Gibson Dunn 2010 Annual Review - Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP

2010 

AnnuAl 

Review

Table of Contents 

Message from our Managing Partner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2 

Litigation Highlights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4 

U .S . Supreme Court Victories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 

Litigation Successes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6 

Business Restructuring and Reorganization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .14 

Transactional Highlights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .16 

Mergers & Acquisitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .17 

Capital Markets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20 

Global Finance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23 

Film . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24 

Real Estate Transactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .25 

Global . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .27 

Europe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .28 

Middle East . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .31 

Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .33 

New Partners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .35 

Promoted Partners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .36 

Lateral Partners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .37 

Diversity — Pro Bono . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .38 

Diversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39 

Pro Bono . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .40 

Frank Wheat Awards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .42

Message from our Managing Partner 

Message from our Managing Partner 

Dear Clients, Colleagues and Friends, 

Gibson Dunn has long maintained a deep and unwavering commitment to excellence that is reflected in our 

client base and the lawyers we have been able to attract . Thanks to both our loyal clients and our talented 

attorneys and staff, we have had a successful year, despite a challenging economic market . In fact, since 

our last report, we opened a Hong Kong office, which gives us a larger platform — along with our Singapore 

office — to serve our clients in Asia and better access to the increasingly vital China market . 

We continue the winning streak that led to our two-year designation as American Lawyer’s 2010 Litigation 

Department of the Year . Legal360 named our Appellate, White Collar, Securities, and Class Action Groups 

among its top five, and our Antitrust Group earned the prestigious USA Award for Excellence from Chambers 

and Partners . 

Our Supreme Court practice continues to make history, emerging victorious this year in Citizens United 

v. Federal Election Commission, where the Court held that corporations and other entities have a First 

Amendment right to engage in political speech . Perry v. Schwarzenegger, our landmark federal constitutional 

challenge to California’s gay marriage ban, is on appeal following an unprecedented three-week trial 

where the court held that California’s Proposition 8 is unconstitutional under both the Due Process and Equal 

Protection Clauses . Since being retained by Chevron Corporation in the Lago Agrio environmental litigation 

based in Ecuador, the Firm has scored significant victories, including persuading the Second Circuit to order 

a filmmaker to turn over highly incriminating outtakes . Our Intellectual Property litigators won a closely 

watched jury trial on behalf of Novell and Red Hat in a patent infringement case . Our white collar practice, 

including corporate and government investigations, continued to strengthen with significant representations 

across the globe . In the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act area, a Gibson Dunn partner has been serving as 

counsel to the Siemens’ Compliance Monitor in the aftermath of the company’s SEC settlement resolving 

corruption-related charges . 

Our transactional practice rebounded in 2010 with Gibson Dunn playing a major role in a wide range of 

transactions . We were privileged to represent some of the largest companies in the world in their strategic 

acquisitions, including Hewlett-Packard in its acquisitions of Palm and ArcSight, Intel in its acquisition of 

Numonyx, and Heineken in its acquisition of FEMSA Cerveza . We also represented Del Monte Foods Co . in 

its sale to an investor group led by KKR and CommScope in its sale to The Carlyle Group . 

2 | GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP 2010 ANNUAL REVIEW

Our Capital Markets group represented issuers and underwriters in equity and debt offerings, including 

IPOs, convertible notes and high-yield offerings . We participated in significant equity offerings on behalf 

of Air Lease Corporation and Towers Watson & Co ., and in the IPO market, we represented Vallar Limited, 

Douglas Dynamics and Goldman Sachs as underwriter to Financial Engines, Inc . 

Our pro bono commitment has increased in every respect — total number of pro bono hours, hours per attorney 

and the number of attorneys performing significant pro bono service during the year . Our pro bono 

efforts continue to be recognized by numerous national legal service providers, including the National Legal 

Aid & Defender Association, which awarded Gibson Dunn its Beacon of Justice Award for extraordinary commitment 

to pro bono legal representation in the area of immigration law . 

Diversity remains a top management priority . Since completing our diversity action plan last year, we have revamped 

our committee structures, updated our policy on flex-time and created a Professional Development 

Department to enhance the professional experience of all attorneys, including our diverse lawyers . We also 

welcomed a new Chief Diversity Officer to help us implement our goals . We believe that attracting and retaining 

attorneys and staff from diverse backgrounds is essential to providing the highest quality legal services . 

Gibson Dunn is proud of its reputation as one of the leading law firms in the world, as well as our core values 

of professionalism, integrity, collegiality and mutual respect . It has been our privilege to work with so many 

outstanding clients in 2010, and we look forward to working together in the coming year . 

Sincerely, 

Kenneth M. Doran 

Chairman & Managing Partner 

GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP 2010 ANNUAL REVIEW | 3 

Message from our Managing Partner

Litigation 

HigHLigHts

Litigation Highlights 

As detailed in the following pages, Gibson Dunn won an important First 

Amendment case in the U.S. Supreme Court, obtained a landmark trialcourt 

decision in a constitutional challenge to California’s ban on gay 

marriage and took on the defense of Chevron Corporation in a multinational 

toxic tort suit. 

U.S. Supreme Court Victories 

obtained Landmark decision in Citizens United 

In one of the most far-reaching decisions of the term, we were victorious in Citizens United v. 

Federal Election Commission, where the Court held that corporations and other entities have a First 

Amendment right to engage in political speech . Gibson Dunn represented Citizens United, a nonprofit 

advocacy corporation that produced a critical documentary about then-Senator Hillary Clinton . 

Citizens United was prohibited from distributing the movie because federal law made it a felony for 

corporations to use general treasury funds for political advocacy . Citizens United filed suit and lost 

before a three-judge district court . Reversing, the Supreme Court held that portions of the McCain- 

Feingold campaign finance law and other federal laws banning corporate and union expenditures on 

political speech violate the First Amendment . 

PrevaiLed on beHaLf of conrad bLack 

Gibson Dunn successfully represented Conrad Black, the former CEO of Hollinger International, 

in a major case before the U .S . Supreme Court, raising the question whether the government’s 

broad interpretation of the ‘Honest Services’ provision of the federal mail fraud statute was unconstitutionally 

vague . We persuaded a unanimous Court that Conrad’s convictions were based on an 

unconstitutional application of the statute . 


Litigation Highlights


Chambers UsA: America’s Leading 

Lawyers for Business 2010 awarded 

Gibson Dunn 204 rankings, with the 

Firm and its attorneys achieving 

a total of 51 first-tier rankings, 

13 of which were firm practice 

group rankings. 

American Lawyer ranked Gibson 

Dunn 7th on its 2010 A-List of the 

nation’s law firm elite. The American 

Lawyer considers the 20 A-List law 

firms to be the most elite law firms 

in the country. The rankings are 

determined by financial performance, 

associate satisfaction, commitment to 

pro bono and diversity. 

the Best Lawyers in America 2011 

named 100 Gibson Dunn lawyers as 

leading lawyers in 30 practice areas, 

based on peer review. 

Corporate Board Member magazine 

ranked Gibson Dunn 8th in its 2010 

annual survey of America’s Best 

Corporate Law Firms, based on a 

survey of general counsel who were 

asked to name the outside law firm 

they most admire. In a separate 

survey, Gibson Dunn ranked 12th in 

the publication’s annual top 20 list of 

America’s Best Corporate Law Firms. 

Litigation Successes 

successfuLLy rePresented nbc in 

“fLeeting exPLetives” case 

We represented NBC Universal in a case that was 

a significant victory for broadcast television networks 

. The Second Circuit ruled that the Federal 

Communications Commission’s policy concerning 

“fleeting expletives” in live television broadcasts 

violates the First Amendment because it is unconstitutionally 

vague and chills protected speech . 

obtained dismissaL for accounting firm 

We obtained a dismissal for client Ernst & Young in 

a case stemming from the Madoff scandal, where 

investors in the Tremont Partners Inc . hedge fund 

sued over losses suffered when Madoff’s Ponzi 

scheme collapsed . The putative class action sought 

to hold Ernst & Young — which audited the hedge 

fund, but not Madoff’s firm — liable . The Southern 

District of New York dismissed, holding that Ernst 

& Young could not be held liable for failing to audit 

Madoff’s operations when they were not engaged 

to audit those operations and no facts were alleged 

demonstrating Ernst & Young had been complicit in 

the fraud, knew of it or had consciously disregarded 

facts that should have alerted it to the fraud . 

PrevaiLed at triaL for vestin mortgage 

We prevailed after an 11-day bench trial in the 

Superior Court of the State of California, County of 

San Diego in two consolidated nationwide class actions 

for Vestin Mortgage, Inc ., one of the nation’s 

leading real-estate-based fund managers, involving 

alleged breaches of publicly traded real estate investment 

trusts . We defeated plaintiffs’ motion for 

summary adjudication, successfully moved to strike 

plaintiffs’ prayer for punitive damages and obtained 

a dismissal with prejudice of plaintiffs’ tort claims . 


successfuLLy settLed inteL ftc action 

We have successfully represented Intel in a series 

of antitrust actions and government investigations 

over the past five years . This year, Intel 

favorably settled a civil antitrust enforcement 

action with the Federal Trade Commission, relating 

to various business activities and products . 

After months of intense litigation, the FTC and 

Intel reached a proposed comprehensive settlement 

agreement in the form of a consent decree 

containing relief on a considerably smaller 

scale than sought by the complaint . Intel did 

not admit any violations of law as part of the settlement, 

but agreed to modify certain aspects 

of its business practices . The FTC action came 

on the heels of the settlement of a monopolization 

suit by Advanced Micro Devices, one of the 

largest antitrust cases ever brought . 


obtained reversaL for saic 

We obtained a reversal for Science Applications 

International Corp . (SAIC) in a False Claims Act 

appeal, arising from SAIC’s contracts with the 

Nuclear Regulatory Commission . The government 

claimed SAIC’s alleged noncompliance 

with conflict-of-interest obligations transformed 

its facially accurate requests for payment into 

impliedly false claims . The D .C . Circuit set aside 

a jury verdict, holding the trial court had improperly 

instructed the jury . 

Won insider trading action against sec 

Gibson Dunn achieved a victory in a contentious 

insider trading action brought by the SEC 

against hedge fund client Wynnefield Capital 

and its chief portfolio manager, Nelson Obus . 

The Southern District of New York granted summary 

judgment in favor of Gibson Dunn’s clients 

following eight years of litigation . In a rebuff 

to the SEC, the court adopted the defense arguments 

that the SEC failed to adduce evidence 

sufficient to prove three elements of insider 

trading: duty, breach, and scienter . 

Won summary Judgment for verizon 

We obtained summary judgment for Verizon 

New York Inc . in a longstanding feud with The 

City of New York . Verizon pays the State of New 

York hundreds of millions of dollars in special 

franchise taxes, which the state distributes to 

municipalities to compensate for Verizon’s use 

of municipal streets and infrastructure . In 2003, 

the City brought suit seeking a declaration that 

Verizon must obtain a separate municipal franchise 

and pay additional municipal franchise 

fees to maintain and operate telecommunications 

facilities within the City . In 2010, the 

Supreme Court of New York granted summary 

judgment, finding that Verizon already had the 

requisite state franchise and municipal permission 

needed to place aerial and underground 

fixtures and lines throughout the City and needed 

no further municipal franchise from the City . 



Global Competition Review 2010 

ranked the Firm’s antitrust practice 

11th in the world in its Global Elite 

ranking, which features the top 20 

antitrust practices. Gibson Dunn was 

also ranked as an elite firm in the 

category United States: California 

and was highly recommended in the 

area of United States: Governmental 

Antitrust. Additionally, 11 attorneys 

are ranked in the international Who’s 

Who of Competition Lawyers: Peter 

Alexiadis, Jarrett Arp, Robert Cooper, 

Michael Denger, Joseph Kattan, Sean 

Royall, Joel Sanders, Gary Spratling, 

Peter Sullivan, Dan Swanson and 

David Wood. 

the daily Journal named 

Ted Boutrous Jr., Scott Edelman and 

Andrea Neuman to its 2010 annual list 

of California’s Top 100 lawyers. 

U.s. news Media Group and Best 

Lawyers awarded Gibson Dunn 41 

top-tier practice area rankings in the 

2010 inaugural publication of their 

Best Law Firms survey. 

Won Jury verdict in Patent case 

In a case that was closely watched by Linux distributors, 

Gibson Dunn prevailed on behalf of Novell 

Inc . and Red Hat, Inc ., the world’s leading provider 

of open-source solutions, in a jury trial in the 

Eastern District of Texas . In this patent infringement 

case brought by IP Innovation LLC, a subsidiary 

of Acacia Research Corporation and Technology 

Licensing Corporation, the jury returned a verdict 

finding that the three patents at issue were invalid 

and declined to award any damages . 

secured victory for magazine WHoLesaLer 

Gibson Dunn secured a victory for magazine wholesaler 

Hudson News Distributors, LLC in an antitrust 

action brought by a former competitor alleging that 

Hudson conspired with major magazine publishers 

and magazine distributors to cut off its supply 

of magazines and drive it out of business . The 

Southern District of New York granted Hudson’s 

motion to dismiss all claims with prejudice . 

overturned muLtimiLLion-doLLar 

Judgment for investment bank 

We convinced the Ninth Circuit to overturn a multimillion-dollar 

judgment against investment bank, 

Bayerische Hypo-und Vereinsbank AG, for alleged 

violations of the RICO Act stemming from a tax evasion 

scheme . In setting aside a summary judgment, 

the Ninth Circuit held that the plaintiff could not 

prevail on his RICO claim as a matter of law because 

he could not establish proximate causation . 

defeated cLass certification for eHarmony 

We represented eHarmony in the successful defense 

of a class action challenging eHarmony’s 

alleged practice of keeping defunct membership 

profiles active and matching them with active, paying 

subscribers without notifying them . The lawsuit 

sought restitution of monthly subscription fees paid 

by millions of eHarmony subscribers . After removing 

the case to federal court under the Class Action 

Fairness Act, we successfully moved to strike 

claims under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act 

and plaintiff’s prayer for disgorgement of profits, 

and defeated class certification with an evidencebased 

showing of lack of reliance on claimed misrepresentations 

and omissions . 

serving as u.s. counseL to siemens’ 

comPLiance monitor 

Gibson Dunn lawyers support partner F . Joseph 

Warin in his role as U .S . counsel to the independent 

compliance monitor of Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 

and several of its subsidiaries (“Siemens”) . In 

2008, Siemens settled civil and criminal charges 

arising from allegations that they had violated the 

U .S . Foreign Corrupt Practices Act . In connection 

with the settlements, Siemens engaged Dr . Theo 

Waigel, the former German Minister of Finance, as 

its compliance monitor . As counsel to the compliance 

monitor, Mr . Warin, with his team of Gibson 

Dunn lawyers, reviews Siemens’ anti-corruption 

compliance controls, policies, and procedures . 

The team, in turn, prepares reports for and meets 

with SEC and DOJ lawyers on the effectiveness of 

Siemens’ anti-corruption compliance efforts . 


Landmark ruLing for gay marriage 

Gibson Dunn represents the plaintiffs in Perry v. 

Schwarzenegger, a landmark federal constitutional 

challenge to California’s Proposition 8, which denies 

marriage to gay men and lesbians . After a three-week trial 

in August, U .S . District Court Judge Vaughn Walker in 

San Francisco held that California’s law is unconstitutional 

under both the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses 

because it denies gay men and lesbians the fundamental 

right to marry and because it singles out gay men and 

lesbians for unequal treatment with no rational basis for 

doing so . The decision is the first federal case to consider 

whether gay men and lesbians are guaranteed the freedom 

to marry under the U .S . Constitution . The New York Times 

described the ruling as an “instant landmark in American 

legal history” and “a stirring and eloquently reasoned 

denunciation of all forms of irrational discrimination .” The 

proponents of Proposition 8 appealed Judge Walker’s 

ruling to the Ninth Circuit, and in December, we argued 

in defense of the decision below . Following oral argument, 

the Ninth Circuit asked the Supreme Court of California to 

answer a question relating to whether the proponents of 

Proposition 8 have standing to appeal the District Court’s 

ruling when California’s Governor and Attorney General 

have chosen not to do so . 




Institutional Investor’s 

Benchmark Litigation Guide 

for 2011 recommended Gibson Dunn 

as a leading firm in the areas of 

Antitrust, Appellate, General 

Commercial Litigation, Intellectual 

Property and Securities, Bankruptcy, 

Product Liability and White Collar 

Crime. Benchmark also recognized 

25 partners as “litigation stars”: 

Wayne Barsky, John Behrendt, 

Theodore Boutrous Jr., Joseph Busch, 

Robert Cooper, Michael Denger, Scott 

Edelman, Miguel Estrada, Barry 

Goldsmith, Nick Hanna, Thomas 

Hungar, Joseph Kattan, Dean Kitchens, 

Josh Krevitt, Randy Mastro, Theodore 

Olson, Mark Perry, Sean Royall, Joel 

Sanders, Eugene Scalia, Wayne Smith, 

Orin Snyder, Gary Spratling, Andrew 

Tulumello and Joseph Warin. Nine 

partners were named “future stars”: 

Robert Blume, Frederick Chung, 

Ethan Dettmer, Michael Farhang, 

George Nicoud, Charles Nierlich, Adam 

Offenhartz, Julian Poon and Aric Wu. 

Chambers and Partners named 

Gibson Dunn the winner of the 

Chambers USA Award for Excellence 

2010 in the Antitrust category. 

Won seinfeLd coPyrigHt case 

We won a copyright infringement lawsuit for Jessica 

Seinfeld and HarperCollins stemming from the publication 

of her bestselling book Deceptively Delicious . 

The suit was filed by Missy Chase Lapine, who claimed 

the Seinfeld book plagiarized her cookbook . The 

Southern District of New York dismissed the copyright 

infringement claims and the Second Circuit affirmed . 

Won reversaL of Jury verdict in 

Hurricane katrina case 

We obtained a reversal of a $20 million jury verdict 

against Lexington Insurance Co . arising from 

Hurricane Katrina by convincing the Fifth Circuit 

that it rested on an erroneous interpretation of an 

insurance policy . The Court held that the policy did 

not permit recovery for business interruption losses 

where the plaintiff earned sufficient revenue from 

resuming operations to pay its actual expenses . 

obtained deniaL of cLass certification 

in securities fraud case 

We obtained an order denying class certification in 

a securities fraud action against The First American 

Corporation and its subsidiary eAppraiseIT, LLC . 

The lawsuit was filed in the wake of allegations 

by the New York Attorney General of improper 

home-appraisal practices and an alleged decline 

of over $2 billion in the market capitalization of 

First American . In denying class certification, the 

Southern District of New York held that investors in 

First American stock were not entitled to a classwide 

presumption of reliance and, therefore, could 

not satisfy the predominance requirement for class 

certification . 

Won dismissaL for fLexsys 

We successfully represented Flexsys America L .P . 

and Flexsys N .V ., a producer of rubber chemicals, 

that allegedly intimidated major tire companies into 

boycotting plaintiff, Korea Kumho Petrochemical, 

through threatened patent infringement litigation 

and threats of supply cut-offs . The Ninth Circuit affirmed 

the dismissal of all antitrust claims against 

Flexsys, ending four years of litigation before three 

district courts in two states, multiple motions to dismiss 

and a significant decision relying on principles 

of international comity to bar the discovery of immunity 

materials exchanged between Flexsys and 

the European Commission . 

Won dismissaL for internationaL Paint 

We obtained a dismissal of state law antitrust 

claims for International Paint in an action brought 

by a terminated distributor of yacht paint in 

Broward County, Florida Circuit Court alleging a 

price fixing conspiracy . 


obtained dismissaL for tesoro 

We obtained a dismissal of all claims from the U .S . 

District Court in Denver in an antitrust class action 

against various energy companies including Gibson 

Dunn client, Tesoro . The proposed class, which offers 

drug and alcohol screening and program administration 

services to employers, claimed they 

had been unfairly prevented from offering their services 

to U .S . oil producers and oil refinery operators 

through alleged exclusionary agreements and monopolistic 

conduct by one service provider . 

overturned inJunction for novo nordisk 

In a patent case, Gibson Dunn persuaded the 

Federal Circuit to overturn an injunction ordering 

Novo Nordisk to alter the “use code narrative” it 

submitted to the Food and Drug Administration . In 

a decision that should benefit innovator drug companies, 

the Federal Circuit, adopting Novo Nordisk’s 

argument, held that the counterclaim added to the 

Hatch-Waxman Act in 2003 is narrowly limited and 

cannot be used to force changes in a drug maker’s 

use code narrative . 


Won dismissaL of securities action for 

canadian imPeriaL bank 

We successfully represented former and current 

officers of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 

including its President and Chief Executive Officer, 

in a putative securities class action arising out of 

the decline of CIBC’s stock price following the announcements 

of write-downs of the bank’s mortgage-backed 

securities portfolio . The Southern 

District of New York dismissed all the claims . 

obtained Judgments for creditors of tHe 

rePubLic of argentina 

We persuaded the Second Circuit to affirm judgments 

worth more than $2 billion in favor of NML 

Capital, Ltd . and other creditors against the Republic 

of Argentina for the Republic’s failure to honor the 

floating-rate bonds it had issued . The Court rejected 

the Republic’s assertion that it should be excused 

from paying even though the floating interest rate 

had climbed to more than 100% per year . 

Won aPPeaL in antitrust suit for covidien 

We obtained an affirmance for Covidien in an antitrust 

suit by purchasers of pulse oximetry products . 

In its published decision the Ninth Circuit rejected 

the plaintiffs’ claims under Sections 1 and 2 of the 

Sherman Act, holding that Covidien’s sole-source 

and market-share discounts did not foreclose competition 

in a substantial share of the relevant market 

and that its product was an improvement over 

previous designs . 

Best Lawyers named Wayne Barsky 

as its 2011 Los Angeles Intellectual 

Property Lawyer of the Year. 

Law360 named Gibson Dunn among 

the top five firms of 2010 for its 

Appellate, Class Action, Securities 

and White Collar Groups. 

the daily Journal named Marjorie 

Lewis, Andrea Neuman and Meryl 

Young to its annual list of Top 

Women Litigators. 

the daily Journal featured Los 

Angeles partner Christopher Dusseault 

in its annual list of Top 20 California 

Attorneys Under 40. 

the daily Journal recognized three 

Gibson Dunn cases in its annual 

feature on top plaintiffs’ and defense 

verdicts in California: Perry v. 

Schwarzenegger, where California’s 

ban on gay marriage was held 

unconstitutional; Tellez v. Dole, where 

the Firm won reversal of a multimillion 

dollar jury verdict based on 

newly discovered evidence of fraud; 

and Lexin v. Superior Court, where the 

California Supreme Court dismissed 

criminal charges against members of 

the board of trustees of the San Diego 

City Employees’ Retirement System. 



Jury verdict set aside for doLe 

Gibson Dunn attorneys scored a major victory for Dole Food 

Company, Inc . this year when a Los Angeles Superior Court 

judge threw out a jury verdict in Tellez v. Dole, finding it 

was tainted by fraud . The verdict had been reached prior 

to Gibson Dunn’s representation of Dole . This was the latest 

success since Gibson Dunn took over the defense of a series 

of cases against Dole alleging that its use of the pesticide 

DBCP in Nicaragua in the 1970s caused sterility in former 

farm workers . Gibson Dunn collected evidence that hundreds 

of Nicaraguan plaintiffs had been recruited by plaintiffs’ 

attorneys and coached to lie about their employment and their 

supposed injuries . In 2009, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge 

Victoria Chaney dismissed two test cases, finding that there 

was a pervasive conspiracy to defraud both Nicaraguan and 

U .S . courts . 


defending cHevron in Lago agrio suit 

Gibson Dunn represents Chevron Corporation in the massive, 

multi-pronged Lago Agrio environmental litigation based in 

Ecuador . Since being retained in the fall of 2009, the Firm has 

scored a series of significant victories . In March, we defeated 

a petition by the State of Ecuador to stay an international 

treaty arbitration that Chevron filed to have its claims decided 

in a neutral forum . Seeking to uncover evidence of fraud on 

the part of the plaintiffs in the Ecuadorian litigation, Gibson 

Dunn has obtained discovery in over 15 U .S . jurisdictions . 

These discovery victories include persuading the Second 

Circuit in the closely watched Berlinger case to substantially 

affirm a district court order requiring a filmmaker to turn over 

hundreds of hours of outtakes from the film “Crude” that 

captured the plaintiffs’ case from behind the scenes . We also 

convinced the Fifth Circuit to uphold Chevron’s right to obtain 

allegedly privileged and confidential communications between 

the plaintiffs’ environmental consultants and the Ecuadorian 

court’s damages expert . In anticipation of a fraudulent multibillion 

dollar judgment being entered by the Ecuadorian court, 

we filed a RICO suit early in 2011 in the Southern District of 

New York and sought and obtained a preliminary injunction 

barring the defendants (the Ecuadorian plaintiffs and their 

counsel) from seeking to enforce the over $18 billion judgment 

that was subsequently handed down by the Ecuadorian court . 



Business restructuring and reorganization 

Business Restructuring and Reorganization 

Gibson Dunn’s Business Restructuring and Reorganization practice focuses on the representation of distressed investors, 

lenders, bondholders, creditor committees and debtors. Our 2010 representations include many of the largest and 

most prominent bankruptcy cases, out-of-court restructurings, and distressed asset and debt transactions. 

In the GM bankruptcy case pending in the 

Southern District of New York, we are counsel 

to WilMington trust CoMPany as indenture 

trustee for approximately $23 billion in 

General Motors bonds and Chair of the Official 

Committee of Unsecured Creditors . In that capacity, 

we have taken a lead role in structuring 

the Plan of Reorganization under which bondholders 

will receive a meaningful stake in a reorganized 

GM, and our client will serve as administrator 

of the main liquidating trust . 

We represented Paulson & Co. inC. in the 

Chapter 11 bidding war and auction that resulted 

in the acquisition of the national hotel chain 

Extended Stay by Paulson, Centerbridge and 

Blackstone . 

Gibson Dunn advised the Almatis Group in its 

successful $1 billion balance sheet restructuring, 

which was effectuated through Chapter 11 

cases filed in the U .S . Bankruptcy Court for the 

Southern District of New York . We devised the 

strategy that allowed the company to keep dissenting 

U .S . and foreign debt holders in check 

while a plan of reorganization could be negotiated 

and confirmed . 

We acted as counsel to the steering committee of 

senior lenders of Trident Resources Corporation, 

a US/Canadian coal bed methane company 

with total debt in excess of $1 .2 billion . We advised 

our clients, which included anChorage 

aDvisors, CreDit suisse, restoration 

CaPital, and WhiPPoorWill assoCiates, 

in connection with their successful acquisition of 

control of Trident through a new capital investment 

and rights offering implemented pursuant 

to a Chapter 11 proceeding in Delaware and a 

CCAA proceeding in Calgary . 

We acted as counsel to the DIP lenders, including 

Farallon CaPital ManageMent, 

luxor CaPital, Canyon CaPital and 

WhiteBox aDvisors, in connection with the 

successful restructuring of GGP . Following litigation 

against the debtors, the company repaid 

the loan in cash, together with all accrued interest 

and a prepayment premium . 

We represented FleetWooD enterPrises, 

inC., a public company traded on the NYSE, 

and its 49 affiliated debtors as general insolvency 

counsel in Chapter 11 cases filed in the 

U .S . Bankruptcy Court for the Central District 

of California . 


We represent, as special reorganization 

counsel, six CMBS debtors in the station 

Casinos Chapter 11 case in Reno, NV whose 

joint plan of reorganization was confirmed in 

August 2010 . 

We represented WhiPPoorWill assoCiates 

in connection with the successful Chapter 11 

restructuring of Loehmann’s . Our client played 

the lead role in the DIP financing, exit financing 

and rights offering implemented under the plan 

of reorganization . 

We represent PriCeWaterhouseCooPers 

as liquidator of Lehman Brothers Finance . LBF 

is a member of the Lehman Brothers corporate 

family that is currently being liquidated under 

the laws of Switzerland . 

GRUPO MEXICO 

We represented BarClays CaPital inC. 

as financial advisor and investment banker to 

Asarco LLC in complex litigation regarding competing 

plans . 


We represented luxor CaPital, a major debt 

holder of California Coastal Communities, in 

connection with its successful Chapter 11 reorganization 

and advised it on the implementation 

of DIP Financing, Exit Financing and the Plan 

of Reorganization, pursuant to which Luxor acquired 

a significant share of the debt and equity 

of the reorganized company . 

We represent laW DeBenture trust 

CoMPany oF neW yorK as Indenture Trustee 

for $400 million of subordinated bonds and as 

a member of the Creditors’ Committee in the 

Southern District of New York Chapter 11 bankruptcy 

case of AMBAC, the Wisconsin-based 

bond insurer . 

We represented tBs international, ltD., 

a global maritime shipping company, in the successful 

out-of-court restructuring of its debt obligations 

and related capital infusion and rights 

offering . 

We represented aPollo CaPital 

ManageMent, llP as the largest holder 

of senior secured debt of Panavision Inc ., the 

world’s leading manufacturer and supplier of 

movie and television camera systems, in connection 

with the company’s successful out-ofcourt 

restructuring . 

We represented the Senior Lenders (including 

luxor CaPital, Mhr CaPital, WhiteBox 

aDvisors and uBs) of Comanche Clean 

Energy, a Brazilian ethanol and biodiesel manufacturer, 

in connection with an out-of-court restructuring 

of the Cayman holding company and 

Brazilian operating company debt . 

Gibson Dunn represented a supermajority of the 

holders of Pegasus’s outstanding unsecured 

notes . The successful out-of-court restructuring 

enabled Pegasus to de-lever its balance sheet 

and continue its recovery, while allowing bondholders 

to rationalize their holdings . 

Business restructuring and reorganization

transactionaL 

HigHLigHts

Mergers & Acquisitions 

Gibson Dunn’s Mergers & Acquisitions group enjoyed a banner year in 2010. Our attorneys handled over $100 

billion of transactions and played a major role in a wide range of high-profile deals. We represented some of 

the largest companies in the world in their strategic acquisitions; major U.S. companies that were acquired 

or sold substantial assets; companies that received hostile bids; and financial advisors on several of the year’s 

largest transactions. 

acquisitions 

We represented heWlett-PaCKarD 

CoMPany in its $1 .5 billion acquisition of 

ArcSight, a provider of cybersecurity and 

compliance solutions, and its $1 .2 billion 

acquisition of Palm, a provider of smartphones 

powered by the Palm webOS mobile operating 

system . 

We represented heineKen n.v. in its headlinemaking 

$7 .7 billion acquisition of FEMSA 

Cerveza, the Mexican and Brazilian beer 

operations subsidiary of Fomento Economico 

Mexicano . 


We represented Coty, inC. in the acquisition 

of OPI Products, a manufacturer and marketer 

of nail care and skin care products, and 

Philosophy, a skincare and cosmetics company . 

We represented Paulson & Co., inC. in the 

$3 .9 billion acquisition, out of bankruptcy, of 

Extended Stay, a hotel chain, by a group of investors 

including Centerbridge Partners and affiliates 

of The Blackstone Group . 

We represented st. JuDe MeDiCal, inC. 

in the $1 .3 billion acquisition of AGA Medical 

Holdings, a manufacturer of medical devices 

used to treat structural heart defects and vascular 

abnormalities . 

Mergers & acquisitions

Mergers & acquisitions 

Latin Lawyer named Heinken’s 

acquisition of FEMSA Cerveza its 

2010 M&A Deal of the Year. 

bti consulting named Washington, 

D.C. partners Dan Nelson and John 

Olson to its 2010 BTI Client Service 

All-Stars list. 

PLC Which Lawyer? 2010 named 

Gibson Dunn one of the Global 50 

in its 2010 Yearbook. Individual 

recommendations include: London 

partners James Ashe-Taylor for 

Competition/Antitrust, Cyrus Benson 

for Dispute Resolution, Thomas 

Budd for Real Estate Finance, Alan 

Samson for Real Estate and Real 

Estate Finance; Brussels partners 

Peter Alexiadis for EU Competition 

and EU Telecommunications, David 

Wood for EU Competition and Media; 

Paris partners Bernard Grinspan for 

Corporate/M&A and Ariel Harroch for 

Corporate/M&A and Private equity/ 

Buyouts; and Munich partner Benno 

Schwarz for M&A/Mid-market. 

saLe of assets 

We represented Del Monte FooDs CoMPany 

inC., a manufacturer of canned food products and 

pet food products, in its $5 .3 billion sale to an investor 

group led by funds affiliated with Kohlberg 

Kravis Roberts, Vestar Capital Partners and 

Centerview Partners . 

We represented BalDor eleCtriC CoMPany, 

a manufacturer of industrial electric motors, in its 

$4 .2 billion sale to ABB, a developer of power and 

automation technology . 

We represented CoMMsCoPe, inC., a provider of 

communications infrastructure products and services, 

in its $3 .9 billion sale to The Carlyle Group . 

defense of HostiLe bids 

We are defending tenet healthCare 

CorPoration in a $3 .8 billion unsolicited bid by 

Community Health Systems, a for-profit hospital 

company, to acquire Tenet Healthcare . 

We represented aMeriCan tire DistriButors 

holDings, inC., a wholesaler of tires, wheels, 

equipment, parts and other products to the automotive 

aftermarket, in its $1 .3 billion sale to TPG 

Capital LP, a private equity firm . 

We represented intel CorPoration in the 

$1 .3 billion sale of its minority equity interest in 

Numonyx, a provider of memory technologies 

and products, to Micron Technology, a provider of 

advanced semiconductor solutions . 

We represent the Special Committee of the Board 

of Directors of harBin eleCtriC, inC. in connection 

with a proposal to take the company private . 


financiaL advisor rePresentation 

We were counsel to golDMan saChs as financial 

advisor to Burger King in its $4 billion 

acquisition by 3G Capital; as financial advisor to 

Bare Essentials in its $1 .7 billion acquisition via 

tender offer by Shiseido, a cosmetics and skin 

care company; and ZymoGenetics in its $885 

million acquisition by Bristol-Myers . 

We were counsel to J.P. Morgan seCurities, 

inC. as financial advisor to Prudential Financial 

in its $4 .2 billion acquisition of AIG Star Life 

Insurance and AIG Edison Life Insurance from 

American International Group . 

We were counsel to CitigrouP as financial 

advisor to Astellas Pharma in its $4 billion 

acquisition of OSI Pharmaceuticals; and 

Citigroup Global Markets Inc . as financial advisor 

to Humana in its $790 million acquisition 

of Concentra . 


We were counsel to BarClays CaPital inC. 

as financial advisor to Stryker in its $1 .5 billion 

acquisition of the assets of the Neurovascular 

division of Boston Scientific . 

We were counsel to lazarD FrÈres & Co. 

as financial advisor to Alcon, a manufacturer 

of eye care products, in its $13 billion acquisition 

by Novartis, a pharmaceutical company; 

Lazard Frères & Co . and Morgan Stanley as financial 

advisors to Continental Airlines in its $3 

billion merger with United Airlines; as financial 

advisor to the Board of Directors of Protection 

One, a provider of electronic security systems, 

in its $868 million acquisition by GTCR, a private 

equity firm; and as financial advisor to 

Griffon Corporation in the $542 million acquisition 

of Ames True Temper, a manufacturer 

of non-powered lawn and garden tools, from 

Castle Harlan Partners IV . 

We were counsel to BanK oF aMeriCa as financial 

advisor to NBTY, a manufacturer of nutritional 

supplements, in its $3 .8 billion acquisition 

by The Carlyle Group . 

We were counsel to uBs investMent BanK 

as financial advisor to MSCI in its $1 .5 billion 

acquisition of Riskmetrics Group, a provider of 

risk management corporate governance services; 

and as financial advisor to Dell in its $960 

million acquisition of Compellent Technologies, 

a provider of storage solutions for enterprise 

and cloud-computing environments . 

Mergers & acquisitions

Capital Markets 


In 2010, the Gibson Dunn Capital Markets Group represented issuers and underwriters in a wide variety 

of equity and debt offerings, including IPOs and convertible notes. Some of these transactions were standalone 

financing transactions and others were conducted in connection with significant M&A or reorganization 

transactions. The variety of transactions reflects the breadth of Gibson Dunn’s capital markets experience for 

issuers in the United States and around the world. 

We represented heWlett-PaCKarD Co. in a 

$3 billion offering of floating rate global notes 

and a $2 billion offering of global notes . 

We represented golDMan saChs as underwriter 

in the $127 .2 million initial public offering 

of Financial Engines, Inc . 

We represented golDMan saChs as underwriter 

to Greenbrier Companies in a $63 million 

public offering of common stock . 

We represented toWers Watson & Co. in its 

$196 .8 million public offering of class A common 

stock . 

We represented KraFt FooDs in its $9 .5 billion 

notes offering . 

We represented Douglas DynaMiCs, inC. in 

its $112 .5 million initial public offering . 

We represented the WilliaMs CoMPanies, 

inC. in its $3 .5 billion exchange offer for debt 

securities . 

We represented WilliaMs Partners lP in 

its $600 million offering of senior notes . 

We represented WilliaMs Partners lP in 

its $392 million public offering of common units 

representing limited partner units . 

We represented J.P. Morgan seCurities, 

inC. as underwriter in Vale Overseas Limited’s 

$1 .75 billion offering of guaranteed notes . 


We represented air lease CorPoration in a 

$1 .3 billion offering of common stock as part of 

an effort to raise capital for a new aircraft leasing 

company . 

Wells Fargo 

We represented Wells Fargo & Co. as underwriter 

in a $1 .25 billion offering of medium-term 

notes by Wells Fargo & Co . 

We represented Wells Fargo seCurities, llC 

as underwriter in the $300 million offering of notes 

by AMB Property, L .P . 

We represented vallar PlC in a $1 .07 billion initial 

public offering on the London Stock Exchange . 


We represented santanDer gloBal BanKing 

& MarKets as underwriter for Vale S .A .’s 

$1 .01 billion offering of notes . 

We represented BarClays CaPital as underwriter 

in a $860 million public offering of common 

stock by MGM Resorts International . 

We represented DeutsChe BanK seCurities 

inC. as underwriter in an $849 million offering of 

warrants of Wells Fargo & Company owned by the 

U .S . Treasury . 

We represented Celanese CorPoration in its 

$600 million offering of senior notes . 

Best Lawyers named Jon Layne as its 

2011 Los Angeles Securities Lawyer 

of the Year. 

The 2011 edition of iFLR1000, a 

guide to the world’s leading financial 

law firms, recognized Gibson Dunn 

as a recommended firm in six U.S. 

categories: Capital Markets — Debt 

and Equity, Capital Markets — High 

Yield Debt, Mergers and Acquisitions, 

Private Equity — Fund Formation, 

Private Equity — Transactions, and 

Restructuring and Insolvency. Eleven 

partners were recognized as leading 

lawyers: Steven Finley, Kevin Kelley, 

and Stewart McDowell in Capital 

Markets; Barbara Becker, Ruth Fisher, 

Stephan Haimo, Jonathan Layne 

and Richard Russo in Mergers and 

Acquisitions; and Jennifer Bellah 

Maguire, Edward Nelson and 

Edward Sopher in Private Equity. 

Gibson Dunn also was recommended 

in three Western Europe categories: 

Belgium — EU Competition, 

Germany — Mergers and Acquisitions 

and UK — Bank Lending. 

Capital Markets


We represented xilinx, inC. in its $600 million 

offering of convertible senior notes . 

We represented tyCo international ltD. 

in its $500 million offering of notes . 

We represented Morgan stanley as underwriters 

in a $499 .7 million common stock offering 

by AMB Property Corporation . 

We represented transatlantiC holDings, 

inC. in its $452 million offering of common 

stock . 

telemovil Finance Co. ltd. 

We represented teleMovil FinanCe Co. 

ltD. in its $450 million offering of subordinated 

debentures . 

We represented CaDenCe Design systeMs, 

inC. in its $350 million offering of cash convertible 

senior notes . 

We represented alliant teChsysteMs in 

its $350 million offering of senior subordinated 

notes . 

We represented rBC CaPital MarKets 

CorP. as underwriter to the $300 million offering 

of convertible extendible unsecured subordinated 

debentures by Just Energy Income 

Fund . 

We represented stanDarD PaCiFiC CorP. in 

its $300 million offering of senior notes . 

We represented zayo grouP, inC. in its $250 

million offering of senior secured first-priority 

notes . 

We represented anCestry.CoM in its $99 million 

public offering of common stock . 


Global Finance 

The Global Finance Group handled a wide range of credit facilities, debt offerings, restructuring and other 

financing transactions last year. Here are some of the major credit facility matters: 

We advised Charter CoMMuniCations on 

its $4 .4 billion term loan and revolving credit 

facility . 

We advised evraz grouP s.a. on the $3 .2 

billion refinancing of its pre-export financing 

loan facility . 

We advised the WilliaMs CoMPanies, inC. 

on a $1 .75 billion senior unsecured revolving 

credit facility . 


We advised Del Monte FooDs Co. inC. on 

its $1 .1 billion revolving credit facility and term 

loan . 

We advised alliant teChsysteMs on its 

$1 billion senior secured credit facility . 

We represented JaCK in the Box inC. in a 

$600 million revolving credit facility and term 

loan . 

We represented aeCoM teChnology CorP. 

in a $600 million credit agreement . 

We represented golDMan saChs CreDit 

Partners in a $455 million senior secured 

credit facility . 

Fowler ridge Wind Farm, llC 

We represented FoWler riDge WinD FarM, 

llC in a $348 .2 million senior secured credit 

facility to finance Phase II of Fowler Ridge Wind 

Farm . 

We represented uBs investMent BanK in 

a $215 .0 million senior secured financing of 

the acquisition by Veritas Capital of certain U .S . 

and foreign assets of PerkinElmer . 

In addition, the Global Finance Group and the Capital Markets Group jointly handled the debt offerings listed 

on the foregoing pages. 

global Finance

Film 

the Hollywood Reporter named 

partners Scott Edelman, Ruth Fisher, 

Orin Snyder and Larry Ulman to 

its 2010 list of Power Lawyers: 

The 100 Most Influential Lawyers 

in Entertainment. 

Film 

acquisitions 

We represented PlayDoM inC. in its $563 million 

sale to Disney . 

We represented shaMroCK CaPital aDvisors, 

inC. in its acquisition of Screenvision Cinema 

Network LLC . 

We represented saBan CaPital grouP inC. in 

its acquisition of Paul Frank Industries, Inc . 

fiLm finance 

We represented ParaMount PiCtures in a 

$275 million investment and distribution deal with 

Skydance Productions . The first film in the slate 

was “True Grit .” 

We represented Fox FilMeD entertainMent in 

a two-year multimillion dollar extension of the Dune 

Capital Management film-slate investment deal, 

which was a result of the investors’ success in investing 

in the film “Avatar .” 

We represented Mat, a German investment fund 

affiliated with KGAL, in litigation and a bankruptcy 

proceeding involving RHI Entertainment, the bankrupt, 

and Hallmark Cards . Our client had produced 

36 films to be distributed by RHI . 


Real Estate Transactions 

Representation of alexanDria real estate 

equities in leasing the first tower of the 

Alexandria Center for Life Science — New 

York, an innovative life science research facility 

in Manhattan, to tenants, including Pfizer, New 

York University and Kadmon Pharmaceutical, 

as well as Tom Colicchio’s acclaimed Riverpark 

restaurant . 

Alexandria Center for Life Science 


Representation of DeutsChe BanK in acquiring 

a defaulted $250 million mortgage loan secured 

by a high-profile development site opposite 

the Time Warner Center, then creating and 

selling a participation agreement in the loan 

to The Related Companies and documenting 

mortgage financing for potential redevelopment 

of the site . 

Representation of Paulson & Co. inC. in the 

$3 .925 billion acquisition, out of bankruptcy, 

of Extended Stay, a hotel chain, by a group 

of investors that also included Centerbridge 

Partners and affiliates of The Blackstone Group . 

Representation of FelCor, a national hotel 

REIT, in connection with their acquisition of the 

Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel, in negotiating a 

long-term management agreement with Fairmont 

Hotels for this landmark Boston property . 

Representation of WCl grouP, a British private 

schools’ group, in the development of for-profit 

elementary and secondary schools, including 

the establishment of their first school in New 

York City . 

Representation of virgin grouP, in the creation 

of a new hotel chain that plans to acquire 

over 25 hotels in the United States over the next 

seven years . 

Representation of sol Melia, s.a., a Spanish 

operator of global hotel brands, in the sale and 

leaseback of their Tryp brand, with over 14,000 

rooms, to Wyndham hotels . 

real estate transactions

eal estate transactions 

Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel 

Representation of JDM Partners in the purchase 

from Citibank of a defaulted mortgage 

loan on the Wigwam Hotel and the Biltmore 

golf courses in Phoenix and the acquisition of 

title to the assets through a bankruptcy auction 

process . 

Representation of roCKPoint grouP: 

In connection with the acquisition and complete 

renovation of the shuttered, legendary 1,300 

room Milford Plaza Hotel on Eighth Avenue in 

Manhattan . 

In the acquisition of a joint-control equity interest 

in Manhattan’s Park avenue Plaza, with the remaining 

interest owned by the Fisher Brothers . 

In the recapitalization of the debt, common equity 

and preferred equity of one of the largest 

multi-family projects in the United States . 

Representation of neWlanD international 

ProPerties CorP., a Panamanian real estate 

development company developing the Trump 

Ocean Club International Hotel & Tower in 

Panama City, Panama . Financing for the Trump 

Ocean Club was obtained through the issuance 

of $220 million of 9 .5 percent Senior Secured 

Notes . 

Representation of investCorP in the capital 

restructuring for the W South Beach (Florida), 

an ocean-front hotel with 334 rooms and bungalows 

with retail stores and restaurants . 

Park Avenue Plaza 


gLobaL

europe 

The 2010 edition of UK Legal 500 

recommended our London office in a 

variety of specialist areas, including: 

Mergers and Acquisitions, Flotations: 

Small and Mid-cap, Private Equity, 

Commercial Property, Commercial 

Property: Hotels, Property Finance, 

Commercial Litigation, Corporate 

Restructuring and Insolvency, 

International Arbitration 

and Employment. 

Chambers UK 2011 awarded Gibson 

Dunn 11 rankings: Cyrus Benson in 

Dispute Resolution: International 

Arbitration: London; Tom Budd in 

Real Estate Finance: London; Gregory 

Campbell in Restructuring/Insolvency: 

London; James Cox in Employment: 

Employer — London & UK-wide; 

Kenneth Lamb in Private Equity: 

Buyouts — UK-wide; and Alan Samson 

in Real Estate: London, Real Estate 

Finance: London, and Real Estate: 

Hotels & Leisure: London. 

The 2010 edition of Legal 500 eMeA 

ranks the Munich office for M&A: 

Mid-sized deals in Germany, the 

Brussels office for Competition, 

and the Paris office for Mergers & 

Acquisitions, Insolvency, Private 

Equity, Administrative & Public 

Law and Tax. 

Europe 

In 2010, our Brussels, Munich, London, and Paris offices advised clients 

in a wide variety of areas, including antitrust, capital markets, compliance, 

employment, financing, mergers and acquisitions, real estate and restructuring. 

Our UK Dispute Resolution Group focused on resolving complex matters 

by developing effective commercial solutions, and, if the circumstances 

demanded it, through commercial litigation, international arbitration 

or mediation. 

We represented intel CorPoration in the 

$1 .27 billion sale of its minority interest in Numonyx, 

a provider of memory technologies and products, to 

Micron Technology . 

We represented the inDian FilM CoMPany 

liMiteD in the recommended £63 .5 million offer 

by Roptonal Ltd, a 50-50 joint venture between 

Viacom and Network 18 . 

We represented PaCe PlC in its $475 million acquisition 

of 2Wire, Inc ., a provider of advanced 

residential gateways and associated software and 

services . 

We represented ses in its $1 .2 billion equity 

financing for 03b Networks . 

We acted as counsel to vallar PlC in its $1 .07 

billion initial public offering on the London Stock 

Exchange . 

We represented evraz grouP s.a. in the $3 .214 

billion refinancing of its PXF structured facility . 


We were counsel to houlihan loKey as financial 

advisor to the Board of Directors of Invitel 

Holdings, a telecommunications and internet 

service provider, in its tender offer acquisition 

by Mid Europa Partners, a private equity firm . 

We represented area ProPerty Partners 

in a joint venture with Heron International to develop 

and finance a 38-story mixed-use development 

in the City of London . 

We represented telePo aB in securing a 

€12 .6 million Series B investment from Investor 

Growth Capital and existing investor Accel 

Partners . 

We represented M8 CaPital FunD i l.P. in 

its $4 .2 million A-round investment in SCHAD 

GmbH . 


We represented exPro international 

grouP ltD. in its $120 million acquisition of 

the Production Testers International business, 

a leading well services business providing fast 

track production systems to the upstream oil 

and gas industry, based in Asia . 

We represented aPax in the sale, alongside 

Altamir Amboise, of their stake in the biotechnology 

company Galapagos . 

We represented BCBg Max azria in its acquisition 

of Karstadt AG, a German department 

store chain, with strategic partner Berggruen 

Holdings . 

We represented elliott aDvisors uK 

liMiteD in its $1 .1 billion sale of its interest 

in Autoroutes Paris-Rhin-Rhome (APRR) to 

Eiffarie, a provider of construction and concession 

services . 

We represented itron in its acquisition of AsaÏs . 

We represented KuWait investMent 

authority in its €600 million subscription 

to the €900 million capital increase of Areva . 

The remaining amount was subscribed by the 

French State . 

We represented vivenDi in its €45 million acquisition 

of Digitick SA, a developer of ticketing 

internet software for event organizers . 

We represented yeMen airlines in the $700 

million acquisition of 10 Airbus A320 aircraft 

from Airbus . 

We represented CoMMsCoPe, inC., a provider 

of communications infrastructure products and 

service, as antitrust counsel in its $3 .9 billion 

acquisition by The Carlyle Group . 

europe

europe 

Chambers europe 2010 awarded 

Gibson Dunn 12 rankings, seven 

individual rankings and five practice 

group rankings. The Firm was 

recommended for Competition/ 

European Law and TMT in Belgium, 

Corporate/M&A and Tax in France, and 

Corporate/M&A: Highly Regarded in 

Germany. The recommended partners 

are Peter Alexiadis, Nicolas Baverez, 

Benoit Fleury, Ariel Harroch and 

David Wood. 

the Belgian Legal Awards has 

nominated the Brussels team for 

TMT Law Firm of the Year from 

2006 to 2011. 

The German publication JUVe 

recognized the Munich office in the 

2010/2011 edition of its annual 

Handbook in the South/Munich 

region, M&A, Corporate and 

Antitrust categories. 

We represented alMatis grouP in its $1 billion 

Chapter 11 restructuring . 

We represented roCKPoint grouP llC in its 

$51 .5 million joint venture with Westmont Hospitality 

to acquire and finance the Renaissance Le Parc 

Trocadero Hotel, Paris . 

We represented MeaDoW Partners in its acquisition 

of a UK office building (leased to Sun Life) 

with financing from Nationwide . 

We represented DeveloPMent seCurities PlC 

in a £62 .2 million joint venture with Patron Capital 

to acquire and finance the Manchester Evening 

News Arena . 

We represented lehMan Brothers holDing, 

inC. in a joint venture with Resolution Property to 

acquire a senior loan secured by a first charge on 

the Queensbridge House . 

We were antitrust counsel to energizer 

holDing, inC. in obtaining approval from the 

German Federal Cartel Office for the acquisition of 

American Safety Razor . 

We represented ChungWa PiCture tuBes, 

ltD. before the European Commission and national 

competition authorities in relation to the cartel investigations 

in the TV and LCD sectors . 

We represented MiCrosoFt in relation to online 

competition issues . 


Middle East 

The Dubai office serves our many clients in the Middle East, as well as U.S., European, Asian and other 

companies doing business in the Gulf. In 2010, we advised sovereign wealth funds, local companies, and 

commercial and investment banks. 

RECREATED LOGO 

We advised orBit shoWtiMe netWorK on 

strategic matters . 

We advised investCorP on capital-raising initiatives 

and its private equity investment activities 

. 

We represent gulF CaPital in the acquisition 

of a majority interest in TechnoScan and 

Consultant Radiology Centres, the Middle East’s 

largest chain of diagnostic imaging centers . 


We represent invest aD in connection with its 

MENA Buyout Fund II . 

We are advising aBu DhaBi retireMent 

Pensions anD BeneFits FunD in connection 

with its global investment program . 

We are advising Waha CaPital in connection 

with global fund-raising initiatives . 

We are advising MuMtalaKat, the Bahrain 

sovereign wealth fund, in connection with its 

strategic assets . 

We advised eastgate on its portfolio restructuring 

and fundraising initiatives . 

We are advising Metito, the region’s largest 

water and wastewater treatment company, in 

connection with its fundraising activities and 

acquisitions . 

Middle east

Middle east 

Chambers Global 2010 recommends 

Gibson Dunn’s Middle East practice 

in the fields of Corporate/Commercial 

and Investment Funds and our 

UAE practice in the field of 

Corporate/Commercial. 

Legal 500 eMeA 2010 ranks our 

Dubai office as a leading player 

in the field of Corporate/M&A and 

Investment Funds. 

We represented the Carlyle grouP in the leveraged 

acquisition of a 30 percent stake in Saudi 

company General Lighting Company . 

Bank 

We are advising aDDax BanK in connection with 

its portfolio investments . 

We represented KuWait investMent 

authority on its global investments, including 

its role as a cornerstone investor in the AIA and 

AgBank public offerings in Hong Kong . 

We are advising arCaPita in connection with global 

fundraising initiatives . 

We are advising MarKaz in connection with fund 

raising initiatives and global investments . 

We advised the FaMily oFFiCe on the establishment 

of a real estate investment program . 

We advised oasis CaPital BanK with respect to 

the structuring of their investment in Capital Spring . 


Asia 

Marking a major expansion of its presence in the Asia market, Gibson Dunn opened its Hong Kong office on 

August 1. Joining the Singapore office, which opened in 2008, the Hong Kong office focuses on corporate 

transactions and corporate compliance, regulation and investigations. Together, the two offices have the 

capacity to handle the most challenging and substantial transactions in Asia, including cross-border Mergers 

& Acquisitions, Energy & Infrastructure finance, real estate, private equity, capital markets transactions, and 

finance and restructurings. 

Bio*one CaPital Pte ltD 

We advised Bio*one CaPital Pte ltD in its 

Series D investment into TriReme Medical, a 

developer and manufacturer of medical devices 

for the treatment of coronary and peripheral arterial 

disease . 

We (with our Munich office) advised eDB 

investMents Pte ltD in its investment in 

Triton Water, the leading provider of complete 

water-cycle industrial and maritime water 

treatment solutions . The investment will support 

Triton’s strategy to establish a presence in 

Southeast Asia . 


We advised Expro Group on its $120 million 

acquisition of Asia-based Production Testers 

International, a leading well services business . 

We advised lehMan Brothers 

CoMMerCial CorP. asia liMiteD (in liquidation) 

in restructurings and workouts of financings 

for dozens of projects in Thailand . 

We represented sPiCe gloBal holDings in 

the formation of Spice i2i (formerly MediaRing 

Ltd .), a joint venture with Dato Eric Chuah, and 

the acquisition of certain assets of the CSL 

group of companies . 

We counseled the Brunei eConoMiC 

DeveloPMent BoarD in connection with 

the award of the contract for the construction 

of 4,000 houses to be built in 48 months under 

Brunei’s National Housing Scheme . 

We represented vitol in connection with a 

joint venture with MISC Berhad, a subsidiary of 

Petronas, the Malaysian national oil company, 

to manage the construction, commissioning 

and operation of an initial phase oil blending 

terminal . 

asia

asia 

Chambers Asia Pacific 2011 ranks 

the Singapore office in the top-tier 

in the category of Brunei — General 

Business Law: Overseas Counsel and 

recommends us in the following fields: 

Capital Markets, Corporate/M&A, 

and Projects & Energy. Emad Khalil 

is recognized as a leading lawyer 

in Singapore — Capital Markets 

and Projects & Energy. Jai Pathak 

is recognized as a leading lawyer in 

India and Singapore for Corporate/ 

M&A. Saptak Santra is recognized as 

a leading lawyer Corporate/M&A. 

The Legal 500 Asia Pacific 2010/2011 

ranks our Singapore office in Projects 

and Energy, Banking and Finance, 

Capital Markets: Foreign Firms, 

Corporate and M&A and Restructuring 

and Insolvency. Emad Khalil was 

named a Leading Individual in the 

Singapore: Projects and Energy: Local 

Firms category. 


neW 

Partners

New Partners 

Promoted Partners 

JESSE CRIPPS DAvID DEBOLD 

HOWARD HOGAN JASON LO AUSTIN SCHWING 

ROBYN ZOLMAN 

Jesse criPPs — Los angeLes 

Jesse Cripps practices in the areas of labor and 

employment and general commercial litigation . 

His successes include defeating collective action 

certification of a nationwide class under the Fair 

Labor Standards Act and securing the dismissal of 

state law class action claims without any discovery 

having taken place . In addition to his employment 

practice, Mr . Cripps has represented clients 

in a variety of commercial disputes . Mr . Cripps is 

a member of the Firm’s Hiring Committee . 

david deboLd — WasHington, d.c. 

David Debold has represented individuals and 

businesses in a wide variety of matters, including 

major SEC enforcement actions and investigations, 

Foreign Corrupt Practices Act allegations, 

internal investigations and federal criminal investigations 

and prosecutions . Prior to joining the 

Firm, Mr . Debold served as an Assistant United 

States Attorney in Detroit, where he was as a 

member of the office’s Criminal Trial and Appellate 

Divisions . He also acted as Special Counsel to the 

Sentencing Commission . Mr . Debold served as 

a law clerk to Judge Cornelia G . Kennedy of the 

U .S . Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit . 

HoWard Hogan — WasHington, d.c. 

Howard Hogan’s practice focuses on intellectual 

property litigation and counseling, including 

trademark, copyright, patent, false advertising, 

right of publicity, licensing, and trade secret 

matters . He has represented various corporations 

and individuals in a broad range of industries, and 

a significant portion of his practice involves computer, 

Internet, and new media-related issues . 

Mr . Hogan served as law clerk to Judge Naomi 

Reice Buchwald of the U .S . District Court for the 

Southern District of New York . 

Jason Lo — Los angeLes 

Jason Lo practices intellectual property law with 

a focus on patent and trade secrets litigation . He 

has successfully represented leading companies 

in various industries, including the video game, 

semiconductor, military defense, and pharmaceutical 

industries . He has litigated high-stakes 

patent infringement cases in courts throughout 

the United States, as well as the U .S . International 

Trade Commission . Mr . Lo served as a law clerk 

to Judge Mariana R . Pfaelzer of the U .S . District 

Court for the Central District of California . 

austin scHWing — san francisco 

Austin Schwing has substantial experience 

with complex commercial litigation, including 

consumer and antitrust litigation . His litigation 

and counseling experience includes work for 

companies in the retail, professional service, 

manufacturing, energy, health care, hightechnology, 

and defense industries . Mr . Schwing 

is a member of Gibson Dunn’s National Pro Bono 

Committee . He coordinates pro bono work in 

the San Francisco office and serves as a liaison 

between the Firm and nonprofit organizations . 

robyn zoLman — denver 

Robyn Zolman’s practice is concentrated 

in securities regulation and capital markets 

transactions . She represents clients in connection 

with public and private offerings of equity and 

debt securities, including investment grade, 

high yield and convertible debt offerings . She 

also represents clients in connection with tender 

offers, exchange offers, consent solicitations and 

corporate restructurings . 


Lateral Partners 

KELLY AUSTIN ANDRéS FONT GALARZA JAMES HO 

STEPHEN NORDAHL JEFFERY ROBERTS 

keLLy austin — Hong kong 

Kelly Austin’s practice focuses on government 

investigations, regulatory compliance and international 

disputes . She has extensive expertise in 

corporate internal investigations, including those 

involving the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, and in 

creating effective compliance programs . Prior to joining 

the Firm, Ms . Austin served as the Compliance 

and Litigation Counsel for General Electric in Asia . 

Before moving to Hong Kong, she served as Special 

Counsel to the Executive Office of the President . 

She also clerked for Judge Boyce F . Martin Jr . of the 

U . S . Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit . 

andrés font gaLarza — brusseLs 

Andrés Font Galarza’s practice encompasses antitrust 

issues relating to mergers, joint ventures, 

distribution issues, IP, the abuse of dominance 

and cartels . In addition, he provides strategic and 

policy advice to clients in regulatory matters affecting 

sectors such as the Internet, consumer goods 

brands, pharmaceuticals, health and food, energy 

and the EU internal market freedoms . Prior to 

joining the Firm, Mr . Font Galarza spent 15 years 

as a senior official of the European Commission . 


James Ho — daLLas 

James Ho rejoined the Firm after serving for 

the past three years as the Solicitor General of 

Texas . He will continue to focus on complex 

appellate, constitutional and business litigation . 

Ho has served in all three branches of the federal 

government . He served on the Senate Judiciary 

Committee as chief counsel to Senator John 

Cornyn of Texas; the Justice Department in 

both the Civil Rights Division and the Office of 

Legal Counsel; and clerked for Justice Clarence 

Thomas of the U .S . Supreme Court and Judge 

Jerry E . Smith of the U .S . Court of Appeals for 

the Fifth Circuit . 

stePHen nordaHL — neW york 

Steve Nordahl, a member of the Outsourcing 

Transactions Practice, focuses on information 

technology, business process and asset management 

outsourcing transactions, and commercial 

and other technology-related transactions, as 

well as joint ventures and strategic alliances, in 

each case, with a particular focus on complex 

international transactions . 

Jeffery roberts — London 

Jeffery Roberts has a broad corporate 

transactional practice that includes public and 

private M&A, private equity and equity capital 

markets and joint venture transactions both in 

the UK and across borders . He has significant 

experience representing multinational companies 

and financial sponsors . Prior to joining the 

Firm, Mr . Roberts was a partner at Freshfields 

Bruckhaus Deringer, where he managed the 

Moscow office from 1996 to 1999 . 

New Partners

diversity 

Pro bono

Diversity 

We will deliver the highest-quality legal services by fostering a culturally fluent, inclusive and open environment 

that welcomes individuals from diverse backgrounds and with different perspectives to achieve Gibson Dunn’s 

core values of excellence, fairness and individuality. 

— Gibson Dunn Diversity Vision Statement 


This year we reaffirmed our commitment to diversity by implementing a new action plan . We restructured our 

committee structures, instituted a dedicated diversity budget, updated our policy on flex-time and through 

the Professional Development Department, educated our U .S . offices during a national Flex-Time Roadshow . 

With a new plan in hand, we now have clear goals . They include developing initiatives to increase the retention 

and promotion of diverse attorneys, pursuing strategic collaborations with clients and organizations, and 

increasing the involvement of the entire Gibson Dunn community in the Firm’s diversity efforts . 

We also welcomed our new Chief Diversity Officer, Zakiyyah Salim-Williams . Zakiyyah was most recently 

Director of Diversity with the Association of the Bar of the City of New York’s Office for Diversity, where 

she developed diversity programming and counseled attorneys on career development . She received the 

Diversity Champion Award from the City Bar in 2007 . We also hired Vicenta Arrizon Maffris as the Diversity & 

Professional Development Coordinator to ensure coordination between the two departments . 

BarBara l. BeCKer 

Chair, Firm-wide Diversity Committee 

Diversity

Pro Bono 

Pro Bono 

Gibson Dunn continued its long tradition of service 

to the community this year by providing muchneeded 

pro bono legal services on a wide variety 

of matters . Our pro bono commitment increased 

across the board: not only did our total number of 

hours increase over 9 percent from last year, the 

number of hours per attorney and the number of 

attorneys performing more than 120 hours of pro 

bono work also increased . 

Each year, we honor the pro bono work of our attorneys 

and staff by giving the Frank Wheat Award 

to one team and one individual . We also recognize 

the extraordinary efforts of the nominees . The 

Frank Wheat Memorial Award is given to the lawyer 

or group of lawyers who have demonstrated leadership 

and initiative in their pro bono work, obtained 

significant results for their clients, and served as an 

inspiration to others . 

This year the Firm is pleased to give the team 

award to the Los Angeles attorneys who served as 

pro bono counsel to the Tejon Ranch Conservancy, 

one of the most valuable conservation properties in 

California, in its purchase of perpetual easements 

across 62,000 acres of wildlife habitat . Our individual 

winner is Katie Marquart in the Los Angeles 

office, who successfully sued to restore state funding 

for therapy for autistic children . 

This year’s nominees for the team award provided 

diverse and successful representation . Denver attorneys 

obtained the cancellation of a “steer-tailing” 

event after a previous one ended with the death of 

two animals . New York attorneys filed a civil rights 

action in Connecticut on behalf of immigrant day 

laborers who were subjected to improper profiling 

tactics . Palo Alto attorneys successfully represented 

a resident alien who had originally been ordered 

removed by the immigration courts to El Salvador, 

bringing three years of imprisonment to an end . 

Individual nominee Quincy Lu of the Palo Alto office 

helped a young man obtain guardianship over 

his teenage brother and also worked on an asylum 

case for a man who fled ethnic violence in the 

Democratic Republic of Congo . Akiva Shapiro of 

the New York office worked on a number of significant 

pro bono cases involving such issues as 

the right to effective assistance of counsel, religious 

freedoms, immigration rights and voter rights . 

Recipients of the Frank Wheat Award receive a 

$2,500 prize, which will be donated to a pro bono 


organization or organizations designated by the recipients 

. The award honors Frank Wheat, who founded the 

Alliance for Children’s Rights, was a founder and trustee 

of the Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund, was a leader of 

the Sierra Club, and a board member of the Center for 

Law in the Public Interest, which established a fellowship 

in his name to train young lawyers in public interest 

litigation . 

We are proud of our pro bono achievements in 2010 and 

anticipate the same level of dedication in serving the underserved 

in the coming year . 

sCott eDelMan 

national Pro Bono Chair 


the national Legal aid & defender 

association awarded its Beacon of 

Justice Award to Gibson Dunn for 

extraordinary commitment to pro bono 

legal representation in the area of 

immigration law. 

Public counsel’s children’s rights 

Project named John Sharer and Katie 

Marquart the 2010 volunteers of the 

Year for their work on restoring state 

funding to children with autism. 

sanctuary for families honored New 

York associates Tyler Amass, Kristen 

Hendricks, and Kristen Mathews 

with its Award for Excellence in Pro 

Bono Advocacy for their legal work on 

behalf of Sanctuary clients. 

Number of pro bono 

hours by lawyers in our 

U .S . offices: 

123,296 

Number of pro bono 

hours per attorney: 

132 

Number of U .S . attorneys 

who performed more 

than 20 hours of 

pro bono work: 

665 

Pro Bono

Frank Wheat awards 

Frank Wheat Awards 

TOM MCHENRY EDUARDO CARvAJAL DOUG CHAMPION SARAH GARBER 

JANNA BOELKE 

MIKE SZCZUREK CLAIRE vIGIL 

team Winner 

teJon rancH conservancy 

Gibson Dunn serves as pro bono counsel to the Tejon Ranch 

Conservancy . The Conservancy is charged with managing the conservation 

values on one of the largest and most valuable conservation 

properties in California . Tejon Ranch conservation has great significance 

due to the intersection of four ecological regions and the wildlife 

linkage functions the Ranch provides . The Conservancy’s mission is to 

preserve, enhance and restore the native biodiversity and ecosystem 

values of the Tejon Ranch and the Tehachapi Range for the benefit 

of California’s future generations . Among many notable features, the 

Tejon Ranch includes habitat for the endangered California condor . 

The Conservancy was created as part of the Tejon Ranch Conservation 

and Land Use Agreement (the “Ranchwide Agreement”), which was 

signed in 2008 by the Tejon Ranch Company, Audubon California, 

Endangered Habitats League, Natural Resources Defense Council, 

Planning and Conservation League and Sierra Club . The Conservancy 

is a qualified 501(c)(3) organization overseen by an independent 

Board of Directors that includes leaders from the environmental community, 

the Tejon Ranch Company and their development partners, 

academia, business and government . Pursuant to the Ranchwide 

Agreement, environmental groups obtained a binding commitment 

from the Tejon Ranch Company to protect up to 240,000 acres of 

the Tejon Ranch in advance of the Tejon Ranch Company’s proposed 

development projects in the years ahead . The Ranchwide Agreement 

created the Conservancy to be an effective steward of the conserved 

lands . The Ranchwide Agreement balances sustainable development 

on the Tejon Ranch with the preservation of the land’s conservation 

values and will, it is hoped, serve as a nationwide model for cooperative 

conservation and land use planning . 

Gibson Dunn reached a milestone in its representation of the 

Conservancy when, after months of extensive work, the California 

Wildlife Conservation Board on November 18, 2010, approved $15 .8 

million in state funding for the Conservancy’s purchase of perpetual 

conservation easements across 62,000 acres of significant wildlife 

habitat on the Tejon Ranch . The acquisition closed on February 28, 

2011, and the Conservancy now holds some of the largest conservation 

easements in California . 


individuaL Winner 

katie marquart, Los angeLes 


Katie obtained a preliminary injunction on behalf of a group of autistic children to restore funding for their treatment 

after it was terminated during California’s economic crisis . Children in California diagnosed with autism 

are eligible to receive state-funded services from regional centers under the Lanterman Act . However, last 

summer, the legislature cut funding for experimental therapies under the Trailer bill, and the East Los Angeles 

Regional Center (ELARC) threatened to cut off floor-time therapy . This therapy, known as Developmental, 

Individual Difference, Relationship-based treatment, makes a critical difference in children’s lives — in some 

cases enabling them to speak and play with others for the first time . 

After reviewing the Lanterman Act and the Trailer Bill, Katie concluded that the actions taken by ELARC violated 

California law because the autism treatment programs were not experimental, but in fact well-established . 

ELARC’s action forced all parents in the area to use one type of treatment, which simply did not work for many 

of these children . In January, Gibson Dunn and co-counsel Public Counsel sued on behalf of a class of 2,300 

autistic children, alleging that ELARC misapplied the Trailer Bill and was violating the class plaintiffs’ rights 

under the Lanterman Act and their due process and equal protection rights under the California Constitution . 

In June, Katie prevailed at a two-day hearing on a motion for preliminary injunction . Within five days, services 

were reinstated for the children . The very favorable settlement agreement that followed provided that 

all the services would be reinstated and it also put in place monitoring provisions to ensure that the children 

remain protected . 

Katie was supervised by retired partner John Sharer . First-year associates Colin Fraser, Abbey Hudson, 

Eric Ideta, and Justin Burden provided support . 

Frank Wheat awards

www.gibsondunn.com 

Brussels � Century City � Dallas � Denver � Dubai � Hong Kong � London � Los Angeles � Munich � New York 

Orange County � Palo Alto � Paris � San Francisco � São Paulo � Singapore � Washington, D.C.

Gibson Dunn 2010 Annual Review - Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?