18.12.2012 Views

FIREBREAK 4H Full Presentation - ArcelorMittal

FIREBREAK 4H Full Presentation - ArcelorMittal

FIREBREAK 4H Full Presentation - ArcelorMittal

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The Certified Fire wall


Why the Firestop wall?<br />

• Insulate and keep a fire in ONLY ONE cell of a building<br />

• Avoid the structure and the front fall towards the outside<br />

– Secure intervention of firefighters & emergency services<br />

– Optimize rescues<br />

• Meet the new insurance companies requirements<br />

– 4h certified !


<strong>Presentation</strong> Plan<br />

• Section I: Firewall Firebreak 4h general presentation<br />

• Section II: Firewall Firebreak 4h detailed presentation<br />

• Section III: Firewall Firebreak 4h CSTB Certification Test<br />

• Section IV: Firebreak system promotion & development<br />

• Section V: Extra part on Fire regulation


Section I<br />

Firewall Firebreak<br />

General <strong>Presentation</strong>


Firebreak 4h: Description<br />

• Standard panels :<br />

– Length: 2,50 m<br />

– Height: 1,25 m<br />

– Thickness: 170 mm<br />

• Smaller panels available (for adaptation to the<br />

wall dimensions)<br />

• ALUZINC coating<br />

• Less than 100 kg/m 2<br />

• Steel structure on each side


Internal Composition<br />

• Symmetrically, successive coats of :<br />

– Cellular glass (Foamglas)<br />

– Plaster (Prégyfeu)<br />

– Core in Fibro-silicate<br />

– + bonding (special glue)<br />

Steel sheet<br />

in ALUZINC<br />

Foamglas<br />

Plaster<br />

Fibro-silicate<br />

Plaster<br />

Foamglas<br />

Steel sheet<br />

in ALUZINC<br />

17 cm


Main Advantages<br />

• Light construction with a good stability<br />

• Flexible (easy to dismantle, well adapted for the renovation)<br />

• No foundations needed (pressure on the ground surface around<br />

1kg/cm 2 a height of 15 meters) => construction simplified, removable<br />

and reusable<br />

• Delivery in standard panels ready for use<br />

• Easy erection by a steel fabricator<br />

• 4h ISO-fire resistance attested by the approved French laboratory of<br />

the CSTB, for a height of 15m with unlimited width


Main Advantages<br />

• The only one fire wall system in the market (4h, 15m) certified<br />

• Collapse towards the side of the fire, therefore no risk for firefighting<br />

and rescue teams<br />

• Good thermal insulation : Maximum temperature of 120 degrees on the<br />

outer face<br />

• Good acoustic insulation => Rw (C t r) = 43 (-1, -3) dB<br />

• Aluzinc Benefits : aesthetics (naturally silver), excellent resistance to<br />

corrosion, officially approved for food storage application<br />

(according to the standard NFA 36-712-6 April 2006) : No specific<br />

treatment or additional surface is to be added


Sustainable Advantages<br />

• Free of fibers : Inside the wall, mineral, insulating and non<br />

combustible materials (M0)<br />

• Guaranteed corrosion protection against perforation<br />

• Dry system (doesn’t require water during construction phase)<br />

• Doesn’t emit toxic substances (gases and fumes) during normal<br />

conditions and in case of fire<br />

• Recyclable and environmentally inert materials


Sustainable Advantages<br />

• Safe working conditions during erection<br />

(light elements)<br />

• Fast, easy and cheap installation process<br />

• Allows less disruptive refurbishment for<br />

existing buildings<br />

• Possibility of re-use and relocate the wall<br />

• Storage on pallets, less space needed,<br />

less trucks, less fuel consumption


Scope of applications<br />

Industry<br />

Combustible<br />

Materials<br />

Warehouses<br />

Refurbishment /<br />

Rehabilitation<br />

Warehousing<br />

companies<br />

Food storage<br />

Theatres /<br />

Concert halls<br />

Refrigerating<br />

industry<br />

Other possible applications :<br />

Maritime/Naval<br />

applications


Section II<br />

Firewall Firebreak<br />

Detailed <strong>Presentation</strong>


Mechanism<br />

• The wall is supported by a steel<br />

structure on each side<br />

• The structure doesn’t bear the wall …<br />

but the FRAME !<br />

• Fuse fixations : bimetallic strip joined<br />

with tin<br />

=> when the tin casts, the steel<br />

structure comes off and sags on the fire.


Steps of fire expansion in a warehouse cell<br />

• Start of fire in a cell<br />

• Vertical fire expansion


Steps of fire expansion in a warehouse cell<br />

• Accumulation of warm<br />

gas under the roof<br />

• Deformation of the frame<br />

• Fusible connections<br />

ensure that the link<br />

between wall and heated<br />

structure disappears


Steps of fire expansion in a warehouse cell<br />

• The fire is spreading in<br />

the burn-out cell.<br />

• The structure collapses<br />

on the fire.<br />

• <strong>Full</strong>y developed fire and<br />

failure of the heated<br />

structure. The wall<br />

supported by the<br />

structure on cold side<br />

ensures 4 hours of fire<br />

resistance.


Steps of fire expansion in a warehouse cell<br />

• Fire is decreasing /<br />

Decay phase of the fire<br />

• Protected by Firebreak,<br />

the adjacent cell on the<br />

cold side is safe. It is not<br />

damaged.


Structure and fitting: Fastening systems<br />

Fuses on 5 m x 5 m grid<br />

Traditional endwall structures<br />

Designed to resist wind and roof loads: manufacturer does not need to<br />

make specific allowance for fire-resistance capability.


Layout of fuses on endwal structures<br />

on either side<br />

5 m<br />

5 m<br />

5 m<br />

5 m<br />

5 m 5 m 5 m 5 m<br />

Standard design :<br />

One fuse every 5 metres : 1 fuse for 25 square metres


Firebreak 4h: structure and assembly<br />

Exceptional reliability:<br />

4 hours / 15 metres high / unlimited width<br />

Wall density<br />

98.75 kg/m 2<br />

Structure (beams)<br />

Special fasteners<br />

Firebreak wall<br />

Horizontal & vertical<br />

joints<br />

Floor fastening


Overall view, elevation<br />

Standard panel Non-standard panel, type 1 Non-standard panel, type 2<br />

Fast elevation with two team works


Structure and assembly<br />

Unlimited<br />

width<br />

Assembly method<br />

• Assembly with small mobile crane<br />

• Easy fitting (slot-in)<br />

Approximate weight of panel<br />

300 kg<br />

Firebreak wall up to 15 metres high


Structure and assembly: joints<br />

Aluzinc strip, 1 mm thick<br />

Aluzinc facing, 1 mm thick<br />

Horizontal and vertical assembly<br />

Steel hat-section rail, 1.2 mm thick<br />

Palusol PM<br />

A2 stainless steel Lag screw<br />

TH 6 x 80<br />

ZN steel self-tapping screw<br />

TH 4.7 x 16


Structure and fitting:<br />

Floor fastening<br />

Levelling mortar base<br />

(thickness as required)<br />

Concrete floor slab<br />

Concrete<br />

Floor fastening<br />

- Generally no need to strengthen<br />

an existing concrete slab<br />

- “U” or flat section performs<br />

fastening rail and levelling<br />

functions<br />

- Fastening on existing concrete<br />

• Time savings<br />

• Clean, dry worksite<br />

• Lower assembly costs<br />

Floor surface pressure around 1 kg/cm 2 for partition 15<br />

metres high


Lifting spreader supplied


Structure and fitting:<br />

Extention through façade and roof<br />

50 cm<br />

Façade<br />

1 m<br />

Roof


Section III<br />

Firewall Firebreak<br />

CSTB Certification test


Fitting of hat-section assembly profiles<br />

and lag bolts


Intumescent strip and screw-down closure<br />

sheet


Test load corresponding to height of 15 meters<br />

Test carried out by CSTB


CSTB certification test<br />

After 4 hours 15 minutes in standard fire conditions, only half the<br />

thickness has been destroyed.


CSTB evaluation & test report


CSTB evaluation & rating report<br />

II – Findings<br />

II.1 – Rating criteria: standard<br />

II.1.1 – Load-bearing capacity<br />

Duration: 240 minutes<br />

II.1.2 – Flame and fume seal-off<br />

Duration: 240 minutes<br />

II.1.3 – Heat insulation<br />

Duration: 240 minutes<br />

II.2 – Laboratory evaluation basis<br />

II.2.1 – Test report n° RS07-050<br />

(self-supporting wall, load 1162 daN / ml)


Section IV<br />

Firebreak system<br />

Promotion &<br />

Development


Exhibition at Batimat trade show in Paris,<br />

November 2007


Exhibition at Expoprotection trade show<br />

in Paris, November 2008<br />

In recognition to its innovative characteristics, the<br />

Firebreak Wall <strong>4H</strong> has received a the Innovation award


Development<br />

• Firebreak 2 hours : height 15 m<br />

• Firebreak 1 hour : height 12,5 m<br />

• Acoustic tests of Firebreak 4hours<br />

• Getting European Technical<br />

Accreditations<br />

• Floor and ceiling firestop<br />

=> High Buildings


Section V<br />

Extra Part on<br />

Fire regulation


Regulations<br />

…require compliance with structural<br />

fire-resistance rating criteria


Fire resistance rating criteria<br />

• R (SF): mechanical resistance time under standard test<br />

conditions of ISO 834 � load-bearing structures<br />

• RE or E (PF): flame and fume seal-off time � partition<br />

structures (slabs, walls)<br />

• REI or EI (CF): heat insulation (140°C on face opposite to fire)<br />

� partition structures (slabs, walls)


Regulation and decrees<br />

General texts<br />

Decrees, orders, circulars<br />

French Ministry of Ecology & Sustainable Development<br />

• Decree of 5 August 2002 on prevention of disasters in<br />

covered warehouses requiring authorization under item 1510<br />

(Official Journal of 1 January 2003, page 50)<br />

• Decree giving innovative specification of clear objectives


Measures on fire resistance of warehouses<br />

Article 6 (� specific objectives)<br />

“In general terms, construction measures seek to ensure that<br />

collapse of a particular item (wall, roof, pillar, beam, etc.) does not<br />

lead to a domino-effect collapse of the building structure as a<br />

whole (typically the neighbouring storage cells, or the partitions<br />

between them), and that if collapse occurs it does so within rather<br />

than outside the initial fire zone.”


Physical data<br />

• Survival is possible up to 80°C (or possibly 150°C for firefighters<br />

in special clothing).<br />

• Usual materials resist temperatures up to 500°C and beyond.<br />

• When materials reach 500°C, the local ambient temperature is<br />

much higher.<br />

• Conclusion: Conditions have ceased to be life-sustaining long<br />

before structural collapse occurs in the fire


Consequences<br />

• Local collapse of a structure in a fire is not a catastrophe in itself<br />

provided that we can be certain there are no people alive in the<br />

collapse zone….<br />

BUT<br />

• Collapse of one item must not lead to collapse in structures not<br />

affected (or less affected) by the fire, which may not yet have<br />

been vacated or which may be occupied by firefighters � Domino<br />

collapse must be avoided.<br />

In most cases, the feasibility of rescuing victims in a<br />

building on fire depends not so much on the fire resistance<br />

of the structure as on the risk of domino collapse.


Domino collapse, illustration<br />

Metal racks absorbed domino collapse of the structure in prestressed<br />

concrete


Objective: inward collapse kinematics<br />

• Metal structures usually respond well to this criteria.<br />

• A design guide is available, based on a parametric study by<br />

CTICM (SCMF site).<br />

• CTICM = Centre Technique et Industriel de la Construction Métallique (Steel construction<br />

technical and industrial institute)<br />

• SCMF = Syndicat de la Construction Métallique de France (French Constructional Steelwork<br />

Association)


« Item 1510 » storage warehouses :<br />

compartmentalization and layout<br />

Article 9<br />

Storage cells should be limited in surface area to reduce the<br />

amount of combustible material burning in the event of fire, and<br />

prevent fire propagating from one cell to another.<br />

Storage cells should not exceed 3,000 square metres if there is no<br />

automatic fire extinguishing system, or 6,000 square metres if there<br />

is an automatic fire extinguishing system.


« Item 1510 » storage warehouses :<br />

compartmentalization and layout<br />

Article 8<br />

Storage warehouses should be split up into cells to reduce the<br />

amount of combustible material burning in the event of fire.<br />

Compartmentalization should be capable of preventing fire<br />

propagating from one cell to another.<br />

To meet this objective, the cells must meet the following<br />

requirements:<br />

• The partitions between the storage cells must have a firebreak<br />

capability of at least two hours.


« Item 1510 » storage warehouses :<br />

compartmentalization and layout<br />

• The partitions must continue through the roof and extend at least<br />

1 metre above it at this point. Either the roof must be covered<br />

with a protective strip extending over a width of least 5 metres on<br />

either side of the partitions, or alternatively, if warranted, a dry<br />

standpipe may be fitted along the partitions to afford similar<br />

protection.<br />

• Unless the outer walls have a one-hour firebreak capability, cell<br />

partitions must extend through the outer walls and terminate<br />

either in a section 1 metre wide along the outer walls, or extend<br />

for 0.50 metres beyond the outer walls.


Storage compartmentalization and layout<br />

Fire partition walls may be arranged in any configuration with<br />

respect to the load-bearing structure.


APSAD Regulation<br />

Regulatory minimum<br />

requirements can be tightened<br />

by additional requirements<br />

specific to insurance<br />

companies.


APSAD Regulation<br />

2.1 – Purpose<br />

2 – Firebreak partitions<br />

A firebreak partition (FBP) separates two buildings or two parts of the same building<br />

so that fire breaking out on one side of the partition will not propagate to the other<br />

side.<br />

2.2 – Behaviour in fire<br />

A firebreak partition must be rated to at least REI 240, whichever side is exposed to<br />

the fire risk. The fire resistance of the firebreak partition must be validated by an<br />

accredited technical inspector or by a worksite report issued by an accredited<br />

laboratory, as appropriate. A work completion report must be submitted to the project<br />

owner in two copies, one for the insurance company.<br />

Validation concerns the fire resistance of load-bearing items, filling materials and the<br />

fittings of openings and passageways through the partition.<br />

Ouvrages séparatifs coupe-feu Règle ARSADR15 – Edition xx 2007.0


APSAD Regulation<br />

Firebreak partitions must extend at least 1 metre above the highest point<br />

of an area extending 7 metres either side of the partition. (See figure<br />

2.4.1.1.a.)<br />

Partition 1 metre above highest point in this area<br />

Figure 2.4.1.1.a – Firebreak extending above roof between two buildings<br />

of same height<br />

If the partition separates buildings of different heights, this requirement<br />

applies to the higher of the two buildings. (See figure 2.4.1.1.b.)<br />

Figure 2.4.1.1.b – Firebreak extending above roof between two buildings<br />

of different heights<br />

This measure is to ensure that fire cannot propagate through the firebreak,<br />

by direct action of the flames or by radiated heat, and to provide a screen<br />

protecting firefighting personnel as they work to extinguish the fire.<br />

FBP<br />

2.4.2 – Extension through outer walls<br />

2.4.2.1 – Title pending<br />

Firebreak partitions must extend 0.5 metres clear beyond the outer face of<br />

an outer wall. (See figure 2.4.2.1.a.)<br />

Top view<br />

Building A Building B<br />

Figure 2.4.2.1.a – Firebreak extending beyond outer wall<br />

This requirement may be lifted if there is a strip rated to EI 120 at least 2<br />

metres wide along the whole height of the outer wall either side of the<br />

partition, in material rated A1 or A2s1d0, with no opening it it. (See figure<br />

2.4.2.2.a.)<br />

Top view<br />

FBP<br />

Figure 2.4.2.2.a – Exception to extension through outer wall: façade with<br />

no openings, rated EI 120, in material rated A1 or A2s1d0<br />

FBP<br />

Facade<br />

Building A Building B<br />

Facade


APSAD Regulation<br />

2.5.2 – Openings (unobstructed bays)<br />

Openings in a firebreak partition must be fitted with automatically closing double doors rated EI 90 and E1 120, meeting the design and<br />

fitting requirements specified in APSAD rule R 16. (See figures 2.5.1.a and 2.5.1.b.)<br />

FBP<br />

FBP<br />

Bays must not be more than 3.8 metres wide or 4.4 metres high.<br />

Firebreak door, open<br />

Firebreak door, closed<br />

Figure 2.5.1.a – Double firebreak door<br />

Horizontal section<br />

Door closure must be operated by means of an automatic detection system or independent type I sensor-triggers.<br />

The materials surrounding the openings (lintels and jambs) must be strong enough to support the weight of the firebreak doors and<br />

withstand the impacts of repeated open-close action. If the material is not strong enough (cellular concrete, for example), a special frame<br />

must be built on which to fit the door mechanisms. (Figure 2.5.1.c.) Metal lintels are not allowed.


APSAD Regulation<br />

Type of<br />

partition<br />

Firebreak<br />

partition<br />

Regulatory<br />

firebreak<br />

partition<br />

Ordinary<br />

partition<br />

Fireproof<br />

compartment<br />

Fire<br />

resistance<br />

REI 240 or EI<br />

180 on both<br />

faces of<br />

double-face<br />

firebreak<br />

partition.<br />

REI 120<br />

REI 120<br />

REI 90 for<br />

outer face<br />

and EI 90 for<br />

other faces<br />

Selfsupporting<br />

Yes<br />

No<br />

requirement<br />

No<br />

requirement<br />

Not<br />

applicable<br />

Load bearing<br />

Load borne by<br />

means of brackets<br />

or consoles and<br />

sliding supports.<br />

Load-bearing<br />

capability allowed<br />

for double firebreak<br />

partition.<br />

Target result: no<br />

domino collapse<br />

and no outward<br />

collapse of fire<br />

outbreak cell.<br />

Load-bearing by<br />

sliding supports or<br />

fuse links.<br />

Not applicable<br />

Extension through roof<br />

Extension 1 metre above<br />

roof and A1 or A2s1d0<br />

protective strips 5 metres<br />

either side.<br />

Extension 1 metre above<br />

roof. Extension 0.5<br />

metres beyond façade or<br />

1 metre along façade on<br />

either side. Roof covered<br />

with protective strip 5<br />

metres either side<br />

As firebreak partition,<br />

except for concrete roofs<br />

Not applicable<br />

Structure<br />

materials<br />

A1 or<br />

A2s1d0<br />

No<br />

requirement<br />

A1 or<br />

A2s1d0.<br />

”Fragile”<br />

faces not<br />

allowed if<br />

rack parallel<br />

to ordinary<br />

wall<br />

A1 or<br />

A2s1d0<br />

Openings<br />

Automaticclosure<br />

double<br />

doors, EI 90<br />

and E 120.<br />

Automaticclosure<br />

doors,<br />

EI 120<br />

Automaticclosure<br />

single doors,<br />

E 120<br />

Single doors<br />

EI 90 &<br />

A 120 (inner<br />

face)<br />

Single doors<br />

E 90 (outer<br />

face)<br />

Ventilation<br />

& air conditioning<br />

ducts<br />

Not allowed<br />

EI 120<br />

EI 120<br />

EI 120<br />

Conveyors<br />

Compliant<br />

with APSAD<br />

rule R16<br />

EI 120<br />

Compliant<br />

with APSAD<br />

rule R16<br />

Compliant<br />

with APSAD<br />

rule R16


APSAD Regulation<br />

Metal-frame firebreak walls are not allowed unless they have a double face.<br />

(See section 2.7.)<br />

APSAD R15 rule: self-supporting firebreak walls were required for<br />

reasons of symmetry, which appeared logical at the time, but not<br />

now.


Traditionnal construction by concrete pillars<br />

embedded in the floor<br />

Fitted in front of<br />

concrete pillar<br />

Concrete<br />

framework<br />

Fireproof joints<br />

between<br />

panels<br />

Concrete<br />

frame<br />

Stringer<br />

Frame<br />

Variant: panels<br />

fitted between<br />

reinforced<br />

concrete pillars<br />

As an initial approximation, the firebreak capability of a wall in solid<br />

prefabricated concrete panels can be calculated using the simple rules<br />

set out in standard P 92-701 (DTU fire concrete), as shown in the<br />

table below. These rules apply two walls with a slenderness ratio no<br />

more than 50. The walls may be exposed to fire on one or both sides.<br />

Loadbearing<br />

walls<br />

Nonloadbearing<br />

walls<br />

Firebreak<br />

capability<br />

Thickness<br />

(cm)<br />

Thickness<br />

(cm)<br />

½<br />

hour<br />

10<br />

6<br />

1<br />

hour<br />

11<br />

7<br />

1 ½<br />

hours<br />

12<br />

9<br />

2<br />

hour<br />

s<br />

15<br />

11<br />

3<br />

hours<br />

20<br />

15<br />

4<br />

hour<br />

s<br />

25<br />

17.5


BUT… deformation of free-standing<br />

(i.e. self-supporting) wall embedded in floor<br />

Convex deformation on side<br />

exposed to heat<br />

Initial position<br />

Deformed position<br />

Wall


Self-supporting firebreak walls:<br />

potentially dangerous<br />

The wall leans outward<br />

from the fire if not free to<br />

rotate at the foot.<br />

This goes against the aims<br />

of item 1510.


Former rules (APSAD R15)<br />

• There is no straightforward, reliable method for designing a selfsupporting<br />

wall compliant with standards. Resort must be made<br />

to sophisticated calculation models that are not in current<br />

usage.<br />

• Former rules do not allow for the effect of temperature gradient<br />

when determining stress. (Text in extenso in R15 till 2007.)<br />

• But the temperature gradient, and the second-order effects<br />

thereof, is the main cause of wall collapse.


Conclusion<br />

• Current recommendations (APSAD R15) should come under<br />

serious critical review.<br />

• Embedded pillars and outer façade shear walls should be<br />

prohibited if they can be exposed to high temperature gradients.<br />

• Interior firebreak walls embedded in the floor should only be<br />

allowed if the effects of expansion and the resulting additional<br />

stress on neighbouring structures can be properly evaluated.


Is full chaining really necessary?<br />

Not if we can be sure that collapse will be in the right direction<br />

without risk for the wall.


Classical deformation and possible solution?<br />

Wall embedded at foot<br />

and free at top<br />

Wall curves gradually<br />

Wall supported horizontally at foot<br />

and top<br />

In the scenario to the right, the wall curves less, so the weight offset is<br />

less, and the risk of collapse is toward the fire rather than away from it.<br />

As we said previously, thanks to its steel structure the Firebreak wall is<br />

not concerned by this problem


Thank you for your attention<br />

Contacts :<br />

Fabrice Sokolowsky,<br />

Innovation & Development Manager<br />

fabrice.sokolowsky@arcelormittal.com<br />

Frédéric Goujon,<br />

Project Manager<br />

frederic.goujon@arcelormittal.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!