26.01.2024 Views

Angelus News | January 26, 2024 | Vol. 9 No. 2

On the cover: High school student Atticus Maldonado smiles between classes at St. Pius X-St. Matthias Academy in Downey. On Page 10, Angelus contributor Steve Lowery has the incredible story of how Maldonado’s school community rallied behind him in prayer — and why his unlikely recovery from a rare cancer may not even be the story’s biggest miracle.

On the cover: High school student Atticus Maldonado smiles between classes at St. Pius X-St. Matthias Academy in Downey. On Page 10, Angelus contributor Steve Lowery has the incredible story of how Maldonado’s school community rallied behind him in prayer — and why his unlikely recovery from a rare cancer may not even be the story’s biggest miracle.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ANGELUS<br />

FIGHTING<br />

CHANCE<br />

How his school’s<br />

‘prayer force’<br />

took on cancer —<br />

and won<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> <strong>Vol</strong>. 9 <strong>No</strong>. 2


<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong><br />

<strong>Vol</strong>. 9 • <strong>No</strong>. 2<br />

3424 Wilshire Blvd.,<br />

Los Angeles, CA 90010-2241<br />

(213) 637-7360 • FAX (213) 637-6360<br />

Published by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese<br />

of Los Angeles by The Tidings<br />

(a corporation), established 1895.<br />

ANGELUS<br />

Publisher<br />

ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />

Vice Chancellor for Communications<br />

DAVID SCOTT<br />

Editor-in-Chief<br />

PABLO KAY<br />

pkay@angelusnews.com<br />

Associate Editor<br />

MIKE CISNEROS<br />

Multimedia Editor<br />

TAMARA LONG-GARCÍA<br />

Production Artist<br />

ARACELI CHAVEZ<br />

Photo Editor<br />

VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

Managing Editor<br />

RICHARD G. BEEMER<br />

Assistant Editor<br />

HANNAH SWENSON<br />

Advertising Manager<br />

JIM GARCIA<br />

jagarcia@angelusnews.com<br />

ANGELUS is published biweekly by The<br />

Tidings (a corporation), established 1895.<br />

Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles,<br />

California. One-year subscriptions (<strong>26</strong><br />

issues), $30.00; single copies, $3.00<br />

© 2021 ANGELUS (2473-<strong>26</strong>99). <strong>No</strong> part of this<br />

publication may be reproduced without the written<br />

permission of the publisher. Events and products<br />

advertised in ANGELUS do not carry the implicit<br />

endorsement of The Tidings Corporation or the<br />

Archdiocese of Los Angeles.<br />

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to:<br />

ANGELUS, PO Box 306, Congers, NY 10920-0306.<br />

For Subscription and Delivery information, please<br />

call (844) 245-6630 (Mon - Fri, 7 am-4 pm PT).<br />

FOLLOW US<br />

facebook.com/<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />

info@angelusnews.com<br />

<strong>Angelus</strong> <strong>News</strong><br />

@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />

@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />

angelusnews.com lacatholics.org<br />

ON THE COVER<br />

VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

High school student Atticus Maldonado smiles<br />

between classes at St. Pius X-St. Matthias Academy<br />

in Downey. On Page 10, <strong>Angelus</strong> contributor Steve<br />

Lowery has the incredible story of how Maldonado’s<br />

school community rallied behind him in prayer — and<br />

why his unlikely recovery from a rare cancer may not<br />

even be the story’s biggest miracle.<br />

THIS PAGE<br />

VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

The St. Charles Choir performed a free concert at St.<br />

Charles Borromeo Church in <strong>No</strong>rth Hollywood on Jan.<br />

14 with a musical prayer for peace in the Holy Land.<br />

The choir was originally scheduled to perform in the<br />

Holy Land during its pilgrimage, but the Hamas’ attack<br />

on Israel on Oct. 7 canceled the trip.<br />

Sign up for our free, daily e-newsletter<br />

Always Forward - newsletter.angelusnews.com


CONTENTS<br />

Pope Watch............................................... 2<br />

Archbishop Gomez................................. 3<br />

World, Nation, and Local <strong>News</strong>...... 4-6<br />

In Other Words........................................ 7<br />

Father Rolheiser....................................... 8<br />

Scott Hahn.............................................. 32<br />

Events Calendar..................................... 33<br />

14<br />

16<br />

18<br />

20<br />

24<br />

<strong>26</strong><br />

28<br />

30<br />

After visiting Auschwitz, LA teacher brings her experience back to students<br />

Here are some <strong>2024</strong> California laws that Catholics should know about<br />

Imprisoned Nicaraguan bishop is freed, along with other jailed priests<br />

Infertility isn’t a Catholic problem. But are there Catholic answers?<br />

Charlie Camosy: What’s behind the ‘deplorable’ tragedy of surrogacy<br />

Robert Brennan asks: Am I the only one who doesn’t have a podcast?<br />

‘Poor Things’: Award season favorite mistakes provocative for interesting<br />

Heather King: LA Natural History Museum’s ‘100 Carats’ exhibit is a jewel<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 1


POPE WATCH<br />

Hoping hell is empty<br />

While a pope can resign, Pope<br />

Francis said it is not something he is<br />

thinking about or worrying about now.<br />

“It is neither a thought, nor a worry,<br />

nor even a desire; it is a possibility,<br />

open to all popes. But for the moment<br />

it is not at the center of my thoughts,<br />

my worries, my feelings,” he said in an<br />

interview on Italian television Jan. 14.<br />

“As long as I feel I still have the capacity<br />

to serve, I will go on,” the 87-yearold<br />

pope said. “When I can no longer<br />

do it, it will be time to think about it.”<br />

Francis made the comments in an<br />

interview lasting more than 50 minutes<br />

on the program “Che Tempo Che Fa”<br />

on Italy’s <strong>No</strong>ve channel.<br />

He also said that “in August I have<br />

to make a trip to Polynesia” and that<br />

sometime after that, he hopes to go to<br />

Argentina for the first time since his<br />

election in 2013.<br />

Francis was asked how he imagines<br />

hell if he really believes God forgives<br />

everyone who asks.<br />

“It’s difficult to imagine it,” the pope<br />

said. “What I would say is not a dogma<br />

of faith, but my personal thought: I like<br />

to think hell is empty; I hope it is.”<br />

The pontiff was also asked about his<br />

approval of Fiducia Supplicans (“Supplicating<br />

Trust”), the Dicastery for the<br />

Doctrine of the Faith’s declaration that<br />

a priest can offer informal blessings<br />

to gay couples as long as it is clear the<br />

Church is not equating their union to<br />

marriage.<br />

“The Lord blesses everyone who is<br />

capable of being baptized, that is, every<br />

person,” said Francis. “But then people<br />

must enter into conversation with the<br />

Lord’s blessing and see what path the<br />

Lord is proposing for them.”<br />

The pastoral work of the Church, he<br />

said, is to “take them by the hand and<br />

help them to go down that road, not<br />

condemn them from the start.”<br />

“I always tell confessors: Forgive<br />

everything and treat people as kindly<br />

as the Lord treats us. And then if you<br />

want to help people, you can talk and<br />

help them move on, but forgive everyone,”<br />

he said.<br />

Fabio Fazio, the program’s host, asked<br />

the pope about the phrase in the classic<br />

Act of Contrition: “I detest all my sins<br />

because of thy just punishments.”<br />

“Sin deserves punishment,” the<br />

pope said. But he said he believes<br />

the “literary expression” in the classic<br />

version of the prayer “is too harsh given<br />

God’s love. I prefer to say, ‘Because by<br />

sinning I have saddened your heart.’ ”<br />

Francis said that in his 54 years of<br />

priesthood, he’s only denied forgiveness<br />

in confession once, because of the<br />

person’s “hypocrisy.”<br />

“I’ve always forgiven everything even<br />

when I knew the person could fall<br />

again, but the Lord forgives us. He<br />

helps us not to fall or to fall less, but he<br />

always forgives.”<br />

Asked what worries him, Francis<br />

responded that “some things do scare<br />

me. Some things frighten me. For example,<br />

this escalation of war frightens<br />

me.”<br />

With nuclear weapons stockpiled, he<br />

said, one wonders “how will we end<br />

up, like <strong>No</strong>ah’s ark? That scares me,<br />

the capacity for self-destruction that<br />

humanity has today.”<br />

Reporting courtesy of Catholic <strong>News</strong><br />

Service Rome bureau chief Cindy<br />

Wooden.<br />

Papal Prayer Intention for <strong>January</strong>: We pray that the Holy<br />

Spirit may help us to recognize the gift of different charisms<br />

within the Christian community and to discover the richness<br />

of different traditions and rituals in the Catholic Church.<br />

2 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


NEW WORLD OF FAITH<br />

ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />

OneLife LA — 10 years on<br />

Ten years ago, we founded<br />

OneLife LA with the hope of<br />

starting a new conversation and<br />

encouraging a new way of thinking<br />

about the right to life and the cause of<br />

human dignity in our city and in our<br />

nation.<br />

At that time, Roe v. Wade was the<br />

law of the land. The lives of millions<br />

of unborn children were being taken<br />

in the womb each year as the result of<br />

that 1973 U.S. Supreme Court ruling,<br />

which claimed to find a “right” to<br />

abortion in the federal constitution.<br />

Catholics and other concerned<br />

citizens had long taken to gathering<br />

on Jan. 22, the anniversary of Roe v.<br />

Wade, to peacefully march for an end<br />

to abortion and advocate for public<br />

policies that support women, children,<br />

and families.<br />

The pro-life movement is one of the<br />

most diverse and significant initiatives<br />

for nonviolent social change and civil<br />

rights in our nation’s history, and it<br />

is a coalition of conscience rooted in<br />

the prayers and sacrifices of countless<br />

ordinary Americans from every race<br />

and walk of life.<br />

Our aim with OneLife LA is to help<br />

support and broaden this movement<br />

by raising awareness of the beauty and<br />

dignity of every human life, from conception<br />

to natural death. We also want<br />

to recommit ourselves, as Catholics, to<br />

our duty to work for the beautiful Gospel<br />

vision of a culture of life and love.<br />

The Church has always defended the<br />

unborn child’s right to life, since the<br />

first century.<br />

We still believe that abortion is a<br />

grave evil and social injustice, because<br />

it attacks life itself and targets the<br />

weakest, most defenseless members of<br />

our community. We also believe, as the<br />

popes teach, that the right to life is the<br />

foundation of every other human right.<br />

Sadly, even beyond abortion, we see<br />

everywhere in our society the spreading<br />

of an anti-human spirit, a disregard<br />

for the sacredness of human life.<br />

In many ways, our society is forgetting<br />

the beautiful vision of Jesus and the<br />

Church.<br />

Jesus brought into the world a profound,<br />

radically new idea about the<br />

human person.<br />

He taught that everyone is created for<br />

a reason by the Father, who from before<br />

the world’s foundation knows us and<br />

loves us and has a plan and purpose for<br />

our lives.<br />

Every person, from the moment of<br />

conception, is created in God’s own<br />

image to be his own beloved son or<br />

daughter.<br />

Jesus told us that we are so precious<br />

that every hair on our head is numbered,<br />

and that God gives every child an<br />

angel in heaven, to guard and guide<br />

that child.<br />

And to show us how much we are<br />

loved, Jesus offered his own life on the<br />

cross for the redemption of all men<br />

and women, again, without exceptions.<br />

Even secular historians recognize that<br />

these Christian truths marked a “revolution”<br />

in human thought and shaped<br />

the foundation of Western civilization,<br />

changing how we think about women,<br />

children, the family, the poor, and<br />

more.<br />

These truths are the basis of our<br />

country’s founding belief that all men<br />

and women are created equal, with<br />

God-given rights and freedoms, and<br />

that the purpose of government is to<br />

safeguard these rights and freedoms.<br />

OneLife LA is about proclaiming<br />

these truths and restoring this vision of<br />

the human person in our society.<br />

America has changed in these past 10<br />

years. Thanks be to God, Roe v. Wade<br />

has been overturned.<br />

But abortion remains widespread and<br />

threats to unborn life have multiplied<br />

— through embryo research, “surrogate”<br />

motherhood, and a host of new<br />

“reproductive” technologies.<br />

We still face the challenge of building<br />

a society and economy that supports<br />

marriages and families, where every<br />

woman has the help she needs to bring<br />

her child into this world in love.<br />

More than that, we need to keep<br />

working for a society where no one is a<br />

stranger and there is no life that is not<br />

worth living, no life that can be left<br />

behind or thrown away.<br />

That means resisting the growing<br />

pressures for assisted suicide and<br />

insisting that the elderly and disabled<br />

be cared for with true compassion, as<br />

children of God.<br />

That means serving the homeless<br />

and the mentally ill, the immigrant,<br />

and the prisoner. It means confronting<br />

racial and economic injustices, and the<br />

crises of drugs, family breakdown, and<br />

human trafficking.<br />

We need to keep working for a society where no<br />

life can be left behind or thrown away.<br />

Ten years on, OneLife LA continues<br />

to be a dream worth living for. It is the<br />

dream of the world as God intends it<br />

to be.<br />

Pray for me and I will pray for you.<br />

And let us ask our holy Mary, the<br />

mother of life, to help us to build a<br />

world where every life is precious and<br />

sacred, where every person is treated<br />

as a child of God, and where we love<br />

every person as Jesus loves us.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 3


WORLD<br />

■ Lebanon: Bishops warn of larger war ‘time bomb’<br />

As Israel’s campaign against Hamas in Gaza continues, Lebanon’s Maronite Catholic<br />

bishops are sounding the alarm about the risk of a larger war in the region.<br />

National and international authorities must “take serious steps and adopt the<br />

necessary diplomatic and political measures to free Lebanon from this burden that<br />

weighs on its demography, its economy, and its balance,” wrote the bishops in a<br />

nine-point statement Jan. 3.<br />

The bishops focused primarily on conflicts along the Israel-Lebanese border, exacerbated<br />

by Israel’s ongoing war with Hamas, citing casualties and injuries in the<br />

region. They called on Israel to announce “a final ceasefire,” and for negotiations<br />

for a two-state solution in its ongoing war with Hamas in the Gaza Strip.<br />

The bishops also warned about a yet-unfelt threat from Syrian refugees in the<br />

country.<br />

“The searches carried out by the military and security forces have shown that the<br />

displaced people are in possession of ammunition and sophisticated weapons,”<br />

the statement said. “This is a time bomb that poses a real threat to the Lebanese<br />

people.”<br />

A nation’s hunger — People displaced by fighting between the Syrian Democratic Forces and Islamic State<br />

militants are pictured in a file photo carrying boxes of food aid given by the United Nations World Food Program<br />

at a refugee camp in Ain Issa. The U.N. said it would end its main food assistance program in <strong>January</strong> across<br />

war-torn Syria, where more than 12 million people lack regular access to sufficient food. | OSV NEWS/ERIK DE<br />

CASTRO, REUTERS<br />

■ African bishops say no<br />

to new blessing rules, with<br />

Rome’s thumbs up<br />

The bishops of Africa announced they<br />

would not permit blessings for homosexual<br />

couples within the continent, in<br />

response to the Dec. 18 Vatican declaration<br />

allowing priests to bless couples<br />

in irregular marriages.<br />

Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo of the<br />

Democratic Republic of Congo, president<br />

of the Symposium of Episcopal<br />

Conferences of Africa and Madagascar,<br />

issued a Jan. 11 letter which described<br />

itself as a synthesis of all the African<br />

bishops’ opinions.<br />

He said that, while the bishops “have<br />

strongly reaffirmed their communion<br />

with Pope Francis,” they believe<br />

enabling the blessings proposed by<br />

the Vatican “cannot be carried out in<br />

Africa without exposing themselves to<br />

scandals.”<br />

“The African Bishops’ Conferences<br />

emphasize that people with homosexual<br />

tendencies must be treated with<br />

respect and dignity, while reminding<br />

them that unions of persons of the<br />

same-sex are contrary to the will of<br />

God and therefore cannot receive the<br />

blessing of the Church,” the letter read.<br />

Ambongo told Catholic <strong>News</strong> Agency<br />

that the letter “received the agreement”<br />

of Pope Francis and Cardinal Victor<br />

Manuel Fernández, prefect of the Dicastery<br />

for the Doctrine of the Faith.<br />

■ Knights to help renovate<br />

Rome’s most famous canopy<br />

After almost 400 years, the famous 100-foot-tall canopy<br />

standing over the main altar of St. Peter’s will be getting<br />

some much-needed repairs.<br />

Known as a baldachin, Baroque master Gian Lorenzo<br />

Bernini’s 17th-century masterpiece will be covered in scaffolding<br />

for an estimated 10 months.<br />

The project is estimated to cost 700,000 euros ($766,000)<br />

and will be entirely funded by the Knights of Columbus,<br />

which has funded 17 other Vatican restoration projects.<br />

“We’re in union with the Holy See, with the successor of<br />

St. Peter, and so these kinds of projects are very much in<br />

keeping with who we are and our mission,” Patrick Kelly,<br />

supreme knight, told Catholic <strong>News</strong> Service.<br />

Bernini’s baldacchino in St. Peter’s Basilica. | CNS/LOLO GOMEZ<br />

4 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


NATION<br />

■ White House to gut conscience protection rules<br />

The Biden administration announced plans to reverse a 2019 rule that would<br />

have enforced conscience protections for certain health care providers.<br />

The old Trump-era rule, which never took effect due to lawsuits, would have<br />

stripped federal funding from facilities that required workers to provide any service<br />

they objected to, such as abortions, contraception, gender-affirming care, and<br />

sterilization.<br />

The new Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) rules are scheduled<br />

to go into effect March 11. The HHS said the old rules sometimes undermined<br />

“the balance Congress struck between safeguarding conscience rights and protecting<br />

access to health care.”<br />

Andrea Picciotti-Bayer, director of the Conscience Project, told Catholic <strong>News</strong><br />

Agency that the change doesn’t change legal protections for health care workers<br />

with conscience, but makes them harder to enforce.<br />

“[The White House] is incapable of erasing those rights,” she said. “But it looks<br />

like they’re going to do all in their power to make people think that they don’t have<br />

them.”<br />

Martin Scorcese in the 2021 PBS show “The Oratorio:<br />

A Documentary with Martin Scorsese.” | PBS<br />

■ Scorsese sets his<br />

sights on Jesus (again)<br />

Martin Scorsese said he wants to get<br />

rid of the stigma around organized<br />

religion — so he’s making an 80-minute<br />

film about Jesus.<br />

“Right now, ‘religion,’ you say that<br />

word and everyone is up in arms<br />

because it’s failed in so many ways,”<br />

Scorsese told the Los Angeles Times.<br />

“But that doesn’t mean necessarily<br />

that the initial impulse was wrong.<br />

Let’s get back. Let’s just think about it.<br />

You may reject it. But it might make a<br />

difference in how you live your life.”<br />

The director said he has finished a<br />

screenplay, set mainly in the present<br />

day, with writing collaborator Kent<br />

Jones based on “A Life of Jesus” by<br />

novelist Shusaku Endo. This will be<br />

Scorsese’s second adaptation of an<br />

Endo book, following the 2016 film<br />

“Silence.”<br />

Scorsese directed the 1988 film “The<br />

Last Temptation of Christ,” which was<br />

heavily criticized by Catholics at the<br />

time for its depiction of Christ and<br />

rated “morally offensive” by the U.S.<br />

Conference of Catholic Bishops<br />

Scorsese cited meeting with Pope<br />

Francis in 2023 as the inspiration for<br />

the film, which is set to be shot this<br />

year.<br />

■ Illinois teen’s fundraiser to save<br />

Catholic school has unlikely success<br />

A Catholic grade school in Ingleside, Illinois, was brought back from the brink of<br />

insolvency thanks to one high-school-aged alumna.<br />

Susan Lutzke, a 17-year-old who attended St. Bede School as a child, learned<br />

last December that the school was facing closure due, in part, to decreased state<br />

funding. The next morning, she started a GoFundMe campaign.<br />

By Jan. 13, the campaign had raised $380,000 of the $400,000 needed to close the<br />

budget gap.<br />

“It’s pretty crazy. I don’t think I ever really expected it to get where it is,” Lutzke said.<br />

As of press time, neither the school nor the Archdiocese of Chicago had made any<br />

definitive statement about St. Bede’s fate.<br />

Opening a new chapter — Boston Cardinal Seán P. O’Malley greets Carlos Metola, postulator for the sainthood<br />

cause for Servant of God Carmen Hernández, co-initiator of the Neocatechumenal Way, at a Jan. 7 event in<br />

Boston to officially introduce the English translation of a book of Hernández’s diaries. Hernández’s sainthood<br />

cause was opened officially in December 2022. Metola confirmed that a medical committee is studying two<br />

reported medical “favors” attributed to Hernandez’s intercession that have occurred in the U.S. since her death in<br />

2016. | OSV NEWS/GREGORY L. TRACY, THE PILOT<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 5


LOCAL<br />

Walking for change — The Sisters of St. Joseph of Carondelet were among many other religious sisters, supporters,<br />

and advocates who participated at the <strong>2024</strong> LA Walk for Freedom to End Human Trafficking on Jan. 13.<br />

Blessed Sacrament Church in Hollywood hosted the event and was the starting location for the two-mile walk. |<br />

SISTERS OF ST JOSEPH OF CARONDELET<br />

■ Are you ready? LA Congress lineup announced<br />

A local filmmaker will headline the <strong>2024</strong> Los Angeles Religious Education Congress<br />

in Anaheim, set for Feb. 15-18.<br />

Congress keynote speaker Jessica Sarowitz is the founder of Miraflores Films and<br />

executive producer of the 2023 documentary, “With This Light,” on the life of<br />

Maria Rosa Leggol.<br />

This year’s workshop speaker lineup also includes Cardinal Robert McElroy,<br />

who will speak about the Synod on Synodality, <strong>Angelus</strong> contributor John L. Allen<br />

Jr., Archbishop Joseph Nguyen of Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam, Auxiliary Bishop José<br />

Arturo Cepeda of Detroit, and Victims Assistance Ministry Coordinator Heather<br />

Banis for the Archdiocese of LA.<br />

Youth Day on Feb. 15 will include a workshop on “Gaming, God, & the Heroic<br />

Life” and another titled “Awkward: When Following God Gets Uncomfortable.”<br />

Get more information and register at recongress.org.<br />

■ Abbots in Orange<br />

County launch Catholic<br />

fundraising firm<br />

St. Michael’s Abbey in Orange<br />

County has launched a consulting<br />

and fundraising firm to help Catholic<br />

institutions make progress on their<br />

projects.<br />

The firm, the Abbey Group, will<br />

help religious organizations, educational<br />

institutions, and leaders with<br />

“ambitious apostolic endeavors and<br />

strong leadership but are in need of<br />

the financial and temporal resources<br />

to accomplish their objectives,”<br />

Gregory Clark, the strategic planning<br />

director of the Abbey Group, told<br />

Catholic <strong>News</strong> Agency.<br />

The idea for the firm came after the<br />

abbey’s success in raising more than<br />

$150 million for a capital campaign to<br />

build a new monastery.<br />

The Abbey Group doesn’t market its<br />

services but instead relies on word-ofmouth<br />

to allow for effectively vetting<br />

of the organizations and projects it<br />

pursues. The group said they take on<br />

only four projects at a time.<br />

“It is an authentically Catholic<br />

approach to fundraising — one that<br />

is desperately needed in our Church<br />

during this moment in her history,”<br />

said R. Shane Giblin, CEO and<br />

co-founder of the Abbey Group.<br />

Y<br />

■ USC Catholic students attend SEEK Conference in St. Louis<br />

USC students and local seminarians were<br />

among the thousands at the <strong>2024</strong> SEEK Conference<br />

in St. Louis, Missouri, this month.<br />

Organized by FOCUS (Fellowship of Catholic<br />

University Students), SEEK featured guest<br />

speakers, daily prayer, Eucharistic adoration,<br />

workshops, and live music, plus additional<br />

ways to evangelize, including seminary formation,<br />

missionary opportunities, and volunteer<br />

work.<br />

Guest speakers at the Jan. 1-5 conference<br />

included Father Mike Schmitz, the host of the<br />

popular podcast “The Bible in a Year,” Tim<br />

Glemkowski, CEO of the National Eucharistic<br />

Revival, and Sister Mary Grace, SV.<br />

Next year’s event will be Jan. 1-5 in Salt Lake<br />

City, Utah.<br />

USC students from the Caruso Catholic Center with women religious at<br />

this year’s SEEK conference. | USC CARUSO CATHOLIC CENTER<br />

6 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


V<br />

IN OTHER WORDS...<br />

Letters to the Editor<br />

After Fiducia Supplicans, nothing may be the same<br />

In his article “Explaining to do” in the Jan. 12 issue, John L. Allen Jr.<br />

takes a cautious approach in explaining why Fiducia Supplicans may<br />

be less consequential than media reaction to it might seem. I disagree with this<br />

assessment.<br />

As Allen himself notes, the fact that the prefect of the Dicastery of the Doctrine<br />

of the Faith had to “clarify” that this document was not “heretical” or “blasphemous”<br />

is unprecedented, and is a clear sign that we have entered a new era in<br />

the Church. The Vatican can now issue purposely ambiguous declarations on<br />

doctrinal matters, issue multiple “clarifications” in the media, and get away with<br />

it. This would have been unthinkable just a few years ago.<br />

I still don’t know if Fiducia Supplicans is meant to lay the groundwork for<br />

changes to doctrine in the future, or if it’s Pope Francis’ way of trying to keep the<br />

Church together in a difficult time. But let’s not pretend the debate over same-sex<br />

blessings will go away quietly in the future.<br />

— James Stance, East Los Angeles<br />

What about the synod?<br />

I found it concerning that the end-of-2023 summary on <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com (by<br />

OSV <strong>News</strong>) did not highlight the global Church synodal process, one of the most<br />

significant Church happenings since the Second Vatican Council.<br />

— Barbara Born<br />

Y<br />

Continue the conversation! To submit a letter to the editor, visit <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/Letters-To-The-Editor<br />

and use our online form or send an email to editorial@angelusnews.com. Please limit to 300 words. Letters<br />

may be edited for style, brevity, and clarity.<br />

Catholicism in color<br />

Amy Rodriguez is a digital artist from Pasadena. Rodriguez spoke with the Archdiocese of Los Angeles on how digital<br />

media can help connect Catholics with God, while not ignoring the in-person relationship with him. Watch Amy’s and<br />

all #LACatholicsStory videos at lacatholics.org/stories. | ADLA<br />

To view this video<br />

and others, visit<br />

<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/photos-videos<br />

Do you have photos or a story from your parish that you’d<br />

like to share? Please send to editorial @angelusnews.com.<br />

“This is John Steinbeck,<br />

‘Grapes of Wrath,’ stuff.”<br />

~ Father Dennis Kriz, pastor of St. Philip Benizi<br />

Church in Fullerton, in a Jan. 11 Orange County<br />

Register article on three Catholic churches starting<br />

a mini-loan program to keep people from going<br />

homeless.<br />

“That is our mission: to<br />

give people a taste of the<br />

Gospel even in secular<br />

landscapes.”<br />

~ Msgr. Georg Austen of the German Catholic<br />

charity group “Bonifatiuswerk,” which supported<br />

the December 2023 opening of the northernmost<br />

Trappist monastery church in the world in <strong>No</strong>rway,<br />

in a Jan. 13 National Catholic Register article.<br />

“What the researchers<br />

need to figure out is where<br />

stupidity is harmful.”<br />

~ Selma Šabanović, Indiana University Bloomington<br />

roboticist, in a Jan. 4 Wired article on designing<br />

robots to help people with dementia.<br />

“It’s not an exaggeration to<br />

say behavior on the road<br />

today is the worst I’ve ever<br />

seen.”<br />

~ Capt. Michael Brown, a state police district<br />

commander in Michigan, in a Jan. 10 New York<br />

Times article on why American drivers are so<br />

deadly.<br />

“Even if I have struggled<br />

with these sins for years,<br />

it is never too late to break<br />

free from them, and even if<br />

I fall, Jesus will keep loving<br />

me through it.”<br />

~ Elizabeth Gedra, a sophomore at Auburn<br />

University, in an interview with “The Pillar” on her<br />

experience at the FOCUS SEEK <strong>2024</strong> conference in<br />

St. Louis this month.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 7


IN EXILE<br />

FATHER RONALD ROLHEISER, OMI<br />

Oblate of Mary Immaculate Father<br />

Ronald Rolheiser is a spiritual<br />

writer; ronrolheiser.com<br />

Piety and humor<br />

Piety is the enemy of humor, at<br />

least whenever something less<br />

than piety is masquerading as<br />

piety. Here’s an example: I once lived<br />

in community with an overly serious<br />

man who, after someone would tell<br />

a colorful joke, would bring us back<br />

to earth with the question, “Would<br />

you tell a joke like that in front of the<br />

Blessed Sacrament?” That not only<br />

deflated the joke and its teller, but it<br />

also took the oxygen out of the room.<br />

There’s a response I would have<br />

liked to have given to his question,<br />

namely, a joke my Oblate novice<br />

master used to tell, one whose irony<br />

exposes false piety. The joke runs<br />

this way: A young woman was getting<br />

married and her family could not<br />

afford a venue for a reception for the<br />

wedding. The parish priest generously<br />

offered them the foyer at the<br />

entrance of the church, telling them<br />

they could bring in a cake and have<br />

a reception there. The father of the<br />

bride asked whether they might also<br />

bring in some liquor. “Absolutely<br />

not,” the priest replied, “you can’t<br />

drink liquor in a church!” “But,” protested<br />

the bride’s father, “Jesus drank<br />

wine at the wedding feast of Cana.”<br />

“But not in front of the Blessed Sacrament!”<br />

replied the priest.<br />

Admittedly, humor can be impious,<br />

crass, offensive, dirty, but whenever<br />

that’s the case the fault normally lies<br />

more in the aesthetics than in the<br />

content of the joke. A joke isn’t offensive<br />

because it is about sex or religion<br />

or any other area we surround with<br />

sacredness.<br />

Humor is offensive when it crosses<br />

a line in terms of respect, taste, and<br />

aesthetics. Humor is offensive when<br />

it is bad art. Bad art crosses a line in<br />

terms of respect, either vis-à-vis its<br />

audience or its subject matter. What<br />

can make a joke offensive or dirty is<br />

when it is told, or how it is told, or to<br />

whom it is told, or the tone in which<br />

it is told, or lack of sensitivity to what<br />

is being told, or the color of the<br />

language as it is being told. Whether<br />

or not it can be told before the<br />

Blessed Sacrament isn’t a criterion.<br />

If a joke shouldn’t be told in front of<br />

the Blessed Sacrament it shouldn’t be<br />

told in front of anyone. There aren’t<br />

two standards of offensiveness.<br />

Still, bad piety is the enemy of<br />

humor. It’s also the enemy of robust,<br />

earthy living. But, that is only the<br />

case for bad piety, not genuine piety.<br />

Genuine piety is one of the fruits<br />

of the Holy Spirit and is a healthy<br />

reverence before all of life. But it’s<br />

a reverence that, while healthily<br />

respectful, is not offended by humor<br />

(even robust, earthy humor) providing<br />

the humor isn’t aesthetically<br />

offensive — akin to nudity, which<br />

can be healthy in art but offensive in<br />

pornography.<br />

False sensitivity that masks itself<br />

as piety also strips all spirituality of<br />

humor, save for the most pious kind.<br />

In doing that, in effect, it makes Jesus,<br />

Mary, and the saints humorless,<br />

and thus less than fully human and<br />

healthy. One of our mentors at our<br />

Oblate novitiate told us young novices<br />

that there is not a single incident<br />

reported in Scripture of Jesus ever<br />

laughing. He told us this to dampen<br />

our natural, youthful, rambunctious<br />

energy, as if this was somehow a<br />

hindrance to being religious.<br />

Humorous energy is not a hindrance<br />

to being religious. To the<br />

contrary. Jesus is the paragon of all<br />

that is healthily human, and he, no<br />

doubt, was a fully healthy, robust,<br />

delightful human person, and none<br />

of those words (healthy, robust,<br />

delightful) would apply to him if he<br />

hadn’t had a healthy, indeed earthy,<br />

sense of humor.<br />

For 15 years I taught a course<br />

entitled The Theology of God to<br />

seminarians and others preparing<br />

for ministry. I would try to cover all<br />

the required bases asked for in the<br />

curriculum — biblical revelation,<br />

patristic insights, normative Church<br />

teachings, and speculative views from<br />

contemporary theologians. But, inside<br />

all of this, like a recurring theme<br />

in an opera, I would tell the students<br />

this: In all your preaching and teaching<br />

and pastoral practices, whatever<br />

else, try not to make God look stupid.<br />

Try not to make God look unintelligent,<br />

tribal, petty, rigid, nationalistic,<br />

angry, or fearful.<br />

Every homily, every theological<br />

teaching, every ecclesial practice,<br />

and every pastoral practice ultimately<br />

reflects an image of God whether<br />

we want it to or not. And if there is<br />

something less than healthy in our<br />

preaching or pastoral practices, the<br />

God who underwrites it will also<br />

appear as unhealthy. A healthy God<br />

does not undergird an unhealthy theology,<br />

ecclesiology, or anthropology.<br />

Hence, if we teach a Jesus who is<br />

humorless, who takes offense at the<br />

earthiness of life, who is uncomfortable<br />

hearing the word sex, who<br />

flinches at colorful language, and<br />

who is afraid to smile and chuckle at<br />

irony, wit, and humor, we make Jesus<br />

appear as rigid and uptight, a prude,<br />

and not the person you want to be<br />

beside at table.<br />

8 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


THE MIRACLE ON<br />

GARDENDALE STREET<br />

A year ago, Atticus Maldonado was facing stage 4 cancer and low odds<br />

of survival. Then his school community’s ‘prayer force’ stepped in.<br />

BY STEVE LOWERY<br />

Atticus Maldonado with St. Pius X-St. Matthias Academy<br />

president Christian De Larkin (left) and school principal Claudia<br />

Rodarte during his first week back at school this month<br />

since his cancer diagnosis. | VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

10 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Miracles are nice but, truth be<br />

told, all Atticus Maldonado<br />

really wanted for Christmas<br />

was to be just another kid.<br />

Though it’s wonderful to know he’s<br />

been on so many people’s minds —<br />

and in their prayers — now all he wants<br />

is to blend back into the St. Pius X-St.<br />

Matthias Academy (PMA) community<br />

that helped to sustain him and his<br />

family for more than a year.<br />

“I’m good with not being in the<br />

spotlight,” he said. “I’d like to be just a<br />

regular student again.”<br />

In December 2022, Maldonado was<br />

diagnosed with rhabdomyosarcoma, a<br />

rare and unusually aggressive form of<br />

cancer of the soft tissue.<br />

What was more, and worse, doctors<br />

told him that he was at stage 4 of the<br />

disease, a stage with about a 20% rate of<br />

survival.<br />

The news of his illness spread quickly<br />

through the tightknit community of St.<br />

Pius X-St. Matthias in Downey. Masses<br />

were offered for his health. Friends<br />

made visits. Gifts were given. And an<br />

unknowable amount of time was spent<br />

thinking about him, his family, and<br />

what their struggle meant for the rest<br />

of us.<br />

In that time, he went from the sweet<br />

kid who loved baseball, Hot Wheels,<br />

and being an altar server, to a young<br />

man a whole lot of people were praying<br />

for, rooting for, and shedding tears for.<br />

His fight was theirs now.<br />

“There were moments when I was so<br />

angry about why this happened to my<br />

child, that I couldn’t pray,” his mother<br />

Evelyn Ochoa said. “And when I<br />

couldn’t pray for my own child, they<br />

did. This tribe that came together for<br />

us. I birthed him but, through that<br />

time, he was ours.”<br />

Anna Granados, in many ways the<br />

leader of that tribe, said that whenever<br />

the prayer group she helped found<br />

would turn their attention to Maldonado,<br />

“he became everybody’s kid.”<br />

Fitting since, before his diagnosis,<br />

Maldonado was as typical a Catholic<br />

kid as one could imagine — save for an<br />

exceptionally developed level of faith.<br />

Evelyn admitted her son’s faith has<br />

“always been greater than mine,” and<br />

said that when informed of his cancer<br />

diagnosis “it felt like my whole world<br />

came tumbling down. All I had was<br />

questions, no answers. You know, why?<br />

Why my kid? He’s such a good kid.”<br />

And yet, moments after the diagnosis,<br />

she looked at her son to find him<br />

smiling, seemingly as unconcerned as<br />

if he’d just been diagnosed with a cold.<br />

Confused, she asked him how he was<br />

feeling to which he replied, “OK. God<br />

loves me.”<br />

Around the same time, Granados had<br />

helped start the Parents in Prayer group<br />

Maldonado works during<br />

class. | VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

at PMA, having felt a calling from the<br />

Blessed Virgin Mary to do so.<br />

“These times are hard for kids, for<br />

our families,” she said. “The rosary is a<br />

weapon for these times. Our youth is<br />

going through so much and we felt the<br />

need to help out, especially because we<br />

are so close here.”<br />

With a student population that hovers<br />

around 500, PMA is the kind of place<br />

where students know not just one<br />

another, but one another’s families,<br />

too. Many arrive in packs from local<br />

parishes and have known one another<br />

since they were young children. <strong>No</strong>t<br />

only is Maldonado friends with Anna’s<br />

kids, but her husband, Jaime, coached<br />

him in sports at a local park.<br />

The prayer group would always dedicate<br />

the first mystery of the rosary to<br />

Maldonado. Anna, whose own mother<br />

was battling cancer, was always there,<br />

rain or shine, along with about 17 core<br />

members of the group. Sometimes<br />

they were joined by Evelyn, who found<br />

herself both strengthened and overwhelmed<br />

by the group’s devotion to her<br />

son and family.<br />

“Many of these women were just<br />

people I’d said hello to and now they<br />

had become a force, a prayer force,”<br />

she said. “Praying for my son like it was<br />

their son.”<br />

<strong>No</strong>ne of which surprised PMA’s president,<br />

Christian De Larkin. Along with<br />

Parents in Prayer, a student campaign<br />

to send Maldonado direct messages got<br />

underway so that he knew he had not<br />

been forgotten. When it was mentioned<br />

how much he missed baseball, he was<br />

invited to sit in the dugout during a<br />

PMA game. When it was discovered<br />

that he was a serious collector of Hot<br />

Wheel cars, Christine Godoy, part of<br />

the prayer force and whose daughter<br />

Eva is a classmate of Maldonado,<br />

mentioned that her husband actually<br />

worked for Hot Wheels.<br />

“So he put together this really cool<br />

collection of limited edition cars and<br />

we took it over to Atticus and when he<br />

saw what it was he almost burst into<br />

tears,” De Larkin said. “This is what<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 11


Maldonado with his mother, Evelyn<br />

Ochoa, and school chaplain Father<br />

Sam Ward at a special school Mass<br />

last September for Childhood Cancer<br />

Awareness Month. | SEMAJ SANDERS<br />

you sign up for in Catholic education.<br />

“You show how much you love each<br />

other, the whole person, including<br />

the spiritual, in tough times and good.<br />

That’s what this wonderful group of<br />

people did, created all these moments<br />

of grace as Atticus went through this<br />

crazy time.”<br />

And during that crazy time, Atticus<br />

remained pretty much Atticus. Evelyn<br />

described him cracking jokes throughout<br />

the process, “making me laugh<br />

while he’s vomiting from the chemo,”<br />

her son sustained by a faith she said she<br />

wishes she could “bottle and drink from<br />

every day.”<br />

His faith was such that he believed<br />

he could not only survive but serve<br />

through his illness. He volunteered to<br />

be part of a rhabdomyosarcoma study.<br />

Though his mom thought he had<br />

enough to worry about just getting better,<br />

the kid who wanted to be an altar<br />

server since he was 7, and had more<br />

recently taken to training younger servers<br />

at his home parish of St. Gertrude<br />

Church in Bell Gardens, said he was<br />

just following a divine plan for him.<br />

“I felt maybe this was a sign from<br />

God, a way I could help others so<br />

that another kid wouldn’t have to go<br />

through what I did,” he said. “This can<br />

help a kid from experiencing the same<br />

speed bump I did, maybe save another<br />

kid’s life.”<br />

Evelyn showed up at the PMA Christmas<br />

Tree Lighting ceremony Dec. 1,<br />

2023, to share the news that her son<br />

was now cancer-free and was now in<br />

the maintenance phase of treatment,<br />

which will continue for another six<br />

months. She thanked all those who<br />

did everything they could to make that<br />

happen. Some people started calling it<br />

the Miracle on Gardendale Street, the<br />

street the school is located on.<br />

Maldonado, of course, was just happy<br />

it meant that he could go back to<br />

school. He did so for the first time in<br />

a long while on Jan. 8, as PMA went<br />

back after Christmas break. He said he<br />

was a little nervous about being able to<br />

keep up with school and homework,<br />

but by the end of the day felt like he<br />

was back in the flow of things.<br />

“He arrived in uniform wearing a<br />

beanie to cover his head and joined us<br />

for our morning assembly,” De Larkin<br />

said. “There he sat among his peers in<br />

the junior section of the<br />

gym and began his first<br />

day of school as a normal<br />

student. It was a beautiful<br />

sight to see.”<br />

Maldonado agreed it was<br />

nice. He said he thought<br />

there might be a lot of<br />

questions from classmates<br />

about what he’d gone<br />

through, but none ever<br />

came.<br />

“<strong>No</strong> one really asked me.<br />

It was pretty good to not<br />

talk about it.”<br />

So perhaps he can find his way back<br />

to normal sooner than later, though<br />

always with a faith his mother calls “out<br />

of this world,” a faith that combines the<br />

innocence of a child with the strength<br />

of a survivor.<br />

“I guess I just feel like if something<br />

bad happens, I’m going to get through<br />

it,” he said. “It’s just a speed bump. Me<br />

and God, I feel like we have a pretty<br />

good connection.”<br />

Steve Lowery is a veteran journalist<br />

who has written for the Los Angeles<br />

Times, the Los Angeles Daily <strong>News</strong>,<br />

the Press-Telegram, New Times LA, the<br />

District, Long Beach Post, and the OC<br />

Weekly.<br />

Maldonado with friends at St. Pius X-St. Matthias Academy earlier this month. | VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />

12 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Andi ium endam fuga. Nemperiora<br />

qui aceptas pellitatatur alit<br />

eatet eumquis cipiet pos mo<br />

omnim rem. Xero tem invendantio<br />

estium ut officto modipsanis ex elit,<br />

omnimusda aciatur, conecabo. Bor as<br />

ercium re debitis nate erit abo. Nemperfero<br />

blaborum eres siminci andicit<br />

landenimolut optatus minciti aerata<br />

non et harchitatium int in res eum<br />

fuga. Itature pror acepe volest aliciet<br />

optatatecto to magniet expelibus sit<br />

estiorumquid quunt aborupti sum,<br />

volorepudi cori tempori tatur, omnis<br />

sunt volent.<br />

Lorehenihit, que nem re, ipsaepr<br />

atibus voluptat a ped que dit as sunt ea<br />

quam fugiam apient facipsae iureium,<br />

namusam, experspel id quam alisci<br />

occum quos aut etus, to maioriatemo<br />

Credit<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 13


ABSORBING AUSCHWITZ<br />

After seeing the Holocaust site close-up, an<br />

LA-area Catholic school teacher is bringing her<br />

experience back to students.<br />

Michelle Herrera poses outside of<br />

the Polin Museum of the History of<br />

Polish Jews in Warsaw, Poland, during<br />

a trip as part of the Auschwitz Legacy<br />

Fellowship. | MICHELLE HERRERA<br />

BY NATALIE ROMANO<br />

Catholic school teacher Michelle<br />

Herrera never had a<br />

Jewish friend, never stepped<br />

inside a Jewish synagogue, and never<br />

learned much about the Jewish faith.<br />

But after noticing a rise in antisemitism<br />

in recent years, Herrera thought<br />

it was time to better inform herself<br />

and her students. So she joined the<br />

Auschwitz Legacy Fellowship, a<br />

unique program that gives American<br />

teachers academic-focused tours of<br />

the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial<br />

and Museum in Poland. Herrera knew<br />

seeing the concentration and extermination<br />

camps was going to be difficult,<br />

but it was tougher than expected.<br />

“That first night I prayed the most,”<br />

she said. “I wasn’t ready for the emotions<br />

that came up … nothing can<br />

prepare you for it.”<br />

The Auschwitz Legacy Fellowship<br />

is a yearlong intensive education on<br />

the Holocaust, antisemitism, and<br />

Auschwitz-Birkenau, the network of<br />

Nazi-run camps where more than<br />

1 million people, mostly Jews, were<br />

murdered. The Auschwitz-Birkenau<br />

Memorial Foundation (ABMF)<br />

launched the initiative in 2022 so<br />

younger generations would be taught<br />

not only the history of the Holocaust<br />

but its social relevance today.<br />

This year, the ABMF, with partners<br />

like Holocaust Museum LA, invited<br />

teachers from California to apply to<br />

the fully funded program. It includes<br />

in-person and online classes as well as<br />

a weeklong tour of historical sites in<br />

Poland. Herrera, who teaches theology<br />

at Ramona Convent Secondary<br />

School in Alhambra, was one of 20<br />

educators chosen from Southern California<br />

and the only Catholic school<br />

teacher.<br />

“I felt a certain responsibility with<br />

that,” Herrera said. “I thought about<br />

what this history teaches us about<br />

14 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


our faith and how do we enter the<br />

conversation.<br />

“I wanted to receive what I was there<br />

for.”<br />

Herrera visited Poland in 2016 for<br />

World Youth Day, but the mood of<br />

this trip was quite different. As soon<br />

as she arrived at Auschwitz-Birkenau,<br />

she felt a “heaviness” in the air. Rain<br />

and gray skies added to the gloominess.<br />

The fellows, accompanied by<br />

representatives like Sarah Klein from<br />

Holocaust Museum LA, toured prisoner<br />

barracks and what remains of the<br />

deadly gas chambers. Herrera had no<br />

words for the latter except to say she is<br />

now a “witness” to atrocity.<br />

Especially chilling, she said, were the<br />

exhibits of personal items seized from<br />

prisoners — including shoes, eyeglasses,<br />

and even a collection of hair that<br />

had been removed to curb the spread<br />

of lice.<br />

“Seeing the amount of hair that was<br />

shaved off people’s heads — that alone<br />

got me,” said Herrera. “I just had to<br />

walk out alone under my umbrella.<br />

I just needed a moment to gather<br />

myself.”<br />

Although nothing could erase those<br />

cruelties from her mind, Herrera<br />

said she found solace in the courage<br />

shown by prisoners like St. Maximilian<br />

Kolbe. In 1941, the Catholic priest<br />

was arrested for hiding Jews from the<br />

Nazis, and while serving his sentence<br />

in Auschwitz-Birkenau, he willingly<br />

accepted another prisoner’s death sentence<br />

so that man could live. Decades<br />

later, Polish-born St. Pope John Paul II<br />

placed a paschal candle in St. Kolbe’s<br />

prison cell.<br />

“That was cool to get to see with my<br />

own eyes,” Herrera said. “I didn’t know<br />

the candle was still there. I think I<br />

needed that in the midst of so much<br />

darkness and intensity.”<br />

The Montebello native said even<br />

though the experience was deeply<br />

emotional, she never forgot why she<br />

was there: her students.<br />

“My teacher hat was definitely on,”<br />

Herrera said. “I took notes, tried to put<br />

it all together for myself, and think<br />

about how I’m going to teach this.”<br />

After the tour, Auschwitz Legacy<br />

Fellows were given school lesson plans<br />

on how to explain the Nazis’ brutality<br />

and the antisemitism that led to it.<br />

Herrera takes on those difficult topics<br />

in her theology classes and allows her<br />

students to weigh in.<br />

“That’s what stuck out to me, how<br />

things evolve over time,” said Iana Anikalumibao,<br />

a sophomore at Ramona.<br />

“(Bias) doesn’t just drop out of the sky.<br />

We should be spreading peace instead<br />

of blind hate.”<br />

Herrera also shares with her students<br />

how imprisoned Jews secretly drew<br />

pictures, wrote poems, and documented<br />

what was happening to them. The<br />

students say hearing those accounts<br />

made the Holocaust more real.<br />

“You could really connect with their<br />

stories,” said Madelyn Macias, a sophomore<br />

at Ramona. “It wasn’t just numbers<br />

you would read in a textbook. You<br />

could tell they were real people.”<br />

Herrera, a product of Catholic<br />

schools herself, has been teaching for<br />

about five years at Ramona, an all-girls<br />

high school sponsored by the Sisters<br />

of the Holy Names of Jesus and Mary.<br />

She’s also the campus minister.<br />

Ramona officials say by participating<br />

in the Auschwitz Legacy Fellowship,<br />

Herrera is opening her students’ eyes,<br />

and others’ too.<br />

“Michelle is very committed to what<br />

she’s doing here, particularly in the<br />

theology department,” said Sister<br />

Kathleen Callaway, SNJM, president<br />

of Ramona. “She took the initiative to<br />

do this, to enrich her experience as a<br />

teacher. I also hope some of the other<br />

participants were enriched by having<br />

her Catholic perspective.”<br />

Herrera and others involved with<br />

the Auschwitz Legacy Fellowship<br />

are closely following<br />

the ongoing conflict<br />

between Israel and<br />

Hamas militants in<br />

Gaza.<br />

The Oct. 7 attack on<br />

Israel and the retaliatory<br />

strikes in Gaza<br />

have given rise to hate<br />

crimes in the United<br />

States with both Jews<br />

and Muslims being<br />

targeted. Klein noted<br />

the current crisis and<br />

its fallout are exactly<br />

why the fellowship<br />

program exists.<br />

“I want to make it<br />

clear that hatred for American Jews is<br />

never OK and blaming them for the<br />

activity of the Israeli government is an<br />

old anti-Jewish trope,” said Klein, senior<br />

manager of museum education at<br />

Holocaust Museum LA. “The Jewish<br />

people persevere, not only persevere<br />

but thrive. A lot of that, I think, comes<br />

from remembering who we are, our<br />

past, and then using that to create a<br />

better future so we can live in peace<br />

and safety.”<br />

As an Auschwitz Legacy Fellow and a<br />

Catholic, Herrera feels called to help<br />

with that effort.<br />

“I feel a change and a transition from<br />

the experience,” Herrera said. “As<br />

people of faith, we are called to be<br />

witnesses, allies, and advocates when<br />

we see hate rising, especially with<br />

our Jewish brothers and sisters with<br />

whom we share a common spiritual<br />

heritage.”<br />

Herrera also wants to empower her<br />

students to act as “bridge builders”<br />

who can change the world for the<br />

better.<br />

“I feel called to invest into this next<br />

generation of faith leaders and particularly<br />

here at Ramona, young female<br />

faith leaders,” said Herrera. “I really<br />

love my students.”<br />

Natalie Romano is a freelance writer<br />

for <strong>Angelus</strong> and the Inland Catholic<br />

Byte, the news website of the Diocese of<br />

San Bernardino.<br />

Madelyn Macias, left, and Iana Anikalumibao are both<br />

sophomores at Ramona Convent Secondary School<br />

in Alhambra, where Michelle Herrera is helping teach<br />

her students about the Holocaust and antisemitism. |<br />

VERONICA FERNANDEZ<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 15


The California State Capitol<br />

building. | SHUTTERSTOCK<br />

LETTERS OF THE LAW<br />

Many new California laws for <strong>2024</strong> will leave Catholics<br />

in the state either satisfied or concerned.<br />

BY ANGELUS STAFF<br />

With <strong>2024</strong> underway, several<br />

new California laws have<br />

taken effect — or will soon<br />

— that would be of interest to Catholic<br />

residents in the state and beyond.<br />

Here are just some of the hundreds<br />

of laws being put into action in <strong>2024</strong>.<br />

Read or search for all bills at leginfo.<br />

legislature.ca.gov.<br />

ABORTION<br />

Several bills related to abortion were<br />

signed into law by California Gov.<br />

Gavin <strong>News</strong>om. Said <strong>News</strong>om: “The<br />

right to an abortion is enshrined in<br />

California’s Constitution. We will<br />

continue to protect women and health<br />

care workers who are seeking and<br />

providing basic care.”<br />

SB 345: Crafted by state Democrat<br />

Sen. Nancy Skinner, this law would<br />

protect health care professionals who<br />

perform or provide abortions and<br />

gender-affirming care in California<br />

from punishment by states where these<br />

procedures are illegal. The bill would<br />

also safeguard any out-of-state patients<br />

who came to California to receive this<br />

care.<br />

AB 352: The bill would require<br />

companies and institutions that<br />

manage electronic health records from<br />

protecting, separating, and shielding a<br />

patient’s data as it relates to abortion,<br />

contraceptives, and gender-affirming<br />

care. The bill, authored by state<br />

Democrat Assemblywoman Rebecca<br />

Bauer-Kahan, would also prohibit<br />

healthcare providers from releasing<br />

medical information that would identify<br />

someone who received those specific<br />

services. Companies need to comply<br />

by July 1.<br />

SB 385: State Senate President Pro<br />

Tem Democrat Toni Atkins generated<br />

this bill that would allow physician<br />

assistants to be trained beyond their<br />

normal instruction to perform certain<br />

abortions without the supervision of a<br />

physician or surgeon. The goal of the<br />

bill is to expand the number of health<br />

care providers who have the ability to<br />

perform abortions.<br />

HEALTH<br />

Several bills increased health care<br />

services and health-related leave for all<br />

California residents, including more<br />

for undocumented immigrants. Said<br />

<strong>News</strong>om: “We’re making it known that<br />

the health and well-being of workers<br />

and their families is of the utmost importance<br />

for California’s future.”<br />

Expanding Medi-Cal to immigrants:<br />

With this new bill, California made<br />

history, becoming the first state in the<br />

U.S. to provide health care coverage<br />

to undocumented immigrants of all<br />

16 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


ages. The state had already provided<br />

coverage to those under <strong>26</strong> years old<br />

and for immigrants over 50. This law<br />

is expected to cost $4 billion annually,<br />

but a new bill has already been<br />

introduced attempting to repeal it. The<br />

move brings California closer to its<br />

goal of providing health care coverage<br />

to all of its residents.<br />

SB 616: California Democrat Sen.<br />

Lena Gonzales initiated this bill that<br />

would guarantee eligible workers in<br />

the state receive at least five days of<br />

paid sick leave. After five days, employers<br />

can control how many more days<br />

the employee could accrue. The new<br />

law increased the minimum number<br />

of sick days from the three that were<br />

approved in 2015. “Too many folks are<br />

still having to choose between skipping<br />

a day’s pay and taking care of themselves<br />

or their family members when<br />

they get sick,” <strong>News</strong>om said.<br />

SB 848: Under this new law, an employee<br />

would be granted up to five days<br />

of leave for a “reproductive loss,” which<br />

includes miscarriages, in vitro fertilization,<br />

or failed adoption or surrogacy.<br />

The bill, sponsored by state Democrat<br />

Sen. Susan Rubio, would apply to both<br />

parents.<br />

HOUSING<br />

SB 4: It’s no secret that California<br />

has continually fallen short in creating<br />

housing for its growing population,<br />

especially affordable housing. Several<br />

bills were passed in the latest legislative<br />

session meant to spur housing construction<br />

by removing some of the red<br />

tape. SB 4, dubbed the “Yes in God’s<br />

Backyard” bill, is one of those laws,<br />

allowing religious institutions, colleges,<br />

and universities to build affordable<br />

housing on their land without having<br />

to go through lengthy rezoning processes<br />

and environmental reviews.<br />

A church, for example, could have<br />

unused land that it could develop for<br />

affordable housing, and would have<br />

the ability to build the project “by<br />

right” — without needing a discretionary<br />

approval process.<br />

The bill does have restrictions on affordable<br />

housing — requiring a 55-year<br />

commitment for rentals and a 45-year<br />

commitment on owned units — and<br />

distance from industrial or refinery<br />

sites.<br />

“The era of saying no to housing is<br />

coming to an end,” said state Democrat<br />

Sen. Scott Wiener, who authored<br />

the bill. “We’ve been planting seeds<br />

for years to get California to a brighter<br />

housing future.”<br />

A pro-abortion rally in downtown<br />

Los Angeles on May 14,<br />

2022. | SHUTTERSTOCK<br />

LGBT<br />

California continues to introduce<br />

policies for those who identify as<br />

“LGBT” that <strong>News</strong>om said “will help<br />

protect vulnerable youth, promote<br />

acceptance, and create more supportive<br />

environments in our schools and<br />

communities.”<br />

AB 5: Dubbed the “Safe and Supportive<br />

Schools Act,” state Democrat<br />

Assemblyman Rick Zbur authored this<br />

bill, which would require the California<br />

Board of Education to develop an<br />

online training curriculum to support<br />

LGBT cultural competency training<br />

for teachers and other certificated<br />

employees, starting with the 2025–<strong>26</strong><br />

school year. At least one hour of<br />

training would be required annually for<br />

teachers of students in grades 7-12.<br />

SB 760: Introduced by state Democrat<br />

Sen. Josh Newman, this law would<br />

require schools to provide at least one<br />

gender-neutral bathroom by July 1,<br />

20<strong>26</strong>. The law applies to all public<br />

and private schools with students in<br />

grades 1-12. The bill does not apply to<br />

transitional kindergarten or kindergarten<br />

classes.<br />

MISCELLANEOUS<br />

SB 2: Controversial, and already challenged<br />

in court, the law would prohibit<br />

someone from carrying a firearm into<br />

specific locations, including places of<br />

worship, schools, and other “sensitive<br />

areas.” The law, authored by state<br />

Democrat Sen. Anthony Portantino,<br />

would also amend several requirements<br />

to allow a person to carry a concealed<br />

firearm. A federal appeals court<br />

had allowed for the law to go into effect<br />

on Jan. 1, but a special appellate panel<br />

blocked it on Jan. 6 until the case can<br />

be heard again in April. Beyond the<br />

law, <strong>News</strong>om has previously called for<br />

the U.S. Constitution to be amended<br />

to include gun safety measures.<br />

AB 645: Introduced by state Democrat<br />

Assembly Members Laura Friedman<br />

and Phil Ting, this bill allows<br />

six California cities — including Los<br />

Angeles, Glendale, and Long Beach<br />

— to install “speed cameras” near<br />

schools or areas where high-velocity<br />

incidents have occurred. Drivers will<br />

receive a warning in the first 60 days of<br />

installing the cameras and then fines<br />

ranging from $50-$500 will be assessed<br />

depending on how far over the speed<br />

limit. The law is a pilot program that<br />

will last until Jan. 1, 2032.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 17


FREE BUT<br />

IN EXILE<br />

In a surprise<br />

development, a<br />

Nicaraguan bishop<br />

and several other<br />

churchmen were<br />

sent to Rome thanks<br />

to some behindthe-scenes<br />

Vatican<br />

diplomacy.<br />

BY DAVID AGREN<br />

MEXICO CITY (OSV <strong>News</strong>)<br />

— Bishop Rolando Álvarez<br />

of Matagalpa was released<br />

from prison after more than 500 days<br />

of detention and sent into exile along<br />

with 18 imprisoned churchmen as the<br />

Nicaraguan government expelled its<br />

most prominent critic, whose presence<br />

behind bars bore witness to the<br />

Sandinista regime’s descent into totalitarianism,<br />

along with its unrelenting<br />

persecution of the Catholic Church.<br />

Vatican <strong>News</strong> confirmed Jan. 14 that<br />

with the exception of one priest who<br />

remained in Venezuela, all released<br />

priests, including Álvarez and Bishop<br />

Isidoro Mora of Siuna, have arrived in<br />

Rome “in the last few hours” and are<br />

“guests of the Holy See.”<br />

Photographs circulated on X,<br />

formerly Twitter, showed the two<br />

freed bishops concelebrating Mass in<br />

Rome and the churchmen meeting<br />

with Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Vatican<br />

secretary of state.<br />

Independent Nicaraguan media<br />

reported Jan. 14 that the churchmen<br />

had departed Nicaragua on a flight for<br />

Rome after the government reached<br />

an agreement with the Vatican for<br />

their release and exile. Auxiliary<br />

Bishop Silvio José Báez of Managua<br />

— who left the country in 2019<br />

— also confirmed the news at his<br />

weekly Mass in Miami, and was visibly<br />

moved.<br />

“This is the power of the people of<br />

God’s prayers,” he said. “The criminal<br />

Sandinista dictatorship of [President]<br />

Daniel Ortega has not been able to<br />

defeat the power of God.”<br />

The Nicaraguan government acknowledged<br />

the churchmen’s release<br />

in a Jan. 14 statement, which “deeply<br />

thanked” Pope Francis and Parolin<br />

“for the very respectful and discreet<br />

coordination carried out to make possible<br />

the Vatican trip of two bishops,<br />

15 priests, and two seminarians.”<br />

The statement continued: “They<br />

have been received by Vatican authorities,<br />

in compliance with agreements of<br />

good faith and goodwill, which seek to<br />

promote understanding and improve<br />

Nicaraguan Bishop Rolando Álvarez of Matagalpa<br />

walks outside a Catholic church in Managua in 2022.<br />

Álvarez, who had been the Nicaraguan government’s<br />

most prominent critic, was flown to Rome along with<br />

18 other imprisoned churchmen on Jan. 14. | OSV<br />

NEWS/MAYNOR VALENZUELA, REUTERS<br />

communication between the Holy See<br />

and Nicaragua, for peace and good.”<br />

The statement struck an unusually<br />

respectful tone — far from the<br />

government’s frequent accusations of<br />

terrorism and coup mongering against<br />

Church leaders, who attempted to<br />

unsuccessfully facilitate a national<br />

dialogue after mass protests erupted<br />

demanding Ortega’s ouster. The Nicaraguan<br />

government also severed relations<br />

with the Vatican and expelled<br />

the nuncio, Archbishop Waldemar<br />

Stanislaw Sommertag, in 2022. The<br />

Vatican subsequently closed its embassy<br />

in March 2023.<br />

“We recognize the chance for direct,<br />

18 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Photos circulated on social media showed Bishop Rolando Álvarez and Bishop Isidoro Mora<br />

celebrating Mass and being greeted by Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin. | X.COM<br />

prudent, and very serious dialogue, a<br />

responsible and careful dialogue,” the<br />

government statement said.<br />

The release of 19 churchmen — including<br />

Mora and more than a dozen<br />

priests detained during a wave of<br />

detentions over the Christmas period<br />

— provoked reactions of joy among<br />

Nicaraguans in exile, along with statements<br />

of defiance.<br />

“ ‘Get up quickly.’ The chains fell<br />

from his wrists,” Báez said on X, quoting<br />

Acts 12:7.<br />

“With great joy, I thank God that my<br />

brother bishops, priests, and seminarians<br />

are out of prison. Justice has<br />

triumphed. The power of the prayer of<br />

God’s people has been displayed.”<br />

Ambassador Brian A. Nichols, assistant<br />

secretary for Western Hemisphere<br />

Affairs in the U.S. Department of<br />

State, said on X that the regime “expelled<br />

19 unjustly detained Catholic<br />

clergy, including Álvarez.”<br />

“We are reassured to see the release<br />

of these religious leaders. All people<br />

have the right to worship at home and<br />

abroad. We continue to call for the<br />

release of all those unjustly detained<br />

and the restoration of the fundamental<br />

freedoms of the Nicaraguan people,”<br />

Nichols emphasized.<br />

Álvarez has become the face of resistance<br />

in Nicaragua, raising his voice<br />

against the increasing intolerance of<br />

the Sandinista regime, which has subdued<br />

the business community, forced<br />

the free press out of the country, and<br />

attempted to control the Catholic<br />

Church.<br />

The bishop spent more than 500 days<br />

in custody after police arrested him in<br />

August 2022 during a pre-dawn raid<br />

on his diocesan curia, where he had<br />

been holed up protesting the seizure<br />

of Catholic media outlets. In February<br />

2023, he was sentenced to <strong>26</strong> years in<br />

prison on charges of conspiracy and<br />

spreading false information — one day<br />

after he refused to leave the country.<br />

Álvarez refused subsequent attempts<br />

at exiling him — as expulsion or refusing<br />

priests reentry to the country after<br />

traveling abroad became a common<br />

tactic.<br />

“The dictatorship feels safer or more<br />

comfortable with religious people<br />

outside the country than inside the<br />

country,” Arturo McFields Yescas, a<br />

former Nicaraguan diplomat in exile,<br />

told OSV <strong>News</strong>.<br />

“When they are inside [the country]<br />

they consider them a threat, a danger,<br />

a counterweight to their official<br />

narrative. And when they are outside,<br />

[the regime] feels that they no longer<br />

have that critical voice, or that voice of<br />

truth, which spoke to the people and<br />

people listened to,” he said.<br />

David Agren writes for OSV <strong>News</strong><br />

from Mexico City.<br />

What’s next?<br />

The release and exile of Bishop Rolando Álvarez and<br />

18 other churchmen from Nicaragua to Rome was<br />

a welcome surprise for those who have been praying<br />

and pleading for his release.<br />

But the news has done little to relax concerns about violations<br />

against religious freedom in the country, and left the<br />

Catholic Church there in a weakened state.<br />

Nicaraguan newspaper La Prensa reported Jan. 15 that<br />

among those exiled by the Ortega government were two<br />

priests from Álvarez’s Diocese of Matagalpa, who had been<br />

kidnapped by police over the Christmas holidays, later<br />

released, and then again detained and taken to Managua’s<br />

airport to be flown away with the other exiles.<br />

“Matagalpa is left without ecclesiastical authorities,”<br />

tweeted Nicaraguan human rights activist Yader Morazan<br />

in response to the news.<br />

The government continues to threaten priests who speak<br />

out publicly against the Ortega regime with arrest or expulsion.<br />

There are still believed to be several Catholic priests<br />

in custody, and an estimated 15% of Nicaragua’s Catholic<br />

clergy are believed to be in exile.<br />

— Pablo Kay<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 19


SHUTTERSTOCK<br />

SEARCHING IN THE DESERT<br />

Infertility isn’t a<br />

Catholic problem. But<br />

as it becomes more<br />

common, a growing<br />

number of couples are<br />

turning to the Church<br />

for help.<br />

BY ELISE URENECK<br />

Cassie Taylor and her husband,<br />

Michael, were married in<br />

2016. She was 27 and in the<br />

midst of a reversion to the faith; her<br />

husband, 31, had discerned out of<br />

religious life because he felt a strong<br />

desire to be a husband and father.<br />

Two years into marriage, Cassie was<br />

diagnosed with ovarian and uterine<br />

cancer and had to undergo a hysterectomy.<br />

“From the time we found out I was<br />

sick to the time of the surgery, it was<br />

only three months,” Cassie remembered.<br />

“We had to come to terms very<br />

quickly with the reality that we were<br />

never going to have our own biological<br />

children.”<br />

Her oncologist proposed getting a<br />

surrogate. Friends asked if she wanted<br />

to freeze her eggs. Cassie wanted to explain<br />

her commitment to the Church’s<br />

position against the use of technology<br />

which separates procreation from<br />

sexual intercourse and endangers<br />

embryonic life, but the pressure to find<br />

any solution was palpable.<br />

“There’s only so much you can do to<br />

defend the faith from the exam table,”<br />

she laughed. Then her tone turned<br />

somber. “At that point, I just wanted a<br />

place to talk about my grief.”<br />

***<br />

“Like every young Catholic couple<br />

… we thought we were going to look at<br />

each other and get pregnant,” Matthew<br />

Marcolini shared in a video reflection<br />

for the Diocese of Arlington, Virginia.<br />

20 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


After months of failed pregnancy tests,<br />

surgery, and the reality of infertility<br />

setting in, his wife, Elizabeth, experienced<br />

a spiritual desolation.<br />

“It’s hard to believe that a God who<br />

loves you wouldn’t want to give his<br />

daughter everything that she’s asking<br />

for,” she confided in a friend.<br />

Matthew struggled watching his wife<br />

suffer such profound disappointment.<br />

The couple thought back to a conversation<br />

they had in marriage prep in<br />

which they both shared they were open<br />

to adoption. “That was a hypothetical<br />

conversation, but a providential one,”<br />

Elizabeth said.<br />

Five years into marriage, after prayers<br />

and pilgrimages in search of peace,<br />

they got a phone call from a friend who<br />

had heard an announcement at daily<br />

Mass: a local woman was two weeks<br />

away from giving birth and looking<br />

for adoptive parents for her child with<br />

medical needs.<br />

Matthew told his wife that someone<br />

had found their baby.<br />

***<br />

Catholic couples like the Taylors<br />

and Marcolinis are used to hearing<br />

about the need to be “open to life” and<br />

forsake personal comfort for having a<br />

larger family than the social ideal.<br />

But a growing number are struggling<br />

with the opposite: not being able to<br />

conceive or bear children at all.<br />

They are part of a statistically significant<br />

number of people across the<br />

world experiencing infertility, broadly<br />

defined as the inability to conceive<br />

after one year of unprotected sex for<br />

women under 35 and six months for<br />

women 35 and older.<br />

According to a report issued by the<br />

World Health Organization, 1 in 6 people<br />

worldwide — between 60 and 80<br />

million couples — experience infertility<br />

during their reproductive years.<br />

In the U.S., 1 in 5 married women between<br />

the ages of 15-49 with no prior<br />

births have difficulty conceiving. Miscarriage<br />

moves that rate up to 1 in 4.<br />

Common causes of infertility include:<br />

Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome, which<br />

impedes ovulation; improper functioning<br />

of the thyroid, pituitary gland, and<br />

hypothalamus; structural abnormalities<br />

or growths in reproductive organs;<br />

endometriosis, in which uterine lining<br />

grows outside of the uterus; poor sperm<br />

quality and count; and sexually transmitted<br />

infections.<br />

Additionally, delayed childbearing<br />

is driving up rates. More women are<br />

waiting until their mid-late 30s and<br />

early 40s to try to conceive.<br />

According to Caroline Gilbert, a certified<br />

nurse practitioner at University<br />

of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Divine<br />

Mercy Women’s Health, “Fertility<br />

drops a little after 30 but takes a nose<br />

dive after 40.”<br />

“I don’t think a lot of women want<br />

to be getting married later, especially<br />

my Catholic female patients,” she said.<br />

“But that’s just the way the world is.”<br />

The default assumption within the<br />

medical community is that individuals<br />

and couples will use artificial means of<br />

procreation — from donor gametes to<br />

IVF to surrogates — to have biologically<br />

related children. Insurance companies<br />

today are more likely to provide<br />

coverage for these services but not for<br />

alternative treatments. And the proliferation<br />

of celebrities using these means<br />

of reproduction is shifting cultural perceptions<br />

about everything from success<br />

rates to moral acceptance.<br />

***<br />

The challenge the Church faces is to<br />

help an increasing number of Catholics,<br />

many who suffer in silence, to<br />

discern God’s plan for their marriage<br />

and pursue avenues to be fruitful that<br />

respect God’s plan for life and love.<br />

Therese Bermpohl, director of the<br />

Office of Family Life for the Diocese<br />

of Arlington, Virginia, said she was<br />

receiving call after call from priests<br />

asking what they could do for couples<br />

in their parishes who felt unseen and<br />

needed support.<br />

“I think as a Church we tend to minimize<br />

the loss and grief associated with<br />

infertility and miscarriage.”<br />

Her office launched Our Fruitful<br />

Love, a website that “provides practical<br />

resources, testimonials, Church teaching,<br />

and a community that stands with<br />

people in their sorrow and grief.”<br />

One of their<br />

most popular<br />

initiatives has<br />

been an annual<br />

novena<br />

concluding on<br />

A doctor is pictured in a<br />

file photo preparing eggs<br />

and sperm for an attempt<br />

at artificial insemination. |<br />

OSV NEWS/ALESSANDRO<br />

BIANCHI, REUTERS<br />

the feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe.<br />

Bishop Michael Burbidge, who leads<br />

the diocese, offers a private Mass for<br />

participants at its conclusion.<br />

While she encourages participants to<br />

pray for miracles, she’s always moved<br />

when people let her know it helped<br />

them come to “complete peace” about<br />

God’s plan for their marriage.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 21


Bermpohl established a mentorship<br />

program which pairs up more experienced<br />

couples with those new to<br />

grief, expectation, and disappointment.<br />

“Community is key,” she said.<br />

Chris O’Neill, director of the Office<br />

of Marriage and Family Life for the<br />

Diocese of New Orleans, said his team<br />

tries to address infertility in marriage<br />

preparation.<br />

“We try to emphasize how a child is a<br />

gift,” he said. “We share with couples<br />

that you love each other and attend<br />

to a life that you share together, and<br />

that life starts to bear fruit. It may<br />

or may not include children. The<br />

commitment is not to build the life<br />

you want — it’s to love each other with<br />

everything you have and to let the marriage<br />

take the shape that God grants.”<br />

How and when the Church speaks<br />

about infertility is a topic which Melissa<br />

Moschella, associate<br />

professor of philosophy at<br />

The Catholic University of<br />

America, thinks a good deal<br />

about.<br />

“The places where the<br />

Church talks most directly<br />

about infertility are in documents<br />

concerning ethical<br />

issues about reproductive<br />

technologies,” she noted,<br />

citing Donum Vitae (“The<br />

Gift of Life”) and Dignitas<br />

Personae (“The Dignity of<br />

the Person”).<br />

Moshcella believes there<br />

are limitations to that<br />

treatment, because infertility<br />

is never explored as its<br />

own topic. And while the<br />

Church expresses sympathy<br />

for couples who desire to<br />

have a child, it has not yet<br />

offered a comprehensive<br />

theological look at marital<br />

fruitfulness outside of<br />

forming a family through<br />

procreation or adoption.<br />

In her courses exploring<br />

the ethics of reproductive technologies,<br />

Moschella has begun presenting students<br />

with information about fertility<br />

awareness-based methods of family<br />

planning. “Most of my female students<br />

have never heard of these. Most don’t<br />

understand how their cycles work or<br />

what the signs of fertility are,” she said.<br />

“The fact that things can actually be<br />

treated is new to them.”<br />

***<br />

The good news is that Catholic physicians<br />

have been advancing treatment<br />

for infertility for decades.<br />

Gilbert is a part of a health care practice<br />

that specializes in Naprotechnology,<br />

an approach to fertility pioneered<br />

by Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers, the director<br />

of the Saint Paul VI Institute for the<br />

Study of Human Reproduction and the<br />

National Center for Women’s Health<br />

in Omaha, Nebraska.<br />

With colleagues at the St. Louis<br />

University and Creighton University<br />

Schools of Medicine, he developed<br />

what is known as the Creighton Model<br />

FertilityCare System. Beyond helping<br />

to address infertility, this method<br />

is used to treat repeat miscarriage,<br />

postpartum depression, premenstrual<br />

symptoms, and preterm birth.<br />

Unlike mainstream endocrinology<br />

and fertility medicine, which uses a<br />

standard 28-day cycle to evaluate hormonal<br />

imbalances in women, Naprotechnology<br />

looks at each individual<br />

woman’s biomarkers to create what<br />

Gilbert calls a “total hormonal profile.”<br />

“Standard fertility medicine will<br />

spend three months prescribing<br />

medicine to strengthen ovulation and<br />

then move onto IVF,” Gilbert said.<br />

“Naprotechnology seeks to restore<br />

fertility by getting to the root cause of<br />

the problem.”<br />

The practice involves an analysis of<br />

all of the hormones involved in a women’s<br />

cycle (not only those related to<br />

ovulation), robust testing of the thyroid,<br />

surgical interventions, and identifying<br />

causes of inflammation or insulin<br />

resistance.<br />

Gilbert noted that physicians are starting<br />

to acknowledge that the Western<br />

diet and lifestyle is contributing to the<br />

issue.<br />

“As far as male infertility is concerned,<br />

alcohol, drugs, high blood<br />

pressure, and cholesterol can all contribute,”<br />

she said. “For women, there<br />

are a lot of endocrine disruptors<br />

in our diet, cosmetics,<br />

and the containers we drink<br />

and eat out of.”<br />

Gilbert says the widespread<br />

prescription of the birth<br />

control pill to girls, who<br />

often stay on it until they<br />

are ready for childbearing, is<br />

contributing to the problem.<br />

Some studies indicate<br />

that the pill interferes with<br />

the production of cervical<br />

mucus, which is important<br />

for fertilization.<br />

But a bigger issue is that the<br />

pill is widely prescribed to<br />

relieve painful symptoms of<br />

menstruation, which are often<br />

indicative of underlying<br />

issues like endometriosis. Because<br />

the condition advances<br />

even when symptoms are<br />

Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers, ameliorated, women come<br />

director of the Pope Paul off the pill after a decade or<br />

VI Institute on the Study of more to find that they had<br />

Human Reproduction. | CNS been unknowingly masking<br />

an underlying condition.<br />

While not all of her<br />

patients conceive, Gilbert finds satisfaction<br />

that almost all of them say that<br />

they are thankful to have “found someone<br />

to take them seriously, listen to<br />

them, and give them a real diagnosis.”<br />

***<br />

Many women report that they simply<br />

want someone to acknowledge they<br />

22 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


exist and to hear what it feels like to<br />

have their body fail them.<br />

A turning point for Cassie Taylor<br />

was registering for an online retreat<br />

focused on infertility and grief, hosted<br />

by a ministry called Springs in the<br />

Desert. She was relieved to hear they<br />

were “Christ-focused, not conception-focused.”<br />

Springs in the Desert was born from<br />

the personal experience of Ann Koschute,<br />

who began to observe common<br />

feelings about identity, vocation,<br />

and isolation in her conversations with<br />

other Catholic women experiencing<br />

infertility.<br />

“We’re all kind of hidden,” she said.<br />

“The ministry started out of necessity,<br />

because we needed accompaniment.”<br />

Springs in the Desert has become<br />

one of the leading ministries for<br />

Catholic couples experiencing infertility,<br />

offering retreats, educational and<br />

pastoral resources, a podcast, small<br />

groups, and online events.<br />

Taylor now manages its social media<br />

accounts and hosts its podcast. The<br />

demand is increasing, evidenced by<br />

the growing body of podcast listeners,<br />

engagement with social media, and<br />

the number of dioceses promoting its<br />

work.<br />

Koschute hopes they can help facilitate<br />

some changes in the way Catholics<br />

approach the topic and those<br />

affected by it.<br />

“Within the Catholic space, there is<br />

often an idolizing of the child and the<br />

big Catholic family, which is the flip<br />

side of the contraceptive mentality and<br />

a culture focused on self-fulfillment.<br />

But it can create a culture that says the<br />

way to holiness is producing children.<br />

“We need to be reminded that our<br />

marriages are life-giving, that they are<br />

powerful witnesses in a world where<br />

people so easily give up on theirs<br />

because they don’t get what they want<br />

or don’t feel personally fulfilled,” she<br />

said.<br />

Her ultimate hope for the ministry is<br />

that couples will better come to know<br />

Christ as the wellspring in what she<br />

calls the “desert of infertility.”<br />

Marcolini wishes Catholics would<br />

refrain from making assumptions<br />

about childless couples, couples with a<br />

small number of children, or couples<br />

who have adopted, saying that it’s impossible<br />

to know what anyone is going<br />

Dr. Anne <strong>No</strong>lte, right, a family physician with the<br />

National Gianna Center for Women’s Health and<br />

Fertility in New York, follows Catholic teaching and<br />

guidelines for health care in her practice. | CNS/<br />

GREGORY A. SHEMITZ<br />

through or what has gone into their<br />

discernment.<br />

<strong>No</strong>w a mother of two adopted<br />

daughters, Zelie, 2, and Gianna, 6<br />

months, Elizabeth said her experience<br />

“has been a deeper invitation into the<br />

mystery of divine love since we are all<br />

adopted sons and daughters of God.”<br />

She and her husband share their story<br />

with other couples preparing for marriage<br />

in their diocese.<br />

When asked what she would say to<br />

others facing infertility, Elizabeth said<br />

to pray for what you desire, but not to<br />

spend your marriage and life waiting<br />

for something that is not promised.<br />

“Receive what God has for you today.<br />

God is a God of the present, not of the<br />

past or the future,” she said. “So live<br />

right now.”<br />

Elise Italiano Ureneck is a communications<br />

consultant writing from Rhode<br />

Island.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 23


OF WOMBS<br />

AND WOUNDS<br />

Pope Francis’ recent condemnation of<br />

surrogacy was needed. But can we talk<br />

more about what’s driving the practice?<br />

BY CHARLIE CAMOSY<br />

In his annual foreign policy address<br />

to diplomats accredited to the Holy<br />

See, Pope Francis this month made<br />

some striking remarks on a topic not<br />

typically associated with foreign policy.<br />

“The path to peace calls for respect<br />

for life, for every human life, starting<br />

with the life of the unborn child in the<br />

mother’s womb, which cannot be suppressed<br />

or turned into an object of trafficking.<br />

In this regard, I deem deplorable<br />

the practice of so-called surrogate<br />

motherhood, which represents a grave<br />

violation of the dignity of the woman<br />

and the child, based on the exploitation<br />

of situations of the mother’s material<br />

needs. A child is always a gift and never<br />

the basis of a commercial contract.<br />

Consequently, I express my hope for an<br />

effort by the international community<br />

to prohibit this practice universally. At<br />

every moment of its existence, human<br />

life must be preserved and defended;<br />

yet I note with regret, especially in the<br />

West, the continued spread of a culture<br />

of death, which in the name of a false<br />

compassion discards children, the<br />

elderly, and the sick.”<br />

The Holy Father often tries to do two<br />

things at once: (1) hold fast to traditional<br />

doctrine (if often in ways that<br />

are intentionally and helpfully nonpolitical)<br />

and (2) emphasize the pastoral<br />

value of mercy. This is evident in his<br />

description of the Church as a field<br />

hospital which tries to stabilize deeply<br />

wounded people.<br />

It is striking and can be disorienting<br />

when he does one without the other, or<br />

when certain people or groups emphasize<br />

one without the other. Here, when<br />

it comes to his engagement on surrogacy,<br />

he emphasizes Church teaching<br />

without referencing mercy — as he<br />

does in so many other contexts, including<br />

abortion and irregular relationships.<br />

SHUTTERSTOCK<br />

Thus his remarks, though powerful<br />

and needed, get only two cheers from<br />

me.<br />

In a culture like ours, where surrogacy<br />

is an unquestioned good — especially<br />

(but not only) in contexts of infertility<br />

and same-sex marriage — speaking in<br />

such morally and legally clear terms is<br />

admirable and even brave. One hopes<br />

that his allies, including some who<br />

accept and promote surrogacy, will be<br />

given the grace to hear what he’s saying.<br />

The Holy Father is speaking from<br />

his central moral theological commitment:<br />

resisting Western-style consumer<br />

throwaway culture. Instead of seeing<br />

God’s creation — including human<br />

beings — as merely products to be used<br />

and discarded, he wants us to recognize<br />

their proper value.<br />

The global surrogacy consumer<br />

network not only exploits vulnerable<br />

women, but also treats children as items<br />

for purchase. Tragically, in most cases<br />

of IVF, the “excess” human beings are<br />

often discarded as if they are waste.<br />

And it is doing so on a growing scale.<br />

An estimated 18,400 infants were born<br />

in the U.S. via surrogates from 1999 to<br />

2013, according to one study. But now,<br />

with the advances in surrogacy-related<br />

technology and growing popularity<br />

24 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


in the media, the global industry is<br />

expected to become worth $129 billion<br />

in the next decade (up from $14 billion<br />

in 2022).<br />

The desire to have a biological child<br />

is, for many, one of the most powerful<br />

desires in nature. But that desire cannot<br />

change the truth — a truth Christians<br />

like the Holy Father are bound to<br />

proclaim — that no one has a right to<br />

a child. Children are gifts from God to<br />

which we can be open, but can never<br />

demand.<br />

If everyone has the right to purchase a<br />

child on the open market (or even the<br />

“right to procreate” via the financial<br />

support of the government), this feeds<br />

the consumerist throwaway culture<br />

about which the Holy Father rightly<br />

warns us.<br />

But what about mercy and the<br />

Church as a field hospital? My wife<br />

and I — along with so many others —<br />

know firsthand the incredible pain of<br />

infertility. I wish the Holy Father had<br />

acknowledged that this pain is in part<br />

driving the demand for surrogates.<br />

Those bearing the pain of infertility as<br />

well as those who have used surrogates<br />

and are now beginning to question<br />

what they have done are among<br />

those who are hurting. They need the<br />

Church to be a field hospital which<br />

emphasizes God’s mercy on the way to<br />

speaking the truth in love.<br />

And they need a Church which focuses<br />

on other ways faithful Christians<br />

can be fruitful. Our spiritual father, St.<br />

Joseph, certainly provides a primordial<br />

example in his fatherhood of Jesus. (He<br />

was a foundational inspiration — and<br />

remains an ongoing help — for and<br />

with our three adopted children.)<br />

But let’s move even beyond adoption.<br />

The Church must do a much better job<br />

making space for childless people in<br />

the Church, both single and married.<br />

Far too often, one of the first questions<br />

I hear from Catholics I meet is, “How<br />

many children do you have?” Can you<br />

imagine how such a question hits for<br />

those bearing the pain of infertility?<br />

Having biological children is a wonderful<br />

gift to be given by God, and we<br />

must continue to make cultural space<br />

for these gifts, especially in a culture<br />

that is often hostile to children. But let<br />

us also make space for the wounded<br />

people in the Church bearing the pain<br />

of not having been given this gift —<br />

The global surrogacy consumer network not only<br />

exploits vulnerable women, but also treats children<br />

as items for purchase.<br />

and let us do so in ways which make it<br />

clear we value the gifts they bring to the<br />

table just as much.<br />

Charlie Camosy is professor of medical<br />

humanities at the Creighton University<br />

School of Medicine. In addition, he<br />

holds the Monsignor Curran Fellowship<br />

in Moral Theology at St. Joseph Seminary<br />

in New York.


AD REM<br />

ROBERT BRENNAN<br />

Why don’t I have a podcast?<br />

SHUTTERSTOCK<br />

Remember that bygone era when<br />

there were only three on-air<br />

national broadcast networks<br />

and — here in Los Angeles — another<br />

four local television stations? Current<br />

consumers of digital television would<br />

consider that a primitive state equivalent<br />

to cave paintings.<br />

But I actually pine for them every now<br />

and then.<br />

It was not a perfect system. Because<br />

of limited platforms, it was harder to<br />

find your niche either on the news or<br />

entertainment side.<br />

If you were a musician, you worked<br />

in dingy clubs and high school sock<br />

hops for years until you got your break.<br />

An actor may have worked for years<br />

parking cars or waiting tables and doing<br />

local theater only to get one guest spot<br />

on “Bonanza.” Many talented people<br />

never got a break of any kind, yet some<br />

of the most talented artists and news<br />

reporters still managed to burst forth<br />

from this cauldron.<br />

<strong>No</strong>w everyone is a star. And it seems<br />

I am the last person on the planet who<br />

does not have a podcast. There are<br />

literally tens of thousands of podcasts<br />

on every topic under the sun and many<br />

topics that do not deserve to see the<br />

light of day. It does not take much. If<br />

you have about 40 bucks you can get<br />

yourself a cool-looking microphone<br />

at an electronics box store, a little<br />

lighting from the same store and maybe<br />

a bookshelf behind you to give you<br />

gravitas and voila: you are a podcaster<br />

(obviously, you need a good internet<br />

connection, too).<br />

Podcasters have a tendency to take<br />

themselves very seriously with anchorman<br />

desks like they were working at<br />

CNN, but they come off looking more<br />

like Ron Burgundy. I have watched<br />

podcasters that are comical, intentional<br />

and unintentional, but most of the ones<br />

I have found are trivial and listening to<br />

them has not proven an effective use of<br />

time.<br />

And yet, they are legion.<br />

I wish I could say the advent of<br />

technology and its ability to distribute<br />

information so quickly and cheaply<br />

would be a boon for the Church and<br />

her adherents. But when I look at the<br />

Catholic blogosphere that dream vaporizes<br />

like when rubidium makes contact<br />

with water.<br />

It seems anyone with a microphone,<br />

free time, and a copy of the Vatican<br />

II documents, is now an ecclesiastical<br />

expert who needs to be heard. Before<br />

<strong>26</strong> • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Robert Brennan writes from Los Angeles, where<br />

he has worked in the entertainment industry,<br />

Catholic journalism, and the nonprofit sector.<br />

this technology got so far ahead of us,<br />

before a person with limited income<br />

could use the internet to have his or her<br />

very own “channel,” the economics of<br />

media was a natural roadblock to too<br />

many people with too many opinions.<br />

You had to be really good on camera<br />

and have something positive to<br />

say — like Bishop Fulton Sheen — to<br />

be granted paid time on television.<br />

<strong>No</strong>w, if you get enough “likes” or your<br />

subscription numbers on YouTube are<br />

good enough, you can actually pay<br />

your utility bills off a podcast dedicated<br />

solely to how terrible things are in the<br />

Church today. The more anger, the<br />

more controversy, the more likes and<br />

the more clicks.<br />

It is a feeding frenzy but unfortunately,<br />

we are eating our own. Taking a random<br />

sampling of your average Catholic<br />

blog, you would surmise that the<br />

Church is on her last legs. It is a world<br />

of gloom and doom with prophetic<br />

warnings about the End Times and the<br />

coming of the AntiChrist.<br />

The hosts of Catholic-themed podcasts<br />

run the gamut from laymen and<br />

laywomen, priests and religious, and<br />

everything in between. There are good<br />

ones more interested in lighting candles<br />

against the night than relishing in<br />

the darkness, and there are far too many<br />

podcasts that mislead and all to readily<br />

rely on anger as their fuel. If you put<br />

14 of these podcasters in a room you<br />

will get 14 opinions on what is wrong<br />

with the Church, what is right with the<br />

Church, and what needs to be done in<br />

the Church.<br />

At the risk of sounding like a podcaster<br />

myself, I know what needs to be done:<br />

Stop listening to podcasts.<br />

If you are troubled by the way things<br />

are, say a rosary or pray a novena.<br />

Take solace in the irrefutable fact, not<br />

opinion, that Jesus promised to be with<br />

his Church forever. It is not always easy,<br />

it is not always pretty, but the Church<br />

traveling in its prison of time and space<br />

will do remarkable things and not so<br />

remarkable things.<br />

And as flawed as his bride may be, the<br />

consistency of Christ’s promise must be<br />

our focus, and not how many “likes”<br />

we can get by yelling fire in a crowded<br />

cathedral.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 27


NOW PLAYING POOR THINGS<br />

BELLA’S BIG ADVENTURE<br />

Awards season favorite ‘Poor Things’ turns a<br />

Frankenstein bride into a sorority girl<br />

Emma Stone and Mark<br />

Ruffalo in “Poor Things.”<br />

| IMBD<br />

BY JOSEPH JOYCE<br />

Often in the English language<br />

there are words mistaken for<br />

synonyms while nestling adjacent<br />

or even opposed to one another.<br />

For instance, anyone who has ever had<br />

their heart broken quickly learns the<br />

chasm between “affection” and “love.”<br />

Many more then have their heart’s<br />

shards snapped further by a waiter<br />

conflating the merits of Coca-Cola and<br />

Pepsi.<br />

But more notable and more relevant<br />

to this review is the difference between<br />

“provocative” and “interesting.” It’s<br />

easy to reach the former, and even easier<br />

to mistake it for an achievement.<br />

Thus is the quandary with Yorgos<br />

Lanthimos’s “Poor Things,” fresh off its<br />

Golden Globes wins earlier this month<br />

for Best Comedy and Best Actress in a<br />

Comedy for Emma Stone.<br />

Stone plays Bella, a Victorian woman<br />

resurrected from the dead by mad<br />

scientist Dr. Godwin Baxter, played by<br />

Willem Dafoe. Though perhaps resurrection<br />

is again one of those adjacent<br />

but conflicting synonyms: When Godwin<br />

finds her floating under the bridge,<br />

he places the brain of her unborn child<br />

into her dead mother’s skull. I’m sure<br />

the more squeamish have tapped out at<br />

that alone. But that is what they want,<br />

and we cannot let them win. Who<br />

“they” and “we” are, and what indeed<br />

what “winning” entails, is irrelevant to<br />

the mission at hand.<br />

Bella is quite literally a child trapped<br />

inside an adult woman’s body. She<br />

staggers about like a marionette at the<br />

mercy of a drunk puppeteer, and in<br />

true toddler fashion makes up for her<br />

limited vocabulary in violence with<br />

the words she does possess. Unable<br />

to pronounce his full name, she calls<br />

her creator “God.” It’s the most blatant<br />

of the blunt symbolism throughout,<br />

which I’m sure Lanthimos would<br />

insist is tongue-in-cheek. But it’s ironic<br />

turtles all the way down, and at the<br />

bottom of the stack is still a character<br />

called God.<br />

28 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Bella is cared for by Godwin’s kindly<br />

assistant Max (Ramy Youssef), who<br />

with Godwin’s permission, bordering<br />

on insistence, proposes marriage. But<br />

even childlike Bella recognizes it is<br />

“God’s” attempt to keep her at home<br />

away from a wider world which he<br />

fears and she longs for.<br />

(While allowing for curiosity, I think<br />

the film overestimates a child’s mind<br />

for new experience. Children are<br />

natural reactionaries; ask them to<br />

sample new food other than chicken<br />

fingers and they’ll respond with all the<br />

liberality of a Russian czar.)<br />

With his permission she instead<br />

runs off with Duncan Wedderburn<br />

(Mark Ruffalo). A caddish lawyer (at<br />

the risk of sounding redundant) he<br />

takes advantage of Bella’s naiveté and<br />

whisks her off on a lover’s holiday.<br />

Bella’s accelerated mental progression<br />

now finds her in the thick of adolescence,<br />

so if Duncan uses her, she is<br />

an enthusiastic accomplice.<br />

But we are back again to the great<br />

divide of provocation and interest. In<br />

the longest stretch of the film we are<br />

shown in great detail the particulars<br />

of Bella’s sexual awakening, sequences<br />

that most readers of this magazine<br />

would find lewd and indecent.<br />

But throughout all this extracurricular<br />

activity my eyes averted from the<br />

screen not from prudishness but boredom.<br />

Sexuality is indeed part of growing<br />

up, but it isn’t the skeleton key of<br />

adulthood. Lanthimos takes Bella into<br />

the wider world, but his focus on this<br />

one aspect of her person shrinks it.<br />

She wants to see the pyramids, but she<br />

must settle for the ceiling.<br />

It even puts him at odds with his own<br />

thesis. Bella is an Edenic creature, her<br />

innocence putting her at odds with<br />

a fallen society. It would certainly<br />

explain her comfort with nudity. She<br />

eats sloppily, dances merrily, and lacks<br />

the patience for innuendo in polite<br />

conversation. Most importantly, she<br />

doesn’t fathom the absurd strictures<br />

her society places on women, and<br />

like most children ignores what she<br />

doesn’t understand.<br />

But Lanthimos groups her freewheeling<br />

sexual liberation in with<br />

her burgeoning feminism, a pairing<br />

that fell out of fashion somewhere<br />

between Rocky II and Rocky IV. It’s<br />

a retrograde feminism, not respecting<br />

women in all their baffling facets but<br />

to the extent to which they please the<br />

drooling patriarchy.<br />

In fairness, the film recognizes the<br />

abuses. For all his talk of spurning<br />

convention, Duncan grows more<br />

possessive the wider Bella’s perspective<br />

expands. He says he wants to show<br />

her the world, but we realize along<br />

with her that a narcissist thinks the<br />

world ends at his sightline. He tricks<br />

her onto a cruise ship where she can’t<br />

leave him, but that is only prolonging<br />

the inevitable. Rid of his dead weight,<br />

she later takes up a brief residency<br />

in a brothel, a rose-colored vignette<br />

on sex work where her sex positivity<br />

goes over like gangbusters. After her<br />

adventures she finally returns and is<br />

reconciled to her fiancé and “God,”<br />

her wild oats sufficiently sown.<br />

Perhaps as a Catholic I should<br />

endorse such a tidy resolution, but<br />

I have never found myself more<br />

offended at a film coming full circle.<br />

It meant all its provocations were for<br />

nothing, even its postures of defiance<br />

ultimately subjugated to conventional<br />

mores. What we watched for the last<br />

two hours was not a young woman<br />

bucking the absurdities of our society,<br />

but a sorority girl on a gap year<br />

abroad.<br />

In other words, “Poor Things” is<br />

about controlled rebellion, the cinematic<br />

equivalent of Woodstock hippies<br />

who went on to work for weapon<br />

manufacturers. I have more genuine<br />

respect for sticking to a principle, even<br />

in violation of my own, than dabbling<br />

in revolution only to embrace the cog.<br />

God can forgive any sins, but I can’t<br />

forgive you for wasting my time.<br />

Editor’s note: “Poor Things” is rated R<br />

for strong and pervasive sexual content,<br />

graphic nudity, disturbing material,<br />

gore, and language.<br />

Joseph Joyce is a screenwriter and freelance<br />

critic based in Sherman Oaks.<br />

Willem Dafoe in “Poor Things.” | IMDB


DESIRE LINES<br />

HEATHER KING<br />

Large and in charge<br />

Los Angeles’ Natural History Museum<br />

is mounting a super-duper<br />

show in Exposition Park through<br />

the spring.<br />

The museum recently unveiled “100<br />

Carats: Icons of the Gem World,”<br />

an exhibition of some of the highest<br />

quality rare gems on earth, including<br />

the world-famous Jonker I diamond,<br />

which has not been viewed publicly<br />

for decades.<br />

The centerpiece of<br />

the exhibit, the Jonker<br />

I Diamond. | AARON<br />

CELESTIAN/NATURAL<br />

HISTORY MUSEUM OF<br />

LA COUNTY<br />

“Right this way!” you can almost hear<br />

the carnival barker’s cry.<br />

Says Lori Bettison-Varga, the museum’s<br />

president and director: “Gems of<br />

such magnificent size and quality have<br />

never been displayed before in this<br />

quantity in one exhibition.”<br />

The 125-carat Jonker I, one of the<br />

largest cut diamonds in the world, is<br />

the centerpiece of the exhibition.<br />

The Jonker, found by a South African<br />

farmer in 1934, was at the time the<br />

fourth-largest uncut gem ever discovered.<br />

At 7<strong>26</strong> carats — a little over<br />

five ounces — it was later cut into 13<br />

smaller stones, the Jonker I being the<br />

largest.<br />

Far more interesting than the stone’s<br />

size, to my mind, is the intrigue surrounding<br />

it.<br />

From Wikipedia: “In 1949, King Farouk<br />

of Egypt purchased the Jonker I,<br />

but after he was deposed and exiled in<br />

1952, the gem was lost. After a number<br />

of years, the gem reappeared in the<br />

ownership of Queen Ratna of Nepal.<br />

The last known location of the Jonker<br />

I was in Hong Kong in 1977 when it<br />

was sold to an anonymous buyer for<br />

$2,259,000.”<br />

Lost? Wouldn’t you give anything to<br />

know how the gem made its way from<br />

Egypt to Nepal? Whoever the anonymous<br />

buyer was in 1977, today the<br />

Jonker I is owned — and on loan to<br />

the NHS — by Ibrahim Al-Rashid. <strong>No</strong><br />

further details given.<br />

In its 80 years of existence, the<br />

diamond has never been on display in<br />

a museum. Which just goes to show,<br />

really, what can you do with this exquisite<br />

jewel except put it in a safe?<br />

But the exhibition includes way more<br />

than the Jonker I. Other treasures<br />

include a 241-carat emerald known<br />

as “The Crown of Colombia,” a deep<br />

aquamarine beryl called “The <strong>No</strong>rthern<br />

Light,” an exquisite blood-red<br />

rubellite tourmaline, “The Princess<br />

Pink Sapphire,” and “The Ukrainian<br />

Flag Topaz.” Every stone in the exhibit<br />

is at least 100 carats (a carat weighs<br />

.007 of an ounce), which in the gem<br />

world is gigantic.<br />

“Every gem is a minor geologic miracle,”<br />

the museum notes.<br />

Think mountains, volcanoes, tectonic<br />

30 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


Heather King is an award-winning<br />

author, speaker, and workshop leader.<br />

plates, and mysterious movements<br />

deep within the earth’s surface. After<br />

millions of years, these brilliant, sparkling<br />

gems emerge (helped along by<br />

master cutters, polishers, and jewelry<br />

designers like Robert Procop, who<br />

figures prominently in the exhibit).<br />

But gems also have a sinister side.<br />

They’re mostly worn by women. At<br />

this level, they’re insanely expensive:<br />

in 2015, a “perfect” 100-carat diamond<br />

sold at Sotheby’s for $22 million. Put<br />

the two together and mayhem, at some<br />

point, is bound to result.<br />

Having spent most of my own<br />

unglamorous life reading rather than<br />

boning up on carats, the phrase “iconic<br />

gems” evokes any number of juicy<br />

stories, novels, and films where the lust<br />

for jewels has led to ruin.<br />

Anthony Trollope’s 1871 novel “The<br />

Eustace Diamonds,” for example, in<br />

which gold digger and pathological liar<br />

Lizzie Greystock marries the sickly Sir<br />

Florian Eustace knowing he will soon<br />

die and leave her a wealthy widow.<br />

The diamonds are a family heirloom<br />

that Lizzie coolly refuses to relinquish.<br />

Romantic hijinks and interminable<br />

litigation ensue, the upshot being that<br />

Lizzie, satisfyingly,<br />

gets just what Stained-glass windows<br />

she deserves.<br />

depicting the Parable<br />

Guy de Maupassant’s<br />

1884<br />

of the Hidden Treasure<br />

(left) and the Parable of<br />

the Pearl (right) in Scots’<br />

short story “The Church, Melbourne. |<br />

Necklace” is a<br />

WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />

cautionary tale<br />

about a woman<br />

who disdains her loving, faithful<br />

husband and prefers to live in fantasy.<br />

When they’re invited to a fancy ball,<br />

she borrows an expensive diamond<br />

necklace from a friend, a move that<br />

results in one night of ecstasy and a<br />

lifetime of abject misery.<br />

That’s not even counting the German-born<br />

film director Max Ophuls’<br />

“The Earrings of Madame de…”<br />

(1953), a romantic drama that ends<br />

with a duel and an implied suicide.<br />

But far be it for me to be a wet blanket.<br />

The once-in-a-lifetime show runs<br />

through April 21. So go. Ooh and aah<br />

at these wonders of nature. Gasp at the<br />

brilliance, the vivid colors, the perfection.<br />

Ponder the fact that such gems<br />

occur nowhere else in the solar system.<br />

Let’s not forget, however, that Jesus<br />

also knew about jewels. “Again, the<br />

kingdom of heaven is like a merchant<br />

seeking beautiful pearls, who, when<br />

he had found one pearl of great price,<br />

went and sold all that he had and<br />

bought it” (Matthew 13:45–46).<br />

Here’s the distinction: the kingdom of<br />

heaven is not reducible to a stone. The<br />

kingdom of heaven, for which we’re<br />

willing to give up everything we own,<br />

can’t be bartered, bought, traded, or<br />

sold. It’s beyond price.<br />

And you never have to keep it in a<br />

safe.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 31


LETTER AND SPIRIT<br />

SCOTT HAHN<br />

Scott Hahn is founder of the<br />

St. Paul Center for Biblical<br />

Theology; stpaulcenter.com.<br />

In Crete our faith<br />

Around this time every year, my mind returns to the<br />

island of Crete. Around a dozen years ago I led a<br />

pilgrimage there, in the midst of a cruise “in the<br />

footsteps of St. Paul.”<br />

There’s no detailed scriptural account of the apostle’s<br />

visit there. All we know is that he “left” his disciple Titus<br />

on Crete (Titus 1:5),<br />

ordaining him to lead<br />

the Church there. He<br />

had surely “laid hands”<br />

on Titus, as he had on<br />

Timothy (2 Timothy 1:6).<br />

Both men had received<br />

the grace of holy orders,<br />

and then they lived up to<br />

it. Thus we honor them<br />

together on the feast they<br />

share, <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>.<br />

In a letter to Titus, Paul<br />

aims an insult at the people<br />

of Crete: “Cretans,”<br />

he says, “are always liars,<br />

evil beasts, lazy gluttons”<br />

(Titus 1:12).<br />

Ouch. That hurts, even<br />

after 2,000 years. But Paul<br />

was quoting a Cretan<br />

poet when he said it.<br />

The poet’s name is Epimenides<br />

— a pagan! —<br />

and Paul actually quotes<br />

him more than once in<br />

the New Testament. He<br />

even refers to him as a<br />

prophet.<br />

Epimenides was a<br />

semi-mythical, semi-historical<br />

figure who lived on<br />

Crete in the sixth or seventh<br />

century before Christ. He was a shepherd who one day,<br />

according to legend, fell asleep in a cave and awoke 57 years<br />

later. He emerged transfigured, filled with supernatural gifts.<br />

His fame spread far, even to Athens, some 214 miles away.<br />

Athenians, centuries later, remembered Epimenides for<br />

delivering their city from a curse. They had been suffering<br />

“St. Paul,” by Hans Baldung Grien, 1484-1545, German. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />

from a series of calamities, so they called upon the poet-prophet<br />

for help. He suggested that perhaps there was a<br />

god yet unknown to them, who would be willing and able<br />

to help if appropriate sacrifices were offered. So the people<br />

of Athens built altars to this nameless deity all over the city,<br />

and the legacy of Epimenides in Athens was an aggregation<br />

of altars dedicated “to an<br />

unknown god.”<br />

Paul spoke about such<br />

an altar when he was<br />

preaching in the city<br />

(Acts 17:23).<br />

In the same speech, Paul<br />

also quoted one of the<br />

poems of Epimenides.<br />

The poem said of a certain<br />

god: “In him we live<br />

and move and have our<br />

being” (see Acts 17:28).<br />

Paul apparently saw this<br />

line as a prophecy of the<br />

divine life that Christians<br />

experience through<br />

baptism.<br />

His citation is no<br />

happenstance. In fact,<br />

the line comes from the<br />

same poem from which<br />

he drew the insult that<br />

appears in his Letter to<br />

Titus. He knew the poem<br />

well.<br />

And he knew well what<br />

he was doing when he<br />

left Titus on Crete. Paul<br />

gave the island something<br />

better than the legendary<br />

Epimenides. He gave the<br />

Cretans a priest after the<br />

image of Jesus Christ. He gave them a bishop who would<br />

lead them away from lying and gluttony — a saint they<br />

would honor forever. When I visited his church in Crete, I<br />

saw his relics encased in silver.<br />

<strong>No</strong>w his feast is upon us. We’re not in Crete, but we can<br />

invoke his intercession. Please join me in doing so.<br />

32 • ANGELUS • <strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong>


■ FRIDAY, JANUARY 19<br />

Praise and Worship Mass and Healing Prayers. St. Frances<br />

of Rome Church, 501 E. Foothill Blvd., Azusa, 6 p.m. Celebrant:<br />

Father Parker Sandoval. Music by Clarissa Martinez.<br />

OneLife LA Holy Hour. St. Teresa of Avila Church, 2216<br />

Fargo St., Los Angeles, 7-8 p.m. Visit onelifela.org/holy-hour<br />

for more.<br />

■ SATURDAY, JANUARY 20<br />

Embracing the Winter of Life: Aging to Saging. Mary & Joseph<br />

Retreat Center, 5300 Crest Rd., Rancho Palos Verdes,<br />

9 a.m.-12 p.m. Workshop will help connect with your inner<br />

sage to the divine to help you age in comfort and health.<br />

Areas covered include spirituality, mental, geographical,<br />

financial wellness, and more. Email MarkMitchellSpeaks@<br />

gmail.com.<br />

100th Celebration. St. Sebastian Church, 1453 Federal<br />

Ave., Los Angeles, 10 a.m. Mass. Celebrant: Bishop Matthew<br />

Elshoff. Reception to follow. Email stsebastianoffice@<br />

gmail.com.<br />

OneLife LA. LA State Historic Park, 1245 N. Spring St., Los<br />

Angeles, 11 a.m.-6 p.m. Join Archbishop José H. Gomez on<br />

a walk for life through downtown Los Angeles, followed by<br />

a festival with speakers, music, and food. Theme: “10 Years<br />

Together As One.” For more information, visit onelifela.org.<br />

Requiem Mass for the Unborn. Cathedral of Our Lady of<br />

the Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 5 p.m. Archbishop<br />

José H. Gomez will celebrate the annual Mass for<br />

the Unborn to end OneLife LA.<br />

■ SUNDAY, JANUARY 21<br />

Feast of Santo Niño Mass. Cathedral of Our Lady of the<br />

Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 3 p.m. procession,<br />

3:30 p.m. Mass. Principal celebrant: Bishop Brian Nunes.<br />

Hosted by the Santo Niño Cruzada (SNCU) organization.<br />

Bring statues of Santo Niño for a special blessing.<br />

■ MONDAY, JANUARY 22<br />

Mass and Healing Service. St. Rose of Lima Church, 1305<br />

Royal Ave., Simi Valley, 7 p.m. Celebrant: Father Michael<br />

Barry, with Deacon Pete Wilson. Call 805-5<strong>26</strong>-1732.<br />

■ WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 24<br />

LACBA Family Law Clinic. Virtual, 2-5 p.m. Covers child<br />

support, custody, divorce, and spousal support. Open to LA<br />

County veterans. Registration required. Call 213-896-6537<br />

or email inquiries-veterans@lacba.org.<br />

■ SATURDAY, JANUARY 27<br />

The Indwelling Wholeness of the Trinity. St. Andrew<br />

Church, 538 Concord St., El Segundo, 9:30 a.m.-3:45 p.m.<br />

Retreat focuses on a contemplative experience to prayerfully<br />

enter the inner sanctum of the heart in the art of attention.<br />

Cost: $25/offering, includes continental breakfast<br />

and lunch salad bar. RSVP by Jan. 20. Contact nbstjames@<br />

gmail.com.<br />

■ SUNDAY, JANUARY 28<br />

Mass Honoring Sisters of Mercy. St. Pius X School, 10855<br />

S. Pioneer Blvd., Santa Fe Springs, 10 a.m. St. Pius X parish<br />

and school will celebrate 33 years of service by the Sisters<br />

of Mercy with a special Mass and dedication. Call 562-234-<br />

1165.<br />

Religious Jubilarian Mass. Cathedral of Our Lady of the<br />

Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 3:30 p.m. Religious<br />

sisters, brothers, and priests from the Archdiocese of Los<br />

Angeles will celebrate jubilee anniversaries.<br />

■ MONDAY, JANUARY 29<br />

End of Life Preparation. St. Bruno Church, 15740 Citrustree<br />

Rd., Whittier, 9-10:30 a.m. or 7-8:30 p.m. RSVP to<br />

Cathy by Jan. 10 at 562-631-8844.<br />

■ SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 3<br />

Nun Run, 5K, 1-Mile, and Community Service Fair. La<br />

Reina High School, 106 W. Janss Rd., Thousand Oaks,<br />

8 a.m. 10th annual Nun Run, hosted by Sisters of <strong>No</strong>tre<br />

Dame, will raise proceeds for local and global outreach.<br />

Visit nun.run.<br />

■ SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 4<br />

Rite of Election. Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels, 555<br />

W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 3 p.m. The Rite of Election<br />

is the final required step for anyone preparing to receive<br />

the sacraments of baptism, confirmation, and the holy<br />

Eucharist on the Easter Vigil. Email Leticia Perez at LPerez@<br />

la-archdiocese.org.<br />

■ WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 7<br />

Changing Seasons: Lent to Palm Sunday. Zoom, 7-8:30<br />

p.m. Class led by Father Felix Just, SJ, will explore Bible<br />

readings for Lent to Palm Sunday. Visit lacatholics.org/<br />

events.<br />

■ SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 10<br />

Valentine’s Dinner. Our Lady of Perpetual Help Church,<br />

23233 Lyons Ave., Newhall, 12 p.m. Hosted by the Italian<br />

Catholic Club of SCV, includes complimentary glass of<br />

wine. Cost: $45/person. RSVP to Anna Riggs at 661-645-<br />

7877 by Feb. 5.<br />

Malta World Day of the Sick Mass. Cathedral of Our Lady<br />

of the Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles, 12:30 p.m.<br />

Hosted by the Western Association of the Order of Malta,<br />

all are welcome, especially those who are suffering in body<br />

or spirit. Blessing and anointing of the sick will be administered.<br />

■ TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 13<br />

Memorial Mass. San Fernando Mission, 15151 San<br />

Fernando Mission Blvd., Mission Hills, 11 a.m. Mass is<br />

virtual and not open to the public. Livestream available at<br />

CatholicCM.org or Facebook.com/lacatholics.<br />

■ THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 15<br />

Youth Day: RECongress. Anaheim Convention Center,<br />

200 S. Anaheim Blvd., Anaheim, 7:30 a.m.-3 p.m. Young<br />

people will enjoy a general session, keynote speech, two<br />

workshops, and Eucharistic liturgy. Speakers include Baby<br />

Angel, Chris Estrella, and Maggie Craig. Cost: $40/person.<br />

Register at recongress.org.<br />

■ FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 16<br />

Religious Education Congress. Anaheim Convention<br />

Center, 200 S. Anaheim Blvd., Anaheim. Events run Feb.<br />

16-18, and include speakers, sacraments, films, and<br />

workshops. Keynote speaker: Jessica Sarowitz, founder of<br />

Miraflores Films. Cost: $85/person. For more information,<br />

visit recongress.org.<br />

■ SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 24<br />

Anniversary Mass for Bishop David O’Connell. San Gabriel<br />

Mission, 429 S. Junipero Serra Dr., 10 a.m. Celebrant:<br />

Archbishop José H. Gomez. Blessing of memorial exhibit to<br />

follow after Mass.<br />

Items for the calendar of events are due four weeks prior to the date of the event. They may be emailed to calendar@angelusnews.com.<br />

All calendar items must include the name, date, time, address of the event, and a phone number for additional information.<br />

<strong>January</strong> <strong>26</strong>, <strong>2024</strong> • ANGELUS • 33

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!