Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...
Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...
Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
161:0 axe3 3=0:177(6:5%) Booktitlegoeshere M<strong>in</strong>uit<br />
0:5<br />
0:0Aged'Homme<br />
Flammarion Gallimard<br />
�0:5 Chambon Seuil 1=0:484(18%) axe1<br />
Alb<strong>in</strong>Michel Grasset<br />
-1 -1 �0:5 0:0 0:5 1:0 Laont LogicielsEyelid/LATEX-PsTricks 1:5 2:0<br />
Champvallon<br />
Climats<br />
Complexe<br />
PresenceAfrica<strong>in</strong>e DesFemmes<br />
TempsQu'ilFait Noir/Blanc Ombres VerdierVirag Place Salvy<br />
Nadeau Hamy Zulma Picquier Zoe CalmannLevy<br />
ActesSud<br />
Belfond Defallois<br />
Denoel Bourgois AutrementLattes<br />
p.o.l.<br />
RivagesStock Plon<br />
Fayard<br />
Carriere LianaLevi Losfeld Balland<br />
SerpentaPlumes Marval Metailie OlivierPhebus Nil Ramsay Corti<br />
BellesLettresJulliard MercuredeFrance ClassesdelaCAH classen1 classen2 classen3 classen4 classen5 Rocher TableRonde<br />
FIGURE1.7 ThespaceofFrenchpublishers.Cloudof<strong>in</strong>dividuals<strong>in</strong>plane1-3(Bourdieu1999[9]).<br />
1.6Conclusion Bourdieuwasnotonlyconsciousoftheshortcom<strong>in</strong>gsofthedom<strong>in</strong>antquantitativemethods <strong>in</strong>socialsciences(especiallyregressionmethods),whichhediscoveredwithAla<strong>in</strong>Darbel geometricmodel<strong>in</strong>gofdata,whichhepractisedaround30years,fromthebeg<strong>in</strong>n<strong>in</strong>gofthe sented<strong>in</strong>termsofhypotheses,empiricaldataandresultsconrm<strong>in</strong>g|orfail<strong>in</strong>gtoconrm| asearlyas<strong>in</strong>the1960s.Heconsciouslyfoundanalternativetothesemethodswiththe 1970suntilthelate1990s. hypotheses.Neitherdidhealwaysclearlyseparatebetweensociologicalandstatistical<strong>in</strong>terpretations,nordidhecompletelyformalizehistheoryofeldsandhissociological<strong>in</strong>terpretationofstatisticalanalysis.Probably,thewayhisstatisticalpracticewas<strong>in</strong>tegrated<strong>in</strong>toBourdieudidnotapprovenorpracticetheusualrhetoricofscienticpublications,prethusiasticaboutthepossibilityoffuture<strong>in</strong>tegrationofregression<strong>in</strong>totheframeworkof mayndthistoregrettable. hissociologicalwrit<strong>in</strong>gdidnotencouragedialoguewithotherquantitativetraditionsand<br />
geometricdataanalysis. theclearunderstand<strong>in</strong>gofwhathedidfromastatisticalpo<strong>in</strong>tofview.Manyresearchers<br />
astrongempiricalsociologicalresearchprogram.<br />
ButBourdieuwasclearly<strong>in</strong>searchforageneralgeometricformalization;hewasen- Bourdieu'sadoptionofthegeometricmodel<strong>in</strong>gofdatahasthereforeopenedaspacefor
Change language