08/2009 - Superior Court

TITLE
984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS
LOWER COURT
NUMBER/
COUNTY
Acorn v. Gryphin 2667 Sept. T., 2006
(Philadelphia)
Acorn v. Gryphin 2667 Sept. T., 2006
(Philadelphia)
DOCKET
NUMBER
DATE
DISPOSITION
3349 EDA 2007 08/06/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed,
Remanded and
Vacated
884 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed,
Remanded and
Vacated
Adopt. of D.B.W. 265 of 2006 (Delaware) 3063 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Adopt. of L.A.W. 266 of 2006 (Delaware) 3064 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
REARG
DENIED
DATE
Albert v. Albert 2008-01633-28-2 (Bucks) 3489 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Quashed
Ambrose v. Granite Run 3306 Sept. T., 2007
1083 EDA 2008 07/15/2009 Reversed and 09/18/2009
(Philadelphia)
Remanded
Arce v. Arce 2007-FC-1281 (Lehigh) 3038 EDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Armstrong v. U.S. Steel GD 05-30463 (Allegheny) 492 WDA 2008 07/17/2009 Affirmed 09/22/2009
Ashford v. Brown CI-02-05275 (Lancaster) 1222 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Autry v. Autry 0704V7452 (Philadelphia) 3547 EDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed 09/30/2009
Bank of America v. Fish 14653-2006 (Erie) 16 WDA 2009 08/14/2009 Affirmed 10/21/2009

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Bauer v. Bauer 1448 CV 1999 (Dauphin) 1657 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Belle v. Chernard 2007-2309 (Cambria) 1598 WDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Black v. Penn Nat’l 3280 CV 2002 (Dauphin) 863 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Bono v. Direnzo 02-16287 (Montgomery) 1632 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
Brodt v. Brodt CI-03-10935 (Lancaster) 316 MDA 2009 08/18/2009 Affirmed
Bushee v. Bushee FD 92-10899-06 (Allegheny) 998 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Bushee v. Bushee FD 92-10899-006 (Allegheny) 1877 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Callowhill v. BMCK & Maurer 02728 Nov. T., 2007 2245 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
(Philadelphia)
Carr-Heidelberg v. Heidelberg 11424-2007 (Erie) 1485 WDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Cheslak v. Kurtz 01-2180 (Carbon) 2097 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Colonial v. Warminster 06-09619-19-1 (Bucks) 1650 EDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Abdullah CP-51-CR-0500071-1998
(Philadelphia)
3019 EDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Adams CP-22-CR-0004696-2005 1397 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Reversed and
(Dauphin)
Remanded
Com. v. Addison CC 200311423; CC
200313549 (Allegheny)
1584 WDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Aiello CP-02-CR-0007117-2000
(Allegheny)
363 WDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Alexander CP-51-CR-0000390-2007 1229 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Allen CP-22-CR-0001676-1996,
CP-22-CR-0001677-1996,
CP-22-CR-0001791-1996,
1385 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
CP-22-CR-0001792-1996,
CP-22-CR-0002621-1996,
CP-22-CR-0003239-1996
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Alonzo CP-51-CR-0327071-1993
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Amenuvor CP-45-CR-0001859-1999
(Monroe)
Com. v. Andrews CP-51-CR-0507091-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Appel CP-67-CR-0001526-2004,
CP-67-CR-0002637-2004
(York)
Com. v. Assaro CP-23-CR-0006514-2002
(Delaware)
Com. v. Aviles CP-39-CR-0000422-2007
(Lehigh)
Com. v. Bahiy CP-23-CR-0001545-2001
(Delaware)
Com. v. Bailey CP-02-CR-0006409-1994,
CP-02-CR-0008102-1994
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Baldwin CP-36-CR-0004163-2007;
CP-36-CR-0004164-2007,
CP-36-CR-0004165-2007
(Lancaster)
2101 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
2951 EDA 2008 06/26/2009 Affirmed 09/25/2009
2001 EDA 2007 08/24/2009 Affirmed
1328 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed and
Vacated
2963 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
2036 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
2762 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
22 WDA 2009 08/14/2009 Affirmed
2131 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Ballard CP-51-CR-0001033-2007
(Philadelphia)
3187 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Barber CP-08-CR-0000559-2005
(Bradford)
600 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Barr CP-30-CR-0000033-2008
(Greene)
1391 WDA 2008 07/28/2009 Affirmed 10/09/2009
Com. v. Beasom 98-CR-857 (Blair) 1414 WDA 2007 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Beckett CP-15-CR-0002133-2004,
CP-15-CR-0004868-2004,
CP-15-CR-0005467-2003
(Chester)
2297 EDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Bensing CP-48-CR-0002047-2008
(Northampton)
3004 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Benson CP-23-CR-0001679-2007
(Delaware)
2078 EDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Bentley CP-23-CR-0003663-2008
(Delaware)
2959 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Bishop, I. CC 2292 C 2002
(Westmoreland)
456 WDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Bishop, M. CP-05-CR-0000377-2007
(Bedford)
1543 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Remanded
Com. v. Bishop. R. CP-51-CR-0012520-2007
(Philadelphia)
1600 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Blackman CP-51-CR-0005742-2007 2418 EDA 2007 08/05/2009 Reversed and
(Philadelphia)
Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Bobbett CP-19-CR-0000354-2007
(Columbia)
Com. v. Bolden CP-02-CR-0000097-1995,
CP-02-CR-0000193-1995
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Borelli CP-06-CR-0003664-2005
(Berks)
Com. v. Bourgeois CP-36-CR-0004224-2001;
CP-36-CR-0004975-2001
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Bragg CP-38-CR-0001485-2004
(Lebanon)
Com. v. Brenner CP-23-SA-0001443-2007
(Delaware)
Com. v. Brenner CP-23-SA-0000489-2008
(Delaware)
Com. v. Brettman CP-06-CR-0002372-2008
(Berks)
Com. v. Bridge CP-60-CR-0000159-1998
(Union)
Com. v. Brightwell CP-15-CR-0000060-2003;
CP-15-CR-0000540-2003
(Chester)
Com. v. Brinson CP-46-CR-0004953-2007
(Montgomery)
1597 MDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed,
Vacated and
Remanded
2009 WDA 2008 08/20/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
1383 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
1296 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
1761 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
423 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
3126 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
2212 MDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
2078 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
3144 EDA 2006 08/20/2009 Affirmed
3009 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Brooks CP-02-CR-0009310-1975
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Bryant CP-25-CR-0000479-2008
(Erie)
Com. v. Bush, A. CP-11-CR-0000306-2005
(Cambria)
Com. v. Bush, T. CP-51-CR-0804121-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Butler CP-02-CR-0015888-2004,
CP-02-CR-0017235-2004
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Caesar CP-51-CR-1300572-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Canady CP-51-CR-0011865-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Caraballo CP-51-CR-0013656-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Carpenter CP-51-CR-0708031-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Carter CP-06-CR-0002407-2005
(Berks)
Com. v. Casper CP-51-CR-1212451-1986
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Cheman CP-10-CR-0000882-2003 and
CP-10-CR-0002567-2007
(Butler)
37 WDA 2009 08/19/2009 Affirmed
108 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed
1633 WDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
1990 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
1958 WDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
2031 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
668 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
2531 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
299 EDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
1412 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
3294 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
1490 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Carver-Schlesser CP-40-CR-0004424-2006,
CP-40-CR-0004425-2006
(Luzerne)
888 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Case CP-51-CR-0712531-2000
(Philadelphia)
1034 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Castillo CP-51-CR-0109801-1998
(Philadelphia)
1110 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Castro-Reyes CP-38-CR-0002233-2007
(Lebanon)
1128 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Cepeda CP-06-CR-0001759-2005
(Berks)
1459 MDA 2008 08/11/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Champagne CP-38-CR-0000249-2007 166 MDA 2008 08/24/2009 Reversed and
(Lebanon)
Remanded
Com. v. Chick CP-51-CR-0403371-2005
(Philadelphia)
1420 EDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Clarkson CP-51-CR-0003563-2007 2353 EDA 2008 07/29/2009 Affirmed Dismissed
(Philadelphia)
09/14/2009
Com. v. Clegg CP-50-CR-0000133-2008 1722 MDA 2008 07/14/2009 Reversed and 09/18/2009
(Perry)
Remanded
Com. v. Cobbs CC: 200607125 (Allegheny) 526 WDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Collazo 3002 of 2007 (Erie) 1511 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Collazo 3003 of 2007 (Erie) 1512 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Collins CP-51-CR-0400291-2006
(Philadelphia)
2166 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Coolbaugh CP-26-CR-0001559-2008
(Fayette)
556 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Cruz CP-25-MD-0000546-2008
(Erie)
Com. v. Cuevas CP-09-CR-0007270-2007
(Bucks)
Com. v. Curtician CP-02-CR-0003107-1994 &
CP-02-CR-0004716-1994
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Cypher CP-02-CR-0016325-2004
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Dade CP-51-CR-0212731-1989
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Daubert CP-54-CR-0000239-2007
(Schuylkill)
Com. v. Davenport CP-46-CR-0003758-2006
(Montgomery)
Com. v. Davis, J. CP-51-CR-0830071-1983
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Davis, R. CP-48-CR-0001933-2004
(Northampton)
Com. v. Deiter CP-40-CR-0002474-2007
(Luzerne)
Com.v. Duncan CP-32-CR-0001075-2007
(Indiana)
Com. v. Eades CP-51-CR-1107731-1995
(Philadelphia)
72 WDA 2009 08/21/2009 Affirmed
1247 EDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
1392 WDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
1397 WDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
2333 EDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
1639 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
897 EDA 2007 08/07/2009 Affirmed
2373 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
3138 EDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
1352 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
75 WDA 2009 08/19/2009 Affirmed
3066 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Eberle CP-25-CR-0001530-2008
(Erie)
Com. v. Edwards CP-09-CR-0007081-2004,
CP-09-CR-0007082-2004,
CP-09-CR-0007083-2004,
CP-09-CR-0007485-2004
(Bucks)
Com. v. Engelke CP-50-CR-0000014-2005
(Perry)
Com. v. Eubanks CP-15-SA-0000480-2008
(Chester)
Com. v. Evans CP-02-CR-0000376-2007
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Fabio CP-51-CR-0203481-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Faison CP-51-CR-0510291-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Fargas CP-06-CR-0003367-2005
(Berks)
Com. v. Farward CP-23-CR-0005490-2007
(Delaware)
Com. v. Fazzino CP-10-CR-001700-2005
(Butler)
Com. v. Featherstone CP-52-CR-0000110-2006
(Pike)
18 WDA 2009 08/03/2009 Affirmed 10/06/2009
1386 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
1986 MDA 2008 08/11/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
368 EDA 2009 08/17/2009 Affirmed
1434 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
1248 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
1730 EDA 2007 03/31/2009 Affirmed 10/02/2009
1116 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
30 EDA 2009 08/26/2009 Remanded
205 WDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
2291 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Fedorka CP-02-CR-0000657-2007
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Fields CP-63-CR-0000969-2004
(Washington)
Com. v. Fisher CP-38-CR-0002215-2007
(Lebanon)
Com. v. Fleet CP-22-CR-0004181-2007
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Fogle CP-51-CR-0011349-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Ford CP-36-CR-0003702-2000
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Fret CP-38-CR-0001864-2007
(Lebanon)
Com. v. Fullard CP-51-CR-0011894-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Gainer CP-51-CR-0010995-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Gallagher CP-23-CR-0006648-2007
(Delaware)
Com. v. Garcia CP-39-CR-0003482-2004,
CP-39-CR-0004111-2004,
CP-39-CR-0004112-2004
(Lehigh)
Com. v. Garnett CP-23-CR-0002875-1975
(Delaware)
821 WDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed
1657 WDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
2159 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
1157 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Remanded
549 EDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
488 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
1925 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
1419 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
742 EDA 2008 07/23/2009 Affirmed 09/25/2009
3501 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
1876 EDA 2007 08/06/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
3010 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Gaudiello CP-23-CR-0007519-2007
(Delware)
2222 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Geedy CP-21-CR-0001993-2006
(Cumberland)
474 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Gibson CP-06-MD-0001669-2007
(Berks)
1630 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Gilmore CP-37-CR-0000555-2005
(Lawrence)
1940 WDA 2007 08/03/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Com. v. Gomez CP-08-CR-0000843-2007
(Bradford)
1389 MDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Gonzales CP-25-R-0001662-2008 (Erie) 121 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Goodson CP-02-CR-0013670-2003 1317 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed and
(Allegheny)
Remanded
Com. v. Gould CP-40-CR-0001925-2007
(Luzerne)
1577 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Graves CP-51-CR-0810851-1994,
CP-51-CR-0810861-1994,
CP-51-CR-0810871-1994,
CP-51-CR-0907281-1994,
CP-51-CR-1000861-1994
(Philadelphia)
3331 EDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Greene CP-51-CR-0010415-2007
(Philadelphia)
874 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Grice CP-04-CR-0001700-2005
(Beaver)
1688 WDA 2008 08/06/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Griffin CC 199908358 (Allegheny) 468 WDA 2009 08/06/2009 Reversed 10/16/2009

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Griffiths CP-40-CR-0001634-2007
(Luzerne)
Com. v. Grim CP-30-CR-0000350-2007
(Greene)
Com. v. Grines CP-51-CR-0000931-2008
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Haigh CP-21-CR-0000716-1994
(Cumberland)
Com. v. Hall CP-51-CR-0409511-1997
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Hancock CP-02-CR-0012895-2007
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Hanes CP-22-CR-0002651-2007
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Hanible CP-51-CR-1302792-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Harding CP-05-CR-0000547-2006
(Bedford)
Com. v. Harold CP-51-CR-0105591-2005
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Harris CP-51-CR-0903160-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Hayes CP-51-CR-0108141-2004
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Heard CP-51-CR-0312431-2006
(Philadelphia)
637 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Remanded
206 WDA 2009 08/05/2009 Affirmed
2478 EDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
1690 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
2553 EDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed 10/02/2009
1258 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
2003 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
405 EDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
1088 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
2052 EDA 2007 08/11/2009 Affirmed
2532 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
1309 EDA 2007 08/19/2009 Affirmed
1319 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Hefflin CP-02-CR-0007099-2001 &
CP-02-CR-007681-2001
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Hernandez CP-38-CR-0000546-2002,
CP-38-CR-000797-2001, CP-
38-CR-0000805-2001, CP-38-
CR-0000806-2001, CP-38-
CR-0000807-2001, CP-38-
CR-0000808-2001 & CP-38-
CR-0000809-2001 (Lebanon)
Com. v. Hill CP-36-CR-0000717-2005 ,
CP-36-CR-0000721-2005,
CP-36-CR-0000746-2005
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Hollman CP-36-CR-0002352-2005
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Holzer CP-39-CR-0002570-1999
(Lehigh)
Com. v. Hood CP-51-CR-0303561-2000
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Hudson CP-51-CR-0000614-2008
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Hull CP-28-MD-0000101-1975
(Franklin)
Com. v. Hunter CP-51-CR-1200141-2005
(Philadelphia)
1149 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
500 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
1995 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
1348 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
2933 EDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
2741 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
1490 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
1823 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
3210 EDA 2007 08/27/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Isaacs CP-23-CR-0003659-2008
(Delaware)
Com. v. Islam CP-51-CR-0205721-2000;
CP-51-CR-0311471-2000
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Jackson, B. CP-67-CR-0001076-2006
(York)
Com. v. Jackson, E. CP-02-SA-0002225-2008
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Jackson, W. CP-51-CR-0807401-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Jacobs, A. CP-02-CR-0002109-2006
(Allegheny)
Com.v. Jacobs, J. CP-01-CR-0001404-2007
(Adams)
Com. v. James, D. CP-22-CR-0000503-2008
(Dauphin)
Com. v. James, K. CP-41-CR-0001553-2006
(Lycoming)
Com. v. James, L. CP-51-CR-0012657-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. James, T. CP-67-CR-0001345-2001,
CP-67-CR-0001760-2001,
CP-67-CR-0002022-2001
(York)
3449 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Remanded
3180 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
1818 MDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
2144 WDA 2008 08/26/2009 Quashed
3250 EDA 2007 08/20/2009 Affirmed
1373 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
1245 MDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
2164 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
2123 MDA 2007 08/26/2009 Affirmed
2972 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
1425 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Jamison CP-67-CR-0005478-2007
(York)
1350 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Reversed,
Vacated and
Remanded
285 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Jenkins CP-02-CR-0017712-2006
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Johnson, A. CP-51-CR-0010262-2007
(Philadelphia)
1639 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Johnson, Thomas CP-39-CR-0002041-1994
(Lehigh)
3122 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Johnson, Timothy CP-36-R-0002456-2007
(Lancaster)
2065 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Johnson, V. CP-51-CR-0001245-2007
(Philadelphia)
2550 EDA 2007 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Joiner CP-17-CR-0000390-1997
(Clearfield)
1892 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Jones, C. CP-02-CR-0010728-2002
(Allegheny)
1746 WDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Jones, R. 6039-06 (Delaware) 2661 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Jordan CP-25-CR-0000371-2008
(Erie)
1678 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Jovich CP-38-CR-0002026-2007
(Lebanon)
1806 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. C.K. CP-14-CR-0001357-2003
(Centre)
1819 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. M.W.K. CP-14-CR-0001358-2003
(Centre)
1820 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Kaminske CR No. 421-2007 (Venango) 514 WDA 2008 08/28/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
Com. v. Karnam CP-39-CR-0003338-2007
(Lehigh)
3491 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Kemper CP-02-CR-0008374-2001
(Allegheny)
1804 WDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. King CP-51-CR-0111401-2006 &
CP-51-CR-0111411-2006
(Philadelphia)
2332 EDA 2007 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Kleinfelter CP-38-CR-0001605-2007
(Lebanon)
431 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Kougher CP-17-CR-0001127-2007,
CP-17-CR-0001128-2007,
CP-17-CR-0001129-2007,
CP-17-CR-0001130-2007
(Clearfield)
1595 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Kovachick 211 of 2005 (Fayette) 1654 WDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Kupetz CP-11-CR-0001440-2007
(Cambria)
828 WDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. LaSorda CP-46-CR-0006998-2006
(Montgomery)
3008 EDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Lines CP-08-CR-0000052-2008
(Bradford)
1721 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Lippert CP-25-CR-0001665-2005 369 WDA 2009 08/06/2009 Affirmed,
(Erie)
Vacated and
Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Litman CP-63-CR-0001732-2007
(Washington)
1469 WDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Lowenthal CP-09-CR-0005080-2007
(Bucks)
503 EDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Lowrie CP-51-CR-0007759-2007,
CP-51-CR-0007760-2007
(Philadelphia)
345 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. MacInnes CP-09-CR-0000196-2007 3087 EDA 2007 08/11/2009 Affirmed,
(Bucks)
Vacated and
Remanded
Com. v. Mann CP-20-CR-0000153-2005
(Crawford)
1739 WDA 2008 08/05/2009 Remanded
Com. v. Martin CP-23-CR-0006450-2006
(Delaware)
2484 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Martinolich CP-06-CR-0001421-1969
(Berks)
735 MDA 2008 07/22/2009 Affirmed 09/22/2009
Com. v. Mastrangelo CP-35-SA-0000062-2007, CP-
35-SA-0000063-2007, CP-35-
SA-0000064-2007, CP-35-
SA-0000065-2007
(Lackawanna)
1493 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Maxwell CP-51-CR-0008116-2007
(Philadelphia)
1497 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. McBride CP-23-CR-0007874-2007 2974 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Vacated and
(Delaware)
Remanded
Com. v. McFarland CP-06-CR-0004546-2007 1971 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. McGrath
(Berks)
CP-51-CR-0013516-2007
(Philadelphia)
1316 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. McMullen 01-06-0670 (Philadelphia) 2899 EDA 2003 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. McMullen 2483, 2484 CP# 0106-0670,
M.C.# 0308-2479, 2480, 2481,
2482 (Philadelphia)
1271 EDA 2004 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. McWilliams CP-67-CR-0004555-2007
(York)
1231 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Mercurio CP-02-CR-0001700-2007
(Allegheny)
772 WDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Miller CP-38-CR-2355-2007 1749 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Reversed and
(Lebanon)
Remanded
Com. v. Minnich CP-09-CR-0006291-2007
(Bucks)
1407 EDA 2008 07/29/2009 Affirmed 09/23/2009
Com. v. Mitchell CP-36-CR-0000589-2004
(Lancaster)
1950 MDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Mohammad CP-51-CR-0003134-2007
(Philadelphia)
2300 EDA 2007 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Molina CP-06-CR-0002914-2007
(Berks)
1827 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Montgomery CP-08-CR-0000177-2007
(Bradford)
1283 MDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Moody, C. CP-23-CR-0005565-2006
(Delaware)
2601 EDA 2007 08/13/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Moody, J. CP-67-CR-0006243-2005
(York)
1870 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Moore CP-51-CR-0003931-2007,
CP-51-CR-0003934-2007
(Philadelphia)
2541 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Morales, F. CP-51-CR-0205501-2002
(Philadelphia)
1993 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Morales, W. CP-36-CR-0001015-2006;
CP-36-CR-0005077-2006;
CP-36-CR-0005078-2006
(Lancaster)
157 MDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed 10/02/2009
Com. v. Morris CC 2007-01472 (Allegheny) 631 WDA 2008 08/25/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Moyer CPJ 7, pg. 321 (Lancaster) 971 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Mueses CP-67-CR-0004909-2003
(York)
1381 MDA 2007 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Murphy CP-26-CR-0001578-2007
(Fayette)
1408 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Murray, A. CP-51-CR-1300104-2006
(Philadelphia)
1532 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Murray, G. CP-51-CR-0201541-2002
(Philadelphia)
2534 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Murray, T. CP-51-CR-0801161-2003
(Philadelphia)
2168 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Myers CP-36-CR-0002039-1999
(Lancaster)
1951 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Nail CP-20-CR-0000957-2007
(Crawford)
Com. v. Nasir CP-02-CR-0003173-2006
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Nechab CP-15-CR-0003862-2007
(Chester)
Com. v. Ortiz CP-52-CR-0000260-2007
(Pike)
Com. v. Parler CP-67-CR-0000389-2008
(York)
Com. v. Parrotte CP-02-CR-0009498-2001
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Patrick CP-48-CR-0002429-2008
(Northampton)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001594-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001598-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001600-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001601-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001604-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001608-2007
(Centre)
2041 WDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
1433 WDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
3517 EDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
225 EDA 2009 08/24/2009 Affirmed
1448 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
572 WDA 2009 08/06/2009 Affirmed
3247 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
711 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
712 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
713 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
714 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
715 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
716 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Patton CP-14-CR-0001594-2007,
CP-14-CR-0001598-2007,
CP-14-CR-0001600-2007,
CP-14-CR-0001601-2007,
CP-14-CR-0001604-2007,
CP-14-CR-0001608-2007
(Centre)
Com. v. Pegram CP-39-CR-0004529-2007
(Lehigh)
Com. v. Peters, D. CP-22-CR-0004053-2007
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Peters, K. CP-02-CR-0010180-2006
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Philips CP-51-CR-0012502-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Piel CP-38-CR-0002048-2006
(Lebanon)
Com. v. Pierce CP-40-CR-0002503-2003
(Luzerne)
Com. v. Pitts CP-23-CR-0006464-2003
(Delaware)
Com. v. Pleasants CP-51-CR-0014648-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Pollard CP-51-CR-0807361-2001,
CP-51-CR-1001391-2001,
CP-51-CR-1001451-2001,
744 MDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
2152 EDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
1545 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
1118 WDA 2008 08/18/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
1042 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
2125 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
1299 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
740 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
1410 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
2421 EDA 2007 08/11/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
CP-51-CR-1001461-2001,
CP-51-CR-100471-2001, CP-
51-CR-1104451-2001
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Pollard CP-02-CR-0007492-2004
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Preacher CP-23-CR-0001286-2008
(Delaware)
Com. v. Profic CP-06-CR-0005892-2003
(Berks)
Com. v. Queen CP-22-CR-0002072-2007
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Reed CP-36-CR-0002652-1997
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Richardson CP-36-CR-0002246-2004
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Riddick CP-51-CR-0700991-2004
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Roberts CP-46-CR-0005728-2003
(Montgomery)
Com. v. Robertson CP-54-CR-0000615-2005,
CP-54-CR-0000616-2005,
CP-54-CR-0000617-2005,
CP-54-CR-0000618-2005 &
CP-54-CR-0000619-2005
(Schuylkill)
2142 WDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
3480 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
1421 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
858 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
1293 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
1743 MDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
1020 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
225 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
1258 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Rodriguez, O. CP-06-CR-0003634-1992
(Berks)
2145 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Rodriguez, S. CP-06-CR-0000093-2008
(Berks)
1709 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Rodriguez-Malave CP-38-CR-0000833-2004
(Lebanon)
2198 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Rucker CP-51-CR-0010824-2007
(Philadelphia)
2544 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Rufini 633 of 2005 (Erie) 1224 WDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed
Remanded
and
Com. v. Ruoss CP-36-CR-0001147-2002
(Lancaster)
2179 MDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Russell CP-26-CR-0001756-2005 1671 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Vacated and
(Fayette)
Remanded
Com. v. Sakkas CP-42-CR-0000443-2007
(McKean)
648 WDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Com. v. Sanabria CP-67-CR-0000943-1974
(York)
1533 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Santiago CP-06-CR-0005222-2007
(Berks)
843 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Scott MC-51-CR-0035225-2007
(Philadelphia)
2302 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Searcy CP-10-CR-0000781-2004
(Butler)
1677 WDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Seidel CP-06-CR-0001776-2008
(Berks)
Com. v. Sepulveda CP-36-CR-0001540-2006;
CP-36-CR-0001550-2006;
CP-26-CR-0001556-2006
(Lancaster)
Com. v. Serge CP-35-CR-0000260-2001
(Lackawanna)
Com. v. Settles CP-51-CR-0004552-2008
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Shafferman CP-33-CR-0000465-2008
(Jefferson)
Com. v. Sheeler CP-46-CR-0000173-2003,
CP-46-R-0001246-2003, CP-
46-CR-0005652-2003
(Montgomery)
Com. v. Shelton CP-02-CR-0002888-2004
(Allegheny)
Com. v. Smart CP-51-CR-1207781-2002
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Smith, C. CP-51-CR-0006544-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Smith, Jaron CP-51-CR-1302256-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Smith, Juan CP-51-CR-0600141-1995
(Philadelphia)
1824 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
2216 MDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
768 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
2465 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
107 WDA 2009 08/19/2009 Affirmed
2984 EDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
138 WDA 2009 08/20/2009 Remanded
2001 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
889 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
2008 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
2120 EDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Smith, K. CP-41-CR-0001339- 1513 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Vacated and
2007 (Lycoming)
Remanded
Com. v. Smith, R. CP-21-CR-0003001-2007,
CP-21-CR-0003009-2007
(Cumberland)
1411 MDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Smothers 3139 of 2007 (Luzerne) 1353 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Spady CP-51-CR-0801651-2006
(Philadelphia)
1228 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Speech CP-51-CR-0007266-2007
(Philadelphia)
1142 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Splatter CP-67-CR-0001167-2008
(York)
1704 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Stanback CP-51-CR-0208911-2006 3388 EDA 2007 08/19/2009 Vacated and
(Philadelphia)
Remanded
Com. v. Stephens CP-64-CR-0000408-2006
(Wayne)
3321 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Stephens CP-64-CR-0000255-2007
(Wayne)
3319 EDA 2008 08/25/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Stephenson CP-61-CR-0000150-2007 1466 WDA 2008 08/07/2009 Vacated and
(Venango)
Remanded
Com. v. Stirling CP-09-CR-0004237-2005
(Bucks)
986 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Sumpter CP-02-CR-0017389-2007 1719 WDA 2008 08/20/2009 Reversed,
(Allegheny)
Affirmed and
Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Taylor CP-14-CR-0001313-2007
(Centre)
630 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Thomas CP-02-CR-0009080-1988;
CP-02-CR-0009082-1988
(Allegheny)
1573 WDA 2008 07/24/2009 Affirmed 10/09/2009
Com. v. Turner CP-51-CR-1007161-1980
(Philadelphia)
3059 EDA 2008 07/13/2009 Affirmed 09/18/2009
Com. v. Vazquez CP-51-CR-0008875-2007 876 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Reversed and
(Philadelphia)
Remanded
Com. v. Vessells CP-51-CR-0004545-2007
(Philadelphia)
1739 EDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Voneida CP-22-CR-0003356-2007
(Dauphin)
685 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Wade 0002108-2007 (Washington) 1231 WDA 2008 08/05/2009 Quashed
Com. v. Wagner CP-21-CR-0003274-2006
(Cumberland)
1266 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Webb CP-56-CR-0000511-2007,
CP-56-CR-0000512-2007
(Somerset)
1709 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Wesley CP-02-CR-0016392-2007
(Allegheny)
1414 WDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Wheeler CP-51-CR-0314671-1979
(Philadelphia)
406 EDA 2009 08/05/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Whitaker CP-23-CR-0001147-1994
(Delaware)
646 EDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Williams, C. CP-25-CR-0000251-1996
(Erie)
Com. v. Williams, F. CP-15-CR-0001747-2001
(Chester)
Com. v. Williams, G. CP-51-CR-1300927-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Williams, L. CP-41-CR-0000899-2005
(Lycoming)
Com. v. Williams, T. CP-67-CR-0005526-2007
(York)
Com. v. Wilson CP-51-CR-0012077-2007
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Wise CP-51-CR-0002398-2008
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Woodberry CP-51-CR-0203901-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Woodberry CP-51-CR-1300740-2006
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Woodruff CP-51-CR-1000821-2005
(Philadelphia)
Com. v. Woodson CP-22-CR-0005008-2007
(Dauphin)
Com. v. Wright CP-67-CR-0004732-1997
(York)
Com. v. Wysocki CP-23-CR-0004329-2007
(Delaware)
265 WDA 2009 08/19/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
260 EDA 2009 08/11/2009 Affirmed
2776 EDA 2008 08/27/2009 Affirmed
26 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
974 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
921 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
1568 EDA 2008 08/17/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
140 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
1711 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
3341 EDA 2007 08/07/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
1313 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
1801 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
3137 EDA 2008 07/13/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
09/18/2009

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Com. v. Yard CP-51-CR-0402201-2005,
CP-51-CR-0402211-2005
(Philadelphia)
3466 EDA 2006 08/03/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Yohn CP-67-CR-0005242-2007
(York)
1402 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Young CP-51-CR-06040571-2005
(Philadelphia)
2261 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Zelenky CP-17-CR-0000122-2007;
CP-17-CR-0000220-2007;
CP-17-CR-0001282-2006
(Clearfield)
31 WDA 2009 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Ziliox CP-45-CR-0001254-2007
(Monroe)
3492 EDA 2008 08/18/2009 Affirmed
Com. v. Zimmerman CP-36-SA-0000019-2008 1143 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Vacated and
(Lancaster)
Remanded
Com. v. Zitis CP-40-CR-00003328-2007
(Luzerne)
638 MDA 2008 08/28/2009 Affirmed
Com. ex rel Thorne v. Arnold 00-772-DRS PACSES No. 2778 EDA 2008 08/05/2009 Reversed and
117101051 (Delaware)
Remanded
Com./Montgomery Cty. V. Jackson CP-46-CR-0006256-2006 2604 EDA 2007 08/13/2009 Reversed and
(Montgomery)
Remanded
Concordville v. Sucher 05-10352 (Delaware) 2113 EDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed
Constantinidi v. Dambro 04-08025 (Chester) 1148 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Quashed
Cook v. Kimmel S756 of 2008 (Schuylkill) 1209 MDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Crouse v. Crouse 2001-DI-05282-Y02 & 2001- 1611 MDA 2007 08/06/2009 Reversed and
SE-05282-Y15 (York)
Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Crouse v. Crouse 2001-DI-05282-Y02 & 2001-
SE-05282-Y15 & 2001-SU-
05282-02D (York)
Dalembert v. Ohio Casualty 002662 May T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
1839 MDA 2007 08/06/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
3205 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
Direct mail v. Bordo CV 2006-3086 (Northampton) 2318 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Donnelly v. Tosh S-3912-05 (Schuylkill) 1564 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Donnelly v. Tosh A-155-2008 (Schuylkill) 1073 MDA 2008 08/18/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
Dormer v. AAA Mid-Atlantic 2006 CV 5888 CV (Dauphin) 1320 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Dryer v. Cordes 05-8530 (Allegheny) 123 WDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
EMC Mortgage v. Conklin 2006-SU-433 (York) 188 MDA 2008 06/17/2009 Affirmed 10/06/2009
Ebert v. Schwalm 05-3661 (Berks) 1252 MDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Fetterolf v. Hogg 321 of 2008 (Cumberland) 1000 MDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Gorey v. Assoc. Medical 3353 Oct. T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
2525 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Gorey v. Assoc. Medical 3353 Oct. T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
2584 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Harkless v. Trybus 2001 GD 6489 (Blair) 1912 WDA 2008 07/30/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
10/09/2009
Herman v. Berwick Gas 48-E of 2003 (Luzerne) 1220 MDA 2008 07/15/2009 Reversed and 09/22/2009
Remanded
Hertlein v. River Hill Coal 07-1448-CR (Clearfield) 1254 WDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Hirsch v. Hirsch 11323 CD 2007 (Indiana) 54 WDA 2009 08/13/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Huwe v. Huwe 02-9048-008 (Allegheny) 1464 WDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
In Re: A.A. 2002-07-01, Juvenile No.
373251-01 (Philadelphia)
3389 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
In Re: I.A. 2003-07-01, Juvenile No.
373251-02 (Philadelphia)
3537 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Adopt. of E.M. 67 Adoptions 2008
(Cumberland)
2033 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Adopt. of D.J.S. 2006-0157 CP-67-DP- 2069 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Reversed and
0000594-2005 (York)
Remanded
In Re: Adopt. of M.J.S. 283 of 2008 (Fayette) 135 WDA 2009 08/06/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Adopt. of T.M.Z. 80568 (Berks) 61 MDA 2009 08/10/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Auman 14-06-0500 (Centre) 1658 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
In Re: A.B. D#6531-07-11, J#462380-02
(Philadelphia)
2076 EDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
In Re: S.B. D 2871-06-08 June 2008
090006 (Philadelphia)
2389 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Baby A.W. & Baby B.W. O.C. No. 2008-139 A&B
(Crawford)
1613 WDA 2008 07/22/2009 Affirmed 09/22/2009
In Re: Baby A. P/S & Baby B. P/S O.C. No. 2008-140 A&B
(Crawford)
1704 WDA 2008 07/22/2009 Affirmed 09/22/2009
In Re: Distr. Of Atty Fees 08-CV-2099 (Lackawanna) 1112 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Estate of Kazmierczak 1493-2000 (Lackawanna) 1970 MDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Estate of Livingston 535 of 2007 (Fayette) 650 WDA 2008 08/03/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Estate of Rau 2005-0933 (Lehigh) 1824 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Estate of Savitsky 06-178E (Schuylkill) 1563 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Reversed and
Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
In Re: B.F. J1108 of 2007 (Lancaster) 1594 MDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In Re: N.G. DP#33700611, J#39054501
(Philadelphia)
81 EDA 2009 08/07/2009 Affirmed
In Re: S.R.H. 2008-62-OC (Susquehanna) 2199 MDA 2008 07/29/2009 Affirmed 10/06/2009
In Re: Invol. Term./Parental Rights
to H.L.B.
A2008-0106 (Lehigh) 673 EDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Invol. Term./Parental Rights
to M.M.B.
A2008-0107 (Lehigh) 674 EDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
In Re: Invol. Term./Parental Rights
to D.M.B.
A2008-0108 (Lehigh) 675 EDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
In Re: C.P. CP-16-DP-12-2007 (Clarion) 493 WDA 2009 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In Re: S.P. CP-16-DP-10-2007 (Clarion) 491 WDA 2009 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In Re: T.P. CP-16-DP-11-2007 (Clarion) 492 WDA 2009 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In Re: S.V. D 2870-06-08 June 2008
090005 (Philadelphia)
2388 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
In the Interest of B.B. CP-18-DP-0000063-2007 43 MDA 2009 08/07/2009 Vacated and
(Clinton)
Remanded
In the Interest of H.B. CP-18-DP-0000064-2007 44 MDA 2009 08/07/2009 Vacated and
(Clinton)
Remanded
In the Interest of J.C. Petition#00332-08-05 2095 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Vacated, 10/07/2009
(Philadelphia)
Affirmed and
Remanded
In the Interest of G.W.F. CP-06-DP-0000030-2006
(Berks)
193 MDA 2009 08/17/2009 Quashed
In the Interest of S.G. 06-FN-00141-2008, CP-06-
DP-0000029-2006 (Berks)
192 MDA 2009 08/17/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
In the Interest of M.H. 90006 July T., 2008, Juvenile
No. 385384-02 & 385384-03
Petition No. 2799-05-10 &
2800-05-10 (Philadelphia)
In the Interest of T.H. 90007 July T., 2008, Juvenile
No. 385384-02 & 385384-03
Petition No. 2799-05-10 &
2800-05-10 (Philadelphia)
In the Interest of E.M. CP-09-JV-0000899-2008
(Bucks)
In the Interest of J.M. CP-28-DP-0000082-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
In the Interest of J.M. CP-28-DP-0000082-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
In the Interest of L.M. CP-28-DP-0000083-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
In the Interest of L.M. CP-28-DP-0000083-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
In the Interest of M.D.M. 14 WCCB 2008
(Westmoreland)
In the Interest of N.M. A-7247, 7248, 7249, 7250 &
7258 (Luzerne)
In the Interest of Z.M. CP-28-DP-0000084-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
In the Interest of Z.M. CP-28-DP-0000084-2007
(Franklin/Fulton)
3557 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
3558 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Affirmed
3047 EDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed
2176 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
2220 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
2175 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
2221 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
1699 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
478 MDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed
2174 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
2222 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
In the Interest of T.R. 1 January 2006/JV-3-2006
(Washington)
1996 WDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
In the Interest of T.R. A-7099 (Luzerne) 372 MDA 2009 08/20/2009 Affirmed
In the Interest of W.R. CP-738-0801 Juvenile No.
46348601 (Philadelphia)
1679 EDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
In the Interest of N.M.S. Juvenile #323581-02, MC-51-
MD-0000087-2008, MC-51-
MD-0000088-2008, MC-51-
MD-0000089-2008, & SID
#306-27-63-6 (Philadelphia)
990 EDA 2008 07/31/2009 Reversed 09/30/2009
In the Interest of S.M.S. A-7279 (Luzerne) 162 MDA 2009 08/18/2009 Affirmed
In the Interest of C.W.C.T. CP-14-JV-112-2008 (Centre) 2111 MDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Jack v. Jack CI-04-09135 (Lancaster) 581 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Kennedy v. Kennedy 99-14283 (Delaware) 2414 EDA 2007 07/17/2009 Affirmed 09/18/2009
Kennedy v. Kennedy 99-14283 (Delaware) 2597 EDA 2007 07/17/2009 Affirmed 09/18/2009
Kotov v. Kalinnikova 2389-Civil-2008,
307-DR-2008, 5751-
Civil-2008 (Monroe)
3264 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Kozel v. Kozel FD 98-000761-004
(Allegheny)
681 WDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Krasley v. Krasley 2006-FC-1146 (Lehigh) 888 EDA 2009 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Little v. Crozer-Chester 05-14295 (Delaware) 1292 EDA 2008 08/19/2009 Affirmed
Magnus v. Sargent 2007-10188 (Montgomery) 2217 EDA 2008 08/24/2009 Reversed
Mallery v. Mallery 4861 G.N. 1997 (Blair) 1211 WDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed 10/16/2009
Manf. v. Lassiter 3471 April T., 2007
(Philadelphia)
1313 EDA 2008 08/28/2009 Remanded

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Martin v. Crennan A06-07-63871-D-29 (Bucks) 3 EDA 2009 08/11/2009 Quashed
Meyer v. Meyer 1825 of 2006-D
(Westmoreland)
1630 WDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Mitchell v. Guman 001105 Nov. T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
1322 EDA 2008 08/20/2009 Affirmed
Modern v. D’Alessandro 05-51878 (Delaware) 303 EDA 2008 08/04/2009 Reversed and
Remanded
Osprey Ridge v. Graham 2008-2187 (Lackawanna) 2184 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Pernanteau v. Lacey-Bates 08-081512 (Delaware) 3426 EDA 2008 08/17/2009 Affirmed
Powell v. Decker 1770 of 2005 (Centre) 1561 MDA 2007 08/28/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
Price v. Zerega 1890 of 2008 (Fayette) 11 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Ritchey v. Ritchey 850, 1996 (Bedford) 494 WDA 2009 08/26/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
Roland v. Gall 07-CV-3896 (Lackawanna) 554 MDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed and
Remanded
Rossi v. Rossi OCD 2005-8 (Wyoming) 1033 MDA 2008 08/21/2009 Quashed
Sarnosky v. Wilkinson 03 FC 000411 (Bradford) 463 MDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Saunders v. Alexiades GD08-001944 (Allegheny) 423 WDA 2009 08/19/2009 Vacated and
Remanded
Scott v. Scott 8 DR 2006 (Washington) 913 WDA 2008 08/14/2009 Affirmed
Sepulveda v. Thompson 07-7636 (Berks) 1680 MDA 2008 08/10/2009 Affirmed
Servin v. Servin A06-03-60357-Q (Bucks) 1467 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Siegfried v. Siegfried DR-07-01627, Pacses No.
422109122 (Lehigh)
3041 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Smith v. Phillips-Smith 2006-5335 (Washington) 1360 WDA 2008 08/21/2009 Quashed
Spear v. Zibelman 01122 Oct. T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
1109 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Speight v. Mahalis 1499 June T., 2006
(Philadelphia)
1242 EDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Spell v. Jones C0048CV2005-5704
(Northampton)
2646 EDA 2008 08/07/2009 Affirmed
Summerson v. Pifer 2006-1960 (Cameron) 252 WDA 2008 08/26/2009 Quashed
Trust Estate of Colen 83546 (Montgomery) 414 EDA 2008 07/10/2009 Affirmed 09/18/2009
Tuscarora Wayne v. Neff 2008-00419 (Clinton) 1785 MDA 2008 08/26/2009 Affirmed
Vestal v. Vestal 2004-FC-01230-03 (York) 1964 MDA 2008 08/05/2009 Affirmed
Vicchiarelli v. Hrabovsky 5548 CV 1980 (Dauphin) 952 MDA 2008 07/27/2009 Affirmed 10/06/2009
Vile v. Vile A06-07-61261-S-31, Pacses
No. 872109127 (Bucks)
1002 EDA 2008 08/21/2009 Affirmed
Volunteer Medical v. Hynes 001731 Aug. T., 2007
(Philadelphia)
2380 EDA 2008 08/13/2009 Affirmed
Weibley v. Weibley 01-2099 (Cumberland) 473 MDA 2008 08/11/2009 Affirmed
Wells Fargo v. Doe 2008-1199 (Washington) 1550 WDA 2008 07/17/2009 Affirmed 09/22/2009
Williams v. Kelly 03424 June T., 2005
(Philadelphia)
1221 EDA 2008 07/22/2009 Affirmed 09/18/2009
Wollaston v. Plessinger 2003-2584 (Franklin) 1060 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed and
Vacated
Wollaston v. Plessinger 2003-2584 (Franklin) 1182 MDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed,
Reversed and
Vacated

984 A.2d 1004 – 984 A.2d 1033
Woodford v. Braum 2007-563 (Elk) 1267 WDA 2008 08/04/2009 Affirmed
Yu v. 224 East 13 th Streeet 3261 June T., 2006
(Philadelphia)
281 EDA 2008 08/06/2009 Affirmed
Zarra v. Numico GD 02-22529 (Allegheny) 1617 WDA 2007 07/23/2009 Affirmed 10/02/2009
Zavala v. Five-R GD-05-004723 (Allegheny) 1492 WDA 2008 08/07/2009 Quashed
Zavala v. Ritenour G.D. 06-014648 (Allegheny) 1955 WDA 2008 08/20/2009 Vacated,
Reversed and
Remanded