11.05.2024 Views

CMW-WB-CH15

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

UNIT 6 CHAPTER 15<br />

The<br />

Life-Giving<br />

Virtues<br />

332


Chapter 15 Overview<br />

Virtue is moral excellence, or the habit of doing good. Our habits are in-built attitudes that give rise to spontaneous<br />

responses and behaviors. Through the natural virtues of prudence, temperance, justice, and fortitude,<br />

we become free to act for the ultimate goals of goodness and the Kingdom of God. The natural virtues<br />

also help us recognize and resist temptation, overcome obstacles, and remain steadfast in the face of fear<br />

and danger. The natural virtues, however, are not enough on their own. They must be transformed by the supernatural<br />

virtues of faith, hope, and love to reach a much higher, graced level.<br />

In this chapter you will learn that …<br />

■ Virtue is moral excellence, or the habit of doing good.<br />

■ There are two kinds of virtues: the natural virtues and the supernatural virtues.<br />

■ Prudence seeks to know the good in itself and helps us discern what is truly good.<br />

■ Temperance helps us discipline our passions and moderate our ego.<br />

■ Fortitude helps us contend with our fears and discouragement productively.<br />

■ Jesus revealed love to be the highest good and goal of all the virtues and commandments.<br />

■ The supernatural virtues of faith, hope, and love transform and perfect the natural virtues.<br />

Bible Basics<br />

I have fought the good fight, I have finished<br />

the race, I have kept the faith. Henceforth<br />

there is laid up for me the crown of righteousness,<br />

which the Lord, the righteous judge, will<br />

award to me on that Day, and not only to me<br />

but also to all who have loved his appearing.<br />

— 2 Timothy 4:7–8<br />

“[W]hoever would be great among you must<br />

be your servant, and whoever would be first<br />

among you must be your slave; even as the<br />

Son of man came not to be served but to<br />

serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”<br />

— Matthew 20:26–28<br />

Connections to the Catechism<br />

■ CCC 981<br />

■ CCC 1805–1806<br />

■ CCC 1808–1809<br />

■ CCC 1835<br />

■ CCC 1837–1838<br />

■ CCC 1844<br />

■ CCC 2055<br />

■ CCC 2290<br />

■ CCC 2341<br />

■ CCC 2546<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers<br />

333


Chapter 15<br />

Aa<br />

VOCABULARY<br />

Natural Virtues: Four virtues<br />

acquired through our own<br />

effort that play a pivotal role in<br />

the exercise of other virtues.<br />

They are the fruit and seed<br />

of morally good acts and<br />

help prepare the powers of<br />

human beings for communion<br />

with God’s love. They are<br />

prudence, justice, fortitude,<br />

and temperance. Also called<br />

Cardinal Virtues or moral<br />

virtues.<br />

Supernatural Virtues: Gifts<br />

infused by God into the<br />

souls of the faithful to make<br />

them capable of acting as<br />

His children and of meriting<br />

eternal life. They are faith,<br />

hope, and charity (or love).<br />

Also called theological virtues.<br />

The Natural and Supernatural Virtues<br />

Together with the Sacraments (particularly the Holy Eucharist and the<br />

Sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation) and a life of prayer, cultivating<br />

virtue in our lives is a powerful weapon in our arsenal for contending<br />

with sin and the evil spirit.<br />

Prized by generations of theologians and pre-Christian classical<br />

philosophers such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, virtue is essentially<br />

moral excellence, or the habit of doing good. Habits are in-built attitudes<br />

that give rise to spontaneous responses and behaviors — behaviors<br />

that we do not have to think about before we do them. They come<br />

out of the virtuous naturally, which is why the ancients called them second<br />

nature.<br />

There are two kinds of virtues: the natural virtues and the<br />

supernatural virtues. The natural virtues are:<br />

■ Prudence: Knowledge of the good and how to act on the good in<br />

particular situations.<br />

■ Justice: The will or desire to give others what is owed to them by<br />

nature and contract.<br />

■ Temperance: Self-control regarding discipline or moderation of our<br />

passions and feelings.<br />

■ Fortitude: The courage to face adversity and to struggle for the<br />

good amidst challenges.<br />

The supernatural virtues are faith, hope, and love. We have implicitly<br />

discussed faith and hope in Chapters 1–4 and have examined love,<br />

particularly Jesus’ prioritization and definition of it, in Chapters 1 and 2.<br />

We will look again at this highest virtue and its sub-virtues later in this<br />

chapter. But first, we will probe more deeply into the four natural virtues,<br />

examine their necessity for love, and then explore how we can develop<br />

and use them in our lives. We will not specifically address justice<br />

here because it is implicitly contained in the treatment of love. Thus, our<br />

consideration of the natural virtues will focus on prudence, temperance,<br />

and fortitude.<br />

334 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


The virtues should be<br />

continually cultivated in life.<br />

Prudence: A natural virtue<br />

that helps us discern what is<br />

good and then choose the<br />

correct means to accomplish<br />

it. It is the “charioteer of the<br />

virtues,” right reason in action.<br />

The First Natural Virtue: Prudence<br />

Prudence is a special kind of knowledge aimed at knowing the good<br />

and how to achieve it. Beyond knowledge of the world around us or of<br />

universal truths, prudence seeks to know the good in itself and what is<br />

good for us. Thus, to understand prudence, we must turn toward conscience<br />

and divine revelation. These two sources sometimes overlap<br />

and complement each other. As we have learned, conscience is the<br />

gift God gave human beings to be able to use reason in order to judge<br />

right from wrong. It is God’s voice in our hearts that helps us choose the<br />

good and avoid evil. When we act in conformity with our conscience,<br />

we feel noble — particularly if we exert effort or struggle to act rightly.<br />

Conversely, when we act against our conscience, we feel a sense of<br />

guilt and self-alienation (shame).<br />

Four Cardinal Virtues by Friar Laurent (ca. 1290–1300)<br />

[C]onscience<br />

is the gift God<br />

gave human<br />

beings to be<br />

able to use<br />

reason in order<br />

to judge right<br />

from wrong.<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

335


The great Christian writer C.S. Lewis suggested eight major principles<br />

of conscience that most major religions and cultures agree upon:<br />

1. To respect, worship, and gain knowledge of the Sacred Creator<br />

(God) and to follow His will and law.<br />

2. To respect and take care of one’s family and to avoid dishonoring<br />

it.<br />

3. To refrain from killing an innocent person or harming him in his<br />

person, property, or reputation.<br />

4. To refrain from adultery — breaking the marriage covenant.<br />

5. To refrain from stealing another’s property.<br />

6. To refrain from cheating (acting unjustly against established<br />

rules).<br />

It is not enough to know the<br />

good, we must put the good<br />

into practice.<br />

7. To refrain from lying in all its forms — bearing false witness against<br />

one’s neighbor, claiming credit for what is not due to you, not<br />

taking responsibility for misdeeds.<br />

8. To help others who are disadvantaged or in need by using one’s<br />

available time and resources.<br />

People of the Soil by Edwin Boyd Johnson (ca. 1938–1939).<br />

336 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


Given that these eight principles overlap with the teachings of<br />

many religions, we might say that conscience and the practice of religion<br />

complement and reinforce one another. The prudent person not<br />

only knows these eight principles, but he also has an awareness of their<br />

goodness and origin in God, which causes him to love them. This love<br />

of principles inspires him to form and follow his conscience so that he<br />

can act rightly even in complex and difficult situations.<br />

There are two aspects of prudence: first, the love of virtue coming<br />

from the dictates of conscience and love of God, and second, the<br />

knowledge of how to best act on the good in particular situations.<br />

The two sources of our knowledge of the good — conscience and<br />

divine revelation — are complementary. As we have learned, each of<br />

us has an interior sense of the transcendent, spiritual, and divine that<br />

moves us to seek the sacred in the world around us. It follows, then, that<br />

the more we grow in knowledge and love of God, the more we grow in<br />

love of His sacred will and commands.<br />

Thus, if we want to grow in the first aspect of prudence, we should<br />

take steps not only to form our conscience by studying the virtues<br />

and eight principles in philosophy, literature, and life experience, but<br />

also to develop our relationship with God through the Sacraments,<br />

prayer, and the study of His precepts, which are given by Scripture and<br />

the Church. The more we engage in these two disciplines, the more<br />

we will grow in prudence — the understanding, desire, and practice of<br />

the good and all the virtues.<br />

It is not enough, however, to simply know the good. We must also<br />

put the good into practice. When the prudent person sees a need or an<br />

opportunity to do the good, he is moved do something about it. Acting<br />

out on this desire requires setting goals to achieve either a partial or full<br />

solution. Without goals, the best intentions go nowhere. To ensure that<br />

our goals to do good actually come to fruition, we also need to create<br />

a plan to accomplish our goals. Creating a plan often requires learning<br />

who to consult and how to do the research to get the necessary tasks<br />

done effectively. Once we have the steps to our goal laid out, we then<br />

must commit the time to completing them. If we discipline ourselves<br />

to begin quickly, acting immediately on doing the good will eventually<br />

become habitual. We will naturally move promptly into action, expedite<br />

steps, and accomplish much in life.<br />

[I]f we want<br />

to grow in the<br />

first aspect of<br />

prudence, we<br />

should take<br />

steps not only<br />

to form our<br />

conscience ...<br />

but also develop<br />

our relationship<br />

with God ...<br />

and study His<br />

precepts given<br />

by Scripture and<br />

the Church.<br />

St. Thomas Aquinas called prudence the first and most important<br />

of the natural virtues. Without the first aspect of prudence, we would be<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

337


Detachment:<br />

Disconnectedness or removal<br />

from worldly concerns and<br />

temptations in order to focus<br />

on things that truly matter.<br />

hazy about the good to accomplish and evil to be avoided, and this confusion<br />

renders us powerless to do the good. Without the second aspect<br />

of prudence, we might know what we should do, but we would not have<br />

the skills and discipline to do the good or defeat the evil. When both aspects<br />

of prudence are present, there is no stopping us. We will be forces<br />

for good and the Kingdom of God — forces to defeat evil and injustice.<br />

The Second Natural Virtue: Temperance<br />

Prudence leads us to the point of promptly moving our first steps into<br />

action, but now we face the challenge of finishing the course — of getting<br />

to the goal. Two things can really stand in the way of accomplishing<br />

our goal:<br />

■ Allowing our passions and ego to get in the way.<br />

■ Becoming fearful or discouraged when we meet obstacles to our goal.<br />

As we grow in<br />

love of God and<br />

refinement of<br />

conscience, we<br />

open ourselves<br />

to God’s<br />

presence and<br />

grace as well as<br />

the persuasions<br />

of conscience.<br />

The virtues of temperance and fortitude are important complements<br />

to prudence to help us combat these potential obstacles.<br />

Temperance is the virtue of disciplining or moderating our passions and<br />

ego. Temperance requires self-control. Fortitude is the virtue or discipline<br />

of productively contending with fear and discouragement. Let us<br />

first consider the virtue of temperance and then the virtue of fortitude.<br />

Psychologists would say there are two dimensions of our selves — a<br />

rational-prudent dimension and a base egotistical dimension. It is not<br />

enough for us to cultivate prudence through forming and following<br />

conscience and being in close relationship with God. We must also have<br />

the capacity to say “no” to our base and egotistical self. If we are incapable<br />

of saying “no” and allowing the prudent self to reign, we are likely<br />

to suffer a sad fate and never reach our goals.<br />

How do we develop temperance? First, we must develop the virtue<br />

of prudence through the formation of conscience and a relationship<br />

with God. As we grow in love of God and refinement of conscience, we<br />

open ourselves to God’s presence and grace as well as the persuasions<br />

of conscience.<br />

Secondly, when temptation inevitably comes, we must learn to<br />

resist it. To do so, we must first and foremost turn to prayer to bring<br />

the presence and grace of God into our struggle with temptation. We<br />

should also practice indifference to the temptation. For example, if we<br />

are tempted by anger, we might tell ourselves and God, “I could care<br />

less about what this person did to me — it is not a matter of great concern.”<br />

Indifference leads to detachment, the enemy of temptation.<br />

338 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


Some spiritual writers also recommend thinking about the negative<br />

consequences of acting on the temptation to sin, such as the risk to our<br />

salvation, the harm we would be doing to others, and the harm to ourselves,<br />

so that we might fear acting on the temptation. This fear, like<br />

indifference, causes us to detach from the temptation, which weakens<br />

its effect over us. When indifference to temptation and fear of the consequences<br />

of sin are combined, we have a significantly increased opportunity<br />

to disengage from temptation.<br />

Fasting is another method long recommended by the Church (and<br />

practiced by Our Lord Himself) to resist temptation. It is linked with<br />

prayer many times in the Bible. By being able to say “no” to our hunger<br />

in the name of God or another good, we practice being in control of<br />

ourselves. We remind our belly, the traditional location of the passions,<br />

that our head (the intellect) is in control and directing our will. Fasting is<br />

a powerful weapon against Satan, and a necessary one. St. Gregory the<br />

Great wrote, “It is impossible to engage in spiritual combat, without the<br />

previous subjugation of the appetite.”<br />

As we practice these techniques, we become more adept at recognizing<br />

and opposing temptation almost immediately after it starts. The<br />

more quickly we resist temptation, the less powerful it will be, making it<br />

easier to defeat. Further, the more we quickly respond to temptation,<br />

the more we will develop a track record of successful resistance and<br />

build a habit of resistance.<br />

Fasting: Voluntarily going<br />

without food for a certain<br />

time. Along with prayer, fasting<br />

can strengthen us against<br />

sinful temptations. On Ash<br />

Wednesday and Good Friday,<br />

the Church requires healthy<br />

adults to fast, defined as<br />

eating no more than one full<br />

meal and two smaller meals<br />

that together do not equal<br />

one meal on those days.<br />

We must first and foremost<br />

turn to prayer.<br />

Conversion of St. Augustine by Fra Angelico (ca. 1430–1435).<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

339


The Third Natural Virtue: Fortitude (Courage)<br />

As opposed to temperance, which resists excessive or evil passions, fortitude<br />

encourages good initiatives. Most philosophers say that fear and<br />

lack of resolve stop us from actualizing our good intentions. Fortitude,<br />

then, is the virtue of contending with fear (courage) and developing resolve<br />

to actualize good intentions.<br />

Most of us have experienced how debilitating fear can be. Perhaps<br />

there was a time when we could have done some good, like standing<br />

up for a classmate who was being made fun of, but did nothing out of<br />

fear of being ridiculed or rejected. Fear of loss of esteem, failure, injury,<br />

loss of status, ridicule, and the like brings so many of our best intentions<br />

to nothing. As the philosopher Edmund Burke noted, “The only thing<br />

necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing.” It is<br />

for this reason the ancient philosophers placed so much emphasis on<br />

courage and fortitude.<br />

How can we develop courage? Three techniques can help:<br />

1. Use spontaneous prayers to invite God’s grace into the situation<br />

to help alleviate fear.<br />

2. Be rational. When a sense of panic begins to arise, think about<br />

questions that will help deal with the situation, such as, “What<br />

is the worst thing that can happen, and how can I lessen it?”<br />

or “Who can I consult for help?” As we ask and answer these<br />

questions, we get a sense of rational control, which brings our<br />

fear level down considerably.<br />

3. Reach out to experts and friends for help.<br />

Fortitude helps us not to lose<br />

heart.<br />

The Repentance of St. Peter by Johannes Moreelse (ca. 1630).<br />

340 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


The truly courageous person does not rush headlong into danger<br />

but rather is prayerful and rational in making deliberate choices to contend<br />

with the challenge. When we practice these three techniques, fear<br />

naturally subsides, which makes us free to do what we need to do.<br />

As we have seen, many of our best intentions are not reducible to<br />

a single short-term action. They have multiple steps extended over<br />

time that may require significant effort. They may require us to struggle<br />

through many obstacles. As with temperance, prudence is the foundation<br />

on which fortitude is built. When we see a need and opportunity to<br />

do the good (or defeat evil), prudence can help us recognize our part in<br />

bringing that good to reality. It can also help us to form form goals and<br />

plans, do research, and initiate actions. Fortitude is the habit of maintaining<br />

our effort and enthusiasm to bring the good to reality over the<br />

course of time and the habit of believing in our ultimate success amidst<br />

protracted struggles and obstacles. The traditional location of the will is<br />

the heart. Fortitude helps us counteract the tendency to become discouraged<br />

or, as we often say, lose heart.<br />

How do we maintain our effort and enthusiasm and believe we will<br />

succeed? Four techniques will prove useful:<br />

1. Use spontaneous prayers to ask the Lord to give increased<br />

resolve to actualize a particular good or defeat a particular evil.<br />

2. Believe in the nobility of your cause. The more we recognize the<br />

nobility of our call, the less likely we will be to lose enthusiasm<br />

for the effort and the more our hearts will be disposed to work<br />

and struggle over the long term.<br />

3. Believe in ultimate success amidst challenges, obstacles, and<br />

struggles. If we say to ourselves, “I will never succeed,” it will<br />

become a self-fulfilling prophecy, almost guaranteeing that we<br />

will lose our enthusiasm and energy. If we say, however, “I will be<br />

able to succeed, by the grace of God, if I am creative and patient<br />

enough in dealing with these obstacles,” it will similarly most<br />

likely lead to success.<br />

Fortitude is<br />

the habit of<br />

maintaining<br />

our effort and<br />

enthusiasm to<br />

bring the good<br />

to reality over<br />

the course<br />

of time and<br />

the habit of<br />

believing in<br />

our ultimate<br />

success amidst<br />

protracted<br />

struggles and<br />

obstacles.<br />

4. Stop looking only at the finish line. When we are only focused<br />

on the finish line, the end seems to never come fast enough,<br />

which discourages us and undermines our enthusiasm. What<br />

we really need to do is think about the next steps, because if<br />

we can complete those, and then the next steps, and so on, we<br />

will ultimately come to the finish line by simply believing in the<br />

nobility of our cause and the probability of our success.<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

341


Beatitudes: Eight ways of<br />

living Jesus taught at the<br />

Sermon on the Mount that will<br />

lead us to perfect happiness<br />

and fulfillment, which we<br />

ultimately find with God in<br />

Heaven.<br />

[P]rudence is<br />

oriented toward<br />

the good as<br />

recognized by<br />

the dictates of<br />

conscience and<br />

divine revelation.<br />

The Virtue of Love<br />

When we build a strong foundation of natural virtue, particularly the virtues<br />

of prudence, temperance, and fortitude, we become free to act for<br />

the ultimate goals of goodness and the Kingdom of God. Furthermore,<br />

the natural virtues help us recognize and resist temptation, overcome<br />

obstacles, and remain steadfast in the face of fear and danger. The natural<br />

virtues, however, are not enough on their own. They must be transformed<br />

by the supernatural virtues of faith, hope, and love to reach a<br />

much higher, graced level.<br />

As we have seen, without faith and prayer, the natural virtues<br />

emerge as weak in comparison to their transformation through grace.<br />

Hope in eternal life also transforms the natural virtues. When we have<br />

a sure hope in the resurrection, prudence is no longer oriented toward<br />

this life alone but toward eternal life. Additionally, hope gives temperance<br />

a whole new significance because we are not only resisting evil and<br />

temptation until death but rather for the sake of the Kingdom, which<br />

lasts forever. When we resist evil in this world, we not only help ourselves<br />

but many others into the Kingdom of Heaven. Furthermore, when we<br />

seek to do the good not only for the sake of this world but also for the<br />

Kingdom of God, it increases our motivation and sense of nobility, which<br />

increases our enthusiasm and energy to finish our good works amidst<br />

struggles and obstacles. As St. Paul declared, “I have fought the good<br />

fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith. Henceforth<br />

there is laid up for me the crown of righteousness, which the Lord,<br />

the righteous judge, will award to me on that Day, and not only to<br />

me but also to all who have loved his appearing” (2 Timothy 4:7–8).<br />

We now come to the supernatural virtue of love. How does love<br />

enhance the natural virtues to bring them and us to our highest perfection?<br />

As we have seen, prudence is oriented toward the good as<br />

recognized by the dictates of conscience and divine revelation. Also,<br />

as we have learned (see Unit 1), Jesus Christ (the highest point of<br />

divine revelation — the Son of God Himself) has declared love to be<br />

the highest good — the good to which all other virtues and commandments<br />

are oriented and the good that reflects the very heart of the<br />

Father. Thus, Jesus’ revelation of the essence of love (agapē) and His<br />

gift of the Holy Spirit to inspire it within us bring prudence’s objective<br />

of the good to perfection.<br />

Jesus transformed the notion of love not only by making it the highest<br />

commandment but by explaining it through the Beatitudes — the<br />

interior attitudes from which true love springs (see Matthew 5:3–11).<br />

342 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


Alms (Study for the picture Poor) by Josef Hanula (1894).<br />

Because Jesus’ idea of love is so rich and multifaceted, the early Church<br />

Fathers were led to create a set of eight sub-virtues of love that capture<br />

the different aspects of Jesus’ highest virtue:<br />

Jesus asks us to be generous.<br />

1. Contribution/generosity<br />

2. Gratitude<br />

3. Care for others<br />

4. Humble-heartedness<br />

5. Gentle-heartedness<br />

6. Compassion<br />

7. Forgiveness<br />

8. Chastity<br />

Let us look now at each of these in turn.<br />

Contribution/Generosity<br />

Jesus exhorts us to give to the poor, to be a servant, to help the needy,<br />

and to spread the Faith. In other words, be generous. We have learned<br />

that the third level of happiness, contributive-empathetic happiness,<br />

refocuses our lives away from sensuality and materialism and ego-centric<br />

comparisons (levels 1 and 2 happiness). The more we contribute,<br />

the greater our positive effect on others, the community, the Kingdom<br />

of God, and the culture. These contributions, rather than depleting us,<br />

fulfill us. Jesus tells us that whoever wishes to be great must be a servant<br />

to others (Matthew 20:26), implying that true greatness is perfection<br />

in love, and perfection in love is service and generosity to others.<br />

Jesus exhorts<br />

us to give to the<br />

poor, to be a<br />

servant, to help<br />

the needy, and<br />

to spread the<br />

faith.<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

343


Christ lends us the ultimate<br />

example.<br />

Christ Washing the Apostles’ Feet by Dirck van Baburen (ca. 1616).<br />

Gratitude<br />

Gratitude is not only the key to virtue but also to happiness and prayer.<br />

The grateful person who takes nothing for granted sees his life as a<br />

blessing from God and others. The ungrateful person, however, is continually<br />

tormented by what he does not have, consumed by resentment,<br />

anger, and envy. The former cannot help but be happy while the<br />

latter consigns himself and others around him to misery.<br />

Jesus asks us to give thanks to God and calls the sacrificial offering<br />

of His own Body and Blood Eucharist, which means “thanksgiving.” The<br />

saints have taught us to take nothing for granted but rather to recognize<br />

God’s blessing and to give thanks. When we show someone gratitude,<br />

we are not only recognizing the love extended to us but also expressing<br />

our love for the gift they have given us. In a very real way, the<br />

spiritual life begins with gratitude — it is our most fundamental expression<br />

of love.<br />

Care for Others<br />

This sub-virtue of love arises out of our natural power and desire for<br />

empathy. We can switch on this natural power and desire by simply<br />

looking for the good in others. When we look for the good in others,<br />

we put the bad within the context of the unique goodness and lovability<br />

of the other, which prevents the bad from controlling our feelings<br />

344 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


about them. Then, empathy and respect for the person begins to naturally<br />

arise. Empathy goes further; it seeks to do the good for others not<br />

only out of a sense of duty but as a loving gift of self that brings joy and<br />

fulfillment in spirit. When we genuinely care about others, their welfare<br />

becomes connected to our own; their joy becomes our joy.<br />

Humble-heartedness<br />

Humble-heartedness (the first Beatitude) in the Christian context is<br />

the conviction that every person is uniquely and equally good, worthy,<br />

lovable, and transcendent before God, who created each of us with a<br />

unique, transcendent, and eternal soul. Though we are transcendent<br />

creatures wonderfully made (Psalm 139:14) in the very image and likeness<br />

of God (Genesis 1:27), we are not God. We cannot attempt to be<br />

God for anyone, including ourselves. Thus, we should not see ourselves<br />

as superior to others. God alone is superior, and all of us share the same<br />

common characteristics of creatures called to fulfillment in Him.<br />

Gentle-heartedness<br />

Gentle-heartedness (the third Beatitude, “meekness”), like humble-heartedness,<br />

begins with empathy coming from looking for the<br />

good in others. Distinct from humble-heartedness, gentle-heartedness<br />

affirms the goodness and lovability of others in their weakness and fallibility,<br />

while humble-heartedness affirms the truth about oneself in relation<br />

to God and others.<br />

[G]entleheartedness<br />

affirms the<br />

goodness and<br />

lovability of<br />

others in their<br />

weakness<br />

and fallibility,<br />

while humbleheartedness<br />

affirms the truth<br />

about oneself in<br />

relation to God<br />

and others.<br />

Gentle-heartedness goes beyond looking for the good in others. It<br />

is a sublime expression of love because it continually attempts to put<br />

ourselves in the shoes of others and to see them through the unconditionally<br />

loving eyes of Jesus, who sees everyone’s unique goodness<br />

and lovability even when our behaviors suggest sin, selfishness, impiousness,<br />

and darkness.<br />

Compassion<br />

Compassion builds on care, humble-heartedness, and gentle-heartedness<br />

because it originates from empathy encouraged by looking for the<br />

good in others. Compassion differs from these other virtues because<br />

it arises out of the context of suffering (compassion means “to suffer<br />

with”). As we have seen, when we truly empathize with others, their welfare<br />

becomes connected to our own, so that even their suffering causes<br />

suffering within us.<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

345


Chasity: The true integration<br />

of sexuality within a person’s<br />

bodily and spiritual being. It<br />

includes an apprenticeship<br />

in self-mastery. Each of us is<br />

called to chastity.<br />

Jesus taught that compassion is the highest form of love, identifying<br />

it with the perfection of His Father’s love (Luke 6:36–38). As<br />

we have learned, this most difficult yet most perfect form of love has<br />

transformed the world. It has led the Catholic Church to start hospitals,<br />

schools, and public welfare organizations, take actions to mitigate<br />

the cruelties and slavery of Rome and beyond, and improved the lot of<br />

billions of people throughout history. The Catholic Church is, by a vast<br />

margin, the largest international educational and healthcare provider in<br />

the world.<br />

Forgiveness<br />

Jesus mentioned forgiveness more often than any other moral precept<br />

in the Gospels. Without forgiveness, we are left in a world where vengeance<br />

begets vengeance and violence begets violence. A world without<br />

forgiveness not only undermines families and friendships but also<br />

organizations and culture. Jesus models the ideal of forgiveness on His<br />

Father, showing us that radical forgiveness exemplifies the heart of His<br />

Father as revealed in the Parable of the Prodigal Son.<br />

We owe<br />

forgiveness to<br />

one another<br />

because we<br />

have already<br />

received and<br />

will continue to<br />

receive the far<br />

greater mercy<br />

of God.<br />

We owe forgiveness to one another because we have already received<br />

and will continue to receive the far greater mercy of God. If we<br />

deny others forgiveness, then God is justified in denying forgiveness<br />

to us. For Jesus, it is better to forgive others because we feel genuine<br />

concern and care for them than to forgive them out of mere compliance<br />

with God’s just command. Though it is good to obey God’s just<br />

commands, it is much better to imitate the heart of the Father by genuinely<br />

loving the person who has unjustly sinned against us. This love can<br />

be difficult. But if we pray to God and turn the offense and offender<br />

over to God, we free ourselves from the burden of exacting retribution,<br />

a goal that only stokes the fires of anger, bitterness, and resentment.<br />

Through prayer, we can begin the process of letting go of the just claim<br />

we have over the offender and truly forgive them.<br />

Chastity<br />

Chastity is related to the virtue of temperance. It is the moral virtue<br />

that helps us manage our desires for bodily and spiritual pleasure in the<br />

way God intended. It specifically involves self-mastery of our sexuality,<br />

keeping it in its proper place. It means we practice self-control by bringing<br />

the passions under the direction of our intellect. Christianity has always<br />

included chastity as one of the subsidiary virtues of love because<br />

violations of it result in unloving acts, the undermining of marriage and<br />

346 Apologetics II: Challenges of the Modern World<br />

© Magis Center


Radical forgiveness is found<br />

in the Parable of the Prodigal<br />

Son.<br />

The Return of the Prodigal Son by Rembrandt (ca. 1668).<br />

family, and the undermining of our spiritual life. Jesus’ conviction about<br />

the importance of this virtue is attested to by His teaching that even<br />

imagining illicit sexual relationships constitutes adultery of the heart<br />

and undermines our relationship with God and others (see Matthew<br />

5:27–28). As we learned in Units 3–5, the consequences of violating the<br />

virtue of chastity show why it is one of the most important virtues for<br />

an individual’s emotional, relational, and spiritual health as well as the<br />

well-being of marriage and family.<br />

Conclusion<br />

Almost every aspect of our culture encourages us to violate the teaching<br />

of Jesus regarding chastity by promising whole new levels of freedom<br />

and fulfillment. Unfortunately, however, it is a false promise on almost<br />

every level. If we look at the issue from the opposite perspective,<br />

we can see the benefits of chastity as Jesus defined it — significant increases<br />

in emotional health, relationships with others spiritual practice,<br />

and relationship with God, self-respect, respect for others, emotional<br />

intimacy within marriage, familial stability, marital satisfaction, security<br />

of children, and responsible contributive action within society.<br />

© Sophia Institute for Teachers Unit 6, Chapter 15: The Life-Giving Virtues<br />

347

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!