14.12.2012 Views

GEORGEW BUSH '64 DEFEATED IN LANDSLIDE SHARES eevs ...

GEORGEW BUSH '64 DEFEATED IN LANDSLIDE SHARES eevs ...

GEORGEW BUSH '64 DEFEATED IN LANDSLIDE SHARES eevs ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

2 THE PHILipiAN COMMENTARY FEBRUARY 4,2000 ____________<br />

PHILLIFIAN<br />

Volume<br />

z 5 Symbols of ~~~~~~~~~~~~Divisin Hero inNe<br />

Daniel B. Schwerin andmov rhHa m<br />

Tlia er ~.Editor-in-Chief Stars dBars ovrCarolinashr<br />

yan ~ Ch'risitodor0 Zahr .FEchte<br />

Managing Editor Managing Editor<br />

News Commentary Biness Manager<br />

Silla Brush Andrew Chin Andrew Goody<br />

'F~~~~~Jr very Dr. King holiday, I Ad mS irThis is not hard to figure<br />

jj spend some time taking a __________Sklar__ out. George W. Bush wimped<br />

t measure of where race OP<strong>IN</strong>ON out 6n this question in a South<br />

Gilman Barndollar<br />

OSRA W OPNO<br />

CNEVT P O<br />

y the, time you read this article, either in<br />

Macmellan<br />

Spate<br />

Lfuhot Gr pyakeigne-e~<br />

Sports Head<br />

Head KutorpyBale<br />

Charles Resor<br />

B~~~~~~~~Mradeyi Burecto<br />

uw<br />

relations seem to be going in America. Every<br />

year, I regard with no small awe the giant leaps<br />

we have made, from a nation that allowed slav-<br />

~~~~~~~~~~~~~ery,<br />

to a nation that allowed separate schools<br />

Carolina debate. His reticence<br />

came, no doubt, from a desire not to inflame<br />

either side of this tempest, where heels are dug<br />

in hard and few-are budging. We have made<br />

a rolledupcystfeinormalx<br />

B or (like me) a Phillipian pilfered from<br />

Dickey's desk or the mailroom, what I am<br />

writing might not mean anything. I've just<br />

Arts Photography Wendy H~~Ciruang and water fountains, to the nation we have vast progress in remedying- racism, but we stili eundfo oe 5mlsu h odi<br />

Plz htean ed un today, which no longer has one letter of law on have far to go. That task would be greatl New Hampshire. I was returning from the sur-<br />

Scott Sherman<br />

Interim Arts<br />

Interim Features<br />

Luerimkeeatures<br />

Technology<br />

John Marc Imbrescia<br />

the books that discriminates against minorities,<br />

We have had that pedal pressed so far to the<br />

floorboard, in fact, that we have careened into a<br />

helped if we could put aside the cynicism and<br />

rancor with which we approach each other.<br />

I myself have had face to face encounters<br />

piinysmlmdlechogmweeIwa<br />

ketbally gas, h u where tworh hou s ago Ibashetande<br />

ams, piee tof apern a ad<br />

Alida Payson<br />

Cop Editor<br />

Rowan R~iley Internet<br />

Michael Jaffe<br />

Associate Editors<br />

Asci Kate Edit r ff-~<br />

status quo of affirmative action, which can<br />

penalize people for not being minorities. But<br />

~~~~~~this isn't about that. For years, I ha~'e gladly<br />

noted that with each passing year, I expect<br />

with racism, Growing up in New Hampshire<br />

and being a conservative Jew were two aspects<br />

of my life that did not exactly go hand in hand.I<br />

Racist views existed all around me; howeverI<br />

told to finish the arrow pointing to my candidate<br />

for president of the United States.<br />

I took that pen and finished the only arrow<br />

thtpiedoaraledr:JnMca,<br />

JuliaStephens SAbn Gic,<br />

Con, Ln rew<br />

A~Aen s~,C6Btheros, o<br />

m~s, Cooknoo o~o Mucbl ~ ~~'~'have<br />

more Americans to have shed racism, more to<br />

taken steps toward enlightenment, and of<br />

never understood what they meant, or what<br />

racism was. One day in 7th grade my math<br />

Phoenix, Arizona. Journalists and activists<br />

alike can preach for hours about the Democcourse,<br />

more babies to have been born who will teacher gave my class the assignment to make rats' jowly basketball player and wooden Ten-<br />

* A<br />

have no reason to develop a racist bone in their<br />

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~adult<br />

bodies.<br />

posters of our favorite mathematician, and only<br />

the best posters would be put up in the halls.<br />

nessean, or even Phillips Academy's own<br />

George W. Bush, but McCain i the only one<br />

This Year is no different in that regard. Anxious to make the best poster possible, I who really stands for something. John McCain,<br />

Breath aly z r s ,<br />

However, this year there are a couple of issues<br />

swirling around that give me cause to worry<br />

about obstacles hindering further progress. One<br />

is the reaction to all of the "race based" trials,<br />

flew home, conjuring up phenomenal ideas to<br />

create the greatest poster possible. To make a<br />

long and painful story short, I spent hours on<br />

this poster, and it was one of the few chosen to<br />

whether he has triumphed in New Hampshire<br />

or not, remains the true heir to the'conservative<br />

legacy of Barry Goldwater and Ronald Rea-<br />

gan.<br />

In'the wake of Zack Tripp's alcohol-tinged resignation as, stUdent pT~si<br />

The other is the continuing Confederate flag be placed on the walls of the school. The next<br />

flap, ii South Caroli- _____________ morning when I went<br />

Let's even toss out the whole issue of persnlhsoy<br />

cansetfv er en<br />

dent and Upper Representative Joe Maliekel's controversial commentary. na and elsewhere. "Goigu nNwHm sie to my classroom, I saw tortured inHaohvnbmoosot<br />

in ~A last week's .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*<br />

recumrng prob- "Goigu nNwH msiemy poster. A student shoved under his fingemnails, while Bill Clinpiece<br />

Phtllipian, the Deans'Council decided to take U~ ~ lem in the judicial and being a conservative Jew were had taken the liberty of towalesryspnngiminElnd<br />

question of breathalyzers this past week system is the comn- . aigafwchanges Then again, nobody seemed to care for that<br />

two asp Ot for me. In red ma othrrwrkhroeobrole<br />

"We wnt dont necesarily to g down hat roa, but tat's soething mn perception that tW sects of my life that did no forerme.rIneoredomarker<br />

"We don't want necessarily to'go dminorityadefendantsut ehhad drawn a large Sonignor cMc in'nsshheroismBBradley'<br />

we have to consider," said current Dean of Students a.-Ld soon t be Dean of canorhidefehidteeatyg diandantcst vew swatika ar em jumpshots, and Bush's elite upbringing, and<br />

Faculty Stephen Carter. imense wall of were all around me, however I never beautiful work. Standhard-won<br />

civil rights Although the deans' ing there staring concern about at the campus drinking is well merited due I<br />

victories. But I can' understood what they meant, or what poster, I felt hate run<br />

toboth the scope of the problem and the seriousness of the, issue,, this help but notice an I ,, thck through my body.<br />

to ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~a mwsbarely<br />

youatil haeives n on Main, whand upvfry<br />

whteblivsn:JnMca.Wieeer<br />

oiiino h altwspasn tao<br />

poliiin owhallo wcasriingi liethanolH<br />

sbiisi oa cantl tlk ti.H<br />

set foot in the state that is second only to<br />

approach is wrongheaded and should be dismissed immediately. While we echo of the disturbing rimwa..Why did this happen? NwHaphrasaGPknme.Wil<br />

must as a community deal with the underlying problems that produce the,<br />

widespread abuse of alcohol on campus, we must'not tke such a dconiani<br />

pnheoenon werycaesawokngbWka po ad aro<br />

in arin te OJ. Bary impon ase. nd<br />

You might call it the "We don't care about evitatomin<br />

s dfferen<br />

Lokig bck t tht trmetin da brngs<br />

a feeling of disappointment.- a frustration,<br />

Bush shatters every canipaign finance record<br />

known to man, and Honest Al Gore begs Bud-<br />

ditmnsfrdntos canhsfuh<br />

and potentially detrimental measures as the institution of a breceoaisgitthes lc, ow'r einlofuinreadnghwa ruio epl s<br />

policy. breathalyzer ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~him"<br />

syndrome. smart and talented as we are at Phillips Acadepolicy.<br />

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~This<br />

is pernicious, and it keeps racism my could completely miss the ploint. On Martin<br />

the powerful special interest groups that are<br />

udermining two centuries of American<br />

dneorc.Wiems fu eei u vr<br />

The original 1965 Steering Committee;- charged With coiisideringi_'the' alive, If you go back 30 years, plenty of juries Luther King Day we as a school passionately tower at Andover seem to regard gun control<br />

current of the efectivenes poicies andpractices f the andin<br />

currnt ffetivnessof he oliiesand racice oftheAcademy an&<br />

Mississippi or elsewhere tilted justice in a<br />

white direction. We have come to revile this,<br />

discussed the merit of affirmative action, and<br />

during the assembly the, topic solely targeted<br />

and gay marriage as common sense, McCain<br />

represents the majority of Americans who feel<br />

inake recomm~endations for its development in the future," came down hard<br />

againt th kin nd imersoal of iflexble dsciplne sstemthat e ~di,<br />

and properly so. Sadly, however, examples of college admissions. otherwise. While Bush proposes a big tax cut<br />

1 ~ such can still be found today. But we seem College Admissions? We as a community and plenty of budget pork for everyone,<br />

could result from the- use of breathalyzers. According to his jorian FfitZiAls,<br />

primed as a nation to find and stamp out bias<br />

against minorities in our judicial system. The<br />

were tallting about college on a day where we<br />

as the next generation was suppose to think Of<br />

McCain wants to lower the deficit, make sensi-<br />

ble tax cuts, and end a shameful system in<br />

"What the Comm-ittee wanted was a flexible system whereby the house- national dialogue about this is generations old, ways to end racism. No, instead we as an elite which some of our nation's soldiers have to<br />

master, he boy ho est, knew coud deal wth discplinary ases an<br />

maste, wh oy knewthe bet, culd dal wth diciplnary aseson-a<br />

and it should continue. But we must never<br />

allow our empathy for judicial injustice toward<br />

institution were pondering ways to make it easier<br />

for the white majority to get into college. Is<br />

feed their families with food stamps because<br />

military pay is so low.<br />

individual basis." The 1996 Steering Committee stated, "Any good dislcipline<br />

far, ystemshouldbe<br />

fir, undrstanable, nd posess astron eduminorities<br />

to addle us to the extent that we<br />

become tolerant when guilty people follow a<br />

that all this school is about? Is the college you<br />

go to the only substantial result of your time at<br />

The Boston Globe's David Nyhan charac-<br />

terized the McCain campaign as a crusade, and<br />

cational component." -<br />

revenge motive and seek a tilt of justice in their<br />

direction.<br />

Phillips? I was truly insulted by the subject<br />

matter elected to direct our attention towards<br />

I can't think of a better word to describe<br />

McCain's movement. Unlike most elections,<br />

With this in mind, and conscious of the importance of trust and honesty<br />

in every facet of academy life, we find a breathalyzer policy cohtrary to,<br />

The playing field must be level. That<br />

means blacks and whites need to be big boys<br />

and girls when heroes of their respective color<br />

that topic. Sitting in the chapel, I remembered<br />

miy experience in 7th grade. I imagined that<br />

same feeling entering the hearts and minds of<br />

American voters aren't left to choose the less-<br />

er of two evils. John McCain is the kind of<br />

politician America can,'believe in, a straightthese<br />

ideals. The systematic or random use of breathalyzers would be, b'oth (or sex, or political inclination, for that matter) other black, Hispanic, Jewish, and Asian chil- shooter who stands out as a true leader in a<br />

an encroachment on students' individual rights, and a wedge in sttident-fiaculty<br />

relations.- Essentially, we would be turning faculty into police officers<br />

wind up to be criminals. I hope am not asking<br />

too much. I know I am asking for the moon in<br />

wishing that both sides of the Confederate flag<br />

dren, and at that moment I was embarrassed to<br />

be a member of this school. After this MLK<br />

Day, I once again took out the measuring stick<br />

crowd of silver-tongued followers. You proba-<br />

bly know by now if his crusade is on the path<br />

to victory or defeat. Regardless, I hope that all<br />

and students into criminals. ' ' debate would try to walk in the other side's to evaluate the progress of man in the area of of you Massachusetts residents, unless you're<br />

shoes. ~~~~~~~~~racism,<br />

not a small task for a sixteen-year-old. so far gone that you would actually cast a bal-<br />

How would such a policy work? Would roving faculty members armed sos<br />

Whether atop the South Carolina Capitol This year I believe that the country has taken a lot for the liberals, will vote in your primary a<br />

with breathalyzers randomly' te st students on Saturday nights? Perhaps the, dome or woven into the Georgia state flag, the step forward, while the "elite" Phillips Acade- month from now and help John McCain wipe<br />

price o admision<br />

toa danc wouldbe pasing a reathayzer tst .~-or per-, most recognizable Confederate symbol rankles my communt took a step back, that smug smirk off Bush's face.<br />

black Americans, and with good reason. It is<br />

haps it would be part of the face-to-face sign in ritual. Would students be th anrbnat hc hi acsoswr<br />

required to submIit to these tests regardless of proper cause? Would faculty enslaved. Those with an affinity for Confeder-<br />

be the executors of these tests, or perhaps public safety officers? What about atimgraequctopntuthtteeae<br />

multiple reasons for embracing it: a love of hissurprise<br />

or random breathalyzer, tests? Questions abound. tory, a family legacy, a passion for state's 1<br />

It is worth noting that before faculty members can'search drrntoqy rights. They add, quite rightly, that the Civil<br />

rooms- f theacadey proerty - tey mut firt assmble he clster War was not predominantly about slavery, but<br />

room f th acdemy - ropety thy mst frstasseblethe luser, if you were black, it was. ecently, I've found Elizabeth Edmonds ly all right about not being<br />

president, cluster dean, and the student in question. Such an elaborate pro- Guys doing reenactments in period cos- myself dining alone. I -head cheerleader. But wait,<br />

cedureis preseve intnded stuent t pivacy.Shouldwe nothold sarch- tumes have a right not to be presumed racists. R.~.could come up with a OP<strong>IN</strong>ON cheerleading isn't offered at<br />

And those seeking the removal of Confederate number of reasons for this, from PA.<br />

es of students' bodies -not property of the academy .7- to the santehlugh flags are right to point out the divisive flash scheduling, to not choosing a dining hail, to Maybe we make such assumptions on the<br />

standard? on - thedeans' breathaizers ruminatins will remai ~ point that hose flagsicanse.cchangingesocal pattemsgtoeatinghlargeyhelthysbasisuof ournownrpersonalexperiences.MM<br />

Hopefully,<br />

stmdard? po~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~inc<br />

sthat oe flags shoul nie. rteta<br />

dividensSouthiCarolinan shouldaflyrsits flagmalone<br />

snacks between mealtimes; the list goes on.<br />

However, I think I will spare you the reasons.<br />

experiences sitting alone began my junior year<br />

when I dared to enter lower right and to have a<br />

rumination& - there are certainly enough arguments against such a pOlC .<br />

If by some strange logic they decide to move forward, we strongly urge<br />

atop its dome. Georgia should strike the Con-<br />

1, smbo fderte fro it stae fag. ut oth<br />

fdrtsyblro issaefagBubth<br />

states should have Confederate memorials or<br />

ilsaeyuteraosbcuem<br />

instinct is to list such reasons and to try to<br />

explain why I sit alone. I'm afraid that if I do<br />

rpfutaoedrn yfrtpro re<br />

had planned to meet friends and-was embarrassed<br />

about looking lonely. However, I was<br />

d e-fl<br />

them publicy no to do conslting o withut-firs te facuty and tudents exhibts, on heir stte Captoltgrondsiiftheynnonjustifndininoaloneyouederereadrsdand ooonjjoneddbyy benevoentoloertandwerrfon<br />

exhbit, thir tat a Caito grund if fellow eaters in Commons, will immediately lowing of hockey boys, boys for whom I<br />

This potential invasion of privacy and diminishment of student rights would wish, and of course no law will ever keep indi- label me as someone needing the attention of .declared my unrivaled passions to a curious<br />

viduals from flying their Confederate flags the Community Health only be Team and perhaps compounded crowd of Nathan-Hale by the type of girls after back-door summer the "breakfast<br />

policy cange We. fo"hi atr, oefapls r rc orevs<br />

from flapoles, their or rafers, truk home yourselves.experience."<br />

'have seen al too frequently in recent years. --. '' windows. However, in justifying my own reasons for Following this experience, I wondered if<br />

- . ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~sitting<br />

____ DID<br />

alone, in trying to make excuse's about sitting alone would always attract attention. I<br />

- --- - -' - - - ' -------------. - ~~~~~~~~- ~ ~ ~ .~. - - -~ scheduling and not wanting to stay long, I sat alone. It didn't attract much attention. I read.<br />

neglect the reason I actually do sit alone, and I wrote. I thought. I tried to appear confident<br />

M155 ~~~~~~~~~4E i DO~~~~~~~~~~~<br />

b~~~V~~~L ~that is this: I enjoy sitting-alone. 'and deep for fear of appearing lonely. I pre-<br />

4, "I I'll, ~~~~~~I enjoy walking into ,Commons second peri- ferred dining in solitude -to the loud conversa-<br />

D ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~.7 od and having a cup of coffee and a waffle tions about choosing work or friends or sleep. I<br />

while reading the paper, a book, a letter or preferred it to the socially conscious atmoswhile<br />

writing in my joumnal. I enjoy having the phere of many meals, and the novelty of dining<br />

more exciting.<br />

~~ i , -t % I ~~~~.- , fA I<br />

-r-4-- *j(, - watch people come in and overhear bits of their However, the most rewarding solo dining<br />

TYA R? S1dOT? R E~ Ib 4'f quietness and freedom to look outside or to alone made it

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!