i'tt)ii 1 - PoCoMotion
i'tt)ii 1 - PoCoMotion
i'tt)ii 1 - PoCoMotion
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
-•- i-<br />
i’tt)<strong>ii</strong> 1<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
ENVIRONMENTAL ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE<br />
AGENDA OF TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2012<br />
3RD FLOOR - HERITAGE ROOM, 4:00 PM<br />
City Hall, 2580 Shaughnessy Street, Port Coquitlarn, BC<br />
L ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA Page<br />
1.1 November 20, 2012 Regular Meeting Agenda<br />
Reconnne,,dafjo,,: That the Agenda of the NoveLnber 20, 2012<br />
Environmental Enhancement Committee meeting be adopted as circulated.<br />
2. ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES<br />
2.1 September 18, 2012 Committee Minutes<br />
Reconunendation: That the Minutes of the September 18, 2012<br />
Environmental Enhancement Committee meetings be adopted as circulated.<br />
DELEGATIONS<br />
4. REPORTS<br />
4.1 Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC Update<br />
Recoinniendation:<br />
3-58<br />
That the report titled “Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC<br />
Update” dated November 15, 2012 be received for information.<br />
4.2 Community Charging Infrastructure Fund Electric Vehicle Charging<br />
Station Planning Study - Status Update<br />
Recommendation:<br />
That the staff report titled “Community Charging Infrastructure Fund Electric<br />
59-64<br />
Vehicle Charging Station Planning Study -<br />
15, 2012 be received for information.<br />
Status Update” dated November<br />
4.3 2012-2013 Waste-Loss Challenge Contest 65-66<br />
Recommendation:<br />
That the staff report titled “2012-2013 Waste-Loss Challenge Contest” dated<br />
November 14, 2012, be received for information.<br />
I ACTION TABLE<br />
5.1 Business Arising from Minutes & Action Table - November 20, 2012 67-68<br />
6. INFORMATION ITEMS<br />
6.1 Coquitlam RiverWatch Newsletter -<br />
2012 Issues<br />
August, September and October 69-77<br />
6.2 Hyde Creek Watershed Society Minutes - November 7, 2012 78-80<br />
6.3 Burke Mountain Naturalists - October and November 2012 Issues 81-96
Environmental Enhancement Committee<br />
November 20, 2012<br />
Page 2<br />
7. OTHER ITEMS<br />
& ADJOURNMENT
Pf2R.T Report to Committee<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
DATE: November 15 th, 2012<br />
To: Environmental Enhancement Committee<br />
FROM: A. V. Jensen. B. Tech. AScT.<br />
Manager of Environmental Sen’ices<br />
SUBJECT: Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC Update<br />
RECOMMENDATION:<br />
That the report titled “Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC Update” dated<br />
November 15, 2012 be received for information.<br />
PURPOSE:<br />
The purpose of this report is to provide Committee with an update regarding the on-going<br />
development of Multi-Material BC’s (MMBC) planning and implementation of an Extended<br />
Producer Responsibility (EPR) Program for Packaging and Printed Paper. An earlier report was<br />
provided at the November 2011 and July 2012 Environmental Enhancement Committee<br />
meetings.<br />
BACKGROUND:<br />
On May 19, 2011, the Provincial Government added Packaging and Printed Paper (PPP) to the<br />
Recycling Regulation, creating a requirement for the industry to design and implement an<br />
Extended Producer Responsibility program for residents and in public places like sidewalks,<br />
squares and parks. Industry must submit a stewardship plan by November 19, 2012 and begin<br />
operating the program by May 19, 2014. To date, Multi-Material BC (MMBC) is the only<br />
organization that has come forward acting as a stewardship agency on behalf of many producers<br />
(i.e. brand owners and first sellers) to manage the development and implementation of this new<br />
EPR program.<br />
On September 6, 2012, MMBC requested a 1-year extension to develop and implement the<br />
stewardship plan, which was not supported by the Ministry of Environment (MOE).<br />
[mw<br />
1 PAGE<br />
4j
November 15 th 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper -<br />
Page 2<br />
Multi-Material BC<br />
At the September UBCM Conference, MMBC provided a presentation on the next steps for the<br />
PPP Program in BC and the attached UBCM Policy Paper was distributed to the UBCM<br />
members for their endorsement.<br />
Consultants for MMBC met with City staff on October 19, 2012 to be briefed on the activities<br />
undertaken to develop the stewardship plan, to seek our views and input and discuss the next<br />
steps.<br />
On October 23, 2012, MMBC released the attached Draft Packaging and Printed Paper<br />
Stewardship Plan and accompanying Draft List of PPP to be collected under PPP Stewardship<br />
Plans and Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation and held a consultation<br />
workshop on October 29, 2012.<br />
DISCUSSION:<br />
The Draft PPP Stewardship Plan has an overarching objective of “continuous improvement in<br />
recovery effectiveness and efficiency without undennining existing PPP recovery efforts in BC”<br />
and principles that include:<br />
• Focus on outcomes, not process;<br />
• Provide economic incentives and set simple rules;<br />
• Foster interaction, collaboration and competition to drive innovation; and<br />
• Set the stage for evolution.<br />
The collection and processing of PPP in BC involves a complex relationship between private,<br />
public and non-profit entities to recover PPP from residents and deliver to recycling end-markets.<br />
Collection<br />
• MMBC will enter into agreements with qualified collectors to collect and transport<br />
recyclables to Material Recovery Facilities;<br />
• MMBC will offer a market clearing price (i.e. A payment available to service providers<br />
designed to stimulate marketplace activities and act as a market clearing mechanism) to<br />
collectors that will be made available in April-June 2013;<br />
• Where single-family and multi-family recycling is set out at curbside and for streetscape<br />
recycling, MMBC will offer local governments the first right of refusal to provide<br />
collection services at the market clearing price, before tendering the contract to the<br />
private sector;<br />
• All collectors must meet MMBC’s collector qualification standards, which will be<br />
developed in consultation with stakeholders;<br />
• Collectors must provide residents with free collection;
November 15 IH, 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper -<br />
Page 3<br />
Multi-Material BC<br />
• MMBC will pay collectors when its approved material recovery facilities (MRF) accept<br />
the PPP with collectors responsible for contaminated loads; and<br />
• MMBC intends to establish agreements with collectors in April-June 2013 and publish a<br />
list of qualified collectors before it issues a Request for Proposal (RFP) for processing<br />
services.<br />
Processing<br />
• MMBC will contract with processors to receive, sort and market recyclables at Material<br />
Recovery Facilities;<br />
• MMBC may also include the consolidation and transferring of recyclables in some<br />
contracts;<br />
• The contract will include provisions to share the market revenue and commodity risk (i.e.<br />
market value of material);<br />
• MMBC expects processors to be the gate-keeper of material quality and reject<br />
contaminated loads; and<br />
• MMBC expects processors to establish relationships with collectors and respond as a<br />
partnership to the RFP.<br />
Collection Method for Recyclables<br />
• Curbside — everything accepted in the Blue Cart, including other rigid plastics, polycoat<br />
cartons and cups, tetrapaks, aluminum foil, aerosol cans, spiral wound cans;<br />
• Depot — Styrofoam, film plastics (overwrap), plastic laminates (cheese wrap) and paper-<br />
•<br />
plastic (blister packages); and<br />
After May 2014 new materials will be added as the end-markets expand.<br />
Financing<br />
Target<br />
• All PPP producers will pay fees to cover the cost of the program and will be passed on to<br />
the consumer although they will be less than a penny for most products; and<br />
• Producers of PPP that is not currently recyclable will be required to pay additional fees to<br />
cover R&D for recycling solutions and technologies.<br />
• Producers are responsible for recovering 75% of all PPP, while the current recycling<br />
systems in BC have a recovery rate between 50-57%.
November 15 th 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC<br />
Page 4<br />
Schedule & Timelines<br />
• November 9, 2012 - Comments on draft Stewardship Plan due to MMBC;<br />
• November 19, 2012 - Deadline for MMBC to submit Stewardship Plan to MOE;<br />
• December 14, 2012— Additional comments on draft Stewardship Plan due to MMBC;<br />
• January2013 — MMBC submits updated Stewardship Plan to MOE;<br />
• April — June 2013 — MMBC makes agreements for collection services and issues RFP for<br />
processing services;<br />
• July — September 2013 — MMBC issues Request for Expression of Interest to local<br />
•<br />
government for streetscapes recycling pilot;<br />
April — May 2014— MMBC makes agreements for streetscapes collection; and<br />
• May 19, 2014 — MMBC begins operating the PPP program with collectors and<br />
processors.<br />
Metro Vancouver (MV) and member municipalities have continued to engage MMBC and MOE<br />
on this program. Several key municipal interests are currently being considered by REAC Solid<br />
Waste Subcommittee and are summarized as follows:<br />
• Recovery Rate Target: Each type of packaging and printed paper achieve minimum<br />
targets. Once generation data is available, no later than year 4. targets for reusability and<br />
recyclability should be set by the type of packaging and material type.<br />
• Consultation Process: The period for comments on the draft Stewardship Plan is not<br />
sufficient time for local government to express their concerns and provide input in the<br />
development of the Stewardship Plan.<br />
• Enhance Recycling and Stabilize Commodity Markets: Recovery targets should be<br />
set for individual packaging types and materials. This promotes resiliency to swings in<br />
commodity markets.<br />
• Increase Local Processing of Recyclables: The program should adopt practices which<br />
stimulate local demand for recycled commodities.<br />
• Each type of Packaging Pays its Way: Program financing and producer fees section of<br />
the plan should be clarified to ensure that each product type/material type pays its own<br />
expenses, with no cross-subsidization from other product types/material types.<br />
• Maintain Or Improve Service Levels: Service levels must be maintained or improved<br />
in all cases. At a high level, the plan proposes to maintain or improve service levels.<br />
Further details are needed to ensure that equivalent service levels are maintained<br />
regarding:<br />
o Frequency of pick-up<br />
o Response to missed pick-ups<br />
o Cleanliness<br />
JITEM PAGEJ<br />
[
November 15 th 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper -<br />
Page 5<br />
Multi-Material<br />
BC<br />
• Education and Outreach: Education and outreach for PPP must be delivered within the<br />
integrated waste reduction activities in each local government. Communication must be<br />
coordinated with consistent messaging to ensure residents know how to place<br />
discards/materials in the correct containers.<br />
a Performance Measures: In addition to these indictors, the program should include the<br />
Recycling Rate (amount of material ‘recycled’ expressed against the amount of material<br />
supplied). Indicators should be expressed for each packaging type/material type (similar<br />
to the report produced by Encorp Pacific).<br />
• Waste Reduction Hierarchy: include an indicator on the reduction in mass per unit of<br />
PPP. Report on the quantity of materials that were reused, recycled, incinerated, and<br />
residual management.<br />
• Legal Responsibility for EPR Materials: In consultation with local government, the<br />
plan should identify a method of determining how to compensate local government for<br />
managing EPR materials in the garbage, and a commitment to research options to<br />
measure perforn-iance and address street litter and illegal dumping.<br />
• Dispute Resolution: Clarify whether the dispute resolution process also applies between<br />
collectors and processors, in addition to between MMBC and collectors and MMBC and<br />
processors. There exists possible conflicts between collectors and processors regarding<br />
contamination, queuing times, etc.<br />
• Encourage Packaging Reduction: Develop financial incentives and performance<br />
measures for producers to avoid/reduce the packaging required by their product (e.g.,<br />
differential eco-fees. measure the product to packaging ratio).<br />
• Design for Reuse and Recycling: Ensure that packaging discards are managed at the<br />
highest levels of the pollution prevention hierarchy. Develop prohibitions against the use<br />
of PPP that is not recyclable.<br />
implications and Concerns<br />
At this stage of the EPR PPP program there are still many unanswered questions and details<br />
about the specifics of the program that is necessary in order to make informed decisions, such as:<br />
• Consultation Process & Timelines: The consultation process continues to only allow a<br />
short period of time for local government to review the information once received and<br />
dialogue with Committee and Council;<br />
• Quality of Service to Residents: For single-family homes there seems to be a<br />
commitment to curbside collection; however, collection for multi-family homes may vary<br />
based on whether or not the pickup is from private property or City property;<br />
ITEM FAGE
November 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC<br />
Page 6<br />
• Level of Involvement in PPP Service Delivery: The City could possibly have a role as a<br />
collector for single-family, multi-family, depots and streetscape along with promotion<br />
and customer service;<br />
• Market Clearing Price: The market clearing price is a yet to be determined financial<br />
incentive for the City to provide collection services, public education and promotion and<br />
first point of contact for collection service customers. Will the market clearing price<br />
account for “key driver” variables such as distance between pick up points, # of multi<br />
family units per building, # households, distance to processing facility, capital costs and<br />
depreciation of trucks, tonnage of materials, etc.?;<br />
• Collection for ICE An extension of the PPP program to the industrial, commercial and<br />
institutional (ICl) sectors will occur before May 2017; however, in the meantime the City<br />
provides recycling collection services to lCl and in particular to schools which is<br />
currently commingled with residential collection for an efficient truck route pickup;<br />
• Partnership between the Collectors & Processors: It may be necessary for the City to<br />
determine the procedure to choose a processor and have a separate partnership agreement<br />
in place prior to the processor responding to the MMBC RFP:<br />
• Depots: The future of the existing City glass depots and the arrangement for new depots<br />
that will take styrofoam and film plastics is yet to be determined.<br />
• Arrangement for Streetscape Collection: The locations for the City’s current eco<br />
containers may not meet the criteria set by MMBC; however, the specifics of a<br />
streetscape collection program will be provided at a later date.<br />
• Arrangement for Event Collection: It’s unknown whether collection of recyclables<br />
during an event will be included in the PPP program and associated market clearing<br />
price.<br />
Staff will continue to engage in discussions and forums, and report back accordingly.<br />
CONCLUSION:<br />
MMBC has distributed the Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan on October 23,<br />
2012 and required final comments by December 14, 2012.<br />
Metro Vancouver and member municipalities have drafted an initial list of common interests and<br />
are planning to relay supported comments to the Province and MMBC as part of the<br />
development of the EPR PPP program. In the meantime, there are several potential implications<br />
and concerns that require further detailed information from MMBC in order to determine their<br />
level of influence or impact to the City.
November 15”, 2012<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper - Multi-Material BC<br />
Page 7<br />
It is recommended that Committee be provided an update once MMBC submits their final<br />
Stewardship Plan to MOE and the market clearing price has been issued in the first quarter of the<br />
new year.<br />
Allen Jensen,k Tech., AScT<br />
Manager of Environmental Services<br />
Approved by Andrew Wood, Ph.D., P.Eng.<br />
Director of Engineering & Operations<br />
Attachments: I. UBCM Policy Paper: Packaging and Printed Paper Product Stewardship<br />
2. MMBC: Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
3. Draft List of PPP to be collected under PPP Stewardship Plans<br />
4. Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation
TO: IJBCM Members<br />
FROM: 123CM Executive<br />
DATE: September 26, 2011<br />
RE: Packaging and Printed Paper Product<br />
Stewardship<br />
1. DECISION REQUEST<br />
That the paper be endorsed by the 123CM membership.<br />
2. PURPOSE<br />
The purpose of the policy paper is to:<br />
• identify key local government issues arid concerns with the proposed product<br />
stewardship program for packaging arid printed paper;<br />
• propose recommendations for resolving potential local government issues with<br />
the implementation of the packaging and printed paper product stewardship<br />
program;<br />
• build local government knowledge and capacity around packaging and printed<br />
paper product stewardship to assist in negotiations with producers; and<br />
• support a smooth transition in the responsibility of managing packaging and<br />
printed paper (Pt’?) to producers.<br />
3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />
POLICY PAPER<br />
The paper contains the following key recommendations for designing and<br />
implementing a packaging and printed paper (PPP) product stewardship program:<br />
That producers are responsible jbr, and have an obligation to, manage one hundred percent<br />
(100%) of the packaging and printed paper waste in British Columbia. Tins obligation includes<br />
an extension of the PPP program to the industrial, commercial and institutional (IC!) sector<br />
within three (3) years of the program start-up, as well as local government coinpensation for the<br />
management of PPP materials that end up in local government waste streams.<br />
That the packaging and printed paper product stewardship program provides an equitable level<br />
of service between urban and rural areas, and that existing levels of service be maintained or<br />
exceeded for those local governments that have established PPP prograins in place.<br />
That local governments be given the right offirst refusal for providing packaging and printed<br />
paper product stewardship services under the new PPP program. This option would minimize<br />
#2<br />
2012 CONVEWTION
#2:Pc.ckciein e.wuLPEted Paver Product Srewa,dshiv Policy Pavgr Pcwe 2 of 10<br />
and/or prevent any disruption to existing services, employment and service contracts, and<br />
community expectations.<br />
That the design and implementation of the PPP program includes measures and incentives for<br />
redesigning packaging and printed paper, to ensure that the program moves PPP up the<br />
pollution prevention hierarchy and eliminates the need for landfihling and/or incineration of<br />
program materials.<br />
4. BACKGROUND<br />
In May 2011, the Recycling Regulation was amended to include packaging and printed<br />
paper. The amendment shifts financial and administrative responsibility for managing<br />
these materials from local governments to the producers of packaging and printed<br />
paper (PPP). This transfer of responsibility is intended to incent producers of PPP to<br />
incorporate environmental considerations in the design of their products.<br />
The addition of packaging, and to a lesser extent printed paper, is partly in response to<br />
local government requests. In particular, the LJBCM membership has consistently<br />
endorsed resolutions calling for the development of strategies to reduce unnecessary<br />
product packaging, as well as the creation of product stewardship programs for<br />
packaging (1987-B69; 1990-A14; 1991-818; 1995-B38; 1997-B1 1; 1999-B14; 2000-B20; 2004-<br />
813; 2005-B115; 2006-B29; 2008-B31). Most recently, Resolution 2009-839 called for all<br />
packaging to be placed under the BC product stewardship legislation. When<br />
considering packaging, the membership has similarly called for the addition of milk<br />
containers to the Recycling Regulation and the deposit refund system (2011- 838, 2010-<br />
B27).<br />
The product stewardship program will be developed by key producers, which may<br />
include: the Canada Food and Restaurant Services Association, Retail Council of<br />
Canada, Canada Newspaper Association, Food and Consumer Producers of Canada,<br />
the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers, and potentially others. The producers<br />
are represented by Multi Material British Columbia (MMBC), which is a not-for-profit<br />
agency established under the British Columbia Society Act formed in anticipation of the<br />
requirement to develop, submit and implement a stewardship plan for packaging and<br />
printed paper. MMBC’s intention is to assume the role of a stewardship agency in<br />
order to discharge the obligations of PPP producers under Schedule 5 of the Recycling<br />
Regulation. However, some producers may choose to pursue their product<br />
stewardship obligations independently, which may impact collection and recycling<br />
efforts on multiple levels.<br />
Since the amendment to the Regulation, several local govermnents have raised concerns<br />
over what service levels and targets will be included in the program. These concerns<br />
include, but are not limited to: how the program will work with local governments to<br />
ensure there is not a decline in service levels; how the interface with collection systems<br />
under union and procured service contracts will be managed; how collected materials<br />
will be managed; local capacity to manage any increase in collected materials; how the<br />
program will incent more recyclable packaging; and how local governments could be
#2:Packuinp and Printed Payer Product Stewardship Pplkv Paper Ppue 3 of 10<br />
compensated for the capital investments that have been made in the existing collection<br />
infrastructure.<br />
In response to local government concerns and issues, the UECM Executive approved<br />
the creation of a 118CM Packaging and Printed Paper Working Group, issued a call for<br />
nominations for representatives, and convened the first meeting in February 2012. The<br />
UBCM Packaging and Printed Paper Working Group is designed to provide a voice for<br />
local government on their expectations of an industry product stewardship program for<br />
PPP; provide information to build capacity in local government understanding of<br />
product stewardship as it applies to packaging and printed paper; and build local<br />
government capacity to effectively negotiate community interests with the producers.<br />
In addition, the Working Group will: act as a forum for discussing local government<br />
issues, both individual and collective, with the producers; identify relevant issues<br />
pertinent to the materials/products and scope in the May 2011 amendment that may<br />
require negotiating with industry; and identify and propose recommendations to the<br />
producers for resolving potential local government issues with the FF1’ program<br />
implementation. The Working Group is comprised of six appointed local government<br />
staff representatives from all regions on the province, a UBCM staff representative, a<br />
representative from the BC Product Stewardship Council, and a Ministry of<br />
Environment staff member that sits as a subject matter expert on provincial policy and<br />
regulation.<br />
Throughout the Winter and Spring of 2012, the Working Group met to finalize a terms<br />
of reference, identify local government concerns, and develop an issues compendium<br />
that would form the foundation of a policy paper. Delegations were also received from<br />
interested stakeholders, and communication materials about the efforts of the Working<br />
Group were distributed to local government area associations. The Working Group has<br />
sought to create recommendations that would advocate local government interests and<br />
positions, with the intent of having a policy paper considered by the membership prior<br />
to the producers’ submission of a product stewardship plan in November 2012.<br />
5. DISCUSSION<br />
According to the 2007 Environment Action Plan, the provincial framework for any new<br />
or expanded product stewardship program must contain the following measures:<br />
• be fully funded by the industry, in which the industry is responsible for all costs<br />
such as collection, transportation, and marketing of materials;<br />
• maximizes the recovery rate of products from local landfills, with a recovery rate<br />
of 85% or higher;<br />
• ensures the broadest choice of options for consumers, including the use of<br />
deposit refund systems and eco fees;<br />
• ensures the operation of a mixed collection system, including return to retailer,<br />
curbside and depots; and<br />
• links product stewardship programs to local solid waste management planning<br />
decisions of municipalities and regional districts.<br />
)2i
#2:Pac&npinu and Printed Paver Product Stewardship Pohcv Paver Pare 4 of 10<br />
The above position on product stewardship was endorsed by the full 138CM<br />
membership at the 2007 UFCM Convention, and acts as the foundation for discussion<br />
with the Province on all product stewardship programs, including packaging and<br />
printed paper.<br />
Upon review of the amended Recycling Regulation, and as a result of Ministry of<br />
Environment information sessions, local governments have identified several key<br />
concerns and issues with respect to the new extended producer responsibility programs<br />
on packaging and printed paper. These concerns pertain to the scope of the program,<br />
program design, environmental impact, financial and service provision issues, as well<br />
as the role of local government.<br />
Program Scope<br />
While recognizing the functionality of focusing on residential collection, several local<br />
governments have identified concerns over the product stewardship program’s focus<br />
on residential collection prior to industrial, commercial and institutional (ICI) collection.<br />
Local governments have invested heavily in the infrastructure, marketing and outreach<br />
of theft existing collection and recycling programs, including the ICI sector in some<br />
cases. Some local governments are concerned that producers may get to capitalize on<br />
the costly foundations they have laid. More importantly, the ICI sector generates more<br />
PPP than the residential sector, and improving the ICI diversion rate would contribute<br />
more to diversion and waste reduction targets than the diversion from the residential<br />
sector. As such, local governments wish to see an expansion of the product<br />
stewardship program to the Id sector as soon as possible, following the<br />
implementation of the program in the residential sector.<br />
Local governments have also identified concerns over the seventy-five percent (75%)<br />
recovery rate identified within the amended Recycling Regulation. To maximize<br />
recovery rates, the rate should focus on specific material categories as opposed to<br />
overall packaging composite, and the rate should be applied to each local government<br />
to ensure equivalency between rural and urban areas. There is also the recognition that<br />
in spite of the target recovery rate, producers have an obligation to manage one<br />
hundred percent (100%) of the packaging and printed paper waste. This is consistent<br />
with the product stewardship model within BC where producers are responsible for the<br />
entire life cycle of products. In addition, the program should cover all areas that local<br />
governments are currently servicing.<br />
Program Design<br />
Local governments have identified the need to move beyond simply diverting PPP<br />
materials from local landfills and incinerators to actively putting in place incentives and<br />
measures to re-design and re-use packaging and printed paper materials. There is a<br />
recognition that in order to move up the pollution prevention hierarchy, the producers<br />
need to develop market based incentives and/or design requirements for their<br />
products. Such measures would diminish the potential for difficult to recycle or nonrecyclable<br />
materials to be incinerated and/or landfilled, and would simultaneously<br />
reduce the carbon footprint of the product by minimizing production, storage,<br />
collection and transportation costs.
#2:Packagi,,p and Printed Paaer Product Stewardship Policy Paper PaRe 5 of 10<br />
Built-in consultation mechanisms also need to be established with the product<br />
stewardship program. Local governments require meaningful consultation, both in<br />
terms of time and opportunities, in the design of the PPP stewardship program as well<br />
as ongoing consultation and feedback mechanisms during the implementation of the<br />
program. Based on past experiences with product stewardship programs, local<br />
governments desire the opportunity to provide input on the program design if product<br />
stewards are not meeting their stated or expected service delivery levels. In particular,<br />
local governments require an enhanced dispute resolution process, whereby they have<br />
the right to receive compensation for impacted costs if producers are not providing<br />
adequate service levels that result in materials being sent to local landfills and/or<br />
incinerators.<br />
More importantly, the product stewardship program should incorporate flexible<br />
options that local governments can select to best meet the needs and interests of their<br />
respective communities. Many local governments throughout BC have established<br />
collection systems for packaging and printed paper, each with a set of community<br />
expectations around service levels, as well as associated infrastructure and employment<br />
and service contracts. Some local governments have identified the potential for the<br />
product stewardship program to impact existing employment and service contracts,<br />
particularly if the producers decide to contract out collection services or rely on depots<br />
instead of using existing local government staff and curbside programs. Implementing<br />
a “one size fits all” approach will not yield the greatest results. To improve the<br />
effectiveness of the product stewardship program, local governments should have the<br />
choice of either continuing to deliver services with fair compensation or selecting the<br />
producer’s contracted services for their communities. In effect, local governments<br />
should be given the right of first refusal for the provision of services. Similarly, the<br />
product stewardship program needs to be integrated with other waste management<br />
programs to create efficiencies, facilitate maximum recovery rates, and ensure high<br />
customer service.<br />
Environmental Impacts<br />
As stewards of their community, local governments are continuously implementing<br />
measures to protect the environment and address the impacts of climate change. Local<br />
governments believe that the product stewardship program should focus on clear<br />
environmental protection as opposed to simply the cost impacts on producers. The<br />
program should include measures and incentives for redesigning packaging, to ensure<br />
that the program moves up the pollution prevention hierarchy by eliminating the<br />
landfilling and/or incineration of collected program materials. Wherever possible, local<br />
governments maintain that producers should be seeking efficiencies within the<br />
collection, transportation and processing of materials to minimize the carbon footprint<br />
within affected communities.<br />
Funding<br />
Local governments have identified a wide range of costs associated with both their<br />
existing curbside collection programs for packaging as well as costs for the successful<br />
implementation of product stewardship programs. While British Columbia has a fully<br />
JPAGF1
#2.Packc-winQ unit Printed Paper Product Stewards/un Pp/in Paper Pare 6 of 10<br />
industry Funded model for product stewardship, local governments have<br />
acknowledged that they have frequently incurred some management costs for existing<br />
product stewardship programs when materials end up in local waste streams. In light<br />
of this experience, local governments require reimbursement for the management of<br />
any packaging and printed paper materials that end up in local government waste<br />
streams, which include garbage, public disposal facilities and illegal dumps.<br />
Compensation could be determined through standardized and industry funded waste<br />
audits that determine the amount of materials local governments handle. In addition,<br />
in accordance with the provincial product stewardship modeL the producers must be<br />
responsible for all “hard” and “soft” program costs including collection, transportation,<br />
processing, and public outreach and education.<br />
Recognizing that the producers may utilize either contracted services or existing local<br />
government infrastructure and collection programs, local governments have identified<br />
the need for fair compensation for their assistance in any packaging and printed paper<br />
product stewardship program. To date, it is unclear as to whether the producers will be<br />
providing compensation on a per household or service level basis, and on the level of<br />
compensation should local governments choose to participate in collection in the future.<br />
However, local governments maintain that compensation for participating in, or<br />
assisting with, the product stewardship program should be based on a local<br />
government’s true operating costs (capital, operation, maintenance, contract<br />
administration, education and outreach, advertising and disposal costs).<br />
Service Provision<br />
The level of service to be provided under the proposed packaging and printed paper<br />
product stewardship program emerges as one of the biggest concerns and issues for<br />
local governments. Local governments continue to identify service provision challenges<br />
within existing provincial product stewardship programs, particularly within more<br />
rural and remote areas. The new PPP extended producer responsibility program should<br />
ensure that rural and remote areas receive an equitable level of service as their urban<br />
counterparts so that the additional costs of managing PPP materials are not incurred by<br />
local governments.<br />
For those local governments that have established PPP programs in place, there is a<br />
concern that existing service levels and quality of service must be maintained or<br />
exceeded. Such local governments have invested significantly in the infrastructure of,<br />
and public education for, their PPP programs and have established community<br />
expectations around what constitutes quality service levels. As such, local governments<br />
require a seamless transition with the implementation of the new PPP program to<br />
prevent any disruptions to existing service levels, community expectations, and<br />
employment contracts. The latter is particularly important to several local<br />
governments, as there is concern that the new program could potentially impact<br />
existing employment contracts, both in terms timing with contract renewal, and with<br />
the failure to utilize existing union staff in providing the service. Moreover, there is a<br />
need for the producers to clarify how the PPP program will fit within existing solid<br />
waste management plans.<br />
H”i<br />
iTE fPASEI
#2:Packtwinc and Printed Paner Product Stewardship Policy Paner Paye 7 of 10<br />
Local Covemment Role<br />
All local governments will be directly impacted by the implementation of a new<br />
packaging and printed paper product stewardship program. However, to date, local<br />
governments are unclear as to role that local governments will play in managing PPP<br />
materials, as well as the level of local government consultation in the design and<br />
implementation of the program. This lack of clarity extends to whether there will be<br />
potential partnerships with the producers as well as who has ownership over collected<br />
packaging and printed materials. In order to be successfully implemented, the new<br />
product stewardship program must provide options and opportunities for local<br />
governments to play an active role in managing PEP. This structural flexibility is<br />
required given local government’s current administration of recycling and waste<br />
diversion programs, existing local government infrastructure, the linkage to solid waste<br />
management plans, and current community expectations around service levels.<br />
6. RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
That the following recommendations pertaining to the design and implementation of<br />
the packaging and printed paper product stewardship program be adopted by the<br />
118CM membership.<br />
That producers are responsible for, and have an obligation to, manage one hundred percent<br />
(100%) çf the packaging and printed paper waste in British Columbia. This obligation includes<br />
an extension of the PPP program to the industrial, commercial and institutional (ICI) sector<br />
within three (3) years of the program start-up, as well as local government compensation for the<br />
management of PPP materials that end up in local government waste streams.<br />
That the packaging and printed paper product stewardship program provides an equitable level<br />
of service between urban and rural areas, and that existing levels of service be maintained or<br />
exceeded for those local governments that Have established PPP programs in place.<br />
That local governments be given the right offirst refusal for providing packaging and printed<br />
paper product stewardship services tinder the new PPP program. This option zoonld minimize<br />
and/or prevent any disruption to existing services, employment and service contracts, and<br />
community expectations.<br />
That the design and implementation of the PPP program includes measures and incentives for<br />
redesigning packaging and printed paper, to ensure that the program moves PPP up the<br />
pollution prevention hierarchy and eliminates the need for landfilling and/or incineration of<br />
program materials.<br />
That the supplementary recommendations contained within Appendix I be adopted as<br />
a tool for building local government knowledge and capacity to assist in local<br />
government discussions and negotiations with producers.<br />
El PAGE
#2:Packapine and Printed Paper Product Stewardship Policy Paper Pope Sd 10<br />
APPENDIX 1: RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
Program Scope<br />
That the PPP program be expanded within three years to cover the industrial,<br />
commercial and institutional (Id) sector following the implementation of the program<br />
within the residential sector.<br />
That the PPP program seeks a recovery rate of eighty-five (85%) or higher, consistent<br />
with the principles adopted by the UBCM membership in the 2007 Environment Action<br />
Plan.<br />
That the target recovery rate identified in the Recycling Regulation apply to specific<br />
material categories as opposed to overall packaging composite.<br />
That the target recovery rate identified in the Recycling Regulation apply to each local<br />
government to ensure equivalent service levels between urban and rural areas.<br />
That the PPP program include the addition of milk containers to the deposit refund<br />
system.<br />
That the PPP program apply to all areas that local governments are currently servicing.<br />
Program Design<br />
That producers develop market based incentives and/or design requirements to<br />
stimulate product redesign and re-use to diminish the potential for materials to be<br />
incinerated or landfflled.<br />
That material specific targets and performance measures be developed by the producers<br />
and enforced by the Province.<br />
That local governments be given meaningful consultation opportunities in the design of<br />
the program as well as ongoing consultative mechanisms during the implementation of<br />
the program.<br />
That an enhanced dispute resolution process be incorporated into the program,<br />
whereby local governments have the right to receive compensation for impacted costs if<br />
producers are not providing adequate service levels that result in materials being sent<br />
to local landfills and/or incinerators.<br />
That the product stewardship program incorporates flexible and scalable options for<br />
local government participation in the management of PPP materials.<br />
That local governments be given the right of first refusal for providing packaging and<br />
printed paper product stewardship services under the new PPP product stewardship<br />
program.<br />
Hi<br />
ITEM 1PAGF.
#2:Packa8in and Printed Paper Product Stewards/jig Policy Paper Page 9 of /0<br />
Enviromnen tat finpact<br />
That the design and implementation of the PPP program focus on seeking efficiencies<br />
within the collection, transportation and processing of materials to minimize the carbon<br />
footprint of the program.<br />
That the product stewardship program include measures and incentives for redesigning<br />
packaging, which ensures that the program moves up the pollution prevention<br />
hierarchy by minimizing the landfilling and/or incineration of collected program<br />
materials.<br />
Funding<br />
That local government compensation for theft assistance in, or management of, the<br />
product stewardship program be based on a local government’s true operating costs.<br />
That local government be compensated for the management of FTP materials that end<br />
up in local government waste streams, and that standardized and industry funded<br />
waste audits be conducted to help determine appropriate levels of compensation for<br />
such management.<br />
That the product stewardship program be fully funded by industry, in which producers<br />
are responsible for all costs associated with the management of FTP materials including,<br />
but not limited to collection, transportation, processing, public outreach and education.<br />
That local governments receive compensation for continued education and outreach<br />
activities following the implementation of the product stewardship program.<br />
Service Provision<br />
That rural and remote areas receive an equitable level of service as their urban<br />
counterparts under the PPP product stewardship program.<br />
That existing service levels and quality of service be maintained or exceeded for those<br />
local governments that have established PIN’ programs in place.<br />
That the implementation of the program seeks to provide a seamless transition for those<br />
local governments with established PIN’ programs, in order to minimize and/or<br />
prevent any disruptions to existing services, employment and service contracts, and<br />
community expectations.<br />
Role of Local Government<br />
That local governments be provided the option and opportunity to play an active role in<br />
the management of packaging and printed paper under the product stewardship<br />
program.<br />
AGF.<br />
118]
#2:Packapinc and Printed Paper Product Stewardship Pplicv Paper Pare 10 of 10<br />
That the PPP program incorporate meaningful consultation opportunities in the design<br />
of the program as well as ongoing consultative mechanisms during the implementation<br />
of the program.<br />
That local governments explore the creation of a local government product stewardship<br />
agency that would facilitate active engagement, and negotiation with, all product<br />
stewards on existing and new product stewardship programs.<br />
1Th iAT:
9<br />
Multi-Materia I<br />
British Columbia<br />
I Li<br />
DRAFT<br />
Packaging and Printed Paper<br />
Stewardship Plan<br />
4 October 23, 2012<br />
—S
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Table of Contents I<br />
1. Introduction I<br />
2. The Stewardship Agency 1<br />
3. Packaging and Printed Paper 2<br />
3.1 Packaging 2<br />
3.2 Printed Paper 4<br />
3.3 Sources of Packaging and Printed Paper 4<br />
4’<br />
4. Program Design 5<br />
4.1 BC Packaging and Printed Paper Reverse Supply Chain S<br />
4.2 Packaging and Printed Paper Program Delivery Principles 6<br />
4.3 Packaging and Printed Paper Program Delivery Overview 6<br />
4.4 Collection of Packaging and Printed Paper from Residents and Streetscapes 7<br />
4.5 Post-collection 9<br />
At<br />
4.6 Collector and Processor Qualification Standards 11<br />
4.7 Dispute Resolution 12<br />
4.8 Communications 13<br />
4,9 AdmInistration of the Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan 14<br />
4,10 Program Financing 14<br />
5. Program Performance 16<br />
5.1 Recovery Target... 16<br />
5.2 Accessibility 18<br />
5.3 Product Life Cycle Management 19<br />
5.4 Pollution Prevention Hierarchy 21<br />
5.5 Reporting 22<br />
6. Conultatlon 23<br />
‘A<br />
6.1 Approach 23<br />
6.2 Activities 24<br />
Appendix A— Glossary 26<br />
Appendix B — Member List 27<br />
Appendix C — Consultation Comments and Responses 28<br />
hi
1. Introduction<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
The British Columbia (BC) Recycling Regulation (B.C. Reg. 449/2004 —the “Regulation’) under<br />
the Environmental Management Act requires that, as of May 2014, every producer of packaging<br />
and printed paper product (PPP) that wishes to sell, offer for sale or distribute their products to<br />
residents in British Columbia must operate, or be a member of, an approved plan concerning<br />
the end-of-life management of their products. The Regulation further stipulates that producers<br />
wishing to receive BC Ministry of Environment approval for such a plan must submit their plan to<br />
the Ministry on or before November 19, 2012.<br />
The proposed stewardship plan is unique in that it deals with the residential packaging and<br />
printed paper product category that is already being recovered at an estimated 50% recycling<br />
rate through local government and not-for profit and private sector initiatives. This plan is<br />
different from other plans developed for BC where no or limited collection services were in place<br />
prior to the material being added to the Recycling Regulation. ‘i<br />
The PPP stewardship plan outlined in this document proposes to build on these existing<br />
services in order to minimize economic dislocation for those currently operating the system, to<br />
avoid confusion for residents, and to mitigate any potential temporary loss of environmental<br />
performance. Building on the current operating recycling system through development of<br />
commercial partnerships with existing economic players is the most responsible, economically<br />
efficient and environmentally prudent approach to maintaining and enhancing the recovery of<br />
PPP in BC.<br />
2. The Stewardship Agency<br />
r”) —<br />
This proposed stewardship plan for PPP has been developed by Multi-Material British Columbia<br />
(MMBC) pursuant to the requirements of the Regulation.<br />
A<br />
MMBC is a not-for-profit agency established under the British Columbia Society Act formed in<br />
anticipation of the requirement to develop, submit and implement a stewardship plan for<br />
packaging and printed paper. MMBC is acting as a stewardship agency on behalf of producers<br />
in order to discharge their obligations under Schedule 5 of the Recycling Regulation.<br />
MMBC is governed by a Board of Directors comprising representatives of producers appointed<br />
by the Retail Council of Canada, Food and Consumer Products of Canada, Canadian<br />
Federation of Independent Grocers, Canadian Restaurant & Food Services Association, Loblaw<br />
Companies Limited, Overwaitea Food Group, Tim Hortons and McCain Foods.<br />
MMBC is acting on behalf of producers<br />
purposes of the PPP stewardship plan, the producer for a specific unit of packaging or printed<br />
1 of PPP in submitting this stewardship plan. For the<br />
Section 1 of B.C. Reg. 449/2004 defines “produce?’ of packaging and printed paper as,<br />
krL*IPAGE]<br />
1
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
paper is the supplier of service packaging or the first of the brand owner, the franchisor or the<br />
first seller (also known as the first importer).<br />
3. Packaging and Printed Paper<br />
In October 2004, the province passed the Recycling Regulation. In May 2011, the Regulation<br />
was amended to include Schedule 5 which added packaging<br />
and streetscapes<br />
3 as product categories.<br />
3.1 Packaging<br />
2 and printed paper from residents<br />
British Columbia’s Environmental Management Act defines packaging as “a material, substance<br />
or object that is used to protect, contain or transport a commodity or product, or attached to a<br />
commodity or product or its container for the purpose of marketing or communicating<br />
information about the commodity or product”.<br />
Schedule 5 does not further refine the definition of packaging beyond that provided in the<br />
Environmental Management Act as described above. cr<br />
Packaging for purposes of producer obligation and reporting<br />
includes:<br />
‘4<br />
4 under the PPP stewardship plan<br />
(a) Primary packaging i.e. packaging that contains the product at the point of sale to the<br />
residential consumer; I<br />
(b) Grouped packaging or secondary packaging that goes to the household<br />
5;<br />
(c) Transportation, distribution or tertiary packaging that goes to the household<br />
6;<br />
(d) Service packaging designed and intended to be filled at the point of sale and<br />
‘disposable’ items so!d, filled or designed and intended to be filled at the point of sale<br />
such as:<br />
-Ac<br />
(I) a pein who ‘rnanufactures the product and sells, offers for sale, distributes or uses in a commercial<br />
enterprise the product in British Columbia under the manufacturer’s ow1 brand,<br />
(<strong>ii</strong>) il subparagraph (I) does not apply, a person who is not the manufacturer of the product but is the owner<br />
or\censee of a trademark under which a product is sold, distributed or used in a commercial enterprise<br />
n British Columbia, whether or not the trademark Is registered, or<br />
(in) if subparagraphs (i) and (<strong>ii</strong>) do not apply, a person who Imports the product into British Columbia for<br />
P ‘ sale, distribution or use in a commercial enterprise.<br />
2 Schedule 1 of the Recycling Regulation addresses beverage containers which are managed under a provincial<br />
deposit return program, with the exception of milk containers which are excluded from the deposit return program.<br />
Refer to Section for a description of streetscapes.<br />
While producers of packaging described in Section 3.1 are responsible for contributing to the cast of providing<br />
reasonable access and achieving a 75% recovery rate, only those types of packaging for which there are viable<br />
commodity markets and recycling end markets are proposed to be collected from residents at program launch in May<br />
2014. Refer to Section 4.1.<br />
Multiple packages of product sold in a unit, often wrapped in fifrn plastic.<br />
May be both the primary packaging for the product and the packaged used to ship the product but is referred to as<br />
transportation packagina that goes home with the consumer. For example, household products packaged in<br />
corrugated boxes intended for final use or management by the consumer or end user,<br />
2
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
- Paper or plastic carry-out bags provided at checkout;<br />
- Bags filled at the shelves with bulk goods, produce, baked goods etc.;<br />
- Disposable plates and cups;<br />
- Take-out and home delivery food service packaging such as pizza boxes, cups,<br />
bags, folded cartons, wraps, trays etc.;<br />
- Flower boxlwrap;<br />
- Food wraps provided by the grocer for meats, fish, cheese, etc.<br />
- Prescription bottles filled and provided by pharmacists;<br />
- Paper envelopes for developed photographs;<br />
- Gift wrapping/tissue paper added by the retailer; and<br />
(e) Packaging components and ancillary elements integrated into packaging, Including<br />
ancillary elements directly hung or attached to a product and which perform a packaging<br />
function unless they are an integral part of the product and all elements are intended to<br />
be consumed or disposed of together<br />
7. r —<br />
For the purposes of the PPP stewardship plan, paper packaging means all paper materials<br />
regardless of the cellulosic fibre source of the material including but not limited to wood, wheat,<br />
rice, cotton, bananas, eucalyptus, bamboo, hemp, and sugar cane (bagasse) fibre sources.<br />
The following items are not considered packaging for the purposes of the PPP stewardship<br />
plan:<br />
• Beverage containers governed by Schedule Ito the Recycling Regulation;<br />
• Empty oil containers as defined by Schedule 2 of the Recycling Regulation;<br />
• Empty paint and stain containers nd aerosol containers as defined by Schedule 2 of the<br />
Recycling Regulation; J<br />
• Empty antifreeze containers as defined by Schedule 2 of the Recycling Regulation;<br />
• Transportation and distribution packaging that is not intended primarily for use or<br />
management in the home, for example plastic pallet wrap;<br />
• Industrial or bulk packaging that is not intended for sale or use by residents in the home;<br />
• Other items that are not generally considered to be packaging such as accessories to<br />
the product that do not serve a packaging function (e.g., plastic cutlery, straws, paper<br />
serviettes) and packaging components sold as product (empty) to the end consumer<br />
(e.g., garbage bags, organic waste bags, food storage bags, food storage containers);<br />
items that constitute an integral part of the product (eg., toner cartridges, single use<br />
cameras);<br />
‘Examples of this kind of packaging include, but are not limited to: labels and lids hung directly on or attached to the<br />
packaging; mascara brush which forms part of the container lid; staples, pins, clips; toy on the top of a candy product<br />
which forms part of the lid; devices for measuring dosage that form part of the detergent container lid; plastic make<br />
up case; brush contained in the lid of corrective liquid paper; zipper on a plastic film bag containing a product.<br />
WT<br />
LJ4J
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Durable packaging, which is packaging that has a useful life of at Least five years and is<br />
intended to facilitate storage or transport or to prevent the loss of product components<br />
for durable products and which remains with the product throughout its useful life, e.g.,<br />
CD/DVD cases, packaging used to store piecea of a board game; and<br />
• Wood, ceramic, crystal, rubber and leather packaging.<br />
3.2 Printed Paper<br />
I.<br />
Schedule 5 defines printed paper as “paper that is not packaging, but is printed with text or<br />
graphics as a medium for communicating information, and includes telephone directories, but<br />
does not include other types of bound reference books, bound literary books, or bound text<br />
books”.<br />
For the purposes of the PPP stewardship plan, printed paper comprises any type of cellulosic<br />
fibre source including but not limited to wood, wheat, rice, cotton, bananas, eucalyptus,<br />
bamboo, hemp, and sugar cane (bagasse) fibre sources.<br />
3.3 Sources of Packaging and Printed Paper<br />
S.<br />
Under Schedule 5 of the Recycling Regulation, the packaging and printed paper program Is to<br />
address residential premises and municipal property that is not industrial, commercial or<br />
institutional property.<br />
Residential premises<br />
8 are: )<br />
• Single-family dwellings inhabited year round or seasonally<br />
• Multi-family dwellings including rental, co-operative, fractional ownership, time-share,<br />
condominium and seniors residence&°.<br />
‘4—<br />
9; and<br />
Municipal property that is not industrial, commercial or institutional property comprises the<br />
following which are collectively referred to as ‘streetscape’ in this stewardship plan:<br />
• Sidewalks which are municipal property, which adjoin buildings in an urban commercial<br />
area and which are used for pedestrian traffic;<br />
Plazas or town squares which are municipal property and which are available to the<br />
public; and<br />
• Parks which are municipal property.<br />
Section 1 of the Recycling Reoulation defines residential premises” to included houses, apartments,<br />
condominiums, town homes and other premises in which persons reside but does not include institutional<br />
accommodations or visitor accommodations.<br />
VacaUon facilities, such as hotels, motels, cottages and cabins, are considered commercial businesses and are not<br />
included.<br />
‘° Residences at which medIcal care Is provided, such as nursIng homes, long-term care facilities and hospices, are<br />
considered institutions.<br />
‘I
4. Program Design<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
4.1 BC Packaging and Printed Paper Reverse Supply Chain<br />
BC residents who participate in PPP recycling programs and collectors and processors of PPP<br />
can be charatecterized as a reverse supply-chain that moves PPP from residents to recycling<br />
end-markets. The reverse supply-chain comprises millions of BC residents served by hundreds<br />
of collectors who deliver PPP to dozens of PPP processors who then market the material to<br />
dozens of end-markets both in and outside of British Columbia.<br />
Local governments are currently the primary drivers of residential PPP collection and recycling<br />
activity — they either deliver PPP collection and processing directly or contract for those services<br />
with private or not-for profit collectors and processors. In some cases, residents contract directly<br />
with private collectors for PPP collection or drop off PPP to private or not-for-profit depots for<br />
recycling.<br />
Collection and processing of PPP involve varied and complex relationships between private,<br />
public and not-for-profit entities to move PPP from residents to recycling end-markets. For<br />
simplicity, these relationships can be summarized as cnsisting of two main players: collectors<br />
and processors. Each of these is described beIo: ‘%is<br />
Th¼%<br />
PPP collectors include:<br />
‘I<br />
• Local governments and First Nationsgovernments delivering PPP collection services<br />
directly supported by public education, promotion and first point of contact for collection<br />
service customers;<br />
‘<br />
• Local governments and First Nations governments utilizing not-for profit organizations or<br />
private sector companies to provide the collection services supported by local<br />
government or First Nations government delivery of public education, promotion and first<br />
point of contact for collection service customers;<br />
• Private sector PPP collectors delivering collection services through subscription;<br />
• Private depots receiving PPP delivered by residents; and<br />
• Not-for-profit depots receiving PPP delivered by residents.<br />
PPP processors include:<br />
I<br />
•‘ Local governments delivering PPP processing directly;<br />
• Local govemments utilizing private sector PPP processors or not4or-profit organizations;<br />
and<br />
“ Not-for-profit depots may or may not have a funding relaLionshlp with their local government.<br />
IL:.
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Private sector PPP processors which may be vertically Integrated with collectors (i.e. the<br />
same company provides collection and processing services) or may provide processing<br />
services to private collectors, private depots and not-for-profit depots.<br />
4.2 Packaging and Printed Paper Program Delivery Principles<br />
Selecting the PPP program design has been driven by one overarching objective — continuous<br />
improvement in recovery effectiveness and efficiency without undermining existing PPP<br />
recovery efforts in British Columbia. r—<br />
To achieve the objective of maximizing outcomes while minimizing dislocations MMBC has<br />
developed the following market engagement principles to guide the development of the PPP<br />
stewardship plan:<br />
• Focus on outcomes, not process — maximize recovery, maximize efficiency, enhance<br />
resident service levels while minimizing complexity;<br />
h.<br />
• Provide economic incentives and set simple rules — effective economic incentives<br />
will drive behavior that Increases recovery activity throughout the PPP reverse supplychain;<br />
simple rules will provide clarity and certainty to those collecting and recycling<br />
PPP;<br />
• Foster interaction, collaboration andmpetition to drive innovation — innovation is<br />
the result of complex interactions of ideas and efforts among producers and private,<br />
public and not-for-profit entities with parties bringing together complimentary skills to<br />
collaborate and deliver more value;,and<br />
• Set the stage for evolution harness existing activities and build on success through<br />
continuous improvement aPid use’of economic incentives to increase collection of PPP<br />
and improve system efficie<br />
4.3 Packaging and Printed Paper Program Delivery Overview<br />
Under the Recycling Regulation, MMBC will assume responsibility for driving residential PPP<br />
collection and recycling activity in BC, effectively supplanting the role that local governments<br />
have historically played. Accordingly, at the outset, MMBC will largely assume responsibility for<br />
the existing BC PPP collection and recycling system and will set conditions for future<br />
Improvements in effectiveness and efficiency of PPP recovery In BC.<br />
The approach that MMBC has chosen to do this involves direct and separate interaction with<br />
collectors and processors based on two core elements:<br />
• An agreement between MMBC and each service provider setting out the activities to be<br />
performed and the outcomes to be achieved (e.g. collected tonnes successfully<br />
delivered to processors, households serviced, tonnes of PPP marketed etc.); and<br />
6
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Payment to the service provider upon verification that the outcomes specified In the<br />
agreement have been achieved.<br />
The nature of the agreements and how the agreements are entered into differ between<br />
collectors and processors, as described below.<br />
4.4 Collection of Packaging and Printed Paper from Residents and Streetscapes<br />
The approach to delivery of PPP collection services<br />
those Involved in the collection of PPP today to be part of the PPP collection system when<br />
producers assume responsibility for the PPP recovery system in May 2014.<br />
Qualified collectors will be offered financial incentives for PPP collection. The value offered will<br />
be established as market-clearing prices<br />
program operation, MMBC will pay collectors once the PPP they have collected has been<br />
accepted for processing by a primary processor under contract with MMBC.<br />
12 is based on providing opportunity for<br />
13. Consistent with an outcomes-based approach to<br />
MMBC will establish a set of collector qualification standards’<br />
qualifications common to all PPP collectors<br />
tracking and reporting sources and quantities of collected PPP. Local governments, private<br />
companies and not-for-profit organizations that to comply with these collector<br />
qualification standards will be qualified as MMBC collectofs, subject to the following approach.<br />
MMBC will engage qualified collectors as follows:<br />
4 that will Include basic<br />
15 today as well as additional requirements for<br />
• To service residents where set-outs of PPP is at curbside<br />
reasonable access criterih(’<br />
- MMBC will offer a financial incentive to a local government or First Nation<br />
9overnmen that is currently either directly providing or contracting for collection<br />
services for the provision of a bundle of services that includes PPP collection<br />
services, public education<br />
service customers; and<br />
promotion and first point of contact for collection<br />
‘F<br />
17 in areas that meet the<br />
12<br />
Also refer to Section 5.2 Accessibility.<br />
13<br />
A market clearIng price Is a payment available to servIce providers (subject to executing an agreement to provide a<br />
defined service, comply with a specified qualification standard on a continuous basis, report specified data on a<br />
defined schedule) designed to stimuiate marketplace activities and act as a market clearing mechanism.<br />
ALso refer to Section 4.6 collector and Processor Qualification Standards.<br />
15<br />
collectors will be required to provide free access for residents to collecton services as part of the quarificatioin<br />
standards.<br />
h<br />
Set-out of PPP at curbside by single-family and/or multi-family households.<br />
17<br />
While the majority of PPP diverted is collected in dedicated recycling systems, some local governments accept<br />
specific types of PPP, such as soiled paper packaging, In organic waste collection programs. MMBC will undertake<br />
research to determine the quantity of PPP in organic waste collection programs and will, if the quantity is significant.<br />
develop a market-cleahng price financial incentive reflecting the portion of PPP in the organic waste stream. Should<br />
local governments decline the offer, MMBc will not directly undertake collectkan of oroanic waste given the relatively<br />
small portion of PPP compared to food waste in this collection stream.<br />
1!<br />
Refer to Section 5.2 Accessibility.<br />
J.ITEM L’gj<br />
I 1281<br />
7
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
- Where the local government or First Nation government declines the offer or<br />
where there is no current collection service provided by the local government or<br />
First Nation government, MMBC will issue a tender for collection services, will<br />
select a service provider to provide PPP collection services and will provide<br />
public education, promotion and management of collection service customers<br />
through its own means.<br />
To service multi-family dwellings where set-out of PPP is on private property<br />
MMBC will offer a financial incentive for PPP collection services to any interested party<br />
that is able to comply with the collector qualification standards:<br />
- Where<br />
a local government accepts the offer of the financial incentive, an<br />
additional incentive will be offered to provide public education, promotion and first<br />
point of contact for collection service customers; and<br />
- Where a private company accepts the offer of the financial incentive, MMBC will<br />
provide public education, promotion and management of collection service<br />
customers through its own means. “¼,<br />
To operate depots for receiving PPP from residentspemted from single-family<br />
and multi-family households MMBC will offer a financial incentive to any interested party<br />
that is able to comply with the collector qualification standards for PPP collection<br />
services contingent on the types of materials accepted from residents:<br />
- Where a local government accepts the offer of the financial incentive, an<br />
-<br />
additional incentive will be offeed’to’rvide public education, promotion and first<br />
point of contact for collection seivlcelcustomers; and<br />
Where a private cornpanyepts the offer of the financial incentive, MMBC will<br />
provide public education, promotion and management of collection service<br />
•<br />
customers through its own means.<br />
To service streetscapus in areas that meet the reasonable access criteria<br />
- MMBC will offer a financial incentive<br />
a bundle of services that includes PPP collection services<br />
- Where<br />
19<br />
20 to the local government for the provision of<br />
21, public education,<br />
promotion and first point of contact for collection service customers; and<br />
the local government declines the offer, MMBC may issue a tender for<br />
PPP streetscape collection services, may select a service provider and may<br />
provide public education, promotion and management of collection service<br />
customers through its own means, subject to reaching agreement with the local<br />
government on the management of the garbage component of streetscape<br />
system.<br />
19 Refer to Section 5.2 Accessibility.<br />
29 Prior to offering a financial Incentive for streetscape collection services, MMSc will conduct audits of PPP and<br />
garbage in existing streetscape collection programs and conduct one or more pilot projects in order to develop a<br />
oreferred approach to slreetscape collection and recycling services.<br />
21 Streetscape collection activities include collection of PPP generated by routine pedestrian traffic and by those<br />
participating In public events where waste management services are provided by local governments, rather than<br />
event organizers.<br />
HiEi<br />
ITEM fT ASH<br />
B
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Market-clearing prices are the prices at which the market will deliver the service required by<br />
MMBC. Setting appropriate market-clearing prices Is Important to drive effectiveness (i.e.<br />
collection of PPP), reward the efficient operator and encourage efficiency among other<br />
operators. An effective market-clearing price should reward and encourage continued efficiency<br />
by those who can deliver the service at less than the market-clearing price while encouraging<br />
initiatives to reduce costs where costs exceed the market-clearing price.<br />
The financial Incentives offered to collectors will be determined by establishing market-clearing<br />
prices for the collection of PPP from single-family and multi-family households at curbside, from<br />
multi-family households where set-out of PPP is on private property, at depots and through<br />
streetscape collection systems. Establishing the market-clearing prices for collection has two<br />
components:<br />
• A clear definition of the outcome being priced: The market-clearing price can be set<br />
at a flat rate per tonne accepted for processing by a primary processor or at a flat rate<br />
per household serviced, or some combination. Market-clearing prices offered as<br />
incentives should drive behavior to maximize PPP placed into the PPP collection stream<br />
rather than the garbage stream by all households serviced. Since MMBC’s objective is<br />
to increase the collection of PPP, the market-clearing price will be benchmarked against<br />
a baseline performance standard.<br />
• The price level or quantity of financial incentive: The price level will be determined<br />
through research Into collection service performance (I.e. kilograms collected per<br />
household) and service delivery costs a&oss British Columbia. The results of this<br />
research will be used to inform a <strong>ii</strong>arket-clearing price for each type of service for which<br />
a market-clearing price will be offered. The market-clearing price will be set taking into<br />
consideration any additional requirements of collectors as a result of the PPP<br />
stewardship plan.<br />
Market-clearing prices may be stratified to accommodate circumstances that change over time<br />
such as fuel prices. As welQ market-clearing prices may be reviewed in relation to the changing<br />
characteristics of PPP being supplied by producers to residents 23<br />
prices to drive collection activities is an iterative process that will be monitored and adjusted to<br />
reflect changing conditions.<br />
4.5çst-CollectIon<br />
. Setting market-clearing<br />
Post-collection services include receiving PPP from collection vehicles, picking up PPP from<br />
depots, consolidation and transfer where required, handling and sorting PPPI preparing PPP for<br />
shipment to end-markets or downstream processors, marketing PPP to maximize commodity<br />
Measured as kilogram per household served by dividing total tonnes collected by households served.<br />
23 changes implemented by praducers to the material utilized for packaging (e.g. plastic rather than glass) and/or to<br />
the design of a package or a printed paper product can increase the cubic volume of a tonne of PPP collected.<br />
9
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
revenue, appropriately managing residual materials and reporting the quantities of material<br />
received and marketed and other metrics to MMBC as required.<br />
Primary processors are considered to be the first receivers of collected PPP that market at least<br />
some types of processed PPP directly to end markets. Primary processors may engage<br />
secondary or downstream processors that can more efficiently or effectively sort, process and<br />
market some types of PPP.<br />
MMBC will engage PPP primary processors on a contractual basis using the following process:<br />
1. Issue a Request for Expressions of Interest (REQI) to PPP processors to gauge<br />
processors’ capacity to receive, process and market a defined list of PPP received from<br />
collectors.<br />
2. Issue a Request for Proposals (RFP) to PPP processors that are able to manage the<br />
defined list of PPP.<br />
Processors will be provided with the names and locations of qualified collectors<br />
participating in the MMBC program. This information will allow processors to make<br />
arrangements with these qualified collectors as required in order to respond to the RFP.<br />
The RFP will solicit information to allow MMBC to confirm<br />
processor qualification standards setby4MMBC. The RFP<br />
post-collection services, delivered in compliance with<br />
standards, including: rj<br />
• Receiving PPP from vehicles operated by qualified collectors:<br />
• Consolidating and transferring PPP from qualified collectors where required;<br />
• Preparing PPP for shipment to end-markets or downstream processors;<br />
• Marketing PPP to end-markets;<br />
• Transferring PPP to downstream processors, as required;<br />
• Appropriately managing residual materials;<br />
• Tracking materials receIved and shipped by the processor and its<br />
processors to final destination; and<br />
• Reporting to MMBC as required<br />
Processors will be qualified based on compliance with the processor qualification<br />
standards and evaluation criteria including but not limited to price, location, capability,<br />
capacity, output to recycling end-markets per tonne received and material revenue<br />
received. MMBC will also consider its contract administration including, for example,<br />
audits and compliance activities for in-province and out-of-province processors and<br />
recycling-end markets.<br />
J<br />
4<br />
a processor’s ability to meet<br />
will also solicit bid prices for<br />
the processor qualification<br />
downstream<br />
10
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Arrangements between qualified collectors and processors will be left to the discretion of the<br />
parties through arrangements made in the free-market. Free-market negotiations between<br />
primary processors and collectors offer the best opportunity to maximize the quality of materials<br />
received by primary processors and, in turn, maximize the quantity and quality of PPP marketed<br />
by processors. As collectors are only remunerated by MMBC when primary processors accept<br />
their collected PPP, primary processors are able to provide collectors with a strong incentive to<br />
ensure that they collect PPP in a manner that maximizes material quality.<br />
In the contractual arrangement between MMBC and primary processors, primary processors will<br />
be tasked to find the “best” markets for materials (i.e. reliable markets that command the highest<br />
commodity prices) and the agreements will incorporate mechanisms to share market revenue<br />
and commodity risk. By building in opportunities for processors to benefit from maximizing<br />
commodity values, processors have a strong incentive to maximize both the amount of PPP<br />
marketed and its commodity value.<br />
4<br />
4.6 Collector and Processor Qualification Standards<br />
Collector and processor qualification standards, including reporting protocols, are the minimum<br />
operating standards that a service provider must meet on a continuous basis in order to be<br />
eligible to provide collection, depot operation and/or processing services under a contract with<br />
MMBC. -<br />
Qualification standards will be used by MMBC to support the continued growth of a safe, stable<br />
and sustainable PPP collection and processing system across British Columbia. MMBC will<br />
incorporate qualification standards Into requests for expressions of interest (REOI), request for<br />
proposals (REP) and into agreements with collectors and processors.<br />
24 will set out basic requirements, such as free collection service to<br />
Qualification standards<br />
residents, proof of all necessary licenses and permits, compliance with health and safety<br />
requirements and specified Iability and business insurance coverage. Qualification standards<br />
will also include reporting requirements to allow MMBC to meet its reporting requirements to the<br />
MOE, Li’<br />
Collectors will be required to report data such as:<br />
• Number of single-family and multi-family households served with household collection;<br />
Number of single-family and multi-family households served by depot collection;<br />
• “Tonnes of PPP collected through household and streetscape collection and at depots;<br />
and<br />
• Tonnes of PPP delivered to each processor under contract to MMBC.<br />
‘ Qualification standards for coEectors and processors will be subject to consultaton fo!owing submission of the PPP<br />
stewardship plan.<br />
11
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Processors will be required to report data such as:<br />
• Tonnes of PPP received from each collector under contract to MMBC and, of this<br />
amount, tonnes of PPP delivered to downstream processors and recycling end-markets<br />
by material type:<br />
• Names and locations of recychng end-markets receiving PPP from the primary<br />
processor and downstream processors;<br />
• Revenues received for PPP materials marketed:<br />
• Processing residue rates; and<br />
• Names and locations of recovery end-markets and disposal locations.<br />
4.7 DIspute Resolution<br />
MMBC will seek to balance the principles of access, efficiency, fairness arid equitable outcomes<br />
in the design of its dispute resolution mechanisms. Dispute resolution processes will be tailored<br />
to the nature of disputes as well as the likely parties to a typical dispute. The objectives of the<br />
dispute resolution process are to manage disputes to resolution rather than adjudication, earlier<br />
and faster and at a reduced cost to aN parties involved. r<br />
The following suite of alternative dispute resolutioqo will be used:<br />
Dispute Type<br />
Resident<br />
Collectors and<br />
processors<br />
Path of EscalatlonlResolution<br />
• Discussion with MMBC management<br />
• If unresolved, involvement of MMBC Board<br />
• Discussion with MMBC senior management<br />
• Facilitation: to prevent escalation and to explore interests/remedies<br />
• Mediation: to be used if facilitation is unsuccessful process to be<br />
specified in commercial agreements regarding selection of mediator,<br />
roles of parties, time and place of mediation, conduct of mediation,<br />
length, responsibility for fees/costs, confidentiality, conclusion of<br />
mediation by agreed settlement or final settlement proposal by the<br />
% mediator<br />
• ArbItration: to be used if mediation is unsuccessful; process to be<br />
specified in commercial agreements regarding notice of arbitration,<br />
submission of written statements, place and conduct of meetings and<br />
hearings, the process for rendering and delivering decisions;<br />
jurisdiction and powers of the arbitrator, allocation of costs/fees;<br />
application of the B.C. Arbitration Act (RSBC 1996)<br />
12
4.8 Communications<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
The Recycling Regulation requires that, as part of the stewardship plan, MMBC design and<br />
deliver an effective resident education program that achieves two overarching objectives:<br />
• Make residents and other target audiences aware of the program features and benefits<br />
through communication activities; and<br />
• Employ promotion and education (P&E) activities to engage and encourage residents to<br />
make informed and proper decisions concerning the preparation and management of<br />
PPP for collection and recycling.<br />
The design of the PPP stewardship communication activities will be set out in a strategic<br />
communication and P&E plan that will be developed following approval of the stewardship plan.<br />
The communication and P&E plan will comprise three activity phases: pre-launch, launch and<br />
post-launch (first year following launch).<br />
The principles guiding the development of the communication and P&E plan will be:<br />
r J<br />
• Understand MMBC’s resident and stakeholder audiences —<br />
identify<br />
the various<br />
audiences who will participate in the PPP stewardship program by sorting, collecting.<br />
processing and recycling PPP and assessing each group’s information and P&E needs;<br />
• Design effective communication and P&E —<br />
ensure<br />
that communication strategies,<br />
images, messages and tools reflect needs, are clearly understood, overcome perceptual<br />
and real barriers, contain a call to action and motivate appropriate behaviour;<br />
opportunities to collaborate with other BC stewardship<br />
• Collaboration —<br />
explore<br />
agencies, local governments, retailers, community-based organizations and others to<br />
develop strategies and distribute P&E materials that strive to inform and motivate;<br />
• Establish measurement metrics —<br />
establish<br />
a benchmark measurement of program<br />
awareness, perceptions and reported behaviour against which to track and assess<br />
changes pertaining to year-over-year performance;<br />
• Deploy an effective mix of communIcation and P&E tactics — develop and<br />
disseminate a strategic mix of tactics that ensure residents and stakeholders are<br />
effectively exposed to primary and supportive messaging; to undertake this in<br />
cooperatid’r with local governments and others who have developed and operate<br />
successful, mature recycling programs: and<br />
‘. Engage audIences to elicit feedback —<br />
employ<br />
contemporary methods of<br />
. communication interaction (e.g. social media) as well as traditional methods to engage<br />
residents and encourage them to provide direct feedback regarding program changes<br />
and to ask questions.<br />
The communications plan will be evaluated periodically using various key performance metrics<br />
such as its effectiveness in developing consumer awareness and delivering clear,<br />
13
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
comprehensible P&E messages across geographical and cultural demographics. The<br />
communications plan will be updated and enhanced as required.<br />
4.9 AdminIstration of the Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
MMBC is responsible for implementing this PPP stewardship plan on behalf of the producers<br />
that have chosen to be members.<br />
MMBC will administer the implementation of the PPP stewardship plan effectively andfflclentIy<br />
through a combination of in-house and outsourcing of key specialized functions or services.<br />
Activities to be administered through out-sourcing include those that will ntt’èompromise the<br />
relationship between MMBC and BC stakeholders and where effectivenCnd efficiency is<br />
enhanced through the adoption of best practices delivered by the ser4ejpovider that would<br />
otherwise be a multi-year stabilization and continuous lmprovementeffortr MMBC.<br />
MMBC will directly administer collection and processing services including dispute resolution,<br />
communications to BC residents and performance reporting to the BC MOE.<br />
MMBC will outsource producer registration, reporting, fee invoicing, payments, audits and<br />
compliance in order to facilitate harmonized systems for Canadian producers, whether operating<br />
only in BC or in other Canadian provinces.<br />
4.10 Program Financing<br />
MMBC is responsible to the producer that have chosen to be its members to deliver an efficient<br />
and effective PPP stewardship program.<br />
h.<br />
Producers that choose to be members of MMBC are responsible to pay fees that are sufficient,<br />
in aggregate, to implement the PPP stewardship plan. These costs fall into three categories:<br />
-1<br />
_b<br />
• Administration - what it takes to manage the business;<br />
• Resident awareness - what<br />
• Material management - what it takes to manage materials.<br />
It takes to promote the behaviours that drive collection; and<br />
Producers thafsupply types of PPP that are currently recyclable and that will be included in the<br />
PPP stewardship plan collection system will pay fees that are intended to cover:<br />
1<br />
• An equitable share of MMBC administration costs:<br />
• An equitable share of resident awareness costs; and<br />
• A contribution to the costs to manage the recyclable PPP that is the basis for the PPP<br />
stewardship program performance.<br />
lTi*\1<br />
14
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Producers that supply types of PPP that are currently not recyclable and will not be included in<br />
the PPP stewardship plan collection system when the program launches in May 2014 will pay<br />
fees that are intended to cover:<br />
• An equitable share of MMBC administration costs;<br />
• An equitable share of resident awareness costs; and<br />
• A contribution to the costs to manage the recyclable PPP that is the basis for the PPP<br />
stewardship program performance; and<br />
• Research and development (R&D) to resolve technical and market capacity barriers so<br />
that the PPP that is currently not recyclable can be included in the collection system over<br />
time. R&D efforts will include:<br />
- Resolving sorting, processing and end-market technical challenges;<br />
- Establish processing capacity; and<br />
- Establish end-market capacity and demand.<br />
It is anticipated that producers that choose to be members of MMBC will not apply a fee at the<br />
point of sale of products in packaging and printed paper, frimarily due to the relatively low cost<br />
per unit of packaging and printed paper that, for many products, is less than one cent. In the<br />
absence of a fee at the point of sale, costs Incurred by producers to meet their obligations under<br />
the Recycling Regulation through membership in MMBC would be considered a cost of doing<br />
business in BC and would be managed by the producer accordingly. Each individual producer<br />
will determine for its own business how it will manage the costs incurred to meet its obligations<br />
under the Recycling Regulation through membership in MMBC.<br />
ad<br />
Costs Incurred by MMBC to delivjd administer the PPP stewardship plan will be allocated<br />
among producers based on the foJng principles:<br />
,1<br />
• Encourage reduction,aredesign and recyclability<br />
- Allocation of program delivery costs to reward producers that supply recyclable<br />
PPP for which there is market demand and high commodity value and to<br />
encourage producers that supply PPP for which there are no end markets or<br />
limited markets with low commodity value to consider reduction, redesign and<br />
recyclability;<br />
• Program delivery costs, subject to the principle above<br />
Allocation of costs to producers that supplied the PPP for which costs were<br />
incurred;<br />
- Where costs are incurred for commingled materials, allocation of costs to each<br />
category of PPP reported by producers using a cost allocation model<br />
by composition audits, cost allocation studies and other analyses to Identify the<br />
relative cost share for each category of PPP; and<br />
V -<br />
25 informed<br />
The cost allocation model is subject to modification over time consistent with the principles of conUnuous<br />
improvement.<br />
15
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Administration costs<br />
- Equitable sharing of administration costs and common costs by all producers.<br />
5. Program Performance<br />
5.1 Recovery Target<br />
MMBC’s aspiration is to have all PPP supplied Into BC effectively collected and recycled.<br />
Achieving this outcome will involve a number of steps of which the first will be to expand the<br />
existing collection system to accommodate a uniform province-wide list of PPP materials. This<br />
list will be predicated on the existence of recycling end-markets for each material on the list.<br />
Collecting the full range of PPP for which there are existing markets in all areas of the province<br />
will require adjustments to the majority of collection programs<br />
downstream processors that receive the collected material. It will also require effort to ensure<br />
that the additional PPP is effectively marketed with<br />
market arrangements.<br />
minimal disruption to local commodity<br />
2° and by the primary and<br />
Subsequently, the uniform list of materials will beQpanded incrementally in a step-wise<br />
process to ensure collection, processing and rarketing of additional materials will not<br />
compromise the operation and reliability of the a isting collection and recycling system, the<br />
quality of materials shipped to end-markets, the ability of these end-markets, the confidence of<br />
residents in their recycling program and the enlronmental performance of the system.<br />
C<br />
The benefits of this incrementaI.pprçch to expand the scope of collected materials Include:<br />
• It builds on the exlstng recycling programs collection and processing systems In a<br />
logical, envirmentally and economically prudent manner;<br />
• It protects theQnvironmental performance of the existing recycling program by ensuring<br />
the addition of materials to the list is preceded by requisite investments and operational<br />
changes to deliver best use of materials and no degradation to the collection and<br />
recycling of materials already on the list; accordingly,<br />
• It upholds the pollution prevention hierarchy by ensuring the PPP program focuses on<br />
ecycling outcomes and does not rely on the recovery and disposal options on the<br />
pollution prevention hierarchy.<br />
A<br />
The Recycling Regulation specifies that the PPP stewardship program must achieve, or is<br />
capable of achieving within a reasonable time, a 75% recovery rate.<br />
26 Approximately 30% of single-family households and less than 15% of multi-family households are currently<br />
receiving collection of all rigid plastics.<br />
16
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Based on surveys carried out in late 201127, it is estimated that approximately 200000 tonnes<br />
of residential PPP were being recycled annually in BC. While the quantity of PPP supplied to<br />
BC households cannot be accurately quantified until producers report to MMBC, based on<br />
preliminary estimates, these 200000 tonnes of PPP likely represent a recovery rate between<br />
50% and 57%.<br />
To put BC’s baseline residential recycling rate into context, both Quebec’s PPP stewardship<br />
program (established in 2005) and Ontario’s PPP stewardship program (established in 2004)<br />
are recycling 65% of the province’s residential PPP. European PPP stewardship programs<br />
are recycling various amounts of the residential PPP targeted in the program: France is<br />
recycling 63%29; Germany is recycling 71%°; and Belgium is recycling 93%3<br />
26<br />
During the first years of implementation of the PPP stewardship plan, MMBC will be compiling<br />
data from producers on the quantity of PPP material supplied to residents and from service<br />
providers on the quantity of PPP materials collected and marketed to recycling end-markets.<br />
32 to identify the composition of collected and marketed PPP will be required to determine<br />
Audits<br />
the quantity of each type of PPP material being recycled. These data will allow MMBC to refine<br />
the baseline estimated recycling rate range of 50% to 57% and to compile, over the first years of<br />
program implementation, data on the quantity of PPP material types being supplied, collected<br />
and recycled.<br />
Building on the PPP collection and recycling systems already in<br />
required to increase the recovery rate fro<br />
recovery rate. This additional recovery will involve:<br />
place, producers will be<br />
7n BC’s baseline recycling rate to the 75% target<br />
• Delivering more collection services;<br />
• Increasing participation by encouraging residents to utilize available collection systems;<br />
• Collaborating with provincial and local governments to implement policies that support<br />
PPP collection, such as limits on the quantity of garbage that can be set out for<br />
collection, reducing the frequency of garbage collection, charging fees for garbage<br />
collection and/or banning PPP from disposal;<br />
• Resolving technical and convenience barriers in multi-family collection systems;<br />
• Increasing capture rates by encouraging residents to place PPP in the PPP collection<br />
system rather than the garbage collection system;<br />
Increasing the effectiveness of processing systems to reduce processing residues and<br />
Increase the proportion of collected PPP delivered to end-markets; and<br />
27 Refer to the report titled The Current System for Managing Residential Packaging and Printed Paper in BC, March<br />
2012.<br />
28 Refer to report titled Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Program Design Options, March 2012: Section<br />
4.2.1.<br />
29 Of glass, paper, steel, aluminum and plastic packaging.<br />
3° Of paper and packaging made of paper, plastics, metals and glass.<br />
31 Of glass, paper, steel and aluminum packaging and plastic bottles.<br />
32 The audit sampling protocol will involve a sufficient number of samples and sample points over multiples seasons<br />
and years to be considered reasonably statistically valid.<br />
17
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Developing new end-markets and processing capabihty and capacity to support the<br />
addition of more types of PPP to the collection system.<br />
MMBC Is commiffed to building the residential PPP collection and recycling system in BC to<br />
deliver the required 75% recovery target within a reasonable time and within the framework of<br />
the pollution prevention hierarchy.<br />
5.2 Accessibility<br />
Section 5(1)(c) of the Recycling Regulation requires that a stewardship plan provide reasonable<br />
and free access to collection facilities. -<br />
‘‘S<br />
$<br />
‘I<br />
Access by householders to various types of services differs across BC communities, reflecting<br />
population density and other factors. The following table sets out current access for residents to<br />
PPP collection services based on surveys carried out in late 2011.<br />
Single-family<br />
Households<br />
MMBC will provide reasonable access to collection services<br />
the nee’d for:<br />
Multi-family<br />
Households<br />
for PPP taking into consideration<br />
• Services in large, urban areas as well as remote, sparsely populated areas,<br />
• Effective and efficient collection services within their geographic and/or demographic<br />
context;<br />
Refer to the report titled The cuent System for Managing Residential Packaging and Printed Paper in BC, March<br />
2012.<br />
IITEM IPAGE!<br />
Total<br />
Kouseholds<br />
Total # of Households 1 ,2023Q) 512,511 1715,441<br />
# of Households Receiving Household<br />
Collection Service r9361<br />
% of Total Households Receiving<br />
Households Collection Service<br />
# of Households (Not Receiving Collection<br />
Service) with Access to Depots<br />
% of Total Households with Access Only<br />
to Depots<br />
l8<br />
405,666 1,341,784<br />
78% 79% 78%<br />
217,758 90,096 307,854<br />
18% 18% 18%<br />
# of Households Receiving Household<br />
Collection Service or with Access to 1,153,876 495,762 1,649,638<br />
Depots<br />
% of Total Households Receiving<br />
Household Collection Service or with 96% 97% 96%<br />
Access to Depots
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• A collection system with sufficient capacity to achieve the recovery target; and<br />
• Predictability for residents wishing to recycle PPP.<br />
Reasonable access to collection services for PPP will be provided:<br />
• For single-family households through<br />
- Curbside collection in areas currently receiving curbside collection of PPP;<br />
- Curbside collection in areas currently receiving curbside collection of garbage<br />
which can be serviced for the market-clearing price offered by MMBC;<br />
- Depot collection for PPP in areas which can be serviced for the market-clearing<br />
price offered by MMBC;<br />
• For multi-family households through<br />
- Curbside collection for PPP where the PPP is placed on public easements for<br />
collection on regular single-family curbside routes;<br />
- Collection services from multi-family dwellings where set-out of PPP is on private<br />
property which can be serviced for the market-clearing price offered by MMBC;<br />
• For streetscapes, subject to proof of concept through testing effective delivery of<br />
streetscape collection systems, through collection:<br />
S<br />
- In urban commercial areas with business activities that generate large amounts<br />
oIPPP; •<br />
r c<br />
34<br />
- Where the local government operates a lifter collection system; and<br />
- In municipalities with a population of 20,000 or more and a population density of<br />
200 or more people per square kilometre.<br />
a<br />
5.3 Product Life Cycle Management<br />
Section 5(1)(c)(v<strong>ii</strong>) of the Recycling Regulation requires that a stewardship plan adequately<br />
provide for eliminating or reducing the environmental impacts of a product throughout the<br />
product’s life cycle.<br />
The producers that are members of MMBC will contribute to eliminating or reducing the<br />
environmental impacts of a product through innovations that affect the stages of its life cycle<br />
before it reaches the consumer. The following are examples of activities that have been<br />
implemented.<br />
r<br />
Reduction<br />
N,<br />
• A number of brands, primarily in the home and personal care category, have created<br />
refill packs designed to make it very simple for the consumer to refill the original pack<br />
with new product. The refill pack is manufactured of a lightweight material producing<br />
Where a local government prefers depot collection over curbside collection, MMBC will consider this preference.<br />
19
Redesign<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
less waste. This approach addresses the first R in the 3Rs hierarchy by reducing<br />
packaging, in some cases, by over 75%.<br />
Packaging can be reduced through the reformulation of a product, such as<br />
concentration, requiring less packaging per use of product. This has been done<br />
extensively in the laundry, home care and personal care product categories.<br />
Plastic packaging can be created with new technology that delivers the same strength<br />
and performance but requires less resin. This can be achieved through the use of<br />
umicro_bubbles incorporated into the plastic. This reduces the density of the resin but<br />
does not impact performance — an approach to packaging reduction that is often invisible<br />
to the consumer.<br />
Research and development is also being directed at incorporating other materials into<br />
product packaging — primarily replacing plastic resin with renewable materials. To<br />
minimize plastic use, the redesigned package incotporates fibres such as bamboo,<br />
sugarcane and bulrush. Research and market testing has shown that incorporation of<br />
these different materials delivers packaging that stays strong under compression and<br />
consumer use (opening and closing) and transportation. In some cases the bamboo<br />
sugarcane and! or bulrush has replaced’the use of PVC, which is a known recycling<br />
disruptor.<br />
• Several non-food manufacturers have invested in research and development allowing<br />
them to utilize 100°k post-consumer recycled resin in their plastic packaging.<br />
• Companies are making commitments to sustainable sourcing of their paper-based<br />
packaging. Some companies have committed to purchasing only Forest Stewardship<br />
Council certified paper. Others are committing to source paper products only from<br />
managed forests and are involved in the replanting of those forests to ensure ongoing<br />
regeneration.<br />
bas’<br />
The producers that are members of MMBC will contribute to eliminating or reducing the<br />
environmental impacts of a product through innovations that affect the stages of its life cycle<br />
after it reaches the consumer. The following are examples of activities that have been<br />
imiplemented.-.,,<br />
A<br />
Recyclability<br />
• Companies are redesigning packaging so that it is more easily recycled by, for example:<br />
harmonizing the plastic resin of a cap with its bottle; providing a removable barrier<br />
between the packaging and the product to reduce contamination<br />
35; or, in the case of<br />
paperboard packaging, reducing or removing a coating from the carton making it more<br />
easily recylable.<br />
For example, paper liner in expanded polystyrene meat tray.<br />
20
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
• Companies are redesigning packaging and closures to allow consumers to get every<br />
last drop of the product out of the package. This provides better value to the consumer<br />
and results in less contamination in the recycling system.<br />
Implemlentation of the PPP stewardship plan will manage PPP after a resident has placed it into<br />
the PPP collection system through recycling, and where recycling options are not available,<br />
through recovery or disposal.<br />
MMBC, through Implementation of the PPP stewardship plan, and the PPP producers that are<br />
its members will continue to strive to eliminate or reduce the environmental impacts of PPP<br />
supplied to residents in BC throughout the products’ life cycle. Information on PPP end-of-life<br />
management compiled by MMBC during implementation of the PPP stewardship plan will be an<br />
additional source of information for PPP producers as they consider opportunities to reduce the<br />
quantity of PPP supplied as well as design PPP with the environment and recyclability in mind.<br />
5.4 Pollution Prevention Hierarchy<br />
Section 5(1)(c)(v<strong>ii</strong>i) of the Recycling Regulation requires that a stewardship plan adequately<br />
provide for the management of the product in adherence to the order of preference in the<br />
pollution prevention hierarchy.<br />
The PPP stewardship plan will adhere to the pollution prevention hierarchy through the following<br />
activities:<br />
Pollution Prevention Hierarchy Activity<br />
.<br />
Reduce the environmental impact’f” • Initiatives undertaken by individual<br />
producing the product by eliminating toxic producers<br />
components and in easing energy and • PPP stewardship plan encourages<br />
resource effiden reduction through cost allocation which<br />
rewards companies who reduce the<br />
weight of PPP sold into the market<br />
4<br />
Redesigjth’ejduct to improve reusability • Initiatives undertaken by individual<br />
or recIa’kjI<br />
V<br />
producers<br />
• PPP stewardship plan encourages<br />
redesign through cost allocation<br />
• MMBC will provide guidance to producers<br />
on design for recyclability<br />
Eliminate or reduce the generation of unused • Not applicable a packaging and printed<br />
portions of a product that is consumable paper are not consumable<br />
lTEt -<br />
21
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Pollution Prevention Hierarchy Activity<br />
Reuse the product • Initiatives undertaken by individual<br />
producers<br />
• PPP stewardship plan encourages reuse<br />
through cost allocation<br />
Recycle the product • PPP stewardship plan utilizes payments<br />
to service providers to encourage<br />
collection of PPP and processing of PPP<br />
to meet recycling end-market<br />
requirements<br />
• MMBC will provide guidance to producers<br />
on design for recyclability<br />
Recover material or energy from the product • Primary and downstream processors will<br />
be encouraged to further process system<br />
residues to meet recovery end-market<br />
requirements and minimize the amount of<br />
residue sent to landfill<br />
Otherwise dispose of the waste from the • Primary and downstream processors will<br />
product in compliance with the Act itbe required to manage residue in<br />
5.5 Reporting Li<br />
CL<br />
compliance with the Act<br />
Following approval of the PPP stewardship plan, MMBC will begin collecting baseline data that<br />
will be used to establish annual performance objectives related to the 75% recovery rate.<br />
During implementation of the PPP stewardship plan, MMBC will compile data in order to report<br />
on the following indicators:<br />
Accessibility indicators to describe access to PPP collection services in the province<br />
of BC such as:<br />
‘Single-family and multi-family households receiving household collection service;<br />
p, Number and location of depots accepting PPP;<br />
\ Operational effectiveness indicators characterizing program performance such as:<br />
- Tonnes of PPP collected within each regional district;<br />
- Kilograms per capita of PPP collected within each regional district;<br />
- Tonnes of PPP recycled and recovered for the province;<br />
- Kilograms per capita of PPP recycled and recovered for the province;<br />
- Recovery<br />
rate expressed as a percentage for the province;<br />
• Operational efficiency indicators reflecting program performance in financial terms<br />
such as:<br />
22
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
- Total program cost per tonne recovered;<br />
- Total program cost per household;<br />
Environmental impact measures to characterize actions by producers 4o are<br />
•<br />
members of MMBC and by MMBC during implementation of the PPP stewardship plan<br />
intended to reduce the environmental impacts of packaging and printed paper; and<br />
Resident awareness indicators to assess public awareness and engagement such as:<br />
- Percentage of residents aware of PPP stewardship program;<br />
- Percentage of residents reporting use of available collection services; and<br />
- Visits to the ‘resident section of MMBC website. %‘<br />
4%<br />
MMBC will report on the performance of the PPP program in an annual report submitted to the<br />
BC MOE and posted on its website by July 1st each year. MMBC will include a reasonable<br />
assurance opinion of the accessibility indicators and operational effectiveness indicators by a<br />
third-party in its annual report.<br />
The MOE requires that a stewardship agency provide third-party audited financial statements<br />
prepared in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards if fees are applied at the<br />
point of sale to fund the stewardship plan. It is anticipated that producers that choose to be<br />
members of MMBC will not apply a fee at the point of sale of products in packaging and printed<br />
paper. Should this be the case, MMBC would not be obligated to provide third-party audited<br />
financial statements as part of its annual reporting but reserves the right to choose to do so.<br />
6. Consultation<br />
6.1 Approach<br />
For purposes of consultation on the PPP stewardship plan, the following are considered<br />
stakeholders:<br />
• Residents; r<br />
• Producers of PPP supplied to residents in BC;<br />
• Those currently delivering PPP services including local governments, not-for-profit<br />
organIzations, private companies, First Nations governments;<br />
• Those potentially interested in delivering services under the PPP stewardship plan<br />
j .including local governments, not-for-profit organizations, private companies, First<br />
Nations governments; and<br />
• Those with an interest in the management of PPP.<br />
MMBC has used a combination of mechanisms to consult with stakeholders during development<br />
of this PPP stewardship plan.<br />
23
6.2 Activities<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
In February 2012, MMBC provided opportunities for stakeholders to:<br />
• Review and propose corrections to data presented in the draft version of the report titled<br />
Current System for Managing Residential Packaging and Printed Paper in British<br />
Columbia dated February 2012; and -<br />
• Review and provide comments on the draft version of the report titled Packaging and<br />
Printed Paper Stewardship Program Design Options dated February 2012. i<br />
‘4<br />
Starting in late September 2012, MMBC began meeting with local governments, not-for-profit<br />
organizations, private sector companies and public interest groups to provide opportunities to<br />
hear directly from stakeholders and to discuss possible approaches to the PPP stewardship<br />
plan. As of the posting of this draft PPP stewardship plan, more than 40 meetings have been<br />
held including meetings with:<br />
• Representatives of the UBCM PPP Working Group;<br />
4tXs4p<br />
‘<br />
• Representatives from a number of industry trade associations;<br />
• Representatives from<br />
governments;<br />
more than 15 regional districts and more than 30 municipal<br />
• Representatives from 6 not-for-profit organizations;<br />
• Representatives from more than 25 private sector companies.<br />
‘I<br />
Meetings with local governments, not-for-profit organizations, private sector companies and<br />
public interest groups will continue into December 2012.<br />
MMBC also developed a website that was launched on October 10, 2012 as a mechanism to<br />
provide information to stakeholders and for stakeholders to submit comments to and ask<br />
questions of MMBC.<br />
Si<br />
The draft PPP stewardship plan was posted on October 23, 2Q12 and MMBC will hold a<br />
consultation workshop with simultaneous webcast on October 29, 2012. Stakeholders are<br />
encouraged to submit written comments on the draft plan following the workshop.<br />
1. 1<br />
Comni’ents received by November 9, 2012 will be summarized in Appendix C together with<br />
responses from MMBC describing if and how the comments were addressed in the final version<br />
of the PPP stewardship plan submitted to the Director.<br />
MMBC will continue to receive and consider comments on this draft PPP stewardship plan until<br />
December 14, 2012 when the stakeholder meetings will be completed. The plan may be refined<br />
based on written submissions received and stakeholders meetings between November 12 and<br />
December 14, 2012. Written submissions received between November 12 and December 14,<br />
2012 will be added to Appendix C together with responses from MMBC describing if and how<br />
L’ 141]<br />
24
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
the comments were addressed in the updated version of the PPP stewardship plan. An<br />
updated PPP stewardship plan may be submitted to the Director in early January 2013.<br />
e‘N<br />
/.1rz:I N.,<br />
LTh .5<br />
• ‘C)<br />
/2<br />
25
Appendix A — Glossary<br />
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Collector<br />
Entity providing services for collection of PPP from households or from streetscapes under<br />
contract with MMBC.<br />
Depot<br />
Facility where residents can drop off PPP under contract to MMBC.<br />
Market Clearing Price<br />
Payment available to service providers (subject to executing an agreement to provide a defined<br />
service, comply with a specified qualification standard on a continuous basis, report specified<br />
data on a defined schedule) designed to stimulate marketplace activities and act as a market<br />
clearing mechanism,<br />
ICI<br />
Industrial, commercial and institutional, a<br />
Processing<br />
Manual or mechanical alteration of PPP for the purpose of ?ource recovery.<br />
Primary Processor<br />
First receivers of collected PPP that market at least some types of processed PPP directly to<br />
end markets. Primary processors may engage downstream processors that can more efficiently<br />
or effectively sort, process and market some ts’q PPP.<br />
Qualification Standard<br />
t%./<br />
Minimum operating standard that a service provider must meet on a continuous basis in order to<br />
be eligible to provide collection, depot operation and/or processing services under a contract<br />
with MMBC.<br />
—<br />
Recovery Rate ( ‘V’<br />
Calculated as a percentage with the numerator representing the quantity of PPP recycled or<br />
recovered and the denominator representing the quantity of PPP available for coHection.<br />
( Recovery Rate % =<br />
A’<br />
Recovered (material utilization) xlOO<br />
Available for Collection<br />
Service Pr&iger<br />
Entity th collects PPP from single-family or multi-family households or streetscapes, operates<br />
a deptr4provide post-collection services under contract with MMBC.<br />
‘1<br />
PAGE<br />
LJ!1!i<br />
26
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Appendix B — Member List<br />
To be included in stewardship plan when submitted to the Director on November 19, 2012<br />
PAGE<br />
[qe<br />
N.<br />
6\.<br />
27
Draft Packaging and Printed Paper Stewardship Plan<br />
Appendix C — Consultation Comments and Responses<br />
To be completed following consultation workshop scheduled for October 29, 2012<br />
E’<br />
ITEW<br />
N’.<br />
28
Draft List of PPP to be Collected under PPP Stewardship Program<br />
PPP Accepted In Existing Collection Systems<br />
During preparation of the report titled Cuffent System for Managing Residential Packaging and<br />
Printed Paper in British Columbia, MMBC compiled information on the PPP collection services<br />
provided to BC residents in single-family and multi-family households.<br />
These data highlight the inconsistencies in PPP accepted among BC collection programs today.<br />
While all of the single-family and multi-family households currently receiving collection service<br />
(78% and 79% of single4amily and multi-family households respectively) can recycle their<br />
printed papers and steel and aluminum packaging, collection service for other types of<br />
packaging varies widely across the province, as shown in the foIlowin’ table.<br />
% of Total Singlefamily<br />
Households<br />
% of Total Multifamily<br />
Households..<br />
% of Total<br />
Households<br />
Newspapers and inserts<br />
Office paper<br />
Mixed waste paper<br />
78%<br />
78% A W’<br />
79%<br />
79%<br />
- 78%<br />
• 78%<br />
Telephone directories 78% ‘W 79%<br />
Corrugated cardboard 75% 77% 76%<br />
gabletop<br />
4% 0% 3%<br />
1 78% , 79%<br />
All rigid plastic containers 33% ‘! 13% 27%<br />
Film plastic 21% 13% ., 18%<br />
1 -PET bottles 57% Afl”68% 61%<br />
1 -PETother a 66% 58%<br />
2-HDPEclear F’ 57% 68% 60%<br />
2- HDPE coloured k57% W 68% 60%<br />
2- Milk jugs a .S6% 68% 60%<br />
3-PVC ‘jS’fl8% Y 2% 13%<br />
4—LDPE .a. ‘<br />
55% 68% 59%<br />
5—PP ‘t.. ‘1 57% 68% 60%<br />
6- PSnon-expanded’<br />
6-PSfoam<br />
‘wl<br />
‘1% 1% 5°’<br />
7-other 15% 1% 11%<br />
Aluminum cans 77% 79% 78%<br />
Aluminum foil and plates 58% 66% 60%<br />
Steel cans 77% 79% 78%<br />
Other metal packaging 21% 11% 18%<br />
Glass containers 60% 78% 65%<br />
‘Includes boxboard.<br />
4% 2% 10%<br />
L<strong>ii</strong>
Draft List of PPP to be Collected under PPP Stewardship Program<br />
Proposed PPP to Be Accepted under PPP Stewardship Plan<br />
MMBC’s aspiration is to have all PPP supplied into BC effectively collected and recycled.<br />
Achieving this outcome will involve a number of steps of which the first will be to expand the<br />
existing collection system to accommodate a uniform province-wide list of PPP materials. This<br />
list will be predicated on the existence of recycling end-markets for each material on the list.<br />
Collecting the full range of PPP for which there are existing markets in all areas of the province<br />
will require adjustments to the majority of collection programs and by the primary and<br />
downstream processors that receive the collected material, It will also require effort to ensure<br />
that the additional PPP is effectively marketed with minimal disruption to local commodity<br />
market arrangements.<br />
The following list is the proposed PPP to be accepted when MMBC assumes responsibility for<br />
the PPP stewardship plan in May 2014.<br />
Material Type<br />
Printed Papers<br />
Newspapers and Inserts I<br />
Magazines/Catalogues 4<br />
‘ !‘<br />
I<br />
Via Curbside<br />
Collection Where<br />
Provided and Via<br />
Depots_In_Other Areas<br />
Via Drop off<br />
Depots Qy<br />
Via Organics<br />
Collection Only<br />
2<br />
Telephone Directories P’ 4<br />
Other Printed Paper j’<br />
‘1<br />
Paper PackagIng<br />
Corrugated Cardboarah,. a<br />
Boxboard<br />
.<br />
If contaminated<br />
with food<br />
Kraft Paper Sags 4 If contaminated<br />
with food<br />
Molded Pulp Containers<br />
Polycoated Cartons and •I<br />
I<br />
If contaminated<br />
with food<br />
Cups<br />
Aseptic Containers .fl’ 4<br />
Plastic_Packaging<br />
PETBottles(#1) I<br />
PET Thermoform (#1) 4<br />
HDPE Containers (#2) 4<br />
2 While the majority of PPP diverted is collected in dedicated recycling systems, some local governments accept<br />
specific types of PPP. such as soiled paper packaging, in organic waste collection programs. MMBC will undertake<br />
research to determine the quantity of PPP in organic waste collection programs and will, if the quantity is significant,<br />
develop a market-clearing price financial incentive reflecting the portion of PPP in the organic waste stream. Should<br />
local governments decline the offer, MMBC will not directly undertake collection of organic waste given the relatively<br />
small portion of PPP compared to food waste in this collection stream.<br />
ITEM
Draft List of PPP to be Collected under PPP Stewardship Program<br />
.<br />
Material Type<br />
Tubs and Lids (#2,4, 5)<br />
Via Curbside<br />
CollectIon Where<br />
Provided and Via<br />
Depots_In_Other Areas<br />
1<br />
Via Drop off<br />
Depots Q&<br />
Via Organics<br />
Collection Only<br />
Polystyrene Non-expanded<br />
Polystyrene Foam<br />
I<br />
3 ‘4<br />
PP Containers I -<br />
4 S<br />
5 fl<br />
0<br />
7<br />
6 ‘1<br />
2<br />
Other Rigid Plastics (#4, 5.<br />
7 or unmarked)<br />
4<br />
LDPEIHDPE Film<br />
Other Films<br />
Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)<br />
Bottles and Other 1<br />
Containers (# 3)<br />
Subject to<br />
Biodegradable plastic confirmation of<br />
packaging composting<br />
facility capability<br />
Plastics Laminates<br />
Paper/Plastic Laminates<br />
Other Packaging<br />
Aluminum Cans<br />
Aluminum Foil I<br />
Steel Cans<br />
Spiral-wound cans I<br />
Glass Bottles & iars<br />
9 I<br />
Subsequently, the uniform list of materials will be expanded incrementally in a step-wise<br />
process to ensure collection, processing and marketing of additional materials will not<br />
compromise the operation and reliability of the existing collection and recycling system, the<br />
quality of materials shipped to end-markets, the viability of these end-markets, the confidence of<br />
residents in their recycling program and the environmental performance of the system.<br />
The benefits of this incremental approach to expand the scope of collected materials include:<br />
Packaging only. Does not inciude poiystyrene foam used for construction or other purposes.<br />
Inciudes plastic grocery bags, plastic retail carry out bags (except bags with metal gromrnets, rape drawstrings and<br />
other non-plastic items), newspaper I flyer bags, dry cleaning bags, overwrap used for bottled water cases, pop<br />
cases, toilet tissue, paper towels, diapers etc., overwrap around durable products and marked #2 or #4 (such as<br />
around mattresses, furniture or eiectronic equipment), piastic water softener/sait bags , garden product bags (e.g..<br />
soil, mulch, etc. provided residues are removed), bread bags (transparent), produce and bulk Food bags for dry fruits<br />
and fresh vegetables, cereai box <strong>ii</strong>ners<br />
Includes cellophane overwrap (clear crinkly/non-stretch plastic), supermarket fresh meat wrap (food residues are<br />
health risk to coflectors and processors), pasta bags, prewashed saiad mix bags<br />
Includes cheese, pouitry and meat overwrap, plastic bubble wrap, stand up pouches<br />
Examples include bhster packages<br />
including empty aerosol containers.<br />
Including empty aerosol containers.<br />
ID Giass may be accepted at depots rather than in curbside collection programs.<br />
trEri PAG El
Draft List of PPP to be Collected under PPP Stewardship Program<br />
• It builds on the existing recycling programs collection and processing systems in a<br />
logical environmentally and economically prudent manner;<br />
• It protects the environmental performance of the existing recycling program by ensuring<br />
the addition of materials to the list is preceded by requisite investments and operational<br />
changes that ensure best use of materials and no degradation to the collection and<br />
recycling of materials already on the list; accordingly,<br />
• It upholds the pollution prevention hierarchy by ensuring the PPP program focuses on<br />
recycling outcomes and does not rely on the recovery and disposal options on the<br />
pollution prevention hierarchy.<br />
LZZ<br />
‘3J
Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation<br />
Note: Estimated timelines are based on an assumption that the PPP stewardship plan is<br />
approved In Quarter 1, 2013 and are subject to revision.<br />
To Prepare for Collection Activities<br />
The list of PPP proposed to be accepted in single-family and multi-family household collection<br />
systems and in depots will be posted for consultation with stakeholders during Quarter 4, 2012.<br />
It is anticipated that draft PPP collection vendor standards, including a reporting protocol, for<br />
collection services for single-family households, multi-family dwellings and depots will be<br />
prepared early in 2013 for consultation with stakeholders during Quarter 1, 2013.<br />
Research into system costs for purposes of setting market-clearing price financial incentives for<br />
collection services for single-family households, multi-family dwellings and depots will be<br />
undertaken during Quarter 1, 2013. Following analysis of the information compiled during this<br />
research, it is anticipated that:<br />
• Offers to local governments and First Nations that are the incumbent collector for PPP<br />
set at curbside will be issued in Quarter 2, 2013: Where local governments accept the<br />
offer, agreements will be executed;<br />
• Where the local government or First Nation declines the offer or where there is no<br />
current PPP service In an area that meets the reasonable access criteria, an RFP will be<br />
issued and an agreement will be executed with the respondent best able to comply with<br />
the vendor standards and deliver the collection services required; and<br />
• A request forrexpression of interest to provide collection services from multi-family<br />
dwellings and at depots will be issued In Quarter 2, 2013. Agreements will be executed<br />
with respondents able to comply with,the vendor standards and deliver the collection<br />
services required.<br />
4__<br />
It is anticipated that activities with respect to streetscape will begin with audits of PPP and<br />
garbage in existing streetscape collection programs and audits of the PPP recovered during<br />
processing and directed to recycling end-markets undertaken during Quarters 1 and 2, 2013.<br />
Following analysis of the information compiled during this research, it is anticipated that a<br />
request for expression of interest to collaborate with MMBC in the implementation of a pilot<br />
project for streetscape collection services will be issued in Quarter 3, 2013 wIth the pilot project<br />
operating into Quarter 1, 2014. Following analysis of the information compiled during the pilot<br />
project, it is anticipated that a preferred approach to streetscape collection will be developed<br />
and offers of market-clearing price financial incentives to local governments for streetscape<br />
collection will be issued in Quarter 2, 2014. Where local governments accept the offer,<br />
agreements will be executed. Where local governments decline the offer, MMBC will enter into<br />
discussions with local governments to discuss issues related to integrating producer-operated<br />
PPP collection with local government-operated garbage collection in streetscapes.<br />
h
Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation<br />
In order to assess the feasibility of offering market-clearing price financial incentives for PPP<br />
included with organics collection, it is anticipated that audits of source separated organic waste<br />
to identify the types and quantities of PPP will be undertaken during Quarters 1 and 2, 2013. If<br />
the quantity of PPP in the organics collection stream is determined to be material, MMBC will<br />
undertake research into system costs for purposes of setting market-clearing price financial<br />
incentives for organics collection services will be undertaken during Quarter 2, 2013. FollowIng<br />
analysis of the information compiled during this research, it is anticipated that offers to local<br />
governments that are the incumbent collector of organic waste from single-family households<br />
will be issued in Quarter 3, 2013. Where local governments accept the offer, agreements will be<br />
executed. Where local governments decline the offer, MMBC will not undertake collection of<br />
organic waste given the relatively small portion of PPP compared to food waste in this collection<br />
stream.<br />
To Prepare for Post-collection Activities<br />
It is anticipated that the PPP processor vendor standards, including reporting protocol, for postcollection<br />
services will be prepared early in 2013 for consultation with stakeholders during<br />
Quarter 1, 2013.<br />
It is anticipated that a request for expressions of interest (REOI) will be issued to processors<br />
during Quarter 1,2013. The REOI will request information such as:<br />
‘ .A<br />
• Types of PPP accepted;<br />
• Degree of commingling of PPP accepted (e.g. single stream, two stream, separated<br />
streams for certain materials); \<br />
• Quality specifications for PPP received;<br />
• Receiving capacity per day;<br />
• Storage capacity for PPP received (prior to processing);<br />
• Types of sorting equipment;<br />
,• Sorting capacityper hour;<br />
• Current hours of operation per day;<br />
• Storage capacity for processed PPP ready for shipment;<br />
• Types of commodities produced;<br />
• Grades and quality specifications for PPP shipped; and<br />
• Mass balance of Incoming PPP In relation to commodities shipped to recycling markets,<br />
recovery markets and disposal.<br />
Following analysis of the information submitted in response to the REQI, it Is anticipated that the<br />
request for proposals (RFP) for post-collection services will be Issued In Quarter 2, 2013.<br />
Agreements will be executed with qualified processors.
Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation<br />
To Prepare for Producer Reporting<br />
Following approval of the PPP stewardship plan, MMBC will formalize its relationship with those<br />
producers that choose to be members. This process will involve the following activities:<br />
• Execution of a contract between MMBC and each producer,<br />
• Registration of producers in MMBC’s data management system:<br />
• Reporting by producers of the quantity of each type of PPP supplied to the residential<br />
sector;<br />
• Calculation of steward fees: and<br />
• Fee invoicing, payments, audits and compliance activities.<br />
‘‘‘I<br />
It is anticipated that registration and reporting by producers will occur in Quarter 2, 2013 with<br />
calculation of steward fees to follow in Quarter 3 or early Quarter 4, 2013.<br />
Administration<br />
&<br />
Between approval of the PPP stewardship plan and the May 2014 implementation date, MMBC<br />
must acquire the necessary human and other resources to manage all aspects of plan<br />
implementation.<br />
Examples of the administrative systems that must be delivered directly or through contracted<br />
services include: ‘*<br />
• Typical administrative activities to establish and support an office infrastructure and to<br />
manage employees;<br />
• Financial management services to manage receivables, including producer fees and<br />
MMBC’s share ,of commodity revenues, and payables, including payment for<br />
administrative services and program delivery casts;<br />
• An internet accessible system to enable producers to report the quantity of PPP supplied<br />
to residents; •<br />
• An internet accessible system to enable qualified collectors and processors to report the<br />
data required to support invoicing and payments;<br />
• A system to receive and manage data reported by producers and service providers;<br />
• Contract management services for agreements with producers and service providers:<br />
and ‘<br />
• Ancillary activities such as periodic composition audits of collected and processed PPP.<br />
1
Communications<br />
Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation<br />
Preparations required to effectively launch the PPP stewardship plan in May 2014 will include<br />
but not be limited to:<br />
• Conducting qualitative and quantitative research with residents to test the effectiveness<br />
of P&E materials and channels of communication and to establish measurement<br />
benchmarks;<br />
• Identifying potential partners with whom MMBC can potentially develop collaborative<br />
P&E programs;<br />
• Reviewing existing successful, mature local government programs to determine how<br />
communication tactics and materials might be utilized oñmodified as necessary, and<br />
shared widely to aid program P&E activities throughout the province;<br />
• Developing messages and assembling visual images and graphics, as required;<br />
• Identifying appropriate print and electronic creative materials; ‘a<br />
• Developing a paid and earned media plan to produce news stories and advertisements<br />
that will help disseminate Information about the program;<br />
• Developing a social media plan to disseminate Information and engage residents in<br />
interactions concerning recycling activities;<br />
• Organize event(s) to launch the program;<br />
• Develop a P&E resources portal to offer program-based P&E materials to local<br />
governments, First Nation governments and other program stakeholders; and<br />
• Integrate key program information into existing solid waste mobile apps<br />
r<br />
1 to help<br />
disseminate and clarify PPP program elements (what’s in/what’s out, how to prepare<br />
a<br />
recyclables, and what to do with them, etc.).<br />
Opportunities for Dialogue<br />
Stakeholders will have opportunities to review and comment on:<br />
• Proposed list of PPP to be collected;<br />
• Draft vendor standards;<br />
• Proposed market clearing price financial incentives for collectors; and<br />
• MMBC’s proposed approach to streetscape collection system design.<br />
MMBC will consult with local governments and First Nations responsible for delivering local<br />
public education and promotion during development and deployment of its communication<br />
strategy.<br />
1 Many local governments have solid waste apps for residents to download to their smartphones and tablels putting<br />
information at residents’ fingertips 24/7. Examples are my-waste’ already in use in more than a dozen municipalities,<br />
RcBcs web-based recyclepedia’ and Vancouver’s werecycle.
Preliminary Approaches to Preparing for Implementation<br />
Where local governments decline the financial incentive offer to provide collection of PPP at<br />
curbside, MMBC will work co-operatively with them to minimize disruption to residents during<br />
the transition of PPP collection services.<br />
Where local governments decline the financial incentive offer to provide collection of PPP from<br />
streetscapes, MMBC will collaborate with them to resolve issues, where possible, related to<br />
integrating producer-operated PPP collection with local government-operated garbage collection<br />
in streetscapes.
C I T Y o P<br />
PØRT<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
DATE: November 15, 2012<br />
To:<br />
FROM:<br />
Environmental Enhancement Committee<br />
Allen Jensen, B. Tech., AScT<br />
Manager of Environmental Services<br />
Report to Committee<br />
SUBJECT: COMMUNITY CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE FUND ELECTRIC<br />
VEHICLE CHARGING STATION PLANNING STUDY - STATUS UPDATE<br />
RECOMMENDATION:<br />
That the staff report titled “Community Charging Infrastructure Fund Electric Vehicle Charging<br />
Station Planning Study - Status Update” dated November 15, 2012 be received for information.<br />
PURPOSE:<br />
At its June 2012 meeting, the Environmental Enhancement Committee supported the<br />
participation in a region-wide electric vehicle charging station planning study coordinated by<br />
Metro Vancouver (MV) which will determine a regional system and framework. As well, work<br />
has been undertaken by some member municipalities to construct pilot charging stations in<br />
priority locations throughout the region.<br />
The purpose of this report is to provide Committee with an update of the planning study and the<br />
partnership between MV and participating member municipalities to assist eligible businesses<br />
and non-profit organizations to access incentives through the Provincial Community Charging<br />
Infrastructure Fund to host an electric vehicle charging station.<br />
BACKGROUND:<br />
On July 30, 2012 Metro Vancouver and participating member municipalities were awarded a<br />
$75,000 grant under the Provincial Community Charging Infrastructure Fund to carry out a<br />
region-wide planning process for electric vehicle charging stations.<br />
The study is being conducted to determine the priority locations<br />
electric vehicle charging stations or technically known as Electric<br />
(EVSE), recruit and inform potential hosts, conduct site assessments<br />
estimates) and obtain host commitment to install 75 EVSE through<br />
Charging Infrastructure program.<br />
iJ<br />
to site publicly-accessible<br />
Vehicle Supply Equipment<br />
(including electrical budget<br />
the Provincial Community
COMMUNITY CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE FUND ELECTRIC VEHICLE<br />
CHARGING STATION PLANNING STUDY - STATUS UPDATE<br />
Page 2<br />
A Request for Qualifications and subsequent Request for Proposal were issued in September<br />
with the project being awarded to RB Lanarc a member of the Golder Group of Companies in<br />
early October.<br />
On October 19, 2012 a meeting was held to receive an update from HB Lanarc on identified<br />
EVSE priority sites from spatial analysis and to discuss the outreach strategy.<br />
The attached advertisement will appear in the local papers to promote the local EV Charging<br />
Station Incentive Information Session scheduled for November 19, 2012 in the Council<br />
Chatnbers at the Coquitlam City Hall.<br />
DISCUSSION:<br />
To determine the possibility and framework for a regional network prior to committing capital<br />
investment, the City has been participating in the regional planning study (funded through a<br />
grant applied for by Metro Vancouver under the Provincial Community Charging Infrastructure<br />
Fund). The following sections highlight the progress to date and initial findings.<br />
Spatial Analysis & Prospective EVSE Hosts<br />
The criteria to undertake the spatial analysis was based on priority location types, average daily<br />
traffic volume, employment density, large property owners and proximity to existing EVSE.<br />
An initial list of businesses at 32 priority host locations in Port Coquitlam has been developed<br />
and shown in the attached map. These location types are led by Big Box Retailers, Large<br />
Property Owners, Large Commercial and Parks Playing Fields. These locations have significant<br />
vehicular traffic volume most days of the week and parking durations from one to four hours.<br />
Communications and Outreach<br />
The objective for the communications and outreach is to provide information to businesses and<br />
organizations and to relay the potential benefits of hosting an EVSE, such as:<br />
• Demonstrate forward-thinking, community interest;<br />
• Attract trend-setting, values-driven clientele;<br />
• Take advantage of substantial, time-limited incentives and technical support;<br />
• Gain profile through Metro Vancouver and participating municipalities;<br />
• Retailers: provide incentives and services to EV customers;<br />
• Parking garages: increase parking space ROl and attract new business; and<br />
• Employers: attract caring employees and support sustainability efforts.<br />
Zi<br />
ITEM (PAGE
COMMUNITY CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE FUND ELECTRIC VEHICLE<br />
CHARGING STATION PLANNING STUDY - STATUS UPDATE<br />
Page 3<br />
EV Charging Incentive Info-Sessions<br />
Several free EV Charging Incentive Info-Sessions will be held during November throughout the<br />
region that include a briefing on the incentive, tech support on charging equipment and small<br />
group discussions to answer questions on site specific costs, benefits and technical issues.<br />
• November 14, 9:00 AM — 11:00AM<br />
Metro Vancouver Head Office, Burnaby<br />
• November 15,9:00 AM — 11:00 AM<br />
District of North Vancouver Municipal Hall<br />
• November 16. 9:00 AM — 11:00 Atvl<br />
Surrey, Chuck Bailey Community Centre<br />
• November 19, 9:00 AM — 11:00AM<br />
Coquitlam, City Hall<br />
To date, the City’s contribution to the project has been staff resources, without the commitment<br />
of installing City owned and operated stations.<br />
The study is attracting interest, and identifying a number of potential locations, of which private<br />
sector locations may be in the position of providing the best impact and support for a useful<br />
regional EV system.<br />
With the identification of potential private sector locations, Metro Vancouver and participating<br />
member municipalities will be able to assist businesses and organizations by profiling hosts on<br />
their websites, online communications, public events and media releases. In addition, there may<br />
be the possibility of the City as well as Metro Vancouver and other member municipalities to<br />
assist eligible businesses and non-profit organizations access provincial incentives to host an<br />
electric vehicle charging station.<br />
Further work and discussions are anticipated as the project and EV programs develop.<br />
CONCLUSION:<br />
The region-wide planning study is well underway with the completion of the spatial analysis and<br />
an initial list of priority locations, which sets the stage for the information sessions on EVSE.<br />
The planning and deployment of a successful regional network of EV charging stations will rely<br />
on the partnerships between Metro Vancouver, member municipalities and the private sector.
COMMUNITY CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE FUND ELECTRIC VEHICLE<br />
CHARGING STATION PLANNING STUDY - STATUS UPDATE<br />
Page 4<br />
As this project proceeds, staff will report back on the findings and progress on potential stations<br />
and partnerships within the boundaries of Port Coquitlarn. In addition, staff will continue to<br />
liaise with Coquitlarn and Port Moody staff<br />
Tech., AScT<br />
Manager of Environmental Services<br />
Approved by Andrew Wood, Ph.D., P.Eng.<br />
Director of Engineering & Operations<br />
Attachments: I. Electric Vehicle Charging Incentive Program Advertisement<br />
2. EVSE Site Selection Map<br />
Ei1
Electric Vehicle Charging<br />
Incentive Program<br />
Charge Up Your Business<br />
Show community leadership. Attract customers.<br />
Gain profile. Get a big rebate and tech support!<br />
Contact Metro Vancouver by November 30th!<br />
Provincial incentives of up to $4000 are available forthe<br />
purchase and installation of public electric vehicle charging<br />
stations. MetroVancouver, in partnership with the Cities of<br />
Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam and Port Moody, would like to help<br />
you to access these incentives!<br />
Attend An Electric Vehicle Charging Station<br />
Info Session!<br />
Sessions are free. Registration is not required. This two-hour<br />
session includes:<br />
• Power” briefing on the incentive<br />
• Technical support on charging equipment<br />
• Optional discussions on site specific costs, benefits and<br />
technical issues.<br />
Monday, November 19<br />
9:00 a.m. - 11:00 am.<br />
Coquitlam, City Council Chambers and Foyer<br />
3000 Guildford Way, Coquitlam<br />
Free parking available at Evergreen Cultural Centre<br />
Contact Metro Vancouver at<br />
Evstation@metrovancouver.org<br />
or call 604-688-9769, ext 135<br />
PØRT<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
metro Vancouver<br />
CoQuitlam
EV Site Selection Long List for Port<br />
Coquiflam:<br />
Large Property Owners:<br />
Community Centre: 0<br />
Cultural: 1<br />
Government Buildings: 0<br />
Hospital: 0<br />
Hotel: 0<br />
Office Buildings: 1,<br />
Food Market: 0<br />
Retail Stsip: 4<br />
Small Commercial: 2 i<br />
Large Commerciat: 6<br />
Big Box Retailer<br />
Shopping Centre: 0 i<br />
Shopping Centre Regional: 0<br />
Parkade: 1<br />
Parks Playing Fields: 6 I<br />
Tourist Destination: 1<br />
Recreation: 0 -<br />
Arena: 0<br />
School: 0<br />
-* [sir [ar.foioUcg<br />
• coie,,o,.,c..m<br />
• cadaral<br />
• Coo.io<strong>ii</strong>i.ieeoMa,<br />
S Hoon,bi<br />
• Hold<br />
• OWcteodaag.<br />
• Food Macti<br />
Reia,i Sore<br />
Sioa<strong>ii</strong>C0000aoaI<br />
• Lou. Coooow,oiai<br />
• eq e..e.iao.,<br />
• a<strong>ii</strong>ipp.g<br />
• Shipp.q c.ot;u-q,o,ooa<br />
A Paus and Rep<br />
A<br />
9 F qlds<br />
• Palo. S Play.<br />
• t&roiO..tr.ooen<br />
• R.ni.aSo.<br />
• —l<strong>ii</strong><br />
• aohoia<br />
uonnicoa.q.<br />
C Ni N..aGo.u<br />
- •<br />
* Pi.a5ShIloLlnSo’-,<br />
Eailye.d<br />
[aao.d
C I •I Y (5 F<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
DATE: November 14,2012<br />
TO: Environmental Enhancement Committee<br />
FROM: Gordon Voncina, Manager of Operations<br />
SUBJECT: 2012-2013 WASTE-LOSS CHALLENGE CONTEST<br />
RECOMMENDATIONS:<br />
Report to Committee<br />
That the staff report titled “2012-2013 Waste-Loss Challenge Contest” dated November 14,<br />
2012, be received for information.<br />
BACKGROUND:<br />
Over the past years, the City has implemented several initiatives to divert solid waste materials to<br />
recycling, kitchen and green waste processors. These initiatives included, implementation of the<br />
Green Cart Program, bi-weekly curb-side collection of solid waste with weekly green and<br />
kitchen waste collection throughout the summer, financial incentives for residents using smaller<br />
refuse carts, education programs, “how to” video clips, printed literature and brochures. In 2011,<br />
a diversion rate of 62% was achieved for the City’s curbside solid waste program.<br />
To inspire residents to continue to explore waste reduction opportunities, the City introduced a<br />
new awareness campaign in 2011. This program, named the “Waste-Loss Challenge” was<br />
presented to the public in the form of a contest to increase community participation. Building on<br />
this strategy, the 2012-2013 contest is titled the “Biggest Waste Loser” and has been developed<br />
by staff in the Communications and Engineering & Operations Departments.<br />
DISCUSSION:<br />
Building on the 2011 strategy, the 20 12-2013 contest is titled the “Biggest Waste Loser”. From<br />
January to April 2013, four Port Coquitlarn households - including families with children,<br />
individuals, couples and seniors - will compete to reduce what they send to the landfill while the<br />
community follows their journey through blogs, video. Facebook and advertisements.<br />
The contest is designed to have participants try to divert as much as they can away from landfills<br />
and is based on contestants achieving the highest diversion rate by the end of the period, rather<br />
than at the start of the contest. During the course of the competition, the City will assist with<br />
resources and tips to the participants.<br />
4sbc
2012-2013 WASTE-LOSS CHALLENGE CONTEST<br />
Page 2<br />
The contest will run January to April 2013 and the City will announce the waste-loss champion<br />
during Earth Week which is scheduled for April 16 through 22 and provide prizes which have<br />
been donated by a number of City partners.<br />
Contestants currently being sought include families with children, seniors, couples and<br />
individuals who have a Port Coquitlam address and receive City garbage collection. Applications<br />
will be accepted online until November 26, 2012 (with video entries welcomed), and contestants<br />
will be named in early December.<br />
Throughout the contest period, City staff will weigh and monitor what contestants set out at the<br />
curb. As well, each month from January to April, contestants will be required to submit either a<br />
150-400 word description or a 1-2 minute video about what they have learned, actions they have<br />
taken and tips for other residents. The submissions will be published and/or publicized on City<br />
websites and in newspaper promotions. The monthly messages relating to waste reduction<br />
efforts will raise awareness of the City’s initiatives and details of the contest and entry<br />
information will also be posted in all civic facilities.<br />
CONCLUSION:<br />
The City has identified a goal of reducing waste and has developed a participative program. The<br />
2012-2013 program is titled the “Biggest Waste Loser” and seeks contestants that will showcase<br />
the desire and possibilities and practices to reduce waste. The objective of the contest is to<br />
inspire residences to continue to improve diversion rates, and in doing so, allow the City to move<br />
towards accomplishing its waste reduction goals.<br />
oncina<br />
ci ger of Operations<br />
Approved by Andrew Wood, Ph.D., P.Eng.<br />
Director of Engineering & Operations<br />
W:bng\t)cpcCummiIIeesEIflReports\20I2\20I2-I I-21)\2012-I 1-14 - 21)12-2013 Wasw Ij,ss ChuIIene fl’ritcsi<br />
ITEM PAGEj
C I T Y 0 P<br />
PØRT<br />
a<br />
City of Port Coguitlam<br />
2530 Shaughnessy St. Port Coquitlam B.C. V3C 2A6 / Phone: 927-5411/Fax: 927-5407<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
Status Of Ongoing Environmental Enhancement Committee Activities<br />
November 20, 2012<br />
LOw Expected<br />
EEC<br />
LN Agenda Item Resp Action i Completion<br />
Mtg —<br />
a. U) Date<br />
School District #43- The City is partnering with School District #43 to provide<br />
1 Recycling Program E&O L recycling and organics collection to all schools in Port IP Ongoing<br />
Coquitlam.<br />
Streetlighting System Undertake an streetlight inventory (location, wattage, road<br />
com<br />
Inventory for LED classification) to facilitate the conversion to LED<br />
p<br />
. . . leted<br />
Conversion<br />
luminaires.<br />
2<br />
E&O H<br />
2012 2012<br />
progr<br />
am<br />
Pitt River Intertidal<br />
Hold a celebration event for the completion of a 23-acre<br />
E&O<br />
3 Habitat Project ‘ M habitat area for fish, birds and other wildlife along the Pill IP 2012<br />
. Comm<br />
Celebration Event River.<br />
Maple Creek Integrated A strategic plan designed to meet the planning and<br />
Watershed Management E&O, environmental objectives for the Maple Creek Watershed<br />
4 Plan P&R, H and the cities of Port Coquitlam and Coquitlam’s IP 2013<br />
DS commitment under the Meto Vancouver Liquid Waste<br />
Management Plan.<br />
Floodplain Policy DS, Create a floodplain policy to regulate development in the<br />
Project deferred (staff resources not<br />
5<br />
H<br />
F TBD<br />
E&O floodplain funded)<br />
Urban Forest<br />
Develop an Urban Forest Management Program, including<br />
P&R<br />
Management Program<br />
street tree inventory and park tree replacement<br />
6<br />
E&O, H<br />
B TBD<br />
regulations.<br />
DS, Fire<br />
High Performance<br />
Develop a high performance (green) building program and —<br />
DS<br />
(green) Building Program set of policies that promote energy and water<br />
Project deferred (staff resources not<br />
E&o H<br />
F TBD<br />
conservation, stormwater management, construction funded)<br />
P&R<br />
— material recycling, and noise attenuation. —<br />
7<br />
Ia’&;I<br />
Page 1 of2
Status Of Ongoing Environmental Enhancement Committee Activities<br />
November 20, 2012<br />
EEC<br />
LN<br />
Agenda Item Resp Action o Completion<br />
Mt g 0<br />
a<br />
Date<br />
On-Site Rainwater Update and implement local government regulations<br />
Guidelines E&O, (engineering standards, develop permit guidelines) to<br />
8 DS, H reflect current riparian area and rainwater management F TBD<br />
P&R best management practices such as on-site rainwater<br />
management.<br />
Environmental Develop an Environmental Procurement Policy (EPP) that<br />
Procurement Policy CS, includes mandatory and desirable critieria for purchases.<br />
H<br />
TBD<br />
E&O Implement the EPP across all City departments.<br />
a, a, Expected<br />
Project deferred (staff resources not<br />
funded)<br />
Enhance of Solid Waste Provide presentation on various aspects & methods to<br />
10 Collection Service E & 0 H increase diversion IP 2013<br />
Shark Finning Practices Letter to Provincial and Federal government in support for<br />
11 E & 0 H sustainable shark fisheries management and practices. IP 2012<br />
Status Codes: P - In Progress; F - Future; H - On Hold for Information; B - Budget<br />
cc: Mayor & Councillors Chief Administrative Officer Corporate Management Team Engineering Managers Engineering Department Staff<br />
EEC Citizen Advisors<br />
Priority<br />
High<br />
H -<br />
Medium;<br />
M -<br />
Low;<br />
Priority Codes: L -<br />
2 of 2<br />
II I Page
COQUITLAM RiverWatch<br />
940 Stanton Ave. Coquitlam, B.C., V3J 4V2<br />
imcart@telus.net<br />
AUGUST 2012 NEWSLETTER. NUMBER 167<br />
JULY HIGHLIGHTS FROM REACH W-4<br />
It has been a remarkable month on Reach W-4. Indian Pipe has been very abundant. The first one was seen on June<br />
24 and I kept finding new clumps along much of the reach, from the Cooper property at the north end south to Grist<br />
Creek. The area near Savary is almost carpeted with it. A Great Blue Heron was fishing at the Gabriola outfall on<br />
two mornings. \Ve have had four frog sightings. in the drying side channel just north of the Gabriola outfall. These<br />
have been identified as Red-legged frogs, based on some not very good photographs. Red-legged frogs are a bluelisted<br />
species meaning that they are of special concern and at risk. A small salamander hatchling was seen several<br />
times in the same area. With the river so low the pools in this side channel drain quickly and in spite of efforts to<br />
keep some water in them they dried n immature Coopers l-lawk was spotted on July 18 and I have seen it<br />
almost even day since. Jay Brogan. a grad student at SF13 who is studying Coopers Hawks, came out to find the<br />
nest. We were unsuccessful but Jay is sure that the nest is located within a 50 metre radius of the north end of<br />
Gabriola, and is confident that we will find it.<br />
I<br />
Li<br />
L1<br />
1
Ian (\V-l) July31<br />
5 cars “crc parked along tite road and people were<br />
enjtsying the cool river on a ‘cry warm day. The Rier<br />
was clear and the level a as low, ‘v Isiehs is nonnal fr tlti<br />
ritne rtf year. Slate (‘reek was clear and flowing. The only<br />
birds I sa” “crc 2 American Dippers. The Al Grist<br />
\\<br />
Met non al I latetteo’ has a ne’v strrte tore over the tank<br />
area. It Istoks very sturdy. I luekiehernies “crc ripe and<br />
good to cat. Some of’ sIte berries were she largess I ha’<br />
ocr seen, hut did not ha’ e as much flavour as the<br />
stssallcr ones. ‘lltimhlehcnics ‘vere also ripe asid good<br />
eating. I Iitnalayan blackheo and toochs-me-not aetv<br />
flowering.<br />
Ian (W-2) July 31<br />
2 people ‘vere enjoying paddling in the river. The tra’cl<br />
trailer I sa’v last tnonth has been retr,o’ed and the area<br />
has been cleaned up. The Ri’er “as clear and at a lo’v<br />
Ic’ el at,o c and below the gravel operations. The water<br />
Ic’ el at the CalcIte gauge “as .541) tnetrcs. Falacea<br />
tFulawka) Creek (54) “as clear and at a low flow.<br />
Mantle (‘reek (a5) was clear and at a trw’ flo’v. Panridge<br />
Creek “as clear and lion ing lore. Marquart Creek “at<br />
altnost clear and firi i ng elI. Gsrodvcar Creek t I<br />
was clear and flow ing low. TIte tipper CoquitIatn River<br />
Park Prrnd vas srs tretnely low. No water was firm i ng oat<br />
trw the surbee. The outlet streatn was dry. Birds incudd<br />
female Mallard with 3 young, chickadees, and a robin.<br />
Some of the gra’ el piled up at the Upper Coquitlatn<br />
Ri er Park has been retnoved.<br />
Da’.e (W-3) July26<br />
l’etiple “crc” adtng and sitting hy the river at boIls<br />
Galetic and McIa isis Parks and 4 youngsters using<br />
hoogie hoartls and tn fiatablet to raft down the river. The<br />
shallower part at the toutlt end of I Ioekaday alst, had 8 to<br />
10 people wading in or sitting by the river. Park users at<br />
MeTavish clean op after lhetnselves and the Galette users<br />
tend to leave mt,re litter behind vhen they depart. Good<br />
veather brings out the recreational users tn the river.<br />
Galette Park is frequented tntire hy young adults,<br />
especially later in tlte day. MeTavish is used fore by<br />
fatnily groups ‘vith clsiltlrcn. ‘lie River was clear and at a<br />
nonnal level, hut cnitning down as the weather dries out.<br />
saw a stnall group of cltickadees, whiclt ‘vas the first in<br />
several mntntlts lhtere ‘vas also one cute Itouse ‘vren<br />
flitting among rite rocky riverside and a fbtnily of4<br />
flickers in the hruslt. .‘\ raccntntn with a datnaged front<br />
paw’ Itas hectitne a regular. I tltink it is being ted by the<br />
park users or is scavenging rite ‘ciod the users leave,<br />
Charlene & Itirger (W-$) .tuhy 29<br />
TIte river lecl was tnoderate and quite cloudy,<br />
although “e could see the ri’ erhed from the<br />
pedestrian hridge. Bird activity included ha”kt.<br />
sparrov. Dam and Tree Swahlt,svs, tnerganscrs.<br />
Mallard, and a lsutntninghird. We spent a fair<br />
atnount oftitne around Niundy (‘reek and the<br />
habitat restn’ration area. l’he only a ildlifc<br />
isihle “as tinc Mallard. We “crc surprised to<br />
see so few birds hut ltnipetiallv there is In,ts of<br />
a ildlifc in the area hut just trot of sight.<br />
JULY RiverWatcher’s REPORTS<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
LAKE<br />
“ANCOU”ER<br />
PIPELINE<br />
OALETIE<br />
/<br />
LOUIEtlO<br />
HW7<br />
JULY RAINFALL<br />
Cs<br />
C4<br />
hi t:t:ti:4:set7tt;r:::rzzzs;’:,;s;;:ssrtI<br />
dassof±eronth<br />
i’slalltx ([-2) July 7<br />
OR C RL’t:K I saw 27 peop!e doing a varies) ofacti’itics<br />
which is quite a few since this is pri’ ate properlY and<br />
there is a proposed development fr this area. This<br />
“as still far less hikers than last visit, probably due<br />
to the tine as I wanted to miss the worst of the heat<br />
There was ery little garbage Although the sound of<br />
the Ri er moving quite rapidly” as refrcslting. it was<br />
often drowned out hy the dntning quaff) trucks on<br />
tlte opposite side. While all the tiny creeks I crossed<br />
stn the trail were pristine, the ri’ Cr had an odd lioge<br />
rRtrc ttETT (H<br />
/<br />
END OF<br />
CORTtS St t ‘t rot iNtSSV<br />
PAtRt( Li<br />
PEDESTtrt,N<br />
tttilttot<br />
o,’rrs<br />
P-rK<br />
IONS<br />
tars<br />
FRASER RIVER N<br />
t<br />
to it. I heard Ins of birds, hut I didn’t see an’<br />
as I was too busy conceotrating sin ‘vltere I<br />
“as stepping. Because of ttte dry, warm weather<br />
o’er the last couple of da’s, I expected tlte trail; the<br />
most a•la-natural along the ri’ er. to he a little easier<br />
going hut it still retna ins a Isa’ en for mosquito<br />
breeding with puddles and hoggy conditions.<br />
Additionally, on sotne parts of the trail, the<br />
vegetation closed in on the path where at one point, I<br />
would have been mowed down by a hiker whir,<br />
couldn’t see me. if tt hadn’t been for my hear hell<br />
For some reason I didn’t notice this amazing cedar<br />
stutnp last tune. It must have been at least 301) years<br />
old before it svas chopped down.<br />
Murray ([-3 nortls) July 17<br />
Tisere were 6 kids in the River and 2 parents<br />
watching. II “-as a great day to he down by (lie River<br />
altltough no really deep ho let fr sw imtssi ng<br />
anymore. I picked up a bag ofgarhage — really<br />
qutle clean considering I ltadn’t been down for clttse<br />
to a month and it’s ntov summertime at the River<br />
The River was clear and quite low hut normal after<br />
o weeks of little rain. Questionable if enough<br />
ater is in tlse River to let me tube dow n it w itlt the<br />
grandson. The River is a great place to go and put<br />
yctur let in (if you can stand the tetnpcrature) wlttle<br />
reading a hook.<br />
Murray I L-3 south) July 19<br />
It “as a a ann afternoon along the Reach with a Fe” tn tog to<br />
find enough water ahoe their knees to get cool. Four people<br />
“crc in the Riser. This end of the Re’ cli ‘vas pleasantly<br />
surprisingly clean with, only a handful ofgarbage picked up. I<br />
pulled a kids floater raft out of the River. It had a hole in it so or,<br />
point bringing it home for tlte gtndcisildren. The Ri’er ‘vas<br />
clear attd normal bus mv It’s thts ttti,e ttf year that it hecomes<br />
inerea.singlv evident that there are l)u er and fewer decent deep<br />
spots in the Ri’ Cr that Ita’ ent already filled tn with gra’ el and<br />
silt,<br />
Charlene & Roger (\V-9) July 29<br />
The ri’er Ic’ el was moderate and quite cloudy.<br />
No’ that the recent high ‘vaters are receding.<br />
Ptfl Rt”ER RD<br />
e can see tftat the slope of rite btaacls at the<br />
mouth has decreased. When our dogs ‘vent in<br />
the river for a drink tttey were able to walk out<br />
quite a ways. All of tite logs (often used as<br />
bencltesi ha’e been washed away. flird actt riy<br />
included hawk, heron and pigeon. [Ite dyke<br />
rtrad hct’vcen the pedestrian bridge and the<br />
parking lot has been temporarily closed — no<br />
reason gi’en — so park visitors had to ose the<br />
lovcr tra t I. A sew’ dog ‘v alker etiquette hoard<br />
and dt’ggy bags have been erected at the COLONY<br />
head of the lower trail Park nales (dogs on FARM<br />
leash, no fires, no hikes, etc.) signage post<br />
also erected. There ‘vas also a sign posted<br />
at the mouth entrance directing walkers and<br />
cyclists to Maquahreak Park.<br />
RED BRIDGES<br />
COLONY<br />
FARM<br />
MARY rita BY ‘ASS<br />
Chiariene & Roger (F-St July29<br />
Tt tsr’ nirk veltie Its were in the Wilson Farm — we “crc titink in g that<br />
they were probably doing some fish wildlife monitoring. There were a<br />
fv plasttc bags and a Ttm I lorson S eofk’e cup. There ri’ erie’ el was<br />
tnoderate and tlsere dtdnt seem to he much current The W hon Farm<br />
waterways ‘vere moderate and had Isits of lily pads. The pump house<br />
wasnt ruttnttsg Bird actt’ tty included Red-tailed I Iawk, wren, sparrow<br />
and loads Dam and Tree Swallows. The swallows “crc very aett’e in<br />
light. On the new tidal gates were 4 young Barn Sw-aIIo’v s being fed<br />
by their parents. We noticed a few piles ofhear scat along lie dyke. Ve<br />
sa’v and heard three big frogsjust norshs ofthe pump house. Vegctatissn<br />
“as very big. \Vhite and pink s’veet pea flowers lined the dyke trail.<br />
The newly planted trees and sbtruhs in rise Wilson Fanis seem tb—<br />
establishing. A ne’v garbage can hat been erected near the new tkil<br />
gates—goodtosee! .—
Jeff(W-4) July 14<br />
The river was very low and clear, as it had been all<br />
month thus far except one day when the level had risen<br />
unexpectedly. I walked south on the main trail and<br />
returned along the river. Joggers (I 7) outnumbered<br />
walkers (9) and cyclists (4) as usual at an early hour.<br />
And, again as usual, dogs off leash (9) outnumbered<br />
dogs on leash (2). 3 dogs were in the river. The water in<br />
the large outfall at the north end of Gabriola had a<br />
soapy cast to it with some foam below the outfall. Coho<br />
fry were in the smaller of the two outfalls. Fry were<br />
also seen at many places among boulders along the<br />
river’s edge. The Maple Creek well and the Grist pipe<br />
were running well. Since the river was so low I could<br />
hop boulders to a small boulder island near the north<br />
end of the reach, something I have been meaning to do<br />
for a long time. I was horrified to discover a small<br />
clump of knotweed among the boulders in the middle of<br />
the river. I picked up litter on Sunday July 22. The<br />
trail was in good shape, most of the garbage<br />
was at the party areas.<br />
Murray (W-6) July 22<br />
The only cyclist was a regular to a<br />
homeless camp between Maple Creek and<br />
the Wilson power line. I-Ic’s been living<br />
along the river for a couple of years. More<br />
activity, which I think is good for the area,<br />
as a result of more families moving into the<br />
neighbourhood. Lots of dogs out today.<br />
Two people had 4 large dogs off leash —<br />
JULY RiverWatcher’s REPORTS<br />
a<br />
little unnerving to say the least. I collected<br />
a ½ bag of garbage. The Reach was COLONY<br />
quite clean, again mainly due to no FARM<br />
homeless camps underneath the Kingsway<br />
Bridge. The River was clear and very low<br />
measuring .5 metres at the gauge south of<br />
the Lougheed Bridge. Maple Creek at the<br />
culvert was I’ below the unofficial high<br />
water mark. A lot of green slime was in the<br />
pond just north of the culvert. As I<br />
mentioned above the area is becoming<br />
more popular for young families and will<br />
continue to grow with the development of<br />
Burleigh Walk once completed. I think this<br />
will generally be good for the area as it<br />
may discourage homeless camps<br />
from being set up along the River. FRA<br />
David (E-5) July 31<br />
CALE1IL__\ I saw 39 people along the River and was<br />
surprised to see so many people out and<br />
about on a Tuesday morning. Lots of<br />
people enjoying the coolness of the forest<br />
along the river. There was work going on<br />
END OF<br />
(‘ORIES ...<br />
PATRICiA<br />
PEDES1 RIAN<br />
SlUDGE<br />
i.ouGIiEE:/<br />
HWY.<br />
4<br />
CAFES<br />
PARK<br />
111] RiVER RD.<br />
(RED BRIDGET<br />
‘1<br />
N<br />
COLONY<br />
FARM<br />
at the Mountain Bike Park near<br />
SITAUGITNESSY Patricia Ave. The trail was clean<br />
and the beach near the Patricia Pedestrian<br />
Bridge bad a rock fire pit that had been<br />
recently used. There was a fair amount of<br />
debris around the fire pit. The River was<br />
clear and at a low level. People were<br />
throwing sticks, for their dog, in the river.<br />
It was a quiet day for wildlife with only<br />
seeing North-western Crow, American<br />
Robin. & Swainson’s Thrush. Mountain<br />
Ash, False Lily of the Valley and Indian<br />
Plum were all in fruit. The Forest was still<br />
looking green.<br />
Ian (E-7) July 16<br />
LiONS I saw 12 in the river & 4 by the river. The<br />
PARK River was clear and at a nonnal level in<br />
MARY luLL<br />
BY-PASS were out.<br />
r<br />
9ERRJY1{<br />
the upper part of the reach, but at the Red<br />
Bridge the River was high and barely<br />
flowing. This was due to the freshet in the<br />
Fraser River. Maple and Scott Creeks<br />
appeared clear, but I couldn’t see them<br />
flowing. Birds included Swainson’s<br />
Thrushes, Wood Duck, Great Blue Herons,<br />
crows (60 in one flock). Spotted Towhees.<br />
chickadees, and robins. I saw an Eastern<br />
Grey Squirrel that was in rough shape and<br />
I thought it might die right in front of me.<br />
It eventually gathered its strength and<br />
disappeared into the bushes. I heard frogs<br />
and mosquitoes were around. Invasive<br />
touch me not and morning glory were<br />
flowering. Himalayan blackberry were<br />
starting to flower. Hardhack and fireweed<br />
were flowering. Some of the salmonberries<br />
were still around and the thimbleberries<br />
were ripe and delicious. Oregon grapes<br />
Newsletter editor<br />
Ian McArthur (604-9394039)<br />
Email: imcar<strong>ii</strong> telus.net
COQUITLAM RiverWatch<br />
940 Stanton Ave. Coquitlam, B.C., V3J 4V2<br />
irncart@telus.net<br />
SEPTEMBER 2012 NEWSILEF[ER. NUMBER 168<br />
ENGLISH IVY REMOVAL IN REACH W-4 by Dana Slocum City of Coquitlam<br />
On Saturday August 1 1t1, the City of Coquitlam worked with 97 volunteers from Iglesia Ni Cristo Church of Christ<br />
to remove invasive English Ivy along the Coquitlam River between Savary and the north end of Gabriola, It was a<br />
beautiful sunny day filled with laughter and excitement as the group tackled the English Ivy that has been taking<br />
over the forest along the west side of the Coquitlam River. With the help of these 97 volunteers we were able to<br />
remove approximately 600 cubic feet of English ivy (4 large truck loads).<br />
COQUITLAM RIVER WATERSHED ROUNDTABLE MEETING<br />
On Saturday November 3, the Coquitlam River Watershed (CRW) Roundtable will host a public information<br />
meeting from 9:30 am - 2:30 pm (doors open at 9:00 am). Highlights of the meeting will be view the new Web site<br />
with virtual tours, hear about Roundtable initiatives such as the Watershed Cafés, learn about new funding for a<br />
watershed plan and share your ideas, and meet the new Roundtable Coordinator. The location of the meeting is The<br />
Outlet (Work Room). 2253 Leigh Square, Port Coquitlam. There is no fee to attend, but pre-registration is<br />
requested. Contact Dave Peterson (meeting coordinator) Email: davedevonknight.com Tel: 604-677-2759.<br />
For more information about the Roundtable. visit the CRW website at www.coquitlamriverwatershed.ca<br />
SALMON COME HOME FESTIVAL<br />
On Sunday October ,1st the Hoy/Scott Watershed Society and the City of Coquitlam will be hosting the festival<br />
from II am to 3 pm at the Hoy Creek hatchery. Free parking is available at Douglas College, City Hall and Pinetree<br />
Community Centre. For further information please call 604-927-6536 or check the website at www.hsws.ca<br />
RIVER CHAT by Gord<br />
On August 20th, Hydro opened one of three gates at the dam with<br />
the result of a rapid increase in flow. On August 19”, a crew was in<br />
the river moving logs to deflect high flows into the Upper<br />
Coquitlam River Park channel to keep the mouth open. The flow<br />
wasn’t high enough to clean out the channel, although the bar at the<br />
mouth actually decreased slightly. It did refill the UCRP Pond.<br />
which had got very low during this recent dry spell. On the 21st, 1<br />
returned and dug the channel down for 5 solid hours, and now the<br />
flow is sufficient to bring the pond back into functional shape. Adult<br />
sockeye are in the river with two live ones and one carcass so far!!<br />
What an amazing fish, with so few<br />
juveniles successfully passing the dam,<br />
we still get returns.<br />
Photos<br />
These photos were taken by Grant<br />
Mayert of a soaring Cooper’s Hawk and<br />
a Barred Owl. Both were spotted on the<br />
Cooper Property where there is a plan<br />
to develop the forested property.<br />
ITEM (PAGE
Ian (W-2) Aust. 29<br />
11w River was clear and at a nttnnai tevel ahote and<br />
below I lie grat ci operations. The “awl I et ci at the<br />
Galette gauge ‘t as .580 metres. Falaeea (Fulawka) Creek<br />
(a-I) “as clear & low Ilow inc. Mantle C’ reck (uô) was<br />
clear and low flow ing. Partridge Creek “as cear and low<br />
flowing. Marquart Creek was almost clear and lowing<br />
wellS Goodyear (‘reek (all) was clear and flow intL The<br />
Upper Coquitlatn Riter Park lord was higher than last<br />
mont!, and the outlet was flowing. WiIdlif included a<br />
Raten, Great Blue Herons, Spotted Tow bee, a Northern<br />
Flicker and fry. I talked to a person litlting and he said he<br />
caught and released a rainbow trout the day before. Fry<br />
were seen in one of the UCRI’ side channels. Last month,<br />
I commented on the lack of water flowing to tlte UCRP<br />
l’t,nd. It was flowing again this nsonth due to the hard<br />
work ofa local river steward. lie spent live hours digging<br />
out a channel Ri r tlte water to flow when the River level<br />
is low, l’hanks so much! Touch-toe-knot Ipolteeman’s<br />
heltnet) was flowering.<br />
Date I W-3) Aug. 23<br />
Lots ofpeisple at Galeste and Mel’avish Parks. There<br />
were pettple on the trail between the parks which is rare.<br />
I saw- waders and rafters, although she ncr is gettine a<br />
little shallow. There Svere drink cans and fst food<br />
containers at Galeste and the south end nfl loekaday.<br />
MeTat ish ‘vat clean, The Riser was clear and the les-el<br />
a-as nurmal for August. Wildlife included American<br />
Dipper, tnergansers. deer, raccoons, and squirrel.<br />
has- cut seen atiy kitiglishers for a long Itnte It ‘t’as an<br />
interesting mooth for wildlife. ‘[Ite large doe idec,l “as<br />
by steTas- sb Park. A fatoily of-I raccoon, S mergansers<br />
regally stvinitning upstreatn, hut tlsc tnost unusual<br />
sigitsing was what I took its he a mink, It was black, about<br />
a toot long including the tail antI “as scurrying atnong<br />
the nt erside rocks, Looks like C’t’quitlam is going ahead<br />
with the McTatislt Park completitsn. I have mixed<br />
foelings about this, Probably going to be overbuilt and<br />
possibly os.erused, The ultimate consequences to the<br />
ri’ Cr and surrounding area are unknttw n.<br />
Murray(W-6) Aug.18<br />
TIte busiest area was sooth of Ihe McAllister Pedestrian<br />
Bridge hotlt on the east side oftlie River and the gravel<br />
hacs Witls the increase in apartments Lw downtown<br />
AUGUST RiverWotchers REPORTS<br />
tIFIRO “j<br />
VANCOUVER<br />
GAit<br />
9(5(5<br />
I’ It’ t( L IN t<br />
O,tLtriE<br />
(NO I<strong>ii</strong><br />
tORTES sttAtJOt tNtSSV<br />
r,sil:c t<br />
Ports, and latk of outdoor s” itnming pools people are raDEsiRttN<br />
nc rea,si ngly tra’ cling to the Riter to trs to coo I off t’ ith ARJDGE<br />
young families despite the Ris cr water still very cold.<br />
Today was lie hustest I e seen tltts Reads in 11w 4—5<br />
years Fve been tnvt,lved witlt R tverWaleh. One guy<br />
‘vat fishing under the train bridge hut nothing running<br />
and no hope anyt ass with people and dogs in the<br />
River. Gsstd old ‘-Il and their Slurpee cups “crc<br />
eset’wltere. ( pteked up ‘shag ofgarh’,sge without<br />
eten getling close to thc likely mets tell by Ite -<br />
sttnhathcrs & Sw ttntncrs. If llscrc st crc c cr a nu_d<br />
for a ncr cleanup — at least between he Lougheed<br />
/<br />
Bridge and Gates Park — is would he in Septetnher (<br />
‘\ /<br />
. /<br />
LIONS<br />
t Atk<br />
,<br />
or early October. There were an increasing number<br />
of grocery carts along the River as well. The River<br />
‘tat clear and at a nonnal level, The gauge south of<br />
the Lougheed Bridge measured .5 meters. Maple<br />
‘ ottEs<br />
(‘reek svas 15’’ below tile htgh water titark with the .—<br />
water slimy and stagnant north of’ the culvert. I’ve<br />
likely said this before, witlt the increasing<br />
population in Po(’o and (‘oquitlasn lit ing in<br />
tnu)til’amilv facilities, it has become increasingly<br />
itnporiant that the two cities tuake l’uriher<br />
intestmdnt to protect and enhance the C’oquit!am<br />
Kiter Watershed. People need to get outdoors tvith<br />
their liamilies ‘ersus spending time tndoors.<br />
During this hot spell, the River has hecotne<br />
increasingl important place for people to go and<br />
cool oft’ It wouldn’t hurt to have someone dtg a<br />
rr RtVER Rn<br />
RED RRtDOE<br />
few decent swimming holes to the Ri’er, COLONY<br />
which w sold also likely enhance the I tshtng FARM<br />
in the at I. With the Ris ci being so lot’ right<br />
mw, despite continuing e li’orts by’ II ydro to let .. t LLtPAw<br />
waler ‘tat t,f the dam periodteall>, 5’s et ident that<br />
any decent holes for swimtning sir fishing<br />
are gradually tilling up with grate<br />
COQUITLAM 25i<br />
LAKE 1-<br />
N<br />
1. FRASER RIVER N<br />
AUGUST RAINFALL<br />
I<br />
a 4 s ‘ a tat: 23 :4:1:6:? (its :aat 11:4 as:s:’:t 3:3:<br />
dtys cfthe tiantb<br />
MalIce (E-2) Aug. 9<br />
/ OR CREEK l’his was the first etsoler day alter this<br />
summer’s stunntog heat I expected she puddles and<br />
smaller creeks to Itave dried up hut amazingly, waler<br />
was still trickling towards the Coquitlam Rit er and<br />
there were still muddy patches. Precarious leaps and<br />
balancing were necessary to rat igate the trail. Es-en<br />
at Crystal Falls, a substantial outpouring of water<br />
pelted down, I however, crossing Pritehest Creek was<br />
notv easily manageable without getting a et as it<br />
htadtt’t heert on my prevtous walks along thts stretch,<br />
I saw 4 people cycling and 46 people<br />
PRtT[ttEFr rR. walkine, Unfortunately. his was the first<br />
walk s-s here I’d nsstteed a dtsturhtng ansottnt of<br />
garbage: piles of empty pop cans, plastic bottles,<br />
Starhucks’ contatners and even evtdence that<br />
/<br />
V<br />
sotneone had lit a eatnp fire. No stttnes were tisible<br />
around the ashes — very worn ing to find under the<br />
present dry cttnditions. The Coquitlatti River was<br />
super clear and in spite of ots recent rain, thte current<br />
tvas lion ing pretty quickly.<br />
Murray (f/i soutlt) Aug. I.)<br />
I collected about ¼ hag ofgarhage Relatively clean<br />
considering activity down around the river this lime<br />
of year, The River was clear and at a nonnal level,<br />
It ‘vat pretty quiet for wildlilb — nothing jutuped out<br />
at me.<br />
David (E-5) Aug. 29<br />
It was the rrst time I had seen tlte dog off leash<br />
park etnpty. Work is almost iloisitecl at tlte<br />
Mountain Bike Park near I’atricia Ate, Talked ttt<br />
one of she itoss’wcsrkeys; they were busy testing<br />
their a irk as they went, The trail “at clean. The<br />
K s- Cr a as low , hut no nna I ftir it, is time of ear.<br />
The only birds spotted a crc North-st estem Crow &<br />
Atneriean Robin ..‘\Iountain Ash, and Indian Plutn<br />
Stere noticeable as their leases are already starling<br />
to tum y ellotv, probably from all of tlte heat<br />
recently. l/t en with the shssst Cr. the forest looked<br />
dry- Lions lark is always busy in the sumtner, the<br />
kids really enjoy the playground,<br />
Ian (E-7) Aug.27<br />
I saw 6 dogs on leash and atnazingly nts dogs tiP’ leash. l’he Rtver was<br />
clear and at a low’ level, Maple and Setttt (‘reeks were clear and barely<br />
lowing. Birds included Great Blue I Iertsn, Wood Ducks, Brown<br />
Creepers, Spotted ‘loss-bees, and chickadees, I saw sotne hear seat on<br />
the paved t’oC’o Trail, Sntswherries svere out, I lardhack, fireweed,<br />
ttttich-tne-not (pttlteeman’s helmet), & knotweed were llos-vertng<br />
Blackberries s-vere ripe and delicious,<br />
k<br />
,_‘zz_<br />
- This isa photo of<br />
tns-asts-e<br />
touch-me-not<br />
(pnl tceotan ‘5<br />
I Itelmet) taki<br />
N ,,,-‘,<br />
1<br />
-<br />
— otertheptp t(lta<br />
- ,,‘,; ‘..<br />
—-—-_-—,_-_L,,.’<br />
‘e<br />
right-of-svay1151<br />
oy;:<br />
i!i
AUGUST RiverWatcher’s REPORTS<br />
Ian (W- I) Aug. 29<br />
The River was clear and at a normal level. Slade Creek<br />
was clear and flowing. There was no wildlife to report.<br />
There were a few foxglove plants still flowering.<br />
Jeff(W-4) Aug. 12<br />
The river was very low and clear all month except for<br />
approximately 36 hours on August 20 and 21 when the<br />
level rose dramatically and the river was cloudy. With<br />
the river so low, the warm weather, and August being a<br />
month when fish wouldn’t be bothered by people in the<br />
river, I decided to do a real “River Walk”. Starting at<br />
7am on a beautiful sunny morning I made a quick trip<br />
down the trail then waded slowly back up river from<br />
Patricia, staying close to the west bank. Wading gives a<br />
view of the river very different from walking the trail or<br />
hopping boulders along the bank. Variations in river<br />
bottom — sand vs pebbles vs boulders; river slope -<br />
rapids vs pools; water depth and velocity, and<br />
riverbanks become immediately obvious. Water<br />
temperature was pleasant and wading was<br />
straightforward, except for the three Large<br />
Woody Debris structures where the water was<br />
deep and fast. The most interesting stretch of<br />
riverbank, visible only from the river or the east<br />
bank, was in the vicinity of Grist Creek where<br />
near vertical clay and cobbles have been<br />
exposed. I counted 37 occurrences of iron oxide<br />
leachate, most between Patricia and Grist Creek<br />
with a few farther upriver. Two more small<br />
clumps of knotweed were discovered on banks<br />
not visible from the trail or boulders owing to<br />
bush or steepness. The river’s edge was COLONY<br />
Murray (E-3 north) Aug. 13<br />
Despite the low actual numbers the<br />
Reach seemed quite busy — must have<br />
been the kids in or around the River and<br />
some City crew taking away garbage or<br />
cutting back along the trail. There was<br />
END or also a private contractor building<br />
SIIAUGIINESSV some fences along certain parts<br />
\<br />
FARM<br />
teeming with fry and water striders. A<br />
Great Blue Heron flew upstream. Most of the<br />
garbage in or beside the river reflected<br />
seasonal activities —6 single flip-flops, a<br />
deflated rubber raft (1 have seen at least 3<br />
others recently), 3 sand toys, 4 balls (“Fetch<br />
doggie”), a blanket, a tanning lotion bottle,<br />
2 pallets intended for firewood,<br />
marshmallows and approximately 40 cans,<br />
mostly beer, Many of the cans were<br />
submerged in the river. Other garbage<br />
included plastic bags, bits of rope and two<br />
concrete blocks. One plastic bag on a<br />
small rocky island has been bugging<br />
me for months and 1 linally got it.<br />
a- of the Oxbow Side Channels as part of<br />
GAL [LIE<br />
Ku<br />
CORIES<br />
the salmon enhancement protection<br />
program. This would appear to be near<br />
certain sections of the stream close to the<br />
PATRICIA<br />
PEDESTRIAN walking trails to try to prevent or<br />
BRIDGE discourage dogs off leash from going into<br />
the stream. It was generally very clean<br />
considering it’s summer with kids and<br />
families picnicking by the River. I picked<br />
up about ½ bag of garbage mostly of a<br />
plastic nature. The River was clear and at<br />
a normal level. The River looked good<br />
and while not high it would appear that<br />
BC Hydro is doing a good job of letting<br />
some water out to keep the river at a<br />
reasonable depth. I’m still tempted to<br />
take the grandson down on tubes from<br />
the David Bridge to the Patricia<br />
GATES Pedestrian Bridge.<br />
PARK<br />
I’IIl RIVER RD.<br />
Newsletter editor<br />
(RE.D BRIDGE)<br />
Ian McArthur (604-939-4039)<br />
Email: imcart@telus.net<br />
I Charlene (W-8 & 9) Aug. 30<br />
N The River was relatively low. Sand bars were<br />
evident. Water was murky. Bird activity included<br />
hawks, lots of Mallards, kingfisher, loads of<br />
swallows, gulls, and a Northern Flicker. I saw one<br />
COLONY<br />
FARM<br />
snake and some squirrels. A (seemingly) small<br />
black bear was moving lazily through the<br />
Kwikwetlem First Nations housing. It eventually<br />
sat down in front of one of the homes. Notices<br />
MARY hIlL<br />
BY-PASS<br />
were posted at the west end of the Sheep Paddock<br />
Trail and near Kwikwetlem First Nations housing<br />
stating that VRT herbicide had been sprayed in<br />
the area. The sign was warning people to avoid<br />
FRASER RIVER<br />
the area for 24 hours
COQUITLAM RiverWatch<br />
940 Stanton Ave. Coquitlarn, B.C., V3J 4V2<br />
imcart@telus.net<br />
OCTOBER 2012 NEWSLETTER<br />
COQUITLAM RIVER WATERSHED ROUNDTABLE MEETING<br />
On Saturday November 3. the Coquitlam River Watershed (CRW) Roundtable will host a public information<br />
meeting from 9:30 am - 2:30 pm (doors open at 9:00 am). Highlights of the meeting will be view the new Web site<br />
with virtual tours, hear about Roundtable initiatives such as the Watershed Cafés, learn about new funding for a<br />
watershed plan and share your ideas, and meet the new Roundtable Coordinator. The location of the meeting is The<br />
Outlet (Work Room), 2253 Leigh Square, Port Coquitlam. There is no fee to attend, but pre-registration is<br />
requested. Contact Dave Peterson (meeting coordinator) Email: dave@devonknight.com Tel: 604-677-2759.<br />
For more information about the Roundtable, visit the CRW website at www.coquitlamriverwatershed.ca<br />
World Rivers Day celebrated its 8 anniversary<br />
and BC Rivers Day celebrated its 32 anniversary.<br />
It all started in 1980 by Mark Angelo and friends<br />
doing a clean up on the Thompson River and is<br />
now in over 60 countries worldwide. Our group<br />
participated in the event at Lions Park by having a<br />
display and talking to people about the importance<br />
of the Coquitlam River Watershed.<br />
SALMON COME HOME FESTIVAL<br />
On Sunday October 21 st, the Hoy/Scott Watershed Society<br />
and the City of Coquitlam will be hosting the festival from<br />
II am to 3 pm at the Hoy Creek hatchery. Free parking is<br />
available at Douglas College, City Hall and Pinetree<br />
Community Centre. For further information please call<br />
604-927-6536 or check the website at www.hsws.ca<br />
HYDE CREEK SALMON FESTIVAL<br />
The Hyde Creek Watershed Society, in partnership with<br />
the City of Port Coquitlam, hosts their Annual Hyde Creek Salmon Festival. The festival this year will take place on<br />
November I 8 from 11am to 3pm at the Hyde Creek Recreation Centre and the Hyde Creek Education Centre. Join<br />
in on celebrating the salmon as they return to their spawning grounds. There will be activities for all ages, including<br />
nature walks k -<br />
4.-a;ia,, displays. hatchery<br />
information,<br />
sampling<br />
demonstrations,<br />
site tours. kids<br />
activities and a<br />
first-hand look at<br />
the salmon in the<br />
creek.<br />
NUMBER 169
Ian (\V-I) Sept.30<br />
I leavy equipment has been In the River just north of the<br />
At Grist Memorial Ilatchery Some oftite Kiter flow has<br />
been diverted to how close to the etest hank (hatchery<br />
sidek The K iver has been lots ire in this channel vhcn<br />
the Ic’ cis arc nonnal. hut not tstten the Rit er gees low.<br />
Someone let) a tsn of beer cans and garbage in the fire<br />
pit at the pony beach. [lie Ricer was clear and at a tow<br />
evet. Stade Creek was clear and was flt,s ing tery low. I<br />
only saw a raven and chickadees.<br />
SEPTEMBER RiverWatcher’s REPORTS<br />
Gord (W-2) Sept.29<br />
This salk covered frtito Overtand Creek to Upper<br />
Coquitlaxn Kiter Park. I was on an intasive plant patrol<br />
in w aders from she river netted I 1108 stems of Japanese<br />
knotweed and 392 stems of l’olicetnan’s I lett,tet att fretu<br />
the banks, while passing o’ er approx 300 l’oltcentan’s<br />
I leltnct sterns & 300 knots ecd stems in the Archery rsrruct<br />
braid. The vast snaiority of stems were putted in areas<br />
not previously treated (since 20113, that is). One stern was<br />
growing out of a root chunk caught in a logjam, the<br />
chunk connected to a dead steIn, apparentty tossed into<br />
the river in tlse past mantIs. The flow was beautifully<br />
etear and substrate particles defined without significant<br />
silt coating. Undercut banks readily tisihle throughout,<br />
promising excellent rearing potential huh is also a<br />
possible indicator of spawning substrate scouring frotn<br />
the ltiglter flow regime (release from the darn since<br />
20011/9). There was a liglsl stls release from Partridge<br />
Creek early am tti II Oflatn I saw 9 adult chutn wish<br />
3 pairs on redds (a ness made of gravel in which saitnon<br />
spatvners lay their eggs) at tlte tail ofditing hoard pool.<br />
I also saw a raven load, and a tree frog.<br />
lan (\V-2) Sept. 3))<br />
A dog was oil leash and searing around the UCRP side<br />
channels. The Ri’ er “as clear and at a low let el afxne<br />
and below she gra’el oj’rations. ‘One ‘vaser level at the<br />
Galette gauge “as .560 metres. Falacea (Fulawka) Creek<br />
(4) was clear & only a trickle. Mantle C’ reek (an) “as<br />
clear and low flowing. Partridge Creek was clear and los’<br />
flow ing. Marquari Creek ‘vas almost clear and flowing<br />
well. Goodyear Creek (alt) was clear and low flowing.<br />
Wildlife included Atncniean Dipçscr, Rat en, crows.<br />
chtckadees, Northern Flicker, and fit in UI RI’ side<br />
channel. Wlsen I first saw ihe Atneriean Dipper it ‘vas<br />
doing its usual knee bends, hut when is flew so a different<br />
log it stopped doing Ihe bouncing for a few minutes. I<br />
had never seen tlsis before.<br />
Jeff(W-4) Sept 21<br />
1 he ri’ er “as clear and tc,rs low all month w tth only a<br />
sltght rtsc. on Septetnhc.r II) when the rt’er became<br />
sltghtly cloudy Thts month s olltetal stalk “as on<br />
frsday Seplember 21, lIst last day of sumtntr,<br />
startsng as 6 I 5PM under cloudt sktcs tuSh the w tnd N<br />
htgh tn the cotton” oods hrtngtng dott n many lea es I /<br />
headed south sc.ctng fry and water strsders along the<br />
rt’er sedge a lest people on the east hank and one<br />
dog in slit rtser fhe reeks area at the head of the stde<br />
channel dow nslrt,atn of Dunksrk “as cotnplctely dry,<br />
the sIde channel “as onls hetng fed hs a ‘cr5 stnall<br />
LouGttLt<br />
1D<br />
osita<br />
srtk’e I ha,] a hard look frt’tn 1 e Patrtesa Pedestrtan<br />
Brsdce’t ondersng t I there night be some saltnon tn the<br />
r.t ct but saw none Stree’ltghss were on ht then so I rt’n Rt’ ER an<br />
returned along she tral s daltLht faded and it gi-e BR 060<br />
dark atnong slit tree’s Three e’ cltsts two walkers and a<br />
‘,katehoarde’t’ w crc. all that I sat’ on the trail TIse outfall<br />
at Dunktrk “as cm mplesels di’s the outfall as Saltsprtng<br />
had a tnodc,rate flow ‘claple CraS ‘sell ard the Grsst<br />
CresS ptps. ‘crc running c.ll I sac’ a ‘Jor,hern<br />
Flseke’r and heard snany untdersttlte’d hsrdsongs<br />
A1W<br />
(OtO’s\<br />
I \t{M<br />
COQUITLAM<br />
LAKE 25<br />
‘‘<br />
ERtt’t itselF’ rsss<br />
“l’RASER RIVER N<br />
days cHIme Tenth<br />
Nlurra’ ([-3 north) Sept.<br />
OR C REEK<br />
Ntce morning for a stalk. Mv wife “as wish<br />
me and cososnensed Itow pretty site Oxbow Side<br />
Channel looked running sisroualt tise heavily treed<br />
riparian area. Needless to say wonh protecting. I<br />
only collected about ‘. hag ofgarhage including a<br />
fetv doggie bags Garbage ssscluded a kid’s floater<br />
and a tnesal cylinder, which appears to have been<br />
throsvn out by a house in the subdivision that borders<br />
the I’oCo ‘frail near she David cut de sac. l’he River<br />
was clear hut low. I suspect BC I lydro is still<br />
controlling the depth, as it could he a lot<br />
lower without any rain for she past month<br />
and half. The Oxbow Side Channel looked good and<br />
they’ve done a gttod job of snstalltng a wottd and<br />
tvire fence along portions of the channel, presutnably<br />
so protect migrating fish frosn unleashed dogs and<br />
o’vners nut appreciating the need to protect she<br />
streatn and the fish,<br />
tRITCIIETI CR.<br />
SEPTEMBER RAINPALL<br />
II I<br />
:s4567t9tyslI:; tlLiI. tiIy:.22L:2:i:42.16::y:s3a<br />
Murray ([-3 soutlt) Sept. 29<br />
/ Fairly quiet despite a lo’ely early al’ternoon along the Riser.<br />
/ ‘The Reach “as ‘cry clean considering it has been over a<br />
/ month since I was along here. Picked up about a ‘. hag of<br />
/ garbage. The Rit er St as clear and at a normal Ic’ el.<br />
/ Considering ‘ye have had s’ery little rain for she lass two<br />
/ monilt the River looked pretty good and ‘Se need it to heat<br />
+ reasonable heiglsts as she chutn will he coming into the ri’ Cr<br />
in site next week or so. We can thank BC lltdro fr<br />
COkES ‘.tt.’ottxt.ss’ ,,.<br />
matntasntng tlte ‘5 ascr level tn she Rt’ Cr. It has<br />
become increasingly c’ ident tb, there are fewer and fewer<br />
decent holes for the spawning fish to rest In Whtle we’’<br />
been thnunase sisat BC I l>drt, has kept tlte Rt’ er vistt a<br />
reasonable amount of ‘vater, tt ‘5 dtsapp.t tnt’ ng that there has<br />
been little action taken by groups fonned over the past IS<br />
years to protect and enhance the ctindision of the River.<br />
Cltarlene (0-8) Sept. 29<br />
Undoubtedly, some of the saltnon seen on [-8 tvere the satne as those<br />
seen on W-8, Many were making tfte trek upstream. The area at she<br />
bend ofthe river, near the net” tidal gales, seemed to he a playground,<br />
Many of the salmon seemed to pause tlsere to s’vim feverishly in<br />
circles, breaking she surfitce. The old putup house has been<br />
cosnpletely dismantled and most of the materials save been removed,<br />
Out with site old and in with she nesv. The respective diverting pipe<br />
was alscs retnoved and the area Isas been filled in tvitit rocks and sand.<br />
The River ‘sos very low and clear. Water w’as also very low, if not<br />
dry, in the Wilson Fann channels. Bird acttvity included lots ofgeese<br />
and gulls. Lots of hrighs blue dragonflies buzzing around like<br />
helicopters.<br />
Matle-e Stanley (F-S & 9) Sept. 2<br />
Although the day “as warm & sunny, there tt etc only a smattering of<br />
huttercups. thistle, yarrow, sIte tips of firewee’d, and a clump of<br />
goldenrod that were still flow cring. Only morning glory, red clover,<br />
dandelion and tshat I thought “as peas inc ‘vere profusely flowering<br />
as if tt was still spring. I larditack Iluwers Isad turned brown. One<br />
fisher had his rod planted in she sand bus satd Ite hadnt had any luck<br />
There ‘vere more hikers (411) than walkers (23) and more dogs on<br />
leash (3) than ofl’(2l. I spotted It pieces of garbage. mostly under<br />
the Man Hill By-pass not far fresn the only black squirrel I spotted<br />
before reaching she moutlt ofshc riter. Sctoeone sad bailt a fire in the<br />
sand witit tite ash residue a little too close tm the trees br his time of<br />
year. l’lte Coc)u itlatis Rt Cr was tlte lowest I’d ever Seen It — 0’ er<br />
Millennium Bridge it appeared under 30 cm deep with mud banks<br />
“caving ihrstttglt she middle The ‘cater was clear and didn’t ap<br />
to he moving. Birds ‘vere scarce as I only saw 8 Wood Ducks in<br />
channel closest to Lougheed I lighsvay Perhaps this was due to 1<br />
most noticeable difference — the ‘cater level, Several channels<br />
nearly dried up and sotne ctsvered in grass with intermittent pool
SEPTEMBER RiverWatcher’s REPORTS<br />
Murray (W-6) Sept. 30<br />
spent the whole time walking in the River doing a<br />
cleanup, walking from the McAllister Pedestrian Bridge<br />
to the mouth of Scott Creek. The sole purpose was to<br />
clean garbage in the River from the summer bathers &<br />
picnickers. As a result, the only count done was the<br />
S fishennen, which I was surprised to see as I wasn’t<br />
expecting any fish to be in the river for a week or two.<br />
I got two large bags of garbage plus a couple of old<br />
lawn chairs, There’s still a couple of bags of garbage in<br />
the River along this stretch but I was pleasantly<br />
surprised by how clean this part o the Reach was<br />
considering the number of people were down at the<br />
River during the month of August. It gives me some<br />
hope that people are concerned about picking up their<br />
garbage. The River was low but in reasonably good<br />
shape considering the lack of rain for the last couple of<br />
months. There was only one hole during the entire<br />
stretch that I walked which would have been deeper<br />
than waist level. When I swam this stretch of the<br />
River 50 yrs ago most places were over my head.<br />
There were a few dead chum in the River but both<br />
were in reasonably good shape so it appears to be<br />
the start of the fall spawning run.<br />
Charlene (W-8 & 9) Sept. 29<br />
There were 4 dogs on leash and none off leash.<br />
Two fishermen were at the mouth of the<br />
Coquitlam River and I saw three boats near the<br />
mouth. The River was very low and clear.<br />
I could see the top halves of two car tires from<br />
the pedestrian bridge. Birds included hawk.<br />
chickadees, Mallards, gulls and a heron.<br />
I also saw a seal off of the mouth and COLONY<br />
multiple salmon from the pedestrian<br />
bridge. Watching the salmon was amazing!<br />
From a distance, I could see ripples on the<br />
surface of the river. Some ripples were\<br />
moving very fast and zigzagging. As the<br />
ripples moved nearer to the pedestrian<br />
bridge, I could see that the ripples were<br />
caused by salmon. Big Salmon! There must<br />
have been at least 40 of them, moving up and<br />
down river. In the “habitat restoration” area<br />
between the Sheep Paddock Trail and the<br />
Lougheed Highway, trees/bushes have been<br />
planted by Metro Vancouver. This is the<br />
area that was mechanically cleared<br />
FARM<br />
and Vantage XRT treated last month. FRASER,RIVER<br />
ITEM i;AaE<br />
GALEIlE<br />
CORI[.S<br />
‘Al lUCIA<br />
I’LDLSTRI:\N<br />
13 R JOG I:<br />
I<br />
N<br />
COLONY<br />
FARM<br />
MARY [JILL<br />
13Y-I’ASS<br />
S<br />
LIONS<br />
PARK<br />
David & Myma (E-5) Sept. 26<br />
A city storm drain cleaning truck was in<br />
the city works area near the bike park,<br />
could only assume they were dumping<br />
the sludge that they suck out of the storm<br />
drains. Always lots of leachate coming<br />
[NOOF off this site, across the PoCo Trail<br />
SIIAtJGIINI:SSV and into the river. We saw more<br />
garbage than usual. The River was clear<br />
and the level was very low. Birds<br />
included Winter Wren & American<br />
Dippers. Great to see American Dippers,<br />
especially two at once. We watched as<br />
they frolicked in the faster waters. A sure<br />
sign that we are into fall. There was a<br />
dead raccoon along the edge of the forest<br />
on Shaughnessy Street near the Patricia<br />
Pedestrian Bridge path. Japanese<br />
knotweed was along the Patricia<br />
walkway very noticeable especially at the<br />
entrance from Shaughnessy Street. The<br />
forest was extremely dry, many trees and<br />
plants showing the signs of heat stress.<br />
Lots of leaves on the ground, dry and<br />
brown, not colourful as in most falls. As<br />
much as I enjoy the wonderful warm<br />
weather the riparian area along the river<br />
is suffering from the extended summer.<br />
Ian (E-7) Sept. 30<br />
This walk was done on World Rivers Day.<br />
The PoCo Trail and Gates Park were so busy the<br />
parking lot at the north end of the Gates Park was<br />
full, which I have never seen before. Policemails<br />
Helmet was flowering and the blackberries are<br />
drying up. Snowberries were out. One off leash<br />
dog was in the River. The River was clear and at<br />
a low level, Maple and Scott Creeks were clear<br />
and had a low flow. Birds included Belted<br />
Kingfisher. chickadees, and Mallards. I didn’t see<br />
any spawning salmon, but I heard reports of<br />
fishermen under the Kingsway Bridge seeing<br />
spawning chum and spring salmon. This was a bit<br />
of a surprise as the River was still quite low.<br />
Newsletter editor<br />
Ian McArthur (604-939-4039)<br />
Email: imcart@telus.net
Attendance:<br />
Minutes of Meeting<br />
Hyde Creek Watershed Society<br />
General Meeting<br />
Wednesday November 7, 2012 7:15 — 8:30 pm<br />
Hyde Creek Education Centre & Hatchery<br />
3636 Coast Meridian Road, Port Coquitlam, BC<br />
Gert Nielson, Clara Brolese, Nick Calderone, Shane Peachman, Eija Seppanen, April Crockett,<br />
Linda Dore. Roy Reinrnuitt, Cliff Kelsey. Nigel Butterfield, Ian Barrie, Terry Sawchenko, Janice<br />
Christie, Jean Peachman (recorder)<br />
Item I Welcome and Introductions (Cliff)<br />
Item II Agenda Approval<br />
Moved hi’ Tern’, Seconded l,’ Jan i/nit the Meeting Agenda be accepted as presentect<br />
Passed.<br />
Item III Review of October 3 Minutes and review of actions (Cliff).<br />
Correction noted by Linda in Item Vito add “applicant” to members. Moved by Clara,<br />
Seconded by Nick that the minutes qf the October 3rd” Meeting with noted correction be<br />
approved. Passed.<br />
Action Items were reviewed.<br />
Item IV Treasurer’s Report (Ian)<br />
• ian reviewed the financial reports that were circulated with agenda.<br />
• Donations — ajar of pennies was left by the gate. Harry brought the container in and<br />
$21.57 was deposited as donation. Thank you to the anonymous donor.<br />
• Underwriters property insurance documentation has been received.<br />
corrected documents for the Festival Event Insurance.<br />
We are awaiting the<br />
• Thank you to Danilo Brolese for again donating 5500 to the well fund.<br />
Salmon Festival purchases are being processed. Fund now holds $3,343.97<br />
PIP grant discussion regarding new paper process. Members agreed that we will look at<br />
the PIP grant reconciliation and new processes after the Festival.<br />
Item V Membership (Terry)<br />
• New applicant member Roy Reinmuitt status will be processed at a Director’s meeting<br />
after the general meeting.<br />
• Other new applicant members are Isaac Nelson, Courtney Beck, Eija Seppani. Hien Vu,<br />
Kourosh Kliosraviani. and Jeremy Porterfield All have attended events/meetings.<br />
• Blank name tags have been purchased and members name tags are available, If you need<br />
a name tag. please contact Jean,<br />
Item VI Education Committee Update (Terry).<br />
• Tour sheets were circulated for information and review. Classes are busy and all<br />
members are encouraged to assist with tours. Please contact Terry if you can assist<br />
during this busy fall.<br />
• Thanks to Janice and Bill Christie for working with the tours. Also thanks to April, Hien<br />
and Isaac for helping with ,weckendslasses. Much appreciated.
FICWS M<strong>ii</strong>i isles November 7, 2012 2<br />
Item1LI Education Centre & Hatchery Update (Terry/Shane)<br />
• Maurice wiLL be at the hatchery tomorrow (Thursday) to evaLuate our brood stocks. There<br />
will be a fish lake next Saturday. Meet at 9:00 at the hatchery.<br />
• Fish Takes — discussion ensued regarding non-members working in the creek. Due to<br />
insurance coverage, it was determined that only active members should be in the creek as<br />
they are covered by our insurers.<br />
• Ian noted that the Lions who had booked the use of our classroom had to cancel due to<br />
stair access being difficult for handicapped members. Discussion about fund raising for a<br />
wall style stair lift in the future.<br />
Item VIII Salmon Festival Update (Jean)<br />
• Flyers — members were asked to take some flyers and distribute to local stores and<br />
businesses, friends etc. Thank you to Gert, Nigel and Ian for already working on this.<br />
Nigel has emailed out a copy of the flyer to all members (last month) if you would like to<br />
print off a few copies at home.<br />
Signs — large wooden sign will be placed at Lougheed and Shaughnessy tomorrow by<br />
Nick and Shane.<br />
Outside signs to be placed on the day of the event. We have some new signage along<br />
with our old ones. Brent has volunteered to look after this and is asking Ted for<br />
assistance. Anyone else who would like to help Brent, please call him.<br />
Tent & Room Set Up — An inside/outside map, along with exhibitor’s names and<br />
placements is prepared. Ian has a copy and Jean will bring extras on Festival Day.<br />
Volunteers — Ashley is still looking for a few more student volunteers. Please contact her<br />
if you have any prospective volunteers.<br />
Member Volunteers are needed for set up on Saturday November 17 at the Hatchery.<br />
Also, for early Sunday November 18 for set up at the Rec Centre Gym. Members are<br />
also needed to man the Hatchery and Rec Centre sites. Contact Jean if you would like to<br />
work at any of the following spots:<br />
• Haiche,y — tours, watershed model, microscopes, fish dissection, membership<br />
information. Starbucks coffee, upstairs craft. (Marion has organized the craft but will be<br />
away on the I gib)<br />
• Music — April is connecting with local musicians. Thanks April.<br />
• Raffle — continues to grow. Rocky Mountaineer train trip to Whistler and back and gift<br />
certificates have been added. Asking members to let their friends know that the prizes<br />
are great. And tickets are still 52.<br />
Wind Up — at the end of the Festival all members are invited back to the Education<br />
Centre for a short get together to compare notes and laughs. We’re putting on a pot of<br />
soup, buns and coffee. Bring a beverage along if you like.<br />
Item IX Recent Events<br />
• Salmon Come Home — October 2 1’ at Roy Creek —Thanks Ian for setting up, and<br />
thanks to Larry and Garry for taking down. And a thank you to the members who<br />
covered the table and attended. A good event with Chum showing in their creek.<br />
I ±ZZ.Zti
HCWS Minutes November 7, 2012 3<br />
Item X Upcoming Events<br />
Vancity Open House on November 13 — We have been asked to present a display at our<br />
local branch. Cliff has prepared a video presentation. Ian, Shane and Nigel will attend to<br />
answer questions from the visitors.<br />
• City of Port Coquitlam Meeting November 13— CLiff has prepared a slide show, along<br />
with an invite to the Councilors and community to attend our upcoming Salmon Festival.<br />
Shane and Jean will attend.<br />
• 13 di<br />
Annual Hyde Creek Salmon Festival November 18<br />
• Burke Mountain Young Explorers Sunday, November 25— are meeting at our facility.<br />
Looking for a member to open up and close up. We’re checking on the exact times.<br />
Please let NigeL know ifyou can cover this. (Time confirmed as 12-3 with set up time<br />
from 12-1)<br />
Item Xl Well Funding and Grant Applications (Shane..’Jean)<br />
DFO is processing their donation. Shane is still working with local builders for<br />
donations. We are awaiting information from Telus, RBC and Scotia Bank. The TD<br />
Bank has confirmed a $2,700 donation and Danilo Brolese donated S500. We are now at<br />
S59,0 14.12 funds in place. Require another $17,360. Discussion ensued regarding the<br />
built-in contingency of S5.000 which if we don’t need it will bring our funds needed to<br />
S12,360. (Members have voted at a past meeting to use S5,000 which is in term deposit.)<br />
Members discussed channeling excess funding from Salmon Festival towards the vell.<br />
ItemXll Old Business<br />
• Surfwood Equipment has donated a new Stihl Blower, chain saw, helmet and accessories<br />
to replace our stolen equipment. Local papers picked up our press releases thanking<br />
Surfkvood.<br />
• Inventory is still in the works. Sheds need to be completed along with the work bench.<br />
Ian is still looking for volunteers.<br />
• Website — Jean is asking for interested/knowledgeable members to also work on the<br />
website. We’re also looking for free (hopefully) editing software that is more user<br />
friendly than our existing one. April and Cliff’s daughter Laura wiLl look into this.<br />
Meeting Adjourned at 8:30 pm.<br />
Next Meeting Wednesday December 5.<br />
Directors Meeting held immediately after General Meeting.<br />
Summary of Actions<br />
Action: Assigned to: Status:<br />
Stolen Equipment Replacement All Members Closed<br />
Inventory (downstairs) — to be done — contact Ian All Members In Progress<br />
Notify members of upcoming evening classes for<br />
members to observe<br />
Terry Closed<br />
Name tags box —<br />
Cliff/Jean<br />
can’t be located. Contact All Members Closed<br />
Task List Binder — extra copy for upstairs Jean Closed<br />
Website editing software All Members/Jean<br />
November 8 jp<br />
i-ti
]3 urke Mountain Naturalists<br />
Promoting Nature Awareness in Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam, Port Moody — and beyond<br />
Pacific Tailed Frogs at<br />
Mossom Creek<br />
by Ruth Foster, Co-Founder Mossom Creek Hatchery. 1976<br />
The abundance of tiny Pacific Tailed Frogs in Mossorn Creek is a<br />
testament to its excellent water quality and dependable flow.<br />
Partially spring fed as it flows down off the north shore of Port<br />
Moody into Burrard Inlet, Mossom does not dry down significantly in<br />
summer and its largely intact forest canopy keeps the water well<br />
shaded and cool.<br />
Pacific Tailed Frogs, Ascaphus truei,<br />
are provincially ‘blue listed’ because<br />
of an increasing dearth and<br />
fragmentation of the cold fast stream<br />
habitat on which they depend,<br />
These Tailed Frogs are also<br />
federally listed as a Species of<br />
Special Concern. While other<br />
species of frogs reproduce in still<br />
waters, these frogs have<br />
adaptations that permit them to<br />
manage all stages of their life in and<br />
alongside the rushing waters of<br />
coastal streams. Adult males have a<br />
tiny tail-like appendage that permits<br />
the sperm to be inserted into the<br />
female’s oviduct in the fall where it is<br />
stored until egg laying the following<br />
summer. Paired strings of fertilized<br />
eggs are glued to cobblestones in the creek. Young Tailed Frogs<br />
remains as tadpoles for several years and avoid being washed<br />
downstream because they can adhere to rocks with the large<br />
sucker that surrounds their mouth, They feed by scraping algae<br />
from rocks. To see a short video of the tadpoles, go to the Mossom<br />
Creek Hatchery website home page www.mossomcreek.org and<br />
click on the YouTube link.<br />
Adult Tailed Frogs are voiceless and it is posited that such ability<br />
would be wasted in the noisy environment of a coastal stream.<br />
When full grown, they are the size of a large Pacific Chorus Frog,<br />
Hyla regilla. Their skin is pebbly and usually brown or coppery; the<br />
eye’s pupil shape is distinctly vertical like a cat’s. It is reported that<br />
these tiny frogs can survive over twenty years.<br />
Volunteers at Mossom Creek Hatchery encounter Tailed Frogs<br />
regularly. When aquatic insects are sampled by rubbing rocks in<br />
the stream, a tadpole or two is usually collected in the downstream<br />
net along with a variety of stoneflies. mayflies and caddisflies,<br />
When we are working at streamside, we are mindful of the possible<br />
presence of the small adults and we choose our steps carefully.<br />
I IlhLi I<br />
a<br />
October 2012, Issue 238<br />
This past summer, SFU Master’s student Corinna Lichota<br />
conducted field research that compared the fish populations above<br />
and below culverts on several local streams. On Mossom Creek,<br />
she found distinct differences in reaches 100 m below and 100 rn<br />
above loco Road Coast Range and Prickly Sculpins were<br />
abundant downstream of the culvert and completely absent above<br />
it. Not surprisingly, given the predatory nature of sculpins, juvenile<br />
coho and trout were much more numerous above the culvert. Also,<br />
while only one Tailed Frog tadpole was collected downstream of<br />
the culvert, 52 were found in the 10Dm reach above it! It appears<br />
that the culvert structure controls the<br />
sculpins’ access to the upper<br />
reaches of the creek.<br />
Upstream of the Mossom Creek<br />
Hatchery, the watershed drains a<br />
very large area of the Village of<br />
Anmore - specifically above and<br />
below East Road. The creek has<br />
suffered numerous serious siltation<br />
episodes that have been traced to<br />
poor development practices in that<br />
area. Steep slope development is a<br />
great worry Recently, a large swath<br />
of hillside was cleared of mature<br />
forest and the creek has become<br />
noticeable more flashy. Anmore’s<br />
huge Pinnacle Ridge site is now<br />
open to individual contractors. For<br />
over twenty years, Mossom Creek<br />
streamkeepers have communicated<br />
their concerns to the Village of Anmore and it is good news that the<br />
municipality has improved its environmental oversight in the past<br />
two years. Hopefully each new builder and homeowner in the<br />
watershed will follow best environmental management practices. If<br />
this could be assured, the Tailed Frogs, the Red-legged Frogs, the<br />
Chum and Coho Salmon, the aquatic insects and all other living<br />
things that depend on the Mossom Creek watershed might stand a<br />
chance. Clearly there is much ongoing monitoring and educational<br />
work to be done.<br />
http:/fv.Nwv.geog.ubc.ca/biodiversity/factsheelslpdf/Ascaphus_truei.pdf<br />
A good field guide is Lone Pine Publishing’s Amphibians of Oregon.<br />
Washington and British Columbia by Corkran and Thorns.<br />
NEXT MEETING:<br />
Tuesday, November 13<br />
th at 7:30pm:<br />
Como Lake United Church<br />
King Albert Avenue, Coquitlam<br />
Guest speaker will be Christianne Wilhelmson on<br />
Oil Tankers on Burrard Inlet (re-scheduled from Sept)<br />
Visit our website for updates and additional information<br />
www.brnn.bc.ca
Upcoming Events<br />
Wednesday, October10 at 7:00 PM: Town Hall Style Meeting<br />
on Burnaby Tankers and Pipelines hosted by the Wilderness<br />
Committee, Tanker Free BC and BROKE (Burnaby Residents<br />
Opposed to Kinder Morgan Expansion) to raise awareness about<br />
Kinder Morgan’s proposal to build a new tar sands pipeline through<br />
their community, and about the resulting tanker traffic that will travel<br />
through Burrard Inlet. At Confederation Community Centre, 4585<br />
Albert Street, Burnaby. For more information, call 604-683-8220<br />
Friday, October12 at 6:00 PM: Special Children’s Art<br />
Exhibition: WILD@ART at the VanDusen Botanical Gardens. This<br />
exhibition showcases BC’s endangered species and is hosted by<br />
the Wilderness Committee as part of their campaign for<br />
endangered species legislation in BC. Students from Kamloops to<br />
Vancouver have contributed diverse artwork celebrating BC’s atrisk<br />
wildlife The opening Night Reception is on October12 from 6<br />
to 9 pm at VanDusen Botanical Gardens in Vancouver for an art<br />
exhibition Enjoy great art. food, wine, and inspiring speakers. The<br />
exhibition runs from Oct. 8 to Nov. 13 at the VanDusen Botanical<br />
Gardens, 5251 Oak St. Vancouver.<br />
Saturday, October13 from 11am to 3pm: Bums Bog and<br />
nearby wetlands have been given a Ramsar designation. Find out<br />
what this designation means for Burns Bog at this event to<br />
celebrate the new designation. Meet at 4-7953 120 Street, Delta,<br />
right behind the Greek Village Restaurant at the intersection of<br />
Scott Road & 80th. Coffee and Labrador tea by donation. RSVP at<br />
eventsbumsbog.org.<br />
Sunday, October14 at 12:00 PM: loco Ghost Town Day, Port<br />
Moody. Celebrate a unique community—the heritage site that was<br />
once the Imperial Oil Company town on the north shore of Burrard<br />
Inlet. This is a free family event with family activities, variety show<br />
entertainments, kids’ games and crafts. Lawn Bowling Green, loco<br />
Townsite. From noon — 4 pm.<br />
Sunday, October14 at 1:00PM: Last guided tree tour of the<br />
season at Riverview. Join the Riverview Horticultural Centre<br />
Society for a guided tour of the heritage trees on the Riverview<br />
Lands. This is a glorious time of year to view the trees. Tour lasts<br />
about two hours, and goes rain or shine. Wear comfortable shoes<br />
and dress for the weather. Dogs on leash are welcome. For more<br />
information, see the Riverview Horticultural Centre Society’s<br />
website or phone 604.290.9910. Meet on the uphill side of the<br />
Henry Esson Young (HEY) Building. For additional information, see<br />
w.rhcs.org. Banners and signs will be in place to lead you<br />
through the site. To reach HEY building take Holly Drive through<br />
the hospital grounds. then go uphill on Oak Crescent. and<br />
the HEY is on your right on Kalmia Drive. Find parking, and meet at<br />
the front door. Buses do go through the grounds (#177). Ask to be<br />
let off at Holly Dr and Lilac, or Holly Dr and Sorrel, and walk uphill<br />
to Kalmia. Note: Special tours for groups can be arranged by<br />
contacting Mary at 604-939-7769 or Norma at 604-942-7378, or<br />
leave a message at 604-290-9910.<br />
Tuesday, October16 at 7:15 pm: BMN Education-Conservation<br />
Committee meeting at Elaine’s. Any BMN member who is<br />
interested in joining this committee is most welcome to attend.<br />
Contact Elaine at 604-937-3483.<br />
Saturday, October20 Evans Valley Trail (Golden Ears Park)<br />
This is a trail that has not been on the Golden Ears Provincial Park<br />
trail map for many years, but it is still used and has been recently<br />
worked on. The trail stays close to Evans Creek and travels through<br />
a forest with large old growth trees. Views of Evans Peak and<br />
Blanchard Needle can be seen on a clear day. This is a moderate<br />
hike. Roundtrip distance is 9km (5.6 mi) with an elevation gain of<br />
50Dm (1640 ft). Meet at the Starbucks parking lot on the corner of<br />
PAGE 2<br />
Lougheed Hwy and Oxford Street in Port Coquitlam at 8:00 am.<br />
Return 4:00 pm. For info call lan (604-939-4039).<br />
Saturday, Oct20 at Sam or9 pm: Birding at Colony Farm with<br />
Lee Harding. Join Lee at 8am at the end of Colony Farm Road in<br />
Coquitlam or Mike Griffin at the Shaughnessy Street entrance in<br />
Port Coquitlam at 9 am. Phone Lee 604-469-6795 to confirm time<br />
and get additional information.<br />
Saturday, Oct20 at 1 pm: Join members of the Wilderness<br />
Committee for their Annual General Meeting at their Water Street<br />
office in Gastown on the 4th floor of 341 Water St.<br />
Sunday, October21 at 11:00 AM: Witness the return of the<br />
Salmon to Kanaka Creek, Maple Ridge.<br />
Hosted by the Kanaka Education and Environmental Partnership<br />
Society (KEEPS) and Metro Vancouver.<br />
From 11 —3. Located on 240th Street, north of the Lougheed Hwy.<br />
For info, call 604.530,4983.<br />
Sunday, October21 at 11:00AM: Hoy Creek’s Salmon Come<br />
Home Festival. The Hoy Creek Fish Hatchery celebrates the return<br />
of BC’s favorite fish with fishy activities including salmon viewing.<br />
children’s crafts and music. BMN will be at this annual celebration<br />
with our display and children’s puzzles along with many other<br />
volunteers and local stewardship groups. Dress for the weather.<br />
Festival runs from 11 are — 3 pm. Location is around the Hoy Creek<br />
Hatchery. just downstream of Douglas College (north of Coquitlam<br />
City Hall and west of the Aquatic Centre).<br />
Monday, October 22: The call has gone out to people across BC<br />
concerned about the environment and impacts of pipeline<br />
construction to join hundreds of others to protest at the Legislative<br />
Buildings in Victoria. A mass sit-in in will occur in Victoria at the BC<br />
Legislature. The event is sponsored by Defend Our Coast and<br />
others. It will provide individuals a chance to express their<br />
opposition to proposed tar sands pipelines and tankers for BC.<br />
Organizers are planning what they hope will be Canada’s largest<br />
ever act of peaceful civil disobedience.<br />
Wednesday, October24 at 10:30 am: The Retired Teachers of<br />
School District # 43 (Coquitlam) will hear a presentation by Elaine<br />
Golds and Victoria Otton on the history and current activities of<br />
BMN.<br />
Tuesday, October30 from 9am — noon somewhere in Port<br />
Moody: Port Metro Vancouver invites people to attend an<br />
upcoming Phase 2 workshop with an opportunity to review and<br />
provide feedback on the goals, objectives and policies of their draft<br />
Land Use Plan which will articulate the Port’s policies on land use<br />
and development, and will identify the types of uses appropriate on<br />
land and water across its jurisdiction over the next 15-20 years.<br />
Check their website, w.portmetrovancouver.com/landuseplan,<br />
for an update on the location of this workshop which is yet to be<br />
announced. If you are concerned about impacts on recreational<br />
use of Burrard Inlet from increased tanker traffic, now is the time to<br />
speak up.<br />
Tuesday, October30 at 7:15 pm: BMN Executive meeting at<br />
Victoria’s.<br />
Saturday, November39 am —3pm: Metro Vancouver Parks<br />
will host their annual Parkfest day at BCIT. For more information,<br />
contact Trina in the Central Area Office at 604-520-6442.<br />
Saturday, November 3 from 9am — 2:30 pm: Next meeting of<br />
the Coquitlam River Roundtable at the Outlet in Leigh Square next<br />
to the Port Coquitlam City Hall. Learn about watershed planning<br />
and other projects in the watershed. Krista Englund, a BMN<br />
member, has recently been hired to be the new part-time<br />
Coordinator for the Roundtable.<br />
Saturday, November10 at 9:00 AM: Birding with Larry at<br />
DeBoville Slough and Minnekhada Park
Join leader Larry Cowan and members of Nature Vancouver<br />
for a half-day birding field trip to Deboville<br />
SloughlMinnekhada Regional Park This area is home to<br />
many over wintering species with waterfowl in the sloughs,<br />
ponds and river, with a chance of raptors over the helds.<br />
Meet in the parking lot adjacent to the washroom facilities at<br />
Cedar & Victoria Drives, in NE Coquitlam at 9:00 AM. We<br />
will position an appropriate number of vehicles in the parking<br />
area off Quarry Road in Minnekhada Park for our return trip.<br />
Contact Larry atlawrencecowan@shaw.ca for more info<br />
Tuesday, November13 at 7:30 PM: BMW monthly<br />
meeting.<br />
Guest Speaker on “Oil Tankers on Burrard Inlet”. This is the<br />
talk that was scheduled for our September meeting. Unlike<br />
the Enbridge pipeline in northern BC, the proposed twinning<br />
of the Kinder Morgan pipeline to carry diluted bitumen from<br />
Alberta to a coastal terminus in Burnaby has received little<br />
attention. The expansion means a huge jump in the number<br />
and size of tankers on Burrard Inlet and in the Strait of<br />
Georgia. The Georgia Strait Alliance is encouraging local<br />
residents to get informed about this proposal. The executive<br />
director of the organization. Christianne Wilhelmson. will present a<br />
slide show on this issue at the Tuesday. Nov 13th meeting of the<br />
Burke Mountain Naturalists. The Georgia Strait Alliance is<br />
concerned about potential spills of heavy tar-like bitumen, and they<br />
suggest that communities should focus not on pipeline expansion<br />
but on transitioning to new sustainable sources of energy.<br />
Sunday, December 2 at 1:00 PM: Christmas Open House at the<br />
Burnaby Lake Nature House. Enjoy a guided winter walk along<br />
forested trails to discover wildlife in the Park and learn about the<br />
lake and its history. Afterwards, join members of the Burnaby Lake<br />
Park Association for kid-friendly activities and complimentary<br />
refreshments in the Nature House. Dress for the weather. Meet at<br />
the Burnaby Lake Nature House, 4519 Piper Aye, off Winston St,<br />
Burnaby. For info, call 604.520.6442. From 1 —3pm.<br />
Annual Silent Auction at<br />
December BMN Meeting<br />
by Victoria Otton<br />
Mark your calendars for the evening of Tuesday. December 11”—<br />
the date of BMNs annual Silent Auction, with only two weeks to go<br />
until that Christmas shopping needs to be don& As in previous<br />
auctions, this year’s event will have an appealing assortment of<br />
nature-themed items donated by local businesses, as well as<br />
nearly-new books and items donated by our members. Some<br />
businesses have generously donated gift coupons, and we will also<br />
have gift coupons for what we now call ‘BMW Time and Talent”<br />
donated by our members. For example, on the auction block this<br />
year is an hour or two of tutoring with a very patient BMN member<br />
who is a whiz with PowerPoint, Excel and Word, Another member<br />
is offering 3 hours of his handyman services again this year. Do<br />
you have some skill or hobby that you’d like to share with other<br />
members? A half-day trip in your canoe or boat? An afternoon of<br />
bird or plant identification? Some special cookery skill? This is your<br />
chance to be creativ& If you can offer a service or if you have an<br />
item to donate. please contact Carole Edwards<br />
(caroleedwards@shaw.ca, 604.461.3864) or Victoria Otton<br />
(votton@sfu.ca. 604.937.5379).<br />
One corner of the room that is always lively during our auctions is<br />
the Baked Goods Table. This is a great opportunity to stock up on<br />
delicious baking, and preserves and other sweets for the holidays.<br />
If you have some specialty baking that you do this time of year that<br />
you could donate to the Bake Table, please contact Liz Thunstrom<br />
(ethunstrom@shaw.ca, 604. 939.9571).<br />
- -.<br />
A Western Grebe is released back into the wild after being cared for at<br />
Wildlife Rescue in Bumaby. Funds raised at this year’s silent auction will<br />
support the work of the Wildlife Rescue Association.<br />
I<br />
V<br />
- PAGE3<br />
ITEM . .‘ .<br />
- 1<br />
The BMN Silent Auction is a chance to get some good deals on<br />
gifts for yourself or others, and to support a worthy cause at the<br />
same time. This year, a small portion of the funds raised will be<br />
used to meet the club’s operating expenses, but the bulk of the<br />
proceeds will be donated to the Wildlife Rescue Association of BC<br />
in Burnaby. BMN has donated to WRA several times in the past.<br />
They are always in need of funds and this is one way we can show<br />
our continuing support of the valuable job that they do, Several<br />
BMN members are also active volunteers at WRA.<br />
December 11<br />
Please note that the doors will open 30 mins earlier than usual<br />
for this meeting -- at 7 pm --to provide more time for viewing<br />
items, bidding and counter-bidding.<br />
Notice of Annual General Meeting — Dec. 11th at 7:30 pm<br />
Tracy<br />
1h will be an evening packed with good cheer, good<br />
food and great company. One of the highlights of the evening will<br />
be Ian McArthur’s slide-show on ‘The BMW Year in Review”. Bring<br />
your friends and neighbours and let’s make this year a huge<br />
success. We hope to see you there!<br />
Coastal Waterbird Survey<br />
If you would like to become more familiar with the birds that use the<br />
Port Moody inlet and make a contribution to citizen scienc&, the<br />
Coastal Waterbird Survey looking for volunteers to join in the<br />
monthly waterbird count from the Shoreline Trail in Port Moody.<br />
We go out on the second Sunday of the month from September to<br />
April (see schedule below). The count typically takes place on the<br />
high tide and all eyes are useful, experienced or not. Contact<br />
Krista Englund at kenglundalumni.sfu.ca for more information.<br />
SURVEY DATES 2012-2013<br />
Sunday September 9<br />
Sunday October14<br />
Sunday November 11<br />
Sunday December 9<br />
Sunday January13<br />
Sunday February 10<br />
Sunday March 10<br />
Sunday April14
Education-Conservation<br />
I<br />
I<br />
Report byEl&ne Golds<br />
We are now well into our regular tall events and truly appreciate the<br />
BMN volunteers who come out to be with our displays, chat with<br />
members of the public and help children with our wildlife puzzles.<br />
Despite some trepidation over the closure of the Henry Esson<br />
Young building. TreeFest was once more a wonderful success with<br />
many people showing up to participate in tree tours and heritage<br />
building walks. TreeFest does not happen without considerable<br />
planning. Carole Edwards represents BMN on the Planning<br />
Committee, which meets several times throughout the year - we<br />
really appreciate her efforts. In addition, other BMN members<br />
attend these meetings for the Riverview Horticultural Society<br />
(Donna Crosby & Mary Brown). It was great to see many! many<br />
BMN members volunteering at TreeFest on behalf of various local<br />
groups. In particular, Don Gillespie was a leader for some of the<br />
history tours conducted by bus. These were very popular with<br />
standing room only. In general, all the tree tours were<br />
exceptionally popular as was Don Luxton’s heritage building walk.<br />
Back at the BMNlNaturescape/CFPA tent, we much appreciated<br />
help from Hilary, Anne, Victoria and Jenny.<br />
were more along the lines we would anticipate such as “majestic<br />
old buildings, stunning old brick facades” and “the healing qualities<br />
of natural and green spaces”. I expect such positive remarks<br />
formed the majority of comments submitted — but we have no way<br />
of knowing as quantitative summaries were not provided. We have<br />
every right to expect some quantifiable summary of public input in<br />
this report but this is totally missing. Without such numbers, there<br />
is no way to get a sense for how the majority of people responded<br />
to the questionnaire. When I first attended the public meetings this<br />
spring and saw there was no questionnaire that asked people to<br />
rank their feelings about Riverview, feared exactly this outcome.<br />
There are a number of photographs in the report but none of them<br />
has a written legend so it is sometimes hard to understand what<br />
exactly is being shown and why. Another, more minor, concern is<br />
that Kiyoshi’s bird checklist is provided in the report but no credit is<br />
given for where it came from so some readers could make the<br />
mistake of thinking it was based on data collected by the<br />
consultants. A number of reports are listed but no information is<br />
provided as to where these reports may be obtained. Even the<br />
BMN report on Riverview is simply listed as “unpublished’ although<br />
it has been available on our website for many years. Comments on<br />
the draft report are due Oct lOso a quick response from the public<br />
is required.<br />
Just over 20 people, including a number of BMN members, showed<br />
up to help remove knotweed at DeBoville Slough in late September.<br />
Although I was unable to attend, understand the group is making<br />
great progress with the knotweed now under apparent control in<br />
several areas — although ongoing weeding and surveillance will be<br />
required to keep the knotweed “in its place”.<br />
We had glorious sunshine for the Rivers Day event at Lions Park in<br />
Port Coquitlam — a new venue which we thought was terrific. We<br />
didn’t need to worry about getting blown away by the winds which<br />
often whip down the Pitt River at Peace Park. Attendance was light,<br />
but, hopefully, more people will be aware of the event site by next<br />
year. Once again, much thanks to Victoria, Don, Carole and Anne<br />
for helping under the BMN tent. Other BMN members were busy<br />
The report also seems rather negative when assessing the value of<br />
Riverview. A number of ‘enduring myths” are discussed. These<br />
include the misunderstanding that John Davidson played a critical<br />
role in the planting of the trees in the arboretum (this is a good point<br />
that we should keep in mind — John Davidson had moved to UBC<br />
by the time much of the landscaping was done at Riverview) as well<br />
as the apparently false perception that Riverview was a leading<br />
edge treatment facility throughout its entire history (?). It is,<br />
perhaps, not surprising that Riverview was not considered “leading<br />
edge” during the last years of its downsizing but I hardly feel this is<br />
a fair comment and it certainly detracts from the valuable<br />
leadership role the hospital played in providing mental health care<br />
in the ear<strong>ii</strong>er part of the<br />
volunteering for other groups at this event.<br />
Riverview Heritage Conservation Report —<br />
Passion and Metrics are Missing<br />
A few days before this newsletter deadline, a draft Heritage<br />
Conservation Plan was released by the group of consultants hired<br />
by the provincial government to conduct the public consultation last<br />
spring and prepare the report which is now posted at<br />
www.riverviewvalues.com. Public meetings were held in early<br />
October to solicit feedback from the public. In general. the report<br />
appears to adequately document much of the history of Riverview<br />
but I found it to be quite lack-lustre and lacking in detail when<br />
summarizing public input. Apparently, a total of 702 questionnaires<br />
were submitted but. for some reason, the number of participants<br />
was listed as only 577. The reason for this apparent discrepancy is<br />
not clear. Of those who submitted responses, about two thirds were<br />
from the Tn-Cities area and 31% from the Metro Vancouver area.<br />
The people who responded were mainly casual recreational visitors<br />
(54%). members of a special interest group (24%) or “other”’ (37%).<br />
Note: these percentages total more than 100% because some<br />
people checked off more than one category.<br />
The summary of public input is quite unsatisfactory and a bit of a<br />
mish-mash to read through. For example, it was reported people<br />
felt “many buildings were old and have little value and that “some<br />
buildings with bars evoke a prison like atmosphere which it was for<br />
some” but nowhere was it slated how many responses fell into that<br />
category, i.e., were these single one-off comments or commonlyrepeated<br />
themes? This is simply not an acceptable way to<br />
summarize public input from hundreds of people. Other responses<br />
20 ih century.<br />
While some negative comments are made about the tree collection,<br />
e.g., “the majority of the trees are species commonly found and<br />
used in parks and the public realm around the Lower Mainland”, the<br />
appendix at the end of the report nicely summarizes and identifies<br />
rare specimens including some species at risk. I am sure BMN<br />
members will be delighted to see the inclusion of this information in<br />
the report.<br />
Also absent from the report is an expert evaluation of the site by<br />
heritage architects. The Stantec reports done in the 1990s when<br />
the site was being evaluated provide the most recent such<br />
evaluation to the bests of my knowledge. To my mind, this report<br />
should have included some relevant comments from the Stantec<br />
reports so that members of the public have a good sense of what<br />
experienced architects have to say about Riverview. Simply<br />
reporting on comments from the public is quite inadequate for a<br />
proper heritage evaluation.<br />
The final part of the report which deals with Heritage Conservation<br />
Planning is also disappointing. Most of the language is typical<br />
“boiler-plate” stuff which is probably taken directly from other<br />
documents. For example, a number of conservation approaches<br />
were outlined ranging from “maintenance’ through to “managed<br />
decline” wfth no recommendations for which approach would be the<br />
best fit for Riverview. The conservation principles and immediate<br />
actions were feeble and lacking in substance.<br />
The City of Coquitlam’s Riverview Advisory Committee had<br />
requested a meeting with the consultants once the draft Heritage<br />
Conservation Plan was released but this request was denied. We<br />
can expect the focus to soon shift towards land use planning for<br />
Riverview’s future uses. One thing seems clear; the provincial<br />
government no longer appears to be rushing into this process and<br />
PAGE 4
this is a good thing! Currently, it is anticipated this land use<br />
planning will take several months and continue into spring. Frankly,<br />
I think the development of an adequate future land use plan for<br />
Riverview will require a much longer time frame. We must ensure<br />
this planning process is not rushed and that time is allowed for<br />
potential partners to come forward while ideas for future use slowly<br />
develop and take shape.<br />
I was really pleased to see that Metro Vancouver Parks submitted a<br />
letter to Greg Hamilton, the provincial Real Estate Manager for<br />
Riverview, regarding Riverview which indicated Metro Vancouver is<br />
interested in participating in the future planning of the Riverview<br />
lands. They also submitted a brief report outlining their position that<br />
the connections with Colony Farm should be strengthened in the<br />
future in a way that will provide benefits for the region’s residents<br />
and wildlife. They also stated support for a thorough planning<br />
process to determine the future of this important site. It’s wonderful<br />
to have such a strongly worded letter from Metro Vancouver. I hope<br />
this will be the beginning of a new era in which we can work<br />
together with them to achieve some common objectives and forge a<br />
new vision for Riverview.<br />
Colony Farm Park Update<br />
A New Agricultural Proposal<br />
Just before newsletter deadline, I received a phone call from Frieda<br />
Schade, Central Area Manager for Metro Vancouver Parks, to<br />
inform me the Parks Committee would be receiving a report at their<br />
October 4 meeting which will recommend the initiation of a program<br />
at Colony Farm Park with Kwantlen Polytechnic University (KPU) in<br />
Surrey. While I have not had time to review this report in detail (it is<br />
available on the Metro Vancouver website — look under the Parks<br />
Committee agenda). KPU is apparently proposing to use the field<br />
formerly farmed by the Progressive Inter-Cultural Society (PICS) for<br />
their educational training. Frieda was concerned we might oppose<br />
this project and offered to host a meeting to listen to our concerns<br />
and answer questions. We will try to set up such a meeting in the<br />
next couple of weeks. While we had expressed serious<br />
reservations about the introduction of commercial farming to Colony<br />
Farm Park, there are, I believe, far fewer concerns (if any) about a<br />
partnership between an educational institution and Metro<br />
Vancouver Parks. This could become the equivalent of the “UBC<br />
Farm”, a popular area at UBC where apprentice farmers receiving<br />
training and nature, apparently, abounds with birding walks offered<br />
on a regular basis. Kwantlen is initially proposing farming in a 5.6<br />
hectare space. Lazuli bunting habitat in the treed areas of this field<br />
will be set aside as will the wetland areas where the SORA nested<br />
(an area also used by the buntings). The shed used by the barn<br />
owls will apparently remain in place. Students using this field will be<br />
enrolled in KPU’s Sustainable Agriculture Program. My main<br />
concern with this proposal was with some of the crops proposed<br />
such as blueberries which could attract bears and starlings with<br />
consequent negative impacts for park safety and biodiversity.<br />
Kinder Morgan Pipeline Concerns<br />
In the September issue of the BMN newsletter. I outlined a number<br />
of concerns regarding the proposed twinning of the Kinder Morgan<br />
pipeline which runs through Coquitlam on its way from Alberta to<br />
Burnaby. A major reason to be concerned is Kinder Morgan’s plan<br />
to ship diluted bitumen through this pipeline. Dilbit. as it is<br />
commonly called, is a much more hazardous material to transport<br />
than crude oil. Nor can we be assured by Kinder Morgan’s safety<br />
record. For example last year. U.S. regulators caught Kinder<br />
Morgan, a big pipeline player with extensive Canadian properties<br />
and controversial bitumen expansion plans. violating welding codes<br />
and nearly a dozen other sections of the US Pipeline Safety<br />
Regulations when Kinder Morgan was building the Rocky Express<br />
PAGE 5<br />
natural gas pipeline between 2007 and 2008. This year, the US<br />
regulators fined the company $347,000 for a number of infractions<br />
including operating their pipeline at higher pressures than allowed.<br />
Victoria has kindly laminated a map of the route taken by Kinder<br />
Morgan’s pipeline through Coquitlam (thanks also to the office of<br />
MP Fin Donnelly for providing us with a copy of the map). We will<br />
have this map on display at upcoming events. It remains unclear if<br />
Kinder Morgan will have sufficient space to twin this pipeline —<br />
some rerouting is likely to be needed which will involve the<br />
expropriation of more private land. People who seek more<br />
information about the expropriation process are encouraged to<br />
come to the October10 meeting in Burnaby (see Announcements).<br />
Action Item: Protect the ALR<br />
in Pitt Meadows by Elaine Golds<br />
Construction of one new road always seems to lead to many more.<br />
The construction of the Golden Ears Bridge in Maple Ridge has<br />
been a perfect example - I can hardly recognize the Lougheed<br />
Highway in this area now because there are so many new<br />
“connector” roads in place. Construction of these roads has led to<br />
the loss of considerable agricultural land in the surrounding areas.<br />
Years ago, we participated in an ultimately futile yet lovely<br />
demonstration to protect an organic blueberry farm threatened by<br />
such road construction which was proposed to provide a<br />
connector to the bridge even though the bridge was many miles<br />
away.<br />
It seems there are still, apparently, not quite enough new connector<br />
roads. Pitt Meadows Council recently considered a proposal to<br />
exclude (i.e., remove) more agricultural land from the Agricultural<br />
Land Reserve (ALR) to build yet one more connector. Despite the<br />
submission of a petition with over a hundred names on it, Pitt<br />
Meadows Council seems inclined to support taking 33 more<br />
hectares of land out of the ALR to construct a connector road north<br />
of the Lougheed Highway from Harris Road to Golden Ears Way.<br />
The public hearing was held in mid September so Council is likely<br />
to make a decision soon. Joe Foy from the Wilderness Committee,<br />
who attended the public hearing and spoke at it, has suggested<br />
now is the time to start writing to the Agricultural Land Commission<br />
(ALC) to request the Commission to not allow the loss of more<br />
valuable agricultural land. If you go to the Wilderness committee<br />
website, you can click on to a page<br />
(http ://wi Idern esscom m ittee .0 rglwrite_wil d_s ave,,,p itt_meadows_en<br />
endanger_farmland) which allows you to compose your own letter<br />
and email it. Alternatively, you can write one in the old fashioned<br />
way to Mr. Brian Underhill, Executive Director, BC Agricultural Land<br />
Commission, 133-4940 Canada Way, Burnaby, BC V5G 41
Young Naturalists Club<br />
September Explorer Day - Burke Mountain Young<br />
Naturalist Shoreline Cleanup by Nicholas Ward (13)<br />
On September 222012. The Burke Mountain Young Naturalist Club<br />
participated in the Great Canadian Shoreline Cleanup near the<br />
Noons Creek Salmon Hatchery in Port Moody. Even though there<br />
were only two families there, we found quite a lot of garbage and<br />
sortie very interesting stuff.<br />
To find the garbage, we went down to the beach and started<br />
looking around above the tideline where the beach meets the forest<br />
because the tide would probably have washed away anything<br />
below that line. We spent about an hour and a half looking for<br />
garbage and collected about two garbage bags full. Some of the<br />
more interesting things that we found were two golf balls, a big<br />
pipe, some cool pottery, a spoon, and little toy boat. We also found<br />
lots of small pieces of carpet, sortie cigarette butts, lots of plastic<br />
bags, plenty of recyclable drink cans and plastic bottles, and a<br />
bunch of Styrofoam.<br />
It was a bit surprising that we did not find anywhere near as much<br />
garbage on the beach itself as I would have expected but there was<br />
a lot in the old foundations. I was also surprised by the abundance<br />
of bricks all over the beach but later learned that there was a brick<br />
factory there.<br />
I think that it was really important that people participate in the<br />
shoreline cleanup but wish that we didn’t have to because people<br />
would be responsible with their garbage.<br />
Nature and Feeder Watch<br />
by Liz Thunstrom<br />
This has been a quiet<br />
month for sightings.<br />
possibly due to the<br />
very warm<br />
temperatures<br />
delaying some of the<br />
migrants, but there<br />
have been a few<br />
interesting birds show<br />
up.<br />
Victoria had a White<br />
throated Sparrow for<br />
several days, along<br />
with an Anna’s<br />
Hummingbird, and<br />
Orange-crowned and<br />
Yellow-rum ped<br />
Warblers of the<br />
Myrtle variety in her<br />
habitat garden in Port<br />
Moody. Larry saw a White-throated Sparrow on a feeder in Pitt<br />
Meadows and a Gray Catbird at Grant Narrows, very late in the<br />
season for a catbird.<br />
Anne and Hilary saw 12 Turkey Vultures fly over the Pitt River from<br />
Minnekhada to settle in a stand of trees, then take flight back to the<br />
DeBoville side of the river, where they descended into a large tree<br />
to be photographed!<br />
Dave Schutz saw and photographed an adult Green Heron, and a<br />
juvenile Great Blue heron and Belted Kingfisher. all at Colony Farm<br />
Park. He got some excellent shots of the birds and was most<br />
surprised how close they allowed him to get, especially the adult<br />
bird.<br />
City of Coquitlam parks have recently removed the accumulation of<br />
silt from the NE settling pond in the wetland area of Como Lake<br />
Park. These ponds were originally designed to prevent sediment<br />
from the storm drains from entering the lake, but over 12 years<br />
sediment built up almost up to the bridge. The resident stickleback<br />
were caught with a small dip net and replaced when the cleaning<br />
was completed. A week after this was done. I saw a juvenile Great<br />
Blue Heron on the creek bank fishing. It was quite unafraid of<br />
passersby and I got an excellent view of the bird.<br />
On a recent walk at DeBoville with my granddaughter, we saw a<br />
kingfisher hovering for several seconds before diving, a Cooper’s<br />
hawk flying along the ditch and at least four bears feeding in the<br />
blueberry fields. There was a lot of bear scat on the dyke as well.<br />
On September 16th I once again saw two Sandhill Cranes flying NE<br />
over my house, calling constantly - it is an unforgettable sound.<br />
This is only the second time I have ever seen these birds near<br />
here. On the 30th, the first American Coot appeared at the lake.<br />
Recently I was in Campbell River but I saw and heard very few<br />
songbirds and no eagles or seabirds, which surprised me<br />
Thanks again to this month’s contributors.<br />
BMN’s 2012 Annual General<br />
Meeting will be on Tuesday,<br />
December 11 at 7:30 pm<br />
in our usual meeting place. As part of the AGM, there will be an<br />
election for the 2013 Board of Directors, Any BMN member is<br />
eligible to sit on the Board and people willing to serve as ‘members<br />
at-large’ are especially welcome. This position will give you an<br />
opportunity to be involved in the behind-the-scene workings of the<br />
club, making decisions on directions and issues the club takes on.<br />
and organizing the monthly meetings and other events. The Board<br />
meets once a month (except during the summer), and it is<br />
invariably a pleasant evening spent among friends. Please contact<br />
Victoria if you have any questions about joining this committee.<br />
The AGM evening will also include a year-end slide show<br />
presented by Ian McArthur, and BMN’s annual silent auction. This<br />
year, funds raised at the silent auction will be donated to the<br />
Wildlife Rescue Association of BC located in Burnaby. We will also<br />
use some of these funds to support BMN activities over the coming<br />
year.<br />
Request for a Volunteer (small<br />
job): Magazine Exchange, Anyone?<br />
Is there anyone interested in organizing a magazine exchange for<br />
BMN? The idea is that members attending BMN meetings can bring<br />
recent issues of magazines (e.g., Beautiful BC, birding and<br />
gardening magazines, Harpers, The Walrus, The New Yorker) to be<br />
passed along to anyone who wants them. “Exchange” isn’t quite the<br />
right word to describe this as it’s not necessary to bring a magazine<br />
to take one away. Take them all away, if you wish! I think that a lot<br />
of us with magazine subscriptions feel a bit guilty about it. The guilt<br />
of our guilty pleasure might be lessened if we could pass our<br />
magazines along so that a few more eyes enjoyed them before<br />
they get tossed in the big blue box. What is needed is someone<br />
who is willing to take remaining magazines home with them after<br />
the meeting, and bring them back for the following meeting. Ideally.<br />
the selection will be constantly refreshed. Its not necessary for the<br />
person who takes this on to attend every single meeting, so don’t<br />
let that deter you from stepping up!<br />
If this interests you. please contact Victoria (604.937.5379).
BMN Archives - Excerpts from<br />
previous October newsletters<br />
by Anne HolE<br />
From Oct. 1989<br />
Flowers First’ from the Globe and Mail, 2 September 1989<br />
‘I note the headline in the continuation of your Aug. 19 story on<br />
the Furbish lousewort (Rare Flower, Power Plant Vie for Tenure on<br />
NB. site) as ‘Flower Threatens Project’.<br />
Isn’t it time we started reading headlines which read ‘Project<br />
Threatens Flower’?’<br />
Alec Sommerville, Windsor Ontario’<br />
From October 1990<br />
“Editorial” by Christine Hanrahan<br />
“Listen! The wind is rising,<br />
And the air is wild with leaves,<br />
We have had our summer evenings,<br />
Now for October eves,<br />
Humbert Wolfe, Autumn. 1926<br />
Summer evenings, and summer days. have indeed disappeared.<br />
but autumn brings its own beauty. The bright colours of summer<br />
give way to the muted tones of brown and gold, a soothing palette<br />
after the sun- drenched days of summer. October is also the time of<br />
returning birds, leaving their northerly homes they come to spend<br />
the winter months in our more temperate climate<br />
Also from October 1990<br />
‘Announcements” - Christmas Raffle<br />
It is not too early to begin saving items for our 2nd annual<br />
Christmas Raffle. Last year we successfully raised over $25.00 to<br />
buy an acre of tropical rainforest through World Wildlife Fund<br />
Remember - the gifts need not be fancy, elaborate or expensive<br />
Anything you no longer want (as long as it is in reasonable<br />
condition!) will do. Just gift-wrap and bring for the draw.<br />
From October 1991<br />
“Colony Farm Walkabout” by Elaine Golds<br />
The second annual Colony Farm Walkabout was a huge success!<br />
Over 200 people joined us to savour the delights of the farm. There<br />
were young folk and old, kids on bikes and in strollers and 1 dog.<br />
There was even an enthusiastic Brownie Pack. A festive air<br />
predominated as crowds surged around the displays. talked to each<br />
other, picked up free handouts. and looked through the spotting<br />
scope while waiting for the opening “ceremony<br />
One of the most frequently heard comments concerned access to<br />
the farm. Most people didn’t know they could walk through the farm<br />
and they were delighted to discover a new and very delightful green<br />
space to explore. This, of course, is what our Walkabout is all about<br />
- spreading<br />
awareness of Colony Farm, on the theory that the more<br />
people who know and use the farm, the more voices there will be in<br />
support of its preservation<br />
From October 1992<br />
“Fabulous Frogs” by Pamela Hickman<br />
Frogs belong to a group of animals called amphibians, along with<br />
salamanders and toads. The word amphibian means double life, as<br />
most amphibians spend part of their lives on land and part in water.<br />
Amphibians were the first vertebrates to live on the land. It is<br />
believed that they evolved from fish about 350 million years ago,<br />
well before dinosaurs roamed the earth.<br />
Is it a frog or a toad? - Although they look alike, it’s easy to tell them<br />
apart when you know what to look for<br />
- Frogs have slender bodies with smooth, wet skin. The round<br />
bodies of toads are covered with rough, dry skin.<br />
- The long hind legs of frogs help them take large leaps and jumps.<br />
Toads have shorter legs for small hops.<br />
- A Frogs mouth has small teeth to hold its prey. Toads are<br />
toothless.<br />
- Most frogs lay their eggs in water in masses of floating jelly.<br />
Toads lay their eggs in long strings of jelly wrapped around<br />
underwater plants.<br />
- You’ll always find frogs living in or very near water. Adult toads<br />
may be found a long way from water<br />
From October 1995<br />
“Grand Opening of Maplewood Flats”<br />
by Norma Gillespie and Joan Spira.<br />
In September a small group of BMN members joined a tour of<br />
Maplewood Flats Wildlife Conservation Area. This is the first<br />
conservation area to be established by the Wild Bird Trust of BC.<br />
Located on the north shore of Burrard Inlet, a little east of the<br />
Second Narrows Bridge, the site had formerly been a saltmarsh,<br />
and later was overlaid with tons of excavation material and<br />
demolition debris.<br />
Volunteers have worked tir&essly for some years to clean up the<br />
site, and within the last year have planted native vegetation, set up<br />
a nursery to propagate more native plants, built a viewing platform<br />
and equipped a trailer and shed as headquarters.<br />
Just east of the 75 acres of green space, a large bay at low tide<br />
offers the biggest expanse of mudflats along the north shore, and<br />
already hosts great numbers of water birds.<br />
It was particularly fitting that special guest Robert Bateman,<br />
speaking at the official opening ceremony. praised the members of<br />
WBT for their contribution to “CPR” - Conservation. Preservation<br />
and Restoration. Mr Bateman. along with second special guest.<br />
Rick Hansen. cut the ribbon to mark the opening of the site<br />
PAGE 7<br />
Welcome to our new members!<br />
We are very pleased to welcome the following new members to the<br />
club over the past couple of months. Please look out for them at<br />
the next meeting or hike and extend your own personal welcome.<br />
Burnaby Coquitlam<br />
Helga Bonner & Sheilah Hunter<br />
Port Coquitlam<br />
Bob Cowin<br />
Jane Shoemaker<br />
Sherry Calhoon & Tim Kelley Port Moody<br />
Laura Dupont & Family Woojung Rho & son Minjae Kim<br />
Carole Edwards, Membership<br />
BMN Hike: Buntzen Lake Loop<br />
by Mark Johnston<br />
In my announcement of our planned hike around Buntzen Lake, I<br />
stated: ‘On sunny weekends Ithe lake] can be a very busy place,<br />
but we will avoid the crowds by sticking to the lesser travelled<br />
Academy and Lakeview trails.” We needn’t have worried; hike<br />
day—the last day of the Victoria Day weekend—proved to be both<br />
sunless and very wet, thus keeping the crowds at bay. Still, we<br />
stuck to our plan and walked the quieter trails<br />
Beginning on the Academy Trail, the four of us walked north along<br />
the east side of the lake. This trail runs through lush second-growth<br />
forest and then traces the edge of a power line right-of-way.<br />
Thankfully, as we left the forest’s sheltering boughs and walked<br />
along the power line right-of-way, the rain tapered to a drizzle, so<br />
we weren’t unduly soaked. We could look across to mist-shrouded<br />
Buntzen Ridge, but distant views of Mounts Seymour, Elsay, and<br />
Bishop were unavailable. Still, we found plenty to look at close-athand.<br />
The trail was lined with buttercups, and we discovered a
number of clumps of red columbine in bloom. Also, beneath the<br />
power lines there was a thick growth of salmonberry.<br />
From the end of the Academy Trail, we walked a short stretch of<br />
Powerhouse Road and then along the Buntzen Lake Trail. When<br />
we reached North Beach, we took a short break. We enjoyed<br />
looking down the length of the lake, but, as the rain was beginning<br />
to pick up, didn’t linger for long. Instead, after a few moments’<br />
respite, we carried on—across the suspension bridge and up to the<br />
Lakeview Trail and better forest cover. Switchbacking steeply<br />
upward, we gained elevation quickly. Behind us we could hear the<br />
roar of Swan Falls, and looked over our shoulder from time to time<br />
to glimpse its snow white waters cascading down the steep lower<br />
slopes of Eagle Ridge. Near the top of our climb, we took a short<br />
side path to a rocky outcrop where we had an obstructed view of<br />
the falls, North Beach, and the northern end of Buntzen Lake.<br />
Ironically—given the weather and my design to use underutilized<br />
trails—just before turning off to the viewpoint, we met a very large<br />
party heading oppositely—there must have been 16-20 hikers!<br />
Other than that one large party, we had the Lakeview Trail pretty<br />
much to ourselves. The trail runs through gorgeous second growth,<br />
and, especially in its northern reaches, is partly defined by many<br />
interesting rock faces It is also crisscrossed by a number of creeks,<br />
bearing the names of trees, shrubs, and plants in acrostic fashion<br />
(Sitka, Trillium, Umbrellawort, etc.). (As far as I can tell, the names<br />
have more to do with maintaining the sequence of the alphabet<br />
than actually identifying which plants are growing alongside any<br />
given creek.) As one might guess, the trail on this side undulates,<br />
dropping down to a creek, crossing, climbing up to a high point,<br />
then dropping down to the next creek, and so on. After several of<br />
these ups and downs, we had worked up a good appetite, and<br />
finally sat down beneath a trailside fir to eat lunch. One of our party<br />
commented that if someone had said to him that today he would be<br />
sitting in the woods, having his lunch in the rain, and actually<br />
enjoying it, he might have had trouble believing it!<br />
After lunch, we crossed the west side power line once or twice, but<br />
mostly stayed inside the forest<br />
margin, eventually coming out on<br />
Pumphouse Road. As we made our<br />
way along the road, across the<br />
floating bridge, and back to our<br />
vehicles, we passed a number of<br />
walkers, most with umbrellas in hand.<br />
It was remarkable to see so many out<br />
in less than ideal conditions.<br />
We finished our hike in about five<br />
hours’ time. Despite the grey skies<br />
and steady precipitation, we had<br />
taken our time and enjoyed the<br />
rainforest at its rainy best!<br />
I..<br />
This newsletter is printed on Enviro 100 Paper, 100% post-consumer fibre, is<br />
ecologo, pmcessed chlorine-free and FSC recycled certified and is<br />
manufactured in Canada using b/cgas energy.<br />
The DEADLINE for the next BMN Newsletter is November 3Td 2012.<br />
Membership Form<br />
Burke Mounlain Naturalists Membership<br />
U IndivIdual Membership ($25.00/year)<br />
U Family Membership, including children ($30.Oolyear)<br />
(Please include all first names and indicate which are children.)<br />
U Group Membership ($3000/year)<br />
Membership information: Members receive ten monthly newsletters<br />
lhat cover BMN activities, local issues and events, Membership also<br />
includes the BC Nature quarterly magazine, Nature BC. BMN is a<br />
registered non-profit society vth charitable income status.<br />
PAGE 8<br />
The Burke Mountain Naturalists was formed in January 1989 and is<br />
a member club of BC Nature (formerly Federation of BC<br />
Naturalists) BMN is a registered non-profit Society with charitable<br />
income status.<br />
Our objectives are:<br />
• to promote the enjoyment of nature<br />
• to foster an interest in, and an appreciation of, our environment<br />
• to promote the accessibility and maintenance of natural areas,<br />
parhcularly local areas<br />
• to actively pursue the conservation & preservation of the<br />
natural world<br />
President: Victoria Otton (604.937.5379) votton@sfu.ca<br />
VP: Mark Johnston (604.552.0727)<br />
Past President: Ian McArthur (604,939.4039) imcart@telus.net<br />
Treasurer & Membership:<br />
Carole Edwards (604.461.3864) caroleedwards@shaw.ca<br />
Recording Secretary: vacant<br />
BC Nature Directors:<br />
Elaine Golds (604937.3483 Tel & Fax) egolds@sfu.ca<br />
Members-attarge:<br />
Anne Holt (604936 4108), Candice Archer (604 4656853).<br />
Christina Saremba (604.945.0318), and Hilary Maguire<br />
(604.469.5805)<br />
Newsletter Editor:<br />
Hilary Maguire (604.469.5805) 8urkeMtnNatsgmail.com<br />
Newsletter Design: Brigitte Breuer, brigittebtelus.net<br />
Newsletter Layout: tan McArthur, imcart@telus net<br />
Education/Conservation Committee:<br />
Chair: Elaine Golds, Recording Secretary: Victoria Otton<br />
Members: Mike Griffin, Ian McArthur, Niall Williams,<br />
Carole Edwards<br />
Nature and Feeder Watch: Liz Thunstrom<br />
email ethunstrom@shaw.ca and phone 604.939.9571<br />
Young Naturalists Club:<br />
Noriko Nakaya (604.675.9031) bmnyncgmail.com<br />
BMN Publications: 10 newsletters a year (except July and August)<br />
Natural History Brochures: Miller Park Ravine, DeBoville Slough<br />
Riverview Lands, Coquitlam River Corridor<br />
Bird Brochures: Minnekhada Reg. Park and Area. Deboville<br />
Slough. Como Lake, The Herons of Colony Farm<br />
Plant Brochures: Colony Farm, DeBoville Slough<br />
Wildlife Inventory of the Shoreline Park System, by Christine<br />
Hanrahan<br />
et al, 1994, 121 pages, available at the Port Moody Library<br />
Our Backyard Wilderness. A Park Proposal, by Mark Haddock.<br />
1992,<br />
23pgs. plus Appendices, available at Coquitlam Poirier Library<br />
The Rivervlew Hospital Site: “Respecting Its Past, Realizing Its<br />
Future”,<br />
by Elaine Golds, Victoria Otton and Lori Austin (2004), 26 pages<br />
available on our website wwwMmn,bc.ca<br />
Name(s):_<br />
Address:<br />
City:________<br />
Postal Code:<br />
Telephone:_<br />
E-mail:<br />
Send your completed membership form to:<br />
Burke Mountain Naturalists,<br />
P.O. Box 52540, R,P,O. Coquitlam Centre, Coquitlam, BC V36 7J4
I3urLe Mountain NaturalIst5<br />
Promoting Nature Awareness in Coquitlam, Port Coquitlain, Port Moody. and beyond<br />
Remember the BMN Silent<br />
Auction on Tuesday Dec. 11th<br />
by Victoria Otton<br />
The doci’s open at 7 pm on December 11th so that you can get a<br />
head start on viewing and bidding on the enticing items in our annual<br />
SilentAuction. This year, the bulk of funds raised will be donated to<br />
Wildlife Rescue in Burnaby, an organization with several ties to BMN<br />
though our volunteers. Wildlife Rescue is the largest urban wildlife<br />
rehabilitator in BC. Each year, their Care Centre on Burnaby Lake admits<br />
an average of 3,000 injured, orphaned and pollution-damaged wildlife of<br />
more than 140 species.<br />
If you have an item to donate, please call Carole Edwards at 604-461-<br />
3864 or myself at 604-937-5379, and let us know what tile item is. This<br />
way, we can prepare most of the bidding forms in advance. It’s okay to<br />
bring something on the night, too, but please try to arrive a little bit early.<br />
As in the past, we are encouraging BMN members (and anyone else!)<br />
to consider donating their time and talents in some way. Are you a good<br />
birder who could introduce someone to our local birds some afternoon?<br />
Do you have a canoe or other boat to take people out on the water?<br />
Be imaginative — everyone has something they could offer. I’d pay for<br />
someone to show me how to make pie pastry, so if you’re daub-hand in<br />
the kitchen, come up with an idea! So far, we have handyman services,<br />
computer help and cooking a Japanese meal on the auction block.<br />
There will be a baked goods table in one corner of the mom; please<br />
contact Liz Thunstrom (604-939-9571) if you have some specialty baking<br />
to donate. Used books of interest to naturalists will also be on sale; please<br />
contactMne Hott (604-936-4108) with any questions about these.<br />
For a successful auction, it’s important to get donated items, but it’s<br />
equally important to have people wanting to bid and bid generously on<br />
them. Bring your friends and neighbours — there are always some great<br />
deals at our silent auctions.<br />
November2012, Issue 239<br />
B1VIN Hike: Keats IslandTraverse<br />
‘r,1&1.b<strong>ii</strong> Sat, July 21, 2012<br />
Despite some eaily morning rainfall, eight of us turned out for our<br />
latest venture in combining seafaring and hiking. If, upon awaking that<br />
morning, one had looked out the window, he or she would have been<br />
forgiven for getting back into bed. But our hardy little band was trusting<br />
that the forecast for afternoon clearing would prove to be correct.<br />
After carpooling to Horseshoe Bay, we boarded the Queen of Surrey for<br />
the 40 minute trip to Langdale. As we sailed toward the Sunshine Coast,<br />
we had a good look at Keats Island and got a sense of its length. Then, at<br />
Langdale, we switched to the small passenger ferry, Stormaway IV, and<br />
retraced much of the route we had just travelled. Toward Bowen Island,<br />
we could see a ribbon of silver on the otherwise cloud-darkened waters,<br />
and hoped it might be a harbinger of the forecasted clearing. Veering to<br />
the south, we rounded the northeast corner of Keats Island and moments<br />
later landed at Eastbourne.<br />
After disembarking, we made our way along the main east-west road.<br />
At first, the road switchbacks steeply upward, but eventually the grade<br />
eases. We travelled along the wide thoroughfare through second-growth<br />
forest, only occasionally aware of buildings north or south of us.<br />
When we reached Corkum Road, we turned north toward waterfront<br />
property that islanders call “The Farm:’ Anliough there was no indication<br />
of the name of the road, we were reassured of our direction by a sign<br />
announcing Barnabas Family Ministries, which occupies the farm. As we<br />
proceeded along the private drive, we were amazed to see a number of<br />
old-growth Douglas-fir and cedar trees, some of truly sizeable dimensions.<br />
At last coming to the farm gate, we weren’t sure whether to proceed or<br />
not, but when I enquired of a woman who was out jogging, she said by all<br />
means and mentioned that if we wanted an ice cream, the camp’s general<br />
store would be open in the afternoon. While we didn’t have time to stay for<br />
an ice cream, we did enjoy looking around and especially taking in the view<br />
across the water toward Gambier Island.<br />
Back through the gate, we bore right along a mad and then fumed left<br />
on a signed tail to Plumper Cove Provincial Marine Park. This bail, like<br />
the mad to the fami, was a revelation. Again, we were awed by the oldgrowth<br />
fir and cedar, and took delight in picking out the largest specimens.<br />
Staying as close to coast<br />
as feasible, we soon<br />
began to pass the park’s<br />
well-developed walk-in<br />
campsites, and upon<br />
reaching the cove, went<br />
down to the pebbled<br />
beach to have our lunch.<br />
We looked out to the<br />
Shelter Islets, just a little<br />
way offshore, and beyond<br />
the islets, across the<br />
water to Gibsons and<br />
__..Langdale.<br />
]I1 111.<strong>ii</strong>lrLli<br />
Tuesday,Dec,11 2012at7:OOPM:<br />
Cn Lake UnIted Chwch KMq Albert<br />
Avenue, Coqulifarn<br />
BMN Annual General Meeting a very short<br />
session in which officers for the coming year<br />
will be elected. The main events at<br />
this meeting are Ian McArthur’s slide show<br />
of the ‘BMN Year in Review’ and the<br />
annual BMN SilentAuction.<br />
Visit our website for updates<br />
and additional in!ormatloit<br />
www.bmn.hc.ca
After lunch, we continued along the coastal trail and started to gain<br />
elevation. While we had been walking under cloudy skies all day, the<br />
sun was beginning to make its promised appearance. At a fork, six of us<br />
decided to take a short, steep side-trip to a high point variously called<br />
Lookout Peak, Stony Hill, or Highest Peak. While not the highest point on<br />
the island (it gets the latter name fmm its location near the high point of<br />
the main mad), it is a fine vantage point. Scrambling up the grassy bluff,<br />
we had superb views of the outer islands, including Ragged, Pasley, Hermit,<br />
and the Pophams, with Worlcombe behind. We could also look down on<br />
Keats Island’s southwestern extension toward Home Island (Salmon Rock).<br />
‘7*<br />
4 1fl4.i_4J<br />
Rejoining those who had sat out the climb, we continued to the end of<br />
the trail near a BC Hydro building on the main road. At the intersection we<br />
were happily diverted by the sight of a tree-like huckleberry laden with<br />
fn<strong>ii</strong>t. Reaching up rather than down, we picked the ripe red berries as<br />
one would pick apples, and quickly ate our fill.<br />
From the 1-lydro building, it is a short jaunt through Keats Camp down<br />
to the landing. Since we still had more than an hour until our passenger<br />
ferry arrived, some of us wandered about hiking out to the island’s<br />
southwestern tip. After consulting with some folks who were sifting in<br />
lawn chairs, talking, the same six of us who had scaled<br />
the bluff decided to go out to the point. We hastened<br />
exercise tolerance, Directions: If coming from Fort Langley follow River<br />
Road east, make a right at 256 Street, then make a left on to 84Ave.257A<br />
street is on the left hand side.<br />
Thursday, November 152012 at 7:00 PM: Consciousness, a film<br />
by lisa g — Part Ill : Riverview Hospital Story Project This is the story of<br />
Or. Ralph Arrowsmith, a mid-century asylum psychiatrist with a life-long<br />
connection to British Columbia’s Riverview Hospital, a passion for the<br />
psychiatric movement and an unending commitment to his patients.<br />
Featuring archival film and photography, this story spans forty years of<br />
mental health history. Room Al 470 Lecture Theatre, David Lam Campus<br />
in Coquitlam. Produced with the generous support of Douglas College &<br />
The Riverview Historical Society. For more info check the BMr’J website.<br />
Thwsday, Nov15 from 5-8 pm. Kinder Morgan hosts an information<br />
session on the proposed twinning of their pipeline through Coquitlam<br />
into Burnaby at Harbour Centre in Segal Hall, 515 West Hastings Street,<br />
Vancouver.<br />
Friday, November 162012 at 7:30 PM: Starry Nights @ SFli:<br />
“Exoplanets and the Search for Habitable Worlds” by Prof Sara Seager,<br />
Simon Fraser University and the Vancouver Centre of the Royal<br />
Astronomical Society of Canada are jointly hosting a very special<br />
presentation on Friday November 16, 7:30-8:45PM, at SFU’s downtown<br />
Harbour Centre campus. The distinguished speaker will be Dr. Sara<br />
Seager, Professor of Planetary Science and Physics at MIT. Seating is<br />
reversed, FREE of charge. Please visit the Starry Night © SFU web site<br />
to find a link to the on-line reservation system, and more information on<br />
the location and the lecture: http://www.sfu.ca/starrynights/ and also on<br />
our website.<br />
Saturday and Sunday, November 17118,2012: Fraser Valley Bald<br />
Eagle Festival. This two-day annual event (which started as a BMN tour<br />
in the early 1990s) provides a wonderful chance to see spawned-out<br />
salmon, hundreds of eagles, other wildlife and learn about First Nations<br />
history in the Fraser River Valley just beyond Mission. While RMN no<br />
longer participates as a group, this event can provide an outstanding<br />
experience during late fall in the spectacular Harrison Bay/Chehalis Flats<br />
area. See www.fraservalleybaldeaglefestival.ca/ for more info.<br />
Saturday, November 172012 at 7:30 PM: Book Launch - John<br />
Clarke Biography. There will be a celebratory<br />
book launch at the Centennial Theatre,<br />
along a beautiful shaded path, and in twenty minutes or<br />
so, came out on a splendid sunny bluff just a few metres<br />
above the surf, We now had a more horizontal view of the<br />
islands we had looked down on earlier, It is a lovely spot,<br />
and we were sorry not to be able to dawdle awhile. A sign<br />
indicated that it’s been the location of many a romance,<br />
and it’s easy to see why.<br />
Back at Keats Landing, we boarded the Stormaway<br />
for the short crossing to Langdale. Then, after a lengthy<br />
layover, we embarked on the big ferry for the voyage<br />
back to Horseshoe Bay. It was a gorgeous evening,<br />
and mast of us were happy to remain on the upper<br />
deck, drinking in the sunshine and island scenery, and<br />
perhaps thinking about making another trip out on the<br />
waters of the Salish Sea.<br />
Looking For<br />
Photos<br />
Ian McArtt’ur is putting the<br />
BMN Year in Review slide show<br />
togetherfortlie December<br />
meeting. If you have a photo or<br />
a few from BMN events in 2012,<br />
we would like to use them in the<br />
slide show. Please email digital<br />
photos to Ian (irncart@telus.net)<br />
or phone (604-939-4039) him fur<br />
more information.<br />
North Vancouver, as part of the Vancouver<br />
International Mountain Film Festival. lickets<br />
should be available on line [www.vimff.org]<br />
Sunday, November18 from 11:00 am to<br />
4:00 pm. Hyde Creek Salmon Festival. BMN<br />
will be at this annual celebration with our<br />
displays and children’s puzzles at this very<br />
popular event.This is the last local community<br />
event of the season and provides excellent<br />
views of spawning salmon in-nearby Hyde<br />
Creek.<br />
Week of November19 -watch our website<br />
for the dates and locations of Kinder-Morgan’s<br />
“information sessions” to be held somewhere<br />
in Coquillam and Burnaby.<br />
Announcements:<br />
Every Saturday and Sunday this fall at 200 pm. Public tours of a<br />
rare forested parcel in Langley Township. The Langley Township-owned<br />
forest in the Glen Valley area of Langley Township is a 25 acre parcel that<br />
is for sale by the Township. It is a mixed conifer/deciduous forest with<br />
different types of habitat. There is extensive vegetation on the forest floor,<br />
various tree types and over 100 species of birds and animals that have<br />
been observed by naturalists. WOLF are a group of Langley residents<br />
who have come together in support of conserving this forest. This tour is<br />
part of their public awareness campaign. Meet on the roadside of<br />
257A street off of 84th Avenue. Bring good hiking boots, 1._ moderate<br />
TUesday, November 20 from 5:00 pm<br />
to 8:00 pm Info Session in the KlnderMorgan/Transmountain Pipeline<br />
Twinning - Centennial Secondary School, Courtyard (570 Poirier Street).<br />
While not as informative as a townhall-style meeting, this is what Kinder<br />
Morgan is offering to inform the public about their pipeline expansion.<br />
You can also submit your comments to http:!/talk.transmountain,com/bc<br />
lowermainland.<br />
Thesday, Nov.20 at 7:15 pm: BMN Education-Conservation<br />
Committee meeting at Elaine’s.<br />
Thurs4y,Noveniber 222012 at 6:00 PM: Coquitlam Leadership<br />
keF1i(éiEFjeld to Fork - Creating Community through
Food.. an evening with a distinguished panel to discuss the benefits<br />
and challenges of purchasing and eating locally grown food. Panelists<br />
include Alisa Smith, co-author of The 100 Mile Diet and co-host of The<br />
1000 Mile Challenge television series; Peter Ladner, former Vancouver<br />
City councillor and author of “The Urban Food Revolution: Changing<br />
the way we Feed Cities”; chef Andrea Carlson, former Executive Chef<br />
from Bishop’s Restaurant and now partner with Harvest, a local food<br />
grocer & café; Stephen Gallagher, farmer at Nathan Creek Organic Farm<br />
Community Supported Agriculture and Janis Magnuson, facilitator, L.L.B./<br />
JO. and food security, and co-housing advocate. Local food and beverage<br />
tasting starts at 6:00 pm; speakers at 7:00 pm at the Evergreen Cultural<br />
Centre, 1205 Pinetree Way, Coquitlam, BC. Tickets: $20 ea. Available for<br />
purchase at the Evergreen Cultural Centre Box Office<br />
Phone 604-927-6555 or online: www.evergreenculturalcentre.ca<br />
Saturday, November24 Coquitlam River<br />
This hike with start with a car shuttle to David Ave. We will head south<br />
on the east side of the Coquitiam River towards its confluence with the<br />
Fraser River. We will spend lime on both sides of the River and hopefully<br />
see spawning salmon in the Oxbow Side Channels and in the main<br />
stem. There could be a number of critters feeding on the salmon. This<br />
is an easy late season hike. One way distance is 12 km (7.5 mi) with<br />
an elevation loss. Meet at the south end of Colony Farm Road (near the<br />
Community Gardens) at 9:00 am. Return 2:00 pm.<br />
Thesday, Nov27 at 7:15 pm BMN Executive meeting at Anne’s.<br />
Sunday, December 2 2012 from 1-3 pm: Christmas Open House<br />
at the Burnaby Lake Nature House. Enjoy a guided winter walk along<br />
forested trails to discover wildlife in the Park and learn about the lake<br />
and its history. Afterwards, join members of the Burnaby Lake Park<br />
Association for kid-friendly activities and complimentary refreshments<br />
in the Nature House. Dress for the weather. Meet at the Bumaby Lake<br />
Nature House, 4519 PiperAve, off Winston St Burnaby. For info, call<br />
604.520.6442.<br />
Ibesday, December11 2012 at 7:00 PM: BMN AGM and Silent<br />
Auction. The BMN Annual General Meeting will be a very short session<br />
in which officers for the coming year will be elected. The main events at<br />
this meeting are Ian McArthur’s slide show of the ‘BMN Year in Review’<br />
and the annual BMN SilentAuction. Available at the silent auction will be<br />
items and gift certificates donated by local businesses plus items and<br />
baked goods donated by BMN members. Calendars and cards from the<br />
Wilderness Committee will be offered for sale and volunteers from the<br />
Riverview Horticultural Centre Society will likely sell fresh holly and other<br />
seasonal decorations. Funds raised will be donated to the Wildlife Rescue<br />
Association in Burnaby, Auction items come in a range of prices, and are<br />
ideal as gifts for people on your list or for yourselt Doors open at 7:00pm<br />
for viewing and bidding. In the hall of Como Lake United Church, corner<br />
of MarmontAvenue and King Albert Street in Coquiflam. Free & all are<br />
welcome, For more info, please call 604-936-4108 or 604-461-3864.<br />
Saturday, December 152012: Audubon Christmas Bird Count<br />
in our Area. If you want to volunteer or get more info, email<br />
BurkeMtnNats@gmail.com.<br />
Volunteer(s) Needed ByV)ctoria<br />
Alter a year at the helm, Alison Burton has decided to move on to<br />
other volunteer opportunities with BMN and so a replacement is<br />
needed for her job-- ajob which has no official title but could be<br />
called ‘Refreshments Coordinator’. The task of the RC is bring the<br />
coffee and tea things to our monthly meetings, make the coffee and<br />
tea, organize the rota of people that bring the baked goods, and<br />
clean up the kitchen at the end of the evening. We heartily thank<br />
Alison for her services as our AC over the past yeai Anyone<br />
interested in being the AC starting in 2013, please contact me at<br />
604.937.5379 or votton@sfu.ca.<br />
Education Conservation Report<br />
By Elaine Golds<br />
Defending our Coast<br />
A never-ending list of deadlines prevented me from attending the<br />
Oct22 rally of approximately 4000 people on the grounds of the<br />
legislative buildings in Victoria to voice opposition to the proposed<br />
pipelines that would carry diluted bitumen from the Alberta tar sands<br />
to the coast for export. North Burnaby MP Kennedy Stewart was one of<br />
the speakers. He reminded people the Conservative government had<br />
promised in their platform before the 2008 election “to prevent any<br />
company from exporting raw bitumen (unprocessed oil from the oil<br />
sands) outside of Canada for upgrading in order to take advantage of<br />
lower pollution or greenhouse gas emissions standards elsewhere.”<br />
So, I’m not sure - do we call this a broken promise or a lie?<br />
BMN members were among the group of people demonstrating against pipehew<br />
construction outside MM Diane Thome’s office in Coquitlam on Oct 24.<br />
MM Diane Thorne joined the group for this photo. photo: Anne Tseng<br />
At high noon on Oct 24,1 attended a much smaller gathering in front of<br />
MLA Diane moines office in Coquitlam. The weather was a little nippy<br />
for sign waving so we were glad to receive supportive honks from the<br />
passing traffic. Diane, who is not normally in her office on Wednesdays,<br />
dropped by to cheer us on. In Port Coquitlam, a larger group of about 40<br />
people gathered at MLA Mike Farnworth’s constituency office. lam glad<br />
to report That we had 8MM members at both of these events. Across the<br />
province, an estimated 6200 people gathered in front of MLA offices to<br />
express their opposition to pipelines that would allow for the export of<br />
diluted bitumen.<br />
Hay Creek Salman Come Home<br />
The weather turned out to be mostly dry and almost sunny. Thanks<br />
to Don, Victoria, Anne, Noriko, Gay, and Marion who attended to the<br />
BMN display. A number of other 8MM members were busy volunteering<br />
at other community group displays. We had an almost overwhelming<br />
number of enthusiastic children at our tables working on our wildlife<br />
puzzles. Gay’s delicious cookies gave us a sugar boost which helped<br />
to keep us warm. Salmon, attracted by the heavy rainfall the previous<br />
weekend, were abundant in the creek. We are now looking forward to the<br />
next event attlie Hyde Creek Salmon Festival where we will be inside,<br />
relatively warm and dry.<br />
Colony Farm Update:<br />
The Colony Farm Park Association hopes to get an update on the<br />
Kwantlen Polytechnic proposal for training agriculture students at Colony<br />
Farm at their Board meeting on Nov 7. In addition, a public meeting to<br />
discuss the proposal will be held at some point although, as of newsletter<br />
deadline, a date has not yet been announced. The Metro Vancouver Board<br />
will not be officially approving the proposal until some time early in 2013<br />
so there is still time to decide if we want to submit comments or appear<br />
as a-delegation to theMetro Vancouver Parks Committee.<br />
PAGE3f --
Riverview Hospital Update contained some valuable information which could form the basis of<br />
The public consultation aver the draft Heritage Conservation Plan has<br />
now concluded. We hope to be able to read the final report at same point<br />
in the near future. However, a worrisome statement in the plan noted<br />
that the HCP “is not intended to be used a public document’. That might<br />
mean the final report will not be released for public perusal. If anyone<br />
would like to read the comments I submitted on behalf of BMN, please<br />
email me and I will send them to you. We asked for several immediate<br />
actions to be taken. These included:<br />
1. Seeking opportunities far adaptive re-use of facilities before<br />
stabilization strategies such as motliballing are undertaken. Many of<br />
the buildings at Riverview already have a long history of successful<br />
adaptive re-use and re-purposing. This would be the mast constructive<br />
first approach to take with regard to protecting the heritage values of<br />
the site providing, of course, that new uses do not compromise heritage<br />
values. Unfortunately, the mothballing activities (removing all furniture<br />
from buildings, etc.) that are now taking place at Riverview are likely to<br />
prevent any constructive re-use of these facilities.<br />
2. Taking action with regard to West Lawn. The deteriorating state of<br />
West Lawn needs immediate and specialized attention. Priority should<br />
be given to stabilizing West Lawn and preventing any further water<br />
damage. There also needs to be same attention paid to possible wildlife<br />
use of West Lawn given the ability of birds and bats to now penetrate<br />
the structure. West Lawn is truly a monumental building, the first one to<br />
be constructed at Riverview; its design was the result of an architectural<br />
competition. It could be the first example of the use of reinforced<br />
concrete in Canada.<br />
some interesting tree tours to highlight them. For example, there are<br />
a number of trees in the collection that are considered to be at risk in<br />
their native habitat including a magnolia, tulip tree and rubber tree from<br />
China, a Spanish fir as well as the giant sequoia and California redwood<br />
from the USA. It turns out that the tree collection contains an impressive<br />
list of trees from eastern North America (Carolinian forest) including the<br />
butternuts which are now at risk from disease in the east In addition,<br />
a number of trees were identified as being of local significance - these<br />
included a number of the beeches and the Camperdown elms (also at<br />
risk elsewhere in Canada from Dutch elm disease).<br />
BC Alliance on Mental Illness wants trust fund If Riverview sold<br />
We were alarmed by the front page headline in the Coquitlam Now<br />
on October24 which indicated a group called the BC Alliance on Mental<br />
Illness had put out a press release calling for all proceeds from the sale<br />
or lease of the Riverview Lands to be directed towards a trust fund for<br />
mental health care which would be administered by groups working<br />
in mental health and addiction services. I subsequently got in touch<br />
with the staff person mentioned in the article as well as one of the<br />
co-chairs of this Alliance. The Alliance represents 21 groups of health,<br />
social service and criminal justice organizations that have developed<br />
a campaign to get the “ear of Government” in order to work in<br />
partnership towards an “evidence based” system of care, Their mission<br />
is to ensure that every citizen has timely access to services that are<br />
preventative, that reduce harm and provide the best opportunity to<br />
achieve optimum mental and physical health and community inclusion.<br />
All of this sounds good - but I am very worried their most recent press<br />
3. Working with Metro Vancouver to strengthen the historical<br />
release makes it sound they support the sale of the Riverview lands<br />
connections with Colony Farm. We recommended a dialogue be<br />
as long as the funds come back to them to provide mental health<br />
opened with them with regard to how this can be best accomplished. care services. The groups that belong to this Alliance include the BC<br />
Given that Kwantlen College is likely to be entering into a partnership<br />
agreement with Metro Vancouver Parks to create training opportunities<br />
at Colony Farm Regional Park for students in their agricultural program,<br />
opportunities to provide teaching facilities at the HEY building on the<br />
Riverview grounds should be explored.<br />
Schizophrenia Society and First United Church on the east side of<br />
downtown Vancouver. Sadly, their press release stated that “with the<br />
last beds of Riverview closed,.., the process of de-institutionalization<br />
is more or less accomplished”. I think this statement shows a complete<br />
lack of understanding on their part of what Riverview has to offer.. and<br />
4. Keeping lines of communication open with the City of Coquitlarn. We what it did provide to patients for many years.<br />
recommended the City should be kept fully apprised of further feasibility When I tried to explain to their spokesperson that their press release<br />
studies and consulted with regard to re-use of existing facilities.<br />
5. We also said the development of a land use plan for Riverview<br />
“must” take into account heritage values and features (the HCP plan<br />
only said “consider” them). We reminded them that recognition is also<br />
required that it may take some time for appropriate solutions and suitable<br />
partners to emerge — thus, this land use planning process must not be<br />
constrained by too short a time-line. A key consideration of any long-term<br />
use plan would be any potential impacts of new buildings/roads, etc.,<br />
on the water table and water flow through the site as this could alter<br />
conditions best suited to sustain tree growth and health.<br />
6. We also suggested that management of the tree collection requires<br />
ongoing attention and an adequate budget for maintenance, etc. With far<br />
fewer users groups on site, it is not clear that the budget will be adequate<br />
could easily be interpreted by government as support for the sale of<br />
the Riverview lands, he begged to differ. To my mind, without a doubt,<br />
the government would be highly likely to use this press release as<br />
evidence of the desire of mental health groups to sell tile Riverview<br />
lands. I think we need to be corresponding with this Alliance and their<br />
member organizations so that we are not speaking at cross-purposes<br />
to government I was even more concerned when this spokesperson<br />
said their press release was part of a strategic action that included<br />
correspondence with politicians. Please see the “action of the month”<br />
elsewhere in this newsletter for how you can help to protect the Riverview<br />
lands. I would also encourage our members to write letters to the editor<br />
of the Coquitlam Now regarding this article and the need to preserve the<br />
Riverview lands for mental health care and mental wellness.<br />
to monitor and maintain the tree collection in good health. Should any<br />
new buildings be contemplated on site, we recommended there be a<br />
special budgetary requirement for landscaping so that the tree collection<br />
can be enhanced and the tradition of maintaining an outstanding tree<br />
collection on the Riverview Lands will continue.<br />
6. We also said immediate actions should also include a commitment<br />
to keep the public engaged and apprised. In this regard, we feel the<br />
Riverview Natural Heritage Stewardship Committee has played a valuable<br />
role for many years in strengthening the lines of communication between<br />
the local stewardship groups and the province. Currently, membership<br />
on this committee includes the Riverview Horticultural Centre Society,<br />
Burke Mountain Naturalists and Shared Services BC, We recommended<br />
this Committee continue and consideration be given to expanding the<br />
membership to include Metro Vancouver Parks and the City of Coquitlam.<br />
Watershed Watch Analysis on “Run-of-River” Projects<br />
The Watershed Watch Society, based in Coquillam, has just released<br />
an excellent analysis of the many impacts associated with the so-called<br />
“green” energy derived from mn-of-river projects. Several years ago,<br />
BMN alongside other groups successfully fought against such a proposed<br />
project in the Upper Pitt River Watershed. Since that time, several of<br />
these projects elsewhere have been approved and many more are still<br />
in the works. Such projects don’t really live up to the definition of green<br />
energy because there are huge impacts associated with them including<br />
the many kilometers of forests that are cleared for transmission lines and<br />
the roads that must be built to construct these projects in remote areas.<br />
Nor are these projects really “mn-of-river” because much of the water is<br />
removed from the stream; this report more correctly calls them “riverdiversion”<br />
projects. They typically result in the diversion of most of the<br />
The Appendix in the HCP report on the trees of the arboretum<br />
waterin a stream for•a considerable length and thus impoverish<br />
PAGE 4- — -<br />
zJ
the stream, diminish habitat and destroy ecosystem values. Sadly, a copy of our 2004 report, “The Riverview Hospital Site, Respecting its Past,<br />
some of these projects are now being approved in reaches of rivers that<br />
provide significant wild salmon habitat. Nor are the provincial or federal<br />
governments prepared to undertake adequate monitoring to ensure<br />
damage is not done to fish habitat With years of cuthacks to government<br />
budgets, there are no longer adequate levels of staff in place to “mind the<br />
store”. The report, Tamed Rivers, a Guide to River Diversion Hydropower<br />
in BC, is available at www.watershedwatch.org. I highly recommend it<br />
Another Omnibus Bill with more Ominous Implications for<br />
Environmental Protection<br />
Last spring, the Harper government tabled and passed a huge, socalled<br />
omnibus “budget” bill, Bill C-38, that fundamentally altered the way<br />
the federal government will (no longer) protect fish and the environment<br />
The manner in which it was done, without any public consultation and<br />
essentially no Parliamentary debate, was an affront to democracy. On<br />
October18, the Harper government did it again with a second omnibus<br />
“budget” bill, C-45. Buried in this 437-page new bill are changes to the<br />
laws that once protected Canada’s waterways including the Navigable<br />
Waters Protection Act. As a result, of the 32,000 or so lakes in Canada,<br />
only 97 will be protected under the new legislation as will only 62 rivers<br />
and streams. The bill will also specifically exempt the impacts of pipeline<br />
construction on waterways from being considered in environmental<br />
assessments. It also will allow industry to request exemptions from<br />
any previous commitments they have made to undertake fish habitat<br />
compensation projects. DFO habitat biologists will be reduced to only 60<br />
positions in BC (down from 120 only a few years ago) and their office in<br />
New Westminster will close. After previous staff cuts in 2005, the number<br />
of patrols and violations observed plunged at least 75%.<br />
Action Item — Write to<br />
Provincial Opposition Leader,<br />
Adrian Dix, about Riverview<br />
By Elaine Golds<br />
With a provincial election coming this spring, it is looking very likely that<br />
we could have a new premier, Adrian Dix, in place. Thus, it is important<br />
that Dix has opportunities to hear from people around the province about<br />
issues of particular concern to them. We think this is an ideal time for our<br />
members to be writing to Dix to inform him about the values of Riverview<br />
and the need to preserve this site for mental wellness. We have been<br />
lucky to have exceptional support from our local MLAs Diane Thorne, Mike<br />
Farnworth and Joe Trasolini with regard to Riverview. However, we can’t<br />
expect to rely only on them to extol the virtues of the Riverview site. As<br />
local residents, we also need to speak up to ensure that the voices in our<br />
community are heard. Please write to Adrian Dix, Official Leader of the<br />
Opposition, Room 201, Parliament Buildings, Victoria, BC V8V 1X4 or Adrian.<br />
dix.mla@leg.bc.ca.<br />
You could explain to Dix that, with the closure of Riveiview Hospital this<br />
summer, you are very worried about the fate of the Riverview Hospital<br />
site. You should point out that this wonderful 100 heclare site contains<br />
heritage buildings, a fabulous tree collection, beautiful natural areas and<br />
forms an important Ibik in a green corridor which reaches from Colony<br />
Farm Regional Park on the Coquitlam River through to Burrard Inlet. You<br />
could also point out the need to continue mental health care at Riverview,<br />
not only in the 3 newer facilities operated by the Fraser Health Authority<br />
but also in some of the older but still very functional buildings at Riverview<br />
- such asValleyview which opened in 1%0 and, until a year ago, offered<br />
75 beds for the care of dementia and related patients. Please point out to<br />
him that the Riverview grounds are designed to provide close contact with<br />
nature and have been found to provide a very therapeutic setting for mental<br />
health care. Remind him of the thousands of people who signed petitions<br />
in 2000(22,000 signatures) and 2007-9(18,000 signatures) to request<br />
the entire Riverview site be kept in the public trust and used to provide<br />
much-needed mental health care. BMN will also be officially writing to Dix<br />
and providing him with additional background information including<br />
PAGE5<br />
Realizing its Future”. Your letter will help to convince him that there are<br />
many people in this community who support the protection of Riverview<br />
and its continuing use as a mental health care facility.<br />
Kinder Morgan Pipeline Update<br />
By Elaine Golds<br />
By the time of the November BMN meeting, we hope to have a map<br />
which clearly shows where the Kinder Morgan pipeline threads its way<br />
through Coquitlain into Burnaby. Howevet given the challenges with<br />
finding space for a second pipeline beside it, it is not clear that the<br />
“twinning of the existing pipeline witl follow the same path. Certainly,<br />
this residential area is much more built-up than it was years ago in 1953<br />
when the first pipeline was constructed. There is some speculation that<br />
the new pipeline might even come across the northern slopes of the<br />
TriCities through Coquitlam and Port Moody into the old loco Refinery and<br />
across Burrard Inlet to the tank farm in Bumaby.<br />
To kick-off their public consultation process, Kinder Morgan is<br />
planning on holding local “information sessions” as part of their first<br />
phase for the proposed twinning. They hosted the first one in Belcarra on<br />
November 6 and, according to their website, will host other sessions in<br />
Coquitlam and Burnaby during the week of Nov19. Once we learn when<br />
and where these meetings will be held, we will post this information to<br />
our website. These “sessions” are likely to take the form of an “open<br />
house”. A serious problem with such open houses is that information<br />
is not readily shared with all members of the public. A far better format<br />
is to hold a sit-down public meeting where information is presented by<br />
the proponent, members of The public can ask follow-up questions and<br />
everyone can hear the answers. This is the type of public meeting we<br />
should be demanding.<br />
According to information provided by North Burnaby MP Kennedy<br />
Stewart, Kinder Morgan will make an official application to the National<br />
Energy Board (NEB) to construct the new pipeline some time in 2013. By<br />
2014, the NEB will undertake a public hearing with approval or rejection<br />
of the project expected in 2015. By 2016, construction could begin. The<br />
new pipeline is expected to be operational by 2017. The main purpose of<br />
this pipeline will be to carry diluted bitumen from the tar sands in Alberta<br />
for export overseas from the Westridge terminal in Burnaby. Mother<br />
major impact will be vastly increased tanker traffic in Burrard Inlet. Once<br />
the NED approves the general conidor for the pipeline, Kinder Morgan will<br />
apparently have the right to expropriate any land along the route that it<br />
needs. In addition to a 30-meter right of way (ROW), they expect to also<br />
require an additional safety zone 30 meters in width of both sides of the<br />
ROW.<br />
MP Kennedy Stewart has been busy conducting polls. He found that<br />
only 31% of BC residents and 20% of the residents in his riding support<br />
the proposed new pipeline. The Mayors and Councils in Burnaby and<br />
Vancouver have also stated their opposition. Please note, residents<br />
in Stewart’s riding do not oppose the existing pipeline which brings<br />
oil products from Alberta to support local needs. However, there are<br />
fears that the export market could create such a large demand for<br />
diluted bitumen that local requirements for gasoline would no longer<br />
be met This could also lead to increased gas prices for people in Metro<br />
Vancouver if we have to complete with foreign markets.<br />
BLrnaby residents have organized themselves to oppose the new<br />
pipeline and me tanker traffic. They have formed aat group called<br />
BROKE (Bumaby Residents Opposed to KnderMorgan Expansion) and are<br />
wrkhig cooperatively with other groups such as the Wikierness Committee,<br />
NoTankers,org and The Council of Canadians. It makes me wonder why we<br />
don’t have a CHOKE (Coquitlam Residents Opposed....) working to make<br />
local residents more aware of this important issue? BROKE has already<br />
hosted a public meeting in October attended by hundreds of people which<br />
received much attention from the media. The people and Council in Coquillam<br />
?Plrnar-to be asleep at the switch on this issue.<br />
[93
Young Naturalists Club<br />
Explorer Day in October<br />
Two accounts of the search for mushrooms at Buntzen Lake<br />
with Terry Taylor (in the pouring rain)<br />
The mushroom walk was a great learning experience and we learned<br />
about lots of different types of fungi. We found a surprising amount of<br />
mushrooms and fungus considering the weather. It was fun but the<br />
weather was not really agreeing with us. It was a complete downpour<br />
and a little cold but interesting. There was a massive amount of Things<br />
to look at. Our leader pointed out mushroom species and which ones<br />
are edible and which ones are not. He explained how the black spots on<br />
fall leaves where really fungus feeding off the leaf? Isn’t that cool? We<br />
walked along the beach and saw a car whose front tires where nearly<br />
under water and you’d need a boat to get to tile boat shed. The lake had<br />
gone up 4 inches since the morning ! It was really fun and I loved it?<br />
By Eleanor Didicher (12)<br />
Young Naturalists and parents having a mini-lecture on fungi from Terry at the gazebo,<br />
which was the only place we didn’t need to use an umbrella during the event.<br />
photo: N. Nakaya<br />
Although it was pouring rain, we enjoyed a nature walk with our family,<br />
our friends, and our leader in Buntzen Lake. We learned that leaves turn<br />
into their autumn coloursas They die. On some of the sugar maple leaves<br />
there are large black spots which are actually fungi. With a magnifying<br />
scope, we observed a green hue around these black spots. This green<br />
area is a sugar supply that the fungi use as energy to spread. We took<br />
a walk around the lakeside and stood beside a dangerous looking river<br />
where a strong nish of water and mud stirred up the lake. Apparently, the<br />
lake used to be part of the woods as we saw hundreds of tree stumps<br />
standing up in the middle of it. We saw the most fascinating site of large<br />
mistletoe. We learned not to stand in front of a mistletoe as it shoots out<br />
seeds at a rate of 80 kilometers an hour; this allows the plant to attached<br />
itself on the trees in order to grow.<br />
We had so much fun looking<br />
for different mushrooms and<br />
learning about them. For<br />
example, fairy rings, reishi<br />
mushrooms and red belts (hard).<br />
The cycle of living organisms<br />
depend on the kingdom of fungi.<br />
By Megan Chen (II)<br />
andAdrian Chen (13)<br />
Picture byAlexandra Didicher (8)<br />
WhatAli saw — mushrooms, plate<br />
fungus, “Canada” leaves with spots,<br />
rain drops (lots of those) and a stick<br />
with moss. -<br />
Call forVolunteers:<br />
Christmas Bird Count on<br />
Sat., December 15th bytoo,n<br />
Each year in the weeks around Christmas, tens of thousands of<br />
volunteers spend a few hours along local trails on the annual Christmas<br />
Bird Count (CRC). This is now the longest running ‘citizen science survey’<br />
in the world. It began in 1900 when an American ornithologist asked<br />
people to head out on Christmas Day to count birds instead of shooting<br />
them, as was the tradition. The CRC is now conducted in more than 2000<br />
localities across North America, Latin America and the Caribbean. The<br />
observations form a huge database that reflects the distribution and<br />
numbers of winter birds over the past 112 years.<br />
RMN has been participating in the TriCities sector of the Pitt Meadows<br />
CRC fur the past 19 years, and we’ll be out again this year, rain or shine,<br />
by foot, car and possibly by boat. The BMN-CBC-coordinator is John<br />
Reynolds, assisted by Hilary Maguire and myself. Volunteers will be<br />
assigned to a team that is sent to one of 14 Areas (e.g., Colony Farm,<br />
Como Lake, Inlet Park, Lafarge Lake, along the Coquitlam River); even if<br />
you’re not great at bird identification, you can still be a valuable member<br />
of the team as spotters and recorders are needed too. You can also<br />
participate by watching your feeders that day if your yard is located<br />
within the count circle. Fun for the whole family!<br />
In a change from past years, the $5 participation fee paid to the<br />
Audubon Society will be waived this year.<br />
If you haven’t already signed up for the RMN-CBC, please contact us at<br />
BurkeMtnNals@gmafl.com or call Victoria at 604.937.5379.<br />
Nature & Feeder Watch By Ui Thunstrom<br />
The local creeks are full of salmon at long last after the rains arrived.<br />
Hewn watcher Lindsey Munson saw a ‘good sized fish” in the new<br />
pond at Colony Farm, inside the tidal gate and trying hard to escape. It<br />
likely would have been able to do so at the next high tide. An interesting<br />
sighting in this newly developed area.<br />
The bears at DeBoville Slough continued to be visible as they shifted<br />
from the berry fields to nearby rivers and creeks in search of the<br />
spawning salmon. Hilary had the good fortune to photograph a bear at<br />
close range as it walked down the section of Partington Creek adjacent<br />
to the DeBoville parking lot. This bear was only toying with a few dead<br />
fish, so it must have had a full stomach. Another very well-fed bear<br />
spent the day sleeping in my neighbour’s garden in the Como Lake<br />
area of Coquitlam. Only after we had finished working, did we notice it<br />
- within fifty feet of where we were, so it had to have been watching us<br />
all afternoon? The bear left during the night leaving no trace - fallen fruit,<br />
garbage and compost were all left alone. This is the second bear sighting<br />
in the garden this year near Como Lake; the first time in over thirty-five<br />
years we’ve been visited by them.<br />
PAGEI<br />
cation: snacking in Partington Creek photo: H. Maguire
On October 13th on a walk at DeBoville Slough 1-lilary was very<br />
surprised to see a Bald Eagle bringing sticks to the nest, while the other<br />
partner looked on from a nearby tree. However, according to David<br />
Hancock’s website (http://www<strong>ii</strong>ancockwildlife.org) this behaviour is<br />
not unusual. Nest repair can go on in the fall months, though the most<br />
intense repair period is from January to March, with egg-laying typically<br />
occurring from late February to March.<br />
Hilary also reported that wintering waterbirds are returning to Port<br />
Moody arm. Barrow’s Goldeneyes are favouring the loco Boat Club area<br />
so far this fall, and Buffleheads are present in good numbers at the<br />
Noon’s Creek end of the inlet. A flock of 20+ scaup were present on<br />
October22 and an immature swan also made a brief appearance on the<br />
inlet that day.<br />
Unusual ducks seen were 2 adult male Long-tailed Ducks in the midinlet<br />
on November 1st and a pair of Wood Ducks (October 29) near the<br />
Noon’s Creek estuary - unusual for salt water, but perhaps not in such<br />
proximity to the fresh water of Noons Creek. Hilary also saw a Western<br />
Grehe in the area, an increasingly uncommon species now.<br />
Anna’s Humrningbirds are back at Hilary’s feeders, though still relying<br />
on “natural food” in the garden, owing to the mild weather.<br />
Bill and Sue Aaroe have had female Anna’s Hummingbirds winter over<br />
the last two years. Bill says that This year it appears they will have at<br />
least one male, as one has been visiting their feeder regulaily. Bill is not<br />
sure how many females they are getting this yea The first year there<br />
was only one and last winter, two or three. This year he is not seeing<br />
females as frequently<br />
The Aaroes have a Chickadee house in their yard and over the last<br />
couple of weeks they have watched a Downy Woodpecker male working<br />
on the opening to make it a bit larger.<br />
Bill walks his dogs on the dike at the end of Dominion where them is<br />
a wetland that has been created and usually sees many ducks etc., but<br />
got a treat on Thursday when he saw the biggest flock of Red-winged<br />
Blackbirds he has ever seen; “many hundreds for sure - simply beyond<br />
my ability to count or estimate” he says.<br />
There are very few migrants at Como Lake this year A Pied-billed<br />
Grebe, a pair of Widgeon, two Coats and a large flock of robins passing<br />
through were the only ones noted so far, although Pine Siskins are busy<br />
in the trees at the lake and around my feeders. The garden has been<br />
quite lively, however, with a Pileated Woodpecker on the dead trees, Song<br />
Spariows, a Pacific winter) Wren, nuthatches and Chestnut-backed<br />
Chickadees visiting the feeder and a mother raccoon and five kits who<br />
come to the pond!<br />
And a butterfly sighting: yesterday I was sweeping out the garden<br />
shed and caught up what appeared to be a dead leaf.., but it moved<br />
and was then seen to be a beautiful Mourning Cloak butterfly (Nymphalis<br />
antiopa) which had apparently gone into the shed to overwinter! It luckily<br />
was undamaged; after about an hour in a low basket, it had moved off,<br />
supposedly to another hiding place! It was a treat to see and I will work<br />
with great care now so that it is not disturbed again. This species is<br />
one of the so called “winter butterflies” that may be seen flying in early<br />
spring since they overwinter as adults, even in areas where temperatures<br />
go below freezing. The dark colour of the wings acts as a solar collector<br />
so when the butterfly basks in sunlight, the fluids in the wings and body<br />
are warmed until they reach a temperature sufficient for flight.<br />
Thanks to all for the interesting and unusual sightings.<br />
BMN Archives - Excerpts from<br />
previous Nov. Newsletters ByAnne<br />
from November 1997<br />
“Golden Ears Ascent” by Oewk Wilson<br />
As the sun was just starting to cast a rosy glow over the mountains to<br />
the East on Sat. Sept. 20h, ten intrepid members of BMN<br />
PAGE ,<br />
gathered in the parking lot in the west canyon of Golden Ears Park. We<br />
were eager to start the 12 km. hike which would take us 1500 metres<br />
above to the summit of Golden Ears. Finally, we slipped across the<br />
glittering snowfield to ascend the final 200 metres to the peak of Golden<br />
Ears We hauled ourselves along airy ledges, plunged through<br />
clumps of prickly junipers and scrambled over loose piles of scree.<br />
At last we heaved ourselves onto the peak for the ultimate view.<br />
The Lower Mainland faded into a haze to the southwest Mighty Mount<br />
Baker thrust its symmetrical white cone over its neighbouring peaks to<br />
the south, Tiny motor boats left traces like meteors on the blue-brown<br />
surface of Pitt Lake far below. A vast sweep of jagged peaks filled the<br />
field as far as the eye could see to the north and east.<br />
Earty That evening we regained the parking lot Foot weary and<br />
hungry after the arduous descent, we had garnered many memories of<br />
Panorama Ridge and Golden Ears Mountain before the autumn storms<br />
shroud these heights in a new mantle of snow.<br />
from November 1999<br />
“Keeping an Eye on the Osprey” by Elaine Golds<br />
Late This summer, Susan Mewhort, who has been keeping close<br />
watch on the nesting osprey at Rock Point Park for several years, thought<br />
that she could see some wire in the ospreys’ nest, which was getting<br />
entangled around their feet She felt this was causing the osprey to<br />
abandon their chosen site, so she contacted Rod Macvicar to see if he,<br />
with his boat, could help. The nest could only be reached at high tide<br />
- which, in summer, occurs only in the middle of the night Thus, Susan,<br />
her son, and Rod with his intrepid crew, undertook a successful rescue<br />
mission late one night<br />
As Rod told the story, he wasn’t quite convinced that them really was<br />
wire in the nest until he saw Susan pull it out. They surmise that the wire<br />
- and other hazardous material found them - was inadvertently brought<br />
to the nest by the parent ospreys along with some fish - the perils of<br />
catching fish for your babies in an urban environment!<br />
Also from November 1999<br />
“Wotid flade Organization Meeting In Seattle” by Joan Spin<br />
The 135 member countries of the W1’O meet in Seattle in late<br />
November. At the same time, many individuals and international<br />
organizations will take part in teach-ins and other events in Seattle, in<br />
what is predicted to be the largest anti-free trade protest ever held in the<br />
United States, Many from Canada and other countries are going; hotels<br />
are full, and private homes are opening their doors to host these visitors.<br />
The Ralph Nader group, Public Citizen, is one of several helping to<br />
organize the citizens’ campaign. There is a program of events - teach-ins<br />
and forums - for the whole week, including a demonstration at the end of<br />
the week.<br />
from November 2000<br />
“A New Era Begins” by Karen Beckenbach<br />
In the Sept 2000 issue of our newsletter, Mike Griffin had an article<br />
entitled “Colony Farm - Lest we Forget” Accompanying his article was a<br />
photo of the bridge that used to connect the Home Farm side of Colony<br />
Farm with the Wilson side. However, years of neglect cased the old bridge<br />
to become rickety and unsafe. The final blow was delivered in 1995<br />
when vandals burnt it down. This was a huge loss to the many people<br />
who enjoyed walking the dykes on both sides. It just wasn’t the same<br />
experience having to get in the car to drive around. Now, as of Oct 1st,<br />
park users can once again cross the Coquitlam River via the Coquitlam<br />
River Millennium Bridge in Colony Farm!<br />
from November 2001<br />
“Nature and Feeder Watch” by Rozanne Thomson<br />
From our Okanagan reporter Susan None reports on some mid<br />
summer nature happenings. One of the exciting views that we have had<br />
recetIywaswhen we went to an artesian well locally to get some of<br />
itS reputedly marvellous drinking water. As we started off along
the path, we heard the “CH-K-CH-K-CH-IC’ of a Western rattlesnake! Not<br />
10 feet horn us, coiled up in a little clump of grass in a riparian zone, was<br />
our very first sighting of a live raWer since moving to the Okanagan - all<br />
tile others have been highway pancakes, unfortunately. Needless to say,<br />
we didn’t try to get too close. But it was a marvel to watch this mediumsized<br />
snake shake his warnings and slowly glide off to safety. We slowly<br />
slid off to safety too, for that matter!<br />
from November 2005<br />
“BMN Plaque and flee Planting” Announcements<br />
This past spring we were delighted when BMN won an environmental<br />
achievement award from the City of Coquitlam. Now, to commemorate<br />
that award, we have been invited to plant a tree as part of the Poirier<br />
reforestation project at the upcoming new civic centre complex. If you<br />
are interested in joining us for this planting, planned for sometime this<br />
winter, (2005] please let us know. A plaque will be installed with the<br />
name of our society and date of award. We get to choose a tree species<br />
from a short list of native frees. [Note: The tree is a cedar tree and is<br />
planted behind the Coquitlam Library on Poirier St.<br />
--II<br />
The plaque, tree, and members<br />
of BMN at the commemoration<br />
planting. photos: V Otton<br />
Tills newsletter is printed on EnviroiOO Paper; 700% post -consumer fibre, is ecologo, processed<br />
chionhe-tree and FSC recycled certified and is manufactured in Canada using blogas energy<br />
Membershi’- I<br />
Burke Mountain Naturalists Membership<br />
Form<br />
Name(s):.<br />
J Individual Membership ($25.00/year) Address:<br />
The Burke Mountain Naturalists was formed hi January 1969 and is a<br />
member club of BC Nature (formerty Federation of BC Naturalists)<br />
BMN is a registered non-profit Society with charitable Income status.<br />
Cur objectives are:<br />
• to promote the enjoyment of nature<br />
• to foster an interest in, and an appreciation ol, our environment<br />
• to promote the accessibility and maintenance of natural areas,<br />
particularly local areas<br />
• to actively pursue the conservation & preservation of the<br />
natural world<br />
President Victoria Otton (604.937.5379) votton@sfu.ca<br />
VP: Mark Johnston (604.552.0727)<br />
Past President Ian Mckthur (604.939.4039) imcart@telus.net<br />
teasurer & Membership:<br />
Carole Edwards (604.461.3864) caroleedwards@shaw.ca<br />
RecordIng Secretary:<br />
vacant<br />
Members-at-Larqe:<br />
zme HoIt (604.936,4108), Barb Sherman (604.939.6511), Candlce Archer<br />
(604.465.6853), chrIstina Saremba (604 945-0318), Hlary Maguire<br />
(604.469.5805) and Mark Johnston (604.552.0727)<br />
BC Nature Directors:<br />
Elaine Golds (604.937.3483 Tel & Fax) egolds@sfu.ca<br />
Na Edftor<br />
‘J Family Membership, including children ($30.00/year) City:<br />
(Please Vgth.:e all rst names ar.d ‘r,dica:c wrth are cnidren)<br />
Postal Code:<br />
J Group Membership ($30.00/year)<br />
Hilary Maguire (604.4695805) BurkeMtnNats@gmafl.com<br />
Newsletter Design:<br />
Brigitte Breuer, brigitteb@telus.net<br />
EducatloniConservatlon Committee:<br />
Chair: Elaine Golds, Recording Secretary: Victoria Otton<br />
Members: Mike Griffin, Ian McArthur, Niali Williams,<br />
Carole Edwards<br />
Nature and Feeder Watch: Liz Thunstrom<br />
email ethunstmm@shaw.ca phone 604-939-9571<br />
Young NaturalIsts Club:<br />
Noriko Nakaya (604.675.9031) hmnync@gmaiI.com<br />
asci Publications: 10 newsletters a year (except July and Augus<br />
Nabnl History Brochures Miller Park Ravine, DeBoville Slough<br />
Riverview l.ands, Coguitlam River Corridor<br />
BIrd Brochures: Minnekilada Reg. Park and Area DeBoville Slough,<br />
Coma Lake, The Herons of Colony Farm<br />
Plant Brochins: Colony Farm, OeBov’dle Slough<br />
Wildilte Inventory of the Shoreline Path System by Christine Hanrahan<br />
et al, 1994,121 pages, available at the Port Moody Library<br />
Ow- Backyard Wilderness, A Park Proposal, by Mark Haddock, 1992,<br />
23pgs. plus Appendices, available at Coquitlam Poirier Ubrary<br />
The Riverview Hospital Site: “Respecting Its Past, Realizing Its Future”,<br />
by Elaine Golds,Victoda Otton and Ion Austin (2004), 26 pages available on<br />
01 website www.bnin.bc.ca<br />
Membership information: Members receive ten monthly newsletters<br />
Telephone:<br />
that cover BMN activities, local issues and events. Membership also E-mail:__________________________________________________________<br />
includes the BC Nature quarterly magazine, Nature BC. BMN is a<br />
registered non-profit society with charitable income status.<br />
send.your completadmembership form to: Brute MountaIn Naturalists,<br />
P.O. Box 52540, R.RO.’Coqultlam Centre, Coqultiam, BC V3B 7.14<br />
PAGE 81 H”