be expected to<br />
do so? Piers Schmidt at Luxury Branding<br />
Consultancy undertook a study on this last<br />
year in which he found that a significant<br />
proportion of hotel brand slogans actually<br />
employ very similar sound bites, which he<br />
describes as “buzzword bingo at its best!”<br />
Branded residences that present a clearly<br />
defined and offer an attractive lifestyle which<br />
genuinely resonate with buying audiences, will<br />
succeed to a much greater degree than those<br />
that do not stand out for anything distinctive.<br />
9<br />
This is where good marketing can really make a<br />
difference, by effectively packaging, presenting<br />
and communicating the offer to differentiate<br />
the development, so that it truly stands out<br />
from its competitors.<br />
With so many branded residences in the<br />
market, do you think it will reach a saturation<br />
point where the customer can no longer see<br />
the differentiation?<br />
In the Southeast Asian market, notably<br />
Thailand and Vietnam, branded residences are<br />
now becoming so engrained and prolific in the<br />
market that they risk being the norm rather<br />
than the exception. Branded residences achieve<br />
a generous price premium over comparable<br />
non-branded homes because of the exclusivity<br />
and kudos that the association with the brand<br />
offers to owners; as such, in a market that is<br />
becoming ‘saturated’ with high-end branded<br />
residences, exclusivity can really only be defined<br />
by the desirability of the location and the<br />
perceived status of the brand itself.
May - June 2018<br />
25<br />
10<br />
11<br />
Any examples where the arrangement between<br />
the owner/developer and the brand operator is<br />
terminated. Usually, what are the reasons for<br />
the termination?<br />
Normally this is caused by a failure by the<br />
developer or operator to perform its obligations,<br />
a breach of contract, or any risk of causing<br />
damage to the brand. For example, if the<br />
common areas of the branded residences are not<br />
maintained to the required standards, e.g. due to<br />
insufficient funding, this usually gives the brand<br />
operator the right to terminate the association.<br />
Of course, this has significant repercussions for<br />
the residents and the value of their properties.<br />
Why is there a worldwide shift from branded<br />
resort residences towards branded urban<br />
mixed-use developments?<br />
Branded residences had been established in<br />
North America for many years before the<br />
global industry woke up to the benefits that<br />
they offer – not least as developers realised<br />
that they could benefit from a substantial price<br />
premium and (generally) faster sales absorption<br />
rate by partnering with a respected brand. This<br />
has been driven largely by increasing demand<br />
among HNWI consumers seeking high-end<br />
residences with the convenience of hotel<br />
services in their own homes, together with<br />
the confidence that the association with an<br />
established luxury brand delivers. Previously,<br />
with the high cost of purchasing prime central<br />
urban land combined with strong demand<br />
for luxury homes sustaining prices, urban<br />
developers did not see the need (along with the<br />
added costs) to bring on a brand; however, as<br />
markets soften, competition increases and the<br />
bar is raised, the branded option presents a very<br />
compelling route for more quickly achieving<br />
differentiation, status and sales.<br />
GRAHAM:<br />
TRENDS IN THE NEXT<br />
10 YEARS<br />
From my research and discussions with eminent<br />
market professionals around the globe, I predict<br />
the following trends during the next decade:<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
t<br />
Continuing expansion in the sector in terms<br />
of the number and range (i.e. sectors) of<br />
market participants.<br />
Broader quality of branded units for sale (i.e.<br />
lower star rated hotel operators).<br />
Less focus on ‘tangible’ elements, more on<br />
emotional connections.<br />
Wellbeing and positive ‘healing’<br />
environments will become mainstream.<br />
The emergence of residential lifestyle brands<br />
for specific demographic segments (e.g.<br />
retirement).<br />
The expansion of branded residences into<br />
exciting new destinations across the globe,<br />
including South America and Africa.<br />
More branded residences across Europe,<br />
both urban and resort.<br />
Premiums being squeezed in developed<br />
markets with more competition.<br />
More standalone branded residences, mostly<br />
in an urban environment.<br />
Editor’s Note: A free copy of the second edition of Chris<br />
Graham’s report “Branded Residences: An Overview”<br />
can be downloaded at www.gagms.com
26 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
RISING NUMBER<br />
AND DIVERSITY OF<br />
BRANDED<br />
RESIDENCES<br />
IN ASIA<br />
Even budget chain YOTEL is<br />
talking branded residences.<br />
Anantara Phuket Layan
May - June 2018<br />
27<br />
Asian Property Review talks to leading Asian hotel expert, Bill Barnett,<br />
Managing Director at C9 Hotelworks on the branded residences<br />
scenario in Asia.<br />
Which emerging Asian countries/cities/areas are<br />
sought after by developers of branded residences<br />
and the brands themselves?<br />
Large luxury hotel brands like Ritz-Carlton and Four<br />
Seasons are seeing a high proportion of their hotel<br />
pipeline being generated in mixed use or project with<br />
branded residences; they tend to favour gateway cities<br />
and key well-known leisure destinations with strong<br />
airlift. Japan has been active in top end projects like<br />
the Four Seasons Kyoto or Park Hyatt Hanazono<br />
near Niseko. Overall, the urban push is strongly,<br />
interestingly two key Asian resort brands, Aman and<br />
Six Senses, both have city branded residences coming<br />
up in New York City.<br />
Supply and demand track the<br />
overall real estate market and there<br />
remains strong sustained growth<br />
in the region, with the notable<br />
exception of Vietnam which may<br />
see an oversupply.<br />
How important is the investment angle to the Asian<br />
HNWI buyers of branded residences? What is the<br />
typical target rental return and capital appreciation?<br />
It all depends, it’s entirely a different universe<br />
for HNWI buyers. HNWIs often view trophy<br />
assets defined by location, brand and quality of<br />
development. It may be a second home or investment<br />
versus traditional yield-focused buyers.<br />
“Currently across<br />
Southeast Asia, there<br />
is an estimated 94<br />
mainstream hotel<br />
residence projects<br />
with more than 21,000<br />
units on line, with 78<br />
properties expected to<br />
complete between 2018<br />
and 2020, representing<br />
an 83% increase over<br />
current inventory.”<br />
It seems like SEA is Bill Barnett<br />
experiencing a boom.<br />
Do you think there will be an oversupply in the<br />
coming years given this exponential growth?<br />
Supply and demand track the overall real estate<br />
market and there remains strong sustained growth<br />
in the region, but there are some exceptions.<br />
Vietnam with between 20,000 to 30,000 condo<br />
projects comes to mind as potentially being<br />
oversupplied.<br />
What is the outlook for branded residences in Asia<br />
in the next 3 years?<br />
More and greater diversity in real estate grade from<br />
luxury to entry level. Even budget chain YOTEL is<br />
talking branded residences.<br />
How is the situation in China given the increasing<br />
number of HNWIs there and their propensity to<br />
buy branded goods including residences?<br />
China is likely to still experience growth given the<br />
government restriction on exporting capital; domestic<br />
investment into property is likely to remain active.
28 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />
DESIGNING<br />
A BRANDED<br />
RESIDENCE<br />
Asian Property Review talks to Arianna Leopard<br />
(Director) and Bruce Wright (Senior Vice President<br />
and Principal) from SB Architects on what it entails to<br />
design branded residences.<br />
Ocean Drive Residences<br />
1. How important is design for branded<br />
residences? How different would you<br />
approach a branded residence compared<br />
with say, a typical serviced apartment<br />
or condominium?<br />
All brand owners set guidelines<br />
and design specification to<br />
architects and developers so that<br />
they accurately reflect the brands<br />
down to the smallest details.<br />
We approach the design of<br />
branded residential differently<br />
than traditional serviced<br />
apartment. The unit sizes are<br />
generally larger than nonbranded<br />
equivalents,<br />
reflecting the trophy<br />
positioning.<br />
Branded<br />
residential<br />
needs to have a<br />
high-degree of<br />
personalization<br />
and the accent<br />
is on interiors<br />
that tag the<br />
buyer’s lifestyle and wrap around emotion and<br />
feelings. We seamlessly merge architecture,<br />
interior design, and lifestyle in a way that<br />
speaks to the aspirations of the buyer. Branded<br />
Residential uniquely differs from unbranded<br />
real estate in that the buyer of a branded<br />
property becomes a stakeholder in the brand.<br />
Usually the access to ownership comes at a<br />
higher cost, but the return is a deep emotional<br />
connection to the brand philosophy, culture<br />
and often the related hotel amenities.<br />
2. What are examples of the branded residences<br />
that you have designed? What are each of<br />
their unique characteristics?<br />
We have worked on several Ritz-Carlton<br />
properties over the years including Dorado<br />
Beach, A Ritz-Carlton Reserve, Ritz-<br />
Carlton, Rancho Mirage and The Cove, Ritz-<br />
Carlton Reserve Residences. We are working<br />
on two St. Regis properties, which will both<br />
include a residential component. For St.<br />
Regis Bahia Beach, we designed the Ocean<br />
Drive Residences and a series of custom<br />
estate homes.<br />
Arianna Leopard
May - June 2018<br />
29<br />
b<br />
DORADO BEACH, A RITZ-<br />
CARLTON RESERVE RESIDENCES,<br />
PUERTO RICO<br />
b<br />
These luxurious waterfront residences follow<br />
the contours of the beach to provide the most<br />
complete and private beachfront experience<br />
imaginable. The three and four-story<br />
structures feature two and three-bedroom<br />
units with a rooftop pool and covered living<br />
space. Some buildings include a fourthlevel<br />
penthouse with terraces on three<br />
sides to provide outdoor living space to all<br />
three bedroom suites. Expansive terraces or<br />
balconies for each unit connect to the indoor<br />
living spaces with retractable doors.<br />
OCEAN DRIVE RESIDENCES AT<br />
BAHIA BEACH<br />
Bahia Beach offers the tranquility and purity<br />
of a private island amid an unspoiled, lush<br />
tropical haven with spectacular beachfront<br />
views. These three- and four-bedroom<br />
residences are serviced by The St Regis and<br />
feature spacious interiors, ample terraces, etc.<br />
b<br />
Ocean Drive Residences<br />
LIHU COLD SPRINGS GOLF<br />
ESTATES, HAINAN ISLAND, CHINA<br />
This expansive resort development is sited<br />
along the shores of NanLiHu Lake, a<br />
stunning jewel on Hainan Island near the<br />
city of Haikou. Encompassing 122 ha, the<br />
master plan utilizes the site’s hilly topography<br />
to weave the golf fairways through existing<br />
valleys. Residences, lodging and public<br />
spaces are sited to capitalize on views of<br />
the golf course and lake. Residences range<br />
from single-family villas, to townhomes, to<br />
apartments in five and six-storey buildings.
The Lodges at Calistoga Ranch<br />
were formed around the trees,<br />
with many lodge terraces built<br />
with ancient trees growing up<br />
through the terraces.<br />
construction methods, which generally also<br />
makes financial sense. Combining destination<br />
specific material choices, and working so<br />
closely with these branded design details we<br />
can create properties that both embrace local<br />
qualities and exemplify the aesthetics of the<br />
brand owners.<br />
ONE St Petersburg<br />
3. How much of the local materials or culture<br />
do you appropriate for the design despite the<br />
typical standardization of such designs? Do<br />
the design owners e.g. hotel or luxury brands<br />
allow any deviation from their standard<br />
cookie cutter design?<br />
Our process begins with a deep respect<br />
for the site, the history of the land and the<br />
culture of its people. We are fully aware that<br />
to create authentic destinations, we must<br />
preserve the elements that have drawn us<br />
there in the first place.<br />
We always like to work with topography<br />
and use materials indigenous to the location.<br />
Developers in Asia can be somewhat<br />
pragmatic about introducing new materials,<br />
but we try to tie the design back to the history<br />
of the site, utilizing sustainable design and<br />
4. What sustainable features or construction<br />
methods/materials do you employ in your<br />
designs?<br />
We partner with a broad spectrum of<br />
consultants and certifying organizations to<br />
ensure that we deliver projects that are both<br />
ecologically and socially sustainable. Our<br />
experience working with organizations such<br />
as the USGBC and Audubon International<br />
give us the tools to create unique projects that<br />
live in harmony with their surroundings.<br />
In the initial design phase, we think about<br />
a myriad of elements that will inform our<br />
approach that includes everything from<br />
sunlight aspect placement that allows for<br />
maximum solar orientation for photovoltaic<br />
panels, to passive heating, and cooling<br />
systems. Local availability, recycled content,<br />
and sustainable production drive the selection<br />
of each material, appliance, and detail.
May - June 2018<br />
31<br />
GLOBAL FOOTPRINT<br />
Based in San Francisco, Miami and Shenzhen,<br />
China, SB architects has a global footprint with<br />
projects in China, North America, Lebanon,<br />
Montenegro, Egypt, Puerto Rico and Mexico to<br />
name a few. A recent project that the firm is proud of<br />
is the Miami Design District, which transformed the<br />
once gritty Miami neighbourhood into a glamorous<br />
international luxury shopping destination with two<br />
department stores, rooftop gardens, a boutique hotel<br />
and luxury condominiums. In China, they have just<br />
completed the design work for Luneng Wen’an<br />
winery and resort.<br />
Bruce Wright<br />
For example the Calistoga Ranch in Sonoma,<br />
the site was on a 52-acre California live oak<br />
parcel, and the resort had to be designed<br />
to not despoil or do damage to the ancient<br />
trees present on the site. So, the Lodges at<br />
Calistoga Ranch were formed around the<br />
trees, with many lodge terraces built with<br />
ancient trees growing up through the terraces.<br />
5. What are the branded residences in the<br />
pipeline that you are working on?<br />
100 Las Olas<br />
Most of our resort projects included branded<br />
residential into the program such as St.<br />
Regis Los Cabos at Quivira in Mexico and<br />
Mandarin Oriental in Boca Raton.
32 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
SHOPHOUSES<br />
IN A CLASS OF ITS OWN
May - June 2018<br />
33
34 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
SINGAPORE<br />
SHOPHOUSES<br />
SOUGHT-AFTER TROPHY ASSETS<br />
The allure of the Singapore shophouse goes beyond its architectural<br />
history and aesthetics or even its limited supply; ultimately,<br />
it’s about owning a part of Singapore’s history.<br />
Text & Photography by Jan Yong<br />
A<br />
treasure trove of historical assets are<br />
changing hands at record prices in<br />
Singapore. On 31st March 2018, the<br />
headline in Singapore’s Straits Times<br />
read: “8M buys shophouses, building for $82.5m.”<br />
That averages about SGD10 mil for each shophouse.<br />
In land-scarce Singapore, landed properties are<br />
priced at a massive premium and this naturally<br />
applies to all shophouses particularly conservation or<br />
heritage shophouses.<br />
Conservation shophouses are heritage buildings<br />
that were given conservation status by the Urban<br />
Redevelopment Authority of Singapore (URA),<br />
says Simon Monteiro, Associate Director at Savills<br />
Singapore specialising in heritage buildings. “There<br />
are about 8,900 estimated buildings in primary and<br />
secondary areas that are gazetted. This means their<br />
façade needs to be maintained. For those located<br />
in the primary core areas such as Boat Quay, Amoy<br />
Street, Telok Ayer Street and Boon Tat Street,<br />
you can’t do much to them whereas you could still<br />
increase a few levels to 4-5 storeys for those in the<br />
secondary areas.”<br />
Due to their very limited number, the heritage<br />
shophouses command an even bigger premium and<br />
are sought after by real estate funds, family offices,<br />
foreign companies specialising in design, finance,<br />
investment and business consultancy as well as Ultra<br />
High Net Worth Individuals (UHNWIs) – from<br />
Singapore and abroad.<br />
Simon Monteiro<br />
Examples of funds include 8M Real Estate, Silk<br />
Road Partners, Clifton Real Estate & Arc Assets.<br />
Heritage shophouses in Singapore are equivalent<br />
to rare vintage collectibles – they are collected due<br />
to their intrinsic historical and cultural as well<br />
as artistic value. There is also the advantage of<br />
staggering capital appreciation due to their limited<br />
quantity. “The high net worth buyers don’t buy them<br />
for rental returns because the return is dismal, falling<br />
from 7 – 8% back in the 1980s to about 2 -3 % these<br />
days,” Monteiro reveals.<br />
The inverse relationship of skyrocketing capital<br />
appreciation to falling rental yield can be explained<br />
by the fact that there are comparatively many more
A number of heritage shophouses have been<br />
converted into boutique hotels. This one in<br />
Kampong Glam sports a very captivating facade.<br />
buyers than tenants for these heritage shophouses.<br />
The high net worth buyers have the holding power<br />
and can keep the shophouses without even renting<br />
them out. Meanwhile, tenants are not as many due<br />
to the high rentals commanded by these soughtafter<br />
units. It takes a very profitable business to<br />
survive these rents.<br />
During a survey in the tourist areas of Kampong<br />
Glam, Haji Lane and Arab Street where there is a<br />
proliferation of these heritage shophouses, Asian<br />
Property Review saw a handful of upper floor units<br />
being advertised for rental while there were none<br />
observed for sale.<br />
Prices have been rising steadily in the last 10 to 15<br />
years. In 2005, a 99-year leasehold in Duxton Hill<br />
area will cost about $380 psf. “Today, these streets<br />
are sought after and command prices above $2,000<br />
psf based on the estimated built-up area of 3,500 sq<br />
ft to 5,000 sq ft,” says Monteiro.<br />
“I remember selling 3 assets in Duxton Hill in 2005<br />
- 28 Duxton Hill and 20/21 Duxton Hill - for $6.1<br />
mil for all 3; today you have to pay about 7 to 8<br />
times as much,” Monteiro continues.<br />
“Prices of freehold units are even higher, going from<br />
$600 psf in 2005 to an estimated $3,500 psf in<br />
today’s market.”<br />
Due to their very limited number, the<br />
heritage shophouses command an even<br />
bigger premium and are sought after by<br />
real estate funds, family offices, foreign<br />
companies specialising in design,<br />
finance, investment and business<br />
consultancy as well as Ultra High Net<br />
Worth Individuals (UHNWIs) – from<br />
Singapore and abroad.<br />
- Monteiro<br />
FOREIGN FACTOR<br />
Despite the sky high prices, buyers are literally lining<br />
up to buy them. Among them are foreigners.<br />
“In general, the price increase over the last 20 years<br />
was due to the economy, scarcity, heritage, the unique<br />
Singapore theme and an increasingly affluent society.<br />
A notable factor is also the influx of UHNWIs from<br />
abroad looking at shophouses as a unique alternative<br />
asset to condominiums and common office spaces in<br />
normal office buildings,” Monteiro notes.<br />
The fact that the government promotes locations<br />
such as Chinatown, Little India and Kampong Glam<br />
also helps to bring in the crowds which increases the<br />
value of the shophouses there.
36 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
Most owners don’t want to sell<br />
even if a very attractive offer comes<br />
along. This is because they want to<br />
keep the shophouses as an asset for<br />
future generations.<br />
– Han<br />
Vanz Han Liang Siew<br />
Richard Tan Kah Peng<br />
The only restriction for foreigners is that the<br />
shophouses must be designated commercial<br />
properties located in fully commercial zones.<br />
Foreigners can have 100% ownership and the tenure<br />
can be freehold or leasehold of variable years. The<br />
most popular tenure especially among Indonesians<br />
and Malaysians is for the 999-year lease which is<br />
effectively a freehold title.<br />
“In my opinion, we have about 3,000 to 3,500 units<br />
that a foreigner can safely buy without the need for<br />
paying Additional Buyer Stamp Duty (ABSD) or<br />
the need to get approval from the Land Dealings<br />
Unit, a department that controls land ownership on<br />
land which is zoned landed residential,” the heritage<br />
assets specialist continues.<br />
“The rest are either fully residential or mix<br />
residential /commercial, the sale of which are<br />
restricted to Singaporeans and companies with<br />
Singaporean directors only.”<br />
“As with antiques, beauty and passion lie in the eyes<br />
of the beholder. There is no right time to buy as<br />
it’s more of an emotional buy; the buyer values the<br />
architectural history and aesthetics and wants to own<br />
a piece of Singapore history and maybe be part of our<br />
diverse culture,” Monteiro adds.<br />
DEMAND OUTSTRIPS SUPPLY<br />
For shophouses that have not been gazetted as<br />
conservation or heritage, demand similarly outstrips<br />
supply but in this case, the rental yield is an<br />
important consideration, says Richard Tan Kah Peng<br />
from PropNex (Richard Tan & Associates). “Most<br />
buyers are looking at good yield. Their greatest fear is<br />
that they can’t rent out.”<br />
“To determine yield, it’s crucial to look at the lease<br />
tenure – the balance remaining on the lease if it’s<br />
not 999 years or freehold. For example, even if the<br />
yield is high but if the balance lease is only 20 years,<br />
then it’s not worth buying because you will have to<br />
renew the lease at the expiry and this is subject to the<br />
government or private owner’s approval,” Tan explains.<br />
On the other hand, even if the yield is a low 2%, it<br />
is almost certain that after 50 years, the yield will<br />
rise. In other words, if the tenure is longer, you will<br />
definitely break even eventually, he concludes.<br />
In terms of yield, the rate differs on every floor. A<br />
popular location is Lorong Haji which can fetch<br />
SGD8-10 psf for the ground floor and less for the<br />
upper floor.<br />
Chinese-style shophouses at Short Street.<br />
A savvy investor will also look at the tenant profile.<br />
If it’s a new tenant, they might not survive the rental
May - June 2018<br />
37<br />
Around Haji Lane and Arab Street, a lot of the corner shophouses showcase<br />
murals on their exterior walls.Tourists love taking their photos there.<br />
while a famous or popular tenant will command a<br />
better rental rate.<br />
Without a doubt, the most popular and expensive<br />
shophouses are those located in the CBD area in<br />
Districts 1 and 2, as well as Districts 9 and 10. The<br />
latter comprises a lot of mixed developments, prime<br />
shopping areas like Orchard and River Valley road,<br />
Holland Road where a lot of middle to upper class<br />
residents and expatriates are staying.<br />
“Tourist areas such as District 7 comprising<br />
Kampung Glam, Arab Street, Little India and<br />
Chinatown are also popular as the footfall is high,”<br />
says Vanz Han Liang Siew of Propnex (Vanz Han<br />
& Associates).<br />
“Transaction volume has fallen but the price has<br />
gone up. This is because there is more demand than<br />
supply. Transactions peaked in 2012 – 2013 with<br />
about 200 – 300 transactions a year but since the<br />
last 2 years, it has hovered around 200 transactions<br />
In recent years, buyers from China,<br />
Indonesia, Hong Kong, Malaysia<br />
and Europe, and even a handful from<br />
Vietnam, Thailand and Mynamar have<br />
snapped them up – some even buying a<br />
few in a row.<br />
– Tan<br />
per year. Most owners don’t want to sell even if a<br />
very attractive offer comes along. This is because they<br />
want to keep the shophouses as an asset for future<br />
generations,” Han observes.<br />
“Between 2014 – 2016, the transaction volume fell<br />
to about 100 transactions a year but in 2017, there<br />
were 148 transactions with visibly more Malaysian<br />
participation. In the first quarter of 2018, the<br />
increased volume continues and we foresee the total<br />
number of transactions for the whole of 2018 might<br />
surpass that of 2017,” predicts Tan.
38 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
… even if the yield is high but if<br />
the balance lease is only 20 years,<br />
then it’s not worth buying because<br />
you will have to renew the lease<br />
at the expiry and this is subject to<br />
the government or private owner’s<br />
approval.<br />
– Tan<br />
higher while for 2 or 3-storey, the lower per sq foot<br />
price of the upper floors will reduce the overall price<br />
of the entire shophouse,” adds Han.<br />
In some cases however, the ground floor and the<br />
upper floor units might have separate titles and<br />
owners, hence the buyer might only be able to buy<br />
one floor – obviously the ground floor is more in<br />
demand and can command a higher price due to its<br />
higher footfall.<br />
There are also shophouses where the ground floor<br />
is designated commercial but the upper floor is<br />
designated residential. If the entire shophouse is held<br />
under one title deed, then foreigners aren’t allowed to<br />
buy these at all.<br />
The 5-foot walkway along Kandahar Street, Kampung Glam<br />
Also, the Singapore economy is picking up so a lot<br />
of sellers are holding up for a higher price. At the<br />
same time, there are a lot of en bloc sales going on<br />
with new launches expected to scale higher prices.<br />
“We expect to see new launches hitting new levels<br />
of high,” Han anticipates.<br />
There is no doubt shophouses are facing boom time<br />
prices – for example, a 999-year old ground floor<br />
unit in Bugis Cube is selling for SGD10,000 psf<br />
while in Alexandria, a ground floor unit was sold<br />
at SGD9,000 psf even though it is only a 99-year<br />
leasehold of a new development.<br />
“For Kampong Glam (conservation shophouses),<br />
you have to see whether it is a one-storey, double<br />
or 3-storey shophouse. If purely only one storey<br />
ground floor, the per square foot price will be<br />
BUYING BINGE<br />
In recent years, buyers from China, Indonesia, Hong<br />
Kong, Malaysia and Europe, and even a handful<br />
from Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar have snapped<br />
them up – with some even buying a few in a row.<br />
Asians far outnumber the Europeans, especially<br />
those from China and Indonesia although last year<br />
saw quite a number of UHNWIs from Malaysia on<br />
a buying spree, Tan reveals.<br />
For foreigners with that kind of deep pockets, it’s<br />
the most natural alternative asset after residential<br />
properties. Singapore is considered a safe haven by<br />
HNWIs and these shophouses have great potential<br />
for long-term capital appreciation which fit their<br />
strategy of wealth building and leaving a legacy for<br />
their next generation. There is also the advantage of<br />
political stability and a strong currency.<br />
Another plus point is the flexibility of usage as<br />
compared to the pure office space or retail space
May - June 2018<br />
39<br />
TIPS FOR FOREIGN<br />
BUYERS<br />
Tan and Han from PropNex recommend the following:<br />
Dr Julian Davison<br />
in office buildings or mall respectively. If the<br />
shophouse has 3 or 4 storeys, you can have a<br />
gym or consultancies on the upper floors while<br />
the lower floor can be used for spas or F & B<br />
businesses such as restaurants, bakeries or bars.<br />
F&b businesses are the most sought after tenants<br />
due to their perceived viability and the fact that<br />
F&B is one business that still requires a physical<br />
presence while retail is gradually moving to the<br />
online space through e-commerce.<br />
On top of that, most of the conservation shophouses<br />
are located in prime city centre areas such as<br />
Chinatown, Little India, etc. The capital appreciation<br />
that can be expected is staggering. How high it can<br />
go is anybody’s guess – as long as the government<br />
does not restrict sales to foreigners and as long<br />
as no further shophouses are given conservation<br />
status, the 8,900 shophouses will continue to rise<br />
in value notwithstanding the ups and downs of the<br />
Singaporean property market.<br />
Clearly, the market gyrations have little effect on<br />
the conservation shophouse value due to its limited<br />
number and historical value – every shophouse has<br />
a different history and that adds further value to<br />
the individual shophouse. This can be attested by<br />
Dr Julian Davison who has studied shophouses in<br />
Singapore and has written a book about it called<br />
simply ‘Singapore Shophouse’. It’s a compelling read<br />
particularly for those thinking about investing in one.<br />
1. Some shophouses have commercial title for the<br />
ground floor while the upper floors have residential<br />
strata titles. In such cases, the foreigner can only<br />
buy the ground floor. If however, the entire unit is<br />
held under one title including the residential upper<br />
floor, then the foreigner can’t buy any portion of the<br />
unit at all.<br />
2. It’s better to use a company to buy and to register<br />
the company as a GST-registered company to<br />
purchase those units with GST. They can then claim<br />
back the 7% GST if their company is GST-registered.<br />
3. Use an investment holding company to buy 100% of<br />
the shares of the company owning the commercial<br />
properties e.g. shophouse. This will save you the<br />
3% stamp duty for purchase of the shophouse.<br />
Instead, you pay only 0.2% of the transfer tax. Your<br />
company is also exempted from the 15% additional<br />
buyers’ tax. Foreigners can own 100% shares of a<br />
Singapore-incorporated company. The corporate<br />
tax is 17% maximum while for individuals, it can be<br />
over 20%. Note: this is only applicable to purchasing<br />
commercial properties under company name.<br />
4. Property tax for commercial property is subject to a<br />
ceiling of 10% unlike residential which can go up to<br />
16% for both individuals and companies.<br />
5. Tenure – sometimes it’s better to buy a leasehold in<br />
a high traffic area despite a relatively short balance<br />
on the lease rather than a freehold in a quiet area.<br />
This is because commercial property is all about<br />
location and rental. The leasehold may command<br />
higher rentals than the freehold due to its prime<br />
location. If the rental is higher, then the capital<br />
value will also go up.<br />
6. Proximity to the MRT station helps; it is a bonus<br />
point when buying property.
40 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
THE SINGAPORE SHOPHOUSE<br />
WINDOW TO THE<br />
PAST & FUTURE<br />
Simon Monteiro, Associate Director at Savills Singapore specialises in<br />
heritage buildings especially shophouses and boutique hotels. He was a witness<br />
to the great Singapore Shophouse Investing phenomenon from the<br />
beginning and hopes to be part of its future as well. Here, he narrates his<br />
experience as a witness as well as a participant of the ongoing story.<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
“When I was 12 years old, I used to follow<br />
my grandmother to work. She worked at The<br />
Mission to Seamen which was housed in a<br />
shophouse at 219 River Valley Road which also<br />
contains a small chapel. Shophouses have intrigued<br />
me since then. (In 2001, a week after the 911 attack<br />
on the World Trade Centre, they decided to sell the<br />
shophouse which has a total area of 4,500 sq ft for<br />
SGD950K to a couple.)<br />
When I started my career back in 1994, my first sale<br />
was a beautiful 5,500-sq-ft residential shophouse<br />
at 55 Spottisowoode Park Road, which I sold for<br />
SGD1.6 mil to a doctor.<br />
Between 1997- 2001, I was attached with Goldhill<br />
Group of Companies. It was a lucky break. They<br />
were the pioneers in Conservation Shophouses.<br />
The late Mr William Goei, whom I worked for,<br />
is the ‘Father of Investing in Shophouses’, in my<br />
opinion. Between 1988 and 2007, he purchased,<br />
restored and refurbished many shophouses in the<br />
Duxton and Tanjong Pagar area. He later sold<br />
them for a profit.<br />
ORIGIN OF THE SINGAPORE<br />
SHOPHOUSE<br />
In 1819 with the founding of Singapore by Sir<br />
Stamford Raffles, what was once a small fishing<br />
village, grew to become an entreport. Various culture<br />
and ethnic groups came and this brought about a<br />
mix of different people working to create Singapore<br />
into a trading hub.<br />
Raffles saw the need to segregate the various ethnic<br />
groups into separate areas. So today thanks to<br />
him, we have Little India, Chinatown, Kampong<br />
Glam, and Arab Street. People from parts of China,<br />
the Middle East, Java, and India started arriving<br />
and brought with them the different styles of<br />
architecture that would later be infused into today’s<br />
Singapore shophouses.<br />
The government started looking into conservation<br />
in the 1970s but it was not until the late 1980s that<br />
they decided to take action to create a conservation<br />
plan for Singapore. The first Sale of Site by the<br />
government was in Duxton, Duxton Hill, Tanjong<br />
Pagar and Neil Road area.
May - June 2018<br />
41<br />
Simon<br />
Monteiro<br />
This was in 1988 and it started the movement of<br />
the Singapore Shophouse. These shophouses were<br />
later refurbished. They were cheap, maybe $200psf<br />
and were later sold at $400psf in 2005 and now it’s<br />
$2,200psf on average for a 99-yr Leasehold.<br />
The floor plate is typically 2/3/4-storey with a land<br />
size of 1,000 sq ft to 1,500 sq ft. So the built-up of a<br />
typical 2-storey shophouse is 2,000 sq ft to 3,000sqft<br />
which may come with an additional attic which is<br />
anywhere from 200 sq ft to 500 sq ft depending on<br />
the configuration.<br />
So a 2 1/5 Storey will command in today’s market<br />
the price of $7m to $8m for a 99-year leasehold<br />
These 8,900 shophouses are<br />
a window to our past and<br />
they can be used to tell the<br />
Singapore story.<br />
to about between<br />
$9.5m and $11m for<br />
a Freehold/999-Yr<br />
shophouse.<br />
A 3-storey shophouse<br />
with attic would easily go for<br />
$14m - $15m and for a 999-<br />
year freehold unit around $17.5m to<br />
$19m with corner unit having a premium because<br />
it brings better natural lighting and better frontage<br />
for visual advantage.<br />
There is also the 4-storey shophouse with prices<br />
ranging from $17m-$18m for a 99-year leasehold<br />
and more than $20m for a 999-year freehold.<br />
URA has gazetted about 8,900 units with<br />
Conservation status, located within a mix of Primary<br />
Areas and Secondary Areas. Primary areas comprise<br />
mainly the core CBD areas like Amoy Street, Telok<br />
Ayer Street and Boon Tat Street.
42 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
coffeeshop style of operations in Tanjong Pagar,<br />
Duxton and Tras Street.<br />
The URA then started regulating pub licenses and<br />
outlawed massage parlours in this area. This created<br />
a better tenant mix of upmarket businesses such as<br />
consultancies, hedge funds, family offices and fund<br />
investment houses which started coming in from<br />
2010. Today, in addition to those, you have a great<br />
mix of entertainment outlets and co-working spaces.<br />
The F & B units that were on the ground floor were<br />
also paying better rentals and this gave investors<br />
the motivation to spend on the refurbishments.<br />
One of my clients who is a Hong Kong permanent<br />
resident, started buying up some shoplots there and<br />
refurbishing them with million-dollar uplifts to<br />
the interiors, and the layout. These units became so<br />
pleasing that they attracted better quality tenants<br />
like upmarket restaurants and boutique firms. This<br />
brought in a more affluent crowd.<br />
GENTRIFICATION AND RENTALS<br />
The rental returns are now very low - below 3%<br />
rental to cost of acquisition compared to the 6% to<br />
7% rental yield in 2005. The rental have not gone up<br />
as much as the capital appreciation.<br />
HOSPITALITY-INCLINED<br />
I also sold The Duxton Hotel to a client who<br />
refurbished it into a boutique hotel taking the asset<br />
to the next level of Ultra High Net Places (UHNP),<br />
a word which I coined for heritage assets that have<br />
been refurbished to such an extent that they attract<br />
the most affluent people in our society.<br />
This is due to the high demand for shophouses and<br />
also gentrification. The URA was also looking at<br />
regulating the use of these conservation shophouses.<br />
I believe the start of real gentrification was at the<br />
Duxton / Duxton Hill area which is home to a<br />
beautiful part of Tanjong Pagar where you can view<br />
some very nice architecture of the past. The cobbled<br />
stone walkway up Duxton Hill gives you a sense of<br />
walking on sacred ground. In the 1890s, the street<br />
on Duxton Hill was the Millionaires Row where the<br />
rich peranakans used to live.<br />
Compare this to 2005 when I used to lease<br />
shophouses to many pubs, massage parlours and
May - June 2018<br />
43<br />
The F & B units that were on the<br />
ground floor were also paying better<br />
rentals and this gave investors<br />
the motivation to spend on the<br />
refurbishments.<br />
Along Neil Road, at No: 136/138, Goethe Institute<br />
leased from me years ago. This is one of the finest<br />
works of Swan & Mclaren Architects who in the<br />
late 1920s designed one of the most eye-catching<br />
heritage assets which is still flourishing today with its<br />
architectural ingenuity.<br />
Today, many of the new owners of the Singapore<br />
Shophouses are from real estate funds and UHNWIs<br />
looking at owning great assets that have a bespoke<br />
heritage of the past. Many investors also like to own<br />
hospitality assets with a heritage past.<br />
I sold Naumi Liora recently to 8M Real Estate<br />
while Hotel 1929 was sold to Mr Cheong Koon<br />
Hooi who is also the owner of The Warehouse Hotel.<br />
When I acquired Wanderlust for Mr Loh Lik Peng,<br />
his vision of hospitality gentrification from an old<br />
school to a hip and well known hotel speaks volume<br />
of what one can do to a heritage asset.<br />
I am looking into doing the same in Singapore’s<br />
other heritage streets where we can bring together<br />
buyers who are into heritage, talented architects and<br />
F & B and hospitality entrepreneurs to transform the<br />
streets into a gentrified area attracting tourists and<br />
locals alike.<br />
Working alongside me is Dr Julian Davison who<br />
has written a coffee table book entitled ‘Singapore<br />
Shophouse’, a compelling narrative inclusive of<br />
wonderful photography of the history of the<br />
Singapore shophouse. Dr Davison is an authority on<br />
this heritage asset. Together, we are confident that<br />
the next 10 – 15 years will see more shophouse areas<br />
being gentrified amid growing tourist numbers.<br />
Added to this mix are<br />
the millennials who<br />
started the co-working<br />
and co-living concepts.<br />
We will all come together<br />
for ‘Co-Minding’ sessions<br />
– basically a word I coined<br />
to mean like-minded people<br />
coming together to change the way<br />
the world works.<br />
Closely related to this is Dr Davison’s work<br />
which endeavours to give a story to each of<br />
the heritage shophouse. We are creating a<br />
unique formula to better make use of our built<br />
heritage to showcase our past glories and pains<br />
as our society progresses further. These 8,900<br />
shophouses are a window to our past and they<br />
can be used to tell the Singapore story. ”<br />
9 NEIL ROAD<br />
Between 1987 and 1988, 32 dilapidated<br />
shophouses of a hybrid Hokkien-<br />
Teochew style were restored by the Urban<br />
Redevelopment Authority. This was the first<br />
ever project undertaken by the government<br />
to demonstrate to the private sector that it<br />
was technically possible and commercially<br />
viable to restore Singapore’s heritage<br />
buildings to their former glory. The first unit<br />
to be restored was 9 Neil Road. It was then<br />
converted into a teahouse which hosted<br />
Queen Elizabeth II on her State visit in 1989.<br />
– Source: URA.<br />
Dr Julian Davison
44 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
BUYING HERITAGE<br />
SHOPHOUSES<br />
IN MALAYSIA<br />
Asian Property Review chats with KL See, director of Metro Homes<br />
Sdn Bhd who is also the deputy president of the Malaysian Institute<br />
of Professional Estate Agents and Consultants (MIPEAC) on the<br />
investability of shophouses in Malaysia.<br />
1 Define heritage shophouses in Malaysia.<br />
A heritage shophouse or building is defined under the<br />
National Heritage Act 2005 (ACT 645) as a building<br />
or groups of separate or connected buildings which,<br />
because of their architecture, their homogeneity<br />
or their place in the landscape, are of outstanding<br />
universal value from the point of view of history, art<br />
or science.<br />
It is always the right time to buy<br />
heritage shophouses in Malaysia due<br />
to their limited supply.<br />
2 Given that conservation or heritage shophouses<br />
are a limited asset class, do you think its price<br />
will hold steady and even increase over the years<br />
despite negative factors such as oversupply of new<br />
shophouses or sluggish economic conditions?<br />
Yes, the price will hold steady and a marginal increase<br />
over the years is expected because of its limited<br />
availability. But overall, such shophouses are still<br />
subject to town planning laws, etc. For example,<br />
rules such as traffic flow, parking requirements will<br />
affect the entire area which may contain heritage<br />
shophouses. But these external factors will not have a<br />
major impact on heritage shophouses.<br />
3 Is it the right time now to buy heritage shophouses<br />
in Malaysia? If yes, which are the preferred areas?<br />
Yes, it is always the right time to buy heritage<br />
shophouses in Malaysia due to their limited supply.<br />
Most of the time, the unit is sold even before it<br />
reaches the market as there is always a group of<br />
investor ready to buy it.<br />
Penang, Melaka and Kuala Lumpur are popular<br />
locations but Ipoh is now the new destination for<br />
tourists – be they locals or foreigners.
May - June 2018<br />
45<br />
Jonker street in Malacca is filled with<br />
restored heritage shophouses which<br />
makes it very popular with tourists.<br />
4 Who are mainly the buyers and why do they prefer<br />
heritage shophouses?<br />
The buyers are mainly locals who are already<br />
operating a business in a heritage shophouse or are<br />
planning to do so. Foreigners who buy are those who<br />
appreciate the value of heritage shophouses although<br />
in some cases, they might be put off by the cost of<br />
conservation or renovation.<br />
5 Apart from those doing businesses in heritage<br />
shophouses, why are heritage shophouses not<br />
popular as an investment asset with locals?<br />
Locals don’t see the long term potential value of the<br />
shophouse as they are usually in a bad condition due<br />
to age, say for example, a 100-year-old shophouse.<br />
It is usually 2 storeys only – and furthermore, most<br />
of these are located in the city centre which lacks<br />
parking space and are usually adjacent to narrow<br />
roads. New township shophouses on the other hand<br />
have ample parking spaces.<br />
6 For foreigners, what are the limitations, if any?<br />
The only limitation is the same which applies to all<br />
foreigners e.g. in KL, it has to be RM1 mil or above.<br />
Like any<br />
commercial<br />
property, it is<br />
easy to get a<br />
loan – the only<br />
challenge is the<br />
valuation.<br />
See Kok Loong<br />
7 What is the price range (psf ) for heritage<br />
shophouses in the most sought-after locations and<br />
what was the appreciation like since 2009?<br />
For KL, the price per sq foot varies tremendously for<br />
example, along Jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman alone,<br />
the price can range from RM800 psf to RM8,000 psf<br />
between 2009 - 2017! (See table).<br />
As for Penang, we have many transactions of pre-war<br />
shophouses e.g. 80 transactions for Georgetown alone<br />
from 2009 – 2017. As an example, as per the table, in<br />
Kawasan Jalan Penang, a shop which sold for RM215<br />
psf in 2009 was transacted at RM1,669 psf in 2017.<br />
That’s six times plus increase in appreciation.
46 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
TRANSACTION PRICES OF SHOPHOUSES IN JALAN TUANKU ABDUL RAHMAN 2009 - 2017<br />
Transaction Date Area Address City Category Condition Land Area (Sq Ft) Price Per Sq Ft. (Rm)<br />
3-Oct-17 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No.44, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,537.01 3,211.21<br />
4-Jan-17 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No.153, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,098.96 8,099.25<br />
28-Aug-15 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 497, Jln Tuanku Abd.rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,884.87 1,782.62<br />
24-Aug-15 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 217, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,292.71 6,106.31<br />
10-Oct-14 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 520, Jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,095.93 858.81<br />
20-May-14 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 47, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,472.91 4,043.82<br />
3-Jun-13 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 346, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,002.09 499.48<br />
27-Aug-12 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 3, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,995.93 3,206.53<br />
30-Nov-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 319, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,999.93 1,000.03<br />
28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />
28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />
28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />
23-Dec-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 442,jln Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,997.93 825.85<br />
11-Nov-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 502,jalan Tar Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,883.68 849.40<br />
11-Nov-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 504,jalan Tar / Jln Ipoh Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,878.46 851.76<br />
12-Oct-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 358,jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,002.09 549.43<br />
6-Mar-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 501,jln Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,838.94 1,141.96<br />
Transaction Date Area Address Location Category Condition Land Area (Sq Ft) Price Per Sq Ft. (Rm)<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 41, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 39, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 33, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,044.10 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 35, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 37, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 43, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 47, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 979.51 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 49, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 53, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 656.60 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 45, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />
13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 55, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,108.68 1,669.97<br />
29-Jul-15 Kawasan Jalan Penang 212, Jln Transfer Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 2,143.92 704.32<br />
10-Mar-15 Kawasan Jalan Penang 18, Lebuh Dickens Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,421.95 1,406.52<br />
14-Apr-14 Kawasan Jalan Penang 133, Jln Hutton Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 3,288.89 851.35<br />
13-Mar-14 Kawasan Jalan Penang 107, Hutton Lane Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 723.98 897.81<br />
20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 326, Jalan Penang Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 850.35 215.36<br />
20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 322, Jalan Penang Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 904.17 215.4<br />
20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 324, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 215.53<br />
20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 318, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 957.99 215.45<br />
20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 320, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 925.70 217.84<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 55, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,108.68 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 53, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 656.60 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 51, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 764.24 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 47, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 979.51 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 45, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 41, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 49, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 43, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 39, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 37, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 35, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 33, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,044.10 215.43<br />
18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 31, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 14,025.36 215.43<br />
Source: JPPH
May - June 2018<br />
47<br />
8 How is the rental yield?<br />
Rental yield is not high - usually around 2-3% and<br />
this is also one reason why locals are not so interested<br />
because the cost of fund is higher as compared to<br />
Singapore and Hong Kong which is below 2%.<br />
After the repeal of the Rent Control Act 1966 in<br />
1997, although owners of pre-war shophouses could<br />
increase their rentals, by then many local tenants<br />
prefer townships outside of KL city centre.<br />
As for Penang and Melaka, the story is a bit different<br />
because some core city centre areas of Georgetown<br />
and Melaka were designated as UNESCO heritage<br />
sites. This attracted a lot of tourists - continuous<br />
government promotion of local tourism and social<br />
media also contributed to the interest in shophouses<br />
there. As a result, there were a lot of transactions in<br />
those areas in the last 10 years.<br />
A row of restored shophouses in Penang.<br />
9 Are newly built shophouses a competition in terms<br />
of price and rental yield?<br />
Newly built shophouses are targeted at a different<br />
market now - the yield is higher and it usually has<br />
more floors such as 4-5 storeys as compared to the<br />
2-storey heritage shophouses.<br />
For KL, the price per sq foot varies<br />
tremendously for example, along Jalan<br />
Tuanku Abdul Rahman alone, the price<br />
can range from RM800 psf to RM8,000<br />
psf between 2009 - 2017!<br />
10 Why are boutique hotels and eateries such popular<br />
businesses in heritage shophouses?<br />
These businesses have a lifestyle element where<br />
customers have the time to appreciate and live in<br />
to understand more about the heritage building.<br />
It is unlike selling groceries where the shopper is<br />
more concerned about the price and then move on.<br />
Retailing is also not popular due to the popularity of<br />
e-commerce – it’s not able to survive the high cost of<br />
heritage buildings.<br />
11 Is it easy to get a loan to purchase heritage<br />
shophouses? Can foreigners obtain such a loan?<br />
Yes, like any commercial property, it is easy to get a<br />
loan – the only challenge is the valuation. The bank’s<br />
panel of valuers would be adding the restoration<br />
cost into the loan amount, etc. As every building<br />
condition is different, each case is approved on a case<br />
by case basis.<br />
Can foreigners get a loan? Yes but at a lower margin.<br />
In any case, I believe most foreigners come in with a<br />
bigger capital and big operation plans like running a<br />
designer hotel.<br />
12 What is your advice for foreign investors interested<br />
in buying a heritage shophouse in Malaysia? Are<br />
there any downsides or risks?<br />
Foreign investors must come in with a plan and must<br />
be familiar with the town planning rules as well as get<br />
all the required approvals and permits.<br />
The downside is that if the area is not popular, then<br />
it is harder to resell. So, it is better for the foreigners<br />
to group together or on their own buy and develop<br />
not just one unit but the entire row of heritage<br />
shophouses; or restore the entire street, if need be.<br />
Only then can it have an impact and attract tourists<br />
and locals alike with its eateries and fine dining<br />
restaurants, etc.
50 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
“HOW I<br />
BOUGHT MY<br />
FIRST FLAT<br />
IN TOKYO”<br />
Canadian property author cum entrepreneur<br />
Christopher Dillon narrates how he bought his first<br />
apartment in Tokyo.<br />
Christopher Dillon<br />
CONCRETE ACTION<br />
Back in May 2010, it was time to use what I had learned<br />
when researching on my book on how to navigate through<br />
the Complexities of Japanese Real Estate. I decided to buy<br />
an apartment in Tokyo. With Erik Oskamp, an agent I had<br />
met while researching my book, I spent the afternoon of<br />
September 30, 2010, looking at apartments in Nakano-ku,<br />
in Tokyo’s western suburbs, and in Itabashi-ku, Adachiku<br />
and Katsushika-ku in the north.<br />
The apartments were 16–42 sqms in size and 22–36 years<br />
old. Some buildings had hundreds of units, while others had<br />
fewer than 40, and the group included buildings made of<br />
steel-reinforced concrete as well as steel frame construction.<br />
All were priced at less than ¥6 million and served by a train<br />
or subway line, although one apartment was a 20-minute<br />
walk from the nearest station. In Japan, prospective buyers<br />
cannot view the inside of tenanted apartments. But we were<br />
able to walk around the neighbourhoods, some of which<br />
were quasi-industrial. Overflowing mailboxes indicated<br />
buildings with high vacancy rates, while rust stains and<br />
peeling paint suggested maintenance problems.<br />
I short-listed three apartments and, on October 1, made an<br />
offer for one in Itabashi-ku. The offer, which was 5% less<br />
than the asking price, was rejected, and I subsequently met<br />
the original ¥4.2 million asking price. When that offer was<br />
accepted, I started doing the paperwork, which included a<br />
notarized declaration that I was not a resident of Japan.<br />
I also signed two powers of attorney, one authorizing Erik’s<br />
company to purchase the apartment on my behalf and<br />
a second enabling a judicial scrivener, Kawanabe-san, to<br />
register the property in my name. Erik also began the due<br />
diligence process to ensure that there were no problems with<br />
the building, title or tenant.<br />
SIMPLE PROCEDURE<br />
Located in Tokyo’s Itabashi-ku, this apartment was built in<br />
1974 from steel-reinforced concrete. This was followed by<br />
two video chat sessions on Skype. One was with Kawanabesan,<br />
who needed to verify my identity and confirm that I was<br />
buying the property. The second was with Wakabayashi-san,<br />
a licensed real estate agent employed by Erik’s company, who<br />
read me the explanation of important matters.<br />
The recitation took 70 minutes and degenerated into<br />
comedy when the agent told me that the tenant, a retired<br />
civil servant, “had a problem with his waist.” I asked for<br />
clarification, wondering if he was confined to a wheelchair<br />
or if there was a trash-related problem. After consulting<br />
a dictionary and much discussion among the office staff,<br />
Wakabayashi-san told me that the tenant had a severe<br />
case of hemorrhoids, which was the reason he had retired.<br />
The sale closed on November 15, 2010, and the tenant has<br />
remained in the apartment.<br />
Built in 1974 from steel-reinforced concrete, the unit is 21<br />
sqms in size, plus a six-square-meter balcony. The apartment
May - June 2018<br />
51<br />
is adjacent to the Shuto Expressway and is a 10-minute<br />
walk to the Mita subway line, from where it is 30 minutes to<br />
central Tokyo.<br />
I paid cash for the apartment, which I still own. With all<br />
taxes and fees, the total purchase price was ¥4.6 million. In<br />
2016, the apartment generated revenue of ¥424,701, after<br />
deducting management fees, maintenance charges, repairs<br />
and taxes.<br />
As a non-resident Canadian living in Hong Kong, rental<br />
income from the apartment does not create a tax liability in<br />
Canada or in Hong Kong.<br />
SOME BASICS<br />
If you buy a property with a sitting tenant, you assume the<br />
vendor’s obligation to repay the tenant’s security deposit.<br />
The buyer deducts the tenant’s security deposit from the<br />
purchase price.<br />
Many real estate agents provide property management<br />
services. These range from basic plans to full-service<br />
packages that guarantee the landlord will receive the rent,<br />
even if the tenant doesn’t pay.<br />
The Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act (Act No. 228<br />
of 1949) requires non-residents to file a ‘‘Report Concerning<br />
Acquisition of Real Property in Japan or Rights Related<br />
Thereto,’’ with the Bank of Japan if they buy real estate for<br />
investment purposes. The report must be filed within 20 days<br />
PURCHASE<br />
Purchase price ¥4,200,000<br />
Agent’s fee 195,300<br />
Judicial scrivener’s fee 118,400<br />
Stamp tax 10,000<br />
Acquisition tax 63,500<br />
Total ¥4,587,200<br />
2016 REVENUE<br />
Rent ¥639,000<br />
Management fee (34,506)<br />
Maintenance fee (142,560)<br />
Repairs (4,172)<br />
Fixed assets tax (23,900)<br />
Income tax (9,125)<br />
Total ¥424,737<br />
of the purchase and is not required if the property is used<br />
as a residence for the buyer, his relatives or employees; to<br />
house a business or non-profit business; or if the property<br />
is purchased from another non-resident.<br />
Editor’s Note: This excerpt (with minor edits) can be found in<br />
the author’s second edition of Landed Japan.<br />
Overflowing<br />
mailboxes indicated<br />
buildings with<br />
high vacancy<br />
rates, while rust<br />
stains and peeling<br />
paint suggested<br />
maintenance<br />
problems.<br />
Located in Tokyo’s Itabashi-ku, this apartment was built in 1974 from steel-reinforced concrete.
52 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
LAW NOW ALLOWS<br />
EXTENDED<br />
PERIOD TO<br />
SUE FOR<br />
NEGLIGENCE<br />
The new Malaysian Act extends the limitation period for negligence suits<br />
to either 6 years from the date when the cause of action accrues,<br />
or within three years from the date on which the claimant knew about<br />
the material facts (if that period expires after the 6-year period).<br />
Most people are aware that in court<br />
cases, there is a time limit or time<br />
bar for the aggrieved party (termed<br />
“plaintiff ”) to sue the other party<br />
(“defendant”). In civil cases, the time limit can<br />
be different depending on the subject matter and<br />
who the defendant is. In the case of construction<br />
work, the law in Malaysia currently provides for<br />
the following:<br />
• For actions in simple contract: 6 years from<br />
the date of the breach of contract.<br />
• For actions in tort such as negligence: 6<br />
years from the date when the cause of action<br />
accrues (e.g. when physical damage occurs).<br />
• For latent or hidden damage: 6 years from the<br />
date on which the damage occurred.<br />
It should be noted that, in cases of fraudulent<br />
concealment (i.e. deliberate concealment of<br />
defects), the limitation period does not begin to<br />
run until the fraud is discovered or could have been<br />
discovered with reasonable diligence, according to a<br />
blog on Malaysian laws.<br />
However, the time bar has now been extended in<br />
favour of the claimant following the passing of the<br />
Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018 (the “Act”). It<br />
will become enforceable once it is gazetted within<br />
the next few months.<br />
The Act will extend the maximum period for<br />
eligibility to claim to 15 years. According to Datuk<br />
Prof. Sundra Rajoo, Director of AIAC, (Asian<br />
International Arbitration Centre, formerly known as<br />
the KLRCA), the Act will also extend the limitation<br />
period for negligence suits not involving personal<br />
injuries to either 6 years from the date when the<br />
cause of action accrues, or within three years from<br />
the date on which the claimant knew about the<br />
material facts (if that period expires after the initial<br />
6-year period).<br />
The new section applies to all applicable limitation<br />
periods and not just exclusively construction cases<br />
although the latter forms the bulk of cases where<br />
this new limitation period applies as it involves hard<br />
to discover latent building defects. This also explains<br />
why the maximum length of time the plaintiff can
May - June 2018<br />
53<br />
bring a suit is 15 years – as other items such as<br />
cars or electrical items normally do not have such<br />
a long working life.<br />
Most notably, it will cover latent damages in<br />
construction cases, allowing the buyer a right of<br />
action for damages for negligence from the date of<br />
discovery of the damage (as opposed to the date<br />
when the cause of action arises).<br />
“In other words, the right of action starts from<br />
the date when the buyer discovers the damage<br />
and not from the date of purchase or from the<br />
date of possession,” the AIAC Director says in<br />
his explanatory note to ‘A Bill to Amend the<br />
Limitation Act 1953’.<br />
LATENT DAMAGES TARGETED<br />
Clause 2 of Section 6A of the Bill is intended<br />
to cover latent damages in construction cases.<br />
Under the new section 6A, a buyer can claim<br />
damages within three years from the date when<br />
he/she discovered the damage, regardless of the<br />
fact that on the date of purchase, the damage was<br />
not discoverable through general inspection or<br />
the buyer did not know or could not have been<br />
reasonably expected to know the damages.<br />
“Thus, this Bill will make the parties involved in<br />
a project such as Builder, Architect, Engineer,<br />
Contractor, Subcontractor etc. (“the involved<br />
parties”) liable for damages accrued even after<br />
completion of the project.”<br />
Datuk Prof. Sundra adds that the Bill will have<br />
significant effect on the provision for certificate<br />
of completion and compliance (CCC) under the<br />
Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974.<br />
The CCC provision ensures that a project is<br />
complete and complies with all the requirements<br />
under the existing law. But, since the Bill proposes<br />
the starting time of limitation to be from the date<br />
of discovery of the damage, the involved parties<br />
may be liable even if they have complied with the<br />
provision for CCC.<br />
Datuk Prof. Sundra Rajoo<br />
Any of the involved parties in the<br />
construction process may be liable for<br />
damages at any time after completion<br />
even if the project is CCC-compliant,<br />
provided the action is within a period<br />
of three years from the discovery of<br />
the damages, subject to the overall<br />
maximum of 15 years.<br />
However, he notes that the Act prohibits institution<br />
of any proceeding after 15 years from the date on<br />
which the cause of action first accrued (Section<br />
6(3)). Thus, the buyer has a maximum period of 15<br />
years from the date of occurrence of cause of action<br />
to bring an action for damages.<br />
Given the longer timeframe, the legal expert<br />
anticipates an increase in claims by buyers, perhaps<br />
even an increase in frivolous claims with buyers<br />
taking advantage of the long period of time for any<br />
latent damages to appear.<br />
The big deal is that in future, any of the involved<br />
parties may be liable for the damages at any time<br />
after completion even if the project is CCCcompliant,<br />
provided the action is within a period<br />
of three years from the discovery of the damages,<br />
subject to the overall maximum of 15 years.
54 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
For construction companies and others responsible<br />
for the “building process”, casting doubt on a<br />
buyer’s allegations of becoming aware of the<br />
damage very late will be a key defence, Datuk<br />
Professor Sundra notes.<br />
UNDULY LONG?<br />
The table of comparison below shows that the new<br />
Malaysian Act is actually in line with the laws of<br />
England and Wales; and Singapore.<br />
For the avoidance of doubt, the sole reason why<br />
there are different terms in the table as regards<br />
the moment triggering the limitation period (e.g.<br />
“discovery of breach;” “knowledge of defect,” etc.)<br />
is that these are the expressions used in the specific<br />
laws of the countries in question.<br />
Cracked ceiling/wall which only appeared years after vacant possession was given.<br />
COMPARISON OF LIMITATION PERIODS<br />
JURISDICTION STANDARD LIMITATION PERIOD MAXIMUM ALLOWED PERIOD<br />
Austria<br />
Brazil<br />
California (USA)<br />
Florida (USA)<br />
Germany<br />
Queensland<br />
(Australia)<br />
Russia<br />
Singapore<br />
UAE<br />
UK (England<br />
and Wales)<br />
3 years from discovery of breach.<br />
180 days from knowledge of defect.<br />
10 years from substantial<br />
completion of the improvement.<br />
4 years from knowledge of defect.<br />
3 years from discovery of breach.<br />
6 years from the date on which the<br />
cause of action arose.<br />
3 years from discovery of breach.<br />
6 years from the date the damage<br />
occurred or 3 years from the date<br />
on which the claimant had the<br />
requisite knowledge and the right<br />
to bring such an action.<br />
10 years from the date of delivery.<br />
6 years from the date the damage<br />
occurred or 3 years from the date<br />
on which the claimant had the<br />
requisite knowledge and the right<br />
to bring such an action.<br />
30 years from the date of<br />
cause of action.<br />
5 years from handover.<br />
N/A<br />
10 years from actual<br />
possession by the owner.<br />
N/A<br />
30 years from the date of<br />
cause of action.<br />
10 years from the day the<br />
breach happened.<br />
15 years from the<br />
negligent act or omission.<br />
N/A<br />
15 years from the<br />
negligent act or omission.<br />
Source: AIAC
May - June 2018<br />
55<br />
ILLUSTRATIONS<br />
a. C bought a house from<br />
D in 2000. In 2010, C<br />
discovered a crack which<br />
damaged the walls<br />
badly. A building report<br />
made by a consultant<br />
revealed that the cracks<br />
had appeared in 2002,<br />
two years after C moved<br />
into the house. C has<br />
three years from 2010<br />
to file an action in court<br />
against D for damages.<br />
b. C bought a house from<br />
D in 2000. In 2006, C<br />
discovered a crack which<br />
damaged the walls badly.<br />
A building report made<br />
by a consultant revealed<br />
that the cracks had<br />
appeared in 2002, two<br />
years after C moved into<br />
the house. C has three<br />
years from 2006 to file an<br />
action in court against D<br />
for damages.<br />
c. C bought a house from<br />
D in 2000. In 2005, C<br />
discovered a crack which<br />
damaged the walls badly.<br />
A building report made<br />
by a consultant revealed<br />
that the cracks had<br />
appeared in 2002, two<br />
years after C moved into<br />
the house. C has three<br />
years from 2005 to file an<br />
action in court against D<br />
for damages.<br />
Source: Bill to Amend the Limitation Act 1953<br />
15-YEAR TIME BAR<br />
Notwithstanding the extra 3 years, no<br />
action shall be brought after the expiration<br />
of 15 years from the date on which the<br />
cause of action accrued.<br />
C bought a house from D in<br />
2000. In 2017, C discovered<br />
a crack which damaged<br />
the walls badly. A building<br />
report made by a consultant<br />
revealed that the cracks<br />
had appeared in 2001, one<br />
year after C moved into the<br />
house. C cannot commence<br />
an action because he has<br />
already exceeded the 15-year<br />
limitation period.<br />
Source: Bill to Amend the Limitation Act 1953
56 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
FANCY RETIRING<br />
IN THE PHILIPPINES?<br />
The Philippines is one of the easiest countries in the world to obtain residency<br />
on top of its foreigner-friendly property laws.<br />
For those who are thinking of retiring in<br />
Southeast Asia, apart from Malaysia which<br />
has a very friendly retirement programme,<br />
the next country you should consider is<br />
the Philippines. Apart from its beautiful islands<br />
and beaches – it has about 7,600 islands – the<br />
Philippines has the advantage of friendly people,<br />
good weather and an affordable lifestyle.<br />
However, the affordability may not last long as<br />
the country has been experiencing a property<br />
boom since the last 3 years and according to Nick<br />
Stuart, Founder and Managing Director of https://<br />
exclusivehotproperties.com, the boom is causing “prices<br />
to go up very fast”.<br />
Headquartered in Manila, Stuart’s firm specialises<br />
in investment properties, lifestyle properties and<br />
citizenship or residency services.<br />
Of note is the Philippines’ Special Resident<br />
Retirement Visa (SRRV) which allows foreigners<br />
to gain permanent residence easily without<br />
marriage to a citizen of the Philippines.<br />
The SRRV is overseen by the Philippine<br />
Retirement Authority (PRA), which comes up<br />
with the guidelines.
May - June 2018<br />
57<br />
MINIMUM CASH INVESTMENT<br />
The minimum investment to obtain an SRRV<br />
depends on your age and circumstances. The<br />
PRA lists three cases, each case having a different<br />
minimum investment.<br />
Case 1: Applicant is under 50 years old<br />
Minimum investment: $50,000<br />
Case 2: Applicant is at least 50 years old, but has no<br />
qualifying pension.<br />
Minimum investment: $20,000<br />
Case 3: Applicant is at least 50 years of age and has<br />
a pension of at least $800 per month (single) or<br />
$1000 per month couple.<br />
Minimum investment: $10,000<br />
QUALIFYING INVESTMENTS<br />
• Purchase of condominium unit (60:40 ratio);<br />
• Long term Lease of a house and lot,<br />
condominium or townhouse;<br />
• Construction of a residential unit on a leased<br />
parcel of land;<br />
• Purchase of Proprietary Membership/Golf<br />
shares in golf clubs;<br />
• Deposit into a PRA-approved bank<br />
facilities such as a workout room, a restaurant and a<br />
bar. Basically it amounts to living in a country club.<br />
“If you want to live in a city without living in a<br />
country club type atmosphere, there may also be<br />
PRA-approved condo units. Again, talk to a PRA<br />
officer for details or ask us.”<br />
Suppose you want to avail of the SRRV without<br />
committing yourself to living in a PRA approved<br />
community. What if you want to play at the golf<br />
clubs and tennis courts of such a community without<br />
actually living there? Many of the communities<br />
allow you to buy a “use of facilities” share. What this<br />
means is that for a certain amount of money, you<br />
buy a share in the community which allows you to<br />
use all the facilities without having to live there. A<br />
typical share at a decent community with golf, tennis<br />
and swimming might cost in the neighbourhood of<br />
USD10,000, says Stuart.<br />
“There is one problem however. That USD10,000<br />
investment may not be enough money to qualify<br />
you for the SRRV. As described earlier, depending<br />
Stuart cautions however that one can’t just purchase<br />
any condominium, or construct on any leased land -<br />
it must be a PRA-approved investment.<br />
“You pick out a residential community/facility<br />
approved by the PRA and you buy a share or<br />
lease a condo, which allows you to live and play<br />
in this community. Different communities have<br />
different arrangements. But in all cases, the bottom<br />
line is this: You have to fork out some good<br />
money, usually at least USD50K – USD100K, or<br />
sometimes even more.”<br />
Nick Stuart<br />
What are these communities like? Typically they are<br />
very upscale gated and guarded communities on the<br />
outskirts of a major city. They usually contain a golf<br />
course, tennis courts, a swimming pool and other
58 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
on your circumstances, the minimum investment is<br />
10, 20 or 50 thousand US dollars. If you are in case<br />
3 as described above, your minimum investment<br />
requirement is only $10,000 and the “use of facility”<br />
share may be perfect for you. However, even if your<br />
minimum investment is (for example) USD20,000<br />
dollars, there is no reason you can’t invest $10,000<br />
in your golf share, and another $10,000 in some<br />
other PRA-approved investment.”<br />
BANK DEPOSIT<br />
The PRA gives you another option, for those that<br />
don’t want to live in a PRA community or buy a<br />
PRA-approved country club share. Simply open<br />
up a special PRA bank account in a PRA partner<br />
bank and deposit the appropriate amount of money.<br />
“The banks we recommend would be Citibank or<br />
HSBC,” says Stuart.<br />
He adds, “Suppose your minimum investment is<br />
USD20,000, because you are over 50 but have no<br />
qualifying pension fund, simply open up the PRAapproved<br />
bank account, deposit USD20,000 into<br />
this account and the SRRV is yours! Later, if you<br />
decide you want to buy into golf shares or live in<br />
a PRA-approved residential community, you can<br />
transfer your bank account investment into your<br />
new PRA-approved investment.”<br />
Suppose your minimum<br />
investment is USD20,000,<br />
because you are over 50 but<br />
have no qualifying pension<br />
fund, simply open up the PRAapproved<br />
bank account, deposit<br />
USD20,000 into this account<br />
and the SRRV is yours!<br />
PROS AND CONS OF SRRV<br />
What is the downside of a SRRV visa? “Actually, if<br />
you leave money out of the discussion, there is no<br />
downside. The SRRV visa is a wonderful thing. It is<br />
extremely easy and quick to obtain and there is no<br />
reason to feel pressured into a marriage!”<br />
“The problem with the SRRV is that you have to put<br />
money aside and that money is basically untouchable<br />
so long as you want to keep your SRRV.<br />
“If you buy into a golf share, or you live in a condo<br />
in a residential PRA- approved community, you<br />
can argue that your money is being used towards<br />
a good purpose. However, if you use the bank<br />
account method then that money is just sitting there,<br />
basically in escrow and you can’t touch that money<br />
so long as you want to keep your SRRV.<br />
“What happens if you really need that money? Can<br />
you get it? Yes, but perhaps not immediately. You<br />
have to go to a PRA office and file an application for<br />
release of the funds.<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
“Once the release is approved, you lose your SRRV.<br />
So basically, in the case of a bank account, if you<br />
want to live in the Philippines for the rest of your<br />
life, it’s the equivalent of buying an SRRV for<br />
USD10K or USD20K. I guess the bank account<br />
does make some interest, but I don’t think this<br />
amounts to very much.
May - June 2018<br />
59<br />
Traffic on a road in Makati city in Metro Manila, Philippines. Makati -<br />
business center and one of the 17 cities that make up Metro Manila.<br />
“In the case of a golf share or residence in a condo,<br />
if you want your money back, you have to do<br />
two things. Firstly, you have to find a buyer for<br />
your share, and secondly, you also have to file an<br />
application for release of your investment once a<br />
buyer is found. Of course, as in the case of the bank<br />
account, you will lose your SRRV.”<br />
LAST RESORT – MARRIAGE!<br />
There is one other way to get your money back<br />
without losing permanent residence. Suppose you<br />
come to the Philippines as a single man and invest,<br />
for example, USD20,000 in a PRA bank account.<br />
BUYING PROPERTY IN<br />
THE PHILIPPINES<br />
Stuart recommends Metro Manila especially Makati City and<br />
its neighbour Bonifacio Global City which together produce<br />
49% of the GDP for the whole of the Philippines.<br />
All contracts and legal documents are written in English<br />
while the tenure is freehold.<br />
The property sector in Manila is well regulated allowing the<br />
buyer to have peace of mind that their investment is secure.<br />
In the Philippines, there is no need for a lawyer unlike<br />
most other jurisdictions. Property transactions require only<br />
licenced brokers who may or may not be lawyers, but who<br />
function like lawyers.<br />
Suppose, later you fall in love and decide to marry<br />
a Filipina. Having an SRRV visa does not prevent<br />
you from also applying for a spousal permanent<br />
residence visa. Once you get the Spousal permanent
60 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />
“Once at the office, you will start the application<br />
procedure. Of course make sure you have all<br />
needed documentation such as passports, bank<br />
account information, proof of pension, police<br />
clearance, etc. Don’t err on the side of not bringing<br />
enough. Bring everything with you that could<br />
possibly be of use in the application procedure. As<br />
part the application procedure, you will also have<br />
to take a medical examination.<br />
“If your choice is simply to get an SRRV via bank<br />
deposit, they can help you to do that immediately,<br />
and the SRRV can be in your hands in a relatively<br />
short period of time. If your choice is to find a golf<br />
share or residence, they can probably help you with<br />
that as well.<br />
BENEFITS OF SRRV<br />
Once you are an SRRV holder, it opens the door to<br />
vast opportunities and benefits.<br />
These include (but are not limited to the following):<br />
1. Option to Retire Permanently<br />
• You may live, work and study in the<br />
Philippines<br />
residence visa, you could withdraw your money<br />
from the PRA bank account. You would lose your<br />
SRRV visa, but it would not matter because you<br />
would still be entitled to permanent residence via<br />
your Spousal visa.<br />
PROCEDURE FOR OBTAINING<br />
THE SRRV<br />
“You can do-it-yourself or you can seek advice from<br />
consultants like us. Of course, the latter is preferable<br />
to ensure things go smoothly.”<br />
“Having said that, the PRA officers are extremely<br />
well trained and helpful, and will hold your hand<br />
throughout the whole process. I have even heard<br />
they will pick you up from the airport or your hotel<br />
and bring you to the office.<br />
2. Multiple Entry Privileges<br />
• You may travel outside the Philippines<br />
and re-enter at anytime<br />
3. Exemptions from:<br />
• Income tax over your pension and<br />
annuities;<br />
• Exit and re-entry permits of the Bureau<br />
of Immigration;<br />
• Annual registration requirement of the<br />
Bureau of Immigration;<br />
• Customs Duties and Taxes with regard<br />
to the importation of household goods<br />
and personal effects up to US$7,000.00;<br />
• Travel tax, if your stay in the Philippines<br />
is less than one year from the last entry<br />
date; and<br />
• I-Card
WORLD VIEW<br />
Our EXPERTS give their opinions on selected global hotspots
MALAYSIA<br />
JAPAN
64 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
SWEDISH<br />
VISION IN ASIA<br />
At the end of March, IKEA announced the development of Toppen Shopping Centre,<br />
comprising 1.1 mil sq ft shopping centre seamlessly integrated with IKEA Tebrau in Johor.<br />
Asian Property Review had a chat with Christian Rojkjaer, Managing Director of IKEA<br />
Southeast Asia on its expansion plans and its sustainability and technology aspirations.<br />
1<br />
Where else in Southeast Asia is IKEA SEA<br />
expanding next after Penang and the Philippines?<br />
We are investigating the market potential in Vietnam<br />
and have applied to our franchisor for the rights, so our<br />
ambition is strong but we have no firm plans at this time.<br />
MyTown Shopping Mall at Jalan Cochrane, Kuala Lumpur<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
2<br />
We are working on extending<br />
e-commerce to all of Malaysia and<br />
intend to launch a web shop later<br />
this year.<br />
IKEA takes seriously ‘people and planet’ issues -<br />
please share what are some of these issues?<br />
• We make sustainability a natural part of our<br />
everyday business – taking responsibility for the<br />
impact we have on the environment and all the<br />
people touched by our business (including coworkers<br />
and suppliers.)<br />
• We introduce the IKEA code of ethics, called<br />
IWAY, to all suppliers and work with them to<br />
ensure respect for human rights and fair working<br />
conditions for the many people who work for us<br />
through contracted companies.<br />
• Our sustainability principles are also embedded in<br />
the way we design our buildings, the materials we<br />
choose for construction and the features we include<br />
to help us conserve water, generate renewable<br />
energy, manage waste and more.
May - June 2018<br />
65<br />
Toppen aerial view (artist impression)<br />
• Some examples:<br />
• At our IKEA stores, we recycle an average of<br />
70% of all the waste we produce and we help<br />
customers recycle, too.<br />
• We have installed rain water harvesting<br />
systems at all our shopping centres and most<br />
IKEA stores.<br />
• We track energy consumption and outfitted<br />
all our IKEA stores and our shopping centres<br />
with LED lights, which consume 80% less<br />
energy than traditional incandescent bulbs.<br />
• We now have more than 16,000 solar panels<br />
on rooftops of our IKEA stores and our<br />
shopping centres in the region, generating<br />
more than 5.5 million megawatt hours of<br />
renewable energy during 2017 alone.<br />
• At our Toppen Shopping Centre, Johor, we will<br />
be introducing kitchen macerators (decompose<br />
food with solvent) underneath the sinks at all<br />
our Food & Beverage outlets to minimise the<br />
amount of food waste going to landfill.<br />
• We also take social responsibility by developing<br />
long-term partnerships with non-profit groups in<br />
the communities where we operate and, during<br />
2017, donated a total of SGD1.6 million to good<br />
causes. All our co-workers are entitled to a day of<br />
paid leave to donate their time to a charitable cause.<br />
(L-R) Christian Rojkjaer, Managing Director of IKEA Southeast Asia<br />
and Christian Olofsson, Shopping Centre & Mixed Use Director, IKEA<br />
Southeast Asia at the Toppen Shopping Centre Media Event<br />
We invest in real estate including shop<br />
houses, apartments, hotels, a school<br />
and more to maximise the value of the<br />
land we develop and to create walkable<br />
communities where people can live,<br />
work, shop and play.
66 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
3<br />
4<br />
In terms of IKEA’s sustainability aspirations, would<br />
doing away with plastic products be one of its<br />
eventual goals?<br />
This has been something we have been working<br />
together with our partners, tenants, and even<br />
manufacturers of our IKEA products. This includes<br />
minimizing waste in our value chain and turning it into<br />
a resource by using it to make new products.<br />
What are the projects in the pipeline in Malaysia<br />
(after Penang)?<br />
Our vision is to create a better everyday life for the<br />
many people and, as retailers, we want to make it is as<br />
easy as possible for many Malaysians to access our great<br />
range of functional, affordable home furnishings. So, we<br />
are working on extending e-commerce to all of Malaysia<br />
and intend to launch a web shop later this year.<br />
Our sustainability principles are also<br />
embedded in the way we design our<br />
buildings, the materials we choose<br />
for construction and the features we<br />
include to help us conserve water,<br />
generate renewable energy, manage<br />
waste, etc.<br />
5<br />
6<br />
Please share examples of other ‘residential, office and<br />
other types of real estate’ that Ikea will go into?<br />
• In Penang, we partner with Aspen Group to realise<br />
the vision for Aspen Vision City – a development<br />
that will, in addition to our IKEA store and<br />
shopping centre, include shop houses, apartments,<br />
hotels, a school and more. We invest in such types<br />
of real estate to maximise the value of the land we<br />
develop and to create walkable communities where<br />
people can live, work, shop and play<br />
• Meanwhile, the team at Mega Bangna in Bangkok<br />
also opened its doors to other developers as they<br />
aim to realise the vision of Megacity – a modern<br />
community anchored by our retail destination.<br />
The development will add hotels, office towers,<br />
residential and other types of real estate to the area<br />
surrounding our mall.<br />
Would you say Aspen Vision City and Megacity<br />
residential housing component would be in the<br />
affordable range in line with Ikea’s vision of ‘creating<br />
a better everyday life for the many people’?<br />
IKEA Southeast Asia is first and foremost a retailer.<br />
It is our primary goal to create better everyday life for<br />
the many people through both IKEA’s wide-range of<br />
well-designed, functional home furnishing products;<br />
and anchored-by-IKEA shopping centres that work<br />
both as a retail destination and a meeting space for the<br />
Aspen Vision City_IKEA
May - June 2018<br />
67<br />
Aspen Vision City Master Plan<br />
7<br />
community. As for Aspen Vision City and Megacity,<br />
we are currently working with experienced partners and<br />
professional developers to bring it to life in the best and<br />
most integrated way possible. At the end of the day, we<br />
are building this for the community to live and work in.<br />
How would these mixed developments be able to<br />
differentiate from other similar mixed developments<br />
in those areas – what are your USPs?<br />
Our shopping centres and IKEA stores will become<br />
the centre piece of a modern community. It will be<br />
an integrated development where people can live and<br />
work within easy reach of places to shop, meet, play<br />
and socialize.<br />
At our IKEA stores, we recycle an<br />
average of 70% of all the waste we<br />
produce and we help customers<br />
recycle, too.
68 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
8<br />
9<br />
Would the hotels in both mixed developments<br />
be managed by an in-house team or established<br />
hotel operators?<br />
We will be engaging established hotel operators as well<br />
as residential developers.<br />
Why does every mall attached to IKEA have a<br />
different name e.g. IPC, Toppen, MyTown?<br />
We pride ourselves by positioning our malls as being<br />
“local with a Scandinavian touch”; we believe that all<br />
our shopping centres are uniquely appealing to the<br />
local community without foregoing our roots hence the<br />
differentiation. We have deliberately implemented a<br />
‘House of Brands’ brand architecture for our shopping<br />
centres, as we want our strong, robust brands to<br />
resonate with the local community and catchment area.<br />
This is in line with our brand story building centres -<br />
‘Made with Swedish charm and a local touch’.<br />
This ‘house of brands’ strategy allows each and every<br />
brand to be unique in its own right, with flexibility<br />
to adapt to the needs of the surrounding local<br />
community. While we might have different brands, we<br />
share common visions and values for each shopping<br />
10<br />
centre, chief of which is our vision of ‘creating a better<br />
everyday life for the many people.’<br />
The other key thread that unites our different shopping<br />
centres is the strong focus on the customer experience<br />
and journey at every touch point, enabling us to deliver,<br />
with IKEA, a fun and inspiring full day out for the<br />
whole community.<br />
What are the new tech that’s going to be integrated<br />
into the retail shopping experience e.g. AR (Ikea’s<br />
Place app), AI, free home design service, pop-up<br />
garden at home, human-first interfaces, smart veg<br />
growing, etc?<br />
When it comes to technology, we always look at how<br />
we can incorporate tech and create a fun and unique<br />
shopping experience. One of our most recent creations<br />
is for one of our shopping centres – IPC Shopping<br />
We have installed rain water<br />
harvesting systems at all our shopping<br />
centres and most IKEA stores.<br />
Toppen (artist impression)
May - June 2018<br />
69<br />
Toppen Aerial View<br />
11<br />
Centre. We created a shopping centre app that goes<br />
beyond the usual store guide. We worked with Spotify,<br />
one of the biggest music streaming apps, to create a<br />
food and mood matching tool within the IPC app that<br />
allows users to find their perfect restaurant based on<br />
their mood.<br />
Could you briefly describe some of the new<br />
tech adopted in IKEA’s retail destinations around<br />
the world?<br />
Urbanisation and digitalisation is pushing us to meet<br />
the needs of a new generation of shoppers. The IKEA<br />
PLACE app launched in the US, is an important<br />
milestone in IKEA digital transformation strategy.<br />
The app lets people confidently experience, experiment<br />
and share how good design transforms any space,<br />
such as a home, office, school or studio. We recently<br />
launched e-commerce in Singapore and within less<br />
than 4 months, it contributed 5% of total sales. We<br />
are bringing this to both Malaysia and Thailand next.<br />
As for the rest of the tech, we are slowly but surely<br />
adapting it in our everyday business. Embracing the<br />
digital world is one of the many things we look at to<br />
ensure we are constantly meeting the demands of the<br />
ever-changing world.<br />
Christian Rojkjaer, and Christian Olofsson showcasing the progress of<br />
Toppen Shopping Centre which is situated next to IKEA Tebrau<br />
We now have more than 16,000 solar<br />
panels on rooftops of our IKEA stores<br />
and our shopping centres in the region,<br />
generating more than 5.5 million<br />
megawatt hours of renewable energy<br />
during 2017 alone.
70 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
UNDERSTANDING<br />
JAPAN’S COUNTER-<br />
INTUITIVE REAL<br />
ESTATE MARKET<br />
The Japanese market is the ideal cash flow market due to its<br />
steady and high yield rental income.<br />
Priti Donnelly is the<br />
sales and marketing<br />
manager at Nippon<br />
Tradings International, a<br />
proxy and buyers’ agency<br />
representing foreign<br />
investors with purchasing,<br />
selling and managing<br />
real estate in Japan. She<br />
can be contacted at<br />
info@nippontradings.<br />
com or +1 519 546 9473<br />
/ +81 3 4520 9262 www.<br />
nippontradings.com<br />
You may think real estate investing<br />
is solely about property growth<br />
as you would find in Australia,<br />
U.K. US, Singapore and similar<br />
markets. The Japanese property market<br />
is not ripe with prospects for increased<br />
property value. So, why then is the market<br />
saturated with foreign investors?<br />
CREATING OPPORTUNITIES<br />
BEYOND CAPITAL GROWTH<br />
The Japanese property market suffered<br />
at least 25 years of declining/flat-lining<br />
prices. Although capital growth made a<br />
quiet entrance from 2012 to 2016, it was<br />
too soon for investors to comfortably<br />
speculate growth. Instead, investors found<br />
a new opportunity. Because of the decline,<br />
properties became quite affordable while<br />
rental rates remained stable. The result,<br />
steady and higher yields across Japan-- the<br />
ideal cash flow market from high yield<br />
rental income.<br />
To put it in perspective, for as little as<br />
USD30,000 at 7.5% yield net pre-tax,<br />
investors can earn monthly rental income<br />
of approximately USD170/month. As<br />
an added benefit, in a prime location you<br />
might also gain property value, but that<br />
is not the focus of property investing in<br />
Japan. This market is about common sense<br />
investing without the speculative nature.<br />
OVERCOMING THE<br />
LANGUAGE BARRIER<br />
This is not your typical internationally<br />
friendly business market. On one hand, you<br />
will experience the most reliable and honest<br />
professionals in Japan, while on the other,<br />
foreigner-shy professionals who likely<br />
cannot speak English.<br />
Furthermore, to invest in Japanese<br />
properties, you will need a local address,<br />
phone number and a local bank account,<br />
impossible without communication and<br />
Osaka skyline<br />
Photography by Jan Yong
May - June 2018<br />
71<br />
Photography by Jan Yong<br />
A typical house in Osaka<br />
cooperation. To get around this barrier,<br />
savvy foreign investors use a trusted<br />
local Japanese/English speaking proxy or<br />
representative to act on their behalf for<br />
both communication and access to the<br />
required information.<br />
UNDERSTANDING OLD<br />
STRUCTURES<br />
Some novice investors shy away from<br />
the Japanese property market believing<br />
with a huff and a puff, structures could be<br />
blown down. It is true that structures built<br />
before 1981, including smaller steel-frame<br />
buildings, and even wooden frame houses,<br />
were not built to last and require major<br />
renovations and repairs over time. However,<br />
a major change to the Building Standards<br />
Act for earthquake resistant construction<br />
methods for buildings (reinforced concrete<br />
blocks) occurred in 1981.<br />
This became the turning point that<br />
investors often looked to when purchasing<br />
property. That being said, there is still a<br />
niche market for older properties because<br />
of the higher yield. In truth, regardless of<br />
age, with due diligence, if the property has<br />
proof of regular maintenance, renovations,<br />
repairs to the interior and exterior, as well<br />
… if the property has proof of regular<br />
maintenance, renovations, repairs to the<br />
interior and exterior, as well as sufficient funds<br />
for ongoing repairs, and is tenanted, an older<br />
higher yielding property could prove to be a<br />
diamond in the rough.<br />
as sufficient funds for ongoing repairs,<br />
and is tenanted, an older higher yielding<br />
property could prove to be a diamond in<br />
the rough.<br />
ACCEPTING FOREIGN REAL<br />
ESTATE<br />
Today, the best real estate opportunities<br />
do not have to be in your own back yard.<br />
JPMorgan Chase says Japanese real estate<br />
and infrastructure are becoming more<br />
attractive particularly with no more than<br />
50% of leveraged funds. Above that, real<br />
estate doesn’t become the driver, but the<br />
leverage becomes the driver of your return.<br />
Japan provides opportunities for stable,<br />
monthly cash flow from rental income with<br />
yields from 5% to 11% net pre-tax. Add to<br />
that, currency exchange and the yen’s role<br />
as a safe-haven currency and it’s easy to see<br />
why this is a booming market for foreign<br />
investors, contrary to the standard real<br />
estate investment approach.
72 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
OF<br />
EARTHQUAKES,<br />
TRAINS AND AIRPORTS<br />
Asian Property Review chats with award-winning writer and<br />
entrepreneur Christopher Dillon on earthquakes and infrastructure in<br />
Japan – 2 key issues that investors are keen to know more about<br />
before investing.<br />
1<br />
Japan’s construction technology, which<br />
includes advanced earthquake-resistant<br />
designs, is among the most developed in the<br />
world. How effective are the buildings against<br />
earthquakes, say, above Richter Scale 6?<br />
Earthquakes in Japan are measured using the shindo<br />
scale, which rates them as 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 lower,<br />
5 upper, 6 lower, 6 upper and 7, where 0 is only<br />
perceptible by seismometers. In a 7, it is impossible<br />
to remain standing, buildings collapse, cracks appear<br />
in the earth’s surface and landslides occur.<br />
Japan’s building standards are designed to achieve<br />
two goals. In a moderate earthquake, up to about<br />
5 on the Japanese scale, the building should<br />
suffer little or no structural damage and still be<br />
safe for occupancy. In a stronger earthquake, the<br />
building should not collapse and there should be<br />
Seismic retrofitting is not<br />
mandatory in Japan.<br />
no casualties as a result of structural failure. This is<br />
important because 80% of the fatalities in the 1995<br />
Great Hanshin Earthquake (GHE) were due to<br />
collapsing buildings.<br />
The GHE demonstrated the importance of revisions<br />
to national building standards that took effect on<br />
June 1, 1981. Of 923 buildings surveyed in central<br />
Kobe after the GHE, 35% of those built before<br />
1971 collapsed or were seriously damaged, 40%<br />
had moderate or minor damage and 25% had slight<br />
or no damage. For buildings constructed between<br />
1972 and 1981, the statistics were 12%, 31% and<br />
57%, respectively. But only 8% built after 1982 were<br />
seriously damaged, with 17% incurring moderate<br />
damage and 75% sustaining slight or no damage.<br />
2<br />
Is it a good idea to buy non-earthquake<br />
resistant buildings? They may be cheap but<br />
in the long run, are they worth it – perhaps<br />
because over time, the capital value depreciates as<br />
the likelihood of their being demolished grows.<br />
Non-earthquake resistant buildings are not a<br />
bargain, because they are significantly more<br />
expensive to insure than earthquake-resistant ones.
May - June 2018<br />
73<br />
All of Japan is at risk of earthquakes.<br />
Premiums in high-risk areas are about<br />
three times those in low-risk zones.<br />
Rents are lower in areas identified on hazard maps<br />
as having a high earthquake risk. Homes in highrisk<br />
districts that were erected before the seismic<br />
standards were tightened in 1981 rent at a discount,<br />
compared with those built after 1981.<br />
Seismic retrofitting is not mandatory in Japan.<br />
In 2013, about 9 million of Japan’s 52 million<br />
dwellings did not meet modern earthquake<br />
resistance standards.<br />
3Since Japan is in the Pacific Ring of Fire and<br />
is prone to earthquakes and tsunamis, are<br />
there any cities that are completely free from<br />
such natural disasters?<br />
All of Japan is at risk of earthquakes. The Japan<br />
Earthquake Reinsurance Co. divides the country<br />
into three categories when calculating insurance<br />
premiums. The high risk group includes Chiba,<br />
Tokyo and Kanagawa. The low risk group includes<br />
Iwate, Fukuoka and Nagasaki.<br />
Premiums in high-risk<br />
areas are about three times<br />
those in low-risk zones.<br />
4How effective are<br />
the earthquake<br />
warning systems<br />
when it comes to<br />
preventing fatalities?<br />
By giving people time<br />
to take shelter and<br />
automatically stopping<br />
trains and production<br />
lines, Japan’s earthquake warning system has<br />
saved many lives and prevented millions of<br />
dollars in damage.<br />
Aftermath of an earthquake in Japan.
74 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />
The high-speed Linear Chuo<br />
Shinkansen, which uses<br />
superconducting magnetic levitation<br />
technology, is expected to begin<br />
service between Tokyo’s Shinagawa<br />
Station and Nagoya Station<br />
in 2027.<br />
While the system is imperfect, even a few seconds of<br />
advance warning can make an enormous difference.<br />
5What are some futuristic building<br />
technologies and intelligent building<br />
solutions that Japan has created?<br />
Japan’s base-isolation and vibration-damping<br />
technologies allow people to live comfortably in<br />
high-rise buildings despite the threat of earthquakes.<br />
Japan’s electronic toilets are also in a class of<br />
their own.<br />
6Please share what are the new road and rail<br />
network links that will be completed before<br />
the Olympics in 2020? How will this affect the<br />
housing market particularly those that are located<br />
near the lines?<br />
A new station on the Yamanote Line, which circles<br />
downtown Tokyo, is expected to open by 2020.<br />
The currently unnamed station will be between<br />
Shinagawa and Tamachi stations.<br />
A new subway station between Kamiyacho and<br />
Kasumigaseki on Tokyo’s Hibiya Line is scheduled<br />
to open by 2020. The station is tentatively known as<br />
Toranomon New Station.<br />
The Tokyo Outer Ring Road and the Metropolitan<br />
Inter-City Expressway are expected to be 90%<br />
complete by 2020, with new sections under<br />
construction in Tama, Chiba, Kanagawa and Saitama.<br />
Over the long term, these developments will be<br />
positive for nearby homeowners. Noise and traffic<br />
disruptions will pose short-term challenges, however.<br />
The N700A Series bullet train for Tokaido Shinkansen at Nagoya station.<br />
7Will there also be new airports coming up?<br />
The biggest aviation stories are improved rail<br />
links at Tokyo’s Haneda airport and a new, second<br />
runway at Fukuoka airport. The government<br />
is also planning on expanding the number of<br />
landing slots at both Haneda and Narita to cater<br />
to growing tourist numbers.<br />
8What are other new infrastructure projects<br />
coming up that might impact the housing<br />
market?<br />
The high-speed Linear Chuo Shinkansen,<br />
which uses superconducting magnetic levitation<br />
technology, is expected to begin service between<br />
Tokyo’s Shinagawa Station and Nagoya Station<br />
in 2027. The service will be extended to Osaka<br />
by 2045, and will allow you to live in Nagoya and<br />
commute to Tokyo.<br />
Ed’s Note: Christopher Dillon has authored 4 books:<br />
Landed Hong Kong (2008), Landed Japan (2010),<br />
Landed China (2013) and Landed Global—which<br />
includes case studies and data from more than 110<br />
countries and territories—in 2014.<br />
(www.landedbook.com)
Anyone Can Be A<br />
Property Millionaire<br />
Reality TV Show by Gavin Tee<br />
Broadcast<br />
on<br />
CH 301 / CH 306<br />
Every Monday 9.30pm<br />
Tuesday 4:00 am & 10:00 am (repeat)<br />
Sunday 3:00 pm (repeat)<br />
Let Gavin Tee Mentor You<br />
Through A Successful<br />
Property Investment Journey<br />
Producer:<br />
Production of:<br />
Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee<br />
Mentor of The Show<br />
*The organizer reserves the right to change event details without prior notice. Terms & conditions apply.<br />
Log in to 1balcony.com to<br />
WIN PRIZES!<br />
Supported by:<br />
Sponsor Partner:
76 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />
A ‘HOME-MADE<br />
OASIS’ IN KL<br />
Tiny Garden transports you to a magical world amid rows of<br />
drab terrace houses in a Kuala Lumpur suburb.<br />
Text & Photography by Benjamin K. Yong<br />
Lots of relaxing spots. The main gate is just behind
May - June 2018<br />
77<br />
The outdoor dining area<br />
Reading corner<br />
From the outside, the house looks nondescript like<br />
any other terrace house in this residential area<br />
located about 2 kms from the National Zoo in<br />
Selangor, Malaysia. But once you enter through<br />
the side gate, you are immediately transported to a different<br />
world – a world where you can immerse yourself with quiet<br />
times by the koi pond or even play with the tiny dogs that<br />
occasionally come to stay.<br />
Coffee bar which also serves up breakfast<br />
This is Tiny Garden, a marvel in terrace house design –<br />
especially since the designers are not professional designers<br />
but a family who operates a homestay. As Carmen the<br />
daughter says, “Our family likes to Do-It-Yourself. Every<br />
single decoration is done by our own hands.”
78 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />
Pond with koi fish
May - June 2018<br />
79<br />
Eclectic decor with stuff from all over the world<br />
Single room<br />
The main lounge which overlooks the dining area outside<br />
There is a relaxing reading corner, outdoor dining area,<br />
koi pond, and lush garden complemented by eclectic<br />
décor in every corner. You can’t help but get pleasantly<br />
distracted by all the decorations. At the same time, you<br />
feel the calm and serenity of the place. This place makes<br />
you feel at home and you can practically stay all day long<br />
in this pleasant environment.<br />
Outdoor is where the action is – food is served there and<br />
most social interactions take place there despite a very<br />
warm and cozy indoor area. The details show how much<br />
care and effort have been taken to make this house as cozy<br />
and welcoming as possible.<br />
Indeed, it is a beautiful oasis amid the hustle and bustle of<br />
Kuala Lumpur.
80 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />
BENOY<br />
TRAVELS<br />
THE WORLD<br />
From a small design firm in<br />
Nottinghamshire, UK, 71 years ago, Benoy’s<br />
footprint now spans the entire globe<br />
including an increasing number in Asia.<br />
Asian Property Review interviews<br />
Qin Pang, Director and Head of Benoy’s<br />
Shanghai Studio.<br />
Qin Pang<br />
1<br />
2<br />
Benoy started in Nottinghamshire, UK some<br />
71 years ago. It has now evolved into a global<br />
design specialist undertaking many inspiring<br />
and iconic projects. Please list out some<br />
recently completed iconic projects in Asia.<br />
Terminal 4, Changi Airport, Singapore (2017),<br />
Suzhou Center, China (2017), Parc Central,<br />
Guangzhou, China (2016) and Starfield Hanam,<br />
Hanam, Gyeonggi, South Korea (2016).<br />
What is Benoy’s design philosophy and how<br />
does that translate into your works?<br />
At Benoy, we balance creative vision with<br />
commercial viability; we work with clients to<br />
create iconic destinations that enrich people’s<br />
lives, strengthen communities, enhance nature,<br />
and deliver lasting economic value. This is<br />
3<br />
translated into our work in many ways, however<br />
our aim is also to deliver world-class solutions<br />
for the built environment.<br />
Does Benoy have onboard or have joint<br />
ventures with starchitects especially in projects<br />
involving branded residences or mixed<br />
developments e.g. Prada, etc?<br />
Benoy collaborates with a number of design<br />
firms, especially on larger projects which are<br />
overseen by a consortium. In Singapore, for<br />
example, we are working within the consortium<br />
led by Moshe Safdie (famed for his Habitat<br />
67, in Montreal, Quebec) to deliver the high<br />
profile Jewel Changi Airport project. Benoy is<br />
the Interior Design and Retail and Aviation<br />
Facilities Planner on the development.
May - June 2018<br />
81<br />
Suzhou Center - Credit Suzhou Hengtai Holding Group Co<br />
4<br />
Benoy has a strong reputation in<br />
regeneration projects with the firm’s<br />
portfolio including HARBOUR CITY’s<br />
Gala Avenue Westside in Shanghai, the<br />
David Jones Flagship Building in Sydney<br />
and TSUM Department Store in Kiev.<br />
With the upcoming Nanjing cold storage<br />
warehouse project, how will Benoy’s previous<br />
experience help with this project?<br />
Knowledge sharing is always vital for any<br />
project. We are fortunate to be able to draw on<br />
the experience and expertise of many of our<br />
colleagues as we approach the Nanjing MCC<br />
World project. However, all projects are unique,<br />
it’s not about copying and pasting design<br />
solutions from other projects, but using that<br />
information to inform how we approach new<br />
design challenges.<br />
We work with clients to create iconic<br />
destinations that enrich people’s lives,<br />
strengthen communities, enhance<br />
nature, and deliver lasting economic<br />
value.
82 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />
Parc Central, Guangzhou - Credit Benoy
May - June 2018<br />
83<br />
5<br />
6<br />
What are the design challenges when it comes<br />
to regeneration projects?<br />
Balancing the heritage aspects of the<br />
development with the new build components<br />
is always a challenge. We want to ensure we are<br />
respectful and sensitive to the history of the site<br />
whilst also celebrating a new, exciting prospect for<br />
the future.<br />
How much green or sustainable practices are<br />
incorporated into Benoy’s works?<br />
A key feature of the Benoy offer is sustainability.<br />
We work closely with our clients and providers<br />
of expert knowledge to deliver more sustainable<br />
design solutions, relevant to the unique context<br />
of each project. Responsible design practice<br />
and sustainability is promoted by building on<br />
experience, encouraging education, the recruitment<br />
of new and complementary skills and, where<br />
necessary, collaboration with external experts.<br />
We are proud to have a portfolio which includes<br />
numerous sustainable design credentials including<br />
the first LEED Platinum Retail Development in<br />
Greater China, Hysan Place.<br />
Terminal 4, Changi Airport - Credit Benoy
84 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INNOVATION<br />
A CHINESE<br />
‘BUTLER’<br />
FOR CHINESE BUYERS<br />
Singou’s ‘Butler 1’ robot is the first<br />
of many Mandarin-speaking robots<br />
that will be deployed worldwide by<br />
Juwai.com to cater to international<br />
property buyers from China.<br />
No Mandarin speakers in your company,<br />
yet you want to serve the increasing<br />
number of Chinese property buyers? No<br />
worries, a robot is coming near you which<br />
can answer all the queries the Chinese buyer usually<br />
asks about international properties - all in Mandarin.<br />
The Butler 1 robot is developed by an awardwinning<br />
Macau startup, Singou Technology Ltd.<br />
Singou, under the auspices of Macau University of<br />
Science and Technology is an Artificial Intelligence<br />
(AI) and service robot pioneer which has won<br />
an award in November 2017 at the Shanghai<br />
International Service Robot Show.<br />
The benefits are immense – marketers worldwide<br />
can make do without Mandarin-speaking staff and<br />
can scale up their operations quickly. Priced at a<br />
mere USD2,000 each, the 1.4 meters (4’ 7”) tall<br />
robot is very approachable and can even move and
May - June 2018<br />
85<br />
Carrie Law and Dr Hon at the signing ceremony in Macau recently.<br />
approach people just like another human being, says<br />
Dr Hon Chi Tin, Chief Executive Officer of Singou<br />
Technology. “A robot is superior to a fixed device,<br />
smart speaker, or smart furniture,” says Dr Hon<br />
who is also a Guest Associate Professor of Macau<br />
University of Science.<br />
Recently, pursuant to an agreement, Singou has<br />
made available its robots to Juwai.com on a trial<br />
basis where they will be trained in dealing with<br />
Chinese customers using Juwai’s 5-year experience<br />
in dealing with Chinese buyers of overseas property.<br />
Juwai.com is a leading Chinese international real<br />
estate website.<br />
Says Dr Hon: “Juwai.com has a large data set that<br />
can be abstracted into artificial intelligence with the<br />
strong experience of Singou technology and then<br />
put to use in serving customers in smarter ways.”<br />
At the moment, the robots are<br />
only monolingual, speaking only<br />
Mandarin, and are only assigned<br />
the task of giving information to<br />
consumers.<br />
TRAINING THE ROBOT<br />
Juwai will also begin distributing the Butler 1 to the<br />
property industry and to homeowners. However, at<br />
this stage, the company is not yet taking orders for<br />
the robots as they are still under training. “We are<br />
still training the AI behind the robots and at this<br />
point are not yet taking orders,” says Carrie Law,<br />
CEO of Juwai.com.
86 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INNOVATION<br />
During the training period, early robots will be<br />
deployed at international property industry events<br />
in China and in showrooms and offices in five other<br />
countries: Malaysia, Singapore, the USA, Australia,<br />
and Canada or the UK.<br />
She adds that in the initial stage while training the<br />
robots over the next few months, they expect to<br />
deploy one robot per country. “You might say this<br />
first handful of robots is the beachhead or initial<br />
foothold for a much larger invasion.”<br />
At the moment, the robots are only monolingual,<br />
speaking only Mandarin, and are only assigned<br />
the task of giving information to consumers.<br />
According to Law, this is because ‘consumers don’t<br />
want to complete sales with robots. They want the<br />
reassurance and value of working with an agent.”<br />
On how it would impact the website, Law explains:<br />
“On the front end, that part of the website which is<br />
visible to users, probably there will be no change. But<br />
on the backend, the robot’s AI engine will need to<br />
interact with the same systems behind the website.<br />
That way, it can properly provide market and listing<br />
info to the Chinese consumer while at the same time<br />
giving the consumer’s details and needs to the agent<br />
or developer.”<br />
The two companies will spend the next several<br />
months training the Singou AI engine using the<br />
data and insights that Juwai.com has gathered<br />
during its five years of serving Chinese international<br />
property buyers.<br />
The same artificial intelligence is also part of the<br />
brain that will operate the Butler 1 when it is<br />
deployed in the offices of international property<br />
marketers. During the training period, early robots<br />
will be deployed at international property industry<br />
events in China and in showrooms and offices in<br />
five other countries: Malaysia, Singapore, the USA,<br />
Australia, and Canada or the UK. This experience<br />
will provide further data and input to train the<br />
artificial intelligence engine.<br />
MARCH OF THE AI<br />
Singou Technology has deployed earlier models<br />
of robots to provide security and access control at<br />
the premises of large facilities, such as convention<br />
centers, universities, and transit centers.<br />
China installed 90,000 industrial robots between<br />
2010 and 2015, according to Machine Design<br />
magazine. That is one-third of the world’s total and<br />
more than the U.S, Europe, and the rest of Asia<br />
combined, which together installed 80,000. The<br />
International Federation of Robotics estimates that<br />
China will install 160,000 robots next year. Most<br />
will be deployed in factories, but service robots like<br />
Butler 1 are being built in ever greater quantities.<br />
Says Law of the partnership with Singou: “Singou’s<br />
AI chatbot engine will enable Juwai.com to improve<br />
and scale the service we provide to consumers. We<br />
will use the AI and chatbot to crunch data, handle<br />
basic requests, and speed processing.<br />
“The robot is essentially a carrier that lets our AI<br />
consumer service engine be present in real estate<br />
sales offices anywhere in the world. The robot has the<br />
same AI brain and intelligence as our chatbot.”<br />
Law adds: “It’s natural that we turned to a company<br />
from Greater China for this partnership. China plans<br />
to be the global leader in AI and robotics by 2030<br />
and is investing heavily in the field. China’s core<br />
AI industries should be worth, the State Council<br />
believes, US$50 billion by 2025. China already<br />
deploys more robots per year than Europe, the US,<br />
and the rest of Asia combined.”
I WISH TO SUBSCRIBE FOR ONE YEAR (6 issues)( please ✓ ):<br />
Malaysia Singapore Other Countries<br />
PRINT ❏ RM85 ❏ SGD50 ❏ USD40<br />
(Exclude Postage)<br />
(Exclude Postage)<br />
DIGITAL ❏ RM40 ❏ SGD20 ❏ USD20<br />
From _________________________ to _______________________________<br />
Terms & Conditions apply. *Prices are inclusive of postage (Malaysia). ** Rates will apply in accordance with postage destination (other countries).<br />
*** We reserve th right to amend the T & Cs without prior notice.<br />
By filling up the info herein, you hereby consent to our processing of your personal data as per the Personal Data Notice at www.asianpropertyreview.com