16-02-2019
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
EDITORIAL<br />
SATURdAY,<br />
FEBRUARY <strong>16</strong>, <strong>2019</strong><br />
4<br />
US invite to Taiwan's leader would be too risky<br />
Acting Editor & Publisher : Jobaer Alam<br />
Telephone: +88<strong>02</strong>-9104683-84, Fax: 9127103<br />
e-mail: editor@thebangladeshtoday.com<br />
Saturday, February <strong>16</strong>, <strong>2019</strong><br />
The regrettable outflow<br />
of a strategic resource<br />
The 1950's began amid optimism about the<br />
development of Asian countries including<br />
Bangladesh. It was assumed that<br />
investment, education, and modern<br />
management would be sufficient for their<br />
economic growth.<br />
But by the 1960's, disillusionment spread.<br />
The progress of developing countries was<br />
uneven, it fell short of aspirations, the<br />
developed countries grew faster, and therefore<br />
international gaps widened rather than<br />
narrowed. The "brain drain" issue moved from<br />
scholarly analysis and newspaper<br />
recriminations onto the floor of the United<br />
Nations General Assembly in late 1967.<br />
Resolutions introduced by developing<br />
countries demanded that richer members<br />
(particularly the United States) change their<br />
migration policies, encourage foreign students<br />
to learn the skills needed at home, encourage<br />
these students to return, and compensate the<br />
developing countries for losses.<br />
Human capital, as a strategic resource, is<br />
flowing out of the economy of Bangladesh<br />
where it can make the greatest contribution to<br />
human welfare, and into economies already<br />
well-supplied with trained, capable, scientific<br />
and administrative personnel.<br />
A nation is considered to be modern and<br />
advanced by surveying the extents of its<br />
technological developments in the field of<br />
science and industry. The main sources of the<br />
knowledge and know-how for these<br />
technologies are the educated and motivated<br />
individuals who include scientists, doctors,<br />
engineers, teachers, business pioneers, etc.<br />
But in a country like Bangladesh where most<br />
of the people are illiterate, advancement in<br />
development is at stake. On the other hand, the<br />
ones who are educated and capable of<br />
contributing towards the growth of the nation,<br />
prefer to live abroad. There is a significant<br />
number of highly educated Bangladeshis<br />
abroad who contribute to the welfare of foreign<br />
countries.<br />
Statistics show that 65 per cent of the newly<br />
graduated doctors in Bangladesh attempt to<br />
practice abroad. While in the country, there are<br />
millions of children suffering from<br />
malnutrition and childhood diseases. One can<br />
only imagine what improvements the newly<br />
graduates could have made in the country if<br />
they were to practice there. Moreover, every<br />
year thousands of people die due to untreated<br />
diseases.<br />
Even though there are some free treatment<br />
opportunities, the doctors that are available are<br />
usually inexperienced. The public is well aware<br />
of this fact and, therefore, whenever a<br />
complicated operation is to be performed, the<br />
patient, if he happens to be from wealthy<br />
family, is rushed to either Singapore, India or<br />
Thailand. The fate of the poor patient, on the<br />
other hand, lies in the hands of the<br />
inexperienced doctor.<br />
The generally held conception among the<br />
people of Bangladesh is that anything "foreign"<br />
is better. They would rather go and struggle to<br />
survive in a richer country than struggle in their<br />
own land. The underdeveloped countries have<br />
found themselves woefully short of technical<br />
and professional personnel in the key<br />
administrative and research positions. Today,<br />
as never before, there is a "common market" for<br />
brain power which transcends national<br />
boundaries. The improved transportation and<br />
communication available have facilitated the<br />
increased rate of brain drain that drags<br />
Bangladesh backwards into ignorance.<br />
The cream of our students is migrating for<br />
overseas institutions of higher learning-some<br />
through scholarships, others by self-finance;<br />
very few of them ever return. If this trend of<br />
brain drain continues, Bangladesh will surely<br />
face major challenges, if not facing them<br />
already, in the initial decades of this century.<br />
Neighbours such as India and Pakistan have<br />
taken several initiatives to bring back their<br />
expatriates from overseas destinations. It is<br />
high time for our government to act and take<br />
measures to address the situation of brain drain<br />
by initiating discussions with the Bangladeshi<br />
immigrants.<br />
With US President Donald<br />
Trump preparing for his<br />
second summit with Kim<br />
Jong Un and tensions between<br />
Beijing and Washington continuing to<br />
intensify, a group of five key American<br />
senators wrote a letter to House<br />
Speaker Nancy Pelosi urging her to<br />
invite Taiwan's unpopular president<br />
to address a joint session of Congress.<br />
Many onlookers have struggled to<br />
define exactly what that invitation will<br />
mean for the Taiwan Strait if it is<br />
extended. Is there a danger that the<br />
gesture will exacerbate tensions<br />
between the United States and China?<br />
China is one of America's' rivals and<br />
has constantly pressed Taiwan into<br />
submission, and tried to stifle it and<br />
maintain the fiction of the one-China<br />
policy. Beijing has continued to escalate<br />
rhetoric and actions that threaten<br />
Taiwan's democracy and sovereignty.<br />
The only way to preserve Taiwanese<br />
democracy, at this moment, is the<br />
status quo and measured, practical<br />
policy. It's a good thing the vast<br />
majority of Taiwanese voters<br />
understand this.<br />
Taiwan needs Washington's strong<br />
support, but the Americans should be<br />
careful not to adopt a belligerent<br />
posture. Relations between Beijing and<br />
SAUDI Crown Prince<br />
Mohammad bin Salman is set to<br />
arrive in Pakistan tomorrow.<br />
The visit will play an important role<br />
in strengthening the two countries'<br />
economic ties, with MBS ready to<br />
commit to a historic investment in<br />
Pakistan. Last year, Prime Minister<br />
Imran Khan travelled to Riyadh to<br />
negotiate a bailout package, which<br />
led to a $6 billion pledge from the<br />
kingdom.<br />
This significant financial support is<br />
undoubtedly a welcome relief to our<br />
economy. However, as the crown<br />
prince and our premier establish the<br />
agenda for the upcoming visit, it is<br />
important that the latter prioritise<br />
the issue of the over 3,300 Pakistanis<br />
currently languishing in Saudi<br />
prisons with the foreign delegation.<br />
Despite being a crucial geopolitical<br />
ally, the kingdom executes more<br />
Pakistanis than any other foreign<br />
nationality, with at least 20<br />
executions in 2014, 22 in 2015, seven<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>, 17 in 2017, and 30 in 2018 -<br />
nearly 100 in the last five years.<br />
Our governments of the past have<br />
taken no notice of these prisoners'<br />
situation, providing little in the way<br />
of legal or financial assistance, partly<br />
due to a lack of proper protocols<br />
provided to Pakistani missions and<br />
largely due to political indifference.<br />
As former chief justice of the Lahore<br />
High Court, Justice Syed Mansoor<br />
Ali Shah remarked in 2017: "It<br />
appears that the government has<br />
adopted a policy of 'no policy' on<br />
overseas Pakistanis in Arab countries<br />
especially."<br />
On Feb 13, Foreign Minister Shah<br />
Mehmood Qureshi assured that the<br />
THE Warsaw meeting seems to<br />
have failed before it even started.<br />
This is due mainly to what players<br />
in the Middle East see as an<br />
unprecedented retreat by US President<br />
Donald Trump's administration in the<br />
face of an assertive Russia and Iran.<br />
The conference, as expected, did not<br />
rally consensus for a serious drive to<br />
change the behavior of the Iranian<br />
regime, since the objectives of those<br />
meeting in Warsaw were so divergent on<br />
the means to confront Tehran in the<br />
region and globally.<br />
Maybe the US and Europe should<br />
instead have called for a Euro-US<br />
meeting to counter the Russian and<br />
Iranian Trojan horses within the West,<br />
which have been interfering in elections,<br />
funding radicals, and promoting an anti-<br />
Western narrative.<br />
The US retreat from the Middle East<br />
under the Trump administration is<br />
making allies jittery, and Trump's style of<br />
erratic decisions on international affairs<br />
is pushing all those who orbit the US<br />
model of liberal democracy to scramble<br />
for containment or bilateral deals to<br />
circumvent America's chaotic foreign<br />
policy.<br />
The conference was surely a good<br />
photo opportunity but, as it drew to a<br />
close on Valentine's Day, it reflected how<br />
fractured our world has become.<br />
The US withdrawal from Syria, the<br />
inefficiency of US policies and military<br />
interventions in Iraq and Afghanistan,<br />
the trade wars with China, the alleged<br />
collusion with Vladimir Putin's Russia,<br />
Washington have been tense in recent<br />
months, and because the US does not<br />
officially recognize Taiwan's<br />
government and there are so many<br />
global flashpoints that could quickly<br />
divert the Trump administration's<br />
attention, there is a concern is that the<br />
US might take an outspoken stance on<br />
Taiwan and then suddenly soften its<br />
tone, which could leave the island in an<br />
even more vulnerable position.<br />
Taiwan is just a part of the broader<br />
context of Sino-American relations. If<br />
Beijing is taking some hard knocks as a<br />
way of expressing displeasure with<br />
Washington's actions, it pays a price in<br />
inviting President Tsai Ing-wen.<br />
Experts on Taiwan said the senators'<br />
proposal is flawed and Taiwan would<br />
suffer, as a gesture that intended to help<br />
KENT WANg<br />
it would only hurt it. This is because<br />
Beijing would take the opportunity to<br />
squeeze Taipei even more than it is<br />
already.<br />
Washington exercises tremendous<br />
influence on the Taiwan issue. How the<br />
US Congress exercises that influence<br />
could well affect the future prosperity<br />
and safety of 23 million people. Taiwan<br />
must maintain a balanced relationship<br />
with the United States on the one hand<br />
Washington exercises tremendous influence on the Taiwan<br />
issue. how the US Congress exercises that influence could well<br />
affect the future prosperity and safety of 23 million people.<br />
Taiwan must maintain a balanced relationship with the United<br />
States on the one hand and with China on the other. Will inviting<br />
Taiwan's president to Washington mean wading into a conflict in<br />
the Taiwan Strait that could escalate into outright war?<br />
government would raise this issue,<br />
specifically regarding those who have<br />
been incarcerated for petty crimes,<br />
with the Saudi delegation. It is great<br />
that the government has begun to<br />
acknowledge the plight of citizens<br />
imprisoned overseas.<br />
Over 3,300 Pakistanis are currently<br />
languishing in Saudi prisons.<br />
However, the government has an<br />
obligation to afford the protection of<br />
the law to all Pakistanis wherever<br />
they may be, as per the Constitution,<br />
especially those who face the<br />
harshest punishments. Pakistanis<br />
imprisoned abroad have to navigate<br />
local courts without access to<br />
lawyers, impartial translators, or<br />
adequate consular assistance. They<br />
are at a significant disadvantage due<br />
to their lack of understanding of the<br />
legal process, incapability to<br />
communicate directly with the court,<br />
and inability to produce evidence<br />
from Pakistan in their defence.<br />
The recent spate of executions of<br />
Pakistanis carried out by Saudi<br />
Arabia have come at a time when our<br />
government and the kingdom are<br />
negotiating a prisoner transfer<br />
agreement (PTA), which would allow<br />
and with China on the other. Will<br />
inviting Taiwan's president to<br />
Washington mean wading into a<br />
conflict in the Taiwan Strait that could<br />
escalate into outright war? The<br />
invitation is contrary to a fundamental<br />
principle of US relations with China<br />
and for Washington, it could be a fatal<br />
strategic blunder.<br />
A more urgent PTA<br />
MUhAMMAd USMAN<br />
thousands of Pakistani prisoners to<br />
be repatriated, making it easier to<br />
investigate the circumstances of their<br />
alleged crimes and allowing them the<br />
dignity of returning home and<br />
completing their sentences.<br />
The last government seemed to<br />
have made some progress in March<br />
2018. The federal cabinet approved<br />
prisoner transfer agreements with<br />
China and Saudi Arabia, subject to<br />
the 'respective inputs' of the foreign,<br />
The PML-N government suspended all PTAs in 2015 as prisoners<br />
repatriated from Britain were set free without completing their<br />
sentences under dubious circumstances. These PTAs were eventually<br />
reinstated by a Supreme Court order in April last year but it is unclear<br />
whether they are still in force, since the current government has<br />
announced that it is negotiating PTAs with the UAE and Britain.<br />
Trump's reservations on the EU as a<br />
whole, and his questioning of NATO's<br />
role are examples that will make many<br />
diplomats jittery around US Secretary of<br />
State Mike Pompeo in Warsaw.<br />
The proposed meeting of 70-plus<br />
foreign ministers in Poland was<br />
eventually watered down to 50 or 60<br />
senior representatives, mainly ministers,<br />
deputy ministers and ambassadors: A<br />
game of numbers that makes Iran,<br />
Russia and their allies grin. The initial<br />
conference theme of containment of Iran<br />
also shifted to become a "Ministerial to<br />
Promote a Future of Peace and Security<br />
in the Middle East" in order to<br />
accommodate allies with economic<br />
interests with Iran, mostly Europeans.<br />
Iran's Foreign Minister Mohammed<br />
Javad Zarif has dubbed the meeting in<br />
Poland the "Warsaw Circus".<br />
Many Arab countries have for long held<br />
Iran responsible for incitement and<br />
meddling in their affairs, exporting its<br />
Islamic revolution through propping up<br />
groups loyal to its cause in Iraq, Lebanon,<br />
MohAMEd ChEBARo<br />
defence and law ministries.<br />
However, no evident progress has<br />
been made on this front and 24<br />
Pakistanis have been executed since<br />
April last year. These Pakistanis<br />
could have been repatriated and<br />
reunited with their families had the<br />
PTA been finalised.<br />
The PML-N government<br />
suspended all PTAs in 2015 as<br />
prisoners repatriated from Britain<br />
were set free without completing<br />
their sentences under dubious<br />
circumstances. These PTAs were<br />
eventually reinstated by a Supreme<br />
Court order in April last year but it is<br />
unclear whether they are still in<br />
force, since the current government<br />
has announced that it is negotiating<br />
Syria, Bahrain, Yemen and Gaza to<br />
undermine the states and societies of<br />
those countries.<br />
Trump walked away from what he<br />
called a "terrible" 2015 nuclear deal<br />
negotiated by his predecessor Barack<br />
Obama, which left Tehran free to develop<br />
its ballistic missile technology and pursue<br />
its indirect military interference in many<br />
Arab countries. But the EU has defied<br />
Trump and kept its commitment to the<br />
accord by setting up a financial tool for<br />
European firms to skirt US sanctions and<br />
keep doing business in the Middle East's<br />
second most populous country.<br />
Even Poland - always eager to please<br />
Washington as it fears a resurgent Russia<br />
- has been at pains to continue backing<br />
the agreement. Poland, as co-host, even<br />
chose to tone down the conference's aims<br />
to a vague goal of seeking peace in the<br />
Middle East, rather than mentioning<br />
Iran as the main precursor for the<br />
meeting.<br />
European officials, especially those<br />
from France and Germany, are livid<br />
The use of military force would be<br />
catastrophic for those on both sides<br />
of the Taiwan Strait, and for the<br />
region. But how far does the United<br />
States intend to push this? And why<br />
would Washington conclude that<br />
this ill-considered symbolic gesture<br />
is worth the risk? The invitation<br />
would make substantive cross-Strait<br />
progress more difficult, not less.<br />
That these questions must now be<br />
considered highlights the disorderly<br />
nature of US-Taiwan-China trilateral<br />
relations.<br />
Concern over China's reaction is the<br />
main reason Congress would choose<br />
not to invite President Tsai. The<br />
Americans should ask themselves<br />
whether hosting a speech by an<br />
unpopular Taiwanese president is<br />
worth taking such a risk.<br />
If the president of Taiwan were to<br />
speak to a joint meeting of Congress, it<br />
would provoke an enormous backlash<br />
from Beijing. An act such as allowing<br />
her to address Congress might be just<br />
the excuse Beijing would use to take<br />
military action. Would the United<br />
States really commit forces to that fight,<br />
treaty or not? I hope we never get to<br />
find out.<br />
Source : Asia Times<br />
PTAs with the UAE and Britain.<br />
Regardless, it is crucial that these<br />
PTAs are finalised at once. It is<br />
equally important that our<br />
government demand that the Saudi<br />
government halt all executions until<br />
a PTA is finalised. Otherwise,<br />
prisoners that could be repatriated<br />
would remain at the mercy of judges<br />
who can overturn their sentences<br />
without any forewarning. Last year,<br />
Justice Project Pakistan came to<br />
know that several Pakistanis<br />
imprisoned in Saudi Arabia had their<br />
life sentences converted to death<br />
sentences without any forewarning.<br />
Several of these Pakistanis have<br />
already been executed.<br />
Pakistan will not be alone in its<br />
demand for the repatriation of its<br />
prisoners. India has negotiated an<br />
extradition treaty with Saudi Arabia,<br />
and the UK, US and Philippines have<br />
all signed prisoner transfer<br />
agreements with Saudi Arabia in the<br />
past. At a time when we are<br />
furthering our economic relationship<br />
with the Saudis, it is important to<br />
remember that a humanitarian<br />
obligation exists too.<br />
Finalising a PTA with Saudi Arabia<br />
and demanding that the Saudi<br />
government halt all executions of<br />
Pakistanis until a PTA is finalised<br />
would be an excellent step towards<br />
fulfilling a commitment Mr Khan<br />
made in his emphatic first speech<br />
upon taking office. It would prove<br />
that our relationship with Saudi<br />
Arabia is a mutually respectful one,<br />
one that goes beyond photo-ops,<br />
economic or military ties.<br />
Source : Dawn<br />
US-EU discord evident at troubled Warsaw summit<br />
The proposed meeting of 70-plus foreign ministers in Poland was eventually watered<br />
down to 50 or 60 senior representatives, mainly ministers, deputy ministers and<br />
ambassadors: A game of numbers that makes Iran, Russia and their allies grin. The<br />
initial conference theme of containment of Iran also shifted to become a "Ministerial<br />
to Promote a Future of Peace and Security in the Middle East" in order to<br />
accommodate allies with economic interests with Iran, mostly Europeans.<br />
about the conference, which they see not<br />
only as an attempt to increase pressure<br />
on Iran, but also to lead EU members<br />
into rubber-stamping the US' Middle<br />
East agenda, as championed by the<br />
president's son-in-law and senior<br />
adviser, Jared Kushner.<br />
The sole senior EU power to send its<br />
foreign minister will soon be leaving<br />
the bloc. British Foreign Secretary<br />
Jeremy Hunt agreed to attend, if only<br />
to ratchet up support for a flagging<br />
Yemen cease-fire.<br />
The conference was surely a good<br />
photo opportunity but, as it drew to a<br />
close on Valentine's Day, it reflected how<br />
fractured our world has become and how<br />
tense the relationship between Europe<br />
and the US is. Meanwhile, the absence of<br />
Russia and China is an indication of the<br />
failure of multilateral action and<br />
diplomacy in the world today.<br />
Even amongst traditional allies,<br />
differences were prominent in Warsaw,<br />
as conflict in the Middle East intersected<br />
with other global crises like the fear of<br />
Russian assertiveness returning to<br />
Eastern Europe and the rise in tensions<br />
within the EU due to the growth of rightwing<br />
populism.<br />
If anything, Warsaw should have been<br />
a venue for Europe to clear the air with<br />
Washington, as EU officials have<br />
expressed outrage at the US' alleged<br />
efforts to widen divisions within the bloc<br />
and encourage members to leave the<br />
union or downgrade ties with Brussels.<br />
Source : Arab News