16.05.2018 Views

APR24_HighRes

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

PP18617/05/2016(034488)<br />

MCI (P) 046/07/2017<br />

PP18617/10/2014(034059)<br />

MICA (P) 125/07/2015


EDITOR’S NOTE<br />

TROPHY ASSETS<br />

IS THE NEW GAME<br />

In recent years, very niche products in the market are attracting the<br />

interest of a select group of investors – High Net Worth Individuals<br />

(HNWIs) from Asia. It hasn’t gone unnoticed – more branded residences<br />

are being built all over Asia. And as in all things branded, price is not the<br />

main consideration. Thus, selling these prized assets even when the market<br />

is screaming ‘oversupply’ and ‘overhang’ is not an issue as demonstrated<br />

by some of the projects we present here as examples. We have interviewed<br />

developers, architects and consultants on this growing trend.<br />

Across from Abu Simbel temple, Egypt<br />

The other niche product attracting a fair amount of attention is heritage<br />

shophouses - this is particularly so in Singapore where there is an acute<br />

shortage of supply; as a result, shophouses in Singapore have attained the<br />

status of a trophy acquisition. We delve deeper into the situation and include<br />

Melaka, Penang and Kuala Lumpur too due to the many shophouses there<br />

sharing the same characteristics as those in Singapore.<br />

For those interested in Japan, we have two consultants, one of whom has<br />

authored 4 books on investing in property in Japan, China, Hong Kong and<br />

globally, all of which come with many case studies. They will give a better idea<br />

of the investing environment in the next Olympic destination.<br />

From the Land of the Rising Sun, we go west to the Land of the Midnight<br />

Sun – Sweden. When it comes to property, Sweden is famed for its IKEA<br />

furniture and furnishings. But the iconic brand is much more than that – it<br />

embraces sustainability and community, and increasingly technology as its<br />

core guiding principles when growing roots across its global destinations. We<br />

dig dipper into some little-known facts about this popular brand.<br />

The closure of Boracay Island for 6 months as of 26th April might get some<br />

investors jittery about investing in the Philippines. Whatever the speculated<br />

reasons for the closure are, one thing is clear – it doesn’t spell the end of<br />

tourism for the Philippines or Boracay. With over 7,000 islands, there is no<br />

shortage of beaches meaning visitors thinking about retiring there should<br />

carry on with their plans as the Philippines has one of the most relaxed<br />

residency programmes in the world. Check out our story in this issue.<br />

JAN YONG<br />

Editor-in-Chief<br />

editor@asianpropertyreview.com


May - June 2018<br />

5 NEWS SNIPPETS<br />

6 Drastic changes for Thai tenancy laws<br />

14<br />

COVER STORY<br />

8 Branded residences on the ascent in Asia –<br />

Not a new thing, but they are coveted by HNWIs all<br />

over Asia now.<br />

14 Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad and<br />

Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd<br />

talks about 8 Conlay and Kempinski, their<br />

maiden project.<br />

20 Chris Graham (Founder and MD of Graham<br />

Associates), who is regarded as one of the world’s<br />

foremost specialists on branded residences reveals<br />

an insider’s view.<br />

26 Bill Barnett, Managing Director at C9 Hotelworks<br />

talks about the branded residences scenario<br />

in Asia.<br />

28 SB Architects gives their view on how they go<br />

about designing branded residences.<br />

28<br />

HERITAGE SHOPHOUSES<br />

34 Heritage shophouses are trophy assets in<br />

Singapore as interest grows among HNWIs, family<br />

offices and funds in owning them.<br />

40 Simon Monteiro, who specialises in heritage<br />

buildings, gives an account of his experience<br />

from the time interest in heritage shophouses in<br />

Singapore started gaining ground.<br />

44 In Malaysia, the interest is not as obsessive but<br />

is still considered high in UNESCO-designated<br />

areas like Melaka and George Town. KL See,<br />

director of Metro Homes gives his view on the<br />

investability of shophouses in Malaysia.<br />

34


64<br />

INVESTMENT<br />

50 Christopher Dillon narrates how he bought his<br />

first apartment in Tokyo.<br />

52 The new Malaysian Act extends the limitation<br />

period for negligence suits to either 6 years<br />

from the date when the cause of action accrues, or<br />

within three years from the date on which the<br />

claimant knew about the material facts (if that<br />

period expires after the 6-year period).<br />

56 Buy a property and retire in the Philippines?<br />

Why not, says Nick Stuart, Founder & MD of<br />

exclusivehotproperties.com<br />

84<br />

24<br />

76<br />

WORLDVIEW<br />

64 IKEA’s expansion plans in Asia<br />

70 Understanding Japan’s counter-intuitive real<br />

estate market<br />

72 Writer and entrepreneur Christopher Dillon<br />

explains about the impact of earthquakes and<br />

infrastructure on the Japanese property market.<br />

DESIGN<br />

76 A ‘home-made oasis’ in KL – Tiny Garden<br />

transports you to a magical world amid the rows<br />

of drab terrace houses in a Kuala Lumpur suburb.<br />

80 From a small design firm in Nottinghamshire, UK,<br />

71 years ago, Benoy’s footprint now spans the<br />

entire globe including an increasing number in Asia.<br />

Asian Property Review interviews Qin Pang,<br />

Director and Head of Benoy’s Shanghai Studio.<br />

INNOVATION<br />

84 Singou’s ‘Butler 1’ robot is the first of many<br />

Mandarin-speaking robots that will be deployed<br />

worldwide to cater to international property<br />

buyers from China.


www.asianpropertyreview.com<br />

May - June 2018<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

Editor-in-Chief<br />

Contributors<br />

JAN YONG<br />

CHRISTOPHER DILLON<br />

PRITI DONNELLY<br />

DISTRIBUTION TO OVER<br />

500 DIRECT POINTS<br />

Bookstores<br />

Designers<br />

IVY LO<br />

THAM SOOK TENG<br />

CORPORATE<br />

Publisher<br />

DATO’ SRI GAVIN TEE<br />

Accounts executive SHARON LAI<br />

Sales & Marketing ERIC LEE, Senior Manager +6012 376 0020<br />

KHALIL ADIS (Singapore Rep) +65 8201 9254<br />

Department Stores<br />

SUBSCRIBE @<br />

www.asianpropertyreview.com<br />

or email us at info@asianpropertyreview.com<br />

For enquiries or to give feedback, please contact us @<br />

Tel: +603 2288 8588<br />

e-mail: editor@asianpropertyreview.com<br />

Café<br />

PUBLISHED BI-MONTHLY BY:<br />

Genetic Media Sdn Bhd (1056451 M)<br />

29-7, The Boulevard,<br />

Lingkaran Syed Putra,<br />

Mid Valley City,<br />

59200 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia<br />

PRINTED BY:<br />

Unipress Printer Sdn Bhd (731378-P)<br />

117-G, Jln Tiaj 1/4<br />

Tmn Industri Alam Jaya<br />

42300 Selangor<br />

Tel: +603 6038 5578<br />

Any content of Asian Property Review may only be reproduced, in any shape or format, with the<br />

expressed permission of Genetic Media Sdn Bhd. For reprints, please consult the Chief Editor.<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

The materials in this publication and its related online sites including<br />

Facebook have no regard to the specific investment objectives,<br />

financial situation, or particular needs of any visitor. The materials<br />

are published solely for informational and educational purposes and<br />

are not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any<br />

properties or related financial instruments. You are advised to consult<br />

with a licensed, qualified professional before making any investment<br />

decisions.<br />

The content of contributed articles does not necessarily represent<br />

the views of this publication/its staff or advertisers. We make no<br />

representation, warranty, or guarantee as to the completeness and/<br />

or accuracy of the information here. Any opinions expressed here are<br />

subject to change without notice and we and our contributors are<br />

not under any obligation to update or keep current the information<br />

contained herein.<br />

References made to third parties are based on information obtained<br />

from sources believed to be reliable, but are not guaranteed as being<br />

accurate, complete or updated. We accept no liability whatsoever for<br />

any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part<br />

of the materials herein or on our affiliate sites.<br />

Currencies quoted are for information purposes.


May - June 2018<br />

5<br />

YONG TAI, KOF HLDGS TO JOINTLY DEVELOP<br />

U-THANT CONDO<br />

Tourism and cultural property developer<br />

Yong Tai Berhad will jointly develop<br />

a high-end low-density condominium<br />

Impression U-Thant together with KOF<br />

Holdings Sdn Bhd and RISDA Berhad.<br />

Impression U-Thant, which later will be officially<br />

known as “Residensi Mutiara U-Thant”, will be<br />

Yong Tai’s maiden high-end development bearing its<br />

signature Impression trademark amid the lush greenery.<br />

With an estimated gross development value (GDV)<br />

of about RM200 mil, the 1.2-acre freehold project<br />

comprises a 10-storey condominium.<br />

There are six different types of layout occupying builtups<br />

of between 782 sq ft and 1,632 sq ft. Prices for<br />

the 108 units start from RM1.3 mil.<br />

Yong Tai’s Chief Executive Officer Datuk Wira<br />

Boo Kuang Loon said there is a growing trend of<br />

higher-end buyers who appreciate living within a<br />

low-density green enclave while at the same time<br />

seeking the exclusivity.<br />

Impression U-Thant features innovative architectural<br />

designs, dual-key features and amenities and is<br />

expected to be completed by 2021.<br />

The development is strategically located along Jalan<br />

U-Thant overlooking the Royal Selangor Golf Club<br />

and is near the Embassy Row. It is well connected to<br />

major city roads such as Jalan Tun Razak.<br />

The recent Groundbreaking Ceremony at the site<br />

was officiated by Her Royal Highness Sultanah of<br />

Pahang, Duli Yang Maha Mulia Sultanah Hajjah<br />

Kalsom who was accompanied by Yang Amat Mulia<br />

Tengku Fahad Mua’adzam Shah Ibni Sultan Haji<br />

Ahmad Shah as the Chairman of KOF Holdings<br />

Sdn Bhd. Also present at the event were the<br />

Chairman of Yong Tai Berhad Dato’ Indera Syed<br />

Norulzaman Syed Kamarulzaman; Deputy Director<br />

General of RISDA Abdullah Bin Zainal and the<br />

Director of City Planning Department DBKL<br />

Sulaiman bin Mohamad representing The Mayor of<br />

Kuala Lumpur.


6 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW NEWS<br />

NEW THAI LAWS<br />

FAVOUR TENANTS<br />

From 1st May, there will be sweeping changes<br />

affecting tenancy laws in Thailand. The main<br />

changes which fall under the ambit of the<br />

Consumer Protection Act are as follows:<br />

1. 30 DAYS’ NOTICE TO QUIT ANYTIME<br />

Tenants can give 30 days’ notice to move out<br />

anytime as long as their reason is reasonable.<br />

Tenants are not obligated to find another<br />

tenant to take over. Acceptable reasons include<br />

job transfer or moving abroad. However, it is<br />

not clear what the yardstick is for determining<br />

what is ‘reasonable’. This poses potentially<br />

a big problem for landlords who would face<br />

uncertainties in their rental income flow. This is<br />

however mitigated by the fact that this new law<br />

applies only to landlords leasing out 5 or more<br />

residential units which is considered a ‘residential<br />

lease business’. But if caught flouting the rules,<br />

landlords face jail time which is unduly harsh for<br />

what is essentially a civil offence.<br />

2. NON-COMPLIANT LEASES NULL<br />

AND VOID<br />

All existing leases which do not comply with<br />

the new law will be considered null and void;<br />

and their terms replaced by the new law. This<br />

retrospective piece of legislation again is a<br />

dramatic annulment of all non-compliant leases.<br />

It is however unclear whether the entire existing<br />

contract is null or void or only those terms which<br />

do not comply with the new law. If the latter,<br />

then theoretically, existing contracts do not need<br />

to be replaced because the new terms would<br />

automatically replace the non-compliant terms.<br />

3. 2 + 1 ILLEGAL<br />

The typical 2 months security deposit plus 1<br />

month advance rental is now illegal. Landlords<br />

can only ask for one month’s security deposit<br />

and one month’s advance rental. Landlords will<br />

have difficulty recouping their losses if the tenant<br />

leaves behind unpaid bills or damages amounting<br />

to more than one month’s rental.<br />

This amount cannot be used to top up any unpaid<br />

rent or damages. This begs the question as to why<br />

a security deposit is required at all if the landlord<br />

can’t utilise it.<br />

Landlords in Thailand tend to pass on the repairs<br />

and maintenance even of a routine nature to<br />

the tenant. This is now considered illegal along<br />

with marking up the charges for utilities such<br />

as electricity, water, telephone, internet, etc.<br />

Landlords must now charge at cost otherwise it is<br />

considered profiteering and hence illegal.<br />

4. 7 DAYS’ REFUND OF DEPOSIT<br />

Security deposits must be returned within 7 days<br />

instead of the current 30 days. This allows very<br />

little time for landlords to assess the damages to<br />

the unit when tenants leave.<br />

5. 30-DAY WAIT<br />

In the event of non-payment of rental, the<br />

landlord cannot change the locks or remove the<br />

tenant’s belongings. This is considered a criminal<br />

act of trespass and the landlord can be prosecuted.<br />

Instead, the landlord must give 30 days’ notice of<br />

the breach, and if not rectified, then only can the<br />

landlord terminate the lease. This is in line with<br />

international practice.


May - June 2018<br />

7<br />

SWHENGTEE PROPERTY<br />

EXPO IS BACK<br />

The long-anticipated Swhengtee Property Expo<br />

KL 2018 (Swhengtee EXPO) is back! To be held<br />

at Mid Valley Mall from 23 -24th June, the expo<br />

as always promises exciting new developments on<br />

top of lots of activities.<br />

With a solid track record of more than 20,000 visitors<br />

during the 3-day EXPO 2016 and 16,000 visitors during<br />

the 2-day EXPO 2017, the group has proven itself to be a<br />

successful organizer of big scale events. Exhibitors obtained<br />

thousands of quality sales leads and even concluded a<br />

number of sales on the spot during the last two expos.<br />

Investors come from all over Malaysia including Penang,<br />

Johor Bahru, Sabah, Sarawak as well as from overseas<br />

including China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, Singapore, etc.<br />

Through Dato Sri Gavin Tee’s overseas network and<br />

connections with the Malaysia-China Chamber of<br />

Commerce (MCCC) and Malaysia- Xiamen Chamber<br />

of Commerce (MXCC), hundreds of visitors from China<br />

will also be coming to visit the 2018 Swhengtee EXPO<br />

in groups.<br />

Based on the Visitors Demographics Survey in 2017,<br />

Swhengtee EXPO attracted more than 3,000 visitors<br />

from outstation and about 1,000 visitors from overseas.<br />

Additionally, based on research conducted by REM and<br />

Asian Property Review magazines, developers, professionals<br />

and readers affirmed that Mid Valley Kuala Lumpur is the<br />

most coveted venue to conduct property exhibitions.<br />

The said magazines have also interviewed property experts,<br />

Feng Shui Masters and readers, all of whom concluded that<br />

the Malaysian property market would perform better in the<br />

second half of 2018.<br />

A FINE FINALE<br />

Malaysia’s first of its kind Chinese<br />

Reality TV Show “Anyone Can<br />

Be A Property Millionaire” held<br />

its Finale shooting at Connexion<br />

Conference & Event Centre, Kuala Lumpur, which<br />

attracted over 200 guests on 22nd April.<br />

Produced by Swhengtee Group at a cost of RM3<br />

million, the show took 5 years of planning, 2 years<br />

of preparation and 45 days of filming.<br />

During the finale, the 8 Property Millionaire Stars<br />

shared their property investment knowledge gained<br />

from the guidance of Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee and the<br />

other experts in the Reality TV Show.


8 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

BRANDED<br />

RESIDENCES<br />

ASIA’S ULTIMATE TROPHY PROPERTIES<br />

The rising number of HNWIs is fuelling demand for globally recognised branded<br />

residences with all its accompanying prestige and bespoke services.<br />

There are now 2,000 billionaires in the world,<br />

growing at 13% per annum, according to Forbes.<br />

Many of them have homes all over the world and<br />

typically stay in different countries in a year. Their<br />

choice of homes – global branded residences. This is why<br />

the number of such residences has increased tenfold over<br />

the past decade.<br />

These are homes in prime locations that offer bespoke<br />

luxury services and prestige associated with an established<br />

brand. Branded residences started about 100 years ago<br />

in New York but only became a trend in the mid-1980s<br />

beginning with Four Seasons followed by Ritz-Carlton.<br />

When it became a success, other hotel brands came in such<br />

as Starwood, Fairmont, Kempinski, Aman, St. Regis, Hyatt<br />

Regency, Six Senses, Banyan Tree, W Hotels, Viceroy and<br />

Mandarin Oriental.<br />

However, it is in Southeast Asia and the Far East that<br />

resort branded residences have reached a matured phase and<br />

become the ultimate in luxurious accommodation.<br />

In Southeast Asia, Thailand leads the way with Amanpuri<br />

Phuket in 1988 followed by The Four Seasons Chiang Mai<br />

in 1995. Thailand still leads today with the biggest number<br />

of such residences in the entire SEA region.<br />

According to Bill Barnett, Managing Director at C9<br />

Hotelworks, large luxury hotel brands like Ritz-Carlton<br />

and Four Seasons are seeing a high proportion of their<br />

hotel pipeline being generated in mixed use or project with<br />

branded residences; they tend to favour gateway cities and<br />

key well-known leisure destinations with strong airlift.<br />

topped US$16 bil and is still growing at an unprecedented<br />

rate. Across the region, C9 Hotelworks estimates there are<br />

about 94 mainstream hotel residence projects with more<br />

than 21,000 units on line, with 78 properties expected to<br />

complete between 2018 and 2020, representing an 83%<br />

increase over the inventory in 2015.<br />

“Asia is also the testing ground for pioneering iterations of the<br />

concept with regards to scale, business models and levels of<br />

servicing/supporting amenities,” according to Bruce Wright,<br />

Senior Vice President and Principal of SB Architects.<br />

BRANDED RESIDENCE DEVELOPMENTS BY REGION<br />

Asia, Indian Ocean<br />

& South Pacific<br />

16%<br />

54%<br />

US & Canada<br />

BRAND AFFILIANT VS. INDEPENDENT<br />

Number of Projects<br />

Europe<br />

11%<br />

Latin America<br />

& Caribbean<br />

10%<br />

9%<br />

Middle East & Africa<br />

Branded<br />

Independent<br />

“Japan has been active in top end projects like the Four<br />

Seasons Kyoto or Park Hyatt Hanazono near Niseko.<br />

Overall, the urban push is strong, interestingly two key<br />

Asian resort brands, Aman and Six Senses, have city<br />

branded residences coming up in New York City.”<br />

According to research by Barnett’s C9 Hotelworks, the<br />

hotel branded residences market in Southeast Asia has now<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

Thailand<br />

Indonesia<br />

Vietnam<br />

Malaysia<br />

Philippines<br />

Singapore<br />

Cambodia


May - June 2018<br />

9<br />

Room angle, Anantara Phuket Layan<br />

Joanne Kua Bill Barnett Bruce Wright<br />

Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee<br />

WHY BRANDED?<br />

Branded residences tick all the right boxes – for the buyers,<br />

there is assurance of quality in construction, design and<br />

service; secure environment, bragging rights, “Lock up and<br />

leave” capability and the potential for investment returns<br />

from a rental pool (notably in a resort context).<br />

Says Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad and<br />

Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd: “Ultimately,<br />

when people buy a branded residence, they are looking<br />

at buying more than just a property, they want unique<br />

experiences that are often anchored on four key attributes –<br />

o<br />

o<br />

o<br />

o<br />

Opulent design by a renowned designer<br />

Luxury services and facilities offered by a 5-star hotel<br />

brand<br />

Unique architecture by a celebrated architect<br />

Brands associated with a level of quality and trust<br />

these brands can deliver”<br />

“Expatriates or HNWIs prefer branded residences,<br />

particularly famous international brands because these<br />

brands inspire confidence<br />

and provide the kind of<br />

bespoke services that they<br />

are used to. The brand carries<br />

the guarantee of quality and<br />

services as well as safety<br />

and security,” affirms Dato’<br />

Sri Gavin Tee, President of<br />

Swhengtee Group.<br />

Adds Wright of SB<br />

Architects: “Usually the<br />

access to ownership comes<br />

at a higher cost, but the<br />

return is a deep emotional<br />

connection to the brand<br />

philosophy, culture and often<br />

the related hotel amenities.”<br />

Other reasons include hassle-free ownership, owner<br />

benefits, e.g. residents’ discount card, access to the operator’s<br />

properties in other locations and like-minded neighbours.<br />

Indeed, some leading designers such as Luciano Mazza at<br />

HKS and John Hitchcox at YOO are talking about creating<br />

“modern day communities” of like-minded people – a sort of<br />

exclusive residents club.<br />

From the standpoint of the developer, having a brand<br />

associated with its property enhances sales by as much as<br />

30%. The resale value is higher or maintained while at the<br />

same time, it can fetch higher rentals.<br />

Furthermore, these residences yield a typical premium of<br />

between 20% - 40% with some fetching as much as 50%<br />

- 100% more, for example, the branded residences at The<br />

Ritz-Carlton Dorado Beach in Puerto Rico sold at up to<br />

250% above the average per sq foot price of non-branded<br />

units in the same development. The Armani Penthouses<br />

in Dubai were selling at more than 50% higher than<br />

when they were launched five years previously, according<br />

Hotel Branded Residences: Market Participants<br />

1 Banyan Tree Hyatt Place One & Only Shangri-La<br />

Accor Bulgari Hyatt Regency Onyx Sheraton<br />

Address Canyon Ranch Independent Paramount Six Senses<br />

Aloft Chedi Intercontinental Park Hyatt Starwood<br />

Alila Conrad JW Marriott Plaza St. Regis<br />

Aman Dusit Thani Kempinski Radisson Blu Sukhothai<br />

Amari Edition Kimpton Taj<br />

Anantara Fairmont Le Meridien Regent Thompson<br />

Andaz Four Seasons Louvre Renaissance Trump<br />

Angsana Gansevoort Mandarin Oriental Ritz-Carlton Versace<br />

Armani Golden Tulip Millennium Rock Resorts Viceroy<br />

Atlantis Grand Hyatt Mondrian Rosewood Vida<br />

Baccarat Hard Rock Montage SLS W<br />

Baglioni Hyatt Movenpick Setai Waldorf-Astoria<br />

Westin


10 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

Chris Graham<br />

Glen Chan<br />

Arianna Leopard<br />

to a report by Chris Graham, Founder and MD of<br />

Graham Associates.<br />

Interestingly, it is not just hotel brands which are the<br />

players, luxury brands from the fashion and jewellery<br />

industry such as Bulgari, Versace, Moschino and Armani<br />

and those from the automotive sector such as Porsche and<br />

Mercedes Benz have also licensed their names to developers.<br />

Royalty fees typically range between 3-5%, according to<br />

HVS and Savills.<br />

According to data from Savills, 65% of branded residences<br />

around the world are located in urban locations and 35%<br />

are in beach/resort locations. Many experts believe that this<br />

urban-dominant trend will continue. “Prime urban branded<br />

developments have greater appeal because they are perceived<br />

as less risky,” observes an insider.<br />

However, Wright from SB Architects believes that despite<br />

the urban-centric focus, there is a growing number<br />

of thriving ultra-luxury branded resort real estate in<br />

destinations like the Maldives, Caribbean or Turks & Caicos.<br />

THE DESIGN FACTOR<br />

Apart from location which is the most important factor<br />

for branded residences, architects and interior designers<br />

are also a critical part of the mix. “Branded residences need<br />

to have a high-degree of personalization and the accent is<br />

on interiors that tag the buyer’s lifestyle and wrap around<br />

emotion and feelings. We seamlessly merge architecture,<br />

interior design, and lifestyle in a way that speaks to the<br />

aspirations of the buyer, explains Arianna Leopard, Director<br />

of SB Architects.<br />

Wright concurs: “Consumers are more design conscious than<br />

ever before; they want to work in creative spaces and holiday<br />

in unique hotels. They want that bespoke design aesthetic to<br />

continue through their personal lives into their homes.”<br />

Yoo’s founder John Hitchcox says: “This can really be<br />

attributed to the growth of the design savvy consumer, the<br />

ever increasing importance of brand trust in our society and<br />

ultimately, developers recognising the importance of the<br />

home as a high involvement purchase.”<br />

Yoo is a leading designer in this sector with a portfolio<br />

of over 80 projects around the world and a stable of top<br />

designers including Philippe Starck, Jade Jagger and<br />

Kelly Hoppen.<br />

The ultimate design differentiation is of course to<br />

engage “starchitects” for example WATG’s St. Regis<br />

Hotel & Residences in Singapore and the residences<br />

by Norman Foster and Frank Gehry at Battersea Power<br />

Station in London.<br />

BRANDED RESIDENCES - DRIVERS OF PREMIUM<br />

Factors comanding price premium above unbranded residential product<br />

Medium premium<br />

• Prime global city / destination<br />

• Ultra - prime area & very good access<br />

• Star architect / renowned building<br />

• Famous designers & excellent fit out<br />

• Excellent views / higher floors<br />

HIGH PREMIUM: 25% +<br />

• Exceptional five - star hotel services<br />

• Luxury spa & wellness<br />

• Extensive luxury leisure facilities<br />

• High end restaurants & bars<br />

• Unique experience / facilities<br />

• ‘Above and beyond’ service<br />

• Conciege for tailored experiences<br />

• Other residents are ‘people like us’<br />

• Facilities exclusively for residents’ use<br />

• Association with the brand’s values<br />

• Hightly desired destination<br />

• Prime location with good access<br />

• High quality building & fit out<br />

• Recognised architect / designers<br />

• Good views<br />

MEDIUM PREMIUM: 15% - 25%<br />

• High quality hotel services<br />

• Spa facilities<br />

• Health and leisure facilities<br />

• Good quality restaurants and bars<br />

• Desirable experiences<br />

• Concierge, security & management<br />

• Residents-only area<br />

• Recognition and priority for residents<br />

• Discounts for residents<br />

• Cachet & confidence from the brand<br />

• Desirable destination<br />

• Good location and access<br />

• Well-designed<br />

• Attractive fit out<br />

• Lesser views / lower floors<br />

Location and<br />

product context<br />

MODEST PREMIUM: UP TO 15%<br />

• Quality services and facilities<br />

• Or high quality hotel services but<br />

where the wider managed destination<br />

brand experience is already delivering<br />

notable premium<br />

Associated brand<br />

experience<br />

• Some extra benefits<br />

• Similiar experience as hotel guests<br />

• Security & management<br />

• Reassurance of a brand<br />

Additional benefits<br />

for residents


May - June 2018<br />

11<br />

STRUCTURE OF A TYPICAL BRANDED RESIDENCES PROJECT<br />

Marketing Licence Agreement<br />

Operator permits Developer to use the Residential Trademarks in<br />

connection with the sale and marketing of Residential Units<br />

Technical Services Agreement<br />

Operator to the render technical services in connection with the<br />

planning, building, furnishing, equipping and decorating of the<br />

hotel and the residential component<br />

Operator<br />

Trademark Licence Agreement<br />

Operator grants to HotelCo the right to<br />

use the Trademarks in the operation<br />

and management of hotels<br />

Hotels Management Agreement<br />

For management of Hotel and provision of<br />

services to Residential Component<br />

*<br />

1. appoint as agent of his unit<br />

2. appoint as agent for common area<br />

3. grant proxy for owners’ meetings<br />

HotelCo<br />

(Associated<br />

With<br />

Developer)<br />

*<br />

Lease Units<br />

Buyers joining the<br />

Rental program<br />

Developer<br />

Sell Units<br />

Buyers<br />

Appoint<br />

HotelCo as<br />

agent for<br />

common area<br />

Buyers NOT joining<br />

the program<br />

*<br />

Owners’ Association<br />

appoint<br />

Consultancy Agreement + Residential Services & Facilities Agreement<br />

© 2014 Baker & McKenzie<br />

Property Management<br />

Company & Resort<br />

Management Company<br />

Clearly, the quest to differentiate is a constant race to imbue<br />

the residences with the best and most unique qualities – this<br />

has shifted to more experiential lifestyle.<br />

Says Graham: “Whilst buyers’ priorities remain consistent<br />

in terms of location, design and access to world-class<br />

amenities, very much in line with trends in the hospitality<br />

sector, it is increasingly more about the intangible ‘added<br />

value’ lifestyle benefits associated with a brand. Increasingly,<br />

the shift is towards creating an emotional connection with<br />

residents through experiences. ”<br />

An example is a residence with access to a private marina a<br />

few steps away. Pan Pacific Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour<br />

together with Puteri Cove Residences and Quayside, are<br />

the only luxury waterfront project with both private-marina<br />

(300 berths) and sea views in Iskandar. Developed by Pearl<br />

Discovery, a joint venture by Singapore-based real estate<br />

developers Pacific Star and DB2, the 205-suite Pan Pacific<br />

Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour is scheduled to open in the<br />

third quarter of 2018. The marina facility will be managed<br />

by Singapore’s award-winning Marina and Lifestyle<br />

operator, One 15 Marina.<br />

WHAT’S NEXT?<br />

The supply of branded residences is currently limited<br />

around the world. However, given that more and more of<br />

such residences are being built, it runs the risk of oversupply.<br />

That has already happened in Thailand and Vietnam, where<br />

branded residences are now becoming so engrained and<br />

numerous in the market that they risk being the norm<br />

rather than the exception, cautions Graham. Barnett agrees<br />

saying that there will be more and greater diversity in real<br />

estate grade from luxury to entry level. “Even budget chain<br />

YOTEL is talking branded residences.”<br />

This then is the challenge for the branded residences<br />

segment today – to push that differentiation factor even<br />

further as competition begins to heat up.<br />

Unless otherwise stated, all charts and tables are courtesy of Chris Graham.<br />

In fact, says Glen Chan, President and CEO of Pacific<br />

Star Development: “The private marina in Iskandar will<br />

be modelled after the one in Sentosa Cove which is also<br />

managed by One 15 Marina.”<br />

Pan Pacific Serviced Suites Puteri Harbour


12 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

8 Conlay by Kempinski under construction.<br />

THE BRANDED FACTOR<br />

IN KL’S GLOBALISATION<br />

As an emerging market, Malaysia has seen a steady uptick in branded residences<br />

taking root particularly in its capital city, Kuala Lumpur. Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee,<br />

President of Swhengtee Group shares his prediction of this niche market segment.<br />

“When a city becomes globalised, it will attract<br />

more multinational companies (MNCs) and<br />

international travellers who are used to the<br />

high quality of certain brands and will naturally<br />

gravitate towards such branded establishments<br />

including international 5-star hotels and residences.<br />

That’s why branded residences command a higher<br />

premium than residences that do not have a<br />

prestigious brand attached to it.<br />

Expatriates or HNWIs prefer branded residences,<br />

particularly famous international brands because<br />

these brands inspire confidence and provide the kind<br />

of bespoke services that they are used to. The brand<br />

carries the guarantee of quality and services as well as<br />

safety and security.<br />

Not surprisingly, international branded residences<br />

have the potential to command half the market.<br />

A branded property can enhance its value by 30%,<br />

for example, a property without brand may sell at<br />

The unique thing about Malaysia’s<br />

branded residences is that prices are<br />

at a much lower level for the same<br />

bespoke services compared to other<br />

countries. So, there is a lot of room<br />

for price appreciation.<br />

RM2,00 psf, but if it is branded with a famous<br />

international hotel chain, it can fetch RM3,000 psf.<br />

Further, when a popular or famous brand enters<br />

a market, it can even make the place popular, for<br />

example, when Air Asia flies to a little known<br />

destination, it can make the place popular and<br />

when more people visit the destination, the value of<br />

properties there will rise in tandem (provided other<br />

favourable conditions exist as well).


May - June 2018<br />

13<br />

BRANDED RESIDENTIAL EFFECT<br />

Kuala Lumpur was supposed to have globalised<br />

since 2007 when a lot of Middle Eastern, Korean<br />

and other foreign investors beat a path to its doors.<br />

However when the Global Financial Crisis hit in<br />

2009, it slowed down the globalisation process to a<br />

large extent.<br />

It took some 10 years before KL got back into<br />

international investors’ radar. The influx of China’s<br />

investments especially in infrastructure such as<br />

railways, ports and finance, as well as the siting<br />

of key regional headquarters in Malaysia such<br />

as China Communications Construction Co<br />

Ltd (CCCC) , Ali Baba’s Digital Free Trade<br />

Zone (DFTZ) kickstarted the second wave of<br />

investments into Malaysia.<br />

This was followed by a number of other foreign<br />

companies setting up their regional headquarters in<br />

Kuala Lumpur and its surrounding areas. Several<br />

critical transportation infrastructure such as the<br />

MRT1 and the LRT extension were also completed.<br />

Seeing a gap in supply, a number of branded<br />

residences were set up and were completed in<br />

2017/2018 such as Four Seasons and W Hotel.<br />

Around the same time, a few others were launched<br />

such as 8 Conlay by Kempinski and Ascott Star<br />

KLCC Residences.<br />

With the rising number of such residences, we can<br />

expect 2018 – 2020 to see a lot of activities in this<br />

segment – either some will be completed, new ones<br />

launched or being constructed.<br />

It’s only now that we can expect to see a significant<br />

price appreciation. In the last few years, high end<br />

properties were hovering around the RM1.5K –<br />

RM2K price level. We can now see price levels<br />

jumping to RM2.5K – RM3.5K level, for example,<br />

Four Seasons. This is the beginning of what I would<br />

term as the ‘branded residential effect’.<br />

PRICING ADVANTAGE<br />

The unique thing about Malaysia’s branded<br />

residences is that prices are at a much lower<br />

level for the same bespoke services compared to<br />

other countries. So, there is a lot of room for<br />

price appreciation.<br />

Previously, I have forecasted that prices of high end<br />

residence could reach RM5K psf, but due to many<br />

unforeseen circumstances such as the Malaysia<br />

Airlines (MAS) disasters and the 1MDB issue,<br />

the progress has been slow. However, I believe the<br />

price level will still hit RM5K by 2020 for branded<br />

residences not only in the city centre but in resort<br />

areas like Penang and Kota Kinabalu.<br />

Currently, a major concern in Malaysia is the delay<br />

in the setup of more international corporations and<br />

the arrival of expatriates in Malaysia. However, I<br />

predict properties completed within the next 3 years<br />

should enjoy the fruits of right timing – being first<br />

in the market; thus having the advantage of quick<br />

occupancy with high rental yield and a possible fast<br />

price appreciation.<br />

For example, 8 Conlay by Kempinski in KL will<br />

enjoy good returns because by the time<br />

it’s completed by 2020, more foreign<br />

investments would have poured into the<br />

city centre.<br />

The competition is also not intense<br />

as there aren’t too many of such super<br />

branded residentials setting up in<br />

Malaysia. The ones that immediately<br />

come to mind are Four Seasons, St<br />

Regis and Ritz-Carlton.<br />

I believe the price<br />

level will still hit<br />

RM5K by 2020<br />

for branded<br />

residences not<br />

only in the<br />

city centre<br />

but in resort<br />

areas like<br />

Penang<br />

and Kota<br />

Kinabalu.


14 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

1<br />

BRANDED<br />

IN THE TRUEST SENSE<br />

Asian Property Review chats with Joanne Kua, CEO of KSK Group Berhad<br />

and Managing Director of KSK Land Sdn Bhd on branded residences and<br />

their 8 Conlay debut project.


May - June 2018<br />

15<br />

1<br />

What was the inspiration behind 8 Conlay<br />

development?<br />

8 Conlay is KSK Land’s debut project, and we<br />

want to construct something new and exciting,<br />

an iconic development that becomes a distinct<br />

part of KL city centre. The birth of 8 Conlay<br />

was based on one revolutionary mission – that<br />

is to bring together A-list brand partners to<br />

curate one-of-its kind living spaces through<br />

three main elements – liveable architecture,<br />

world-class designs and bespoke personalised<br />

services. We want to bring luxury living in<br />

Malaysia to the next level.<br />

Unlike other developers that bring in designers,<br />

landscape and service partners at the end<br />

stages, we brought in our partners right at the<br />

beginning and work together to map out every<br />

detail and offering of 8 Conlay. We have never<br />

looked back since then, and today 8 Conlay<br />

has become this massive project - an integrated<br />

development offering lush living experience<br />

with the highest level of service.<br />

With an estimated GDV of RM5.4 bil, it<br />

sits on a 4-acre piece of land at Jalan Conlay,<br />

comprising two branded residence towers<br />

called YOO8 serviced by Kempinski, a five-star<br />

Kempinski Hotel and serviced residences, and a<br />

lifestyle retail quarters.<br />

Just some quick facts about our brand partners<br />

– some of them are making their debut<br />

appearance in Malaysia through 8 Conlay:<br />

• Liveable architecture – We brought in<br />

Ar Hud Bakar from RSP Architects,<br />

a visionary Malaysian architect. Hud’s<br />

designs emphasise liveable architecture<br />

that focuses on local content and the<br />

human aspects of buildings.<br />

• We have entrusted the landscape design<br />

elements to award-winning Bangkokbased<br />

design studio, Terrains+ Open<br />

Space (TROP). We are transforming<br />

the common amenity floors of YOO8<br />

serviced by Kempinski on Level 26<br />

(Water Lounge) and Level 44 (Green<br />

Refuge) into retreats that encapsulate<br />

2<br />

Every city needs a gem development<br />

that will put the city on the world’s<br />

map, and branded residences have<br />

the capability to give Kuala Lumpur a<br />

different character that will put it on par<br />

with other top cities in the world.<br />

the idea of a futuristic vertical park that<br />

blends architecture and nature, something<br />

Malaysians have yet to experience.<br />

• Interior designs – For designs, we have<br />

YOO, an international design studio<br />

working with high-profile designers<br />

including Philippe Starck, Marcel<br />

Wanders, Jade Jagger and Kelly Hoppen.<br />

YOO started designing branded residences<br />

since 1999. For Tower A of YOO8<br />

serviced by Kempinski, we partner with<br />

Steve Leung & YOO, to transform the<br />

branded residences experience through<br />

design of living spaces.<br />

• Personalised luxury services – Kempinski<br />

Hotels is Europe’s oldest luxury hotelier<br />

with a 121-year rich heritage. We believe<br />

Kempinski will be able to redefine<br />

hospitality for our guests and residents at<br />

8 Conlay with impeccable, personalised<br />

services. We are so proud to host the first<br />

and only Kempinski Hotel in Malaysia at<br />

8 Conlay.<br />

What is the stage of development currently?<br />

What is the take-up rate so far? When is the<br />

estimated completion date?<br />

Tower A of YOO8 serviced by Kempinski<br />

was launched at the start of 2016, and we<br />

have sold 80% of the units to-date. In terms<br />

of construction progress, the foundation and<br />

basements works were completed mid last year,<br />

and we have proceeded with the superstructure<br />

construction works. We are currently on track<br />

for completion in 2020. We are planning to roll<br />

out Tower B of YOO8 serviced by Kempinski<br />

mid this year, and will definitely share details<br />

once ready.


16 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

3<br />

What is it about branded residences that<br />

makes them in demand among High Net<br />

Worth Individuals (HNWIs)? Share with us<br />

what are the unique features that made YOO8<br />

serviced by Kempinski stand out?<br />

Globally, branded residences are perceived to be<br />

at a level above high-end luxury properties and<br />

increasingly popular among wealthy investors<br />

as they offer both five-star luxuries and capital<br />

protection/hedging tool. According to Knight<br />

Frank, branded residences command 31%<br />

higher capital yield compared to non-branded<br />

luxury property segment.<br />

Ultimately, when people buy a branded<br />

residence, they are looking at buying more than<br />

just a property, they want unique experiences<br />

that are often anchored on four key attributes –<br />

• Opulent design by a renowned designer<br />

• Luxury services and facilities offered by a<br />

5-star hotel brand<br />

• Unique architecture by a celebrated<br />

architect<br />

• Brands associated with a level of quality<br />

and trust these brands can deliver<br />

When you curate branded residences, you need<br />

to have a very good location, good design and<br />

a consistent level of bespoke, luxury service. 8<br />

Conlay is situated at a prime location within KL<br />

city’s Golden Triangle. It is within five minutes’<br />

walking distance of Pavilion KL and Jalan<br />

Bukit Bintang’s shopping district, Conlay MRT<br />

station, High Speed Rail, and is 20 minutes’<br />

walking distance to Petronas Twin Towers.<br />

Although branded developments are not<br />

new in Malaysia, it is still at an infancy<br />

stage. In fact, many of the KL branded<br />

residence developments are branded solely<br />

by a hotel partner.<br />

For now, we see opportunities in<br />

prime locations in Malaysia.<br />

4<br />

The supply of branded<br />

residences is limited around the<br />

world. People who buy them<br />

don’t generally want to sell<br />

because these are limited and<br />

priceless possessions they are<br />

proud to own.<br />

If I were to pin point the single most important<br />

value proposition of 8 Conlay, it would be the<br />

values and trust associated with our brand<br />

partners. We have Ar Hud Bakar, an awardwinning<br />

architect; Europe’s oldest luxury<br />

hotelier, Kempinski for bespoke, personalised<br />

luxury service; and YOO for the highest<br />

standard designs.<br />

In Tower A of our branded residences, YOO8<br />

serviced by Kempinski, the interior design is<br />

by Steve Leung & YOO. Steve Leung is a<br />

world-renowned design guru who has won over<br />

130 awards worldwide, and he was awarded<br />

the Andrew Martin International Designer of<br />

the Year Award in 2015 (which is equivalent<br />

to the Academy Awards in design). His works<br />

reflect a sophisticated and unique character of<br />

minimalism, with skillful adoption of Asian<br />

culture and arts. In addition, we also have the<br />

renowned Pok Kobkongsanti, TROP’s lead<br />

design director, to manage the landscape which<br />

plays a vital role in enhancing city living quality.<br />

Simply put, each of our brand partners brings<br />

to 8 Conlay unique qualities that ultimately<br />

become a tangible benefit for our buyers and<br />

investors. We want our residents to proudly say<br />

they are buying a gem in KL and it’s worth it!<br />

What is the ratio of local and foreign buyers?<br />

Where do the foreigners come from?<br />

Currently, our buyers’ profile are about 80%<br />

foreign and 20% local. We have buyers from<br />

Tier 1 cities in China, Hong Kong, Singapore,<br />

Taiwan, Indonesia, Middle East and more.


May - June 2018<br />

17<br />

5<br />

What is the percentage of price premium of<br />

your branded residence over a comparable<br />

non-branded residence? Why would buyers<br />

pay the premium?<br />

As mentioned earlier, Knight Frank reported<br />

that branded residences commanded an average<br />

uplift of 31% compared to non-branded<br />

property segment. In addition, according to<br />

a market update report by Horwath HTL<br />

published in January 2018, a property with<br />

hotel affiliation could translate to a 25–35%<br />

uplift in pricing.<br />

8 Conlay was launched at RM2,700 psf in 2016<br />

and reached RM3,200 psf in 2017.<br />

6<br />

Our premium price can be fetched due to:<br />

• Quality of the brands delivered;<br />

• Central prime location;<br />

• Luxury service and trust that brands like<br />

Kempinski will maintain the property and<br />

ensure the uplift of capital appreciation;<br />

• Good design – Good designers help design<br />

and optimise spaces that are easier to live in<br />

or to rent out.<br />

What is the built-up range for the units and<br />

their price psf?<br />

The branded residence units of Tower A of<br />

YOO8 serviced by Kempinski range from 700<br />

to 1,308 sq feet. They are priced at RM3,200<br />

Despite soft market sentiments and the<br />

oversupply issues facing the Malaysian<br />

property market, we remain upbeat about<br />

the long-term prospect of the Kuala<br />

Lumpur property market.<br />

Bedroom - Type B layout, Tower A by Steve Leung & Yoo


18 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

7<br />

If I were to pin point the single<br />

most important value proposition<br />

of 8 Conlay, it would be the values<br />

and trust associated with our<br />

brand partners.<br />

psf or an average price of only RM2.3 mil<br />

per unit. All units are fully-furnished with<br />

furniture selected by Steve Leung & YOO and<br />

offer views of the Royal Selangor Golf Club<br />

and KLCC, in addition to receiving the same<br />

Kempinski service.<br />

Why choose Kempinski?<br />

8 Conlay was created with the idea of providing<br />

service excellence in liveable, design-led<br />

architecture. We wanted people to know that<br />

living at 8 Conlay is more than having a shelter<br />

over their heads. It is an experience which<br />

allows each resident to create their own story.<br />

For this, 8 Conlay needed a brand partner who<br />

could provide the top-notch services that would<br />

reflect hospitality at its best and simultaneously<br />

allow residents to form incredible memories.<br />

We know Kempinski Hotels will be able to<br />

meet our guests’ and residents’ expectations as<br />

every aspect of Kempinski’s 121 years of luxury<br />

bespoke services is geared towards serving guests<br />

who expect excellence and value individuality.<br />

Each Kempinski hotel is unique<br />

to its location and local cultures;<br />

providing a sense of place but<br />

maintaining the same consistent<br />

bespoke service standard<br />

throughout its hotels.<br />

Dining room - Type E layout, Tower A by Steve Leung & Yoo


May - June 2018<br />

19<br />

8<br />

9<br />

Kempinski does not adopt a one-size-fitsall<br />

approach. They try to incorporate what is<br />

distinct about the location where the hotel<br />

will be built. That’s why each Kempinski hotel<br />

is unique to its location and local cultures;<br />

providing a sense of place but maintaining<br />

the same consistent bespoke service standard<br />

throughout its hotels. This uniqueness sets<br />

Kempinski apart from other luxury hoteliers.<br />

We hope that more Malaysians will find<br />

meaning in luxury living as a reflection of their<br />

passion to achieve excellence.<br />

What is your view on the competition from<br />

other branded residences in KL?<br />

The supply of branded residences is limited<br />

around the world. People who buy them don’t<br />

generally want to sell them because these are<br />

limited and priceless possessions they are proud<br />

to own. We believe 8 Conlay offers buyers<br />

and investors a good investment opportunity<br />

as it will command better capital yield for the<br />

longer term. Besides, prices of luxury properties<br />

in Malaysia are considered among the cheapest<br />

in Asia. We are also the only branded residence<br />

in Kuala Lumpur to bring a luxury five-star<br />

hotel brand and a world class branded designer,<br />

Steve Leung & YOO into the mix, rather than<br />

just a hotel brand.<br />

What is the market outlook for such branded<br />

residences in Malaysia, particularly in KL?<br />

Despite soft market sentiments and the<br />

oversupply issues facing the Malaysian<br />

property market, we remain upbeat about<br />

the long-term prospect of the Kuala Lumpur<br />

property market. Furthermore, there is<br />

not much land left in the KLCC area and<br />

therefore supply is finite and limited.<br />

Firstly, Kuala Lumpur is still a key investment<br />

destination for businesses and investors.<br />

Secondly, the property market will enjoy the<br />

spillover effects of major mega infrastructure<br />

projects such as the High Speed Rail and<br />

MRT project, because once these projects are<br />

completed, they will change the city, just like any<br />

other major city in the world. By then, Kuala<br />

10<br />

8 Conlay was launched at<br />

RM2,700 psf in 2016 and reached<br />

RM3,200 psf in 2017.<br />

Lumpur will transform into a more vibrant and<br />

liveable city, and property prices are set to rise.<br />

So, the immediate need is to rebuild buyers’<br />

confidence. We cannot overlook the fact<br />

that today’s discerning buyers have high<br />

expectations and are very selective. In addition<br />

to pricing, their buying decisions are affected<br />

by factors like services, quality, location and<br />

capital appreciation.<br />

Buyers will continue to invest if they see the<br />

right property – developments offering the<br />

right concept, location (within the Kuala<br />

Lumpur city centre) and long-term rental yield<br />

potential. For example, they prefer branded<br />

residences due to its characteristics of better<br />

capital yield, quality hotel servicing and<br />

consistent maintenance of the property.<br />

As Kuala Lumpur transforms into a worldclass<br />

city, there is definitely greater demand<br />

for branded residences. Every city needs a<br />

gem development that will put the city on the<br />

world’s map, and branded residences have the<br />

capability to give Kuala Lumpur a different<br />

character that will put it on par with other top<br />

cities in the world.<br />

What other projects are in the pipeline in<br />

Malaysia for KSK Land?<br />

For the rest of 2018, we will remain<br />

focused on developing 8 Conlay, nurturing it<br />

to completion.<br />

11<br />

Any plans to expand overseas?<br />

If opportunity presents itself, KSK Land is<br />

open. However, for now, we see opportunities in<br />

prime locations in Malaysia.


20 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

BRANDED<br />

RESIDENCES<br />

THE INSIDER’S VIEW<br />

Asian Property Review talks to Chris Graham (Founder and MD of<br />

Graham Associates), who is regarded as one of the world’s foremost<br />

specialists on branded residences.<br />

1<br />

2<br />

Does the shift of consumer preference for<br />

more independence through branded serviced<br />

apartment spell the beginning of the demise<br />

for the pure stand-alone hotel set-up?<br />

There will always be strong demand for<br />

stand-alone hotels. Whilst branded residences<br />

and serviced apartments certainly add to the<br />

range of accommodation choices available<br />

to travellers, in reality these still represent a<br />

relatively small percentage of the market. In<br />

many cases – notably prime urban locations –<br />

the lack of availability and the high cost of land<br />

are key factors that can inhibit the opportunities<br />

to include a branded residential component<br />

alongside a hotel. Many travellers seeking<br />

greater independence are of course turning to<br />

AirBnB – although currently most branded<br />

operators do not permit their homeowners to<br />

use this platform to rent out their residences,<br />

which must instead be put into the operator’s<br />

managed rental programme.<br />

Apart from concierge and butler services,<br />

celebrity or Michelin chef restaurants, inhouse<br />

cinemas, branded spas, golf simulator,<br />

wine storage, award-winning designers and<br />

even starchitects, what other distinctive<br />

services or characteristics mark the branded<br />

service residence?<br />

100 Las Olas<br />

There is a long list of facilities and services that<br />

developers are incorporating in their branded<br />

residences (including those listed above). In<br />

addition, there is the convenience of owning a


May - June 2018<br />

21<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

I have seen cases where<br />

high-end developments use<br />

celebrities such as footballers<br />

to promote ‘the exclusiveness’<br />

of their offer, yet in reality<br />

many HNWIs do not wish<br />

to have these types of high<br />

profile individuals as their<br />

neighbours, so this can in fact<br />

sometimes have a negative<br />

impact.<br />

3<br />

“lock up and go” home, that will be kept secure<br />

and professionally maintained – and possibly<br />

earn valuable income - when the owner is not<br />

in residence.<br />

Above all, rather than simply providing more<br />

5*+ facilities, the focus is more about creating<br />

a personal and emotional engagement with<br />

customers. Some leading branded residences<br />

designers such as Luciano Mazza at HKS and<br />

John Hitchcox at YOO talk about creating<br />

“modern day communities” of like-minded<br />

people – a sort of exclusive residents club.<br />

Whilst buyers’ priorities remain consistent in<br />

terms of location, design and access to worldclass<br />

amenities, very much in line with trends<br />

in the hospitality sector, it is increasingly more<br />

about the intangible ‘added value’ lifestyle<br />

benefits associated with a brand. Increasingly,<br />

the shift is towards creating an emotional<br />

connection with residents through experiences.<br />

What are the most common challenges<br />

faced by developers when building a branded<br />

residence?<br />

There are innumerable challenges that a<br />

developer faces and every project brings its<br />

own unique set. I would say generally that<br />

securing the best locations and ensuring<br />

that branded residences are designed for the<br />

local marketplace rank quite high. On this<br />

second point, most branded operators have<br />

rigid guidelines about FF&E, room sizes<br />

and facilities so in some cases these may, for<br />

Chris Graham<br />

example, require that units will be too large –<br />

and therefore expensive - for the local market,<br />

when priced on a per sq m basis. Many<br />

developers today will appoint an operator once<br />

the design concept for the residences is already<br />

well developed, so marrying up the design to<br />

the brand guidelines in such circumstances can<br />

be an issue. Another challenge is financial –<br />

notably achieving sufficient off-plan pre-sales,<br />

since construction is often only triggered once a<br />

specified number of units has been sold.


22 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

Increasingly, the shift is towards<br />

creating an emotional connection<br />

with residents through experiences.<br />

4<br />

5<br />

In terms of the buyers, are they filtered to<br />

create an exclusive community of persons<br />

of a certain standing, yet free of scandals or<br />

drama – for some developments that you are<br />

aware of?<br />

When there is a committed buyer with<br />

money on the table sitting in front of a sales<br />

negotiator, it is very difficult for him or her to<br />

find reasons not to make a deal! However, I<br />

certainly know of situations where potential<br />

buyers have been politely turned away. In<br />

upper-upscale developments especially, most<br />

developers and their sales teams recognise<br />

the importance of maintaining an exclusive<br />

residential community and are well aware of<br />

the negative sentiment that one ‘less-thandesirable’<br />

resident can attract.<br />

Similarly, I have seen cases where high-end<br />

developments use celebrities such as footballers<br />

to promote ‘the exclusiveness’ of their offer, yet<br />

in reality many HNWIs do not wish to have<br />

these types of high profile individuals as their<br />

neighbours, so this can in fact sometimes have a<br />

negative impact.<br />

How much higher can we raise the bar for<br />

luxury or is it a meaningless word now, being<br />

overused and made up of standard offerings?<br />

Interbrand’s Rebecca Robins was spot on<br />

when she observed that the definition of<br />

luxury has become so diluted that it is<br />

becoming meaningless. This is particularly<br />

true in real estate, as almost every residential<br />

development that launches is promoted as<br />

“luxury”. Design, technology and innovation<br />

all continue to expand the boundaries and<br />

6<br />

7<br />

opportunities for developers, notably around<br />

sustainability and Smart Homes, which are<br />

fast becoming standard.<br />

Should branded residences adapt to<br />

their local environment by incorporating<br />

local elements such as local design and<br />

architecture, and materials - without diluting<br />

the world class standard of the branded hotel<br />

operator?<br />

There is no right or wrong way, as every<br />

situation is different. It depends on several<br />

things, for example the location, the intended<br />

target audience, and the brand. Some brands<br />

such as W have a very distinctive design<br />

style, which is either suited to a particular<br />

location and lifestyle or it isn’t. Generally,<br />

architects are pretty sympathetic to the local<br />

environment and prefer to use locally-sourced<br />

materials. I recently heard about an extreme<br />

example in which a developer moved an<br />

entire village across to his new resort site for<br />

total authenticity.<br />

What are the common challenges faced by<br />

luxury hotel brands when dealing with local<br />

developers as their partners?<br />

Ensuring that the developer designs and builds<br />

the property to satisfy its brand standards, and<br />

then subsequently maintaining the property<br />

to the highest standards. It is important<br />

to remember that a local developer may be<br />

seeking an earlier exit from the project than<br />

the international brand operator, so the<br />

operator needs to ensure that its interests<br />

– and those of the residence owners – are<br />

adequately protected over the longer term.


May - June 2018<br />

23<br />

8<br />

Upper Deck Sala View, Anantara Phuket Layan<br />

“80% of CEOs believe their brand differs from<br />

the competition, but only 20% of customers<br />

agree with that.” - Ricco de Blank, CEO of<br />

SHKP Hotels (owns two Ritz-Carltons, a St.<br />

Regis and a W Hotel)<br />

The above seems like a big disconnect in<br />

perception. How should the hotel CEOs<br />

rethink their brand differentiation?<br />

Yes, this quote neatly emphasises a key point<br />

I highlighted in my report. There is such a<br />

proliferation of brands competing at various<br />

levels of the market and to different audience<br />

segments, all trying to differentiate themselves<br />

by carving out a unique identity and positioning<br />

in the marketplace. Yet reading through<br />

many brand positioning statements is pretty<br />

confusing, even to industry professionals - and<br />

if we cannot understand what a particular hotel<br />

8<br />

Anantara Phuket Layan


24 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

Ocean Drive Residences<br />

I recently heard about an extreme<br />

example in which a developer moved<br />

an entire village across to his new resort<br />

site for total authenticity.<br />

brand represents, then how can consumers<br />

and potential purchasers be expected to<br />

do so? Piers Schmidt at Luxury Branding<br />

Consultancy undertook a study on this last<br />

year in which he found that a significant<br />

proportion of hotel brand slogans actually<br />

employ very similar sound bites, which he<br />

describes as “buzzword bingo at its best!”<br />

Branded residences that present a clearly<br />

defined and offer an attractive lifestyle which<br />

genuinely resonate with buying audiences, will<br />

succeed to a much greater degree than those<br />

that do not stand out for anything distinctive.<br />

9<br />

This is where good marketing can really make a<br />

difference, by effectively packaging, presenting<br />

and communicating the offer to differentiate<br />

the development, so that it truly stands out<br />

from its competitors.<br />

With so many branded residences in the<br />

market, do you think it will reach a saturation<br />

point where the customer can no longer see<br />

the differentiation?<br />

In the Southeast Asian market, notably<br />

Thailand and Vietnam, branded residences are<br />

now becoming so engrained and prolific in the<br />

market that they risk being the norm rather<br />

than the exception. Branded residences achieve<br />

a generous price premium over comparable<br />

non-branded homes because of the exclusivity<br />

and kudos that the association with the brand<br />

offers to owners; as such, in a market that is<br />

becoming ‘saturated’ with high-end branded<br />

residences, exclusivity can really only be defined<br />

by the desirability of the location and the<br />

perceived status of the brand itself.


May - June 2018<br />

25<br />

10<br />

11<br />

Any examples where the arrangement between<br />

the owner/developer and the brand operator is<br />

terminated. Usually, what are the reasons for<br />

the termination?<br />

Normally this is caused by a failure by the<br />

developer or operator to perform its obligations,<br />

a breach of contract, or any risk of causing<br />

damage to the brand. For example, if the<br />

common areas of the branded residences are not<br />

maintained to the required standards, e.g. due to<br />

insufficient funding, this usually gives the brand<br />

operator the right to terminate the association.<br />

Of course, this has significant repercussions for<br />

the residents and the value of their properties.<br />

Why is there a worldwide shift from branded<br />

resort residences towards branded urban<br />

mixed-use developments?<br />

Branded residences had been established in<br />

North America for many years before the<br />

global industry woke up to the benefits that<br />

they offer – not least as developers realised<br />

that they could benefit from a substantial price<br />

premium and (generally) faster sales absorption<br />

rate by partnering with a respected brand. This<br />

has been driven largely by increasing demand<br />

among HNWI consumers seeking high-end<br />

residences with the convenience of hotel<br />

services in their own homes, together with<br />

the confidence that the association with an<br />

established luxury brand delivers. Previously,<br />

with the high cost of purchasing prime central<br />

urban land combined with strong demand<br />

for luxury homes sustaining prices, urban<br />

developers did not see the need (along with the<br />

added costs) to bring on a brand; however, as<br />

markets soften, competition increases and the<br />

bar is raised, the branded option presents a very<br />

compelling route for more quickly achieving<br />

differentiation, status and sales.<br />

GRAHAM:<br />

TRENDS IN THE NEXT<br />

10 YEARS<br />

From my research and discussions with eminent<br />

market professionals around the globe, I predict<br />

the following trends during the next decade:<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

t<br />

Continuing expansion in the sector in terms<br />

of the number and range (i.e. sectors) of<br />

market participants.<br />

Broader quality of branded units for sale (i.e.<br />

lower star rated hotel operators).<br />

Less focus on ‘tangible’ elements, more on<br />

emotional connections.<br />

Wellbeing and positive ‘healing’<br />

environments will become mainstream.<br />

The emergence of residential lifestyle brands<br />

for specific demographic segments (e.g.<br />

retirement).<br />

The expansion of branded residences into<br />

exciting new destinations across the globe,<br />

including South America and Africa.<br />

More branded residences across Europe,<br />

both urban and resort.<br />

Premiums being squeezed in developed<br />

markets with more competition.<br />

More standalone branded residences, mostly<br />

in an urban environment.<br />

Editor’s Note: A free copy of the second edition of Chris<br />

Graham’s report “Branded Residences: An Overview”<br />

can be downloaded at www.gagms.com


26 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

RISING NUMBER<br />

AND DIVERSITY OF<br />

BRANDED<br />

RESIDENCES<br />

IN ASIA<br />

Even budget chain YOTEL is<br />

talking branded residences.<br />

Anantara Phuket Layan


May - June 2018<br />

27<br />

Asian Property Review talks to leading Asian hotel expert, Bill Barnett,<br />

Managing Director at C9 Hotelworks on the branded residences<br />

scenario in Asia.<br />

Which emerging Asian countries/cities/areas are<br />

sought after by developers of branded residences<br />

and the brands themselves?<br />

Large luxury hotel brands like Ritz-Carlton and Four<br />

Seasons are seeing a high proportion of their hotel<br />

pipeline being generated in mixed use or project with<br />

branded residences; they tend to favour gateway cities<br />

and key well-known leisure destinations with strong<br />

airlift. Japan has been active in top end projects like<br />

the Four Seasons Kyoto or Park Hyatt Hanazono<br />

near Niseko. Overall, the urban push is strongly,<br />

interestingly two key Asian resort brands, Aman and<br />

Six Senses, both have city branded residences coming<br />

up in New York City.<br />

Supply and demand track the<br />

overall real estate market and there<br />

remains strong sustained growth<br />

in the region, with the notable<br />

exception of Vietnam which may<br />

see an oversupply.<br />

How important is the investment angle to the Asian<br />

HNWI buyers of branded residences? What is the<br />

typical target rental return and capital appreciation?<br />

It all depends, it’s entirely a different universe<br />

for HNWI buyers. HNWIs often view trophy<br />

assets defined by location, brand and quality of<br />

development. It may be a second home or investment<br />

versus traditional yield-focused buyers.<br />

“Currently across<br />

Southeast Asia, there<br />

is an estimated 94<br />

mainstream hotel<br />

residence projects<br />

with more than 21,000<br />

units on line, with 78<br />

properties expected to<br />

complete between 2018<br />

and 2020, representing<br />

an 83% increase over<br />

current inventory.”<br />

It seems like SEA is Bill Barnett<br />

experiencing a boom.<br />

Do you think there will be an oversupply in the<br />

coming years given this exponential growth?<br />

Supply and demand track the overall real estate<br />

market and there remains strong sustained growth<br />

in the region, but there are some exceptions.<br />

Vietnam with between 20,000 to 30,000 condo<br />

projects comes to mind as potentially being<br />

oversupplied.<br />

What is the outlook for branded residences in Asia<br />

in the next 3 years?<br />

More and greater diversity in real estate grade from<br />

luxury to entry level. Even budget chain YOTEL is<br />

talking branded residences.<br />

How is the situation in China given the increasing<br />

number of HNWIs there and their propensity to<br />

buy branded goods including residences?<br />

China is likely to still experience growth given the<br />

government restriction on exporting capital; domestic<br />

investment into property is likely to remain active.


28 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW COVER STORY<br />

DESIGNING<br />

A BRANDED<br />

RESIDENCE<br />

Asian Property Review talks to Arianna Leopard<br />

(Director) and Bruce Wright (Senior Vice President<br />

and Principal) from SB Architects on what it entails to<br />

design branded residences.<br />

Ocean Drive Residences<br />

1. How important is design for branded<br />

residences? How different would you<br />

approach a branded residence compared<br />

with say, a typical serviced apartment<br />

or condominium?<br />

All brand owners set guidelines<br />

and design specification to<br />

architects and developers so that<br />

they accurately reflect the brands<br />

down to the smallest details.<br />

We approach the design of<br />

branded residential differently<br />

than traditional serviced<br />

apartment. The unit sizes are<br />

generally larger than nonbranded<br />

equivalents,<br />

reflecting the trophy<br />

positioning.<br />

Branded<br />

residential<br />

needs to have a<br />

high-degree of<br />

personalization<br />

and the accent<br />

is on interiors<br />

that tag the<br />

buyer’s lifestyle and wrap around emotion and<br />

feelings. We seamlessly merge architecture,<br />

interior design, and lifestyle in a way that<br />

speaks to the aspirations of the buyer. Branded<br />

Residential uniquely differs from unbranded<br />

real estate in that the buyer of a branded<br />

property becomes a stakeholder in the brand.<br />

Usually the access to ownership comes at a<br />

higher cost, but the return is a deep emotional<br />

connection to the brand philosophy, culture<br />

and often the related hotel amenities.<br />

2. What are examples of the branded residences<br />

that you have designed? What are each of<br />

their unique characteristics?<br />

We have worked on several Ritz-Carlton<br />

properties over the years including Dorado<br />

Beach, A Ritz-Carlton Reserve, Ritz-<br />

Carlton, Rancho Mirage and The Cove, Ritz-<br />

Carlton Reserve Residences. We are working<br />

on two St. Regis properties, which will both<br />

include a residential component. For St.<br />

Regis Bahia Beach, we designed the Ocean<br />

Drive Residences and a series of custom<br />

estate homes.<br />

Arianna Leopard


May - June 2018<br />

29<br />

b<br />

DORADO BEACH, A RITZ-<br />

CARLTON RESERVE RESIDENCES,<br />

PUERTO RICO<br />

b<br />

These luxurious waterfront residences follow<br />

the contours of the beach to provide the most<br />

complete and private beachfront experience<br />

imaginable. The three and four-story<br />

structures feature two and three-bedroom<br />

units with a rooftop pool and covered living<br />

space. Some buildings include a fourthlevel<br />

penthouse with terraces on three<br />

sides to provide outdoor living space to all<br />

three bedroom suites. Expansive terraces or<br />

balconies for each unit connect to the indoor<br />

living spaces with retractable doors.<br />

OCEAN DRIVE RESIDENCES AT<br />

BAHIA BEACH<br />

Bahia Beach offers the tranquility and purity<br />

of a private island amid an unspoiled, lush<br />

tropical haven with spectacular beachfront<br />

views. These three- and four-bedroom<br />

residences are serviced by The St Regis and<br />

feature spacious interiors, ample terraces, etc.<br />

b<br />

Ocean Drive Residences<br />

LIHU COLD SPRINGS GOLF<br />

ESTATES, HAINAN ISLAND, CHINA<br />

This expansive resort development is sited<br />

along the shores of NanLiHu Lake, a<br />

stunning jewel on Hainan Island near the<br />

city of Haikou. Encompassing 122 ha, the<br />

master plan utilizes the site’s hilly topography<br />

to weave the golf fairways through existing<br />

valleys. Residences, lodging and public<br />

spaces are sited to capitalize on views of<br />

the golf course and lake. Residences range<br />

from single-family villas, to townhomes, to<br />

apartments in five and six-storey buildings.


The Lodges at Calistoga Ranch<br />

were formed around the trees,<br />

with many lodge terraces built<br />

with ancient trees growing up<br />

through the terraces.<br />

construction methods, which generally also<br />

makes financial sense. Combining destination<br />

specific material choices, and working so<br />

closely with these branded design details we<br />

can create properties that both embrace local<br />

qualities and exemplify the aesthetics of the<br />

brand owners.<br />

ONE St Petersburg<br />

3. How much of the local materials or culture<br />

do you appropriate for the design despite the<br />

typical standardization of such designs? Do<br />

the design owners e.g. hotel or luxury brands<br />

allow any deviation from their standard<br />

cookie cutter design?<br />

Our process begins with a deep respect<br />

for the site, the history of the land and the<br />

culture of its people. We are fully aware that<br />

to create authentic destinations, we must<br />

preserve the elements that have drawn us<br />

there in the first place.<br />

We always like to work with topography<br />

and use materials indigenous to the location.<br />

Developers in Asia can be somewhat<br />

pragmatic about introducing new materials,<br />

but we try to tie the design back to the history<br />

of the site, utilizing sustainable design and<br />

4. What sustainable features or construction<br />

methods/materials do you employ in your<br />

designs?<br />

We partner with a broad spectrum of<br />

consultants and certifying organizations to<br />

ensure that we deliver projects that are both<br />

ecologically and socially sustainable. Our<br />

experience working with organizations such<br />

as the USGBC and Audubon International<br />

give us the tools to create unique projects that<br />

live in harmony with their surroundings.<br />

In the initial design phase, we think about<br />

a myriad of elements that will inform our<br />

approach that includes everything from<br />

sunlight aspect placement that allows for<br />

maximum solar orientation for photovoltaic<br />

panels, to passive heating, and cooling<br />

systems. Local availability, recycled content,<br />

and sustainable production drive the selection<br />

of each material, appliance, and detail.


May - June 2018<br />

31<br />

GLOBAL FOOTPRINT<br />

Based in San Francisco, Miami and Shenzhen,<br />

China, SB architects has a global footprint with<br />

projects in China, North America, Lebanon,<br />

Montenegro, Egypt, Puerto Rico and Mexico to<br />

name a few. A recent project that the firm is proud of<br />

is the Miami Design District, which transformed the<br />

once gritty Miami neighbourhood into a glamorous<br />

international luxury shopping destination with two<br />

department stores, rooftop gardens, a boutique hotel<br />

and luxury condominiums. In China, they have just<br />

completed the design work for Luneng Wen’an<br />

winery and resort.<br />

Bruce Wright<br />

For example the Calistoga Ranch in Sonoma,<br />

the site was on a 52-acre California live oak<br />

parcel, and the resort had to be designed<br />

to not despoil or do damage to the ancient<br />

trees present on the site. So, the Lodges at<br />

Calistoga Ranch were formed around the<br />

trees, with many lodge terraces built with<br />

ancient trees growing up through the terraces.<br />

5. What are the branded residences in the<br />

pipeline that you are working on?<br />

100 Las Olas<br />

Most of our resort projects included branded<br />

residential into the program such as St.<br />

Regis Los Cabos at Quivira in Mexico and<br />

Mandarin Oriental in Boca Raton.


32 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

SHOPHOUSES<br />

IN A CLASS OF ITS OWN


May - June 2018<br />

33


34 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

SINGAPORE<br />

SHOPHOUSES<br />

SOUGHT-AFTER TROPHY ASSETS<br />

The allure of the Singapore shophouse goes beyond its architectural<br />

history and aesthetics or even its limited supply; ultimately,<br />

it’s about owning a part of Singapore’s history.<br />

Text & Photography by Jan Yong<br />

A<br />

treasure trove of historical assets are<br />

changing hands at record prices in<br />

Singapore. On 31st March 2018, the<br />

headline in Singapore’s Straits Times<br />

read: “8M buys shophouses, building for $82.5m.”<br />

That averages about SGD10 mil for each shophouse.<br />

In land-scarce Singapore, landed properties are<br />

priced at a massive premium and this naturally<br />

applies to all shophouses particularly conservation or<br />

heritage shophouses.<br />

Conservation shophouses are heritage buildings<br />

that were given conservation status by the Urban<br />

Redevelopment Authority of Singapore (URA),<br />

says Simon Monteiro, Associate Director at Savills<br />

Singapore specialising in heritage buildings. “There<br />

are about 8,900 estimated buildings in primary and<br />

secondary areas that are gazetted. This means their<br />

façade needs to be maintained. For those located<br />

in the primary core areas such as Boat Quay, Amoy<br />

Street, Telok Ayer Street and Boon Tat Street,<br />

you can’t do much to them whereas you could still<br />

increase a few levels to 4-5 storeys for those in the<br />

secondary areas.”<br />

Due to their very limited number, the heritage<br />

shophouses command an even bigger premium and<br />

are sought after by real estate funds, family offices,<br />

foreign companies specialising in design, finance,<br />

investment and business consultancy as well as Ultra<br />

High Net Worth Individuals (UHNWIs) – from<br />

Singapore and abroad.<br />

Simon Monteiro<br />

Examples of funds include 8M Real Estate, Silk<br />

Road Partners, Clifton Real Estate & Arc Assets.<br />

Heritage shophouses in Singapore are equivalent<br />

to rare vintage collectibles – they are collected due<br />

to their intrinsic historical and cultural as well<br />

as artistic value. There is also the advantage of<br />

staggering capital appreciation due to their limited<br />

quantity. “The high net worth buyers don’t buy them<br />

for rental returns because the return is dismal, falling<br />

from 7 – 8% back in the 1980s to about 2 -3 % these<br />

days,” Monteiro reveals.<br />

The inverse relationship of skyrocketing capital<br />

appreciation to falling rental yield can be explained<br />

by the fact that there are comparatively many more


A number of heritage shophouses have been<br />

converted into boutique hotels. This one in<br />

Kampong Glam sports a very captivating facade.<br />

buyers than tenants for these heritage shophouses.<br />

The high net worth buyers have the holding power<br />

and can keep the shophouses without even renting<br />

them out. Meanwhile, tenants are not as many due<br />

to the high rentals commanded by these soughtafter<br />

units. It takes a very profitable business to<br />

survive these rents.<br />

During a survey in the tourist areas of Kampong<br />

Glam, Haji Lane and Arab Street where there is a<br />

proliferation of these heritage shophouses, Asian<br />

Property Review saw a handful of upper floor units<br />

being advertised for rental while there were none<br />

observed for sale.<br />

Prices have been rising steadily in the last 10 to 15<br />

years. In 2005, a 99-year leasehold in Duxton Hill<br />

area will cost about $380 psf. “Today, these streets<br />

are sought after and command prices above $2,000<br />

psf based on the estimated built-up area of 3,500 sq<br />

ft to 5,000 sq ft,” says Monteiro.<br />

“I remember selling 3 assets in Duxton Hill in 2005<br />

- 28 Duxton Hill and 20/21 Duxton Hill - for $6.1<br />

mil for all 3; today you have to pay about 7 to 8<br />

times as much,” Monteiro continues.<br />

“Prices of freehold units are even higher, going from<br />

$600 psf in 2005 to an estimated $3,500 psf in<br />

today’s market.”<br />

Due to their very limited number, the<br />

heritage shophouses command an even<br />

bigger premium and are sought after by<br />

real estate funds, family offices, foreign<br />

companies specialising in design,<br />

finance, investment and business<br />

consultancy as well as Ultra High Net<br />

Worth Individuals (UHNWIs) – from<br />

Singapore and abroad.<br />

- Monteiro<br />

FOREIGN FACTOR<br />

Despite the sky high prices, buyers are literally lining<br />

up to buy them. Among them are foreigners.<br />

“In general, the price increase over the last 20 years<br />

was due to the economy, scarcity, heritage, the unique<br />

Singapore theme and an increasingly affluent society.<br />

A notable factor is also the influx of UHNWIs from<br />

abroad looking at shophouses as a unique alternative<br />

asset to condominiums and common office spaces in<br />

normal office buildings,” Monteiro notes.<br />

The fact that the government promotes locations<br />

such as Chinatown, Little India and Kampong Glam<br />

also helps to bring in the crowds which increases the<br />

value of the shophouses there.


36 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

Most owners don’t want to sell<br />

even if a very attractive offer comes<br />

along. This is because they want to<br />

keep the shophouses as an asset for<br />

future generations.<br />

– Han<br />

Vanz Han Liang Siew<br />

Richard Tan Kah Peng<br />

The only restriction for foreigners is that the<br />

shophouses must be designated commercial<br />

properties located in fully commercial zones.<br />

Foreigners can have 100% ownership and the tenure<br />

can be freehold or leasehold of variable years. The<br />

most popular tenure especially among Indonesians<br />

and Malaysians is for the 999-year lease which is<br />

effectively a freehold title.<br />

“In my opinion, we have about 3,000 to 3,500 units<br />

that a foreigner can safely buy without the need for<br />

paying Additional Buyer Stamp Duty (ABSD) or<br />

the need to get approval from the Land Dealings<br />

Unit, a department that controls land ownership on<br />

land which is zoned landed residential,” the heritage<br />

assets specialist continues.<br />

“The rest are either fully residential or mix<br />

residential /commercial, the sale of which are<br />

restricted to Singaporeans and companies with<br />

Singaporean directors only.”<br />

“As with antiques, beauty and passion lie in the eyes<br />

of the beholder. There is no right time to buy as<br />

it’s more of an emotional buy; the buyer values the<br />

architectural history and aesthetics and wants to own<br />

a piece of Singapore history and maybe be part of our<br />

diverse culture,” Monteiro adds.<br />

DEMAND OUTSTRIPS SUPPLY<br />

For shophouses that have not been gazetted as<br />

conservation or heritage, demand similarly outstrips<br />

supply but in this case, the rental yield is an<br />

important consideration, says Richard Tan Kah Peng<br />

from PropNex (Richard Tan & Associates). “Most<br />

buyers are looking at good yield. Their greatest fear is<br />

that they can’t rent out.”<br />

“To determine yield, it’s crucial to look at the lease<br />

tenure – the balance remaining on the lease if it’s<br />

not 999 years or freehold. For example, even if the<br />

yield is high but if the balance lease is only 20 years,<br />

then it’s not worth buying because you will have to<br />

renew the lease at the expiry and this is subject to the<br />

government or private owner’s approval,” Tan explains.<br />

On the other hand, even if the yield is a low 2%, it<br />

is almost certain that after 50 years, the yield will<br />

rise. In other words, if the tenure is longer, you will<br />

definitely break even eventually, he concludes.<br />

In terms of yield, the rate differs on every floor. A<br />

popular location is Lorong Haji which can fetch<br />

SGD8-10 psf for the ground floor and less for the<br />

upper floor.<br />

Chinese-style shophouses at Short Street.<br />

A savvy investor will also look at the tenant profile.<br />

If it’s a new tenant, they might not survive the rental


May - June 2018<br />

37<br />

Around Haji Lane and Arab Street, a lot of the corner shophouses showcase<br />

murals on their exterior walls.Tourists love taking their photos there.<br />

while a famous or popular tenant will command a<br />

better rental rate.<br />

Without a doubt, the most popular and expensive<br />

shophouses are those located in the CBD area in<br />

Districts 1 and 2, as well as Districts 9 and 10. The<br />

latter comprises a lot of mixed developments, prime<br />

shopping areas like Orchard and River Valley road,<br />

Holland Road where a lot of middle to upper class<br />

residents and expatriates are staying.<br />

“Tourist areas such as District 7 comprising<br />

Kampung Glam, Arab Street, Little India and<br />

Chinatown are also popular as the footfall is high,”<br />

says Vanz Han Liang Siew of Propnex (Vanz Han<br />

& Associates).<br />

“Transaction volume has fallen but the price has<br />

gone up. This is because there is more demand than<br />

supply. Transactions peaked in 2012 – 2013 with<br />

about 200 – 300 transactions a year but since the<br />

last 2 years, it has hovered around 200 transactions<br />

In recent years, buyers from China,<br />

Indonesia, Hong Kong, Malaysia<br />

and Europe, and even a handful from<br />

Vietnam, Thailand and Mynamar have<br />

snapped them up – some even buying a<br />

few in a row.<br />

– Tan<br />

per year. Most owners don’t want to sell even if a<br />

very attractive offer comes along. This is because they<br />

want to keep the shophouses as an asset for future<br />

generations,” Han observes.<br />

“Between 2014 – 2016, the transaction volume fell<br />

to about 100 transactions a year but in 2017, there<br />

were 148 transactions with visibly more Malaysian<br />

participation. In the first quarter of 2018, the<br />

increased volume continues and we foresee the total<br />

number of transactions for the whole of 2018 might<br />

surpass that of 2017,” predicts Tan.


38 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

… even if the yield is high but if<br />

the balance lease is only 20 years,<br />

then it’s not worth buying because<br />

you will have to renew the lease<br />

at the expiry and this is subject to<br />

the government or private owner’s<br />

approval.<br />

– Tan<br />

higher while for 2 or 3-storey, the lower per sq foot<br />

price of the upper floors will reduce the overall price<br />

of the entire shophouse,” adds Han.<br />

In some cases however, the ground floor and the<br />

upper floor units might have separate titles and<br />

owners, hence the buyer might only be able to buy<br />

one floor – obviously the ground floor is more in<br />

demand and can command a higher price due to its<br />

higher footfall.<br />

There are also shophouses where the ground floor<br />

is designated commercial but the upper floor is<br />

designated residential. If the entire shophouse is held<br />

under one title deed, then foreigners aren’t allowed to<br />

buy these at all.<br />

The 5-foot walkway along Kandahar Street, Kampung Glam<br />

Also, the Singapore economy is picking up so a lot<br />

of sellers are holding up for a higher price. At the<br />

same time, there are a lot of en bloc sales going on<br />

with new launches expected to scale higher prices.<br />

“We expect to see new launches hitting new levels<br />

of high,” Han anticipates.<br />

There is no doubt shophouses are facing boom time<br />

prices – for example, a 999-year old ground floor<br />

unit in Bugis Cube is selling for SGD10,000 psf<br />

while in Alexandria, a ground floor unit was sold<br />

at SGD9,000 psf even though it is only a 99-year<br />

leasehold of a new development.<br />

“For Kampong Glam (conservation shophouses),<br />

you have to see whether it is a one-storey, double<br />

or 3-storey shophouse. If purely only one storey<br />

ground floor, the per square foot price will be<br />

BUYING BINGE<br />

In recent years, buyers from China, Indonesia, Hong<br />

Kong, Malaysia and Europe, and even a handful<br />

from Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar have snapped<br />

them up – with some even buying a few in a row.<br />

Asians far outnumber the Europeans, especially<br />

those from China and Indonesia although last year<br />

saw quite a number of UHNWIs from Malaysia on<br />

a buying spree, Tan reveals.<br />

For foreigners with that kind of deep pockets, it’s<br />

the most natural alternative asset after residential<br />

properties. Singapore is considered a safe haven by<br />

HNWIs and these shophouses have great potential<br />

for long-term capital appreciation which fit their<br />

strategy of wealth building and leaving a legacy for<br />

their next generation. There is also the advantage of<br />

political stability and a strong currency.<br />

Another plus point is the flexibility of usage as<br />

compared to the pure office space or retail space


May - June 2018<br />

39<br />

TIPS FOR FOREIGN<br />

BUYERS<br />

Tan and Han from PropNex recommend the following:<br />

Dr Julian Davison<br />

in office buildings or mall respectively. If the<br />

shophouse has 3 or 4 storeys, you can have a<br />

gym or consultancies on the upper floors while<br />

the lower floor can be used for spas or F & B<br />

businesses such as restaurants, bakeries or bars.<br />

F&b businesses are the most sought after tenants<br />

due to their perceived viability and the fact that<br />

F&B is one business that still requires a physical<br />

presence while retail is gradually moving to the<br />

online space through e-commerce.<br />

On top of that, most of the conservation shophouses<br />

are located in prime city centre areas such as<br />

Chinatown, Little India, etc. The capital appreciation<br />

that can be expected is staggering. How high it can<br />

go is anybody’s guess – as long as the government<br />

does not restrict sales to foreigners and as long<br />

as no further shophouses are given conservation<br />

status, the 8,900 shophouses will continue to rise<br />

in value notwithstanding the ups and downs of the<br />

Singaporean property market.<br />

Clearly, the market gyrations have little effect on<br />

the conservation shophouse value due to its limited<br />

number and historical value – every shophouse has<br />

a different history and that adds further value to<br />

the individual shophouse. This can be attested by<br />

Dr Julian Davison who has studied shophouses in<br />

Singapore and has written a book about it called<br />

simply ‘Singapore Shophouse’. It’s a compelling read<br />

particularly for those thinking about investing in one.<br />

1. Some shophouses have commercial title for the<br />

ground floor while the upper floors have residential<br />

strata titles. In such cases, the foreigner can only<br />

buy the ground floor. If however, the entire unit is<br />

held under one title including the residential upper<br />

floor, then the foreigner can’t buy any portion of the<br />

unit at all.<br />

2. It’s better to use a company to buy and to register<br />

the company as a GST-registered company to<br />

purchase those units with GST. They can then claim<br />

back the 7% GST if their company is GST-registered.<br />

3. Use an investment holding company to buy 100% of<br />

the shares of the company owning the commercial<br />

properties e.g. shophouse. This will save you the<br />

3% stamp duty for purchase of the shophouse.<br />

Instead, you pay only 0.2% of the transfer tax. Your<br />

company is also exempted from the 15% additional<br />

buyers’ tax. Foreigners can own 100% shares of a<br />

Singapore-incorporated company. The corporate<br />

tax is 17% maximum while for individuals, it can be<br />

over 20%. Note: this is only applicable to purchasing<br />

commercial properties under company name.<br />

4. Property tax for commercial property is subject to a<br />

ceiling of 10% unlike residential which can go up to<br />

16% for both individuals and companies.<br />

5. Tenure – sometimes it’s better to buy a leasehold in<br />

a high traffic area despite a relatively short balance<br />

on the lease rather than a freehold in a quiet area.<br />

This is because commercial property is all about<br />

location and rental. The leasehold may command<br />

higher rentals than the freehold due to its prime<br />

location. If the rental is higher, then the capital<br />

value will also go up.<br />

6. Proximity to the MRT station helps; it is a bonus<br />

point when buying property.


40 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

THE SINGAPORE SHOPHOUSE<br />

WINDOW TO THE<br />

PAST & FUTURE<br />

Simon Monteiro, Associate Director at Savills Singapore specialises in<br />

heritage buildings especially shophouses and boutique hotels. He was a witness<br />

to the great Singapore Shophouse Investing phenomenon from the<br />

beginning and hopes to be part of its future as well. Here, he narrates his<br />

experience as a witness as well as a participant of the ongoing story.<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

“When I was 12 years old, I used to follow<br />

my grandmother to work. She worked at The<br />

Mission to Seamen which was housed in a<br />

shophouse at 219 River Valley Road which also<br />

contains a small chapel. Shophouses have intrigued<br />

me since then. (In 2001, a week after the 911 attack<br />

on the World Trade Centre, they decided to sell the<br />

shophouse which has a total area of 4,500 sq ft for<br />

SGD950K to a couple.)<br />

When I started my career back in 1994, my first sale<br />

was a beautiful 5,500-sq-ft residential shophouse<br />

at 55 Spottisowoode Park Road, which I sold for<br />

SGD1.6 mil to a doctor.<br />

Between 1997- 2001, I was attached with Goldhill<br />

Group of Companies. It was a lucky break. They<br />

were the pioneers in Conservation Shophouses.<br />

The late Mr William Goei, whom I worked for,<br />

is the ‘Father of Investing in Shophouses’, in my<br />

opinion. Between 1988 and 2007, he purchased,<br />

restored and refurbished many shophouses in the<br />

Duxton and Tanjong Pagar area. He later sold<br />

them for a profit.<br />

ORIGIN OF THE SINGAPORE<br />

SHOPHOUSE<br />

In 1819 with the founding of Singapore by Sir<br />

Stamford Raffles, what was once a small fishing<br />

village, grew to become an entreport. Various culture<br />

and ethnic groups came and this brought about a<br />

mix of different people working to create Singapore<br />

into a trading hub.<br />

Raffles saw the need to segregate the various ethnic<br />

groups into separate areas. So today thanks to<br />

him, we have Little India, Chinatown, Kampong<br />

Glam, and Arab Street. People from parts of China,<br />

the Middle East, Java, and India started arriving<br />

and brought with them the different styles of<br />

architecture that would later be infused into today’s<br />

Singapore shophouses.<br />

The government started looking into conservation<br />

in the 1970s but it was not until the late 1980s that<br />

they decided to take action to create a conservation<br />

plan for Singapore. The first Sale of Site by the<br />

government was in Duxton, Duxton Hill, Tanjong<br />

Pagar and Neil Road area.


May - June 2018<br />

41<br />

Simon<br />

Monteiro<br />

This was in 1988 and it started the movement of<br />

the Singapore Shophouse. These shophouses were<br />

later refurbished. They were cheap, maybe $200psf<br />

and were later sold at $400psf in 2005 and now it’s<br />

$2,200psf on average for a 99-yr Leasehold.<br />

The floor plate is typically 2/3/4-storey with a land<br />

size of 1,000 sq ft to 1,500 sq ft. So the built-up of a<br />

typical 2-storey shophouse is 2,000 sq ft to 3,000sqft<br />

which may come with an additional attic which is<br />

anywhere from 200 sq ft to 500 sq ft depending on<br />

the configuration.<br />

So a 2 1/5 Storey will command in today’s market<br />

the price of $7m to $8m for a 99-year leasehold<br />

These 8,900 shophouses are<br />

a window to our past and<br />

they can be used to tell the<br />

Singapore story.<br />

to about between<br />

$9.5m and $11m for<br />

a Freehold/999-Yr<br />

shophouse.<br />

A 3-storey shophouse<br />

with attic would easily go for<br />

$14m - $15m and for a 999-<br />

year freehold unit around $17.5m to<br />

$19m with corner unit having a premium because<br />

it brings better natural lighting and better frontage<br />

for visual advantage.<br />

There is also the 4-storey shophouse with prices<br />

ranging from $17m-$18m for a 99-year leasehold<br />

and more than $20m for a 999-year freehold.<br />

URA has gazetted about 8,900 units with<br />

Conservation status, located within a mix of Primary<br />

Areas and Secondary Areas. Primary areas comprise<br />

mainly the core CBD areas like Amoy Street, Telok<br />

Ayer Street and Boon Tat Street.


42 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

coffeeshop style of operations in Tanjong Pagar,<br />

Duxton and Tras Street.<br />

The URA then started regulating pub licenses and<br />

outlawed massage parlours in this area. This created<br />

a better tenant mix of upmarket businesses such as<br />

consultancies, hedge funds, family offices and fund<br />

investment houses which started coming in from<br />

2010. Today, in addition to those, you have a great<br />

mix of entertainment outlets and co-working spaces.<br />

The F & B units that were on the ground floor were<br />

also paying better rentals and this gave investors<br />

the motivation to spend on the refurbishments.<br />

One of my clients who is a Hong Kong permanent<br />

resident, started buying up some shoplots there and<br />

refurbishing them with million-dollar uplifts to<br />

the interiors, and the layout. These units became so<br />

pleasing that they attracted better quality tenants<br />

like upmarket restaurants and boutique firms. This<br />

brought in a more affluent crowd.<br />

GENTRIFICATION AND RENTALS<br />

The rental returns are now very low - below 3%<br />

rental to cost of acquisition compared to the 6% to<br />

7% rental yield in 2005. The rental have not gone up<br />

as much as the capital appreciation.<br />

HOSPITALITY-INCLINED<br />

I also sold The Duxton Hotel to a client who<br />

refurbished it into a boutique hotel taking the asset<br />

to the next level of Ultra High Net Places (UHNP),<br />

a word which I coined for heritage assets that have<br />

been refurbished to such an extent that they attract<br />

the most affluent people in our society.<br />

This is due to the high demand for shophouses and<br />

also gentrification. The URA was also looking at<br />

regulating the use of these conservation shophouses.<br />

I believe the start of real gentrification was at the<br />

Duxton / Duxton Hill area which is home to a<br />

beautiful part of Tanjong Pagar where you can view<br />

some very nice architecture of the past. The cobbled<br />

stone walkway up Duxton Hill gives you a sense of<br />

walking on sacred ground. In the 1890s, the street<br />

on Duxton Hill was the Millionaires Row where the<br />

rich peranakans used to live.<br />

Compare this to 2005 when I used to lease<br />

shophouses to many pubs, massage parlours and


May - June 2018<br />

43<br />

The F & B units that were on the<br />

ground floor were also paying better<br />

rentals and this gave investors<br />

the motivation to spend on the<br />

refurbishments.<br />

Along Neil Road, at No: 136/138, Goethe Institute<br />

leased from me years ago. This is one of the finest<br />

works of Swan & Mclaren Architects who in the<br />

late 1920s designed one of the most eye-catching<br />

heritage assets which is still flourishing today with its<br />

architectural ingenuity.<br />

Today, many of the new owners of the Singapore<br />

Shophouses are from real estate funds and UHNWIs<br />

looking at owning great assets that have a bespoke<br />

heritage of the past. Many investors also like to own<br />

hospitality assets with a heritage past.<br />

I sold Naumi Liora recently to 8M Real Estate<br />

while Hotel 1929 was sold to Mr Cheong Koon<br />

Hooi who is also the owner of The Warehouse Hotel.<br />

When I acquired Wanderlust for Mr Loh Lik Peng,<br />

his vision of hospitality gentrification from an old<br />

school to a hip and well known hotel speaks volume<br />

of what one can do to a heritage asset.<br />

I am looking into doing the same in Singapore’s<br />

other heritage streets where we can bring together<br />

buyers who are into heritage, talented architects and<br />

F & B and hospitality entrepreneurs to transform the<br />

streets into a gentrified area attracting tourists and<br />

locals alike.<br />

Working alongside me is Dr Julian Davison who<br />

has written a coffee table book entitled ‘Singapore<br />

Shophouse’, a compelling narrative inclusive of<br />

wonderful photography of the history of the<br />

Singapore shophouse. Dr Davison is an authority on<br />

this heritage asset. Together, we are confident that<br />

the next 10 – 15 years will see more shophouse areas<br />

being gentrified amid growing tourist numbers.<br />

Added to this mix are<br />

the millennials who<br />

started the co-working<br />

and co-living concepts.<br />

We will all come together<br />

for ‘Co-Minding’ sessions<br />

– basically a word I coined<br />

to mean like-minded people<br />

coming together to change the way<br />

the world works.<br />

Closely related to this is Dr Davison’s work<br />

which endeavours to give a story to each of<br />

the heritage shophouse. We are creating a<br />

unique formula to better make use of our built<br />

heritage to showcase our past glories and pains<br />

as our society progresses further. These 8,900<br />

shophouses are a window to our past and they<br />

can be used to tell the Singapore story. ”<br />

9 NEIL ROAD<br />

Between 1987 and 1988, 32 dilapidated<br />

shophouses of a hybrid Hokkien-<br />

Teochew style were restored by the Urban<br />

Redevelopment Authority. This was the first<br />

ever project undertaken by the government<br />

to demonstrate to the private sector that it<br />

was technically possible and commercially<br />

viable to restore Singapore’s heritage<br />

buildings to their former glory. The first unit<br />

to be restored was 9 Neil Road. It was then<br />

converted into a teahouse which hosted<br />

Queen Elizabeth II on her State visit in 1989.<br />

– Source: URA.<br />

Dr Julian Davison


44 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

BUYING HERITAGE<br />

SHOPHOUSES<br />

IN MALAYSIA<br />

Asian Property Review chats with KL See, director of Metro Homes<br />

Sdn Bhd who is also the deputy president of the Malaysian Institute<br />

of Professional Estate Agents and Consultants (MIPEAC) on the<br />

investability of shophouses in Malaysia.<br />

1 Define heritage shophouses in Malaysia.<br />

A heritage shophouse or building is defined under the<br />

National Heritage Act 2005 (ACT 645) as a building<br />

or groups of separate or connected buildings which,<br />

because of their architecture, their homogeneity<br />

or their place in the landscape, are of outstanding<br />

universal value from the point of view of history, art<br />

or science.<br />

It is always the right time to buy<br />

heritage shophouses in Malaysia due<br />

to their limited supply.<br />

2 Given that conservation or heritage shophouses<br />

are a limited asset class, do you think its price<br />

will hold steady and even increase over the years<br />

despite negative factors such as oversupply of new<br />

shophouses or sluggish economic conditions?<br />

Yes, the price will hold steady and a marginal increase<br />

over the years is expected because of its limited<br />

availability. But overall, such shophouses are still<br />

subject to town planning laws, etc. For example,<br />

rules such as traffic flow, parking requirements will<br />

affect the entire area which may contain heritage<br />

shophouses. But these external factors will not have a<br />

major impact on heritage shophouses.<br />

3 Is it the right time now to buy heritage shophouses<br />

in Malaysia? If yes, which are the preferred areas?<br />

Yes, it is always the right time to buy heritage<br />

shophouses in Malaysia due to their limited supply.<br />

Most of the time, the unit is sold even before it<br />

reaches the market as there is always a group of<br />

investor ready to buy it.<br />

Penang, Melaka and Kuala Lumpur are popular<br />

locations but Ipoh is now the new destination for<br />

tourists – be they locals or foreigners.


May - June 2018<br />

45<br />

Jonker street in Malacca is filled with<br />

restored heritage shophouses which<br />

makes it very popular with tourists.<br />

4 Who are mainly the buyers and why do they prefer<br />

heritage shophouses?<br />

The buyers are mainly locals who are already<br />

operating a business in a heritage shophouse or are<br />

planning to do so. Foreigners who buy are those who<br />

appreciate the value of heritage shophouses although<br />

in some cases, they might be put off by the cost of<br />

conservation or renovation.<br />

5 Apart from those doing businesses in heritage<br />

shophouses, why are heritage shophouses not<br />

popular as an investment asset with locals?<br />

Locals don’t see the long term potential value of the<br />

shophouse as they are usually in a bad condition due<br />

to age, say for example, a 100-year-old shophouse.<br />

It is usually 2 storeys only – and furthermore, most<br />

of these are located in the city centre which lacks<br />

parking space and are usually adjacent to narrow<br />

roads. New township shophouses on the other hand<br />

have ample parking spaces.<br />

6 For foreigners, what are the limitations, if any?<br />

The only limitation is the same which applies to all<br />

foreigners e.g. in KL, it has to be RM1 mil or above.<br />

Like any<br />

commercial<br />

property, it is<br />

easy to get a<br />

loan – the only<br />

challenge is the<br />

valuation.<br />

See Kok Loong<br />

7 What is the price range (psf ) for heritage<br />

shophouses in the most sought-after locations and<br />

what was the appreciation like since 2009?<br />

For KL, the price per sq foot varies tremendously for<br />

example, along Jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman alone,<br />

the price can range from RM800 psf to RM8,000 psf<br />

between 2009 - 2017! (See table).<br />

As for Penang, we have many transactions of pre-war<br />

shophouses e.g. 80 transactions for Georgetown alone<br />

from 2009 – 2017. As an example, as per the table, in<br />

Kawasan Jalan Penang, a shop which sold for RM215<br />

psf in 2009 was transacted at RM1,669 psf in 2017.<br />

That’s six times plus increase in appreciation.


46 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

TRANSACTION PRICES OF SHOPHOUSES IN JALAN TUANKU ABDUL RAHMAN 2009 - 2017<br />

Transaction Date Area Address City Category Condition Land Area (Sq Ft) Price Per Sq Ft. (Rm)<br />

3-Oct-17 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No.44, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,537.01 3,211.21<br />

4-Jan-17 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No.153, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,098.96 8,099.25<br />

28-Aug-15 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 497, Jln Tuanku Abd.rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,884.87 1,782.62<br />

24-Aug-15 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 217, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,292.71 6,106.31<br />

10-Oct-14 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 520, Jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,095.93 858.81<br />

20-May-14 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 47, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,472.91 4,043.82<br />

3-Jun-13 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 346, Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,002.09 499.48<br />

27-Aug-12 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 3, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,995.93 3,206.53<br />

30-Nov-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 319, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,999.93 1,000.03<br />

28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />

28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />

28-Jul-11 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 120,120a-d, Jln Tuanku Abd Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,752.94 2,738.25<br />

23-Dec-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 442,jln Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,997.93 825.85<br />

11-Nov-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 502,jalan Tar Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,883.68 849.40<br />

11-Nov-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman No. 504,jalan Tar / Jln Ipoh Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,878.46 851.76<br />

12-Oct-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 358,jalan Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 2,002.09 549.43<br />

6-Mar-09 Jalan Tuanku Abd Rahman 501,jln Tuanku Abdul Rahman Kuala Lumpur, Bandar Kuala Lumpur Perdagangan Pre War 1,838.94 1,141.96<br />

Transaction Date Area Address Location Category Condition Land Area (Sq Ft) Price Per Sq Ft. (Rm)<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 41, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 39, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 33, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,044.10 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 35, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 37, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 43, Jln Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 47, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 979.51 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 49, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 53, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 656.60 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 45, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 1,669.97<br />

13-Oct-17 Kawasan Jalan Penang 55, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,108.68 1,669.97<br />

29-Jul-15 Kawasan Jalan Penang 212, Jln Transfer Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 2,143.92 704.32<br />

10-Mar-15 Kawasan Jalan Penang 18, Lebuh Dickens Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,421.95 1,406.52<br />

14-Apr-14 Kawasan Jalan Penang 133, Jln Hutton Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 3,288.89 851.35<br />

13-Mar-14 Kawasan Jalan Penang 107, Hutton Lane Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 723.98 897.81<br />

20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 326, Jalan Penang Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 850.35 215.36<br />

20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 322, Jalan Penang Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 904.17 215.4<br />

20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 324, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 215.53<br />

20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 318, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 957.99 215.45<br />

20-Feb-13 Kawasan Jalan Penang 320, Penang Road Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 925.70 217.84<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 55, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,108.68 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 53, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 656.60 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 51, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 764.24 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 47, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 979.51 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 45, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 41, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 49, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 882.64 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 43, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 39, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 37, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 35, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 990.28 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 33, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 1,044.10 215.43<br />

18-May-09 Kawasan Jalan Penang 31, Jalan Phee Choon Timur Laut, George Town Perdagangan Pre War 14,025.36 215.43<br />

Source: JPPH


May - June 2018<br />

47<br />

8 How is the rental yield?<br />

Rental yield is not high - usually around 2-3% and<br />

this is also one reason why locals are not so interested<br />

because the cost of fund is higher as compared to<br />

Singapore and Hong Kong which is below 2%.<br />

After the repeal of the Rent Control Act 1966 in<br />

1997, although owners of pre-war shophouses could<br />

increase their rentals, by then many local tenants<br />

prefer townships outside of KL city centre.<br />

As for Penang and Melaka, the story is a bit different<br />

because some core city centre areas of Georgetown<br />

and Melaka were designated as UNESCO heritage<br />

sites. This attracted a lot of tourists - continuous<br />

government promotion of local tourism and social<br />

media also contributed to the interest in shophouses<br />

there. As a result, there were a lot of transactions in<br />

those areas in the last 10 years.<br />

A row of restored shophouses in Penang.<br />

9 Are newly built shophouses a competition in terms<br />

of price and rental yield?<br />

Newly built shophouses are targeted at a different<br />

market now - the yield is higher and it usually has<br />

more floors such as 4-5 storeys as compared to the<br />

2-storey heritage shophouses.<br />

For KL, the price per sq foot varies<br />

tremendously for example, along Jalan<br />

Tuanku Abdul Rahman alone, the price<br />

can range from RM800 psf to RM8,000<br />

psf between 2009 - 2017!<br />

10 Why are boutique hotels and eateries such popular<br />

businesses in heritage shophouses?<br />

These businesses have a lifestyle element where<br />

customers have the time to appreciate and live in<br />

to understand more about the heritage building.<br />

It is unlike selling groceries where the shopper is<br />

more concerned about the price and then move on.<br />

Retailing is also not popular due to the popularity of<br />

e-commerce – it’s not able to survive the high cost of<br />

heritage buildings.<br />

11 Is it easy to get a loan to purchase heritage<br />

shophouses? Can foreigners obtain such a loan?<br />

Yes, like any commercial property, it is easy to get a<br />

loan – the only challenge is the valuation. The bank’s<br />

panel of valuers would be adding the restoration<br />

cost into the loan amount, etc. As every building<br />

condition is different, each case is approved on a case<br />

by case basis.<br />

Can foreigners get a loan? Yes but at a lower margin.<br />

In any case, I believe most foreigners come in with a<br />

bigger capital and big operation plans like running a<br />

designer hotel.<br />

12 What is your advice for foreign investors interested<br />

in buying a heritage shophouse in Malaysia? Are<br />

there any downsides or risks?<br />

Foreign investors must come in with a plan and must<br />

be familiar with the town planning rules as well as get<br />

all the required approvals and permits.<br />

The downside is that if the area is not popular, then<br />

it is harder to resell. So, it is better for the foreigners<br />

to group together or on their own buy and develop<br />

not just one unit but the entire row of heritage<br />

shophouses; or restore the entire street, if need be.<br />

Only then can it have an impact and attract tourists<br />

and locals alike with its eateries and fine dining<br />

restaurants, etc.


50 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

“HOW I<br />

BOUGHT MY<br />

FIRST FLAT<br />

IN TOKYO”<br />

Canadian property author cum entrepreneur<br />

Christopher Dillon narrates how he bought his first<br />

apartment in Tokyo.<br />

Christopher Dillon<br />

CONCRETE ACTION<br />

Back in May 2010, it was time to use what I had learned<br />

when researching on my book on how to navigate through<br />

the Complexities of Japanese Real Estate. I decided to buy<br />

an apartment in Tokyo. With Erik Oskamp, an agent I had<br />

met while researching my book, I spent the afternoon of<br />

September 30, 2010, looking at apartments in Nakano-ku,<br />

in Tokyo’s western suburbs, and in Itabashi-ku, Adachiku<br />

and Katsushika-ku in the north.<br />

The apartments were 16–42 sqms in size and 22–36 years<br />

old. Some buildings had hundreds of units, while others had<br />

fewer than 40, and the group included buildings made of<br />

steel-reinforced concrete as well as steel frame construction.<br />

All were priced at less than ¥6 million and served by a train<br />

or subway line, although one apartment was a 20-minute<br />

walk from the nearest station. In Japan, prospective buyers<br />

cannot view the inside of tenanted apartments. But we were<br />

able to walk around the neighbourhoods, some of which<br />

were quasi-industrial. Overflowing mailboxes indicated<br />

buildings with high vacancy rates, while rust stains and<br />

peeling paint suggested maintenance problems.<br />

I short-listed three apartments and, on October 1, made an<br />

offer for one in Itabashi-ku. The offer, which was 5% less<br />

than the asking price, was rejected, and I subsequently met<br />

the original ¥4.2 million asking price. When that offer was<br />

accepted, I started doing the paperwork, which included a<br />

notarized declaration that I was not a resident of Japan.<br />

I also signed two powers of attorney, one authorizing Erik’s<br />

company to purchase the apartment on my behalf and<br />

a second enabling a judicial scrivener, Kawanabe-san, to<br />

register the property in my name. Erik also began the due<br />

diligence process to ensure that there were no problems with<br />

the building, title or tenant.<br />

SIMPLE PROCEDURE<br />

Located in Tokyo’s Itabashi-ku, this apartment was built in<br />

1974 from steel-reinforced concrete. This was followed by<br />

two video chat sessions on Skype. One was with Kawanabesan,<br />

who needed to verify my identity and confirm that I was<br />

buying the property. The second was with Wakabayashi-san,<br />

a licensed real estate agent employed by Erik’s company, who<br />

read me the explanation of important matters.<br />

The recitation took 70 minutes and degenerated into<br />

comedy when the agent told me that the tenant, a retired<br />

civil servant, “had a problem with his waist.” I asked for<br />

clarification, wondering if he was confined to a wheelchair<br />

or if there was a trash-related problem. After consulting<br />

a dictionary and much discussion among the office staff,<br />

Wakabayashi-san told me that the tenant had a severe<br />

case of hemorrhoids, which was the reason he had retired.<br />

The sale closed on November 15, 2010, and the tenant has<br />

remained in the apartment.<br />

Built in 1974 from steel-reinforced concrete, the unit is 21<br />

sqms in size, plus a six-square-meter balcony. The apartment


May - June 2018<br />

51<br />

is adjacent to the Shuto Expressway and is a 10-minute<br />

walk to the Mita subway line, from where it is 30 minutes to<br />

central Tokyo.<br />

I paid cash for the apartment, which I still own. With all<br />

taxes and fees, the total purchase price was ¥4.6 million. In<br />

2016, the apartment generated revenue of ¥424,701, after<br />

deducting management fees, maintenance charges, repairs<br />

and taxes.<br />

As a non-resident Canadian living in Hong Kong, rental<br />

income from the apartment does not create a tax liability in<br />

Canada or in Hong Kong.<br />

SOME BASICS<br />

If you buy a property with a sitting tenant, you assume the<br />

vendor’s obligation to repay the tenant’s security deposit.<br />

The buyer deducts the tenant’s security deposit from the<br />

purchase price.<br />

Many real estate agents provide property management<br />

services. These range from basic plans to full-service<br />

packages that guarantee the landlord will receive the rent,<br />

even if the tenant doesn’t pay.<br />

The Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act (Act No. 228<br />

of 1949) requires non-residents to file a ‘‘Report Concerning<br />

Acquisition of Real Property in Japan or Rights Related<br />

Thereto,’’ with the Bank of Japan if they buy real estate for<br />

investment purposes. The report must be filed within 20 days<br />

PURCHASE<br />

Purchase price ¥4,200,000<br />

Agent’s fee 195,300<br />

Judicial scrivener’s fee 118,400<br />

Stamp tax 10,000<br />

Acquisition tax 63,500<br />

Total ¥4,587,200<br />

2016 REVENUE<br />

Rent ¥639,000<br />

Management fee (34,506)<br />

Maintenance fee (142,560)<br />

Repairs (4,172)<br />

Fixed assets tax (23,900)<br />

Income tax (9,125)<br />

Total ¥424,737<br />

of the purchase and is not required if the property is used<br />

as a residence for the buyer, his relatives or employees; to<br />

house a business or non-profit business; or if the property<br />

is purchased from another non-resident.<br />

Editor’s Note: This excerpt (with minor edits) can be found in<br />

the author’s second edition of Landed Japan.<br />

Overflowing<br />

mailboxes indicated<br />

buildings with<br />

high vacancy<br />

rates, while rust<br />

stains and peeling<br />

paint suggested<br />

maintenance<br />

problems.<br />

Located in Tokyo’s Itabashi-ku, this apartment was built in 1974 from steel-reinforced concrete.


52 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

LAW NOW ALLOWS<br />

EXTENDED<br />

PERIOD TO<br />

SUE FOR<br />

NEGLIGENCE<br />

The new Malaysian Act extends the limitation period for negligence suits<br />

to either 6 years from the date when the cause of action accrues,<br />

or within three years from the date on which the claimant knew about<br />

the material facts (if that period expires after the 6-year period).<br />

Most people are aware that in court<br />

cases, there is a time limit or time<br />

bar for the aggrieved party (termed<br />

“plaintiff ”) to sue the other party<br />

(“defendant”). In civil cases, the time limit can<br />

be different depending on the subject matter and<br />

who the defendant is. In the case of construction<br />

work, the law in Malaysia currently provides for<br />

the following:<br />

• For actions in simple contract: 6 years from<br />

the date of the breach of contract.<br />

• For actions in tort such as negligence: 6<br />

years from the date when the cause of action<br />

accrues (e.g. when physical damage occurs).<br />

• For latent or hidden damage: 6 years from the<br />

date on which the damage occurred.<br />

It should be noted that, in cases of fraudulent<br />

concealment (i.e. deliberate concealment of<br />

defects), the limitation period does not begin to<br />

run until the fraud is discovered or could have been<br />

discovered with reasonable diligence, according to a<br />

blog on Malaysian laws.<br />

However, the time bar has now been extended in<br />

favour of the claimant following the passing of the<br />

Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018 (the “Act”). It<br />

will become enforceable once it is gazetted within<br />

the next few months.<br />

The Act will extend the maximum period for<br />

eligibility to claim to 15 years. According to Datuk<br />

Prof. Sundra Rajoo, Director of AIAC, (Asian<br />

International Arbitration Centre, formerly known as<br />

the KLRCA), the Act will also extend the limitation<br />

period for negligence suits not involving personal<br />

injuries to either 6 years from the date when the<br />

cause of action accrues, or within three years from<br />

the date on which the claimant knew about the<br />

material facts (if that period expires after the initial<br />

6-year period).<br />

The new section applies to all applicable limitation<br />

periods and not just exclusively construction cases<br />

although the latter forms the bulk of cases where<br />

this new limitation period applies as it involves hard<br />

to discover latent building defects. This also explains<br />

why the maximum length of time the plaintiff can


May - June 2018<br />

53<br />

bring a suit is 15 years – as other items such as<br />

cars or electrical items normally do not have such<br />

a long working life.<br />

Most notably, it will cover latent damages in<br />

construction cases, allowing the buyer a right of<br />

action for damages for negligence from the date of<br />

discovery of the damage (as opposed to the date<br />

when the cause of action arises).<br />

“In other words, the right of action starts from<br />

the date when the buyer discovers the damage<br />

and not from the date of purchase or from the<br />

date of possession,” the AIAC Director says in<br />

his explanatory note to ‘A Bill to Amend the<br />

Limitation Act 1953’.<br />

LATENT DAMAGES TARGETED<br />

Clause 2 of Section 6A of the Bill is intended<br />

to cover latent damages in construction cases.<br />

Under the new section 6A, a buyer can claim<br />

damages within three years from the date when<br />

he/she discovered the damage, regardless of the<br />

fact that on the date of purchase, the damage was<br />

not discoverable through general inspection or<br />

the buyer did not know or could not have been<br />

reasonably expected to know the damages.<br />

“Thus, this Bill will make the parties involved in<br />

a project such as Builder, Architect, Engineer,<br />

Contractor, Subcontractor etc. (“the involved<br />

parties”) liable for damages accrued even after<br />

completion of the project.”<br />

Datuk Prof. Sundra adds that the Bill will have<br />

significant effect on the provision for certificate<br />

of completion and compliance (CCC) under the<br />

Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974.<br />

The CCC provision ensures that a project is<br />

complete and complies with all the requirements<br />

under the existing law. But, since the Bill proposes<br />

the starting time of limitation to be from the date<br />

of discovery of the damage, the involved parties<br />

may be liable even if they have complied with the<br />

provision for CCC.<br />

Datuk Prof. Sundra Rajoo<br />

Any of the involved parties in the<br />

construction process may be liable for<br />

damages at any time after completion<br />

even if the project is CCC-compliant,<br />

provided the action is within a period<br />

of three years from the discovery of<br />

the damages, subject to the overall<br />

maximum of 15 years.<br />

However, he notes that the Act prohibits institution<br />

of any proceeding after 15 years from the date on<br />

which the cause of action first accrued (Section<br />

6(3)). Thus, the buyer has a maximum period of 15<br />

years from the date of occurrence of cause of action<br />

to bring an action for damages.<br />

Given the longer timeframe, the legal expert<br />

anticipates an increase in claims by buyers, perhaps<br />

even an increase in frivolous claims with buyers<br />

taking advantage of the long period of time for any<br />

latent damages to appear.<br />

The big deal is that in future, any of the involved<br />

parties may be liable for the damages at any time<br />

after completion even if the project is CCCcompliant,<br />

provided the action is within a period<br />

of three years from the discovery of the damages,<br />

subject to the overall maximum of 15 years.


54 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

For construction companies and others responsible<br />

for the “building process”, casting doubt on a<br />

buyer’s allegations of becoming aware of the<br />

damage very late will be a key defence, Datuk<br />

Professor Sundra notes.<br />

UNDULY LONG?<br />

The table of comparison below shows that the new<br />

Malaysian Act is actually in line with the laws of<br />

England and Wales; and Singapore.<br />

For the avoidance of doubt, the sole reason why<br />

there are different terms in the table as regards<br />

the moment triggering the limitation period (e.g.<br />

“discovery of breach;” “knowledge of defect,” etc.)<br />

is that these are the expressions used in the specific<br />

laws of the countries in question.<br />

Cracked ceiling/wall which only appeared years after vacant possession was given.<br />

COMPARISON OF LIMITATION PERIODS<br />

JURISDICTION STANDARD LIMITATION PERIOD MAXIMUM ALLOWED PERIOD<br />

Austria<br />

Brazil<br />

California (USA)<br />

Florida (USA)<br />

Germany<br />

Queensland<br />

(Australia)<br />

Russia<br />

Singapore<br />

UAE<br />

UK (England<br />

and Wales)<br />

3 years from discovery of breach.<br />

180 days from knowledge of defect.<br />

10 years from substantial<br />

completion of the improvement.<br />

4 years from knowledge of defect.<br />

3 years from discovery of breach.<br />

6 years from the date on which the<br />

cause of action arose.<br />

3 years from discovery of breach.<br />

6 years from the date the damage<br />

occurred or 3 years from the date<br />

on which the claimant had the<br />

requisite knowledge and the right<br />

to bring such an action.<br />

10 years from the date of delivery.<br />

6 years from the date the damage<br />

occurred or 3 years from the date<br />

on which the claimant had the<br />

requisite knowledge and the right<br />

to bring such an action.<br />

30 years from the date of<br />

cause of action.<br />

5 years from handover.<br />

N/A<br />

10 years from actual<br />

possession by the owner.<br />

N/A<br />

30 years from the date of<br />

cause of action.<br />

10 years from the day the<br />

breach happened.<br />

15 years from the<br />

negligent act or omission.<br />

N/A<br />

15 years from the<br />

negligent act or omission.<br />

Source: AIAC


May - June 2018<br />

55<br />

ILLUSTRATIONS<br />

a. C bought a house from<br />

D in 2000. In 2010, C<br />

discovered a crack which<br />

damaged the walls<br />

badly. A building report<br />

made by a consultant<br />

revealed that the cracks<br />

had appeared in 2002,<br />

two years after C moved<br />

into the house. C has<br />

three years from 2010<br />

to file an action in court<br />

against D for damages.<br />

b. C bought a house from<br />

D in 2000. In 2006, C<br />

discovered a crack which<br />

damaged the walls badly.<br />

A building report made<br />

by a consultant revealed<br />

that the cracks had<br />

appeared in 2002, two<br />

years after C moved into<br />

the house. C has three<br />

years from 2006 to file an<br />

action in court against D<br />

for damages.<br />

c. C bought a house from<br />

D in 2000. In 2005, C<br />

discovered a crack which<br />

damaged the walls badly.<br />

A building report made<br />

by a consultant revealed<br />

that the cracks had<br />

appeared in 2002, two<br />

years after C moved into<br />

the house. C has three<br />

years from 2005 to file an<br />

action in court against D<br />

for damages.<br />

Source: Bill to Amend the Limitation Act 1953<br />

15-YEAR TIME BAR<br />

Notwithstanding the extra 3 years, no<br />

action shall be brought after the expiration<br />

of 15 years from the date on which the<br />

cause of action accrued.<br />

C bought a house from D in<br />

2000. In 2017, C discovered<br />

a crack which damaged<br />

the walls badly. A building<br />

report made by a consultant<br />

revealed that the cracks<br />

had appeared in 2001, one<br />

year after C moved into the<br />

house. C cannot commence<br />

an action because he has<br />

already exceeded the 15-year<br />

limitation period.<br />

Source: Bill to Amend the Limitation Act 1953


56 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

FANCY RETIRING<br />

IN THE PHILIPPINES?<br />

The Philippines is one of the easiest countries in the world to obtain residency<br />

on top of its foreigner-friendly property laws.<br />

For those who are thinking of retiring in<br />

Southeast Asia, apart from Malaysia which<br />

has a very friendly retirement programme,<br />

the next country you should consider is<br />

the Philippines. Apart from its beautiful islands<br />

and beaches – it has about 7,600 islands – the<br />

Philippines has the advantage of friendly people,<br />

good weather and an affordable lifestyle.<br />

However, the affordability may not last long as<br />

the country has been experiencing a property<br />

boom since the last 3 years and according to Nick<br />

Stuart, Founder and Managing Director of https://<br />

exclusivehotproperties.com, the boom is causing “prices<br />

to go up very fast”.<br />

Headquartered in Manila, Stuart’s firm specialises<br />

in investment properties, lifestyle properties and<br />

citizenship or residency services.<br />

Of note is the Philippines’ Special Resident<br />

Retirement Visa (SRRV) which allows foreigners<br />

to gain permanent residence easily without<br />

marriage to a citizen of the Philippines.<br />

The SRRV is overseen by the Philippine<br />

Retirement Authority (PRA), which comes up<br />

with the guidelines.


May - June 2018<br />

57<br />

MINIMUM CASH INVESTMENT<br />

The minimum investment to obtain an SRRV<br />

depends on your age and circumstances. The<br />

PRA lists three cases, each case having a different<br />

minimum investment.<br />

Case 1: Applicant is under 50 years old<br />

Minimum investment: $50,000<br />

Case 2: Applicant is at least 50 years old, but has no<br />

qualifying pension.<br />

Minimum investment: $20,000<br />

Case 3: Applicant is at least 50 years of age and has<br />

a pension of at least $800 per month (single) or<br />

$1000 per month couple.<br />

Minimum investment: $10,000<br />

QUALIFYING INVESTMENTS<br />

• Purchase of condominium unit (60:40 ratio);<br />

• Long term Lease of a house and lot,<br />

condominium or townhouse;<br />

• Construction of a residential unit on a leased<br />

parcel of land;<br />

• Purchase of Proprietary Membership/Golf<br />

shares in golf clubs;<br />

• Deposit into a PRA-approved bank<br />

facilities such as a workout room, a restaurant and a<br />

bar. Basically it amounts to living in a country club.<br />

“If you want to live in a city without living in a<br />

country club type atmosphere, there may also be<br />

PRA-approved condo units. Again, talk to a PRA<br />

officer for details or ask us.”<br />

Suppose you want to avail of the SRRV without<br />

committing yourself to living in a PRA approved<br />

community. What if you want to play at the golf<br />

clubs and tennis courts of such a community without<br />

actually living there? Many of the communities<br />

allow you to buy a “use of facilities” share. What this<br />

means is that for a certain amount of money, you<br />

buy a share in the community which allows you to<br />

use all the facilities without having to live there. A<br />

typical share at a decent community with golf, tennis<br />

and swimming might cost in the neighbourhood of<br />

USD10,000, says Stuart.<br />

“There is one problem however. That USD10,000<br />

investment may not be enough money to qualify<br />

you for the SRRV. As described earlier, depending<br />

Stuart cautions however that one can’t just purchase<br />

any condominium, or construct on any leased land -<br />

it must be a PRA-approved investment.<br />

“You pick out a residential community/facility<br />

approved by the PRA and you buy a share or<br />

lease a condo, which allows you to live and play<br />

in this community. Different communities have<br />

different arrangements. But in all cases, the bottom<br />

line is this: You have to fork out some good<br />

money, usually at least USD50K – USD100K, or<br />

sometimes even more.”<br />

Nick Stuart<br />

What are these communities like? Typically they are<br />

very upscale gated and guarded communities on the<br />

outskirts of a major city. They usually contain a golf<br />

course, tennis courts, a swimming pool and other


58 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

on your circumstances, the minimum investment is<br />

10, 20 or 50 thousand US dollars. If you are in case<br />

3 as described above, your minimum investment<br />

requirement is only $10,000 and the “use of facility”<br />

share may be perfect for you. However, even if your<br />

minimum investment is (for example) USD20,000<br />

dollars, there is no reason you can’t invest $10,000<br />

in your golf share, and another $10,000 in some<br />

other PRA-approved investment.”<br />

BANK DEPOSIT<br />

The PRA gives you another option, for those that<br />

don’t want to live in a PRA community or buy a<br />

PRA-approved country club share. Simply open<br />

up a special PRA bank account in a PRA partner<br />

bank and deposit the appropriate amount of money.<br />

“The banks we recommend would be Citibank or<br />

HSBC,” says Stuart.<br />

He adds, “Suppose your minimum investment is<br />

USD20,000, because you are over 50 but have no<br />

qualifying pension fund, simply open up the PRAapproved<br />

bank account, deposit USD20,000 into<br />

this account and the SRRV is yours! Later, if you<br />

decide you want to buy into golf shares or live in<br />

a PRA-approved residential community, you can<br />

transfer your bank account investment into your<br />

new PRA-approved investment.”<br />

Suppose your minimum<br />

investment is USD20,000,<br />

because you are over 50 but<br />

have no qualifying pension<br />

fund, simply open up the PRAapproved<br />

bank account, deposit<br />

USD20,000 into this account<br />

and the SRRV is yours!<br />

PROS AND CONS OF SRRV<br />

What is the downside of a SRRV visa? “Actually, if<br />

you leave money out of the discussion, there is no<br />

downside. The SRRV visa is a wonderful thing. It is<br />

extremely easy and quick to obtain and there is no<br />

reason to feel pressured into a marriage!”<br />

“The problem with the SRRV is that you have to put<br />

money aside and that money is basically untouchable<br />

so long as you want to keep your SRRV.<br />

“If you buy into a golf share, or you live in a condo<br />

in a residential PRA- approved community, you<br />

can argue that your money is being used towards<br />

a good purpose. However, if you use the bank<br />

account method then that money is just sitting there,<br />

basically in escrow and you can’t touch that money<br />

so long as you want to keep your SRRV.<br />

“What happens if you really need that money? Can<br />

you get it? Yes, but perhaps not immediately. You<br />

have to go to a PRA office and file an application for<br />

release of the funds.<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

“Once the release is approved, you lose your SRRV.<br />

So basically, in the case of a bank account, if you<br />

want to live in the Philippines for the rest of your<br />

life, it’s the equivalent of buying an SRRV for<br />

USD10K or USD20K. I guess the bank account<br />

does make some interest, but I don’t think this<br />

amounts to very much.


May - June 2018<br />

59<br />

Traffic on a road in Makati city in Metro Manila, Philippines. Makati -<br />

business center and one of the 17 cities that make up Metro Manila.<br />

“In the case of a golf share or residence in a condo,<br />

if you want your money back, you have to do<br />

two things. Firstly, you have to find a buyer for<br />

your share, and secondly, you also have to file an<br />

application for release of your investment once a<br />

buyer is found. Of course, as in the case of the bank<br />

account, you will lose your SRRV.”<br />

LAST RESORT – MARRIAGE!<br />

There is one other way to get your money back<br />

without losing permanent residence. Suppose you<br />

come to the Philippines as a single man and invest,<br />

for example, USD20,000 in a PRA bank account.<br />

BUYING PROPERTY IN<br />

THE PHILIPPINES<br />

Stuart recommends Metro Manila especially Makati City and<br />

its neighbour Bonifacio Global City which together produce<br />

49% of the GDP for the whole of the Philippines.<br />

All contracts and legal documents are written in English<br />

while the tenure is freehold.<br />

The property sector in Manila is well regulated allowing the<br />

buyer to have peace of mind that their investment is secure.<br />

In the Philippines, there is no need for a lawyer unlike<br />

most other jurisdictions. Property transactions require only<br />

licenced brokers who may or may not be lawyers, but who<br />

function like lawyers.<br />

Suppose, later you fall in love and decide to marry<br />

a Filipina. Having an SRRV visa does not prevent<br />

you from also applying for a spousal permanent<br />

residence visa. Once you get the Spousal permanent


60 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INVESTMENT<br />

“Once at the office, you will start the application<br />

procedure. Of course make sure you have all<br />

needed documentation such as passports, bank<br />

account information, proof of pension, police<br />

clearance, etc. Don’t err on the side of not bringing<br />

enough. Bring everything with you that could<br />

possibly be of use in the application procedure. As<br />

part the application procedure, you will also have<br />

to take a medical examination.<br />

“If your choice is simply to get an SRRV via bank<br />

deposit, they can help you to do that immediately,<br />

and the SRRV can be in your hands in a relatively<br />

short period of time. If your choice is to find a golf<br />

share or residence, they can probably help you with<br />

that as well.<br />

BENEFITS OF SRRV<br />

Once you are an SRRV holder, it opens the door to<br />

vast opportunities and benefits.<br />

These include (but are not limited to the following):<br />

1. Option to Retire Permanently<br />

• You may live, work and study in the<br />

Philippines<br />

residence visa, you could withdraw your money<br />

from the PRA bank account. You would lose your<br />

SRRV visa, but it would not matter because you<br />

would still be entitled to permanent residence via<br />

your Spousal visa.<br />

PROCEDURE FOR OBTAINING<br />

THE SRRV<br />

“You can do-it-yourself or you can seek advice from<br />

consultants like us. Of course, the latter is preferable<br />

to ensure things go smoothly.”<br />

“Having said that, the PRA officers are extremely<br />

well trained and helpful, and will hold your hand<br />

throughout the whole process. I have even heard<br />

they will pick you up from the airport or your hotel<br />

and bring you to the office.<br />

2. Multiple Entry Privileges<br />

• You may travel outside the Philippines<br />

and re-enter at anytime<br />

3. Exemptions from:<br />

• Income tax over your pension and<br />

annuities;<br />

• Exit and re-entry permits of the Bureau<br />

of Immigration;<br />

• Annual registration requirement of the<br />

Bureau of Immigration;<br />

• Customs Duties and Taxes with regard<br />

to the importation of household goods<br />

and personal effects up to US$7,000.00;<br />

• Travel tax, if your stay in the Philippines<br />

is less than one year from the last entry<br />

date; and<br />

• I-Card


WORLD VIEW<br />

Our EXPERTS give their opinions on selected global hotspots


MALAYSIA<br />

JAPAN


64 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

SWEDISH<br />

VISION IN ASIA<br />

At the end of March, IKEA announced the development of Toppen Shopping Centre,<br />

comprising 1.1 mil sq ft shopping centre seamlessly integrated with IKEA Tebrau in Johor.<br />

Asian Property Review had a chat with Christian Rojkjaer, Managing Director of IKEA<br />

Southeast Asia on its expansion plans and its sustainability and technology aspirations.<br />

1<br />

Where else in Southeast Asia is IKEA SEA<br />

expanding next after Penang and the Philippines?<br />

We are investigating the market potential in Vietnam<br />

and have applied to our franchisor for the rights, so our<br />

ambition is strong but we have no firm plans at this time.<br />

MyTown Shopping Mall at Jalan Cochrane, Kuala Lumpur<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

2<br />

We are working on extending<br />

e-commerce to all of Malaysia and<br />

intend to launch a web shop later<br />

this year.<br />

IKEA takes seriously ‘people and planet’ issues -<br />

please share what are some of these issues?<br />

• We make sustainability a natural part of our<br />

everyday business – taking responsibility for the<br />

impact we have on the environment and all the<br />

people touched by our business (including coworkers<br />

and suppliers.)<br />

• We introduce the IKEA code of ethics, called<br />

IWAY, to all suppliers and work with them to<br />

ensure respect for human rights and fair working<br />

conditions for the many people who work for us<br />

through contracted companies.<br />

• Our sustainability principles are also embedded in<br />

the way we design our buildings, the materials we<br />

choose for construction and the features we include<br />

to help us conserve water, generate renewable<br />

energy, manage waste and more.


May - June 2018<br />

65<br />

Toppen aerial view (artist impression)<br />

• Some examples:<br />

• At our IKEA stores, we recycle an average of<br />

70% of all the waste we produce and we help<br />

customers recycle, too.<br />

• We have installed rain water harvesting<br />

systems at all our shopping centres and most<br />

IKEA stores.<br />

• We track energy consumption and outfitted<br />

all our IKEA stores and our shopping centres<br />

with LED lights, which consume 80% less<br />

energy than traditional incandescent bulbs.<br />

• We now have more than 16,000 solar panels<br />

on rooftops of our IKEA stores and our<br />

shopping centres in the region, generating<br />

more than 5.5 million megawatt hours of<br />

renewable energy during 2017 alone.<br />

• At our Toppen Shopping Centre, Johor, we will<br />

be introducing kitchen macerators (decompose<br />

food with solvent) underneath the sinks at all<br />

our Food & Beverage outlets to minimise the<br />

amount of food waste going to landfill.<br />

• We also take social responsibility by developing<br />

long-term partnerships with non-profit groups in<br />

the communities where we operate and, during<br />

2017, donated a total of SGD1.6 million to good<br />

causes. All our co-workers are entitled to a day of<br />

paid leave to donate their time to a charitable cause.<br />

(L-R) Christian Rojkjaer, Managing Director of IKEA Southeast Asia<br />

and Christian Olofsson, Shopping Centre & Mixed Use Director, IKEA<br />

Southeast Asia at the Toppen Shopping Centre Media Event<br />

We invest in real estate including shop<br />

houses, apartments, hotels, a school<br />

and more to maximise the value of the<br />

land we develop and to create walkable<br />

communities where people can live,<br />

work, shop and play.


66 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

3<br />

4<br />

In terms of IKEA’s sustainability aspirations, would<br />

doing away with plastic products be one of its<br />

eventual goals?<br />

This has been something we have been working<br />

together with our partners, tenants, and even<br />

manufacturers of our IKEA products. This includes<br />

minimizing waste in our value chain and turning it into<br />

a resource by using it to make new products.<br />

What are the projects in the pipeline in Malaysia<br />

(after Penang)?<br />

Our vision is to create a better everyday life for the<br />

many people and, as retailers, we want to make it is as<br />

easy as possible for many Malaysians to access our great<br />

range of functional, affordable home furnishings. So, we<br />

are working on extending e-commerce to all of Malaysia<br />

and intend to launch a web shop later this year.<br />

Our sustainability principles are also<br />

embedded in the way we design our<br />

buildings, the materials we choose<br />

for construction and the features we<br />

include to help us conserve water,<br />

generate renewable energy, manage<br />

waste, etc.<br />

5<br />

6<br />

Please share examples of other ‘residential, office and<br />

other types of real estate’ that Ikea will go into?<br />

• In Penang, we partner with Aspen Group to realise<br />

the vision for Aspen Vision City – a development<br />

that will, in addition to our IKEA store and<br />

shopping centre, include shop houses, apartments,<br />

hotels, a school and more. We invest in such types<br />

of real estate to maximise the value of the land we<br />

develop and to create walkable communities where<br />

people can live, work, shop and play<br />

• Meanwhile, the team at Mega Bangna in Bangkok<br />

also opened its doors to other developers as they<br />

aim to realise the vision of Megacity – a modern<br />

community anchored by our retail destination.<br />

The development will add hotels, office towers,<br />

residential and other types of real estate to the area<br />

surrounding our mall.<br />

Would you say Aspen Vision City and Megacity<br />

residential housing component would be in the<br />

affordable range in line with Ikea’s vision of ‘creating<br />

a better everyday life for the many people’?<br />

IKEA Southeast Asia is first and foremost a retailer.<br />

It is our primary goal to create better everyday life for<br />

the many people through both IKEA’s wide-range of<br />

well-designed, functional home furnishing products;<br />

and anchored-by-IKEA shopping centres that work<br />

both as a retail destination and a meeting space for the<br />

Aspen Vision City_IKEA


May - June 2018<br />

67<br />

Aspen Vision City Master Plan<br />

7<br />

community. As for Aspen Vision City and Megacity,<br />

we are currently working with experienced partners and<br />

professional developers to bring it to life in the best and<br />

most integrated way possible. At the end of the day, we<br />

are building this for the community to live and work in.<br />

How would these mixed developments be able to<br />

differentiate from other similar mixed developments<br />

in those areas – what are your USPs?<br />

Our shopping centres and IKEA stores will become<br />

the centre piece of a modern community. It will be<br />

an integrated development where people can live and<br />

work within easy reach of places to shop, meet, play<br />

and socialize.<br />

At our IKEA stores, we recycle an<br />

average of 70% of all the waste we<br />

produce and we help customers<br />

recycle, too.


68 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

8<br />

9<br />

Would the hotels in both mixed developments<br />

be managed by an in-house team or established<br />

hotel operators?<br />

We will be engaging established hotel operators as well<br />

as residential developers.<br />

Why does every mall attached to IKEA have a<br />

different name e.g. IPC, Toppen, MyTown?<br />

We pride ourselves by positioning our malls as being<br />

“local with a Scandinavian touch”; we believe that all<br />

our shopping centres are uniquely appealing to the<br />

local community without foregoing our roots hence the<br />

differentiation. We have deliberately implemented a<br />

‘House of Brands’ brand architecture for our shopping<br />

centres, as we want our strong, robust brands to<br />

resonate with the local community and catchment area.<br />

This is in line with our brand story building centres -<br />

‘Made with Swedish charm and a local touch’.<br />

This ‘house of brands’ strategy allows each and every<br />

brand to be unique in its own right, with flexibility<br />

to adapt to the needs of the surrounding local<br />

community. While we might have different brands, we<br />

share common visions and values for each shopping<br />

10<br />

centre, chief of which is our vision of ‘creating a better<br />

everyday life for the many people.’<br />

The other key thread that unites our different shopping<br />

centres is the strong focus on the customer experience<br />

and journey at every touch point, enabling us to deliver,<br />

with IKEA, a fun and inspiring full day out for the<br />

whole community.<br />

What are the new tech that’s going to be integrated<br />

into the retail shopping experience e.g. AR (Ikea’s<br />

Place app), AI, free home design service, pop-up<br />

garden at home, human-first interfaces, smart veg<br />

growing, etc?<br />

When it comes to technology, we always look at how<br />

we can incorporate tech and create a fun and unique<br />

shopping experience. One of our most recent creations<br />

is for one of our shopping centres – IPC Shopping<br />

We have installed rain water<br />

harvesting systems at all our shopping<br />

centres and most IKEA stores.<br />

Toppen (artist impression)


May - June 2018<br />

69<br />

Toppen Aerial View<br />

11<br />

Centre. We created a shopping centre app that goes<br />

beyond the usual store guide. We worked with Spotify,<br />

one of the biggest music streaming apps, to create a<br />

food and mood matching tool within the IPC app that<br />

allows users to find their perfect restaurant based on<br />

their mood.<br />

Could you briefly describe some of the new<br />

tech adopted in IKEA’s retail destinations around<br />

the world?<br />

Urbanisation and digitalisation is pushing us to meet<br />

the needs of a new generation of shoppers. The IKEA<br />

PLACE app launched in the US, is an important<br />

milestone in IKEA digital transformation strategy.<br />

The app lets people confidently experience, experiment<br />

and share how good design transforms any space,<br />

such as a home, office, school or studio. We recently<br />

launched e-commerce in Singapore and within less<br />

than 4 months, it contributed 5% of total sales. We<br />

are bringing this to both Malaysia and Thailand next.<br />

As for the rest of the tech, we are slowly but surely<br />

adapting it in our everyday business. Embracing the<br />

digital world is one of the many things we look at to<br />

ensure we are constantly meeting the demands of the<br />

ever-changing world.<br />

Christian Rojkjaer, and Christian Olofsson showcasing the progress of<br />

Toppen Shopping Centre which is situated next to IKEA Tebrau<br />

We now have more than 16,000 solar<br />

panels on rooftops of our IKEA stores<br />

and our shopping centres in the region,<br />

generating more than 5.5 million<br />

megawatt hours of renewable energy<br />

during 2017 alone.


70 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

UNDERSTANDING<br />

JAPAN’S COUNTER-<br />

INTUITIVE REAL<br />

ESTATE MARKET<br />

The Japanese market is the ideal cash flow market due to its<br />

steady and high yield rental income.<br />

Priti Donnelly is the<br />

sales and marketing<br />

manager at Nippon<br />

Tradings International, a<br />

proxy and buyers’ agency<br />

representing foreign<br />

investors with purchasing,<br />

selling and managing<br />

real estate in Japan. She<br />

can be contacted at<br />

info@nippontradings.<br />

com or +1 519 546 9473<br />

/ +81 3 4520 9262 www.<br />

nippontradings.com<br />

You may think real estate investing<br />

is solely about property growth<br />

as you would find in Australia,<br />

U.K. US, Singapore and similar<br />

markets. The Japanese property market<br />

is not ripe with prospects for increased<br />

property value. So, why then is the market<br />

saturated with foreign investors?<br />

CREATING OPPORTUNITIES<br />

BEYOND CAPITAL GROWTH<br />

The Japanese property market suffered<br />

at least 25 years of declining/flat-lining<br />

prices. Although capital growth made a<br />

quiet entrance from 2012 to 2016, it was<br />

too soon for investors to comfortably<br />

speculate growth. Instead, investors found<br />

a new opportunity. Because of the decline,<br />

properties became quite affordable while<br />

rental rates remained stable. The result,<br />

steady and higher yields across Japan-- the<br />

ideal cash flow market from high yield<br />

rental income.<br />

To put it in perspective, for as little as<br />

USD30,000 at 7.5% yield net pre-tax,<br />

investors can earn monthly rental income<br />

of approximately USD170/month. As<br />

an added benefit, in a prime location you<br />

might also gain property value, but that<br />

is not the focus of property investing in<br />

Japan. This market is about common sense<br />

investing without the speculative nature.<br />

OVERCOMING THE<br />

LANGUAGE BARRIER<br />

This is not your typical internationally<br />

friendly business market. On one hand, you<br />

will experience the most reliable and honest<br />

professionals in Japan, while on the other,<br />

foreigner-shy professionals who likely<br />

cannot speak English.<br />

Furthermore, to invest in Japanese<br />

properties, you will need a local address,<br />

phone number and a local bank account,<br />

impossible without communication and<br />

Osaka skyline<br />

Photography by Jan Yong


May - June 2018<br />

71<br />

Photography by Jan Yong<br />

A typical house in Osaka<br />

cooperation. To get around this barrier,<br />

savvy foreign investors use a trusted<br />

local Japanese/English speaking proxy or<br />

representative to act on their behalf for<br />

both communication and access to the<br />

required information.<br />

UNDERSTANDING OLD<br />

STRUCTURES<br />

Some novice investors shy away from<br />

the Japanese property market believing<br />

with a huff and a puff, structures could be<br />

blown down. It is true that structures built<br />

before 1981, including smaller steel-frame<br />

buildings, and even wooden frame houses,<br />

were not built to last and require major<br />

renovations and repairs over time. However,<br />

a major change to the Building Standards<br />

Act for earthquake resistant construction<br />

methods for buildings (reinforced concrete<br />

blocks) occurred in 1981.<br />

This became the turning point that<br />

investors often looked to when purchasing<br />

property. That being said, there is still a<br />

niche market for older properties because<br />

of the higher yield. In truth, regardless of<br />

age, with due diligence, if the property has<br />

proof of regular maintenance, renovations,<br />

repairs to the interior and exterior, as well<br />

… if the property has proof of regular<br />

maintenance, renovations, repairs to the<br />

interior and exterior, as well as sufficient funds<br />

for ongoing repairs, and is tenanted, an older<br />

higher yielding property could prove to be a<br />

diamond in the rough.<br />

as sufficient funds for ongoing repairs,<br />

and is tenanted, an older higher yielding<br />

property could prove to be a diamond in<br />

the rough.<br />

ACCEPTING FOREIGN REAL<br />

ESTATE<br />

Today, the best real estate opportunities<br />

do not have to be in your own back yard.<br />

JPMorgan Chase says Japanese real estate<br />

and infrastructure are becoming more<br />

attractive particularly with no more than<br />

50% of leveraged funds. Above that, real<br />

estate doesn’t become the driver, but the<br />

leverage becomes the driver of your return.<br />

Japan provides opportunities for stable,<br />

monthly cash flow from rental income with<br />

yields from 5% to 11% net pre-tax. Add to<br />

that, currency exchange and the yen’s role<br />

as a safe-haven currency and it’s easy to see<br />

why this is a booming market for foreign<br />

investors, contrary to the standard real<br />

estate investment approach.


72 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

OF<br />

EARTHQUAKES,<br />

TRAINS AND AIRPORTS<br />

Asian Property Review chats with award-winning writer and<br />

entrepreneur Christopher Dillon on earthquakes and infrastructure in<br />

Japan – 2 key issues that investors are keen to know more about<br />

before investing.<br />

1<br />

Japan’s construction technology, which<br />

includes advanced earthquake-resistant<br />

designs, is among the most developed in the<br />

world. How effective are the buildings against<br />

earthquakes, say, above Richter Scale 6?<br />

Earthquakes in Japan are measured using the shindo<br />

scale, which rates them as 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 lower,<br />

5 upper, 6 lower, 6 upper and 7, where 0 is only<br />

perceptible by seismometers. In a 7, it is impossible<br />

to remain standing, buildings collapse, cracks appear<br />

in the earth’s surface and landslides occur.<br />

Japan’s building standards are designed to achieve<br />

two goals. In a moderate earthquake, up to about<br />

5 on the Japanese scale, the building should<br />

suffer little or no structural damage and still be<br />

safe for occupancy. In a stronger earthquake, the<br />

building should not collapse and there should be<br />

Seismic retrofitting is not<br />

mandatory in Japan.<br />

no casualties as a result of structural failure. This is<br />

important because 80% of the fatalities in the 1995<br />

Great Hanshin Earthquake (GHE) were due to<br />

collapsing buildings.<br />

The GHE demonstrated the importance of revisions<br />

to national building standards that took effect on<br />

June 1, 1981. Of 923 buildings surveyed in central<br />

Kobe after the GHE, 35% of those built before<br />

1971 collapsed or were seriously damaged, 40%<br />

had moderate or minor damage and 25% had slight<br />

or no damage. For buildings constructed between<br />

1972 and 1981, the statistics were 12%, 31% and<br />

57%, respectively. But only 8% built after 1982 were<br />

seriously damaged, with 17% incurring moderate<br />

damage and 75% sustaining slight or no damage.<br />

2<br />

Is it a good idea to buy non-earthquake<br />

resistant buildings? They may be cheap but<br />

in the long run, are they worth it – perhaps<br />

because over time, the capital value depreciates as<br />

the likelihood of their being demolished grows.<br />

Non-earthquake resistant buildings are not a<br />

bargain, because they are significantly more<br />

expensive to insure than earthquake-resistant ones.


May - June 2018<br />

73<br />

All of Japan is at risk of earthquakes.<br />

Premiums in high-risk areas are about<br />

three times those in low-risk zones.<br />

Rents are lower in areas identified on hazard maps<br />

as having a high earthquake risk. Homes in highrisk<br />

districts that were erected before the seismic<br />

standards were tightened in 1981 rent at a discount,<br />

compared with those built after 1981.<br />

Seismic retrofitting is not mandatory in Japan.<br />

In 2013, about 9 million of Japan’s 52 million<br />

dwellings did not meet modern earthquake<br />

resistance standards.<br />

3Since Japan is in the Pacific Ring of Fire and<br />

is prone to earthquakes and tsunamis, are<br />

there any cities that are completely free from<br />

such natural disasters?<br />

All of Japan is at risk of earthquakes. The Japan<br />

Earthquake Reinsurance Co. divides the country<br />

into three categories when calculating insurance<br />

premiums. The high risk group includes Chiba,<br />

Tokyo and Kanagawa. The low risk group includes<br />

Iwate, Fukuoka and Nagasaki.<br />

Premiums in high-risk<br />

areas are about three times<br />

those in low-risk zones.<br />

4How effective are<br />

the earthquake<br />

warning systems<br />

when it comes to<br />

preventing fatalities?<br />

By giving people time<br />

to take shelter and<br />

automatically stopping<br />

trains and production<br />

lines, Japan’s earthquake warning system has<br />

saved many lives and prevented millions of<br />

dollars in damage.<br />

Aftermath of an earthquake in Japan.


74 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW WORLDVIEW<br />

The high-speed Linear Chuo<br />

Shinkansen, which uses<br />

superconducting magnetic levitation<br />

technology, is expected to begin<br />

service between Tokyo’s Shinagawa<br />

Station and Nagoya Station<br />

in 2027.<br />

While the system is imperfect, even a few seconds of<br />

advance warning can make an enormous difference.<br />

5What are some futuristic building<br />

technologies and intelligent building<br />

solutions that Japan has created?<br />

Japan’s base-isolation and vibration-damping<br />

technologies allow people to live comfortably in<br />

high-rise buildings despite the threat of earthquakes.<br />

Japan’s electronic toilets are also in a class of<br />

their own.<br />

6Please share what are the new road and rail<br />

network links that will be completed before<br />

the Olympics in 2020? How will this affect the<br />

housing market particularly those that are located<br />

near the lines?<br />

A new station on the Yamanote Line, which circles<br />

downtown Tokyo, is expected to open by 2020.<br />

The currently unnamed station will be between<br />

Shinagawa and Tamachi stations.<br />

A new subway station between Kamiyacho and<br />

Kasumigaseki on Tokyo’s Hibiya Line is scheduled<br />

to open by 2020. The station is tentatively known as<br />

Toranomon New Station.<br />

The Tokyo Outer Ring Road and the Metropolitan<br />

Inter-City Expressway are expected to be 90%<br />

complete by 2020, with new sections under<br />

construction in Tama, Chiba, Kanagawa and Saitama.<br />

Over the long term, these developments will be<br />

positive for nearby homeowners. Noise and traffic<br />

disruptions will pose short-term challenges, however.<br />

The N700A Series bullet train for Tokaido Shinkansen at Nagoya station.<br />

7Will there also be new airports coming up?<br />

The biggest aviation stories are improved rail<br />

links at Tokyo’s Haneda airport and a new, second<br />

runway at Fukuoka airport. The government<br />

is also planning on expanding the number of<br />

landing slots at both Haneda and Narita to cater<br />

to growing tourist numbers.<br />

8What are other new infrastructure projects<br />

coming up that might impact the housing<br />

market?<br />

The high-speed Linear Chuo Shinkansen,<br />

which uses superconducting magnetic levitation<br />

technology, is expected to begin service between<br />

Tokyo’s Shinagawa Station and Nagoya Station<br />

in 2027. The service will be extended to Osaka<br />

by 2045, and will allow you to live in Nagoya and<br />

commute to Tokyo.<br />

Ed’s Note: Christopher Dillon has authored 4 books:<br />

Landed Hong Kong (2008), Landed Japan (2010),<br />

Landed China (2013) and Landed Global—which<br />

includes case studies and data from more than 110<br />

countries and territories—in 2014.<br />

(www.landedbook.com)


Anyone Can Be A<br />

Property Millionaire<br />

Reality TV Show by Gavin Tee<br />

Broadcast<br />

on<br />

CH 301 / CH 306<br />

Every Monday 9.30pm<br />

Tuesday 4:00 am & 10:00 am (repeat)<br />

Sunday 3:00 pm (repeat)<br />

Let Gavin Tee Mentor You<br />

Through A Successful<br />

Property Investment Journey<br />

Producer:<br />

Production of:<br />

Dato’ Sri Gavin Tee<br />

Mentor of The Show<br />

*The organizer reserves the right to change event details without prior notice. Terms & conditions apply.<br />

Log in to 1balcony.com to<br />

WIN PRIZES!<br />

Supported by:<br />

Sponsor Partner:


76 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />

A ‘HOME-MADE<br />

OASIS’ IN KL<br />

Tiny Garden transports you to a magical world amid rows of<br />

drab terrace houses in a Kuala Lumpur suburb.<br />

Text & Photography by Benjamin K. Yong<br />

Lots of relaxing spots. The main gate is just behind


May - June 2018<br />

77<br />

The outdoor dining area<br />

Reading corner<br />

From the outside, the house looks nondescript like<br />

any other terrace house in this residential area<br />

located about 2 kms from the National Zoo in<br />

Selangor, Malaysia. But once you enter through<br />

the side gate, you are immediately transported to a different<br />

world – a world where you can immerse yourself with quiet<br />

times by the koi pond or even play with the tiny dogs that<br />

occasionally come to stay.<br />

Coffee bar which also serves up breakfast<br />

This is Tiny Garden, a marvel in terrace house design –<br />

especially since the designers are not professional designers<br />

but a family who operates a homestay. As Carmen the<br />

daughter says, “Our family likes to Do-It-Yourself. Every<br />

single decoration is done by our own hands.”


78 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />

Pond with koi fish


May - June 2018<br />

79<br />

Eclectic decor with stuff from all over the world<br />

Single room<br />

The main lounge which overlooks the dining area outside<br />

There is a relaxing reading corner, outdoor dining area,<br />

koi pond, and lush garden complemented by eclectic<br />

décor in every corner. You can’t help but get pleasantly<br />

distracted by all the decorations. At the same time, you<br />

feel the calm and serenity of the place. This place makes<br />

you feel at home and you can practically stay all day long<br />

in this pleasant environment.<br />

Outdoor is where the action is – food is served there and<br />

most social interactions take place there despite a very<br />

warm and cozy indoor area. The details show how much<br />

care and effort have been taken to make this house as cozy<br />

and welcoming as possible.<br />

Indeed, it is a beautiful oasis amid the hustle and bustle of<br />

Kuala Lumpur.


80 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />

BENOY<br />

TRAVELS<br />

THE WORLD<br />

From a small design firm in<br />

Nottinghamshire, UK, 71 years ago, Benoy’s<br />

footprint now spans the entire globe<br />

including an increasing number in Asia.<br />

Asian Property Review interviews<br />

Qin Pang, Director and Head of Benoy’s<br />

Shanghai Studio.<br />

Qin Pang<br />

1<br />

2<br />

Benoy started in Nottinghamshire, UK some<br />

71 years ago. It has now evolved into a global<br />

design specialist undertaking many inspiring<br />

and iconic projects. Please list out some<br />

recently completed iconic projects in Asia.<br />

Terminal 4, Changi Airport, Singapore (2017),<br />

Suzhou Center, China (2017), Parc Central,<br />

Guangzhou, China (2016) and Starfield Hanam,<br />

Hanam, Gyeonggi, South Korea (2016).<br />

What is Benoy’s design philosophy and how<br />

does that translate into your works?<br />

At Benoy, we balance creative vision with<br />

commercial viability; we work with clients to<br />

create iconic destinations that enrich people’s<br />

lives, strengthen communities, enhance nature,<br />

and deliver lasting economic value. This is<br />

3<br />

translated into our work in many ways, however<br />

our aim is also to deliver world-class solutions<br />

for the built environment.<br />

Does Benoy have onboard or have joint<br />

ventures with starchitects especially in projects<br />

involving branded residences or mixed<br />

developments e.g. Prada, etc?<br />

Benoy collaborates with a number of design<br />

firms, especially on larger projects which are<br />

overseen by a consortium. In Singapore, for<br />

example, we are working within the consortium<br />

led by Moshe Safdie (famed for his Habitat<br />

67, in Montreal, Quebec) to deliver the high<br />

profile Jewel Changi Airport project. Benoy is<br />

the Interior Design and Retail and Aviation<br />

Facilities Planner on the development.


May - June 2018<br />

81<br />

Suzhou Center - Credit Suzhou Hengtai Holding Group Co<br />

4<br />

Benoy has a strong reputation in<br />

regeneration projects with the firm’s<br />

portfolio including HARBOUR CITY’s<br />

Gala Avenue Westside in Shanghai, the<br />

David Jones Flagship Building in Sydney<br />

and TSUM Department Store in Kiev.<br />

With the upcoming Nanjing cold storage<br />

warehouse project, how will Benoy’s previous<br />

experience help with this project?<br />

Knowledge sharing is always vital for any<br />

project. We are fortunate to be able to draw on<br />

the experience and expertise of many of our<br />

colleagues as we approach the Nanjing MCC<br />

World project. However, all projects are unique,<br />

it’s not about copying and pasting design<br />

solutions from other projects, but using that<br />

information to inform how we approach new<br />

design challenges.<br />

We work with clients to create iconic<br />

destinations that enrich people’s lives,<br />

strengthen communities, enhance<br />

nature, and deliver lasting economic<br />

value.


82 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW DESIGN<br />

Parc Central, Guangzhou - Credit Benoy


May - June 2018<br />

83<br />

5<br />

6<br />

What are the design challenges when it comes<br />

to regeneration projects?<br />

Balancing the heritage aspects of the<br />

development with the new build components<br />

is always a challenge. We want to ensure we are<br />

respectful and sensitive to the history of the site<br />

whilst also celebrating a new, exciting prospect for<br />

the future.<br />

How much green or sustainable practices are<br />

incorporated into Benoy’s works?<br />

A key feature of the Benoy offer is sustainability.<br />

We work closely with our clients and providers<br />

of expert knowledge to deliver more sustainable<br />

design solutions, relevant to the unique context<br />

of each project. Responsible design practice<br />

and sustainability is promoted by building on<br />

experience, encouraging education, the recruitment<br />

of new and complementary skills and, where<br />

necessary, collaboration with external experts.<br />

We are proud to have a portfolio which includes<br />

numerous sustainable design credentials including<br />

the first LEED Platinum Retail Development in<br />

Greater China, Hysan Place.<br />

Terminal 4, Changi Airport - Credit Benoy


84 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INNOVATION<br />

A CHINESE<br />

‘BUTLER’<br />

FOR CHINESE BUYERS<br />

Singou’s ‘Butler 1’ robot is the first<br />

of many Mandarin-speaking robots<br />

that will be deployed worldwide by<br />

Juwai.com to cater to international<br />

property buyers from China.<br />

No Mandarin speakers in your company,<br />

yet you want to serve the increasing<br />

number of Chinese property buyers? No<br />

worries, a robot is coming near you which<br />

can answer all the queries the Chinese buyer usually<br />

asks about international properties - all in Mandarin.<br />

The Butler 1 robot is developed by an awardwinning<br />

Macau startup, Singou Technology Ltd.<br />

Singou, under the auspices of Macau University of<br />

Science and Technology is an Artificial Intelligence<br />

(AI) and service robot pioneer which has won<br />

an award in November 2017 at the Shanghai<br />

International Service Robot Show.<br />

The benefits are immense – marketers worldwide<br />

can make do without Mandarin-speaking staff and<br />

can scale up their operations quickly. Priced at a<br />

mere USD2,000 each, the 1.4 meters (4’ 7”) tall<br />

robot is very approachable and can even move and


May - June 2018<br />

85<br />

Carrie Law and Dr Hon at the signing ceremony in Macau recently.<br />

approach people just like another human being, says<br />

Dr Hon Chi Tin, Chief Executive Officer of Singou<br />

Technology. “A robot is superior to a fixed device,<br />

smart speaker, or smart furniture,” says Dr Hon<br />

who is also a Guest Associate Professor of Macau<br />

University of Science.<br />

Recently, pursuant to an agreement, Singou has<br />

made available its robots to Juwai.com on a trial<br />

basis where they will be trained in dealing with<br />

Chinese customers using Juwai’s 5-year experience<br />

in dealing with Chinese buyers of overseas property.<br />

Juwai.com is a leading Chinese international real<br />

estate website.<br />

Says Dr Hon: “Juwai.com has a large data set that<br />

can be abstracted into artificial intelligence with the<br />

strong experience of Singou technology and then<br />

put to use in serving customers in smarter ways.”<br />

At the moment, the robots are<br />

only monolingual, speaking only<br />

Mandarin, and are only assigned<br />

the task of giving information to<br />

consumers.<br />

TRAINING THE ROBOT<br />

Juwai will also begin distributing the Butler 1 to the<br />

property industry and to homeowners. However, at<br />

this stage, the company is not yet taking orders for<br />

the robots as they are still under training. “We are<br />

still training the AI behind the robots and at this<br />

point are not yet taking orders,” says Carrie Law,<br />

CEO of Juwai.com.


86 ASIAN PROPERTY REVIEW INNOVATION<br />

During the training period, early robots will be<br />

deployed at international property industry events<br />

in China and in showrooms and offices in five other<br />

countries: Malaysia, Singapore, the USA, Australia,<br />

and Canada or the UK.<br />

She adds that in the initial stage while training the<br />

robots over the next few months, they expect to<br />

deploy one robot per country. “You might say this<br />

first handful of robots is the beachhead or initial<br />

foothold for a much larger invasion.”<br />

At the moment, the robots are only monolingual,<br />

speaking only Mandarin, and are only assigned<br />

the task of giving information to consumers.<br />

According to Law, this is because ‘consumers don’t<br />

want to complete sales with robots. They want the<br />

reassurance and value of working with an agent.”<br />

On how it would impact the website, Law explains:<br />

“On the front end, that part of the website which is<br />

visible to users, probably there will be no change. But<br />

on the backend, the robot’s AI engine will need to<br />

interact with the same systems behind the website.<br />

That way, it can properly provide market and listing<br />

info to the Chinese consumer while at the same time<br />

giving the consumer’s details and needs to the agent<br />

or developer.”<br />

The two companies will spend the next several<br />

months training the Singou AI engine using the<br />

data and insights that Juwai.com has gathered<br />

during its five years of serving Chinese international<br />

property buyers.<br />

The same artificial intelligence is also part of the<br />

brain that will operate the Butler 1 when it is<br />

deployed in the offices of international property<br />

marketers. During the training period, early robots<br />

will be deployed at international property industry<br />

events in China and in showrooms and offices in<br />

five other countries: Malaysia, Singapore, the USA,<br />

Australia, and Canada or the UK. This experience<br />

will provide further data and input to train the<br />

artificial intelligence engine.<br />

MARCH OF THE AI<br />

Singou Technology has deployed earlier models<br />

of robots to provide security and access control at<br />

the premises of large facilities, such as convention<br />

centers, universities, and transit centers.<br />

China installed 90,000 industrial robots between<br />

2010 and 2015, according to Machine Design<br />

magazine. That is one-third of the world’s total and<br />

more than the U.S, Europe, and the rest of Asia<br />

combined, which together installed 80,000. The<br />

International Federation of Robotics estimates that<br />

China will install 160,000 robots next year. Most<br />

will be deployed in factories, but service robots like<br />

Butler 1 are being built in ever greater quantities.<br />

Says Law of the partnership with Singou: “Singou’s<br />

AI chatbot engine will enable Juwai.com to improve<br />

and scale the service we provide to consumers. We<br />

will use the AI and chatbot to crunch data, handle<br />

basic requests, and speed processing.<br />

“The robot is essentially a carrier that lets our AI<br />

consumer service engine be present in real estate<br />

sales offices anywhere in the world. The robot has the<br />

same AI brain and intelligence as our chatbot.”<br />

Law adds: “It’s natural that we turned to a company<br />

from Greater China for this partnership. China plans<br />

to be the global leader in AI and robotics by 2030<br />

and is investing heavily in the field. China’s core<br />

AI industries should be worth, the State Council<br />

believes, US$50 billion by 2025. China already<br />

deploys more robots per year than Europe, the US,<br />

and the rest of Asia combined.”


I WISH TO SUBSCRIBE FOR ONE YEAR (6 issues)( please ✓ ):<br />

Malaysia Singapore Other Countries<br />

PRINT ❏ RM85 ❏ SGD50 ❏ USD40<br />

(Exclude Postage)<br />

(Exclude Postage)<br />

DIGITAL ❏ RM40 ❏ SGD20 ❏ USD20<br />

From _________________________ to _______________________________<br />

Terms & Conditions apply. *Prices are inclusive of postage (Malaysia). ** Rates will apply in accordance with postage destination (other countries).<br />

*** We reserve th right to amend the T & Cs without prior notice.<br />

By filling up the info herein, you hereby consent to our processing of your personal data as per the Personal Data Notice at www.asianpropertyreview.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!