You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
PAGE 24—SUNDAY VANGUARD, FEBRUARY 28, 2021<br />
By Adesina Wahab<br />
The ban placed on<br />
crytocurrency by the<br />
Central Bank of<br />
Nigeria (CBN) on the<br />
grounds that it encourages<br />
money laundering and<br />
terrorism has continued to<br />
generate ripples.<br />
Youths, especially, say<br />
cr<br />
trading in cryptocurrency<br />
gives them the opportunity to<br />
be gainfully employed and<br />
suggested that instead of<br />
banning trading in it,<br />
government can evolve means<br />
of regulating it. They that<br />
outright ban would be like<br />
throwing away the baby with<br />
the bath water.<br />
Cross section of the youths<br />
told our correspondent that<br />
government should take a cue<br />
from countries such as<br />
Australia where a regulatory<br />
platform had been created to<br />
ensure that things are done<br />
in accordance with the laws<br />
of the land.<br />
A former teacher in a private<br />
secondary school, who gave<br />
his name as Johnson, said his<br />
job, where he earned less than<br />
N35, 000 a month, was wiped<br />
off as a result of the outbreak<br />
of coronavirus.<br />
“Our February 2020 salary<br />
was yet to be paid when the<br />
lockdown was announced last<br />
March and it did not take the<br />
owner of the school a.long<br />
time to send us messages that<br />
running the school was becoming<br />
difficult and eventually we were laid<br />
off and a friend later introduced me<br />
to cryptocurrency trading.<br />
“It has sustained me since and I<br />
think that is better than stealing or<br />
engaging in fraud that tarnishes the<br />
image of the nation. Honestly,<br />
banning it is not the solution, it would<br />
rather create more problems. Which<br />
jobs has the government provided for<br />
youths to do?<br />
“I agree that the business is very<br />
volatile, but all businesses have their<br />
own risks too. By February 2020, the<br />
Cryptocrisis<br />
•Why we can't let go of<br />
crypt<br />
yptocurrency despite<br />
volatile nature — Youths<br />
Many young Nigerians<br />
have taken interest in<br />
cryptocurrency and<br />
blockchain related<br />
matters because of their<br />
educational and career<br />
benefits - for traders<br />
and non-traders<br />
price rose to over $10,000 only to drop<br />
to $9,160 in March and $8,784 in<br />
April. I entered the market in March<br />
and despite a decline in the market,<br />
I still made a profit.<br />
“I like the volatile nature of<br />
cryptocurrency and with the help of<br />
cryptocurrency trading, I’ve been able<br />
to earn money at home, even much<br />
more than the salary I earned as a<br />
teacher. I have been able to feed my<br />
family and conveniently pay my other<br />
bills,” he stated.<br />
Another youth, Samuel, urged the<br />
government to have a rethink, noting<br />
that the social consequences of<br />
banning it could be greater than<br />
whatever the government thinks<br />
it is trying to prevent.<br />
He recalled that he<br />
downloaded the Binance app,<br />
a global crypto exchange, and<br />
began a journey that saw him<br />
meeting his needs without<br />
much stress.<br />
“Apart from those trading in<br />
it, there are people have set up<br />
exchanges to make the<br />
business seamless. To say there<br />
is no way the government can<br />
monitor how it goes is a lie. The<br />
Security<br />
Exchange<br />
Commission, SEC, can do that<br />
among other government<br />
agencies. I used the money I<br />
made from it to pay my school<br />
fees and I have graduated and<br />
still earning a living from it.<br />
Many people would be thrown<br />
into a state of confusion if the<br />
ban if not reversed. Crime<br />
would increase and further<br />
more, many youths who<br />
hitherto shunned internet fraud<br />
would go into that, “ he opined.<br />
He appealed to the<br />
government to take another look<br />
at the matter.<br />
Many young Nigerians have<br />
taken interest in cryptocurrency<br />
and blockchain related matters<br />
because of their educational<br />
and career benefits - for traders<br />
and non-traders.<br />
Few days ago, a former<br />
Deputy Governor of the CBN,<br />
Kingsley Moghalu, said<br />
Nigerians had made over $500<br />
million<br />
through<br />
cryptocurrencies in the past five<br />
years, though some said it could be<br />
more.<br />
Since the announcement by the<br />
CBN, global exchanges like Binance<br />
and Luno have suspended naira<br />
deposits on their platforms, while local<br />
exchanges like BuyCoins, Bundle,<br />
and Quidax have done the same and<br />
have placed restrictions on naira<br />
deposits on their platforms.<br />
While the National Assembly has waded<br />
into the matter, asking officials of SEC and<br />
others to appear before them, industry<br />
watchers are waiting to see where the<br />
pendulum will finally swing.<br />
No proof Bitcoin,<br />
others boost<br />
economy<br />
—Ronak Gadhia<br />
By Nkiruka Nnorom<br />
Ronak Gadhia is the Director of Sub-<br />
Saharan Banks & Research, EFG<br />
Hermes Frontier. In this interview,<br />
he speaks on the ban on cryptocurrency<br />
trading in Nigeria, saying that volatility and<br />
lack of regulation in the cryptocurrency<br />
space could have a significant negative<br />
impact on Nigerians in case of sudden<br />
correction in the value of the assets.<br />
The Central Bank of Nigeria, CBN,<br />
has given reasons for the ban on<br />
cryptocurrency in Nigeria. Do you<br />
have a contrary opinion?<br />
Apart from the reasons highlighted by the<br />
CBN which include that trading in<br />
cryptocurrency is unconstitutional, not a<br />
store of value, volatility, and speculative<br />
risk, I think the CBN may have also been<br />
prompted to act due to the potential for<br />
perpetuating illegal scams and money<br />
laundering activities on the platform. Also,<br />
it can also be argued that the ban is an<br />
extension of the CBN’s attempt to plug<br />
various sources of FX leakages in the<br />
Nigerian economy<br />
To what extent does it constitute<br />
a threat to Nigeria’s financial<br />
system?<br />
The inherent volatility and lack of<br />
regulation combined with the increasing<br />
popularity of cryptocurrencies among<br />
Nigerians could have a significant and<br />
negative impact on Nigerian savers if<br />
there was a sudden and significant<br />
correction in the value of these<br />
instruments (as has consistently been the<br />
case in the last few years) or, indeed, if<br />
some of these underlying instruments turn<br />
out to be Ponzi schemes.<br />
Do you agree that it also puts<br />
the investment of participants in<br />
danger?<br />
Yes, lack of proper regulations for any<br />
financial instrument increases the risk<br />
of loss for participants. Furthermore,<br />
the lack of basic financial education<br />
augments these risks in our opinion.<br />
Some have argued that<br />
cryptocurrency is even an economic<br />
booster to any economy in the world...<br />
We would ask how? What are<br />
the real assets that have<br />
been created on the<br />
•Gadhia<br />
back<br />
of<br />
cryptocurrencies?<br />
Can this be<br />
demonstrated?<br />
Nigeria was<br />
said to have<br />
ranked second<br />
globally in the<br />
cryptocurrency<br />
space. Should<br />
that not have<br />
discouraged<br />
the CBN from scraping it in the country?<br />
Perhaps, instead of completely banning<br />
the trading of cryptocurrencies, the CBN<br />
should have sought ways of regulating the<br />
industry, like in South Africa, and/or tried<br />
to determine why the asset class has become<br />
so popular and introduce alternative asset<br />
classes to meet that demand.<br />
Can you tell us how much Nigeria<br />
has made from it in the last few years?<br />
It is difficult to tell, but some analysts<br />
estimated that Nigerians have traded up to<br />
US$500 million of cryptocurrencies in the<br />
last five years. However, this value traded<br />
should not be understood to be a net benefit<br />
to the Nigerian economy. That is a different<br />
matter.<br />
Daily Crytocurrency trading is<br />
believed to worth about N2 billion,<br />
a figure that is more than the value<br />
of daily trade at the Nigerian Stock<br />
Exchange. What is your thought on<br />
this considering the recent<br />
development?<br />
First, this shows the decreasing<br />
importance of the Nigerian Stock Exchange<br />
as a capital intermediary in the Nigerian<br />
economy as trading volumes have<br />
persistently been on a downward trend in<br />
the last 10 years, and as a result, are much<br />
lower than other economies of a similar<br />
size.<br />
Second, the significant volume for<br />
cryptocurrencies suggests that the<br />
currency investment needs of a vast<br />
proportion of Nigerian investors are not being<br />
met by the existing product available in the<br />
country. The CBN and other regulatory bodies<br />
such as the Pension Commission (PenCom),<br />
the Securities and Exchange Commission<br />
(SEC) among others should try to introduce<br />
new products that could satisfy this need.<br />
Having said that, one cannot ignore the<br />
possibility that the high usage of<br />
cryptocurrencies is being driven by<br />
money launderers.<br />
What do you think those affected<br />
by the CBN policy should do?<br />
They should lobby the CBN to reconsider<br />
their decision to either allow trading of<br />
cryptocurrencies in a regulated environment<br />
or introduce an alternative product, such as a<br />
Naira digital currency, as we have seen in<br />
other countries.<br />
What do you think the CBN should<br />
have done differently?<br />
As indicated above, I think the CBN could<br />
have sought to regulate the industry like in<br />
South Africa. Having said that, we are very<br />
encouraged to see the CBN take an active<br />
position on cryptocurrencies, and for this<br />
reason, we are confident that a regulatory<br />
framework will be built for the trading of<br />
these currencies.