learning from human and robot teachers Monica N - USC Robotics ...

,XZF¾79TS½Ÿb!¾j[FTJFHJFÜaK[F8ERS:=>9D,»Fj;>|daÀ
RJj;F»`Fj;>|dÆ:G7ETPÀ‘»;>EHPFIL¨ikT
>ORJj;FTRSj;>,8
:=79T¨:CHK`HPK;>9DGD=f0RSTJ:=º9FTJTSFL©RSj[TJ7EK[º9jRSj[F2¾79TSD=L#b;T
RJj;TJ7EK[º9j¤:G8aRSFTS8;>,D#HJFÜaK[F8;,TSDGfhFÐ[>,XZY[D=F79i¦FXB»FL[L\:=8[ºZTSFY[TSFHJF8aRS>,RJ:=7980:=8aRJ7
4
>,DCHP7EH…L\798[F5»afZÕGÖ9֋בA¦¹†j[F5TJFY[TJFIHPF8aRS>ORS:G7E8_¾†>9H
Xh>,8[:=Y[K[DC>ORS:G7E8#A
TS79»7,R&DGFI>,TS8[:=8[º;b
Ñœ8ÈRJj;FÌ|dÆ:=79TJÀˆ»`>9HJFL
j[FH j;>|d9F¡»`FF8Z>ORRJj[F†D=Fd9FDÆ7,i;D=F>9TJ8[:=8[ºỲ 7EDG:GÀ
XZ7EHPR>9Y[Y[TS7E>E<
RSj[FÉ9< j[:=8[º¢»Æf”L[FXZ798;HPRJT >ORS:G7E8#b0Õsë×
ќ8
>ORJFIL¢HP:=XZY[D=:eÍ;FIL°Xh>!5F­D=F>9TJ8[:=8[º¢Ò§:zA F9A=bD=F>9TJ8;:G8[º
L\FX7E8;HPRJT
L…b D=F!iwRIb>,8;LÄTS:GºEjaR2RJK[TS8[:=8[ºM»Fj;>|dÆ:=79T HSÔ!A¦ÕGÖ“È|×K;HJFL
ik79TS¾†>,T
RJ:=798¿DGFd9FD¤ÒkTSFHJK[DGRJFIL&:G8¿TJFI>9ORS:G8[º&j;:GºEj\ÀˆD=FdEFD
98;LËTJFỲ
S 79T­,8;L
,Y[Y;TJ7a>9< jRJ7_DGFI>,TS8[:G8;º†ikTJ7EX”jÆK[Xh>9879T
4
>ORS:G7E8;H#¾j;:=< j>,DCHP7>EL[L\TSFHSHPFIH…RSj[F¡Y;TJ7E»[DGFX
TS79»7,RL[FXZ798;HPRJT
Õ׈A2¹†j;F>9TS< j[:GRJFI9TJ8Z>¤d97\9»[K[DC>,TSf7,iÃÞP¾79T L[H§ß
RJK;TJF¨>9DGD=7O¾¨HRJj[FTS79»7,R
H#:=8¤RJj[F¡F8ÆdÆ:GTS798;XF8aR#79T
TSFY[TSFHJF8aRJ:=8[ºY[TS79YFTJRJ:=FH#7,i[79»[NgFOR>,D=DG7O¾¨H>2TS79»7,R¡RJ7BD=F>9TJ8
ǦF_Y[TSFHJF8aRSFL0>98©>,Y;Y[TJ7a>9<
r ;Æ´ t ; p õ;6†;
ú'ûÃü —0ý—`¥ƒz–{~vE—hþÿ¡ £¢¥¤§¦©¨¡ þ¢'ÿ¨¨¦§‘—¤uw¨`ƒˆ‚g}ˆ}Pž^ýŸ¥¡ž
ù
ú ! —
ù "§û ¥5—$#Ÿ{~Œ~Œ € ƒˆ‡_€ v|‡&%—$'€ •Ixˆ‚gv|y|€ y|va—)(ƒˆ‰‹•|vI‡|{~v|’g‰‹•|vI{~J€Sxz{~‰‹v
•Ixˆ‰‹vI‰‹‰‹•|}ƒz‰‹Š9‰ xz}§*\€ v†‚œ›I,‚gƒˆ{~‚gv!x‘€ Œ|}§xˆ•I‡£+!—,¨¨¦§-¢.$
{~v€
¨¥.$¨12¨ 0 4365Nÿ§1798:3;Bÿ§¦¢=¡ 0 ÿ&¨.3§¦ÿ§.@¦ ABC1Àÿ§ £¨ ¥
/)0
¦D< ÿ79¨¨¦§ˆž "GF * ú " * H úI H ž ú ! —
¦D.&1E¨
ú H—
S§û2d —e(€SxJ—^fv.xzy|ƒˆ‚g‚œwŒ € +!‚gƒ€ ƒˆ‘y|{ xz‚gœxˆ•|ƒz‚g}J—2uwvg'¡—h%‰‹ƒzxz‚PvI– € až
ù
—6;—,#Ÿ‰‹v|vO€ }z}ˆ‰|ž[€ v|‡ ü —i¤•|ƒz|y¥+ža‚g‡|{ xˆ‰‹ƒz}Jž / ¡©¦ AB ¦©¢¤X:CL[L\D=F
#«ŽJ¡&F&¥]'I$
DC>|f9FTRS72HP7EDGdEF5RSj[FL\:FTJF8;,RJ:=798.>98;LBRJ:=XFÀ
>9,D=FHŸ»F!Rg¾FF8¤RJj[F5Y[jÆfÆHJ:C,D,>98;LRJj;F5>,»;HPRJT
Y[TSFHJF8aRSFLÙ>98¿798[ÀˆD=:G8;F©>,D=º97ETJ:GRJj;X
RSj;>ORZK;HJFHBRJj[F¤»`F8[F!Í;RSH
>ORJ:=798¿RJ7&>,D=D=7O¾ÅRJj[FTS79»7,RZRJ7
79i_RSj[:=HZ»Fj`>|da:=79TZTSFY[TSFHJF8aR
>ORS:G7E8;HbIFdEF8BikTJ7EXÃ>HJ:G8[ºEDGF
D=F>9TJ8.j[:GºEj\À‘DGFd9FDERS>EHP½TSFY;TJFIHPF8ER
< j[:GRJFI9< j[:=FdEFH RJj[:CHºE7E>,DaK;HJ:G8;º»Fj`>|da:=79T H¾:eRSjBRSj[F
>,T
HS>,XZF¤TJFY[TJFIHPF8aRS>ORS:G7E8©>98;L0RS:GXZF2HS9DGFEA
>ORS:G7E8#Ä ¹†j[FBFÐ\Ỳ FTJ:=XZF8aRS>9D TSFHJK[DeR HL\FXZ798;HPRJT >ORSF
L\FXZ798;HPRJT
RSj[FÛ;F!Ð\:=»[:GD=:GRgfZ>98;L0TS79»;K;HgRS8[FHSH¡7,i…RJj;F>9DGºE79TS:eRSj[XÅ>,8;LhdO>9DeÀ
j[:GRJFIORSF¤RJj[FTSFD=:C>,»[D=F¤F!ÐÆRJF8;HP:=798`H†79K[T¨>9TS<
Ó†Ó†]…A RgfÆY[:C9D
HPRJTSK;|dÆ:G7ETSHb…>,8;LÁ¾†>9HK;HJFLÁF!Ð[,Y[Y;:G8[º©>,8;LY;>,RJjMY;D=>98[8[:=8[º;AÇ¢j[:=D=F2RJj;F.>,Y;Y[TJ7a>9<
:G8aRJ7>Ó†Ó]Ÿb
,RJFIH#L\FD=:=»`FTS>,RJ:=d9F¡,Y;>9»[:=DG:GRJ:=FH
:GR:CH5D=:=X:GRJFILhRS72RJj;F_8;>|dÆ:=ºE>,RJ:=798ZRS>EHP½Ÿba¾j[:=DGF_79K[TTJFY[TSFHJF8\À
RS>,RJ:=798;H¤>,TSFMXZF>98aRšRJ7¿»`FÁRS>EHP½aÀ‘:G8;L[FYF8;L\F8aR¤>,8`L°,D»Fj;>|dÆ:=79T HTJFY[TJFIHPF8aRJ:=8[ºšRSj[FhTS79»7,RBŒ H
FX.»`FILÄ>,8ÆfMº9F8[FT
9Y;>,»;:GD=:eRS:GFIH¥8¤:=8É7EK[Th9HJF9b5»`79RJjË8;>|dÆ:Gºa>ORJ:=798É>,8;LÉ79»\NgFI]‚@y¢.@¡¢¥§¦¨.@)¨.ƒ¨¨¦§¢.$
‡|‰‹¨€ {~vE— /:0 P¨.$¨1E¨ 0 :¨¨ˆž F ® ú ¯* H J§IX!J ž ú H—
j[FT>98;L.RJj[FD=F>9TJ8;FT>,8;L
>99TJFIL2»F!Rg¾FF8RSj[F†RJFI>9<
jöÞJ¾¡7ETSL[H§ß[A Ç Ff_L\:ŸFTSF8;,DCHJ7†RJ7D=F>,TS8HPFIÜaK[F8;9TJF_RJj`>ORRJj;FTSFY;TJFIHPF8ER >ORS:G7E8;HF8;|da:=79T HT >ORSj[FT¤RSj;>,8
79K;TB>,T < j[:GRJF,TSFh»[K[:=DGRBikTS79X
’‹‚gŒ~‚g}Jž$ý#€ Œ~{ G‰‹ƒˆvI{ €Iž "WWW —
>,8;LÁ>,DCHP7©RJj`>OR2L\K[FRJ7¤RSj[F:=T2HgRSTJK`99TJF¤>OR>j[:=º9j;FT¨>,8`LšXZ79TSF¤:G8aRSK[:eRS:GdEFDGFd9FDzA
{~v|’ ‰ Ixˆ€ }ˆ–ƒz‚g|ƒˆ‚g}ˆ‚gv!x‘€Sxz{~‰‹v|}[=ƒz‰‹(y•I¨€ vIwƒˆ‰‹Š,‰ x\{~v!xz‚Pƒˆ€ œxˆ{~‰‹va—uwv
—Y‹‰‹ƒz‡O€ važ€ vI‡(¨—p;‚œxz}ˆ‘yI‚!ž‚g‡|{ xz‰‹ƒˆ}Pž / ¥¤z¢.$ÿ§Z¦.£ÿ 0 y¢<
7O¾8¤FÐ\Ỳ FTJ:=F8;EHP½©TJFY[TSFHJF8aRS>,RJ:=798;H¡ikTS79X4:GRSḦ
j[FTIA ǦF_L[F!>9jÆK[Xh>,8h>,8;Lh>2TJ7E»`79RRJF>E<
`ƒˆ‚g}ˆ}Pž$ý…€ ŠIƒˆ{~‡|’‹‚‹ž ú H—
HS,8š>9TS< j[:GRJFI,RFÐÆRJF8`L[HRSj[F¤,Ỳ >,»[:=DG:GRJ:=FH79i
ŠO€ }z‚g‡¤g‰‹vxzƒˆ‰‹ŒC—­uwvmy¨§zo 8~, “ÿ g=.@