YSM Issue 95.4
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Yale Scientific<br />
THE NATION’S OLDEST COLLEGE SCIENCE PUBLICATION • ESTABLISHED IN 1894<br />
DECEMBER 2022<br />
VOL. 95 NO. 4 • $6.99<br />
14<br />
RECODING IN<br />
THE BRAIN<br />
STREAMLINING THE<br />
16<br />
SEARCH FOR NEW DRUGS<br />
ON DEMAND<br />
18<br />
MEMBRANE DEFORMATION<br />
THE NEW<br />
21<br />
CIRCULAR ECONOMY<br />
LAB PROFILE:<br />
24<br />
CARDS LAB
TABLE OF<br />
VOL. 95 ISSUE NO. 4<br />
14<br />
Recoding in the Brain<br />
Elisa Howard<br />
The brain is constantly recoding itself. Researchers at Mount Sinai and Yale School of Medicine<br />
uncover details of adenosine-to-inosine (A-to-I) editing in the brain, thereby providing insight into<br />
neurodevelopment and disease.<br />
16 Streamlining the Search for New Drugs<br />
Emily Shang<br />
The research and development process of drug synthesis has always been long and arduous.<br />
Researchers of the Ellman Lab have recently synthesized a molecule capable of targeting the 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor using a novel screening technique that can expedite the drug discovery process.<br />
18 On-Demand Membrane Deformation<br />
Risha Chakraborty<br />
Studying complex cellular processes in real-time continues to prove difficult for researchers,<br />
since manipulating many biological, chemical, and physical factors simultaneously requires nearimpossible<br />
levels of precision and control. Reimagining the role of common macromolecules in the<br />
cell might just help.<br />
21 The New Circular Economy<br />
Abigail Jolteus<br />
As climate change worsens, the need for more sustainable methods to produce energy also<br />
increases. Researchers at the Yale School of Environment have investigated the potential of a new<br />
technology, bioenergy with carbon capture and storage, which could help create a sustainable<br />
and low-carbon society.<br />
24 Lab Profile: CarDS Lab<br />
Yusuf Rasheed<br />
Cardiovascular disease I'd the leading cause of death across the United States, with one affected person<br />
dying every 34 seconds. The CarDS Lab at Yale is revolutionizing how cardiovascular health is treated and<br />
managed through AI and machine learning.<br />
2 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
CONTENTS<br />
More articles online at www.yalescientific.org & https://medium.com/the-scope-yale-scientific-magazines-online-blog<br />
4<br />
6<br />
27<br />
36<br />
Q&A<br />
NEWS<br />
FEATURES<br />
SPECIALS<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
Does Parkinson's Smell? • Dinara Bolat<br />
Would You Trust Working With a Robot? • Jamie Seu<br />
Hidden Pandemic • Sofia Jacobson<br />
Big Tech is Always Watching • Alex Dong<br />
Optimistic Results for RSV Prevention Strategies • Madeleine Popofsky<br />
Forecasting Extinction • Evelyn Jiang<br />
It's Not All Bad • Matthew Blair<br />
The Case Against Intelligent Computer Vision • Samantha Liu<br />
The Soot Factor • William Archaki<br />
The Winding Synthetic Road to New Antibiotics • Nathan Mu<br />
Turtle Transformers • Riya Bhargava<br />
A New Approach to Cystic Fibrosis • Matthew Zoerb<br />
The Strength of Weak Ties • Eunsoo Hyun<br />
An Unexpected Marriage: Robot Drones & Flower Power • Cindy Mei<br />
Robots vs. Humans: Organic Chemistry Edition • Anya Razmi<br />
Gamer Neurons • Maya Khurana<br />
Conan the Bacterium • Kayla Yup<br />
The Golden Standard • Anavi Uppal<br />
Undergraduate Profile: Eric Sun (YC '23) • Cindy Kuang<br />
Alumni Profile: Jonathan Rothberg (GSAS '91) • Sophia Burick<br />
Science in the Spotlight: Eating to Extinction • Dinesh Bojja<br />
Science in the Spotlight: Atoms & Ashes • Ximena Leyva Peralta<br />
Counterpoint: Life on Mars Was Its Own Undoing • Crystal Liu<br />
Hidden Histories: Nettie Stevens • Anjali Dhanekula<br />
Synapse Essay Contest: Pulling Teeth • Kate Kim<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 3
WOULD YOU TRUST<br />
WORKING WITH A ROBOT?<br />
&<br />
DOES PARKINSON'S SMELL?<br />
By Dinara Bolat<br />
Currently, no specific diagnostic tests exist for Parkinson’s<br />
disease, a degenerative brain disorder. Instead, patients<br />
get diagnosed once they start displaying trademark<br />
symptoms like tremors, muscle stiffness, and impaired balance.<br />
However, thanks to Joy Milne, a Scottish nurse with a<br />
hypersensitive nose, this is changing.<br />
Milne came to the attention of UK scientists in 2015 when<br />
she proved her ability to detect people with Parkinson’s by their<br />
unique smell. With her help, researchers from the Universities<br />
of Edinburgh and Manchester identified specific molecules that<br />
cause ‘Parkinson’s smell.’ They identified molecules in the sebum,<br />
an oily substance on the skin surface, and found that people<br />
with Parkinson’s have altered lipid signatures compared to non-<br />
Parkinson’s patients. Using these results, they developed a skinswab<br />
test to detect this lipid signature which analyzes sebum<br />
with PS-IM-MS, a type of ion mobility mass spectrometry. This<br />
new method reveals specific compounds unique to Parkinson’s<br />
sebum samples and identifies lipid classes that are differentially<br />
secreted in patients with Parkinson’s.<br />
Scientists are hopeful that this swab test will be a key tool for earlier<br />
and faster Parkinson’s diagnosis, leading to more opportunities and<br />
options for treatment. Although there are still clinical trials and<br />
accuracy assessments required before the tests can be authorized in<br />
hospitals, scientists involved claim that the test has a greater than<br />
ninety percent accuracy. This ground-breaking technology has<br />
inspired other research teams to study the olfactory signature of<br />
other diseases, opening a new field of research yet to be explored. ■<br />
By Jamie Seu<br />
It’s a familiar trope: a well-meaning scientist invents a piece<br />
of revolutionary technology that develops consciousness<br />
and rises up to destroy the human race. Machine<br />
consciousness has long been a subject of fear and fascination,<br />
but for people who regularly interact with robots, such as those<br />
who work in the manufacturing industry, trust in automation<br />
is an incredibly pertinent issue.<br />
To better understand the nuances of trust in human-robot<br />
collaborations (HRCs), researchers at Texas A&M University<br />
designed a series of trials that allowed them to study operator<br />
trust. Participants (operators) were instructed to polish a<br />
metal surface with a robot along an S-shaped trajectory under<br />
varying levels of robot reliability and operator cognitive<br />
fatigue. Working with an unreliable robot reduced task<br />
efficiency and accuracy (deviation from the defined trajectory)<br />
but not precision (variance in deviation from the trajectory).<br />
Participants also perceived the task as more demanding than<br />
when they worked with a reliable robot. For participants<br />
experiencing cognitive fatigue, higher fatigue scores and<br />
reduced task efficiency were reported, with female participants<br />
more strongly impacted than male participants.<br />
Analyses of human factors on trust in HRCs can be utilized to<br />
create more effective worker training programs and adaptations<br />
to robot design that will maximize efficiency and workplace<br />
safety, improving and fortifying HRC systems. Robots are here<br />
to stay, and it’s on us to figure out how to work alongside them<br />
and trust them as partners. Maybe then they’ll spare us when<br />
they decide to take over the world. ■<br />
4 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
The Editor-in-Chief Speaks<br />
A FUTURE WITH SCIENCE<br />
In our final issue of the volume, we have focused on what science innovation<br />
means for the future. Novel technologies come with such great potential<br />
but almost always with caveats. While science can help lift society towards<br />
a utopia, it certainly can also do the opposite. Our duty as scientists is to<br />
prioritize the bigger picture, recognizing the ethical issues that accompany<br />
innovation. The following stories highlight science at Yale and beyond and<br />
their implications for the future of our world.<br />
Our full-length stories spotlight science’s potential in healthcare innovation.<br />
A study from the Ellman lab uses virtual screening for small molecule synthesis<br />
targeting antidepressant activity (pg. 16). The CarDS lab at the Yale School<br />
of Medicine uses data-driven strategies such as machine learning to improve<br />
cardiovascular healthcare for patients (pg. 24). Another study from the Yale<br />
School of Environment investigates how to capture energy from biomass in<br />
hopes of creating a more sustainable, low-carbon society (pg. 21)<br />
Beyond academia, the promise of science can be pursued through<br />
entrepreneurship. Jonathan Rothberg, our alumni profile, describes his prolific<br />
career, founding numerous companies inspired by the ultimate goal of helping<br />
someone he loves (pg. 37).<br />
As technology becomes increasingly advanced, the ethical questions facing<br />
researchers with each successive discovery have never been more critical. For<br />
those at the forefront of artificial intelligence, should machines be held to a<br />
higher standard than humans in the context of, for example, accidents caused<br />
by a human driver versus a self-driving car? For lead geneticists, where do they<br />
draw the line for engineering traits of our offspring—should we be able to edit<br />
out diseases, to engineer in intelligence or physical traits? For those tackling<br />
aging, what are the implications of increasing human lifespan beyond several<br />
hundred years—would it broaden the distance between social classes; would it<br />
stagnate the innovations and perspectives of new generations?<br />
It has truly been an honor serving as the Editor-in-Chief of Yale Scientific,<br />
and it is an experience I will treasure forever. Thank you to the amazing 2022<br />
masthead, writers, artists, and the Yale science community. Like the amazing<br />
people behind the stories of the last calendar year, I hope to follow suit and<br />
dedicate my life to science and the benefits it creates for society. And I hope<br />
these stories continue to inspire for years to come.<br />
About the Art<br />
Jenny Tan, Editor-in-Chief<br />
Treating cardiac disease, developing<br />
pharmaceutical drug candidates,<br />
quantifying greenhouse gas<br />
emissions: today’s growing<br />
medical, environmental, and<br />
scientific concerns look towards<br />
novel methods of research such<br />
as integrated machine learning,<br />
techno-economic analysis, and<br />
DNA nanotechnology. This issue’s<br />
cover reflects the wide array of<br />
research avenues that scientists take<br />
in order to solve our world’s most<br />
poignant problems.<br />
Anasthasia Shilov, Cover Artist<br />
MASTHEAD<br />
December 2022 VOL. 95 NO. 4<br />
EDITORIAL BOARD<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
Managing Editors<br />
News Editor<br />
Features Editor<br />
Special Sections Editor<br />
Articles Editor<br />
Online Editors<br />
Copy Editors<br />
Scope Editors<br />
Website Editor<br />
PRODUCTION & DESIGN<br />
Production Manager<br />
Layout Editors<br />
Art Editor<br />
Cover Artist<br />
Photography Editor<br />
BUSINESS<br />
Publisher<br />
Operations Manager<br />
Advertising Manager<br />
Subscriptions Manager<br />
OUTREACH<br />
Synapse Presidents<br />
Synapse Vice President<br />
Synapse Outreach Coordinators<br />
Synapse Events Coordinator<br />
WEB<br />
Web Managers<br />
Head of Social Media Team<br />
Social Media Coordinators<br />
STAFF<br />
William Archaki<br />
Riya Bhargava<br />
Matthew Blair<br />
Dinesh Bojja<br />
Dinara Bolat<br />
Wineth De Zoysa<br />
Mia Gawth<br />
Daniel Havlat<br />
Elisa Howard<br />
Eunsoo Hyun<br />
Sofia Jacobson<br />
Evelyn Jiang<br />
Maya Khurana<br />
Jenna Kim<br />
Jessica Le<br />
Ximena Leyva Peralta<br />
Cynthia Lin<br />
Crystal Liu<br />
Samantha Liu<br />
Yurou Liu<br />
Cindy Mei<br />
Kenna Morgan<br />
Nathan Mu<br />
Victor Nguyen<br />
Avi Patel<br />
Himani Pattisam<br />
Emily Poag<br />
Madeleine Popofsky<br />
Tony Potchernikov<br />
Yusuf Rasheed<br />
Jenny Tan<br />
Tai Michaels<br />
Maria Fernanda Pacheco<br />
Madison Houck<br />
Alex Dong<br />
Sophia Li<br />
Cindy Kuang<br />
Ethan Olim<br />
Tori Sodeinde<br />
Breanna Brownson<br />
Hannah Han<br />
Kayla Yup<br />
Anna Calame<br />
Hannah Huang<br />
Meili Gupta<br />
Catherine Zheng<br />
Ann-Marie Abunyewa<br />
Brianna Fernandez<br />
Malia Kuo<br />
Anasthasia Shilov<br />
Jenny Wong<br />
Jared Gould<br />
Lauren Chong<br />
Sophia Burick<br />
Shudipto Wahed<br />
Krishna Dasari<br />
Lucy Zha<br />
Rayyan Darji<br />
Hannah Barsouk<br />
Risha Chakraborty<br />
Bella Xiong<br />
Katherine Moon<br />
Emily Shang<br />
Anavi Uppal<br />
Abigail Jolteus<br />
Elizabeth Watson<br />
Anya Razmi<br />
Alex Roseman<br />
Noora Said<br />
Jamie Seu<br />
Rishi Shah<br />
Ishani Singh<br />
Kayla Sohn<br />
Yamato Takabe<br />
Kara Tao<br />
Robin Tsai<br />
Hanwen Zhang<br />
Lawrence Zhao<br />
Matthew Zoerb<br />
The Yale Scientific Magazine (<strong>YSM</strong>) is published four times a year by Yale<br />
Scientific Publications, Inc. Third class postage paid in New Haven, CT<br />
06520. Non-profit postage permit number 01106 paid for May 19, 1927<br />
under the act of August 1912. ISN:0091-287. We reserve the right to edit<br />
any submissions, solicited or unsolicited, for publication. This magazine is<br />
published by Yale College students, and Yale University is not responsible<br />
for its contents. Perspectives expressed by authors do not necessarily reflect<br />
the opinions of <strong>YSM</strong>. We retain the right to reprint contributions, both text<br />
and graphics, in future issues as well as a non-exclusive right to reproduce<br />
these in electronic form. The <strong>YSM</strong> welcomes comments and feedback. Letters<br />
to the editor should be under two hundred words and should include the<br />
author’s name and contact information. We reserve the right to edit letters<br />
before publication. Please send questions and comments to yalescientific@<br />
yale.edu. Special thanks to Yale Student Technology Collaborative.
NEWS<br />
Gender Studies & Data Science / Computer Science & Law<br />
HIDDEN<br />
PANDEMIC<br />
BIG TECH IS<br />
ALWAYS<br />
WATCHING<br />
BY SOFIA JACOBSON<br />
BY ALEX DONG<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF PIXABAY<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
The pandemic drastically altered the daily tasks of many<br />
adults who, in addition to their everyday professions,<br />
took on new responsibilities in the home, including<br />
child and elder care. As many of these new duties fell mainly<br />
to women, associate research scientist Ji-Young Son and<br />
Professor of Environmental Health Michelle Bell launched a<br />
series of studies on how women and minority scientists were<br />
potentially disproportionately impacted by the pandemic.<br />
One study with the Yale School of Environment, supported<br />
by the Yale Women Faculty Forum, focused on gender<br />
disparities in submissions to academic science journals.<br />
The researchers hypothesized that the percentage of<br />
women scientists submitting articles would decrease during<br />
the pandemic. They found that there was actually an increase<br />
in women’s submissions compared to men. They examined<br />
99,114 submissions from January 2019 to July 2021. Of<br />
these, the corresponding authors were 82.1 percent male,<br />
17.8 percent female, and 0.1 percent nonbinary. Comparing<br />
the pre-pandemic time to the pandemic time, the percentage<br />
of women submitting slightly increased to 18.7 percent.<br />
However, the pandemic did have one notable effect on<br />
women’s submissions. “The rate of increase in submissions<br />
[by women] slowed during the pandemic compared to the<br />
pre-pandemic period,” Son said.<br />
There is still enormous gender disparity in the sciences.<br />
Although studies such as this one are bringing the issue to<br />
light, the problem continues—before, during, and after the<br />
COVID-19 pandemic. “More resources from universities,<br />
not [just] individual efforts, and other measures for women<br />
scientists are needed to promote equality,” Son said. ■<br />
Have you ever read Facebook’s Terms of Service after<br />
downloading the app? Chances are, probably not. While<br />
we often mindlessly click ‘accept,’ big tech companies<br />
like Meta have been known to violate user privacy without<br />
their knowledge or consent. With the rapid rise of big tech, data<br />
privacy has increasingly become a concern for both individuals<br />
and regulatory organizations.<br />
In light of this issue, Adrian Kuenzler (YLS ’15), Assistant<br />
Professor of Law at Zurich University, presents a new framework<br />
for how competition between big tech companies can promote<br />
data privacy. Kuenzler’s research draws on a variety of legal<br />
investigations, empirical economic analyses, and cognitive<br />
science studies. He proposes a new way of protecting consumer<br />
interests by integrating three strategies typically used separately.<br />
Firstly, users should be able to choose between different<br />
platforms like Google Chrome and Safari to maintain consumer<br />
sovereignty. Next, different providers must be interoperable—<br />
switching platforms and migrating data must be practical.<br />
Finally, consumer input should be considered and used to<br />
improve existing services such as feature addition and product<br />
design. Taken together, these strategies promote consumer voice<br />
and choice, giving users more authority to prioritize data privacy.<br />
Authorities typically only use a single approach, often<br />
overlooking the convergence of the three strategies when<br />
remedying data privacy issues. “It doesn’t follow that we only<br />
need one account or that a certain regulatory scheme is always<br />
appropriate,” Kuenzler said. Ultimately, using the three strategies<br />
as complements rather than substitutes enables us to better<br />
navigate data privacy concerns and leads to more effective<br />
regulatory policy decisions. ■<br />
6 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biology & Health / Environmental Science<br />
NEWS<br />
OPTIMISTIC<br />
RESULTS FOR<br />
RSV PREVENTION<br />
STRATEGIES<br />
FORECASTING<br />
EXTINCTION<br />
BY MADELEINE POPOFSKY<br />
BY EVELYN JIANG<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), a deadly respiratory virus,<br />
has swamped hospitals globally. “Most of the [Connecticut]<br />
hospitals are packed, and they need to build tents outside<br />
some hospitals to meet [the demand of] the children who are<br />
infected for RSV,” said Zhe Zheng, a PhD candidate at the Yale<br />
School of Public Health. Critically, the virus has no vaccine or<br />
other effective, widely accessible prevention method.<br />
However, Zheng’s analysis of clinical trial results for three<br />
prevention strategies in development proves there is hope<br />
ahead. First, extended half-life monoclonal antibodies, blood<br />
proteins that counteract pathogens, already have approval<br />
in the European Union but could take another year or two<br />
to be approved in the United States. The second, a maternal<br />
immunization, has promising clinical trial results but hasn’t<br />
yet been filed for approval. According to Zheng’s findings, each<br />
could avert more than half of RSV hospitalizations in children<br />
under six months. Live-attenuated vaccines proved highly<br />
effective for children between six months and five years, though<br />
they are still in the early stages of development.<br />
An important question Zheng shed light on relating to these<br />
prevention strategies involves the efficacy of seasonal versus<br />
yearly vaccination plans. While previously reliably seasonal,<br />
COVID has made RSV’s seasons irregular, in addition to<br />
differences between seasonality in northern and southern states.<br />
“A seasonal program may provide minor [cost] advantages<br />
over a year-round [program], but the year-round would<br />
cover more children,” Zheng said. Zheng’s research compares<br />
RSV prevention methods and discusses the best method of<br />
distribution—information that could relieve overwhelmed<br />
hospitals and save children’s lives. ■<br />
While extinction is a natural phenomenon, human activity<br />
has accelerated the deterioration of ecosystems worldwide<br />
and driven an epidemic of species extinctions, leading<br />
growing numbers of scientists to search for ways to conserve the Earth’s<br />
existing natural resources for future generations. Geospatial analytical<br />
tools like range maps, which describe the geographic area a species is<br />
believed to inhabit, are essential resources for informed conservation<br />
planning. Researchers can use data from these maps to forecast future<br />
range dynamics to identify vulnerable “gaps” in protection, informing<br />
decision-making and conservation resource allocation.<br />
Traditional gap analyses tend to focus solely on threats<br />
to species’ range. However, a team of researchers led by<br />
Nyeema Harris, an associate professor at the Yale School of<br />
the Environment, has developed an innovative methodology<br />
that simultaneously analyzes positive conditions and threats to<br />
generate more comprehensive range maps.<br />
“We aggregated different layers. Some were threat layers that<br />
were detrimental to species’ range, and others were resource<br />
layers that were positive for promoting species conservation,”<br />
Harris said. “We overlapped these resources and threats to<br />
identify areas vulnerable to range contractions and that maybe<br />
aren’t receiving enough conservation and research efforts.”<br />
The researchers performed a gap analysis across the ranges of<br />
ninety-one African carnivores to determine whether existing<br />
and available conservation capacities are sufficient. The team<br />
assessed factors like hunting pressures, drought vulnerability,<br />
cultural diversity, and protected area coverage. They found<br />
that, on average, fifteen percent of a species’ range was at risk of<br />
contraction. “We hope this analysis can be used to inform future<br />
conservation and research,” Harris said. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 7
FOCUS<br />
Molecular Biology<br />
IT’S NOT<br />
ALL BAD<br />
Examining the role of H-NS<br />
protein degradation in the<br />
growth of good bacteria<br />
BY MATTHEW BLAIR<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF ISTOCK<br />
There is a common misconception that all bacteria are bad<br />
bacteria. Perhaps this narrative is bolstered by the branding<br />
of disinfectants claiming to kill 99.9 percent of all viruses<br />
and bacteria or the cartoonishly frightening drawings on the<br />
walls of doctor’s offices. This generalization is simply untrue.<br />
Bacteria play a critical role in helping humans maintain a<br />
healthy gut. Our gut is an amalgamation of trillions of bacteria<br />
that form unique interactions and express various genes essential<br />
to their colonization of the gut. This bacterial colonization helps<br />
humans to maintain a balanced gut and, consequently, a healthy<br />
body. Already, questions abound. How do organisms “decide”<br />
which genes to express? Are there genes whose expression<br />
is more desirable than others? It is just these questions that<br />
Jeongjoon Choi, an associate research scientist in the Department<br />
of Genetics at the Yale School of Medicine, focused on answering.<br />
Specific genes are expressed when they receive the direction<br />
to do so from regulatory and signaling proteins. “But what I was<br />
kind of surprised by is even when you give such an inducing<br />
signal, some genes are not expressed under certain conditions,”<br />
Choi said. Interestingly, many unexpressed or silenced genes<br />
were of a specific variety: horizontally transferred genes<br />
(HTGs), also called foreign genes. HTGs are important as they<br />
drive bacterial evolution by introducing foreign DNA, and thus<br />
new traits, to the recipient organism.<br />
The silencing of foreign genes is done by the heat-stable<br />
nucleoid structuring protein (H-NS). Nucleoid structuring<br />
refers to how this protein upholds the basic structure of DNA.<br />
Building on this function, H-NS represses foreign genes by<br />
specifically binding to the corresponding DNA. In some<br />
instances, gene silencers like H-NS are beneficial. The laissezfaire<br />
expression of all foreign genes at once would be fatal.<br />
Unfortunately, however, H-NS can suppress the expression of<br />
important HTGs. For foreign genes to be expressed, they must<br />
overcome gene repression by the silencer H-NS.<br />
Choi’s study provides new insight into how organisms can<br />
overcome foreign gene repression by silencers such as H-NS.<br />
It has been a dogma in the field that H-NS amounts remain<br />
constant regardless of the conditions. Choi made the groundbreaking<br />
discovery that the abundance of H-NS varies in<br />
different conditions, such as acidic and neutral conditions.<br />
Additionally, in some conditions, H-NS is degraded. “Because<br />
H-NS amounts were believed to stay constant, overcoming<br />
foreign gene silencing was largely ascribed to anti-silencing<br />
proteins,” Choi said. Thanks to Choi’s research, there is a new<br />
understanding that both anti-silencing proteins and H-NS<br />
degradation work collaboratively to overcome gene silencing by<br />
H-NS and control foreign gene expression.<br />
The study focused on Escherichia coli, an example of a “good”<br />
type of bacteria. Choi found that for the E. coli to grow in the<br />
guts of mice and express HTGs, H-NS had to be degraded. The<br />
silencing effect of H-NS can be overcome in two steps. Firstly,<br />
the DNA binding regulatory protein PhoP—a protein impacting<br />
the expression of certain parts of DNA displaces H-NS, making<br />
it susceptible to degradation. Then, the protease Lon—an enzyme<br />
that breaks down proteins—targets specific regions of H-NS to<br />
degrade it. With H-NS degraded, E. coli can grow.<br />
“This is basic molecular biology, and I like basic science, but<br />
if the basic science wants to change the word, then we need to<br />
transfer it, making it more applicable for treatment or another<br />
purpose,” Choi said. The impacts of this finding are far-reaching,<br />
potentially changing how we address many ailments, from minor<br />
bacterial infections to tuberculosis. The possibilities of Choi’s<br />
discovery lie in the manipulation of H-NS. “By manipulating H-NS<br />
degradability, we can cause our bacteria, not our good bacteria but<br />
those big, bad bacteria, to be more susceptible to environmental<br />
changes. This will prevent harmful bacteria from causing much of<br />
a problem,” Choi said. This approach could work in tandem with<br />
antibiotics commonly prescribed to remove harmful bacteria. In<br />
cases of intense antibiotic resistance, H-NS manipulation could be<br />
the solution: where antibiotics do not work, causing the bacteria to<br />
be more vulnerable to the natural processes of our body can make<br />
these harmful bacteria unable to cause disease.<br />
Choi’s research done in the guts of mice can be extrapolated, with<br />
some caveats, to human health, making leaps in our understanding<br />
of how bacteria can be regulated and how we can work to maintain<br />
a healthy gut through the development of “good” bacteria. ■<br />
8 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Computer Science / Biology<br />
FOCUS<br />
THE CASE AGAINST<br />
INTELLIGENT<br />
COMPUTER VISION<br />
Neural networks are lagging behind<br />
human brains in visual perception<br />
BY SAMANTHA LIU<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Convolutional neural networks, or CNNs, are deep learning<br />
networks trained with millions of images. Designed to imitate<br />
primate brains, they proved highly adept at object recognition,<br />
sparking media excitement over the future of computer vision—the use<br />
of AI to interpret visual input. Moreover, researchers hoped CNNs could<br />
offer a shortcut to studying the primate brain. Rather than undertake<br />
copious MRI scans and patient trials, scientists could run a simulation<br />
through a CNN to predict how the human brain would respond.<br />
But the research of Yaoda Xu, a senior research scientist at Yale,<br />
proves otherwise. Ten years ago, when a perfect visual recognition<br />
system and its manifold implications—think! driverless cars!—loomed<br />
on the brink of discovery, those possibilities now seem distant as ever.<br />
“People got excited about using the CNN to model the brain,” Xu said.<br />
“But my findings have been that, no, it doesn’t look like the brain. It’s<br />
maybe a primitive, overdeveloped, early visual area of the brain.”<br />
As her recent paper published in NeuroImage clarifies, where CNNs<br />
fail is in the realm of identifying transformation tolerant representations.<br />
The process sounds complex, but it’s something humans carry out every<br />
day: when a person walks toward a table and sees it enlarge in their field<br />
of vision, they know it’s the same table as before. The same goes for<br />
objects viewed from different perspectives or positions—even as altered<br />
representations, the brain maps them onto the same visual identity.<br />
This intuitive procedure proves much more challenging for neural<br />
networks. In her project, Xu took images of eight real-world objects,<br />
ranging from a pair of scissors to an elephant, and distorted them in<br />
various ways. Some she geometrically transformed, moving up and<br />
down or dilating on the page. Others she subjected to non-Euclidean<br />
transformations, changing the contrast and resolution. In each case,<br />
when tested on eight different CNNs, the neural networks showed<br />
weaker consistency and tolerance for these images.<br />
The implication is striking: a process trivial for primate brains<br />
remains elusive for the complex, pre-trained machines meant to<br />
model them. Xu attributes this discrepancy to the mechanics of<br />
human cognition versus machine learning. The primate brain<br />
processes visual information through two streams: dorsal, which<br />
recognizes the object’s spatial location (the “where”), and ventral,<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
which recognizes the object’s identity (the “what”). Though<br />
seemingly redundant, the ability to identify the same object in<br />
different contexts arises from these two systems.<br />
The CNN, in contrast, employs a sub-optimal approach. “In<br />
my view, it basically has a huge amount of memory,” Xu said. “It<br />
memorizes each instance of each object it was exposed to, without<br />
making a connection among these different objects.” Scientists are<br />
unsure how this algorithm works precisely, thus creating a “black box.”<br />
But Xu is hopeful about cracking it—if only the scientific community<br />
reframes its approach. She plans to delve deeper into neuroscience<br />
research, seeing where and how primate vision diverges from neural<br />
networks, to shed light on the CNN algorithm and identify stages<br />
for improvement. Importantly, she believes the key lies in crafting<br />
a comprehensive biological understanding of vision rather than<br />
tackling the problem unilaterally through computer engineering.<br />
She compared this pursuit to trying to replicate flight: someone can<br />
blindly tweak the wing, fold a new flap, and throw everything against<br />
the wall until something flies or falls off a cliff. But someone can also<br />
investigate how flight works, learning the fundamental aerodynamics<br />
and physics which drive movement to find inspiration for an airplane.<br />
“What is vision trying to achieve? What is the problem you’re trying<br />
to solve?” Xu asked. She expressed aversion toward the trial-anderror<br />
experimentation employed by many computer science labs. “I’m<br />
showing you that, hey, this is the algorithm and computation that’s<br />
happening in the brain. If the system you’re building can have the same<br />
principles, maybe you can do a lot better than what you have right now.”<br />
Xu looks towards a future where artificial networks could perfectly<br />
mimic human vision. She recalled how, as a student growing up in<br />
China, she spent entire weekends hand-washing her clothes. When<br />
the laundry machine mechanized the process, her free time could be<br />
put toward more valuable endeavors — like advancing her research<br />
career. “There’s a lot of human potential that is untapped,” Xu said. “If<br />
some of our boring tasks can be done by a machine efficiently with<br />
this kind of visual intelligence, it could lead to another leap in human<br />
development. We could have the creativity to be who we want or to<br />
be the best version of ourselves.” ■<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 9
FOCUS<br />
Environmental Chemistry<br />
THE SOOT<br />
FACTOR<br />
Picking the sustainable<br />
jet fuel of the future<br />
BY WILLIAM ARCHACKI<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Next time you’re cruising at forty thousand feet in the<br />
air, think about how amazing it is that a few hundred<br />
tons of metal can whisk you between two distant cities<br />
in just a few hours. For the seasoned flier, air travel is so simple<br />
it almost feels like magic. Behind that magic, though, lie many<br />
technological innovations—one of the most important being the<br />
jet fuel that keeps the engines running.<br />
Most aircraft engines today burn petroleum fuels that emit large<br />
volumes of carbon dioxide, the primary pollutant behind rising<br />
global temperatures. To reduce these emissions and make aviation<br />
more sustainable, biofuels may be a necessary replacement. Biofuels<br />
consume carbon dioxide from the atmosphere in production,<br />
balancing the amount they emit when burned. Because they<br />
have similar physical and chemical properties to petroleum fuels,<br />
biofuels could easily power existing jet engines. However, with<br />
thousands of possible biofuels competing for a single spot in<br />
the future of aviation, it’s hard to say which one to use. Thus, it’s<br />
necessary to consider a key piece of data: the soot factor.<br />
Soot is the black residue left behind by burnt organic matter.<br />
When dispersed in the atmosphere, it absorbs solar energy and<br />
contributes to climate change alongside carbon dioxide. Under<br />
some circumstances, it can even induce the growth of high-altitude<br />
cirrus clouds that absorb solar radiation more strongly than carbon<br />
dioxide. When inhaled, soot can lead to the development of heart<br />
disease and certain cancers, adding to the public health risk of air<br />
pollution. To minimize the burden of soot emissions on the climate<br />
and human health, researchers must select biofuels that burn<br />
without releasing harmful amounts of soot.<br />
In an effort to improve available data about soot emissions, the<br />
Pfefferle Lab Group at Yale developed a new method to measure<br />
a fuel’s “sooting tendency” and then examined two dozen biofuel<br />
candidates. Earlier techniques for calculating sooting tendency<br />
required researchers to burn large volumes of fuels to observe the<br />
complex properties of the flames. The Pfefferle group’s new method<br />
reduced the amount of fuel necessary to generate data. They opted<br />
to calculate sooting tendency by measuring the luminosity, or<br />
brightness, of the fuels’ flames when burning individual drops—<br />
the brighter the flame, the sootier the fuel.<br />
The biofuel candidates subjected to this new test all fall under<br />
the category of terpenes, which are combustible chemicals<br />
found in organisms ranging from redwood trees to algae.<br />
Charles McEnally, a chemical engineering research scientist at<br />
the Pfefferle lab, explained that terpenes are of special interest<br />
as candidates because of their diversity.<br />
“What’s interesting about terpenes is that the biochemistry that<br />
makes them is always the same, and the input molecule is always<br />
the same: its isoprene,” McEnally said. “Depending on exactly how<br />
the chemistry works, you can get an enormous number of different<br />
outputs. There are tens of thousands of terpenes that are known.”<br />
Out of the twenty-four terpene biofuels that the Pfefferle group tested,<br />
seven were produced through a process known as hydrogenation, in<br />
which the chemical structure is modified to include more hydrogen<br />
atoms and fewer double bonds. These hydrogenated options<br />
outperformed their unmodified competitors for soot reduction,<br />
posting lower numbers on the sooting index that the Pfefferle group<br />
developed. Hydrogenation—as well as other chemical processes that<br />
are broadly referred to as “upgrading”—have the potential to further<br />
improve the properties of biofuel candidates.<br />
“We have all of organic chemistry at our disposal, so we’re no longer<br />
limited to the molecules that are in petroleum. Almost certainly, out of<br />
all of organic chemistry, there are other molecules that will make better<br />
fuels than the ones that happen to be in petroleum,” McEnally said.<br />
In their paper regarding terpene biofuels, the authors note that<br />
large-scale production of terpenes could shift toward bioreactors in<br />
the future. By genetically engineering microorganisms like E. coli<br />
to synthesize terpenes in bioreactors, the aviation industry could<br />
find a path to a simple and sustainable fuel source.<br />
The Pfefferle group’s measurements for terpenes add to an evergrowing<br />
set of data about biofuel candidates. Their simplified method<br />
for determining sooting tendency provides a starting point for further<br />
research. With the group’s work, a biofuel alternative to petroleumbased<br />
jet fuel may eventually be what takes you to the skies. ■<br />
10 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biochemistry<br />
FOCUS<br />
THE WINDING<br />
SYNTHETIC ROAD<br />
TO NEW<br />
ANTIBIOTICS<br />
BY NATHAN MU<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY MATTHEW ZOERB<br />
Since the very first use of antibiotics, researchers have known<br />
about antibiotic resistance in bacteria. However, it takes a<br />
large investment of time and resources to discover novel<br />
antibiotics, which must be made cheaply available for patients.<br />
Therefore, the pharmaceutical industry has turned away from<br />
antibiotic development due to the immense input required and<br />
limited opportunity for profit, allowing antibiotic resistance to rise<br />
and our ability to fight infections to fall.<br />
Olivia Goethe and Mikaela DiBello, former and current<br />
graduate student researchers in Professor Seth Herzon’s lab in<br />
the Yale Department of Chemistry, tackled this issue by seeking<br />
to create new antibiotics from one core molecule, pleuromutilin.<br />
Pleuromutilin is naturally produced by fungi, and its derivatives<br />
have been used clinically as antibiotics for skin infections and<br />
community-acquired pneumonia. Herzon’s lab has also previously<br />
worked with pleuromutilins.<br />
Their recent paper, published in Nature Chemistry, presents a<br />
new total synthesis pathway to create pleuromutilin derivatives.<br />
This pathway is an improvement upon Herzon’s previous method<br />
published in 2017, as well as pre-existing semisynthesis pathways,<br />
which rely on bacteria to synthesize products rather than commonly<br />
available chemical reagents. “Our [new] synthetic route can access<br />
[unique] chemical modifications, like changing functional groups<br />
and changing ring sizes. But through semisynthesis, you’re kind of<br />
blocked in. You can only modify the easily accessible functionality,”<br />
Goethe said. Essentially, this new pathway allows for infinite new<br />
pleuromutilin derivatives to be produced by changing, removing, and<br />
rearranging atoms in a way that other synthesis methods could not.<br />
This total synthesis pathway is a powerful tool for learning about the<br />
properties of various pleuromutilin derivatives.<br />
Another key advancement was the ability to produce pleuromutilin<br />
derivatives in higher yields. Having enough product is vital for testing<br />
antibiotic activity. Obtaining viable yields of products was not an easy<br />
process, however. Each step in the synthesis pathway must be executed<br />
properly to give the correct molecule with the correct orientation or<br />
stereochemistry. Otherwise, subsequent reactions will result in little<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
to no yield of product. This was one of the most challenging parts<br />
of the research process. It took Goethe months of going through the<br />
available literature and experimenting with different reactions to<br />
obtain the desired product in a reaction that initially gave the wrong<br />
stereochemistry. “I had to have the right stereochemistry in order to<br />
make a usable amount of [the pleuromutilin derivative], which is why<br />
I definitely had to fix this, or I was screwed,” Goethe said.<br />
Out of all the pleuromutilin derivatives tested for antibiotic<br />
activity, many were surprisingly inactive, including many of the<br />
core derivatives proposed to improve metabolic stability, which<br />
would help the overall antibiotic effect. The most successful<br />
derivative contained a halogen, which was somewhat unexpected.<br />
“If you went into the ribosome site [of the bacteria], there wasn’t<br />
really any indication that including a halogen there would be<br />
helpful,” Goethe said. Successful pleuromutilin antibiotics usually<br />
bind to sites on bacterial ribosomes, but the chloride group had an<br />
unexpected effect that is worth more exploration. Work can also be<br />
done to find more compounds and, eventually, test the stability of<br />
pleuromutilin antibiotics once they enter the body. “It seems like,<br />
to me, medical chemistry is just a numbers game. You just need to<br />
make a ton of compounds and study them to get trends. There’s a<br />
lot of interest in studying pleuromutilins, and we’re contributing to<br />
the information available about what we can do to this molecule,”<br />
Goethe said. Ideally, this research will lead to the straightforward<br />
synthesis of novel, cheap, and accessible antibiotics.<br />
Goethe found this research for her PhD to be extremely rewarding.<br />
“I think that it’s really cool, just something you made with your<br />
hands from stock materials can be used to kill bacteria,” Goethe<br />
said. Now, Goethe works at Gilead Sciences, a biopharmaceutical<br />
company. She works in process chemistry, preparing materials for<br />
clinical phase trials, which test previously experimental treatments<br />
in human participants. “I think that my ideal dream [job] would be<br />
that I’ll combine the experience that I get here [at Gilead] in drug<br />
development with the passion I had for antibiotics, and maybe once<br />
I get a couple of years of experience, I can help antibiotic companies<br />
actually start to make some more drugs,” Goethe said. ■<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 11
FOCUS<br />
Robotic Engineering<br />
TURTLE<br />
TRANSFORMERS<br />
Reshapeable multienvironment<br />
robots and<br />
the future of soft robotics<br />
BY RIYA BHARGAVA<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF JOKO DIAZ<br />
Pictured above is a baby leatherback turtle, a deep-diving<br />
reptile that lives in the ocean for years but migrates to<br />
the land to lay eggs. Leatherbacks have sleek, paddlelike<br />
forelimbs to navigate the seas, claws to walk on sand,<br />
and a mosaic of breathable cartilage for a shell. Many such<br />
adaptations have made turtles the masters of their niche<br />
between the land and the sea for over 200 million years.<br />
Accordingly, when engineers Robert Baines and Sree Kalyan<br />
Patiballa sat down to ideate a multi-environment mobile robot,<br />
they drew inspiration from turtle body plans and kinematics<br />
and named their robot the Amphibious Turtle Robot, or ART.<br />
“The importance of the paper is that we are showcasing<br />
how you can have robots that have adaptive components—<br />
components that change shape, and how this design paradigm<br />
can improve their efficiency and effectiveness,” says Baines, a<br />
PhD student researcher in Rebecca Kramer-Bottiglio’s lab at<br />
Yale, describing the lab’s recent Nature publication. ART is a<br />
quadruped with a streamlined shell, weighs nine kilograms,<br />
and has a body amalgamating soft materials that respond to<br />
external stimuli and traditional, rigid robotics components.<br />
The most remarkable feature of the robot is its morphing<br />
limbs that undergo adaptive morphogenesis—the limbs can<br />
alter their gait or shape in response to a stimulus, adopting<br />
morphologic features that best suit aquatic and terrestrial<br />
locomotion. For example, the limbs can morph into the<br />
streamlined flippers of a sea turtle when in water and the<br />
columnar legs of a land-faring tortoise when walking.<br />
While rigid-bodied robots can be programmed to perform<br />
a single task efficiently, they do not afford the same body<br />
compliance needed to design bio-inspired robots with<br />
muscle-like actions. Soft materials also have move-andhold<br />
operability–these materials can retain changes in shape<br />
without the constant application of external force, enhancing<br />
the overall energy efficiency of the robot.<br />
The best metric for ART’s performance was the Cost of Transport<br />
(COT), which measures the effectiveness of robot locomotion in<br />
terms of energy efficiency. ART had a minimum COT of three and<br />
ten for aquatic and terrestrial locomotion, respectively–a number<br />
that equals or outperforms other famous unimodal quadrupeds<br />
like EPFL’s Cheetah Cub and the Titan V-III.<br />
However, many improvements must be made before the<br />
robot is put to commercial use, especially when it comes to<br />
untethering. “One of the things we’re moving forward with is<br />
putting additional sensors on the robot to understand how it’s<br />
moving in the environment,” Baines said. “This way, it would<br />
know, for example, if it were in choppy water or still water, or<br />
if it were going down a hill and stumbling versus being stable<br />
and standing on flat ground.” The lab is also working to find<br />
better gaits for the robot.<br />
Even with such challenges, Baines foresees several important<br />
applications of such robots in the near future. Robots such as<br />
ART can be used to monitor ecosystems less invasively. “Such<br />
a platform is unique because it is bio-inspired. It would have<br />
less disturbance on the environment and the animals living in<br />
it,” Baines said. Instead of using turbulent propellers, the turtle<br />
robot swims using streamlined flippers. This design paradigm<br />
also foreshadows advances in disaster relief distribution,<br />
security, and the study of animal locomotion physics. ■<br />
12 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biology / Medicine<br />
FOCUS<br />
A NEW<br />
APPROACH TO<br />
CYSTIC FIBROSIS<br />
BY MATTHEW ZOERB<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
The possibility of rewriting genetic code has given hope to<br />
the 35,000 Americans suffering from cystic fibrosis (CF). In<br />
individuals with CF, a mutated gene causes a specific protein<br />
called the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator<br />
(CFTR) to malfunction, wreaking havoc on the respiratory system.<br />
In each breath, dust, allergens, and pathogens enter our lungs<br />
and become trapped in a thin layer of mucus. This mucus must be<br />
constantly replenished to clean our airways and digest food, but<br />
without the properly functioning CFTR protein, mucus becomes<br />
viscous and thick, trapping contaminants in the lungs. The<br />
symptoms of CF manifest as coughing fits, frequent lung infections,<br />
and other discomforts. However, with the advent of gene editing,<br />
there is hope for a treatment for CF and other genetic diseases.<br />
A recent study by Yale postdoctoral research fellow Alexandra<br />
Piotrowski-Daspit and Marie Egan, a professor at the Yale<br />
School of Medicine, investigated a novel gene editing approach<br />
to restore the function of the mutated CF gene in mice. They<br />
targeted a specific mutation, the F508del mutation, responsible<br />
for about ninety percent of CF cases. To edit the mutated gene,<br />
the researchers encapsulated peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) and<br />
an unmutated “donor” version of the CFTR gene into polymeric<br />
nanoparticles. PNAs are synthetic nucleic acids with a similar<br />
structure to DNA and the same complementary base pairs, which<br />
allow them to bind to target sites in genomic DNA. Once inside<br />
the cell, the PNA molecules form complexes around the mutated<br />
DNA, leveraging the cell’s natural repair mechanisms to insert<br />
the corrected sequence using the donor DNA as a template.<br />
There are several key differences between PNA and CRISPR/<br />
Cas9 gene editing. CRISPR/Cas9 uses nucleases to “cut”<br />
genomic DNA, which reliably enables genetic modification,<br />
but may accidentally damage DNA in regions other than the<br />
target site. PNA-based editing reduces the possibility of offtarget<br />
effects by harnessing the cell’s existing, non-mutagenic<br />
repair mechanisms to incorporate the correct DNA sequence.<br />
This makes them an attractive choice since they reduce the<br />
likelihood of accidentally harming other systems in complex<br />
living organisms.<br />
The experiment demonstrated that gene editing has the<br />
potential to treat CF, which affects multiple organs throughout<br />
the body. “It’s kind of the holy grail of gene editing—to be able<br />
to effectively deliver gene editing agents systemically,” lead<br />
researcher Piotrowski-Daspit said. Even though the percent of<br />
cells edited in the treatment was less than the estimated five to<br />
fifteen percent needed to match healthy individuals, a partial<br />
restoration of function in the affected organs was observed<br />
without any off-target effects.<br />
Looking beyond the specific F508del mutation that served as<br />
the focus of this study, new PNAs will need to be synthesized<br />
to target other mutations responsible for CF, for which<br />
no treatments are currently available. Piotrowski-Daspit’s<br />
personal goal is to improve delivery efficiency and restore<br />
function to a higher percentage of cells. These advances may<br />
eventually translate into treatments that can cure CF and other<br />
genetic diseases in humans. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 13
FOCUS<br />
Neuroscience<br />
RECODING IN<br />
THE BRAIN<br />
Applying A-to-I editing in human<br />
neurodevelopment and disease<br />
BY ELISA HOWARD<br />
The human brain is constantly recoding<br />
itself. Adenosine-to-inosine (A-to-I)<br />
editing, a form of RNA modification,<br />
occurs at more than one hundred million<br />
sites in the human transcriptome, diversifying<br />
RNA sequences of the human brain.<br />
In a recent paper published in Cell Reports,<br />
researchers at Icahn School of Medicine at<br />
Mount Sinai and the Yale School of Medicine<br />
investigated the spatiotemporal and genetic<br />
regulation of A-to-I editing over the course<br />
of human brain development. Their work<br />
catalogs A-to-I editing sites throughout<br />
human brain maturation, enhancing current<br />
understandings of neurodevelopment and<br />
underlying mechanisms of neurological<br />
diseases. “RNA editing is dysregulated in<br />
neurodevelopmental disorders,” said Winston<br />
Cuddleston, a PhD candidate at the Icahn<br />
School of Medicine and lead researcher<br />
of the study. “We are trying to get a better<br />
understanding of which RNA editing sites<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF HANNAH HAN VIA WINSTON CUDDLESTON<br />
Postdoctoral fellow Winston Cuddleston, the<br />
first author of the paper published by the Breen<br />
Lab, poses for a photograph while running<br />
biocomputational analyses.<br />
are dynamically regulated across brain<br />
development to realize which cellular and<br />
molecular processes are being affected.”<br />
The Science of RNA Editing<br />
According to the central dogma of molecular<br />
biology, coined by biophysicist Francis Crick,<br />
the expression of protein-coding genes<br />
involves the flow of genetic information from<br />
DNA to RNA to protein. A gene’s DNA is<br />
copied into RNA through transcription, and<br />
that RNA specifies an amino acid sequence for<br />
protein synthesis in the translation process.<br />
In eukaryotes, primary RNA transcripts<br />
undergo diverse post-transcriptional<br />
modifications, resulting in mature RNA<br />
molecules prior to protein production. These<br />
modifications diversify the transcriptome, the<br />
collection of an organism’s RNA transcripts.<br />
A-to-I editing is a post-transcriptional<br />
modification involving adenosine conversion<br />
to inosine nucleosides. This conversion process<br />
is catalyzed by a family of enzymes called<br />
adenosine deaminase acting on RNA (ADAR)<br />
and occurs most prominently in the central<br />
nervous system (CNS). These modifications<br />
affect neuronal genes, including those involved<br />
in synaptic transmission and signaling.<br />
In protein-coding regions, A-to-I editing can<br />
result in amino acid substitutions at locations<br />
known as recoding sites. These recoding sites<br />
are necessary for normal neurodevelopment,<br />
given their involvement in modulating calcium<br />
permeability, desensitization recovery rates,<br />
and cytoskeletal organization at excitatory<br />
synapses, alongside other functions.<br />
Investigation of A-to-I Sites in the Brain<br />
Millions of individual A-to-I<br />
editing modifications have been<br />
found in humans—many in the brain.<br />
Nevertheless, according to this study’s senior<br />
author Michael Breen, assistant professor<br />
of psychiatry, genetics, and genomic<br />
sciences at Mount Sinai, only a small<br />
subset of these modifications appears<br />
to be functional. “Those sites that<br />
are functional have precise temporal<br />
patterns across time: their editing efficiency<br />
changes throughout age and development in<br />
the brain,” Breen said.<br />
Breen and colleagues took a systematic<br />
look at A-to-I editing sites across<br />
prenatal and postnatal stages of human<br />
brain maturation. The researchers<br />
collected RNA sequencing data from<br />
brain samples of the dorsolateral<br />
prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), cerebrum,<br />
and cerebellum. They also analyzed<br />
RNA-sequencing data from in vitro<br />
models of neuronal maturation, postmortem<br />
cortical samples from late stages of aging, and<br />
murine and non-human primate models of<br />
brain development. In doing so, the researchers<br />
collected brain RNA sequencing data covering<br />
the human lifespan.<br />
“RNA editing is dynamically<br />
regulated in the brain during<br />
aging, and this is a unique<br />
property of RNA editing in the<br />
brain compared to other tissues<br />
in the body,” Cuddleston said. In<br />
their paper, Breen, Cuddleston, and<br />
14 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Neuroscience<br />
FOCUS<br />
colleagues provide an atlas of A-to-I<br />
sites that are spatiotemporally and<br />
genetically regulated throughout brain<br />
maturation while uncovering key features of<br />
RNA editing throughout neurodevelopment.<br />
In particular, A-to-I editing is enriched in<br />
repetitive sequences known as Alu elements.<br />
Using an Alu editing index (AEI) to quantify<br />
modification levels, Breen and fellow<br />
researchers observed that global Alu editing<br />
steadily increases across all stages of brain<br />
development and neuronal maturation. This<br />
editing peaks around thirty to fifty-nine years<br />
of age, while advanced aging stages do not<br />
exhibit dynamic regulation.<br />
The researchers identified thousands of<br />
editing sites that are temporally regulated<br />
and increase in editing levels throughout<br />
neurodevelopment. The majority exist in the<br />
three prime untranslated regions (3' UTRs)<br />
of genes critical for neurodevelopment.<br />
The minority of spatiotemporally<br />
regulated editing sites exist within<br />
protein-coding regions, and thirtyseven<br />
RNA-recoding sites appear<br />
to change in editing levels<br />
across maturation.<br />
The researchers<br />
also describe trends<br />
in hyper-editing. As<br />
opposed to A-to-I<br />
editing at individual<br />
adenosine nucleosides,<br />
hyper-editing refers to<br />
modifying many adjacent adenosines along<br />
an extended region. The results indicate that<br />
hyper-editing is enriched in advanced stages<br />
of aging with the function of stabilizing RNA<br />
secondary structures.<br />
A-to-I Editing in Neurodevelopmental<br />
Disorders<br />
Editing rates increase globally throughout<br />
brain development. “Global increase is<br />
dynamic in different neurological diseases,<br />
so it could be looked at as a predictor of<br />
brain health,” Breen said. The researchers<br />
asked whether sites displaying increased<br />
editing throughout brain development<br />
are affected in neurodevelopmental<br />
disorders. Their results suggest that<br />
A-to-I sites disrupted in postmortem<br />
brain tissue from individuals with<br />
schizophrenia and autism spectrum<br />
disorder are temporally regulated,<br />
exhibiting an increase in editing levels<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF HANNAH HAN VIA MICHAEL BREEN<br />
The Breen Lab, headed by principal investigator<br />
Michael Breen at the Icahn School of Mount Sinai,<br />
poses for a photograph on a rooftop at sunset.<br />
across maturation. “Knowing what we think<br />
these sites do in typical brain development,<br />
[i.e.,] modulating the ability of micro-RNAs to<br />
regulate host gene expression, and that these<br />
sites are disrupted in neurodevelopmental<br />
diseases gives an immediate avenue towards<br />
trying to understand what these sites might be<br />
doing in these disorders,” Breen said.<br />
Recoding sites where A-to-I editing results<br />
in amino acid substitutions provide further<br />
insight into neurodevelopmental diseases. “A<br />
handful of recoding sites have been described<br />
as dynamically regulated in Alzheimer’s,<br />
schizophrenia, and other neurological<br />
disorders,” Breen said. “We know that these<br />
sites are important for synaptic transmission,<br />
and their editing efficiencies are altered in<br />
these different diseased states.”<br />
Additionally, hyper-editing data enhances<br />
the current understanding of the aging brain.<br />
Only a handful of prior studies investigate<br />
RNA hyper-editing, and none consider the<br />
developmental regulation of hyper-editing<br />
in the brain. Breen and fellow researchers<br />
discovered that hyper-editing increases in the<br />
aging brain and appears to affect transcript<br />
stability rather than directly regulating gene<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
expression. Considering all study datasets,<br />
the normalized hyper-editing signal steadily<br />
rises across brain development periods and<br />
peaks into advanced aging stages. “While<br />
site-selective editing peaks in terms of its<br />
rate of change in mid-fetal development,<br />
hyper-editing continues to accumulate all the<br />
way into advanced aging,” Cuddleston said.<br />
“This is really important for aging research.”<br />
RNA hyper-editing may provide insight<br />
into Alzheimer’s disease, for instance, which<br />
Cuddleston aims to investigate in the future.<br />
The Prospects of RNA Biology<br />
In Cell Reports, Breen and colleagues<br />
provide an atlas of spatiotemporally and<br />
genetically regulated A-to-I sites in the brain<br />
throughout human neurodevelopment while<br />
unearthing key features of RNA editing<br />
throughout the lifespan. These findings not<br />
only improve current understandings of<br />
human brain development at the RNA level<br />
but also provide an avenue for learning more<br />
about the foundations of neurodevelopmental<br />
disorders. “We know very little about RNA<br />
modifications and what those might mean<br />
for disease pathology,” Breen said. “We<br />
are just starting to paint that picture.” It is<br />
through understanding such diseases at<br />
the neurobiological level that progress can<br />
be made toward treatment development.<br />
“Understanding which RNA editing events<br />
are functionally relevant for disease is how we<br />
are going to get closer to therapeutics that we<br />
can use in the clinic,” Cuddleston said.<br />
With thousands of temporally regulated<br />
RNA editing sites, the brain is a fascinating<br />
organ of continual change. How is your<br />
brain recoding itself? ■<br />
A R T B Y E V E L Y N J I A N G<br />
ELISA HOWARD is a junior Neuroscience major in Berkeley College. While a senior staff writer for<br />
<strong>YSM</strong>, she researches axon regeneration using stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy in<br />
the Strittmatter Lab at the Yale School of Medicine. She is the Donor Outreach Coordinator for the<br />
American Red Cross at Yale, the Mentorship Chair for the Yale Neuroscience Education Undergraduate<br />
Research Organization (YNEURO), and the creator/head of Yale Volunteers at Downtown Evening Soup<br />
Kitchen (DESK). She is also a member of the Yale Collegiate Figure Skating Club and volunteers for<br />
Connecticut Hospice.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Michael Breen and Winston Cuddleston for their time and<br />
enthusiasm about their research.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
ELISA HOWARD<br />
Slotkin, W., & Nishikura, K. (2013). Adenosine-to-inosine RNA editing and human disease. Genome<br />
Medicine, 5(11), 105. https://doi.org/10.1186/gm508<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 15
FOCUS<br />
Chemistry / Pharmacology<br />
STREAMLINING<br />
THE SEARCH<br />
FOR NEW<br />
DRUGS<br />
Discovering promising molecules<br />
with antidepressant activity<br />
BY EMILY SHANG<br />
Have you ever wondered how scientists<br />
synthesize drugs? Everything, from<br />
the Advil you take to alleviate a<br />
headache to the Vitamin C gummies you eat<br />
to strengthen your immune system, needs<br />
to undergo rigorous scientific testing and<br />
scrutiny to ensure that it is safe for human<br />
consumption. The process of efficiently finding<br />
and synthesizing drugs is especially challenging<br />
for those treating specific medical maladies<br />
since the drug’s functional mechanism must<br />
be investigated. Drugs often function by<br />
targeting specific receptors in our bodies and<br />
either block the effects of the receptor’s typical<br />
function (antagonism) or activate the receptor<br />
to create a response (agonism).<br />
The Challenge of Synthesizing Drugs<br />
that designing a drug that is specific, effective,<br />
and safe is no easy task: it’s why the research<br />
and development process, not to mention the<br />
process of clinical trials and safety testing, is so<br />
long and arduous.<br />
But recently, in a collaboration between<br />
the Ellman Lab at Yale University, the Irwin<br />
and Shoichet Labs at the University of<br />
California San Francisco, the Wetsel Lab at<br />
Duke University, the Skiniotis Lab at Stanford<br />
University, and the Roth Lab at the University<br />
of North Carolina, researchers have been able<br />
to use a novel virtual screening technique<br />
to streamline the beginning stages of drug<br />
discovery by finding promising molecules that<br />
bind potently and selectively to the 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor. This receptor is a serotonin receptor<br />
involved in producing both the negative<br />
(hallucinations, delusions) and positive effects<br />
(alleviation of anxiety, depression) of the<br />
psychedelic drug lysergic acid diethylamide<br />
(LSD) and its affiliates in the brain.<br />
When synthesizing new drugs, researchers<br />
have a lot of metrics to satisfy and a lot of<br />
factors to consider. First, the specificity and<br />
favorability of the drug to the drug target: are<br />
the pieces of the receptor and drug compatible,<br />
and is there a possibility for off-target binding?<br />
Second, the size of the drug: will its molecular<br />
weight hinder its ability to get where it needs to<br />
be in the body? Third, the molecular kinetics of<br />
the drug: how many of the bonds are rotatable,<br />
and how stable and likely is the conformation<br />
it takes on to bind the receptor? It’s no secret<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY EMILY POAG<br />
Representations of organic molecules are scrawled across the sash of a fume hood in the Ellman Lab.<br />
16 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Chemistry / Pharmacology<br />
FOCUS<br />
The virtual screening process started with a<br />
broad analysis of the commonalities between<br />
the chemical structures of a variety of FDAapproved<br />
drugs. Researchers found that the<br />
most often-observed structures included<br />
the six-membered nitrogen heterocycles<br />
piperidine and pyridine. Thus, they began<br />
looking into using a virtual library technique<br />
to create a tetrahydropyridine (THP) drug, a<br />
much less investigated subclass of the kinds<br />
of structural molecules described above.<br />
This structure also produces some obstacles<br />
for synthesis, which made it an interesting<br />
candidate for virtual screening and analysis of<br />
molecular docking and binding.<br />
Creating a Database of THP Molecules<br />
Using the THP structure as a foundation,<br />
the researchers created a database of 75<br />
million THP molecules. The contents of this<br />
database were limited to synthetic chemistry<br />
techniques available to the Ellman Lab using<br />
three different types of starting materials:<br />
an amine, enal/enone, and alkyne. The<br />
researchers also implemented a molecular<br />
weight limit of 350 grams per mole to<br />
increase the likelihood that the compounds<br />
would have effective delivery in animals.<br />
They also considered a cationic property of<br />
the molecule that would help the molecule<br />
competitively bind to G-coupled protein<br />
receptors such as the 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor, as well<br />
as eliminate chiral starting materials that<br />
would have resulted in mixtures of THPs with<br />
different three-dimensional structures, for a<br />
simplified single-conformation output.<br />
Narrowing Down the Search<br />
These 75 million THP molecules were then<br />
pared down using computational molecular<br />
binding techniques. Since the structure<br />
of the 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor was unknown, the<br />
researchers composed one thousand models<br />
of the receptor bound to LSD in the hopes of<br />
analyzing the dynamics of the binding and<br />
finding a competitive molecule. Using this<br />
refined structure of the 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor, the<br />
binding of the 75 million THP molecules was<br />
evaluated, and thirty molecules were selected<br />
as most likely to bind to the receptor. From the<br />
thirty molecules, seventeen molecules were<br />
able to be synthesized using commercially<br />
available materials. Four of these molecules<br />
were identified to bind to 5HT 2A<br />
receptors,<br />
and two of these molecules exceeded preset<br />
binding thresholds in testing. Based upon<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
the initial THPs that bound to the receptor,<br />
the team then designed, synthesized, and<br />
tested numerous additional analogs to obtain<br />
compounds that were potent and selective<br />
5-HT 2A<br />
receptor agonists.<br />
“While you can dock to predict binding, at<br />
this stage, you cannot predict if a compound<br />
is going to be an agonist or an antagonist.<br />
Virtual screening is just a foot in the door;<br />
afterwards, you really need chemistry for<br />
synthesizing a lot of compounds, testing a<br />
lot of compounds, critical analysis of data,<br />
and many iterations,” said Jonathan Ellman,<br />
principal investigator of the Ellman Lab.<br />
The 5-HT 2A<br />
receptor can undergo two<br />
different pathways once activated. The first<br />
is the beta arrestin pathway, which has been<br />
linked to undesired psychedelic effects,<br />
and the second is the G-protein mediated<br />
pathway. “Our molecules are more biased<br />
towards the G-protein mediated pathway,<br />
and we didn’t see the psychedelic effects,”<br />
James Kweon, one of the lead researchers<br />
from the Ellman group, explained. While<br />
it’s very hard to predict just by looking<br />
at a chemical structure which signaling<br />
pathway will be favored, the molecules<br />
synthesized by the Ellman Lab are able to<br />
bias the receptor towards the G-protein<br />
mediated pathway rather than the beta<br />
arrestin pathway, which can then separate<br />
the psychedelic function of the receptor<br />
from the antidepressant function.<br />
Looking Into the Future<br />
The next steps for the Ellman Lab and<br />
their collaborators include using the same<br />
virtual screening approach to find more<br />
complex molecules to selectively target<br />
a new receptor: this time, a pain receptor<br />
that is targeted by opioid drugs such as<br />
morphine. They hope to separate the harsh<br />
respiratory distress associated with opioid<br />
use by synthesizing a molecule with great<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF CREATIVE COMMONS<br />
A schematic depicts the virtual screening process<br />
to look for promising molecules.<br />
functional selectivity that can separate<br />
these negative effects from the painrelieving<br />
positive effects. “We’re basically<br />
trying to demonstrate that virtual screening<br />
really can be used as a tool for even more<br />
complex molecules,” Kweon said.<br />
The kinds of molecules they’re synthesizing<br />
have a three-dimensional component which<br />
opens up more complex levels of docking<br />
analysis and will show that the technique<br />
of virtual screening is capable of taking on<br />
complex problems and solutions. Given its<br />
efficacy in successfully finding possible drug<br />
molecules fast, it’s likely this virtual screening<br />
technique will become increasingly important<br />
for the discovery of new drugs. ■<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR EMILY SHANG<br />
EMILY SHANG is a sophomore in Timothy Dwight College studying Molecular Biophysics and<br />
Biochemistry. In addition to managing the website at <strong>YSM</strong>, she loves to play chess and perform research<br />
at the Yale School of Medicine.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Dr. Jonathan Ellman and James Kweon of the Ellman lab for<br />
their cooperation and contributions to this article.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
ART BY<br />
MALIA KUO<br />
Kaplan, A.L., Confair, D.N., Kim, K. et al. Bespoke library docking for 5-HT2A receptor agonists with<br />
antidepressant activity. Nature 610, 582–591 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05258-z<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 17
FOCUS<br />
Nanotechnology<br />
ON DEMAND<br />
MEMBRANE<br />
Using DNA nanostructures to understand and control the cell membrane<br />
BY RISHA CHAKRABORTY<br />
ART BY MALIA KUO<br />
Scientists learn more about the cell<br />
every day. From taking microscopic<br />
pictures to performing biochemical<br />
tests on pellets of harvested cells, biologists<br />
are able to determine the organization and<br />
interactions of major cellular components,<br />
including organelles, proteins, and nucleic<br />
acids. But understanding what these interactions<br />
look like in real-time is much more<br />
difficult than capturing fluorescent images,<br />
which offer a freeze-frame snapshot<br />
of the cell, and biochemical assays, which<br />
offer only a general understanding of molecular<br />
interactions but are often limited<br />
by the experimenter’s ability to manipulate<br />
the reacting biomolecules in space<br />
and time. In a recent article in Science Advances,<br />
Yale Professor of Cell Biology and<br />
Biomedical Engineering Chenxiang Lin<br />
and postdoctoral fellow Longfei Liu pioneer<br />
a unique way to study cell biology by<br />
harnessing the power of DNA as a molecule<br />
with a highly controllable structure to<br />
study the interactions of proteins and the<br />
cell membrane in real-time.<br />
Students typically learn that DNA is the<br />
genetic code of the cell, responsible for encoding<br />
the information eventually converted<br />
to the proteins responsible for cellular functions.<br />
But Lin offers an alternate perspective<br />
on DNA: that DNA itself has unique structural<br />
and chemical properties that can guide the<br />
assembly of other biomolecules and modulate<br />
how they interact. The DNA contained within<br />
our cells’ nuclei is in the traditional double-stranded<br />
helix because this conformation<br />
keeps DNA stable and relatively easy to<br />
transcribe. But scientists can now control the<br />
sequence of short single-stranded DNA molecules,<br />
called oligonucleotides, such that they<br />
spontaneously form nanoscale assemblages<br />
of precisely defined shapes. And because<br />
DNA oligonucleotides are easier to synthesize<br />
and chemically modify than molecules not<br />
found in nature or even proteins, they form<br />
nanostructures desirable for biochemical and<br />
biophysical experiments, where scientists<br />
want to study the finest details of molecular<br />
organization, dynamics, and function. The<br />
programmability and self-assembling nature<br />
of the DNA structures allow scientists to repeat<br />
such experiments many times and with<br />
all kinds of permutations. “This bottom-up<br />
approach is very powerful since all you need<br />
to do is design the DNA molecules correctly.<br />
The DNA strands can find each other and<br />
self-assemble into larger structures, with precise<br />
experimenter control.” Lin explained.<br />
History of DNA Nanotechnology<br />
According to Lin, the idea to use DNA as<br />
a structural macromolecule for more than<br />
IMAGES COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
18 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Nanotechnology<br />
FOCUS<br />
just encoding genetic material harkens<br />
back forty years to New York University<br />
Professor Ned Seeman. Seeman imagined<br />
DNA nanostructures completely conceptually<br />
before creating them was even possible.<br />
DNA nanotechnology began to materialize<br />
upon creating a stable four-way<br />
DNA junction in a test tube resembling the<br />
Holliday junction, a somewhat complicated<br />
three-dimensional arrangement of single-stranded<br />
DNA pieces that forms during<br />
a type of DNA repair called homologous recombination.<br />
Scientists then began experimenting<br />
with combining multiple small,<br />
single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides into<br />
“tiles” and harnessing the symmetry of<br />
these tiles to build two-dimensional lattices<br />
or three-dimensional crystalline structures.<br />
In 2006, Paul Rothemund at the California<br />
Institute of Technology invented a new<br />
technology called DNA origami. He folded<br />
a single-stranded DNA extracted from<br />
viruses into shapes like smiley faces with<br />
the help of tens to hundreds of oligonucleotides.<br />
Importantly, these helper strands<br />
could each carry additional modifications<br />
to attach other molecules to the DNA origami<br />
structure at precise locations.<br />
Scientists sought to create domains in the<br />
DNA nanostructure that would change<br />
in conformation in response<br />
to some physiologically<br />
relevant signal, such as changes in<br />
pH, visible light, or UV radiation. These<br />
DNA nanostructures can mimic proteins<br />
to study how changes in these proteins’<br />
structures would impact their biochemical<br />
activities. DNA structures containing<br />
regions of non-conventional motifs, such<br />
as four stacked cytidine bases (one of four<br />
nitrogen-containing cyclic molecules that<br />
comprise the inside of the DNA helix),<br />
change in conformation in acidic environments,<br />
which are characteristic of cancerous<br />
cells. Similarly, chemically joining an<br />
azo-benzene group (two hexagonal carbon<br />
rings connected by two nitrogen atoms) to<br />
the DNA backbone allows DNA to change<br />
conformation in response to a visible or UV<br />
light source. Such trigger-responsive DNA<br />
structures allow engineers to build nanorobots<br />
under users’ command by adding a<br />
drop of a chemical or simply by shining a<br />
light. This is also very useful for mimicking<br />
the dynamic activity of some proteins that<br />
act as enzymatic molecular switches.<br />
Studying Membrane Dynamics<br />
Unfortunately, while DNA nanotechnology<br />
has seen some traction in studying soluble,<br />
cytoplasmic proteins, proteins embedded<br />
in the cell’s<br />
membranes<br />
are harder to manipulate. Membrane<br />
proteins are crucial for many of the cell’s most<br />
basic functions, such as motion, regulating<br />
molecular traffic through the membrane,<br />
and interacting with pathogens, all of which<br />
require the membrane proteins to respond<br />
to changes in the membrane landscape and<br />
sometimes actively remodel the membrane.<br />
However, the membrane proteins are often<br />
involved in very complex interactions with<br />
lipids, other membrane proteins, and the cytoskeleton,<br />
scaffolding proteins that give cells<br />
their shape. Because this system is so complicated,<br />
Lin and Liu aimed to build a highly reductionist<br />
cell membrane model to contain<br />
only some features or proteins of interest. In<br />
their article, the proteins were foregone and<br />
replaced with mimics made of DNA. “These<br />
DNA structures were designed to look like<br />
a membrane-remodeling protein and work<br />
like one,” Lin said. “By tweaking them and<br />
observing how they behave on membrane,<br />
we may learn a thing or two about how the<br />
protein works in cells.” This system enabled<br />
them to study cell membranes as a platform<br />
and create artificial environments relevant to<br />
biological problems.<br />
One of the most important membrane<br />
dynamics researchers have attempted to<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 19
FOCUS<br />
Nanotechnology<br />
model is membrane<br />
tubulation, whereby<br />
one part of a membrane<br />
pokes out from an existing<br />
piece of a membrane but<br />
remains in close contact, essentially<br />
creating an extended “tube” of the membrane.<br />
This process is ubiquitous across<br />
the cell, involved in organelle and cell division,<br />
as well as packaging molecules for<br />
transport in membrane-enclosed vesicles.<br />
The interaction requires exquisite molecular<br />
machinery to change the membrane<br />
curvature and actually pinch the membrane<br />
destined to be separated from the<br />
old membrane (budding).<br />
Liu and Lin were able to understand the<br />
key factors required for membrane vesicle<br />
formation to occur using DNA nanostructures.<br />
The DNA nanostructures in their<br />
study mimicked the proteins that integrate<br />
into the membrane, contributing to membrane<br />
curvature. This allowed them to study<br />
the proteins’ properties and their effect<br />
on tubulation and vesiculation. The DNA<br />
nanostructures they integrated into their<br />
cell membrane model were initially set in an<br />
open state with high internal tension. Releasing<br />
such tension caused the DNA structures<br />
to buckle and adopt a closed, highly curved<br />
conformation (imagine a spring-loaded<br />
clamp). When they operated such DNA nano-clamps<br />
on the<br />
membrane,<br />
membranes<br />
were able to<br />
be curved, and<br />
many DNA-coated<br />
membrane tubes spontaneously<br />
emerged. However,<br />
fewer tubes were observed<br />
when the closed DNA<br />
clamps were less curved<br />
themselves. Moreover, releasing<br />
the DNA clamps from the<br />
high internal tension state seemed<br />
important for tubulation since preventing<br />
the DNA from changing from its initial state<br />
prevented the phenomenon. Interestingly,<br />
removing the DNA from membrane tubes<br />
led to vesiculation. Thus, Liu and Lin were<br />
able to deduce that the curvature of certain<br />
membrane proteins contributes to membrane<br />
curvature and that the ability of these<br />
proteins to switch conformation can release<br />
energy and act as a biophysical switch to determine<br />
whether the membrane could bud<br />
or not.<br />
Next Steps<br />
ABOUT THE<br />
AUTHOR<br />
Lin and Liu’s study was landmark in several<br />
ways. They were able to provide a proof<br />
of concept that the geometric properties of<br />
DNA nanostructures could act as a reliable<br />
substitute for the geometric properties of<br />
a membrane-bound protein and that tuning<br />
the mechanical properties of the DNA<br />
structures to modulate membrane dynamics<br />
could provide insights into how proteins<br />
impact membrane dynamics. “Membrane<br />
proteins are quite hard to manipulate. With<br />
DNA nanostructures, we can control the<br />
structure, shape, geometry, and modifications,<br />
which means we can do experiments<br />
in a more controlled way,” Liu said. Moreover,<br />
they were able to model membrane<br />
tube formation across multiple designs<br />
and experimental conditions—such as by<br />
varying the curvature and internal tension<br />
of the DNA clamps and changing the starting<br />
curvature of the membrane—and show<br />
that the curvature of the DNA nanostructure<br />
was the instigating factor in tubulation<br />
across these varying conditions. This<br />
highlights the unique advantages of using<br />
DNA nanostructures for such experiments.<br />
These nanostructures enable researchers<br />
to tune previously inaccessible parameters<br />
and ensure experiment reproducibility.<br />
However, both Lin and Liu expressed<br />
some caution about applying such conclusions<br />
definitively to the cells of living organisms.<br />
First, while DNA nanostructures<br />
may be used to structurally approximate<br />
proteins, key differences in the two classes<br />
of molecules’ stability, folding, and activity<br />
need to be accounted for when<br />
making conclusions about how<br />
proteins interact with membranes.<br />
Secondly, since the cellular models<br />
they employed were simplified, their conclusions<br />
from their experiments will probably<br />
need to be verified by studies<br />
in cells extracted from living<br />
organisms since membrane<br />
proteins in cells are engaged in<br />
many more<br />
interactions<br />
than the<br />
minimal set.<br />
Both researchers<br />
are embarking on new projects,<br />
including several in collaboration<br />
with Martin Schwartz, a Yale professor,<br />
to study how membrane proteins and the<br />
DNA structures that mimic them act on<br />
membranes with underlying cytoskeleton<br />
in major cellular processes.<br />
Lin and Liu aim to further investigate<br />
how external signals impact DNA nanostructures<br />
mimicking membrane proteins<br />
and how cellular processes are accordingly<br />
modulated. Eventually, they aim to harness<br />
the similarities between membrane proteins<br />
and DNA nanostructures to create a<br />
reliable cell model from scratch. “It would<br />
be very cool to build synthetic cells that<br />
would work similarly to naturally existing<br />
cells,” Lin said. With these headways in<br />
the field of DNA nanotechnology and cell<br />
biology, the scientific community is on its<br />
way to learning more about<br />
real-time cellular processes<br />
than ever<br />
before. ■<br />
RISHA<br />
CHAKRABORTY<br />
RISHA CHAKRABORTY is a sophomore in Saybrook College majoring in Neuroscience and Chemistry.<br />
In addition to writing for <strong>YSM</strong>, Risha plays trumpet for the Yale Precision Marching Band, Yale Concert<br />
Band and La Orquesta Tertulia, volunteers for HAPPY (Hypertension Awareness and Prevention<br />
Program at Yale) and researches Parkinson’s Disease at Chandra Lab in the School of Medicine. She<br />
enjoys cracking jokes with her friends and taking Choco Pies from the Asian American Cultural Center.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Dr. Liu and Dr. Lin for their time and enthusiasm about their<br />
research.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
Liu L, Xiong Q, Xie C, Pincet F, Lin C. Actuating tension-loaded DNA clamps drives membrane tubulation.<br />
Science Advances. 2022;8(41). doi:10.1126/sciadv.add1830<br />
20 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Environment<br />
FOCUS<br />
THE NEW<br />
CIRCULAR<br />
ECONOMY<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Bioenergy<br />
for a more<br />
sustainable<br />
and circular<br />
society<br />
BY ABIGAIL<br />
JOLTEUS<br />
ART BY<br />
KARA TAO<br />
Increased wildfires, heat, drought,<br />
and hurricanes are some of the<br />
devastating effects of climate<br />
change that continue to be seen<br />
across the world, and urgent action<br />
must be taken. To ensure that the Earth<br />
remains tolerable for humans to live on,<br />
environmentally friendly technologies<br />
are crucial. Over the past few years,<br />
there has been growing excitement about<br />
hydrogen fueling stations worldwide.<br />
The media portrays hydrogen fuel as a<br />
sustainable alternative to fossil fuels, with<br />
water being the only by-product.<br />
In reality, hydrogen fuels are usually<br />
generated using fossil fuels, emitting<br />
carbon dioxide (CO 2<br />
) as a by-product.<br />
Hydrogen comes from methods such as<br />
steam methane reforming, coal gasification,<br />
and electrolysis from electricity sources<br />
such as grid, solar, etc. Hydrogen fuel<br />
contributes to greenhouse gas emissions<br />
and, consequently, climate change.<br />
But if many methods to generate<br />
hydrogen fuel either directly or indirectly<br />
contribute to greenhouse gas emissions,<br />
what can we do to mitigate its impact on<br />
the climate? The answer lies in a process<br />
called bioenergy with carbon capture and<br />
storage (BECCS), which is the process<br />
of generating energy from biomass or<br />
organic matter while capturing and<br />
storing the CO2 emitted and providing<br />
net negative greenhouse gas emissions.<br />
In previous studies, methods such<br />
as techno-economic analysis (TEA)<br />
and life cycle assessment (LCA) were<br />
used to assess the economic feasibility<br />
and environmental impacts of BECCS.<br />
However, these studies did not consider<br />
the effect of the choice of energy supply.<br />
Moreover, previous studies rarely<br />
explored categories beyond climate<br />
impact, such as a broader range of impact<br />
indicators (e.g., human health impacts) of<br />
hydrogen as a fuel. In order to maximize<br />
the potential of BECCS, a holistic<br />
understanding of the effect of energy<br />
supply strategies and the implementation<br />
of carbon capture is crucial.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 21
FOCUS<br />
Environment<br />
Researchers at the Center for<br />
Industrial Ecology at the Yale School<br />
of Environment wanted to assess the<br />
efficiency and impact of BECCS. “The<br />
basic idea is to evaluate the economic<br />
feasibility and environmental impacts of<br />
emerging biotechnologies,” said Na Wu,<br />
a postdoctoral researcher in the Yao Lab.<br />
To assess its impacts, the researchers<br />
developed the techno-economicenvironmental<br />
assessment (TEES)<br />
framework–a method to evaluate the<br />
environmental and economic impacts of<br />
BECCS and other similar carbon capture<br />
technologies. This framework incorporates<br />
methods used in previous studies, such<br />
as TEA and LCA, but also simulations<br />
of implementing BECCS with different<br />
possible conditions for the biorefinery, the<br />
facility that converts biomass to energy.<br />
How It Works<br />
This study assessed gasification-based<br />
BECCS, using leftover wood scraps and<br />
branches from logging, called forest<br />
residues, as a source of biomass for gas<br />
conversion. Their analysis focused on<br />
forest residues from the Pacific Northwest,<br />
specifically the Douglas fir and ponderosa<br />
pine, because there is a large amount of<br />
biomass present in the region, and due to<br />
wildfires, there is a need to thin the forests.<br />
This assessment was conducted using the<br />
TEES framework and is novel because it<br />
is an integrated model addressing the<br />
knowledge gaps of the biorefinery with<br />
all carbon dioxide emission sources.<br />
These simulation models integrate<br />
energy supply strategies while also<br />
taking into consideration the realworld<br />
application of these models.<br />
“We tried to maximize the carbon<br />
c a p t u r e<br />
a n d<br />
storage process using our simulation<br />
models and integrate that with energy<br />
supply strategies,” Wu said.<br />
In order to simulate real-life scenarios,<br />
the researchers used a system with<br />
various components to measure and<br />
calibrate different options. They modeled<br />
eight biorefinery processes to determine<br />
which scenario is the most economically<br />
and environmentally feasible. These<br />
components include biomass preparation<br />
(such as size reduction and drying),<br />
gasification, cleaning syngas (a mixture of<br />
hydrogen and carbon monoxide), watergas<br />
shifting, carbon capture, pressure swing<br />
adsorption, air separation, and heat power<br />
generation. This was used to simulate the<br />
conditions required to produce syngas<br />
from biomass. Additionally, they modeled<br />
the three main stages of carbon capture:<br />
capturing the CO 2<br />
, transporting it, and<br />
then storing it deep underground. As the<br />
amount of biomass can affect the method’s<br />
perceived efficiency, different scales with<br />
different amounts of biomass were used.<br />
With the appropriate boundaries<br />
established, the researchers analyzed<br />
four different scenarios.<br />
Scenario one<br />
consists of<br />
burning the syngas produced to generate<br />
heat and power simultaneously, leading to<br />
electrical self-sufficiency while trapping<br />
carbon underground (carbon capture).<br />
Scenario two is similar to scenario one but<br />
with no carbon capture, which served as a<br />
baseline to understand the effect of carbon<br />
capture implementation. Scenario three<br />
includes the same components as scenario<br />
one but uses all the syngas products for<br />
hydrogen production, leading to partial<br />
electrical self-sufficiency. Scenario four<br />
includes carbon capture technology but<br />
does not use a combined heat and power<br />
generation plant, which makes it the least<br />
self-sufficient electricity scenario.<br />
The researchers decided which scenario<br />
was most favorable based on considerations<br />
such as the highest capital expenditure and<br />
operating expenditure. The most and least<br />
favorable scenarios varied depending on the<br />
type of expenditure examined. For instance,<br />
scenario one (fully self-sufficient) has the<br />
highest capital expenditure (CAPEX),<br />
whereas scenario two (no carbon capture)<br />
has the lowest CAPEX. This indicates that<br />
carbon capture requires<br />
a large amount<br />
of capital<br />
since scenario<br />
two is the<br />
only scenario<br />
without carbon<br />
capture included.<br />
However, scenario<br />
four (least selfsufficient)<br />
has the highest<br />
yearly operating expenditure<br />
(OPEX), whereas scenario one (fully<br />
22 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Environment<br />
FOCUS<br />
self-sufficient) has the lowest OPEX due to<br />
the lowest utilities needed as a result of the<br />
full electrical self-sufficiency.<br />
After calculating and analyzing the<br />
minimum selling price for hydrogen and<br />
carbon price for these four scenarios, they<br />
made two main conclusions. First, hydrogen<br />
derived from forest residues has the potential<br />
to achieve similar economic feasibility to<br />
current fossil fuel-based hydrogen with<br />
carbon capture. In fact, when the price of<br />
carbon dioxide is higher than $89 per ton<br />
of CO 2<br />
, all four scenarios become more<br />
economically attractive than the current<br />
fossil fuel-based hydrogen. However, the<br />
opposite—lower economic attractiveness<br />
when the price of CO 2<br />
is lower—also<br />
applies. This leads to the second conclusion,<br />
which is that CO 2<br />
prices help determine<br />
how economically competitive the three<br />
scenarios with carbon capture can be.<br />
To further analyze the effect of renewable<br />
energy, additional cases for scenarios<br />
one (fully electricity self-sufficient) and<br />
four (least electricity self-sufficient) were<br />
examined. Instead of using an electricity<br />
source from the current grid, solar and<br />
wind energy were used. The findings<br />
indicated that renewable energy sources<br />
make scenario four preferable to electricity<br />
self-sufficiency (scenario one). However,<br />
further research needs to be conducted to<br />
determine the optimal renewable energy<br />
design for BECCS.<br />
These findings suggest that using BECCS has<br />
lower environmental impacts than the current<br />
hydrogen production methods and highlight<br />
the need for individuals from various sectors,<br />
including chemistry, analytics, business,<br />
engineering, and more, to successfully<br />
implement this biotechnology approach.<br />
Limitations<br />
There is no denying that BECCS has<br />
an immense amount of potential to be an<br />
excellent environmental solution, but it is<br />
important to acknowledge certain limitations<br />
in this study. The study did not include CO 2<br />
transportation and storage or hydrogen<br />
transportation in its model. Moreover, the<br />
study focused on the Pacific Northwest of<br />
the United States, which is only one small<br />
region in the world. Similar studies must be<br />
conducted in other regions to determine if<br />
this technology is economically feasible and<br />
has reduced environmental impacts.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
A shell gas station that sells premium gasoline fuel.<br />
Implications and Next Steps<br />
Looking towards the future, BECCS could<br />
be used in other waste feedstocks beyond<br />
forest residues to sustainably provide energy,<br />
such as animal wastes, food wastes, etc. This<br />
could be used to reform the agricultural<br />
industry, which is responsible for much of<br />
global greenhouse gas emissions.<br />
The findings from this study can help<br />
inform further research on other types<br />
of carbon capture and storage. Looking<br />
ahead, Wu wants to expand their study<br />
of carbon capture technologies to assess<br />
their economic and environmental impact.<br />
“BECCS is a chemical-based process, but<br />
there are more natural methods for carbon<br />
capture and storage, such as afforestation<br />
and reforestation, enhanced weathering,<br />
and biochar and soil carbon sequestration,”<br />
Wu said. Afforestation and reforestation<br />
rely on trees, enhanced weathering relies<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
on rocks, and biochar and soil carbon<br />
sequestration rely on the soil (after CO 2<br />
is transformed into more stable carbon).<br />
“The next project I am working on is<br />
analyzing enhanced weathering carbon<br />
capture—using rocks to capture CO 2<br />
in the<br />
atmosphere. We are trying to explore the<br />
different possibilities,” Wu said.<br />
“We can help in the decision-making of<br />
various parties, such as researchers working<br />
in the lab, and we can also provide insights<br />
to companies. For instance, we can explain<br />
if it’s a good investment by determining if it<br />
is profitable, and we can also provide insights<br />
to the environmental authorities,” Wu said.<br />
One thing is clear: an interdisciplinary team<br />
is necessary to create a more sustainable,<br />
low-carbon, and circular society. “We<br />
need different kinds of parties: authorities,<br />
companies, chemists, engineers, business<br />
people, etc. In that way, we can make sure we<br />
are heading in the right direction,” Wu said. ■<br />
ABIGAIL JOLTEUS<br />
ABIGAIL JOLTEUS is a sophomore in Berkeley College studying Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. In<br />
addition to writing for <strong>YSM</strong>, she is the web manager. Outside of <strong>YSM</strong>, Jolteus conducts research at<br />
Yale’s School of Medicine.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Dr. Na Wu for her time and enthusiasm about her research.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
Wu, N., Lan, K., & Yao, Y. (2023). An integrated techno-economic and environmental assessment<br />
for carbon capture in hydrogen production by biomass gasification. Resources, Conservation and<br />
Recycling, 188, 106693. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2022.106693<br />
In-na, P., Sharp, E. B., Caldwell, G. S., Unthank, M. G., Perry, J. J., & Lee, J. G. M. (2022). Engineered living<br />
photosynthetic biocomposites for intensified biological carbon capture. Scientific Reports, 12(1).<br />
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21686-3<br />
Nowotny, J., & Veziroglu, T. N. (2011). Impact of hydrogen on the environment. International Journal of<br />
Hydrogen Energy, 36(20), 13218–13224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2011.07.071<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 23
FOCUS Lab Profile<br />
AI<br />
COMBINING AI AND<br />
MACHINE<br />
LEARNING<br />
WITH CARDIOVASCULAR<br />
HEALTH<br />
BY YUSUF RASHEED<br />
According to the CDC, one person<br />
dies every thirty-four seconds<br />
from cardiovascular disease in<br />
the United States. It is also the leading<br />
cause of death for men and women<br />
across the country, costing over $200<br />
billion annually. In 2020, around 697,000<br />
people in the United States died from<br />
cardiovascular disease, which accounted<br />
for twenty percent of all deaths that year.<br />
There are strong efforts worldwide in<br />
research and clinical care to improve the<br />
diagnosis and treatment of this disease,<br />
particularly at the Cardiovascular Data<br />
Science (CarDS) Lab at the Yale School<br />
of Medicine, which is tackling this<br />
issue through a creative intersection of<br />
computer science and patient data.<br />
The CarDS Lab aims to improve<br />
cardiovascular health using data-driven<br />
insights into how care is delivered<br />
to patients. This means they use<br />
technology—artificial<br />
intelligence (AI)<br />
with machine<br />
learning, for example—to augment our<br />
ability to diagnose and treat patients. For<br />
example, the lab has built AI models that<br />
can detect cardiac muscle dysfunction<br />
from electrocardiograms (EKG), which<br />
humans are unable to do. “The entire<br />
idea is to democratize the access to<br />
technology so that more people know<br />
they may have [cardiovascular disease]<br />
so that they can be referred to the health<br />
system for more advanced imaging,” said<br />
Yale University Assistant Professor of<br />
Cardiovascular Medicine Rohan Khera,<br />
who is the principal investigator of the<br />
lab. The group also works with national<br />
registries and datasets to define best<br />
methodological practices in conducting<br />
studies, evaluates healthcare policies and<br />
their association with cardiovascular<br />
health outcomes, and interprets clinical<br />
trial results personalized for individual<br />
patients. These goals are reflected in the<br />
structure of the lab, where members are<br />
part of a “core” or a specific aim within<br />
the lab’s overall goal. “Some folks work<br />
on natural language processing, some<br />
work on ECGs, some work on cardiac<br />
imaging, some are focused on EHR<br />
design, some are working on trials.<br />
People present from one theme to the<br />
others, so everybody can learn what<br />
the others are doing, but [they] tend to<br />
focus on their own domain. That’s been<br />
our key, to focus on building micro-labs<br />
within a large lab,” Khera said.<br />
Khera grew up in India, where he<br />
attended the All-India Institute of<br />
Medical Sciences for his medical<br />
training. He then had a variety of<br />
away rotations at several institutions,<br />
including Johns Hopkins University, the<br />
University of California, Los Angeles,<br />
and the University of Pennsylvania,<br />
where he gained broad exposure to basic<br />
translational and clinical research. This<br />
experience continued at the University<br />
of Iowa during his residency and at UT<br />
Southwestern for his fellowship. “When I<br />
graduated fellowship, I knew I was going<br />
to start a research program…It felt like<br />
there was a lot happening at [Yale]. It<br />
was very exciting how [Yale] had been<br />
at the cutting edge of health policy and<br />
outcomes research, so I came here to see<br />
if I could extend that further into more<br />
advanced data science,” Khera said.<br />
“That’s been our key, to<br />
within a large lab.<br />
focus on building micro-labs<br />
”<br />
24 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF PNGNICE
Lab Profile<br />
FOCUS<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF JENNA KIM VIA DR. KHERA'S TWITTER @ROHAN_KHERA<br />
Members of the CarDS Lab at the 2022 American Heart Association's Scientific Sessions in Chicago, IL<br />
these findings independently in the<br />
ACCORD BP trial. “The traditional<br />
interpretation of clinical trials does not<br />
necessarily inform us about whether a<br />
given treatment works for each patient…<br />
We’re interested in better understanding<br />
how the results of a study can be<br />
individualized for each unique patient<br />
in front of us at the clinic…We think<br />
that’s pretty interesting because not<br />
every patient should be treated in<br />
the same way.<br />
And that’s one<br />
step closer to<br />
more personalized<br />
cardiovascular<br />
care,” said<br />
Evangelos<br />
Oikonomou,<br />
a clinical fellow<br />
in cardiovascular<br />
medicine at Yale.<br />
Khera started his faculty position at<br />
Yale in July 2020, during the peak of the<br />
COVID-19 pandemic. “Everything was<br />
shut down, and there was a lot of time<br />
spent thinking how one would structure<br />
the lab when nobody’s around,” Khera<br />
said. He noted that there were fewer<br />
opportunities to meet new people who<br />
would be interested in the lab, so he<br />
spent the first several months of the lab’s<br />
inception exploring the Yale community.<br />
He credits the decision to run the lab<br />
virtually as one of the key reasons for its<br />
success, as people do not need to be in the<br />
same room all the timeNow, the CarDS<br />
lab has grown to over twenty people.<br />
Along this mission to integrate<br />
machine learning with cardiovascular<br />
health, the lab recently published a<br />
paper titled “Individualising intensive<br />
systolic blood pressure reduction in<br />
hypertension using computational trial<br />
phenomaps and machine learning: a<br />
post-hoc analysis of randomised clinical<br />
trials.” This study looked at two clinical<br />
trials, SPRINT and ACCORD BP, which<br />
each compared intensive versus standard<br />
blood pressure control treatment. Using<br />
a machine learning algorithm and a<br />
“phenomapping strategy,” which creates<br />
a network of all patients recruited in<br />
the trial to compare their phenotypes,<br />
they found that not every patient in the<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
SPRINT trial benefitted to the same<br />
extent from the intensive blood pressure<br />
control treatment. In other words, the<br />
effect of the treatment seemed to vary<br />
across different types of patients. From<br />
these results, the lab was able to analyze<br />
a given patient’s key characteristics and<br />
can tell how likely that patient is to<br />
benefit from intensive blood pressure<br />
control treatment. They then validated<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF JENNA KIM VIA<br />
DR. KHERA'S TWITTER @ROHAN_KHERA<br />
Veer Sangha, recipient of the Elizabeth Barrett-<br />
Connor Research Award, with PI Dr. Rohan Khera<br />
“We’re<br />
interested<br />
in better<br />
understanding<br />
how the results of a<br />
study can be individualized<br />
for each unique patient in<br />
front of us at the clinic…<br />
We think that’s pretty<br />
interesting because not<br />
every patient should be<br />
treated in the same way.<br />
”<br />
A second project that the lab has been<br />
working on is developing AI models to<br />
diagnose structural heart diseases from<br />
printed ECG scans. The focus on ECG<br />
comes from the fact that they are the<br />
most widely accessible and ubiquitous<br />
tool in the world to better understand a<br />
patient’s heart. However, physicians are<br />
only able to diagnose certain conditions<br />
and heart rhythm disorders from ECGs,<br />
creating the need for more expensive<br />
and harder-to-obtain screening tools for<br />
other heart conditions.<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 25
FOCUS<br />
Lab Profile<br />
The goal of the project is to<br />
be able to diagnose these conditions from<br />
ECGs—leading this effort is Yale College<br />
senior Veer Sangha YC '23, who has<br />
recently received the Rhodes Scholarship<br />
for his work with the lab. “We have a large<br />
repository of patients at the hospital, so<br />
we have their ECGs, and we know which<br />
patient has which disease," Sangha said.<br />
"So we can train our deep learning models<br />
to be able to learn features in the ECG that<br />
are relevant to a certain class of disorders<br />
or a certain disorder that a patient may<br />
have. And it can learn these features that<br />
humans themselves cannot learn.”<br />
To make this further accessible for<br />
patients, Sangha developed the model<br />
so that it didn’t need to use the signal<br />
data from the ECGs, which is not always<br />
available at the point of care. Instead, the<br />
model can make these inferences from<br />
printed scans of an ECG, which are widely<br />
available to patients and their clinicians.<br />
For undergraduate students interested in<br />
joining the CarDS lab, Khera recommends<br />
using the lab’s website Contact page or<br />
reaching out to him directly. He also<br />
suggests that students who want to join<br />
should ideally be interested in health<br />
technology and its applications and have<br />
some coding experience. Finally, he enjoys<br />
having students who want to be part of<br />
the lab for a long period of time. “Those<br />
who engage for a longer time are always<br />
there in a community learning, adapting,<br />
and growing. The folks that have really<br />
developed their careers in the lab have<br />
been associated with us for a couple of<br />
years already now,” Khera said.<br />
You can learn more about the CarDS Lab<br />
at https://www.cards-lab.org/. ■<br />
IMAGES COURTESY OF CARDS LAB WEBSITE<br />
Principal Investigator Dr. Rohan Khera (top) and members of the CarDS Lab<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
YUSUF RASHEED<br />
YUSUF RASHEED hails from the Bay Area and is a sophomore in Trumbull College majoring in<br />
Biomedical Engineering. He has a deep interest in physician-patient relationships and how budding<br />
medical professionals can develop their soft skills during and after their education. He hopes to apply<br />
his experience in engineering to a clinial setting in the future by improving and personalizing patient<br />
care. Yusuf also believes in the power of writing to effect change at all levels, whether that's personally<br />
through a journal or publicly through the Yale Scientific Magazine. He encourages all interested<br />
students to get involved with the magazine and try their hand at writing an article.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Dr. Rohan Khera, Dr. Evangelos Oikonomou, and Veer<br />
Sangha for their valuable time and support for this article.<br />
26 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
THE STRENGTH<br />
OF WEAK TIES<br />
Sociology<br />
FEATURE<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF PIXABAY<br />
BY EUNSOO HYUN<br />
ART BY KARA TAO<br />
CAN LINKEDIN ACQUAINTANCES HELP YOU FIND A NEW JOB?<br />
In 1973, American sociologist Mark Granovetter published a<br />
paper that fundamentally changed the field of sociology. The<br />
paper, titled “The Strength of Weak Ties,” theorized that weak<br />
ties (think casual acquaintances, friends-of-friends, and other<br />
arm’s-length relationships) help disseminate new information and<br />
provide more job opportunities than strong ties (such as close<br />
friends, family, or immediate coworkers).<br />
This phenomenon, which may seem counterintuitive at first<br />
glance, happens because weak ties—interpersonal relationships with<br />
fewer mutual connections—help expose people to new information<br />
and opportunities outside their immediate social bubble. “Weak ties<br />
tend to span a broader width of the overall social network of the<br />
labor market. Strong ties tend to be redundant because you have<br />
access to the same sort of resources, information, and so on,” said<br />
Karthik Rajkumar, an applied research scientist at LinkedIn.<br />
For Rajkumar, it was fascinating to see this correlation in action.<br />
As a graduate student applying to internships in 2019, he found<br />
himself sending out resume after resume, just hoping to hear back at<br />
all. (A familiar story to many readers, especially those now looking<br />
for jobs and summer opportunities!) “It really made me think:<br />
there’s so much more to the job market and the interview process<br />
than your resume and your credentials and your interviewing skills.<br />
There’s that personal touch—that connection, and that’s something<br />
I learned the hard way,” Rajkumar said. This prompted him to ask:<br />
what is the effect of social networks on job mobility?<br />
The term “job mobility” means that people in the labor market are<br />
able to move to new jobs when they want. “Job transmission” refers<br />
to job mobility as a result of connections made. “‘Job transmission’<br />
is this idea that if I connected with you now, am I going to join your<br />
company a year down the line?” Rajkumar said.<br />
Rajkumar and his co-authors designed a study to test for a causal<br />
relationship between interpersonal ties and job mobility<br />
using five years of data from LinkedIn. Their new<br />
paper in Science, titled “A causal test of<br />
the strength<br />
of weak ties”, is the first to conduct a<br />
large-scale,<br />
experimental study of a causal—<br />
not just correlational—<br />
relationship between weak<br />
ties and employment. More<br />
specifically, the researchers<br />
used LinkedIn’s People<br />
You May Know (PYMK)<br />
algorithm, which recommends new<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
connections for LinkedIn users to add to their networks. By adjusting<br />
the algorithm, the team randomly varied whether users got weak or<br />
strong tie recommendations in the PYMK section. The tie strength<br />
between two users was determined by the number of messages sent<br />
back and forth and the number of mutual connections they had.<br />
The results empirically validated the theory that weak ties cause<br />
increased job mobility. This discovery disproved the “paradox<br />
of weak ties,” identified by previous correlational studies that<br />
proposed strong ties as the agents behind job mobility. The overall<br />
relationship between tie strength, measured by the number of<br />
mutual friends, and job mobility was nonlinear, following an<br />
“inverted U-shape.” In other words, the weakest ties weren’t the best<br />
at increasing job mobility. Rather, moderately weak ties increased<br />
job mobility and job transmissions the most. The strongest ties<br />
affected job mobility the least.<br />
However, when they looked at the results according to<br />
interaction intensity (the number of messages exchanged) as the<br />
metric of tie strength, weak ties with low interaction were the most<br />
helpful. Interestingly, these results varied by job industry. Weak<br />
ties mattered most when applying to jobs in industries that rely on<br />
software, but strong ties still held sway in less digital industries. This<br />
difference may be due to the importance of up-to-date information<br />
in rapidly evolving industries like tech. “Weak ties are conduits for<br />
information. They’re very efficient in bridging these information<br />
gaps across vast corners of the social network,” Rajkumar said.<br />
So how has this discovery been applied to sites like LinkedIn? One<br />
example is the updated “People You May Know” section. Before, the<br />
PYMK page simply showed a list of connections. Now, LinkedIn<br />
separates these connections into categories—connections from the<br />
same school, company, industry, and so on. “A lot of times, I hear<br />
people say, oh, I would like to have weak ties,<br />
but you know—how would I approach a<br />
total stranger? It’s all about finding that<br />
commonality, whether it’s your professional<br />
interest or mutual connections,”<br />
Rajkumar said.<br />
The discovery of a causal<br />
relationship between<br />
weak ties and job mobility<br />
provides important insights<br />
for networks like LinkedIn<br />
as the labor market becomes<br />
increasingly digitized. ■<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 27
FEATURE<br />
Robotics<br />
AN UNEXPECTED MARRIAGE:<br />
ROBOT DRONES & FLOWER POWER<br />
SAVING KAUAI’S ENDANGERED PLANTS<br />
WITH A CLIFF SAMPLING DRONE<br />
BY CINDY MEI<br />
ART BY SOPHIA ZHAO<br />
Flying over the cliffs of Kauai, a drone known as the Mamba<br />
sweeps the area on a rescue mission, searching for valuable<br />
buds of life beyond normal reach. On these cliffs lie extremely<br />
rare plants, many only found in Kauai, and some the last of their<br />
kind. The Hawaiian island is home to 250 endemic flora species<br />
found exclusively on the island, ninety-seven percent of which are<br />
classified as endangered or extinct. Environmental hazards are<br />
increasing the extinction rate to five hundred times the expected<br />
rate without human interference. For years, botanists have braved<br />
Kauai’s cliffs and other hard-to-access locations in search of these<br />
critically endangered plants. However, the areas are extremely<br />
hazardous and are time-consuming and expensive to access.<br />
For years, drones have been a prominent tool in environmental<br />
conservation and monitoring in harsh environments, imaging across<br />
different wavelengths of light and identifying plant habitats and<br />
distributions. However, the development of drones to navigate and<br />
interact with dangerous and inaccessible environments is an entirely<br />
new innovation in this field. “What differentiates what we’re doing<br />
with drones is that we’re interacting directly with the environment,”<br />
said Hughes La Vigne, a PhD student of robotics engineering at the<br />
University of Sherbrooke and co-founder of Outreach Robotics.<br />
The company first took root following the creation of the DeLeaves<br />
sampling system, a device designed to collect branches from treetops<br />
and canopies. “The purpose of Outreach Robotics is to develop<br />
robotic tools that could help scientists working in conservation,<br />
reforestation, and other environmental purposes,” La Vigne said.<br />
Enter the Mamba, the first aerial system that can sample plants<br />
on cliffs and transport them to a safer place. With a grant from<br />
National Geographic, Outreach Robotics teamed up with Ben<br />
Nyberg, a PhD student at the University of Copenhagen and the<br />
drone coordinator of the National Tropical Botanical Garden<br />
(NTBG), a nonprofit organization dedicated to the conservation<br />
and restoration of tropical plants. The project, which was published<br />
in Scientific Reports this fall, spanned two years of prototyping,<br />
iterating, and testing amid disruptions from COVID-19.<br />
Throughout the design process, the team considered many factors<br />
to optimize and stabilize flight collections. The drone had to be able<br />
to endure windy conditions, collect samples quickly and gently, and<br />
navigate around unwelcoming terrain. The final system prototype<br />
utilized a suspended platform equipped with propellers that swung<br />
in a pendulum, reducing rigidity and allowing an extended reach<br />
from cliffsides, minimizing the potential for collisions. In addition,<br />
the Mamba had to be easy to use with minimal roboticist training.<br />
“When you’re developing tools that might have an impact on<br />
conservation or the environment, you want it to be used by people<br />
who are working in that field,” La Vigne said.<br />
The final design was tested in two field trials in late 2021 and<br />
early 2022, with La Vigne and fellow University of Sherbrooke<br />
researcher and Outreach Robotics co-founder Guillaume Charron<br />
teleoperating the Mamba from the ground. Following imaging<br />
and identification of plant species targets, the Mamba navigated<br />
to the sites with built-in global navigation systems. Using an active<br />
robotic arm wrist suspended by long, snaking cables beneath the<br />
drone, the Mamba was able to cut and recover eleven otherwise<br />
inaccessible samples of seeds and cuttings with minimal impact<br />
from five critically endangered plants on Kauai’s cliffs. These<br />
plants were then deposited at the NTBG, which used methods<br />
such as seed banking and ex situ cultivation to maintain growth.<br />
The final prototype of the Mamba was also time-efficient and<br />
could reach several sampling sites from one base station.<br />
Since then, some plants like the Lysimachia iniki have flourished<br />
in the NTBG nurseries, becoming the first recovered plants of<br />
their kind to do so in captivity, while others, like the Euphorbia<br />
eleanoriae, did not survive in the long run. L. iniki grew roots for<br />
the first time in captivity, bolstering the hope that the surviving<br />
single-population plants of Kauai will be able to regrow with the<br />
combined effort of the drones and conservation. In future projects,<br />
the Mamba will be taken to other islands of Hawaii, where ninety<br />
percent of flora is not found anywhere else on Earth, in its pursuit<br />
to save these rare plants. “This is what we dreamed about for the<br />
last two years or so when we saw that drones were being used to<br />
interact with the environment,” La Vigne said. “[NTBG] is doing an<br />
amazing job to preserve these endemic species, and our goal is to<br />
help them and continue to work with environmental scientists.” ■<br />
28 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
ROBOTS<br />
Using AI and robots to optimize<br />
organic chemistry reactions<br />
vs<br />
Chemistry / Machine Learning<br />
HUMANS<br />
ORGANIC CHEMISTRY EDITION<br />
FEATURE<br />
BY ANYA RAZMI<br />
ART BY MALIA KUO<br />
For thousands of years, human innovation has been defined<br />
by the creation of big tools: the wheel, the watch, the scythe.<br />
Only in the last two centuries have we begun to investigate the<br />
power of small tools: molecules. From synthetic dyes to life-saving<br />
medications, molecular toolmaking has the potential to solve some<br />
of society’s greatest technological challenges.<br />
But making molecules isn’t easy. The synthesis of small organic<br />
molecules usually requires very specific reaction conditions—a<br />
tailored combination of solvents, temperature, pressure, and<br />
catalysts—to maximize product yield. Knowing which conditions<br />
suit which reactions takes expertise, the kind of expertise that only<br />
organic chemists, after years of highly specialized study, possess.<br />
“Right now, molecule making is this very exclusive club that only<br />
a few of us can get into,” said Martin Burke, professor of chemistry<br />
at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. “We want to<br />
shatter those barriers and invite everyone into the molecule-making<br />
space.” A recent collaboration between Burke and his colleague<br />
Bartosz Grzybowski, Professor at the Polish Academy of Sciences,<br />
is working to achieve just that. The paper, titled “Closed-loop<br />
optimization of general reaction conditions for heteroaryl Suzuki-<br />
Miyaura coupling,” was published in Science in October. Together,<br />
the two teams of researchers searched for a way to optimize general<br />
conditions—conditions that, regardless of the building blocks<br />
used, maximize the final product of a reaction. In particular,<br />
they investigated Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling (SMC), the<br />
quintessential reaction for carbon-carbon bond formation.<br />
With so many factors affecting a reaction, finding the best<br />
combination to optimize yield is enormously challenging. “The<br />
haystack is astronomical,” Burke said. “It’s literally beyond the capacity<br />
of collective capability of our planet.” The researchers needed a way<br />
to shrink this haystack—to find a list of possibilities for general<br />
conditions, then test them as quickly and accurately as possible.<br />
The solution? Artificial intelligence and robots.<br />
At the Beckman Institute in Illinois, robots performed 530<br />
chemical reactions. Syringes, purification columns, and pipettes<br />
were connected by masses of tubing, all of which worked in sync<br />
to carry out experiments independent of human hands. It wasn’t<br />
humans typing in which conditions the robots should use, either—<br />
it was AI. Grzybowski and his colleagues developed a machine<br />
learning algorithm to instruct the robots on which conditions to test.<br />
The process was a closed loop: Once a reaction had been<br />
performed, the data was transferred to the AI. The algorithm then<br />
developed altered procedures and transferred them back to the<br />
robot, which performed the reaction again under this new set of<br />
conditions. Then the cycle repeated.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
“The AI was in Poland. The robots are in Illinois. The loop was<br />
happening across the world,” Burke said.<br />
Burke and his colleagues had tried defining general conditions<br />
before. In 2009, they published a paper in the Journal of the American<br />
Chemical Society which used human-guided experimentation to<br />
identify general reaction conditions for the SMC reaction. It was<br />
the best that humans could do, and it took six years.<br />
Within four months, artificial intelligence doubled their yield.<br />
The implications of this result are far-reaching. The scientists’<br />
ultimate goal is a “plug-and-play” platform in which researchers<br />
can enter the desired function for a molecule and have robots<br />
create it for them. With this type of technology, the synthesis of<br />
organic molecules could be democratized, no longer limited to a<br />
small group of experts. Ideally, this platform would use a limited<br />
number of reactions—maybe even just one.<br />
“Right now, in chemistry, there are about fifty to one hundred<br />
thousand reaction types. And it all might be unnecessary, in some<br />
sense,” Grzybowski said. “Nature uses very few operations, but<br />
repeatedly, in an iterative fashion. The robots are trying to do<br />
exactly the same.”<br />
Part of the algorithm’s success hinged upon its ability to probe<br />
both negative and positive results. “The AI was learning not<br />
only what works, but also what doesn’t work,” Grzybowski said.<br />
“With failure, the robot learns. And then it finds the right path.”<br />
For this algorithm to succeed,<br />
negative results were<br />
just as important<br />
as positive ones.<br />
This is a notable<br />
departure<br />
from how the<br />
scientific field<br />
currently works: people<br />
don’t publish negative<br />
results. For Burke, this<br />
was an important lesson.<br />
“We don’t spend a lot of time<br />
trying to figure out why things<br />
fail,” Burke said. “We’re always trying<br />
to teach AI about how to do the things<br />
that we do. I think things just flipped.<br />
AI is teaching us something very<br />
important about how to do science.<br />
I feel like I learned something from<br />
AI, and that’s exciting.” ■<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 29
FEATURE<br />
Cell Biology<br />
GAMER NEURONS<br />
IN VITRO NEURONS PLAY A<br />
SIMULATED GAME OF PONG<br />
Our brains are a collection of<br />
billions of neurons, firing in<br />
synchrony to make up the<br />
complex organ that is our brain. But<br />
zooming in, what if we consider a small,<br />
isolated subset of cells? What might<br />
they be capable of?<br />
Neurons are unique cells in the body.<br />
Unlike other cells, which can simply<br />
maintain their functions isolated in a<br />
petri dish, neurons process information,<br />
meaning they need a stimulus that<br />
prompts them to act. This makes them<br />
both fascinating and difficult to study.<br />
Computational models have been used<br />
to study neural networks, but they are<br />
limited by the constraints of technology,<br />
which is no substitute for a biological<br />
system. To alleviate this concern, what<br />
if neural networks could be made from<br />
biological neurons in a petri dish? In<br />
their recent paper, Brett Kagan, his<br />
colleagues at Cortical Labs, and several<br />
university collaborators have set out<br />
to study the interface of biology and<br />
intelligence by exploring how biological<br />
neurons respond to electrophysiological<br />
input and feedback in vitro.<br />
The team’s research process started<br />
in 2019. However, the pandemic threw<br />
a wrench in their plans, especially<br />
with Australia’s strict lockdown<br />
procedures. “Fortunately, we were able<br />
to get exemptions to go to work because<br />
we were considered critical workers,<br />
being in a hospital setting. But it was<br />
incredibly different circumstances<br />
nonetheless, getting supplies in and all<br />
the basic little things that we used to<br />
take for granted,” Kagan said. Once the<br />
lab could work around the restrictions,<br />
the group hit the ground running,<br />
resuming their research skillfully and<br />
deliberately. Kagan and his colleagues<br />
adopted an approach called “agile<br />
science,” where they set up a series of<br />
small pilot experiments in tandem to<br />
see which conditions would be best for<br />
their cells. This allowed them to adjust<br />
their research environment as they went<br />
along and optimize their experiments<br />
throughout the process. By growing<br />
long-term cortical neurons that formed<br />
dense connections with supporting glial<br />
cells, Kagan and his colleagues were able<br />
to study the behavior and capabilities of<br />
these biological neurons in a petri dish.<br />
A silicon chip inside the dish<br />
stimulated the neurons to create a<br />
simulated Pong game-world, where<br />
a paddle is moved up and down the<br />
screen to block a ball from hitting the<br />
side. “We chose Pong because we wanted<br />
something [in] real time, simple to<br />
code for with a clear ‘win and/or lose’<br />
condition—in this case, there was a really<br />
clear lose condition—and [something]<br />
recognizable to people. It’s actually the<br />
fiftieth anniversary of Pong [this year],”<br />
30 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Cell Biology<br />
FEATURE<br />
Kagan said. Inputs from the silicon chip<br />
were delivered to a predefined sensory<br />
area of eight electrodes. These electrodes<br />
stimulated sensory neurons that then<br />
communicated with motor neurons also<br />
cultured in the dish. The researchers<br />
wanted to see if the motor neurons<br />
would learn to move the paddle and<br />
intercept the ball. Any time the neurons<br />
missed an interception, they would be<br />
stimulated randomly, while successfully<br />
intercepting the ball meant they would<br />
receive predictable stimulation.<br />
Why might random stimulation in<br />
response to error cause the neurons<br />
to learn to play the game? Kagan and<br />
his team used the idea behind the free<br />
energy principle, developed by Karl<br />
Friston, a collaborator on their paper,<br />
to inform their hypothesis. As Kagan<br />
explained, the free energy principle says<br />
that a system will minimize the surprise<br />
or uncertainty in its environment.<br />
“What we did was give the neuron<br />
feedback randomly if it got [the game]<br />
wrong. If the free energy principle is<br />
true, then the system should reorganize<br />
itself to minimize randomness,” Kagan<br />
said. This means that to minimize the<br />
amount of random stimulation they<br />
received, the in vitro neurons would<br />
need to learn to play the game.<br />
This learning could be done in one<br />
of two ways: either the neurons could<br />
create a model or a “belief system” so that<br />
the network can respond and match the<br />
model with the real world, or they could<br />
physically act upon their environment<br />
to change their surroundings. Kagan<br />
and his colleagues showed that in vitro<br />
neurons learned to move the paddle to<br />
play Pong, and biological neurons can<br />
thus be adaptive. “We found that these<br />
neurons want to act in a way that can<br />
minimize unpredictability, [and] we<br />
can see this by them learning to play<br />
Pong,” Kagan said.<br />
They also uncovered some interesting<br />
and unexpected findings. Kagan<br />
explained that one of the intriguing<br />
results of the paper was their data<br />
on information entropy, which is the<br />
amount of information conveyed in an<br />
event. “It was really exciting because<br />
it showed that the cultures were able<br />
to distinguish between internal and<br />
external noise,” Kagan said. Essentially,<br />
they showed that the neurons could<br />
determine the difference between<br />
information generated on their own and<br />
information from an outside source,<br />
highlighting the specificity with which<br />
the neurons can source the signals they<br />
receive. “[It] makes sense because I can<br />
distinguish between my thoughts and<br />
your words, so there must be a way to<br />
break that up. But to see that you’re<br />
getting one response for external noise<br />
and one response for internal noise was<br />
pretty exciting,” Kagan said.<br />
This system, which Kagan and<br />
colleagues aptly termed “DishBrain,”<br />
sits at the interface of neurobiology and<br />
computational technology. Short-term<br />
benefits of the system are numerous:<br />
drug discovery, disease modeling, and<br />
building a basic understanding of how<br />
neurons create intelligence. “All general<br />
intelligence that we have ever seen is<br />
biological—from flies to cats to humans,”<br />
Kagan said. Still, there are limits to<br />
biological neural networks. “This does<br />
not mean that you end up with a human<br />
in a dish. What it means is that neurons<br />
are this biomimetic material that can<br />
adapt to new information, so can you<br />
use it as an information processor,”<br />
Kagan said. “It offers us an ethically<br />
responsible way to move forward.”<br />
Though many questions remain,<br />
Kagan and his colleagues at Cortical<br />
Labs are looking forward to digging<br />
deeper into their work and making<br />
new, exciting findings. Now, they’re<br />
working on perfecting their research<br />
infrastructure, from creating new<br />
biological environments to advancing<br />
their technology. “We’re trying to improve<br />
what we call the wetware (the cells), the<br />
hardware, [and] the software. We’re<br />
starting to do some disease modeling and<br />
drug testing, and all of these options are<br />
super exciting,” Kagan said. While many<br />
questions remain, neurons are certainly<br />
firing at Cortical Labs to help uncover<br />
more answers. This exciting research is<br />
sure to produce more interesting data that<br />
will guide the field of neuroscience and<br />
biological intelligence in the future. ■<br />
BY MAYA<br />
KHURANA<br />
ART BY<br />
MALIA KUO<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 31
FEATURE<br />
Planetary Sciences<br />
CONAN THE BACTERIUM<br />
COULD THE WORLD’S TOUGHEST<br />
ORGANISM SURVIVE ON MARS?<br />
BY KAYLA YUP<br />
ART BY BREANNA<br />
BROWNSON<br />
Conan the Bacterium may be<br />
Earth’s most promising astronaut.<br />
Named the world’s “toughest<br />
organism,” Deinococcus radiodurans—<br />
nicknamed Conan—could survive for<br />
a whopping 280 million years if buried<br />
ten meters beneath the Martian surface.<br />
This resilience suggests that if life ever<br />
existed on Mars, it could still exist today.<br />
The surface of Mars is deeply frozen<br />
and extremely dry. The atmosphere<br />
contains almost no oxygen and is over<br />
one hundred times thinner than Earth’s.<br />
Any life form released on Mars would<br />
essentially be freeze-dried and exposed<br />
to intense radiation from the sun. But<br />
Conan regularly challenges known limits<br />
of survival. The microbe can be frozen,<br />
desiccated, and face intense radiation, yet<br />
still live to see another day. In a recent<br />
study led by Michael Daly, a professor<br />
of pathology at Uniformed Services<br />
University of the Health Sciences and<br />
a member of the National Academies<br />
Committee on Planetary Protection,<br />
Conan and five other organisms were<br />
tested for potential survivability on Mars.<br />
As missions to and from Mars reach<br />
fruition, worry over cross-contamination<br />
between planets is putting the spotlight on<br />
Conan and other hitchhiking microbes.<br />
Future manned missions would expose<br />
Mars to astronauts and their microbiomes,<br />
raising the concern that Earthen microbes<br />
could be released and contaminate<br />
Mars’ surface. Daly’s study examined<br />
six microbes found in the human gut:<br />
Conan the Bacterium, E. coli, three sporeforming<br />
Bacillus bacteria, and a strain<br />
of baker’s yeast called Saccharomyces<br />
cerevisiae. In this study, Conan and the<br />
baker’s yeast broke all previous radiation<br />
survival records, even when compared to<br />
Bacillus spores, which are renowned for<br />
their resistance.<br />
To simulate the conditions on<br />
Mars, all six organisms were first<br />
dried in a desiccation chamber<br />
for five days and then stored on<br />
dry ice. The frozen organisms<br />
were later placed in an irradiator<br />
and exposed to very large doses of<br />
ionizing radiation in the form of<br />
gamma rays and protons—imitating<br />
forms of radiation from the sun.<br />
When charged particles, including<br />
protons from the sun, approach Earth,<br />
our magnetic field deflects them, and our<br />
atmosphere blocks them. But Mars has no<br />
magnetosphere and virtually<br />
no atmosphere to protect<br />
itself: protons are free<br />
to crash into the<br />
Martian surface<br />
and generate<br />
additional<br />
gamma rays.<br />
This is why<br />
the most<br />
dangerous<br />
part of Mars<br />
is the top ten<br />
centimeters of the<br />
Martian surface—<br />
Conan could only<br />
survive that amount of<br />
ionizing radiation for about<br />
1.5 million years. Further below the<br />
surface, shielding can protect against main<br />
forms of ionizing radiation, leaving only<br />
t h e<br />
p l a n e t ’ s<br />
low natural<br />
background<br />
radiation, as<br />
it is on Earth.<br />
“The deeper you<br />
go [into Mars’<br />
surface], the<br />
more likely it is<br />
that you will find<br />
the remnants of<br />
life,” Daly said. “The<br />
survivability of life is<br />
now greater than we had ever<br />
thought possible.”<br />
Conan’s mechanisms for survival<br />
have previously been characterized, but<br />
32 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Planetary Sciences<br />
FEATURE<br />
not in the context of Mars. Past studies<br />
looked at radiation under Earthen<br />
conditions, representing a planet where<br />
life revolves around liquid water. The<br />
limits of ionizing radiation survival<br />
have traditionally been established by<br />
increasing doses of gamma radiation<br />
until the last viable microbe is dead. In<br />
decades past, Conan’s ‘survival limit’<br />
was approximately 25,000 kGy of gamma<br />
radiation under aqueous conditions. The<br />
present study found that if first dried and<br />
then frozen into a dormant state, Conan<br />
could withstand a whopping 140,000<br />
kGy of gamma radiation.<br />
“In the past, folks and scientists<br />
considered the survivability of life on<br />
Mars to be on the order of perhaps<br />
millions of years,” Daly said. “But<br />
we now have the evidence to<br />
support that life, when dormant,<br />
could likely survive hundreds of<br />
millions of years.”<br />
There are two essential<br />
reasons for Conan’s extreme<br />
resistance to radiation: the<br />
hyperaccumulation of manganese<br />
antioxidants (Mn-antioxidants)<br />
coupled with polyploidy and<br />
the presence of multiple identical<br />
genomes. Mn-antioxidants protect<br />
proteins needed to rebuild DNA, and<br />
polyploidy provides the cell with backup<br />
genomes used in repair.<br />
Extremophiles like Conan accumulate<br />
Mn-antioxidants, which are small<br />
complexes that consist of manganous<br />
ions bound to a variety of common<br />
metabolites. Generally, the more Mnantioxidants<br />
accumulated in a cell, the<br />
greater the organism’s resistance to<br />
ionizing radiation. Ionizing radiation<br />
is a high-energy form of radiation that<br />
can strip electrons from water, forming<br />
unstable molecules called ‘reactive<br />
oxygen species’ (ROS). The most toxic<br />
ROS in irradiated cells is superoxide,<br />
which “fries” the proteome, Daly<br />
explained. The proteome is the organism’s<br />
set of proteins—including the molecular<br />
machinery required to reassemble DNA<br />
broken by radiation. Mn-antioxidants<br />
in Conan defend the proteome against<br />
ROS and thereby preserve the enzymes<br />
needed to rebuild its broken genomes<br />
after radiation. In contrast, cells like E.<br />
coli that lack this Mn-antioxidant defense<br />
lose the ability to reassemble DNA<br />
damaged by radiation.<br />
Manganese antioxidants do not prevent<br />
DNA damage caused by radiation—<br />
luckily, the second molecular trick in<br />
Conan’s tool kit is polyploidy. Polyploidy<br />
means that when one genome is damaged,<br />
other undamaged copies can be used to<br />
repair the broken one. Conan contains<br />
eight identical copies of its genome per<br />
cell. The team showed that the organisms<br />
with the greatest resistance to radiation<br />
are polyploid. E. coli and Bacillus spores<br />
typically have only one or two genome<br />
copies, while baker’s yeast has four copies.<br />
In Conan, the eight genome copies are<br />
linked together by interstrand crosslinks<br />
called Holliday junctions, further<br />
accelerating DNA repair. “When you get<br />
a double-strand break caused by radiation<br />
in the genome, then the repair templates<br />
for homologous recombination are never<br />
far away,” Daly said.<br />
The baker’s yeast strain studied is also<br />
a polyploid, but this fungus accumulates<br />
fewer Mn-antioxidants than Conan. By<br />
comparison, E. coli does not accumulate<br />
Mn-antioxidants and typically has only<br />
one or two copies of its genomes. While<br />
the Bacillus spores accumulate Mnantioxidants,<br />
they are merely haploids,<br />
containing only a single copy of the<br />
genome. In the end, the data showed<br />
that dried and frozen Conan would<br />
possibly survive 280 million years when<br />
buried ten meters below the Martian<br />
subsurface, the yeast would survive<br />
48 million years, E. coli would survive<br />
sixteen million years, and Bacillus<br />
spores would survive relatively less.<br />
The forthcoming ExoMars mission’s<br />
Rosalind Franklin rover plans to drill<br />
two meters below the surface of Mars and<br />
collect samples in search of life. While<br />
the surface of Mars has been frozen and<br />
desiccated for billions of years, Daly<br />
theorized that life could still exist not<br />
far beneath the surface. He explained<br />
that Mars’ lack of an atmosphere means<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF DALY<br />
These Deinococcus bacteria were used in a new<br />
study that suggests that if there is or ever was life<br />
on Mars, it would still exist today.<br />
that meteorites regularly bombard<br />
the planet. Upon impact, frozen water<br />
beneath a crater will melt, and simple<br />
organic compounds delivered by some<br />
meteorites could fertilize and fuel<br />
cellular recovery. If this theory holds<br />
true, Conan could have a Martian<br />
doppelganger out there to challenge its<br />
title as the world’s toughest organism.<br />
Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty (OST)<br />
of 1967 is an international agreement aimed<br />
at preventing harmful cross-contamination<br />
in the exploration of life across celestial<br />
bodies. While Conan’s survivability<br />
suggests that forward-contamination of<br />
Mars would be essentially permanent over<br />
mission time-frames of thousands of years,<br />
this would not be considered harmful under<br />
the OST because the organisms cannot<br />
proliferate when frozen and desiccated.<br />
Harmful backward contamination from<br />
Mars to Earth is also unlikely because if<br />
life ever evolved on Mars, it would now<br />
be anaerobic—able to survive without<br />
oxygen—and susceptible to the toxic effects<br />
of Earth’s oxygen-rich atmosphere.<br />
“It is not considered harmful<br />
contamination unless these organisms<br />
were dispersed across the planet and<br />
somehow found some warmth and water,”<br />
Daly explained. “There are good reasons<br />
to think that we can explore the surfaces<br />
of Mars without harming the science that<br />
is dedicated to looking for the possibility<br />
of extraterrestrial life. One can speculate<br />
that Martian life, if it ever existed there,<br />
still exists below the surface.” ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 33
FEATURE<br />
Chemistry<br />
THE GOLDEN<br />
Whether you're cooking a meal<br />
or mixing a drink, chances are<br />
that you taste your creation<br />
to figure out if it's right or not. Maybe<br />
there's too much sugar in the lemonade,<br />
or your tomato sauce isn't cooked enough,<br />
or your stir-fry needs more salt. Our<br />
senses have always helped us decode the<br />
mysteries of what we eat and drink. But<br />
now, we can also use chemistry to figure<br />
out when our favorite refreshments are<br />
perfect to consume. Researchers from<br />
the University of Glasgow and the Scotch<br />
Whisky Research Institute have recently<br />
designed a way to determine the flavor<br />
maturity of whiskey by using gold.<br />
After whiskey is distilled, it is stored for<br />
years in charred wooden casks to gain its<br />
characteristic flavor and amber color. The<br />
type of cask used for whiskey storage and<br />
the duration of aging can dramatically<br />
change its flavor profile. This flavor comes<br />
from chemicals called congeners that the<br />
whiskey absorbs from its wooden cask.<br />
Traditionally, casks of whiskey must be<br />
constantly sampled by a master blender,<br />
who determines if the flavor is just<br />
right. Since there are often hundreds or<br />
thousands of casks to sample, each taking<br />
so long to age, whiskey distillers are very<br />
interested in developing a quicker way to<br />
assess the maturity of their products.<br />
William Peveler, a chemist at the<br />
University of Glasgow in Scotland, first<br />
came across the science of whiskey when<br />
he saw a related infographic in Chemical<br />
& Engineering News magazine. He noticed<br />
that some of whiskey's chemical structures<br />
looked similar to the chemicals he worked<br />
with during his doctoral studies, which<br />
focused on creating gold nanoparticles.<br />
He wondered if whiskey could also be<br />
used to make these nanoparticles, and<br />
his team tested the hypothesis by using<br />
a cheap supermarket-brand whiskey in<br />
their lab. "And it did work, which was<br />
surprising since things don't always do<br />
that!" Peveler joked.<br />
The researchers found that the qualities<br />
of gold nanoparticles that form in<br />
different types of whiskey can<br />
reveal how long it has been<br />
aged. Their analysis involves<br />
taking just fifty microliters<br />
of whiskey—the equivalent of<br />
one droplet—and mixing in the<br />
same amount of gold salt. The<br />
flavor congeners in the whiskey<br />
reduce the gold salt into gold<br />
nanoparticles and stabilize<br />
them against growing any<br />
larger than a few hundred<br />
nanometers. These<br />
particles are so tiny that<br />
they can’t be seen by the<br />
naked eye. However, they<br />
do give the whiskey a visibly<br />
different color because<br />
gold nanoparticles absorb<br />
light very strongly compared<br />
to many other materials. Gold<br />
nanoparticles typically absorb<br />
green wavelengths of light the<br />
strongest. This means that we<br />
don’t usually see green light from<br />
gold nanoparticles—rather, we perceive<br />
the gold nanoparticles as different tones<br />
of pink, red, or purple. After just fifteen<br />
minutes, the final color of the sample<br />
reveals how aged or flavorful the whiskey<br />
is. Whiskeys with more flavor congeners<br />
generally produce more nanoparticles,<br />
giving the sample a more intense color.<br />
The researchers' use of gold might<br />
strike some as strange. "Of course, you<br />
use gold, and everyone goes, 'Well, gold's<br />
really expensive. Why are you using<br />
gold?'" Peveler said. Peveler's group also<br />
explored using silver for their study since<br />
silver is cheaper and its nanoparticles<br />
absorb light even more strongly than gold<br />
nanoparticles. However, the composition<br />
of silver is<br />
different, and the<br />
researchers found that<br />
the chemistry of whiskey<br />
wasn't powerful enough to<br />
reduce silver into satisfactory<br />
amounts of nanoparticles. The<br />
color of the whiskey and silver mixture<br />
did change, but it took hours or days for<br />
the reaction to become visible, so Peveler's<br />
team stuck with gold. And surprisingly,<br />
34 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Chemistry<br />
FEATURE<br />
BY ANAVI UPPAL<br />
ART BY NOORA SAID<br />
STANDARD<br />
t h e gold they used wasn't that<br />
expensive: the amount<br />
of gold needed for each<br />
whiskey test is much less<br />
than one cent.<br />
In their research lab,<br />
Peveler and his team used<br />
a spectral photometer<br />
worth thousands of<br />
dollars to analyze the<br />
exact colors of these<br />
whiskey mixtures.<br />
This instrument<br />
looks at light on<br />
a wavelengthby-wavelength<br />
basis to see<br />
how much of<br />
each color<br />
the whiskey<br />
absorbs.<br />
H o w e v e r,<br />
i t ' s<br />
possible<br />
to create a much cheaper version of this<br />
device that whiskey distillers could use to<br />
quickly and inexpensively test their own<br />
samples in-house. This device would use a<br />
diffraction grating, a clear piece of plastic<br />
or glass that spreads out white light into<br />
the rainbow of colors that it is composed<br />
of. By shining a light through the whiskey<br />
mixture and looking at it through a<br />
diffraction grating, you can tell which<br />
specific colors of light are being absorbed<br />
or reflected by the whiskey, revealing its<br />
age. Such a setup could be strapped to a<br />
smartphone camera and would only cost<br />
tens of dollars to make.<br />
In future studies, the researchers hope<br />
to use gold nanoparticles to measure more<br />
than just the age of whiskey. "What we<br />
saw tantalizing hints of in the paper but<br />
couldn't necessarily pin down in the time<br />
frame that we were working with was that<br />
sometimes we measured a whiskey, and<br />
it gave a really different colored particle,<br />
or it was a much bigger particle, or a<br />
different shape," Peveler said. "Sometimes<br />
we saw spheres. Sometimes we saw a sort<br />
of triangle plate-like thing. Sometimes<br />
we saw rods or a star-type shape. My<br />
hypothesis is that that is linked to the<br />
different chemistry that is coming out of<br />
the wood." Ideally, the gold nanoparticles<br />
would not only allow whiskey distillers to<br />
determine how much flavor has infused<br />
the whiskey but also identify the specific<br />
flavors. For example, they might be able<br />
to correlate certain particle shapes or<br />
colors with buttery flavors or with smoky<br />
undertones. "That's going to be a key<br />
challenge going forward," Peveler said.<br />
Through chemistry, it's becoming<br />
possible to dissect the flavors we encounter<br />
in our daily lives. "I'm fascinated by this<br />
kind of stuff: how we taste, how we smell,<br />
how we perceive flavor, and things like<br />
that," Peveler said. Peveler has previously<br />
done similar sensing research that goes<br />
even beyond food and beverages, such as<br />
detecting explosives in wastewater and<br />
sensing liver disease in blood. But as a big<br />
whiskey fan—and a researcher based in<br />
Scotland, which is famous worldwide for<br />
its whiskey—he has particularly enjoyed<br />
working with it for this project. "It's<br />
whiskey! It's fun, right?" ■<br />
USING GOLD<br />
NANOPARTICLES<br />
TO REVEAL THE<br />
AGE OF WHISKEY<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 35
UNDERGRADUATE PROFILE<br />
ERIC SUN<br />
YC ’23<br />
BY CINDY KUANG<br />
Eric Sun (MY ’23) is a lot of things: aspiring physician-scientist,<br />
cancer biology researcher, competitive yo-yo player, longdistance<br />
runner, and most recently—a 2022 Barry Goldwater<br />
Scholar. Double majoring in Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry<br />
(MB&B) and Statistics & Data Science (S&DS), Eric dedicates his time<br />
outside the classroom to researching and understanding cancer drug<br />
resistance, with previous work in epigenetics and DNA damage.<br />
Growing up in northern Virginia, Eric was always excited by<br />
the proximity of the National Institute of Health in Maryland:<br />
“You see experiments in the textbook, and you’re like – how do<br />
you actually do that?” Eric said.<br />
At sixteen years old, Eric cold-emailed NIH principal investigators<br />
hoping for a summer laboratory experience and ultimately joined<br />
Philipp Oberdoerffer and Mirit Aladjem’s labs, where he spent the<br />
next two years. There, he studied the<br />
epigenetics<br />
behind the DNA damage response,<br />
primarily<br />
how different types and<br />
modifications of histones<br />
(which are what DNA<br />
wraps around in the cell’s<br />
nucleus) could dictate or<br />
inform the environment<br />
in which DNA repair<br />
processes occur.<br />
He continued<br />
pursuing this<br />
interest in<br />
epigenetics at Yale,<br />
where he joined<br />
Andrew Xiao’s lab<br />
in the fall of 2019<br />
as a first-year. “I felt<br />
that the projects that<br />
were ongoing were really<br />
fascinating,<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF SOPHIA LI VIA ERIC SUN<br />
and there was great mentorship<br />
from the MD/<br />
PhD students in the lab that have helped me tremendously<br />
through the last couple years, especially navigating the pathway<br />
of applying for an MD/PhD,” Eric said.<br />
Despite initial setbacks due to COVID-19, Eric’s work on<br />
cancer drug resistance—specifically targeted therapies in the<br />
context of lung adenocarcinoma—has made great progress. He<br />
focuses on epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) mutant lung<br />
adenocarcinoma, a subclass of non-small cell lung cancers, and<br />
how these cancers ultimately develop resistance against therapies<br />
that are initially greatly effective.<br />
Currently, in the clinic, patients with EGFR mutant lung<br />
adenocarcinoma are treated with specific targeted therapies called<br />
tyrosine kinase inhibitors, one of which—Osimertinib—is used as a<br />
first-line treatment for EGFR mutant lung adenocarcinoma patients,<br />
and is the focus of Eric’s research. These patients are sensitive to<br />
these targeted therapies because these inhibitors bind to mutated<br />
EGFR but not wild-type EGFR, effectively only targeting and killing<br />
the cancer cells and not wild-type healthy cells.<br />
“The problem is, patients often develop resistance in just a<br />
matter of months,” Eric said. “In the clinical setting, we see<br />
tumors initially regress but then expand again and metastasize<br />
further, so understanding why tumors become resistant has been<br />
a major question in the field.”<br />
Eric’s project particularly questions how oncogene amplification<br />
is involved in resistance, notably how two copies of an oncogene<br />
can amplify to fifty copies or even one-hundred copies and how<br />
the cell can then exploit that upregulation to develop therapeutic<br />
resistance. Through mining sequencing data, including rich clinical<br />
trial data from the National Cancer Institute, as well as hands-on<br />
imaging, genomics, and assay work at the bench in different cell<br />
line models, Eric has studied the acquisition of resistance through<br />
various approaches. “We have a lot of data from<br />
various aspects, from patient data to cell line<br />
models, suggesting a common mechanism<br />
of oncogene amplification that drives<br />
Osimertinib resistance,” Eric said.<br />
Eric reflected on the Barry Goldwater<br />
Scholarship and how the award has<br />
influenced him as a researcher. “I take<br />
pride in that it’s an affirmation that<br />
I’m doing the right things,” Eric said.<br />
“Really, I’ve been mentored really<br />
well, and it’s a testament to the faculty<br />
and the professors that I’ve been able<br />
to get to know at Yale who really<br />
supported me both in the classroom<br />
and in my research.”<br />
After graduation, Eric plans to pursue an<br />
MD/PhD, stating that though he really enjoys<br />
research, he also really loves spending time in the<br />
clinic to see how his research interfaces with clinical issues.<br />
“I don’t think science lives in a vacuum; you don’t do science just<br />
for science. You see patients, you see what their challenges are,<br />
you see patients fail treatment with a drug or develop resistance,<br />
and then you go back to the bench and ask: now how do you<br />
understand this?” Eric said.<br />
Regarding advice for aspiring researchers, Eric stressed a confident<br />
mentality. “Just don’t be afraid in general. Reach out to people, screw<br />
up an experiment, those are small things in the grand scheme of<br />
everything. If you’re afraid, you aren’t even going to try,” Eric said.<br />
Without a doubt, Eric’s passion and enthusiasm for science and<br />
medicine will not just better the research community but will also<br />
continue to inspire everyone around him for years to come. ■<br />
36 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
ALUMNI PROFILE<br />
JONATHAN ROTHBERG<br />
GSAS ’91<br />
BY SOPHIA BURICK<br />
J<br />
onathan Rothberg GSAS’ 91, the pioneer of nextgeneration<br />
DNA sequencing, has always had a scientific<br />
bent and entrepreneurial spirit. His father, a chemical<br />
engineer, built his own company and turned the basement of<br />
their family home into a laboratory. Conversations around the<br />
dinner table often revolved around business.<br />
After earning his bachelor’s in Chemical Engineering from Carnegie<br />
Mellon University in 1985, Rothberg arrived at Yale to complete a PhD<br />
in Biology. In the lab of Yale professor emeritus Spyros Artavanis-<br />
Tsakonas, he investigated the molecular basis of nervous system wiring.<br />
While still a student at Yale, Rothberg founded his first company,<br />
Curagen. Curagen was one of the first movers in the genomics industry<br />
in the 1990s. They invented a new field dubbed global proteomics,<br />
which entails identifying and analyzing all the proteins in a sample.<br />
“We were the first ones to map out all the protein interactions in a yeast<br />
cell, which got featured on the cover of Nature,” Rothberg said.<br />
When his son had difficulties breathing after birth, Rothberg was<br />
frustrated that genome sequencing technology was not fast enough to<br />
provide him with genetic answers regarding his son’s condition.<br />
While in the hospital, Rothberg saw<br />
an InfoWeek magazine cover<br />
featuring the new Pentium<br />
semiconductor chip. In<br />
that moment, inspiration<br />
struck. He could<br />
apply the concept of<br />
transistors—which are<br />
used in circuits in large<br />
quantities to switch<br />
or amplify electrical<br />
signals in a massively<br />
parallel way—to DNA<br />
sequencing. “I could<br />
interrogate a sequence of<br />
bases, but this time, instead<br />
of doing it in one test tube, I<br />
could do it thousands of times or<br />
millions of times in parallel,” Rothberg<br />
said. While still working at Curagen, Rothberg<br />
founded his second company, 454 Life Sciences, to develop this<br />
revolutionary technology. Rothberg’s method became known as<br />
next-generation sequencing and is still used today.<br />
Shockingly, Rothberg was fired by the boards of Curagen and 454<br />
for this idea. The company’s board believed the completion of the<br />
Human Genome Project had rendered the technology obsolete and<br />
sold 454 Life Sciences for 140 million dollars.<br />
Still convinced that next-generation DNA sequencing was the<br />
future, Rothberg founded Ion Torrent. This time, he would have to<br />
do something different. Instead of just using the general concept<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF ALEX DONG VIA JONATHAN ROTHBERG<br />
of massively parallel analysis derived from transistors on a chip—<br />
sequencing the DNA at many different spots simultaneously—<br />
Rothberg approached the issue more directly, creating a<br />
semiconductor chip that could<br />
directly sequence DNA in<br />
a massively parallel way.<br />
Out of this idea came<br />
the Ion Torrent chip: a<br />
semiconductor chip<br />
capable of sensing the<br />
chemistry of DNA<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF ALEX DONG VIA JONATHAN ROTHBERG<br />
synthesis through<br />
pH changes, allowing<br />
the user to rapidly<br />
sequence DNA. “We<br />
were really on a great<br />
path to a thousand dollars<br />
genome by just going to newer<br />
factories or foundries and making<br />
denser chips,” Rothberg said.<br />
Rothberg sold Ion Torrent to Life Technologies for 725 million<br />
dollars—five times the amount 454 Life Sciences was sold for.<br />
Ironically, almost exactly ten years after he was fired for the<br />
idea, President Barack Obama awarded Rothberg a National<br />
Medal of Technology and Innovation for his work on nextgeneration<br />
sequencing.<br />
After Ion Torrent, Rothberg wanted to transition to<br />
parallel entrepreneurship—helping several different<br />
startups develop at once. To do this, he launched a startup<br />
accelerator called 4Catalyzer. Rothberg has three key<br />
criteria that startups under 4Catalyzer must meet: each<br />
startup must solve a problem that affects the life of someone<br />
they love, use artificial intelligence, and take advantage of<br />
semiconductors or the concept of large-scale integration<br />
behind semiconductors. One of 4Catalyzer’s startups, Detect,<br />
played a major role in the COVID-19 pandemic. Detect’s mission<br />
was to develop an at-home COVID test with sensitivity comparable to a<br />
PCR test. The test they developed was sometimes demonstrated to be ten<br />
thousand times more sensitive than the at-home alternative of antigen<br />
tests. Now, Detect is applying their technology to other ailments. “It will<br />
be for universal testing, and they’ll do STIs, COVID, and flu. They’ve<br />
raised about 160 million dollars for the company,” Rothberg said.<br />
Many of the companies under 4Catalyzer, like Detect, are headed by<br />
Yale graduates, and Rothberg is always eager to work with the latest<br />
talent coming out of Yale. For Yalies looking to try their hand at scientific<br />
entrepreneurship, Rothberg’s advice is simple. “Find somebody that<br />
compliments you. If you’re good at business, find someone good at<br />
science. I think that raises your probability of success the greatest—just<br />
finding a complement that you can work with,” Rothberg said.■<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 37
EATING TO EXTINCTION<br />
BY DINESH BOJJA<br />
SCIENCE<br />
IN<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
THE WORLD'S RAREST FOODS AND<br />
WHY WE NEED TO SAVE THEM<br />
Every day, our dining halls are filled with countless choices: dozens of<br />
types of pizza, chicken tikka masala and aloo gobi, Cajun fish tacos,<br />
and cheese quesadillas. But if we take these foods back to their base<br />
ingredients, that variety vanishes. In fact, only three plants—rice, wheat, and<br />
maize—account for half of all calories consumed globally. This expanse of<br />
diverse food options masks a dramatic loss in true food biodiversity and the<br />
increased homogenization of agriculture and food production.<br />
In his book Eating to Extinction: The World’s Rarest Foods and Why We<br />
Need to Save Them, Dan Saladino discusses the uniformity of modern food<br />
production, driven by a steep demand for low-cost, high-quantity food<br />
species. For example, half of the world’s cheese is made from bacteria and<br />
enzymes produced by the same company. The same breed of pig controls the<br />
international pork trade. And only one of the 1500 types of bananas dominates<br />
the global market. Saladino attributes this trend—sacrificing variety for<br />
surfeit—to a few concurrent factors: shifts in land usage, the introduction of<br />
chemical fertilizers and pesticides, and a rise in genetic modifications for crops<br />
and livestock alike. Dubbed the “Green Revolution,” this shift in the 1960s<br />
and 1970s was marked by unparalleled crop prosperity and food production,<br />
enough to sustain the world’s growing population. Overall yields of staple<br />
crops skyrocketed, but other wild crops were driven to near extinction.<br />
While there may be more food produced overall, this marks a dangerous<br />
trend. A decline in food biodiversity increases the risk of pests and diseases<br />
disrupting global food security. For example, one fungus, Fusarium<br />
graminearum, has led to billions of dollars of damage by infecting wheat<br />
crops in Europe, Asia, and the Americas. Saladino runs through countless<br />
examples of mass-produced foods overshadowing traditional species, from<br />
Cosmic Crisp and Red Delicious apples overpowering the apple market<br />
to slaughterhouse chickens, eliminating the need for traditional breeds or<br />
historically used but now obsolete species. A loss of diversity comes with a<br />
loss of culture, identity, and history.<br />
It is not too late to reverse the trend, however. From scientific seed repositories<br />
in Norway to government-run food conservation efforts, thousands of different<br />
crops, animals, and fruits have been painstakingly preserved in hopes of future<br />
reintroduction and production. Thankfully, corporations also have recognized<br />
the need for increased food biodiversity, and twenty of the world’s biggest food<br />
businesses have pledged to preserve traditional foods.<br />
But the real hope is in the hands of farmers daring to continue their<br />
tradition, even in the face of agricultural giants. A “chocolate lab” in<br />
Venezuela specializes in producing traditional chocolate made from Criollo<br />
cacao. A village of resilient fishermen holds steadfast to their roots of selling<br />
wild Atlantic salmon. A group of millers on the Orkney Islands work with<br />
agronomists to bring back nutritious Bere barley. Even on the individual<br />
level, every effort is the chance to bring another species back from the brink<br />
of extinction. With a stroke of encouragement and support, the opportunity<br />
to restore food biodiversity is within reach. ■<br />
38 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
ATOMS AND ASHES<br />
A GLOBAL HISTORY OF<br />
NUCLEAR DISASTERS<br />
Ever since scientists first split the atom in 1938, nuclear power has both<br />
fascinated and terrified millions. Today, ten percent of world energy<br />
is supplied by almost 440 nuclear reactors. In the US, closer to twenty<br />
percent of electricity comes from nuclear power. Regarded as a highly efficient,<br />
low-emission energy source, nuclear energy is an attractive option for many<br />
countries seeking to reduce their carbon footprint while meeting population<br />
needs. Yet, nuclear disasters like Chernobyl have shown the risks of working<br />
with radioactive material. Considering the industry’s troubled history raises<br />
the question: Just how safe is nuclear energy?<br />
In his new book Atoms and Ashes: A Global History of Nuclear Disasters, Serhii<br />
Plokhy, Harvard University professor of Ukrainian History, explores the dangers<br />
of nuclear power through six of the worst nuclear disasters: the 1954 Castle<br />
Bravo hydrogen bomb test, the 1957 Kyshtym nuclear waste tank explosion, the<br />
1957 English Windscale reactor fire, the 1979 Three Mile Island partial reactor<br />
meltdown, the 1986 Chernobyl reactor meltdown, and the 2011 Fukushima<br />
disaster.<br />
Plokhy expertly creates a picture of the international nuclear industry. “The<br />
story told here is a global one,” he writes, examining “not only the actions<br />
and omissions of those directly involved but also the ideologies, politics,<br />
and cultures that contributed to the disasters.” For example, the Castle Bravo<br />
accident sets the stage for later chapters by introducing the pressures of the<br />
Cold War, government efforts to cover up disasters, and the inevitability of<br />
human error when dealing with emerging science and technology.<br />
Plokhy complements his well-researched piece with a skillful narration.<br />
Meticulously selected testimonies bring every accident to life, making the<br />
historical events all the more palpable and impactful. Discussing the Fukushima<br />
meltdown, Plokhy anchors his narration around plant superintendent Yoshida.<br />
“Yoshida was sitting behind his desk, [...] when things around him started<br />
shaking. [..] ‘My mind should have been panicking. But strangely, [it] was<br />
telling me to keep calm and start planning,’ recalled Yoshida,” Plokhy writes. In<br />
this manner, Plokhy builds an entertaining, well-informed historical thriller.<br />
Atoms and Ashes shows that science and technology alone cannot cause or<br />
BY XIMENA LEYVA PERALTA<br />
T H E<br />
SPOTLIGHT<br />
prevent nuclear disasters. Many political, social, and cultural factors are involved<br />
in regulating nuclear energy. New international legislation was established through<br />
international cooperation to prevent future nuclear accidents, making it easier to<br />
exchange technology and enforce rigorous standard safety measurements.<br />
Though the impacts of nuclear disasters should not be disregarded, their<br />
rate and severity are lower than accidents in the coal, gas, and hydropower<br />
industries. While not perfect, nuclear fission reactors are the most efficient<br />
zero-emission energy source. As Plokhy recognizes, “the major accidents<br />
involved [...] technologies developed in the 1950s and 1960s, [offering] some<br />
hope that the [industry’s] major errors [are] behind us.” Better policy-making<br />
and increased funding for research and development promise a safer future<br />
for nuclear energy. Moreover, they open the door to a promising, carbonfree,<br />
potentially safer option to power the second half of this century: nuclear<br />
fusion, fusing atoms instead of splitting them apart. ■<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 39
COUNTERPOINT<br />
Life on Mars Was<br />
Its Own Undoing<br />
Has life existed on Mars? If so, how would<br />
it have affected Mars’s climate? There has<br />
been ample research on Earth’s early life<br />
forms and their effect on the planet. Scientists<br />
have been particularly interested in methanogens,<br />
microorganisms that consume hydrogen (H2) and<br />
carbon dioxide (CO2) and generate methane (CH4)<br />
as waste. Both CO2 and CH4 are greenhouse gases,<br />
which trap heat in the atmosphere and lead to<br />
temperature increases, but CH4 retains twenty-five<br />
times more heat than CO2. Therefore, methanogen<br />
metabolism increased global temperature and, as a<br />
result, made Earth habitable to other organisms.<br />
However, a recent study in Nature Astronomy<br />
found that if methanogens ever existed on early<br />
Mars during the Noachian period (about four<br />
billion years ago), they would have had an opposite<br />
cooling effect. This is because early Mars had a<br />
CO2-dominated atmosphere, as opposed to early<br />
Earth’s nitrogen-dominated atmosphere. Collisions<br />
between CO2 and H2 molecules absorb more heat<br />
energy than CO2-CH4 collisions or CH4 alone.<br />
Since the existence of methanogens would have<br />
drastically changed the climate, it is important to<br />
evaluate whether the early Mars environment could<br />
support methanogenic life. The researchers concluded<br />
that Mars’ subsurface environment was probably<br />
favorable to microbial life. Mars’ crust is covered by<br />
regolith, a loose, heterogeneous layer made of dust,<br />
sand, and broken rocks. At that time, regolith may<br />
have sheltered microorganisms from ultraviolet and<br />
cosmic radiation. Simultaneously, brine, highlyconcentrated<br />
salt water, would have filled the porous<br />
layer and provided an aqueous environment.<br />
In addition to an aqueous solution and shelter<br />
from radiation, the land must also have been free<br />
of surface ice to sustain life. Ice-free regions allow<br />
gases to exchange from the atmosphere, which<br />
microorganisms need to survive. Ice coverage<br />
depends on surface temperature and the brine<br />
freezing point. Researchers estimated the surface<br />
temperature on early Mars by modeling H2 and<br />
CH4 concentrations combined with the latitude<br />
By Crystal Liu<br />
ARTIST’S IMPRESSION OF MARS FOUR BILLION YEARS AGO.<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF ESO/M. KORNMESSER.<br />
and elevation of any given geographical area. They<br />
found that before any life forms existed, the average<br />
surface temperature ranged from 216 to 294 K (-57<br />
to 21°C). Brine’s freezing point, however, is largely<br />
unknown. As salt concentration increases, the<br />
solution’s freezing point decreases, which is why<br />
we salt the road before a snowfall to prevent snow<br />
from settling. Brine likely consisted of other ions<br />
besides sodium and chloride, which would also<br />
have altered the freezing point. Estimates of early<br />
Mars brine freezing points from existing literature<br />
range from 203 to 273 K (-70 to 0°C).<br />
Researchers ran three models, estimating the<br />
probability of methanogenic life with brine freezing<br />
points of 203, 252, or 273 K. If brine had a lower freezing<br />
point, more area would be ice-free and habitable. With<br />
a freezing point of 203 K, one hundred percent of Mars’<br />
surface would have been ice-free, whereas simulations at<br />
273 K generated a median of only 0.15 percent ice-free<br />
area. In all three cases, some parts of Mars would have<br />
been habitable to methanogens, typically in lowlands at<br />
low-to-medium latitudes. It is important to note that<br />
this study only shows that early Mars satisfied every<br />
condition for methanogenic life rather than confirming<br />
the existence of life. However, the studies’ findings will<br />
inform the search for traces of life in fossil records.<br />
If methanogens had really existed, their metabolic<br />
activity would have significantly changed Mars’<br />
climate, leading to new equilibrium temperature<br />
and atmospheric composition. The study estimates<br />
a reduction of 33 to 45 K. As a result, the fraction<br />
of ice-free regions would have dropped, and<br />
habitability would have been compromised. Even<br />
in places with no ice coverage, methanogens would<br />
have been forced deeper into the crust, which was<br />
warmer but scarcer in essential gases. Somewhat<br />
counterintuitively, if Mars had a lower brine freezing<br />
point, more methanogens could have existed in the<br />
first place, but they would have induced a larger drop<br />
in temperature and lower habitability at the steady<br />
state. Unlike on Earth, where the first life forms<br />
facilitated the emergence of later organisms, life on<br />
Mars may have been its own undoing. ■<br />
40 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
HIDDEN<br />
HISTORIES<br />
NETTIE STEVENS<br />
BY ANJALI<br />
DHANEKULA<br />
ART BY<br />
MALIA KUO<br />
Nettie Maria Stevens was born on July 7, 1861, in<br />
Cavendish, Vermont, where her family had lived for<br />
several generations. Still feeling the aftereffects of the<br />
Civil War, women in the US generally had few educational and<br />
professional opportunities. However, in part because of her<br />
father’s accumulated wealth, Stevens attended public schools,<br />
eventually graduating from Westford Academy at the age of<br />
nineteen. Stevens was a dedicated student, earning praise from<br />
teachers and peers alike.<br />
After graduation, Stevens became a high school teacher to<br />
save money to continue her education. Later, she attended Bryn<br />
Mawr College and pursued a graduate scholarship in biology.<br />
After just six months at Bryn Mawr, Stevens performed such<br />
brilliant work that she was awarded a fellowship to conduct<br />
research abroad. She studied at the Zoological Station in Naples,<br />
Italy and the Zoological Institute of the University of Würzburg<br />
in Germany. After earning her doctorate at Bryn Mawr, she<br />
continued to teach and research at the college until her death<br />
due to breast cancer in 1912.<br />
Stevens studied morphology, the study of the forms of<br />
living organisms, and cytology, the study of the structure and<br />
function of plant and animal cells. Her research focused on sex<br />
determination, how biological sex and sex characteristics are<br />
determined in organisms. At the time of Stevens’ research, there<br />
were two major schools of thought on sex determination. Some<br />
believed sex was determined by external factors and others<br />
believed that sex was determined at the point of fertilization,<br />
not by the surrounding environment. Over the course of her<br />
research, Stevens noticed that male mealworms produced<br />
sperm with either a large chromosome (now known as the<br />
X chromosome) and sperm with a small chromosome (now<br />
known as the Y chromosome), but female mealworms only<br />
produced eggs with large chromosomes. She concluded that<br />
chromosomes, specifically on the paternal side, are responsible<br />
for sex determination.<br />
Despite Stevens publishing her groundbreaking discoveries, many<br />
credit Edmund Wilson, a geneticist who worked in the same fields<br />
as Stevens, for the finding. While Stevens and Wilson worked on<br />
chromosomal sex determination simultaneously, they arrived at<br />
the conclusion independently. In fact, Thomas Hunt Morgan, a<br />
mentor to Stevens who did not accept the theory of chromosomal<br />
inheritance at the time, is often credited with discovering the genetic<br />
basis for sex discrimination. Morgan even went on to win a Nobel<br />
Prize in 1933 “for his discoveries concerning the role played by the<br />
chromosome in heredity.”<br />
Stevens is not the only female scientist whose contributions to<br />
science were not recognized as her own until long after her death.<br />
Others include Rosalind Franklin, who co-discovered the helical<br />
structure of DNA, and Esther Lederberg, who discovered a virus<br />
that infects E. coli bacteria, a widely used tool in the current study<br />
of genetics. This pattern indicates the Matilda effect: the repeated<br />
dismissal of scientific discoveries made by women in science.<br />
Stevens’ discoveries about sex determination are the basis for many<br />
advancements in research on Turner syndrome and Down syndrome,<br />
as well as developments in the chromosomal basis of heredity.<br />
Although Stevens dedicated much of her life to her education and<br />
research, making crucial contributions to the field of genetics, the<br />
highest position she ever reached was as an associate in experimental<br />
morphology at Bryn Mawr College. Thomas Hunt Morgan described<br />
her as more of a lab technician than a true scientist. Reporters at the<br />
time stressed Wilson’s discovery over Stevens’, even though Stevens<br />
stated her conclusions more explicitly.<br />
Without Stevens’ discoveries, it is impossible to know where<br />
the field of genetics would be today. Yet, like many other female<br />
researchers, her work has been consistently undervalued. There is<br />
limited research available on how to diminish gender bias in scientific<br />
fields. However, by continuing to acknowledge the contributions of<br />
female scientists, we can work to create a world where the Matilda<br />
effect does not exist—a world in which we celebrate Nettie Maria<br />
Stevens for her achievements. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 41
SYNAPSE<br />
Essay Contest Winner<br />
P<br />
LLING TEETH<br />
I<br />
turned sixteen last May, meaning, I<br />
have officially entered the “wisdom<br />
teeth removal” era of my life.<br />
According to my last dentist visit, I have<br />
3 lovely molars waiting for me in a couple<br />
of years' time. That got me thinking, why<br />
do we even have wisdom teeth?<br />
Retired now, wisdom teeth’s original<br />
function was to grind down hearty, rough<br />
food. According to Herman Pontzer,<br />
an evolutionary anthropologist at Duke<br />
University, the myth of the prehistoric<br />
diet consisting mostly of meat isn’t true.<br />
Instead, early humans ate what they could<br />
forage from their environment, which<br />
heavily varied depending on location,<br />
season, and climate. In an article for<br />
National Geographic, Leslie Aiello,<br />
president of the Wenner-Gren Foundation<br />
for Anthropological Research in New<br />
York City says this, “What bothers a lot of<br />
paleoanthropologists is that we actually<br />
didn’t have just one caveman diet, The<br />
human diet goes back at least two million<br />
years. We had a lot of cavemen out there.”<br />
Even so, all paleoanthropologists seem<br />
to agree on one thing; The diet of early<br />
human beings was coarse and rough.<br />
Enter, the adaptation to have a third<br />
set of molars. Wisdom teeth grew in with<br />
the function to provide more chewing<br />
power. Now, with softer foods and the<br />
inventions of cutlery, wisdom teeth are<br />
obsolete. If anything, they are quite a<br />
literal source of irritation. This is due to<br />
human jaws becoming much smaller over<br />
time. Without the extra space, wisdom<br />
teeth become blocked by surrounding<br />
teeth. This can result in bone and<br />
jaw disruption, as well as damage to<br />
neighboring teeth. To avoid these side<br />
effects, many young adults undergo a<br />
42 Yale Scientific Magazine December 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Essay Contest Winner<br />
SYNAPSE<br />
ART BY MALIA KUO<br />
procedure to have<br />
them removed. Annually, Americans<br />
remove around 10 million wisdom teeth.<br />
This adaptation, while useful at the time,<br />
has been outgrown for thousands of years.<br />
It goes to show that some solutions work<br />
better in the past and are best left there.<br />
Although optimization isn’t contained to<br />
biological changes, it is in human nature<br />
to find the “better” solution. According<br />
to Applied Psychology: Health and Wellbeing,<br />
“Optimal functioning, which may<br />
be in physical, cognitive, emotional, and/or<br />
social terms, emphasizes the importance of<br />
a person’s inner strength, state of resilience,<br />
virtue, and the maximization in capability”<br />
People most often self-optimize to achieve<br />
self-fulfillment and inner satisfaction.<br />
I share this human need to optimize; I<br />
myself have terrible handwriting.<br />
It started in third grade<br />
when my mom told me<br />
"teachers will take off points<br />
KATE KIM is a junior at James Hillhouse<br />
High School in New Haven,<br />
CT, where she enjoys swimming<br />
for the East Haven/New Haven<br />
girls' swim team and participating<br />
in the student council as class president.<br />
She loves painting, writing,<br />
and opening SAT books (but not<br />
studying in them). Through her<br />
writing, she aims to capture her life<br />
experiences as a recording for her<br />
future self.<br />
Kate Kim is the winner of the 2022<br />
Yale Synapse Essay Contest for<br />
high school students<br />
for messy writing". From then on, I was<br />
living a double life. Picture chicken scratch for<br />
personal notes transcribed into calligraphy<br />
for official assignments. Even now, I have<br />
separate notebooks for in-class notes and<br />
for homework. But like wisdom teeth,<br />
the solution my eight-year-old self came<br />
up with seems to have run its course.<br />
The strategy slows me down. I<br />
have piles of notes waiting for me to<br />
transcribe them, I get lost in lesson material<br />
after rewriting notes from weeks prior and<br />
I'm pretty certain I have acute Tendinitis.<br />
One could argue that my strategy was<br />
never an optimized solution to my issue.<br />
“Why didn’t I just learn to write neater from<br />
the start?” I asked myself while rewriting my<br />
notes. It was then that I realized understand<br />
that optimization comes in stages.<br />
My handwriting solution may have not<br />
been the best solution, but it was one that was<br />
a quick fix to my needs when I was eight. My<br />
issue lay within the fact that I never sought a<br />
better solution, becoming comfortable with<br />
a fix that I outgrew years ago.<br />
Now, I grapple with the consequences:<br />
Deciphering the scrawl of my handwriting,<br />
late nights revising pages upon pages of<br />
work, and practicing neat handwriting in<br />
the limited free time a high school junior<br />
has. Maybe it's time I do my own operation<br />
and remove the problem at its root. ■<br />
Nuclear Propulsion Officer Candidate<br />
Launch your career before you<br />
finish college – enter the Nuclear<br />
Propulsion Officer Candidate<br />
(NUPOC) Program. Future Nuclear<br />
Officers in the NUPOC program<br />
may earn up to $168,000.<br />
Benefits include:<br />
• Fully funded undergraduate<br />
college courses offered aboard<br />
all Navy ships<br />
• Comprehensive medical and<br />
dental care<br />
• 30 days of vacation with pay<br />
earned each year<br />
SCAN THE QR CODE &<br />
START YOUR JOURNEY<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
December 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 43
Interested in getting involved with<br />
Yale Scientific<br />
for writing, production, web,<br />
business or outreach?<br />
Learn more at<br />
yalescientific.org/get-involved<br />
AD_YALE_SC_ENG_Half_winter_2023.qxp_8 1/31/23 7:55 AM Page 1<br />
YSEA Wants You!<br />
The Yale Science and Engineering Association is<br />
where students and alumni connect to...<br />
• Connect with STEM luminaries from around the world through the YSEA Speaker Series<br />
• Support top-notch undergraduate research through the YSEA grants program<br />
• Provide meaningful STEM experiences to high school students at science fairs and<br />
robotics competitions around the world<br />
• Salute the achievements of distinguished Yalies with prestigious YSEA Awards<br />
• Foster STEM journalism by sponsoring Yale Scientific Magazine and Yale Undergraduate<br />
Research Journal<br />
• Have fun at networking events, speaker receptions, and other activities<br />
BE PART OF ENGAGING AND IGNITING THE YALE STEM COMMUNITY.<br />
Join us at: ysea.org<br />
Photo courtesy of Yale’s Graduate Society of Women Engineers