Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
SPRING <strong>2022</strong><br />
INSIGHT<br />
Special<br />
Forestry<br />
Feature<br />
P8-9<br />
bellingram.co.uk<br />
Net Zero<br />
Opportunities<br />
in this growing<br />
market P6 -11<br />
Property<br />
Agency team’s<br />
record results for<br />
rural clients P14<br />
Mapping<br />
Spotlight on<br />
our in-house GIS<br />
experts P18<br />
Beavers are back, but what does it mean for UK?<br />
As beavers make a comeback across the countryside, our land management<br />
experts explore the case for and against rewilding P12<br />
Land Management ❘ Estate Agency ❘ Forestry ❘ Design ❘ Utilities ❘ Renewables summer bi2019 ❘ Carbon 5
welcome<br />
news<br />
Welcome<br />
Welcome to the <strong>Spring</strong> Edition of Insight Magazine.<br />
Unlike this time last year, there’s a great deal to<br />
look forward to over the coming year and at Bell<br />
Ingram we are building for the future with the<br />
announcement of some exciting staff changes<br />
(p4). We also say a fond farewell to our Chairman<br />
Graham Lumby who steps down after 40 years with<br />
the business. Graham has made an outstanding<br />
contribution to the company and his leadership, experience and wise counsel<br />
have been tremendously valuable over that time.<br />
With the easing of the Covid restrictions, we’re planning an action-packed<br />
events programme with our professional staff teed up to attend all the top<br />
rural and agricultural shows and conferences. Remember to look out for the<br />
Bell Ingram gilets and visit our stands to say hello.<br />
As Chairman of Perthshire Agricultural Society, I am particularly pleased that<br />
the agricultural show calendar has been given a green light to proceed after<br />
a hiatus of two years. Unbelievably, this will be the first Perth Show I’ve been<br />
able to organise … despite being in post for three years (surely some kind of<br />
record!).<br />
I’m delighted to announce that our Highland and Aberdeen offices are<br />
partnering with NFU Mutual and Blackadders to hold two exciting events in<br />
spring covering the topics of Agritourism and Succession Planning respectively.<br />
Elsewhere, Bell Ingram will once again host our much-anticipated Insight Day<br />
in Perth where our experts will present on a range of Estate Agency, Forestry,<br />
Design, Renewables and Carbon topics to industry professionals.<br />
The need to address climate change is putting new demands on landowners<br />
and land managers, and in this edition Partner and Head of Carbon Mike<br />
Thompson cuts through the chatter to focus on the very real opportunities<br />
around both Woodland and Peatland restoration (p7).<br />
Assistant Land Agent Matthew Imrie gets a mention for the woodland scheme<br />
he’s delivering on his family farm in a special feature from our friends at<br />
Scottish Forestry which gives an update on the Integrating Trees Network and<br />
how to sign up for their upcoming free events (p8-9).<br />
Still on the subject of carbon, Highland-based architect Murray Fleming takes<br />
us inside a stunning low carbon build he’s created for Forestry and Land<br />
Scotland at Durris, while Northwich-based Land Agent Ben Hewlett examines<br />
Biodiversity Net Gain and its impact on development projects (p6).<br />
Rewilding is always a hot topic in our sector and Charlotte Gilfillan and Carrie<br />
McLennan from our Highland office make the case for and against the reintroduction<br />
of beavers (p12-13).<br />
This <strong>issue</strong> also features insight into the property and land markets from Head<br />
of Agency Carl Warden and Head of Valuations Sarah Tyson. We also showcase<br />
some of the sales success stories of the last 12 months (p14-15). It’s definitely<br />
been a seller’s market!<br />
While there are still post-pandemic challenges ahead, I am optimistic that <strong>2022</strong><br />
will see improvements for us all and in the meantime, Bell Ingram remains<br />
grateful for the support of our clients, something we never take for granted.<br />
Mark Mitchell, Managing Partner.<br />
*Insight magazine is prepared for general information only. While care is taken in its compilation, neither<br />
Bell Ingram LLP nor its employees or officers accept any liability for the contents or their application to any<br />
individual circumstances. Readers are strongly recommended to contact Bell Ingram to obtain advice<br />
appropriate to their needs.<br />
Contents<br />
4 Learning Milestone: Members of Countryside<br />
Learning Scotland’s Youth Advisory Group are<br />
on course to debut their new film which raises<br />
awareness of training and career opportunities in<br />
the rural sector.<br />
5 Farming for the Future: Bell Ingram underlines<br />
our commitment to the farming community<br />
through a new membership with NFU Scotland.<br />
6 Biodiversity Net Gain: With sustainable<br />
development high on the political agenda<br />
Northwich Land Agent Ben Hewlett examines why<br />
biodiversity is becoming a key driver for developers,<br />
landowners and local planning authorities alike.<br />
6 Legacy of COP26: Changes, even small ones,<br />
can have a big impact as we work towards Carbon<br />
Net Zero targets says Senior Associate Amy Clark<br />
Kennedy.<br />
7 Business of Carbon: Practical strategies are key<br />
to navigating the fast-developing Carbon landscape<br />
and unlocking associated opportunities, advises<br />
Partner and Head of Carbon Mike Thompson.<br />
8 Guest Feature: The Integrating Trees Network<br />
is up and running and going from strength to<br />
strength with a number of farmer-led events<br />
teed up this month, including one featuring Bell<br />
Ingram’s Matthew Imrie.<br />
11 Amazing spaces: Architect Murray Fleming takes<br />
us inside a stunning low carbon office building he’s<br />
designed for Forestry and Land Scotland (FLS) at<br />
Durris.<br />
12 Rewilding: Beavers are back but what does that<br />
mean for the UK’s wild spaces? Senior Associate<br />
Charlotte Gilfillan and Assistant Land Agent Carrie<br />
McLennan look at both sides of the rewilding<br />
argument.<br />
14 Special Agents: Partner and Head of Estate<br />
Agency Carl Warden reveals how his team have<br />
achieved record results for clients in a complex<br />
property market.<br />
18 Spotlight on GIS Mapping: Find out how<br />
Bell Ingram’s GIS Mapping experts helped Estate<br />
Agency colleagues achieve a record result for a<br />
farming client<br />
Editorial contacts for Insight<br />
l<br />
l<br />
l<br />
Alison Lowson, Marketing Manager<br />
alison.lowson@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Eleanor Mackay, Digital Marketing Coordinator<br />
eleanor.mackay@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Tel. 01738 621 121 or 07584 093354<br />
Design by Stuart Cameron<br />
design100cam@gmail.com<br />
Graham<br />
Lumby steps<br />
down as<br />
Chairman<br />
in brief<br />
Graham Lumby is to step<br />
down from his role as<br />
Chairman of Bell Ingram.<br />
He will retire from the Board<br />
on 1st April and Head of<br />
Land Management Malcolm<br />
Taylor will move into the role,<br />
supporting Managing Partner<br />
Mark Mitchell and Board<br />
colleagues.<br />
Graham began his career with Bell Ingram in 1982 and was<br />
Managing Director for 23 years before stepping into the role of<br />
Chairman. During this time, he has<br />
overseen the company’s growth into one<br />
of the UK’s leading firms of independent<br />
rural chartered surveyors.<br />
Graham Lumby said: “It’s been a privilege<br />
to have worked for Bell Ingram over the<br />
past 40 years and help manage the<br />
business as it has grown and developed.<br />
I hope I have played my part in both its<br />
current success and contributed to future<br />
l Malcolm Taylor<br />
endeavours.<br />
“I’d also like to thank all the wonderful<br />
colleagues and clients I’ve worked with on many significant and<br />
exciting projects over the years. I’ve really enjoyed my time at Bell<br />
Ingram and wish the company every success for the future.”<br />
Graham is not cutting ties completely and will remain within the<br />
business as a consultant focusing on work for utility and renewables<br />
clients.<br />
Managing Partner Mark Mitchell added: "Graham has made an<br />
outstanding contribution to the company over the last 40 years and<br />
we are deeply grateful for the time and energy he has brought to<br />
the role of Chairman. His experience and wise counsel have been<br />
particularly valuable during the pandemic, and he steps down from<br />
the Board with the warm thanks of his colleagues.”<br />
Graham’s departure heralds a number of staff changes as Bell<br />
Ingram builds for the future.<br />
Ayr Partner Geoff Brown takes on the role of Service Head Utilities<br />
(Scotland) while Neal Salomon, Service Head Utilities (England)<br />
joins the Finance Board alongside Managing Partner Mark Mitchell<br />
and Finance<br />
Partner Gordon<br />
Thoms. Senior<br />
Associate Hugh<br />
Maclean takes<br />
over as head of<br />
the Perth Utilities<br />
department. l Geoff Brown l Neal Saloman l Hugh Maclean<br />
l Geoff Brown l Neal Saloman l Hugh Maclean<br />
Career milestone for<br />
Borzo Taheri<br />
Borzo Taheri has successfully passed his<br />
Assessment of Professional Competence<br />
(APC) to become a qualified chartered<br />
surveyor.<br />
He is formally elected to the class of MRICS<br />
and will be able to use the professional<br />
designation MRICS, an internationally<br />
recognised and respected mark of excellence and integrity.<br />
Based in our Northwich office, Borzo joined Bell Ingram in June<br />
2017 and works across a large spectrum of clients within the<br />
utility and renewables sector.<br />
AGI-Scotland<br />
Annual<br />
Conference<br />
Bell Ingram is one of the<br />
sponsors of this year’s AGI-<br />
Scotland Annual Conference<br />
and our GIS Manager Marcus<br />
Humphrey is a guest speaker.<br />
You don’t have to be a<br />
member to join in this virtual<br />
event on 23-24 February<br />
<strong>2022</strong> (mornings only) and<br />
registration is open now. Visit<br />
Scottish Hockey gets<br />
new Property Partner<br />
Bell Ingram has signed in Scottish sport.”<br />
a deal with Scottish<br />
Hockey to become its<br />
‘Property Partner’ for<br />
the next four years.<br />
The new sponsorship<br />
agreement will see the<br />
company sponsor the Senior<br />
Women’s Team and female<br />
youth teams.<br />
As well as helping to nurture<br />
Scotland’s hockey talent,<br />
the partnership will allow<br />
Scottish Hockey to continue to<br />
encourage girls to take up the<br />
sport.<br />
Managing Partner, Mark<br />
Mitchell comments:<br />
“We are delighted to be<br />
teaming up with Scottish<br />
Hockey as their Property<br />
Partner. At Bell Ingram we<br />
understand the value of<br />
education and developing<br />
the next generation of land<br />
agents and rural business<br />
professionals, it is therefore<br />
a natural partnership for our<br />
organisation to support the<br />
development of youth talent<br />
www.agi.org.uk to register<br />
your place.<br />
Running over two mornings<br />
the theme for this year’s<br />
event is Global to Local:<br />
What Scotland can offer<br />
the world and what the<br />
world can offer Scotland.<br />
Hear how Scotland’s GI<br />
community is innovating<br />
to tackle these challenges<br />
and gather insights from the<br />
international community on<br />
the successes that can help<br />
Scotland to achieve its goals.<br />
Andy Tennant, Head of<br />
Performance at Scottish<br />
Hockey adds: “Scottish Hockey<br />
is delighted to partner with<br />
Bell Ingram to support<br />
women’s hockey across all the<br />
age groups in Scotland.<br />
“Partnerships of this nature are<br />
so important for us to sustain<br />
and enhance the quality of<br />
opportunities available to<br />
our most talented athletes<br />
of all ages while attracting<br />
new people to the sport. It’s<br />
great that we have such a<br />
high quality and established<br />
business on board, particularly<br />
one who places important<br />
emphasis on developing<br />
people. Many thanks to Bell<br />
Ingram for their kind support<br />
and we look forward to<br />
working together in the years<br />
ahead.”<br />
You will spot Bell Ingram’s logo<br />
across the team shirts and on<br />
event days at Scottish Hockey’s<br />
home ground at Glasgow<br />
Green.<br />
2 bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 winter spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 3
news<br />
land management<br />
Big turnouts<br />
at regional<br />
receptions<br />
Bell Ingram continued our<br />
successful relationship with Scottish<br />
Land and Estates by sponsoring two<br />
Regional Receptions in Aviemore<br />
and Scone Palace respectively at<br />
the end of 2021.<br />
The Highland Reception enjoyed<br />
excellent presentations and debate<br />
covering a broad range of topics,<br />
from Margi Campbell’s interesting<br />
(and entertaining!) tax update, to<br />
integrated land management,<br />
Natural Capital and carbon<br />
opportunities, rural housing and<br />
inspiring the next generation.<br />
The Central Reception saw a big<br />
turnout to hear keynote speaker<br />
Hamish Trench, Chief Executive<br />
at Scottish Land Commission,<br />
examine ‘the role of the landowner’<br />
while SLE Chief Executive Sarah<br />
Jane Laing gave a fascinating policy<br />
insight into Scottish Parliament.<br />
It was clear from both events<br />
the scope of work SLE has been<br />
undertaking on behalf of its<br />
members, just how hugely valuable<br />
and effective that continues to be<br />
and how much support it deserves.<br />
Partner and Vice Chair of SLE<br />
Highland Rob Whitson is pictured<br />
with Mairi Coleman, Chair of the<br />
SLE Highland Committee and<br />
Stephen Young, Head of Policy at<br />
SLE. n<br />
in brief<br />
YAG video is a milestone<br />
for countryside learning<br />
Bell Ingram has<br />
welcomed three new<br />
colleagues on board<br />
as the company<br />
continues to invest in the<br />
development of its teams.<br />
Alex Morrison<br />
has joined the<br />
company as an<br />
Associate, based<br />
in our Forfar<br />
Office. Alex, who<br />
is a fully qualified chartered<br />
surveyor and Agricultural<br />
Valuer, previously worked<br />
for the Duchy of Lancaster<br />
where he was Estates<br />
Director for Yorkshire and<br />
the Foreshore. Prior to this,<br />
Alex worked for Carter Jonas<br />
LLP where he was Assistant<br />
Estate Manager at the<br />
Newby Hall Estate in North<br />
Yorkshire.<br />
Alex can offer advice across<br />
a broad spectrum of topics<br />
including, rural estate<br />
management, heritage<br />
property and tourism/leisure.<br />
Meanwhile, Henry Jamieson<br />
takes up the position of Land<br />
and Business Development<br />
Agent in our Ayr office. Henry<br />
previously worked for family<br />
firm John Marshall & Sons<br />
where he was Contracts<br />
Manager for 18 years. The<br />
Ayrshire-based plant and<br />
fencing contractor is one of<br />
the area’s leading suppliers,<br />
working with firms like<br />
Babcock and Balfour Beattie.<br />
As well as his<br />
Land Agent role,<br />
Henry will be<br />
working to identify<br />
new business<br />
opportunities.<br />
Mark Mitchell, Bell Ingram Managing Partner,<br />
added: “I am delighted to support YAG and<br />
looking forward to welcoming them to<br />
Ingliston and learning more about the video<br />
and their wider remit to help define the future<br />
direction of the charity.”<br />
Based in Perthshire, Countryside Learning<br />
Scotland is an education charity formed in<br />
2003 to meet the need for outdoor learning in<br />
primarily secondary schools.<br />
When members of Countryside<br />
Learning Scotland’s Youth Advisory<br />
Group (YAG) join Bell Ingram on our<br />
Royal Highland Show stand this<br />
summer, it will be a milestone moment in the<br />
drive to nurture Scotland’s future countryside<br />
custodians.<br />
Despite the pandemic, this select group of<br />
young people have been pressing ahead with<br />
their project to create a special video to increase<br />
awareness in secondary schools of training and<br />
careers in the rural sector.<br />
The group is currently putting the finishing<br />
touches to the film, which will be ready to view<br />
in time for the <strong>2022</strong> Royal Highland Show.<br />
David Ritchie, CLS Youth Advisory Group’s Project<br />
Manager, said: “The film covers the results of a<br />
questionnaire looking at barriers to countryside<br />
learning and the opportunities for landbased<br />
careers and it’s filmed and presented by<br />
YAG members themselves.”<br />
www.countrysidelearning.org.uk n<br />
Ian Robertson, CLS Executive Director, said: “We<br />
encompass all areas of the countryside, from<br />
recreation to the environment and traditional<br />
land uses, helping to sustain Scotland’s<br />
countryside through education and providing<br />
opportunity for people from all backgrounds<br />
and abilities.<br />
“We do this by increasing rural opportunity<br />
awareness through outreach events and<br />
teacher training and by partnership building<br />
and rural business training in the local<br />
community. Teachers become our ‘countryside<br />
champions’ and businesses learn to engage<br />
with their next generation of employees.<br />
“For young people we build a progressive<br />
programme of awareness, residential and work<br />
experience events and support them transition<br />
from school to work.”<br />
New starts in Forfar, Ayr and Beauly<br />
Elsewhere, Kylie<br />
Shaw has joined<br />
our Beauly team as<br />
Property Assistant.<br />
A graduate of<br />
the University of<br />
the Highlands and Islands,<br />
where she studied business<br />
administration, Kylie previously<br />
worked as a Lettings and Sales<br />
Negotiator at Your Move. She<br />
is also the office’s first aider.<br />
Commenting on the new<br />
appointments, Managing<br />
Partner Mark Mitchell said:<br />
“We are delighted to welcome<br />
these talented individuals to<br />
the Bell Ingram team. As with<br />
any business, the introduction<br />
of new people and new ideas<br />
is an exciting prospect and I<br />
have no doubt that all three<br />
of our new recruits will add<br />
real value.” n<br />
Bell Ingram cements relationship<br />
with farming community with<br />
NFU Scotland membership<br />
We have shown our commitment to<br />
the Scottish farming community<br />
through a new membership with NFU<br />
Scotland.<br />
Bell Ingram, which specialises in rural land<br />
management, including farm and estate sales,<br />
has joined the NFU Scotland network of farmers<br />
working towards a bright and sustainable future for<br />
Scottish agriculture.<br />
With our roots in rural estate management, we<br />
manage some of UK’s finest agricultural and<br />
sporting estates and currently oversee hundreds<br />
of thousands of hectares of private and corporate<br />
estates across the UK.<br />
Supporting the Scottish farming community is<br />
integral to Bell Ingram’s rural land management<br />
work and, with many of our team members from<br />
agricultural backgrounds, the NFU Scotland<br />
membership only further cements this close<br />
relationship.<br />
The business closely aligns with NFU Scotland’s<br />
values and is committed to promoting sustainable<br />
Scottish farming alongside the union who are<br />
leading the industry on climate change.<br />
Ross-shire Branch Chair, Alasdair Macnab<br />
welcomed the company as professional members<br />
when he presented Bell Ingram’s Rob Whitson with<br />
the official membership certificate.<br />
Rob Whitson, Head of Bell Ingram’s Farm and<br />
Estates Sales Team and Highland Partner,<br />
commented: “There is a real synergy between<br />
Bell Ingram and NFUS and we couldn’t be more<br />
pleased to have joined as corporate members. By<br />
the nature of what we both do, we endeavour to<br />
support the farming community in our regions<br />
by being embedded at a local level, thereby<br />
understanding local pressures and providing<br />
tailored support.”<br />
lasdair Macnab, Chair of the Ross-shire<br />
Branch, said: “It is encouraging that<br />
Acompanies like Bell Ingram are recognising<br />
the benefits of engaging more closely with the<br />
rural community where they operate. NFU Scotland<br />
looks forward to working with Bell Ingram in the<br />
future where its range of expertise and knowledge<br />
can help with our work and providing the best<br />
service to members.”<br />
Johnny Hogg, Group Secretary of the Ross-Shire<br />
branch, added: “We are delighted to welcome the<br />
whole of the Bell Ingram team to the NFUS. Having<br />
worked with Charlotte and Rob in the Beauly office<br />
over a number of years, I have seen first-hand the<br />
care and attention they have provided to a vast<br />
number of our members and it is great that they<br />
have chosen to further strengthen their relationship<br />
with NFU Scotland by joining as Professional<br />
members. We look forward to having them and<br />
others join us at branch meetings going forward.” n<br />
From left: Alasdair Macnab (Chair,<br />
Ross-shire Branch of NFUS), Rob<br />
Whitson (Head of Bell Ingram’s Farm<br />
and Estates Sales Team and Highland<br />
Partner) and Johnny Hogg (Secretary,<br />
Ross-shire Branch of the NFUS),<br />
pictured at Alasdair’s farm to publicise<br />
Bell Ingram’s membership of NFUS.<br />
<strong>2022</strong> Agri<br />
Show Diary<br />
Our Land Management<br />
teams will be hitting the<br />
show circuit this season<br />
after a two year hiatus.<br />
Below is a list of the<br />
events our experts will be<br />
attending, so make sure you<br />
say hello.<br />
June<br />
Thursday 23rd – Sunday 26th<br />
Royal Highland Show<br />
July<br />
Friday 1st<br />
GWCT Scottish Game Fair<br />
Friday 15th – Saturday 16th<br />
Caithness Show<br />
Saturday 16th<br />
Kirriemuir Show<br />
Saturday 23rd<br />
Sutherland Show<br />
August<br />
Thursday 4th<br />
Black Isle Show<br />
Friday 5th – Saturday 6th<br />
Moy Highland Field Sports Fair<br />
Friday 5th – Saturday 6th<br />
Perth Show<br />
4 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring<br />
winter bi2019 1
carbon<br />
carbon<br />
Biodiversity Net<br />
Gain and its impact<br />
on future infrastructure<br />
and housing projects<br />
by Ben Hewlett<br />
Biodiversity Net Gain is an approach to development<br />
which aims to leave the natural environment in a<br />
measurably better state than beforehand. Implemented<br />
correctly, it should have a positive ecological impact,<br />
delivering improvements through habitat creation or<br />
enhancement.<br />
It’s by no means a new concept, in fact Biodiversity Net Gain has<br />
been best practice among responsible infrastructure companies,<br />
developers and landowners for some time now. Bell Ingram, for<br />
example, has been working for a major utilities client on a project to<br />
provide biodiversity enhancement for a major pipeline development<br />
in the North-West of England. Our land agents have been tasked<br />
with identifying and acquiring nearby land with the potential for<br />
habitat creation and enhancement. The project started in 2020 with<br />
completion scheduled for 2030.<br />
It’s worth noting that Biodiversity Net Gain has been a part<br />
of planning policy in England through the National Planning Policy<br />
Framework for a couple of years, although it has not been widely<br />
adopted.<br />
However, the principle has now become enshrined in law as one of<br />
the more ambitious provisions of the new Environment Act 2021.<br />
This legal requirement, which applies only to England*, requires<br />
new developments to provide a 10% Biodiversity Net Gain to be<br />
maintained for a period of at least 30 years in order to secure<br />
planning permission.<br />
While this condition has no legal effect yet (and will be brought into<br />
force through secondary legislation at a date not yet known), the<br />
provisions are far reaching and complex.<br />
n essence, Biodiversity Net Gain means developers in England<br />
must ensure their projects deliver biodiversity improvements to<br />
Imeet the required 10% increase. To do this, they must evidence<br />
a project’s final Biodiversity Net Gain value using the specified Defra<br />
biodiversity metric if they want their plans to get a green light.<br />
To achieve Biodiversity Net Gain, proposals must follow the<br />
‘mitigation hierarchy’ which compels planning applicants to avoid<br />
harm in the first instance, then mitigate or finally compensate for<br />
losses on-site, off-site or through a combination of the two solutions.<br />
These measures will be implemented in planning conditions.<br />
*The Biodiversity Net Gain principles set out in the Environment<br />
Act only applies to England, but the Scottish Government has<br />
committed to bring forward a new biodiversity strategy in October<br />
and its delivery plan six months later.<br />
With a background in environmental management, Ben Hewlett<br />
is a Land Agent based in Bell Ingram’s Northwich office where he<br />
works on behalf of our utilities clients. n<br />
Peatland opportunities<br />
was fortunate enough to<br />
attend COP26 and came<br />
I home from my day at the<br />
conference considering the<br />
mammoth task before us. It<br />
is not going to be easy but I,<br />
like many people, look to the<br />
next generation, in my case my<br />
small children, and my focus is<br />
on “what can I do?”.<br />
The summit in Glasgow<br />
presented delegates with a<br />
fascinating, if terrifying, picture<br />
of the <strong>issue</strong>s before us, but<br />
the big question is whether<br />
the message about climate<br />
change got through to the<br />
right people?<br />
The UK is a world leader<br />
in many sectors, and the<br />
improvements we make in<br />
technologies and processes<br />
ripple through to other<br />
countries at an incredible rate.<br />
In short, what we do, matters!<br />
s a Land Manager<br />
predominantly covering<br />
AScotland, what is it<br />
that I can do? If I have learned<br />
anything in my last 20 years in<br />
this industry, it’s that changes,<br />
even small ones, can have a<br />
significant impact.<br />
I am in an incredibly lucky<br />
position that I regularly<br />
contribute to projects which<br />
directly help clients reach their<br />
Net Zero targets. The work Bell<br />
Ingram does in conjunction<br />
with renewable schemes<br />
makes a real contribution to<br />
the ambitious government<br />
targets which in turn will make<br />
a difference the world over.<br />
However, it is also the work<br />
we do with our private clients<br />
which is really lighting my<br />
‘non-carbon’ fire. Landowners<br />
have a great opportunity to<br />
lead change, but planning<br />
their next move is crucial, and<br />
Bell Ingram can help with that.<br />
The Carbon Credit market<br />
is developing as we speak,<br />
and here at Bell Ingram we<br />
are keeping a keen eye on<br />
developments and ensuring<br />
that our team is getting the<br />
best training and updates<br />
available. This means we are<br />
able to advise you how to<br />
balance the risk versus the<br />
significant opportunities<br />
available.<br />
One of the key opportunities<br />
we have across the UK is the<br />
restoration of peatland. In<br />
Scotland, peat soils are said<br />
to cover more than 20% of<br />
the country and store around<br />
16,000 million tonnes of<br />
carbon. The frightening part<br />
of this is that over 80% of<br />
our peatlands are thought to<br />
be degraded. Leaving them<br />
degraded will cause damage<br />
to the atmosphere itself.<br />
Restoring these peatlands to<br />
their full potential will have<br />
significant positive impacts<br />
ensuring that we are removing<br />
damaging Greenhouse Gases<br />
from the atmosphere.<br />
By accessing the Scotland<br />
Peatland Action Fund,<br />
managed by NatureScot, you<br />
are able to tap into a twostage<br />
form of funding. Firstly,<br />
funded feasibility studies could<br />
be an option for your property?<br />
Secondly, 100% of the cost<br />
of restoration is available, but<br />
watch closely as there are<br />
tripping hazards.<br />
There are key elements which<br />
you also need to consider,<br />
specifically not only having<br />
control of the land for a<br />
significant enough period<br />
of time, but also taking the<br />
correct steps in the correct<br />
order. The all-important<br />
planning of works in order to<br />
unlock that grant is significant.<br />
Having professional assistance<br />
is the key to unlocking the<br />
value and increasing the<br />
carbon store potential of your<br />
property.<br />
Amy Clark Kennedy is a Land<br />
Agent and Senior Associate<br />
working from Bell Ingram’s Ayr<br />
office on behalf of major utility<br />
companies. n<br />
The Business of<br />
Carbon Net<br />
Zero<br />
Mike Thomson<br />
Partner and Head<br />
of Carbon<br />
Tel: 01738 621 121<br />
There’s no doubt that climate change<br />
and nature decline are the big buzzwords<br />
within the UK’s rural land sector as both<br />
Holyrood and Westminster push to meet<br />
their Carbon Net Zero targets by 2045 and<br />
2050 respectively.<br />
How we address these <strong>issue</strong>s is placing<br />
new demands on the landowners and<br />
land managers who, as custodians of the<br />
landscape, must find a balance between<br />
securing the natural environment for future<br />
generations while supporting the multiple<br />
objectives the land must meet.<br />
While the growing number of government<br />
targets has opened up new opportunities<br />
for the land-based economy, the<br />
application of carbon and ecosystem<br />
investment and natural capital concepts is<br />
still in its infancy and further complicated<br />
by different legislation, aims and targets<br />
both sides of the border.<br />
At Bell Ingram we believe that a practical<br />
land management strategy is the key to<br />
navigating this fast-developing landscape<br />
and unlocking associated opportunities.<br />
Woodland Carbon<br />
Carbon in forestry is the hot topic at<br />
the moment. Not only does planting<br />
trees help to combat global warming<br />
by absorbing carbon dioxide, but it has<br />
the potential to generate a significant<br />
additional income for landowners.<br />
In a nutshell, this is because Woodland<br />
Carbon (and Peatland) is tradable and<br />
Woodland creation.<br />
has a value. Carbon sold when trees are<br />
planted (or Peatland restored) can provide<br />
landowners with additional income. And<br />
verified carbon can be used by business<br />
to offset their UK carbon emissions.<br />
The Woodland Carbon Code (WCC),<br />
which is administered by Scottish<br />
Forestry, is the quality assurance<br />
standard for woodland creation projects<br />
in the UK and generates independently<br />
verified carbon units. Backed by<br />
government, the forest industry and<br />
carbon market experts, the Code is<br />
unique in providing woodland carbon<br />
units right here in the UK.<br />
Bell Ingram has an established track<br />
record of delivering Woodland Carbon<br />
Code (WCC) projects, successfully<br />
implementing both native woodland and<br />
commercial conifer schemes ranging<br />
from a few hectares to many hundreds.<br />
From woodland creation through to longterm<br />
forest management and timber<br />
harvesting, our carbon team can offer a<br />
comprehensive range of environmental<br />
services and have the expertise to ensure<br />
the carbon opportunity in your new<br />
investment is developed to maximise<br />
potential..<br />
Peatland Restoration<br />
Peatland is an excellent carbon store.<br />
The hydrology of peatland, in its natural<br />
waterlogged state, prevents carbon<br />
within organic matter at the surface<br />
oxidising and being released as carbon<br />
dioxide. Restoration is crucial as degraded<br />
peatland has been contributing to rising<br />
carbon emissions.<br />
While woodland creation carbon work<br />
is already well established, Peatland<br />
Restoration is less advanced and although<br />
there are many schemes (and even more<br />
planned) the general belief is that there<br />
will be major changes to come in order<br />
to make this more appealing/available in<br />
the future.<br />
Like the Woodland Carbon Code, the<br />
Peatland Code is a voluntary certification<br />
standard designed to provide assurances<br />
to carbon market buyers that the climate<br />
benefits being sold are real, quantifiable,<br />
additional and permanent.<br />
The Code was developed in 2015 and<br />
is managed by the IUCN Peatland<br />
Programme. The reduction in carbon<br />
emissions by peatland restoration is<br />
quantified, validated, and verified in a<br />
similar way to the Woodland Carbon<br />
Code.<br />
Get in touch<br />
Done right, these new natural capital<br />
markets offer exciting opportunities.<br />
However, carbon funding is a fast-moving<br />
and developing area and we strongly<br />
advise both buyers and sellers of carbon<br />
to take professional advice. Please<br />
contact Partner and Head of Carbon<br />
Mike Thompson at Bell Ingram for more<br />
information. Tel. 01738 621 121 or email<br />
mike.thompson@bellingram.co.uk<br />
62 bi2019 bi<strong>2022</strong> winter spring winter spring bi2019 bi<strong>2022</strong> 97<br />
Peatland<br />
restoration.
carbon<br />
carbon<br />
Resources<br />
As the network has developed, more resources have been created to help<br />
land managers take that next step to planting trees on their land. Simplified<br />
woodland creation guidance, small farm loan scheme, FAS funding to name<br />
but a few and most of all, having access to other farmers and crofters who<br />
can share their practical knowledge to those considering woodland creation on<br />
whatever scale. This information is available online at www.forestry.gov.scot and<br />
www.fas.scot<br />
Scottish Forestry continues<br />
to forge stronger working<br />
relationships with farmers through<br />
A video featuring Bell Ingram’s Matthew Imrie, Hillhead Farm, Torrance, one of the host<br />
farmers, discussing the decision to plant trees on his family farm and key considerations<br />
others farmers should be aware of. Watch it at www.farmingforabetterclimate.org/<br />
integrating-trees-on-your-land<br />
Everyone is welcome to book onto these free virtual online events. This is a farmer<br />
and crofter-led network so please get in touch and let the organisers know what<br />
topics you want to discuss. Drop lyn.white@forestry.gov.scot or Hilary.Grant@gov.scot<br />
an email. Events coming up:<br />
Tea and Trees with Crofters: Thursday 17th February, 6 – 7pm<br />
A chance to chat about planting trees on your croft - come and share your experiences<br />
and ask your questions. This discussion group will bring crofters together to chat<br />
about woodland creation projects along with specialists from Scottish Forestry and<br />
The Woodland Trust, Croft Woodland Project. This will be an informal networking<br />
event and a chance to make connections and chat with other crofters to share<br />
your experiences and knowledge. Join with a cup of tea to discuss the objectives,<br />
challenges and potential for integrating trees on crofts. Look out for booking details<br />
on the Integrating Trees Network website www.farmingforabetterclimate.org<br />
The Integrating Trees Network is<br />
up and running and going from<br />
strength to strength.<br />
This farmer and crofter-led<br />
initiative is supported by Scottish<br />
Forestry and the Scottish<br />
Government. Its aim is to build<br />
up a strong network of farm<br />
woodland demonstration sites<br />
across Scotland, with the hosts<br />
showcasing how growing trees<br />
has helped their business.<br />
Sharing experiences and hearing<br />
from those who are actually<br />
doing it – including<br />
Bell Ingram’s Matthew Imrie -<br />
is all part of the ever growing<br />
Integrating Trees Network. The<br />
initiative has now run ten virtual<br />
events, attracting farmers and<br />
crofters from all over Scotland.<br />
The network has built up a strong<br />
network of farm woodland demonstration<br />
sites across Scotland.<br />
There are six farm woodland<br />
demonstration sites across Scotland,<br />
hosted by:<br />
• Andrew Adamson of Messrs W<br />
Laird & Son, Netherurd Home Farm,<br />
Peeblesshire.<br />
• Matthew Imrie (Bell Ingram), Hillhead<br />
Farm, Torrance.<br />
• Andrew and Debbie Duffus, Mains of<br />
Auchriachan, Tomintoul.<br />
• Andrew Whiteford, Burnfoot and<br />
Ulzieside Farm, Sanquhar.<br />
• The Barbour family, Mains of Fincastle,<br />
Pitlochry.<br />
• The Lockett family, Knockbain Farm,<br />
Dingwall.<br />
These fantastic farming hosts have<br />
shared their experiences along with a<br />
number of key practical messages for<br />
others thinking of planting trees. These<br />
are:<br />
• Use well known contractors - not always<br />
the cheapest but being recommended<br />
by others shows they know their job.<br />
• Environment - you have to work with<br />
what’s on the ground, don’t try and<br />
change it too much or work against it.<br />
• You can do the work yourself and you<br />
don’t need to rely on contractors. It can<br />
be a steep learning curve and there<br />
are challenges. It just takes time and<br />
planning, but there is support out there.<br />
• Understand your reasons for wanting<br />
to plant trees on your land and your<br />
business priorities.<br />
• Do your research: evaluate your land<br />
and monitor your farm to find out what<br />
areas are under performing for livestock<br />
but could still be suitable for planting<br />
trees.<br />
Bell Ingram’s Matthew<br />
Imrie is a big supporter<br />
of the Integrating Trees<br />
Network. He is pictured<br />
with his father John<br />
and brother Ben on the<br />
family farm outside<br />
Glasgow where he is coordinating<br />
a woodland<br />
creation scheme.<br />
• Make sure you consider whether<br />
planting trees will complement your<br />
existing farm enterprises.<br />
• Treat your woodland as another crop,<br />
making sure you are managing it<br />
properly.<br />
• Involve the local community as much<br />
as possible in planning - that helps to<br />
defuse any potential <strong>issue</strong>s.<br />
• Ask whether having trees on the farm<br />
will help diversify the nature of the<br />
business to become more adaptable,<br />
and in the future will it provide much<br />
needed shelter.<br />
• Create a habitat for wildlife: life’s pretty<br />
boring without wildlife! n<br />
Woodland Creation for Biodiversity: What needs to be considered? Discussing the<br />
ground examples, Thursday, 24th February 7 – 8pm<br />
Come along and hear from Colin Edwards, Environment Policy Advisor, Scottish<br />
Forestry, on how to create woodland to meet your biodiversity objectives. Looking<br />
at basic principles of site selection, key species to plant, integration of open habitat<br />
and creation of future habitat to maximise your biodiversity benefits. Hear and<br />
discuss with our land managers their practical experiences of creating, woodland<br />
for biodiversity. Hosts for the night are Andrew Barbour, Mains of Fincastle, Pitlochry<br />
and Richard Lockett, Knockbain, Dingwall. There will also be a representative<br />
from, Woodland Trust. Booking details on the Integrating Trees Network website<br />
www.farmingforabetterclimate.org<br />
8 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 93<br />
Copyright Crown
news<br />
Saddling up to<br />
support Netherton<br />
Bell Ingram has saddled up to<br />
support an equestrian centre whose<br />
facilities were partly destroyed by fire in<br />
2019.<br />
Supporting<br />
the ALBAS<br />
in brief<br />
Bell Ingram is delighted<br />
to support Lantra<br />
Scotland’s ALBAS<br />
Awards by coming<br />
on board as one of the main<br />
sponsors of the <strong>2022</strong> event.<br />
The prestigious ALBAS<br />
(Awards for Land-based and<br />
Aquaculture Skills) recognise<br />
and celebrate the<br />
achievements of trainees in<br />
Scotland’s rural sector, as well<br />
as encouraging employers to<br />
invest in the next generation<br />
of talent.<br />
Not only do they highlight<br />
the incredible individuals<br />
who work within our landbased,<br />
aquaculture and<br />
environmental conservation<br />
industries, but they also<br />
promote the many rewarding<br />
careers available.<br />
The <strong>2022</strong> awards are<br />
now underway, with the<br />
judges looking at all the<br />
nominations to decide who<br />
to shortlist.<br />
Bell Ingram Highland<br />
Partner Rob Whitson<br />
said: “Supporting Lantra’s<br />
ALBAS awards is a unique<br />
opportunity to help celebrate<br />
the achievements of<br />
Scotland’s top trainees and<br />
training programmes.”<br />
The awards ceremony is<br />
being held in the DoubleTree<br />
by Hilton Hotel Dunblane<br />
Hydro on Thursday 3rd March<br />
The company has sponsored both a<br />
jump and advertising board at the newly<br />
constructed arena at Netherton Equestrian,<br />
near Bridge of Earn, where owners the Wilkie<br />
family are working hard to build two new<br />
indoor schools and other amazing facilities.<br />
Find out more at www.<br />
nethertonequestrian.co.uk<br />
RSABI Supporters<br />
Scheme<br />
Bell Ingram is once again<br />
supporting farmers’ charity<br />
RSABI through its corporate<br />
supporters’ scheme.<br />
By joining the scheme, the company<br />
will support 10-12 counselling sessions for a farmer struggling<br />
with poor mental health helping them to move forward.<br />
RASABI exists to support people in Scottish agriculture<br />
by providing important emotional, practical and financial<br />
assistance to individuals and their families across the sector.<br />
Find out more at www.rsabi.org.uk n<br />
<strong>2022</strong>, hosted by farmer and<br />
stand-up comedian, Jim<br />
Smith.<br />
Lantra is one of the leading<br />
awarding bodies for landbased<br />
industries in both<br />
the UK and the Republic<br />
of Ireland. It develops<br />
quality training courses<br />
and nationally recognised<br />
qualifications that are<br />
delivered through a national<br />
network of training Provider<br />
Partners.<br />
Find out more at<br />
www.lantra.co.uk<br />
Don’t miss the<br />
Scottish deadlines<br />
Basic Payment Scheme - To<br />
apply and claim your entitlements,<br />
you must submit a Single<br />
Application Form. This is normally<br />
sent to you in March, unless you<br />
are a new claimant or did not<br />
claim the previous year. The closing<br />
date for the Single Application<br />
Form is 15th May <strong>2022</strong>.<br />
Less Favoured Area Support<br />
Scheme (LFASS) - You can<br />
claim LFASS through your Single<br />
Application Form during the<br />
application window, from 16th<br />
March to 15th May <strong>2022</strong>.<br />
Agri-Environment Climate<br />
Scheme - The <strong>2022</strong> Agri-<br />
Environment Climate Scheme<br />
application round opened on<br />
Monday 24th January and will<br />
close on Friday 29th April <strong>2022</strong><br />
Scottish Suckler Beef Support<br />
Scheme (Mainland and<br />
Islands) - Claims can be made<br />
throughout the year and there is<br />
no limit to the number of claims<br />
you can make by the close of the<br />
scheme year on 31st December<br />
<strong>2022</strong>.<br />
Scottish Upland Sheep<br />
Support Scheme - Claims can<br />
be made from 1st September<br />
<strong>2022</strong> and there is no limit to the<br />
number of claims you can make<br />
until the close of the application<br />
period on 30 November <strong>2022</strong>.<br />
If you would like to hear more<br />
about our applications and<br />
schemes advice services,<br />
contact your local Bell Ingram<br />
office for no obligation chat<br />
about your situation.<br />
Durris depot<br />
reflects the future<br />
of low carbon<br />
workplace builds<br />
Designing a<br />
low carbon<br />
office for<br />
Forestry<br />
and Land<br />
Scotland<br />
(FLS) has<br />
been a<br />
hugely rewarding experience<br />
for Murray Fleming, Bell Ingram<br />
Design’s senior architect.<br />
He wanted to create an<br />
exemplar for his clients,<br />
who are strongly focused on<br />
sustainability as they strive to<br />
become a greener organisation<br />
and ultimately reach their Net<br />
Zero goal.<br />
The build, which is located<br />
at FLS’s Durris Depot near<br />
Banchory, provided the<br />
opportunity to deliver an<br />
optimised workplace, using<br />
sustainable materials and<br />
minimising energy consumption.<br />
Murray Fleming says:<br />
“Forestry and Land Scotland’s<br />
commitment to making its<br />
infrastructure more sustainable<br />
meant it was extremely<br />
important for BID to deliver<br />
a sustainable and inclusive<br />
workplace which embedded<br />
our client’s green principles in<br />
its design.<br />
“In many ways Durris offers<br />
a glimpse into the future<br />
of workplace construction.<br />
Unfortunately, builds like this<br />
are still the exception, but by<br />
highlighting the benefits of<br />
using sustainable materials,<br />
making renewable energy<br />
choices and incorporating<br />
smarter working principles,<br />
we hope to encourage others<br />
in the sector to consider such<br />
techniques.”<br />
A flexible design has enabled<br />
Bell Ingram Design to embrace<br />
the Civil Service’s ‘smarter<br />
working’ principles of using<br />
technology, property and<br />
leadership to give workers more<br />
flexibility over how, when and<br />
where they work.<br />
There are no allocated desks<br />
or fixed computers, instead<br />
the office accommodation at<br />
Durris allows for quick laptop<br />
connection at any workstation<br />
by any user. To facilitate a<br />
‘clear desk’ policy, lockers are<br />
provided for personal staff<br />
belongings. In addition, all<br />
desks are ‘rise and fall’ allowing<br />
a personalised set-up from<br />
sitting to standing.<br />
cell spray insulation provides<br />
exceptional air tightness.<br />
Murray used aluminium<br />
clad timber windows and<br />
doors which combined the<br />
low embodied energy of<br />
timber and the long-term<br />
performance of aluminium<br />
with its ability to recycle<br />
at end of building's life.<br />
Aluminium profile sheeting<br />
was used on the roof as<br />
well, again for its long term<br />
performance and recycling<br />
credentials.<br />
To minimise energy<br />
consumption, the orientation<br />
and glazing were designed to<br />
maximise passive solar energy<br />
gains, with external louvres<br />
providing protection from<br />
summer overheating. Summer<br />
cooling is enhanced by the<br />
inclusion of sliding doors to<br />
the staff room and main office.<br />
All lighting is LED although<br />
the high levels of daylighting<br />
reduces the need for artificial<br />
lighting.<br />
Heating is provided by an air<br />
source pump also serving<br />
water based underfloor<br />
heating. With 100% renewable<br />
electricity available this<br />
approach allows the building<br />
to operate with a fully<br />
renewable energy source.<br />
Along with the construction of<br />
the new building, the brief also<br />
included extensive upgrades<br />
to the external yard areas to<br />
provide additional parking and<br />
improvements to the day-today<br />
operation of the depot. n<br />
10 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 11 3<br />
E<br />
Murray Fleming<br />
Associate Design<br />
Highlands<br />
Tel: 01463 717 799<br />
lsewhere, breakout areas<br />
are provided for casual<br />
one-to-one meetings<br />
and ‘touch down’ short period<br />
use, and an external terrace<br />
further extends the flexibility<br />
of the working environment.<br />
A key element in the build<br />
was the choice of materials.<br />
Sustainably sourced larch<br />
cladding was the low energy<br />
choice for the timber exterior,<br />
while castor-oil-based open<br />
carbon<br />
If you are considering a<br />
building project of any size,<br />
Bell Ingram Design is on<br />
hand to provide the expert<br />
advice to help you achieve<br />
your goals. Email design@<br />
bellingram.co.uk
land management<br />
land management<br />
Devil’s Advocate: Making the case for and against<br />
the reintroduction of beavers<br />
Carrie McLennan<br />
There’s no doubt that beaver<br />
reintroduction has caused<br />
plenty of conflict between<br />
conservationists and land<br />
managers. Depending which<br />
side of the fence you’re on,<br />
you either love them or hate them …<br />
and in my line of work, it tends to be the<br />
latter.<br />
conservationists could be the key to<br />
helping both sides understand the<br />
species and its management options.<br />
There are a number of effective<br />
measures which can mitigate the<br />
negative impacts of the species and<br />
allow for landowners and beavers to<br />
coexist. Flow devices, for example,<br />
alleviate the impacts of beaver-related<br />
flooding <strong>issue</strong>s by allowing the flow of<br />
water to continue in a waterway where<br />
dams are present.<br />
Recent developments regarding<br />
translocation also allow for beavers to<br />
be relocated, under a protected species<br />
licence through NatureScot to other<br />
parts of Scotland if they are causing<br />
a disturbance to land managers and<br />
prime agricultural land. Previously the<br />
only option was to relocate beavers<br />
to the established trial population in<br />
Knapdale, or to move them to England.<br />
This means beavers can now be moved<br />
to places where they will benefit nature<br />
and the environment, reduce the risk of<br />
damage to agricultural enterprises, and<br />
crucially, help resolve conflict between<br />
key stakeholders.<br />
with society since 1922, offering one<br />
of the best examples of the benefits<br />
brought by reintroducing a lost species.<br />
There is no reason why this cannot be<br />
the case in Scotland, we just need to<br />
better understand the benefits that<br />
keystone species such as the beaver<br />
can bring, and utilise the management<br />
options available. n<br />
However, it is important to look at<br />
re-introduction with an open mind, as<br />
beavers have the potential to bring a<br />
whole host of environmental, economic,<br />
and social benefits. Right now, this is<br />
more important than ever, and keystone<br />
species such as the beaver have the<br />
power to define entire ecosystems, so<br />
maybe it is time that we viewed them in<br />
a different light?<br />
Indeed, this is about more than just<br />
re-introducing an extinct species, it’s<br />
about restoring lost ecosystems. Beavers<br />
are called ecosystem engineers for good<br />
reason as they have a profound impact<br />
on their surroundings and possess the<br />
ability to restructure their environment<br />
through the creation of new habitats,<br />
increasing biodiversity, and restoring<br />
ecosystem functionality.<br />
I believe that improved communication<br />
between stakeholders and<br />
We should also bear in mind that<br />
beavers can and do coexist with<br />
people. This has been evident<br />
elsewhere in Europe, where the<br />
species reintroduction in Sweden has<br />
been commended as one of the most<br />
successful ever, as they have coexisted<br />
Evidence of beaver<br />
activity near Clunie<br />
Loch in Perthshire<br />
In 2009 the Scottish Wildlife<br />
Trust, in partnership with the<br />
Royal Zoological Society of<br />
Scotland and Forestry and Land<br />
Scotland, launched the first<br />
beaver re-introduction trial at<br />
Knapdale Forest in Argyll.<br />
The trial had mixed results but<br />
through further re-introductions<br />
elsewhere, both legally and illegally,<br />
Scotland’s beaver population is now<br />
reaching record levels.<br />
This increase in numbers has<br />
prompted much controversy<br />
and debate, especially with the<br />
announcement of a new beaver<br />
release site being approved at Argaty,<br />
near Doune, which is the first since<br />
Knapdale,<br />
Against this backdrop, Senior<br />
Associate Charlotte Gilfillan and<br />
Assistant Land Agent Carrie McLennan<br />
from our Highland Office explore both<br />
sides of the argument and discuss the<br />
future of beavers in Scotland.<br />
Hunted to<br />
extinction around<br />
400 years ago,<br />
beavers were once<br />
a native species<br />
Charlotte Gilfillan<br />
The reintroduction of the beaver in the UK has been<br />
hailed a huge success by conservationists and rewilders,<br />
with numbers tripling in Scotland over the last<br />
three years.<br />
While I recognise there are some important ecological<br />
benefits to the return of beavers, it has come at a huge cost. From<br />
destruction of arable crops through blocking drains and ditches,<br />
burrowing through flood defences, felling of trees, flooding of<br />
commercial forestry plantations, the list goes on. Even designated<br />
sites have been impacted in some areas, with beavers raising<br />
water levels sufficiently to threaten the site's favourable status.<br />
Infrastructure hasn’t escaped unscathed either, with roads and<br />
railways being damaged by burrowing, damming and flooding.<br />
Last year Network Rail announced they had successfully built<br />
‘Scotland’s first beaver tunnel’ in a culvert under the Highland line<br />
in Perthshire, to much fanfare. What they didn’t highlight was that<br />
it took several teams from Network Rail plus outside contractors<br />
and specialists many months of work to resolve the problem of<br />
the dammed culvert and build the tunnel, all at significant cost to<br />
the taxpayer.<br />
Although mitigation measures like flow devices, translocation and<br />
tree protection are available, there are still costs attached to these<br />
options. One of the most effective tools in managing beavers,<br />
particularly around arable crops, is a licence for lethal control.<br />
The future of NatureScot’s Beaver Management Framework and<br />
licensing system, which includes lethal control, was subject to<br />
judicial review last year, following a legal challenge by Trees for<br />
Life. The majority of the complaints were thankfully dismissed<br />
but it is vital that this licence remains available as numbers and<br />
impacts of beavers increase.<br />
The re-introduction of any species will inevitably bring its own set<br />
of unique challenges, particularly those that have been extinct<br />
for hundreds of years and whose natural range and landscape<br />
is now completely managed. Trials are therefore imperative to<br />
determine the feasibility of any re-introduction and to consider<br />
the consequences, both intended and unintended.<br />
Given the uncertain success of the initial trial at Knapdale, where<br />
the population failed to grow, there is a question of whether<br />
future legal re-introductions would have been supported by<br />
the Scottish Government. However, by the time the trial results<br />
were available many beavers had already been released illegally<br />
by private individuals in Perthshire, deliberately and without<br />
repercussion, leaving farmers and landowners to pick up the cost.<br />
With the beaver then subsequently becoming a protected species<br />
in 2019, this undoubtedly fuelled the debate further and set a<br />
dangerous precedent for future re-introductions.<br />
Driven by the Climate Emergency and Biodiversity Crisis, species<br />
re-introduction has never been more topical or more polarised.<br />
If the re-introduction of beavers in Scotland is to be used as a<br />
benchmark against which other proposed re-introductions are<br />
considered, then I have a gnawing feeling we could be in serious<br />
trouble. Ultimately the question remains, do the benefits really<br />
outweigh the costs - I remain unconvinced. n<br />
in Scotland<br />
12 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 13 5
property<br />
property<br />
Achieving record<br />
results for our<br />
clients in a complex<br />
property market<br />
Rural expertise pays<br />
dividends for our clients<br />
By Carl Warden, Property Partner<br />
Crianlarich, Stirlingshire<br />
An amenity farm, about 216 acres,<br />
with principle farmhouse, a range of<br />
farm buildings and sporting rights.<br />
Offers over £550,000<br />
Methven, Perthshire<br />
An amenity farm, about 149 acres,<br />
principle farmhouse, detached cottage,<br />
farm buildings, sporting rights.<br />
Offers over £1,500,000<br />
Milnathort, Kinross-shire<br />
Luxury detached family home with<br />
latest energy saving techniques and<br />
smart technology.<br />
Fixed Price £509,000<br />
Despite the uncertainties surrounding the Covid-19 crisis and ever-changing<br />
guidelines for the industry, Bell Ingram’s property team has enjoyed huge<br />
success over the last two years.<br />
Repeated lockdowns have seen us all spend more time in our homes, which<br />
has really focussed the mind of buyers on what they truly want and need from<br />
their spaces, and as a result we are seeing unprecedented demand for rural<br />
property with ample green space as well as additional living space.<br />
Such high demand coupled with a shortage of stock has driven up valuations<br />
with residential properties achieving anything between 5% to 30% over the<br />
asking price, and I expect this upward trend to continue into <strong>2022</strong>.<br />
The land and farm sales markets are also highly competitive, and our wellplaced<br />
agents have experienced great results in these markets. As rural<br />
business experts, Bell Ingram agents understand the rural market and are<br />
able to take a creative approach to selling to achieve the best results for our<br />
clients.<br />
Being part of a firm that includes, valuations, land management, forestry,<br />
mapping and planning pays dividends. For example, our Perthshire agents<br />
recently achieved 25% over the asking price for a farming client by separating<br />
land for forestry and securing permissions for property development.<br />
Meanwhile, a recent large estate sale achieved 13.5% over the asking price of<br />
£1.6million following 173 viewings and 50 offers for our client.<br />
With so much opportunity in the market currently, now is a favourable time<br />
to sell. But for buyers it is not always the ones with deepest pockets who are<br />
coming out on top! Buyers who have all their ducks in a row, and who are<br />
outwith chains, are often more successful than the highest bidder in securing<br />
their dream home.<br />
Because we ask our buyers the right questions, we always secure the best<br />
deal for our clients. We would therefore recommend that anyone who is<br />
thinking of selling their rural property to get in touch with our agents as soon<br />
as possible to discuss your options.<br />
If you are considering selling your home, farm or estate, our dedicated team<br />
is on hand to provide the expert advice you need. Contact Carl Warden<br />
on 01738 621121 or email carl.warden@bellingram.co.uk.<br />
Dornoch, Sutherland<br />
Diversified arable farm, about 155<br />
acres, farmhouse, farm buildings,<br />
commercial trout lochs, caravan site<br />
and golf driving range.<br />
Offers over £850,000<br />
Oban, Argyll & Bute<br />
Unique beachfront property with open<br />
views across to the isles of Mull and<br />
Lismore.<br />
Offers over £875,000<br />
Logierait, Perthshire<br />
Residential Estate, about 275 acres,<br />
principle house, two cottages, grazing<br />
land, woodland and salmon fishing<br />
rights.<br />
Offers over £1,600,000<br />
Bankfoot, Perthshire<br />
Substantial stone built villa in elevated<br />
grounds of 0.6 acres with panoramic<br />
country views.<br />
Offers over £475,000<br />
Logierait, Perthshire<br />
A unique substantial barn conversion,<br />
with typical period features, in a<br />
stunning elevated position.<br />
Offers over £625,000<br />
Balcraig, Perthshire<br />
A substantial, beautifully presented<br />
family home in over 0.4 acres of<br />
grounds with views over the golf<br />
course to the hills beyond.<br />
Offers over £625,000<br />
14 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 153
land management<br />
estate agency<br />
What is rural land worth?<br />
Land values in Scotland and the North of England<br />
of surrounding land), the hill land with<br />
grazing, and the salmon fishing rights.<br />
This highly successful strategy generated<br />
173 viewings, which required careful<br />
organisation by our Agency team as Covid<br />
restrictions were still in place!<br />
Sarah Tyson<br />
Partner and Head of<br />
Valuations<br />
sarah.tyson@<br />
bellingram.co.uk<br />
Bell Ingram’s guide to average<br />
rural land values in Scotland<br />
and the North of England<br />
has been updated and<br />
proves a useful tool for<br />
many involved with land<br />
transactions.<br />
In reviewing the figures, Sarah Tyson,<br />
Head of Valuations, said:<br />
“Average arable land and the best<br />
pasture land values have been relatively<br />
steady but there is still limited supply<br />
and continuing demand, especially<br />
where neighbours have the chance<br />
to buy. Borrowers are looking to take<br />
advantage of current low interest rates<br />
whilst they can and certainly AMC<br />
lending has seen a lot of fixed loan rate<br />
being very popular.<br />
“The forestry sector remains very<br />
strong with good timber markets. The<br />
unprecedented demand from investors<br />
for land suitable for tree planting<br />
continues and is further fuelled due to<br />
the impact of Natural Capital, including<br />
peatland restoration and rewilding<br />
projects, although values are very site<br />
specific (and can seem eye watering),<br />
making it difficult to apply averages.<br />
“Values for sporting interests are steady,<br />
but again vary depending upon the<br />
particular estate, location and facilities.<br />
Scotland has seen an increase in estate<br />
sales to those looking for forestry/Natural<br />
Capital interests and these examples of<br />
land use bring different dimensions, and,<br />
approach to prices. Nevertheless, deer<br />
management is still essential, and fishers<br />
are ever hopeful of a catch!”<br />
Note: The figures quoted provide general indications of value only and should not be relied upon. If<br />
you have a property which needs an updated valuation for any reason, get in touch and one of our<br />
team of RICS Registered Valuers or Sales Agents will be able to assist. n<br />
Bare Land Capital Values,Scotland* £/per acre (min) £/per acre (max)<br />
Best Arable 8,000 17,000<br />
Secondary Arable 5,000 8,000<br />
LFA / Low Grade Arable 3,000 5,000<br />
Temporary Grass / Silage 2,500 5,000<br />
Permanent Pasture 1,500 4,000<br />
Rough Grazing 450 1,000<br />
Hill 50 750<br />
*excluding any forestry planting premium<br />
Existing Forestry (crop and solum) * £/ per ha (min) £/per ha (max)<br />
Productive Conifer Woodland 6,000 16,000<br />
Pre-‐Productive Conifer Woodland 3,000 6,000<br />
Native/ broadleaf/ retention woodland 3,000 8,000<br />
*these exclude any carbon credit/ peatland sums which may apply <br />
Sporting Values, Scotland <br />
Red Deer Stags (per head) 12,000 40,000<br />
Driven Grouse (per brace) 3,500 5,000<br />
Salmon (per fish) 2,500 7,000<br />
Land Values -‐ North of England* £/per acre (min) £/per acre (max)<br />
Best Arable 9,000 15,000<br />
Secondary Arable 7,500 10,000<br />
Permanent Pasture 5,000 8,000<br />
Rough Grazing 3,000 6,500<br />
Hill 1,500 2,500<br />
*excluding any forestry planting premium<br />
Existing Forestry (crop and solum) * £/ per ha (min) £/per ha (max)<br />
Productive Conifer Woodland 6,000 16,000<br />
Pre-‐Productive Conifer Woodland 3,000 6,000<br />
Native/ broadleaf/ retention woodland 3,000 8,000<br />
*these exclude any carbon credit/peatland sums which may apply <br />
Perthshire estate achieved<br />
significantly over the<br />
asking price after being<br />
offered in five separate lots<br />
The successful sale of a compact rural<br />
Estate was one of the highlights of 2021<br />
for Carl Warden, Partner and Head of<br />
Estate Agency.<br />
The 275 acre Perthshire<br />
property, which centred<br />
around a nine-bedroom<br />
principal house, parts of<br />
which dated back to the<br />
1500s, had been in the<br />
same family for a number<br />
of generations.<br />
With outstanding views<br />
over River Tay to the hills<br />
beyond, the property<br />
also encompassed two<br />
detached cottages,<br />
grazing land, salmon<br />
fishing rights and<br />
woodland. Interestingly,<br />
Fifty offers were<br />
received in total<br />
and the Estate was<br />
eventually sold in<br />
three lots achieving<br />
significantly above<br />
the initial listing<br />
at offers over £1.6<br />
million.<br />
the top section of the Estate was subject<br />
to an SSSI as an important breeding<br />
ground for the Northern Blue Damselfly.<br />
On the death of the<br />
last of the family, the<br />
Executors asked Bell<br />
Ingram to put the Estate<br />
to the open market and<br />
it generated significant<br />
interest when it was<br />
launched for sale in<br />
springtime.<br />
To achieve the best<br />
possible outcome for our<br />
client, it was decided<br />
to offer the Estate both<br />
as a whole and also as<br />
five separate lots - each<br />
of the three residential<br />
properties (with an area<br />
It went to a closing date after seven<br />
weeks and interested parties were asked<br />
to submit two offers each – one covering<br />
a complete ‘lot’ and a second offer with<br />
their ‘wish list’.<br />
Fifty offers were received in total and the<br />
Estate was eventually sold in three lots<br />
achieving significantly above the initial<br />
listing at offers over £1.6 million.<br />
Carl Warden said: “This was a fantastic sale<br />
to be involved with and the complexity of<br />
the situation demonstrated Bell Ingram’s<br />
range of expertise and our ability to add<br />
value to your property sale.<br />
“When selling a property like this, it is vital<br />
that you employ a professional agent who<br />
can navigate the market with experience<br />
and sensitivity.<br />
“Our sales team can offer a full range<br />
of marketing strategies and create a<br />
bespoke blueprint to deliver maximum<br />
exposure which could result in additional<br />
offers and a higher value being attained.<br />
“Looking ahead to the rest of <strong>2022</strong>, we<br />
predict clients who bring land to the<br />
market will be rewarded with strong<br />
prices.”<br />
If you are considering an Estate sale, our<br />
dedicated team is on hand to provide the<br />
expert advice you need to help achieve<br />
the best possible result. Contact Carl<br />
Warden on 01738 621 121 or email carl.<br />
warden@bellingram.co.uk<br />
16 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring winter bi<strong>2022</strong> bi2019 171
GIS mapping<br />
land GIS management<br />
mapping<br />
Spotlight on our<br />
GIS Mapping Service<br />
Bell Ingram’s GIS experts provide high quality plans and<br />
maps for use in a variety of situations.<br />
Based in our Perth office, GIS Manager Marcus Humphrey<br />
works closely with GIS Technician Mhairi Walker, to support<br />
clients and colleagues across a range of land management<br />
sectors, including forestry, utilities and renewables, and<br />
estate agency.<br />
Says Marcus Humphrey: “Our dedicated team, which<br />
is enhanced by a number of colleagues with mapping<br />
skills, fully understands the requirements of the rural land<br />
management sector, its changing requirements and the<br />
organisations within it,<br />
“We combine current GIS technologies with the most<br />
relevant datasets to deliver a high-quality mapping service<br />
and no matter the size or scale of the project we have both<br />
the agility and ability to provide a quick turnaround when<br />
deadlines are at stake.”<br />
Mapping services<br />
• Land Registry<br />
compliant title plans<br />
• Lease plans<br />
• Wayleave, servitude<br />
and easement plans<br />
• Land referencing<br />
• Geo-referencing<br />
• Feasibility studies<br />
• Farms & Estate<br />
mapping<br />
• Data cleansing<br />
• Database management<br />
• Bespoke GIS solutions<br />
GIS Manager Marcus Humphrey and<br />
GIS Technician Mhairi Walker.<br />
• Large scale utility<br />
project mapping<br />
• Forestry mapping<br />
• Historical mapping<br />
analysis<br />
• Web-GIS applications<br />
• 3D visualisations and<br />
modelling<br />
• GPS Surveys<br />
• Drone Surveys<br />
Data Management Services<br />
• GIS transformation<br />
• Geographic data<br />
science<br />
Get In Touch: For more information, please contact GIS<br />
Manager Marcus Humphrey. 01728 621 121 or<br />
marcus.humphrey@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Bell Ingram’s<br />
multi-service<br />
approach<br />
achieves<br />
record price<br />
for farmer<br />
Bell Ingram’s<br />
Estate Agency<br />
team drew on<br />
the expertise<br />
of colleagues<br />
from the<br />
company’s<br />
GIS Mapping,<br />
Forestry and Planning<br />
departments to achieve a record<br />
result for a farming client.<br />
Located on the edge of the<br />
very buoyant Glasgow market,<br />
the 380-acre Bandominie<br />
Farm consisted of a farmhouse<br />
with outbuildings, a modern<br />
bungalow and a large area of<br />
potential forestry land.<br />
The owner, who had lived<br />
there all his life, occupied<br />
the modern bungalow with<br />
his own family, while his<br />
elderly parents remained in<br />
the original farmhouse,<br />
which was in need of<br />
considerable modernisation<br />
and renovation.<br />
To achieve the best possible<br />
price for our client, we<br />
advised that breaking the<br />
farm into separate parts would<br />
be the most lucrative way<br />
forward.<br />
The first step in this process was<br />
to map the property thoroughly<br />
and our in-house GIS Mapping<br />
Department was tasked with<br />
providing three mapped areas<br />
of land – 275 acres for forestry<br />
planting, 19 acres to go with<br />
the old farmhouse and its<br />
considerable outbuildings, and<br />
a further 2.5 acres of paddock<br />
to be sold with the modern<br />
bungalow.<br />
Bell Ingram’s Planning<br />
Department then made<br />
an application to have the<br />
Section 75 planning condition<br />
removed from the farm<br />
which allowed us to sell<br />
the residential properties<br />
separately.<br />
The two residential properties<br />
were listed at £200k for the<br />
farmhouse, outbuildings and<br />
19 acres, while the modern<br />
bungalow was put to the market<br />
at £250k with the paddocks and<br />
two small stables.<br />
The attractive guide price,<br />
coupled with the lack of<br />
available stock in the Glasgow<br />
area, generated just short<br />
of 200 enquiries which<br />
resulted in 121 viewings being<br />
arranged in only six working<br />
days. A closing date saw both<br />
properties sold to the same<br />
buyer, achieving significantly<br />
above the initial listing.<br />
However, it was the Forestry<br />
potential of the sale which<br />
ultimately generated the<br />
best outcome. Bell Ingram’s<br />
Forestry Department<br />
approached their private<br />
clients offering the 275<br />
acres for an asking price in<br />
the region of £450,000 to<br />
£650,000, and our client<br />
was rather overwhelmed<br />
when a closing date achieved<br />
significantly above the asking<br />
price!<br />
Head of Estate Agency Carl<br />
Warden said: “Bandominie is<br />
a great example of why it can<br />
make sense to break complex<br />
properties down into separate<br />
components if you want to<br />
achieve the best possible<br />
price. It also underlines why it’s<br />
important to employ an agent<br />
with rural land and business<br />
experience who can draw on a<br />
range of expertise to add value<br />
to the sale.”<br />
If you are considering selling<br />
your farm, our dedicated team<br />
is on hand to provide the<br />
expert advice you need<br />
to help achieve the best<br />
possible result. Contact<br />
Carl Warden on 01738 621<br />
121 or email carl.warden@<br />
bellingram.co.uk<br />
18 bi<strong>2022</strong> spring spring bi<strong>2022</strong> 19
www.bellingram.co.uk<br />
Follow Bell Ingram on:<br />
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter,<br />
Linkedin<br />
Beauly<br />
Oban<br />
Ayr<br />
Aberdeen<br />
Forfar<br />
Perth<br />
Morpeth<br />
Ambleside<br />
Head Offce: Durn, Isla Road, Perth<br />
Northwich<br />
Thirsk<br />
Perth<br />
Isla Road<br />
Perth, PH2 7HF<br />
Tel: 01738 621 121<br />
Email: enquiries@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Aberdeen<br />
2 Albert Street,<br />
Aberdeen, AB25 1XQ<br />
Tel: 01224 621 300<br />
Email: aberdeen@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Ambleside<br />
Low Nook, University of Cumbria<br />
Rydal Road, Ambleside<br />
Cumbria, LA22 9BB<br />
Tel: 01539 896 101<br />
Email: ambleside@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Ayr<br />
33 Sandgate,<br />
Ayr, KA7 1BG<br />
Tel: 01292 886 544<br />
Email: ayr@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Forfar<br />
Manor Street<br />
Forfar, DD8 1EX<br />
Tel: 01307 462 516<br />
Email: forfar@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Highland<br />
5 High Street<br />
Beauly, IV4 7BS<br />
Tel: 01463 717799<br />
Email: highland@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Morpeth<br />
Ellington Business Centre<br />
Lynemouth Road, Ellington<br />
Morpeth, NE61 5HB<br />
Tel: 01670 862 235<br />
Email: morpeth@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Northwich<br />
Blakemere Village, Chester Road<br />
Sandiway, Northwich<br />
Cheshire, CW8 2EB<br />
Tel: 01606 523 030<br />
Email: northwich@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Oban<br />
5 Albany Street<br />
Oban, PA34 4AR<br />
Tel: 01631 566122<br />
Email: oban@bellingram.co.uk<br />
Thirsk<br />
Thirsk Rural Business Centre<br />
Blakey Lane, Thirsk<br />
North Yorkshire, YO7 3AB<br />
Tel: 01845 522 095<br />
Email: thirsk@bellingram.co.uk<br />
winter bi2019 1